12-12-95 Regular
·
DElRA" BEACH
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA - CITY COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING tzttd
i1iifP
DECEMBER 12. 1995 6:00 P.M.: PUBLIC HEARING 7:00 P.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS
The City will furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where
necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity
to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or acti-
vity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Randolph 243-7127
(voice) , or 243-7199 (TDD) , 24 hours prior to the program or activity in
order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive
listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.
RULES FOR PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
1. PUBLIC COMMENT: The public is encouraged to offer comments with the
order of presentation being as follows: City Staff, public comments,
Commission discussion and official action. City Commission meetings are
business meetings and the right to limit discussion rests with the
Commission. Generally, remarks by an individual will be limited to three
minutes or less, (10 minutes for group presentations) . The Mayor or
presiding officer has discretion to adjust the amount of time allocated.
A. Public Hearings: Any citizen is entitled to speak on items
under this section.
B. Comments and Inquiries on Non-Agenda Items from the Public: Any
citizen is entitled to be heard concerning any matter within the
scope of jurisdiction of the Commission under this section. The
Commission may withhold comment or direct the City Manager to take
action on requests or comments.
C. Regular Agenda and First Reading Items: When extraordinary
circumstances or reasons exist and at the discretion of the
Commission, citizens may speak on any official agenda item under
these sections.
2 . SIGN IN SHEET: Prior to the start of the Commission Meeting,
individuals wishing to address public hearing or non-agendaed items
should sign in on the sheet located on the right side of the dais. If
you are not able to do so prior to the start of the meeting, you may
still address the Commission on an appropriate item. The primary purpose
of the sign-in sheet is to assist staff with record keeping. Therefore,
when you come up to the podium to speak, please complete the sign-in
sheet if you have not already done so.
3. ADDRESSING THE COMMISSION: At the appropriate time, please step up
to the podium and state your name and address for the record. All
comments must be addressed to the Commission as a body and not to
individuals. Any person making impertinent or slanderous remarks or who
becomes boisterous while addressing the Commission shall be barred by the
presiding officer from speaking further to the Commission unless
permission to continue or again address the Commission is granted by
majority vote of the Commission member present.
.
Regular Commission Meeting
December 12, 1995
.
APPELLATE PROCEDURES
Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by
the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at this
meeting, such person will need to ensure that a verbatim record includes
the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. The City will
neither provides nor prepares such record.
AGENDA
1. Roll Call.
2. Invocation.
3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
4. Agenda Approval. Action: Motion to Approve.
s. Approval of Minutes:
None
6. Proclamations:
Recognizing and Commending Division Chief Douglas Trawick.
Recognizing and Commending Lt. Larry Garito.
7. Presentations:
Site Plan Review and Appearance Board Recognition Program.
8. Consent Agenda: City Manager recommends approval.
A. AUTHORIZATION TO PROCEED M NITORING STUDY OF THE iEACH NOURISH-
MENT PROJECT: Authorize oastal Planning & Engineering, Inc.
to proceed with the three-year performance monitoring of the
Beach Nourishment Project at a cost not to exceed $35,910; with
funding from the Beach Restoration Fund. The entire cost will
be reimbursed from Federal, State and County appropriations.
B. AGREEMENT WITH ~ALM BEACH COMMUNITY COLLEGE/PARAMEDIC PROGRAM: ~~
Approve an agreement with Palm Beach Community College to oifj;
provide clinical experience for City paramedics enrolled in the
college's paramedic program.
C. AGREEMENT WITH THE PALM BEACH COUNTY~CHOOL BOARD/CARVER MIDDLE
SCHOOL BEFORE AND AFTER SCHOOL PROGRAMS: Approve an agreement
with the Palm Beach County School Board for before and after
school programs for underprivileged children at vCarver Middle
School, to be fully funded by the Board.
-2-
,
.
Regular Commission Meeting
December 12, 1995
D~ CONFIRM THE DATE FOR THE ANNUAL~OWN HALL MEETING: Confirm the
~o~ ~,date January 30, 1996 for the annual Town Hall Meeting to be
~~ q. held at the Crest Theater at Old School Square.
~~ ~
E. RATIFICATION OF APPOINTMENT IDS AND COPS COMMITTEE: Ratify
the appointment of Sean Anderson as a representative from the
Police Benevolent Association to an unexpired term ending April
22, 1997.
F. AMENDED LEASE BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE~EC RAILROAD: Consider
the amended lease between the City and the FEC Railroad for six
parcels, raising the yearly lease from $5900 to $6000.
G. RESOLUTI N 89-95: Adopt a~esolution supporting the Palm Beach
County unicipal League's affiti Eradication Program proposed
by the County Criminal Justice Commission.
H. RESOLUTION NO. 82-95 (~ANDONMENT OF A PORTION OF ALLEY RIGHT-
OF-WAY IN BLOCK 85) & ACCEPTANCE OF REPLACEMENT ~ASEMENTS:
Approve a resolution vacating and abandoning a portion of the
16' east/west alley right-of-way located in ~ock 85, Town of
Delray, based on positive findings and acceptance of a water
and sewer easement.
1. REVIEW OF APPEALABLE LAND DEVELOPMENT BOARD ACTIONS: Accept
the actions and decisions made by the Site Plan Review and
Appearance Board and the Historic Preservation Board during the
period December 4 through December 8, 1995.
J. AWARD OF BIDS AND CONTRACTS:
1. Bid award to~torola Communications and Electronics, Inc.
for Phase II of the two-way-radio system upgrade, in the
amount of $51,179 from 334-6112-519-64.90 and 442-5178-
536-61.76.
9. Regular Agenda:
A. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE i3TORMWATER MANAGEMENT PROGRAM/NATIONAL
POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM -ANPDES} : Consider
implementation and augmentation of the Stormwater Management
Program in regard to the National Pollutant Discharge Elimina-
tion System (NPDES) Stormwater Permitting Program.
B. DEMAND FOR JUDGMENT/CHARLIE BROWN, JR. v. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH:
Consider a Demand ~r Judgment in the above referenced case as
recommended by the ity Attorney.
C. CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #1) ¿CTEAGUE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY,
INC. : Consider Contract Addition (C.O. #1) in the net amount
of $63,165 and 19 day extension to McTeague Construction
Company, Inc. This included the addition of heat pumps for
J76, 500, and miscellaneous Value Engineering items for the
ompey Park Pool project for a credit of $13,335. Funding is
-3-
.
.
. Regular Commission Meeting
December 12, 1995
available from 334-4170-572-63.45 through budget transfer from
D. 228-4126-572-63.45.~ & TAYLOR, INC. : Consider Change
CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 'CONNOR
Order No. 2 to O'Connor & TaYl~, Inc. as part of final
reconciliation for the Municipal olf Course proj ect, in the
amount of $15,510 from 445-4763-572-62.10.
E. FUNDING REOUEST/~LANTIC HIGH SCHOOL VARSITY CHEERLEADERS:
Consider a funding request from the Atlantic High School
Varsity Cheerleaders to help cover the $10,000 cost of
attending the national cheerleading competition in Dallas,
Texas in the amount of $500 from 001-1111-511-4810.
F'.Cf-G. - fš4 ~ dd~du.rn
10. Public Hearings:
None
11. Comments and Inquiries on Non-Agenda Items from the Public-
Immediately following Public Hearings.
A. City Manager's response to prior public comments and inquiries,
B. From the Public.
12. First Readings:
None
13. Comments and Inquiries on Non-Agenda Items.
A. City Manager
B. City Attorney
C. Commission
-4 -
.
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA - CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - DECEMBER 12, 1995 - 6:00 P.M.
PUBLIC HEARINGS - 7:00 P.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS
AGENDA ADDENDUM
THE REGULAR AGENDA IS AMENDED TO INCLUDE:
9.F. CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #2}/JOLLOY BROTHERS, INC. : Consider
Contract Addition (C.O. #2 ) to Molloy Brothers, Inc. for the
removal and replacement of 161 linear feet of deteriorated 12"
sanitary sewer main and two manholes, in the amount of $25,670
from 442 - 51 7 8 - 53 6 - 63 . 51) .
9.G. REOUEST FOR ~PECIAL EVENT PERMIT: Approve a request for a
Special Event permit for the Florida Jaycees to hold a
carnival in the northwest area of the Delray Beach Mall, from
December 27, 1995 through January 7, 1996.
.
·
[),f<
~1
WHEREAS, Douglas Trawick was hired by the City of
Delray Beach Fire Department on August 14, 1973, was promoted
to Emergency Medical Services Coordinator in 1982 and currently
serves as the EMS Division Chief; and
WHEREAS, Doug was one of Delray's first EMT's and
was in the first group of Paramedics. He has served on many
local and state committees, including the Florida Association
of EMS Providers and the Palm Beach County Advisory Council and
currently serves as Chairman for the State EMS Advisory
Council; and
WHEREAS, Division Chief Trawick has assisted in the
, , establishment of the local EMS ordinances and the Palm Beach
County Health Care Public Trauma System, which is now a
national model; and
WHEREAS, on July 13, 1995, Division Chief Doug
Trawick was awarded the "AI Ridgeway Memorial Award" for
Administrative Excellence as Emergency Medical Services
Administrator of the Year for the State of Florida,
NOW, THEREFORE I I, THOMAS E. LYNCH, Mayor of the
City of Delray Beach, Florida, on behalf of the City
Commission, do hereby commend
DIVISION CHIEF DOUGLAS TRAWICK
"' in recognition of his many accomplishments and of
years
dedicated service to his community overseeing the Paramedic
Program, providing a high quality of pre-hospital emergency
medical services for accidents, health emergencies occurring in
residences, places of work, on highways and other public
places,
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and
caused the Official Seal of the City of Delray Beach, Florida,
to be affixed this 12th of December, 1995.
MAYOR
THOMAS E. LYNCH
SEAL
~,A·
.
[ITY DF DElRAY BEA[H "...'-'
--;"'""~'--:-
FIRE DEPARTMENT ¡ : 'j (:; " t C c· " . (,J! r I R i: :'.1\-1 . ; \ GHLAND BEACH
i ¡ h t'; -. t- ,.-~-
DELRA Y BEACH
f loa J D A
bad June 28, 1995
rAmerica Ci,
, II J@ Bill Godfrey/Randy Vick
A wards Committee
1993 c/o Stuart Fire Rescue
Dear Mr. Godfrey,
The Delray Beach Fire Department would like to place the name of Douglas R.
Trawick in nomination for the Al Ridgway A ward.
Doug Trawick has been an employee of the Delray Beach Fire Department for 22
years. He wé\~ one of the department's first EMT's and in the first group of Paramedics.
In 1982, he was promoted to serve as the EMS Coordinator and currently serves as the
EMS Division Chief. During this time he has been on numerous local and state
committees and has served with many professional organizations, Doug was one of the
original members of the Florida Association of EMS Providers. He has been a member,
:~;.:_; then chairman of the Palm each County Advisory Council. He has helped in the
establishment of the local EMS ordinances and the Palm Beach County Health Care
Public Trauma System, which is now a national model. Doug has been on both the
County and the State grants review team and is now on the State EMS Advisory Council
representing the Fire-Administration position. He is currently the Chairman of the State
EMS Advisory Council and in the middle of a 2 year term in that position.
Doug has demonstrated outstanding commitment and dedication in our internal
environment. He is truly a leader in the EMS field, In conclusion, I believe he more than
meets the criteria for the Al Ridgway A ward for administrative excellence,
~ßÁ
Robert B, Rehr
Fire Chief
RBR/mmh
, , :! r ' . ! I i., I lit· ljfL Fir'\Y BEACH FLORIDA 33444
I ~ !,,:
-i . .:., ,:,./, c;I,/;,J,Li,¡'161
.
·
,-.
4"
~.-
- / .
,
,
PRESS RELEASE
For immediate release 7/21/95
The Delray Beach Fire Department is proud to announce that Division Chief Doug
Trawick has been awarded the Al Ridgeway Memorial A ward for Administrative
Excellence as EMs (Emergency Medical Services) Administrator of the year, for the
State of Florida. This award was presented to him by the State of Florida Association of
EMS Providers in Orlando, July 13, 1995 at the state meeting of the EMS Advisory
Council.
Division Chief Trawick has been with the Delray Beach Fire Department for 22 years and
is currently the EMS Division Chief overseeing the Paramedic program for the City of
Delray Beach.
For additional information you may contact Fire Chief Robert Rehr at 243-7410.
- 30-
- .
--"".... --,_..._-,._" - -" -- -,,"-'--'- -_.._-_._~------._-- ._..'-- -
~
. DK
eM
WHEREAS, Larry Garito was hired by the City of
Delray Beach Fire Department on October 1, 1973, and was
promoted to Fire Inspector Lieutenant in September 1979; and
WHEREAS, since the City of Delray Beach has
contracted with the Town of Gulfstream and the Town of Highland
Beach to provide Fire Protection and Emergency Medical
Services, Larry has assumed responsibility for these areas as
part of his zone for fire inspections, often handling difficult
situations; and
WHEREAS, Larry is also very involved in public
education which provides fire and home safety programs for our
" . school children and adults as well as hurricane preparedness
for all fire department personnel, general city employees,
police and Homeowner Associations throughout the City. Through
these efforts the Fire Department provides a safer community
and a higher quality of life; and
WHEREAS , through his efforts, on November 1, 1995,
. " Larry Garito was awarded the State of Florida Fire Inspector of
the Year award by the Florida State Fire Marshals Association.
NOW I THEREFORE, I, THOMAS E. LYNCH , Mayor of the
City of Delray Beach, Florida, on behalf of the City
Commission, do hereby commend
LT. LARRY GARITO
".
in recognition of his many accomplishments and years of
dedicated service to his community.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and
caused the Official Seal of the City of Delray Beach, Florida,
to be affixed this 12th day of December, 1995.
MAYOR
THOMAS E. LYNCH
SEAL
fa ,(3,
.
.
.'
--
[IT' DF DELAA' BEA[H
/~<;-
FIRE DEPARTMENT SERVINC DELRAY BEACH . GULF STREAM . hiGHLAND BEACH
DELRAY BEACH
F L 0 I IDA
~
'11It September 29, 1995
I (}\I;
Peter T Bergel, Deputy Chief
Florida Fire Marshals Association
c/o Palm Beach Gardens Fire Department
10500 North Military Trail
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410-8269
Subject: Fire Inspector/Public Educator Awards
Dear Chief Bergel:
1 am submitting the name of Lieutenant Larry Garito as my nomination for Fire Inspector
/Public Educator of the year. Larry has been with the Department for 22 years, working
within the Fire Safety Division for the past 16 years,
The City of Delray ßeach Fire Department has contracted with the Town of Gulf Stream
and the Town of Highland Beach to provide Fire Protection and Emergency Medical
Services to both communities, As a result, Lt. Garito has taken on the expansion areas as
part of his zone for tìre safety inspections,
The Town of Gulf StreaÎ11 had a history of not having any fire safety inspections for
existing buildings. The Town Manager has expressed nothing but praise for Lt Garito's
profèssional manner and ability to deal with people in often difficult situations. As a
result, the relationship between our Department and the Town has developed into one
which sets an example for others to follow,
The Town of Highland Beach is predominately high-rise residential buildings which require
a great deal of technical knowledge in order to maintain proper fire and life safety in the
areas of alarms and voice evacuation, fire sprinkler protection, maintenance of mechanical
systems and means of egress. Again, Lt Garito has handled many often difficult situations
due to his strong ability to deal with people,
ICIRE DEPARTMENT HEADQUARTERS · 501 WES"T ATLAf\JTlC AVENUE · DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
407/243-7400 · SUNCOM 928-7400 · FAX 407/243-7461
Pnnlea on Reey/eo Paper
. '
.
Page 2 - Peter Bergel, Nomination for Fire Inspector/Public Educator of the Year " -
,~-;--
Although a great deal of fire code issues have <'ealt with, we have yet to have one which
has req'lired enforcement action to date.
In the area of public education, Larry has had such a positive result on the communities
we serve that we continue to maintain the same fire loss and injury record as we had 20
years ago when our area had well below one half the population that we serve today.
Lt. Garito also has taken on the enormous task of training all fire department personnel,
general city employees, police, and countless groups through out the community on all the
finite details of hurricane preparedness. Larry has become our resident expert on this
subject as well.
We constantly receive complements on Larry's outstanding abilities as an educator, public
speaker, inspector and all around public relations abilities. Attached is an editorial written
by a local news columnist who observed Lt. Garito in action with a group of three year old
children. The article well describes Larry's professional abilities as a public educator.
You will also note on the enclosed resume, the recognition by the Training Officers of
Palm Beach Coúnty. I believe this was the first and only time a fire inspector was
recognized as Instructor of the Year.
Sincerely,
~.~r~
Fire Chief
. '
--
Elario (Larry) A. Garito
2200 South Ocean Blvd.
Delray Beach, FL 33483 ~--
EMPLOYMENT
Employed with the City of Delray Beach Fire Depat1ment since October I,
1973 (22 years). I-leld the position of Fire Inspector Lieutenant since
September, 1979 (16 years). As Fire Inspector, responsibilities include~
routine inspections, plans review, new construction inspection, fire safety and
accident prevention education, fire investigation.
ADDITIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES
Additional responsibilities include member of the City of Delray ßeach
Accident Review Board which involves review of accidents of City
employees and recommendations for prevention of accidents for all City
Depal1ments. Hurricane Preparedness instructor, informing employees and
citizens on how. to prepare for a hurricane. Fire Department Safety Officer,
responsible for firefighter safety at emergency incidents.
EDUCA TION
Education includes graduation from Matawan High School, Matawan, New
Jersey and received a Fire Science Certificate from Palm Beach Community
College, West Palm Beach, FL.
MEMBERSHIPS
Memberships include Past President and member of the Delray Beach
Exchange Club~ Past President and member of the Palm Beach County Fire
Marshals Association~ member of the Delray Beach Police Benevolent
Association~ member of the Florida Fire Marshals Association~ and member
of the International Association of Arson Investigators.
AWARDS
Awards include Firefighter of the Year presented by the Delray Beach
Exchange Club and the Kiwanis Club of Delray Beach~ Citizen of the Month
awarded by the Delray Beach Board of Realtors~ Exchangite or the Y ear~
and InstrÜctor of the Year awarded by the Palm Beach County Training
Officers.
.
();<
C1v"l
CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION RECEIVED
{}fC-l199S
TO: DAVID T ~HARDE~NAGER CITY MA"" ,,~...,... f)r'
D~U z, DIRE~^-&~ FICE
THRU:
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING D ZONING
FROM: J~S~LANNER
SUBJECT: MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
SITE PLAN REVIEW AND APPEARANCE BOARD AWARD
RECOGNITION PROGRAM
BACKGROUND:
This year is the fourth annual Site Plan Review and Appearance Board (SPRAB)
Award Recognition Program. The awards are given to those property owners
and their design teams who have significantly contributed to the beauty of the
community through creative design or renovations to existing properties. Eligible
projects are those which were approved by the Board, and received a Certificate
of Occupancy during the previous fiscal year (October 1, 1994 - September 30,
1995).
This year's design categories and recipients include:
:i!:i:l:i:i:l:i!!:I!!:i!!!!!!!!!!!!:i!!:i:i!:1!1¡i!!!!f,~!!!!:ill!!¡i!!!!!!!!:I!:i¡i!~¡BIIIIIIIJII_I_II!I!I!!:I!:i!!IIII!:i!l:illlllll!¡¡II:III:iI1~:I!IIIIIIII:I!!!!!1:illlll!:I:
The Antilles - Southeast Corner of Venetian Drive and Miramar Drive,
o Cary Glickstein (Developer)
o David Martin (Architect)
o Debora Turner (Landscape Architect)
!¡ilii¡¡¡¡!¡¡¡!!¡!¡¡!i!!¡iii¡!i!¡i!¡¡!¡¡¡!li!i!¡iiiiiiii¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡!¡¡¡!I!¡!I¡!¡¡¡!¡!¡!¡!i!¡¡!!¡!¡!IIII¡IIIIIIIf¡t1I1I1I_11~¡!¡!r~II¡¡¡¡¡f¡1i!¡i!I¡¡~¡¡~!¡!!i!¡!i¡i¡!i!!I!!1!¡~I¡¡¡¡!!ii!!i¡!!¡¡¡!i¡¡¡iii
De/ray Outpatient Surgery & Laser Center - 4800 Linton Blvd.
o HDA International (Developer)
o Clifton Thomason (Architect)
o Debora Turner (Landscape Architect)
7·
,
¡!:!:!¡!!!¡!¡!¡!!!!!!!!!!!!!¡!¡!!!¡!!!!!!!!!¡!¡!!!!!¡¡¡¡¡¡!!¡!¡¡!!!¡!¡¡I!!!!!!!III!¡!!¡!¡¡¡!ff.I¡¡¡¡¡!¡!III¡¡!¡¡I¡!¡!!!!!¡¡[llIilll.I__IIIII¡ir¡!¡!;f,fl¡¡¡111¡¡ríf.!I¡!1!!!¡¡I¡!f!¡II¡¡¡!!!¡¡¡!I¡I!¡¡!I!¡¡r~¡¡¡¡¡I!¡I¡¡I!¡¡1!I!II¡
Backdraft Barbeque - 2515 North Federal Highway
o Richard Brochu (Owner)
!¡!¡!!!!!!!!!!¡!!¡!!!!!!!!!¡!¡!¡!!!!!!¡!!!¡!¡!¡!¡!!¡!¡I!¡¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!!!¡¡¡!¡¡¡!!¡!!!¡¡¡!!¡¡!¡!iill!¡!!¡!¡!¡¡¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡!¡¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡lllIllIllllj¡!¡!¡¡¡¡!!!¡!¡¡¡¡¡!~!¡¡¡¡¡!¡!l¡!¡¡¡¡¡!!¡¡¡i¡¡!¡¡!I!¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡!¡¡!¡¡¡!¡¡¡!!!!!¡¡¡!¡!¡¡!¡!¡!!¡¡¡!¡!¡!!¡¡¡!¡¡¡!!!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡¡¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!!¡!¡!!!¡!!!¡
The Irish Cottage Pub - 2713 North Federal Highway
a John Reilly (Owner)
!~¡¡i¡i¡¡¡!!!~~i¡!¡¡'ji~~~¡¡!!~'!i¡~!~~~~~~~lj~¡!!¡¡!!!!!i¡!i1J1:!!!I!¡!!J1:!!!!!!!!!¡¡!~rt¡!!!¡~!I.RI_III!I~1¡'~lr~il!!!!!!~!!!!llfff¡!!!!¡I!~!!!!!~I~~~~~~~!I¡i~~!~~~!~!¡!fll¡!!I¡I~!!!!¡!!!¡!
Pineapple Grill - 800 Palm Trail
o Charles Tobias (Owner)
Speedway Service Center - 200 N.E. 6th Avenue
o Mark Pollis (Owner)
a Mark Marsh (Architect)
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~¡~/¡~¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~¡i¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡/¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡1¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~¡¡¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡¡¡IRIIIIIIIII¡l~I¡¡¡¡~!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~!¡I¡I¡¡¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ j¡¡¡¡¡l~¡¡¡¡!¡1¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~¡¡f¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡~¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡¡¡¡~¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡i.¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
Surles Office Building - 140 N,E. 4th Avenue
a Leonard Surles (Owner)
o Ted Bessette (Architect)
The Award Recognition Program will be conducted by Dick Sheremeta,
Chairman of the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board. The presentation
will include a slide show with commentary. Mr. Sheremeta will present a framed
certificate to each of this year's recipients for their outstanding contribution to
the City of Delray Beach.
.
.
..
£IT' DF DELRA' IEA£H
DELRAY BEACH
f lOR I () A
tKftd 100 N,W, 1 st AVENUE, DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 ' 407/243-7000
;¡iir FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE P.R, 29-95
DESIGN AWARDS ANNOUNCED
1993
DELRA Y BEACH, FLORIDA (November 28, 1995) -- The City of
Delray Beach Site Plan Review and Appearance Board (SPRAB) has
announced the winners of this year's annual design awards. The awards
will be presented at the City Commission meeting of December 12, 1995 at
6:00 P.M.
The SPRAB awards are given to property owners and developers who
significantly contribute to the beauty of the city through creative design or
renovation. The projects which were eligible for the awards must have been
approved by the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board and received a
certificate of occupancy during the previous fiscal year,
On the back of this release is a complete list of this year's winning
projects and the design professionals who will be receiving awards. For
more information, can Senior Planner Janet Meeks at 243-7049,
- 30-
@ Printed on Recycled ParJer THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS 1·A·
. '
1995 SPRAB AWARD WINNERS . . .
EXTERIOR RENOVATIONS:
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT:
BackDraft Barbeque
The Antilles
Richard Brochu (Owner)
Cary Glickstein (Owner) 1026 S. Dixie Highway
Ironwood Group, Inc. Delray Beach, FL 33483
P.O. Box 651 (407) 272-7905
Delray Beach, FL 33447 SIGNAGE:
(407) 279-8952
David Martin (Architect) The Irish Cottage Pub
David Martin Architect
100 N.E, 5th Avenue, Suite B-1 John Reilly (Owner)
Delray Beach, FL 33483 619 Allen Avenue
(407) 243-4654 Delray Beach, FL 33483
(407) 243-9696
Debora Turner (Landscape Architect)
Jerry Turner & Associates of Florida REDEVELOPMENT:
277 S.E. 5th Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33483 Pineapple Grille
(407) 276-0453
Charles Tobias (Owner)
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT: 191 S.E.1stCircle
Boynton Beach, FL 33435
Delray Outpatient Surgery & Laser Center (407) 738-9540
Cecilia Leal (Owner) Speedway Service Center
HDA International
Sanctuary Centre - Suite 100-0 Mark Pollis (Owner)
4800 N. Federal Highway Emro Marketing Company
Boca Raton, FL 33431 3148 Meridian Way N" Suite 5
(407) 391-2297 Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
(407) 694-6730
Clifton Thomason (Architect)
AlE Technologies, Inc. Mark Marsh (Architect)
3555 Timmons Lane, Suite 1550 Digby Bridges, Marsh & Associates
Houston, TX 77027 124 N.E. 5th Avenue
(713) 961-1563 Delray Beach, FL 33483
(407) 278-1388
Debora Turner (Landscape Architect)
Jerry Turner & Associates of Florida ARCHITECTURE:
277 S,E. 5th Avenue Surles Commercial Building
Delray Beach, FL 33483
(407) 276-0453 Leonard Surles (Owner)
313 S.E. 2nd Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444
(407) 278-4995
Ted Bessette (Architect)
Bessette Associates
1300 N. Federal Highway, Suite 109
Boca Raton, FL 33432
(407) 395-8111
· O/(
v~VJ
CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION
TO: David T. Harden, City Manager
THROUGH: Di~~~nning and Zoning
FROM: John Walker, Project coordinato¿- tu~
SUBJECT: MEETING OF DECEMBER 12. 995
AUTHORIZATION TO PROCEED - THREE YEAR
PERFORMANCE MONITORING STUDY OF THE BEACH
NOU~SHMENTPROJECT ** CONSENT AGENDA **
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE CITY COMMISSION:
The action requested of the City Commission is that of approval of an
authorization to proceed with the three year performance monitoring
project of the beach nourishment project.
BACKGROUND:
Annual monitoring of the beach nourishment project is required by our permits
from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection to assess the
performance of the project. The information gathered is also used to set
parameters of design and timing for future maintenance nourishments. Work in
this task includes beach, dune, and offshore profiles; borrow area surveys;
analysis of volume and shoreline changes; analysis of sand grain size; and dune
accretion evaluation.
This item is covered in our contract with Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc.
Funds are available in the Beach Restoration Fund, The entire cost will be
reimbursed from Federal, State and County appropriations.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, authorize and direct the City Manager to authorize Coastal Planning
& Engineering, Inc. to proceed with the Three Year Beach Performance
Monitoring Study at a cost not to exceed $35,910. as requested in their attached
correspondence.
Attachment:
* Letter from CPE
S:\adv\beach\survey3 fA·
,
.
.'
COASTAL & OCEAN ENGINEERING
COASTAL SURVEYS
COASTAL PLANNING & ENGINEERING. INC. BIOLOGICAL STUDIES
GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES
BOCA RATON: 2481 N,W, BOCA RATON BOULEVARD, BOCA RATON, FL 33431 (407) 391-8102 TELEFAX: (407) 391-9116
JACKSONVILLE: 1542 KINGSLEY AVENUE, SUITE 142E. ORANGE PARK, FL 32073 (904) 264-5039 TELEFAX: (904) 264-5039
TOMS RIVER: 250 WASHINGTON STREET, SUITE B, TOMS RIVER, NJ 08753 (908) 244-3366 TELEFAX: (908) 244-3664
November 3, 1995
Mr. John Walker
Project Coordinator
City of Delray Beach
100 N.W, 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444
Re: Proposal for 36 Month Monitoring Study - 1992 Renourishment
Dear John:
The third anniversary of the construction of the 1992 renourishment project is coming up in
December. The Department of Natural Resources pennit requires that topographic and
hydrographic surveys of the beach fIll and borrow area be taken annually to monitor the
perfonnance of the renourishment project, The infonnation will also be useful in future design
considerations of the beach project and in keeping the City infonned as to the condition of the
beach,
The following proposed monitoring study will meet the DNR permit requirements:
1. Beach, Dune and Offshore Proflles
~
Proflles from R-175 through R-192 will be surveyed in accordance with the permit requirements,
These proflles will be surveyed from the dune to the 30 foot depth contour. Proflles will be
surveyed with CPE's sled to provide the best possible accuracy and repeatability with future
monitoring surveys.
The dune in the vicinity of the public beach will also be surveyed. Dune proflles will include
intennediate lines at 5OO-foot spacing along the public beach in the dune area. This will provide
a more accurate assessment of accretion rates.
2, Sand Grain Size Analysis
Surface sand samples will be collected at 4-foot contour intervals from + 12 feet to -20 feet
along four DNR prof1le lines. All samples will be subjected to sieve analysis, The mean grain
size will be computed and compared to post-construction data. The change in grain size will be
assessed.
3. Volumetric and Shoreline Analysis
The data obtained from the prof11e surveys will be reduced, plotted and compared to the 1992
post-construction and December 1994 surveys. Volume changes will be computed, mean high
water shoreline recession or accretion will be computed and plotted.
.
John Walker
November 3, 1995
Page 2
4, Dune Evaluation
The change in the volume of sand in the dune will be computed based on the profile
comparisons, The quantity of accretion will be determined for the three years after construction
of the 1992 renourishment. The change in the dune profile will also be evaluated,
5, Borrow Area Surveys
Hydrographic surveys of the 1992 dredged borrow areas will be conducted using DGPS
positioning and fathometer survey methods, Line spacing between survey track lines will be 200
feet. Bathymetric charts will be computer-generated to meet state requirements and a
comparison to the March 1995 borrow area survey will be conducted to determine infilling rates.
We had requested a waiver of this last year which was denied. I recommend, that we conduct
the survey this year and, in the absence of any major changes, request a waiver again.
6, Report
A report will be prepared summarizing the results of the study. We will provide copies of the
report to the City as well as the Department of Natural Resources to meet the permit
requirements. Additional copies will also be made available to the Corps of Engineers and the
~ Department of Environmental Protection.
The total cost of this monitoring study is $35,910. A cost breakdown is attached. Please
approve this proposal at your earliest convenience. If there are any questions, please call me.
Very truly yours,
COASTAL PLANNING & ENGINEERING, INC.
?C"
~ /?/
Kim E. Beachler, P,E.
Vice President
db03:00295prp.304
cc: Elizabeth McCarthy
Tom Campbell
Jeff Andrews ~ìt(!';1EUWIE)D)
'NOV '7 \99:1
If.lANN~NG&;ZONtNG1
~
COASTAL PLANNING & ENGINEERING, ING.
,
DEATAILED HOURLY COST BREAKDOWN
DELRAY BEACH RENOURISHMENT 3 YR. MONITORING BEACH PROFILES
COASTAL PLANNING & ENGINEERING, INC,
OCT. 31, 1995
1. TWO /3) YR. POST ..cONSTRUCTION PROFILES
PERSONNEL (HOURS) EQUIPMENT (DAYS)
TOTAL COAST OC, LEVEL BRONCO
PE CIH ST ST STATION SLED PROG, BOAT & ROD ON BCH
A. BEACH PROFILES
1. ADMIN, & SUPERVISION 6 4
2. SURVEY RECON, 4 4
3, DUNE PROFILES 16 32 2
4. BEACH PROFILES 24 48 2 2
5, SLED PROFILES
A. MOBlOEMOB 4 4 10
B, FIELD 16 16 32 2 2 2 2 2
TOTAL HOURS 6 24 64 126 2 2 2 2 4 4
RATE 38.51 24.95 14.54 11.41 120 100 250 400 50 100
MULTIPLIER 2,75 2,75 2,75 2,75 1 1 1 1 1 1
SUB-TOTALS 635.415 1646,7 2559.04 3953,565 240 200 500 800 200 400
SUB-TOTAL $11,135
2. SAND SAMPLE & ANALYSIS (3 YR. POST..cONSTRUCTION )
NOTE: INCLUDES SAMPLES FROM PROFILE LINES R177, R180, R184 AND T187 (TOTAL SAMPLES 54)
~ PERSONNEL (HOURS) EQUIPMENT (DAYS)
COAST OC,
PE ST GEOL. EC FAiH PROG, BOAT LAB
---
A. SAND ANALYSIS
1. COLLECT SAND SAMPLES 8 8 1 1 1
2, LAB ANALYSIS 4 54
3, COMPUTATIONS I ANALYSIS 2 8 4 8
TOTAL HOURS 2 20 12 8 1 1 1 54
RATE 38.51 11.41 13.49 35 100 250 400 50
MULnPLlER 2,75 2,75 2.75 1 1 1 1 1
SUB-TOTALS 211.805 627.55 445.17 280 100 250 400 2700
JOB TOTAL $5,015
. '
3 DATA REDUCTION & ANALYSIS (3 YR. POST-CONSTRUCTION)
PERSONNEL (HOURS)
CE PE E ET EC
--
A. PROFILE VOLUME & SHORELINE
1, SURVEY DATA REDUCTION 8 20 12
2, VOLUMES COMPS, & PLOTTIN 4 8 16 8
3, DATA ANALYSIS 1 8 8
-..----
TOTAL HOURS 1 12 24 36 20
RATE 50,11 38,51 21.12 14,03 35
MULTIPLIER 2.75 2.75 2.75 2,75 1
SUB-TOTALS 137,8025 1270.83 1393,92 1388.97 700
SUB-TOTAL $4,892
4. DATA EVALUATION & REPORT ( 3 YR. POST -CONSTRUCTION)
PERSONNEL (HOURS)
CE PE E ET D WP
.-
- B. DUNE EVALUATION
1, SURVEY DATA REDUCTION 2 4 12
2, VOLUMES COMPS, & PLOTTIN 2 4 8 4
3, DATA ANALYSIS 0 4 8 4
TOTAL HOURS 0 4 12 12 20 4
RATE 50.11 38.51 21.12 14,03 15.45 35
MULTIPLIER 2,75 2,75 2,75 2.75 2,75 1
SUB-TOTALS 0 423,61 696,96 462,99 849.75 140
SUB-TOTAL $2,573
PERSONNEL (HOURS)
CE PE E CIH D C WP
--
C. REPORT
1, WRITING 2 16 24 16
2, DRAFTING 16
3. WORD PROCESSING 16 16
4, REPRODUCTION 4
--------
TOTAL HOURS 2 16 24 16 16 20 16
RATE 50.11 38.51 21.12 24,95 15.45 15.16 25
MULTIPLIER 2.75 2,75 2.75 2.75 2,75 2,75 1
SUB-TOTALS 275.605 1694.44 1393,92 1097,8 679,8 833,8 400
SUB·TOTAL $6,375
JOB TOTAL $29,989
.
~
5. BORROW AREA SURVEY ( 3 YR. POST -CONSTRUCTION)
PERSONNEL (HOURS) EQUIPMENT (DAYS)
FATH- COASTOC,
PE CIH ST1 ST2 D DGPS OMETER PROG, BOAT
...-------
A. SHORE CONTROL SURVEY
1, MOBlRESEARCH/PLAN 2 2 2
2, CAL. OOPS 2 2
B. BATHEMETRIC SURVEY
1. MOBlRESEARCH/PLAN 1 4 2 2
2, SET TIDE GAUGE 2 2
3. HYDROGRAPHIC SURVEY 8 8 8 1 1 1 1
4. DEMOB 2 2
C. DATA ANALYSIS
1, DATA REDUCTION 2 6 12 4
2, BATHYMETRIC CHART 4 6 8
3. DATA CONVERSIONS 2 2
-- .--
TOTAL HOURS 3 28 38 16 12 1 1 1 1
RATE 38,51 24.95 14.54 11.41 15.45 400 100 250 400
MULTIPLIER 2,75 2.75 2,75 2.75 2,75 1 1 1 1
SUB-TOTALS 317.7075 1921,15 1519.43 502,04 509.85 400 100 250 400
SUB TOTAL $5,920
JOB TOTAL $35,910
~
. '
·
f"''¡/
L.A \
RECEIVED tïv1
[IT' DF DELHA' BEA[H DEC - 4 1995
CITY M~~" ~-..,'..
, , rH::r:/r,r:
CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE 2Cti-¡ ~.~\\ }q A\'[,:<l~E . UELR:\Y BEACH. FI,ORtOA 3J-,-t~~
F/\<'S\~~:11.r: ~t!)):= -7.:\."';
Writer's Direct Line: (407) 243-7091
DElRA Y BEACH
F lOR I D A
~
AII·America City MEMORANDUM
, III I!
DATE: December 1, 1995
1993
TO: City Commission
FROM: Susan A, Ruby, City Attorney
SUBJECT: Paramedic Clinical Agreement
The attached agreement is between the City and Palm Beach Community College to
provide clinical experiences within the City for paramedics enrolled in the colleges
paramedic program. The Agreement is for one year and may be renewed for an
additional year upon mutual consent of the parties,
By copy of this memorandum to David Harden, our office at the behest of Fire Chief
Rehr, requests that this Agreement be placed on the City Commission December 12,
1995 agenda for Commission approval.
Attachment
cc: David Harden, City Manager
Chief Robert Rehr, Delray Beach Fire Department
Alison MacGregor Harty, City Clerk
~ an ~
/ ¿;¿.f¡:J/9.s-
clinic.sar
¡.f3.
® Printed on Recvcled Paper
, '
.
"
. .
AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into by and between the DISTRICT BOARD
OF TRUSTEES OF THE PALM BEACH COMMUNITY COLLEGE, a public corporation
4200 Congress Avenue
under the laws of the State of Florida, whose address is Lake Worth. Florida 33461 ,
hereinafter referred to as "THE BOARD" and the. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH,
FLORIDA, a Florida municipal corporation whose address is 100 N,W. 1st Avenue, Delray
Beach, Florida 33444, hereinafter referred to as "CITY",
WIT N E SSE T H:
WHEREAS, the CITY and the BOARD desire to provide educational and training
opportunities for students desiring to be educated in the field of paramedics; and,
WHEREAS, the parties hereto desire to enter into a contractual arrangement providing
for the education and training of students in the Paramedic Program.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties hereto as follows:
1. The BOARD, through its facilities at the Palm Beach Community College,
agrees to establish a program to educate and train students in the paramedic field,
2. The CITY agrees to not commence any training programs in the paramedic
field which is similar to the program conducted by the BOARD while this agreement is in
effect, unless the BOARD consents to the program,
3, The BOARD shall place the program in its Allied Health Division,
4, Control of the program shall rest with the President of the Palm Beach
Community College with the assistance of the Chairperson of the Allied Health Division. The
. '
mees
BOARD -ttftf:Î:-.... ¥-itgfee' to establish an Advisory Committee which will counsel the
President and Division Chairperson responsible for the program.
5. This agreement shall continue for one (1) year from the date hereof unless
sooner terminated as hereinafter provided. The parties may renew the agreement at the end of
one (1) year by the mutual consent of the parties hereto. In the event that either party desires
to terminate the arrangement prior to the expiration of the one (1) year period, the party
requesting termination shall provide written notice to the other party. Such termination shall
not be effected until all enrolled students have the opportunity to complete their prescribed
program. The BOARD shall not accept new enrollees after receipt of notice of termination,
6, FURTHER, THE BOARD agrees to:
a. Accept eligible students in the program as regular enrollees of the Palm
Beach Community College, subject to the rules and regulations of the College.
b. Select a qualified faculty to teach the program,
c, Provide a college approved course of study.
d. Consult with the designated CITY staff in order to select clinical
experiences for the program's students. A list of students and their dates of attendance will be
provided to the CITY by the College.
e. Provide supervision for students participating in clinical experiences at
the CITY.
f, Adhere to the policy and procedures. established by the CITY, including
the Exposure Control Plan for Bloodboume Pathogens and all related OSHA and Infection
Control Policies.
2
,
g. Cooperate with CITY staff in all matters pertaining to this program.
7. FURTHER, CITY agrees to:
a. Provide the necessary facilities for clinical experiences in order to permit
proper paramedic instruction,
b. Cooperate in the assignment of students to the CITY. Assignment shall
be made under the supervision of the College faculty.
c, Provide liaison between the designated CITY administrator and the
Chairperson of Allied Health Division.
d. Provide suitable area at the CITY for student conferences and group
training programs related to the paramedic program.
e, Cooperate in obtaining guest lecturers from the staff of CITY following
receipt of a reasonable request from the Allied Health Division.
f. Provide all health examinations and immunizations required by the
CITY other than the basic physical examination and initial immunization which are required of
each student upon enrollment with the College.
g. Cooperate with the College staff in all matters pertaining to this
program,
8. FURTHER, BOTH PARTIES agree to:
1. Require that each paramedic student at his/her own expense provide the
following:
a. Uniforms,
b. Meals.
c. Laundry Service.
d. Transportation.
3
, '
.
e. Physical Examination and Immunizations.
f. Hospital and Medical Care,
g, School Accident Insurance or evidence of such insurance protection.
h, Professional Liability Insurance coverage of not less than $1,000,000 per
occurrence and $3,000,000 aggregate. Proof of insurance will be
provided to CITY at the commencement of the program for each student
involved in the program.
9. This Agreement contains the entire understanding of the parties relating to the
subject matter hereof superseding all prior communications between the parties whether oral or
written, and this Agreement may not be altered, amended, modified or otherwise changed nor
may any of the terms hereof be waived, except by a written instrument executed by both
parties. The failure of a party to seek redress for violation of or to insist on strict performance
of any of the covenants of this Agreement shall not be construed as a waiver or relinquishment
for the future of any covenant, term, condition or election by the same shall continue and
remain in full force and effect.
