Loading...
160 Marine Way, *1937 - FMSF 1 . r 'I ... r,. ,, • t 1.7 .' ...7 . \ I m •"."la - !,‘, `,%%. „• ; ' '1, ' ,.,2 I% . ,,,lik ,..- .. ,... ,A.- . . it.k • ‘, - ..14,te7 .<•-, 4 ' ' IL . . z..._ 4a1,1 1111111111112.,..,1 • m .- ,- . .. l: • . • : -- : ,... , 40 - .:' ;,• --- . -. , .0044r, , - *Pr' • ,t• ,_ re 1--:,-, . •'• .,,,Ir , V.-- 1 I 1 - f---4- -„,„,,- l'•--' '. , --1 e„A, . - •; :s.fk- ti ' :i•k• e ' f; :15i* . -- , --.... - ..- _ INIIMma -1 Florida Site#8 PB00269 Master ,1 i i HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder# o SlteV , = Electronic Version 1.1.0 Field Date 5/10/2008 i F le Form Date 6/15/2008 FormNo 200805 First Site Form Recorded for this Site? FormNo=Field Date(YYYYMM) GENERAL INFORMATION Site Name(address If none) 160 Marine way Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names » Surveyor Project Name Marina Historic District Resurvey, 2008 Survey# National Register Category Building(s) LOCATION & IDENTIFICATION Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 160 Marine Way Cross Streets(nearest/between) SE 2nd Street City I Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YEs County Palm Beach Tax Parcel#(s) Subdivision Name Town of Delray Block 126 Lot 13-15 Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Route to(especially if no street address) MAPPING USGS 7.5' Map Name Publication Date »DELRAY BEACH;1997 Township: Range: Section: 114 section: » 46s ;43E ;16;Vague / Unknown Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone 17 Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) 2007 Tax Roll Palm Beach County Property Appraiser DESCRIPTION Style Minimal Traditional Other Style Exterior Plan Irregular Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 2 Structural System(s) » Wood frame Other Structural System(s) Foundation Type(s) » Unknown Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) » Poured Concrete Footing Other Foundation Material(s) Exterior Fabric(s) » Stucco Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) » Cross—gabled Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) » ,Tin Other Roof Material(s) Roof Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) » Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys 1 Chimney Material Concrete block Other Chimney Material(s) stucco Chimney Location(s) North elevation Page 1 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB00269 DESCRIPTION (continued) Window Descriptions DHS, wood frame original windows. Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) Faces east to Marine way. Porches: #open 1 #closed #incised Location(s) East elevation. Porch Roof Types(s) Flat Exterior Ornament Decorative gable vent, original tiled entry porch. Interior Plan Irregular Other Interior Plan Condition Excellent Structure Surroundin's Commercial: Residential: ALL this category Institutional: Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Number I type of outbuildings,major landscape features) Outbuildings to rear — not visible. Archaeological Remains(describe): None observed If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? Narrative Description(optional) HISTORY Construction year 1940 Architect(last name first): Lawson R.C. Builder(last name first): Lawson R.C. Changes in Locations or Conditions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes >>Addition;1994;;Second story addition Structure Use History Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended >> Private residence;1940; Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) Original owner A.E. Turner RESEARCH METHODS Research Methods >> Informal inspection Other research methods SURVEYOR'S EVALUATION OF SITE Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? NO Name of Local Register if Eligible Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES Area(s)of historical significance » Architecture Other Historical Associations Explanation of Evaluation(required) This residence represents the Minimal Traditional style of the 1940s and illustrates the development history of the area. This resource contributes to the Marina Historic District. Page 2 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB00269 DOCUMENTATION (Photos, Plans, etc.) Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other Important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name(Last,First) Adams, Warren RecorderAddress/Phone 618 E. South Street, Orlando, FL 32801 Tel: (407) 423-8398 Ext. 3006 Recorder Affiliation GAI Consultants - SE Other Affiliation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? ****** MASTER SITE FILE USE ONLY****** SHPO's Evaluation of Resource Cultural Resource Type: Electronic Form Used: Date Form Type Code: Form Quality Ranking: Form Status Code: Supplement Information Status: FMSF Staffer: Supplement File Status: Computer Entry Date: Form Comments: REQUIRED (1) USGS 7.5" MAP WITH STRUCTURE PINPOINTED IN RED PAPER (2) LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP ATTACHMENTS (3) PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, B&W, AT LEAST 3"X5" Page 3 of 3 PB00269-200805 Supplementary Printout > USGS map name/year of publication or revision: DELRAY BEACH;1997 > Township/Range/Section/Qtr: 46S;43E;16;Vague/Unknown > Structural system(s): Wood frame > Foundation types: Unknown > Foundation materials: Poured Concrete Footing > Exterior fabrics: Stucco > Roof types: Cross-gabled > Roof materials: Tin > Roof secondary structures(dormers etc): > Change status/year changed/date noted/nature: Addition;1994;;Second story addition Unspecified;2005;;Loggia enclosed > Original, intermediate, present uses/year started/year ended: Private residence;1940; > Research methods: Informal inspection Examine local property records Examine local tax records Sanborn maps FL Master Site File-Cultural Resources Building permits > Area(s)of historical significance: Architecture > Repositories: Collection/Housed/Accession#/Describe > [Other name(s)]: Page 1 Of 1 j WI.. I :';',%57:, . !',,.: ,. . r •' `• F y —i •■ .r r ■ ■••IP • I • o ■ FI �*•elm* 1ye?.S® . a l•• ■ - ;.. rr.L.,� ... r ie• — . g 1■ P ■ o . P� ■ � ti 1. N M 1 ji m b G • `i'. . ( i . .- .,, 4 i• a a• i s v '_ �..�,:....�'s.°six ■ ■ '■ ■••^a�A1� I- -- s (� �{ 11-6.42svH" ° q I®F ti k'■' r ira �y.-_ "t' Ikl,l/ •''7 .,,-1 .i. 1 i . 4. I — 4, ,,, . P Ft[[F .., UEFA' id * .ou 4 I. ..qoplil a I lb+ '_i . NW& sat+ M• s r 4■ P T1' , t.:0 y�Ry1J111 @@ '�{" I it, • 1. 1 I •n ::: ;:1[t M ; '""'" - Dl f amigr cq r _ - Lv/y' .... . .49 is :s 'Q ra r - ■ • "'r . :trIr -• • [1: • ,1 4 • r • _ u . jil fil • up ' 31 pJ ••• M R r• I • , `toEV.M.1, ate"7MI L . P.: iaF..._. _ . W1JVT�114 r. 11,E *e LC B • 1_. . ,� _'—� :. 0.64 ?. •',fsi o---. MI 'Cf4":1.1 d d I i 13 A,'N =Nom E-imivam . oh_ . . 1 ..,, imilliim. . „. .. (..„.): 0110,14, ::. .. e _....c,,.- 0:1,10,..-6- ,q,.._..Ji ...,_ 5.)..,.:,..,,, '' ,.. ; III; +i�I..�" . - --_-_- m _ ... . J , , , , i I r' , 1 ''".,0, i '-'--- "..., i IMAM Y h w' t3 T_ AVE r ..■ • i ,f i 46 lal.1 TER A y nl(6.;.., ---:-.--..., p ,.....,,,,...... .t �'7 , . c k 4 (7$ r •■ ' '' . (P F--,. ..._______4.,„....,_ ,i, .. _ ......,.... r ......;5:.::,...1.../p.. . .40 . 441 1�I 4Oil —.--jr4 I I .• ,�,.�� � 111 4 ?a..Y .._.:-........_�... .. �""-,•v-ir ILA ^r•.. .rr — _ r .s • i�_` 1 s, �, u;Ip i f ,� ` K i;4 4 { a 9.1 2 1 i AT LANT!C AVE (4,--- — — - Ze( 5 };' x ., r:.It - `7 y ' WA!E • :11112 . I M04 4..i i'. i4 at I PI1. a ;'�= 1 • .5 TW 1 •R •M7, L.r: Vl u. - ` 5 G WA t71 TKA- . I .�.t� C f R 1 :i1 f •. 1� 1 - �']]~ L{�`,,��7 _ ,J� ���� ! ,,r HARI 111E ifiii 4 i3 y �1I' '4n+n e�n1♦ a : C . < •a.-+a 1, 1S7' �'3t r ■IflL!E! '.� c - z C i 1'1 L! I ,,lf, MULL VI1 • .. � �) .I' COED i fJ `� . 0- I 1.1 F� . 1y I 3 y WtRM �I . SLO#,N ` BEACw 'I MB a corm . .,.1T,�j,, ,,, ,!� U a 1 Loh, '.� ''PCs C I 17. ACL I I er .�..—..., rl, f'L �- Y9 Q ,.c.. -Q ' IfpF�� Ji 3 Q il — • „ ' J _. 41 tdi��! _ `4 "�41 >,1--?- 5..30 AC y 1 01 _ i 1_,I i 2.1:r.11 /(-OW c � LZ f......,51:4 �9 1 'L •,ba. y i ()J 3 I I .55.6 ., .'8.1_ 39AC '1-AC'A 1 t I [r ' �Sbr z0' `T i: Nl Ac �,, (_ - `•2F ` (I) 2 , ,I.a I 1 _i.i,. A ll ' 17.1 �f r_ - , nt9�56 6 1 •� (, 1SK uontu1 ia. 12-!27-(j2 Ce .IS!.I , { •al4 ITI •1 z -e. II ,� �ff• II., 1J [ ,3(,)—1,3,7'.— 'I Imo^ I:`i'•- 1 AT F----41-1- ] 1 l , Syi'i —.•a F[*r—��T-'=�_;_ .r 1::waA'I _ _ err Ow r_"�: • ' _I war = f�- .1 «<-`f —l)�Iz Z _3.°°"° C� S-1 _h: • - : '' - - — 144 -- — Tim i,I iT- � , CJ ( I 11. .y 1. 1 za „1 I !7R !Jo — _ r , � tq� q SEAGATE MAivC:P C^NO - F t PB3P2 NW J7 P/PdFAPPLE GROVE VILLAGE COND(2006) NW H3 PORTA AL MARE(2006)PB101P' •-46-21-01 SW J8 ROYAL ATLANTIC PLAT(20061 P8107P10 NW.4116,i"ii-i0l.141.111ii" "^'•'^'" ti ,. ` ,,_ �.. i�''` C•-ba !•t . G .'t:F: N .i ` A� - �-..ems r t•'• ••J t _ -raw a.. .. ;4'r �.-•• t` •• "fir-*...."' ,`.,,,, � 4-._L.•' .. ,..%.s•r e .,.,.. r t� � � ���{-'���`C��};r#�'�.,�i!''moo'.#' f,•iA ° lr� � 3_1 f• ••-•••••••N...t-t., ....h... ...:Iti, .:44. • ...zy4„ 1.4•••.,. 