Loading...
02-10-15 Workshop Meeting AgendaCITY COMMISSION DELRAY e► CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA WORKSHOP MEETING — TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2015�'�"�"�' 6:00 P.M. DELRAY BEACH CITY HALL 1 X39$ 2001 The City will furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Contact the City Manager at 243 -7010, 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. WORKSHOP AGENDA 1. Public Comments 2. Discussion regarding the Delray Beach Dune Management Program 3. Public Art Advisory Board Presentation 4. Delray Beach Historical Society Presentation 5. Discussion regarding Sidewalk Deferral Update and Mobility Fee. 6. Commission Comments Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, such person will need to ensure that a verbatim record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. The City neither provides nor prepares such record. MEMORANDUM TO: Mayor and City Commissioners FROM: Donald B. Cooper, City Manager DATE: January 29, 2015 SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM WS.2 - WORKSHOP MEETING OF FEBRUARY 10, 2015 DISCUSSION REGARDING THE DELRAY BEACH DUNE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM DISCUSSION Robert H. Barron from Coastal Management and Consulting will discuss The Delray Beach Dune Management program and the current condition of the program. PRESENTATION ELEMENTS GRAPHIC HISTORY OF THE BEACH AND THE DUNE PROGRAM What's the current condition and how did it develop. Natural history Management and restoration history Rare plant conservation Vista restoration Permit conditions Atlantic Dunes Park THREATS TO THE SYSTEM Overwhelming exotic contamination Expanding seagrape monoculture Reduced dune stability and storm protection Permit noncompliance results in loss of vista Dune evolution results in loss of vista Increasing repair and maintenance /management cost WHAT THE CITY NEEDS TO DO Recognize the situation and the cost of complacency and neglect IMMEDIATELY CONTROL EXOTIC PLANT CONTAMINATION ON BEACH DUNE Reevaluate to update the program and assign clear responsibility for oversight Develop and adopt a revised Dune Management Plan for the Municipal Beach and ADP Commit to funding the Plan WHAT BPOA CAN DO Insist that the City take action Follow up Nag More nagging A copy of the presentation is available at: www.mydelraybeach.com then go to: Departments • City Clerk • Document Archives • City Commission Meetings Agendas and Backups H dA ca ca G i V fC m L v Cv C O a U 0 Q i v 3 O v 0 a U a v m a v M i v v U v Q i 01 H H a) 00 (L L O s CL a) _ o m s ° C u L U 7 a) }r CO 4- (1) — '(6 W -a o -� U C 4- CL U Vl V) +, C L O C -a V) U OL 0 cn a) 'a a) N U vi 4� C O 4. F- U, u � C N +O+ C W` w 4' O E °' �: E / C CQ •E L a) +J U a) s aC) E C7 C a) o Z o c� O h s L m tw O L W > O� C L > O C W (1) _ O O C O Z 76 N E a) U = 4- a..i Z a) : -� E Q to > Vl Vl _C •E �-+ O L w U u S O L ii L ii L 3 s° s Q L N H N H Ln F- Z W W J Q V H J O a O s w U a .0 0 O s 3 a +' (1) caa0) to o nz U N _Q C U O (6 00 a) C L bio i 4 , O O > ° a) = d a) O , a O a O av3 ) U ° � o o c > s 4' > O nn � a nn 4 , nz �' C o a) E + s a) Y o aMi a) O o o ° N N Ln E Ln as U E 3 *' 11 In C� O O- Q N C C C +�•� V m - c U> c ° �? Vi Vi -a c O U aa0i > C s o a) z0 s U s 1 0 s bD t 4, N c o 3 o a) nz L ° •� a 3 N a) C C a) +' O a) (A 4' O = C w O = W w 'a C L C C: Q (6 U +m' C a) L L Q- +' C E Ln N W _ C a) O U CL m ca 'a U a) U a) vOi CL O a) O L O Z 2 U s N ,_ L 00 O O s f6 E c Q O O a) C C U Q 3 7 um W C +� m a) o `~ U m O � � O U 1 f6 a) C 3 z U a) v m O m a) o -0 x a) � a) o x a) a) ° L a +, (n 4 , (n CO (n > W L CCI tw O M O Ln 00 I� 00 0) 0) Ol Ol Ol Ol Ol c-I c-I c-I c-I c-I O O M Ln 00 Ol M t.0 I-� N Ln Q Ln r- r r" r 00 00 00 00 0, 00 W 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) c-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I r-I a) 00 (L ^W ^Y, W r ^Y, ^W, W C71A i 4l i D U fC m L D E .� O nz 4 � � s � 0 E 3 c E o E L +' O (p U U L N om- O O •� U m (6 E m O � � 3 a) O +, N U +, U C > O Q U a a, E s o U -a a) � o E CL C to tin 0 C a) L Q U s s (6 -a N vOi C � 7 7 L (6 � O_ U Q Co a) E s > E C � f6 � O tin 4, L L O Q Q (6 Q a L � N s v ,} VI (6 O ' s U ::a O a CL s L O O O E •? a) 7 tw CA a) C s L nz E a s a) E *' C O N U U N i a) tw CL CO C 0 > C ca C a) Q � � C s s a) tw C Q a) C C m t O CL E a) s s }r •3 a) 7 C C O U O a) `o w a) tin nz a C a c a) E a) tin m C f6 Z C C C: a) w C a) E > p E s W C s 'C C7 'L Z_ L f6 0 O Z y y� m C W = C Z L aC) s cn a N Z o W U- Cl nz 4- CC _: 4- U o 4; c = m E 0 p —° 3 a-•; O C> C c tw -a i L 7 C 0 O U Q E C w a) C o m .O +� o .� CA a) p 0 3 M O_ VI � N C •E Q 0 4, C m > � CL -a C U- a) to M a) a) E L N CA s L a) > O C tw VI L U 7 N U c > O a) i L (6 C —-a '} a) O O a) N a) �_ O E a a) a) O E s +, U C O Z 4- a) a) = L U U a) s -a C1 W m W a) — (6 a) U L` s a) U LL -a L pl 'E C LJJ N ia• i`n• � L V) a-•� ` s u Q O C O s Q L L a) O O Q a) -0 L m L o U C t6 1 Q) a) m m > O O f6 — C Q) a) U C O (E6 j O N 4 I'm a) -a C L a) J +� U �n •� E L ,n f6 U a) L -0 W- f6 L 0 O a a) to E -a O Co >, ' W p W a) >= O O a) .0 a) 0 Q O Q >, S ±, N 0 0 0 N E �6 a) O a CL U LL tw a s a) a nz U u O Q Q Q p a Z a E tw -a C 'E m ::a L C E qA > -a C C L O E Q � a) L O E O O C o E a) Q Q a) E u U O U U O O 0 0 C: a a C: 0 c6 X a) H X s C +� U z w > L } o u C a) a) E C C W I 4� C a 0 N O U z O -a -� O N -a Qa) > C , a U z U U a O O O O N N °O Q 0) 0 0 0 0 � W Ol O O O O O O O E .� O nz 4 � � s � 0 E 3 c E o E L +' O (p U U L N om- O O •� U m (6 E m O � � 3 a) O +, N U +, U C > O Q U a a, E s o U -a a) � o E CL C to tin 0 C a) L Q U s s (6 -a N vOi C � 7 7 L (6 � O_ U Q Co a) E s > E C � f6 � O tin 4, L L O Q Q (6 Q a L � N s v ,} VI (6 O ' s U ::a O a CL s L O O O E •? a) 7 tw CA a) C s L nz E a s a) E *' C O N U U N i a) tw CL CO C 0 > C ca C a) Q � � C s s a) tw C Q a) C C m t O CL E a) s s }r •3 a) 7 C C O U O a) `o w a) tin nz a LL CA C) ui �s= — _:. ❑ W aj o � Qj V1 W — 5 Q W C bio oC M W L ❑ ❑ 0 S - � a LU U nro LU Ln LU cn LU LL I Ln Z) lD 00 r-I D LL LU LL 0 LU L/) D 0 r ca Joe milt I _ C� a-J V) .0 a� .E cu CL V) c� 0 r� a� U 0 L- 0 W 4-J U L U Fs1 4.� 0 4 0' U 0 4-J • .ul aj 0 -0 aJ 0 C- U 4-J . r A W40 "w t y r n r e , ■ y . -,Jowlpv 9 wll�i • 14 ty, Ln I. Lui 0 J CL a L - e� �("�� ar'' L _� f vto LM _ t r v 4 _ _ a Q J CL a L - e� �("�� ar'' L _� f vto LM W <A k, 2L� -5 _ t r v 4 _ _ W <A k, 2L� -5 L (/) 2 C v N CZO c6 ro U m N m x ti MIT tt x V , , -7 7 Ilk ot s- ��� rIFn t Cif _ s Ni- # OW Ilk Ar 700 N. OCEAN'.* moor IN 1969 r _ti i7 9� -� - r 4L r. �. 10 O.r, a41 Ne gl-iborhood Past THE WAY WE WERE ( 1 (�04-7 Special to Neighbzorhood Post Quiet corner DELRAY BEACH — Where are .ail the people? The cars? The city hasn't seen this kind of emptiness since :.. well, at least 1969 when this picture was taken of the 'intersection at Atlantic Avenue and the beach by the 5eacrest Hotel, now a Marriott. FciG -_o Courtesy 9orida Photographic Collection All washed out DELRAY BEACH --� This 1972 shot shows a section of AIA that was washed out during a storm. r- l "Hard solution" IW 4- - %�- iled within one year­­ a mom �• -- 19 7 2 J � 4 � T � wk -fl �r 3 1973 First Nourishment ti WW + 1 if 4" 11ti S Fl;. X, WIN /y 4a a A 17 Awl 4 7, Ts. X7 Non native Hawaiian seagrape and sand fenced installed in late 70's to keep sand from blowing into the street. Thanksgiving 1984.. 3 day Northeaster erodes most of the nourished beach almost back to the sidewalk. Thanksgiving 1984 storm caused 90 ft. recession of high water line in 3 days. r M 0'! let t Ta I +�4 .- . -- _ •:ice .-..,- ���� -.T. X y'. y,, E • � v y . } }e - °- .- ' 's _ - - '„'r`� +rah �r _ . �•?,c.'.. �;; "��:ec} - s - - - - ,�,� . •4_ Flo'''.,- . 1984 dune planting installed sea oats in a 6 to 12 foot wide Strip just to seaward of the exotic Hawaiian seagrape - Ag The initial contracted installation failed, but CDB Parks staff used the contract retainage to purchase plants and finish the job with better than 95 per cent survival. No other dune grasses have been added. i i ;•s� 7 < � I T 11 a 1980 Scaevola hedge S r 1 - b L JJ ALL of the seagrapes on Delray Beach p r ' started from t h i size in 19 S0 . - " • `tip ti _ * - - — - _ e e ' f `i y Seagrapes planted in 1980 did not begin to thrive until after sea oats foredune was established in 1984-then grew to 25 ft. in the next 16 years. 1'. 4 - a: A Between 1955 and 1997 the unmanaged dune grew. Z -- tom- - w fr U. m the street wa.• . ' �t i Comprehensive Dune Management Plan was written in 1997, to include pruning, replanting. EYJs TiNG CONni•i ON tsisliAg ioretnx txglic I IaN'Ai *Ti14(Jlgr.�pG lv bo rrmovcJ SRAIA nufxr� I R ff wiJf� sidewalk bench vrall 98wida 'J It wick ARQPOSED MODiF(CA'TfONS . .. - � sees eicarwl nperntu: scavuka m ba teplamed with mix aio.6vc v.u4vtll gr+®d sh[uhs and palmeueks This u an aetw d Aun=,}xd, armed h�YA, token of FLDZti --Kw 064; ttb -kl, Tlw putpuae of ibis hawingss be:lpuly rkl'ur illt luopnted i�iaf rnud�atitw. end hvB lems mainkeeence plans (r Wis 4GIak of the dour M:Mc�r a:.xsc wAlkway% u i by refek"ee, fat the nthm sr Kiwi of Lbc dww el dm Nhray Publiu lleack w area which r"de.A oppmx -uAy f = swvc) ntou mn R- Mat d. N"end, m munkxl—dlt-18awk fl z $umh cod of the I'oblie 11esclL cxiskirig swlll� tree[ W 23 h buigbt, lu be tedutd ro Ihrult IkcieN etdstin8 sabre dime grasxii. '� ryA a rem! o aadistwbLJ rcduced teskgrspc canopy to ba memlAiecd laag law av sluub fnkm „- _I __ _ PRIIN iNG1vfR'I'F117DS - _ 1.'[h[s project is iokndeJ to mists The Sltight of na Lorot xwgrapc by n Ivgktiy crown o:duckiaa p,—g W14 W36 i-N, -hove Cade, In chow Fuk the tmt6bl bmeok Of- brmclune sub swum- iu the Bla seavan oiler the pnwiop, lmi Wen to ILAml.m the seagrApes m mur*164c 48 m hn beighl es daubs lone W. M foes and leafptvlvng, wW4 is u luxudt cxraup n MOY. 2.'1., _i_wof xhk.8 saagtp.tucsao�wiil be wwunlP.I by UI—I prwiioe..rw.Hi hdy Ahoy Cade, wbrre srexnt arc spmadiae .woes the ground but tat mmtd WD s� erouod. Tbu is hk wewtt Ilw aad of.tapaj a And prcamr: kb. divusiky ufudxi 3ooc4ouutPa . and paluchw. 3.'Lbe presavbcd ptmd.g bcighls say be h,iWly lower. whM "IY I=d Ii& -akin- V1 Ih has rcardWl iu ldug 6rEK%9 which Cow low Igaiou the grade. C'ommea hwsi.xdtmal axt[sc will I,kt. ad a. Ali w,veg ut d —csri -d by r--ng vv'iU be t I-wd according 10 the Ipcciptuttove nfthc P,j.t AIaaa'fFa of Nut" "cede dune —it. ,mgmper pnmcd c! — to WA& In ci thbf lattral spread..ckmed lew eipl.uled N11L dmte�[srs 21-00.4 FDEP approved plan tt z 0 LID z U aAF.,, I�• � iG�t. Z_+ !!t! Saturday, March 2, 2002 The Palm Beach Post • PalmSeachPostxom _Migrant center program's face financial crisis \ EWS PAGE 4C LOCAL ��; Trimming of Delray sea gapes under fire �Y Itnrrle Paul Ifat�tett lui Brarb Past Sk f Water DELRAY BRACH --- When city workers planted. sea grapes along North Ocean Boulevard bao administration, they c and li die keep the ; But t a.�ter more tear major storm damage Offi grown as high as 24 #'t 50, earlier this Dune trimmed them down - . It's too stark a cl Ta3gtton, a state Dial ronmental Protection "He (city consuka just way over his perr 'He took some large. and cut them down t, appears to be a violati Barron said Tayn again at the permit ht 7he intent was never to allow those sea grapes to establish "Anything larger than 3 inches in diameter obvioisly shouldn't be cut down to 3 feet tall," Tayrtton said. "I personally thinly it's a violation, but at to allow those sea grapes to establish themselves as trees. They were sup- posed to be maintained as a hedge," The intent Barron said, is "to create 9 rmmnIMP dune ecosystetn that`s as -- e09 faints Delray for se a �a A es � P r. said MarkTaynton, afield engineer plants in the city's fi,d80 -fnn, - streets. are P song For the DER L_- kiarrcyn has argued thedune iaself Will sufficiently blocklight and that ga grapes aren't normal dune -line 1)1 >rnts in the first place. As part of a possible penalty, Bar - rnnsaid thestate may require him to plant moreseagrapes alonganother Bart of the beach. Until the matteris resolved, Baron laid the DEP will allow him to go ihead next week and plant new vege- ation, suchas saw palmetto, that was r.ore dominant on dunes decades !eil Santaniello can be reached at mntaniello (rr..suri:scrttirtcl.eom or tit -243 66 25. cut trees to rr room for plai BY Nf i SAKI AAIiF uo > 1 .5 1, i F',' k l 'I J: R DELRAY BEAM - A state mental inspector said Thu r he is going to recommend th be cited forviol ati ng state gi for trimming sea grapes beta along the beach were cha near - stumps. Whether Delray Beach act ceives the violation, and a Pint up to supervisors at the state men t of Env iron.ntentalPro � Y S Trlm DeIr attitude was halted alter Palm Beach Cer 11saw peach coordinator, Babe ilie the results and a8ked, world is going on here ?