Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
238 SE 7th Avenue, *1937 - FMSF
/26/2006 14:41 FAX 5612437221_/! DELRAY BCH COMM IMP-P& _ [j001 .T- W W W W W W W W W W W W W W ********************* *** TX REPORT *** ********************* TRANSMISSION OK TX/RX NO 1839 RECIPIENT ADDRESS 99544291207 DESTINATION ID ST. TIME 04/26 14:36 TIME USE 05'07 PAGES SENT 19 RESULT OK • PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT 100 N_W. 1st AVENUE DaMBEACH Ci• s ` DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 Aue; ;.:' �;, A icac 4,1.E` cz, (561) 243-7040 ` 400, .4 Y 8- (561) 243-7221 FAX 00 1993 e-mail: pzmailOmydelraybeach.com 2001 FASCIMILE COVER SHEET DATE: Ot d , TO: C'bAr\ M2Q I/' 0 , Itasp ��,L29 . l` - FROM: _ Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: COMMENTS 1` IAA, L...La(e.4) _ ��,1...;__Z)1‹T C `D-'), 1 ti r • . I> LcJ() /J 0C,2-eat---)A-- ' PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT :4: 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE DELRAYBEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 All-Arne ��. v (561) 243-7040 ' (561) 243 7221 FAX e-mail: pzmail(a�mydelraybeach.com 2001 FASCIMILE COVER SHEET DATE: a TO: JUlL TVLQ FROM: Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: COMMENTS Mc Palm Beach County Property ,=.iser Property Search System Page 1 of 2 , I li I,1 e i t: i / l it t ti ir' P a l a a i :a 41;-u E I - Property Information Location Address: 238 SE 7TH AVE View Map Municipality: DELRAY BEACH Parcel Control Number: 12-43-46-16-B3-000-0150 Subdivision: GRACEY-BYRD Official Records Book: 04819 Page: 1072 Sale Date: Feb-1986 Legal Description: GRACEY-BYRD LT 15 (LESS E 20 FT SE 7TH AVE R/W) &S 10 FT OF LT 16 (LESS E 20 FT SE 7TH AVE R/W) - Owner Information Name: DIETRICH DANIEL G All Owners Mailing Address: 238 SE 7TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 5241 Sales Information Sales Date Book/Page Price Sale Type Owner Feb-1986 04819/1072 $73,500 WARRANTY DEED DIETRICH DANIEL G - Exemptions Historic 10 Year Ex - Pbc/mun: Yes Year of Exemption: 2006 Regular Homestead: $25,000 Total: $25,000 - Appraisals Tax Year: 2005 2004 2003 Tax Year 2005 Improvement Value: $146,256 $133,986 $126,395 Number of Units: 1 Land Value: $272,160 $194,400 $200,000 *Total Square Feet: 1855 Total Market Value: $418,416 $328,386 $326,395 Acres: 0.16 Use Code: 0100 Description:RESIDENTIAL * in residential properties may indicate living area. - Assessed and Taxable Values Tax Year: 2005 2004 2003 Assessed Value: $115,360 $112,000 $109,912 Exemption Amount: $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 Structure Detail Taxable Value: $90,360 $87,000 $84,912 - Tax Values Tax Year: 2005 2004 2003 Tax Calculator Ad Valorem: $1,394 $1,347 $1,310 Non Ad Valorem: $158 $158 $158 Details Total Tax: $1,552 $1,505 $1,468 Back to Search Previous Page Print NOTE: Lower the top and bottom margins to 0.25 on File->Page Setup menu option in the browser to print the detail on one page. Record Search I Information l Exemptions I Community I Employment I New Home Buyer I Office Locations Value Adjustment Board I Save Our Homes I Senior Corner I Disclaimer http://www.co.palm-beach.fl.us/papa/aspx/web/detail_info.aspx?p_entity=12434616E 3 000... 4/26/2006 es: • DISTRICT • CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA �, j .. • SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT � � "� Improved OWNER %��r .� r l • sa y�� Vacant ADDRESS _ - r+ y-. ��L-4`7',•7 '�-/.(<�� 'r;. ,%(.6 r�% _ — 119 16 & Exempt - - Jf ' DESCRIPTION: S 10' of 16 & All of 15 N • l' of lir c OWNER Chester L. Newman, ADDRESS 216 SE 7th Ave. y.• • • 1\, S/ /�jGv� NER !u�U �' (^h-- 4�p"U�� Y i�// !/fl�/� ADDRESS YEAR- 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 EXEMPTION I� I .�/ / �j /' q �j '�/ LAND 7cc..S -() ( I� ,�j ey d r • ! I Coe' 2(ZJ © I Yo �c� - /yore /G d 0 /edo / -'c'-7 / / C�"'i BLDGS. ..`T�S•, D.b �. O a r.60 A `�/r/1 G� .2J)-✓��Y�fj f U �j7 /5C)G+9 Jr/0�� �0 / d TOTALS .L / %jOO J� O O�. 3/J K' o� � i`01 �7' U r/- G, !�30 LO 3o o lJ 3 Cr--0 41 . //v�� f� qq J P F t /1 �1 PER. PROP. 7.:."f� , O3 • tl�ir� °" -. C,1.S J C.t-0 v v S C ..) a-cn 3 ere.) ."" ... 'z"-�,..) 'C) U V 4-iv7',S • 6e, At. 7�(TNANi TGddCA ILI5ING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS • DESCRIPTION OF BUI}„D N ) / 7 7r v. �[V-57"4'1.71Cr LF? I — --- ---- N0. SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS I '_.Singie Dwlg• None ....H../Gable Plaster Sprink. (Fire) �I — -- X y 2- e __Double Uwlg• Part Hip Pine.Deco tod - _ _ _ _ �— ci_ __.Pine ......-_-Fire Escapes — — �— 1 I I _......_Duplex Dwlg. .______-Full Flat Hardwood Refrigerators — �f Z$ -------Metal --- `2 I(. - I I X _____.Apartment ____._.Dirt Floor fdansard Marble&Tile Vac.C.Sys. I [—_-- - ------- __..Store Cement Floor Panels LI U — VI u^-Sk�- PORCHES Skylights __—_Store&Office Finish t Cr V _ 1 1 1 1 _Z Hone X Rear Steel Beams J -- ; — LOOKS Fireplaces - Store&Apt. X Front ,Er ---- HEATING - __-Wood Joists Incinerators ---- �yt,L�—I_II—I_I I_____ C•r ______-_Office Mill Solar W.Sys. ------/_ -t _ ei X/a> q7 r Hotel — Air Con.Sys. --- — - — --- — -- - Reinf.Concrete _ t -____Theatre Stoves X Sleep. Refnf.Tile `_L10-- — CONDITION ______Garage(Apt.) -------011 Burner Dirt --,— ---�--_— F11 e EXT. WALLS FACTORS _ -, I GOOD FAIR BAD -- Garage(Sere.) f I— -- -t I j Garage(Prvt.) food Siding Y/FLOOCING -_No.of Rooms J—'— ---- , r -f- I_ (•// CO STRUCTION Gas Station brick Pine Apartments Hardwood __ 1'' ____School Wood Frame Brack Cased Rooms&Apt. Vtj 7 1-1 Concrete ' --- Lumber Sheds Steel Frame Stucco Tile ......._..Fin.Attic R. . I Reinf.Concrete Metal Marble Fin.Base.R. I --�� ---" �---� I'�I�— MIII Block Terrazzo o --� --- y -- — CAA, -Se.FT. V.P. T ROOFING - — PLUMBING .-:Date Complt. I LT —I_I�I-•r _t?= _ I 1 I 1 I _ Cj i.. Shing e Concrete Tile V ....._.Brick Shingle --FixturesRemodeled ----� M 41 �r ----- ` 4.,, Petall&Gravel it FOUNDATIONS `�EPlain OXT.rnamental ! Toilets IGHTING H �I 1 c— _ • 1 H—E• — R�zCAP TUT VALUATION Y-_.Composition _____-_Slate ._...-Concrete �j Wood '_-_.Tile Floor Electric --- -_..Brick Stucco Tile Floor H � $ •�1 +°a Tile—Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Oaths,Bulit•In Gas . I I ,__�ti__—_ _ Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps I 1 I _ I I 1 m I LLLL__-_ LAND APPRAISAL -1 I I I I I LI _ __ _ ,1. I _ ) I I Ill I ____ ADDITIONAL Front and Depth I� .7d-- —v 1i I IT � ! ' I I I �i BUILDINGS • Unit Depth Corner Front p Price Factor Factor Foot Value Valuation LOTS ACREAGE ST. IMPROVEMENTS p �b ee. {/ 0 X /r-> 3 - ,�? / • Level Level Dirt _-__jam Hlgh HIlly TOTAL / Rocky .------Sidewalk . BUILDINGS $ •(y O X Low Curb , •. Rocky Swampy Enbagcing Factor __d!'Water TOTAL ._______Swampy Farm 'ewer Detracting Factor % ACRES <J Wooded /`' LAND • ' .- -Electric Light TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION Gas AND BLDGS. $ ' DISTRICT William. J. & Brenda J. Nelson • CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 23.8 SE 7th Ave. ,. Delx.ay Bch. ,F1.334 # IAA SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT I Improved OWNER Chootor L. TcwTIian 119 Vacant ADDRESS 38'&.E• "1 ADO. i De11Day a�CCoh,^'-1a• 7 Exempt E are �i�5 a.ea ADDRESS DESCRIPTION: S 101 of 16 & All of 15 OWNER qL0J ..a �,n.. s nrt ... n lid OWNER QuenLiiu M. & 16:arT P. Bishop 238 S.E. 7th Ave. ADDRESS P.O. Dux 18.83, Bclraq B-Lacc1.1, Fla. 33-44 YEAR— 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 EXEMPTION LAND /f vr r /P/" / �l' /918 . /9.�R /93'8 ,2 8 •74/y4 BLOCS. L// K / I / t '/i./C I eT'V 'TI7- 6 ` i L 6 +`,�//2_3 •f/ (l �' ['/ TOTALS l /0-0� t , e-� l7 /� O/ 00 U I^I 00 6/ �0t 0 7 t) ,4p d j am® — PER. PROP. (� 3oo 3O0 3oo goo 3O0 ,�trtp , \ I)• BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING 1.--- — - ---_ _ ._. ._.__..... _._--.._.-- P ei SIZE 3r1'PE BLDG. ?ANENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS S E HE GHT STO IES -_—..Plaster -..•_..-.SingleOwl,. Nona Gable Decoratd ....._..Sprink. (Fire) ---_.— —-- — —��_�... .. �) y X Double Dwig• Part Nlp _Pine Fire Escapes , _.._..__. _ �:�_ <. �1,� Hardwood __—_--..._....Duplex Dwlg. Fell Flat .__•_..Metal Refrigerators _--- — �� �� X �y Apartment Dirt Floor Mansard Marble&Tile Vac.C.Sys. __ : /M' � �� • / 94 .._.....Store Cement Floor pOR ES Panels kylights ,,f•9/J X ji•P Store&Office Finish }, (�/( /TLOORS .-yr Fireplaces . �� �p �/ X O Front ✓ Cfi /� __Store&Apt. .... ..Wood Joists Incinerators _........_ ._.....--.__.-. Y , • -..._.-..Office HEATING X Side MIII Solar W.Sys. _ 1'11 1 i el Mai 1A5 8X „ V..Hotel None X Rear Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. -------- ' � ` -•-•-- Reinf.Concrete i Theatre Stares % Sleep. —__.-.Relnf.Tile 11111 i �f CONDITION Garage(Apt.) ---.-Oil Berner Dirt FACTORS -----.___..-,------ /0 Fireplace T. WALLS /_ I GOOD FAIR BAD _..Garage(Seer.) ,FLOOKING (J ---- - — r > Garage(Pert.) Wood SlJing / -_._.No.of Rooms ._.._._.._.__...... m t , •-•-'.." CO STRUCTION i Pine Gas Station Bnck -----AParlments ---- .—. --— ■ �,� ■ ill . ChurchHardwood _......Wood Frame Brick Cased .._....Rooms&Apt. -----• ------— —- ScColoncrete Lumber Sheds Steel Frame Stucco The Fin.Attic R. --- . �— Reinf.Concrete Metal Marble ✓r�Fin.Base.R. IIIIII �ROOFIN6 Mill Block Terrazzo / —.. _____-__— —_ — SQ.FT. Y.P. TOTfI1- "'' Llnoleem / Date Ccmplt. Brick Shingle Shingle Concrete Tile PLUMBING Ave Pitch&Gravel XT. TRIM None Remodeled �_. .. — FOUNDATIONS / -----•- —. — �_ VALUATION Metal Plain Toilets GHTING RECAPITULATION -_ .-.Composition - Stone Ornamental ...4...,Toilets .._...__....._ ._._.._ _ ._. __._ Q�j .1.Concrete Wood --L-._Bathroom: _ — S 57 .SlateStucco Tile Floor — Electric 11111 .. 