19 - FMSF - , l II II I I I I II - r -aGGK bA.G.P✓G6
1 e. D¢eLD"ea.
13 . ;, ' _ _ r
- - - - - - - - I �11v�1
It40cm.L , d
BRICK
s I 4"coNc..ue 'r�w�S
OM LOMPALTeD flu.
I .AT EDGE INTt RMEDIATE
• PI 6LE TY CALL AT L1.LVPU(44.1,5.Nv RAW" I!o
11 _ _ wNE2E INDtlA7t0 AS"P.RIG• FAVO•V
OP,f . I I 1_015 OGLE F,4'I.�sr Rai ID NCE I
I I C ,_.1O T 111GLUDB Lint IID � I \ 0
I I �
• II ( t.Ap ARE..,
. 7Se.Rew G4�:o
wVR Z
I
' 1 I � 3r[ITI PF1cE(l�la%TED) ur..
❑ ofr- ,� �k les
he-l +o.
.1.11 Ilt 4t: >
'
1--- \mJu. N6-r 1- plosilvED
•
i i I II 1-y --
1[
] New WlD
P
tlg
-Z
I MAR 23 1995
- dt
c�h : {t1f
y�l I yr� .� --�NI O1i . 14I
FI•1•PLG" I \
- m 2235 \ PLANNING & ZONING
-Urt rOrJNp EL6e. -1 I I. *Zeta 2
o IFd..ENca rE[I I LO 6FiaNrE •tN•IJt
b ._�. TOG.1cr2,cE �'. 6fr ■ .-3
Pt 6t
/ 11/6" _y Mel po35;Ft..,� Nliii�1{ Y -k ]JIk
■_ •
o r�LnPEP. �r I/'I ,:N �NG� . 0.✓ i'' � 1CWINOGVV �Wo _6.,-__ r O 1 _ Q_ _• utluty � ER LK FLvG.c ffQ -R I l.:I- ■ +11.13 hi
following information oust b pc«ldq In the,p,c••blovr
d ddNa+PPEo IbLe WM.KVILY - ;Go• 4�4=} id-o -4•-Ir--114_71 L'G-�" �i '-G 13'8I• .Rym Y / •eem[leer.e.n nn a lye •4 ii: 19''�t ei:ii:
u.loarr wo slbc. •/•• .1 FUTURe +4t.ti ' f2o.r6 - l++s I �'� `I \`
•
5E7far.E 7u[%a.2 %//� 1 ♦-.. _.PAT to -_ $. -+--.�22:31 =1ry:--..os) ,`\II //)) iota f eer,r..�� -j��.4. zt-t
4' ''`` 116W TRE65(L) { N ,,to D.r 4a-0 ep•e Ilan ec,pwl•pee•. lsl •4.ft. yy�-t o[efts
' / I -` i 3'A7,r ' 1 rl �N ,r.WS T I Dodl«. -•4•!t. -t o!•lc•
•°�TiP•) e,tuT..c �.• P. 'Q / 4f+ATE C>M7
r' \f� I r of r«1a«tla dwelling wilts,
} I7.
Yrt�s �/ : Q1 '- a y Lilt :5$ 7fe ,�E
Neater vac•p.t.�or wi7i al,•
14.6
,:�/ii i � .■rl. - cf[lcb..cy p.ft.
I -1 r�'/, f N 4 rtA.uJc _ ..Qn.t IK� f- Bedroom
i40.1e r e I 7 1••tro« N.!t.
_a I l e.dro« N•ft.
+2Lo4' 'rE 14/24'-■_ .- rdeo ors.. _ .• Iv w•ft.
M0'9NC'rao) rI I celna• c••rpulrqWr•o•nt toILAtodcioa t...t, w•«.
p1�'o I �� e'e I L- CV .t:`: .il « .« (t•u�l. rut .n.:�woDll.d«l.r.elp7'-e ` 2ole - �3JGo` d.nwro«.�o[il«.od a�br.. ,.) -T A- :nD..nah ,cana.ew a it•wt..v.r 1pp�cftle� Al. [y_
b• .eaml.c.d•e .wr,. 11-3w«•
p • perB.. .c•lwl•t.a.e •wr«p•e_t7 - ill I"I T � $UII�DING N42 -I� I, u.• SAL.
3RAwl+S --'\.,
cewc c.oze N e I I 1 ■ I rgd,, 1- -ADDInoN j. Pw.rime, I 1/ i 174 r eWc 1 .144� 8-eI. L2.35 t p.ruw•p•o«prowl*.
0
Regular 9
�l NpiN r+Tf✓. +WA'- rl Daiwa. 0 (Iql.. Yp ce lot e[rp•lc.d•p,c,•
rmerem tes'.,.Te ,p 1
v[r.4R�N I L. N„IE2.1•Gowue�r.ow .,, itr*^Y1DuT..0 1 1. / ••^-" R{, '[mRc, �_ (sue at ma a6tu v,nlnc,e.0+q
I rcc•.N wes. __ // I Z
1 .,,,,, +tr , .of t7(LILir /11, 1rnItIMUf-"fin rr00,1112^afi0n. f L., ' wlldln�ad.t, p Wjpt,'r«bt co rDR Bwtl« f.l..(i)t
' I _ .. 1� yRJvut40�d jReS/y r 1� D•r t.uM•
�.3�-f^}- I I LI 1 4-)::i+0.2 `.. P _ rr111711 ":M' ,.:11 ,1:..,l.l,� J1 none. n' «. Rrl,7_ec.
1 O n••a 2•�,K4 .
pltA4 �iD CI....L.4_,
l1 [nt•cloc aide.1l_ft. 1 tr„r,ld.. _ _ 1t.
N �yv„vn. 70a' '4'SYI.LIMO W . I U1 ...f,oA rI Gary u✓irc •!
n,llat. 1.. -.o.ft. -167-f5oor•
!j 10 I I .0. �„ 2(i'_b r` .rory-14'[t.
1`�/] ., cy�nmuumimt uuumnmr, CeNG 11
' _.,,I.,,,,. J -- �1 / �: fH1' l-�-I t /New rmu Fs+ra .
�i vv
_ _ pS vl yy' PAVCD Ana. Naw ans6M1newT. -+Kt. I /I 7r I�
"''0 131.�' 'ARTY 1.IHE
'
I I I LE_T
Hore -ru.q DNA,WIwc SureEGeOEV nbsE mce.�lO_ I5St'6D.
1(/�I- I I - .9 tab 5/94•R2d11■D■NTM/wALKA•+V S■t4/G6'WU.A.T 01.04 2
I _ �/ jj�� - I I RESTORATION/RENOVATION of TWO HOUSES for
I - - - - d - - - - - I I COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
' II, 207 EAST ATLANTIC AVENUE, DEL.RAY BEACH,FLORIDA
I ROY M. SIMON A.LA 100 N.E.
1 I DMFIFTH AVE N E
�\ /\ IA•RCHITECT
SCALE: APPROVED OY DELRAY ACH.FLOREA
407-278-1914
O ' DATE:1.22-94 ' DRAWN OY
sW•8.5-14
q1-20-9
4
I NoRF S. PLAN q.2194
WING NUNB.P
- - 1 - - - - - -- COMM.NO•9407 A-1
• NEW ADDITION
LINE CF EXIST11,6 ROGF
1uuIIIIIII I• VENT NEW ADDITICN I T - VENT INSTALL NEW ASPHALT SHINGLES
/7
� . f
!STALL NEW ASPHALT SHINGLES 6 IQ'EXPOSURE FOR SHIPLAP SIDING NEW WOOD DOUBLE HUNG WINDOWS
REPAIR EXISTING WOOD . -
4.12 YAW 6E'AM �
t•�1 II u u I. uft u u u,u �u.- u `r ' CEILING LINE a a e ,, a a a
I l k-.
LovJER NEnD of EXISTING
■■ I! ' Yr eee{iDiwG I 1i
_ I ECH+� `MYM37f_ , p r — I //�' oPEN1N4 T 8-a"
// _ 1 . -I I , / VENT INSTALL NEW ASPHALT SHINGLES
I . i
4X4 COLUh4J5 J ® 4 II® -® ® 7 -- — _ ..
�_
3X3 TOP 1 BOT.RAIL _AI 1[ •
- SECOND FLOOR LINE --
Dd SPINDLES J�� 7 --
1
-r
.1. I 1 CEILINGIE I - �J
4X8 BEAMS-SCULPTED I I
e$ $ 17 $ =_- _� - --- I® ® P 7.;__. _ V I
] — r
W.I.METAL_RAILING �_ ® ® - - `- o -1- _ J
•
I= 1
.- 1 G ri o ; - 1 I BAY WINDOW-8EYo1.Iv
G S
j i 6 1{ - ,I \''' 1— -T-- ❑. - =IRST OOR LINE - - -- -- �S
If + - _N - - } I �- NEW PANEL DOOR
i 1 } I .I DRIP- = I Haw twyevyeNalS pn..,.-,N Ex,6nr+4 iTALL IIl00D L. SIDING 1 TRIM-
;,,?: :, ,t =\I apcNwc, OVER NEW Dc6 SHEATHING NEW WOOD CASEMENT WINDOW 14EW 1x4 f 1,13 NEW WINDOW 3 SHUTTERS
SGRP-ENEO VENT-J T NEW t�SE-EMT WINv _ NE.W PS AND GORNEfL TRIM
T`(PicA.- r .1 I 1. FILL SA15TN4 opE,11N44 WAI-WAiAY - WALL NEW LAP SIDING Wr T IR'EXPOSURE (rVPICAi.)
TO FLOOMMOOATE
NEW WooD DECK WALKWA NEW WOOD PANEL DOOR ADD NEW U1MDC(U
Y Ea4ZTiNG NEW F•D�1TON ��F-7C1 ST1N4 NEW AcDITION J- ElIS•r1NG�
I-IOI TI-1 ELEVATION v4••r-m• �IIC
W ES'( E.LEVQTI ON va•=P-o'
-ResASED b•5.44
•
�b---I RECONSTRUCT CNII•NEY TOP
= 1h c. . RECONSTRUCT CNIMEY TOP
LINE CP EXISTING ROCf T C '1ET
NEW ADDITION .1ululnu,IL Iuu fHU
^' / J `Ev/ VENT
MODIFY OPLTIING I INSTALL Mt'J
INSTALL NEW ASPHALT SHINGLES IL000 CASEMENT WINDOW 1 513.TTERS NEW ASPHALT SHINGLES
NEW IL D' UTTERS
INSTALL RECONDITIONED SHUTTERS
— — \ - IN51ALL UJOZ�-CAStMtNI WINDOWS
- -t ..����. _ V, 3 •_ L OVF WIND* .- 0 t
II ® • �.- ®_ ® - v ® NEW II/OD PANEL DOOR BEY• . i4 ■ _ ■■■ _; E■ .. : - I-I INSTALL NEW SLATS
I
NEW SLATS BE1u.EEN COLUMNS ■_ — NEW WOOD PANEL DOOR BEYOND
VENT I .7 - w ■■1■■f■■i. it■'■■f■■■.:■0■t`■'■' NUM w I w IN
FUTURE TRELLIS(vJ D�
�. ..■■■■■■■■ El■■■�IBaB�IBa�,.■111•111.111•11110 MI■■.■.■■■.. I ON NO / b-?�/E W/-1 vWA--
v u . u — ~— E 1 E `III n n rn n• n rt n n „n n n
i G INSTALL NEW 5/4.X 6
�S. � _ I fII _ _ I� =A■■ =� =c■■■ ■■■ � LEADMGBOARD
■■ -- --} 4 ® _. _. I1D II _•.�_ li,,====_..- E�■101 _�I,.■E , 3X6 BEAMS dIBAY'.'JMDOW II =,in..— r1' 1 `fB_--��� , _���
('1
.,��ffl!1I� ■ ill MOOD O ER. No r�
-- - - - r - - �RI- IaY.-
-*� L—1 1_1 I
I _ A INSTALL SWTIERS ��a�� ilt. 11 LI
NEW WALL SIDING --'==- M �- - KK/A
GENERAL NOTES: L. INSTALL NEW WOOD PANEL FRONT DOOR —5C-EENEO VEF4T
(� BAY URJDOW I.ALL PAINT SURFACES ARE TO BE SCR4 PED-OR RESIZE OPENING 3 INSTALL NEW (TYi'I CAL)
MlL Yfi4Ci!
MODIFY OPENING 4 INSTALL Orr-+Bee.1Eo PRESSURE CLEANED TO A SMOOTH SU! 4CE,PRIMED DOUBLE HAGWOOD WINDOW INSTALL NEW WOOD WHERE BAD WOOD REMOVED D PO D. rnm
WOOD CASEMENT WINDOW 3 SPUTTERS seFf'T'Nosy Delray Beech FIaWB
3 REPAINTED PER SPECS. 334414210
INSTALL NEW CAST STONE STEPS
TYPICAL IX8 SKIRT BOARD 2.REPLACE ALL ALLMINLM WINDOWS WM I NEW WOOD 401n16-7217
DOUBLE RAG WINDOWS OR CASEMENTS AS NOTED. INSTALL NEW WROUGHT IRON RAILINGS
oU T la EL E VAT I O E,1 va =r-B" TEM
4.REPLACE ANYLROTTTEE'N WOOD WHEREVER FOND. EAST E LE\IA i I O va•=1.-0"
5.OVERLAP SIDING 50 THAT VERTICAL JOINTS ARE
' NOT ALIGNED CONTINUOUSLY ABOVE ONi:ANOTHER
fiR� � �V aEevI4E NRESTORATION/RENOVATION of TWO HOUSES for
'(�_l a��- I.0/S/9d REVISE NOeT7 ELEJ�.TON;�` ceLErre.....e,T.nMx ; COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
CYnuGE ST�Cw.-oaco h[44
207 EAST ATLANTIC AVENUE. DELRAY BEACH.FLORIDA
ROY M. SIMON A.LA 100 N.E.FIFTH AVENUE
23 TOG' ARCHITECT DELRAV BEACH,FLORIDA
MAR1995 407-278-1914
084t&11/4•'•1'-O° •MBOVEO BY OBnwx BY 6 A•:.
BI:4E:7/E1;ad" RBN:eo 6.5.9.1
PI_A N I N I N G &SON I N G (Imp°w-1L.E M1f oiamLLi.r14-rs =`
c�NM1551oN •7... •CEs.e,r,p-r.m.'- B.ww:.a..BEB
WI 44a•7 N0 2515 A-5
.4H* 2 cif` f
4,65r le tfr4. o2'7f
a .1-tor
BLez,k 6 IMeleeesr ' 131.6' 131,6' •
til r a K
i%, 0
o g
- I I (45
1.�
. I I I
PHASE III 1
PROPOSED PARKItiG LOT .
I
• Id1 P® p 1�
7 )le„ �a (O
a I H,..., \- $ _.07
I
\ re Connection
Ut 1 �g S� I
88,
III
I - - - - l31b' 1 I 131.6' I
ol
1 za °
I
1 °� 1 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE 0 IIli
Temporary PRASE II r �' 1 —), 1
I Access PROPOSED PARKING LOT O
° 9U
1 III 1
r )
° ' 1 131,6'_ I
o x hry
1 i—t
-
- O 111\__ - PROPOS=D i / I
I
u; ( I NISTORIGI
I u_--- 'I ® c14-4OUSES
1IIi >u - -/ 1 - - -
�' C
I ,
I
° �a ck -Vj \I- •_//-nm ?
I - 1
(S) I I 1 �I 11 I�
I W 1 --
I ra
vC 725
—
z. 1 \4\,,,,4,_______), r--\
I I 55 .?H2-FiLi a"
L.TE
IC_
'LANNIRNG23O; N� G— —� — I } a; i
131b' 131.6' -
0
`
I ° 16' ALLEY ;� {:_ '.
,I 279 ' _ 1I
I ° [1-]
1 I � DC ,S SOFT 1 II I SERVE RESTURANT
• ; 1 r-- -
•
•
•
✓ L� tom` L.: ,a S - A r wtt J'L..._i
..
..
• ,
.. .
. ,‘., , 4
4 MAR '`' .�<,....ti y
. ....!) •
i • s-c•rik. PLANNING & ZONING vic_� �- li
• 1 ' ' .-/flit
•
.1 • , it, . / ,
•
-N- . z , /1 Il
. •. , ., ,.. .. . i • ., _
. ..
• • ..... . ...
• „.. . . , . , . ., • . . , . \\.. .,...,,,.... v, -. . , I
Ill
i • g�,
, - ' ‘. v .\ 1 . l' . , . , •
\, ' . ( ! I ,, 0) .......%y-vI--.....-1$.21- '..-...i. •
'T a -r • 11
—
II
it 3 , ii. . li
• ,
,,� _ �a\� ��L:ill � i I i�j '� , jj s it
-- __
' _ ':. )t;......,-=i • o: r -.._
I.
e rr---�,r --` �7'' CAA./ •�'; e�.: -R�-. , _ _ - .. • ' 1 S - ` ,.yam 1�1••-• __ - • P I�
•
•
•
/ 1 1 ' '. !! //�c:N_E.41 -- „it,.- • T ! . � �"' '. I _ 7.p •r . /�L-8 i �•�--_ _. 1
,; �.w. S%.�t. ..�: ;► r -I 4. --pL6- - _ [ • •!fi•
r
`m%S= t"¢"o •"%�f 41`�`S- I' !! .t �� • _• i! .:
• w
• yyI ; •c c:a�:. 7is�I / - .il 'tL.I. t.•F + +.- .• •I„' � >..( ` `.tv / �� 4 • -
. _ 1 . a.T+Meiae Jr 1 , 73iT�/ i 5M1- y c
•
•o • .rb.r 'T ��a ty� • - r
f ,' 8,e�...Fitt, f _ `- lid : 'O_ it,:_4Z 44640_}`f ••G - -%3"—X, Zi".tt_71-i-e�' I.