� Barron said the.re's no proof that the Carr enzgers sea turtles or contributes to erosion, and the city should use other plants to boil sand. Richard Moyrood of Me! - scape ;ays "11atl1ral sea-grap e stands appear to be the result of humane; stopping the occttssonal fires that I would keep them frUtn growing tall enouj;h Lt),-roved out other species. But th=tt doesn'tlessen le value of overmlents and homeowners afte have G c a'snati eh vegetation, be �� a grapes or ❑iatigroWs, often for no reason aside froru 1111proving the view. In Delray Beach, this sort of "atchet job is becoming a habit wurkeTS cut In J997, when city some Moot sea -grape bushes to S inches and uprooted o be l% any tnisutlderstood orders, Recreation Director Joe Weldon said at the tine. Last 111011th. Mr_, Weldon says ]tc cltc.cic� 1 with the Lays beach t:o11yult _ t, Iiob T3, . A - - 1 n it f •V - � rr .���. �_'�._ _ _^� ,ter , + °„"; yr, r • t ��-]� -' �• "'t � 'h`�' 1 4F If .' ads `4 K' - • � _ -Y � .. - : x- �' - ti' '� t After much turmoil and thorough scientific review, FDEP approves and partially funds the comprehensive Delray Beach Dune Management program. i Listed coastal plants have no inherent weakness..but are suffering from habitat loss. Preserving them for future generations simply requires finding safe places to plant them. Delray Beach supports many. Ab Beach verbena grows well in semi - sheltered backdune areas. Threatened species in FL. r A6 - -'`x -! • ' Burrowing four o'clock r `: . • • okenia hypogaea S f r • ' I � r ms's - _ Endangered Florida} F � F . v J -a• 'f • * +J .� ' r4lr L j'. s, �y X1'4 k' r �1 V � Aj 4 l „A�' fl�l '1 �'� ` � ��',• � ���a� {� i +• � #mot �•��'y 'ai4 �.�. � ,, lUd.,Y�` I 4L Jacqu,bmontlo reclinato L_iste fftd :p e re_ d US � r ;�- - 4 Imlk l '. Af OST TO. CR,EA ANEW POPU LATI O R 100 NEW PLANT,r�. DER FED r 457 April 2014 post Sandy dune repairs �r OW-44 d 12, 000 10,000 111 6,000 4,000 23000 I 00 00 0� o�` ono o� o0 0) 10, �o �o No No No No f f f Year Turtles benefit.. �-- So how to manage the ........... i _ t4iinn c►icto m n nlnl? Prevention vs Intervention? Not all disasters are man made l� ri l � ff r 2005 Ocean Village project, `10 kv t�wsn �t� before planting, in December, post- Frances /Jeannie..a blank slate. Y At S - s K M-1 .ei .. � F --_.- _ � + �� ,�� �•�_�, `r 4-r.► ' .: 7 � _� '�' ,mow :'•: » . yam} Chain and beach cleaning tractor yanks 46 foot section of 3 year old 400 square yard cover invasive coin vine in about 4 minutes setup and reset time. a f4 I f N,��� Ak r Ii 4t es lk I TODAY'S INSPECTION OF NORTH 500 FT. Invasive exotic tropical almond..Terminalra catawpa 12/3/14 INSPECTION OF NORTH 500 FT. Homeless hotel.. would be discovered with regular inspections. 12/3/14 INSPECTION 500 FT. NORTH END Invasive exotic5caevola taccada, 2 to 3 year old cluster. Cost to remove maybe $150 12/3/14 INSPECTION 3 year old invasive exotic Casuarina and several 2 to 3 year old Scaevola, not removed as recent $20K contract effort stalled at mid beach. 12/3/14 INSPECTION Cost to remove a seedling by hand.. Maybe $1.50 12/3/14 INSPECTION Cost to remove 400 square yards after 3 years neglect..$750 C'. W z Fi O� L] 00 =2 ag U : - 0. O xa C fn Z tlf } OAM,INf mxaT 27 PLANTING P1.Ahi 2 1991..55 wild native species found.. Today at least 10 lost. sp PLANT LIST. ATf.ANTfC DUNES PAIIK b4 Mtt. 5r Fl , r.tw. w•� a r.rr y w� YSm NAtlf mtmt9N N.WI raN. yaur, yp ..' FP O UI �� _ • Jf.r.r+r �r � Iw G Q —•— Crrrr.rwtr...r t.ryti* v� n .. Addltim m I -- ��r -M•� t.��r. R 1 6g A PC 6f riatttAr m wew✓r�w vJw G a . A Ts Fr ! 5p ` ++rwt. tstur e.x t... R tiv cd \ ; e. �w !w fd fd st Vv 1 PR Oh k a rn� .dv o��f 'RJw 0 j u �' 1 � y i+.a• +oar. a 1•.....rY., rr+rvt ..tN.r t�. r / \ sr I A uott tad L6 S t z � � Groud Cows � i' z �l . -- amw swir� [lorfrma a t< • 4 t 5p Sr xw.l r, w4� �•ri u tl a Gd st + Mr— Jf,t��r S�ttRN @!!t Wr Rh w ,v —A— t. y..r -u.. .r.. W m A :�'.•. nrr..nw— m-W— or. J•p �fa.a��l PC ✓ 1 �.i (`tuJ\ fUr. t.rr rrr, tti [4Yr tv M \� 1J iJl .. ' lNitMiriMwFtWd4�t IiY]�td •V.Iw 7[ %� :: y v pw-. f4rW. l�Wt � tiw W rYr WltCtiR b .c Q 4 Y�� •+. �� Vm dwrfJW JJ� ltlrt =Obw der O Sr Wv pYw I. Ntrt .fcr >T JN ' .: �.: t� • Lt�•r• �w r✓•� yr tdiwrt rr Jt 4 V � -- / �. �- sYle set b L Ott _ 1 �� 3rr•+.I� +n.+m waM+` Mq�.tr! Tt�c Plan represents species and general location These racummeddsuions should be eFaluattd ' r't•" �w,er. Ott sM.. only: plant sizes to be determined by ftuors at the time of the staged restoration of each 1 0— wt Such as budget, availability d materials, and arcs to determine if adjm;hnemts should he �" Ln accessibility of planting site, made for growth existing at tbat time. m rr ' ♦ rr Aw,tr arr wtl� rf C'. W z Fi O� L] 00 =2 ag U : - 0. O xa C fn Z tlf } OAM,INf mxaT 27 PLANTING P1.Ahi 2 1991..55 wild native species found.. Today at least 10 lost. !.f ?Mrs. 't.r.1 •'• }� - `. t � Y • s �' y' '�� c� ti' k5u Y � - it 'i! . -71 _ �. n�' -ib�, . � •.��M 4 • }� � !. I kni�li iV rs if }�� ,� .� 1.rk '. ids � S {,�", � � "'s- ', ll '•+�•�",�, -� ;, •�Yw,, A � � ��7E •�+yr. - rrF � "L5 tit:. `�•cr i � \'N'# av,1 '� I �� r. "'n� _ �, y r 4L 4 /�-7 r a:v'T' - 'fir 9, ,y.� 3. �H':f a w ., 'r .T,•, 'r v , ur �`j /~ '�jC� ��� ��r` 'W T?$+'f�� �'� � r�1s, •�•f�'3��d' ��.rt- 4 y��;�" � '' t� + ` '�r f �1 ���' ?aav° �S' .f �¢•"p�.i�� -.' � ^ �5. } +t ��`l � � � F`... , • ` .. •�' , _. i fx� :A - ..m — . WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE • Recognize the situation and the cost of complacency and neglect • IMMEDIATELY CONTROL EXOTIC PLANT CONTAMINATION • Reevaluate to update the program and assign clear responsibility for oversight • Develop and adopt a revised Dune Management Plan for Gleason Beach and ADP • Commit to long term funding MEMORANDUM TO: Mayor and City Commissioners FROM: Suzanne Davis, Director Parks & Recreation THROUGH: Donald B. Cooper, City Manager DATE: January 20, 2015 SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM WS.3 - WORKSHOP MEETING OF FEBRUARY 10, 2015 PUBLIC ART ADVISORY BOARD PRESENTATION BACKGROUND On February 1, 2005, the Delray Beach City Commission adopted a public art ordinance, establishing the Public Art Advisory Program and setting aside 1.5% of Delray Beach capital construction projects over $200,000 for public art. The seven - member board recommends, initiates, and oversees public art projects; establishes the direction for selection of artwork; and advises the City Commission as to policies regarding visual arts. Board members are appointed by the City Commission. Projects include temporary, permanent, and educational site - specific installations in two and three dimensions from individuals or collaborators. Three seats on the Board must be filled by persons who are either an artist, architect, landscape architect, or engineer. Lay persons of knowledge, experience, and judgment who have an interest in public art shall make up the balance of the Board. The members of the Public Art Advisory Board are: Daniel Bellante, Chair Kevin Rouse, Vice -Chair Shirl Fields Patricia Truscello Carolyn Pendleton - Parker Glenn Weiss (term expires 7/31/2015) (term expires 7/31/2016) (term expires 7/31/2016) (term expires 7/31/2015) (term expires 7/31/2016) (term expires 7/31/2015) The Board currently has 1 vacancy. OPERATING COST Funding is available from 115- 1702 -579 -31.90 (Special Projects Fund: Professional Services /Other Professional Services). FUNDING SOURCE Funding is available from 115- 1702 -579 -31.90 (Special Projects Fund: Professional Services /Other Professional Services). RECOMMENDATION Motion to approve the Public Art Advisory Board's request to fund 5 specific projects, as detailed in their 2015 -2016 Work Plan. rm O �o U •L/, ' O > N O rm O �o U •L/, O •4� > N O Q L O Q Q N U U •— rm �h;rt n rt +rt Mrt Art :.rt art Art ^rt I-rt �.-.rt Art ,P rt Art A\r-t _rt rt art ;art ' "° rt j%rt 1 ,art art . rt kart Art .Ert A/"rt - rt 1rt art i►rt _ rt j rt ;i rt (rt cilrt art A r t A.-' rt rt Art Art rt Lrt art art art *Art Bart rt -rt Lrt A-rt art art drt &rt rt art .'.rt ;'�,rt rt rt .: -,rt *rt ^,rt art rt art art ART; 84 ways by dirt :2 rt .Art rt rt / rt Pentagram for Philadelphia museum .art *rt .art ` rt ; rt � rt i. ART - Citywide • The Creators Mayor, Commissioners, City Staff, City Boards Parks and Rec, Department heads, Waste collection, City Policemen and Firemen, Human Powered Delray, Historic Preservation, Chamber of Commerce, all City School Administrators ,Creative Collaborative, Arts Center, Delray Art League, and all City museum Administrators. Creators will sign and submit. June 2014 • PAAB selected Artist to curate and manage project. • Exterior rated works will be displayed horizontally and vertically • Selected Curator to be Delray 2nd Artist in Residence; June 2015 -16 • Estimated Project Budget: $20,000 - See Samples f r i AO I in parks, green spaces, along the Intracoastal, roads, sidewalks, all civic buildings, city alleys, etc. Art -CITYWIDE DE Y BEACF fl "m (' Y HALL �' 2.Chair Sculpture • Delray Affair - 3 days. Temporary performance piece. • PAAB supplied wooden chairs. • PAAB selected Artist to construct sculpture on site. • PAAB coordinating best location with Chamber of Commerce and Parks and Recreation. • Estimated Budget $5,000. R 2. Temporary Performance Sculpted CHAIRS April 2015 I .A fr 1 :.r Work Delray Affair 3. Tenniswall STR E ETA R • PAAB selected South Florida StreetArt ARTIST. 0 0 Existing wall dimensions 15' x 30' . August 2015 -installation. Estimated Budget: $7,500. PAAB to provide project lighting. Tennis Center Practice Wall 6N AM- r qh OF REA P i'J :Vv�VV ►NIrN�' rVVVW �� J - Y , R �� •- i 4. High Water Line Delray.. Earth Day April 25 performance Artist Eve Mosher + Climate Action Coalition - Sustainable Delray, funded. National, Regional and local focus. 15 mile line - 3 sections; Frog Alley, Nassau Street, Atlantic Avenue. • Reflective chalk HWL line; Drawn by citizens + civic leaders • PAAB funded Water Dance performance at sunset $5,000 & Local artists Activist Art training session $500. j R 1 rM Hilipu I ni[nIIIVt Jam; Delray Beach Frog Alley Legend Frog MICy Communliy Garden Vulnerablikty w Groundwater Flpoding Map br Dr Karen Bolter 2015 Source: US Gen1w 3rney 2411 FAVA FI Model far Biscayne Aquifer 5. Grove Parking Garage - A r t f u l W a I I • Synthetic Lawn application • Visual graphic, verbiage or educational Estimate; $3,500 - 5,000 i v ♦ i r P � •;fir -.� ti .0 i R r I In " City +Public Art Advisory Board: Study Items • PAAB Public Art Administrator and project manager; part time position filled October 2015. City + PAAB to pursue qualified applicants. • Private Developers 1% for Public Art. City Commission review + approval. October 2015 • PAAB to generate Public Art ordinance revisions; Policy and Procedures. Review with City. June 2015. Thank you for your Creative Thinking and support! 