The URL can be used to link to this page

18 - FMSF S r Cf 'r 4 r t.fk, _... DESIGNATION, , 1,_ p. k.7_, svet I REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA i •c , ' x. 4. i t f`J f }Y.�'.'.53 iR bt '�j 4:.:,�'._ l ;µ.. •T �t MY a' T`�• s.r eh rs x.—..4' ; -2.•.- .ram... ___ \ -fir .tfh4 f., - s•_�7.y� .-. A. r]- ,rifk__: • - —,.*..x- •-�s� � , Q .,salt. ..• "�-,, • 4. - - . ' s '�:. 's ..-1,L.,', s"+ '3 SI.W1. vFw "F' 31'F r i, � � � -tj 'a � � . t sl k , � . v _ .0 K..0 t* a• yK� 1 + b A►z- ��'� t. -. ✓ Tr ..•? ..7.� �� frf%"' .r x t..d x^ 11� 'z`." } l .s ,,Ss' ' ' .+Jr'f'i, 1r4 * jYe f o- 4C S t7', z .N � �y' ^, 'lM .A Say .t ' c4<-4.v b ., +` ' .—' L s -+' •--+ i,.- L r.. 1tc:i -tc, eS, -- etenl7li ^-A .its.. 'AJ7.'CN 41 . 'T!'. .+ry- 1 .Y_- ,.'`h?.�` r.�S. .- e ' 5-p .t y ig 3i'sq a.1 a'i z u s` •ca�••yv :-'as..$ 1;,. 7 r {" - -' fir ir7• ,- 1 ^n ,t sr ! r 3 T. • �t gems y -_+�� 4..4+7'11 'd'f`ti.-•�(_,y:`,y"Z�`V:-`.< ?, s`, 1n,ilsr4.4" ♦11\._'� . 45•!� - .'i- `•zt`,,..,•�::. THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE 30 N.W 3RD AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1935 t' • MEMORANDUM TO: Historic Preservation Board DATE: October 18, 1994 Delray Beach FROM: Douglas T. Williams RE: Historic Designation of the Munnings House I do feel that the Munnings house on northwest third avenue meets the requirements to be designated an Historical Site. The American Bungalow meets the design guidelines that are set forth by the city. The history of the house (which, at onetime, was the home of the city's only mid-wife) is certainly noteworthy. I have been a resident of Delray Beach for most of my life and have experienced and been a part of the many changes that have occurred. I do realize the importance of preserving the rich, cultural, historical heritage in all sectors of the city. I am, therefore asking that the Historical Preservation Board present this house, which is located 30 N.W. 3 Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida, to the city commission for consideration of being designated to the Local Register as an historic site. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION IV. HISTORICAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared October 1994 by Vera Farrington, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board Member and Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. • Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1935 Architect: Unknown Builder: Isaiah Bruin, originally from Quincy, Florida Present Owner: Douglas T. Williams, 118 N.W. 8th Avenue, Delray Beach FL 33444 . Present Use: Residential, single family Present Zoning: R-1A, Single Family Residential Legal Description: Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally Town of Linton Property Control Number: 12-43-46-16-01-036-0050 Classification for Designation: Architectural significance, good example of bungalow style. Cultural Significance, home of one of the first midwives in the community. .t I ., Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 4 II . MAP o..o...�,....- - �_— _ <-- _ An.l. - 2ND ST. N.E. __ liz ... _ i___ I X 'L v --Laid:- li Z CITY HALL > —5_ _.....„ L Q N.R. 1ST Si. N.E. 1ST i Minn 1 III Li -- s DLO 3 3 3 -c. SCHOOL - z z - z Siimin. SQUARE • �. TENNIS - l 11 1! STADIUu 1II:I . ATLANTIC AVENUE 1 I POLICE SOUTHEn . DEPART/JEN-1 - COUNTY ' $1 re ! COURT a 4 a HOUSE _ 1 Ra, { ,__ s.•_ 1ST ST. (n S.E. 1ST 1111 `. I N z-,-`- 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE r_A,,Zti IXY AR D 0,11 O7-Y 6( wJIAY BU.OI,fl mi. t __ [r_AL QOSC W S)S1pf -- Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 5 III . Architectural Information The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is a good example of the South Florida bungalow style as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . Many of these homes were built from pre-designed plans purchased from publications such as the Home Owners Service Institute catalog and the AIA sponsored Architects Small House Service Bureau, or from local lumber companies . But whether designed by an architect, or constructed by local builders from pre-designed plans, they all share the basic design elements of the bungalow. Walls : Horizontal wood or stucco exterior facing. Roof: Low pitched gable roof with the ridge either perpendicular or parallel to the street; often with multiple gables . If the primary ridge is perpendicular to the street, the front porch is usually roofed with a separate offset gable. Roofs often have exposed rafter tails . Porch: Porches are prominent. They are usually deep and extend the full width of the facade . The porch roof is supported by piers. The design of the pier supports is usually unique to the house and varies depending on the creativity of the builder. Windows : Double hung or casement, multi-paned and arranged for cross ventilation Plan: Usually rectangular and often modest in scale. The Williams House contains many of the classic bungalow features. There are two gables at right angles to the street and an opposing gable roof covering the front porch. The porch roof is supported by 2 traditional massive piers which are broken at the middle with a molded cap. Above the cap the piers taper gradually to the porch roof ' s supporting beam. Exposed rafters are visible throughout. Original casement windows with a 4 over 1 pane configurations are a feature of the front facade adjoining the porch. All of the original multi-paned windows are in place and most of the functioning wood shutters are existing. The house originally had wood siding and possibly a wood shingle trim. However, the facing has been covered with vinyl siding so it is not possible on visual inspection to determine what style of wood siding was used. The house has a composite shingle roof. The foundation is a combination of pier and cement block. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 6 IV. Historical Information The house is located on Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36 . This block was subdivided into 16 lots when the Town of Linton was platted in 1895 . In 1913 the block was replatted by the owners, J.H. Jackson and W.H. Brady; 39 smaller lots were created out of the original 16 . Lots 5 and 6, and most of the replatted lots were purchased by George H. Green and his wife and the balance were owned by W.H. Brady and his wife. By 1922 there were 14 structures on the block including the Primitive Baptist Church on the northeast corner, and two grocery stores fronting on W. Atlantic Avenue. When the Town of Linton was platted all of the streets had names, the change from names to numbers was adopted in 1924 . The streets which bounded Block 36 were as follows : on the east, N. Beatty Street (N.W. 3rd Avenue) ; on the west N. Larson Street (N.W. 4th Avenue) ; to the north, Miller Street (N.W. 1st Street) . Though the historic house was not owned by Susan Williams, she resided there during the last 4 years of her life. The property will be listed on the Local Register as the Susan Williams House. Susan Currie Williams was born in the Bahamas in 1870 . In about 1898 she and her husband and their small daughter Agnes, boarded the Sir Charles Orr and set sail for their new life in the Town of Delray. Susan Williams had been trained as a midwife in the Bahamas and it is possible that she had been asked to come here by the Bahamian settlers who had established themselves in the community. Her services were soon in demand, both as a midwife and general nurse practitioner. The town did not have a resident doctor until J.R. Cason set up practice in 1905, ten years after the first settlers arrived. Medical facilities were available in West Palm Beach but one had to travel by train (Florida East Coast Railroad) to get there. A competent and caring midwife was essential to the community, as babies did not time their arrivals to conform to train schedules . Nurse "Susie" Williams delivered black and white babies alike and gave other medical attention as needed. As medical facilities became available and doctors moved to the City, Susan was called upon by the medical profession for home nursing. Tall, slender and imposing in her white uniform and dark cloak, she is remembered even today, by those who recall seeing her striding purposefully along with her black medical bag in hand. The original Williams homesite, now demolished, was located at the southwest corner of S .W. 4th Street and S.W. 4th Avenue. Susan William' s daughter, Agnes, married Grover Cleveland Munnings in 1924 . Mr and Mrs Munnings purchased Lots 5 & 6 and built the bungalow in 1935 . At the age of 80 Susan Williams suffered a stroke and moved 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue to be with her daughter and son-in-law. After a long and distinguished career in public service Susan Williams died 4 years later in 1954 at„ the age of 84 . Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 7 V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance The house at 30 N.W. 3rd , Avenue, also known as the Susan Williams House, is a good example of a modest residential bungalow as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . The house presents the major physical elements typical of bungalow construction. With the exception of the vinyl siding which has been installed over the original wood siding, most of the bungalow' s defining character remains in tact. Additionally, for the last 4 years of her life, the bungalow was the home of Susan Williams one of Delray Beach' s first midwives . It should be noted that the original Williams homesite has been demolished, as have many significant buildings in the historic black community. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2 ) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property and justification for designation. (2) "A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) "Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in the city, state, or national history ( for example, the homestead of a local founding family) . " The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue was the home of Susan Williams, one of the first midwives in the City, from 1950 until her death in 1954 . For 10 years after the first settlers arrived 1895 the community had no doctor, the nearest medical assistance was in West Palm Beach. The presence of a competent midwife was not only significant but essential to both the black and _white citizens of the community. Because the original Susan Williams homesite has been demolished, it is appropriate to recognize the house she occupied during the last years of her life. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue -Pa=ge 8 ( 3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed—to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " This house is characteristic of the many modest bungalows built in the community during the 1920s and 30s . It is appropriate to offer recognition and some protection to this structure because many of the early bungalows have been demolished, or have been altered in such a way that the original style cannot be identified. (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " The Susan Williams house contains most of the distinguishing characteristics of the bungalow style. It has a double gabled roof with an opposing gable over the porch roof. Exposed rafter tails are used throughout the roof construction. The front porch is prominent and its roof is supported with massive piers . The plan of the house is rectangular and the multi-paned windows are massed for cross ventilation. 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria be met. . Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 9 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Resourceful Rehab, Metropolitan Dade County, Division of Historic Preservation, 1987 City Building Cards Property Assessors Records, 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1926 & 1941. Oral History Documentation: Douglas Williams , Grandson Agnes Munnings, Daughter • .��. . -.... a.�� •••• cliff y Y L n Y• ^CFr .i ' ' . .i jam-'<' .t 0.-ii }e F„1'+ trite` 4.7 .� �" 1 is+5`Sro+i 'T'Y "r -+mr.,,. , •.A! .f• eet k. Y< M/ A3a VTyC yet 7 �,. •i' _ t1 jtai r.• 3gi ,y*M- .E ' sa"'r- �4 t F : ..d ' ss�t �J�1S .>'�1 �.- s L"1f•'�.� '.Y t r;t::"wk i1P*. -t<tt 6• fti':i vtVt.;S•)- .713t C 1- y4Y��> i+ {v v ` -,k tr.c��wf'6 + * y24--, a'�,L., ft`f �J-r Jo `- la t -1 ��,+ou ie -,t L.� .. T-.yfn.j•'h tl. /N�•,Y'4NS y,11-i 4 y r-,..:..�t ; ,-v.4Mf.Yt+t. 4y ' ';4"S •:`rr tL.- t/Yit'-.. rrof4 ''. - :%... v im , • . • • Y ..ipe. �'F,' s< .y.i?c�•'.'.I,,,�!-." t `. Z� ++s i .- ! s��L1�' - ••.,• .-11%- ' -;O'•.sP"••r�t• w < rJ7�t•:£•"c•'inl +. �..��._...-y .� 4 irk_ •4. • `a__ L t 37�yri . �{ �l+iSis '..+ fir+ .r.Y fiV, - r , t. `,�N-••-'{rJrn - t '4`1;3'-.:1",,- E e. Y s.."'t N '-'- �-. `S..ryr 1�n. S-'•ts --t /'- s a 7yv1 �` * •d • -E 1}i..-,.4.z.�,.:. t �t';< ita� ,"i $ �V. 41'< r` we _ i•2 y ''f .'i r */, • d'�.+NYtri..ny'. 1 r rs- f s.5 ...x+°r y- i ..ti- -1l-4 LY ?1 ... .s' ,, :f ai r 7 t ..7 rut .i,-,zA-....:.-.-+r.... s...-•+�- -rs' y.� .eI' t -r ..t a IFS L `'Y 't. - W aS"3 r>- 't p .0 i . x a- S'l-r` t-<'w. - yc• • ti•• t:Ir.s;4 .�,�$�. .'�a<- -i .• s.: ai ' • 4 •.1 � .' aJ'.�. Y" i ' 66 ^'3 .3-'. �'i P '�-F•r ' igs t ,� }}11 }i . ,.'I4V.Z; .C A . r-a - A • `ma' s:.3 a�Y N.,.� 1- axx ? f,; --., s ti,N 000 y-I-i�,ai� a • ••-• 'W_torzteii i srs r.,tR.'r'-a-p_f,,.•t Ta +S� t :, - �.a-_n,�tfy., 6 . -.•-.,+-..�aa�R1.e t. r''.r >�se 'L+^ '.1 tols.=n:.r t , a�,�r'•.. i �. .. -• +.�'y A 'f�`,€h r j� �+ ;y--1 >- e � y�ar 4 7,, sr '%d •e F• ,.t '3'� •i ,.t.. x '4. �.�r Z h �+l i r-t -t a•t' i,_. .-1.'. •.i.k+ pose-46_ i. {:,F�4Y r_ ,,> :-•h c"'?' a, t.111 y f+s '2t 47 ' 1M i.' .T"`1;;•4 - 'sue - yr`,.n^' 1 . •f-+a - . w i .,+ l �} r41.- beix,t,.�-:-., 7 �J ? S^ r�sk. d. ; `C• 7-;.fir. S.•'•'• "'T�$"' - -a - 1t'a�}'�.S� T .�.•Y i R•v s.. • R ro s•�h,33•a iy x .r 1 y Y� A•1T. f tx+�+ _ i_. t..4� .44.=f, r.:.r.S-t rG*.4C -ta _ '.:M ._ 1 = t ��1• !at ft v ;� '� r .ny ' .n�T+-s��''"�'.T, "h 3� 'i'a ! r < a '. • {-4 r t{'S y , a 1k'ji{. `. }' �. ,r. .,,,.tiL v s3 �i t �.. -w. S s t'-: 11, Aso :es,.4(4*-- Ii s"'3,.s � 4-.'",'•=•St Say F -r.r nr a'i'c,--tr t r.; • - _ s.; xc.} +yam& ' fy'tTV.7 .v.. j. r sr..= • Asr- r '�`�'��,_i� 0'li f.,T.'s 7 ti r,� •• �t YL : - _ -.5?_fnir,.