Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Ord 15-09
ORDINANCE NO 15-09 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE 11:ESURVEY REPC)RT OF DEL-IDA PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT INCLUDING E~iTENSIC-N OF THE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE AND RECLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTIES FROM NON-CONTRIBUTING TO CONTRIBUTING, PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the City retained RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc., to resurvey the Del-Ida Park Historic District and the City Corrux5ission accepts the survey recommendations to extend the Period of Significance, and seek listing of the district on the National Register of Historic places; and, WHEII:EAS, the Del-Ida Park Historic District was originally designated and placed on the Delray Beach Local Register of Historic places in 1988 with a Period of Significance spanning from 1923-1943; and, WHEREAS, RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. resurveyed the Del-Ida Park Historic District and those properties originally classified as contributing for continued significance and maintenance of historic integrity; and, WHEREAS, RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. resurveyed the Del-Ida Park Historic District and those properties originally classified as non-contributing far current significance and reconammends that the Period of Significance be extended through 1970; and, WHEREAS, the Del-Ida Park Historic District was originally significant far its collection of architecture representative of the period from 1923-1943, and is currently significant for its collection of architecture representative of the period from 1944 -1965. WHEREAS, 48 structures now meet the eligibility criteria for contributing status, attributed to the newer resources built 1944 through to 1965, as these buildings have had alterations completed in an appropriate and compatible manner consistent with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, or have had alterations which are reversible thereby not compromising the structure's integrity; and, WHER.E?AS, the Del-Ida Park Historic District was originally and is currently significant under the Secretary of the Interiors Criterion A for significance due to associations with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad pattern of the City's history as one of the first planned residential developments in Delray Beach with representation of the 1920s Land Baom and 1930s settlement following the Land Boom and inclusion of post World War II growth from the 1940s through the 1960s; and, WHEREAS, the Del-Ida Paxk Historic District was originally and is currently significant under the Secretary of the Interiors Criterion B for significance due to associations with people significant to the City, as one Ord. No. 15-09 of the early investors was Frederick Henry Link, a Craftsman at Mizner Industries, and whose daughter, Catherine Link Strong was the City's first female Mayor and lived in the neighborhood, and, WHEREAS, the Del-Ida Park Historic District was originally and is currently significant under the Secretary of the Interiors Criterion C for significance as it embodies one or more distinctive architectural styles or types such as the Mission, Mediterranean Revival, Minimal Traditional, Contemporary, Masonry and Frame Vernacular, Ranch, and Streamline Moderne, with the Mission and Mediterranean Revival style containing influences directly from renown Architect Addison Mizner, as Frederick Henry Link was a craftsman at Mizner Industries; and, WHEREAS, Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach provides for the change of historic classification of historic sites and districts; and, WHEREAS, RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. found that the City should seek listing of the Del-Ida Park Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places; and, WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District an September 16, 20Q9 and voted 4 to 1 to recommend approval for the acceptance of the Final Resurvey Report and its recommendations including extension of the Period of Significance to 1965 and changes of historic classification for 4S properties within the Del-Ida Park Historic District; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach adopts the findings in the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District; and WHEREAS, the City Corrus~ission of the City of Delray Beach adapts the findings in the Historic Preservation Board Staff Report dated September 16, 20Q9; and WHEREAS, the City Con~nission of the City of Delray Beach finds the ordinance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS the City Con~rnission of the City of Delray Beach has conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the adoption of the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the recitations set forth above are incorporated herein. Attachment A. ection 2 That the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District is included as Ord. Na 15-09 Section 3 That the Period of Significance is extended to 1965. Section 4 That the properties listed in Attachment B are hereby classified as set forth in Attachment A and in accordance with and under the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, Florida. Section 5 That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby repealed. Section 6 That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thereof any paragraph, sentence or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid. Section 7 That this ordinance shall became effective immediately upon passage on second and fina~~' ding. ASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final reading on this the day of , 200. MAYO ATTEST: e n Csty Clerk First Readin ~~ ~- '~' Second Readin ~~ ~ 3 ©rd. No, 15-49 Page 1 of 1 MEMC~RANDU~ TO: Mayor and City Commissioners FROM: David T. Harden, City Manager DATE: October 13, 2009 SUB.I~ECT: AGENDA ITEM 10.A. -REGULAR COMMISSION MEETING OI{ OCTCIBER 20, 2009 ORDINANCE NO. 15-09 (SECOND READINGfSECQND PUBLIC HEARING) ITEM BEF(JRE CQMMISSI(3N This ordinance is before Commission for second reading and second public hearing to consider an ordinance providing for the acceptance of the resurvey report of Del-Ida Park Historic District including extension of the period of significance and reclassification of properties from non-contributing to contributing. BACKGROUIYI} At the first reading on October b, 2009, the Commission passed Ordinance No. 15-09. REGQMMENDATION Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 15-09 on second and final reading. http:/lmiweb001 /AgendasBluesheet.aspx?ItemID=2724&MeetingID=222 10/21 /2009 ORDINANCE NO 15-09 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACI~ FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR T'HE ACCEPTANCE OF THE RESURVEY REPORT OF DEL-IDA PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT INCLUDING EXTENSION OF THE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE AND RECI_.ASSIFICATION OF PROPERTIES FROM NON-CONTRIBUTING TO CONTRIBUTING, PROVIDING A GENEI~:AL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. ~'-TT~REAS, the City retainE~cl RJ Hei.~enbattle Architects, Inc., to ~,~urvey the Del- Tc~ Park Elistaric District and the City Canmtission accepts the survey recommendations to extend the Period of Significance, and st~k listing of the district on the National Register of F~staric Places; and, WHEREAS, the Dei-Ida Park I-l~i~toric District ~n~as originally designated and placed an the Delray Beach Local Register of I-l~i~toric Places iin 19$$ with a Period of Significance spanning from 1923-1943; and, V'JI~EREAS, RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. resurveyed the Del-Ida Park Historic District and those properties originally cl~~sifi~~cl as contr~uting for continued significance and maintenance of historic integrity, and, WHEREAS, RJ Heisenbottle A~v~hitects, Inc. resurveyed the Dei-Ida Park F~~storic Dist~zct and those properties originally classified as non contrr~uting far current sig~~ificance and recommends that the Period of Si€~rlifYCance ~ extended through 1920, and, WHEEREAS, the Del-Ida Park I Iistaric District was originally significant far its collection of a~x:hitecture r~~pn~sentative of the period from 1923-1943, and is currently sig~~ificant far its collection of architecture relxresentative of the period from 1944 -19b5. V1~HEREAS, 4$ stnactures now zx~eet the eligibility criteria for contributing status, attnbuted to the newer resources bt.rilt 1944 through to 1965, as these building have had alterations completed in an appropriate and compatible mariner consistent with the Secretary of the Interior's Ord. Itilo. 15-C}9 Standard for Rehabilit~~tian, ar have had alterations which are reversible thereby rrot corr'promising the stx~ture's antegrlty, and, WHEREAS, the Del-Ida Park I-listaric District was originally and is currently significant under the Secretary of the Irtteriars Criterion A far si~ance due to associations with events that have made a significant cantribuiaan to the broad pattern of the City`s history as one of the first planned r'esiclential developments in Delray Beh with r~.>presentatian of the 1920s Land. Baam and 1930s settlerrrent follov~~ng the Land Baam and inclusion of post World War II growth from the 1940s through the 1960s; and, V'-~REAS, the Del-Ida Park Historic Di~~trict was originally and is curxerrtly significant under the Secretary of the Interiors Criterion B for si~cance due to associations with people sigrriificant to the City, as one of the early investors was Frrrick Henry Lank, a C;raf tsman at l~firzrrer Industries, and whale daughter, Cat]ne Lank Strong was the City's first female Mayor and lived in the neighborhood; and, V'~REAS, the Del Ida Park I~istaric District was originally and is currently significant under the Secretary of the Interiors Criterion C for signifiicance as it embodies one ar mare distinctive arz:hitecttrral styles ar types such as the Mission, Mediterranean Revival, Minimal Traditional, Contemporary, Masonry and Frame Vernacular, Ranch, and Streamline Moderne, with the ll~ian and Mediterranean Revival style cantiMinirig influences directly from renown Architect Addison Romer, as Frederick I-i~~ry Lank was a craftsman at IG!fizner Industries; and, WHEREAS, Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Re;~]atians of the Cade of Ort~inances of the City of Delray Beach provides far the clh~rrrge of historic cl~~ification of historic sites and districts; and, WHEREAS, RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc, found that the City should seek listing of the Dellda Park Historic District an the National Re;~ister of Fistoric Places; anc~ WTdEREAS, the Historic Pservatian Board held a duly noticed public hearing in x~~ard to the Final Resurvey Report far the Del-Ic3a Park Historic Disixict on September 16, 2009 and voted to 1 to recommend approval for the acee~pta7tce of the Final. Resurvey Report and its recorrnnendations including extension of the Period of Sig~ifYCance to 1965 and changes of historic classification for 48 properties within the Del-Ida Park Historic District; and z C7rd. Na. 15-09 V'VHE RE AS, the City Convnissian of the City of Delray Beech adopts the findings in the Fir3al Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Fistoric District; and WHERE AS, the City Comrn'~ion of the City of Delray Beach adopts the fines in the I~listoric Preservation Board Staff Report dated September 16, 2009; and VVI~I2EAS, the City Comrrtiss~ian of the City of Delray Beach finds the ordinance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plary and WEIEREAS the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the adoption of the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Icy Park Historic District, NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY T'I~ CITY COZti~IVffSSION OF THE CITY OF DEL1iAY BEACH FLORIDA AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the .recitations set Earth above are incorporated Mein. Section 2 `That the Final Resurvey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District is included. as Attachment A. Section 3 That the Period of Sigruificance is extenc~d to 1965. Section 4 That the properties listed in Attachrr~ent B are hereby classified as set forth in Attachment A and in accordance with and unc~r the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Re;~~latians of the City of Delray Beach, Florida Section 5 That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the saxx~e are hereby sr~pealed Section 6 That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thet~~af any paragraph sentence or ward be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder ~f as a whole ar part thereof other than the part declared. to be ink Section 7 That this on~inance shhall become effective imit~~diately upon passage on second and final reading. Card. Na 15-U9 PASSED AND ADC~PTE D in r~~;u~lar se.~,sion on second and fuial reacting on this the day of 20Q ATTEST: City Clerk Fast Reading Secand Read ~-- MAYC}R C}rd. Na. I5-09 Page 1 of ~ ~EMt~RA~~DUM TO: Mayor acid City Commissioners 1~ROM: Arny E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Paul Dorling, AICP, Director of Planning and Zoning THROUGH: City Manager DATE: October 1, 2009 SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM -REGULAR COMMISSION MEETING C?F C?CTUBER 6.2009 ORDINANCE NO, 15-09_{F'IRST READINGJF]RST PUBLIC HEARING) ITEM BEFORE COMMISSION The item before Commission is consideration of Ordinance 15-09 which accepts the recommendations of the Del-Ida Park Historic District resurvey report, including expansion of the Period of Significance {POS} and reclassification of properties. BACKGROUND The City hired RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. to conduct a survey of the Del-Ida Park, Old School Square, Nassau Park, and West Settlers Historic Districts from July 2008 -January 2009, The objective was to survey all properties developed at least thirty-five years ago within each of the aforementioned districts, and to identify both contributing and non-contributing buildings and structures. A historical overview of each area was provided in the final report. The City Commission reviewed the final survey report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District at its workshop on February 10, 2009. The report contained the following recommendations: « That the POS be extended to 19?0 {currently spans to 1943); « That 48 properties be reclassified from non-contributing to contributing, and, « Options for listings on the National Register of Historic Places (NR:HP) Staff recommends that the POS extend through 1965 in order to remain consistent with prior POS designations adopted by the City. This would include those eligible properties that are currently at least 45 years old and would be at least fifty years old by the time the next survey is completed. It is noted that the report did not identify any remaining properties built between 1965 and 1970 as eligible for reclassification to contributing, Therefore, this revision would not affect any of the 48 properties recommended for reclassification. As noted above, the subject Ordinance includes properties constructed less than fifty years ago. The ItiIRI-IP notes "that properties less than fifty years old may be an integral part of a district when there is http:!