Loading...
60 Palm Square, *1928 - FMSF Florida Master r r Site#8 PB00300 Site Master HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder# File `ice' Electronic Version 1.1.0 Field Date 5/10/2008 Form Date 6/15/2008 FormNo 200805 First Site Form Recorded for this Site? NO FormNo=Field Date(YYYYMM) GENERAL INFORMATION Site Name(address If none) 60 Palm square Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names » Surveyor Project Name Marina Historic District Resurvey, 2008 Survey# National Register Category Building(s) LOCATION & IDENTIFICATION Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 60 Palm Square Cross Streets(nearest/between) SE 1st Street City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YES County Palm Beach Tax Parcel#(s) Subdivision Name Palm square Block 125 Lot 30-33 Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Route to(especially if no street address) MAPPING USGS 7.5' Map Name Publication Date »',DELRAY BEACH;1997 Township: Range: Section: 114 section: >> 46S ;43E ;16;Vague / Unknown Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone 17 Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) 2007 Tax Roll Palm Beach County Property Appraiser DESCRIPTION Style Mediterranean Revival Other Style Exterior Plan Rectangular Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 125 Structural System(s) » Wood frame Other Structural System(s) Foundation Type(s) » (Unknown Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) » Poured Concrete Footing Other Foundation Material(s) Exterior Fabric(s) » ,Stucco Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) » Flat Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) » [Tar & gravel Other Roof Material(s) Roof Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) » Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys 0 Chimney Material Other Chimney Material(s) Chimney Location(s) Page 1 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FuiM 8PB00300 DESCRIPTION (continued) Window Descriptions Fixed and casement, metal. Arched windows to front. Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) East elevation facing Palm Square. Brick walkway. Arched door with decorative surround. Original door and hardware. Porches: #open #closed #incised Location(s) Porch Roof Types(s) Exterior Ornament Decorative door surround, clay water pipes, balustrade to front parapet, exposed rafter tales, decorative tiles. Interior Plan unknown Other Interior Plan Condition Good Structure Surroundin's Commercial: Residential: ALL this category Institutional: Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Number I type of outbuildings,major landscape features) 1928 rear accessory structure. Archaeological Remains(describe): None observed If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? Narrative Description(optional) HISTORY Construction year 1928 Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): Changes in Locations or Conditions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes >> Rehabilitated to standards;1957;;Repairs to guest cottage Structure Use History Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended » Private residence;1928; Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) RESEARCH METHODS Research Methods » Informal inspection Other research methods SURVEYOR'S EVALUATION