2015 Public Art Advisory Board Dan Bellante - Chair Kevin Rouse - Vice Chair Shirl Fields, Carolyn Pendelton- Parker, Patricia Truscello , Glenn Weiss MEMORANDUM TO: Mayor and City Commissioners FROM: Donald B. Cooper, City Manager DATE: January 29, 2015 SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM WS.4 - WORKSHOP MEETING OF FEBRUARY 10, 2015 DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY PRESENTATION DISCUSSION Winnie Edwards, Executive Director along with Leslie Callaway and Howard Ellingsworth will discuss the mission, vision and services offered by the Delray Beach Historical Society. I Delray Beach 1< 11i"storical A Vision for the Future XA ISTQ,, � w DBHS Table of Contents Executive Summary Our Mission Our Campus Organization Structure Services Programs, Exhibits & Events Marketing Community Connections Delray Beach Historical Society Timeline Financial Plan and A Vision For the Future EXECUTIVE SUMMARY What did curious travelers to a tropical wilderness see 100 years ago that made them want to stay and build a town? What did it take for the first settlers to overcome harrowing obstacles to develop industries such as farming, tourism and real estate? How did our community fare during times of economic uncertainty, war and hurricanes? Who are some of the notable people that lived here and changed the face of our town? What are the stories behind our iconic buildings, neighborhoods and streets? What do we know about race relations and different cultures that migrated to Delray Beach? What were artists, writers, businessmen and politicians inspired by, living and working in Delray Beach? How has the ocean, one of our greatest assets, played a role in our cultural heritage? The exploration of topics like these makes a historical society a powerful and essential component in any community. It directly connects us with the people of the past who shaped our landscape, named our landmarks, and made the decisions that ultimately affect us today. The Delray Beach Historical Society is essential because we provide a unique platform to explore our history, and not just our pioneering past, but the evolving narrative and expanding record of our town's growth. We preserve the memory of those who have built and continue to build upon our collective history so future generations can ultimately benefit and be inspired by this wisdom. Did you know that Historic Preservation helps bring an additional $6.3 billion a year to the Florida economy ?i Researchers at the Center for Government Responsibility focused on several key areas relative to historic preservation such as historic rehabilitation, heritage tourism and museum operations. This study suggests that historic preservation produces a large return for the public money invested and is one of the most efficient ways public funds can be invested. This report is evidence that investing in the protection of historic places, and the legacy of cultures that create them, produces positive and measurable results both directly and indirectly for the local economy. In a companion study researchers looked at how Floridians quality of life is impacted by historic preservation." This study confirms that historic preservation enhances the quality of life through economic and cultural contributions. i "Historic preservation, at the local level, involves more than rehabilitating historic structures and sites that are significant to the architecturally oriented preservationist. It also can encompass the events that take place in and around these structures, the traditions associated with an area and its structures, the perpetuation of arts and crafts that reflect a threatened way of life within an area, or the festivals celebrating the history of the people and the distinctive aspects of the locale. This broader concept of historic preservation creates the component parts of heritage tourism. Heritage tourism is an increasingly important part of Florida's tourism industry." Today, the Delray Beach Historical Society is at a crossroads. We've inherited a beautiful and compelling legacy at a time when growth, development and preservation are at the forefront of entrepreneurial vision, conversation and debate. As cultural preservationists and keepers of our cultural record, the Historical Society offers a place to research, discover and be guided by the stories and the memories of the pioneers, the entrepreneurs, the visionaries and the charismatic and passionate townspeople who set the course for the Delray Beach of today. Yet, we find ourselves unable to fully implement our plans for a sustainable future, our vision to contemporize our campus, and services to keep up with demand and growth. The men and women who founded the Delray Beach Historical Society in 1964 had vision and confidence successive generations would endow and implement this vital organization. Since then, the Historical Society has served the community of Delray Beach by continuing the important work of acquiring, preserving and protecting the City's archives, historic documents and artifacts and serving as a guardian of our City's heritage and culture. Did you know that it was this very Society that fostered the development of the Spady Cultural Heritage Museum, The Preservation Trust, The Historic Preservation Planning Department, and what is now known as Old School Square / Delray Center for the Arts? Proudly, our community has expanded its advocacy for Education, Arts and Humanities and the cultural organizations that provide this important platform. The Historical Society shares this passion, and asks for your support in defending against one of Delray Beach's next great threats —the extinction of preservation and our local history! As we embark on the 51 st year of the incorporation of the Delray Beach Historical Society, we are working diligently to revitalize of our mission, building a sense of excitement for local history, pride of citizenship and stewardship of our legacy for generations to come. With a vision that includes expanding our community partnerships, creating a robust infrastructure and developing exciting and contemporary programming, exhibits and events reflecting area history, we are poised to become a significant contributor to the overall vibrancy, quality of life and growth of our town. However, if we continue to find ourselves in a "Starvation Cycle," a phenomenon of underfunding and understaffing, our vision cannot come to fruition. This cycle not only jeopardizes our mission and vision, but our very existence. Our hope is to break this cycle, by developing a sustainable model for the future and maintaining a realistic expectation of what it costs to run the Society. The Society and the City of Delray have a responsibility to keep the Archive Bunker and Research Facilities at the Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center open on a regular, year -round basis. The Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center is subject to a three -party agreement between the City of Delray Beach, The Delray Beach Historical Society, and Palm Beach County to keep the Archive Research Room open to the public through 2037. As we are a function of and a resource for the City of Delray Beach, we are requesting to be funded as a line item in the City Budget, starting with $150,000 per year and increasing 3% per year. The following Business Plan contains information about our history as an organization, our structure and our vision for the future. Please join us as leaders in safeguarding Delray Beach history — keeping the link to our past strong and our future bright. Economic Impacts of Historic Preservation in Florida, Center for Governmental Responsibility, University of Florida Levin Contributions of Historic Preservation to the quality of life in Florida, Center for Governmental Responsibility, University of Florida Levin College of Law, Center for Urban Policy Research, Florida Trust for Historic Preservation (2006) OUR MISSION The Delray Beach Historical Society, believing that a sense of history is fundamental to understanding human experiences, collects, preserves and shares materials from Delray Beach's past, so that present and future generations can comprehend more fully their predecessors, their communities and themselves. The society encourages and assists people of all backgrounds and interests to learn more about Delray Beach's diverse history. OUR CAMPUS Three buildings encompass the Delray Beach Historical Society campus. The City of Delray Beach and the Delray Beach Historical Society as a joint venture, maintain all three buildings. The buildings are City owned. Authentically furnished and reflecting the South Florida lifestyle from 1915 to 1935, The Cason Cottage Historic House Museum is an historically designated education institution devoted to the preservation of Delray Beach History. It is a vernacular style house with craftsman cottage details, solidly constructed with Dade County pine. Reverend John Cason, Sr., community leader and Methodist minister, whose descendants still live in Delray Beach, built the cottage circa 1924. It was built on this site and has survived the three 20th Century hurricanes of 1926, 1928 and 1947 which all caused extensive damage in Delray. Reverend Cason and his wife moved to Delray to be near their son, John Cason, Jr., who was the first physician in Delray Beach. Visitors enjoy rotating exhibits of art, artifacts and records pertaining to the City's storied past. The DBHS and the City of Delray Beach restored Cason Cottage through a joint effort in 1988. The Museum is open to the public for tours and a glimpse of life during Delray's pioneer days. The 1926 Florida Bungalow and Gift Shop provides the museum with additional space for exhibits on local Florida history is also the office of the Executive Director. The Hunt House is an original Florida farmhouse, which was dedicated and named the Ethel Sterling Williams Archive and History Learning Center in 2009. This state -of- the -art and award - winning center houses the City's archives and is open for local research, school classes and exhibits. Individuals, writers, researchers, homeowners, students, businesses, government agencies and organizations are served. A revitalized Florida Native Plant Garden has been installed just outside the Cason Cottage Museum and around the campus. This is part of our tour program to educate visitors about native pant use at the turn of the century. ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE Governance / Board Composition and Terms The Board of Governors has the authority to manage the affairs of the Society. Currently there are fifteen members of the Board who were elected at the annual meeting through a nominating committee. Each Governor is elected for terms of three years and can serve no more than three consecutive terms. All Board members are active members donating both time and money to the Society. The Board of Governors is an all- volunteer board. Board of Governors Date Joined Co- President - Angela Kumar 2012 Co- President - Leslie Callaway 2012 Vice President - Patti Alexander 2011 Vice President - Tom Stanley 2008 Treasurer - Howard Ellingsworth 2006 Secretary - Mary Renaud 2011 David Cook 2013 Hannah George Connell 2014 Michael Cruz 2013 Suzy Long 2013 Steve Miskew 2014 Elisabeth Salvadore 2013 Laura Simon 2013 Roy Simon 2010 Lisa White 2013 Immediate Past President Jane Orthwein 2002 Patroness of Cason Cottage Marsha Love 2010 Board Responsibilities It is the responsibility of the Board of Governors to determine the Society's mission and purpose, select and support the Executive Director and review performance, ensure effective organizational planning, adequate resources and monitor the Society's programs and services. The Society has established committees to help execute these responsibilities. Executive Committee The Executive Committee consists of the Officers elected by the Board of Governors. The Committee exercises all powers of the Board of Governors between meetings of the Board and shall report its actions no later than the next meeting of the Board. Other Committees Archives Committee This committee oversees the acquisition, care, and exhibition of all collections in the Society's inventory. The committee should make recommendations on acquisitions to ensure the collection is in line with the Society's mission. The committee is responsible for actively updating any collection policies, including an acquisition policy to ensure any donated items are relevant to the interpretive stories in the archive and museum. Education Committee This committee is responsible for ensuring the appreciation of local history among school -age children and young people and to encourage history preservation and appreciation through public educational programming. This committee oversees all activities related to local school programming and adult education series. Membership /Development Committee This committee oversees the fundraising, membership, annual appeal, major donor, or corporate sponsorship tasks. This often includes involvement with events held to specifically raise money for the Society. Nominating Committee It is the duty of the President of the Society to appoint a Nominating Committee of three Members of the Society. This committee shall nominate as many members for the Board of Governors as are to stand for election or re- election and shall report the names of their nominees prior to the Annual Meeting of Members. Finance Committee This committee oversees and develops an annual operating budget with staff, making certain the Society is adhering to the budget. The committee sets long -range financial goals along with funding strategies