/miweb0011AgendaslBluesheet.aspx?ItemID=2694&MeetingID=220 1 QlI 312009 Page 2 of 2 sufficient perspective to consider the properties as historic" which may be demonstrated by the following: 1} That the district's Period of Significance is justified as a discrete period with a defined beginning and end, 2) That the character of the district`s historic resources is clearly defined and assessed, 3} That specific resources in the district are demonstrated to date from that discrete era, and 4} That the majority ofdistrict properties are aver fifty years old. Additional analysis is contained within the attached HPB Staff Report of September 16, 2009. Ordinance 15-09 also contains two attachments: Attachment A -Del-Ida Park Historic District Resurvey Report, and Attachment B -Del-Ida Park Historic District property list including dates of construction, architectural styles, and classifications. The recommendation for listing on NRTIP will be explored at a later date and would begin with a property owner workshop with HPB. A Powerl?oint presentation is also attached which provides an overview of each property recamrnended for reclassification including a photo and evaluation comment, Additional designation criteria utilized by the NRHP is also included to illustrate that the subject Ordinance is in keeping with national standards. It should be noted that pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1{O}{5), if any property owner within the subject historic district ar within five hundred feet {504°} of the edge of the property seeking a change of historic designation andlor classification objects, the City Commission approval shall require a super majority vote of four {4} votes. REVIEW BY OTHERS The Historic Preservation Board {HPB} reviewed Ordinance 15-09 at its September 16, 2009 meeting where a recommendation of approval was made {4-1 vote, Pam Reeder dissenting} to accent the resurvey report for the Del-1da Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Si~mificance to 1965, and reclassification of 48~roperties from Non-Contributing; to Contributing. Ms. Reeder dissented as she felt that the POS should not extend past 1959 and should include only those eligible properties aver 54 years old. In addition to the property owners who supported the Ordinance, three property owners were in attendance at the HPB meeting who spoke against the reclassifications of their own properties, each of which is listed below: 223 NE 5th Court - 1947, Contemporary Style 110 T1E 5th Street - 1963, Contemporary Style 2281}TE, 5th Street -1952, Contemporary Style, The Community Redevelopment Agency {CRA} reviewed Ordinance 15-09 at its September 24, 2009 meeting and supported the Ordinance with the suggestion that those affected property owners be given the opportunity to opt out of the reclassification. REGONIMENDrATION Approve Ordinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report far the Del-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 1965, and reclassification of 48 properties from Nan-Contributing to Contributing. http:1/miweb401lAgendasBluesheet,aspx`?ItemID=2694&MeetingID=220 1011312409 ATTACHMENT A CITY CAF DELRA-Y BEACH Ft.ESURVE~Y tJF F(~[.TR LUCAL ~CEGISTER HISTQI~;IC IIISTRI~TS I3EI.,~-IAA PAI~:~~ HISTORIC DISTRICT ~., ~;. ~~ : ~' _^ M. . ~~ z ^.±[ Prepared by: R,J, HEISENBt~TTLE ARCHITECTS! P.A. January 30, 2Q{l9 DEL-IDA PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT HISTORIC SURVEY REPORT INTRODUCTION The City of Delray Beach has retained the firm of R.J. Heisenbottle Architects, P.A. {RJHA) to resurvey four areas within the city previously listed on the Local Register of Historic Places as Historic Districts. The four areas to be studied are Del-Ida Park, Nassau Park, Old School Square, and West Settlers Historic District. RJHA's task will be to prepare individual Survey Reports for each of the four historic districts. These survey reports will include the following information: • Historical overview of the district. + Review existing criteria for determining contributing and non-contributing structures. • Recommendations on extending Periods of Significance, where appropriate, within the district. • Update Florida Master Site File forms far previously recorded structures. • Prepare new Florida Master Site File forms for previously unrecorded structures • Prepare maps and photographs for all sites within. the district. These surveys are reviewing all structures located within the locally designated historic districts that are thirty five (35) years or older. Information on structures currently listed is being updated, noting any alterations, relocations and demolitions since the time that the Designation Report was originally prepared. Structures not previously listed, that meet the 35 year or older criteria and that are deemed "contributing" to the historic district, are being added to the Florida Master Site File and are being recommended for inclusion in the Local Register of Historic Places' Historic District Designation Report. To date, RJHA has completed work on the Nassau Park Historic District and on the Old School Square Historic District and the West Settlers Historic District. The Del-Ida Park Historic Survey Report covers the fourth and final area being studied under this project. This report will provide information on those items outlined above, based on: field work; research conducted on City records including building cards and permits, Sanborn map records available at the Delray Beach Planning and Zoning Department; existing historical publications; previous surveys covering the Del-Ida Park Historic District, such as the Historic Resources Survey. Phase II, conducted by Janus Research in 2Q0~; the Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey conducted by John P. Johnson in 19$7 and on historical research conducted at the Delray Beach Historical Society. The Del-Ida Park Historic District was officially listed in the Local Register of Historic Places in 19$$. A total of 47 sites were listed as individual contributing buildings. Additional contributing sites were identified by the "Historic Resources Survey Report Phase II", conducted by Janus Research in 20Q2, but were not incorporated as part of the Designation 2 Report. The RJHA Report will update and re-evaluate the information provided in the 3anus Report and will make recommendations for additional sites that should be officially listed as contributing structures in the Del-Ida Park Designation Report. BOUNDA~tIES (See Attachment A: Historic District Map} The Del-Ida Park Historic District is bounded on the north by N.E. 8th Street, on the east by the Florida East Coast Railway, an the south by N.E. 4th Street, and on the west by the east side of N. Swinton Avenue. These are the original boundaries of the development originally platted in 1923. Based on that historical fact, no boundary extension or modification is being recommended for the Del-Ida Park Historic District, CQNTEXT The Del-Ida Fark Historic District is a 14 block suburban residential area just four blocks north of the heart of downtown Delray Beach. It consists of primarily single family, one story residences, although there are some two story houses and a few duplex structures that were built during the 195Qs and 1960s. Although some of the houses have been converted to light office use, the residential character of the area remains fairly intact. The same can be said about the original historic fabric of the structures. Few of the historic houses have been demolished. Only two houses listed on the 1988 Designation Re~art have been demolished. These were located at 6111. N. Swinton Avenue and at 11}7 N.E. 6 Street. Most of the houses have survived with relatively few unsympathetic alterations or additions. In several instances additions have been made with respect and sensitivity to the original houses, compatible in design yet clearly distinguishable from the historic portion. Specific examples will be presented in the "Architectural Significance" Section. The original plat was laid out in an interesting and unusual fashion, combining a rectangular grid with a series of diagonal streets. Most notable is Dixie Boulevard, which serves as the main concourse in the development, having been laid out 211 feet wider than the rest of the streets. The combination of rectangular and diagonal street design produces a series of unusual triangular blocks and Tats with varying street frontage. There are three small public parks that, slang with we111andscaped grounds and mature trees, contribute to the overall visual quality of the neighborhood. HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE Del-Ida Park is one of the first planned residential developments in Delray Beach, In 1923, the Ocean City Development Company purchased a 5$ acre tract in the northeast section of Delray Beach, during the heyday of the Florida Real Estate Boom, and created Del-Ida Park. The development company was organized by Mr. 3.C. Secord, of Miami, along with Mr. B.E. Clutter, also of Miami, and Mr. Charles Kuschke of Fort Lauderdale, who planned to open sales offices in Delray (not yet renamed Delray $each), West Palm Beach and Miami. On September 18, 1923, Del-Ida Park was officially platted and recorded and appears to have been an almost instant success. Del-Ida Park was widely promoted in the Delray News, In a front page article dated September 28, 1923, the newspaper proclaimed that "Del-Ida is growing fast". It goes an to state that 25 of the available Sli lots had been sold and that city water and electricity were being installed, The article also states that "Two beautiful parks are being made and 100's of Australian pines, other trees, flowers and shrubbery are being planted". The newspaper further states that "Mr. Secard and his group bring people daily to visit Del-Ida Park and soon they will have to put more of their lots on the market", On October 19, 1923, the Delra~News reported that "~Vanderful progress is being made in Del-Ida Park, our new suburb. Nice hard surfaced streets are being run through the property and it is beginning to look like a real town". One of the first investors in the area was Frederick Henry Link, formerly a craftsman of Mizner Industries in West Palm Beach, who in 1923 purchased several lots in Del-Ida Park. Mr. Link soon became the general contractor for the development, and mast of the early hawses in Del- Ida Park were built by him. That same year he began construction of his own home, located at S24 N.E. 2°~ Avenue. The great almost overnight success of the Del-Ida Park was as typical of the Florida Real. Estate Boom as its rapid collapse following the Stock Market Crash of 1929 and subsequent years of the Great Depression. Construction continued, but at a much slower pace during the ] 930s and 1940s. It was not until the end of World War II that Del-Ida Park experienced a new surge in construction. During the immediate post-war era, Delray Beach saw a marked increase in population, the result of former military personnel stationed in the area that returned and relocated with their families. Del-Ida Park was an attractive middle-class suburban community, central]y located and reasonably priced. Many new houses went up at this time, modest in scale, but representative of the latest trends in architectural design, materials and technology. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE There are many architectural styles represented in Del-Ida Park. Fallowing are examples of the most prevalent ones found within the designated historic district; Frederick Henry Link brought to Del-Ida Park with him the experience he had acquired while working with Addison Mizner in Palm Beach. Inspired by Mizner's grand Mediterranean Revival style houses in Palm Beach, Mr. Link's pause set the tape far the architectural style in Del-Ida Park. Smaller in scale and simpler in design, the Link House is mostly Mission style, but with same Mediterranean Revival details, such as the octagonal corner tower and the heavily rusticated doorway surrounds. 4 The Link H©use, 524 N.E. 2"`~ ~ivenue (1923} The Mission Style became the predominant design mode for the original houses in the Del-Ida Park development. A scaled dawn version of the Mediterranean Revival style, the Mission style was widely popular in the 1924s, and its charm and currency made it an important selling tool for the planned residential development. While the Mediterranean Revival style awed its inspiration to the Spanish, Italian and Moorish architecture along the Mediterranean coast, the Mission style was derived from the Spanish Missions in California and New Mexico. In Del- Ida Park, textured stucco surfaces on wood frame structures, flat roofs, molded parapets, scuppers and sparse, if any, applied decorative details were the primary features of the Mission style. Simple designs and inexpensive construction methods made these houses attractive and affordable. A total of 25 of the original Mission Style homes are still standing in Del-Ida Park, although three have seen their original stylistic features altered beyond recognition. These structures have been incorrectly identified as Mediterranean Revival in past surveys. That classification should be corrected in all records. Mission Style Houses ~: "~ :~ ra~a~Jir/4.'rP' ..:.~~-f 11 pixie Boulevard 214 N.E. 5`" Street The more ornate Mediterranean Revival Style, one of the most popular architectural styles in Florida during the 192Qs, is also represented in Del-Ida Park, although not as widely. These buildings are larger, usually two stories and have a greater amount of applied decorative details than the simpler Mission style houses, including arches, a combination of flat and pitched tiled 102 N.E. 8`" Street roofs and balconies. One of the best examples of the Mediterranean Revival style may be found in the residence located at 515 N. Swinton Avenue. The fact that it was originally built outside Del-Ida Park at 324 N.E. 2"d Avenue and relocated to its present site in 1961, may explain the anomaly of its more ornate, larger scale within this historic district. The apartment building at 441 N.E. 2"~ Avenue is also Mediterranean Revival by its more elaborate design, although its bell-shaped central parapet still harks back to the Mission style. Several of the original Mission style buildings have been modified through additions and alterations into Mediterranean Revival designs. These will be covered in the "Additions and Alterations" Section below. ~fediterraneun Revival Style S15 N. Swinton Avenue Several fine examples of the Minimal Traditional Style are also found in Del-lda Park. These generally date back to the 1930s to 1950s decades, built originally during the Depression era, and show simple, saber designs with some modest detailing harking back to more traditional styles. Some of the more typical details for these houses include law to medium pitch gable roofs generally facing front, modest overhangs, prominent chimneys, decorative wood details on gable ends, inset porches supported on decorative wood supports and sparsely used Colonial or other traditional applied decoration, such as door and window surrounds. 