160 Marine Way Delray Beach t ARCHITECT unknown , 872= _ BUILDER unknown 874= _ STYLE AND/OR PERIOD • _ (IA;�: Ui ¶ ,c4J'+,o ) 964= = PLAN TYPE Irregular 966= _ EXTERIOR FABRIC(S) Stucco 854= = STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S) Wood frame 856= = PORCHES 942= = FOUNDATION: concrete 942= = ROOF TYPE: cab1P 942= _ SECONDARY ROOF STRUCTURE(S): 942= = CHIMNEY LOCATION: • North elevation 942= = WINDOW TYPE: 942= = CHIMNEY: . Yes 882= _ ROOF SURFACING: shingle 882= = ORNAMENT EXTERIOR: 882= = NO. OF CHIMNEYS one 952= = NO.OF STORIES 1 950= = NO.OF DORMERS 954= = Map Reference(incl. scale &date) Delray Beach Topographic 1:24,000 • 1962, 1983 809= = Latitude and Longitude: o „ o „ 800= = Site Size(Approx.Acreage of Property): LT 1 833= = LOCATION SKETCH OR MAP N Township Range Section south east • E. ATlantic Ave. 47 43 16 812= = UTM Coordinates: 890= _ Zone Eashng Northing S.E. First St co cd .3 coV v 4 E f~ . ro 160 w S. E.. 2nd St. Photographic Records Numbers 860= = Contact Print STATE F FLORIDA O DEPARTMENT OF STATE FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE • Division of Archives.History . Site InventoryForm FDAHRM = and Records Management 802= DS-HSP-3AAA Rev.3.79 1009= _ Site No. Site Name 830= = Survey Date 860i 820= = Address of Site: 160 I ri ne Way, Delray Beach 33444 905= = Instruction for locating 813= = Location: Linton 126 13,14,15 868= = subdivision name block no. lot no. County: PALM BEACH 808= = Owner of Site: Name: Hackle, Faith n ; Address: 160 Marine Way,. _Delray Beach, Fl 33444 902= = Type of Ownership Private 848= = Recording Date 5-1-8b 832= = Recorder: Smith, Sanford I. Name & Title: Address: HPRr.PR 818= = Condition of Site: Integrity of Site: Original Use Residence 838= = Check One Check One or More Present Use Residence 850= = Excellent 863= = ❑ Altered 858== Dates: Beginning 1940 844= = SI Good 863== I Unaltered 858= = Culture/Phase 840= = . • ❑ Fair 863= = el Original Site 858== Period 845= = ❑ Deteriorated 863= = ❑ Restored( )(Date: X )858= = ❑ Moved( )(Date: X )858== NR Classification Category: Building 916= = Threats to Site: Check One or More P Zoning( )( X )878= = ❑ Transportation( X X )878== I Development( )( )( )878= = ❑ Fill( X . X )878== ❑ Deterioration( )( X )878= _ ❑ Dredge( X X )878== ❑ Borrowing( X X )878= = ❑ Other(See Remarks Below): 878== Areas of Significance: Architecture - 910= = Significance: • . , 911 = = /7 Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM si `� FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Field Date II 4 ❑,Original i , Form Date / / - Version 4.0 1/07 ❑Update '` 1111T�: Recorder# - / Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none) 1 (r(-? Fl C rZ to iA.;prr Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) r building 0 structure\e2raistrict 0 site 0 object Ownership:Oprivate-profit ❑private-nonprofit !private-individual Oprivate-nonspecific ❑city Ocounty Ostate Ofederal ❑Native American Oforeign ❑unknown _ ;'..i.::::: ::::.-...,:-;?". :j:: LQ ATIOK&MAPPING - .__ Address(include,N s E w#;St Ave etc.) 7 � /� >'GL A,-(V L;{1C�t Cross Streets(nearest/between) S.6 14, 9,1-. _ USGS7.5'Map Name&Date��(,4.1 4'�t�o�( erMap � r'1 � R:(� c•� c I j'j( 1 4 City/Town(within 3 miles) i tese y lase D C In City Limits? yes Ono ❑unknown County J ,w 7At,G c. Township yr Range e 5 Section / '/4 section: ❑NW ❑SW ❑SE ONE ❑Irregular-name: Tax Parcel # /'J� II-5 1 & Di 12r. 01 0 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block d _C Lot UTM: Zone 016 017 Easting .— D Nlthing 0 Other Coordinates: X: < Y: — Coordinate System&Datum 1_ Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) (-------- ORX ; Construction Year: /7 Y 12 proximately ❑year listed or earlier ❑year listed or later Original Use* f-gias49 iviq lr.- tlite.;1 From(year): To(year): v Current Use* f ) S f 'From(year): To(year): Other Use* r'kir2..e...- From(year): To(year): Moves:VAlte ations ,❑yes Ono ❑unknown Dates Nature Original address(if mo S yeti) Additions ` es Ono ❑unknown .,• -44- en,,,),..,-- toed,r • q cik7Fod Dates - -Z----)r? Nature*_ e�jstI r.112 ,..d.- Architect(last name first): >� • (- it,�SUY1 Buildeer'-(t name first): /2. i,' - -1-1 1-)�''>'� Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) {�!'j_ rr-,r(`,2af A. . 1..)s^;/7 ....a,"--Is the Resource Affected_by a Local Preservation Ordinance ,yes Ono qunknown _Describe G(lruQ -�, +-c "\:z.ci . 'l,sy DESCRIPTION ` raj •-�7 Style+ 1G • V VIG l� Exterior Plan,; L rYsg-=�- Numberof`Stories I , 2... Exterior Fabric(s) ` -I,t C 0, Roof Types)-* Roof Materials) l lTi Roof secondary s cs.(dorm rs etc.)* r Windows(types,materials,etc.)* 7 - t; a it ati Distinguishing Architectural Fe. ures(exterior or interior ornaments) -ICEI�t m.as,.���,�,`—__ --��` i. r►--IP. C r.. 1. , . ►�.:�- L _' 0 y'c�,(++ • S C.t-7� Q ",061-- ' 2t 1 i t t t��Lv.41 ,!/! I Sfled Ancillary Feattfres/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation heet if needed.) (i GzebOi • ,&0 - 'p a PA4'. cA d d zctl 1'1 1 ? 2 *Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). RAM. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO-Appears to meet criteria for NR listing:Oyes Ono ❑insufficient info Date I_I Init. _/_l KEEPER-Determined eligible: Oyes Ono Date_/_/ O Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: ❑a; Ob ❑c `Cld` (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources I R.A.Gray Bu ilding 1500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399.0250 Phone(850)245.6440 I Fax(850)245.6439I E-mai SiteFile@dos.state.fLus • Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 -:r�.,.-�- �e�, �x ..•�< � a. z ��fiylj�� ._.. ■r" ��rA��.y�.-�`�i`�er].a�"�€��z �'-.r� 1 £<x�a:-��„REF .�� �a - �t-'��' Chimney:No. ( Material(s)• ( ( t1 Structural System(s). C> c`-% •-_�" Foundation: Types)•• ' %� Material(s)• -t': .•. Main Entrance(stylistic details) Q Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roo types,etc.) L.Lu► t L�: �f c� �? t pek '1 Condition(overall resource condition): excellent Ogood Ofair ❑deteriorated ❑ruinous Narrative Description of Resource Sec ( es4/./ Archaeological Remains 0 Check if Archaeological Form Completed *Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). RESEARCH'METHODS,"Kieck a'ilhat a FMSF record search(sites/surveys) Jalibrary research ti b' iiidtng permits vEr8inbom maps ❑FL State Archives/photo collection , 0 city directory \. occupant/owner interview . D plat maps ye-Property appraiser/tax records ,,O-newspaper files neighbor interview 0 Public Lands Survey(DEP) ,..-Ercultural resource survey -,,,9-historic photos yt7interior inspection ❑HABS/HAER record search ❑other methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) D� �C 2 CL' 9 } DPINION-OPI ESOURGE`SIGNIFICANCE,._ ". , Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? es ono Dinsufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district?) Oyes ono ❑insufficient information Explanation of Evaluation(re uired,whethe significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) �► tticf ! ' tCC C� tie �C G Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic eritage"," mmunity planning&de lopmenr,etc.)• DOCUMENTATION °F Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field&analysis notes,photos,plans,other important documents that are permanently accessible: For each separately maintained collection,describe(1)document type(s),*(2)maintaining organization,*(3)file or accession nos.,and(4)descriptive info ation. (L,4 r}, ece-Ld S 7 ) i f'P41 7,Cci 3 ) Kf s RECORDER INFORMATION /,1 Recorder Name r / ,' CoS/2 Yf Gl/l r tca e Cc. u,C / Recorder Contact Information(address 1,f.ne/fax l e-mail) --/-( c J( : . : _ _alr A ! Recorder Affiliation •• ( Yf,r Use a Supplement for Site Forms or other continuation sheet for descriptions that do not fit in the spaces provided. OUSGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required q © LARGE SCALE STREET;"PLAT OR PARCEL"MAP (available from mostpropenyappraserwebsites), Attachments 0 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image fle;it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy.format(plan paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. STATE FLORIDA DEPARTM°ENTOFSTATE FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE - Division ol Archives,History • Site Inventory Form FDAHRM and Records Management 802= = DS•HSP•3AAA Rev.3.79 • 1009= = Site No. Site Name 830= = Survey Date 8604 820= = Address of Site: 160 ',Prine Way, Delray Beach 33444 905= = Instruction for locating 813= = Location: Linton 126 13*14,15 868= = • •, subdivision name block no. lot no. County: PALM BEACH 808= = Owner of Site: Name: Hackle, Faith D-- Address: 160 Marine Way, Delray Beach, Fl 3340-4 } 902= = Type of Ownership Private 848= = Recording Date 5-1'8 b 832= = Recorder: Smith, Sanford I. Name & Title: Address: TliDRr:PR ' 818= Condition of Site: Integrity of Site: Original Use residence 838= = Check one Check One or More Present Use Residence 850= = ❑ Excellent 863== I® Altered 8 == Dates: Beginning 1940 844= = S Good 863== Unaltered 858= = Culture/Phase 840= = • ❑ Fair 863= = lie Original Site 858== Period • 845= = ❑ Deteriorated 863== 0 Restored( )(Date: x )858= = 0 Moved( )(Date: x )858== NR Classification Category: Building 916= = Threats to Site: Check One or More A Zoning( )( )( )878== 0 Transportation( x x )878= = III Development( x )( )878== ❑ FIII( x A )( )878= = 0 Deterioration( )( x )878== 0 Dredge( x x )878= = ❑ Borrowing( x x )878== ❑ Other(See Remarks Below): 878== Areas of Significance: Architecture • 910= = Significance: .. • 911 = = t Y _ ARCHITECT unknown •--- i--tt - H 872= = BUILDER unknown ' C 1--4; :: S y, 874= = • STYLE AND/OR PERIOD _ /14:,;wvut T v-ti '+...,1 964= = PLAN TYPE Irregular 966= = EXTERIOR FABRIC(S) Stucco 854= = STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S) Wood frame 856= = PORCHES • 942= = FOUNDATION: concrete 942= = ROOF TYPE: Gable 942= = SECONDARY ROOF STRUCTURE(S): 942= = CHIMNEY LOCATION: • North elevation 942= = WINDOW TYPE: 942= = CHIMNEY: . Yes 882= = ROOF SURFACING: -e .