11
t ---- ; /o C / '•3c 6 {5��v)-C.a��e.- .Q[L uoJ�cr- 1►.�.a,ec l'i�er _.f • r
• 1 ...i /• L ' .. a / ; . - "O; i R T 4•4(- 1Kip 114.0E 7t) Vs �I�� udto ,ey . •... '
ov.aL.• .t t pp
/ t" ,.. , i Q ,.ss .ca 1'J•dcar" ..ar ;a .0 ogg•G►'er.470.e._.�Jr j_�aT=.•.4c.?
ex.
r � JJf qi`.. I , �y v -.>>! `= \ _ t. �</<tJ1+T!lIay./1 'swif L, .QC pCRMl x7'EO o t/ 1I
.. • F --- —_ --- _ — d.cf ur{ y ? A" 1 % .ar�r ,erors.� �Oae eCo. __--_T
i; ••' I./'\• 4--.4 r 1, )
I, 5_ :
j . • •!
• I ° ' •3 •g— 1 - + V , f Al Al..iifertail:f�eC f.0G/JT aA/ !.i
I. ,,� ���{.e. \ r7f•wI• .�,� I �1• •
- �,, •`' • _ , _.:_'.:�. �..r�.t� .,h%�: .^, f,
o . 4. ) . e.- ` rep,ft&JA . . . ` • 1` z?„ f' .N:, ,,sa.l i;
K ti u ,� , r__ ' ,(�,, _ . A. r le p 4.o,= — '�' \ k` I2-- i �v �%•� .Cep ip r ' xr', ' f,,7
�! i o l• ��i9 l f4.G t- ! 78.r�c�tc y tom'" a j t
!/�cG!ewe !ti �Atz raweX-
tr
•
-,.�_r. _�._� likklt' • '.\,..' ... S\,•!••. • • ,
_ _ _ _�_�_.._ _ _.�.. - _ems . _..... --
•
•
j I i 8
.T .Y- i+e i �"
,
r
- ••••!;;,.:_l,
I •
I 0. ,
i '11111111111 C
IpISIEVIED
3C, („d v,,-ram_.t...„ -o r 41,..0 f ) • I i
I r J
1 MAR 23 1995 .�, T i t'=r' r T_-_ _- _ -�__ 1
' r
PLANNING & ZONING ! lr 4 . .
� • '• Tom . .l• / ''d'' - _ `s»'.rore scoviser r
, a =,.t r I
h ,
• . '11D-F7 ,r-1, . •
•
I' 1 _ . V.%F PO✓/ cs• . *-zsar{T 1--�w• - �rfyb,�t�,f/�.rj;
•
I t L 1.'� 4` , • c.....•
^ r Thy .{ Y
. ,% 1 i t 1 ' , _ ..--_,„,-____J*. z..4 .i i _ .
if '.\N- I -- tz �`* z 1
i i ) ` -ter,,,;, =-t 1 ,-, �
Ilt I . :.i«c.: • _.....t.r_- ---_-._�. _�:
l it IL _ �_ ` .e-1 !r'11° "'� "e ��! - — 1 >
��
•
' ` Pwru / ,I /++1We` f 44• � e1./.! lc�r0�./ , ., ,i �sa -�u � r_ , -'_��-� - „ _ s
;{, MJtT.'t
-- .•.... -.- +.+-+.•.,..,..+..--....--- --- -". ._,,:`_ ', ..r - i _ e. . 1ST 4 d L ��T •- �ALdI�f.KJ �X.
• ,� ! - }
I. i ' . .
- -- _
H,... _..,„_....---.., —
• � . _ :___ ad 0* •• y; • _-. .
- • -_ __. ... +--_ \.. .....•aZ •-�.�..►. r7 ...f 4 w/a.$.J .r .r[r .o-� ,
r! I /6^o, dLrJ.areR j•rwlp 1i�; —� r/ • A - j - — ✓ /r / edrav•
11
1\2:‘,........14. . . . , ___..4••0.c. 1 'Cil, 'f ,,
pcisavED .
•
• I MAR 23 995 . f E,•- J►aw/./ d r...��.�� t , f�?../ '' TVA
; . .f,t/v• f•r--L / ; •n,a.X. s:• 'o.G.
I '• ' `� !
; PLANNING & ZONING •k. } • •
i if
�...../
1: . • 1111 1\ ..\
y t f ? ;I �'_ /{'X1 ram i;
7J_ , / L,
• tt -f . Jr.4/L.•looksar . •
v
r
i t • j a I r :ic
_�9 a:
-1 •
•
::;1111_-:,t.....‘_ 1:;;
.- ,. �teE:.rd:..r.,
• Acct.:, defw"r. a re* /11 f!_ P1/4"/ ; i
.:,!.
, . .
� , . ..,-,...._ .,..., ,
_ .~ i F ��� �? �, . —eAEcL.- t.'.W 47; � o • . • F, •
III,
yy ;;?:I
w.
e.i-1 ^ �4L.Ri e�
a 4e a4: rz;it1 _ - •
'jet,'- sG ' •i... /,aoAc. iil
0....,,......, ,.,. -.
t,, .
• a• A Ir ! - I. I . I• . - •• ill! . , .
. . ,
"-
. .
/ . ,-,-... - - ., . . ., .,... .. .., „.„....e.4.•••-,..--•.V-....;
•
. . •
-F
I • • ' 7-1J 6'.'i- —- '4
I ! a Qj i --.. ! •- ��/ i u, a p.(-. S • 'r
Q .. , *ll'1•!� �.���-• / • + qP ! I_ ::aa ) { r• ;w tom �lra >.{�j���t~.
•
7 _, .� • �' 7 /0 �2=0� n.� 4 41 • t f_ < .! • � ar. .ra - `� 1.
7 k a —• r i1y[ a ,:C''4 4 ` i f -♦ //� r► •' +. • • v1
! '- /',tow•BR/c(.N . ! tV • . \. • J �O • ,- ... y .A 7 i-. - ‘\a":4Nii . ..fir/ Ai+d �!
•++1 /"X;3' .1 I \ •)( V� �_ 1 h• 4. N.. CO Astret/ueul• /id ♦: �. - 1 `t' t� v,'
i y1 ( 0 g y t �# Jost foarl✓yJ �'• l' 4 K �{ LZ• :i" ......,�_ ~ ij:
I Q� til i ! / � ��// -�- f
It Al` 1 i • \ •lG �
of > �,�sst I. ; ! I y _ = T :rr1.•t': .G _:•
i .
- �• ��_ . , .
.i��_. ._.•._.�, j �. _- - --_ -- .f i .-4-r----- — .. �'�'�i_.--'.....� , j --:t!:11
"q--7'�-IEJG:. J ....,.........._1:.:.._,,,...- ,....S. ' i'.'2 . �1 } .. .
I
, .. . , -
',--- * -
+ .. +ar1
_ ----+•!-- st_FtE-f vAl r"f' 1J i' d ort,.°.•....'.:t-.4.1 3::• :'..:-
,,
` I f�f /: i ! - � ,. 74,
''-r I ''-, __• i ! G, p�,ls.�� 'i /� f _ • , fat t scl'.!' J t.- .•
1 - 1.
. 11*. ' 1 . . 1 .. •
1 f / I J1yv.O U,c./L,./f t o. ''- .c y. C/a -: ; .' y .,�NQ ,•
' f I !�...1__..._ �/� - �-+.^• .r..isv. c,. t _. ��,� .sT�,C�,�¢Sp �-. t'`V}T'�'- rt1-'�".1'./�..-
. -• - _ -� _ _.. --� ~' d�'I•`!✓ i 13A:oGiL Co .f{I1,:t.GcC✓r',...•li1llr./Cr[. I.J�IA C JX' _
6 _
,1 '� ,�, •-CAI -.� /41 7 ,.
_. _• - '/ 1. .-' 4'
_. -7 - r4rt-Atif 7,174:0"r"."-ilr-047:-: .1.140.1:igit ifA;delY!. : •.
liemaim. ;;;;Alt ... a, �' 1 .a= t ._ �- r•4 ' +li* K'! 1..-? .•:` .A. * 45
. ___ _ -- ...I_ _ n -te r. r _ _ _
•
• .
t` _.�.___...�..-�_..._._.__.. ....-.._ .. �_...�_.
- —
•
i nhht411�u
•
IP.'PIS I V' ita .•. .
•• .
11
MAR 1995 - �!i'r-.,. 1`y ;i
2� 1 ri
...4 .-.____,,,Thir
PLANNING dt ZONING 1' =r �� • i__�____:-�
,i , , . .
• • • , . _______:,..,:i..„....„..„.„ • ... -.....- . ,....„....__
. L,‘,• .
•
_._._.� ._._f-' .____—._r. �_.. c.j i_ -S r . t
' .------3T1 ----------"---- ------- .)4 3. OYtR/rfoti► .Ao o t .Q•
.�. .. i ,, •«✓ j tr -. :
II
•
-- —
1 I!I
W.
yy� ;�s/I.PJ� .�. - ••-,�-/-"�.. G -.-/ s.+•� __.< �7 ! ',�. �1�.°� j '��y*"'r-'. x'-iF. str+r -_�'('y �.� 1 _
'r-.-.---"- --+ • ... ! '�,' ._-•�__-.•sa ♦ .▪ 4, r M ,i..44 j "fit •fyr•
h /F' . - • ; r^ -'+e !; � 5.' f Y �y1 (� a `.Sy,. '+!i I. .�.t.'�r t' T - \ .,�ti,fir q'4'�+ 4t `iit ? 'ft ' '�y
• • . • •• ... , • . • . . - a r' 4 • rl� , 7p �+d 'a r°=. �,f� „xis '?�I'tir , '
-' -e: , `.- - ,,, --. . ' --. .- {�--*r: i-.r mn. ••••vw.e: f p .i• 14
'42i` �l' 4'`15? y' 'L- _'Ro•.11; ,! /%
. .
. . v.� Qr e t rTar. _ ,. •• S / ..."� >r v": ` :� 'T R•'` psi M•
'
_• _ F- 7*--�7- 'i' 1� t�-'F=�•�717�'r---i ,T - tea.,: f`>•" •>. 'P :, xiti .'� 1k.
r _ tf _�iwri�•
-�' a If....-A. ei:az issr i -�-•.c�y_ - r-� trrr �i ._- ./�' _•--- , fit l ,y`
- «� _ 1. _ < I -_-'•'t- '• • 1• .FYI .,t ' • 1 ' •.: ��i?� ', ,.
•
•
• •
- e -.ter•.. ` 1r. - -. —_ •.�'t+ • r i - �' 'r,`k_ 7_
-. •� ` is j 1 I • 1_ I' ,1� f. �.' , r ti �':
C :' I + 1 I 1 - ',ii fix.' • 4;
_ • hjoeir4_ 44;.•T.1' 1.. 1 •
,+ �� i 'L • ii h -__ ,I-:. ♦e, ,r►. :,..
-+g' { •�- � 1�ii I ,r - 1 sv iC I n!. J i' `-�•Z-•l'•--- - . � s
J rMr u' 1t e' ' .r ri { IS 1 t+ u .I ` • I}�Fi - 1� .11.- ... 1. 'I .. d:•r. •s5 q4' :�"' f •�" `S -{N
_ - 'f. QOP/Y '_'-1-_ �:a� .: i. :i' �r 'ft t f f' 1 .. 1 A -: -'L7V .•i � ..� ._...�.-_ � ♦ '�� '�' l.T
1 l�t��l i 1 • �' r ► _ -1 i. 1_ e• -_ 11 _ f , � ��` +o ;�,, ..
— — .1� .�.� \ L�yy r .
y< V _ -- ; -_---- --r -i. �.- .•4- - >'.s - ± "�..r."` tT`. - . -,.-.....:..:�.'- .. ''�¢ •sr>„ 7yi. r A. t., �l'•':
•
1' i `�- 1 .. _ !i^�'., .
- • Y,._tT r� " r
- i j utcd 9{y+�' 1 ` r r. y rtU L
i .1_1 i - -- - ""_"', !!;"`.` ., _. =-�'t • -... •44.- - 1,._-_,.._:::• ' - .c' r' , , Via. ! '_Y
1 I. I4' /. -`off e' _ __ +,'_ i m �I Yl _ <�
.i
•
->V=r.,t'-...;••--;"4„.,r-i,-'-.,"1.'.;,•",1*1"1.1"i1.N Os---f•
. 1� tiy.} � t �i I"r s (s •�'� ..-�_..�::.tt •i,. - �� :vr-: #'-r-a'-•t'y.:.- h :�d 0'\. '� ,.o�ham. 1r.
.� _ -, i �..--:.•r f1, . ,' �_' •.J .. 1 1 '• • •1: t _. . 1_ .•._.c_ ,•..� i..t`�'i�r y•
,.`+,
'1�=.r ,I hh 44 41 �. _ <./t _ ' .�r , '} _ '�^"...'`i :•Lr - ; -_. _ �".. lY S�f ~M,a1'a•' .r�6, =•• L< '-w. '!.'�a.,.` 9 �<t.i
_ <- F ,t' - f` - ♦tI _ 'r- .., '' :)• .i " a+ 1 ,a.. rl - _ ••Yd'• - �.ty
r -I'r i-v•r ♦ 1 y-._—_.._i„_. --- _ - ^r —. S'-wcr--- .-----1 — {. JJpp� { i
1 a'a6 — 'L r f '� _ .i...t :r,..ie " ': 'w't: ,4 :-
-' ' ICY : 1 _ ... _ .�� ., - •7-�}`�-.:: �-ie_ - '-{Si. 4.+•,.5:
-.-L.-.--- c— . -- - - — - 4 ,. �...r +E Y
• r _ - _ %; � T'"�i`.�L__ 1•'si srJr '(r Yt ,* _
+�t.ns.+�C.r....-.+. .•�-+r'•. .....� _._.-t_,.. ._ ..- - - ! ---i-'• !—+.; -- -^--r-+�r-::lwAic'.Y• .Y44 "`...n ` 4 '')^ - .•44
• . - - - ✓� 0 __0_rr- /Y .r./.+.-„`_.'.1:-. -� .Q .( • ,- . -' • ��f 7�- • '!.. r. �4f_+Y>4 .1P''�i.:'yi i. '.�'t4.,, ., �,- <_T•01'`.-' f_ v` : •
= (� �• - .•{�.:J t 1 .+-"iram..:'T r A.J''''r.r`•..G 1 .+.
it/.c.4. CA r j 1.L 1?l i .., .• +I9.• t �' `,.' +,'; -d r r . „ -y.
.::.-..e ......__. _... ._.... '' �'.a• �•1 ��- �.._.:y^� ...__�.�±+0...7- .. _ ... ..+aw ._.. _" `. �•a.7•'-'•'- .. '- --. !▪.. "-.4�� �iw.•'.�r.. tli''�',t _.. _._..�. �.'� - .. �. ..t c:. _ ♦ ..� ". r ��t�SLte^' •�ra9}': +� _ •
�.. •--� ...•• ++ram... rw--+.s-..re.+n••r►w �'�wi'l^•,. •'p uC� .,.•
• il, .
• .
...•.
% .
DESIGNATION REPORT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
•
. .
••1 ;:i..-ep'T:-!;rvf‘,:,•-:•-•-,.!1..- -, - -_,. ••,..•..:....V1.-;......V.,...-i...-......z; ..--
Plen:P.I.e....041:tatS*.,r.,..,.., ,.,. .•,.„......„ .„:„........„..„:„:„...........„............,.........„,..............4-:.-..;,--.. , ... . .
:::,V•I'7.1 i. ":71.i,:f.;;(4,4..-'1fLi.--elt :.4-',$:'i.:W.44.:.i:'7V:.;'!"1.:,134'.1:?''''!)%i'l.i.;',C6t4.1:,!.:.:;..ti:Z...•/!.c....f.7:.--;r::."2,.'?..i.;%;,,:7;:,...;',;:e.r.S.;,•,..tr.:i..:;.%.(i,..,:-..4'...',,...,..,.
..-4,...,-;.....;,,; :TE
...;.....Tv,- ,-;........:.V-.•-•..'4"..,..`",-,-',.•''''1'''.1.,.''.."',......:....,..Vet ,,..t.,,,.••.,...-r...'•ri.,...•...-.....
:.447,*ir.:i'''IP."..:.-Xeji:LI-r:.•!...41*,,:.;...;,7•7-,$'•./;V:f..-..T‘I'Ll:-::Ves:$1,...21;'.. .;.--i'l-e.•;...:.-;),4•42-0,,,--,I;.,:*-4--2r-s' . '.‘;;:.,:f.14.?;----.1:!:4-ig:V4Z....;•ittr.•;:;.::;*:*,._.'7.1:r....!2,4-
,Vigic!...V.?:44.0::,41-r•:•ti.7.f.:-.:::: :41-1..1:Z.,;..i:1:.qt>.;•..7..i1:!'11::1th:':•:*.i0.-Pt:-.11P1141,1g.T:ZgillYilt'''',11. _ - ;,•-•,,.":..*,&.e1.1,,-;i1":„..?...Z F,:!..!?:::-;4%.',1`.:Fii:7-•',...-'v
VIX,?:0117....t'e•le,:'2iai;: iiil.;'..-"-->::S4'.' "=4.:.i*.tP:fggi,i..11/'.1.1_
,-V:•-• .4.1;i_kNi"S-'ts.. W4.'::F?..3.".:'.4. ‘"'It.4'.'$74.-1.:.:14.;;;e:443;'1"...' •''''-'''''''' x ....,:v.,r,;,- •::/.;'...:...'!'..:CA..:.'f.:. ''.4:-.
....1,,..;,).r. 4.0,....4;!.i..-t.i.,.:.!.•:il..);.. %?-ke."..4-.."'..e.;ijt'...7-.ib,:,.. .- - - ..At''..-..,...,!.r•t:'..Y:-ZiV:.i.I.J.:::-.1:':-?.,.q;„;:a1:-.,.7,,. .