3 _._. = Brick... Gas —- --_. _ _ Tile—Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Bdlt•In Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps —.----- — - — — - -- - LAND APPRAISAL ..____._.._.._.....-.._.._.f_......._.-_._.._._....._.. . __.-._.._ _. ._____._.... -._ __.___--.____ ADDITIONAL — BUILDINGS Unit Depth Corner Fran ront and Depth Pri Factor •Factor Foot ale. Valoati n /� t n R Q�j �`� j� LOTS ACREAGE ST.JhiPROYEMENTS V X /�J ,a /t z V __� a /Level Level .e.PavDired TOTAL X High HIIIY Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ / � "— Low Rocky Enhancing Factor r Rnky ' Swampyrm ... °rh TOTAL if. .S' Detracting Factor l % ACRES @ Swampy Farm Water LAND (!„( ........Wooded ewer — TOTAL LAND VALUATION Electric Light ANDACLOGS. S �j / • • ,. ., .. • 1/ Z.,•.;,&. ' • ., . .. . , PR?•'(i T no,.....17,5.7- ,-•-•‘••,'•.•:•••••• — • • , • • . , . . ...,-;:),. '. --,..: ',,...•'- ' ' .' -.1'...i,..,... .7 _ _-‘'..,..(i-:.-•.: ;...!'-' - .'.: -3;.2./„.- . . . , • • . .- ,,r. . .. . . . . - • • •- 1. - '.: :::. -.-ep-.),:•,,-,,,. ,.:•: c,„,, ,,,,,, ,.,>c„..,„.,a..-,.• . ...,.,. . ••:.._;•... . . . . ... .. . : .. :,.-:.:-..,..,. 7 .:.-... - .• . .;:.,,,-,......: ............, . - -:..7,-........:,-,•;„:..,•::•••...,......;,. .., .. .. :::-.. spILD.F.R.4..-.7.777::::;•. : ;,....,...,7.••!•;,••• , ,:.. • ' , • . . .. . . . ... . . .... .. ._. ,. . ... .„ . .. . . . . ... .... • . . , .. .. . . . . . . . . , . ., . . . . . . . `•-• • • • • • c. ,.. ',;'., ;,,, •-..."-''':;•••••,'..'-',(..."•-.'.:•;..,•-;•,•:•• '':::: ......'.,,•••-:"--: ,-.. .., ;'••-* ,. .". ,•":; '.4.i.,":',.±•••“),Z1,?jf•*':'.' iali'f.:,,I!'•*'!'..C.".. .'.,';.;?7"--,,;? . •S l'.'..' i.,'/.;:.!-..... ":_.." ';',,....,....:.,..-:.,;.:"r"..:''..:•;s7:','',A:.k...:.;,'...'--:'::''''...;•..-,-; - 7'.'',".....-- -s'..';'-j:::''',',‘• -,i,,:' -....1,1.:-•' .0,•',,:.;••.11.'K!"-.tegc,:,--f-;-:::, -'. .,.......,..7',..:.;A:(,,---.1,if,_,-:;.,:..; ;.-.7,•;./.,r,.. :''--: .....,.-''*'-,..',....'••.':'-•.':,.;,;',.'''.... .. ':-.: *.:-..-,':7.:';',,:*•e;.1 -'`'..-` ... .••' .‘....'•: ':,. ' ..• • '*7'.;* ;,•:.:•-•:.:;:,•i>!'''.: • ;-Y•7 *-'-':--:;- '''• •••-•-:'...;:-"•';••'.f*.°'''.**'''':'*-. • -•;;....'•';';*,,:<•.''s.'•••• .".i"."....'";'`......'.;..;.): :li--"•.:..',,,..,•,•,'p,;;',.,..'.:!.',,./75.....,;".,.`,;.•• .7. ..:.,?..,,,.:;'•';.;.,;'. •.:• ....:. . ••.. .: , -..i.,.;.;...••;,..•..., c-:,,,,,v.-. ...... . . . . '. . .- . ''''.: ' ' .::•. .... -...• -7.'•'''.. ''L..1.: ''''' .'. ' *.•-•,',';,7,*.':. **.:-;:'-',--.•••.:. ..."..S:**,-:.•,....,:::;.:::.',•,7,.1,,'It,:•,;.r.,,,,,,:s::,,,...,.._:;•.,..0,:\::-7',•-i:',.'3.:-',..n..-.; ::':::-74,-. ::•-,.•..,..:;.„...-..I.• ... „•:;•.::';',.'7,•7:7...•7.;; s:-..: ,....- . . ,i • • . ..,..7........'"...:;--..1..:;:l• '-: '.:- •• : . .;.: ''',7,. çr j.;-•'- ;.........*;,..',,.'..,"...;t.i4.ir!....",i' S`. .;'.-:,..::-::'-:•. 1.**: ,''.'.,'*4::;''' ..'.';'%-"‘.*,':::i....,*!.'','•'?'''•,."‘.%.-A.".',::"Zr•N' TZ,:,';': .‘;:,•.:*:'::,..:',;?....,:. ......:;:•;.::;:s.......:: . '... '. :::'....:•;••.„,1..,';-,L.:...,....::;;:.,t.:.......;,.::-.::Js..:•-.--. , •. . .,, „,.,........,.. , , ,, . ,....:......,,,.,;.s.......-.....,-,•,,,--; :,...:,;,-...J.7...,,:.7,•-:,,,,,, ;.;,.77,:;.•T.;:-,,,.'-,....,. .:.:... -,..,;:;,-..':;,...:,...--.i.,.., ..,,,t-..),::-.2,..::::;:::.'''..:.':.:cy:]:...'...',' -,.'•':,..'•'.....',......i .:-;T:,'-,-::;:... . ..:2,,--.'•':g.,...'.:-.;::::::::::.1,7:7?-:...'-.::,..::•..';',;,4.::-..4:z4-:..--.r.'....:.?:::-':---': ' .. - . . ; ;,. ...:,. i - ;'.f. .:7---C-'::- ...r:::,-•'•'' o:,'. .....-' •;•C.'.. ,-...: ...:;,-., •:-..*.±.-..„:!...i.::.:...: .;: -,...„,„;;J,-,.. ...:;'.i;; ;.::::-....,:• 4_,'..,..f.,.::;;;,.-.., •;.34::. ..f;', :.,'.,•:,...,;; ;:,....i ',..i.,',,.:', ...:;..:.;:.... .T.:•..--;i, ;:.*'.:Fi,.ir,?,.,`Z3,..7..;......,:......."........,,,'.,;7:;"•..:fdl;:it7.'•..?3• ;.1.:1:',-•''-;;;'''.'.•'.-'7••=-.''''':--"-..--!f---''''''''.7-7'''''''' : ......:,:- •, .:„.,.... ..,----_-,..•:... ...... ..,.... .,,, ..,..,:.,..........:. j.,..i,,,..,.......,-.:,,„...,....,:..,....;,,,,4,..,4;:_v...;...z.i,,vi,..;,...:•::,..--,f.... -..,....;:,.-:....,,.,...r....,1.7,-,-,::',:,.,;,,,:f!,;-,..,':',-...,,..,;•••,,,,....-,,,,,,,,....,:::,,i,....y.;,,,,,;;;...1.,...„.:„..,::: :4,...,,,,..:,-..-4,,,,,,,,,,,,,„:::::,.::::::-_-;;;.;:_.,:., ;:7,, ,,..:,, ;,- ,-,--,:-.H,7, ....,;:i.,•,..,;,-..."?..".:',i-:,,.,..::'Ti",;:;",-."..•::,:,,,,, ,i;:-_,, ;-',.';.:;•..7,'," ")..•:"Zy........f.. .5:f,:t'" ':- . , t'---,,.--10,".pi -7 ,..,..------!!!1";iaF '2'?"•'1.1'I...!/,'"."'',7••:::?•-• 11....'.::.-7-;::-'.• • "'-.'. " . •-• - • ' - .' • . • '.: -''''..": •..".:::"?...,.-.5;•.;.. ‘:,,-"•,•;•.,41"- ''.• '-* ' '' — , ,,,,,,,;;;4-1,?M;S:t..:1:••:,'",,,,';‘..'•274f.-.7....?;:1;".•...t -1...."q•-":7';;;;;;!-,•, ,, , '.:-..'....,-;...•.:.,"":":',.:::.;..,•f• -.• 7.•....''.•. ..-,..,:•• .'_::.......•;:::,....,:1,:::__.L., • _...••••","-, ;L' F--;.;.'''''' ::: ... ,,,,,v4,6,,,t;,11- 12:1,1t: $f:'..1" ;.4j7i-Tt'fia-7.•;,i-C7.:%; :; :1-:.'-',"-..:::^-•• ...f"'..4":',"...!.',;•-::).:; •7-. T.:;.:':;4 ... .".",'..,, :-"7'',1:.='.....27..-.1-7.,-..:-.---7,-.. . - .--;.- ;-•••••• --:''-,,'-';'•."..-A',c4:..,....'' ' ''•' . ,t.,.,z-:';‘'-i.,•'-i-.41, ,,,4-,:ic.tt5;:.-:•;i.'±`..- ':.' ' -" .,•;,,, ':';':,;;.:-:.":.,.7:',--.'rj.",..'t.-.:,, i.,.....,:.•..,.',..,....,..::.: .,. , _.i -..., . ,:. .• . . i • 7 - . ! :-,:• • .y... .,,.,,•:.,-;. . , . .:/. .--!:.,..:„,:.•;.,--.-i....'.......;i.':'•-:',,'1,.2,:';.L Y, •••••••••..',:,.:::,.•-,::::•_ ..::.::::: :.•,•••st • . ':,, . .1.:.,, •s ..,•'.•• ,::.•.,:.-• ••: -. • . . ..ft. • . •'•, '..:•,.,•,: •!• • n,.',•:•.:7./.'•...;•:.r:..'.'y... .,„fi.•.....:....•%'i'.'.,•.'.•1.: J:2••••:';;T:,:',••:;...•••.':.;;.''..'''..',.•••.• ."'''''?.',-;2.:;•;'.7...:?:':,"' .•'''.:',......"',•ii':,•,..:•••.,!-,2'7• •.;;••••.' • : . S.'' ••- • • • .•...;.. -".••''....'., ' ' • -;'.c2.'1.•"'' • ' .-'-'.:,:.')•':!••••‘••••:•': '•t.';;.;:=7.;',.';.•':r-•-',i•.f;'.......i.,'/...:,'• ,•.'..,''.:...,,• '-'•:.•:...;..::.....'..:::,-:-::::',7. :": --, .•-•..,-,:-:::--' ' -. , ,,...-.2p • - : ,. . , :::,, , ,r-. - ..,., - .'..„...•.-:, ,_ :. .-.. ....:•.:,.. :•,.::;:•-;;,-7,-,,.... ,.-- :,-,,41.,•....;•zi:..,::!:„.-,..i.,---„-f,.. ....',..•,,;'){:i.:::......,•-:,-..,':-.7.-,:,:...:;,-.....,:::.,_,.:,;::: . ... -,,,,,•-•.::,:.:::,,...-,•„'..."-i.,,...7::• ;•-•'.;•..." • . . •.:;,'":-. .: :..* • ., !',1-. '''-/.= , .,...,;:..:.:.:-...:•••.:,,,:,.:_ ......i-..,,...',..„-;.,....::::-.., ,a-1,,::::‘:•.:.;.i:::.-....tt.:;i7;::., i. ;.7.,:::i.t,,,!/,';',.-,....,-..,,i‘,..„,..::i.,,y,,::::••......:::..,-;:::::.;.:;.::.,..',2•:.t--...,......:,7•::::',:,,... ....:Iii:....:::....i.:-.';'.:-:,...:::',.:......f-:,...i...,'-",,':'.'...::'..:..:::. ..,;..:;• • . -• ...,... : ,••<--, .. . . . ':... . .: .!. . ,...,..,.•••,.. ,.;;-, , ._,. ...;..;,.....,..-,:;:•.,.,•'...;••,-..:-.• -.....n.;..;.'' :'.:,:4i::::.;...7,..,.....,;1.:;•:•.:,:,•:..:.2 .',;; ;...;',:•:::.. .:5( ..... ':-...-• .-*.............,i,.,,;.,:;,..•• •••:',../:".':.:;:.,i-;,:..''''. 2.,..-'.';.....;;.-.TY,...-..".., *..•'1'..'•-•.-;',..5. ' - . . . . . ' '• '..••.. •••-'• ' '• • ' . ". '''.-''''-'"-::*'-''''''''---`"'"':"--•:-'•'''"--'''1.,'-'''''''"''''',:4. .---4..;.•'::,5,7;-•'''''' 'i;F"..'';'-',:..'.:,..:::...::. =•-',7;.....-: ::::.,:-.:.•".7 ' •••, 4.';',..:',..'":::. . . .,.,.._: ..,, .,,.,' .. .. ...••,:. • '' : 'ts. • , .:'....:":•'..,.-:'.'. ' :,'./ '.,..,‘::::. .,...'77.-...,,,',...::Z.,..:::'X';'...1.;.7,'`',:...: ',',"'?'''',T;.,f1...:',:':,:n.'', 7:3:."-''';',"47:N:;.;";4 c.'-'4---;;z.:',..,..,..::: -/6,':::::::.,,:',:,-;-:.',7,:f":-,--'''.'''.:'..."•'.Z`..,;...-':...;f.-:'-!..,'.'.--..f.:. ' f':--..'..-= '.. - • • --.- . ' - . •• '. .),:. , ., ... .•.1...-. ......:-:.. • :.,:::.,...-:.i.,.:?.:;',':-::;:-!;".:-1..'..7;:.i'::''''.:..:';',: : :..-2.4;':::',-..';•/:-4.tig:..-... ..;',.:,54k.1',':;-',4.:;.;".....i:.1:.::'..;',.. .',•:.. .........;: -.,....1:'':-= :'-'6.--'.-':',.;'='..:-.T.-7:".'.1':.:'.....-'.':::' ,":... ....,...... ....•-, • - -....,i,,...:.;.. . . :,'... . .•.....- • .. ;- .. — ........, - .. . ...:.....:'.-..:---:;: .:.. :'..7":.,.'.','::',7.-?...':-Y,...r..".".".',i... ..,71'q"....'...:;',,. .1'17, ::4-,: .',-•.1....?:',.:',...2.. ":"::?-..,•;,!.:L:f-.:,:i.'-':::::',.11,7- ......,''''i'..,....''i.:;..:.,i.;_::;:-:-.i.c.'?.........7":-...:?:::,,..":,.'-_7:::::;:i,. ..:...:.f.':-- :...- .-:...s.:-:.3.1..;":"‘i-... ' ..-...',--...'"::: '; - ....,.:.i..'. .-,..1:::'. z.:....,." - . • :. ".: '7'•:: •-.-. ':: .:...',...'''...-:.:,-.-L;---...--: -',...;......a:.:-..?.:.f;'f'..7.:1-,-..-!:-...,..L..":;.:-.'.1.;..:?.,---..;-::::5:',-..k...r,-2t1t....4i,....7;:-Fr;s::;`...f,,-,:'-'.:.-';'-'241:1,..:;:.-:4.:''.2'..--. .::;',--....,'...-...:k=-',-.7L'-'-':;:..,,,7.'...:.:-.-;.::.•.1.,"..:-:•,"A';'..........:,g.:',. '•,.' '-'..•••'::,• ,-:-..''',-.: .''.: -.....--., •'-,. '•-••;:,7 - - '- • • - .• . ' ---......' .--. ,.-:. .:"...".. .!:: -..-;;T,-.,-.':;• ,....-:`.' ,•,.:•,,z,,,..,•,;;','•-,',::::-.';•:-,,,,..C-2;: l"T-,".:,?,,"-:.:,..,.v.,;,.f;;;:.:,..,--,,,,,,,j,,'n.3,7,-,-;:::;:'..::..le.'".-',".!.';',.:_,.,:....'.;-..:'•:----..,..:-.-....:.,:.--.'.':",,••'-',: .." -. ic 2,-..;.,"r.f:•....-.-, - -.':'.•':''.'f:'-'"': - ',....:-..,/...". .',, , . . '....': 2---•.:,;'.-''.2...-'--...,','...-,"':'• 1:,..:'••••%.:•:.:•:;: ::!..- ,__Fj;'.•:';'.1'.;;;"...::::::::. .'')7..:-.:;'.•';'",;4t-'.--::'5;,',.'. f,':i4:F.'.:14:,' .:-,. :i..:I,.-:: ::....:...--1!".'.. J.-7:::;:-..... .::. :'.:::--::::::.,.: :17.'...'. ...: - . . . .:--':'''. ,.. ::..,...,:,.:..