OF SITE Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? YES Name of Local Register if Eligible Delray Beach Local Register Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES Area(s)of historical significance >> Other Historical Associations Explanation of Evaluation(required) This residence represents a style popular in the Florida Land Boom of the 1920s and illustrates the development history of the area. This resource contributes to the Marina Historic District. Page 2 of 3 141040, T - 6 , i- V • t . , a 1 !o 'P s .. , Allail% wg1 • IR1111 _ _ s 0,4 ,li�iltt iri .�- lk .. •r 44x _ HIS i JRICAL STRUCTURE FIM 8PB00300 DOCUMENTATION (Photos, Plans, etc.) Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other Important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name(Last,First) Adams, Warren Recorder Address I Phone 618 E. South Street, Orlando, FL 32801 Tel: (407) 423-8398 Ext. 3006 Recorder Affiliation GAI Consultants — SE Other Affiliation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? ****** MASTER SITE FILE USE ONLY****** SHPO's Evaluation of Resource Cultural Resource Type: Electronic Form Used: Date Form Type Code: Form Quality Ranking: Form Status Code: Supplement Information Status: FMSF Staffer: Supplement File Status: Computer Entry Date: Form Comments: REQUIRED (1) USGS 7.5" MAP WITH STRUCTURE PINPOINTED IN RED PAPER (2) LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP ATTACHMENTS (3) PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, B&W. AT LEAST 3"X5" Page 3 of 3 1 PB00300-200805 Supplementary Printout > USGS map name/year of publication or revision: DELRAY BEACH;1997 > Township/Range/Section/Qtr: 46S;43E;16;Vague/Unknown > Structural system(s): Wood frame > Foundation types: Unknown > Foundation materials: Poured Concrete Footing > Exterior fabrics: Stucco > Roof types: Flat > Roof materials: Tar&gravel > Roof secondary structures(dormers etc): > Change status/year changed/date noted/nature: Rehabilitated to standards;1957;;Repairs to guest cottage Rehabilitated to standards;1992;;Exterior repairs Unspecified;1993;;Swimming pool > Original, intermediate, present uses/year started/year ended: Private residence;1928; > Research methods: Informal inspection Examine local property records Examine local tax records Sanborn maps FL Master Site File-Cultural Resources Building permits > Area(s)of historical significance: > Repositories: Collection/Housed/Accession#/Describe > [Other name(s)]: Page 1 Of 1 If !ELi:71y 'd 1 -_-!'F r'•-�.,...1�Y41 �..-.._•.._ ram - _ 4 S. ;, w4 TH S T 1 f3 �t . ---- i I . Ell ! " k I ''' ' II! 1.- -• 1/4. !;, ; -, j 1 ., i _ j 1, r 0 I r ,,f---"T'•--D ri ._.....77. ..„.,„ ._, ,. 2l] 1 ` �,, r- -?• j-, Ill . 1.2 1-17—Vatgriffirk 4-0 I I L4 ; Ill p,.4 , 1 1 i ,.. , i • • , • �}I �_ r f l ,f . •rou d ' ' ' ' tY Y +i I 1 Y + i II 1111 lit - 1 i � i .jr , • , -- <: t,r - li f i mi imp/ , i : , .4 1 4 tj tillPark ii1iiiiIIIt is ° ctt re 4.„„ ----,':- 1 N, f : 1 : .r—i . l i 4: 'irj. ,..., - i ta!Li ......] i ...::. 77-7 kij molt :` i • , I a t O rr .Z I N i.., i ki ' f .t , .; di .Ili a 11 gigi rt1rat 1:,-..ri r' ' ,' ••• ,s. .'.- i:: ...--1 i 4: 2 • 4 u � ,. i re- 1 �j j .. r Wy- -! •dry i'. - t t ° i s DII• - �+, L 1 ai rt■ -+ �L.. • S_� li l.y w ? ' r 1! , _ -'_ • Ian r F • ttr tall g•L r,., 4 ! ®alila 1 ae 3 } • 1 j-_ 1 ' 3 I t yastnlB iJ�' ! ? g �' a ■I I: 1 fit' itaaaoar■■j • d _ _ �}E}p�o!