.i.'..jfii•ji .1:'..:.:,:4 -..... -, ... .--"•'.7'; ..'.1.1'.i ',,...-i: - -
^,414.V;: if43...3.',§S.P.*.rrlie:.t.i0iiIr.&',;kr,TP.A.Wrri'. . . ,,. .....,...•..........-.:,--....,-,,f.:.X•...;%!,/.,1%,::'...„...W.....r.,-„,. ',..,..
..•. --..7.:.e.'‘'..;,•:r....,.-•-,...=...-..........,.,....,..., .1: .
=,:wi.,1t.1,..;:}..,.,:..c,1:,.$.ra,..Z.:4'-.D-t.' . .. ..........,,,-...,:,.-...;,:.14-_:;.:it.',...,-!,:-.7?.'e'rire•.41.- - '
..,..0t.,,,,ivi, ,- , -,-,..-.,-,.-f,,,,,,,,..-,.. -,„4„,..7,1,.,y.,- .. ,...,..•, .:14.-,:,,,,,,,..-;,..„:11!...r..,.;3,4,,,--,,...6.
4:4.-,..-_,...s_s„.....4„,,..iii:e4,•;.:,........ii.e.-- ....•-,-vi-,..._.1.,Ai•r15,447.....fo:•...-•,: .4, i i •-'• .7 io,e--1.0.t., : • .
. ..•?,e b.,
.3.:: : i•N "--'''..-"--' - ... _ .-.-.--- '.i.t.4 44:<..,.......•..‘.:.-I;
- ..,-
,. ''4,. 1:15•2:i.:., -•• .:. .- :,•‘-'--
, ... . • .
•-,..---r• . -•;,e, .. -?"':•':Az-et,f.•••••••- -- '-..7-.*•,,i'.41". -4,•'7,:ts C-1;Z54"....7-c-,-'41'.'S,les•t'.43o.v..",-,..n1,3,Sir.44';•g-r3:47.4.2--4`,. .--=
• '''''''',,,'--1.1".' ;-,lit' ,-.-:„.4%-le. •. -, -,":.:;-:•,''''-44t.. '....4,••!,,,-_,.c.---S.P.::: cr, .,. --t.,7411.. ..,-::c.>-$•-.i,-i:V.Z..--Z-•:,-----4.c.!:1‘.42.rtrar •••,-.1.,:i
..1 . t ••4,..;„,..-;,%,......----,-- --.........v.-
-,,_,., . I,..:- ... '•,....1-...;;.,, ,,t4:,...,: ::%"- ;;.LZ:.1.,e;
'' ..;:l...:4,...: ... . :..1T:-':iv.:.,... .-•:".......-!,:f...,..,."....., . .-.,...,,,_.., ...,i'i,:..S. ..,,,,, %w.are,...,,,..1.....-,.:._:...,--,,,,,,.-....,,r.:„...r...,;,.. „, ..,,zz„..y....,:.
-••• 7 ,....„.4 • ...... i .•... :• :„.„...., :...1,....„..„,,,,•,..-".., • ••,,,4.....s. 0`, • ',;;...,'sr.:',,,. ; ...P'‹.4,--.4
, •;„ a. „,„...„::-...;.: .P'.1,!.---
1
• ""• t .2'.5.'-r-riii, !;17±;-i;:';f:;-F,4--',"::::,:tti.:1:....-*:,.v...-4-;"..-.:i:•-i.,,: rug...— ..-•:-;:,-•,--.1.e; • -• ,...7.1'.•41'..0.;7•::!' - .
_ • -
•''%. AN, !.: ' 7i.‘Ti,.--.:.-ZtAiIit.1351,.,_.. .:Et >1.. ,,!‘,1, .,:e4"4 -;;::rt. ..•':.,:-•,--;!,: .-;;--_:. ..-WV,iit..ii..-i,
i':;;.:; 'fp-:•;.- 1--•'-•••• -1.7.-•:'.-:',Ar--t..-.--.._..;%.'31,1'..7`,..:1AlliMiliiir.';-‘.. ..- ".....'ifitii it .3;:.;'1.: 7:1'Y: f4:-3--_;---,-,--.--.:-.:4--;;- :-:',...li:;: :r. ."4,"...ZiVi'::444-i1724
;:it'-:. • :.'• --! %,...:i.::.,-.,.-.:.... -•'' .?•!..i.:4:::-.;:'.••07:1,-----;Th.,Lula I:j b i a 1::i , vv:••7.Vt-'... .f-1, -...:,;.,,..!.-:::`,v!..1.•.:*-:-'45--e.:-;.:-'-Zii;
.:,•,•;••.,.- .•b-.--. ... :„..,...,....,-.,:%::,_;....„1.,•:..,:;.4-,. .z.,-.;:r!,:..17.-f...,:it-e.:‘,"7,4,44.,,,;.!•::::1,;.--..._."...,,.,• •.- I,..i.;...-Er_•(:-Tts-----1-4-.. .,?rt„-.7.=,.....•:•••,.;-.:".:z.:;.;;;;:,...,:-.fnci4..4"V
firii .. •.-v.!j".-- •I. `' ,Zttr.,1•10114.-1...e,•;..&Z:.::3.4A7gti._:1'1.Y1 at^Fif4-- %:F.I..Tilti.7-t-t,..tiF:It'..4 ,s-Y7,i:... ..,.:--P- -,7-f4,5f-a. .S..:1-1-.:.;:•::: ;:i)1.4:71P"'
.
4 ..,: ...:,...5fa...,04..,5*-ez.17:::=.7...:,..„0.v.4.,...4-.::.:.;,:_3-,,,:,,,,,7,,,„,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,F4,6 Ns4;1:.% cp.,k,....1
• ;,•LI,-y 'I.,tr.*: r , •:i;..;;;:e:ci- 1.i;Ar 4-.':•;.7. 1.--1.--4::e'le-...:.*:c.tv;z1fikt*•'''..,‘-'•••=4 - -•;•:-.1.- -::-1' --.-.... .re.-.,.',.--4z.rtIV.,:,-&:::NT.., 4,,:,L,.,T;',.',::zt-.
c ."Era...,:. .....4...q..::.p.:;z:is iN.-.11:4;-:•."4"..?c-y-:;t:151A-7•••`,1 ,t5C-tiTc-qt.ACal'it--",:"TA-1...2.,:, -ini;:7*---:*i t;•-1:-.f 131:4,./ .'?--;!•'4' •••••:-..i.';‘--17:a-,'7-
x--fir:.-:::•tf,-...7,*".;:lda:17Y-.';.2i-q-MtXi•s:::-.E4:.44..glegzi4;-tic;:e-o-.,.f,?-1t-t-L,V-itff --n-4,14---: -N:L.-i---.;.:;h:-9.;,A,,;,i,,,,4:-.1,-;.:,,.-.. ...: ,
4..-.f..0;•7--"i'1.--;.:•:,11-....:., -•---•%,.....-. 4.:-.-.."..,..?.,..,1.'11.1.t.,:,-",....-....-----.:: ••4.-,Z.---.:- ,..- ---.1...I.. .
'''..';'•,;. ,.7.1:'.4f::,;:-....=:::X1:;..i.i1/4AV.1;:iet.:7,..%:.t...,•;,;,,....P..:f11:ge;±P:,1..4,444.1.?''''',Y.--.1% Int :,..:fti --..:7.11;t:-.,.:1-.-.01,Strie,,;.;,?A_::.'.. R-,.!-
!:,,s: .../rkT..."-r- ..,....;,.:._...0. ..:,••.t.?.'+.11 .._,...:41,..... . ...........•••-•,,.....-...,..-a,....e..,........., -... .•211-a-•A„ -.--- No"...4'........iI..V1V.1.)."...:,...,:j.,,j ,
...:,,/,,!....,:,....„• , ,..,;.,,...,;.,,,,; kr.••ci S.,...........d.":3:Zt.re;211:Y.:;T:gf:'-... .::;.%:.:Z:V....:•;:.1.." ''''''Th.....'...r.... 5....."' •"4:7,..0:::',.-4;i:;
%le •.::',"..„;-',:.:--;!-.4... . .....,,i..,.....,..,. .,-.:.*:--......., ..,,...1,..,.:-.•:,..,... -: .,,.....•..,-,-.-- .•..-:,•• --.-.,..---. -T. -r-----., ' '-- ' z-1
:.::-..s.-r--;;,??...:.* ::Vf.;;?:.;::5.:;:......•t:,S ,F,.»,:i.,%,..!...';,:rici-,:,,--1-1 .--.:tSetif..i-:i...;-,,;;:: "ntitr-r:—:;457.. .'''.. ' ,:f.2:49. .,;;J:7_,,,Z,.
..`:•-•-:..'".'',-;,'..::-1.--.------"e'F,--,`•-f)"ei C 'n7:1:'',"*;,:le.-.;•-,Fi&1.14';',"411::-.41Afv.-.!".";•...*:,":::-.;7 y.,,11',::::'-•-.7'71.T.I. .;..V..:•.;i.z.,.._ vittg.1:).=•-•! ,;re;-:‘•••:K4 1
1..•-•. -.....,------7-----""nr-a--7,.-:.v. *-ilia:logtrilti,--Nillii -.-%-- —'. - -"- - • -- . •:•---' -'-"•"• '-'-t77•7:::
•-ot....,y4---.4`.. ....,-...-...- -.,,.. —. ..:•:•,,, 1..,re„,,...„.....k..„-.....,,--,------,-.-. __ .. . -....:•.-,.• ......r. ...,.. .-:-,,::•••;••-',.... ---.....- •••
--e-=4,-Yite-•-:‘,.,;-,----------..:...• . • --•--- VPPP-i-i'.?.,4,4=..'4 .... _-.... ..Zki.,•,--..,-.....zse-.....,.•
.z...;24.:.,...,....7..r..1.4,,x.,,,,...,;-:-..
,-1.:•;;;;-yriri.`4,-.,-,4t...nli.;.41,:s7k ,..,_ „_,Wf.,. 9V(•*;...e,.1:AP.. ..1,!,,,Ein..,,,,,A.71.,..+.7,,,x;‘_,<ZIriA, .;;;,.4.;2,...C:141S-."4.--.:::..ea'Ace&; : `'.1-1.'
Y.I.Z:7A•g.T,tar'f)i-Alt.:,?a,;:ie+.6s.--1:04:.-04:1:1S'i-i.?,%?'' rn-V14^.......-''' 215 't*-4‘4.,:-.75-:: :-,---,,v4iiivi-:.fe:clo4.1,....', ,,r1741/4...,Q t,..t.--,:.---,:i;via•-..;eitys-,,,----_,T,435„x,-
40:v.:,,14.-.tf.......fipm._: :4-etiltie.ev.,,,,,-*,_,.. -2,--;---,--4::-.3.K ;21.--434*- ".6-44':'-'•"''
-.1 , ,..t,7,,r.l.'W-.,...1,s.t-'1......04-44 ry:.41•7„. •-...,,,.., us wei..• ..n... ••=--
:1•111Arila424..-4-tr.:4!..1-Ver..Pitig-erN.•.1--,41...),....,,-,.......,4.7.--s.....0--.-• --•- .....-. „....„1' ._,._,..;-„;,r,,...,_;..,..„.,....,-... _..„....;„...;,,,,z,-:-.i.. ...
• '''''?'1 c<g MI i ri.IF;Vit:t'''.1 ,V'Ari44 4,4.V•1C' 4i.'7,•e ;."-fs.$C-Wfr-P;.•Pgt.:.•,IE'p 1.,i.E5:r4;:c--"."?''ttkP
•
i...n.....,.,-..-„--„;ee_1,..t.7..a. FJ...:Vretc41-to, -hAZ.--.17- -t+AP r...,,,i, ...e, et.''.1.!‘. ,-..-g-Vee":"--',Zriti,%49 -1,Yiries,p--.1.--....r-S4-4.4,4:10,..•
Y51.4%..f.Z.14-0;4'..1kf;:::it-Vilt-,10 a,47 rili.2 rtii; .;;''0 , ,01.„ ..V.,1,44,0:;k1-,••:,,-:.r411,3,-.7.ii,f..s,,!:.‘,...:-_-___$F,vtay..,•.5.r*:4,,..-R=z7,51,,,.
. 0,1.0...:-..., .,.....41- .0.34,30:zorkq.x.0-.,_4...v.-•, -.:*,.* -Vsv7W-e71$3. ):4.-Vvi-34-.Rs.i49.1,4**it,.41,:tfliwe--'41-,$1,2,
4".''-=0;'-•;7'l'ael ttono;R:fil;Ttalg--i:',Att -t-z--t.-Ppl:P.,_::F45,.-04,-}:;‘,.•_,o,:
-. • _ ...,:_,:x.z. .,44::-...fr...3.4-.A.1.4,7 .4.1:-.%?•1.,••••.oft,•44,:y.',...,
• 3,A-:;,-*,,,,_p?.-..i.ie
HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE
20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
CONSTRUCTED 1939
i . ..
Designation Rep
20 N.Swinton Avg
Page 2
DESIGNATION REPORT: 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. GENERAL INFORMATION
II. LOCATION MAP
III. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
IV. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION
V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE
VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES
VII. PHOTOGRAPHY
Report prepared March, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic
Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach.
Designation Rep..
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 3
I. GENERAL INFORMATION
Location: 20 North Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, Palm Beach County,
Florida
Date of Construction: 1939
Architect: Belford Shoumate
Builder: Unknown
Present Owner: Community Redevelopment Agency
24 N. Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, FL 33444.
Present Use: Vacant
Future Use: Office of Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board
Present Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts
District (OSSHAD)
Legal Description: Lot 12 of Block 60, Delray
Beach, formerly Town of Linton,
Palm Beach County, Florida
Classification for
Designation: Architectural significance.
Designation ReinII
20 N.Swinton Ad Lritle
Page 4
II. MAP
Designation Rep IIII
20 N.Swinton Av
Page 5
III. Background Information
The subject property is one of two houses which has been
relocated to the Old School Square Historic District. The
purpose of designating the building to the Local Register of
Historic Places is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to
the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the
Old School Square District.
This house was constructed in 1939 in the Hillcrest subdivision
of West Palm Beach. Its street address was 1031 Hillcrest
Boulevard and the legal description was as follows: The West 37
1/2 ' of Lot 18 and the East 27 1/2 . of Lot 17, Block •6, City of
West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. The neighborhood
is bounded by Ridgewood Avenue, Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and
Interstate 95.
In 1987 the county Department of Airports announced that it would
begin a buy-out of houses in the Hillcrest subdivision that were
in the flight path of the jets arriving and departing from nearby
Palm Beach International Airport. Approximately 360 houses
would be purchased and demolished over a four to five year
period at a cost of about $30 million. Many of the residents
concerned about the future of their architecturally significant
buildings questioned what could be done to protect them. The
Historic Preservation Planner for the City of West Palm Beach
found, in a preliminary study, that many of the houses were
architecturally significant and notified the Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board. The HPBCPB, in turn, notified the
State Historic Preservation Officer who informed the Federal
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation of the situation. The
Council, through Section 106 of the National Historic
Preservation Act of 1966, has jurisdiction over use of federal
funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect on
cultural resources. Further research and survey work documented
30 properties which were considered eligible for individual
listing in the National Register of Historic Places and an
additional 28 properties were considered contributing to an
historic district.
Two plans were considered for the Hillcrest neighborhood. Plan
A was to create an historic district for the 58 houses and
rezone the property from residential to commercial or alternate
use. The rezoning would allow sensitive adaptive reuse of the
properties for other than residential purposes. The second
plan, Plan B, was to provide a relocation plan through creative
marketing, the houses were to be given away along with a cash
benefit equal to the cost of demolition; a documentation plan;
and if necessary a demolition plan. Ultimately, Plan B was
found to be in compliance with Section 106 of the National
Preservation Act and was adopted by the Airport Authority and
the City of West Palm Beach. At present approximately 18 of the
58 architecturally significant houses have been relocated.
•
Designation Repu 1-
20 N.Swinton Av
Page 6
In 1993 the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) entered into
negotiations with the Airport Authority to relocate two of the
historic houses to a vacant parcel on Block 60 as part of their
redevelopment project for that block. With the relocation
agreement in place, the houses began their historic journey
south in January, 1994 . Logistically it was an interesting
relocation project. The houses were moved by truck to a point of
access on . the Intracoastal Waterway and barged south to the
City's Knowles Park. From Knowles Park they were taken by truck ::
to a temporary site at the northwest corner of S.W. 1st. Street.:;:
and S.W. 1st Avenue. The houses were left on their moving skids
and a temporary fence was erected to protect them from
vandalism. In June, 1994 the houses were moved to their
permanent location on the west side of North Swinton Avenue in:
the Old School Square Historic district.
The City is currently planning to purchase the . Monterey house
from the CRA. The City will then enter into a long term lease
with the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board who will
use the building as their permanent headquarters.
IV. Architectural Information
This house was designed in the Monterey style by prominent Palm
Beach architect, Belford Shoumate in 1939 . Fortunately, Mr.
Shoumate's original plans for the house have survived and are
added to this designation report.
Overview of the Monterey Style
The Monterey style has its origins in the Spanish colonial
architecture of early California. As a revival style it was
largely forgotten until several noted California architects
began designing in the style during the early 1930s. Being
highly suited to moderate and tropical climates, in the days .
before air conditioning, it quickly became popular in South
Florida.
Two story Monterey houses are generally rectangular in form and
usually have a gable roof running the length of the building.
Often an extending ell bay is at one end of the front facade and
is topped by an opposing gable roof. The exterior walls are
generally framed in wood clapboards but may have masonry or
brick walls on the first floor. A distinctive feature of the
style is a front balcony which runs the length of the second
story. Usually French doors open out to the balcony. Front
entrances are generally simple and located under the overhanging
balcony. Rafter tails and the cantilevered balcony supports are
exposed and are often carved at the ends .