to achieve them. They present all financial goals and proposals to the Board of Governors for approval. Grounds and Maintenance Committee This committee arranges for physical upkeep and maintenance of the buildings and grounds on the Society's campus. Regular maintenance schedules and necessary repairs are recorded by the committee to ensure proper stewardship of the site. Events Committee This group is responsible for creating a comprehensive event plan for the year as well as setting guidelines for events and event submittals. Staff Executive Director: The Executive Director is hired by the Board of Governors. He /she has day - to -day responsibilities for the organization, including carrying out the organization's goals and policies as prescribed from time to time by the Board of Governors. The Executive Director will attend all board meetings, report on the progress of the organization, answer questions of the Board of Governors and Executive Committee, keep the Board of Governors /Executive Committee, officers, and committees of the organization fully informed as to the business and affairs of the Society. The Executive Director serves as the main face of the organization. He /she directs external relations and communications focusing on marketing, and public relations efforts including general promotions and brand management by overseeing the website, publications, and Social Media. The Executive Director manages fundraising operations and works closely with the Board on all public initiatives taken on behalf of the Society. It is the responsibility of the Executive Director to build donor loyalty and retention. It is the task of this position to increase the visibility and understanding of the work and mission of Society by developing programs, exhibits and events that are unique and exiting. Archivist: The Archivist is the Society's key curatorial and collections manager. He /she plays a pivotal role in caring for and expanding the Archival Collection on behalf of the City of Delray Beach. He /she is responsible for overseeing the acquisition, organization, cataloging, processing, care and accessibility of all collections. The Archivist is also responsible for assisting the Executive Director in the planning and implementation of the Cason Cottage Historic House Museum programming and school tours. Volunteers Approximately 10 regular volunteers are supplemented with additional volunteers for special exhibits or events. We have a seasonal docent program that is responsible for leading tours through the Cason Cottage Historic House Museum. DBHS Events 2013 -2014 Attendance and Volunteer Participation: Smithsonian Magazine's Museum Day Live! 98 attendees 4 volunteers Halloween Fall Fest 425 attendees 15 volunteers Winter Harvest Farm -To -Table Event / Exhibit 82 attendees 10 volunteers Delray Beach: The WWII Experience Exhibit Event 225 attendees 9 volunteers Delray Beach: The WWII Experience Rare Artifact and Memorabilia Exhibit 125 attendees 6 volunteers Greatest Generation Storytelling Coffee 16 attendees 1 volunteer Docent Appreciation Luncheon 25 attendees 1 volunteer Barefoot By The Sea Event 225 attendees 9 volunteers Judith Acker "Vintage Buildings of Delray" Photography Exhibit 48 attendees 2 volunteers Cason Cottage Tours 490 guests 12 volunteers 3 Memberships Mixers 60 — 100 each 5 volunteers Society Annual Meeting 2014 75 attendees 3 volunteers Lake Ida Fish Fry Membership Drive and History Exhibit 228 attendees 5 volunteers DBHS Anniversary Birthday 210 attendees 5 volunteers Palm Beach County Surfing History Exhibit & Kick off Event 750 attendees 6 volunteers Christmas at Cason Cottage Children's History Hour & Tours 220 attendees 7 volunteers Total Event & Exhibit Attendance: 3,342 Participation in Other Non -DBHS Events Downtown Delray Merchant Appreciation Day 2 volunteers 2013 Heart of the Grove 2 volunteers Delray High School Reunion 2 volunteers Delray Beach Pavilion Ribbon Cutting 1 volunteer Woman's Club of Delray Beach "Kick up Your Heels" 2 volunteer Delray Beach Chamber of Commerce Leadership Delray 2 volunteers Historical Society of Palm Beach County Young Friends 2 volunteers DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY SERVICES Hours of Operation The Delray Beach Historical Society Office is open from 9am to 5pm, Tuesday — Friday. The Cason Cottage Historic House Museum is open November through May, 11 am — 3pm, Thursday, Friday and Saturday for docent - guided tours. The Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center is open Wednesdays and Fridays, 9am — 5pm by appointment for research and other Archival Collection related business. The Ethel Sterling Williams Learning Center & Archives The core of our mission at the Delray Beach Historical Society is the maintenance, preservation and expansion of the historic archives of the City of Delray Beach. These archival materials are irreplaceable assets. The collection is housed in one of the City's oldest buildings, itself a historic site to explore local heritage. Along with private donations, the City, County and State have invested in excess of $650,000 to ensure that Delray Beach historical records are secure, accessible and useful for educational and civic purposes. This organization's mission, the campus, the events and educational programs are essential to keep our history alive and to provide a legacy for future generations. Our approximately 500 research and archival requests and visits per year come from individual citizens, writers, researchers, homeowners, the media, realtors, builders, students, businesses, other non - profit organizations and City groups such as The Delray Beach Public Library, Delray Beach Fire Service, Delray Beach Police Department, Parks & Recreation, Historic Preservation Department, the City Manager's Office, the City Attorney's office and the City Clerk /Records Department. The Archive Collection features over 20,000 items, including photographs, real estate documents, architectural renderings, original charters, City of Delray Beach records, books, memorabilia, letters, newspapers, paintings, original drawings, rare artifacts, pioneer and family histories — both oral and video, clothing, and other three dimensional artifacts. Our database of architectural drawings lists 1,200 items. Our book collection includes rare and out -of -print books and city directories dating back to the early years of local settlement, and contemporary guides to local art and architecture. Our computer contains many entries for over 2,500 individual items, and we have catalogued lists of those objects awaiting data entry. The materials, artifacts, pictures and information in the collection are meticulously organized and stored an Archive Bunker attached to the Ethel Sterling History Learning Center. These materials are maintained at an optimal temperature with a gas back -up generator for weather emergencies. The archives are a continual work in progress as new donations are received each year. The Delray Beach Historical Society Executive Director, Archivist and small volunteer staff are responsible for maintaining the collection, which includes assessment, research, cataloguing and conservation. Why Our Archives Are Important (1) All DBHS educational programs, preservation projects and exhibits originate from materials and inspiration found in our Archives. (2) The Archives are the basis of our knowledge of Delray Beach History and greatly enrich our continuing story. The precise care of the archives and the stories they contain serve to inspire future generations. (3) The impetus for the founding of the Historical Society in 1964 by some of the children of original settlers was to start an archives collection so that the history of the town "would not be lost." (4) The archives, artifacts, memorabilia, documents and art and the stories they convey provide lessons for the present and the most fair, democratic and ethical guidance for the future. The Learning Center area of the ESW building is a room where the public can visit to do research, order historic images and read about a variety of historical topics via our extensive area history reference library. A computer is available for research. Our Archivist is on -site to facilitate research requests and all services are free to the public. The Learning Center is also a stop on Children's tours. We show tour groups the archives, talk about the importance of history and preservation and demonstrate interesting preservation techniques. Photo Orders and Gift Shop The Archival Collection holds hundreds of original negatives. The Society adds to its income by providing reprints, canvases, posters and other special projects from the Archive negatives and vintage photograph collection. Our Gift Shop sells books on local Florida history and a variety of gifts, which we plan to expand in 2015 -2016. Event Venue During the 2013 -2014 season the campus was used by several external organizations for meetings and fundraising. They included: The Pineapple Grove Merchants - Heart of the Grove Event Colonial Dames of America Chapter Meeting and Luncheon Boca Raton Jr. League Women and Small Business Seminar Grass River Garden Club Board meeting Douglass Layton Jewelry Show and Lecture Judith Acker Photography Exhibit PROGRAMS / EXHIBITS / EVENTS An exciting yearly calendar of programs, exhibits and events are planned to fulfill our mission. Our exhibits and events also serve to raise money for the Society and increase memberships. Celebrating our rich cultural heritage through visuals and storytelling in new and fascinating ways ensures our narrative remains alive. Passing down the stories and educating the community is at the core of our mission, creating a legacy for the future. Total attendance for DBHS Exhibits and Events for 2014 = 3,342 Our 2013 - 2014 Calendar Hiqhliqhts: Membership Mixers Provides an opportunity for our growing membership to mingle, socialize, network learn the latest happenings at the Society. Annual Meeting Provides the membership an opportunity to learn about our financial status, elect new Board members and socialize. "Winter Harvest" / Event & History Exhibit A celebration of Delray Beach's rich agricultural heritage. Exhibit includes a look at 100 years of farming history through stunning enlarged archival photos and the stories behind them. We highlight individual families and farms. The Exhibit is supported by a kick -off event, which includes a showcase of current day, local farmers, their crops and stories. A five - course farm -to -table food and wine pairing dinner merges the past with the present, as local restaurants present their dishes. "WWII: Delray Beach / Celebrating the The largest Exhibit in the Society's history was Greatest Generation" opened with an event honoring this cherished generation and an important time in American history. Nostalgic food, refreshments and live Big Band music brought together multiple generations. A color guard ceremony honored those named in our Veteran's Park. Additional events during the week included a screening of the award - winning documentary, "Honor Flight and a Greatest Generation Coffee Hour. "Celebrating Delray's Neighborhood Series" This is a new series that we will carry over into 2015. It kicked off with our exploring and sharing the history of the Lake Ida neighborhood. Never before seen images and stories were shared for our guests and visitors for two months, providing history and perspective on this popular neighborhood. The Exhibit kick -off included a fish fry and a bluegrass band. 50th Anniversary Birthday Celebration 2014 was our 50 Anniversary of incorporation. We invited the entire town to enjoy a complimentary slice of the "largest pineapple cake in the world" and a cup of pineapple punch. Fresh gladioli were given out to the first 100 guests. Multiple generations heard special comments from new members, town dignitaries and founding pioneers of the Society. "Halloween Fall Fest " This event brought families from multiple counties together to experience an evening of nostalgia. We screened an outdoor movie: "The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown. "A Haunted " History" House replicated the journey of the famous "Delray Shipwreck – The SS Inchulva." An accompanying history exhibit, up for two months, provided in images, art and captions, the story of the ship, the sailors, the hotel where the survivors sought refuge and how it