„;.i::•.::f•:: .' :-.1i....;'......:..*,- •-....... . • ; S• . ": ;2::•*-,.::'-...:-:'...'..*:-''.,'-r..:1.....".:•'..4.':•':,..*.*--'1.....,::-.''"*;:'[..::::: ;''...--!.:;7::::-.±...';, ..?':', ,,:.:.?2;C:',..'!".; :•_-:'•.•:;''.*- ,....:2 .::%;*.•::: ',,;..'..:77;''':;;;;-,":,:',..:.;.;.*:.....i!':::.•-:.''..• ..,::::• .*-••••.•• . ..:**-' .., . •..,-z-.--,:; ' :__ • * , , . :':•;*.*:•,;.'!-1-. :•'..:',"‘.;,,-!**,,......i!' •-• ''.' * • .. . .• ; ....' .*'; : *.,-;..,:::',.'..•:•*::.....* -'':-.":.::..':::.....-:.-'*;::••!`..,;-'..:.7.'1:.;',. :I,..::::.':"..':*!.";•.*,-..:,;;'.'',..-.11*/.;:.*:.::',.';:.',,*-,:T;'.::***;.:',.:.."',':',.:*:'''..t.,i2:.*:;;;;*,.:".;.'.).........•-.:.- ' .: ' - . ' ... ') ,.' ' *.:.;.';:'.,.;•'.:.;:.j':-*, •.;-..: . . • - - . '* - '.: ' '. . ' . ' . '' . .. • • " • '-',*:-A:t-. ;:•,..:2-..i''',.; ‘ .';'?.",.•;li.,.*:- '.. ' ' . . 1 --ft . , • I . r _ I • -'. j { • • g Q • ; • i . • . / • • • • 5 �' 4 1 •\•\, \ f 7 •,si. • • • • •• { p k rZ I ! 1 • i i ` v' a • ' 1 • i �,- r r r .* • I • ' -- •.�o a_t/ ,East /J/��/ �.�• • ..K • '• _ PERMIT NO--.- .1.DAT$.. $ 1957 . •.• • • OWNER I '' •,. t•y„.. /i 1UILDF.R / E ,•. ile . h } , a - ! .}' 7 T. F i j. . t.. , pksCk ii pp , •y r,t Gig l ': sj 1 •} r,4 1y =i kt .1 1 i1rt 1 -i�j - - t -� ' -! I� t=� #1 1r 1,tf H $ �x ;ti 1 • — • r • r4. J ` f'g31� i'S{ I1 `eF r '`�ti a•'i,1} ' - -`. 1. , ' � r'z' ���._— � try_�I 1 - I r--� v •��(� a,y f j ( ` 1 f. h 1�' i fit. •'iit: I. yt , • r„ I �� 1 t if i'�t �. } ` • is • t ir.� ir. �� ' f 1 ffi '.. c, •' • 1 .. _ / • . ' • / y • • . . ',,.� PERMIT NO_,S �r.__.DAI. _GZ�vw(. ...193.�. •' _� • J I� - - ` • ARC ITECT .__..J 1 • _ . J BU LDF.R• .�.:: ! 1, ' I/ - 1=,t _ iI - • ■ ) . • . 1� `1'. 1tT� C N -� •. -i- YS; • • • — • • I o • �. • .ii PY.r'f � � :• ' y y te '���,''Stir , f{y .r ,�' . ' ' • .. . _Y: �� . � � P I pf f, rt 'f"h1�V J . ;•' � :'44--�.V e • �4 pp'� • • C a ',+►� - t Q_ k= d �' .• . 1 :"•- 7 �`h '..4",- i'r°:y74▪,. ,r7'q"i rlr ). } • kr • r i'r ,t iy`'4'y�. + .. . A ',t:VY 't 4-I"H 8 'y 1�r I� Y d �l• [ • I ) ', €-•. yam_ - ' --It LT-_ — - I _ - .- .. y sr, 4:?; 1~ Esrr ,-- , .... • . tea i, ›, "'P -. +:: L . _r. s4 � ,:-e-- .•• ,, li", •-i. *.,."., .• . . •., _ *..5-.4k:•;•.-- '..•;...• / ,, • . , :•'••••••••,:,;•....,:•••••'i* -. ••• '••;:•••.•':•]:• •••••:"• •'''--i''•'.•''''• -. r. �.. r', :.: ::r:.. ` yP+J .;i'. i'+::. .i src '• cR'4 ri¢^'rf c) } 7?u '..h � a• - is`t 4a fi I f h. a [ / C •.��• -\ t r QY„ � .' +1f ..y •-•• / ' r t' s .l i �K.p•G I ry� �� J t• 1 � .. -,mil r J ) �k ' —r— ,. _ I y 7 r / - J, N - } i ..,. . .. ..t....—:-...,-, ( •. . 11:.... . ., ‘-.;-.,,.,.....t • 1..... ... . ,.. . .. 1 ,.. DESIGNATION REPORT • el. . .l n / - Fox House (a.k.a. Ocean Apple Estates) 610 N. Ocean Boulevard • , . • _:,.: . . _ ,• .-4- ... •-•-..., ---,- ,.• ;-1,:1 !‘ .,,o ..1 ,, .,., • i .t. 0, ge;,..*„.•,..i............,,,,,,.,,,,,s_ ... . 414..,,....., • . . , ...• .,-, ,-1-4p.:4,444 . \---...-... .• .. _ ... - ,i -t.,./ .'' •• ..:•, Ilk' — 44 ...t. , _. .. ..„....,• .-.- .-:-.1.--,--__z_.--:_-_,-E-_-:::.,;:•., se r..-,e., • t )1.-... • : _ • -,..______,....„-:-...... ...._-_,...„--___,--- • - .f-Aw :' . "-- ' • . ..... _,..4 '--7.:-.7.7.:::-Z------:-..:a7----.--7-...S.-- /• •..' . 40' u •••t:' • . . . ,:',a‘..0.• '.. • „ It, \ ! . .I• - i,,,t ,- 4;',... I, , .."':::...--••' -., ''.---- : ':.'".• • .• 9• . - -'...A......-,•-•-•..•:- ',....! ... .. k i,-a- .. 1 i',/ • i .' -' 1.;, \ i„'": i I.. ..... z--- --- • .-.•.•.. . -.. ,. ..• .„„,--.,.4.°:ir• . e;,, r. r 44',A•••••• - ,. etc- lit,- - ,. . .. r. .---.....;-- ,---.,..... ..a.p...--r.-,... • ..,-- e r- ..1-',.4':‘-, • • • oTitimili ,1911 . _.:-....?_-_:„.---.....,--_-_-_-,---,-. ___ . ..„_-,..;::::„.:.2.r.,,,,;:..:: .- : •• •,!-•,... ........: •.. • • e. lea _ .. _„••- -tvtipt.4%...w• .--...ii3O A 1 1 I 11.i - •• 1 •:„./. -----•--- — ,..... .....----_-----...•••"1"-°"... .-• ... '-.4-$ `111.-1,• - 'II I •-f ,--.. F.:--- •"*"---_----- ••.--;-;-....,-• , ,. - . ar . .e:•... •• - ' "We'.1./I;r...1 .'-•-•jb - p '4 4-4.,!,;..-7..---...%-.7-- .." - ._ .- / . - 4r.) oei, • .- I' (., - I 111 --- ------------------ ... --- ..4 kb• 2 .'..-,jr 4 .1,4 tk 1. it , .,,,----,.--7,-,----- ,,. -"" •• ..''.o.0: )v.,,It'.;.1:14/‘i a'epg. .. , - _. .-.'--".; -r''' .. -.• • • • , i .. • .4*‘. • '.'Ai •'?10114...% ,...,,. '.....;.........-•- ' .4. . .. .--'..'- • lit. .40/3, ! ::li .. '.!I .. ,,,..,,..•...--''...<r.,.i - ',...., V, 4, .. .. i...(1' t aft ... .14'V%ilittelt4: •'ail )'..110c-. . . . '..' . . .. 4.. t.• . ' • - • _. \sr*. • ...-:,-. ri,10..,... ; . ,.... ;3 . . 1361, . ,sitItliff....- r - .,45..re.g.L•tk-4 ..,• ,4 . . , . I • ; t 1 . t.. •• •i "•I i-"1 - • ,,:ip,' Zr•....1, 1...ilAtr-, .. : 1...4' . - ..:,, . •f y . -- .:...)••P' '' • .4:Itt• .Ott Ill;1 it. .ii17.. / ii-I . ... : ..h, - ,. ---r4:.".4,70.„„- 7'.. .-4' .'d f V-.::::::-; , ' - ._,,.•. . -Z-.14,-..-.' • . .... . :. ....... %. .-3 •'' '2:"•'..-...' •aNA,rjr: %$ .Zer":. *. 1 • - e- ., .% i .: .. .• _.,-,,,,-- .. - - 1 _.......___. —. .:---Ire -•. . ..,; ..t• .4, • *-e .. 1 a I •,.• -fl• 4.1 V . . . lit -7. •:, •- •-• ' "' . . . -A. ., . ......7,. . __-.,. .,,- - - ' .. ,::•-• .---4.-.. -:. ••• :‘ . - 2-7 :":,:".;.... - --- ..''...::f:Sit • • ' • ' -- - • - . . • - t DESIGNATION REPORT \ THE FOX HOUSE aka "OCEAN APPLE ESTATE" 610 N. Ocean Boulevard, Delray Beach) } I. PURPOSE The purpose of designating the Fox House, 610 N. Ocean Boulevard, to the Delray Beach Local Register of Historic Places is to preserve the architectural and cultural significance of one of the City's most distinctive private residential oceanfront estates, which is popularly known as the "Ocean Apple Estate" (hereinafter the "Subject Property") . A nomination for designation has been filed and considered by the Board (See Exhibit A) and a public hearing held pursuant to Chapter 174 of the City of Delray Beach Zoning Code. II. LOCATION The Subject Property is located at 610 N. Ocean Boulevard Delray Beach. It is 2.5 acres more or less and is comprised of land on the oceanward and landward sides of State Road A-1-A. The Subject Property extends from the Atlantic Ocean to Andrews Boulevard. The legal description; of the Subject Property is described in Exhibit B. III. HISTORICAL AND ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE The house is significant because of its architectural style, the man who, first owned the Property and the man who designed the improvements. The house was originally constructed for and owned by Fontaine Fox, a world-famous cartoonist. Designed by John Volk, it represents one of a few remaining "beach" cottages reflecting the Cape Cod bungalow style typical of houses built on North Ocean Boulevard from Delray/Gulfstream to Manalapan. The Owner: Fontaine Fox In 1933, Fontaine Fox began purchasing the land for what would-be known as 610 North Ocean Boulevard. By 1934, he owned all of lots 1, 2, 3, 4 and the north half of lot 5 of Palm Beach Shore Acres. The house itself is located on lot 3 and the north half of lot 4. Fontaine Fox commissioned John Volk, a personal friend, to design a house on North Ocean Boulevard. Fox, a cartoonist of both national and international acclaim, was best known for his cartoon "Toonerville Trolley". Launched in 1916, the cartoon was syndicated throughout' the world, appearing in several languages. 1 if I Born in 1884 in Louisville, Kentucky, Fox began his career as a cartoonist in grammar school, continuing throughout high school when he began working at the Louisville Herald as a reporter and cartoonist. After two years of study at the University of Indiana, where he studied and drew cartoons part-time, he returned to Kentucky to work at the Louisville Times until the Chicago Post gave him national recognition and distribution in 1915. Much of the small town subject- matter for his cartoons came from people he knew in then suburban/rural Louisville. He moved to Delray in 1931, after having visited there in the 1920's. Fox, in coming to Delray, joined a number of well known artists and writers who by making Delray their home -- created an artists and writers colony. These people included the cartoonist Herb Roth (whose cartoons reflected life in Delray) , Wood Cowan, writers Hugh McNair Kahler, Clarence Buddington Kelland, Nina Wilcox Putnam (whose articles published in Good Housekeeping magazine were illustrated by another Delray resident Anita Brown) and poet Edna St. Vincent Millay. Fox made his studio on the second floor of the Arcade Tap Room, the hub of winter activity in the town of Delray. He ultimately built two homes on North Ocean Boulevard. He was an accomplished golfer and the author of several books and articles, including a series which ran in many papers which was based on his narrow escape in 1939 from war-torn Europe. During the war he was a member of the Division of Pictorial Publicity. In 1951,. Fontaine Fox sold the house at 610 North Ocean Boulevard to Alfred and Anne C. Hart. (Alfred died in 1958, and Anne C. Hart ultimately became Anne Hart Mott of the Mott Applesauce family. ) Fox formally retired in 1954 and died at his home in Greenwich, Connecticut in 1964. The Delray Beach Historical Society recently honored him at an exhibit shown at the "Cason Cottage" Museum. The Architect: John Volk In the late 1930 's, Fontaine Fox, having had a long-term friendship with John Volk, commissioned him to design the house at 610 North Ocean Boulevard. Volk was also the architect of Fox's home just north of 610, as well as several others located in the immediate Delray/Gulfstream area including Ocean Boulevard, Seabreeze, and Palm Trail. Born