10, Any notice require under this Agreement shall be sent via U.S. Mail, return
receipt requested, to:
As to BOARD: Palm Beach Community College
4200 Congress Avenue
Lake Worth, Florida 33461
Attn: Jan S. Bussell
As to CITY: City of Delray Beach, Florida
Attn: City Manager
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
4
.
" -
.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement the day
and year above first written.
DISTRICT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
ATTEST: PALM BEACH OMMUNIT COLLEGE
~~17 By:
Secre ry .
(SEAL)
ATTEST: CITY OF DELRA Y BEACH, FLORIDA
By:
City Clerk Thomas Lynch, Mayor
Approved as to Form:
City Attorney
medic.agt
5
.
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGERtf1t(
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # f· C· - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
AGREEMENT WITH THE PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD/
CARVER MIDDLE SCHOOL BEFORE AND AFTER SCHOOL PROGRAMS
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to approve an agreement with the
Palm Beach County School Board for before and after school
programs for underprivileged children at Carver Middle School.
Total estimated program costs for the 1995-96 school year are
projected at $130,500, and will be fully funded by the School
Board.
Recommend approval of the agreement with the Palm Beach County
School Board for before and after school programs at Carver
Middle School.
.
.
Agenda Item No.: f·e·
AGENDA REQUEST
Date: December 1, 1995
Request to be placed on:
X Regular Agenda Special Agenda Workshop Agenda
When: December 12, 1995
Description of agenda item (who, what, where, how much): Request approval
of Agreement with the School Board for before and after school programs at Carver
Middle School to be fully funded by the School Board in the amount of $130,500.
ORDINANCE/ RESOLUTION REQUIRED: YES.@ Draft Attached: YES/NO
Recommendation: Approval.
Department Head Signature:
Determination of Consistency
City Attorney Review/ Recommendation (if applicable):
"
Budget Director Review (required on all items involving expenditure
of funds):
Funding available: YES/ NO
Funding alternatives: (if applicable)
Account No. & Description:
Account Balance: .
City Manager Review:
Approved for agenda: @/ NO ~I
Hold Until:
Agenda Coordinator Review:
Received:
Action: Approved/Disapproved
.
.
£IT' DF DELIA' BEA£H
CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE 2\1() :,W lst ¡\,/E;,,[][ . DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
FACS! \11 ¡ E HJ72 7S4 755
Writer's Direct Line: (407) 243-7090
DELRA Y BEACH
f LOR D A
.........
AlI,America City MEMORANDUM
" III!
DATE: November 30, 1995
1993
TO: Joe Dragon, Assistant Director of Parks and Recreation
FROM: David N. To1ces, Assistant City Attorn~
SUBJECT: Carver Agreement
Attached is the revised Carver Agreement. Please review the Agreement and place it on
the December 12, 1995 City Commission agenda.
Please call if you have any questions.
DNT:ci
Attachment
cc: Joe Weldon, Director of Parks and Recreation
Alison MacGregor Harty, City Clerk
carver .dnt
® Printed on ,Secycio¡f Paper
.
·
AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT made and entered into this _ day of ,
19_ by and between the CITY OF DELRA Y BEACH, FLORIDA, a Florida municipal
corporation (hereinafter referred to as "City"), and the SCHOOL BOARD OF PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FLORIDA, a corporate body politic pursuant to the Constitution of the State of
Florida (hereinafter referred to as "School Board"),
WIT N E SSE T H:
WHEREAS, it is the intent of the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Plan
Development Regulation Act, F.S. 163.3161(4), to encourage and ensure cooperation between
and among the local government entities to provide for the coordination of development
activities of units of local government; and
WHEREAS, the School Board is the controlling body of the public schools of Palm
Beach County, Florida, and does own and operate schools in the City of Delray Beach; and
WHEREAS, the City is authorized to enter into agreements with other governmental
entities to provide services for its citizens; and
WHEREAS, there are school programs which at the present time provide needs for
underprivileged elementary school children with respect to tutoring, recreation, and counseling;
and
WHEREAS, School Board and City desire to provide a similar structured before and
after school program for middle school students; and
,
.
WHEREAS, the years during which a child is in middle school are those years during
which children may be drawn into crime and violence, and the proposed program will be an
effort to provide the underprivileged children with a positive alternative; and
WHEREAS, such a program will include academic tutoring, recreation and counseling
components.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual premises, covenants and agreements
contained herein, the parties hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. The School Board shall permit a before and after school program to be held at
Carver Middle School to serve needy students during the 1995-1996 school year.
2, In accordance with School Board requirements, in order to qualify for the
program, each child must be eligible for and receiving free/reduced breakfast and/or lunch at the
school.
3. The parties agree that children who would be unsupervised before or after school
would receive priority.
4. Transportation to and from the school to activities shall be provided by both the
City and the School Board,
5, The School Board shall appoint a Site Director who shall have responsibility for
the program at Carver Middle School. The Site Director shall report to the City's representative,
as well as the School Board's representative.
2
.
.
6. As part of the program, medical services shall be provided by the Delray Beach
Branch of the Palm Beach County Health Department, which shall include: physicals, dental
services, eye exams and glasses, counseling, and crisis intervention.
7, The School Board agrees to provide tutoring services at the Carver Community
Middle School on a rotating schedule that will provide opportunities for instruction by state
certified teachers in English, math, social studies and science. Additional tutoring will be
provided for ESOL students, and the media center and computer lab at Carver Middle will be
made available for studying, research, and individualized projects,
8, Personnel for the After School Program shall be hired through the City of Delray
Beach Parks and Recreation Department. The staffing ratio shall be no more than 15 to 1.
9. The City of Delray Beach will be the fiscal agent for all aspects of the program.
The City shall set up separate accounts, and a monthly budget update will be reviewed by both
the school principal and the City's representative. Auditing services shall be provided by both
the City and Palm Beach District Schools. Payments totaling $130,500 shall be paid by June 30,
1996 in monthly installments starting September 1, 1995, $120,000 will come from Safe School
funds, and $10,500 from County Recreation funds administered by the School District.
10. The attached Exhibit "A" provides the budget requirements for the program:
11. This Agreement contains the entire understanding of the parties relating to the
subject matter hereof superseding all prior communications between the parties whether oral or
written, and this Agreement may not be altered, amended, modified or otherwise changed nor
may any of the terms hereof be waived, except by a written instrument executed by both parties.
3
.
.
The failure of a party to seek redress for violation of or to insist on strict perfonnance of any of
the covenants of this Agreement shall not be construed as a waiver or relinquishment for the
future of any covenant, tenn, condition or election by the same shall continue and remain in full
force and effect.
12, All notices submitted or required by this Agreement shall be sent by registered or
certified mail and addressed to the parties as follows:
To the City:
City of Delray Beach
100 N,W. 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
To School Board:
School Police Department
3330 Forest Hill Blvd" Suite B-121
West Palm Beach, Florida 33406-5869
or to such other addresses as either party may designate in writing,
13. The validity, construction and effect of this Agreement shall be governed by the
laws of the State of Florida, Any claim, objection or dispute arising out of the tenns of this
Agreement shall be litigated in the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County,
Florida.
14, This Agreement shall be recorded in the Public Records of Palm Beach County,
Florida.
15, This Agreement may be cancelled be either party given a thirty (30) day notice of
the same.
4
.
.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this agreement and one counterpart,
both of which shall constitute originals, to be executed by its proper officers hereto duly
authorized on the year and date first above written.
CITY OF DELRA Y BEACH PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD
By: By:
Thomas Lynch, Mayor
ATTEST: ATTEST:
Alison MacGregor Harty
City Clerk
Approved as to Form: Approved as to Form:
City Attorney School Board Attorney
carveL3b>t
5
.
.
- -
Sheet1
CARVER COMMUNITY MIDDLE SCHOOL
------.--- DELRAY BEACH PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT
--------.--- EXPENDITURES
----.--.--...
001-4105-572
~SOÑNi~L~r~oörl .r= - i-:=--+::=·~::1==t =---
1 Each Ree. Sup. II 7 A.M. to 9 A.M. ~_==±
i 10 Hourslweek x 40 weeks x $9.61 ~3,844
--~ 2 Each Rec. Le~d. 1117 A.M. to,9 A.M. ' I, I ,
__-+ 10 Houlõiweek x 40 w:"'ks x $7.52 x 2 * i $6.014
.=-~ ~! ~fter1:i5~~~~;:J~~~:~h:-- ·~I --- Þ$9.61:=-::
_____,_.J b 6 Each Rec. Leader 113P.M.-6:30 P.M·--~---l !
-------J 17.5 Hourslweek x 40 weeks x $6.82 x 6 i ! $28,645 I_
i c 1 Each Bus Driver/Rec. Su .13 P.M.-7 P.M. I I
__________L____+ 20 Hourslweek x 40 weeks_~_j!3.7~___-'_______L__~~~~,r~,L-_,_______
I , i ==:=J. I ¡ -+
--13:'1oT I ¡ Total Salaries:--J---'-'-¡-$55,090 ¡-------
----'---'1 _r I -1---------~-..---r---
21,101 FICA 0.016~ $4,214
----------'E-·
------..---.-".- -1,------,-.1..-------
24.10 WORKERS COMPENSATION $3,124 I
I ' I
I i I
-~-~~-=~'-=-J ,_ TOTAL PERSONAL SERVICE~ $62,428 ~---
OPE::-~~t:PPLl~:~:::::::t P~I~~:~~~ ~~$!~.~._~- $7j ---
I] I i I
__~~_~~_O !__ qther Pro!.ess~onal Services ._L__,__, __ I _ '_
-=.::=1__ SecUri~~ou-r~ x 40.we¡kS x 15 ~ººº- _____
34.90 Other Contractual Service I I +-
-I
-,---------.J Golf Lessons $2.50 x 90 x6hrs I ' ¡________-+-~_135_q L___.__
i Tennis Lessons $15 x 4hrs x 40 ¡ r I $2,4001 ,___,,___..
I Tutorial Teachers $15 x 12 hrs x 36 wks I I $6480 i
_ ' Arts and Crafts classes ±----f' I
,-------=t- ~/Wk x 6 wks @.r!15 per h~ì~~~ ____'-___, $1 ,080+____
______-t-___~puterlab I i I
______,_____+___ 2 hrslwk x 6 wks @ $!?"per hour x ..§..groups 1- ! $1,080 ¡
TV/Radio Production "
_______'__-¡-____ 2 hrslwkx 6 wks $15 er hour ì 6 groups $1.080j_____ -
-L ¡Creative Writing ~ J
______.J_.,__14 hrslwk x 30 wks @ $15 per hour=-___ I==- I $1,800 1---
------__~~~~()_L_ _ -tªrus Transportation I 1 j! I
__,______+__~~u_=~ 4ò'mi!es/~ x 1 äÕ~J1---¡--------~~---'- ==____-1_,_~L..~OO~==~~--------
------------:------------~, i C ! I i I
-,~~ºI_, IOther insurance costs ----r-----T~_~==.=~_=r-_=__=__=:=l--'~-==
__,__,__u¡______,___JJ?.!!~lnsuran~~ 150/month x 10 months ¡ I $1,500 i
t . ,- -- . -.._.____~_____..___.__,...,__..._-....-- __n ---1 --. ....-.._.. -__ _ .._ ..._____....___.*__. _._ '..___..__ __.."..._.. _,_ ____ __
! j artici ants insurance 90 x $1.44 i ; $130 ¡
.
- . - --
.. r 51.10;
51.901
,
52.101
I
I
5220i
$15,422 I
I I $900 ---
- ~-==~r-='=t-- ,--
! ! I $1,000
I I
52.42: Snacks for Afterschool Program I ! i
i . SO/day x 140 days x 90 participants I '$6,300
___t____-!other days snacks are donated \ I
! I I ¡ ! ¡
: I '" I '
_~J9~ :Youth Basketball i --J $6,500
j I ì \
I ¡TOTAL OPI~TING !OSTS
I ¡TOTAL PROGRAM COSTS I
Page 2
,
.
'ìl/
l/ ~
tX/
CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION
TO: DAVID T, HARDEN, CITY MANAGER
~~
~"
FROM: D E OMINGU . DIR~~
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNIN AND ONING
SUBJECT: MEETING OF DECEMBER 12. 1995
ESTABLISHING A DATE FOR THE ANNUAL TOWN HALL MEETING
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
The action requested of the City Commission is that of settina a date for the
fourth annual Town Hall Meeting.
BACKGROUND:
The Planning and Zoning Department is in the process of coordinating the fourth
annual Town Hall Meeting, to be held at the Crest Theater at Old School Square in
January. As in previous years, the meeting will consist of presentations by advisory
board members and the City administration, input from the public, and remarks by the
Mayor and Commissioners. The purpose of the meeting is to report on the
accomplishments of the past year, assess the level of progress made toward achieving
goals, and provide additional opportunities for public input and interaction.
The previous Town Hall meeting was held on the last Tuesday in January. Given the
schedule for this January's Commission meetings, the last Tuesday (January 30th)
again appears to be the most appropriate date.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, designate a date in January 1996 for the fourth annual Town Hall Meeting.
m ð Vfid) 10 í? Eq ú.../Iì;e I7r¡ &l /J.IÏ- ItS 9 l1li-,
S:/PLANNIIDOCUMElREPORTS/CC96.DOC
{bnt:£m d;:r/£ o-ß /30/96 !H70 (!omßlnE. w/'//)
Pcf-2 Znlbr~~ ¡;¿J;/I~ hM;ðnc¡ -
5-d ff)·
. ,
·
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER t~l
SUBJECT: RATIFICATION OF APPOINTMENT/KIDS AND COPS COMMITTEE
DATE: DECEMBER 6, 1995
Jeffrey Miller, representative from the Police Benevolent Association,
has resigned from serving on the Kids and Cops Committee creating a
vacancy to an unexpired term ending April 22, 1997.
Sean Anderson, Police Officer, has submitted an application and
resume for consideration.
Recommend ratification of the appointment of Sean Anderson to the Kids
and Cops Committee as the representative from the Police Benevolent
Association.
mil. doc
~cm ~
/~/~qs-
g',£
, '
.
.
<, /--' i .tc (~ /".',\
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
BOARD MEMBER APPLICATION
NAME SeAf\) AN o~,..;
HOME ADDRESS (S~reet, City, Zip Code) (LEGAL RESIDENCEr---- - ,-
h E"-L Fe..
City, Zi
HOME PHONE . BUSINESS PHONE '1"'~a~3- .,&-~,
--
ON WHAT BOARDS ARE YOU INTERESTED IN SERVING ~10 5 A-uD COP~
.
LIST ALL CITY BOARDS ON WHICH YOU ARE CURRENTLY SERVING OR HAVE PREVIOUSLY
SERVED (Please include dates)
-
EDUCATIONAL QUALIFICATIONS ßSo ,Y\ ~ "ctö"";G - FSu IC,C¡O
.)
ßS'" (.z;..." , "-'lJ '" ,J 1" _/ - F S L-{ /C,'jO
/
Ft-(.,oz 'ò/t "{t7'l It: {'1:""r ¡.., FI ~ L.4M.J ErV,t:.~)~rc"""ti-.v1 V¿C¡<::1l f<.'7!!' ¡c¡qi> -) f.ec:~&:...->+
LIST ANY RELATED PROFESSIONAL CERTIFICATIONS AND LICENSES WHICH YOU HOLD
p.:>L.o.c,.... Vr:~l(·(.~ C e~"Lh ~'C..4 ~c,"'; .I A-n u.'u.s A 0 vA 1W',-'~'1> ..,....~A'IV''''-·.. ('{)<.' ~S C·~
..
GIVE YOUR PRESENT, OR MOST RECENT EMPLOYER, AND POSITION Dez.-2~y ß.."Y\-CH R.~,(cÇ
D~ P~rr L~+- - R)L .c..:: Or- FI (,-:-R..
DESCRIBE EXPERIENCES, SKILLS OR KNOWLEDGE WHICH QUALIFY YOU TO SERVE ON THIS
BOARD
:::r:: A....·, A {)ç.(..\( ."" () .-,; ç, ( ts"'I'è t...ù dO ìM..5. PA-/2't1 ('. PA hs-n i .'\..> hf'.~
"- 1/:;' !. ,~)D CC P S. (?I?o i:.''<! ~'.-, r:"t:J .~ 7îf,-~ pit 5.T -1./ Ill·;-y¡....f?~\ .; Æo...·.
. I
,1.) ,S ~/..l.C h}, ·h-+ rt-r.r D ='l ,~,qt p, ... II.. ':- bt~"t.
P,éYt$c=- ~,~ ~ TìYtC fT'...=b f2.t: '-I ~ ~ r<-, ~ F Co .f> 'Ht...7l..
PLEASE ATTACH A BRIEF RESUME.
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT ALL THE ABOVE STATEMENTS ARE TRUE, AND I AGREE AND
UNDERSTAND THAT ANY MISSTATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS CONTAINED IN THIS APPLICA-
TION MAY CAUSE FORFEITURE UPON MY PART OF ANY APPOINTMENT I MAY RECEIVE.
~~Z, ~~'-,- I :2 <3 " c¡ $'
...--' -SI ATU E DATE
4/90
. '
.
. .
SEAN ANDRE ANDERSON
~ ..~ ~ - ---
PROFESSIONAL OBJECTIVE
To obtain a Management intensive position within an organization valuing experience and
knowledge in Security, Personnel Interaction and Community Relations.
SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS
Offering extensive training and practical experience in: Positions of leadership and
guidance... Communications and proactive relations... Law enforcement and security..,
Personnel supervision and motivation... Marketing, promotions and business
administration...
Outstanding communication and interpersonal skills; rapidly develops rapport, trust and
calming influence in all situations with individuals of all ages, races, ethnic backgrounds...
Excellent organizational and analytical skills... Highly motivated, self-reliant and dedicated
to professional standards, procedures and career...
EDUCATION / PROFESSIONAL TRAINING
1991 BROWARD COMMUNlìY COLLEGE I BROWARD POLICE ACADEMY Davie, Florida
Certificate of Compliance - Florida Law Enforcement Standards (698 hours)
Certificate of Achievement - Academic Honors
1990 FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSlìY Tallahassee, Rorida
Bachelor of Science - Marketing 1 Communications
Bachelor of Science - Criminology
Cumulative G.P,A.; 3.01
1988 FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSlìY Tallahassee, Florida
Associate of Arts - Liberal Arts
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
1 0/90 DELRA Y BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Delray Beach, Rorida
to Police Officer
Present Full responsibility for protection of life and property through prevention, detection and
investigation of crimes, maintaining law and order, community involvement and enforcing
city ordinance and state statutes in sea-side community of 50,000 full time residents and
seasonal population of up to 100,000... Provide security and safety of visitors for major
events including Virginia Slims Tennis Tournament and Delray Affair (300,000 people
visiting during 3-day event)... Interact with youth of community through -Kids & Cops·,
-DARE", Explorer, DUI Task Force programs.., Additional responsibilities (part-time)
inclucle Dispatcher - Police Department Communication Center with responsibility for
management of computer tracking of police units in their performance of duty
assignments...
07/94 ALL COUNìY TRAFFIC SCHOOL INC. Davie, Florida
to Instructor
Present Responsible for instructing driver inprovement training in a class room setting to adults of
all ages...
, '
.
-----
. .
SEAN ANDRE ANDERSON
Page 2
08/89 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFFS OFFICE West Palm Beach. Florida
to Internship
1 2/89 Internship position through FSU acquiring "hands-on" knowledge of Marine patrol,
Aviation. Evidence, Communications. Records. Training, Traffic, Road Patrol, Warrants, K-
9, Detective Bureau, Crime Scene, Crime Lab. Organized Crime Bureau, Special
Operations Unit and Tactical Operations areas of law enforcement agency encompassing
3600 square miles of primarily residential/industrial development including exclusive
private estates... Participated in the execution of search warrants, arrests, surveillance
and routine patrol activities.,.
FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY Tallahassee. Florida
05/90 Administrative Assistant to Internship Director: School of Criminology
to Responsible for tracking and reporting on progress of student participants in FSU
07/90 Criminology Department internship program.., Provided information and assistance to
student appHcants to aide in program acceptance,
08/88 Student Ambassador: Visitor Information Center
to Fulfilled obligations of University Host including visitor services, interaction with
05/90 prospective Students and their families, and welcoming of special guests of University
President...Host / Speaker for numerous conferences; large and small... Entertained
foreign dignitaries, top educatOrs. corporate executives...
08/88 Judicial Officer: JUSTICE of University Lower Court
to Appointed by FSU Chief Judicial Officer to hear cases involving violations of student
08/89 conduct code in cooperation with other Justices.,. Determined guilt or innocence,
administered appropriate sentences.,.
01/88 Judicial Officer: CHIEF JUSTICE of University Residence Hall Judicial Board
to Elected by peers to serve in position requiring supervision of 12 Justices... Assured
05/88 fairness of trials and supervised all hearings / trials.
08/87 Judicial Officer: JUSTICE of University Residence Hall Judicial Board
to Heard cases involving code violations, determined guilt or innocence, recommended
08/88 proper sanctions...
08/87 Student Assistant: Kellum Hall-- Resident Student Life
to Assumed responsibility for 65 male residents within dormitory environment; managed all
04/88 problem situations, maintained order, coordinated activities, and BSSlJ'ed conformance to
conduct codes while promoting an atmosphere conducive to learning. maturing. and
enjoyment.. .
AWARDS / COMMENDATIONS
Co-Employee of the Month - May 1995
Officer of the Month - January 1995
Patrol Division Commendations - 10
Performance Recognitions - 20
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Listing of additional professional certifications / training courses available upon request.
State of Florida -- Real Estate Sales Person License (inactive status)
Driver Training Associates - Driver Improvement Instructor
NAUI Scuba Certification
Florida Chauffeur's License / Florida Motorcycle License
Willing to travel or relocate
.
.
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER~
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # ~,F - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
AMENDED LEASE BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE FEC RAILROAD
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider the amended lease
between the City and the FEC Railroad for six parcels being
leased for parking, roadway, sidewalk, and beautification.
The current lease has been amended to increase the rental by $100
to $6000 per year, and includes the stipulation that the railway
have the right to enter the property for the purpose of inspec-
tion and to ensure the City's compliance with the terms and
conditions of the lease. All other terms and conditions of the
Agreement remain unchanged. The last price increase was prior to
1991.
Recommend approval of the amended lease with the FEC Railroad for
the six parcels leased by the City.
~ FLORIDA EAST COAST RAILWAY COMPANY
ONE MALAGA STREET, p, O. BOX 1048, ST. AUGUSTINE, FWRlDA 82085·1048
November 28, 1995
File: 317-3-1
DELRAY BEACH: Lease of6 Parcels for Parking, Roadway, Sidewalk, Beautification MP 316 + 3857'±
Mr. David T. Harden, Manager
City of Delray Beach
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444-2698
Dear Mr. Harden:
As part of the Railway's ongoing Lease review and revision program, rentals for Railway's property are
periodically amended to reflect a fair return on the current market value of property. Additionally, new terms
and conditions are added to reflect the changing needs of the customer and the Railway. Accordingly, your
Lease has been amended to include a new rental charge and provision as set forth below:
1. The base rental will be increased to $6,000.00 annually, plus Florida Sales and Use Tax, effective
January 9, 1996, and Lessee will thereafter be billed accordingly.
2. Railway shall have the right, at reasonable times during the term of this lease, upon prior notice to
Lessee and accompanied by a representative of Lessee (except in cases of emergency) to enter the
leased property, including any building or structure that may at any time be on the leased property, for
the purpose of examining and inspecting the condition of the leased property and to ensure Lessee's
compliance with the terms and conditions of this lease.
All other terms and conditions of the Agreement will remain unchanged and in full force and effect Kindly
acknowledge your acceptance of this amendment by endorsing and returning one executed original to the
undersigned prior to the effective date. Your prompt handling and return is requested.
Sincerely yours,
7$,;1 ß~
M. O. Bagley a ger
MOB/ver Industrial Development and Real Estate
AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT ACKNOWLEDGED AND ACCEPTED:
This day of 19
By:
Print Name and Title:
cc: Mr. D. A. Smith
Mr. R. 1. Jones
, ,
·
'~
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the hereby leased property:
For the term of one ( 1 ) year from the effective date hereof
subject to renewal as provided in paragraph liD" hereof, or until
terminated as hereinafter provided.
LESSEE COVENANTS TO PAY RENTAL AS FOLLOWS:
An annual rental of $5,900.00, plus Florida Sales and Use
Tax, payable in cash upon the execution and delivery of this Lease,
and if renewed, the same amount in cash in advance for each and every
year thereafter until terminated. All rentals for initial and renewal
terms are payable in cash on the date specified, in advance, without
oeal oe written demand. Lessee heeeby expeessly waiving such demand.
LESSEE AND RAILWAY COVENANT AS FOLLOWS:
-
A. In the event of termination of this lease by Railway before
the expiration of the initial or any renewal teems, any rental paid
in advance unearned shall be returned to Lessee, less any amounts
owing to Railway undee this lease.
B. That none of the peovisions hereof shall be waived oe
modified, except by Railway, or by mutual agreement, in writing,
and no alleged veebal or written inducement prior to execution nor:-
subsequent verbal waiver, or modification, shall be binding under
any circumstances. Fuethee, that this lease constitutes the entir:-e
undeestanding of the parties and that neither the failure of the
Railway to enforce each and every provision, nor any course of
conducê-s¥ the Railway shall be considered as a waiver of these
provisiOns .
C. Either party may, in its discretion, for; any reason
whatsoever, terminate this lease at any time by ~he giving of notice
to the other party as hereinafter provided. If this lease is for a
term of one or more years, then 30 days prior notice i0 writing of
the intention of the party to terminate this lease shall be given
to the other party. If this lease is for any term less than one
year, then 10 days prioe notice in writing of the intention of the
party to terminate this lease shall be given to the other party;
PROVI DED, HOWEVER, Railway may, at its option, terminate this lease
for any default or breach of lessee by giving 2 days notice in writing
of such termination to the lessee. Any notice of termination shall
be delivered to the other party by placing such notice in the United
States mail with sufficient postage directed to the other party's
post office address, either as last furnished to the terminating
party or as otherwise known to it.
D. If Lessee holds over and remains in possession of the hereby
leased property after the expiration of the term specified i,n this
lease, or any renewals of such term, this lease shall be considered
as renewed for one ( I ) year, subject to the same terms and conditions
as herein contained in this lease. That Lessee shall have no expecta-
tion of renewal and that the term of this lease is only for the time
Page 2
·
[IT' DF DELIA' IEA[H
DElRAY BEACH
f \ 0 II: I [) A
tI.ftd 100 N,W. 1st AVENUE, DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 . 407/243-7000
AII·America City
, III I!
1993
The following land parcels are presently leased from F,E.C. Railroad and
are budgeted in the Public Works accounts as indicated,
001-3113-541-44.10 STREETS MAINTENANCE
PARCEL B ROADWAY (RAILROAD AVENUE)
PARCEL E-F BEAUTIFICATION ALONG RAILROAD
PARCEL C SIDEW ALK S.E, 3RD A VENUE
001-3151-545-44,10 PARKING FACILITIES
PARCEL A PARKING LOT
PARCEL D PARKING LOT
12/8/95/sdl
@ Print9d on Recycled Paper THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
, '
--J l
-.JTIC
l
I (' ,. I - I I ,
I '; '-, , ; ~ - J I 1-1-- --.'~, _1,1
~ (;"67
'" I Z9~36
·4 ;-
I AS;7.30 I ; I ~~6
., .
, -, !rL II
~ I j I -~ L___
.E. ~ R E E T (RAY1\AOND AVE.)
-, ¡ l ,-
, ,~ I II
~$/J~~~~~- ~ i
Q·<,.:Jõ?, . .1
I I .--- qg T-~ - ¡
-n ~ I;:;
-
tu U' I ·1 I
, 0 -.. , j
~-~.,~--- (', ~¡ ~ i :
-~ - : I ' ~ ¡
i œ f I
r .. -~)_ t _ ~
;.E. ~ STREE/.T I nNGRAHAM AVe..
--" , ( lItE, ;'%;:¡it73.;:-~-1 '---, r--
." 1 :Z , 4~ 0 3~ Zý' A
~ ' I I /'"f~"'Q#',
'~-""7
:P
i . r oS 15 ~ "11
)Þ ,.-----. 0
, , ~ IE; 16 ,
(, n , ----.-.-. --1 C ¡
, /It ' 7 11-'
'1"( ,--_.'...:r (Q
8 18
---:-" - ~
,.~. _1~" ~ ~ ):
f 10 to ~ " I
-- .--..- ' , Þ- .
II 'Z I
, ..-- -.------ <
1% z: f11
.,,- ;/6";7. 'I
4- 4. Ib ,,' 4.s
rv~ S: w. ¡ 14-- ';is'!í '" .--.J_
'" , "'. I'''' 5.. ë.TH' ~D STR.E ET
¡ I f' " . , '~ " r,-'" ,,' -l r---
. ~ ' , . I ' ~ ,
"', I I) \) , I
'...-.-1 ~_.-:. c,.' , ' I j
. 'I
J 't "Qj
I . r~~,....;
N . E. L. (LA! NG ST.) L"'-tfl RD I';OL~-! -~JJ~i!R1tT ", ~-
- -I 4. -. -~ r-' '7--'~ ~I.
I N.w. NW -J ~' I 1 11
: (j). --.~ .1 "
1"11 : rn ,.I
h () 'u_____.__ » t
'10' !ol·~---·· .-- . -- cD './ , ê?
lit. I m 0 I'
,VII '... , :z' , - -- Z ( lV1 p
,-f t' t ¡ , , ' J U7 '. 31,
, ! '-.JO~. - ~¡, t '"', CI' ) J
. -~ t' . )("111 ~: -
1; I~· OJ
j I r-" -----,,' ! r ,', ';I
t I 'Ii i i 0
¡ Ir'-:-~: I .
- ---- ...:=.- ~. - ~.)
N. E.. (THOMAS AVE E CON '
~----l I T ~
L.-..-__
i
I I I
» I ,
< < I- /'
~ ~ , ,
~ Z ~ '" 'f ~, zit
C" "1m
i~ !m Ii J
I ¡ I /:-- t
I : " -.'....¡ ......l'
...~_.-J L. _...J ¡I! . . . . j~ ----.J I', I
N . E. eM 1 Ll..E. R ST.) FIR. S T " Jfé7/9f70,4 £-tGO' ~~s T R E E T
------. ---lirs.w 4. N. w.... ,,~ Q;
- ! lJ _'hn_ I '::....
rl ~ I' ~
ell' ?J - ,___ -. _ ~ ()
y I 7IJ ' I I~ ;,. <
"1M I' I'
(V I I ~ ' I ~ t)
~ I .,'.~!~ ~ f
¡(J) '~IQ~'
CI\ 1:-1:, r.\ I
:-; I' _/ ~~ : 'fJ
I,~ ' I ~
i,~ ,fl' ~ i :
"þ..;' "" s: No. / D 1- ~=.-=::J . . I, 1._
I L:·G, /6""7 I ¡II
. ... .s ~ 7/ j " ' , ¡ , I'
. o". t- /L' ..". -. I I
\) 0".:1" i
.:> ,
, , t
j , -\ -n." , 47. I L" J i L-. 'n'
.. .,... , ^ "I T I ' ~" , I A \
,'\. (' -~.R806-- ____ _ __._ _ _ ,
'" --- - -- -,/"6 '?' ,"':"
~---:-, /O/.~ ii ¡ . - 6 í ,,? /. 2 ~ ~---
Ií ~ I. ! tó' 7" ~~,
.
. , , r \ ,>:>:<:.",,0/. ·.jr '
~. ,," "p~
"J~1:;J<;1~~~~~i,~~~? ~y:;" .
'\ii~";'!"'''M<'' ',' " ",'<
- ....!'~0~;;~':~Jt¡1~' '~t .'
"'k'~~'""<' ... "',.. '.
. ""r'~;\' ~'ë" "~"~I' Æ.,., ' ,. "
,.;'.. ,:'''' . ,:"J ~1Í-~ 1.1'., '. ';':..'~ .... /t," ,:~;~-. ,\",,'"
·...';(",:\t!i~~.I,,~\ .:~". ¿tr ~/,
.- ': "'" :,' ~\' .~,~,~",.¡".~ ,g." ~~,
,,, "'t ','" "~r'
/ -, \"" ""'ì~""" ·"C " .",
,<{;{~::~/i::·,\~·,J!1:'\.-Æ·) :!,;,: . -.~':~'. . _:¡.~;þ'
, , . ", Y" '" :"""''f'' '
, '.. ii' '" 'j. ';;,'."'. '. t,~:¡:,...t;~r-- ¡o; ì'
~ . ~ h. [f~ l' ! :~::~' '.~^J
. ,'_ _'_--~- ,-,,- ," ..3, >,',. ''-:¡i¡ ~,: ,~~
"- " '_ .. ....-..--~ ....\;. t f '~1Í' ,,~ ^
'. " . r':'<;"I¡¡q~, .:
" j:c ;...~ j '..''fc ....
. '. : ;A/l'!(¡¡ '. 't \
, , " f'~:,;J~t"1>"(¡' ,
, ; ,..!"¡.~..,.
. ··I'·,·tt~\ ~?
\ \ $" : 't¡;~';J~:- I~
. '1P,f~~::'
) "Ii- kl.~ 1 > "'Ì"~.;.. "fl,
)\ ", \ ..,. ·:....1 ¡~..~ ¡ .~~ 'r
, ~~".,~,,~ ~ .
l¡'c ", >i':\':. '. ,'1.; \. f7' :¡,~.
ðlDC~ S¡ 9' no/oS /6775 .¡- ~s. 2 ) ".;';í~ ,. pi'
"', I .'" . "2.
':~\'¿!~:::\I -:. .",
ì" - .j....'..,,) >
. ^', " . '\ > /\ .;." ~
\ .. " I e- I'
~fi .~ 4 (5
1&7 .1
" Ô' - !:>
> . 'Q;! \' .,; ~ » 14 ~
~ " :H( b
1 ~
CX) ,.10' rl
¡
\)) l\ \l
~ \ . '~ ß
I'
=' 5\,
. :'" -? J....-' ''"';
__'15 Paved X~/'n<? "'801 ... r '" (' ~ ( . , '
/b .' L.... II..
.) ----'-
\
/ô73::.'..L3/,)
A-'-
N.V'J. ::>
,;
/' /'
.
I
/67<'3 5 ~ 3ð.O 'É 35'.,;,",
I \S'A '.,
.
-
- - --. - ~-
:"'", 7"~ '\
.l
. ~ . , ,',
I '.~ I~_..-
.
·
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER m(
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # 5'·G. - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12. 1995
RESOLUTION 89-95
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to adopt Resolution No. 89-95
supporting the Palm Beach County Graffiti Eradication Program
prepared by the Criminal Justice Commission. The Municipal
League is endorsing a policy of zero tolerance, and requesting
the Criminal Justice Commission to coordinate the implementation
of the program. The outline of the Program is attached to the
resolution. The only direct effect on us is that some graffiti
in Delray Beach may be reported to the Graffiti Hotline. The
report would then be relayed to us for action.
While the Program is certainly a step forward, in our experience,
starting steps 6-10 thirty days after the initial report is not
compatible with the stated objective of "eradicationll. Our
objective is to have graffiti removed within one week.
Recommend adoption of Resolution No. 89-95.
~ðn ~
,
--~--- .--_. .. --
¡
I
I
Section 3 : The Criminal Justice Commission is hereby I
requested to coordinate the implementation of the program using I
resources available for this purpose as a pilot project and it is I
further respectfully requested that a copy of the status report be ,
,
provided to the City of Delray Beach, Florida.
¡
Section 4: This Resolution shall take effect immediately ¡
i
upon adoption. I
I
I
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on this 12th day of I
I
December, 1995. I
~~ !
¡
ATTEST:
()1/Nrn'i[)J~ /t;,1"r hh-ॠ:
City Clerk t
,
I
,
I
\
-2- Res. No. 89-95
. ,
12/e7/1995 11:19 4e7-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 02
~
ii'
¡. ~
~
I:
n
§' ;
ÞO-' . (þ
='
~ ~.........
t--' ~ '-J
~ ~
~ =-. to ~
~ n ~
(J1 (C ~ ~
n ~ ~
°n~ 0
§ g Z CO '''.
00· =
L. 5' ~ ~
-
-
.-
......~:L
.....
,
!L/~II!~~~ !!:!~ q~/-j~~-4~41 . P~C CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 03
:':Y~~7~'~;1,:r~ .
, ," ",,"""" I~J"""'_;';
~ .,~ ;. _:""':'~';\B'I:~;~~;:( ,~,.....~
,;.",r.'J' t~;i-.l
, ':~-J f.' ,Ii~~,:~: . . . ~ .~
9?.
I -I
I Q) Q) Q) 0 0 e
:::Jt.n::3ca
0. c.Q)c.
Q) c- CD
= -0 2. 0
Sl c- :3_ N ëD
<- 0 < CD
-- Q) Q) C. Q)
0:...,...... (J)
CD C. (t) cc CD
tJJ en a
· "'C
........,C,....
OO-o:T
-C(J)CD
-0(1)
a~O-C
'"'" ,<-hO
~
~ :] '<"""
0... (t)
t:::T0:J ',. .~
::Jas.~ . .oj.
ÿ~:
'··'f'·il
g""':
£C::TeE.. m ."
'~;.
I,Çf~
CC...., I"
==::ra ' ~ --~ .~~!
~ !r
m03 ~t-.
~ .~"i.~~ ~t:
ccs. .., j~~~~:,
;;{~i~~
Lr eE........c:'<
' ',> J1.~t:~
. ~. ,~--,-:".:"~',:.~
£:. ::TtJ'J :j/11~f1:,
'''..1 -. CD S· 0 :'.':, "~~1:"~'~i
-- ::J cc t: ,:/'-
..... ,....
III CD() ::r
III :Jo-C :I
=cc:w
III 0:JC-
::Sro+=:::]
- cn,<nc. ....
______eek;
t\)
12/0711995
. 11: 19 4a7-355-4941 '
i' PBC CRIM JUST COMM
PAGE a5
!t
i .
f- ëDO . .
CJëD-i
33: "0-1 .
o N (1) "'C :T ~~ ()
< CD D) 0 CD a::r
CD ~ g.:::1ãJ "OCT)
ccen (1) c c:: 0
("') .-+ -. ~, S: ~ at £:
œ 3 o :::r en ~ ~
:;R£: c: CD :::s 3· ~. ... CQ ~
.-+cn ~ Q. 0 .-+~ am
-. .-+ ~~@
::T(J) c:: ~
æ Q) S ~ CD::r ¡CD
~ ~ .-+ 8 ~
Q.3Q3 ::J
3 CD Q)O'
0 CD - ( ) ~
:::s ~ n 3::: ~£
-c ~o c=
~§ ~- ffi3
a =:;:CD
- -0 it err 0 i~
~
~ en ..,
CII -. ~ -aQ)
(:)" ¡ ~ 0 ('þ(Q
:t .-+CÐ
0 0 2:8 æ ~
..,-0 o Q.
~ "0 2. g.~ ëiJ m
::1. ;::, ~a
~ <....
D) 0 =r - o::r
Cñ (i)~ ~o .....1:\)
c.c~ . .' .;!
....... "'C8 -< ~, ., ·r~
0 <. CD .~
.., , r:'''~
~' a ~ CD .., Q) æ r:J
" c. ~ ;:~,.~~
',," -oS" ~8
.. ...
I. J.. ~I,.,
CD ~ ::T = ' '41#;
II æ- ~s¡ ·:f'·~~
o CD cc .' ..ct'¡
,,, ~~ .~'..
~ ~ 2. f!.~';"
- 0' ~c. VI:: ,""I'
,:.4'.1';\' .l'~~
t~r;;~~~·~~t1.
:e ..... CD :::::s N ì;~:\t, /-.10 ~;!,t
III Q) ~(') Q)ãr g.~ :t!~:;j
~ =r;:+ 5.£
III Q. -
-. -. _.~
:::::s N "2.3 t/J 0 0\,
~ ,,~ . ,.:' .. ~~f
III 3 c: )-, ._,
::r Q) CD .¡ I, ~ .-:,;:~ ' '.
""';;"i' -,Ii
- CD Q) en ~:::s :r St
:::s - ' .
3 0 ....
.-."'.,' ".'
0 s:~ ;;-"
-... .....
... ..øœ CDQ., :I
, ' ' -
!~/~(I!~~~ 11:19 4E:17-355-4941 ' PSG GRIM JUST GOMM PAGE 06
I
it
k · · · . . . .
;' ~ ~"£;f õ;! ....... ~i~;i ~~~ i ~
I !! CD !: CD ¡fCD rp~!~~lg I~ if.i ;.8'
. -g 0 G')
:: ~ 8 ::I. 0'"
. 9. ~ I» 3 ::!. ~ i! i]ll' CQ 3' . 2 m ~ (þ S-
a. -. 3 r 'fn~~ CD ~~ ~s;¡ III i
~. 0 ~ ¡ -, . < "'tJ 0 ' -. 0 G') 3
g~o-~m !Hrh~~ ~'b' i-~ ~g
() - c.. m. iJ
O)o~c c..Q.
sa c 0 sa. c -. flU. . ,HI ~3 ::0 ~ ' e.
)(':1 (D' Q' ~ i C1
éñ~ ~ 8 ' 'UHf! ! ~ i:l~ [~,
-0 i~ ::I
3 0 g> en
o 3 sa, § 3 c iiìl(lï I ~~ 3 8 ii -.
~:iI. ~ iiI' 3 i I f I ~!P. i::o ::0 ~ C.
CD m, !f -. iii' ". "T1 Q) ..... 1J
<: 0 0 en 3 tit f . ~ ~l ~~c8:r
-. æ <D ~ g' .
2 ti1 <. 0 ' i ( .' "~~i»"
, ~I[ ~J I i r ~ ~ ~ ! i ~J
o ~õ ~
.... '2~... CD i-' f I Ii!)!!: g~g'
~ ~ ~.8 i Ii.. . ~!6 c I¡!¡
-f f D)< ~ =r
UI ~ )( 3 lj ~ ~~õ ~'fi
m3
-c- Q) "TJ 0) "C..... ~ C ' ~
.~. .