6 401 N.E. 2"d Avenue Minimal Traditional Style ITouses 706 N.E. 2"~ Avenue There are many fine examples of Contemporary Style houses that were built during the post World War II building construction surge in Del-Ida Park. These houses are inspired by the International Style that originated in Europe and later traveled to the United States, where it was eminently established by Mies Van der Rohe and his disciple Philip Johnson, among many others. An even more direct influence can be found in the past-war work of masters like Richard Neutra in California and Paul Rudolph in Sarasota. Contemporary style houses in Del-Ida Park have simple, clean lines, highly abstracted, geometric designs and are mostly devoid of any applied decoration. Cane of the mast important features of these buildings is their complete break with traditional, historical models. They rely on massing, new materials and methods of construction and sculptural forms for architectural expression. Most of the houses have flat roofs with broad eaves, may have glass jalousie windows and often an attached carport. These houses were not 50 years old at the time when the Del-Ida Park Historic District was designated, therefore not meeting the age threshold to be considered as contributing structures. It is, however, RJHA's strong recommendation that these houses should be recognized and officially listed as contributing buildings in the Designation. Report, for their historical and architectural significance as representative examples of Post- war Era design. Contemporary Style Hou,~~~s ~; . ,g 240 Dixie .Boulevard 7 105 N.E. 6`h Street 222 N.E. S`h Street 204 N.E. S`" Terrace 21 S N.E. Soh Street There is a variety of other architectural styles represented in Del-Ida Park, although not as numerous as the ones identified above. Among the styles that can be found are examples of Frame and Masonry Vernacular, one drastically altered Bungalow, some Streamline Moderne, and several Ranch houses. ADDITIONS AND ALTIJRATIONS Many of the original structures have been altered and others have been added ta, both with varying degrees of success. Some of the original Mission style houses were enlarged during the 1 DSOs. The additions have been successful as statements of their own time, although they may have completely altered the architectural character of the original house. The Mission style house at 21'7 N.E. 4th Street is no longer recognizable from the front. The addition itself, however, is quite handsome, with a boldly cantilevering carport, and the original building is fairly intact toward the rear of the new structure (See photo below). ~~ t ~ - ` - 1 ` ., ~~ r ?~ 2 M ~`. ~ y J ?'Y. ~5 • .j ~ .~` , Y~ ': E ~~ ~~ } ~ :. _ . r~'1 _.. r .~. 217 N.E. 4''' Street Similarly, the house located at 251 Dixie Boulevard is no longer recognizable as Mission style, yet its original simple lines lent themselves quite nicely to its transformation as a Contemporary style structure {See attached photo). 2511)ixie Br~ulevard At 204 Dixie Boulevard, the addition is considerably larger than the original Mission style house, yet the original house is still recognizable, and the addition has been done in a manner which is respectful and compatible. The original house has a simple molded parapet, while the parapet on the addition has a continuous banding at the top. In spite of the all the good attributes of the addition, the overall effect and character is now that of a Mediterranean Revival style building, rather than the original Mission style design intent. A less fortunate addition, however, can be seen at 203 Dixie Boulevard, where the original Mission style house is no longer recognizable, and the entire structure has deceivingly and disarmingly become faux Mediterranean Revival. 204 Dixie Boulevard 203 Dr'xie Boulevard Finally, the following two additions are highly successful in their execution, In the house at 110 N,E, 7`s Street, the addition is very similar to the original Mission style house, but the connection between old and new is set back, clearly differentiating between the two (See photo below). At 105 N.E. 7`h Street, the large two story addition is significantly set back from the original Minimal Traditional style house, and the different massing of the two leaves no doubt where one ends and the other begins (See photo below). -> , ` :~ ~; ~ ~ :,~~~ ,. r~ _ _._ _ ~ _.__:~ ~~'~"~ ~ ; ~. ~_.~~. 105 N.E. ?`h Street 9 >~ ;t;; ~~ >_ n ~. ;. - ~~ :~~ 110 J1~r E. 7`h Street PERIUI} OF SIGNIFICANCE One of the objectives of the Delray Beach "Resurvey of Four Local Register Historic Districts" project is to assess the feasibility of expanding the current Period of Significance. Structures thirty five {35) years or alder will be recorded in the Florida Master Site File, so that the information contained in the State's database will be not only current but actually ahead of the SQ threshold for historic consideration. This does not mean that structures that are 35 to 50 years old will automatically be deemed contributing, but rather they will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis for possible eligibility. The Del-Ida Park Historic District Designation Report, approved in 1988, places the Period of Significance cut-off date by which structures are to be evaluated at 1943. The cut-off date is based in the generally accepted 50 year old threshold for considering eligibility of structures for listing as "contributing" within a designated historic district. In terms of historical and architectural development, it is difficult to justify this date under any other criteria than the 50 year threshold. The post World War II era was a significant period in the historic and architectural development of Delray Beach. There was a marked population increase, as many GIs stationed in the area relocated with their families after the war. As a result, Delray Beach saw a period of growth in business, tourism, and consequently in job opportunities and therefore an increase in demand for housing. Although the housing shift was mostly, towards outlying suburban expansion and away from the center of town, as was typical everywhere else in the country at that time, Del-Ida Park remained an attractive neighborhood, affordable and conveniently close to downtown. This report has already discussed the architectural significance of the Contemporary Style housing built during this era. Many of the structures that RJHA has identified and recorded for the first time as part of this Resurvey Project date from 1963-1965. The house pictured below, for instance, is part of a block-long cohesive group built during that time period, although unfortunately, most have been seriously altered. 10 NE Sth Street Based on the above cited historical and architectural significance of Del-Ida Park in the past-war era, it is our recommendation to extend the Period of Significance to 1970. 10 RE-EVALUATION OF CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES This report has updated and re-evaluated the "District Inventory" provided as part of the 1988 Designation Report, which identified 47 Contributing Structures. Fallowing is a summary of our re-evaluation, which includes sites previously recorded and recommended for inclusion in the Designation Report by the 2402 Janus Report: • Contributing Structures Identified in the 1988 Designation Report 47 • New Contributing Structures per 2042 Janus Report 34 • New Contributing Structures per RJHA Report ]9 • Nan-Contributing Structures 58 • Demolished Structures 2 NATIONAL REGISTER ELIGIBILITY The Del-Ida Park Historic District contains sufficient historical and architectural significance as a planned 1920s residential development to be potentially eligible for consideration as a National Register Iistoric District. A stronger yet case could be made for a Multiple Resource nomination for the original 1920s Mission style buildings in the development. Another option is to pursue individual National Register nomination for the Frederick Henry Link House at 524 N.E. 2°d Avenue, based on Criteria A (for its association with the planned development), Criteria B (for its association with an individual who made a significant contribution to the development) and C (for its architectural significance as a 1920s Mission style-Chemed development}. Any of the above options are feasible and realistic far National Register consideration. FLO)F:IDA MASTER SITE FILES Florida Master Site File forms have been updated for all "Contributing Structures" previously recorded as part of the 1988 Designation Report or as part of the 2402 Janus Report. The following structures will be submitted for addition to the FMSF and new numbers will be requested for them: • 543 NE 3r~ Avenue • 741 NE 3`~ Avenue • 14 NE 5"' Street • 14 NE 5th Street • 18 NE 5th Street 22 NE Sth Street • 142 NE 5th Street • 146 NE 5th Street • 110 NE 5th Street • 215 NE 5th Street • 222 NE 5th Street • 225 NE 5th Street • 116 NE ~th Street • 721 N Swinton Avenue • 14 NE 7th Street • 113 NE 7th Street • 14 NE 8th Street • 225 Royal Court • 202 Palm Court SUMMARY RECOMMENDATIONS It is recommended that the Del-Ida Park Historic District local designation be amended to reflect the following: • Amend the Inventory contained in the 1988 Designation Report to include the new structures being added to the FMSF as part of this report. • Extend the Period of SigniFicanre to 1970, based on the historical and architectural significance of the Post World War II period in the development of Del-Ida Park, • Amend the Inventory to identify the original structures in the Del-Ida Park development as designed in the Mission style, not as Mediterranean Revival, as originally indicated in the 1988 Designation Report and in the 1987 Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey. The breakdown of Mission and Mediterranean Revival style houses within the Del-Ida Park Historic District is provided in the attached "List of Surveyed Resources" in Appendix B. CONCLUSIONS Del-Ida Park is a remarkably cohesive and well preserved neighborhood. Few of the original structures have been demolished and alterations have been, for the most part, relatively benign. Even those structures deemed "Non-Contributing" due to their recent date of construction or unsympathetic alterations maintain a sense of cohesiveness in their scale, setback, use of materials and overall architectural character. The new encroaching development is nearby, but it is yet to cross N.E. 4`h Street into Del-Ida Park. There is a palpable sense of pride and identity in the neighborhood residents. The historic district designation. has made a positive contribution towards the visual quality and historical integrity of Del-Ida Park. This is evident in the marked improvement in the alterations and additions being made, and in the slowing down of the development pressure that the immediate area is facing. 12 SOURCES • Florida Master Site Files. Delray Beach. • Historic Site Files. City of Delray Beach Planning and Zoning Department. • Building Card Files. City of Delray Beach Planning and Zoning Department. • Property Control Numbers, Property Appraisers Office. City of Delray Beach. • Sanborn Insurance Maps. 1926, 1949, 1963, • Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey. By John P, Johnson. Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board. July 1987. • Del-Ida Park Historic District. Designation Report. Historic Preservation Board. Delray Beach, Florida. January 15, 1988. By Patricia Cayce. • Historical and Photographic Files. Delray Beach Historical Society. • De1ra~News. August 17, 1923; August 31, 1923; September 28, 1923; October 19, 1923. Delray Beach Historical Society. • City of Delray Beach. Historic Resources Report. Janus Research. July 1999. • City of Delray Beach. Historic Resources Report. Janus Research. June 202. 13 APPENDIX A LIST C?F SURVEYED RESOURCES 14 a i iii-i-i-i~i~i-i~i~i-i-i-i~i~i~i-i~i~i~rri~ri rri a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~` ~! ~;, ~''. ~' ' ' r r .~ _ r r r r r r r ~ .. ~~ ~ ~ ~ 'V p d ,~r~ ~` l..i ~ ~e $ ~ G ~ ~ ® 0 ~ ~ N W Z h 3W g R6 p ~p ~ yy Z ~ !K ~ Q ~ _ N ~ ~ ~ R ~ ?P 9' ~ S+ ~ i m YA H +,,,~ Z y y ii _ _ ~. .~ } iii~i ~i~i~i ~~i i~~~i~~~~i~i i~~~i~i~~i~i x K rc x x x x ~ x x x ~c ac x x x: ac x ar x ac :x x x ac x u A ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ !~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~° ~ '~ ~. ,- a ~ a ~ ~ Q ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A ~ ~ ~ Q ~ x k ~ x ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~c ~ ~ ~ x ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ x k ~ x u ., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s. ~! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ yy $ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g `~ ~ i `'''' ~, d. ~ ~ ffi id ~ ~ ~ Cd ba ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ffi ~ ~ 7!S ~' ; Q ~ .8 ~ ,8 ~ ~ o ~ ~ p H IBI ~ iM til Z 4+t W z PI W' a 41 ItJ a fM W a '~ ~ ~ ~ ~„ ~ AM Y~ T e! ~It ~ rJ ~I a ~ ~ d ~ ~ e IQ m r ~ ©© !+1 ~ ~p ~ ~ .@ r ~ P/ ~ T m R p ~ ~ ~ ~ gg d~ K " ~ r= 'b Y PV n W ~ ~ P~ ~ M1. ~! ~. ~ ~ R. M1 ~ ~ 96 ~R3 ~~ ~ N ['d ~ ~ C@ K li,. IpsCY ~L~ _O ~ mb_ ~L E7 ~ yLO1 M1L 6F ~ _G ~ Q©_~ 1~ b OT ~: 4_ ~ Cp7~ Effi mb_ ~a +qd~t 1l G_ ~ CS Q_ T' V_ T_ i R' V_ T_ @_ S_ 1/ x x x .x v x as x x x' x ~ x .k x ~c >e >c x x x ~ ~c ;~ x x "` ~ ~ f ~ ~ ~ '6 fi ~ ~' ~e ~ ~ ~ y "~ '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r r r - r r T r r `f~....L" f~ r',P '' ~ ~ Li d [ 7 H + VIII f f ~qq ~ @ ® ~ E ~ i Q ~ ' N O ~ gg ~ '' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l+Y C3 ~ y O G N CA y ~ fY (+~ 0.+R ~ R9 p 'm r ~ a ~ ~ ,~ l+tl ' ~ 7? 'i1V ~ ~ ~ r p t~ .^ r ~ y ~RP ~ ~ ( ~ _ {gip @'~ 'v If9 'G~ ~ .~ ~ v ~ ~ N ~_ ~ r ~~ v ~ ~ CV t ~~ ~ ~ c ~ .4 ~ r_ N v l~B ~_ ~_ ~ r Ri ~ •r ~ a ~ Ig ~ ~ ~c ~s ~ .u x ~ ~ se ~ ~ x x x x x ac ~c x x x ~ x ~e ~ '6 v ~ ~ a ~ ~ i.3 ' ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ «..j ~ 4A Z ~ ~ ~ ~ yy U ~ © g V ~ ~y gg V y9~ V ~ ~ y '~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ e to i ~ S ~ 6~1 Z ~ ~ ~ : ~ a ~ . p '!d SV .J~+ W ~ ~ ~ iV p [4 ~ y fi ry dV ~ ,ry iA ii"`iii~~~~~~ Z R ~ }`4 ~,. b R X65 p, fA 4Y p~ Q ems- ~ p Ul 19 x x ~c ~ u x x x x at as ac .re qr x rc ~c ac x x x x x ~ ~r 8 ~ "~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~ ~ > ~ > ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 63 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w r r e- r r r r ~ r r k '[? ~ V iT +C ~ 4 +R' +~ 6 ' K 4 +C d ' Q ' +~ C ' sC 4 ' +~ ' 4 +C ' ~'~y ® ~ ~ $ Pd ~ 4X ~ 49 E D A .' E ~'d ~' C+i ~ d,'1 F 1!'D ~ i!1 h°1 W ~ F ~ B 47~ E Px ~ B C'f B l'~i ~: f7~ ~ 07 E !'D ~ E Q WW W. p ~ Z ~ ~ ~ p ; ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 9 3 ~ ~ ~ zy,j J Q ~ ~ - ~ ~ a . m ~ ~ ,~ o ,~ m ~ ~ m ,~ e n 20 APPENDIX B DEL-IDA PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT 1~ZAAP 21 16FN TRtIV~?"Y Ltd TNERA N.E. ~4e7. .~a. ! ""--"'l ....L....,.E-.-.._.. €' ' S ~., ~ r ~ I - ~r i t L l \ Gf ' ~ f _ >~;, ~ +-. fir-- ... ~ i „ r----s~^ _, <.~ _ r r _ - __~ ,~ r b~ ~ ST. ~, / ~'S ~,,: ~ ~' ~K~ /* t~ n J ~ \ l l `+ , \ `~ J _..{{ - A ~ . ~`~ l ~ .._ / l ~~~ /~ .~~~ ,~ TN TCRR ~ ~-~-___ ~:y1fi~ f ~ i ' ~ ' 1 ~f~'~ ~I ' 1 R1 ~ ib ' C] t~ ''e ~ i ~~" R~ ~. - k ... _ ~ I~ ~ ~~ 1.~ \ ~ ~ V ~ ,,, ~ p ,,. ,~ ~, '3~ ~ ~~ r. ~ _ l - i ~ ~ ,.. 'J F .~..._.___ ~ . 4 ~ J, IH - . - ~~~ ~ .~.~....._ i + ~~ r, ~ > U -t i 'r ~ ,`~ ~ ~; ~"`_ , ~~t ~~~~~ ~ ~~ --- fin, ~ ~~ ' ~' r ~"~' 1-a7 t i-- ~~ ~~ ~~ y {!S Uj ~?tlBl.1rY ~ N /~ ~. ~ t? ?- ~ ~ ~ ~...~ wA1.- , o GRE'E'iV~ ~ - ~ ~ CASa1V ~" G}~F1GE ~ ~ ... ~ ~ A9~ Tt1Ut11ST z _ ---- --- ~. _ r CNUR~t-f ~ '~ 4 4. -°~ _. ~ ,~ , ~. ...._, F.. cx. ~ ; _, ... ~ Lx;j. z w ~ ~ 3FtU S . hI,E. _ 3R0 S'F. ~.. 3 -~~~"'I tJt1 PAf~.K ~~~.