+ l r S ■a..ls. (i(9t30�i101: r r tra r �._ �JI- IN!C...-.-"- - 4 It? ar ' * r o• a, 4w■to-laa0.D AfQ ! t ` ' :I[i�Y �•^ t { _r - a tt3 ., ar'`t�0i+a■at' ! t i _; , 1 stu: i� at a t wart I iF�r ' • rr • 1 1 2.1 / 1 1 ' 1 • i a ® . �`; r{((} 2.4I., 3 i • L ® Q uq. iF f lt _ 4 ' ' r•a i a 1 g , .i BL�`l 19 a • meta r _ -8 1� a '— _ Copyright(C)1997,Maptech,Inc. 21,1 ,.� ,- i -.. 1 1 i t ,., AT LANT!C AVE ��_R .u. �� _ }r F-- �.,ri i `• ;,/,Al wA I E �' 1� i , , 4 r I rm..' L a ii T4 • p' 1` �t � 1 .1 L14.i..... - 1 III it ia w! RJ .. ,eR. t�� tq ILA .�:.- W r,�>!f+ �I�q ; u , 1 ,+(H�! F s` i�, ��� cc.. TnA i -r.ims .5,,I,��1 •• 1 i I HARE- I �f aili �'1 i3.., It• •4,..n . r+=•1�>♦ 4 w+-' `.t .. - .4..1a �:Y.„,„ , tS� �.�I y. • 4wrimpip •l:,i.l� �, [`_ �y •� , (mot I'.)Li f` r .- - —� - J I ! (31� ,y j J. fit; '' r 02 1 : oELR�r E 5A_ I VSLOAN y ,.r — _ ;31 aeAcn q1,f• " �. 4MMOC,+s �4 a � f CI cN l • n, ,� x ) 04. 1 FQ Q LQ' Az_ a�.� �GL. ,, /1 k'C 4. i: tie II o = Fa %F';!f t): g= a?l a =� 1 4.;► j A L� v IE.� k9 � 1 1 7 ONE ... •,7.172:3_ 1 wzrilli, _ENTER -{� . COaID .1 1 t1�F LZ .�•.' t`� I 1 ~' • 's"' S� I'' ,$, G► I' . . .�,3.1 _.1 I N —717-.1r 3 et ,:815s.c & --1 39ACj . -_._ 21 `:1. =— 1 J ff ; rowE �� I � « is 1 I. a, z' n ,iir . ( L . �j �� TK i Rae_;xt...i_ r_ L*, - `A19. orill 5. tt 12 27- (, ` Poona I � . r -I 1-2 C . 151 . Z1` f-- ' 1� f ! �n:1 - — 12 j tj [ ._71/4)-1,..-‘;.7.:- .1 Ir,r=, tll—,t t•• W 7 ;:a, ▪ F -y'�L�'I_ YILLA ▪ f.�—Ill= �.��, I .r O ,l = 'i,<F-47'"'16-• -4�► (}U,c-�p'..�� 41. ' 1 •(ID s `11 Cn J Dawn S_I 14 i 7 - �' `� l ^SIX __ z ,... .. ,._ - 1 .-' - - - -- - M M 1-.) 1 IQ..il : 27,y 4 FIND 1 y „-• , 7 4)--- ' illN:.fv,Z.7.1 1 SEAGATE M,^,i\a,.P ,.-.NIJ - F PB3P2 NW J?PINEAPPLE GROVE VILLAGE COND(2006) NW H3 PORTA Al.MARE(2006)PB101P' --46-21-01 SW J8 ROYAL ATLANTIC PLAT 120061 Pe10?P10 - .^""^..,"•,- 7 2-22-57 --Frame,,Guest, Cottage & Wall AlongRear P L $ j a `{ "" / 18.. �..16 L..�P� �, a ARL'ES DEIBL , =. r 3000 � r • 2 th. Ave P3ttsb'ur h Penn. fTV OF..,..DEL Al':;BEACH, FLORIDA �z � ��+ , SUBDIVISION • BLCCK LOT Iti'��l BO3C"75j,c�S1� 11 Improved 05%NER (30,31,32,f �� 9° . e6t�s'_� ��r, ��: c • 125 I Vacant �a U. 1)ut;h 1 �P tltor 33) Vacant ADDRESS M�� use vr ,.., 2021 1.46Bsc ,, Bldg .'gC.Leve DESCRIPTION: OWNER P.JbI'p'E _#3386-Remodel Interior- 1,800-1/7/55-Ted Roth - ' ' 14 - Lew-ls=-F.- R- Bel lnws_�,,, .1 S 1001 of N 563,61 of E 1001 J` f (- OWNER • �7/' i� %,' �d., �i r `. l�n OWNER d� �w.,Y. au.ri.:a�.ay::� l RO• .~ 44 ,�# .eft. y 7; / 9L C. I �nIPtOA+�E ADDRESS 1439011MetteretirrI.Thent4411184PPIIIIIK 60:.Palm iltr-.;:: .r.G YEAR- 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 EXEMPTION - - _ 1958 1959 LAND .. n y d O D 7-5 b ' a/.J ; BLOCS. 7"C`) ) / l, D to t'n rJ -C ( u� / 7 °�1 LI/ `��� /Q '� X n ���� �. TOTALS !/ r d V !! Cr �i` cr �:�� t`y W) ✓ CA �i 0 // I t // ,5/4 !.,;,1 ?ry ' !.(y (' �; 1�� GI 2 O .0 `�:'4P-0 i• . r, i'r'Gr—t'l /� v/',G J y �J e ' / a PER. PROP. �f 1 00 6 I d �� �� /���L/ F (��1 ( 'Jr{). 'J DESCRIPTION OF BUILDINGBUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMEI • TYPE BLDG. CASEMENT ROOF T FINISH MISCELLANEOUS .L.-� ''�-- -I- I� - __ _ �VSingle Owlp. !•� -`---- -- _ - SIZE .. C-None Gable ,INT. (Plaster` �� --- - HEIGHT ..