in 1901 in Austria, Volk came to the United States when he was nine years old. He was a student at Columbia University School of Architecture as well as the world renowned Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris. Volk continued to design homes until his death in 1984. John Volk arrived in Palm Beach in 1925 while Addison Mizner was building Spanish and Mediterranean style mansions for wealthy 2 • if families. A prolific architect, he designed over 1,000 houses, theatres, and buildings all over the world. Some of the world's most powerful and wealthy people commissioned him to design their , homes, including William Paley, George Vanderbilt, Henry Ford II, Herbert Pulitzer, Horace Dodge II, and John Phipps. Volk has often been called the last of the original Palm Beach architects which included Addison Mizner, Maurice Fatio, and Marion Sims Wyeth. In 1926, he formed a partnership with Gustav Maas which lasted almost ten years. Volk's homes, which number several hundred scattered along the coast, covered a broad range of designs from Spanish and Italian motifs to Normandy, Bermuda, Regent, Classical Oriental, bungalow, and what he called British Colonial. Known to have "broken the excesses" of the Mediterranean style after the Depression, Volk began designing British. Colonial houses that could be built for forty-five cents a square foot versus two dollars per square foot for the Spanish mansions. He related in an article in Architectural Digest in 1972, "when the market crashed and the Depression followed, there wasn't a client in sight who wanted to build the elaborate Spanish house. Everyone was broke. Those who weren't, didn't want to make a show of their money. " It was during this period that the, houses along North Ocean Boulevard were designed. Volk designed some of the most prominent buildings in the area, including the First National Bank building in Palm Beach, the Royal Poinciana Plaza and Playhouse (which opened in 1950, becoming the first new professional theatre to be built: in the United States since the Ethel Barrymore and the Adeiphi Theatres opened their doors in 1928) , the galleries and theatre for the Society of the Four Arts,, part of the. Town Hall of Palm Beach, the Beach Club, Phipps Oenza, and: Good Samaritan Hospital. In later years, he. designed Paradise Island and was involved in early development of planned golf course communities such as Port Royale in Naples and Old Port Cove in North Palm Beach. During the Mott family's ownership, the southerly portions of the land seaward of State Road A-1-A were conveyed to the City of Delray Beach in support of .a beach stabilization and renourishment program. Recently the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach voted to convey ten feet along the southerly border of the Subject Property east of State Road A-1-A back to the current property owner as a part of the property owner's proposal to plat a buildable lot on the east side of State Road A-1-A. IV. PRESENT USE, CONDITION AND ZONING A. Present Use 3 / The Subject Property is improved with a two bedroom principal residence, garage, swimming pool and three small guest cottages. 4114 The improvements were designed by renowned architect John Volk and was originally constructed in 1934. The improvements to the Subject el Property have been renovated in accordance with the architectural theme and character of the original design of the principal residence and the other improvements. _ _ B. Condition The structure is in very good condition. C. Zoning The current zoning of the Subject Property is R-1-AA. The Nomination submitted by the owner is subject to proposed conditional zoning regulations. V. IMPACT This designation is being made at the request of the owner of the Subject Property. VI. RESOLUTION The Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach hereby finds and determines as follows: A. The Nomination for designation of the Fox House as an historic site is appropriate and conforms with the standards and criteria of Chapter 174: Historic Preservation of the City of Delray Beach Code. B. The Subject Property is appropriate for designation as an historic site because: 1) The Subject Property is associated with the life or activities of a person of major importance to city, regional and national history in that the Subject Property served as a residence of famed cartoonist Fontaine Fox, a notable person in the history of the City of Delray Beach and the country. The Subject Property also served as a residence for the Mott family of applesauce fame; 2) The Subject Property exemplifies the social and historical trends of the community in that the principal residence represents a lifestyle, quality of life and architectural character that once typified seasonal living in South Florida; 4 I 3) The principal residence on the Subject Property has Il architectural and aesthetic significance in that: il a) The building portrays the materials and design of an era of distinctive architectural style, to wit, ' natural wood reflective of traditional cypress construction. - _ _ . b) The building reflects distinguishing characteristics of a style, period and method of construction, to wit,: the building is reflective of traditional South Florida cypress homes that are no longer extant. c) The building was designed by renowned Florida architect John Volk and represents one of the finest examples of this style and type of residential design by Mr. Volk. d) The building contains design, detail, material and craftsmanship of an outstanding quality which represented, in its time, a significant innovation in adaptive design for the South Florida environment. B. Such designation should be conditioned upon the adoption of the following zoning regulations: 1) notwithstanding the fact that the minimum lot size requirements of the R-1-AA District and the existing number of platted lots that make up the Subject Property would allow more than three (3) dwelling units, the total i number of dwelling units that can be developed on the Subject Property shall not exceed three (3) ; i 1 2) notwithstanding the minimum lot dimension requirements of the R-i-AA District, a single family detached dwelling may be constructed on the Subject Property east of State Road A-1-A, provided that the dwelling is constructed within the area designated by building lines depicted on Exhibit C attached to the Nomination, to wit no portion of the dwelling is constructed within five (5) feet of the north and south property lines; 3) notwithstanding any provision of the City of Delray Beach Code, the single family dwelling which may be constructed on the Subject Property east of State Road A-1-A through the Subject Property may not exceed twenty four hundred (2400) square feet; and 4) notwithstanding any provision of the City of Delray Beach Code, the right-of-way of State Road A-i-A shall be sixty (60) feet and no reservation of right of way in excess 5 • of the east half of sixty (60) feet shall be required as a condition of development east of State Road A-1-A. C. The Subject Property is unique in regard to a confluence of circumstances that render it potentially unbuildable under the current provisions of the R-i-AA- District., D. The construction of a single family dwelling on the land east of State Road A-1-A, is consistent with the goals and purposes of the City of Delray Zoning Beach Code. E. There is no other lot in the same zoning district that suffers from the same confluence of circumstances and the conditions and circumstances are peculiar to the Subject Property. These unique circumstances include: a) the property being the southernmost of a long series of oceanfront lots which are improved with residences, b) the granting of an easement for public beach use over a substantial portion of the lot in support of a public program of beach stabilization and renourislment, and c) the establishment of an erosion control line divesting the owner of technical title to a substantial amount of land area between the mean high tide line and the erosion control line to which the property owner retains riparian rights. F. Absent the conditional zoning regulations, the property owner will be deprived '. of the rights enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district. G. The special conditions appurtenant to the Subject Property are the result of public, .initiatives in regard to beach access, use and renourishment, initiatives that the owners of the subject property have supported and contributed to by granting of beach access and use rights of way and acquiescing in the establishment of the erosion control line as a part of a renourishment. program. • 6 . \\\\ lr. iii 11/: . , _ 4./!.�► 9 L. �.vy •sue,fl� yra';a�• .. •• �• ,/i••, ' N ww •1 �,--. • 'i ..; '2'1; • • 7 , rf;• t�i . ,.. ....4-... . . a .•‘ . - ;,i,-. .--- :,..........—... .-• 0 • , 0,No,. '14 ,111'-,-.....4 kir 1,4,4*.,w...Pr - ' - . ,'..... '" :' •t :. '‘ if.,e.,.,,,4_1,1( ,..fi),..„0,t1 i i : . , •., •' f. tyty k-i.t . 1 I:.1 ' ' rr Jl .0 r • •* ice•. ,1Y i 1 a ,..11�7.w4 •'- ' k! h- f •f .a.. � . L L— - , f • rc_ • 1. Fox House, main residence, south side. • f r` s _�'` I t es t�1 • �. x „G , r -To oftwalfferi . '• •C� v" „c.' !..rr.r► �I- a, o'�,l,.t1 t.,%•••..„1!K. �1.,..xwi • t A a, • 1,• ;tY841.400. r,. ,fi r ;,. tm:� •Wit► •.lgkj ' ZIP a'} � ! ,.-4—t 4 0;�4i•4t,• ®l®•'+'.!1g•F�.! t• _' r irk O1 v 1' a , ♦{d,:):1 t ..�� •" n fir♦ xt af. ,. '' .. 4I a .,ice .,,, .. '1' :M . D . lri �. • ` i•s �h• e3�y �e� �ra't® ,3171 V.• Aet . f'ic•• • �•„',t.N:t . 1 ri.i • 4T..._:-..'if.. '.%�t �;k`6:: ,�• ?Ili _.�ls- -*:?�i ce- y�i4 .. n :ten �. :. .pP' '!