... 3 CD "0 i.'" ªc»æ 3 ~ " ;""'")'. . ;~~
c8 = - ' '~f
o a. I» Ii £!!lQ~' ~ ,t(:~~
¡) 3. - ::I . ~.' ._~.,~
3 =r0 Q) :~~fr~ :i ~"ei
fJ) ~ ::I ":':;5,-r,t
. Q. !. 3 -, ID ": '~.>'.
g g' (D -. ~ S' g ;~f~':
8Q.!., - ;C ":\~:;c: :
§ å e o' œ 0 a ~ . .~.;;~~ .';¡
".,' .'....
'.. ...'111.,.
3 :.. I ~ë~ ~ ~g II . '~:,;:~
L i "ª- it f~~' 1 J :c
a:: (n CD ëa 3 8 ~ ~ ~.
- 3 8
__ ~ CD
æ 3. 3 3 3 3 ..... B- ID
a33 Q)
_ U1 ~ 3 m ~ m: § if
Q) 0 CD -t
en ::J ::I
__ ~ 9. _ ~ f~ î I
tD
_ ~ :T g
s: =r 2- -
I CD (D 0 0 .~
--
_II____~~;I..
01
I
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 07
r
~
I ~ --
i II:III.Ii
~B
~
~
.-D
D.-
... ~
~
~ ...
CJ\
I ~
CIIÞ '.t, .'
\~1
- -& "1 !~:~
~
,.il~
~ ,~
~ :"'.~.~
,;~.~~~f
:;æ<;";~]
~ ~- f~~ ~~r;'~
, .' ·f;r,~-.,
t~1ê·
£i ~
'"
-~ ,_',"'_ .0..:,.... _'.
",', ..¡. .,'
." ('O",,,,,¡.,.
S? .... .¡.,.....;.;. .
't,', .!-;.',:, -'..
" .;"""':~ ."
--
-
-- ~
,. ."
II
--
-.....ø_
0)
.
PAGE 08
. PBC CRIM JUST COMM
407-355-4941
12/137/1995 11:19
4
..
~
ï ~ »
@. ~ Q)::3......
¡. ~ ~s =~ ~
C/J P (') ~ -=:
'ÞJ O"'\P @g~
J.i...J (') ~ . ~ CD
l7j c~ ~ ~ ã3 ~
Cð ~ ~ ~ "" SQ. (') tD
"'-.. ... ~ \..J. a. Q)
(J)" h .... C CD ~ ...
<: .oÞo ~ p :J -5 w
~. ~ 0 fJl ~ Cñ Q) ..
$ · f"'+- Q) -. Vt 0
~ 0..l1 (J '<. ::3 cg .... ) ,
,...... ~ C. II "" .. {,
~ ¡.., ~ -. "V" _;t .~
ìb ./"ttw 0 (JJ... ~ '"
'" t= -- S". 3 _ .... -,¡ ij, J'
~ '=i:? Sf'\ ~ C Q) AI It".~',;"
-: '<1 _1' ... C a !~'~'i~
~ ..... ..........
- . -. '''~'.-.'-
,... .....
- - - ~. (") :J !."~", ':0;.,':-"
. ~ - ~ -. (') ~{.,,,,,
~ ... ~ "'0 ::r~::,;,.
.,. .... - ~ I:?. , et (1)0. :e. t~:~.',::,.;:::;·' .~,;.
-... ! (J '" _. ~'" .
r _. r..:. __ _ . ',',".'"
",\~ a P - ã)' õ"
~A:' ~ ~ - en 0
I!iJ ~ -- t::: ~ ........,) _.
· ~~ ~ p.::o- ~ s. a .....
"'" ~ - ..... t -4 0 ~
.: ~ Õ· ~ _ ... ~
.~ ~ tj c:f!!! ~ 3 ~
- ~
:.....II!tá!'
....,¡
. '
12/e7/1995 11:19 4e7-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 09
"'-..,. ,......~·~rn·
'" , ., "" 1" ·"t~~r
,::;, ~;::;,\~~~> \~j~ .~'. ',:¥, ~.~
( .. ,·~,/Ji~~Î.\~~·
;<:'.;-,::i~~t~é.~I~J,:~.t t' "lí!
G)
~
t ~
I
~
,.....
-.
-.
CIJ
tJ'J
-C
0
=
CD
C.
·
·
·
'"
.. ....
~ II
"
f.1I
~
- ·
0 ·
·
n ,.....
::s-
O) CÐ
~
-.
t:~ 0 Q)
.' . :J c..
" ,~ , ',' .~ ~. ',J
-. C. ,:, .,.,~:~.~~..~
fæ ~...:' . .t'
'1'::-' .'~ ,.
,"f en ã3 . "
.
.
- .
:J (JJ ~,¡ ....:.......,
-- 0 (JJ
fIllIP
-- (1) 0
Q. ..,
. ·
·
·
.
----__øœ
Q:)
. '
.
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 10
n
~:
~
k
ã' OJ:
I CD:"
Q) ::r
n CD
::rtJ?
()-o
o ~
c:: CD
:J ..,
~....
I\.) CD
.þ.-g
::t:æ-
0
c: ...
-, ::r
G)CD '"
- -, Q)
~ ...
Q) C. tD
( :f¡~ "
c:tCD W
::r:tJ?
O~
... -
=:0
::J 0
CD æ. X';;.~
· -. 1.1,"
· 0
· "
::J
L a-
t.
~ ,
,....
. ::r
CD
III -c
-- Q)
-
- 3
-
-----_':!:I..'
c.o
.
.
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 11
I · · .
· · .
· ·
." .
I- ,t_AA"1 "G» n o.:t0 8 c: m ";i
a n - 0 .., ::S::J (1)
~ 0 m ::J CD -c 3 :r "'""h
f æ(Q~ ::J (1) 3 a "2.8 ~ º
i c: c: "C Q) ...
-I 0 "C ~ =' CD -. -g (1) Ñ·
· ~ .... 3 - õ·;:¡ ~ 3 CD
o " ... -. ãr =r" CD ::J
::s :T 9- ~ "'0 Q) ::J
-r'I CD :: Q) tA Q) ~.r+ en
o -~- tA (1)
~ ::J œ 0. ~ £ C'" -. <
Q §¡ 2. ( ) : ( ) ~ ~ ~.
( ) 0 -.... CD CD ::J
... 3-"'[::J
o ~ Q) -. Q) =:
... ., U) ëiJ U) ::h 0
=r c:t. ::T CD :e .. CD CD
mow SS; "8 Q) ( ) ::s
< ::J r+ m tA...
(1) C" "C - .;:::a. ... (1)
st ür CD N ~::s (1) :e æ ....,
(II (1) Q) Q. (1)
CD æ ......, : = :e
co U) 0 st3 . Q)~;::+
., a. E...... m c: ( ) 0 :::r
Q) ... 0 .... ::J -c
~ 6" U) œ ... õ' 0 CD Q)
- ... ., ::T _. :H ~ U)
~ .... ::T Q) 0 "C 0 U)
::T (1) U) Q) -. (if
"0 CD _.::J CÐ - m ,....
0\ ::r .., Q ;::+ lñ 0 Q)
So "'C æ 3 ':< ~ ~ :;,
o œ en" C::f O::J @
cc-oo::J "CD
ã3 3 ~ == õ· CD ¿:¡r"':r
-c aJ ~ ~ -e. 0 Q. Q) 0
=r CÐ Q) CD CD::J 3
8. m ~ 0 ::': ::s OJ Q.
g.' ::J ~ãt - '1J
~ · (1) ::J Q)
o ccU)-s mo-
., (") i» E~' &. ~ 3
Ë{ ~ g :R:T= en CD OJ
.,....,
,- '., Q)::J cr. 0 3 6t en CD
II -~ m'" Q)
(J) Q)::T~ (1)~o
- ür en ::J ~ CÐ "C 0 ::T
Q)::T 0. (1)::J a ~ ()
III ::J~ CÐ::S~ ¡ 0 '"'''''.-..''''V.
. .......'
.:,'.,f
C. -. t/J 0 -. 0 c: ..' ".; "'~. _,', _ ',(.1
" ~".,1.,....,
- :::; ärr+::h ;::¡'~::J
-g t/J C" Q) Q ':<:J .:<
III ~o =:;:;c:t. ...CDO
ø CD 0 ::T"
III -. :R ::s- D)::S Q) CJ) 0
2: Q 0. r+ ... _. 0-
eD Q) '< 0 Q)::J CD
.._____lIIe_
0
--
, '
.
1~/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 12
.. .-..-;-- ~~.~r-'
I ¡;'-'-'-J:J:J:G)G)G)~G)i°aJaJr~~ CD -C'
CCC - - -~O - ·
i ~i:i:5~cg.~ 5.i ~ ! D1 ~~~ ër!l ~ ~ S:
~. a! !It g'~Iªg¡¡¡: I' ~i~!01Ig¡fØIt- ~ 3 CD
I: ii g.°g'-~a 'ig.~mrgi fimQ
en 0 D) a n =r ('þ -.
::r 2. 9- :r "C Q) 3
o 0 ..., (") -.
m ::J 0 :::r ~
~ ~m~
~,;¡':) p~ 11). c....
. R~· · 3 :E ~
: ~.~ -<P !"=c:!:
1 9.~?J ~: -~
~~ R' ~ g. ~ ()
: 0 00
: 0 · 0 03
: , .0 c
~ ;¡'~. Á1,-o,~ ã3 2.
: ~.lon cc en
: CD en '"
· ~~ -.
.... · Q) g i
~ ·
, f!§.
ii · ~ ... "
·
( · O-:E
· ~~ ~ '"
· -.
t·~ :E"'"
· t ,«,~~.
· 0::T
:... ~ ~ },.,. t~ .... ., Q)
· '.·'.I'~I
· ~ [ ,,' ';.~':.\ ';1\"(1)
· R ~'I' .,'
, ~ ,f·' ",-' en
· ~. = ;~;.(~~
· :E ëir
· li~
,
· - . ,....
, :.TO)
·
, ::::J
'4 ~ ffi 3 £ '. . .
.:..': c:
~ ~~lØ~~~~~~~~O!~~¡;¡;¡; 2. a'
~~ 0 o<~~__ ~ D)D)i~~ G. 3
. :::~Ii~§:1¡¡)3333ð ~i CDID ~
e!.m
· 1~1~~iil[lrii~~I¡¡:!¡ ;:+('þ
3 3'< ::J, g. a-a:::S -'0)
('þ c:
· f f r 'iø~ 'if~ . (I).....
-.
,..--to\
· :3 g. g. fag. oE-
III a
.. 1
...
,
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 13
( ~ ~:
~ O~Q)·
~ ..... _. ~ --I
2 -. ~ =r
I: f::StlJCD
C. Q),..,.,
, =~~
o .... .. CD -.
:;jO-'~
CD .... ~
() ::r:::J
CD CD
:::.1 Q. -. en
CD 2. CD
..,Q)~<
.. Q)-.
;:r-,-n
Q) CD 8 CD
..0,)
....(,/J::;,()
:::r œCD
(1) S. n ~ '"
.. Ci> .... ~ ~
~ ~ ~ .~
<ìS Q) '::j ,.... (J) "
QI ~CD 0 (1)
~ .....::J 0-
-. '::j a.
::TeJO(j)
Q) 0 (J)
en c: CD Q)
C'" a"'C
CD'<.,~
CD 0 . "
~ .-+ -c Õ=" ;
L' 0, ::T CD ~
, ~Q);::¡'<
~" " CD ..... '< c:1
~ 3
..
_ 0 :ro-c
. ~~~~
-- : ;] ~
· ::J v#
III 0 -. (.ù
III ....::;,0
_.....£.:1-
...
I\,)
, '
.
12/07/1995 11: 19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 14
.,' :':'i <~:;1~:'11: .....,.:..
......, I . ·F'!,,¡.'.:¡~~f.I' .,~I'.
O ..,{,..,...~+'" ~".
..'.. ...I.,~,,,M, .
I ," '''I'' ,¡r,..~ . ..
.. .. . ' , ',~ I." ,~. ....'....
· .',," ,'-,~.'\... (..:-.....,Jt.....~s.:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~§:
~ : g. e. Go e- -.:0
I ~ ~ ~ å It'Þ ~ CD
· ~ ~ ~ S t/I
· ::s ~ ~ I-' ...-a
g. 101 ::to -a 0
~ a S o:S
"'0 ~ ~ ... t/I
~ 8 0 g- ad>
~ ~ & g tD-a
'< ..... F... a. 0
~. [ · ~ s» t/I
~ =- EI ~ t/I
~ C'Ø ~ CD-'
~~ ~ A'c-
=:¡ =:::r Q. ..., -.
2 ~ : t/I =
- -. . ...
~ en 0 -.
o = .... CD '"
-= = ... (I) eo
~ ~ II
~ a i fa' "
~ ~ g. ~ 0-' --..
~ 101: ã 0 0
=:::r å ~ ~. : c ~
(j 0 ~ g : ~ :s
o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a CD
§ 9-;:+' ~ ~ ;:s '< ...
~ C'Ø ~. e.. ~ ~. : fA
... r-r .
(j Q9 0 ~. þ) ~. -.
&. ~ gg ~. ~ _ ::::s
.n.' ('þ Si C'Ø C 0= cß =
~ t:n p-. Q.. ~ c§ ~
S'.- = . ~ CD ~ Q.. CD . ".';".':'
.,!, O~ Q.. c·· .,"~
c ÞO;oot -. ,.. .
~ 0 ~ ~ ~.,
· § 8 is ~ 6J
-- g ~ a ..., ä
II,.... ('þ ~ ~. ëñ ·
§ !. genS
- c.. < ~ ~ (' ) .,
-: (' ) . a 0..
. . ~ ¡" .
·
1I_____ØI!~
.....
(,,)
.
.
12/e7/1995 11:19 4e7-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 15
º
I 8~:
~ tu .
~ ~ -. C")
i.. tJJ 3. 0
CD c.
~ en CD
. ~~
I, cr:g ~
3~0'
: en §
::J 3
CD CD
CD ::J
0.,..
CD
0.<
.. -.
en
,...p - .
:rP"+
CD en
.....
3æ
tu en
::J -.
- -c ED
~ ~ .....
~ < 0
~ n
D) 0
::s 3
c."'C
ëÐ ~··m·· ,,'
::T ~ I~!~~" '.
I'll, "" , ..
êñ ::: ~l4. ~.,~ ~ ".:
Wool ~~.. 'i:;:
= ~ h~~;i,1,
..J 0 ~'I:Ç :Mo/.1'1
~If\" '~'.~~ .' ,~'...
~~ ,: ~:.!:r.~"~·¡""
.~~,. CD -"r. ~'" ' ,i >
Iii 3 ' ... ,. '.
, {jJ~
." 0 ."",,"
· ~ c.. ..".',.....
.-.,..,.;0..,....,....
- - '" ':~)::"
....., \1' ~t',;""
,.. ..~ ;it
"" D) . " ",':';"Ji!
" of . r. '~i,·~t· ·,i..:
_ _ """"1"
-. --. :"~... ,·r:··.'
tJJ ~ .-. ¡:~
- ~.~
- ~~
Q) CD
-
---___ølfP
-
'"
'.
, ,
12/e7/1995 11:19 4e7-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 16
ï 8 (/J 0 :
-
~ c:: -f\ ·
I- o-c<()
I: a '2. CD 0
-. -.:::::s a.
~CÞc.CD
~rom
CD· "':::J
Q)en~
~s.~~
-. :3" £
~ n 0 3
3 0
Q) :::::s :::T CD
éDQ)~3.
C.$lCDëi)
(þCJJ ~ '"
6)....nCÐ ¡
-. :::T 0 ën
::;CD3.... "
.... o 3 °
~ -0
~ 8 -. ....
CÐc:=:::T
3 :::::s CD CD
o,.....c.Q)
< '< r+ -
CD ° CD
:r8c.Q)
.., c.
CÞæ°'<
(Qn~CD . ;';,:, ..~,
L._ .,1,
L m!:!';.-+CJ) ,-
"
:R0(1)ñ)
L -::I 0-
ct: en -c _
II . Q) -.
: en -. (J)
II ,..:::::s::r
D) ..... CD
II ~Q)c.
-
-- .-+ ::] -.
oa.sa.
.
....IIIIII~:L:
...
0,
-
. '
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 17
ï
¡. Q) C/J :
I ::J('þ;"
f Q.<:T
..... -. ('þ
i£
()
()()O
CD CD c:
::;, ::;, :J
êDCD~
..., ...,
(JJI"+()
6r=r
~Q)Q
_I"+m
o ..... (1
CC :T ..... V)
en (1) 0· I
-. ::s
,.... ..,
-. CD (JJ
..
~ ::s 3 ...
Q) 0 en O·
c.n 1"+
en < Q)
en ~~
Q)
~=r::s
(ncuo
::!1en,....
CD -. " ..~..:'\,fI ~~
c.c-::h . p,~,~
f€.' ,,;e
· CD CD ,~q'., '~.
",.\K1"~ ~
~f·~~.t:
: CD en i'''t~·¡¡;?
~? J~~j¡~,: ;
,'!..," :::J ¡;':"''''~J '''.;.t
", :,:,:>'t~·:r~;::,
fIII+
œ ;:s- , :~->;~,:~:'t:'
8 CD ~,~
--
3
"·'·:':'\1'-"
III () , , ;. ,~.-
"'C
-.
- - ,.... ,,'.
CD -.
.....N
- (1) CD "
c.::s
III
. . III . III 111 S lEi
..
CI)
, '
12/07/1995 11:19 407-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 18
ï :,; ..:i!;:f1~~:·~,·
, ... ',.'","',."!"
:', ,:" .. -. rl.,~, ~ ....
-
(
~.
~
I
-
~
UI
"-::";~"..
,;.1'
'~,
'., ~ '
L
a:.
.. '
-
III
III
.
III
- II III III II III ~.: La
....
....,
, '
.
12/ß7/1995 11:19 4ß7-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 19
~
:;,.
it ~ :i' þotj ~ f. ~ ~
to.
i ::1. ~ a
... . ~ a
;. < <
a a (Ð
I ~ ~ æ. ~ D. t:C 1
~ t ~ i. ~ 3:
< š-
_. ~. ~
= =' < 0
§ ~ ~ ~ (j "
0 ~
~, ('þ ~ ! =
:::s a
(j .... . ~ ~
~ (j
~. a Q.
'"Cj 9 0
þ) ~
- .... ~
~ ~. ~
~
·
.... ~ ·
~ ·
P- I.
0
~ ...
a
.... ~ :-1
~ .-D
01
...
~"? ~ ft»
~ ~ ~ ~ -= 51
e. ..... ~ "
~ ~ ~ ~ i- ~ 3: ~
~ ~ ... :II '
a ~ ("';).
~. ~ ~
....... ~ ...... Q ~
Q ~ ~ ..... ~ ~ .. .. . ,i' "~\¡ ~;
§ œ ' .."1 "
r : ~\'':~~ ~
Q -. ~ ~ ~~~ ~
- C":)
L ~. Q :s' D M..
~ ~. ~ ~ ;ß aQ 0 c
L~ ~ =
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
.
-. ~ ~~~ ...
- ~ ~ CIQ
~ - . ...
-- it ~ tÞ
· sa.
·
~ · ~B
--
~
III
¡-' ~~
III ~
..
____IIIIL'·L ..
..
~
Q)
,-,
, '
12/e7/1995 11:19 4e7-355-4941 PEC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 2e
n
i ~ ~ ~ ~
I ~ ~ f ~
~ ~ ~ ~
t:S 0 0
o ~ ~! _
~ ~ ~
(" ) ~ ~ ..... . -
~ : 0 0 c.
. 0 · ~ ~ _
: c: e; ~ ~ C ..
~ a ð ~- ~ ~-
~ ('þ (" ) ~ (":j ð - 0
~ rI.I V-I ~:r :;:¡"
~õ : g æ ~ ~._
~ '~~ .
i ~ ¡r § ~'.g ~ h ã
(S' ~::r ~ š' ~ ~ ~ == _.
~ tf. f-to -. ~, 0 -
æ §- ('þ (" ) (J ~ - Ill:
.... ô CIJ 0 c;n Q.... ~ - no r..
~ c: ~ = (" ) r::r ::s "'" "
~ 0.. "C ì-+ "C S" c::: 0.. \..1 .. ~)' ~
01 0"'0 _0' "'0 ""'" ,f-to : .... -a ' '.
::s - - - - , ::r L,.....J
-, = _. ~ ~ ~ ~
a (" ) CIJ ('þ "!'t"?1 ~ tf. 00 0 O¡;.i·
c;n ã rI.I 0"'· ,... · ~{
8.. \# ::s \ ~ . ~~<:".
a cr a 0 ~ 2 · Iì a~i,~:'!'
~.... = -. - I .",. "
Q. .........';,
(J;.....:r :s ¡fL.. "
Q..::r ('þ::r ('þ a g- ";:t31' $~
~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ A.~¡'f,el·í
~ ~ ~ 0 ~ <: ..'''~ ,
~ " '~,I .",
_ = ~!:':t = 0 0 (" ) '4 "'X'~",,~~".
=' 0 [ ~ = ~ ~:"1 AI~'t~.1~~
8 =t § ~ ('þ : ~ ~t'-)::::;'
~ ~ ~ a .w ~~~~
~ ..... tf. , ". ,,',." I"
.~,~ ~ ~ 0 ~: .. ID;;.~(,.~~~;,
....; (" ) = ~ 0 . ' :',~I·.""
~ ~ ~ Q . ,,/":.;;:
Q] Q. ~ - No"" ~ . :"'.~;~',,::
., ,., n ' '.; ..~.
. ".¡ (" ) :'1 þ) II II" ., ': '
S" (" ) r: Q.. e 0,. <,¡' ::';',
.. =.: "'1 (" ) ~ . .u'".
- ~:' ~ ~ ".,";',.......
_ co ('Ø (T,) II '" '
- 3 ~ a s ~" ',',
..0 ~ 0 0
-< ~ < <
(" ) - (' ) (" )
_ en ~ . rI.I en
- ::+.' (J - , ::..'
. . rt" .
III
...._."1;::
...¡
co
, '
12/67/1995 11:19 467-355-4941 PBC CRIM JUST COMM PAGE 21
.
I DI
i ::I
I. Co ~tD
Co J".tj lJ.rJ ty ~-r
~t;-o.Ç:" ~Cti
1./]J:tJ 0./]8 CtD
~~~~ ~~ð. Cites
,,~
'),\olJ.J .
"
~ =0
QWQ ~~Ž œa
~>8 ~
~ ~ 3·1 08-
~~~ 1'\11
~ Cš R t8
ª<O
~. ...... 0=
tn~§
a'a
0 tDl
' '¡;
~,..
.. .~:;:;~
bf~:'~
};ri":
..t;.. . ~ .:
~¡·..f·J., '"
õ-o.o-<¡.8 :r~ ~1~~}
.. ",,'
;;;,: -.'~"". ':l~
~¥.{~~
~ ,,~?
- 0
·-(¿':ttl:,J,t, ~ '.~
,J' . "1';- - .. : ~;
-- ,\.,' ';:-;~'-J'.j:
a ,';:7 i:,~~~~: .;.;
':: ¡ :~,:-,~:",,:,
;. - .
-- .,
--
-"
-- ....
·
I"""""ØflJ ·
·
.'
,
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER [~ 1
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # ~~. - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
REVIEW OF APPEALABLE LAND DEVELOPMENT BOARD ACTIONS
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
Attached is the Report of Appealable Land Use Items for the
period December 4 through December 8, 1995. It informs the
Commission of the various land use actions taken by the
designated boards which may be appealed by the City Commission.
Recommend review of appealable actions for the period stated;
receive and file the report as appropriate.
, '
·
~~1
CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION
TO: DAVID T. HARDEN, CITY MANAGER
THRU: .~TOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLA N G AND ZONING
íæorn.h ~
FROM: JASMIN ALLEN, PLANNER
SUBJECT: MEETING OF DECEMBER 12,1995 * CONSENT AGENDA*
REPORT OF APPEALABLE LAND USE ITEMS DECEMBER
4. 1995 THRU DECEMBER 8. 1995
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
The action requested of the City Commission is that of review of
appealable actions which were made by various Boards during the period
of December 4, 1995, through December 8,1995.
BACKGROUND
This is the method of informing the City Commission of land use actions,
taken by designated Boards, which may be appealed by the City
Commission. After this meeting, the appeal period shall expire (unless the
10 day minimum has not occurred),
Section 2.4.7(E) of the LDRs applies. In summary, it provides that the City
Commission hears appeals of actions taken by an approving Board. It
also provides that the City Commission may file an appeal. To do so:
1. The item must be raised by a City Commission member.
2. By motion, an action must be taken to place the item on the next
meeting of the Commission as an appealed item.
, '
City Commission Documentation
Appealable Items Meeting of December 12, 1995
Page 2
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD
No Regular Meeting was held during this period,
SITE PLAN REVIEW AND APPEARANCE BOARD MEETING OF
DECEMBER 6. 1995
A. Approved (5 to 0), the elevation plan for the Historic F.E.C. Train
Station at the Ocean City Lumber site, located on the east side of
N,E. 2nd Avenue, between Atlantic Avenue and N.E. 1st Street.
B. Approved (6 to 0) a request to change the previously approved
elevations for a proposed restaurant at Grove Square (aka Block 85
Redevelopment), located at the southeast corner of Atlantic Avenue
and S.E. 2nd Avenue.
C. Approved (5 to 0), the site plan and landscape plan for the CRA/Peach
Umbrella Parking Lot, a proposed 23 space public parking lot to be
located on the west side of S.W. 4th Avenue, south of Atlantic Avenue.
D. Approved (6 to 0), the site plan, and landscape plan associated with
the construction of a 7,475 square foot video store (Video Avenue) on
a outparcel at the South Delray Shopping Center, which is located at
the northeast corner of Lindell Boulevard and Federal Highway. The
Board recommended approval of the proposed elevations despite the
incompatibility in architectural style with the South Delray Shopping
Center. The architectural elevation plan will be forwarded to the City
Commission for final action.
Other non-appealable items which were considered by the Board,
. Approved (4 to 1), two flat wall business signs for Gracie Lawrence
Gallery, Inc. located at 411 East Atlantic Avenue.
HISTORIC PRESERV A TION BOARD MEETING OF DECEMBER 6,
~
1. Approved (7 to 0) with conditions and excluding the proposed pool
cabana requests for a Certificate of Appropriateness, site plan,
. '
City Commission Documentation
Appealable Items Meeting of December 12, 1995
Page 3
landscape plan and the architectural design elements associated with
the restoration of a three unit apartment building, a single family
residence and the addition of a second single family residence for
Sloan Hammock Rental Compound, located on the west side of S.E.
7th Avenue, south of S.E. 1st Street. The requests seek to reactivate
an expired site plan which was previously approved in October 1993.
Additionally, the Board considered the following non-appealable item.
Approved (7 to 0), a variance request to reduce the side setback from
15 feet to 10 feet to allow a 238 square foot addition to the existing
triplex building.
2. Approved (7 to 0) with conditions, requests for Certificate of
Appropriateness and site plan associated with the conversion of a
single family structure to an architect's office for Ames International
Design, located at the northeast corner of the intersections of N.E.
2nd Avenue, N.E. 6th Street and Dixie Boulevard. Additionally, the
Board approved the architectural design elements on a 4 to 3 vote for
the proposed exterior colors and on a 7 to 0 vote for a proposed
exterior stairway. The landscape plan was tabled.
The Board also approved on a 7 to 0 vote several waivers namely;
· A request to permit parking in the front yard.
· A request not to provide the 5 feet right-of-way dedication for N.E. 2nd
Avenue and N.E. 6th Street.
· A request to permit a 20' two-way aisle (24' is required) for the parking
area on the north side of the property and a 12'drive aisle for parallel
parking areas.
· The use of a gravel surface for eight (8) parking spaces,
3. Approved on a 5 to 2 vote, a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow
the demolition of a contributing commercial building located at 35 N.E.
1st Avenue to allow the expansion of the Block 76 parking lot.
RECOMMENDED ACTION.
By motion, receive and file this report.
Attachment: Location Map
,
LOCATION MAP FOR
CITY COMMISSION MEETING
OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
L-30 CANAL c
--------------~------- ~
¡
¡ '"
...J
c: _J 5
III
...J ¡
¡¡:
II<:
t- r------------
¡ c
! <
0 LAKE IDA ROAD
II<:
¡
, '"
! u
! ~
! <
I III
!'--.-.- j
.,----- ~ r------'-- , -_.__,
.. '-,_-_-_-.."r",
, , ~-, I
I·'· ,
I '
, , I
I L,_,_,_, ,_-_,_______-_,.1
¡ B
, !'1
r·,.... , -_,.I ¡ ATLANTIC AVENUE
...'-, ¡
¡ ~ ~
,.--,-,..; < <
¡ OIl ..
¡ C
II<: ~ ~
¡ ~ VI
¡ '"
...J
~ ::;)
0
LOWSON BOULEVARD m
S.W. 10TH TREET
c z
i <
'"
'" g
:2 U
0
:r ¡:;:
Z
<
I=!
<
,..'-'
1..--- >-
~
G
~
...J >-
< II<:
Z ~
<
U ::::;
I') :i
I
'"
._-------_._---_._-_._---_._----------------------
L-38 CANAL
~.f>.~.~.E3.: H.f> .R:
City LIMITS ---,-----'.
A. - OCEAN CITY LUMBER 1. - SLOAN HAMMOCK RENTAL COMPOUND
B. - GROVE SQUARE 2. - AMES INTERNATIONAL DESIGN
I MILE I (BLOCK 85 REDEVELOPMENT) 3. - 35 S.E. 1ST AVENUE
, C. - C.R.A/PEACH UMBRELLA
SCALE PARKING LOT
D. - VIDEO AVENUE
N
-
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL
PlANNING DEPARTMENT
- - DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM --
.
.
-
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER f~1
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # F·r· - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
AWARD OF BIDS AND CONTRACTS
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to approve the award of the follow-
ing bid:
Bid award to Motorola Communications and Electronics, Inc. for
Phase II of the two-way radio system upgrade, in the amount of
$51,179 from 334-6112-519-64.90 and 442-5178-536-61.76.
.
.
.
Agenda Item No. ¡~ ¡.
AGENDA REQUEST
Date: 12/6/95
Request to be placed on:
_ Workshop Agenda When: 12/12/95
XX Regular Agenda
_ Special Agenda
Description of item (who, what, where, how much): Staff requests Commission approval of the
award of bid to Motorola Communications and Electronics, Inc. in the amount of$51,179 for Phase II
of the Two-Way Radio System Upgrade Project. Funding is available from General Fund Other
Machinery and Equipment Account No. 334-6112-519-64.90 - $25,737 and Water and Sewer R&R
Account No. 442-5178-536-61.76 - $25,442 (pending a budget transfer).
ORDINANCE/RESOLUTION REQUIRED: YES/NO DRAFT ATIACHED YES/NO
Recommendation: Staff recommends approval of the award of bid.
DEPARTMENT HEAD SIGNATURE: ~fi:~ __,,>_2 /'¡~5
Determination of Consistency with Comprehensive Plan:
City Attorney ReviewIRecommendation (if applicable):
Budget Director Review (required on all items involving expenditure of funds):
Funding availabl~TO ,
Fundingalternat~' ~a~ G I.I\(,~[ /Î^,.;fy FwM -ONwv
4. Account No. & De!cription~2.- S/ . fL.f/\JU t-V\ G(WLS;. , ~+
óí Account Balanœ ;2. <;¡1!@,. !$M r /i.~
~ 2-5/ .(01- W S ~Q, .'
City Manager Review: APproved- 0: agenda~ 7b l,r "lS j h.fff w.p ~
Hold Until: : C::;YIIV tyfV{- \ I 't\ r
Agenda Coordinator Review: Received:
Placed on Agenda:
Action:
ApprovedJDisapproved
.
I
MEMORANDUM
TO: David T. Harden, City Manager
FROM: WHHam H. Greenwood. Env;<onmental SeNke, Directo' 4tJø
SUBJECT: A WARD OF BID - PHASE II TWO- WAY RADIO SYSTEM UPGRADES
DATE: December 6, 1995
Phase II of the Two-Way Radio System Upgrade includes the following:
· Purchase and installation of a second base station; utilizing the second radio frequency.
· Assignment of one frequency for use by Environmental Services and Public Works and the second
frequency to be used by Community Improvement, Parks and Recreation and Utility Billing.
· Retrofitting of existing mobile radios with private line and second frequency capabilities.
· Replacement of older radios which cannot be retrofitted.
These proposed changes will increase the transmission range of our current radio system and provide a
back up channel for Channel I. The new desk sets will have a F1/F2 capability which will allow them to
operate on either channel. A detailed summary from Motorola is attached as backup material for this item.
The proposed cost allocations (prorated) by departments is as follows:
Base Station & Mobile & Portable Total
Department Antenna Equipment C.QS!
ESD $ 5,766 $14,592 $20,358
PW 2,071 5,230 7,301
C,I. 1,594 4,050 5,644
P&R 3,622 9,170 12,792
UTB .1A3..4 3.650 5.084
$14,487 $36,692 $51,179
ESD's and UTB's share of the costs for this project is funded from Water and Sewer R&R Account No.
442-5178-536-61.76 (pending processing of the attached budget transfer). The remainder will be funded
from General Fund Other Machinery and Equipment Account No. 334-6112-519-64.90.
I am requesting that this item be placed on the City Commission agenda of December 12, 1995, for
consideration of the award of bid to Motorola Communications and Electronics, Inc. in the amount of
$51,179 for Phase II of the Two-Way Radio System Upgrade Project.
WHG:c1
Attachments
9·"[ .1
OCT 09'95 08: 06PM t10TOROLA FT LAUDERDALE P, 10/12
,
Pg.3 Phase \I
MOBILE AND PORTABLE EQUIPMBNT SECTION 2
The mobile and portable upgrades are broken out by department.
If PTTID is required in a mobile than the proposed unit is a Maxtrac 300.
The Maxtrac 300 proposed will included 46 watts, multi frequency, PL.
PTTJD capability and a gain antenna. If a option 5 watt speaker is needed
it would be 45.00 extra.
Environmental Services
14 Maxtrac 300 packages @!20.00 2280.00 ' !
C (' !
14 Installation. programming and PTTIO upgrade
@ 210.00 2800.00 ( ,¡ t
4 Units modified with 2nd freq.. PL and PTTID f., / ¡
278.00 1112.00
"
13 Older portable units modified for 2nd fraq. and PL
with no PTTID @280.00 3640,00 j I'
17 Older mobile units modified for 2nd fraq. and PL (,
with no PTTID @280.00 4760.00
., f ILf/sq-z.
Public Works
4 Existing Maxtrac 300 mobiles modified with
second freq., PL and PTT1D@270 1080.00 .'
7 Older portable units modified for 2nd Ireq. and PL
with no PTTID@280.00 1960.00
3 Maxtrac 300 mobile packages @520.00 1560.00
3 Installations, programmings and PTTID upgrade
@21 0.00 630.00 tS,Z30
, '
-
ÇU:;T 09 ' 95 08:07PM MOTOROLA FT LAUDERDALE P.11/12
PO 4 Phase II
Community Improvement Frequency one only.
11 HT1000 portables modified for PL and
pn1D @ 190.00
( These units must be HT1000) 2090.00
14 Older portables modified for 2nd freq., PL
with no PTTID@ 140.00 1960.00 :{ C{,Z<;!D
Parks and Recreation Dept. Frequency one
10 Maxtrac 300 mobile package
@ 520.00 5200.00 .f ,. .
10 Installation/removals, programming
and PTT 10 @ 210 2100.00
,
1,
11 Add PL to 11 HT90 portables
leave on channel one no PTT ID
@ 170.00 1870.00 1C?,l7éJ
-,
Utility Billing
5 Maxtrac 300 mobne packages@520.00 2600.00
.-
5 Installations, programming and PTTID
upgrade@ 210,00 1050.00
Prices valid for 45 days. -f 3;-5 D
None: non PL units woutdn't fuction on this system.
Total of mobile and portable section 2 36692.00
.
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # 1Æ· - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS/
NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES )
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to review financial and other
considerations connected with the implementation of the Storm-
water Management Programs with respect to the National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Stormwater Permitting
Program, being administered by the Environmental Protection
Agency.
The concern of municipalities in Palm Beach County in regard to
the NPDES Stormwater Permitting Program is the cost and the
inherent problems of duplication between Federal and State
regulations as they affect municipalities.
The EPA prepared guidelines for the preparation of the permit
applications. They require a comprehensive permit application
detailing existing stormwater facilities and programs. Their
estimated cost to a medium municipality such as Palm Beach County
for preparation and filing the application was to be $49,249.
Palm Beach County's expenses in this preparation now total
approximately $1 million. CH2M Hill, an expert on NPDES, using
the EPA affordability criteria, estimates Palm Beach County's
cost of implementation at approximately $555 million. The NPDES
requires nine stormwater management programs; seven of which are
already covered by State programs and requirements. The
remaining two programs fall within municipality responsibilities.
The proposed NPDES program will require municipalities to
duplicate and exceed efforts of existing State and Federal
programs.
This EPA administered program is an unfunded Federal mandate
which requires duplicate documentation of State and Federal
programs, and transfers additional responsibilities and costs to
the local level. The Palm Beach County Municipal League is
pursuing a position of deregulation or elimination of this
mandate. Federal dollars for implementation are needed or
deregulation should occur, particularly considering that the
State of Florida has current effective programs in place for
improving the quality of discharges into its receiving waters.
Please review the financial and other considerations connected
with the implementation of the NPDES Program,
.
· '!'" ,,..... - -. - . - =
...l::·"7"-~';';:-7:,.:....l =I.~'~:; J=::::::: f ~~ ~,'~~T ..;.:.~ ;::'~=.: - - - - - --
--- -- --
A. Implementation and Augmentation of Storm Water Management
1. ProiTams OJ)eration and maintenance
Task 1, Inspections and maintenance on a yearly basis
Equipment required
Grade all $180,000
T, V. /Closed circuit 150,000
Vac Con 180,000
Computer and Program 30.000
Subtotal Equipment Cost $540,000
Personnel
7 Total
Supervisor $ 32,980
Staff Asst. II 26,190
Equipment Tech, II - 2 each 56,270
Equipment Tech. I . 1 each 24,730
Street Maint. Worker I ~ 1 each 23,620
Equipment Operator 23,620
Equipment Replacement 51 ,000
Fuel Maintenance 20,000
Misc. 20,000
Uniforms/shoes 2,000
ToolslEquip. 10,000
Subtotal PersonneJ Cost $290,410
Total First Year $830,410
Expenditures
Annual Cost Approx. $320,000
Task La To be completed by Storm Water Tech,
Task 2.a, Information to be provided by Operations and Maintenance crew and
compi1ed by Stormwater Tech.
Task 2,b, Summary of debris/Operations and Maintenance to be compiled by Storm water
Tech.
Task 2c. To be included in report by Stormwater Tech.
1
, ,
~._": -~""_":t- I ":'..i.~ ~: '''_-:¡. :~::..::.:- ~ ;L-:; L;~t-' i -,.~..... ï._~~ ~ 1::. _ ,_. = -- -.;... . ---
- -
Task 3. To be conducted On an as needed basis, where iIIega! connections are suspected
by Stormwater crew currently funded using smoke detection method (cost
minima1).
Task 4, In·house Stormwater crew.
Task 5. Require oW'tiers of private storm water systems to provide a report on an annua.J
basis from a registered engineer that the system is clean and functioning as
designed, Commission to pass means of enforcement.
Task 6, Being completed by Stormwater Tech.
2, Control of discharges from area of new development
Task l.a, Refer to Stormwater, Master Plan
Task l.b, To be included in yearly report by Stormwater Tech,
Task 2. Completed
TaskJ. Will be included as part of inspections currently being conducted by
Engineering,
Task 4. Require as part of the permit re\iew process a plan for erosion contra]
measures,
Task 5, For private developments, developers will be advised during the review process
that they will be required to provide an annual report as outlined in Section
A.I.H. Public systems will be incorporated as part of the annual operations and
maintenance.
Task 6. To be coordinated by Stormwater Tech
Task 7. The City currently has a guideline for acceptance of private systems,
Task 8. The City currently has a 25% open space re,quirement, but no incentive
procedures.
Task 9, Adopt ordinance referring to State water quality standards
2
·
.
...lC~-~"'::-~3:4 ~.<;~ ! r..!::::::¡:: : I.~:;: :I::='T ..::: ¿ ¡::;>=~: "",=:,- -, = .::=- . '
--- -- - - - - --
City of Delray Beach, specifically,
1.) Enforcement ofL.D.R. is currently being implemented regarding stoffi1\\'ater
management systems.
3. Overation and maintenance of public streets. roads and hi~wavs.
Task 1. Currently being implemented v.ith existing personnel and equipment
Task 2. Provide copy of Operations and Maintenance schedule and proposed s\\'ale
construction for the fiscal year, Superintendent of Streets.
Task 3. Will be incorporated as standard practice for municipal projects,
Task 3a. Program currently exists,
Task 4. Wil1 be conducted annually by proposed Operatìons and ~faintenance crew,
Task 5, Log will be maintained by Operations and Maintenance crew
Task 6. Program currently exists.
City of Del ray Beach, specificalJy
I.) As outlined in the Master Plan to be funded from Stormwatei Utility Fee
2) As outlined in the Capital Improvement Plan
3.) Current!y being done.
4. Ensure flood controJ proiects complv with State storm\\'ater quality requirements
Task la, Will be conducted by Operations and Maintenance crew and developed by City
Engineer and Public Works Director.
Task 1.b. Will be provided,
Task 2. Program/procedures are currently implemented,
Task 3, Included as part of development requirements,
3
, '
--i~~ -.;.'4-..:,-; ":;14 tt L~ 1 t 4¿t:.~' I r -E~: DE~'-:- -Ll"': ¡ ,_':: _'t:. _ :_':: ~- _..:.- . - -
City of Del ray Beach, specifically,
1.) CUlTently implemented as part of project review,
6. Control ofpol1utants relates to application of pesticides, herbicides and
fertilizers.
Task 1. All municipal appJicators of pesticides and herbicides are trained and certified
regarding the proper application.
Task 2. City has existing standard operating procedure for storage and mi>..-rure of
pesticides, herbicides and fertilizers We are current]y inspected semi-annual!y
by the Florida Department of Agriculture.