•i+'� ri•IC''-f ..,,�,J"t• 'C,�' `w.' 3n�y N`=-nyr fF 0,it cz .o+.,'._ .r -v- ,a.---,. - __.— s 9� ; •' C i r 4 y • ji• .., t• [ i a- *"5•a 't 1> `�'* -...r.+t Y, •s- a. k- r r 1 L t't✓r' i rt''t`"1'" .•�r`i'•''..fi,. Ycv. n-3 _ '4 i fN' .tF _ as o"�{ Y`..: ". ^'j `V t t x - z t � y + 1 t .. t ,f i„-r i"y f'"sa„ e - s, n: ` .fir + ` .r ? --' � - ; 4. `if-tz es. x' raC t� S;�clik�• :ti-••+ t '.- b.. D� n. % e 4-• t a •: Y.'Y' • ��•3 zT % .FE'„.rf w a"> itr` ^c c -.. > -gLrk � ' ' 7f�3'� '1 i :4<g•• ' Ce•a � ��. y ,yam . - �,y T - . "�.'v*n: •rr Pik ti t ''3'r+"'s wt Z -t ~t ,4 c..,...°•.'lG.Y ,S,Y .�*'' Y A. r; :'' !u A xLt-s, t .. .i t"f •+' ' i±x -.r 1s _ .^^n... ,, s ' �� c"Z-'"it .4 L, •- £. .ay f"�.. fel 'F1't -`k � '—d; ,-.. �- _ ... ,�_•40. s�,�'�� Kam ,, ;, .< x !' .. •�l� �',''t_ F_l .� . •�'. . `k',,: fv • ryYt3.- k r • -- _ • V i ,- r ' .f x a� fi b- t; f s �..�_ � 111 .. YZ:>>7-k-t viax i f - ., - •• t#y.'1 Y .CQ t x t 4' r 'i. I•f7.-,2,11.Z�..'.~Tf4� ^ft,,i -'°'rs" '.._4;-' y + 'r .:.1-: ��'Ta •.1- r • :- . s ,�v; �.,., '4r. c .i• t t��{ya� t � �4-.swY-1.•.�. 'ate .gip ' '} Gj '}�k '..1 E WI z h a- i • L`s•J+t.'YS� L' t 'a•-`'� •- ,- {� Y.. ar _...: l „r+Y f t 4 _ IF 5,:f• (. • ...a'.Yi:hL ':,V_,`f,� ra�•_: T'!x's'..y `•y.!'?A �:. - -a..1; Y'._.,:.7.?.r`r ..�.. .. r... --1- • i:t-. i rr C, Y 1.;:m � tt'r sv-lid v:.X-14j• /�_7”*,7;; a t• _ .► •.t s'+" a^?,i'^'inh'is At4 is t •91- S.� --..+n6 tv. a .,. i:►.rt. �5...�`'':' r ."�) t'i/J� j ^K.. 4.4.:Wi ..,„ • .7'` •j,fir' jib ri,,k�•• y'0 3h y 4- i� �,�}�•i��t%i- '(ii 4 .£s l• a+Udv.,;,- a .ar a,;,r•s aa- 1, t t, 1' t ,•14�.Lsc.•-4'4• Tia! t:4if; '"> t" '1[[ 147fit�s?y� :1"': ''+5y4�:�a` tgAi,'f,r ,ti=3 ` i' .• ,. b '. - FX:...f��l r-'a"Ril.'.. U;�T4! MI.�.i'tLTl'JY n'. — _.-_-_.-____, _ OA/ 4 t). J1 .. lam••I Amay�... ] .".w.s� ..4 oS•f_ G " • y t Mtn?-Y� L ; c isIp� � _ r �it 1 f �9 ►(1.9; :.ri±.;;;;A.p.'.4.:0....V.t.'4..!:(i' .'t_14t.,?.."1...,kesitill.ttr.t. -.. ' "4-.4-1`..L.%'..1i221 • % y y "_}} �i ..s`A.0t s• wtr r. "t l s` `>•I. ��+srrJi ,,� >,} ‘ i -_--,— -..o.�S.y. . �f y 5� ` _E�1,C�, r i. n'' .3.P.; C .. -.E�a t. ,10 }Yh a ) 1` > ? 1r.;ti er,'h •.'.�5,.- Y.�, .44. 1 >-. r e J. 1`• -.5.. '°1). I ;i4 t1; i'.& _ Y t7l z s -/. •M r s�".i ' it +T<' �i ��s rrr'�t 7• �.� • .. ov r e r . �r yn i�\ a• - ..! to h-„,.. . - v}'f 4 j..• -• r c - 1: �- rf*,—,••. i� -<'3 9 .., ,;•)S .„ ,.:�`.�ss >�t ♦shJ'.lt: ^' • 3 .L`r 'S t +-ti e 'r.. i'' f :-. i"° r i.a- t BIS rs3 X`*r, �♦° r;,,t• 'g. t••f �• Ws i. :r�g�.f- �r"-� a.,r r.^.•. t. r a ;i�i �"v � 3+t p ,i j}�r�GY'' �• h� \ l fi. '+rl •t'..s- 'F�7 ctr Q,,� .( ;'o.•'t.,,tir�� '?` r., ',,; � {.� `y is D ri j�M`%p s r � � 1"il/.iS+Y" �"{i 'VAN,* Tf�� s ..•e� .t. ' „14 R-''''.'{'2'. -Sir�i--. "C„ t \�i[y�+p �. •f f Jy .1.Y 7` ♦ •- f -r`.b 4fk t„r Z.� iY l_ j,.. '3 J `y"(�' Via:' �Y ::.r.-- -. tt} .,--,.3 4;) .i.,.`!� _a. ,; 4i ,- }4 '>°'': �` . -�- 'ra t- :l .>1�.•5ti °. a • '`•� ter` .14! c emu:$. 4W.s Z:L t .e. ¢iF a, •t4I\LYi t•'�''tz.'`k ' .•,"+•i!�. •14• T ` t4z_' 4 s r., ,.,._ c al. "-c 4 .qr.-tv- -11 '` +'r l'" 0 4,1-..->rai��.?: v - 3 v. '<• • -s ssr}•a'1i`<s �.•-�:.s l � .. 'sue s �r -. -t '4 �'s 's � �a a�'it �t�{'r '4.- .�1 ,o.v c, n .} .,"4- 4 r .si T '+`-d1 t J 7. y .; .r's'rso_r >'��)F ,n.Ka.' `S`bs" o- -a.i' •F•1 y i0 �h{• i s s. v-k t r .z.,yi ti 1 . .vs -- -c ttVix-yy'yp4t. o., �i J` �' ..'* -s-k v... `�r..+� L •� a Z 7r -�S`jrn' * '`'y`s i sR.s n i ..zj ��'�Na. �, :r" 'w}5 4 r ri„1. - o .-ev }w a, -Z tom• -Y as - tc ice} ',, � iS�T .-G b • s' -Y'syfi i� h V` ,t s�-•`'r„++1`. 1+w},'� v•.`fit l�iy�,, ?j11.yr-yc+cl^. ' !Z aFy i.. s'R,.3Y"r"s..... t..y„ t� -,-c fr-,.. Imo' t -42„-..'F *.,)1 s.'�`s.fi-;1`'� ;v .. �tr.4. *'. `M• 4s-- i+w>F - �i.r f er r -. h:0, .,. „,--- S"~iYwD1� J'S; � .%--c'.•:c'4. '•r- 'r c...rJs o K_ st:�' z, t • •-r .c -•a .F` i s. .,,,,:z .-�' 1 C r_i :,V. 1'' 4. ...5�'a':= a , 3;'1.s�� µ ; S. -74:'t•`E,.+' ! w 7: irk v��a + y' s•tqk" A a:rttv t_v o h u ::,, 1- £-> s r rr1 x r ,, .% _, Y� • ti. • S44•". • acts :,4- a p c .v r b • _ r :t b ,: r z;-,Z, �Y' a$rti..,f '•sv�i4. , , ,�,��C �. a. .3Y C ^"ss a s in L "` J �.•`•w•�v yr.N rh* t>-+�•'r : 'C".. is _ s+ )r i'1 f' i' ✓..i.y+...• 1�, S n 2. -s�./ t'c rs^91.u. �S� ''�� c :- y.�ycT `� ,, .K a«1. F ..s, Y t .i �`RIVII.ti st�-v t c i h'tax x 'st F�,i '4:1. i <,fY • '{ s r• "Y E s 'r. ..-'-. T. ../4• 'I ,' ,-ti Wie..e, '. .., '.rs -'Yh..L I'd 'tiz-- ,c.7' e. 'a'. a�sa'cr .,.r S.,a i fit` k w x.1j.C•s,•3'� i 4a �.•,r 4-.Q'... r3 s 4,. -r.+'�f'£tt r -r i. ri - F 1 tidy-�.;+ s� i ..r i F- --,,,, '-• a1..).ui+,•r-. '' a 5' S' r •r t P n"Y sr .. '• .- ter : n f. i �». s> . �,,,,.l+f..:'*'X ..r•. i..3 4x41 .[u"tF � Y n. •4 Y o s :i.ri .s s. ,i•-r +'".•ac • `+ .� > Y '>r, s�`r `t 'a Y r t ;�" -- ..� r�'" .�.' . ,�.s`.. -S. a-— _ u -b� >P.54S�r�'*}' 4 �' trA+w .-, r--.raa Sk i—'em s :3 • �Ar,: fi k..r ryr - ^.t' t' '1• ,. t`` <y tv i . _ � .tSr t � L[ --i"�.g's- ,VA `k'� r .I -s t,.�-•Y s 't•a lei L azr- +. 'ss+ X,44r .vz,-'F i/' ,„(. r..,;i� aY.. ..`Y ti\ Z:74 - �,.+y �..a.; r T '.fF.r~' S ,y,E--�� r; tiny tr.,- \.'1�. C,'. �L •'W¢ i -ram f- -^ yd fib + i...3t'r• zn-L' .�y. t ra`tR . `.�i -a_•.S•_.?+ i . ._ ti.r .: 2V ].11.'..�=y J.;fi v-i.. . - • vs, c 4 I r- ' a 3t ,u.•h➢ t,K x.�....,•Fr*f s . . bjt ■ i ,''_ ,: . L r ` i. f�" t v v fa l r i\y t >s V4.B.l. Z. .i y.: lif. ZY s, , - - . ,A,, i. �✓._r•-+^�x`Y 1� 8„^C' �X'�✓dI y �»� �r i' ' �y, r:G".k'• ,. r'►,s�r ?, s ii aY,t'`g 3 �`"..t ,fi r r' •v"�l 14,,- t. 3� Y-1^ ..it.'_ --i .y,. w� r try)'" y ♦; �.0 eca-z ij s !;-:,..:4.r.1 , *x sty.4• • j? ,,,j' i s '.,i ltL"r Vr7 f%.41 le• .a'i 11 ` a�yS l = e'r t Y r .aa,� 3 >•r j--;31$t 4 ] ♦ M'{ Thy +' s ,iit �„ ^f-`L` }.rr�' n° ;��r k � S� ? 3s r. � ,R r i a F sq�r*w'+S' �S i Ji er tr'f,-w1,lr S.a ti.,, .4 S.,14k�j a3'c't� -.*71, - , f.,. ` ' ---73t,.. yg :' ��t"y•,'t � T. l k.a1':r,,1'L �.`+ ....- .�wr Y;}p r ♦♦4-.i.,;91 f,14 :- •1 4•-ee- Wt'.�,g9-r�i. 1 ?,. J J� th,...+I✓ .., y-,A Z'3>at>.•+:.'.,. ii !A 41 :: •- ry - 1"1- 1 ... ....A.,„.„'�T:0., ..4 7'� n i .a,4 ,r"•7 r,g,,,w .,1.„„,,.a.�,.,s,• "'f",t�� s.. �-a ., , y~ `Ar 7.sax ',NA,-3a 'u t r.r .j<1. -smear s • .a _ c�:t V.111,ifq,•, f..41v �jv •f,r r- r..•^c' 3 3,f Nt`e .s-. vt a c: ,g•st ,N• 4r�"r_L\ .. ?•... y .,,-eta.I..r� '�": '''' uttFr- '' .-? 'L 4 *^.. z+ t e!.'r_ ws"k r101:4 ` E�_ .-7 a� •. - pt �r.6 S{. ``~ - -.'2t •:; ) ..? x a ?r r^a �iit t`�t i y- a' �.#'�1_ f VI-A- �S�` ,`'• -�`- b �Z ; rT✓ � e,y.tY 7r � c 3 •� ,.i{1 e4s7' Lf+tw^utitw� �s�'+"Sj..<`�'�j"3-a`a Y , ` . f.:��a;.F-.•yin. i�?'t*a ''X,s�-S,t 3•.+'�y .t` '+r��`L7ei' .'FY"` � � ., � � ��ss��',f t��`° N`tea•; �.N. ,/ #'. � ( a ,•,l r� �►' r ryt 1 � -% r 1 1 a, £+..' r +.a R'y • - �, � .. r y, . �x $ rid ' 06 : -e'ijae'Ir- --------- -—1 4- ti . A yU Si ' -' ue,,a"1 ` '; •� ..j; j ; •'.: ). N.',,,,s i $ r - .>'i, n fitw; •1 _ elv c. • � �a n • Ytam ' '' • ,s„= a enf tr Tr- ,- �rcay... ,, }t• . v-r.c4`.o. •y .. a-'f� ,� �, 471,r r : r J•• Y.. _•�.- .: F ... a ..e,k..t t 0>•oks C..e S.. .CL�., . .z7y->_'[�.'`Ij `7l�� _.caswt d`art_?+:,. s'^. 1 . v ?.tea 'j '-i``� ,�j Sy, .; e i ` ..- 1.mo ::.;j. 111a'y � ts. t,7.�p gif;+?a, aF 5..•.c,.,&.''"• . * •' ' •• +ir e ,., rS t +„fie` <Zt , .?.-zivi z-3S_- i .w- v- x+. y{�. z Y :I �1 ; 7 5 1L. t :f ae N 4"',,�T._3 T y«tiL � .� y oZ. -r r r r• J +f^ � ' 'j iti ar:g €. �� L} .rla t4.- e 'T `.•�.w:`, -M S. �i ..l ;,k-1: Sh ' Z tx r•a a-1i 'F catyue -,:$c Ln4-:,,, 9 +^ G '4a's'-. i c-`r.0• t . h.i ..4r ', : c; t�a 1� + rs >\ +r . \'S4r. s �x,-� < i 0> ., ari .,4•iO-t.r•,,F,..,.•4..f',,-..--,..'''f.,.44*4.'.t4.V,.,xt3,-14-.,:,i, .'_rIs..w x i'k" -'a s... 'T. 21 3;•17 ..�..----r v ti `' - 5 a,.,.r-:l,<is ,.}tr:-+ tr,I f r•2 :.t •.,rs• fix. rtv 3 u 1�C cr x .. - 4 vi.�. t'7's. -.F •' n y 9•a1<v rt >.�4 f y. `.Za ,..•Iry t 1.Y3 1,5 ai t-.ft .x r4i 4.-4- tt - f.f~* i filaZ, d r}'sims1 J i.'-:r.7��Y 4. + ," —�''" i•','*:,,9a - S.nar.- C t 'S.w1 .•ri"" r ` t ._+! �rj3 7 5�i�w��-"c"�� " 3-> �F•t S T�;�tFc�f.i� k`� ,5, ..ilia -��yq rr'�T �y Z -F..`�W� k' `� r Q.ty rc :4',+"• f..Y« c'. 'Wai. • -�i.. : `ss :<. jz�r ,,''' •sn•3s h.IYy.`1+nZ y, .>�l"t- � '° ie ^. .`; a•�cy-�F r vl' 47,444`r'•''r�` YIc+: 0w ;•• '.5T% Fy 4.1 - 4 S > 0,off'-'Y , i .3.. - t gEse':5,4- 1 . .ra..?l_iy-r .. ;,-:1.,- .a -t<f. tX,,Y 5 4. 4 +�� ? •t• vi g",AZT_¢s Fwv>�w n„F s- -. a ->,•a.. - may' y.p" *r,r-i f., *'Y;�.- :•.'L.x, Sa75;f- 7�'-' 5�2 w 'tf�;,2y5-�f°'fritiCsTrfyc,Y'^�•2'ts' ,`sl'Yaa'j•.ts\"srst' Y+ .,-"£r T-}- L it 't7, cot., .v'3•.. -I,3st`�s4.�a�r4S za.`tom r " 1;.;V'.. A2`�Ti,r , '� , et.5 a �y ....n. < 1 �+ST . rsx 4".� t r ' r a r k�OC'.._: r• S, v,Z err or,sic°4.;,:.< r+.+ 2�1~ ; S r s 2� W e j = --X" e. e Ate-c-S,-,-,-, >r•�++ ;.i Y' w- •• • r-S. ,j• •I.I'S�i' t� '0 '? es �`{ 'vS' t: z�.a r.��t-?•i`�:`4.h� .Y'ir•a wU-,�. fc� � -`•'•r14 'Rr e; � _'^' ..: . `3,P.a?�- v +. 3 t k-y x s .P-f a ' 41- "r t-77; ,,W-4f t' ' �.% a "•'•aN7r yy y-.YS r� dF, tisL >a v- T r t•• t• r. �_ ti 4 i- y i'•,c4 tcr, � .S, ,a�SiC,tFS t a_;u .,t, •yl F. '.•,:. S.T�yC }e.+e ?c�' "C F y' t a+- ' �e u 71- t v?. '- -1- <.i <rL�,4 e • lika'5. '•a°`a ti y ic. f3 st-i ? - .� 7a. ,s7zix\, c,3^� � as ..:15A5:1„r-r.FA�• 4:,> ., ai.a .a...,4_'Cy 4i -,,, 9 t.,^ ?c. ' S ! ``��''a,�?� c•< Y`tiTiz�yrly `` n'5" �;` '5...- :r: r- r i ro •�' r[( 'I 'Rn.Y--14: 1�•at.4 Ka .1` '34' VA,:,w,.. .i 4^ ,Rs�'-51.4*„: 'Y+ti F'a�agir',TL -xµt'.�'i SJnj r•„`jri,-•j? 0 a hdA,.. j?Nr ,� .tom e*rsg:" S c4"� L'- J,}., t;Y,f•:.a�� W t l .-� 1.' �i�1�'Hf{f.I`.`�R�.,,+-§i'LL�. e:rx �%a. '=.'�-Y=t„��`ef.4 ?�,><'9��S•�9 S'�'�..a S ,' • •,r a to- v�4 � sa - - 21*- • •*:-'4A",--.11-444.:1r.:•::: 3y rN " ' 1. h . 4 s �" fi. �. is „ 1 `.Sr \ .. 5 4� yin. ,, ( 3r' r.:,-rx s} r'4)21,1l :i� " tiD aJ' ,4.y''' .,�err ri.lit{ qt ;r<', i 4''{ T s y . .,•-ek y.-�y;"Z lt.;EN / j`y)f Y 9 ' ''c i.�.�-.l fir a'•fin• 1 qyg-k- i -•,4 t -' ,r• k}y _� '`r•5 .• . a 4: :6 s, Ali 07. 1itio ;., `% e•}- , +t :+ • • 4•i�i;�c'q:-.1.'"Y- �4 � i. 7-4?-c•am"" s f,r;t.Fr' �i'•e •ti;r x"-..r.3•,l,-c N �� Y� •t ra V < 7` t 'c• :nt 1 :. J•- e,. .,,. t ..-fie.' `•• •. , '1f�. 'i+ -.;It..- yrG111 yTr'F• a -� s-?i r tt ..•le•ate+' 0,'•Ey T i- r;,' . ..._ H•�\- -a{r�sa '�/S�Y� J' S 5" y t ..is•+:"f s• S i• '+ ,_ ,�.+• .,4. : . . Gam •• d � . -i- a>yr• Tw..x • '. - ..—-• -1. i- `L., .ii:. tel: t•.. c.�_. •,.c ). V.•,f. • "''•Q 4t+`v +kt, a ? i �y.F,� tr ., ..-.71k,t :` ?;,,mac F \�• -.•`< Ir 1, t . 2), • �' ,✓•-•. 7,--, :-r � 5,,r I i r ''r- `c' ,r.'? � =}s:lf•� •._: <`�(- �t- t .. j7 of . •� -5.•,�-. 't e' !ci { !l_`.-ti.: -r.'.ti,x..n1� •i_ <.a !4t. ..•o:...rt..11i _o.• i..,.... _ t-.c. .. .t. 1.S J.�T St O • FEBRUARY 26, 1986 I AGNES MUNNINGS, GIVE MY SON DOUGLAS TYRONE WILLIAMS POWER OF ATTORNEY TO TRANSACT ALL BUSINESS AND PROCESSING OF ALL PAPERS IN MY CONCERN. AS OF THIS DAY FRIDAY FEBRUARY 26, 1988. • 017C- 1 r Notary rabic. State of F:3:.tfa y Ccn:misson Expires t,r,T 26, GNES MUNNINGS oun�aa iniu iroy lain•Intclance Inc.i a ) . `16)4'-' CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION TO: DAVID T. HARDEN, CITY MANAGER THRU: DIANE DOMINGUEZ, DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING FROM: PAT CAYCE, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER SUBJECT: MEETING OF JANUARY 17, 1995 FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE, 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE, TO THE LOCAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES. ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION: The action requested of the City Commission is that of approval on first reading of an ordinance designating a property as a local historic site. The property consists of a single family residence constructed in 1935 and located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue. The legal description of the property is Block 36, Lots 5 and 6 . BACKGROUN D: The building was constructed in 1935, the architect is unknown. The builder was Isaiah Bruin a well known contractor who built a variety of residential structures in the City during the 1920s and 1930s . The building is a good example of the Bungalow style of architecture which was popular throughout Delray from the 1920s until the advent of WWII . The building retains most of its original architecturally defining elements, including the multi-gabled roof, the prominent front porch and massive porch piers, most of the original multi-paned windows are existing. As the home of Susan Williams, one of the City' s early midwives, the house has considerable cultural significance. Mrs Williams 's original homesite was located at the southwest corner of S.W. 4th Street and S.W. 4th Avenue, after its demolition she moved to the subject property which was owned by her daughter Agnes Munnings and her husband Cleveland. Though she only resided in the house during the last four year of her life, it is the only remaining building in the City to physically link the social and cultural history of the pioneer midwives to the community. It is important to the identity of the neighborhood to recognize this site and to make the community aware of its existence. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. The request for designation is being made by Douglas T. Williams who has power attorney from the owner, Agnes Munnings . HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CONSIDERATION: The Historic Preservation Board formally reviewed the designation report at its meeting of November 2, 1994 and made positive findings to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , (2) (d) & (e) and and 4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) and (b) , Criteria for Designation of Historic Sites or Districts, and set a date for a Public Hearing to allow the public to comment on the designation. Pursuant to Section 4 . 5 . 1(C) Designation Procedures, the Public Hearing was held on December 7, 1994 . The Board voted 6-0 to recommend that the City Commission approve the ordinance designating the Susan Williams House as a Local Historic Site. RECOMMNEDED ACTION: By motion, approve on first reading the ordinance designating the Susan Williams House, 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue (Block 36, Lots 5 and 6 ) to the Local Register of Historic Places . Attachments : * Letter of approval for designation from Douglas T. Williams . * Power of Attorney from Agnes Munnings to Douglas T. Williams . * Designation report. * Historic Preservation Board Staff Report, December 7, 1994 . * LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , Criteria for Designation of Historic Sites . file/y:munnings , Zr DESIGNATION REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD - DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA I i t ♦ tri.