~--~+ .. cOM1"*Ftt~'J}'ING-~Dfd.l)ESfGX;ATt6N kEPORT ~} Via' p J~+^~p ~-+-7- ~-.-..__~ vCfiYffi!~.71'tt+tG-lt+xEYV '""~"" H ~ *~ I V 1~ 1 V ~ ! ~3 t F 1 ~ V 1 ~ Nat+: c~r+~~auttHC i arr ~ ~uu~ st~as. rt 'ev~exn~? ~ zart~st ot~KZnxm --°-, a©n~E~s ~os-r~i~T ~~~ ~..__ ~~~~~,s~Ea _~- rxstra ,wap srsr~e --_ u~ Rex:.ac~-uM r~a~+c - ,., „,~; _,. _.-ti~az~ixr_+mn ,... _.. _ -., v ~ ~.... {3rdinance 'I ~-49 Attachment B Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Classification List Address Classification Year Built Style 401 NE 2" Avenue Cantributin 1936 Mediterranean Revival 412 NE 2" Avenue Contributin 1955 Ranch ', 415 NE 2" Avenue Non-Contributin 1995 Frame Vernacular 418 NE 2" Avenue Cantributin 1925 Mission 503 NE 2" Avenue Contributin 1947 Streamline Maderne 511 NE 2" Avenue Nan-Cantributin 1954 Masonr Vernacular 518 NE 2" Avenue Nan-Gontributin 1950 Masonr Vernacular 524 NE 2" Avenue Contributin 1923 Mission 615 NE 2" Avenue Nan-Cantributin 1957 Masonr_ Vernacular 706 NE 2" Avenue Gantributin 1953 Frame Vernacular 714 NE 2" Avenue Cantributin 1925 Mediterranean Revival 401 NE 3 Avenue Nan-Gantributin 1968 Masan Vernacular '! 405 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1968 Masonr Vernacular 410 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1968 Mason Vernacular 412 NE 3 Avenue Non-Cantributin 1968 Mason Vernacular 415 NE 3 Avenue Non-Cantributin 1968 Mason Vernacular 505 NE 3 Avenue Non-Gontributin 1968 Masan Vernacular 520 NE 3 Avenue Non-Gantributin 1947 Mason Vernacular 524 NE 3 Avenue Cantributin 1947 Frame Vernacular 525 NE 3 Avenue Non-Gontributin 2001 Masan Vernacular 541 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1968 Masonr Vernacular 543 NE 3 Avenue Cantributin 1955 Gontempara 601 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1955 Masonr Vernacular 605 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1972 Mason Vernacular 609 NE 3 Avenue Nan-Contributin 1957 Masonr Vernacular 615 NE 3 Avenue Non-Gontributin 1972 Masonr Vernacular 617-619 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1972 Masonr Vernacular 621 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1956 Mason Vernacular 625 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1957 Mason Vernacular 701 NE 3 Avenue Contributin 1955 Contem ora 702 NE 3 Avenue Non-Gontributin 1953 Mason Vernacular 703 NE 3 Avenue Gontributin 1955 Minimal Traditional 710 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1953 Masonr Vernacular 715 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1972 Masonr Vernacular 723 NE 3 Avenue Non-Contributin 1968 Mason Vernacular 15 NE 4 Street Gontributin 1925 Mason Vernacular 101 NE 4 Street Nan-Contributin 1972 Contem ora 111 NE 4 Street Nan-Contributin 1947 Masan Vernacular 200 NE 5 Gourt Non-Cantributin 1952 Masonr Vernacular 201 NE 5 Court Non-Contributin 1948 Masonr Vernacular 209 NE 5 Court Contributin 1949 Frame Vernacular 210 NE 5 Court Contributin 1917 Frame Vernacular 215-217 NE 5 Court Contributin 1952 Gontem ora 218 NE 5 Court Cantributin 1925 Mission 223 NE 5 Gourt Contributin 1947 Contem ora 114 Ordinance 95-09 Attachment B Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Classification List Address Classifiication Year Built Style 225 NE 5 Gaurt Contributin 1947 Masonr Vernacular 226-228 NE 5 Gourt Contributin 1953 Contem ora 229 NE 5 Court Non-Gontributin 1947 Frame Vernacular 230 NE 5 Court Non-Contributin 1954 Mason Vernacular 232 NE 5 Street Nan-Contributin 1952 Mason Vernacular 219 NE 5 Street Nan-Contributin 1950 Masonr Vemacular 9 NE 5 Street Gontributin 1925 Mission 10 NE 5 Street Contributin 1963 Contem ora 14 NE 5 Street Contributir7 1963 Contem ara 18 NE 5 Street Contributin 1963 Contem ara 22 NE 5 Street Contributin 1963 Contem ora 101 NE 5 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 102 NE 5 Street Contributin 1964 Gontem ora 106 NE 5 Street Contributin 1965 Contem ora 110 NE 5 Street Contributin 1965 Contem ora 214 NE 5 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 215 NE 5 Street Contributin 1950 Contem ara 219 NE 5 Street Non-Contributin 1950 Masonr Vernacular 222 NE 5 Street Contributin 1953 Gontem ara 225 NE 5 Street Contributin 1948 Minimal Traditional 228 NE 5 Street Contributin 1952 Contem ara 202 NE 5 Terrace Contributin 1951 Masan Vernacular 204 NE 5 Terrace Contributin 1947 Minimal Traditional 216 NE 5 Terrace Contributin 1949 Minimal Traditional 218 NE 5 Terrace Non-Contributin 1953 Mason Vernacular 226 NE 5 Terrace Non-Gontributin 1954 Masonr Vernacular 230-232 NE 5 Terrace Nan-Contributin 1956 Masonr Vernacular 234-236 NE 5 Terrace Contributin 1954 Gontem ora 238-240 NE 5 Terrace Contributin 1954 Gontem ora 10 NE 6 Street Contributin 1947 Minimal Traditional 11 NE 6 Street Contributin 1947 Minimal Traditional 17 NE 6 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 101 NE 6 Street Gontributin 1949 Contem ora 105 NE 6 Street Contributin 1939 Minimal Traditional 107 NE 6 Street Contributin --- Qemolished - 2005 110 NE 6 Street Contributin 1944 Minimal Traditional 116 NE 6 Street Gontributin 1965 Ranch 4 NE 7 Street 531 N Swinton Ave Nan-Contributin Masan Vernacular 5 NE 7 Street Contributin 1939 Frame Vemacular 10 NE 7 Street Nan-Contributin 1999 Frame Vernacular 14 NE 7 Street Contributin 1965 Gontem ora 17 NE 7 Street Non-Contributin 1954 Masonr Vernacular 18 NE 7 Street Nan-Contributin 1969 Masonr Vemacular 102 NE 7 Street Contributin 1953 Minimal Traditional 105 NE 7 Street Contributin 1941 Frame Vernacular 2/4 Ordinance 15-09 Attachment B Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Classification List Address Classification Year Built Style 109 NE 7 Street Non-Contributin 1999 Frame Vernacular 110 NE 7 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 113 NE 7 Street Contributin 1962 Contem ora 117 NE 7 Street Contributin 1939 Frame Vernacular ' 14 NE 8 Street Contributin 1948 Ranch 102 NE 8 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 110 NE 8 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 114 NE 8 Street Contributin 1925 Mission 230 NE 8 Street Non-Contributin 1962 Masonr Vernacular 2 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1937 Masonr Vernacular 11 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission 14 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission 19 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission 23 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1937 Frame Vernacular 101 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1939 Minimal Traditional 102 Dixie Boulevard Non-Contributin 1948 Mason Vernacular 106 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1930 Bun aloes 109 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1937 Minimal Traditional 112 Dixie Boulevard Non-Contributin 2007 Mason Vernacular 118 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1930 Mission 125 Dixie Boulevard Contrfbutin 1928 Mediterranean Revival 203 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mediterranean Revival 204 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mediterranean Revival 216 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1947 Ranch 219 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1950 Contem ora 220 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1947 Ranch 227 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1949 Ranch 228 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1947 Minimal Traditional 232 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission 236 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission 240 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1953 Contem ora 243 Dixie Boulevard Non-Contributin 1961 Mason Vernacular 250 Dixie Boulevard Non-Contributin 1972 Modern 251 Dixie Boulevard Contributin 1925 Mission/Contem ora 109 Fern Court Contributin 1954 Ranch 117 Fern Court Non-Contributin 1957 Ranch 10 Lake Court Contributin 1940 Minimal Traditional 14 Lake Court Non-Contributin 1956 Ranch 18 Lake Court Contributin 1941 Frame Vernacular 20 Lake Court Contributin 1952 Ranch 26 Lake Court Contributin 1925 Frame Vernacular 30 Lake Court Contributin 1925 Mission 202 Palm Court Contributin 1948 Masan Vernacular 222 Palm Court Nan-Contributin 1956 Mason Vernacular 226 Palm Court Non-Contributin 1957 Mason Vernacular 3/4 Ordinance 15-09 Attachment B Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Classification List Address Classification Year Built Style 230 Palm Court Non-Contributin 1959 Mason Vernacular 225 Ro al Court Non-Contributin 1997 Mason Vernacular 235-239 Ro al Court Non-Contributin 1952 Masan Vernacular 241 Ro al Court Contributin 1925 Mission 247 Ro al Court Contributin 1925 Mission 249 Ro al Court Non-Contributin 1956 Contem ora 403 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1925 Masonr Vernacular 407 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1941 Minimal Traditional 411 North Swinton Avenue Non-Contributin 1956 Mason Vernacular 415 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1925 Mission 515 North Swinton Avenue Gontributin 1925 Mediterranean Revival 521 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1939 Minimal Traditional 527 North Swinton Avenue Non-Contributin 2007 Masonr Vernacular 531 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1947 Masonr Vernacular 605 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1925 Mission 701 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1940 Minimal Traditional 711 North Swinton Avenue Non-Contributin 1962 Masonr Vernacular 721 North Swinton Avenue Contributin 1956 Ranch 4J4 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT MEETING OF: September 18, 2009 ITEM: CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCE 15-09 TO ACCEPT THE RESURVEY REPORT OF DEL-IDA PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT INCLUDING EXTENDING THE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE AND REG~ASSIFYING PROPERTIES FROM NON- CONTRIBUTING TO CONTRIBUTING. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is that of making a recommendation to the City Commission regarding Ordinance 15-49 which provides for the acceptance of the resurvey report of Del-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance {POS}, and reclassifying properties from Non- contributing to Contributing, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR} Section 4.5.1 {N}, Criteria for Change of Historic Classification and 4.5.1(0}, Procedures for Change of Historic Classification. BACKGROUND The City hired RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc. to conduct a survey of the Del-Ida Park, Nassau Park, Old School Square, and West Settlers Historic Dis#ricts from July 2048 -January 2449. The objective was to survey all properties developed at least thirty-five years ago within each district and to identify those which contain both Contributing and Non-Contributing buildings and structures. A historical overview of each area was provided in the final report. The City Commission reviewed the recommendations of the final surrey report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District at its workshop on February 10, 2009 and supported Staffs proposal to move forward and process the acceptance of the resurvey. The final survey report to be adopted is for the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The final survey report recommendations are as follows: That the Period of Significance {POS} be expanded to 1974, which would reclassify 48 properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. The current POS spans through to 1943. See Appendix A for those properties recommended for reclassification. • That listing on the National Register of Historic Places be sought for the entire district. Following are details regarding the Period of Significance and listing on the National Register of Historic Places: Period of Significance The resurvey report notes that the POS for the Del-Ida Park Historic District should be extended to 1970, based on the historical and architectural significance of the Post World War II period in the development of Del-Ida Park. The POS extension would reclassify 48 properties currently classified Non-Contributing to Contributing, which were constructed from 1944-1965. C3r~inanc~ 15_f}g: D~i~l~a Park Hisioric District F:~survey HPB It+1~:2tinc S~;ptembe; i 6, 2~Q9; Pa~2 €~f 8 National Reciister of Historic Places tNRHP~ 1_isting on the NRHP would provide additional recognition for the district, but it should be noted that additional review criteria or restrictions would not be placed on properties located within the boundary. Additional explanation of NRHP listing is provided below. Ordinance 15-09 includes Attachment A, which is the Final Survey Report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District, and Attachment B, which notes each property and its date of construction, historic classification, and architectural style, At its April 15, 2008 meeting, the HPB reviewed and tabled the subject item until their June 17, 2009 meeting with the following direction given to Staff: 1. That an analysis be conducted regarding extending the POS to 1970, while only reclassifying those structures built through 1959 (later referred to as Alternative 2); and, 2. That an analysis be conducted to extend the POS only to 1959 {as opposed to 1970) (later referred to as Alternative 3}. The requested analyses are provided in the "Analysis" section of this report where a comparison is provided between the survey recommendations {Alternative 1) and the two scenarios requested by the Board as noted above {Alternatives 2 and 3}. Gonsideratian of Ordinance 15-09 is now before the Board for review and recommendation to the Gity Commission. REVIEW LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.2.6{A}, a Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach is hereby created. The ur ose of this Board is fo foster and promote the recognition, protection, enhancement and use of historic resources in the City of Delray Beach and fo have a lay body which shall have authority fo act on matters pertaining to hisforic preservation. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.2.6{D}{1}, Du#ies, Powers, and Responsibilities, fhe Historic Preservation Board shall develop, maintain. and update a survey of archaeological sites. properties, bui/dings, structures, and districts of special historic, aesthetr`c, architectural, cultural, or social value or interest. The Board will endeavor fo improve, expand, and make more accurate the survey as additional documents, information, oral histories, and other such materials may become available, and it will periodically reevaluate the survey. The Board will work with the City Historical Society, fhe State Bureau of Historic Preservation, and other appropriate public and nonprofit organizafions in maintaining Phis survey. Pursuant to LDR Sec#ion 2.2.6{D){2), Duties, Powers, and Responsibilities, the Historic Preservation Board shall nomr`nate properties for desr`gnation, and regulafe such properfies, structures, buildings, sites, districts, and the like sa designated as hisforic sites and/or historic districts. STAFF COMMENT: The C_DRs specify that as part of the HPB duties, the Board shall protect historic resources, and update surveys of historic resources. The resurvey of the Del-Ida Park Histarie District complies with this requirement. Ordinance 15-t?9; del-Ida Park Historic District Resurvey HPB Meeting Septemt~er 16; 209; Pace 3 of 8 LDR Section 4.5.1(N}, Criteria for Change of Historic Classification (1} A survey of all historic districts may be conducted by the Cify every flue (5) years. The surrey report may recommend changes to the historic designation andfor c/assificafian of properties located within or immediately adjacent to a designs#ed historic district. {b} Criteria for Change of Historic Classification: If aCity-initiated survey conducted within the last five (5) years reveals that a property within a historic district should be reclassified as either Contributing or non-Contributing, then the classification may be revised in accordance with LDR Section 4.5.1 ~0) and shalt be determined as follows: 9. The survey recommends the inclusion of an additional "Period of Significance'; which would reclassify properties from non-Contributing to Contributing, or; 2. The surrey recommends that a property or properties have been so significantly altered that the changes are irreversible and have compromised the structures historic integrity of the structure, which would reclassify the structure from Contributing to non-Contributing. STAFF COMMENT: The subject survey meets the criteria for change of historic classification as it was conducted within the last 5 years (camplete January 2009}, and the survey recommends that the Period of Significance be adapted which would reclassify 48 praperties from Non-Gantributing to Contributing, per the survey recommendation. Therefore, the reclassifications of the praperties listed in Exhibit A are eligible for review. It is noted that additional resources are recommended far reclassification by Staff. These resources are further analyzed below. LDR Section 4.5.1{O}, Procedures for Change of Historic Designation andlor Classification {2} Procedures for Chance of Historic Classification: Applications to change the historic classification of a property or properties within a historic district shall be made to the Historic Preservation Board and may be initiated by written request of (a} The Historic Preservation Board based upon the recommendations of a Cify-initiated survey completed within five (5J years prior to the application; or (b} The Cify Commr`ssion based upon the recommendations of aCity-initiated survey completed within five {5) years prior fo the application; or (sJ The Planning and Zoning Director or hislher designee shall conduct a preliminary evaluation of the information provided on each application to determine if it generally conforms with criteria in LDR Section 4.5.1 ~N)(9). The Planning and Zoning Director or hislher designee shall then prepare a report which shat/ contain the following. (b} Chancae of Historic Classification: 1. Analysis of the properties to be reclassified,' and 2. A staff recommendation as fo whether or not the properties should be reclassified due to either;' a. loss of historic integrity as a result of irreversible alterations to a Contributing property; or b. inclusion of an additional "Period of Significance" per the survey recommendations. STAFF C©MMENT: Period of Significance & Reclassifications It has been determined that the subject request conforms with Section 4.5.1{N}(1}, and the recommendations have been justified within the report with respect to the expansion of the Pt}S to 1970. The information has been provided and reviewed by Staff and deemed to be complete. It should be noted that the date of construction for 251 Dixie Boulevard has been corrected via the Qrdinance 15-09; DeE-I:ia Park Histgric C3istrict Resurvey HPB Meeting Se~temt?er 16; 2009; Page 4 of 8 resurvey, as it was found to be a 1920s structure and not the 1950s structure it was thought to be when the district was designated in 1988. There were modifications to the Mission-style structure in the 1950s, and the survey now notes this property to be a Mission/Contemporary style. Page 8 of the Del- Ida Park final survey report recognizes and compliments the "transformation" of the structure from Mission to Contemporary style. In 2008, the HPB approved a demolition of this structure, and it was reviewed as anon-contributor. The demolition occurred earlier this year. The properties recommended far reclassification by RJ Heisenbottle Architects, Inc, were initially developed between 1944 and 1965 and are a part of the historic Del-Ida Park streetscape. While these structures may differ from the architectural styles of Del-Ida Park's initial development, they are compatible and illustrate the development building typologies of their time. It is important to note that the "Period of Significance" identifies the growth periods of a historic district and places the PQS within its historical content. Therefore, extension of the PQS to 1970 rather than 1965 when the last remaining eligible structure was built, includes the entire Post-WWII development impact on Del-Ida Park, and may recognize those appropriate improvements made to contributing structures during this timeframe. Staffs anal sis of the resume recommendations are ravided below. ANALYSIS RESURVEY RECOMMENaATIt~NS The follawing gives a comparison of the three potentially different alternatives the Board may choose to support based on the request from the April 15, 2009 meeting. However, Staff has provided an additional alternative for Board consideration. The PC)S, justification, and analysis for Alternative 4 are included below. Period of Significance Alternative 1 1970 Alternative 2 1970 Alternative 3 1959 Alternative 4 1965 Reclassified Properties 48 38 38 48 Justification Alternative 1: The follawing contains excerpts from the resurvey report: "...lt was not until the end of World War 11 that L7el-Ida Park experienced a new surge in construction. During the immediate post-war era, Delray Beach saw a marked increase in population, ...Del-lda Park was an attractive middle-class suburban community, centrally located and reasonably priced. Many new houses went up at this time, modest in scale, but representative of the latest trends in architectural design, materials and technology. There are many fine examples of Contemporary Style houses that were built during the past World War 1! building eonsfrucfion surge in Del-Ida Park... These houses were not 5g years old of the time when the Del-lda Park Historic District was designated, therefore not meeting the age threshold to be considered as confributing strucfures. if is, however, RJHA's sfrong recommendation that these houses should be recognized and officially fisted as contributing buildings in the Designation Report, for their historical and archifecfural significance as representative examples of Past-War Era design. The Del-Jda Park Historic District Designation Report, approved in 1988, places the Period of Significance cut-off date by which structures are to be evaluated of 1943. The cut-off date is Urclinance ~ 5-09; C?e!-Iefa Park Historic District Resurvey HPB Meetin Septem~xer "6; 2QD9; Pale > of & based in the generally accepted 5(1 year old fhreshold for considering eligibility of sfructures for listing as "contributing" within a designated historic disfrict. In terms of historical and architectural development, if is difficult fo justify this date under any other criteria than the 5t1 year fhreshold. The post World War l/ era was a significant period in the historic and architectural development of Delray Beach. There was a marked population increase, ...As a result, Delray Beach saw a period of growth...and therefore an increase in demand for housing...Del-tda Park remained an attractive neighborhood, affordable and conveniently close to downtown...(report) discussed the architecfural significance of the Contemporary Style housing built during fhis era. Many of the sfructures that RJI-IA has identified and recorded for the first time as part of this Resurvey Project date from 1963-1965...(1Q NE 5th Streets is part of a block-long cohesive group built during that time period... Extend the Period of Significance to 1970, based on the historical and architectural significance of the Posf World War 11 period in the development of Del-Ida Park." The justification provided above by the City's Consultant was a result of extensive research including the City's records, the Delray Beach Historical Society's records, and field surveys. Alternatives 2 and 3: These alternatives were requested by the Board in response to owners of properties containing structures built after 1959 and who voiced their opposition to the reclassifications at the HPB meeting of April 15, 2009. Alternative 4 Staff's proposal of Alternative 4 is provided See Staff's Analysis of the 4 alternatives below. Analysis Alternative 1: Alternative 1 has been provided in the resurvey report which was prepared by a qualified professional knowledgeable in historic preservation, architectural history, and historic site surveys, among other qualifications. As a result of extensive research on the Del-Ida Park Historic District, a recommendation was made to extend the POS to 1970 and that those eligible and qualifying structures (48} are reclassified as contributing to the historic district. The justification of the POS extension to 1970 illustrates the time frame of the Post WWII impact on Del-Ida Park, not necessarily by the most recent construction date {1965} of a structure recommended for contributing classification. Based on the justification noted in the report (also noted above} and additional information and analysis provided below for Alternative 4, the Board may not find it appropriate to adopt the recommended PC}S extension to 1970. Alternative 2: Alternative 2 would extend the PflS to 1970, and reclassify 38 properties constructed through 1959. Support for the subject alternative would arbitrarily omit eligible resources constructed in a decade in the noted P4S and compromise any future attempts at recognizing those structures built in Del-Ida Park after 1959 as significant. Those eligible structures built in the 1960s are of the Contemporary and Ranch styles, both of which are representative of styles constructed in the 1950s. The following is an explanation of the importance of the Contemporary Style, as provided in the resurvey report: C3rdinance 15-09; I~el-Ida Park Historic ~7istrict Resurvey HPB Meeting Septemk7er ~fi; 2C}t}g; Page 6 cf 8 "There are many fine examples of Contemporary Style houses that were built during the post World War 11 building construction surge in Del-lda Pant. These houses are inspired by the fiternafional Style fhat originafed in Europe and later traveled fo the United States, ... Contemporary style houses in Det-lda Park have simple, clean lines, highly abstracted, geometric designs and are mostly devoid of any applied decoration. {one of fhe most important features of these buildings is their complete break with fraditional, historical models. They rely on massing, new materials and methods of construction and sculptural forms for architectural expression. Most of the houses have flat roofs with broad eaves, may have glass 1alousie windows and often an attached carport. These houses were not 5t? years old at the time when fhe Del-lda Park Nisforic Disfr7cf was designated, therefore not meeting the age threshold to be considered as contributing structures. It is, however, RJNA's strong recommendation that these houses should be recognized and officially listed as contributing buildings in the Designation Report, for their hr"storical and architectural significance as representafive examples of Post-War Era design." As a general Hate, it is important to consider that while these styles may exist throughout the City as a whole, there is not a large concentration of any single style within any of the City's five historic districts. Therefore, the protection of any of the eligible resources is important in maintaining the historic environment of each district. Based an the emphasis provided in the report {also Hated above) on the Contemporary-style and significance of Past-ViJWII development subsequent to 1959, the Board may find that it would not be appropriate to adopt the recommended POS extension to 1970, while reclassifying 38 structures built through 1959, and omitting the 10 identified structures built between 1960 and 1965. Alternative 3: Alternative 3 would extend the POS to 1959 and reclassify 38 properties constructed through 1959. Revising a POS to the end of a decade for the sake of omitting structures built subsequent to this time period is only justifiable when the end of the decade actually coincides with the end of a historical period. The subject alternative would arbitrarily omit a decade in the noted POS along with the noted eligible resources from this decade. Those eligible structures built in the 1960s are of the Contemporary and Ranch styles, bath of which are representative of styles constructed in the 1950s. These ornissians would have ttie potential of compromising any future attempts at recognizing those structures built in Del-Ida Park after 1959 as significant. Based an the emphasis provided in the report {also noted above} on the Contemporary-style and significance of Post-WWII development subsequent to 1959, the Board may find that it would not be appropriate to revise the recommended POS extension from 1970 to 1959, while reclassifying 38 structures built through 1959, and omitting the 10 identified structures built between 1960 and 1965. Alternative 4 As an additional alternative, Staff suggests that the Board consider extending the POS to 1965, as opposed to the recommended 1970. The reduction to 1965 would maintain the reclassification of 48 properties, as na potentially eligible properties were identified after 1965. It is likely that properties over 45 years old were not considered as it is common practice to evaluate resources up to 45 years old, and Hat younger unless compelling evidence Hating its significance has been presented. For example, when Delray Beach designated its first four historic districts in 1988, the POSs for those districts were established at 1943, and those eligible structure built between 45 and 49 years prior were classified as contributing to Chase districts. While this practice may contradict the arbitrary interruption of a historical time period, Policy A-4.2 of the Comprehensive Plan's Future .and Use Element Hates, "In order fo protect the City's historic resources, the Land Development Regulations shall include provisions for designation of historically significant buildings, structures, archaeological sites, or districts. The City Grdinance 15-(}9; Del-Ida Park Histt~ric District Resurvey HPB Meeting September 16, 2Gt}9; Pace 7 of 8 shall conduct periodic neighborhood surveys to identify and evaluate potentr'a/ historic resources at (east once every five years." With this adopted policy to conduct surveys at least once every five years, it is unlikely that any potential historical resources within a designated historic district would be unprotected as they would be reviewed at least every five years. Further, the City's historic district records would be consistently up to date. In considering the suggested omission of 1965-1970 from the POS, this Policy would ensure that those years will be reviewed no later than 2014. Based on the justification noted in the report regarding the significance of Post-V~JWII development and the emphasis provided on the Contemporary-style, the Board may find it appropriate to adopt the recommended POS extension to 1965, and reclassify 48 structures as listed in Exhibit A. National Register of Historic Places {NRHP} As previously noted, the resurvey report recommends that the City seek application for listing of the Del-Ida Park Historic District on the NRHP. It should be emphasized that the subject Ordinance recognizes this recommendation but upon adoption the Ordinance will not automatically put forward an application for NRHP listing. Once the City is prepared to seek Fisting on the NRHP, additional steps will be required for application submittal which would include, but not be limited to, a workshop with property owners, and public hearings held by both the HPB and City Commission. COMPREHENSIVE PEAN Pursuant to CDR Section 2.4,5{M){5), Findings, the City Commission must make a finding that the text amendment is consistent with and further the Goals, Objectives and Policies of the Comprehensive Plan. Ordinance 09-08 amended the I_DRs to provide for Section 4.5.1{N), Criteria for Change of Historic Classification. During the review period for Ordinance 09-08, the reviewing and/or approving bodies found the amendments to be in conformity with the City's Comprehensive Plan, as follows: • The Historic Preservation Board held a Public Hearing for Ordinance 09-08 at its August 6, 2008 meeting. • The Planning and Zoning Board held a Public Hearing for Ordinance 09-08 at its August 18, 2008 meeting. • The City Commission held a Public HearingJFirst Reading for Ordinance 09-08 at its September 3, 2008 meeting, and a Public HearinglSecond Reading at its September 16, 20{78 meeting. Therefore, the subject Ordinance may be found to be in compliance with the City's Comprehensive Plan as it is in compliance with LDR Section 4.5.1(M), Criteria for Change of Historic Classification. REVIEW BY OTHERS The GRA will review the subject Ordinance at its meeting of September 24, 2009, when a recommendation will be made to the City Commission, ALTERNATIVES 1. Recommend approval to the City Commission of Ordinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 1970, reclassification of 48 properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. 