•rt� �;..�{•:lk {%.". : :e i.Kin.i.t:...:'`• .. .•► �tN • `.. t •v• •►.• �^. ;i • •.� s/ :� o�r.4. S. 1 q •�� 4*,• a;r✓ a. .� . • e •,�s• t..t.7 • a�1w1.4. •• ", e s• �:•n• ��•••• ,.aR.(p f• ..Rt. _ •:: . �jfkq';� .1� ,t. • 2. Fox Ilouse, main residence, south side. tafM�'Q.44R,S, ' -*.4% - - V t ? ,4zt if I L ,5 ,}1 ice: I da „t. : I. .i .s,.=Y£,..,ji- • 4T.....,ivirp .„4„,i,....:,_ __.Ss- _ .a" --.- ir Sti' �'"� , i „+`/. i - w '1 1:1 �i '•---Lq S t.-- -sx-,N '� A 4x�;_�µ,�'r'1•idw(+rli.... ` 'rt.' t §.t ti ff a»`Qr t ^ L.k�rj .-.z ..fC .-'`+ t p�, = y 1 feir 3 \\\\ • = A : ca. I L 1`M1 ---.o»,.—..: •,-t ,¢ ems, 3. Fox House, main''residence• , west side (rear). ' -. -..-•wt.& .--......- ' •'i - • Zit g. A2'3 nt..i.- 1./.. " . a9a; — .. • . ip ,A s. a_� E_ fr o' •i-..4,• • . k` ..,: r _ • t1•t r, " 7"7 • ) •tl 1 i9 i . c +� t= ._ _ it -I/ . - r' , - L Ala• . ' . rt} I t•1 �' p ,40 f j(o '... .4#• h Jam• t• 4. Fox House, main residence, south side with view to ocean. .e•X . . =i- (.... I- . • A •• \• , , -;;;-:', - .:• -_ ., . 'Ns, • - • - • • •• - , 1%. , . . . .., , • ' . ,..fi• • ...ale -... - -. .. ---..,•-- _1.7.•-.F`-- ..N, '''' :'' ..1 •••'`‘*111 =--jvP2;17'*i';'..j1j*.' '.: -1- -''7' ''''4`' ' 7.:.',7-:-.•::"4*. '--' '',..-'.-, .... 40.,:** _'''- - --: ri..i'.' :1.*- *-' 1'11, *11. '-Vi--4 '1 -. ''.• -.•';•;.-' .-• ; • T. • • '- •••---t'"- .r .-....-.:•.,'•- .:-.•:-::.- _'4•r' ' ''''` .-, - -:-.1"--V--"••` - • sox.......;_ '7 *,_ ' --- . •-4. - _ - :-. 4-- i ,- ,),,!---- _• . -, A..\. -- -I i . 1,7, :•- • 1 '''.-s• !..1 -""'""*"..- • '71.11- - _ , . ; i . -,,,., , , -,-- , , liimmirlialnattir. i .. . . 4 - ` ,....g, t•'' - \ .44.14111,1113M. -/1". ; I * - • ' ' _ '- 1.**' . . 4 , .0116.°4041/411%46,14:"4•eaLa.- 11 \ r.1. a. , .1 ,. ' ' •"' .,,- `--- ,•••7 ' ' -i 1 .- Ali' - ai , •_, i , :: . 4 .u• I ' -' , I -!-.11 ' ' .- I••• . - - , -... , • ' _ .‘v - ' .. ' - - -- ,....--, .7.,-- -'-- ."-; - ,A.._,4,,,,, • -- ...-'' --.*- ,„•.-..._"./ _-. _ -- , N.... ' .. .....--.Ainipaitif awl f ,...- sary:;;,„Akiiita I :-..--.....--"r, ...„,,,-•----%•-"-, ad.!..--.. . ... -, - . .. . , -. ,.::,,,„ ,-_ ....., , .- . •i .._ 5. Fox House, main residence, south side, upper balcony detail. -.L. ...,c r 4 ... ., 0. ...: ..4)., \„i a- 1 •A A 0' 1 ' i .ei. - • •,-,-- k .,..i/ i • ••il. ? ? ;:.' i •; • L le ' e•y. . I , ''i---,' - -.- I-1 , I, 1 • • 9, , i 4 ail- P *dy ..,.. - '`... x '• ' !. I • ,,,,, .e.ato Om - 4, 4.'4--4*- a ••44 *It ‘41•64 i 4 .' 1.'1 ''t - ' -.".... 01 ii:t..:f'''._,-4•• \ ', '' '; ' '4)4°4,J. IA" • ' - - * - - •, $ : . ,. 2. ,1 or'''4.1P• '• ',. IF . 4 • . 4 .%.*I - -.- : 0.„ t.•'• ' -t f.,:i OP • °- - --: - , ';., :le.. .. t ,-• .riir: • . t,-:,-, . if • •-• fr . • ) '.'. -,.-' -.. , 1, 7- '''''' r.... P. 4. ' • 4, •.-, •F. ==.' i 0' ' • 44 .,,11,.E,. ., .Ir.: _ _. .., . . ,,,_‘ - I.% .. 0 a• -----,‘-•--,-.,,.--4-•-•-•4 : ,.....,. -, ' , : • • '.- i, f %I i%. .1°' .vc i., ,• t -,' t.- • - , -..",11"71"'' -.'---I i,4 t;,• 1 - J. • ' — . . fr . • t • fk t .:. 0 1,4'1-.' . ... . I if, ,..7,- • : .• . r 'on . 1 ... ' II !"4 • 1 •..S.- i 14. °I, ' ta, et/ ft. 1 • ! V i AI i ' / ' ' • II, el.1 V . • - ' "/ " k''--:a i 7 e: '.0...-.., --• , , .,. --\ _,, - ,f..•-•-,' . ' Aii d '11 i • , . . • P. -._ . - , - •-•,_ .. .ruiromistmaterwe.,:;„:1•.. (1 . to , , - ,. . •, • , i . ,, • i . ._ , - •_ •t•- .„?.,,a,, ,••• . ._ -...-, 1 if 1, i . --i'-'• t i -# - 'Aike.,1 ' — ` ti, 1 . • 'i / •i1 -T24' • .... .. - --'.:--.4i 9 . 4- 01 4. ......• : I I 1 ,I . t)/ . - ...... ,..._........,_ .......1.,....t-....., - : -. 4 1* , .„. Ch •• : I. :.Ir•••• : . • • ,...-4... :., ,...rto 'o III • i ••,a, 41, .• • #0 - •, , Pah _ ..a.- ... .,-,--"/„.., - -,„ . ": "P•im.--'_ '- - ,. , , , - • ‘:....,,,__ , . ..4 .... two—6"---4*-- . ... ,. 6. Fox house, main residence, front entranceway. PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT ,�.( p� 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE pELRAYBEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 ;All-AmericaCity 0 cr (561) 243-7040 (561) 243-7221 FAX e-mail: pzmail(a�mydelraybeach.com tool FASCIMILE COVER SHEET DATE: ,96 , . TO: LeILQ. TrE+GLAha. FROM: G4tV'L) 01./Q/L....ga2 Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: COMMENTS c 33 I Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORIVii Site# PB10270 Original k FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 366 Update Consult Guide To Historical SWcture Forrns fordetailed instructions Recorder Date 2/1999 Site Name 238 SE 7th Avenue Other Names None Project Name Delray Beach Survey& Planning Project Historic Contexts Depression/New Deal National Register Category Building an Address 238 SE 7th Avenue Vicinity of SE 3rd St and SE 2nd St on W City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969& 1973 Townshi 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr SE Irregular Section UTM Zone 17 Easting 0593097 Northing 2926450 Land Grant Unknown Latitude Longitude Plat or Other Map Palm Beach County Aerials Architect/Builder Mark Vigneault(1999 renovations) Construction Date 1937 Circa Alterations w Date c. 1999 Type/Location windows replaced Additions w.Date c. 1999 Type/Location two-story addition added to the northeast corner M^ •ed Original Location L._4inal Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence Style Split-Level Exterior Plan L-shaped Interior Plan Unknown Stories 2 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Weatherboard Foundatio Pier Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infil Concrete Block No.of Porches 1 Locations/Features east: hipped porch supported by wood posts(inside the"L") Dormers O Number/Location Outbldgs. Number 1 Nature/Location (Describe below) One-story wood frame shed to the northwest Roof Type Cross-Gable Roofing Materials 5-V Sheet Metal Secondary Structures Li Comments/Location Chimneys Number 1 Orientation South Location Wall, Exterior Material Brick Wood Windows w Type DHS Light# 6/6 Metal Windows Ei Type Light# Exterior Ornament Cornerboards, Rafter Tails,Vents,Shutters Condition Excellent Surroundings Residential Narrative(general, interior, landscape,context; 3 lines only) This building has been significantly altered by the replacement of windows and a large two-story addition which obscures the original structure. Flat wood trim surrounds the windows and triple French doors are located in the entryway. This building was originally a common example of 1930s residential construction. .aeological Remains Present ii None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form.Completed (if yes, attach) L Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 I Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10270 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms_for detailed instructions �' Y ,. .. R�COR-DER"S EUALUAT'ION O�SITS Eligible for National Register? Yes ❑ No Fzi Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information Significant as Part of District? Yes o No off/ Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information • Significant at Local Level? Yes w No 0 Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information O Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This late-1930s residence is considered a contributing resource within the Marina Historic District.Although it has undergone modifications, it still maintains its integrity and represents the historic architecture of the area.This residence is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP on an individual basis or as part of a historic district. DHR'USE:ONLY OFFICIAL:EVALUATIONS DHR°USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER:DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES N0 SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL.DETERMINATION OF.EUGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL OFFICE Research Methods Sanborn maps, Plat maps, Local&County Historical Societies Bibliographic References Location:City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Location of Negatives City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Negative Numbers 9874-24;21;W RECORDER INFORMATION: 5 f i 4' Recorder Name Amy Groover,Jo-Anne Peck, Susan Hochberg Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 • REQUIRED. 1 USGS 7.5: MAP WITH:STRUCT•URES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET.OR:PLAT MAP • 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, PREFERABLY B&W,AT.LEAST 3x5 Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 •,g;. Tt..4 a.+y"ilr'`a<4C fs „'".S . 4'ex y, t :,t. S� w_bcr.:...,,, �•-t..._KF a ce• ,.,. -t • • ,4k<T.,; .:/ �•• r . � ; ,--"-' ;�, ' �., {1SGWQUADRANGLfr MAP ' E- ,`, t=t • IF-4,, r - ' ;""y- • :��c, r>. fp#^+ ,`-'x )T'3'r, fkf+ y sa 'e,L' ..3y„ . "N*- 4 4'• f. .� /y-�t/ �"j �[�t�,'Y +,�x�s.�.£s...-"~,s.., ,Is. �•�.+y� .••.:.-.L.t 3�.. �•l.: _ t r-t' �+,f'„y s•"'�•`itv""�S'•�=''s '�i• _', ?� I -[ - �I( �* _ y - NW.;E.TH�Ii�i��I 1+1 _ + la Cluo �._'4,. Yc sS.a.. --s>k7i r�..`Y•-:ar.�., f�-f:.+.,.,cia.>"t;+< • r — Z —1f u • air , , /� / i� __ _� .=--1 119 •i 5""i;-111��23- NE , BrN I I j 1 1� / _.�Q• .( / — l 11 / q k. I�I-II I /s j I�19 — ; 4 p 3.Y. J I i /' l ti �� �f/ ih: •• k ti 1sT 1_I �� it I °i� lI� i/ -• \��_ I L_".II�`Jc J L zl /a ;' �-J� ( l)a--h ' / ,. /✓ rl r ■__,__ --.�'�• .-i, �i y.� J� 1 r ( I"WII` ?l:�r fy}�/ 7 _ r 1EPkhact .y. i _/�` �• ',YW'� 4TH ST. � 1 I�.l 1/.3: �[] 3 • L /o 7L4 / t , .il—.l: .� �l l •.=. E 3Ot �✓` - . 3 _K I. i G I.a, 1 �i1 .r—�11{�2 w rk I .. I� 1� , : �i' ' '`•- 1 II 1 ,.