Loading...
319 SE 7th Avenue, Hadden 1950 Blank - FMSF DISTRICT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA H IAA SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT ' Improved OWNER Virginia 3LANK-NICHOLS Ni 128 51O1 of & vacant Blank Hadden . All 6 ADDRESS Box 1114, Delray Beach., Fla. Exempt r DESCRIPTION: OWNER' t ADDRESS • OWNER 319 S.E. 7th Ave . ADDRESS YEAR- 1962 �jJ, 1963 1964 t J 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 EXEMPTION {-] U j� H ).1, ...... J _ 1972 1973 -I LAND (0z3 0 C�/�..0 . h�1/v 6.230 623o1, 623o 787 7 7,7 BLOCS. 3I ba T /0/. Y,/ a( 23 /o5 2193-ot, 21950 '71743'7_ y7y'�j7 TOTALS 9 ,3 (r0 7,7'�er, 7,�9'3OD 29 300 2 8 zo o P. .- / /� Js , , 2$,zoo _fie}5po ��yo� 3��oa PER. PROP. 00 g:00 SQ o jQ 0 cO 0 P, ✓ DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING BUILDING PLAN i ;%)) BUILDING DIMENSIONS 1 � 1 _ TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF iNT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS It} / ✓ I .� U�. C,/ ��SIFE z� NO. • rilFIG STORIES / Slagle Dwlg. `� None Gable ••---••Plaster 7 Decorated Sprint. (Fire) ! vrzj (� art Double Dwlg. Part /_Hip Pine �_ �] ' X - �' �� �, Fire Escapes a . 'y* Duplex Dwlp. Fell .....--Flat •-•--•-Hardwood ._ F 7 Refrigerators r -- - .,. / `�,"y -o,f Apartment Dirt Floor Mansard -••••-Metal 7�> _ • Marble&Tile Vat.C.Sys. X Store Cement Floor • PORGIIES Panels Skylights J{ - ._._.._Store 6 Office Finish FLOORS Fireplacesti �// _ f,� X _-_.Store 6 Apt. X Front + ----- y 2�J y/ , I ,r Office HEATING x Side Wood MIII Joists Incinerators I �' _ % +.1 Solar W.Sys. .".. �,p_------..Hotel None X Rear Steel BeamsAir Con.Sys. f . . --- ��c�6' X 6 Oft'-' ✓s--.. --______Theatre Stoves X Sleep. .---✓R;inf.Concrete --' _._ 011 Burner _____-.Reinf.Tile Garage(Apt.) CONSTRUCTION FLOORING •" i s6G C%N•I IR BAD EXT. WALLS Dirt FACTORS , _--Garage(Sere.) Fireplace r + t { 7 I GOOD FAIR BAD _.-._..Garage(PM./ l-Wood Siding .No.of Rooms I - _ __.....Gas Station RrIck yr Pine Apartments - "- - - hChurch Wood Hardwood --•-- "' - - ---- -- Wood Frame ..--. Brick Cased ___-_--Rooms 6 Apt. School / Concrete Lumber Sheds Steel Frame d Stucco ✓....The Fin.Attic R. s ,--✓ Me.Concrete Metal 65 �.Marble Fin.Rase.R. I ROOFING Mill M ingl Terrazzo t Brick Shingle Linoleum •- -'0Date Cemplt. �,_ SQ.FT. V.P. TOTAL Shingle Concrete Tile {DL Aqe f o o 7 ______ Pitch 6 Gravel EXT. TRIM PLUMBING Remodeled____Metal Plain FOUNDATIONS Plain ..�- -Nona c� - ♦ 1-. ,,. l - Fixtei �. . _ Stone Ornamental LIGHTING - i-- .-__.--..Composition .Toilets ( VALUATION Slate (/ ••--Concrete Wood .. .1 Bathroom: ✓ RECAPITULA1ON Brick Stucco Electric or _..-V_Tile-Flat or Tile Terra Cotta Baths,lBeflt-In ✓ Gas $ �� r / Ornamental Piers Metal !1 - Showers Lamps �.."... + ... . ... "... �. .__. ..1. ..._. LAND APPRAISAL ...... -- -- --- - ADDITIONAL--- I BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front JNice Factor Factor Foot V ee Valuation io x 173.E /t�0 /.o b' Q �J LOTS — __ / ACREAGE St.- IMPROVEMENTS Level Level BUILDINGS S V (� .1 / Enhancing Factor j"" v ((�/ Detracting Factor % ACRES ® Rocky Swampy Curb TOTAL Swam /Water l� %�z f Swampy Farm LAND / , Wooded Sewer - - --./ TOTAL LAND VALUATION Electric Light TOTAL LAND .0,, !` / /g Cs AND CLOGS. $ J 6 r / — DISTRICT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA R ( A I SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT Improved OWNER Vi r'ri ni n in r nk liaddPn S1O' of JCJ Vacant ADDRESS Box 1114 Cie BLANK-NICHOLS N 2 128 rill 6 Exempt ' Y DESCRIPTION: OWNER ADDRESS ,; OWNER ADDRESS YEAR— 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 , 1968 1969 '1970 1971 1972 • EXEMPTION LAND 3/ i 0 ~ -- BLDGS. 