4rdirsarrce i5-09; aei-Ida Park Historic pistrict Resurvey HPB Meeting September 't6; 2rJ~9; Page 6 of 8 2. Recommend approval to the City Commission of prdinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 19?0, and reclassification of 3$ properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. 3. Recommend approval to the City Commission of Ordinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report for the De!-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 1959, and reclassification of 3$ properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. 4. Recommend approval to the City Commission of prdinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report for the Del-Ida Park Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 1965, and reclassification of 4$ properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. RECOMMENDATION Recommend approval to the City Commission of Ordinance 15-09, accepting the resurvey report for the Del-Ida Paris Historic District, including extension of the Period of Significance to 1965, and reclassification of 4$ properties from Non-Contributing to Contributing. Prepared by: Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: • Exhibif A -Recommended Reclassifications • het-tda Park Historic District Map • Ordinance 15-Q3 wifh Attachments A and B EXHIBIT A -RECLASSIFIED PROPERTY LIST Address Year S le 412 NE 2" Avenue 1955 Ranch 503 NE 2" Avenue 1947 Streamline Moderne 706 NE 2" Avenue 1953 Frame Vernacular 524 NE 3 Avenue 1947 Frame Vernacular 543 NE 3 Avenue 1955 Contem ora 701 NE 3 Avenue 1955 Contem ora 703 NE 3 Avenue 1955 Minimal Traditional 209 NE 5 Court 1949 Frarne Vernacular 215-217 NE 5 Court 1952 Contem ora '~ 223 NE 5 Court 1947 Contem ora 225 NE 5 Court 1947 Mason Vernacular 226-228 NE 5 Court 1953 Contemporary 10 NE 5 Street ]..963 ~ Contemporary ~ 14 N 5E '' Streei 1963...... 'Contemporary ~ 18 NE 5 Street 1963 Contemporary 22 NE 5 S eet ~ - 1963 Contem ora 102 NE 5 t _.____ r-1964 ~~ Contem ora 106 NE 5 Stree# ' ' 1965 ~..--- .1965 T 110 NE 5 Street ; Contempora _. ~Conternporary _ 215 NE 5 Street T 1950 Contem ora 222 NE 5 Street 1953 Contem ora 202 NE 5 Terrace 1951 IVlason Vernacular 204 NE 5 Terrace 1947 Minimal Traditional 216 NE 5 Terrace 1949 Minimal Traditional 234-236 NE 5 Terrace 1954 Contem ora 238-240 NE 5 Terrace 1954 Contem ora 225 NE 5 Street 1948 Minimal Traditional 228 NE 5 Street 1952 Contem ora 10 NE 6 street 1947 Minimal Traditional 11 NE 6 Street 1947 Minimal Traditional 101 NE 6 Street 1949 Contem ora 110 NE 6 Street 1944 Minimal Traditional 116 NE 6 Street 1965 Ranch 14 NE 7 Street 1965 Contempora~_ ~ 102 NE 7 Street 1953 PJlinimal Traditional _ 113 NE 7 S etr et ' 1962 Contemporary 11 E 'Street - 1948 Ranch 216 Dixie Boulevard 1947 Ranch 219 Dixie Boulevard 1950 Contem ora 220 Dixie Boulevard 1947 Ranch 227 Dixie Boulevard 1949 Ranch 228 Dixie Boulevard 1947 Minimal Traditional 240 Dixie Boulevard 1953 Contem ora 109 Fern Court 1954 Ranch 20 Lake Court 1952 Ranch 202 Palm Court 1948 Mason Vernacular 531 North Swinton Avenue 1947 Mason Vernacular 721 North Swinton Avenue 1956 Ranch Note: Shaded addresses are (hose properties omitted from reclassification in Alternatives 2 and ~. T21 ~~ 'IOi2 .9a~ia ata 711 5 105 708 701 ~ 't17 G~. ~ Q N.E. 7TH ST. ~`1' 61}5 14 t02 .1p W. 515 <~ r '1'1 `~? 01 105 Zpg N.E. 6TH 5T. W 531 10 ~~o a6 ~~~ ~~ ~, W 521P,~t~, `~ Q 4` ''~ _..~~4', 23p ~~ ~ ~UL.EVARd 3a0 723 703 7{i1 ~ . ~jj ffjjjjjj[[[[[[jjjjE ~~~ i ~~ EE ~ ~~ l f N.E. 5TH T ER R. v ~' ~ ~~ - ~! '~Q ''~ 524 ~~~ ~ N 204 co m N ca c~v 238 *a ~ ~ ~~? _ J T~,, ~ 2t~1 209 r. ~ cNV ~ ~ 524. ~' 1 ~ 52t3 ~ ~~ ~' ~~ ~-~ N.E. 5TH CT. p ~~ r,~ r~ c'`'" ~ ~ ~ 1tI1 ~~~~ O 2~0 218 511 3 213 225 . a 51 ~ ~~" t t~~ 5~5 ~~ N.E. 5TH ST: 4'tT +l~G~. 49 5 N cn c5 418 ~ c D N 41 ~ ~ .. . ` ~ ~ ~~ 15 1111 103 111 ~ ~~ 1 ~') 7 z ~ ~ ~ 4fl3 AdI'1 N.~. 4TH ST. S .. T Pt~ c ,~ DFFI ~E ~ ,-,,,,,,,, _'~ ; N HIST~}RIC DlSTR~CT ~ '"'"''" -]LdBRlBURYEY Qry fF ~7~RAY ~YiS'fi..tl LQ±~ATIC?N MAP p Y -._- ~: ~.-~ ~ t r r F Jk ` ~ L- ~. _'7 ~ r~ ~ . ~ ~~'. ~ 3~ ,~.,~€• ' S~ ::~ ~~~ ~~a w i < d Lj~ ' ~ ' t ~ ~ ~. rte" ~ ~ ."':~,.` ~+ ~ ; .t1: ' .. ' 3 ~~ r , LrI ~ ~ :. ~ t -~ } ~~ ~.. -~ r ~ ~ ... ~ ~~if ` ~ ~ •. ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~~ b •~ t, ~~. ~-. `'~. -1 -~a. ~~ ' r c r ^ v; A F ~' .~ _ ....,, F ' s ~- f L. eft ' -~:~ ~~~..... a~~l> >' ~ ~~ i f _ ~^ • ~ - 'w ~ 2 7 . ..r r J-= ~ I 'a " ~' ~ 85 .~ `E~r~ ~ ~y~ $ ~ t~ _ar. 3 S <~ . .+~° 4 ' ti+~. •• ~ z _ ~ ~,, ~°~ _ ~ - ~ ~V ~ 1 Yi. ~ ` ~ ~ Y = •' i S ~ :.y K'~' ~x }Y~ tl~ H '7> ~ • ~ t .'fit ~4 S' x~ w..: ~. ~ ~ ~ ~'' ~ s j s ~ :~ ~ : `s _ c t ` :*, 1 R,y.Y 'hm~~t. v. i.. .~. ~ s ,, } S ~h .w,r~r», .4 ~'' wt ~ § T r, ~ Y 1' ~~ 7ril' -~~~ ~' ~iE 1~ V `(I( ~ J~ • ~. ~': i ~ ~~ t E r~ ' t ~` r~~~ ~, ~` ,~, ~~ ..~. ~ ~ ~# 5.: ~ ~/~ (6 ~' ~~ ©' ,~.~ O ~ '~ ~ Q t N ~ } i . ~ O . ~ (~ H t/'f ~ .~ ~ ~ ~"~' ~ ® ~ ~ ~ ~ i.a ~ N ~ tV ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .,,. ~ ~ Q? EL i2 Q L.L. ~ . r ~ ~ Cy , ~ L .... L . ~ ~r ii. ~ r..i++ ~ V r V ~-+ ++..~.~,~ {~} ~ ~ ~ *4u-vim mow. -w» ~.. :+v..~ .. .u. ..••i w.....~ M0... a...r. n ~. - ra ~, C ~ ~1 ~ ~y tii dd ~ (~ '~C' ~~ ~ ~~. f Q ~` Q ~ ~ ~ ~ N to t ~ af?' ~ ~ ~ , .~ rya cS~ n -C ~ ~ 'ti`~ ~ ~Z ,~~ ~ SZ~ 9 u~ $ZZ ~ „~/ ~ ' ~ ~~. N (lI ~~ ~ ~ 9l~ o ~ > r ~ #~.~' ~ w ' '~ ~ ~ ~ ra ~ ~ ~ o ~ .N ~ ~ .. j ~ ~ O ~ Xl ~ ~ ;~ ~ h~V ~ ~ '- ~/Vy~ . ,. a ~ ~ N r ~ 'Y ~ ~V~ ~ cc . r„ ~, ~. +tt ~ ~ p 8 G Z ' '~' v3 P ` ~., tq ~ ~~~~~ ((~~ ~•ti` ! ~I1J~ ~ ~~~~ i ~"~ V~~ ~, ~. -%-~ u'; L +-~ . ~`: -L^1 .,U L 0'' t1~~ i .~~, \/ ~'; ~. t"C3' ~~ U .~ t~A ~ ~ _ s~ . 4- p ~ ~ ~ C} ~ ~ ,~,,,, '~"'' cn .t~} {U ~ ~ ~ ca :~-+ C ~ a s.~ :~, ~y„ ft3 -i-~- C ~ = QJ ~ ~ ~ tU C3~ ~ ~ v ~ c~ ;~+! ~ ~ ~+- ~ ~ ~ n ~ Q ~ L .~,, /~`+~ 1w.1 v 'Z~ cU ~ 4- C} tit? V ~ t't~ ~ ~ ~ ~. C3 p(} +~ .~ ~' cn ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~~ v~ a, o~ cn +~ ~ ~ ;~- w ~ ~ c~c ~- ~ •y' o a L N ~ C~ C~ ~ .~. .+. L 4- ~ Qt t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tc3 ~ +~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c~'n t~ cti '~'' ~ ~ •~ o ~ ~ o a} ~ F- ' . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Q? ~ ~ ~ +~ ~ c~v O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ v ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ q,i V't `+= c/'y ~ ~ aA -~ p .~ ~ o ~ .N Z3 ~ .~ v CL ~ ~ ~ cn ._ ~ ~} ~ ~ ~ Q U ~ ~ cU ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ _v cart - s v ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~--' ~ C1,} ~ ,,~„ l~ Z:3 ~ ~ +~ a~ ~ Q -~ ~ ~' m rn ~~, `'- ~ ~ •- ~ to ~ ~ ~ tU ~ ~ ~ .}_.t •- ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ 'Z~ ~C ~ p ~ ~ ~ ~ v O ~ 4- cll ~ ~. ~ °' ° ~ ~ O ~ c~iy ra ~ a U au ~ a .~ a-_+ .~ CU ~5 fl ~- s. cn C cL~ ~- s {U a D } CL ~ ~, ~ z ~ a ~ ~ •~ a ~, - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ft~ ~ +- ~t~ (t ~ s ~- cn a z3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t {ll `,t t.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o • ~ ~.? ~ .~ na ~ y w ~ ' n~ {{ W ~ -a in o .~ ° - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ '~ N V ~ ~ ~ .~ (/} ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ s_ ~ ~~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .O L a , a N ~ c6 ~ ~` Q? s- Q} ~ ~ ~ `~~.,' ~ ° v ~ ~ ~ .~ cts ~ _? ~ ~ ~ .~.- .~ ., ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ .N ~ ~ ~ ~ c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4= ~ ~ ~ ~' ~- o - ~ cu r s W y„_ _ ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t,~ tJ ~ ,~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ U ~" ~ `~ ~ ~' o ~ ~ ~ 'i ~ ~ ~ ~ _~ ~ .~ U c~. ~ ~ ~, ca ~ cn ~ '~ .~ ~ ~. '~ C ~ ~ '~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~ ~ +L i.. ~ 'F'd ,~„~ W `~ ~ '% ~ ~ v U .~ ~ ~ O OC '- i ~ ~ .~ C~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~, ©.o a ~' ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ L O e"'a cU ~ U _,~.~.._._ ~~_,T = ~ ~ a--~ (~ ~ a..~ ~ QJ ~ ~ O ~_ L ~ ~~ ~ • ~ I ~ ! O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~k O~ ~i Z'"I~ ~~ V- ~, ~ ; ~r. ~~ i ~5 n~ V ~~ 'V lR~ ~~ ..'; `~~ 4,;; Q', S .V L: Q' . ~~~ ~.~ ..~' ~~ ~` LJp .. W V u. ~Z V V 0. 'i ~~+ .~ ~~+ .~ a1 .~. Q a--~ O X U ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ O ~ .U L O •> ~ a_+ U ~ N a_+ ~ ~ O p O ~ N a--~ ~ U O ~ ~- ~- .~ •~ N N ~ ~ ~ ~ U N f6 ~N ~~ O Q . O O h~ v L a--~ U L U 'L O _N a--~ a--~ N O f6 a--+ f6 aJ ~2 N L co 'L a--~ .N O a--+ N ~ a--+ . N Q N O ~ a--~ N ~ U N In (~ v ~ L O Q _ O N ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O O ~ ~ O U N U ~ +L-+ ~ N ~ ~ ~~ ~ +~ N ~ +~ ~ L Q O Q ~ U O ~ ~ O~ U ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~' L U L ~ ~ ~A ~ ~ ~ ,~ .. N ~ a--~ ~ _U 'L N O a--~ W V_ LL Z X Z Q J V 0. 'i .~ .~ a1 .® .~. L ~ ~ N Q ~ ~ ~ L •~ ~ ~ ~ .~ }~ ~ ~ -~ f6 ~ a"~ O }' ~ ~ ~ ~ a--+ ~ U ~ a--' aJ ~ ~ ~ O - U ~ ~ QJ 7 Z N L ~--, ~ Q ~ N O ~ '~ ~ O U p +~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ - ~ ~A ~ ~ ?~ O O v O ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ L ~ ~ m ~ O .i ~ U ~ O N ~ L N L O QJ ~ r ~ ~ a.., .L ~ ~~D ~ O O L O _ .~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ L O U .O +~-+ `~ ~ N ~ ~ U ~ ~ +~ vi i +~-+ a--+ U ' L ~ a--+ O ~ L 4 N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~• O L ~ X a~-+ ~ O U U 'L ~ N ~ a--~ ~ ~ 'L O N ~ > QJ ~- O ~ _ . L +.+ ~ ~ Q • ~ _ ~ _ ~ ~ }, ~ a_+ , O ~ Q • ~ U a~-+ ~ U L ~ ~ ~ -~ _ Q • ~ O N > N -~ ~ U Q O N ' ~ -~_ U ' L ~ N +~., ,~ N ~~ O ' L ~ +-+ • i U `'~ U ~ Q U ~ Q • O ~ U ~. ~, I QJ ~° ~3 ~. I ~ ~` L V' ..._, L ~' ._ 0 V' .= -L~ 0" . ~, L. C~ ~° ~~ ~? ~~ F. Ct3 Q ~ ~ t~ ~ ~ a-+ L ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~-+ ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ CQ ~ C41 •- ~ O ~ a.7 LL ~ ~ ~ i Cll ~ ~ ~ {~ ~ ~ ~ ~' '~+- tai ~; ~~,,,~ {ll ~ .~-~ +_+ hA R'~ ~ ~ ' - t~ C? -~'' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W p tU ~ ~ tl1 .N ~ tti ~ s' ~ ~ ft3 ~ ~ ~ cn . to s_ tl.I ~ ~ RT tJ'1 Q} ~ cn - -~ Ct3 tU to ;~,,, 4l ~ .~ ~ c~ ~ ~. ~ ~.-` ~ _ ~ ~ Z'3 ~ .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ `~ ~ ~ t~r~ ~ ZS tU can >" © ~ C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '~ +~-~ :%" ~ ~ '~ ~ ~ •~ ~ ~- ~ p to CLi ~ ~ o sz 3 Q~ ~~ a~ "~ ~ ~ ~ z~ ~ .~ ~ ~ u Q n~ cv •;, ~ v ~ ra c~u tL~ C~ u i ~ ~" 'i tLt ~+ {ll cry '~ ~ ~O~°° ~~~ ~. Q~, Up fir. ~. ~~. ~~. ~:. O ~ =+` V'' ,:._ Vd iY~~ L,: ~o=~ ~~~~~~. +-+' ...^~ u L. S ~. ~~ ~' I' ~' ~? .O •_+ z C f~ +~+ +~+ u J •-+ •-+ 0 u ._ +~+ .;. o ~ > ~ ~ i o c~ _ , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U v~ f6 ~ ~ ~ N +, v +, ~, ~ 4- +~ ~ ~' O ~ O v p ~ ~ ~ O ~, U ~ Q O +~ C6 ~--+ V ~ v ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ +~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ N - ca ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ o ~ i , ~ ~ Q ~ O . ~ ~ ~ wo _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ``'~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ a +~ ~ ~ ~' ca ~ ~ ~ p ~ ~ O - C6 ca ~ ~ O U N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ' N C! ) ~ ~ ~ iJ N C6 C6 ~ dJ i Q ~ ~ ~ a'' C6 dJ dJ •- •- N U ~ ~ ~ '~ ~-+ U C6 C6 ~ ~ _ O i ~ ~ ~ tzA v ~ 0 ~ ~ , vii O ~ O ~ ~ ~ O 'wo ~ a a~ °~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ a~ ~ a~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U dJ Q ~ ~ i a. v i a. ~ Q N N o o c~ o ~ o o c~ .~ i 0 4- dJ O U ~, wo ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ N ~ ~~ > a~ ~ ~ +~ wo ~ °' ~ ~ ~ ~ . '~ U ~n ~ U ca ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ -~ ~ ~ }' N = i O v ~ O +, ~ O :+-' ~ ~ ~ ~ O c~ ~ ~ ~ O -_ ca ~ ~ ~ N ~ ,~ ~ ~ ~, a.~ ~ v o ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ Q ~ ~ O O ~ o 0 ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ 0 v ~, a~ i . ~ .~ O v i ~ > . ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ N 4- +~ ~ ~ t, O ~ O ~ tiA ~ O dJ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ N i ~ ._ dJ ~ O ~ Q N ~-+ ~ i ~ , C1A O i ~ ~ ~ dJ .~ U - , Q V ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f C6 _ ~~ ~ O ~ u ~ ~ '~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ • ~ ~ o V ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ .O ~ z ~ O U ~' ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ v U .~ ~ 4= ~ '"~ ~ ~ ~ .~ .~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ~_ +~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ a~ ~ ,N C6 N - a~ v ~ ~ '~ ~ ~ 0 • ~ v .N ~ ~ Q Cll cn ~ .,-+ ~., cv .y-+ ~ N~ ~ ~ 4) N O p (11 ~ tU ~ ~ C ~ N ~ ~ to S~ ~ ~ tt3 p ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t~3 v }, N O~ N ~ t1 rj. '" L U C) ~ O ~~-' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cry cry :~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ •~ ~ ~.. _ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ S~ tai ~ ZT ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _~- £~2 ` ~ J ~ ' ~ ~ tU -~ ~ O -C ~ ~ ..C C? ~ i~~ Q V' ~~ ~$ fir/ ~ ~ ~i..+ ~ ~ ' ~` S i2 L2 ~ '~'-' i 3 '~ ~""' {13 Cam„} ~ 4 ~ '~ N ~ ;~~'~ '~ "~'3 Q tL ?~ ~: ~t ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ p t3 tU ~+- S2?~' M.,~ E .... C:1 • ~ ~ 1.~ ca . '~ to ~ ~ ~ to Q ,h; . v ~ Z3 . {~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ sA/. '~ try (~ ~ .~ ~ ~ .~ ~ cry +-+ ~" tl? ... ~.. ~ (U t6 +.' U ~ Cl} ~ :h.r tB ~ t'6 :-- t.} 'i3 ZZ .,... . ~: W `,,;fir q1 ~ ~ i ~+= C +-+ t13 ~ ~ 'a-..: - ~ ~ -• p ~ s_ .