07-26-88 Regular
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
REGULAR MEETING - CITY COMMISSION
July 26, 1988
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
Commission Chambers
Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made
by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at this
meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these
proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that
a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes
the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The
City does not provide or prepare such record.
1. Roll Call.
2. Invocation.
3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
4. Proclamation:
Delray Beach National Little League.
5. Agenda approval.
Action: Motion to approve.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
6. WAIVER OF ORDINANCE AND APPROVAL - AMERICAN CANCER SOCIETY AUGUST
20, 1988.
7. ORDINANCE NO. 80-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance annexing
property on Atlantic Avenue at Barwick with initial zoning of ART and
PRD-L (Sherwood Forest Development). If passed Second Reading August
9th.
8. ORDINANCE NO. 75-88: (Continued Public
Reading) An Ordinance rezoning 25 acres of City
to RM to accommodate the proposed Auburn Trace
If passed Second Reading August 9th.
Hearing and First
owned land from R-lA
Housing Development.
9. ORDINANCE NO. 76-88:
An Ordinance amending the
lOth Street and Federal
zoning from MF-lO to C.
(Second
Land Use
Highway
Reading and Second Public
Plan for property located
(Gulfstream Motor Lodge),
Hearing)
at S. E.
changing
10. ORDINANCE NO. 78-88: (Second Reading and Second Public Hearing)
An Ordinance amending the Land Use Plan for property located east of
Military Trail, south of the L-32 Canal (Pylon Professional Building),
changing zoning from MF-6 to O.
11. ORDINANCE NO. 81-88: (First
property on South Federal Highway
City zoning of GC and RM. If passed
Reading) An Ordinance annexing
(Enterprise Leasing) with initial
Second Reading August 9th.
12. ORDINANCE NO. 82-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending the
Zoning Code by revising the P.C.C. zoning district in its entirety.
If passed Second Reading August 9th.
13. ORDINANCE NO.
Chapter 162, "Signs
to permit fees. If
83-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance
and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances
passed Second Reading August 9th.
amending
relative
14. ORDINANCE NO. 84-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162, "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances to
eliminate the necessity of Community Appearance Board approval for
certain signs within the central Business District. If passed Second
Reading August 9th.
15. ORDINANCE NO. 85-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances to allow
identification structures to be placed in the medians or rights-of-way
adjacent to subdivision entrances. If passed Second Reading August
9th.
16. ORDINANCE NO. 86-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances to permit
permanent special events sign. If passed Second Reading August 9th.
17. ORDINANCE NO. 87-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances providing
that the definition of sign area shall equate with the definition of
sign face. If passed Second Reading August 9th.
18. ORDINANCE NO. 88-88: (First Reading) An
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of
a freestanding directory sign in a nonresidential
passed Second Reading August 9th.
Ordinance amending
Ordinances to permit
zoning district. If
19. ORDINANCE NO. 89-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances providing
for limitations on the size and number of freestanding identification
signs in shopping centers. If passed Second Reading August 9th.
20. ORDINANCE NO. 90-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending
Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of Ordinances to permit
a sign denoting the hours of business operation. If passed Second
Reading August 9th.
21. ORDINANCE NO. 91-88: (First Reading) An Ordinance amending the
Zoning Code by revising the definition of "Family". If passed Second
Reading August 9th.
PUBLIC HEARINGS - ENCLAVE ORDINANCES
22. ORDINANCE NO. 62-88: (Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
annexation of Enclave 3lB, located on the west side of S. W. 4th
Avenue, between Linton Boulevard and S. W. lOth Street.
23. ORDINANCE
annexation of
intersection of
NO. 63-88:
Enclave 32,
S. W. lOth
(Second Reading)
located at the
Street and S. W.
An Ordinance for the
southwest corner of the
4th Avenue.
24. ORDINANCE NO. 64-88: (Second Reading) An Ordinance
annexation of Enclave 38, located between U. S. Highway No. 1
Intracoastal Waterway, south of S. E. 10th Street.
for the
and the
25. ORDINANCE NO. 65-88: (Second Reading)
annexation of Enclave 39, located on the south
the west end of said street, lying east
Intracoastal Waterway.
An Ordinance for the
side of Brooks Lane, at
of and adjacent to the
26. ORDINANCE
annexation of
(Highway AlA).
NO. 66-88:
Enclave 42,
(Second
located
Reading) An
at Linton
Ordinance for the
and Ocean Boulevard
27. ORDINANCE NO. 67-88:
annexation of Enclave 46,
Boulevard (Highway AlA) just
(Second
located
south of
Reading) An Ordinance for the
along the east side of Ocean
Linton Boulevard.
28. ORDINANCE NO. 68-88: (Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
annexation of Enclave 47, located one quarter mile south of Linton
Boulevard between Ocean Boulevard (Highway AlA) and the beach.
29. ORDINANCE NO. 69-88:
(Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
-2-
annexation of Enclave 48, located one quarter mile south of Linton
Boulevard on the west side of Ocean Boulevard (Highway AlA).
30. ORDINANCE NO. 70-88:
annexation of Enclave 43,
McCleary Street.
(Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
located in the Tropic Isle Subdivision off
31. ORDINANCE NO. 71-88: (Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
annexation of Enclave 44, located on the southeast corner of the Sun
Bank property to the north of Burger King on South Federal Highway,
just south of Linton.
32. ORDINANCE NO. 72-88: (Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
annexation of Enclave 45, located on the east side of South Federal
Highway and is presently the site of a portion of the Delray Beach
Toyota Automobile dealership.
33. ORDINANCE NO. 73-88:
annexation of Enclave 58,
Road and the L-30 Canal.
(Second Reading) An Ordinance for the
located at the southwest corner of Davis
ENCLAVE ORDINANCES - FIRST READING - NO PUBLIC HEARING
34. ORDINANCE NO. 92-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
49, located at 2325 South Ocean Boulevard (Cote d'Azure). If passed,
Public Hearing August 23rd.
35. ORDINANCE NO. 93-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
51, located east of Florida Boulevard and bordered on three sides by
Tropic Bay Condominiums. If passed, Public Hearing August 23rd.
36. ORDINANCE NO. 94-88: An
52, located west of Federal
Public Hearing August 23rd.
Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
Highway, north of Lindell. If passed
37. ORDINANCE NO. 95-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
54, located south of the South Delray Shopping Center and Avenue L.
If passed, Public Hearing August 23rd.
38. ORDINANCE NO. 96-88:
56, located on the L-3l
Hearing August 23rd.
An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
Canal off Barwick Road. If passed, Public
39. ORDINANCE NO. 97-88: An
57, located in the Windward
Hearing August 23rd.
Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
Palms Subdivision. If passed, Public
40. ORDINANCE NO. 98-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
60, located south of Lake Ida Road between 1-95 and the FEC Railroad.
If passed,Public Hearing August 23rd.
41.
64,
feet
ORDINANCE NO. 99-88: An
located west of the FEC
south of the L-32 Canal.
Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
Railroad right-of-way approximately 750
If passed, Public Hearing August 23rd.
42. ORDINANCE NO. 100-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
67, which consists of a mile long canal which lies east of Dover Road.
If passed, Public Hearing August 23rd.
43. ORDINANCE NO. 101-88: An Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave
70, which consists of a vacant parcel of property and adjacent canals
east of 1-95, west of the Tropic Palms Subdivision. If passed, Public
Hearing August 23rd.
FIRST READINGS - NOT ENCLAVES
44. ORDINANCE NO. 81-87:
the Zoning Code relative to
tabled on October 20, 1987.
Reconsideration of an Ordinance amending
the definition of "Family" which had been
-3-
SECOND READINGS - NOT ENCLAVES
45. ORDINANCE NO. 61-88: An Ordinance annexing property on North
Federal Highway (Borton Volvo, Inc.) with initial zoning of SC.
46. ORDINANCE NO. 74-88:
PCC and R-lA to SC for
along Germantown Road.
An Ordinance rezoning land presently zoned
the proposed Wallace Automobile Dealership
47. ORDINANCE NO. 79-88: An Ordinance rezoning land presently zoned
SAD to POC for the existing Pylon Professional Building, located east
of Military Trail, south of the L-32 Canal.
48. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST (CU
conditional use and attendant site plan for
the southwest corner of Federal Highway and S.
6-241): Requesting
proposed Hotel/Motel
E. lOth Street.
a
at
49. ORDINANCE NO. 77-88: An Ordinance rezoning land presently zoned
RM-lO to SAD for the proposed Gulfstream Motor Lodge located at S. E.
10th Street and Federal Highway.
REGULAR AGENDA
50. DOLPHIN PILE VARIANCE REQUEST - MICHAEL BACARELLA: Requesting a
variance for installation of dolphin pile at 917 Banyan Drive.
51. DOLPHIN
Requesting a
Drive.
PILE VARIANCE REQUEST NANCY SIEGEL-OLMSTEAD:
variance for installation of dolphin pile at 947 Jasmine
52. INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT FOR DEVELOPMENT OF 33 SINGLE FAMILY HOMES:
Consider authorizing execution of Interlocal Agreement between the
City and Palm Beach County for the development of 33 single family
homes bounded by S. W. 2nd Street and S. W. 8th Avenue.
53. TEMPORARY TENT - REVIVAL MEETING: Consider request from Daughter
of Zion Seventh Day Adventist Church to erect a tent on their property
located across the street from their church at 201 N. W. 3rd Avenue
for a revival meeting from July 31st through September 3rd.
54. TEMPORARY TENT - REVIVAL MEETING: Consider request from Bethanie
Zion 7th Day Adventist French Church to erect a tent on vacant
property located on the corner of S. W. 6th Avenue and S. W. 10th
Street for a revival meeting from July 31st through August 27th.
CONSENT AGENDA
55. CHILDREN SERVICES COUNCIL GRANT: Consider acceptance of a
$112,362 grant from the Children Services Council for the expansion of
afterschool program at the Community Center, Carver School and Pompey
Park.
56. LAW ENFORCEMENT ACCREDITATION: Consider appropriation of $18,000
from Law Enforcement Trust Fund for second phase of Law Enforcement
Accreditation.
57. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
conditional use and attendant
Automobile Dealership facilities
REQUEST (CU 6-222): Requesting a
site and development plan for Wallace
east of Germantown Road.
58. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST (CU 6-575):
conditional use and attendant site and development plan
Gasoline Station at the northwest corner of Atlantic and
Requesting a
for the Exxon
Congress.
59. RESOLUTION
nuisances on 31
the City.
NO. 40-88: A Resolution assessing costs for abating
parcels of property at various locations throughout
60. RESOLUTION NO. 41-88: A Resolution assessing costs for abating
-4-
nuisances on 4 parcels of property at various locations throughout the
City.
61. RESOLUTION
action required
Federal.
NO. 42-88: A Resolution assessing costs for abatement
to remove an unsafe building on property at 911 North
62. RESOLUTION
action required
10th Avenue.
NO. 43-88: A Resolution assessing costs for abatement
to remove an unsafe building on property at 102 N. W.
63. AWARDS OF BIDS AND CONTRACTS:
A. Scott Airpacs - Safety Equipment Company _ $21,743.30.
B. Handtools and Hardware Supplies - Duncan-Edwards _ $21,000.
C. Cellular Telephones
$lO,680.
Cartel Business Communications
D. Watermain Construction in Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course
- Onontario of Palm Beach - $251,817.45.
E. Street Resurfacing - Hardrives of Delray _ $300,510.
F. N. E. lst Street Storm Drainage Project _ Hardrives of Delray
- $749,763.
G. Contract for Construction of Air Stripping Units to Treat the
20 Series Wel1field - Elkin Construction _ $l,485,478.90.
H. Water and Sewer Revenue Bond Issue _
Paying Agent and Registrar - Citizens and Southern _
$l2,075.
Escrow Agent - Mid1antic National Bank - $11,200.
PROCEDURAL ITEMS
64. Comments and Inquiries on Non-Agenda Items by Citizens.
65. Approval of minutes of Regular Meeting of June 28, 1988,
66. Comments and Inquiries on Non-Agenda Items:
A. Commission.
B. City Attorney.
C. City Manager.
-5-
[ITY OF DELAAY BEA[H
100 NW. 1st AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
ADDENDUM
REGULAR MEETING - CITY COMMISSION
July 26, 1988
No.4B Presentation:
Labor Day Police Competition - Ray Gerner, Director
De1ray Citizens for De1ray Police
No.30 Ordinance No. 70-88 is withdrawn for revision and re-
advertisement
THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
305/243- 7000
[ITY DF DELAAY BEA[H
100 N.W. 1st AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
305/243-7000
EXECUTIVE SESSION
OF
THE CITY COMMISSION
An Executive Session to review Collective Bargaining
matters will be held on Tuesday, July 26, 1988, in the
Conference Room at 6:00 P.M., pursuant to Florida
Statutes 447.605.
THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
MEMORANDUM
TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: CITY MANAGER
SUBJECT: AGENDA REPORT - MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
DATE: July 22, 1988
PRESENTATION
PUBLIC HEARINGS - NON ENCLAVE ORDINANCES
Item No. 6 Request for Waiver of Ordinance. The American Cancer
Society South Palm Beach County Unit represented by Karen Mathews has
requested permission to distribute free sunscreen products from booths
place along the public beach on August 20th between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m.
The American Cancer Society will not be endorsing any particular
product but rather promoting safe sunning practices. All permit
applications, proof of liability insurance, and other staff
requirements have been satisfied.
Reconunendwaiver of Code Section 101.25 (B) (sale of goods or services
on the beach) and approval of the American Cancer Society "Sun-Safety"
program.
Item No. 7 (Ordinance No. 80-88) Sherwood Forest Golf, Inc.,
represented by the Sanders Planning Group has requested voluntary
annexation with initial zoning of PRD-L and ART for 73.28 acres of
property located on the south side of West Atlantic Avenue between
Country Club Acres and Forest Road.
The 73.28 acre tract is presently utilized for golf course purposes.
It is proposed to construct 131 single family detached zero lot line
housing units surrounding the golf course which will remain as will a
driving range adjacent to Atlantic Avenue.
There are no required
an enclave, required
voluntary annexation.
findings other than annexation will not create
by Florida Statutes prior to approval of a
The proposed zoning designations are PRD-L (Planned Residential
Development--Low to Medium Density) for 62.87 acres and ART
(Agricultural Residential Transitional) for 10.41 acres. The proposed
development of single family, zero lot line homes is consistent with
the existing Land Use Map designation and adjacent zoning.
The Planning and Zoning Board at its June 20th meeting recommended
that the annexation and zoning request be acted upon at this time but
has continued the conditional use and site plan review until a later
date. The Planning and Zoning Board recommends approval of the
annexation and finding that:
1. That annexation will not create an additional enclave(s).
,
2. That service will
similar to that for
already in the City.
be provided to this property in a manner
similarly situated properties which are
3. That the proposed zoning of PRD-L and ART are consistent with
the adjacent zoning and complies (does not conflict) with all of
the seventeen standards for evaluating rezoning requests as found
in Section 30-23 (D).
4. The proposed zoning is
the existing County zoning
course) of the property.
consistent (does not conflict) with
of AR or the existing use (golf
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
5. The proposed zoning is consistent (does not conflict) with
the City's Land Use Plan designation of SF for the property.
6. That a Title Certificate for the parcel fronting on Atlantic
Avenue and a corrected annexation application encompassing that
parcel is submitted.
Recommend approval
owned by Sherwood
and ART.
of Ordinance 80-88 annexing 73.28 acres of property
Forest Golf, Inc. with an initial zoning of PRD-L
Item No. 8 (Ordinance No. 75-88) This is a continued Public Hearing
and First Reading of an Ordinance rezoning 25 acres of property
from R-lA to RM-lO to accommodate the proposed Auburn Trace affordable
housing development. A 13 acre parcel adjacent to this one is
presently zoned RM10. Approval of this rezoning action will allow the
development of 368 units of low and moderate income housing on the
presently vacant sites.
The rezoning action on this property was initiated in November 1987
with a proposed designation of RH. Following Planning and Zoning
Board hearings in January, it was recommended that zoning for the
Auburn Trace project be changed to RM consistent with a companion
action on a Land Use Map Amendment.
Under provisions of the RM zoning district seven units per acre is
guaranteed. An increase in density of up to ten units per acre is
permitted provided that performance standards are met in the site plan
of the project. A detailed analysis of those performance standards is
contained in a backup memo enclosed in your agenda packet. In
considering this rezoning action the Commission should be guided by
the 17 standards found in the City's Municipal Code Section 173.888.
They include:
1. will the change be contrary to the existing Land Use pattern?
2. Will the change alter the population density pattern, thereby
increasing the load on public facilities such as schools,
utilities, streets, and the like?
3. Will the change adversely influence living conditions in the
neighborhood?
4. What impact will the projects have on traffic and drainage in
the area?
5. Will the change adversely affect property values in the area
and the adjacent area?
6. Is the change out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood
or the City?
City and Palm Beach County School Board staff -met to discuss the
impact the Auburn Trace Complex might have on school attendance
boundaries and racial composition. Following that meeting a position
statement from the District opposing the Auburn Trace complex was
forwarded. A copy is enclosed in your agenda packet as are memos from
the Director of Community Improvement and the Planning & Zoning
Director assessing the affordable housing proposal.
The Auburn Trace development has a long history. At issue is whether
or not 368 units of low and moderate income housing on this 38 acre
tract is an appropriate use given its location and its impact on
racial composition of various school attendance areas in South Palm
Beach County. The City and procacci Development Company received
a UDAG Grant in the amount of $5,048,860. The grant application
- 2 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
contemplated 368 units of housing with rentals ranging from $290 to
$494 per month. An amenity package for the apartment complex includes
a privacy wall and a security system all of which are designed to
attract a stable tenant mix and offer a quality living environment.
Several suggestions for proposals with lower densities have recently
been discussed as alternatives. A review of the circumstances and
conditions which existed when the plan initially went forward in the
fall of 1987 till now do not support a change in direction at this
time. The City needs an affordable housing component to ~ts
redevelopment plan. It is consistent with our Community Redevelopment
and Code Enforcement efforts. A market for quality housing in this
price range exists based on the market rental rates in Delray Beach
even for properties with no amenities. Rentals for similar property
in the "CD target area" range between $350 and $550. The CRA
currently received $335 per month on one bedroom units it owns and
manages on S.W. 1st Street.
Although there is no way to guarantee or accurately forecast the
actual number, it is reasonable to expect that most if not all of the
new residents can be drawn from the Delray Beach population. It is
not unreasonable to expect that professionals and semi-professionals
such as police, fire, sales, education, and other workers in similar
income groups will find this housing attractive given the Auburn Trace
amenity packages and built in security systems. It is important to
keep in mind that will imposing lower densities may still allow a
financially feasible project, there are other cash flow factors to
consider. A reduction in construction and mortgage costs for a
complex fewer units will occur. Operating costs for an apartment
complex of this size will not however be reduced and thus the amenity
package which makes this project a worthwhile one, may not be
affordable with lowered operating revenues.
By way of summary, the City has a $5,048,860. UDAG Grant to offset
the cost of this affordable housing complex. A market exists for the
housing; the parcels being considered for development are unlikely
candidates for non-residential development; and the developer has
signed a contract to construct the housing. On the other hand there
is some community concern about the impact that 368 units of
additional housing in this largely black neighborhood will have on the
future of Delray Beach, especially its school population. A nine
member task force consisting of City and School District staff and
members of the public will be convening shortly to address this topic
which is of course a regional issue in addition to being a Delray
Beach issue. While not discounting this issue, its impact does not
weigh against proceeding with this important component to the City's
housing assistance plan which will provide 368 units of low and
moderate income housing in a quality environment.
of Ordinance No.
associated with ro osed
from R-lA to RM.
75-80
Auburn
rezoning 25 acres of
Trace affordable housin
Item No.9 (Ordinance No. 76-88). This is a Second Reading of an
Ordinance amending the Land Use Plan for property located at S.E.
10th and Federal Highway from MF-10 to C. Freedom Savings and Loan
Association, represented by Currie, Schneider and Associates, has
requested consideration of a Land Use Plan Amendment from MF-10 to C.
The vacant 2.07 acre parcel is proposed as a site of a new 98 room
hotel/motel to be called the Gulfstream Motor Lodge.
The Planning and Zoning Board at its June 20th meeting recommended
approval of the request for the proposed Land Use and zoning changes
finding them consistent with existing Land Use patterns and
surrounding zoning designations. Contemplating approval of this Land
- 3 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Use Plan Amendment a conditional use and site plan and rezoning
ordinance are included later in your agenda.
Recommend approval of Ordinance
designation from MF-10 to C for
and S.E. Federal Highway.
Item No. 10 (Ordinance No. 78-88) This is a Second Reading of an
Ordinance amending the Land Use Plan from MF-6 to Office for property
located along Military Trail south of the L-32 Canal. Pylon Medical
Associates, Ltd. represented by David L. Keesler has requested
consideration of a Land Use Plan amendment from MF-6 to Office. The
1.967 acre parcel presently contains a professional office building on
the site.
No. 76-88 amending the Land Use Plan
property located at S.E. 10th Street
The Planning and Zoning Board recommended approval of the Land Use
Plan modification at their June 20th meeting.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 78-88 amending the Land Use Plan
from MF-6 to 0 to POC for the Pylon Professional Building.
Item No. 11 (Ordinance No. 81-88) This is a First Reading of an
Ordinance voluntarily annexing Enterprise Leasing located on South
Federal Highway and applying City zoning of GC and, for one lot only,
RM zoning. This item has been before the City Commission earlier when
the appropriateness of Commercial zoning on Lot 14 was discussed.
At. that time the Commission determined that Lot 14 should remain
Residential and that two zoning designations should be applied. The
owner's representative has met with his client who is receptive to the
split zoning approach and asks that processing resume.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 81-88 annexing Enterprise Leasing
and applying zoning of GC and RM.
Item No. 12 (Ordinance No. 82-88) Amendment to the Zoning Code
revising P.C.C. (Planned Commercial Center) Zoning District. The
P.C.C. Zoning District has existed in the City for a number of years.
The first project to use the zoning was Congress Park South with a
site plan approved in 1982. The present language in our zoning code
was included in 1985 modifications following which the Delray Park of
Commerce began development.
The Delray Park of Commerce located on Congress Avenue north of Lake
Ida Road has consistently desired changes to the regulations in order
to provide more flexibility for development. The Planning and Zoning
Board at its June 27th meeting adopted a number of changes to
significantly increase flexibility within the P.C.C. District by
increasing the land area available for service industry use and
allowing pure research and development uses to locate anywhere in the
P.C.C. regardless of the land use designations otherwise noted on the
development plan. There is also more exact definition provided as to
use categories and the research and development category is removed
from the light industrial definition.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 82-88 amending the Zoning Code by
revising P.C.C. zoning district in its entirety.
Item No. 13 (Ordinance No. 83-88) This is a First Reading of an
Ordinance amending Chapter 162, "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of
Ordinances relative to permit fees. This item and the six ordinances
which follow amend the City's sign ordinance to reflect consensus from
your work session on June 21st. The City Attorney has determined
individual ordinances are required for each of the amendments.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 83-88 amending sign and billboard
permit fees.
- 4 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Item No. 14 (Ordinance No. 84-88) This is a First Reading of an
Ordinance amending Chapter 162, "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of
Ordinances to eliminate the necessity of Community Appearance Board
approval for certain signs within the Central Business District.
Recommend a roval of
Ordinance eliminating
to ap rove certain si
Ordinance No. 84-88 amendin Si n and Billboard
the necessity of the Community Appearance Board
ns within the Central Business District.
Item No. 15 (Ordinance No. 85-88) This is a First Reading
Ordinance amending Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the
Ordinances to allow identification structures to be placed
medians or rights-of-way adjacent to subdivision entrances.
of an
Code of
in the
Recommend a roval of Ordinance
structures to be placed in the
subdivision entrances.
No. 85-88 to allow identification
medians or rights-of-way adiacent to
Item No. 16 (Ordinance No. 86-88) This is a Fir-st
Ordinance amendin'J Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards"
Ordinances to permit permanent special events sign.
Reading of an
of the Code of
Recommend a roval of Ordinance No. 86-88 amend in the
Billboard Ordinance to permit permanent special events signs.
Si nand
Item No. 17 (Ordinance No. 87-88) This is a First Reading
Ordinance amending Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the
Ordinances providing that the definition of sign area shall
with the definition of sign face.
of an
Code of
equate
Recommend a roval
Billboard Ordinance
shall equate to the
of Ordinance No. 87-88 amend in
to provide that the definition
definition of the sign face.
the Si~n and
of a sign area
Item No. 18 (Ordinance No. 88-88) This is a First Reading of an
Ordinance amending Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of
Ordinances to permit a free-standing directory sign in a
nonresidential zoning district.
Recommend a roval of Ordinance
Billboard Ordinance to permit a
nonresidential zoning district.
No. 88-88 amendinthe Si~n and
free-standing directory sign in a
Item No. 19 (Ordinance 89-88) This is a First Reading of an Ordinance
amending Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards. of the Code of Ordinances
providing for limitations on the size and number of free-standing
identification signs in shopping centers.
Recommend a roval of Ordinance No. 89-88 amendino the Si nand
Billboard Ordinance providing for limitations for the size and number
of free standing identification signs in shopping centers.
Item No. 20 (Ordinance No. 90-88) This is a First Reading of an
Ordinance amending Chapter 162 "Signs and Billboards" of the Code of
Ordinances to permit a sign denoting the hours of business operation.
Recommend a roval of
Billboard Ordinance to
operation on structures.
Ordinance No.
permit signs
90-88 amendin_ the Si~n and
denoting the hours of business
Item No. 21 (Ordinance No. 91-88) Amendment of the zoning code to
revise definition of family. This ordinance was prepared following
workshop meetings on December 9, 1986, June 16, 1987, September 15,
1987, October 20, 1987, and on Tuesday July 19, 1988. The Ordinance
is similar to those which are in effect in West Palm Beach, Lake Worth
- 5 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
and Miami Beach and will assist our Code Enforcement effort by
limiting the number of unrelated adults living in a household.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 91-88 relative to definition of
family.
PUBLIC HEARING- ENCLAVE ORDINANCES*
*These Ordinances have been distributed to you previously and are not
enclosed in your 7/26 agenda packet because they were in your 6/28
agenda packet. A copy of each Ordinance i~ located in the Commission
office should you be unable to find a specific Ordinance.
Item No. 22 (Ordinance No. 62-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance annexing Enclave No. 31B. This Enclave includes
properties between S.W. 10th Street and the Southridge Subdivision.
It also includes the undeveloped eastern portion of Southridge.
Proposed zoning is R-lA and for one parcel only, RH. The level of
servJ.ce is "D" meaning water and sewer is not generally available and
there are significant costs and factors to provide service to the
enclave. On the other hand the benefit to the City comes from the
increased level of code enforcement and Police presence which is
necessary in this particular enclave. The difficulty in coordinating
law enforcement and property maintenance codes weigh in favor of
annexation of this enclave.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 62-88 for the annexation of
Enclave No. 31B with proposed zoning of R-1A and RH.
Item No. 23 (Ordinance No. 63-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 32 which consists
of a single 9.3 acre parcel on which the Pine Grove Elementary School
is located. The initial proposed zoning is to CF. The level of
service is classified as "B" meaning that service meets general
standards and is equal to that provided similarly situated areas in
other parts of the City.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 63-88 annexing Enclave No. 32
with proposed zoning of CF.
Item No. 24 (Ordinance No. 64-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave 38 which consists of
a single 4.09 acre parcel owned by the Florida Inland Navigation
District (FIND). The undeveloped vacant parcel is located along the
Intracoastal Waterway east of a point where Federal Highway north and
southbound come together, south of 10th Street S.E. Proposed zoning
for the vacant parcel is CF. The level of service is "A" meaning that
all services are immediately available.
Recommend a roval of Ordinance No. 65-88 annexin Enclave No. 38 with
proposed zoning of CF.
Item No. 25 (Ordinance No. 65-88) This is a Second Reading of an
Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 39 which consists of a
single family residence on one parcel totalling .27 acres located on
Brooks Lane west of Ocean Boulevard (Highway A-1-A) with proposed
zoning of R-1AA. Level of service is "B" meaning that service meets
general standards and is equal to that provided similarly situated
areas in other parts of the City.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 65-88 annexing Enclave 39 with
a proposed zoning of R-1AA.
Item No. 26 (Ordinance No. 66-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 42 which consists
- 6 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
of three parcels of property with a total acreage of 3.09 acr~s. The
site is presently occupied by the Colony Cabana Club located at Linton
and Ocean Boulevard (Highway A-1-A). Proposed zoning is RH. A public
hearing will be held by the Planning and Zoning Board on Monday June
23rd and it is possible that density recommendations may be altered
fOllowing the Planning and Zoning Board hearing. The level of service
is "B" meaning that service meets general standards and is equal to
that provided similarly situate areas in other parts of the City.
Recommend approval
proposed zoning of
Board.
of
RH
Ordinance No. 66-88 annexing Enclave 42 with a
pending findings by the Planning and Zoning
Item No. 27 (Ordinance No. 67-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 46 which consists
of 40 existing multiple family residences on two parcels of property
totalling 2.7 acres. The properties are located along the east side of
Ocean Boulevard (Highway A-I-A) just south of Linton Boulevard.
Proposed zoning is RH pending the findings of the Planning and Zoning
Board at their meeting on June 23rd at which time a public hearing
will be held. The level of service is "B" meaning that service meets
general standards and is equal to that provided similarly situated
areas in other parts of the City.
Recommend approval
a proposed zoning
Zoning Board.
Item No. 28 (Ordinance No. 68-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 47 which consists
of a six foot wide strip of land approximately 1/4 mile south of
Linton Boulevard between Ocean Boulevard (Highway A-1-A) and the
Beach. The parcel totals .06 acres and a proposed zoning of RH is
recommended pending comments at a public hearing scheduled before the
Planning and Zoning Board on June 23rd. The level of service is "A"
meaning that all existing services are immediately available.
of Ordinance No. 67-88 annexing Enclave No. 46 with
of RH pending the findings by the Planning and
Recommend approval
a proposed zoning
Board.
of Ordinance No. 68-88 annexing Enclave No. 47 with
of RH pending findings by the Planning and Zoning
Item No. 29 (Ordinance No. 69-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 48 which consists
of three single family residences on three parcels totalling 1.07
acres located approximately 1/4 mile south of Linton Boulevard along
the west side of Ocean Boulevard (A-1-A). Proposed zoning is RH
pending a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Board following
their public hearing scheduled for June 23rd. The level of service is
"c" as a result of the sewer service not being readily available.
Sewer service will be provided at owner expense.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 69-88 annexing Enclave 48 with
proposed zoning of RH pending the findings by the .Planning and Zoning
Board.
Item No. 30 (Ordinance No. 70-88) WITHDRAWN.
Item No. 31 (Ordinance No. 71-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the Annexation of Enclave No. 44 which consists
of two parcels of developed land on the southeast corner of the Sun
Bank property to the north of Burger King on South Federal Highway
just south of Linton. Proposed zoning is SC. The lots total .29
acres. The level of service is "A" meaning that all existing services
are immediately available.
- 7 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 71-88 annexing Enclave No. 44 with
a proposed zoning of SC.
Item No. 32 (Ordinance No. 72-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the Annexation of Enclave No. 45 which consists
of a 1.01 acre parcel located on the east side of south Federal
Highway and is presently the site of a portion of the Delray Beach
Toyota Automobile dealership. The level of service is "A" meaning
that all existing services are immediately available. Proposed zoning
is GC.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 72-88 annexing Enclave No. 45 with
a proposed zoning.of GC.
Item No. 33 (Ordinance No. 73-88) This is a Second Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the Annexation of Enclave No. 58 which consists
of a 29.19 acre area containing 21 existing and five vacant single
family lots in Lone Pine Estates. Proposed zoning is ART
(Agricultural Residential Transitional). The level of service is ."D"
primarily as a result of the absence of water and sewer service and
the additional Fire and EMS services required. When water and sewer
becomes available, property owners will be assessed the appropriate
connection fee. It is anticipated that revenues derived from property
taxes will largely offset additional expenses required otherwise.
Recommend approval of Ordinance 73-88 annexin~ Enclave No. 58 with a
proposed zoning of ART.
ENCLAVE ORDINANCES - FIRST READING -(NO PUBLIC HEARING)
Item No. 34 (Ordinance No. 92-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance annexing Enclave No. 49 which consists of two
parcels totalling 1.2 acres under one ownership. The eastern side is
occupied by a 17 unit hotel, the western portion is vacant. Proposed
zoning is RH. The level of service is "B" meaning that service meets
general standards and is equal to that provided similarly situated
areas in other parts of the City.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 92-88 annexing Enclave No. 49 with
proposed zoning of RH.
Item No. 35 (Ordinance No. 93-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 51 which consists
of a single family home on a .19 acre parcel of property lying east of
Florida Boulevard and bordered on three sides by Tropic Bay
Condominiums. Proposed zoning is RH. The level of service is "A"
meaning that all existing services are immediately available.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 93-88 annexing Enclave No. 51 with
proposed zoning of RH.
Item No. 36 (Ordinance No. 94-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 52 located west
of Federal Highway, north of Lindell, which consists of four parcels
totalling 4.25 acres containing approximately 67 mobile home sit~s and
three single family homes. Proposed zoning is GC with the mobile home
park remaining as a non-conforming use. The level of service is "c" as
sewer service is not readily available. Sewer service will be
provided at owner expense.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 94-88 annexing Enclave 52 with
proposed zoning of GC.
Item No. 37 (Ordinance No. 95-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 54 which consists
- 8 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
of two single family residences and two vacant lots on a .98 acre
parcel of property. This Enclave is located south of the South Delray
Shopping Center and Avenue L. Proposed zoning is RM. The level of
service is "A" meaning that all existing services are immediately
available.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 95-88 annexing Enclave No. 54 with
proposed zoning of RM.
Item No. 38 (Ordinance No. 96-88 This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 56 which consists
of two five acre agricultural parcels, with a single family home on
each parcel totalling 10 acres. This Enclave is located on the L-31
Canal off Barwick Road. Proposed zoning is ART. The level of service
is "c" as a result of the sewer service not being readily available.
Sewer service will be provided at owner expense.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 96-88 annexing Enclave No. 56 with
proposed zoning of ART.
Item No. 39 (Ordinance No. 97-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 57 which consists
of 42 existing single family homes and 9 vacant single family parcels
on a 13.34 acre parcel. Proposed zoning for the property which is
located in the Windward Palms subdivision is R-1A-B. The level of
service is "D" primarily as a result of the absence of water and sewer
services and the additional Fire and EMS services required. When
water and sewer becomes available, property owners will be assessed
the appropriate connection fee. It is anticipated that revenues
derived from property taxes will largely offset additional expenses
required otherwise.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 97-88 annexing Enclave No. 57 with
a proposed zoning of R-lA-B.
Item No. 40 (Ordinance No. 98-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 60 which consists
of a vacant 1.35 acre parcel of property located south of Lake Ida
Road between 1-95 and the FEC Railroad. The proposed zoning is LI.
The level of service is "C" as a result of the sewer service not
being readily available. Sewer service will be provided at owner
expense.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 98-88 annexing Enclave No. 60 with
proposed zoning of LI.
Item No. 41 (Ordinance No. 99-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 64 which consists
of a vacant .63 acre parcel of land located west of the FEe Railroad
right-of-way approximately 750 feet south of the L-32 Caniill. Proposed
zoning is MI. The level of service is nB- meaning that service meets
general standards and is equal to that provided similarly situated
areas in other parts of the City.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 99-88 annexing Enclave No. 64 with
proposed zoning of MI.
Item No. 42 (Ordinance No. 100-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave No. 67 which consists
of a 6.15 acre strip of canal which lies east of Dover Road. Proposed
zoning is RM-6 and RM-10. The level of service is "A" meaning that
all services are immediately available.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 100-88 annexing Enclave No. 67
with proposed zoning of RM-6 and RM-10.
- 9 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Item No. 43 (Ordinance No. 101-88) This is a First Reading of an
enacting Ordinance for the annexation of Enclave 70 which consists of
a vacant 10.86 acre parcel of property and adjacent canals totalling
9.08 acres east of 1-95, west of the Tropic Palms subdivision.
Proposed zoning is ART. The level of service is "c" as a result of
the sewer service not being readily available. Sewer service will be
provided at owner expense.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 101-88 annexing Enclave No. 70
with proposed zoning of ART.
FIRST READINGS- NON ENCLAVE ORDINANCE
Item No. 44 (Ordinance No. 81-87) Definition of Family. This
Ordinance had been considered by the City Commission, was adopted on
First Reading and, following a public hearing at Second Reading was
tabled indefinitely. In order to take final action n this Ordinance
it should be taken off the table and the earlier action rescinded.
Following that, the Ordinance may be denied. This item will have two
actions which may be considered 44A and 44B.
Recommend (A) Ordinance 81-87 be
earlier action of the Commission
Reading be rescinded; and (E) that
taken off the
approving the
Ordinance 81-87
table and
Ordinance
be denied.
that the
on 1 s t
SECOND READINGS- NON ENCLAVE ORDINANCES
Item No. 45 (Ordinance No. 61-88) This is a Second Reading of an
Ordinance for the annexation of property on North Federal Highway.
Borton Volvo, Inc. represented by Roger Saberson, has requested
voluntary annexation of a 4.9 acre parcel of property located on North
Federal Highway adjacent to N.E. 22nd Street extended. The 4.09 acre
parcel requested for voluntary annexation is contiguous to the City
via property on the west side of u.S. 1 at the southwest portion of
the site.
The Planning and Zoning Board at its May 16th meeting recommended
approval of annexation with initial zoning of SC (Specialized
Commercial) finding that a new enclave will not be created by this
annexation, that approval is consistent with adjacent zoning, does not
conflict with existing County zoning on usage and does not conflict
with the City's Land Use designation (C) for this property.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 61-88 annexinq property owned by
Borton Volvo located on North Federal Highway, with a proposed zoning
of SC.
Item No. 46 (Ordinance No. 74-88)
Ordinance rezoning property located
Road north of Wallace Nissan from
parcel is presently vacant and
automobile dealership.
This is a Second Reading of an
on the east side of Germantown
PCC and R-IA to SC. The 11.28 acre
is intended for expansion of an
The Planning and Zoning Board at its June 20th meeting recommended
approval of the rezoning request and conditional use finding that the
proposed zoning of SC is consistent with adjacent zoning and does not
conflict with the City's Land Use Plan designation for this property.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 74-88 rezoning property located on
the east side of Germantown Road north of Wallace Nissan from PCC and
R-1A to SC.
Item No. 47 (Ordinance No. 79-88) This is a Second Reading of a
Companion Ordinance to the above item for rezoning from SAD to POC
(Planned Office Center) for property located along Military Trail
south of the L-32 Canal. Pylon Medical Associates, Ltd. represented
- 10 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
by David L. Keesler has requested rezoning from SAD to
Office Center). The 1.967 acre parcel presently
professional office building on the site. "
The changes are being requested to accommodate a broader range of uses
than are allowed under the existing SAD to avoid the need to
continually process each new request to the Planning and Zoning Board
and City Commission. POC zoning will allow business, professional,
medical, and dental offices in addition to those presently provided
for in the SAD. The developer believes he can move more easily to
lease available space with the greater flexibility.
POC (Planned
contains a
The Planning and Zoning
June 20th meeting and
stipulations:
Board reviewed the rezoning request at their"
recommended approval subject to the following
1. Installation of a 6' Cyclone fence along the north property
line and a 4 1/2 foot hedge.
2. Planting "trees along the south
spacing of 24 feet and installation of
maintained at six foot height.
property line to provide
a 4 1/2 foot hedge, to be
3. Replacement of dead Queen Palm in the entry median and one
along north border of the property.
4. Replacement of ground cover in the entry median.
5. Replacement
either side of
building.
of
the
ground cover at entry to the building and on
stairway to the north and south side of the
6. Trim dead palm fronds, fertilize plant materials, remulch
planting beds to a minimum 2 inch depth, and trim Orchid Trees.
7. Provide trees a maximum of 25 feet on center along the east
property line.
8. Repaint south wall in the color originally approved by CAB.
Stipulation number 1
developer will place a
of the cyclone fence.
was modified at your July 12th meeting. The
six foot hedge along the property line in place
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 79-88 rezoning
Professional Building on Military Trail south of the L-32
SAD to POC sUbject to the stipulations cited above.
Item No. 48 Conditional Use Request (CU 6-241). This is a request for
a Conditional Use and Attendant Site plan for the proposed Gulfstream
Motor Lodge located at S.E. 10th Street and Federal Highway. Site
plan approval is required prior to applying the zoning designation of
SAD to a parcel. Pending approval of this Conditional Use request,
Ordinance 77-88 which follows will apply SAD zoning to the Gulfstream
Motor Lodge project located at S.E. 10th Street and Federal Highway.
the Pylon
Canal from
Recommend approval of Conditional Use Request (CU 6-241) and attendant
site plan for the proposed Gulfstream Motor Lodge located at S.E. lOth
Street and Federal Highway.
Item No. 49 (Ordinance No. 77-88) This is a Second Reading of an
Ordinance rezoning the above mentioned property at Federal Highway and
S.E. 10th Street from RM-10 to SAD. Freedom Savings and Loan
Association, represented by Currie, Schneider and Associates, has
- 11 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
requested rezoning from RM-10 to SAD in order to construct a new 98
room hotel/motel to be called the Gulfstream Motor Lodge.
The Planning and Zoning Board at its June 20th meeting recommended
approval of the request for the proposed Land Use and zoning change to
C finding them consistent with existing Land Use patterns and
surrounding zoning designations. Following discussion at your June
28th meeting it was determined that application of SAD zoning would be
preferable to Commercial zoning. Utilization of SAD zoning will
assure the intended use of this parcel as a Motor Lodge will occur as
planned.
Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 77-88 rezoning property located at
Federal Highway and S.E. 10th Street from RM-lO to SAD.
REGULAR AGENDA
Item No. 50 Dolphin Pile Variance. Mr. and Mrs. Bacarella have
requested a variance in order to construct a dolphin pile closer than
the 25 foot minimum distance from adjacent property as required by the
City Code. The request is rather complex and has involved litigation
between one property owner and an adjacent neighbor. Engineering
staff, following discussion with the City Attorney have recommend
approval of the variance because they believe it impossible to
construct a dolphin pile at this location and meet City Code
requirements. The variance will not present a danger to public
safety however, adjacent property owners have objected to the variance
request. Copies of their letters are attached.
Recommend approval
construction of a
Isle subdivision.
of a variance to setback requirements for
dOlphin pile at the rear of lot 169 in the Tropic
Item No. 51 Dolphin Pile Variance. Nancy Siegel-Olmstead, 947
Jasmine Drive in Tropic Isle has requested a variance in order to
construct a dolphin pile closer than the 25 foot minimum distance from
adjacent property as required by City Code. Engineering staff with
the concurrence of the City Attorney have recommended denial of the
variance because they believe it is possible to comply with the Code
given the 90 foot width of Ms. Siegel-Olmstead's lot. City Code
requires a 25 foot setback for dolphin piles in order to assure that
neighboring property owners are afforded equal navigability for their
own boats.
Adjacent property owners were notified of the variance request and a
written objection was received from the owner of Lot 426.
Recommend denial of request for a Dolphin Pile Variance on Lot 427 in
the Tropic Isle subdivision.
Item No. 52 Interlocal Agreement between the City and Palm Beach
County to Allow Construction of 33 Single Family Homes. The Palm
Beach County Housing Partnership proposes to construction 33 single
family homes on a 8.9 acre parcel consisting of one square block
adjacent to S.W. 2nd Street and S.W. 8th Avenue. The agreement calls
for Palm Beach County to provide $150,000 to the Housing Partnership
and for the City to waive certain development fees and construct
infrastructure on the sight. Community Development Block Grant
funding of approximately $130.00 is designated from this year's and
next year's CDBG Program. Palm Beach County has also been requested
by the developer to waive road and other impact fees. This will be
handled as a separate item by the County Commission. The Palm Beach
County Commission approved the transfer of the 8.9 acre parcel to the
Housing Partnership contingent upon execution and approval of this
Interlocal Agreement.
- 12 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Recommend
Palm Beach
to develop
approval
County to
33 single
of an Interlocal Agreement between the City and
allow the Palm Beach County Housing Partnership
family homes.
Item No. 53 Request for Tent Permit. The Daughter of zion Seventh
Day Adventist Church is requesting a permit to erect a temporary tent
on church owned property at 201 N. W. 3rd Avenue which is directly
across from their church building. The temporary tent will be used
for a church revival meeting between July 31 through September 3,
1988. All of the appropriate conditions and requirements of the City
Code have been met.
Recommend approval of a tent permit for the Daughter of Zion Seven Day
Adventist Church as requested.
Item No. 54 Tent Permit. The Bethanie Zion 7th Day Adventist French
Church is requesting a permit to erect a temporary tent on property
located on the corner of S. W. 6th Avenue and S. W. 10th Street.
The property owners have given permission to the Church to erect the
temporary tent on the site. The temporary tent will be used for a
church revival meeting between July 31 through August 27, 1988. All
of the appropriate conditions and requirements of the City Code have
been met.
Recommend approval of a tent permit for the Bethanie Zion 7th Day
Adventist French Church as requested.
CONSENT AGENDA
Item No. 55 Children Services Council Grant. This item is an
agreement between the City and the Children Services Council of Palm
Beach County to provide reimbursement funding in the amount of
$112,362 for the City's after-school program. The after-school
program serves children ages six to 15 and provides a structured
supervised recreation activity with adult supervision for a large
number of "latch-key" kids. The after-school program is conducted at
the Community Center, Carver School and Pompey Park. The after-schOOl
program is concluding it's first year of operation in Delray Beach.
The Children Services Council funds other after-school programs
however ours is unique in that we work closely with the School
District and identify latch key children.
Recommend approval of
Services Council of
after-school program.
Item No. 56 Approval of Funding for Law Enforcement Accreditation.
The Police Department has been working toward accreditation under a
program sponsored by the International Association of Chief's of
Police beginning in 1985. The accreditation process involves a
comprehensive review and analysis of Police Department procedures and
operations for compliance with professional recognized standards. The
Department is now completing the second of three phases toward
becoming accredited by the Commission on Accreditation for Law
Enforcement Agencies. This request is for a transfer of $18,000 from
Law Eniorcement Trust Fund to cover cost of office supplies, printing
and part-time secretarial assistance to complete this second phase.
An additional $10,000 will be required in 1989 to complete the
accreditation process.
an agreement between the City and
Palm Beach County to conduct
the Children
the City's
Recommend approval of an appropriation of $18,000 from the Law
Enforcement Trust Fund to cover cost associated with the Police
Department's accreditation program.
Item No. 57 Conditional Use Request (CO 6-222) and Site Plan Approval.
Wallace Ford represented by Digby Bridges, Marsh and Associates has
- 13 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
requested a conditional use for an automobile dealership and site plan
approval in order to expand an existing automobile dealership on a
vacant 11.2 acre parcel of property located at Germantown Road and
Queens Avenue. This development proposal includes approximately ten
acres of land annexed in 1987 as part of the Weir annexation and
approximately 1.3 acres annexed pursuant to the Enclave Act. The
property has been rezoned to SC.
The Planning and Zoning Board at it's July 18th meeting recommended
approval subject to the following stipulations:
1. A variance be obtained to reduce the
loading areas or the site plan be modified
additional areas.
required number of
to accommodate these
2. If phase one construction precedes abandonment of Queens
Avenue or if a petition for abandonment of Queens Avenue is not
granted that the "Parts Receiving" loading dock and its access be
redesigned so that Queens Avenue is not used for maneuvering
purposes and that other dimensional requirements for loading
areas be complied with.
3. That an off-loading and storage area be provided concurrent
with phase one development.
4. Perimeter landscaping along the north
for that length of the boundary which
phase one development.
boundary be provided
is contiguous with any
5. That any part of phase two development which is cleared in
conjunction with the initial development be sodded and irrigated.
6. Platting should be completed prior to applying for a Building
Permit and the preliminary plat shall address in addition to
normal platting matters:
a. Dedication of ten feet along the Germantown frontage for
right-of-way purposes.
b. Installation of a sidewalk five feet in width along the
entire length of Germantown Road frontage.
c. Dedication of 25' along the eastern boundary for S.W.
10th Avenue right-of-way purposes.
d. Replace the phrase "an improvement" with "a landscaping".
e. Continue a public sewer main from Manhole No.
north property line with an appropriate easement
main at a depth sufficient to accommodate sewage
the north.
3 to the
and place a
flows from
f. Preliminary construction plans for Germantown Road
improvements shall be of at least one additional travel lane
with a total travel-way being 36' and that a pavement marking
plan shall be developed in concert with Palm Beach County
Engineering prior to their submittal to the City.
7. The following modifications are made to the site plan:
a. Eliminate parking spaces which are aligned with points of
entry from Germantown Road.
b. Reduction of the northerly driveway to 24' in width.
c. Addition of a fire hydrant at the south of the building.
- 14 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
d. On site signing and pavement marking for traffic flow
including on site truck routing.
8. The site and development approval shall be valid for a period
of three years at which time compliance with the requirements for
vesting the project must be met.
Recommend approval of Conditional Use Reguest (CU 6-222) and Site Plan
approval for the Wallace Automobile Dealership located at Germantown
and Queens Avenue subject to the stipulations cited above.
Item No. 58 Conditional Use Request (CU 6-575) and Site Plan Approval
for Exxon Gasoline Station at Atlantic and Congress Avenue. Exxon
Company represented by Corporate Property Services has requested a
conditional use and site plan approval for redevelopment of the Exxon
Station at Congress Avenue and Atlantic. The company plans to
re-build gasoline stations having seven islands under one canopy and
an expanded kiosk service center. A separate building will provide
three bays for automotive servicing. This' proposal involves
demolition of all .existing facilit.ies.
Dedication for Congress and Atlantic Avenue rights-of-way and the
special landscaping regulations which pertain are being accommodated
in this plan. No code violations or waivers are involved. A special
traffic study was required and provided to justify the location and
size of curb cuts and traffic flow on the site.
The Planning and Zoning Board at it's July 18th meeting recommended
approval of the request.
Recommend
a roval
northeast
approval of Conditional Use Request (CU 6-575) and Site
for modification of the Exxon Gasoline Station at
corner of Atlant~c Avenue and Congress Avenue.
Plan
the
Item No. 59 (Resolution No. 40-88) A Resolution assessing costs for
abating nuisances on 31 parcels of property at various locations
throughout the City. Debris, weeds, trash, etc. were removed from
these parcels. The Resolution sets forth the actual costs incurred
and provides the mechanism to attach liens to property in the event
these assessments remain unpaid.
Recommend a roval of Resolution No. 40-88 assessin costs for abatin
nuisances.
Item No. 60 (Resolution No. 41-88) A Resolution assessing costs for
abating nuisances on 4 parcels of property at various locations
throughout the Ci ty. Debris, ,:eeds, trash, etc. were removed from
these parcels. The Resolution sets forth the actual costs incurred
and provides the mechanism to attach liens to property in the event
these assessments remain unpaid.
Recommend a roval of Resolution No. 41-88 assessin costs for abatin
nuisances.
Item No. 61 (Resolution No. 42-88) This item is a Resolution
assessing costs for abatement action required to remove an unsafe
building on property at 911 North Federal. The Resolution sets forth
the actual costs incurred and provides the mechanism to attach a lien
on this property in the event the assessment of $1,298.00 remains
unpaid.
Recommend a roval of Resolution No. 42-88 assessin costs for abatin
an unsafe building within the City.
- 15 -
AGENDA REPORT
Meeting of July 26, 1988
Item No. 62 (Resolution No. 43-88) A Resolution assessing costs for
abatement action required to remove an unsafe building on property at
102 N. W. 10th Avenue. The Resolution sets forth the actual costs
incurred and provides the mechanism to attach a lien on this property
in the event the assessment of $2,578.40 remains unpaid.
Recommend approval of Resolution No. 43-88 assessing costs for abating
an unsafe building within the City.
Item No. 63
AWARDS OF BIDS AND CONTRACTS:
A. Scott Airpacs - Safety Equipment Company - $21,743.30.
B. Handtools and Hardware Supplies - Duncan-Edwards - $21,000.
C. Cellular Telephones
$10,680.
Cartel Business Communications
D. Watermain Construction in Delray Beach Municipal Golf Course
- Onontario of Palm Beach - $251,817.45.
E. Street Resurfacing - Hardrives of Delray - $300,510.
F. N.E. 1st Street Storm Drainage project- Hardrives of Delray-
$749,763.
G. Construction of Air Stripping Units to Treat the 20 Series
Wellfield - Elkin Construction- $1,485,478.90.
H. Water and Sewer Revenue Bond Issue _
Paying Agent and Registrar - Citizens and Southern _
$12,075.
Escrow Agent - Midlantic National Bank - $11,200.
- 16 -
July 25, 1988
Jeffrey Kurtz, Esq.
Assistant City Attorney
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
310 S.E. 1st street, suite 4
Delray Beach, FL 33483
Re: Auburn Trace Land Purchase Contract
Dear Jeff:
I have enclosed the signed agreement for the purchase of the Auburn
Trace development site as forwarded by your office several weeks
ago. It was my understanding, from your conversation with Ken
Simback, that a revised agreement would be forthcoming. Since I
have not heard from you, I am returning the original agreement,
signed at this time, as you have requested.
I have also enclosed a letter from Robert A. Sweetapple, Esq., our
attorney, that sets forth the conditions and circumstances under
which I have signed this contract. Should you have any questions
about either the contract or Mr. Sweetapple's letter, please feel
free to contact me.
Sincerely,
PROCACCI DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
~
Philip procacci
President
KS/jk
Enclosures
Fi.E(;El;~,'~~D 01\,':
.. ,,\C?
-- --,/,-:.L-__::..llS!._
c:;y i,\r.;,':;:;~C';:'::~ Ol'lrt::v
(...;';y .~, u<.P~/ :.~;jd,::'h'
PROCACCI OEVEL.OPMENT CORPORATION
401 West Linton Boulevard, Delray Beach, Florida 33444
(305) 265-0500 . (305) 427-3555 CBrowardJ . 1-800-233.2844
k.LJ1fca
~2Z Y~J 9.2Z
55~ ff~ ':6'~ ygu.:Meny
Y~--"", J%tff~ YIud
~, ff~ 1J/J0
Y~ 405/""-5621
Y~ 405/1-"-1021
Y.d:. ....15"-YYY
July 18, 1988
fl&Y~ ':6'...-..
ffo<{yA'.dff~~~
yg_~, ff~11"1f
Y~ 40t/19N210
~~h
ROBERT A. SWEETAPPLE
ALEXANDER D. VARKAS
GEOFFREY C BENNETT
BOCA RATON
HAND DELIVERED
City of Delray Beach
Assistant City Attorney
Jeffrey Kurtz, Esq.
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
Re: procacci Development
Dear Mr. Kurtz:
Enclosed is Purchase and Sale Agreement, which you prepared
on behalf of the City of Delray Beach, Florida. The
agreement has been executed by my client, procacci
Development Corporation.
The Purchase and Sale Agreement contains numerous represen-
tations inserted by the City which were not included in the
previous contract and are, in fact, contrary to specific
repeated representations of material fact made to date by
the City. Mr. procacci has signed the contract on behalf of
procacci Development Corporation under duress and under pro-
tes t.
procacci Development ~orporation has spent hundreds of
thousands of dollars ~n costs and professional time pro-
moting the Auburn Trace Development. The company intends to
hold the City strictly accountable for representations of
fact and inducements made to it as well as to the United
States Department of Housing and Urban Development.
'rhe self-serving statements, which have been inserted in the
recent contract, in no way exhonerate the City for its pre-
Jeffrey Kurtz, Esq.
Re: procacci Development
July 18, 1988
Page No.2
vious representations and inducements. If the City does not
comply with its earlier representations, the company intends
to pursue all legal remedies available and to bring the
City's conduct to the attention of the appropriate authori-
ties at the United States Department of Housing and Urban
Developmen t.
Very truly yours,
/;'7'> __ /; I ~
~ ,_ J. ,...,.." __
/' j;//' -I ',-- ,/(>- 'ii>
/ v' //""
ROBERT A. SWEETAPPLE
RAS:kcr
87/LTR.15
~d ~~ 9 d
PURCHASE AND SAl.E AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into this day of
I 1988 by and between PROCACCI DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION, a Florida corporation (hereinafter referred to as
"Procacci") and the CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, a Florida
municipal cor'poration, (hereinafter to as "City").