-h n 882= = ORNAMENT EXTERIOR: 882= = NO.OF CHIMNEYS one 952= = NO.OF STORIES 1 950= = • NO.OF DORMERS 954= = Map Reference(incl. scale &date) Delray Beach Topographic 1:24,000 • 1962, 1983 809= = • Latitude and Longitude: 800= = Site Size(Approx. Acreage of Property): LT 1 833= = LOCATION SKETCH OR MAP N Township Range Section • south east E. ATlantic Ave. 47 43 16 812= = UTM Coordinates: 890= = Zone Easting Northing a; S.E. First St ra /3 •3 CT 160 cts S. E., 2nd St. Photographic Records Numbers 860= = Contact Print T((l roof-- -r- 'a di;11-•ci. 4 �-i vi .g „ _ r r E Yt9iL4-doo-c ' act#i.T It fib ' , Y S'� et-L-4 i . r'( S' T i i 5 G l.L' - lo IV2^K.r. fr-e.t i i.5 l t`- E 1 U( Cut liZ✓ev<L;ri•,•,_ i.,'.), 14 iu - �� t-ki-�C>'L i l%a2 At- S 7 do . I'}— i-s v L 0� c� et:. r G L- 1 a-d - '( - l - ; �c� (,,�-4,_ Pia- s 1—c=atil `'t_.0-i is to-tt e-tv _c( i e z-;t2±1 L AGENDA ITEM 5 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING DECEMBER 2, 1992 COA 8-198 160 MARINE WAY STEPHEN AND CLAUDIA ECHOLS, OWNERS ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is that of granting a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow the construction of a decorative wood trellis to be constructed across the front porch and along the north side of the driveway. Replace existing front door with French door and sidelights. ANALYSIS This is a contributing house and guest house in the Marina Historic District The applicant is proposing an interesting and appropriate treatment for the property. The trellis across the front porch will enhance the north/south wing of the house without obscuring the front windows and door. It will also provide architectural detailing and trim which is currently lacking from the transitional colonial cottage facade. The driveway trellis visually enlarges and balances the house; the arched walkway entrance which leads to the rear of the property is typical of colonial revival garden architecture. The trellis will be constructed of wood and will be painted white. The French door is appropriate to the facade. POSSIBLE ACTION Deny with reasons stated. Approve with modification. Approve as presented. RECOMMENDED ACTION Approve as presented. 5 . COA 8-198 : Marina Historic District; 160 Marine Way; Stephen & Claudia Echols, Owners . The Board approved the applicant 's request for COA 8-198 to construct a decorative wood trellis across the front porch and along the north side of the driveway. The trellis will be constructed of wood and will be painted white. The applicant will also replace the existing front door with a French door and sidelights. Pat Healy-Golembe moved for Approval of COA 8-198, seconded by Sandy Jamison. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes; Margie Miller - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Said motion passed 7-0. 7 . REPORTS FROM HISTORIC DISTRICTS: None. 8. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: Mrs . Cayce informed the Board the the OSSHAD meeting has been postponed to January 11, 1993. 9 . NEW BUSINESS: Mrs . Miller informed the Board that the old Ocean City Hardware Building will be reopened by Easter as Holidays on the Avenue. 10 . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: November 18, 1992 Meeting The Board approved the minutes for the November 18, 1992 meeting with the following condition: * On Page 3, 1st paragraph; the date for the Sundy Feed Store Bar B.Q. be changed from April 4, 1993 to April 24, 1993 . Pat Healy-Golembe moved for approval of the minutes for the November 18, 1992 meeting, seconded by Buck Miller. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes; Margie Miller - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes . Said motion passed 7-0. - 4 - 12/2/92 Historic Preservation Board Agenda May 18, 1994 Page 2 D. COA S-048, 701 N.E. 3rd Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, Lisel Rudderman, Owner. Re-roof from cement tile to fiber glass shingle. E. COA 8-224, 354 N.E. 1st Avenue, Contributing residence Old School Square Historic District, Susan Cross, Owner. Construction of an attached garage, handicapped access rear of the ro ert . F. COA 8-225, 160 Marine Way, contributing residence, Marina Historic District. Claudia & Stephen Echols, Owner, Francisco Perez, Architect Agent. Second story addition to the existing residence. G. COA 8-226, Lot 13, a vacant lot adjacent to the north property line of 160 Marine Way, Marina Historic District. Claudia & Stephen Echols, Owner, Francisco Perez, Architect agent. New construction of a single family residence. H. COA 8-227 Lot 19, a vacant lot adjacent to the west property line of 102 N.E. 8th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District. Mr and Mrs William Stone, Owners . 'on of a single family home. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTIONS ITEMS None VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VII . ADJOURN POSTED ON : May 12, 1994 Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner ' ' "' ' • .1•. • • .' . -• • ••1• .••• '‘...i. .'• •; • ...z." ii• •' .. .-•:"..1`.' •: ' . 4,-'• ...."... 1, • .- -1 *.:Ai .,-- ...,•..•• ...j N. r •'‘'.4'. '1'.....‘ -•••:. ''' •.' 1".•' •.. ^if . •,•••• • 1 /: , • • • ' .... • •.,* .3...4.t' 1:'‘ 're.• Z:.4;',1 fi. -,...? , • ;_. , . .1: • • --..... r41.J.-.0e14‘ ' . ,,Z... ' '.• ',..,-',,...r ..•••:*4.• ., ''' ••• e 1. '.' ...0. ' ;. ...-• ''. •••• ., . , •• %..3,-ta;11.- ••. - -- •-•:'''....- •-••• : .- .• ; .1 .. .••••.' • .• •-,,,-.--.•••--A - ; '' 1.'4. •P • .-. : ' • " ''''' - • ' • • • t , • a . I: • . — . .., '( • . 1,Y. • . .i• I /•..2--• ••••••••• -,-= - •.' . . •.-.,- .•-•- • .-...... Soi•g"-3•VP1.11%---•••• .- ' -. ,...,:,.. ,.. ,.. : ..,.:-•-• --"ONIM14-Ptigkg•..7"-A...t. •:•;•?"-%. • .'. ,..-;."•'.--,..,.. -, -.4•14)viirtt:•‘:..--1 :- - -I' • . __ -- - ... • • -- . -,-:slk;•,,:.-:,,,,- -.::::,..N., r --,-.-• ••- ., •• •-• I:-. "'-.,?;..... '''.-- •• ' r. .:'-- - — - ..,. • . s• • •::-• • ...--.--, : -. - • " -- ' ..... -- - .... . . _ . _ - -- • 'it...:...::':,•':!...* .16,ii:t.- ,.., i. ' alb lir I 1 4- ' 1:ft' - •• „•,fc,-- 4. il -T..,, -ellt..., • 41:•• . •••••• . :., . ":. • " •-..e s- , • - • •C.. ...ALI ,, , .1 ....,,, .•-,•:.• • - 7.- . . •- .•. ^•,-.-if...."..,1.,-.1•4 -„ . • t:-.•.. • . '..- • - ',.. .• ', -'• -'•.::-j--.7. , ' ;' :•• •• . , . '''.- -.r. ' ' '5 ' ''.V..310PV1,-.1,..-Z4•VtZ;- -e--.._,-.-.., ,t-:'-'=.- ': -01°- :.-, , ....- ..:-•l - e',- „-..•rv".•-.:,,a,-;k•'/'''• -a:-_•'4.44c..r*:?-._.- 4-:-'''• -N ',,. • - ..-‘7.3•' ' . .r ' - , -•. •,....—.:, "-•-•-....--: c. . •"" ' .-‘,..! - • • — --• - :7-•;•;„..? '0% • ''':' ".?. .'' - •• " ..."."- -t.• ' . . - •_,.,_. . - _ .. ..r,,;•- ' !"-x-'--•••.;.." -- - •--..- - -en.".,..,`•V....f.-.-..'•-4. k•--4. c• ' -•'.,..:-..•?.;4.•' .. - '7"-;',"....; 4: ,.,_.. ' .., '-" ""•••.••:-...:.:.-.;.:::,'-- -' . . .. -45.."';';CIX‘. Z;C•t•"--- ;`-'..-1. -- •--"...F."''''''"".- . -•"--;•.'.-;:.:A.;,*:-.,•`..-:-.:._."":"•••;••-7.. ---••-i'..,f•,?.::,,,o-h.!,:,'-...:.0,',:i:..ta,r.b.'-','Y ,.14.4. i. ...•-•`.... ' '..... - .1".11,111""R ..---'•4-4:s '•-•.; IR,'.11.-1-'3,-!•(•;-=•Jr:-•''''''' - -.eri.`7••4•11,,11-.7;:.- ' •-:-...' •.:1."'-,:;-:;:7••:'..t.. z.....:"...-z-..... .a.-."-•••••••-•1••- '- ' . ' • wr. . ' st. ''' '•v• ".' id. .. . . •.• - ,.--ir • .t.• • .. ..ti...‘ ,.. ..__.....-;• ti l'el I•I'.:.„,., -7- • .. 2 . -:p4 i• .,., ,r ...-:.11:--- ....- •:- --..,-•.‘:. ., it ...,--. L., .. ••• 4 -., .,-;-."•-•• . "A. "t . V 44.-." '1 11" r ..., .. .. r7..-." 1 .... •••• -- n:---. ,_ . I ...S. 'S., '•...1 1 .:::: -..`---... L • ; '1 ••• -',.'. 1,atr .... .ill,••• ti• •...,-; , - -:--ii .. --- -',. . _--. •:',.z, -:, ‘,..„. .--.. -t-'--4.,---f: -..•....ti---. ?":"...-'-'"_-4'••. -''.."_ '.6 .,-;'..... ••,, - 4,;•_. .. -''••"._ •-.• ''''°:•••••,"'; ... '•', ' ''a• • '. :': ; . _ • . . ;IA'"... . . ''. .- . 'i ' . ..01, ' •• 0 • - . • r,.. 41 --.:. • . „•,. . .,•,. - , . ..-•:-.. ... i - , ._ •.. _:,: _.- .. t . •-• • - - 4 = 4 -.1.••••.:4*-;It .i -.----•7.1- '.. ',:..7r,.,,.f:: '7104 4,...,1 ii.:41.,.... -; a ,, ,..-.7,-•• r..., : .- , .el,,, . .---.•ffra-gmur,fa. •t • 'AiirilPt*Paita• —* . . i--,..;r7 ,- ..,-..;•••,'''' .`.--s'S.-;.....st.n,.....•-....4144-...c Ayorti11,i •- • .. .„, ••••• •-•• .... Itog.er",' ,<-.4-.......nz,•- •.., •_.s•,,,y.,• 4,- . .-.z,....-,-.,4:14;4S-'''- "•,i.$A''4 ' g.,- , . - ._....,fakt:',..•. .Sz,IT'•`.•.,•t-;,., tr..: . ... . ---_• ....