affected our town. Vintage family photos, games and refreshments were included in this free event for the community. "Palm Beach County Surfing History" / Exhibit A look into our extraordinary and little known and Event surfing history culture was on display for two months in two of our buildings. Professionally executed, large format images and text panels and vintage surfboards told fascinating tales of a different side of Delray. The kick -off event was free to the public and included live surf music, live surfing demos, vintage Palm Beach County surfing movies on an outdoor screen and refreshments. "Barefoot By The Sea" In partnership with the County and Sandoway House Nature Center, we celebrate our life in the Village by the Sea, with a historic exhibit of beach artifacts, imagery of fishing and coastal architecture and Barefoot Mailman lore. The "Palm Beach Pioneer" character visits, serves as a docent, and provides a history lesson for the children. Includes themed activities and refreshments. "Christmas at Cason Cottage" We opened up Cason Cottage Historic House Museum for the first time in the evenings during December for enchanted tours and a look back at life at Christmas time in 1924 Delray Beach —a pivotal time in our history. The house was decorated for the holidays with authentic period adornments and decor. One evening brought families together for a special reading of "The Night Before Christmas" around the Christmas Tree. Proceeds helped to raise funds for Cottage repairs. Palm Beach County Historic Institute In partnership with the County Historical Society, Teachers' Workshop we hosted area teachers to a day in Delray Beach, which included a tour of our campus, museum and archives, a trolley tour through our City's historic districts, a guest speaker on native plants of past and present and a home - cooked pioneer lunch. Lessons learned help teachers prepare valuable area history curriculum for their classrooms. Ongoing School Tours Area schools take a tour of our Cason Cottage Historic House Museum and learn about Delray Beach History. Visit includes a trip to the City's archives on -site, a lesson in preservation and refreshments. Leadership Delray The Society hosted Chamber of Commerce members to a day of touring historically designated sites and neighborhoods, plus a tour of the Society campus. Museum Day Live We participated in this Smithsonian Museum sponsored day, where visitors purchase a pass to visit area museums. Cason Cottage is one of only three museums in Delray Beach. MARKETING The Delray Beach Historical Society Marketing Plan features a mix of public relations, print and digital media execution. (Addendum 1) The services we provide, our events and history exhibits appeal to a broad demographic and all work to fulfill our mission of preserving our cultural heritage. Our marketing objective is to reach as many residents, visitors and business owners as we can and to build a sense of excitement for local history, pride of citizenship and stewardship of our legacy. Success of our marketing plan is measured by event and exhibit attendance, an increase in membership and fundraising levels. Audience / Target Market Today, we are more committed than ever to providing programs for the widest and most diverse audience possible. Through day -to -day contact, we know that history is important to the citizens and visitors of Delray Beach. We are dedicated to preserving our heritage for the future and ensuring a new generation of stewards. The Society's target audience is multi - generational. We service the public including but not limited to: individual citizens, writers, researchers, homeowners, media, realtors, builders, students, government organizations, cultural centers, businesses and history buffs of all ages. With our City changing and growing and our demographic expanding, it is important that the Historical Society change and grow with the environment around us. COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS & COLLABERATION Spady Museum The Society collaborates with the Spady Museum on several programs and tours throughout the year. Historical Society of Palm Beach County We have partnered with the Historical Society of Palm Beach County for the Barefoot by the Sea event. This Event has become one of the Society's signature family events, providing educational programming in a fun and affordable way. The event brings to life our special environment of our Village by the Sea with a themed history exhibit and talks by the Palm Beach Pioneer. Palm Beach County History Institute We are happy to represent Delray in this valuable workshop for teachers. Attendees visit our campus for the day and tour historic neighborhoods and designated sites to learn about the interesting and diverse history of Delray Beach to take back to their classrooms. Sandoway House The Society continues to partner with the Sandoway for cross promotions and exhibit collaboration. Human Powered Delray We are partnering with this important group to create pedestrian and bicycle friendly historic and scenic tour routes around our City through series of maps. Our 2015 -2016 plan includes creating a "Cultural Pass" with Spady, Sandoway House Nature Center, Delray Center for the Arts and the Delray Beach Public Library. DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY TIMELINE Note: A couple of years before establishment of the DBHS there was a scathing article by a local reporter asking, "...Where is the record of Delray Beach history?" July 30, 1964 The society holds an organizational meeting at the First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Delray Beach on East Atlantic Avenue. Kenneth Ellingsworth, Director of the Chamber of Commerce, was the "Temporary Chairman." He appointed a nominating committee to appoint a seven - member steering committee. Ethel Sterling Williams became the first president. The purpose of the Delray Beach Historical Society is defined at "the organization and preservation of records to form a definite and authentic history of the City of Delray Beach." At the meeting "it was decided that each member should contact friends and early residents of Delray Beach to create greater interest in forming the society and to establish the most complete and factual history of the city as possible." Attending the first meeting were: Mrs. W.C. Williams, W.C. Williams III, Mrs. Dorothy Bauer, Miss Addie Sundy, Miss Lucy Sandidge, Mrs. Glenn Sundy, Mrs. H.A. Hubbard, Mrs. Clyde Smith, Kenneth Ellingsworth, Robert Worthing, J. LeRoy Croft, Lonnie Cook, John Ross Adams, James Nowlin Jr., Paul Walton Ledridge, Roy Diggans, William Gwynn and Gary Gooder. Many of the first members were children of Linton /Delray pioneers. August 1964 The Delray Beach Historical Society is chartered as a non - profit organization and the organizational meeting of the Board of Governors is held at the Chamber of Commerce building. Officers were: Mrs. Ethel S. Williams, President Roy C. Diggans Vice President Roy M. Simon, Recording Secretary Sue Rose Zeder, Corresponding Secretary William E. Gwynn, Treasurer The board approved a resolution extending an Honorary Life Membership to Ken Ellingsworth for his "extraordinary services in initiating the formation of the society." Sept. 9, 1964 The Society began immediately to collect the record of Delray Beach history. The archives committee decides the city library will be the home of archives material and plans a window display at the First National Bank during the week of Sept. 26 to Oct. 3. Sept. 23, 1964 At the time of the first regular meeting of the Board of Governors the society has 86 active members, 1 patron member, 3 student members and 4 life members. The by -laws defined membership levels: Student - $1.00; Active — $2.00; Patron - $25.00; Life - $100.00 The first general meeting of the society is held the next day. By October there were 146 members. 130 of these were active members. July 20, 1966 The society discusses restoring the Florida East Coast train depot to be used as a museum but determines that the fledgling society doesn't have the resources to complete the project. The depot restoration was taken up again decades later and completed in 1996. 1971 The Society discusses collections, a place for the archives, and publishing a book about Delray Beach History. Discussions about the above subjects continued for several years. Feb. 18, 1972 In a letter to the City Council the Society recommends that the City change the name of South Twelfth Street to Linton Boulevard, after Congressman William Linton, who platted and registered the town -site of Linton. 1972 Society events include a panel discussion on life in early Delray with a display of 100 photos of early Delray, and a presentation by Lora S. Britt, long -time area resident and editor of Palatka Daily News. June 1, 1985 The society moves into new headquarters upstairs at the Arcade Tap Room on Atlantic Avenue. March 1986 Members work with the Old School Square Foundation to plan the restoration of Old School Square. The site was officially listed on the national Register of historic places in March 1988. April 1986 The society proposes the purchase of property on the corner of North Swinton Avenue and Northeast First Street. October 1986 DBHS plays an important role in the city's 75th anniversary Diamond Jubilee, hosting an old - fashioned picnic and a downtown parade. 1987 The DBHS holds a contest to name the Society's newsletter. "The Orange Grove Observer" submission wins. The annual spring brunch is held at the Colony Hotel. March 1987 With the assistance of the Society, the City approves a historic preservation ordinance that provides for a seven - member board to designate and preserve historic buildings in Delray Beach. 1988 The society is instrumental in bringing about the designation of four city historic districts: Nassau Park, the Old School Square District, Del -Ida Park, and the Marina Historic District. The annual spring brunch theme is "Old School Days" in honor of Old School Square project. DBHS continues its oral history projects. The $6,000 profit from the DBHS Christmas House is donated to the restoration of Old School Square. January 1989 The Cason Cottage Museum opens and the society administrative office moves into the cottage. The cottage hosts its first exhibits of Delray Beach History, including Legends, the Art of Architecture, The Cartoonists, and A Victorian Christmas House. Cason Cottage is 25 years old this year (2014). 1991 The Washington & Friends Come to Delray exhibit at Cason Cottage includes study guides for students. The Cason Cottage Gift Shop thrives. Paul Stanton and William Luke continue croquet lessons and donate regulation croquet sets for school tours. DBHS hosts golf and tennis tournament fund - raisers. 1992 Foreign Exchange students from Japan — hosted by the Sister Cities organization — visit Cason Cottage. 1993 The society opens the Cornell Archives Room at Old School Square, upstairs at the Cornell Museum. February 1994 The Society hosts the first Antiques Show and Sale at the Delray Beach Community Center. In addition to the Show and Sale, the DBHS sponsored lectures by nationally known antiques experts and published the AS &S Magazine that included articles about Delray Beach history. 1995 Delray Beach celebrates its Centennial of Settlement. DBHS is instrumental in the yearlong celebration. The society moves the old Florida East Coast railway depot to the Ocean City Lumber property. The 1896 depot originally stood downtown, at East Atlantic Avenue and Southeast First Street. It was abandoned in the 1960s and being too unwieldy to move in one piece, was split into two parts. The freight area was moved to Wellington and destroyed in a 1985 fire. The remaining section was moved to a gladiola farm west of Delray where it was used for storage before the Delray Beach Historical Society purchased and restored it. The FEC depot is the logo of the city's centennial celebration, and the depot becomes the DBHS office. 1998 The DBHS receives an award from the Florida Trust for Historic Preservation for restoration of 1896 FEC Station. DBHS donates $25,000 to the new S.D. Spady Museum. 1999 The society underwrites research for historic designation for the Atlantic Avenue and George Bush Boulevard bridges. The Archives Gallery exhibit Exploring the Civil War in Florida draws more than 2,000 visitors. 