WIT N E SSE T H:
WHEREAS, City owns certain real property and is willing to
attempt the acquisition of additional property adjacent to
Carver Estates and the municipal cemetery, which property has
considerable potential for development as a mUlti-family
residential area; and
WHEREAS, City has been selected by the Department of
Housing and Urban Development to receive a Urban Development
Action Grant in the amount of Five Million Forty-Eight Thousand
Eight Hundred Sixty Dollars ($5,048,860.00) for the purpose of
developing a mUlti-family project on said property; and
WHEREAS, procacci has been selected by the City to pur-
chase and develop said property after City invited proposals,
int.erviewed and considered developers for the property;
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises
and covenants contained herein, the parties do hereby covenant
and agree as follows:
1. TRANSFER OF THE PROPERTY. City shall sell and
Procacci shall buy the following property (hereinafter referred
to as Property) and which Property is located in Palm Beach
County, Florida, being approximately 36 acres of land located
in the Southwest quarter of the intersection of 4th Street and
S.W. 8th Avenue, and more fUlly described in Exhibit "A"
attached hereto.
2. Purchase price for the property is Seven Hundred
Thirty Thousand Dollars ($730,000.00) payable as follows:
(a) Deposit of $1,000.00 to be
held in trust by the City, due
upon execution of the contract
$
1,000.00
(b) procacci to execute a promissory
note bearing no interest. with one
payment of $65,000.00 payable
one (1) month from the date of
closing, five (5) equal annual
installments of $25,000 each,
commencing one (1) year from the
date of closing and a payment of
of $530,000.00 payable on the 15th
anniversary date of the closing
720,000.00
(c) Certified or cashier's check in
local U.S. funds on closing delivery
of deed (or such greater or lessor
amount as may be necessa.ry to com-
p1et.e payment of purchase price
after credits, adjustments and pro-
rations).
TOTAL
9,000.00
$ 730,000.00
3. TIME FOR ACCEPTANCE: If this contract is not exe-
cuted by the City and procacci on or before July 1, 1988, the
aforesaid deposit shall be, at t.he option of procacci, re.turned
(
.
to Procacci and this agreement shall be null and void. The
da'te of the contract, for purposes of performance shall be
regarded as the date when the last one of the City and procacci
has signed this contract.
4. CLOSING DATE: This contract shall be closed and the
deed in possession shall be delivered on or before August 1,
1988; unless extended by other provisions of this contract.
5. PRORATIONS: Taxes, insurance, interest, rents and
other expenses and revenues of said property shall be prorated
as of the date of closing.
6. EVIDENCE OF TITLE: Prior to closing, City shall at
City's expense provide procacci with a title insurance commit-
ment in accordance with Standard A of the standards for real
estate transactions attached hereto.
7. RESTRICTIONS AND EASEMENTS: procacci shall take
title subject to: (a) zoning and/or restrictions and prohibi-
tions imposed by governmental authority, (b) restrictions and
matters appearing on the plat and/or common to the subdivision,
(c) Public utility easements of record; taxes for the year of
closing and subsequent years mortgages referred to in this
contract further provided that none of the foregoing interferes
with the use of the property for residential purposes.
8. STANDARDS: Standards for real estate transactions
attached heret.o with the exceptions of Standards D, F, Nand 0
are applicable to this transaction.
9. CONTINGENCIES.
A. This agreement is contingent upon acquisition by City
of portion of property presently owned by the Delray )3each
Housing Authority.
B. This agreement is contingent upon Procacci and City
entering into a separate land use restriction agreement,
restricting the use of the land to low/and moderate income
housing. Such agreement shall be for a term of not less than
fifteen (15) years, and in any event remain in effect until
such time as Procacci' s Obligations with respect to any loan
amounts referenced in this agreement to the City have been
completely satisfied. Such agreement shall be executed in
recordable form and run with the land regardless of the
owner/owners or form of ownership of the property.
C. This agreement is contingent upon City accepting and
r'eceiving funds pursuant to the Urban Development Action Grant
award in the amount of $5,048,860.00 from the Department of
Housing and Urban Development.
D. This contract is contingent upon Procacci, and the
City entering into a separate agreement to loan to Procacci
$6,057,860.00 consisting of UDAG monies in the amount of
$5,048,860.00 and City matching funds in the amount of
$1,009,000.00. Said loans shall be secured by mortgage on the
property and improvements to the property in an amount equal to
the loan and Procacci shall repay that portion of the loan
consti tuting UDAG funds in accordance with a note to be exe-
cuted having the terms specified in the UDAG Grant Agreement
Exhibi t E III ( a copy of such agreement, is attached hereto and
made a part hereof). The $1,009,000.00 representing City
matching funds shall be repaid in seven (7) equal annual
installments over seven (7) consecutive years beginning on the
2
,
anniversary date of Procacci' s first draw against the City's
loan. Procacci's draws on the City's loan shall be made
pursuant to UDAG grant agreement Exhibit E III requirements
with the City matching funds being disbursed at the same time
and in the same ratio as the UDAG funds.
10. CITY WARRANTIES. City hereby warrants to Procacci as
follows:
A. There are no condemnation or imminent domain
proceedings pending or to the best of City's knowledge, contem-
plated against the property any part thereof, and the City has
received no notice of the desire of any public authority or
their entity to take or use the property or any part thereof.
B. There are no pending suits or proceedings
against or affecting the City or any part of the property which
(i) do or could effect title to the property any part thereof;
or (ii) do or could make unlawful the consummation of the
transaction contemplated by this agreement or render the City
unable to consummate the same.
C. There are no binding contracts, oral or written,
wi th Palm Beach County, any municipality or any other regula-
tory body with respect to the property currently owned by the
ci ty except as have been disclosed by the City to Procacci in
writing.
D. There are no known agreements of any nature with
respect to the property, except as have been disclosed by the
City to Procacci in writing.
At the closing, City shall, in writing, reaffirm to
procacci that a truth and correctness, as of the closing date
of each of the warranties.
11. COVENANTS OF CITY.
Procacci as follows:
City hereby covenants with
A. Between the date of this agreement and the
closing, City will not, without Procacci's prior written
consent, create by consent any encumbrances on the property nor
will City accept any additional advances under any existing
mortgage on the property. For purposes of this provision, the
term "encumbrances" shall mean any liens, claims, options,
mortgages or other encumbrances, encroachments, rights-of-way,
leases, easements, covenants, conditions or restrictions.
B. Between the date of this agreement and the date
of closing, City will cooperate fUlly with Procacci by exe-
cuting consents, applications and other such documents reason-
ably requested by Procacci in connection wi th its efforts in
developing the property to a condition such that building may
COllUTlence.
C. The City. of Delray Beach hereby agrees to accept
by dedication for use as a city park approximately four (4)
acres of the property to satisfy the City's park and recreation
land dedication requirements and in lieu of city park and
recreation fees.
D. The City shall waive all developmental applica-
tion fees and building permit fees.
E. The City will contribute up to $200,000.00 to
Procacci to help offset the cost of infrastructure development
of the property as required by City in the site plan approval
3
,
process. Such i.nfrastructure costs shall i.nclude but not be
limi ted to construction, widening, improvement of onsi te and
offsite roads and onsite and off site drainage required to
develop the property. 'rhe monies up to $200,000.00 shall be
payable to procacci by City at the time the development re-
ceives a Certificate of Occupancy, such funds received by
Procacci will not have to be repaid to the City.
F. The City shall convey 'the property by warranty
deed subject to a reverter or provision regarding use of the
property for low to moderate income housing units, which
reverter language is acceptable to the first mortgage lender,
and which reverter shall expire upon repayment of the UDAG
grant and all other monies payable to the City purusant to this
agreement, but no less than fifteen (15) years from the date of
closing.
12. PROCACCI'S WARRANTIES.
A. Procacci agrees to comply with and accept the
imposition of terms required of developer and participating
parties within the UDAG grant agreement which has been attached
hereto and made a part hereof.
B. Procacci shall complete the residential develop-
ment described in the tJDAG application by March 1, 1990 unless
extended herein by j oint agreement of the City, Procacci and
the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
C. Procacci hereby agrees to give first priority to
tenant applicants who are already residents of the City of
Delray Beach who need to be relocated due to some redevelopment
action taken on the part of the City of Delray Beach, or any of
its associated agencies, boards, or committees, and second
priority to all other tenant applicants who are already resi-
dents of the City of Delray Beach and to work with the city's
designee and the Delray Beach Housing Authority in the selec-
tion of residents.
respect
procacci
D.
to
to
There are no known agreements
the property, except as have
City in writing.
of any nature with
been disclosed by
reaffirm to
closing date
At the
Ci ty that
of each of
closing, Procacci shall,
a truth and correctness,
the warranties.
in writing,
as of the
E. procacci understands that through the execution
of this agreement, City has not made any guarantees as to the
number of residential units which may be developed on the
property.
13. SURVIVAL OF WARRANTIES AND COVENANTS. Warranties,
representations and indemnifications set forth in this contract
and an attachments shall survive closing.
14. ASSIGNABILITY. Procacci may assign this contract
only to a limited partnership wherein Procacci Development
Corporation is a general partner.
15. Typewritten or handwritten provisions inserted herein
or attached hereto as addenda shall control all printed provi-
sions the contract in conflict therewith.
16. The City may rescind this contract should Procacci
not submit site plan for development of the property by
September 1, 1988. Either party shall have the opportunity to
4
f/
rescind this contract within thirty (30) days of the final
hearing in regards to the above submitted site plan, should it
become impossible for Procacci to comply with the development
of the number of units granted by the City through its site and
development process or anticipated by the UDAG application.
Rescission shall be the parties sole remedy and damages shall
be limited to the amount of funds expended towards the purchase
of the land.
17. The subject property is being sold in its "as is"
condition, and Procacci acknowledges the status of the soil
condi tions per soil tests obtained by City and furnished to
Procaccio
18. REAL ESTATE COMMISSIONS. Ci ty hereby warrants to
Procacci that City has not engaged in a broker or agent with
respect to the purchase and sale of the property as contem-
plated by this agreement. City shall indemnify and hold
Procacci harmless against any and all liability, cost, damage
and expense (including but not limited to attorneys' fees and
costs of litigation and appeals). Procacci shall suffer or
incur because of any claim by any broker or agent claiming to
have dealt with City, whether or not meritorious for any
commission or other compensation with respect to this agreement
or to the purchase and sale of the property in accordance with
this agreement.
Procacci hereby warrants to City that Procacci has
not dealt with any broker or agent with respect to the purchase
and sale of the property as contemplated by this agreement.
Procacci shall indemnify and hold City harmless against any and
all liability, loss, cost, damage and expense (including, but
not limited to attorney's fees and cost of litigation and
appeal). City shall ever suffer or incur because of any claim
by any broker or agent claiming to have dealt with Procacci
whether or not meritorious, for any commission or other compen-
sation with respect to this agreement or to the purchase and
sale of the property in accordance with this agreement.
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
ATTEST:
By:
Mayor
City Clerk
Approved as to form:
Assistant City Attorney
WITNESSES
clz:~~%)~ By,
NT CORPORATION
President
(SEAL)
5
< ,"f..:,.',";V--
"'.., ..........._,....'-,~ l~:..
AMERICAN
CANCER
SOCIETY''' SOUTH PALM BEACH COUWY UNIT
UNIT OFFICERS
DIANA BUSH
President
ElPJNE KAPlAN
Vice President
DANIEL DUMMIT
Treasurer
SHARON NASH
Secretarv
JANE M CAlVERT
executive Director
Members of the Board
Arnold Berliner MD.
Andrews Bowes
Alan Bush
Doak Campbell
Suson Cole
Denise OaPra
Jeff Deutch
Marcia Gill
James Hankins
Barbara Holland RD.
Esther Intriligator
Mellntriligator
George LaBelle
Gillian McMullin
Peter McMullin
Paula Mendelsohn MPH. RD
Robert Moore
Marjorie O'Suilivan RN.
Valeska Picker
John Penniman
Lee Porterfield MD.
Rita Ryman
Steven Reznick M.D,
Russell Richardson
Elaine Roth
Carrie Rutherford em
ROderick Santa-Moria MD.
Daris Stenroos
Phillip Smith MD.
Marc Taub MD.
Christopher Virtue MD.
Not West
Christopher Wheeier
Betsy Whisman M.ED.
Dale Wickstrum MD
JerryWotf
Honorary Board Members
Esther Bortscheiler
Richard Buker MD,
Emily McChesney
June 28, 1988
Ms. Elizabeth Arnau
City Clerk
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
De1ray Beach, FL 33444
Dear ~ls. Arnau:
The south county chapter of the American Cancer
Society is promoting "Sun-Safety" during the month of
August. We would like to set up a booth at De1ray
Public beaches (Atlantic Dunes, Anchor Park, Downtown
Beach) and hand out free Sunscreen products. It is
not our intention to endorse anyone product but
rather to promote safe sunning practices. We are
currently planning for August 20th from 11 a.m. to 2
p.m.
We would like to have the consent of the city
and are anxious to work within any guidelines De1ray
warrants.
I first submitted this request to Joe We11don
and he referred me to you as the City Council must
approve such a request.
Please let me know if you need further
information or if I can assist in any way.
Kind regards,
/! /1 ',d
/" ,,' . 'j' IlL. IL(U"z-
/><.~ U';~ N
, I ,
I
Karen Mathews
Siemens Information Systems
5500 Broken Sound Blvd.
Boca Raton, FL 33487
cc: Betsy Whisman
6401 CONGRESS AVENUE, SUITE 200, BOCA RATO~J. FLORID~, 33487 .)i~.s!)Q4!
b
.
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
C~R O. BARRY, CI.TY MANAGER
IQ~.( J ~C)ucL-
A ID J. KOVACS, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT:
MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM
PUBLIC HEARING RE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION WITH CITY ZONING
OF A.R.T. AND P.R.D.-L. FOR THE PROPOSED SHERWOOD
FOREST DEVELOPMENT (ATLANTIC AVENUE AT BARWICK) FIRST
READING ORDINANCE 80-88
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval on first reading of the enacting ordinance for
this annexation and zoning on a total area of 72 +
acres.
Subsequent action will include second reading of the
ordinance and consideration of a site and development
plan. These items would both be scheduled
(tentatively) for consideration on August 23rd.
BACKGROUND:
This request involves two zoning classifications. One is PRD-L
and is to be affixed to the area presently encompassed by
Sherwood Golf Course and adjacent (encircling) land proposed for
residential development. The other is ART (Agricultural to
Residential Transition) which is for approximately ten acres
along the Atlantic Avenue frontage. The ART designation is being
applied as a "holding zoning" i.e. the existing use (driving
range) would continue but no other substantial development can
occur without first having a rezoning processed (and approved).
The basis for determination of appropriateness of any future
rezoning lies in the underlying land use designation as shown on
the Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan. Currently that
designation is single family residential. Preliminary discussion
pertaining to a designation which may evolve from the
Comprehensive Plan program indicates a medium density or
transitional (buffer) use may be applied.
'1
To: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearing Re Voluntary Annexation With City Zoning Of ART
And PRD-L For The Proposed Sherwood Forest Development
(Atlantic Avenue At Barwick) First Reading Ordinance 80-88
Page 2
Initially the applicant desired to except the ten acres from the
annexation petition. However, the ten acres is a part of the
entire seventy-two plus acres and the Planning and Zoning Board
felt it appropriate to annex all the property, not just the part
proposed for immediate development; thus, its inclusion and the
"holding zone" approach.
Planning and Zoning Board Recommendation: At its meeting of June
20th, the Board held a public hearing and then recommended
approval of the proposed annexation and zoning. It was noted
that, at present, water and sewer services do not extend to the
si te. The developer will be responsible for the extension of
existing mains to the site or if extended (prior to development)
by others, a "benefitted user" charge will be imposed. Further,
the capacity of Atlantic Avenue is approacm~)LoS "D"; thus, the
resulting development may be required to provide special
improvements with respect to access and traffic matters. (This
latter item is addressed in the site and development plan
consideration which is in process).
Community Opposition: An abutting development, The Hamlet, while
agreeable to the PRD-L zoning designation does not agree with the
"holding zone" approach associated with the ART designation. It
would rather have a permanent zone designation applied at this
time; thus, making a firm statement as to the character of
development which is to occur in the future.
Applicant's Position: The applicant has stated that there are no
plans, or thoughts, pertaining to the development of the frontage
at this time. Thus, providing a definitive zoning category
(and/or a conceptual site plan) would be misleading. Further, an
access matter (extension of Barwick Road south of Atlantic) will
create at least two parcels neither of which can be "planned" for
at the present time.
Planning Staff Comment: At the time the preliminary plat is
processed, the alignment of the Barwick Road extension will be
firmed up. Also at that time, restrictions can be placed upon
where access (to the resulting parcels along Atlantic) will be
allowed. Until such time as these parcels are configured, it
seems inappropriate to affix a "permanentn zoning designation.
Some of the concerns which will be aired by the neighbors, such
as distance of new construction from the existing property line,
are best addressed with the Forest Road abandonment action and
platting action. Thus, the Planning Staff supports the
application before the City Commission.
To: Walter o. Barry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearing Re VOluntary Annexation With City Zoning Of ART
And PRD-L For The Proposed Sherwood Forest Development
(Atlantic Avenue At Barwick) First Reading Ordinance 80-88
Page 3
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, approval of Ordinance 80-88 on First Reading, pursuant
to the findings and recommendations of the Planning and Zoning
Board.
Reference material:
Planning and Zoning Board staff report of June 20, 1988,
provided to the City Commission on June 28th.
Ordinance * 80-88 provided by the City Clerk.
REF/DJK*26/CCSHWD.TXT
3600 HAMLET DRIVE, DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33445
July 8, 19B8
The Honorable Doak S. Campbell
Mayor, City of De1ray Beach
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
De1ray Beach, FL 33444
RE: AGENDA FOR TUESDAY, JULY 26, 198B
Dear Mayor Campbell:
It is my understanding that you try to set up the agenda t,
large groups of residents who attend a particular meeting ]
of making their position clear on an issue to be voted upor
PHONE: (407) 498-7600
~ 1./\
lV
. ,
l ,=""O-.C J
'----c--""~, ". L
F ~ ..'-~
~J.:J...- .
1'>-.' . '~L' ~ 'r'~
,J '\' .,..'--
I. , _"L""""-
r--.---I'-''l
(~.
Ii
On July 26th a group of Hamlet residents will be present regarding the
Sherwood Park development.
If you can set the matter early on the agenda, we would be grateful.
ver;c:'
SHELDON N. REIBMAN
President
tss
cc: Walter O. Barry
City Manager
David Kovacs
Director, Building & Planning
I
I
i l (J, ~ ,'J~. ._, ,.,../,_. ,__ .,'_.~ /7 ' 1-'
c>--OJYi..LSf CJ \ C-'- c.~i_~,L,-_~l. G'~"-:1-:iOc.La.....Lon
2'3,~O H,L,;v:LET DRIVE
CELRi~\ Y BCf'\CH, FLORlO/\ 33445
(305) 495-1105
PETITION
][( 5, 1983
c c,'\ D(:_~!L(U/ B ,2,(1. C:1. eLi':; -'J{S,SJ:.O;LC-/1S
;t't C:-i.(-:-LOJ~: CLtU :.!aHags'L'_~ 05:);cc~
1 C i,,'r,': 7,.'l-I AUe;iu.c.
De- /:IL~I !3C~((Cj2, F 'l/lda. 33444
RE: ^lUle.xa.t~oJl cU1d Zonz_l1Cj
ShvuiJood Foltc 6 t Go C (" I II Co
1 ~",
~ - -'~
,\,lC'il,-'/'v6 :
(ll ~' 11;, [ , ,
'd ,{1iii..:I, '--iC-C.'iCStc!cut,s u:1 (fIe J{c"U::C((:, ({}[C ~FLc_atCu cOllcc/uled (wa
,~,~) - ~
,c,c-U'u un,'
~H
CL{JL".'l~ /lC:~C'I.c.IICC!_d l:i'::cttC/L.
\'1'0
, c.
/LecC'Dll-LZC
-,
:1l: (uld cfl!.6-C,'i.('.
(I :1
aJJ (,[t'JlC':
,to develop ,UU!)/L ph.Cpc/t-tlj.
l',!C
Lt
:~L') ~
-t .( t L.::!
~;.: 6t'i.Lc,tC',1 w,i.tf:.LII the. C.(Jlt,~,.Lnc.':\ o;~ -the.
'-'1.,-",
,Ll:.,'
rnCL:!_tc'L P,~C(IL.
,~;'!- Li:':'i~,i~!'V'(!. (L;7U CU;;I':~X:Ltioli in~I..,~t Lc ,{it t;,,'(at, ,l.l!. tflc c-nt,cfLe. p'wpc,,~,.'tu ,~o .tfwt
C'_.J";_
UL~::...'. c(',i(<~.,c
L ~,,~-~:'~ [1:-<~;ttL Dc.C,ta!I r3c((ch.
r"f' . ,'.
." ;','I...L:.'
:'<\C, ailU 06 ti'lC, P'i.,:,':A!''1..t!j
1';:0 u6ed c-iJ!u:_,'[ ~C'/i l)'u[t-i,sto/~_U !w((,j,iJ!J
:.,:)
!,()nC) (',7, c.oJI!~n(~/Lc.('{(L ,:,."t..'[,'C(U'LCS. .'luCL{jto"l.lj flt'.'u.j,{Pg [{.\}uCd
...1-/...-,
L_',.,
c!J C't;,}:'"
s :1'1'-;'
/'"," ,~'f' ," I.
~"-' c- J - -,~
;-:'.(I~t!-L-5f}, (UU-{ ~(I'TJhC,'7.rl:J/'7Z,
would
,:1' :JC. '(_I! "_
'j (I}Lt:L ,tfu2 i.l/Lc.a.
The. ['L\2 0,/; Fc)~c,s,t (LS a m({,u'r e;p~~,C;:2C. tt'C'Ldd v2-''tU }~,({2et.1J C/1-CILtC. CL majo:L t'7f/(;II;-tc.
}J',,-' ::.:.rn ('I; :\l'~{\;L(((i_ r-\\.!(,iHLC. T:-1I2 a(tL"z );((-t-i_\'C_ C () us,LJ7.9 B(uuo,Lc..h Road C1i?d a .-south
,-,
"..\ '--'
1 C,< ,6(;lne u).iJh ,-Cr;,:.! p!tc..~c..;:'t ceJl't'u).C C'{~Jr1.t ('iI At~CULtic Avenue [t'oUL.d,'rccfi_0y
"'~c b:'l;' L.
(':e, (i'{ ;1 U !d,':iuest ..tILe CCin;))('~,S{.(,i!C'lS C':-\OeL".(({{ Beach to zelle, tile.. ftc(C!lc.l1ccd
,;'; e(~
(( [i: (; ,~):.' ,6c
J(i:':.,i(;! ~((iir(_(u'!(!_\idcJ!i..:c's C'J?"f~f, \1_.Ii~ ll'ith adcqu((te. 'rcc:/('tltil.'lwt.
""::!((,j
-t::',',( :..C-6
:t6.
.
,,',//\:1,if
I\CDIZESS
CITY
!.....:---..--
/
/,
"-
-j
"
( ;:
1
, f
I
,
'I
,I'
!").
ell ~);, < L
, ~
, I
.I,/I~'-7~/
/
(
,:.-1t
/
--.
j if
,,:... 1 ~
")
,.~r,J jj l'
,I,
, ,
{
;,
,
I
/, /~ 1
/1. ./
\- J
l,
! /,
/0'1'
, L', -Ill
/
{ ,
--,I
/
I
, /
, /
'y/
~ "C_ <^
Il' , (,'
- "'.~
"
\.~_:
-; ).--':'
j.~ i- (
- (',: /"~,
(/
"
'. i.\
,
-{,/
, i
/.l-, \ (,-"-
/,
'-
)
/ rl
I L
, I, I
/
l, (
'/
/ \< (" ( (
/
/
"
/ ,r.. C
I
"-\
'<( '\_'\ ",
, /
"
-,:
",(j) t
r,
r., \
1(\
r'\ /,
(.
. .
'<)
.',
'-'--.//~/ 'f
"
'.'
L_<
,-,
, "
'-~ -',
1\
\
/ '--- __1" ,~- ~,~C:::\__..j~'
'f_
. "1
,--".-\,
I'
I
''- I
\', '
L'I\I,
;/.,\- ' >(.1 C
"
/_ I
/ {
/ {,
J
,
J
(J'
'--'i~
t....... \
,-,
~ U
'J t L~d (
I/"' ;-
l/ (Y
I
"I,
/:
I
/
.:: I:::. ~ L:,C/../'
'- !....~-
.)
"
I
/j
/~ '
, f
"
1/ {,
I ,
/.
! '
,
,
. ~\.:/.:
i,/
(:..
/((.1
'---.,..!
IL.
...e_
(, ~J~.,.
.1_, '
c
C
{'
r:.~/-~'L(_,
I
1:/::1-"1
,,--",'
\ ,f,
~"" '
/'...-,--
''; _--t,
I
/1/
,f--/
/-,
// .-r__ ,_
,,- ",./
<.;.--\
I
I
~.
?'- I'
-_'~".L- ' J
~ ~l " ,i'~(2 1'1 ..C~[
\,/
j'l (
!_J 2-\6-
/'
--'--_~_.~~J..~'----_~,
...., ~--
~ ) (
e- '7 '. " / -I,,' "
f !f),1 '~~:..~ l~ ". :.1-_.
" , ,
I'
"1
,
'.
~(
,
,_ 1-
::
I
/1
r;;; I
'.--1
/' '-, !_,
I
f',_'
I
i
I
1_'-
(
t."
.
(, (,
, ,
c_
,/',-
MAriE
') ,
, ~ ,
, \,
". "
.v -,~--,- - \
AVDRESS
CITY
/)) ./2 /6
/L/.6(-"R~7 -d".__
/
~ r>,~l2-lL,(-'~
/
;-!c (
'r
<:.-:~-, >'
',1 I '\ :; r'---' /' '!
, ..- I .-' ;,,: /2:7.. ;..A:....'" L{/L-C~L..
( /
,\ ,.,-,,,,,,\-/'
-::v .
,~ -, J ~/ {~ {, j~Q gl-^~
!i
'''/;) 0
./] --
0}1/.'/ J
v, ._.f'......- (
.-
, /.L.~ C:Y/i/>.'/)I)/} i:z!/L~/),I)i~lj'l/
~r111
_~" /1"'"
J,~./ I - I
""',
\\.<.
"',
1\......\_\~
F t'f/r~ ~J"
c'
, \
,;
(, "
, uJ~_'\(
~', ". ,\ 1"\
, ' ,M""
(, \-::r-
'I ~ '. '.'("~-\~\_
-,'../
,
/2~-:i<~'
/) /
/' /?f. /(
'- '. .,. v(~__
/:
, I -
,/" , '
7, ( . /
./ l \;/ ~r'~ ??4-r-:_~ ~
L-f' ~
/
L/
-,
-.,,)
'yo
,\ .-~;
/'
(,
,/
,
/' ;,.., q
/-,:--f.'( / I
/i '
~~ / -
~"~L."1C(1_..(-(..c.L~(~
/
:'--j"'/'< (
~ /:
(,-
,/
(~~ / J
// __J
/J
CC---2.
; U)"/' t 'Z /",:;;{
!) !
! ,
I ( "7 'i I
.: /'L l.' " ./1--.....1.....
/
,-/
':"/ c,
c. /"
ii..,
, ,
" \,":,l.-",
! /;
(.J f
v'll:
11/ .
.~
,-'
( /. I J,
r'~
! I
, "
/i- ;.
,
-( }j(p,";;'
,
....,; -
( /"
-\ v
"
-./) .'-. i.
~ C'-/.)..J#./._v.\.
(/}'-'<\.l
I
s
)/ / '.
'I'
,
" ;j
~" ,p, ,.I,
,/' -.::: '/7. ,._J
,/ .'-~./ j~':'111
);
n
/ :,
0'/ ,
, ,
1 '
, '
;"
--
,
c'
I /'-""
,/ _',I -- \.---'
,,' J/,
C/) lj:,,::~/-,,//:,.
:1;
j J ,/_~ /, '
.!._(
\ "", ," '-/,:
I'I)V
I,..,
,. ,,~ ",' ,\
"
,
')
, /
\ (.,:~
-'/----- " \
j
-,
-'(" ~c_:...--<~ -::-:>~----' ~_......;/......___""':.'./"-
,/ ,
'---.,': ;l\.-.....
-r\...
("I
-:---,--'{~c,_ f
""",
/
'1>0/'1
\
.J
.-: Ie
~
l..'
'/\.{
(
n_
,e //;/:'/1-'
,\ r. f) ,
0-"--, ,I, '-, ',: ).~"" I
,
~ .
lJ"- j
,II /
,_&( L. CL" ,
I
J)"lIL) / /~(i t/l
I
/) ~,1
jtG",j/, k,/;
I' "
;;
'~ ~
, (J; ~ ., /)/,~
I
1
!r
i)
''';''''',1
),
'./, .
/
'I, ..-
I'
_1 ~,\.__
"
.l_,-
"
~-C~_.. ~_(j'
/1, _:.1
'~:'I
c'}. , _
to' .~(<-",
')
L.<:..._-<.!
~ " . ((-.re_._-
/,,("_t.~~.._.... '
,(- .J'
" )l.._'
" ,."
(t/ L
-(I (,-
L-<_ / .'( 't:'
()
'.T/ ~ C:.!.. ",:'
~
i ",I I" ,f _-'/"'-(/'(' .j,'/.
~ I .' /. - - (.-_
./
.~,' .~
(
'/
/ij
(-J">(,! ..{ ..::....../...'r /i /~/)
C. '-:~/ .
.c'1. /-
I
.r/;.
".', ,
[' ~;,': ..
((' I
t /,
,
',/ ..
1
~./
C'
NAME
ADDRESS
CITY
.\
.~-\j~-.-
('
-, ' 'I I~
,- / ) ,'<-, ~~
cd, '"' c,.'>.s. _'~-C)-(]G-'v, J>_-~",
\ .
/1_ _. I )
<:( ':-"[-1 I (;.
.../ :> __, ;~..,J"",~V G......I..-.:.Q_-\.l\. ~
~...-~--"\-
t
,,",: .
',---""",
i /
\j ,.
i' q.!.,_
....--
( I
)., !
1:'-1
-1
i,(_,('-l
"
,
/
'~-,
I~ ~,j ~ ( ).....--_-
-)
/. --~ )
',). ~/-
If'
7L.
\./
,..,
f. /'/
,....~' 1"; .
.' /,/ .. _i,Y" .. /./.,
.',' ~ ~.~ .. .~
1-"-"--- _./ .v/j.. ..v/../ ...
'.: // f "J, t~ '/1' ,<.;1'h:'/ /;/ ../~"-.~/
"'-.~.., \.~../ .,f r /../" i-"'V__l.~
., (, i .'{ (, ;){ I
\. L.VC:
[.:.J. /, Jf.:... (,_, 'I (j n \.,.,
{/
:f'
\Lj~i\
'j
~; // C/'0:f'e:# j,lt/".;J/PR
;,
/ /.- ..'-
'\ / // i:})/{:5:J
1
d
('
'.
,
.-J./t I~' ,-"i
. "/,', /'
;/ II / 0., 'r
'?' \--!/-_--=:'_~/(-I-{; ..-' "-""'
DO I'
i~
" {/ ( r;
/ "
(
c
f, (
.(-
L
ii ,.
..-,-"-
,
Le'(-
j
,. ;..,.
I /~.--)
;: :';->'~:: .'/
,I j')./i
;: J, .....) , ,
C.Lt) J /), C_~_L,('-.:-:.t.L_J/__Ii..-/
5-5-
'.~.' .-----'
~) t_ .. ,
"J.'," ':.-':'('{
/~
'-'
J ',,\
, ~ : \ ...', ,-
). ;' I,_:~ !,.....-',\,,/
") ,,', r
'); ")
,
1\
i ~'(U) ,..{<.1L-
"..
:.'''-'
';\..--.
,
,
(:'
L _
"
, "
,"). . 7
~ (j '\ '-~, LL,,-t
-- /"
1\)0'
,;--
/\
1"-
"
. i I, ,,>~,
,
-". /'~~ ///'':-', __c,l
/~ '~,/ '~'J
/\/-J.L_.---A 1'-J/0'\
/ ' / " 1'- _
C':'::r. , C'.' ('" ~{l' __L"
'-'-[', d tL fcY ,--,---/--:{,-, 1j -j - .
0; \'
;) "
.......!,7,
. ,
f/ /
fj
() ~'}
II. I
, , ' ...,
Gr'-fI' ./[
1/
/ I J I
\
\/1/ . 'I ''-j
,I./y"
d' i
c.l/\,
-'1
"
,/ "
;'
c:>.' ,;;'
/)
,/
l/ /
r ~ -'/I
{/'..-/"",'
(f;', r"
.~ <.::/ "
/...~)
,.:/
,:;
/
,
./ /,/ /.- /) _../ (" f',. 'I
/ 'Lc-7----.f_-vl/ '.L
7' J ;-
'j(, ~
!
If L/....,
V-
, ,
I::.-
/,
. I
..
/ ,) -; I IF'
/_._/1:..;....' v~/!./ ~;
,
----'7}I /
.--.1/, ..
/' lL<."
/1
'j ,1' .I t( ,f{(
-1:-1--- -
~'
'-_/ - L}:,;,I
~-..j 'C; .' ,I
/~'/',/ . .' / /.
/ .<\/1/ '5 /.
,/
, "
.. c:::..( (./,.f..:./
I
'C'
~,.J{' j/t-(~
/
v'
C j 'Q..
lJ
G -/03
(,'"
f1 /
L/.././VL/!/
~'
o
.I
,
I
//c: (
, ,It L _ " ct f /
/1--'"
U
/ / ---
,----, .,' /,(( r/..
'_ f tet. {(C{( c.____I,-f.", '~'L(_
/
.
('f".,
"J
<.-i'/{.'
,
/,
/?7
:'lz! ," , L- Cc_/
f) /:
.''':',
'-';/,,!)I-((
, c
,', j' " ('
\~,_ (Cf',;, Lf,...LCl) I i,_
/1 -e--
.__/).." '. 'I (--;/
, .... "......1- ---tf,,^-
, c
~
'~"
.'
f,\ "
\
C~i--'i :C.,C("V~1f'",.:::
""I
~ /JJ jJ]L
/'
/{\Ji../ F L:. ;)
./ ; "
~---"
Lj-~_ /.,,(1 < L",..- C-.c 'y
^ C k! ?',/G.,~. 'c ,'(2c (',.{
")
(J
~",1 LJ
1./
(\;.' /),.,
''I --!-c.- L-I'..-.A.._:' ,,{1 c:-.-!L..1
;
/' ,.,
'1'-7 -',
t,_.-<;:,.,..(
";
A,
..~---"';;::,
,
,'c2:
,
);C C ',- ~'1 ,;: r~' ,"l.l
-,
.A-,-.c,'''
.- '-'~
i) 1/ ,'~
'/.', ,
/.'&-'-",'..1-i'i-, C'.C"'r.
,
/
j\
u
~/
"
i
1G'f
( ' J
l!tl..~o/ JUl;/
;1-"
1).,;/!!~y/-
NAME
It \"
r\ll
4: \it '!lA
, .
'-')
; ., :J
I /, /
/ <:::-CG v\--....
!
\..CC",
~
\i I_.._~^
ADDRESS
_-<0: '\)
.--1--6-;'"".... :-1-
,
,
,
<' )--,
-.J Ie 3 "AA'U::U(r!-j r
CITY
\.
C~-7,
;!
/'/
"
<:..J
'f /I.Ui/}
(") (.
/ )
iLu...{LI<J',/!
I - - .....,._
,..' I /
<-.:t.C1..~.~C"
}
.(,,/'--Q-,
i
#
l}ec.
1,/1 ,"
, ;
tJI-f' /~~.~(,/'
'---
lfyr.(
v
/7
Lc;
/',
I /
.(1/...-4___
/ - I
/7.'1
1 /,"1 , --I;
, //;/ ~'V-l.!.:\ /
,
\\\./\. , , f\
:) ,.\ \\
\;''/'-'''/; \,
I I J
/[1../\,"- /[0\(').. T
. \
.^. 'Lc,</ \,"/' '>A--C:\l
':)i 1 S
/5' (, l/A~'A,/{w,}J A. 4~ It ~
" /
~,IL )15\/"3-'... G....~ U. ,~
,) ,
b ,~ /';!.J0.{ ,-'eel};, f.. 'L
;' /,'
('// /' ~
'-. j:--;;::/1.._,/--'---(" \--,"-<-<::_-'C
'/
'/i ,. (I/I.!-(.e
,J, / ,Ii. ,,'
~/I..i'~ ~CU('1U{j
~ /'
I _./ ,/ .'
//j- Cl- /. "l(~/,><j/t [( ( t /
"'I' L (') r', < , J J --;-... ,-' I,].J._". (
-.J _J ':"r:~r.:-+-"'.f';t.(/...y/" t~ ,/~!:L/.:.nLl /_ 1:;4 ~/At.
,/
./
/l ..(
,
,
'/ .i,
'.'
; 0
/,//(//
( : ' ,4
/ L-~(; /(1 /I'?f'//'.I',
/;'/ ,
, /
~~ '"
'(I /1
i.: //>,; i (j
/j "/;>~
,/ I ,', I.. i'l /f,
>":/\.. c. l.(/vV'
;\_ l
~
I
;It;~':1 >~::..v?-
~
j",,)
,- , (, <I
'-/ ,/ ,....e~~"{/l.!:..,.?"_ ___-1
-'/}?,t;l- \
-- -,
i'I,'v/ - \~,
- (/'
)
-~ I / r'
/ / ( /
v
,
~- ~ -"
~'" cJ
'njl.tt
?.... Lc't~ '"
1;/ "
7'(11<(, .'1
,1\ Liley ,C/J 9-<.<;
,J{
/ /
/'~/
; -t. /~:}
-/';';;/'/
"/' ~ i /"
,
, ,'" ., I ~'
"
L/'
-;1
.'
/ / ')
. /"'/.l/'
'~ ?> / ~~/- r'/
.
~'I/ ,/
/,'. ,,1/./ 1"'//
/ // t. ~~ /.-(_/ ,_- ._;;;.----
.c.--_ _, ..
,
L,
'"
~=::~_~ (I,
", \..~,
f-) 0
~~,~ ,>^ ~l' !
.....*'~
"." ','.
~""-''''''<''''-'
\.'>,., "
'~"",--'._,(::......
,-,
"
..- ",T"
1..._ '-...~ _ I
//
.;.,(
}--'--::"'~
--- ?I
-----,/"
. '-Z / "
,. '--., ,'/
/ -\'- '--'.'
\
/ "','
, ,
./ ",'
,/;'/:"() i'l'/ J.~F,
,'.J t "'('?--- "<(""L'C.~;J" 7":';:
), 1 '
,-,~ ,l,~ 1.,,( \.: I '{ i,,/ ,-/~!,'
'J '
.'/ :.' \ '>E !.) C \--
i
,
'~) , ,'. '" '.j -, /_-"
/.' ~-----,"
"
" /: -
'---~I
//
,
/ 'il /
j'/i/.,1/) ,
, /:~/./;-
'-'
<; )",/ \,
'" <';. "
..., , ~ ';' -"1.--'
~ .--;/....,-<y-,./~/.( /.: / .J'_-//_,1
,'- I .~ i.', ./- ';, ~ < 1...-//';-':"--1._;::.,- . / /
,/' /.;" "/ A, /,' ,"/ __ . ( / _.
~l'.A'/;i;::'t':kt7[,_, /-/( ) '5/ L
I 1 .
, ,---I ( ")...--
...2 /2,.f C'~L..L! L (.)~.: c:-.~ t1 _/
c:) (, !,'r: (( c:'~ c {<';/-." -, (/</ Pi
,----;" /,
,/ "....) :J
'/' )
.1/,,/;';
I i /
.'
/' -""
. '.
I
,
..L /
,) ,r
~ /J
'/
,1/1
_":,.1 ___
' 1(/ r;~.!-/
. i' ~-tl ,A~--)
,---
.,
L /) / /', ,) (,. )
,'.,-~c ! i -( / c , LL Lf.-t/ ,. C '.-\ I/J , Fe ,.
, , "
',!
\
../
;-.
'.
('s..! /
I' /
" )
( ;1,
"
c z"'II;
! (/'1'--1_ --'__ /; ./ L
(I ;':' I
/
i) I.
t.
/
!
-,\,
.J ./
.
NAME
ADDRESS
CITY
, ') tt
I ......--- j
f !< I !
,--_I" \ ""I
I \\.V', ,
'7 i /, \
, j ! ' (IC( , , f r
; I,.j I, ,l) C ",--(
'/ I, i "~I ", '~
J-T- ; ,
I ,,-_,_ L~
')
( /'
!.,_..A.-/1_.L.
,"'1_:\
~(.(\ ~ L'_L
,I .":.1 Lj"_~
t,;""::J
Ll''/\.:c",-V' -"Jfl{(
( ,
~V_LL
, '
L' I
L../ LJ.
, I,
/,,;-C'-L!\.
\
r,..LL",- J_t:_,_~_---
') L, I
,
/-
,
/l~'-- ; L.L-~-
:
:\
~-f'- i
/' - 1.(,,/
v.... 'u_<-1..f>....... J....
/ ;,
.'
.----
[:' , ,
I \.}--i'\;/l' fL-
,
,-,; /, L ~i j). f
cz"/L L....v- ;,\(..l.{;.!;:~ ;=~<<-c./{~
/ '. I
. ~fc.; - (!,! v ' ~/I:' ?
- ( . , , .' ~/L,/' /"\' ,,/1' J'/
---^-.~c'V- '-- ,L.,n ...(".."(,'; , , A.,'
f)
/-~. :<---Lv .-c /c/U' Cu
/ .. "
L\ L Cc
j /!/
i -/'(,..
'v/C-/.,__ L' ./
\ / c ,; J'
/
L~'. ! :,
,/ ./
(
~ t~_
;?
f C )
-:.._,:..~-Z/ v-
i'
i/
,~- ~_.
...'( c-;,.'_,
,/ /;,'/( ,...::
( 'v' .','l/L I':'L (
'( ,( .,
L (' _, r., I~ I,.
'- - '- ,< ~ / I
,
" ;.j~,
\_':
,
I
,J
'\. '
/
-i.!~({ ",,-'t.! ;(;.{{('\' .\~/ ;I_f
'\.., L 1'l (e I f
;;.__l
-. V"
r,. ',._---'-
rt ~.--
',-- ':.>'l
'2;
,"--'J
to" -:- _;.,
/
/ ,:.-
_~-" t,LL- ~
~-( ~.
/'
,---"-
i'
V'."
,
,
('
/
'.//. .'
. ('r'
..-~ Jr. . /~ .', -,\-'...c ,/. (:'
">'- '-, .
/
,,~
'" ';'.r
,/',
-' (,:' '-
~~ - "
, . .J
,
/ " 4"',-C~"-'..s.: ',,/"l-"'--?'"1~LD
/'
l/:cFl
l.r-./I~:r k~c:.'?(<S'/VP/( !)
'--::;;.<<' ,..../..~
t)-
...L
~,;~,;.,
( [~~;""
/~/ I
.._' V7'j " /, /'
,.' / ; I/;:',/::-_
::/ / ,: IC, zf-:::>;-;:---7--
"'-'
>""/;...-:-
L L-- (~,.'
c----r-
/
A !,<<-),-",
/ ,
he ,I"
. 'v,
"- <J //'
- I
/\_( (,;; /./../v:>-~J.__,
c..~;''':''
\J
,-
/
-"-.'!
I;~ (.
'I
c -~ \.
r...-(" ," . _____..~ (:7~,..,~
",
'_ (; L/-
,/
./ ,.~/.;t e V./'--~. :l~
"
~
/,
:
, '
'.,\~ (:,
) \ '.-/ ~',-~,A_-"
?
~ " ,4 /'
,A~,f //,-_p L(,
(':'-J
J
~..o /3
\ ~GJ.J (' c..J ~"t<-A L
/'-'
u\.,((
(" It", )~LD,f:
, /'1
'("'. 1
r--.l.../~\ ft)
!.i /~{JJ'...,t--f.. ~
/ /
U
;_J /I '
/"l....
/ \ ()'J~~~ Li ?-L^_~
IJ
f
(c;;
7/Ci:
,,-(
-;-' ,\JC.r.:J.. C\.A. k
r
,
~t!.-"
/l
l. A,\'/ j
~
/
;',.,/, 1_
,'/',
'v __ j-'\:-C ,""".;
'~....::-//'
,/
'/
, /.
1-.--"7' ;' / .
1-1'//....:.-1 1 "
'(, &,. ;/ - ~ '"-'-
t f../C/
(ic.' (f ul/~/1(
?-( /9 ;"
,v
1/: ,/ t: J </:',/ I~-;"-/'_f(.
,'" '/
";/!' .~/
f' / _ /
./,;:;'?///:/, ,~,
/ ,.f..,__./.,_.." L'
:::::/ __.;";7' J _
'<,72 / ~ ~<<:.c;r;;.
if
,__~ .' (' L.L.--/
-J
_~.=_-!: [1--:" (
') ,\j
c~l~:~::2~':-~:~> /j f ~7~.~~
.J{.lt::'>
'/' :c/
l / /
,_~Y/~c~-// ~1,-'7"-'. c7
,
,~~/
Il,JA/'..[E
ADDRESS
CITY
"
.,
(.
{. /
, ,
/ (/1
,
I,
-. /
"
:/
-i"--I':
"
/~ I,
),Uf
\'.,',
,;
, -Ii
, II
1
/
"
"
t',
~
/ '-
,
f-
)>':" (
,,( ,
I'
,',
,,'
"i~l
<-I
r
C,_
'- '-
L C-
! / '. ',I ')
/1__/ ~._~" "'--_f /l/ u/ (/ ~ jJ /"
. A,-
:3 <-t c.;
,
'-. __~t~_.!./ r
---',
L(.'" :'-
,:> -; (~: ';-' -;/ /'
i '-. '/'''':'/'--.r /.
./ /^---"'./ ..... ,/------
'" ~-':2A ~I
L.- L.- <..---;
F5''i?
1/ /\...
...c<
flt'L'
)
,
-
L LLl,V\( I."
h~
r
'\,-'
L{ '-
c,
i,)"
, ,
J
'\ ,--'-
jl,
i
"I-
1-,
, 7
I <
~ f/
/j
'--.... :
31'1
..
.
"
'--<.
/
\,-,
,/ ',,,-, c-_~ j
J -"__"
,"
~\ '(--
"i>
( I \
;
;' /
! I /
,/1/
/~ .
/--:
-:r , _ ,I
)
,
t A , {~'"
? .'.
,,< ' ,"
',/'
(
,
i
J
"
~,
/
C
.) /
. 1
"-t:':' ,
... - ~..
'.',"
!
'1') I
. I I
1'- ,( ; '--
.-,
, I
...-' r/
,\ 1-(/.....1.
'I
,:.;. ',j_A
/',
'''(/,./'1"
/
/
>-~-/-
--..:------,'
DEPAR1 ,1ENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
FROM
Lula Butler -
Communi ty Improvement Director~ ~
[Iry DF
DELRAY BEACH
..~
TO
Walter O. Barry - City Manager
"AUBURN TRACE PROJECT"
SUBJECT CONSIDERATION OF REZONING - CITY COMMISSION ACTION
7/21/88
This memo is regarding the Auburn Trace Project as proposed under the
UDAG application between the City of Delray Beach and Procacci
Development Corp.
The project as proposed is consistent with the City's goals and
objectives to providing "Affordable rental units" to low and moderate
income residents of the City of Delray Beach, and is consistent with
the identified need for affordable housing units in the City.
The proposed rent ranges of $290 to $494 per month allows for maximum
benefit to the low and moderate income residents and when compared to
comparable units in the private market, allows for a savings in rent
payments. Without the public assistance approval with this project as
proposed, the rental rates would be substantially higher thus
destroying the objective of the project.
As proposed, the Auburn Trace Development will most likely attract the
"working" family, be it a single parent or a couple, who can afford to
pay the rent without any form of direct subsidy. There are no direct
rental subsidies guaranteed with this project, although eligible
tenants holding Section 8 certificates or vouchers may exercise their
right to request management participation in the program.
When you compare the proposed rents associated with the Auburn Trace
Development and those of the private market in the same area, you will
recognize the rental savings and the term "affordable". For instance,
the average rent for a 2-bedroom unit in the CD target area ranges
between $350 to $450 per month, with the 3-bedroom ranging between
$400 for older units and as high as $550 for newer units. The CRA is
currently receiving $335 per month for the one-bedroom units it now
owns and manages on SW 1st Street.
The Commission should also keep in mind that while imposing a lower
density may still allow a financially feasible project, there are
other factors to consider. We may reduce construction and mortgage
cost with less units, while operation cost may not be reduced as much.
C:'v1362
T"E E,.ccORT ALWAYS MATTE,-,;
fl
Auburn Trace Rezoning
July 21, 1988
Page two
Consider the fact that if we are expecting a security gate, the cost
of staffing and maintenance remains the same; lawn maintenance costs
will remain the same or more if additional green space is added;
utilities and garbage cost will not decrease at the same proportion,
etc.
The UDAG grant is really a subsidy to the development phase rather
than the operation of the project. The developer will need to be able
to generate enough revenue to maintain the development throughout the
life of the project and not be forced into a position of not enough
money for adequa~e operation thus forcing another "Carver Estates
situation". We will probably see a site plan with fewer ammenities
with lower density.
Given the need for affordable rental units established by the Reinhold
Wolff study and the application for and fund reservation approved on
the Auburn Trace Project, staff recommends the RM zoning to
accommodate the 368 units proposed by Procacci Development.
LB:DQ
Disk - Lula
A:AuburnRezone.CM
THE SCHOOL BOARD
OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
3323 BELVEDERE ROAD
P.O. BOX 24690
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33416-4690
305-f.i84-5000
THOMAS J. MILLS
SUPERINTENDENT
OF SCHOOLS
l(lrVA__
o1'~W-
July 11, 1988
Walter Berry, CIty Manager
City of Delray Beach
100 NW First Avenue
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
RE: AUBURN TRACE SCHOOL IMPACT
Dear Mr. Berry:
This statement is provided in fulfillment of Chapter 235.193, Section 2, Florida Statutes to
ensure that public educational facilities are coordinated with plans for residential
development. It addresses the concerns of Palm Beach County School Board as they
specifically relate to the anticipated impact of Auburn Trace Development which is to be
located between Southwest Fourth Street and Southwest Eighth Street on Southwest
Eighth Avenue In Delray Beach. The prOject will encompass 38 acres of land adjacent to
Carver Estates. As currently proposed the development will contain 80 one bedroom unIts,
232 two bedroom units and 56 three bedroom units. The project Is classified as
"affordable housing".
A study was conducted utilizing demographic multipliers for Palm Beach County to
estimate students which would be generated from this development. Because no
information was provided as to architectural unIt type, it was assumed that all units will
be townhomes. The Growth Management Center estimates 53 elementary, 16 middle, and
13 high school students will be generated by the project.
A parallel study was conducted utilizing Wedgewood Plaza In Riviera Beach as a
comparable development. The mUltipliers this derived indicated roughly double the number
of students would be generated for the Auburn Trace Project as the first study Indicated.
The geographic area in which this development is located is presently served by Addison
Mizner Elementary, Carver Middle, and Atlantic High. Following is a breakdown for each
school of projected enrollment for 1988-1989, current capaCity and recommended ultimate
capacity as noted in The Educational Plant Survey, Palm Beach County, February 1986;
Addison
Mizner
Carver
Middle
Projected Enrollment w/o Auburn Trace 765
*Projected Enrollment w/Auburn Trace 871
Current Permanent Capacity 697
Recommended Capacity 589
891
923
1,301
1,103
A tlan tic
Hilt'h
1,729
1,755
2,155
1,920
* Utilizes multipliers developed for Wedgewood Plaza.
wpd8\poliey\imp
l
.
Page 2
July 11, 1988
Walter Berry
City of Delray Beach
Analysis of this information Indicates that this project wlIl significantly Impact the public
school system and add to the cumulative effect of overcrowding In schools serving the
area.
In addition, the construction of an affordable housing development likely to house
predominately minority Individuals and families In an area already housing predominately
minority individuals and families Is virtually certain to have a negative Impact on School
Board efforts to racially balance area schools. The School Board opposes placement of
developments anywhere in the County which have a negative impact on the racial balance
of Palm Beach County's public schools, or which make the integration of our schools more
difficult.
The School Board will continue to actively pursue a policy of providing adequate school
facilities for all the children of Palm Beach County.
Sincerely, ~
~I.'
.4,,;. V. Hw"U. P. ., &'
Assistant Superintendent
Growth Management Center
WVH:dkh
cc: Thomas J. Mills
James G. Daniels
J. Kenneth Schrimsher
wpd8\poiicy.imp
l
.
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
/ ~,
TO, lJ"~'r'~:::GER
FROM: DAVID J. KOVACS, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 12, 1988
AGENDA ITEM
PUBLIC HEARING RE REZONING OF PROPERTY ASSOCIATED WITH
THE PROPOSED AUBURN TRACE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT, R-lA TO
RM
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval on first reading of the enacting ordinance for
this rezoning from R-IA to RM of twenty-five (25) acres
of City owned land.
BACKGROUND:
A rezoning on a total of thirty-eight acres on property owned by
the the City and the Housing Authority was initiated by the City
Commission in November, 1987. The proposed designation at that
time was RH. Following Planning and Zoning Board hearings in
January, it was recommended that the zoning over the entire
property involved in the proposed Auburn Trace housing
development be RM. That recommendation was consistent with a
companion action on a Land Use Map Amendment which converted five
acres from Single Family (SF) to RM.
The Planning and Zoning Board's recommendation on the rezoning
was placed on-hold while the Land Use Map Amendment cleared the
State review process. SUbsequently, comments have been received
and the Map Amendment has had a second public hearing before the
City Commission. Second reading of the enacting ordinance is
scheduled on July 12th. With that action near completion, it is
now appropriate to consummate the rezoning action. To that end a
proposed ordinance has been drafted and advertised for public
hearing at first reading. The proposed ordinance addresses only
that territory on which the zoning designation is to be chanqed.
Thus, it includes only twenty-five acres of the tot:aJ.
thirty-eight acre project.
To: Walter o. oarry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearings Re Rezoning Of Property Associated With
The Proposed Auburn Trace Housing Development,
R-1 To RH
Page 2
At the time that the City Commission held its first public
hearing on the associated land use map amendment, it was clear
that by limiting the map amendment to RM, instead of RH, any
development would have to measure up to performance standards in
order to achieve maximum density under the RM zoning district.
Since that hearing there have been concerns aired about the total
unit count and resulting density of the Auburn Trace development
proposal. In order to provide an assessment of options and
impacts associated with varying densities, we have attached a
copy of the documentation which was provided to the Commission
for the public hearing of February 9th. Pages 7 through 9 of that
documentation address density matters.
Under provisions of the RM zoning district a base of seven units
per acre is established. An increase in density, up to ten units
per acre, is permitted provided that "technical" performance
standards are met (these are assessed in the February 9th
background material). In addition, a site and development plan
is sUbject to the ten standards of Code Section 173.867.
REZONING ANALYSIS:
In considering the rezoning action, the Commission is to be
guided by the seventeen standards found in Code Section 173.888
(copy attached). While these standards were addressed to some
degree during the land use map amendment process, it is
appropriate to specifically revisit them at this time since the
zoning action is more specific than the land use map action.
Standards which deserve attention include:
(B) Will the change be contrary to the existing land use
pattern?
(C) Will the change alter the population density pattern,
thereby increasing the load on public facilities such
as schools, utilities, streets, and the like?
(G) Will the change adversely influence living conditions
in the neighborhood?
(H) Re traffic and (I) re drainage are specifically
addressed in the performance standards assessment.
(K) Will the change adversely affect property values in the
adjacent area?
(0) Is the change out of scale with the needs of the
neighborhood or the City?
.
To: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearings Re Rezoning Of Property Associated With
The Proposed Auburn Trace Housing Development,
R-l To RH
Page 3
The February 9th background material provides a discussion of
other housing proposals which were considered for this area. In
those cases a limitation was placed upon the ultimate density of
the projects. Those limits were in the range of six and seven
units per acre. If the Commission desires to have such limits
placed on the proposed Auburn Trace development, this rezoning
action is the final step at which such a limitation is
appropriate -- i.e. this is the most discretionary action left
before the Commission.