____Double Dwig. Part Decorated Sprink. (Fire) I ___ ---'-- Hlp y, Pine Fire Escapes "�-- - _._..�I�: L-I - --- ,al' I. I I-----'J!j` / 2- X 3 / Z Duplex Dwig. _.._._.Full ,/flat • Hardwaad -.- _ . ^a I T- �^ '- ---_ ir t� 7. 7 Refrigerators_._..Apartment - Dirt Floor Mansard Metal ---_ I ___- Metale&Tile Vac.C.Sys. ----------- Store _ -- - -' ---- r ____ Cement Floor Panels -'------ ( � I I /i' PORCHESSkylights -----' X -__._Store&Oiflce Finish ✓ - �fI ��----�I S'> FLOORS __..Fireplaces �y' - ___Store&Apt. ''p X /d Front ___ S 6, r HEATING X Side "' Wood Joists Incinerators - 1 `�....___Of flee ---_ _.__..Hotel • '- one ��,X Q Mill Solar W.Sys. �- - - �I • 1 \ )�>T77.`r, c Rear Steel Beams , �- ' I II-I r _---• X• Air Con.Sys. ---- -- Theatre Stoves X sleep. P,einf.Concrete -- J----_ Garage(Apt.) Oil Burner ----___Rein(.Tile ---- _I__ _ __ ---- k---�- 7- _..Garage(Serv.) FIT'laca _, EXT. WALLS Dirt FACTORS 'h -a LL CONDiTIO� Garage(Prot.) Wood Sid;ng -I. - --= -- GOOD -FLOORING I,.-No,of Rooms / - �--`- __ pas Station CONSTRUCTION Brick �A"cine • -�- -/ � '--Church Apartments - s�'Wood Frame Hardwood School - Brick Cased Concrete Rooms&Apt. - Lumber Sheds Steel Frame •1.:1-:::Stucco ltrR;_.s Tile t- '-- L-------- -- Bahl.Concrete Concrete ........Metal - Marble Fin.Attic R. _-�_'L�-� I _ I ROOFING __Brick ...... Bieck Tcrrble Fin.Base.R. -�p-pfir "'� �,• -----I$ I I _---- Shingle Linoleum Date Cempit. v t F I �� __-__.Shingle Concrete Tile I ---- SO.F1'. V.P. Ago - 1 I Q. w �y ter..:_ L.1. `_!: ;Itch&Gravel EXT:•TRIM PLUMBING -_ I- IC_ _ __Metal FOUNDATIONS ::/ None5 5 Remodeled _� I �� - -.a`e-# I I I ---- " jy--' Plain - _J 3 -- I I i j / 0 l Composition $tone i J.._f lxttires K ---- ---- -- r' - li r'; �:l�Ctone a '••-•-Ornamental _J....._Toilets LIGHTING ---- -- I f 1` Slate Wood B - D--- __ ` -----._/.-_. athroom:�' /'v ---/ -- - -LEI' VALUATION ---..Electric ---f-Tile-Flat or Brick Stucco The floor ------4- ---- Tile ' • --..Terra Gotta 1_..Bwike;-Bdtt-In . Gas .------ --I CAPlTULAT Ornamental _ ---- Piers Metal Showers,,'-/•- / Lamps _--- - $ _I I_1_I LAND APPRAISAL — _� — --------1-LCLi__ _ I� I I I I I I _ Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front I I I s %-1 I I I 'I I 1 �� --- ADDITIONAL Price Factor Factor BUILDINGS Foot Yaiue Valuation le LOTS ACREAGE ST..IIgdPROVEMENTS /�-'v X /PL� v r .__level Level e'Paved X //High Hilly Dirt TOTAL Lew Rocky ._-.Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ Enhancing Factor p/ Rocky Swampy C rb Detracting Factor /n ACRES Swampy Farm. ..Water TOTAL Wooded ,;ewer I LAND I'//t v I . II 'Exempt i� DE:MC.• /' `� • 1942 1943 1944 1945- *Mit!7 1947-� d • /c��.e_ LAND t ;:C. • )WNER 2, S.4- %t. w . ,A4). Z BLDGS. r'I(; • (-- .�7y `�o� 3 9� r" o ts'i \DDRESS r . 6 G sue.f. A I L TOTAL — —_ DESCRIPTION jOF BUILDING I BUILDING PLAN i‘ BUILDING DIMENSIONS TYPEBI.U(1. ItAHE)tKNT ROOFINT. !'INthll \IIYI', f RILE HEIGHT NO. 1'lualrr STORIES ....Mingle Da lc. Vtianr ....Gable Decorated ....P.D. :Ito. Fri. n� ....Double Dols. ....Part ....IIIP , t .t'1ne ••••HPrluk It'Irr) I /i X . ....I/uplrt Dols. ....Full .✓..Flat ....11w!'woud ....Pao. Eli,. ....Bungalow, ....Vial Floor ....Mansard 11r1.1 Frt. Elev. C !...Cottage ....ermrnt Floor Marble CTar .•.•Ruud Eli . ....Aparlmrnt ....Finial! I'anrl■ ...Fire t:arapra PORCHES •••• ....Kefrlgerulur. / ....Nlure ' , ,.Hloreallftlre II PATIN° X urront. FLOORS •••\•ar. ('. h)., - I.' II ..Wood Julal. .