-%S.. i-...... +t' '.~�'st r 'mac: "... v^r{ ✓'T fi'tk •.tt r's`�i s=:— y-2 .., t: s •3 r+ 's.i JA. � . Via. Q s_ ` wwJ to_3ri+s.Y+a�t+3•• 3+' — s_._.- .F •_i`� . 4C a}2'} h y ?s, 111 i-,.;z-_ 1 "_' may_.. "--- _ • �—a i •t'''3► 4. - fii 7- .. ��,fi�.�t'•`.•r' t �N• •`sa- _ 1 __ ;T1��J'!. ��.i�•'.k yt ,,av��-.�� YJtT u9•ct*--"s�uaa'_.`�..��,`rt.".' �� iJ r+`�^`.-��.ti+ a •:..:riv rr•1. ,.� i s.�.'.: sny::••J .•d i ='•T.V:k 't+:igr g 3f �:-5-','Fr... s i• -... 4, r i?• vS'i y 7-;s� [.�i:. , r� *----•r 7�ti�;�.o v, lft.-,..L t 47 ft -4ao .t„ - _,yi.s: 4 '� ;� ..�• .�++ �'. • 0 1SS "r:.+Kit"?_ 'F a w v.2r 1's 43 t•• a ;k - ' s? r'"-6. ,-7...s'�...- '•.- ..�;• a4i Ac is l�- • S s 4'`V� .• ,},-�•y T..�.iS.w �,t1•A•.ei''rY ..'-, ��.9 Y,;�3; ...*��.�:�j••- ��3YY T.'J • r1;�_L,y:�i{.�i-�ty � '� �j +i . . ' .-• s..,r. .(j•` f t / • .' ,... ar. r�� , ."''� `� �ti«x r--'i *•ct '-0 a '. . .''dal i ems.. a.n •`' .xs„ .';� ,:�1 Vir, /.`�Pyyt4 4e r . +rt J `^ry2tifJ•� 1' .r'�. �`Sn:y Jr. �.C"� _ .L ,yveG�i ��.,,� _[.!r5't # .Q 60. yil \3qx ,- `a d ap r '.yam?...4-. ;4 ; �.-,..._2!r k .-.o {i ~;y fr.•+. ay s ei.:Y'�Y• 4 i t "••''xja � - 5 ..� "y'' 4z --ht • .4 0 jj� Yam, f YZ.Cywhw-;:— THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE 30 N.W 3RD AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1935 Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd _Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION IV. HISTORICAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII. PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared October 1994 by Vera Farrington, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board Member and Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. • Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1935 Architect: Unknown Builder: Isaiah Bruin, originally from Quincy, Florida Present Owner: Douglas T. Williams, 118 N.W. 8th Avenue, Delray Beach FL 33444 . Present Use: Residential, single family Present Zoning: R-1A, Single Family Residential Legal Description: Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally Town of Linton Property Control Number: 12-43-46-16-01-036-0050 Classification for Designation: Architectural significance, good example of bungalow style. Cultural Significance, home of one of the first midwives in the community. ' Designation Report 30 K.W. 3rd Avenue Page 4 II . MAP J Q 1 " R.R. 2ND Sr.___ N.E. 2NC • - 5---: — I ,...< —r- -- IA --r — j --Tz r'11 LJ-_-.. _ CITY HALL FLK. 1ST ST. - N.E. 1 I :� _ L _ OLD 3 • 3 3 -c. SCHOOL z z z Immin. SQUARE -- �TT ..e.ri Mill TENNIS HI I 11 J fj ATLANTIC AVENUE I II POLICE SOUTH mil - , OEPARTIJENT - COUNTY - . ' _ QCOURT Q G-' .. HOUSE t R- ff, „_____,--- 0 ,.., 1 S k ^� 1ST ST. (I) S.E. 1ST 1 ,. 4,- loll j — _ N 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE 0"Y U L.(_fAY PU.O(.R `_ _. __._— ._--_I --- C.'..A. a:.( wt $)S1L)A -- Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 5 III . Architectural Information The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is a good example of the South Florida bungalow style as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . Many of these homes were built from pre-designed plans purchased from publications such as the Home Owners Service Institute catalog and the AIA sponsored Architects Small House Service Bureau, or from local lumber companies . But whether designed by an architect, or constructed by local builders from pre-designed plans, they all share the basic design elements of the bungalow. Walls : Horizontal wood or stucco exterior facing. Roof: Low pitched gable roof with the ridge either perpendicular or parallel to the street; often with multiple gables . If the primary ridge is perpendicular to the street, the front porch is usually roofed with a separate offset gable. Roofs often have exposed rafter tails . Porch: Porches are prominent. They are usually deep and extend the full width of the facade. The porch roof is supported by piers. The design of the pier supports is usually unique to the house and varies depending on the creativity of the builder. Windows : Double hung or casement, multi-paned and arranged for cross ventilation Plan: Usually rectangular and often modest in scale. The Williams House contains many of the classic bungalow features . There are two gables at right angles to the street and an opposing gable roof covering the front porch. The porch roof is supported by 2 traditional massive piers which are broken at the middle with a molded cap. Above the cap the piers taper gradually to the porch roof ' s supporting beam. Exposed rafters are visible throughout. Original casement windows with a 4 over 1 pane configurations are a feature of the front facade adjoining the porch. All of the original multi-paned windows are in place and most of the functioning wood shutters are existing. The house originally had wood siding and possibly a wood shingle trim. However, the facing has been covered with vinyl siding so it is not possible on visual inspection to determine what style of wood siding was used. The house has a composite shingle roof. The foundation is a combination of pier and cement block. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 6 IV. Historical Information The house is located on Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36 . This block was subdivided into 16 lots when the Town of Linton was platted in 1895 . In 1913 the block was replatted by the owners, J.H. Jackson and W.H. Brady; 39 smaller lots were created out of the original 16 . Lots 5 and 6, and most of the replatted lots were purchased by George H. Green and his wife and the balance were owned by W.H. Brady and his wife. By 1922 there were 14 structures on the block including the Primitive Baptist Church on the northeast corner, and two grocery stores fronting on W. Atlantic Avenue. When the Town of Linton was platted all of the streets had names, the change from names to numbers was adopted in 1924 . The streets which bounded Block 36 were as follows : on the east, N. Beatty Street (N.W. 3rd Avenue) ; on the west N. Larson Street (N.W. 4th Avenue) ; to the north, Miller Street (N.W. 1st Street) . Though the historic house was not owned by Susan Williams, she resided there during the last 4 years of her life. The property will be listed on the Local Register as the Susan Williams House. Susan Currie Williams was born in the Bahamas in 1870. In about 1898 she and her husband and their small daughter Agnes, boarded the Sir Charles Orr and set sail for their new life in the Town of Delray. Susan Williams had been trained as a midwife in the Bahamas and it is possible that she had been asked to come here by the Bahamian settlers who had established themselves in the community. Her services were soon in demand, both as a midwife and general nurse practitioner. The town did not have a resident doctor until J. R. Cason set up practice in 1905, ten years after the first settlers arrived. Medical facilities were available in West Palm Beach but one had to travel by train (Florida East Coast Railroad) to get there. A competent and caring midwife was essential to the community, as babies did not time their arrivals to conform to train schedules . Nurse "Susie" Williams delivered black and white babies alike and gave other medical attention as needed. As medical facilities became available and doctors moved to the City, Susan was called upon by the medical profession for home nursing. Tall, slender and imposing in her white uniform and dark cloak, she is remembered even today, by those who recall seeing her striding purposefully along with her black medical bag in hand. The original Williams homesite, now demolished, was located at the southwest corner of S .W. 4th Street and S .W. 4th Avenue. Susan William' s daughter, Agnes , married Grover Cleveland Munnings in 1924 . Mr and Mrs Munnings purchased Lots 5 & 6 and built the bungalow in 1935 . At the age of 80 Susan Williams suffered a stroke and moved 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue to be with her daughter and son-in-law. After a long and distinguished career in public service Susan Williams died 4 years later in 1954 ate the age of 84 . • • • Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 7 V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance The house at 30 N.W. 3rd . Avenue, also known as the Susan Williams House, is a good example of a modest residential bungalow as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . The house presents the major physical elements typical of bungalow construction. With the exception of the vinyl siding which has been installed over the original wood siding, most of the bungalow' s defining character remains in tact. Additionally, for the last 4 years of her life, the bungalow was the home of Susan Williams one of Delray Beach's first midwives. It should be noted that the original Williams homesite has been demolished, as have many significant buildings in the historic black community. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property and justification for designation. (2 ) "A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) "Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in the city, state, or national history ( for example, the homestead of a local founding family) . " The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue was the home of Susan Williams, one of the first midwives in the City,_ from 1950 until her death in 1954 . For 10 years after the first settlers arrived 1895 the community had no doctor, the nearest medical assistance was in West Palm Beach. The presence of a competent midwife was not only significant but essential to both the black and -white citizens of the community. Because the original Susan Williams homesite has been demolished, it is appropriate to recognize the house she occupied during the last years of her life. • Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 8 (3 ) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed--to h architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " This house is characteristic of the many modest bungalows built in the community during the 1920s and 30s . It is appropriate to offer recognition and some protection to this structure because many of the early bungalows have been demolished, or have been altered in such a way that the original style cannot be identified. (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " The Susan Williams house contains most of the distinguishing characteristics of the bungalow style. It has a double gabled roof with an opposing gable over the porch roof . Exposed rafter tails are used throughout the roof construction. The front porch is prominent and its roof is supported with massive piers . The plan of the house is rectangular and the multi-paned windows are massed for cross ventilation. 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria be met. 'Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 9 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Resourceful Rehab, Metropolitan Dade County, Division of Historic Preservation, 1987 City Building Cards Property Assessors Records, 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1926 & 1941. Oral History Documentation: Douglas Williams , Grandson Agnes Munnings, Daughter .�*r^•�/ -�i gym: ZxS:in-.. ."TN.,:k4` �• %a'...r,�','--"i. , s'?t'�'}.•tom <;r�'xr's�'•{.';kir .. MO H'',. 'u. '�= •• • Y• ;'$is'`'t •tier .,r-''•`-ti r.•-., . f 1�y-�"� �J^i'S ~ �' U'.. ,�r tr.y'a'u.+.4a •^�"�`ry T .. .�� .Y.'- � +, !' -,a vim':.' : i` R9,.,.;7,r.•101 h,.o: fir•+ ,. ______• .. .. • �i ,�;f ° 3 •at'Tt �Ztk� '",r,.^t�t `,t'4 ?ri": .,,,,.r.^. L+v ,-^z:•t' v�. .. rl y �. S�'' ! •�ib - k {•-e:^,ti{v� °ih'-$4 -tj r{ t re,•Z r�;.t.T;t:•'-r�ai7?w;t'O` + ' '�•`' . �" t tti•Y" ., , ;.. .rrny D r.»•r-• .ii�tit'< •.S••..i{..�v •.Z . y J rrr i V w} M, l,r' E iJ ,y..I. _• . 'L•34 i3 �, I 1 a.y j st r wt'" j it .+., ��g 'v.�s.n .r k -7�,r t'+ •;or...�— �t •- a.Zie- t": _.. ..y+•n• Y t.• 4,;«t{ �t.r. rY3 ,t v i •• .4.`'-*7 6 .. t r• i. ; •r4 rig_ i ,t1t� y +t u ;3 ff t �t. .✓ ).' r .'7• •.w.YrRy{%),•64...4 t v rt:.:.. - ,t +a a 17 1F}S �' •...'rf,i �F��t rt�- ,<. `K.r 1'7 ,y tom;i,. ! �fY� j '.,:15 r..:511i^S:_ f, • fz14"s-•«1,..R,5,. c'i...., •--+�'fc,,v —.- -_—__-'. -'-k #y9.,: it'•:J�•r�1__�`'v�r `71' C t -'''3'.`.,,ttg. '41 a, ,.e-4.mer'!t!;7` V;•; -`- h"' �•n•.`>xy r - a •+7 ��/y♦,•, ,c. k .i �+` -- ;. $K' r•-.-'r{— uN sr' z) a M4*,}. Y•74., 7f H.t.r✓ •trk" 6 �, rF.2.,;,r/� "`au.S�.;; >-,,• .i s.,' t _ a 4 - ; 4•' •d 4 tHIK.S?t, . rat •• t zVy�u�r��•l�'#a. p itr•taa/ `i -zs 4 ' f� ry'z y4t.. �.4:?'jr rj'•_*,y. 1te T 7.'. rFtr<.{* *•••••- V' rS-.-:•Y•v f. •`'s.r^ s r r�+ ��•-T .'va`7•i.y ••- • •",- V ��T • •t Scim'�; L l i w!t'�, _ ��.--F a sna,-.Y-...-Y. ,r..., ••.�- n-,-..-•• 74 •:ti2� p �v-1 4.0 t! 141 V:a--. • ,a •, `•.•.• ". .'.. meson 3'+.. s r: •`f4t4- t 4: •S' "tf j•`?>w yL'�`- 4 s•1-ti p` a ".�u . 'A':""' ":. }: -y F. r�Iz!T`r �'.�fii ;1 s' _ i `.. _r,. h t4-.x .� a v v• i.-aa"-u' :g." iir'''.i&yr,"?tii_-L.� .,.•�- > ?s -'' • •?, Y• i �`t��))r 1'iC + •,r. r'_l ,�+• ;3••{X :.K !- y" 7 } -1 + apt' 1 6'r C,Y: .t,{R^ ti•• le ••:',•r gyp �•'� 4it.6'r i}-a•. • k.'s ;••••�.' '- ••-1 .;47L..,:-iYivi;ge3'rtJ'y. sa -e43 !f= F•~KY� s: tS:•:.�r'; G am - 'i s¢ I t t:- ty ) 1Q�.1•t+ ..s 11.•Si ! t- a y��}+1 YY�.t� .:`K - a a:�i..r _. •1. ti 1 :r"�`Z1u�'' •y ''4• ..• '�+}C° S H ~{,�. r s}.•,.Y ,,.„. tc ,r^, .-,�t)•a7 ti '' • j#'� v sY t``'y e•rY''-'•,',h ..14-. /• S tiRJ`.w 1-... .- r .li` .;."s - �r��.• rat+. 5•} o•1• %• {,'Ve.-44.4 �•41r b a f j, Y 3 %a. $t rF 0r4h j•a e �""'+ > e.3> •fr• _i,• '`.-r. . t•?�;m�� a y.i s.,' _".X.r u - ..,,+�.,... jr^ _ >a 4y`s, r )� f'r..`g is' f{ . rsr Ar Yt i : �.:.. ..rs ? .+1� t,,.Y-� it Dt'` �-.e+ • r„aS'S'- " 1:4't 1- v�J7 ;yi y'c,,,•�- ,r,.y,.4""---'3'`.xtt t• c •yK,sP-�• 1r i ' �. t ! Y l a"'!j A , -a 7- -•s'?r„ 1's -r.� L S*Y r a.4. S --i• ty`•tyEO Y a.. • r -1,,,,,, yr. y r .wi'st1 .r .' 4.:v "t�'2 •}^,,a, .e.•> - _ X i,,_•••'��Ys�Se "�, 14.4 -....,, 7` .'i a' 1rs. t t.YFJ fSt.�•r'riL.•sF• c,•'1�••.-+ etSAi. e..,,, e L 4..;.'