If a density limitation is to be included in the Commission's
action, it may be necessary to amend the caption of the enacting
ordinance and thus necessitate rehearing. Further, a limitation
associated with the territory under hearing at this time affects
only the twenty-five acres of City owned property. The Housing
Authority parcel is not included in the current rezoning action.
Thus if an overall unit count of 290 were desired, a limitation
of six units per acre on the City owned land would be necessary.
To accommodate this situation, it would be more appropriate to
apply RL zoning (3 to 6 units per acre) than to consider a
numerical limitation. In addition, a RL designation would be
more consistent with the R-IA designations which abut the City
owned property to its north and east and would also serve as a
buffer between those areas and the higher density portions of the
overall site.
Information addressing density and unit count as they apply to
the U.D.A.G. and proposed project are addressed under separate
cover by the Director of Community Improvement Services who is
responsible for the C.D.B.G. and housing programs.
ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS AS THEY PERTAIN TO ZONING DESIGNATIONS:
1.
Proceed with RM zoning
ordinance on first reading.
approve the enacting
2. Proceed with RL zoning, thus setting a maximum unit
count for the entire project in the range of 290 units
with the lesser density situated adjacent to existing
R-1A zoning.
3. Proceed with RM zoning but with a stipulation in the
enacting ordinance as to unit count. Consider that
only 25 of the total project is governed by this
zoning action.
4.
Direct that
modified to
the matter.
the ordinance before the Commission be
include the total project and readvertise
1
To: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearings Re Rezoning Of Property Associated With
The Proposed Auburn Trace Housing Development,
R-l To RH
Page 4
5.
Do not rezone the property i.e. deny
ordinance on first reading. Such an
require complete processing through the
Zoning Board prior to reconsideration.
the enacting
action will
Planning and
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Commission discretion.
Attachment:
background material from the February 9th public
hearing on the Land Use Map consideration
Code Section 173.888 Standards for Evaluating Rezoning
Requests
REF/DJK*25/B:CCTRACE.TXT
l
INFORMATION FOR PART (A) OF PLAN AMENDMENT 1988-1
Property OWner.............
City of Delray Beach. Approximately
20 acres was owned by the Housing
Authority. It was transferred (sold)
to the City so that property devel-
opment could be facilitated. The
balance of the property was owned
by the City.
Location
................. .
A general area bounded by the north
boundary of Carver Estates; on the
east by S.W. 10th Ave.; on the west
by S.W. 14th Ave; on the north by
S.W. 4th St.; less the Haitian
Church and Carver athletic field
sites. Approximate area of 37
acres.
Current Map Designations ... 4.79 acres of Single Family (SF),
31.73 acres of Medium (7) to Medium
High (10) Density Residential (RM).
Requested Designation Medium High (11) to High (15)
Density Residential (RH)
Purpose for the requested amendment: This request was
formally initiated by the City Commission in order to proceed
with a proposed affordable housing project. The proposal which
was presented to the Commission called for a unit count of 368
units. In order to guarantee that 368 units would be built it is
necessary to have a RH designation. This would accommodate the
RH zone district designation which carries a base density of
eleven units per acre or approximately 400 units.
A map designation of RM over the entire holdings would yield a
density range of 7 to 10 units per acre or a unit count of 255 to
365 units. While the high end of the RM designation would
accommodate the proposed project, such a unit count is not
guaranteed through the RM designation since application of the RM
zone district only guarantees the base of 7 units per acre.
Increases to the maximum (10 units per acre) must satisfy
criteria found within the "Performance Standards" portion of the
RM district regulations. Those criteria are assessed at the time
that a site plan is presented for formal review and approval.
III~A (AJ
Analysis:
The fOllowing factors were explored in' the analysis of this
request:
a) history of land use map designations;
b)
Community Redevelopment
recommendations;
Plan
designation
and
c) goals, objectives, and pOlicies of the Plan including
the housing element and pOlicy guide to the land use
plan;
d) performance standards identified in the RM and RH zone
districts which must be met in order to exceed base
densities.
~ history of land use map designations: Previous to the 1979
Land Use Map. this property had been identified for single
family development. The 1979 Map initially designated the
land for single family, recreational, and "public" land use.
(The "public" designation was applied to any publicly owned
parcels and did not necessarily reflect any specific land
use. )
In 1984, an amendment was made which placed approximately 10
acres of the land under consideration into the RM category.
That amendment was made under the auspices of the Housing
Authority and was initially for a RM-15 designation. Concerns of
a concentration of public housing and traffic impacts through
single family neighborhoods led to a change to the RM designation
along with further stipulations that any resulting development
should be in the range of 7 units per acre.
In 1986, an amendment was made which placed 18 acres of City
owned land into the RM designation to accommodate the proposed
"Homestead" project which involved duplexes at a density of
approximately six units per acre.
The draft land use map which was prepared in 1987 along with a
draft land use element showed the land as single family along
with extensions of the Carver middle school recreational area
into it. This designation apparently reflected policy guide
statements which called for single family housing in the
sou thwest part of the City (see later section). . Also, it may
have reflected the situation wherein the subject area is not
adjacent to a collector or arterial traffic system. The
designation may also have been intended to further the "homestead
program" which was, in 1986/7, being proposed for a portion of
the area.
- 2 -
1
Ql Community Redevelopment Plan designations/recommendations:
The CRP reflects the then zoning pattern of mUlti-family
housing (1/3) and single family housing (2/3). The CRP
while citing the need for affordable housing and the pursuit
of housing programs did not provide specific recommendations
as to areas where housing projects should be located.
Proceeding with a designation contrary to the existing
designations in the CRP should not be considered as being
inconsistent with that plan since its residential land use
pattern generally followed existing zoning.
c;:.l Goals. policies and objectives of the Plan including the
Housing Element and the Policy Guide: The Housing Element of
the 1979 Plan drew primarily from a 1976 Housing Assistance
Program (HAP) which was being implemented by the City. With
that HAP and Plan Element were stated the following goals:
(Page 101 of Plan)
1. Foster a safe and decent home for all City residents,
both present and future.
2. Expand the range of housing choice.
3. Improve the conditions of the existing housing stock.
4. Improve the quality of life in residential areas.
5. Increase understanding of the housing field.
6. Expand employment opportunities and increase household
income.
7.
Coordinate housing programs
activities.
with
other
planning
Plan concepts to achieve those goals included rehabilitation,
replacement, development of lower income housing, development of
programs to maintain the quality of existing housing, improvement
of neighborhood conditions, and enhanced economic opportunity for
residents.
The City has established its own Community Development program,
funded through an entitlement CDBG, and is actively working
toward the above goals. The City has also established a Housing
Authority which is managing the Carver Estates project and has
pursued other avenues for providing additional housing for lower
income families. At present the City provides housing assistance
through:
244 Section 8 Certificates
31 Section 8 Vouchers
403 Section 8 Elderly
200 units in a public housing project
for a total of 878 subsidized units.
- 3 -
l
The City's efforts are mainly directed to the rehabilitation of
substandard, owner-occupied housing through direct grants. 18
to 20 units are targeted each year for these grants.
Non-occupied dilapidated structures are demolished in order to
help reduce adverse neighborhood conditions. A rental
rehabilitation program is in its initial stages of development.
In the early 1980s a task team addressed methods in which the
affordable housing stock could be enhanced. Its suggestions were
to pursue duplex, triplex, and four-plex development on vacant
lots.
In recent years ~here have been two efforts to provide additional
"affordable" housing stock. One was called the "Auburn Trace"
project. It began on ten acres of Housing Authority property (a
part of the area under consideration in this plan amendment) and
was proposed for 104 units. Deemed "too dense", the City added
another 5 acres to the property for an effective density of 7
units per acre. Apparently, problems with long-term cash flow
and continued operations funding prevented continuing with the
project i.e. a greater unit count was necessary in order to cover
operational costs.
Another project was initiated under the auspices of the City and
was called the "Homestead Program". It was intended to provide
106 units through ownership of 53 duplexes with supplemental
income from the renting of the second unit. It involved 18 acres
of the land under review in this plan amendment. Difficulties
with the duplex program including statements that it would be in
competition with the Auburn Trace Project and an uncertainty on
the status of Section 8 Certifications for the rental units lead
to the abandonment of the project. It was replaced with a
concept of placing approximately 75 single family units on the
same site. That change in direction occurred in March, 1987.
Preliminary survey work and soil testing were undertaken. As the
project was ready to proceed to preliminary site planning,
administrative direction was given to go to a "hold" position
while the larger scale multi-family project was pursued.
Another potential affordable housing project proposed on County
land, just to the north of the land under consideration in this
plan amendment, is based on the same single family program as
intended in March, 1987. It will provide 33 single family homes
through a pUblic-private partnership approach.
The City's Policy
Comprehensive Plan
issues associated
include:
Guide to the Land Use
contains pOlicy statements
with this proposed plan
Element of the
which pertain to
amendment. They
- 4 -
RESIDENTIAL
(1) A wide range of housing choices should be provided for
the residents of Delray Beach. Emphasis should be put
on upgrading existing housing and providing housing
opportunities for young professional and business
households.
(3 )
The City should develop programs and incentives
infill housing throughout the Enterprise Zone
Community Redevelopment Area.
for
and
( 5)
Declining residential neighborhoods should
identified and every effort made to upgrade them.
be
(6) The City should work diligently to provide its fair
share of the regional needs for low cost housing.
The proposed program appears to be compatible with these goal
statements as one means to achieve the overriding concern for
providing affordable housing for Delray Beach residents. There
has been concern, aired over the years, that Delray Beach is
providing more than its fair share of accommodating regional
needs. While this seems to be the case, there is a local need
(documented by the Wolff low and moderate income housing need
study of 1987) for affordable housing. Thus, it appears that to
be consistent with current policy direction provisions must be
made that will result in City residents having priority in
obtaining housing made available through the proposed affordable
housing proiect.
(d) performance standards in the RM and RH zone districts:
these performance standards are to be met or deficiencies
mitigated in order to exceed base densities of 11 units per
acre in RH and 7 units per acre in the RM categories. A copy
of these standards are attached for reference.
(1) Water Service: There should not be a problem with
providing water to the site. A limitation of 368 units
(number of units specified in a related UDAG
application) is compatible with water service planning
for the area.
( 2) Sewer Service: There should not be a problem with
providing sewer service to the site. A limitation of
368 units is compatible with sewer service planning for
the area. It has not yet been determined if lift
stations will be required. If so they should be a cost
of the development.
- 5 -
1
(3) Streets: A full traffic study should be required at
the time of site plan review. In order to make
findings that the existing level of service will not be
diminished it is expected that traffic flow will need
to be directed to the south (to S. w. 10th Street)
instead of through the single family neighborhoods
north of the proposed project.
A schematic road/circulation system which has been developed for
project review contemplates the abandonment of S.W. 10th Avenue
and its function as the northerly exit from Carver Estates.
provision for maintaining a northerly exit can be made through
use, and improvement, of the cemetery access road. Right-of-way
is readily obtainable since the cemetery property is City-owned.
Development costs for improvement of this street connection would
be a City expense pursuant to terms of the contract for sale.
The circulation system also provides that s. W. 12th Avenue be
extended and connected to existing S.W. 14th Avenue. While that
portion through the project would clearly be the developer's
cost, a portion (700') leading to the project from the north may
be required to be a City expense. Also, the connection to S.W.
14th Avenue will require acquisition of right-of-way over Housing
Authority property (Carver Estates) and new construction which,
pursuant to terms of the contract for sale, would be a City
expense.
In addition to the above traffic network, it is anticipated that
by directing a greater percentage of traffic from Carver Estates
to the south, and by designing the new project to encourage
traffic to flow to the south, intersection improvements will be
necessary at S.W. 14th Avenue and S.W. 10th Street. In addition,
it is anticipated that the increased traffic will accelerate the
need to improve S.W. 10th Street between Congress and Germantown
Road. Funding for these improvements will be a City expense. If
at the time of site plan review it is determined that the above
expenses must be incurred to accommodate the 368 unit project and
funding for the improvements will not be concurrent with the
creation of the increased need, RM district regulations would
dictate that the situation be mitigated by the reduction of unit
count to no more than 260 units. Under a RH designation, the 368
unit project would proceed and the City would need to defer other
projects to accommodate the necessary improvements to the street
system.
(4) Environmental Impacts:
(a) environmentally sensitive areas -- no such areas
exist on the property under review.
(b) hazardous waste -- so such impact is associated
with either the land or proposed uses.
- 6 -
.
(5) Additional Considerations:
(a)
adequacy of fire protection: This is a site
related item. Water pressure should
sufficient. Hydrants will be required at
developer's expense. Sprinkler systems
the multi-family units will be required
the developer's expense.
plan
be
the
for
at
(b) drainage -- major drainage devices are necessary;
on-site retention will not be sufficient, by
itself, to accommodate drainage. Because of the
intensity of development it is anticipated that a
conduit system will be necessary to convey
concentrated drainage to the canal system by 1-95.
This is normally a developer's expense but,
pursuant to terms of the contract of sale, it may
be a City expense.
(c) recreational proposals some on-site
recreational amenities are to be provided which
will be restricted to use of the residents. In
addition a site of approximately four acres is to
be provided, in lieu of fees, adjacent to the
Catherine Strong Center parcel and the athletic
fields of Carver Middle School. This site is
proposed to have active recreational facilities
(basketball courts, play fields, tennis courts)
installed at the developer's expense (not a part
of the contract of sale but an item costed out in
the associated UDAG application). Negotiations
are anticipated as to the manner in which
maintenance and operation of the park site will be
continued over time i.e. sUbcontracting to the
developer or directly provided by the City's Parks
and Recreation Department. Recreational needs can
be readily accommodated if carried out as
indicated in the contract for sale and UDAG
application.
(d) flood hazards -- the property is not near a water
course which is subject to flooding.
(e) development patterns and compatibility of density
and character of surrounding neighborhoods
-- public records show previous concerns with a
high concentration of units in this general area.
Previous land use map amendments to RM
designations contemplated development in the range
of 7 units per acre (Auburn Trace) and 6 units per
acre (Homestead Program). An RH designation which
would guarantee a density of 11 units per acre (or
the proposed unit count of 368) is not consistent
with those previous actions.
- 7 -
-- the proposed project is compatible, from a land use
perspective with existing use to the south (Carver
Estates at high density) and the Catherine Strong
Center to the west. While currently compatible with
the Carver Middle School property to the northwest, it
is anticipated that that school will be abandoned
within a decade and that reuse of the property will be
sought at an intensity equal to or greater than that
which is associated with development resulting from
this plan amendment. The only other large parcel of
land in the immediate area is a County owned parcel
currently being promoted for single family affordable
housing (33 units). If that affordable housing project
does not materialize, it is anticipated that a land use
change will be sought which is comparable to the action
on this plan amendment. Between this area and Atlantic
Avenue there is a single family area (plan and zoning).
It is highly probably that as decisions are later made
to develop vacant parcels in that area requests will be
made to depart from the single family pattern and
infill with duplex, triplex, or four-plex development.
While such development may be a viable strategy to
provide affordable housing, it may work against other
stated goals of maintaining the integrity of
neighborhoods.
The measure of this matter of neighborhood compatibility should
be dependent, to a great degree, upon testimony which is provided
at the public hearing. All property owners within 500 feet of
the perimeter of the proposed amendment have received written
notice of the hearing and the contemplated actions.
ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
The fOllowing courses of action
they contemplate the myriad of
proposed plan amendment.
are available to the Board as
aspects associated with this
1. Following the public hearing defer action to a special
meeting. Also, provide direction to staff regarding
additional information desired or the preparation of a
draft recommendation. The City Commission's hearing
date for the plan amendment is February 23, 1988.
2. Forward a recommendation that the land use map be
amended to show a RH designation for the 38 acres.
Such a recommendation would be based upon an overriding
community need of providing affordable housing. It
would guarantee approval of a site plan containing at
least 368 units (providing on-site technical compliance
is achieved) in that it would allow RH zoning which has
a base of 11 units per acre. A restriction to 368
units is compatible with the maximum unit count under
the present designations (359 units) and if such a
restriction is affixed, the item could be approved as a
local amendment.
- B -
3. Forward a recommendation that the land use map be
amended to show a RM designation for the 38 acres.
Such a recommendation would be based upon fact that 90%
of the property is already in that designation. It
would guarantee approval of a site plan containing at
least 260 units under RM zoning provided that on-site
technical compliance is achieved. Any increase to that
base would require positive findings with respect to
all the performance standards of the RM zone district
or the mitigation, through City financial participation
of those negative impacts which involve public
improvements. This recommendation would result in a
local amendment.
4. Forward a recommendation that the land use map should
not be amended to accommodate the proposed affordable
housing development based upon the following:
it will accommodate a proposed development, which
at a projected density of ten units per acre, is
not compatible with existing land use to the north
and east of the site;
it will set undesirable land use statement and
direction for the eventual redevelopment of the
Carver Middle School site and for vacant parcels
which are available for in-fill development;
it will make an undesirable statement regarding
other efforts which are intended to stabilize
residential areas and encourage revitalization
through maintaining a high degree of
homeownership;
it will necessitate expenditure of City funds for
infrastructure improvements primarily for the
street network which are not currently programmed
and thus will shift priority away from projects
which are currently scheduled;
it represents a significant change to the concepts
and basis which existed in the granting of the two
previous actions which resulted in RM designations
in the area; those being a density of 7 units per
acre for Auburn Trace and 6 units per acre for the
Homestead program.
ASSESSMENT AND CONCLUSIONS:
The general intent of the proposed amendment, to accommodate an
affordable housing project which will provide priority to
existing residents of the City of Delray Beach, is consistent
with various goals of the City. A conceptual site plan which
shows a compact, well designed project indicates that the
proposed unit count (368) can be properly accommodated within the
area.
- 9 -
However, the terms of the contract or sale and other items
necessary to accommodate the desired development require several
City actions which are expensive, alter other improvement
programs, and may be time-consuming. In addition, apparent
adverse neighborhood impacts and related service expense may
negate the perceived benefits of accommodating the affordable
housing project which was the impetus for the plan amendment. A
highlighting of these concerns/items are:
taking right-of-way from
possibly taking a portion
proposed development thus
plan;
the Cemetery property and
of the right-of-way from the
putting a pinch on the site
taking right-of-way from the Carver Middle School site
and possibly taking a portion of that right-of-way from
the proposed development thus putting another pinch on
the site plan;
acquisition of right-of-way for the southerly extension
of S.W. 14th Avenue over Housing Authority hOldings;
capital expenditures for the 14th Avenue extension,
intersection improvements at 14th and S.W. 10th Street,
street realignment northerly out of Carver Estates then
east to S.W. 8th Avenue, and possibly the extension of
S.W. 12th Street southerly into the project;
capital expenditures for drainage devices (and possibly
obtaining easements) to the canal along I-95;
a higher per capita demand on law enforcement to
provide services in a relatively high concentration of
low and low-moderate income households it is
anticipated that the Police Department will be seeking
three officers added to its staff concurrent with
occupancy of the project;
the existence of a soils analysis which comments that
the soils are of "loosely compacted material" which may
require "some type of stabilization" but should be okay
for single story, single family housing construction
.... by transposition, it may be anticipated that soil
conditions could dictate either increased development
costs or redesign of the site plan to accommodate
sensitive soils;
the potential precedent setting nature of
designation with respect to in-fill
development in that part of the community.
the land use
and future
- 10 -
The decision before the Board as to what direction to take is
indeed difficult. On one hand, opportunity is knocking in the
form of UDAG participation in funding which may add affordable
housing to the City a goal which while stated has been
difficult to realize through previous efforts. If successful,
the project will return millions of dollars to the City at the
end of its fifteen year financing cycle.
On the other hand, to achieve that goal will require expenditure
of unprogrammed funds and detract from other community
priorities. It will place unusual demands upon the City in terms
of acquisition and development and provision of services. It may
have adverse land use and associated neighborhood impacts.
While some other approaches to increasing the stock of affordable
housing for families have not progressed, the single family lot
alternative to the Homestead program is being pursued by others
nearby. A strategy for in-fill, vacant lot development, has not
been pursued.
Considering all the factors known to the Planning'Department, it
appears prudent not to proceed with the alternative action (RH
designation) which would guarantee development of the property
with a unit count of 368. Proceeding with a designation of RM
would allow the project to have site specific analysis once the
zoning is affixed and a formal site plan submittal is made.
However, such an action does not accommodate the project
proponents need to have a guaranteed unit count of 368. In fact,
based upon the indicated demands upon the City it would appear
that, if the RM route were taken, we may be hard pressed to make
findings to allow a unit account above the base of 260.
An unknown factor at this point in time is that of community
opinion. If testimony at the public hearing reflects opposition
or serious concern or is generally lacking it is recommended that
a recommendation be forwarded that the land use map not be
amended and that consideration be given to resurrecting the
single family alternative to the Homestead program and in-fill
strategies in order to provide affordable housing for Delray
Beach residents. If there is overwhelming support for the
project, it, is recommended that the RH designation be applied
thus putting to rest any future second-guessing about proceeding
with the resulting development.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
The Director of Planning and Zoning recommends taking a position
of either going completely for (the RH designation) or rejecting
the matter before the Board. A middle ground (RM) is not
recommended since it does not provide the firm decision which the
project proponent feels is necessary in order to make additional
commitments to the project. The decision as to which position to
take would be dependent upon community comment at the hearing.
REF/DJK#14/B:LUPHOUSE.TXT
- 11 -
l
.~.. ...re,,';'. '
,.,'." I~':ili"'''':-l
"to.... .?~~~:.\;~~~ \0'
MF'15
-
R
PCC
-P~altC\
Mr-
15
MF.l5
1F.IO
ljEL~A! _ :&;A<;~: .,',
.... :S~~ .
. .
- - -..<(
,'I "'-:
~'
BLVD.
POI
( \ ~8 '-r )
.
I
I
C ,,'c Cl ;, ~ i,,, to\ l h, 1"1 "p
,
-" "
t')-e s \ ~Y~"'h crnJ
\
1
~ ~'-~~-~~: "::' .;-~;;}r~::rf~-~..-
..MF~: ItKb" ,
'i .'.. :01-' rUiI:'
,
,.... 'F"ll.:!.::.{'.t.
: .._~ I. ., .,~:,
;'.' ....,.." ", . p
, :dMFHi .
,. . ~' , ~~
~r:.'
.'~ i
tJt\~~:;-
!~~~
~: :;:
",Ii'
. 'r '
", ,
J J,I;i,
..,
..t,
"
w
>
0<(
!'. .
., .
. .. ..
~, ,
, , I
'.
.. . '.-
'It' ...., ,
, I R
. . "0
~ ~
!. ,.
~:~~:.~
,/:,.,.
P
.'
. ."-: ~ ~
.' f .r',r.
"
.11, "\'\:1,",
,
I C ~ .
9 :. 4 ~)
i..III....' !'<',
. ..
i+'T::-U-r.~-_ ~.
.,.:4;;:'~ M~
f-.....
l"t
N~tJ\
I: ~
.~ 4J
:1 h.
'I
~
~
I
'SE: .,
. ''''\
,: - "', It,,~lf' '
P
~ '.
"".
. '. - . '.t..
':':R"!Ei.rO"Ii-~',: ~("
. ''V ": ~';
., ,
j5f (;, ~.t
MF.IS
~,~
-.,' ..
P,..
.. .
.:... ..
, ,~.. ....
. d .
.~,./ '';.i..- ....~ ',' ~
piAilK - "'::: '.I'd. _.
. . _ ." -, "'..J" .......~.
. .!Io\; ~ ,x;;.S, .l~i',..~" ,.
'.;..~ ::ti'\"'~~~~i:~;;r~... t:t"t'.',
.... 1'!'tj;;'H/ 11'1>'~ '.. ~ ,_. -.. _
.' ..." ;W;-:-l~ :~.:::~.._ ~~::.~.':.,,::,.,~~,~~
..... .. . -- -.... '~-~........-_....-
':.-1j ~~~~;~'. ~4r~~:'1~'f"I.:;--
~~ <L_\.::~_~ ~~~. ~
c
~l.; ~
10
'H. 'iT'--
"
CF
....
',..:;j
~01"ts1::'T
, ('AR'"
~ ! ".. c~.
c(
I
I
I ~
"
r;.J.~
'.........4.\
.
MF-15
ART "
rt
-;',.j~.: H't,.
.'SF
""';'':'
'"
..
~-
cJ
.+::
\()
a,
'" . . :l
. -.- .
. ..... .-'.'
,
---
I
I '17~ L""ct L\"",I\ \\\"\'
DC?s "L~\u-+\ tR\\
\
s 0
I,
I'
~'
M
MF.IO
,
I
~ '
"
'" .
......r
..
-.
.......
_ .._....,.. J '--~ ~ __
...........-......-..-
,.
.. . _ '. ..J
,
'.
..,.,
u
, I
I
I I
I
.. -,
MF.IS I
,
I
I
'.
P i I
,/
,
t
.,
.,
.
,
j;:j .
I
.1
:z
lD
-..-~~Pi; '-- ~
.- 7\?t,}tCT
\
.."!".
.
'''I
,I
; ~
'"',
~, .tli
1
. ,
.1, I.i.J
~ :11 "-
~: ~
F ~;
I I
I P
I
I
I ~
Iii
I
*
,
"
,
"
, '
I; ,"
1'0'
,
)!
'0
.'..0
'0
~
w
~
o
J:
h''''J-'' .
1:1" -U
ij::;i ;" ..J' ~
~I .' -;)"'!'
1'1
1;-;; oJ...-!!!
.MF.J5
~. '" ..-. .....
.
S 173.887
IlEUU IIIIIIaI
his representative has waived the 6O-d-r
period .
('80 Code, S 30-23(8)) (Ord.. passed
4-1-80, Am. Ord. 28-84, passed
4-24-84, Am. Ord. 138-85, passed 12-17-85)
S 173.887 LIMITATIONS ON TIlE REZONING OF
PROPERTY.
(A) Whenever the Commission has
denied an application for the rezoning of
property, the Commission shall not
thereafter:
(1) Consider any further
application for the same rezoning of any
part or all of the same property for a
period of 12 months from the date of such
action.
(2) Consider an application for
any other kind of rezoning on any part or
all of the same property for a period of
six months fram the date of such action.
(8) The time limits of division (A)
above may be waf ved by three affirmative
votes of the Commission when such action
is found and deemed necessary to prevent
injustice or to facilitate the proper
development of the city.
('80 Code,S 30-23(C)) COrd., passed
4-1-80)
5 173.888 STANDARDS FOR EVALUATING
REZONING REQUESTS.
In considering an application for
rezoning, the Planning and Zoning Board
and the Commission shall make written
findings indicating that the proposed
change has been studied and considered in
relation to the fallowing standards,
where applicable:
CA) Will the change be contrary to
the proposed land use plan, and have an
adverse effect on the plan?
(8) Will the change be contrary to
the existing land use pattern?
CC) Will the change create an
isolated district unrelated to adjacent
and nearby districts. That is, is this
spot zoning?
(0) Will the change alter the
population density pattern, thereby
increasing the load on public facilities
such as schools, utilities, streets, and
the like?
(E) Are the present district
boundaries illogically drawn in relation
to the existing condition on the property
proposed for change?
(F) Have changed or changing
conditions made this proposed rezoning
necessary?
ZONING CODE
190
(G) Will the change adversely
influence living conditions in the
neighborhood?
e
(8) Will the change create or
excessively increase traffic congestion
or otherwise affect pUblic safety?
(I) Will the change create a
drainage problem?
(J) Will the change seriously reduce
light and air to adjacent areas?
(K) Will the Change adversely affect
property values in the adjacent area?
(t) Will the change be a deterrent
to the improvement or development of
adjacent property in accord with existing
regulations?
(M) Will the change constitute a
grant of special privilege to an
individual owner as contrasted with the
public welfare?
(N) Are there substantial reasons
why the property cannot be used in accord
with existing zoning?
(0) Is the change out of scale wi th
the needs of the neighborhood or the city?
e
(P)
adequa te
proposed
allowing
Is it impossible to find other
sites in the city for the
use in zoning districts already
such use?
(Q) Has sufficient evidence been
presented to justify the need for the
change?
('80 Code,S 30-23(0)) (Ord.. passed
4-1-80)
5 173.889 CONTENTS OF REZONING
APPLICATION.
Applications for rezoning shall
contain the following items:
(A) A general application form.
(S) A statement of the applicant's
interest in the property to be rezoned,
including a copy of the last recorded
warranty deed, and a certificate fram an
attorney-at-law or a title insurance
company certifying who the current fee
simple title holders of record of the
subject property are. and the nature and
extent of their interest therein, and
(1) If jOint and several
ownership, a written consent to the
rezoning proposal by all owners of
record, or
(2) If a contract purchase, a
copy of the purchase contract and written
consent of the seller/owner, or
e
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
C-~ER O. B~Y, CITY MANAGER
Q,- ;-.( J lie l cic(/
DAVID J. ~~v~(, DIR~
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM
PUBLIC HEARING RE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION WITH CITY ZONING
OF G.C. AND R.M. FOR THE ENTERPRISE LEASING ANNEXATION
(SOUTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY) FIRST READING ORDINANCE 81-88
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval on first reading of the enacting ordinance for
this annexation and zoning on approximately .7 acres
with zoning of RM zoning on Lot 14 and GC zoning on the
portion of the property which currently encompasses the
Enterprise Leasing business operation.
Subsequent action will include second reading of the
ordinance.
BACKGROUND:
This item has been before the City Commission when it was first
referred from the Planning and Zoning Board. Concerns were
raised at that time about the appropriateness of commercial
zoning on Lot 14 which is not a part of the currently developed
portion of the Enterprise Leasing operations.
At a subsequent workshop, the consensus of the Commission was to
proceed with two zoning designations. The agent desired to
proceed with the singular zoning designation of commercial. At
the next City Commission meeting, the agent sought a deferral of
action (which would have been to deny) so that he could further
converse with his client.
Later, the agent notified the Director of Planning and Zoning
that the owner was receptive of the split zoning approach and
asked that the processing resume. Thus, the enacting ordinance
was prepared and the hearing duly noticed.
I I
l
.
To: Walter C Barry, City Manager
Re: Public Hearing Re Voluntary Annexation With City Zoning
Of G.C. And R.M. For The Enterprise Leasing Annexation
(South Federal Highway) First Reading Ordinance 81-88
Page 2
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, approval of Ordinance 81-88 on First Reading, based
upon findings that the annexation is consistent with provisions
of Florida Statutes and an enclave is not being created.
Reference material:
Planning and Zoning Board staff reports provided previously,
Ordinance # 81-88 provided by the City Clerk
REF/DJK#26/CCENTER.TXT
.
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
CJR O. BARRY, CITY MANAGER
C\J--J( J ~ (Jof)
DAVID J. KOVACS, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT:
MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM
PUBLIC HEARING RE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE ZONING
CODE THROUGH A TOTAL REVISION OF THE P.C.C. ZONE
DISTRICT; FIRST READING OF ORDINANCE 82-88
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval on first reading of the enacting ordinance for
proposed amendments to the PCC Zone District
regulations.
Subsequent action will include second reading of the
ordinance.
BACKGROUND:
This item was initiated by the Planning and Zoning Board upon
request of Cedarwood Companies, developers of Delray Park of
Commerce.
The revised text was developed through the combined efforts of
Cedarwood representatives and the City's Planning Staff. A
representative of Congress Park PCC was involved in the later
stages of the review and it was discovered that Congress Park
South cannot comply with existing regulations let alone the
proposed revisions. Thus, the best way to handle Congress Park
is for them to seek SAD zoning with the PCC district regulations
which applied in 1982 being its development regulations.
The Congress Park matter aside, there is no reason not to proceed
with the proposed text amendment. The Planning and Zoning Board
reviewed the proposal on several occassions and following a duly
noticed public hearing has forwarded the item with a
recommendation of approval.
1'2--
.
...
To:
...<e:
Walter O. Barry, City Manager
Public Hearing Re Proposed Amendments To
Through A Total Revision Of The PCC Zone
First Hearing of Ordinance 82-88
Page 2
,
The Zoning Code
District,
Please refer to the previously provided Planning and Zoning staff
reports for detailed background and analysis. There are several
aspects to the revisions and it is not possible to offer a
capsual summary. If the Commission desires a thorough briefing
on the topic, I suggested that the ordinance be approved on first
reading and a work session scheduled prior to second reading.
One hour of work session time should be setaside if a full
briefing is desired. Otherwise, I suggest that individual
members contact staff with their questions.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, approval of Ordinance 82-88 on First Reading, pursuant
to the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Board.
Reference material:
Planning and Zoning Board staff reports provided previously,
Ordinance # 82-88 provided by the City Clerk
REF/DJK#23/CCPCC.TXT
1
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
~~R O. BARRY, CITY MANAGER
~-k.j~~'V~\j '~I_'C' ~
DAVID J. KOVACS, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM
CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCE 81-87. HOLD-OVER ORDINANCE
RE DEFINITION OF FAMILY
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Disposition of Ordinance 81-87
BACKGROUND:
Ordinance 81-87 was before the City Commission last year. The
ordinance was considered at a public hearing and has received
approval on first reading. Second reading has been deferred as
an action of "tabling" oCCurred.
Now that the City Commission has pursued the subject matter of
this ordinance through other legislation (Ordinance 91-88), it is
appropriate to disposed of Ordinance 81-87.
The procedure for so doing is outlined under the "recommended
action" .
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion,
1st remove Ordinance 81-87 from the table.
2nd by motion, deny Ordinance 81-87.
REF/DJK#23/CCORD81.TXT
'+4-
.
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
cjTER O. BARRY, CITY MANAGER
~ \\ (UJ/{ J ~\0( / .
D J. KOVAb~, DHECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEMS
CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCE 77-88, REZONING FROM RM-10
TO SAD AND CONSIDERATION OF THE SITE AND DEVELOPMENT
PLAN FOR THE PROPOSED GULFSTREAM MOTOR LODGE
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
First, approval of the site and development plan for
the proposed Gulfstream Motor Lodge to be located at
the southwest corner of Federal Highway and S.W. 10th
Street.
Second, approval on second reading of Ordinance 77-88
which is a rezoning ordinance (RM-lO to SAD). The site
and development plan referenced in the first action
becomes, by reference, a part of Ordinance 77-88.
BACKGROUND:
When the rezoning action associated with this proposed project
was before the City Commission it was desired that SAD, instead
of GC, zoning be applied to the property. The applicant amended
his petition accordingly and an enacting ordinance was approved
on first reading. Prior to second reading it is necessary to
first act on the associated site plan. Thus, the site plan
consideration precedes second reading of the enacting ordinance.
The site and development plan has sUbsequently been processed and
has been acted upon by the Planning and Zoning Board. Attached
is the Board's staff report which provides full background and
analysis.
tf-9
To: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
Re: Consideration Of Ordinance 77-88, Rezoning from RM-10
To SAD And Consideration Of The Site And Development
Plan For The Proposed Gulfstream Motor Lodge
Page 2
Planning and Zoning Board Recommendation: At its meeting of
July 18, 1988, the Board reviewed the site plan and forwarded it
with a recommendation of approval subject to conditions along
with a recommendation that "Administrative Relief" be granted for
compact car spaces pursuant to the site plan. The conditions of
approval are as presented in the attached staff report on pages 9
and 10.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion,
1st .... granting of Administrative Relief for the use of
compact parking spaces and approval of the site and development
plan for the proposed Gulfstream Motor Lodge pursuant to the
findings and conditions of the Planning and Zoning Board.
and, 2nd .... approval of Ordinance 77-88 on second and final
reading.
Attachments:
P & Z Staff Report of July 18th, Item III.A
Ordinance 77-88, separate packet
REF/DJK#23/CCGULFS.TXT
/
.
PLANNING B ZONING
CITY OF OELRRY
BOARD
BEACH
STAFF REPORT.
MEETING DATE:
JULY 18, 1988
AGENDA ITEM:
Jll:.4.
ITEM:
CONSIDERATION OF CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A HOTEL AND SITE PLAN APPROVAL
FOR TRIZAX FINANCIAl. CORPORATION ON THE SOIIT1NF.ST CORNF.R OF S E. 5TH AVE.
AND S.E. 10TH ST.
3ENERAL
DRTR:
0Wner...........................~ ...ift98 ... LoaD
....aocl.t1_
COD~ract Purcha..r..............!Tl.at Financial ~r.tiOD
(W1111_ C. Field)
Aqeat..................... ......L&rrr N. IebM1cIer
CUrrie, SOtuMllc1u' UId Aaeoclu..
AIA, PA
LocatiOD........................SOU~t ~ ~ 12. 5th Ave.
ad D. IOu It.
Pr~rty .1.....................Z.017 ~ (10,.12... ft.)
Cley c.ad u.. .1............... ..__10 (Ia&1Up1e r.-ll' ..
10 \&ILlu/..:nJ
Idou.v City _............_10 1I0.1Up1e '_11'
"'WeaUa1J
I.. Tt Laad u.. .lu..........C C&...ral&1) UIf w.xau)
I.. II ZoaiDg.................UD (1,.01.1 AcUntJ... DlatdctJ
CAlI . UIIporUJ' ~ &ODII
UIltJ.l t.blI "80ft ~u. Dlnd"
b 111 plaoe.
(III .......,
Adjaoebt &oa1Dr.................~ of .wbj~ ~~ 1.
aOMd. a..u.ca1Dg1e "_111') U4 ac:
(Spocl.allHd -.a!&ll. lout!>
J.8 10Md &AD. laIC 1.8 aOMd. Ie
and ....t 18 .... ~ ..
C".1dutid 1111I -'1ty,.
IZl.t1Dg Laad U.................VacaD~ 1aa4
P1 .. ... Laad U..................A " ~ hotel
W.ter ..n1oe...................b1.8c:1D9 vater ~ located OIl
the DOrtb aide ot '.1. 10~ .~..
a10ag vlUl -.1A ....1ou to
prcw1de adequate wter flow lot:
Un h,.sruta.
.....1' ..nice...................b1.tlav irI'.Yl~ IIaaltaq..wr
located OIl tbre eou.tIl a1de of ....
lOt.ll St.
ITEM:
ill ^.
1
.
ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD:
The item before the Board is that of making a recommendation on a
conditional use and attendant site plan, to allow the development of
a ninety-seven (97) room hotel, with accessory meeting rooms,
lounge and restaurant designed around a central courtyard located at
the southwest corner of Southbound Federal Highway (S.E. 5th Avenue)
and S.E. 10th Street.
BACKGROUND:
A land Use Plan Amendment from MFlO to Commercial and concurrent
rezoning from RM-10 to GC (General Commercial) was heard by the
Planning and Zoning Board at the Regular/Public Hearing Meeting of
June 20, 1988, and a unanimous recommendation of approval was
forwarded to the City Commission.
At the City commission meeting held on June 28, 1988, the City
Commission accepted the Board's recommendation regarding the Land
Use Map Amendment from MF-lO to Commercial, but questioned the
Planning and Zoning Board's recommendation to rezone to GC General
Commercial. The City Commission then directed that the SAD Special
Activities District zoning designation be applied as a temPOrary
zoning category until the proposed "Resort-Tourism" District is in
place. Public Hearings on the Land Use Amendment and the SAD zoning
ordinance will be held on July 12, 1988.
Refer to the rezoning Staff Report for additional background.
PROJECT ANALYSIS:
The site plan was initially designed to comply with the General
Commercial District regulations, however, with the proposed rezoning
to the Special Activities District and subsequent Resort-Tourism
District, the following analysis includes assessment in accordance
with Section 173.848 Conditional Use Standards; Section 173.867
Site and Development Criteria, as well as the Special Regulations
for Hotels Section 173.070; the Special Activities Districts
Section173. 630; and the proposed "Resort-Tourism" District (draft
#1) .
Pursuant to Code Section173. 001 , this use is consistent with the
current definition of 'Hotel" in that the proposed development
contains more than 10 sleeping rooms for transient guests with
no provisions made for cooking in the individual rooms, along
with accessory uses such as meeting rooms, lounges and
restaurants. However, with the provision of concrete walkways
- 1 -
I
To: Planning ant oning Board
Re: Gulfstream Motorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Sice Plan
~
on the southern and eastern sides" the bUilding from the adjacent
driveway areas to the main structure which provide access (not via
the inner lobby) to the sleeping rooms, the development will not
meet the proposed definition of "Hotel". It does, however, comply
with the proposed definition of "Motel" which is proposed to be
allowed as a conditional use in the Resort-Tourism District.
Review of the site plan pursuant to the proposed Resort-Tourism
District results in a potential code violation in that the
proposed minimum ten (10) foot interior perimeter landscape
requirement is not met, as only five (5) feet is provided. The
five foot standard is consistent with present landscape codes.
Dedication of additional right-of-way in accordance with the
County Thoroughfare Plan which requires a 40 foot half section
right-of-way for S.E. 10th Street, is provided for. This
dedication shall formally be accommodated in the platting
process.
STANDARDS FOR EVALUATING A CONDITIONAL USE
Standard # 1 (ingress & egress):
The development of the site proposes two twenty-four (24) foot
curb-cuts, one along S.E. 10th street and the other along
Federal Highway (southbound). Traffic flow at the Federal
Highway entrance will be limited to right turns only, Le.
right-in/right-out turns, because the one way pair for Federal
Highway exists in this location. However, right and left
turning movements in and out of the site, at the S.E. 10th
Street entrance will be accommodated.
On site, a continuous traffic circulation pattern encircling
the main structure is proposed, with the driveway adjacent to
the building; and parking spaces separated from the building by
the driveway. This arrangement forces all pedestrians to cross
the driveway in order to enter the building. Flip-flopping of
the parking and driveway areas would result in a deficiency of
parking spaces. The provision of pedestrian cross-walks in
selected locations would provide an acceptable solution thus
providing some pedestrian safety and convenience.
Standard #2 (parking and loading areas):
Ninety-five (95) parking spaces, as required by Code
have been provided on site. Also, per Section l73.773(E) two
(2) handicap parking spaces are provided. These
spaces flank the main entrance area and provide easy
- 2 -
l
To: Planning an~ Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstream tor lodge , Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
accessibility to the lobby. Categorizing the type of parking
spaces provided on site reveals that 76.8% or 73 spaces are
standard spaces with dimensions of 9 by 18 feet; 21% or 20
spaces are, 8 by 16 foot, compact spaces; and 2.1% or 2 spaces
are handicap spaces. The applicant has submitted a request
pursuant to Code Section 173.775(B)(4) for Administrative
Relief to allow the use of compact car parking spaces for long
term employee parking. Pursuant to the Code... the Board must
make findings in accordance with Section l73.775(A)(4) as
follows:
1.
The relief sought is
prov~s~ons applicable to
Section l73.775(B)
consistent with
the request as
the
set
specific
forth at
2. The intent of the parking code is preserved
3. The parking provided will be sufficient to serve the use
for which it is intended.
4. The relief sought will not be detrimental to the public
health/welfare or safety.
Re: Criteria U
Code Section 173.775(B)(4) states" Administrative Relief may
be approved in accordance with Section l73.771(F) to allow the
use of compact car parking spaces for long term employee
parking. In order to apply for such relief, a site plan shall
be submitted showing the location and number of the proposed
compact car spaces".
Section 173.77l(F) states: "When approved in accordance with
the provisions of Section 173.775 "Administrative Relief", uses
which provided long term parking, i.e., a parking lot or
facility that is intended to be used primarily by on-site
employees, may be permitted to provide compact car parking
spaces up to thirty percent (30%) of the total parking
requirement".
Thirty percent (30%) of the total parking spaces
spaces, as only 20 compact spaces are proposed.
is in keeping with provisions mentioned above.
equates to 28
This request
Re: Criteria #2:
The intent of the parking code is to allow compact parking
spaces for "long-term parking" or employee parking. Since this
use triggers a high employment demand (resources from the ITE
- 3 -
l
.
To: Planning an~ ooning Board
Re: Gulfstream i _or lodge , Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
manual indicate employee density ranges of 0.46 to 1.38
employee per room) the request to allow compact parking spaces
meets the intent of the Code. However, any approval should be
based on compliance with Section 173.772(C)(5) "markings and
signing" and with the additional requirement that the wheel
stops be marked for employee use only.
Re: Criteria #3
This request does not reduce the number of required spaces,
only the size of the parking spaces are reduced.
Re: Criteria #4:
The location
abnormality
established.
of the compact parking spaces does not create any
with the circulation and parking pattern
Upon consideration, the Board must make a specific
recommendation to the City Commission on this request.
Pursuant to Section 173.791 two (2) loading berths are required. A
service area is delineated on the site plan with specific detail
indicated on an attached floor plan. The loading berths are located
in a manner which creates conflicts with the adjacent twenty-four
(24) driveway as the berths encroach upon eight (a) feet of the
driveway. This conflict will have to be accommodated through
redesign.
Standard #3 (refuse and service area):
An adequate refuse and service area has been provided on site.
Standard #4 (utilities):
Water: An existing 6 inch water main runs along the north edge of
the S.E. 10th Street right-of-way. This water main dead ends south
of Lot 10, Block a, Rio Rey Shores ( just short of the S.E. 5th
Avenue right-of-way). Also a 2' service line runs along the
west right-of-way of Federal Highway (southbound) extending
from the Acquilano site to the existing 6" main mentioned
above. The applicant proposes to connect to the 6" water main via a
6" service line. However, this arrangement is not sufficient for
fire suppression and was rejected by the Fire Department. ~n
additional fire hydrant was required and adequate water flow would
not be maintained on the existing 6 inch main as a looped water
system does not exist.
- 4 -
1
To: Planning,. Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstream Motorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
In order to resolve the fire suppression deficiency two
options were communicated to the applicant:
a) obtain off-site easements to connect to the 6" water
main located at the east side of Park Place and extend
such main to the existing 6" main at S.E. 10th Street,
thus looping the system.
b) Extend the 6" main to connect to the existing 12" water
main located along the east side of northbound Federal
Highway.
The applicant sUbsequently revised the plans and now shows an
extension of an 8" main along the eastern frontage of the
property to the southern property line. This extension will
require jack and boring both Highways. The additional hydrant
is placed at the southern extremity of this main. However,
inorder to maintain adequate fire flow, extending the existing
6" main to connect to the proposed 8" main will be required.
Sewer: Sewer service is available from a 10 inch sewer main
which runs along the southern area of the S.E. 10th Street
right-of-way. The applicant is proposing to connect to the
existing lines via a service line.
Standard #5 (screens and buffers):
Plant materials in the combination of trees, hedges and shrubs
are propo~d to meet the screening and buffering requirements.
This site?,"ha:; arterials to the north and east, and residential
zoning to the west all of which trigger special
landscape/buffer requirements.
Along Federal Highway a twenty foot (20) landscape buffer
has been provided. However, wi thin this landscape
area a utility easement occupies the eastern fifteen (15) feet,
thus requiring all trees, hedges and shrubs to be planted
within the western (rear) five (5) feet. This proposal has
been reviewed by the City Horticulturist and has been found to
be acceptable.
Along S.E. 10th Street a ten (10) foot landscape strip has been
provided from the ultimate right-of-way, thus future
dedications will not reduce this buffer area.
Along the western perimeter, a wall six (6) feet high or a
continuous hedge four and one half feet (4 1/2) at the time of
installation is required to meet the district boundary
regulations pursuant to Code Section 173.036 (A). In addition,
the landscape code, Section 159.30, requires trees to be
planted 25 foot on center. The site plans show a continuous
- 5 -
.
To: planning a ' Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstream .otorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
hedge 2' at the time of installation and trees spaced
approximately 40 foot on center. Additional trees along with
the installation of 4 1/2 foot hedging is required to meet code
standards.
As previously mentioned
requirement does not meet
regulations.
the interior perimeter landscape
the proposed Resort-Tourism District
Standard #6 (signs and lighting):
The site plan indicates the location of one free standing
business sign, however no additional details such as height,
materials and lettering are provided. Only referencing the
location of the sign is necessary on the site plan as the
function of a site plan as it relates to signage, pertains
primarily to site distance requirements.
Lighting is provided for the parking areas. Lighting will be
sharp cut-off luminaries (Le. confirmed on site) mounted on
twenty (20) foot poles.
Standard # 7 (setbacks and open space):
All building setback requirements are met. Also the prov~s~on
of a 10,296 sq.ft. central courtyard meets the proposed
Resort-Tourism District regulations where a minimum of 10 % of
the lot area shall be open space.
Standard # 8 (compatibility):
This development is consistent with the surrounding commercial
uses to the south and north, and reasonably compatible with the
potential of high density residential development to the west.
Two vacant, single family lots, are located to the northwest
but these lots are separated by S.E. 10th Street, an arterial.
Standard # 9 (height):
The building height of 35 feet is consistent with code
requirements.
Standard # 10 (economic effects on adjacent properties):
This petition will have little economic effect on adjacent
properties as the area is commercial in nature, and the
development is somewhat similar to a high density residential
development. Therefore the proposal should not have adverse
impacts on value and development on adjacent properties.
- 6 -
To: planning a-' Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstrean 0torlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
SITE PLAN ANALYSIS:
The site plan has been reviewed using criteria outlined in
Section "Standards for Evaluating Site and Development Plan
Application".
Standard *1 (sufficiency of material):
This standard has been met with this submission.
Standard * 2 (impact of proposed use):
As the proposal fronts on two arterials (Federal Highway & S.E.
10th Street) a commercial area in nature, and the development
proposed is similar to high density residential, this proposal
should not adversely impact conditions in adjacent
neighborhoods. All traffic will utilize the arterial street
system and all parking, loading, and drainage will be
maintained internal to the site.
Standard * 3 (ingress and egress); and Standard * 4 (off-street
parking and loading areas):
These standards are dealt with under Standards 3 and 4 of the
Conditional Use Standards
Standard * 5 (screens and buffers):
This condition is addressed under Standard *5 of the
Conditional Use Standards.
Standard * 6 (drainage):
No adverse situations regarding the treatment of containing
drainage on site is apparent. Conceptual drainage plans have
been submitted. Additional drainage calculations and
topographic information will be required as part of the
platting process.
Standard * 7 (sanitary sewers) and Standard * 8 (utilities):
These standards are addressed under Standard * 4 of the
Conditional Use Standards.
Standard * 9 (recreation and open space):
These standards are met. See discussion under Conditional Use
Standard * 7.
- 7 -
To: Planning 1 zoning Board
Re: Gulfstrear.. .1otorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
standard * 10 (site development):
This criteria's
general layout
harmonious with
whole.
intent is to assure that the appearance and
of the development will be compatible and
adjacent properties, as well as the City as a
The Communi ty Appearance Board reviewed the pro j ect on June 29,
1988, and approved the plans in concept, subject to the applicant
providing detailed landscaping plans.
Technical Review:
The applicant has addressed most of the staff initial comments
in the revised site plan submittal, however the following
outstanding comments needs to be addressed.
1. Provide calculations for interior greenspace requirements
to substantiate that an area equal to 10% of the total
paved area is in interior greenspace.
2. On the site plan indicate that a five (5) foot sidewalk
will extend from U.S. Highway No.1 to the western edge of
the property. Such sidewalk shall be located adjacent to
the ultimate right-of-way line.
3. Provide a planting plan for the courtyard area.
Other Items:
The Engineering Department is requiring platting prior to the
issuance of any building permit. The plat will combine the two
parcels and provide right-of-way dedications for S.E. 10th Street.
A traffic study has been required. This study is to focus upon
turning movements in and out of the site and upon adequacy of the
s.w. 10th - Federal intersection. Recommended improvements will be
required as part of the platting process.
ASSESSMENT:
The project is quite straight forward. The applicant has worked
well with various departments and Boards in resolving initial
differences. Remaining design items are relatively minor and can be
handled as conditions of approval.
- 8 -
l
.
To: Planning a . Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstream .otorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
ALTERNATIVE ACTION:
1.
Continue, with direction,
applicant.
and with concurrence of the
2. Recommend approval of the site plan and conditional use and the
accompanying request for Administrative Relief.
3. Recommend denial of the site plan and conditional use with
reasons stated.
RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend approval of the site plan and conditional use request
subject to the following:
1.
That Administrative Relief be granted to allow
parking spaces to be designed as compact car
designated exclusively for long-term employee use.
That a plat be approved and recorded prior to the issuance
any building permit. Such plat shall accommodate
appropriate right-of-way dedications on S.E. 10th Street
shall contain water, sewer, and street improvement plans.
twenty
spaces
(20)
and
2 .
of
the
and
3. That a detailed landscape plan, including a planting plan for
the courtyard, be submitted and approved by the Community
Appearance Board prior to the issuance of any building permits.
4. That this approval be valid, pursuant to Code Section 173.849
and Section 173.868 for eighteen (18) months.
5. That the site plan be revised addressing the following items
which have been described in the Staff Report:
a) Calculations for interior greenspace requirements to
substantiate that an area equal to 10% of the total paved
area is in interior greenspace.
b) A five (5) foot sidewalk extending from u.S. Highway No.1
to the western edge of the property adjacent to the
ultimate right-of- way line.
c) The loading area be redesigned to accomodate two 12 by 30
foot loading berths whilst maintaining clear access for
the adjacent 24 foot driveway.
- 9 -
To: Planning L ~ Zoning Board
Re: Gulfstream Motorlodge, Ltd.
Conditional Use and Site Plan
d) The prov~s~on of two additional trees along the western
boundary in order to maintain maximum tree spacing of
twenty-five (25) foot on center.
e) A four and one-half (4 1/2) foot hedge be provided at the
time of installation along the western property line.
f) Pedestrian crosswalks across the 24 foot driveway
coinciding with access points to the building.
REF/DJK*23/B:MOTORL.TXT
- 10 -
,
.
:!
1---
il
c ~-::t~7 '
.u.. l...,f;}., ~ ___ __ ._
Is
I
~.
I
r.
I
<i
I
~...,. I ....
I
I
/0
I ,
,-:
_ ~ 1
;1
~~
- -~ati smEiE'f--
-----; -
..,. '.'
~ ".'
.ll6l"CPl'
I
~,
'" '
-~ \
. -. ~ '
Itf;
.. ,
~
-....
~_.....JIL..___. I
-"''-.....~~~ '::-"'~..L ___~L_
., ._.~...- .~... - Ii
.
--------J----
.' _00.... M7~ ,,'-VW)
- -- ---
F
I-r
,
,
<l>i
t ." #I ...,
.
'\
-.
e
" ~
,
,
~,
I
-,I
:1
.
--.--.---
/
:'
"
~
-....
i"'~
.;:- ~-<,
'--~I- ~ - )
. . ,
\ '; _/'
o-t._~. t .--
"' ::~, ",;.1\'
Fl ;-d-~ . - ~-
.-- "1,' ......
./ ~-;-::. .
/ ~1 ~:~
-~
\.
~
_.Cl>
"".0'
~-
.,4 _____.
,
I,
J"
'~
(
~
I
!
r
,
':/
.,
I
.~~-
,
.
,
.1
---
j-- ~
II
,
~
---
,t'd,
l "..1
~.. ; ~
-~.---~ -
-....... .......
,
,
\.lI,\ 00_._';"'_"']
L- --: ~. _
1_M"I.
7
,
.-
DEPART-1ENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
"_ ".,._........_._.....H. ._.n_....__ __ . ._.,..._..__~_...._.
[ITY DF
DELRAY B,EA[H
~(i
TO
Walter O. Barry, City Manager
FROM ~~rCild___B. Chur~h,_ P. E. ,<;i_ty En9"-~l1e.er
._-..-=:-:-~:-:.-_~-=~:-..~-:.-.:- ~- .-.-,. -:.__':--"':'.-:::=-_-::-:=:- .:.__~._. __"_...__. ___n '~_:-::::'::::::::::-.~-': __,..
Dolphin pile Variance Request
Lot 169, Tropic Isle
SUBJECT.Re~eJ:e_~.ge _ ouE___~~IlI_'?_._6_:_1?~ 8~__.____________
7/19/88
DATE
As per your request we met the City Attorney to review Mr. Bacarella's
request for a variance to install a dolphin pile. After due consid-
eration the City Attorney concurred with our findings and recommenda-.
tion that the variance be approved.
GBC:slg
cc: City Attorney
~
~o
UI::t-'AHI MI::NTAL
CORREvrONDENCE
I,
CITY DF
DELAAY BEA[H
.