Designation Re
xpe
20 N.Swinton A
Page 7
Subject Property
This building was one of the 30 properties in the Hillcrest
Neighborhood survey considered eligible for individual listing
in the National Register of Historic Places.
It is an excellent example of the style and presents all of the
defining features of a Monterey building. With its clapboard
siding, front second story balcony, horizontal gable and exposed
rafter tails and simple entrance, it is true to the style. An
interesting feature is the original one story portion of the
front facade with a bay window and secondary gable roof running
parallel to the primary roof. Originally the structure was
rectangular in form, an addition to the rear of the building was
added to adapt the building for use as the headquarters for the
HPBCPD. This sensitive addition was granted a Certificate of
Appropriateness by the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board.
It provides space for a display gallery, handicapped access to
the building, handicapped rest room facilities and an exterior
stairway to the second floor.
Information about the Architect.
Palm Beach architect Belford Shoumate AIA ( 1903-1991) was a
graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of
Architecture. He first started practice in New York City in the
office of Joseph Urban, Urban was the architect who designed
Mar-A-Largo. Shoumate's first commission in South Florida was in
1937 when he designed a home at 1221 N. Lake Way in Palm Beach.
Built in the Art Moderne style it was named "The House of the
Future" at the 1939 New York Word's Fair. Mr. Shoumate was in
active practice in Palm Beach for over 50 years and during that
time he designed over 1,500 buildings in South Florida.
V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation
Statement of Significance
This house is an excellent example of the Monterey style of
architecture which was popular throughout South Florida during
the 1930s and 40s . It was designed by one of Palm Beach
County's most renowned and prolific architects. In its original
location it was considered eligible for listing in the National
Register of Historic Places. In its present location it is an
asset to the built inventory of historic structures in the Old
School Square Historic District. It is a visual compliment to
an important historic corner and serves as a constant reminder
that beautiful buildings do not have to suffer the fate of
demolition, but can indeed, with imagination and ingenuity, be
useful to a community. .
Designation Rep
20 N.Swinton Av
Page 8
Designation of the property will preserve, protect and recognize
a distinctive architectural style, as well as the distinguishing
characteristics of craftsmanship, design and detail unique to
the Monterey style, which was prevalent throughout South Florida
during the 1930s and 40s.
Criteria for Designation
Section 4.5.1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City
of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties
or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places. It suggests
that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be
met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which
relate to this. property.
(3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have
architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or
more of the following criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles. "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
(c) "Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent
architect. "
This building is worthy of being designated to the Local
Register of Historic Places. It more than fulfills the criteria
for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires
that only one criteria of the above be met.
Designation Rep
20 N.Swinton Av
Page 9
VI. Bibliography and Sources
Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic
Preservation Board, 1990
Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West
Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992
Architect Leaves Imprint on South Florida Landscape, " Palm
Beach Daily News, August 22 through 28, 1988, p. B9
National Register Nomination Report, El Cid Historic
District, West Palm Beach, FL, Prepared by Beth Miller,
1994.
Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, Quarterly
Newsletter, Vol 4-No 1, Summer 1989 . John P. Johnson
Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach, Belford Shoumate's
original plans.
Palm Beach County, Facilities Planning, Architectural
Division, Plans for Project No. 91240-19 .
file/y:house
DESIGNATION REPORT i
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
''-"''..--*--,----:,--- •-••',-•-d,•',•-",-;,:i-,;..1!c.-.''.:-.1.4‘...7i';'•.:,..f..-:;•-•,:;,;--.,:...-:-.-..:.',";.-i2.:;:.t i..;:, *: ,.:-.-..-z,.:.i...,
.f.,,Yi".1:;'?:,,.;:?;;•::•:q.:f.:..., --iftl'''t:421rNii-4,,,,.:,. . ''': -.. .i .,1f,;=•';.„i;.:11<.Y,.....*'.1-:--1i,"?;--1::...y.:,..."-j.:;.?,:,"f,..';';$:If.•:i'1.(1.:,I=L-'..-;ig..'----(2.7.a':'",-`.:1-‘•."- .'i,.,•'.-'-,''..:.•!:-:-?.---t;;;-':,-,....-:.:ir's:z•-11/(.. ..:.::":7".',:•-:!-.''.4...1;:-,'•
.,.,;(.....4.,:r...,i-::,,,,..,-.-715:...1-.7;:..,.3. ., ....,.,,,:.,k,:,..;:,,,r::e:f...,,-•..7?-.,..?...• . „..„.::..-f.;!....,....-:.--.,,'-.-,.„..........
..,:,•,:.,‘,.;-4-4?:::-i,;..-1.-.. t.e..2.--,:.1.:,-• Y-.!..vztE---,.:,....;-: . ;:',::•-,:.':-v..:Tro i-:-.::-.-,:-,:•-,'t-:,.::-:- ....•:*:";:tii::.
,.,..Q.-4.i.........-1—.,r...:z-...•:...t.-,,....c:...:-.1....-,-.,-1.....?-:,:..--.4.. ,-,:!.,..,....::-,.,-,.....,,,,,....\-...z...-;,.-".-.-:-...-.:-
_;,•:,,,...,..:,:-.,::i_,....,,?:...-,-,:y.---..---,-;:-,. ..,':-.'-4•7,'-'1,•-4:..T-•!'''''='-•-•',;'''•-'.••f".':'4"::'. '''';.z..'.
•.v.,:ii,1.•:-•,!..72--,.t,s,, I;-;..-:.2•-•--.--:--,.-.•-••-•-,'•-•:-..t.r-s:.4 1:•:4-"••...'1'7:1-z.'... •••t,'
l'``4;',1:`;"tt:".:1:-•f:.:1- 'i."4.11'.i..;i•-•.',--LN .,:;:----'-.7,..:--3....-. ......0:•- .--.0-'afl'il*.'4-4:-,-.,?"
4.,...!..e.-}'..:::--.:.;;',;;i.i- 4.1.4,-::.,-;.:?j•,--;--.•:.?:--:,:•.i-t_,1:Alw,f,,t1.-a-z-4--1-=...4.1is-r4i-0-- r e.-.-!*,-...,_:•-•.•-•-..--,...•;:-:!:-.,,,-,
ti . ,ri..-:',1:;:iqi.v.:4!i3;14.-",4,',Nrer„, ---
.., 0., ..?;i4:,..,,,,,....-=1,,t,g,...,,,vx:v,e,3,,yt•
'''s11"---c.4qA5.1;t:q474:ia74#7• .....,-,,.t-P1"..-7.-N,...:;•1,:::::ar-
••-•-‘4•!•.::•-(14,.:A:-:.?"".•:mai.;-. ' e'l..,`-24-4.;-T:
..i.--AN.,,,,41. :.; , pzi-Itii,),.4 ,/,==-1.5%-, • ,:41,4:,,,----vL,:ii-::-..t:!--•ci•:: ,-, --,,,A-A5v:-:•--`2tS'i'
ftt3.,...."" ''':-...,'" I, ' .., ...k.i.... biik• 4•41.4 ,,-i..4•qt.'1*......'; : __47:4;ZfeSip.,-41;e6••';:::,::''''A'•',"a'%'•:(''
t :. 1 ..• . .....• '-:.. ...;.:.,j....,'"1.--;724.7,--.•.--7•-•-.T-TP--,..,,,,;•-.'li . -i.--i:4%P.,'.." '1.4:.r.:4*,..t.:4";.4.!;V'-'1Z;T'. .-7:::-t•-710,; ;7.`-:• -•:.-;.k.'...
- .•••••••••...... /• •-• • 4.-- .• elillk"....:-Z:te...'. •'•.;W_c."-•-•-. ..- ifs."- ''•rectri.,!**•,....t.'-r.:1•.:••t-:,';,";•"••.:-::;-:',..." '.•-"" 1;•s••••••1*--,•.-o-v, -
, .'; ,..•,,-..............".....,.. . •- - •-,...&:„.. ..".•;•:__,...r.:::,•;../." . ."•71Z_di:,- . ....”1 •.• ,•&......"4:4
.4 Ille -.. ,!..- •,ir _ ".,:-••----
4•, 43,,,- • 49 • • 1 - .
.1.-s--i-`-'-'14-1 • - ..:- --7.-Z,-,•;-4'. - •-.- - .• ..: --• .---' - - :'-,•.:.t.'....7..;,./!-".4.1.,,z4a•
&:'-4':; -.;',Z-.4.-' 11:-;:','' .;-- illi1,0 bi Pt4:1:!:1!;:' :,.:•-•€-'r----17-Irr.As,,?-•-•ri, •-•.,,.,..r.:•:-"•-•.",11";',7;:f.;
.pi...,.......,..br,...rz,f.vila jaalialiaLl. ,._,...:t:4•(..:,;.-;:-, . .•i. .,.^ -,‘„•
.....-* --:C----:;.2.:---"i:•:.•:.:•---,,. :.--..:-..•--..,.---• ‘I'',-,-----' --•ilt,""-itri"'----'-'—'''---------''''''• • - ` '` -.01
---::5,-'1:•.:.1:./4.1:•:•t.:•.=..-T:.,s:7..,;..--.• •: "_,•-;,-.-_-,.ii_..-:?..:i---..:-.i,',..':,,-;r..i.:.,1.1,1:-E-7;----.:i••1,ze_—:tft,;,.t,.:t:.,:,;,•..;.-:..;;:f,1i..•4-•.:•-1••:•...,:;.--.:.-.--,.,:.•V..,---,'.,,:.-::-:•-•::!:•;,.•1,.:",•.5.1.-,Fi•...:..'...;•-•.:•.-.::::::,::1:.:.7.-,.....---.-.,_•-•----•-.-,•-:.:,,::.-:•..•-.... M..;a-.:i-••._:;;k.',I...1,4::- ,.r,-)-i.-.•z]j• ;.1
LI: - 1 ,27.4/.*.7•;,::-:.:„:'-:=--.._-.,•-:,-s:
...
• ...II' •'•:'.
1
.. -
.0r; --:.• •1"..:r.4.:.!-:=:::- -;••-:-:1.--7-7-.:7;”:"...-7="--.711 ::•:•,-..• .-'•-•;:•?,•.-•':.---.:•:.•..- 7:7.1-ir--Yr"'vf. - -. .V.Ittizr•-•`..":":;.:::+4- •••-•.'•=:'
...''''.''..'. ' .41:''''''':4"3'./..:".'-'.''-/-•---;r::•::' ;-.••••••::;""*.Z.::".'.?'-';'•-•:::••.'",•7"•••=---::i...•..'''-' --'...•'-••t.'., ••-:- .•••• ••,„ -......:. ..:
• ,..1,';•1•••. ,'"'"A‘``,..5e"`..........r•.. .7777-"r'"_... .," •' --'---"_ ,...,.......•nr..--., , •=--...•,.vai•••••-'•-••-,"-:-t4;'-'7•74-•-':.:4' 64'441 .K,Ifit.1-:=.'7-t_ . .,__,..._ ;-,. ... .,_,,., ....,,,-4;,.-....e-t-i-i•s.re, ''::"•=z`7-.1t•C',:+.:••E''''. .fr;riTP:4".:1--Nt.--. 1,i -W.4:3V-t`..-eo,Y!S•zi,,:e.-.•??,--:-i.,,,:z.i..
--::'::;-- 7:----.177-7.07'r"- ----- ...2--.....-..-----•,-1-.1.11'4`,. ."'---• ... ''''', 4,-...-_,e.,.-..:-..,•; `,1;-':7x!,i';-7--••:.:---.,,'"-_E'ff;-.::,":7..-..-,,:if.i.,,----.,'-r-el.
, -;:--•• ,..' •,,-•-•- •--:...,.., •.,••••::1,--,---.--- ''''''''—`. " -,.. .1:-."1--.1.,...a.%ezzy.,.......-,::1-4,Ftv--_,..._1,..f-SA.
---.°•-',./.-- :s:`,..,•-•-• ,.....,i,-.0.V24-ierv.;Nekir...:,,,Ael.,44.,.1.1.4,1,;,-,...a.,•44,,,,-„,•;4444,-.`".;.:...Z.)---V.41-..i•atr.;: .--t.- ..,"..--.1'..""'"''''S.- 11. '.;•....-".47A-,;.-
1 1-„,-.••••.- •-- . .,......,...-,,..;‘,--,4,....A--,,•rs,,,,-0....4CK-..-44-•••:'•--C-ii-...e5.),--.":"•;,!..-ttlik... 4.,:;-,3:1,...41,17',.. - - ... -,..,. ..11.„..4$.,..1-..,1-•:....,k...
t.,./..,,,f,.•-;-.1•.-Y,11-1V:I.c...'::;:.-:1.3:"•';',..-t:gs.....-•••••,••••••'•:•..__,--.,:-..e:'.).•7,;••••.4-4F-_,:rtg,A.),I.i 1-",.i.,-,..-. ..3re,... .......,,,-v.,* ...p.s.„-,../.....,..+2,,,-a.;•.i..-.A.,:,,,,
•ir".-PAV7-:.:.,:r..z.h;7.'-'-':,,:,i':•••:1-:-.‘1.7,1•-•::5=;;;:-.:7•X•cg.;;,tt:...2.1,-04634 .7g;:4,4ft,k4tx.1!**-•-.-• .....,,,,,r.„.1,,.,-gr.s;s3i,sfe.,..,,r;; ;:%IT:4,V:'"i•l,e,...e...-Aez:F:•:-7-.-(sli.n_,..t:
1 ...ts.--,....----i--. .,,--t,-'.7-A-7.--..,.....!,r.k;'4::-....-°-1.'4';;;..../.:4,.-A-44-':ct.,- - • '.'-',"-,-.1.44,7-:',:‘.4. 4.4..;::•*:..t,174"%esa-51•7:7.441a,•,?ilLee:rvtx:45i7,‘A;;.,41-PiT.;.;41.!•4::R-.4:P7':
. ....-:,:-=. ,...,;,......,,,,--.. ......-,,--.vrz,....„.,,,,,ci,....... -t ,...v...,,,,,,,,,Avetrri..).;;AljZt. wq.kftltbg.x.ft,11.11w=4 ,11,:10:2i::!:?4:•;'.-Z>kg-4?)7!A•.;,',..r.::•;'....4-'1.'A:-•.&"/P7'.. .
'= ""•'1*-.-"-•' ..,-..---.,,,;*:;,--4,. . Yi'i..-.*:4•1r1‘41.::PePter.,;4451VV,bcoal.:•-:avt:A.,Xe-J, 0,1‘.,a-4,-;?/..T.N;t:trir.t.Pv .t11:•t•A-,te v-Pk.:::,•-:v.:
........_,. ....,.....,z:,:-.„.....,-....;,•!t-,;.;,,,,o,vv,$....._.....)..g -.• .f.t..4.a.,..3r....:- ..,..zo.,u.:.r.19-- ...,,frys, t..c,.. ,...,-.1§,---,---.;,;:s..........,-ersr.;14r.,:.>:.,..,:,.n,-,...6...,:
I :::.`j.!:,;:tn.'.:7-il'z;:i::$1._•-•:k`.4.1,....'71tt';..51.1.6.0:1.114$1,,..,...Z.S:fi.?.4.;0464:c41:0.g.>V:9*ft115/". .;11:4:46-R.'.--4, -;:4-5;-.21.4;'.; it':-'4...-'-.Y-t4":..i-':''''
..,,,r2;1.4.17_,I,i..,11,..v.,-0-....e.,-:.-1,....,..f..,...,..,':,..,=::-.• .ti*.ari-- -- •- •---,.!L••••:C 1 -..z.‘?....1.-„*.; •• .?- __,..1..-...-4 ttr-el,t.--a'2',.......• ,•-••• • - •. -I
HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE
2 0 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
CONSTRUCTED 19 39
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 2
DESIGNATION REPORT: 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I . GENERAL INFORMATION
II . LOCATION MAP
III . BACKGROUND INFORMATION
IV. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION
V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE
VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES
VII . PHOTOGRAPHY
Report prepared March, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic
Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach.
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 3
I . GENERAL INFORMATION
Location: 20 North Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, Palm Beach County,
Florida
Date of Construction: 1939
Architect: Belford Shoumate
Builder: Unknown
Present Owner: Community Redevelopment Agency
24 N. Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, FL 33444 .
Present Use: Vacant
Future Use: Office of Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board
Present Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts
District (OSSHAD)
Legal Description: Lot 12 of Block 60, Delray
Beach, formerly Town of Linton,
Palm Beach County, Florida
Classification for
Designation: Architectural significance.
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 4
II . MAP
_> I a - Q Q
1
I
"'
111
iI
imm. 2ND ST. N.E. 2ND ST. 1 -
z 1 �
N I
I
w ,
(f) z ui T
z —I" L IQ
to W 1.
z CITY
— HALL > IW
- .< 1``
� 1
N.E. 1ST ST.
—
1 I
SCHOOL I
—z 7 - - SQUARE
- � 1
- • •:! 1
TENNIS '
STADIUM 11111
01111 i
111111.
ATLANTIC AVENUE
71- POLICE SOUTH 11:111:11
DEPARWIENT • COUNTY > > 1
li
a ! COURT Q ate— a 1 ■
HOUSE 1
R — 1 :—N (� hiuI
r
V. tsr ST. (/� S.E. � 1ST sT. ,
I
inIst N
I
w 1
.. 3 Li ui I
vi ui dui if) I
I
I I I _ I I II I I l — _ _ — I
N
--rissmi— HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 5
III . Background Information
The subject property is one of two houses which has been
relocated to the Old School Square Historic District. The
purpose of designating the building to the Local Register of
Historic Places is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to
the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the
Old School Square District.
This house was constructed in 1939 in the Hillcrest subdivision
of West Palm Beach. Its street address was 1031 Hillcrest
Boulevard and the legal description was as follows: The West 37
1/2 ' of Lot 18 and the East 27 1/2 of Lot 17, Block 6, City of
West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. The neighborhood
is bounded by Ridgewood Avenue, Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and
Interstate 95 .