~ c~ to ~ ~ . :h, O C3 ~} > t~iy Z3 ~' (,,,~ ~ d- C N ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ .~, c- (17 ~ ~ O ~ . V N = S_2 Q ~ O U , CJ ~ i ~ try -y-+ ,~ { ~ ~ ~ S t 5 ~} ~ a q,} C~ R3 ~ t~lJ 'i ~ ~ ~ K E"="' ~` ~ ~ ~ i '~~, Cpl} `.~"~, .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.., _ ~ .~ ~_ W ~ ~ ~ ~ O th t'~''t3 ~ ~ CC3 ~ ~ ~ .i = vi to +-' ,~.,' l/1 W r~ ~ '~'~ .1-r ~ „~ ~ ~ ~ ~ to Q L Ul #'3. ~ Q ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ Q +-+ ~ to N p }. N p Q ~ ~-+ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -~ try ~ 't"' ~ ~' ~ C Q ~ tU d (~ ~ ~ ~ ~ V ~ ~= ~ ~ ~~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~} ~ t13 {l} ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ O 4= ca tv to N ~ t~A t1} ~ .~ ..~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ to ~ •~ +-+ +~ cn +-+ ~ ~ ~, 1 ~ ~ ~-+ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ X31 a` ~~ c~~ ~; ~~ ~' . r.r. =E-+ ~~ ~. ~:: ..:.. ~ o ~: _, V L f ~, "tiff CIS ~` 0~~ 0 ._ 0 0 1 u c=c~ .~ ,a a a .;. i i3 V C? ~+-~ v'~ cu ~ u Q ~ ~ fa ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~n o Q cu F- ~ a-~+ ~ ~ ~ ~ R5 ~ ~ ~, ~ © ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e~ ~., ~ ~ v ~ o > z~ tt'! ~ .~ ~ ~ "'~ ~ sZ ~ N ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ _ to ~ ~ ~ d v v ca ~ ~ ~ v a z~ v ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~' .~, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .+.~ ~ tt'f ~ {Z} Ct~ ~ Lx.I cu p cu ~ ~ ~ ~ r~ r~ ~ ~ ~ c ~ u, cu ~ ~ ~ ~-~' ~ ~' ~ CL} ~ ~^ ~ + ~ ~ ~- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ `~ o ~ ~„ ~ ~ ca ~ ~ ~ ~ s- -~ ~ ~ ~ v, `~' ~ ~ • ~ ~ ~ v :--~ ~ `p ~ a • ~ ~„ ~ ~ C:~ . _. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 's- CU x .~ ~ O +~ - {~ ~ cv ~ ~ ~ ~+-~ ~ ~ ~.- ~ d- ~ ~ ~ L. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ..~ ~ m ~ cu O +~ ~ c,.y ~ ~ ~ ca ~ to CQ C} ~ CU L ~ p - ~ ~ ~ c., ~ ~ t„ cn ~ ru .,.~ ~ ~ ~, ~ .~, r~ ~ ~-.+ Q,} ~ ~ ~ y ~ t~v -~ ~ ~ ~ cn ,~,, res ~ ~ qa ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '~. ra ~ ~ cU ~ ~. ~ .~ v ca 0 0 ~` V ssi +-~+ ~: =„ ~` 1> ~' ~ . ~~ ~u /!~ ~' Z3 ~` 0 O U O Z !xA ,~ .t? .,.. L aA .~ ~i t.,) O :~-.+ t't3 ~` v CCS v .~ N ~ ~-.+ ~ C3 tU ~ ~ ~ i~ ~-.+ • ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~-_+ ~ V -l--+ .~ .~ . ~n v .~ a-.+ fi3 O v ~ ~ ~ L {'~ Q ~ v ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ .~--+ ~ ~ ~ ~ Q~ .. ~ c Q ~; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, 'u V ~ •#+- fC3 ~ ~ C} .~ .~, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ } v ~ ~ .~ 4 s- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ N ~ •~ ~ •- v ~ try ~-.+ t/'~ ~ tt3 -i-~ Q Q CL ~ ~.? U .~ ~ . "~ ~ S ~ ~ ~+- - C3 fl3 ~_ ~ ~ •~ .~. tl7 ~- ~ '•~ 0 ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o t{. V ~ .~ ~~ v ~ 4- ~ ~ ~~ ~~ .o ~ ~ a~ +~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. +~ ~ ~ +a ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z-~ v ._ ~ ~ 4 try ~ ~ ~ tt~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~,,, ~ - tt~ ~ ~ tty ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Ct3 ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ •- ~ U ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ O ~ ~ +-+ ~ ~ U cll .cn ~ dA "~ ~ .~.., g S~ Q ~ p ~ R3 i ~ Cg V dJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s~ ~--' tl') ~ u ~ ~-' a a~ ' ~ o ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ 0 a o ~ .~ u ~ ~ °; ~ s~ ~ _ ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ CAA ~ ~ ~ v 'x ' +_- ~ ~ '+ cn Q ~+- ~ ~ cn t ~- ~ ~+- p ~ ttf s- CkA {ll ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~_ ~ ~ ~ #~ }~ . v ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ ~ ~ -~ ~, au ~ ~ `" ~ a~ ;~ ~ • L ~"~ ~ C3 L ~ (~ L ~ ('l'~ ~ ~ ,, ~ µ,_ ~ ~ ~ ~ tU . ~ i © CtA q} ~ ``'` J d -~ ~ Q ~ © . ~ f13 ~ J aA • • V ~ L ~ .s ~" ~ ago ~'' c~ .~ ~ ,.~. 'u ~ ci. a. ~ o ~ ~ ,~; v _ cyc - ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o v C'~ ~ cu 0 ~ ~ ~, ~ +-' ~ ~ ~ ~ • ~ s3 ~ O ca v i 0 L V7 ft3 t1. 's. . 4 ~+- O L {!~ .~ a~ 0 .~ .~ ~- .~ C3 V ._ ~` L. ~? ~'~ ~. s ~,.~, ~ ~: ~~ s ~_ ~~ 4 ~' t,3 ~~ ~~ 0 ~.T ~ ~ fti. ~~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ o a ~ +~ ~ ~ c~ ~ ~ ~ 4~A . ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ C v ..~..., -~ - Rf ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ;~ ~ ~ ~ '~ ~ ~v p o 'ci3 ~ u' ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 c~L V ~_ v ~ v v O v aA ~ m~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~-+ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cn ~_ .Q c"c3 t3 ~ C} ~" CL1 ~ ~ ~ L +1 t'.~ ~ v Z3 ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ '~"~ O Z3 ~ u~ q .. v '~""' ~ p V u ~,, ~ ~ ~ tU CAA v~ ~ '~ ~v u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~_ v tLT ~ ~ ~ !~ ~ ~ g v ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L aA }-' s- ~ fl ~ y ~ ~ _Q ~ S1 ~ :~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ Q tti 4- ~ +~ ~ ~ ft3 •i v v Z3 ~,,,, ~ ~ ~ fCS ~ ~ w,,, ch V L +_+ -~ ~ to tU Cll U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ct3 p d Z3 L ~ ~ ~ ~ V (~,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;~ ~ ~ ~_ ~ ~ ~- c~i"f '~ ~ vii a, ~ ~ O Z ~ U ~' ~4 V' ~, ~: ~' i V L, t£ f7 i-- ~' ~~. ~:}? to ._ ~_ ~, ~ 6 . ~l ~` ~~ ~` Q3 .~ i u .~ ~- ~~ m ..., CJ .... ~. q N s..,, W a .~ t~U .~ "{.~ v ~. .~ -~ ~~~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ tU ~ .~ ~ ~ ~- N s~. ~ ~ u o ~ ~ ~ ~ ?~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N a-' ~ ~ t.3 ~ +o, ,~ to"" ~p cn ~ a ~ Q ~ a a s~ `~- ~ ~ ~ '~ 4 cL ~ ~ ~ ~ C3 -~ `t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cU C'} -.~ .+-' •~~ ~ `~ 4 -~ .~ L *~~~.~ ~V t~ . a ~... v ..a.~ ~_ S "~ a a V v ~~ V ~ ~ ~ ~ :.~ v •~ s~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~+~ ~'' ~ Z3 Cl.~ v t'~ ~ ~ ~ •~ -~ ~ .~, ~ p ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ `~ ._ °' o v cu ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ •- ~i t~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ cL•- ~~~ a ~ ~ ~ 4- u a, ~ O -a ~- ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ a~ ~~ ~ ~ a ~ 'N L '~ `a} ~ ~ ~ C> _~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ N Q j }, a--~ ~n , ~W a 'i ~ t~ ~ ~3 ~ ~ ~ ~. v ~ °_ ~ ~ C3 =cn t~A ~ U fg •tn ~ 5 ~ ~ ~ ._ O ~ ~ i L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ +~ ~ ~ ~ o ° ° `~ +, •1 ~ Tr A` LJnj v ~ ~ {3 ~ ~ cn ._ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ C} ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~++y 41 -•y` +-+ CC3 Q ~ ~ cn a 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- - c~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ .~ a~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ p .~-~ ~ 4 tll ~ ~? v L ~_ z~ '#~ N C) ~~ W CC3 U ~ - :+%- a ~ ~ a~ ~ '~ ~ ~ ~ ' . ~~ N Q ~ ~ cn ~~ ^ ~ V' ' sz. ~ pr ~ ~_' L ,~i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v V` 1~ ~~ ~ ,.y ~j/ 3.~~ ~ ~ :~ ~ a ~_ ~ ~ ,~ 4 ,- a r.a` 1~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.}~ t~ ~} ~[~ 1i/`lYh 7I = ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~,J S.L. V' C R •( L ~ ~ ~ 1MM ~ S~ ~ C.} /~~ ;~/ (J} `/ i T iP ~ /~ Yl ~ ~~ ~ ~ (!~ t w./ / \ IV AI V • ~ ~ W i ~ '""~w HM ~ `~'d ~~ ~ ~ ~ F ~ ~M T' yd /'R S~ L ~' ~; ~ p I ~ ~ ~ pC cn ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ , J ~ ~ • ~ ,~,r a.d ~ ~ ~ 1e V iii ~ U t/~ ~F-+ ~ L ' .~ ~-- d. ~' ~ ~ n O c ~ cn . 4 V VV •~ W ~,, cn > (~ J ~ U z3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ,,, a ~ ~} Q ,~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ * s~ .~ ~ '~ ~ ~ t d ~ _ ~ o ~ ~ ~ W W _ Q c~ c~ c~ v ~ o 0 .;. .;. c1'f L s 0 ^N W •~ a~ L .~ L m a C31 C7 C~ N w V Z 0 z 0 c .~ z~ c cv il} Q} {.~ .~ S .~ Q t!9 c v I ~.~.. .~ .;. v cu •~ v .~ L ,~-+ 1 4 L c~ u. c~ f° V Z tL' .~ V r~ a~ G"f .~~ N ~--~ ,N v L ~~ i/~tJ Y `~ Y I a~ .~ c .~ u O tg U O L •{~ ~ ~ a~ s~ ~ O ~ ~-+ '~-' v L v ,,,, +~ cn ~~ +~ ~ ~ •~ o °.~' ~ .~ c~ ~ L ~ .+~ ~ ~ u .,., ~ ~ ~. ~ ..1 t!) ~~ `2~ ~ T "~~ ~~ j~ ~w1 W ~ ~ N ~ ~.} ~ ~ r~s c.r ~?` a o /~ ~ V y~, T ~ ~ .~ ~ S. 4- L ~. d ~ ~ v ~ 0 Q m N U a~ ac r ozS °J p u {`~ ~ ..~ -F-~ t!} VL! W ~"`~ - i (~IWi `,~+. _~ ,._ cv v ~ ._ ~, +~ ~ Y `~ t3 ~ ~ ~ ~ v _L ~ a ra 0 v L .a +-~ x ~~ Y /' .~ •~ 0 i!! M`~ ~~ u i.. ~. .,.: LL S :, j #°~~ ~. v, ~~ 5~ ~ ~' ~ N ~. ~' ~ ~ ~ 3 ~~. (~ `i V ~ ~ ~ ~- ~'~ '" y ~~ ~J!q~'k `ti.J t ;i ~ C W ~~~ *riM/ .}.7 ~} ~i t..~ 1if v s... ,~ _ Q ~ O V Q m LU Z ~' N 0 m ~x N t1J Q7 ~.u Z c7 tU C s.. a -~ 0 tU .~ t'C~ Q ..®. '~3 Ri ._ {~ } Q f^J W m O tt'a as F~ its w C~ N Q u u~ w N N ~~~ ~F ~, ~~ V' ~: C6` ~, i .~, V' .:,~. ~. ~} ~~ ~': Cl~~ .= u L rA7~6~ 1~ tt5$ i` Q~`. ~~, O .~ ~.+ .~ tII H {p .~ ,~ J ~. a~ c O X ~_- a~ a~ ~~~ s~ • c~ ~ ~ '~ o ~ - a o cu ~, a ~, rn ~ , ~ ~ -a o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~, ~ v ~ ~,, ~ cu ~ ~ :~ ~ v ~ ~- a o ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o .~ o o ~ ~ z~ ~ ~ a ~ ao cu t,~ ~ ~ ~ o -~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ` ~ v ~ ~ - +~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s~ ~ s ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~' a~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ^ ~~1.! /~+~ '~"~ • ~i.L '~"~ CtA ~ .~ tU ~ ~ v O ~ +~., O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~ -~ ~ ~ q,~ .~ ~ ~ c,a ~ ~„~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~- ~ s ~ ~ g +~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ m ~ ct3 t3 .~ ~ cg ~ .- cU O ~ ~,,,} ~ ~ ~ + +~-~ t~0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c a ~ d +~-~ ~~' c'E''n ~ a ~ ~ f1 _ ~ _ C ~ T3 . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ -~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ° C ~ n ~ ~ ~ - • ; ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ E- ~~ , ~, ~ r t ~ ~_ ~~: ~ ~,' ,; ~: ~~ •;~.. r . ! ~ .' y~ ~~ ; ~, Ot tG w Z tf1 O v 03 F- uJ Z ~' d CV ~.~ ~; Q ~ F ~V t ~_ °'. ~; ~. =~ .~~: ~-. ~~ ~~ c'l! .~_ s:.;, ~. ~~ I~ ~~ Q. V +~ ~- ~ s~. t~ v m ~ ~ r~ ~ .~, ~ v ~ ~-- o ~ ~ y} ~ ~ ~ ~i- ~ ~ ~` ~ ~ . + ~ "C3 ~, N Q ~ to „ ~ a- DJ Z3 'L3 ~ C3 tU " ..~ 0 ~ O = C2. ~ ~ .,~ ~ ~ cu ~ ~- ~ c~ ~ ..~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ .y ~ i~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- s~ Q ~- "~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ~ ~ ~ cL co ~• '~"' 0 a . ~ ~+- ~- ~ C? O v~ ~ -p _ c n ~ cn -~ ~ ~ C ' _' C ;~ ~ _ i ~ rv -I-~ IT3 - ~ ~ i/} ~ . t/7 .~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cn ~ ~ , o as n~ ~. ~ s ~ ~ ~,,, '~3 ' ~ ~ ~ ~ cn ~ ~ ~ ;~ 'v, ~ ~ ~+- .~ tg ~3 C i3 p U cn ~ tt3 t~ ~ tl) N ~ ~ +~ ~ ~ Q,} '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cn ~' ni ? ~ Q :~_+ s2 t0 ~ ~ S cn O C} ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v a ~ ~ ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~`"' t,}.,. ~ ~ ~ • .fit {~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ Cl) ~ ~..i ~ ~ ,y„ ~ N ~ ~ ~ • ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ ~ o o ~ :~ o ~ s~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~ a ~ ~~y L z c 4t N L N L N ppj {~U ~ ~ p vpi ~ L ~ O ~ O ~ O ~L " v'f ~ to ~ ~ ~ •~ ~ ~ O ' ~ ~ t..t ~ C3 ~' ~ •O t 1 ,~ ? rv ~ ,~ a • Q ~ to Z3 ~ ~ ~ O p _C ~ ~ i + c v ~ 91 sZ ~ ~ _. ~ ~ ., O O •- ,_ ~ v ~ O s~ c Q ~ ~ ._ O ~ `~ ~ ~ ~ '- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i p ~ ~ ~ ~ {'~ t U ~ ~ O U ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O • ,~ + a..+ ~ r1 ~ O a=+ ~ O ~ ~ O ~ tn to ~ ~ O > ~ ~ ~ ~ a-+ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ E ~ >~ ~~ ~ V O ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ O ~,,, ~ ~ O L ~ " iT3 ,~, . ~ ,~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ vi O 'C . ~ .~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O }~' .y_ _ . ~ L ..._ ~ O ~ ~ bA ~ to ~ ~ . ~ ~ . ~ t~ O ~ ~ .~-+ ~ ~ O ~ ~ O L ~ ~ ~ .~ C ~ ~ ~ O CU .F.~ ~ N z3 ~ ~ ~ • . ~ v~ ~~ V q • © • ~ ~.~ ~ ° / ~ • ~ ~ ~~ • ~ ~ W ~ a~ V, ~.._ ~ ~ a -c ~ ~ ~ v ~ c ~ v _ co ~ ~ c '~- _ ~ v ~ .,~ p ~ ~ as .4.,, ~ ~ ¢g~ ~~ , ~' •~ ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ O s ax b1J • ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . V'I C~ ~ Ct3 V 1 O O ~ - ~ ~ ~ .f.,+ ~ ~ ~~ ~ O ~ ' i ~ C51 ~, ..C z3 ~ O tU ~ ~` ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ ° ~ ~ ~- ~ ~ ~ ~ a, t~ , o ~ ~, ~ °' ~ ~ ~ o :~ rn ° `~, cv ~ ~ z3 ~ cu Cl~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ °-' ° u r~ a~ ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ s~ O }, ~ c ~ ~ ~ "' ~ - ~ ~ + Q ~ .- .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O O ~ .~ O _ c~ +~ ~ q3 ui ~ .~, N ~ t.3 ~ ~ ~ ~ C6 N ~ Q bA > ~ Z3 '~ ~ cn ~ ~ ' ~ 2 rtT .~ ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ tll Z~ C O ~ t~ R5 N ~ tU L ~ ca ~ . ~ ~ ~ p cri ~'3 V}' ~' O` V •~ • Q' V .~ o~: ~..~ • ~" t],0 L '~ C ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ L 4 - _ ~ O '~"~ ~ CQ '~ ,1~-~ U ,1~-~ N ~ .. ~ ~ ~ U 0 N O ~ - L L 0 ~ L U - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ U. (~ ~ ~~ d-- ~~I- ~ 0 ~ CQ.. ~I- L L _ N ~ ~ N ~ ~. ~ L ~ ~ O -N ~ C ~ O 'L ~ ~ 'N ~ N O N N N O N ~ Q; U O O b''o ~ 'N N ~ , ~ N , C ` ~ •~ ~ Q O O .~ ~ ~ LL ) N N N .V ~ N U N L N ~ ~` LA ~ N U ~ O ~ ~ N ~ ('a (II ~' L O '~ . . ~ ~ O : , L U '~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.. ~ O ~ -' ~+ ~ ~ ~ a -+ ~ 0 fII ~ N fII fII aJ QJ U U N U ~ ~ ~ fII ~ 'L ~ O fII ~ O N N i 'v . U ~ ~ V ~ ~ ~ U ~ v i ~ ~ . ~ .;. .:• ~ • ~ ~ • ~ • o ~ • ~ O dA 'O L ~ ~ N O L O (~ '.' ~ ' C O ~ O ~ ~ "~ N ~ ~ ~ fp N !'a cc C • • ~ ~ ~ C Q) ~ ~ ~ ~ C U ~ L 4- Q ~ L O i ~. u c~ C i i W C v + •~ O ~, ~ N ~, ~ ~ ® ~ L (a ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ dL-~ C ~ ~ ~ O y- ~ p ~ ~ taA a ~ vi ~ aj ~ O ca L ~ O ~ ,N ~ O L _ N U O _ N N L L O v~ ~ ~ `~ ~ C v '~ N ~ ~ ca ~. N O c~ c~ ~ U ~ .~, ~ ca '~ ca .~ ~ ~ Q a ~ a '~ ~ O~ v C L vi +~ ca ~ Q .~, . ~ L ~ a" ~ N +~ y= ~ O -O ~ ~ - O •N ~ N ~ p ~ ~ U ~ O ~ ,C `~ O -00 ~ ~ 4A > ~ v~ a; iJ m ~ C ~ 3 C U ~ ~ ~ ~~, ~ ~ 4A ~ ? ca ~ L ~ ~ ~ ,~ 4~A C ~n ~ v .~ ~ ~ N -O O ~ ~ •- ® L •- fa ~ fII ~ C L ~ ~ L d--~ U O N a--+ Q~ -. U N ~ ~ fp ~ .N ~ U O vi .O ~ 4A .,~., O O pA N `."+~ ~ fp L fII C N U v ~ ~ ~ ° - O ~ ~ '~ a.., c ~ a., ®~ ~ vii cn ~ o O ~ u- -° ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~~ ~ 3 ~~~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~. (,$ ~w/' l ~~ 1 !c ~` ~~ 4 ~ 1 ~~ ~, ~~ ~~ ~' .~ L i ~ ~ ~ C~ ~ s j sa 5 j t~~ ~' i U ~M~1~ T •~r ~. i 4F ~' ~ GC V~r .,~ ~' N ,v ~ 1I ~t ~' in ~. «a,~ ft~~ ~ ~ ` ~ ~~ ~~ ~; ~~ ,_~- L ~' ~, j~1~/ y~~j i» wV' +r ~a t (k (.~'~ ~t~~f rig p F cn; ,. v ~ - ~: _. c6~ T:,~. ~; L ~$ ~~ D L~ G V 4- .~ (t/f V cC ~° 0 L a. cu ~. Q V~' ~r ~,~` ~~ 0 ~' D V ~;, . V N rG in i. ~- ~ cv ~_ V ~' 0. ~ ~~~ ~~" L ~' ~ Us ' "_' ,a ~ ~ N ~~' Q _u O ~ a .~ ~` ~ ~ ~t a. .- O L ~~ =~~ o ~~ a ~~ CUB ~ , ~E i L L 0 Q 0 0 V 0 ~ L 0 0 !'~ L (~ ~ .~:0:- .~d 0 ~ •3 ~ ~ ~ ~ a' O V ~ ° ~ -a M v ~ w Zi ~ z ~ `~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ X11 }; ~ a-+ ~ ~ ~ ~ iJ m U QJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ `~ ~ `~ .~ Q ~ Q w 'cs ~~~. L~...'. ~'!~ .~ , ~, F r ~c _ ~ - j ...,,,, ~ ~r V~ ,._~ i -~-+ ~ ~' o , C31:.~ ~- ~ ` v O ._ `~ ~! V V1 ~'~ ~ - s.,. i ~ ~ ~~ o~ ~± }~ V1' ~ L ~ Vi `" ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ Q ~~, ~, 0 ~"i 5... L 0. mm `V'' ~ 5: : ~; ~~ . o o ~ L ~~ ~ ~o ~. -~ ~~ ~~ o C C O "~ cv L 0 ~ 0 ~ 0 s ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ a, ~ ~ c .ouo c _~ ~ a~ ~ ~ °' c ~ s Q ~ ~ M N x ~ 3 ~ Z ~ ~ c c ~ ~ `a' -~ ~ ~ ~ '~--+ ~ o ~ ~ N _ ~ 00 U ~ ;+_' ~ ~ X ~ ~ CQ ~ U ~ CQ ~ ~ Q ~ Q l1J V ~'" ~~ ._ ~~ ~~ ~>>; ~r ~f r. $. ~- '` -':_ '',. ,. ~~`, ,~ 4 ~f .