• _ '"- •r'. -al.I ••'r t. {o,,�.vt. $'t.F?rrr�r ,.. a�o e'i• s' -t••-'•o- .,._. <,, 1i-t-•e: s'r J'^' Sr .,+r y n -- i : 1 e 1.r r•' f'y'i - �,- r. f ^A. ar �''•a'l .ti 'x.: '� #�, t•r! nyi •?�'3•+a .rY`>°' : -,,""� •ryq"zy. � • ,.t,: t. r'*yr-a' ♦ % t �q. rt�rnt y `b-,.: �•,F 't' --"'•` 4 - r _ -. __.— • s _fta�ttt '•t•r't••.n»4-jrrrl.•• • a* S -N.07-i..r.eT,..a. ,.,y, ali 'y+ m K " _ .k Y vx t.„.-'. •-'r •.: 7 ,z,,rt:a�L-a.� 7*:4-"-s..-s 'z.�-'i• - 'S -ts._ -+-L"•� 1 r-.1• `•ram.? 1. ,;f7r,,:Jf. .`1'.t -yt <'yw `s _ `7f :. 1.�y .rse �' ..,fie r� C •G 1 "�.r •i• +a st �` ` 4^t'el _ 3 '0---i'i.r..-r>'•n .tnf >�. : .1._erl. fi r- .z"S-r'�• w`.rL F+� i r••a•L {*4+;:t`-•v . c<';z°S .r ? 5.-..s ;-, --s -r. �'• a. 3 ,{t S"!' -- t y -.. : Fy' i S ;.y .' *.' .r :fit. t..•+ t- As a it - `^t fC"t aC A r L•raz�,..r4' �. r x^ r .a, ...ca `sya ij •e`4e ,-is fir. ...•••rPi• • X•reiy-*�+...#i';,;t'•`{. - r 7i ;F �+ `.' ''�••`a'a-2' 7'' +.3'r`s^c•r ••!!. y r: e `eLsYS i' ,�' •ss a- ,•a,! ;•-•r..-••r� -„- t c :.rt+p § •.t `�se•+�kti t e"�'•.,j }. '• •'fir r'l•L'1 ry r .'•t, s p k'S'� ,ts r,.s<W� �,Y „r g L'S •:'ate t -. . _ t 'S? -t. Irr.,?va.g s rr ,. ....,--z rt, r _ter- •air'"L �-•` 4 'z fir. ;3.! r.. •Q •Yt cy{,� .,--. y `•'� � a.t, f t lyl. cz ter c r "f y}' ,. 'fix 1s i• • -r.s t-! ♦ ,.i F tii_�`•iC+� a � G,E:}3 r_r�� 1�.'' 'S xth K. :w.. ..� • s'i.-� 7:2 • . '3 t .• `. •A:__ t+° ,y�'y '1<`q� Y t•'s as- - ..�. ' r �-•r �',..'•T 1.: LL Y• .._ _ _`'MT, �f'••ri '�•i t•.ri. r.a xe ��•� ) < 3$eY r -xik�" U Xr . .. •x i .�r"'.- t-`-' ...' k i r• }y•� > t y r " `' � r t. .`. t mil. {;� ti ,g" -•.l „� i'1.i r �� .. . e'- - 1'--t i5*, rJF K r s • ,� . .• r,:-d•.7•? y k''"f c. s 1 r } ) Rom.. ..i xr ars •r.• ', w• r`4 ^..Kr •i•',.7 i•• Y 1• r,. ,, .4, ai- a aa.-.. .�r em s.._ �� s !' - �•a.f. �. • - `- �yydyg3)1 �,�sttt j ydS..' t y V. s rY Y iS 7 •',• Af•�.e `�ZS ter J+� .. ',. .y,+•:9 4Y.^,yo j y r`i t ,• �,• s.:-.y: • rt..ay y . '2 }: r `'r t r' Y r+ -C `.:, ;% o a,t•"kt 3 y +r-z ,.r Z of " `'" L.j @X •t•, tJ. ;;7;?A l t.",7»•^i w 4t•rs.Mg-.4 ;- •.+.,. L! '�ti j. is j • y+ .. }'S' s-+ , f'. :}.. 'it.13J...4:4,+ , y? .M o- r•-y. ':�• :- .. •}- ^µ,.3n s •S'•'" ••1al�Cy.y. .- •,� .tt et,,,4.+,Y:;,ti<t�?`, i ` r ; )A-,.-..h}.. :r':•o?'-•e- 1.:w,•-:.._....4. 1`f..,r;Y..i.'..'-" �. '�,,, ,_.>•_• 0 ` • ;tom. • 'fii�x'1ury f'5 S[ G-_ 3 it cr s -rZ�'.s� \, \ Tr y3..E . ', t,.4%-a r S .,t F- K3+• .+ .•yv tE i h "4:1 t:.?=•. '-. 1 i r} ^3.r , y,4.., . `7 ‘r•'•tr 'f•z ., -r ♦^T..a-•a -f , :t 41 1 r r {*: {r 1 ..t .t'. V> by r 7 t' - \ *.. . -,>- . y ry lt_N 1 h•Z. '1 is x 3 s A- -. '• . j,,K js'.,Z,. K-'�ry, s ix'4 1.Oe -t+ ,:"fit 3 Z i I e "'++': ;•,- ] e`^.. >,w '="1 „E.t z t:z o -aT ,,1" •e .a. '1i.• ::Tn••- 'x�• x; .'.I,s-..._.•r i.V'.'-,..:„'.1'..w.:..-l, S..7:� r Ttl'si '�', t1E.'SP.� „:' x�J'•••,,Kk-} max.. } ..� .rT-�s. y . r; .-t x4.•:_: w t ,.q=m�i�" `-t "'-"''S•i;• 'E +,X++"'S'1'S4y"z'f+' +�3'.'..e •s ts"...s• t� .,__•.,�v'� -i\ 't r �s �.-,•�.. s _ r"'s'�t �'' -•-�f7�- f • r .+ 1 <,�„�,'S_, T.,� y 2,t. N=\i 1"''` •„..,t`�w'4✓x r C `.E'r as y'a TYri -..r •>>.4 .. :ft"'",,',, .7,,•? a!yyr�Y�„b t cI-. .• N C» ♦., , ,7 y.".,.., LYy'fl-'..a 1.f �iRic'tL--- ' •..r.,: is -- -•[r.-.. .+'r' . Pit 7 $•~a-Y t• N.', yj - e.Y.-r t '-.•� ., .u-i' S `t✓ t ylyy�i s dLf ='l."t ..•a •,os r ^,> may' t,'"'41, '` e m>:'�.ha1x.-V K+>r„<+ti"r 'fit _ t . yy f i v L R ,,f ..• '^L'^E f t f. ti. -A. ."'" 1.'1".,1f•^-.t r-.�,ry J =a. 41;: ~ LAM rt Yt��gY..' o.♦! -. r c .. 1, '.rl}t-Y } r.f.-t L 1...i1/ i ).i;,M ^^ 'n t r,[` ••S •., v� K iiE.r. rep ... y $ ,'f .: zr '+ T+t.� Mtn 1.. y'tea ..r s t- < ,'s•..t S,1�h��hA'L �'•a 4 pT,�+�'•.4✓t f r 7 ti+�.,s� a>y ci _ � �� ,i. T � c3iw .)y'n c a4 4 p' 7itfi 1l•t' Y_' V.Yy;"...�7 -J" .i• 7 y ..41 .. f.'�a. . i 7X 7i 'i s �.h• • Sl � -C> rc'"`' .r' `2•i�•' '^�: S.• , +�.. 4`.4. 4 3 7•• a�:•• �ti. r fa ts,? _' "-�.}" ."s Ac,,, F d M a•s' z "`. f'sg4'v f°y.rS".T+. ✓)„1.: s+:*'.». .E.r3, �i2""r',♦t '" c ;.1 r ..w� ^-f `'-ss`F7 .A'1t•4s;'`.. �" ilk•' ys�- '.. f4"--6'"Vy i '•s•-' .-r.Ei:.-r.�''+�A+. F�'.1' ikrc a--ffyi. �a.f:? -,- - • -t j ;,r ..ys'�Af- +,•n�Fra-,\,fi ". 4J Y• ^I2� .Z.•\J.f tat► 1 >�. Z Y.(•l L � wT f J• f � - -�-"\1 �P.\ •..t' �� x .r\ ,.tx `' �• x"' .ii 'at �; ' �a-.:- i. - x '-x rr."tr a W 'a � ;y�,A>�.(+-r♦- C -s t,.. t� �� r t� �� -.a.^`J.� a.}'i't' . y-i�::..• �' It s7`S.'-��y, yy„-�''�,�\.".v�S� .i".-�,`+{'.• +- .f i.s.x .A. fit,y?.,y- `i :RSA.. s ,.'=a``;'i er,;�+. .}.�'Fy,}+ �'dt- r `Y tf •j .� 3, I.N.•i Y,y..•vE} i� - . .'} _. l ...FF r L ,_,� tlS PYL...k .r<�+•.!>",r .+fK. ".t• ",7 �Me- '-- ��ariU "' ,r - teals st , �,.,4E a•e y •ea?t:..si a. '' r.; ' �R,O',« t• S'y3-V } ,:: S Y wax S ?'Vti.Aw 'w.w.� -rs+y S .'r•°z aL j'.c•;a'? s-s .0"``• i'i y'•.t oab*ugh.',.. 1f z , �'3.r' s - - - ya 'i ' )..„..,„x+'f- t let�,Y`r rs •�i;x* l / fi..gdG a,. E S >t 't .. <r`�ss -x.r of r ?rp7+F i.,'.�, �irc�.r.�.yl,. {''c`t, i n r.„...a�+ .,.1 �� 7 x:*a." +.;7 .. aF:ti♦ 'mot e r s! n „ �iiY 14F•1.. E-�'fi{ i os ".ra.a. x ,aa->.t':.„. -r, -, _ '„u. t ;9lAi . t y can si: ..P t�^n+'y��xY,t',` ),,-Y...C,!21,{S��r�'r't',�Pa,t �+R�+r�:�l.} 1 4a"'0a..T rd• +r„ .< �-S may}. YSI;i,•,r 7Si •-t ty(f i•.•-....4,• l:eS'ti�''''r�. Y.fL'>WSr-s+,C^end ,d e73X{-i:�.ati'+l'"-Yethu' *F!�'S�s',is .3 .x•-i..e;a.- 3 .:" :}_ .Y.+:5��.'?r4a-,i-iz,- ..n ♦ ri (a '0.f2 •4, s t'.s' �^'-'y..•_ £"iy 't• ir;`' +��a:ti A• rt\-was S+" 'ist--#: _. 1. fi/►'" .. y. ?..s,-4 Y`,`7-- ft.Y` • a.a•� 'ae ..k a''`�1'i' y.""...n's Al: i r+t.. '°' �.,. q , r. ! tz, •y1.t-sr, ..sue- w \ I'•• i,•.� n]'t Y.=. s�t• r'e" t�- ; d t7•.- d _ '<'ST it _ „�} -4 !y E Z to c}nyL's..; '� :• HCYs, .. :F'. .f, f3 Pr.•..t\-•-'• y,.D-S �• W \ >ssx,s J fit'" i. 0 -_�•s� + �)-r 4' • ,'rr ", K �`-' Sri Yre ' 't.y.F',1f4 .♦--4?`rA t »f.?,: RS1F,�,4>e {'i�e+,ix..T.^t'•i - s •, �l rY V-4' - a='rt t�-x •s{M4 t.7 .. w/ ♦.+77�7'. t i y L ` �4 r^ '�" 1/4,z f a•tE7:,la`a S.�' ! o� •`mot 's dt ..,3� ---• r v;�"3•d ":- •1S> ?z. } �t .t! 25 ,• : �-t r' �,�s �w`:ia '��^� „]�r .-y'ta�'•ra-'.��y'�lu� l r s �j3 J,s3 _i s-..+ti,r j Y- r ''Y '. .r,E� x1 y! ',. y!y 1 '� 33 y ,1:::•! .:' .,Sf F4*f Y t �y,N ; 5;'c. �•i..i �,.Z ht i :t c. •airc. :cC3�1i;-al xjl 7 -. r.tv. ) t3 .•tom' 4, z i y.3:�y> - 'G 'fd x'o Li s;•"ti#' f a A a\+►��L 1-t-- :'.,^_ • .«>.,,L\x 4r.� �11':a[ :! �. tom. nA ♦ t't w. . h.,, s ,c-tr ey'S:•,a + r.y y,..-,y 4 f. ^` i � -. -..�'...� 1, ,.. +'s. ? i' x. ?,1::P \E^• ] r 'T Y3' ; I .1. // y, i:\ xt` ♦T 'a'^S'7'_ i1tti,` z [J..ilz +• c� t k 'Nf '``�. e3 .�S er+ .Y : _11 i'�' I••,. ti J.'•S.V C �T- .r aT:.,rst•`\ �',� ,� ?�'ti F �• 4ti \7 t 1 st•�fif • d IOW;`\!4. • • -• AV • 3z0E4t;: .t'. .."t_, a.. Y,�=`:s2 • ._....---.... t f -.'1' ......17'4r4•;4.4}.-tt#S,-ztlaysw-11-sV-4,-,„-e-.&,,i:--747aw.11_,-, i-, ji,5 •-••:-'1,--•'',ZF* 'RA. 1:P::a'•-k7:34igg.1491;4011•dr7.* '''.• • :;1'-,...S.h,3.:r ; H tt�Ss-s t eri i a�',• 7i 4y .. _. ( '' . ',(.�i.11ryr.'Y-:.rsJ:%,`t•14rK+ y1.','+1',.:G'�iZih 1 i�"ryj -_ • r. i,(,'r• • t.Y6'R �+E",•l1 .I.45 .-4.! .'t,j�hb ••.-7!-4.1,„: t Si • ' _-_-. .- i. ..,y . Piy✓t ;4LS`•3 - • - - 1146 ...Y',i1%*(SCy.y �gu1•y�}j` L z.,{-- +--- - - - 1 k.11 '.?yam.:., per,-y��.y • 'T+�i��1{.-S'4 J�Se+rFL. ��,F' J -r..gt.( ,, ✓1.. ,.t� / Kr •'tom aQ• „'f •• +�pr��._.+�+.y 6a•�r t"r ^'�"1�r�a', � i--=�. �T1ib}. 4�G? `�• •t. r;1t'-� 1} y •7''`•�.. • .c„I� ` C l- t. ,i. ,,+., J �+.'mil. ,•,' *trJ �Z.' YG T(' r ' 2t�/ • N A.. Sr. f�:lc+ ✓, d'?`+�fEL '�';en...d' {. s t:+Cti. • a . .?•Y.tt _y?x?: Av. �)1. r.�..�4, .�.. .,..,, „�. ...a Wit,iii;2T: 4. .PKS:Mv.%:24.A7.fi sVv:....,• ✓ti a�: • ,c,•*.'". .,",ccS3 ,..* '.-.r' rt tircf +r'�ti•S. ' i r ,�sJ:+•� 4i �4., A.a.q•. i4i .:,.. +7:• r. a r..'li..W.-f .0. s. a+F�l pr •t • 4•.4.L /L .4.!' *.i i • T t n rr2 a\ i \+ 'ti A •e o h �v,.,w+-a• �t ��,�+- y. ! �✓ K t+� �x +14, c .�y+. •r'�!. a ✓ r .l s•. tr i•w{ t D•1.' .rV i'1}r S�ot� ) ,ti-X-04'-. ht+,. <;*-• "r ,' ','N. 61- iy '. ya..t,- ,ji.�' i RT'�`l �",�"3!ti J^'1Y c s*:--s'. •• ` •tIJ '' r. ��L ..:.'. i� �i.aY't. r.f+^n •)? j't -%-v: r s 5.N r`---...a-K .•;t,, .••,rt. ...'Y • a rt .- yt r X0 t\? y " 'n;4.. 'd " r f at-<• �n. r i r} ufii..! •.+›' 1" Y ''.-'ii .isa': `t`A• • k. ti r, -µme ftt ,J]y f i,r'r rtr J p'f, � t. T - .. 4 �f.Jl �� +li*'5A1- •T �K .,e., Lit " .+ i 3 -L.. L,t V c • t� t'J l.w- � +.S �.,v .lei. y'tr ++4 J.^'I •1 .+\, � { .4=3,z w..i.r3...� v rk .`t.� '2'3�.: `��3. '."''�Ei+t yT�S'�+'s�'y4 'T''!' i-�""ai'.ra :�';°.'� 3':'!�.•r'i-�,'z e„i,r r r�TJ4 Y ��-p �lE�.�A�lC az T st at +'47�,i: _r v71.w - !-5..s s • {,4! •' �-A�,:e!, .. •c Cl^ -Z' �4 b 9r.+ :•• c.+ - 'w u w �.. ins .S c a++��'�'�''�"" 'h`/`v n-a r. . sYi� '{- fj !,s rtj.X'-•e' -• '�* w.,.► '0. 'i��,yy�CCCtt??�>�� rS1:r,�f+. '�`� .rxa�-�'"� .�i,.""5,:;r. `�g�.,d.'i�t- ^e•t. aY r e �2! �.'rw� 4};✓ i� s". i, y , �r tze + �+�, t• *'•t r.-. ^ Z,L °+r.+ tiei s -",4:0-Z. r a4sY 4'+t2:Nc-A.ur i:1=5n "' yy�{ 1 ; .4 to } 7 w4: '.Sx.Y S j ..:ct''2 n � i...t . ice- l-'.i.7�f a w �:�r"" t. c �-rw sue` t•^sc i-�*,•�`:S v�.l s ?, w A .t alas- ': 11.,,,�k;f, A�" .�_ •-3—4:;Age-. £=ti • •µ14 s�r"4,.7-- i y. 5��na.. �. r'a_3 a _..__r 'tea r tiy�K" x.= 3r:. r it , tr, c '`i �+. -A. i' .• srX• i 'a t'i� .i T •.�: {�Y 34,• •ts.� i s �, ter, f l 3} ., ... :M r'eYi- ',s �.''aw w_ 1,,, wit 441-: yr % :,-5 . Qt �: f r� {6 �d. `� ` ue✓ I.`W aii-- t d 1'J.N C � C Vr ti , ' ; SL v.k 3. • ".. f .. Rom'. :n K.. 'y 0. , ' 7 '� ` ` - , 4 •_ �tN. t " ..c: . xw ,frl^ ._,t.�.,,e`ls € .y:s ao-w -��,: R, Y.t.: e41' t; jeg- t :• y sAy., 4 T Arekoa Pme T.,. t. :` eiio °/PI; ^ • * e 4, F . LM `'r :.- { k _ 3 ": t PY t. �F sawc • c A + ' .m .. mt z... e ''m"r.e � k�•' . rtr if = ;�SZ P-. �a� �a xr _ . A i` . ` "'C 2rtt •t K 3i£r Z -tt: u;: '> .L +"'� i t+ZI., `ttt.f F?=. 0 t t a.y ?r�1r,4yt 2 -='�'Er' 7 +; • �- 3Y4_- r er:iyt 'F^ 1 r_72�. s ' :9O .- . x :t. - Je.'e a-e . �zaz141. i,��'!ls ;^-"1C - "7- -:yw raeaTfiy !sx •vh + ✓n� 1� e �v*s � I s' t� W s = ,-.xS.x4:4•1.q}f . �. c !9ti.'a ti I + f„�..wr,W..M .�1-s•. �. \�trw "" r4• 4,�.. Y�. r•_� :-.,vt- 7*.+7,rrti::r.:&sx%oe�� }�f°9�n' t '- 1 +I Gof t Y.il; et i*. t f`Qt.^ r .ia s M-t}&tic lY� tY- ' a 4�.ArstZ% raY` ,' *Wr'...i t �; ...'5; W t.ai![W y�1y �Y{,i �.''-^aarlA3t:L:S2" � s Wel rk �, �"�'4iL':�4f� 4sr••� + f '4`t ^ 1.,"► =(`Ly.4�V��^• ��.[ �•r1 ye! y�f� r 3 +t„ 4a-Y i042 iri•Cii."` Sr.Ent " rt- T"f aittef� 4 < iX:- Irv; �Pk !�. W' ws, y{y4 < � }C �'�/. J,(J;a+ '.;.ca. ' :ye ' •?.hJi", r:r+" >.:Y +YS .r�s�dr".4 . • ?' fS3W ;0. 6Za . 7 "4 to4rt y[-0J%je TVki,. 4yF .✓ + ,N,` 11+� _z; � �4;;.t):4:, ' 11.. . %. _ : r41`,,5.. ' : �t:b � . 2� ' _ „,4-.1,14 4.-t,y r ��9ci " 821XA�—*t. ,,r- Aw p ,-. :a^1�.?: ps,�ss., Ne7 a . p,..—S1f ,triT�t 7 �a%,.4.4 . .71,*�x ' .,, gt .,,,,, - .tvra,° s L3a •+} .tyS ri9' ► 1 5�' y- r- e4. s --#. oae. "' t,,,.,„.. ► -� ° wI-x'' c .. r ✓r ea;as -.1" � 44 rr% ' s,.. .` .`t-efi'V `zza.�-r,<z} }r "' ' st ' 4 r1^ r * _ 1 `n s� ar t � i .�. ^) } :te. �. 1s� ` t : . t5t°'a .f3.+ .�srrEx‘ilt t"' ,C . rIl- - • w e i � as x5• t : • t4. , , *?sAna ` '="� � P X ' rs0: i ?-1,.31 ,. •y*?'�, a .r3 ,4- ,4t �e I ', ; )�s � 4y-Pt`3t, .c. �*' ' •fW fg"--;-' 1 x j � - e} , ' "'41t K rir • ; "j .�Z 7 §nTM� yer3 Yam• Ter.'"- c. : .. + * , ""? 7,4, - 7y � { `yyet,L .4 4s • t �ilK.-f, ':T ' },T' g ,, -. ! i Kk -..+`y ' a , y . s r}r , ,i ." •?•:",0 ep• � , ' ' 0. �y.'t. 1 .,.- ' Lst'1 k'ua � # 1 7 '3 # 3m3 s ta �a ;a 4 '.k 4 . x�C , - - ,,,...,.......„ r .a.- To , . ii, .7.1,;%.,,.0...v..0.. ,.. . • . .--:r.:17 -,•10,Z-e , - ,;(4`..- • .:=1.1%..—4:-4.—.1M.**4 74 .. r`i. t ! �.. +. ...s-.+.•-, ..a �••t;lP•;tcr}-Tx^t r• A' S ' .� =Via. s �`�D •a..'. •. aX. .31, ` 4- -4 � 1,. 3.'11.,``- -`s 5...14.0far.r..'i--.. xsly1Arols. r • • s. :: r. 44.3%.$WV,..- 7— ,,,, •-r .5... q, . ...,,,x! v.,: -0,„a„.,, tv„....t.- .we..1•14-tv, ,1,..f. 1,-... Ly F . :Y" ' str,V-1, . ..____,,,. rv-7---.' I v..... ,i_________ . , ,.,..,,,,..,, 4.,,,r.z.__a_ai f •‘01.'%; ••-r. flw.*-6; •• ...:::r-r-ii'--.:-.4•ARAtir ,S t :� L ! r-„ • may, ., f •°t j �� :-4` ,-. .`t� u`+}}� tt-' 7? +2' Y x=y -'1 nAtrr, �w L `.,V.-v'1r iR .s. ' • }ty,�t�M� • x' � '� 4��'� f� �'�.Jy. 1� • ..� 'y.r�,Y i,�.��pyY�S' �i,ti�""'�!�'M�y Y,•�S�ry~'� '•y tJ• e:K.• fit.;.�c: ,'+ .i'' 'tjY r ' r• " -r4"tt..• •i Y i� t,• •"t4P.."-r x' 1 4. X< > �`• r. !.Q.,;J ,..YL'k4: �:..r3r_Trs 'r�,.�+'�<L{rT tje,,t(► :. �1t-i +:.i}l to .1.1 _. ..t-.:YE ft, i'.t.:t '4 ; l..t::n..t,:,,. 1. - .s!' ,.t 't 5 ..yr`"- :44. :.r'� a-. a,"c`.`1yr ,4{_ . ,I, ` {I t` ..')...s+• :It sr;4 . ... :a -w }c,- --c'�Y':.,4�••. c.,t.. ! •O. 1,.. b`!.•..'. ..•ir. ..,.4.N _6.. .t...._. v..: .-.t. 1'I-,.�.1.2V_3at I — 2ND ST N.E. 2NC . i w.. ..........• I I 1 N r W r O Z a 3 W Z CITY > f HALL Q — IN.E. 1ST ST N Yi. ST.._.. 1ST Zg MEMz OLD 3 3 3 -:: SCHOOL - — z Z Z SQUARE IMMOIi TEN N:S III11HIW[HI STADIULI I ATLANTIC AVENUE t UMPOLICE SOUTH HII1= ` DEPARTI.ZENT • COUNTY Y COURT < 4....._ HOUSE ' •P----Ca _, 4! N J1 1 1ST ST. (V) S.E. 1ST s"` • < < IIIII H --r M o s �y ��Vi ��_ i —. — F-- VI vi i v _` — - - -- --F....a% N 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE PtAHN04G DEP ARTY F.N7 6Tf OF DELRAY BEACH. A. DtCYTAC BASE tuP .S rS it4 -- fa_ .�. .t-.,,a 1«.+ci,-xw r .s- ��^_ r5�..sr.�x-ni...,•_asGrz+e.r. Kl"a2f_ _ - •.x.Ytt`�, _n +ta_ur.-.-.r-�r,�—.xa..��r -a2 ,wr -- .5. MEMORANDUM TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS FROM: CITY MANAGER( SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # /O. B• - MEETING OF FEBRUARY 7 . 1995 SECOND READING AND PUBLIC HEARING FOR ORDINANCE NO. 8-95 DESIGNATION OF SOLOMON DAVID SPADY HOUSE AS LOCAL HISTORIC SITE DATE: FEBRUARY 1, 1995 This is second reading and public hearing for Ordinance No. 8-95 which designates the Solomon David Spady House located at 170 N.W. 5th Avenue as a local historic site and adds it to the Local Register of Historic Places. The property consists of a single family home which was constructed in 1926 and remains a good example of the Mission Revival style of architecture as built in Delray Beach in the 1920s. The house is associated with Delray' s most prominent black educator and community leader from 1923 to 1956, Solomon David Spady, and is an important landmark to the identity of the community. The Historic Preservation Board conducted a public hearing on this matter on December 7, 1994, at which time the Board voted 6 to 0 to recommend the designation of the Solomon David Spady House as a local historic site. At first reading on January 17, 1995, the Commission passed the ordinance by unanimous vote. Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 8-95 on second and final reading. 