3 ; U , r/ TOTALS t ,• .I PER. PROP. 3 V c) DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING _ ,JitTNG PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS — �4 -- — -- ------I—�—{—k=— SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS Oa-- _ I I _ ___ Piaster Slagle Dwip. None Gable Decorated SDrink. (Fire) ng r__-�_ — #� —� •} X ! ---- Double Dwlp. Part Hip Pine Fire Escapes _---_-ITI T -_-_-_- Double Duplex DwID. Full Flat Mard Hardwood Refrigerators I I X ---- ------ — Aparlment _......Dirt Floor Mansard Marble&Tile Vat.C.Sys. -- I - rI LI Store Cement Floor Panels .Skylights —`S. —_-- I I —_ I LE— &Office Finish PORCHES ...._• FLOORS Fireplaces --- I I r X ...._....Store 6 Apt. % Front —_ -- T —— —— HEATING Wood Joists Incinerators --- ! ..._....Office % Slde Mill Solar W.Sys. — --- I _`_ �I I I — X Hotel None X Rear Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. — --- --Steel Beams Concrete _ _ _ —I —%J Theatre Stoves X Meta. Reinf.Tlie 1 — ---- - CONDITION Garage(Apt.) 011 Burner Dirt -- r' EXT. WALLS FACTORS —�— Garape(Scrv.) Fireplace I I __—_— GOOD FAIR BAD ._.-..Garage(Prrt.) Wood Siding FLOORING ....__No.of Rooms _.— LI ____—! __-- CONSTRUCTION Pine --- Hardwood Gas Station Brick .Apartments L I _ Church� �•—•• -------- --------I _ �I Wood Frame Bruck Cased Marble Rooms t Apt. — - 1- —=-- Ehh ---- Ct ----Wri illi.Coete BlockIII Sheds tee ra • Terrano Shtch a Grarel _ —� I JJd _ I ' I IISD.FT. V.P. TOTALG riek Y Shingle .. Concrete Tile PLUMBING Age -- ---- EXT. TRIM Remodeled FOUNDATIONS None .____Metal Plain Fixture ----I _____— I II-LI1 VALUATION ._ Composition Stone Ornamental Toilets LIGHTING ----I --- herb- _--_ -I I RECAPITULATION Concrete Wood Bathroom: I -- SlateElectric -Bilek Stuccoer Bile aths,Floor _—, —I_I —___---- --I I __ S .._......Tile---Flat or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Balit•In .....--Gas — I I�— -- _ I I Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps -----1 .nl r} _ I I I I_ J..jT�I' R —LL—I---- LAND APPRAISAL J _I_I_ --- _^e7 LI— A7DITIONAL I I I�� I�l 3 II BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Cornerct Front Valuation j.a a r- — �(i /0 0 Q Price Factor Factor Foot Value �f 7 �7 LOTS ACREAGE ST. IMPROVEMENTS 1 .�,•I X 160 h6 / V 6 0 Level Level red --- TOTAL/ ✓ High Hilly Dirt TOTAL I X 7?�•J 75- / 3/ Low Rocky Sidewalk BUILDINGS S Rocky Swampy Curb Enhancing Factor • / ter TOTAL ACRES 3 / 7 U Swampy Farm LAYD Detracting factor � @ Wooded Sewe.. eetrk Light TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION Gas AND CLOGS. $ • "" DISTRICT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA (i'-•/ f1 Fr SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT Improved OWNER Vpir ni a Blank Had den n('1 C Vacant ''O�"`" - City Bwc 5 f// ' • JX cl.n.A.,`� - .\-"C11i.6�') ' ' w I/y 128 Pt 5,6 Exempt ADDRESS / -- DESCRIPTION: ' • ? 0OWNER 5-"ke 12t..d-6--YYte/ 1.,..,,,., rd,;.�s.'t —,1 ,i.--4�Q. � ADDRESS S 10' of Lot 5 and All Lot 6 /.....,_ '/`j�� OWNER J/ ADDRESS YEAR— 1949 1950 1\\."'1951 '.I( 1952 I 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 J EXEMPTION HA hir r ! AN - X,. ff-- LAND 1 �Jt!) z p 7 �,,://8 e"7 7i Y�o 'G` �/ "YJ 07 �J2/7'/D'�7 ill / Y, ci---�� 7,r �,r_. BLDGS. ) R1.K� c c I`Yt?Gf0 l y'UL•U r G 0' ;Ja I Co-0 I7 (�L'U r t-.� TOTALS / % /g IS /C 0 0_. /`6 r i I�!f r /2 /ow /z� o�ro / /o - /‘ 4& /(, ��`7T) /4' , �: PER. PROP. t°+r r �� % �} '7 .:f G (/ •J C' Z 1 i.:,,.ti ; r� .✓ r-r h fi ,/' C s--r, 5 D BUILDING.�LAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING 1=17 �.—:,'� ei6 -7a� —I SIZE HEIGHT STORIES TYPE BLDG.. BASEMENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS _— 'r i ____ _— Single Dwlg. v None able Decorated Sorhik.(Fire) / Double Owlp. Part Y.._.Jrd capes -- X?µ a.L� ?� t/— + - — f — 1�rators _ �. ", rIItFloor Marble&The Vac.C.Sys. .e� I� _ r — %` --- v''! ,� I �)A 1' L'' e ____--.Store Cement Floor PanelsSkylights ,✓ Zjg r �--- T cs PORCHES -- -- c—T— f — --- FLO Store&Office Finish AP/ex''' 'Side Wood Joists Solar Sys. — -- — — . 1" C— �' � 10 R� I�}yt'= r ! Store&Apt. a 6 Front _RS .Fireplaces 'HEATING ' -E _ '— _ -- Office Mill ___ _—___..Hotel None X Rear 1�/Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. -- — -- — G Stoves X:` Sleep. ---Y-Point.Concrete -- — p/ r` +'' ,��' f /' i„s' '' !NI_ _ it Theatre P• Reinf.Tile ----� ,r�7'`-9`— v di 7 �' -- ' l'CO DITION Garage(Apt.) Oil Burner Dirt = /.