- -`11‘V'''•J'-•• "'--•t • . -,,... ,...., , c•,,. -,. t ,,,i..,,...; -05 1 • . . , , • ::- li 0 . ? 44 /.'4 e*;?6A.;0.'14 ' --- . ' a:4 •' -"."` .)....C..)1,,1•52 -- Nar, :t;" - -!: r g_..kaaA 3;:•_ STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING MAY 18, 1994 AGENDA ITEM IV-F COA 8-225 160 Marine Way, contributing residence Marina Historic District Claudia & Stephen Echols, Owner, or Francisco Perez, Architect Agent. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of granting approval for COA 8-225 to allow construction of a second story addition to the existing residence. ANALYSIS This is an appropriate and attractive addition to a very small contributing single family residence. The existing free - standing guest house to the rear of the principal residence will remain and will be connected to the to the main house by the second floor addition. The front gable of the second floor addition repeats the original first floor gable and the trellis pavilion on the roof is set back 32 ' from the front facade of the original house. Elevations, floor plans and finishing schedule are attached and fully explain the proposed addition. The Chief Building Official has reviewed the plans and has approved the second floor addition to the nonconforming setback of the south wall as it does not add to the footprint of the nonconformity. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1. Appro COA 8-225 by making positive findings to Section 4 . (E) . 2 . Deny COA 8-225 by failing to make positive findings to Section 4 .5. 1(E) with reasons stated. RECOMMENDED ACTION 1 . Approve COA 8-225 by making positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(E) . DATE: May 10, 1994 TO: Patricia Cayce Historic Preservation Planner City of Delray Beach 100 N.W. 1st Avenue Delray Beach, Florida FROM: Francisco E. Perez-Azua API Group INC. Architecture 111 East Palmetto Park Road Boca Raton, Florida 33432 Finish Schedule for Echols House: Walls White stucco finish to match existing construction. • Windows Vinyl clad wood windows, fixed, double-hung, and awning. Windows on the front elevation will most likely be double-hung to match existing construction. Side and rear window may be a combination of the types mentioned, designed so as to maintain the overall historic character of the existing house. Doors Wood french doors, painted white, to match existing construction. Glass Clear, to match existing construction. • Shutters Wood, operable, painted yellow to match existing construction. Trellis/trims Wood, painted white, to match existing trellis. Roof Standing seam metal roof, light grey Stairs/railings Wood, painted white. • • •. If. •. ` •.. ' S-!' ` ` l _-.a, ICI. '_ j rll. _i_ ' l • 4. 2 . 2 • - �.—. — S . - • `ems .l• R • �+ r .► �♦ • • ♦ 'ink-.n•% •t:'� ar �.;' • � % . III.4111111111111‘ - ' ".7--.„—••-• . 0 1:, 144-.A.g.x.--,. .„., • • $��. + - •. -.y....:041S.*4-"....ti__••••••• fic;...•.- '''...-•+..++s'1ti -..�za.w.....• +r... /.o.p�i .SG . - " ' - - y a�1 Mom• N-....q.Y __ -- — ...♦' - ——I----.. .fir •.'. _ _ _ .•k_ .rr_ STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING MAY 18, 1994 AGENDA ITEM IV-G COA 8-226 Lot 13, a vacant lot adjacent to the north property line of 160 Marine Way, Marina Historic District. Claudia & Stephen Echols, Owner, Francisco Perez, Architect agent. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for COA . - 8-226 to allow new construction of a single family residence. BACKGROUND • This residence is proposed- for Lot 13 which is a vacant lot to the north of the Echols residence, 160 Marine Way. The lot is 50 ' x 143 ' with a total of 7, 150 s. f. It is located in the RM zoning district which requires a minimum lot size of 8,000 s . f. • The lot is currently a lot of record which means that it was platted before these development requirements were adopted and is therefor a buildable lot. However, new construction can not occur on lots of record which are adjacent and are under common ownership until the text amendment to Section 4 . 1.4, which is described in the attached. memorandum, is approved or denied. If the amendment is approved this lot will require a variance from Section 4 .3.4 (K) Development Standards, with respect to minimum lot size before building permits can be issued. ANALYSIS This is an appropriate design for the Marina Historic District. It is consistent with the criteria for new construction. The attached elevations, floor plans and finishing schedule fully explain the development. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1 . • •prov- COA 8-226 based on positive findings to %ec : on 4 .5. 1(E) with the following condition: If a variance from Section 4 .3.4 (K) is required it must be approved by the Historic Preservation Board before building permits are issued. 2 . Deny COA 8-226 based on a failure to make positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(E) with the reasons stated. RECOMMENDED ACTION 1 . Approve COA 8-226 based on positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(E) with the following condition: If a variance from Section 4 . 3 .4 (K) is required it must be approved by the Historic Preservation Board before building permits are issued. DATE: May 10, 1994 TO: Patricia Cayce Historic Preservation Planner City. of Delray Beach 100 N.W. 1st Avenue Delray Beach, Florida FROM: Francisco E. Perez-Aztia API Group INC. Architecture 111 East Palmetto Park Road Boca Raton, Florida 33432 Finish Schedule for house on Lot 13 Marine Way: • Walls White stucco finish. Windows Vinyl clad wood windows, casement, fixed, double-hung, and/or awning. Combination of window types will be designed so as to match and maintain the overall historic character of the existing house on lot 14 Marine way. Doors Wood french doors, painted white. Glass Clear. Shutters Wood, operable. Color to be selected by owner. Trellis/trims Wood, painted white. Roof Standing seam metal roof, light grey Driveway Gravel, to match existing driveway on lot 14 Marine way. Colors may vary as per owner request. Any changes will be presented to the board at the meeting on May 18. \ %? Forrvo . - r •l�Gt/ -- t:r'r✓_^ #_at57 Z. lovrrF,1c/ 1 f 1 ,co!/ND of K/Acc ft tvL' allb ..44. o.v r/All to/Ucro11 it .w,vr/.rcvr �;s. i11 9" • / a .` �, i Q to —. n. .- _—— . . ._—. —__-— • i ^ $ r I I Q ` b �- 1�- 4 d:c:P :v? so r' eaoeEv co KrrlP 0 z r� i� '\ \ .. - ! to W, v IQ O :� 4'L/. .. 1s S' i 13.5' 1.t". .. «11./ �` OA 9' It I�--° I*11' ( 11 % '` t tti tV 1 IL vl ( 1ti \! ck 1)), • V I `\ • c/A✓ei re. I 0 >: MO,VV F, r 'k _ �: O a k. �Er /413 W' �1 s/i'1 eifi o ' .rraei.er ?we i Illimumi l'CB 353 "me& • /lt at✓Es )PI . ., . AV rs•vi r/.vs Z , E 2 ST - 4 • ..„. ru. /0e-sC'.4'„A0,r-Div/ LOTt /3, /•1 A,t v/5-, A 5 80/✓/t/D.t/ Al,. y Al f 5Tc P,f/E.1/,Q. 6-evo/S OF 64 'c t'/Z., Oe't.47,4 740,e/04, 4 ernv,'O/A/G /"a{�T.+'£ {PZ47-T//t:Qcv`F KCLQ�/KOL,,O// //�'ZIT // ��u� I IltatS• :fat Ft t^•t th• plat aho..n h•r•on I. • tru• •na at,.act O,'TiVe ,"C/i3 /C ge-e' ,0s 0,-P,9L,cf r.h,•a•-:•: on of „r.•T al th• I docr10•4 h•r•on•a:. In •trord•^c• •+tn v• •Inl•..n t•alln[cal •t and•rda for lena a ...rtnp .9 'I C'// ('d ''V FCO,<'/OA. In th• ::•.• .f . . .a. a. .a: ,o.th or ✓:•ct•r 211aa•t F::- a• Ad•inl•:r• 'alld•.t,:.: •r (97://.1(77. "CD.4l. CO,IYC`= G/.l S"..i`%".<'4::" x�>Z e.a.5 =(•':cr. G• ;r r(yc:".'' T1 0,a a 2o/l/f: A6- a L 7 O'BRIEN, SUITER & O'BRIEN, INC. ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS, LAND PLANNERS 2601 WORTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY. DEIRAY BEACH. FLORIDA :);Ale A /992 «.ro.• �•�/a.24 )Ice. ev ••r•--P2-//` , ' 1.:1\ '. • ' ..: - . . i S. ...I .... I \ •". . I - •s : . I . • . - V e . Fou Z Av., __ x.4-—- — J"ii" 0,itmze etA. 0,4.,I ma' - . • ca/aerre ... I II, mwemiew,A- , 1.4 f r•••r ,,II 0 ••-: 1 ... '1 • • ••• 4t k . 4 t ...... •• t: ` s ta ‘:.• No. ,..i NI -'''-' •-.-.- ...11--..--.....___ .-_____ . ...`. ... . . --._.... _ A' .19 c Ar, ,•; E. - ...•,40.••Aor-----,',:- , .-•-y•-___._---- -r--- • li '7ii I 4, e. .1( A I/ Iii Ill 17.4x ' I rt:.-•-n<.:1 g 6' '• " . . 1\ .13 tS ./...fre:i 5,004..-,/ ,..... ii"..ffeif" 16...J• I alr•• ,_ '... ''''.f•i- --..D. i LI A t s. N Ate 12 . .% • L. ••••,.... -.-....... ., It••,'Ve••C .-, 1; • 1 N 1 i 0, . K to.5• .., ,I... ••. .• •' r V ..... i.7 a.•• •.. .ts h t ....."\\.% e I: .... -,- ii•9' 14 5 , 73 5' 19/' .... 37.9• ,.. tr..-g... _______A____L; . , II,' 4 ---.- ____ I I . .1_,,.....i \ - A 1 . . c.\ , 4.1 . '-T 4t.1 ‘1‘ .4 . ... 1 . .- kt 4 s‘ L . •-• 1 Nt t % I:is ',.. " 1., kl"...N • kh TA ,-,•,..% , ..„, „„.. ',... •- Ni • "1. ;.,.. N \I t •,.._,‘ ,.s.kq i , k° t,,% ...„ -c .\' \ 1 t4 _ ,z1 ‘ ":,,, i , .,.-. - -- .1• • . - tit -1, • . raigia i. u .l .9. s- ..1›. NI C/A/CAW I. AI CI . -Z,-- AtaAVA/C.4,T IP 'k ... . . • .o,e-A" . - .4,eciA:w /-1.. i 1, ° "de...,47— -f-•••/.4-0A4 o v r.e.0 z._-- '-----"'zA,(''------,c3 57....---. z...--r... .),•, ,,i.e.s °17"‘r.1"." ____ rd ..,... .*e le - te t... e, -2- /ea • \ , , Ot-s e/2/"7",v/t/: egOthf/a4 XV 5 ,,e'VEY "0".. ear5 /3, /, /1/./a/5, ef 144 9 0/V/5/0,4/ rffie. 