~Ci
TO Walter O. Barry, City Manager
)JAC-
,y-'Gerald B. Church, P.E., City Engineer
FROM
SUBJECT
Dolphin Pile Variance Request -
Lot 169, Tropic Isle
6/1S/B8
DATE
Mr. Max Hagen, attorney for Mr. and Mrs. Michael Bacare11a, has
requested, on behalf of his client, the subject variance re-
quest. As per Mr. Hagen's letter (copy attached), the request
is rather complex and involves a ~awsuit between the property
owner and an adjacent property owner.
Engineering recommends approval of the variance for the following
reasons:
1. It would be impossible to construct a dolphin pile at
this location and meet City code requirements.
2. It would not endanger public safety.
Both adjacent property owners object to the variance request
(see attached copies of letters). Also attached are an agenda re-
quest form for the item and a sketch of the proposed installation.
GBC: slg
CM 362
THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
rJUN 1 0 \9a~
LAW O"F'ICES
MAx M. HAGEN, P. A.
Or.
te15l53 'l'- E.IQ!!:! AVENUt;
NORTH MIAMI 8.EACH, "LOAIO", 331152
TEl.EPHONE (30!5) 940-0.513
PL..EASE REIl'. TO
OUR "'L.E .
June 7, 1988
2540-11
Gates D. Castle, P.E.
Assistant City Engineer
City of De1ray Beach
Delray Beach, Fla. 33444
Re: Lot 169, SECOND SECTION OF TROPIC ISLE, according
to the Plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 24, Page
246, of the Public Records of Palm Beach County,
Florida.
Request for variance for installation of Dolphin pole.
Dear Mr. Castle:
Please be advised that I represent Michael J. Bacarella and
Deborah Bacarella, his wife in connection with their request for
a variance to install a dolphin pole adjacent to their property
to dock their boat.
The purpose of the placement of the dolphin pole is to avoid any
technical encroachment of any riparian rights of either of the
adjoining property owners. When the boat is docked sideways
adjacent to my clients' property there may be a very minor
encroachment on one or the other adjoining property owner's
property depending upon the position in which the boat is moved,
forward or backwards.
My clients and the adjoining property owner, Mr. Anthony Coneff,
have been involved in certain litigation. Mr. Coneff complained
that the original position of the beet constituted a technical
encroachment of his riparian rights. We secured an engineering
survey and it showed a very minor encroachment on his vacant lot
adjacent to where my clients' property is located. Mr. Coneff
resides on the second lot not directly adjacent to my clients'
property but made a major fuss over his view of the canal being
obstructed by about a two foot portion of the rear of my clients'
boat. In order to avoid lengthy, time consuming and expensi"'ie
litigation my clients' voluntarily agreed to the entry of an
Agreed Stipulation with regard to the placement of the boat.
Mr. Coneff apparently has engaged the support of the adjoining
owner who has title to another piece of property and has created
a second possible objection to the placement of the boat now
being forward and thereby possibly making a similar technical
encroachment on the other adjoining landowner's property.
.~.
Our surveyors and engineers have determined that the application
for the placement of the dolphin pole will eliminate any
technical violation as to either adjoining landowner and that is
the reason why the request for the variance has been made.
It is obvious that the canal is used for pleasure boating
purposes and that is why my clients' and other similar owners
situated along that canal have purchased property in that area
and have docked their respective boats along the canal. The
sight of these boats is obviously a beautification rather than a
hinderance of the canal area. However, if somebody wants to
complain that a two foot view of the rear or front of a boat
constitutes an eye sore, then so be it. To my clients this type
of complaint constitutes a clear indication of harassment versus
an actual problem. My clients' boat is a 24' Sea Ray which is a
relatively small boat that does not create .any problem whatsoever
with regard to its use nor the right of ingress nor egress to any
other adjacent property owner and certainly does not disturb the
view of any owner residing on a waterway.
Since Mr. Coneff has created the problem by the filing of the
lawsuit and the entry of an agreed order, it now becomes
necessary for my clients to require the variance for the
placement of the dolphin pole, so that they may use their
waterfront property for the purposes for which it was intended.
We invite you or a member of your staff or any other interested
party to make a visual inspection of the area and the situation
that is involved and the only conclusion that can be drawn is
that some relief should be given to my clients under the
circumstances.
Please make the necessary arrangements to set this matter for an
appropriate hearing with notices to all parties concerned and we
will plead our case accordingly at that time.
Thank you for your attention and cooperation in connection with
this matter.
I
rr r4~tl" /
Jx~ HAGEN 0/
MMH: If
cc: Mr. and Mrs. Michael Bacarella
LAW O""ICES 0" MAX M. HAGEN, P. A.
11515153 N. E.IQ!!! AVIE.. NORTH MIAMI BEACH, "LORIO'" 33115Z
t
{
j
r
\00
o~
'v
t..
r
I.
f:
I
,
1..-
r
t
r.:
l.
['.
l'
i,
,
,
o '
104 3A AD
\\
nO
, "
I'
.n'}
s"
~
\ ~.
o
v
"
>
\ P "'- "'- \
"---
,"--- \
"---, \
,
" \
"" \
"--.\
ilPg
,
/0
/,0
e(.1
30 I,
(iC
\ O.f
V
....
-
I,
C~h'~~~L:
~5~./'~ W-/'.
d~~c7'L ? "
~~~,&/.&~/?
..~d /$t. ~~~/
6k ~, ~:~ ~~~.
~~C~~
, ~~-A~~4~ ~ ~~
.~~~~,?~~~.~~ ,.2{ ~~
~ S~~~~&.:~
~-~~~~ Ad~"'?3'~z
~#/7tJ.~.~~ft~&~
f!#ic ~ /,v' ~y /6'7~ - d- ?-X~
.?7U&U~ ~4c/~~ .
~~r~
:;~d ~r-' I
. V' ::..---c-:-.':'"'''
'~/7 ~.
~~O~~-:~
~
,
May 20, 1988
Gates D. Castle, P.E.
Assistant City Engineer
City of Delray Beach
Delray Beach, FL 33444
Re: Notification Regarding Variance Request
Lot 169, Tropic Isle
Dear Mr. Castle:
In further response to your letter of April 28, 1988, which I
received by certified mail on May 14, 1988, reference the above,
I wish to clearly state that I object to the proposed variance.
The proposed variance would allow the boat to be p1ac.d right in
my line of vision from my backyard and the boat would block my
view of the canal. Therefore, granting of the proposed variance
would result in loss of my enjoyment of my property, as well as
loss of marketability of the property.
Furthermore, I feel
matter and request
may attend.
there should be a public hearing on this
notice of any such public hearing so that I
,
Thank you for your kind cooperation.
Very truly,
~d76~
Anthony B. Coneff
ek
All tlwll.Y R. COlle ff
910 A11amanda Drive
De1ray Beach, Florida 33444
I
~
!1ay 19, 1988
Gates D. Castle, P.8.
AsSistallt City Engineer
City of De1ray Beach
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
De1ray Reach, Fl. 33444
Re: Notification regarding Variance request _
Lot 169, Tropic Isle
Dear Hr. Castle,'
Ill' response to YOllr letter dated April 28, 1988, which I
received by certified mail on May 14th, regarding the variance request
to install a do1!lh~l; pile for Lot 169, Tropic Isle, less thall the
code requirement of ~5', please be advised that the own~r of said
'Lot 169 is under a permanent injunction from encroachiug over my
riparian rights fronting Lots 167 and 168, which is adjacent to
the above mentioned Lot 169, said injunction is recorded in
Official Record Rook 5611, Page 850, iu the Public Records of Palm
Beach COlillty, Florida. III the past, I have met ~dth the owner of
Lot 169 and have had llurnerous verbal cornmitm~l'lts from him that he
would stop a110win& his boat to be parked within the area of the
canal behind my property, but, to this ~ate the owner of Lot 169 has
continued parking his boat behind my pronetty in Spite of tne Ibove
mentioned injunctioll, because of the above lack of ;,rillingness to
abidC;! by his' comr,Jitme,nts, I wish to express to you my objection to
the requested variance and feel the only solution is for the owner
of Lot 169 to remove his boat and place it in some available storage
-1-
-'-- "--"-
-.
lilarillil since.! th" ~lrc!a 1'.(; owns Hd.i,~c(.'l1t: tu his propvrty is t;co slnilll.
I
for tl1(~ size.!. hoat he' 0\"115.
I have il court datc on \~CdllCSrlcl'y. ~Iay 25th, ill which the
OWller of Lot l7l) illtellds to jOill llith ITlC ill an atter"Pt to havc the
boat removed fro':1 the area behi:ld Lot 169. I Cll1[1reciate your
letter nctifyiDi, ~,K! of the variance r.equest ant! will J)e 'l?pry to
i;,ive you the CI:tCOi.1C of tl,e above i,lentio:1ed court .illdg~'l1ellt
if lleedcc1.
Yours Truly,
~.~l~;t
AUC:HAG:skm
-2-
DEPAR""-\I1ENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
TO Walter o. Barry, City Manager
FROM rlcera1d
B. Church, P.E., Acting Director of Public
Works/City Engineer
[ITY OF
DELAAY BEA[H
~~(j
SUBJECT DOLPHIN PILE VARIANCE - LOT 427, TROPIC ISLE
DATE 7/15/B8
On April 18, 1988, Mrs. Nancy Siegel-Olmstead requested a variance to construct
dolphin piles in the waterway at a distance closer to property line than allowed
by the City Code of Ordinances. As is the normal procedure, the adjacent prop-
erty owners were notified of the variance request. Mr. Rubino, owner of Lot 426,
filed a written objection to the request. On June Bth, Engineering wrote Mrs.
Siegel-Olmstead recommending against the variance request, explaining the reason-
ing behind the recommendation and outlining the procedure for appealing Engineer-
ing's recommendation. ~"h
/f{rI'-""" ;;'Y/(..
Mrs. Siegel-Olmstead has a 90 foot lot along e Abaco Canal. ~he requests that
dolphin piles be located 10 feet and 20 feet ~ her property^rather than the
25 foot setback, as required by Code of Ordinances. In this situation, it is
possible to comply with the Code since the lot is wide enough. It is not con-
sidered a hardship on the basis that she intends to dock a 60 foot boat. Also
when dolphin piles are close to the neighboring lot, they may restrict boat
navigability for adjacent property owners. Considering these findings, the
Engineering department recommended against a variance. Note that this deter-
mination is consistent with other reviews and recommendations for similar con-
ditions, though some dolphin piles may exist in violation of present Code re-
quirement, either illegally installed without permit or were in place before
present Code requirement adopted.
Following the procedure, as outlined in Sec. 9-534 of the old Code, Mrs. Siege1-
Olmstead submitted a June 13th letter to your office requesting that the matter
be submitted to the Commission for action. Copies of the various pertinent
correspondence are attached for your reference, including a survey of Mrs.
Siege1-01mstead's property showing location of proposed dolphin piles and a
sketch of Engineering Department's standards for dock and dolphin piles.
The City Attorney concurs with our recommendation.
GBC:m1d
c: City Attorney
CM362 THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
t
7
;:
~
i
;:
f
t
~
~
!
,
;
i
;
,
..
,
1
I
l
1
~I
rnR..~,~ ~
~\~1t-1~
10-0 IJ. w. I ~ ftu--'C
~iO---- 33 VLf</
1 w-. trh f3/Wl- r ' .
~ a,CfcndttrU-c. ..kv-c.::/--. ~C'~ 9- s3S12i) k ~Z1"-<-~~
~ ~ffE<t-l_1~~, d'~~ 7~. ~ ~7I'K-/>e~~,
ifI-ev, ~.~ ~ e(e:~.,- wdI t6l-u-67{.. tKJ ?/4!7
.;t41-d-:Jlu~ ~ /b'l. OAt.. hv ~ yot~-1} ~~""r -0 6~--/
~r 6~t4~ a~d ft-, ~ ~ ~ A~/~
tH 7J:<. . .1~4C </- MJu-..~--b /~, ~ ~---.t1.-i2 /7, ./ ./l
. / p'" I..... ~~, 'J-C ~ (1'/ t<)-u.t..,-
ltIt-~ ~);(}<?t- .h-'\j /'lU",-j: JI- vk ./)u.-e-~ 6-
~ at ~a-d- 60 /. &/ ~-hk-,. t6 ~~"7\.; 7C
~ ~ ~~- aJ4, i! ~ * ~:I- r Ii;;;-
~~ ~ ae.;;I- tJ1(1~o ~ ~l~- c21ctZ._
i ~ J&ta.Ct<~. ~~ ~'- ~J
-!it'\. CL{f~ ~I ~/~thL0 .~e~'Yl 0t;.. ~tUkA1
1 jN. ~1'b 4'1 L lIa-tJ i71h ..<l~ r"'--
v~ . '--
~ ~_~~ fA ~~~ tA~
~vr"'t.. v~ a..~~-z~-.~ ~~df-c!i; 4-
~ ~~-e ~ ~ ..P1-rL(' ~vJ ~NI.
~uL-<-'()--.JI1A, It!. ~..c,.'07-'1; -!/,;JS/ L./~1-": 7;ed~c- J;t;:
~~~'~~d~k;F1
/jtJ-' / w .yo1;Z, 1R~t ./vtc_
, ~ ~ ~~ "
~~~v
THE OLIllTEADS
Ml JASIIUl! ..
DEWY lEACH.n IS4U
7.;
i~
!~
11
1::
i
>
f
I
~
,
,
4
,
7
~
$
JUN 3 i933
.,-
May 31, 1988
1503 Lake Drive
Dekay Beach, FL 33444
Mr. Gates D. Castle, P.E.
Assistant City Engineer
100 N.W. 1st Avenue
Dekay Beach, Florida 33444
Subject: Variance Request - Lot 427
Tropic Jsl.e
Dekay Beach
Dear Sir:
In answer to your letter dated May 26, 1988 on the above subject, please be
advised that we prefer that the city code be conformed to.
As we understand, the dolphin pilings must be a minimum of 25' from our
property.
Sincerely"
d~
Vincent Rubino
.
~
,
!
,
~
t
~
6
i
I
J
'. . 'flQrn .' .
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
. OELRAY BEACH, FLORID..:.. 3JJJ": . 305278-284
June 8, 1988
Mrs. Nancy Siegel-Olmstead
947 Jasmine Drive
Delray Beach, Florida 33483
Subject: Variance Request _
Dolphin Piles
Lot 427 - Tropic Isle
Dear Mrs. Siegel-Olmstead:
The Engineering Department has reviewed your request for the
subject variance. Since neither condition for granting a
variance is met in this instance (ie, it is feasible to meet
code requirements and it wouldn't constitute a hardship to
impose the code requirements), Engineering recommends against
the variance.
In accordance with Section 9-534 (b) (copy attached, you can
appeal this decision to the City Commission through the City
Manager's office.
If there are any questions, please contact this office.
Very tr.uly yours,
):J~ ~ c.~
Gates D. Castle, P.E.
Assistant City Engineer
GDC:ji
Attachment
cc: City Manager
I
.
.1
!
~
f
~
I
t
I
BUILDINGS AN,D CONSTRUCTION
5 9-535
Sec. 9.534. Modification of standards for approval; appeals.
(a) Upon the recommendation of the city engineer, the city council may authorize a modifi-
cation in the standards for approval as set forth in subsections 9-529(b), 9.529(c), 9-530(b),
9-53l(b) and 9-532(b), above, if it is determin.d that the requirements of said sUDsections would
not be feasible or would constitute hardship in a particular instance, and provided that such a
modification would not endanger public safety and welfare.
(b) Should the city engineer recommend against any request for modification of the stand-
ards for approval as set forth in subsections 9-529(b), 9-529(c), 9-530(b), 9-531(b) and 9.532(b),
above: the applicant shall have the right to appeal such decision of the city engineer to the city
council, by filing a written request to the city manager within ten (10) days after such decision of
the city engineer. The city council shalI conduct a hearing on such appeal at a regular or special
council meeting and shall render a decision within a reasonable time after such hearing. (Ord. No.
13-82, 5 1,2-23-82)
ARTICLE XVI. CONTRACTORS AND SPECULATIVE BUILDERS.
Sec. 9-535. DefiJiitioDB.
As used in this article:
Board or board of examiners, shall be construed and defined to mean the board of .
examiners of contractors herein provided for.
General contractor means any person who is engaged in the business of accepting
orders and/or contracts as a general contractor, with a person as an owner, for
compensation other than wages, by doing work on or in any building or structure, on
any private or public property, on any private or public street or right-of-way, on any
private or public waterway requiring the use of paint, stone, brick, mortar, cement,
wood, structural steel or iron, sheet iron, metallic pipe, tin, lead or any other bUilding
materials; or to do any paving or curbing on sidewalks or streets, or public or private
property, using asphalt, brick, stone, cement, wood or any other material, or any
combination thereof; or to excavate for foundations, or any other purpose, or to
construct bridges, construct seawalls and bulkheads of any and all descriptions, or who
is in the business of bUilding, remodeling, repairing, razing and demolishing or moving
any building or structure, who may do all the work himself or themselves except as
otherwise prescribed by law or who subcontracts with other subcontractors and acts as
co-ordinator of any and all work applying to his or their contract.
Owner-builder means any person who shall build, alter, add to or repair himself or
herself a home, who is the sole owner of the property or land 'OD which the home is
constructed, provided said home is used as living quarters by the said owner.
Speculative builder means any person who is engaged in the business of building
homes for sale to the general public, who is the sole owner of the property or land on
'CroBB reference-Licenses generally, Ch. 15.
Supp. No. 11
642.3
r
I
.
~
{
~
I
i
<
j
t
I
~
,
f
3333 N. FEDERAL HWY.
JOHN A. GRANT, JR., INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS
"
10CA RATON, fLORIDA
SKETCH OF SURVEY LOT 427
TROPIC ISLE 3 rd. SECTION
PLAT BOOK
DELRAY BEACH, PALM
SURVEY FOR:
. _'6'~&T r;Jy..,.C AiA-':Jcy CX.h1u-,-c;.-/l,O
ELEV SHOWN HEREON ARE BASED ON
NGVD MEAN SEA LEVEL DATUM
BOUNDARY SURVEY 1{-,. -f),.I.... C"
l 10
I J
,Se-r
r-c ,to
4'wocl-
~C"-lf..'"
I;.:.. ;'>i..: t_~'''~7~ j':J
"N F'-/.I.)_~ ;:..."'...:. 'A<...
_(0.. <1 -;; '11.="/ -!li: "
e:1I!:.~. G........,...IJ"N.?:7' t.
f-"~~' ,/'J.u"''';r'~'A:. "
/Z...--r/o2., 000,",(.;. "I
/V/~)p 7:..../ls:I:' ri.
~j:./1Z.~.4d""':;' 2~:,/~~ \)
rft:s C:~"-;').Jn()'1 ~
Ru'Ov/"cc.:.'..s L..)~'''l....;- r .
r7~.,.;{ E'(.L.,.~7i~..._ 70 ~
~hc A ,"",,....,,..,....,....' ~,..:: ~
/.:0 " Al:lovl'..~ ih'E, "
C).:--C)"""'AI Qr PIG "'''''l.Yl.(t.
W/<I/c:rl. .........,~. ,(:.(v';. Tf;'.(.'
7a C".:-..., ;=;":'~"''''I 77.> ~l.~'r'l~
El".........l, /,....!..<!........,..,,'.[.
~"OG~'A,~;'
....~e 7" /.P
I.....,:'. r
~
-- N.-
,
25. PAGE "51
BEAC H COUNTY,
FLOR IDA
,
/lh:u:o (""'/1<1/
"Ni.\.>
"-
i
~
~
~
- .
'1"
"'ll
, \
!~
;4;V.4i ~
10' -" I
~" .'...~1..,..t,.
',\ ' ... _r. ~ _~' ._
. r I'!: I._~. ,A ~ ;'f:'.l"J
\ :29.<,,) ~"") ,
~. 'JI
.'1
n
NI
.
I
I
90.00
~
~
.....
0,,..' S.,,- iL't'.1-'
~ I
t'l
,'\
"
.
Of
4.:....~"
~.
I\~
. .:11'''
, ~ "'.
.~
\;
'-,1'. .
2'3$'~"
,9..:S"
o
,~ "
)- ~
~ (,
\.1....'
<;I .....
t~ "','
r" .
. ,
Pc>,.,.~
=- .,
.. ~ ,-.
. ..
b
"
1$
Iii
'.
iJ.
- \
~
<;)
'l
"
'.
.~~~')
/7"!A
~"".'I~
i
/ .:5r'.l C 8:; N.._~...J",: .:"'.
9"17 .J4S/YlOVO;:: 7)/.?""e:
'"
r-'
'"
c:J
f/~ 4~
.~: ~ IX. ,i
;! ;:",. ~
..-
Z.~.4$"
:l!.:.17
.
0\
',' 11.P1'4f() .': ~:'
.',"'., ",.f" .
..\~.~:'~'.\.: ':-:l/Ji. I
"t .(.'~~'. : ~..h ';;."~ i
q '~< ~~l{{~:t_j~';} 1.' :.;.
',:;..f~.,\)1:.~',;.l:~1 ,
1,j : :. '. .....1.1'" :1. ~.;.'fj.::" 'n
';"1 ~ ,(' :/.1: 'J: .r,. ~I
i ":"<'~ .;-~~~':F': l:i;;1{i:.: I
! .\ . ,~ " ;",~1 'it J .r::1~~~
'..' ):,. \,:.': .':" t:~~(~:),
::'~~:,./f -::~ ::~::,' ~;:}:..j
..r.,.lrt,{'';_':\:~;''':'';:<
~':.. ":-:',:10:"~,,,~
'},:1r"'~"", .i...~.r" .~~
a' '\ ;::lk.. .,,~ ~/ ~.,~.~,: ~~ ','
~:..... .
17,::~
~,
.I!
'.1,
.I-ov"'!;::'~. i::~~,..... "':' ..
(.~~,', ". ..'/7';'1" I' :r.. ;~5
,
"
Il'
,F;." /,,;'
~~/., '.
90.170
J
I
- -- -0.. -- .. - ~ f-
,
I
, o__.~
t -'
" .'i-?:.:'.7'_.oO
...-;. ~.;.'
, f'Y,f
;O';""7~1O ~~:?SM/;VE. Q..f2...R
q '" 7i"~"IW1A"'~1 4"1'1/.. .!f';.ftJ1
l~.
Ii
"""-.0
"'//,,,..,
~)..;.:if:v.<.-r",.';,.:" ",";/ 7-1(.. .1J7<iiiMI, 3Z"7. zz.
r.': U V '-
Drawn 8y v?-.
ll1/..
Checked Iy ~/;'. ,
Seal. /"~ ZO'
St.mwall . 2-1';' 77
, . .-(EnI'SV CERTI"''''I' TP'Wr t'"'l. "SI":Jttr:H OF SUAVF.V'~ 0' U"ot
boy. cH.~"'I~d P~e"'Y ,. ,....... Il^dI cO"'''.ct ,. \r.
r..Cf,. ar\d wll.r.. r-ec;.",Uy .""1"'.... """~... y:,r.c i
,IO~" to v.. "'I""'..........""" t.e.......t . n...c;t.. \ 0..,
;u~~ 0' I..anct Sc.""",.yO"'_.
z. Z
/tJ- S'7("
F.I. Z4e Pg. -ZL-
Jab'Na. /rYl. ..<;~:::'
F.8,~Pg, S3
~Jllf/77
( 'oJ <t .~..
\ I 011(."0.3 LAnd S""
tA&Il 01 P le"\d.ll
l ~,.,~, '1oI~.)' r"lO' wHet """e4. ""00"'.0 \\o'lU"l ".IUcf ".1.
1141
- --
DEPARTMENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
tJTY OF
DElARY gE~t:i
~~ <.,~
Director~-~~( <)
ro
Walter O. Barry - City Manager
f=R;JM
Lula Butler - Community Improvement
Proposed Interlocal Agreement Between the City of
'~I '8J~CT
.~ - Delray Beach and Palm Beach County for the Development
of 33 Single Family Homes
7/18/88
The attached proposed inter10cal agreement is submitted for approval
and execution by the City Commission. The document has been reviewed
and accepted by the City Attorney's office with one recommendation.
I spoke with George Steele, the managing partner of the Palm Beach
County Housing Partnership, who stated his office has discussed the
possibility of the County waiving road and other impact fees for the
proposed project with the appropriate County staff. This request will
be handled as a separate item by the County Commission upon a staff
recommendation.
The County Commission approved the land transfer to the partnership at
its 7/12/88 meeting contingent upon the City approval and execution of
the Interlocal Agreement. The Partnership chose to have the waiver
request handled under separate cover in order to facilitate a more
timely closing date on the land transfer.
Staff is recommending Commission approval of the Interlocal Agreement.
LB:DQ
Attachments
Disk - Lula
A:Agreemnt.SFR
I \1 _~IJ::
T:-E ErF':'i~T ALWAYS MATT~R3
~2.
-'--
[, 110 D. F ~r;:~ ;;;:;;rt?:-:n P['":.,~:;-0:1
, "I~ M flJJ~;~tH~~1 I 1 ~_n \.~.:_,.l4..~,d
'-,
,
" ,"
'/
CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFlC~
'I ,,, I 1 I ',! I" 'I I I I I I '" I) I I I' " . I ~ I, r I I , I I I I ~ II ) \, t ~ I" ;
1'1 '1' - 'I If I 'i'!II' I'"
MEMORANDUM
Date:
From:
July II, 1988 A~
Lula.~utler, Director Community Improvement t'
Jeffrey S. Kurtz, Assistant City Attorney
Proposed Interlocal Agreement Between the City of
Delray Beach and Palm Beach County for the Develop-
ment of 33 Sinqle Family Homes
To:
Subject:
I have reviewed the agreement and found it to be legally
sufficient and in proper form' for execution by the Commission.
The agreement is relatively simple in that it calls for Palm
Beach County to provide $l50, 000 to the Palm Beach County
Housing partnership and for the City to waive certain develop-
ment fees and provide infrastructure for the construction of
the housing proj ect on 8.9 acres of county owned land wi thin
the City. The only aspect of the agreement which I would
recommend to be considered for revision is that the county, in
addition to providing $150,000, waive its road impact fees or
any other impact fees which may be in place at the time devel-
opment takes place.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please do
not hesitate to contact me.
JSK:sh
cc: Walter o. Barry, City Manager
Frank Spence, Development Services Director
\R\~<c~~VJ~\Q)
J\Jl138a
'NSPNE~6~~~ENT
CODE E
\
INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN PALM BEACH COUNTY
AND THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
THIS INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT, made and entered into this
day of , 1988 by' and between:
PALM BEACH COUNTY, a political subdivision of the
State of Florida, hereinafter referred to as the
"COUNTY" :
and
THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, a municipality duly or-
ganized by the laws of the State of Florida,
hereinafter referred to as the "MUNICIPALITY",
WHEREAS, the parties hereto have tho common power to per-
form Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) activities with-
in Palm Beach County, said common powers being pursuant to
Section 125.01, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 163, Part III,
Florida Statutes; and
WHEREAS, it is mandated by Title I of the Housing and
Community Development Act of 1974, as amended, that a county
must enter into Interlocal Cooperation Agreements with munici-
palities in its jurisdiction for the purposes of implementing
CDBG activities within said municipalities; and
WHEREAS, Palm Beach County desires to join with municipali-
ties in order to carry out the planning and professional ser-
vices necessary to implement CDBG activities; and
WHEREAS, Palm Beach County entered into an Agreement with
the Palm Beach County Housing Partnership, Inc, hereinafter
referred to as the "PARTNERSHIP", on October 15, 1987 to pro-
vide $150,000 of CDBG funds for administrative activities of
the PARTNERSHIP for Fiscal Year 1988 (October 1, 1987 through
September 30, 1988); and
WHEREAS, the Partnership is an organization dedicated to
combining public sector resources and private sector ini tia-
tive to construct affordable housing for low- and moderate
Interlocal Agreement
Delray Beach/Palm Beach County
Page 2
income residents throughout Palm Beach County; and
WHEREAS, a part of the Partnership'~ overall program activ-
i ties, the construction of, 33 affordable single-family homes
on an 8,9 acre parcel of County owned land bordered on the
north by S,W, 2nd Street, on the east by S.W. 8th Avenue, on
the south by s. W, 3 rd Street and on the west by S. W. 10th
Avenue within the City of Delray Beach is contemplated, herein-
after known as the "PROJECT"; and
WHEREAS, the City of Delray Beach;' through Resolution
Number 8-88, has agreed to construct on-, and off-site infra-
structure improvements, including water and sewer hookups and
interior streets, and agrees to consider waiving permi t and
impact fees in support of this Project; and
WHEREAS, it is appropriate for the County to cooperate
with the Municipality to facilitate development of the Project
through the appropriation of County CDBG administrative funds
and the transfer of said 8.9-acre parcel of County owned land,
NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereby agree as follows:
l. The COUNTY and the MUNICIPALITY will cooperate so that
the COUNTY may provide CDBG funds to partially subsidize eligi-
ble administrative activities by the PARTNERSHIP wi thin the
MUNICIPALITY during the period from October I, 1988 through
September 30, 1991 (including program income generated from
expendi ture of such funds) under Ti tIe I of the Housing and
Community Development Act of 1974, as amended, and receive
funds under said Act,
2. The MUNICIPALITY and the COUNTY wi 11 take all actions
necessary to ensure compliance with the urban county's certifi-
cation required by Section 104(b) of Title I of the Housing
and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended, including
Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title VIII of the
Civil Rights Act of 1968, Section 109 of Title I of the Housing
Interlocal Agreement
Delray Beach/Palm Beach County
Page 3
and Community Development Act of 1974, and other applicable
laws,
3 , The COUNTY,
through its Division of Housing and
Communi ty Development, shall undertake all professional and
administrative services necessary for the purposes of appropri-
ately administering the granting of CDBG funds to the Partner-
ship, including preparation of all applications and other
necessary documents required in accordance with Federal, State
and County laws and regulations,
4, The COUNTY will carry out essential activities as may
be required by the U,S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development (BUD), pursuant to Title I of the Act by providing
funds to the PARTNERSHIP as budgeted during the period of this
Agreement.
However, it is understood that the COUNTY's in-
volvement in the funding of the PARTNERSHIP and administration
thereof is independent of the administration of the Community
Development Block Grant entitlement received by the MUNICIPALI-
TY,
5, The COUNTY and the MUNICIPALITY may amend this Agree-
ment by mutual consent.
Such amendments shall be incorporated
by written amendment as part of this Aqreement and shall be
subject to approval of the Palm Beach County Board of Commis-
sioners and the MUNICIPALITY.
Except as otherwise provided
herein, no amendment to this Agreement shall be binding on
either party unless in writing, approved by the Board of Coun-
ty Commissioners and signed by both parties.
6. The MUNICIPALITY must inform the COUNTY wi thin ten
(10) working days of any income generated by the expendi ture
of CDBG funds expended in support of the PROJECT. Any program
income generated by CDBG-supported acti vi ties must be repaid
to the COUNTY, unless the COUNTY provides wri tten authoriza-
tion to the MUNICIPALITY for said program income to be re-
tained by the MUNICIPALITY to further the objectives of the
Interlocal Agreement
Delray Beach/Palm Beach County
Page 4
PROJECT and to be used for eligible CDBG expenditures. In
this event, program income must be retained, managed and uti-
lized in accordance with Office of Management and Budget Circu-
lar A-l02, Circular A-110 Attachment D, the Common Rule, and
other CDBG regulations as may then apply,
The COUNTY shall assume the responsibility for monitoring and
reporting to HUD as to the disposition of program income gener-
ated by any CDBG-supported activities.
Therefore, the MUNICIPALITY shall implement and maintain ade-
quate recordkeeping procedures as needed for this purpose in
conformance with the above-referenced regulations, and others
that may then apply.
In the event of close-out or change in
status of the MUNICIPALITY with respect to this Agreement, any
program income on hand or received subsequent to close-out or
change in status must be repaid to the COUNTY,
With respect to funds provided by the COUNTY to the PART-
NERSHIP, the COUNTY'shall assume the responsibility for moni-
toring and reporting to HUD as to the di sposi tion of program
income generated by the PROJECT. Therefore, the MUNICIPALITY,
through the PARTNERSHIP, shall implement and maintain adequate
recordkeeping procedures as needed for this purpose in confor-
mance with the above-referenced regulations. The COUNTY will
reserve the right to monitor said procedures at its discretion,
7. The MUNICIPALITY shall be responsible for notifying
the COUNTY of any modification and/or change in the use of che
PROJECT from that planned by the Partnership and described
herein, Notification to the COUNTY shall take place within
Interlocal Agreement
Delray Beach/Palm Beach County
Page 5
ten (10) days of said modification or change,
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this
Agreement to be executed by their duly authorized officials,
ATTEST:
COUNTY
PALM BEACH COUNTY BY ITS
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
BY
BY:
Chair
Deputy Clerk
(SEAL)
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL
SUFFICIENCY
County Attorney
MUNICIPALITY
ATTEST:
BY:
Mayor
City Clerk
City Manager
(SEAL)
Ref: Agree17
Interlocal Agreement
Delray Beach/Palm Beach County
Page 6
LEGAL CERTIFICATION BY PALM BEACH COUNTY
As legal counsel for Palm Beach County, I hereby state that
the terms and provisions of this agreement are fully author-
ized under State and local law that the ,agreement provides
full legal authority for the County to allow the Palm Beach
County Housing Partnership, Inc, to facilitate development of
single-family affordable housing within the City of Delray
Beach as part of its overall program activities, which are
subsidized with the County's Community Development Block Grant
funds,
Michele R, Franke
Assistant County Atto~ney
DEPARTMENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
CITY DF
DElRRYeE~[}t
TO
Walter O. Barry - City Manager
F::l.O\l
Lula Butler - Community Improvement
" 1''''''':.
· , ~,'f
,.... 'c t 1111
Director ~ '-'~ \,~
Request for City Commission Approval
"_'SiECT Temporary Tents/Revival Meeting
Daughter of Zion 7th Day Adventist Church
7/19/88
The Daughter of Zion Seventh Day Adventist Church is requesting City
Commission approval of a permit to erect a temporary tent on their
property located across the street from their church addressed as 201
NW 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach.
The temporary tent will be used for the purpose of a church revival
meeting from July 31, 1988 through September 3, 1988. The same is
submitted in accordance with City Code of Ordinance, Chapter 150.100.
Applicant has complied to prerequisites to approval by City Commission
as listed in Chapter 150.102.
Staff recommends approval of th permit as requested by the applicant.
Required documentation is attached.
LB:DQ
Attachments
Disk - Lula
A:TempTents.CC
Tc.c EcFUF'r AL,>;AYS MATTERS
~3
[ITY UF DElnn~ Jl~n(U
111<1111,-; I,'", Il'''lf
. . ,I I q.\, 1'1 ,II! I I 1/ II (II I ~ '111
. 1ll"",,/18?Ho11
REQUIREMENTS FOR OBTAINING ! TENT PERMIT
Listed below are the requirements involving the use of a tent or any other structure
for temporary assembly of persons within the City of Delray Beach:
1. Letter of approval from property owner.
2. Approval of ministerial association for assembly pertaining to religious
services.
3. Fire Department Approval:
A. The tent or structure shall be approved for fire resistance by the Fire
Department.
B. Adequate fire protection equipment will be provided on the premises at
all times subject to the approval of the Fire Department as to type
and capacity.
4. Building Department Approval:
A. Permit to erect and dismantel structure.
1. Permit fee of $50.00
2. Submit a plot plan.
3. Deposit of $50.00 which will be returned after final inspection
for removal and clean-up operations.
B.
Permit to connect temporary electric service on the premises.
, -" .
CAB approval required for temporary sign. *Sign permit 'required.
C.
5. Sanitation Department Approval:
A. Toilet facilities for both men and women located on the premises, subject
to approval from the County Health Department.
6. City Council Approval:
A. Approval as to location and purpose of assembly.
B. Time limitations.
NO OCCUPANCY OF ANY PREMISES FOR TEMPORARY ASSEMBLY WILL BE ALLOWED UNTIL ALL
FOREGOING PROVISIONS ARE COMPLIED WITH AND THOSE IGNATURES PR VIDED FOR BELOW ARE
ACQUIRED:
4.
5.
City Council
11/87
.
'\0 . ["$ E"7+/
. ,~ sl
,q
.0
;
~
....
'" ..
'" ~
'"
'''' "'
"
;;:: '.
'Q ,~
'" .
~ .::-:. "'
"
V ~ "
"
\ .
(J ': "
~
~ .'
\J '" -'
..'
'""
~ \ _I
,
~ ...
.
0,
, ."
'i
>..
\ '"
..,
~ ~, '. ,
"'
' ".. ~ ~ ":
" ~~ ~ ~~
~ ~ -b ~ 0,
" Io~ T~ ...
~ ~ ...
\z ~~ ""
~~ 04:
"- I,
H Q ~~" ::(
-..9 ~ ~12 i ~ .;
"
~ "'~~ ",
-. ~\ ..
<'I~ .:'
- ,~S .:
"'.'
Q~ ...
\ ~~
,I
~H
~~"
~~
,"
In
~
::'i.
.~
~
~
.",t,'
,.'
.0
~ < ,"<!I:Z
l.a(" Ii " ~ hf
"B .
.~2S ~ , .
~ ~
,00$ !li.-S.
,~$EI
~ ~ ~
,~/'Ep/ ;~
.S<:4!:.
~~~
~~~~
~q~
~h~
~ ~'~'
~~!i
'1 ~ ' ~
,
~t
~ ~ ~!l~
'\l ~@ ~"
I I
I I
I I
I I
I 0/
I ~I
I " I
I 'I
I I
' ,
I I oS
L----_L__~"'[-~I ,
. ~.~ ! .~
io ~ ''\, ~
'\:, ., . .
_~S'~.? ~)'V _~---- ___ ."is>~~ ~_'"
I
I
I
I
I~
I'
I
I
":~
DEPARTMENTAL
CORRESPONOENCE
CITY DF
DE1RRY BERC}J
Director~~Q
TO
Walter O. Barry - City Manager
FROM
Lula Butler - Community Improvement
Request for City Commission Approval
SUBJECT /R ' 1 M t'
Temporary Tents eV1va ee 1ng
Bethanie Zion 7th Day Adventist French Church
7/19/88
The Bethanie Zion Seventh Day Adventist Church is requesting City
Commission approval of a permit to erect a temporary tent on vacant
property located on the corner of SW 6th Ave and SW lOth Street.
The temporary tent will be used for the purpose of a church revival
meeting from July 31, 1988 through August 27, 1988. The same is
submitted in accordance with City Code,of Ordinance, Chapter 150.100.
Applicant has complied to prerequisites to approval ,by City Commission
as listed in Chapter 150.102.
Staff recommends approval of the permit as requested by the applicant.
Required documentation is attached.
LB:DQ
Attachments
Disk - Lula
A:TempTents.CC
.'~6~
T' C
Ac,'fAYi MATTE",
S'lf-
\
[IT' OF DElnny ll~"["
PIIJU'."J 1-'.'" 11..1111
. 'd I .. '. . 1'1 '" I I IlH'''^ '," 1.1
. HI~ 7 In 1~':" 1
REQUIREMENTS FOR OBTAINING ! TENT PERMIT
Listed below sre the requirements involving the use of s tent or any other structure
for temporary assembly of persons within the City of Delray Beach:
1. Letter of approval from property owner.
2. Approval of ministerial association for assembly pertaining to religious
services.
3. Fire Department Approval:
A. The tent or structure shall be approved for fire resistance by the Fire
Department.
B. Adequate fire protection equipment will be provided on the premises at
all times subject to the approval of the Fire Department as to type
and capacity.
4. Building Department Approval:
A. Permit to erect and dismantel structure.
1. Permit fee of $50.00
2. Submit a plot plan.
3. Deposit of $50.00 which will be returned after final inspection
for removal and clean-up operations.
B. Permit to connect temporary electric service on the premises.
C. CAB approval required for temporary sign. *Sign permit required.
,J 5. Sanitation Department Approval:
A. Toilet facilities for both men and women located on the premises. subject
to approval from the County Health Department.
6. City Council Approval:
A.
Approval as to location and purpose o~ assembly.
/
B. Time limitations.
NO OCCUPANCY OF ANY PREMISES FOR TEMPORARY ASSEMBLY WILL BE ALLOWED UNTIL ALL
FOREGOING PROVISIONS ARE COMPLIED WITH AND THOSE SIGNATURES PROVIDED FOR BELOW ARE
ACQUIRED:
\
4.
Building Department
5.
City Council
11/87
QrrNH
S""rAG-E"
I1RIA Q ~'>O~ c.el/T&R- ~ p
U/IMG 0
?O~ e~o'~(') jlotA
\
~ ~O ~ 3 \oof;; ~
'v J
V) ~ "'
-.. ~ 't
't -( 0
CJ
~
0
Fb.E
OP/:.IJ Au.. SIDE-So
J-jO/
IRe .".u:O
t'.'ltTJH6U-
60/
(
lE-NT SE.i=VP
_ "fo(M.", ')00
~
DAUGHTBR OF ZION SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH
201 Northwest Third Avenue
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
(407) 272-8698
Elder Amos Bossous
Bethanie SDA French Church
541 N,W. 10th Avenue
Boynton Beach, Florida 33435
Dear Elder Bossous:
We've considered your request to use our property which is
located on S,W, 10th Street for your forthcoming Evangelistic
Meeting, and we want you to know that you may indeed use the
property for the extent of your Revival, We understand how
important such an undertaking as this one will be,
If there is anything else that we can do to help you. please
feel free to contact us.
~~
j
~outheaj.u.7.12 C012feu12ae
of
~1!.1J'U1.th-da.!:J d/-dlJ'U1.tu.t~
June 23, 1988
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
This letter is to serve notice that Pierre Aaos Bossous has been
authorized by the Southeastern Conference Ministerial Association
to conduct a tent meeting on the corner of 6th Avenue SW and
10th Street from July~o August 27, 1988.
3/
The property on which the tent will be located is owned by the
Southeastern Conference Association of SDA,
If we may be of any further assistance, we shall be happy to do
so.
Respectfully
on, Director
ern Conference Ministerial Association
j
180 Westmonte Drive, 1'0, Box 340 (32715,0340) . Altamonle Springs, Rorida 32714 . (305) 869-5264
,j
TO
FROM
SUBJECT_
CM 362
DEP ARTf\ ..=NT AL
CORRESPONDENCE
[ITY OF 11t~ <~~
DElRAY BEA[H~
~(i
Walter Barry
City Manager
Joe Weldon
Director of Parks and Recreation
Children Services Grant
, 7/14/88
. DATE
Attached please find the revised agreement for acceptance of a
$ll2, 362.00 grant from the Children Services Council for the
expansion of our afterschool program at the Community Center,
Carver School, and Pompey Park. Susan RUby, City Attorney, made
the changes in agreement with Tom Sheehan, attorney for the
Children Services Council, in paragraphs 5, 7, 8B, and 17.
Addi tionally, the opening paragraph and executi:on pages were
changed to reflect the City of Delray as the legal entity. The
Children Services Council approved and signed the agreement at
their meeting on July 13, 1988.
The grant will reimburse the Parks and Recreation Department
$l12,362 for the afterschool program for children aged 6-15 and
will provide structured and supervised recreation activities,
provide adult supervision for a large number of "latch-key"
children, and provide an environment for long term development
of social and interpersonal skills.
I'm requesting this be placed on the City Commission agenda on
July 26 for approval.
Parks and Recreation
JW:cc
cc: Joe Dragon, Assistant Director of Parks and Recreation
Susan Ruby, Assistant City Attorney
C~
THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
.
AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, entered into this lst day of July 1988, by
and between the Children's Services, Council of Palm Beach
County, a pOlitical subdivision of the State of Florida,
(hereinafter referred to as "Council") and the City of Delray
Beach (hereinafter referred to as "Provider"), for the period
from 01/01/88 to 09/30/89.
WIT N E SSE T H: In consideration of the mutual
agreements hereafter contained, the parties, intending to be
legally bound, hereby agree as follows:
1. The Council agrees to reimburse to the Provider sums
up to $112,362 for provision of services described in RFP # 059,
attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit A and in the
Provider's proposal dated June 27, 1988, attached hereto and
made a part hereof as Exhibit B. ~t is expressly understood and
agreed, by and between the parties, that the services to be
rendered hereunder by the Provider shall be provided in
compliance with all terms and conditions set forth in Exhibits A
and B and in the Special Conditions attached hereto and made a
part hereof as Exhibit C, as well as with the terms and
conditions of this document.
2. The Provider agrees to comply with all applicable
federal, state and local laws.
3. The Provider agrees to comply with the fOllowing
requirements:
a. To maintain books, records and documents in
accordance wi th normally accepted accounting
procedures and practices, which SUfficiently and
properly reflect all expenditures of funds provided by
the Council under the Agreement.
b. To assure that these records shall be available,
upon reasonable notice, to inspection, review or audit
by the Council and personnel duly authorized by the
Council to make such inspection, review, or audit.
c. To maintain and file with the
progress, fiscal, inventory, and other
Council may require during the terms of
Council such
reports as the
the Agreement.
d. To include these aformentioned
record-keeping requirements in all
subcontracts and assignments.
audi t and
approved
1988-l989 Children's Services Council/Provider Agreement
Page 2
4. a. To retain all financial records, supporting
documents, statistical records and any other documents
pertinent to this Agreement for a period of five (5)
years following termination of this Agreement, or if
an audit has been initiated and audit findings have
not been resolved at the end of the five year period,
the records shall be retained until resolution of all
audit findings.
b. Persons duly authorized by the Council shall have
full access to and the right to examine any of said
materials during said period.
5. To the extent provided by law, the Provider agrees to
indemnify and hold harmless the Council from liability on
actions, causes of actions, claims, suits, judgements and
damages accruing, including court costs and attorney's fees, as
a result of services performed or not performed, or any
negligent act by the Provider or funding granted or not granted
by the Councilor any action arising out of the operation of
this agreement.
6. This contract may not be assigned or subcontracted to
any other party by the Provider without the prior written
approval of the Council.
7. , The Children Services Council aCknowledges that the
Provider is self-insured and accepts the levels of self
insurance provided by the Provider.
8. The Provider shall not use or disclose any information
concerning a client under the Agreement for any purpose not in
conformity with federal and state laws and regulations except on
wri tten consent of the client, or his responsible parent or
guardian when authorized by law.
a. The Provider agrees to establish and maintain
procedures and controls acceptable to the Council for
safeguarding records, so that no information contained in
the Provider's records or obtained from others carrying out
the terms of the Agreement, shall be used by or disclosed
by the Provider, its agents, officers or employees except
as provided by law.
Agreet.doc
June 7, 1988
4:00 pm
1988-1989 Children's Services Council/Provider Agreement
Page 3
b. It shall be the responsibility of the Provider to take
all reasonable steps necessary to implement promptly such
procedures and controls in order to protect the privacy of
a client receiving the services hereunder and in order to
assure the maintenance of confidentiality of any medical or
other information pertaining to any such client, to the
extent provided by law.
9. The Provider shall submit to the Council management and
program data, including client identifiable data as deemed
essential by t~e Council.
lO. The Provider shall furnish the Council with reports of
the effectiveness of the program and include statistics and data
on the number of persons served and such other reports and
information that the Council may require. Said reports shall be
made as requested from the effective date of this Agreement and
in a format provided by the Council.
ll. The Provider is performing the services and duties
required hereunder as an independent contractor and not as an
employee, agent, partner of, or joint venturer with the Council.
The Provider shall assume sole and exclusive responsibility for
the payment of wages to all employees for services performed by
them under this Agreement. The Provider shall, with respect to
said employees, by responsible for withholding federal income
taxes, paying federal and social security taxes, maintaining
unemployment compensation coverage in amounts required by
applicable federal and state laws.
12.
provided
reserves
services.
The
on a
the
services provided by the Provider hereunder are
non-exclusive basis, and the Council specifically
right to subcontract with others for similar
l3. Payment for services rendered pursuant to this
Agreement shall be made to the Provider monthly on a
reimbursement basis. Provider shall submit an invoice to the
Council by the 10th day of each month fOllowing the month in
which the services were provided. The invoice will include
documentation reflecting all expenditures made by the Provider
under this Agreement, in whatever form reasoni;lbly required by
Council. Subject to the availability of funds, the Council will
provide to the Provider within 45 days after receipt of the
invoice.
Agreet.doc
June 7, 1988
4:00 pm
1988-19~ Children's Serv~ces CounC~l/Provider Agreement
Page 4
14. The Provider agrees to return to the COuncil any
overpaYments made through inadvertence or miscalcUlation
or because payment is disallowed as not having been
prOperly earned under this Agreement. Such funds shall be
refunded in full by Provider to the Council as follows:
a. Within twenty (20) days from the date of written
notification by the Council to the Provider of
overpayment or disallowance: or
b. within thirty (30) days following the end of this
Agreement:
c. the Council shall have the right to deduct from
any subsequent payment request submitted by the
Provider. the amount of any overpayments or disallowed
funds.
15. The Council may, for reasonable cause, suspend
the payment of funds pending corrective action by the
Provider or pending a decision by the Council to terminate
this Agreement. The Council may, for reasonable cause,
prohibit the Provider from incurring additional Obligation
of any funds received from the Council, pending corrective
action by the Provider or a decision to terminate this
Agreement. Said suspension of payment of funds or
Obligation thereof may apPly to all or part of the
Provider's operations.
Before SUspending payment of funds to a Provider or
preVenting a Provider from incurring additional Obligation
of funds received, the Council shall notify the Provider.
in writing, of the action to be taken, the reasons for it,
and the conditions, if any, under which the suspension
will be lifted. Within five (5) days or receipt of the
notice of suspension, the Provider may request a hearing
before the Council. Suspension shall be effective five
(5) days after receipt by the provider, unless the Council
has determined that immediate suspension is necessary and
so informs the Provider.
If a hearing is timely reqUested by the Provider. the
suspension will not be effective until a date determined
by the Council fOlloWing the hearing. The hearing will be
held within a reasonable time after request therefore to
consider any matters relevant to the suspension and will
determine, in light of matters presented if the suspension
and any conditions imposed on reinstatement are warranted.
The decision of the Council shall be final.
Agreet.doc
Jun 7, 1988
4:00 pm
.
1988-1989 Children's Services Council/Provider Agreement
Page 5
16. In the event funds to finance this Agreement become
unavailable to the Council, the Council may terminate this
Agreement upon no less than five (5) days written notice to the
Provider. The Council shall be the final authority as to the
availability of funds.
17. The Council may terminate this Agreement for any
breach by the Provider. If Council intends to terminate this
Agreement, notice shall be provided in writing to the Provider
no less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the effective date
of the termination. The Council's failure to terminate or
suspend a Provider for past breaches of this Agreement shall not
be construed as a waiver of its right to demand strict
compliance with the terms of the Agreement or to terminate for
said breaches or similar breaches, and shall not be construed to
be a modification of the terms of the Agreement. The Provider
may terminate this contract with or without cause provided that
Provider shall give sixty (60) days notice in writing to
Council. The Council shall reimburse the Provider for all
monies expended up to and including the effective date of the
termination.
l8. Notices: all notices required hereunder shall be in
writing and shall be addressed to the following representatives
of the parties:
For the Council:
Barbara A. Kauffman
Executive Director
Children's Services Council of Palm Beach County
Suite 243
311l S. Dixie Highway
West Palm Beach, FL 33405
For the Provider:
Joe H. Weldon
Director
Delray Beach Parks and Recreation Department
50 N.W. lst Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444
Telephone: (407) 243-7250
19. This Agreement, which includes the attached Exhibits
A, B, and C, contains all the terms and conditions agreed upon
by the parties. No other agreements, oral or otherwise,
regarding the subject matter of this Agreement shall be deemed
to exist or to bind any of the parties hereto. This Agreement
shall not be modified unless in writing and signed by both
parties hereto.
1988-1989 Children's Services Council/Provider Agreement
Page 6
In Witness Thereof, the parties have caused this Agreement
to be executed by their undersigned duly authorized officers.
PROVIDER
~ITY OF DELRAY BEACH
CHILDREN'S SERVICES COUNCIL
OF PALM BEACH COUNTY
7;
. Chairman. CSC
~
/' 4
" -{,U ?;)J~
: - , ti. {ic I:" _:- /,,,!
Elaine Webb Alvarez. Vice Chairma~ CSC
Date:
Date:
,//Ii:~:;1 -; ~
,/////11""'" ...">\'\
I' 9'0~ I] III,
...,Q-~:v \
~ 0
_I
,~
'-- OLlG~ to
.i) r:-";
" .
......'
Delray BE:ach Ponce Depart
300 We.t Atlantic Avenue · Delray Beach, Florida 33C44.
(305) 243-7888
e~
CHARLES KILGORE
Ch,., 0/ l'o'ICe
MEMORANDUM
TOI
Robert A. Barcinskl
Asslstant Clty Manater/Manatement Servic s Group
Richard M. Lincoln. Major
Acting Chief of Pollce
June 29. 1988
FROMI
DATE I
SUBJECT I
L&W E~EOBCE~E~I &CCBEDII&IIC~
-
Pursuant to your request of June 28. 1988. the \ Ci tv Council
appro~riatad $10.000.00 in FV 85/86 on advice from the City
Attorney/City Manager from the Lau Enforcement Tr~st Fund for
accreditation. On September 12. 1986. a check for \$3.650.00 uas
sent to the Commission (one half of the accreditation fee) prior
to a scheduled October 1st increase in fees.
The Police Department has been uorking on the accreditation
process since 1985 uhen former Captain Lorenzo Brooks began the
process. Upon his retirement. Captain Allen Cole succeeded him
and continued the process. It uas not until September of 1987
that Chief Kilgore delegated Captain Frank Henriques to the
accreditation process full tim4~ Many sundry items have been
purchased and paid for uith our oP.ratinq budget. Houever. this
request for $18.000.00 uill allou us to recover funds from the
Trust Fund touards this process.
One additional appropriation uill be required after October 1st
during FY 88/89 and at this point. ue can only estimate that it
uould be in the neighborhood of $5.000 to $6.000. That would
include the other half of the accreditation fee and any other
as~ociated expenses incurred for a public hearing and the
aSSessment team to visit our facility for one ueek in earv 1989.
If' ue can furnish additional information. please do not hesitate
to call upon us. III(
Respect fu 11 y submi t t ed. ::>~i81'
~ -
/J ~"-"'.j~"I!JI8!.;..~~
__?!.~:..~!;~~~__________ " ."",,,,;~~~~.,OI ,..~.
RICHARD M. LINCOLN. MAJOR ~~~
Actin~ Chief of Police ' t~~
cc: Chief Killlore (JCb"CJo(..,I/~
Major Cochrane ~
Captain Henriques 0' .rAt .. ~"
PARTNERS WITH CITIZENS IN BRINGING THE COMMUNITY TOGETHER
:.: J';{, :';;', ~,
. # .
7"... '"
/'1r" "~.~'
/1, i' ~,. ...., \'\ \
I~\>-'l (J~\
S' y
'" 0
D I
-
'/j {-
. OUe .>i
'--"'.;'1, ~../
.. f I ~
Delray Beach Ponee Department
300 Welt AtlantIc Avenue . DelrayBeach, Flortda 33444.3866
(305) 2G7888
e~
,~ .'
.
CHARLES KilGORE
ChIe, 0' (folIC.
MEMORANDUM
TOI
FROM I
Waltar O. Barry. City Manager
Richard M. Lincoln. MaJor
Acting Chief of Police
June 27. 1988
DATE I
SUBJECT I
~6W E~EQBtE~E~I 6ttBEDII6IIQ~
The P'olica Departmant is nay completing the second of three
phases toyards ,becoming accreditad by the Commission on
Accreditation for Lay Enforcement Agencies. A great percentage
of the mandatory standards have been developed. 'uritten and
published throughout the Department: hoyever. several months
yill be needed to co~plete the task.
We respectfully request 518.000.00 be appropriated from the Lau
Enforcement Trust Fund to cover costs of office supplies.
printing and part-time secretarial assistance (detail sheet
attached). Sometime after October. 1988. ueuill seek an
appropriation to finalize the accreditation process and have
the on-site assessment. ~~
Your consideration in brining this before the City Commission
i s appr~c iated.
Respectfully submitted.