In 1987 the county Department of Airports announced that it would
begin a buy-out of houses in the Hillcrest subdivision that were
in the flight path of the jets arriving and departing from nearby
Palm Beach International Airport. Approximately 360 houses
would be purchased and demolished over a four to five year
period at a cost of about $30 million. Many of the residents
concerned about the future of their architecturally significant
buildings questioned what could be done to protect them. The
Historic Preservation Planner for the City of West Palm Beach
found, in a preliminary study, that many of the houses were
architecturally significant and notified the Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board. The HPBCPB, in turn, notified the
State Historic Preservation Officer who informed the Federal
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation of the situation. The
Council, through Section 106 of the National Historic
Preservation Act of 1966, has jurisdiction over use of federal
funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect on
cultural resources . Further research and survey work documented
30 properties which were considered eligible for individual
listing in the National Register of Historic Places and an
additional 28 properties were considered contributing to an
historic district.
Two plans were considered for the Hillcrest neighborhood. Plan
A was to create an historic district for the 58 houses and
rezone the property from residential to commercial or alternate
use. The rezoning would allow sensitive adaptive reuse of the
properties for other than residential purposes . The second
plan, Plan B, was to provide a relocation plan through creative
marketing, the houses were to be given away along with a cash
benefit equal to the cost of demolition; a documentation plan;
and if necessary a demolition plan. Ultimately, Plan B was
found to be in compliance with Section 106 of the National
Preservation Act and was adopted by the Airport Authority and
the City of West Palm Beach. At present approximately 18 of the
58 architecturally significant houses have been relocated.
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 6
In 1993 the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) entered into
negotiations with the Airport Authority to relocate two of the
historic houses to a vacant parcel on Block 60 as part of their
redevelopment project for that block. With the relocation
agreement in place, the houses began their historic journey
south in January, 1994 . Logistically it was an interesting
relocation project. The houses were moved by truck to a point of
access on . the Intracoastal Waterway and barged south to the
City' s Knowles Park. From Knowles Park they were taken by truck
to a temporary site at the northwest corner of S.W. 1st Street
and S.W. 1st Avenue. The houses were left on their moving skids
and a temporary fence was erected to protect them from
vandalism. In June, 1994 the houses were moved to their
permanent location on the west side of North Swinton Avenue in
the Old School Square Historic district.
The City is currently planning to purchase the Monterey house
from the CRA. The City will then enter into a long term lease
with the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board who will
use the building as their permanent headquarters.
IV. Architectural Information
This house was designed in the Monterey style by prominent Palm
Beach architect, Belford Shoumate in 1939 . Fortunately, Mr.
Shoumate' s original plans for the house have survived and are
added to this designation report.
Overview of the Monterey Style
The Monterey style has its origins in the Spanish colonial
architecture of early California. As a revival style it was
largely forgotten until several noted California architects
began designing in the style during the early 1930s . Being
highly suited to moderate and tropical climates, in the days
before air conditioning, it quickly became popular in South
Florida.
Two story Monterey houses are generally rectangular in form and
usually have a gable roof running the length of the building.
Often an extending ell bay is at one end of the front facade and
is topped by an opposing gable roof. The exterior walls are
generally framed in wood clapboards but may have masonry or
brick walls on the first floor. A distinctive feature of the
style is a front balcony which runs the length of the second
story. Usually French doors open out to the balcony. Front
entrances are generally simple and located under the overhanging
balcony. Rafter tails and the cantilevered balcony supports are
exposed and are often carved at the ends .
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 7
Subject Property
This building was one of the 30 properties in the Hillcrest
Neighborhood survey considered eligible for individual listing
in the National Register of Historic Places .
It is an excellent example of the style and presents all of the
defining features of a Monterey building. With its clapboard
siding, front second story balcony, horizontal gable and exposed
rafter tails and simple entrance, it is true to the style. An
interesting feature is the original one story portion of the
front facade with a bay window and secondary gable roof running
parallel to the primary roof. Originally the structure was
rectangular in form, an addition to the rear of the building was
added to adapt the building for use as the headquarters for the
HPBCPD. This sensitive addition was granted a Certificate of
Appropriateness by the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board.
It provides space for a display gallery, handicapped access to
the building, handicapped rest room facilities and an exterior
stairway to the second floor.
Information about the Architect.
Palm Beach architect Belford Shoumate AIA ( 1903-1991) was a
graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of
Architecture. He first started practice in New York City in the
office of Joseph Urban, Urban was the architect who designed
Mar-A-Largo. Shoumate' s first commission in South Florida was in
1937 when he designed a home at 1221 N. Lake Way in Palm Beach.
Built in the Art Moderne style it was named "The House of the
Future" at the 1939 New York Word' s Fair. Mr. Shoumate was in
active practice in Palm Beach for over 50 years and during that
time he designed over 1,500 buildings in South Florida.
V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation
Statement of Significance
This house is an excellent example of the Monterey style of
architecture which was popular throughout South Florida during
the 1930s and 40s . It was designed by one of Palm Beach
County' s most renowned and prolific architects. In its original
location it was considered eligible for listing in the National
Register of Historic Places . In its present location it is an
asset to the built inventory of historic structures in the Old
School Square Historic District. It is a visual compliment to
an important historic corner and serves as a constant reminder
that beautiful buildings do not have to suffer the fate of
demolition, but can indeed, with imagination and ingenuity, be
useful to a community.
Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 8
Designation of the property will preserve, protect and recognize
a distinctive architectural style, as well as the distinguishing
characteristics of craftsmanship, design and detail unique to
the Monterey style, which was prevalent throughout South Florida
during the 1930s and 40s .
Criteria for Designation
Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City
of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties
or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests
that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be
met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which
relate to this property.
( 3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have
architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or
more of the following criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles . "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
(c) "Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent
architect. "
This building is worthy of being designated to the Local
Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria
for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires
that only one criteria of the above be met.
. 0 Designation Report
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 9
VI . Bibliography and Sources
Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic
Preservation Board, 1990
Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West
Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992
Architect Leaves Imprint on South Florida Landscape, " Palm
Beach Daily News, August 22 through 28, 1988, p. B9
National Register Nomination Report, El Cid Historic
District, West Palm Beach, FL, Prepared by Beth Miller,
1994 .
Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, Quarterly
Newsletter, Vol 4-No 1, Summer 1989 . John P. Johnson
Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach, Belford Shoumate' s
original plans .
Palm Beach County, Facilities Planning, Architectural
Division, Plans for Project No. 91240-19 .
file/y:house
••
DESIGNATION REPORT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
•••:•••-,. ,..r.,..---„:„..„,,„114,..z;o:...z.....,;.,.::.••••:-,,e!,-„::.z.--•••••t.:,:::-..-.:-.::::::•,-...:•.;:,..-r-f:...f,::„.f..:-•;-••:.;•:::-.;!,..::-.%:‹.. ..
,'"1:•...,;:::-."..:....,,-..':.,C,:.:f.-_.;:•::A.:rf.,,•*. .1;4$.. ..—•:'%:9•-gzli ,::,,,?.;..::•::;-::-.a:.',.1-;:;;./.::.;:v-s,-•,::-?i.-ii,-,,T:iil ,..----:-......,.....----::„.::••••••:.-:.-;.-_f-...--,...I. ,;.,•`-i.!:-..:::;:::".,T;;;;;,.::::;.•
• -, : - . •• .11. :„•:::-.4.....,,. -...i. ,: •••_••••.-; 4-. •••,;•,,::,•:. .4,...,,,,, •••-•-:•••...:.:7. •••••••-••••--:----.e. •,•-. I. . •I
tp,/•.:.?..,..0:'•..-•i%• •:..-C*..:.,tit:,f4;,.I.:r.••• ,, ..r.c...?:•...,.14":!:'., . -'...-;--,••••fr. re:--;.,-•'t'..f•;.t; :-.:*t.:-.:-.::.?.'t• .1.-,..`,•?-,..-..•::-.. -•.,,-7.t....t-c-;;•.-1 •••,- •:;„:”..-,•.•:r. 6•••••:-:)"t-4 1:s...7.•,•:•/„.••:--.- '•-••--••'.- •,.. •::f...!!-•••-•-‘ ;••••:- o...
7.r.4"'- .... '- .....' ..."..':.."•';'.-.-P-•1•-44.ni'!...`;'...4,-::-..... ..4'....7.4.•;••44.C.:-.1.A.:1::....2:::.;"::r",-,7.•:::, . .... . .....4.41-•::::;,:i.V.,.::,4:,4...:1:441.•:.,•`.2'...7,i
.,,,,,,,.,....,...?,....,,2 1,,•1. t,.,rzn‘f,44,,. .tot:,.V.Z.:....:';-.,:it6..1.;-4.;.:se.:,:-.•:.:::-.5,.',..%Ve-e•ty....,......Z.414••••• - s ;•,,•'rr :w--Z.--• -... t-,,•...-."4'•;„-....•':_•..*•-',. '•:!,11:1.•_'"' '...':'t--.. -.1.:;;7•."'- ''.:41'••:?;':•:'::r•;',1c;Ci..: :`4**"."Z.•= :•i- ..... ...,......„.%_.7.4.•..,::...e.:....;•,...1:1.,;.;:3...1;::'1J.:.,-...:•:<'::•:,::::::.;,•••••?4.37•:;..;...,?.,,..1,....s.•.,•••,:•..
.r.;,}....,.......-..•.;-1-• I.••,..-.• •:•.:-... .......,-;-:...,,.., ...?:•..?'.".,V.:,..,Z.:'...,.,...•'1• -...'
V.:,‘‘...t., . .:,..,.... „ ,t1.3,.izt.y............ts
-"....--,.. -e,•...:•••..,?-.......n,'...:,,.!.7;....... .'.'NI'.;...•/1".;
-.,...t-",'',•':_;:-_-::z.-{, ' :1'.':,..,...'tF•:,k'..f.Z:;••;-,,r,,,4•3r,4A,,„:741.,-•itt.:•:•;;.1"Z• :- :r7•Fr :: •;::. !•'1.:••;,•,,•:,•_,::?•;.•a>-:11'./..L.•. ,
1
, •,,,•:y-.,, 7.i.,..4..e.,/•-•,-.t.n`,i, ri_f...',74-1..,-1-.r•s••*, • .
. ...a-ril'a-'r -''.4....P.':-fas41-•-11.4.:01...-,:,e.;.i!ttr.---Ar..,,t.••:.•'• l•Ce. - %.,•••• 1110; .•:.•••._,,t,
I'l'..xt`•-, • :;',;•;••:it•-141-'''.7•-:-''•r•*:;;.".._stIcA' .-...7.. - -.4•-•r•••'''':•3'.r)-"t'z'L.
.-4/7.-;;;,,,:f;:. ; -''''.."--'r;A•••i,,;.11..iiit,4r:•.:1-r-t.t: ,...'t .i„.7.,.,..4'.:.';'"i•-.1..t.... .-. .. -. .'..,4, - 4.:,' i
.•:-"'-‘KR: ..• 'Y.---.1.1.0vs'etS-1.'-f•-••'''' • • ' 0---w
•:., ' ,",...1:1„..T.:r,ii:•,•.,.;4.4 4 6..1„,,- "IL,-l'..„,.,
...t,,,,..".0.,,,se..1,7,-.,,.._-%.*::::.1... ...':-.1.1k. ..•IF- ...-.
;-" - -- ' a:3' s , ,4' -,a51'..'‘,',•::.i.•
, 1_:,-,,..? • ,...;;••,.•,,--•-•:,--.!--,-,,29.7,,,t-_,SA:-.,;:ffi.t..Y.,.:,-I.',.:::::`,---...v•
-...1.41111h. P. 11 ;::, - 1:1`1:' & ..43...-.1%;:•••2 -c-tbal'=-',....Kx- - '•-44*"!1.'"• '1-4-'=••`47'...Z.;tri•:=-:-i;:r i:.•..L..--.••.7-.P., ".?-'7.4-44j.'''''''''''"'"'. ' '- -' • 't . •• '','.'.:fa'.11;.;;; ;t:,,t:'.. .;... ...?p,....7.11rAra.-eark6At'll...,4;.'in.%:--I;:f:3;.4...r.
:.A.P1.:7X-f '; '.7'. :---#:-;;.-1- ,I, % *:1•••••„• . •&.7 -----D-- .".0 AV'•• •tir•••'7.i!."7,5--rs•-,..:-%-7,V tri..7-1•::'.--• '• - -7,..!..; ,-,`-ftft- _
°' ''''ZLIlif •: .• '.•:•'''.s.•:••: ,....* li :!1;•.1f-i:-.•-;.g.•.f..1:::::: :::.3.':;•••:;•!-- ., e,;:it..-r-77-'3'.h .,..%4•-',;1.1e.;:e.,.,...,..,...li?;..4*4'.;t1/A .
-,LI IV!•' '''re4'•'l'A •-•--•c .11.1‹:=1".•;P:i il-1.":::-.;:;\'•:-•-:'zZii.;7•:,--,•;...:"-...-/....';•1,1•.!.=.::.•----.....1::.'-...•.,:i.-.,-i4':-,-;•!:•;,:;.-...;i.Z:', ••••,•i•:!;i.•',9
. -.-7-1041- ' .:.(-'3".. .71•::-:'-',57-: • :Ef I 52:'!!riii".•••Ln44:::••" ''''''':Lt./:••• '1 -----::- •."-••••-.1.;=-----;:.••'::' ;',::•tk•-•?14•.°11:4.-:•.•..ii".
• . u.;.t--- •_ . zi, 7 . ;i it 11::-I i II)1 i: jilt!l!:WA; !zst',-;1.y..... .Y.1;:17.1- 1.k.--ii.cif7!iil-i",:•:;&,.;?31;:t1-•
' g:;7:-.-. •-;•%:::::: -..:-.1.--i•: ::?j•;:ii.*:t•i:74-. :!:?1:114-t;;•-fik'S-e4:-irf.;;,';'',.,:;21,;.ii- :.pt..-'34:1.-f=AIL1,..-"e•.;.-f::.‘k:-,n-i••.•): 5-`-'ie;;C,`•:',..--7:
;:•••:. .-!,: '' :::•:;?.-.......1.11 7;iltli:tI.;;:::.:"1.:1',!f:;_•%,1•.,••;-'').1-...-:1,;_';',..IT:;,.:71g:‘,7:7•1.S.:;._,'„,,t,„-ti,.......,::.,.::,•_.:;i'....1-:.-t-1..,'-:.;::: 7.:....,--_!..._:_-•-•:,,,...i.,it..*--":::::,:.,,-:"jr,r-i.:S,..-,•:::?.:,1,14,q,..„:4-,.:p..;.....->.:
11
7:,... -••• ;••••- ' .;:;;;.:::-... ,7;77.31..::-.,..,..1..2•;;L.;!3::-...i.1.s.i.T.:1;;;:vq..5...',i-:.*:"..;',..?:::::.;`-•.'•;Fzi.;;•--; " ..747'' At.11-1:-.J•;.;;P:''''-''''.."' -'
•''''••Le'2"..7.!- • *.ss::-•'-'.•1::::::afmt):12,5i- ,:fi.•:-f:4:4 i'-"izirt!1-::::Arfp.'31=7•F;t1t......-17-= .-A-4•_!-:•-,1:- -11617-:.!...i.. '...;-.;1::).0...:7:z.;t:•::44 e..1j:.•:',:•-.•: .
,71:•:.;-'.......: 44:11.-5•72-5.i..7-1,1:; :.:%f;:4•;"•‘4;:: ::=i--til',7;f:;:tr..?)Th::. 1--..7 9:12!-Z;li. sf•f::::31:-:-Isik:',.-.`•-!-•"1";:t.::"::`.'S.•
'.:‘::T 1•::• :?:....*.T:70 i'•••!'•;.1i:":4'.:I.-ii:',•, :r I:.7':';`;;;":il •''it...;. .::;.'4Wilif5_;.:::: .t7i:. ...----; .7f.,:.::.. ..,:•11.41i:Vig... ...--,:7:YS-gf..;•Ff:-.P.::::
..,:-.. -:.:.- ..•.-:.*.--' •••••.;•.''. ' . . Zt',..i•:-.......:::.;ylet.r.;::?..;:?..••:•!..f:-.:...,. :.......,...._.......:-...!.v.-....,.:., ..-;:..2:.:::: :,::::::„5:: :,.....,:...:;;...,:z4v.,2..-.4,,y.:-.t....--:-.:-....,-i-:,•,-,,---;:-------.--- ~ . . _ .._ .: ..„.-.,._,:•_--.-......,.
-1-1,;:,... --.,----,------ —s•-,..- ...----......_ - . • • —:4:77: ---.._ ,~ • -• •_- •• . A
•"-
. ...- •.....,.....ypa".....,•54,Z":"... ,,,Liyi$A..44, :1:4
v .1r-t•e-rz,,,..,-.7,, " 44..i....air7r4".:- , V44
....- •Str.,:fe„,Js.,.., ,,.-::.....,...s.1/4..;, ..:::;;.n..
i.::.:.1k-" 1,- 7....... ... . ...:....\''''-',....4r.•'....nr'''..,..,•-•*'''.'''''' •:-„',....,..., .=,.,...,Vi_-,.!..;W:;,.....;.•;-•:";:.,:tr:,,,,e•47,-.Y.4.'...4a,4•,g,..1:X.