140.5. sreelhic(/ ee. EC'ev..5 elf- 41 cone/2' ,0 CZAIAre A-CO4'/al, • :,. lif CCO,Q a/4./G To rya-,01,11"7/ e1,‘" .., :- Re--020e-0 //./,,,Z,fr doox' f4 Afere-1 I Met Ile MI)Ire let•t lb. •Ist else.w 1.•reoe.. le • 1,..• and so rrrrr • °le/We./2e/e1/c. ,Q'erea,424:25 4.e-,•=7,1Z, f ..14 saantall.lyrs •f • rrrrrr •I lb, I and• d•ece 1••• horieton••••• 1F. et•f•rA•ne• ...1p, (1.•.Inlo.... 1••15•14,1 et•std•rde f eoe i•nd Due.0,4 degLe-fir ew edv,(//); ,,-eo/Qtarf. . In II• -t I f toe 1•• •• ••l r.,lk be Cl.efpt•r 111•1•11 'ivy Ids Sehlnleler•tle• Cod, -,. - tette Of e•Ine net •el Id ..111..rarr1/•rs riorrer rrrrr •••j. 417///1 '..., "'" P',4414V .e. i(r/6 :fAila "ecy./e."• 4VA/reere - . 41,412 .C .dMc-iVA"A/o. $9 2*z •coAle. Sr,t'A'.i.sr,:ero eir e- e-z 7 O'BRIEN, SUITER & O'BRIEN, INC. ENOIPfEERS, SURVEYORS, LAND PLANNERS 2601 Nonni FEIDERAL - -• , 241011WAY. oLnAr BEACH, FLORIDA - toi 11-13.1 1.1 .rA,CA 19:92 /fr.z,,,• 71,r '-'-.0 0 -"-- ___ Historic Preservation Board Agenda Meeting of March 15, 1995 Page 2 CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS CONTINUED C. COA 8-246 , 15 N.W. 1st - Avenue, Medical Office, New Construction, Old School Square Historic District . Michael Weiner, Authorized Agent. Approval for: Site Plan Design Elements Landscape Plan D. COA 8-243, 714 E. Atlantic Avenue, Northern Trust Bank, New Construction, Marina Historic District. Digby Bridges, Architect/Authorized Agent. Approval for: Site Plan Design Elements Landscape Plans V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Block 126 Lot 13 , ).-6154 Marine Way, Steven and Claudia Echols, Owners . Recommend to the City Commission that a waiver be granted from Section 4 . 1.4 (C) , Use of Lots of Record, • 4° t to allow construction of a single family residence on k\VO./1( Lot 13 . B. Recommend to the Planning and Zoning Board that the proposed ordinance pertaining to ad valorem tax exemptions for historic properties be approved. VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS : A. Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VI . ADJOURN POSTED ON: March 9 , 1995 Patricia Ca , Historic Preservation Planner .. 2 . Continue the decorative lighting on the north elevation along the east elevation excluding the covered parking area and provide lighting in the pedestrian arcade. Mr. Jamison returned to the Board. IV. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: A. Variance 88-36 : 15 N.W. 1st Street; Old School Square Historic District; Medical Office; Michael Weiner, Authorized Agent. It was moved by Mr. Jamison, seconded by Ms. Devitt and passed 7-0 to approve Variance 88-36 to LDR Section 4 . 3 .4(K) to reduce the front setback requirement from 25 ' to 15 ' based upon positive findings with respect .to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(J) ( 1) (a) (b) (c) (d) . V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Block 126, Lot 13; 1451O -Marine Way; Steve & Claudia Echols, Owners; Wavier to LDR Section 4 . 1.4 (C) to Allow a Single Family Residence to be Built on a Substandard Lot. .r v , d) It was moved by Mr. Jamison, seconded by Ms . Devitt k) �,t\ and passed 7-0 to recommend to the City Commission 6 6` based upon positive findings pursuant to LDR Section 2 .4 . 7 (B) (2) that a waiver be granted from LDR Section 4 . 1.4 (C) to allow a single family residence to be constructed on a substandard lot of record. B. Recommend to the Planning & Zoning Board that the Proposed Ordinance Pertaining to Ad Valorem Tax Exemptions for Historic Properties be Approved. It was moved by Mr. Vaughan, seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed 7-0 to recommend to the Planning and Zoning Board that the Tax Exemption Ordinance be adopted. VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None - 4 - 03/15/95 ` O. AGENDA = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING o4Y � P CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: August 18, 2004 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Randolph at 243-7127(voice), or 243-7199(TDD), 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES • July 21, 2004 III. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Saraga & Lipshy, 203 NE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Roger Cope, Authorized Agent. - Continued from August 4, 2004. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness and an associated Class Ill Site Plan Modification for the conversion of a single family home to office and an associated variance and waiver request. IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. Willis Residence, 160 Marine Way, Marina Historic District, Francisco Perez, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the enclosure of a loggia on a single family home. V. DISCUSSION &ACTION ITEMS A. Northwest Swinton Avenue (Lake Ida Park) Historic District Designation. Set a Public Hearing date for September 15, 2004 for consideration of a proposed historic district designation. B. Dell Park Historic District Designation. Set a Public Hearing date for September 15, 2004 for consideration of a proposed historic district designation. August 18,2004 HPB Meeting Page 2 VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments B. Reports from Historic District Representatives C. Board Members D. Staff VII. ADJOURN Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: August 13, 2004 Historic Preservation Board Minutes • August 18, 2004 4) That accessibility modifications are noted on the site plan and elevations, where applicable; and Motion amended by Ms. Sexton, seconded by Ms. Schatz, and approved 6 to 0 to move approval of the site plan modification to include the following: 5) That the pedestrian pathway between the front door and sidewalk be restored as indicated on the survey. Landscape Plan It was moved by Ms. Sexton, seconded by Ms. Schatz, and approved 6 to 0 to move approval of the request for the Landscape Plan approval for 203 NE 1st Avenue, Saraga & Lipshy Office, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Section 4.6.16 of the Land Development Regulations, subject to the following condition: 1) Address all Landscape Plan Technical Items and submit three (3) copies of the revised plans. Motion amended by Ms. Sexton, seconded by Ms. Schatz, and approved 6 to 0 to move approval of the landscape plan to include the following: 2) That the vertical elements at the front of the house are symmetrical to the front walkway. IV. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPORIATENESS A. Willis Residence, 160 Marine Way, Marina Historic District, Francisco Perez, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the enclosure of a loggia on a single- family home. Chairman Perez stepped down. Mr. Tefft presented the items to the Board and entered a copy of the project file into the record. The property consists of Lot 14, Block 126, and is located on the west side of Marine Way. The property is zoned Medium Density Residential and includes a 2,510 sq. ft. contributing dwelling constructed in 1940 (including a 1,795 sq. ft. second story addition constructed in 1955 which utilized the existing guest cottage). The dwelling is considered contributing within the Marina Historic District. The applicant is now before the Board for the enclosure of the existing 186 sq. ft. loggia on the contemporary portion of the dwelling. The applicant is proposing the enclosure of the 188 sq. ft. loggia located on the first floor of the dwelling between the living area and the previous guest cottage (presently a garage). The enclosure consists of the installation of two paired divided light French doors with stucco relief arches above. 6 Historic Preservation Board Minutes August 18, 2004 Decorative wood knee braces support proposed wood trellises that extend three (3) feet beyond the footprint of the building into the side setbacks. Existing wood supports are to be removed. Staff is recommending approval subject to the condition that an updated survey depicting existing site conditions is provided prior to issuance of building permit. Francisco Perez, Architect, for the project, inquired if the present survey could be used as it was done after the construction. Ms. Shay advised that Mr. Phil Etchison, Chief Building Inspector, is requiring a current survey as the property is under different ownership. Mr. Perez inquired If the motion could read "to provide the survey if required by staff and the Building Department". Ms. Shay advised they could contact the Building Department. However, as this is a very old survey and it does not show all the improvements that were done some time ago. I have spoken to the Building Department on several occasions and they are requiring an updated survey. Ms. Schatz advised the cost of a new survey is approximately $250.00. Vice Chairman Silberstein asked if there was any one from the public who wished to address the Board. There were none. Vice Chairman Silberstein asked if the Board had any comments. There were none. It was moved by Mr. Miller, seconded by Ms. Schatz, and passed 5 to 0 to move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness for the enclosure of the 188 sq. ft. loggia at 160 Marine Way, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Sections 4.3.4(H)(4)(I), and 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(g) of the LDRs and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, subject to the following condition: 1) That an updated survey depicting the existing site conditions is provided, prior to issuance of a building permit if so deemed necessary by the Building Department, City of Delray Beach. Chairman Perez returned to the Board. V. DISCUSSION ITEMS AND ACTION ITEMS A. Northwest Swinton Avenue Historic District Designation. Item Before the Board: Review the Designation for the Northwest Swinton Avenue Historic District and set a date for the Public Hearing. 