-tr:~:~~~!t,(~____________
RICHARD:M. LINCOLN. MAJOR
Acting Chief of Police
gb
Attachment
CCI Chief Kilgore
Major Cochrane
Captain Henriques
PARTNERS WITf! CITIZENS IN BRINGING THE COMMUNITY TOGETHER
ATTACHMENT
Office Supplie"
S inch binders
,front insert
,'oS-hole white paper
a-hole color paper
3-hole tab separators _
lettering
printer ribbons
file cabintes (3)'
-
Printingl
'P.rt~tl.e SecretarYl
<1.040 1/2 hours X $8.00)
.
- $3.250
310
1.470
1.056
280
75
230
$ 505
TOTAL:
i\
$ 7.176.00
$ 2.500.00
$ 8.324.00
$18.000.00
-
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
~TER O. BARRY, CITY MANAGER
~~LJ.~ ~O~~~~ iD~~OR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
FROM:
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM ** CONSENT AGENDA **
CONSIDERATION OF A CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST
AND ATTENDANT SITE AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN
FOR A PROPOSED AUTOMOBILE DEALERSHIP FACILITY LOCATED
ON THE EAST SIDE OF GERMANTOWN ROAD (WALLACE).
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval of a conditional use (automobile dealership)
and its attendant site and development plan on ll.28
acres located on the eastside of Germantown Road, north
of the Wallace Nissan Dealership.
The only SUbsequent action with be the ministerial act
of final plat approval.
BACKGROUND:
This development proposal involves approximately 10 acres of land
annexed in 1987 as the Wier (PCC) Annexation and approximately
1.3 acres annexed as R-lA pursuant to the Enclave Act.
Subsequently the property has been rezoned to S. C. (Ordinance
74-88).
The site and development plan proposes two phases of development.
The first involves the western portion of the site and requires
improvement of Germantown Road through the construction of an
additional travel lane. The attached Planning and Zoning Board
staff report provides a full background and analysis of the
project.
There was
Planning
request.
no public comment at the public hearing held before the
and Zoning Board relative to the conditional use
s~
.
To: Walter O. ~arry, City Manager
Re: Consideration Of A Condi';ional Use Request And Attendant
Site And Development Plan For A Proposed Automobile
Dealership Facility Location On The East Side Of
Germantown Road (Wallace)
Page 2
Planning and Zoninq Board Recommendation: At its meeting of
JUly l8th, the Board forwarded the conditional use request and
attendant site plan with a recommendation of approval sUbject to
conditions. Those conditions are listed on pages 9 and 10 of the
attached staff report. Modifications to the conditions were made
as follows:
Re #3: that an off-loading and storage area be provided
concurrent with Phase I development.
Re #4: that perimeter landscaping along the north boundary
be provided for that length of the boundary which is
contiguous with any Phase I development.
Re #6d: replace the phrase "an improvement" with "a
landscaping".
Add a condition #8 that "The site and development approval
shall be valid for a period of three years in which time
compliance with the requirements for vesting the project
must be met."
CAB approval has been obtained.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, approve the conditional use request and attendant
plan for the Wallace Automobile Dealership located on the
side of Germantown Road pursuant to the findings made
conditions imposed by the Planning and Zoning Board.
site
east
and
Attachment:
P & Z Staff Report of July 18, 1988, Item IV.B
REF/DJK#23/CCWALLAC.TXT
.
PLANNING 8. ZONING
CITY OF OELRAY
f30ARO
BEACH
STAFF REPORT
---
MEET ING DnE:
JULY 18. 1988
AGem ITEM:
:tt:, ~
COHSIDERAnON FOR SITE AND DEVELOPMEllT PLAN APPROVAL FOR THE WALLACE ADTOMOBILE
ITEM: DEALERSHIP ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF GERMANTOWN RD. AND QUEENS AVE.
.
...
@:
.
-
~
0-
:"<'
GENERAL
DATA:
,
atDer.. ........................ . Wallace PaN IDe.
_~..o... ...........,...... ...lIark liar...
D19bF 8r~, _ . All..,.,.
r.oc.t1Cl1l.............."........IfoRlleu~ _ of_town
___A_
IToporty .1............,.....'..11.2. Ac... 1411,]57 84. f~.l
euJ' LoDlI U.. .1.................l'CC I.~ - _ euter)
e1t)' ZODlag.....................se ('poc1ol1ao4 oo.oorc1011
Adj_t 1ClIllD9.................lfortb of oubj_ _rtJ' 1.
&0_ ~ (~ It)' r..,1UU..,
Ioutll 1. _81:. ...~ of
aubjeoe ....w.,..RJ' 1a loned City
"'-15 Jaalt1p]a r..usr
...1datlol). _ 10 .-
l~."
1tK1.t1zl9 LoDlI U................. v......~ lad, _ for tbo rrr.
~l. .wr~ &I'M.
.. . .ed LoDlI V.................SXpoAo1OD of AutooDb11.
Deal.raMp
Vatoer Servlee.................. .ax1at.1a9 10. vater MiD located
OD tbe .ut aleSe of GeZIMDtawIl
Rood.
&ew.r ..rvlc....................Ix1.tlag 11ft .tAtloa at tbe
~daw.t COrDer of Genaaat.OWII.
lid. _ lC11frod .~. ..""lee
require. exteaaloa. of .. PYC frea
.u.t1zl9 ....-bo1. .t tbo ....._.~
COrDer of lC11frod .~. _
GeDl&lltOWD. lid.
ITEM:.E~ 'B
ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD:
The action before the Board is that of making a
recommendation on a conditional use request and attendant
site plan for the Bill Wallace Automobile dealership. The
project is to be located just north of the existing Bill
Wallace Nissan Dealership at the northeast corner of Linton
Boulevard and Germantown Road.
BACKGROUND:
The total site consists of 11.28 acres of which a 9.9 acre
parcel was annexed to the City in March of 1987, and given a
zoning of PCC. The remainder, a 1.30 acre parcel, has been
annexed under the provisions of the "Enclave Act". The
annexation of the 1.30 acre parcel with initial zoning of
R1-A, was completed on June 28, 1988.
The annexation of the 9.9 acre parcel was made with the
proviso that appropriate dedications' ~ made along S.W.
lOth Street and Germantown Road. Following annexation ther~
was no further action on the intended PCC ~evelopment an
the property was sold.
Around this same period of time, approval was granted for an
automobile dealership to the south. During review of that
site plan, an area larger than what was finally approved
(legal problems kept the entire area from being available
for development) was reviewed. The new dealership, while
meeting code, did have a practical problem in providing
sufficient employee parking. In an attempt to accommodate
additional employee parking the applicant requested the
granting of special permission (Administrative Relief) to
use a portion (8.5 acres) of the PCC parcel for off-site
employee parking. Administrative Relief approval was
granted, sUbject to various conditions including that a site
plan reflecting the improvements necessary for developing
the parking area be approved by the Planning and Zoning
Board.
On December 2l, 1987 the Planning and Zoning Board discussed
a request for site plan approval associated with the request
for Administrative Relief for an employee parking lot on the
8.5 acres of the 9.9 acre PCC parcel. A recommendation of
approval was given, subject to conditions which included the
processing of a subdivision plat for the entire 9.9 acre
parcel previously approved as a PCC, all to occur prior to
April I, 1988. A plat was not submitted and thus, the
action of site plan approval has become void.
At the Planning and Zoning Board's meeting of June 20, 1988,
a rezoning request from PCC and R1A to SC, along with a
conditional Use, request was heard. A recommendation of
To: Plan..._'1g and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 2
approval was forwarded to the City Commission on the
rezoning while the condi~ional use was continued to the July
l8th meeting pending submittal of, a traffic study. The
traffic study has been received and reviewed, and the site
plan and conditional use request is now before the Board.
PROJECT ANALYSIS:
The site plan and attendant conditional use request
accommodate an ultimate 95,506 square feet of building
devoted to automobile dealership use. Development is to
occur in two phases. The first phase would encompass the
frontage along Germantown Road and provide showroom, office,
and service facilities (58,906 Sq. Ft.). The second phase
is geared toward enhanced repair and service facilities and
will contain 36,600 square feet.
In conversation with the dealership owner, the Phase I facilities
may either accommodate an expansion of the existing dealersliPs
(Nissan, Ford) to the immediate south or they may involv
relocation of another dealership (from elsewhere in the Cit ).
Firm business decisions as to the course to be taken or its
timing will not be made until the rezoning, conditional use,
site planning and platting processes are completed. There
is no timetable for development.
The site plan, which is accompanying the conditional use
request, shows the dedications which were desired by the
Planning and Zoning Board at the time of action on the
annexation petition. One half right-of-way (25') for S.W.
10th Avenue is provided along the east boundary of the
parcel along with 10 feet for Germantown Road. These
rights-of-way will be conveyed through a plat.
SITE PLAN ANALYSIS:
The site plan has been reviewed using criteria outlined in
Section 30-22(D) "Standards for Evaluatinq Site and Development
Plan Applications". Following is the result of that review.
Standard #l (sufficiency of materials).
This standard has been met with an acceptable submittal. A
resubmitted traffic study has been received, and reviewed.
Standard #2 (impact of the proposed use).
The proposal
redevelopment of
concentration of
will probably help
the area. In addition,
automobile use which, in
promote further
it will provide a
turn, may generate
To: P lam.,.lg and Zoning Board
Re: Staff RepJrt - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 3
a basis for repair and automobile related uses in the
Industrial area west of Germantown Road.
Standard #3 (ingress and egress) and Standard #4 (off street
parking and loading).
The applicant has proposed
site from Germantown road.
be 30 feet in width, must
feet.
three points of access to
The northern entry, proposed
be reduced to a maximum of
the
to
24
The most southerly entry has been realigned (from the
initial submission) to eliminate any offset i~ the entry
directly across Germantown Road. The modification to the
driveway was a recommendation of the traffic report provided
by Daniel Murray.
No access is indicated or proposed to s.w. 10th Avenue.
Pursuant to Section 30-19 (B), Phase 1 will require 1
loading areas while Phase 2 will require an additional two
A requirement of six loading areas appears to be excessive
and staff would support a ~\~~, to reduce the requirement
on this project. A large loading area is proposed with the
development of phase 2, yet no off loading provisions are
proposed with Phase 1 development. 'In,:;, off loading area s~
be provided for Phase I.
The applicant has indicated a parts loading area accessed
from the south from unimproved Queens Avenue. The applicant
has indicated an intention to abandon Queens Avenue and
incorporate the right-of-way within traffic circulation
patterns of the dealerships to the north and south. If
development of Phase I occurs prior to the finalization of
the abandonment, alternative off-loading areas must be
provided to assure off-loading does not occur from a
right-of-way.
Standard #5 (screens and buffers).
The site plan shows a 20 foot landscape strip along the
German~own Road frontage. A twenty foot landscape buffer
and 6 foot C.B.S. wall is proposed along the east property
line adjacent to the proposed right-of-way of S.W. 10th
Avenue. The required 5 foot (minimum) perimeter landscape
strip is provided a\~ the north and south borders of the
site. In addition to proposed installation of perimeter
landscaping along Germantown Road in Phase I, the applicant
should install the north perimeter landscaping which abuts
the existing H.R.S. building. Perimeter landscape
treatments are further discussed under the "Other Code
Items" section of the staff report.
.
To: Planl g and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 4
Standard *6 (drainage).
There are no known drainage problems in the area. Drainage
is accommodated through normal engineering techniques, thru
installation of exfiltration and storm sewer systems.
Standard *7 (sanitary sewers) and Standard *8 (utilities).
The area currently has access to City water via a ten inch
(lO") water main which runs along the eastern edge of
Germantown Road. Sewer will be tied in via a proposed 8"
line to an existing lift station at the northeast corner of
the Bill Wallace Ford dealership across the street from the
proposal. ,Neither facility has capacity problems.
Standard *9 (recreation and open space).
These criteria do not apply to this commercial use petition.
Standard *10 (site development) deals with overall impact ot
site development. t
the
CONDITIONAL USE ANALYSIS:
The project was also reviewed under criteria in Section 30-2l(D)
"Standards for Evaluatinq Conditional Uses."
Standard *1 (ingress and egress).
This standard is addressed under site development Standard
*3.
Standard *2 (parking and loading areas).
Parking and loading areas are
development Standard *4.
addressed under
site
Standard *3 (refuse and service areas).
The applicant has proposed two enclosed dumpster areas
two dumpsters each - one set with the development of
I and the other with development of the balance of the
with
Phase
site.
Standard *4 (utilities).
These standards are discussed under Site Plan Standards
numbers *7 and *8.
Standard *5 (screens and buffers).
Proposed landscaping buffers are discussed under Site Plan
To: Pla~ ~g and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 5
Standards number #5. In addition, S.W. 10th Avenue will
create a boundary between residential use east of it and
commercial uses to the west. Because of this "natural
boundary" and the distance between this development and
residential developed proposed to the east, additional
buffering is then afforded these adjacent properties.
Standard #6 (signs and lighting). The applicant is advised
signage is approved by separate application thru the
Building Department. Lighting is proposed, and a note has
been included on the site plan that all lighting is to be
confined on site.
Standard #7 (setbacks and open space).
All minimum setbacks pursuant to Section 30-l2 (N) (4) (b)
have been met. Open space criteria does not apply as this
is a commercial development.
Standard #8 (compatibility) and Standard #9 (height). i
S.W. 10th Avenue will create a boundary between residentia
use east of it and commercial uses to the west. Al
commercial uses, including the proposal, will be restricted
to taking primary access off Germantown Road. Because of
this "natural boundary" and the distance between this
development and residential developed proposed to the east,
there should not be an adverse impact on adjacent
properties. Regarding the few residential dwellings which do
exist in the immediate area (west of S.W. 10th Avenue), they
are destined for destruction as commercial uses evolve.
In general, development of the property will enhance living
conditions in the area by replacing vacant land with
development which will enhance the area and which will
provide activity which may discourage current illicit
activities which are known to occur there.
Standard #10 (economic effects on adjacent properties).
The change will have little effect on adjacent property
value. The immediate area to the northeast is transitional
and is slated for future commercial and industrial
development. The use to the immediate east of this proposed
development is proposed multi-family, which will act as a
buffer between the commercial use and the single family
subdivision to the east.
Other Code Items:
The proposed site plan shows a 25 foot dedication along the
eastern property boundary which is partial right-of-way for
1
To: Plann. J and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 6
S.W. lOth Avenue. This dedication would combine with
dedications from the Haggerty residential proposal ,to
provide a future street connection between Linton and S.W.
lOth Street. The site plan shows no access between the
dealership and the S.W. 10th Avenue right-of-way. A twenty
foot landscape buffer consisting of berming, in conjunction
with a six foot C.B.S. wall is proposed on the Wallace site
abutting the 10th Avenue right-of-way. It is to be installed
with Phase II work.
Pursuant to Section 159.29 (B), adjacent property owners are
required to provide and maintain sod and irrigation to the
edge of pavement within adjacent rights-of-way. This
proposal is unique in that no pavement exists within this
future right-of-way. This creates a situation of unclear
responsibility for care and maintenance of ,the right-of-way
area until such time as a street is constructed within it.
Upon development of Phase II, the applicant should be
responsible, pursuant to current code requirements, to\
provide sod, irrigation and maintenance for the 25 foot
right-of-way until such time as a road is constructed.
The site is proposed to be in two phases. The site plan
relating to proposed employee parking which was before the
planning and Zoning Board at its December 21, 1987, meeting
addressed perimeter landscaping in conjunction with phasing,
and the following was outlined:
A. North Boundary: Since the property to the
developed (HRS facility), it seems appropriate to
required perimeter landscaping installed along
first phase of development.
north
have
with
is
the
the
B. East Boundary: As Phase I does not incorporate any
frontage along S.W. lOth Avenue, it does not seem
appropriate to require installation of landscaping in the
dedication area since the site has no access and it would
fall into disrepair. This perimeter landscaping should be
provided concurrent with development of the balance of the
site.
c. South Boundary: The perimeter landscaping should be
provided along the southern border of the property with
exception of the extreme eastern portion which should be
provided with Phase II. Also, along the southern border
driveway connections are shown. Unless they are to be used
to connect to an approved parking lot or traffic circulation
system, the connecting driveways should not be installed at
this time, and the area should be landscaped. The applicant
has indicated an intention to abandon Queens Avenue and
incorporate the right-of-way within traffic circulation
patterns of the dealerships to the north and south. A semi
.
To: Plam.~ng and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - wallace Automobile Dealership
site and Development Plan
Page 7
truck loading area is shown along the south border taking
access from the unimproved Queens Avenue right-of-way. If
development of Phase I occurs prior to the finalization of
the abandonment, alternative off-loading areas must be
provided to assure off-loading does not occur from a
. right-of-way. Also, in the event an abandonment
is not granted, the proposed loading area would be in
violation of code.
D. West Boundary:
Germantown Road, is
landscaping will be
The entire
included in
installed.
west boundary, adjacent to
Phase One and all associated
E. Interior Boundary: Applicant should
of five feet perimeter buffering between
II. If the entire site is to be cleared
Phase I, hydro mulch must be applied
prevent erosion/blowing, etc.
F. Improvements to Germantown Road: Traffic report
prepared by Daniel Murray recommends the followin
improvements be provided to assure safe and efficien
vehicular access:
provide a minimum
Phase I and Phase
,at development of
to Phase II to
l. That a center lane for left turning traffic be
built on Germantown Road along the property
frontage.
The three lane section must be added to the site
plan and construction drawings, including proposed
striping, submitted4a and approved by the County
Engineering Department with copies provided to the
City Engineering Department.
2.
To adequately
movements, it
driveways, thus
control the southerly
is important to align
eliminating any offset.
driveway
adjacent
This item was incorporated in the last
resubmittal.
G, ,Abandonment of Queens Avenue: The site plan shows
future proposals for parking and cross access to the
existing Nissan Dealership within the Queens Avenue
right-of-way. The issue of abandonment Of Queens Avenue is
not before the Board at this time as there is property to
the east which is accessed via Queens Avenue at present.
The applicant is advised abandonment of Queens Avenue will
be required prior to any approval of a site plan that
utilizes it.
l
To: Planr g and Zoning Board
Re: Staff ~eport - Wallace Automobile ~ealership
site and Development Plan
Page 8
plattinq: Platting is required. Appropriate right-of-way
dedications for Germantown Road (10 feet) and S.W. 10th
Avenue (25 feet) are to be provided through the plat.
Landscaping: The C.A.B. reviewed the project on May 25,
1988 and approved the Landscape Plan and elevations.
Outstanding Comments:
The applicant has addressed most of the initial staff
concerns with a resubmittal, yet the following items remain
to be addressed:
1.
Elimination of: three parking spaces adjacent to
the south entry; three spaces adjacent the center
entry; and two spaces adjacent to the north entry
__ all pursuant to Section 173.772 (2) (b), as
they back out into through drives.
3.
A five foot sidewalk is to be provided along
total frontage of the property. The sidewalk is to
be located adjacent to the ultimate right-of-way
line.
t:l
2.
Northwest driveway must be reduced to a maximum
24 feet.
4.
An additional fire hydrant is required at
south side of the south building in order to
the maximum spacing of 300 feet pursuant to
Code Section 1l-6.
the
meet
Delray
5.
On-site signing should be provided for the on site
truck route (i.e. to and from the parts receiving
dock) .
ASSESSMENT:
A determination of the appropriateness of the conditional use
was addressed at the June l8, 1988, planning and Zoning
Board hearing. It was the consensus of the Board that the
conditional use is appropriate in the proposed location.
The site plan deficiencies are minor except for the one
concerning the loading area which requires maneuvering in a
public right-of-way. The agent should address ways of
handling that situation at the meeting.
ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
1. Continue with direction.
l
To: Planning and Zoning Board
Re: Staff Report - Wallace Automobile Dealership
Site and Development Plan
Page 9
2. Recommend approval of the conditional use request and the
attendent site plan subject to conditions
3.
Recommend denial for a failure of the project
adequate mitigation measures. (This action is
only if there is refusal to accommodate
conditions which are recommended).
to provide
appropriate
significant
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, based upon findings of compliance with Sections 30-21
(D) "Standards for Evaluating Conditional Uses" and 30-22-(D)
"Standards for Evaluating Si te and Development Plan
Applications", recommend approval of the conditional use of an
automotive dealership to be established pursuant to the site plan
preapred and hereby approved for 11.3 acres of land located east\
of Germantown Road, north of Queens, sUbject to the following
conditions: '
1. that either a variance is granted from the Board of
Adjustment for a reduction in the required number of
loading areas or additional areas accommodated through
revision to the site plan.
2. if Phase I construction preceeds abandonment of Queens
Avenue, or if a petition for abandonment of Queens
Avenue is not granted, that the "parts receiving"
loading dock and its access be redesigned (as a
non-impacting site plan modification) so that Queens
Avenue is not used for maneuvering purposes and
otherwise complying with dimensional requirements for
loading areas.
3. that the off-loading and storage area on the north end
of the overall site be included in Phase I development.
4. that the perimeter landscaping required along the north
boundary be provided for that length of the boundary
associated with the off-loading area.
5.
II which
development
is
be
cleared
sodded
in
and
that any part of Phase
conjunction with initial
irrigated.
6. platting shall be completed prior to applying for a
building permit the preliminary plat submission
shall accommodate and/or address, as appropriate, the
fOllowing (in addition to normal platting matters):
a) dedication of ten feet along the Germantown
frontage for right-of-way purposes;
.
To:
Re:
Planning and Zoning Board
~ff Report - Wallace Automobilr
".te and Development Plan
Page 10
alership
b) installation of a sidewalk, five feet in width,
along the entire length of the Germantown Road
frontage;
c)
d)
e)
dedication
boundary
purposes;
of twenty-five feet along the eastern
for S.W. lOth Avenue right-of-way
an improvement program for
right-of-way which shall
limited to:
the s.w.
include,
10th Avenue
but not be
deferral of ultimate buffering until
installation of S.W. 10th Avenue, or until
called for by the City; however, some aspects
of the perimeter landscaping may be required;
assumption of maintenance for the
right-of-way area and the installation of sod
and irrigation within it. \
continuation of the public sewer main from M.H.#3
to the north property l~ne, with appropriate
easements, and the main placeQ at a depth
sufficient to accommodate sewage flows from the
north.
preliminary construction plans (design plans) for
Germantown Road improvements which shall be of at
least one additional travel lane (total travelway
width of thirty-six feet); along with a pavement
marking plan. these design and pavement
marking plans shall be developed in concert with
Palm Beach County Engineering prior to their
submittal to the City.
7. that the following modification be made to the site
plan:
f)
a)
b)
c)
d)
Attachment:
elimination of parking
with points of entry
spaces) ;
spaces which are aligned
from Germantown Road (8
reduction of the northerly driveway to 24' width;
addition of a fire hycrat at the south building;
on-site signing and pavement marking for traffic
flow including the on-site truck routing.
reduction of site plan
REF / PD#6 / A:WALLACE.TXT
'I
h ~
'. 2
" II:
Ul .
---I
!t.
.w . .
I I
"l~
I '
. :'
-~fl r
.~ 1---
f; '~:
I. iii "
. ,
,..
:~.
C I T Y
COM MIS S ION
DOC U MEN TAT ION
TO:
WALTER O. BARRY, CITY MANAGER
FROM:
DAVID J. KOVACS, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 26, 1988
AGENDA ITEM ** CONSENT AGENDA **
CONSIDERATION OF A CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST (MAJOR
MODIFICATION) AND ATTENDANT SITE AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN
FOR THE EXXON GASOLINE STATION AT THE NORTHc8ST CORNER
OF ATLANTIC AVENUE AND CONGRESS AVENUE
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
Approval of a major modification to an existing
conditional use (gasoline station) and its attendant
site and development plan.
The only subsequent action with be the ministerial act
of final plat approval.
BACKGROUND:
This project involves l.34 acres of land. It encompasses the
existing Exxon Station and a .3289 parcel to the immediate north
which was annexed to the City in January of this year.
The proposal involves the demolition of all existing facilities
and construction of a kiosk and gasoline canopy and a separate
service building. Dedications for Congress and Atlantic Avenue
rights-of-way are being accommodated. Special landscaping
regulations which pertain to Congress and Atlantic are being
accommodated. No code violations or waivers are involved. A
special traffic study was required and provided relative to the
location and size of curb cuts and traffic flow on the site.
Planning and Zoning Board Action:
The Board held a public hearing on the conditional use aspect of
the request and there was no public comment. The site and
development plan was approved on a 5-2 vote. The approval was
subject to compliance with six conditions of minor significance.
CAB approval has been obtained.
~g
To: Walter o. Jarry, City Manager
Re: Consideration Of A Conditional Use Request
(Major Modification Attendant Site And Development Plan)
For The Exxon Gasoline Station At The Northwest Corner
Of Atlantic Avenue & Congress Ave.
Page 2
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
By motion, approve the conditional use request and attendant site
plan for the Exxon Station redevelopment on the north~~st corner
of Atlantic and Congress pursuant to the findings made and
conditions imposed by the Planning and Zoning Board.
Attachment:
P & Z Staff Report of July l8, 1988, Item IV.E
REF/DJK~23/CCEXXON.TXT
PLANNING B ZONING
CITY OF OELRAY
BOARD
BEACH
STAFF REPORT
---
MEETING o::tTE: JULY 18, 1988
AGeo:I ITEM: IV.E.
CONSIDERATION OF THE SITE PLAN FOR THE EXXON STATION REDEVELOPMENT AT
ITEM: CONGRESS AND ATLANTIC AND DISPOSITION OF CONDITIONAL USE REOUEST
-,
GENERAL DATA:
OWner............,..............1ZxoD co.pany U.S.A.
.nt................, .... ......Da..ld J. Felton
OOrporat. pro...rty lIervlc..
Loc.tlon........................Moctbe..t corner of W. Atlantic
A.... &IIcl 00n9i-... A....
Property .1.....................1.34 Acre. 151,51'.1' aq. ft.)
Lancl u.. Plan Dad9D&ti.......... .~rclal
Boning Dad9D&tion..............ClC lGe.....al ec-rclall
Adj......t Bonlll9.................Nort/a &IIcl1a.t of tile au!lject
- properq 1& IOned Cawlty It.
lLigllt IDclll8trl.U. .....t11 and
w..t 1. 10Mcl Clty ClC.
Ex1&tiD9 U............. 00..... ooGa...u... Sutlon
propa.edu......................Rebu11cl 9..011ne .utl0R ba..ing
7 1&l&11cl11 IIIlcler one CUlOW and III
"upancled lcJ....k. .....r.te
buJ.1cl1n9 _ld provide 3 bay. for
.utaDOtlve ..rvlclng.
Wat.r lIervlce...................w.t.r can be pro..lded by
coanectlnq lnto exi.tln9 1 1/2"
water meter on the DOrth .ide of
Atlantio Ave.
Sewer S.rvlce...................connect to. .&Ditary .ewer force
..In alOD9 OOnqre.. Ave. requir..
CODetructlon of a 11ft .tatlon.
ITEM: 1J7. E'
ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD:
The action before the Board is that of making a recommendation on
a conditional use request and attendant site plan for a proposed
rebuilding of the Exxon gas station located at the northeast
corner of Atlantic Avenue and Congress Avenue.
BACKGROUND:
On August 17, 1981, Exxon Company entered into a water service
agreement for the gas station site and agreed to annex
voluntarily when contiguous. With the annexing of adjacent
property, the Exxon site became contiguous and was sUbsequently
annexed to the City, Ordinance No lOl-82, January ll, 1983. The
zoning was, at that time, Industrial in the County but was
changed to Commercial so that the facility would come into the
City as a conforming use.
On January 25, 1988 the Planning and Zoning Board considered a
petition for annexation, rezoning and local land use amendment
for a .3289 acre parcel just north of the existing Exxon station.
The initial zoning requested was that of GC (General Commercial)
and the requested land use change was from I (Industrial) to C
(Commercial). The Planning and Zoning Board forwarded a
recommendation of approval which was sUbsequently enacted.
The petition before the Board includes the existing Exxon gas
station site and the forementioned .3289 acre parcel. The site
currently has a one story C.B.S. building with an attached canopy
covering six (6) gasoline dispensers each having two hoses, along
with a free standing canopy covering two dispensers with six
hoses each (24 total).
The new site plan proposes a kiosk/canopy combination with seven
( 7) dispensers and 42 hoses; and, a separate building as the
"main structure" to accommodate office, storage, restroom, and
service facilities.
The proposal involves expansion of the capability of the site to
accommodate more vehicles. The design is such to facilitate
traffic flo~ and work high volume pumps. Generally gas station
renovations involve a focus on providing "convenience services";
however, in this case the station has high volumes and this is
the aspect of the business which is to be enhance. However, the
design of the facility is such that the kiosk proposed to be
located under the island canopy does provide convenience services
in addition to just receipting for the payment of gasoline.
To: Planning j Zoning Board
Agenda It..,n III. F.
Cc,nditional Use and Attendant Site Plan - Exxon Station
Page2
The conditional use process is being followed since the
demolition of the existing facility and its total replacement,
and expansion, constitutes a major modification (and hence, full
processing) to an existing conditional use. On June 18,1988 the
the Board made a determination as to the appropriateness of the
use, along with a determination that the proposed repair facility
is the principal building and continued the item to the July
meeting.
PROJECT ANALYSIS,:
The request is to be reviewed pursuant to Sections 30-2l(D)
Conditional Use Standards and 30-22(D) Site and Development
Criteria as well as Section 30-17(0) Special Regulation for
gasoline stations.
Section 30-17(0)(10) (Special Regulation for Gasolin~
stations) requires' that any lift and repair facilities be located
inside of the "main structure". Action on the conditional use
request necessitated a determination of which of the structures
(the kiosk and canopy or the office/service building) constitutes
the "main structure". A determination was made by the Planning
and Zoning Board on June 18, 1988 that the "main structure" is
the office/service building.
Standards for Evaluatinq Conditional Uses:
Standard *1 (ingress and egress) The existing Exxon site has four
forty foot curb cuts, two along Atlantic Avenue and two along
Congress Avenue. The applicant, in his initial submittal, had
proposed two thirty-five foot entries along Atlantic Avenue which
comply with Section 30-17(0)(13). He also proposed to retain the
two existing forty foot entries on Congress Avenue. The maximum
driveway width pursuant to Section 30-l7(0)(13) is thirty-five
feet and the applicant has compiled with this requirement with
the site plan resubmittal.
On initial -review, the closing of entrances closest to the
intersection of Atlantic and Congress was favored by Planning and
Zoning and Engineering Departments. The applicant contends, due
to on-site traffic patterns, all existing entries are necessary.
Based upon his explanations, the staffs are inclined to support
the two accesses per street request; A traffic study addressing
traffic volumes and flow has been provided to justify the
applicants position.
To: Planning d Zoning Board
Agenda Item III.F.
Condition~l Use and Attendant Site Plan - Exxon Station
Page3
Upon review of the traffic study it appears the southern entry
along Congress Boulevard experiences limited use and could be
closed with minimal impact to the remainder of the site. The
entry however meets the minimum setbacks from the intersection
and upon 6 laning of Congress will be restricted to right turn in
and right turn out, as a median will be installed.
Standard #2 (parking and loading areas) The number of parking
spaces, 20 per Code, can been provided. Twenty-two (22) spaces
were shown on the initial submittal, however three ~~ located in
such a manner as not to readily serve customers at the kiosk or
service building (they were located at the landscaping in the
southwest corner). O,,<t. "O>?,~e.. was removed to accommodate
increased landscaping demands. The proposed parking in the
southwest corner of the site was removed to accommodate additional
landscaping in the site plan resubmittal. The applicant has
provided 21 striped spaces with two adjacent the Kiosk. The
applicant has indicated a willingness to relocate the space
shown by the Kiosk if qj,.~~ . tvlt ct-eel\\<!cl ,'na.p)'...~\a1e., _ " The
agents rational for requested credit is that people who utilize
the kiosk for convenience items will utilize the area whether it
is designated as such or not. The proposed parking space would
meet parallel parking requirements pursuant to Section 30-18 (C)
(5) (a) (4).
Standard #3 (refuse and service areas). Adequate refuse area can
and have been provided.
Standard #4 (utilities). Water service is available from a 12"
water main which runs along the north edge of Atlantic Avenue
right-of-way. The applicant is proposing a one and a half inch
connection to the office/service building.
Sewer service is presently accommodated by an on- site septic
system. The applicant proposes to enter into a joint venture
with the Chevron station located across Congress Avenue to
construct a lift station at the northeast corner of the Chevron
site which will connect to a force main which runs along the west
side of Congress Avenue. The Exxon station will construct a
lateral under Congress Avenue to access the proposed lift
station. The U\,l,ht!. ~\'~t"",,J- should verify sizing of
proposed lift stat~on on the Chevron site to assure proper
capacities are made available for future development in the area.
Standard # 5 (screens and buffers). The original submittal was
inadequate in meeting the required landscape/buffer of 20.9 feet
required pursuant to Section 30-16(K) along Atlantic Avenue. The
site also has a deficiency in meeting the lO% of paved area
internal landscaping requirement. These items have been
addressed on the revised site plans.
To: Planning i Zoning Board
Agenda It~" III.F.
Conc..itional Use anrl Attendant Site Plan - Exxon Station
Page4
Standard # 6 ( signs and lighting). Details have not yet been
reviewed. It is anticipated that new signing and lighting will
be provided. However, the existing signing and lighting appears
to be in compliance with code. A lighting plan was requested and
not received showing location, type, height, strength and
direction of proposed lighting. Submittal will be a condition of
approval.
Standard #7 (setbacks and open space). All applicable setback
minimums have been met.
Standard #8 (compatibility) and Standard #9 (height). These
standards are met in that the new structure and use are similar
to the existing conditions on site and to the south and west.
The use is also compatible with adjacent industrial uses to the
north and east.
Standard #10 (economic effects on adjacent properties). This
petition will have little economic effect on adjacent properties
as similar uses exist adjacent to the site and this proposal is
to replace an existing station.
SITE PLAN ANALYSIS:
The site plan has been reviewed using criteria outlined in
Section 30-22(D) "Standards for Evaluatinq Site and Development
Plan Applications". Following is the result of that review.
Standard #l (sufficiency of materials)
This standard has been met with an acceptable submittal.
Standard #2 (impact of the proposed use)
No additional impact is anticipated as the proposal is a
reconstruction of an existing use. The intensity of potential use
will be increased in that 14 gasoline service points will be
available compared to the 10 now available. An additional
service bay is also proposed to be added. Concerns were raised by
a board member in relation to the visual impact of the proposed
service bay building. The applicant has indicated he wishes to
proceed with the present application as the proposal will reduce
the eXisting visual impact of the building as it will be set back
an additional 55 feet. If the applicant was to provide
conventional clear glass service bay doors instead of the solid
opaque overhead doors proposed, further reduction in the impact
would be realized.
To: Planning ,d Zoning Board
Agenda It~m III.F.
Conditional Use and Attencant Site Plan - Exxon Station
Page5
Standard # 3 (ingress and egress) and Standard #4 (off street
parking and loading)
These standards have been addressed under Conditional Use
standards #l and #2
Standard #5 (screens and bUffers)
This standard has been addressed under Conditional Use standard
#5
Standard #6 (drainage)
Drainage is to be accommodated by the installation of French
drains on site. No problems appear to exist.
Standard #7 (sanitary sewers) and Standard #8 (utilities)
These standards are addressed under Standard number 4 of the
Conditional Use analysis.
Standard #9 (recreation and open space)
This standard does not apply as the proposal is a commercial
development.
Standard #10 (site development) deals with overall impact of the
site development.
The new structure and use are similar to the existing conditions
on site and to the south and west. The use is also compatible
with adjacent industrial uses to the north and east. The
intensity of the gasoline sales will be increased but at the same
time will become more efficient with the installation of quicker
dispensers. No adverse impacts are anticipated.
Other Items:
The Engineering Department is requ~r~ng the platinq prior to
issuance of any building permit. The plat will incorporate the
.3289 acre parcel to the north and make appropriate right-of-way
dedications for expanded intersection protection at Atlantic
Avenue and Congress Avenues.
The C.A.B. reviewed the project on May 25, 1988 and conveyed to
the applicant concerns regarding the adequacy of landscaping,
previously cited. The applicant was directed to revisit the site
plan with respect to these items and resubmit for C.A.B.
approval. The site plan has been scheduled for C.A.B. review on
JUly 27, 1988 applicant appears to have met all of the Board's
initial concerns.
To:
Planning a
Agenda Iteln
Conditional
Page6
Zoning Board
III. F.
Use and Attendant Site rlan - Exxon Station
Though the applicant has submitted a revised site plan addressing
staff concerns the following items have not been addressed.
1. Indicate height, type, strength and direction of proposed
lighting pursuant to Section 30-22 (G) (5) (0);
2. The following notes must be added to the landscape plan;
All landscaped areas will receive 100% irrigation from a
source other than City water.
Sod and irrigation will be provided to the edge of pavement.
All Landscaped areas adjacent high traffic areas will be
curbed pursuant to Section 9-374 (b).
All plant material will be Florida #1 or better pursuant to
Section 9-378 (c) (l).
3. Provide calculations to show that the required 10% of total
paved area is provided in interior green space.
4. Conf licts exist between the landscape plan and proposed
lighting location. Along the north perimeter two light poles
appear to conflict with tree canopies.
5. Re plating will be required prior to the issuance of any
building permit.
6. The fOllowing contributions are required of this development
and must be payed prior to issuance of a building permit.
At the time of widening of Congress Avenue, a contribution
shall be made to the City for beautification of the Avenue.
Such contribution shall defray the cost of irrigating and
landscaping the median on the roadway in accordance with
plans developed by the City. Payment shall not exceed
$10.00 per front foot and shall be applied in accordance
with an ordinance to be adopted by the City which the
applicant understands and agrees will be applicable to this
project.-
ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
l. Continue with direction
2. Recommend approval of the Conditional Use and attendant Site
plan for the Exxon Service station subject comments 1 thru 6
contained within the staff report.
To: Planning 2~d Zoning Board
Agenda It III.F.
Conditional Use and Attendant Site Plan - Exxon Station
Page7
RECOMMENDED ACTION
By motion, based upon a finding of compliance with Section 30-21
(D) " Standards for Evaluating of Conditional Uses "and Section
30-22 (D) "Standards for Evaluating Site and Development Plan
Applications ", recommend approval of the conditional use and
attendant Site Plan for the Exxon Service station subject to
conditions (l) thru (6) of the staff report.
ref:PD#6/EXXCU.TXT
.'
.
...". \
, \
'\ <i>'
i 'rt il
." ~~ "r-fJ
, ;;!I~l:J
. L@
. ," lot ~
~ .~!n t
~Io;'t~
P @
~l ~ !;I~ @
9hll>
~. .~
~ :
,
;;;
'\
~
~
76\
~
~
~,
;>
'<6'
.
.
.
~
'"
@
,
,
\~,
.
.
<i>
.
..
~
.
~
()
:fI./~."'.O/f
-I
'. ,
U
~5
....
....
...
.,....
,fI
.-
-anrf3(\~ c;<;:J'-l~o:)
---_._._--_._-~_._..-
----.------.-~-----
-.---~n~ ~".~ 19""..J
-----
.
.
RESOLUTION NO. 40-88
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY
BEACH, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 100 OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, ASSESSING COSTS
FOR ABATING NUISANCES UPON CERTAIN LAND(S) LOCATED WITHIN
THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH 1 SETTING OUT ACTUAL COSTS
INCURRED BY THE CITY TO ACCOMPLISH SUCH ABATEMENT AND
LEVYING THE COST OF SUCH ABATEMENT OF NUISANCES 1
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR A DUE DATE AND
INTEREST ON ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR THE RECORDING OF
THIS RESOLUTION, AND DECLARING SAID LEVY TO BE A LIEN
UPON THE SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR UNPAID ASSESSMENTS;
PROVIDING FOR THE MAILING OF NOTICE OF LIEN.
WHEREAS, the City manager or his designated representative has,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, declared the existence
of a nuisance upon certain lots or parcels of land, described in the
list attached hereto and made a part hereof, for violation of the
provisions of Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinancesl and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 100.20, 100.21 and 100.22 of the
Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach, the City Manager or his
designated representative has inspected said land(s) and has determined
that a nuisance existed in accordance with the standards set forth in
Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, and did furnish the respective
owner(s) of the land(s) described in the attached list with written
notice of public nuisance pursuant to Sections 100.20, 100.21 and 100.22
of the Code of Ordinances describing the nature of the nuisance(s) and
sent notice that within ten (10) days from the date of said notice
forty-two (42) days in the case of violation of Section 100.04 pertain-
ing to seawalls) they must abate said nuisance, or file a written
request for a hearing to review the decision that a nuisance existed
within seven (7) days from the date of said notice, failing in which the
City of Delray Beach would proceed to correct this condition by abating
such nuisance, and that the cost thereof would be levied as an assess-
ment against said propertYl and,
WHEREAS, the property owner(s) named in the list attached
hereto and made a part hereof did fail and neglect to abate the
nuisance(s) existing upon their respective lands or to properly request
a hearing pursuant to Section 100.21 and 100.22 within the time limits
prescribed in said notice and Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, or
if the property owner(s) did request and receive a hearing, said prop-
erty owner(s) failed and/or neglected to abate such nuisance(s) within
seven (7) days subsequent to the rendering of a decision adverse to the
property owner(s) (thirty-five (35) days for violation of 100.04); and,
WHEREAS, the City of Delray Beach, through the City Administra-
tion or such agents or contractors hireQ by the City Administration was
therefore required to and did enter upon the land(s) described in the
list attached and made a part hereof and incurred costs in abating the
subject nuisance(s) existing thereon as described in the notice; and,
WHEREAS, the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach has,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray
Beach, submitted to the City Commission a report of the costs incurred
in abating said nuisance (s) as aforesaid, said report indicating the
costs per parcel of land involved; and,
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances desires to assess the
cost of said nuisance(s) against said property owner(s),
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
59
Section 1. That assessments in the individual amounts as shown
by the report of the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach, involving
the City I s cost of abating the aforesaid nuisances upon the lots or
parcels of land described in said report, a copy of which is attached
hereto and made a part hereof, are hereby levied against the parcells)
of land described in said report and in the amount(s) indicated thereon.
Said assessments so levied shall, if not paid within thirty (30) days
after mailing of the notice described in Sec. 3, become a lien upon the
respective lots and parcells) of land described in said report, of the
same nature and to the same extent as the lien for general city taxes
and shall be collectible in the same manner and with the same penalties
and under the same provisions as to sale and foreclosure as City taxes
are collectible.
Section 2. That such assessments shall be legal, valid and
binding obligations upon the property against which said assessments are
levied.
Section 3. That the City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach is
hereby directed to immediately mail by first class mail to the owner(s)
of the property, as such ownership appears upon the records of the
County Tax Assessor, notice(s) that the City Commission of the City of
Delray Beach on the has levied an
assessment against said property for the cost of abatement of said
nuisance by the City, and that said assessment is due and payable within
thirty (30) days after the mailing date of said notice of assessment,
after which a lien shall be placed on said property, and interest will
accrue at the rate of 8% per annum, plus reasonable attorney's fees and
other costs of collecting said sums.
Section 4. That this resolution shall become effective thirty
(30) days from the date of adoption and the assessment(s) contained
herein shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of said assessment(s), after which a lien shall be
placed on said property(s), and interest shall accrue at the rate of
eight (8) percent per annum plus, if collection proceedings are
necessary, the costs of such proceedings including a reasonable
attorney's fee.
Section 5. That in the event that payment has not been
received by the City Clerk within thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of assessment, the City Clerk is hereby directed to
record a certified copy of this resolution in the public records of Palm
Beach County, Florida, and upon the date and time of recording of the
certified copy of this resolution a lien shall become effective on the
subject property which shall secure the cost of abatement, interest at
the rate of 8%, and collection costs including a re~sonable attorney's
fee.
Section 6. That at the time the City C~erk sends the certified
copy of this resolution for recording, a notice of lien, in the form
prescribed in Section 100.27 of the Code of Ordinances, shall be mailed
to the property owner.
of
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on this the
, 1988.
day
MAY 0 R
ATTEST:
City Clerk
- 2 -
Res. No. 40-88
COST OF ABATING NUISANCES UNDER CHAPTER 100
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
RESUB. OF S 1/2 OF BLK 38 &
N 1/2 OF BLOCK 39, DELRAY
BEACH, LOT 13, BLK 38, PB 11,
P 34, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(SW 3RD AVE)
LOT 1, BLK 67, TOWN OF DELRAY,
PB 1, P 3,PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY,FL.
(145 N SWINTON AVE)
LOT 9 & 25' OF LOT 10, BLK 66,
TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 2, P 81,
PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FL.
(248 NE 1ST AVE)
LOT 5, BLK B, WEST SIDE
HEIGHTS, PB 13, P 61, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(131 NW 9TH AVE)
LOT 4, BLK B, WEST SIDE
HEIGHTS, PB 13, P 61, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(133 NW 9TH AVE)
S 50' OF N lIS' OF W 135' OF
BLK 26, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 5,
P 64, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 5TH AVE)
S 150' OF E 50' OF BLOCK 18/
LESS E 20' RD R/W, TOWN OF
DELRAY, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 2ND STREET)
E 100' OF W 200' OF N 50' OF
BLK 18, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 1,
P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 3RD STREET)
S 50' OF N 200' OF W 120' OF
BLK 25, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 5,
P 2, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 5TH AVE)
S 50' OF N 300' OF E 135' OF
BLK 20, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 1,
P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 5TH AVE)
LOT 15, BLK A, CARVER MEMORIAL
PARK, PB 20, P 56, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(245 NW 14TH AVE)
S 3' OF LOT 10 & LOTS 11 & 12,
BLK 43, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 1,
P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(134 NW 2ND AVE)
OWNER
RONNEY E GILBERT
500 WEDGEWOOD PLAZA #508
RIVIERA BEACH, FL 33404
$180.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
JEANNE M. VAN TREESE $ 15.00
145 N SWINTON 50.00 (ADM. COST)
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444 (RECORDING)
K. C. & PATRICIA RODE $ 15.00
HUSBAND AND WIFE 50.00 (ADM. COST)
ROUTE 1 BOX 191 R (RECORDING)
HIAWASSEE, GA. 30546
& LOAN $ 50.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
( RECORDING)
FIRST FED. SAVINGS
C/O WIENER ET AL
P.O. BOX 694347
MIAMI, FL. 33269
JOSEPH E. THURIN
GISHLAINE & JEAN P. LOY
133 NW 9TH AVE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
FREDERICK D. MC COY JR.
215 NW 5TH AVE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
H. & HAZEL CLEM
HUSBAND AND WIFE
3 SUMMER STREET
NORWALK, CT. 06851
$ 40.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 40.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 60.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
L.& VASSEINA WILLIAMS EST $ 35.00
HUSBAND AND WIFE 50.00 (ADM. COST)
227 NW 5TH AVE (RECORDING)
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
EDWIN C. IVY $ 35.00
519 SW 15TH TERRACE 50.00 (ADM. COST)
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444 (RECORDING)
CLARENCE SR.& RUTHIE
EVANS (HUSBAND & WIFE)
400 NW 8TH AVE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
EVELINA GAINER
245 NW 14TH AVE
DELRAY BEACH, FL.
33444
EDDIE JR. & YVONNE ODOM
HUSBAND AND WIFE
3905 LOWSON BLVD.
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33445
-3-
$125.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$205.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
( RECORD IN G)
$ 50.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
Res. No. 40-8il
S 3' OF LOT 10 & ,LOTS 11 & 12,
BLK 43, TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 1,
P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(126 NW 2ND AVE)
LOT 12, BLK 96, LINN'S ADD. TO
OSCEOLA PARK, PB 1, P 133,
PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FL.
(347 SE 3RD AVE)
N 50' OF W 130.44' OF W 1/2 OF
S 1/2 OF BLK 4, TOWN OF DELRAY,
PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 8TH AVE)
LOT 27, BLK 1, ATLANTIC PARK
GARDENS, PB 14, P 56, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 12TH AVE)
LOT l3/LESS S 20', BLK 28, TOWN
OF DELRAY, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(W ATLANTIC AVE & NW 5TH AVE.)
LOTS 1 TO 9 INCL, RESUB OF BLK
85, BLK 85, DELRAY, PB 4, P 14,
PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FL.
(29 SE 2ND AVE)
LOT 21, BLK 49, TOWN OF DELRAY,
PB 12, P 86, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 4TH STREET & NW 1ST AVE)
LOT 19, BLK 12, MONROE SUB.,
PB 14, P 67, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 6TH AVE)
N 69.5' OF LOT 9, BLK 78, TOWN
OF DELRAY, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(SE 2ND AVE & SE 1ST ST)
E 50' OF W 583' OF S 140' OF
N 165' OF N 1/2 OF NW 1/4 OF
SW 1/4 OF NW 1/4, SUB 17-46-43,
PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 2ND STREET)
S 53' OF LOT 2, BLK 43, TOWN OF
DELRAY, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(133 NW 3RD AVE)
N 100' OF E 131.6' OF BLK 63,
TOWN OF DELRAY, PB 6, P 3,
PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FL.
200 S SWINTON AVE)
LOT 21, BLK B, TOURIST NOOK,
DELRAY, PB 11, P 47, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 8TH AVE)
EDDIE JR. & YVONNE ODOM
HUSBAND AND WIFE
3905 LOWSON BLVD.
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33445
PIERRE & BERNADETTE
PONGNON (HUSBAND & WIFE)
FRANCIOS S.ITACY &
W. MARCEAU
347 SE 3RD AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33445
EARL & ODESSA MCDONALD
HUSBAND AND WIFE
414 SW 15TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
BENNIE THOMAS
1720 1ST STREET N
WINTER HAVEN, FL. 33881
SHUKRI AYESH
5911 ALBERT ROAD
W. PALM BEACH, FL. 33415
$ 50.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 25.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 60.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 49.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 35.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
WILLIAM C.WILLIAMS III TR $ 85.00
PALM BEACH CO. COURTHOUSE 50.00 (ADM. COST)
#314 (RECORDING)
W. PALM BEACH, FL. 33410
PAUL V. SCUREI
151 NE 5TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33483
WILLIE & ANNIE ALBERT EST
HUSBAND & WIFE
34 NW 6TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
J.REEVE & ANNE S.BRIGHT
HUSBAND & WIFE
700 SEA SAGE DRIVE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33483
JACQUEL DAWSON
2917-82 SW 13TH STREET
GAINESVILLE, FL. 32608
GEORGE & DOROTHY M. MACK
HUSBAND & WIFE
313 SW 11TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
CLERMONT MESIDOR
200 S SWINTON AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
ROSS WISKIN
3680 FRANWOOD CIRCLE
APT #101
BRADENTEN, FL. 33505
-4-
$ 45.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 70.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 55.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 50.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 60.0(1
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 10.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 25.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
Res. No. 40-88
LOT 12, BLK 3, NORTHRIDGE, PB
23, P 168, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(1917 N SWINTON AVE)
LOT 29, BLK B, TOURIST NOOK,
PB 11, P 47, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 8TH AVENUE)
S 30' OF LOT 6, BLK 28, TOWN
OF DELRAY, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 5TH AVENUE)
S 24.7' OF LOT 5 & N 44.7' OF
LOT 6, BLK 28, TOWN OF DELRAY,
PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC RECORDS,
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(NW 5TH AVE)
S 50' OF N 208' OF E 208' OF
W 1/2 OF E 1/2 OF N 1/2 OF
LOT l/LESS 25' OF RQ R/W, SUB.
OF SEC 20-46-43, PB 28, P 68,
PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FL.
(418 SW 5TH AVE)
E 50' OF W 450' OF S 135' OF
W 1/2 OF S 1/2 OF LOT 5, SUB.
8-46-43, PB 1, P 3, PUBLIC
RECORDS, PALM BEACH COUNTY,FL.
(NW 4TH STREET)
CORA A. DAPP
1917 NW 8TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
DELVERNA C. RILEY
231 NW 8TH AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
LEONARD DAVUS
C/O GENERAL DELIVERY
LOS ANGELES, CA. 90073
ALEC M. SHATZ
THOMAS J. WOOLLEY, JR.
P.O. BOX JJ
BOYNTON BEACH, FL. 33435
HAZEL SANDERS
P.O. BOX 1162
CRYSTAL RIVER, FL. 32629
CARRIE WILLIAMS
615 NW 4TH STREET
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
$ 50.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 35.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 80.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 70.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 55.00
50.00 (ADM.COST)
(RECORDING)
$ 45.00
50.00 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
VIOLATION IS: SEC 100.02 LAND TO BE KEPT FREE OF DEBRIS, VEGETATION, MATTER
CONSTITUTING HAZARDS; DECLARED NUISANCE.
-5-
Res. No. 40-88
RESOLUTION NO. 41-88
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY
BEACH, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 100 OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, ASSESSING COSTS
FOR ABATING NUISANCES UPON CERTAIN LAND(S) LOCATED WITHIN
THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH; SETTING OUT ACTUAL COSTS
INCURRED BY THE CITY TO ACCOMPLISH SUCH ABATEMENT AND
LEVYING THE COST OF SUCH ABATEMENT OF NUISANCES;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR A DUE DATE AND
INTEREST ON ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR THE RECORDING OF
THIS RESOLUTION, AND DECLARING SAID LEVY TO BE A LIEN
UPON THE SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR UNPAID ASSESSMENTS;
PROVIDING FOR THE MAILING OF NOTICE OF LIEN.
WHEREAS, the City manager or his designated representative has,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, declared the existence
of a nuisance upon certain lots or parcels of land, described in the
list attached hereto and made a part hereof, for violation of the
provisions of Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 100.20, 100.21 and 100.22 of the
Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach, the City Manager or his
designated representative has inspected said land(s) and has determined
that a nuisance existed in accordance with the standards set forth in
Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, and did furnish the respective
owner(s) of the land(s) described in the attached list with written
notice of public nuisance pursuant to Sections 100.20, 100.21 and 100.22
of the Code of Ordinances describing the nature of the nuisance(s) and
sent notice that within ten (10) days from the date of said notice
forty-two (42) days in the case of violation of Section 100.04 pertain-
ing to seawalls) they must abate said nuisance, or file a written
request for a hearing to review the decision that a nuisance existed
within seven (7) days from the date of said notice, failing in which the
City of Delray Beach would proceed to correct this condition by abating
such nuisance, and that the cost thereof would be levied as an assess-
ment against said property; and,
WHEREAS, the property owner(s) named in the list attached
hereto and made a part hereof did fail and neglect to abate the
nuisance(s) existing upon their respective lands or to properly request
a hearing pursuant to Section 100.21 and 100.22 within the time limits
prescribed in said notice and Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances, or
if the property owner(s) did request and receive a hearing, said prop-
erty owner(s) failed and/or neglected to abate such nuisance(s) within
seven (7) days subsequent to the rendering of a decision adverse to the
property owner(s) (thirty-five (35) days for violati~n of 100.04); and,
WHEREAS, the City of Delray Beach, through the City Administra-
tion or such agents or contractors hired by the City Administration was
therefore required to and did enter upon the land(s) described in the
list attached and made a part hereof and incurred costs in abating the
subject nuisance(s) existing thereon as described in the notice; and,
WHEREAS, the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach has,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray
Beach, submitted to the City Commission a report of the costs incurred
in abating said nuisance(s) as aforesaid, said report indicating the
costs per parcel of land involved; and,
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach,
pursuant to Chapter 100 of the Code of Ordinances desires to assess the
cost of said nuisance(s) against said property owner(s),
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
OF THE
tlO
Section 1. That assessments in the individual amounts as shown
by the report of the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach, involving
the City's cost of abating the aforesaid nuisances upon the lots or
parcels of land described in said report, a copy of which is attached
hereto and made a part hereof, are hereby levied against the parcells)
of land described in said report and in the amount(s) indicated thereon.
Said assessments so levied shall, if not paid wi thin thirty (30) days
after mailing of the notice described in Sec. 3, become a lien upon the
respective lots and parcells) of land described in said report, of the
same nature and to the same extent as the lien for general city taxes
and shall be collectible in the same manner and with the same penalties
and under the same provisions as to sale and foreclosure as City taxes
are collectible.
Section 2. That such assessments shall be legal, valid and
binding obligations upon the property against which said assessments are
levied.
Section 3. That the City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach is
hereby directed to immediately mail by first class mail to the owner(s)
of the property, as such ownership appears upon the records of the
County Tax Assessor, notice(s) that the City Commission of the City of
Delray Beach on the has levied an
assessment against said property for the cost of abatement of said
nuisance by the City, and that said assessment is due and payable within
thirty (30) days after the mailing date of said notice of assessment,
after which a lien shall be placed on said property, and interest will
accrue at the rate of 8% per annum, plus reasonable attorney's fees and
other costs of collecting said sums.