Task 3. All contractors are required to provide evidence of proper certification and are
kept on file 'With the city,
Task 4,a WilJ be incorporated into the monthly news Jetter to residents by the city
Task 4.b. Copy v.ill be provided to EP A
7,a. illicit dischar.,ges and improper dìsDosal - inspections, ordinances and
enforcement measures.
Task 1, This is currently being performed by our Building Department.
Task 2, All enforcement actions are kept on iì]e in the Building Depal1ment
Ciry of Del ray Specifically
1.) \Ve are currently operating within the guidelines of the Palm Beach County Wellfield
Protection Ordinance.
7.b, Illicit dischar.ges and improper disposal - field screening
Task 1. Will be conducted by storrnwater tech,
Task 2. Stonnwater Tech.
Task 3, Stormwater Tech.
7 ,c, Illicit discharges and improper disposal - investigation of suspected illicit
and/or improper disRosal.
Task 1. A standard operating procedure will be developed for the investigation ofi jjcit
discharges by the director of Public Works and the City Engineer.
4
. '
- t:. i":. .I. li:::'::.r-. 1':' LJ=...... -..-- '- .I...'=-_ ,_"= -
"""t._ ,-.;:.-_ -'.......,. - - - - - -
Task 2. Summaries of investigations will be provided in the annual report.
Task 3. A periodic training course will be implemented by the Human Resources
Department to identify and report illic,it dis.charges.
City of Delray Beach
1, Program currently exists and has been in operation for 5 years,
7,d. Il1ìcit dischar~es and improper disposal - spiH prevention and response
Task 1. Persons dealing with hazardous material are currently trained for City of Del ray
Beach standard operating procedures.
Task 2. Currently done
Task 3,a.Hazardous material emergency response team is currently operating witrun
the firm depar1ment.
Task 3b This v.riIl be included 'with the annuaJ report.
Task 4. This operation is currently under the control of Palm Beach County
Environmental resource Management and will continue to be,
Task 5. Notification and containment procedures for hazardous spills are
implemented by the City of Del ray Beach hazardous material team.
Task 6. The City will adhere to the Palm Beach County Wellfield Ordinance
7.e. Illicit Discharges and Improper Disposal - Public Notification
Task I,a.WiIl be included in the monthly news letter by the City.
Task 1 b. Articles in the news letter will inform the public what to look for,
Task I.e. Copies of the monthly news letters \\lill be included with the annual report
Task 2. A log for citizen complaints and the results will be kept by the stann water tech
Task 3, Log will be included "'..ith the annuat repot1
7,g. Illicit dischan!es and improper disposa1 - Limitation of San1taTv Sewer
Seepage.
Task 1. Proper authority will be advised of"ioIatìons
Task 2, Is currently identified and mapped.
Task 3, Appropriate agency will be informed if violations are identified,
City of Del ray Beach, specifically.
1. Program is currently undeN.·ay.
5
,
~C~-2~3-7::4 E;·~i;:: ~ ;~=:P I r·)I~ :'IEF- "':¡.:..J F'D'= Ii:::': .:'.= ':-~ -- --
8,a.) Industrial and high risk runoff· Identification of Priorities and Procedures
for inspections,
Task 1.a, Completed
Task l.b. Completed
Task 2,a. Will be computed by storm water tech.
Task 2,b, Inspection log will be kept by storm water tech,
Task 2,ç, List has been compiled and is included in Part II of the application.
8.b.) Industrial and hi.gh risk runoff - monitoring fOf high risk industries,
Task 1. Palm Beach County D.E.P,
Task 2, Palm Beach County D.E.P.
Task 3, Palm Beach County D.E.P.
9.a,) Construction Site Runoff· site planning- and Stmctura] and Non Structural
Controls
Task 1.. Will be implemented as part of the review process for site deveJoprnent
Task 2.a. Will be reviewed at the technical Advisory Committee level.
Task 2b, Documentation of reviews wiU be kept on file and provided in the annual
report.
Task 3,a Will be evaluated on a case by case basis as new technologies evolve
Task 3b, Acceptable technologies will be adopted where City of Del ray Beach,
specifically
City of Delray Beach Specifically
1,) See 9.a.b.
2,) See 9.a.b.
6
.
.
i- ~ 1 -,. "
/ /i£--"~V',\..-
, .,,-
Palm Beach County MUNICIPAL LEAGUE
P.O. BOX 1989, GOVERNMENTAL CENTER, WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33402 (407)355-4484
May 2, 1995
Honorable Bob Graham
524 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20510
Dear Senator Graham:
On behalf of the cities in Palm Beach County I have previously
brought to your attention the concern of municipalities in Palm
Beach County, Florida, in regards to the National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Stormwater Permitting Program-
-its associated costs and the inherent problems of duplication
between Federal and State regulations as they affect the
municipalities.
The Northern Palm Beach County Water Control District is lead agent
for Palm Beach County in this program which consists of thirty-
three cities, five special districts, the Florida Department of
Transportation and Palm Beach County. As lead agent, Northern
supports the efforts of the Municipal League to garner your support
in reevaluating this particular Federal program. The costs of the
program inxelation to the real benefits is an issue of concern.
Northern Palm Beach County Water Control District, as lead agent,
made a funding application in the amount of $2.2 million to cover
a portion of the üaxt part of this requi~'?d; b'~i: tmfunded program.
This request was carried forward by Congressman Alcee Hastings'
staff to the Appropriations Committee staff. We were later told
that Federal monies would not be available. Therefore, we are
pursuing our next reasonable position of deregulation or
elimination of this unfunded Federal mandate. Provided below is
background and a synopsis of our concerns.
The Water Quality Act of 1987 added Section 402 (p) to the Clean
Water Act. This section set forth a new permitting process for
municipal storm sewer systems. It established a phased program
for cities and counties based on population thresholds for
obtaining an NPDES permit. It set a new standard of permit
compliance, known as "Maximum Extent Practical" which emphasizes
.
.
,
Senator Bob Graham
May 2, 1995
Page 2
establishing Best Management Practices to control pollutants in
stormwater discharges. On November 16, 1990, the United States
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued final regulations
covering permit application requirements for cities and counties
with a separate storm sewer system serving a population of 100,000
or more. The regulations required a comprehensive permit
application detailing existing stormwater facilities and programs.
The cost of preparing the application and implementing future
programs was placed upon the applicant. The Clean Water Act did
not provide,EPA with any mechanism to fund or cost share stormwater
programs.
In setting forth the regulations, EPA estimated the cost to a
medium municipality such as Palm Beach County for preparation and
filing the application to be $49,249. EPA then prepared guidelines
for the preparation of the Part I and Part II Permit Applications.
To prepare the permit application according to these guidelines,
Palm Beach, County's expenses have now totaled approximately $1
Million. At this time, EPA does not have a cost estimate to
implement this program, but we can be assured that it will be high.
The regulations attempt to establish an upper compliance limit as
"Maximum Extent Practical", but this term is nebulous and thus the
cost exposure is not definable. At a widely attended seminar on
NPDES, a national engineering firm, CH2M Hill, an expert on NPDES,
provided cost guidance by stating that an affordable criteria used
by EPA to evaluate wastewater improvements is approximately 2% of
the city or county gross income. This same affordability criteria
may be used by EPA for the NPDES. For Palm Beach County, this
would represent approximately $555 Million. without assistance
provided by the federal government for implementation and
compliance, the cost to the local governments and taxpayers would
be staggering.
I
In the State of Florida and in Palm Beach c~nty, - many of the
programs that are proposed by EPA i~ the NPDES permit process have
been in existence for many years. As docume¡¡ted in the 3.ppl':'=ation
process to EPA, the cost of the current rather aggressive storm-
water management programs within Palm Beach County is estimated at
$120 Million a year. The NPDES requires nine stormwater management
programs addressing the following: Operational Maintenance of
Stormwater Facilities; New Development or Significant Redevelop-
ment; Maintenance of Public Roads and Highway Facilities; Flood
Control Projects; Municipal Waste Facilities; Application of
Herbicides, Pesticides and Fertilizers; Illicit Discharges;
Monitoring High Risk Industries; and Inspection of Construction
Activities. Seven of the nine stormwater programs are covered by
State programs and requirements. The remaining two programs fall
within the local government (municipalities) responsibilities.
These programs include the operation and maintenance of the
stormwater facilities and the operation and maintenance of public
.
.
,
Senator Bob Graham
May 2, 199s
Page 3
roads. The proposed NPDES Program will require municipalities to
duplicate and exceed efforts of existing State and Federal
. Programs. It will also require many of the municipalities to
document in detail the activities being performed by these agencies
within municipal boundaries.
The NPDES program requires Annual Summary Reports and monitoring
with all backup documentation to be kept by each municipality.
Additionally, EPA is using its program to transfer to the munici-
palities, tbe inspections of NPDES Industrial permits issued by
EPA. This will require increasing staff and costs at the local
level.
The State of Florida has implemented a number of stormwater
management programs to improve on the quality of discharge to
receiving water bodies. These programs include Surface Water
Improvement and Management Plans (SWIM) (i.e. Lake Okeechobee),
Local Comprehensive Plans required for drainage and water quality
level of services, Public Facility Reports for Special Districts,
and stormwater management rules and regulations established by the
Regional Water Management Districts. The Florida Department of
Environmental Protection Agency and the Regional Water Management
Districts administer Florida's stormwater programs.
In the NPDES program, agricultural areas are exempt. However, in
Palm Beach County, agricultural areas are not. Agricultural areas
that are discharging into State Water Conservation Areas and the
Everglades are required by the State to implement best management
practices and the State is providing additional regional stormwater
treatment areas. Palm Beach County through regional water
management district taxes and the State of Florida are actively
pursuing watèr quality enhancement measures for the Everglades.
{
The stormwater management goals associated with_ the-EPÀ program
are admirable. However, we feel the program is an unfunded Federal
mandate which requires duplicate documentation of State émd F$deral
Programs, and transfers additional responsibilities and costs to
the local level. Federal dollars for implementation are needéd or
deregulation should occur, particularly considering that the State
of Florida has current effective programs in place for improving
the quality of discharges into its receiving waters.
It is our understanding that you serve on the Transportation and
Infrastructure Subcommittee of the Environment and Public Works
Committee. We are hopeful that further discussions can be
accomplished with you and your staff. We are prepared to answer
any questions you may have and we are available to supply you with
additional information as necessary.
.
.
1
.
Senator Bob Graham
May 2, 1995
Page 4
:
At the request of Valerie Wagner of your staff, I have brought this
matter to the attention of Mr. Estus Whitfield of Governor Chiles'
. . . '. . Office. In fact, he and I had a lengthy discussion regarding this
program when I was in Tallahassee April 6, 1995. Be is going to
speak with FDEP and the South Florida Water Management District
regarding this matter to see if some duplication, as outlined
above, could be eliminated. When I hear back from Mr. Whitfield
I will relate our mutual concerns to you. Your support in this
crucial matter would be greatly appreciated.
We will begin similar efforts in the Bouse once we mutually agree
on a future direction.
, :~/ ~~<-
t
ack L. Bor'nÍD1an
Executive Director
JLB/drh
bcc: Tom McCarthy, President, Palm Beach County Municipal League
Alan D. Wertepny, Project Manager, Mock, Roos & Associates, Inc.
Peter L. Pimentel, Executive Director, Northern Palm Beach County WCD
..
~ .
( - ~-
-
.,.,
¡
.
.
I SEI? 28 >95 13: 20 NPBCWD P.l/2
, .
(¡ c ¿ {'l/P,,- t·, 1 í¡..{
';10 It...... ~ '-.d ('..etc; c..í- ~'
(a... '( ........." (l
(ft'i
Si UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
~~,r- REGION ..
)45 COURTI.ANO STI'.£ET, N.I.
A TLANT A. CEOItCIA ]O~5
September IS, 1995
- -' - ._--- -- .._. .-
CBRIllIl....D MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REOUESTED
REF: 4WM-WPEB ,
I
Mr. Peter L. Pimentel
Executive Diæctor
Northern Palm Beach County Water Control District I
357 Hiatt Drive _~Ì', ~ "
, \
Pabn Beach Gardens, Florida 33418 "r. .-
;-., , -::"}:.,~ w_ -0:---;"- .-....'
0;,Ji-·JJ.,·j· -
RE: Intent to Issue . --- ' ~ "'. ..¡ , ,: :-..' . .
, ¡, .
Palm Beach County· Municipal Sepaxate Storm Sewer System Q'';':'G' i' ·':'/L-v,;",_. .:0, ~, -
.........
NPDES Number FLSOOOO18 - ?
I
Dear Mr. Pimentel:
The Environmental Protet..1ion Agency (BPA), Region IV, intends to issue a National
Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit in accordance with the Federal
Clean Water Act to the referenced syst,em in the near future.
The enclosed draft MS4 NPDPS Permit, dated September 7, 1995, shows the
proposed conditions to be incorpomted as part of the final MS4 NPDES Pennit. ParticuJar
attention should be given to the Stonn Water Management Program elements, scbedu1e of
compliance, and the monitoring program requirements.
EP A solicits your comments on this draft permit. Specifically, we request your-t'
determination of applO¡1¡-iatc dates for accomplishing the development and implementation of
the Storm Water Management Program activities identified in Part m of the permit.
omments relative to this draft permit should be submitted to EP A on or before
ember 18, 1995 Comments made during this time period may be incorporated into the
draft permit pnor to public notice, After this date, EPA will proceed with the permitting
process, includiDg requesting state certification and publicly noticing the draft permit. At the
time of public notice, a copy of the notice will be sent to you. At that time you will have an
additional opportunity to comment on or object to any aspects of the draft permit.
,
SEP 28 '95 13: 2Ø NPBCWD P.2/2
,
- 2 -
If you have any questions concerning the enclosed conditions or the proceduTeS
associated with BPA Region IV's MS4 NPDES permitting program, please contact me at the
above address or by calling (404) 347-3012. extension 2978.
Sincerely,
~~~~
Caroline O. Bjimofor
Environmental Engineer
Pennits Section
Water Permits and Enforcement Branch
Water Management Division
Enclosures (2)
(1) Draft NPDPS Permit
(2) Fact Sheet with Appendices
cc: (with enclosures)
Mr. Eric LiviDgston
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
, '
. ,
PERMIT NO. FLSOOOO18
Major MS4
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
REGION IV
AUTHORIZATION TO DISCHARGE UNDER THE
NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM
In compliance with the provisions of the Clean Water Act, .:.): ,S.C. 1251 et seq"
as amended by the Water Quality Act of 1987. P .L. 1~"",¡~I¡i;i¡j;¡¡,:Act'"
Palm Beach County - Municipal Separate :~¡¡¡~¡,:;·':::.:~~wer Syst ::,:,::. Permittees:
Palm Beach County Town of Lake Clarke Sho ':::\,::,¡¡; :: . of South Bay
City of Atlantis Town of Lake Park ·"¡¡m,:. own of South Palm Beach
City of Belle Glade City of Lake ..... h :'\.. age of Tequesta
City of Boca Raton Town of Lan ~:::::\H':,::.. ". ty of West Palm Beach
City of Boynton Beach Town of ::: ·::\H1i::::.. Aane Improvement District
Town of Cloud Lake Town of Mang ·:::~:...,.,,"¡::·::¡H¡i:· Indian Trail
City of Delray Beach V'..:.. e of North '.;::.' Beach Water Control District
Town of Golfview ':':':':':1-. Ocean ":. North Palm Beach Heights
City of Greenacres .¡¡¡¡!( ity..::::,.,::. okee Water Control District
Town of Gulf Stream ·:1%......:..··:::·:·· <.:.... Beach Northern Palm Beach County
Town of Haverhill .: ;.:..... of P .'.:.' Beach Gardens Water Control District
Town of Highlan ..:.::..:.:.:.:.;. .:::.::;.:: f Palm Beach Shores South Indian River
Town of Juno . .:: ..',. '·¡¡i¡¡¡i,. ViII '.' e of Palm Springs Water Control District
Town of Jupi '::;11;;: :¡¡¡i¡i: City of Riviera Beach Florida Department of
Town of Jupiter' '::.;... Col.::::: ,Village of Royal Palm Beach Transportation - District 4
are authorized to':¡¡¡¡¡\'¡¡¡¡[~ge, in accordance with the approved Stonn Water Management
Program(s), effluent limitations, monitoring requirements, and other provisions as set
forth in Parts I, II, ill, IV, V, VI, VII, and vm herein, from all portions of the
Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Owned or Operated by any Permittee listed above,
to waters of the United States and all tributaries thereto.
This pennit shall become effective on
This penn it and the authorization to discharge under the National Pollutö.nt Discharge
Elimination System shall expire at midnight, on
Date Issued Robert F. McGhee, Acting Director
Water Management Division
.
.
d :::
.;. ..::. -
.¡,~~
00 ~~-..J """
.-.
c:. .. """
c:. _"0 "0 ~ t
c:. o - O>~ '- 41 0
c:. ~ c: Rè,~ '2 ...
~ >- 0·_ ._ 41 <II t\., æ
4J.,s= eft :s- <II 41
ti <II '-<11' O>4IC:cr '2 - 0> II<
41 <II c: ~ O..c·- 41 C f
58- o_U') _ 3'- CO '2 .;
~ .::!8-~u~~ &. ~ I
....- >.-~-~-8 ~ 0 <II ~ ãí
uo.. =::
~~ Q; IDOO <II 0> <II
''::: 41 'I-~-i" 41 CO> 8.
Z~5~ UI C ~ ._ c: '1 to-.
ë ~ ....- !II
j 4I~ >- 0 ... <II :s
o <II C '" ..., CO .- t~ "0 ;.. ~
.- 41 8:""0 5 ... u
~ ... 41 ~ \
~ O>S~ ~,.,~ :! ~ ... ~
u ~ ' ... c:
~ 0>'" ð c'" - .~ '- <II ù_ 2j ~
¡g... .-ù~o~ i
.2-e".a- ... c: tII !II
f ..... O.....~cu._~ ä 0 .- 0> ¡¡ .~
"O~.8 > c
_ "'1 ,2 -S -S 8. ù '" =:'ã !II
~ ~:s~ ~ .... ~
o c ... .- u ......
tIIO OJ-tll"O:ZO>'C > 8.= 8.N- ~
II :;: ~ ~ t;'; .~ ~ >,.=:::.8 "0 '" u 0.... <T)
III Cii1! ~.~1!.Õ~~:; a..;\"
'" ~ 0'" ,-
- c: co > .:.- en .... t.. u <II
.... ..... ._..... J:1C1....,O tII tII &. ...
E ~~'" ~"O-~O¡as'5~ . ~ ... .
:z ~!,œ - ~
.... as -8..c u >- 0 :z
.... "0 C '" 41 U ",_.c - ~.- GI ... ä
1.1 u:stll u~"8.cu,-0 - .c>
c ~2~ ~ ¡~3. ~ ~~ C ",ùfi ~ C·-
- '- c... 2j'" .
~ O"Þooc CD- _~ U4l....u ft 1£ L. . ~
-co .c_III] .....c.-- > ... ... -..u
:II 0.- Ù _ >-tII...ÙO i tII ... ¡¡...>
< '- CI) CtØ _ . ....-08."- CI .8 _0
:II o..~tII '-eII ~._O ... ell tII U U (1)0- U
W U -0'" , uut-GSGJ ~ . tII c: > > -
.... 1;ca¡ ~~.~i8.!.'-oUQ., <II u I r~ 1 uc~
. <II'" ~ >-
i <II .oc- t118.O>!š41 .- C tII ~~ ~
Cl)Q)~C ·_~IIÞU c: > ~.!¡¡ U"C:
CUll 0 ~ O~ ~._._.- <II ~
.!' '; -g '=.: ð ~ .... 5'- ~ = = ~~~ 41 ""'0>
"O¡¡'8 ...
ø~;::&.IU]ð·=~~Z~ 4lltII- tII ~C411
~'8¡ "0 '" .. o ..
~ .- '-- cas: -x 'ü 15 c: 411 ca·- 0
o C >-_ GI ~ =' rJj &....... ....- U '" ~ tII ... ...
~ .~ = :ë -Z ~] = ~ ., ~c.... ,.: 4I~ _... tII 8 Ù '"
~ 0 ... ... 41 411 411
>.",aaca ::)i~'-'_"""_'_ON 41_ <II .8 <II '" ..."'..
.~ ;.~ ~ ~ :: :;: Ole ~ 8: IJ <Ii --... "'0'" 8. c .; ... .
... ~ .8"'0
_ > .... en m- c: co .r; C >- .- ä Ù ~ ~ "'...
'ü:; '¡: 5 ~ - "'2.= -¡'- ~ ... .~Gí - ~.~ . 411 0
·-41'" oc: &. ~~'8
IU µ_'-OCl?; 0(1)41<11'" ~ "ã; ~ ~ '" 0...2 ...
....œ .....c.. ~.... '- ca 0 8.- <II
c>-..........~ 0>.-- CDN:JC.....,c....
....-c:-~cu.. "0 ....cQ. lUC:ù'" ~ '" ~
U-gCl-6~8õo~.:~:1U0 01- Co.. >- 41 ..... U 0 8..= 0
c:.-.- 41'- IU'-
8.- 41 41 411 C"O Ù ~ ~ u @ '-..c<ll>~.cª Ù ~ .~¡¡
~gõ'5~~..8:~~~OÕ :zIUO"C...... '"
0... 411 0 ~ 411 IJ .. 411
_.-zU);:).... ocaUCI)4Jzca ZII)II<UZQ'" Q (1)011)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
u 'r)
~ ~
"0
411 t-..;:
... .c ~
IJ
0'" (I) ~
1.1 "0 ~
~:II 41 0>
1.1< ¡¡ c: .~
:11:11 '"
~; 41 >
C ~
E 0
"'- '" < >
~I c 411
II<
~ ~
'"
41 I
>-
In :::
å
... ~ :.:::
O! - 2:
'"
~- E
1.11- )S
a 1.1
=~ c a
.
wa .~
.- ~
... II)
Ô
I::
::t
~ a
i ... ..... ..::
c c:
I- 2j.2 ~
~ ... ... ~
'" C
.J CII CII
~...
i ... 41 ..§
II<
~
411>-
~ ... ~ ~
IUQ
.... ::I....
II) e <II
~'2
... 0
II)Q.
.
.
~ ~
ëš..... _ 0.....
~ 5 ~"'~ 5 0 c..~ ~ c.. ~
... '" " . ,C; 0 '- 0 ~
~ U C; .. C; C; '" ",.0 0-"" ,- ~
_..I :::7 0 _ . '- to m ....., 41 C ........- ~ C .w en C 41 ~-
~ L.. ._ ~ ....... ._", 41 '- c: > q,¡.,.,.. ..... 0 GJ GI ca QI 0 y\ ......
~ ~ ~ L.. ~ & ~ ~ u.E ~ ~ ~ .;;; ~ N'" ~ ... Z' i "'0 ~ ~ ~ ';:: '': ~
c:; _ 5 0.. ~.! C; =" 2! t-6 ~ Õ :;:.....! ~ ~ c.. :¡: ~ CU CII ~ 2 - '" I
~ 0..... -g C CII CIICII'- 4IU >-GlU'" 0::1 C;...."CII 41 "'"-
'"" c.." " - .c .- Q. .c - "0 ,s;)( '" " ... '" t CII·_ c.. c.. > GI ,....,
... ... ..... C; -u 0 ...::ICII uu4I C;, I: ......8. "... "'OQ.OGl '" .....
'- ã .2- Z 11 ;: :ë g. >- -g '" "" IJ ..."O 1.1 CU 8. :ü ~ .! 0 ~ ¡; '" .~ - ~ E-.
0:: U Q. U :.... ..c CII _ 1::' I: '" 0 > 0 .- - - U ... Q.- ::I
E:: ::s ." en .".~ cu.r. _.eu 0 (0 ..., L..c...oc: ._0 cO·- ca 0 ~
"ow CII 0'" C; _ '" .. CII 0 '" ... CII tJI > ...,Q CII Q.'-'- - "0 .. ... ,Q "1: U -
_ .c ... ... CU CU)( U ._ _ .c e CII U C I "0 C Q. .- CII·_ I: -
._ ... I: II> S!" 0 -... ..... " '" 41... ..." I: _ GI CU tJI .. CU 0 ... .c "0 01 CII to.,...
"'.l ._ c! L.. .J:1 > ..Q as.o c: - CL 41 co... .z:. .- en - c: C c·- .....
~ 2 _0 2 CU _~>. _"cu ãí~o ~ CU Q ........... &. ~~~·-I~ 2,
¡;:¡ ._... ... 041 "'''',Q ¡¡¡_>. ...c..... '" 0 <II:'''CU I", :'CU"'"O "0
~ co'" CU >..... !!j::l'" 0Q. ... CII' ... 8.0"''' !!j.- ::IOC: '" ~CII
~ .. <III: I: 0 Q....>. UO·- ... >. 0 ... <11"0 -0'" -" "CTQ.<DU... "'"0
c:;;,. > 0·- Ole: ._0..... U"'- ......'- :S~. ""Gle.. 0 Cliúe 41·_ cc
._ _ U e 01 Q.- .- cu <II .- _ C; cu" ... I: .- ,Q > .. ... ".- C; ... '-1
01 0 <D <D"O U U _<D"'''' U 19 ! "0 >... ,Q u<D 0 0 ..
.... ..... ~c .,,>'ca ..., CD ......,_U') CLt :I ~ .......aat u :J Q·-fA..... CI)
II CILt OCl c'"Oo.. c.... a..., L.. L.. 0 CD øs'" ,-c",.,·- u
,Q 0- 5... cucucu QI~ <II U Q."'... e·~ "20"c; .'" ...·--u... >u
~ ._..... u encn ...uu ECð41 "CUQ,I CoOC fA ð g ca~4I'- ....~ cnG:lca~ca41 L..&I
'"0 m::J C øL.. ._.z:. C'-I: '- uea oS c..., 41> CD''-
- - 00 c; _0 - "..... .... "...... -" i-~... ... 0C;"''''0.c
... ::I'" 0 0'- ."411 u.c -~I:.c'" 411 I: ".,... u·-·-c..cuu '"
-> 0 "41 '.a ... .CC ...."'" ... GI .....41 41 - co C c: ~ ~ ....-
_ .z:. ........z:. '- '- ::11__ ,-.. 0 0 ....r.. > c.,..., CIS '- .. ':JI, I GJ e .... "'"' ø >
~ cA m....·;~ £:"2 -;"'-= ~~'+- 2C1:Z;:~¡ (II >~ U'J CI'fS"t; c·- Z-o-=~~ '=fš
CooIc c: C ...Q..o GI 0 :..- G '+- ca~ "C U-"'"' GlJ:. ., ..... ~.. 41"0 C"'- u ca >- U·-
o ._"'GI....cu ...... 011 ,,>O.c 011 <II 1:........ &." cu ·C:'.c .....
Q... ...,,:. <II..Q 011 ,,>..c ...._ ... <II :'"0 ...... ... !II " ~ I: :II en z:"O c: <D Q. -..
..... ._Q. >- u caGlQ. ca...cn ucrt........... C co e..s:: .- co co cu-
~! c: Q.'- GI.c 011 ._ "0 ... .- .- ::I . C c: CII cu '" ~.. '- '" .. .. .- ~ 011'" '" .-
GI C1..... >J:. _ 0-- c...>OIØC "'--:1 ""O'--N > . .....,Q,u E
.... '+- GJ e Q Q. _.... c... .... ._ .Q ... c: U - 0.... Q, c... "'" Ú ~ o· Q .... at ~ ca 0 ca '- .-
~ ø 0~'1-~ æ~ ~o~ -~~ ~.__Q.N~"8~.. <II "'41>" æ~ ,:ê:~-5l:e~:;:
= iIU- _ c....... Cot Si.... fA 0-0 ca.,,-:ö c.. ." C G.I &....0 tU c... '- ..... CD crt·-·-..... =' c:a
... : g c ~ ~: ~ -g I..s:; II U'õ .~ ~ ~ en iIU ." ~ U ....: o.....::a: !.: Q. ~i c 0 Z»...,
I 0 .. .- .-... "2... - ... 11 U ... 011 > i'- 0 cu "2 c:.. - ... '" 0 ... > "2 Q. > 0 0 I: ... c;
u .~...,-x. cox. :...~ :'š ]ca.s=x:~i ca ~~ "'"' "'"' >C~~ ase ;G"':'=.~ "'"'~
"">00 <II>. uC:.c" _ou"O·_e ...c; 0 - .3"", <III! .c·-I:>u......:;,
.8G.1>.'4-ãí §..c.-=:;Zu 35- ::!.....L..'- CI) ~ ~~ E f f!3CÞ~ as .~ca¡-a~ .c::
"~"O"'''''' __0__011 0-011 _>-00.... U'" 0... 00&.0 _U "2-I:-Gl~~l!i
ICn""'C.-IÞO .....O'-c...u..c.,C s: - ..c.... '- '-41 '- C ....z::....c .....cu .410 c..G.tøZ
co .,c-.., CO'.....O ctl".... ....._rA_....ca G.I -en.... 0 C4 ca ca.Q c;.-....... '-111m
e.. ._~ _<IIC;"O" .. G::IGlcu",]:;, U e"O" - ",""'0'" "'G"O
tUœou~4I ¡¡¡co"'....- "'...C; &'-'-'-1:'- ..c <II 0=-- ¡¡¡<II I:,QG"'I:~C;I:"
"'0 ¡ ~ .; .& .~ !; .~ U CD ð ð Q- ~ 0 .... ~ ~.~:ë :: .: .~ ~ '- ë ~ -; ð U ! ä II -... z'S ~ CD ~ I ~
,-..c CJ ø u U'J .... .&:. J:: .I: !::J "0 ell as Q.... .... G.t G.t C 3:.- .Q e >.J:. ....... U'- Ii 0 u r:r c... en ca
ou..GI"'<II U C;U"'<II ~UGI GIU<IIGI-U NCU U CII ~ ....."'011 U'" '" c;"'8."'I:"O~
-.~.s.s,,~ lDë~¡~", ...ãí:3 'Z"04I~:'~ :=,Q::';:;"O ... I:-c...~~ <D:.t; ~~8.i .:-¡..
>-"0 c;)( ......Q. C.. I:U,Q. ._..>,Q<II '-"oQ.,~ 011 U ~...o...."'...c; <11'- ....0......_
..... .....ccøGl~C'- 0$..... GI GI _c....- Gel) ~cuo > -~~ G CO E~'" ~CI)cn.....~
.__cu._ NQltOUGI"'" eGl-'" ._O<ll.c..... CU"O- ~"'"Oo ·U !IIU' :a.c... CIIoGle
_0 ~"''''''''E ._UL-Q ._.Qasea u....ca....'-c: ....oU'S «S 4.tC c: e """ ....oœuca>e~ca
._ "'1:410 ._e:...._U '"0 >... <D'->'-<DtU <11"'"0 :; <II<DIt-",... ._u,., c...·-.. ...
U"'I:O'" >."....>"'_GI.."O~ _CI::' ~ GlGlI:'" 2 GI~-~ ,,-.... CUU-<IIC:"C:",s;
cuc.-.-O"'-GI g." o><II-æl: i'- GI...."2"O<D <D --~"'Q OIl-&."" _c.. c;....c.-.....
- '-&. ~ ~ c: ã. ~ eI) ~ c "C ~ Z G ";ñ ~ L..2 § ..... 6 ~ _ CO ~.;;.... ~ CI,) 0 ~ ~ ~ e '" 0 ~ a.. ~ f/a....- ~ - ... .... ~
.... ~ '- GI'- CD c....... L. CO C > >o..c ..... _ 41 o·-.s= co c: co > ~ 0 c: ~ c... U 0 U c... CD C ~ '-
u uQ,t~cn·-o "IS) 0 cacn....cu ....~ .........- L..-CtCU as'" -'- 0....>0·- ·-04lUQ,tc...ØI
IlU'GlL. L........w:>-c "'uœJJ c- C -'- u ·-·-c·- c cn >c>oca .....~- ...........~'-·-u.....
Q..c 011 ... ~ 011 Q.._ U'- 011 '" c.. = 2! ¡¡¡ 011" cu ... GI'- 8. ,Q'-'" cu cu g II 411 I: S! .- GI'" .. c;.. ~ I: ... '" ..
~ ..... "2 ~ ~ ð ~ ã ~ = ~ ~ =.; å':.- ~ ~ -; ~ Q. ~ 't GI ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ti '- .0 ';' ! ä....!. a- ~ .s ¡ .: 8.. s .~
-"2~"20ze:z:u>=<Dco~>"u OOæ~ZI: ~IJ Z:Z u - «-g"-- z:10 C""'>"'U U'"
.ca:o.~oaso.;.~.ëJ.~=~ .-¡L..u..! 0... . . .cn'f;å~ ..a. .~~8~~~o~
~
a: .=~ -¡ t::::
'" " 411 - " 5::)
~ ;>. CGI ë~'" OS
O~ - .; ~ '- ~ 2! ~
~1i ] ;>. ãí Õ~ æ~CII '"
CooIC " -::I > <lie !;:
.. .. .c C 411 0......·
=L&.I GJ .., C ~'- wo: L.
... c; c: <D 0 ...... 0 ~
z 0 t L. -0"'....
....._ en :E - cau 41 >-
~I C i ,,- -g~"O-
'" >'::1 Glcul: - ~
~] c;&<D ~ I
-5 ~~ E ~
<II to C _
::
a
....
~ >. >. ~
O! _ = ~
~- .... ; ~ ~
1i1:¡ ~ 2: c I
III/~ 2 411 ¡ a
!~ c ~ .~
.- Ii Ii ~
... en IJ
~
::
t =
<:... \'.' a
~ ë :....) C'." ..¡::
= QlI: r-, 1 ~ ~
. 5 .~ c...... <>I - ~
z:s cu..... -::.. - ~
-' ~¡ 0 ~ ~ ~
... ... -
~ .. d ~0 S i!!
c... Q ~ (j ¡¡¡;
.. -J '- .....
......~ ..- ~
So! III";>' .0 ..¡ _ f ~-
~ ::. ~.~ ¿ - -
... e - ,'::::) "
en 1.."0'- / r-'-.o
o c: U '-!
... 0 ..
IJ ~...
. '
.
.
~ ~
~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~c _ ~ ]U ~ ~ ~
~ 'B . . '0 ~ UI ð. _ ~ ... ';: ~ .. .; ...
~ 111"'_ >.IIIIIIJI C.. ~_O - U ....Q >'0 0.8 -..
t') '0 CICI ..._.. O.__UlCI" C ~ 0111 IIIe:: UI ..~ !:S
~ C...s;:>"ClC..c'-ClO '-1110 >... .-... __"'111 III UI'OClU Q;;
~ ~=~~~:.~~~~W ~2~~~5 c c ~~2~U ~ ~3~2
~uu ~~u~~~u ~3UO u '- ~_~ ~ u~ oo·_~ I
Õ 'OJlJI~I:O-III'" ~ 1110......... III O'-CVIII::JO .c~-
~ ::s:>!4U::~~CO~" Ø-:;::~~ð~ ~ -;; "~J::.£JZ' co)l.. c""·ü~
::JO..-III 111.--.'0.. ..,,1:- ... IIIU...~.. fII" i....,tII :::::
-':::t '_"0_1: >41 '-..c Q.CO 0 .I: .......__01 QlU C"+-'"
@ c'" >--Ulo"oe .... VCI..c ... > 1II0Jl::JCI ..>.c41 t-
~e G .~CU'- _>~~_ ~ U ~U oœ ~O ...e0 ~
.c>I...JI"1 01110 ..0-...... tII '0 OCl"'~ UI'" --Cl~ -
~ JI"~C C 111-"'_ aI ::J... 0'" _ CIIICI IIICI JI'O>tII -
~ -~~æ~~ ~~III~ ~'BJ~=~ - ~ "'B~III~ ~.. 'O~~CI ~
V, &. ..c .- ... I: ... .. III ... .. a. C III III aI ~ 0'- &. III aï - tII e CI >.. ~
~ ._O&:~I0'-=~" ..Ø):::-~~ &... ~ ..,,~ëã8 u¡ ~ ..=~
~ ~ ø~'" ~c·_",,~ -u&...·-oc CII ell >œ_2 g~ ~~
"'- '>.'" -O..c. -...·-0..111 1 > iCo. .. III "::I>.C
~ .. _ co u a:: CD'- CD ~ ... 0 _ II CL. '- eII.I: - ,.., C ... ... 0 - 0
~ .c >-'0 C.c "'.1: 0 >JI-ga.... ,'0 1.....-", 41" 1111:_-_
....::,..,.2'... .&.~f~C: ~~2:¡G(I) ~ - &... .,igN ë~ s:æt;
o cu UlC~'-'" C CD 0 ~CO _ ~ ~'- ~ ~~ U-&...~
W -.mG~~~~-&.... C-C"'U CII X e~-~~> ~ UO~
... c:i':~_=c::;'=OU 15.~'t-~i- :1.8 -a..& ~_ E-! :.C>-
== OUJliGl.-OO)(OtA&... _.&......."0.... GI .au .e; ~.- .-...c.o..c
~ -=..2 "5 ~ GO: II:::. = a ~ ¡ ~ ~ .... g ~ t . ëí c.. ~.= ~ 8 ~ ~::
~ cøC- .::1... ...>occ ~ »--eo -... --...~
u -JlOO-c..c~G"'> c- ..'0 '0 e IIIC--~~ sa. --01
c §o_...o.--ou - .~~ee41 c III ...41'-111'" ...,-....
'0 ~.....c...... & C--.I: . = x JI::IC .0 ....a.OCl
w 3~~œ ....e.~u -~.~~~ wU ~O~ -~ ~. ~c
C.1 Uftl"...c..ccn.,cS41 aJG &$.- - L. ....c uo..c 't-0&"'-
~ ~ -6 ~ g:t;,~:t; .. ~ ::: .. _ = UI <It:¡) Õ 0 . ~2 'B ... ~ ~ 'i 8 o:ë &. ~
. Q ~.c:3: c&:c.. _._ c:ca .......- ~"""IOC:CU ·-en L.......... ell
u.& .... ..J:&"'- Glca·-·- GO.,... .11.... ...."""- ut..cø I~ CD=' 'It- 11:1
~ c~u~~t~ul....~ .3=3~~ C:~~ø 5~~~.-g ~ ....: .~~
~ 1_.. c en cm ~en-- IN..... '-cacca~ø ] CL.~~~
C '-~.Q"fII.-c-'~æc ~IIIU>CI.8' '_...,::1'- ... ."41'- III æ:;J",i·....
Z ã1>-'02=--~~-~ <ltc:~E I.. ã1>.0~ ~~"ClUI~ -r _...~ CI
w'-_~ca~~~G~ - øC~ .~a- OL.~"" ~ >e ~~~....~
u:::r U_CCU%GlO .cncnc: fØ- L..J:.- CUGlC·..c.... atL.:::r~
&..>o..._-w~ 0CC.CUOL..~CD eu~u c:oøu- ._~ ø~~oø
OO.J:....~....EE ou~-o-o~ ð~ CD OUCD--~ -~ ø-c~
... u ø CD C )(._ .." CI._ C "''to- u.s= u &.. 0 e... .- u as 0- .- 0·" L. CD QI
~ --4I'O-.e~"~III.I:'" <It _..0 ...CI >..::1 ..c-4I~"'I~"
~~~o ....~u~....ca.cu..~L.. ~L.~ Gc....- 0 ca~........c -~
.... ....ucnocnc..ca ~Q "">~ocn.J: .... ~c ....·-ø~c:~ ~~.G~ u
_~"""'4I 1II...-Ul::I"'III-III--'" c_ - -~Qilll" 1IIa...- .. .c
=~8.&.~œ2~~i~~""'Q~'O~_ æo~~ =Se ~.c "'>. i...a.,~
u- ..t:~ ....'-!~.....;Z-... 41410 ._..&...... .Qoc...u.... ClJL.ã!L..~"'.z:;
11101:0 O-'CO"'UlC2tO .'0-- 'OUI..c- 111"-0 0 <It~'-"'ã:041
_>O"'N ::1_.1:...1110111 ~c~ C 1110410.1:" u_ III...... 0.>-
_ ~CI'OÇUlIII.U <ltUIII~"'O Ula.'O CI:;J -..... ~ã1111111 'O-..c
~~t;~c:.~ eCtJGEct;L.~rn..c~·:: IJ'~GI~ '-"'''':'.:!~~ 5 ;;GI-:Q.L..
"'lØu::I._m~...->..CI&..8 .-...glll >'0> - .a."XCI ~->"8.uo
~~i=5~_g~gg~UI~i}"=~ g'Og~ ~&.~~u= i~;g~fII~~
o~cca__O_Gl~-Q C~~Q O-- ~c~~ o·_~~o·- ~~xti~.-cc
%~_~~u>%_&..e~_U3~~U~ «c«u ~Q.~E~~ ~~u~o~-~
. ..... .
c.!: ~~ 2
.;;¡ 5 C '0 IØ '0 ~
.....- me ~ ~. ~
~ _::I';¡IIIC ã1~ ~
~ i ~ >- ell ~ 0 ~ .- -
,... e...,o·- c> ~
~~ 0~4I-~~ <It~ ~
16!U G! "'1Ø.l:o~·ë III" ~
5~ C 0....>-.- CI ~
w! ø ~~~~-- ~c
.~ c ~ OC- 0
"'Z ::g,.,æ~ f~
c~~~~ :IE.
"0 eII~ ,.. ~
oCt; z~ In
I
~
1::
... >- a
C! ~ ~
,.._ III ~
~ti ê ~
16!~ ã ~
5U1 (:)
~~ ¡ 0
... III
~
Q
::
:::
~ , (:)
~ .;~ ..) 0
. ;;: ~., ..E::
I-.&. -. h
ill g ---;' ~ ~
ö CI ~ ~
i ~ ~ t ~
~ - -
~ Eq;-- ~
Þ- """ c...) ",..'
UI _ <:"I ,
i< ~ '1
w
.
.
NPDES PenniJ No. FLSOOOO18
1. Structural Controls and Storm Water Collection System OperaJion: (continUed)
---,._- --.-.--..- ,-
Additionally, to satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall -
b.,// -,
~Plement the Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part ill.A.!.
, pages ~ - 27 of this permit. _,
I
~ -
" ----.---
2. Areas of New Development and Significant Redevelopment: A comprehensive master
planning process (or,equivalent) shall be implemented 'to reduce, to the MEP, the
discharge of pollutants from MS4s, which receive discharges from areas of new
development and significant redevelopment, after construction is completed. The
master planning process shall limit the increases in the discharge of pollutants in
storm water as a result of new development, and shall reduce the discharge of
pollutants in storm water from redeveloped areas, and shall not cause or contribute to
violations of State surface water quality standards of the receiving stream.
a. To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall implement the
Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part m.A.2. on pages 28 -
A of this permit.