7 r V :` .--�:.;. - .. '�. 'mil_ 1 . . ".. . r 1V.• • zl i� i t. R'ifil1 7v 1 t x� tir; • 2y04 •Zii. {"r•.d , „y h} , ,_ a attf {:�n yf� �.�ar- >✓r�'�•i1 K�•,(�,;{;a� 4., � ` j • j?$:.Via'^ ' .% i �1 c�L , � �' Q �Y•,s • • rV.n :K rr c� 160 Marine Way Delray Beach r • 4iiire - ' '1/4.44 it e ir:r.r �... t 1 gy�pp,,,, 10 lF e 111 / ...11 N �, .(fa ric.i ' -- , .. -- a �... f 1~ems ,i.� .1 _ oy •• .1 . Et. '; -:�. _ _ . .veer•.4e04a 1^•(....ra0;r IN PAN Iuvv. vileutiuri o'-, f .,,,,s• i v.v. DISTRICT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA ?•• J ,‘./ SUBDIVISION BLOCK ILOT Improved OWNER r,�—.. ' $ Vacant 126 ' / '.) 14 j is! Exempt OWNER Faith D. Hack]. DESCRIPTION: ' /6 ADDRESS 251 Bayard Lane, Princeton, N.J. I Y i�SftRiti, 1 NO J„ OWNER 'k"'1" ADDRESS YEAR— 1949 1ft1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 EXEMPTION • 7 / y / / /f LAND I ✓. S...r. �^.( a - /7' 'j— J` ^ s'I / Y /�� / '�"'! r'd / 75 / 1.r'7 '/ 4b 4226U ^{/4 o. il+ 31 BLDGS. I' .'i D h...c 00 • .(T'l-...k ��.L.�,.• �7/ri r'� V :)/''(f'/ ,�5 /� / 7�7 p J / 9 7,5/ s''�r�;/ u97,7 r f� TOTALS•;,u,) t ; If / WO b•(f d5 ( ` (7)0_ f /` . ,.� /// 22 ,. ��... � .,• /�,.p-,�J ,`��'�/-/-j,,.L-; (�,J ozro �'y/�.�y /�/o o v �f;./:t'�, ,, ,��°.. �►-� PER. PROP. 1,579 do C> '�j 1 r G 4»..,n, p.. „�,( S� '- f ! i M-ir) / V y r�.' G.'? 7 / err ✓ '"� BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING I NO. $y5-1,1(f j_L. -I�jJD� kJ- - --- SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF INJ. rimy MISCELLANEOUS — -- ----- --- _— Plaster �/ / `F xSingle Dwlg- f�.None vGable Decorated Sprink, (Fire) l_—_._Deuhlo Dw18• ' -..Part .--.fCFtip ....: .:Pine Ftre Escapes — --'— —z� I••- — -1 I t 'Duplex Dwig. ;:. Full Hardwood --------- --- ------ --LI r -1 I [---- `'7 /6� Y U y..Flat Refrigerators ` ' / /Apartment 4s..Dlrt Floor Mansard Vac.CSy. __—� __DI �_� _ __ f�arble&TileL--_-_.__.Store Cement Floor PORGIIES V ravelsik•r"4 Skylights 1 ---- —L� _-__--_-.store&Office Finish FLOORS ...e:Fireplaces _ _ FI __-___.Store&Apt, ti X /I! Front Wood Joists Incinerators ` / / 7 —._",,_—_— ___I—I—i_I_I_ . • HEATING X side --- — _— _ I I I I I ---- �•� zp X y Office MIN Solar W,Sys. - // Hotel .,e/-::None X Rear Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. — I y r-- Theatre Stoves X Sleep. _.:.Reint.Concrete ------- _-,T-- — -- I.—CONDITION i' Oil Burner Rclnf.Tile __ _ _ -.-..d__-Garage (Apt.) Fireplace Dirt —I _ �� --I—_f- I GOOD FAIR BAD EXT. WALLS FACTORS L ____ __.__._.Gaspe(Serv.) FLOORING __ _ __-.._-_Garage (Prot.) Woos Siding No.of Rooms -- — Gas Station CONSTRUCTION Brickine Apartments --I— --- ------ -�c p-----_ Church Hardwood I� Wood Frame prick Cased Rooms&Apt. — ------ -- �•c� r7Ji School --- _ oncrete -yi I I , \ f. !' Lumber Sheds Sleet Frame �.:......Stucco t __ Tile Fin.Attie R. '°a" ---� �" ' ((////yy�� / f� /U 7 ileinf.Concrete Metal Marble Fin.Base.R. -- �+ ---I �_----�� / Mill Block Tcrrauo !,.]. -- —1--r % -- s I I I I SO.FT. V.P. TOTAL ROOFING �:/?.DatO Compit. _ -• Brick Shingle Linoleum - — — — .,.,--�— ��—"-- . - �---- r r t .a Age ----_--__ —I II1 I I I _____ ,Shingle ... Concrete Tile • I ---- — -- � --- (76) �j ; ,/' Pitch&Gravel PLUMBIN r�� I I t /-V 7i'(� ✓^ / r EXT. TRIM �'p� Remodeled I� -- J �—_-- L_ FOUNDATIONS None 1,;' —I — ---- _If —�•-'' VALUATION ,:),./. Metal _:_e...Plain 1.--Fixtures/ ., ----- q _ — ;:'�'" Stone Ornamental Toilets �l LIGHTING ---- ---��{-" ---- RECAPITULATION) y _...._.Slats itfon /.y..,::Concrete Wood i t Bathroom: 1 .' Brick Stucco The Floor =�= Electric s+ / c /) Slate ___ F �I---- I 5 . N d' '�, I Tile—Flat or Tile Terra Gotta i---_Baths,Bufft-M ......--Gas _____ Ornamental Piers Metal • Showers Limps . 1-1 1 I --L— I I— —1 I I I-1 — —I—\ ---- —7— LAND APPRAISAL i I—I—I I I I i----- ADDITIONAL I I 11 1 I ------ -- �� ---- BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front • Price Factor Factor Foot Value Valuation • LOTS ACREAGE ST. IMPROVEMENTS ' X Nt U?- , 5" Level Levelirt 1. 'Paved r _ `IIigh Hilly TOTAL • Sidewalk BUILDINGS. $ /•') X / `. ✓ Low Rocky ♦ ::./..."') • ._..:__-Curb Rocky Swampy TOTAL • Enhancing Factor O ACRES Swampy Farm •••_`'Water LAND Detracting Factor �� @ Sewer Wooded ...�:=Electric Light TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION Gas AND BLOCS. $ I• DISTRICT • CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA R SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT Improved OWNER Fai th 1). Hackl 126 13,14 & 315 Vacant ADDRESS 2 'B' Exempt OWNER 160 Marine Way; D.B. , FL 33444 DESCRIPTION: ADDRESS OWNER 160 Marine Wayre„nbi-ar ADDRESS YEAR— 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 EXEMPTION t ��JJ // Q (/Z • LAND ) 73 �/ 7C0 /3 . vie / /35+6 /3$ I35y1-6 �.Gg3?.. ,i&:,,', - BLOCS. G ( 3 'C �G,,3‘ 4 �,��A 6/ 3 G 6 / 36 6/36 747a 2C7c. S TOTALS / ? / u) // ,� /r7t v I (� 700 I? 7 00 I 0.0 Lzh W l�O .g3�03 PER. PROP. (O o o , o oA 0 0 � / C..,, 1`o DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING 1, BUILDING PLAN 7 BUILDING DIMENSIONS J_....__............,....................._.._.....4 G •....-.__....._ r[/ •-- v_�_.....�y t. ..t .!.___..— /aJ No. ,tYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ,ROOF 1 FINISH MISCELLANEOUS 1 ES ..._/_..Slants(twig. ✓None ... Gabie l•-Piaster Spank. (Fire) _. _ _ __. _ .. . _T ILSX j y S/oIr Decorated -••-•••• "' .% HEIGHT Double Dwlp. .._-....Part Hip Pine .Fire Escapes • "" • -i • + - - • / ✓ 7a� �� .........Duplex Dwlp. Fall Flat ,Metal Hardwood Refrigerators 1 ""'� --I •--- -__.._ se_-..- yv x . 111 Apartment Dirt Floor Mansard '_-".." Vae.C.Sys. - _ --_ -�- ---' --"-'- `"-- _` .. . arble&Tile l. ._ _ -._.....Store' ......Cement Floor PORGi(ES /�" Panels JSkYliihts T -IR e - X Store&Office Finish /� /p FLOORS _._ Fireplaces • _ • .__ � " - -�--- -..Store R Apt. ! X Front Wood Joists Incinerators �}_L /8 n ..------.Office N ATING X Side .... ..MIII .. -,ftoj_.; ^-----------�_,_-.---------- ,,/�� X8 •��s!. �14 i ••-• Solar W.Sys. J-!Hotel ... . None X Rear teel Beams _ •----•-•• �. Air Con.Sys. _. -.-_- -- Theatre Stoves X Sleep, Reinf.Concrete - ___- . _._._. _- CONDITION 011 Burner ._._._..Belot.Tile "' Garage(Apt.) .- .. Dirt - . ... • - -._. _ -• .._.__s_-__.._.. . _ _._.._ O Fireplace EXT. WALLS FACTORS !~ GOOD FAIR BAD -.Garage(ServJFLOORING f / - --- ------- -- Garage(Pref.) Wood Siding __...No.of Rooms f _ �--- CON�STRUCTION ! ---.----. -----__- ----- Gas Station s/ liriek Pl^° -_._Apartments - Church Hardwood -- - - TT-` - Cchool Wood Frame B ck Cased ....V./Concrete ..------Rooms&Apt. --- - Steel Frame tucco `-'---'- Lumber Sheds --- --- .-J The Fin.Attic R. --�- - +. •-.------•.-�- -.-�_ _.._ Marble $ .. __... I -_ Relnf.Concrete Metal . Fin.Base.R. - --•---------•------• ROOFING Mill Block Terrazzo Data Ccmplt. • ��._,_._ -------,-- _ _•---- SQ.FT. V.P. TOTAL Brick Mingle Unoleem ,.... !r _. .- ._..-------------._. e� Age Shingle Concrete Tile - ,-, PLUMBING - -- ----------------- E TRIM None Remodeled . ,. + •._ • ��___.___•�Pitch 6 Grave! FOUNDATIONS etal Plain Fixtures VALUATION �( L)CHTING f - -r� T� -- RECAPITULATION Composition • stone Ornamental Toilets j/ -_T -_- Slate ... • Stem Tile Floor """'-"' t _._-....Tile-Flat or Tile .........Terra Gotta Baths,Built-In Gas 1 _ -, ,---- --- Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lambs -•-------+----•--- --_�_ LAND APPRAISAL .__.__._ .i ADDITIONAL I -' --- - BUILDINGS G>-/ / Unit Depth Corner Front Front and Depthpt Ire Factor� Factor Foot Vales VA aluation /�/ X/ ' �z 's" ✓ /ot �V J / � erel LOTS Ler Level /Paved ROYEMENTS ----_ f i ✓.High Hilly Dirt TOTAL / ' r l S�" _ f^{1 BUILDINGS 5 7 (p 70( 7 X e.�7 (/ 42 2 /r /( - �- Low Hilly Sidewalk Swampy Rocky Swampy Curb TOTALLA 93 Enhaoelnp Factor rn ACRESrbWat TD Detruetlntl Factor /� COC!O /¢ __....Wooded ewer - _,/Jt �` TOTAL LAND VALUATION �� �'1� ..►'.. Electrle Light ANDABIOGS S ;/ ‘ O DISTRIL`/ CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA R-3 SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT Improved OWNER Faith D." Hackl . 126 13,14 & ly Vacant ADDRESS 251 Bayard Lane, Princeton, N.J. • Exempt . OWNER - DESCRIPTION: ' /_• j C-r' ADDRESS . ` (� • % • (' OWNER ADDRESS • • YEAR— 196t 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 •1970 1971 1972 • EXEMPTION LAND 5II a • — BLOCS. 