^ Lea --- E T. d Siding FACTORS 7y / //� i Garage(Sere.) Fkepiace /X y_7.e —�,/ „ ---- GOOD FAIN BAD -.1 Wood Siding F OORING No.of Rooms —I� ✓ 1� /� ._._....Garage (Prot.) CONSTRUCTIONPine �_.r �� '��' ----- Gas Station Brick Apartments — _ Church VZ Hardwood y -- + School Wood Frame Brick Cased ,C�oncrete Rooms&Apt. ;' I-I' -. y =I—I y --- r Lumber Sheds Steel Frame //Stucco 1 L (Tile r�Fin.Attic RR.. .y. T.- r?, i I %Qh_ a�- e ..1�..Reinf.Concrete _.... Metal ], Marble - Fin.Base. — `A L' I�4`��45,®` .' . - -�-- -„ff a ---- (q� [/.Terrazzo $cDale Compit. Mill �Qlock e.t. L, _—_— ~ /ROOFING /� Linoleum 6j- I . i _I_r----1-75.-61:- �.01 p4.FT. Y.P. TOTAL Brick ShingleShingle Concrete Tile Age I r PLUMBING -- ------- — ----- G ---- L .e, '7 r', ._,..... &Gravel EXT. TRIM Remodeled I — �/ i �` ,- , FOUNDATIONS None �/� �l Metal Plain -Fixtureu��`' — ----- r � 'I �ti1. — -- VALUATION ComDoslto Stone Ornamental _.._. LIGHTING /► -- --- �_`+ RECAPITULATION __Concrete Wood Bathroom: V./Electric — J t _ r, ----_ Slate(1�(� . Brick Stucco Tile Floor 1 I 1--_r _ yyl�i. - — T - LT—L at or Tile Terra Gotta Baths,Built-In -- --Gas — --- — ,r �— V 1-- Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps I I I 1 , : i z :' y /";, 0-1--- z,I /7✓ / LAND APPRAISAL -- � I j_jJI --- ADDITIONAL 1,-' �I I BUILDINGS i�4• v" s Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front Price Factor Factor Foot Value Valuation ,,:/....;','., LOTS ACREAGE ST. IMPROVEMENTS i•'�. / / O -' v,.2l0 L.-� / LS eL$ a 4-Level Level ----.1.'Paved -- / ; Hilly Dirt TOTAL X y Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ 72 •/ 7 3., 7 3- t i �, 9 L/ ( Low Rocky Rocky Swampy Curb Enhaueinp Factor ___L NJater TOTAL ACRES --� ^'-- Swampy farm Sewer- Detracting Factor % @ LAND L C1 7 Wooded (.Electric Light TOTAL LAND • TOTAL LAND VALUATION / Gas AND BLDGS. $ contributing property at 319 SE 7th Avenue, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). Ms. Shay entered the project file into record and presented the proposed project. In August 2001, the Board reviewed a COA request to construct a 7,232 sq. ft. two-story dwelling and demolition of the non-contributing dwelling. The Board directed that the elevations be altered to reflect a more distinct architectural style. After direction by the Board regarding the elevations, the applicant re-submitted the request and the Board approved the modified elevations. The applicant is now before the Board for review and approval of additional elevation changes and a reduction of the proposed square footage from 7,323 sq. ft. to 6,907 in addition to some additional exterior modifications. Staff requested that the applicant submit a lighting detail and paint samples as conditions of approval. Mr. Colestock was present to represent the project. Mr. Colestock presented a lighting detail and stated that paint samples will be coordinated with the interior and will therefore be submitted at a later date. Mr. Branning asked for details about the balcony railings. Mr. Colestock provided clarification. Ms. McDermott questioned the use of a stone fence in Delray. Mr. Colestock stated that it will resemble sandstone. Ms. Shay stated that the stone compliments the surrounding architecture and landscaping. Ms. McDermott also inquired about the shutters. Mr. Colestock stated that they are decorative and will have shutter dogs. Ms. Sexton questioned the use of the two-story window and its location on the south end of the building. Mr. Perez stated that the large windows are not appropriate for the style. Mr. Keavney concurred. Ms. Elliott expressed concern over the high style displayed in the front of the house and the minimal design of the rear (Intracoastal side) including the change of windows and lack of shutters. Mr. Perez felt that the two-story windows should be separated to create a transom at the top to bring the windows into proportion with the building. -3- HPB Minutes 3/12/03 After much discussion, it was moved by Mr. Perez, seconded by Ms. Sexton and passed 7-0 to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 319 SE 7th Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to the LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8) (a-c), (E)(8)(g), (E)(8)(h), and (E)(8)(j), the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation subject to the following condition: 1) That the applicant submit paint samples and a lighting detail. 