2000 James Abbott, Curator of Decorative Arts for the Baltimore Museum of Art, evaluates authenticity of the Cason Cottage collection and reports to the DBHS. 2001 Lavender Shutters Antiques owners Babs Pickering and Allen Brown donate the 1926 bungalow - style cottage to the society. The historic bungalow will be moved from its 122 S.E. Sixth Ave. location to the society grounds on the corner of North Swinton Avenue and Northeast First Street, where it will serve as additional space for exhibits, offices, gift shop, and as a visitor center for the museum. Restoration is complete in 2004. 2003 The Archives Gallery hosts the Delray Wreck SS Inchulva – 100 Years of Memories exhibit. 2006 The Society, along with the Spady Museum, launches Ride and Remember Trolley Tours. 2007 -2008 The Society acquires the 1908 Hunt House, now known as the Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center. The vacant house stood at 124 N.E. Fifth Ave. and was slated for demolition to make way for a condominium development. Archives documenting the history of Delray Beach are moved from the Cornell Museum to an archive storage facility attached to the former farmhouse. The storage bunker is built of concrete and steel space rated to withstand a Category Five hurricane. Features of the storage area include incandescent low -level lighting, air - conditioning and dehumidifying to maintain a constant temperature and humidity, and a gas back- up generator in case of long -term interruption of power —all to preserve the record of Delray Beach history. 2009 The last Antiques Show and Sale occurs. May 20, 2009 Dedication and ribbon cutting for the Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center in the 1908 Hunt House includes a Celebration of Generations event. July 2009 DBHS wins the Pat Cayce Award for Excellence in Historic Preservation from the City of Delray Beach Preservation Board. 2010 DBHS presents a three - month -long community program, Samuel Ogren Sr. — Delray Beach's National Register Architect, funded by the Florida Humanities Council and the National Endowment for the Humanities. The program includes a portable exhibit displayed at the Ogren designed Sandoway House, at City Hall, and at Art & Jazz on Atlantic Avenue, and public panel discussions facilitated by local architects and historians. 2011 DBHS urges the City to celebrate Delray Beach's centennial of incorporation and participates in several events during the year. DBHS co- sponsors two new historic marker applications, the Cason Cottage grounds and Atlantic Avenue Crossing at the Intracoastal Waterway. 2012 The Society's new web site is completed. DBHS assists Old School Square by providing images and text for refurbishing the history exhibit at the Crest Theatre. The Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center hosts the Palm Beach County History Institute for Palm Beach County teachers. The Cason Cottage Museum participates in Smithsonian magazine's Museum Day Live and hosts a Designer Showcase fundraiser in December. DBHS co -hosts the family- oriented Barefoot by the Sea event at the Sandoway House. The event continues at the Sandoway House in 2013, and moves to the DBHS grounds in 2014. 2013 DBHS hosts an Easter Egg Hunt on the Society grounds, and participates in Smithsonian Museum Day Live and hosts a tour for Leadership Delray. The Society's events included a campus -wide Fall Festival; an Antique Jewelry Show; Christmas at Cason Cottage. 2014 – The DBHS turns 50! DBHS experiences revitalization with a strong Board of Governors and new Executive Director. A strict adherence to the Society's mission and a calendar full of exhibits and events showcasing our history results in increasing memberships and interest in the Society. More artifacts and memorabilia are donated to the Society. The research and archive information requests from the community are in record numbers. FINANCIAL PLAN AND VISION FOR THE FUTURE The Delray Beach Historical Society's revitalized vision includes defining the Society as a vibrant center for education, research and community life by bringing together families and multiple generations of all backgrounds and interests to a series of exciting and contemporary - themed exhibits, programs and events, which showcase the rich and colorful stories of our evolving narrative. We are poised to become a significant contributor to the overall vibrancy, quality of life and growth of our town. In pursuit of the future we have envisioned and aspire to reach, the Delray Beach Historical Society will focus its energies and resources on five areas of priority: 1. Strengthening Financial Security — An improved financial position will be achieved by creating and implementing a development plan that thoughtfully incorporates ways to diversify income sources through grants, expanding membership, strengthening our corporate sponsor program, strategic fundraising events, revitalization of our book and gift shop, increasing staff hours and expanding our museum hours. 2. Stewardship of the Delray Beach Historical Society Campus — The 1924 Cason Cottage House Museum, The 1908 "Hunt House," / Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center, housing the City's Archival Collection and The 1926 Exhibit Bungalow are all important historic properties which are to be managed and maintained for the benefit of future generations. Repairs to the buildings, a campus signage package, and the continuing maintenance of our Florida Native Plant Garden are part of strengthening our foundation. 3. Increasing Engagement of People — An more active membership and volunteer core will play a greater role in fundraising events, developing inclusive history and educational programming that engages a broad audience, and filling Board roles. The creation of a downtown merchant program, partnering with other cultural centers and expanding our intern program are lined up to help us achieve our goals. 4. Expanding Programs and Optimize Collections — Education is at the core of our mission. Our plan is to provide the community with innovative programs that will bring our campus to life in fun and engaging ways that attract youth, families and history buffs, while the Society's Archival Collection will continue to be better organized and preserved to maximize its effectiveness and long -range preservation. It is our plan to enhance the visitor experience to our campus by developing a long -term plan for each building. A permanent Delray Beach History Museum, a full calendar of rotating exhibits, a lecture series, enhanced research capabilities, the digitization of our Archival Collection and creating unique children's programs are in development. 5. Building Public Awareness — The Society has created a comprehensive Marketing Plan to increase awareness of the Society as the keeper of the historic record, and as a destination to experience one -of -a -kind exhibits, events and programs that are compelling, contemporary and unique for the City. Clear and consistent communication will create visibility for memberships, programs, financial support and the Society's resources. FIVE -YEAR PLAN The following five -year plan allows the Historical Society to bring its staff of two to full -time and increase our operation hours in keeping with demand. We will continue to fundraise for all additional costs associated with the programming and operation of the Historical Society. Your support is necessary to assure that core - operating functions are sustained and that resources are available to expand our Cason Cottage Museum programming and support archival and research capabilities associated with the Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center. (Addendum 2) P�Nls 7'(),? 'C' o DBHS K Delray Beach Historical Society — Marketing Plan 2015 l' 1 Mission Statement The Delray Beach Historical Society, believing that a sense of history is fundamental to understanding human experiences, collects, preserves and shares materials from Delray Beach's past, so that present and future generations can comprehend more fully their predecessors, their communities and themselves. The society encourages and assists people of all backgrounds and interests to learn more about Delray Beach's diverse history. Background The Delray Beach Historical Society was founded in 1964. The campus features three buildings: (1) The Cason Cottage House Museum, (2) The 1926 Bungalow, Gift Shop & Exhibit Space and (3) The Ethel Sterling Williams History Learning Center & City Archives. This year we not only celebrated our 50th Anniversary, we hired an Executive Director and a part -time Archivist to organize and maintain the City's vast archival collection. With approximately 3,500 people visiting our campus for exhibits and events this past year, the Society is experiencing a revitalization of our mission. Our vision for the future includes establishing the Society as a vibrant center for education, research and community life by bringing together families and multiple generations to a series of fun - filled and contemporary - themed exhibits, programs and events, which showcase the rich and colorful stories of Delray Beach. Executive Summary The Delray Beach Historical Society Marketing Plan features a mix of public relations, print and digital media execution. Delray Beach has a rich and well- documented history going back to the late 1800's. The pioneer stories and the evolving narratives over the last 100 years continually inspire current and future generations. In a town rich with cultural centers, the DBHS provides a unique storytelling platform, a place to learn and discover and a campus to gather as a community to celebrate how we began and where we live. The services we provide, our events and history exhibits appeal to a broad demographic and all work to fulfill our mission of preserving our cultural heritage. Our marketing objective is to reach as many residents, visitors and business owners as we can and to build a sense of excitement for local history, pride of citizenship and stewardship of our legacy. Though memberships, sponsorships and donations to the Society we can keep our history alive and maintain a strong foundation for the future. Success of our marketing plan is measured by an increase in membership, donation levels, and event and exhibit attendance. Tactic Jan Feb March April May June July August Sept Oct Nov Dec Press 1 Pioneer Second Gladiola Celebrating Barefoot By Halloween Christmas at Releases Kids Annual Festival/ Delray's The Sea / Fall Fest Cason Preserving Winter Farming Neighborhood Heritage Freelance Delray Harvest Series/ Celebration Partnership 2 New /Farming Exhibit & Board Heritage Event Members Articles 1 Pioneer Gladiola Celebrating Barefoot By Halloween Christmas at Kids Festival/ Delray's The Sea / Fall Fest Cason Freelance Preserving Farming Neighborhood Heritage Partnership Delray 2 Series / Celebration Farming Exhibit & Heritage Event Facebook 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts per 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts per 12 posts 12 posts 12 posts per per month per month per month per month per month month per per month month per month per month month month Website 2 per 2 per 2 per 2 per 2 per 2 per month 2 per 2 per 2 per month 2 per 2 per 2 per month Updates / month month month month month month month month month blog On -line Freelance auction Partnership launch "The Record" Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly Newsletter Out Out Out Out Freelance Partnership Photoshoot Campus, Gift Shop, Freelance Buildings, Partnership Archives Collateral DBHS Downtown Event, Event, Event, Development Brochure Merchant promotional, promotional, promotional, Launch Program exhibit pieces exhibit exhibit Freelance Materials pieces pieces Partnership Event pieces Printing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Vendor: Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Monthly Constant Contact Database Management / Email Blasts Cultural Pass Launch Project with Spady, DCA, Sandoway Co -op Winter Summer Fall tours/ Holiday Collateral Harvest tours/ exhibit/ Event City Material with exhibit/ lectures with Collateral Development Spady lectures with Spady / DCA participation presence Spady / DCA / / Chamber/ Chamber/ DDMC DDMC DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY ANNUAL BUDGET FOR THE FISCAL YEARS ENDING SEPTEMBER 30 DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY ANNUAL BUDGET FOR THE FISCAL YEARS ENDING SEPTEMBER 30 Assumptions & Goals: 1 Add 50 new members per year at an average membership dues level of $50 per member 2 Add 1 Corporate Sponsor per year at $1,500 or alternatively increase Corporate Sponsor levels 3 Increase Fund Raising Event Revenue, net of expenses by 5% per year 4 Hire contingent fee grant writer with the goal of securing an additional $2,500 per year in grants 5Increase photo, book and gift shop sales by 5 %a year 6 The Delray Beach Historical Society provides a vital City function and services to the community. Our belief is that the City's contribution to the Historical Society should be sufficient to cover a majority of the staff direct costs (salaries, benefits & taxes) Requested 3% increase per year 7 Increase salary 10% for 2016 fiscal year and 4% per year thereafter B Archivist goes to full time in 2016 with 4% annual raises thereafter 9 Hire adminstrative assistant to allow DBHS director to achieve budget and goals. 