Section 4. That this resolution shall become effective thirty
(30) days from the date of adoption and the assessment (s) contained
herein shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of said assessment(s), after which a lien shall be
placed on said property(s), and interest shall accrue at, the rate of
eight (8) percent per annum plus, if collection proceedings are
necessary, the costs of such proceedings including a reasonable
attorney's fee.
Section 5. That in the event that payment has not been
received by the City Clerk within thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of assessment, the City Clerk is hereby directed to
record a certified copy of this resolution in the public records of Palm
Beach County, Florida, and upon the date and time of recording of the
certified copy of this resolution a lien shall become effective on the
subject property which shall secure the cost of abatement, interest at
the rate of 8%, and collection costs including a reasonable attorney's
fee.
Section 6. That at the time the City Clerk sends the certified
copy of this resolution for recording, a notice of lien, in the form
prescribed in Section 100.27 of the Code of Ordinances, shall be mailed
to the property owner.
of
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on this the
, 1988.
day
MAYOR
ATTEST:
City Clerk
- 2 -
Res. No. 41-88
CPST OF ABATING NUISANCES UNDER CHAPTER 100
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
LOT 43 (LESS S 23' RD R/W) &
S 1/2 OF ABNDED PRINCESS BLVD.
LYG. N OF & ADJ. THERETO, SANDS
OF SEA, DELRAY BEACH, PB 21,
P 27, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(LINTON BLVD.)
LOT 44 (LESS S 23' RD R/W) &
S 1/2 OF ABNDED PRINCESS BLVD.
LYG. N OF & ADJ. THERETO, SANDS
o SEA, DELRAY BEACH, PB 21,
P 27, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(LINTON BLVD.)
LOT 45 (LESS S 23' RD R/W) &
S 1/2 OF ABNDED PRINCESS BLVD.
LYG. N OF & ADJ. THERETO, SANDS
o SEA, DELRAY BEACH, PB 21,
P 27, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(LINTON BLVD.)
LOT 46 (LESS S 23' RD R/W) &
S 1/2 OF ABNDED PRINCESS BLVD.
LYG. N OF & ADJ. THERETO, SANDS
o SEA, DELRAY BEACH, PB 21,
P 27, PUBLIC RECORDS, PALM
BEACH COUNTY, FL.
(LINTON BLVD.)
OWNER
BARRY GARFIELD
691 SOUTH DIXIE HWY.
POMPANO BEACH, FL 33060
BARRY GARFIELD
691 SOUTH DIXIE HWY.
POMPANO BEACH, FL 33060
BARRY GARFIELD
691 SOUTH DIXIE HWY.
POMPANO BEACH, FL 33060
BARRY GARFIELD
691 SOUTH DIXIE HWY.
POMPANO BEACH, FL 33060
ASSESSMENT
$937.50
12.50 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$937.50
12.50 (ADM. COST)
(RECORD IN G)
$937.50
12.50 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
$937.50
12.50 (ADM. COST)
(RECORDING)
VIOLATION IS: SEC. 100.02 LAND TO BE KEPT FREE OF DEBRIS, VEGETATION, MATTER
CONSTITUTING HAZARDS; DECLARED NUISANCE.
-3-
Res. No. 41-88
RESOLUTION NO. 42-88
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY
BEACH, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 165, OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF DEL RAY BEACH, ASSESSING COSTS
FOR ABATEMENT ACTION REGARDING AN UNSAFE BUILDING ON
LAND(S) LOCATED WITHIN THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH; SETTING
OUT ACTUAL COSTS INCURRED BY THE CITY TO ACCOMPLISH SUCH
ABATEMENT AND LEVYING THE COST OF SUCH ACTION; PROVIDING
FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR A DUE DATE AND INTEREST
ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR THE RECORDING OF THIS RESOLU-
TION, AND DECLARING SAID LEVY TO BE A LIEN UPON THE
SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR UNPAID ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR
THE MAILING OF NOTICE.
WHEREAS, the Building Official or his designated representative
has, pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances, declared the
existence of an unsafe building upon certain lots or parcels of land,
described in the list attached hereto and made a part hereof, for
violation of the building codes and building requirements adopted by
Chapter 165 and those Codes adopted in Chapter 96 of the Code of Ord-
inances; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances of
the City of Delray Beach, the Building Official or his designated
representative has inspected said land (s) and has determined that an
unsafe building existed in accordance with the standards set forth in
Chapter 165 and/or Chapter 96 of the Code of Ordinances, and did furnish
the respective owner(s) of the land(s) described in the attached list
with written notice of unsafe building and detailed report of conditions
and notice to vacate as the Building Official determined that the
building was manifestly unsafe and is considered a hazard to life and
public welfare pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances
describing the nature of the violations and sent notices that the build-
ing was to be vacated and that the building was to be repaired or
demolished; work must be begun within sixty (60) days and all work must
be completed within such time as the Building Official determines, said
notice also advised that all appeals must be filed within thirty (30)
days from the date of service of the notice and failure to file an
appeal or to make the repairs required that the Building Official would
have the authority to have the building demolished from the date of the
said notice; and,
WHEREAS, all the notice requirements contained within Chapter
165 have been complied with; and,
WHEREAS, neither an appeal to the Board of Construction Appeals
or corrective action was undertaken in accordance with the order of the
Chief Building Official; therefore pursuant to Section 165.41 the Build-
ing Official caused the abatement action to be done; and,
WHEREAS, the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach has,
pursuant to Section 165.42 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Delray Beach, submitted to the City Commission a report of the costs
incurred in abating said condition as aforesaid, said report indicating
the costs per parcel of land involved; and,
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach,
pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances desires to assess the
cost of said condition against said property owner(s).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
lj/
Section 1. That assessments in the amount of$l,298.00
One thousand two hundred ninety eight and nO/lOO dollars as shown by
the report of the City Manager of the City of Delray a copy of which is
attached hereto and made a part hereof, are hereby levied against the
parcel (s) of land described in said report and in the amount (s) indi-
cated thereon. Said assessments so levied shall, if not paid within
thirty (30) days after mailing of the notice described in Section 165.42
become a lien upon the respective lots and parcells) of land described
in said report, of the same nature and to the same extent as the lien
for general city taxes and shall be collectible in the same manner and
with the same penalties and under the same provisions as to sale and
foreclosure as City taxes are collectible.
Section 2. That such assessments shall be legal, valid and
binding obligations upon the property against which said assessments are
levied.
Section 3. That the City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach is
hereby directed to immediately mail by certified mail, postage prepaid,
return receipt requested, to the owner(s) of the property, as such
ownership appears upon the records of the County Tax Assessor, notice(s)
that the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has levied an assess-
ment against said property for the cost of abatement action regarding an
unsafe building by the thirty (30) days after the mailing date of said
notice of assessment, after which a lien shall be placed on said proper-
ty, and interest will accrue at the rate of six percent (6%) per annum,
plus reasonable attorney's fees and other costs of collecting said sums.
Section 4. That this resolution shall become effective thirty
(30) days from the date of adoption and the assessment(s) contained
herein shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of said assessment(s), after which a lien shall be
placed on said property(s), and interest shall accrue at the rate of six
percent (6%) per annum plus reasonable attorney's fee and other costs of
collection.
Section 5. That in the event that payment has not been re-
ceived by the City Clerk within thirty (30) days after the mailing date
of the notice of assessment, the City Clerk is hereby directed to record
a certified copy of this resolution in the public records of Palm Beach
County, Florida, and upon the date and time of recording of the certi-
fied copy of this resolution a lien shall become effective on the
subject property which shall secure the cost of abatement, interest at
the rate of 6%, and collection costs including a reasonable attorney's
fee.
of
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on this the
, 19
day
MAY 0 R
ATTEST:
City Clerk
- 2 -
Res. NO.42-88
NOI'ICE OF ASSESSMENr
July 26, 1988
Date
TO: Dolores A. Libby, Trustee
ADDRESS: 8 Hazel Street, Cranford, NJ 07016
PROPERTY: 911 North Federal Highway, Delray Beach, Fl 33444
LEGAL ~ION: Lots 8 and 9 (less rd r/w), Block 2, Sophia Frey Addition
You, as the record owner of, or holder of an interest in, the above-described
property are hereby advised that a cost of $1,298.00 by resolution of
the City Council of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, dated Julv 26
19 88, has J:Jeen levied against the above-described property.
The costs were incurred as a result of a nuisance abatement action regarding
the above-described prbperty. You were given written notice on 7-5-88
that the building official has determined that a building located on the above-
described property was unsafe. You were advised in that notice of the action to
be taken to remedy that unsafe condition and of the time within which the remedial
action was required to be taken.
You failed to appeal the decision of the bJilding official to
the Board of Construction Appeals although you were infomed
of your right to an appeal and of the procedures for obtaining
appeal. You have also failed to take the corrective action
required by the notice of the bJilding official.
x
You appealed the decision of the bJilding official to the
Board of Const.J:uction Appeals. You were given written
notification on that you were required
to take the corrective action required by the decision of
the Board of Construction Appeals within a stated period of
tiIre. You failed to take the action as required by the order
of the Board of Construction Appeals.
'!he City of Delray Beach has therefore taken rerredial action to rellDVe the
unsafe condition existing on the above-described property on 6-22-88
at a cost of $1,298.00 which incluJes a ten percent (10%)
administrative fee. If you fail to pay this cost within thirty (30) days, that
cost shall be recorded on the Official Records of Palm Beach County, Florida
against the above-described property.
Copy of all notices referred to in this notice are available in the office
of the bJilding official.
BY ORDER OF THE CITY COUNCIL.
//);~a,~,
City lerk
RESOLUTION NO. 43-88
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY
BEACH, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 165, OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, ASSESSING COSTS
FOR ABATEMENT ACTION REGARDING AN UNSAFE BUILDING ON
LAND(S) LOCATED WITHIN THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH; SETTING
OUT ACTUAL COSTS INCURRED BY THE CITY TO ACCOMPLISH SUCH
ABATEMENT AND LEVYING THE COST OF SUCH ACTION; PROVIDING
FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR A DUE DATE AND INTEREST
ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR THE RECORDING OF THIS RESOLU-
TION, AND DECLARING SAID LEVY TO BE A LIEN UPON THE
SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR UNPAID ASSESSMENTS; PROVIDING FOR
THE MAILING OF NOTICE.
WHEREAS, the Building Official or his designated representative
has, pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances, declared the
existence of an un~afe building upon certain lots or parcels of land,
described in the list attached hereto and made a part hereof, for
violation of the building codes and building requirement~ adopted by
Chapter 165 and those Codes adopted in Chapter 96 of the Code of Ord-
inances; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances of
the City of Delray Beach, the Building Official or his designated
representative has inspected said land(s) and has determined that an
unsafe building existed in accordance with the standards set forth in
Chapter 165 and/or Chapter 96 of the Code of Ordinances, and did furnish
the respective owner(s) of the land(s) described in the attached list
with written notice of unsafe building and detailed report of conditions
and notice to vacate as the Building Official determined that the
'building was manifestly unsafe and is considered a hazard to life and
public welfare pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances
describing the nature of the violations and sent notices that the build-
ing was to be vacated and that the building was to be repaired or
demolished; work must be begun within sixty (60) days and all work must
be completed within such time as the Building Official determines, said
notice also advised that all appeals must be filed within thirty (30)
days from the date of service of the notice and failure to file an
appeal or to make the repairs required that the Building Official would
have the authority to have the building demolished from the date of the
said notice; and,
WHEREAS, all the notice requirements contained within Chapter
165 have been complied with; and,
WHEREAS, neither an appeal to the Board of Construction Appeals
or corrective action was undertaken in accordance with the order of the
Chief Building Official; therefore pursuant to Section 165.41 the Build-
ing Official caused the abatement action to be done; 'and,
WHEREAS, the City Manager of the City of Delray Beach has,
pursuant to Section 165.42 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Delray Beach, submitted to the City Commission a report of the costs
incurred in abating said condition as aforesaid, said report indicating
the costs per parcel of land involved; and,
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach,
pursuant to Chapter 165, of the Code of Ordinances desires to assess the
cost of said condition against said property owner(s).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
1/02.
Section 1. That assessments in the amount of $2,578.40
Two thousana r~ve nundred seventy eight and 40/l00 dollars as shown by
the report of the City Manager of the City of Delray a copy of which ~s
attached hereto and made a part hereof, are hereby levied against the
parcel (s) of land described in said report and in the amount (s) indi-
cated thereon. Said assessments so levied shall, if not paid within
thirty (30) days after mailing of the noti'~e described in Section 165.42
become a lien upon the respective lots and parcells) of land described
in said report, of the same nature and to the same extent as the lien
for general city taxes and shall be collectible in the same manner and
with the same penalties and under the same provisions as to sale and
foreclosure as City taxes are collectible.
Section 2. That such assessments shall be legal, valid and
binding obligations upon the property against which said assessments are
levied.
Section 3. That the City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach is
hereby directed to immediately mail by certified mail, postage prepaid,
return receipt requested, to the owner (s) 0 f the property, as such
ownership appears upon the records of the County Tax Assessor, notice(s)
that the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has levied an assess-
ment against said property for the cost of abatement action regarding an
unsafe building by the thirty (30) days after the mailing date of said
notice of assessment, after which a lien shall be placed on said proper-
ty, and interest will accrue at the rate of six percent (6%) per annum,
plus reasonable attorney's fees and other costs of collecting said sums.
Section 4. That this resolution shall become effective thirty
(30) days from the date of adoption and the assessment (s) contained
herein shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing
date of the notice of said assessment(s), after which a lien shall be
placed on said property(s), and interest shall accrue at the rate of six
percent (6%) per annum plus reasonable attorney's fee and other costs of
collection.
Section 5. That in the event that payment has not been re-
ceived by the City Clerk within thirty (30) days after the mailing date
of the notice of assessment, the City Clerk is hereby directed to record
a certified copy of this resolution in the public records of Palm Beach
County, Florida, and upon the date and time of recording of the certi-
fied copy of this resolution a lien shall become effective on the
subject property which shall secure the cost of abatement, interest at
the rate of 6%, and collection costs including a reasonable attorney's
fee.
of
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on this the
, 19
day
MAY 0 R
ATTEST:
City Clerk
- 2 -
Res. No. 43-88
NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT
July 26, 1988
Date
TO: Margaret Jenkins and Marion A. Newman
ADDRESS: 104 NW 9th Avenue, Delray Beach, Fl 33444
PROPERTY: 102 NW 10th Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida
LEGAL DESC1tD?rION: S50' of E135' of S~ of N~ of Lot 6, less E25' st r/w in Section
17-46-43
You, as the record owner of, or holder of an interest in, the above-described
property are hereby advised that a cost of $2,578.40
the City Council of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, dated
19 , has .been levied against the above-described property.
bv resolution of
uUJ.Y 16, 1988
,
The costs were incurred as a result of a nuisance abatement action regarding
the alJove-described property. You were given written notice on 10-23-87
that the building official has determined that a building located on the above-
described property was unsafe. You were advised in that notice of the action to
be taken to rerredy that unsafe condition and of the tllrA within which the rerredial
action was reqll..ired to be taken.
x You failed to appeal the decision of the building official to
the Board of Construction Appeals although you were infOrmad
of your right to an appeal and of the procedures for obtaining
appeal. You have also failed to take the corrective action
required by the notice of the building official.
You appealed the decision of the building official to the
Board of Construction Appeals. You were given written
notification on that you were required
to take the corrective action required by the decision of
the Board of Construction Appeals within a stated period of
time. You failed to take the action as required by the order
of the Board of Construction Appeals.
The City of Delray Beach has therefore taken rerredial action to renove the
unsafe condition existing on the above-described property on 6-17-88
at a cost of $2,578.40 which includes a ten percent (10%)
administrative fee. If you fail to pay this cost within thirty (30) days, that
cost shall be recorded on the Official Records of Palm Beach County, Florida
against the above-described property.
Copy of all notices referred to in this notice are available in the office
of the building official.
BY ORDER OF THE CITY COUNCIL.
~Y:1~ fc~'~1"~~
,~: :~ ":1'~ 'i
-J
'UI "] E' l
'JI j' .-
., ',' '.,' " ,~
,1,:,; 'j
" i'" i
",' ,,? .'"
,~ Q,,, ~\
, . "..~
MEMORANDUM
TO: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
FROM:
Robert A. Barcinski, Assistant City Manager/
Management Services
~ ,A ' (3. IS/(
SUBJECT: DOCUMENTATION - CITY COMMISSION MEETING -
JULY 26, 1988 - PURCHASE AWARD - SCOTT AIRPACS -
FOR FIRE DEPARTMENT
DATE: July 18, 1988
Item Before Commission:
City Commission is requested to award a sole-source purchase
to the Safety Equipment Company, in the amount of
$21, 7 43.30; funding available in the Utility Tax Construc-
tion Fund.
Background:
The Fire Department has requested that only Scott airpacs be
purchased for their use to maintain continuity of equipment
and for ability to perform in-house repairs and maintenance.
Purchasing has documentation that Safety Equipment Company
is the sole distributor for Scott products for the State of
Florida. Purchasing also has documentation showing the cost
of this equipment is less then list price and therefore is
fair and reasonable.
Recommendation:
Staff recommends award on a sole-source basis to Safety
Equipment Company, in the amount of $21,743.30, with funds
to come from Utility Tax Construction Fund.
RAB:sk
attachments
, '3 -A
:lE~10RANDL"1
To:
From:
Robert A, Barcinski- Asst, City Manager!
Mana~emerlt Ser\"ices
Ted Glas- r"urchasing Director ::;r~
Date:
July 6. 1988
Subject:
Purchase of Scott Airpacs for Fire Department
The Fire Department is requestin~ sole-source pr'ocurement of
Scott airpacs and spare bottles, per their attached memo,
Documentation is attached sllowing tbe firm Safety Equipment
Company is the exclusive dlstributor for Scott equipment for
the state of Flol'ida.
Documentatioll is also attached showing the prices offered by
Safety Equiploellt Company al"e I'educed by 5% for the airpacs
and 15% for the bottles, below list pricing, Therefore, the
prices would seem to be fair and l'easonable.
The Fire Department desires to trade-in ten of their old
alrpacs for a credil of $1,000.
It is recommended that the purchase of ten 101 airpacs and
twenty-five 1251 bottles be awarded to Safe~)' Equipment
Company, at a price of $1,537.33 each for ti,e Scott airpacs
and $29",80 each for the bot tIes, less trade-in, for a total
cost of S21,I~J.30.
Per the B\ld~et Director, funding [(.11' this purchase is
available in account .333-2311-522-60,89 (Utility Tax
f:ollstruction Flind-Capital Outlay-Equipment, Otller}.
Attachments:
4emorandum from Fire Department
Ducumentation on Sole-Source & Pricing
pc ~ike ~j_~derson
Yvonne f\ i Ilf.:'aide
DEPAR1.v1ENTAL [ITY OF \
CORRESPONDENCE I
DELRAY BEA[H
TO TED GLAS, PURCHASING DIRECTOR ~Ci
FROM M. B, WIGDERSON, ASSISTANT FIRE CHIEF
SUBJECT
PURCHASE SCOTT AIR PAKS
DATE
5/16/88
I am requesting the purchase of ten (10) complete Scott S.C.B.A,
PNH930231-6l and 25 lightweight bottles PNH803162-01,
This purchase is part of our three year plan to up-grade our system,
This order will be a sole source purchase to maintain our continuity of
equipment and our ability to do in house repair and maintenance. The order
will be placed through a dealer for Scott air equipment in the State of
Florida,
1 will be turning in 10 of our old S.C,B,A. that we are no longer able
to use, for a credit of $1,000.00.
The cost of each complete unit will
The cost for each spare bottle will
be $1,537,33 X 10 =
be 294.80 X 25 =
SUB TOTAL
Less the $1,000,00 credit
TOTAL
$15,373.30
7,370,00
$22,743,30
$21,743,30
Your concurrence in this matter would be appreciated,
~3.
M. B. Wigderson
Assistant Fire Chief
MBW/nunh
-~
eM 362
THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS
I i6.;,,~ "
.",'.'-\.,.",",.".,.,"
.>:.~.~t:r:..-:.
::,J~~-~~f_;~,
smtr~
September 16, 1987
City of Del Ray Beach
101 W. Atlantic Avenue
Del Ray Beach, FL 33444
ATTENTION: Captain Michael Wigderson
SUBJECT: Scott Products Distribution
Dear Capt. Wigderson:
Scott Aviation Health and Safety Products are sold to customers through a
distributor network. I
Safety Equipment Company is our exclusive distributor for Air Supplied
Respiratory Products and Air Purifying Respiratory Products for the state of
Florida.
Cordially,
',~) ,) "
. ...,,"'-Lift, d /'JNt'--r-1'.1-tt
Shirlee R. Bowden
Manager of Customer Service
Health/Safety Products
SRB:dmt
SCOTT AVIATION. A FIGGIE INTERNATIONAL COMPANY g
225 Erie Streel, Lan_ler, NY 104086 Tel: 716-883-5100 Telex: 91-394
Safety
r:r:r;::rL..Equprient
I:J..:1...I::L.Company
@
20352 NE 16th Place
North Miami Beach, Fl.
SALES OFFICES LOCATED IN
T AMPA/ORLANDO/JACKSONVI LLE/T ALLAHASSEE/M IAMI
33179
Chief Mike Wigderson
City of Delray Beach Fire Dept,
101 West Atlantic Avenue
Delray Beach, Fl. 33444
Dear Chief Wigderson,
As a written follow up to our phone conversations of the past
month, please be advised of the following:
The price of the airpacs, part number 930231-61, with donning
switch and Buddy Breathing capabilities is 1,537,33.
We will accept a trade in of 100.00 for each of your existing
units in a one for one arrangement,
Lastly, the price of the lightweight replacement air bottle
part number 803162-01 is 294,80, While we are aware that it is pos-
sible to purchase bottles from someone other than Scott AViation,
we choose not to do this as it violates the NIOSH approval granted
to Scott Aviation. Violation of any approval means Scott will not
honor their warranties and transfers the burden of responsibility
to the distributor/end user. This practice would increase our product
liability insurance premiums to a totally unreasonable extreme, It is
certainly not worth the 20.00 or 30,00 dollar difference in cost,
More importantly, we want no one hurt,
We at SEC pride ourselves in providing the best possible service
to our customers. We will always try to represent the highest quality
items in the industry and will devote the necessary time to train
the end users,
We look forward to a long and happy association with the City.
Sincerely,
~\j~\ ~\).~(\.~1\. L
Norka Cabanas
Bramch Administrative Mgr.
[il)) 'Jt:aELRH!fJt~~[H
MEMORANDUM
TO: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
FROM:
Robert A. Barcinski, Assistant City Manager/ f,.A./), r<k
Management Services
SUBJECT: DOCUMENTATION - ClTY COMMISSION MEETING -
JULY 26, 1988 - BID AWARD - CONTRACT FOR
HAND TOOLS AND HARDWARE SUPPLIES
DATE:
July 18, 1988
Item Before Commission:
City Commission is requested
Duncan-Edward, in the estimated
funding available in various
Operating Supplies.
to award a contract to
annual amount of $21,000;
department budgets under
Back9round,
Our City spends approximately $27,000 yearly on handtools
and hardware supplies, using blanket purchase orders with
discounts from 7% to 10% off retail price. By utilizing the
City of Boca Raton contract, discounts will range from 12%
to 52%, which will create a $6,000 yearly savings.
Recommendation:
Staff recommends award of contract for handtools and hard-
ware supplies to Duncan-Edward by piggy-backing the City of
Boca Raton Contract as per Code of Ordinance, Chapter 36,
Section 36.02 (E) (2), in the estimated amount of $21,000
yearly.
RAB:sk
attachments
';1, '
"3...8
'tE~10RANDU~1
To:
Robert A, Barcinski- Asst, City Manager/Management
Services
From:
Ted Glas- Purchasing Director 31~
Date:
July 6, 1988
Subject:
Handtools & Hard~are Supplies via Boca Raton
Contract
The City of Boca Raton has received bids and a~arded a
contract for handtools and hard~are supplies for the
contract period from April 12, 1988 through ~larch 30, 1889,
The Boca bid consists of firm discounts from manufacturer's
list price for a one year period, ~ith the option of
renewing the contract for a second year per the same terms,
conditions, and prices.
The City of Delray Beach spends approximately $27,000, on
handtools and hard~are supplies. Currently the bulk of these
items are purchased from blanket purchase orders with
discounts ranging from 7% to 10% from retail price. By
utilizing the Boca contract, which offers a 12% to 52%
discount, we could expect to realize an additional $6,000,
savings each year, We would still need small blanket
purchase orders for emergency purchases onlv.
It is recommended that a contract for handtools and hardware
supplies be awarded to Duncan-Edward, via the City of Boca
Raton Bid approved April 12, 1988; and if Boca Raton rene~s
the contract for one additional year, that the City Manager
be authorized to rene~ the contract for the City of Delray
Beach, subject to vendor acceptance, satisfactory
per'formance and determination that renewal is in the best
interest of tt.e City.
Funds for these purchases are available in the various
department budgets under operating supplies,
,.\ttachments:
Contract Documentation from Boca Raton
c OvW<-(~ 11[10 vf3 . LfI'2-/f'~) '# s--,j' - .L
<tf~o/&8~~ {NQeO be-t~e of ~ 5-)
CITY HALL. 201 WEST PALMETTO PARK ROAD. BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33432. PHONE: (305) 393-7700
March 25, 1988
PURCHASING MEMO NO: 87/88 - 164
TO:
James A. Rutherford, City Manager
THRU:
Susan M. Miller, C.P.A., Finance Director -cJ A
~ r,A...:J4 .
Thomas P. Anderson, CPPO,C,P.M., ~rchasing Supervisor
Caroline R. Westfall, C.P.M., Purchasing Agent II C~
THRU:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Bid - Handtools and Hardware Supplies
Bids were opened
requirements for
Purchasing.
on March
handtools
I,
and
1988 in the Purchasing Office for the City's annual
hardware supplies. Specifications were prepared by
Twenty-two vendors were solicited; four responded with bids.
Purchasing research discovered that the City spent approximately $34,,000.00 for hand-
tools and hardware supplies in FY '86/' 87. This total included expenditures from all
Departments through either blanket orders, purchase orders or special purchase orders
(under $100.00). Since Departments were unable to successfully project what handtools
and/or hardware might be required in the future, we were unable to issue an itemized
quantitative bid. Instead, vendors were advised of our annual expenditure total and,
requested to give discounts based on acheiving that level of sales in a 12 month period.
The bid requested firm discounts from manufacturer's wholesale list prices for a one
year period. Vendors were to advise the major lines (manufacturers) of hand tools they
represented and the applicable discount per line. Additionally, they were requested
to quote a firm discount on miscellaneous hardware. The bid also stated that the supplier
must prOVide both walk-in and delivery service, be within a reasonable distance from
the City, and have had experience with Municipal contracts.
A tabulation of discounts Bid is given below:
Vendor
Handtools
Hardware
Scotty'S, Pompano Beach
Sewell's, Boca Raton
Ace Hardware, Boca Raton
Duncan Edward, Ft. Lauderdale
12%
10%
20-30%
12-52%
12%
10%
20-30%
15-47%
Reconunend approval for Department blanket orders be
Ft. LaUderdale, Florida on an as-needed basis. Blanket
to-date are:
awarded to Duncan Edward Co.,
orders received by Purchasing
Public Works/Building Maintenance
Public WorkS/Streets
$17,000.00'/
1,000.00
11?1~
il/~'7
- AN EQUAL. OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER_
17(~("
page 2
Public Utilities/Plant Maintenance
Public Utilities/Water Network
Public Utilities/Sewer Maintenance
Public Utilities/WW Treatment Plant
Fire Department
Public Works/Dredge
Engineering/Traffic
Total:
2,000,00
2,000.00
2,000.00
2,000.00
500.00
800.00
2,000,00
$29,300.00
11,0 X'
/, 1,01
(1'?0'"
11 ">05
1 7:'-1">
1111<>1-
(12C.'2--
Actual usage of these blanket orders may vary ~ 10% depending on Department require-
ments. Blanket orders from other Departments are anticipated. Approval for any that
exceed $6000.00 will be requested at the appropriate time,
Funds are available in the following accounts:
General Fund-Inventory of Supplies-Building Maintenance account no. 001-000-141-
4000 (Building Maintenance)
General Fund-PW/Streets-Road and Street Facilities-Other Maintenance account no,
001-441-541-4619 (Streets)
Water/Sewer Operating Fund-Plant Maintenance-Water Utility Services-Other Supplies
account no. 470-427-533-5216 (Public Utilities)
Water/Sewer Operating Fund-Water Network-Water Utility SerVices-Other Supplies
account no, 470-422-533-5216 (Public Utilities)
Water /Sewer Operating Fund-Sewage Maintenance-Sewer SerVices-Other Supplies account
no. 470-424-535-5216 (Public Utilities)
Water/Sewer
account no.
Operating Fund-Sewage Treatment
470-423-535-5216 (Public Utilities)
Plant-Sewer
SerVices-Other
Supplies
General Fund-Fire Staff/Line Support-Fire Control-Other Maintenance account no.
001-251-522-4619 (Fire Department)
General Fund-PW/Dredge-Other Physical Environment-Other Supplies account no. 001-
442-539-5216 (Dredge)
General Fund-Eng/Traffic/Special Proj ects-Road and Street Facilities-Other Supplies
account no, 001-346-541-5216 (Traffic)
CRW:TPA:SMM:dd
"rr /JF a~lRRY :1t~ C;1
MEMORANDUM
TO: Walter O. Barry, City Manager
FROM: Robert A. Barcinski, Assistant City Manager/ ,i7.AB, f,(
Management Services
SUBJECT: DOCtlMENTATION - CITY COMMISSION MEETING _
JULY 26, 1988 - BID AWARD - CELLULAR TELEPHONES _
POLICE DEPARTMENT
DATE: July l8, 1988
Item Befor~ Commission,
City Commission is requested to award a bid to
Business Communications, in the amount of $10,680;
available in the Law Enforcement Trust Fund.
Cartel
funding
Back9round:
Invitations to bid were mailed to eight (8) area vendors on
May 24, 1988. Four (4) bids were received on June 22, 1988.
This purchase includes eight (8) portable cellular tele-
phones, chargers, battery packs, battery savers, and wide
gain antennas. A decision on which firm offers the most
cost effective air time is cur rently being evaluated and
will be awarded separately from purchase of telephones.
Recommendation,
Staff recommends award of low bid to Cartel Business Commu-
nications in the amount of $10,680, with funds to be appro-
priated from Law Enforcement Trust Fund.
RAB:sk
attachment
b3-<!.
300 West Atlantic Avenue . Delray 8each, Florida 33444,3666
(305) 243'7888
nEMORMJOUM
11~
Delray Beach Police Department
CHARLES KILGORE
Chief of Police
TO:
Robert A, 8arcinski
Assistant I:itv Manaqer/Manaqement Services GrOlJD
FROM:
Richard M, Lincoln. Major
Acting Chief of Police
THRU:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
Ted Glas, Purchaslnq Director
Jul y 12, 19;38
~Q8188lE CELlUl88 IElE~~Q~ES
Several months aqo. the Police Department began evaluatlnq
cellular telephones in an effort to determine their usefulness in
the law enforcement community, As an administrative aid. the
Police Chief. Fire Chief, Mayor and former City Manaqer all 'lave
positive reviews,
With the assistance of several vendors. a number of portabl~
cellular telephones were tested and evaluatQd by various units In
the Police Department, This increased teccnoloqy qives a broader
range of communications to those in the :ield. The broadened
ability to contact informants or other .qents in the field,
enhances the Investigative arm of the Orqanized Crime Unit. the
Patrol Supervisor(s) ability to communicate durinq critical
incidents. increase productivity. safety and morale. As a result,
I recommended the Motorola portable cellular telephone for
Operations Bureau personnel. The technology and durabilitv was
found to be far superior than all others tested, Bid
specifications were developed and Purchasinq went out to bid on
June 22, Based on the attached spreadsheet, I recommend Cartel
Business Communications be awarded the contract to purchase @iaht
(8) phones, A separate recommendat ion wi 11 be made to Pllrchase
the access fees/air time as that is a recurring expense.
We seek your approval and ask that the City Commission appropriate
funds in the amount of $10.680,00 from the Law Enforcement Trust
Fund for this purpose.
Your consideration is appreciated,
Respectful Iv submitted.
.
__..f:~_ ~ ~___"_'-~ __ __ ___h
RICHARD M. LINCOLN, MAJOR
Act ing Chief of Pol ice
gb
Attachment
PARTNERS WITH CITIZENS IN BRINGING THE COMMUNITY TOGETHER
~lEHORANDU~l
To:
Robert A.
Barcinski- Asst, Cit~ Hana~er/Management
Services
4jr
From:
Ted Glas- Purchasin~ Director
Date:
July 13, 1388
Subject:
Bids on Portable Cellular Telephones; Bid ~88-79
Invitations to Bid were mailed to eight (8) area vendors on
May 24, 1988, A legal advertisement was placed in the Delray
~ews on Hay 27, 1988.
Four 141 vendors submitted bids for the June 22, 1988 bid
opening, A Tabulation of Bids is attached for your review,
Following staff analysis aud review, it is recommended that
the purchase of the eight (8) portabl~ cellular telephones
be awarded to the low bidder, Cartel Business '
Communications, at a total cost of $10,680,
These telephones al'e not budgeted items. Thce' Police
Department is requesting that funds be appl uriated from the
Law Enforcement Trust Fund for this pure has
Attachments:
Tabulation of Bids
Memos from Police Department
~c: Y\"OIllle Kirlcaide
~.1ajor Lirlcoln
..
QI .. ....' ~
~. = I
I""f" Z l",..l
~.... " ~
>'0 = ~ C'l
El l'. -< III
I'D I'D I'D I"".J ~
en I;r.I 0 I'D
~ ~ ~
01
t:1
~
01
..
...."'l"" -: Ill"" "" X III "l
01-" 1'D::r =- Q 0 :l ::r'
00 '1 ","0 :x 0 I""f M' M' I'D
0'1 ~ n 0 :I M' 0 I'D I""f
~'O::r ~I'D ~ I""f:l I'D
=l'.i I'D CI'l 0" 0 :I
A.l C 1-". I-"I-"Q),... _
,... ..... I'D Q) en ra
01 QI ::I ....! e
I""fnl-" l-in~~= en
o f'l) I'D ::r RI 0 :I 0
"""'Q) '"'" I I'D I-" I""f =
,..". ""'. ~I""f I-" ,.." C
I'D :10;:; QI'D C ,... Q) j-lo
'1 '1o""",..,.na..
""l~ 0 O>"1ll 01 ~ "
l'.::r::r < , 01., =
I'D I'D I'D czh ::rl""f ~
Q.l "Q.l I'D Q)
q'Z~" Q)::rI'D:I Q.I-I'
O>O::r::lO....l'. ::I
< "-1 = I'D ,..,. C I'D 0'"
I'D M' I'D I'D I ::r'''<
cr ::I < "
::I" ....
Ill., l'.
....
'"
o
~o
~
~
"
01
o
""
..
N
~ ~
III
....
"
::I
l'.
III
.,
t:1
~
01
'<I
"
III
.,
~
"
~
-<
"
01
"
o
::I
~
.,
III
"
~
H
l'. ....
>'0
01
"
o
=
-.l ::I
" ~
01
C'l
III
....
"
::I
l'.
III
C'l .,
,
o t:1
?~
"
.,
2:
"
'"'
;:;
N
2: ir
" ....
~ "
::I
"" l'.
o III
~ : ~
0; ~
01
00
..
o
o
""
,
S
~ "
~ ~
r:
""
,
II
P "
:-- ~
'"
'"
III
e
"'00 '"
.. ..
CI'lO 0
1110 0
~
="" III
." ,
l'.S' El
I-" Q.l. N'
~'<I, ~ I
~:~~ ?'
~;8g8
,Z l'. ~
'" III III " ...
'<I' ,
El S
, ,
"'00
.. '"
:Co ..
"0 0
" 0
"""
", III
::I El ,
l'.. El
01 ,
,
t;; ...",~ '
!"' =.. f> 00
eo8... ;,;
.,.... . 0
l'.1ll
~i;:'
"', II
,
~
'"
N :;l
~' i
is-?.'
>', 0
::I 0
=
~""
"
00
..
o
-
.
N
~I
S.OO
S ..
>', 0
::I 0
=
~""
" ,
e
,
x
.....
"'l
'"
..
o
o
III
.
El
,
El
,
'"
..
o
o
~ ~
~
=
~
.. ~....
~ 2 ~
... P a ~
:;: ~ ~ g
x"'i!l
" 0
~ ~
o '" 0
., 00 .,
o . 0
....0....
III 0 III
~ ~ !: ~
o ~ CI'l 00
, > 0
o 0
0"00 ~I*o
o 0
0'" 0
0...,
N
~
~
~
'"
....
....
,
o
o
.
o
o
.. ~
~ ~
g~
~
CI'l
.. 00
o
~ 8
8
~ ~ I"" ~ ~
~ ~ ~
:: ~ ~ ~ ~
:5 i:8 i: i:
[0: ~ "l~ ~ f!i ::l
:o:,,~,!Q ~ Q
~ ~ ~ 8
~ 5
~
o
.
o
o
i!: ~ ~
::I ~ ~
~ : ~ ~
... .... ....
:~~f!ii~1ll
~ "
~ ~
"
::I CI'l
::I III
III <
"
.,
"2:~X
~ ~
~1.~~
:~85~
..... ~ en
~.. ... ~
~ .... ::
- ..., 0
N I
>
.. X
"
~
~ ~
o
5 i: ~
~
~ J, ...
~ 8 ~
~ J, !?-
~ ~
.
o
o
I
~
~
o
.,
"
....
III
~ :;jl
...
"
1!:
"
.. X
"
S ~
o
....
III
::l
C'l
.0
... ~
.... 0
o
~
00
o
o
~ "'" ~
~ ~
8 ~ ~
i: 8 :
"l
~ C'l
:; .0
~
~
25
I""
.... ~
~ ;s
8 [
III
~~
~ ~
~ 5 ~
., "
ao .,
"
.,
I*x
"
~
~ ~
5 ~
~ ;:l
"f .. "f
'" N
- ...,
~ ~ ~
:I. Ox>
8
~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ;.
~ ~ ~ ~
00
o
8 ~
"'"
~ ~
3
5
<
~ ~ !;l
~ ,
~ 0 ~
p. a c:
~ i: Q
! i
~ ~ !
::I ~
::I ~
CI'l
"
c
'"
~
~
tr
n
'"
t'"
t'"
c:
~
..,
'"
t'"
'"
'"
'"
c
:z
'"
CI'l
= ~
N ~ "l
o ~ t'l
0" t"'
.,
~ eo ~
III CI'l
...,
'"
~ 0
S
5
5
'"
I
N
N
,
ex:
ex:
~ X
~ ~
~ ~
~
~ ~
~ 0
5
~
~
~
3
~
~
w
o
o
'"
X
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mr. Walter O. Barry
City Manager
FROM:
Robert S. Pontek
Director of Public Utilities
SUBJECT:
GOLF COURSE WELLS-CONNECTIVE PIPING
DATE:
july 19, 1988
Bids were received at 3:00 p.m. on July 18th in the Purchasing
Department for the installation of 4, 700 linear feet of connec-
tive piping for the new golf course wells. There were a total of
ten plan holders with six bidders presenting offers for this
work. We are pleased to report that three bidders were very near
and the lowest bidder is Onontario of Palm Beach at $251,817.45.
The bid spread sheets are attached for your review. Funds are
available for this element of the golf course wells in the
Revenue Bonds.
We recommend award of the bid to Onontario with notice to proceed
with the City Attorney's office and the Pur-
j
^ /'
" ",'
^
RSP:nmt
t3-D
Russell & Axon, Inc.
(r \
\:1.. i
\' .~'
/ ~-'
<>-,......
Established in 1920
July 19,1988
Mr. Robert S.Pontek
Director of Public Utilities
200 N.W. 1st Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444
\ b. "'it(
o!.-(., \'"
" <'\ / f1V
Subject:
Recommendation of Award
Raw Water Connector Mains - Part C
Delray Beach Project # 88-89
R&A Project # 724K
Dear Mr. Pontek:
After review of the bids submitted to the City of Delray Beach
for the construction of the Raw Water Connector Mains - Part C,
the apparent low bidder was Onontario of Palm Beach, Inc. The
low bid amount was $251,817.45 as shown on the attached Bid
Tabulation.
Therefore, it is the recommendation of Russell & Axon, Inc.
that Onontario of Palm Beach, Inc. be awarded the contract for
the construction of the Raw Water Mains - Part C in the amount
of $251,817.45.
Sincerely,
RUSSELL & AXON, INC.
{~4s~~.
MAS/mlb
cc: File DK-16
(enclosure)
9." BROKEN SOIlND PARKW A y, N,W,. SUITE 115. BOCA RA rON, FLORIDA 334M7. 407' 994'9701 . 4()7 73l,7550
. 'RAW WATER CONl'T~CTOR MAINS
for CITY of DELRAY BEACH
Russell & Axon, Inc.
ENGINEERS. ARCHITECTS. PLANNERS
BID OPENING DATE: JULY 18,1988
Sine. 1920
NGINEER'S PROJECT NO, 001Z~ PART C
Suite 115
951 Breeon Sound POI'kwav, N.W.
Boe. Rllton. Florida 33487
407/994.9701 4071732.7550
:1
<?BRIEF
~
<S'O~ BIDDER'S NAME BID BOND COMPANY: I BID AMOUNT
:;-.,0 -?>
1'0..1;
'--'- - - ...
-- - - -,
ONONTARIO OF * $251,817,45
PALM BEACH
, -
>il GATEWAY CONSTRUCTION $377 ,169,00
0
Z
< " '
Z
>il ALL-RITE ENGINEERING
E-<
~ CONTRACTORS INC,
~
p..
p..
< A,O,B, UNDERGROUND
Q
Z
<
>il MADSEN/BARR CORP.
p..
.......
p..
>il BELVEDERE CONST. CO. $272,659.20
s:>::
~
UJ .
UJ
>il
~
p.. MAN CON $411,944,85
>il
Z
>il
....:l
>< UNDERGROUND
:r:
E-< INDUSTRIES $278,254,50
>il
~
0 VICON CONSTRUCTION CO
p..
SOLO CONSTRUCTION CO, $331,090.00
* Corrected Amount
CITY OF DELAAY JiR[H
.,'-. :. ,.1,,'
MEMORANDUM
THRU:
Frank spence, Development Services Group
~7{-~
U~
Director
TO:
Walter o. Barry, City Manager
FROM: Gerald B. Church, P.E., Acting Director PW/City Engineer
SUBJECT: 1988 STREET RESURFACING PROJECT
'DATE: July 22, 1988
A field inspection was made of the streets proposed to be resurfaced
under the contract to be awarded to Hardrives of Delray. Following
this tour an assessment of additions and deletions to the contract
amounted to an approximate five percent increase in the contract. It
is expected the work can be accomplished within the original funding
recommendation which includes a contingency above the quantity
estimate.
Separately we propose to include the driveway to the concession stand
at Pompey Park from the Parks and Recreation budget. The estimated
cost for this improvement will be $4,500.
It may be noted that no streets are listed within the northwest section
between Lake Ida Road and Atlantic Avenue from 1-95 east to N.W. 2nd
Avenue. Future storm improvements will be made in this area and it is
not prudent to expend monies at this time when storm improvements are
scheduled. This area will be considered for the 1989 Resurfacing
Program.
Attachment
,
,
,do i\l"r~c';o
~3-E
STREET
Ilene Ct.
NW 11th St.
SW 6th Ave.
Ibis Dr.
Heron Dr.
Brant Dr.
Palm Ct.
SE 1st Ave.
'Miramar Dr.
NE 5th St.
NW l8th St.
NW 4th Ave.
NW 4th Ave.
Gardenia Terrace
Lake Dr.
NE 2200 St.
NW 16th St.
Enfield Rd.
Laing St.
Lake Dr.
NE 8th St.
Blue Jay Turn
Bikepath along A-I-A
1988 STREET RESURFACING PROGRAM
LIMITS
Congress Ave. to west end
Lake Dr. to NW 4th Ave.
. Atlantic Ave. to SW 4th SL
Albatross Rd. to Curlew Rd.
Albatross Rd. to Curlew Rd.
Avocet Rd. to Lindell Blvd.
NE 2nd Ave. to NE 8th St.
SE 4th St. to south end
Venetian Dr. to A-l-A
NE 7th Ave. to east end
Lake Dr. to swinton Ave.
NW 7th St. to NW 15th St.
NW 16th St. to NW 18th St.
NW 6th Ave. to NW 8th Ave.
NW 17th St. to NW 18th St.
NE 2nd Ave. to NE 3rd Ave.
SWinton Ave. to NW 4th Ave.
NW 4th Ave. to Aylesbw:y Rd.
Andrews Ave. to A-I-A
NW 11th Ave. to NW 12th Ave.
Swinton Ave. to FOC R.R.
Brant Dr. to Lindell Blvd.
Linton Blvd. to Bucida Rd.
ReVised 7/20/88
LENGTH
350'
1000'
2600'
1700'
2200'
900'
350'
700'
1000'
1000'
1700'
2500'
700'
650'
400'
1350'
1300'
550'
700'
750'
1600'
300'
4600'
MEMORANDUM
I From: Ted Glas- Purchasing Director
To: Robert A, Barcinski- Asst, City Manager/Management
Services
Date: June 28, 1988
Subject: Bids on 1988 Street Resurfacing Project: ;88-83
Invitations to Bid were mailed to nine (91 area contractors
on May 25, 1988, A legal advertisement was placed in the
Palm Beach Post on June I, 1988,
Two (2) contractors submitted
opening. A Tabulation of Bids
bids for the June 24, 1988 bid
is attached for Your review.
. '
The low bid is 14% under the Engineer's estimate,
Following staff analysis and review, it is recommended that
the contract be awarded to the low bidder, Hardrives, Inc"
at a total cost of $300,510,
Per the Budget Director, funding for this project is avail-
able in 001-2911-519-60,53 (Resurfacing-Capital Outlay), and
in 001-2911-519-60,63 (Streets & Sidewalks-Capital Outlay).
flu! ~
Ted Glas
Purchasing Director
Attachments:
Tabulation of Bids
Memorandum from Engineering
Locations of Resurfacing Program
pc: Yvonne Kincaide
Gates Castle
'"
'"
:r
'"
00
'"
,."
'"
..
'"
c..
'"
"
'"
:r
~ '"
~ j i I! i ~ i ~ i i ; ~ ~ : ~ ~ i ~ I
~~tB~sl~SI~ a~E~~~~i~E
Eli ssg/ I ~;;~~~
"''''~...1:l...1:l...z ~I =~
i:e:~:~:~~ ~ ~I ~~
Ig~QZgZg~~ ~ t'"o~~;
~ ~ ~ '" '" t'" ~
~ ~ I: iin ~
~ II ! .~
~ '" ~
~ ~,~
-' ...
~
....
..... U1
. .
U1 0
o 0
(I>
w
U1 '"
IV ....
.
~ g: ....
F ~ :"
g g g
1*:
e:-l5
t' Q 8
'"
~
~I*/">
....
\0
8 8
-r-l.l
.. :
o 0
~:""Q
8"'0
'"
...
?..~
8~
S ?
~ ~
~
-c
...
N
N
o
~
~
o
.
8
...
...
N
o
.
8
:;
~
~
o
g
=
...
o
.
8
I:
'"
.
o
o
...
\0
o
.
8
...
o
.
o
o
'"
o
.
o
o
...
'"
""
.
8
...
...
...
o
.
8
...
co
""
.
8
=
co
'"
.
8
...
...
co
""
.
o
o
.....
U1
o
.
o
o
.....
U1
o
.
o
o
...
...
co
""
.
o
o
...
N
~
.
8
-:
""
.
o
o
1*
...
'"
o
.
8
.....
U1
o
.
o
o
.....
.
U1
o
o
.
o
o
~
8
.
o
o
...
~
'"
.
2;
...
...
"\."
'"
o
.
o
o
w
o
.
o
o
.....
r",
o
o
.
o
o
I:
""
.
o
o
...
/">
N
....
o
o
~
~
8
...
N
""
o
.
o
o
1*
N
""
o
.
o
o
~
::>
~
~
::>
p
...
.
U1
o
o
.
o
o
~
8
...
...
.
N
8
.
8
1*
co
N
2;
.
8
~
co
....
""
.
8
...
....
...
....
""
.
8
~
'"
12
~
'"
12
~
...
0-1
fi1
w
o~;~~~
~~g~~~
=;...;:;
~ '" ,- '" I' '"
~ ~ I
;;j ~ 0
t'"
~~~~~~
~:~~~~
g c:l 9 g""
'"
~ ~
'"
a
.....
...
,
U1
o
o
.
o
o
1*
""
o
o
.
8
"",
~
~
"
'"
0,
.
o
o
'"
o
o
.
o
o
/">
\0
o
.
:5
...
\0
:5
~
...
""
o
.
o
o
~
""
o
.
o
o
1*
N
""
o
.
o
o
.....
U1
o
o
o
.....
U1
o
~
~
8
.
o
o
...
w
o
o
.
o
o
1*
~
""
:5
.
8
.....
'" U1
U1 U1
.
o 0
o 0
.....
~ I'-'
~ '. ~
~' 0
g g
=
N
o
.
8
1*
t:"
~
::>
~
-=
8
.
o
o
~
'"
fi1
N
~
'"
12
~
'"
12
... ...
:r AI
~j~j~
Z 1fl ~ 1fl i
~.. ~ .. t:f
~~~~~
...
~ ~ ~
II ... ~
d ~
~ r'l
OJ e;
~
~
8
~
r'l
1*
... ...
~ 1;
('l
~ r'l
Z ~
~.
"i
i
~
r'l
~
r'l
~
N
.
8
...
...
o
~
o
o
.
8
I:
""
.
o
o
\0
o
8
.
o
o
~
~
~
~
Cl
'"
=
~
~
;!
~
c:l
'"
~
~
~
~
w
....
~~ ~
z
:;)
"
CJl
.
o
o
IV
U1
'"
!::,
o
o
.
'.
o
o
~
~~ ~
~
c
...
w
~
.
....
""
"" ~~ ...
; a
'" .
8' -;
l ~~ f'
Ej~
~
...
N
....
W
N
""
o
.
8
...
w
~
.
""
o
"" ~~ ~
.. '"'''' ~
~ e::
; r-F
g, ~ I-l
8~;::j ~
~ .
'"
~
~
~
...
v.
o
o
.
o
o
..
=
...
'"
!i
.
...
CD
CD
I
CD
W
-
\0
CD
...
~
~
~
~
~
('l
~
i'5
...
'"
o
c..
r'l
Q
t
N
~
I
...
\0
CD
CD
w
"
o
o
...
.
:J:
.
MEMORANDUM
FROM:
Wal~~~:it~~Manager
Frank R. Spence - Interim Director - Development Services Group
TO:
SUBJECT: AWARD OF CONTRACT - NE 1ST STREET STORM DRAINAGE PROJECT
DATE:
July 21, 1988
SCOPE OF PROJECT
1. This project is a part of the Downtown Storm Drainage System and
has the highest priority because of extensive flooding at NE 2nd
Ave and NE 1st St, which is the furthest point of the line which
, will drain into the Intracoastal Waterway.
2. Consideration was given to ending the project at NE 4th Ave,
deleting this two-block stretch and not going under the FEC
railroad track:;;, thus reducing the scope of this project by
$150,000 - $200,000. However, this was rejected since it did not
correct the worst flooding area.
3. This line will run right under the proposed CRA Parking Facility
and must be in place prior to its construction.
4. With the Atlantic Avenue Beautification Project now under
construction, it has been determined that a serious flooding
problem exists and must be connected at Atlantic Ave and NE 4th
Ave. So the one-block link to the NE 1st St. major collection line
was added to this project.
JUSTIFICATION
1. This project is essential to correct the most serious flooding
areas in the downtown area.
2. with Atlantic Avenue already closed and torn up, it is only
reasonable and good management practice to construct this link at
this time.
3. This line must be installed and in place before the CRA garage can
be constructed.
RECOMMENDATION
.
1.
That a contract be awarded to Hardrives of Delray in the amount of
$749,763.00.
2. That the primary funding source be the Utility Tax Bond issue, with
the full understanding and authorization that this fund will be
reimbursed for the NE 4th Ave/Atlantic Ave link from the Atlantic
Avenue Beautification portion of this bond fund (not to exceed
$100,000). Since there is only $350,000 committed to this project,
available funds from other authorized yet unfinished projects in
the bond issue would be completed from other funding sources like
the CIP fund and other budgeted Public Works projects.
FRS:DQ
'3-F
DEPAR MENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE,
\
FRoMfjj{erald
B, Church, P,E" Acting Director of Public
Wu"ks/City Engineer
CITY DF
DELRAY BEA[H
~(i
TO Walter 0, Barry, City Manager
AWARD OF CONTRACT
SUBJECT N, E, 1ST STREET STORM DRAINAGE PROJECT
',,;r' 7/19/88
On May 24th, bids were received for the subject project, The low base bid was
submitted by Hardrives of Delray in the amount of $749,763,00, The engineer's
estimate, by Barker, Osha and Anderson, Inc" was $630,700,00, Attached is a
copy of the Tabulation of Bids along with the Engineer's Estimate,
The N. E, 1st Street Drainage Project was included in the Storm Drainage Improve-
ment in the Utility Tax Bond Issue, It is a portion of the Downtown Storm Drain-
age System which was considered the highest priority because of extensive flooding
at N, E. 2nd Avenue and N, E. 1st Street, The storm sewer originates at the
Intracoastal Waterway and extends west, 6n N. E, 1st Street to N, E. 2nd Avenue,
The original drainage shed did not extend to Atlantic Avenue, During the design
phase, the City requested that the drainage at Atlantic Avenue and 4th Avenue be
incorporated into the N. E. 1st Street Drainage Project, if feasible, The reason
was to correct a serious flooding problem at that location, which was felt war-
ranted since the Atlantic Avenue Beautification Project was authorized, A storm
sewer extension was subsequently added ~ N, E, 4th Avenue extending into Atlantic
Avenue, The base bid of $749,763.00 includes the storm sewer extension to Atlantic
Avenue.
It is recommended that a contract be awarded to Hardrives of Delray in the amount
of $749,763.00, with the funding source to be from the Utility Tax Bond for the
Storm Drainage Improvements and Atlantic Avenue Beautificaiton,
,
/
;tiE ;",r 57 57ok'M' OPA/M4C;c PRdJ'Z;;r
(1'-11:'0# /;1/TRAQ:7A5T,-I,(. 11';1TC-Ptr4/ /t!'#c ;?'"' A v'C)
d~ynn :J Q' ,~ 5 C. -:'1
)r ~ >,NE<<~\.5St t
-=--<: <!! :N.E , ,'"
I I POqR
I Ufn",
'ST Z;; NE
UJ UJ 0' -... UJ
> >....; >
... ... z; - < M
,T _' NE
Cot\ ::::
",pl.,1 III UJ N
~)-j, 2 NE
.-\thlell( 1891
'z ~ UJ
. r.rk;; ,; Ii 2
: 2 I' I!:
',.
:; > Ji > >
<f <( W, <( <(
"ST ~: - SE
I
I_
I
I
I
1
ST Z, SE
;;;;0",
(I) CI) 1-1 CI)
ST ZI
--, -- ~
H ~ &
_s~i ~
ST
SE
t-~ NE 5 St 1-_:' I~b-;;. ,j, cU'Jg ~,Ir
<! tz 2 ~ )=='=:10 '51,
'CT Q.. _ I G"ldl <::I: Dr Tit
l.o..I \ CJ '€(l) fA A...er; r----
I :> _ -I,
~ ~ J.I E > ~ ~ Wi1t<:;W<1y4: CJ LaU S-tnd/1wy LiI
~ <t N--1 ~ ~.d.~2!.. 'I Are 4,h Ave:
3 f-- 5T VIsta 0('1 M,1r;_~_ : I ____I-"
:: ~.... t <Xl E SI ( I I OIl ~ '~ 5T'-'R/I1 ,.5CiVGP
., 2:f V"ta~M1' I _' .c-"-"'C-VSON70
2 ~ :>T (....~ Th01ll,lS ~,. ,-,;4,~
~ ~;: "~Ct cd-t'!ii' i A7L.",f/v'77c A VC
i/<f}i<t 1<rl~ SI/V 050~ILoJy AlA)
ci CJ St '>
t LU : r "k 15 ~ L' .[/
z. G~. -.... .... \- Ho..' .