--~-
3. Roadways: Public streets, roads, and highways shall be operated and maintained in a
manner to reduce, to the MEP, the discharge of pollutants and not cause or contribute
to violations of State surface water quality standards of the receiving stream.
a. The permittees shall develop and implement standard road repair practices to
reduce the pollutants in storm water runoff from areas associated with road
repair and maintenance. The program developed shall include practices such
as limiting the amount of soil disturbance to the immediate area under repair
and scheduling potential pollutani-causing routine repair work during dry
seasons, when possible. The program shall establish procedures that address
spill prevention, material management practices, and good housekeeping
measures at all municipal equipment yards & maintenance shops that support
road maintenance activities.
b. Additionally, to satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part ill.A.3.
on pages .12.. - .19- of this permit.
4. Flood Control Projects: Water quality impacts on receiving water shall be assessed
for all flood management projects identified. The feasibility of retrofitting existing
structural flood control devices to provide additional pollutant removal from storm
water shall be evaluated.
a. To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall implement the
Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part m.A.4. on pages 40 -
42 of this permit.
Palm Beach County & Co-applicants - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART 11 - Page 14
.
I
NPDES Pennü No. FLSOOOO18
5. Municipal waste treatment, storage, or disposaljacilities not covered by an NPDES
storm water permit: The permittees shall implement a program to identify measures
to monitor and reduce pollutants in storm water discharges from facilities that handle
municipal waste, including sewage sludge.
a. To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall develop and'
implement a program to reduce pollutants in the storm water discharges from
. municipally-operated solid waste transfer stations, maintenance and storage
yards for waste transportation fleets and equipment, publicly owned treatment
works (POTWs), and sludge application and/or disposal sites which are not
covered by NPDES storm water permits. The initial phase of the program
developed shall contain procedures to evaluate, inspect, and monitor these
sites. Based upon the evaluations, inspections and monitoring performed,
priorities and procedures for implementing control measures for pollutant
reduction at these sites shall be developed. Monitoring methodology used
during the initial investigative period may be relaxed from standard protocol
and may be based on experience gained during actual field activities. The
goal of this investigative portion is to actively identify areas within these sites
with poorer quality discharges during storm events, so that those areas will be
given priority when implementing control measures.
6, Pesticide, Herbicide. and Fertilizer Application: Each permittee shall implement
controls to reduce, to the MEP, the discharge of pollutants related to the storage and
application of pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers applied, by employees or
contractors, to public right of ways, parks, and other municipal property and shall not
cause or contribute to violations of State surface water quality standards of the
receiving stream. Permittees with jurisdiction over lands shall implement programs to
encourage the reduction of the discharge of pollutants related to application and
distribution of pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers.
a. All pesticide applicators must have a State license under Florida Law and be
subject to all regulations in the pesticide application law. Each municipality
must comply will all label instructions, record keeping and storage techniques
required by the State. To satisfy the requirements of this section, the
permittees shall implement the Storm Water Management Programs identified
in Part ill.A.6. on page 44 of this permit.
7. Rlicit Discharges and Improper Disposal: The permittees shall implement an ongoing
program to detect and eliminate (or require the discharger to the MS4 to eliminate)
illicit discharges and improper disposal into the storm sewer system.
.
a. Inspection, Ordinances I and Enforcement Me~ures: Non-storm water
discharges to the MS4 shall be effectively prohibited by the permittees through
the use of inspections, ordinances, and enforcement. The permittees,
however, may allow the following non-storm water discharges to the MS4
where they are not identified as a source of pollutants to waters of the United
States:
Palm Beach County & Co-applicants - DRAFr 09/07/95 PART n - Page 15
.
NPDES Permit No. FLSOOOO18
· water line flushing;
· landscape irrigation;
· diverted stream flows;
· rising ground waters;
· uncontaminated ground water infIltration (as defined at
40 CFR 35.2005(20» to separate storm sewers;
· uncontaminated pumped ground water;
· discharges from potable water sources;
· foundation drains;
· air conditioning condensate;
· irrigation water;
· springs;
· water from crawl space pumps;
· footing drains;
· lawn watering;
· individual residential car washing;
· flows from riparian habitats and wetlands;
· dechJorinated swimming pool discharges;
· street wash waters; and
· discharges or flows from emergency fire fIghting
activities.
To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittee(s) identified in Part
m.A.7.a. on pages 45 - ~ of the permit shall:
(1) Identify those of the non-storm water discharges listed under Part
II.A.7.a. (above), as well as any other non-storm water discharges,
which will be allowed to be discharged to the MS4. Describe any
conditions to be placed on these allowable discharges.
(2) Enforce ordinances which prohibit illicit connections and illegal
dumping into the MS4. The permittees shall develop an inspection
program to uncover illicit connections. The program shall include a
schedule for inspections and an allocation of staff and resources. A
description of the enforcement procedures shall be detailed within the
program developed. Because the potential for illicit discharges and
. improper disposal is generally higher for areas of older development,
areas with many automobile-related industries, and areas with
significant numbers of heavy industrial facilities, the permittees shall
consider the specific land use and age of development when
determining inspection priorities and inspection schedules for this
program component. Facility inspections may be carried out in
conjunction with other municipal programs (e.g. pretreatment
inspections of industrial users, health inspections, fire inspections,
etc.). The permittees shall maintain an internal log documenting the
inspections performed.
Palm Beach County & Co-appUcants - DRAFT 09/07/95 PART H - Page 16
.
.
I
NPDES Pennil No. FLSOOOO18
b. Dry Weather Field Screening Program: The permittees shall continue ongoing
efforts to detect the presence of illicit connections and improper discharges to
the MS4.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
implement a dry weather field screening program to locate and
eliminate illicit discharges and improper disposal into the MS4. This
program shall include the dry weather screening activities identified in
Table II.A.7.b. The minimum level of.effort for the field screening
program shall be based upon a 0.50-mile grid system, with each grid
area containing at least one field screening location. In industrial and
heavy commercial areas, the minimum level of effort shall be based
upon a O.2S-mile grid system, with each grid area containing at least
one field screening, location. Under this program, all grid areas of the
MS4 must be Screened once during the permit term. Some grid areas
may require more than one field screening location or a more frequent
inspection schedule. In lieu of the grid system, the permittees may
choose to field screen at all outfalls. Follow-up activities to eliminate
illicit discharges and improper disposal may be prioritized on the basis
of magnitude and nature of the suspected discharge; sensitivity of the
receiving water; and/or other relevant f~rs. Screening methodology
may be modified based on experience gained during actual field
screening activities. While 'performing field screening activities, the
permittees shall collect information on outfalls and portions of the
MS4 which are not mapped, and this updated information shall be
entered into the database system on an ongoing basis. An internal log .
documenting the results of all field screening performed shall be
maintained.
.
Palm Beach County & Co-appüconts - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 17
.
.
NPDES PenniJ No. FLSOOOO18
Table II.A.7.b.
. ,... ......
.- ..'. .
<HH .'.,.'... '., .'., '" ,.'.."'"...,/H· FREQUENCY OF
GRID MAPCOVERÏNG AREA SERVED FIELD SCREENING
. ".'...'. ',' BY MS4 '
.' . . .
, ,.....,.. _.., ..d__
>:".".,' ." or .H'.'... ,..':..,:,
....- ..- '. ...., .' '-'" ...... .,.....
. ALL OUTFALLS(regardless ofske) >
O.25-mile Grid or
Industrial Land Use All Major Outfalls
Once I 3 years
O.25-mile Grid or
Heavy Commercial Land Use AllOutfalls
Once I 3 years
o .sO-mile Grid or
All Other Land Uses AllOutfalls
Once I 5 years
1/3 of the Outfalls or
1/3 of the Grid Areas
Entire MS4 System Screened During Permit
Years Three, Four, & Five
with the Entire MS4
Screened Once I 5 years
\
Palm Beach County & Co-opplicants - DRAFT 09/07/95 PART II - Page 18
,
,
.
NPDES Pennit No. FLSOOOO18
.c~, Investigation of Suspected ILUcits and/or Improper Disposal: The permittees shall
.. r I develop and implement standard procedures to be followed to investigate portions of
r ,J'".
\\ t ...t"...
. J K.,'r' the MS4 that. based on the results of the field screen or other appropriate information,
" ';. I), ~. ¡ì indicate a reasonable potential of containing illicit discharges or other sources of non-
'[." ..ì'
r h ~ \. storm water. Notification to EPA-of any illicit connection shall be an element of the
:'\" i J , ~ ..
\ ,~ þ.. 'J ( investigative standard procedures.
',! -k
~ ., .
J ~ _ t.
.1'. (1) To satisfy the requirements of this section. the permittees, identified in Part
m.A.7.c. on pages ~ -...8.., shall develop and implement standard
investigative procedures to identify and terminate the source of the illicit
connection or discharge in accordance with the schedule provided. The
procedures developed shall require proper training for the field personnel
involved in identifying conditions that may indicate the presence of illicit
discharges. Upon the verification of responsible parties. the standard
procedures developed shall require the immediate cessation of improper
disposal practices and the elimination of the illicit connection as expeditiously
as. possible. Where the elimination ofan illicit connection or the submittal of
an NPDES application to EPA is not possible within a specified time frame
determined by the permittee, the standard procedures developed shall require
- that the responsible parties submit for approval a written compliance sc;hedule
for the removal of the discharge. In the interim. the permittees shall require
the operator of the illicit discharge to take all reasonable and prudent measures
to minimize the discharge of pollutants to the MS4.
(2) To satisfy the requirements of this section, FDOT shall develop and
implement standard investigative proced\1res to identify the source of the illicit
connection or discharge to the FDOT MS4, in accordance with the schedule
provided in Part ill.A. 7 .c. on page ...8.. of this permit. Upon the
identification of resPQnsible parties, the standard procedures developed shall
require the timely reporting of water quality violations to Florida Department
of Environmental"Protection (FDEP) and EP A. Until such time that the illicit
connection has been eliminated or the responsible parties have submitted an
NPDES application for the discharge to EPA, FDOT shall require the
operator of the illicit discharge to take all reasonable and prudent measures to
minimi7.e the discharge of pollutants to the MS4. Where measures to
minimize the discharge are not taken, the developed procedures shall consider
the termination of the connecting entity's FDOT drainage connection permit.
d. Spill Prevention and Response: The pennittees shall implement procedures to
prevent, contain, and respond to spills that may discharge into the MS4.
l~, (1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall adopt FDOT's
. Emergency Operations Procedures, or a comparable plan and procedures
which effectively mitigate potential pollutant discharges to surface waters.
These documents shall be adopted in accordance with the schedule provided in
Part ID.A.7.d. on page ~ of this permit.
Palm Beach County & Co~pUcants - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 19
.
.
.
NPDES Pennit No. FLSOOOO18
e. Publie Notification: The permittees shall develop and implement a program to
promote, publicize, and faciJitate public reporting of iUicit discharges of water
quality impacts associated with discharges from the MS4.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
develop and implement programs to facilitate public reporting of illicit
discharges and improper disposal of materials into the MS4 in
accordance with the schedule provided in Part m.A.7.e. on page 2Q..
of this permit. The program shall inform the public about what to
look for and how to report incidents. The program shall also enhance
public awareness of the problems associated with illicit discharges and
may include programs such as educating school students, using inserts
in utility bills, and public service announcements in newspaper, on
television, or on radio.
f. Oils, Toxies, and Household HaztlTdous Waste Control: The permittees shall
effectively prohibit the discharge or disposal of used motor vehicle fluids,
household hazardous wastes, grass clippings, leaf litter, and animal wastes
into the MS4.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part
m.A.7.f. on page ~ of this permit.
g. Limitation of Sanitary Sewer Seepage: The permittees shall prevent (or
require the operator of the sanitary sewer to eliminate) unpermitted discharges
of dry and wet weather overflows from sanitary sewers into the MS4. Each
permittee shall eliminate the infiltration of seepage from sanitary sewers into
the MS4,
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part
m.A.7.g. on pages...a. - ~ of this permit.
8. Industrial and High Risk Runoff: The permittees shall develop and implement a
program to identify and control pollutants, to the MEP, in storm water discharges to
the MS4 from the municipallandfill(s); hazardous waste treatment,· storage, disposal
and recovery facilities; facilities that are subject to EPCRA Title m, Section 313; and
any other industrial or commercial discharge the permittees determine is contributing
a substantial pollutant loading to the MS4 and shall not cause or contribute to
violations of State surface water quality standards of the receiving stream.
I
To satisfy the two (2) requirements of this section, the permittees shall:
a. Identify priorities and procedures for inspections: Identify all targeted
facilities and determine priority sites in accordance with the schedule provided
in Part m.A.8.a. on pages ..2£. and 63 of this permit. Inspection schedules
and procedures for the identified facilities shall be developed and
implemented.
Palm Beach County· & Co-appücants - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 20
,
.
,
NPDES Permit No. FLSOOOO18
Also, the permittees shall provide a listing in each ANNUAL REPORT of
additionally identified industrial facilities which discharge storm water into the
MS4 which have not been previously reported. The industrial storm water
discharges that must be included in this inventory fall into the eleven (11)
classes of industrial activities as defined in the November 1990 regulations
under 40 CFR 122.26(b)(14),
b. Monitoring/or High Risk Industries: Develop and implement a monitoring (or
self monitoring) program for facilities identified under this section in
accordance with the schedule provided in Part ill.A.S.b. on page M. of this
permit. The monitoring program shall include the collection of quantitative
data on the following constituents:
· any pollutants limited in an existing NPDES permit for
an identified facility;
· oil and grease;
· chemical oxygen demand (COD);
· pH;
· biochemical oxygen demand, five-day (BODj);
· total suspended solids (TSS);
· total phosphorous;
· total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN);
· nitrate plus nitrite nitrogen; and
· any information on discharges required under
40 CFR 122.21(g)(7)(iii) and (iv).
Data collected by the industrial facility to satisfy the monitoring requirements
of an NPDES or State q.ischarge permit may be used to satisfy this
requirement. Permittees may require the industrial facility to conduct self-
monitoring to satisfy this requirement.
,
9." Construction Site Runoff: The permittees shall develop and implement a program to
reduce the discharge of pollutants from construction sites to the MEP, and shall not
cause or contribute to violations of State surface water quality standards of the
receiving stream.
a. Site Planning and Non-structural &: Structural Best Management Practices:
The permittees shall require the use and maintenance of appropriate structural
and non-structural best management practices to reduce pollutants discharged
to the MS4 during the time of construction.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section, the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Ptograms identified in Part
ill.A.9.a. on pages 65 -.1.Q.. of this permit.
Palm Beach County & Co-appliamts - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 21
.
NPDES Pennit No. FLSOOOO18
b. Inspection and Enforcement: The permittees shall develop and implement a
program for inspecting construction sites and for enforcing the requirement
for control measures.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section. the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Programs identified in Part
m.A.9.b. on pages.1L - 74 of this permit.
c. Site Operator Training: The permittees shall conduct appropriate education
and training measures for construction site operators and those associated with
the implementation of proper sediment & erosion control measures at
construction sites.
(1) To satisfy the requirements of this section. the permittees shall
implement the Storm Water Management Program(s) identified in Part
ID.A.9.c. on page..12 of this permit.
B. Area-specific Stonn Water Mana2ement Program Requirements.
Reserved pending additional requirements which may be included
as a result of State Certification of the pennit.
(See Section 401 of the CWA.)
C. Deadlines for Program Comnliance. Except as provided in Part m. compliance with the
s~nn W:;iter_ management program shall be required 90 days from the effective date of the
permit. ..---~--. .....- -_._--~" -., .- ---~..- -.-..---.---
---------> ..
D. Roles and Responsibilities of Pennittees. The Storm Water Management Program, together
with any attached interagency agreements or interagency agreements developed subsequent to
the effective date of the permit, shall clearly identify the roles and responsibilities of each
permittee. Following the effective date of the permit, interagency agreements developed and
implemented must be included in the ANNUAL REPORT covering the permit year in which
the agreement became effective, .
E. !&gal Authoritv. To the extent allowed by law, each permittee shall ensure legal authority to
control discharges to and from those portions of the Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System
(MS4) over which it has jurisdiction. This legal authority may be a combination of statute,
ordinance, permit, contract, order or inter-jurisdictional agreements between permittees with
adequate existing legal authority to accomplish items 1 - 6 below. This legal authority for
FDOT may be a combination of State statutes administered and enforced by sister agencies
within the State of Florida government system which have adequate existing legal authority to
accomplish the following items 1 - 6:
1. Control the contribution of pollutants to the MS4 by Storm Water Discharges
Associated with Industrial Activity and the quality of storm water discharged from
sites of industrial activity;
Palm Beach County & Co-applicants - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 22
,
.
,
NPDES Pennit No. FLSOOOO18
2. Prohibit illicit discharges to the MS4;
3. Control the discharge of spills and the dumping or disposal of materials other than
storm water (e.g, industrial and commercial wastes, trash, used motor vehicle fluids,
leaf litter, grass clippings, animal wastes, etc.) into the MS4;
4. Control through interagency or inter-jurisdictional agreements among permittees the
contribution of pollutants from one portion of the MS4 to another;
5. Require compliance with conditions in ordinances, permits, contracts or orders; and
6. Carry out all inspection, surveillance and monitoring procedures necessary to
determine compliance with permit conditions.
F. Storm Water Mana2ement Program Resources.
if Each permittee shall provide adequate finances to implement their activities under the Storm
Water Management Program. Each permittee shall also have a source of funding for
implementing all other requirements included within this NPDES storm water permit.
G. Storm Water Management Program Review and Modification.
1. Program Review: Each permittee shall participate in an annual review of the current
Storm Water Management Program (SWMP) in conjunction with preparation of the
ANNUAL REPORT required under Part V.C. of the permit.
2, Program Modification: The permittee(s) may modify the SWMP during the life of the
permit in accordance with the following procedures:
a. Modifications adding (but not subtracting nor replacing) components, controls,
or requirements to the approved SWMP may be made by the permittee(s) at
any time. A description of the modification shall be included within the
subsequent ANNUAL REPORT.
b. Modifications replacing an ineffective or unfeasible BMP specifically
identified in the SWMP with an alternate BMP may be made by the
permittee(s) at any time. A description of the replacement BMP shall be
included in the subsequent ANNUAL REPORT along with the following
information:
(1) an analysis of why the former BMP was ineffective or infeasible
(including cost prohibitive);
(2) expectations on the effectiveness of the replacement BMP; and
(3) an analysis of why the replacement BMP is expected to achieve the
goals of the BMP which was replaced.
P~ Beach County & Co-applicants - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART II - Page 23
.
.
I
, , ~
t ! \ t') ,,') -~
,r ,..:; _ ,. '. ' , /'''---0' ~
, '~(.., t,' _.<: ,.,~. -'-.u ~ ~--X.A / ~~
CL'~'-(- I.. ....- L.. j, -- J - -
...... -.. .~-' ..
/ NPDES Permit No. FLSII/HJ(J18
c. Modifications to adjust the schedule for maintenance activities or the
frequency of inspections or monitoring identified in the SWMP may be made
~ the Dermittee(s) on an annual h:l~i~ The permittees must include in the
subsequent ANNUAL REPORT a description of the schedule adjustment along
with the following information:
" (1) . an analysis of why the former schedule was ineffective or infeasible;
(2) expectations on the effectiveness of the replacement schedule; and
(3) an analysis, if applicable, of why the replacement schedule will ensure
the optimization of equipment use.
d~ Modifications subtracting components, controls, or requirements of the SWMP
may not be made by the permittee(s) UNLESS it can be clearly demonstrated
that with the elimination of this component, the SWMP will continue to
achieve a reduction in pollutants to the MEP and shall not cause or contribute
to violations of State surface water quality standards of the receiving stream.
In the case where this type of modification is appropriate, the permittee(s)
may make the required modification and shall include in the subsequent
ANNUAL REPORT, a description of the component which has been
eliminated along with the following information:
(1) an analysis of why the component was ineffective or infeasible, and
(2) a detailed explanation of why, with the elimination of this component,
the SWMP will continue to achieve a reduction in pollutants to the
MEP and shall not cause or contribute to violations of State surface
water quality standards of the receiving stream,
e. Modifications included within the ANNUAL REPORT shall be signed in
accordance with Part VI.H. by all directly affected permittees, and shall
include a certification that all affected permittees were given an opportunity to
comment on proposed changes.
3, Transfer of Ownership, Operational Authority, or Responsibility for Storm Water
Management Program Implementation: The permittee(s) shall implement the SWMP
on all new areas added to their portion of the Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System
(or for which they become responsible for implementation of storm water quality
controls) as expeditiously as practicable. Implementation of the program in any new
area shall consider the plans in the SWMP of the previous MS4 ownership,
Prior to land annexation, the permittee shall include a schedule for extending the
SWMP to the annexed areas. At least 30 days prior t~ transfer of operatiònal
authority or responsibility for SWMP implementation, all parties shall prepare a
schedule for transfer of responsibility for SWMP implementation on the affected
portions of the MS4. This schedule shall be included in the ANNUAL REPORT,
Palm Beach County & Co-appliCllnts - DRAFI' 09/07/95 PART 11 - Page 24
. '
.
OQ
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
....
....
s
~
~
~
~
~
rIJ
a)
......
....
= '.....
.......
......
u ~
-< ~
~ '"8 0
......
~ ~ 0 1a
'1""'4 ~ ~ a)
1-0
1 u u
'..... 'ïj ~
"""" :g§~
"""" ¡-;¡
~ ~ p.. rIJ
¡-;¡ ~ ~ ]
~ ~
0 ~ p..
E-4 a)
>- 8
E-4 ï
""""
u a)
Q
.
.
s::~ N
0 "'ð "'ð
.-
1a Q) Q)
"'ð S S
Q) ~ ~
S
OJ) ·S 'S
ª CT' CT'
Q) ~
] ~
00 ed ed
s:: ~ ! !
0 ~
,-
~
s:: ~
Q) 0
S ~
Q)
....... =-- "CI Q)
S" "CI
E-- Q) ,-
~ Ë >
.- z 8
~ r-::¡ ~ c.S p.,
~ ~ I-< "CI
Q)
OJ) r-::¡ ~ p., ª
0 ~ ~ en
I-< ~ Q) en
p.., ~ .~ .- Q)
"'ð ...... .-
~ <A .- ......
~ > .-
CI) < .- >
S ~ . en ...... .-
~ ::::-.::r u ~
..... C'd Q)
r-::¡ CI) ð Q)oo .......
OJ) ~ .......~ Q) .g
U C'd -ê"-,, u Q)
Z ª r-::¡ .... ª u ~
~ t-< S ª
< ~ E-- ~ s:: u
~ s:: Q) Q) s:: en
..... .- ...... "'ð Q)
~ I-< "CI en Q)
Q) "'ð u
=-- 1a Ë Q) >. ·a ,- ª
~ ~ ~ li=:oo S C'd
~ ._ I-< S s::
0 "'ð CI) "CI Q)
Ë ~ Q) ~ ~ "'ð
u ~ "CI Q) ª .-
~ 0 ~ ._ 00 en s:: C'd
...... -E Ë 0 s
~ 00 1:1 s:: .-
I-< ~ 0 "t) "CI
;:J 0 ,-
c.S ~ ...... Q) ª
Z s:: ...... u p.,
.::: 000 Q)
en Z p., en s::
0 Q) ~ u CI) s:: .
....... 0 ð .......1a en ,- t-< 0
..... ;::j s:: 4-4~ ,-
E-- ~ ~ .- ......
"CI ..... ~ 00 u
< Q) E-- - ~ Q)
..s:: < ~ ¡: u . enp.., p.,
E-- u Q) C'd C'd en~
U ~ en
Z en E-- ~ :: 200 0 ;:J""'; s::
OJ) Z 'g tjed p.., .9< Q) .-
r-::¡ s:: ~ ·B ~ J3
~ ,- r-::¡ ~ .::: Q) ,9- S:::i
~ ~ ..s:: u
r-::¡ 0 ~ ...... .- ~ Q) Q) ~~ 0
0 4-4 §
~ ....... ~ ~ < ...... ....... ~~ ......
....... ~ ~~ ~-ê ~
=-- c.S =-- ~
~ < o:u u ent-<
Q) E-- ~ ~~ gfs:: .£ en
..... .£ ~ ~ en
~ Z 1:1 .~ .~ 4-4..s:: Q)
.£ z r-::¡ p.,"CI o g u
0 ~ Q) Q) Q) Q)
'~ < ~ "'ð 0 ..s:: Q)li=: "'ð Q) s::
~ Z ~ ,_ u g ~ .- Q) s:: "CI
00 >. r-::¡ .... C'd..s:: "CI"'ð S ,- Q)
0 ~ ~ S u CI) S
r-::¡ ....... s:: I-< Q) en "'ð
~ S"Qj ..... < "CI ~ ,- 0"CI en Q) Q)
E-- ªr:Q u ._ ~ S CI)
~ o u < ~ ~ ~ ~ en "CI
~ u ª ~ en S ....... ~ ~
E-- 1:1 ...... ed 0 en
r-::¡ ....... .- sed < S ~ ] ~ Q)
edõ.. Z ~ OJ)
== {J S r-::¡ ~ ~ ..p p.., -' Q) 0 § ~ ª
u ~ .... U Q) ..... "'ð U
- ..s::
,.-.,0 r-::¡ ¡: Q)..s:: Q)
00 en U r-::¡ E-- p.,...... ....... .- ed ª~ U
"-" ...... o:u en 0 -ê ª B §
CI) ._ ~ ~ ~ .s ......
~ Ë =-- t-< 0
Ë ,Š s:: U g ~
~ .- Q) ~ Q) '5 Ë Q)
..... Ë p., ~ ..... 1a "CI
..... ..... ~ ~ s:: en ~ ~ ;::j
~ Q) I-< "CI ,- -
p.,c.S p., C'd Q) ~
0 Q)..s:: ~ ~.£
Q)"CI p.., U .....
~ ª < E-- en , s:: en
. .- ..D .¿ C'd Qj
=-- 00 C'd"CI U 0
,
M
~ ~
o5~ o5~
<+-<..... <+-<05
O<+-< O<+-<
~ 0 ~ 0
...c:~..... ..J::!~.....
~ ~ ,- E ~ .-
.gQã .goã
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
;>P-< ;>P-<
00·_ ~,_
.....t) Nt)
o5~ o5~
,- (.j...¡ .- (.j...¡
~~ ~~
~
~
~
¡::
....
..... .....
¡:: ~o5ëa
~ ~.~ ~
5::J ~ ~~"tjO
t: ~ ¡::: C,) ~ ,-
~ s::: t: ~ g..~
~ 0 0 ,_ ..... "tj .
~ ';j ..........~s:::.....~
~~ C,) ~ 0.. ;> 0 s::: ~
-.¡ ~"tj S ~ C,) ~ !Z)
;:: ~ ~O"tj..... S,,<::,
~ ~ s::: " § '-ã ~ ~
.... s::: ,- ..., OJ)
't O,$~ cdÞ
~ ';j s:::!;JbD~ C§
~ C,)'- ~ 0.. cd
~ ~ cdSs:::8~ SO
u ã ~o..o5....U
a.. 0 "tjO~<+-< ~...c:
~ C,) C........c:O ~C,)
- td~¡.....:>cd
~ ~"tj ~ 8 ;> ~
~ 0 ~!Z)rñ~ ã!:O
E !:) ~::S8:.::: oS
~ .~ 9 Þ ~ o..s 1;) ëa
..... 0.. >. § s::: "tj P-<
t;,j ~..... ,- 0 ~ ~
~ .... E01:Y S:::..J::!
;:: "tj cd U 0 s::: '¡g ~
I::t ~.~ ...c: ëa ~ s:::.s
Coo:! .... C,) C,).... .- s:::
..... ~ 0.. cd 0.... cd .-
~ s::: ....~.....r.S S~
"'" 0 0 _ .... ~
;:: ';j ~ S 0 ~ "tj OJ)
r~ ~ ¡::; ..... ::c, § ~ a
~ s::: æ cd c ,_ ...c:
- s::: bD P-< td.~ 13 ~
¡;: 0 0 ~ ~;> ~ ,-
== C,) .......c:s:::o "tj
_ ..... 0.......0.... .....
~ ,- 0 ,- 0.. 0 cd
== ~ §.....:B~ >.05
.:: :-:::';j ~ s::: ~ ~ cd
t;,j ~ ~aoS ~~
~ ~ o.....c: C,) ~ ;> cd
~ s::: ~ C,) ,~8 .- .....
~ .- s::: ~ ¡::: 0 .... cd
~ S'-'- t: ~ 0.. s:::
;:: ,_ c"tj ~ s::: ...c: 0
I::t - td...c:o..~ C,)';j
;:: ~ C,) cd C,)
~ 0 ~ ,- ëa ~ ~ :.::::
..... ..... ~...s:: C,) ~ :;." fï:í
.5 ~ S ~.9 <+-< !:f 'C
I::t ;::¡ ~ ~ 0 .....;:1
¡.,¡;¡ "tj - ~"tj s::: s::: '-'
~ ~ o..'¡j c 0 ~ ~
~ C,) S:.::: td ,- ;> ~
;:: 0 ,_.- ~ õ. s::: Þ
I::t ...."tj ~ Q .- .- .-
;:: ~ ~':::s ~ "tj],
.~ 0..' 0.. c ~ ~ ~ 'u
.::: 0 "tj 0 ~ ~ "tj ..Q 'a
¡;: ~ ~ ~ S !Z) cd ,- 3
~ ;>~;>~ ~ ~s
~ ~ 6 ~ ~p.;-g ~
~ QC,) Qc~_ ;:s...c:
~ tdr\C,) C,)
. . .- . S ~ s::: cd
~ OJ) "tj ...c: ~ ._ ~
, '
~ ~
oS ~
II! ~ ~ ."
~r-1 co::I ~
r:04¡;r ~ 0 5
~?S>' 00 ~ p...
...;.;,¡ó(,.........'...,..'.....'........','..,œ',.,.,.,.".,.... ........-
:~.»,"'..> .......
= " ,'. :.§ ~
....<.¡...¡
,- ~
~
Þ "'0 ~
._ c ~
C) Cd »
. co::I ,~ ....
-= ~ ê' S 'E
~ ~ C) 2 t:: ~
is .... rIJ (l) bI)
§- ~ ~ ~ 0. ~
...... bI) c ~ ~ ·8
~ c ,- ~ +J ....
.... ._ co::I .... "'0
~ 0.43 c bI) »
.... 0..- c c
~ co::I bI) ~ .- Cd
I:'< S .s .~ ~ 4-<
~ _....::-- "'0 0
::: '-' rIJ _
~ ~ ,- rIJ '-' C
I:J ~ ~ E 2 0
t.... "'0 (l) ~ ~ ._
.~ o.~S P.. Š
~ ;:joS~ S c
.... C 4-< > 0 ~
~ Cd 0 8 C) S
"!::! ..co.» ~
§ gf.9 S ] P..
.~ ~ _.-4 ~ e
:æ ~ c "'0 rIJ ,-
~ 0 ,- c· c
~ ....... ~ Cd ~ ,_
¡¡¡;: ....... t:: c rIJ
"' t.8~~(l) co::I
6" ....Cd.D....
..... (l)(l)(l)~ ~ c
~ ~"'OS~ C) ~
~ .... co::I ~ > co::I ~
,.... .g .~ C) 8 (l) 0.
"""4 ._ S c 0. 4-< ..9
..;: >~CdS 0 (l)
~ ~ 8 t) "Ë .-?:> >
~ o.~(l)~ æ .g
~ ~ ~ ....0 g ~ ~
ø ~ .~ bI) tH rIJ oS
O t:::I ~~rlJbI) ~
~ .,.._ c C rIJ "'0
~ a... .~ co::I o'~ co::I ,_
~ ~ v. .....- "'a ;:j
~ .~ "'0 ~ d t-< bI)
~ is "'0 .... "'0 ~,J .
Z ~ ;:j ~ C...!:j ~ .B ~
a... t)~~+J 0 cC)
~ ~ ~ ~ S·~ p... d Æ .5>
~ ~ co::I~S"'O ~o p.......
~ ~ c t:: 0 (l) P:::: .,¡j (l) 0.
ø ~ .§ .B ~ ~ ~ g gp E
-< '5 "'0 rIJ .~ 0 ~ 4-< C (l)
z.~ ê -as 5.S ~ ~ .§ 5
:1 ~ o~""rIJ rIJ OC)
~ "::::-. c.eo~t) ~....§
"'" ,rlJO 0 ~~
~ ~ 8. ~ .... C) ~ C) "tic
~ a... "'0 0.2~ C) bI) co::I (l)
~.... ,- co::I.... co::I C ~ "'0
......::: c C) :>.- ~ ,_ ,£:; c
...... ~ Cd·- .,. 0. c .:t:: co::I Cd
:> U (l) § ~ co::I '-;:j '"
í' ....... t:: C) ~ rIJ ..... c
~ Ñ ~;.B-as]~ ~.g
~crIJ~ õ~ >Æ
C).- (l) S C oS (l) .......
o r:/) t) oS ,_ - "'0 o.s
~ , .~ 4-< t) . c ,rIJ .
r:/) co::I (l) 0 (l) .D co::I C) , S "'0
,
,
\r\
(!)
-:S (!) (!) (!)
~-:S -:S-:s
o ~ ~ ¡:::: ~
m 0 ¡:: 0
-:S (!) - -g (!) (!) _
s::: 1d ..... .... E--< 1d '....
~oa ~~ oa
~~æ -:Sa ~æ
1.0 '.... 0 (!) .....
S:::0 -~ 0
..... (!) I-< (!)
-:S !:ô . 0 !:ô
~~ æ ~
m
~ , 0/)"0 :>< m
~ E--< s::: I-< '.... -
" ,J '.... ~ "0 s:::
... ..... t:"O s:::(!)
..21 0 ·....a ª 8. s
:::: ~ - A ~
~ ~ " m ....... .....
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 'I:: A ~ s::: cr
~ ~ 0 (!) '.... '.... (!)
:::: _"O~ _I-<
~ µ.. ~ - '-' (!)
~ ~ _A (!)O/)
;¡¡; ~u"O =3c::1
~ os::: 0 +:IS:::
~ (!) ~ 0 (!) '....
~ ~~~ "O~
::. ... > ~ r.n "0
~ ~ 008~ ð"O
~ c::I ~"Oª mª
=< (!) ___ s:::_
~ s::: 0 ~ " 0 ....
... '.... 0 ~ ..... ....
... - > - (!)
~ m ..s::: '.... c::I d
~ å) m ,';:: "3 ~
~ mm O/)~
.~ g. (!)s::: (!)~
:::: - u ~ ~ s:::
.~ ~ ª >. _ ro
~ (!) s::::::::: s::: S
"= "0 (!);.ø.s £31-<
§ S ·E 0 §, A~
~ .8 u~a~ ~~
:::: '+-I ~o¡:¡(!) (!)
~ "0 (!)(!)OS >a
~ ~ ¡:::: "00 ,!::1 (!) ~ 0 '
~ A .::J >u ~_m
..s: (!) ro U s::: ~ "0 m ~
~ g ~(!)(!)t.H s:::m(!)
~ c::I .......s:::......:'s::: ro~S
t"'\ m >'E--< c::I (!) ...:¡ m A
""'4 d ,';:: >"0 "O(!)O
~ ~ ~A8s::: (!)~-
... (!) "'\r\""ro --(!)
~ t) ...... ~, ....... A '-' >
~ >. cr';,Ad oc::l(!)
~ m l-<C"Ic::Io "O..s:::"O
"" " (!) 1.0 I-< '.... c::I u !U
'W ~ - 0 - '.... -
~ 0/) c::I .t.Hc::I m..s:::_
~ ¡g ~~m-t; ~ª-~ '.... ¡:::: < ª,~ ___ u
"'" c::I ¡:: ,_ ~ s::: ~
" ~ 0 µ.. A 'Cj ,.,.., 0·....
~ _ '"-' ~ _..... s:::
;¡¡; (!) m m ~ "0 >. 1d 0/)
~ ..s::: m s:::..... c::I c::I U '....
~ - (!) 0 m 1-<..... m
'" ~ U '.... ~ rA' ~;:: "0
~ 0 S:::1d0"O ~.......s:::
~ t ¡g"3~ ~ 0 ê'ro
~ 0 ..... 0/) t: ~ ~ .';:: J!3
~ A "0 (!) '.... ..s::: ¡:::: s:::
"5 ~ ~~~- þ¡::(!)
-...., ..... (!) S
.~ 0/) ~ ~ ~ ° U A A
~ ~ g(!)m~ (!)C"I0
~ c::I _ErA' ..s:::t~
~ A mc::l~O/) -ro>
- 0 c::I (!) (!) .S E ~ (!)
~ - . _ I-< d U (!) "0
.::: (!) m AE--< ~ ~ S (!) ~
:::: ~ Ol-<~"O (!)-:S(!)
r~ 0 '3 ~·S ~ õ.. ~ s:::
...., ~c::Icrl-< dOl-<
~ bb ....; ~ ~ ~ .!:1 ~ ~
,
\0
<!) <!) <!)
<!) -5-5 -5 <!)
*-jf&;~ c.,...'8
~~ Oc.,...
~,ç,¡; 0 ~ ~ 0
i4f¿ .§ ..c:,£..... -5<!).....
..... ctt '.... t::I ttt .....
Jqs ~qs
.~....",. <!) <!) ~~ <!) <!)
.,EH.'..~.... :> Q., \0 .~ Q.,
if> "". ... '';:: N .....
'ic....~:·~ ......!J t::I !J
..c:~ 5~
."t: ~ :£~
~~
~ 8 11
M fij .....
~
aN <!)
o t::I ~
¢: ';a 6
~ a 11
0"ö
efij ~
'-< ~ 0
,£~ >.
~>, -.
~ ë;;
..... 0.,
~ S fj 'éJ ~
'§ '';::
":t: ~Æ '>
.~ t::I '3 a '....
~ !J
..... 0" a ctt
"t;:t ;!'1 <!) o <!)
~ fij'ö cJ:: Q
~"' .....,£ it:: fij <!)
;::J ~ '8
::::: <!) o fj
~ o Q, e'ß t::I
~ 0.0 .....
.86 11
¡;.,"' t a
..... .... ..c
~ <!)"ö ~~ ï::;:
~ Q <!) Q
~ .g~ 8 a1
~ ~ 9 ß"g "ö
& .~ o >, ¡g
:¡§ .... -. ~ ~ ~
~ ~&..vj ~ ;::J ß
0 ß,.... .~ ~ ~
~ Q..... -5«î 51·
~ ¡..¡ '§ '> ë;;
öl) ..... ~-5 ~ .¡:::
~ ~ 8 a t) o ~ 0.,£
~ 0. ctt .....g. <!) ctt
-. a <!)
~ ~ cttou N-5i Q a
,9< ¢ fij fij"ö
.... .;¿ "ö fj öl)& e,£
& ·s §fij~ 8 fij ..... u
~ ,s~
~ a '-< ';a o.t::I ctt-.
"t;:t ~ ';a a ctt,£ a B
~ g ~"ö ~'s .....c.,...
-. ctt <!) 0
~ ~ .~ ¡..;, ctt ~ a iÈ <!)
~ >~E .g~ ~ ~
."'" <!) E 1:: <!) 0
~ 'S " ~ -5.§"
~ '8..c: 8- .'Z ~ ....."ö
; ~ .....,~ 0. e >,
e ~ 51 ~ >,
E "ö ..... <!) £31::
~ t'f) <!) <!) ctt S <!) <!)
o..«î-£i -.g.
r::: E'l5.
a 'éJ ~ ;:;
'-i~g. '-i"ö
f-.I ci~-5i "Ö obfij
(J'J
, ,
r---
Q)
~ Q)
~~
Oc+-<
00 0
~ Q) ......
s:: 1a .....
o Q ê
~Q)Q)
M.~ ~
s:: "¿)
..... Q)
~¢i
..... ~
~
U
.....
:g
I-< p,.
Q) ,
...... C I-<
~Æ c.S
~ s::
¡::::; Q) 0
~ t: ;> .....
~ 0·.... 1a
~ ...... 00 U
;:$ 00 s:: '....
... Q) -
.~ "E ~ p,.
.... OQ) p,.
§ ~ ~ -<
~ ..... 8 ......
~ ~ '....
"-I 0 ê
È' 13u Q)
~ p,.Q) ~
..::: ..s~ C"'I
.~ ~ ~ ~
~ Q) ...... '"
'"0 s:: ,......
~ Q)Q) Q)
::: I-< 8 ~
t:::I Q) Q) ......
"' ~- s::
"-I Q) .....
~ ] ~ ~ 13
~ ......t':S tI3 ..0
~ ;>-. s:: ~ '....
...;...;t ....-1 ........,¡ ""-4
~ ,.... t':S Ol) U
~ u--t; s:: ~
~ Q) '.... '"0
.t: ~~ ~ 00
~ ...... t':S
s:: s:: 8 00
.~ .::::: ..... ...... Q)
..::: ...... Q) ~
o.C:) .~ '"0 I-< ;:J
== :> Q) '"0 '"0
~ ~ ~ Q) Q)
t':S;::S 1a g
~ Q)U p,. I-<
I-< 00 ,.... ,..,
~ t\1 '.... U ......
~ '"0 '.... _
00 ...... 0
§ t':S ã E fI5
::: Q) I-< 0 ~
~ ~ c.S U ~
·S 0 "¿) Q) t ~
~ -;;;.Ë '3 .E ,~
~ ã ~ 13 - ~
~ -~ ~ ~]
::: p,. s:: ~ ...... tI3
t:::I ï:: . .... t':S ï:: tI)~
::: Q) ï:: p,. Q) '"0
.S: 8 Q) 0 8 t':S
~ ~ 8 v ~ 8
... p,.Q);> p,.~
~ 80l) Q) 800
~ -§ Q -~
. ,--.. 8 ,--.. ,--.. .þ
~ - C"'I M 00
, '
00
Q)
-:S Q)
t+-.-:S
0t+-.
00 0
-:SQ).... ....
s:: ~..... .....
00 ê ê
::::s Q) Q) Q)
""'">¡::¡.., ¡::¡..,
N '+J
s:: u
,....~
-:Se.+-<
'.... ~
~
t+-.