4% increase per year 10 $360 per month contribution to health insurance cost per full time employee with assumed 10% increase per year 11 Payroll taxes estimated at 8% of salaries 12 With full time Archivist and Administrative Assistant it is the goal of the Historical Society to develop a recurring series of educational programs for local grade school and high school students as well as provide lecture series and educational programs for residents and assist in the publication of books and stories about Delray Beach's history. Project a 5% annual increase 13 Hire a contract grant writer /consultant on a 10% contingent basis 14 Archives facility needs more and better storage containers to ensure preservation of materials. Additionally, it is the goal of the Historical Society to have all archive materials digitized 15 Goal is to update gift shop, photo and book inventory. Estimated at 40% of sales starting in fiscal year 2016 16 Use the CRA grant to update website, collateral materials, review branding and increase exposure to the community. Thereafter will budget sufficient funds to continue to update and provide for printing, brochures and community outreach. Estimate a 5% annual increase 17 Anticipated that the accountant for the Historical Society will have to move out of current office when an administrative assistant is hired thus fees will be paid at full rates. Estimated 4% annual increase thereafter 18 Estimated 5% annual increase in cost 19 Estimated 10% increase in cost 20 Estimate 4% increase in cost Assumption/ 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Goal Ref .N REVENUE Membership Dues $ 36,000 $ 38,500 $ 41,000 $ 43,500 $ 46,000 1 Corporate & Unrestricted Contributions 5,000 6,500 8,000 9,500 11,000 2 Fundraising Events & Exhibits, net ofexpenses 18,000 18,900 19,845 20,837 21,879 3 Grants 5,000 7,500 10,000 12,500 15,000 4 Photo, Book and Gift Shop Sales 5,500 5,775 6,064 6,367 6,685 5 CRA Marketing Grant 10,800 3,600 - - - 6 City Contribution 45,000 150,000 154,500 159,135 163,909 7 Total Revenue $ 125,300 $ 230,775 $ 239,409 $ 251,839 $ 264,473 EXPENSES Personnel Executive Director 60,000 66,000 68,640 71,386 74,241 7 Archivist 19,000 38,000 39,520 41,101 42,745 8 Administrative Assistant - 24,000 24,960 25,958 26,997 9 Health Insurance - 12,960 14,256 15,682 17,250 10 Payroll Taxes 6,320 10,240 10,650 11,076 11,519 11 Total Personnel Expenses 85,320 151,200 158,026 165,202 172,751 Operating & Overhead Expenses Educational& Research Programs 1,000 25,000 26,250 27,563 28,941 12 Contract Grant Writing - 750 1,000 1,250 1,500 13 Archive Supplies & Costs 500 10,000 5,000 5,000 5,000 14 Gift Shop, Books & Photo Costs 500 2,310 2,426 2,547 2,674 15 Marketing, Printing & Collateral Material Costs 12,000 5,000 5,250 5,513 5,788 16 Accounting & Professional Fees 1,500 4,400 4,576 4,759 4,949 17 Website Maintenance & Hosting Costs 500 525 551 579 608 18 Computer Repairs & Upgrades 1,000 1,100 1,210 1,331 1,464 19 Software Costs 1,000 1,100 1,210 1,331 1,464 19 Bank& Credit Card Merchant Fees 250 260 270 281 292 20 Office & Miscellaneous Supplies 2,000 2,080 2,163 2,250 2,340 20 Dues & Subscriptions 450 468 487 506 526 20 Postage 600 1,200 1,260 1,323 1,389 18 Taxes & Licenses 250 260 270 281 292 20 Telephone 2,000 2,080 2,163 2,250 2,340 20 Insurance 7,000 7,700 8,470 9,317 10,249 19 Internet 1,000 1,040 1,082 1,125 1,170 20 Repairs & Maintenance 3,000 3,300 3,630 3,993 4,392 19 Pest Control 600 624 649 675 702 20 Storage Costs 1,560 1,622 1,687 1,755 1,825 20 Security 2,800 2,912 3,028 3,150 3,276 20 Electric 4,400 4,576 4,759 4,949 5,147 20 Water, Sewer & Gas 1,200 1,248 1,298 1,350 1,404 20 Total Operating& Overhead Expenses 45,110 79,555 78,690 83,076 87,733 TOTAL EXPENSES 130,430 230,755 236,716 248,278 260,484 NET PROFIT (LOSS) $ (5,130) $ 20 $ 2,693 $ 3,561 $ 3,990 DELRAY BEACH HISTORICAL SOCIETY ANNUAL BUDGET FOR THE FISCAL YEARS ENDING SEPTEMBER 30 Assumptions & Goals: 1 Add 50 new members per year at an average membership dues level of $50 per member 2 Add 1 Corporate Sponsor per year at $1,500 or alternatively increase Corporate Sponsor levels 3 Increase Fund Raising Event Revenue, net of expenses by 5% per year 4 Hire contingent fee grant writer with the goal of securing an additional $2,500 per year in grants 5Increase photo, book and gift shop sales by 5 %a year 6 The Delray Beach Historical Society provides a vital City function and services to the community. Our belief is that the City's contribution to the Historical Society should be sufficient to cover a majority of the staff direct costs (salaries, benefits & taxes) Requested 3% increase per year 7 Increase salary 10% for 2016 fiscal year and 4% per year thereafter B Archivist goes to full time in 2016 with 4% annual raises thereafter 9 Hire adminstrative assistant to allow DBHS director to achieve budget and goals. 4% increase per year 10 $360 per month contribution to health insurance cost per full time employee with assumed 10% increase per year 11 Payroll taxes estimated at 8% of salaries 12 With full time Archivist and Administrative Assistant it is the goal of the Historical Society to develop a recurring series of educational programs for local grade school and high school students as well as provide lecture series and educational programs for residents and assist in the publication of books and stories about Delray Beach's history. Project a 5% annual increase 13 Hire a contract grant writer /consultant on a 10% contingent basis 14 Archives facility needs more and better storage containers to ensure preservation of materials. Additionally, it is the goal of the Historical Society to have all archive materials digitized 15 Goal is to update gift shop, photo and book inventory. Estimated at 40% of sales starting in fiscal year 2016 16 Use the CRA grant to update website, collateral materials, review branding and increase exposure to the community. Thereafter will budget sufficient funds to continue to update and provide for printing, brochures and community outreach. Estimate a 5% annual increase 17 Anticipated that the accountant for the Historical Society will have to move out of current office when an administrative assistant is hired thus fees will be paid at full rates. Estimated 4% annual increase thereafter 18 Estimated 5% annual increase in cost 19 Estimated 10% increase in cost 20 Estimate 4% increase in cost MEMORANDUM TO: Mayor and City Commissioners FROM: Planning and Zoning Department THROUGH: Donald B. Cooper, City Manager DATE: January 30, 2015 SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM WS.5 - WORKSHOP MEETING OF FEBRUARY 10, 2015 SIDEWALK DEFERRAL UPDATE /MOBILITY FEE DISCUSSION BACKGROUND At the September 9, 2014 City Commission Workshop, the Environmental Services Department and the Planning and Zoning Department presented ideas and options for modifying the conventional approach to addressing sidewalk deferral requests. Until that time, sidewalk deferral requests were typically supported by staff and brought to the City Commission as Consent Agenda items. Prior to the September workshop, the City Commission expressed growing concerns over the sidewalk deferral practice including the lack of measurable criteria by which the deferrals were being granted. In addition, the granting of sidewalk deferrals in neighborhoods where there will likely never be sidewalks (due to physical constraints or neighborhood opposition), result in de -facto waivers to providing sidewalks. During the September workshop, staff discussed different ways of addressing sidewalk deferrals in the larger context of pedestrian and bicycle needs throughout the City. While there are neighborhoods where sidewalks do not exist, and likely will not be introduced in the future, there are other neighborhoods and areas, particularly near downtown and around parks and schools, where sidewalks are essential. Given these factors and the direction provided by the City Commission, staff has adopted a new approach for sidewalk deferrals which provides applicants the following options: Build the required sidewalk as provided for in Section 6.1.3 (C); 2. Provide payment in -lieu at $8 /square foot (for neighborhoods without sidewalks and with recommendation of support from the Development Services Management Group DSMG); 3. Request a Deferral (to be heard on the Regular Agenda of the City Commission meeting and may not have staff support); 4. Request a Waiver (to be heard on the Regular Agenda of the City Commission meeting and may not have staff support). Since the September workshop, 15 sidewalk deferral requests and 7 sidewalk in -lieu requests have been submitted. Currently, the LDRs state that in -lieu payments are for "said" sidewalk, and those funds are intended for future construction of the sidewalk in question. Staff will be bringing forward a text amendment to enable sidewalk in -lieu payments to be provided as funding for city -wide bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure projects through the Mobility Fund. The Mobility Fund is intended to be created as a separate city account for funds dedicated to bicycle, pedestrian, and multi -modal infrastructure projects and maintenance. These dollars would fund projects identified, estimated, and prioritized through the city's Capital Improvement Budget process. Attached is an initial list of staff - prioritized bicycle /pedestrian projects with estimated construction costs. These projects, 11 in all, have a combined estimated construction cost of $16,615,972. Revenues for the Mobility Fund could be generated through in -lieu payments for sidewalks, grant monies, and a proposed Mobility Fee. As was discussed at the sidewalk deferral workshop, and as illustrated in the estimated projects costs above, the needs for bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure improvements throughout the city are extensive and far exceed revenues generated through sidewalk in -lieu payments. To truly tackle these infrastructure needs, and to leverage matching grant funds by establishing a dedicated revenue source, staff recommends the creation of a Mobility Fee. As currently envisioned, the Mobility Fee would apply a �/z % (.005x) fee to all construction projects city -wide, with an estimated construction cost greater than $250,000. Construction projects with an estimated construction value less than $250,000 would be exempted. In addition, the first $250,000 in value of projects exceeding that amount in estimated construction costs would also be exempted. For example: 1. $1,000,000 Const. Value = $750,000 x .005% _ $3,750 2. $2,000,000 Const. Value = $1,750,000 x.005% = $8,750 3. $30,000,000 Const. Value = $29,750,000 x .005% _ $148,750 In 2013/2014, the total construction project values in the City of Delray Beach were approximately $37,519,779. If enacted, the non - adjusted value (not reducing each project by $250,000) of revenues generated for the Mobility Fund would have been approximately $180,600. The combined total revenues that would have been generated for the Mobility Fund in the last three fiscal years (again, non - adjusted) would have equaled approximately $447,000. There are many possible variations to this approach: exempting single family residential; not exempting first $250,000 for non - residential construction; modifying the percentage multiplier, etc. The purpose for bringing this item before the Board is to discuss whether or not this approach is desirable, and if so, gain Commission insight and direction on how it should be implemented. DISCUSSION Environmental Services Department and Planning & Zoning are seeking Commission direction for the consideration of a Mobility Fund and Mobility Fee. Capital Improvements — Mobility Projects Cost Estimate Lowson Boulevard Corridor A - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Sidewalk 12,975 Bike Lanes 13,548 Unit Unit Cost L.F. $ 60.00 L.F. $ 83.00 Total Cost $ 778, 500.00 $ 1,124, 484.