The URL can be used to link to this page

325 SE 7th Avenue, *1947 - FMSF ee• rcmvi000J-OOii, Hu .1tFUi .0 ICillC, UU. ,4ICk.M1CU "` 4---�' 087----Gh — �"" - N. — DISTRI PER#1�g56-8ggM Pool & deck, $14,500. ,9-22-88. checked � CITY OF ;DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA R lA SUBDIVISION BLOCK LOT Improved y�-s�eI-� �r.�•�cw OWNER W1. 1 11 YIl U , 11 S 2 128 • (1) Vacant ADDRESS RtmT1�1,.,-,w- 31-alr«!esia.,.. � ,'1 �C"�i p '> e' it' �:61 1.n� p •• Exempt OWNER -The Owolcy R 41ty CB -Y DESCRIPTION: N87.51 of Si. 2 of Block less W. 201 deeded for ADDRESS ,• Qt Street. .. , OWNER #4\\ c) 1l I 145e,..rk . 325 S _ 7th A VP a ADDRESS YEAR- 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 . 1969 1970 1971 1972 197: • EXEMPTION PER#8546, 8/18 83 ,remodel,$12, 000.Checked I • 29• ' Co'& • 'LAND .7 y z 0 / II. /,2 BLOCS. PER#9865-88M, 6/2/88 , Inst, fence$1,100 .Checked 4 -1 , FD 6, 6 • TOTALS l Xt 7J/ 794o 7ycz0 71-/-2011. 7%.o % &D 7y/or— — PER. PROP. PER4,f11074-88M.10/4./88,Two finger piprgy$S_, nfl l_ChpirkPr9 /6 OCC' �S�C•C• A't$ • • ' BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIOI DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING NI -- --- - -__t-.-.----. ---- - -. ..-- - SIZE HEIGHT STOR TYPE BLDG. BASEMENT ROOF INT. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS .......___._.._-_._-_.__ ...Slagle DwIB. None Gable ---•-Plaster .•.._. ._.....Denoted ._ SDrink. (Fire) ._.__....Double Dwip• Part Hip ..Plot Fire Escapes -•-:--__ -4,_.._,._._.__.__._.........__..._...._._..__...........,__.._._.___.. ..Duplex Dwip. Full .Flat -_._.Hardwood ..___-.Refrigerators --.-._____,--------_.__..._._. .--- --_._-.---._---._--_.___ X .Metal .Apartment ...Dirt Floor Mansard "" ' Vac.C.Sy,. �- - - - -.� "�-- ---� •---- Marble&Tile ----Store Cement Floor Panels __Skylights __ X PORCHES -- --._- - -- -- - _ Store&Offlee . Finish Fireplaces ^- •-•_••• FLOORS --• -• •-- • � _._..Ston&Apt. HEATING • X Front .__ ..Wood lolsb Incinerators X • ...._-Office X Side ._. MIII Solar W.Sys. -- - —----- — -- -I-- Hotel ___None X Rear • Steel Beams Air Con.Sys. --__.._. -_.__.- "___ Role.Concrete _Theatre Stores X Sleep. Reinf.The ---_-_.______.._._...._..____._..__.._.._.__..__.._.. CONDITION -_..-.Garage(Apt.) ..___011 Burner Dirt _.._.,_._.._._.__.__. __,.__ ._�_-_.__ �_____-_,__- _..._..._.__ GOOD FAIR BA Fireplace EXT. WALLS FACTORS ...--•'Garage Wood Siding FLOORING No.of Rooms -Garage(Prvt•) .._-__-. ___...._._.,_............._,.....____...,._._.-.____.__ __ ___.._____ ._..., _._,.-.._-._,._..__....... / -•' CONSTRUCTIONY GasStatloa Brick •-- Pine ..- ADartmcnts _-_-____._-_.._._...__-.- _ T ____.-..___.--.-.__ Church Wood Frame Brick Cased Hardwood - Rooms p. School Concrete &At ....... Lumber Sheds Steel Frame Stucco Tile .Fin.Attic R. ----•-- -_. -- -_-__-� Rein!.Concrete Metal .......Marble Fin.Ease.R. - ---------•----....._.,.____.______ ________.....___,_,__.____________ • ROOFING .••_ MIII .. Block Terearn Date ComDlt. _.._.____.._.._.._..-._._...__..._..__...._.._ ...---_. .....___.....,_. SQ.FT. V.P. TOT. -' Linolnm Brick Slain le _-.__.._._____.___---.-_.-_______ ._._----_._._.-__._._--._--.._-_-._._--_,._ rea Con II..__....Shingle Concrete Tile '' Age PLUMBING --.._...,._................._.,_.............._....._...._...._._...._,.._.-._.._.-----T___.._,.__.____.._..____,T_....._____. Pitch&Gravel EXT. TRIM None Remodeled _...-4-.--...—..._....._•.--_.____,. __..--.—_.�--_�_..___0_.___—_._..._--__._ FOUNDATIONS VALUATION Metal Plain Fixtens -__,__..__._-------.-....___...,__.___,._...._ ..__.,_......_._-.._. ___ LIGHTING RECAPITULATION ComDosltloa Stone Ornamental Toilets ......._.._..............__..._...._.-._ - _..._- --_--._..__._._.__..-._._.__.-.-._.. -" Concrete Wood _Bathroom: Slate " Electric _._...__.__._.---_.__._._._. .._.._..__--..._..._-�__.____..___.._....--................_._..__.._.__......_...,.. $ ----••• Brick Stucco Tate Floor ._............_._.-_..........._-........_._...-....-.__......................_.._....----._---._-._._.•.-----.-.—_.__.-,------___ __....Tile Flat of The Terra Cotta Baths,Belit•In Gas Ornamental Piers Metal Showers Lamps ..-__,._..._..._.,-_._....._.._-.....�......._..__.___�._-_.__-.,___.....-_�._........_..._-�-.....-,...___..-.. LAND APPRAISAL ADDITIONAL C--------------- --.,-.'----.._._--.-.-----_ :.----.-.-•_T__.._..,-____..___._.. BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front Valuation Price Factor Factor Foot Vales �jLOTS ACREAGE St IMPROVEMENTS g7. X /oo w / • f�6jA;L:__ / Level Level + Paved ....,e...High Hilly Dirt TOTAL • X Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ Low Rocky ///�� Enhancing Factor. Rocky Swampy Curb TOTAL (// �) � r-� � Detracting Factor % ACRES @ Swampy Farm '''Water LAND / Wooded . Sewer - • !.. Electric Llpht TOTAL LAND TOTAL LAND VALUATION Gas AND CLOGS. S • + I Ll_n_jii_i_LL 11 I t 1 IfJ ( 1 I iiiI) I I ( I I I I II mil I I I ATLANTIC AVENUE 0 I Il I I I I I 1 ill I I 1 11 1 1 I^ I 11 I I JIIHIII WATERWAY EAST 11 i l l COMMERCIAL .In n • CONDO I < a Ia. i w Lk! BAR > > I HARBOUR _¢ I CONDO , o I I I S.E. 1ST ST. MIRAMAR STREET I I ■o BUD'S I ■ I 1 I 1 1 z I a 1 a OCEAN ■'' I "r'PLACE III 1 CONDOcocoNur / (( ■ i.i w vi ui I ■ ROnf I S.E 2ND `--� ST. ► I INGRAHAM AvENU_ I / Hi2 P1 1 _ I n I (— _ LLI SEAGATE I �µ �p0. OCEAN W C TOWERS I l TER 1 ' NIAISISIAIU J ISIT.I i � =~ III III ( 1 I i IJ S.E. 3RD • ST. I IBAY ! 0- O I STREE1 1 Z Z D c O m LANIKAI _ I I VILLAS I LANCER WAY CONDO O Z MI Mil 6 6 VI S.E. aTH T. I SEAGATE 1 I I I 1 I I III . i MANOR UA'INA ROAD I O 111111111 11111 1 I §LE. 5TH iltiar DELRAY BEACH BUCIDA RD. ITI 1 11 WOMENS , CLUB J W < I l l 441p IIIIIII11 II Q IQvi h �E I I AP*� sTH ST. BARYONN MELALEUCA RD. � >i_ u.i> w APT Q I I .J < < > In Lo CONDOS O 0 MI o -- 0 I .SS� RD orsi wII= CHURCHILL Q isimi c ANN ME ' CONDO S.E. '� N . 1L' TAMARIND RD. Z 7YH JI. Q U - O WO IF , I — ce O oAMIN ✓i J vcc Wi �- uWi^ BAN1 PV H� v o 1BUILOIN G I I SC," A I - 1 1 �H1 S� I BAiHINI1 I R►� . N —imar— KOLLEDA RESIDENCE GTY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL (325 S.E. 7TH AVENUE) PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM211 o AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING 4y V. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: December 17, 2003 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a • disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Randolph at 243-7127(voice), or 243-7199(TDD), 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does-not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners maybe in attendance. 1. CALL TO ORDER II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. International Materials, 710-712 NE 3rd Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, Everett Jenner, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness and associated Class V Site Plan, Landscape Plan, Design Elements, Internal Adjustment, and Waiver for the conversion of a non-contributing duplex to an office. B. Brisa Atlantica, 9 SE 7 Avenue, Marina Historic District, Israel Torres, Owner. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of vinyl awnings, relocation of the A/C units, and an exterior color change for a contributing property. C. 325 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, Stofft Architects, Inc., Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of a non-contributing building and the construction of a single family home. D. Blue Anchor, 802 East Atlantic Avenue, Marina Historic District, American Awning, Authorized Agent. Reconsideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of an awning. E. Old School Square Bread Company, 814 East Atlantic Avenue, Marina - Historic District, Delray Awning, Authorized Agent. After preliminary discussion, Mr. Johnson moved to set the Public Hearing date for June 3, 1998, the motion failed for lack of a second. After further discussion, the Board concluded that the property owners needed more information to understand the pros and cons of becoming a district. It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 7-0 to table establishing the date for the Public Hearing with instructions for staff to do the following: ❑ Mail to all affected property owners the Historic Preservation Ordinance, the Historic Properties Tax Abatement brochure, preservation information sheets, a list of names and addresses of all property owners in the district, a summary of the economic impact of historic designation in the Town of Palm Beach, and, a cover letter explaining the Board's actions. Mrs. Cayce asked the Board to amend the agenda to add Agenda Items IV.F. COA 307, and IV.G. COA 348. The Board was of the consensus to do so. IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 219-Continuation: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. James Kolleda, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA for a small addition to the southwest front ell and to replace an existing roof and extend it over a deck patio area, also located on the southwest ell. It was moved by Mr. Ames seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 7-0 to approve COA 218-Continuation as presented based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), with the following condition: ❑ Two additional roof support columns will be added, equally spaced across - the front (west) patio. A wood railing, similar to or the same as, the deck railing on the east side of the Kolleda residence, will be installed along the south and west perimeter of the patio. The railing is to be painted white. B. COA 334-Continuation: 35 & 41 S.W. 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Sundy Estates. Rodeny Romano, Authorized Agent. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA to relocate or demolish two contributing single family residences associated with the development of the Sundy Estates. It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Ms. Huriburt and passed 7-0 to approve COA 334-Continuation for the demolition of the structures located on 3- 05/06/98 ..::.::.::.::.::::::::.:::..........:. .::::........ Project Name: COA-219 Continuation Kolleda Residence Project Location: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA-219 Continuation for the design elements associated with the following: • Construction of a roofed patio at the southwest corner (front) of the • structure; • The reconfiguration of an existing hip/gable roof at the same corner; • The enlargement of the ell on the southwest corner of the structure. • The construction of a fence/wall on the front and south side property line. Originally this property had approximately 228' of lot frontage. The previous owner replatted the property into 3 separate building lots. The subject property is located on the center lot. At the time of replotting a portion of the subject structure extended over the new south property line. In order to create the south lot, the encroaching portion of the structure was demolished. A variance was granted by the HPB to allow the balance of the house to remain with a 7.5' south setback so that additional demolition would not be required. The demolition of the south portion created a foreshortened, and awkward, hip/gable roof on the southwest corner which faces the street. The applicant came to the Board on April 2, 1997 for a pre-application review. The Board members stated that they could support the variance for the-roofed patio and recommended that the applicant return with a formal submission. The Board also requested that the applicant provide scaled elevations for the north, south and west views of the patio and roof for consideration during the COA review. . The applicant is proposing to remove the foreshortened hip/gable roof covering the southwest ell of the building and replace it with an east/west gable which will Meeting Date: February 18, 1998 Agenda Item:V-B HPB Staff Report COA-219 Continuation Page 3 Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve COA-219-Continuation as presented with the following condition: • That the design of the wall be compatible with the residence. ' File/u/www/coa219cr is �\ . r .?• _ .� ., r, '7*,tip,,,.-._-...eff/if 11 • %\,. gem ---- 4 -- $_iI .i... •i t T I!!4_a% r t • '="�.s- 9•7'.• -�,•— _ij ti4�� <.::-L�y.•',fj• : -i . ..• - • .,,.0!\!1� • •:lJZ F.. .' ` '�< j;mot:j rt�:�.. .. . '-% `�ti•� ':• , - , STYLE OF PROPOSED WALUFENCE It was moved by Mr. Keller, seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 6-0 to approve COA 338 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), for the replacement windows as presented. IV. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: A. Variance 50: 238 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Daniel Dietrich, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a variance to allow a two-story addition to be constructed which will encroach 1' into the north side setback for a length of 26'. The Chairperson declared the Public Hearing open, as there were no members of the public wishing to speak and no comments received by staff the Public Hearing was closed. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 6-0 to approve Variance 50 to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), based upon positive findings with respect to Section 4.5.1(J)(1)(a)(b)(c)&(d), to allow the north side setback to be reduced 9' where a 10' setback is required. B. Variance 51: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. James Kolleda, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a variance to allow a roof patio addition to be constructed which will encroach 2.5' into the south property line. The Chairperson declared the Public Hearing open. Jack Frysinger, 310 S.E. 7th Avenue, spoke in support of the variance. As there was no one else from the public wishing to speak the Chairperson closed the Public Hearing. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 6-0 to approve Variance 51 to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), based upon positive findings with respect to Section 4.5.1(J)(1)(a)(b)(c)&(d), to allow a roof patio addition to be constructed 7.5' from the south property line where a 10' setback is required. V. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 336: 238 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Daniel Dietrich, Owner. -2- 02/18/98 Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval of design elements associated with the renovation and addition to an existing contributing single family residence. It was moved by Ms. Hurlburt, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 6-0 to approve COA 336 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), as presented for the design elements associated with the renovation and addition to an existing contributing single family residence, with the following condition: • That the landscape approval required for the project may be staff approved. B. COA 219-Continuation: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. James Kolleda, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval of design elements associated with the following: 1. Construction of a roofed patio at the southwest corner (front) of the structure; 2. The reconfiguration of an existing hip/gable roof at the same corner; 3. The enlargement of the ell on the southwest corner of the structure; and, 4. The construction of a fence/wall on the front and south property lines. After discussion and review the Board felt that the roofed portion as presented was not appropriate to the existing structure. The Board recommended that the applicant retain an architect to design something which is more compatible to the house. It was moved by Ms. Hurlburt, seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 6-0 to continue COA 219-Continuation. III. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: B. Make a Recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Board with Respect to the Seacrest/Del-Ida Park Neighborhood Plan. Presented by Senior Planner Ron Hoggard. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 6-0 to recommend to the Planning and Zoning Board adoption of the Seacrest/Del- Ida Park Neighborhood Plan. V. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: C. COA 339: 1104 Nassau Street, Contributing Single Family Residence, Nassau Park Historic District. Liz Bold, Owner. -3- 02/18/98 It was moved by Mr. Keller, seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 6-0 to approve COA 338 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), for the replacement windows as presented. IV. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: A. Variance 50: 238 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Daniel Dietrich, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a variance to allow a two-story addition to be constructed which will encroach 1' into the north side setback for a length of 26'. The Chairperson declared the Public Hearing open, as there were no members of the public wishing to speak and no comments received by staff the Public Hearing was closed. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 6-0 to approve Variance 50 to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), based upon positive findings with respect to Section 4.5.1(J)(1)(a)(b)(c)&(d), to allow the north side setback to be reduced 9' where a 10' setback is required. B. Variance 51: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. James Kolleda, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a variance to allow a roof patio addition to be constructed which will encroach 2.5' into the south property line. The Chairperson declared the Public Hearing open. Jack Frysinger, 310 S.E. 7th Avenue, spoke in support of the variance. As there was no one else from the public wishing to speak the Chairperson closed the Public Hearing. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 6-0 to approve Variance 51 to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), based upon positive findings with respect to Section 4.5.1(J)(1)(a)(b)(c)&(d), to allow a roof patio addition to be constructed 7.5' from the south property line where a 10' setback is required. V. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 336: 238 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Daniel Dietrich, Owner. -2- 02/18/98 HPB Meeting February 18, 1998 Page 3 F. COA-338 241 Royal Court, Contributing Single Family Residence, Del-Ida Park Historic District. Brian Shutt, Owner. Approval for Window Replacement. VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VII. ADJOURN Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: February 12 , 1998 file/u/agenda/hpb2-18 / HPB Meeting February 5, 1997 Page 2 f C.- COA 281-Continuation. CRA Parking Lot in Block 60, Old School Square Historic District. Community Redevelopment Agency, Owner. Approval for a Free Standing Sign at the Southwest Corner of the Parking Lot. D. COA-304. 109 Dixie Boulevard, Contributing Single Family Residence, Del-Ida Park Historic District. -James &William Mullica, Owners. Re-Roof with a Change of Materials from Wood Shingles to Fiberglass. E. Pre-Application COA 219-Continuation. 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. James Kolleda, Owner Review and Comment on a Proposal to Construct a Roofed 259 s.f. Patio on the Southwest Corner of the Residence. The Project. Will Require a Variance from the.South Side Setback Requirements. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN $4d*;4°.-4 Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: January 30 , 1997 file/u/agenda/hpb2-5 It was moved by Ms. Turner, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 5-0 to table COA 97-304 until such time as: 1. The applicant provided for the Board's review, all of the required documentation pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(H)(1) & (2) in order to claim undue economic hardship; or, • 2. If the applicant chooses to replace the roof with wood shingles, a sample of the shingles must be provided for the Board's review. E. COA 8-219 Continuation Pre Application: 325 S.E. 7th Avenue; Contributing Single Family Residence; Marina Historic District; James Kolledl Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of a pre- application review and comment on a proposal to add a roofed patio to the front of a single family residence. The project will require a variance. The Board felt it would support the variance providing the roofed area looked less like a carport. Ms. Cayce amended the agenda to add a pre-application review for COA 8-296. F. COA 8-296 Pre-Application: 29 N.E. 1st Avenue; Noncontributing • Commercial Building; Old School Square Historic District; Jerome Vanhille, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of a pre- application review and comment on a proposal to convert a commercial structure to a restaurant, with a second story to be added to accommodate two residential apartment units. The Board previously reviewed this item at their October 2, 1996 meeting. They felt there were several inconsistencies with the elevations and suggested the applicant consult with his architect to resolve these problems. The Board was not enthusiastic about the revised elevations. They felt the building lacked a definitive style and contained too many mixed architectural elements. Additionally, they did not support the fiberglass roof, as the roof is such a prominent architural feature of the building. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None -3- 02/05/97 AGENDA ITEM 5 HPB February 19, 1992 COA 8-173 325 S.E. 7th Avenue. Mr & Mrs James Kolleda, Owners. Contributing single family residence. Construct a seven foot addition to an existing bedroom on the S.E. corner of the house. This is the original house in the center of the Riekse Plat. The new owners plan to add the bedroom addition to the S. E. corner of the house. Wooden French doors will be installed, the exterior siding and roof will match existing. The addition is not visible from the street. Recommend approval I / . I ._ I i 1 i . i 1 APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS a i HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 100 N.W. 1ST AVENUE - DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 i I I The Historic Preservation Board meets on the first and 1 third Wednesday of each month. This application must be filed 15 days prior to the next available meeting. 1 ! / Address of Property S. s �� 7 fwc Can - /73 Affix One Clear Picture ... , :- :,---L--".5' -''''''''- • ---7:-4. :'''''''''''''''''''At:.:4'4: 4: -� You kh. ''',*ea; - Y I • I -'�- Yam. ill 1111111 • _`ram i"Y.-`G• ..) Ns.: -. r iS. K'C9 5. .,c- " .'. T `� -« z ELT - ¢ `•,>� +�'-x_. v Ilk ,� i ]! ff k [k.W` *0• !' ... - +►. - - s. t o • `t • �.. �. F 2 r 1 3 1 . ,-,• . . . . . ../...."..."........... . . . .",................ . . . • . • G/er . , t I . I . .*"..........."......"••••,..........„........................„. . . . . . . . . "........_ . . -*••••• . ........ . . , ... . . • . . . . . . .. .• . . . . . . . . . . \...... .. • 1. . . . , ....- . . • . . . . -. . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . , ..-.. .......... .. . . . . ...-.-... ......-. • . • ...--. . . . • . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .... . . . ..-...-. ...--...... .. ..- . ...... . ...-.....-... ... ........ . ............... .•............. .• • A . . • . ------------------. . . .... . ... .... . \ /c.. ' • . . " • . . . . . * ZI,/1/ •.• 0):i7 -'''. . "' — . •1 . . . . S . . . ., . • ..•FZ.r S:45.1 7-'44 . �25— -Sf T'�`r'rE 79, 35 " c %/ • y /_<7%,G%' ,;/ C', f I-',?ll. • /z' ! //e/ /,�'.QC.z N>;) 0 N,N; ,t,„*NN, NNN x/Sr/k6- Saari/ /r'Itz . . ! NORTH • Ob . .moo• .4lc/.✓ 7 • S 77./ 4s/ i✓I45 c. '6 S. Es. -o. _ 1 — 1 / -A mo a tJ CD/JV &fl fOR STREET ). • 1 :'' •3.75'(4) � 2.05'c) - . 70.OD.,_iv,:-.,,,,.,,,„: '►s.00' u.� 18.35..1 ,!• ,.'• Q8.70' Sd,'",�q/� r►i71T.0 .tr. c Aos•E Asus( .eydz J 4 R • 4- PAR(:� I.` .$ ri ( c ,� ', ( ... „ .0ASP//.4G7 I O.PJ✓1S e• I ��. le ief. :._ ---, ..."> • I474%O f.G4.46' liplip,- .10,I : f., 1 4,.....c..cr"ver.A.Ar• • ''' � ' � C�oi IAEI 2.rf' M ' ' .Mirai4r fr; Z 11111 via N I : �L-. ,..a I iI �.. ' ' T — 'J' i Gd k ' ' frl:%L!Il��ii g {{,�� ... 8gR$EpUE 1 `p O 11---- �, on/E SpatV d , c� 1 I I1/OUo FiC.4ME I � 4/ Q 1 `443 : • 1 I - 1 O I .eE.s,.a�kve� CTL n i 4. , .,s 2•I.6' ' I. c°Ne�e rs- . 1 `� l - I cQ,DIT/d/v etc - -,,. y An1. 1 110? : lli 1 I Poop 1 I ikil 4, � � (�?. � /s al 1' Witi ''' .-,„ ,, cy 4 Z 1'1 r 1 k 91.oo' I 0 VI Plaffuc# fort /ine -'' II L. rc/- aF'au \ j. a AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY, JUNE 19, 1991 5:00 PM FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceeding, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. 1. Roll Call • 2 . COA S-010 721 N. Swinton Avenue. Sandy May, Owner, Presented by Sally O'Laughlin. A. Enclose the lot on 4 sides with a 6 ' tall wood fence installed on the property lines. Two rolling gates 8 ' wide to be constructed at driveway entrances on N. Swinton and N.E. 8th St. Two pedestrian gates to be installed, one on N. Swinton and one on N.E. 8th Street. B. Exterior paint color or wood finish for proposed fence. C. Exterior Paint and trim color for residence. 3. COA 8-153 South Lot of Riekse Plat, 325 S. E. 7th Avenue Charles and Ellen Key, Owners. New Construction of Single Family Residence. 4 . COA 8-154 30 Lake Court. Terry Joyce and Diane Brock, Owners . A. Replace all existing windows with aluminum single hung windows, including screened openings on front porch. B. Install barrel tile pent "visor" over front window and door openings. MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD SPECIAL MEETING WEDNESDAY, APRIL 3, 1991 1. Roll Call: Bill Ayers Present Christine Bull Present Daniel Carter Present Spencer Pompey Present Rose Sloan, V. Chairman Present Pat Healey-Golembe, Chairman Present Absent: Wayne Campbell Staff Present: Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner Stan Weedon, Assistant Planning Director Pat Cayce requested to amend the amendment to the agenda to allow Item 3.A. , under the direction of David Kovacs, COA 8-139 Continu- ation A, which is Phase II, Old School Square. It is the modification of the south wall in the service parking area to allow an 8 X 37 1/2 foot storage room to be built on the north side of the wall. Represen- tative Bert Schneider was present. 