~'T 'r _l . / ~ c:;, Hi 1? 11'1.1' 1'11,1,\
- '.- :AVI:. j,,,,'
C."fC-' , > 3~L ~Q V;~;~ ~fl:~ 'I I. "
<(E~( ~c-;;;<t.
- ,- ST ~ ';:........0' 1: . s: '" Mt 'mJar Of
W W ... "'-0 ~ 0 I
> > 1 c.......c r.; cD )
N <! <t: ,....~ ~ ~ (3 Coconut' ,ow
2 5T :. ;:.i In~rah.", Ave ~'I
/ ~ g ~ lOcean ~ ::::
:;; M", +', e~ ~ f. ~ Na...1u s'yeo, &
3 >i' '-,p<-! , '-~ Bil)' I S.~. ~
l,.;.J ~:: ~ .... .wllt I Lantjer ~ (j
(I? 4 :J: ~ H",,, II 1 ~. C:J
SE 15TCa"~~~ra Rrl--l~r' I .
SE 5 ST\ J 1t~t-.~lflU~'d1 9' j
SE 6 5T wD1 ~.~ > " -'-yFid I
L iii''''' ~",lal.u,\'1',1
1<: &:
'"
Ii
"
M E M 0 RAN DUM
To: Robert A, Barcinski- Asst, City Manager/Management
Services
From: Ted Glas- Purchasing Director
Date: July 15, 1988
Subject: Bids on Storm Darinage System; Bid #88-74
Invitations to Bid were mailed to twenty 120) area
contractors by the engineering firm, Baker, Osha, &
Anderson, Inc" A legal avdertisment was placed in the Palm
Beach Post on May 8, 1988.
Four (4) contractors submitted bids at the May 24, 1988 bid
opening. A Tabulation of Bids is attached for your review,
The low bidder for both the base bid and the alternate bid
is Hardrives of Delray, Inc,
Mr, Gerry Church will submit his recommendation on a reduced
scope of work because of budgetary constraints.
tI-4!
~
Ted Glas
Purchasing Director
Attachment:
Tabulation of Bids
pc: Gerry Church
,~
-
.,. , 0 2' 0 ~I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0)
- z
u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "
:: 2 ~ 0 .; N .,;
- M 0 0, 0 co co co
u.. '" N m N 0 '" '" co "- co '"
. III .,. N :'l; '" "- "': '" .,. 0 ~ '"
'" 0 >- z . , ~ N ~ ...; ...;
:: ~ "- '" M '" "- ~
.., ... M N - N N co N
... .. ...
:E ~
0
>- co u ...
II) co - ...
'-
'" c:i ""
0 N '"
'- :
'" z w I: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" .,;
a:: w ..... .,. '" '" ..; M .,. ..; .,; .,.
... -u "- co '" N M .... .,. 0 '" -
~ .... z- - - .,. - N - -
w 0 :I: 1--
n. w u
W .... W u
0
a:: ~ :I: '"
n. 0 (/) "', ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" '" 0 .,. 0 N '" .,. N '" 0
Z g ...; N .; ...: . N ...: ...;
M .; '" "- M
0 0 '" M '" '" "- N N M .,.
N '" ~ N M - - N 0 .,. M M
III -
U Z '" 0 - ...; - 0 N '" .... '" '" '"
z: ... - N - - .,. - M
- ...
..
z: ~
0 ...
u .
:E I
'" z:
"" ~ '"
'" 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 0 0
co '" .,. N .,. 0 '" .,. N .,. N 0
>- co ..... ~ 0 '" '" M '" '" .,; '" N .,; '"
co -u '" '" "- co '" '" N '" - M '"
II) '- z- - - -
'"
N :I: ...
'-
0 '"
W
:0::
U W 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w .... >- z 0
~ z: 0 co N 0 - 0 .,. co 0 '" co M
:I: "" '" '" M M N N '" 0 co '" '" .,.
0 ... Vi M .,. .,. "- '" '" N ": co - '" '"
U :E . '"
0 z '" '" N M - - M '" 0 '" - ...;
u - N - N '" N
... ... .,.
z: ..
0 ~
'" - .
.... ...
u
Q :l
'"
- .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1:5
III V> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z: ..; ...: ...: N
0 ..... .,. '" '" '" .,. co '" -
u -u "- "- co '" '" 0 0 - ;::, M '" N
- - - - - -
z: z- ...
0 :I:
u
... -
>
0
0 Ii? 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z 0 co 0 ...: .; .,. 0 0 '" "- .,; "-
Z u 0 N co '" M .,. ~ .,. 0 N 0 '" -
z: ~ co N ';, '" '" '" '" .,. - '"
Q - III I:: ~
0 - "- N .,. .,. '" M "- N co
co . Z - - - '" N N
>- ... I-
- w ~
l- i ..
...J ~
C w ...
0
-' ...
0 0 2' 0 0 I~ ~ ~ g g ~
::;) 0 0 0 0 0
V> :;! m ...: N m .,; ...:
III w 0 N "- 0 "-
> ..... '" .,. '" '" "- N M "- M '" co
- - - - -
i! '" -u ...
0 z-
'" :I:
M ""
N :I:
0
-
I
"-
co
~
0 .. ..: ..: ..: ..: ..: ..: ..: ..:
:: ~ ..: ..: ..:
....i ....i ....i ....i ... ....i ....i ....i ....i
.... Z ....i ....i ....i
u I~
w c "- "- .,. N "- M M "-
.., :I N - 0 - '" 0 N "- - .,. '"
0 - N M .,. - N - - .,. - M
'" 0
...
...; It
Q c C c c !~ c c c c
'" w w w w w w w w w
0 "" u u u N u u u u u u
z: c ~ '" "'- '" '" '" E "'- '" '" '"
u - 0 ;" 0 0 - 0 0 Co N 0 0 0 0 0
:E '" e ... co ... co ... ... co ... ~ ... - ... ... ...
~ w 0 z ~ z: z: I z: z: - ~ z: z: 0 z: 0 z:
.... ...J - I I - , - - , - , ~ I g - I - - - - - co
. V> ... W W W - W W I W W I W I W I
Z >- '" '" ;" '" 0 '" '" 0 u '" - '" '" '" ;"
V> U .,. '" - '" '" - co co co
0 :: '" ~ '" '" '" '" ~ '" '" '" ...J
W U W :: :: w :: w :I: w :: w :: :: w :I: W :I: W :: "" :I:
(/) '" "" C .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ~ .... .... .... .... .... .... > ....
a:: "" w w ... ~ ... w ... w ... w ... w ... w ... w ... w ... 0 ...
z: '" ~ :E w w ~ w :E w ~ w :E w :E w :E W :E W W
W - :'5 c "" c c "" c c :'5 c "" c :'5 e :'5 e e
"" >- - - - - - M
0 '" ~ l- e :: e:I: e :I: e :: e :I: e :I: c: e :: e :: e :: '" ::
Z c Z u u u u u u u u u x U
...J z: Co z: ~ z: z: = 'Z: N z: ~ ~ Co z: z: z z:
~ '" w I co w w w 0 w ~I~ w w .,. w 0 w .,. w
w 0 - '" - '" N '" M '" .,. '" " .,. '" '" '" '" '" M '"
.... 0 ... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
d5 "" ... .. ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ~ ~ : ~ ...J ...J ...J ...J
I U ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :: ...J :: ...J :I: ...J :: ...J :: ...J :: ...J :I:
~ .... "" .... "" .... "" t:; .... .... "" .... "" .... ~ .... ~ .... "" ....
~ '" >- x .... x .... x .... "" x .... - ~ I ~ ' .... - x - .... -
0 .... V> V> V> V> '" V> V> '" z: '" V> V> '" V> '"
:I: .... - z: z: z: ~ z: ~ ~ ~ z: z:
V> U - W - W - W W - W w ~I ~ Id w w - w - w
(/) ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
0 e - e - e - e - e - e - e - e - e - e -
z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ... z: ...
. .. "" "" "" "" "" "" i~, i I- "" "" "" ""
a: u w w w w w w I ~ w w w w
... :: .... :I: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :I: .... :I: .... :: .... :I: .... :: ....
W V> W V> W V> W V> W V> W V> W V> W V> W Vl W V> W
..., - '" - '" - '" - '" - '" - '" ~ - '" '" '" - '"
:0:: 0 z: u z: u g~ z: u z: u z: u z: u z: u z: u z: u
L,: . '" z: '" z '" z: '" z: '" z: 11 '" z: '" z: '" z: '" z:
=> 0 :l 0 :l 0 :l 0 :l 0 5: 0 => 0 5: 0 => 0
~ L ... u ... u ...u ... u ... u ... U ~ U ... U U ... u
IlJ ci '1 0 - N
- N M .,. '" '" "; '" - - -
Z I , , , , I I , , ,
"" "" "" "" "" "" I" " "" "" "" ""
.. u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15
~ z 0 0 0
, 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
z 0 .D M M ...:
u.. - N .. .. .. <Xl .D ~ <Xl
Vi ~ 0 '" '" N '" '" ~ 0 ~ N
<Xl 0 >- Z '" 0 '" "" .. 0 N '" ~ .... ~
..; ..; ..; .
X .. ... <Xl i '" ~ '" M .... '" 0
.., "" ~ 0 M ~
"- .. ~ ~
:E ~ ...
>- 0 ...
'-'
III 18 N ..
....
'" 0 ~
0 N
.... Z "" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
W '" "" 0
"" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0: "" .. ...
"- -u .. '" '" .. '" M M '" .. <Xl ..
<l I- z- N .. .... ~ '" '" '" '" 0 '" '"
~ ~ ~ N N 0 N <Xl <Xl <Xl ~
ll. W W 0 ;:)f ..;
'-' ... M N M .. .; '"
W I- W '-'
0
0: <l :z: ""
ll. Cl Vl g
0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 0 0 0 0
z '" N <Xl N <Xl 0 0 0 0 0 ~
0 .... '" ,,; ~ M 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0
'" '" i '" !::i .... ~ '" N '" ~
Vi '" .. M ~ '" ~ '" N
. . 0' .
Z '" .. .... .. 0 ~ ~ N <Xl '" ~
~ M .... '" ~ ~ ~
U ...
z .. ...
- ~
:E ...
'"
<C Z
0
'-'
, 0 0 0 0 '" 0 C) 0 0 0 g 0
<Xl Z M <Xl .... N '" 0 0 0 0 0 0
<Xl ~
>- .... ..... .; .0 <Xl .D 0 0 C) 0 0 0 0 0
III '" -u 0 N M '" .... .... ~ N ~ M M '"
N Z- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" N M '" N '"
.... ;:)f . .
'" ... ~ ~ .. .. .. '" '"
Cl
LLJ
~
U LLJ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
I- >- Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
W z
"" .D ,,; 0 0
:z: <l "- 0 .... 0 N 0 0 0 0 0
:EO Vi M <Xl .... .... .. '" '" 0 '" 0 <Xl '"
U Cl 0 ":. 0 M <Xl .... -: .... 0 .... ":. '" ~
'-' Z '" <Xl <Xl ~ .,; ~ - '" .. '" .... '"
z ... - M <Xl '"
0 .. ...
- ~
'" I-
'-' ...
:::>
Q "" ,
I-
- V> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z
m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'-' ..... '" '" .0 N ..: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z -u N M '" .... <Xl '" '" 0 <Xl, '" '" M
0 Z- - - - - ~ - .... 0 "" <Xl '" '"
~ ;:)~ ... ...: - N N ~ ..; ..
... >
0
, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z u 0 ~ 0' 0 <Xl <Xl .0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0
'" .... .. <Xl '" <Xl 0 '" - N <Xl
'" z III '" .. '" .. '" N .... ~ 0 '" M
0 .. - .
'" Z 0 N <Xl '" - - - '" .. '" .. '"
N .. <Xl 0
- ... >- ... ~
~ i ~ .. ...
~
C -' ... I
""
.... c
"-
:) 0 0 0 Ig 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0
m V> 0 0 0 0 <::> <::> <::> 0 0 ~
"" ..... ...: I~ .0 .0
> '" <Xl N <::> '" 0 0
~ - -u M '" <Xl '" <Xl 0 .... 0 ~ '"
"" z- ~ - - - N '" <::> ~ M '"
C ;:)~ ~ ...: N
M "" ... - N N N
N ""
0 X
-
,
....
<Xl
~
0 .. ...: ...: ...:
z ;: "- ~
...; "- ...; x :z: :z: :z: :z: :z:
I- Z -' -' '-' '-' '-' '-' '-' '-'
'-' -' "" "" "" "" IL:' ""
"" C "" .. '" '" "" "" "" "" ""
.., ;:) '" .... .. .... N I"
<::> ~ N '" .. '" - ~ M N N N
"" 0
"-
M
'" C C C
0 "" "" ""
"" '-' '-' '-'
e,j z c ~ "" "" "" ;:" - -
- <::> N <::> <::> ;,. ;,. ;:" '" .... ....
~ :EO "" e "- e e "- "- -
"" 0 z - :5 0; z 0 II ..;
I- -' - ~ 0 ~7 - - "" "" "" "" ""
. V> "- "" , - "" , "" 0 -' -' -' -' -' -'
z >- "" "" 0 "" ;:. '" - <::> <::> <::> <::> <::> <::>
V> U <Xl ~ ~~ <Xl :z: :z: :z: :z: :z: :z:
0 :z: -' ~ ~ ~ -' z z z z z z
Vl "" '-' C "" :z: :z: "" :z: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
'" "" > l- I- > I-
0: "" "" 0 "- "- 0 "-
z '" ~ "" "" "" "" ~ ;:>> ;.. ;,
LLJ - ;., c c c c "- .., ..,
Cl ;1!>- ~ 0 ~ ~ '"
c;1! '" :z: '" :z: :z: .... :z:
Z Z >< '-' >< '-' '-' >< '-' "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
-' z z z = 'z: "- "- "- "- "- "- "-
<l "" "" ~ .. "" '" "" "" ~I~ >- >- "- >- >- >- "- >- ~ >- "-
"" c 0 "" "" "" "" "" l- I- "" ~ ~ I- "- I- "" l- I- ""
I- ... l- I- l- I- "- "" "" "" ""
ell i "- .. -' -' -' -' -' "" -' c -' "" -' c -' -' c
0 U - -' :z: -' :z: :z: ~ ~ -' :z: -' "" -' -' c -' -' -'
~ I- "" l- I- "" I- "" C ""- "" "" N "" "" N
<l "" >- - I- - - I- - l- I- N l- I- e l- I- e I-
0 l- V> :z V> :z :z V> :z V> Co V> ~ ~ c. V> V> ~ V> V> ~
:z: I- - Z Z ~"" : i ::: z z , z ~ Z , Z ~ Z .
Vl V> '-' - "" - "" "" - , - - , - , - - - -
"- "- "- "- 0 c ;, Co :=: '" c. 0
0 c - c - c _ c - c '" c - c '" '" ~
z "- z "- ~"- z "- z z z z z z Z
. .. "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
u "" "" !~ "" "" "" ~! ""
0: "" "" ""
... :z: I- :z: l- XI- X :z: l- X "" X X "" X "" X ""
W .. V> "" V> "" V> "" V> I~ r V> l- V> V> l- V> I- V> I-
~ 0 - "" - "" - "" - ~ - "" - - "" - "" ~~
z '-' z '-' z '-' z Z :EO z Z ~ Z :EO
0: . "" z "" Z o.:z "" I~ 0.: "" 0.: "" "" "" 0.:'; ~
L :::> '" :::> '" :::> '" :::> ~ ~ - ~ :::> - :::> - ~ ~
<l "- '-' "- '-' "-'-' "- C "- '" "- '" i:i: '"
III ci I~ .~ 0 N "" ~
"" .. '" '" '" ~
- ~ - - - N N N N
Z 0 , , 0 l.l .l 0 0 , , 0 .l
"" "" "" <C "" "" "" "" ""
<t ~
- , z 0 liS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
li! 0 0 Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl
S! N ...: .; . . , ,
u. - to CO .... .... N 0 0 <t
1ft '" '" <t CO N '" '" 0 to M 0
- CO <t to N to 00 00 M '" ":
00 0 >- Z N . N 00 00
:I: Z ... .... M <t CO CO '" .... ....
.., e( .. N - -
0..
'" )( ...
>- 0 ...
U
CD 00 M
00 ..
"-
CO 0 e(
0 N '"
"- Z w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
W CO '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a:: '" .. ... ...: N cO .,; . 0 ~ <t
W -u ~ .... .... N 0
< I- ... z- '" N CO N '" '" 0 '" M 0
CO CO .... 00 N 00 00 00 - '" ":
a.. LlJ LlJ 0 :I:: ..,; . ..,;
U .... '" <t CO '" .... '" 00 ~ 00
W I- LlJ u
0 ...
a:: < J: '"
a.. 0 lJ) 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2' 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g' 0 0 0
'" co N 00 '" to '" .... .... to ....
M to M <t <t - M co co co c:.
1ft . . ..,; ..,; ..,; a ..,; ..,;
Z ~. co - <t <t co
N -
U ...
.. ...
Z )(
-
'" ...
'"
e( Z
0
U '" Ii'!
, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
>- to ~ ..... 0 g: 0
00 -u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
CD "- <t co '" to '" to '" .... .... 00 ....
co Z- '" to '" <t <t - M co co co '"
N :I:: ..,; ..,; <t .
"- co co <t <t co co co co co
0 co
...
W
~
U W 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ; 0 0 0
I- >- Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
W Z 0 0 0
< e( 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
J: 0.. Iii '" to 00 M .... 0 .... <t N M to
0 '" .... <t <t 0 <t 0 <t '" N ~ <t
U 0 ..,; ..,;
u Z .... '" M M <t <t <t a: ... co
Z ... -
0 .. ...
- )(
'" I- ...
u
Q ::>
'" ,
l- Ii'!
- '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
III Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 ..... 0 11, 0
u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-u <t 00 <t M .... 0 .... <t N M to
Z Z- <t <t .... 0 <t 0 <t '" 1 N 00 <t
0 :I:: ..; . ..,;
u co <t M '" <t <t <t <t co
-
... > ...
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i'! 0 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z 2 0 .,; !~ 0 0 0 .,; .,; ~ 0 .,; .,;
Cl U to '" to <t '" M - 0 .... N
- Z '" 00 co '" '" 0 N N ~ N
0 .. - 1ft ..; " ..;
Z N M .... N N <t <t <t co
... . -
- i >- ...
to- ~ .. ...
C -l )(
... ...
Q
... ...
::>> 0 ~
'" 0 0 i'! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
III w .,; .,; .,; ! .,;
> ..... 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 co
~ '" -u .... '" 00 <t '" M - 0 .... N
z- - to .- co '" '" 0 ": N '" N
Q :I:: ..;
'" M <- N N M <t <t <t <t co
M e(
N :I: ...
0
-
,
....
to
~
0 ..
Z ~ :I: :I: I ~ :I: :I: :I: :z:: :z:: :z:: :z:: :z:: :z::
u u u u u u u u u u U
I- Z e( e( e( e( e( !L;: e( e( e( e( e(
u C .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
....
.., :I <t - - - - 1- - N - - -
0 0
'"
...
M
'" .H ~ . 3
Oe( IlllI:: Co Co .... 3 3 3 3 3 ~
e,j ZQ -l ~ ~ ;,. ~ ....
'" 0 '" ~
~ '" e :z:: :z:: >< >< >< >< >< ><
-l
.... 0 .... .... ~~ Z Z -l -l =" -l -l 00
I- -l -l -l ~ ~ ;... Co Co
. V') ... 0 0 .... .... .
Z >- :z:: :z:: ~ ~ 0.. ...
V') . U Z Z b" g >< >< >< .... >< >< w >< ~
0 :z:: ~ ~ 0 0 0 .... 0 0.. 0 .... 0 0..
lJ) .... u C '" 00 00 0.. '" Q '" .... 00 Q '" 0.. ....
'" e( .... .... .... ....
a:: e( .... IlllI:: ::., ::., ~~ ::., ::., ;: .... ::., N ::., Q N ::., .... . Q
Z '" Q .., - .., Q
LlJ - . ~ . - . - .
0 e( >- to- ~ it .... ~ , 0 , Co ~ 0
'" ~ .... .... .... to .... - .... - .... - .... -
Z Q Z 0.. 0.. 0... , ~ . 0.. 0 0.. , 0.. 0 0.. , ,
-l ~ >- >- 0.. I~ ~ ~I ~ ~ >- - >- - >- - >- - Co
< '" w I- 0.. I- .... l- I- 00 l- I- '"
.... Q 0 ... .... .... 0.. ~ ~
dS I- .. -l .... -l Q Iq I~ 0.. -l .... = I- -l I- -l I- -l I- -l I- ~ l-
e( ... -l Q -l .... -l .... .... -l .... -l .... -l .... -l .... ....
l 0 U - e( e(- .... e(Q ! -l e( -l e( -l e( -l e( -l -l
< I- - I- <t Q I- Z I- Z I- Z I- Z I- Z >-' Z
'" >- '" 0 V') _ V')- - V') - V') - V') - V') - -
J: 01- Z - ~.. !~ ~ Co ZO Z Z Z Z z I"
1-- - , I" - - "- - ~ - . - . - . - .
lJ) V') U Co N , , ... ... ... ... ...
Q Q - I~ Q - Q . Q . Q. O. Q . I~
0 Z "" , ~ Z 00 ~ ; ~ Z Z Z Z
.. e( e( e( e( .... e( .... e( .... e( .... ....
. '" '" 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0..
a:: u :z:: .... :z:: .... B' ~ '" :Z::3 ; ~ :z:: >- :z:: >- :z:: >- :z:: >- >-
... V') l- V') l- V')- V') l- V') l- V') l- V') l- I-
W 0 - .... - .... '::: - co - - - -
~ Z '" Z '" ~ i Z >< 1= ~ ~ Z :z:: Z :z:: z :z:: Z :z:: :z::
'" ~ '" e( '" -l '" I- '" I- '" I- '" I- !;
a:: . ::> ::> - G: ::> - i ::> - ::> - ::> - ::> -
L ... Q ... Q ...", ... 3 ... 3 ... 3 ... 3 3
<
CD 0 co '" ~ ~ '" ~ - N M ... co I~
N N N M M M M M
Z , , , , , , , ,
e( e( ..; e( ..; e( e( e( e( e( I";
,
.. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
\I.. ::: 0 .. .. ~ ~ .; N '" ..: 0 0 0 .; .. '" N 0
Vi ~ '" ~ ~ ..., .... .... .. '" ~ ..., '" .. ~ '" ~
,: "':. ": ... '" ... '" '" .... ~ ~ ..., .... '"
'" 0 Z
::: 2 0 '" '" '" .. ..., .. ~ '" ...
.., C( ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Q. ...
X )( ..
>- 0 ...
u
m CO ..
CO ..
"-
'" 0 C(
0 '" '"
"- Z .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
UJ '" '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0:: '" ...... .; oi N 0 .n .; .n
.... -u .... ~ '" CO .... '" .... '" ...,
.... CO ~ ..., ~ '" .... ..., .. '" .... ~ ~ CO
<( ~ Z- .. CO '" .. '" .. ..., '" ~ '"
n. w w 0 =~ ~ '" '" ..., .... ~ ...;
U 0 ....
W ~ UJ u ~ ~ ~
0
a: <( :I: '" ..
n. 0 VI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .n 0 0 .; '" '" .; 0
2 co ..., 0 0 0 0 0 0 .... '" .... '" ..., .... .. ..
~ '" "':. .. .. '" '" '" '" ~ ..., ..., '" co co
VI .;
Z '" .. '" 0 0 gJ ~ 0 ...,
U '" '" '" ~
2 ... ..
~ ...
X )(
'" Z ...
C( 0
U
I
2
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
CO 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
>- CO ...", 0 .n ....:
"- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" .. CO CO CO 0
m '" -u CO ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ..., ~ ~ ~ '" '" ~ ..
'" Z- ~ .. ~ .. '" '" CO '" .... '" ~
"- =~ .
'" '" ~ ~ 0 0 CO 0 0
0 '" ~ '" ~ ~ I.
..
UJ
llI::
U UJ 0 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ >- Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
UJ z <2 0 0 .n N .; ,.;
<( CC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0
:I: Q. '" 0 '" 0 co K' .. 0 0 .. '" 0 '" ..., ..., '"
0 x ;;; co '" ":. '" ..., ..., '" '" '" ~ .... '" CO> ~ ~
U 0 N
u Z '" ..., .. 0 '" .. co '" ..., '" ~
... ~ ~ ~ ~
2 ..
0 ...
~ )(
'" t- ...
u
Q ::>
'"
t-
- V) 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
lID 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 '" CO>
U ...... 0 0 0 0 '" CO> '" 0
-u '" 0 M 0 '" .... 0 CO CO M M, M M M '"
2 Z- CO M '" '" '" ~ '" .... .... M
0 =~ ~ .
U '" ~ ~ 0 .... '" CO>
- ~
... > ..
0
0 0 0 0 0 Ii 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z .. u 0 .... .... '" 0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 '" '" co .. 0
... 2 '" .... ~ '" 0 0 '" '" ~ ~ M M .. '" '"
0 .. - VI . ,,;
Z '" .. '" .... '" CO> ~ '"
.... .
- j >- ... I"
t- ~ ...
C -' )(
.... ...
0
... ....
~ 0 0 i 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
V) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
lID .... .n 0 0 0
> ...... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ - -u .... '" '" 0 0 0 0 '" '" '" '" '" '" '" 0
'" Z- '" '" ": '" ":. '" '" '" '" ~
0 =:: .; ,,;
M '" '" ~ ~ .... ..
'" CC
0 :I: ...
~
,
....
CO
0 ..
2 ...
t- j: ::: :I: ~ ~ :I: :I: ::: I~ I ~ :I: ..: ..: .... ..: .... :::
u u u u u u
u Z CC CC CC CC ~ CC ..; -' ..; U
.... .... .... 0:;: .... .... ..; -' CC
.., C .... ....
0 = ~ M '" - '" ~ " I- I " CO '" .. ....
'" CO '" ~ ~ '" .. '"
Q. 0
...;
~I~I '"
: ~ '"
cJ '" M '" Ii
.... ~ ..
~ !;;1Li: 0 >< :~ 0
-' 0 ~ !ii
. Co 2 2
~ ' t- t- t-
Z .... .... ~ >< >< 5 ~
0 LJ.JG U >< Q. -' -' 0 0
0.... 2 2 '" '" '"
VI '" I~ C CO .... - -
CC Q >- >- >- ~ >- I~
a: 2 '" t- t- t- t-
- aIi: .., - ... ... -' -' -'
UJ CC >- . '" ~ CC CC < ~
0 '" ~ t- ~ - - ~ ~
Q .... I .... .... ~ U U ~
z ffi~ Z Q.- Q. Q. .... '.... ~
<( I: >-0 >- >- Q. Q. Ie; Q.
t-~ t- t- V) V) V) t-
=< '~ 0 ... v ....
cIS ... -' t- -' -' ::. -' -' ;; - ~ -'
~> - -' .... -' -' -' -' 2
U CC-' CC CC CC CC CC ~ I~ - ~
<( t-Z t- t- t- t- t-
o 2_ V) V) V) V) V) ~ '" ~
:I: tnt: V) 2 2 2 2 2 2 Q. Q. Q. Q. Q.
- . - - - - - - X :E :E :E
VI .... t- U U U U U
0 Q. Q ~~ Q Q Q Q I~ V) '" ~ IE
2 2 Q. 2 2 2 2 -
. ... CC .... CC .... CC CC CC CC CC >< N '" CO .. '"
a: u Q. .... ::: ~ .... ~ ~ ~ '" ~
... :I: >- ::: Q ::: ::: :I: :I: ::: ~ ~
UJ V) t- V) V) V) V) V) V) V) .... .... .... .... .... ....
.. - - ;., ;;;. - - - - I[ > > > > > >
llI:: 0 2 ::: 2 2 2 2 2 i i 0 0 0 i
. '" t- '" I '" I '" '" '" '" X :E X I" ~
a: ::> - ::> - ~U: ::> ::> ~ ::> .... .... .... .... .... ....
< .. .... '" .... .. .... .... .... ~ '" '" '" '" '" '"
CD 0 .... CO CO> 0 ~ '" M ~ ::; '" .... '" Iq
CO 0 ~
M M M .. .. .. .. ... .. .. .. '" '"
Z , , , , , .l: , .: I I I , , ,
C( CC CC CC CC CC C( CC C( CC CC CC CC lei
,
... 2 ~ 2 /2 g 12 : 1
~ z 0 0 0 0
u 0 0 0 0
.. 0 ~ '~ 5 ~ 0 I ~ ~ 0 0 0 0
LL ~ Wi ... 0 0 ... on
<Xl ... ..... en 0 <D en
" 0 >- z ... N " ~ '" on en N
.., .. ... ~ ... ~
'" ..
"- Ie
:E
> 0 ...
lXl '" on '-'
'"
..... ..
on 0
0 N ~ ~
..... z 0 0 2 0 0 0 12 0 0 0 0
lJJ on ... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 <D on
'"
a: '" ..... on 0 ~ 0 0 vi ~ vi 0 ... ,.;
... -u N ..... ..... N ..... ..... 0 ~
<t ~ ... z- ~ ~ ~ N ..., ~ 0
ll. lJJ !oJ 0 :If ... ~ .,;
'-'
lJJ ~ !oJ '-'
a: <t :r 0
'"
ll. 0 (J) 0 0 I~ 0 0 0 I~ ~ 0 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2 <D ... ... '" <D 0 0 0 0
..., ... <D on <Xl '" 0 <D on
III N - " 0 <D
Z ... ..... '"
'-' ~ ... ~
.. ...
... ..
, Ie
.. ...
0
'-'
0 : ;
.. 0 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 0
>E 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
> '" ..... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .;. vi
'" -u '" N N en ..., 0 0 0 ~
lXl ..... z- ~ N N N ... on ~ 0
on
N :If ... , :::: <D
.....
0 on
lJJ
::.:: 18 ~
u lJJ 0 0 0 0 0 : 0 0 0 0
~ >- z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
lJJ .. 0 0 0 Ig 0 0 0 , ~ 0 0 0 0
:r <t '" <Xl <D <D '" 0 '" 0 <D N
0 "- Wi ..... '" on ~ en ~ ~ ": en .....
U :E ....: ' ~ .,;
0 z ... I- on ~ en <D 0
'-' <D N
...
z: ..
0 Ie
...
'" 0- ...
'-'
Q => ,
'"
- 0- 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 ,; 1 0 0 0 0
m Vl 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ... <D
..
0 ..... 0 0 0 0 0 0 I ~ vi 0 en on
'-' -u en ..., ~ ..., en on '" , 0 ~
.. z- ..., ... ... ... on ":
0 :If ... ~ <D
'-'
... ...
>
0 I~ ~ i
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 vi
Z .. u 0 on 0 0 on 0 ... 0 0 on
... .. N ..., <Xl ..., ... ..., 0 '" ...,
0 '" ... III ... ~ ~ 0 0 on
... Z ~ ~ ... ~
- i >- ...
... ~ ..
Ie
C ..J ...
...
Q
... ...
::) 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 ~ 1 0 0 0 on
Vl 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
m ... ..... vi 0 ~ 0 vi 0 ~ vi 0 N ...
> -u '" on on ..... 0 0 0 ~
~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ 0
'" z-
'" :I: ... ~ 0
'" ~
..., '"
'" x
0
~
,
.....
'" ~
0 .. :E ..: :E ,.: ,.:
;: x => => vi vi
.. x x x '-' x x x Vl -' Vl
Z '-' '-' '-' '" '-' '-' '-'
0- '" '" '" ... '" '" '" "- "- 0 0
'-' c ... ... ... ... ... ... :E '" % 0 '"
... N => '" => ... .....
.., :I N '" ... ~ N N '" ..J ~ ..J ..., ...,
'" 0
'"
"-
...,
'" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" ...
0 '" ~ => => => => => => => "- Vl
cJ .. Q ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J ... ..
... e "- "- "- "- "- "- "- "- 0
~ % '" '" ... ... ...
... 0 '" '" '" '" '" '" '" ... ... 0- Vl ...
. 0- ..J ;:; ;:; ;:; ;:; '" '" '" Q '" '-' '"
Vl ... 0- 0- 0- .. ... ... <Xl ...
Z >- U '" '" '" '" '" '" '" => ..J .. "-
0 Vl ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 >- .. >< >-
X % % % ... X 0 '-' 0-
(J) ... '-' C '" 0- '-' 0
'" '" Q Q Q Q Q Q Q 0 ... '" ""
a: '" ... ~ .. .. .. .. .. .. .. <Xl >- Co ... '-'
lJJ .. <Xl '" '" '" '" '" '" '" ..J % ...
... .. >- 0 ... ... i:
0 ~ >- ... >< >< >< "" >< >< >< '" "- Q ..J
'-' '-' '-' '-' '-' S '-' >< '"' .. '"
Z Q Z 0 0 0 0 0' 0 '-' ..J ... ... :.-
<t I ..J ..J ..J ..J <<II ..J '" ... <D '"' X <D
'" <Xl co <Xl co <Xl <Xl "" ~ ..., 0- >< ~ ~
... 0 ... ..J gji
ctl 0- .. ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J =- ..J ..J ..J ..J => ..J
'" ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J ..J 0- ..J ..J <Xl ..J
l U - '" '" '" '" ;:; ;:; ;:; '" Vl ;:; '" '"
<t 0- 0- 0- 0- 0- '" 0- '" 0-
'" Vl Vl Vl Vl on on on Vl 0 on Vl z: Vl Vl
:r '" .. .. .. z: .. .. .. .. '-' .. .. - .. ..
0- ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... - 0- ... ...
(J) on ~I~ ~ 0- on
0 Q "- '" "- Q,,- Q "- "- Q "- Q Vl Q '" ... Q 0- Q
.. % .. :E .. '-' .. '-' '-' z: '-' z: '" z .. >< .. .. ..
. .. '" '-' '" '-' "'''' '" '" '" '" '" '" ... '" '" '" '" ... '"
a: u ~ %
X . X . ~I~ x. x . x x '" " x " x ... x
lJJ ... Vl on Vl'" Vl co Vl ... I~ Vl N Vl Q Vl Vl '" on '-' Vl
.. ... ~ ... ~ ... ~ ... N ... ... - ... ... ... => ... '" il~
::.:: 0 .. .. ~I~ .. .. ~ .. .. '" .. '" 0 .. ..J
'" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" I~ '" '" '" 0 '" '" '" '" "-
a: . => 0 => 0 => 0 => 0 => 0 => ..J => => x => ...
<t .. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 0- ... '"
a:I 0 ..., ... on <D ..... ~ en 0 ~ N ..., ...
on on on on on on <D <D <D <D <D
Z , , 0 , 0 0 0 , , 0 ,
'" '" '" '" '" .. '" '" '" '" '" '"
.,. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ Z ::l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .n
z 0 0 .....
~ ~ ~ N 0 N 0 0 '" 0 '" <Xl 0 .....
III ~ '" 0 N ~ ..... '" '" <Xl
0 . z . . . . . . .
... N M ... .... ... '" M
z III .... N
C[ .. 0
"- )( ~ 0 0 V)
%
>- 0 ... "" '" w 0
CD '" u ... "" "" >- Z
<Xl
<Xl ..
..... ci
0 '" ~
N Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ILl ..... w "" 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 0
'" '" .n .,; ~ ...:
er '" ..... '" ..... ~ 0 '" 0
w -u ~ ~ ~ '" ~ 0
~ .... "- z- ~ ~
c.. ILl ILl 0 =: N
ILl .... ILl u
u
er ~ :I: 0
'"
c.. 0 Ul 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ..;
2 0 0 .,. 0 '" 0 0 <Xl '" 0 .,.
<Xl "" .,. .,. '" "'; N '" '"
III N .,; ~ .,. ~ '" ~ '"
z ~ ~ <Xl
<Xl 0 0 V) V)
... N '" W W
U .. ... ~ ~ >- >-
~ z )(
~ ...
z
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u
, 0 0 0 0 '" ~ 0 0 0 0
<Xl Z ..... ...: <Xl .; <Xl .n 0 "" co co 0
>- co ~
..... -u ~ N ~ ~ 0 ~ 0
CD '" z- "l. ~
N =: ~
.....
0 '"
ILl
:.::
u ILl 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0 '"
ILl .... >- Z 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 N '" ...:
:I: ~ z 0 '" ..... .,. 0 N 0 co co co N ~
C[ iii "" ":. ~ c; -: "l. co ~ 0
0 "-
U % Z .,. "" ~ co ~ .,. ~ '"
0 ~ '"
u ... co 0 0 V)
co ~ w 0
.. ... ~ N >- Z
Z )(
0
'" - III
>-
Q u ,
=> 0 0 0 0 0
- '" liS N 1(3 :n I~
>- '" N ..... 0 N
lID V) 0 ..; 0 0 ~ 0 N co ~
z .....
0 ~ ~ N ~ ~ 0 ,
u -u ~
z-
z =: ~
0
II. ~
0 >
0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0
0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" I~ ~ M
Z U 0 0 '" co 0 '" '" 0 '" '"
Z N ":. 0 '" '" N 0 .....
.. - III
0 ... ..... N ~ '" N ~ '"
GO Z ~ .,.
>- ..... 0 0 V) ~
- ... ~ ... "" '" w
l- i .. I.... ~ ~ >-
-I )(
C W III
Q
... "-
0 ~ ~
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
V) 0 0 0 0 '" 0 '" '"
lID w co .n co ..... ..; 0 N '" ~ ~
>
- ..... ~ ~ ~ '"
~ '" -u .....
Q z-
"" '" =:
N C[
0 :t:
~
,
.....
co
0 ..
z .. ,.: ,.: ..: >-
,.: "-
>- .. ..; :t: >- ,.:
u Z V) ..; -I -I U V) >-
w C[ u
.., C 0 0 0 0 w 0 u u
0 = 0 '" 0 0 0 0 0
'" .,. co '" co ~ "" .,. ~ '" '"
"- 0
""
'" '"
w w z ~
0 C3 '" >- -I -
Z >- >- <Xl >-
(j Q1 Illl: => -I ~ -
% Q '" <Xl '" ...
w 0 e w % V) =- -I
~ >- -I N "" Ii Q w Z =>
V) "- - -I Z V) => Z Q
. >- -I C[ C[ V) - w
Z V) - =- C[ "- :t:
:t: U <Xl ... '" <Xl 0 Q U
0 W U ~ Q '" '" >- ... :t: V) ...
'" '" c - I;;: => => Z -I '" U >
, Ul C[ ... V) V) u u ~ C[ ... Z Q - Z >-
er ~ <Xl Q > Q ... - V) 0 '"
, Illl: "" "" I~ "- Q 0 !2 '" '" <Xl => ;:: '"
ILl ~ >- u u f' >- V) 0 >- -I :t:
0 ~ I- - - :t: ... U ... U
Q :t: :t: Q '" '" Z Q Z -I
Z -I Z >- >- .... ... ... ... - z - - - "- z V)
'" ... "- "- '''' -I '" - '" 8 0
I- V)
~ ... Q ~ ;,. '" >- >- 0 0 Q ... .,. ;:: ...
>- 0 '" >- >- "- V) "- Q >- ... ..... '"
i "- ... ... ... V) , ... '"
I I!l 0 .. -I -I -I -I -I -I Z '" '" C[ C[ -I -I 0
U - -I -I ~ -I -I -I -I 0 U '" ;:'!; "- '"
'" >- C[ ~ '" C[ ~ ~ ;:: ... Z :t: % "-
~ 0 >- >- >- >- -I "- 0 >- '" >- 0
>- - V) V) V) V) V) V) ;: ;:'!; - u z ::> ~ u ""
:I: V) u ~ :s z z z z z z "- => 0 '"
Ul 0 8 - - - - C[ '" V) 0 '" >- -I 0
;:: I~ u w '" => % :t: VI C[ =-
0 Q Q >- Q Q Q Q >< >- 0 '" 0 '" >- <Xl Z
Z Z U U Z Z Z Z W ~ "- w w ::> - Q
. .. '" '" => => '" C[ C[ '" w Z Q ~ VI "- w
er u '" '" '" Z -I Z C[ - , Q >-
.. :t: W :t: >- !~ >- :t: :t: :t: :t: 0 '" C[ - -I '" C[ 0 0 z ~
ILl ... V) Q V) V) V) V) V) V) V) - z - '" -I >- >- 0
- -I - Z Z - - - - >- - '" z W -I V) '"
:.:: 0 z => z 0 I~ 0 z z z z - Q W W U ~ % V) V) >-
er . '" 0 '" u u '" '" '" '" Q Q >- V) w >- >- Q V)
L => :t: => W W => ::> => ::> Q w ~ >- ;: 0 >- C[ C[ - w
~ "- VI "- '" '" "- "- "- "- C[ <Xl '" >- - Q Q '"
CD ci '" '" !~ <Xl '" 0 ~ N "" .,.
'" '" '" '" ..... ..... ..... ..... .....
z , , I.J , , , , , , ,
C[ C[ '" C[ C[ C[ C[ C[ C[
'"
~
'" U.
:I:
..., 0
>-
CO '" ....
'"
.....
VI
0 N 0
.....
W VI z
a::
<l: I-
0.. W W
W I- W
0: <l: J:
0.. 0 II)
'"
'"
..
'"
'"
>- .....
VI
to N
.....
VI
0
W
~
() W
W I-
J: <l:
U 0
(/)
Q
-
CO
u..
0
Z Cl
..
0 '"
- i
~
< ~
...J
::J
CO
is
M
N
0
~
,
....
'"
0
Z
....
U
Z ...
...,
0
0 '"
"'-
(/) M
c: 0
w z
'"
Q ...
....
Z V>
>-
V> ..
< Q
... ~
'" '"
.. 0
~ Z ...J
~ "-
~
Q :I:
< U
'" ..
... ...
J: .... '"
:i >-
~ '" ~
'"
0 ...J
.... ...
V> Q
- "-
C:I-Q
WU~
::s::: Wu
Si6
COg:
z
u Q I ~ :~ ~
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
... (/) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.
>- z '" '" 0 .... N <0 I ~ I~ .... .,;
z 11l .... <0 <0 <0 M '" 0 VI
.. '" M ~ "l. N ~ '" '"
"'- I- N N I~ I:::, ~ .;
i!!i .. M N .. '" ....
)( ~ ~ N N .... N
U 11l
.. ...
..
'"
...
'"
'" 1-11l ~
... Q 0 Q Q Q Q ~ Q Q Q Q
"- _u Q Q Q Q Q 0 Q Q Q Q
0 Z- , N ..; ~ ; N ..; N
::llt .... .... .... M ....
U VI VI .... '" '" N <0 VI 0 '"
U ... " .. " ~ N ~
0 ...
'"
Z 0 0 0 VI 0 0 ~ I~ ~ 0 0 0
Q VI 0 VI '" '" ": 0 .... '"
(/) ~ .... '" 0 '" '" ~ VI cO ,.: 0
U z 0 <0 0 VI ~ <0 N '" 0 '"
z 11l VI 0 "':. ~ 0 ~ M '" ~ '"
... .... N ~ ~ M N 0 ~ <0 :::: '" ~ '"
)( ~ ~ N ~ '" ~
Z
0 11l ...
u
,
z
~
....11l VI 0 VI VI 0 '" l\: 5i ~ 0 0 0
N 0 '" '" ~ '" 0 M M
Z~ ~ ..: <0 .,; .; '" ~ ~ '" ..; .,;
::lll: '" '" '" .... '" '" 0 ~ M
Q. ~ ~ ... ~
... .
Z
>- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ g ~ 0 0
Z
.. en 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
"'- .,; N ..: N g I~ ~ .,; .,; ..;
'" z 0 0
'" '" M M '" ~ .... 0 '"
0 11l .... '" '" "':. N '" .... M '" '"
U ....
'" <0 N M N ~ ~ I" M M ~
z )( ~ ~ N N '" N
0
;:: 11l ...
u
::>
'"
....
V>
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 z I ~ z 0 0 0
0
u ....11l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z _u .; <0 ..: ~ .,; .,; ~ I;: ~ .,; .,; ~
0 Z- .... .... '" '" '" 0 N '" VI
u ::lll: ~ ,;... ;... ~ ~ ~
... Q. ...
>
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
U 0 0 .,; ..;
Z U; '" .... 0 0 0 ~
... .... 0 <0 M ~ .... 0 M 0 '"
Z '" ~ N M "':. ~ .... '" ~ '"
>- 11l M '" ~ N ~ .... ~ <0 '" <0 N N
~ .... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M N
...J )( ...
... 11l
Q
"-
0
V> 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z 0 g 0 0
... 0
> ....11l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
... -u .,; .,; N .... '" '" ~ .; ~ 0 .... ,.:
'" ~a:
Q '" <0 '" '" '" '" M 0 '" '" '"
'" ~ ~ ~
.. Q. ...
:I:
~
.... "- ..: "- ..: ..: ..: ~ ..:
Z ....; ..: ..: "- ....; "- ....; ....; -' ....;
< ...J ....; ....; ...J
...J ...J
::l .. .... N N .... .... ~ M
0 '" ~ 0 ~ '" 0 N 0 .... '" '"
N N M '" N N ~ '" ~ ~ ~
0 Q Q 0 Q Q 0 Q Q Q Q Q
... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
(/) U U U U U u u u u u u u
'" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
c: 0 0 0 0- 0 0 0- 0 0 0- 0
"- "- "- "- N "- "- "- N "- "-- "- N "- ~ "- .
f2 z - z . Z - z: ~ z - z - z ~ z - z 0 z ~ z: ZO
... <0 ... '" ... '" ... 0 ... '" ... '" ... 0 ... '" ... ~ ... , ... ~
... 0 ... 0 ... 0 ... - ... , ... , ... ... 0 ... 0 ... - ... ... ,
'" - '" - '" - '" 0 '" - '" - '" 0 '" - '" - '" 0 '" '" -
'" <0 <0 ~ <0 <0 ~ <0 '" ~ '" ~:
~ '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
... :I: ... :I: ... :I: ... 1= ... :I: ... :I: ... :I: ... :I: ... :I: ... :I: ... 1=
.... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... "'- ... e; ~~
'" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... ~ ... '" ... ~ ... "'... '" ... '" ... '"
c: :'5 Q .. Q .. Q :'5 u Q .. Q Q .. Q :'5 Q .. Q :'5 Q
... ... ... ... ... ... ... : r
~ Q :I: Q :I: Q :I: 0 :I: Q :I: Q :I: Q :I: Q :I: 0 :I: Q :I: OJ :I:
U U u li! u u u u u u u
Z ::.l: Co Z Co Z ~ Z "" Z N Z N Z Z Co Z Z Z
... ... ... OJ ... ... ... ... '" ... ... '" ... '" ...
11l ~ '" ~ '" N '" M '" M '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" VI '"
0 t= .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ...J ~ ~
...J :I: -' :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: -' :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :I: ...J :I:
() .. .... .. .... .. .... .. .... .. .... .. .... .. .... .. .... .. :; .. .... .. ....
.... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... .... .... ... .... ...
V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z V> :z
~ Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z ~. ~
... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
"'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'- "'-
Q ... Q ... 0 ... Q ... Q ... 0 ... 0 ... Q ... OJ ... Q ... OJ ...
Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- Z "'- z: "'- Z "'-
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... B
:I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: .... :I: ....
V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ... V> ...
... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ... '" ~
Z U Z u Z u Z u Z u Z u Z u Z u Z u z: u Z u
'" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z '" Z
::> 0 ~ OJ ::> 0 ::> 0 ::> 0 ::> 0 rP 0 ::> 0 ::> 0 ::> 0 ::> 0
"- u u "- u "- u "- u "- u u "- u "- u "- u "- u
d 0 ~ ~
0 ~ N M '" '" <0 '" '" ~ ~
0 , , 0 , , , , , , d
Z '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
...
-
u..
'" 0
:>:
..,
>- '"
[II '"
'"
....
0 '" 0
N
W .... Z
'"
a::
< I-
a. W W
W I- W
a:: < J:
a. 0 IJl
:E
'"
c(
'"
'"
>- ....
'"
[II N
....
'"
0
w
:s:::
0 w
W I-
J: <
0 0
(J)
C
-
CO
LI-
0
co
Z -
'"
0 !
-
I-
<t ;2
....I
~
CO
~
M
N
0
-
.
...
'"
0
Z
....
'-'
w
Z ..,
0
'"
0 "-
(J) M
c: 0 c(
W Z 0
;:; Q2
C 0
.... -'
Z v> ....
>-
'"
<t :>:
w '-'
'" c(
c( w
Z CO
~ -
;i! >-
'" ;i!
<t -'
'" w
w '"
:c ....
c( ....
~ ~ 0
'" >-
0 t::;
....
'" '-'
ffit)
~w
~a
coB:
z
'-' Q 0 0 12 0 0 0 0 2 ~ ; 2 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
- lJ) .;. I~ ai ...: M .~ I~
,: z 0 '" ... '"
N ... 0 M M '" ... 8
Z I.LI 0 M 0 ... '" 0 '"
c( ..... I ; I~ ...
"- M ... '" 0 M M '"
:E X '" - 8 M -
0 I.LI ... -
'-'
..
~
w
'" 12 2 ~
'" It::lj 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.... z- I:: ...: M I ~
N N '" M ... '" M
0 ::)0:: - N ... - '" '" 0 '" '"
'-' Q. - - I": - N N 0 '" '" 0
'-'
0 ... M '" M ... ...
'"
z '" 0 ~ 0 0 '" 0 I ~ ~ 0 0 0
Q '" '" '" ... ... 0 0 0 0
lJ) .,; 0 ~ M N .;. ... 0 ~ . 0
'" N 0 N - ... '" '"
z '" ... - '" ~ " '" '" '"
I.LI N '" '" ... - - j; < - M 0
..... ... - ... '" N - -
'-' x ... .
Z .
- I.LI
.
Z
0
'-'
, ~ 8 ~
Z '" '" '" 0 '" 0 0 0 0
~ .....1&.1 '" - '" ... 0 0 0 0 0
2!~ '" .,; ~ '" ...: N ... ~ 0 0 0
::)0:: '" 0 M '" ... ... - M ...
- - - - - '" M '" M
Q. ... .
- ~ '" ... ... '"
z ~ I~ ~
>- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
c( Cii
"- .;. 0 N ui N 0 0 0 0
:E Z '" M '" '" ... N '" '" 0
0 I.LI N '" N " ": 0 ... N 0
'-'
Z ..... M 0 ~ <Xl '" ... - I" '" '" ...
x '" - <Xl 0
8 ... -
.... I.LI
'-'
:::>
'"
....
'" 2 ~ ;
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'-' .....1&.1
N '" ~ '" - '" 0 0 0 0
Z _u N N '" <Xl '" N '" '" 0
0 z- - - - - - 0 - ": 0
'-' ::)0::
- Q. ... - - . - - N
>
Z 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 ~ 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
..; Cii ... 0 ~ '" N ui .,; ~ .,; .,; 0
Z <Xl M '" '" ... <Xl ... - N
- Z - M ... M 0 "i M '" ~
1&.1 N .,; ~ ... N N - " - 0 ... ...
>- ..... '" - ... '" -
~ ...
x
-' 1&.1
w
'"
....
0 2
v> 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0
w .....1&.1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
> -u ...: ~ ~ N N .;. .,; .,; .,; 0
- 30: '" M '" '" ... <Xl ... 0 -
'"
'" - ; - - - "i 0 '" M
'" Q. ...
c( - ~ - N N N
:>:
~
..... ..: ..:
z .... ..: ....
ct .... -' -' :>: 0:: 0:: 0:: 0:: 0::
-' -' -' '-' '-' '-' '-' '-' '-'
::) -' c( c( c( c( c( c(
0 0 <Xl '" '" W W W W W W
... ... '" 0 ... N
N ... ... - ... '" - N - '" M N
'" '" '" '" '" '"
(J) w w w w w w
'-' '-' '-' '-' '-' '-'
c: '" '" '" '" I~ I~ ;,.
0 0 0 0 ;,. ;., ;., ;., -
.... ....- ....- ....- .... .... - ...
~ Z - Z 0 Z 0 Z 0 z- Z 0
- <Xl - - - - - - - <Xl - - W W W W W W
W , W , W , W , W , W , -' -' -' -' -' -'
'" - "'- "'- "'- '" - '" - 0 0 0 0 0 0
S:'t .., <Xl <Xl <Xl .., <Xl 0:: 0:: 0:: 0:: 0:: 0::
-' -' -' -' -' -' Z Z Z Z Z Z
c( 0:: c(:>: c( 0:: c( 0:: c( 0:: c(o:: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
> .... >.... > .... > .... I~ .... I~ ....
0 "- 0"- 0 "- 0 "- "- "-
c: w w w w w w c.. c.. ;, ~
'" ;., '" '" '" '" '" '" .., ..,
M 0 <Xl '"
I- '" 0:: '" 0:: '" 0:: .., 0:: ... '" ...0::
X '-' X '-' X '-' X '-' X '-' x,-, w w w w w w
Z ::E .. Z Z ro Z ;., Z Z Z "- "- "- "- "- "-
1&.1 w ..w w w row row >- >- "- >- >- >- "- >-
0 M '" M '" M '" ... '" ...'" ...'" .... .... w .... .... "- .... w .... "-
I:: .... .... .... .... .... .... "- w "- w w w
-' -' -' -' -' -' -' w -' '" -' w -' w -' '" -' w
() -' :>: -' 0:: -' :>: -' 0:: -' 0:: -' 0:: -' W -' -' w -' '" -' -' '"
"" .... "" .... "" .... c( .... "" .... "" t::; "" '" c( - c( '" c( c( - c(
.... :i .... - .... - .... - .... - .... .... .... N .... .... - .... N .... -
'" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" v> '" v>- '" - '" - v> 0 '" - v> 0
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z <Xl Z , Z <Xl Z _ Z , Z -
- w - w - w - w - w - w - , - - , - , - - - ,
"- "- "- "- "- "- ;., 0 ;., - 0 -
'" - '" - '" - '" - '" - '" - '" 0 - 0 0 '" '" - '" <Xl
Z "- Z "- Z "- Z "- Z "- Z "- Z Z Z Z Z Z
c( c( c( c( c( c( c( c( c( c( "" c(
w w w w w w '" '" '" '" '" '"
0:: .... :>: .... 0:: .... 0:: .... 0:: .... :>: .... 0:: W 0:: W 0:: W 0:: W :>: w 0:: w
'" W '" W '" W '" W '" W '" W '" .... '" .... '" .... "'.... '" .... '" ....
- '" - '" - '" - '" - '" - '" - w - w - w _ w - w - w
Z '-' Z '-' Z '-' Z '-' Z '-' Z '-' Z :E Z :E z :E Z:E z :E z :E
'" Z '" Z '" z '" z '" z '" Z '" c( '" c( '" ::: "'c( '" ::: '" c(
:::> 0 :::> 0 :::> 0 :::> 0 ~ 0 :::>0 :::> - :::> - :::> :::> - :::> :::> -
.... '-' .... '-' .... '-' .... '-' '-' ....'-' .... '" .... '" .... '" .... 0 .... '" .... '"
0 M ... '" '" ... <Xl '" 0 - N M ...
- - - - - - - N N N N N
Z , , , , , , , , , , , .
'" '" '" '" '" '" <Xl '" '" <Xl '" '"
....
-
co U.
:t: 0
...,
>-
CO '"
co
00
C "- 0
"'
UJ N Z
"-
0:: '"
<( I-
0. W W
W I- W
a: <( J:
0. C IJ)
:E
'"
<(
00
00
"-
"'
>- N
"-
CO "'
C
w
:.::
0 w
W I-
J: <(
0 C
C/)
C
-
[0
L1.
0
..
-
Z ..
!
0
-
l-
e:( ;!
..J
:J
[0
~
M
N
0
-
,
~
00
.,;
z:
I-
U
....
Z ...,
0
'"
0 "-
C/) M
0:: 0 i3
z:
W :E 01
C .... 0
I- ...J
v> ....
Z >-
v>
e:( :t:
.... U
'" <(
<( ....
z: CO
~ -
~ >-
0 ~
...J
e:( '" ....