-`-''4::>•::.••••:::*.i!..,':•••:. '-:-i ''-•.'sr• "''. ...-.4"'' 3,.,...-4,:i,........ .-kle. .g.:,-4.y.*:,........-..:A.:::-;;P:;.y....zr:".„:.:,;.=i7,:rtv-r.r..4.:4-.1::::;.4g;:.... .,.-•,,,m•••:4.?,...sm
-:-.-• - . ........,-,,,tr..-.-,s,...,r.,4,„;?,44,,,t-.3::,.:114.47:i.t....:1•,p,4*,;,-.1,i.,,,-....14.-41tei-z,....„.....3.4-z.i...7--zi-tz--bn-?------•------ • ...........,,,,,t-4,-,,,zv..-,,....:::"..._.!•,...9.---••*.•9.•-..)-7•At•-,-.7,:-.-...44,7,..-••-,--.N•7todezrrortA),.14>s•-.-1;•4,--*,111r....5.,f-kowrtds•- .- . __,,,,,,,,,.....;, •41.,--7:&.....z.....-_,-;..*.-
',.f-t,:`''•:•:,-•z•hVv2.,`"4:1.4.17.=J;.;-;;A:.-,j.;:i.W4rArri. i..:,t.;:ra:v,,,,-4.4,0m.....t,...); . - ,. „„„„.....,-,,,,,..-,--m-rv,:.,...totv*:,.....„.„:,,,:wz,...,.....,...4:
I t‘.:..,•;.:7,....:4:i.,.-7,:::::•:.1:i7-:=,--*i.:,.4.f.v,:tx,p:...34.4?-..tv-4.-,- --- , .,..„--,...e„Aa.r.f.a.t,I..6,-,,-,..1.„.eF;.,:-,..-:pi,,,zt..t.-uzilyElz..k.:7.-4-.-.:.,:.,f44.64,.!:i.?,.,...;.-..:..-.r.1,-..,.t:::,;:y..-,-,2:1--vR,:b.-i--.--,..-- - .,..:1,-,.!v.t.;:isty..2sZza4"tgir40.71:11v.V.I.::::;;;Tr,•.$;4kt. ..:•:::..`t-.'"?Tpl-",,. 'i..L.7-,..,..1V.i.-74's.%).V4••§-7,1 r?cfs..'.110c,„,71‘1---.;:, . _
..f.,....1*,:••.5--s•••.... • • .. ........,.r„...__.••.---4.1:re..;;:,_..reAt...tikl..-... fiVIR.,_w•.,:s.......7,-4,-.....z.i.mr41-42...ivz•tvr:'isslifces-,•11•;:f.-..r.•:,..4;,..:..--tkisVif,•;-.2t1-74,;:r
,....-.,-,....•.:» •:.;•Z.rg?':' •:%::!Z;Z4:.'y'ifsigP'Cqt: VW'f• jtz•..V.-sWier(1/4.1.'f:f:'~'4"-t:t'.r'S.47V' *sc:i•;'4 ••=:••:f.'ssMs...tq'syss7:,•i'VZ.Le:tsa,P1.+Vs':•t4-r•
...1.1•4'.J.*;Z:17atit."0,;'.i•?slitifit.7 744...74.,^ietti>isski,'...,-4,^1).t,..w4e;in4fil,,st..i.„"sle•P51:::;:e.;?,,,z4.«.:;:cit-,79,...Vi..ttis,..:;11w,..,..44..t...9_;:;....,
4.....;',,;s•••,.1.•-•,,.*-:.-••••..•:•,sf••••!•%...s..tif.-.,-. .. • ••,....e....c ,.%*?.....,. . . .. .. _ .._s...-,,.9:-..„-A:.,.Ifs..,,,,,....._,...s.,..,. 1, . ..„.0;;;1„....
HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE
20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
CONSTRUCTED 1939
Designation Rep(
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 2
DESIGNATION REPORT: 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. GENERAL INFORMATION
II. LOCATION MAP
III. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
IV. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION
V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE
VI. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES
VII. PHOTOGRAPHY
Report prepared March, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic
Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach.
Designation Rep,
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 3
I . GENERAL INFORMATION
Location: 20 North Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, Palm Beach County,
Florida
Date of Construction: 1939
Architect: Belford Shoumate
Builder: Unknown
Present Owner: Community Redevelopment Agency
24 N. Swinton Avenue, Delray
Beach, FL 33444 .
Present Use: Vacant
Future Use: Office of Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board
Present Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts
District (OSSHAD)
Legal Description: Lot 12 of Block 60, Delray
Beach, formerly Town of Linton,
Palm Beach County, Florida
Classification for
Designation: Architectural significance.
Designation Rep
20 N.Swinton Ave,tue
Page 4
II. MAP
Designation Rep(
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 5
III. Background Information
The subject property is one of two houses which has been
relocated to the Old School Square Historic District. The
purpose of designating the building to the Local Register of
Historic Places is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to
the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the
Old School Square District.
This house was constructed in 1939 in the Hillcrest subdivision
of West Palm Beach. Its street address was 1031 Hillcrest
Boulevard and the legal description was as follows: The West 37
1/2 ' of Lot 18 and the East 27 1/2 of Lot 17, Block 6, City of
West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. The neighborhood
is bounded by Ridgewood Avenue, Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and
Interstate 95.
In 1987 the county Department of Airports announced that it would
begin a buy-out of houses in the Hillcrest subdivision that were
in the flight path of the jets arriving and departing from nearby
Palm Beach International Airport. Approximately 360 houses
would be purchased and demolished over a four to five year
period at a cost of about $30 million. Many of the residents
concerned about the future of their architecturally significant
buildings questioned what could be done to protect them. The
Historic Preservation Planner for the City of West Palm Beach
found, in a preliminary study, that many of the houses were
architecturally significant and notified the Historic Palm Beach
County Preservation Board. The HPBCPB, in turn, notified the
State Historic Preservation Officer who informed the Federal
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation of the situation. The
Council, through Section 106 of the National Historic
Preservation Act of 1966, has jurisdiction over use of federal
funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect on
cultural resources. Further research and survey work documented
30 properties which were considered eligible for individual
listing in the National Register of Historic Places and an
additional 28 properties were considered contributing to an
historic district.
Two plans were considered for the Hillcrest neighborhood. Plan
A was to create an historic district for the 58 houses and
rezone the property from residential to commercial or alternate
use. The rezoning would allow sensitive adaptive reuse of the
properties for other than residential purposes. The second
plan, Plan B, was to provide a relocation plan through creative
marketing, the houses were to be given away along with a cash
benefit equal to the cost of demolition; a documentation plan;
and if necessary a demolition plan. Ultimately, Plan B was
found to be in compliance with Section 106 of the National
Preservation Act and was adopted by the Airport Authority and
the City of West Palm Beach. At present approximately 18 of the
58 architecturally significant houses have been relocated.
Designation Repo
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 6
In 1993 the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) entered into
negotiations with the Airport Authority to relocate two of the
historic houses to a vacant parcel on Block 60 as part of their
redevelopment project for that block. With the relocation
agreement in place, the houses began their historic journey
south in January, 1994. Logistically it was an interesting
relocation project. The houses were moved by truck to a point of
access on . the Intracoastal Waterway and barged south to the
City's Knowles Park. From Knowles Park they were taken by truck _
to a temporary site at the northwest corner of S.W. 1st Street.
and S.W. 1st Avenue. The houses were left on their moving skids
and a temporary fence was erected to protect them from
vandalism. In June, 1994 the houses were moved to their
permanent location on the west side of North Swinton Avenue in
the Old School Square Historic district.
The City is currently planning to purchase the . Monterey house
from the CRA. The City will then enter into a long term lease
with the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board who will
use the building as their permanent headquarters.
IV. Architectural Information
This house was designed in the Monterey style by prominent Palm
Beach architect, Belford Shoumate in 1939 . Fortunately, Mr.
Shoumate's original plans for the house have survived and are
added to this designation report.
Overview of the Monterey Style
The Monterey style has its origins in the Spanish colonial
architecture of early California. As a revival style it was
largely forgotten until several noted California architects
began designing in the style during the early 1930s . Being
highly suited to moderate and tropical climates, in the days .
before air conditioning, it quickly became popular in South
Florida.
Two story Monterey houses are generally rectangular in form and
usually have a gable roof running the length of the building.
Often an extending ell bay is at one end of the front facade and
is topped by an opposing gable roof. The exterior walls are
generally framed in wood clapboards but may have masonry or
brick walls on the first floor. A distinctive feature of the
style is a front balcony which runs the length of the second
story. Usually French doors open out to the balcony. Front
entrances are generally simple and located under the overhanging
balcony. Rafter tails and the cantilevered balcony supports are
exposed and are often carved at the ends .
Designation Rept
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 7
Subject Property
This building was one of the 30 properties in the Hillcrest
Neighborhood survey considered eligible for individual listing
in the National Register of Historic Places.
It is an excellent example_ of the style and presents all of the
defining features of a Monterey building. With its clapboard
siding, front second story balcony, horizontal gable and exposed
rafter tails and simple entrance, it is true to the style. An
interesting feature is the original one story portion of the
front facade with a bay window and secondary gable roof running
parallel to the primary roof. Originally the structure was
rectangular in form, an addition to the rear of the building was
added to adapt the building for use as the headquarters for the
HPBCPD. This sensitive addition was granted a Certificate of
Appropriateness by the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board.
It provides space for a display gallery, handicapped access to
the building, handicapped rest room facilities and an exterior
stairway to the second floor.
Information about the Architect.
Palm Beach architect Belford Shoumate AIA ( 1903-1991) was a
graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of
Architecture. He first started practice in New York City in the
office of Joseph Urban, Urban was the architect who designed
Mar-A-Largo. Shoumate's first commission in South Florida was in
1937 when he designed a home at 1221 N. Lake Way in Palm Beach.
Built in the Art Moderne style it was named "The House of the
Future" at the 1939 New York Word's Fair. Mr. Shoumate was in
active practice in Palm Beach for over 50 years and during that
time he designed over 1,500 buildings in South Florida.
V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation
Statement of Significance
This house is an excellent example of the Monterey style of
architecture which was popular throughout South Florida during
the 1930s and 40s . It was designed by one of Palm Beach
County' s most renowned and prolific architects . In its original
location it was considered eligible for listing in the National
Register of Historic Places . In its present location it is an
asset to the built inventory of historic structures in the Old
School Square Historic District. It is a visual compliment to
an important historic corner and serves as a constant reminder
that beautiful buildings do not have to suffer the fate of
demolition, but can indeed, with imagination and ingenuity, be
useful to a community.
Designation Repc
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 8
Designation of the property will preserve, protect and recognize
a distinctive architectural style, as well as the distinguishing
characteristics of craftsmanship, design and detail unique to
the Monterey style, which was prevalent throughout South Florida
during the 1930s and 40s.
Criteria for Designation
Section 4.5.1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City
of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties
or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places. It suggests
that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be
met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which
relate to this property.
(3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have
architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or
more of the following criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles . "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
(c) "Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent
architect. "
This building is worthy of being designated to the Local
Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria
for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5. 1(B) , which requires
that only one criteria of the above be met.
-
Designation Repc
20 N.Swinton Avenue
Page 9
VI. Bibliography and Sources
Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic
Preservation Board, 1990
Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West
Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992
Architect Leaves Imprint on South Florida Landscape, " Palm
• Beach Daily News, August 22 through 28, 1988, p. B9
National Register Nomination Report, El Cid Historic
District, West Palm Beach, FL, Prepared by Beth Miller,
1994.
Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, Quarterly
Newsletter, Vol 4-No 1, Summer 1989 . John P. Johnson
Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach, Belford Shoumate's
original plans.
Palm Beach County, Facilities Planning, Architectural
Division, Plans for Project No. 91240-19 .
file/y:house
Meeting Date: July 31, 2003
Agenda Item : 7
Summary N
MONTHLY ACTIVITY REPORT—JUNE 2003
Attached please find the activity report for the month of June 2003. Activities are
grouped into generalized categories. The initials listed after an item indicates the staff
person who was primarily involved in the activity.
Recommended Action:
Review and receive the monthly report for June 2003.
Submitted By: Diane Colonna, Exec. Director
CRA MONTHLY ACTIVITIES REPORT
Month of June 2003
Design Guidelines Project
■ Attended staff meetings to review draft regulations; wrote Purpose and Intent
Statements for applicable zoning districts (DC)
■ Attended staff meetings to review draft regulations; wrote Purpose and Intent
Statements for applicable zoning districts (DC)
• Coordinated and attended staff meetings to review draft documents to project
team and interested parties for comments. Prepared revisions and reformatting
of drafts based on comments from the meetings. (TS)
• Project management and meetings with CW on revised Work Program, timeline,
and deliverables (upcoming presentations). (TS)
Downtown Master Plan
■ Development of evaluation criteria for marketing proposals (RM)
• Develop and send correspondence to selection committee members (RM)
• Prepare agenda and coordinate and attend meeting for selection committee
meeting (RM)
• Prepare and send correspondence to the shorlisted firms outlining the shortlist
process and to proposers not selected (RM)
• Prepared Ads and Public Notices for Marketing Subcommittee (RM)
• Coordinate and prepare packets for shortlist meeting at Delray City Hall (RM)
■ Attend Master Plan Implementation Meeting (RM.TS,DC)
• Update Master Plan meeting activity to the web site. (JS)
• Gateway Design Organizational Meeting (TS, RM, DC)
■ Attend Transportation Meeting (RM, TS)
• Meeting with Bernice Butler of Collins Center re: Land Trusts (RM, DC)
■ Meeting with engineering consultants CH2MHilI re: NW/SW 5t Ave. (DC)
■ Developed, posted, and distributed Implementation Committee and
Subcommittee June and July monthly meeting dates (subcommittee only),
agendas (both), and minutes (both). (TS)
■ Prepared and facilitated Transportation and Design Guidelines Subcommittees'
agenda and meeting. (TS)
• Attended and assisted with the marketing consultants' selection meeting. (TS)
• Coordinate Robert Gibbs speaking engagement to the Implementation
Committee and interested parties in September. (TS)
• Met with SW Management Team to obtain representatives for the
Implementation Committee subcommittees. (TS, DC, RM)
• Prepared updated Implementation Committee members list to include additional
members from SW Management Team for presentation to Implementation
Committee in August. (TS)
• Attended meeting with stakeholders for the AlA project held at the Chamber of
Commerce. (TS)
• Participated in Parks subcommittee meeting to hear presentation of potential
parks lots. (TS, DC, MS)
• Meeting with Bernice Butler of Collins Center to discuss Land Trusts for creation
of affordable housing (RM, DC)
West Settlers Advisory Board (RM)
• Prepare agenda and items for West Settler Advisory Board Meeting (RM)
• Calls members to discuss the demolition of the Parsonage (RM)
• Field press calls regarding the demolition of the Parsonage (RM)
• Review easement language with Attorney (RM, DC)
• Review easement language for understanding (RM)
• Prepare minutes for West Settler Meeting (RM)
• Attended West Settlers meeting to discuss grant program (DC)
Affordable Housing
• Review 2"d Mortgage requests for Ruby Burton and Deborah Delva for purchases
in Atlantic Grove. Prepare agenda items for$20,000 grant requests for each unit.
(JS)
SW Neighborhood Plan
• Attend Saturday Workshop with Management Team members to discuss plan
priorities and implementation (DC)
• Meetings with Management Team and staff members to develop implementation
strategy (DC)
West Atlantic Marketing/Merchants & Property Owners (RM)
• Preparation of correspondence requesting an extension to the County Grant for
Top Notch (RM)
• Ongoing discussions with business consultant for Top Notch regarding the
commitment letter and other terms and conditions (RM)
• Coordinate with Amazing Creations, wood replacement of store, and painting of
the structure (RM)
■ Coordination with S&R Beauty and Historic Preservation Planner the
resubmission of sign application (RM, DC)
■ Attend Historic Preservation Board Meeting on behalf of S&R Beauty (RM, DC)
• Made telephone calls to Jeanette Dobson (Donnie's Golden Spoon) for update
(RM)
• Meeting with Jeanette Dobson to discuss project status (RM)
■ Prepare and coordinate LISC consultant board presentation for WARC (RM)
• Update to Tony Hamden on the status of his grant application (RM)
• Organize and set up meeting between staff and St. Paul AME Church to discuss
parking issues related to NW 5th Ave. (RM)
• Prepared site plan feasibility exhibit for meeting with St. Paul AME Church on
NW 5th Avenue parking. (TS)
Grants Activities
• Conversation with Pam Nolan regarding CRA auto liability coverage.
Conversation with FMIT regarding upgrading coverage to include non-hire and
hired autos. Upgraded coverage to include employees who use their autos for
work related trips. (JS)
• Review reimbursement request from The Vintage Rose. Draft letter detailing
required documents for reimbursement. (JS)
• Prepare Site Development Assistance Application and agenda submission for the
Vintage Rose (RM)
• Conversations with Pam Nolan regarding contract extension for Angie Gray (RM)
• Conversation with Pam Nolan regarding Tony Hamden's job creation
requirements (RM)
• Site visit to SE 9th Ct., letter to owner specifying that home is not within CRA
District (RM)
• Review Donnie Dobson's loan commitment letter and forward copy to Bob
Federspiel. (JS)
• Attend County OEDP Meeting on behalf of Tony Hamden (RM)
• Meeting with City staff regarding Bus Shelter Grant and RFP process. (TS)
• Site evaluation and visits to assess parameters for grant program for Seacrest
Neighborhood landscape and parking lot improvements with City Horticulturalist.
(TS)
Green Market
• Develop preliminary 2003-2004 budget for Green Market. (JS)
• Create PowerPoint presentation for 2002-2003 wrap up presentation for the CRA
board. (JS)
• Revised vendor application for 2003/04 season.(LM)
• Presentation to CRA board (LM)
• Took photos to Kevin to scan and email to Juliana for power point (LM)
• Created GreenMarket note cards on color copier. (LM)
• Meeting with new potential breakfast vendor for next year. (LM)
• Attended co-operative extension meeting (LM)
• Numerous phone calls to the city on new sign for park (LM)
• Meeting with Triple C regarding next years market (LM)
• Looking at and pricing new tents—to replace broken existing ones we have now
(LM)
• Organize files for next season. (LM)
Other Committee/Board Meetings
• PROD Breakfast—Collins Center presentation (RM, DC, TS)
• DMA Meeting(RM)
• Attended DMBA Meeting (RM)
• Meeting with Community Improvement Staff regarding the West Settler's Grant
Program (RM)
• Coordinate and attend WARC Meeting (RM)
• Attend meeting with City staff committee re: downtown maintenance issues (DC)
• Village Foundation board meeting (DC)
Development Projects
• Meeting with owners and representatives of property in south 600 Block of W.