2. Public Hearing: Variance Request 88-20, 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, David M. Riekse, Jr. , Owner. A variance from Section 4.3 .4 (K) of the Land Development Regulations to allow a 2.65 foot building encroachment within the side yard setback of Lot II of the proposed Riekse Plat. The effect of this variance will be to allow an existing historic residence to remain in its original location. The subject property is located within the Marina Historic District and zoned R-1AA. The requirement is 10 feet and divided will be 7.35 feet. Public Hearing was opened. The public hearing was closed. Christine Bull moved approval of the variance allowing a 2. 65 building encroachment, taking it from the requirement of 10 feet down to 7.35 feet, seconded by Bill Ayers. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. 3. COA 8-147 Continuation B. Sundy House, 106 South Swinton Avenue. Louis Jensen, Owner or Howard McCall, Architect, Authorized Agent. MEMORANDUM DATE: MARCH 28, 1991 TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD FROM: PAT CAYCE I7 SUBJECT: HPB SPECIAL MEETING, APRIL 3 , 1991. FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, 5:00 PM. Variance Request 88-20 for David M. Riekse, Jr, 325 S.E. 7th Avenue. BACKGROUND Mr Riekse gained approval from the City commission, at its meeting of November 13, 1990, to replat his property into a subdivision containing three building lots. On November 14, 1990 the HPB gave approval to demolish the contributing single family family house located int`center of the property, Lot II according to the replatted parce‘l. The north and south wings (noncontributing) of the building encroach on Lots I and III respectively. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD FOR VARIANCE CONSIDERATION Mr. Riekse has a buyer for Lot II and the contributing house. The buyer will rehabilitate the house and it will remain in place. In order to accomplish this the north and south wings (noncontributing) will have to be demolished. Though the south wing will be removed, a part of the original house will encroach on the side interior setback of Lot II by 2. 65 feet. The required set back is 10 feet and only 7. 35 is provided. Please see the attached survey. Staff recommends granting this variance as it is the only practical way to preserve the house and prevent demolition. ******************************************** Included in the packet are the designs for the Sundy House signs. This item will come for Sign Department staff review, Friday, March 29 , 1991 for consideration of size, setbacks, etc. If the the signs are approved on Friday the HPB agenda will be amended to include the Sundy House sinage. MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY, JUNE 19, 1991 1. ROLL CALL: Bill Ayers Present Christine Bull Present Wayne Campbell Present Daniel Carter Present Spencer Pompey Present (arrived 5: 22 P.M. ) Rose Sloan, V. Chairman Present Absent Pat Healey-Golembe Staff Present Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner Stan Weedon, Planner III Jeff Costello, Planning Technician 2. COA S-010 - 721 N. Swinton Avenue. Sandy May, Owner. Pre- sented by Mr. & Mrs. O'Laughlin. A. Enclose the lot on 4 sides with a 6 ' tall wood fence installed on the property lines. Two rolling gates 8 ' wide to be constructed at driveway entrances on N. Swinton and N.E. 8th Street. Two pedestrian gates to be installed, one on N. Swinton and one on N.E. 8th Street. Bill Ayers moved approval of Item A, as shown, seconded by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - No; Christine Bull - No; Wayne Campbell - No; Daniel Carter - No; Rose Sloan - No. Motion failed 5-0. - Daniel Carter moved to alter the plan for a 4 foot section down Swinton Avenue and on- the 45 angle to go to the second (2nd) gate, seconded by Bill Ayers. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. B. Exterior paint color or wood finish for proposed fence. C. Exterior paint and trim color for residence. It was the consensus of the Board that if the colors for the fence and the residence are within the guidelines of the City, there is no problem with the color choice. 3. COA 8-153 - South lot of Rieske Plat, 325 S.E. 7th Avenue. Charles and Ellen Key, Owners. New construction of single family residence. -1- 6/19/91 Wayne Campbell moved approval of COA 8-153; color of house exterior, roof tile and design, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. 4 . COA 8-154 - 30 Lake Court. Terry Joyce and Diane Brock, Owners. A. Replace all existing windows with aluminum single hung windows, including screened openings on front porch. B. Install barrel tile pent "visor" over front window and door openings. • As the owners did not show, this item was not discussed for decision. 5. Recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Board regarding the proposed abandonment of the alley in Block 62, in association with the Sundy House and the Sundy apartments. Jeff Costello made a presentation and answered questions with regard to the above item. Daniel Carter moved denial of the proposed abandonment of the alley as filed, seconded by Bill Ayers. Daniel Carter amended his motion, Bill Ayers amended his second. Daniel Carter recommended approval for the abandonment of the alleyway subject to the condition that a master plan be submitted which provides access to the adjacent lots, seconded by Bill Ayers. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. 6 . Reports from Historic Districts: A. Mary Lou Jamison, Chairman of Del-Ida Park Neighborhood Association. Presentation of 8th Street Traffic Circle Plan and Sinage. Mary Lou Jamison presented new changes in the district and will bring back the signage after Dr. Westine approves it. She wanted to comment that there will be only three (3) signs in the district instead of twenty (20) . B. Old School Square. -2- 6/19/91 Gene Fisher reported that there was no news from his area. He briefly discussed the widening of Lake Ida Road and the widening of 10th Street which will put more traffic on Swinton Avenue. C. Marina District. There was no representation from this area of the District. 7. Report on "Banker' s Row" . Daniel Carter reported Banker' s Row will have a presentation on June 27, 1991. 8. Approval of Minutes of May 15, 1991. Wayne Campbell moved approval of the Minutes of May 15, 1991,- seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . 9. New business. Pat Cayce introduced a prospective buyer to the Historical District area. She has lived in the area for ten years as a renter and is now going to buy property with a grant she hopes to obtain in order to help save the property. • 10. Unfinished business. None. 11. Adjournment. Wayne Campbell moved for adjournment at 6: 30 P.M. , seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. -3- 6/19/91 MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 1990 1 . Roll Call: Bill Ayers Present Christine Bull Present Wayne Campbell Present Spencer Pompey Present Rose Sloan, V. Chairman Present Pat Healey-Golembe, Chairman Present Absent: Daniel Carter Staff Present: Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner Stan Weedon, Assistant Planning Director Pat Cayce noted that agenda Item #5 which reads "4.4 .76", should read "4. 4.24.G2. " On Item #10, Approval of Minutes, the date should read "October 17, 1990 " as opposed to "October 12, 1990 . " 2 . COA. 8-60A - Continuation 26 Lake Court, Eva or William Dezearn, ,Owners. Re-roof with same material. Rose Sloan moved approval of the re-roof with the same materi- al, seconded by Bill Ayers . The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . 3. COA 8-142 - 101 Dixie Blvd. , Estate of Edward Carpenter, Pre- sented by Marty Yedvarb, Modern Roofing Co. , Authorized Agent. Re-roof with same material. Rose Sloan moved approval of the re-roof with the same materi- al, seconded by Bill Ayers. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . 4. COA 8-143 - 330 N.E. 1st Avenue, Eileen Baker, Pamela Turner, Wayne Meyer, Owners. Presented by Robert Turner, Authorized Agent. Re-roof, Exterior Paint, Fence, New Front door. The representatives not being present at this time, this Item was moved to the end of the meeting. 5 . COA 8-144 - 120 N.E. 1st Avenue, Frank McKinney, Owner. Rehabilitation/Restoration, Including Roof, Exterior Paint, Windows, Fence, Parking and Required Landscaping. For the record, Frank McKinney stated he was not the owner of the company. Rose Sloan moved approval of the restorations with the excep- tion of the fence, seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. Pat Healey-Golembe .read the letter of Request of Waiver to allow parking. Bill Ayers moved approval of the Waiver to allow parking in the front yard, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. Rose Sloan stated Item #5 could be approved upon submittal of the rendering, followed by a telephone poll. Stan Weedon stated the understanding will be if the design guidelines are adopted as otherwise, it will be handled that way. 6 . COA 8-141 - 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, David Riekse, Owner. Consider demolition of above noted residence. Roger Sabserson, Attorney, was present on Mr. Riekse' s behalf. Bill Ayers moved approval for demolition, seconded by Rose Sloan. Pat Healy-Golembe read a letter from Daniel Carter, an absent Board Member, who stated he chose to deny the demolition request. Letters from residents were also read. The following people spoke regarding the. demolition: Ray Yardley stated he is in favor of the demolition. Dawn Blumgren stated the house should be moved, not demolished. Carolyn Patton stated she is against the demolition. James Bowen stated he is against the demolition. Carol Westendorf stated she is in favor of the demolition. Alieda Riley stated she is against the demolition. In order to avoid demolition, the structure is available for removal if it can be done within a proper time frame. Bill Ayers suggested Mr. Rieske contact a moving company to see if the building can be moved from it' s present location, and then return to the next meeting to present his findings. After extensive discussion, a vote was taken on this issue. The vote for the above motion was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - No; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - No. Motion passed 4-2. The consensus of the Board was to give Mr. Rieske 30 days to see if the building can be moved and/or to see if there is any public interest in this structure. 4. It was the consensus of the Board to inform the owners of this building that no action has been taken, it has not been approved and all work should be stopped. -2- 11/14/90 7 . COA Pre-Application 250 Royal Court, Betty Tomelleri, Owner Sign Design and Location. This Item was withdrawn until the December meeting. 8 . COA 8-119 Continuation 840 E. Atlantic Avenue, Bridge Restau- rant. Consider Exterior Light Fixtures. Rose Sloan moved acceptance of the concept of the deck, thus- far, and approved the lighting, awnings and landscaping as in the Boyd Building, seconded by Bill Ayers. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . Wayne Campbell moved approval of a sign designating parking, subject to the approval of the sign department, seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy- Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . 9 . Consider Plaques to replace Dual Street Signs for "Banker' s Row. " This Item will be back at the next meeting, when more details can be given and a decision can be made. 10. Approval of Minutes of meeting of October 17 , 1990 . Bill Ayer moved approval of the Minutes of the meeting of October 17, 1990 , seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine. Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes . Motion passed 6-0 . 11. New Business. Christine Bull moved to change the meeting date of December 19th to December 12th, seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0 . Pat Cayce informed the Board that the Strubel' s will have hedges around their duplex in the very near future. 12. Unfinished Business. Wayne Campbell stated he is very dissatisfied with Mr. Mc- Kinney' s answer regarding the jalousie windows. Stan Weedon stated the tapes should be heard again, and if the Board is not satisfied, Mr. McKinney should be notified. -3- 11/14/90 13. Adjournment. Motion made by Bill Ayers to adjourn at 7 :25 P.M. , seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Bill Ayers - Yes; Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 6-0. -4- 11/14/90 • MINUTES • HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 21, 1991 1. Roll Call: Wayne Campbell Present Daniel carter Present Spencer Pompey Present Rose Sloan, V. Chairman Present Pat Healy-Golembe, Chairman Present Absent: Bill Ayers Christine Bull Staff Present: • Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner Stan Weedon, Planner III Steve Taylor, Planning Tech I 2. Make a recommendation to the .City Commission regarding a policy change pursuant to Section 4.6.16 (H) (3) (e) of the Land Development Regulations concerning perimeter landscaping in the Old School Square Historic Arts District. • Steve Taylor, Planning and Zoning Department, gave a brief synopsis of the requirements for landscaping in the Old School Square Historic Arts District. He stated it may not go as a policy issue, but . rather as a text amendment, with the Board making the recommendation. Daniel Carter moved to recommend approval of a policy change to not administer - requirement 4 . 