0
.Ç
~ '....
-
'....
::: ..D ....:
.....
~ 00 .....
~ ~ ê
~
.~ .š Q)
== 0..
t::- v
~ v -:S
~ s::
..... 0
.-è> ê E
..::: v .....
~ .... s::
== v 0
~ '"0 .....
.8 ~
... I-<
~ 00 0
~ v e-
u
..... 0
> u
~ v ¡..; s::
'"0 '....
V I-<
- ....
.s ß ~ t8
~ <
~ 8 ê ¡::¡..,
.s '"0.8 ~
~ 0
o 00 ....
~ 0 8 00
.... r;¡::::: v 00
~ 0 ~ 00
~ ~ ~
-ò ta '"0
~ v '"0
~ u > u ~ rñ
2 0 0
ø ð 8 !5. "5t5
.... ..... v
0 00 v v ..c:='=
¡:=:: ~ 001-< -:S ~ 8
~ (.J ..3 § t+-. ~ 0..
~ 0 .¡:: v
E-- .~ 00 ....
..... ;: >-. E ~
Z ~ ~- 0..
Q)- ..... s::
~ v 0 0 I-< .....
~ - .... 0.. u ~ ~
~ ~- ~ oo-t3
~ .::: ;: ~ v s::
- s:: 0'"0
ø ::: ~ 0 -g 00 ..... 0
~ ð > '.... v ~ 0
0..> .~ - § --sr;¡:::::
0'"0 u
~ ....'"0 s:: OOta
~ ~ ..... s::
00 E~ ~ 0..
~ v v .....
~ ~:-9 'E o :~
¡:=:: v 0
~ '"0 > 8
~ Q) 0 0.. v ~ 8
E-- U I-< 0 '"0
~ ~ 8 0.. - 0 :.l.,..c:=
~ 0..0 Q) U
.... > tZ) U
0..00 v v E á1
.,g s:: '"0 U
~ ~ I-< I-< v~
V '.... ~
~¿g v 8
¢:: Q) ~
0 o 0 < ~ - I-<
0..-
E-- .þ 8 v
cod v .¿
00 I-< ..D _0
. '
.
0\
( )
( ) ¿j ( )
¿j ~¿j
~ o~
o rJ: 0
( )- ¿j( )-
-..... s::: 1;:j.....
8§ .go§
( ) ( ) ~ ( ) ( )
>~ \O>~
.~ .~
- -
s::: u s::: u
:E~ :§~
~~ ~~
O ( ) .
- s::: ~ ~
~ ,~ .g ~ §
o rJ: tI:I ~ ( )
. 1;:jtl:lu P.
~ u .D '.... ( ) ( )
~ :,:::~õ.. g ¿j
:Y ê:§§- 13 0
.;:: tI:I';jR I-< 1$
~ ~ tI:I 3 0 .....
r~- p. u d - s:::
"""4 '.... ;::I ¡;;;¡ u 0
~ u "'0 ..... :.::: '....
=: ·2 ( ) ,5 .D 1;:j
t::I ;::I] S 5. ~
~r St-<] ( ) e-
~ ~ tI:I ¿j 8
~ S:::"'O ( ) s:::
.... 0 0 on .....
"f ..... ...t:i tI:I I-<
~ 1;:j "'Q) ~ tE
~ ,~ S 8 -<
~ ( ) ~ s::: s::: ~
~ g. ~.9 ( ) ~
.... rJ: ( ) ~ .8 0
.~ .D "'0 u ,.-., -
~ 0 ..... '.... rJ: p
~ 'Ï"~ õ.. '--' a
~ ( )-B§- § 5b
""-- ...t:i ( ) I-< 0
~ +¡'...t:i ( ) on I-<
=: s::: "'0 .~ 8 p.
~ 0 c - p. s:::
....;:: ~rog s::: 0
::;g t::I ---, ( )!tj 0 .f!
~ ~ "'0 "'0 "' '.... '"
.... êi·...-4 \,loll' ........ C)
..... U - tI:I;::I
~ ..... rJ: U _
1"\' ~ - 0 .........
ø ~ rJ: ~ S >B ( )
o § p. ( ) ( )
,.,.s ..... ~ ( ) U ¿j
;..¡;.¡ rJ: o...t:i .....
~ ~ rJ: _ ....... ~
~ ( )rJ: ( ) ....... .D. 0
~..... rJ: s::: s::: tI:I ;::I rJ: >.
Z ~ on 0 ..... p. p. ~ ,..,
~ s::: .;j s:: '5 U N Õ
~ ~ '.... tI:I t:: .!:j ,,..,:.::: U
~ """4 s::: U ( ) ¡;;;¡ ...... .....
~ ~ 'a :.::: "'Q) ;::I ·5 t: tI:I
~ =: .þ p. "'0 S g, c.S ( )
ø.s rJ: ~ ,§ 0 s::: rJ: "'0 ~
-< == ~ I-< - 0 - c >
z:::::± s::: E ~ rJ: 5 ro 8
-< ~ ·a ~ ~ ~ S ~ 0;
~ ""-- ¡;;;¡ ;> "'0 .~ ( ) "'0 -
~;;::o, ( ) § ( ) ....... ............ s:::
~ rJ: U ..... P. U ( )
~ - ....... 0 t: S:E S
~ <::) ~ 0 I-< ..... I-< P.
~ ~ stj~ "'0] ..8
-< ~ ~]"'O êi~ ~
> U --.2 p.( ) ( )
~ u( )u 0"'0 _
. ;::I N s::: ....... ..... .....
~ \C "'0 'r¡) '.... ( ) ,~ ~
~ S:::tI:I"'O ~tj ¢::
o 8'ß.-g og, -<
~ S...t:i . ~ ,
171 cod( )rJ: uo ( )
, '
.
(I) 0
.£ (I) -
~.£
o~
rn 0
'£(1)_
s::: ~ ,-
00 ã
::;E (I) (I)
N;>~
- ,-
-
s::: u
~ :E~
-<.+-<
~ ,- ~
~ ~
~
.....
~
~ ..s:::
~ u
~ :E
~ ~
~ ¡
§ M
OJ}
~" 8
'iU ~ .
'-I '<1"
::: S:::CZJ
I::t ,g ::;E
.:::
~ ~þ
è - §
8
r.; ~ 0
::: "'C u
~ ã)..s:::
".::: ti:: U
'-I :::: ~
~
~ (l)P4
~ ~ 8
I ~rn ~
~ U~
P4 (I)
~ ~ ~.£
.~ OJ} 0
~ s::: -
~ .- s:::
"'C ._
t¡ .EOJ)
ø U s:::
~ §< s::: ,-
,_ 0..
... ';;§
~ ~
E-- 8"'C
¡,.,;¡ §~
Z ~
~ ::: s::: OJ}
.- (I)
I::t "'C -
~ ;.....:-=
~ O"'C
ø ~ -5 §
-< I::t
i3 cd rn
~ (I) s:::
.~ P4 0
~ 8 'B
~ - (I)
~ .'-1 ~ ê
~ ~ (I) 0
~ ~ ..s::: U
- -
;... - .-
~ I::t s::: .~
(I) -
~ r..: 8;'::::
(I) rn
- -
o..:.õ
0 8 .-
~ -~
CZJ Ú M
0..
.
.
"'O~ -
Q) Q) Q) s:= Q) -
73 Q) 0 1;j "'0 "U ·s ..r:= Q)
~..r:= ro ~Q)Q) +->..r:=
o +-> gf ~ '.... t +-> Q) ,........, ~ +->
r:J) ~ '.... s:= t:j 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 ~
..r:=0 ¡:::0r:J)~Q)0.. U ...- r:J)0
+-> Q) I C r:J) '.... ;> Q) I-< r:J) r:J) 0 ..r:= "
s:= ....r:J)s:=1-<0 Q)..D +->""+->
o 1;j ,-::: t8 Õ ~..... r:J) ~ "'0 '.p Cd s:= 1;j '....S
"<::< r.. ¡::: 1-<..... - 0 Q) <.i-< Qj..... r:J) 0 r..
,.:::¡ ~ C Q) +-> ~ +-> '.p Cd t;::::.::: Cd "<::< ~
....: Q) Q) 0.. Cd s:= ~ '¡j t:j +-> ,.:::¡ Q) Q)
~ ~ .::: p... ,S ..g> 'õ ?:> ~ "'0 ~ ~ ~ \0 .::: p...
~ s:="U ~r:J)~~::; Qj+::i a s:="U
~ '.... ~ Q) ~ s:= r:J) ~ t;:::: ~ ~ :E ~
.~ 73 <.i-< ¡:o s:= 0 ~ ~ d ,s:=§ .-::: <.i-<
f""\ ..... ~ '......, I-< ¡:¡ ~ ~
""'I ~ Q) '.... 0 P
t¡ P s:= c./::"'O
§-
... Q) Q)
§. ~..r:= 73
¡¡;: s:= s:= +->
-..;¡ . .... '€ "'0 "'0 "'0 0
... "'01-<_00"'00 § +-> ¡:::
~ Q)OQ)o..rooro ~ a
~ :-9r:J)§~"'OroQ) 13 Cd I-<
::: !:)S:=o_~~U +-> t:j gp
I::t r:J) 0 r:J) Cd..... s:= ~ g "'0 I-<
.1:::: Q)·.p1-<.þQ):':::0 "'0 - 0..
.::! "'O~ ~ 8.. ~ ~ 0.. r:J) s:=.~ s:=
..... r:J) s:= "" I-< ¡::: Q) 0...... 0
~ Q)s:=:9u~r:J)a73 U "'0 '.p
~ ~oQ)Q)tr:J) r:J) 0 .s
IIU "'0 U t;:::: bo 0 s:= cÞ s:= ro .....
_ Q) +-> _ ...... 0.. 0 '.... 0 - ::::
~ U '.... - .... Q)..... +-> '.... Q) ..D
IIU 0 .~ Cd '¡¡j 1-<.-::: s:= 1;j s:= Cd
~ 1-<::::::1-< s:="'OQ) ~ s:= ..r:=
~ 0.. '.... 0 Cd 0 "'0 "'0 ..... 0 Q)
... ~ tH ~ Cd '.... +-> r:J) 73 I-<
~ ~0r:J)0§"..r:=s:=~ ~ ~ bb
~ ..... ,........, r:J) s:= ~ 0 ;> 0.. Q) s:=
~ 1;j ~ 8 0 13 ::; '.p ,S - 1;j 'S
::: ~ Q) o·.p r:J) 0 U Cd U ro C!5
.S:: 'f! ~ ~ ~ ~ 13 ~ ~ ,9< :.a ~ s:=
_ ~. ~ ""'" L.. Q) +::i U s:= 0
I::t Q) 0 ~ ,::P r--' "'0 ~ '8 ..... ~ '.p
~ 6r:J)S:=r:J)C!5 ,- 0 3» ¡:;u
'';:: '.... Q) '.p .£ t '00' ;g r:J) d Cd 0 Q)
~ .... .... I-< .... 0 ,-,,'+-> +-> ¡:; d '.p s:=
'Iù .... ':;:I 0 Q) Q) ..... "3 ¡:¡ U s:=
È ~ Q) ~..r:= ~ ~ ,S , r:J) ~ 1;j 8.. 0
-..;¡ "'0 1;j 1-<'::: I-< ~ ~ S ~ ..... ..r:= r:J) Y
§s:=Q)....::::::..r:=0Q) I-<+-> S:=r:J)
~ t:j ..... 73 § Cd ~ "S ::ö ~ ê' ~ ': cg
I::t ¡::: r:J) ~..... '.... 0 +-> I-< ..... Q) I-<
~ +->CQ) S:="'001-< ~ 0..,-::: :;.U
.. ~ s:= Q) N f::::..... ~ ,.... 0.. 0 A - ¡;> I-<
~ ~ Q) +->..... ~ s:= ~ ..... Cd '.... Q)
.~ S "'O§ 'Cds "'0 'g :9 ~ ~ ~ Q) ,~ r:J) ~
f""\ Q) Q) +-> :::::: +::i +-> ~ +-> ..... ?:- Q)
""'I õ.. U s:= ..... Q) 0 Cd I-< a r:J)
ø ~ ,§ :E' & ~.~ ] § ~ p...~ .g ~ ''8 S
o ~ ~ s:= ....... I-< U c./:: '8 Q) ~. ro 0
... s:= oo::t.... Q) ¡:; oo::t r:J) +->
g:!;. o~CZJ ~t8 ~ª:.::: ~ .s SCZJ ~
L.. ~ 'B .; ::E 'g Þ ~ ~ ~ < ~ .s ::E è
r--' ..... +-> » ::> ..... +-> ~ ~ I-; r:J) ::.-. .s
~ "'0 ~ +-> :::: Q) r:J) 0 ~ +->' .....
~::: 'C s:= §:to;::-9 1;j 9< "U ,0 ~ § 0
~ I::t ;::! .S .~ r:J) ~ .... Q) r:J) U +-> g!
~ ~ ......, 1;j Uo õ.. s:= '.p Q) !:: s:= ~ s:= Uo »
~ IIU ~ U ><: 0 r:J) U 0 0 s:= ..... 0
ø ~ ~ :.::: ..r:= Q) ~ ~ ~ U -5 'B 'S ~..r:= ~ ro
..,04 I::t '.... 0.. U ~ Q) s:= 0 0 Cd Cd 'g.... U '.p
........:::: :E A Cd 0 I-< '.... r:J) +-> Q) +-> .þ .S Cd :.::: gf
~ ~ Cd Cd ~ ~ ~ oí) ~ s:= s:= s:= n ,-::: ~ '.p '¡::
.,.¡ 0.. N ""'" ........... .... +::i 0 '.... Q) .::: "'0 ""'" """"' Q)
f""\ ..... d Q) +-> ..... '.p ~ S "'0 s:= d >-';>
""'I .~ ¡:¡ S Q) S ~ U Q) 0 0 ¡:; U 0
~.1:::: § ]a 'Cd 0.. ~ Q).S Cd ~ U .¡:: U 'Cd :.::: U
þoio4.::! ....... p... 0..r:= ~ U +-> ~ Q) t p... ..D §
~;:::: S~Q)Qj_~f:!5 ~ 0..0Q) æ
E-- -..;¡ ...... +->..r:= ;>:::: +-> d "Cd o....d s:=
..,04 ....... +-> Q) :;. "'0 » ¡:; r:J) "" +-> Q) +::i Q) .....
...... ~ g.S 0 "'0 ¡;> - :::::: Q) Cd s:= s:= I-< 0 ..r:= r:J)
:> oC:) Q)" +-> Q) ..r:=.~ Cd ~ ,,0 Q) "'0 +-> ~ t:j
¡;¡;.- ....... r:J)..r:= u...... U 0 "" d 0 r:J) .... '....
~. s:= ~ Q) +-> ..... ~ ..... tH "'0 0.. ¡:; ro Q) .... r:J)
t-- :§ ~..r:= ~ 0 1;j 5 '> 7 ~ cÞ ~ ë ~
..... C\ ~ r:J) S 0 ~ ê'..... C\ Q) ..r:=
o ~ CZJ..r:= ::; "S ~ Q) ,S d:: 0 ¡:¡"S ..r:= - U
L.. Q) ~ 0..... r:J) t:j ~ ::::::...... Q) ~ 0.. :E
r--' , ..d ......:E! 0 Q) » Q) . 0 ' "'0 ..... S:;.
CZJ Cd +::i "'0 +-> 0.. I-< r:J)..D ..D tH U . .... "'0 ...... ¡;>
.
·
Q ~~
F Q ~ .:a Q
't'tt " ~ '" ß "" ~~
'¥¡\t ~ "" 'i1 ~ j¡ ~ % ,% ~
,"/:0 ¢¢ tf)o"ÖQ Q ....
",:,:~:, ...... ."'" " Q º" Q' "a .>-\
¡¡¡¡,jO, '" 0 ß ';.. ~ '" 1!. 'ô 1:1 <ß p%
F'Ã.a Q' ç. f£ ¢ t/1 ',p
~ '.. ,'."',' ç. ~ .... ° ,>-\ t/1 \ ....
Ji!t'1' '" .~ 't: 0 ,P 0" '" '" \Qpo.
,', ","".', ,.,"".'. 0 p 'ê 'p oJ).... 'p _.o-! :~
~'ø'~ " " ß.;g..¡; ~''Å '" J?: ~ t)
....: ~""",' ,'".,'. \ '? po. ¢...-\ ° ..;..\ ..-"I ~
'= ~'I ,~ ,~" "" "" 2
"'" ~¡''>~ l ~ ~ 'ð ~ r'à ~ µ;l
Q
:à' j;piit µ¡ .~ ".~ 0
~ :<~ ç. ~
-
~
% Q
- ~A Q
~ .~ ~ -ò -ò {j
...... ..-"I~~~~ ~
-
~ ~ø-ò~Q f;<$
~ Q Q -ò
~ .-"I,?,,,," ~
~ o ~ ~ .>-\ -P.. ~
'= ~~~ï~~ ~
"'"
- opo.ø~t/1~ ~
....
u .~ -ò Q t/1
.... Q..-"I "t:.~"" °
-
- QQQ ç.~ Q
...... ~ ~ 'Õn 0 ° ,..-\ ~
~ ...... ç. % ,,-! ....
~ 8 '"a'fj} ~ ~ ~ ,g
-
u
~ ~ '5 ~ 0 ~ ,>-\ f;<$
~ Q~""" po. " oj)
..... o? .J:; ¢ ,~
,;:::;t/1 0 tf)
V). ..... 'ß ç. -ò ~...-\ Q
~ ¢......Q~Qot) '?
o 0 0·.... if¡ 0 ç
'p /"":' ""' ~ ~ p ~ ,....
~ ~~ po. ~~ ~ ~
Q 'p' g ~ 'fj} J, . ~ ....
....
-
'= 'ß ~.~ ~ t:. ~ 'p. ~
.~ '? ° ° ° Q''a if¡
- ç t/1 º" ~ % on·>-\ á ~
"'"
~ ,.... Q ø .... ~ \<1...... ~
~ -ò~~-ò"""~o~ 'ß
'ð Q~'"a(.)"".e ~
\ 11£ .ß "".~ .¡; 0 "
- t/1 ç.;.o ~ ""' .Þ
'= ~ ~ Q .>-\.... po. ....
"'" tf) .~.>-\ ~ ç...... Q Q ......
~ Q .... --a "Ö '~ .~ A A °
c.. Ç;OßQ....';:::;........ r
.~ ø.... Q ç. ,.... Q
~ a -ò ° ''a -ò ~ t$ ç¿
- %y~ Po ¡; % £ .S ~
0 ~
~ % .~ ~~ ~ $ ~ ~ ~ >¡¿
-
~ ~ ~ ~ '$ '~ ~ ø ~ 0 .¿
í- ...... .~ "'?;: ,~1\ '" ~ \
~ t)..... ~ ~,J:J ~ ? (.) J,
~ ..... QQ..... 01) Q ç.
~ "d .... 0 ~ '8'~ ° þ 0
¡ '= .$. ¿: C) p. 0 Q 0 'p
"'" ~o ~º"Q~(.) U
~ ,.-, 'p' ~ ø t/1 ~ 0 Q ~ ~
~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ ,... t/1.... (.) ~
'= t/1(.) "oP ~ø
-= Q~o.....ßoJ).:ao Qa
~ u 'p p.. ~ ç ç. ,,;.!
.~ ~ ~ ,g %. o·a oj) ~ ,~g
~ ,9' M ~ p.. ~ ß '%.... ~ '5
- .~ ~ po. ~ ~ tl ~ ~ \ ~
~ ....
u ~ oo';:::;t/1t:1a ø
....
- a po. {j t'~ -ò ;?;: Q ç.
-
~ ...... QO-O ~'"aB. <no
- ~-B....Q-5~QO ~
~ ~ ~ ç. 'ß -B '$ ~ '~ ~ Q
r.:. Q ,>-\ on ~ ~ ~ ø "Ó
~ \<1 oP ~ ¢ ....
~ ;;) ~ ~ .$? ''S'o ~
(.) 0 ,... t/1 <n ° ~
~~~~~..o po.
~
.
~ ~
:'> ~,..¡:: .......
<oS ~ ..... ~ ~ ~
" ",' ',',',', ,..¡:: 4-< oS"'¡:: oS
.......~15c:::: 04-< c:::: 4-<
~ 0.. <J) 0 ~ 0 0 0
..oS~..... ~~..... ~ ~.....
=r;;¡ ¡:: ~ '.... § ~ ..... ~ .....
~.,.,.¡;>,.. 0 Q § ~ Q § Q §
e.Ø' ~ ~ æ ~ ~ æ ~ æ
~>e.. \0 ..... ....... '.... .....
..i-;..:è"; ,."',.',,.'.,..',.:,',.,"','.',',,',., .... .......... .... .....
....1:.:.: ", ,,": ,.... u ¡:: u , .... u
..'.'.....',..'..,.,., '. i3 ~ '.... ~ i3 ~
~~ ~~ ~~
.......
ro I-<
'.... 0
~ tH
~ t-<
Õ p:::
0.. 0
~ :l.,
~ ~
~ ..go ~
~ ï§ ~
~ >. ~
~ ....... ~
~ ~ z
~ .~ z
~ (:) -< <J)
§ ~ ~ ~
... ~ ~ ~
~ 0 ~ ,..¡::
.S: ..... c:r ~
=: <J) ~ ._
~ ~ .D "0
;.. ~ 2 ."=
~ "0 ~. u
... ~ ~ '....
Q.¡ g oS S
- I-< -
:::: 0.. ¡:: 0
~ "0 ' ;;; "E!
I § ~ 0
_ ~ u
~ <J) "0 ,..¡::
too) c ~ u
.. ~ Æ U :E
~ ~ 0.. 8 :>
.... <J) 0.. ...
~ ¡:: ~ ~ >-
... 0 ,..¡:: U ~
r;J ~ '.g c:::: § ~
o ~ I-< 0 ¡:: 0
¡::z:: ... 8. :.au
~ ~ ~ ~ 0-5
~ ~ urIi ~ ¡::~
z ~ ¡:: I-< 0
~ ~ ~ .s ..;:: :O
~ ~ ~ ro <J) U S
~ ~ ~ ~ ro E -
~ ~ S ~ ~ 0 ro
r.. ~ ~ U "0"": I-< :l.,
~ ~ ..... ro ~ ..... :l., ¡::
<~ '5 ~1î û§ ~:9i3
.~ S <J) ,S ~ \0 ~ ':::.'
~ ~o ~o.. ¡::;a~
~ ............ ~ ~ 0....... <J)
¡::z:: ·ti S' ~ ~ oS 'B ~ S
.... '.... OJ) ¡:¡ 0 ~ ~
~ E:! "0 ~ g. ~ CZ)..8 ~
L" C"'¡:: ............ ¡::..... ~
< ro U ~ ¡:: ..... <J)
~ ~ 0.. .~ ~ 0 13.s ~
. ~"O "O~ .D ~~
~ t-- ~ 15 I-< I-< .¡:: ~ ~
>CI:I ~o u"'¡::"O
~..... ¢:: e- <J) "0 ¡::
o Q~ -<0 ~-<~
~ ,õ . U . .8
CZ) U 0.. "O.S ~ t.¡..¡ ~ OJ) OJ)
. '
.
("<)
~ -
...s::: ~
-...s:::
4-<-
04-<
en 0
..J::i ~ .
E ~ .t::
o Q ê
::s~~
00 .e: ~
-t
...s:::~
.t:: 4-<
~~
en
S
~
.......
..D
o
I-<
p..
4-< ~
o .;3
~ '"C:I
~ ê
~
en en
~ ~
p.. ~ -
~.:-s! s::
...s:::-.:r u ~
. -t:Jj s:: ;:j
::: 4-< '0:::< '...... c:r
~ o~ ~ ~
~ gfþ 8. ~
So 'ۤ ~ ~
.::: 0 0 0 ~
~ p..u - -
~ ~...s::: ~ s::
I.,¡ U U 0 .......
:.:::: '...... tI:I...s::: ~
~ ....... ~ æ
~ ..g~!:f I-<
Q.,. p.. S 4=< gf
I ~....... ~ I-<
_ ~ tI:I.... p..
!::I _ ~ 0
~ :.=: ~ .~
.. ~ '...... ~ 0' .......
~ ~ g - 0 gf ..g
.~ c+.::¡ 0 .............. p..
~ '"C:I ~ B §p.. ~
r~'" C ....... _ ...s:::
'wi ~ tI:I en tI:I -
o ~ ~....... ...s:::'"C:I 4-<
ÞJ ¡: ~ .~ ~ ~ 0
.... B. . ...... I-< OJ:J?:>
~ æ: ]~]~ æ
E-c ~ ..g S ..g~ ~
Z ~ p.. 4-< p.. '"C:I
~::: ~ 0 ~ c
~!::I ~ ....... ...s::: tI:I en
~ 1'.1 - tI:I _ en -
~ ~ 0 en ~ '"
~ ~ S 8. ê ~ .g
-<!::I 8.~ c.8 ...s::: ;:j
~ .::: p.. '"C:I s:: u Û
I.,¡ 0 I-< ....... en s::
.~ - ~ '"C:I;';:: '......
~ ~ p.. ........... ~
.... 0 ;:j .t:: ~
ÞJ _ I-< 0 U ~
.... I.,¡ I-< p.. ...s::: '...... d
r_'.... OJ:J den:::::: ¡:¡
_ ~ 0 ¡:¡ '...... ~
~ ~ I-< ....... ~ -
L" p.. '"C:I æ .;3 .£
-< --.. tI:I C I-< ....... ~
~ ~ p..tI:I gf~ ~
~. O~ I-<'"C:I '"C:I
t-- ~ OJ:J p.. 2 I-<
;> I-< ~ tI:I ~
~ C\3 ...s:::....... ¢::
2 Q '5 E-< g <t::
L" en en
t:Jj :.a ..D ~ Ù
, '
·
'<:t
......
CI) CI)
.;3.;3
<+-<<+-<
o 0
<IJ CI)
.;3 1d .~
§ Q §
"':::' CI) CI)
,.,::;>~
M ',p
u
:€~
~~
'<:t .....
CI)
~
CI)
~ <IJ
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~
~ <IJ
~
~
è>
.s
....
~ ~
~ ,-
~ ~
~ :;:::
~ S
~ u
.~ .-
~ -
.s ~
.~ ~ vj
.... s:: ª
"'4 CI) .....
I 8 OS)
- ~ 0
~ .....
~ A
.. ~ A _
~ ~ CI) ....
-< .~ Q ,g
~ ~ Õ
r~ ... .g
~ ~ CI)
o ~ .....
~ ... s::
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ro
Z ~ ~
~ ~
~ ~ s::
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
ø ... 0
-< ~ 1§
~ <:.J ,-
~ ~~
~ ȧ
~ ;';::: Us::
~ .<:.J "' 0 ~ ~ ~~
~ ~ .;3~
-< ~ ~~
:> ~ CI).D
'" 8 ro
~ ~ ~~
~ A~
o ~,~
~ ~A
00 ...... ~
, '
·
V)
.....
Q)
oS Q)
Q)Q) t+-<oS
oS oS 0t+-<
t+-<t+-< ClIO
00 oSQ)....
ClI s::= 1i:i .....
oS~.~ ~oê
sOE oo~æ
~ ~ ~ ......~
00 .~ s::= g
..... U ..... !<=i
...s:::Q) oS<.+-i
.... !:8 ..... ~
..... ~ ~
~
~
=:
.~ "1:j ê t+-<
.... Q) 0
~ t+::: >. "1:j ....
o:u .... 00.. cO
~ .~:::::: t1 0 è'd s::=
~ ~ '" 'õ 0 ..,. ¡¡
.~ :g,9 0 '" '" ..,
~ ..... 0 ~ ~.....
~ Q) ~-Q) ~:-;::::
--. oS...s::: CO >. U
~ Q) .... c; .... ,~
'" Q) u'~ I-< s::= ......
~ .~ ã :> !! g 'õ
." 'E.- ~ 0 ü .¡;
~ 0 p. ¡j 0 ~
I::) '¡:: S è'd.~ ....s::: ;::S
~ ..,. ~ Po o:=: ~ '" ¡¡~
... "'~" OPo~ ~~"
¡¡ ::E .¡¡ ~ .S § 8. I§ <Q :"
.. ~'" '" ~ 0", .s s~
~ oS >. CO ¡a . ~ ~ ~ -;.....
o:u .... s::= ClI ,-... "" ....
.... 0 :.::: '.... >. s::= ~ 0.. ~ s::=
·10 ;; .- ~ ~ 0 0.. ~ ~ .:J
~ .- ¡¡ 3J ;s ¡J z ~,9 ._
.... CO <.¡;.::¡ I-< t+-< Q) Q) ,8 >.
;, " "" 0 .- " > ".9 '"
...... '.... ClI ClI s::= c; ..., c;
~ i:? .¡:: ò;j 0 "" 8. ~ "
c; .... U 0 ClI '.... 0
=: ...s::: ........ CO .... .... s::= CO '~
I::) u CO s::= ..... ..... '-' .....
.... ClI .~..... Q) U "1:j. Q) c; "1:j
.... '.... ,.¡;;¡ I-< .... :.::: Q) "....., ...s::: "1:j
8 "1:j ...s::: S .g :-;:::: .!:: 2 oS u c;
~ ClI U '.... 0 ;::S,~ t+-< ClI "-
Q) c; s::= 0 cr' ~, '.... ..-.
.'" ..,~ 0 ~~~~ 0 "'ã
=: :.::: ...s::: d ClI, I-< 0 ~ ClI
o:u ..... U ¡::¡ Q) CO ClI _ Q) t+-<
.. '" 0 .- ~ .., oJ._ ã ~ ~ 0
~.., .s -5' Z :=: ~ >._ ¡¡ ~ f-<
' "":> '" . G .." Po ~ 0 '"
~ .~ 0 'ê .s ~ 'iJ ~ Jj ~ 0
" ~;; > 5b '" .8 ~ ~ 0..
,,~ "" . - '" -i:I 0 "';; bJ) 1;! '-'1
~,¡¡ :Ë q 11 ;; s. -š!! .g ~ 0::
0..... bJ) .2 ~ .iJ '" ~ 5 I§ ~
f-<'!¡ .S ~ § :.<: '" '" Po a .9 ~<r:
Z ~ 1;;.'J.., '" ~ "§ 3 ~
~ ..... c; c; Q) ê è'd.... U _
¡.¡.. "~~ ,,".. '." 0 .
~.... Q) t: ..... ~..... "1:j .~
~..... -Q) 0 ~o....::::::...".¡::¡
¡'¡'" 'õ ¡¡ '" !J 1;; !J 0 Õ ~ ""
"." ....."'" '" ~ S Po - '" u
~ ~ 0 ~._ ._"" ~ ~ _ "",
...... ~ ;::¡ -= t+-< +;i I-< Q) c; ..... Q)
~ - Q ClI Q 0 t+-< '.... 1i:i e _ s::=
.S! 0 "1:j '¡:: ClI 0 6- ~ Q) -; .....
a... ....c 0 S::=ClIQ) .... t+-<Q),
.... s::=è'd.... 0....1-<s::= s::= 0"!:::"1:j
~ Q) - ClI ..... U t:..... '" Q)
0:: ~ ~ :E:E ¡¡ 8. §.9 ã .1'3 "8..1'3
~:::: '........ s::= 0.. ClI.~ ClI _ ;::S-
f-<.... ã g 0 '¡j ~ ~.."1 '" .~ '" ã..Q
-<:...,. Po ~ go .s '-" ¡;¡, '" ;; .S ~ ~
"".. 0 "" '" "" ".¡:: ~ 0 .~ S '" 0
.... - ~ ~ ~ '60 Po ~ 0.. '. ,,~ ._
::;: 00 !! <þ ~ .¡:: ~ e :> Z ::E .¡¡¡ 'õ ~
i2 )¿ ."@ <Q "" <Q Po" ~ . ::E.S s.
O ~"' co .o..>¿:; "1:j
"" . '.... U c; ;> ~
E-- cd :9 ..c ...s:::
rJJ
,
·
,...:¡
<: <t
~g
~~
,~ 0
µ.,P-.
.s ~
.g
.....
;>
0
~
r.;
.~
~
.....
~
'=
~
..::c
.~
~
..:::
.~
~
...
~
~
....
...
.s
....
:::
.. ~
~ .......
I Cd
~ 0..
.....
~ u
~ '....
0 ::: ~
==
~ ~
=-- ..::c -Ë
~ .~
~ ~ t+-;
..::: 0
:?J .~ ~
~ ~
~ ~ ~
-< :::
~ ~
....
.5;! Cd
.::: .g
~ ~ .....
;>
~ '= 0
~ I-<
~ 0..
~ r¡j
-:-- ~ ~
....... .....
oC:) ~:E
~ QÔ u .....
'.... u
õ..c.S
0 ª,ëd
~ ~ 'B
rI1 I-< rn
~ ::;
~]
,
.
( ) ( ) ( ) ~
o5~ o5( ) o5( )
~~ ~o5 ~o5
o~ o~ o~
~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 0
+-> ( ) +-> +-> ( ) +-> +J ( ) +->
s::= ~ ,- s::= ~ .- s::= ~ ._
°o!3 °o!3 °o!3
::E( )( ) ::E( )( ) ::E( )( )
",";>P-. ",";>P-. ",";>P-.
N 'P N .p N .p
s::= U s::= U s::= U
'0:::1 ~ ,- ~ ,;:::: ~
o:¡S<.+-< o5<.+-< ~<.+-<
.- ~ .- ~ .- ~
~ ~ ~
o .
+-> ~
. ~ ( )
~ ~ã ~
,., > 0$3 +->~
.... ;> ~ ::s .- OJ)
::: ( ).-....... s:= s::=
r~ t) s::= 2; Õ t:: ._
"'-'I ( )........ vA ( );>
~ v < P-.'-
- c. ( ) ( )
~ ( ) èd "0 U N U
~ ...c:: ~Q) ::s t ~
.... +-> ~~ ] tijO
~ 05 'o:::'( ) 1-0 P-.+->
... ':::;:'..,::¡ ...c:: ~
~ ~ ~+-> B ~d
'r ( ) '-'S::= s::= +->èd
::: U ~ ,- 0 s::= +->
.... C ( ) ~ ,- ,_ ::s
~ èd U ~ +-> .......
..::.. ;":::.p ( ) ~ "0 Õ
~ A U s::= ,þ ~ A
::: S ~ ~ ~.¡:: ( )
~ 0 ~ P-. ,- s::= U U
["""" +-> 0 ~ ::s
~ U ~ d~ UU ( )"O
10.. ~ 0 ( )~ 8 OJ) "O~
.5 ~ P-. S ( ) A.S::= ~ 0
\,J s::= ~ ( )t) ti3§ c+->
¡: ( ) P::: ~ 0 ;> "0 èd ,$
~ B ~ § U 8ti3 Ã8
"0 <r:: '0:::'] A;>.......d
~ ( ) ~..,::¡ èd ê' 0 8 0
b.o ~ t);>-. 1-0 dU
( ) ( )U "00.. .......
.. .~ .;;= ~ ~ § ê' 8 èd
~ ::: ~ +-> ti3 'c:) ~ OJ) d B
-< ~ ( ) ~ ~ S .~ ,s::=~ ~ 2
~ ~ 8::s "0 ( ) ~ ~ .s t)
rÞOl ~ ~ 0'" 2 1-0 - 1-0 "0 I
'" .1::: c ( ) ,-.... ....... ( ) s:::::
o ~ èd ~ +->( ) 1-0 +->0.. ~o
~ I Ã .g 605 tS ~.E "Os::=
~ ~ ( ) ~ 0 ~ ~ S '¡¡j § ]
E--4 ~ o5...c:: s::= ,- ~ g. s::= s::= èd
..,... ::: ~ g "0 s:= .s ....... 0 0 .......
ti == ~ ( ) c t:: ,- ( ) .p ,- èd
- ~ ( ) èd ( ) ::s ;> U ~ ~
~ """I ,~s::=.......+-> ~ ( )2 O;:J
~ ~ ~.- èd .g "0 "0 +-> ~ "0
t; ~ .§ g B B § .~ ~ ~ Ë
-< ::: +-> ~ 2( ) tS ~8 +->~
..,... .~ 2u ~o +->k; ( )8 ~( ) 8~
fO'-< - ~ 0 .... 1-0 1-0.-
~ \,J t) s::= ;> -Qj ,- 0 ::s
¡: s::= 0 ~ ( ) ...c:: 1-0 6- 0'"
.... 0 'p._;>-. U A ( ) ~ ~
~ ~ U.s ~ ( ) ;E S 1-0 "0 ...c::
r_' ~ 1-0 s::=..... ..d > O...c::. c U
- u tS ( ) O+J ;> UU~ èd;E
E:: ~ E1 § ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "!:: ~
....... ........, ...c::;3 .- ~ 0 +->;> èd ....
~ ~ +-> cñ 15 .E,~ 05 ;>-. ( ) ~ Š §
~ . ~ ( ) "0 èd OJ) +-> 0.E OJ) ( ) ._
Q'\ ::s::S::S0 A Ã+->s::= .......+->
~ 0'" ( ) ti3 ....... 0 c::! '-ê ,- A ~
s::= ,- ~ ;> 0 "0 ¡;;¡ ;> S .-
o ~ .Ê ;> ~ .Ê < ~ 'Q) - Ã
~ U 0 U 0 U A
["""" . ( ) 1-0 '( ) . ~u ( ) ~-"""
íf1 ~ +-> P-. U +-> "0 ...... 1-0 N '"
I'
~ ~ ~ ~
-s~ -s~ -s~
~-s ~-s ~-s
o~ o~ o~
~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 0
....~.... ....~.... ~O....
§ 8 .§ § 8 .§ § 8 '§
:::E ~ ~ :::E ~ ~ :::E ~ ~
~>~ ~>~ ~>~
N~ N~ N~
s:: C,) s:: C,) s:: C,)
..... ~ "~~ ..... ~
-s~ ~~ -s~
..... ~ '.... ~ ..... ~
~ ~ ~
s:: _
o s:: ~ s:: s:: 0
N·,¡j 0 ,t:: 0 0 ~ .tJ
~C,)2ã ~~ã ~§
_ ::SC,)_ C,)
~~~ ~2~ s::
~S:: """.... 01::
..s::: 0 s:: ~ en s:: '.... ~
....C,)o t::S::0 ~d
.~ "'\,1 0·...... ...., ~
,S ~ 1:: ~ C,) 1:: .E ~
..s:::..s:::~ "O~~ en~
.t:: .... > c ..s::: > s:: en
~~~ ~~~ 0"0
~ '.... ~ .... ~ ~ C,) ã
~å)S:: 5-sc ~
:> .s S OJ).s ~ §
, t:: ~ c t:: '+:: '....
00 en"::: OJ)..... ..::: en
~- ~~- 00
~ "0 0 s:: ~' 0 .... """
..s:::o~ ~"""~ """~
. ....C,)""" d~""" ~"O
.... c ~ ¡;;;¡ > ~ "0 ~
= ..... "0 .... """ ~ .... 0""" >
~ "Oc~ ~"O~ 0
a ~~~ ~::s~ .::.::"""
~ ..0 en :>_ """ 0..
CJ ï::::8~ ~g~ oª,
;.. C,)s::t:: ~>-4t::. ::..
cS en~o t:: 0 ~ ;:>~
= .g ,S û) .8 ¡:j û) S g. -s
~ ~ "0 ~ en ~ ~ '.... .... ..d
en """ .... " C,) (/) ~
"t:S 1:) 0 ~ s:: 0 ~ ~ '~
= ~"",,> ~"",,> 0.. ~~
~ .õ' B ~ ~ 0.. ~ ~ "0 ~
.. ~ ~~en C,)§en:':: ãg
~.... ~ s:: "'"..... S::...,-j .... ~
- s:: 0 "".... 0 ~ .... '....
CJ 0 ~ ..... c C,) '.... """ 0 "'5.
~ '.... t:: ~ "¡:: ~ ~ 0 ',¡j d
0.. 1:) 0_ ~ 0.._ 4=< ~ ¡;;;¡
ø rei) 2~::s >~::s.... ÕO
O = _ OJ) 0..... OJ) ~ '.... C,)
~ ~~~ C,)~~ ~ :>s::
¡:z::: I s:: C,) p::: .... ..s::: p:::,.:.:¡ ~ .....
~ = 0.£ """ .~ .... """ ~ 0 ¡g
Q C,) ~ - ~ ~..s::: s::
E-- = """ ..s::: t:: .::.:: N t:: C,) ~ .....
Z 0 .... w C,) '.... ''" C,) tIS
= 4=< ..... ::.. ~ "0 ::.. "0 .,¡j S
~ ¡:z:::~;:> ..s:::~;:> ~ 0
:?J ~ ~8ã ~]ã..9' ~g
~.... "''' s:: 0 0 ~ 0 ~ '"
r.. 00 "" ~ .... '.... .... .... > OJ) 0 .
~ 8~(/) 1:) en(/) ~ S::"Oen
-< ~ 0.. g. (/) g, .8 (/) "0 ·S .Q §
Z ~ s:: ¡;;;¡ ~ en """ ~ ,en en "0 ',¡j
~ CJ 0 0 ,.... s:: ~ ,....'~ en ~ '...
...... = ..... C,)..... ..... "0 ..... ~ ..... .... "0
:?J.:: 1:)~z~ "O~~z ~ È~§
rei) ~~ ~ 0 0..C,)
~ ~ ~ ¡g ~ ~ .S ~ ~ § ~ ,t::
L. U '.... ~ -s ã ¡g....,::s ',¡j..s::: ~
['""' ~ 0 ¡;;;¡ 0 en ~ C,) C,) t::
-< ..s::: 0 .... ( ) .... ~..d ~,~ ~
~ ~ ............ ,p........d ~ O..~~~
.... ~ C,) ............ C,) ¡;;;¡ en -
- .... s:: ~ ~ s:: ~ ',¡j 1:: s:: "0
~. 5 0.= 0 '= - ~ '... en s::
Q'\ S '.g .g g.',¡j .g ~ s ~ ~ ~
~C,)en _C,)en.... ~ ~t::en
O - '.... ~ ~ ~ - 0 '" ~
0..- en . > 0.. en 0.. tH """
E-- do..~~ ~en~~ d s::~
r#\ ¡;;;¡ 0.. ,t:: ,t:: ,.... s::.t::.t:: ¡;;;¡ rT' 0..0 f¥"\
"''' >-4 ~ en en .......... en en >-4 __
,
.
~ 00
;9~ .....
c+-;_
0c+-;
(J) 0
;9~_
s::: 1i:i'-
° Q ê
::8~~
'<:t;>P-.
C"I ';::J
s::: (.)
:.E~
-~
. - ¡.L¡
~
v.i
"0
0
;9
~
S
E
~
S
~
e
c2
s:::
~
"0
~ 1ä
~ (J)
;:$ ~
~ .g
'-
-
~
c ~
~ (.)
0
.... I-<
~ 0..
s:::
~ 0
,-
-
~ (.)
~
~ 0..
(J)
~ s:::
,-
~ E
::: ~
':::I ~
::: v.i
.c ~ 0..
~ .g ~
~ Q
~ ~ OJ)
(.) s:::
~ 0 .-
I-< "0
I 0.. -
.-
~ s::: ;:s
0 ¡:Q
c .-
::: - ..s:::
(.)
:::! ~ ~
~ 0..
(J) ~
~ s::: ¡:Q
,-
1;) "0 ~
::: ~ I-<
- -
.c ;:s ~
.:::: "0 Q
~ ~
:::! ..s::: J3
~ (.)
(J)
~ E E
:::
ð ~ ~
s S
--:-. ~ ~
- -
oC:I S- o..
Q\ S
....... .......
,
.
0'1
.......
Q)
.s
C+-;
o E-<
Q)- "J
tij '.... ~
o§ 0
Q) Q) p.,
,¡:: p., ~
-
U
~
c.¡...¡
µ,:¡
§ ë:
o Q).s a
t) S..... :3
M 8 ~ ~
Q) M U
p.. 0 ~ .....
~ ~ ,9 ~ '
.....Q)<:t:1 u~
S::Q)Q) -00
0.sQ) Q)ü
rn ;> _ Q)
M s:: '.... s:: p..
Botij ~rn
U -0 M ¡:¡ s::
Q) c Q) Q) '....
p..èdp.. --0
.s ~ 8 .§ §
-0 'r;) ,..¡::: ;>-. ~
§§gf ~~
~ ~ ] ê .~
B g - ::3 ~
~.þ-O UM
. Q)rnQ);>-.C
~ p..s::~ ct'iS
.== 0 o.~ èd "E..
... u_ C+-;
.S 2 M t'iS 0 elf
~ '.... 0 rn M
a... rnt.¡;;,Q) co
t:- C rn.D 0 '::::
~ 0 ..... ,~
a... ..... p., ;>-. Ã ~
~ ü ~ t'iS r.ñ .¡:: p..
.. r::: ~N'\SQ) uO
~ a... ¡:, ~..... rn
~ ~ t)-ë:~ Q)2
-< ~ c 8 Q) s:: -0 'r;)
~ C 8ë:SQ) Q)c
~ ~ C 0 ~ -g .s ,9
o ~ ·8 ~ 'S ü E-<~ ü
~ I .þ~cr't'iS ~Ë
~ ~ BS~E ~ Om
~ ~ ~ :.a.~ 0 Cd p., c
Z == Q)"'¡:::u M ~o
:::t L.. M OD U
;¡i¡ Mrn.-.O 0 M
~ I:< ODd¿ 'rn M ,...:¡ 0
~ ~ 0 Q) Q) p.. ...... t.¡;;,
;¡i¡ .1:: ~ § g 'u Q), ~...... '00'
~ ~ t'iS ..... èd s:: .s ,,,= '-'~
== rn·.... Q) C+-; s::
-<z ~ ë:8~f o¡:: M
.::: Q)Q)¡:¡ cQ) OD
-< ~ S -0 0 .~ 0 p.. 0
~ :::t Q) C U - '.... Q) M
~ .::: - èd Q).D Ã,..¡::: p..
,.., foooJ ê- _ _;::s '¡:: - s::
"""" == ¡:¡s::,Sp.. uO 0
;¡i¡ ~ ..... Q)..... rn ë: '....
c...... U -0 S:::: Q) '.... tij
["""' C Q) U -0 U
-< ......... t'iS OD..s t'iS s:: ~
> .~ ,.., t'iS 0 ~ .....
í' " ..... C 0 Q) .;:J Q) 1::
0èd- "'Ót'iS-o
~ a\ ã) S Õ '> ~ '> 8
~ ~MU 88- 8~
o 02B p.,o p.,~
~ . t'iS g. C
00. U ~ ..... Q) èd
.
· CI(
e1v/)
[ITY DF DELAAY BEA[H
CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE 200 NW Is! AVENUE· DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
FACSIMILE 407/278-4755 Writer's Direct Line: (407) 243-7090
DELRA Y BEACH
F lOR I [} A
....
AII·America City MEMORANDUM
, ~ II r!
DATE: December 6, 1995
1993 TO: City Commission
FROM: David N. Tolees, Assistant City AtlOrne#
SUBJECT: Demand for Judgment
Charlie Brown v, City of Delray Beach
The City Attorney's Office received the attached Demand for Judgment in the above-
referenced case. Section 768.79, Florida Statutes, provides for the filing of a demand
for judgment by the Plaintiff in an effort to settle the case. If the judgment obtained by
the Plaintiff is at least 25 % more than the amount of the offer, the Plaintiff is entitled to
attorney's fees and costs incurred from the date the offer is served, The Plaintiff's
demand is for $375,000.00.
This case involves a 1987 hit and run automobile accident in which the Plaintiff was
injured. The Plaintiff claims in his lawsuit that the City's failure to retain evidence
accumulated during its investigation caused him to lose his cause of action against the
anonymous automobile driver, The City denies any liability,
At this time it would be appropriate for the City Commission to consider the demand for
judgment in order that the City Attorney may respond,
Please call if you have any questions.
DNT:jw Vlld;m 12 cIuy
cc: David Harden, City Manager 5-6
Alison MacGregor Harty, City Clerk
Lee Graham, Risk Manager
brown.dnt
@ Printed on Recycled Paper 9-8,
, '
·
~ -
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. CL 90-6904 AI
CHARLIE BROWN, JR.,
Plaintiff,
vs.
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, a
municipal corporation,
Defendant.
/
DEMAND FOR JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULE 1.442
AND FLORIDA STATUTE §768.79
The Plaintiff, CHARLIE BROWN, JR., makes the following Demand for Judgment
pursuant to Rule 1.442 and Florida Statute §768.79 to the Defendant, CITY OF DELRAY
BEACH, as follows:
1. The action will be dismissed with prejudice as to both parties.
2. The parties will exchange General Releases.
3. The Defendant, CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, shall pay to the Plaintiff,
,
CHARLIE BROWN, JR., the total sum of Three Hundred Seventy Five Thousand
($375,000.00) Dollars which is inclusive of costs and attorney's fees incurred by the Plaintiff
to date and is the total amount of this demand.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the foregoing was served by mail upon David N.
Tolces, Esquire, City of Delray Beach, 200 NW First Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida 33444
and Kent S. Pratt, Esquire, Gaunt, Pratt, et al., 1401 Forum Way, Suite 500, West Palm
2
I
.
-
Beach, Florida 33401, this 1st day of December, 1995.
ARTHUR B. D'ALMEIDA, PA
Attorneys for Plaintiff
105 East Palmetto Park Road
Boca Ra ,Fl a 432
407 /36 ~6 4
3
. '
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER f/Þ'1
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # C¡·C, - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #l}/McTEAGUE CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY, INC.
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider Contract Addition (C.O.
#1) in the net amount of $63,165 to McTeague Construction
Company, Inc. This included the addition of heat pumps for
$76,500 and miscellaneous Value Engineering items for the Pompey
Park Pool project for a credit of $13,335. In addition, the
contractor requests a 19 day rain-delay extension which will
extend the contract time to Substantial Completion to January 4,
1996.
Recommend approval of Contract Addition (C.O. No. 1) to McTeague
Construction Company, Inc. in the amount of $63,165, with funding
from the General Construction Fund (Account No. 334-4170-572-
63.45), through budget transfer from Decade of Excellence Phase
II Pompey Pool (Account No. 228-4126-572-63.45) .
~ 5-0
. ,
.
Agenda Item No. 9<~C
AGENDA REQUEST
Date: December 4, 1995
Request to be placed on:
X Regular Agenda
Special Agenda
Workshop Agenda When: December 12, 1995
Description of item (who, what, where, how much) : Staff request City
Commission approve Change Order #1 to MeTe ague Construction Company, Inc. in the
amount of $63,165.00 for the addition of the Heat Pumps (alternate #4), and other
miscellaneous Value Engineering items for the Pompey Park Pool Project.
Additionally, Staff request approval of a Nineteen (19) day contract extension
due to rain delay. Funding is available from the General Construction Fund,
Account #334-4170-572-63.45.
ORDINANCE/RESOLUTION REQUIRED: Not required.
Recommendation: Staff recommends approval of Change Order #1 to McTeague
Construction, Inc. , in the amount of $63,165.00 and a Nineteen day contract
extension for the Porn e Park Pool Pro'ect.
Department head signature:
Determination of Consistency with Comprehensive Plan:
City Attorney Review/Recommendation (if applicable) :
Budget Director Review (required on all items involving expenditure
of funds) : Gì
Funding available: YE NO
Funding alternatives (if apPliC~
~Account No. & DeSCriPtiOn~;f~~C: j;ü¿Ph1L. \ PO¡µ{
~ccount BalanceÎÞ¡ 9;() fXt' / ,
. JD ~ fû OvUlí1U'vf-
City Manager Review: ~ bt/
Approved for agenda: YE ¥NO 1 374--4i10~'77),.b3-4-S-
Hold Until: ~
Agenda Coordinator Review: '
Received:
Placed on Agenda:
Action:
Approved/Disapproved
\esd\9356\agrq1212
. '
.
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
To: David T. Harden
City Manager
From: José Agui1æ
Constructio anager
Date: December 4, 1995
Subject: AGENDA REOUEST
Pompey Park Pool & Bath House
Project No. 93-56
Attached is an Agenda Request for City Commission review and approval of Change
Order #1 to cover the addition of the Pool Heat Pumps (Add Alternate #4) in the amount
of $76,500.00 and miscellaneous credits to the project for Value Engineering items in the
amount of$13,335.00. The total add for Change Order #1 is $63.165.00.
Additionally, the contractor has made two (2) requests for additional rain delay days due
to the unusually severe amount of rain in the past several months. His request was for a
total of thirty-nine (39) days which after review was adjusted to a total of nineteen (19)
days. This contract adjustment will extend the contract time to Substantial Completion
from December 16,1995 to January 4, 1996.
I have attached for review all available information relevant to this request.
cc: William Greenwood
File 93-56 (A)
esd\9356\agmm1212
. '
·
CITY OF DELRAY BEAœ
CHANGE ORDER TO ORIGINAL CONTRACT
CHANGE ORDER NO. One PROJECT NO. 93-56 DATE: December 4, 1995
PROJECT TITLE: Pompey Park Pool & Bath House
TO CONTRACTOR: McTeague Construction Company, Inc.
YOU ARE HEREBY REQUESTED TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING CHANGES IN THE PLANS AND
SPECIFICATIONS FOR THIS PROJECT AND TO PERFORM THE WORK ACCORDINGLY, SUBJECT TO
ALL CONTRACT STIPULATIONS AND COVENANTS.
JUSTIFICATION: Provide and install all necessary components as listed in the
Construction Documents related to Add Alternate #4, specifically those associated
with the provision of the Heat Pumps for the Pool on the referenced project.
Additionally, provide the necessary credits to the City on those items identified
in record correspondence regarding "Value Engineering".
SUMMARY OF CONTRACT AMOUNT
ORIGINAL CONTRACT AMOUNT 1,030,780.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES PREVIOUSLY ORDERED 0.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT PRIOR TO THIS CHANGE ORDER 1,030,780.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES THIS ORDER 63,165.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT INCLUDING THIS CHANGE ORDER 1,093,945.00
PER CENT INCREASE THIS CHANGE ORDER 6.12 %
TOTAL PER CENT INCREASE TO DATE 6.12 %
EXTENSION OF CONTRACT TIME ALLOWED BY THIS CHANGE 19 CALENDAR DAYS TO 1/4/96
date
CERTIFIED STATEMENT: I hereby certify that the supporting cost data included
is, in my considered opinion, accurate; that the prices
quoted are fair and reasonable and in proper ratio to the
cost of the original work contracted for under benefit of
competitive bidding.
CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE (ARCHITECT)
(sign & seal)
TO BE FILLED OUT BY DEPARTMENT INITIATING CHANGE ORDER
Environmental Services 334-4170-572-63.45.
DEPARTMENT FUNDS BUDGETED CODE CERTIFIED BY
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
By its City commission
RECOMMEND: By:
ENGINEER/DIRECTOR MAYOR
ATTEST:
APPROVED: By:
CITY ATTORNEY CITY CLERK
esd\9356\co1
I'
.
-
[ITY DF DELRAY BEA[H
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT 434 SOUTH SWINTON AVENUE. DELRAY BEACH. FLORIDA 33444
407'243-7300 . TELECOPIER: 407/243-7060
september 25, 1995
Mr. Michael McTeague
McTeague Construction Company, Inc.
314 N.E. 3rd. street
Boynton Beach, Florida 33435
Re: Pompey Park Pool & Bath House
Project No. 93-56
Dear Mike:
This notice will serve as your authorization to proceed with add
alternate #4 for the Geo-Thermal Heat Pumps and Pool Blanket for
the referenced project.
Over the next several days I will prepare a Change Order to cover
the cost of these pumps as well the other Value Engineered items
covered in my memo dated June 6, 1995. The figure for this Change
Order will be $63,165.00, based on the following:
- Alternate #4 . . . . . . . · · · · · · · . $76,500.00
- Value Engineering Savings · · · · · · · ($13,335.00)
- Total Change Order #1 . . · · · · · · · . $63,165.00
I would like to take this opportunity to add for rain days to this
Change Order since this also requires City Commission action. We
should therefore try and reach some agreement on the number of days
to be added.
T 1 f r- t:.- ~ .......... ,....., __ ^ I '''' .... " ," 1\ n .. ---- - - .....
. I . L. __ I~ 1- V r-. I ".-" L.IJ \I"""" 'J ,~. j-Jt." I \ C r\ ~
. '
Please contact my office at your earliest convenience to discuss
these items.
Sincerely,
José Aguila,
Construction Manager
cc: Bill Greenwood
Carey Moulton ~
Joe Weldon
File 93-56 (A)
\esd\9356\pumpauth
.
ßID '? J1cl-Ac, E (=J. ~,eJ~ \e)
--.....:è ~_ __ ----
D. Schedule of Alternates:
1. Alternate No. 1 - Aluminum Louvers (ADD/DEDUCT) :
Provide aluminum louvers as speci d in Section
10200 in lieu of wood louvers cified in Section
06200.
2. Alternate No. 2 - Aspha hingle Roofing (DE-
DUCT) : Provide asphal ingle roofing as speci-
fied in Section 07 lieu of standing seam
metal roofing sp fied in Section 07410.
3. Alternate No. - Finishes Downgrade (DEDUCT):
Provide the lowing finish downgrades:
a. Floor g - provide epoxy paint coated floor
as specified in Section 09900 in lieu of
fluid applied floor coating as specified in
Section 09675.
b. Wall covering - provide epoxy painted wall
surfaces as specified in Section 09900 in
lieu of ceramic tile as specified in Section
93_00. -
4 . Alternate No. 4 - Geo-Thermal Heat Pumps and Pool
Blanket (ADD): Provide two (2) GAC S-12 and one
(1) GAC H-7 heating/cooling units for the main and
wading pools including 4 in. well, well pumps for
each pool, val ves, piping and electrical per con-
struction plans including start-up and training of
maintenance personnel. Provide insulated pool
blanket system (McBall Heat Save V) including
double stainless steel storage reel for the main
and wadin pools.
.- - or Pavers (DEDUCT) : Provide
5. Alternaee
floor finish specified in lieu of concrete pavers
specified in Section 02515.
6. Alternate No. 6 - Pool Deck Toppi ADD} : Pro-
vide cementitious pattern toppi specified in
Section 03555 over exterior deck concrete
slab.
7. Alternate No. 7 - Time 0 ompletion (ADD/DEDUCT) :
- Substantially complete e Project in 170 calendar
days in lieu of 235 c endar days as stated in the
Agreement.
8. Alternate No. 8 - quipment Service Agreement
(ADD) : Provide er with 24 month pool equipment
service agree from the pool equipment Install-
er.
1.06 ALTERATION
A. These Spe fications will generally not describe exist-
ing pro ts or standards of execution, nor will they
enumer e products which are not a part of new con-
struc on. The existing product is its own specifi-
cat' n and standard for strength, appearance and other
94186 01015-3
-
, '
-.... -....-,;..- ..;.-.~ =1.':" ¡ r-.E.='-~ ~ h;." ~I;~; O..ll pal M~P, 17 'SS G:::.;18
C Ú YÌ~ (,l (~ -\--on- rYD'rOS~ Q ~ ~ d -itíY~
-~,",----,,------.,~,,-~--- ..--...-------- --_.~--
-' ...-._..__...."-".~.----
- The U,¿'!dersiqned Bidder agrees to do all e work and
furnish all ma~erial~ oalled far by the Bi nq Documents,
in the manner prescribed therein and to e standards of
al.ity and ~fQrm~nce established y the Contract
WIlen~s for the lump su:m. . tad in the
pr:Lce spaces
her . proviàed. Lwnp sum l.ce 5hall inclu.ds
n
imp 1 ntation of all applicable ety requirements.
. BASE BID ð":?"d
.
1"1 . J'1 éT . o-?<: Y-!,4UÖ4V/ ô;.-
. ..-
/,1 o.;¡~ ¿!Ô~. ClQ
($ L;' <>'"' . J s',rl -0. ) .
ALTERNATE BIDS
Tha follQwing below a.re for alternate
bið. 1~ems as O~O15 o~ the cont::'act
Documents;
ALTEMATE NO.
/100 Collars ) .
Asphåit Shinqle Roofinq
~\.vt>
/100 Dollars ($ - .:;~ ¿?~.ð (;) ) .
- Finishes Downc;rade (DEDUCT)
)., ~ d1' o?"'.)
,.ð ð
/100 Dollars ($ - Y ,~~,ðO ) .
ALTERNATE NO. 4 - Geo-Thermal Heat Pumps and Pool Blanket
(~D1):
~~'.J"",,^ ~ -l." 6 ,¡ 'SA II. d 41V-C:- 'n-...µ..d-~ ~-" ~
~": -- n:' ¿:)
\
1100 DoJ..lare: ($ 4- ~6
7(" Sõ¿J. ) .
,.
/'
P-3
, . _L:O''''
._I"'.r- '.' .'J
~I. ". ;.! ~ .
. '~..' [. ,-:·.¡'c:;N
C:o_t: .",
[ITY DF DELHAY BEA[H JUN G ß \9S5
,.. \ Dc;-"t
h'tect"~Gi ",'
ATC I VI '
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT 434 SOUTH SWINTON AVENUE. DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
407'243-7300 . TElECOPIER: 407'243·7060
June 6, 1995
Mr. Michael McTeague
McTeague Construction Company, Inc.
314 N.E. 3rd. Street
Boynton Beach, Florida 33435
Re: Pompey Park Pool & Bath House
Project No. 93-56
Dear Mike:
Following the award of contract, we have been evaluating a series
of Value Engineering items with the idea of reducing the cost of
the pro j ect, while maintaining the design quality and long term
maintenance of the facility. Following is the result of these
considerations.
Items 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, 16, 17, 19, 20, 21, 22,
23, 26, and 27 are not acceptable to the City.
The following items are acceptable to the city and are described as
follows:
Item 1 - Water reducing admix deletion · · · · · · $3,300
Item 3 - Overhead door change from one 30' to two 15' doors
with a crank operation; hood deletion and mill
finish . . . . . . · · · · · · · · · · · · $3,525
Item 9 - Use sch 80 PVC in pool equip room · · · · $1,350
Item 14 - Delete flow meter · · · · · · · · · · · · $ 800
Item 18 - Use PVC vs. cast iron · · · · · · · · · · $2,200
Item 24 - Substitute pool blanket & reel · · · · · · $2,160
Total project savings . . . · · · · · · · · · · · .413,335)
T ¡--Œ E =:=t)P.T A LWA YS M A TiERS
, '
^ -
. '
v::- He.. 1:.. ~""'N\.f? 1$ 1"'.'",,0" ,-
Item 25 will be an added cost to the project if funding is
identified prior to project completion. I will keep you informed.
As far as the savings, for now, we will keep them in abeyance
pending other project considerations which may require available
funding.
I would like to thank you and your sub-contractors for taking the
time to assist the City in identifying the potential savings.
Sincerely,
~'-
José Aguila,
Construction Manager
cc: Carey Moulton, Gee & Jenson ~
File 93-56 (A)
\esct\9356\vefin
.
.
. .
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER tJJ-«
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # q,j). - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
CHANGE ORDER NO. 2/0'CONNOR & TAYLOR, INC.
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider Change Order No. 2 to
O'Connor & Taylor, Inc. in the amount of $15,510 as part of the
final reconciliation for the Municipal Golf Course Clubhouse
project.
The extra charges include items related to the interior design
package, additional electrical items and fire sprinkler heads.
There were miscellaneous additions, changes and credits associ-
ated with the project.
Recommend approval of Change Order No. 2 to O'Connor & Taylor,
Inc, in the amount of $15,510 from the Municipal Golf Course Fund
- Buildings (Account No. 445-4763-572-62.10) .
~ 3&;;2
(~/l. ~ 1- ~õJ ð'f;~
~)
.
, cJK
V1
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
To: David T. Harden
City Manager
From: José Aguila~
Construction anager
Date: December 7, 1995
Subject: Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course
Golf Course Clubhouse
Change Order #2 - Justification
Project No. 93-18
Attached is a listing of all the items identified in attachment "A" as presented as part of
Change Order #2 request. The item numbers are those used on the attachment by
O'Connor & Taylor, the general contractor.
I have provided some brief description of each item and identified the cause of each using
the following code:
A City requested items
B Design changes, additions or modifications
C Unforeseen field conditions
I will be available at the next City Commission meeting to answer any questions which
may come up. Please let me know if you require any additional information.
cc: William Greenwood
File 93-18 (A)
esd\9318\co2mem2
. '
.
.
CITY OF DELRA Y BEACH
MUNICIPAL GOLF COURSE PROJECT
PROJECT NO. 93-18
CHANGE ORDER #2 - JUSTIFICATION
December 7,1995
lItem Description Cause Cost I
1 Change order #1 was approved by the City Commission on Dec, 13,
1994 to cover the cost of additional paved parking area on the north
side of the parking lot. A $16,095.00
2 During the course of the job, the City found it necessary to move the
temporary toilet trailer. The work was done by the general
contractor and the City was billed separately A $ 3,679.00
3.a.1 Once the project was nearing completion, the facility user felt that
the service galley was unsightly and requested additional doors be
placed to separate the public from the service area A $ 3,500.00
3.a.2 After the pro-shop was open for public use, a need for additional
storage shelves became apparent. As requested, the contractor
provided and installed the additional shelves. A $ 1.311.00
3.a.3 Addendum #5 was issued too late in the bidding period and had
to be negotiated after the project was awarded. This cost reflects
a 50/50 split between the City and the contractor. B $ 2,388.00
3.a.4 This item covers seven branch circuits not shown on the contract
drawing necessary for the exhaust fans, and an additional four prong
fire alarm communication device required by the Fire Department B.A $ 715.00
3.a.5 The interior design bid documents were incomplete for bidding
purposes, Once the plans were made available to the contractor.
additional charges were identified to comply with the plans. B $ 2,773.00
3.a.6 The wall areas around the receiving dock at the kitchen was
to be a drywall area. The City felt that the walls would be better
protected if the same wall material was used as the kitchen
walls. The material is a cleanable plastic sheet. B $ 1,218.00
3.a.7 The painted wall finish in the entry, lobby and cupola area was
to have been finished by a painter under the interior design budget.
The designer was happy with the work by the contractors painter,
and she felt he could do the work within the established budget
for that item. This was not an added cost to the overall project. B $ 6,900.00
3.a.8 Once the project was near completion, it was felt that the existing
irrigation pump building, located just east of the new clubhouse
was in need of painting. A $ 690.00
. '
·
Municipal Golf Course
Change Order #2 - Justification
Page 2
3.a.9 The original plan was to use canal water for landscape irrigation
It was later determined that this would be a long term maintenance
problem, and it was decided that use of City water would be better.
This change reflects the modification, resulting in a credit to the City A $ -110.00
3.a.1O In order to access the upper portion of the roof, one would have to
step on a portion of the roof shingles. These shingles are very brittle
and would crack if walked on. It was necessary to provide another
material which would allow traffic. Copper was selected as the best
alternative. B $ 345.00
3,a.ll The mechanical engineer failed to provide three necessary NC
jumper ducts on the bidding document, thus once identified as
necessary, the contractor installed them. B $ 1,472.00
3.a.12 The specifications provided by the interior designer at bid time
indicated that the wall covering would be in yards. What was
actually purchased by the City, and installed by the general
contractor was a "roll" paper. This resulted in double the
installation labor and therefore the cost was passed on to the City. B $ 1,150.00
3.a.13 The City requested that a pair of doors be added between the
service galley area and the corridor leading to the main dining
room to shield the view of the public. A $ 2.484.00
3.a.14 A number of additional electrical outlets were provided, some
at the request of the City, and some which were missed by the
design consultant, but necessary for the project. A,B $ 2,553.00
3.a.15 The City, under separate contract, was responsible for the old
clubhouse demolition and debris removal. Some material was
left behind and was removed from site by the general contractor. A $ 1,200.00
3.a.16 Because the City was responsible for the demolition. a tempo-
rary fence was necessary. Once completed. additional fencing
was required--according to the plans--and the City had to
share in that cost A $ 850.00
3.b.l After installation of the fire sprinkler system per the approved
plans, the Fire Department upon inspection required that the con-
tractor add nine additional heads. This work was done to get
final permit sign off. C $ 1,242.00
3.b.2 This item again reflects a number of added electrical receptacles
and other items both missed in the plans by the design team.
as well as some added by the end user. A,B,C $ 3,874.00
,
Municipal Golf Course
Change Order #2 - Justification
Page 3
3.b.3 The kitchen equipment was purchased by the City under
separate contract including the kitchen hood. Choice Kitchen
contracted with another sub to install the hood. this sub
apparently walked on the roof tiles and broke some of them.
The roofer under the GC had to make the necessary repairs
but failed to notify the City before the kitchen equipment
supplier was paid. This charge should have been passed
on to Choice Kitchen. There were other items the City was
aware of and received the proper credits from Choice. C $ 300.00
3.bA The bid documents provided for a deduct alternate for the
double outlookers from the trusses. The City accepted this
deduct alternate. The architect failed to consider how the
attachment of a single outlooker would work. necessitating
longer members. This cost reflect this added material. B $ 1.888.00
3.b.5 The general contractor had a certain number of exterior
wood signs in his contract. The end used requested two
additional signs be added on the site. A $ 1,143.00
3.b.6 According to the wallpaper installer. the borders should come
to the site trimmed for installation. The interior designer failed
to order them trimmed requiring manual trimming of all
border material prior to installation. B $ 2,024.00
3.b.7 The detail provided by the design team was not strong enough
to support the total weight of the dumpster enclosure doors.
A modified hinge and connection detail was necessary.
which the contractor installed. B $ 600.00
SUMMARY OF CHARGES:
Total additional charges $40.510.00 (exclusive of item 1 and 2)
Contingency per contract $25.000.00
Total for Change Order #2 $15.510.00
CODES USED FOR CAUSE COLUMN
A City requested items $13.464.00
B Design changes/additions $18.604.00
C Construction unforeseen conditions $ 1.542.00
$33.610.00
Item 3 .a. 7 added no cost to the budget $ 6.900.00
Grand Total cost in excess of the contract $40.510.00
esd\9318\co2decr
.
·
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
To: David T. Harden
City Manager
From: Jose Agui1iID:
Constructibu_· anager
Date: November 22, 1995
Subject: AGENDA REOUEST
Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course Project
Project No. 93-18
Attached is information relative Change Order #2 for the Municipal Golf Course Project .
The project has been completed and as part of final reconciliation, there are several items
which resulted in additional cost to the City. Even though this Change Order represents a
final reconciliation, the project will not be closed out until the final retain age is paid.
The extra charges include items related to the interior design package, additional electrical
items, fire sprinkler heads required by the fire marshal and others.
The total amount for Change Order #2 is $ 15,510.00. Funding is available from the
Municipal Golf Course Fund, Buildings Account No. 445-4763-572-62.10.
cc: William Greenwood
File 93-18 (A)
esd\93I 8\co2mem
,
CITY OF DELRAY BEAœ
œANGE ORDER ro ORIGINAL CONTRACT
œANGE ORDER RO. 2 PROJECT NO. 93-18 DATE: November 21, 1995
PROJECT TITLE: Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course Clubhouse
ro CONTRACTOR: O'Connor & Taylor, Inc.
YOU ARE HEREBY REQUESTED ro HAlŒ 'nIB FOLLOWING œAHGES IN THE PLANS AND
SPECIFICATIONS FOR THIS PROJECT AND ro PERFORM THE WORK ACCORDINGLY, SUBJECT ro
ALL CONTRACT STIPUlATIONS AND OOVEHAHTS.
JUSTIFICATION: Provide and install miscellaneous items as detailed on attachment
"A", dated september 13, 1995. All conditions associated with base contract
will be applicable to this work.
SUMMARY OF OOHTRACT AMOUNT
ORIGINAL CONTRACT AMOUNT $1,574,225.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES PREVIOUSLY ORDERED $ 16,095.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT PRIOR TO THIS CHANGE ORDER $1,590,320.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES THIS ORDER $ 15,510.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT INCLUDING THIS CHANGE ORDER $1,605,830.00
PER CENT INCREASE THIS CHANGE ORDER 0.98%
TOTAL PER CENT INCREASE TO DATE 2.00%
EXTENSION OF CONTRACT TIME ALLOWED BY THIS CHANGE, -º-CALENDAR DAYS TO 8/11/95
date
CERTIFIED STATEMENT: I hereby certify that the supporting cost data included
is, in my considered opinion, accurate; that the prices
quoted are fair and reasonable and in proper ratio to
the cost of the original work contracted for under
benefit competitive bidding.
CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE (ARCHITECT)
(sign & seal)
TO BE FILLED OUT BY DEPARTMENT INITIATING CHANGE ORDER
Environmental Services 445-4763-572-62.10.
DEPARTMENT FUNDS BUDGETED CODE CERTIFIED BY
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
By its City Commission
RECOMMEND: By:
ESD DIRECTOR MAYOR
ATTEST:
APPROVED: By:
CITY ATTORNEY CITY CLERK
esd\9318\co2
.
ATTAC:/lf'liNT A I) AC I~ j o f 4
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR, INC.
.
General Contracting · Construction Management
S{' Jt~mh('r 1], 1995
1\11'. Jose A~uila, Cons'mdion Mana~~r
('it)' of Delra)' B~ach
"LH S, Swinton A v~nu~
I h.-Iray Beach, Florida 33444
Ih': Delray Beach Golf Course Cluhhouse
Contract Close-Out
1)(' a I' .I oS{':
I am writin~ this letter '0 provide a single source summary for the additional cost items on
lilt' ahoVl' rd'('renced pruject. The items outlined helow arc comprehensive; includin~ (:lIst
items l'Clvel"ed hy prior Chan~e Or"ders, cos' items 1)I"eviously approved and cost items
whit'h have no' heen here'ofore suhmitted for formal approval.
I. C'IIAN(;E ORDERS: Only one Chan~e Order that was issued during the cOllrse of
the joh was for the parking lot I"evisions. This Change Order was approved in the
amount of $16,H95; and has heen paid through the normal Application process.
2. SEPARATE INVOICE: Additional work was performed and invoiced hy via
separatl' invoice (outside of the Contrad Amount). This worl\ was for the relcH:ation
of the golf fOllrse rest rooms. The amollnt of the invoke was $3,679.
J, CONTINGENCY: The halanl'C of the additional work which was appruved ami
performed dllring tlw t.'Clllrse of the pruject was intended to he dJarged against the
fontingency line item in the Contract. It was our IInderstanding that any cost in
eXfess of the contin~elH:J' wOllld he hilled out via a linal Chall~e Onll~r.
a. I-reviously Approved Contingenq Cost: Outlil\l~d helow is a hrid' desrription
of the item, the date of documentation and the fost of cadI item.
(I.) Extra Douhle Doors April 13th l~e{IUest $ 3,5HH
(2.) Additional Sheh'in~ AI)I'il 6th nequest $ 1,311
(3,) Addendum No, 5 April 20th Request $ 2,.~NN
(4,) Misc. Elel'. Changes Fehruary 20th I~ecluest $ 715
(5.) I D J}ntwin~ Chan~es MalTh 20th Recluest $ 2,77.\
((I.) Additional FI~P Board I\larch 20th Ih~C uest $ 1,21 N
(7.) Copula Finishes I\lardl 5th net lIt~st $ (1,900
(N.) Paint Pump Buildin~
(Inc. Contradm"s OH&P)l\lan~h INth Minutes $ ()90
(9.) Irrig. Credit/Water Meter Char~{'
3Xl)2 Prospect Avenue, SIIilC 7 . Wesl Pall11 Bcach, 1"1,33,104 . (407) X6\-7349 . Fax (407) X61-\Ú7-1
I'
^T'f'ACIJ~H:N'r A PACE ') of 4
"-
I\lay HUh Minutes $ ( I It»)
(W.) Copper Walkway on I~oof (I~evised Pricing,
Induding Contradors OIl&P)
May ISth Minutes $ 345
( II.) AIC .J umper Dnds May HUh Minutes $ 1,"'72
(12.) Wallcovel'Ìng
(Roll Goods vs, Yanl (;oods) May ISth Minntes $ 1,150
(13.) Douhle Doors (cD 127 & 12(, May 18th Minutes $ 2,484
(14.) Electrical Misc. Changes Ma)' 18th Minntes $ 2,553
(15.) lIaul and Disposal (Owner Landsnlping
and Demo Dehris) May 18th I\linutes $ 1,200
(1(,.) (hnH~r Portion nf Cnnst. F(~I\l'e
Oft. Meeting Minutes $ 850
Total of Previonsly Dncumel1h~d ('hanges $29,439
h, Itemized helel\\' arc a few additional cost items whidl were not previously
outlined in terms of lahor and materials.
I. Fire S¡ninkler Chan1?;cs: Fourteen ( 14) Request for Change wcre
suhmitted hy the Fire SI)rinlder Suhcontractor. These fourteen (14)
I~equest for Change wel'e lu'eviously transmitted hy O'Connor &
Taylm', Inc. to the I)roject Engineer I'm' review. No response was
given. Ilaving reviewed the fonrteen (14) Change Retluest, we feel that
then' wel'e three (3) legitimatc Change I~CtlUcsts suhmitted ~IS follows:
a. Two (2) sprinkler heads added to
Port Cachere area per Fire !Vlarshall. $ 270
h. FOIII' (4) sprinkler heads relocated in
lohhy area sheet rod" ('(~iling per Fire
I\larshall re(IUest. $ 450
c. Thrt,(, (3) sprinkler heads rdocated nn
the South exterior covered porch area
per Fire Marshalll·etluest. $ 360
Suhtotal $ 1,080
Contractors OH&P 162
Total $ 1,242
2. Miscellaneous Electrical Chan1?;es: as follows
a. I~l'l'l'plade fut" Idtdll'n pl'Ình' " $ X5
h. neceptade for TV ami cahlt· Iwx $ IOJ
('. Low(~r eight (8) junction hoxes $ JOO
d. Misœllaneous kitchen equipment worl( $ ()OO
('. Acid haloll to lire alarm syst('m $ 554
. '
A TTA CII ~I EN' ' A PACE :3 of 4
f. Add receptacle at soda machines $ 6M
g. Switcll changing room lights $ 65
h. I{eccptade/cash register and lighting
@ Pro Shop $ 130
i. I{eceptacle (q! trophy case $ 6()
.I. Three way switches in Pro Shop $ 225
Ie AUU No.2 heat strip hookup $ 59M
I. Time clock to site light pole $ 175
m. Install Owner fixtures $ 400
Suhtotal $ 3,369
('ontmctors OIl&P 505
Total Elect .-ical $ 3,M74
3. I{epait- of roof tile damaged hy Choice Kitchen
Equilnnent Suhwntractm' (Aho Ait·).
(No !\,Iark-up). $ 300
4. Additionallumher re(luired duc to C)'press outlooker
structural detail; cypress outlooker required to he
provided at four (4) lineal fœt vs. two (2) lineal feet
as indicated on plan.
32() outlool\Crs x 2 lineal n. = 640 lineal feet
640 lineal ft. x $2.95 per lineal ft. = $ 1,88M
5. Two (2) addit ional exterior wood signs
2 @ $497 each = $ 994
Contractors OH&P @ 15% 149
Total Additional Signage Cost $ I, 143
6. Trim all wallcovering hoarders which were not shipped
precut; per industry standard. $1,7()0
('ont!lldors 011&1' 264
Total $ 2,02'"
7. Ih'pair/Replacement of Dumpster Cate lIinges $ (100
Total of New Documented I{eqllests
$11 ,071
SlII\II\IAI{\':
I. PH'vioIlSI)' )Ol'IIIIWllkd ('hallg(' I{(·(t ('sh $21)"BI)
2. Newly Documellted Change nC(IUests 11,071
3. Total of "Contingency" Change n(~quests $40,510
-t Less Project Contingency ( 25,000)
5, Change l{e(IUest No, 2 Ammlllt $15,5 W
, '
ATTACHNENT A PAGE 4 of 4
A h~r ('eviewing the ahove cnst summary and the endosed documentation, please let me
know how you would like to format the final Change I~equest and Application for"
Payment. I apologize for not having provided ~IOU with this information sooner and I thank
you for your patiem'c in the dos(~-out of tlU' prnjed.
Sinrerely,
J.E. TayIOl", III
Pn'sident
\'(: : John Collier
Ifl21.10SEiJ J
, '
,
P.!32
r--- - ~ ¡Irnpoznl . ....-.---.-- .-.
. -------
"
1577 S.W. 1st WAY, BAY 11 E \
!' Southern Coast Enterplises DEERFIELD BEACH, FL 33441
305426·3312
COMMERCIAL & RESIDENTIAL' STATE LICENSED & INSURED 800-585-5132 I
,
ST. LIC, #CCC05045I I:
!I 11
" :1
. ..
'I PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO PHONE DATE ~I
!.
O'CONNOR AND TAYl.OR, INC. 407 -B63-7319 /107-863- 361l.JrAX 5-15-95 "
r -.!
srnEET JOB NAMr "
3892 PROSPCcr AVE fnc. DELMY ßEAC~~ GOLF COURSE CLUBHOUSE
'--ë;~TATê'AND liP CODE JOB l OCA nON ----
..... WEST PALM ßEAQ.LELJ3Q69_ HOMfWOOr) .BLYD~....Qr:Lß6~LßEAO,L..£L. ..... - ., ..
.- -- ---....-, --.-- ---... ..------..- ....-----... ~ ....-. ~ .
We hereby P'OPOSfl 10 ¡,
.
.
,
!j
.'
, :
CHA:t'{çm ORDER :1
:1
,
.'
INSTAlLATION OF 24 OZ COPPER WALKWAY (24"X80")
PRICE ,.....,......."....,.,..." $600,00 /
;
~ II
o\) 'I
::
:1
¥'~ I!
I
I
" I
.
:
I
I
--- ---
Any unpaid balance shall bear interest at 1.5% per month after 30 days from due date. In the event it shall be
1 necessary to employ an attorney to collect any sum of money due hereunder, Owner or Builder agreos to pay all costs or
collection including a reasonable attorney's fee. All invoices are payable COD,
! We assume no responSibility for damage caÜsed by act of God. or any act beyond our conlrol.
¡ The terms and conditions printed on the back hereol, are referred to and made a part 01 thIs proposal
Accepted by Buyer SOUTHERN COAST ENTERPRISES I'
,I
this day of 199 .'
By By (ìAcu~A<J f1M).~~
By - .0- _...._~......
- ----_...._-- -_....--- ---..--- AS AUT~<?.~IZEO REP_'3§~§!i~~IIV~", -,
.-- -.-----------.--..---.-.......--.--.......---- .._._. - .... ...
MAY-15-1995 14:53 96% P.02
,
,..
Southern Coast Enterprises
lS77 S.W, 1st Way. Bay HE
Deerfidd Beach, Florida 33064
ücmstd (305)426-3312 DATE INVOICE #
/nsllrtd lie. #CCC 050451 7/25/95 2269
BILL TO:
O'CONNOR AND TAYLOR
3892 PROSPECT AVE #7
WEST PALM BEACH, FL. 33404
>
DESCRIPTION AMOUNT
RE: THE DELRA Y COUNTRY CLUB
ADDITIONAL CHARGE FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF CRACKED SUPRADUR 900.00
SHINGLES
(j 5~ I ~ flficÛc taM¡. ../0
I L
ri' - JL") i c.x:- ,rv"'-w -;;
yvúf¡\fit,tL WC7c-tfr -=> '-I('ðD0 7l
3 "'I...~ <f ¡¿v; 6¿Øf. &t'j~ ~ ff (.,.cÞ
T::\ ~, I.,. íf
lY Q b {¿'~'-J< --\ú:¡.td.<-~, ¡,~. ,~L 2~~\:
~s,¡.. (Jlw 01 '0 . ~ "Z.'~:~".,
n I J ~ 1), ¡ _ '2..t) -------~
.'J (..IV'"" S ./ r / ,
GltlA ' t ,~i ()\, ¡
( \.. ~/
\ ~_/.
/
'::.--,~
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS - TOTAL
.-- -
,
.
.
Superior !fire Sprink{ers, Inc.
'if Fire Protection Systems
222 JUPiter Street
Jupiter) FCoriáa. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634 rf~rrnrm~
April 28, 1995 qi MAY 02 1995 !L:
Ui¡ '.!
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR DL::! \:J[5u crGG
ATTN: Joe Taylor ~~.s~~_~..~....~._____~~__~__
3892 Prospect Ave, #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #6
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving the relocation
of sprinkler heads in exterior covered porch, as requested by the
fire inspector. Attached is a work order for the details of the
work performed.
GRAND TOTAL $ 360.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $360.00. Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
j)~ 'R~b~f,-
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DBGC.~c6
-.