411/1 ref:agmemol7 MEMORANDUM TO: Historic Preservation Board DATE: October 18, 1994 Delray Beach FROM: Douglas T. Williams RE: Historic Designation of the Munnings House I do feel that the Munnings house on northwest third avenue meets the requirements to be designated an Historical Site. The American Bungalow meets the design guidelines that are set forth by the city. The history of the house (which, at one time, was the home of the city's only mid-wife) is certainly noteworthy. I have been a resident of Delray Beach for most of my life and have experienced and been a part of the many changes that have occurred. I do realize the importance of preserving the rich, cultural, historical heritage in all sectors of the city. I am, therefore asking that the Historical Preservation Board present this house, which is located 30 N.W. 3 Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida, to the city commission for consideration of being designated to the Local Register as an historic site. • i AR-i -199 9 _ irr 9:a-0l _ 1 0�. n O RAF. • ::tea i- a* t-`= { 8 i s E I g $ Gi mia ORDINANCE NO. 9-95 (`‘) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, DESIGNATING THE SUSAN WILLIAMS 11 HOUSE, LOCATED AT 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AS A LOCAL HISTORIC SITE; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, 1994" TO SHOW THE HISTORIC DESIGNATION IN AN OVERLAY MANNER; PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Section 4 . 5 . 1 of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach provides for the designation and protection of historic sites; and WHEREAS, Douglas T. Williams , as duly authorized agent, has nominated the property described herein to be designated as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, a designation repori: was prepared concerning the designation of the property located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue; to the Local Register of Historic Places; and V1 WHEREAS , the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, on December 7 , 1994 , the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach recommended that the property described herein be designated a local historic site; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property described herein as a local historic site . NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE �� CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1 , That the following described property in the City of Delray Beach, Florida, is hereby designated as a local historic site in accordance with and under the provisions of Section 4 . 5 . 1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to-wit: The Susan Williams House, located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida; more particularly described as follows : • • t I Lots 5 and 6 , REVISED PLAT OF BLOCK 36 , TOWN OF DELRAY, as recorded in Plat Book 5 at Page 191 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Section 2 . That the Planning Director of said City shall, upon the effective date of this ordinance, amend the Zoning Map of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to show the historic designation, in an overlay manner. Section 3 . That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be, and the same are hereby repealed. Section 4 . That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid. Section 5 . That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon _passage on second and final reading. PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final reading on this the 7th day of February , 1995 . 4// 10' M A Y ATTEST: // 17)(iP .1462 1*-- City C erk First Reading January 17 , 1995 Second Reading February 7 , 1995 - 2 - Ord. No. 9-95 1 ' 1f 47 _.'''-'t 6„ ice^ ? II . MAP 11( II F:.� 2Np S T.—1 `�._� N.E 2NC i I rLti Z 14 - y11 ecc Z rry — 3 i c1TY � 1 HALL > L , N ir' 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST '[, 1_ I 3 . OlD 3. 3 3 1 SCNC-SL [z: ,z.—. i . _ r TEN N13 i I STADIUM ATLANTIC AVENUE f I I 11 POLICE SDUTH I 111' DEPARTMENT COUNTY i . $ ,c .( COURT < < HOUSE o Z . I z N - n 3 S'ti IS ST. �/) S.E. 1ST :! ' L " 3 N 1.`"" 30 N,W. 3RD AVENUE ..J.4•7+c ov LI TU CM 01r or DC-RA Y suot,it -- O,='At VS(W. SYS7LH-- J ORB 8j 64 ? I_ 990 DOROTHY f• H. WIL 1ENf CLERK CR _C+ i ie-; Fi CERTIFICATION I, ALISON MacGREGOR HARTY, City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, do hereby certify that the above and foregoing is a true and correct copy of Ordinance No. 9-95 which was passed by the Commission on February 7, 1995. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and the official seal of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, on this the 6th day of March, 1995. ad � 1 )616 kt� /`k- V Alison MacGregor Har t City Clerk City of Delray Beach J, 1' �r ;. •'gig y a D zia JA> y y fi� E A i ; '1^13'.' ,:' li A T: i ... ,3 1,i,„;/, - ,;„. . l `3 Pam' ".24tt 4 f r • MEMORANDUM DATE : JANUARY 3 , 1995 • TO: RICHARD BAUER, CODE ENFORCEMENT 'ADMINISTRATOR q) q:;Q\Nts- I\ THRU: DIANEE DOMINGUEZ , PLAN.;I G DIRECTOR FROM: PAT CAYCE, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER SUBJECT: NON-COMPLIANCE OF CODE VIOLATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE LOCATED AT 30 N .W. 3RD AVENUE The subject property was officially nominated to the Local Register of Historic Places by the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) at a public hearing held on December 7 , 1994 . The first reading of the designating ordinance will be heard by the City Commission at its meeting of January 17 , 1995 . Section 4 . 5 . 1 (C) ( 5 ) of the LDR' s states that once officially nominated to the register, no building permits may be issued until the City Commission approves or denies the designating ordinance. The purpose and intent of this delay is to prevent demolition or inappropriate exterior alterations to a property which is nominated to the local register. After reading the code violation notice sent to the property owner, I note that the majority of the infractions deal with interior work which would not be reviewed by the HPB and would not require a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) if the property were already listed on the Local Register. Therefore, it seems to me perfectly in order to allow the building permits to be issued and require the owner to comply with the interior portion of the violations as soon as possible . In order to conform to the purpose aiId intent Section 4 . 5 . 1 (C) ( 5 ) with respect to the issuance of building permits , it will be necessary to defer the repair of the exterior walls and siding, roof and soffits, etc. until the City Commission has approved or denied the property' s listing on the historic register. Once the building is listed, approval for the exterior renovations and alterations will be reviewed by the HPB through the COA review process and exterior repairs can begin immediately. c : Steven Taylor, Planner Vera Farrington, HPB Member CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH 100 NW FIRST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH , FLORIDA 33444 (407 ) 243- 7213 NOTICE OF HEARING TO DETERMINE NONCOMPLIANCE PERIOD AND FINE AMOUNT IN THE MATTER OF : MUNNINGS AGNES CEB CASE NO . 93- 10156 335 SW 4TH AVE DATE : 11/28/94 DELRAY BEACH , FL 334442665 On 10/11/94 , after a hearing before the Code Enforcement Board , an Order was issued to you which required compliance with cer- tain provision (s ) of the Code of Ordinances and/or Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach by a certain date . The Order indicated that a fine could be imposed in the event of noncompliance . The Code Enforcement Board was recently informed that you have not fully commplied with the aforementioned Order and has scheduled a hearing for Tuesday , JANUARY 10, 1995 , at 1 : 30 P.M. , at Commission Chambers , at the above address , to determine the number of days of noncompliance and the amount of fine . Although a hearing is not necessary to impose fines , our practice is to schedule and hold such hearings so that you have the opportunity to present arguments and/or evidence on your behalf . We encourage you to attend this hearing . Please contact us at the above phone number if you need assistance . If you decide to appeal the Board ' s decision to a court of competent jurisdiction , you will need a record of the proceedings . For this purpose , you may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceed- ings is made , which record includes the testimony and the evidence upon ' which the appeal is to be based . The City does not provide such a record or transcription . BY : N. SMITH Norma Smith , Code Enforcement Board Clerk -.�"-.e..�...:�.,a.�.,t- ......aw�sss�e .,,.wa_._:r�ra i±: ,:.nr^-,..� r,.3.-.. .,.]�t"u .:_fr`•."may, '... Sxx.Sa,w, s�.+.crKi�.9"�' ,,r7Ar,! •(, ,i • • % CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH ' 100 NW FIRST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH , FLORIDA 33444 (40? ) 243- 7213 • NOTICE OF HEARING TO DETERMINE NONCOMPLIANCE PERIOD AND FINE AMOUNT IN THE MATTER OF: • • MUNNINGS •AGNES CEB CASE NO . 93- 10156 335 SW4TH AVE DATE: 11/28/94 • DELRAY BEACH , FL 334442665 • • On 10/11/94 , after a hearing before the Code Enforcement Board , an Order was issued to you which required compliance with cer- tain provision (s ) of the Code of Ordinances and/or Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach by a certain date . The Order indicated that a fine could be imposed in the event of noncompliance . The Code Enforcement Board was recently informed that you have not fully commplied with the aforementioned Order and has scheduled a hearing for Tuesday , JANUARY 10, 1995 at 1 : 30 P.M. , at Commission Chambers , at the above address , to determine the number of days of noncompliance and the amount of fine . • Although a hearing is not necessary to impose fines , our practice is to schedule and hold such hearings so that you have the opportunity to present arguments and/or evidence on your behalf . We encourage you to attend this hearing . Please contact us at the above phone number if you need assistance . If you decide to appeal the Board ' s decision to a court of competent jurisdiction , you will need a record of the proceedings . For this purpose , you may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceed- ings is made , which record includes the testimony and the evidence upon ' which the appeal is to be based . The City does not provide such a record or transcription . BY: N. SMITH Norma Smith , Code Enforcement Board Clerk RE: VIOLATION ADDRESS AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION LOCATION: Agnes Munnings 30 NW 3rd Ave. , Delray Beach, 335 SW 4th Avenue Fl. , Lots 5 and 6 , Blk. 36 , Delray Beach, Fl 33444 Town of Delray according to Plat Book 5, Page 38 of the official records of Palm Beach County, Fl . CITY OF DELRAY BEACH CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ORDER C.E.B. 93-10156 • At the Code Enforcement Board Hearing held on October 11, 1994 , the above party was found guilty by the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Delray Beach of violating City of Delray Beach Land Development Regulation sections as enumerated below. The viola- tions occur on property that the Code Enforcement Board deter- mined you own in Delray Beach as described above as the violation •address and legal description. The Code Enforcement Board found that you were notified of the violations enumerated below and further that you were properly notified of this Code Enforcement Board Hearing. A representative for the property owner was present at the above hearing. Based on testimony and evidence offered to and accepted by the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Delray Beach from the Code Enforcement Division, the Code Enforcement Board adjudged by a vote of 5 to 0 that you were guilty of the following violations which were determined to occur at the above violation address and legal description location: 1 . LDR 7 .4 . 1(302 . 9 ) which requires approved listed smoke detec- tors to be provided to all residential units . 2 . LDR 7 .4 . 1( 303 .4) which requires that minimum residential electrical standards are met in halls, habitable rooms, laundry and furnace rooms . It is hereby ordered and adjudged by the Code Enforcement Board that the above party be given 60 days from the date of this Code Enforcement Board Order to correct the aforemetioned violations . • c If the required corrections are not made within the above time period, a fine of $25 . 00 per month shall be assessed until final corrections are achieved. A Formal Hearing shall not be neces- sary to assess fines . There shall be a presumption of noncompliance unless the violator notified the Code Enforcement Division of the City of Delray Beach of compliance on a timely basis . Orn/"44 1 takt /0/7? ,57q/ Cert. # ; �Q � // e7/7 • CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH • 100 NW FIRST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH , FLORIDA 33444 (407 ) 243- 7213 NOTICE OF FORMAL HEARING IN THE MATTER OF: MUNNINGS AGNES CEB CASE NO . 