6.16 (H) (3) (e) perimeter landscaping in OSSHAD, seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. 3. COA 8-113-A 229 S.E. 7th Avenue. Ralph Barding, Owner, Phil Flournoy, Agent. Rose Sloan moved approval of the installation of columns and double decorative aluminum gates at the driveway entrance, seconded by Daniel Carter. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel , Carter * - Yes; Spencer . Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0 . 5 . COA 8-114-A - 32. E. Atlantic Avenue. Polly Noe, Owner; David Martin, Architect, Authorized Agent. A. Non-impacting minor site plan, subject to conditions, to allow an elevator shaft and improvement to the rear parking area. Mr. Martin presented a site plan reflecting changes to parking and landscaping which were . requested by the Planning and Zoning staff. The corrected plan has not been reviewed by staff. If any additional changes are required after staff review, these changes may be approved. by staff. Final landscape plant selection will be approved by staff and. Daniel Carter. The applicant need . not return before the Historic Preservation Board. . • The new awnings .are to match the front awnings- and the rear sign will be. the same style and color as the Atlantic Avenue signs. Daniel Carter moved for approval, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat .Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. B. Recommend to the City Commission approval of granting a waiver for the five (5) foot landscape setback- along the east property. line pursuant to Section 4.6. 16 (H).( 3) (d) . Spencer Pompey moved approval to recommend the City Commission grant the waiver, seconded by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer. Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0 . 4. COA 8-159 325 S.E.. 7th Avenue. David Rieske, Owner. New construction of a single family residence on north lot of Riekse Plat. • Presented by Mark Bud, Architect, and Mr. & Mrs. David Rieske. Daniel Carter moved approval of the new construction of COA 8-159, seconded by Wayne Campbell. . The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter. - Yes;. Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. Mr. Rieske will come back before the Board at a later date regarding the landscaping. 6. COA 8-160 - . 302 N.E. 1st Avenue. Ann Schnabel, Owner or Lawrence Sehres, Architect, Authorized Agent. A. Consider two waivers which can be granted by the Historic Preservation Board. Daniel Carter moved approval of the two waivers of COA 8-160, seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote .was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - ' Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. B. Site Plan approval for Ann' s Quality Grooming establishment subject to waivers being granted by the City Commission. -2- 2/21/91 Steve Taylor gave a brief explanation of how this site plan came into existence. John Johnson, Director of Historic Palm Beach County Pre- servation Board, does not see how this is compatible with Banker' s Row. His recommendation is to defer and analyze this proposal. Wayne Campbell moved approval of the Site Plan, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - 'Yes; Daniel Carter - No; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - No. Motion passed 3-2. C. Recommendation to the City Commission regarding waivers pursuant to the site plan. Daniel Carter moved to waive requirement 4.6. 16 (H) (3) (e) and 4. 6. 16 (H) (8) (c) , seconded by Rose Sloan. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. i D. COA approval which includes landscaping and sign. Daniel Carter moved approval of the COA with the conditions of using marine plywood for the sign, a frame around the sign and a double pole, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. Daniel Carter moved approval of the COA with recommendations, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter. - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. 7. COA 8-161 - 220 Dixie Blvd. James & Rebecca Gilbert, Owners. Extend a portion of the front wall forward and reinstall window and front door. Rose Sloan moved approval of COA 8-161, seconded by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. 8. COA 8-158 A - 840 E. Atlantic Avenue, Brandy' s Waterside Cafe Digby Bridges, Architect, Authorized Agent. Minor site plan modification to relocate steps from the east side of proposed deck to the south east corner. Daniel Carter moved approval of COA 8-158 A, minor site plan modification to relocate steps, seconded by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. -3- 2/21/91 9. Discussion regarding Veteran' s Memorial Plaque and. Monument located at Veteran's Park. Kathy Stokes and Carolyn Patton, spoke with regard to the proposed removal of the Monument when the park is renovated. It was the consensus of the Board to recommend leaving the Monument in the park. • Rose Sloan moved to submit a letter of recommendation to the Site Plan Review Board, the City Manager, Planning Director, Parks and Recreation Director, Commission and Mayor stating the strong desire to leave the Monument intact and in it' s present site, seconded by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. 10. Discussion of uses allowed in the Old School Square Historic . Arts - District. Stan Weedon suggested the Board review the uses and get back to him with their recommendations. 11. Reports from Historic Districts. • There were no reports from the Historic Districts at this time. 12. Recommendation to City Commission regarding Banker' s Row Neighborhood Plan. Wayne Campbell moved approval for recommendation and acceptance to the City Commission, seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0.- 13. Approval of the Minutes for July 17, 1991. Wayne Campbell moved approval of the Minutes from the meeting of July 17, 1991, seconded by Daniel Carter. The vote was as follows: Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer. Pompey - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; -Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. 14 . . Unfinished Business. There was no unfinished business at this time. • 15 . New Business. Daniel Carter questioned the status of Mr. Turner. Pat Cayce stated Mr. Turner has the opportunity to correct. all of the mistakes on 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue, or come before the Code Board to say why he chooses not to correct them. He then has thirty (30) days to correct them and if not he can be fined on a daily basis. One of his code violations is • -4- 2/21/91 • • the fact that he did not get a COA or a Site Plan Approval for additions. Pat Healy-Golembe stated the numbers on Virginia Snyder's house. are very large and bright, a little overpowering. Daniel Carter stated the landscaping- and fence for the swale and outside of the fence on the corner house at George Bush Boulevard and Swinton Avenue, which landscaping and fence was approved, has . not been done as outlined in the COA. • 16. Video Tape of Historic Preservation in Ft. Collins Colorado. Because of time. and two Board members absent, the video tape . will be presented at the September meeting. 17. Adjournment. Wayne Campbell moved for adjournment at 7:00 P.M. , seconded by Spencer Pompey. The vote was as follows: Wayne -Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Spencer Pompey Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - - Yes. Motion passed 5-0. • • • • • • • • • • • • -5- 2/21/91 AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD SPECIAL MEETING FRIDAY, MARCH 2 , 1990, 9:00 A.M. COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY. HALL 1. Roll Call 2 . Introduction of Vickie Johnson, Neighborhood Planner for Pineapple Grove. 3 . COA 8-097 Victor Nocera, 122 S.E. 1st Avenue. Install 8 new solid core wooden doors on south side of building. 4. COA 8-099 Danielle Baudouin, 1023 Nassau Street. Reroof with same material as existing roof. 5 . COA 8-062 Continuation. Hank Allen, 332 S.E. 7th Avenue. Reroof. 6 . Anita Shannon, interpretation of proposed use change for house and cottage, 201 N.E. 1st Avenue. 7 . Acceptance of designation report for 19 Andrews Avenue for Local Register of Historic Buildings. 8 . Discussion of Design Guidelines contract. 9 . Discussion of Old School Square Historic Arts District. 10. Approval of Minutes: October 20, 1989 November 17, 1989 December 4, 1989 December 8, 1989 December 15, 1990 11. Unfinished Business 12. New Business 13 . Adjournment • p AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD SPECIAL MEETING TUESDAY, OCTOBER 2, 1990 5: 00 PM FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation .Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceeding, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. 1 . Roll Call 2 . Election of Chairman and Vice-Chairman 3. COA 8-138 22 S.E. 1st Avenue, Alex King, Owner Repair 3 windows and 1 4x4 porch post. Replace window sills. Install a deflector on the roof abov the electric panel box. 4 . COA 8-139 Old School Square, Phase Two. Ronald Rickert, Project Manager Modification to rear loading area. 5 . COA 8-140 11 S .. Swinton, Andre's Market, Leonard Andre, Owner. Install flat wall sign above front door. 6 . COA Pre-application 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, David Reikse, Jr. , Owner. Preliminary review of potential demolition request. (over) AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 14 . 1990, 5:00 P.M. FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceeding, and for this purposesuch persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. 1. Roll Call 2. COA 8-60A Continuation 26 Lake Court, Eva or William Dezearn, Owners . Re-roof with same material. 3. COA 8-142 101 Dixie Blvd. , Estate of Edward Carpenter, Presented by Marty Yedvarb, Modern Roofing Co. , Authorized Agent. Re-roof with same material. 4 . COA 8-143 330 N.E. 1st Avenue, Eileen Baker, Pamela Turner, Wayne Meyer, Owners . Presented by Robert Turner, Authorized Agent. Re-roof, Exterior Paint, Fence, New Front Door. 5. COA 8-144 120 N.E. 1st Avenue, Frank McKinney, Owner. Rehabilitation/Restoration, Including, Roof, Exterior Paint, Windows, Fence, Parking and Required Landscaping. Consider Granting a Waiver from Section 4 .4 .g6- to Allow Parking in the Front Yard. 6 . COA 8-141 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, David Riekse, Owner. Consider demolition of above noted residence. 7 . COA Pre-Application 250 Royal Court, Betty Tomelleri, Owner Sign Design and Location 7 f .. MEMORANDUM DATE: NOVEMBER 8, 1990 TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD FROM: PAT CAYCE SUBJECT: STAFF COMMENTS ON ITEMS BEFORE THE BOARD FOR THE MEETING OF WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 1990 1. Roll Call 2 . COA 8-60A Continuation 26 Lake Court, Eva or William Dezearn, Owners . Re-roof with same material. The existing roof is asphalt shingle and was originally grey. The owner will replace it with the same material. An historic comment for your interest, this bungalow was built in 1925 and served for many years as the rectory for the First Methodist Church of Delray. 3 . COA 8-142 101 Dixie Blvd., Estate of Edward Carpenter, Presented by Marty Yedvarb, Modern Roofing Co. , Authorized Agent. Re-roof with same material. The existing roof is wood shingle and the trustees for the estate will replace with same material. Eddy Carpenter, who was a great supporter of historic preservation in Del-Ida Park, died of a heart attack last month. His mother built the house in 1939 and he wintered here as a young man and later made it his full time residence. He told me a great deal about the neighborhood as he remembered it in the 1940s and was a great help when we were writing the designation report for the district. 4 COA 8-143 330 N.E. 1st Avenue, Eileen Baker, Pamela Turner, Wayne Meyer, Owners. Presented by Robert Turner, Authorized Agent. Re-roof, Exterior Paint, Fence, New Front Door. As you will see when you drive past, the house has already been painted and a new front door has been installed. I spoke with Robert Turner and he told me that his daughter failed to tell him that he needed approval from the Board before proceeding. He said that he had rehabed his property in Pineapple Grove and thought that 3 building. The original concrete drive will be retained and 6 parking spaces will be provided at right angles to . the south property line. The parking is to be white rock and the wheel stops will be wooden. The existing plants to the south will be maintained and a 4 foot hedge will be planted at the west side of the sidewalk, south of the curb cut, to screen the parking from view. The front and north property lines will have a 3 or 4 foot white picket fence installed. Staff recommends approval. z¢ Ca.�C? Consider Granting a Waiver from Section 4 .4 ..9-6- to Allow Parking in the Front Yard. Section 4 .4 .76 allows parking only in the rear or side yard. This is not possible because of the location of the building, therefore a waiver is requested by the applicant to accommodate parking in the front yard. Staff recommends approval. 6 . COA 8-141 325 S.E. 7th Avenue, David Riekse, Owner. Consider demolition of above noted residence. This single family residence at 325 S.E. 7th Avenue was designed by Nels S . Jacobson for Mr. and Mrs T.W. Boykin, Jr. and was built in 1938. It is a colonial revival cottage which was a very popular architectural style, especially for winter residents, in Delray . Beach during the 1930s and 40s . The house was purchased by Mr. and Mrs. William Clark Arkell and in 1941 a substantial addition was constructed from plans drawn by the New York City architectural firm of Magill Smith. Mr. Arkell was the chairman of the Beechnut Company (baby food, etc. ) which was founded by his father, Bartlett Arkell. The house was later bought by the Owsley family who added a Florida room and other additions . Mr. Riekse has prepared a booklet regarding his demolition request which he tells me he has delivered to the HPB members . The booklet contains photos: of the style of homes he plans to build as well as a sample site plan for the proposed 3 lots. This is a conceptual plan which does not adequately address setbacks and other required items and should not be regarded as a final site plan. Nor should you consider this site plan when deciding on demolition approval. 14,;\ 4 The booklet also contains a list of names and addresses of neighbors who favor demolition. Seventeen of the addresses appear to be outside the Marina Historic District. See attached. At. the HPB's instruction a letter of notification was sent to all property owners in the District. One letter opposed to the demolition has been received, none in favor. See attached. Mr Riekse's final platting for 3 lots on his property will come before the City Commission on Tuesday, November 13, . 1990. The City Manager is recommending approval with conditions pertaining to sidewalk right of way and upgrading of the water main along S.E. 7th Avenue. Please note Kathy Dearden's letter of October 26, 1990, which is attached. The house in question is an important link to Delray Beach's unique, affluent, winter resort community during the 1930s and 40s. While the house probably would not qualify for . National Register designation it is an excellent, and one of the last remaining, examples of the "cottages" built along Delray's. Intracoastal . Waterway. It is in harmony with its location and certainly is a vital contributor to the Marina Historic District. If approval for demolition is denied Mr. Riekse may appeal the HPB' s decision to the City Commission. Staff recommends denial of demolition. 7 . COA Pre-Application 250 Royal Court, Betty Tomelleri, Owner Sign Design and Location This building was built by Charles Toth, Architect, for his office. He is in the process of selling it to Dr. and Mrs Tomelleri for use as a professional office. 8 . COA 8-119 Continuation 840 E. Atlantic Avenue, Bridge Restaurant Consider Exterior Light Fixtures Light fixtures to replace existing and missing fixtures on the east side of the exterior of the restaurant. Also light fixtures to replace existing pole mounted globe lights in driveway area. Samples will be available at the meeting. 1 �GoT f ir/ 1 ';6 DATE 4. • is %/' 7ee ecufive` 'DATE September 1 , 1978 ,TO: OFFICE OF CITY TAX ASSESSOR :Your attention is called to a building change at a35 S .E. 7 Ave. Richard P. Owsley, Realty Co . (No. ) (Street) (Owner) S/D City of Delray , Block. S Z of Blk. 128 Lot N 87. 5' of S 2 of Blk. less W. 20 ' Deeded for street . REASON: il. Structural fire damage in amount of approximately 25, 000. 00 . 1 2. Building or Buildings moved from property, leaving N.A. buildings on property. - (Number) . 3. N.A. Buildings moved onto property . (Number) Remarks: Fire Run # 78-397 Date: 8-23-78 Signed Department Fire P E-A.1G 0P R.00P "ro 1,..A.4."ra.H I 7 ,A2A...E, . I N DEC o2. 10 130'1H 6I17EES 1/ ..EJ.C.1.4 SIpE OF. IN • EX'TE1-.15 Io,J. �I , ADPEr. h/iNiDev/ e IWIlk .2" x .s 411 Tt,DS \\ \ — I to ON Gf�fJ I FL ` \ All t / 1 wit.D1� I J I // I WuJ00../(Ftao rJT) M I in I \ 1 f�t•.ME cOIWI1z \\\\ iiimiii I ---- IA I c • t:• •"T'LR-M 1 T� T2.caTFp ,p Co MP4C''-232 I 0�-�K1 r`T�rSC4._WA�-�-_� I I FIL+- DIRT u 14 II- 1•'II,JIM UM 1. __..L . .. , :G/ T. . , ACf) COLVMN ...__ P.C1-401e1:> TU ff." MIN. G' SA FOVND/s-1TOI.1 Norm-: -icl-% 0(= -maw G Nm-,.../ W I,J 'OwS ANAs•• I 1 • N • G.'•t, • ,h M14 fl t ,✓r .r v5_ v' G � .. • ,•. r o 6 :.� -.., • • ••t,,,, • , .i },a 1 i i,. i s 'S;. 5 c •• • ,•, ,, I' I• i Cl 7 t;• .F d ,. 1.t 'l: l - r i l• I I .I 1 •1 4 Lt ,,..A, d i r •'• � :1 t ,i1 Y r I I ! I I l r l • . •M\ •1 9 r XZ tl ? I .rl i r r tfn , ' ) ;'I: j x i tl f I. f'/� • ' h .SI a' °•c , i ,• ''' X ' r I ,(N i • • • • l 1 ! k r t ` .. ,. r J I r I ''t I ,I LI I I '• ' '� tr r I ,�'""v � . ( I r F { l tl I i' t "f rr 4 ✓ w..' f . . f_ • , r ^ ,�•, a1 IIr. 1 j;• ; X T '" • I ' ti 1 'I'••1• •', • ..�! •/ � ; •,. 1 ,. ! ! • �-•l l,� • • •A •r • I r r, • t a ! J -, • fi'. ,l Lt ,;: • iy.:q' .P: Fytti. , .1 ..•;',,:,..,:•:/1...:..:••..!,..,'•••::::..*,,,,'.;::::::-.',..''•;::,':"...Y...1.••./...?.*'.*:••i,...1.'1'...*; ... • °• 1.� 1 trb Ir I:n• I ' 4 tJ 1 • 1• • Y 1 •1 •t : ,I .aL \ _'-'i • ) ''I 'Y jJf/' .1�l, • • tom .i • • ..t , t ' , 1\t?? . / ./.,,.. • t.1 :'; r •• • • ' .7 4 • (.. r: ',1a d F,%• .:> % t •, t , } •r •'!I'"• D -, • • . , • I '� t- ••r, j X r '':1 r • : • • ' ;j•: •J. ,Y.r. t , If t 1 ti • G + r - • , t •t 1 Sly t , y •,1 4 .. t , r r f 1 r r 1 .f I • • • •• 1 . V �I it r 1i 1 Xy t , • f j' •• • • • .. ` , :•�,„ !,I r*` :: 1.` .•,.,'ram.'; i9 'r•. : •• ' me alai, . s • . . . u t- •.' •. . ty •• .i.:--, . . -•7\1;l1161A.1.i11.1i11.1 1,110_4l b%.t,t%' . •4 • ..1...-1-1' -, - -— -:,.,•,. to ,. . •- •-..: 1 " • :cs• • Jo - .""de••• I/ - • - •••5 4-11, ' 1 ....-, .... •...., •,im,L. - — -. - . , e•• •._ ,..•.••• ::5-- : ..._. „.......,... .,.......„. • _ ..,--tea...4,,,,tv.-1-: • .,„-- .., •----., :: ..., . .., ....... _..,.. ....., _.......:_____,,,„,,n..........-.. - ... fir-.. ...-._ - . .., - ,-6....::\: -, • • • • ' :-.•;:ikitr_ ' ••• <)t::;---... • -„,:`'.,:-.4_ ,. -',„..A-: ‘4' ;:. t' 'stt 1 fr ' / 1 s'"""' • IL;".7.7 •-v.,7..•.. ;OA ,' • ai. - • , .1.• • -- . .......e, . . --,' • • -1'•• .7.- 'N I 1 . 1 ' " I f- .., '- .-4..-.''.. • -"....=1.-iti"-:-.7:. •'..•=""x..- t . " . - •...-- • . `'',-.,,-„z•v,c.•,,• -•-••,•.:fel ,4-4,-•--- .. .--...`"•-,='z••••••••----•-,,:k• -=•--- • . - '--,,•- -.---•--- -7.--1--=.".-IL5-...:77.-=•-•--'1',-,1%,V.*=;"..:'-.-..•-•----,:.-•;'-, ..:,` t. :',.... ---- - -- --- - . . , - - •... e.•,:..:• . ..---:•• -- ..;:••=-. .......,-..--:=3„.mr•-•..„---..•::,-<•'-'; • I %, • < = • -, -. ,• - • - , ; . .•., .._ _-.„..-,•1:-,..-‘,.....-4=-.::-4.R;;;;.::,-,,,f_t..5-,*140-1.-:.=,-,4...:.:,-_---,'---*.t -- — .---/••i.,•-,::: •-,. - - -.. .. - ,-. •--• '-'• -,:s_•'%•-;tv.;-=-!;;.,eY;-f';'-,.1.414'i...:•'---..•;_f".=--i-,'-- -1 •.-,', - -..-- ,*. ,- -• 7-- . .... ,..,:,....... ,: _ ,... : -- -;;;32::::.-..:'--i•;.-•:if:::::---:;,Y.,f-',Zz;:f-1;-,tvjj:".„..- .-:.','-'s.--.-.-1 ,:"--•• . - -• • '* - • •,.• t,• .;4-- • • :• , ---;:---•:-.:=;-.':,.- ,.-. f114-: :.-4111,i.-- -=k4-1i-...1-1 -••1:' • .--;;•.::. ' ...:' .., • ... .< • •.............. •..i.c.=,•:•,.,-,..,).-..../..-,-.;-..f.talrfr...= "*"i,--"- `•••'-hl '••''',.-1 Trir III.* • r. .1. ••j ,6 —. ••• t •- .. • ' /4/jG/b i/ • .., ._/4 / -.-•• . • •-...-• L •r 4' lak%. • / tVI ' II...' \ 4 " .. ' • ... .. .............c.#4,..400r / - •.. -, '-'7'..ia.„-•-• -'1,-- • \ k+,4: 14 llikok .. -. - -•.e .-,. i . I -.11. - i.r.-,,... 4: --. -_ . •ft+ •• --. . •. • ro Mg,. . - --,:ivir):;1 :,---..-..--4,-.7,$,-- __ _ . • *.e. .... .•,.-,_ .., t,IN1/4 ..2..,-.,,,,-..-,-- -z_t-_, . . _ :-,x • I.) - '--'. ..1`....!••• ,,,,41 , 4.?:„. ---= :=.• . . :-':- f It-,ia.... -.w.,4•1,47, -,. _-_=----1...,. -- .- - ir 7,1,.-.4.-..,-,.-7,:^- • - -' .,:::; ---41-.1,, w7.--- • ..„:„..,...,....,,,,,,,,.... -__, ..k...13. -. .--.).--,.. ' - I- ,........... &...,77. ,..... ' . :11:P.:::... 1., ..V% .. . .I....''.'... •. . .7. ... • ..` •. ,.f.. '.• -'W.I... ...• Page 1 I HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 Original w FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 362 Update-'0 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions Recorder Date 2/1999 Site Name 325 SE 7th Avenue Other Names None Project Name Delray Beach Survey&Planning Project Historic Contexts WWII&Aftermath National Register Category Building - # *'4 a aANA CATION ands MT1F(CATION"g g 2F �b'°n£...,.. '�yfz��-�k�' ,�_.,..°`i��;�`�=L i�1.;s�.hr"'_*renF�s..aYra'-r'-��4' �:.'.�33.`.'tL j:iin3_.-st ` ; 'a� Address 325 SE 7th Avenue Vicinity of SE 4th St and SE 3rd St on E City . Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# 3' S't e=^- .,.> _. can.;_, USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969&1973 Townshi 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr SE Irregular Section 0 UTM Zone 17 Easting 0593081 Northing 2926184 Land Grant Unknown Latitude Longitude Plat or Other Map Palm Beach County Aerials Architect/Builder Unknown Construction Date 1947 Circa R Alterations Rj Date c. 1980 Type/Location windows replaced Additions ® Date c. 1980 Type/Location two-car garage added to the north end of the west elevation M^ved 0 Original Location _final Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence 7.— M =a - +c,2.�-d�TPX*MI. 4a �P�s�zc=?:*W �-.-�,-,"r-�_,r ff;V x._a3. Style Masonry Vernacular Exterior Plan Irregular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 1 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Weatherboard, Stucco Foundatio Slab Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infil N/A No.of Porches 1 Locations/Features west:entry porch covered by a fabric awning Dormers E Number/Location Outbldgs. 0 Number Nature/Location (Describe below) Roof Type Gable, Hip - Roofing Materials Composition Shingle Secondary Structures 0 Comments/Location Chimneys ® Number 1 Orientation West Location Wall, Exterior Material Brick Wood Windows ® Type OHS Light# 6/6 Metal Windows ® Type SHS Light# 6/6 Exterior Ornament Comerboards,Vents Condition Good Surroundings Residential Narrative (general, interior, landscape,context; 3 lines only) This building has many alterations included a garage addition and nonhistoric windows. An arched window is located on the south end of the west elevation. Flat wood trim surrounds the original windows. Originally,this building was typical of 1940s residential construction. ' haeological Remains Present 0 None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions �.- Eligible for National Register? Yes D No wi Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information O Significant as Part of District? Yes D No w Likely, Need Informatio ❑ Insufficient Information ❑ Significant at Local Level? Yes w No Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This 1940s building is representative of the city's historic architecture and development.Although it has experienced modifications,this residence could be considered a contributing resource in the locally listed Marina Historic District.The building is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP as part of a district or individually. DIR USE ONLY _ OFFICIAL:EVALUATIONS D.HR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE = KEEPER DETERMINATION OF:ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO` SHPO EVALUATION OFELIGIBILITY DATE 'YES NO LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY z DATE YES NO: _ LOCAL OFFICE - Research Methods Sanbom maps, Plat maps,Local&County Historical Societies Bibliographic References Location:City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Location of Negatives City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Negative Numbers 9874-24;13;E r 4 � ECORDERJNI=ORMATioN k :. Recorder Name Amy Groover,Jo-Anne Peck,Susan Hochberg Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North,St.Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7 5'MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2 LARGE SCALE STREET ORPLAT.MAP • 3. PHOTO.OF.MAIN FACADE,PREFERABLY BiW,AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 l ..122. O.1!ILI P..) t•---r.e'" • --•' 1 1:.., •::/• .(/ / IC° i ilu . ' .., • . • ',...., "' ---- -• " -' •---'-aht-..-2i-',..:. •. • '-' : I: 1.• C . . ., i - , - .:' INV, . M \ L:::'<-1.‘-.-.."--- 13i t.F.•W.L;;......)"\""""i• , i'Z', ,Ht.•;;;;t:t .-.41. ; "L----*j.'',Ii‘'Jii! • . '''. "''::' % 1,1,,:\Y. • ,k1 v .., . • . • . ,:..i.,... ..,.. . ..-. .i r 'A6,, .::-‘7'. ,,,,,,',1 I , \ '••• """--yo 7V•irk.zrr .....-• .4"1;,4i o...)s.. „ ..:-f ..;•,,.,i•. , . ,..... •.,,„' ei ;)2 g. '• c,•• • is\........_._ ...,....,., , , q' .. . . -I •' ' 4, 1,1' .1 ,.., . . -4,• , I t:,".- ,r kik ,,, . 1.. ' , ,----; • :, ''''146•,•-'w. ., ,.. . . ' ipi g.t1, . 1...;,:;•:1:•;•415',. l':4411,0!+ire..-, •ws.s C,:i:P.:•,, • ..._. e_ii.r.„____-;....4::•1 0 —101 1 •" ,- N• s, 7.--.11-7°•. -'ir'.•::::. (--------1,===.-ii, '...:!.. I ,t t ; (1.--- o. . I' ty. t , :•t ..• 1•11:1,if:?.14'.,:t,{ ;-. 4 Jf.' ',,t ,it:L.,...•:•,,,. IN: . • • •: if .4 •• , I:f ,f, f,.• ..j • . , 11 .,••,:,•tr,-..,9y,1, '•:1:!"ft, i .•`--__!1!)I , :• v. i i li •'.' . • ' I ' ."• 'S'V:.Alle:;, I, . '41.514. 1 1 •-•:••... v e ee.r.he.., v, •. I . ': ''',.:ci• •••te \,eeeede7-c.-. _ ••• 11" II. '6(4. , '•r .•...• „... , ...,..,, !I, .7 I • ..... . , ... I r,tej i Vr'' • 1'( -'i"- .--- .. . '..,. . ts''...(k :, j'. 0:., , .,k ,..? • .1 1 I ,....4.:...tr: '"Aifr - - ri.“-'1-- l'''-.7--'''.1.r..' ''•; .•4(X1''' )...( '1:1 •• ..`,.•I ,,,...'i., 1 , ';.i - , . ( '1 t•., ', . ....,„ ;3,,,,,,,,, .f,14, ,---,-;•::. E-- _0. 1 1 4 ,.....1-,.11'1.4 . -,?"hT,1""fhi4Qiitp•,..)7-;711-7-(1 -•,,S,7:77::,ilvi;,..:'.'''!''r"re.i';'•—)74.„t`,...,,,,,,!..1" , 'V P. kill , 1' 'tit • 1 ......k...,'„,..,.' . ‘t. :. r bp. .. i t...-,,,,,,.41,.7.-......-] ,r4.,:„,,i k4,: , 4ii),:r: i,,,),,,, ,,,,,, ,A*.f.'1. .4, 1,1.;,i,..._:_ot.,,_..m,,,---e.t- i..: ,, u,•, , 1 • : :1: 1: -4— r's"::'..4iiiiiir,: „ 4. I TIX:Vc'..i I':,„-_-:'`...,::-.. -.`1'......;'t..;-I...'. 'i 7— $:iikigl 434 , '54 V ,•,.r. ±,71, -,-•;. Ant,..'.., ,,-3,,$).•,.....,1••, A., • J • ,, •eiv.,,,,',44 ,,.;..,.,i,1,.,..,4,..,..,A.,;, ,.•...• ,• •,1, •• ., - k .•.• ••••,— , A, • ,,v., `7....C.,' '••••.' .:,•'4, ,L.', j.,r-•..!:---.---1?;:j:t ri ,'at :•,- [•- -1,-: '• , ,,..i,,,,-„,,,,..,,„. .,....„,: -..,....„,...• ,,,••••-,i, ,„_., ..,:. ., ,...,,.,, • . . #•.:.. ;• :,,,, 1' 1,f., ' f: - ,1- . ,j . -::.:„ r.,,,„.,,,).,•___ :b.. rw:11.LA've4 --.0i.,"44taLi, .,,...1 1, !' ' 4 1 ' ' • t.;': •,0 ' ;;11-,. i'!"• t ', ,,,,• . 4 tt,,,,...i •1 : ,, , , ..,H., . ,,,,, ,,,4 li . . f. :1, ,. , ,. ,f.1,,,,,,,,X1 . • ... r, h•I y 1 ,,,, • .• '''''' "".'11111 '23 1 '` N. 4 c.) •,<, .1%1... oft ... , -,. . I 1 1,.. .-. 9. •i , ' .•/"-• ..•-..----•.Thv,IT.- ,? - 0-• •i ..".,22'.47, '•-• '' ' " •' • :*•••"' ' • . .. ,-- - , A • •......... . ...,. „.. t,.... ,s,,,..,a con- , 1 ,••••1 i;-,J . ....-7-16.17.e: „.4.....,;,. .., .....,..„.,,, . . , ,.. t ,..-1,,I: o r..) •.:LL •B,D...., ,, :1.1 1.,,,,,c.. : „,,,= T.'',1,.,,i:.. $:„..4i,,.!.. ,:.:4,,...::._:..L..4.; • .. . ..1.-if77---,-.7.1=:.,i 0 : 4...1.., '.' ,,,. ,,,..„_,,.-.-2.„:„._.....____,.___......._,__ ,, ....:.,...:_:4.1 ....__„.. ., ,....., ...::,.„„_ .,„t..:„,..„„•i[i..;.„..:J..L.t.,„,„,. '..,:'7 0,'.; .,-,,,,i ... .-, ^).,..,.... • -....o.:t.- .E I i il E E[1."'il"-.... ."7""1 i't•q4n-'" -1?,,IPY-•",•:, 1-•:..- . _.. L•w, ,,,,..-• ',4p4 •,._,.., •••• .• ..._ • .....,..... •••• • • • ., - - - \ _.. . ,• .'•' ijk °,.• I- . --,. .t. .,.:, , '.1• -....,..... . .i • •11.T••'II— ': :i I•I i''''''':Ir.';;;;; •••• .: : • ':..•qr•—•.• i!„".7,-;;T;Tr ....•,;..,,,,1..!:. ,V. •V..,,c'v,:j...,.•4.•:: • • • •." ... ',..1: 7," 401 . • .::-P Lit ; L.'i..L. di. .......,... ••••s, i ' ; 'i ' .,„ ' i 1, .. , ' '....A.. ' • t.e. 0 1 4• •i• L t !i),, -V..., ktil...,..•••••,,h.- 77-17.17: ..IL'....'3:".1 ''..., •• _.1;.•_;:.,H.tii.-111-•,..,—,A..,v.-E.-,-,,..„..1,,,,,,,,,,,,:h.. :,..!22,,,..!:-:,.:,'01 ,•:.. L,,1::_.,..[i.i.•,.127.,:::).. iit! ,,I I ' ''.,,4,,,,f, i ...«,,.,d'.;,•44,.,,,.:. ..,0,,.1.,::$ cne,,r:',., ...:443 q„1:0,1:•,..„,,...„„,]...,,c)......,• „to.. itt, :)\•.,,,,, n.1-6'1!Li 11.----.:•_____,,,,i1 ,r;.--4-744.74•,,,,,'-'74-A4;,,iir'''' .;.-4•4,...,4„.::.:-..,-„,-,-,,,T,,,,T",,,4-• -,,i,„Li"..,.' ..; .....,•.i— :- ,-; . ..# V. ...,..- 0 . .f..;:4 ; . .•II I* -7iiT'.ii,''', 4 41 i 1 ii.'17•M, 43:7.r .,t,o ,rm.,,,,?.,,g-,,,, .:.......,,,i..-F27---•••4F-•-•-•-•'•R -.•••,------- 4.:,--4 Ig: :'I I:. 'ill',''''lq 1.11,'i ''''..." '-'2,L._..,1 a;"w ..-.:-',-A >z::,,,,-=,=11.11—'-: . , • •ivrj1 i .'. 1--;-='f0!NI il IV V.-n_.2. ' 1::t.tug•,..,•,,,,71 ,--. -5.17.,.,.. ••••:,•-•• v$3, •.. .• '5....P •', - # - 5, ••• , iti•ifit , -r„,—, •-.- •11 . ..T 07-;-- -'-'----:1'OA r,„,, ,__•: f 47t,., :,,,"7„,=,..,1.. .;'IVie..77 tr;,'..',-,.„., .„' .;;, , ,,„.,, ,,,, . • . i . , . p.,41E. '''... •.•.' . ,-. _. tj..';•",14' sN.- • • : 1 4tq 11'1=Fitt"j•••-,1 Via'tilicA'k:1'''..tt'.?i''I',`!; :\'`: ''14'1 '....f • '•'.'Q . ,.: I ;(' •..N.I..-... ..::1''X 4111‘i,46'.'4 4jLtHr". .. ` . yol 4 t . —„Ub''r':.,‘!,.:'!,,'.;.,,,..,.1.,-;4.A•1 I;".• '.,„'i''1','e1, .._...„:„--.,•-,,—,EE__.a,L,;i,:__77__-_-3_.1-'_6r.-•i_._-,,...,_-_,-,--,-....a_.t,..i...::. L._—•!. 1 a i F7 1r,.4_V,r4,.7-.n,11,r.:.1 11,.,T....:iTj',-,''.f,---,1•1..7'.1.'4.',4..,.,'.,,...r4-:..4Y'4.,A.•,4..1c-,..m._':f:4:,'7,"''.1:.:_...Fft.2-.1O.P,L.,..<L...V,2;•,,-.!,0.,',:-:,,;..1.7.•4Z-,.-':A777-'.1.•:Z1.1'','-._'-,-,--,.41'..7t.-',.r..A',.'4'ri',i••.r'.'.i'.-.„i-'.iT,, r.,e!,,,,',-,;•,.,-.,,07,.44-..11,.1.7.•..'-..'•:, .`.At..,,zk.,:t.;f‘,".:.i44::-„.•.3', 1p.4..._4.k.;1.."Fj.,,1,;,>,r,":,e_.p1,.;.2ieE_,;.'_..._,_.rLi,__,_-;;_7_,,_;;_:_1'4;'P,44_r,,...";„,...,.".2•,.. 1,, a .,..- :IP:t.,,;,.;*17: ,,v, ,..,.,.,,.,,,17-1.711,,Itilv,:,.. 41:..:;;,,,..,.,ill 4..,.:5!::kil:54,74,!16,3:r:::,:; ;:' .,l'i =1101:11:::::,:ik..,.*: • .'.".r.'I i, - ''''''' ,rF., .. ,,... • , ti, , " , • • •.>,' I , '4 . • •.:„..... t•;• . .,;ir,,, I• .ftft _!•,..s. 71 ,,.p,,,,,,i ;,,vii,?,t,i,v,rt.ti v pi.., 1,, '•.14:gmt.,,,, ,.. , , ' ,i,. ....,t'L • , ,, . - • - V , .. . . 191 : •0,4 LILIERMail MIFF I. .,.r: ,.... ,,,,,,...4 , :,I,i..,..y,, 4, r.-.,.....„12E1:11 ,i.,,,,,, ,h,.,V,h... yv.t.•11.)_2 .. .,V i e AN ,..,. ,_ ... —_ ,___ 1 1 I [ II lli. 1 .,,, , „ ,,:,,,. 0),,-,t, crl, 7,,, ,..., c ,.,/,.„,1 „ft, .,41.- ,,..., .c, ,4,,,.....„1„,, i , ''''r-. ••s r., " '''• • '"lc:t4i. 74:ek...14111:1 ' !..'it li" A, 1 PO 0\ Lii V) t14. '''!''.' f. lAi 1•.;'i!'"Ic''1,-r• . , v 1. -,,i,.,,I.I.,,t .'• ' '/1.1,) ..c.P.t6. .:...". • it?, ,-.) 6-P cA' l'''"H"E' l'4,''41•1-..' -4:;,,,'ra9 MM.-'cf"..'",t.e%•,•lt !,-t.tit 1-'''..''' ,f4'e '':'..-1,4r..4. Or;. ..., •--, .0 LT;• ,i Cr4-,,7-1,10--; ; ,-,-.- .7.4 .,;.7.,,,...,-.,,,i;-.. -4litti: t.i..,.. ,,i.' 4; ---. , .., •• ..... •-+ l-1 ••{-e •41.,,f,,,,,,..4.7,-4... I.0, 4 l t. , !...I'----..,N." Mr. 1,,t • •• •' .t.t •4.1';') • • - • rl . LJ . . • .. ,, 4 L Ltiz....,,,z•„•;Ti i . : •'''-',A,'7%. ;,' '': ; , .1,-, 0 h., --. = ;Tr ,,,,. , ,•, or.,1h. .fi h ; : t• t .i'l i I, Ili i V'' 1 :.i';. Irl: g F-D '• •' fili.",, ,,;‘,..' '"?# '''-. ..:. . i,, ..;., ..., ...:7:-, 0.1t.'12:,1',,Ari..?,,L., :,;, , '-', • .:'•:701,,.,f. ..,,74 1-1-02:1 ,,. .1fTt. 'ist V -....v.i.^e,:'4'-'42'4'-' ',•,---,-. '''''''';',.;4`' •,e1..4..i , : •-r, • o F2 ,4::.=,'V,V:giirst.•:Ani'.i-;',5!:1' ':',f ,„Ut•„-. ;61:,, '1 ,. ...,1.,.....,.0. .j..•4';':'',''', , ' ' ; ___ • . i'ti 41. . ni) C, < :.1.. tC1 .... ••......,-,,.. . 340 315 ; '14 Pimp . • ---,.....„:‘,...,,,,,:.:.:,,,,-__ " ..,•,: 4,,..:, •'..,..; ..,,... ,f •,- ......• ,,4 ii,: S E .2.• , . .......• cii. r,i), . •-•(''''''11 '-' 4, (A ...,. .... . ),. . ... ,, A. '•-• 0 " .1. IP '1 ‘.0 Ti J-ri Oa • • k.0 cm. SI) %.4 .. 51V-111 . ,;• (*.) Du C \ 111111011t 0 ?), . 10 ''•,, , 1:2 ta., ,..._ 0 s• — F• fa. 11 UJ •-. vele, Z:r14-CCI(octsA-ci toakerwcui„, P*44 lAt • • • , B. Brisa Atlantica, 9 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, Israel Torres, Owner Item Before the Board: Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of vinyl awnings, relocation of the A/C units, and an exterior color change for a contributing property. Chairman Perez asked if there were any ex-parte communications. There were none. Ms. Shay presented the project to the Board and entered the project file into the record. Mr. Israel Torres, owner, was present to represent the project. Chairman Perez inquired if there were any questions from the public. There were none. Chairman Perez closed the Public Hearing, and asked if there were any comments from the Board. There were none. It was moved by Mr. Miller, seconded by Mr. Keavney, and passed 5 to 0 to approve the COA and associated Class I site plan modification for 9 SE 7th Avenue, Brisa Atlantica, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(8)(g), and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines. C. 325 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, Stofft.Architects, Inc., Authorized Agent Item before the Board: Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of a non-contributing building and the construction of a single-family home. Chairman Perez asked if there were any ex-parte communications. There were none. Ms. Shay presented the project to the Board and entered the project file into the record. Mr. Craig Valvo, Island Homes presented elevations of the pool, as well as the proposed home that depicts what changes would be incorporated into the plans. Chairman Perez inquired if there were any questions from the public. There were none. Chairman Perez closed the Public Hearing, and asked if there were any comments from the Board The Board recommended that additional architectural elements be incorporated into the side and rear elevations, such as banding, arched windows, and door 3 Historic Preservation Board Minutes December 17,2003 surrounds. The pool needs to be set back, and the applicant must provide a true color palette Demolition It was moved by Ms. Jamison, seconded by Mr. Keavney, and passed 5 to 0_to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the non- contributing dwelling at 325 SE 7t' Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(F), and it is approved administratively when the changes come in. Certificate of Appropriateness It was moved by Mr. Miller, seconded by Mr. Silberstein, and passed 4-1 (Jamison dissenting)to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 325 SE 7th Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to the LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a-k), 4.6.15(G), and the Delray Beach h Design Guidelines, subject to the following conditions: 1) That additional architectural elements be incorporated into the side and rear elevations, specifically including but not limited to: banding, arched windows and door surrounds, and variation of the exterior, 2) That the south end of the proposed pool be relocated to comply with the required minimum ten foot(10') side setback;and, 3) That the applicant submit a true color scheme. 4) That additional landscaping be added facing the intercoastal. D. Blue Anchor, 802 East Atlantic Avenue, Marina Historic District, American Awning, Authorized Agent Item Before the Board: Reconsideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of an awning. Chairman Perez asked if there were any ex-parte communications. There were none. Ms. Shay presented the project to the Board and entered the project file into the record. Mr. Joseph Mattei of American Awning submitted royal blue canvas material to the Board for review. Chairman Perez closed the Public Hearing, and asked if there were any comments from the Board.There were none. It was moved by Ms. Jamison, seconded by Mr. Miller, and passed 5 to 0 to approve the COA associated with the Class I site plan modification for the installation of a canvass awning for 802 East Atlantic Avenue, Blue Anchor, 4 Historic Preservation Board Minutes December 17,2003 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(8)(g), and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, subject to the following conditions: 1) That the awning does not encroach more than one foot (1') into the Palm Square right-of-way (6'from the building). 2) That prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant enter into a Hold Harmless Agreement with the City. 3) That Royal Blue canvas material be utilized and all framing is painted to match. E. Old School Square Bread Company, 814 East Atlantic Avenue, Marina Historic District, Delray Awning, Authorized Agent Item before the Board: Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of an awning. • Chairman Perez asked if there were any ex-parte communications. There were none. Ms. Shay presented the project to the Board and entered the project file into the record. Staff is recommending re-designing the awning to accommodate the existing landscaping at the patio. The owner was notified that if the company occupies 816 East Atlantic Avenue, additional parking will be required. Staffs concern is that the planter area can be covered and the square footage increased resulting in the additional need for parking. Mr. Donald Day, Delray Awning, stated that the awning was re-designed to cut around the planter. The posts will be painted to match the building, and the upper portion of the structure will be painted to blend with the canvas awning. Chairman Perez closed the Public Hearing, and asked if there were any comments from the Board. Mr. Silberstein inquired about exterior lighting. Mr. Day advised that there would more than likely be fans and lighting under the awning. It was moved by Mr. Silberstein, seconded by Ms. Jamison, and passed 5 -0 to approve the COA associated with the Class l site plan modification for the installation of an awning at 814 East Atlantic Avenue, Old School Square Bread Company, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(8)(g), and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, subject to the following condition: 1) That the awning be re-designed as a gable in order to ell from the front door out to the patio area without covering the existing landscape strip adjacent to (east of) the building. 5 Historic Preservation Board Minutes December 17,2003 HI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments: None. B. Report from Historic District Representatives: None C. Board Members: Ms. Jamison expressed her concern that a resident on George Bush Boulevard installed wrought iron gates without approval. George Bush is a collector road and the gates do not open automatically. Therefore, they will be blocking the driveway. Ms. Shay stated that she would look into this. D. Staff Comments: Ms. Shay requested that a Board member attend the West Settlerq Advisory Board meeting on the fourth Monday of each month. Several Board members expressed interest. IV. ADJOURNMENT The Board made a motion to adjourn at 7:45 p.m. The information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for December 17, 2003, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on March 3, 2004. Denise A. Valek If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. 6 Historic Preservation Board Minutes December 17,2003 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD PUBLIC HEARING WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 1994 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM 100 N.W. 1ST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FL 33444 I. ROLL CALL: The Chairman called the meeting to order at 6:00 P.M. Board Members: Christine Bull Present Daniel Carter (Chairman) Present Sandy Jamison (2nd Vice-Chairman) Absent Buck Miller (Vice-Chairman) Present Margie Miller Absent John Vaughan Present Charlie Williams Present Staff Members Present: Jeff Costello, Planning & Zoning Department Pat Cayce, Planning & Zoning Department Diana Mund, Planning & Zoning Department Joe Dragon, Parks & Recreation Department II . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: January 19, 1994 Meeting Buck Miller moved for approval of the minutes for the January 19, 1994 meeting, seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes; John Vaughan - Yes; Charlie Williams - Yes. Said motion passed 5-0 . III . PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None. IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-219 : 325 S.E. 7th Avenue; Marina Historic District; James Kolleda, Owner. The action requested of the Board is that of granting approval for the demolition of a 176 sq. ft. storage room on the west (front) facade. The storage room is to be replaced with 17 ' 6" x 24 ' garage. The Board moved to approve COA 8-219 based upon positive findings with respect to Section 4 .5. 1(E) (8) (Visual Compatibility) , as follows: * Approve the demolition of a storage room on the northwest corner of the building. In its place a 17 ' 6" x 24 ' frame garage will be constructed. The entrance of which will face south, no reconfiguration of the existing driveway will be required. The roof of the garage is to have a gable running north and south and will be the same height as the hip roof on the existing building which is behind it. The west facade, facing the street, will have a small bay window. The garage is to have horizontal siding to match the main residence. The new roof surface will match the roof of the residence. The garage door is to be wood with raised panels . Glass panes may be used in the garage door if the owner chooses to do so. Buck Miller moved for approval of COA 8-219, seconded by Charlie Williams. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Buck Miller Yes; John Vaughan - Yes; Charlie Williams - Yes. Said motion passed 5-0. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Location of the Boat Sewage Waste Pump at the City Marina. Joe Dragon of the Parks & Recreation Department, explained to the Board why the City was placing the boat sewage waste pump at the north end as opposed to the south end of the City Marina. He explained that if placed at the south end it would cost more to install and the marina would loose two boat slips. Where if placed at the north end the installation cost would be less and the marina would loose only one boat slip. He also stated that he had looked at the same model pump at a marina in Fort Lauderdale and found no odor problem. The Board requested that Mr. Dragon check with the Engineering Department on hooking into the sewer line to the marina restrooms at the south end and get an actual cost analysis for installation at both ends of the marina. The Board felt that aesthetically the pump would be better placed at the south end of the marina. - 2 - 2/2/94 VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: - A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None. B. Board Members None. C. Staff Ms. Cayce asked the Board's opinion of a window change out for 300 S.E. 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, single family residence. The Board agreed that awning windows would be an appropriate replacement for the existing jalousie windows, if permitted by the building code. Ralph Cantin presented the plan for the B.F. James & F.J. Bright Park to the Board for their approval. Buck Miller moved for approval of , seconded by John Vaughan. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes; John Vaughan - Yes; Charlie Williams - Yes . Said motion passed 5-0. VII. ADJOURNMENT: Charlie Williams moved for adjournment at 6:50 P.M. , seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes; John Vaughan - Yes; Charlie Williams - Yes. Said motion passed 5-0 . _ The next meeting is scheduled for February 16, 1994 . The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for February 2, 1994, which were formally a and ap ed b the Board on February 16, 1994. a Mund If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes . - 3 - 2/2/94 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING FEBRUARY 2, 1994 AGENDA ITEM IV COA 8-219 325 S.E. 7TH AVENUE, CONTRIBUTING BUILDING, MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT JAMES KOLLEDA, OWNER ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the board is that of granting approval for the demolition of a 176 s.f. storage room on the west (front) facade. The storage room is to be replaced with 17 '6" x 24 'garage. BACKGROUND This house was built in 1938 for Mr. & Mrs. T.W. Boykin Jr. It was designed by Delray Beach architect, Nels Jacobson in the resort cottage style. It sat on a large plot of land; 244' frontage on S.E. 7th Avenue. The house was remodeled with additions in 1941 and again in 1959 . In the fall of 1990 David Reikse the owner at the time, proposed replatting the land into three buildable parcels. However, the house was situated in the center of the plot and Mr. Reikse proposed to demolish it in order to create the three lots. In a pre-application hearing the Preservation Board expressed its opposition to the proposed demolition. The COA for demolition was formally reviewed at the Board's November 14, 1990 meeting. The board voted 4-2 to allow the demolition with the condition that the owner consult with a moving company to determine the feasibility of relocation. (By this time staff had had several inquires regarding the relocation of the house. ) The Board requested that the applicant return to the Board at the next meeting to discuss relocation. No demolition date was established. At the next meeting Mr. Reikse informed the Board that he had found a possible buyer, the present owner Mr. Kolleda. However, in order to sell the house on its original site on the center lot and create the lots to the north and south, several rooms would have to be removed from the north and south facades and variances would be needed to allow for side setback encroachment. Fortunately, the portions of the house to be removed were the later additions. The Board approved the room removals on the north and south facades and granted the necessary variances to allow the original portions of the building to encroach on the side setbacks. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS The applicant is proposing to demolish a storage room on the northwest corner of the building. In is place he will construct a frame garage, the entrance of which will face south. The roof of the garage is to have a gable running north and south and will be the same height as the hip roof on the existing building which is behind it. The west facade (front) will have a small bay window. The garage is to have horizontal siding to match existing and the roof will also match existing. RECOMMENDED ACTION Make positive findings with respect to Section 4.5. 1(E) (8) , visible Compatibility, and approve COA 8-219 on the condition that the horizontal siding is to match that of the existing house. 6„ - V �- J� gr L1-o w .i\C) 5 • ,_ i s } Y - 7 S t r . ' . 1 • -N • . _..1..:: .. .,1 ;;.4 • ' -e•''''' -4111%. . ...ft a e-gli-M7f,_. .nil_ . ,. . im.,,,. . 1_1, ammommlow -¢ - .. i•,emsµ _ : 37 ;F.- „'_xs `-. 'ate :sa . • 'i.....-.A -"is '- _ • -.-..-.:.„. -:- 1 w yr. • ,'-t AS t y ,j : :t. 4- f1. r a - .1ii 1 t o S a s ii�i f �a-• - `4+ . s i :ill -- _ ... • r.. _ • . 9/ • _ �f i ----' . Pa‘je 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 Original fill FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 362 Update_.-D Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions Recorder Date 2/1999 Site Name 325 SE 7th Avenue Other Names None Project Name Delray Beach Survey&Planning Project Historic Contexts WWII&Aftermath National Register Category Building LOCATION'andJDENTIFICATlON Address 325 SE 7th Avenue Vicinity of SE 4th St and SE 3rd St on E City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969& 1973 Townshi 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr SE Irregular Section ❑ UTM Zone 17 Easting 0593081 Northing 2926184 Land Grant Unknown Latitude Longitude Plat or Other Map Palm Beach County Aerials Architect/Builder Unknown Construction Date 1947 Circa w Alterations 1 Date c. 1980 Type/Location windows replaced Additions Date c. 1980 Type/Location two-car garage added to the north end of the west elevation I1 , d Original Location i�nal Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence S I ' Style Masonry Vernacular Exterior Plan Irregular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 1 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Weatherboard, Stucco Foundatio Slab Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infil N/A No.of Porches 1 Locations/Features west: entry porch covered by a fabric awning Dormers 0 Number/Location Outbldgs. ❑ Number Nature/Location (Describe below) Roof Type Gable, Hip Roofing Materials Composition Shingle Secondary Structures 0 Comments/Location Chimneys Tz Number 1 Orientation West Location Wall, Exterior Material Brick Wood Windows EG Type DHS Light# 6/6 Metal Windows w Type SHS Light# 6/6 Exterior Ornament Cornerboards,Vents Condition Good Surroundings Residential Narrative (general, interior, landscape, context; 3 lines only) This building has many alterations included a garage addition and nonhistoric windows. An arched window is located on the south end of the west elevation. Flat wood trim surrounds the original windows. Originally,this building was typical of 1940s residential construction. I-iaeological Remains Present ❑ None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) r Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 1, L Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions .1 -. -� ;RECOROER'S"EVALUATION OF SITE--; `. ,- - Eligible for National Register? Yes 7 No k- Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information Significant as Part of District? Yes ❑ No ki Likely, Need lnformatio Insufficient Information n Significant at Local Level? Yes w No ❑ Likely, Need lnformatio Insufficient Information ❑ Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This 1940s building is representative of the city's historic architecture and development.Although it has experienced modifications,this residence could be considered a contributing resource in the locally listed Marina Historic District.The building is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP as part of a district or individually. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS " DHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL OFFICE DOCUMENTATION" ----- Research Methods Sanborn maps, Plat maps, Local&County Historical Societies Bibliographic References Location: City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Location of Negatives City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Negative Numbers 9874-24;13;E RECORDER INFORMATION � - Recorder Name Amy Groover,Jo-Anne Peck, Susan Hochberg Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5'MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, PREFERABLY B&W,AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Friday,July 09,1999 , __ .........._,...,,,,-. ..-.4----..,--•:-,'---:-tZ.-;'; ;;_i*- 7 .;;-'.,-,:**,:- .i-,•,.V.- ••.7-•,-.':*5,.-„..;,,T,'=-•„..':-.-,::,.•,,:;-4.:•.:-.„-.,.......••;.•:- ..•:,•,.,.•.-4.,•:-•.:••_.. - --- ' -'''.'—''''"'-'-'•'-'-L'L'''''''-t's.'''z-'-''''''''':;;'=,t•.,:t•'-'••••A•j't-6'§'•-:tIUADRANGLE;IV.IAP,',1-',."••' -..:; -ft-czs-J-,'..:_4-. :.,f,L.-,,,,..-L,-,„.-;.,LL:,-.•,.,z.,-?..r,-5..-...•_.,.7..:_-.-..--,-_,„,-..,.,..,.-...,,,,..,.. .„-.- 411%.*:.-.:--"'s'e..t-tt:-:----,--.t.r''It-trtt'-''''.-"---:.1-71'...tz::'''fi';<..1"tt.':;:,-.tt;:-'-1?-.117';71'''.4:fl'-'1:14;1.'.11.:gt.t.3'''''...,....t.:;.:V-'',::11,1'.'„.,"':;:.;::;V-,''''t.‘,!•_‘-ft4......;',•-•--....,'"";;;:''',:_-'7?•-4.".7-'.5-,,''''',..p.lt-;--:-..'' ..L,•:-,72.7-e-^n . .. ilsi.tr,i 7 tt- 7,,. „i:7 ! I- 11 -- -.4. .