Atlantic Ave. to discuss joint development opportunities (RM, DC, TS)
• Meeting with Scott Pape, staff project manager (P&Z) for Donnie's Golden
Spoon to discuss requirements (RM, DC)
• Meeting with property owner of commercial site located at SW 7th Ave. (DC, RM)
• Meeting regarding property at 25 SW 5th Ave. -Site Assistance (RM)
• Meeting regarding property located at 75 SW 5th Ave. Site Assistance (RM)
• Meeting regarding property located at 37 SW 5th Ave. Site Assistance (RM)
• Meeting regarding location of Global Mall with investors— (RM)
• Meeting with Mike Horowitz owner of property at SE 4th Ave. Site Assistance
• (RM)
• Meet and talk with Ingrid Kennemer regarding Atlantic Grove Retail space— (RM,
JS, DC)
• Meetings with Board members and attorney Larry Schone regarding Block 77
Group request for contract extension (DC)
• Meeting with P &Z staff and Scott Porten re: plat for N. Federal property (DC)
• Meeting with George Brewer and Harold VanArnem re: property on Block 69
(DC)
• Reviewed project development plans and elevations within CRA District and
attended TAC meetings. (TS)
Property Activity
• Work with Delray Beach Fire Department to arrange for Parsonage (36 NW 4th
Avenue) to be used to train new recruits. (JS)
• Order lot clearing and grading of 36 NW 4t Avenue following fire department
training. (JS)
• Follow up with Kevin Hennessy regarding Clearview/Allen letter. (JS)
• Order Phase I and Phase II Environmentals for 85 SW 5th Avenue. (JS)
• Order survey and Phase I Environmental for 1400 North Federal Highway. (JS)
• Order backflow testing for Peach SW 4th Avenue parking lot. (JS)
• Inspection of vacant units at SW 9th Avenue apartments (DC, MS)
• Meeting with Carolyn Holder regarding SW 9th Avenue rental properties. (JS)
• Set up water accounts for SW 9th Avenue apartments with City. (JS)
• Meeting with Terry Dalton regarding landscaping at Block 60. (JS)
• Meeting with Carolyn Holder to inspect and make repair recommendations for
all units in SW 9th Avenue apartments. (JS, MS)
■ Process request from Roots Cultural Festival for use of Block 76 parking lot on
the weekend of August 8-10, 2003. (JS)
■ Follow up with Dennis Thompson regarding Clinton duplexes. Draft memo to
Bob Federspiel to begin eviction proceedings. (JS)
• Process request from Bangladesh Association of Florida for use of a portion of
the Block 76 parking lot for a festival on April 3 -4, 2003. (JS)
Other
• Explore lease options for color copier and network software. Negotiate lease.
(JS)
• Arrange reconstruction of copy area to accommodate 2nd copier. (JS)
• Send invoice to City for quarterly reimbursement of%of R. Murray's salary. (JS)
• Discuss with Marjorie Ferrer ( Summer Nights on the Avenue) (RM)
• Coordinate with Clay Wideman using his patio space for Summer Nights, July
25th (RM)
• Draft updated travel reimbursement policy. (JS)
• Review and comment on new internet policy drafted by Bob Federspiel. (JS)
• Research cancellation clauses of leases at Monterey House. (JS)
• Order replacement postage meter for defunct meter. Set up new meter. (JS)
• Coordinate bands or Summer Nights (RM)
• Prepare fundraising letters for Roots Cultural Organization (RM)
• Assist in organizing Roots Prayer Breakfast (RM)
• Attend Florida Community Development Corporation Conference— Delray
Beach Marriott— (RM)
• Meet with Glenn Weiss to discuss Public Arts Ordinance— (RM)
la Preparation of Board Agenda Items (RM, DC, JS, TS)
• Participated in City Commission Leadership Summit (DC)
• Participated in phone interviews of Business Recruitment candidates (DC)
• Meeting with Nancy Stewart and Glenn Weiss re: future of PGMS (DC)
• Worked on 2003 FAPA Conference creation and publication of final mailer and
program. (TS)
DC-Diane Colonna,JS-Juliana Steele, RM-Rosalind Murray, DH-Diane Hervey,TS-Thuy Shutt, LM-Lori Moore, MS-
Mike Simon
CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION
TO: DAVID T. HARDEN, CITY MANAGER
V\Q- C6N-A-A
THRU: D NE DOMINGUEZ, DI ECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING , D ZONING
•Pae—aede..e-
FROM: PAT CAYCE,
HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER
SUBJECT: MEETING OF MAY 16, 1995
FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING THE
HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE, 20 N. SWINTON AVENUE, TO THE
LOCAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES.
ACTION REQUESTED OF THE COMMISSION:
The action requested of the City Commission is that of
approval on first reading of an ordinance designating a
property as a local historic site.
The property consists of two story building constructed in
1939 and located at 20 N. Swinton Avenue. The legal
description of the property is Block 60, Lots 12 .
BACKGROUN D:
The subject property was constructed as a single family
residence in the Hillcrest subdivision of West Palm Beach.
Determined by the County Department of Airports to be in the
area of airport expansion, it was relocated to Delray Beach in
January, 1995. Constructed in 1939 in the Monterey style, it
was designed by prominent Palm Beach architect Belford Shumate.
Before its relocation, it was considered eligible for individual
listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Due to
"relocation out of original context" it is no longer eligible
for national designation. However, relocation does not preclude
its listing in the Local Register of Historic Places .
This building is an excellent example of the Monterey style of
architecture and is worthy of designation. It has been
sensitively restored and is a visual compliment to historic
Swinton Avenue. The purpose of designating the property to the
Local Register is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to
the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the
Old School Square Historic district. Designation will afford it
the protection and special consideration provided to all
historic properties within the historic district.
The request for designation is being made by the Community
Redevelopment Agency, owner of the property.
City Commissionlimcumentation
Meeting of May Id, 1995
Designation of a Local Historic Building
Page 2
The attached designation report provides a full analysis of the
structure's historic significance.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CONSIDERATION:
The Historic Preservation Board formally reviewed the
designation report at its meeting of April 19, 1995 and made
positive findings to LDR Section 4.5. 1(B) (3) (a) (b) and (c) ,
Criteria for Designation of Historic Sites or Districts, and set
a date for a Public Hearing to allow the public to comment on
the designation.
Pursuant to Section 4.5. 1(C) Designation Procedures, the Public
Hearing was held on May 3, 1995. The Board voted 5-0 to
recommend that the City Commission approve the ordinance
designating the Historic Monterey House as a Local Historic
Site.
RECOMMNEDED ACTION:
By motion, approve on first reading the ordinance designating
the Historic Monterey House, 20 N. Swinton Avenue (Block 60, Lot
12) to the Local Register of Historic Places.
Attachment:
* Designation report.
file/y:cra-1
STAFF REPORT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING
APRIL 19 , 1995
AGENDA ITEM V-A, B & C
ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD
The action requested of the Board is that of reviewing the
designation reports to affirm that the properties are
eligible for listing on the Local Register of Historic
Places, and;
Pursuant to recommending to the City Commission that the
properties be designated to the Local Register, set the
required public hearing date for May 3, 1995 .
BACKGROUND -
Blank House
For the past six years it has been a goal of the HPB to
designate the Blank House to the Local Register, and
hopefully to the National Register. The Blank heir who
inherited the historic house was not receptive to
designation, and the the threat of resale and consequent
demolition was ever present.
Fortunately, Mr. Bonchak, the new owner recognizes the
significance of the building and its relationship to the
history of the City. He has requested designation of the
property, which encompasses all of lots 12, 13, and 14, the
original homestead of the Blank family.
Historic Monterey House and Historic Bungalow.
When the Board granted COA' s for the Historic Monterery
House and the Historic Bungalow it was determined that both
buildings would be included as part of the inventory of
contributing structures in the Old School Square Historic.
District. This designation is a legal formality that
officially recognizes their addition to the historically
contributing buildings in the district.
The designation reports are stamped "draft" because the
photographs are missing. My camera malfunctioned and I lost
two rolls of black and white photos taken on a beautiful
sunny day. Photographs will be added before the public
hearing.
RECOMMENDED ACTION
After reviewing the designation reports , set a public
hearing date for the regular HPB meeting of May 3, 1995 .
STAFF REPORT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING
MAY 3, 1995
AGENDA ITEM III , A, B & C
ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD
The action requested of the Board is that of conducting a
public hearing to allow the public to comment on the proposed
historic designation of the three properties described in agenda
items III A,B & C. After the public has been heard, the Board
will vote to recommend to the City Commission that the subject
properties be designated as Local Historic Sites and listed in
the Local Register of Historic Places .
BACKGROUND
Sections 4 . 5 . 1(B) (2 ) & ( 3) of the Land Development Regulations
of the City of Delray Beach outline the criteria for designating
properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It
suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3)
must be met to justify designation.
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Approve by separate motion:
III-A HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE
Recommend that the City Commission designate this property as a
Local Historic Site and list it in the Local Register of
Historic Places, based on positive findings to LDR Section
4 . 5 . 1(B) (3) (a) , (b) & (c) Criteria for Designation, "A building,
structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or
aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the
following criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles . "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
(c) "Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent
architect. "
I r
Staff Report II
Agenda Item III 1-1 & C
Meeting May 3, 1995
Page 2
III-B HISTORIC BUNGALOW
Recommend that the City Commission designate this property as a
Local Historic Site and list it in the Local Register of
Historic Places, based on positive findings to LDR Section
4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) & (b) Criteria for Designation, "A building,
structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or
aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the
following criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles. "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
III-C HISTORIC BLANK HOUSE
Recommend that the City Commission designate this property as a
Local Historic Site and list it in the Local Register of
Historic Places, based on positive findings to LDR Section
4 .5 . 1(B) (2) (a) Criteria for Designation, "A building, structure,
or site will be deemed to have historical or cultural
significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria:
(a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or
activities of a person important in the City ( for example,
the homestead of a local founding family) .
And Section 4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) & (b) "A building, structure, site of
district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic
significance if it fulfills one or more of the following
criteria. "
(a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history
characterized by one or more distinctive architectural
styles . "
(b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an
architectural style period, or method of construction. "
file/y:staff-2
, j�7 s7 %
Tribute to Belford Shoumate Palm Beach
Community College
Palm Beach County Loses Museum of Art
; „ '���
Prominent Deco Architect - - „,
(F ,, , i
Belford Shoumate, the renowned Lago,the former Palm Beach estate of ./,. ; ,� ' 'i�� � x
- Palm Beach architect who designed Marjorie Merri�\�eather Post and cur- .1 s \aF'f\a� a i\ tIt,,
countless buildings in the Palm Beaches rentl Donald Trump. : .\N •�' ��� Z
-including five Art Deco residences- He is survived by his wife, Betsy V'
died recently on his 88th birthday. and two sons, William (Tec) Stanford `;, k \ -, " ,
The streamline homes,which stand and Thomas Stanford Shoumate. �,� ` ��;� , 'c' �\`
as enduring testimonies to Shoumate's In 1991,ADSPB president,Sharon t ��" �; y_\,�
versatility of design and use of new Koskoff had the rare opportunity to `
materials, include the 162 Peruvian meet and interview Shoumate. ;:_..� ., ) . f'M ,-
Avenue,Palm Beach home of Michele ,Y� "
Wood, and the 1221 Northlake Way, 1 ' Exhibition Schedule
ti
Palm Beach home of Kirby Kooluris, •6 k w� /Beyond the Image
--where-A-DSPB-members-ilave held s.,= -- _ - - Nov. 16, 1991 - -Jon.5,-1992-----,,&„ ✓Selections from local
net:�functions.Shoumate also designed � � � collections
the Shopp House at 3135 Washington :" .4M k, -
�� � Jan. 18 - March 1, 1992
Road, the Jean and Sumner Draper J New. 1Works:New York
house at 140 Monroe Drive, and the , ; March 13 - April 24, 1992
Wagner residence at 2631 Flagler Drive '�K � ✓ From the Store Room
-all in West Palm Beach. ,:$ ' May 9 -June 21, 1992
Shoumate was prominent among :‘(
Palm Beachers interested in historic ,
, sz The PBCC Museum of Art,with the.;.Patrick
reservation, and served for several Lannan Gallery, is one of the A' Deco
p `aty-. treasures of the Palm Beccnes. Originally
nears on the National Committee for � � built as the Lake Avenue Movie Theater in
the Preservation of Historic Buildings.
�\ �� 0 I 1939, is a wonder`ul Art Deco building,
Shoumate was born in Aberdeen, r
\��; noted for its stylized,scupturel verticality.
Ohio in 1903.He was a graduate of the ` �� a and rounded corners.
University of Pennsylvania.Hehelped Belford& Betsy Shoumate, 1984 Call: (407)582-0006.
architect Joseph Urban design Mar-A-
During my month-long visit to � �� Tgsi�� � �
Europe last summer, I had oc �/ Villa
casionto tour Villa Savoye,one of eleven
homes and buildings in the Paris area
built by Swiss architect, Le Corbusier.
--While most of the Le Corbusier
structures are in a state of deterioration x {
andnotopentothepublic,VillaSavoye, -.i._ -_-
was recently restored by the French - _ ' ""
government, and staffed by student 7-'
guides associated with the Ministry of _4 �,
Culture. l
Built in 1931 in the Paris suburb of
Poissy,the Villa Savo e illustrates the Y , ; z "A ftriA ",e
classic International Style of architec Ar
ture.The house has the plan of a per- c '" i, r M L, fi:% ,i
fect square. It is supported on 26 slen-
der columns called pilot'.The semi-cir- cupies one-third of the second-floor show its age by the time the war bega
cular ground floor includes a reception area. Another ramp leads to a roof-top in 1939.
The house is still not in the be
hall,garages,and servants'quarters.A solarium.
sculptural circuiar staircase and a ramp Villa Savove was a casualty of World state of repair. There has not bee
afford accesstO the secondfloor,where War II, during which the Germans re- enough money available to restore
the 40-foot living room is located, as quisitioned and vandalized it. It was perfectly, or recover all its former fu
well as four bedrooms, three baths, built of stucco and other inexpensive nishings. David Bittner
kitchen, and game room. A terrace oc- materials, and therefore, was quick to Editor
,L Wa _ Y_ z �� PROFILE OF BELFORD SIJOUAIAI F_. A.I.A. m . 3 t ,., . -.
t / lilFi t. i sacs -: l++ti'} ••;. 1 , 14. :t '
.: 4. . -sty`._ f,? s
.:4;:.?!. ,..
.,,t,� �. '+'1 @ -vim :.- d.y.��rgay .,,._
eC� a 2 d.t x u 'S !E j
•`*:•i2 -•.** tyo-r' '•'‘U t t*,*.• -, ..,* * A': **'!• •••
t1rq . ;� ., d
5
w
�+i I ,
Mr. Belford Washington Shoumate, A.LA., architect, „_, ,,,,,c_,,,,,,- ,,„
recognized in his field by being listed in "Who's Who in the ;
_ . - South and Southwest" and the history of Florida.. During the •_ :;.
-, last five years, by appointment from Washington, he has served
under Earl Reed, chairman of the National Committee for the -- --•- - -
• Preservation of Historical Buildings, representing the local
chapter of the A.I.A.
When Mr. Shoumate built his own home and apartments
in Phipps Plaza several years ago he effectively used parts of.
the internationally known Bradley Casino, such as the entrance
•
columns, the second floor porci intact, and the old bricks. He
himself built a shipstair and hatch door to his two sons' rooms : ,>:
• = —the material used came from the original Bradley staircase g a : ., __ _-
His wife, Betsy. claims they will have to move out of i"-"•''==" =`'
their home if he continues to collect old gates, mantles, win- :: ` ` __ : .
dows, etc. However, there seems to be no end in view since son Kr.'!' . -•. `-
Tom, age fourteen, has inherited his father's interest and has
started a small museum. of his own, in his room. The older
boy, Ted, has a leaning toward old cars.
Through the years Mr. Shoumate's appreciation of his
fellow architect's work has grown and especially that of the
glamorous Spanish era of Addison Mizner. Members of the ,. ,,,,� .
:. �• i ;; ,,.•� .- _ :.: A.I.A. and many townspeople regretted that a decision to
• �. `iii-•:. demolish the Horace Dodge estate had to be faced, but there 1=Vai`:_:'i`•t '`": `'. 1.?::::
.:: was no other solution. However, the fact that Mrs. Flagler E = : f: ::• :. i. ' :
a"'''''' ''-''`' `-````1 Gonzales, of her own accord, came forward to preserve White ' "-- =` .
hall in memory of her illustrious ancestor, Henry M. Flagler,
has given hope to everyone that there may still be a chance for
' Palm Beach County to preserve part of its famous historical
architecture. After all we do have a fabulous internationally
known resort and there should be reminders of the past to pre-
sent to those who come from all over the world to visit us.
In Newport, the Vanderbilt family has set up a fund to
preserve its estate as a tourist attraction. All over the country
similar efforts are being made.
There are twenty one buildings, from this vicinity, to be
filed with the Library of Congress in Washington. Whitehall
is number one on the list.