� c It :I i' _ 1f I' :: � S I s a,: I L :! f.Y I =_�/ >a i 7/5 .I _,,.7,,,,,v I I IIt I aI 1 •Il I• .I { r f ., . ' i< " �r L_�� W 20l IIsTL�L II I-i, 'llt F �I�� '1 �" I (�I III,/� �ii• dl▪ l-} B 1+''L/ l,llrl' I• Iimal -• I Ip. rl• y e. 7 I`_', i'VP ii r 1 1 a`? It ..L I I� -�J�-II '�Jf , ^��ds !:. P[.1. ,.,utd 'F F�� t til _ 11• t I I In I [;J[1f4 :Ar , I I„, . ko4Li /J , / 11 tl .. �'/'1(/'E ,r,. I ' dfI - -i, I�/� 1 7 _ /^ "' II .Jtil- • ��z.aNT+r-LL ;1=41L i. ��� 4 Yr-:1IY< .�_ 4Y 1U� li ti,1$ =4 '( I r W #_ ' I al N tw ,11 t } 'I `ic p s 1= ,f rjyy� 41 I ,-��alt I� I' �` ..1 � II '' Park ' f� > C Jib Cfi�r • M1� 7±. I7 1 :; r -��- '1. it .I 6 1 r C� �I�--1 '1 L w U s It'.1 ii sr:�_� I a y''I i ..r rt the 'z> 1 1? - = i 1 q I! rf,+f S -7� .:I = i �I j I—Ir�f �.-_�r ���(` ,� tom---�!, '�. 11- --[ ` _ O INri -�C ] 1- I 1 a 1 v - '' I'r _1' E 7 I '^ a / . ' -q( ,rk:-: � 't f [ _.lu 1 1 §li ,I _, �IL20. .II ;1.. -. i r+ ' q �:+ ,{fs� .7:,, >_ 1 l- :41 3 iti n - I� I I',r/ r e 414. �� -J� a :i l / -..', F r:. 2t,.lest --� •- ( .• I• 0. ,.� O' I-` I r = + + 3,. ,I � u Sc I � I� ' { �q( 7.; -�I? 11�1 t � c_ il � 53(__It' I�� -Ir I. � 1 �iT1�}'ir$ Tl�,tl�;-.r1 ®s�.r �r 1rlI L n I ' ' • A.`_10 I ii_ 1 k z _ a h , I , .•+, . II -z t_lE , BPl3�d2rlO W �,• nl ', .� , I k -1, ,L USGS Delray Beach, Fla. Quadrangle t l L Pine Ridge I -u u g - !� ` 7.5 Minute Series (To ogra hic _ Cem �I�� LI{fie: �a ue Ii 1 I I I. �� y ——•— I �I Bal F[k[d P .� I , i� 1 -_I 11 1, - -' 1962, Photo revised 1969and 1973 • •-� .I:. i I � a ;, �_ _;�< -,1 ��'+ I I ! J 'rEi I =tIr__ Scale 1: 24 000 -:z� mz,“htswz- ''-•,... -14,..�_.._.....• ? -r'-�.:�M-.tea - - .._,_ ._.?�» _<s�.,• .'+..� �- 't• .xc-_• ,. ".>.1.. sr�^yw,a., ._,�vsv'S's a • '--'-'7`.''-' s, : ...-..„!or-..t-i...,_.•••-•, •—'.."... ., .; , , iiiiky.- • co • a co — . - _ • t N Project Name: Variance Request 88-50, and COA-336 Project Location: 238 S.E. 7th Avenue PUBLIC HEARING The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a variance request to . allow a 2 story addition to be constructed 9' from the north property line where 10' is required. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA-336 for the design elements associated with the renovation, and addition to, an existing contributing single family residence. The variance will be voted on during the public hearing. The COA will be considered during the regular agenda. The contributing, cottage style, residence is located in the Marina Historic District in the R-1-AA zoning district. The lot, which is typical of others in the district, is 60' wide. The interior side setback requirement is 10". The applicant is requesting a 1' reduction to the north property line requirement in order to construct a 2 story addition to the existing cottage. The addition will encroach 1' into the setback for a length of 26'. The existing cottage contains approximately 1,000 s.f. The addition will contain 676 s.f. The addition, which is set back 68' from the front property line, is appropriate to the existing residence and to the streetscape. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Deny the variance with reasons stated. 2. Approve the variance as requested. Meeting Date:February 18, 1998 Agenda Item: IV-A and V-A HPB Staff Report COA-336 • Page 2 RECOMMENDED ACTION 1. Based upon positive findings to LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(1)(a)(b)(c) &(d), grant the variance as requested. The 2 story addition, and new 14' x 13" (182 s.f.) front porch, will be constructed forward of the northeast corner of the existing structure. It will provide a new living room on the first floor and a master bedroom on the second floor. The addition will have a front facing gable roof. Four symmetrically placed aluminum double hung windows face the front; a decorative round window will be placed at the peak of the gable. The new front porch will have aluminum French doors facing south; an aluminum door flanked by full length windows will face east. The existing roof, the addition and the new porch will be roofed with standing seam galvanized metal. The front porch supports and railings will be wood. The addition will be sheathed in cement composite Hardi-Board lap siding to match the existing residence. The shutters for the addition will match existing. The addition will be painted to match the existing yellow with white trim. IMEMEMENENEENotompeimmootabisimignimitgatimid :>::»:::>:::<:;:<:::: Please note that the 2 master bedrooms shown on the plan are provided to give the owners a choice of layout. There will only be one master bedroom. The property is heavily landscaped, however, as the addition is more than 25% of the existing structure it will be necessary for the owner to provide plans for the City Horticulturist indicating that it complies with the landscape requirements for single family residences. The owner has indicated that the existing front • landscaping will be relocated to the front addition, therefore it would be appropriate to allow the City Horticulturist to approve the landscape plans, without additional Board approval. The owners enjoy the neighborhood with its close-in location and proximity to the beach, and have therefore chosen to expand the historic house rather than move to a larger home to accommodate their growing family. The size of the existing residence is very modest by current standards and a request for a 676 s.f. addition is reasonable. The addition will make the house more functional for family living, which is desired if historic properties are to be utilized and restored. In this case the variance provision in our ordinance serves as a good example of "variances being tools of preservation". HPB Staff Report - COA-336 Page 3 ALT E R N A T 11T.E .A.C.T I O N S 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. E: ,::;; .>:. .;.,>:.:: ..... :.,A::::qi.i::;::.: .:: >> >>'i > <'> »>> > »: > »>>'» : >' Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve COA-336 as presented. • • File/u/www/coa335si- • • ,•- :, ,.. ..:_.itir t- n= 4, • IQ -..-::- -, : . :. •3 • .. . _.. ;. ,• • I Ij,, i i , , : i „ - : ,-...,--.- : . .< ` i `. ` • February 2, 1998 Historic Preservation Board City of Delray Beach To Whom it may Concern: I am applying for a one foot variance on my property at 238 SE 7th Avenue,Delray Beach,Florida. This variance is necessary to maintain the historic character of the property, as well as to accomodate my growing family. This variance would not be contrary to the public interest, safety or welfare. The length of the lot is 135 feet and the length of the proposed addition is 26 feet. It will not interfere with traffic, fire safety or in any other way cause harm to anyone. My neighbor,Mr. Guenther Looft,who lives on the north side of the property, is supportive of the variance, as are others neighbors I have discussed this matter with. The one foot variance is necessary because special conditions exist because of the character of the land and the historic setting which make this lot different than other residential lots that have not been designated as historic sites or districts. The existing house is located on a lot that like others in the Marina district, is narrower than other R A 11 lots. The location of the house is on the rear set back. Front of property contains many old trees that I do not wish to disturb. In order to add space to the existing house while maintaining the historic/family character of the house,the proposed addition requires a minimal variance of one foot. This variance will allow for a proper stair way to be constructed and for the added rooms to be usable while being directly porportionate in scale eith the existing structure. While I could apply for a larger variance,it is my intention to apply for the minimum variance necessary to preserve the historic character of the histroric district I live in. Thank you for your consideration of this variance application. I look forward to hearing from you at your convenience. Sincer , Danie Dietrich • 1 H 1L i/ 111 1 1 1 .1 1 1 1 1 mrJ (limo 111) 1 1 L I II I L. . I 1 ! III I 1 ! A T L A N T I C A V E N U E 0 1 I I I 11 11 :IItIII' II 1 . 111111 I, Lill , WATERWAY EAST — .___.• < COMMERCIAL < I N CONDO 7 }} .; - 5 I < i I < < { a La w - I1 BAR sL l 1 > > i I HARBOUR )6) 1 I CONDO S.E. 1ST ST. f MIRAMAR STREET I I I 111 I--0 o BUD'S N I = 5 7/f I il PLACE 11 f W W T �'CONDO uj uj COCONUT I ( alij n �� IN S.E. 2ND ` ST. >- AV-NU• ii Ilio I I I Q �( > c - OCEAN e � SEACATE OCEAN I tERR. C TORS I I T`iR.l ' _ _ �NIAISISIAIU) ISIT.I Aki - i _' I H1 ) 1HI i. S.E. 3RD ST. r AyI STREE Z Z I I ANK A I m m VILLAS_- CONDO D LANCER WAYDCZ W Iv W _ III.N Y] VI ! SEAGATE ....‘ NM S.E 4TH ST. MANOR C UA•INA ROAD' i t l l i l 1 I nv IIIIIIII I I I I I o I .,.. ► DELRAY Ip BEACH S.E 5TH ST. D. l i III wCLUB -J S c BUCIDA < RI H1111111 I II I I I Q I y Ar* ��SE. 6TH ST. ~ I BARTON — McLAI=UGA RD. p I > SME MIi APT <_ I < < In== CONDOS O __ m II f `�D. o _ LAi CHURCHILL < - �,� CONDO S.E. 7TH „�_I- • C TAMARIND RD. Ul ' I I Z 0T I I W U O y G u UI vi BAN/ \ I v� N Vl t tJ U " BUILDING r- I 5=-c.`'P S.E. 5T., S BAUHINIA ROAD 11 1 I I I I I I 1 -1 N --vismi- DIETRICH RESIDENCE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL (238 S.E. 7TH AVENUE) PLANNING h ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP STS/EN. -- IMP REF: LM21I / i K k: "fl M' =—, ` V. TO: DAVID T. HARDEN, CITY MANAGER — THRU: DIANE DOMINGUEZ, PLANNING AND ZONING DIRECTOR 1 iW 14-1 /L. • FROM: PAT CAYCE, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER.: �G�Q�GC% SUBJECT: MEETING OF FEBRUARY 1, 2000 APPROVAL OF THREE FINAL APPLICATION REQUESTS FOR PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTIONS FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO HISTORIC PROPERTIES v rgg: { -z 'i Y� 55 yc¢ ' Y ti. r :? y�''�ry� s' - s� 'p •wu'.