2) That the windows and doors around the great hall be divided with a beam approximately 8'-10' high at the discretion of the architect. Ill. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments: None B. Report from Historic District Representatives: None C. Board Members: Mr. Perez expressed his concern over the design guidelines, particularly with respect to the "New Construction" section. Issues such as scale and massing are a concern and should be the focus of the design guidelines update. It was agreed that.the Board would meet without the consultant to review and edit the section on April 2, 2003, prior to the next special meeting. Ms. Jamison questioned the current setbacks of projects and suggested that they may not be appropriate. Ms. Shay stated that it was a zoning issue. Ms. Elliott presented a new design for decorative wood shutters with copper caps and a brochure with decorative shutter dogs which state that they meet the current Florida Building Code. D. Staff: None -4- HPB Minutes 3/12/03 * The paint is to be removed from the chimney and front porch piers so that the original coquina rock is exposed. * Exterior paint colors: - Walls, Pratt & Lambert 2086 Tenne - Trim, Pratt & Lambert 1288 Argosy Pratt & Second color trim if desired, Lambert 1290 Heron It was moved by Mr. Williams, seconded by Mr. Miller and passed 5-0 to approve COA 8-229 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(E) for Phase II . C. COA 8-34 : 319 S.E. 7th Avenue; Marina Historic District; Blair Construction, Authorized Agent. The action requested of the Board is to grant approval r for e0A floor 34 of aor the single family residence renovations secondre idence as follows: * Remove the center window of the front elevation and install two new double hung wood windows . Window openings are approximately 30" x 40" . The new windows will. extend to the height of the original opening, which is to the frieze board. * Remove the center window on the south facade. * Install wire lath and stucco over the existing paneling. * Exterior paint color as existing: main color pale yellow; trim, white. It was moved by Mr. Vaughan, seconded by Mr. Miller and passed 5-0 to approve COA 8-234 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(E) subject to the following condition: * That functional wood shutters be added to the two new windows on the front facade. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Review the Designation Report and Establish a Date for the Public Hearing Required for Nomination to the Local Register of Historic Places for the American Legion Building at 263 N.E. 5th Avenue. - 3 - 08/03/94 OA AGENDA c.`�..;_ HISTORIC PRESERVATION r BOARD MEETING � 4rP CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: March 12, 2003 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Randolph at 243-7127(voice), or 243-7199(TDD), 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. Saraga & Lipshy, P.A., 201 NE 15t Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Mike Sneiderman, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a sign and an associated waiver. B. Levin Residence, 319 SE 7th Avenue, Marina District, Jeffrey Colestock, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for elevation changes and a reduction of square footage for a previously approved new residence. III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments B. Reports from Historic District Representatives C. Board Members D. Staff IV. ADJOURN Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: March 6, 2003 HPB Meeting September 16, 19982 Page 2 C./ Pre-Application, New Construction, Single FamilyResidence, N.E. 7th Street, Block 1, Lot 10, Del-Ida Park. Review and Comments. The Proposal will Require