Mr. Shoumate says: Our American Heritage is being
challenged in many ways. It's time for us to wake up and ► * -� "E
realize that ,we have a wonderful history for such a" young -:
. country and we should preserve its form of government as weu , " •• :•'
. .-. . as its representative buildings for posterity! ._ . • . . ... •
1d- 40.w:4•L7 . .-yn... a .,L_.- a:I•L+" i�v±� - F^L-'. ,_r::. _ .-0,4 Tua+se.,..:-...Br-"Htit.:'
Jack Walter was in town as a guest of the Historical Society:or their possibility for in-place presery ation and sensitive adaptive use of the 58
17th annual meeting. In his breakfast address,Walter stimulated and historic houses in the proposed Hillcrest Neighborhood Historic
challenged municipal officials in the county to plan more carefully for District. The Agreement is designed to bring the Hillcrest Noise
preservation before a crisis situation arises and also encouraged these Abatement Project into compliance with Section 106 of the National
leaders to use their decision making powers to,make crucial votes in Historic Preservation Act. The rezoning issue is a matter now before the
favor of historic preservation. Mary Mooney, Director of the N-1 i1P's West Palm Beach City Council.
Heritage Society,was also in town to promote their membership and
programs.
c1, Bey �l. F ': j. � ! 1 •
�i 7 fK
e 4f. J 4. a a.r 4
•
? WY v, �?.• :i ILL---;---•.f7j `'� '' _ act' ••~.' g` ' �E.
.•3• 1 `' •:s g+r '�c y3—.p_.,,;,'i y.-'� • .• fF•� 4 <.�V?'. ±sue-z.,,, ' '
:l . - - w!. ,!,til �33 9f{.L'r ' 'ate' .i ` 'I `� : t--4 (i�.- .,I- -
y', .4,. �` Y t mi. �...Ill'a�� nor ' ,...„ •- .j ; 'cars•
Ili #:�F __: fi _ _ - ,n itlui.I1:I t .:'.'}gyp .titre �� `r'.� :`,a rti•
`
--- ,'. :- '''',fi5E1 :• - ,--:74'iTi'lr- •iv:,-;ai'll..431-g.--... ---e•-• :".Z..--1:4 -ti. 7-:....:i --h451
l i,
R'�iY• r iF a y�'� `1 7 "v' r .�xf �'lk- ,,41 ., `1_t__ ..
'..,, `S 4.? '�1` as!'''�t' j �4' "'*.,li ar (�..
Monterey Style 11a se,I936 r �.31=y _
Photo by John P.JohnNon .-
Cthrt '..•:unit 1••a:tr..-alk tns.anatchee`ationat Wildlife Reins,:
e.)art!non P.Johnson
Hillcrest Neighborhood.When it was announced in:he Suns::ter
of 1987 that the County Department of Airports would begin to b 'cut Cypress Swamp Boardwalk.The Cypress Swamp Boardwalk is a
the houses in the Hillcrest Neighborhood.that were in the:ii;-::ua:h cf tranquil Oasis It\ated at the Arthur R. Marshall Loxahatchee National
jets arriving and departing from nearby Palm Beach lr,terna:cnai Wildlife Refuge. halt-aay between Boynton Beach and Delray Beach,
west of U.S.High^..1y 4.1 1 The Boardwalk in this"River of Grass",a term
.-�irpoict. the residents questioned the fate of their ercee::':. •a_::c_: a
voluntary program,about 360 houses in the area could be:-urcitased for coined for the E•.erglades by conservationist Marjorie Stoneman
about$30 million during four to Frye years. The area is bou::'ded b,• Douglas, is only one of the features that attracts visitors to the Refuge.
Ridgewood Avenue,Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and 1.terse::e'' Established in 1'-",-I the Refuge acts to protect migratory birds as part of
During the winter and spring of 1989 the Cityof'X'es:Pain:Bea,:h and the Migratory Laud Treaty Act with Canada and Mexico.
the HPBCPB received numerouscalls from residents aircet the h.:tur_of Trained in the natural sciences and public outdoor recreation, the
their propeny and many questioned what coundbe done toprctec:he Refuge staff provides guided strolls along the boardwalk for school
houses that might be historically or architecturally s:gnii:cara. children, naturali<ts and bird watchers. Along the .-t mile boardwalk,
Preliminary surveys by Beth Miller of the City's Plano:eo tie^:tea:went bleached stumps •d ,-.press trees poke their heads from the murky
indicated that in fact many houses were significant. The i-iPBCPB swamp waters. that are tinted dark by the tannic acid from decaying
notified the State Historic Preservation Officer who in turn:ct fled the leaves. Many of the cypress heads are mottled with red lichen growth
Federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation. The National and many species of ferns t leather,sword,shield,strap,royal,etc.)are
Historic Preservation Act of 1966 gave the Council jurisdiction'Ayer the also protected.Clinging to the trees in the swamp are air plants,orchids
use of federal funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect and Spanish moss The 4i)0)acre Cypress Swamp is pan of a stand that
on cultural resources. once stretched from east of lake Okeechobee south into Broward
In November 1988 a draft Programmatic Agreement was presented by County.The swamps traditionally acted as buffers between the Glades
the State Historic Preservation Officer to the Federal:\viation Administration and drier coastal:u ens.Au iunci 1900 most of the large cypress trees were
and the County Department of Airports.The draft Agreement listed :0 logged out, making the few remaining cypress stands all the more
properties within the project that were considered to be individually precious.
eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. An Other activities at the Refuge include an observation tower,the Marsh
additional 28 properties were considered contributing :e an h:s.>ric Nature Trail and tire Everglades Canoe Trail that travels 5.5 miles in the
district and the remaining 296 were considered not to he ;I ::r:.,a:::- "River of Grass" The L"xaihachee Natural History Association,formed
The Agreement speciticall'said that negotiations for:he a._.t•. :::..a of in 19.82, is the n')new f it cooperating assocation of the Loxahatchee
all properties should proceed as scheduled. Most . it National\L iidlfie Rettige The LNHA works closley with Refuge staff to
contained provisions for the City of Wes: Palm lieac'.t to . ...-:der raise public a:caateness ,)t environmental problems and the needs of
rezoning from residential to some :alternative use to :11,........ wildlife. For inl •na:rti'•n .about LIINA•s membership program or the
preservation of all or part of the identified hist,•rIc h,,usesThe Refuge,call the`•isit,,r Center at-3-f-S30 .
Programmatic Agreement also provides a marketing;':-... .: _. •:.: :,•.
plan.. :a rehabilitation plan. a documentation nIan . r .. .. .-. . a
demolition plan.
The intent of the Programmatic Agre•_raent : :
5 e 1 er
t-g
NPS Form 10-900-a
(Rev. 8-86)
Wisconsin Word Processing Format
(Approved 3/87)
United States Department of the =nteror
National Park Service
National Register of Historic daces
Continuation Sheet
El Cid Historic District
Section 7 Page 6 West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, FL
examples include the garage-apartment at 257r Granada Road, a twc-
story, stuccoed structure with a parapet and round-arched openings
(1925 , photo 11) ; and the garage at 299r Granada Road (1923) , with
its rough stucco exterior, parapet, and barrel-tile-clad pent roof
on brackets (photo 12) .
A related style is the Monterey, which was built between 1930 and
:he mid-1950s . The Monterey style combines elements of the New
ngland Colonial and Spanish Colonial building traditions, in
imitation of the Anglo-influenced Spanish Colonial buildings of
northern California. Monterey houses are two-story side-gabled or
gabled-ell buildings with a full-facade, second-story, cantilevered
balcony on the front, and a heavy exterior gable-end chimney. The
exterior finish can be brick, stucco, clapboard, or vertical board.
Often, the first story finish is brick or stucco, and the second
story finish is wood. Paired windows with shutters are typical .
Monterey houses generally do not have decorative details, except
perhaps in the balcony strade. Wood balconies are typical of
Monterey houses of the =330s and 1940s . Cast iron balconies are
common on examples from the 1950s . 8 There are nine excellent pre-
1945 Monterey homes in the El Cid district, all of which have been
identified as potentially individually eligible for listing on the
National Register. 9 The Norton House at 253 Barcelona Road (1924,
NRHP) was originally Mediterranean Revival in style . In 1937, Palm
Beach architect Marion Sims Wyeth redesigned the building in the
Monterey style (photo 13) . -� The Norton House is finished with
stucco, quoins, a door with a simple classical surround, and a
second story balcony with an intricate balustrade . The Hillbreath
House at 219 Dyer Road (1940, photo 14) has a clapboard exterior
and features a partially-enclosed second story balcony, exposed
rafters and a heavy brick chimney. The other pre-1945 Monterey
-McAlester, pp . 430-433 .
9Files of the City of West Palm Beach Historic Preservation
Planner.
13John Johnson and Vicki Cole, "Ann Norton House and Sculpture
Gardens, " National Register nomination, 1990 .
NPS Form 10-900-a
(Rev. 8-86)
Wisconsin Word Processing Forma:
(Approved 3/87)
United States Department of the ::.ce: cr
Nacional Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
El Cid Historic District
Section 8 ?age 10 West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, FL
high society families . In 1925 , Fatio established a branch office
in Palm Beach. Born to a wealthy family himself, Fatio was
comfortable in Palm Beach society and was able to promote his work
through his social activities . He quickly became one of Palm
Beach' s most active and best architects . Fatio is especially noted
for his Italian-influenced Mediterranean Revival designs, but was
highly skilled in other modes as well .56 One of his best known
buildi._cs is the Society of the Four Arts Library in Palm Beach.
In E_ Cid, Fatio enlarged and redesigned the Mediterranean Revival
house at 262 Barcelona Road (1937) , designed the Monterey style
Mann House at 204 Valencia Road (1936) , the Colonial Revival
Kallman House at 2421 South Flagler Drive (1936) , and the Art
Moderne Rinker House at 2111 South Flagler Drive (1938) .
Palm Beach architect Belford Shoumate (1903-1991) designed at least
five buildings in the El Cid Historic District . A graduate of the
University of Pennsylvania School of Architecture Shoumate first
worked for Joseph Urban in New York City. Urban was the architect
who designed Mar-A-Lago (National Historic Landmark) in Palm Beach.
Shoumate ' s first design in South Florida was the home at 1221 North
Lake Way in Palm Beach. Built in 1937, this Art Moderne residence
was named "The House of the Future" at the 1939 New York World' s
Fair. Shoumate opened an office in Palm Beach in 1938, and
designed over 1 500 buildings in 50 years of active practice in
South Florida. 5' In El Cid, Shoumate designed the Art Moderne
Wagner House at 2631 South Flagler Drive (1937) , the Mount Vernon
Motor Court at 310 Belvedere Road (1941, second building 1948) , the
Spellerberg House at 200 Belmont Road (1941) , the Johnson House at
190 Sunset Road (1939) , and the house at 266 Flamingo Road (1940) .
The latter four are modern buildings, with spare classical details,
in a style Shoumate called "Bermuda. "58
: Alexandra Fatio, Maurice Fatio : Architect, (Stuart : South-
eastern Printing, 1992) , pc . 4-8 .
' "Architect Leaves imprint on South Florida Landscape, " Palm
Beach Daily News, August 21 through 28 , 1988 , p. B9 .
- m__oumate Files, Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach.
BP100I03 City of Delray Beach Florida 7/15/03
Land Legal Description Inquiry 16 : 17 : 12
Property . . : 20 N SWINTON AVE
12 43 46 16 01 060 0120
Legal Description
TOWN OF DELRAY
LT 12 (LESS S 4 FT ADDL R/W
FOR ALLEY LYG S OF & ADJ TO)
BLK 60 (OLD SCHOOL SQUARE
HISTORIC DISTRICT)
Press Enter to continue.
F3=Exit F12=Cancel
• JUN- 9-1 95 u:7ari, 95-;2O6 0
ORB 8812 Ps 1003
1 IIIIMILIMINEll1111111 ME
ORDINANCE NO. 27-95 -
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, DESIGNATING THE MONTEREY
HOUSE, LOCATED AT 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE, AS MORE
N\ PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AS A LOCAL HISTORIC
„j SITE; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP
OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, 1994" TO SHOW THE HISTORIC
N DESIGNATION IN AN OVERLAY MANNER; PROVIDING A GENERAL
REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE
S DATE.
WHEREAS, Section 4 . 5. 1 of the Land Development Regulations
.,' of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach provides for the
r , designation and protection of historic sites; and
WHEREAS, the Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency has
nominated the property described herein to be designated as a local
historic site; and
NN
- WHEREAS, a designation report was prepared concerning the
Li ' designation of the property located at 20 North Swinton Avenue to the
ILocal Register of Historic Places; and
WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of
Delray Beach held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the
designation of the property as a local historic site; and •
L\ WHEREAS, on May 3, 1995, the Historic Preservation Board of
the City of Delray Beach recommended that the property described
1' herein be designated a local historic site; and
N
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has
. conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation
of the property described herein as a local historic site.
'J
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
--(( CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
' `1
Section 1 . That the following described property in the
. City of Delray Beach, Florida, is hereby designated as a local
historic site in accordance with and under the provisions of Section
4 . 5 . 1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach,
Florida, to-wit:
THE MONTEREY HOUSE, located at 20 North Swinton
Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida; more particularly
described as follows:
• ORB ar 81 2 F3 1001
Lot 12, Block 60, DELRAY BEACH (FORMERLY TOWN OF •
LINTON) , as recorded in Plat Book 1 at Page 3 of the
Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida.
Section 2 . That the Planning Director of said City shall,
upon the effective date of this ordinance, amend the Zoning Map of the
City of Delray Beach, Florida, to show the historic designation, in an
overlay manner.
Section 3 . That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in
conflict herewith be, and the same are hereby repealed.
Section 4 . That should any section or provision of this
ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be
declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such
decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a
whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid.
Section 5 . That this ordinance shall become effective
immediately upon passage on second and final reading.
PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final
reading on this the 6th day of June , 1995 .
MAYR
ATTEST: r i
/�
filt;W779V- ,iftil,) l76i This instrument was prepared by:
City Clerk Susan A. Ruby, City Attorney
200 N.W. 1stAvenue
First Reading May 16, 1995 DBeach,Beach, FL 33444
Second Reading June 6, 1995
- 2 - Ord. No. 27-95
ORB 13812 Ps 100..
DOROTHY H. WILK;EN1 CLERK PE COUNTY FL
CERTIFICATION
I, ALISON MacGREGOR HARTY, City Clerk of the City of Delray Beach,
Florida, do hereby certify that the above and foregoing is a true and
correct copy of Ordinance No. 27-95 which was passed by the Commission
on the 6th day of June, 1995.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and the official
seal of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, on this the 26th day of
June, 1995.
ice r<fe4' 7//aLt
Alison MacGregor Hare
City Clerk
City of Delray Beach
SEAL
•
•
- 3 - Ord. No. 27-95
I
0
HI
U
'- 0' 20'-6' 10'-10• w
r
:n 0
,Z, CO
O o
U
t.
O 4
�,_4. � . -
• . o
r' U�
Hi LL 73
b
o � %1/40
o
cit GARAGE '�
•
ARCHITECT: SHOUMATE, BELFORD �, : , 0 .
e CONS I HUCTION DATE: 1939 �' "
tP, — STYLE: FRAME
FOUNDATION TYPE: CONTINUOUS CONCRETE , 0
STRUCTURE: BALLOON WC ,D FRAME , .,�
STOR.
EXTERIOR FINISH: WF i HERBOARD ;�III / ����,
1 • ROOF TYPE: r _4E
1 w
�I
$; SWIMMING
FAMILY ROOM POOL (/)
i 4
.,--A' N N Z Q
I
s1CR
- -- - - - - - 1 Rom. up0 Q W
s SPACE
i 4j1 '' s \I \\\ ' . 1 —I 1
CC
w
KITCHEN HALL. --- C/� CC
UJ
"_lI_ --. _i_,_i _ _ "--6. _ __ -9' CL
16' 4'
co V— M
- !JcL
1 CL.; ) CC CD
-
i BATH CL" � O 1.
ammo ,
aPearo , I I
I
I I
f I I
b Q ROOM DMINNG LMMN�G Fr. BEDROOM . 4 s p p
t f OM • I p I t' t
h Q tC
1 T
• .
r I HOUSE
fl�-8' VI a' 2'-4' I 12'-4' ,
1
_inium
111.MiliMaIMMEW __ 1
T P CAl I j ♦ %
SHUTTERS
I ! revisions
+ _,__ ,,PEN - y+ ABow
r � PROPERTY LlNE �---�
, L------L-----_—_—_—_------. ---------
IT HILLCREST BLVD.
date 10-15-1991
drawn M.N.G.
(
CD_____ _RST
FI FLOOR PLAN SITE PLAN checked
mmummummENIO
- -
o SCALE V4' -1-0' /� NTH
�, Rt
C1!VET
SE
D ,h e c t i
c
k
W - MAR 23 1995
�. 1 ()f 2
PLANNING b ZONING
91240-19
mo
/ 1
0
H
U
35 0'
�- — — - CO
O
4-0' 17'-8' 13-4' OU mot-
� . O t
C `°
. � O
H L LJ
Zi
cd
o ao
u ccl
a U
a) 'cj
c x
- `�it- 0
- _ '
F
l
d
16.-6'
♦ ♦
W
io
. II
BEDROOM Z ci
o >
III 1- -I
Q 00
N I 1,---- �"
TRIMMED LLI
RIDGE OPENING - V
J rya
i � U11J
VAMT1' A J
8LCIlO DOOR TOPII
J
1 __ - — BATH
bo CL. I HALL Q
S ' -I I 5'-10' i 5'-0' U M
1
4 1
SU°"°� DOOR D Q cc o
O r
la f_ 4 i--
cn
I
4iv, DN o C,L CL. CL. N
CIED
OPENNG
,;cal 1411
AR
HALL
ho . 11 1 0
if
) RIDGE i Co BEDROOM O BEDROOM 10
N
1 ao BATH
1 a
------ --- ---
13'-0• T-r 12'-4'
revisions
Q COVERED BALCONY 4
'v - RALNC3 'v
1 1 ------ - —ram
date 10-15-1991-15-1991
---- 35-0' _ drawn M.N.G.
checked
ct PCIEWED
, . CDSECOND FLOOR PLAN sheet
N
U
MAR 23 1995 2
o .
LI
PLANNING &ZONING 2 of 2
WIL
J
W project no.
91240-19
1
_► _______ - -