•HkI light. X ...Nigro Di ii AV1. /,, ' Flrmmlarr• .,.:llfflre NW' ,,,,1111i • „, ,,ems A ' . „mt..I min.,. ..Inrinrralur. • hank !Oda. ,•lint Air . Ilrar I. X ....Hotel ....RAW. (oars —Mu'. 11', h)r. ' ...Strout Rein). The Air Con. h).. I • ..Theatre ...Hat Walrr HIerP- . „Dirt - '! '' X ....!'wrier, ,.Vapor ,..0 (Aul.) „1111 Ilurner LO1►KlN(I FAt'Tlllth 41 (Nrrr) EXT. NALI•o Y.line .I.No. of ROOM. I X ...liar. (I'rrt.)• ((INSTRUCT. •••Wood Siding .,Ilanlwood •••Aparinvnl. r I ' ' „D.. Hi atl.n . ...lirirk ...Ileum• v Apt. ;,j ..tined Fronts .•,Cemrnl - ,,./•hunk ...Mirk lrk tu.rd . —Figs. Mlle If. Sl X •,Hier! tYwnv r 1 . Tile •,- -,��,-,-•�_,—�-� F. ...nrheol �.lur•.Wl.l.l . ,\tarlll. ...Irin. Hour. K. •9"• ...Ilrinf. Conc. . ...Kern.. Illd[. ..Mrlal ..Dalr Cumuli. r► ,MIII ..Trrrw.r. X ...Iumb, NMdr •••Sl.n. •..Age �- .. Ilrlrk ,,,I.Ipolrum \, _Shingle ...Krmoirlyd .Tllr •KO11F1%(I 1'I.l'MIi1N11 X • hhinale FOUNDATIONS JEXT. TRIM .. one 1.11II1TIND .�- ..�Pltch A(last. //Ntune ....Plain .F'IRlurr. �.KleTlrlr ' N .....4r1.1 .v.(•unrrrlr ...OrnamenI.l .1.Tullrl. liver .,,,1'..Iw.lILn ....Drink ...V.wed ...il.lhru.ml ...1wmP. r - t • - - • - X ...h1.1. ...Tile ....Slone ...Tile now i - - - • • . ....Tile-tint Of ...1'Irr. ...Tura t•olla 1.11atk.. twill • CU. FT. UNIT NY.%) <'OSI)ifi(IN (7 CONTENT PRICE VALUE --- --- Or.amealwi ....Poole ....)Metal I -M w'. 1 r♦ GOOD FAtK RAD CUVn. VALUATION itfee /94 3 N 57 6 J_) RECAPITULATION REMA i;ArlitlY t►KiuiNi► r I a r r.e '. Co MAIN BLDG. /. O UTILITY i,xnCRN('R $ o-f ,f�l.b•y' t a�c�1 ![ GARAGE ...SJ • • 7Vi 7 6 i SHED LAND APPRAISAL Treat and Depth Unit Depth Corner Float ADDITIONAL \'aluallo■ • Prire Farl.r Parlor F..t Palle BUILDINGS • N LOTS ACRKAIIK T. IMPROVEMENTS X ...I.etel ...T.r%el ..Patti I...Illsk ...Holy ...Din --- TOTAL IR Sdealk \ Iw ... ...ky BUILDINGS $ ...Rocky ...Ha amp,. ...Curb '--- -..----- ---- ..Swampy ...Farm ...Naha Yakanring Farl.r r;I ACRES @ I TOTAL ..•\t•e..1.4 ...Mlwrr IMlrarlln. Farl.r -- LAND ...KI ern light TOTAL LAND .'....•• I •lLI• V\I 1'►TIII% •win Gl ring a Page 1 TORICAL STRUCTURE F —14 site#8 ❑ Original t FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Field Date 5_/ /_07_ j Version 4.0 1/07 Form Date_11/ /07_ E Update `('il"ill i ■ Recorder# Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none)60 Palm Square Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name: Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) 0 building 0 structure 0 district 0 site 0 object Ownership: ❑private-profit ❑private-nonprofit f]private-individual ❑private-nonspecific ❑city ❑county ❑state ❑federal ❑Native American ❑foreign ❑unknown Address(include N,S,E,W;#;St.,Ave.,etc.) 60 Palm Square, Delray Beach,Florida 33483 Cross Streets(nearest/between) East Atlantic Avenue and Southeast 1st Street USGS 7.5'Map Name&Date Delray Beach Topographic 1:24,000 1962, 1983 Plat or Other Map City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In City Limits? Eyes Ono ❑unknown County Palm Beach Township 46_ Range_43_ Section_16 '/4 section: ❑NW ❑SW ❑SE ONE ❑Irregular-name: Tax Parcel #12-43-46-16-34-000-0300 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block Lot UTM: Zone 016 017 Easting 0 Northing_ 0 Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Construction