2 id • TOTALS /W ' 7,— PER. PROP. / el.; ;) BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING —__ _ _ _ — I No. SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS --— —_----_—_ — — Plaster - -I X ✓Sipple Dwlg. None Gable Decorated' Sprink. (Fire) I, ----- HF 1--- Double Dwig. Part HIp Pine Fire Escapes ^ ------,,p39 ---------- I I LI _ Duplex Dwlp. Fult Fiat Hardwood Refrigerators � I— [---— MarbleApartment Dirt Floor MansardVac.C.Sys. I —�— —7— L Store ........Cement Floor Panels ._.....Skylights -- - --- X PORCHES 1 I I 1 r-r — ..._. Store&Office Finish .Fireplaces ^�__,— FLOORS -----'--^-- -- I i i _.—..Store&Apt. X Front ._Weed Joists Incinerators -- --+�-- ---- Oflice HEATING X Side MITI —� I I-I I I — X .... Solar W.Sys. —� �— None X Rear Steel Beams_._..Hotel Air Con.Sys. — Reinf.Concrete _.__--- Theatre Stores X Sleep. --1 ra ------- CONDITION Relnl.The — Garage(Apt.) Oil Burner Dirt FACTORS _ -_ _ GOOD FAIR BAD •-•ll-- EXT. WALLS____Garage (Sere.) Fireplace --- I (+ +------I � kc____ Wood SlJ lnp FLOORING _,_,No.of Rooms-------Garage(Prrt.) ----('�rI Ir� ----- ._.....Gas Station CONSTRUCTION Brick • Pine ._Apartments Hardwood • Church Wood Frame Brick Cased Concrete Rooms&Apt. �'r/ —`—` -- I School Steel Frame Stucco The Fin.Attic R. `'—' " -----� _____ Lumber Sheds — — —I— ^— R!Inf.Concrete Metal Marble Fin.Base.R. --- — _�_ Mill Block Terra::o v ---- ----1�—�f- I ��� — S:.FT. V.P. TOTAL y ROOFING Date Comptt I —I�p Ci — _r ___I—I 1—I__ — Brlck Shingle Linoleum �• --- - Shingle Concrete Tile Age I . I Is--__—_ 7. _-1I_I_i_ PLUMBING ----{ — Z __ _I^' 1 1 /�---- Pitch&Gravel EXT. TRIM S,Q.Remodeled t--� ---— FOUNDATIONS None — I _—_. I I 1 VALUATION ____Metal Plain Fixtures LIGHTING I-- __ I RECAPITULATION Composition Stone Ornamental Toilets I N '_"'—"" ......__Concrete Wood Bathroom: '�Eiectrie G ___ ___ _ S ..__.....Slate Brick Stucco Tile Floor -- _I -- ..Tile—Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Bullt•In Gas i __ _ _ ^�� Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps I I --_— I I I ---- -- ._ I I I ! I J� I I I --- I �-- -- LAND APPRAISAL J IJIf I — ADDITIONAL 1 1 1-1-1—1 1--1 — —I I' I I 1 BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front Valuation Price Factor Factor Foot Value LOTS ACREAGE ST. IMPROVEMENTS Pared r,.•� x 17 Z v1erei Level TOTAL N V f 3o go lSo yI Dirt • D 1/ High Hilly Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ / x 1' Y 3 / >• l� 30 2 0.5* Low Rocky --.. Curb • Rocky Swampy ✓ TOTAL Enhancing Factor ACRES11 /L Swampy Water Detraetlnp Factor % @ If Farm LAND Wooded Sewer ✓Eleetrlt Light TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION 1 / . Gus AND BLDGS. S • • DISTIT1CT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT ',f , ! ,,f�,; a -- Improved OWNER .''', �".. ......��•,rl�. ,mow w K �; ..., .... _-.:_....:. l Vacant ADDRESS .T (4f�'7 f'f )' 7)' 9 r,� . ;^� �^ , l: /�.:, //,`(r^ r .. Exempt ! DESCRIPTION: OWNER / ,S ADDRESS ?'Ct'" V OWNER �P �;_ rj „ ADDRESS YEAR- 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 EXEMPTION LAND BLOCS. TOTALS PER. PROP. BUILDING PLAN ,S' BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING 1 ,__ J _ -_ NO. l _ SIZE HEIGHT STORIE! TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ,ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS �_ 1 �'_ ster . Single Dwlp. L None ...1.: Gable feorated Sprink. (Fin) _.. L _... _..J• •- 70 s /6 X 2O ‘,ZL Double Owl°. Part Hip Pine Fire Escapes - Duplex Dw11• Full Flat Hardwood Refrigerators - - - f fie" '-- .ry Apartment Dirt Floor Mansard ------Metal Yae..C.Sys .. .... ..-------•--__.------.-_. ._-,----•-- ,7�f-f�(' x /T/ ��r' ` • Marble&Tile _. _ Store Cement Floor Panels Skylights PORCHES ... ... ..... .. _. .. .. - ------------ -- •--•--- --- X ...._...Store&Office Finish FLOORS Fireplaces 1 _ X Front .._.... ._ _..Store 6 Apt. HEATING ..Woed Joists Incinerators .Office X Side MITI Solar W.Sys. / -. _ _.__ _ _ _._ X ____.Hotel None X Rear Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. TheatrefR^inf:Concrete Stoves X Sleep. ! -- J CONDITION Rant.The j a-' Garage(Apt.) 011 Burner EXT. WALLS FACTORS Dirt �- - `"'- "'' - - - - GOOD FAI BAD ...._. Garage(Serv.) Fireplace sWood Siding Sldtn FLOORING / No.of Rooms E J L � - / ____Garage(Prot.) p ..----.. , _._.. ..j�, ---- - ---- - CONS7UCTION Pine •_Apartments ... .� Gas Station Brick _. J _- ___-._ .� .6!/__ -._ ___. t/ Church t�Wood Frame e,h . The wood Fin.Attie R. J '..- t ^- y - Brici Cased ondwo Rooms&Apt. Lomober Sheds •--.Steel Frame z+' Stueeo _,I) t - - - t---------- -----•- --- -- - - _. "" Marble - fl^lest.Concrete Metal -�-�-• Fin.Ease.R. - Terrazzo �._. / SO.FT. V.P. TOTAL ROOFING MITI Block •Q, Date Cempit. l Brick Mingle linoleem _ .,'- Shingle Concrete Tile AQe J PLUMBING Pitch&Gravel EXT. TRIM Remodeled . i . .a �___ VALUATION FOUNDATIONS n'" None -' �- - --'- ..._,.Metal ..fit'..Plain Fixteres IGHTING RECAPITULATION rr Composition .- 4-Stone Ornamental ... Toilets - - I Slate ..1"-.-Concrete .... Wood Bathroom: ./ Electric . _ ._. .._ _ _.._._._.._. __.._ _ . ._._. .. S Brick .......Stucco �T The Floor __......TIle--Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Built-In Gas J -` -' --'- - Ornamental Piers Metal - Showers Lamps •-"-'- - _: ._J. I - LAND APPRAISAL --{` ADDITIONAL ...__..... ..�._......I......-.... _.... ..._ .........._I_......_. _ .-...._.._..--t---._._.....__..._.. BUILDINGS Unit Depth Corner Front f f Front and Depth Price Factor Factor Foot Vales Valuation LOTS ACREAGE ST�J4,1PROVEMENTS X V-Level Level Pared -- Dirt TOTAL High Hilly BUILDINGS' $ X . Low ...... Rocky Sidewalk Enhancing Factor Rocky Swampy --- Cerb TOTAL Delraetlnv Factor ACRES @ Swampy Farm -- Water LAID %O -- Wooded Sewer TOTAL LAND VALUATION e'fGi=ctrlc Light ANDACLDCS. 3 • IR�i r I1 ,```` I Ar 1 ; i 11 v 8 6,. I hr�.1` '-.1 / . il l''-?C`.. • �• ri 116 • . J ..i -- , A v;� V , _, + • 4 . w I 1 L • " , fi r, ya y., ° ,. N 7 !, i .. f r Ali.r f� i dry •t i . •, .-•ty: "f sX` ti �°' ^< t^ Ka f r M t "A I .�^`' ,.':;L, ". let Y 4 .i ,s...,..:-:.. -•- `� ih.-"Ili 1'; ..v , -'4 ti pd'. .y ..._.. f't.;1+.s.•.>,.:... t.....3....1. �A, __ i Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 Field Date_8 /_22_/_07_ 0 Ori final FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE g Version 4.0 1/07 Form Date / / I� Update il'"Ir"' 1 Recorder# Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none) 160 Marine Way Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name: Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) ❑x building ❑structure 2 district 0 site ❑object Ownership: ❑private-profit ❑private-nonprofit Eprivate-individual Oprivate-nonspecific Ocity Dcounty Ostate Ofederal ONative American Oforeign ❑unknown Address(include N,S,E,W;#;St.,Ave.,etc.) 160 Marine Way Cross Streets(nearest/between) SE 2nd Street USGS 7.5'Map Name&Date Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969, 1973 Plat or Other Map City/Town(within 3 miles)Delray Beach In City Limits? Eyes Ono ❑unknown County Palm Beach Township 47_ Range_43 Section_16 1/4 section: ❑NW OSW OSE ONE ❑Irregular-name: Tax Parcel # 12 43 46 16 01 126 0140 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block 126 Lot 14 UTM: Zone 016 017 Easting 0 Northing 0 Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g., park) S Construction Year: 1940 approximately ❑year listed or earlier ❑year listed or later Original Use* Single family residence From(year): 1940 To(year):_Present Current Use* Single family residence From(year): 1940 - To(year):_Present Other Use* From(year): To(year): Moves: Oyes Eno ❑unknown Dates Original address(if moved) Alterations: Eyes Ono ❑unknown Dates 2005 Nature* Loggia enclosed Additions: Eyes Ono ❑unknown Dates 1997 Nature* 800 square foot master bedroom added Architect(last name first):R.C.Lawson Builder(last name first):R.C.Lawson Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) Original owner A.E.Turner Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Eyes Ono ❑unknown Describe Part of Local Marina Historic District 'Zf t SAY Style*Florida Vernacular Exterior Plan* Irregular Number of Stories 1,2 Exterior Fabric(s)*Stucco Roof Type(s)* Gable Roof Roof Material(s)* Tin Roof secondary strucs.(dormers etc.)• Windows(types,materials,etc.)* Double hung—all original except addition Distinguishing Architectural Features(exterior or interior ornaments) Original shutters,windows and original interior finishes • Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) Gazebo,Front trellis added in 1993 Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO—Appears to meet criteria for NR listing: Oyes Ono ❑insufficient info Date_/_/ Init. _/_/ KEEPER—Determined eligible: Oyes Ono Date_/_l_ ❑Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: Da ❑b ❑c ❑d (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources 1 R.A.Gray Building 1500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399-0250 Phone(850)245.6440 1 Fax (850)245.6439 1 E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.Fl.us Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 Chimney: No. 1 Material(s)* Stucco Structural System(s)* Wood frame Foundation: Type(s)* Material(s)•Concrete Main Entrance(stylistic details) Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof types,etc.)Original tiled entry porch Condition(overall resource condition): iexcellent good fair ❑deteriorated Druinous Narrative Description of Resource Archaeological Remains ❑Check if Archaeological Form Completed Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). t] FMSF record search(sites/surveys) library research El building permits El Sanborn maps ❑ FL State Archives/photo collection l city directory El occupant/owner interview 0 plat maps E property appraiser/tax records E newspaper files El neighbor interview 0 Public Lands Survey(DEP) ❑cultural resource survey 0 historic photos 0 interior inspection 0 HABS/HAER record search ❑other methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) PB 00269 .. ....,,e, - ..F .. .,s a... .....,....., ,- om.r x„m. -- ✓� .e,.....