93- 10156 335 SW 4TH AVE DATE: 11/28/94 DELRAY BEACH , FL 334442665 The City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Division previously notified you of the following violation (s ) of provisions of the City of Delray Beach ' s Code of Ordinances and/or Land Development Regulations : SEVERAL VIOLATIONS OF THE STANDARD HOUSING CODE, 1991 EDITION, AS ADOPTED BY THE CITY OB DELRAY BEACH LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS: (SEE ATTACHED) • • The above violation (s ) is reported at the following described property: TOWN OF DELRAY LTS 5 & 6 BLK 36 whose address is : 30 NW 3RD AVE The Code Enforcement Division determined that the alleged violation (s) has not been corrected , and now requests that the Code Enforcement Board hear this matter on Tuesday , JANUARY 10, 1995 at 1 : 30 P.M. at the City of Delray Beach Commission Chambers , located at 100 N. W. 1st Avenue , Delray Beach , Florida . It is to your benefit , and I encourage you to appear before the Board at the above time in order to call witnesses to testify and/or present evidence on your behalf . You may retain an attorney to represent you • at the hearing . • If you choose not to attend the hearing , the Code Enforcement Board may make its ruling solely on the evidence submitted by the Code En- forcement Division . If the Code Enforcement Board finds that you are in violation of the above code (s ) , it may order that you comply with the code (s ) and , in the event of failure to comply , provide for a fine NOT TO EXCEED $ 250 PER DAY PER VIOLATION OR $500 PER DAY PER VIOLATION IN THE CASE OF A REPEAT VIOLATION(S) . Please review the attached Stipulation Form and instruction sheet . If you choose to submit the stipulation form prior to the above hearing , and if the Code Enforcement Board accepts the terms of the stipula- tion , your right to a formal hearing will be waived . Signing the stipulation form will be an admission on your behalf that the alleged violation (s ) exists , and will act as a binding agreement between your- self and the City that you will correct the violation (s ) by the date specified and the City will have the right to impose a fine in the event that the violation (s ) is not corrected by the deadline . You are encouraged to appear at the hearing even if you submit the stipulation form because the Board may not accept your stipulation . For further information , please read the attachments to this notice , and , if applicable , consult with your attorney. You can call us at the above phone number if you need more assistance . The Code Enforce- ment Board may assess a fine for noncompliance without holding another formal hearing . Fines may be recorded as liens against real and per- sonal property in official records . The City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board operates pursuant to Chapter 162 , Florida Statutes , and Chapter 37 of the City of Delray Beach Code of Ordinances . Please be advised that if you decide to appeal the Board ' s decision to a court of competent jurisdiction , you will need a record of the pro- ceedings . For this purpose , you may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made , which record includes the testimony and the' evidence upon which the appear is to be based . The City does not provide such a record or transcription . The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford . an individual with a disability an equal opportuni- ty to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service , program, or activity conducted by the City . Please contact Doug Randolph , (407 ) ' 243- 7127 at least twenty-four ( 24) hours prior to the program or activ- ' ity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request . B Y: N. SMITH Norma Smith , Code Enforcement Board Clerk • • • • • • • • C/ , TM CITY OF DELRAY BEACH • • CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION • 100 NW First Avenue N v Delray Beach , Florida 33444 • 407/243-7213 • • • STANDARD HOUSING CODE VIOLATION NOTICE � . MUNNINGS .AGNES • Case Number ; HC- 93- 10156 • • 335 SW 4TH AVE • Notice Date07/20/94 • DELRAY BEACH, FL 334442665 Final Correction Date : 08/20/94 • Palm Beach County property tax records indicate .that you own the following property: VIOLATION ADDRESS : 30 NW 3RD AVE . • • LEGAL DESCRIPTION: • • TOWN OF DELRAY LTS 5 & 6 BLK 36 • PROPERTY I . D . NUMBER: 12 .43 46 16 01 036 0050 • Please Note : Violation (s ) of the attached provision(s) of the Standard Housing Code as adopted by the City of Delray Beach , Land . Development Regulations were noted at the above property. • You have until the Final Correction Date noted above to correct the attached violation (s) . Failure to comply will result in a hearing before the City of Delray Beach Code . Enforcement Board which Board may assess fines for non-compliance . • If you require assistance , information , or if you believe an error has been made , please contact the Code Enforcement Division located • at the address and phone number listed above or the Code Enforcement Officer at the phone number listed below. Additional repairs or modifications not noted as violations . in this Notice • may be required to conform to City Codes . Also note that • you may be required to secure permits from the Building Inspection • Division and/or to follow other ordinance requirements to correct certain violations . • • In the event that permits are required , please bring this Violation Notice with you when applying for the permit (s) . • Your cooperation in this matter is appreciated . • Code Enforcement Officer Division Administrator (407 ) 243- •• • Certified # ,;2. 7 G t l 0 ? (-PI r/ { • • • VIOLATION DETAIL c., ,\ r l , �` 1 PAGE 1 CASE NUMBER 93-00010156 PROPERTY ADDRESS 30 NW 3RD AVE • VIOLATION . '`x GENERAL INFORMATION DATE QUANTITY COMMENTS . 7/20/94 1 For information this property was declared unsafe in Feb 1993 . during the months that followed the owner of the ' property was working with the city • towards the removal of • tenants and ultimate demolition of the property . In June of this year the owner expressed a desire to repair rather than demolish the property . therefore , the following violations continue to exists and need to be repaired . VIOLATION . 7 . 4 . 1 ( 302-. 4) DATE QUANTITY WATER HEATING FACILITIES 1/25/93 1 WATER HEATER IS IMPROPERLY WIRED AND PRESSURE RELIEF -VALVE PIPING IS NOT CORRECT SIZE. ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION EVERY DWELLING UNIT SHALL HAVE WATER HEATING FACILITIES WHICH ARE PROPERLY INSTALLED AND MAINTAINED IN A SAFE AND GOOD WORKING CONDITION. • VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 302 . 6 ) 'DATE QUANTITY KITCHEN FACILITIES 1/25/93 1 FOOD PREPARATION SURFACES TO BE IMPERVIOUS TO WATER . SHELVING AND CABINETS ARE IN DISREPAIR . ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION EVERY DWELLING UNIT SHALL CONTAIN A KITCHEN EQUIPPED WITH FOOD PREPARATION SURFACES , SHELVING , CABINETS OR DRAWERS AND FREESTANDING OR PERMANENTLY INSTALLED COOKSTOVE . PORTABLE ELECTRIC COOKING EQUIPMENT SHALL NOT FULFILL THIS REQUIREMENT . EVERY DWELLING UNIT SHALL CONTAIN MECHANICAL • REFRIGERATION EQUIPMENT . EXCEPTION : NOTHING PRECLUDES A WRITTEN AGREEMENT THAT THE TENANT WILL FURNISH MECHANICAL REFRIGERATION EQUIPMENT AND/OR A COOK-STOVE . VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 302 . 9 ) DATE QUANTITY • SMOKE DETECTOR SYSTEMS 1/25/93 1 ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION) • • J • 1 VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 2 • CASE NUMBER 93-00010156 ?ROPER'Y ADDRESS 30 NW 3RD AVE LISTED SMOK DETECTOR , INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MANUFACTURER ' S RECOMMENDATIONS AND LISTING . THE DETECTOR • SHALL PROVIDE AN AUDIBLE ALARM . • CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED PROVIDE AUDIBLE SMOKE DETECTORS OUTSIDE ALL SLEEPING AREAS . WHEN USING CEILING MOUNT , THE EDGE OF DETECTOR SHOULD BE AT LEAST ( 6 ) SIX INCHES FROM WALL . WHEN USING WALL MOUNT , THE TOP OF DETECTOR TO BE (FOUR) TO (TWELVE) INCHES FROM CEILING . • VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 303 . 4 ) DATE QUANTITY ELECTRIC LIGHTS AND OUTLETS 1/25/93 1 ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION • EVERY . HABITABLE ROOM SHALL CONTAIN TWO SEPARATE AND REMOTE RECEPTACLE OUTLETS . BEDROOMS SHALL HAVE ONE WALL SWITCH CONTROLLED LIGHTING OUTLET. IN KITCHENS , TWO SEPARATE AND REMOVE RECEPTACLE OUTLETS AND A WALL OR CEILING LIGHTING , OUTLET CONTROLLED BY A WALL SWITCH . HALL , WATER CLOSET COMPARTMENT , BATHROOM , LAUNDRY ROOM OR FURNACE ROOM SHALL CONTAIN ONE CEILING OR WALL-MOUNTED LIGHTING OUTLET . IN BATHROOMS , LIGHTING OUTLET SHALL BE CONTROLLED BY A WALL SWITCH AND AT LEAST ONE RECEPTACLE OUTLET PROVIDED . NEW BATHROOM OUTLET SHALL HAVE GROUND FAULT CIRCUIT INTERRUPTER PROTECTION . CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED • INSTALL LIGHT FIXTURES IN INSTALL RECEPTACLES IN ALL WORK REQUIRES ELECTRICAL PERMIT. INSPECTION/APPROVAL REQUIRED . INSTALL CONVENIENCE OUTLET ON GROUND FAULT INTERRUPTER CIRCUIT. • VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 305 . 16 . 1) • DATE QUANTITY INT . FLOORS , WALL + CEILING 1/25/93 1 • ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION EVERY FLOOR , INTERIOR WALL AND CEILING SHALL BE RODENT PROOF , IN SOUND CONDITION AND SAFE TO USE . CORRECTIVE ACTION. REQUIRED PROVIDE A PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER ' S REPORT ALONG WITH PLANS • • VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 3 CASE NUMBER 93- 00010156 PROPERTY ADDRESS 30 NW 3RD AVE • TO CORRECT STRUCTURAL DEFECTS : ACQUIRE BUILDING PERMIT VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 30'5 . 2) DATE QUANTITY EXTERIOR WALLS 1/25/93 1 ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION EXTERIOR WALLS SHALL BE FREE OF HOLES , BREAKS . LOOSE OR ROTTING BOARDS AND ANY OTHER CONDITIONS WHICH MIGHT ADMIT RAIN, OR DAMPNESS TO THE INTERIOR. SPECIAL NOTE: DUE TO THE EXTENT OF STRUCTURAL DAMAGE EVIDENT AND DESCRIBED THROUGHOUT THIS REPORT , AND TO DETERMINE THE OVERALL DEGREE OF STRUCTURAL DAMAGES , WE • WILL REQUIRE THAT A 1 ' N 2 ' SECTION OF EXTERIOR SIDING BE REMOVED ON FOUR SIDES OF THE , BUILDING . WE ALSO ADVISE THAT THIS BE YOUR FIRST STEP (EXCEPT SMOKE DETECTORS ) OF ANY REPAIR PROCESSES . CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED . ' REMOVE AND REPLACE ALL ROTTED SIDING AND REPAIR ALL HOLES . CAULK AS REQUIRED . VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 305 . 3 . 1) DATE QUANTITY • ROOFS 1/25/93 1 ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION ROOFS SHALL BE STRUCTURALLY SOUND AND HAVE NO DEFECTS WHICH MIGHT ADMIT RAIN. CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED REMOVE AND REPLACE DEFECTIVE ROOF MEMBERS . REMOVE AND REPLACE ROOF STRUCTURE (RAFTERS AND JOISTS ) . ENTIRE RE-ROOF REQUIRED IF 25% OR MORE OF ROOF REPLACED . PERMIT REQUIRED . VIOLATION 7 . 4 . 1 ( 305 . 3 . 2 ) DATE QUANTITY ASCIA , OVERHANGS , SOFFITS 1/25/93 1 • ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION • ALL PORTIONS OF A ROOF INCLUDING GUTTER AND DOWNSPOUT SHALL BE COMPLETE WITH ALL TRIM STRIPS , MOLDINGS , BRACKETS , BRACES • VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 4 CASE NUMBER 93-00010156 PROPERTY ADDRESS 30 NW 3RD AVE AND SUPPORTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH COMMON BUILDING PRACTICES . CORRECTIVE .ACTION REQUIRED REMOVE AND REPLACE ALL ROTTED WOOD. PERMIT REQUIRED. • CAULK , SEAL FLASH , AND PAINT AS _REQUIRED TO COMPLY. . • VIOLATION 7 .4 . 1 ( 305 , 7.) DATE • QUANTITY WINDOWS • 1/25/93 1 ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION EVERY WINDOW SHALL BE SUBSTANTIALLY WEATHERTIGHT , WATER- TIGHT AND RODENTPROOF , AND KEPT IN SOUND WORKING CONDITION. -CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED • PROVIDE CAULKING AND SEALANT TO WINDOWS . • CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of this Notice of Formal Hearing was served on the alleged violator in accordance with and as required by Florida Statutes, Chapter 162 . Method of Service: ---__ Date : • .121 Certified Mail 11/28/94 311 637 699 (-J Hand Delivery ( Advertisement By.: ti t 11'U o a Smith Code Enforcement Board Clerk • Address of Service: 335 SW 4TH AVENUE • DELRAY BEACH, FL 33444 Vital!. l OF 2 CITY OF UELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA • CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD STIPULATION AGREEMENT* • (to 'Waive Formal Bearing, - to Correct Violation and to Impose Fine ' for Non-Compliance, if necessary) . CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CASE NUMBER The underaigned owner or authorized agent for the owner of the real property described below who waa'ieaued or who has legal authority to-bind the real property owner with respect to a Notice of Violation and a Notice of Formal Bearing (cuae number noted above) before the' City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board, concerning a continuing violation enumerated below which exists at the real property legally described as: • • agrees that the continuing violation enumerated below axiata and continuaa to exist as of / / (data of uchedul.id Formal Hearing before the Coda Enforcement Board) et the property described above In violation of City of Delray Beach Coda of Ordinances land/or Land Development Regulations. • . CONTINUING VIOLATION CITATION REFERENCE: LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (I.UR) DESCRIPTION OF OR CODE OF ORDINANCES (CO) • CONTINUING VIOLATION • 1. 1. 2. 2. 3. 3. • 4. 4. 5. 5. Baued on the City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board accepting Chia Stipulation Agreement, I WAIVE the Formal. hearing before the Code Enforcement Board scheduled for / ( and I REQUEST that I be given until / / to correct the continuing violation listed above. I fully understand that the continuing violation must be corrected by the above agreed correction date or a FINE of 4 par day shall be imposed and computed commencing from / / and lancing until the date the violation is finally corrected. A formal hearing shall not ha necessary for issuance of a Code Enforcement Board Order imposing a fine. It a fine is imposed but not Auld, a lien for the amount of unpaid auueeuud fine will be filed against any reel or puruonal property owned by the above real property owner where the violation exists. Under Florida Statutes, the Coda Enforcement Board has the authority to direct foreclosure on non—homestead property againat which a Coda Enforcement Board lien is filed after three moncho from the filing of auch lien. AS EVIDENCED BY MY SIGNATURE (11( THE REVERSE SIDE (IF THIS FORM, I ACENOUI.EDCE THAT I READ AND UNDERSTAND TILE TEILiIS OF TNILl STIPULATION A(:ILEEIIEN'1' AND THAT 1 UNDERSTAND THAT THUS STIPULATION AGREEMENT IS NOT EFFECTIVE IINTII. ACCEPTED BY THE CITY'S CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD DURING A FORMAT. NEARING. IF ACCEPTED, A CODE ENFORCEMENT HOARD ORDER WILL. BE ISSUED FINDING TILE ABOVE REAI. PROPERTY OWNER GUILTY OF THE ABOVE VIOLATION AND RESTATING THE TERMS OF THIS STIPULATION AGREEMENT. TUTS STIPULATION AGREEMENT TO LIE PROCESSED MUST LIE NOTARIZED FOIL EACH (IIBIEIL OIL AGENT SIGNING ON THE REVERSE SIDE. " NOTE: Plurula are implied where necessary chroughout both sides of t111a Agreement- - SEE REVERSE SIDE -- PACE 2 OF 2 WE RECOMMEND WE RECOMM THAT You ATTEND THE HEARING WHEN THIS THIS STIPULATION AGREEMENT. ENENWISH TO CONSULT WITH STIPULATION AGREEMENT, YOUR ATTORNEY PRIOR TO SIGNING AGREEMENT ICNINC AND WILL BE ITEMS A T'll(IUUCii U BELOW MUST BE C SUBMITTING NOTARIZED FOR EACH . AND EVERY COMPLETED. THIS ACItEEMEN'l' PROPERTY OWNER OF RECORD, MUST DE A. PRINTED NAME, SIGNED 1tY AND EACH AUTHORIZED AGENT SIGNATURE AND DATE SIGNED SIGNING FOR A REAL. PROPERTY OWNER WHERE FOR EACH REAL PROPERTY OWNER OR FOR 1• THE VIOLATION EXISTS: PRINTED NAME OF OWNER OR AGENT 2. SIGNATUREDATE PRINTED NAME OF OWNER OR AGENT 3. NAME 8 LCNA('UftE PRINTED DATE OF OWNER OR AGENT y SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME OF OWNER OR DATE AGENT SIGNATURE d• FOR EACl1 AGENT SIGNING ABOVE, IF ANX OF AGENCY TO INDDATE OWNER. , LISTL OWNERUT YOU AREI A, ABOVE.) AND BASIS (USE SAME NUMBIiR LINE UrILIZEO IN A. ABOVE.) 