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 1,902,984.00 " this does not include widening of the bridge at the canal around $500,000 Lowson Boulevard Corridor A - Phase 2 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 6,165 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 369,900.00 Bike Lanes 16,174 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 1,342,442.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 1,712,342.00 Lowson Boulevard Corridor A - Phase 3 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 1,169 L. F. $ 60.00 $ 70,140.00 Bike Lanes 6,990 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 580,170.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 650,310.00 Homewood Boulevard Corridor B - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 2,842 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 170,520.00 Bike Lanes 8,328 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 691,224.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 861,744.00 Old Germantown Road Corridor C - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 0 L.F. $ 60.00 $ - Bike Lanes 8,786 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 729,238.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 729,238.00 S: \EngAdmin \Mobility Fee Fund Sidewalks and Bike Lanes \Cost EstimateCost Estimate 1/22/2015 Capital Improvements — Mobility Projects Cost Estimate Old Germantown Road Corridor C - Phase 2 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 3,330 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 199,800.00 Bike Lanes 7,034 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 583,822.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 783,622.00 SW 17th Avenue Corridor D - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 3,394 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 203,640.00 Bike Lanes 4,116 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 341,628.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 545,268.00 Barwick Road Corridor E - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 3,394 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 203,640.00 Bike Lanes 5,212 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 432,596.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 636,236.00 Barwick Road Corridor E - Phase 2 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 4,600 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 276,000.00 Bike Lanes 11,000 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 913,000.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 1,189,000.00 Seacreast Boulevard Corridor F - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 1,256 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 75,360.00 Bike Lanes 8,562 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 710,646.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 786,006.00 S: \EngAdmin \Mobility Fee Fund Sidewalks and Bike Lanes \Cost EstimateCost Estimate 1/22/2015 Capital Improvements — Mobility Projects Cost Estimate Swinton Avenue Corridor G - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Sidewalk 3,349 Bike Lanes 8,562 Unit Unit Cost L.F. $ 60.00 L.F. $ 83.00 Total Cost $ 200, 940.00 $ 710, 646.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 911,586.00 Swinton Avenue Corridor G - Phase 2 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 0 L.F. $ 60.00 $ - Bike Lanes 8,986 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 745,838.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 745,838.00 Swinton Avenue Corridor G - Phase 3 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 2,316 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 138,960.00 Bike Lanes 10,604 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 880,132.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 1,019,092.00 South Dixie Highway Corridor H - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 2,588 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 155,280.00 Bike Lanes 5,370 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 445,710.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 600,990.00 South Dixie Highway Corridor I - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Unit Unit Cost Total Cost Sidewalk 9,249 L.F. $ 60.00 $ 554,940.00 Bike Lanes 10,606 L.F. $ 83.00 $ 880,298.00 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Total $ 1,435,238.00 S: \EngAdmin \Mobility Fee Fund Sidewalks and Bike Lanes \Cost EstimateCost Estimate 1/22/2015 Capital Improvements — Mobility Projects Cost Estimate George Bush Boulvard Corridor J - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Sidewalk 2,594 Bike Lanes 10,882 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing SW 4th Avenue Corridor K - Phase 1 Estimated Qty Sidewalk 2,764 Bike Lanes 10,624 Bike Lane Unit cost includes roadway resurfacing Unit Unit Cost L.F. $ 60.00 L.F. $ 83.00 Total Cost $ 155, 640.00 $ 903,206.00 Total $ 1, 058, 846.00 Unit Unit Cost L.F. $ 60.00 L.F. $ 83.00 Total Cost $ 165, 840.00 $ 881, 792.00 Total $ 1,047,632.00 S: \EngAdmin \Mobility Fee Fund Sidewalks and Bike Lanes \Cost EstimateCost Estimate 1/22/2015 II I�hrll�ll II = �'�, , � %IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ►� �� •♦ � • � � ..111 IIIIIII�� ��I ��� q� �� � ms`s �+� �� 111111 ■ ��� � � � ��� � � •:� ` �1111111111111111� �I � , �� r lilt '0 Fiore Way No ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■�! ■ ■■ 1 ■Sil ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ login ■■■ ■I - -- - 1 ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■r ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■� ■■■■■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■■ 111111111 ■■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■1 ■ ■■ ■11 ■I ■ ■ ■1 ■ ■ ■1MIME -- ■■■■■■■■� ■■■■ ■■ ■ ■1 ` . ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■■■ � ,� ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■�I■Ylii iii■ ■■■■■■■ J �■■■i�l�li WIN! ■■■■ J 1■■ �. ■ 1111!! '' •' '�' �lllll�l:e� e��1�1C�1J� �lllllllJ�� .!�!� � :.; •;•. •:•' -•- � 111���1111l1 11111111�� •• .�a. 111111111111111 � � 1111 � •� •. • n� • ��� - -• -• • � 11111111111111111 ` � rlllllll1111111111 `•. .. .;. rr��ll�ii��i1 oi��i��rr�lllli���• �OCillllll� .,•,, ,•, .•,,;••,• �. ��I� ►� ill■■ MEN MEMNON EXISTING SW = • KEY CORRIDOR A, PHASE 1 PROPOSED SW = 12975 u NORT EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_LANDSCAPE_20150107 SW 11th Ct E I EA Vill Cir rn E E ELEMEN -w""m Legend - i PROPOSED-SW �J ■ �.za•raJ: • • :Fn.. � 9073 • KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO NORTH I u Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_LANDSCAPE_20150 a d ansy 4 z m LL F SW 11th Ct E I EA Vill Cir rn E E ELEMEN -w""m Legend - i PROPOSED-SW �J ■ �.za•raJ: • • :Fn.. � 9073 • KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO NORTH I u Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_LANDSCAPE_20150 �■ ■■ ■■ ■■ 11111111 ■11111111■ =1- �_ i� � ■■ �� ■■ _■ �- 11111 ■ M� ■� ii ,��ii ■■ ■� ==MEN ■■111111■ ■ i� � ■ � 1 � ■■ ■■�■ '�■■ ■■ 11111■■ ■�I ��■■■■■■■ :� X11111 _ ■ � ■ .� . �i� 1111111■ ���■ 1111■■ ■■■■■■111 '� ■ p p p � � ■■ � � \� 111111111 1111111111 ■111111111■11■■■111 �■ ■ ■ ■ �:� ■■ � � ■ ■�■I�■I■ 1■l■1■■I�� v111■1■ - ■1111111■: _ _ ■ i ■ ■ ■� 111■■■■ 111■ ■1 ■� ,RONNI■■ 11 � ■ 1 ■ ■ ■ ■ 1111■ ■■ p ■ ■ ■�■ 111111 ■11 1■ ■11111111 IIIII■ ■111 11111111■■ ■■■■■■� : _��11� _ _ _ _ ■ ■/� 11111 �IIIII' ■ ��� ■is 1■ 1■ ■11� ■IIIIIIIIIIII '��1�11 ■ `I 1■ �® 111111111��IN11®R.111 � 111 X111111111111 �� .1■ ,. �1�11 ■11111111111 � , 11� 11 MEMO I �_ .. �■ 11111111■■ EXISTING SW 4560 L.F. _ ' CORRIDOR PROPOSED SW = 1169 L.F. y C u • m��q Y •�P O • Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11maps_LANDSCAPE_2015010' _. "4n � ---- ce De 4e on B c J L OJW d a G Cro,0` Q� 4a San Cl a Q Del Aire Blvd Pansy Ln Croton Ln Halm Ln r Hibiscus Blvd L d N 7 w V f6 U L Black Oliv$ BL� SW I 3 n 0 m L Legend Juan r (' 'o PROPOSED—SW L U EXISTING SW s� KEY CORRIDOR EXISTING SW = 4624 L.F. PROPOSED SW = 2842 L.F. NORTH B, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_ improvements _8 x 11_ maps_ PORTRAIT_ 201501 )7 r ■■��� ��► �� is _ .��� - - -- M INN m� 00 11 ON 11 ... son .. �■ _ ■■ �■■■■■■■■■■■■�� LU LU �' ,' I � III��IIIIIIIIIIII ■ � ��I /����0 11111► 1111111 � ! ��- - ,` nmulmip�� _. -I, Mill on F any SSOJBUOO g ' U), 4 y 0 W U) Z O D- o X C d w o li O LL J Z a� J J o u o C,) LU CL I- M Z CM II J II 3: LLJ U) Y cn 0 m W U) Z O Z H d H LD OLD Xa�X waw N W Q 2 a U O JY N r I.L 5D O U e� > 6r Y 5 2 O z A oonnawo L d ILLAGE ACADEMY N rn N SW 7th St S 6 �e O� O d a a t m rn r d Legend N r PROPOSED-SW y DEFFERED SW LJ 516111f th t DEFERRED SW 561 L.F. KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED SW = 3394 L.F. NORTH D, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_ PORTRAIT _201501, )7 EK ELEMENTAR O Sa al La es R Be le r1 Ir e� o� n tl a ' S Cir r B1 4e Flag W 'sod St Country Manors Blvd O � O Legend J PROPOSED SW EXISTING—SW �wr 9 Cav % Lake I Rd m W F:D F�7] FT� IDFT J'% KEY CORRIDOR PROPO ED SW 242491 L.F. Q��RC,vec� ,& TJ NORTH E, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_ PORTRAIT _201501, )7 X-1 ckin9 (Pardi j ja r 9 NW 4th St �0 ❑ ❑� EH EH EE � � EH FH r t ort Dr c CL N IN 3rd Ct A Q co Circle Ter W NW 3rd St i High Po nt Blvd NW 3rd St < 3 St L egend o z NW 2nd St c c Sou h r NW 2nd St a a a V m t s a� a� a� a JG) _ 2 i W rA C � to 143rd PI El KEY CORRIDOR EXISTING SW = 985 L.F. PROPOSED SW4 4600 L.F. Q��RC,vec� NORTH E, PHASE 2 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_ improvements _8 x 11_ maps_ PORTRAIT_ 201501 )7 L egend JG) PROPOSEDSW y" R MIDDLE SAJO EXISTING SW El KEY CORRIDOR EXISTING SW = 985 L.F. PROPOSED SW4 4600 L.F. Q��RC,vec� NORTH E, PHASE 2 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_ improvements _8 x 11_ maps_ PORTRAIT_ 201501 )7 T" Legend EXISTING-SW PROPOSED-SW PLUMOSA SCHOOL OF THE ARTS KEY CORRIDOR EXISTING SW = 551 L.F. PROPOSED SW? 1256 L.F. NORTH F, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO G'� NE 2 nd St L 2 _d i int n it N e c es C k IM] El O O `caret E PM] KEY CORRIDOR G, PHASE 1 Legend PROPOSED SW EXISTING SW DEFERRED SW EXISTING SW = 4200 L.F. DEFERRED SW = 128 L.F. PROPOSED SW = 3221 L.F. EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO X n n N T—NL T it Q L M i NP Q t W Z N 2nd R N d N d St qt -1 Legend EXISTING SW tlan [:-9V 110 EXISTING SW = ' KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED SW 8300 FF Q��RC,vec� NORTH G, PHASE 2 EXISTING BIKE LANE NO G'� Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_ improvements _8 x 11_ maps_ PORTRAIT_ 201501 )7 Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_ improvements _8 x 11_ maps_ PORTRAIT_ 20150 )7 S Dr N Longport Cir L U L ; U p C o a CL o ._ � J � J W d S Longport Cir o c 3 .a d Banyan I ree n �a Legend PROPOSED SW EXISTING W Linton Blvd — SW E Lin LLEXISTING SW x KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED SW 24 N 2588 L.F. Q��RC,vec� 7,J NORTH H, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_ PORTRAIT _201501, )7 Cir E� E3 ED EE :1 El �B 9VO Legend PROPOSED SW L EXISTING SW ° EXISTING SW = KEY CORRIDOR PROPOSED SW 109249 L.F. NORTH I, PHASE 1 EXISTING BIKE LANE = NO G'� 111111 ■I ■■.■ .. r !"■ ®■ ■■■ ■� �� ■■■, LL LL Z 11 Lr) 11 LLJ '�IIIIIIIII ` . �� 11 IIIIII�■ ■ _ 11 MINIM ■1 LU ■�� ■1■ MINI ■�11�11I� : r� ■ ■li1�i ■■ ■■ ��`�1 .1 ■III ■111111■ 1 ■■® ■1■■■ MITI ■■ ■1�1■ 111 11.111111.. ■ ■■ 1111■■ �■� ■ � 11111 :� �■ ■11111111 ■ ■11 ■ ■11■ ■111 ■i� ■ iilll � � 1■ ■ 11- .� ■IIIIIIII�■ � J � �� ®11 ■11■ 11 , ��I C �- X1.11 I� �•■� - ■ • �� �■ _� ■_ -1 JIII � X11 MINE ,�11��� �■ LU INS ■� ■� �- -- -- -■ II■111111�1 11111■ ■I� _�� ■_ ��■ . ■■� i � ♦ ■■ ��� ■■ ® ■I 111 ■� �� �■ �■ ■� M■ ■� �■ ►� I� _■ X11 1 ■1 ■� ■■ ■■ ■■ ■■ ON ■■� ■■ 11► �i *i 1111 ■■ MIoilHob, 0 _ I F M %— �, Document Name: Sidewalk_ proposed_improvements_8 x 11_maps_ PORTRAIT _201501, )7