-,'y 5 ~~ u< 7; °~~ i~:~:/~i U` ~_ ka` ~s: i y„r~`s ~. "ZS ~, ~'' C ;~ .... ~+ •~~ ~~ ~~ ..~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~'~ '~~ L ..~ ~, ~, L a ,~ v .... c~5 ~ ~' =~ ~ ~, cs. :~ ~1 I t t71' ~` i „~ Y.,,. FF~ ~~. f"t~` ~~ ~~ ~` s a -~ =~-1: U9 Y_ L cn ~:~: 0.' :~::r L fl', c.n~ ~-~ .. i.% s. X16 { Cl. i f'~° Z~` CU ~` O .~ v .... '~ G1. .~ C~ Cs. h v' #L ~, I ~~ Cy ..., ~'° ._ V ~o: .~ u }J L I ~~ ~ + ~ ~, •} ~ T ~ + - L/3 ~ ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ~`f ~' ~y L ', , 0. i t ~ V ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a' ~ ~ y' '"; ~ ~~~ ~ _ `~ Y~~ ~~ a }~}~ iV ~ ~ ~ ~st ~ ~^' ~ V ~ ~r ~ ,~ '1 N ... z ~ ~ z,~j ' ;~. ~ _ ra ~ o t ~ t r ' s `~ . ~, , . ~ ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .fi . ~ ~ ~ nA ~ ~ ~ a ~+ c L a .~. v~ ~? ~ ~ s N ~u ,~ ~ LU tti ~ ~ Gi '~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ : ~ ~, ~ .~ ~ ~_ . ~ fL1 iJ CCS L ._ ~! ~, ~,~ ~ ~ ~ +~ _ ~ ~~ ~ `' I% .~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ' L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ tII Q ~ ~ _ ~ .~ {~ {~. ~ ~? V •~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~y~ 1Y ~ ±_ ~ ?- v o ~ ,~ , ~ .:, .~ z~ t ~ ~'~:' i ~ tt..i ca V c~ ~ ~ ~",.4 ,' ~ ct~ A C? Y~/ ! ~ i MM~~ `.... ~t 457 r,' .. - ~ ~' ~ ~ /~~ M/y Si :.. 1 Y ~ ~ ~y ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ i~ ~ d >- Q w s a } ,. , ~ 3 ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ O ~.~ ~ e ~ ~ V / ~ s" _ x t ^ .~{5 T . ~f: ~ ~ o _~ ,, v. . '.. ~ k. ~ i O ~ ~ .;,« ^~ ., .._ ~ ~ L -~~~~.. ~ ~ ~ ~? O ~ ~ r-1 ~ _ ~ ~. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ;t ~ ~ r ~~ g ~ ~ i O O u „ . , ~~ ~~~ { V (n _ ~ ~J ~ x ' ~~,> .~ ~~, aJ V ~ ~ o M1 r ~ ~ ' V~ ~ ~ •Q W i t ~~ ~; .~ .,~, t0 M ~p (~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~H ~~°~".- I V ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~y~~ T O O ~ ~ 4. ~ ~ -. K:~ ~ ~ i v N ~ c ~ A CU ~' ~ ~ ~ v m ~ _ ~ ~~ ` ~ ~ s ~ ~ ~ V ~~ ~ ~ ~ Cp U Cp _ L •~ N ++ ±~ ~ ` ~ _ ~ u1 Q y- Q w ~ ~~ t~A ~ ~ _ O •H ~ ~ '~ a .-- : ' ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ am . ~ .., , , ~~,~~~'''~ ~ i G ! Y`.. € ~ < W O ~ ~ y ~ . ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ..Ip fT +~ O •_ ~ E w VIA __ ~, ¢~•`"'rti s. ~ O ~ •~ •V d ~ :. -,. t~. ~ ~~ V ~ -~ ~ i i -~ `~ ~ ^ A ~ ,v ~, C t ~ ~~ ~ ~' LJJ M ~ Q. ~ ~ ',~ ~ O O _ . J .w N ~ ~ O ~ ,~ ~y ~ ~.,. . E ti-~ l ~r d~p '{~ ~^ ~ G1 ~ ~ . Cp U Cp F ~ Q ~ Q V°F .. ~ ~ c!)= p _ CT'~ . _ ~' . $ u ~~ [ s~ 1,, ~! _ i%~ Ll~ ~ . L ~ u ~~.. ~' ~ ~~ ~~ ~.. (~~ ~~ ~ . ~..~.. I ~ '"' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ry , , j / ~ V w / ~ ~ , ; s ~. ~; ~' ~- i,,, Q -~. ~ .~ a. L~1~ '~- _' +. T~ ~ V~ C1.0 ~ ~ .~ ._ ~ 3 +~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ :'= ~ '- -~ _ +~ o ~ °'~ ~ o ~ ~ °.~' z~ ~ ; ~ ,~ ~ a~ " ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ tom?! ~ ~ O cu ~~ a= c ~ ~ ~ ~" fl ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ cu ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tc ~ F" ~ O 'a t'y CTt ~ #, v O e-t iri = ~ ~ ?" O C11 Cr1 ;~ ~ i p S ~G ~ ~ ~c[ w vair u ~ .~ r n, ,,,-~~., ~~.. __~-~ ,. '~J ~ ~ :~k `~~ . .~~ _ O ~ ~, `'- .C ~ ~ .t2 ~ ~ lll~~~111 ~~y +~ rrr ~ ~ • _ '~ .c oA .~'' ~, ~~ ~ ~ ~ -a +r 0 L ~ f~ `~fl 0 ~ Q Q V ~ .~ ~ ;~=~ ~ ~ ~- CQ ~ ,}~ ~ 0 ~? ~ -` V ~ ~ a ~~~.:. L ,F,. . ~ . Q ~'~' ~ tJ ~ "~ L't ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ H:wl ~ v i ~ f t'=~1~ rl/l .._, it -b=•+' , s ~` ~~ slw"~: ~$ CAA " O ~-+ .~,. ~ ~ ~ ~ .Q ~ .~ _ -~ ~ ~ v > , ~ ~ ~ ~ cu ~' ~- ~ ~ ~ '~ ~ ~ C a ~ a v ~ ~ ~ ~ N c~ v a c- ~ ~ ~' = o 4 ++ ~ p U ,~ C ca v ..,. tU .1r"' ~ ~ ~`"' L Z3 C ~, ~ ~ ~ .. ~- = o si a V ~ ~' ',~ ~ {~~ ~ y W L e~ ( 7r ~ ~} .. ~ V ~ ,,. ri ~ m ~' ct~ ~ ~ ~ Cu0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.•~ c ~ ~t ~ d w ~' ~ ~ ~ au o O t3. s r1 ~ .~..t ~„ ~.:.~ ~ ~ ~ ~::. o ~ ~ s: ~ ~: ci ~.. ~ ~ . . f ; , // ~+~a1 ~, .~.r.- ,, ~~:~. `1r ,^3!! '",~ ' i ., ~. ~j` f. V` • =_ z ~ ~~ _ ~L~ «~~ ~. r'. ~~ i'~i+lb .. :^.. '~ .,. ~~~ :~ . ~;-r ~~ i~~.. y':C. . 9 ~,'~ ~ ~ ~ ~y. ~,.. ; ~. , ~. j f f { i~ k ~~ -~~, .,Y~_, a ~~~ l~ S>~ a ,, ', t r "~~-~ ` ~ ~ ~" '` ~ ~, ,, -_ .. ~ ;, { ~ _ ' ~ :; I ti ?r .,~ ~ _ ~__ _ .. 1 ~: ~. _ ~~k~ t ~~~ ~_: ~ ~ ~~_ <~'~ ~;,~ ~f , .. ~~ ~' ~ '` < ji W. ~r~ ~ ._ ~s L ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ cu ~ s ~ c ~ V N L 0 0 ~- '' ~ °' ~ _ ~' ' ~ a ~ ~ ~ /~~ ij( / 711/ ~ /!~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ V X ~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~~-h~ `1n °' v l ~ ~ L !I ~ L •• a d-a ~ ~ tl CD ~ ~ C L ,~ L ~ ~ ~ _ O!3 V /- ~ ~ ~ Y! ¢' ~~ A !a X/ ~ ~~ ~, ~ ~ • ~` t ' •~ ~ } y' l /~ ~ .+ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ._ .~ ~$ _ r% ~ ~~ ~~ ts. ~ ~' ~, ~ CL? a r { '~" f .~ ,~ ~~.. it-' ~_ r `,~ y~ ~, r i; .~ ~ia'"'L-r. ~: . ~".~~ n ~ ~ s = ~ ~ ~ •- 3 ~= *~ ~ X CJ ~ '~ _ ~ •- O ._ ~ t~ '~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _ _ ~ ~ v V'f ~ X v i ~ ~ ~ ~ a C " ~ ~ ~~" t./) 'p ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ty ~ ~ ~ s ~ ° ~ o n ~ a} ~' cv tt . ~ ~ ~ ~ - s cuo . ~ Q ~ Q w ~ L L O ~, ~ O V ~ V • O ~~' ~~, ~ V'~ i ++ O y.. ~~ ~~ ~~ (~, :.~ Q~ •- v i % ~ O ~ ~•- •- c V ~ ' Ir v in ir1 v co ...~ ~ uJ N ~ ~~ \V lk 1~ °? ~ ~ N ~ r-I _ ~ r ~--~ L .. ~ ~ ~ p ~~. ~~ ~ ~ _ ~ u ~ ~ C V` ' _ ~ v °° ~ ~ ao ~~ O ~ co u co .N ~~~ ~~ r , O Q >- Q W '~ ~ ~ , Q O ~, L ~: N L ~=~ •- i Q~ ~~ a ~'; O ~ F .. ~, ~ , we , r 4 ~.. .~ ~ . -~-~~ . ~~ ,< ',~ ~* :; F ~'t , '. a. `,~ ' ~. r ; .t~,;; i 3 ~r;'. 1? r Y~ ~ F ~;~ Y~ +4~ L co c V L ~ N o ~ ~ V ~ C y.. o a~ ~ i c~ V • ~ ~ c~ +~ ~ c s o ~ v z ~' ~^ n ~ Q N o o, ~ _ ~ N ~ ~ .. ~ ~~ O u ~ N ,. v °° ~ ~ ~ t - ~ • L ~ Q ~" Q w -'• ~ '~. +- ~..? ''-~ L ~ I ~`' = O ~1~ ._: 0' •- a-+ v Q •- V` ~ ~< ~ 11~1~ . - ~: ca V l~` _ Q~~ ~ ~~ ~p ~ V _ ~ ' N y , ~. 0 0 . = a ~ .~.. ~~ ~ CL ,a~ ~-, ,~, 0 ~' ~° ~ -Z 3 a ~~ i `:, ~{ :" ' ai: ~_~ i .~ ~` ~ ~ c:A)' d ~.~~ r~ V .~ rwr V, ~ cn .,.~ ~ ~= v ~~` ~ ~ ~~ L i -, .~ ~ - t~ ~ ~ ~L. :~ - t~ ~~ t ~' ~ ~` 3 I ~s ~' ;. . ! ~~ T 1 ~ f ~ ~ ~ry ~ 'rrr ~~ ~ ~~ .16.-1Y ' •* ~ 1 ~ I s~ ^ ~ ~r ~ ~~, ~ •P~' r ~ ~ ` ~ /YI~J ~ V ~ i ~R ~~ 11Y/1~~~ ~~ h b ~ :w ~ ~ ~ '; ~~ •~..: ~ ~~. ~~` ~ ~~/~ is M / ~ ~~; ~ // ~~~yyy Q L y ~ ~~ ~ .... VP I' 1' ~ '"' " ~e ~. CQ C •yAlllyi T ~ ~ a i • ~~ r~ t~ /R ~~ 1/ W~ W 17~R iY ~~/~ • ~ . ~ ~ +~ ~ i T~~ '^J '~ /^4 S.~ Y) ~~ //~~ v! +~ ~ t' rr ~V ~/ ~ ~m, a V ~ ~ ~I~1/ m V + 1 V m a V ff~MM M) ~J! ~~.+'~~ ~~~ ~Y ~~~'' ~" ~ `r E. y .~ ` ~~ ~ r x .fit "~I_, l~~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~; ~~~ .~: ~~ tir/? ~~ ~~ _~; tf }_ yL:1 ~` .~ ~~ ~/7! ~, 1 ~%' ~, ~~ ~~{~s `I~i.. ;' ~!~ ~R' .;_ i~ E ~~ .r. .~ to _~ t.i L 0 4- 'T.3 i; Q C} Ct. _~ ~i~+ L Q. Q L a ... _,. r 1, ~' ~ ~~ ~ S.. ^~ ~ .~ ~~ t-~ ~ . #~ V ~ } r ~- r V can ~' ..._ S.~ ~ V ~~~ ~;.~ \i/f ~ ~. ~ ~ ' y~ ~ ~ { t ~ w~ ~+a _~ ~ {. iri. t ~ ~ ~ ~f It V.' ~ {w"i ~ ~ ~ O ~, Ct. ,~'~ n~ .. y' ~p^~ i~t t 3~ NXr ~ V ~~~ /~V ~d e~Lst't i3`} . ! P. ~ r ~ ` ~•.!•., "~?v~`p ~`~'w •~vY~4. , 86~. ~R'I~'.1~. w «v. ,~ v y t .r A ' ~ ~ I,L ~ ~'. { _ ~ ,~ ~ .;, , . ' '4' •! ~ s ~ - • . ~S ~ ~ . ~. r• N ,, tr •.5€~:~ y y... ' F , '~ ~ ~~ ~ ~. k y ~ Y •~ ~~ ~ _ . yp T- F5 `~~ ~ ~-~ „ ;;~ . W #, X t1? ~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ fl ~ ~ ~ ~ +~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.u ca .E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u e1" ~i .~ i» W , ~ ~ j W ~, ~ ~3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ °~' ;~ ~ ~ ~ o o .~ ,~; a °o s .~ .~ ~, ~, ~ a, L v ~ ~ _ ~ Q ~ aC w V ~ in r~ V . - i ~R O Cr'.` . ~, ~ Chi ' .. ~ V O;' ` .~ ~~~ V ~ = v~ ~ , ~ • i co I o~~ ~ ~} ~~ I ~~ L ~_ ~, ~ ' ~ ~be< ~ ~` ; c ~> '' ~~ . --~ __ ~ L a ,~k ~~ ~ ~ ,.,,., v +. 'w Y D S_. ~, ~ ~ ~' dt, ~~ ~ Q __ ~¢ ~ 0 L -: a ~; ~ r ~+ -a r ~33 r ~~~ ~'~ ty z ~ ~ ~ 7~fM :< x ~ 3 Z ~, ~- y ~,. v ~ tir { ~~ E~ fr ~j n ~' ...,,,,~ r ,,~s ; :~c ~~~f~a ~. ~, x ~ ~, ~ ~~ ~, '~ ~, r ~,., k~ ;,~~ ~-. t 1 ~ _~ _ f ~ ~~ .~ - -,~. ~'±1{` ~~~~`'~- ~ w ,~ ~,~ - .~ +r- ~ `' ,.F --:.C"x.43 ~.. ~i° -- c~ a a~ o a +r '^ a~ ~ W V ~ ~ N ~ N ~ ~ L ~ ~' ~ a °a o n. a ~' ~ a o ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ C1 ++ LA ~ ~ ~ '~ N Q M ri ~ ri - ~ W .. ~ ~ rl N ~' '~ ~ +-' v ~ O +~ ++ ~ II. ~ L L ~ ~ a C1 o ~ Q fB ~- U Q ~ W T t~Jf ~ f~ _~ i ue - O s t'g G ~ ~ `"~"' t"!. Z3 ~ ~ ~ O ,w; ~ ~ ~ dA O ~ ~ ~ , ~ s w- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ s ~` U~ ~ ~ ~ ~ x sip *' ~ ~ ~~ V"} _ p + ~ V ~ a aA C ~ . ~ ~,;, v ,_ ~ c C31 ~' ~ °° '~ ~; z ~ W `" ~ ~ '~ ~k~" ~ ~ .+..n} ~ ~ ~ to i~ ti :d ~. ~ ~ ~ •~ s {~ ~~ ~~y L ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ `~' ~ ~ wr' IfP ~ Q i'~' K~ I.L~ ~~,~~ __.~._ Z, ~ ~ ..~ ~ ~~ -, \/ t ~ -- ~ J. _ _ '~ -- ~ _ ti~ ~ :. . ~ ~ ~- . ~ v. w , _ ~ ~ L ^~~~ xr .~. i,: ~~; \e y~ ~ ~4„-.j - i~ ~w: ~L `~ ` r r :::~: r ~. - ~ _~, ~ ~ ~t /, jy 1 , ~~~ ~ fir /~.~: 5'"= ~ ~ - _ f \ ~ ~ , ,~ , ~ ~ .~ r~'~'. _. ~_ ._ ,,~ s- .~ !~ rat .:` j ' » f~ ~ '. ~:' { ~~: ~ ~;~*i ,; ~ }sl :,~ ~ ~ I• 3~ ., f~+t t '~ ; ~~ ~~ kr :'II N~ j l ~~ r ~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ 1 ~„ fi,';'' :~ _. ~y:: :, t`~~ '~ to ~: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~` wW/ = ~ V ~ ~ ~~ ~ .A..., W o m ~ ~ °~ ~; ~ * ~ ~_ •~ C'7 ~ ~ T ~ ~~ W Q •~ ~ ~ /~/~~~~~ ~ ~ rt~~~y M! T ~i~ Atf. ~s E yh. ~~~ ~` ~~~ ~~~ i r' k 4 ~~; r x Fn I §; u a ~ ~ ~ £y. # ~' .. ~ ~ ti ~, X1111111 ] ~ ' ^H ~" ~" ~ ~ ~- ~ J~ `. ~ L. ~ r 1, .a _, ° r ° , ( ~ y}~y~ ~~ 1i `1 lift ~11~, ... .. rl ~~ i'. •t~~ H /~1 1rAi/ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ r s ~ & Y'e't. , ne E _ ~ /~Tf ~ ~.__ , ~- ~ d ~- ~C w cn ~ ~/ y' } ~ z [1 ~ %~ . *~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O 1 -~- s,. ~ ~ r~ ~~ ! ~ ~ ~~ '~ .~ ~ ~. ~. n~ , ~ ~ ~ C "~> ~ n~s ~ b ~ .~ ~ _ ~~~~ 3 ._ ~, ~ ~.~ ~ E ~~ ~~~ ~ __ i~" {1J t~! ;N ~ ~ ~ ~ CCF to t0 "~ ~- Q W cy/f ,~-_: ~~' ~':'~ ~:, V' ::: . . i ~ ~ p .... C31 ~ u 0- ~ * =~' t~ ~ V = ch ~, ~ ~ c~ ~, ~' ~ ~~ ~~~ ~ ~ C6 in ~ ~~ ~ O ~` ~~ ~ ~ ~ $ ~ ~, s.. ~ ~ ~"+~ O .~ i` Cs. ~; ~'. I' Q' i is K `,: ~ ~ O ._ ~ ~ ~ zs ~ ~ ~ + 1~ 't ~ ~ ,_ tU ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , ;~- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _... ~ tt. ~ to ra ~ ~ «~ ~ X tv ~ ~ ,~ ai v ' ~ at Op cy ~ rr :,.. ~ ~ s~. ~ .. -- ~ O a r~ ~ ~ ~ s ~ -- ~ ~ ~ ~ ,dA ~ Q ~ Q w m V ~~ ~ _ ~' ~} .... 0~` V ~. .~ Ia V t/! t/f ~; ,A, ~ ~ "- t'Q V l~~ ~~ ~~~ ~' ~, i.. ~ ~~ .~:~: ~ ~/ ~ i ~ © L //A ~+ ~ a -`y ~ L. 1f i~~ •- ~"6t ~} ~fi ~ _,: `' tL aJ` 0'° sill~,~ ~ .: ~:° xs.~ ;, ~; ~, ~~ ~ ~- ; i ~* r ~~ ; ~~' ;. ~ _v~~. 4.t ~-+ of .~ ~ .C V _ ~ x. ~ ~ i ~ 'a ~ ~. ~ s o s a~ 3 a ~ ~ s V X ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ u ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . - ~+-~ o _ c u m ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ro `~' cv w C ~C ~ Q s C C _~ ~ N ~ ~ N O ~ ', O O ~ ~ ~ L t u ~ c .~ ~ V~ ~ ~~ ~4~ .~ 0 ~^ ~ ` ~ ~ ~,,, U ~ . ~ ~.+ a-1 ~ ~` ~ ~ ~ ~ +~ ' C31' . _ ~'a I •- ~ u c u v 3 ~ ~, ~ ~ Q. , y. ' J N ~ `~ Q ~ ~.~ V ~ ~ ~ ' N ~ ~ a~~ o ~ .~ _ t,, V} •' "~' ~ Q ~ Q ~W Vf ~r T r ~ ~~< ~ i ~fT,, Y. ~. ..~ i~, '~~~ ~ ~ fir: ~: ., 1 A•; a ~~ ~ ~ ,_ ++ ~- ~;, ~ ~ ~ `' ~~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ ` _. a ,. ~ -a ~ ~~ ~4 * ~: ; ~'s ~ ~r~_•~ ~i _ «.Wa -`. ._ r. r4 ~:= ~.Y r xs ~1 .... r ~~ ~~, L~~ i "' ~..,...Y,.. ~; ~ ~ t , ~ r ~: =~ ~' ~ . .: ;t ~' ` . ~'~ ~ ,~ ~~ , r 1 J ' ~ _ 2 ~/ ~ - - , ' , `. " -t,. Y t= • „~ ~~ S ~~'I 1 1 I , . l~ ;` i ~~ ~ ;}_ ~ ,. ~t ~~ .. f0 ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ L s 3 .= X ~ cy ~ = U ~ U L ~ ~N ~ = ~ ~-+ U ~ ~ ~ L = ~ ~ mo O V ~ y~ T ` w YI a ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ N ,~ ~ ~ u ~ O ~ ~ .i N ~ ~ m N ~= ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ -~ i - ~ co ~ Cu0 ~~ ~ Q ~ Q W 3 ~ ,,,. G1 ~ '` a t ' t ~.+ t f ,~,, . .~ '3 ~ • , E. 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ c c c =, C i ~ '^ V +~ C O ~ ~ co ':. ~.~. '' F, x.. ..-~- ~,~.;~;~.~,.~ ._ _ ~ 3 cn ~ ~ ~ v a, . -_ ~.~ _ . +-j ~ ~ ~„~ (;/), ~ O s ;., ~ i u cn ~' , `~~ i.:-- -fir, ~~~ ~~, ~ ~ V Z ~ Q1 ~ - O cc ~ ~ O ~ '~ ,'~rw~, r ~ ''R •- e-I G _ ~ ~ ~ o ~ •~ M e1 ~ ~ ~ s ~ f ~ ~. - ~~~j~ ~~, ~ ~ ~ , ~, .. ~ ~T V ~ ~ ~/ ~~~ 0~ ~ a~ v ~ m *~' s ~ ~ s ~ : ~ '~ CSC ~ m u ~ (~ ~ '~.- (U': o -,t ~- ~ ~ , (~` . -, ` .a i 1- ~ ~ ~ ~ E # s ~,, ~ ~ O ; ~ ~- ~ O C6 ~~ ~ ~ . ~~ e, ~«- O O _ ~ , + O L ; '' ~~ ~ ~"~ ~' Vf O ~ ~ a !. ~ ~' ~ N Z ~' ~ ~ ~ ~~ >` ~~ .~ f ~~ O _ 'a~ i , , +~ ~ _ . ~ s c (~ ~~ ~ i a~ `~ ; y. ~ a a a Q 4 ~ L ~ ~ --= i a ~ ~ ~ Q s ' i; ~ ~ ~ u 3 _ ~ ,., ~T ~ ,, k ~ O ~ ~ ~ X ~: ~1. ~ ~~ f ` ~~ yJ ~ I ; ~ ~, V ~. ~ .~ ~ v u ~ ;. .,., ~ j O ~. •~ co Y~ ~ Q~ - ~ co ,w ±, ~ O ^ V , ~~ }J ' ate ~. #~ ' [,, h% i; _ •~~',~ _~:: i i:. ~S ` v ~,y t Ott ~. ~'} ~ ` ,-.~::;' - ~r,u. ; '` ~ "- N... NO.47316'6QR }` CITY OF DELRAY ~f:ACH x PROVIDING FC)R THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE RESURVEY REPCfRT fNCLUDfNG RECLASSIFICATfC)N OF CERTAIN PRCIPERT~ES VIIITHfN THE DEL-fDA PARf~~:f-fI~STC~RIC DISTRICT: Tfie City ;Commission of the City of Delray Beach; Florida, prcpvses to adopt ti;e following ordinance; ~~DINA{yCC~ NO, 15-09 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY CCMfv~i551CN OF THE CITY OF~`'DELkAY BEACH, FLGRiDA, PROVIDING FOR. THE ~, ACCEPTANCE OF'THE<RESURVtY DEPORT OF DEt-IDA PARK, HISTORICiDi5TR{CT, INCLUDING EXTtNS'.CN CAF 7HE f'ERICD ~~~ OF°SIGNIFICAI~ICE AND:~REGLASSIFICATIOCJ~OF PROPERTIES FROM NON-CONTR16UT1N~T000NTRIBUTING,PROVIDING:' ;4'GENERAL REPEAIFR C~U5E; t SAVING CI}aUSE, AND aN; ;; `EFFECTIVE BATE. ' Tne`'City, Corrimission will conduct hvo (2j Pubhc Hearings, ' for fhe purpose of accepfing'pubGe testimony regarding fhe p"reposed ordinance. the ~rst Public Hearing will be heldcn, 7UE~p~Y,.'OCTOg~R¢~049~~.Z~OQ,~j~, in the Commission b~ Chambers at City:Hall,. 100 N.W. 1 ' :4venuo, De`ray Betrch;= ._. Florida. ~E~ the prop©sed ordinance is passedon first roadirtg~ a'second"Public WEaring will be held nn TUESDAY, OC~OBE~~~ ~~2009 ~AT(( 7;,Q.Q~f~ ~or,,at any coniinuationof such mc9fing` =' which is etis<set by the~Gomm;ssi~n} intne;Commission Charr~e~s dt-City Half, 100 N.W ;1 ":Avenue, Deiray~Beach, Florida. f AIf interested cifizens are invlt~d to attend the pupfic hearings and t comrnant upon the~proposed ordinanc© or submit their commen!s ~In writing~on or befor~~the date of these hearings to the Planning. ~dnd Zoning Depa~tment.,'For f~rtherinformafion cr to obtain; acopy of'the proposed ordinance, pleasecgntact tfiaPlanning ctnd zoning bepariment, Cily;Hall, 1:00 N.W. l ° Avenee, De~ray'~ Beach, Florida 33444 (email at R~ rr ca ~rnyc~e!Lo~~ c .cam) or by calling 56J /243-704Q);'between ?ho Hours of S:CQ a.rn. and .5:00 p m.~ Monday through' Friday, excludingho!id~ys. Please b~e: advised that if a_person decides ~to appeal any decision rt'iade 6y the Cry Commission with~respecf to any,rii'atter 'considered at tnesPhearings, such personmay need to ensure that a ~er~atim recordinciude; the testimony and Evidflncu upo;i ~- 'whicft the:appealis to~be based. Th`e Ci y does notprovide nor ' prepare'such record P •suart to F:S. 2$6'G10~. CITY CF DEL[~Y BE4CN Cheve)ep. hvubin, CMC {. ~ - City Clerk PUB: The Palm Beach ~'ost September' 29, & C)ctobeF 15, 2009