- -ar, -vra� : ' �--...s�... 3�� �t..�� ��L�.:�°G,.R.���.JY`1J� �r � �'�ks;.�� .;,y�,��^��� � v,=� a�; _.. ....-_.�.. _ . .__ ,«>....rf.,.,.a�.._.-....�.�3:.:..Vie... �....,....,.,.��._._..wsi" � � On November 3, 1992, Florida voters approved an amendment to the state constitution that allows local governments to provide a property tax exemption to increases in assessed values that result from improvements to historic properties. The Florida Legislature enacted Sections 196.1997 and 196.1988 to govern the allowance of such exemptions. The goal of this legislation is to encourage preservation and rehabilitation of-historic properties and to assist in efforts to revitalize older neighborhoods and commercial areas. On November 19, 1996 the City Commission approved an amendment to LDR Section 4.5.1, Historic Sites and Districts, by adding subsection 4.5.1(M), Tax Exemption for Historic Properties. Three property owners have since applied to the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) for the exemption by submitting Pre-Construction Applications detailing the proposed improvements. As required by the ordinance, the HPB granted Certificates of Appropriateness for each property prior to commencement of construction. The improvements have now been completed, and the Final Applications were submitted to the HPB for review. Subsequent to City Commission approval, the applications will be forwarded to the Board of County Commissioners for final approval. Attached is a description of each property and a summary of the improvements made to each. ;HiSTOR1C' PRESER_VkTION :BO.AR C'OI SalDY--`ATj1ON At the meeting of January 19, 2000 the HPB reviewed the Final Applications for each property and determined that the work done on each was completed in conformance with the review standards contained in LDR Section 4.5.1(M)(5), and constituted a qualifying improvement. The Board voted unanimously to recommend that the City Commission grantthe tax exemptions for a period of 10 years for the following historic properties: 1. Dietrich Residence, 238 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District,cost of improvements: $64,754 2. Turner Residence, 145 NE 6th Avenue, individually listed in the Local Register of Historic Places, cost of improvements: $165,000 3. Hayes Residence, 1109 Seaspray Avenue, individually listed in the Local Register of Historic Places, cost of improvements: $287,355 The exemptions will apply to any increase in assessed value resulting from the improvements. '` " _ 'y REOOM'MfN'OD rAC'"Tl ©1+1x � a By motion, approve the tax exemption for a period of 10 years for the 3 properties listed above, subject to the recordation by each owner of a Restrictive Covenant guaranteeing that the character of the property and qualifying improvements will be maintained during the period that the exemption is granted. File/pzlhpb/cc doc for 3 final app tax DIETRICH RESIDENCE 238 SE 7T" AVENUE MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT Cost of improvements: $64,754 The improvements to this historic residence encompass a 676 s.f. addition to the original 1,000 s.f. cottage. The addition is 2 story and contains a master bedroom and bath on the 2nd floor and a new living room and porch on the first floor. The owners enjoy the house and the historic neighborhood, and therefore chose to expand rather than to move to a larger residence to accommodate their growing family. • 1 t • • ' 'co '. ;1 ..,it - h' o.s Ir.11:-.4,w14,-....--,-;-,•:...-_..,.7.-..,..-.rtt'Y � .f , -=-:_ 2, a all -' ea v-__ c wL' S sr .y: tier.,+_' .,,�f_i. `.`':f :v•t• i. ' t-! 3%ti; _ate ‘ North Side of House showing Old & New Construction. _ . pF _ � -- t ; i i , it if;". i, x 4 j gF >� ) L y/ • Y.� "rsia i 3 =- ma y--�2- t�. •Id 'orch...now enclosed to serve as oyer. •riginal Floor &Wood s:Wtanning&Za,ingSoardsu•PB\Dietrich Residence.doc 04/26/2006 10:34 FAX 5612437211 DELRAY BCH COMM IMP-P&Z [2 001 *************************** *** ERROR TX REPORT *** *************************** TX FUNCTION WAS NOT COMPLETED TX/RX NO 1830 RECIPIENT ADDRESS 919544291207 DESTINATION ID ST. TIME 04/26 10:33 TIME USE 00'35 PAGES SENT 0 RESULT NG #0018 BUSY/NO SIGNAL PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE DELRAYUFACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 v = a,t-ae�enrac 1 "`_', " P (561) 243-7040 q4 (561) 243-7221 FAX 1993 e-mail: pzmail@mydelraybeach.com zoos FASCIMILE COVER SHEET DATE: a Lc a--ock . TO: /irll ab, eY_,41!?4,10/1 R SLt •L12g •1 FROM: litri_c_f___CiA Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: l� COMMENTS -:-. .,.. --'- • - - - _ -. -C ..• - -- . .. ••_ • tr-,I,4.1,1044 t ,, - • I -.- 1 -1,110-7 ip.- — , ..------ - -r 4 a, 1 IC •.1 %.. • -1 j•eV' ' 1,1. • oF -'Si. ,, , ••.; y...g 0. .• . L , . ' -- • :;,',,.ki ; I.i 4. ... , ,.. ,..,. ,. ,,, ,,...„... ., .. .. .. _„.... . _. , . --,:sir - - - • ti).00 0. %I, ... .•.4....-......... . i , ,„ .., , . , , . . . ... I .....„ .k.,j..4. .. ,4•.,,,,,-,,aft . el w, -- i , '4,4.• -1;----- ., A_ + 11 - ''' e••% 414 ' "Ila • - -, -, Ai ik.• • •:-.41 1...f: '‘ ' N' ...„,„,......__...------ -.. ---:- . - 1 4••• 14`.^1,•.::, • V • i it- ,•• ./w•• ir 4711.01.:2:, ' ••, ..,.' . ' , .., A ; , . . .1, ,pt, 4 ' ''` 4... . , _... ., . ...,s • • i I 7 . ai: , —,- , ... ... . . , . , .....,„,,q, . . .. ....,,.,.....,,, .,r ,..• l. ' - .•- t 4 —... .• . 1, _-..,_.-:•.-.:.• - 4. • i . w-L - 1"••..c.4 ii•'' t• ..„---i•E`--." i• - ''Iv4vr t • . \ "•_- '1"'- .-• • ,• . .k., . . 11-- ,7- .. -A•hkg!4 -,1 1' r•• • 4•`-' .4''I 1 . ,;'- . • P-.. .' 'e•-, 1 " -- . 1164... Nk ,.., " O4 ,_ ..: i r......:::-.`Zr•3 '.,.11::1 .ii I'',.., AI, '.: 7".. ; - • * ...;•1111%t.' i''' .--4..1? .44 - ;-;t; lt . • ' .' . . .::.411i: : }. i' 4 1,,i. $- •'44 ...•-•,. .• .. ' ' --4' • ti, - ..1,-`2:,;:" •-• ... j ' Ay 154,,..t. ip)-4.:, 'r 4, -•14d--'t f•- - 4 . j 7.'" - 1 --- - -- - ,- __•, , _ , 4,- ,_A„,:...,,,-..- . r- -% .r -, Ili " - ---*ti'' .I i -.,-7--; '‘' - 1 Ili - I . :rill-Alb:1.0'4. i •1 .t, ' • • • 4 . - d'i r i, • . A . ' 1•,- i .. . . , E4-','..-•••-,.. i i .r,_,. • .• 9.., , ii-i_,••*, '14 ill -" ,,,-It'' 4 ,,,.,• VI er -.9 .... i• • ,,,, • I [ .i ,' ••• ......,;•----: .„.... ti• i ..:4 4 • 'i • - • . .11-kitr-I: i •1 . ._.- - '- • i ' .1.1 tr'' i.4.PaPE,.., '. I, 8 L. 3..•• li i _ v 1 ..-- „.,--:.•1•, - 1, • t, ..., i.z. ... 1\--- L.-rar:=1:,4 11 , .? 1. 0.,4f. -. .w... %,• . .. 4 1'? • tJ ,4,.. L,o' •t4°. . ,4 , 0• -.1/4 .,4,...: I - -r . ,,,,e."7.-7 94 e. . 1.; . - , :le f .,--.4, 41. , i'. r7- Ls ,,.. . As. -A,f44' :':e 40 • 1 T'r f j ' ...,...,........„.....---,...0..trylArt; .,.;.:T---7---.. --„, ,..—,. - —r-.••".17.,„="7:-...••••::--- r..r1.7: i'. t; I re': .. , _._ „--,...-...air:; ,7 . • _ip • • - .. _ .. - 'I '"•':"•.•.•'.4.--•--•1.), . 1 - --'''''' - -•4-API ia ' — - --s- At"' -. 1 1 7. Fox Ilouse, main residence, southeast corner detail. '7- " ---...___•—— _2 .. i \- *--- NO 4 -'- -t,I . -•- --- .4 ••• - -' s , t te*i:-.. -4, ,./-:-" . '- i1•_ ., ,,,,.,:,„ , , . he ,.,$:..., _ ... ,,, -‘,. c•:.. • •-ri.,-- - - • •-• • •• - ' - - • t .ir. • - .A. I . •,...4- • b:4' ' -. •. . • ef...7'". . - \ - •1 s _ .• k••,N, k ...-••" _. 1_ .....-10"'"'-',.;4.• r: \ I• 144 i.t . le.4t 's -1-- ---..•-•- il...igiff. .'... - r • r. _ .- ••-.4„ rij:• ..a Asse T 611%. . .'''' • - 'I.. 1 I • - Ao.t- • ' V. 1 .-,_ . • ... .14 1 4 • I.t 1111 1111- 1 • ' L dii a 1054 '.11 . :',1 .•;,' : i 1 ii • • t 4.4 ...... .: ",,,,A .• . 1 1 . t i it ., • - ,-• a... .0;4 .., I i E. i I: I I ., .. .., yrif 14 t 1.---. . .: !ii 1 ti-tl 1 1 -- 1 ; io• --4. ". A• • .... i lirt.dr- ' • ..,. , .41 14) a 1 0 1 ti 1 0 ' IP% •;* I FA en._".......' -... I I NI ""ii"...,, • • • 4444144414* ......,... ig VG••. 4 . . I i - . --.:4 ......_: • -.., . / . . i.. / -•.r-- .• I I 8. Fox House, main residence, south side with guest cottage. ( • ( Page 1 "HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORIILL Site# PB10270 N. Original7. FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 366 Update ❑ Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions Recorder Date 2/1999 Site Name 238 SE 7th Avenue Other Names None Project Name Delray Beach Survey& Planning Project Historic Contexts Depression/New Deal National Register Category Building LOCATION and IDENTIFICATION Address 238 SE 7th Avenue Vicinity of SE 3rd St and SE 2nd St on W City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969& 1973 Townshi 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr SE Irregular Section ❑ UTM Zone 17 Easting 0593097 Northing 2926450 Land Grant Unknown Latitude Longitude Plat or Other Map Palm Beach County Aerials HISTORY Architect/Builder Mark Vigneault(1999 renovations) Construction Date 1937 Circa L Alterations 1 Date c. 1999 Type/Location windows replaced Additions Date c. 1999 Type/Location two-story addition added to the northeast corner II D Original Location _i anal Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence DESGR1pTION.. • Style Split-Level Exterior Plan L-shaped Interior Plan Unknown Stories 2 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Weatherboard Foundatio Pier Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infil Concrete Block No. of Porches 1 Locations/Features east: hipped porch supported by wood posts(inside the"L") Dormers ❑ Number/Location Outbldgs. t Number 1 Nature/Location (Describe below) One-story wood frame shed to the northwest Roof Type Cross-Gable Roofing Materials 5-V Sheet Metal Secondary Structures o Comments/Location Chimneys k Number 1 Orientation South Location