Variances for Setback Relief, a Landscape Waiver Pursuant to LDR Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b), and a Waiver Granted by the City Commission Pursuant to Section 4.1.4(C) with Respect to Adjoining Lots of Record Under the Same Ownership. D. Pre-Application, 319 S.E. 7th Avenue, Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Steve Little, Architect, Ora Sorenson, Owner. Review and Comments on a Two Story Rear Addition which will Require Variances to Side and Rear Setback Requirements. IV. DISCUSSION AND ACTIONS ITEMS --�'�,,'� ' . Select Nominees for the Great Floridians 2000 Program. , ,t V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS (4,1 i/C LL) A. Reports from Historic District Representatives ( • B. Board Members ;� �,�I C. Staff lei v //' VI. ADJOURN Pat Cayc Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: September 10, 1998 HPB Meeting of August 15, 2001 Page 2 D. COA 457: 20 S. Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District. Michelle Balfoort, Authorized Agent. (Continued from the July 11, 2001 Meeting.) Consider the Demolition of an Existing Garage in Connection with A Certificate of Appropriateness and Associated Class V Site Plan for the Conversion of a Contributing Bungalow Style Single-Family Residence to a Bakery. E. COA 468: White House, 21 SW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District. Michelle Balfoort, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness, Associated Waiver Requests, Class V Site Plan, Landscape Plan and Design Elements for the Conversion of a Single Family Residence to a Commercial Business. F. COA-463: 319 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District. Jay Colestock, Architect/Authorized Agent. (Continued from the August 1, 2001 Meeting.) Consider a Request to Demolish the Existing Non-contributing Residence and Replace it with a New Single Family Residence. G. COA 469: Atlantic Grove, North 300 and 400 Blocks of West Atlantic Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, New Construction. Tim Hernandez, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness, Associated Waiver Request, Class V Site Plan, Landscape Plan and Design Elements for the Construction of a Mixed Use Redevelopment Project. H. COA 470: 200 NE 5th Street, Del Ida Park Historic District. Tony Keller, Owner. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for a New Swimming Pool above an Existing Garage. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN Ellen Uguccioni Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: AUGUST 9, 2001 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING AUGUST 3, 1994 AGENDA ITEM IV-C COA 8-234 • 319 S.E. 7th AVENUE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE, MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA 8-234 for exterior renovations to the second floor of single family residence. BACKGROUND The house was designed by well known Delray Beach architect, Sam Ogren, whose 1926 Delray high school and gym are listed on the National Register of Historic Places . It was built for a member of the Blank family in 1950. The first floor is c.b.s . construction and the second story, which is located over the double garage, is of frame construction. Mr. Ogren's original plans called for vertical batten and board siding to be installed on the exterior of the second floor. Either this was never installed or has been replaced, as the present siding is prefab tongue and groove. ANALYSIS Description of the work plan. 1 . The applicant is proposing to remove the center window of the front elevation and install two new double hung wood windows, window openings approximately 30" x 40" . As the proposed windows will be installed in the bathroom area it is impractical to lower them to the height of the original center window. However the proposed windows extend to the height of the original opening, which is to the frieze board. 2 . The center window on the south facade is to be removed. 