<„ i. ,x»,.V,. � ,Via: 4 Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? oyes Ono ❑insufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district? oyes Ono ❑insufficient information Explanation of Evaluation(required,whether significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) Home contains significant original features. Addition was approved according to the • 4 This building represents the Vernacular architectural style that was commonly constructed in the 1940s. As part of the locally listed Marina Historic District,it also illustrates the developmental history of the area. Locally significant,this building is a contributing resource in the district. It is considered eligible for listing the NRHP individually,or as part of a district Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic heritage","community planning&development",etc.) Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field&analysis notes,photos,plans,other important documents that are permanently accessible: For each separately maintained collection,describe(1)document type(s),*(2)maintaining organization,*(3)file or accession nos.,and(4)descriptive information. Building cards,Historic Preservation Board Meeting Minutes, Maps Recorder Name Carolyn Patton and Claudia Willis Recorder Contact Information(address/phone 1 fax I e-mail)(561)274-9823 Post Office Box 250 Delray Beach,Florida 33483 Recorder Affiliation Delray Beach Preservation Trust Use a Supplement for Site Forms or other continuation sheet for descriptions that do not fit in the spaces provided. O USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required © LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP(available from most property appraiser web sites) Attachments 0 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format(pia n paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. .- DISTIICei • CITY OF DELRAY ' BEACH, FLORIDA j..--,,, • SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT improved OWNER a" r T1.a, 126 Vacant ADDRESS '�' ""ar e,6#r �° -pea' '�'y--Be' e...�.,n ,. Exempt �-I- OWNER DESCRIPTION: S 401 of Lot 6 & All of Lot 7 ADDRESS ' 116 Marine Way OWNER James L. Bowen & Margaret W. Bowen " '' TJe _'_- r 'y^• ADDRESS 116 Marine Way, Delray Beach, FL 33444 YEAR- 1962 1963 1 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 EXEMPTION YY \Alif to/ WI • LAND 7 o d-,t0 7' 7-0 •••YYYl 5/7�iD BLOCS. PFR#'7423-87M, 9/3187 ,Re-roof, $ , 560.Checked /-6/7-Pr ae .TOTALS 7 O y (0 0.-i0 7o �Q 70 0 7020 7020 0,7 0 (.71c, /,J ,9� PER. PROP. / BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING l -.._ ._._... -1 - - -- — -- -- -.-_ ----- NO. __._-._--__----------,---._-_-_- SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF •INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS _ -• - - --•-�T-- Plaster - -' SingleDwlp. None Gable ._...".Decorated Spank.(Fire) ............_.-....._......._...._.....................__..__.._..._.__.._......_-............._....-......_......._.._......._..._.....__.._.._."._.._-__..__._.__ X ...__....DoubleDwtO. Part Hip Pine .........FlreEscapes ....._._.....-_.--_e__-...__.._._.....-_--.._...-.._ ._._.._.____._._.-..._-_.... _-._..._�_�-.,._..___--.�-._..-_-_.._. DuplexDwlg• Full Flat -"-._..Hardwood Refrigerators .-.-____._.-._.,_".___._-____..----_--_-___.-__.—_.._.____.____,.._ __ X Apartment Dirt Floor Mansard ----••-Metal -. Marble&Tile Van.C.Sys. Store Cement Floor PORDHES Panels Skylights X Store&Oflln Finish _ __-..Store 6 Apt. X Front FLOORS Fireplaces _ a_. • ...._. X .Office HEATING X Side ---- •.Mood Joists Incinerators .. .. --_. -. Solar W.Sys. _...__. ,- - --�- _ _ Hotel None X Rear Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. - - - ---- -•-- --.- Theatre Stoves X Sierp. R^,inf.Concrete Relnt.The CONDITION Oil Burner _,__ _ Garage(Apt.) EXT. WALLS Dirt FACTORS ~ GOOD FAIR BAD ____Garage(Sett.) Fireplace --- FLOORING -1_______.__-.. _.__.____..__.__..-_---,-.-,-.----,_----,--._._,.-_----_-.-_,.,, .__.__.Garage(Prot.) Wood Siding No.of Rooms ,_- ---.___-_._ ____ Gas Station CONSTRUCTION Brick Pine Apartments Church Hardwood "-" `--'-' -._. .. ' _ Wood Frame Brief Cased Rooms&Apt. ......................................_...........,_........._.._-._....__.._...__._..___.._.__.._ ._..__.._.--_._---•- . School "' Concrete --- ..•... Lumber Sheds Steel Frame Stucco Tile .Fin.Attic R. Relnf.Concrete Metal Marble Fin.Case.R. Terrauo --..-.---_.._._. SO..FT. V.P. TOTAL ROOFING _Mill Block Linoleum Date Ccmplt. Brick Mingle .. --__.-_-___._._ -___.----___.__.._ Shingle -Concrete Tile PLUMBING Ape - EXT. TRIM Remodeled - _ Pitch 6 Gravel ' _ VALUATION FOUNDATIONS None .____--, --__--- Metal Plain Fixtures ... ------ ------ --- Stone Ornamental Toilets LIGHTING i __ - -- _- --- --- _ RECAPITULATION Composltloa Concrete • Wood Bathroom: .___.....Slate Brick Stucco Tile Floor Electric - " _. _ _.__ $ . ._- -- ..- _._.....Tile Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Bd Gas - lt-In - � �" ^ _ Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps T - LAND APPRAISAL t l ADDITIONAL BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front Price Factor I Factor Foot Value Valuation rs//� ��/L� n LOTS ACREAGE STJMPROVEMENTS "'J O X / ' /00 94f, ✓ / 0✓ eret Level ' Pared Dirt TOTAL 4 x ` ? J49 / '/ n High Hilly Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ / (/ D� /D/� L' ....... Low Rocky Enhaocin0 Factor Rocky Swa..... / TOTAL Defrosting Factor % ACRES @ Swampy Farm • Water LAID . /; ........Wooded ,Sewer - (JJ� �/JJn/,n Electric Light TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION / V V AND CLOGS. S CRs xw—,. J f. ,,r 1 s' . �r orb N. • 1•'.• , IV , f.'.i • "�.i� .„ xa•. IR i /. ii. '/ ._ , .. t'• tf #i/ rr ,;+� �r '� i �ra a�' „�� ; S.,• • • r. YA. + i }„ 0 11 e ..a a"♦ n, 3 i.�1, F I !r � i w. iy 1 @ •.' L 1 f.' ' '.. .. . , .- .1, ii 7 it' . i 'MI ;;1111i . 31 ' ' ' ..t • .:::3- r - 4. tom~ = x. •! - C r� i'� tyl ¢ Fr7e"a . • • ,---. xi4` 1+`�l- ✓ Ir - \ it v7vA•rY,is;l,If t` „, s. a Lf 1 'x CKS e/i _ , - . /A „. , :-.\,.. • 1 I I , . ..t• i :,t....je . ;; 1 . - 1. 1 tr rr • • � 1 -- : r 1. 4LJ ( . ,..,. 2,,r,,,, A. • 'yy p ' 'Y r.fi ,a• Jj tt f.t j ql ir ti 1r RI / // a .' ; !11 i� 4��+ Irlkr , • !r . Ai; 1 ;rj '$.:• o,>: Al..' 1y�r .1 1 r..�r ' ` i:., +� •ram- ..n , . . r 1 `r,x 1} F \ 1 4 a 1 • i ml • 1 a r \ ..w.,4: • ray ,' }+�. era rr •r i 1, ° yl i '�� '° ' • (( n 1 ti1:. 7�, ' ,. ��- �Itry • .1, 4my! c +r rl�I''y1yj{�ii. iT ! 1r A T� �•, . �.!�•+mg •'V l," _ I r.• 'Y .. ,1� tiil1 ii1:.., •0 \l'� . , . �— -- s�` fY� ,t' .dal ]I A r I � ,r • . �� • +a, Rai I~ �Ir,.. Y , ...• r I i - • 44,''.4iiiiik,..-*"..•-l'''''''''' - \.... . ii, , T+ - 1 1.-.t 1. ••7,J� A. r y.• '` I . _ -Ti -J1 ' 0 4 tAIl • • .-.'.* ',.,- :. . 1'. P.I.1 ? ' ":' ' , ' . . ., . :7.1.1-•,, a.,...4!Nam al ,... • - i'''') , / ' •";:, ii . '',.'i . t'le 1 : L .1 ... ''1.- '''',./. $...,fr. '..,-,',.„', ;:h ,, ..,',.'.',1 ';.( t:1,:!.', '1, :,..'..',..,71, p:.',',„1 1,1;I :,5,4';,, ''''!..''''''''''':-:'":'; • ‘11, .'1,• L1111i1i111, , • •Sys .. • • �' . r , i i sxt-5Ti1:Gc 6Tr;Ic.Ti.)r..,F • D EV I5fl N ROof --) ___ Hi) a K i19, L,LI S RA F.T ..e---\ t of Tf R i ,r" ..(- I , , +r--- r,E A r-\ ? r..4.6 N c„pc �F RAT' ,� I ----� �; r GFDf�—r---- i 2 1 1. 3-41 . • • 2X4 FAR- ;1TiA(...}ie> - -,•rcZ Gkc',„4, 1)1; E — tl I II I j i CI: :1 ; j I/ : I • 1 W i� •I 'ii ' it `� t•I _d ' I + 11 I f . r ; �� it o 6 d s - o • ?:O`' 1. 6- et `'. G--.. a -- - + If 1 • 4EAGT ELE /ATlot\i - Gdl.!✓ o 3/5 " _ 1 011 N, • - . , • _ . li L. . . 1 . . 1 . . . --..., (2)tv -mai_is _bic3..-r ca C-e"0. . ...., .„ ,5.:-.I‘I Tlf•J 6 FE---5--.1PG_NC-G --7, ,i.:,,..-----1 / • i , . ,-( -) 2 S[8. El S. Res I-•rE)-• ....... N.. ,. ,. . . •I ... ....„ 1 . , ., .. . (F.. ISTIKI 6 R.pc,P 55E Yor.)o k--,., , _______i!l. i _ . . . . ._..., 1 , . . , . . . , . '7)16 -rL.Li I 1 s . • .__. IIIIIIIIIMIIIIMPION i 1 i • . . • . ...,___ z4P . : a.6- 1 I A 1 . ... ..---.. . i ..........me• w - 1 . - , . , , --. 1 I w L-- / 1 •.r.._ ',LID P051- -----.• • , - - ! . . 1 I 01111111Milamm1INIO I • ; ; —t 0 - . . .. • . .. - . . 1 • N 1 ,yei .r.. 9/0 IGI ''') -'`.. • P f...) ` P ......-.------ ' L... I -.. • . '6OT. 1: 1-----1 -v .....-____1-- . ,7:::---•,1::,',,A:',?7•V:)'_,4:• .;=•.'; i i I j.._......... .._____........__j....., tei...........sti . i ' . _ , . . . . . I .,. RTH -Li- .. El = u.A-r.in m ;,...,., • • .„..-.. .