Wall, Exterior Material Brick Wood Windows Type DHS Light# 6/6 Metal Windows L, Type Light# Exterior Ornament Cornerboards, Rafter Tails,Vents,Shutters Condition Excellent Surroundings Residential Narrative (general, interior, landscape, context; 3 lines only) This building has been significantly altered by the replacement of windows and a large two-story addition which obscures the original structure. Flat wood trim surrounds the windows and triple French doors are located in the entryway. This building was originally a common example of 1930s residential construction. aeological Remains Present n None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 f rage 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM • Site# PB10270 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms.for detailed instructions RECORDER'S EVALUATION OF SITE Eligible for National Register? Yes No wG Likely, Need Informatio C Insufficient Information E Significant as Part of District? Yes 7 No o� Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information i Significant at Local Level? Yes j No Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information p Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This late-1930s residence is considered a contributing resource within the Marina Historic District.Although it has undergone modifications, it still maintains its integrity and represents the historic architecture of the area.This residence is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP on an individual basis or as part of a historic district. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS DHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL OFFICE DOCUMENTATION Research Methods Sanborn maps, Plat maps,Local&County Historical Societies Bibliographic References Location:City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Location of Negatives City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Negative Numbers 9874-24;21;W u, RECORDER-INFORMATION : Recorder Name Amy Groover,Jo-Anne Peck, Susan Hochberg Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5'MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3., PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,PREFERABLY B&W,AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 • Y.a, ',.- t1SGS QUADRANGL E-MAP. �t fT t xJ ,, i-"..+�,.,c('`.r,s.'-.�.,;�11gJ "---'`r'i,.'.°"'.. ..7 • '2 , ,i' j .+ 1 v :.•.•' 1 .sue /+• a, _ nr ....�4. i .T : ,.,.`s .,r.. r., / nl r r I niw.-srH �I sr --J , I1i ll Club- •• 4t L ��``•r.rA�^ _s.7 /„ ;/, /k ,`t/. .�.�— __� 7 �'�i9 ^r ' .in:.: .7/ NE �BrH I !i.1�_. - _% .1�=. I _ �_r h 1 -� = t.O �/ • t 1 C I / - I I - _L_.=�_ it r I ti r - = C `J I I =ir � L K 1 1 • y , _ __ • r.IEIJ7 , • �— :` - • ;*-....-:- „ ' , 1. r,/,/ ,_ /, Rio Ii ,'w Ir !. t ,;'h III I Q t_�Elkhart ._ i _ I I - , fit- •• 4TH oT� - • t__Jt�'I IJ4.¢I1I r. . . ✓TI�If i. 1S7. r ' II0{I II I i�i: IiI J I1 �oql Li _�Ii`__�f I. r_.Il _▪ ' /TTai-.- i.sEr.7.7i1 1Iclil- ,.It- .1, ,L 1▪ II •l!.� "aoI -!'7 r- - 'Is JrI -zII�' 3 II I r I I o 1 -�, II i' ``' Wat rw'`r sr'j I •-• I �� I j - --,i , rs -It iT ii• t/I 'I � Jh t 1 +n • .J f - __ ri'I II '� �4 K.V (20I..r[ I T1L i,L__7F I L3 k'�.iE 4k11� iIJ JAI • +II El-4AY I!BE IH 11-io :11 IN:,-I l r1l��y , �-� -I l I I STa 11 F I ' L II I l,�,l I/ t E I s +'f -1sr ____ g.ound I _,1 ,, l���t lr :r !I _I' „_ ...—2 .-i i x`— .. 'z t-- J- = 1 L° • / It ▪-?I'; 'Il If I[ -J Il '1d _ I iI ,l •,..I�i I! r,•11 -t, y • • 1 s / ;` 4J 1 mil II .-I`:11 . Y . t ar�a r .I _ IIE ill fl 1i 11 '.L Jl 1: i I •i 10% i JI�06 _�" � L=� I „j.1_ I •I q I lI _t 1'' alc.ant j I•.■1 I, -• �; 1 I : I WI "IE II 1 I Ball WI c y; ' 11` v;, �/ -'• 4 — r I I- II 11 I >I/� t :1 Chi sc jf ii17 I r I1 ¢I I Ir '7 Lr II� •� iI � <_ L��t` Isw:1 Jusr,1�.J I � I I ¢1l,J�y �, �It �I '� the lPa�.: I' + �` —1 'a :4 Itlt } �• I :, i, tk 1 .—`—' 1� � I r ( ot ,ri . ¢] 1Fu I -' r1 .�' _• � tI p �l= .,u. , � ,_ 41 3 L I r—•-- I 1�— 1 ill • I_ J • . t 3 Ire. . I h�� il- �� JI 1 0��� 1c 11I I _ l �F -. 33 s .▪— d � Iirk rl iii H ' Ht' l Ip_%rep I. d jI Ji, . i,,--:.��,1.....a.: w1 l rr• l l_=1sr1 , �7, _ 1C . , i lI JI I" -i- L III r— 'Zit I if 1u 1 -=w 11 ILA ' '-� J�� BPl3�O270 lii ♦rr 4k ��j USGS Delray Beach; Fla. Quadrangle 1 ;�'_ �1 h • Pine Ride •.0 i. of, -sAi 1[,-,7 sr" (l_ _ =Ce e •ii—_`` ,I I:LIttiThan,ue r J 7.5 Minute Series(Topographic) �11 i_ 11 •I^I 11I_ _ Ba FLbId I I I , ,�° ,5 I. �� � I� 1, I 1962; Photo reused 1969 and 1973 1 1 _ ..� _ i e IF 1 �I• f�'. II , i I,I- Scale 1. 24 000 11 I 17-n II :II- I I' Ir]nLA .. \ b - ` 3 PI QTOGRAR:it `-t Z- = z r SKETC E MA---- _'--- — liL w ` �' �S ti?•,I,Pi!' I .� 1, l�S � w- f�•'-.�,.. --z, )-_,.li CV LI` `'``, ,-fir. •\ 'tr..ir _ L.1• - ;L_ • t. i.- •I-� • •ti7 t / 14l61+ :, -r j to ` ' r .,, t CAD _ J .• _ L �� _ • ss -- • - ��� � -- D N N - • 1• \ to ` ` _ - G ❑ NW 04 — -.ate_.---•.o-:.._....<.._:... - t _-. - - ki , _ ` — l f �� - • '' u r 'e+ emmome.5.. • • • ko - i • • ` 4 9 • i ---.. ..1.N-N%,\E\ . •... . N.} . I ,:——----:-1 • - I N„, 'N.. "'`. •Cf _ 1 14' - .''.e••• Z 1., \I. \/ r• 1 \S.4Nc,... . - - -e . / r / '� • i,,`I -• tit - ` -� ° . • • • i - t• /- -- { . f: -� - _ - -- C� --- — ` ��i ------- ----ram ------ --1 1/ --- . f • � 7 •/-) / -Y=; --, . E-y I \� , ,,. , �1 f f// � i • y, yC ! ` PERMIT NO '-.-'1-�:.�_. ,. - _• _ • 41 - • PEiT � ( -- • / • l • r • ei . - - J_. _-._ - - __- -.�.� • • • T . ._. ! - - - - - _ _ _ _ - • • saw '� _- �. ra ' 'l -• _ _ - - - i , g .: - - -- - - • • • • • • i, • • - .. s': • • • • • - • i' I • -4. _ • _ In • _-, .. v .. , t. ', ' '.� it • �• • 1 1 '•fi�S I - 1/• cl «� °3 I S u3 i" y • le l 3I:wJ�i� t a • ....1 'i • • ' !' • • ! 11 • • �• , �t. t • + it • r ,; • /.' f 1 ` �..• I'• • , .�` 1 {�+ I • • • _ , • "f , • - ./i, 2, 1 . • 1 j� • 1 I J • • • • . II _ _.. i Ft • 1 �� a Is • ( sya : i • • • • _ i f(/ • ,, ,;.). :..r. •..:- ; .!:. •,' ''....;,''.!. - . 'I;i'.•..• .. ' • • Li � I ' 3 • • • • ) . , ,• . . . • . •• . , ' • • • i. r • • • • • v i�h )I' " • ' • • • • I ISI• - " • y, • it i t. ' tI 1 • • • • ..I PERMIT NO. . ',....././):*4. . .S�P .. ... DA i(`• ,Gz��'ct.�. �..,.1g3.•�. •OWNER ...--c .al.r- ,): a " , 1 ARCI- ITECT -. .._..... ... :� . ..... . .. . . • 1;1 ty ..,,,,,,Z":..., ., j,... •':(r.,, i ~ f t • / taw - ' + T {{ A/r.d yf i:S4) .1 ,. �..Iv• .• •,1 • .. • 'i Io a. _i.. m^-µt ?-..n•i,..! nt*'.;;cl•11, ..r i.;,.�. ;r;..r e.±�5 ...�_ e • • • „_ _.—•.-- 7 - ••-•..-j�^_y a`�'I. .;.' llfi '•" 3. • j" .T.: j*��7 •7 v 9 Q /) • k • • • ti L M I I3A10 •, y 1�1II� • �; Q ...�, ® i LIY,Z213�i • t ( • • • • • • .. f • / • ;I!• • i ` >f ��;• ' • • • k\s / •• ('• r L ti I �2 c!l(* 2u • .•14/)1 . 1____47-- , 1.-7_-,.. It 1-:::::::‘,•k_-., ... ,' IL, _,...--'' lk ' • • i) . . . ... . • i. • -.---- 1. '� 7 �1 _, is • , 1• • "I 1. • _t` 1 I / 1f` j • aI �• U/ Tfi 1 (--- , • . . i 1('-, ' ' * - . ''..*:. ; , , . ,, • . • . . 4 0 1:* , •• 1 . .: ' / - N., ,.(4 •,, - .. I ,.\‘, . .1 ' N v ,. 4 , • i, - . .. :_1 1 _ ________..:__:_./ , ..)--1. .. , .' 1 '':I 1 L2L_ .. • . ,...., . I • 4 • • � I T; 1_NI N, .r am ; i•,' :I 1�f , ,,) • .,•4 '—I..1y 1 4 •'fit ., I,• i I ' {n C N >� /� tQ y V ' .gyp C.N N ,' Y• `t, ,• / k ,• ' 1 l • � :1 4 rI I J 5 t Y • ..,.,\ • Yi I }:. r 'Y a a ; , tiII,I' � t _' • , f f ` r �1 a • • • la, , r.rr M r. e J ._ �, t ( • ice . • i < • ti • • • r tM • for• , • • . „ 0 t•'::'I,i . . , ... . ,...!,i1; , • • • ";;'''''• •'I.!!,' .7 t • I . . • :,1:? . • I. . • . , , • • . . 4• , . ' :I'II.'''• . • . .... . • . '•ILil . i' , • ,I. •I:,;,,,,,..•, I . . . '• ' •I • ' i • , , 'V•: ',"1IJ X.. . . . . ; I . . , III 1. • , ... . .,... •, . • 'ot A 4 • . , . . . . , ' '' 'il•l' ' . N I . -..-1:I.II F— ,,_..._.._.___..____. _ • . • \\N....,...„ •• ', t.: 11:,, I . ' . "I.,IR,,, . El .•. •..-_. . , . . . 1 1 :11 . )‘,/,t.• _4 • . 1 • . • • A ''''' . . 1 0 • .I ,_ - - - I • • \ 1.1 . ' . , i • I' • 1 'lld ' I4 I ' 1 • P . I : -,, )< • _. . • :,,,---,----..: .. .. _______ ' '..1)fr!. . • 1\ .1 •- 0 '--7 t .. i . . .,.... -•!;•1.11.;• 1- _ . .. . . - t . • • ,...t•,!lsit,-:, , 1 1 - .____, . . . :, .• __._ .',c..t22 • - -, • - 1 , • , .11 .. • . i•; - .:- • . 1 , ‘•-; I •.;• ______ 11 • . .. , . • ,-..1,19' , .- '1 • ... ! ,,--- •• ---T. , , . :;!-I-r!-› • :- •'- ••••.• '1,. , si• ' • • •-; ) '. ...•;;•!'.•••. , ._ .....••••• . l• . . ; • t • "..) t•I 11,1117' . • • • • I : - • ! ; 1 . I I ( .• Li ' -, , • ,-...-. . , . , • I ‘,..,..••••-•.'- . • . „.•• . , • 1.-.L. i i • I. , -. • • ..• ,. I, , ,, • . ,' ',.......V .‘• i , , . • 4,11.,, u,...4,,,,,,. , , . . . ' ... . , , . . , , . , . . 1 . . • .-- . . _ . . " ri [7 . . . - _ . T •• I II ' . '• I ...— .. • • I'I I I i • ' . ••' — - ,o' . -1 - 1 1 . ...1. .' • I ......... ; .. . _......' . • . k . . ' •+`I II I I . _.. .- .. . • • - • it • 1 ; • ,-7;-- • \ • 1 \ • • . ... • • i , ,• , . , I - —..' i , \ . . .-- • -;' .- ! / I 'I I • r,' , , ,, •._:.., 1 '1.1 -..• i--- ,,,,,,,,,. • , i . .! . . • . . , . 1 -----__ . . , I 4 . k.... :). •,'. ' . , . , rj,''':..:-.".-:• '":::. . ' , . , X . ' . . • • • 1.--— - ' i. : _ it. ..'... .1 . . i ;) ', i_ . . .., , ,, ••::: • : r,'r . . I-- 1 .1 , • :!' . • !• )4 ' ' l'Il ,i 1, , • ; , ) 1 .,.. 1 . . , . ,, / ,,,t.-,0— II, . ?'',......" , i I ) , , c , IF, • . 1.r • .--„, _ ‹c.,5, _ ;3 -/' • 1,, 52)-3 1-,,', -:. •,,.. ..4- • , - : T 7.,I :, ','.,,:• 4er 2_ 1 i •-•----7', 7 • ti /7 ,e...41.").. ::4— •"-1-''74--0 NA':`i 11.7 t: 111..- . --1 4.'- '•,., ' • . .. l . ,- '31511.,D17. -. I—•-/ • • ••••,- -- "-- ' . . . • i .. . . •. , . . , . . . .. . , ' ._.__.....—.-............-.---._..,...„ ,.,..................a.ania.... • .6.M.IMMINOZnegIntIOrak. ' 1 =ma.