3 . Textured paint has been applied over part of the exterior fabricated wood paneling. The applicant is requesting approval to install wire lath and stucco over the existing paneling. 4 . The building has been painted pale yellow with white trim. Staff Report COA 8-234 Page 2 Work com leted with buildin ermits or COA. 1. The original window of the front elevation has been removed. 2 . Openings have been cut to accommodate to 2 new windows on the front elevation. 3 . The center window of the south elevation has been removed. 4 . The exterior of the house has been painted pale yellow. Staf f comments . 1. The removal of the center to ndow and the athetfrontf facade the 2 new windows does not substantially alter and is consistent with the style of the house. Centering the new window over the garage doors is appropriate Visual. The new fenestration is nsrecommends that istent with onfunctional wood 4 .5. 1(E) c �atibilitY. Staff shutters be installed at these Plaster f mold Ph that Sruns also recommends that horizontally above the garage doors be retained and be painted the same color as the house trim to break up the space between the garage doors and the windows. n does not 2 . Removing the center streetscape w on the and south can eleVbelo considered detract from the Visual Compatibility consistent with Section 4 .5. 1(E) , 3 . Covering the fabricated tongue and groove exterior paneling cs f withe th plaster is certainly elected lossto to the use the batten lando board house. Had the owner eneric faceor as the architect in The ed, a much combination less a gsmooth facadade wouuldave resulted. plaster finish and the texture of batten crndtes oard (typical of Ogren' s contemporary houses) interesting facade element ouse. and However, asds a the er to the originally overall design of the if it was evergned , the Boan rd board can not no longer request that existing, be replaced. h used, The use of plaster for the exterior finish is consistent with Section 4 . 5 . 1(E) . 4 . The exterior paint color is attractive and is within the guidelines . Staff Report COA 8-234 Page 3 ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1 . Continue with direction. 2 . Deny COA 8-234 by failure to make positive findings with respect to Section 4 .5 . 1(E) , with reasons stated. 3 . Make positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(E) and approve COA 8-234 subject to the following conditions : A. That functional wood shutters be added to the two new windows on the front facade. RECOMMENDED ACTION 1 . Make positive findings to Section 4.5. 1(E) and approve COA 8-234 subject to the following conditions: A. That functional wood shutters be added to the two- new windows on the front facade. I ► -- - • ! } ` •I..o1L.:,..:....r , 1 , . i r ' "I . • F ' c.'• . T 1. 1 .!! a - AI • . i ' I t t • t•• III O t t Z. trn,;4 ! •• i .-::: !_ 1' _ ....: • • • • . , A , .......„ : : . ff • • ' .. �.� • -, t• -•�r `. - j!••• -,. -f. ,. -'t-•'----- _;-L...-L.,t : '. w -4 a--..... s --z_.e•{/-T, --,--_ _—�--- - 12 _ 4- Li- P ► • fi • x=_ -ram-- /. a R t Qrc.lt•s Ct�o• * -1 t ' 11 • . • • • i I . - �� -- ---.-.r .--- • . . - . . .-_ ..� —1 4. . • • t • • . Fire Inspection._ `i Site Plan Landscaping — L Engineering_---- R.EW:O VC WI N�°w • CLO orcNiNC., 1 s • l • L . uti R IUTC ,00. fAR N ITtO ] • t �1114=16�O•C 1N �fi" Davwa�� i--.., trip tegt, tiOT41 to QES • Q I � /1 tII "i>11`'t I I , V Q 2 rUcw ovEL. 2•Abt •-' �• 5 fxiin-ri 6.)c+ 'roan 5itsi►JG 3- a�.° x \• 1a vl .4-t1'L T -t/�/ - + II7/7.L-F-7+F T —� ARErno�T I II'L I L_.___.,.•________• :Z:. RI / ..----°.i 3.-. . ' 4-lc '' 1... 4- u 2%i. �j'p° �I�1O° .. .. __ i try' {briJ4 b 11110 r ; "� 1,I - �..ri■ t it is understood and agreed that this review for • L-,• _ _. ���� c -,..___"-_._ ...._----_�---�!----- ••---�-- --•--�"--"CODE COMPLIANOEof this plan Is subject to " R — ��-_ the builders and/or owner's compliance with Q,cMo+E wl:l nor., vc� .rv,u Ao y� all building,plumbing,electrical,mechanical, Al f+p! w u p�w� e,,,o sr_ �fc I N 4 ' 'to l zv ir6 zoning,and all other applicable ordinances of • W u A'xU 16 __ 1_� t i C&/,OT/P 0.1 the City of Delray Beach. The under:loned