.... 0
I-
:::c <( ....
~ 0
(/) '" >-
e 0 ~
l-
v> U
~
O::~
wU
~W
~a
[Og:
-
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 <:> 0
u Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z , ..; cO ~ .; .; ...:
- lI'l .; ..; '" .... 00 00
. z '" 0 0 .... 00 .... .... "' 0 00 '"
>- 0 '" '" '" '" .... .... 00 00 00 00
z: UJ
<( t- "' '" '" '" N '" '" .... "' ~ 00 "'
"- - N
:E )( ...
0
U UJ
..
<(
'"
.... ~
'" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'"
.... ...!'l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.... _u .; ..; M ~ - o:i ~ cO .... .; ~
z- '" "' "' '" .... "' 0 00 '"
0 ::)0:: 0 '" '" "' "' .... .... 00 '" 00 00 00
u ll. .,; .,;
U "' .... .... .... '" '" .... ~ 00 "'
0
'"
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g ; 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Q 0 0 .,; 0 0 0 0 q 0 0 .,;
lI'l "' '" '" N - .... '" ~ "' 00 00
'" N 00 0 '"' ~ "' M - -
Z ..; .;- ...
U UJ '" N '" ~ '" '" '" '" "'
z: - - - -
- t- ...
)(
z: UJ
0
u
0
z: ; ~
;e 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
t-UJ 0 0 0 0 0 0 .,; ~ 0 0 .,;
Z~ '" M M .... ~ .... '" '" 00 00
::)0:: '" '" .... M '" '" '" M -: -
ll. "' '" '" '" '" '" '" .. .., '" '" "'
...
>- z 0 cO 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0
z: 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
<( Ui .,; 8
"- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
:E 00 0 00 '" .... 00 N M '" 0
0 Z M ~ '" 00 .... '" 00 M " 0
u UJ - .,; 0;
N .... M '" .... .... '" "' ....
z: t- - -
0 )( ...
;:: UJ
u
=>
'"
l-
v> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ; ~ 0 0
z: 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u t-UJ 0 0 0 0 .,; .,; 0 .,; 0 0
z: _u 00 '" '" M 00 00 N M '" 0
0 z- M "1- '" '" .... '" 00 M .... 0
u ::)0:: N N M .... '" .... .... ..; "' "' ....
-
> ll. ...
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ i 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 .,; .n .n .n .n .n .n 0
u '" .... .... '" '" '" '" N - '"
z lI'l '" M M N ~ 00 00 N - '"
- Z N 00 00 - - .... .... "' .,; M
UJ - -
>- ... ...
<(
'" )(
...J UJ
....
0
....
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0
v> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.... t-UJ .,; 0 0 .n .n .n .n ~ "' .n .,;
>
01 -u '" .... .... '" '" '" '" N - '"
~ir '" - - ~ 00 00 00 N - '"
0 N .... .... M M .... .... 0: "' '.,; M
'" ll.
<( ...
:t:
~
... ~ ~
Z :t: :t: :t: :z: :t: :z: :z: :t: :t: :z:
u u ~ u u u u u u u
< <( <( <( <( <( <( <( <( <(
::) .... .... '" .... '" .... .... .... .... '"
0 - N N M M - - - - - - -
~ "- "- ~
.... "- .... I~
.... .... .... '" .... .... "
- - 0 ;:.. '" Co Co Co 0 ...J ...J ...J
~ ~ 0 0 0 0 '"
f2 0: :t: I~ :t: :t: X
'" . 0 ~ '" '" -0 C: z: z: z: ...J
...J :E - 0 ...J ...J :E - l ;e ;e ;e -
0 0 0 - 0 0 0 0 ~ ~
~ :t: I- - , :t: :z: I- - I~
z: I- 00 z: Z I- 00 ex >< >< >< ><
;e 0 00 ;e ;e 0 0 0 0 0 ~
co co co co co co
l- I- ~
0:: '" ;., I- ., ., '" I'" .,
..., ..., ...J '" ..., ...J ? ..., ..,
, z: - ...J , z:
I- - ~ z: g: - ~ I~ ex
'" '" - '" '" ;: .... '" '" '"
Z ::!! "- "- , "- "-' "- "- "- "- ,
>- "- >- '" Co >- >- "- >- '" ~ >- >- >- >- u
UJ I- '" I- , I- "- I- '" I- , l- I- I- "- I-
e !:: '" - '" '" "- "- '"
...Jo ...J '" - ::; '" ...J 0 ...J .... ~ i ...J "- ~ '" ...J '" ...J '" ...J t;:
U ...J ...J "- ! '" 0 ...J ...J "- ...J '" '" ...J '" ...J 0 ...J
<( - "" >- "- <( ;:: ;,. <( >- <( '" 0 "" 0 <( <( g
I- N l- I- >- I- - l- I- I- 0 l- I- N l-
v> _ v> I- ~ 0 v> - V> v> i 0 V> - v> v>
z: , z: :z: - z: 0 z: :z: z: Co z: 0 z: - z:
- - - I- :t: , - - - I- ;: - - - - - , - ~
0 - l- N i ~ 0 , , 0
0 - 0 " - 0 CO 0 - 0 0 ~ 0- 0 0
Z z: " z: z: z: z: 00 z: 00 z: - z: i
<( "" <( "" "" <( "" "" ""
'" '" i '" '" '" '" ~ .
:z: '" :t: '" '" :t: .... :z: '" :t: '" :z: ~ " :z: " :t: " :t:
v> l- v> l- I- V> l- V> l- v> l- v> V> - v> v>
- '" - '" '" ~ '" - '" - '" - '" "' - ~ - ~ -
z: :E z: :E :E :E z: ~ z: :E z: X X z: X z: X z:
'" ::s '" ::s <( '" "" '" '" ::s '" ...J ...J '" ...J '" ...J '"
=> => - => - => => => ~ => - => Co ~,
.... 0 .... 0 0 .... 0 .... 0 .... 0 .... '" '" .... 00 ....
~, '" ~ 00 '" 0 - N ::l .... "' '"
0 N N N M M M M M M
, , do , , 0 , , d, , , d,
z '" '" 00 '" '" CO '" CO CO
...
-
u.
'" 0
:J:
..,
>- 0
-
10 co
co
....
0 U'> 0
N
W .... Z
U'>
a:
<l: I-
0. W W
W I- W
a: <l: I
0. 0 III
:E
'"
""
>- co
co
OJ ....
U'>
N
....
0 U'>
w
::.::
() w
W l-
I <l:
() 0
(/)
C
-
OJ
u.
o
<=
Z ;;
Qi
.... ~
oCt ;!
...J
::J
OJ
~
0
Z
>-
U
""
Z ..,
0
""
0 a.
(/) .,;
0: 0 C3
W Z
-
:E ""
C "" 0
>- ...J
Z on ....
>-
oCt on ,;
"" u
'" ""
"" ""
~ Z '"
~ >-
0 <Ii
oCt ...J
"" ""
"" 0
J: >-
"" ....
en ~o
"" >-
0 0 >-
>- -
on u
~
0:...
wU
~w
SiB
0J8:
M
N
o
-
,
....
co
z 0 0 0 0 <:> 0 ::;: ~ 0 ::;: '0 0 0
u Q 0 0
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 " 0 0 0 0 0
- (I) .... 0 0 co 0 0 co co :: ,.; ~ - ,.; N
. z a> a> a> M M M 0 - M - M ....
>-
Z III co - 0 U'> '" 0 U'> '" i- co ... U'> ...
"" I- '" '" .... .... co '" .... - '" .. a> .. a> ... M
a.
:E - -
0 x ...
u III
..
""
""
""
"" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 I::;: 0 0 0
"" I-~
"" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.... _u 0 0 '" 0 0 co co : a> I~ - co I"
z- ....
0 ::IS:: a> a> a> M M M 0 - U'> I~ - '" 1:0-
u co -: 0 U'> '" 0 U'> co ... ... N
U '" '" .... .... co co .... - N I" a> .... ::
0
"" ...
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ::;: 0 g 0 0 I
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Q 0 0 0 0 . ~ .~ 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
(I) '" 0 '" .... M ... N a- co 0 0
Z M a> 0 M ":. co ":. U'> co ... ...
III U'> .; <Xl '" U'> '" U'> - " 0 U'> 0 0
u - N N
Z I-
- X ...
Z III
0
U
I
Z ; ~ ~
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
I-Ill 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 I~ 0 0 ~
-u '" 0 '" .... M ... N a> N 0 0
z_
::Ill:: M a> 0 M .... '" .... U'> .... ... N
l1. U'> ... co '" U'> '" U'> - " .: I': 0 0 g
N -
...
>- z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ::;: 0 0 0 I~
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
"" Iii 0 0 g IS
a. 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0
:E .... '" N a> N U'> M 0 0 I~
0 z ... - ": '" N .... co M a> 10
u III .; .; .. ~ .. I::
'" ... U'> ... ... - .... 0 U'>
Z I- - -
8 x ...
>- III
u
::>
""
>-
on ~ ~ ::;: I~
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u I-Ill 0 0 0 0 ~ ~
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
_u .... co N a> N U'> M 0 g 0 a>
0 z- ... - U'> '" N .... co M a> a> '"
u
- ::Ill:: ... ... '" ... U'> ... ... - " . - N 0 .... I::
> l1. -
...
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 : ~ I~ 0 0 0 Ii
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 .,; .,; 0 .,; 0 0 .,; 0 ~ g 0 0
u Iii M a> 0 M 0 0 .... a> 0 0
Z 0 ~ 0 U'> N ": '" ": U'> U'> 0
-
z ... M ... ... ... ... ... - 1 " ... .... a>
>- III
"" I- ...
"" X
...J
"" III
0
....
0 ::;: ~ 25 !
on 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 0 0
0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0
"" I-Ill .,; .,; 0 .,; 0 .,; 0 0 0
> 0 ~ g 0
- -u M a> 0 M 0 0 .... a> U'> 0 0
"" ~o: 0 ~ 0 U'> N U'> '" U'> 0 N U'> U'>
0 .; N
"" l1. ... M ... ... ... ... - - N .... ...
""
:J: ...
~
I- :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: ~ ~ :J: :J: :J: :J: :J:
Z U U U U U U U U U U U U U
<( "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
::I "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
a - - - - - - - - ~ ... N - N -
~ ~ a. a.
a. "" ""
3 "" "" ""
"" ~ 0 0
U'> 0
~ 3 3 M 3 3 3 3 ;" 0: ~ ;" ;"
;" ;,. >< . ;" ;" . , I - N M
...J U'> .... 0 0 ;, ;,. ;,.
~ >< >< ;:n >< >< >< >< ;,. '"= 0
...J ...J :-' :-' ...J :-' 0 0
. . Z Z Z
.... co co '" co co '" >- I~ ~ >- >-
"" "" "" >< >< ><
~ >< >< >< a. ><a. >< a. >< a. >< ...J ...J ...J 0 0 0
o a. o a. 0 "" 0"" 0 "" 0"" 0 Z Z Z '" '" co
co "" co "" <Xl "" CO"" co "" <Xl "" '" a. - I;:: - -
"" "" 0 0 0 0 "" >- >- >-
0 ~ 0 ;:,. ;:,. ;:,. ;:, "" "- I~ ~ >- >- >-
0: .., .., . 0 U'> '" ...J ...J ....0
0 0 = 0 = 0 = N = 0 "" "" ""
~ - - - - I~ it - -
"" - "" - "" , "" , "" , "" , ... '" ... ... "" u u u
2 a. 0 a. , a. . a. . a. . a. . a. , a. a. a. "" "" ""
>- - >- . >- '" >- co >- 0 >- co >- . >- >- >- >- a. a. a.
~ >-co >-<Xl >- >- >- - >- >- '" >- >- >- >- on on on
0 ...J>- ...J >- ...J >- ...J >- ...J >- ...J >- ...J >- ..... I~ ::. ..... ..... ..... ..... .....
..... ... ..... "" ..... "" ..... "" ..... "" ..... "" ..... ... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... .....
(..) "" ..... ""..... ~ ..... ""..... "" ..... ""....0 "" ..... "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
>- Z >- Z Z >- Z >- Z >- Z >- Z >- >- >- >- >- >- >-
on _ on _ on - on _ on - on _ on - V> V> V> V> V> V> V>
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z =:; Z =:; Z Z Z
- = - = - = - = - = - = - = - I;:: - - - -
.... .... U'> U'> .... U'> .... I~
o = 0= o = 0= o = 0= o = 0 0 Q Q Q Q Q
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z
"" ... ""... "" "" """" "" ... ""... "" ... "" "" "" "" "" "" ""
a. a. a. a. a. a. a. :1
:J: >- :J: >- :J: >- :J: >- :J: >- :J: >- :J: >- :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: :J: :J:
V>>- V>>- V> >- V>>- V> >- on>- V> >- on on on on on on on
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Z:J: Z:J: Z :J: Z:J: Z :J: Z :J: Z :J: Z Z Z Z Z Z Z
"">- "">- "" >- "">- '" >- '" >- '" >- '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
::> - =>- => - => - ::> - => 'i ::> - => => => => => ::> =>
....3 ....3 .... 3 ....3 .... 3 .... .... 3 .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
.... co a> 0 - N M ... U'> '" .... co a> 0 -
0 M M M ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... U'> U'>
, , , , 0 , , , , , I , , , ,
z '" <Xl <Xl <Xl '" '" <Xl '" <Xl '" <Xl co '" co <Xl
...
-
'" Ll.
x 0
..,
>- -
CO '" -
'"
.....
'"
0 N 0
.....
W '" z
ex:
<t f-
0.. W W
W f- W
ex: <t I:
0.. 0 lJl
:>:
t.O
<(
ex)
>- ex)
.....
CO '"
N
.....
'"
0
W
~
U w
w l-
I: <t
U 0
(f)
C
-
CO
u..
0
..
...
Z '"
0 ~
- ~
~
~
...J
:)
CO
~
'"
N
0
-
,
....
'"
0
:z:
I-
U
""
Z ..,
0
'"
0 "-
(f) '"
0:: .,;
:z: <(
W Q
:>: -
C "" '"
I- 0
V> --'
Z >- ...
V>
~ "" ,,;
t.O U
<( <(
:z: ""
~ ... '"
<(
'" >-
Q ::ii
~ '" --'
'" ""
I- Q
J: <(
~ ...
~ 0
'"
0 l-
I- ...
V> U
~
O::t;
~W
~a
aJ8:
z 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 '" 0 0 0 ~ I <::) ; .0 0
u Q <::) ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
:z:
... (I) ~ .... 0 <::) ~ ... N N 0 ~ .,; 0 0
>- z .... ... 0 0 N ... - '" '" ... I~ N
": ": ... ": - - '" .... - '" ...
:z: W
<( ... - '" '" - N
"- .... - ...
:>: X
0 ,...
U W
..
<(
'"
""
'" 0 <::) 0 0 ~ 0 <::) 0 <::) 0 ~ 0 IE <::) 0
'"
"" I-!'J 0 ~ 0 <::) 0 <::) <::) <::) <::) <::) <::) 0
... _u '" .... <::) .,; ~ .... '" '" '" .,; ~ 0 I~ <::) 0
<::) z- '" ... 0 <::) - - '" .... .... ...
u :::Ill: '" ": ": '" - - N
U .... - -
0 -
'" "'"
Po <::) <::) <::) :- <::) 0 0 <::) <::) ~ <::) E 0 0
z 0 <::) 0 0 0 0 <::) <::) <::) 0 0
Q Po 0 0 <::) .; ~ N '" 0 .,; ~ <::) 0
<::) ... ex) N '" .... ... '" ... ... ex)
(I) ": ": ": --:. '" '" '" ex) ": ... '" . '"
z
w - 0 N '" - - N
N -
U .... r>
:z: X
... W
:z:
<::)
u
, 0 0 <::) <::) ~ 0 <::) <::) <::) <::) E 0 IE 0 0
:z:
~ 0 <::) <::) <::) 0 0 0 <::) <::) 0 0 0
....w <::) <::) '" .,; ~ ex) ....: ex) ex) <::) ~ .,; ,~ .,; <::)
-u <::) <::) '" - - N N - ... N N R'
z_ ex) ": .... '" - N N
:::Ill:
a.. <::) 0
- -
>- z <::) 0 <::) <::) I: 0 0 <::) <::) <::) ; <::) IE <::) 0
:z: 0 <::) <::) <::) . <::) 0 0 0 <::) <::) <::) 0 <::)
<( in <::) <::) <::) 0 N ... ~ ..; <::) <::) I~ .,; 0
"-
:>: ... 0 N '" <::) N '" '" ... '" '" ex)
<::) z '" N - '" .... '" '" ex) <::) ex) - '"
u W ex) '" '" '" - '" " '"
:z: .... -
0 x r
...
I- W
u
=>
'"
l-
V> <::) <::) <::) 0 I; 0 <::) <::) 0 0 ~ <::) 2 <::) 0
:z:
0 0 <::) 0 0 0 0 0 <::) 0 <::) 0 0
u ....w .,; <::) <::) .,; '" ~ ~ '" <::) .,; ~ .,; .,;
:z: .... 0 '" ex) '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
_u - N .... .... '" ... ... ...
0 z-
u :::Ill: ~ '"
...
> a.. ...
<::) 0 <::) <::) ~ 0 <::) <::) 0 <::) ; <::) 1:- <::) 0
z 0 0 <::) 0 <::) <::) <::) 0 <::) <::) 0 0
u 0 <::) <::) <::) <::) ~ <::) 0 .,; .,; 0 0 <::) .,;
<::) 0 <::) 0 '" N '" ... 0 0 <::) '"
:z: (I) <::) ~ ~ ~ '" '" ... '" "': '" '" '"
... z '" '" - '" - - ...
. w ...
>- ....
::ii
--' x
"" W
Q
...
0 0 0 <::) <::) g 0 0 0 <::) 0 E 0 <::) <::) <::)
V> 0 ~ 0 0 <::) 0 0 <::) 0 0 ~ <::) 0
"" .,; .,; .,; .,;
> ....w <::) <::) 0 0 <::) 0 <::) <::) ~ 0 '"
'" -u <::) <::) '" '" N N N N N <::) '" N '" ....
~a: '" ~ N N - - - - -
Q ... '"
'" .0..
<( i""
x
~ ~
.... x ..: "" I"" "" ~ .~
z x x ~ u x x x
u u <( ... ....; u u u
<( <( <( '" - .~ - <( <( <(
:::I "" '" '" --' "" "" ""
N ex) ~ . !;; ~ ~
0 N - .. - '" - N N '"
(f) g ~ g t.O ~ ~
=>
0:: ... '" ;;: ;;: --'
"-
~ .,; 0 i '" i
:z: :z: ;;
>< ~ '"
S:i 0 0
'" :>:
>- >- ~ .~ ~ Q !~ ~
l- I- :z:
0:: --' --' <(
<( <(
~ ... ... ~ I~ It "" "" ""
u u u S 5
z :::I!! '" "" '" <::)
"- "- --' --' --'
w V> V> <::) l- ii '" '" '" '"
0 !:: x ""
--' --' :z: --' ~ I; --' --' --' --'
--' --' ~ :z: --' --' --' --'
() << ;; ... ;; << << << <(
l- I- l- I- l- I-
V> V> t.O t.O E It V> V> V> V> V> V>
:z: :z: :z: :z: "- "- ~ Ie:: :z: :z: :z: :z: :z:
... ... ;: ;: :>: :>: ... ... ... ... ...
u u
0 0 V> V> I~ ~ Q,,- 0"- 0 "- ~ ~ Q "-
:z: :z: ... ... N ~ I~ :z::>: :z::>: :z: u :z: u
<< << >< >< '" '" <<u <<u <<u << '" <<'"
"" "" - - -
x x x . x. x. x. x. x.
V> V> "" '" "" "" I! ! '" V> N V> '" V>'" V> '" ~ ~ V> ...
... ... > > > > > ... - ... - ... - ... - ... N
:z: :z: 0 0 ~ 0 ~ :z: :z: :z: :z: ~~ :z:
'" '" :>: :>: :>: '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
0 0 "" "" "" "" "" 00 o 0 o <::) 0 0 o 0
... ... '" '" '" '" '" ... ... ...... ... ... ... ... ... ...
N '" ... '" '" .... '" ~ 0 - N '" ... '" '"
0 '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
z '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
...
-
u.
'" 0
x
..,
>- N
-
co ex)
'"
.....
0 '" 0
N
W :;;. Z
ex:
<t f-
0.. W W
w I- w
ex: <t I:
0.. 0 lJl
:>:
t.O
."
>-
CO
0
w
~
U w
W l-
I: <t
U 0
(f)
C
-
CO
u..
0
..
Z ...
'"
0 i
-
~
~ -'
...J c
:)
OJ
~
'"
N
'"
-
,
....
ex)
0
:z:
I-
U
Z ""
..,
<::)
0 '"
"-
(f) '"
0:: ."
<::) Q
W :z: ...
'"
C :>: 0
"" --'
I- ...
Z >-
'"
X
~ "" U
t.O ."
." '"
:z: '"
~ ...
." >-
'" ::ii
0
--'
~ '" ""
"" Q
I-
." ...
~ <::)
~ '" >-
<::) l-
I- -
'" U
~
O::~
wU
~W
~a
[Og:
z 0 0 Ii ~ 0 0 0 <::) 0 I~ <::) 0
!E Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '0 0
d 0 , d cO 0 . , ,
... (I) 0 0 I~ 0
. 0
'" 0 0 ... 0 0 0 '" '"
>- z .... - 0 <::) ... ": 0 '" ....
:z: W ....:
." ... ::. '" '" " .... N ." I~ N
"- l- - '" .... N ..... '" ex)
:>:
0 X :z:
u l1J .
.
.. .
."
'"
""
~ l1J :5 :5 : Ii!! :5 ~ i :i 8 i!! :i 5l
l::u .,; d g . .; d .;.
! ~ '" - 0 ..;
0 z- .... '" - 0 ." <::) ...
:::Ill: '" '" 0 0 ..... 0
u :z:
u ... I~ '"
0 N ...
- .
'" .
0 0 I~ ! 0 0 <::) 0 0 '" '" '"
z <::) 0 0 0 0 '" '" 0 0 <::)
Q '" 0 .,; .,; 0 0 <::) 0 0 '"
'" 0 0 0 ex) 0 0 0 0 0
(I) '" 0 0 ex) ... '" ... '" ~ 0
z <(
... - I~ 0 ... N '" '" ..... '" - N
l1J '" .... '" '" :z: '" -
u ....
:z: X
...
l1J
:z:
0
u : E
, 0 0 ; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
:z: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" '"
~ ....l1J .,; .,; 1 ~ .,; ....: '" '" .,; .,; .; ...
z~ '" 0 0 - 0 ." '" -
... '" 0 ... ..... -
:::Ill: :z:
... ~ 0 '"
a.. '"
z 0 0 ! ~ E 0 0 0 0 0 <::) 0 0
>- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '"
:z: in .,; .,; ~ 0 0 0 0 0 .,; 0 .,;
." 0 ex) 0 0 N . 0 0 0 '" 0
"- - N " 0 ex) .... N .... '" '" 0
:>: Z . ."
0 l1J - - I~ '" '" .... ex) 0 N ..... ... '" ...
u .... - '" .... ... :z: ... -
...
:z: X
0
... l1J
I-
U
=>
'"
I- 0 0 : <::) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
V> 0 0 0 0 '" 0 .... 0 0 ... '"
:z:
0 ....w 0 0 '" .,; '" N ~ 0 .,; '" .,;
u '" ... '" 0 - 0 ." - -
:z: _u '" '" 0 .... ..... N
z- . :z:
0 :::Ill: ... ~ '" N
U -
... a..
>
0 0 !i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 .,; ~ 0 0 0 I 0 .,; .,; 0 0
0 0 0 0 '" 0 .... '" 0 '"
u ... '" 0 '" '" 0 0 '" 0 0
:z:
... (I) ... - N '" a: ."
z 0 '" ..... N .... 0
- - - '" '" :z: N -
>- l1J
::ii ....
--' x
"" l1J
Q
...
0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0
'" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
"" ....l1J .,; 0 .,; 0 N ~ .,; .,; '" N .;
> 0 '" 0 0 .... - -
... -u N N - 0 0 <( -
'" ~a: .,; .....
Q ... N :z:
'" a.. -
."
X
~ :>: ..: :>: >- ,.: >- :>: :>: >- >-
.... => => => => x
x x '" ....; '" '" '" V> V> '" U V> i
z u u <(
<( <( ." "- "- 0 0 0 "- "- "" I~
"" "" :>: ex) :>: <::) '" 0 ~ :>:
:::I => 0 => ex) '" 0 => 0
0 N N --' - --' '" '" '" --' --' N
l- I....
--' V> I~
"" "" <( :z:
0 '" X t.O
(f) t.O t.O "" ..; ." ." "- '" "" ... ~
=> => "- '" '" '" '"
0:: --' --' '" ... '" t.O ." z Z I-
"- "- "" "- '" I- U ""
~ 0 => "" - :>: :>: ... "" :
'" '" z "" :>: '" "" , 0 0 ... '"
<( ." => :z: 0 '" '" '" '" ... l-
I- I- "" '" 0 I- ... !.L ::ii V> ~
'" '" "" --' ... "" V> ""
S:i 0 0 '" >- N "- I- l- I- ""
:>: :>: 0 x z ... "" >- :z: :z: u
'" I- 0 --' U I- ... ... --' 0 I~
Q Q "" ... ... 0 ." <( ." '"
:z: z Q >- I- '" '" "" "- "- :z: ""
0:: ." ." Z --' u ." "" u <::) :>:
." >- 0 "" I- :>: ... t.O t.O ... ...
~ "" "" <( "- '" '" ... x z Z I- --'
U U "" '"' --' I- ... ... ...
0 0 u --' >- N "- "- Q .
Z :::I!! --' --' ." ... '" ." "" N ... '" ... "" 0 '" I"
~ '" '" .., ." '" '"' => - z '" :z: :z: '" => '" => ." -
0 '" Q :z: 0 8 0 I- Z I- Z
--' --' --' --' ." "" --' ... --' --' ... '" "" '" "" --' --' I:
--' --' --' I- --' 0 > --' I- --' I- --' I- > > --' --' ~
() ;; ;; ;; '" ." '" ." <( u <( u <( u >- ." >- ." ." ." I~
." l- I- "" I- "" I- "" --' --' l- I- I- [
'" '" V> 0 '" t.O X '" '" '" '" '" V> "- X "- X V> '" Z
z :s z u z Z I- Z Z Z "- ..... "- I- Z z I~
... ... ... ... '" ... "" ... "" ... "" <( '" ." '" ... ... I"
l- I- l- I- I-
Q "- Q "- Q '" Q '" ..; Q ." Q ." Q ." 0 ..; 0 ..; 0 0 u ~ --'
:z: u z u Z ." :z: ... z :z: z z z z :z: :z: z z <( "-
<( '" ." '" ." "" <( >< '" ." '" ." '" ." '" <( '" ." Z ." ." 0:. ""
"" "" "" '" '"
x x . x ." X X l- X l- X l- X X X X "" ~
'" '" '" N '" 0 '" "" 0 '" --' '" --' '" --' '" 0 '" 0 '" V> '" I-
... '" ... ... ... ... ... > I- ... ." ... ." ... ." - I- ... I- ... ... ""
:z: z :z: '" :z: 0 z z =:: :z: :z: :z: . z "" ~ ""
'" '" "'''' '" 0 '" :>: 0 '" '" '" '" '" '" '" Q '" Q '" '" V> '"
~ 0 ~~ ~ --' => "" z => 0 => 0 => 0 => z => :z: => => ." I-
... ... ... '" N ... ... ... ... ... ... ... N ... N ... ... '" '"
0 .... '" '" 0 - N '" ... '" '" .... '" '"
'" '" '" .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
z , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
'" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
"
~
!.
"..,.
~
<:.
,""
.....
Ll.
'" 0
x
..,
>- '"
-
CO '"
ex)
.....
0 '" 0
N
W ..... Z
'"
ex:
<t f-
0.. W W
w I- w
ex: <t I:
0.. 0 lJl
:>:
t.O
<
'"
>- ex)
.....
CO '"
N
.....
'"
0
W
~
U w
w l-
I: <t
U 0
(f)
C
-
CO
u..
e
..
...
Z '"
0 !
-
~
~
...J
:)
OJ
~
'"
N
0
-
,
....
ex)
.,;
Z
I-
U
Z ""
..,
0
0 '"
"-
(f) M
0:: 0 <
W :z: e
-
C :>: '"
"" 0
I- --'
Z '" ...
>-
V>
~ X
"" U
t.O <(
< ""
~ :z: '"
-
::ii >-
e ::ii
~ --'
'" ""
'" e
J: I-
< ...
~ l 0
'" >-
0 l-
I- -
'" U
~
O::t;
~W
~a
OJ8:
u Z 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 ! ,;
Q 0 0 0 '0 0
:z: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C
- (I) 0 0 .,; .,; .,; .,; .,; .,;
I~ 0 0 0
>- z '" 0 0 0 0 '" 0 '" 0 ex) 0
z l1J 0 0 0 '" - '" ... .... '" '"
< .,;
"- .... - '" 0 '" '" ... '" '"
:>: N
0 X ...
u l1J
..
::ii
""
'" ~
'" 1-l1J 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
"" '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 0
... .,; .,; ~ ..: ....:
_u '" '" '" '" 1::- 0 '" ..:
0 z- 0 ..... - ..... ..... '" 0
u :::Ill: ... 0 N ..... 0
U -
0 '" N
'"
Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ; 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Q 0 0 0 0 .,; .,; 0 0 .,; .,; .,; 0 0
(I) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OJ '" 0
... 0 0 ": ex) N '" '" ... N '"
Z
l1J - '" 0 .... 0 .... '" '" '" .....
.... N -
...
U X
:z: W
-
.
:z:
0 0 0 0 I~
u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z ....w .... 0 ~ N .; ~ ..;
~ ex) ex) 0 ex) OJ 0
Z~ 0 - N - N - - 0 - 0
:::Ill: ... 0 ex) -
'" -
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I~ 0 0 0 0 0
>- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" 0
z in 0 .,; .,; N .,;
< 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
"- ex) 0 '" .... N - 0 0 0 ex) '" ex) N
:>: Z - ":. N '" " N '" 0 ex) '" -
0 w N '" 0 '" '" .,; ~
U .... N '" '" ... -
Z X ...
0
- W
I-
U
0
'"
I- 0 . ~
'" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z '" 0 N N N .... 0 0 0 N 0 '" 0
0 ....W .,; 0 ~ ~ '" .,; :: N <0 ~ .,;
U 0 0 0
_u - 0 - - - N - - 0 - N
:z: z- ":. '" N
0 ...
u :::Ill: '" -
- a..
,.
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ! ~ 0 0 0 0 0
z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.,; .,; . .,; .,; .,;
0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 .,; .,;
0 0 '" '" 0 0 '" 0 '" 0 '" .... ....
U (I) '" ~ ":. N 0 ... co:; '" N ~ '"
:z: M
- z ... 0 ex) '" '" '" '" '" N -
W - - -
>- ....
::ii X
--' W
""
e
...
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" '" 0 '" '" 0 0
'" ....W N 0 .,; .,; .,; ..: '" ~ .,; N .,; .,; .,;
"" ex)
,. -U 0 - - - - '" - ....
- ~a: ... 0 ....
'" 0
e a..
'" -
<
X .
~ ,.: :>: ,.: ,.: ..: u ,.:
.... 0 .,.; >- >- ... ~
.,.; '" .,.; ....; ~ .,.; >- ,.: ,.:
z '" V> --'
<( "- 0 U U
0 :>: '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 u
:::I 0 0 N '" 0 0 '" 0 " 0 0
0 N --' - '" '" '" '" '" ... - '" '"
..
! "" '"
--' ""
'" ""
'~ < Z
~ I- -
V> t.O
e z I! :z: z:
"" 0 0 ""
N - "" "" "" ""
~ - I- --' --' --' --' ... >-
--' u ::i < ::i < 0 '"
- "" Z '"' Z '"' ~
OJ z: '" 0 '" 0 "" "" '" ! ~ --' e
S:i < z: e - e_ e e '" < "" X
I- 0 - I- - I- - - 0 ,. '" U
V> U '" U V>U V> '" U 0 "" z:
"" "" OJ e :>: e ""
"" "" '" ""V> "" "" C '" "- 0 "" '" '"
0:: ~ '" U U U U 0 V> '" 0 I-
... - "" - "" - - U
~ X e X l- XI- X X ~ e '" to Z
I- Z < I- < 1-< l- I- "" "- '" - 0 z: -
- "" z: z: "- 0 "- --' ... -
Z :::I!! '"' X '" '" >- '" >- 0 e ""
~ '" I- "" ... '" ~"" ... '" l- e I- '" :z: e l-
e --' l- I- 0 "" ""
--' --' 0 --' --' --' --' --' --' --' --' --' --' - '" '"
--' --' OJ --' <( --'< --' --' --' --' --' I ~ --' I- U
() <( < ;; < <( < ;; <( ;; < < "" z:
l- I- t.O '" 1-'" l- I- l- I- ,. --' "- 0
'" '" z '" 0 '" 0 '" '" V> '" '" '" <( <( - U
z: z ;: z: ... z ... z z z: z: z z :s z: U _ "-
- - - - 8 - 8 - - = - >< '" '"
'" z: z I~ "" "" '" 0
0 e - 0 0 eo e l- e l- e e e 0 I- 0 0
z z: >< z ;: z: _ z: U z: U z: z: z: z: ;i~ ... ""
< < "" < <I- <( 0 < 0 < < <( <( z:
'" U U '" '" z --' <
X "" X X X 0 Xo X l- X l- X X X X 0 to < --'
V> e '" t.O '" '" '" '" V> V> V> '" V> V> '" '" - z: - --'
- --' - 0 - I- -I- - Z - :z: - - - - I- - '" ""
z 0 :z: 0 z '" z V> :z: 0 z 0 :z: :z: :z: z - e "" U
'" 0 '" '" '" :z: "'z '" U '" U '" '" '" '" e e I- '"
0 X 0 X 0 0 00 0 "" 0 "" 0 0 0 0 e "" ~ i:
... '" ... I- ... U "'U ... '" ... '" ... ... ... ... < OJ
0 - N '" ... '" '" .... OJ I~ 0 - ~I '"
0 '" OJ ex) '" ex) '" ex) ex) ex) '" '" '"
, , , , , , , , , 1,,1 , , , ,
z '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
/ 7_ 1':.>
...
-
Ll.
'" 0
x
..,
>- ...
CO -
ex)
OJ
0 ..... 0
'"
N Z
W .....
ex: '"
<t f-
0.. W W
w l- W
ex: <t I:
0.. 0 lJl
'"
t.O
<
ex)
>- ex)
.....
CO '"
N
.....
'"
0
W
~
U w
W l-
I: <t
U 0
(f)
C
-
CO
u..
0
..
...
Z '"
0 ~
- !
~ ~
~
...J
:)
CO
~
'"
N
0
-
,
....
OJ
I-
U
""
Z ~
0"-
(f) '"
0::
W
C
Z
~
~
~
J:
~
O::~t;
~w
~~
OJa.
z 0
u Q 0
Z ~
'":. (I)
>- Z N
'"
~ W . ~
.... - 0 Vl
0 '" "" 0
'" X '" '" >- :z:
0
u W -
.. ...
"" .
'"
'" .
'"
'" I-!'J
""
... _u
z-
0 :::Ill:
u
u
0 .
'"
0
N
Z ....
Q "
(I) '"
z ...
U w 0 ~ '"
N 0 '"
:z: .... '" "" ""
... X - - >- >-
:z: W ...
.
0 .
u
,
:z:
~
....W
Z~
:::Ill:
0
'"
>- z ..:
:z: 0 -
< in '"
"- .
'" z '"
0 '"
u W -
:z: .... - 0 ~ Vl
0 X ... "" 0
... W ... N >- Z
I-
U
=>
'"
I-
'"
:z:
0 I
u ....W
:z: Z~
0
u :::Ill:
...
,. a..
0
0
z N
0 '"
N
U (I) M
:z:
... Z '" .~
ex) 0 Vl Vl
. W '" "" ""
>- .... ... - >- >-
<
'" X
--' W
""
e
...
0
Vl
"" ....W
,.
... -u
'" ~a:
e
'" a..
<
X
~
....
z
<(
:::I
0
""
--'
~ =>
e
""
x
u '"
~ Vl ,.
... --'
I~ Vl ;;
=>
I" --' 0
S:i U I-
Z
e ... Z e
;;;", 0 ""
0:: ... l-
I- "" U
~ ~ "" --' ""
~ --' => '"
<'" "- Z e '"
Z :::I!! ~X '" 0 "" 0
0 ;: X U
~ ~ g u u .
0 "" Vl .
<~ --' --'
() < "- Vl
I~ X ... '" '"
l- I- 0 ""
Z U '"
- ;; t.O
, --' 0
'" '" < '"
'" :z: "-
Vl => ...
I~ '" Vl ... e
"" e ""
" I- 0 0 :z: I-
... l- I- 0 ~
!~ '"
Vl '"
>- >- e ;:
'" < < ... '"
e e '" ""
0
z
0<
z8
"''''
"'0
1---'
'" ...
>-
'"
X
""u
t.O<
< ""
Z '"
...
::2>-
e02
--'
'" ""
"" e
I-
""...
~o
"'>-
OI-
I- ...
VlU
DEPART 1ENTAL
CORRESPONDENCE
TO
Walter O. Barry, City Manager
CITY DF
DELRAY BEAtH
.~~-~
~I
FKOM~,'DaVid M. Huddleston, Director of Finance
:;UBJECT
Banking Services for 1988 Water and Sewer Bond
Background
07-21-88
d6-~~
On July 6, 1988, the City sent a Request for Proposal to eight financial
institutions requesting interested parties to submit proposals to serve as:
1. The City's paying agent and bond registrar
2. Escrow agent
for the approved 1988 $30,000,000 Water and Sewer Revenue Bond Issue.
The following banks submitted
p.m. July 15, 1988 deadline.
individually or on a combined
sealed proposals in compliance with the 2:00
The City reserved the right to award the bids
basis.
Barnett Bank and Trust Company
Citizens and Southern Bank
Florida National Bank
Midlantic National Bank
NCNB National Bank
Sun Bank, N.A.
The attached schedule reflects a summary of fees for the above mentioned
services.
Recommendation
I recommend that the low bidder, Citizens and Southern, be appointed to
serve as paying agent and registrar and the low bidder, Midlantic National
Bank, be appointed as the escrow agent by the Commission for the approved
1988 $30,000,000 Water and Sewer Revenue Bond. Both satisfy the minimum
requirements and Midlantic National Bank currently acts as escrow agent for
the 1984 Water and Sewer Bond Issue.
DMH/rso/sam
cc: Becky O'Connor, Treasurer
~ ::67
T,
,
': ~ '")r:-~ T A l_'.,\/\ YS M 1-\ TTEn.>
~3-H
l
.
~
co
'"
Ul UJ
~
~
~
z ~
..:;) 0::
~~
~
~
~ ~
7.: :z
"'~
~ =
~ ..
""
'"
~ <>
~""
=- (...;a
~'"
~ ~
eQ
;;;:~
,r ""
~ <<
~ '"
<:r !--,
::;;c:~
,U =
'" ~
~ ""
L ~
~ '"
<< ~
~ =
"" ..
~_ (.0
.. '"
""
-, ~
~ <<
<> n.
,~ ""
'" '"
~.
1-- U)
~
" ~
~.
~
X
~
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
,
z
..
""
~
~
~
..
""
""
""
_--J ::..::
.. ..
'" <<
0,,"
~
""
%
~
~
T-
..
~
o
r.
......J ~
"" %
'" ""
0""
>-
'"
%
""
T-
~
'"
<i
T-
:...:
%
""
'"
'"
'"
u,
.:cJ ~
""
u, ~
% X
~~
..~ ::)
<>
t-- Ul
'"
"
"
"
"
11 ~
" '"
"
" ~
II Oi'::
" '"
" ~
II (.,1')
" ~
" =>
" 0
"
::
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
N
"
"
"
"
~;...:
.. '"
'"' ""
0'"
~
'"
%
..
~
'"
'"
-,
~
~ ">
.. T-
O< 0
~--'
% --'
"" r.
"-
:;0;
'" --'
'" ""
~~
% "
<< %
~
~""
~ 0<
=>
o
--''''
""-
e:;~
"'E
Z >-
a;:~
"-
~
, ~
, ~
,
.
,
,
,
,
,
0::> I C'
~ , C>
C>OC>OOOoOO 1,,-')
l.I'") U'"J y-, tr:I "'""] I/"l in..... , .......
.......-.............-___ Ie.
---...__.... I
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
gggg:g
gg~gggg~!
r-.. -.a U'"ll U'1I tr:IlI"'I U'1I I
------- ,
, ,-
,
, ~
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
, ~-
, ><
, '"
, =
, ..
,
,
,
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
,
:
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
, 0
, '"
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
gggggg~gggggggggg
ggggggg~o,~_..~gggggg~
..0 _ N.;:':o ~OD..o':" _ ........... l"'.l 0:.0 1.1'") IrJ tr:I
- - - - ~., ,..., ,..') ,.., ,..') (""" N ("1 _ _... _ ___
------------.....---
o:;:!o C>O..::-oo '-"0'-' 0
0000000000.0.00500
tr:IolI')ovi
0'-""'..0 0"'"
_ _,.'"""N
..~ '="' C'> V)
.......-..... ,......
("-" c.:. 00-
- ~
o 00 <:>.:;::. ~
-:- ooc.<:>
--=>0:::.""; "'")"'; I.,.,
CO CDlI"lN
00-__"'-"_""
-------
c. C-
O C>
- - --
--------
-=>0 <:> Co
OOoc>o
g6
..:>OC>OOO::::>OOc>-::>
oOo:;;.ooooc>c>o
.,;
o
~
,,~ o'n 0. l(") 10"') CO
~~~iT,~~~
00
.,., C>
00-
-~
It')c. 00==> 0.
(".j In I/"l U"'l ""'
CD,.....,.......... ........
-----
.,.,
~
- - - -.......
----------
C)oooC)C><~..;;:;,._=_.c>c.C)~
.::> 0':;:) -==- -=- C> .0 .-, 0::.' <0 -=> -=- C) 00
ooC>C).:-:- 0-:::> <:..:.=.-'O
~~c>g~~;i;~~~~=:g::
-~
r-tC"lC"-fC"..._.._______
---"""--------
c:;;o 00"::'
c; c; .0. -=-
0000.0-:=0
000_
,..~ In ,.."
~ ~ ~
.:::.-:=OOO~.~c._Oc_oQOo.;;:.
oOOoCoC:-<'::>O<::><::::Oooo<=>
~R~~;g~~t?;~
oo__r--......,....,..~,....._
---------
c.-oooo.=:.oo
-=>00,:=1>0':=>00<:)
c.ooooo...-=-<:)
""OIrlOli")li")OO
o.ocr-cr-O"-Q3
-- -=-----
- - --
<>
<>
.,;
.,.,
~
..
c.ooo
.0000
..-:- r...
.;'-~ t".~
~> 0'" 0-- tXJ -0 Ll1 ..... r;...
t".~ .....~
- cr. r- ....') ", .;:....
&gggggggggggggggg
gg8gg8ggggg~gggg~
~~~~~~u;~~~~~~~~~
-...cJNN..oNOo-CDl("lO"-COC"-faJ_O-
..., CO - ,..') _ I,f'J I,f'J ,..., _ CD ,.., ...... 0:::. 0 0- VI
~ -~;~~~~~~~;~~~
NNNN___ ____.....__
------------
00000000000000000
00000000000000000
8g8888ggggggggg8g
00000000000000000
o~onnnoo~oo~non~o
~_~_4~N__~~O~~~~~
~.~~m_O_N~_~_~__~
------ ..----..-----
--------NNN
-----------
""0
~ ~
0'
~
0<>=
<> C> 0
<>
o
~
~
'"
'"
>-
..
0<
--'
""
-
<>
.....
8
o
on
e
~
~
..
.,.
<>
=
<:'>
~>
CD
-
~
~,
is
o
N
.,.,
~
o
c-
O
.,.,
~
""
~
o
<>
c-
<>
-
<>
C>
<>
o
c-
~
.. ,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
C> ,
<> ,
,
o ,
<> ,
C> ,
- ,
<> ,
~ ,
.. ,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
C> .
<> ,
,
,~ ,
.0,
<> ,
,
~ ,
,
~ ,
,
,
.
,
:
N
~
~
~
~
~
""
<<
""
-
~
=
~
""
u,
~
~
~
~
'"'
~
'"
""
-
<>
""
'"
~
~
~
=
--'
n.
c.
<>
",
.0
=
N
;;
<>
<>
.,;
<>
~
~
,~
c-
O
o
o
-
~
~
.
~
~
~
~
~
~
z ~
~=
=~
~
~t:'j
> ~
i<!~
11
~~
~~
~~
ffi~
:::~
==
=~
>=
:r~
~ ~
~=
= ~
=
~z
~~
~~
~ =
~E
~
~
~~
r
~
Z
~
=
Z
~
~
Z
= Z
~ ~
r =
~
~
~
~
~
~ ~
~ Z
Z ~
= =
~
z
~
=
=
=
~
~
20
~~
~o::
O!
...",,-
~ Z
Z ~
==
~
z
~
-,
i'
=
Z
O!
~
~
~
=
Z
:..
<i
,,;
~
t:J
=
~
=
~
=
~
~
~
~
=
'"
~
~
..;
z
=
z
~;:!!5~
5:~~ii
~~~!
~~4:~
~ r ~
~~~
."'''''-...J
Z Z =
- ~
= ~ -
~z ~
""-<1:<1:0-
~ ~
=~Z
_00.......,...
,~., :::J <I:
-=
~
~
~=
=z
ZQ
8~
~~
~~
:~
:;t':g
Z
~=
~=
""
-
-
~= z
=~~
z= _
~~~
~~
.-..... C>
z~
o::c~
~II
!;;~
z
=
z
~=
~'"
z~
~~
:E:
~~
~II
=:.
-
~
z
~
z
..... ""':II:
=z ~
-z
Z~ ~
::3~ :z
~~ :
11:5:
=~
~~
:;';:"'"
~
Z
II
~~~
Z~ _
2~':::;
::i~1I:
-- =
z ~ =
=~
= -
~~
o...~
==
~=
~
Z~
~~
>~
~~
g!
~~
t:J
~
~
~
~
z
=
z
~ ~ Z
~*
~=z
:::;:E:B
u:;;;
= ~
~ ",
~
~
=
~.~ <->
z
~
~
I
=
~
=
z
z
=
>
=
=
~
~
i
=
~
~
~ z
~~
~ ~
~~
,;;
~
"'
~
~
i5
'"
~
~
~
Z
1'l
~
~
~
.~ =
~ '0
~~
-
~
z
:i!
~ ,
~
S~
:;;-
';!
~S
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
=
Z
~
~
~
=
g
=
o::.a ?;
= Z ~
...... _LLlC>
~ ~
~=:~u
cnU<n:o.l
8"",~~
~~~i:
;:~'~lf"
~ ~
'3 g_
~
~ ~
z z
~
~~
==
~~
=
':~ C>
N
~~
",
'0 =
~ ~
~
,,-,8
<00<1:
=
=
LJ':;:
:;;
:;;
=
u
~
=
~
:;;
~
~
:;;
~
=
:;;
=
g
-
~
~
=
~
:;;
~
.;
t:J
Z
~
3
::;
~
ilJ
~
~
=
"
"
~
~
=
u
~
~
~
=
'"
"
~
=
:;;
~
B
:;;
~
~
8
:;;
=
!!!
=
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
z~
~~
-~
>
~i
..~
-~
~~
-~
"'\;I
11
:;j
~
~
~
~ ~
=~
~~
- ~
:~
!~
o~
:;~
:;;
~
Z
=
Z
j
=~
~g:
~
;:
..
iI
~
~
~
~
~
~
11
z
~~
~ ~
~ Z
Z ~
z ~
~=
=~
= z
;-
~
~
~
=
~
ijl
=
~
~
Z
=
z
~
~ ~
~ Z
s:ig
:~
g:~
=
z
~
~
>
~
=
=
~
Z
=
Z
~
~
~
~
=
~
N
-
~
~
I
=
~
~
~
Z
~
~
~
~
-,
~ Z
~ ~
~~
~ z
=8
,;;
=
:;;
~
!
~
~
~
~
~
'5
~
Z
1'l
~
..
~
~
~
1I
~
Z
=
z
=
~
~
~
'"
~.....
'"
=
~
=
~ ~
;1
!
i
~ z~
=- .:x:.......
==~
~ ~ ~
~ =~
~ ~~
Z<I'lO"""
~ ~ =
~<X.......~
- ,~
:;::5
= Z =
- ~-
:It:""'............
~
~ ~
~~
~ =
=
~
Z~ =
<I: ""'..0_
_........~
~ ~ =
:z~~~
Z""<::IE
~= ~
z W 0.........
~~ .
:Z~<i
~ -
z==
~ = =
= ~
z=~
~ ,=
~ ~ =
~
>
=
=
~
~
~
~
~
Z
= ~
~:
~~ ~
=~ ~
~ ~~
~ ~
_<l:V"J~
~ - ~
Z::EC=>
......""""'<1:
_z ~
:c=
<-.J~~......
~
~
~
~
~
=
;ji
zQ;:5u...
:i~5tQ
~ ~ =
= ~
~ ~ =
~ ~~
'"'.....~~
~ ~ -
~:3<f>::::'
= ~-
==
~=
...... '-~ ..-, '"
~
~~
~~
> =
~~
~
~ ~
z~
~
~~
~=
~~
= ~
"",0.;
l!~
=~
~"
=>
z15=
~....~
==~~
!;!U
~
~
Z ~
= ~
-11
~ ~
=
~=
"'';!
~:=
IB
~
>
~
~
"'
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
=
~
=
Z
~
~:
~ ~
::~>-
~ ~ Z
= ~ ~
~~~
~ z
r =
~~~
~ ~
~~e:
= =
~ ~ =
~ ~
= ~
~ ~ ~
~ . ~
e~:
~::r:
'=':::0.::':
;~~
'f:.a!.~
z =
~ ~ =
==~
l.LI~o...
> =
= ~ z
~:<::
~l5.!5
~
~=~
~~~
~z=
~
~
~
~
~
~
15
:;
"_ Engineers
_ Planners
~ Economists
_ Scientists
July 22, 1988
SEF24708.A5
Mr. Jeffery S. Kurtz
Assistant City Attorney
310 S.E. First Street, Suite 4
Delray Beach, ~lorida 33483
Dear Mr. Kurtz:
Subject: Results of July 22, 1988, Bid Opening for the
Construction of the Contamination Treatment System
for the 20-Series Well Field
The bid opening for the referenced project was conducted at
our Deerfield Beach office on Friday, July 22, 1988, at
10:00 a.m. in the presence of the following representatives:
I. Garrick Hart with Elkins Industrial Constructors Inc.
2. Jim Folds with Indian River Industrial Contractors,
Inc.
3. Jim Daniels with Mechanical & Chemical Company, Inc.
4. Bob Pontek and Ted Glass with the City of Delray Beach,
Florida.
5. Mark Morris, Ted Belser, Bob Wright, Greg McIntyre, and
Rodolfo Valladares with CH2M HILL
The results of the bid opening are recorded on the attached
bid tabulation and summarized as follows:
CH2M Hill
Southeast Florida Office Hillsboro Executive Center North, 800 Fairway Drive, Suite 350 305.426.4008 rr
Deertield Beach, Florida 33441 407.7376665
'3-
Mr. Jeffery S. Kurtz
Page 2
July 22, 1988
SEF24708.A5
Elkins
Industrial
Constructors
Jacksonville, FL
Indian River
Industrial
Constructors
Jacksonville, FL
Mechanical &
Equipment
Company
Brandon, FL
Part I-General $ 86,200,00 $ 75,163.00 $ 149,000.00
Requirements
Part 2-Cash Allowance 991,000.00 991,000.00 991,000.00
Part 3-Lump Sum 118,000.00 202,611.00 200,000.00
Part 4-Unit Price 208,278.90 211,805.00 306,110.00
Part 5-Fixed Fee 82,000.00 75,000.00 112,890.00
TOTAL BID AMOUNT $1,485,478.90 $1,555,579.00 $1,759,000.00
The apparent low bidder is Elkins Industrial Constructors,
Inc. The total bid amount of $1,485,478.90 falls within the
range of the cost estimate prepared by CH2M HILL and pre-
sented to the City Commission during the June 14, 1988,
Commission meeting.
On the basis of the submitted proposal, we recommend that
the contract be awarded to Elkins Industrial Constructors.
A copy of the proposals from each of the bidders is attached
for your information.
Sincerely,
~~4~~t
Ted L. Belser, P.E.
Project Engineer
DBX5/d.301
Attachments
cc: Robert S. Pontek/City of Delray Beach
Ted Glass/City of Delray Beach
Bob Wright/CH2M HILL/DFB
0 0 0 0 0 '"
'" 0-1 '0.... 0 0 0 0 0 '"
r.. llI"*'
....-I-l 0> 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" t:: >, aJ3 0 0 0 .... '" 0
U III t:: t:: 0 0 0 .... 00 0
'''; S '" 0 <JP ....'0 , ,
t:: 0. 0.'0 It'l ~ t:: '" .... 0 \D N '"
"""; S t:: o III .... '" 0 0 .... It'l
..c::;:l0", t::'O .... '" N M .... r--
U t1'CJ k ~'O ,
llIr.:! III U..; ....
'0 :;: ..; tI>- tI>-
....
III
''';
r..
....
....
III
~ 0-1
r..
Ul k Ul '0.... 0 0 0 0 0 0
III llI.... k , llI"*' 0 0 0 0 0 0
'''; > '" 0 III 0>
k "r-i "" +J ~ aJ3 M 0 .... It'l 0 '"
III I'::kU.... \D 0 .... 0 0 r--
CIl -I-l ;:l',,; <JP ....'0 .... 0 \D 00 0 It'l
I t:: Ul k > It'l ~ t:: , , , ,
>, "';:l-l-lt:: o III It'l .... N .... It'l It'l
-I-l '''; '0 Ul 0 t::'O r-- '" 0 .... r-- It'l
t:: 'Ot::t::Ul ~'O '" N N It'l
III t:: H O~ U..; ,
~..c:: H UU ..; ....
E-o U '" tI>- tI>-
'" 'J
ZllIllI
O..c::IIllt'l
H-I-l ..;
E-o >,.
";k"'oo
0-10ko
::l4-l....r--
III llI....
";SON 0-1
E-olll r.. r..
-I-l4-lr.:! Ul '0..; 0 0 0 0 0 0
OUlOCll ....k , llI"*' 0 0 0 '" 0 '"
H>, '" 0 III 0>
III CIl >, Ul',,; -I-l.... aJ3 0 0 0 00 0 00
-I-l t::kU.... 0 0 0 r-- 0 r--
-I-l.,.; '''; -I-l ;:l,,.; <JP ....'0 N 0 0 N 0 ....
t::U ~Ulk> It'l ~ t:: , ,
III ....;:l-l-lt:: o III \D ..; 00 00 N It'l
S r.:!'OUlO t::'O 00 '" ..; 0 00 00
-I-l t:: t:: Ul ~'O '" ..; N ....
'" HO~ U..; ,
III U U ..; ....
k '" tI>- tI>-
E-o 'J
t::
0
''';
-I-l
'"
t:: ~
'''; III k
m U ~ 0
t:: k ~
-I-l '0 '" 0 E-o
t:: '0 t:: ~ ~ III Z
0 III '0 '" 0 U III ::l
U Ul III .... 3 '''; III 0
0 > ....Ul .... k r.. ~
.... '''; "'-I-l t:: ..; CIl ~
U III k t:: 0 '0
t:: U III llI',,; ..c:: ~ -I-l III 0
r.:! III t:: S Ul Ul '''; X H ..;
I':: III llI',,; '" t:: '.-I III 0
'0 (.!Jk> U 0-1 ::l Ii. ....
t:: '" I '.-I k I I I I 0-1
0 '0 ....;:llll N M .... It'l ES '0
III t:: 0'0. "-
III -I-llll;:l -I-l -I-l -I-l -I-l 0 It'l
'0 '0 kl'::CIl k k k k E-o >:
,.-I '0 '" '" '" '" '" III
III ..; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0
.