1. ' • OWNER REPRESENTED AGENCY DASIg 3, 2. OWNER REPRESENTED AGENCY BASIS • U NER REPRESENTED AGL•'tICY BASIS 4. - -_ C• ADDRESS Ot�NER E RESENTED AGENCY DASIS TELEPHONE NUMBER OF SI(NINC PARTIES IN A, UTILIZEDDDRES ANDD TE EPHONE N ABOVE: (USE SAME NUMBER LINE I. STREET ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP 2. TELEPHONENUMBER STREET ADDRESS CITY STATE u r 3. TELEPHONE NUMBER STREET ADDRESS 4. CITY STATE ZIP TELEPHONE �� TELEPHONE NUMBER — STREET ADDRESS CITY . 'STATE ZIP • TELEPHONE NUMBER D. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH I' The foregoing instrument wns acknowledged before me this 19 by day of personally known to me or who has Rho is produced (NAPIE) identification and who did take an oath. (TYPE OF ic. an • Signature IYl1e, Print or Stamp Name (Seal) Title Serial Number • CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD — INFORMATION FOR FORMAL HEARING — CITY OF DELRAY BEACH NOTE: The following is information from Sections 37.38, 37.30, 37;40, 37.41, and 37.42 of Chapter 37 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Defray Beach, Florida. For further information, it is suggested that the party• seeking assistance review the full text of that Chapter of the Code or seek legal counsel, or both: Section 37.38. Formal Hearing • 1. When the Board sets a violation for formal hearing, 'the Cleric of the Board shall set a time and date for the formal hearing and notify the alleged violator and the City Attorney. The violator . shall be given at least seven (7) days written notice of the formal hearing. 2. At the time and place set for the formal hearing, the Board shall hear and consider all testimony offered and shall examine and consider all the evidence presented. After the conclusion of the 'hearing, the Board shall issue findings of fact and conclusions of law and an order commanding whatever.steps are necessary to bring a violation into compliance by the time set in the .Order. The findings and Order shall be by motion approved by a "majority of those present and voting, except that at• least four (4) members of the Board must affirmatively vote in favor of the action for the action to be offica.ai. 3. In the event the. Board believes that a violation presents a serious threat to 'the public health, safety and welfare, the Board may direct• tiie City Attorney to see appropriate injunctive relief in the name of the City from the Circuit Court. • Section 37.39 Hearing Procedures 1 . No Board member shall act in any case in which that member has a conflict of interest. 2. All hearings of the Board shall be open to 'the public and any ' person whose interests may be affected by the matter before the Board shall be given an opportunity to be heard. Minutes of all Board hearings shall be kept by the Board Clerk. 3. Hearings shall be informal and need not be conducted according to technical rules relating to evidence and witnesses. They shall, however, be conducted in accordance with accepted parliamentary procedures relative to motions, votes and decisions. Fundamental due process shall be observed and shall govern all hearings. (3) • • • • 4. All relevant evidence shall, be admitted if, Board, •it is the L• ' pini in the o YPe of evidence upon which reasonable' andon the responsible. Pereons..would:normal�.' businesible irs•,• • : Y rely;•itt the coiicliicC' a :: regardless of the ex or staEittory;;rule which might Make suchsevidenceinadmissabletence of 'lcotnmon law over objections in civil .act;ions. Overuobje tiOns in'd civi•Iit ,ac '.The .Ch airman.'of. .. r ;' ,• -, ► '•'' us iri` ll hi;, Y 'repetitious evidence: •the' Board may i�5:,,;tlaarsay`evidence rria 'be a ` ' , ar` Y ccepted� or the 'purpose;'of fii'y orFiexplaining 'any'direcC`eviiience;_ •buL'•:stich-.hearse r P she'd hal ' not4in1and of3i salfonsidered sufficient to'su •`or Y'ev.idence shall finding or decision unless the evidence would be'admissibl•e • ' objections PP t!$.,. n' a .civil action. ='r,'�� over • 6• mach , art. �O ti P Y the. hearing shall have the right ' ' examine:witnesses,: b) ixntroduce exhibits to: a) Call and PpoeingWitneei3es; •:a ;` a) Cross—examfne; f )• Impeach Withesaes;''e)• Rebut: evi'd.ence. 7. TheTalleged violator ,haa the rig•h•t' to be re res t_. . attorney at the, formal hearing. ,X •i• �'�i+,rr{1 8 ,,Al]. test ) t`' P ented'by,an imony;,before, the Board shall •be 'under oath ,and s a1 • recorded The .alleged violator''or ':the City of Delray 1Beachlmaye cause the,-:Proceedings to be recorded'b • ,.Reporter •or ,otheir.:;cer.tified recordist i •a, rumenfied Couxr .; 9•4., ! 1, f,, ,lr •lei •ti,�i ;•,' '., !! f,:. g itlatrlllTlent. , •� ' • ever`Phe4+Board,ishould attempt to convene no�.lesa frequently�`�than once y two 2 ' �' t °' ( ) tinonths. but 'may meet•more or less of Ceti as�..the demand necessitates. .' • • Section 37.40 Subpoena.Powers .! : • The 'City, the Boaz or the' alleged violator. may .• witnesses and •recorca}. including surveya;• ti request that be subpoenaed 'to-- any formal hearin olnas 'shd l .ber mrtedibys, officers of the Cit g• '. .Subpoenas shall be •served. by of the Board shall providelthe Clerk ofy Beach lthe'tfloardtwith su • sighed ;and blank,witness subpoenas to;ba .. xhe:. Cltairinan• signs ore and.nk wit ya Attorneysubpofficient provided to alleged : ' the purpose of subpoenaing wilnesses�andsrecords,C 'Theity Attorneor slit pay to the;Cit}• of •belray Beach a •fee 'of twelve dollaz8vioxatoo short each subpoena :served. � Zz:QO) for • . ` t NOTE.: Subpoenas and subpoenas duces ,tecum are av • • 'D Enforcementivision: The 'same should be .filledoutAby tat•::;' Code r interested `party rooting 'the name and address• of the e , . ,,: p aeon to Ue - • .if -( lI' 1, . :,• • •• ('ii • • served and the date and time of the hearing. The original and a copy should be delivered to the City of Delray Beach, Code Enforcement Department, 100 N. W. First Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida, Attention: Norma Smith. A charge of $12.00 is made for each subpoena served by the Police Department. ,All checks should be made payable to the City of Delray Beach. • Section 37.41 Decisions and Enforcement Orders 1. Every enforcement order of the Board shall be final subject to the right of the aggrieved party, including without limitation the City of Delray Beach and the violator, to appeal a ruling or order of the Board by certiorari to the Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida in and for Palm Beach County, Florida. An appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed., 2. Every enforcement order of the Board .shall •be in writing and shall include findings of fact and conclusions of law, and shall. indicate the vote upon the order. • 3. Every enforcement order shall be signed by the Chairman and shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach, Florida. A copy of the signed order shall by sent by Certified Mail, Return Receipt Requested, to the Violator. 4. The Board shall in every proceeding reach a decision without • unreasonable or unnecessary delay and shall in all instances, reach a decision within twenty (20) calendar days from the date of the hearing. 5. All City employees shall take action as necessary in accordance with a decision of the Board. Section 37.42 Lines for Non-compliance with orders The City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board, upon notification by the Code Enforcement Officer that a previous order of the City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board has not been complied with by the time set, may order the violator to pay a fine not to exceed two hundred and fifty dollars ($250.00) per day for each day a violation continues past the date set for compliance. A Certified Copy of an order imposing a fine may be recorded in the public records and thereafter shall constitute a lien against the property upon which the violation exists and upon any other real or personal property owned by the violator. After six (6) months from the filing of any such lien which remains unpaid, the Code Enforcement Board may authorize the City Attorney to foreclose upon the lien. (5•) i MEMORANDUM1 . 4110 TO: MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS FROM: CITY MANAGER Pq SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM # ` 4) - MEETING OF JANUARY 17. 1995 FIRST READING FOR ORDINANCE NO. 9-95/DESIGNATION OF SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE AS LOCAL HISTORIC SITE DATE: JANUARY 12, 1995 This is first reading for Ordinance No. 9-95 which designates the Susan Williams House located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue as a local historic site and adds it to the Local Register of Historic Places. The property consists of a single family home which was constructed in 1935 and remains a good example of the Bungalow style of architecture which was popular in Delray from the 1920s until the advent of World War II. The house is associated with Susan Williams, one of the City's early midwives, and is the only remaining building in Delray Beach to physically link the social 1110 and cultural history of the pioneer midwives to the community. The Historic Preservation Board conducted a public hearing on this matter on December 7, 1994, at which time the Board voted 6 to 0 to recommend the designation of the Susan Williams House as a local historic site. Recommend approval of Ordinance No. 9-95 on first reading. If passed, a public hearing will be held on February 7, 1995. ref:agmemol6 A ORDINANCE NO. 29-02 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 9-95 BY AMENDING THE CAPTION, THE THIRD "WHEREAS" CLAUSE AND SECTION 1 TO CORRECT THE PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND ADDRESS; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, 2002" TO SHOW THE HISTORIC DESIGNATION IN AN OVERLAY MANNER; PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 9-95 was passed and adopted in regular session on second and final reading on February 7, 1995; and WHEREAS, on August 4, 1999, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the expansion of the municipal tennis center to the west; and WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board voted unanimously to recommend approval of the expansion, subject to the condition that the Williams House be relocated; and WHEREAS, the plans for the tennis center expansion later changed and the Community Redevelopment Agency then moved forward with plans to redevelop Block 36 (the site of the Susan Williams House); and WHEREAS, on October 6, 1999, the Historic Preservation Board approved the relocation of the Williams House to the Spady Museum Complex; and WHEREAS, the Williams House was relocated, but the property description and address in Ordinance No. 9-95 were not amended accordingly; and WHEREAS, on June 19, 2002, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach recommended 7 to 0 that Ordinance 9-95 be amended to reflect the correct property description and address. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA,AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the caption of Ordinance No. 9-95 be amended to read as follows: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, DESIGNATING THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE, LOCATED AT 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE 154 N.W. 5TH AVENUE, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AS A LOCAL HISTORIC SITE; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, 4-994 2002" TO SHOW THE HISTORIC DESIGNATION IN AN OVERLAY MANNER; PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE,AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Section 2. That the third "Whereas" clause of Ordinance No. 9-95 be amended to read as follows: WHEREAS, a designation report was prepared concerning the designation of the property located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue 154 N.W. 5th Avenue to the Local Register of Historic Places; and Section 3. That Section 1 of Ordinance No. 9-95 be amended to read as follows: Section 1. That the following described property in the City of Delray Beach, Florida, is hereby designated as a local historic site in accordance with and under the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to-wit: The Susan Williams House, located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue 154 N.W. 5th Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida; more particularly described as follows: Lots 5 and 6, REVISED PLAT OF BLOCK 36, TOWN OF DELRAY, as recorded in Plat Book 5 at Page 191 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County,Florida. South 12 feet of Lot 7 and Lot 8, Melvin S. Burd Subdivision, as recorded in Plat Book 11, Page 73, of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida (154 NW 5th Avenue). Section 4. That the Planning Director of said City shall, upon the effective date of this ordinance, amend the "Zoning Map of Delray Beach, Florida, 2002" to show the historic designation in an overlay manner. Section 5. That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be, and the same are hereby repealed. Section 6. That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such 2 ORD NO. 29-02 I. decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid. Section 7. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon passage on second and final reading. PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final reading on this the day of , 200_. ATTEST MAYOR City Clerk First Reading Second Reading 3 ORD NO. 29-02 .'- s� n 3r - -! 6, DELRAY BEACH All-America City 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 561/243-7000 August 10, 2000 a. Dr. Janet Matthews 1993 State Historic Preservation Officer Department of State R.A. Gray Building, Room 305 500 S. Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0250 Dear Dr. Matthews, On behalf of the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, I am pleased to write in support of the Grant-in Aid application which is being submitted for the restoration of the historic Munnings Cottage. The cottage, also known as the Susan Williams House, was listed in our Local Register of Historic Places in 1995. Susan Williams, the mother of Agnes Munnings, was a trained midwife in the Bahamas, when in 1898 the small group of Bahamian settlers in Delray asked if she and her family would immigrate to the US and serve as a midwife to their community. The town did not have a resident doctor until 1905 and nurse "Susie", tall, slender and imposing in her white uniform and dark cloak delivered both black and white babies alike and gave other medical attention as needed. Agnes Williams Munnings and her husband built the cottage in 1935. At the age of 80 nurse "Susie" came to live with her daughter and spent the remaining 4 years of her life at the Munnings Cottage. The Munnings Cottage was in the "path of progress" and was scheduled for possible demolition when it was relocated to the site of the Spady Museum, where it will serve as office and exhibition space. Architecturally significant as a modest residential bungalow in the African-American community, it also retains a great deal of historical significance for its association with Susan Williams. Your favorable consideration of this worthy renovation project will leave a legacy for generations to come. Sincerely, Patricia Cayce Historic Preservation Planner i HE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS Fnntedor,h ;yJed Feaer CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION TO: DAVID T. HARDEN, CITY MANAGER THROUGH: PAUL DORLING, DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND ZONING FROM: WENDY SHAY, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 2, 2002 REQUEST FOR AN AMENDMENT TO ORDINANCE 9-95 FOR A PARCEL OF LAND LOCATED AT 154 NW 5th AVENUE (THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE), ADJACENT TO THE SPADY MUSEUM BETWEEN MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR DRIVE AND NW 1sT STREET; AN INDIVIDUALLY LISTED HISTORIC PROPERTY. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS The Susan Williams House historic designation was previously applied to the house located at 30 NW 3rd Avenue, Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally the Town of Linton. The structure has been moved to 154 NW 5th Avenue just south of the Spady Museum described as approximately .15 acres of land in the Melvin Burd Subdivision that includes the south 12 feet of Lot 7 & Lot 8. The bungalow style structure, with its battered porch columns and open porch design was constructed in 1935. The residence was built by Isaiah Bruin, however the architect is unknown. The structure was designated based on its contribution of Bungalow architecture as well as its historical affiliation with Susan Williams, a mid-wife who often times provided the only medical service in the historic Sands area (currently a part of the West Settler's Historic District). The residence was her home for the last four years of her life. The house was individually designated in January 1995 prior to the establishment of the West Settler's Historic District. The Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA), along with EPOCH (Expanding and Preserving Our Cultural Heritage), sought the Historic Preservation Board's approval to relocate the Susan Williams House from 30 NW 3rd Avenue to 154 NW 5th Avenue. The Board approved the relocation of the Williams House to the Spady Museum Complex during its meeting of October 6, 1999. While the house was subsequently relocated by the CRA, the property description and address in Ordinance 9-95, that established the individual historic designation for the house, was not amended accordingly. Therefore, it is necessary to amend Ordinance 9-95 in order to update the property address and description. During it meeting on June 19, 2002, the Historic Preservation Board recommended approval (7-0) of the amendment to Ordinance 9-95 to the City Commission. Public comment during this meeting was in favor of the amendment in order to update the designation. The historic structure retains its architectural and historical integrity despite its relocation. Therefore, there is no need to alter the historic designation other than to update the property description. Staff recommends approval of the modification to Ordinance 9-95. RECOMMENDED ACTION Approve Ordinance 29-02. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Item: II. A. - Meeting of June 19, 2002 Consideration of an amendment to Ordinance 9-95 regarding the Susan Williams House historic designation. Location: 154 NW 5th Avenue ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is approval of an amendment to Ordinance 9-95 for the Susan Williams House historic designation, pursuant to LDR Sections 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(K)(2). BACKGROUND During the Historic Preservation Board meeting on August 4, 1999, the Board reviewed the City's proposal to expand the municipal tennis center to the west, which involved closing a portion of NW 3rd Avenue between Atlantic Avenue and NW 1st Street and included the relocation of the 1935 Williams House. The Board voted unanimously to recommend approval of the expansion, subject to the condition that the Williams house be relocated as planned. However, the plans for the tennis center expansion later changed and the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) then moved forward with plans to redevelop Block 36 (the site of the Susan Williams House). The CRA, along with EPOCH (Expanding and Preserving Our Cultural Heritage), sought the Board's approval of their plan for the relocation of the house to the Spady Museum property. The Board approved the relocation of the Williams House to the Spady Museum Complex during its meeting of October 6, 1999. The house was subsequently relocated by the CRA, however, the property description and address in the ordinance were not amended accordingly. Currently part of the Spady Museum Complex and known as the Munnings Cottage, the vacant structure is slated for future use as a community children's center by the neighboring museum. The Susan Williams House historic designation, previously located at 30 NW 3rd Avenue, consisted of Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally the Town of Linton. Today, the property consists of approximately .15 acres of land in the Melvin Burd Subdivision that includes the south 12 feet of Lot 7 & Lot 8. The property is currently located just south of the Spady Museum at 154 NW 5th Avenue. The bungalow style structure, with its battered porch columns and open porch design was constructed in 1935. The residence was built by Isaiah Bruin, however the architect is unknown. The structure was designated based on its contribution for its Bungalow architecture as well as its historical affiliation with Susan Williams, a mid-wife who often times provided the only medical service in the historic Sands area (currently a part of the West Settler's Historic District). The residence was her home for the remaining four years of her life. The house was individually designated in January 1995 prior to the establishment of the West Settler's Historic District. .4 \ 154 NW 5th Avenue, Ordinance amendment Individually Listed Property Page 2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION/ANALYSIS Project Description The proposal is to amend Ordinance 9-95 to replace the property description and address of 30 NW 3rd Avenue with the current property address of 154 NW 5th Avenue and a revised property description. The individual historic designation will remain intact. Conclusion The historic structure retains its architectural and historical integrity despite its relocation. Due to this fact, there is no need to alter the historic designation other than to update the property description and the property's address. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Recommend to the City Commission approval of the amendment to Ordinance 9-95 affecting 154 NW 5th Avenue, the Susan Williams House, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(K)(2) and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines. C. Recommend to the City Commission denial of the amendment to Ordinance 9-95 affecting 154 NW 5th Avenue, the Susan Williams House, with the basis stated. RECOMMENDATION Recommend to the City Commission approval of the amendment to Ordinance 9-95 based on positive findings affecting 154 NW 5th Avenue, Susan Williams House based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1 (B) and (K)(2) and the Design Guidelines. Report Prepared by:Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION TO: DAVID T. HAR EN, CITY MANAGER III TIAL THRU: D ANE DOMIN UEZ , DIR TOR DEPARTMENT OF PLANNIN A ONING FROM: PAT CAYCE HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER SUBJECT: MEETING OF JANUARY 17 , 1995 FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE, 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE, TO THE LOCAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES . ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION: The action requested of the City Commission is that of approval on first reading of an ordinance designating a property as a local historic site. The property consists of a single family residence constructed in 1935 and located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue. The legal description of the property is Block 36 , Lots 5 and 6 . BACKGROUN D: The building was constructed in 1935 , the architect is unknown. The builder was Isaiah Bruin a well known contractor who built a variety of residential structures in the City during the 1920s and 1930s . The building is a good example of the Bungalow style of architecture which was popular throughout Delray from the 1920s until the advent of WWII . The building retains most of its original architecturally defining elements, including the multi-gabled roof, the prominent front porch and massive porch piers, most of the original multi-paned windows are existing. As the home of Susan Williams, one of the City' s early midwives, the house has considerable cultural significance. Mrs Williams ' s original homesite was located at the southwest corner of S.W. 4th Street and S.W. 4th Avenue, after its demolition she moved to the subject property which was owned by her daughter Agnes Munnings and her husband Cleveland. Though- she only resided in the house during the last four year of her life, it is the only remaining building in the City to physically link the social and cultural history of the pioneer midwives to the community. It is important to the identity of the neighborhood to recognize this site and to make the community aware of its existence. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. The request for designation is being made by Douglas T. Williams who has power attorney from the owner, Agnes Munnings . HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CONSIDERATION: The Historic Preservation Board formally reviewed the designation report at its meeting of November 2, 1994 and made positive findings to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , (2) (d) & (e) and and 4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) and (b) , Criteria for Designation of Historic Sites or Districts, and set a date for a Public Hearing to allow the public to comment on the designation. Pursuant to Section 4 .5 . 1(C) Designation Procedures, the Public Hearing was held on December 7, 1994 . The Board voted 6-0 to recommend that the City Commission approve the ordinance designating the Susan Williams House as a Local Historic Site. RECOMMENDED ACTIO N: By motion, approve on first reading the ordinance designating the Susan Williams House, 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue (Block 36 , Lots 5 and 6) to the Local Register of Historic Places . Attachments: * Letter of approval for designation from Douglas T. Williams . Designation Report . file/y:munnings CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH bigkig 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE • DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 • 561/243-7000 All-America City 1 1 1993 July 17, 2002 2001 Ms. Diane Domiguez Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency 104 West Atlantic Avenue Delray Beach,Florida 33444 RE: Susan Williams Ordinance 9-95 Amendment Request/COA 2002-274 Ms.Domiguez: The City Commission completed its review of the amendment to Ordinance 9-95 and approved Ordinance 29-02 on second reading during its meeting on July 16,2002. Please feel free to contact me at(561)243-7284 if you have any other questions. Thank you for your interest in the historic preservation efforts of our community. Sincerely, b{)L Wendy Shay Historic Preservation Planner ® Printed on Recycled Paper THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH bglid 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE • DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 • 561/243-7000 All-America City June 20,2002 1993 2001 Ms.Diane Domiguez Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency 104 West Atlantic Avenue Delray Beach,Florida 33444 RE: Susan Williams Ordinance 9-95 Amendment Request/COA 2002-274 Ms.Domiguez: The Historic Preservation Board completed its review of the Certificate of Appropriateness application for the project referenced above during the meeting of June 19,2002.Approval for the ordinance change of address and property description was recommended to the City Commission.The amendment request for Ordinance 9-95 is slated for the City Commission agenda of July 2, 2002 for first reading.You will be notified immediately if there is any change to this meeting date. Please feel free to contact me at(561)243-7284 if you have any other questions. Thank you for your interest in the historic preservation efforts of our community. Sincerely, b rVIA(c-- Wendy Shay Historic Preservation Planner Cc: Community Improvement Project Files: COA 2002-274 ® Printed on Recycled Paper THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS