Loading...
35 - FMSF CITY COMMISSION DOCUMENTATION TO: DA . HARD; Cif MANAGER THRU: P LING, DIRE OR OF PLANNING AND ZONING FROM: W E A , HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER SUBJECT: MEETING OF JULY 5, 2005 REQUEST TO INDIVIDUALLY LIST THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE (NORTH END OF SEABREEZE AVENUE) TO THE LOCAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS. , The Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) was originally owned by Sewell C. Biggs, a person important in preserving, conserving, and promoting American fine and decorative arts. The style of the home is a design unique to Delray Beach and is the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in the 20th-century American design field. It is also the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach (although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings) and is representative of 20th-century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further, the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving historic buildings in Delray Beach. Designating this site as historic will help preserve the character of the extant historic dwelling and will promote the preservation of other surrounding historic properties. To qualify as a historic site the property must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, Sections 4.5.1(B)(2) and/or (3). The residence at 212 Seabreeze Avenue is being considered for listing in the Local Register of Historic Places as it fulfills four of the criteria. It is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(2)(a)]; it embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(b)]; it is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(c)]; and, it contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(d)]. Additional information concerning the proposed individual designation can be found in the attached Designation Report. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CONSIDERATION At its meeting of May 4, 2005, the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) conducted a formal review of the designation report and set a public hearing date for the designation of the subject property for May 18, 2005. However, as the applicant did not submit the required names and addresses of property owners within a 500' radius of the property to meet that deadline, the public hearing was held on June 15, 2005, when the HPB voted unanimously (7-0) to forward a recommendation of approval to the City Commission to list the Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) in the Local Register of Historic Places. RECOMMENDATION Move approval on first reading of Ordinance No. 50-05 that the residence and associated property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (The Sewell C. Biggs House) be listed in the Local Register of Historic Places, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and Sections 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(C) of the Land Development Regulations. Attachments:Ordinance No. 50-05 and Designation Report ORDINANCE NO. 50-05 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, DESIGNATING THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE, LOCATED AT 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AS A LOCAL HISTORIC SITE; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, APRIL 2005"; PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach provides for the designation and protection of historic sites; and WHEREAS, Erskine H. Courtenay and Virginia W. Courtenay, as property owners, have nominated the property described herein to be designated as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, on June 15, 2005, the Historic. Board of the City of Delray Beach recommended 7 to 0 that the property described herein be designated a local historic site; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach adopts the findings in the Planning and Zoning Staff Report; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach finds the ordinance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property described herein as a local historic site. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the recitations set forth above are incorporated herein. • I L_ __I U I I I I I I I w N.E. 5TH ST. z w ,> z 1 ISLQND DRIVE Q c J c / In i cn J.1 ‹Cw z 1 0 \ Z N.E. 4TH ST. t BEACH DRIVE I..i U.LI C SEA SPRAY AVE. Q 11 SANDOWAY LANE - o WATERWAY LANE a Z J , — O _ ¢ Z Z -Y 7 ~ � I N J = J LAING ST. N.E. 3RD S I. MAR v VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE �1J A 1 SOU 1- LLJ Z La Q `.! I DORCHESTER Z CO—OP I THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. Z EAST WIND I J CS5 BEACH CLUB L Q 1 BERKSHIRE • f— J w I DRIVE m N.E. 1ST CT. (1) ZZ, BY THE SEA 7 Q N Q Q „ w GROSVENOR w a o Q 0 33 z Q C.) LOWRY LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE O N.E. 1ST ST. Q CONDO Z ,' FIRE VETERANS DELRAY "\, . STA. r SUMMIT _ GROVE No. 2 ATLANTIC PARK I— CONDO w \ w CONDO NI a PLAZA Z I // w BARR w TERRACE IW CONDO I SPANISH DELRAY BEACH I� MARRIOTT RIVER o I RESORT A T L A N TIC AVENUE N -iimft-- THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM833 • Section 2. That the following described property in the City of Delray Beach, Florida, is hereby designated as a local historic site in accordance with and under the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to-wit: Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Section 3. That the Planning Director of said City shalt, upon the effective date of this ordinance, amend the zoning Map of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to show the historic designation, in an overlay manner. Section 4. That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be, and the same are hereby repealed. Section 5. That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid. Section 6. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon passage on second and final reading. PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final reading on this the day of , 200_. ATTEST MAYOR City Clerk First Reading Second Reading 2 ORD NO. 50-05 File Number: 2005-177-COA-HPB Petition Name: The Sewell C.Biggs House A. City of Delray Beach Comprehensive Plan as Existed on 07/19/05. B. City of Delray Beach Land Development Regulations as Existed on 07/19/05. C. City of Delray Beach Zoning District Map as Existed on 07/19/05. D. City of Delray Beach Future Land Use Map as Existing on 07/19/05. Are Entered Into the Record. ITEM DATE NUMBER DESCRIPTION OF ITEM ENTERED IN FILE Certificate of Appropriateness Application 04/22/05 Designation Report 04/22/05 Historic Preservation Board Staff Report 05/04/05 Notice of Public Hearing —Public Notice 06/01/05 Notice of Public Hearing for Publication 06/02/05 Courtesy Notice 06/01/05 Historic Preservation Board Staff Report 06/15/05 City Commission Documentation 07/05/05 Resume Briefs: 07/19/05 a. Warren Adams, Historic Preservation Planner RESUME BRIEF OF WARREN ADAMS Current Title: Historic Preservation Planner Professional Affiliations: Member of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Education: Currently writing PhD thesis on Architectural History of Georgian Mansion Houses in Paisley, Scotland, 1700-1830 University of Paisley, Scotland Master of Arts(with distinction) in Conservation Studies University of York, England Bachelor of Science in Land Economics University of Paisley, Scotland Construction Management Credits Glasgow College of Building & Printing, Scotland Experience: Oct. 2004-Present Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach, Florida Sep. 2003-Oct. 2004 Townscape Heritage Initiative Project Manager, North Somerset Council, Weston-super-Mare, England Jul. 2002-Sep.2003 Project Manager, Strathclyde Building Preservation Trust, Glasgow, Scotland Sep. 2001-Jul. 2002 Heritage Planner, Historic Scotland, Edinburgh, Scotland Jan. 2001-Sep. 2001 Project Manager, Addyman & Kay Building Historians & Archaeologists, Paisley, Scotland Sep. 1999-Sep. 2000 Estates Valuation Surveyor East Renfrewshire Council, Paisley, Scotland Jun. 1989-Sep. 1999 Property Valuation Surveyor Renfrewshire Valuation Joint Board, Paisley, Scotland Work Related Affiliations: Jan. 2005-Present Disaster Management Planning Group Jan. 2003-Sep. 2003 Policy advisor to the RICS in Scotland on preservation policy Aug. 2003 Delegate on Georgian Group Study Tour of Country Mansions Apr. 2003 Delegate on the National Trust for Scotland Little Houses Improvement Scheme Symposium Oct. 1999-Oct.2000 Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings Group Organizer, Yorkshire, England f ORDINANCE NO. 50-05 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, DESIGNATING THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE, LOCATED AT 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AS A LOCAL HISTORIC SITE; PROVIDING FOR THE AMENDMENT OF THE "ZONING MAP OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, APRIL 2005"; PROVIDING A GENERAL REPEALER CLAUSE, A SAVING CLAUSE, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach provides for the designation and protection of historic sites; and WHEREAS, Erskine H. Courtenay and Virginia W. Courtenay, as property owners, have nominated the property described herein to be designated as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach held a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property as a local historic site; and WHEREAS, on June 15, 2005, the Historic Board of the City of Delray Beach recommended 7 to 0 that the property described herein be designated a local historic site; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach adopts the findings in the Planning and Zoning Staff Report; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach finds the ordinance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach has conducted a duly noticed public hearing in regard to the designation of the property described herein as a local historic site. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the recitations set forth above are incorporated herein. Section 2. That the following described property in the City of Delray Beach, Florida, is hereby designated as a local historic site in accordance with and under the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to-wit: Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Section 3. That the Planning Director of said City shall, upon the effective date of this ordinance, amend the zoning Map of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, to show the historic designation, in an overlay manner. Section 4. That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be, and the same are hereby repealed. Section 5. That should any section or provision of this ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder hereof as a whole or part thereof other than the part declared to be invalid. Section 6. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon passage on second and final reading. PASSED AND ADOPTED in regular session on second and final reading on this the day of , 200_. ATTEST MAYOR City Clerk First Reading Second Reading 2 ORD NO. 50-05 Designation Report Historic Preservation Board Delray Beach, Florida The Sewell C . Biggs House Table of Contents I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. NOT APPLICABLE IV. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VIII. ATTACHMENTS Report Prepared By: Dorothy W. Patterson 1206 NE Second Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 (561) 278-2191 (home) 274-9578 (Archives) 717-3425 (cell) E-mail summerpatt@iearthlink.net Date of Report: April 20, 2005 Name of Owners: Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay 212 Seabreeze Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33483 2 I. General Information Address The Sewell C. Biggs House, named for its original owner, is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue within the city limits of Delray Beach, Florida. Legal Description Lot 21 and the west 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Location Lots 21 and 22 are at the end of Seabreeze Avenue. A driveway at this point leads to the front entrance of the Courtenay home. The lots are bounded by Lot 26 of Ocean Breeze Estates on the south and Vista Del Mar Drive South on the north. At the time of construction in 1955 the front entrance faced Vista Del Mar Drive South. This area is on the barrier island between the Intra-coastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean. Zoning Single Family Residential Classification for Designation We believe that the Sewell C. Biggs House, designed by esteemed mid- century modern architect, Paul Rudolph, meets the criteria for both architectural and cultural significance for the reasons described in the following pages of the report. 3 II. Location Map To be provided by City of Delray Beach. III District Inventory Not applicable 4 IV. Historical and Cultural Significance Before 1895 the lots where the Sewell C. Biggs House is located were part of a semitropical wilderness between the coastal ridge and a swampy morass. Less than two blocks away from the lots the coastal ridge begins. The first construction known in the area was the Orange Grove House of Refuge built by the U.S. Life Saving Service (precursor to the Coast Guard) in 1876. The former site of the House of Refuge is a short walk from the Briggs House. The Refuge keeper's son, Charles Pierce, described the land around the Refuge House as follows: The house... was built on a broad flat that ran back from the open sand beach to the higher ridge behind the house...At the Orange Grove it was covered with a thick growth of saw palmetto. The flat was covered with sea oats and scattered bunches of stunted seagrape and cocoplum. This flat extended north two and one-half miles and ended at the caves; to the south it stretched for nearly four miles ... To the west, commencing at the foot of the palmetto-covered ridge, was a deep swamp of tall sawgrass with numerous small channels turning about its eastern side. The morass was about half a mile wide and extended from Lake Worth to Boca Raton; west of it were pinewoods reaching back as far as one could see." The Pierce family encountered deer, bear and heard panthers screaming in the night. They killed the bears for food. After settlement by Americans of European descent began, the area was used for farming such crops as strawberries, pineapples, mangoes and tomatoes. Beginning with the mid-1920's Florida Real Estate Boom, the land became more valuable for residential housing. Or as Adolf Hofman said in one of his letters home to Germany, "Since Delray is growing and the lots fetch colossal prices, I will divide my land between canal and railroad into lots." One of first the farmers in the area, Adolf Hofman developed the Ocean Breeze Estates subdivision adjoining Delray Beach Esplanade, in 1937. Local attorney Ernest Simon recalls that in the late 1930's and early 1940's when he was delivering the De/ray Beach News on his bicycle, there were only a few houses in the area. Delray Beach Esplanade, the subdivision where the Briggs House is located, was platted in 1938 by H. H. and Charlotte Wellenbrink and Williard and Billie Waters. The Waters were 5 well-known in Delray Beach. Wiiiard Waters was a building contractor who had graduated from Delray High School. His family lived at 222 N. Ocean and farmed land on the barrier island in the early years of the 20th century. Waters was also active in city politics and civic clubs. After World War II, building in the neighborhood began in earnest. Tom Woolbright, who went into the building business for himself in 1949,recalls spending the 1947 hurricane in a house in the neighborhood. He said the area was pretty well built up by then and that Willard Waters built many of the houses. Mr. Woolbright remembers that H.H. Wellenbrink was "the money man" who paid for improvements such as building roads, filling land, and paying engineering fees for the plat. Roy Simon, native of Delray Beach, was an apprentice architect in the 1950s for local architect, Ken Jacobson. He recalls that Vista del Mar (Delray Beach Esplanade) was fairly built up by then. After he saw the Paul Rudolph designed house under construction, he and other architects were enthusiastic about the chance of designing contemporary housing. However, he said, "I seemed to keep drawing nice cottages." There were many important clients for houses in the neighborhood such as CEO's of nationally known corporations, famous professional golfers and prominent Delray Beach citizens. The clients loved the smallness and "laid-back" atmosphere of Delray Beach. But evidently they did not have the artistic sensibilities of Sewell C. Biggs and did not request avant garde contemporary designs. James Sinks, a local building contractor, constructed architect Paul Rudolph's design. According to Ernie Simon, Sinks had a reputation for being a "good builder." Jim Sinks father, Irwin J. Sinks, was also a builder originally from Champaign, Illinois. During World War I he went to work for the U.S. Government and was sent to Charleston, S.C. to build soldiers' barracks. In Charleston he roomed with Fred J. Schrader from Delray Beach. Schrader was the first builder in Delray with architectural training. He came to town in 1911 and built the town's first jail, the Cromer Block on Atlantic Avenue and the original part of the Presbyterian Church on Gleason Street. Schrader encouraged Sinks to come to Delray. In 1922 after another assignment in Miami, the Sinks family moved to Delray. The Sinks, father and son, quintessential Delray builders of their time, had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 6 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. Jim built the Atha Building which replaced the Cromer Building. Laura Sinks Britt said in her book, My Gold Coast, "My father had become a builder of more structures on Atlantic Avenue than any other one contractor and Jim added his score." Today some of the "nice cottages," which fit gently into subdivision-sized lots on the short winding streets of the neighborhood, are being torn down to make way for large estate style homes. At present we do not know 'the exact circumstances of how Sewell C. Biggs came to build a house in Delray Beach and chose Paul Rudolph as his architect. He has been described as "enigmatic" and not easy to know. A biography of his life is in the process at this time. The curator at the Sewell C. Biggs Museum in Dover, Delaware, said Biggs owned the house about six years. The Delray Beach City Directory lists him as the owner at the address for about nine years. Randy Grover, the curator, was asked to present a retrospective of Biggs life to the museum board when Mr. Biggs died suddenly in 2003 at age 88. Grover said he felt that the story of the house in Delray Beach was a high point of his presentation. The reason for this was that Biggs was known for his collection of 18th and 19th century American art. The house signaled the beginning of a turn toward the 20th century. In fact Sewell Bigg's vision was for his collection to cover the entire range of American art. Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. In 1937 he took a trip around the world that had an enduring impact on the rest of his life. After the trip he was interested in international exchange and began to sponsor foreign students for one-year scholarships at the University of Delaware. A serious collector of art, he was also involved in historical preservation and art conservation. Biggs collection of American fine and decorative art has been described as "elegant, wonderful, pristine, remarkable, impressive, and an incredible journey ranging from Colonial portraiture to the Hudson River School." With his vision and eye for quality, Biggs spent most of his life on his American art collection. In 1998 the Biggs Museum of American Art opened in Dover to house his collection which includes Delaware and 7 Delaware Valley fine and decorative arts. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American fine art and decorative art gems. That same year Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The title of an exhibit at the Biggs Museum of American Art says it best --"Artful Living: The Legacy of Sewell C. Biggs." Mr. Biggs sold his house at 212 Seabreeze about 1970 to a New York lawyer and his wife, Richard and Alice McAvoy. Evidently the McAvoy's did not have much time in the house because a Webb Brothers Real Estate information sheet is headed Estate of Richard McAvoy. (See attachments) Reference No. 2 on the sheet cites a merit award, medium house class (600-2800 sq. ft.), given in June 1959 by House & Home,-an architecture magazine. The fourth and present owners of the house, Virginia and Erskine Courtenay, bought the house in 1973. Well-known Delray Beach Realtor, Pat Patterson, showed the house. Before becoming a real estate salesman for Ben Adam's Realty, Patterson was known for his pharmacy, his photography, and his volunteer work as a ham radio operator during World War II. Virginia Courtenay says that she "fell in love with the light, being up in the trees, and the architecture. She already greatly admired the work of Paul Rudolph. Mrs. Courtenay's grandfather was a builder in Chicago. She attended the Art Institute of Chicago and has owned an interior design business in Delray Beach for more than 25 years. Erskine Courtenay agreed to the purchase because Virginia loved the house, and he loved her. Paul Rudolph has been sometimes criticized for elevating style at the expense of function and some changes had to be made for practical-living. Mr. And Mrs. Courtenay have always wanted and have strived to keep the house as close to the original design as possible. Sensitivity to the original design while making changes has always been an important aspect of planning. In addition Rudolph's Florida houses had been designed just prior to the time when air-conditioning became a standard feature of south Florida homes. Some of the innovative design features meant to ameliorate the Florida climate worked against the efficiency of air-conditioning. For example, in the back of the house paneling was installed over the aluminum louver windows because the strength of the wind blowing against the louvers had been a problem at times, and after air-conditioning was installed, the problems continued. The windows in the front of the original part of the 8 house look the same even though they have been replaced. Paul Rudolph drew a plan for an addition and approved the changes to the house in 1980. (See attachments). However, Rudolph was not aware of the need to raise the house 4 feet because of a new law which dictated that the house must be 7.5 feet above mean sea level. (Flooding of the lot during the rainy season had occurred at times after original construction in 1955.) Local architect Bob Currie was then hired to plan lifting the house and the addition in 1980-81.. The interior of the addition matches the interior of the original house. The original hedges, trees and landscaping remain the same. (See attachments) 9 V. Architectural Significance The architect of the Sewell C. Bigg House in Delray Beach, Paul Rudolph (1918-1997), was an important influence on American modernism in the mid-twentieth century. He was a Kentucky native and son of a Methodist minister. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design and Engineering at the Library of Congress, Rudolph drew on many influences for his Florida work. He was open to new and experimental methods of construction-- stretching structural possibilities of materials to their limit's while celebrating their static and aesthetic possibilities, spatial richness, complexity and inter-relationship of the interiors and exteriors... of his buildings, their site, their natural surroundings and their climate. His appreciation of these qualities in both modern architecture and in the vernacular buildings of his native South had been fostered by E. Walter Burkhardt under whom he studied architecture at Auburn University (then Alabama Polytechnic Institute). Burkhart recommended his student to Walter Gropius who was instrumental in Rudolph's admission to Harvard Graduate School of Design. Burkhart was one of the most energetic and enlightened directors of the Historic American Building Survey, now one of the most frequently consulted collections in the Library of Congress. Mr. Peatross wrote the preface to Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. He is well-acquainted with Rudolph's work because the architect bequeathed his professional papers and drawings to the Library and funded the Center of Architecture, Design and-Engineering there. Peatross' accolades include the statement: "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence of the second half of the 20th century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation." His assessment of Rudolph's Florida buildings is that the "innovative, adventurous and elegant Florida buildings launched Rudolph's career." Petross further finds in working with drawings of many famous architects in the Library of Congress Collections that "with the exception of Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the 'speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of 10 • • Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the `speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of lessons, ideas, and possibilities that will speak to and inspire generations to come." Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses, visited the present owners in Delray Beach. The Courtenays are listed in the Acknowledgments on page 13. The Sewell C. Biggs House is featured in the "Independent Practice" section on page 183 where the house is compared to the "award-winning Cohen House...(1953-1955)" on Siesta Key. The authors' opening statement is: "While coming of age as architects along the west coast of Florida in a landscape increasingly homogenized by air-conditioning and prolific land development, Paul Rudolph's architecture stood alone in our eyes as a rigorous counter-argument." Domin and King met in the graduate program at the Georgia Institute of Technology. After discovering their shared interest in Rudolph's work, they made their avocation the searching out of buildings designed by Rudolph across the state of Florida. The authors' conclude that "Rudolph's early work in Florida over a 20-year period was a necessary testing round for a multi-layered design methodology of a complex career. The fact that the architect's work was widely publicized at the time played a significant role in national recognition of Rudolph's work. The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism. The beautiful photographs are seen today in a bittersweet light as we are now all -- too aware of what happens when a vastly enlarged population of affluent Americans descends on all too few miles of pristine beaches." The Delray Beach Historical Society featured the Sewell C. Biggs House as one of the components in its "The Art of Architecture in South Florida" exhibit in 1989. One of the displays described how orientation, sun, heat and ventilation were addressed by the design. (See attachments) 11 VI. Statement of Significance The owners, Esrkine H. & Virginia W. Courtenay, wish to nominate their property for the following reason: "After living in it since 1973, are very much like those of the original owner, Mr. Sewell C. Biggs. It has maintained its sense of elegance in its simplicity and its feeling of"dateless" architecture which stands the test of time. In 1981 we raised the original house four feet to add a lower floor which now houses a library, guest bedroom and laundry room. This was accomplished with the collaboration of local architect, Robert Currie, who was interested in the house for its historical importance." The style of the home is a design, unique to the neighborhood and to Delray Beach, of the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in 20th century American design field. It is the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings. It is representative of 20th century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving buildings in Delray Beach. Other reasons for designation are that respect shown for the characteristics of our property will draw attention to the need for preservation in Delray Beach's older neighborhoods; the hope that local designation will afford some protection for the house in the future,and to set an example in a neighborhood being pressured by demolitions. In summary the Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving and promoting American fine and decorative arts. His collection spans the more than 200 years that the United States has existed as a country. The property has been followed under Historical and Cultural Significance in this Designation Report throughout the entire history of Delray Beach after 1876. Further it reflects social and economic trends in the community and is indicative of the winter colony of artistic and socially prominent people which has existed in Delray Beach since the 1920's. Since the house at 212 Seabreeze fits comfortably into the history of Delray Beach, and the original owner proved to have the "vision and eye for quality" of a major American art collector, there seems no doubt that the house at 212 Seabreeze has historical and cultural significance. 12 The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II and embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism and innovative uses of new materials. It is an example of the work of a leading American architect whose testing round was Florida. The design is both a significant innovation and adaptation to the South Florida environment. 13 VII. Bibliography & Sources Britt, Laura Sinks, My Gold Coast. Palatka, Florida: Brittany House Publishers, 1984. Delray Beach Historical Society Archives. Delray Beach City Directories, 1953-54, 1955, 1957,1961,1963,1966, 1973, 1976,1979, Miller, Polk, Price & Lee. Domin, Christopher & King, Joseph. Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. New York, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2002. Hofman, Charles, Letters from Linton. Hollywood, Florida: Legacy Press, 2004. Palm Beach County Records, Palm Beach County Courthouse, West Palm Beach, Florida. Pierce, Charles W., Pioneer Life in Southeast Florida. Ed. Donald Walter Curl. Coral Gables: University of Miami Press, 1970. Interviews: April, 2005 Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay, property owners. Randolph Grover, Curator, Biggs Museum of American Art Roy Simon, Architect, Delray Beach native Ernest Simon, Attorney, Delray Beach native Tom Woolbright, retired builder, Delray Beach native 14 Attachments 1. Photographs Attachments 1 through 9 2. Survey, house plans Attachments 10 through 13 3. Chain of Title/City Directories Attachment 14 through 15 4. Webb Brothers Info. Sheet Attachment 16 5. Art of Architecture Attachments 17 through 25 DBHS Exhibit 15 Attachment Delray Beach City Directory listings for 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. And 212 Seabreeze. 1953-1954- no listing (widow of John E. Biggs, Jr, Cary H., was living in GS) 1955-Biggs Sewell C. —no occupation listed- 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. 1957-same listing 1961—same address 1963-street address changes to 212 Seabreeze ( Vista del Mar re-numbered) Biggs listed rem to Delaware 1966 listed with rem to Delaware 1970—no listing for S.C. Biggs (Frank E & Dorothy J.Biggs-- Listed in Highland Beach) Richard McAvoy & Alice C. listed at 212 Seabreeze-- occupation given as lawyer (NY) 1973 212 Seabreeze is listed as vacant 1976- Courtenay, EH. & Virginia W., listed at 212 Seabreeze Ave. EH emp. Sterry Real Estate, Virginia— emp.. R.R. Robinson antiques 1979- Courtenay, Erskine H (Virginia W) assoc DeMarco & Sons Realty, Inc. h 212 Seabreeze av Virginia Interiors, Virginia W. Courtenay pres 706 E. Atlantic av, etc. Yk hnne-r\ 16 RUDOLPH HOUSE TIMELINE Delray Beach Esplanade subdivision Lot 21&West 35 feet of Lot 22(Unless noted otherwise) 212 Seabreeze Ave.,Delray Beach,FL 33483-7022 YEAR PATE EVENT CONSID- REFERENCE SELLER BUYER ERATION• PBC CTIISE 1938 24 Jan Esplanade subdivision established,bounded by Intracoastal Waterway on the East,Vista Del Mar Drive on the North, Andrews Avenue on the East and Ocean Breeze Estates on the South.... OWNERS:Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK&husband H.W.WELLENBRINK& Willard M.WATERS&wife Willie E.WATERS Plat bk 18,page 39 1941 18 Apr Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK George C.MARSTED $100.00 DEEDS BK 627,P389 1945 20 Mar George C.MARSTED Stanley M.BABSON $100.00 DEEDS BK713,P546 1952 22 Apr Florin E.GRIER,widow Marie R Mc COLLON $10.00 DEEDS BK984,P69 E 30'Lot 19,all 20,all 21&W 35'Lot 22 1955 13 Apr Marie R.McCOLLOM,widow Sewell C.BIGGS,single $10.00 DEEDS BK1089,P463& of Middletown,Delaware 1956 House built,2 stories,2938 total square feet with 2600 under air OFFICIAL RECORDS BK2129,P810& 1963 22 Nov Sewell C.BIGGS,single Richard McAVOY $10.00 OFFICIAL RECORDS of New Castle County,Delaware of New York City BK939,P379& 1971 1 Aug Alice C.McAVOY,executrix:, Arno W.McGRAW& OFFICIAL RECORDS estate of Richard McAVOY wife,Helen C. $6750 BK1921,P805& of Boca Raton,Florida 1973 1 Mar Arno W.Mc GRAW&wife Helen C. Erskine H.COURTENAY Jr$53,000 price OFFICIAL RECORDS &wife,Virginia W. $159.00 BK2129,P810& of Goshen,Kentucky *CONSIDERATION:Usually contains amount of document stamps paid the county or sales price,where noted.Document stamp rates: Before 1957—S1/$1,000 of price_ July 1,1963—$3/$1,000.Oct. 1,1979—$4/$1,000. &Photocopied and attached Researcher: Richard F.Robinson _ Legacy Scribe,LLC,Boynton Beach,Florida 561.7422150 19 April 2005 • �a ,._ .. , ., n �,, .r`ti"� . . ..., / v --.✓"L fir \.- • _ �-( L i'l � h /-113,.„ �� ) 1 ' f'...,a,F r Yz 5 r �. k z�"r 1' `f J e t 1 t II t sY F p�\ 1, t111,. / .. '£s e:tit 4-;-- - en-- 4ti't t'tv,t;���i� J"§.,-'-.. F k �. ' )I;- ., .. —..'.., 1 T` V f t3, ' _ I G tam--$' t - 6 `£u t - r N i t gtS i tE� ''4i-�410.�4scl ,tf''sf` . �r»��-�s �.V°' 1 - t },. `tom Y 1'S• 'i-k: 1 r£a'zl`t' s§- r1.. , i- '`r3r"��.', s w�+;--- .irwt.-r- T:l'=-:,'.z',,'-,-:,''.V S-'S 14 Y b ^F�'A _ Y 11 .4` `t Yak ,- 4-1Y \AI 1 , Kz.y} ,. a 1.4 4 t 4t s"i`t*fr 2-', 4 i ', ,a-1.0 ?} 1 y _. sr`"ri ,cif,,,, `5'`a t t�ut`,7, .1_ ' ,It .+. ,q '1 -, _. __ ' _ c: ,, / t•� iJ _1 4 S^ :,3 i ,V� .1 . 3 : f .- p,„_,;).:i. •- - : ,.. i ' 3 £�' "' i• ",7Jv �.�1 '"`n-ram ` � S fi N • Al 1 c thmeri -4--- I Drac�x� IDy Pc+u l Rudo l P h Cvp edrOm , -C F."Pa Lk 1 -Rud of pin, he, for� Jot A5 r , )110 J . r • , i. , • t, W. !'v.fl- - ., , - ,..t.,i.': - , et ...10144 „,,=7,,,,...., . ..1.7,... .. .,.. : .. . 1 .i_, .7::..t. .- ts.i4‘..:„..„,..,%.,..,,..ya. ....,...„ ...::.......,:,.....::..,...''......„..„+,...„..,,,::1...5._.:,,,.t,,...,„.„..,i....:;;;,..„.,,,,,___...._. ..,,.. .:,..4.(..A.„.4. ..:.,..E .. 0, ..:. i ,i, .., . _ . , ,. -_-.',.'',•.:144iff.1i i,..,.7 ---'-':---:=--:---z-4:-;'--•iragi•--. '� T .� . - ! ftom �. t 'a... ` Y — kd { i -mac: ' '^ „ 4 1 1\t: _--- ; - r 1 } f Y" • s. • t tY r� f=.8 _ _ } ... ' -� -vr._ -e�'. +,•,;;-.. sy.L•ts. , ..' �-, ,R $ '2.. g• «..-t ,Y.''"t „-;-.mac. - ._s.'ii ,: � w � z-n x �se--r'2Y�� � 4'a_ k �3-"z .v�-`F ,z�•' -[�� E r `4'fi! r a. -, f' --.y -.- y k3-{ T "& --°' } .= . -;.1, -xr- i T fi-' - 4.i hi I' ,r� .4 . y-s.+.L .'y +;,,,- Cj�,- 1 "Sty �-, 4'3,. '= e s • _ "� * - 4r� r i- �! • > -f-.t, .�,' T ,'�' .:• -.�'^•-,.-'4 ,fit a�``:�rr�3-« Y�Y* � r P. aR .Rn r t--5 r • pho-t-acycz).?1,, Ia55-5b Copy oF- Ezro, s%\ o1\c\ t .�\phoi-olZvdo\0h,me• Plorlda uouse S• '' r • ... 0 1 ' • • �n • r ; d T \ : ::—"•:•';:•;:!:,:•-•-=':.4.41*::1"4:iaitittra;•Mii;%•: :::'•;•. •;•';''':'-:..:. :•..!'••••• ..-:• -.: . • • r T 0 .Irv. �-a : L: . �, ` t . a x i �. %/ j • te T�7 ¢ E /yam f �a -• a �. 1%. • ./* Ott d�IA•� 'I? t y;x -,•c.1 - • n-t-ex-t orphod ogrcz �h b y 5Zr S--oiler', tQs Co GD p c1. C-r�m �ce l tl �uc�o l}�17 -1 h� Co rt a.c- "- -°uses . • • :_.ff.,:-..e.-X,:--e•:':,-:.7.1--;.:.-4:*4i4.-;'...1:1,11. ,jam - :• . 1` i. ,.,' .•• _-- -,%=ate - .rM`A* ,,,i, . i. _,t.1..i.-i,.N..,-0,.,_,•__-.i--_.:_;._•..._-f_.,._....-.:(,-;r:_.t.,2:_-1.:''. .." ti .,1. L \ r' •x- 1 8 - _. _ =_ . ... • 3 "s, 4 %45r .tilt £ ♦�,.-• o - • 'tt•9 im• - .t t'N "4 ,> „roc ,�,' • • am— ,�- =-ram } -,a-- '- �,w ..a.. s"' "f` M- •_,.K,: . .1KSi� Yy .rTs.J�` .a•^-n� o "'�J � �, I3 gLTy6M Y4 . a r .i1 • I '- � �', 1 ° ��� • ` J `" t -d r - ! {fit{-,t . ,.s '�'' ""° . • --- •�� ! _ ' - - 0.) .-.tom 144. ...' T_: s ` 1 {t ♦ l d \ ..c�a.�' --- • l �i� . ,�r:�ra -, "yam • cKmeN-1-- — ' 4- CJu5c . o c'(3 LLZf'd p1•(1c) _ A{) '-\ 1 IQ) 2ooG . fi 5`-�'?"4 Z l'",t k f' --t -`Yt'*r, '{ 2'"fz� 3y �'a^€ "`{�. ^� :. "¢ J - C .,vq - - s s ,Z a •-tg. _y+,.t'`�-.- l r., ,zit; 1,1 " am 2:. z..•.- ,; i S( - -i r �-' T- Y _# r /i rk'uhk5'•� d'�S}i L;. ?- n s Z 5 ask t ` . a si.1 4 ?y,.. ? -f 1- ' i 1 F ; ' }t 'e.'a z o r r• { ,t 1--:` c'ysl .C -.._. i :.r•-, dam : _ .:i,•;*,,,,"'� -- -, z hY -4 r `x _ --" 3 4. - _. sramCz ft" 7 ra w i- s�5 vr }'t _� ` , ,i , �3 W T)t s t?+ { . 3 y 5 t ot3 y' w 1 s x ss Y n v�,_ a 0 } V • • j X t t a�# } f fit si z j "7 - 1. f - .y-- ' .'i'•- `mot ^� r.S--�x,,1; -' `�` L-..,..A.„„...„,,....„.„,,,,....,,,,,,-..,---,,,,,,,am -yY 7' ' r C ; -�-i, l�,- �'a '' i '' 'z- `.1 .t- i3f (VL ��.: t i 'C - F-4x ;xi 1 .i�''i' `. sak` {"' i ,} . -4 a'•" ems- �-�,.• O N i-_-414fiv--;,--.,-..,,,,,,-4-%,----, k '.; 1,13.-----Tp-,;_9_,,_,•_- -- -,-.-,..ti.,.: , T.,..--.;--1.t.t.,. .;::!•„,,::ot,...,,..,=4...4....,±, ...,,,,,,,,I,„,,,... .y.„,„. , ....,.._. , ,... ,_ . ., „ ..: _ :_ :. .'�� - _ �k� � �yy++''- -ii- . ,i_l�'4 J • S : 5 -� .sue t' •• - ^x5 K#-t =,4. --- .R' -4- J L k Ee- �...r y ---�_ .`L _ # `C� : ''1`{yr� . # , #c.3 4j_ ,,7�'2t'� ..-WFe y: - _g`•3 -',-•-:-. k - -4 g V :,:.. :-„,_,,.,;,,,,-:,-„,_,-„,,k;L'•:z-fil:'- _ _ F' ` -ski z,. " < r- ' r v-ca .n � •^ --1:1 _ tea#- vas • LE Y..-�' ♦ ""'- _ - ' �` ram+• .... •-.kR,4 to rs 4 f s 4 i v*, '4'> ..tt•"', ✓ Ti 37:1 `. -§ .3 ' 'i �z s� T•z'r-.ice 'fr#_a� _ • _ 4 s!' Y"'�x Lei, s - - •4 y • �. _vK - a''3k *�ss, '3tI_ * 7:is �L.€-.-' :f,�, b(` • �,.b� •- ei,'�f"''.� i r1,iY _„_...f � :�� - l,r �� -';.s -�F - - ` Y/�f�Jzi''`-.'tom • t, x • • • • i --17--4E war iR 4 USES t2ff- /iGff. WH IGH nLOGK H �uN uT ,ALLOW J4J MOvnmE NT LOuvE.iS PRovvr rLUS Lk9f b • 1, - U •_ ISOLAT HEA.T6ffKIEKNTING AK 'D UGH INP LAUNtK1 3 1 OH LIVIN& S ACES. e • , t , , II= j li p .7 P IGNffP Fol M,kYIMUM YEW-ILA-IN cV ,, UNnriN Nn THKOU&H THE HOME . } f Designation Report Historic Preservation Board Delray Beach, Florida The Sewell C . Biggs House Table of Contents I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. NOT APPLICABLE IV. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VIII. ATTACHMENTS Report Prepared By: Dorothy W. Patterson 1206 NE Second Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 (561) 278-2191 (home) 274-9578 (Archives) 717-3425 (cell) E-mail summerpatt@earthlink.net Date of Report: April 20, 2005 Name of Owners: Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay 212 Seabreeze Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33483 I. General Information Address The Sewell C. Biggs House, named for its original owner, is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue within the city limits of Delray Beach, Florida. Legal Description Lot 21 and the west 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Location Lots 21 and 22 are at the end of Seabreeze Avenue. A driveway at this point leads to the front entrance of the Courtenay home. The lots are bounded by Lot 26 of Ocean Breeze Estates on the south and Vista Del Mar Drive South on the north. At the time of construction in 1955 the front entrance faced Vista Del Mar Drive South. This area is on the barrier island between the Intra-coastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean. Zoning Single Family Residential Classification for Designation We believe that the Sewell C. Biggs House, designed by esteemed mid- century modern architect, Paul Rudolph, meets the criteria for both architectural and cultural significance for the reasons described in the following pages of the report. 3 II. Location Map To be provided by City of Delray Beach. III District Inventory Not applicable 4 IV. Historical and Cultural Significance Before 1895 the lots where the Sewell C. Biggs House is located were part of a semitropical wilderness between the coastal ridge and a swampy morass. Less than two blocks away from the lots the coastal ridge begins. The first construction known in the area was the Orange Grove House of Refuge built by the U.S. Life Saving Service (precursor to the Coast Guard) in 1876. The former site of the House of Refuge is a short walk from the Briggs House. The Refuge keeper's son, Charles Pierce, described the land around the Refuge House as follows: The house... was built on a broad flat that ran back from the open sand beach to the higher ridge behind the house...At the Orange Grove it was covered with a thick growth of saw palmetto. The flat was covered with sea oats and scattered bunches of stunted seagrape and cocoplum. This flat extended north two and one-half miles and ended at the caves; to the south it stretched for nearly four miles ... To the west, commencing at the foot of the palmetto-covered ridge, was a deep swamp of tall sawgrass with numerous small channels turning about its eastern side. The morass was about half a mile wide and extended from Lake Worth to Boca Raton; west of it were pinewoods reaching back as far as one could see." The Pierce family encountered deer, bear and heard panthers screaming in the night. They killed the bears for food. After settlement by Americans of European descent began, the area was used for farming such crops as strawberries, pineapples, mangoes and tomatoes. Beginning with the mid-1920's Florida Real Estate Boom, the land became more valuable for residential housing. Or as Adolf Hofman said in one of his letters home to Germany, "Since Delray is growing and the lots fetch colossal prices, I will divide my land between canal and railroad into lots." One of first the farmers in the area, Adolf Hofman developed the Ocean Breeze Estates subdivision adjoining Delray Beach Esplanade, in 1937. Local attorney Ernest Simon recalls that in the late 1930's and early 1940's when he was delivering the De/ray Beach News on his bicycle, there were only a few houses in the area. Delray Beach Esplanade, the subdivision where the Briggs House is located, was platted in 1938 by H. H. and Charlotte Wellenbrink and Williard and Billie Waters. The Waters were 5 well-known in Delray Beach. Wiiiard Waters was a building contractor who had graduated from Delray High School. His family lived at 222 N. Ocean and farmed land on the barrier island in the early years of the 20th century. Waters was also active in city politics and civic clubs. After World War II, building in the neighborhood began in earnest. Tom Woolbright, who went into the building business for himself in 1949,recalls spending the 1947 hurricane in a house in the neighborhood. He said the area was pretty well built up by then and that Willard Waters built many of the houses. Mr. Woolbright remembers that H.H. Wellenbrink was "the money man" who paid for improvements such as building roads, filling land, and paying engineering fees for the plat. Roy Simon, native of Delray Beach, was an apprentice architect in the 1950s for local architect, Ken Jacobson. He recalls that Vista del Mar (Delray Beach Esplanade) was fairly built up by then. After he saw the Paul Rudolph designed house under construction, he and other architects were enthusiastic about the chance of designing contemporary housing. However, he said, "I seemed to keep drawing nice cottages." There were many important clients for houses in the neighborhood such as CEO's of nationally known corporations, famous professional golfers and prominent Delray Beach citizens. The clients loved the smallness and "laid-back" atmosphere of Delray Beach. But evidently they did not have the artistic sensibilities of Sewell C. Biggs and did not request avant garde contemporary designs. James Sinks, a local building contractor, constructed architect Paul Rudolph's design. According to Ernie Simon, Sinks had a reputation for being a "good builder." Jim Sinks father, Irwin J. Sinks, was also a builder originally from Champaign, Illinois. During World War I he went to work for the U.S. Government and was sent to Charleston, S.C. to build soldiers' barracks. In Charleston he roomed with Fred J. Schrader from Delray Beach. Schrader was the first builder in Delray with architectural training. He came to town in 1911 and built the town's first jail, the Cromer Block on Atlantic Avenue and the original part of the Presbyterian Church on Gleason Street. Schrader encouraged Sinks to come to Delray. In 1922 after another assignment in Miami, the Sinks family moved to Delray. The Sinks, father and son, quintessential Delray builders of their time, had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 6 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. Jim built the Atha Building which replaced the Cromer Building. Laura Sinks Britt said in her book, My Gold Coast, "My father had become a builder of more structures on Atlantic Avenue than any other one contractor and Jim added his score." Today some of the "nice cottages," which fit gently into subdivision-sized lots on the short winding streets of the neighborhood, are being torn down to make way for large estate style homes. At present we do not know the exact circumstances of how Sewell C. Biggs came to build a house in Delray Beach and chose Paul Rudolph as his architect. He has been described as "enigmatic" and not easy to know. A biography of his life is in the process at this time. The curator at the Sewell C. Biggs Museum in Dover, Delaware, said Biggs owned the house about six years. The Delray Beach City Directory lists him as the owner at the address for about nine years. Randy Grover, the curator, was asked to present a retrospective of Biggs life to the museum board when Mr. Biggs died suddenly in 2003 at age 88. Grover said he felt that the story of the house in Delray Beach was a high point of his presentation. The reason for this was that Biggs was known for his collection of 18th and 19th century American art. The house signaled the beginning of a turn toward the 20th century. In fact Sewell Bigg's vision was for his collection to cover the entire range of American art. Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. In 1937 he took a trip around the world that had an enduring impact on the rest of his life. After the trip he was interested in international exchange and began to sponsor foreign students for one-year scholarships at the University of Delaware. A serious collector of art, he was also involved in historical preservation and art conservation. Biggs collection of American fine and decorative art has been described as "elegant, wonderful, pristine, remarkable, impressive, and an incredible journey ranging from Colonial portraiture to the Hudson River School." With his vision and eye for quality, Biggs spent most of his life on his American art collection. In 1998 the Biggs Museum of American Art opened in Dover to house his collection which includes Delaware and 7 Delaware Valley fine and decorative arts. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American fine art and decorative art gems. That same year Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The title of an exhibit at the Biggs Museum of American Art says it best --"Artful Living: The Legacy of Sewell C. Biggs." Mr. Biggs sold his house at 212 Seabreeze about 1970 to a New York lawyer and his wife, Richard and Alice McAvoy. Evidently the McAvoy's did not have much time in the house because a Webb Brothers Real Estate information sheet is headed Estate of Richard McAvoy. (See attachments) Reference No. 2 on the sheet cites a merit award, medium house class (600-2800 sq. ft.), given in June 1959 by House & Home, an architecture magazine. The fourth and present owners of the house, Virginia and Erskine Courtenay, bought the house in 1973. Well-known Delray Beach Realtor, Pat Patterson, showed the house. Before becoming a real estate salesman for Ben Adam's Realty, Patterson was known for his pharmacy, his photography, and his volunteer work as a ham radio operator during World War II. Virginia Courtenay says that she "fell in love with the light, being up in the trees, and the architecture. She already greatly admired the work of Paul Rudolph. Mrs. Courtenay's grandfather was a builder in Chicago. She attended the Art Institute of Chicago and has owned an interior design business in Delray Beach for more than 25 years. Erskine Courtenay agreed to the purchase because Virginia loved the house, and he loved her. Paul Rudolph has been sometimes criticized for elevating style at the expense of function and some changes had to be made for practical living. Mr. And Mrs. Courtenay have always wanted and have strived to keep the house as close to the original design as possible. Sensitivity to the original design while making changes has always been an important aspect of planning. In addition Rudolph's Florida houses had been designed just prior to the time when air-conditioning became a standard feature of south Florida homes. Some of the innovative design features meant to ameliorate the Florida climate worked against the efficiency of air-conditioning. For example, in the back of the house paneling was installed over the aluminum louver windows because the strength of the wind blowing against the louvers had been a problem at times, and after air-conditioning was installed, the problems continued. The windows in the front of the original part of the 8 house look the same even though they have been replaced. Paul Rudolph drew a plan for an addition and approved the changes to the house in 1980. (See attachments). However, Rudolph was not aware of the need to raise the house 4 feet because of a new law which dictated that the house must be 7.5 feet above mean sea level. (Flooding of the lot during the rainy season had occurred at times after original construction in 1955.) Local architect Bob Currie was then hired to plan lifting the house and the addition in 1980-81. The interior of the addition matches the interior of the original house. The original hedges, trees and landscaping remain the same. (See attachments) 9 V. Architectural Significance The architect of the Sewell C. Bigg House in Delray Beach, Paul Rudolph (1918-1997), was an important influence on American modernism in the mid-twentieth century. He was a Kentucky native and son of a Methodist minister. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design and Engineering at the Library of Congress, Rudolph drew on many influences for his Florida work. He was open to new and experimental methods of construction-- stretching structural possibilities of materials to their limit's while celebrating their static and aesthetic possibilities, spatial richness, complexity and inter-relationship of the interiors and exteriors... of his buildings, their site, their natural surroundings and their climate. His appreciation of these qualities in both modern architecture and in the vernacular buildings of his native South had been fostered by E. Walter Burkhardt under whom he studied architecture at Auburn University (then Alabama Polytechnic Institute). Burkhart recommended his student to Walter Gropius who was instrumental in Rudolph's admission to Harvard Graduate School of Design. Burkhart was one of the most energetic and enlightened directors of the Historic American Building Survey, now one of the most frequently consulted collections in the Library of Congress. Mr. Peatross wrote the preface to Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. He is well-acquainted with Rudolph's work because the architect bequeathed his professional papers and drawings to the Library and funded the Center of Architecture, Design and Engineering there. Peatross' accolades include the statement: "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence of the second half of the 20th century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation." His assessment of Rudolph's Florida buildings is that the "innovative, adventurous and elegant Florida buildings launched Rudolph's career." Petross further finds in working with drawings of many famous architects in the Library of Congress Collections that "with the exception of Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the 'speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of 10 Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the `speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of lessons, ideas, and possibilities that will speak to and inspire generations to come." Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses, visited the present owners in Delray Beach. The Courtenays are listed in the Acknowledgments on page 13. The Sewell C. Biggs House is featured in the "Independent Practice" section on page 183 where the house is compared to the "award-winning Cohen House...(1953-1955)" on Siesta Key. The authors' opening statement is: "While coming of age as architects along the west coast of Florida in a landscape increasingly homogenized by air-conditioning and prolific land development, Paul Rudolph's architecture stood alone in our eyes as a rigorous counter-argument." Domin and King met in the graduate program at the Georgia Institute of Technology. After discovering their shared interest in Rudolph's work, they made their avocation the searching out of buildings designed by Rudolph across the state of Florida. The authors' conclude that "Rudolph's early work in Florida over a 20-year period was a necessary testing round for a multi-layered design methodology of a complex career. The fact that the architect's work was widely publicized at the time played a significant role in national recognition of Rudolph's work. The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism. The beautiful photographs are seen today in a bittersweet light as we are now all too aware of what happens when a vastly enlarged population of affluent Americans descends on all too few miles of pristine beaches." The Delray Beach Historical Society featured the Sewell C. Biggs House as one of the components in its "The Art of Architecture in South Florida" exhibit in 1989. One of the displays described how orientation, sun, heat and ventilation were addressed by the design. (See attachments) 11 VI. Statement of Significance The owners, Esrkine H. & Virginia W. Courtenay, wish to nominate their property for the following reason: "After living in it since 1973, are very much like those of the original owner, Mr. Sewell C. Biggs. It has maintained its sense of elegance in its simplicity and its feeling of"dateless" architecture which stands the test of time. In 1981 we raised the original house four feet to add a lower floor which now houses a library, guest bedroom and laundry room. This was accomplished with the collaboration of local architect, Robert Currie, who was interested in the house for its historical importance." The style of the home is a design, unique to the neighborhood and to Delray Beach, of the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in 20th century American design field. It is the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings. It is representative of 20th century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving buildings in Delray Beach. Other reasons for designation are that respect shown for the characteristics of our property will draw attention to the need for preservation in Delray Beach's older neighborhoods; the hope that local designation will afford some protection for the house in the future,and to set an example in a neighborhood being pressured by demolitions. In summary the Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving and promoting American fine and decorative arts. His collection spans the more than 200 years that the United States has existed as a country. The property has been followed under Historical and Cultural Significance in this Designation Report throughout the entire history of Delray Beach after 1876. Further it reflects social and economic trends in the community and is indicative of the winter colony of artistic and socially prominent people which has existed in Delray Beach since the 1920's. Since the house at 212 Seabreeze fits comfortably into the history of Delray Beach, and the original owner proved to have the "vision and eye for quality" of a major American art collector, there seems no doubt that the house at 212 Seabreeze has historical and cultural significance. 12 The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II and embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism and innovative uses of new materials. It is an example of the work of a leading American architect whose testing round was Florida. The design is both a significant innovation and adaptation to the South Florida environment. • 13 1 VII. Bibliography & Sources Britt, Laura Sinks, My Gold Coast. Palatka, Florida: Brittany House Publishers, 1984. Delray Beach Historical Society Archives. Delray Beach City Directories, 1953-54, 1955, 1957,1961,1963,1966, 1973, 1976,1979, Miller, Polk, Price & Lee. Domin, Christopher & King, Joseph. Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. New York, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2002. Hofman, Charles, Letters from Linton. Hollywood, Florida: Legacy Press, 2004. Palm Beach County Records, Palm Beach County Courthouse, West Palm Beach, Florida. Pierce, Charles W., Pioneer Life in Southeast Florida. Ed. Donald Walter Curl. Coral Gables: University of Miami Press, 1970. Interviews: April, 2005 Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay, property owners. Randolph Grover, Curator, Biggs Museum of American Art Roy Simon, Architect, Delray Beach native Ernest Simon, Attorney, Delray Beach native Tom Woolbright, retired builder, Delray Beach native 14 I Attachments 1. Photographs Attachments 1 through 9 2. Survey, house plans Attachments 10 through 13 3. Chain of Title/City Directories Attachment 14 through 15 4. Webb Brothers Info. Sheet Attachment 16 5. Art of Architecture Attachments 17 through 25 DBHS Exhibit 15 Attachment Delray Beach City Directory listings for 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. And 212 Seabreeze. 1953-1954- no listing (widow of John E. Biggs, Jr, Cary H., was living in GS) 1955-Biggs Sewell C. -no occupation listed- 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. 1957-same listing 1961-same address 1963-street address changes to 212 Seabreeze ( Vista del Mar re-numbered) Biggs listed rem to Delaware 1966 listed with rem to Delaware 1970-no listing for S.C. Biggs (Frank E & Dorothy J.Biggs-- Listed in Highland Beach) Richard McAvoy & Alice C. listed at 212 Seabreeze-- occupation given as lawyer (NY) 1973 212 Seabreeze is listed as vacant 1976- Courtenay, EH. & Virginia W., listed at 212 Seabreeze Ave. EH emp. Sterry Real Estate, Virginia- emp.. R.R. Robinson antiques 1979- Courtenay, Erskine H (Virginia W) assoc DeMarco & Sons Realty, Inc. h 212 Seabreeze av Virginia Interiors, Virginia W. Courtenay pres 706 E. Atlantic av, etc. A krne,n- -- 16 RUDOLPH HOUSE TIMELINE Delray Beach Esplanade subdivision Lot 21&West 35 feet of Lot 22(Unless noted otherwise) 212 Seabreeze Ave.,Delray Beach,FL 33483-7022 YEAR DATE EVENT CONSID- REFERENCE SELLER BUYER ERATION* PBC CTHSE 1938 24 Jan Esplanade subdivision established,bounded by Intracoastal Waterway on the East,Vista Del Mar Drive on the a North, Andrews Avenue on the East and Ocean Breeze Estates on the South.... OWNERS:Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK&husband H.W.WELLENBRINK& Willard M.WATERS&wife Willie E.WATERS Plat bk 18,page 39 1941 18 Apr Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK George C.MARSTED S100.00 DEEDS BK 627,P389 1945 20 Mar George C.MARSTED Stanley M.BABSON $100.00 DEEDS BK713,P546 1952 22 Apr Florin E.GRIER,widow Marie R.Mc COLLON $10.00 DEEDS BK984,P69 E 30'Lot 19,all 20,all 21&W 35'Lot 22 1955 13 Apr Marie R.McCOLLOM,widow Sewell C.BIGGS,single $10.00 DEEDS BK1089,P463& of Middletown,Delaware 1956 House built,2 stories,2938 total square feet with 2600 under air OFFICIAL RECORDS BK2129,P810& 1963 22 Nov Sewell C.BIGGS,single Richard McAVOY $10.00 OFFICIAL RECORDS of New Castle County,Delaware of New York City BK939,P379& 1971 1 Aug Alice C.McAVOY,executrix, Amo W.McGRAW& OFFICIAL RECORDS estate of Richard McAVOY wife,Helen C. $67.50 BK1921,P805& of Boca Raton,Florida 1973 1 Mar Arno W.Mc GRAW&wife Helen C. Erskine H.COURTENAY Jr S53,000 price OFFICIAL RECORDS &wife,Virginia W. $159.00 BK2129,P810& of Goshen,Kentucky *CONSIDERATION:Usually contains amount of document stamps paid the county or sales price,where noted.Document stamp rates: Before 1957—S1/$1,000 of price. July 1,1963--$3/$1,000.Oct. 1, 1979--$4/$1,000. &Photocopied and attached Researcher: Richard F.Robinson Legacy Scribe,LLC,Boynton Beach,Florida 561.742.2150 19 April 2005 My ek ;. i'I I 1\ li f f'i 1,.. 11 . ,.-, : "i-I-:!.-.::-.--::::-L!,.--'-.1::.-.:,--::[:---;-;- ,.:,---::'-1::'jr---.:,::--,--';::' •:.''' 1." ,.' - ' ')i \ ( ' cl '' 1 •-•'- .--'- '''' 1 , \ . i ; 1 .,,y ray, .R, -i-r�chmerI-�-- 1 Drt�c,J • �j ?oaul RUdol Ph Cc pies Y'O � "tau 1 - ucl of pti,^Chi�lnr 1 �O — , ......, ,: A - .. • i . • ., . . 6, • •'''. • • 4, '7 ,. :.• -:,-""- , ..... ,4,- 1 , 1 -•,:._,, .'\-. „„,„.-- .- : -,.:, •,. '-„f• • : ..,1111‘ tgøI,•-r.. ,,,....._. -..- 7 -,-'.-, '‘'•'t :• • • • \--. ..•-,-- ..,--,,,-.',...1--,*,; .,,..•,-,1;;•;-.; - _..- -.:._-_:.. ____ -; .- :;. - _ - •--v-._ -.. . . e---viii.. ,,,..,, itet.st 1). • i..... •• • ....„-:• ..,,,,...,..-:,...„ ,i,-,,,: ,..------,...-- : , i,,:! ,, . - -----,=:-.,:------=------ = _ "IL- , ir....1:,,.. ., , _i,., ..„:",. -.:i;.„.1...7*-:.1.. ,---:,, j',:,,,....; ,---_---_---. .-,J,-,--_::_--=-:::_--_-=--- . - •,- ' 1 1.--..`. ,i,,:: ',, ..,_.„--,=------,--,--,--:-.______ - _,-,.. .--- .- ---,-.:-___-_-_f_. WI' .. 1 ,_ .....- --s-,,.. , •..I - ,-_-_---___--=------,-.=- :,- i - 4 'ir,',.1 , 1 ..-.....,.___-.: ....._..._., i __-_-_----_____ -_a____,.. ..,,_-__-=_-_-..--, ...k.rt'f.---,-': 1'".kv. ':-.,, . ....---------,-,----------' ill .2.1-- -. -4 ''---------_6-72=--------- -----7---------- - ': '.'l -1.' • .. :,-.1Z-3-il:=:-:r64 Zs-."---' _ •:i...' '': '. _=-_-• .-----___-----_f__---n-1 • !: ,- =-------.--=-__.----- --.--,----. 1 ..7_.._77 _. 1 -."I . . ,-.-_.,,---. ...,-_----,.._,..._.___.-.,_-„_..„-......... - .. • -...ik _ ,.. ..:7-..-.......,....;: ..1 • . . 1.1-....4:-,tr-11.-•; ....•!-7% „ . . i . . , . • 1 -'•, 1.1.! . '..,-.i.'"_-,-',' ' 3- r',:-:X•_ . ':.-',-, - , „. -- . • .-' -.... --• • :, - .-.'4., :4 "i'. ''. - .. --t-C1.-.1-- ' • :" 1 . .. , •,,. ...'.7, .n • .4 = Vi ii.-3.; L•..-..-••••-7.`""•'' " - 7 •- - —- 4 -,... .y..: W•''' ' • "C 1 %,'- ---- • • ,.."-,:.‘• -..., ......- - -....,- :•-1:- - ..e-7. -,.-r. -- , ,,,,,,,,,,--.7 1.----,=r,'--:---,-,..,._:.,-._ •.,-.--,-.:..,-- -. ----. . -' • 1 •-...,'_';,1.:_i ',:::::.-, - ___=-;;;.-.., ', -:.. ..-'-'.=' - .:-'' '-,-;i- -c„:...-_:::.-:.-17'.----,,_...‹.:--:-;'.'--,_,,-!,,r„ = , ,-, _ - ,•--,,-..-,' .-.„,_ •.'''t*:;*-7,..-,-": ..--', __ ..„.-,,,..-___...,.........a.,,,,f- ,, - .•-..-„,-..,7-_,,,,,,-...,.. ;z1,1, :$-Z--.;----,....'t."-.'--5c-'.%-.7!„.,4"' 4-cluFtit4, 42- _ i-:::-_-;-:,:_-:_ ,.-.,-- ,,„ , --,. . . --. .=-7.:_- -t•-.4.4....-,,s14-..,- -.4,1•"'•,;.; 4-`:ZIr.:,•.v.-,..- 41.4.4 4, ' ...',., _ _ •11. ,. t---1= ,---'. '-'- ' --- ' ...__,,itz,......,-- --A .- - —C- Z6t\A-Vc,c-h ro t•I 4-- 2- phor,,,v v.\ lq 5 —.5(0 ex-- Cop(-) 0C- E' r''' ol‘ ` ‘, p1-10+-051-0-P‘n C.1--(D'i o Aok.- 11-0,1e. P -ild4 \-touSes t, -p3,...),.\ .k),-- ,r I t. • N. g. ,y; { , ms. wK' 7-x � -kt S s > t rf..Ff { '.:ter" 4 .' zC A"; j 1 • 7 7,2 f / - a i`. • Asti me M-t-- 4 n-t r►or ?ho-�ogra�h b 9 . E r SA-o11e , 1q?K.B z (a cop(ed r c�rr - C irce LA\ --g,Lclo l pll 1 -rhe. -Cortdc'- Vk°useS • . ill/I �'•� Lt - - Ylll' %.'• Y r /• • :YIY •! ���1- t � fell 4rr+�. I /� 1. , . �; .. ' • I w . i -- - `' • . :. k5 •` sH.i • aR �— 14., 3 > ^ ^, v - f • f� r ,- _ �' • -p.r ' ��s.t .. ~`..+"ram.,. µ.n u .•'(i22! "!•'. r t".Wklai':7= . ti.LJ�'I�1�'Y✓ • _ * f 1.,•, ...-¢a . 4x`tw •. '.•, ,,,,,,R'�'.1'S'.wd+'- .ra• A . ' .... `.y`as.....' L""Y. 1a' :l,.tM Nikr, ,. .a.. -i1d •. ___,_ P_. 44 ie'' )- . 4'./ . • i _L1_ 1H&Jt & ; ��� _ �> ��� t . p d I, .a t • a �.. ' I •• i,_ Kam' r..T.s a -� ``" -�"" •�..,.- <, - ':Ewa"` t •..�•�•'� '_"`_f ......"c"'•''' �_ - -cA-c k m e tit-1-- (0 - - -- -ou5e. cxra 1- c S \1ng Apr\ 1 ta) 2006 `��'hh r • e bn - y - •3 _ - � _ `may .. 1 : tl 3 � •�, , , _ : , .;_. . ...,,_ - ..„,,,i, i t , . : 1 :' :_11 .2°(--9--P (‘.."1-- ..:- _ _ ham^ i „,,,V -.:..,!":',74;4,,, ' —- - ,a _..— _, . ,, fi-ti,;.,_,z4U'te'n= - 4: - -, ." '4"-1-"'*..'.-- ''''''L' -*-=71'''''':4''' t-io.Ift-'`,, ' a .may FL tt t M1+,�-,Irr_s�x-fib-.Y 1_ t :4..4 ,3 r4 7 i i USES 31--1,&.11I N G I7.CVIGff 14H lcH nLocK TH1: S UN f UT ALLOW A\II MOV>=MINT LOUVES r�oV!2 PLUS L16-IT b f.1 II ■` • ■ 1 � ISSLAT H56T6 K I TI \e A UGH76 /Nn LAUN22I � rKoM LIMING S N S. e ilGN 0 FO MAXIMUM VVNTII TIOINI av l;, UN FNn THKOU&-1 T}-E Hc7H . t . 1 DELRAY BEACH DELRAY EACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD liii MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT liii t'J93 7993 Project Name: The Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) Historic Designation Report for an Individual Property Virginia & Erskine Courtenay, Owners Report prepared by Dorothy W. Patterson ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of making a recommendation to the City Commission on a request for individual historic designation for The Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue), pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 4.5.1(C). BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS The current property owners have proposed to designate the subject property to the Local Register of Historic Places. As stated in the attached designation report, Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School, and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. He became a serious collector of 18th and 19th-century American art and, in 1988, the Biggs Museum of American Art opened in Dover, Delaware to house his collection. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American art and decorative art gems. That same year, Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The architect of the Sewell C. Biggs House, Paul Rudolph, was an important influence on American Modernism in the mid-twentieth century. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design, and Engineering at the Library of Congress, "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence on the second half of the 20th century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation". Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of 'Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses', state that "The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a _ formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism'. The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II and embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism, the innovative uses of new materials, and adaptation to suit the South Florida environment. Paul Rudolph's design was constructed by the Sinks, father and son, who had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. The Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving, and promoting American fine and decorative arts. The style of the home is a design unique to Delray Beach and is the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in the 20th-century American design field. It is also the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Meeting Date:June 15,2005 Agenda Item: III.A. Historic Preservation Board Memorandum Staff Report The Sewell C. Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue)Designation Report Page 2 Delray Beach (although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings) and is representative of 20th-century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further, the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving historic buildings in Delray Beach. Designating this site as historic will help preserve the character of the extant historic dwelling and will promote the preservation of other surrounding historic properties. At its meeting of May 4, 2005, the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) conducted a formal review of the designation report and set a public hearing date for the designation of the subject property for May 18, 2005. However, the applicant did not submit the required names and addresses of property owners within a 500' radius of the property to meet that deadline. These have now been submitted and the proposal is now before the Board for recommendation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(B) (1), to qualify as a historic site the property must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in LDR Section 4.5.1(B) (2) and/or (3). The designation report contains, at minimum, sufficient information to meet the criteria stated in both LDR Sections 4.5.1(B) (2) and (3). The criteria are as follows: LDR Section 4.5.1(B) (2): (a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history (for example, the homestead of a local founding family); (b) Is the site of a historic event with significant effect upon the city, state, or nation; (c) Is associated in a significant way with a major historic event, whether cultural, economic, social, military, or political; (d) Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, economic, or social trends of the community in history; or (e) Is associated in a significant way with a past or continuing institution which has contributed substantially to the life of the city. LDR Section 4.5.1(B) (3): (a) Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles;and, (b) Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction; (c) Is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder; or (d) Contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment. Historic Preservation Board Met♦ !idum Staff Report The Sewell C.Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue)Designation Report Page 3 The designation report demonstrates that the subject property qualifies as a historic site as it: is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history[LDR Section 4.5.1(8)(2)(a)]; embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction [LDR Section 4.5.1(8)(3)(b)]; is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(c)]; and contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment[LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(d)J. Comprehensive Plan: A review of the Objectives and Policies of the Comprehensive Plan was conducted and the following is noted: Housing Element Objective A-10: The City shall support the conservation and rehabilitation of historically significant housing, especially where such housing is an identifying characteristic of a particular neighborhood. As briefly discussed above and as further stated in the attached designation report, the Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving, and promoting American fine and decorative arts. The style of the home is a design unique to Delray Beach and is the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in the 20'h- century American design field. It is also the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach (although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings) and is representative of 20th-century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further, the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving historic buildings in Delray Beach. Designating this site as historic will help preserve the character of the extant historic dwelling and will promote the preservation of other surrounding historic properties. COURTESY/PUBLIC NOTICES Special courtesy notices were provided to the property owners within a 500' radius of the subject property proposed to be individually designated. Letters of support or objection, if any, will be presented at the HPB meeting. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move a recommendation of approval to the City Commission that the residence and associated property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (The Sewell C. Biggs House) be listed in the Local Register of Historic Places, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, and Sections 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(C) of the Land Development Regulations. C. Deny the listing of the residence and associated property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (The Sewell C. Biggs House) in the Local Register of Historic Places, by finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan, and Sections 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(C) of the Land Development Regulations. Historic Preservation-Board-M ndurn-Staff-Report The Sewell C. Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue) Designation Report Page 4 RECOMMENDATION Move a recommendation of approval to the City Commission that the residence and associated property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (The Sewell C. Biggs House) be listed in the Local Register of Historic Places, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, and Sections 4.5.1(B) and 4.5.1(C) of the Land Development Regulations. Attachment:Location Map, The Sewell C.Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue)Designation Report,Photographs Memorandum Staff Report Prepared by:Warren Adams,Historic Preservation Planner L-IU I I I I I I 1 ` w D N.E. 5TH ST. z w z i ISLAND DRIVE a a J ce L. N Q w cD z Z /'� N.E. 4TH ST. \ BEACH DRIVE i Q w a - - LLl C SEA SPRAY AVE. 4i Q - -- SANDOWAY LANE o WATERWAY LANE a z" _J O — Q ZZ cc I- Va J = J iIjjjI1! LAING StN.E. 3RD SI. VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE jii Az...A. NM1 I....AA . :Q1 w i DORCHESTER z CO—OP THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. z EAST WIND J J�� BEACH CLUB Q v BERKSHIRE I— J w N.E. 1ST CT. U7 DRIVE w BY THE SEA 7 C cn Q Q L., GROSVENOR a O co • z .K. Q HOUSE U LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. CONDO 2 _,.i FIRE z CC DELRAY STA. VETERANS NO. 2 PARK � SUMMIT � GROVE ATLANTIC CONDO Lic N CONDO ci PLAZA z I //� w 0 CD i BARR N TERRACE ti Li CONDO I SPANISH DELRAY BEACH I� MARRIOTT RIVER 0 I I RESORT A T L A N TIC AVENUE N --101.- THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM833 Designation Report Historic Preservation Board Delray Beach, Florida The SeweliC . Biggs House Table of Contents I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. NOT APPLICABLE IV. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VIII. ATTACHMENTS Report Prepared By: Dorothy W. Patterson 1206 NE Second Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 (561) 278-2191 (home) 274-9578 (Archives) 717-3425 (cell) E-mail summerpatt0earthlink.net Date of Report: April 20, 2005 Name of Owners: Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay 212 Seabreeze Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33483 2 I. General Information Address The Sewell C. Biggs House, named for its original owner, is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue within the city limits of Delray Beach, Florida. Legal Description Lot 21 and the west 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Location Lots 21 and 22 are at the end of Seabreeze Avenue. A driveway at this point leads to the front entrance of the Courtenay home. The lots are bounded by Lot 26 of Ocean Breeze Estates on the south and Vista Del Mar Drive South on the north. At the time of construction in 1955 the front entrance faced Vista Del.Mar Drive South. This area is on the barrier island between the Intra-coastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean. Zoning Single Family Residential Classification for Designation We believe that the Sewell C. Biggs House, designed by esteemed mid- century modern architect, Paul Rudolph, meets the criteria for both r architectural and cultural significance for the reasons described in the ., following pages of the report. 3 II. Location Map To be provided by City of Delray Beach. III District Inventory Not applicable 4 IV. Historical and Cultural Significance Before 1895 the lots where the Sewell C. Biggs House is located were part of a semitropical wilderness between the coastal ridge and a swampy morass. Less than two blocks away from the lots the coastal ridge begins. The first construction known in the area was the Orange Grove House of Refuge built by the U.S. Life Saving Service (precursor to the Coast Guard) in 1876. The former site of the House of Refuge is a short walk from the Briggs House. The Refuge keeper's son, Charles Pierce, described the land around the Refuge House as follows: The house... was built on a broad flat that ran back from the open sand beach to the higher ridge behind the house...At the Orange Grove it was covered with a thick growth of saw palmetto. The flat was covered with sea oats and scattered bunches of stunted seagrape and cocoplum. This flat extended north two and one-half miles and ended at the • caves; to the south it stretched for nearly four miles ... To the west, commencing at the foot of the palmetto-covered ridge, was a deep swamp of tall sawgrass with numerous small channels turning about its eastern side. The morass was about half a mile wide and extended from Lake Worth to Boca Raton; west of it were pinewoods reaching back as far as one could see." The Pierce family encountered deer, bear and heard panthers screaming in the night. They killed the bears for food. After settlement by Americans of European descent began, the area was used for farming such crops as strawberries, pineapples, mangoes and tomatoes. Beginning with the mid-1920's Florida Real Estate Boom, the land became more valuable for residential housing. Or as Adolf Hofman said in one of his letters home to Germany, "Since Delray is growing and the lots fetch colossal prices, I will divide my land between canal and railroad into lots." One of first the farmers in the area, Adolf Hofman developed the Ocean Breeze Estates subdivision adjoining Delray Beach Esplanade, in 1937. Local attorney Ernest Simon recalls that in the late 1930's and early 1940's when he was delivering the De/ray Beach News on his bicycle, there were only a few houses in the area._ Delray Beach Esplanade, the subdivision where the Briggs House is located, was platted in 1938 by H. H. and 'Charlotte Wellenbrink and Williard and Billie Waters. The Waters were 5 well-known in Delray Beach. Wiiiard Waters was a building contractor who had graduated from Delray High School. His family lived at 222 N. Ocean and farmed land on the barrier island in the early years of the 20th century. Waters was also active in city politics and civic clubs. • After World War II, building in the neighborhood began in earnest. Tom Woolbright, who went into the building business for himself in 1949,recalls spending the 1947 hurricane in a house in the neighborhood. He said the area was pretty well built up by then and that Willard Waters built many of the houses. Mr. Woolbright remembers that H.H. Wellenbrink was "the money man" who paid for improvements such as building roads, filling land, and paying engineering fees for the plat. Roy Simon, native of Delray Beach, was an apprentice architect in the 1950s for local architect, Ken Jacobson. He recalls that Vista del Mar (Delray Beach Esplanade) was fairly built up by then. After he saw the Paul Rudolph designed house under construction, he and other architects were enthusiastic about the chance of designing contemporary housing. However, he said, "I seemed to keep drawing nice cottages." There were many important clients for houses in the neighborhood such as CEO's of nationally known corporations, famous professional golfers and prominent Delray Beach citizens. The clients loved the smallness and "laid-back" atmosphere of Delray Beach. But evidently they did not have the artistic sensibilities of Sewell C. Biggs and did not request avant garde contemporary designs. James Sinks, a local building contractor, constructed architect Paul Rudolph's design. According to Ernie Simon, Sinks had a reputation for being a "good builder." Jim Sinks father, Irwin J. Sinks, was also a builder originally from Champaign, Illinois. During World War I he went to work for the U.S. Government and was sent to Charleston, S.C. to build soldiers' barracks. In Charleston he roomed with Fred J. Schrader from Delray Beach. Schrader was the first builder in Delray with architectural training. He came to town in 1911 and built the town's first jail, the Cromer Block on Atlantic Avenue and the original part of the Presbyterian Church on Gleason Street. Schrader encouraged Sinks to come to Delray. In 1922 after another assignment in Miami, the Sinks family moved to Delray. The Sinks, father and son, quintessential Delray builders of their time, had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 6 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. Jim built the Atha Building which replaced the Cromer Building. Laura Sinks Britt said in her book, My Gold Coast, "My father had become a builder of more structures on Atlantic Avenue than any other one contractor and Jim added his score." Today some of the"nice cottages," which fit gently into subdivision-sized lots on the short winding streets of the neighborhood, are being torn down to make way for large estate style homes. At present we do not know the exact circumstances of how Sewell C. Biggs came to build a house in Delray Beach and chose Paul Rudolph as his architect. He has been described as "enigmatic" and not easy to know. A biography of his life is in the process at this time. The curator at the Sewell C. Biggs Museum in Dover, Delaware, said Biggs owned the house about six years. The Delray Beach City Directory lists him as the owner at the address for about nine years. Randy Grover, the curator, was asked to present a retrospective of Biggs life to the museum board when Mr. Biggs died suddenly in 2003 at age 88. Grover said he felt that the story of the house in Delray Beach was a high point of his presentation. The reason for this was that Biggs was known for his collection of 18th and 19th century American art. The house signaled the beginning of a turn toward the 20th century. In fact Sewell Bigg's vision was for his collection to cover the entire range of American art. Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. In 1937 he took a trip around the world that had an enduring impact on the rest of his life. After the trip he was interested in international exchange and began to sponsor foreign students for one-year scholarships at the University of Delaware. A serious collector of art, he was also involved in historical preservation and art conservation. Biggs collection of American fine and decorative art has been described as "elegant, wonderful, pristine, remarkable, impressive, and an incredible journey ranging from Colonial portraiture to the Hudson River School." With his vision and eye for quality, Biggs spent most of his life on his American art collection. In 1998 the Biggs Museum of American Art. opened in Dover to house his collection which includes Delaware and 7 Delaware Valley fine and decorative arts. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American fine art and decorative art gems. That same year Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The title of an exhibit at the Biggs Museum of American Art says it best --"Artful Living: The Legacy of Sewell C. Biggs." Mr. Biggs sold his house at 212 Seabreeze about 1970 to a New York lawyer and his wife, Richard and Alice McAvoy. Evidently the McAvoy's did not have much time in the house because a Webb Brothers Real Estate information sheet is headed Estate of Richard McAvoy. (See attachments) Reference No. 2 on the sheet cites a merit award, medium house class (600-2800 sq. ft.), given in June 1959 by House &Home, an architecture magazine. The fourth and present owners of the house, Virginia and Erskine Courtenay, bought the house in 1973. Well-known Delray Beach Realtor, Pat Patterson, showed the house. Before becoming a real estate salesman for Ben Adam's Realty, Patterson was known for his pharmacy, his photography, and his volunteer work as a ham radio operator during World War II. Virginia Courtenay says that she "fell in love with the light, being up in the trees, and the architecture. She already greatly admired the work of Paul Rudolph. Mrs. Courtenay's grandfather was a builder in Chicago. She attended the Art Institute of Chicago and has owned ant interior design business in Delray Beach for more than 25 years. Erskine Courtenay agreed to the purchase because Virginia loved the house, and he loved her. Paul Rudolph has been sometimes criticized for elevating style at the expense of function and some changes had to be made for practical living. Mr. And Mrs. Courtenay have always wanted and have strived to keep the house as close to the original design as possible. Sensitivity to the original design while making changes has always been an important aspect of planning. In addition Rudolph's Florida houses had been designed just prior to the time when air-conditioning became a standard feature of south Florida homes. Some of the innovative design features meant to ameliorate the Florida climate worked against the efficiency of air-conditioning. For example, in the back of the house paneling was installed over the aluminum louver windows because the strength of the wind blowing against the louvers 'had been a problem at times, and after air-conditioning was installed, the problems continued. The windows in the front of the original part of the 8 house look the same even though they have been replaced. Paul Rudolph drew a plan for an addition and approved the changes to the house in 1980. (See attachments). However, Rudolph was not aware of the need to raise the house 4 feet because of a new law which dictated that the house must be 7.5 feet above mean sea level. (Flooding of the lot during the rainy season had occurred at times after original construction in 1955.) Local architect Bob Currie was then hired to plan lifting the house and the addition in 1980-81.. The interior of the addition matches the interior of the original house. The original hedges, trees and landscaping remain the same. (See attachments) 9 V. Architectural Significance The architect of the Sewell C. Bigg House in Delray Beach, Paul Rudolph (1918-1997), was an important influence on American modernism in the mid-twentieth century. He was a Kentucky native and son of a Methodist minister. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design and Engineering at the Library of Congress, Rudolph drew on many influences for his Florida work. He was open to new and experimental methods of construction-- stretching structural possibilities of materials to their limit's while celebrating their static and aesthetic possibilities, spatial richness, complexity and inter-relationship of the interiors and exteriors... of his buildings, their site, their natural surroundings and their climate. His appreciation of these qualities in both modern architecture and in the vernacular buildings of his native South had been fostered by E. Walter Burkhardt under whom he studied architecture at Auburn University (then Alabama Polytechnic Institute). Burkhart recommended his student to Walter Gropius who was instrumental in Rudolph's admission to Harvard Graduate School of Design. Burkhart was one of the most energetic and enlightened directors of the Historic American Building Survey, now one of the most frequently consulted collections in the Library of Congress. Mr. Peatross wrote the preface to Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. He is well-acquainted with Rudolph's work because the architect bequeathed his professional papers and drawings to the Library and funded the Center of Architecture, Design and Engineering there. Peatross' accolades include the statement: "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence of the second half of the 20th century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation." His assessment of Rudolph's Florida buildings is that the "innovative, adventurous and elegant Florida buildings launched Rudolph's career." Petross further finds in working with drawings of many famous architects in the Library of Congress Collections that "with the exception of Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual 'curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the 'speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of 10 Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the `speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of lessons, ideas, and possibilities that will speak to and inspire generations to come." Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses, visited the present owners in Delray Beach. The Courtenays are listed in the Acknowledgments on page 13. The Sewell C. Biggs House is featured in the "Independent Practice" section on page 183 where the house is compared to the "award-winning Cohen House...(1953-1955)" on Siesta Key. The authors' opening statement is: "While coming of age as architects along the west coast of Florida in a landscape increasingly homogenized by air-conditioning and prolific land development, Paul Rudolph's architecture stood alone in our eyes as a rigorous counter-argument." Domin and King met in the graduate program at the Georgia Institute of Technology. After discovering their shared interest in Rudolph's work, they made their avocation the searching out of buildings designed by Rudolph across the state of Florida. The authors' conclude that"Rudolph's early work in Florida over a 20-year period was a necessary testing round for a multi-layered design methodology of a complex career. The fact that the architect's work was widely publicized at the time played a significant role in national recognition of Rudolph's work. The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism. The beautiful photographs are seen today in a bittersweet light as we are now all too aware of what happens when a vastly enlarged population of affluent Americans descends on all too few miles of pristine beaches." The Delray Beach Historical Society featured the Sewell C. Biggs House as one of the components in its "The Art of Architecture in South Florida" exhibit in 1989. One of the displays described how orientation, sun, heat and ventilation were addressed by the design. (See attachments) 11 VI. Statement of Significance The owners, Esrkine H. & Virginia W. Courtenay, wish to nominate their property for the following reason: "After living in it since 1973, are very much like those of the original owner, Mr. Sewell C. Biggs. It has maintained its sense of elegance in its simplicity and its feeling of"dateless" architecture which stands the test of time. In 1981 we raised the original house four feet to add a lower floor which now houses a library, guest bedroom and laundry room. This was accomplished with the collaboration of local architect, Robert Currie, who was interested in the house for its historical importance." The style of the home is a design, unique to the neighborhood and to Delray Beach, of the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in 20th century American design field. It is the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings. It is representative of 20th century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving buildings in Delray Beach. Other reasons for designation are that respect shown for the characteristics of our property will draw attention to the need for preservation in Delray Beach's older neighborhoods; the hope that local designation will afford some protection for the house in the future,and to set an example in a neighborhood being pressured by demolitions. In summary the Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving and promoting American fine and decorative arts. His collection spans the more than 200 years that the United States has existed as a country. The property has been followed under Historical and Cultural Significance in this Designation Report throughout the entire history of Delray Beach after 1876. Further it reflects social and economic trends in the community and is indicative of the winter -Y- colony of artistic and socially prominent people which has existed in Delray Beach since the 1920's. Since the house at 212 Seabreeze fits comfortably into the history of Delray Beach, and the original owner proved to have the "vision and eye for quality" of a major American art collector, there seems no doubt that the house at 212 Seabreeze has historical and cultural significance. 12 The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II and embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism and innovative uses of new materials. It is an example of the work of a leading American architect whose testing round was Florida. The design is both a significant innovation and adaptation to the South Florida environment. 13 VII. Bibliography & Sources Britt, Laura Sinks, My Gold Coast. Palatka, Florida: Brittany House Publishers, 1984. Delray Beach Historical Society Archives. Delray Beach City Directories, 1953-54, 1955, 1957,1961,1963,1966, 1973, 1976,1979, Miller, Polk, Price & Lee. Domin, Christopher & King, Joseph. Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses New York, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2002. Hofman, Charles, Letters from Linton. Hollywood, Florida: Legacy Press, 2004. Palm Beach County Records, Palm Beach County Courthouse, West Palm Beach, Florida. Pierce, Charles W., Pioneer Life in Southeast Florida. Ed. Donald Walter Curl. Coral Gables: University of Miami Press, 1970. Interviews: April, 2005 Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay, property owners. • Randolph Grover, Curator, Biggs Museum of American Art Roy Simon, Architect, Delray Beach native Ernest Simon, Attorney, Delray Beach native Tom Woolbright, retired builder, Delray Beach native 14 • .L' .`-, i` ; 7 } 'f 11.:'..C.i1N.--':,:',,,i',' t.. . /i,'','''''' Y,e t F F 4 ii 1+ ib; 1r £ � i t ' t- ' .W,T7 tg iY. v '* #. ,,.. : NY 'i c � : I1:"-.-:::':_:`:-.::,-\''.:-.- ::-4 5-::',3:,!:-.-5::':,....•-,:•:-'---f-,',:.',;--'2,-:::'-'---',9.i',a7L,:-.,17,':2-z2.-,V.VUW:67-1:1-pit-z0A:1W,:4„--.,-.,t.',:E=4;.--i-WAti-7 *-14-f&i..,_ _::_;_,..:..4, _.„,,...:,,,,„.,:+i:14,g-47,*74,..30.A.,._:07,fix,,:,i,I,73.;_,: ,‘ , r _ R - -- ;'" 's - - d L ti ue^--n + -r ; t p i.::rf:.:-.._:,,. -.-',.\71.: . .1!:..'7,-:::'::-';-',.::'-:,---..;-;'': :-':,,t%',:if-_-:f,:::t:c5::=,Stf-Z-",-R';:-K,tiig'jn'Z::-*.'-:--v-.:,-F,-:a-'IWit-','-'--kg', -- -4--4,-'1":,;F.---' r v - -t+^ am '' -"" a T � t` - � L s 5"` *R"`+ frk 'I• ;-cam - �' '-- 9 ,' Y i ' - � ¢" ..., _ ---T` � is��� � yam, -s:.-ar'-���' c _ �_ �.- �'_,�`'' if �Y I! /� •L !` 'Sc i 4.i -c t s t" tit• k --3-t` -`�- a =�,. G%t4 r a4 z� ,1••..� k ' } .Y.Lrs ;` '` Wit _`- ,-f .�.� - ` c ,; s s x. A--'', �Z. - ,- - f,• -sue r .f" *4 r„-ii.,-:3--;: :::::2; --:-.*::.:':--:::;',:;y,••.-'?.-',T.,,-_: -�,,y. i:=7 _ i s r .Y r� .� r "_ -W , • € 4 s ... y,- ....... . ,.•4 ,.,." :,,,. s :4.4 r ..,▪ z .. t ' _ ..r,. i- n-r. ."� ._a7 �are;.'.V :1 �'4:1 ..k'.. . L A 4 Lhmet,1 -4-- I - • r:),--,,c01,10, b y ¶c+u l Ruda! e h Cramp1ec v orr "Po_u 1 -udolpl-l;The, -lDY1 Ja il—S , t' ii t x. As •'J e- .,:f h, .4, x :,,,_. ,_ { k_ ., ,.., : . : . . . . „..,E -:=.--.--.._--,.,---:-,--,_:--,,,:,;....-,-;,-_-.-i,,,,:-_-,..32--;„,-;...-.-;:---......-._----, ,--.‘'-. .-- . ..-- : --,-.:-_ _ . -..., ,.,., -,,--,1.g.:sli 4,2f yf Ay PM'_ I` _ 24 . "s.a a 0.t-�4�fie , s" Yt r 7Yc�'� `r a y r ftt't i {4 • tii �7 ---34r �� �. .ems • , -.4;4 1-.--zaim A-,.,-,--,;.;._-L__,;1-5.i..m.--trps ------..__,_,-, _,--4.- tk„tn- .‘litir ,,,1 ___....„-,-____„..- ____-____-__.— :-.-,v,,,,,,tiz..z.,1-:.„ __&..,...,-.... 4,,,,,,*-- _ . _., ....1/41....,,,,... .._.?..7„...„, :i?...,.:.._._::_.........,m.:54 ___ ....„. ,,.tall f•---;', --- -al--1 •, •- • ••.`- I < _i sr r ...:s �� '�d Z '• 't�{ '_.t = jWit§` Nit i i.. i '&."Z..E _ • � r • a" ems,.'' r f "y �=. , ''" s m'", ---' a - 'a .4:-n - i `� { .- `" r � •tip '-" _ yY;„ a�_ • • t\A-5CcAC.,h m e 1,1-A--- pho-t-vc,ro.?11 tg56-5b Copy 0E- E -r.o. A o11er- phoi-o ra 1, F-r-(Dry, •L i�,,..).\ V..'0,161hi-c-Nne lor1(14 uoUSesI) , • ....- . ' . • • -- • . . -L. . _ • %,, .."-.:. .... '-•..-.t..:::,i.s.•-•*-.*J:-......- ; -- -- - - . . A.,,. - . . %.-...'.--;,-..-.';-.-. "s•-..-.:•-.:-.:-•-'-::.-.-.:'...:.• •1. \ • • •-:...... .••'-::.',:-.:- .'' ' ,.;•:-:s-,,r..'i''.4.' -4•& -,,,;,_. "*.•':s.„'''' '.'-...• .;'`,•:i',-....,:-::.-;.-• ., •._ .. . -.. . \'. . -... :,1'.-.' ',......"..:::• -•?'-;:::-...K::::-,i1.-4?!.f:,?F.:7.-.:- -;? ..::"..-:*::::'.. -,..." .-- * I • Vk 'T-4- • • X:,..:.:,..:', :'..-7"•:::;.:'':";•:....‘ ,.7-4:%ii:,...,...Z::::.;,,-..-:;--;f::'::1'."; :•.'::-..--: -..:-: i •. '''''.' .':‘,:;'i'i-..:...;•- 5..t'''Z'rl'gr;kt;"1.V.-741,1,-":i.7P':::.'..'''',:: :,:,..' : ...... '-;,:. .,.1 :‘,':::::.:.::::1.!1::.i.:::.;:f...16.1.1f,,:.f.11;:::,,;-::::•1/4111.T5,,...:47:::::::„:•1;;,:,...:.11.1.Fi-.1r:Li.z.:.--;::.:2.::-.:;.::::-.....":„.:':.-...."-'.;.:..::-...,•-•'* . ...4. . ... ':.•••;',e'-':::'::,. .f:::--4-4.:?-'4.1.,:iN'*-4-`4:A:.;'-.. .'t?-;-_,..".•.,-.,:. . ... ...I - - -....-:',....,-..-.-,..,,,,c-,--..;:".. .,==_-.:-,-i'--..'. .,,---;:,.---,--.-':-,,.-. • .- ' ': •..-::::,.. ..::.,:::::'-•-•-•-. ''''.:;---'4;2::'-6.7:: '•-'". '• '-'14j- 2;'.:*;?..r.-.----3f47-V.-'-_-;-11.iiigz..',TrAt,,-i.,2`...';'-,.'.-..',1','. - '.".,-•';.'5''-',''.i?-1,11Mi-?iz-f-.1i-'67.:itf.-4-tr:.4e4!:-.:' ,:-1--...!,,.:,..-1.f-:.,.'..;,.. '.:•-.6.44tr-.1';.e.",:'1,. . ' --,-.,-.„,-,',.-51.-ItP-Y,PCIirt.-'7;1.:-7..kftvr:::;',Y.....fi'-ii-r?3--. ' „A '"•`::'"-r:.:.,:-.-?'---c..:Y.:4--.."4-... .,-_,...s.ry-:;N,f11-:-=.;: :-,-,-.7z-=',.. . :--; z-...`,.:,1;•-•-•-t-t;i1f.--'7C:5-rs''',.-'65t0-cf.'"1,;•.'Eff.:`,-:•:::',.... '.. .. ---.... . '-c-i-,1-.z'1,.-.4,, ,,t • ‘... -4.14P-Ple'f.;-'f!1 _' t.i+k-li&Ekt.:5;„-'-: ' •• --_.---_,i'-;_Wri„;-,, - 1,•-%. .. ...-.--- . •. .::i'. ow-,-`74Z.-v- .it; .-••,- . • -._ - --:,,,,,--,-,vii.r.a.,-. --c.---If.lx- -,,,-'-,- 4,3a•--; - .,2.-. ...:T-- .- • --•°"'-;---ifz- . 4.,,--'-''-'=-=--',"-tt -_-..-._,,,...-e,- ,.,,-:-• . - - .,.-.-'-'...':::-'_..T-23-,,,,.: .• v.j--t..,'2::,,T.-4,,-_.zefew3-„.--,,. .--4. ,:.;: . -1,-.-::::_-:„;:,.-----;-=-4.-7*., -s- 'f;-:--4,'"V,..M-G-727* q-5_ :-•-, . ..•.:-....,,•-••-.. z..---._- -.:--4,_.., ----_,-...-,1,..-• . ::,.....-.4- -.- . ---,- -,.7. _,'.77,7------ - - ,-.,..--.' ,..-- • ' -- •-:.-;. , , •. 11101--K,, ,Inz-•,-7---_:,,,,,,,-.;---„,....-.... 4 •. .:,.:.:-;.-..;-• -.. --' F------ --- ••--,", ._, . _ , , .(4-•,;•...--:.•••,:, -•--- .--,;- . . `2-- ,..-. -:-?------i..-r-_---„,-.„If P--:-:---.•--- .--r- F.- 1 24 ! :;-;,113 I c:-.,-iz •_=ij -4.,.... i '- -' 7' '' - -::"*-,-- -.-------=-, 1 '-'..;-; _,.• - '41.7 '''"t'-'-2' =7.,'''."':+-L -91-:=--,.e., - •-•,;;.,if-.i-,...,,,,--. -.,--,:...;.,,,,-,5 ,,,,,,-. -....1111: ' .7- "':-.;--- - - .:,:=';',,:s'- •,-•-•-,•---',1':-;-------,T-"":':€,..••::::,-•:, - 1 1 .,._, ..c.,--i-,-46477,-•:.''-• t„-,----4 •1!.,,- '::,-,--',. 1-`',NVI- -- ,--„: -,,r--"?.',.-1;7,---,i,-;-:!-",„,-,,,,,:,,,1„.„„.: `,„_,•„„:.-,- *"'* i p,-;.-.- ' .,.i-,`,..;?,:7-,--:2:'- .:-•--2-',---F- ,,,--;•:. ,-Alli , -•,11- --, 1:•,;. „-i-t--,..--_-_,-,,-,•---,;:-'-,-,-4--•-;-:-..---gr,:,-:t ,1-,,,,,,-:,-_- ,,,......- / , , -_,.,- • :t.&-.„,,,,c,..,,-...--,..,=.,,,..y6',..:,-,. ------- ',f,'",---..:I ii 2 .-_,_--.-.a i pg r.c.,- -,-eg-4,-,.:,,,*:.' ' .,-.7:_q---g ,,c-,. i.O. -,k7.4-..,,,-,-;!v--'.:,...,:;,:,is=7.f,-;,,,..., ..-.---,--.':--n'--•.;--,--!„..c-, ..1-47-..2.4. - ..4- u'' . fr-- .-.-----..-.7-.---- .. . .11 1 r1.=::„:-t. ,..---; .,1,_2.,.';'7-i,---7..›rtL`-',..-`-::-------_-.. -7. --r:-.--'. --.;`,- -''-"---.:-.n ' -.4"K Vg.1'i$.4 • '----i.,,--"-' .ft, 'i--,T ,'-'--,-'' N i.,/..„,..... .„,_:. ,.. -,:. .....,,,,.. i ...e-_..3.t7,:,fr .. o--kr/p.:,a-..--,;:?. •- . -.-:.- -. . r.i,,I, ;•• „:„_..,<, . i.... .„ ,„...,„,... 4..„,......:._•,.,..r.,•„:„..y_..,„....;,:;.ii_5 • .......6 I S";74 -=''' '''7;''' ... .. .' ' , ",f '...---1-,-',;:;-% \i '-,- 12,:g1,-=:, ,..'''-:,,,:•"-•-_'-:::-:',..---- ,-•:',:z.,...-;::;:,7;:t: tic/ :.?„,_-,4 F ik* , "f_,•'..„-dr-•.A,..`r.3'4.-.1-=.:•1:-._v.:-,..7..i7i.,,eiri.,,-;...- - „.-.:*.„.. E-:.-:-. ....- . . ..• : .lei,,,,.,. $. •,..• . -4---•.__:.-A,,,,,,--- "•,.,-,;-,..,0,,,,,,:--,.,-...v, - .... f. --.. ,- . . . , ,.T..;0•`.' rf.,' . -- - -•:. .,.4grd-Ar,.<:-F•ii,,,,_••,,--z-,•,--:-Itz,.•;:•.-:0.:4,34-.,x--.5-:- ••4:. -.• ,. .,•..;,:.; e• -_--- . ' ,,Ar 4 ...„,,_--iff ...„• 9,. -- • -,..4T„,,,t's--;>-$4'..f.-17,1,13.1',IY.:Fill.. *-• 7.5---ii.g...24 ''' ' ' ' . ' ' :''''' '12 . ."., .,7--.•. t.',--....,Z-x...„-A,-,„?.: ::--,-,?,..,,..-f.,.., . .., . - -....4.,- e. '. ..- . - r -• q "N5ki;r4; ;;;41-Z* 7;!;X---,-;f''.-'ic;i':: F',W;'-'" .- —,.."4"."'fil tii:.-.-::-"..::: •-t ... . ... ecgwith.„.„ 1, .,ysZoy- --- ---,-, 4,:,.., ,:,;_-_-tiEF.1_;-, t_it*.,-....:-:',:t-i-:1„,-Vtg,'1„.'474-4---.=';-::';'':.•.7::1 • ' '. -- --1v,4*' t4 • . ,.. , I1 4/ f'li IP •,i ir,•'‘Zitil'-.:::::,;-1,5i-j. t.tv.*,,,Z•;i:•4;•i-i,F,f!...,•,:::;.::::...:' i,••••IA/ 1 r ST iii,..1.--,t.---:.-.,,,,,,,Z,,i.:34.-.'4-'21..4-',. .4--.,..,,4-;,..„X'4..,, ,_!•_.,i,f.-,,-,,.....:-...-.-.., ;.2:: - -.. • . . 1 i .,. ,:„.,-,.,...A'r-,,,,..,.....:..„.1•;•;,:,,,,,.• • • i./. rj IV 1 r;,;,..,-Jft's,••----,"''..':44*,0•-#0.-NR••=-g:-1'.5:-$.'.i.--.:-::::,-.!' :::•". .':- .'' - ' .. . j`' 4'4 -111,..„.„.... ,-...--4),17,•„,,,,,,,,,,,„„..., ••.,. .,„ ,....,.. . , •‘,...„, . ...i....„-,,,,,,„„,,,,,,,,...,....... , . # _ ,....„..., .•.,.,.-• ..,.....,- • • • • • • • 1,, --t--- 4- L. 0 1 .. ii._\_k_k_._0 .k cy.)e- - r, . hcA-ograY" . . • . i-l-te-rA wr. P lc‘F, 7-5(c) _L„i)e , ,_ tplo 1 __..2.-1---t S ' a- C-rcYrr . G_Dpie- \_\Q use-s -Co r-t ac---- . . tile_- - . - - • • • • . • • ' '----\ ,...)a ' ,.---le:41)i....:'-'71. •-'-'.'....:,.,.. --.- , -s•g•-•;- .4. '. - ' . ''•i-' •-•:.: I, Aan. -,.. . .'.'0 i•-,.---„..16'i N. NI '' ' ...4(. 1;.A- • - . ,,,r,e -4A .S. -?;.1.0.V..repe- 4'..W''`I'l •,--.:"7.'-'64-'`. - : .; . • . i, .A'''';'$‘ 4. - '-' ; _e4:: . • ',"' .??. 'i t • - '14:-.1 s , _ . ,. • ! _ - ..•:' -'F 14''''' .• ^' .•- . . - --- -- -••••.r; .. 1:-•-•-:• ____-----7_ , ---4-,-;O.?, ; ...1 ,..,- • .•< , ''‘. .•.- l, .• .a --------- -- ---.._,_ .. 1 • sa..7 ' N-----.-----___--..----,---- -----.'-i-- -.. `''..P1''g.:-..;' 1 't154.P 11. ' ' a. '. ec.1.;. . t;,-.1. ' '••==---•--__,,-.=--- -----,--_-- ----- -4,, ---'--r-,i-,:-,4,-• ---. '44.--. - r2-j-i-tti: ' 1 1 t ' -.z_ ,• ‘ , ,____-___,_______ w- ,,,;j.'a, ..-c-----------:_=-.-- - -, - - -----=-____: ______________ :- 4_• -.-,-_-_--=---__- .-z--------_-_--=----------,------___---'____,__________-- V-'''':- -._-_---,_-_---,_-- , __-----z--_----- .___.___ _____ . •,, -- - ___-_ ____ • _______ •-,---.-_-• -- . • —____ —=_.=„-- ' s r r• i r.; —_ -_--- ,---- ,11; -,.. •i5• it -1114 . --___--,-•_-__-•=_-=--__----__---_ • -_-_----_ -i-4---=-----,_,_ =----__ .4,,.....„-. . 1 - - 1. .•• !.., .t _ ,_ -_.. ..- • -', ' • fif 5",..„,--- • • •' tIS -,...-..ar• _ ' 14,-.0--'?a,.,, ...i.;i1.' ''' '..- - -----„,,---..„,-, .......ov,. . ti.i....4„.. . . , • ,'-•.'-,,..4.-eF-':•_•-•k•*•:•- ' '•.•‘-' -, ••.f.',1_.: a - .,-. g &''-'' '`)1 ....'v.''ir -,,...t.•‘..;•••;:-'••• ''''`., ,D.-,, s•,•.. .„. .,,_.........." -vm• i i •a e - '---, - i r,-:•-"-t-..-;-.: 4-4-...- .;.i..5.... -•, -. -' - -.- -.., : t - :•----- .4 a 1;•:•?•.--;,•.,-,ti- ,.. .-t•.:" ,..,,.4, . ,--0... •-0 4,",..:: . •-., --. •' ••2_4.•,•;m:-_..' -,=•---* ; -B -• 1" ---1.1;-1:-:".; ''';?'-';`,... -"•'.- ;z7"k', -.•--; • - • / ' '' '.<-1-.'..2' kiV I ' '-..f::::_. -c--7.--, 1 k1-- ..,•_.: ,.-„,-----:-----:::?-' ''7'A t ...L.' ' . .: .•----- -'''''' -:'',-----.-.4. - 1 ..,-,.--•(• , 1 ,;:1.• ----. . • - •, ... . -,- . ...;•-r--,--1,--_. — -_.- -= ,-. .110, I • ...vaffleion-Th:---. .. I .:.. "----•-••••:.• 1 %r,-, c3 .- :-'--7.--',,...'. ` ...:, t...,..".7........-..1/1 ' . . 4 —- ....- -- - ,.....- :-....7.7.....---....,* .,.=.1,...-- , :'-'-•:---- 1_„..-4'-- .. .' '•''': - -7-^-^'•'<'_'-- ''T'':., •...i...''-,-'-:,:4;.i..,;'''' ....- _. -7, -:•-•-• :....„-- -- -,-.4. -.• --.,-,-t------- 17,•-•,e'•,,--'• .: :•,,1 - . f W--17 - • -4.-..---- --- - - ----. - -re--., -.......,....„.„,..,r7 -------- •-.10,--m .......- -•• . „ , . • • ---c-,---,-:-.*4----....-. ,••-•-.'1'‘--- - '-'•!-- -!:- '..'-,-;,,,„,_•57"3-4- -- - -.-':,' 1',.4 -- ,z,:e1',•6 •,. „.. ;;••,- .---' -&-C11-•;.;,- •--0?, -..•=1"----:72-74------.--';w..N.:•.:"4- ,,•91.:4..”,“- ' a ,,--,-10.:,1-.f•-ex/s-4-1-•--,,,,--•47... .= -..,..,• _A-,...*...-.- -•-* - -- -; --- --- - _-f--------1-`,'-`-:----..----3,2:. -- . • :,. , , e •' •' ..•,.;4;',:-.-.....; . . . ... 4 , -: • .• , - ,: ••••••••• s t . -4 -'1 '..telkv•-• -.s. ' •• __ - - . • 4 ' .. . ..• "3'6 if f;;;i • 1-_,,,;;;;. ..,.. v,.• , '...-- _______ • - - i . I s 7-,-1-r-, • :-. , . ' --I --,•.•• .;.‘ ,s''S;-' .''."' ':•.t, • ''''.2,"'- '•••-'...--z=----.•-• --- -`-':•---=:-.._-----:,. ..:"...w.- :. r../ '4V:,#3 •.,....,,/7.-. 1:.1,4,.. _, „A,,,. , _,,,,,,,, ;-- . \. ..................................— ".............--.._'-'4r•-%..Z....=........... ......--='.....---..... ...., i ..-------•----------„i. --.. ............._____::_,..n.,--..........7.;,. f'___,_.z....._,` :,../. ..it.Ati... l'!„-ff.qi VT.:,. . ,' 1)1 ....... .---........,...." --___. .---___.----___,..___----_, - 1- -'5' ' 7-•=-.''=---- ________ ----.._:--••••••••'7_---___--•:,- .s't -•"-"Y-,-."---,-.....„_ -.__•-- f t ----"----- -------- ' ' - ',•,-, - , ,......., t •• A i —_______------ -____-----__•-----__---- i .• -1• „•••-_—_. ---_---.---•—_-__,_ -I ...,,,,,,3„-z -t ' - --- '. .t..?.•- __________ ..L ._-_.--__ __ ----_,-___,____, --------- _ --- . _ ,.. _ _' •:.,._ _ _ i .. .... .• — .., - „..,. - .,. . ,.---,-, ,,4 C...,61„'''''''-':-••'-''. ).•,: -.'%.c1".. . . 1 -'-' ' _- -'" - ,..•.„..: -.,-.... `"4:•-/•-;:.'5. '...'• --- - 1 '''-':.".' . * ••; :.# I • • ",•••=:-'-. -7,.•,c...;.rzt-?•*".• ''.:•.,'F.t ' .. •4:, ' • 1 ';' , -4,g ---; .,:,1 _ - - I i-,-,,- .-',.. -' ' -er..' ... ....., - -,- -.....{•... • .. :.`..-- -•-:•-••:- . . ; ;:,::: ; Le--'..t•-it. Li -_ T.-- ....: ..; : _‘. • a •- ' . • - — .,..-.e-•,,-: . - ri, I:if-----r---.I. -- z--;,-.1......,4 ..-.z,s.7 , , 4...,;':" :, . •.. t - " - • i.,,, -. .r.t.:,-.41.,=---.- •..--A •. i ' Etrrtir ,r1C1; .. '• . :,II, 1 !A I"I' . '. '''• . • ' %-r.."`"?"! • • -:- Z,,,-.7.--;. .11,r;:''.••./q.:4,-,..;-- i i7 • . • P. ' ' _ u....* ...=2F7.1- r ....r-. if-_ __ - - • , • •,,,,•;.,•,:.,-•_ ,.__•••„.... _ ,_—_. ._ -....a ._____ ....,,A•-:‘ ., - .. . .•- -,-._ ,-,,_ . ___•--.- _-..- • . . . -- _.. __1....-_* . T.• ,. V" ..,• • • ' # --='..?" -- - - -- ----__.---•-• ,.:,J..-=-::;-:-:-..?-----;---='•1------..-- I • • - ---=---- - --- - __ •--- z-...1,6,----=-1-7:--.-----,-T.-Tr---i-',:-„ „.,..„,., ,-,----- - - - ----.;..- ----,s7.--,L-------.-- --.01.4---.-,••7.......F=-- 1:---- - ":" --• -- :,''•--:--'-7,---'..." .-,-. " -77.,------'• -.---_,,-..• ••.;---_--..,:::.. ..i.-1-1,- Jar .,_ -:"- ..„,___z.,-,....7„.---?-'-.:..-„,:- ,-.-tr‘•-• -.7_5-r.--. -;;_••........._ .:.,,..,--a--.a->.- .--- „•-`.,..f...4:-..--'_-___ :ii4.41- ...,7'... " .. . i , ,_______I,KI.,•'_‹.-.n,....------- ,„,„.......,•-.-•>.-4----.:„.,-- .- -...-.„ ,r•cc__--. ..,... .„_,..,...--sr..f..-„,!:. ,-.a.- . .• •14-CA- - k rr-1 e . 4O LA5 - cc l 1—cknc --"c;`911\c) . Apv-1 1 1c1) 2-c)° • - ••'••-• - •.-..---,•-.--.-,•••s_J.,-:;.'-'',••,•:.,......•",.1:- :-.,:"(:.-,',3------t?-t;;!:::',--,;:=3:-.. --.--i--.----•44-A,-;`,._•:,;••:. ,j • ��,Tom. 4�'i - s- -may .s..�. - -Fo .,-. i--� T 1 -�%� -��`'tfa <x ` .-t ma's 3 4� h� .�.. � - : ,.a _.F-.- 'a- s�'...iZ'� r t F .c ��� -• sue - F %"' '.kr d r f.. � il u.- -. Qs '�` s ' 7 ,,-t b-4,c,.. Ft - tr Y -am 1,-Ic- git t _. x7';,t:f4os . � @ r 2 t 1 's' ks "' ��a.i _ -y _em " `si . '-� : • • • .z - £z .. - c r - A- 2 Va F 5* S "s f 1 .. s{ t l 'r .ri ' .t i. -0 — u ✓ S5 es' ,r., tr ` 3s • 3 ,. .,.. % f . t- _-4 i � `c.,- 4��� , T }.u„ 41 { s,..z""fc ;,. y - :.r; f,:, - ,3 �'af. ''5s- ya r rt � a SV3 iF2 t .� c _3", y4;' r �' +a.'% +.e yc4-.a- v. ce {4,y" 4;1- .rG3 A ' K li; e �k k .4 t 1 .f - K jInfaIs- - e ; - 1. .: tT. a-k-.. - sTrqr i g✓ - n., so ' g h N-✓ `r � I.,✓ d < vs 4u tz- . i> � lr d- 'vT ; ' 3:!;. `-rC+s,.7 . � t tea ---. , . i" ;X S z }. -c s a-- 74 • ,' a S�._.a '-, �r _ rF 3- hs` --,` :iam=-�`'^`"^rs � -"' 2. ' '- 'f' _ _ ` 4 � 4. 4i.7 W � Y 5 y 4 s� • ._+ Y ..-� a4" . a -' ; ' {Y J-c -ae - p-- �Y a? yea '( -S •,, _ } 5'- - Tyra. s. '4 -5- :a. ,-.'7,. t57 - f t '�S�f}-t' ''. ,r` I !-AT s• "? _ter" "..'s J - s? .-� ,.f. i 'l al s....a.�� R�-+ irLi \__.... _ { ge4 ,y, ``ate.,.*_- --s- .�-, its z..'-t'e- tt- "C� . .l p 1a: -' ' '- -'4-!:1 -max'_ siwr .li k 1 .p- .- _ r." .,,, , .,'-----1,---3744114-44',ikN4'&4- --= -- -.--',-:.7,i,•,:!-A ; .i t - �' ; 9 t;:--,,,,11:,':--;;; ''. (-\,‘P—v is. - {_ r ice, 04:.--y` t .. { �, v r` -z - ..+ ('� 1 - LQ li - '- F - tt1``r -# s - -ter-SZ t :-,2-} t - { . t -- i` 0. 'X -s'�4,4,. ' t'' sip---+— ' 3ri-t':5"-..- 's a- -- '.+ d s -a -.' � .,z x` %*<_0 .--, a,tz� " =-1 .� . °E' t to --- -�_ `% _Y`2•. 'a r �`f =gnu' s �slk 5'�-s + '�` ,6t 3. ', ?,E�• c'�' ,z k --- �- - t{' _ -..+� € w '�-� € -''�. -- *`,i -vim 1. A i - "- ? ,a aw,} `=�: z; ''.Sv z _ r 9 ;; ,+a z e p r z.. 4 5.: % ((� r- s'F s �. . , �� ..ya y _ i""' _. rr f 1€ �-e x.h s 47 _ $ t .V_! �. S .i-r-, • - F i"s="- '3e r,p_ y Y' • - -u� u.�'�'---fi t .'�a'..- -r� r ter,.. 1. 7 --a z :-4. .--.:k.-: .rs• .1.4- . ` � = ''r3 "-- `�_ Fi .{ice c-__- -ate -t-:'` -> . -'+e- ?-- i -� ` �.,c S, 7 y - -ac`- r _ i 5 y = `•,--sue'. _--.- t,4-..,w - =,''? -,75INE,.-s ° `0`3.,.- ` ,A,W7'Zic- '`y1 �'Y .1 . r� A - e: � '*t • raxr - .' V. • • • F • 1.7Z-aii amino tj ==. - • =-= =i= =men =1=:•=r...„LP•mon.-.01•=r.- • LISE id/L,171N6 prrvioe. •WHICH DLOoK TH SLIk1 LJT ALLOW A\1 MOVE_MENT LOUVE.rS rKovvr -FLLIS- L-16HT • • J - J • ri ISOLAT HEATGffHEK'crING 1.1cH ICIT&HN\is A,HP LAUHIS mom LIVINO - - 111111-- ‘ t illtalli,- It tL .. .4- s' '• :: .:- 2.1 1: --T 1 iiilr*0 Pr_ IGKIrD FO MAYIMum vrkrriLA\TIONE avr_, LiNrri m7-rHouGH THE HOVIr- . f CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH kraal l R i p 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE • DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 • 561/243-7000 All-America City 1 ' 1993 SPECIAL COURTESY NOTICE TO YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD 2001 ASSOCIATION The purpose of this special courtesy notice is to inform you that at its Meeting to be held on WEDNESDAY, JUNE 15, 2005, the Historic Preservation Board will consider a request for proposal to have the Sewell C. Biggs House designated as a local historic site. The meeting begins at 6:00 p.m. and will be held in the City Commission Chambers, City Hall 100 NW 1st Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida. The following is a brief description of the project. The plans are available for review at the Planning and Zoning Department. If you would like to obtain additional information on this project please feel free to contact Warren Adams, Historic Preservation Planner at 243-7040. If you cannot attend this meeting but would like to be heard on the project, you may submit your comments as follows: By fax at (561) 243-7221 By e-mail at pzmail@mydelraybeach.com By regular mail at 100 NW 1st Avenue, Delray Beach, FL 33444 The subject property is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (north end of Seabreeze Avenue). The Historic Preservation Board has studied the historical significance of this property and deems it worthy of consideration for placement in the Local Register of Historic Places. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places. A copy of the designation report is available in the Planning & Zoning Department at City Hall. Date Mailed: June 1 , 2005 THE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS L, Printed on Recycled Paper _ uu ! IilI ! N.E. 5TH ST. Z Li Z I ISIND DRIVE a a J ce _ in > LT J ' Q \ I ,z N.E. 4TH ST. n BEACH DRIVE Li > MI l i I f-- SEA SPRAY AVE. w > Q SANDOWAY LANE o WATERWAY LANE a o = Q oZ ce 7 LAING ST. N.E. 3RD SI. \ MAR p VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE sou F. LLI Z w LiQ DORCHESTER z [3..N.E. 2ND ST. CO-OP THOMAS STREET - EAST WIND BEACH CLUB J C4-:Q BERKSHIRE I— Li DRIVE Z N.E. 1ST CT. Cr) BY THE SEA z Q , a Li GROSVENOR 0 m < Q C_) LOWRY LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. CONDO 2 Q E z VETERANS DELRAY _ s A. SUMMIT vw GROVE NO. 2 ATLANTIC PARK I— CONDO ill N CONDO PLAZA z // Li Q CD I Lr BARR N TERRACE I� CONDO SPANISH DELRAY BEACH RIVER MARRIOTT cv0 RESORT ATLANTIC AVENUE N --igimr- THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL SASE MAP SYSTEM -- - MAP REF: LM833 Jam and Smudge Free Printing www.avery.com 0 AVERY® 5960TM. Use Aveiy®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY • JERRY FRANCIOSA PROD ' 939 EVE STREET DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 i ; CAROLYN ZIMMERMAN PRESIDENTS COUNCIL 212 SW 2ND AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FL 33444 BOB SPAVERO BEACH PROPERTY OWNERS ' ASSOCIATION 200 MACFARLANE DR. APT 605 • DELRAY BEACH, FL 33483 BI4 W D CHANIBE 'OF COMMERCE 64 SE TH AVENUE DELRA CH, FL 33483 • • • Aa3AV-09-008-I. ■_ • DI1096S Ilaege6 al zasiii;n ,L0966 al 1?IaAb l VI//\ I IInl•AC Ianpannnnnn abide.'a6eu as e Ia a6e unogque uoissaidw ccc �/ DO 1 QUESTRCVH' INSURANCE BILLER ti vuo Ogu 7 -VV74 Private home health la 9°�rCO1°_. agency in Boca seeks a off "`""' F/T Human Resources I news.COn1 Generalist with experienceVATE PARTY RATES EMPLOYMENT RATES in a private home careagency, strong computer and organizational skills. Please fax resume to: $55.95 $95.55 $135.15 561-347-7567 or call I SALES MERCHANDISE - 11 561-347-7566 1: 5 lines/1 day 5lines/5 days 5 lines/10 days . — I. 218 1— i 50 $1000 or less $2500 or less y �gg�Ny items my include pricers) Items must i avde Pets). rcom 13 SALES/MARKETING is days $9.95 $20.00 FREE AD 20 EMPLOYMENT Igo sale signs. 5linesr5 days 5 lines/5 days $2501 and over. For Merchandise — i 200 I MOWN • TATE ASK ABOUT $250 or less $30 00 OUR DAILY For Private Party Advertisers Only, PROFESSIONAL HIRING Re will run your ad for 5 days/5 toes. It/Sale 5 fines 5 days SPECIALS Dee'ce"to itemiViogl tos)mint ta$2 Rcite"or Nees regist ecollred d architect ra ed and or CLASSIne ADVERTISING ;' 120.00 COMMERCIAL RATES person w/exp incl. autocad. Fax Grleylpdays CLASSIFIED DEADLINES resume to:561-347-0220 The Boca Raton News is BOCA FIRM NOW HIRING .Net o C ♦ RUN DAY PLACE AD BY looking for energetic •TI VE $50.00 $80 50 $130 0O Programmer, Web ricer; motivated team player •Monday • Friday before a 5pm open, Content Writer; to take classified ads •Tuesday Monday before Graphic Designer Fax or over the phone as well 5lines✓1 day 5lines/5days 5 lines/10 days Wednesday Email res to: 561-750- as sell clssified prod- rine •T Friday Wednesday before5pm 6795,infoecendyn.com ucts. Exc.phone/comp. 1 •Fr d day COUNSELOR ASST. (Male), skills. Prior exp.a plus. /5WE/�CGEI •Sunday, Friday before 5pm needed to assist wonder- Email resume to: •Sunda Friday before Spin ful& bright 6 yr.old boy nsmith@bocanews.com MA Yet Real Estate mursday before 5Pm w/mild attention issues at or fax 561-893-6674 013 months) •d:MA , l J No" Guide summer camp in Coconut RE AGENTS New & exp'd Creek.Must be 17,patient for busy E&W Boca Guar mature & willing to take leads.We give you all the sdelor 1 — 100 100 100 irer staff.isn. Salary nego- ' noun tools for success. Clients tiable.F/T.561-445-3715. waiting.Call Marjie 561- LEGAL NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES GULFSTREAM GOODWILL 400-5367 INDUSTRIES INC. South I 228 id the term of the Franchise Agree- below - requested electronically Ad#1223E0 Operations is seeking t front one year to floe years and by contacting Jean Full/PartTime ADC Atten- ide a provision for a performance AB creditors of the decedent and other TRADES I;providing for severability,pro- persons having claims or demands Moorefield at jmoorefield - dants to work in Boynton g for repealer,providing for codie- against decedent's estate on whom a @delraycra.org.Propos- PIIBtKBALE Beach & Boca West to •n:providing an effective date copy of this notice is served within als may be filed with the accept donations, and A1C TECH AND HELPER. Need three months after the date of the first CRA until 2pm on Tues- TO BE HELD JUNE 17,2005 AT 2:00 look after attended dona- - own toolsftrans .Call 561- Ordinance No.4878 publication of this notice must file their P p claims with this Court WITHIN THE day July 5,2005. PM THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE tion center area and 392-1419,756-2457. rdinance of the City of Boca Raton LATER OF THREE MONTHS AFTER BELIEVED TO BE THE CONTENTS OF grounds. We orizing and directing the Mayor THE DATE OF THE FIRST PUBUCA- Howard Ellingsworth, STORAGEIG U�LOCATED BOCA AT ABTON opy competitive and vide ��� pp Own truck / City Clerk to execute Construction TION OF THIS NOTICE OR THIRTYP salary tools.Apply in person 215 Demolition Debris Rolloff Coo- DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF SERVICE Chairman BLVD., BOCA RATON, FL 33431 excellent benefits (mod- N.Fed.H Ste.#1 Boca r Service Franchise Agreements OF A COPY OF THIS NOTICE ON Diane Colonna,Secretary WHICH BOCA STORAGE HOLDS A ical, dental, life, depen- . or fax 561-392-3561. TO the vendors identified in F thit MEM- Community Redevelop- LIENSTAT trP U 06 FOR UNPAID RENT dent life, 403b, PTO). Plances;ursuant to Chapter 14,Code of )All other creditors of the decedent and merit Agency FOR THE FOLLOWING TENANTS: Please call Nat S.at(56 252 I—I. —.clin for repealer, for severability, persons having claims or demands Delray Beach 833-1693. EOE M/F/DN [rye date Galen providing against the decedent's estate must file 561-276-8640 Unit/329 David Gribble Misc. PRE.IK TEACHER EXPERIENCED • their claims with this court WITHIN Unit/612 Party Events Inc.Misc. DOMESTN: • ICE: It sc. for Christian pre-school in THREE MONTHS AFTER Unit#2123RobertSassM arty decision of City Coun- THE FIRST PUBLICATION OF THIS NOTICE OF PUBLIC NEARING Unit Y2125 Robert Sass Misc. Boca Raton. Please call fleas you, and NOTICE.ALL CLAIMS NOT SO FILED Unit#2409Amedeo Belmonte Misc. 561-391-2171. HOUSEKEEPER Part time.Ref- al any decision made at this meet-e WILL BE FOREVER BARRED. Pursuant to Section 4.5.1(A),(B)and Unit/2703 Christian Eminente Misc. 1 - vith respect to any matter consid- (C)of the Land Development Regula- Unit#2707 Edward Anthony Misc. ` erencee flex.hours. hr. you may need to ensure that a NOTWITHSTANDING THE TIME PERI- lions,the Historic Preservation Board - 202 1 lish speaking.$10 per hr. arm record of the proceedings is ODS SET FORTH ABOVE,ANY CLAIM .of the City of Delray Beach will conduct THE PROCEEDS OF ABOVE ITEMS TO Boca call 561-393-0087. e,which record includes the testi- FILED TWO(2 YEARS OR MORE a Public Hearing on Wednesday,June BE SOLD SHALL BE APPLIED TO TFN- ENGINEERING HOUSEKEEPER/CHILDCARE for y and evidence upon which the AFTER THE DECEDENT'S DATE OF 15,2005,at 6:00 P.M.in the Commis- ANTS'DELINQUENT ACCOUNT.BOCA al is to be based. (The above DEATH IS BARRED. sion Chambers at City Hall,100 NW 1st STORAGE HAS THE RIGHT TO weekend live-in position, CE is required by State Law. If Avenue. The purpose of the Public REJECT ANY OFFER WHICH DOES STRUCTURAL INSPECTOR for Sat.am-Sun.pm for Boca desire a verbatim transcript,you The date of the first publication of this Hearing is to allow the public to copy- NOT EQUAL NOR EXCEED THE have the responsibility,at your Notice is June 2,2005. ment on a proposal to have The Sewell threshold buildings. Long famiy. Must speak Eng- cost,toarrangeforthetrarscripL) C.Biggs House designated as a local AMOUNTCAS DUE ON THE SCCOOFFERUNT. term employment. Palm hsh.valid drivers license. PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE historic site.Based on the analysis and BOCA SCHASE MAY ALSO PRICEF cordance with the Americans with STEVEN J.SILVERSTEIN testimony presented at the meeting, TO PTOCHASED THE LOT AMOUNTT A UE Beach area.deArgree req. Send excel cleaning, excel ref. iilities Act and Florida Statutes 637 Park Road the Board will make a recommendation NOT SUBJECTT CEAC DUE resume civil de 0e 305-770-0957 Send 561-3 Part time 7 16,persons with disabilities need- west Hartford,CT 06107 to the CityCommission as to its ON ACCOUNT.EACH SALE to: NANNY time to full fime pedal accommodation to partici- meet en he Local Register of Historic SHALLA BE FOR H UNIT.ENTIRE LOT CAN- in this proceeding should contact Places. TAMED IN EACH 204 child care, light house- I: in of the City Clerk at 393-7741 ATTORNEY FOR "ALL SALES ARE CASH GAI FS" keeping, some errands. st three business days prior to the PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE: The historic site is located at 212 Own car preferred. Refs eeding (whenever possible) to DONALD M.ALLISON,ESQUIRE Seabreeze Avenue). Delray Beach, Publish:June 2&9,2005 ACCOUNTING required.561-504-5280. st such accommodation. Gillespie&Allison,P.A. Florida.--The legal description of the Boca Raton News PT HOUSEKEEPER needed, 1515 South Federal Highway property is as follows: • Shay Caranrrame,CMC Suite 306 Ad 6122375 Sharma City Clerk Boca Raton,Florida 33432 Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, English, 20/hrs.week,must speak . Del Beach Esplanade,accordingto , own mans City of Boca Raton,Florida Rorid 368r No. ray p 1 1 0 NOW Polito RR°riaa Bar No.263958 the plat thereof,as recorded in Plat tion, E Boca, must have ISH:June 2,2005 Book 18,Page 39,Public Records of H I R 1 N G references.561-362-3690 )LINT NO.98842 Publish:June 2&9.2005 Palm Beach Count',Florida. LOST & FOUND 264 ASH PROOF OF PUBLICATION: Boca Raton News 786(62-A) Ad#122376 The Historic Preservation Board has Raton News studied the historical significance of COLLECTIONS f ACCOUNTS • 122351 this property and deems it worthyFOUND white dog, medium NOTICE FOR REQUEST FOR PRO in °f to large size,Lyons&Pal- The Boca Raton News has MIST.EMPLOYMENT IRE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE ISTR pOSAL consideration for placement in the g Y -an immed. opening for a • JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,IN AND FOR Local Register of Historic Places. A motto Park Rd. Call 561- collections / accounting CARPET CLEANER No exp. PALM BEACH COUNTY,FLORIDA The Community Redevel- copy of the designation report is avail- 483-5586 ' person.Must be proficient opment Agency of the able in the Planing&zoning Depart- necessary. Opportunity PROBATE DIVISION City of Delray Beach merit at City Hall. LOST PET SKUNK "Sophie" in Word/Excel/Quick- for advancement. Clean BE NO.:502005 CP DOI838)000TSB (CRA)herebyannounces Please be advised that it aTimberwalk II W Boca, books. Must have excel- ESTATE OF ts Request fr Proposal decides to appeal any decisio person REWARD. Please call if lent customer service DL req.Flexible schedule. • q P . 561-488-0101 lv msg. • (RFP)for the acquisition by the Historic PreseratonBoard with seen or found 561-271- skills. To apply for this 1IL SILVERSTEIN, from the CRA of property respect to any matter considered at this - 1609 position email resume to: I 268 located at 127 SW 2nd nmeeting eed hearing, into willch person ebaez@bocanews.com proceedings,and PART•TIME NOTICE TO CREDITORS Avenue,legally described for this purpose such person may need � 1 124 208 as Lots 5&6,Block 54, to ensure that a verbatim record of the EMPLOYMENT administration of the estate of of proceedings is made. Such record the Resubdivision of TH M.SILVERSTEIN.deceased, includes the testimo and evidence PERSONALS C.LERICALXIFFICEf PART TIME Mini storage com- e date of death was December 25. the S 1/2 Block 54,Del- upon which the appeal is to be based. SECRETARIAL g and whose Social Securiyg Nun- ray Beach,by qualified The city does not provide or prepare plex, 3-9:30pm every it Court for 7Pd nty,is p�lm Beadmm in the entities for the purpose of such record pursuatrtto F.S.286.0105. WIDOW FEMALE, Financially +xp. wpm other wk-end.Light maint a,Probate Division,the address constructing affordable CITY OF DELRAY BEACH secure,pretty seeks mar- dictaphone. Some Sats. /night duty 561-392-4549 sick is.-So.Palm Beach County housing.The REP pack- Chevelle D.Nubin riage&committed person req. Boca RE office. Fax PERSONAL ASST.to real estate house,200 W.Atlantic Avenue, age is available at the City Clerk age 60-65.Reply Box N-3, 561-392-8938. prof.Knowledge of Word, ,ail addressesida per- . office of the CRA at 20 Boca Raton News, 5801 p. uicken & Excel. Good representative and tie personal North Swinton Avenue, Boca Rat June 2a zoos N. Congress Ave, Boca Boca RE ofc. Some Sats. organiz skills, bkkpg. PT senta°ve';:attorney are set forth Delray Beach,or may be Boca Raton/Delray seam News Raton,FL 33487 req.Fax 561-392-8938. flex hours.561-99 093. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH bitid 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 561/243-7000 All•AmencaCdy NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING 1993 Pursuant to Section 4.5.1(A), (B) and (C) of the Land Development Regulations, 2001 the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach will conduct a Public Hearing on Wednesday, June 15, 2005, at 6:00 P.M. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue. The purpose of the Public Hearing is to allow the public to comment on a proposal to have The Sewell C. Biggs House designated as a local historic site. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places. The historic site is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida (see attached map). The legal description of the property is as follows: Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. The Historic Preservation Board has studied the historical significance of this property and deems it worthy of consideration for placement in the Local Register of Historic Places. A copy of the designation report is available in the Planning & Zoning Department at City Hall. If you would like further information on the proposed action, please contact Warren Adams at the Planning and Zoning Department, City Hall 100 NW 1st Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida 33444 (e-mail at adams@mydelraybeach.com), Phone 561/243-7040, between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M. on weekdays (excluding holidays). All interested parties are invited to attend the public hearings and comment upon the proposed action or submit their comments in writing on or before the date of the hearing to the Planning and Zoning Department. Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such person will need a record of the proceedings, and for this purpose such person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record pursuant to F.S.286.0105. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Planning and Zoning Department Date Mailed: June 1, 2005 THE EFFORT ALWAYS I.: Printed on Recycled Paper if- No- N.E. 5TH ST. Z w Z 1 ISLAND DRIVE ¢ Q J U) L In i W Z ec r--(17.. N.E. 4TH ST. BEACH DRIVE Z .¢ Li > W l SEA SPRAY AVE. Li > Q SANDOWAY LANE oWATERWAY LANE a Z J _ O _ Y ¢ Z Z I- ¢- 03 2 J LAING ST. `, N.E. 3RD ST. I M R RI p VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE SNF LAI z Li ¢ Li '� DORCHESTER Z r CO—OP I THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. z EAST WIND c_ BEACH CLUB h J J� Q v BERKSHIRE I— J w DRIVE Z N.E. 1ST CT. (t) �, BY THE SEA z Q U, w GROSVENOR I C 0 m z U • I ¢ HOUSE LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. Q CONDO Z o Z VETERANS D DELRAY . STA. SUMMIT in GROVE NO. 2 ATLANTIC PARK I-- CONDO w w CONDO a PLAZA z I /., w wcc Q a I BARR TERRACE I�' CONDO SPANISH DELRAY BEACH r� RIVER MARRIOTT co RESORT ATLANTIC AVENUE N --isms— THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH: FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- - MAP REF: LM833 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Pursuant to Section 4.5.1(A), (B) and (C) of the Land Development Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach will conduct a Public Hearing on Wednesday, June 15, 2005, at 6:00 P.M. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue. The purpose of the Public Hearing is to allow the public to comment on a proposal to have The Sewell C. Biggs House designated as a local historic site. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places. The historic site is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue), Delray Beach, Florida. The legal description of the property is as follows: Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. The Historic Preservation Board has studied the historical significance of this property and deems it worthy of consideration for placement in the Local Register of Historic Places. A copy of the designation report is available in the Planning & Zoning Department at City Hall. Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such person will need a record of the proceedings, and for this purpose such person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record pursuant to F.S.286.0105. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Chevelle D. Nubin City Clerk PUBLISH: Delray/Boca News June 2, 2005 Note: This advertisement must be placed in the Classified section under "Legal notices" Thank you. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH battil 100 N.W. 1st AVENUE • DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 561/243-7000 All•AmencaCity 1 1111 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING 1993 Pursuant to Section 4.5.1(A), (B) and (C) of the Land Development Regulations, 2001 the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Delray Beach will conduct a Public Hearing on Wednesday, June 15, 2005, at 6:00 P.M. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue. The purpose of the Public Hearing is to allow the public to comment on a proposal to have The Sewell C. Biggs House designated as a local historic site. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places. The historic site is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida (see attached map). The legal description of the property is as follows: Lot 21 and the West 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, Page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. The Historic Preservation Board has studied the historical significance of this property and deems it worthy of consideration for placement in the Local Register of Historic Places. A copy of the designation report is available in the Planning & Zoning Department at City Hall. This public notice is being provided as your property is located within a five hundred (500) foot radius of the subject property (shaded area on map). If you would like further information on the proposed action, please contact Warren Adams at the Planning and Zoning Department, City Hall 100 NW 1st Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida 33444 (e-mail at adams@mydelraybeach.com), Phone 561/243-7040, between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M. on weekdays (excluding holidays). All interested parties are invited to attend the public hearings and comment upon the proposed action or submit their comments in writing on or before the date of the hearing to the Planning and Zoning Department. Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such person will need a record of the proceedings, and for this purpose such person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record pursuant to F.S.286.0105. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Planning and Zoning Department Date Mailed: June 1, 2005 HE EFFORT ALWAYS MATTERS is Printed on Recycled Paper —I I . II II 1 II ( I J I ` N.E. 5TH ST. z Ld z C ISLAND DRIVE a _ c , I _ >- � Q w u z \ 1 z o /''� z N.E. 4TH ST. t BEACH DRIVE w > -. LLI SEA SPRAY AVE. C-- Li > Q a . . [ I I I SANDOWAY LANE f oWATERWAY LANE a z J ' p - = I Q Z Z Q' H. I— N J I-2 .J CO �� LAING ST. N.E. 3RD ST. \ I I I I M IV I 'C '' VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE II 1 1Ii11 S w / I 1 Z I W Z a ¢ DORCHESTER CO-OP I THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. EAST WIND = z Z J (It BEACH CLUB 1 1 f BERKSHIRE I— J W N.E. 1ST CT. o R I v = BY THE SEA cn Q 1 1 I J Qcr GROSVENOR i1 , o CD - 1 Co 1 Q HOUSE U LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. 1 1 Q I _ CONDO Z DELRAY _ SAE • VETERANS SUMMIT GROVE NO. 2 ATLANTIC PARK CONDO w wIV CONDO PLAZA z I //� w a BARR w TERRACE11/ CONDO SPANISH ; ' DELRAY BEACH Q RIVER MARRIOTT 0 RESORT 1 ATLANTIC AVENUE N THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM833 Jam and Smudge Free Printing MEE www.avery.com o AVERY® 5960TM Use Avery®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY 12-43-46-16-18-000-0210 12-43-46-16-17-000-0070 COURTENAY E H&VIRGINIA W HAPGOOD ELAINE P RADIUSe0-500 ' 212 SEABREEZE AVE 1030 WATERWAY LN DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7154 12-43-46-16-17-000-0080 12-43-46-16-17-000-0090 12-4346-16-17-000-0100 GLICKSTEIN CARY FRIED SAMUEL P& GLICKSTEIN CARY 1118 WATERWAY LN 230 PARKVIEW AVE S 1118 WATERWAY LN DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7156 BEXLEY OH 43209- 1650 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7156 12-43-46-16-17-000-0110 12-43-46-16-17-000-0120 12-43-46-16-18-000-0010 BROWN BROS CADILLAC INC SELLERS KATHLEEN R CARNEY PETER H& 728 S 4TH ST 316 ANDREWS AVE 1137 VISTA DEL MAR DR LOUISVILLE KY 40202-2104 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7165 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0021 12-43-46-16-18-000-0040 12-43-46-16-18-000-0051 COURCHENE PAUL L& COURCHENE PAUL L MCCARTY-LAWRENCE K 1119 VISTA DEL MAR N 1119 N VISTA DEL MAR DR 1109 VISTA DEL MAR DR N DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 12-43-46-16-18-000-0070 12-43-46-16-18-000-0080 12-43-46-16-18-000-0090 GRAVETT STEPHEN& KEITH TIM P VISTA DRIVE ASSOCIATES LLC 1101 N VISTA DEL MAR DR 324 NORTH RD 5302 MILL STREAM DR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 BEDFORD MA 01730- 1016 ' SAINT CLOUD FL 34771 -8709 12-43-46-16-18-000-0100 ' 12-43-46-16-18-000-0110 12-43-46-16-18-000-0120 PETER ARTHUR C& CASTER RICHARD F& CHALAL JOSEPH B& 1017 N VISTA DEL MAR 39 NE SIXTH AVE 5009 NW 24TH CIR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7143 ' DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5421 BOCA RATON FL 33431 -4329 12-43-46-16-18-000-0130 12-43-46=16-18=000-0140 12-43-46-1 6-18-000-0151 LOT 13 ESPLANADE PHILLIPS MARTHA P SCHMIER ROBERT J& 1515 S FEDERAL HWY 1002 VISTA DEL MAR 1008 VISTA DEL MAR #300 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BOCA RATON FL 33432-7451 • 12=43-46-16-18-000-0152 12=43-46-16-18-00010170 12-43-46-16-18-000-0180 GRAHAM KRISTIANE C TR DUANE PATRICIA JONES KELLY PO BOX 936 1020 S VISTA DEL MAR DR 1028 VISTA DEL MAR MIDDLEBURG VA 20118-0936 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7150 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0191 12-43-46-16-18-000-0221 12-43-46-16-18-000-0240 MILLER JAMES& RHODES PAUL TY JR& REEVES ROBERT F 9755 PATUXENT WOODS DR 1121 VISTA DEL MAR DR 1118 VISTA DEL MAR DR S COLUMBIA MD 21046-2286 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7152 12-43-46-16-18-000-0250 12-43-46-16-18-000-0260 12-43-46-16-18-000-0270 MERLAU ANN& HOFFMAN HOWARD& WINITSKY HOWARD 1124 VISTA DEL MAR 218 ANDREWS AVE 220 ANDREWS AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7102 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7102 J1213A`d-O9-008-L W096S 1!aege6 el Zas!i!1n 3096S ®AZ13AV IC wonruanewuwa wiliNilm apldea a6etpas a 1a,a6eaanogque uo!ssaidwi Jam and Smudge Free Printing www.avery.com n AVERYO 5960TM Use Avery®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY I ►� 12-43-46-16-18-000-0282 12-43-46-16-18-000-0300 12-43-46-16-18-000-0281 MARINCOLA FRANCIS& PODSAID PATRICK A TR STIGLI4JO A GERARD JR 1138 VISTA DEL MAR DR S 1126 VISTA DEL MAR 1130 VISTA DEL MAR DR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7152 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0311 12-43-46-16-18-000-0321 - 12-43-46-16-18-000-0340 MCCARTHY JOHN L HOOVER ALLIANN HARRIS TR GEIGER DAVIS E ET AL 1114 VISTA DEL MAR DR 1108 VISTA DEL MAR DR 28TH FL CITIZENS PLAZA DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 LOUISVILLE KY 40202 12-43-46-16-18-000-0350 12-43-46-16-18-000-0361 12-43-46-16-18-000-0371 VARGAS THEODORE SMITH LAWRENCE L& MISKEW STEVEN 920 ORCHID LN 3614 GLENVIEW AVE 1012 VISTA DEL MAR DR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6118 GLENVIEW KY 40025-7502 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0390 - 12-43-46-16-18-000-0401 12-43-46-16-18-000-0421 REUBINS STEPHANIE SNYDER JEAN S -- MCMILLEN VIRGINIA N 1015 VISTA DEL MAR DR BLACKBURN RD VIRGINIA N MCMILLEN TR HLDR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 PO BOX 85 1103 VISTA DEL MAR SEWICKLEY PA 15143-0085 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0431-_ 12-43-46-16-18-000-0450 12-43-46-16-18-000-0460 JONES RICHARD C& SCHAPPERT KEN &JANE RHODES PAUL T JR&JUNE 1111 VISTA DEL MAR DR S 1117 VISTA DEL MAR DR 1121 VISTA DEL MAR DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7151 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 12-43-46-16-18-000-0470 - 12-43-46-16-18-000-0500 12-43-46-16-19-000-0210 ROCKEFELLER MARGARET K DELRAY BEACH CITY OF UDERITZ DONALD& 1127 VISTA DEL MAR 100 NW 1ST AVE 126 SEABREEZE AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 12-43-46-16-19-000-0221 _ —" - - -12-43-46-16-19-000-0231 12-43-46-16-19-000-0240 DE RHAM GLENNA M ' GLAIZE FRED L III & DE BAPTISTE ROBIN P& 134 SEABREEZE AVE 142 SEABREEZE AVE 202 SEABREEZE AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 12-43-46-16-19-000-0251 12-43-46-16-19-000-0252 12-43-46-16-19-000-0253 DUANE PATRICIA B TR GRAHAM BENJAMIN H TURKELL ANDREW A& 1020 S VISTA DEL MAR DR PO BOX 936 204 SEABREEZE AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7150 MIDDLEBURG VA 20118-0936 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 12-43-46-16-19-000-0254 12-43-46-16-19-000-0255 12-43-46-16-19-000-0260 SCHMIER ROBERT J& JONES KELLY MAX TERRY G&LINDA 7777 GLADES RD 1028 VISTA DEL MAR 1101 THOMAS ST #310 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 BOCA RATON FL 33434-4150 12-43-46-16-19-000-0271 12-43-46-16-19-000-0290 12-43-46-16-19-000-0320 LAKE LINDA K REDD CARTER C& BESINGER LESLIE A 1111 THOMAS ST 1125 THOMAS ST 125 SEABREEZE AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 � �v AZ13AV-O9-008-I. ,w0965 3Uege6 al zasii! n 3Vd096S 1 %J troy tiane•nnnnnn immim apidei a6eams a a6e.unogiwe uoissaadtui Jam and Smudge Free Printing MOM www.avery.com Q AVERY® 5960Tm Use Avery®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY • 12-43-46-16-19-000-0340 12-43-46-16-19-000-0350 12-43-46-16-19-000-0330 BENNETT JOHN C& DES COGNETS JULIA RIVERS✓CHRISTINA L 137 SEABREEZE AVE 143 SEABREEZE AVE 131 SEABREEZE AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 12-43-46-16-19-000-0420 12-43-46-16-22-007-0010 12-43-46-16-22-007-0020 DELRAY BEACH CITY OF VULTAGGIO TOLE TR BARBAREE FRED D& (YACHT BASIN) 1877 ROYAL PALM WAY 13856 BORA BORA WAY 100 NW 1ST AVE BOCA RATON FL 33432-7443 #C 126 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 ' MARINA DEL REY CA 90292-6885 12-43-46-16-25-000-0150 ' ,12-43-46-16-30-147-0020 12-43-46-16-65-000-0010 POLUDNIAK STEPHEN E& ' ' DELRAY BEACH CITY OF DELLAQUILA SUSAN R TRUST 1202 VISTA DEL MAR DR 100 NW 1ST AVE SUSAN R &FRANK J DELLAQUILA TRS DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7168 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 1841 WINTER RUN CT CHESTERFIELD MO 63017-5674 12-43-46-16-65-000-0020 12-43-46-16-65-000-0030 12-43-46-16-65-000-0040 JOHNFRY • ANSARI ZAKIR H& - MONNIN PROPERTIES LLC 333 15TH ST 130 ANDREWS AVE 11545 OLD OCEAN BLV TEMPEAZ85281 -6611 #3 #D DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7054 OCEAN RIDGE FL 33435-7358 12-43-46-16-65-000-0050 - 12-43-46-16-65-000-0060 12-43-46-16-86-000-0010- REDELHEIM DAVID&JOAN PERRIZO MARY J ZENGAGE JAMES A 130 ANDREWS AVE#5 110 1NTERLACHEN RD 75 NE 6TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7054 HOPKINS MN 55343-8524 #214 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5453 12-43-46-16-86-000-0020 12-43-46-16-86-000-0030 12-43-46-16-86-000-0040 SMITH CLAUDIA T RIESCHER RONALD A SR MONTGOMERY SARA J 1200 THOMAS ST 1200 THOMAS ST 409 MAPLE AVE #B #C DANVILLE KY 40422-1101 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7033 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7033 12-43-46-16-86-000-0050 12-43-46-16-86-000-0060 12-43-46-16-86-000-0070 GLICKSTEIN ROSE H PARKS BARBARA J HEFFERNAN C G&LINDA • PO BOX 1250 246 ANDOVER DR ' 1200 THOMAS ST#G DELRAY BEACH FL 33447-1250 WAYNE NJ 07470-2961 ' DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7034 1243-46-16-86-000-0080 ; 12-43-46-16-99-000-0000 12-43-46-16-99-000-1010 PAYNE KAY B i i DORCHESTER INC MURDAUGH RUTH W 1200 THOMAS ST 200 N OCEAN BLV 200 N OCEAN BLV #H . ; DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 APT N1 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7034 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 1I 12=43-46-16-99-000-1020 12-43-46-16-99-000-1030 12-43-46-16-99-000-1040 JUNK WILLIAM M& CANARY NANCY H SEARCY W TUNSTALL JR 200 N OCEAN BLVD , 200 N OCEAN BLV 200 N OCEAN BLV APT 2N #3N #4N DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 12-43-46-16-99-000-1050 12-43-46-16-99-000-1060 12-43-46-16-99-000-1070 LAUGHTER PEGGY R ARMSTRONG JACK G& • GRUNAU GARY 200 N OCEAN BLV JACK&ELIZABETH ARMSTRONG ET AL 200 N OCEAN BLV #5 TR HLDRS DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 200 N OCEAN BLV #N6 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 ®A��d AAI3AV-O9-008-L .� 096S 3!Jege6 Nzaslll;n �w0965 1`�// X uiortianelIMMA Eim apldei a6eqpas a;a-a6e.unogl;ue uoissaidull Jam and Smudge Free Printing www.avery.com a AVERY® 5960TM. Use Avery®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY 12-43-46-16 C5 000 0011 12-43-46-16-05-000-0020 12-43-46-16-05-000-0021 BILLOW GERALD 0& SEBBA LUCETTE A CHAN4 HARROLD R 1TR 1 CHA 200 ANDREWS AVE LUCETTE A SEBRA TR TITL HLDR 4240 LAKE KE RD W 44004-2106 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7171 200 ANDREWS AVE OH #2A DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7162 12-43-46-16-05-000-0030 12-43-46-16-05-000-0031 12-43-46-16-05-000-0040 PERRONE FRANK ALEXANDER ANN L BUEHLER MARIAN J 200 ANDREWS AVE 200 ANDREWS AVE J M BUEHLER ET AL TR TITL HLDR #3 #3A 200 ANDREWS AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7161 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7161 #4 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7161 12-43-46-16-05-000-0041 JESSE NEIL B TR 9200 SHELBYVILLE RD #517 LOUISVILLE KY 40222-5134 • • • • • • • �l1 A213AV-O9-008-L • 0965 l!aege6 at zesu in 3 4965®AU3AV ICY%1 uao7 AMAVnnnnnn memot apidei a6etpas a;a-a6e.unogriue uoissaadwi Jam and Smudge Free Printing MEM www.avery.com o AVERY® 5960T"' Use Avery®TEMPLATE 5960TM 1-800-GO-AVERY 12-43-46-16;9y-000-1080 12-43-46-16-99-000-1090 12-43-46-16-99-000-1100 DUNNIN�.0 JOHN A BENSON NANCY C KILPATRICK HAROLD D& 200 N OCEAN BLV NANCY C BENSON TR TITL HLDR 200 N OCEAN BLV #8N 200 N OCEAN BLV #N10 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 #N-9 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 12-43-46-16-99-000-2010 12-43-46-16-99-000-2020 12-43-46-16-99-000-2030 VOELKEL ROBERT JR POLLEY KATHLEEN B TR& ROUNSAVALL ROBERT W III& 200 N OCEAN BLV 200 N OCEAN BLV PO BOX 19799 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 #S-2 LOUISVILLE KY 40259-0799 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 12-43-46-16-99-000-2040 12-43-46-16-99-000-2050 12-43-46-16-99-000-2060 JONES DONALD S FRANDEN ROBERT A& HIMMELRIGHT SUZANNE H 200 N OCEAN BLV 200 N OCEAN BLV 200 N OCEAN BLV APT S-4 #S5 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 12-43-46-16-99-000-2070 12-43-46-16-99-000-2080 12-43-46-16-99-000-2090 DRAGISIC SUSAN • DONNELLY GERARD L& MCDONALD PETER J & 14370 HILLSIDE RD 200 N OCEAN BLV 50123 MANLY ELM GROVE WI 53122- 1617 UNIT S8 CHAPEL HILL NC 27517-8569 • DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 12-43-46-16-99-000-2100 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0010 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0020 GREENE BRUCE D CASEY ANITA J BAIRD CURTIS S& 200 N OCEAN BLV 400 GULFSTREAM BLV 3187 W STRIEGEL RD APT S 10 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-4369 #9 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 CARBONDALE IL 62901 -5415 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0030 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0040 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0050 PUGH DAVID J & WOODARD GEORGE WYANA CLAXTON INC 423 ANDREWS AVE 150 ANDREWS AVE 2525 FLORIDA BLV DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7105 #4 #3 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-4952 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0060 12-43-46-16-82-000-0070 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0080 PUGH MARY ATR CASEY ANITA J& TURTURRO KAMI 423 ANDREWS AVE 150 ANDREWS AVE PO BOX 540969 LAKE WORTH FL 33463 #7 LAKE WORTH FL 33454-0969 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0090 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0100 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0110 BANKS TAMMY MCCALL EDWARD F& AYLOTT JAMES A R 150 N ANDREWS AVE 3909 MAURICE DR , 1637 LE ROY AVE #9 DELRAY BEACH FL 33445-3224 ' BERKELEY CA 94709 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0120 . 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0010 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0020 CASEY ANITA J& BROCKWELL THOMAS C& BENNETT JOHN C& 150 ANDREWS AVE • ' 1116 THOMAS ST 137 SEABREEZE AVE #7 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7019 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0030 12-43-46-16-B7-001-0000 12-43-46-16-05-000-0010 BENNETT JOHN C& BENNETT JOHN C& CLORE LEE S& 137 SEABREEZE AVE 137 SEABREEZE AVE PO BOX 21 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 CRESTWOOD KY 40014-0021 �► A213AV-09-008-I. N4096S 3!1ege6 al zasiptn w096S®AU Ad I 1 wortiane AAAA apldeJ a6etoas?la a6eianogi ue uolssaidwi 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0- 500 Page 1 OF 14 1243.46.16.18-000-0210 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- 00 MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 21&W 35 FT OF LT 22 ,COURTENAY E H&VIRGINIA W VALUE-896986 PRICE-53000 PUSE-0100 212 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-218716 DATE-1/1/1973 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 BLDG-221986 BOOK-02129 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-0810 EXC-HX 12.43-46.16.17-000.0070 ACRES- 0.6812 SALE INST- LE MTG- WATERWAY LANE SUB HAPGOOD ELAINE P VALUE-2247247 PRICE-0 PUSE-0100 LT 7&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 1030 WATERWAY LN TAXBL-644401 DATE-12/29/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7154 BLDG-247247 BOOK-16363 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-2000000 PAGE-1639 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-17-000-0080 ACRES- 0.3405 SALE INST- QC MTG- H38 WATERWAY LANE SUB GLICKSTEIN CARY VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 LT 8&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 1118 WATERWAY LN TAXBL-863562 DATE-12/21/2001 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7156 BLDG-13562 BOOK-13241 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-358 EXC- 12-43-46-16-17-000-0090 ACRES- 0.3444 SALE INST- WD MTG- C1H WATERWAY LANE SUB FRIED SAMUEL P& VALUE-0 PRICE-1000000 PUSE-0100 LT 9&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 230 PARKVIEW AVE S TAXBL-1084871 DATE-8/16/2001 TAXDIST-12984 BEXLEY OH 43209-1650 BLDG-234871 BOOK-12887 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-869 EXC- 12-43.46.16.17.000.0100 ACRES- 0.3444 SALE INST- WD MTG- WATERWAY LANE SUB GLICKSTEIN CARY VALUE-1597399 PRICE-165000 PUSE-0100 LT 10&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 1118 WATERWAY LN TAXBL-984728 DATE-10/1/1995 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7156 BLDG-747399 BOOK-08953 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-0176 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-17-000-0110 ACRES- 0.3444 SALE INST- 00 MTG- WATERWAY LANE SUB BROWN BROS CADILLAC INC VALUE-0 PRICE-125000 PUSE-0100 LT 11&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 728 S 4TH ST TAXBL-994733 DATE-1/1/1978 TAXDIST-12984 LOUISVILLE KY 40202-2104 BLDG-144733 BOOK-02985 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-1296 EXC- 12-43-46-16-17-000-0120 ACRES- 0.3444 SALE INST- QC MTG- WATERWAY LANE SUB SELLERS KATHLEEN R VALUE-866506 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 LT 12&N 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG S OF&ADJ TO 316 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-660850 DATE-10/23/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7165 BLDG-16506 BOOK-14429 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-1621 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0010 ACRES- 0.373 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE CARNEY PETER H& VALUE-1369649 PRICE-810000 PUSE-0100 LT 1,E 1/2 OF LT 2&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF& 1137 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-959980 DATE-6/12/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-469649 BOOK-12150 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-900000 PAGE-419 EXC-HX,HX 12.43.46.16.18.000.0021 ACRES- 0.3418 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE COURCHENE PAUL L& VALUE-0 PRICE-790000 PUSE-0000 W 1/2 OF LT 2,LT 3&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF& 1119 VISTA DEL MAR N TAXBL-850000 DATE-3/1/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 BLDG-0 BOOK-16613 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-850000 PAGE-1378 EXC- 5120/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 2 OF 14 12.43-46-16.18.000.0040 ACRES- 0.2943 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE .COURCHENE PAUL L VALUE-0 PRICE-400000 PUSE-0100 LT 4,E 1/2 OF LT 5&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF& 1119 N VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-2104454 DATE-12/15/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 BLDG-1354454 BOOK-10822 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-750000 PAGE-0408 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0051 ACRES- 0.2765 SALE INST- WD MTG- F84 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE MCCARTY LAWRENCE K VALUE-773672 PRICE-250000 PUSE-0100 W 1/2 OF LT 5,LT 6&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF ADJ TO 1109 VISTA DEL MAR DR N TAXBL-174286 DATE-3/1/1994 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 BLDG-23672 BOOK-08198 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-750000 PAGE-0226 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0070 ACRES- 0.1643 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE GRAVETT STEPHEN& VALUE-758609 PRICE-365000 PUSE-0100 LT 7&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 1101 N VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-576183 DATE-5/30/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7145 BLDG-273609 BOOK-11808 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-485000 PAGE-589 EXC-HX,HX,VX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0080 ACRES- 0.1659 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE KEITH TIM P VALUE-0 PRICE-422000 PUSE-0100 LT 8&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 324 NORTH RD TAXBL-507915 DATE-8/24/2000 TAXDIST-12984 BEDFORD MA 01730-1016 BLDG-22915 BOOK-11978 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-485000 PAGE-1625 EXC- 12.43.46.16-18.000.0090 ACRES- 0.1704 SALE INST- WD MTG- W04 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE VISTA DRIVE ASSOCIATES LLC VALUE-0 PRICE-1480000 PUSE-0100 LT 9&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 5302 MILL STREAM DR TAXBL-1143854 DATE-6/11/2004 TAXDIST-12984 SAINT CLOUD FL 34771-8709 BLDG-658854 BOOK-17613 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-485000 PAGE-1427 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0100 ACRES- 0.2062 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE PETER ARTHUR C& VALUE-601013 PRICE-582078 PUSE-0100 LT 10&S 10 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 1017 N VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-576013 DATE-3/13/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7143 BLDG-151013 BOOK-16598 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-450000 PAGE-858 EXC-HX,HX 12-43.46.16.18.000-0110 ACRES- 0.291 SALE INST- QC MTG- F81 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE CASTER RICHARD F& VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0000 LT 11&20 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 39 NE SIXTH AVE TAXBL-903825 DATE-11/1/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5421 BLDG-3825 BOOK-17723 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-900000 PAGE-288 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0120 ACRES- 0.4692 SALE INST- WD MTG- H38 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE CHALAL JOSEPH B& VALUE-0 PRICE-2400000 PUSE-0100 LT 12&20 FT ABND LAING ST LYG N OF&ADJ TO 5009 NW 24TH CIR TAXBL-2100675 DATE-3/11/2002 TAXDIST-12984 BOCA RATON FL 33431-4329 BLDG-675 BOOK-13500 NAV-00412 LAND-2100000 PAGE-203 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0130 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 13 LOT 13 ESPLANADE VALUE-0 PRICE-1975000 PUSE-0100 1515 S FEDERAL HWY TAXBL-3129467 DATE-9/27/2002 TAXDIST-12984 #300 BLDG-1729467 BOOK-14215 NAV-00412 BOCA RATON FL 33432-7451 LAND-1400000 PAGE-1023 EXC- 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 3 OF 14 12-43.46.16.18.000.0140 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 14 PHILLIPS MARTHA P VALUE-1709198 PRICE- PUSE-0100 1002 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-589628 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-209198 BOOK- NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1500000 PAGE- EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0151 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 15/LESS TRGLR TR IN DB624 SCHMIER ROBERT J& VALUE-4086048 PRICE-2550000 PUSE-0100 P413/ 1008 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-4061048 DATE-5/14/2001 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-1686048 BOOK-12560 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-2400000 PAGE-142 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0152 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE TRGLR TR IN LOT 15 IN DB624 GRAHAM KRISTIANE C TR VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 P413&LOT 16 PO BOX 936 TAXBL-1219364 DATE-3/31/2000 TAXDIST-12984 MIDDLEBURG VA 20118-0936 BLDG-19364 BOOK-11718 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1200000 PAGE-1914 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0170 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 17 DUANE PATRICIA VALUE-807780 PRICE-100 PUSE-0100 1020 S VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-309920 DATE-7/1/1988 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7150 BLDG-7780 BOOK-05743 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-800000 PAGE-0690 EXC-HX 12-43.46.16.18-000.0180 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- B06 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 18&W 35 FT OF LT 19 JONES KELLY VALUE-0 PRICE-946000 PUSE-0100 1028 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-706877 DATE-9/30/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-31877 BOOK-17650 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-1276 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0191 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- H38 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE E 30.06 FT OF LT 19,LT 20 MILLER JAMES& VALUE-0 PRICE-1025000 PUSE-0100 9755 PATUXENT WOODS DR TAXBL-1031650 DATE-1/23/2003 TAXDIST-12984 COLUMBIA MD 21046-2286 BLDG-356650 BOOK-14759 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-840 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0221 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE E 30 FT OF LT 22&LT 23 RHODES PAUL TY JR& VALUE-905681 PRICE-770000 PUSE-0100 1121 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-210048 DATE-1/25/2005 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-230681 BOOK-18075 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-1604 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0240 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- DT MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 24 REEVES ROBERT F VALUE-544983 PRICE-325000 PUSE-0100 1118 VISTA DEL MAR DR S TAXBL-285628 DATE-2/9/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7152 BLDG-4983 BOOK-11629 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-540000 PAGE-268 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0250 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 25 MERLAU ANN& VALUE-609007 PRICE-100 PUSE-0100 1124 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-189092 DATE-1/28/1999 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-9007 BOOK-10921 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-600000 PAGE-0670 EXC-HX 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 4 OF 14 • 12-43-46-16-18-000-0260 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 26 'HOFFMAN HOWARD& VALUE-465185 PRICE-460000 PUSE-0100 218 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-389019 DATE-5/2/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7102 BLDG-36515 BOOK-15204 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-450000 PAGE-305 EXC-HX,HX 12.43.46.16.18.000.0270 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 27 WINITSKY HOWARD VALUE-603942 PRICE-181900 PUSE-0100 220 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-136007 DATE-10/1/1994 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7102 BLDG-153942 BOOK-08451 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-450000 PAGE-0829 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0281 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 28/LESS TR IN OR678P641/ STIGLIANO A GERARD JR VALUE-810401 PRICE-175000 PUSE-0100 1130 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-180192 DATE-7/1/1995 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-135401 BOOK-08855 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-1758 EXC-HX 12-43.46.16-18-000.0282 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- R30 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE TR IN LT 28 IN OR678P641& MARINCOLA FRANCIS& VALUE-808750 PRICE-1 PUSE-0100 LOT 29 1138 VISTA DEL MAR DR S TAXBL-217655 DATE-10/16/2001 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7152 BLDG-133750 BOOK-13029 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-1370 EXC-JX 12.43.46.16.18.000-0300 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 30&E 35 FT OF LT 31 PODSAID PATRICK A TR VALUE-0 PRICE-230000 PUSE-0100 1126 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-829024 DATE-9/1/1981 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-179024 BOOK-03602 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-650000 PAGE-0134 EXC- 12-43.46.16.18.000.0311 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- F33 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE W 30.28 FT OF LT 31&E 50 FT MCCARTHY JOHN L VALUE-698446 PRICE-530000 PUSE-0100 OF LT 32 1114 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-411442 DATE-12/28/1999 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-148446 BOOK-11538 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-550000 PAGE-1970 EXC-HX,HX 12.43-46.16.18.000.0321 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- LE MTG- IPP DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE W 25.13 FT OF LT 32&LT 33 HOOVER ALLIANN HARRIS TR VALUE-606298 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 1108 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-194204 DATE-4/20/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-6298 BOOK-11794 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-600000 PAGE-1983 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0340 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- 00 MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 34 GEIGER DAVIS E ET AL VALUE-0 PRICE-34500 PUSE-0100 28TH FL CITIZENS PLAZA TAXBL-657010 DATE-1/1/1970 TAXDIST-12984 LOUISVILLE KY 40202 BLDG-107010 BOOK-01796 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-550000 PAGE-0000 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0350 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 35&E 10 FT OF LT 36 VARGAS THEODORE VALUE-0 PRICE-436000 PUSE-0000 920 ORCHID LN TAXBL-585000 DATE-4/17/2001 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6118 BLDG-0 BOOK-12464 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-585000 PAGE-1699 EXC- 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 5 OF 14 • 12.43.46.16.18.000.0361 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 36/LESS E 10 FT/&E 10 FT SMITH LAWRENCE L& VALUE-0 PRICE-250000 PUSE-0100 OF LT 37 3614 GLENVIEW AVE TAXBL-605618 DATE-12/1/1990 TAXDIST-12984 GLENVIEW KY 40025-7502 BLDG-105618 BOOK-06715 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-500000 PAGE-1115 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0371 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 37/LESS E 10 FT/&LT 38 MISKEW STEVEN VALUE-0 PRICE-790000 PUSE-0100 1012 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-681923 DATE-9/17/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-6923 BOOK-14201 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-675000 PAGE-536 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0390 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 39&LT 40/LESS E 10 FT/ REUBINS STEPHANIE VALUE-0 PRICE-835000 PUSE-0100 1015 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-833256 DATE-7/13/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-133256 BOOK-17262 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-700000 PAGE-1423 EXC- 12-43-46-16-18-000-0401 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE E 10 FT OF LT 40,LT 41&W 35 SNYDER JEAN S VALUE-981492 PRICE-1 PUSE-0100 FT OF LT 42 BLACKBURN RD TAXBL-763725 DATE-2/19/2002 TAXDIST-12984 PO BOX 85 BLDG-206492 BOOK-13481 NAV-00300,00412 SEWICKLEY PA 15143-0085 LAND-775000 PAGE-720 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0421 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE E 30 FT OF LT 42&W 55 FT OF MCMILLEN VIRGINIA N VALUE-678332 PRICE-100 PUSE-0100 LT 43 VIRGINIA N MCMILLEN TR HLDR TAXBL-339031 DATE-9/11/2000 TAXDIST-12984 1103 VISTA DEL MAR BLDG-128332 BOOK-12004 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 LAND-550000 PAGE-1604 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0431 ACRES- 0.23 SALE INST- WD MTG- P20 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE E 20 FT OF LT 43&LT 44 JONES RICHARD C& VALUE-575000 PRICE-650000 PUSE-0000 1111 VISTA DEL MAR DR S TAXBL-550000 DATE-3/23/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7151 BLDG-0 BOOK-16786 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-575000 PAGE-369 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0450 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- S47 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 45 SCHAPPERT KEN&JANE VALUE-726463 PRICE-57500 PUSE-0100 1117 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-279439 DATE-5/1/1984 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-226463 BOOK-04239 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-500000 PAGE-1168 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0460 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- B29 DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 46 RHODES PAUL T JR&JUNE VALUE-606811 PRICE-288000 PUSE-0100 1121 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-280129 DATE-3/12/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-106811 BOOK-10287 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-500000 PAGE-1613 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-18-000-0470 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- 00 MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT 47 ROCKEFELLER MARGARET K VALUE-609805 PRICE-170000 PUSE-0100 1127 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-208153 DATE-1/1/1979 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-159805 BOOK-03093 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-450000 PAGE-1040 EXC-HX 5120/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 6 OF 14 • 12.43.46.16.18-000.0500 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- MTG- DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE LT MARKED PARK DELRAY BEACH CITY OF VALUE-0 PRICE- PUSE-8900 100 NW 1ST AVE TAXBL-0 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 BLDG-0 BOOK- NAV-00412 LAND-3600 PAGE- EXC-05 12.43.46.16.19.000.0210 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- R19 OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 21&S 1 FT OF LT 22 UDERITZ DONALD& VALUE-2004469 PRICE-2150000 PUSE-0100 126 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-1979469 DATE-2/26/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 BLDG-504469 BOOK-13465 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1500000 PAGE-626 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0221 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 22/LESS S 1 FT/ DE RHAM GLENNA M VALUE-1981927 PRICE-100 PUSE-0100 134 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-618007 DATE-3/20/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 BLDG-481927 BOOK-10316 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1500000 PAGE-327 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0231 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES S 100 FT OF LT 23 GLAIZE FRED L III& VALUE-2006092 PRICE-825000 PUSE-0100 142 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-1890402 DATE-3/1/1995 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7016 BLDG-606092 BOOK-08646 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1400000 PAGE-1883 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0240 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 24 DE BAPTISTE ROBIN P& VALUE-1401275 PRICE-200000 PUSE-0100 202 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-405107 DATE-7/1/1984 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 BLDG-351275 BOOK-04308 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1050000 PAGE-1544 EXC-JX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0251 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES E 65 FT OF W 313.06 FT OF LT DUANE PATRICIA B TR VALUE-0 PRICE-100 PUSE-0000 25 LYG N OF YACHT BASIN 1020 S VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-1000 DATE-7/1/1988 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7150 BLDG-0 BOOK-05743 NAV-00412 LAND-1000 PAGE-0690 EXC- 12-43-46-16-19-000-0252 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES E 130.34 FT OF W 248.06 FT OF GRAHAM BENJAMIN H VALUE-0 PRICE-850000 PUSE-9500 LT 25 LYG N OF YACHT BASIN PO BOX 936 TAXBL-1000 DATE-4/26/1999 TAXDIST-12984 MIDDLEBURG VA 20118-0936 BLDG-0 BOOK-11158 NAV-00412 LAND-1000 PAGE-1053 EXC- 12-43-46-16-19-000-0253 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 25/LESS W 323.06 FT/ TURKELL ANDREW A& VALUE-1247431 PRICE-100 PUSE-0100 204 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-627620 DATE-6/1/1999 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7022 BLDG-197431 BOOK-11162 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1050000 PAGE-0005 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0254 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES W 117.72 FT OF LT 25 LYG N OF SCHMIER ROBERT J& VALUE-0 PRICE-2550000 PUSE-0000 YACHT BASIN 7777 GLADES RD TAXBL-1000 DATE-5/14/2001 TAXDIST-12984 #310 BLDG-0 BOOK-12560 NAV-00412 BOCA RATON FL 33434-4150 LAND-1000 PAGE-142 EXC- 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 7 OF 14 12.43.46.16.19-000.0255 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES E 10 FT OF W 323.06 FT OF LT JONES KELLY VALUE-0 PRICE-946000 PUSE-9500 25 LYG N OF YACHT BASIN 1028 VISTA DEL MAR TAXBL-400 DATE-9/30/2004 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 BLDG-0 BOOK-17650 NAV-00412 LAND-400 PAGE-1276 EXC- 12.43-46.16.19.000.0260 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 26&W 50.5 FT OF LT 27 MAX TERRY G&LINDA VALUE-1408522 PRICE-545000 PUSE-0100 1101 THOMAS ST TAXBL-556332 DATE-6/18/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 BLDG-208522 BOOK-10478 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1200000 PAGE-1732 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0271 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES E 32 FT OF LT 27&LT 28 LAKE LINDA K VALUE-1032015 PRICE-180000 PUSE-0100 1111 THOMAS ST TAXBL-273158 DATE-9/1/1988 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 BLDG-32015 BOOK-05809 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-1000000 PAGE-1554 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0290 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 29 REDD CARTER C& VALUE-778663 PRICE-675000 PUSE-0100 1125 THOMAS ST TAXBL-582983 DATE-7/11/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7018 BLDG-38663 BOOK-13905 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-740000 PAGE-409 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0320 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 32 BESINGER LESLIE A VALUE-828251 PRICE-150000 PUSE-0800 125 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-191561 DATE-6/1/1986 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-143251 BOOK-04917 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-685000 PAGE-0001 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0330 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 33 RIVERS CHRISTINA L VALUE-720010 PRICE-425000 PUSE-0100 131 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-490293 DATE-5/1/1997 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-35010 BOOK-09857 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-685000 PAGE-0205 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0340 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- S12 OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 34 BENNETT JOHN C& VALUE-963964 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 137 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-334362 DATE-12/18/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-278964 BOOK-16346 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-685000 PAGE-1574 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0350 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LT 35 DES COGNETS JULIA VALUE-847181 PRICE-10 PUSE-0100 143 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-618064 DATE-5/19/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-162181 BOOK-15417 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-685000 PAGE-680 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-19-000-0420 ACRES- 0.73 SALE INST- MTG- OCEAN BREEZE ESTATES LTS 23A&24A DELRAY BEACH CITY OF VALUE-0 PRICE- PUSE-8900 (YACHT BASIN) TAXBL-0 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 100 NW 1ST AVE BLDG-0 BOOK- NAV-00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 LAND-300 PAGE- EXC-05 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 8 OF 14 12-43.46-16.22.007.0010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- BEACH LTS,DELRAY W 200 FT OF N 60 FT OF S 65.5 VULTAGGIO IOLE TR VALUE-0 PRICE-100 PUSE-0800 FT OF LT 7/LESS ST R/W/ 1877 ROYAL PALM WAY TAXBL-574318 DATE-7/1/1992 TAXDIST-12984 BOCA RATON FL 33432-7443 BLDG-24318 BOOK-07313 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-550000 PAGE-1553 EXC- 12-43.46-16.22.007.0020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- 00 MTG- IPP BEACH LTS,DELRAY W 160 FT OF N 100 FT OF LT 7 BARBAREE FRED D& VALUE-0 PRICE-65000 PUSE-0800 /LESS W 17 FT ST R/W/ 13856 BORA BORA WAY TAXBL-843855 DATE-1/1/1976 TAXDIST-12984 #C 126 BLDG-78855 BOOK-02546 NAV-00300,00412 MARINA DEL REY CA 90292-6885 LAND-765000 PAGE-0935 EXC- 12-43-46-16-25-000-0150 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- VISTA DEL MAR DELRAY BCH LTS 15&16 POLUDNIAK STEPHEN E& VALUE-935741 PRICE-625000 PUSE-0100 1202 VISTA DEL MAR DR TAXBL-518055 DATE-11/7/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7168 BLDG-110741 BOOK-12127 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-825000 PAGE-1220 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-30-147-0020 ACRES- 2.23 SALE INST- MTG- SUB 16-46-43 LYG E OF CNL N 1/2(LESS N 15 FT,S 15 FT, DELRAY BEACH CITY OF VALUE-0 PRICE- PUSE-8900 E 15 FT&PT OF N 25 FT OF S 40 FT IN DB962P197&199)BLK 100 NW 1ST AVE TAXBL-0 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-2612 BLDG-0 BOOK- NAV-00412 LAND-1035 PAGE- EXC-05 12-43-46-16-65-000-0010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 1 DELLAQUILA SUSAN R TRUST VALUE-0 PRICE-405000 PUSE-0400 SUSAN R &FRANK J DELLAQUILA TRS TAXBL-191400 DATE-4/27/2004 TAXDIST-12984 1841 WINTER RUN CT BLDG-191400 BOOK-16883 NAV-00300,00412 CHESTERFIELD MO 63017-5674 LAND-0 PAGE-1244 EXC- 12-43-46-16-65-000-0020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- DT MTG- PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 2 JOHNFRY VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 333 15TH ST TAXBL-191400 DATE-10/19/2000 TAXDIST-12984 TEMPE AZ 85281-6611 BLDG-191400 BOOK-12132 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-650 EXC- 12-43-46-16-65-000-0030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 3 ANSARI ZAKIR H& VALUE-191400 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 130 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-122415 DATE-5/18/2001 TAXDIST-12984 #3 BLDG-191400 BOOK-12603 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7054 LAND-0 PAGE-261 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-65-000-0040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- F72 PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 4 MONNIN PROPERTIES LLC VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 11545 OLD OCEAN BLV TAXBL-191400 DATE-10/17/2003 TAXDIST-12984 #D BLDG-191400 BOOK-16093 NAV-00300,00412 OCEAN RIDGE FL 33435-7358 LAND-0 PAGE-1173 EXC- 12-43-46-16-65-000-0050 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- 012 PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 5 REDELHEIM DAVID&JOAN VALUE-191400 PRICE-180000 PUSE-0400 130 ANDREWS AVE#5 TAXBL-98719 DATE-1/19/1999 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7054 BLDG-191400 BOOK-10895 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-0481 EXC-HX,HX 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 9 OF 14 12.43.46.16.65.000.0060 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- PINE BEACH SOUTH COND UNIT 6 PERRIZO MARY J VALUE-0 PRICE-32000 PUSE-0400 110 INTERLACHEN RD TAXBL-191400 DATE-5/1/1999 TAXDIST-12984 HOPKINS MN 55343-8524 BLDG-191400 BOOK-11251 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1542 EXC- 12.43.46.16.86.000.0010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- B13 OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT A ZENGAGE JAMES A VALUE-0 PRICE-350000 PUSE-0400 75 NE 6TH AVE TAXBL-409400 DATE-7/1/2003 TAXDIST-12984 #214 BLDG-409400 BOOK-15484 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5453 LAND-0 PAGE-908 EXC- 12.43.46.16.86.000.0020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- B26 OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT B SMITH CLAUDIA T VALUE-396000 PRICE-1 PUSE-0400 1200 THOMAS ST TAXBL-370500 DATE-7/13/2004 TAXDIST-12984 #B BLDG-396000 BOOK-17292 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7033 LAND-0 PAGE-1378 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-86-000-0030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- B26 OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT C RIESCHER RONALD A SR VALUE-396000 PRICE-135400 PUSE-0400 1200 THOMAS ST TAXBL-95344 DATE-11/30/1998 TAXDIST-12984 #C BLDG-396000 BOOK-10782 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7033 LAND-0 PAGE-0935 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-86-000-0040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT D MONTGOMERY SARA J VALUE-0 PRICE-122500 PUSE-0400 409 MAPLE AVE TAXBL-408000 DATE-5/20/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DANVILLE KY 40422-1101 BLDG-408000 BOOK-15361 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-714 EXC- 12-43-46-16-86-000-0050 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT E GLICKSTEIN ROSE H VALUE-0 PRICE-150000 PUSE-0400 PO BOX 1250 TAXBL-408000 DATE-2/7/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33447-1250 BLDG-408000 BOOK-11624 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1294 EXC- 12-43-46-16-86-000-0060 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- IPP OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT F PARKS BARBARA J VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 246 ANDOVER DR TAXBL-396000 DATE-8/20/2004 TAXDIST-12984 WAYNE NJ 07470-2961 BLDG-396000 BOOK-17592 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1305 EXC- 12-43-46-16-86-000-0070 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- C40 OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT G HEFFERNAN C G&LINDA VALUE-396000 PRICE-125000 PUSE-0400 1200 THOMAS ST#G TAXBL-98719 DATE-5/29/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7034 BLDG-396000 BOOK-10446 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-699 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-86-000-0080 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- OCEAN REACH APTS COND UNIT H PAYNE KAY B VALUE-409400 PRICE-140000 PUSE-0400 1200 THOMAS ST TAXBL-100266 DATE-2/1/1990 TAXDIST-12984 #H BLDG-409400 BOOK-06359 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7034 LAND-0 PAGE-1823 EXC-HX 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 10 OF 14 12-43-46-16-99-000-0000 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- MTG- DORCHESTER INC COMMON AREA A/K/A BEACH LTS 'DORCHESTER INC VALUE-0 PRICE- PUSE-0510 DELRAY,S 5.5 FT OF LT 7& LT 8 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-0 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 BLDG-0 BOOK- NAV-00412 LAND-0 PAGE- EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-1010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-1 MURDAUGH RUTH W VALUE-318000 PRICE-325000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-247450 DATE-12/9/2003 TAXDIST-12984 APT N1 BLDG-318000 BOOK-16409 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 LAND-0 PAGE-246 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-2 JUNK WILLIAM M& VALUE-0 PRICE-300000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLVD TAXBL-348000 DATE-2/1/1992 TAXDIST-12984 APT 2N BLDG-348000 BOOK-07128 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-1433 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-1030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-3 CANARY NANCY H VALUE-356000 PRICE-100 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-281440 DATE-6/1/1995 TAXDIST-12984 #3N BLDG-356000 BOOK-08812 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 LAND-0 PAGE-0191 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-4 SEARCY W TUNSTALL JR VALUE-364000 PRICE-0 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-290180 DATE-4/4/2000 TAXDIST-12984 #4N BLDG-364000 BOOK-11736 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-231 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1050 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-5 LAUGHTER PEGGY R VALUE-372000 PRICE-335000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-298420 DATE-6/1/1996 TAXDIST-12984 #5 BLDG-372000 BOOK-09340 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 LAND-0 PAGE-1056 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1060 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-6 ARMSTRONG JACK G& VALUE-380000 PRICE-650000 PUSE-0510 JACK&ELIZABETH ARMSTRONG ET AL TR HLDRS TAXBL-306660 DATE-11/15/2002 TAXDIST-12984 200 N OCEAN BLV BLDG-380000 BOOK-14943 NAV-00300,00412 #N6 LAND-0 PAGE-910 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1070 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-7 GRUNAU GARY VALUE-0 PRICE-420000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-388000 DATE-2/11/2000 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 BLDG-388000 BOOK-11647 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1004 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-1080 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-8 DUNNING JOHN A VALUE-396000 PRICE-430000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-318601 DATE-6/1/1998 TAXDIST-12984 #8N BLDG-396000 BOOK-10482 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-1313 EXC-HX,HX 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 11 OF 14 12-43-46-16-99-000-1090 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-9 BENSON NANCY C VALUE-404000 PRICE-10 PUSE-0510 NANCY C BENSON TR TITL HLDR TAXBL-323273 DATE-8/2/2002 TAXDIST-12984 200 N OCEAN BLV BLDG-404000 BOOK-14274 NAV-00300,00412 #N-9 LAND-0 PAGE-1971 EXC-HX,WX 12-43-46-16-99-000-1100 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT N-10 KILPATRICK HAROLD D& VALUE-552000 PRICE-575000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-448800 DATE-3/14/2001 TAXDIST-12984 #N10 BLDG-552000 BOOK-12498 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-389 EXC-HX,HX 12-43.46.16.99-000.2010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-1 VOELKEL ROBERT JR VALUE-0 PRICE-305000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-336000 DATE-2/24/2001 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 BLDG-336000 BOOK-12397 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1189 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-2020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-2 POLLEY KATHLEEN B TR& VALUE-0 PRICE-0 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV . TAXBL-348000 DATE-3/31/2003 TAXDIST-12984 #S-2 BLDG-348000 BOOK-15427 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-1547 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-2030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-3 ROUNSAVALL ROBERT W III& VALUE-0 PRICE-605000 PUSE-0510 PO BOX 19799 TAXBL-356000 DATE-12/19/2003 TAXDIST-12984 LOUISVILLE KY 40259-0799 BLDG-356000 BOOK-16363 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-295 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-2040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-4 JONES DONALD S VALUE-364000 PRICE-340000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-290180 DATE-4/27/2000 TAXDIST-12984 APT S-4 BLDG-364000 BOOK-11767 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-1022 EXC-HX,HX 12.43.46.16.99.000.2050 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-5 FRANDEN ROBERT A& VALUE-0 PRICE-750000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-372000 DATE-5/5/2004 TAXDIST-12984 #S5 BLDG-372000 BOOK-16967 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7178 LAND-0 PAGE-616 EXC- 12-43-46-16-99-000-2060 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-6 HIMMELRIGHT SUZANNE H VALUE-380000 PRICE-465000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-306660 DATE-11/1/1989 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7100 BLDG-380000 BOOK-08720 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1531 EXC-HX 12.43.46.16.99.000.2070 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-7 DRAGISIC SUSAN VALUE-0 PRICE-0 PUSE-0510 14370 HILLSIDE RD TAXBL-388000 DATE-2/9/2000 TAXDIST-12984 ELM GROVE WI 53122-1617 BLDG-388000 BOOK-11826 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1439 EXC • - 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 12 OF 14 , .12-43-46-16-99-000-2080 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- PL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-8 DONNELLY GERARD L& VALUE-396000 PRICE-675000 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-371000 DATE-4/1/2003 TAXDIST-12984 UNIT S8 BLDG-396000 BOOK-15003 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-33 EXC-JX 12-43-46-16-99-000-2090 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- QC MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-9 MCDONALD PETER J& VALUE-0 PRICE-100 PUSE-0510 50123 MANLY TAXBL-404000 DATE-11/18/2002 TAXDIST-12984 CHAPEL HILL NC 27517-8569 BLDG-404000 BOOK-14581 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-998 EXC- 12-43.46.16-99.000.2100 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- AL MTG- DORCHESTER INC APT S-10 GREENE BRUCE D • VALUE-552000 PRICE-0 PUSE-0510 200 N OCEAN BLV TAXBL-448800 DATE-2/22/2001 TAXDIST-12984 APT S 10 BLDG-552000 BOOK-12343 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7179 LAND-0 PAGE-1117 EXC-HX,HX 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 1 CASEY ANITA J VALUE-0 PRICE-130000 PUSE-0400 400 GULFSTREAM BLV TAXBL-198000 DATE-1/29/2002 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33444-4369 BLDG-198000 BOOK-13367 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1551 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 2 BAIRD CURTIS S& VALUE-0 PRICE-96000 PUSE-0400 3187 W STRIEGEL RD TAXBL-138000 DATE-11/26/2001 TAXDIST-12984 #9 BLDG-138000 BOOK-13126 NAV-00300,00412 CARBONDALE IL 62901-5415 LAND-0 PAGE-613 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 3 PUGH DAVID J& VALUE-0 PRICE-44500 PUSE-0400 423 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-138000 DATE-12/1/1989 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7105 BLDG-138000 BOOK-06315 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1428 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 4 WOODARD GEORGE VALUE-138000 PRICE-100000 PUSE-0400 150 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-64213 DATE-7/15/2002 TAXDIST-12984 #4 BLDG-138000 BOOK-13928 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 LAND-0 PAGE-1736 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0050 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 5 WYANA CLAXTON INC VALUE-0 PRICE-93000 PUSE-0400 2525 FLORIDA BLV TAXBL-138000 DATE-9/27/2001 TAXDIST-12984 #3 BLDG-138000 BOOK-12999 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-4952 LAND-0 PAGE-482 EXC- 12.43.46.16-B2.000.0060 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- IPP BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 6 PUGH MARY ATR VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 423 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-198000 DATE-12/1/2004 TAXDIST-12984 LAKE WORTH FL 33463 BLDG-198000 BOOK-17833 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-484 EXC- 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 13 OF 14 12-43.46.16-B2-000.0070 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 7 CASEY ANITA J& VALUE-0 PRICE-202730 PUSE-0400 150 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-198000 DATE-7/19/2003 TAXDIST-12984 #7 BLDG-198000 BOOK-15568 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 LAND-0 PAGE-1460 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0080 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 8 TURTURRO KAMI VALUE-0 PRICE-162000 PUSE-0400 PO BOX 540969 TAXBL-138000 DATE-7/20/2004 TAXDIST-12984 LAKE WORTH FL 33454-0969 BLDG-138000 BOOK-17312 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-893 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0090 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 9 BANKS TAMMY VALUE-138000 PRICE-48000 PUSE-0400 150 N ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-113000 DATE-10/31/2000 TAXDIST-12984 #9 BLDG-138000 BOOK-12195 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 LAND-0 PAGE-1910 EXC-HX 12.43.46.16.B2.000.0100 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 10 MCCALL EDWARD F& VALUE-0 PRICE-52800 PUSE-0400 3909 MAURICE DR TAXBL-138000 DATE-3/27/1998 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33445-3224 BLDG-138000 BOOK-10318 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1616 EXC- 12.43.46.16-B2-000.0110 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 11 AYLOTT JAMES A R VALUE-0 PRICE-168000 PUSE-0400 1637 LE ROY AVE TAXBL-138000 DATE-8/30/2004 TAXDIST-12984 BERKELEY CA 94709 BLDG-138000 BOOK-17542 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1092 EXC- 12.43.46.16.B2-000.0120 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- BEACH HOUSE OF DELRAY COND UNIT 12 CASEY ANITA J& VALUE-0 PRICE-195000 PUSE-0400 150 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-198000 DATE-8/15/2003 TAXDIST-12984 #7 BLDG-198000 BOOK-15706 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7048 LAND-0 PAGE-1206 EXC- 12.43.46.16-B7.000.0010 ACRES- 0.38 SALE INST- WD MTG- WALLACE SQUARE LT 1 BROCKWELL THOMAS C& VALUE-910321 PRICE-1200000 PUSE-0100 1116 THOMAS ST TAXBL-885321 DATE-8/11/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7019 BLDG-235321 BOOK-15686 NAV- LAND-675000 PAGE-1101 EXC- 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0020 ACRES- 0.38 SALE INST- QC MTG- WALLACE SQUARE LT 2 BENNETT JOHN C& VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0000 137 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-648000 DATE-12/18/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-0 BOOK-16346 NAV- LAND-648000 PAGE-1569 EXC- 12-43.46.16-B7.000.0030 ACRES- 0.28 SALE INST- QC MTG- WALLACE SQUARE LT 3 BENNETT JOHN C& VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0000 137 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-487536 DATE-12/18/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-1536 BOOK-16346 NAV- LAND-486000 PAGE-1569 EXC- 5/20/2005 9:17:22 AM Property Appraiser GIS Parcel List by Parcel Control Number Radius:0 - 500 Page 14 OF 14 :12.43.46-16.B7-001.0000 ACRES- 0.3 SALE INST- QC MTG- WALLACE SQUARE TR A A/K/A LUKE LANE BENNETT JOHN C& VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-9400 137 SEABREEZE AVE TAXBL-0 DATE-12/18/2003 TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7017 BLDG-0 BOOK-16346 NAV- LAND-0 PAGE-1569 EXC- 12.43-46.16-05.000.0010 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- F1C LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 1 CLORE LEE S& VALUE-0 PRICE-122000 PUSE-0400 PO BOX 21 TAXBL-178200 DATE-12/1/1994 TAXDIST-12984 CRESTWOOD KY 40014-0021 BLDG-178200 BOOK-08572 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-0264 EXC- 12-43-46.16-05.000.0011 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 1-A CHANEY HARROLD R TR VALUE-0 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 4240 LAKE RD W TAXBL-178200 DATE-3/15/2001 TAXDIST-12984 ASHTABULA OH 44004-2106 BLDG-178200 BOOK-12432 NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE-1922 EXC- 12.43.46.16•C5.000-0020 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 2 BILLOW GERALD 0& VALUE-0 PRICE- PUSE-0400 200 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-178200 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7171 BLDG-178200 BOOK- NAV-00300,00412 LAND-0 PAGE- EXC- 12.43.46.16-05-000.0021 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 2-A SEBBA LUCETTE A VALUE-178200 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 LUCETTE A SEBRA TR TITL HLDR TAXBL-94782 DATE-3/27/2003 TAXDIST-12984 200 ANDREWS AVE BLDG-178200 BOOK-15018 NAV-00300,00412 #2A LAND-0 PAGE-1384 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-05-000-0030 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 3 PERRONE FRANK VALUE-0 PRICE-365000 PUSE-0400 200 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-178200 DATE-3/23/2004 TAXDIST-12984 #3 BLDG-178200 BOOK-16710 NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7161 LAND-0 PAGE-1481 EXC- 12.43-46-16-05.000.0031 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 3-A ALEXANDER ANN L VALUE-178200 PRICE- PUSE-0400 200 ANDREWS AVE TAXBL-79427 DATE- TAXDIST-12984 #3A BLDG-178200 BOOK- NAV-00300,00412 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7161 LAND-0 PAGE- EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-05-000-0040 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 4 BUEHLER MARIAN J VALUE-181200 PRICE-10 PUSE-0400 J M BUEHLER ET AL TR TITL HLDR TAXBL-82651 DATE-1/1/1993 TAXDIST-12984 200 ANDREWS AVE BLDG-181200 BOOK-07578 NAV-00300,00412 #4 LAND-0 PAGE-308 EXC-HX 12-43-46-16-05-000-0041 ACRES- 0 SALE INST- WD MTG- LYNDON ARMS APTS COND APT 4-A JESSE NEIL B TR VALUE-0 PRICE-190000 PUSE-0400 9200 SHELBYVILLE RD TAXBL-178200 DATE-12/31/1999 TAXDIST-12984 #517 BLDG-178200 BOOK-11544 NAV-00300,00412 LOUISVILLE KY 40222-5134 LAND-0 PAGE-1680 EXC- 111, fir r Fax To: Palm l3each County Public Records Attention: Clarice 1=14-e•r-ki r\ Fax: 561-355-? 4271 From: Dorothy Patterson (' Delray 13each Historical Society 561-274-9578 dhhsarchabel lsouth.net Subject:Address labels for properties within 500 feet Date: May 17,2005 I am working on a historic designation report for a property in Delray Beach. The City Preservation Planner, Warren Adams, has requested that 1 obtain an address label list. • from you for properties within 500 feet of the following : Address: 212 Seabreeze Avenue ! '7_ �f3_W Legal Description: Lot 21 and the west 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof,as recorded in Plat Book 18, page 39,Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Property Owners: Erskine 11. and Virginia W. Courtenay Please let me know if you need further information,the time-frame for my request,and if 1 need to pick up the list at your office. 'thank you. • if� as' aba • Ft: I Sooz'SZ ,�Kfn1 05-20-2005 Property Appraiser GIS Page 1 of 2 C=Condo Flag PCN List by Parcel Control Number Radius 0-500 S 12-43-46-16-18-000-0210 12-43-46-16-18-000-0282 12-43-46-16-19-000-0340 12-43-46-16-17-000-0070 12-43-46-16-18-000-0300 12-43-46-16-19-000-0350 12-43-46-16-17-000-0080 12-43-46-16-18-000-0311 12-43-46-16-19-000-0420 12-43-46-16-17-000-0090 12-43-46-16-1S.d)00-0321 12-43-46-16-22-007-0010 12-43-46-16-17-000-0100 12-43-46-16-1�s-000=0340 12-43-46-16-22-007-0020 12-43-46-16-17-000-0110 12-43-46-16-18-000-0350 12-43-46-16-25-000-0150 12-43-46-16-17-000-0120 12-43-46-16-18-000-0361 12-43-46-16-30-147-0020 • 12-43-46-16-18-000-0010 12-43-46-16-18-000-0371 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0010 12-43-46-16-18-000-0021 12-43-46-16-18-000-0390 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0020 12-43-46-16-18-000-0040 12-43-46-16-18-000-0401 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0030 12-43-46-16-18-000-0051 12-43-46-16-18-000-0421 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0040 12-43-46-16-18-000-0070 12-43-46-16-18-000-0431 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0050 12-43-46-16-18-000-0080 12-43-46-16-18-000-0450 C 12-43-46-16-65-000-0060 12-43-46-16-18-000-0090 12-43-46-16-18-000-0460 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0010 12-43-46-16-18-000-0100 12-43-46-16-18-000-0470 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0020 12-43-46-16-18-000-0110 12-43-46-16-18-000-0500 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0030 12-43-46-16-18-000-0120 12-43-46-16-19-000-0210 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0040 12-43-46-16-18-000-0130 12-43-46-16-19-000-0221 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0050 12-43-46-16-18-000-0140 12-43-46-16-19-000-0231 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0060 12-43-46-16-18-000-0151 12-43-46-16-19-000-0240 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0070 12-43-46-16-18-000-0152 12-43-46-16-19-000-0251 C 12-43-46-16-86-000-0080 12-43-46-16-18-000-0170 12-43-46-16-19-000-0252 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-0000 12-43-46-16-18-000-0180 12-43-46-16-19-000-0253 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1010 12-43-46-16-18-000-0191 12-43-46-16-19-000-0254 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1020 12-43-46-16-18-000-0221 12-43-46-16-19-000-0255 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1030 12-43-46-16-18-000-0240 12-43-46-16-19-000-0260 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1040 12-43-46-16-18-000-0250 12-43-46-16-19-000-0271 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1050 12-43-46-16-18-000-0260 12-43-46-16-19-000-0290 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1060 12-43-46-16-18-000-0270 12-43-46-16-19-000-0320 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1070 12-43-46-16-18-000-0281 12-43-46-16-19-000-0330 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1080 , R 05-20-2005 Prop-I—=Dpraiser GIS Page 2 of C=Condo Flag PCN List by Parcel Control Number Radius 0-500 C 12-43.46-16-99-000-1090 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0020 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-1100 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0021 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2010 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0030 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2020 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0031 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2030 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0040 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2040 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0041 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2050 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2060 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2070 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2080 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2090 C 12-43-46-16-99-000-2100 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0010 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0020 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0030 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0040 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0050 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0060 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0070 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0080 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0090 C 12-43-46-16-62-000-0100 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0110 C 12-43-46-16-B2-000-0120 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0010 12-43-46-16-67-000-0020 12-43-46-16-B7-000-0030 12-43-46-16-B7-001-0000 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0010 C 12-43-46-16-05-000-0011 • J15 16 17 18 19 20 21 LI Li c•+ to 21 vcoc 8 6 YACHT iN, 1 ;' 722 ^ 12 E5 ES 10 137 BASIN 1 2 `� 7 3 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 1 129 9 ES ES _ ' 12 13 4 8 6 9 3 10 4 14 - _--WATERVVArtiit I --- -. r- -___ 283 8 22 3 6 5 U 7 4 6 u— 4 z 4 2 8 10 11 12 10 9 L 8 74 M 3 12 11 5 / / Q 6 = 1 - ABND OR12 "315 ,7 ✓ ✓ 17 1 < OD 15 16 7 8-0-0120 : 0-011 g 8-0-01116.89011B-ao 8 9° '-b7 ` i°1: 'i; -- _ _, 14INC sT— , ! .LsN ra 11 19 9 g 7 0021 //1 2 v Z f l 005j/ 4 O921 �/1 12 0091 a8 0061 3920� ; V ,/ co 0041 2 0, J ✓ -VISTA DEL----MAR--DR -NORTH y 0 `• 1 > 0011 0022 12 .--- o, eC 13 f 5v _ VISTA DEL MAR DR I-- 1 037'�. 0 61 34✓ 03p. 031 30� zco 1-`1 0012 0021 11 14 J V V 15 17 0191 0211 0221 0241 0252 0282 ! 39 0401� 042� 043� 4� 0 26 0031 0032 10 '� 0281 u Q a 0151✓ VISTA -DEL MAR DR --sou- . 2 V 3 f 001-0000 0042 0041 9 0152 1V 18 ,/ 0l, 1 21 Q2�1 2� 25r 27✓ w 7 a 0000 j I/ Q 1 t/ ",� �3 V ,., u) ; 72 i83 B3 °L'YNDON 5 8 } o2sd o252� oK 025 CC ,kMS z DORCHESTER INC CO-OP co Cr ,9'26 0271 2 APTS < 7 z 42 24 `� 9,CONDO, DB997P240 9 42 �_ THOMAS ST-- 1 _ BEACH ___ .9, HOUSE20 o, 0231 J 35,f V 8'- ZE7 OFO' EAN REACH EAST WIND Y DELRAY AP A' BEACH CLUB 3 5 0061 8 0092� 1 l 34 j l� CO +DO CO-OP 7 0221" J 0 p e y, . �R4527P668 -3 DB997P260 / C7- • 0020 w 33 ,PIN :ETb1 139 YACHT BASIN ¢ 2 ✓3 OU 0151 0131 0121 0102 °3 21 CONDO BERKSHIRE BY THE SEA r o020 `' 17 _.__I-- 15 32✓ CONDO DR 67 67OR3038P1068 t NE'STaT ,a ALBOT I OR3478P1277 / 13 U 10 HOUSE III 17 15 o teett4130"5 73 3 APPARENT R/W 22 0231 25 0261 0271 Q - PUT IN BY AERIAL 19 12 ° 0081 6 5 0021 GROSVENOR o, m IPARKVIRY1 1 1 J o HOUSE INC i MANC R o 1 1s 16 14 147 , 1 CONDO GARY R. NIKOLITIS, CFA SCALE: 1" =200' LOCATION: PALM BEACH COUNTY 05-20-2005 Rng 43E-Twp 46S-Sec 16 Key: Subject 0-500 PROPERTY APPRAISER NOTES: N A I I _ I I—J L_J I I I I I I I ` W N.E. 5TH ST. z w z C ISLAND DRIVE a Q J ce /.�L• \ L' w Z /Q Z 5 1 N.E. 4TH ST. C- BEACH DRIVE LLi I / � L.LI I C SEA SPRAY AVE. ui > Q a 1 I . . I I I SANDOWAY LANE oWATERWAY LANE ■ J w = Q Z Z 1 tA� LAING ST. N.E. 3RD S I. 1 1 1 • TG�B:a7 • • I I 1 p VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE \ 1 M ! I I I � I / vdr. �'T'I s. w / •*i i > I f�t Q Li i DORCHESTER CO-OP THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. z EAST WIND _ 1 I I BEACH CLUB C Q Cti BERKSHIRE I- J w 1 I DRIVE M N.E. 1ST CT. w BY THE SEA - U 1 Q GROSVENOR I U z Q I m a I C..) LOWRY LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. Q CONDO z 0 z VETERANSti DELRAY Ir s AE I SUMMIT GROVE NO. 2 ATLANTIC PARK CONDO w \ wNJ CONDO PLAZA z 1 // w a 0 BARR w Lu TERRACECONDO I , SPANISH - DELRAY BEACH Q RIVER MARRIOTT c) I III , RESORT A T L A N TIC AVENUE N THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM833 i ucuu3 ouch uu3uvuucn ��d kotil HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD 1111. MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT IIJL 1993 1993 2001 2001 Project Name: The Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) Historic Designation Report for an Individual Property Virginia & Erskine Courtenay, Owners Report prepared by Dorothy W. Patterson ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is to review the designation report for Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) and to set a date for the public hearing, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 4.5.1(C), Designation Procedures. BACKGROUND The owner has proposed to designate the subject property to the Local Register of Historic Places and has employed the services of Dorothy W. Patterson to undertake the research and prepare the designation report. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(1), to qualify as a historic site the property must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(2) and/or (3). The designation report contains, at minimum, sufficient information to meet the criteria ,stated in both LDR Sections 4.5.1(B)(2) and (3). The criteria are as follows: LDR Section 4.5.1(8) (2): (a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history (for example, the homestead of a local founding family); (b) Is the site of a historic event with significant effect upon the city, state, or nation; (c) Is associated in a significant way with a major historic event, whether cultural, economic, social, military, or political; (d) Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, economic, or social trends of the community in history; or (e) Is associated in a significant way with a past or continuing institution which has contributed substantially to the life of the city. LDR Section 4.5.1(8) (3): (a) Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles; and, (b) Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction; (c) Is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder, or Meeting Date: May 4,2005 Agenda Item: III.A. Historic Preservation Board Memorandum Staff Report The Sewell C. Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue) Designation Report Page 2 (d) Contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment. The designation report demonstrates that the subject property qualifies as a historic site as it: is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history[LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(2)(a)]; embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(b)]; is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder [LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(3)(c)]; and contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment[LDR Section 4.5.1(8)(3)(d)]. Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School, and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. He became a serious collector of 18th and 19th- century American art and, in 1988, the Biggs Museum of American Art opened in Dover to house his collection. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American art and decorative art gems. That same year, Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The architect of the Sewell C. Biggs House, Paul Rudolph, was an important influence on American Modernism in the mid-twentieth century. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design, and Engineering at the Library of Congress, "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence on the second half of the 20th century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation". Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of'Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses', state that "The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism'. The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II which embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism, the innovative uses of new materials, and adaptation to suit the South Florida environment. Paul Rudolph's design was constructed by the Sinks, father and son, who had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. The Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving, and promoting American fine and decorative arts. The style of the home is a design unique to Delray Beach and is the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in the 20th-century American design field. It is also the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach (although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings) and is representative of 20th-century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further, the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving historic buildings in Delray Beach. Designating this site as historic will help preserve the character of the extant historic dwelling and will promote the preservation of other surrounding historic properties. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(C) (4), after formally reviewing the designation report, the Board shall set a public hearing date for the proposed designation. Historic Preservation Board MerfIUhz-dum Staff Report The Sewell C. Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue) Designation Report Page 3 RECOMMENDATION Move to set a date for the required public hearing associated with the proposed historic designation of The Sewell C. Biggs House (212 Seabreeze Avenue) for the Historic Preservation Board meeting of May 18, 2005. Attachment:Location Map, The Sewell C.Biggs House(212 Seabreeze Avenue)Designation Report Memorandum Staff Report Prepared by:Warren Adams,Historic Preservation Planner L-lU I I 1 I 1 I N.E. 5TH ST. z - w z C ISLAND DRIVE ¢ J c II / in LT- N I.i Q W Z � Z N.E. 41H ST. n BEACH DRIVE i Q w i 1 > LEI 1— C SEA SPRAY AVE_ w.; I > Q SANDOWAY LANE 1 WATERWAY LANE a — o`- z z La_ ¢ as cr a D I- � In J 2 .J CO - LAING ST. —� N.E. 3RD S I. i \ VI A M R RV p VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE _ / � i I sour Z Lv Q DORCHESTER z a CO-OP THOMAS STREET N.E. 2ND ST. Z EAST WIND _ e:}v BEACHCLUB JL Q BERKSHIRE i f— w DRI v E N.E. 1ST cr. > BY THE SEA - Q in it ui Q itGROSVENOR ir z 0 z HOUSE 0 LOWRY STREET MANOR HOUSE N.E. 1ST ST. CONDO Z z DELRAY FIRE VETERANS SUMMIT r GROVE NO. 2 ATLANTIC PARK CONDO w N CONDO PLAZA z i I CC Q 0 CD — a Ct BARR w W TERRACE SPANISH 1- CONDO I III RIVER DELRAY BEACH f- III RESORT MARRIOTT 0 ATLANTIC AVENUE N --immr- THE SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM833 Designation Report Historic Preservation Board Delray Beach, Florida The Sewell C . Biggs House Table of Contents I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. NOT APPLICABLE IV. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VIII. ATTACHMENTS Report Prepared By: Dorothy W. Patterson 1206 NE Second Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 (561) 278-2191 (home) 274-9578 (Archives) 717-3425 (cell) E-mail summerpatt©earthlink.net Date of Report: April 20, 2005 Name of Owners: Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay 212 Seabreeze Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33483 2 I. General Information Address The Sewell C. Biggs House, named for its original owner, is located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue within the city limits of Delray Beach, Florida. Legal Description Lot 21 and the west 35 feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 18, page 39, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Location Lots 21 and 22 are at the end of Seabreeze Avenue. A driveway at this point leads to the front entrance of the Courtenay home. The lots are bounded by Lot 26 of Ocean Breeze Estates on the south and Vista Del Mar Drive South on the north. At the time of construction in 1955 the front entrance faced Vista Del Mar Drive South. This area is on the barrier island between the Intra-coastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean. Zoning Single Family Residential Classification for Designation We believe that the Sewell C. Biggs House, designed by esteemed mid- century modern architect, Paul Rudolph, meets the criteria for both architectural and cultural significance for the reasons described in the following pages of the report. 3 II. Location Map To be provided by City of Delray Beach. III District Inventory Not applicable 4 • IV. Historical and Cultural Significance Before 1895 the lots where the Sewell C. Biggs House is located were part of a semitropical wilderness between the coastal ridge and a swampy morass. Less than two blocks away from the lots the coastal ridge begins. The first construction known in the area was the Orange Grove House of Refuge built by the U.S. Life Saving Service (precursor to the Coast Guard) in 1876. The former site of the House of Refuge is a short walk from the Briggs House. The Refuge keeper's son, Charles Pierce, described the land around the Refuge House as follows: The house... was built on a broad flat that ran back from the open sand beach to the higher ridge behind the house...At the Orange Grove it was covered with a thick growth of saw palmetto. The flat was covered with sea oats and scattered bunches of stunted seagrape and cocoplum. This flat extended north two and one-half miles and ended at the caves; to the south it stretched for nearly four miles ... To the west, commencing at the foot of the palmetto-covered ridge, was a deep swamp of tall sawgrass with numerous small channels turning about its eastern side. The morass was about half a mile wide and extended from Lake Worth to Boca Raton; west of it were pinewoods reaching back as far as one could see." The Pierce family encountered deer, bear and heard panthers screaming in the night. They killed the bears for food. After settlement by Americans of European descent began, the area was used for farming such crops as strawberries, pineapples, mangoes and tomatoes. Beginning with the mid-1920's Florida Real Estate Boom, the land became more valuable for residential housing. Or as Adolf Hofman said in one of his letters home to Germany, "Since Delray is growing and the lots fetch colossal prices, I will divide my land between canal and railroad into lots." One of first the farmers in the area, Adolf Hofman developed the Ocean Breeze Estates subdivision adjoining Delray Beach Esplanade, in 1937. Local attorney Ernest Simon recalls that in the late 1930's and early 1940's when he was delivering the De/ray Beach News on his bicycle, there were only a few houses in the area. Delray Beach Esplanade, the subdivision where the Briggs House is located, was platted in 1938 by H. H. and Charlotte Wellenbrink and Williard and Billie Waters. The Waters were 5 well-known in Delray Beach. Wiiiard Waters was a building contractor who had graduated from Delray High School. His family lived at 222 N. Ocean and farmed land on the barrier island in the early years of the 20th century. Waters was also active in city politics and civic clubs. After World War II, building in the neighborhood began in earnest. Tom Woolbright, who went into the building business for himself in 1949,recalls spending the 1947 hurricane in a house in the neighborhood. He said the area was pretty well built up by then and that Willard Waters built many of the houses. Mr. Woolbright remembers that H.H. Wellenbrink was "the money man" who paid for improvements such as building roads, filling land, and paying engineering fees for the plat. Roy Simon, native of Delray Beach, was an apprentice architect in the 1950s for local architect, Ken Jacobson. He recalls that Vista del Mar (Delray Beach Esplanade) was fairly built up by then. After he saw the Paul Rudolph designed house under construction, he and other architects were enthusiastic about the chance of designing contemporary housing. However, he said, "I seemed to keep drawing nice cottages." There were many important clients for houses in the neighborhood such as CEO's of nationally known corporations, famous professional golfers and prominent Delray Beach citizens. The clients loved the smallness and "laid-back" atmosphere of Delray Beach. But evidently they did not have the artistic sensibilities of Sewell C. Biggs and did not request avant garde contemporary designs. James Sinks, a local building contractor, constructed architect Paul Rudolph's design. According to Ernie Simon, Sinks had a reputation for being a "good builder." Jim Sinks father, Irwin J. Sinks, was also a builder originally from Champaign, Illinois. During World War I he went to work for the U.S. Government and was sent to Charleston, S.C. to build soldiers' barracks. In Charleston he roomed with Fred J. Schrader from Delray Beach. Schrader was the first builder in Delray with architectural training. He came to town in 1911 and built the town's first jail, the Cromer Block on Atlantic Avenue and the original part of the Presbyterian Church on Gleason Street. Schrader encouraged Sinks to come to Delray. In 1922 after another assignment in Miami, the Sinks family moved to Delray. The Sinks, father and son, quintessential Delray builders of their time, had a long record of building in Delray Beach. The elder Sinks built many of the structures on or near Atlantic Avenue such as the Masonic Building, the 1926 6 High School, the Wuepper Building, the Casa del Ray Hotel, and the Arcade Building. Jim built the Atha Building which replaced the Cromer Building. Laura Sinks Britt said in her book, My Gold Coast, "My father had become a builder of more structures on Atlantic Avenue than any other one contractor and Jim added his score." Today some of the "nice cottages," which fit gently into subdivision-sized lots on the short winding streets of the neighborhood, are being torn down to make way for large estate style homes. At present we do not know 'the exact circumstances of how Sewell C. Biggs came to build a house in Delray Beach and chose Paul Rudolph as his architect. He has been described as "enigmatic" and not easy to know. A biography of his life is in the process at this time. The curator at the Sewell C. Biggs Museum in Dover, Delaware, said Biggs owned the house about six years. The Delray Beach City Directory lists him as the owner at the address for about nine years. Randy Grover, the curator, was asked to present a retrospective of Biggs life to the museum board when Mr. Biggs died suddenly in 2003 at age 88. Grover said he felt that the story of the house in Delray Beach was a high point of his presentation. The reason for this was that Biggs was known for his collection of 18th and 19th century American art. The house signaled the beginning of a turn toward the 20t' century. In fact Sewell Bigg's vision was for his collection to cover the entire range of American art. Sewell C. Biggs, a northern Delaware native, graduated from the University of Delaware in 1938. He also attended the University of Virginia Law School and studied architecture at Harvard, Oxford, and Cambridge Universities. In 1937 he took a trip around the world that had an enduring impact on the rest of his life. After the trip he was interested in international exchange and began to sponsor foreign students for one-year scholarships at the University of Delaware. A serious collector of art, he was also involved in historical preservation and art conservation. Biggs collection of American fine and decorative art has been described as "elegant, wonderful, pristine, remarkable, impressive, and an incredible journey ranging from Colonial portraiture to the Hudson River School." With his vision and eye for quality, Biggs spent most of his life on his American art collection. In 1998 the Biggs Museum of American Art opened in Dover to house his collection which includes Delaware and 7 • Delaware Valley fine and decorative arts. The 14 galleries of the museum contain a collection which covers more than 200 years of American fine art and decorative art gems. That same year Biggs established the Sewell C. Biggs Chair in American Art History at the University of Delaware. The title of an exhibit at the Biggs Museum of American Art says it best --"Artful Living: The Legacy of Sewell C. Biggs." Mr. Biggs sold his house at 212 Seabreeze about 1970 to a New York lawyer and his wife, Richard and Alice McAvoy. Evidently the McAvoy's did not have much time in the house because a Webb Brothers Real Estate information sheet is headed Estate of Richard McAvoy. (See attachments) Reference No. 2 on the sheet cites a merit award, medium house class (600-2800 sq. ft.), given in June 1959 by House & Home, an architecture magazine. The fourth and present owners of the house, Virginia and Erskine Courtenay, bought the house in 1973. Well-known Delray Beach Realtor, Pat Patterson, showed the house. Before becoming a real estate salesman for Ben Adam's Realty, Patterson was known for his pharmacy, his photography, and his volunteer work as a ham radio operator during World War II. Virginia Courtenay says that she "fell in love with the light, being up in the trees, and the architecture. She already greatly admired the work of Paul Rudolph. Mrs. Courtenay's grandfather was a builder in Chicago. She attended the Art Institute of Chicago and has owned an interior design business in Delray Beach for more than 25 years. Erskine Courtenay agreed to the purchase because Virginia loved the house, and he loved her. Paul Rudolph has been sometimes criticized for elevating style at the expense of function and some changes had to be made for practical living. Mr. And Mrs. Courtenay have always wanted and have strived to keep the house as close to the original design as possible. Sensitivity to the original design while making changes has always been an important aspect of planning. In addition Rudolph's Florida houses had been designed just prior to the time when air-conditioning became a standard feature of south Florida homes. Some of the innovative design features meant to ameliorate the Florida climate worked against the efficiency of air-conditioning. For example, in the back of the house paneling was installed over the aluminum louver windows because the strength of the wind blowing against the louvers had been a problem at times, and after air-conditioning was installed, the problems continued. The windows in the front of the original part of the 8 house look the same even though they have been replaced. Paul Rudolph drew a plan for an addition and approved the changes to the house in 1980. (See attachments). However, Rudolph was not aware of the need to raise the house 4 feet because of a new law which dictated that the house must be 7.5 feet above mean sea level. (Flooding of the lot during the rainy season had occurred at times after original construction in 1955.) Local architect Bob Currie was then hired to plan lifting the house and the addition in 1980-81. The interior of the addition matches the interior of the original house. The original hedges, trees and landscaping remain the same. (See attachments) 9 V. Architectural Significance The architect of the Sewell C. Bigg House in Delray Beach, Paul Rudolph (1918-1997), was an important influence on American modernism in the mid-twentieth century. He was a Kentucky native and son of a Methodist minister. According to C. Ford Peatross, curator of Architecture, Design and Engineering at the Library of Congress, Rudolph drew on many influences for his Florida work. He was open to new and experimental methods of construction-- stretching structural possibilities of materials to their limit's while celebrating their static and aesthetic possibilities, spatial richness, complexity and inter-relationship of the interiors and exteriors... of his buildings, their site, their natural surroundings and their climate. His appreciation of these qualities in both modern architecture and in the vernacular buildings of his native South had been fostered by E. Walter Burkhardt under whom he studied architecture at Auburn University (then Alabama Polytechnic Institute). Burkhart recommended his student to Walter Gropius who was instrumental in Rudolph's admission to Harvard Graduate School of Design. Burkhart was one of the most energetic and enlightened directors of the Historic American Building Survey, now one of the most frequently consulted collections in the Library of Congress. Mr. Peatross wrote the preface to Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. He is well-acquainted with Rudolph's work because the architect bequeathed his professional papers and drawings to the Library and funded the Center of Architecture, Design and Engineering there. Peatross' accolades include the statement: "Paul Rudolph was a profound influence of the second half of the 20t" century and a model of rare integrity who is being rediscovered by a new generation." His assessment of Rudolph's Florida buildings is that the "innovative, adventurous and elegant Florida buildings launched Rudolph's career." Petross further finds in working with drawings of many famous architects in the Library of Congress Collections that "with the exception of Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the 'speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of 10 Wright; however, I have found none of their graphic works to be as consistently daring, stimulating, accomplished, and often beautiful as those of Paul Rudolph's drawings. His drawings convey his restless intellectual curiosity, his prodigious spatial imagination and, in Phillip Johnson's words, the `speed of his mind'...Collectively, they represent a treasure chest of lessons, ideas, and possibilities that will speak to and inspire generations to come." Christopher Domin and Joseph King, authors of Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses, visited the present owners in Delray Beach. The Courtenays are listed in the Acknowledgments on page 13. The Sewell C. Biggs House is featured in the "Independent Practice" section on page 183 where the house is compared to the "award-winning Cohen House...(1953-1955)" on Siesta Key. The authors' opening statement is: "While coming of age as architects along the west coast of Florida in a landscape increasingly homogenized by air-conditioning and prolific land development, Paul Rudolph's architecture stood alone in our eyes as a rigorous counter-argument." Domin and King met in the graduate program at the Georgia Institute of Technology. After discovering their shared interest in Rudolph's work, they made their avocation the searching out of buildings designed by Rudolph across the state of Florida. The authors' conclude that "Rudolph's early work in Florida over a 20-year period was a necessary testing round for a multi-layered design methodology of a complex career. The fact that the architect's work was widely publicized at the time played a significant role in national recognition of Rudolph's work. The Florida houses are an accessible entry into a formidable career. His work is a compelling example of regionally inspired modernism. The beautiful photographs are seen today in a bittersweet light as we are now all too aware of what happens when a vastly enlarged population of affluent Americans descends on all too few miles of pristine beaches." The Delray Beach Historical Society featured the Sewell C. Biggs House as one of the components in its "The Art of Architecture in South Florida" exhibit in 1989. One of the displays described how orientation, sun, heat and ventilation were addressed by the design. (See attachments) 11 VI. Statement of Significance The owners, Esrkine H. & Virginia W. Courtenay, wish to nominate their property for the following reason: "After living in it since 1973, are very much like those of the original owner, Mr. Sewell C. Biggs. It has maintained its sense of elegance in its simplicity and its feeling of"dateless" architecture which stands the test of time. In 1981 we raised the original house four feet to add a lower floor which now houses a library, guest bedroom and laundry room. This was accomplished with the collaboration of local architect, Robert Currie, who was interested in the house for its historical importance." The style of the home is a design, unique to the neighborhood and to Delray Beach, of the artistic work of an architect who was a leader in 20th century American design field. It is the only Paul Rudolph designed building in Delray Beach although Rudolph designed many Florida homes and buildings. It is representative of 20th century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. Further the house is an example of the skill of the Sinks construction firm which built some of the best surviving buildings in Delray Beach. Other reasons for designation are that respect shown for the characteristics of our property will draw attention to the need for preservation in Delray Beach's older neighborhoods; the hope that local designation will afford some protection for the house in the future,and to set an example in a neighborhood being pressured by demolitions. In summary the Sewell C. Biggs House is associated with an original owner who was important in preserving, conserving and promoting American fine and decorative arts. His collection spans the more than 200 years that the United States has existed as a country. The property has been followed under Historical and Cultural Significance in this Designation Report throughout the entire history of Delray Beach after 1876. Further it reflects social and economic trends in the community and is indicative of the winter colony of artistic and socially prominent people which has existed in Delray Beach since the 1920's. Since the house at 212 Seabreeze fits comfortably into the history of Delray Beach, and the original owner proved to have the "vision and eye for quality" of a major American art collector, there seems no doubt that the house at 212 Seabreeze has historical and cultural significance. 12 The design of the house portrays a significant example of the modernism which swept through the state in the years after World War II and embodies the characteristics of mid-century modernism and innovative uses of new materials. It is an example of the work of a leading American architect whose testing round was Florida. The design is both a significant innovation and adaptation to the South Florida environment. • 13 VII. Bibliography & Sources Britt, Laura Sinks, My Gold Coast. Palatka, Florida: Brittany House Publishers, 1984. Delray Beach Historical Society Archives. Delray Beach City Directories, 1953-54, 1955, 1957,1961,1963,1966, 1973, 1976,1979, Miller, Polk, Price & Lee. Domin, Christopher & King, Joseph. Paul Rudolph, The Florida Houses. New York, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2002. Hofman, Charles, Letters from Linton. Hollywood, Florida: Legacy Press, 2004. Palm Beach County Records, Palm Beach County Courthouse, West Palm Beach, Florida. Pierce, Charles W., Pioneer Life in Southeast Florida. Ed. Donald Walter Curl. Coral Gables: University of Miami Press, 1970. Interviews: April, 2005 Erskine H. and Virginia W. Courtenay, property owners. Randolph Grover, Curator, Biggs Museum of American Art Roy Simon, Architect, Delray Beach native Ernest Simon, Attorney, Delray Beach native Tom Woolbright, retired builder, Delray Beach native 14 Attachments 1. Photographs Attachments 1 through 9 2. Survey, house plans Attachments 10 through 13 3. Chain of Title/City Directories Attachment 14 through 15 4. Webb Brothers Info. Sheet Attachment 16 5. Art of Architecture Attachments 17 through 25 DBHS Exhibit 15 Attachment Delray Beach City Directory listings for 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. And 212 Seabreeze. 1953-1954- no listing (widow of John E. Biggs, Jr, Cary H., was living in GS) 1955-Biggs Sewell C. -no occupation listed- 130 S. Vista Del Mar Dr. 1957-same listing 1961-same address 1963-street address changes to 212 Seabreeze ( Vista del Mar re-numbered) Biggs listed rem to Delaware 1966 listed with rem to Delaware 1970-no listing for S.C. Biggs (Frank E & Dorothy J.Biggs-- Listed in Highland Beach) Richard McAvoy & Alice C. listed at 212 Seabreeze-- occupation given as lawyer (NY) 1973 212 Seabreeze is listed as vacant 1976- Courtenay, EH. & Virginia W., listed at 212 Seabreeze Ave. EH emp. Sterry Real Estate, Virginia- emp.. R.R. Robinson antiques 1979- Courtenay, Erskine H (Virginia W) assoc DeMarco & Sons Realty, Inc. h 212 Seabreeze av Virginia Interiors, Virginia W. Courtenay pres 706 E. Atlantic av, etc. ��rn e-,n 4-- 16 RUDOLPH HOUSE TIMELINE Delray Beach Esplanade subdivision Lot 21&West 35 feet of Lot 22(Unless noted otherwise) 212 Seabreeze Ave.,Delray Beach,FL 33483-7022 YEAR DATE EVENT CONSID- REFERENCE SELLER BUYER ERATION• PBC CTHSE 1938 24 Jan Esplanade subdivision established,bounded by Intracoastal Waterway on the East Vista Del Mar Drive on the North, Andrews Avenue on the East and Ocean Breeze Estates on the South.... OWNERS:Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK&husband H.W.WELLENBRINK& Willard M.WATERS&wife Willie E.WATERS Plat bk 18,page 39 1941 18 Apr Charlotte M.WELLENBRINK George C.MARSTED S100.00 DEEDS BK 627,P389 1945 20 Mar George C.MARSTED Stanley M.BABSON $100.00 DEEDS BK713,P546 1952 22 Apr Florine E.GRIER,widow Marie R.Mc COLLON $10.00 DEEDS BK984,P69 E 30'Lot 19,all 20,all 21&W 35'Lot 22 1955 13 Apr Marie R.McCOLLOM,widow Sewell C.BIGGS,single $10.00 DEEDS BK1089,P463& of Middletown,Delaware 1956 House built 2 stories,2938 total square feet with 2600 under air OFFICIAL RECORDS BK2129,P810& 1963 22 Nov Sewell C.BIGGS,single Richard McAVOY $10.00 OFFICIAL RECORDS of New Castle County,Delaware of New York City BK939,P379& 1971 1 Aug Alice C.McAVOY,executrix, Arno W.McGRAW& OFFICIAL RECORDS estate of Richard McAVOY wife,Helen C. $67.50 BK1921,P805& of Boca Raton,Florida 1973 1 Mar Amo W.Mc GRAW&wife Helen C. Erskine H.COURTENAY Jr$53,000 price OFFICIAL RECORDS &wife,Virginia W. $159.00 BK2129,P810& of Goshen,Kentucky *CONSIDERATION:Usually contains amount of document stamps paid the county or sales price,where noted.Document stamp rates: Before 1957—S1/$1,000 of price. July 1,1963—$3/S1,000.Oct. 1,1979—$4/$1,000. &Photocopied and attached Researcher: Richard F.Robinson Legacy Scribe,LLC,Boynton Beach,Florida 561.7422150 19 April2005 .1 • '" • • mow. , . '''i f •::i' -', -, /j '):i� fi•,''':f:N • vj ta��� .tom x` rr €� i t< - it- l -x`.`3.cr .,� r1i 3 € n. � i �i bi. s. - tom- 2' 1$-' = '� .�. �?"3 F _ ` tt-.17: 1<,_ 'z' �.- j f -.&•,.Sf.`E.Fi.,-ka• ir• 3'� Is.' ` __—_ f___ ! _._. -- __ a- b MJ �i.iL f F +-vt� 'U- . Al I c- zhrner14--* • 12)rniK.)%1'-1 IDPaul Rudolph Cep 1 eA -torn f "Po.u 1 -Rudo1 plc), he F.tor 1 Jet At1 eS 4•'- C;. 1 :ki ."::,i, V. i - - I ' Zi 1 ., ,.,a : ;:-x,.: .,......_,.__,.,..-z,_-_-_-_,,..12,,f,,•:. • eto.. :. ... _ 14 r'..„.". ::.,.: ..,.,.,....,..,:::‘,,-:,,,----::,-:-T.4-1_,:frilitr4111Grii!,;:sil 1'E__ __..:-11--jliz:_,--:-.--1. :T..7.-1.,1,111:7..i.11-i;';1Z,:;:,:,,,---1.1,:::.:-11.:::;,:-:--__.;;::-:.._____'',_j'-','"..L-L-;-1-4,-,:.-,T,-;:,:,;:ki:LZ.:,-k-1,1'7..-"......1c1--.'';:,1.1-1,";:,4:::faee!,6-: --?y,4 1_,,si'':: 41 11;. ,,,,4,,,, --- p ! 'S;• s : 1 t _ z r t v i,ems!`- 11111! • # 3 j a a 1 '.sue''-tr-;;::-=,..-,75:114 7.7,-7,,__, - •'''. ' ' - . la ,__,, - ..� .�..�._-.dam rg - - 1 r.. i ; _ ; , • p/...... T� .o� M1 `ems.' c . �y '^C.l.�_ t ,,i"f1* �-r2 £ er , — � 'H' +.�...3t +. J i'4i '� . �t ,�-. ....-. u,.. s-s.t..:,._. r .> l\Afic4ch 1.1 A-- 2- Ph ` rt let 55-547 Cop oE- Ezro GA-o1\er phoi-o y-a. In F-r-dm . a 1 r Nr== 6 Yr a �f4 i ,I '-.._._ '•'.. :,'.,-.A.:1'.f.t # 4 :te #ta a�r t 4. 5 " v f t v,,,1 % - 7--' _ . .. „,-;;;;.-AL,.- '-' 4.'- - -. i t .,..fr:g..4,-;1-1- ..' . ' .i4i$1, j-..,_____________.•''''':. . '• _ - -''t i . gm W.-:, t C:,-?' -,' '.. f ii,,1 - 9,id f- 1 t • CT F = cc�h b yho4ogr55��o 1Rnrner',Erk s �cA u1 iA8ot P • 1-)Cep ed- m 7 ue' Co rt dG. �-Th --. _- ' '.,- 4,-, ..:re,r,.46,, 1 Sri:- t 1. ,_,..,_ .._ „.....,„ :___,.._______ __ _ z;_si y 4 E.. •.41 C 777 ] .! ,. A . ' 2h 41i - • �� is , - r" fr. - 5 44 ' a`. F t ,/ •, .dr { i.• •`„ 1' .'�*fie' • `ice + ___ : sr: � � -� -•••,. {, , . fr r 1 5N, Y e;, ���, h. r• 7� ;. _ _.�.++ -fir'_ _. �.-r _ —r+�•".:f1.�3rr�-- .•__a's.� Tyr � . _ • , ... -''' ' 4: ''...4. ) '''../ 1.' .ft'Q--------,_..----1 ------________, I..„ 1., - -7- 'k•::,•e,...1..he' ', • { 'tom- ' y:.._== *�= - ';%- I •_-� -_ L ' , L , ,;=== R r r•� 6F �C -•�y��w�l!�• s �-�^ L'I g._,:::_,- , ,..!.,: . ., i X,,..-Z_.‘- - it',> .;.,- " '_, :.:.: • .. „,., -6•, _ _ :1R� : i4 • aK.. . s '1 • • II D id --, -r . , a:-_ - j _ • •-.:ter om .....�- -1-4ou5�. o r,a Land \WCz° Apr, \ la, 2006 • . [-. -• ._-. ' -.- -.-...:-.--:,-.-:4..:._--;__"-iZr.::-...-i-i-.,'.,-;,:_::=:.,:---;--..*-_--,-- -_-1.4-,.--,. .!:•.1,:-,-.-,F.,,,-.,,r2-..,..-,:-.,:--.*:1Y----.---:i.::.!,:v.,-.',5-::ie,--.:A .7:. . ,,,,,,-'•=-.7-'--,-".--'-•','-•-7--'':-`- -- -;',--.1-.•7.-----' •''•-r•- -1 '•--••- - :.• :-' ---'• ,•:'-'.•=•=-:-.:;i..•i-i.---C::--;•-_ _=-;:-=z,:;•- :',--'7 ;=•-'•Z--',-,-:.-'',-,: •-•--..-,i .:-.'=,--.:7---,,,:-;-•,ii). .-:.7.:-- -1;-.--_ ,-. .ikr:'.103...},1 r-J-.:;:-..7 2._7V-iL•- a-- =•--. .--'-:"--- 7:-•-', -,-=;-,--,--:•,-,,,,,:::- ._ ,-7-:••_.-•.::- ;-•-_-_,-.--_-;.- _ ,_,. _ =:-•,---,-=:- :::•--,.=:,.--,,:-_,-1-;_::...,,=:..:,,-..,. -:_.: .i,-.-7:g.-,:.,,:„-..4,-..4-;-;_±;-7.,...,i-.=w4,.- tzlii.:_-=';-,,L.tfl--.:--Xt...i•:,5i•-Ativi:.---. ...,a',...,,K-,-,,,„==._,-,21,,,..----..r..1 ., -,,Kii,f44.,.-A ---;:,-:•4 :"- -"=".:••=.:2-......±:s.•f....'4.-"--..:'-:- ::-..:.•::_,:-.:::•--,f t-t..4:'tit::.?-t, -.,,-------- ,,,-,-,-......,_,:,-.?;',..,-.4,,-4-.",,-,4-7_--t':.---,t,t..4,,,--,71.4,: t-4;4':-T--4t-r.t,:.-44',---it ;tit-±"-t_4?-;444-44.E.taltt--Lt4,t.V:44,M ,- ---,tfA "---',4.--4"4-,•:..;•:-t4-41:1`4,4-4ttt--.Jr<ttit't:-4444C---n.4-4...-FF-, t14-fii7-tt:'4NTittt.„,.4.-q=t--45.,i'lt-,- -4?-4:. .--_.1,-;> -,-.:,4:-.1...,-,._;y4:-.4*,"„)-..,.- --4 -'''-4.'-'''',"4-:1-:•.4 -'4,4R-1 ,.-Z4R24,44:7't-F,KPK-Zt.Wtt-t•?4-tTift--:!•-t -4,4Z?4,:ljt.',44tt. :4-4-'-i'r4145 -7.4g4",V,-.-t:rtif ...- .4•'-'--'1::::-AZaW-V4..--ti[7:A,„M-4,IP-,].4_:!,:" 4::•.,- ---- . -"44:ft:T44t-';'".•- -1-F-,:li'5;.:4:444- .-f,•§: 4.-:4-t'5-V_":--- •:4-r.-.4:4444-44,14i,t2;,-4-f4,.:i .',,;.-n'4'•' :',-,241--';4.-•:'-4-f.-. 4!-:.-t4 : -1:,_-_:_.--;.'f'•-",- -i-Vgi.'t:47-74-.';4,r:741t.`k",:;4t•h:4•4"444-:•:'•4::t4.:-44-;-•4:: -.-4 " . ...-4,t754:14:•i.t4.K4,:t.;--ii;i4P- ,t.:*A.•i.;,=q4V_t,•-t4:•4." .'..11?'--PM-42.,%;42f4rt:•- -411'2,,-,--.414F4?4:_ ,-W,if•-, "f-'t''-‘4,44iii-,14.1- -;f;4:444..t,'4,-iq'--X;.•--;..-ft4:r44 .-t-4,44•-•;-ittlE:'L':,-,;:--444 •--. , „,t47--;-:14±4-1-4-;---4,.il:': -';'‘..S-7;:titv-,^7,4,-f. -&-;-"7:4F•4-tt:_,:-4:444.t.tt4t,4.-tt",--"-,":- --Yt4.4.4 •44....---4t'4•••‘--4 .44.4Z',C44.•. .::a":•-t..-',--,47,1-k1 't 434,4-1:1 ;:-?,',•.-§X,F .,I,:IP-4-- -3-'!',5:•- ..-till':-....:1-1''i-:;-,-_-•• ••••-j'' ''',::.:T.'41:4_4'.:•'4--' -?::.•'-:f'-;tt- --:'-'.',-„.,,,-::4':::-;:'j5,. ''-rrMit:q; '-'-;•e.V•r:i;,4,„.--. :„--_,.. 4,ikl-'2i?" ..-14nit3i4. .4-74-7.3.1.'41*.4--- -.;..--=_ 427:;..4;;:;4•4-'4-1,. ' •;:fft444'.-4.:•1:4:YAi4Y4_,_;.4.,gt-t4,:,,":4-414;•:;;;'4":4.-:-'_1-4.4H.1. 4:_--;4--;'"----'-----44:.::t:•.:•:17'.4.:7C, :f.,.-§.4'f,.:,,4 :f.'L.t1.4 -:: .4- '''!4.i',11i.gt;:t:i4-P".Yii_f!ff•;--?31gMei';'t4i'il_Ri.;S;V--.-4;:;,42.4i1-Z-Elti'. .,.: ."-IP. '.4.'-',--iit.7--' -42--!?.."';1',.- 4,-_- ..'=.7-'i'''.-t.14.',.-4:,;-.-',.1._„...;.,,.:__,-.,-4:t,-,,--:.:..-:-'',- :-;-44".4-'4,t,T•±f',.--..-7.7,t*:,..-.k-ti.,..t-,..'4441sT,14;1:4-4:,-4A-Mi-Mti-ALV---'4.444'41•:--.;444. 44. 44•:;-:,. ,:ltIr:-.J-L-4 i''44.-:',:4!-•;t :4•:-•Y.-4e-4 •.44.T4:- i...... .t:';'-'.47.4't.4-4.4- 4-;.--:-4.:tt-4--r-t•.4-1V,4•-t.4...4,.-:.'•--4...•''1•'' - : -••••_- -4. . .•4'. '-'•' "-.'-:71' 'tr:i'r-:rit4-.4.44-4'-•••. :--1 -',.ti44.Z1.-tli-Z. I'11444.4:•- •t4.' 'C'i-: ,'S...---4-44t:44-44.:-;••?.':'-'::.$.44Zn-C.,444'- -4- .'tt•,-:14t,147. 4,-"4.-'; •-,.,•lk .T..-3,--, f1;14,-;-i1.-t-4•:,;i44.k:2_44--;::',"tY444..,'''-':4•::--.'4't4;_.:4••-,'.:•:. ..4' :- . ' 44 -: '•.'.:-;'..:'.-•:4_4:t:4'.4..:-4:44:;i '_'.. -..f4. 4: 4•.'4,7---- '4•4''.14'''''"'-'',--,X.F.af.4.4-tYt::f:',--ti"4"T;f:,. ... -'4-4;;••-•-•7--'-4 .t:?:=4.14.-';'_•;-:4-n-r.,44V*.-'-'..i ,_&:.k.tt,'F,,... ..T,t2_2-7.:4,,-,-.]:;,4„ .4 .-4.:-....4,;,-;!•::, -...; . ...-,, : _..- -._, t• t.'- 4'r:-.,-,..•-•::,4„:-;:-.:,,,,'...,::.,"--.4'.4:_4,'4,-:-.:1;, k.it,.tift:.4:4 _,::,,,,."1,-;;‘ . „iL-Z-, - .,..: 44-t.-,li., 4t-ft .tf --t-.-,4,;Z-4.:',-;;444.-4ri-';',-•• :4-7:',.. .-.ri ;V172i-4.4.2-41g; i4,;'4i:4,,,-!:4-.:-.4, -4'-'44'4••-, .'-':-“'"':''_...._.'-t- .:' -' ' -t. • . - :'•-4--,.,,4:-_'..:±1-4.-4.:4;';,:t i• 41 4:4E ..:.4, t.,f-:,41'*;4,;:i??4,-4:?trt.:.t.'1,, i;itj..3,--:• -'2,41_,44.'".:4:Y:::4J.: 2...,-•:.t.'4,Z-,.:',:',?',-',..t,Viti -_0: 4,.4,',-.'.-:••••;:,t;1-:_:--!;7.,4:1--,, t'_..y 4'_ ,--t,t.----4:'..t.4. •";-4-• ' ..-':-,.:. .'_'..•,,,_:-..-,:f4-;4...-4-'_4,--.-A4. - :,... -4-if-t'ti?tr.:NV •':;:(4.'1'.;04,----i•t'.q. -;;P,:ti ;:,-47-421:,:.•-, -;i••k:e.•4•-.44;4-:4 -414',..;4•41Z4_4 ''-dtt'it:;:,.4„-t; .-ififI :.;•;-•4;1.,'::-444,41 4•:.'•-,44,4';:'•,-':.:.4:14.4-,-:- .--.•'.‘-4'',4' ,:''1.1'4. t.:.'lt.-''-':'.'..-4';;44.: .,'-'•••,',-.. ...-,..4-Aa'!:,•:4,44'-Atat:TO. V..4k4_0;ktit.71-.1-t,.;:_!•?1,;1747,..TSIAtjOit,.•-•:t.4_40'i:,t4,-N -;t*:4`::44- -; 4''''.4. 4'4-.'4.::' .'i 'E.-4s•-•1.:''..'4•-11:-'-'-'::••'-:•::-''-'- •-:-•t.--.. -7.-:-.:•:...-.--:-.X'':':'::::'-'1 .f'-.'-'--4',.:::-4:';'--4.;:-.i-Z-,:-:-.ZU-Ceif,1 lit _:'- '- ',4i.t44..f;'-ai-;',5-..•3;14.:;4.',144•4 ..--'..ii,--,,i3.--, .-17„-i.:-F,--.. .": •;.'::'.-§i,, - . ',.::::, ---::::-. .-.- -",:;,:::-;.--.::::,t-•,-,:- -_::_:.• -:-..---.=::.-...-_-_-i;:i,,•)..,i,;'::-Ii2„:"., -;g3,, .4i „5::it-4'.43:43-_ -,..,?:'--" •;-•:::: :,:-;:g,,:;-:- '-4g.:-!!a.;:,.-€tn..-,4 ...... ..„_:,, _ -:.•'_,,,,.-,:-...-:•--:,,-:-.7_--_,•;•:::.--,...•:::-:::.. .i.-A--,:i.:AEv.:',.---- •--=:. --'-±7.-..-'-:-:- ? -. --`..5...;=:. ...M.-';'?:-•_-•'f----?, - .•== .-,----..-'-'• ----- - ..-- '-•='-'•'`.- - -'''-:•:::'•.•":7-='?-::•'''''-::•:'•'-':..-':,..-,--1-!--;-,:.',=_;--:---'.-•,"4---- 7:•,-I---i,•-i- -"i4§-4.--U4.4-4tV `,4.;17M-:,Xt-'1-.:ft.',':--V.'•?Ti--..-',;. --‘:---:•-r- -;. -'3I.-1'.?_''tt-'2.1.e0;•04 ,77-'-----•-t-'"'''•-'-•,•••'•44-'-'-';'," 4.4"-4-444'-'-'''-;-•- t-':ir,•":54-4:;•41•ti -4-$-.5-4,^,. ..-- - ' - :.4-.'444,4-1--14.\t;,A1,44.-44 tt-,4''';'4-"t-t-Z-.;-4,'74..;-E.:,--',:-...,i-- F.,.4=1-4.,4.:';./.14t.t.4,4AAZ--i. -,-----,---'''''-'444:'"-44'''':'-'4---4"''44'4-tt't----'7444--‘4,14-..---'tZt - ' -- •-- tt. 1 .--..ti-,-,•,--tn,"-.-,_-',,-.---7,-_',-,,,,:-.;.tr:..:,,f›,C..._..,!A,,,,----.',•:,...tAzg.T.I.i _1,--t",:,..i4-4.-;-44tt4-,--,..--•,;.=---,447---ttttt.4'44- ..4...:t..-,`,-.-.-,.-„ . ' ',..' .:.4:-'44----g'..t..tizz't:`.44,t4 `i•-4'--" - J4:,-:.:,•_7.:.-. . .:s; . -,1--.•,--:.:.--7,',-r,-,-.45:-I---.--*-L-7.Vir:,--sv;-----•'----"---:7-7:------g-1-'-',4-7- --,,- .'• '•]•-••t•-44.-:-.1--t4•4`44.4:44,'---71-.:444":.-',47i-t 4-'t.. -.14.R:t•'4,4Z't.--. -;-1;.4-Xt:,--_f-. . ?-:4 .",,4:;-•tt""!-`,14.-:ft.:.4...4 4 44--,.. 4f.-,;_;i,--:::4, . . l't; '!"";'''4'''...:.4 't-,'""4.:-.4 tit7;•..- -'.t"--;-:t4;:;;•4.:444:;Z4,:tt,iti--1;144ttt•4" i '6-4- •L----': - t -: i-. 4t.-14.15ft-*-tit-R-' --•-•::-4-71.1":.• ,":4:i4-:4i'; r3S-'''- ..,,,.._. !..:4-:.-•:,j'j' ,_ :t ti4.4., ::'1:-4.•••;•`:!,:'74-n'ir'-''''!2-.44.al--.f.F3'4.4•1 4V.451--tr:t.t.--4-.4. - ::;:47':4-4,,,,.,-t. . 1L-4-•-•.:44si 'i---z•f':: ::4•,'-'-:-.-• 4d _-_-- 'S'.!_'..:,_•'t - : ::'1 •_•'',---4 T4:411;47- '4iitj ! 4..1;;-.Z-,--:::,',T-4-7_tit';4-f•:, .•:::'rti -1-2:_--,7:--::'-; , -.: .:--_--,::„-.T1t.4.-i.;,;_f_,'-.,;24--Zzfti,ati : .f-.-:.2-:,-,i.,,,-i'i.':',- ..- ---. . _ , . • ___V.-::;.:,:,.,,•.:;i ',-::.-_--.'.-,.,---:-:':::Z.:jil.;: •.:i',4.:: ,..4-.ii."1:1.1:14A.1 1 -i--_, _. :,,,:',-f.,., : :,:,,:,:,,._. :,•_,---:...---.__. • _-„ii-1-, .:44,:,,-,*.:1424:_lit-T tIgar:',':: --- Ti-_-..1: 1:-• .',• ;',•.--g'--S.:,-.._ac.;-:::--_::,E.'.:,',1,&--s:.,. ;',,-,:: ::,-ii• -il',-.-m i-',':15.,"All:i4! I ! '-' - ,,,,,:,:„ _ ....„:__ _._,, :::-_:=,_i :. -;:-,_-.:____,,,:i--, ,;,_-.:-.,-.:a:,_._ -_,-,..._ ...1,...,---.---.2..: . ..:b. ,-_,*:•_,5-,;-:,,,,,.....:,..---,..J.-,,•-.T.--=,,,•.:-..r.t7-:!.-7-.v.,,,„:-.---,,...F-, 1 _t_;..-.. , 0-i4 ., .. .,_ ,__,.,.„.„ .__ . . _ • •,,_„.,„...„, ,,,„;-:-„,-,--_-:-.,",;•,,i2:,,,,!-„;.n,.:-:::,..1_,,::,..:_:;:,;-4--,,,,:-,-,,_.,, ,•-. .::,: -_--,-:::,,,,1•:_;.,_,,,•;; v.i- --;t..7-_--::.,_ ,:-.1..1'''•-r- ::_."1-_-g--_1...4.-yr _. ,,,,,g,- ',------..-. .i-_,...,-77,7f4,4--- ..7,', -i-_--,,,,,,i0_4--cz,.-tri Ell:;:-;--..i.., -----:,,-:,.:::.• • ,• ,,,-..2,,,,',kT'4. •.'.-:..t..:='•:..-,:,m- -)7ir,L-0,-All 0C9 (11 . _ ...... -.._-- , . ---_,-,., -----, - '-.-. r\f -;',,,,: 1 T:-..„4:.wkr-i,TR:8i.:.-ii-f. 4:1-3f4iii7.4-:::-Fi il'4,-: -':: :g:3.: 4-; -:•i_Ag-.F..f:•.,::::f:14:glifTi?,-ikti-:%: .. : 0 P t.. ':.,:::::::::;-':-.,;-,1:.- --::-= -:-,:: ;- - - :r : --.:,*:-.:1'. -_,.i',!-;:--_:=3:,, ,,,, r:,,i,:, 1.7,,..„., ,,gst, tr.,-,,,,,-,,,,,,,q4:-„-.,:=-5 &,,,__i;if.i .:4.1'.'414 t:'-il:;-444Z''-.. ..4'4"•t!it'tR---;A.1:T,..-16.4.14;P't_t4,-L'.. 4 • - 1 '-'-"-'-.,1_',4,144i7 - - -- ••- • 7----It' -;'''.',tit-4-'-' .4, 4 tV 7-.'Itt., i 4-.;,--t-..'-,4-qt:4:4-. 1-41,?.. t.-4-.-4.3tt,4*4414. 4'-i-1.-i.4:4 .t-tj,-.1‘.;--tt'.-.. -t4:- .-1-,I,F.-4--lit-Altn.% 4-t4... taii471-:;',-....,44 .,,,,-,.74.i. , ' 44'1 : :=-:_-.-':''-"•'-'' •;"; ''''''':'4-• ' . ' • -:--"':±ii' ':-'i''..J.:-;7' •- i ''r-.‘: .------:, ittl-----'5-04•41giVEZ-:-.;:•'It...,Sfg•-g.-&-VaK-.:•--ftri--744.',?;-=18.111.5Z-e:'-' '. IP ...,-‘1 •-\k., i ..-------:- :_ ..--_" - ' • '• 1,• -=•----'-; '''.'ii:cirl- __--,-Ylvvvia„.„-A14-44 ,.tit-fi*rt-;i-',--re'-';=4;i7i•P'-• _:•,.':. r.'-'.::._:,le-Tqf'-•--C---'. i.'---•;:- .:•g-i'-7'.P-7----T •g-,‘:1-Zi-alt-r-lita • 0 "' 0 -'-= '-----:-pt: r•-• -r _ - , '7 i'-3 `,"-='_----,"4.44-i-P:2'VL•'-'4E----'.f.-1 -'''''T-4-1--;'.-1.-:•'-ri•-•=4I-1:-.':: 0.-,•,..,, ••1,---::••_.-,..-2.?.sit ::,,,:. =.=;-:,,,r'g-'-...:6.:-.E.. :1-,.-.-1.--,.,,kif::..-",',1,,34--a-c--ty.ws-o, -, _i ._ • . --1 -..••,-.--,V,s-,--.;$--.4"54-4--;_tr.,'• .„, .I.V.p----:-17..4=',Z=. --f-g - -:-,--4*.4:1':'-:4--',-,'-';:;41'-''• '=:;-:-=1:-.3,12=', --'''iv. '-'-;•4&'•----''-'ASIS-M-'-ir4•4' = •-• 0 0 - ;' ' '-'•-7,- - • ' • - , ---"-- ‘... :`-=-''';'--Zel-, •‘,_51!0*---:---f 4--z- -'.*=,1.,.,;.-41-1_ii',....x.-i-1._ ----i,-.- , -,L.:-...,-.':,,,,z.3-:-,3-,--;1,,t- 74_•-:-..--i.:...11-.--i:.,;,, -=,_±- =,,, ,.71:4.,y-i,.-:-.i.,-,.-1,mt=,3-4--i•zill • , ,, . J. i_--; - - - . : ,I - : - -•.=.:ti.:-..;•f-,•,-F:1-g.„--__•,aw_-:.:,_440,4--..-4.:.., :74. ,i.--104.,:lot--A.i.ftl-t,i- :-.•%,--,•,:2,-- ii,:-,,.---_,-.-. .-I-. • .-=,!4..,-..1:-_,..4, , ... ,:.-L.,,,,Iffi..,7,-.; .;;--47-A.v,";.,: _=-.....0-,-1:-.1 - ‘......)•0 ,r-N ... - - . -. i; . i ••=_=:.-:.N-:414-t-I-Vi_ M`t`,:;- •-'i•-•4 ' gii.,,asillis..le, ---J-r--4:''.-'14-:iri4t ii:-:&i,:41,'W '-: --:!':::-.0ft-:•'.1.4i-,,: .4!4-:Ztij : ":": 1 U •.•=4'i';C'P''''t'A':"- k-alt.'1'4-'21'M 4--T-11•AF4 7-44.'4'- ' • t-''''.--74.--,-- -',--A;41n.i4,,:i.- t:'P-72- At::....J--: r: .--:•:';',AV.ff,:tf-,,,r '::=-4---7.. .: n ,(3‘' , ' .,.. .1,,,• ..i4 4'.t;-'1-4 ,..:4417,--_-_-.-_ ,_.,._,...,::,-,!..„. .,,,„,...1._ ,.„.,_ _ - ••. ------_--..,i,,,,A,kr.-s.s"-.4;,,,7,-. ..,RA _ __. _ ,.._ t . ... _,_ _ :,_ _ _ _ ,s4..:::fri-"..-t. .:4-•'.--:4Ntcl.ieri,.,-74-A;14.-; . -t44 's 4:,'I.'4'''''''•' - ''.- ,t .. - •4.'4--'t- ',_': :.:_.-4 4',,A,i•:;.: ;-'.-- ,;---tA:-.,.:4•!..-,ts,--;:.-t:'-j.4 ,...;--t--".';-.-..•-----' , lt,f:.:%t.i.•'- als,. .,':',4',V.::.„ '71T:;;;-T•i_j 7•T-,..&-.3-!AV 1 ..: • -. . . ..-_.-_---:..-,._IT',., 3....44:,-,-‘14-41a44Z--;iteR4.."-N-?,54-: ;";:-_-,,,it, :,..l..t._l_it4,t..4',4t-,-:--44-j:-'14,' .L'_t tj;t341.„43, -..V.tge,t_*;,,, ,'":.:;:: _-,- :-::;t,-3f.:•t-1-1:11-7--r-L--.:1:'."-t4t-J4 '; .14 .i _ ,-•„.::,-,.:,-. 1_1...._'4i,',14-]!,,t_t!l'•4414.W54:1;14'73ffit'faiaa.t%.,4_4V;**44it'Vit.-'''''44.1'4.--;4•:-•:••.44-r--i. '7;,-?. --,,,,211-,. 4!t•'4i4MV-i.,:-r-;:-:-f14•'''. f.:4."144.;;,:lit;•--•--4---;'?;;.-"?.tetit i (2. 1 1,•-::::::•-,i;,•,i- - : 44ii6-4i1-44.'tii1.4V,44•40.,,Aaff:ft4;-1.:•7;t Sat-Ire.•''' 7;!:--ii,•.-_,-lry-' :•i• ii-!-•.'-'''.- -('-li-A;:-Aifit=•;i7_,,z.,',F1.=----"' ''-;-.•-_-';:74,--4-.4 tAr4.41-13, ; CO 1 ; -4:'..f.''A:7?A'..:•'-- -' 7AliAL•f--•;;;-#45:4 -.;-,:-",-,ft:.%-2,-•.';:t .•--.-i tif.t_f-At;,4-',3;:-.;.; -,--.. .:•;:*: .;i,..';7•P•f4,17,,,,'74; ',,'- iii-;• .-tf,•;'.4.tr-A-CAPA th 0 1 --14.i,'.;'4(ti?"-4Pri-34-1.fiar;P-40.,?;•7- -.•! --...;i:il - -:141;**-', --1;- Pii;t--ItiN; i'-'14F-.,--:- '''''!_4'4T4.,-,5*-itifitai:9.17.,•;:t4 P91-1-rif-V-4; i cb- i A "4'4'4.!:".4'••= 4- .-i14-V3--Vielt•-1• 14-R-4,--i ,'''214Z17:W. 54 i'Z'O'i 4.014,-•,A,11 t4 ..tta-,._ivt:;:=4if attrw: ,_:. -,.'_c.i.-,,,,:-. -A-iy,t..-•!.t.f_1,,.-,.;-,,,.;:„_,I': raitti.-7: :-F-;,:_-*, 1 , 1 f:-"-4''t,t4-34. 4-,=..4,--1. ,....,-:=.1-XEIT,.?-1.;----44:1'..iF=7-?'.--*---':--.:-.'1,;5.-,.---..*••- -g-..--•,-a--. tkv.,,:a,z -'''''j-6,',A--:;r4-.,FI--.7.7-,-,,, , -76-0:::•':,--•-' '--i'__: -:.--.:.-• --:':----i•'::0-4---:.;.- •:.• -.4 I ' .L----11- -'1-:,'"'---7,_'_'z'•.:7.-;.C.,--'•••f,mr-11,-4.•:1---1'-!'14-_-.1.4=.:--;*..li:'i;•-g,--:::4ij-E? .!.5,'•!?'..' -;----,,'--- -,• -•-_,,-..--7-",---:----;;P,T-ze-1-4..e.-85e7jvi„,.•--:--.. .i-_: .--.,._-•_!k,-7i, :?_?-.:,,1-:•=..,f:Tt ; _. 4,-,iz i,_tY.-4,';',''---,-4-t.i t:-.!ttiT- I.,,..rtr..,,i,::::.=*i.t,N;-K11-,•:•ri.g,;,,jii:-,----_-',.--,-i.T.T.r .;•%-. .-•-"-•',.-:.t-,-„-4j,•-:;ia-Wi-iN,'rt:te7,4:!N-::77, 7''''''1'‘-''- .'=-. '*."••'',-• ••,:':'::".t. . ' " -- . ' ''• '•.5 •-i'i.-4t47,;1' ;;-'7;--.--•;:;;-t.. •'-'111 -.p.'--•t.--.:'_'-;:-.,'--- :!::--;"-Iiii - -44.6.,_40--ftis :4,10.0...----- l''' •' !Ii.:f.'--- - , '•.'{-:'_'-ftv:V.Alk--',. .-g;•'.iT •...-i '':It .iit.-.1.1,..tit•-p*- iii*:-Wif-04 -: : - • w-;,'--.-,.._-.4:.,x,'-,--:i-o,f4lcz....A:;:'..4-5 -----114.4wp.f.sw-iimff.,,_.,..,_Wv.i.:.: -.€•,- - _ - - _- ----..--, -- -,., • ..,Th..-.-----,,,,,,,..,,,,,L,,,,,v,:=.--.----fg,--,1..i:---,__--,,..-...',.:•s7.,....-----.$,74-,...,. .. .. -.....,.....p,.... .g.....,-=!,----it-11/4,5..,..,,,,,--- --• - . • - • •-Cti44.-ii.1?1::'-:,-:,_-\-,.:-i,;';:-r.iiM:qt:'igA;.•i'6-',-t-•i.-:W:?:M;t:rlk-i:g7' ..-. 7.. •: - -. _•- , • - --- , . :2.•.,•-:,:.•::: :::_,_---.1.• -;!:''--;-._;W; 7±-:;•::,?':•-•1-7,11-r#-14.61- .:.t-Zf7t.t-t-Olg-7,. -'--T .7:.-:-'::.'-':: '-' : - --- : • : • ..------:.-- ''.- ', -- ---•-.-'.' 4i .-i?..Ji;.;.:-7!.;..:*;•4 ---15.1k,-;.$-*74;:N2-$;;-•- •`..,::::, -,-n;:,,,,. ._7,-,-.7:-: ., . . ::„-. .-. .7 - -•- •-.- -,,o• - •-•4 l'it-4,-'.,•-6„::,_,,:_d4AitAli'l,'..4-;:::•-!.-r,S.-?:-_-:--N-'-''" ' : ::,..-..... ,:.:_.-_- --•• :.,. ---• _ ,.....i. • :. . -. - • --,-, ._. -.-... ....„: -- - '---,.: , ..„;,----- .. .'-....-7 -... ...,,,. ._-,E-, • • - -... ..:, ..-,_.... :,-•..... - -:- , _ _„_:-- _ . -...:. -_•:.-.;;: _,. ----,.-_:::„.:-.,-. ..-.:: .. -:',..•- :7., .,, _ _. .• ,., -- ' . ' •.J.-.. ... . - .. .. , , ,•,...,, • .. ._ r., . ., . ,r...... ,_ . ,.,--...-_,- 2..--, .• . . -: .; : ..- . - .. -..- • . • - • - . , . • •... - . ... . _ ,___ . . .•.,s _ ..._ _ -._ _._. ___„ .. . _, _,, , . _. .-- „,.., __.._ _ .• . . . :.-,.... . . . - . .:. _ - , ..__- _-. - - -• ,.. , , -.. , - - r r . _ .-. -•_.-- • • ,-- -.7.--_. • '-. . -: -."-.7-- ....--:-...'-_ „ - - : - .• - • - --. .-.:' _ • . . • - .. - - . . - . . _ - • --- . . • „ . .. -. ._ :. • .- , , ••. .:-..,...... . -.,:.-7. . : . ... . . ,. - .-•,,.--...7,- -. _ . .. ,. . . . -., ... ._-.: -.., _ - -,-- - , • . .. _.....,....„ ..,... .„ _ .-.:• ,-.•_ ..... - . - _ . i __ 'F' F iC z 7 / L ES SH E I N G t7 /IG WHICH DLOcK H S uN BUT ALLO„1 MOVtME_NT LOUVE1 S f tovI X H rL US Ll T b . - _ • • _ _ _ • HEAT6f\1E_K\TINe � UGH 7.6% KITGH-NS A NP LAUN9 .1 3 1 OM LIVIN0 SAGES. e 1=olz MAXIMUM V HrnL TIoN UNTr.c fNn THKOU&-1 Ti-E f