--- tßpndeá - lnsureá
.
.
.
"
-
Superior !fire SprinK.{ersl Inc.
'flf Fire Protection Systems
222 JUPiter Street
Jupiter) FCoridå. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634
April 28, 1995
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR
ATTN: Joe Taylor
3892 Prospect Ave. #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #9
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving four ( 4 )
sprinkler heads relocated in lobby area sheetrock ceilings to
provide additional floor coverage. Attached is a work order for
a further explanation of the details of the work performed,
GRAND TOTAL $ 450.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $450.00, Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
~JJ:& ~d~
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DBGC.co9 ffr?(;!~nD m\
l' .; . ,~II: ._.t I ~ .. , . 'I !
!¡ !
~ MAYO 2 1995 :J :
L .__._ 'U!
IL,il ":J\':ïL:JU U L:::J~
---...--- - ---- - - -------------
- - tJ30mfeá - In.sureá
.
- - -
-
. - .
Superior ~ire SprinK{ersl Inc.
'if Fire Protection Systems
222 JUPiter Street
Jupiter) FCoriáa. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634
April 28, 1995
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR
ATTN: Joe Taylor
3892 Prospect Ave. #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #10
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving two (2 )
sprinkler heads added to attic protection in area designated "Porte
Cochere". Attached is a work order for a further explanation of the
details of the work performed.
GRAND TOTAL $ 270.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $270.00. Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
~~ ~/~
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DBCC.colO ~- .. -IF! ~
,- ---.,
¡ ili N,JJ,y :} 2 1995 If
'-ILJl~ :--~u
... _.. -. ... - . . ..~...-..._------
tßonáeá - lnsureá
.
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER&7vÎ
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # c¡,'p, - MEETING OF DECEMBER 5, 1995
CHANGE ORDER NO. 2/0'CONNOR & TAYLOR, INC.
DATE: DECEMBER 1, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider Change Order No. 2 to
O'Connor & Taylor, Inc. in the amount of $15,510 as part of the
final reconciliation for the Municipal Golf Course Clubhouse
project.
The extra charges include items related to the interior design
package, additional electrical items and fire sprinkler heads.
There were miscellaneous additions, changes and credits associ-
ated with the project.
Recommend approval of Change Order No. 2 to O'Connor & Taylor,
Inc, in the amount of $15,510 from the Municipal Golf Course Fund
- Buildings (Account No. 445-4763-572-62.10) .
(!omm¡,ss/on ¿u;:;ncls d ~ftn lEi)
b I:-fl1-K-t>ow n 'I- t;t¡;/¡:;/ll1-V7o/? ot O!JHJ9&s/
who ns Þét:; foe- I¥ whoSf3:. l=éSfMS' b ¡'h ~.I
~.
fb.s rp::;n &:J ~ 1..:2/1;;if 95
.
.
Agenda Item No. C¡.F
AGENDA REQUEST
Date: November 20, 1995
Request to be placed on:
X Regular Agenda
Special Agenda
Workshop Agenda When: December 5, 1995
Description of item (who, what, where, how much) : Staff request City
commission approve Change Order #2 in the amount of $15,510.00 to O'Connor &
Taylor, Inc" to cover miscellaneous additions I changes and credi ts associated
with the Municipal Golf Course Project (see attached descriptions) . The Project
number is 93-18. Funding is available from the Municipal Golf Course Fund,
Buildings Account No. 445-4763-572-62.10.
ORDINANCE/RESOLUTION REQUIRED: Not required
Recommendation: Staff recommends approval of Change Order #2 to the Contract
with O'Connor & Taylor, Inc. , in the amount of $15,510.00 for miscellaneous end
of contract adjustments associated with the Munici al Golf Course Pro·ect.
Determination of Consistency with Comprehensive Plan:
City Attorney Review/Recommendation (if applicable) :
Budget Director Review (required on all items involving expenditure
of funds):
Funding available~/NO
Funding alternatives ,.J),4 ~f applicable}
Account No. & DescriptionlflfÇ-L{7c:'3-57'd-- b2,/D 6rJLF CfM.,4r$E 6LJ?)
Account Balance #t{.Ç/~' k .;
. r;;¡:t;c r I f ''¡.Ptf "'s"
City Manager Review: §>NO [l7/t'1
Approved for agenda:
Hold Until:
Agenda Coordinator Review:
Received:
Placed on Agenda:
Action:
Approved/Disapproved
\esd\forms\agreq125
.
.
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
To: David T. Harden
City Manager
From: Jose AgUil~
Constructi _ anager
Date: November 22, 1995
Subject: AGENDA REOUEST
Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course Project
Project No. 93-18
Attached is information relative Change Order #2 for the Municipal Golf Course Project .
The project has been completed and as part of final reconciliation, there are several items
which resulted in additional cost to the City. Even though this Change Order represents a
final reconciliation, the project will not be closed out until the final retainage is paid.
The extra charges include items related to the interior design package, additional electrical
items, fire sprinkler heads required by the fire marshal and others.
The total amount for Change Order #2 is $ 15,510.00. Funding is available ITom the
Municipal Golf Course Fund, Buildings Account No. 445-4763-572-62.10.
cc: William Greenwood
File 93-18 (A)
esd\93I 8\co2mem
.
·
CITY OF DELRAY BEAœ
CHANGE ORDER TO ORIGINAL CONTRACT
CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 PROJECT NO. 93-18 DATE: November 21, 1995
PROJECT TITLE: Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course Clubhouse
TO CONTRACTOR: O'COnnor & Taylor, Inc.
YOU ARE HEREBY REQUESTED TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING œANGES IN THE PLANS AND
SPECIFICATIONS FOR THIS PROJECT AND TO PERFORM THE WORK ACCORDINGLY, SUBJECT TO
ALL CONTRACT STIPULATIONS AND COVENANTS.
JUSTIFICATION: Provide and install miscellaneous items as detailed on attachment
"A", dated September 13, 1995. All conditions associated with base contract
will be applicable to this work.
SUMMARY OF CONTRACT AMOUNT
ORIGINAL CONTRACT AMOUNT $1,574,225.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES PREVIOUSLY ORDERED $ 16,095.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT PRIOR TO THIS CHANGE ORDER $1,590,320.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES THIS ORDER $ 15,510.00
ADJUSTED CONTRACT AMOUNT INCLUDING THIS CHANGE ORDER $1,605,830.00
PER CENT INCREASE THIS CHANGE ORDER 0.98%
TOTAL PER CENT INCREASE TO DATE 2.00%
EXTENSION OF CONTRACT TIME ALLOWED BY THIS CHANGE, -º-CALENDAR DAYS TO 8/11/95
date
CERTIFIED STATEMENT: I hereby certify that the supporting cost data included
is, in my considered opinion, accurate; that the pr ices
quoted are fair and reasonable and in proper ratio to
the cost of the original work contracted for under
benefit competitive bidding.
CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE (ARCHITECT)
(sign & seal)
TO BE FILLED OUT BY DEPARTMENT INITIATING CHANGE ORDER
Environmental Services 445-4763-572-62.10.
DEPARTMENT FUNDS BUDGETED CODE CERTIFIED BY
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
By its City Commission
RECOMMEND: By:
ESD DIRECTOR MAYOR
ATTEST:
APPROVED: By:
CITY ATTORNEY CITY CLERK
esd\9318\co2
,
.
. A TT kCHMENT A PAGE 1 of 4
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR, INC.
General Contracting · Construction Management
September 13, 1995
Mr. Jose Aguila, Construction Manager
City of Delray Beach
434 S. Swinton A venue
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
Re: Delray Beach Golf Course Clubhouse
Contract Close-Out
Dear Jose:
I am writing this letter to provide a single source summary for the additional cost items on
the above referenced project. The items outlined below are comprehensive; including cost
items covered by prior Change Orders, cost items previously approved and cost items
which have not been heretofore submitted for formal approval.
1. CHANGE ORDERS: Only one Change Order that was issued during the course of
the job was for the parking lot revisions. This Change Order was approved in the
amount of $16,095; and has been paid through the normal Application process.
2. SEPARATE INVOICE: Additional work was performed and invoiced by via
separate invoice (outside of the Contract Amount). This work was for the relocation
of the golf course restrooms. The amount of the invoice was $3,679.
3. CONTINGENCY: The balance of the additional work which was approved and
performed during the course of the project was intended to be charged against the
contingency line item in the Contract. It was our understanding that any cost in
excess of the contingency would be billed out via a final Change Order.
a. Previouslv Approved Contine:encv Cost: Outlined below is a brief description
of the item, the date of documentation and the cost of each item.
(1.) Extra Double Doors April 13th Request $ 3,500
(2.) Additional Shelving April 6th Request $ 1,311
(3.) Addendum No.5 April 20th Request $ 2,388
(4.) Misc. Elec. Changes February 20th Request $ 715
(5.) ID Drawing Changes March 20th Request $ 2,773
(6.) Additional FRP Board March 20th Request $ 1,218
(7.) Copula Finishes March 5th Request $ 6,900
(8.) Paint Pump Building
(Inc. Contractors OH&P)March 18th Minutes $ 690
(9.) Irrig. CreditlWater Meter Charge
3892 Prospect Avenue, Suite 7 . West Palm Beach, FL 33404 · (407) 863-7349 · Fax (407) 863-3674
· ,
ATTACHMENT A PAGE 2 of 4
May 18th Minutes $ ( 110)
(10.) Copper Walkway on Roof (Revised Pricing,
Including Contractors OH&P)
May 18th Minutes $ 345
(11.) AlC Jumper Ducts May 18th Minutes $ 1,472
(12.) Wallcovering
(Roll Goods vs. Yard Goods) May 18th Minutes $ 1,150
(13.) Double Doors @ 127 & 126 May 18th Minutes $ 2,484
(14.) Electrical Misc. Changes May 18th Minutes $ 2,553
(15.) Haul and Disposal (Owner Landscaping
and Demo Debris) May 18th Minutes $ 1,200
(16.) Owner Portion of Con st. Fence
Oct. Meeting Minutes $ 850
Total of Previously Documented Changes $29,439
b. Itemized below are a few additional cost items which were not previously
outlined in terms of labor and materials.
1. Fire Sprinkler Chane:es: Fourteen (14) Request for Change were
submitted by the Fire Sprinkler Subcontractor. These fourteen (14)
Request for Change were previously transmitted by O'Connor &
Taylor, Inc. to the Project Engineer for review. No response was
given. Having reviewed the fourteen (14) Change Request, we feel that
there were three (3) legitimate Change Requests submitted as follows:
a. Two (2) sprinkler heads added to
Port Cachere area per Fire Marshall. $ 270
b. Four (4) sprinkler heads relocated in
lobby area sheet rock ceiling per Fire
Marshall request. $ 450
c. Three (3) sprinkler heads relocated on
the South exterior covered porch area
per Fire Marshall request. $ 360
Subtotal $ 1,080
Contractors OH&P 162
Total $ 1,242
2. Miscellaneous Electrical Chane:es: as follows
a. Receptacle for kitchen printer $ 85
b. Receptacle for TV and cable box $ 103
c. Lower eight (8) junction boxes $ 300
d. Miscellaneous kitchen equipment work $ 600
e. Add halon to fire alarm system $ 554
·
ATTACHMENT A PAGE 3 of 4
f. Add receptacle at soda machines $ 68
g. Switch changing room lights $ 65
h. Receptacle/cash register and lighting
@ Pro Shop $ 130
i. Receptacle @ trophy case $ 66
j. Three way switches in Pro Shop $ 225
k. AHU No.2 heat strip hookup $ 598
I. Time clock to site light pole $ 175
m. Install Owner fixtures $ 400
Subtotal $ 3,369
Contractors OH&P 505
Total Electrical $ 3,874
3. Repair of roof tile damaged by Choice Kitchen
Equipment Subcontractor (Aho Air).
(No Mark-up). $ 300
4. Additional lumber required due to cypress outlooker
structural detail; cypress outlooker required to be
provided at four (4) lineal feet vs. two (2) lineal feet
as indicated on plan.
320 outlookers x 2 lineal ft. = 640 lineal feet
640 lineal ft. x $2.95 per lineal ft. = $ 1,888
5. Two (2) additional exterior wood signs
2 @ $497 each = $ 994
Contractors OH&P @ 15% 149
Total Additional Signage Cost $ 1,143
6. Trim all wallcovering boarders which were not shipped
precut; per industry standard. $1,760
Contractors OH&P 264
Total $ 2,024
7. RepairlReplacement of Dumpster Gate Hinges $ 600
Total of New Documented Requests
$11,071
SUMMARY:
1. Previously Documented Change Requests $29,439
2. Newly Documented Change Requests 11.071
3. Total of "Contingency" Change Requests $40,510
4. Less Project Contingency (25.000)
5. Change Request No.2 Amount $15,510
.
.
ATTACHMENT A PAGE 4 of 4
After reviewing the above cost summary and the enclosed documentation, please let me
know how you would like to format the final Change Request and Application for
Payment. I apologize for not having provided you with this information sooner and I thank
you for your patience in the close-out of the project.
Sincerely,
cc: John Collier
162/JOSE913
....._.
P.Ø2
rr·--------· - - :Jrnposnl - .. ...._._4.___.__. ._.
. -.-----.--
,
I, 1577 S.W. 1st WAY, BAY 11 E \
I Southern Coast Enterprises DEERFIELD BEACH, FL 33441
~ 305-426-3312
,
COMMERCIAL & RESIDENTIAL' STATE LICENSED & INSURED 800-585-5132 I
I
ST. LIC. #CCC050451 I'
11 1\
" :1
. '- ~I
'I PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO PHONE DATE
!'
O'CONNOR AND TAYl.OR, INC. 407-863-7319/107-863- 36/ J. r AX 5-15-95
, -.!
srnEET JOB NAMf. "
3892. PRospccr AVE IOe. DFLRAY ßEAC~~ GOLF COURSE CLUBHOUSE
·--'·C.i~TA'TËÃND liP CODE JOB LOCATION .------.--
.. ."' WEST PALM ßEAClLELJ3Q69__ HOMfWOO[).BLYD__....Œ:J..BßLßEAO.L£L__ ...... - ....
.- - --- -----.--.. -.--..--..----.. -.......------... ._._...~-..._._._. -. ....-. ;1
We hereby p,oP<>SG 10 i.
,
,
!¡
.'
, :
CHANGE ORDER :1
"
,
"
INSTAlLATION OF 24 OZ COPPER WALKWAY (24"X80")
PRICE ........",...,........".., $600,00 /
;
;t- 'I
o\) 'I
::
:1
¥'~ I ~
¡
,
,
. 1
"
,
--- --
Any unpaid balance shall bear interest at 1,5% per month after 30 days from due date. In the event it shall be
I necessary to employ an attorney to collect any sum of money due hereunder, Owner or Builder agreos to pay all costs or
collection including a reasonable attorney's fee. All invoices are payable COD,
! We assume no responsibility (or damage caÜsed by act of God. or any act beyond our control.
! The terms and conditions printed on the back hereof, are referred to and made a part ollhl$ proposal.
,
Accepted by Buyer SOUTHERN COAST ENTERPRISES "
,I
this day of 199 "
By By(ìÁLu~A<1 f.wJ'{t.~
By - --. -, ~--"~.
___'___44'___~ __._~~__________ ___ AS AI¿II:!9..~IZED R§£!3§~§.!:IJ~IIV~.. -,
u_ -~-----------_.__..._--_._..._-_..__......_.._- -.-..-. - ...
MRY-15-1995 14:53 96% P.02
. '
Southern Coast Enterprises
1 '577 S.w. 1st Way. Bay lIE
Deerfield Beach, Florida 33064
LiCmltd (30'5)426-3312 DATE INVOICE #
InJlmd Lie. #CCC 0'504'51 7/25/95 2269
BILL TO:
O'CONNOR AND TAYLOR
3892 PROSPECT AVE #7
WEST PALM BEACH, FL. 33404
>
AMOUNT
RE: THE DELRAY COUNTRY CLUB
ADDITIONAL CHARGE FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF CRACKED SUPRADUR 900,00
SHINGLES
(2 ?~ i ~ I7tcÛ.C ~I/¡ ~
I L
rí: .- ~") i . ''ì}'''''''' -;.
y VÚf¡t( ~ W'7c4Jfr . -=> '1r ()X> '7 l ()L-
3 .tIAl~ f iW1 6fß1 ~~ ~ .1f c,.cÞ
.. ~, íf
T:;') í) J-. a ~ . ~ w '
lJI u( V ~ \¿/.;ft~ /' \~,UL 26 '995~\ .'
. h {)lw\~ ;6," ~.. \\~c=,:r~ .",
~? . II d! l~ '")_h&~ __ ~~-_.--_.
n,,}~ =t ' If...- '2...\j ---- ,
I"J (,.iV'" is ./ ....j ,
G I tu * fð i () \(. ¡
\. 0/
- /
\, /
'''=.--'-~
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS TOTAL
. '
. .
.
Superior ~fire Sprinf((ersJ Inc.
'if Fire Protection Systems
222 JUPiter Street
Jupiter) FforUfa. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634 rr~f?nfVIL~
April 28, 1995 r:! MAY 02 1995 il i
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR U~ '.'
L:J ~[5u [j'ë:;O
ATTN: Joe Taylor ~~~~Ñ~._8&~~~..~.~~·_-~~~---
3892 Prospect Ave, #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #6
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving the relocation
of sprinkler heads in exterior covered porch, as requested by the
fire inspector. Attached is a work order for the details of the
work performed.
GRAND TOTAL $ 360.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $360.00. Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
j)~'R~btv
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DSCC.cab
-,- 13gnáeá - Insureá
, '
.
" .
-
Superior :Tire Sprinklers! Inc.
,if Fire Protection Systems
222 ]upiœr Street
]Uþiœr) Fforida. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634
April 28, 1995
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR
ATTN: Joe Taylor
3892 Prospect Ave. #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #9
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving four ( 4 )
sprinkler heads relocated in lobby area sheetrock ceilings to
provide additional floor coverage. Attached is a work order for
a further explanation of the details of the work performed,
GRAND TOTAL $ 450.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $450.00. Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter,
Sincerely,
;)bJJ£' 1(~~
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DBGC,co9 r P(¡i)r?~1
,-~-- Pi
¡ MAY 0 2 1995 ! \ \ \
L .-_.-~ L.:J@
\ U L~ I..::) L.::1U U
.---~-----------------------
--- 130ndeá - Insureá
. '
.
-
Superior !fire Sprink.{ers, Inc.
'il Fire ProtectWn Systems
222 JUPiter Street
Jupiter} Fforida. 33458
(407) 575-9001
FAX (407) 575-0634
April 28, 1995
O'CONNOR & TAYLOR
ATTN: Joe Taylor
3892 Prospect Ave. #7
West Palm Beach, FL 33404
RE: DELRAY GOLF CLUBHOUSE - CHANGE ORDER #10
Dear Joe,
The total cost indicated below is for work involving two (2 )
sprinkler heads added to attic protection in area designated "Porte
Cochere". Attached is a work order for a further explanation of the
details of the work performed,
GRAND TOTAL $ 270.00
Please issue a Change Order in the amount of $270.00, Thank you
for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
~~ ~-L.
Dave Ruble
Vice President
DBGC.calQ ~' "'n¡?!~
-----....,
¡ n V ~ q :1
i 1¡! Mfl,,;" 1995 II
JLb -'"'~
-" - ....:J
--, _.- -. - - ~ - ... .>,...~..._------
130ndeá - Insureá -
.
.
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER ,Af01
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # C¡.6 - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
FUNDING REOUEST/ATLANTIC HIGH SCHOOL VARS ITY CHEER-
LEADERS
DATE: DECEMBER 8, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider a funding request from
the Atlantic High School Varsity Cheerleaders to help cover the
$10,000 cost of attending the national cheerleading competition
in Dallas, Texas.
The squad competed in a National Cheerleaders' Association camp
and were awarded a bid to the Dallas competition. They have been
holding various fundraisers to cover the costs for travel,
hotels, meals, registration and competition fees, uniforms, etc.
for the 14 team members and two coaches.
Recommend consideration of the funding request from the Atlantic
High School Varsity Cheerleaders to help cover the cost of
attending the national cheerleading competition in Dallas, Texas.
The uncommitted balance in the Commission Special Events (Account
No. 001-1111-511-48.10) is $750. I recommend a grant of $500 in
response to this request.
<$ 600 ~}~~
& ~ ~ cØ '¡~SõO
~~ -
j -c)
.
.
MON 15:27 FAX 407 243 1532 ATLANTIC H,S. 141 002
12/04/95
- .
Atlantiv Community High School
Varsity Cheerleaders
2501 Seacrest Blvd.
Delray Bea(:h. FL 33444
Leanne leGro, Head Coach
(407) 243-1505
David T. Harden, Cit)i Manager
100 NW 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, FL :B444
Dear Mr. Harden:
I am writing this Jetter to ask for your assistance and support. The Atlantic CommuDit~' High School
Varsity Cheerleaders have qualified to attend national cheerJeading compctition in Dallas, Texas, this
December. This is the first time in the history of tbe 8chool that a checrleading squad has aChieyed
this honor, The squad attended and competcd in a National Cheerleaders Association camp this summer,
and were awardcd ét bid to the competition. as well as superior ratings in all evaluation categories. The
team, which consists or l(one) male and 13 (lhirteen) fcm<'l.le mcmbers, have been holding various
Í\mdrilisers Î1\ ¡In effon to ruise the approximately $10,000.00 needed to covCt the cost of attending the
cornpetitìon. These monies include travel, botels, meals, registration & competition fees, unifOtttls, etc,
for t1\e 14 team members Clnd two coaches. Our fundrai~ing effons have been added to 25+ practice bours
per week already SpCTlt in preparation for regular season games, pcp rallics and events,
It has recently COl'ne to my attent1(,n that tl\C City of DelTay allocßles funds to deserving groups or students
fTom the DelTa)' area. As this is the first time in the history of the school that any cheerleading team has
bees é\sked to eompetc in any tournament, Icl alone a nalional one, { can't think of a more deserving group.
Although we have been working hard to raise all the monies needed for our trip, il would be a huge hclp
lo the team if lhc city could allocate funds to suppon our efforts. Any assistance you could provide in tlùs
arca would bc greatly appreciated, The opportunity to compete at the national level is one thai does not
come along on a rcgular basis. and ít would be a shame if our YOW1g people couldn't participate due to
lack of funds. Not to mention the wonderful image a 1\Blionally competitivc team portrays for our city.
Ifthcre is anything I can do to help obtain this request, or any further information I can providc, feel free
to call me at (407) 243-1505 (days) Ot (407) 737.0545 (cvenings).
'rhank you ror your lime, and support
Sincerely,
\. ,(' .,? :j)i a
'0-)-< (,L.._..._,,-__ ,,-). /..- ,_ '. L:>
(, _J ',_, .....,
Leanne S. LcGro
Head Coach
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FLORIDA - CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - DECEMBER 12, 1995 - 6:00 P.M.
PUBLIC HEARINGS - 7:00 P.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS
AGENDA ADDENDUM
THE REGULAR AGENDA IS AMENDED TO INCLUDE:
~9.F. CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #2}/MOLLOY BROTHERS, INC. : Consider
Contract Addition (C.O. #2) to Molloy Brothers, Inc. for the
\ ,/0 removal and replacement of 161 linear feet of deteriorated 1211
sanitary sewer main and two manholes, in the amount of $25,670
from 442-5178-536-63.51).
9.G. REOUEST FOR SPECIAL EVENT PERMIT: Approve a request for a
Special Event permit for the Florida Jaycees to hold a
carnival in the northwest area of the Delray Beach Mall, from
December 27, 1995 through January 7, 1996.
I'
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER{1'7U(
SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # 9F - MEETING OF DECEMBER 12, 1995
CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #2)/MOLLOY BROTHERS, INC.
DATE: DECEMBER 11, 1995
This is before the Commission to consider Contract Addition (C.O.
#2) to Molloy Brothers, Inc. for the removal and replacement of 161
linear feet of deteriorated 12" sanitary sewer main and two man-
holes on s.w. 2nd Street between S.W. 1st Avenue and Swinton Ave-
nue. This is in addition to the Atlantic Avenue/Miramar Drive
Stormwater Pump Station project.
The Commission previously approved a Contract Addition (C.O. #1) to
replace the sewer line segment immediately west of the segment now
being requested. Several sinkholes had developed over the first
line segment due to the deteriorated condition of the line. After
completing construction on the first segment, we attempted to clean
the sand and silt out of the downstream line, only to discover the
line was so badly deteriorated that we could not clean it. Thus we
are requesting this second Contract Addition for Molloy Brothers.
Funding in the amount of $25,670 is available from Renewal and
Replacement - Sewer Mains (Account No. 442-5178-536-63.51) .
Recommend approval of Contract Addition (C.O. #2) to Molloy
Brothers, Inc.
.
.
DEP ARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
MEMORANDUM
TO: David T. Harden
City Manager
FROM: Howaro WIy/L
Dep. Dir. of t IOn
DATE: December 8, 1995
SUBJECT: Atlantic AvenuelMiramar Drive Stonnwater Pump Station (95-30)
Agenda Request of Additional Change Order #2
Staff requests the City Commission to consider approval of additional Change Order #2 to
Molloy Brothers, Inc, for the Atlantic Avenue/Miramar Drive Stonnwater Pump Station
(project 95-30), Change Order #2 is for the removal and replacement of an existing of
161 If of deteriorated 12" sanitary sewer main and two (2) manholes on S.W. 2nd Street
between S,W. 1st Avenue and Swinton Avenue. This segment of pipe was identified as
needing replaced when Molloy was repairing the segment immediately to the west per
Contract Addition (C.O. #1) previously approved and the pipe was clean of sand and silt
fÌ"om infiltration.
The price fÌ"om Molloy includes all labor equipment and materials to replace the piping,
dewatering, by-pass pumping, traffic maintenance and surface restoration to a like or
better condition,
The amount of Change Order #2 is $25,670.00. Funding Source is R&R Sewer Mains
442-5178-536-63.51,
CC: Dan Beatty, P.E., City Engineer
Memos to City Manager
mem09530.doc
.
.
.
CITY OF DELRA Y BEACH
CHANGE ORDER TO ORIGINAL CONTRACT
CHANGE NO. 2 PROJECT NO, 95-30 DA1E:
PROJEer TITLE: Atlantic Avenue / Miramar Drive Stonnwater Pump Station
TO CONTRAerOR: Molloy Brothers, Inc.
YOU ARE HEREBY REQUESTED TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING CHANGES IN THE PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS FOR
TInS PROJEer AND TO PERFORM THE WORK ACCORDINGLY, SUBJEer TO ALL CONTRAer STIPULATIONS AND
COVENANTS,
JUSTIFICATION: Remove and Replace 168 if of existing deteriorated 12" VCP on S.W. 2nd St ûom Swinton Ave. and S.W 1st
Ave. with new 12" C-9OQ pipe. Work to be done in accordance with the schedule of items below. All other incidental work required
to complete the work is included in the items below:
1) Mobilization and Traffic Maintenance 1 LS x $1,600.00 = $ 1,600,00
2) Manhole (10' depth) 1 EA x $2,450,00 = $ 2,450.00
3) Drop Manhole (10' depth) 1 EA x $2,950.00 = $ 2,950.00
4) Rem Exist 12" VCPlInst 12" C-900 161 LF x $ 75.00 = $12,075.00
5) Service Lateral Replacement 2 EA x $ 500.00 = $ 1,000,00
6) Roadway Restoration 215 SY x $ 23.00 = $ 4,945.00
7) Swale Grading / Sprinkler Repair 1 LS x $ 650.00 = $ 650.00
Total $25,670.00
SUMMARY OF CONTRAer AMOUNT
ORIGINAL CONTRAer AMOUNT $727,955.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES PREVIOUSLY ORDERED $ 22,800,00
ADJUSTED CONTRAer AMOUNT PRIOR TO THIS CHANGE ORDER $750,755.00
COST OF CONSTRUCTION CHANGES THIS ORDER $ 25,670.00
ADJUSTED CONTRAer AMOUNT INCLUDING THIS CHANGE ORDER $776,425.00
PER CENT INCREASE THIS CHANGE ORDER 3.5 %
TOTAL PER CENT INCREASE TO DA1E 6,6 %
TIME EXTENSION: Q Calendar Days
CERlil'l1ill STA1EMENT: I hereby certify that the supporting cost data included is, in my
considered opinion, accurate,
Molloy Brothers, Inc.
FWlding Source: 442-5178-536-63,51 (R & R - Sewer Mains)
DELLRA Y BEACH, FLORIDA by its City Commission
RECOMMEND: By:
William H, Greenwood, Director Thomas E, Lynch, Mayor
of Environmental Services
AITEST:
APPROVED: By:
City Attorney City Clerk
.
.
.
( (
.
w
>
<C
NOT TO SCAl.£
r-
if)
~
.
5
.
if) s. W. f2~N,~~
,.. /~
¡ \-
\
}
/
',- --- r
~ -~"
-~'
I ¡
l
.
" i j :1:\ 1..- w
>
«
PROJEC"'
CD I 'z
C.O. 0
r-
z
5
if)
,¿;&- CITY of DELRAY BEACH ~r:a Emergency Replacement I Sketch
~ ENVIRONYENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT LOCATION #1
4:U sotrm !I'IDftON j.VEHOE. UUU,y BACH. ~ :ss444
.
-
Agenda Item No. :
AGENDA REQUEST
Date: December 8, 1995
Request to be p~aced on:
X Regular Agenda
-- Special Agenda
Workshop Agenda When: December 12, 1995
Description of item (who, what, where, how much) : Staff requests City
Commission to approve add Contract Addition (C.O. #2) to Molloy Brothers, Inc.
for the Atlantic Ave / Miramar Drive Storrnwater Pump Station - (95-30). C. O.
#2 is for removal and replacement of 161 If of existing deteriorated 12"
sanitary sewer main and two (2) manholes on S.W 2nd St between S. W. 1st Ave and
Swinton Ave. This segment of pipe was identified as needing replaced when
Molloy was repairing the segment immediately to the west per Contract Addition
(C.' O. #1) previously approved and the pipe was cleaned of sand and silt from
infiltration.
The price from Molloy includes all labor equipment and material to replace the
piping, dewatering, by-pass pumping, traffic maintenance and surface restoration
to a like or better condition.
The amount of C. O. #2 is $25,670.00. Funding Source is R&R Sewer Mains 442-
5178-536-63.51.
ORD:INANCE/RESOLtJ'TION REQUIRED: YES.(§ DRAFT ATTACHED YE@97
Recommendation: Staff Recommends a C· #2)
Department Head Signature:
Determination of Consistency
City Attorney Review/Recommendation (if applicable) :
Budqet Director Review (required on al~ items involvinq expenditure of funds):
Funding available: ~NO
Funding alternatives "i/A (if ay>liCable)
Account No. & Description Wd" 5178"- 5?G-c:''J r:;¡ ('fJ+C;. 72.-t'. 5"€"toJer2- /'^fI-lfIIS)
Account Balance f"J.Lf7 .1t¡3.~ ' ,
I ~ /';)-/III'f"
Ci ty Manaqer Review:
Approved for agenda: YES/NO
Hold Until:
Aqenda Coordinator Review:
Received:
Placed on Agenda:
Action:
Approved/Disapproved
/agen9530.doc
.
.
.
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA - CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - DECEMBER 12, 1995 - 6:00 P.M,
PUBLIC HEARINGS - 7:00 P.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS
AGENDA ADDENDUM
THE REGULAR AGENDA IS AMENDED TO INCLUDE:
9.F. CONTRACT ADDITION (C.O. #2}/MOLLOY BROTHERS, INC. : Consider
Contract Addition (C.O. #2) to Molloy Brothers, Inc. for the
removal and replacement of 161 linear feet of deteriorated 12"
sanitary sewer main and two manholes, in the amount of $25,670
from 442-5178-536-63.51}.
¿ REQUEST FOR SPECIAL EVENT PERMIT, Approve a request for a
Special Event permit for the Florida Jaycees to hold a
, 0 carnival in the northwest area of the Delray Beach Mall, from
6/ December 27, 1995 through January 7, 1996.
. '
.
L¡j<
V1.11
MEMORANDUM
TO: DAVID T. HARDEN - CITY MANAGER
FROM: LULA BUTLER - DIRECTOR, COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT
SUBJECT: REQUEST TO HOLD A CARNIVAL - DELRA Y BEACH MALL
DATE: DECEMBER 11, 1995
ITEM BEFORE THE COMMISSION:
Consideration of a request from the Florida Jaycees to hold a Carnival at the outparcel of the Delray
Beach Mall, (comer of Linton Boulevard and Federal Highway) from December 27, 1995 through
January 7, 1996. Hildebrand's Amusement is the company providing the service, This action is
before the Commission pursuant to Section 2.4.6 (H) of the LDR's,
BACKGROUND:
Written authorization from the General Manager of the mall is attached along with a site plan
indicating the location of the carnival and associated parking. Proposed hours of operation are:
Monday through Thursday: 5:00 PM to 1O:00PM
Friday: 5:00 PM to 11:00PM
Saturday: 12:00 noon to 11 :OOPM
Sunday: 12:00 noon to 1O:00PM
The non-profit organization has requested a waiver to any fees required. Staff will document the
Jaycees participation in the fundraiser and if eligible, the 70% waiver to permit fees will be granted,
pursuant to City Commission policy.
The required investigation of the applicants business reputation, permits and approved inspections
from the health department and normal building requirements will be met. We would also require
the hiring of off-duty police as mandated by the police department for security,
RECOMMENDATION:
Staffis recommending positive consideration of the Jaycees request along with the requirement to
hire off-duty police for security as directed by staff.
CARNIV AL96
1
qG
.
· . M I NOL jR¡:ok. F R.-'<; PAGE 02
_.,-,
¡~ ...,~ ¡r Florida
¡ '.."
ì
I
I
I
To Whom It May Cancer":
Tne Junior Cha~~r of Commerce/J.ycees would like to hold our .nnuøl
Holiday Carnival again this year at the Oelray Beach Mallon December
27. to January 7, 1996. with the Carnival Comøany arriving on Monday,
Oecember 25th to set up and the Carnival will open on ~.dn.eday Night
The Carnival will name ~~ insured for one million dolla~.. .. ten mi1-
lion .ggr.gate, the City of Delray Beach. Florida, tn. D.l,.~y Beach
Mall and the Jaycee~ and each will reeiev. a copy of the 1neurance.
The Carnival is owned by Hildebrand's Midway of Fun, IncorþQrated:
They ",ill L Will provide insurance.
2. will p~ovide p~rtable toilet~.
3. Will provide trash elean-up and ,..mQval daily.
4. Will nave off duty pOlice during carnival hour..
5. Will provide promotion at the event.
4.. will þrovide 5ecurity for the p~operty when net op.n.
7. No stakes are driven into your parking lot.
S. Canvas tarps are plaoed under ride. so oil does not
ruin grass or asphalt.
" S tee 1 trailer legs nave wooden blocks under them.
10. Any canva$ on game booths are fir. retardant, with oer-
tificates_
1l. All ride~ will be inspected by State and local i",peot-
tors before the 5how opens.
Sinc.,.ely;
Øk·(~¿~
!ton 80....n
Junior Chamber of Commerce/3aycees
,
· .,...
FAX
PAG£ 0.)
f 0
'1
'" rr¡
!:' r
2 U) .:0
~»
t,.,., -<
..
~ CO
~~
~2
~
»
r
r
~ ~;;{J
~ ~ f'T1
~ ~;;
-
r-
I
I
,
t
r'1 I NOL ;,A, :+:1 FAX
PAGE 04
S êU 'Ol ô..A'.:]
-..... .. - -- "] - - -
~ t,~~~ ~"'-----'-"-~-rn c:I ~. r* tJ'.
,.,' ,..'__.__,_.____,.' --1
~ -......,......-..~...._... ..'._.~.. ,.~. ...\...... ..,.,.... ...-...,........,........-.,#,._-~,......,.....- .
k~("\ r · \l¡ COCO . ~
C;+Q,::"o;.)Od·· ~
i
.~ !
t
J
.,.., CO 3 3 ø
- ))
- . '" 3
~ - . - '
("I - " .0- !J-. !J.
-t- ~ ~
f ""'\ j ~ (0 -
- ..,
'" :.:c.. t . I" co
Sa
~ , r
- p
$t ~
3 ~ I 10
! r
I
,
t r
¡
)
1 ~
, ~
/-t--
(j)~
! B ~
"'t- ~X
~X ~.\1fJ\ P ~ W f;:
-...........,-............., .
e::. ~+~ r --
£
- := ___t___ ___.. _____ ~-aW'Q0
.......- ..., -
. .'.... ',...",'~,,~....._-----..~....
ë-nA 'ðl ''(J) ~ N
-
, '
M I HOl fA! :+:1 FRX PAr%: 05
-..._______'__4.._'_·______.... j.,__ ... -- -- _ _ ____ ·.n··.. -.- --.-.. ,-'. ..--. ... - - ~._._.__ ---.i..
.,..... .....'...-..---.- ,--'~. ---.......- .....-.".
M..... CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE "tVl OAT! (MMIOO"'VI
(,/:?1/9:'i
I'ItOOUCiR fHiSCERTlFìëATE is 'ŠSUEÒ-AS A MATTiR OF INFORMATION NLV AND
HAAS . ÞlllKERSON [NSUR~H(;( CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON TI* CERrlFICATI HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE
HAAS MtL.,ÞEPSÐN WUHl.Pt~O r·J\.1 . DOES NOT AMEND. eXTEND OR ALTER THE COVeRAGE AFFORDED BY THE
POUCIES BElOW.
~300 SIfAMNEE MISSION PA~ (WA\' ---....-..
I SHAMMU. MI9S1[)~, ItS E;620~. COMPANIES AFFORDING COVERAGE
f~T~~~NV A CJGNn } tlSm'AHtl COMf'flHV
INtUJIID f~T~:~NV B
HILOE9RANOS MIOWAY or F IJt4 {Nt f~T~~~NY C
20(,0 'Πun AVUWf; t~T~~~NV D
,O.PANO BEACH FL 330~O
f~W~:NY E
".- u. _.__ '''...--'.-'- ,.... '--__·__.~r
CO\ÆRAClE'
THIS 18 TO CERTIFY THAT THIi POI-I(:1ES Of INSIJIIANCE LISTED 8ELOW HAVE 8EEN ISSUED TO THE INSURiD NAMED A80VE 'Oft TH~ POLICY 1'1"100
I NOtCATiD. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, nllM OR CONCITION OF ANY çQNTRACT OR OTHER OOCUMlNT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH ,.,..1$
CEftrtFlcATE MAY Be ISSUED 0" MAY PERTAIN. THE INSURANCE AFFORDED I!V THE POLICIES DESCRIBED H!REIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS,
EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POliCIES, LIMITS SHOWN MAY H,WE eEEN REDUCED BY PA.lD CLAIMS.
:co TV,., 0. INBURANCf POUC:Y NUMIER !'OLICY I~~ICTIVE POLICV UP'"A T1( \ L~
L1ft DATE ~MMI )OIYY DATE (MMiODIYVI
, GENE""L uaR.lT:Y ~ ., ..' ~;,.,-- .,----...., '-",r7TJTi ~J ~ 4f, . GENEflAL AOOAEG. TE ·
X COMM£IICIAL OEIWt".L L:AiltLITY I'I\OOIJCTS'COM~IOP AGG, · ~OOO()OO
¡ CLAIMS MADf )( OCCUlt lEllSONAl .. ADII, INJURY · JOOOOOO
OWNEA'$ Ii CONTIIACTOR'S ""'DT, EliCH OCCI)IIMNCE , 1000000 -
~AI! DA_ (Any 9n. ,.., , '0000
'-leD. EXPENSE IAIW _....-.. .
..._." ·_..·n·,.._. -...-."...
, AU?OMOIIU lIAa.UTV COMIINID BlNOLE
·
ANY AUTO LIMIT
IILL OWNED IIVTO' 1001. Y INJUI'I"
ICHICII.!UD AUTOS ¡!>Of I"'<eo~. ·
MIRfP AVTOS BOOll V INJ"I'IY
II''' '.Q ~I ·
NON,OWNetl "I.ITO&
I3AMG£ LlA"~ITY ·
PROPERTY OAUAG(
..",',...-... ...---.-,,-..... .
; Elicae UAll\.l'fV IACH OCCUIIIIIENCI ·
UMtllfLLA f~A.t AOClR(OAfE ·
OTIIEI'I THAN UMlAElLt. FOAM
,'....-.--,...-.....--. "_+0.. _ .___ ' --
STATUTDIIY LIMIT'
WOfIKIII" COMPilll....TION -.,.".
EACH "CCIPINT ·
AND
OIlUIISI -POI.ICY LIMIT ,
IM'LOYeIlB·u.~nY
DlSJA$r -EACH ENI'\,OVEr ,
0TttI1I . , 5""""TU" .1AIlVAIT ".,
QIlftOMI, fhulClJ1t em or DEUtAY lOCI! FLORIDA
.... Y IIAOII llAu., I
I
..--- "''''-...-.. ---.
DlICIIIPTION 0' OI'lMTiOHtILOCATIOIII/WHlCl.UI8t'IÇI"l ITIMB
Any Carnival Liability In&\Jfance made 8 part of the Policy includes as an additional insured with respect to an occurrence
taking place 8t a Carnival site /11 The Fair or Exhibition Association, sponsoring organization or committee (2) The owner
or I....e thereof end (3) A munioipality ~~~~t.ing, t~~~.!n.:'~~ ì~~P.ermission to operate a Carnival. ~ .In,,
ClltTFICATE HOLPIR CANCEI.LA TION
em or DlLMT 114CIJ SHOUL() ANY 01' THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES 8E CANCELLED II~FOIII! 1141
100 .... 1" .VllÐI EXPIRATJON OAn 'tHEREOF, HI! ISSUING COMPANY Will ENDIAVOR TO
JlJ.Uy llACIf. J'LOItM 'I)
MAIL " DAYS WRITTEN NOTICf oro THE C~TIf'ICAn HOLDER NAMED TO ntl
LEFT. BUT FAILuRe TO MAIL SUCH NOTICE SHA~l IMPOSt NO OBLIGATION OR
lIABIL TV OF ANY' KIND UPON 1HE COMPANY, ITS AGENTS OR l'IiPRESENTATIVfS,
-_....' "---."-'-- ~
___~_'~::-~".' 9 ¡g¡
ACORD 26·8 (7/901 CACORD CORPORATION 19!J0
. '