-I•I- -IIt-.I /I't. 'i -L.It ,-t; ov I Q I • 'I 2-- . •- Eli 1 11'-.j,i tuLL': 11 :ti...1.1-.„ii,,-t._,Iici.#-_,.,•:. , -.II t'4-,L,1;1 .„.,'--- • - _7.7—.7,_. .r......„ 1...r.1,o I, • I ; -,.-,14 Q ..-. i. .•!,;•.1 zll; - .- ,----------- , h)9.Y.. 11 . „,!N,. .,__ i . . 1, .-.,1„ P.aipt -T-.t:',-'; ---Jtaliz: ____L.----- -- .... 4- /,,'• -, __,."94--.'.-t it;.1 .-1 , . ,.. 11 - t t . - ..-/-t ' ...-.--'---:--_, :tE7.77..-77.7:I•t-,..F ,,-2/1:.'_ 5 71: :.:..,.-._ '74,--. .. 1.-.----';"-------6-1Lff-:.-.::: :-----1-1-r..-'---17.i7±."- i917r`s: P.1717.-1-: --iiiip-i--.;--,.-ii,,oil-i,,,,,' ...,::: -.-:=.,:,,..-11,,.).7b.: .,-------- ...: ,. , 7 1: • 't L -',:"L' 1/: •I -7 : !;_.il,-7;i, 'it./: II!J'!I--i-I/ . II n t iL-11,It-iL:zilLttiltttti 12L-.t" ".--JL-"--2.1_A tit7.7771,T,- ( /I I - - ::-'2•!. / t 641L1. 1,_-"Tit-,--21147L, iIIT.-ir-Z71t, ttt.--•,;;tf-17'2-7F.•;. --:-,„ *tt:'-'11.):"..:7:1- t Ir ': li.--. -- I!!t --...--- -7--.------rildi .:r15171Eri (11-/..,'L- 4/?•1 :::II:j(c;j4 L ' • '-': P'1:Pcid ":':-11'!:1, ....' =•:-'1-,,';',.„..,.... 0) El I-IK ..,.. -, '-...-—1 , . ' - 1. •,,--.'--1,. i r.,, LI rt,g.,, s ''',ST,_1 _,-_,--a.,_,____ _.__, .,....1,-, -II ! i ."-t'. .":,:,JI/:- II!-IJI' t I"-ti 1'I-•-L:11--It-•-, ---- ,---:,'77t-iiI,T.TI.r .I t•-t,-0.,-,Li,t./-7. -, 7411'.- ,a! ! t;t:t./,./....F.':I' ..'---•'t!j I:,",". ..;;; )/L-- il jj,'":;7.t-tHj,,r7r-..'.F-....1 ,. ,,n7i{1...... !,J,F1-'..r° ..,'I-f li*,.' ;,-;I III:...1iI:',..: ,.7. =iii!,".". ; '-'i.-±=.-..›•'.Alp.1;::t: ,.; __,J4.,:,:f LI— .• ;-.iii,-- • : !,,--.-.41-- •::-. 11-.-2.• ,.',.-_--i::;:.1: -.,',i-,- ! - .'J---, it.:T.:.-ill_,, .,.'.1,' .11--;'. -::,'.;1-1: '..,-,411.c.::, •.!: ,-,-,!.iiL I 7-!:-7 -•t;'•--',.t'I., 1 ,0 --7 1 n . 11t I;11: -11-:;.':,11'4 71';,44--,',-/171.- --;,,,,, : . ,' ..,- :„ .,..„ .4,.,,,,.,, ,.. 4!L).,E, 7, L° -/'; /-- ;7%Z :'.I - . ...- 57: ,.,/,...- ': li • ir--, PI"-I.-•-1."-•-•tI-1'; Ball"I'''7't jfi&J;TIY' ll- "t.;. Ci-iiic.. '<it ..':.':-Nt,,nr1:7 i:;:,•-: -.! _---7.-,--- -: ' • r-,'--.-:iiI.I I :;t.,- i.41:-'11-..,;ILL,L---1 _1-... I.; II..-Lk';II: park I--J.:.1--‘•?,11:-.!'.C.1 V! lejt!'"..--;:L_____:.t}i.fiL',_,,'" ::';';' 1, ','.--L-:::'1' ''.-; -.-.•:I!.,..-....; 1,_. .0,,,,„.!:•sill . iii,:-....zi--::i_:::,1......i:::::11ck, -;i.-4-,,.,,.=!!,,-.7,1,_;_..._Jr. • ___ '-- • -+4.:L,r____:7711 ii---1,_:7.7.,--7,--7_, - i',i, •t , 1:7:1,,,..,:.:_l I.-',-2.4._ !-.:.!: 'f'---i'..1;7_, -•C' --1- • '(.9. -.Itt2 ,i _-,-,tir--h',:.:I FL:7-,1---.. .;t1t 711C.t.71r74 .1:-.----:; (j1,[71i-',...-1,711=J:1:.:4-r-1,1..,'::111t.:-",1,;: 1111 -:".- t::;:l' I; k. '.ii:;'11:.1--•:_ '::,,-.1.:1 l'i j ..: ,.,_ ,,: ;.•;1,.. :p co 1:•114',.;*, ',.',I:. t/I 3E- --.-'---... "-_-:---7.1".• IIII *-,-,c il -1, -I,V,IIII-, ,;.: II. .111511•...','1111-4t-r,7.:.-illidt".1 liLL LI '''" L't• I;-'' " II ""' "•-t--, ;----1-- -"I . ,- '---- •.."''11:7--../" Eli lit -'4.---;Lttlft//z, ' si.:_---A----1„.7-j-t--!,,-77. ,r-.1t-:. -.70,7,1717.-; :.:, -r.-71 1 .) arl;l'-- i ,: -'-',€;:it2-,- „,,,„ ,,,/I-- '•• - II;;`,___..17.7,Ftl,tt.I.tt-,1,1 "...-,.itt/.(,,:j t 1--"'-_ f:1,1,i'I'./"IV.:,t/li,::f.t.t., 'tI.,:i::'.'"I II % •5:6!- t.; -.7j"t"""' i ' '-,* ItlZE'n>1!!'",-i-i,''., 1•:.!.:.12.<'; . II ;i1 I.I•lit.'-..":1,:di 7::1:-•'-•11••• ,11-_-:4•'s'ellL_tAini.: r1-t-- ''' • -t:•:71 - -•„ df,ei-1.'•=-:,'it--,91-e,[11- - -'..1•----' F-E ---7F-717T4---- '-----f'.1:`: •,-----__ .... -...; ,, -;-ii: -!._11--..--4-i •.:! -25 ,--,_ ,.,,i_tt-Ltt I-pi,..--'-t'1 -4i______ _ .-..._ _ ,.- -4,,, 1,::1,z:, 1 -1„; .y7, -_:.I.- ILL '_,.i:,_, .;._ ,t rig.i.x>s. ;:.-:, -...,, ,'----.. -„:-, ,, 1E-..,:i...::::14.-„ii-41.,-, _-__ . ::: •-• it :11'.'•7-::'-ii .. l!''•'-::;:.,::-.'.....••••••• •• 4'W`,-':-'--f,---t--',-- r,T17111.11,-:Vy i---- -g : ,.://t117711-_- _•,I, 7- -- ' 7:-•T;-- ...:I„./77,t--;/_LLIitt.-i:II°I fil on I iunn,2--"---t-L:L/_._f_t-. t —_- ‘,!•••- •!•-::, .7 ---- ,, 1--1I'll-,;-:1,1( --- hi '1 " ! - .'-'. j=''--- 7 t' 1''II- .11E11-16i .. 1 ,LLILL' I: -., "'PY:', .. - ZI':•,.1 -..--' 7.!.i I - ,._ - .: Ff-' ..ff3-.' j I.; .''''''. '''''' 7-75-°- -1.ir:j1-71.;-_•-''-k1.11-1=----F--,-c- 7 2--.- '% I. - -::-.L.:LI:.---,--:.'., '......' - ... j ff. '4.. :, ...•.:; ,,,..,1„.....,..,...1.....---,b.i.g_ gr,r7-Hi:.• ST I j'•1•17.7: ,-:-••,.L.,-. •17; i;ine Ridge :;• i';',::I i;,•('....'"----'-_-_ _/-,.. il - .,......... '-- --,-41.• II ;;Baf I.F.i.01,,i-',1'-',, 'l'.- lch,,•, f,--,' - 1;1 '' _,_ ..1 ..,'''----..., ,. -t-•Fi; 7.i .1 :I t'1,, _ -3i• P.---4---`1:-''IL''-"- ill_1 . „.:_ii..,7; ub 1.,, 11 1 .._ Ti 11 1: !;...00 7-,,s 1..::: I; .1(.....-- -;-IFI:r7 if;-TF7 ..!g•J, --!_ Ai 11' ':."-,„ : 7'....'"? :.----; _2:=-;.-7-.-•;:-'.:-;==,1 41-:.:Ileit!-„,..-7•-ttiZr14::!-I.-.1• ;_•-pi_."-I--.-1I1t-)1.i-1;_,1•',..Ii'iIi!-tL_'.Ii.,_1I.'t.-_H-,-;-o.m.:-,nc s,,e_s,f.`'!t. -..,E7-11L-•E.Ik•. - ill1! I 1•i2_1/.T7i4/;...:!l.:'•::2;:0Li1i-'.1::1'II.i.:.':I,.ii'';,11....::...1I'.ILi"••.,---t-''-'1. .----,;!-!!')-.'';..—'-2'-;'-•_..'i, :'14I.;1,L.---i1'•--.--.---"--,,1I,'I,,:••.g-,_-7,-.-12- IIi-•--.1:..9.j1I.•--lt;t 1' 4;-E"47i7I!..=- • xLI ,'... •,!'.-,,''In•:)nJ:t-T?r".].7.,7 n: 1. USGS Delray Beach,e ach, Fla. Quadrangle;k1 - , . , - i ? 1 i 1 : / 4 L- - 75MinuteSeries(Topoaraphic) I ' : i I 1962, PhotoreNisedi969and 1973 _ 7/- - LF, BM7r- Scale 1 24 000-; ' _ L I„-,,,,,,,,;s--,..:4•_,-....,,---'...„:q,..---m.a'',----Irr..0 2,----',,F,',2.,•;;I:71::E.,Z;',.:kS'*,.';'- .Y:.:A.y,4,:c.'„:,;.. .4.1,-E'7.,.*,_,•. ":.: ::-•...:-.,:,---;,-,'It--,,.--7-'-'.. .."-'..1.,..t-Vis!,,,,,,,,...,...7-_,:-..— . r • , SE 3 rti Si'. 7013_1 • ., ‘ iol.-1...•'- , li -..-- • x..,„..., ,40.:A...,.. . ,.'" 4k i• ' - in i 11 As-li,'''•• ,. . '4./ o El -/1.19 . , .10. '- I !.. . ,, S _..., 6‘• _, . . 0.• • . A.• -.• V) • I:3 -rya , , . .• • .--..1 44,4%.,. 407.:T--,,ii, '-.4'. , . ..•• - ., . ..: ..... ." ,_, • 4.,,,--iwo.,..... v.iitiiiii-ak . • • . a) .,.. ..,..-..-...,,,-„-_,-...=_,-,-,. — 4:r ...74 Iya---_-::------,,...72::, -----;.:,:•:.:7----=•.ip - :--.„-- , -4_ ..va ,._:t‘,.:,- s, ,::-:,----•:., :::1 --;:-------,4 :2' 4,T. j....,, , ..!....% • -.•••••,'F•--: . ... .. . - ;;:•• 1 ' Vc‘.N,-•A'f•:!;7-7 -ii!..72 ' _.1...*:*...s".&\ * ;......*‘. - .,.,..- •.._..-7---_, .;*•-:.--.....-...,_-,41.....% •,...... ..*• •• • . •''''-ft:„.---.;..-,...1..;,-1°! ......._.'*:'***•...- •••,,Z..t •5‘ '..*„ i ' ...tik •.•-•-*S--.f_4':',......7:::--. . rrgl K) ,_-- --. _ - lilt. : „I, ._ t., - - - ._,....,....:.....-.... T. .., N./ . , ., , ..,.--i t St - . E---1 o t ti:.. ..e...;..7t• ,,,•.r. .... . - sr . . _ -,-1 . . -, - --- _ --F • • s.tt- :----, • -• .ii.---.,-- .-••„:•-•,- ._ a - ' -- •,‘ - , - -- - • -,Vaie.' -- _4. - - • • . _ .. .. • =-'..--..;,..1 , . . . .., _ - (I) -- - • - .. .. :.... -. . $ __.... ._ • - . .. -..-._._ . . _-....-...,...- , ' - --- . ,-___ _.. ....-. .._,...-_,,....i......,,,...-.,...., - . • —- - - • • Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 t Original FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 362 Update (E Consult Guide to-Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions Recorder Date 2/1999 Site Name 325 SE 7th Avenue Other Names None Project Name Delray Beach Survey& Planning Project Historic Contexts WWII &Aftermath National Register Category Building __- ;�, _. .� LOCATION and_IDENTIEICATION .:' Address 325 SE 7th Avenue Vicinity of SE 4th St and SE 3rd St on E City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969& 1973 Townshi 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr SE Irregular Section ❑ UTM Zone 17 Easting 0593081 Northing 2926184 Land Grant Unknown Latitude Longitude Plat or Other Map Palm Beach County Aerials Architect/Builder Unknown Construction Date 1947 Circa w Alterations y Date c. 1980 Type/Location windows replaced Additions oC Date c. 1980 Type/Location two-car garage added to the north end of the west elevation ^� d 0 Original Location 'ii_nal Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence _. .DESCRIP ION°• .. Style Masonry Vernacular Exterior Plan Irregular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 1 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Weatherboard, Stucco Foundatio Slab Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infil N/A No. of Porches 1 Locations/Features west:entry porch covered by a fabric awning Dormers 0 Number/Location Outbldgs. 0 Number Nature/Location (Describe below) Roof Type Gable, Hip Roofing Materials Composition Shingle Secondary Structures ❑ Comments/Location Chimneys wz Number 1 Orientation West Location Wall, Exterior Material Brick Wood Windows wG Type DHS Light# 6/6 Metal Windows k Type SHS Light# 6/6 Exterior Ornament Cornerboards,Vents Condition Good Surroundings Residential Narrative (general, interior, landscape,context; 3 lines only) This building has many alterations included a garage addition and nonhistoric windows. An arched window is located on the south end of the west elevation. Flat wood trim surrounds the original windows. Originally,this building was typical of 1940s residential construction. II aeological Remains Present ❑ None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) Printed Friday,July 09, 1999 Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# PB10266 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions RECORDER'S EVALUATION OF SITE' -: Eligible for National Register? Yes n No Likely, Need Informatio ❑ Insufficient Information ❑ Significant as Part of District? Yes n No 1 Likely, Need Informatio Insufficient Information �l Significant at Local Level? Yes k No Likely, Need Informatio ❑ Insufficient Information E Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This 1940s building is representative of the city's historic architecture and development.Although it has experienced modifications,this residence could be considered a contributing resource in the locally listed Marina Historic District.The building is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP as part of a district or individually. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS DHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL OFFICE DOCUMENTATION Research Methods Sanborn maps, Plat maps, Local&County Historical Societies Bibliographic References Location: City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Location of Negatives City of Delray Beach; 100 NW 1st Avenue Negative Numbers 9874-24;13;E RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name Amy Groover,Jo-Anne Peck, Susan Hochberg Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North, St.Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, PREFERABLY B&W,AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Friday,July 09,1999 .•— - .,.... .. r.....-... Y. ' 'l.-..; E.._._USG,..S...Q. -.U_.aA_.vDR...ANGLEMAP - M n k ?. ;- ; :4 )' „„ .. , ..,, •..:r, �... ,4, . ,«+: .,�Y - � '' fL ry --J ^—,� 1I I II :II II . 1 !� .) .ill hi-1V - 1. r Y .A-'!II -1 I pl. Shady i ! I I II . 'I I iI I I.It W 1 �! I t I_ Sch I, ?�! I INE JD QI /� 7 I .. II• • 1I- 1 �- . _ 2 -7 I, .I j ;{I 1,,0 i •••I Ii 11- IVJa: ' '1[k 1t Q 1��h( -10 r, 1--- _;j=��-i l ,=11 it•s ■I' • / I '. ✓` ',I- III I I! II- •!I II .J! II y) K .�I 17. I-_�i KW I I L u I,-_i�1 t`D I It 1i sT Y kt i Ji Jt` I 1 - -- ,-�.I ,\--L[iM Ir 'm1;iT - JI' :tSta I^ - 1I` 1 -,I- (.itiJI Playground it II �j t - !. ,• •''I •• ,ih ! {T I r i II:. I` I1-1'r-'2Q II1-�1 1 I .(I Ir _-• '�r r` .� I, 1 12,� r 1 1 0 I , 1 II i I I{ �l,r ! V IItilt; ° 17 /- i 'll I � � L ;!I! ■ I« II 1- t I 17 ,i I' !1 II ,L f 11 / ♦j 11 E.} :ii°o� I1 I c1� rI In71la n a I I- ' �✓ _ l 14 I !1'. I I I L-1 I k Il a -lit - J �I�I -;I ' / • r:11 1 h I: 1` 11 ! 71 I Ball I f l [-1 t I a I - Park I o7Ij� t h lL of� � pi � LJLj'15J, ST1 I ¢�• 11jll �! • t-.- i•,lI I� 1^{�^, ' / —Ire .• �r ii 1 O u( � _:1 �= 11 i >1�i Ih -1I 1_` I��,"I�11;! !' (1 it ,, ' =a 1. 1, ; t �I I {;I II f Q i 1k . I!-I a y ._h t • , ! _, , _ ,,71_ 7_. m ii 11 - ---�J " 6 _ .. I}i 1 1,71(� 1 I zI' I 1 jI II.pI.• 1I 7;1,1,I Ii' ./ , I r u I .IIr7 a ";o! -, 11 J I, hl_JI ! ILz[- Its y' b' I' .'/ I J Qr t r U 30` Il t d I-!! :ICI - J ' JELJ1LftUTL, eh ® I�-,,E `, _ ``�_ - tt 1! _+1 .� ,-Ohl •• • II I�I�'o I II aJI F"1 - 1 { ,II -i�d�i 6 " .1I LI:1 - �i 7'z i ii l 11 — .• I ._J 'tee {- V` y" T Pine Ridge a I p s ++ sT I each,,,.� � 1ii `e fern ;u c q�7.1i- le eague 1 lub It �I111I1 _ i .l I� Ba I Fuld --. �(=r • is '" 11 '� II !� 'o�=\� I. t -T7_i• l 'I !I _ I ' l`o li �III C ��a� _ �I I: II ( II II• : -% 1 �'•/ • ..I:�_[.�_ x.1 11 - li..at 1 II II ! r 7o I -- II I�•1 ' Iad�ljl#Y--k F' Al 8P� oe-�r0 ef I .'' �!'L I_jl_11_1.t.r • ,oT T Ir". 1: .. l s�uah ss5�, -C.'1 USGS Delray Beach, Fla. Quadrangle t • ,8 •oi. 'I� yl ;• ' :i'' � I i:�llrraile� T F, — 7.5 Minute Series(Topographic) ti - ;,, {'/,,- 11 -! II •Ib� I1� Park i. -- 1962, Photo revised 1969 and 1973 _"Rainbow I I'� -- - .;,; -:1 fr—, Homes �� 1i �:�' ;II BN119 ' _— • h Scale 1: 24 000 - - •o 4 x 1'HO?C GI P't�� 4 ' ` - .,SKETCH}MA; ; `� ...ix — ..t."...:� ..-. .r-... ....,..v .�' .'ee_. ..�._...._L6�: ._ .— ?.'^.3'_M,. .04— e-x --. rt« is 9 � 4 t. .t.f 5E rti Si- 708 Y i-va s.: '4..-" �;T� 1. ma's:.; 'k El ` M • ZiC z .- r _ �, _ - h E ,. 1 _"r,� R s rt 1 a ` i 'ems : 1. 4T Y, -fy, t ''it- �j.. - ._, ; 4�1 w /-ri t , r _.ice,-_ - N ,.. •..,_ ,....... ... ..,.....:......„....„ ,„ 1A 1