Year: 1928 ❑approximately ❑year listed or earlier ❑year listed or later Original Use* Residence From(year): 1928_To(year): Present Current Use* Residence From(year): 1928_ To(year): Present Other Use* From(year): To(year): Moves: Oyes Ono ❑unknown Dates Original address(if moved) Alterations: oyes Ono ❑unknown Dates 1959 Nature* Repair Cottage Additions: Oyes Ono ❑unknown Dates Nature* Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.)Retakolean(artist)(Current David Clitter) Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Oyes Ono ❑unknown Describe nfu �,o._.w._ ,-s....�.3- ,r.,ru.n_1,,.. a.... .tom;_ .": . tryP4 4.r-�, ,. - .. ° a�,-. �� z ,3'� Style* Mediterranean Revival Exterior Plan* Rectangular Number of Stories 1 Exterior Fabric(s)*Stucco Roof Type(s)* Flat Roof Materials)* Tar and Gravel Roof secondary strucs.(dormers etc.)* Windows(types,materials,etc.)* Original porch enclosed with windows on front,metal,arched—approved by Historic Preservation Board—some original remain on house. Distinguishing Architectural Features(exterior or interior ornaments) Ornamental trim—original includes tiles from Mizner Industries. Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) Wood framed 1 story 200 square foot rear shed constructed in 1928. Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO—Appears to meet criteria for NR listing: Oyes Ono ❑insufficient info Date_/ / Init. // KEEPER—Determined eligible: Oyes Ono - Date_/_/ ❑Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: ❑a ❑b ❑c ❑d (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File/Division of Historical Resources/R.A.Gray Building/500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399-0250 Phone(850)245.6440/Fax(850)245.6439/E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us • Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM . Site#8 Chimney:No. Material(s)* Structural System(s)* Wood Foundation: Type(s)*Concrete Material(s)* Main Entrance(stylistic details)Original door and hardware(pecky cypress) Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof types,etc.)decorative tile Condition(overall resource condition): Dexcellent ❑good :Hair Odeteriorated ❑ruinous Narrative Description of Resource Contributing Mediterranean Revival style single family residence and accessory structure,distinctive type of construction to this period. / Archaeological Remains 0 Check if Archaeological Form Completed Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). D FMSF record search(sites/surveys) D library research D building permits D Sanborn maps ❑ FL State Archives/photo collection D city directory D occupant/owner interview D plat maps D property appraiser/tax records D newspaper files D neighbor interview 0 Public Lands Survey(DEP) ❑cultural resource survey D historic photos 0 interior inspection ❑HABS/HAER record search ❑other methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) k FfE b, 4G Q 3 Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? Oyes Ono ❑insufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district? Oyes Ono ❑insufficient information Explanation of Evaluation(required,whether significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) This Mediterranean Revival house with details from Mizner Industries may be the sole example of this remaining in the Marina District. Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic heritage","community planning&development",etc.) Community Planning and Development Y.LH•t,•BLyi L� .f tiSR'. 'V.w'a :.YS`.. l -1 h1 �..lit IA k C. \I , Y� h�a l Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field&analysis notes,photos,plans,other important documents that are permanently accessible: For each separately maintained collection,describe(1)document types),*(2)maintaining organization,*(3)file or accession nos.,and(4)descriptive information. Recorder Name Carolyn Patton and Claudia Willis Recorder Contact Information(address/phone/fax/e-mail)(561)274-9823 Post Office Box 250 Delray Beach,Florida 33483 Recorder Affiliation Delray Beach Preservation Trust Use a Supplement for Site Forms or other continuation sheet for descriptions that do not fit in the spaces provided. 0 USGS 7.5'MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required © LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP(available from most property appraiser web sites) Attachments 0 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format(plan paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. • ♦' : ��.; , j z f :I � ,! ! !j!i!11$I IIii!Il! ' . ............ -• /, lrrrrrf a y I 4 T 4 • s F . S e4Uft 'Lt µ''ttic 0rw ' k r.'t t _-{ " 4+'r * S`c � 4 F t •4r hfi %r: , `kl'y42, z,'!... . .4.'t l . { te« !t' �a 7 y w :. I .., • - .. ._ ,,,„i„ • mow, f�CC +rs !'r ,,tea. . f ��„«.�.. � ' cRTg �,�v Art - . 1 S3-.' - .. . • ,1 y Fri,. 1_Y fs'.i%..+x',�`F'h; w.A • t J. . /-• ,---.� I Ir • j ` n +p/•,5 T7, 7'4 wl CSC; 1 60 Palm Square { Delray Beach 1 \ ,41 ARCHITECT Unknown 872= = BUILDER Unknown 874= = STYLE AND/OR PERIOD Nediterranean Revival 964= = PLAN TYPE Rectangular 966= = EXTERIOR FABRIC(S) Stucco _ 854= = STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S) yo�rl 856= = PORCHES 942= = FOUNDATION: Concrete 942= = ROOF TYPE: Flat 942= = SECONDARY ROOF STRU C__TUR E(S): 942= = CHIMNEY LOCATION: 942= = WINDOW TYPE: 942= = CHIMNEY: . 882= = ROOF SURFACING: Pitch & gravel 882= = ORNAMENT EXTERIOR: Ornamental trim 882= = NO.OFCHIMNEYS 952= = NO. OF STORIES 1 950= = NO.OF DORMERS 0 954= _ Map Reference (incl. scale & date)— Delray Beach Topographic 1 :24,000 • 1962, 1983 809= = Latitude and Longitude: 0 800= = Site Size(Approx. Acreage of Property): LT 1 833= _ LOCATION SKETCH OR MAP N Township RangeSection south east _ - T 46 43 812= = UTM Coordinates: 890= = Zone Easting Northing N � if) -N 5 C— r- U2 60t SE 1st St. Photographic Records Numbers _ 860= = Contact Print • .' • w / . I STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Division of Archives,History and Records Management Site Inventory Form FDAHRM 802= = DS•HSP•3AAA Rev.3.79 1009= = Site No. Site Name 830= = Survey Date o6pi 820= = Address of Site: 60 Palm Snilare, -Del ray -Reanh 33i1/1i 905= = Instruction for locating 813= = Location: calm Square --- 50_� 868= = subdivision name block no. logo. County: PALM BEACH 808= = Owner of Site: Name: Fred J. Brotherton, Inc. , Address: 185 Atlantic Street, Hackensack, N.J. 07601 902= = • Type of Ownership Onrnnrata 848= = Recording Date 832= = Recorder: Name & Title: Smith, Sanford I. ; Address: HPBCPB 818= = Condition of Site: Integrity of Site: Original Use Residence 838= = Check One Check One or More Present Use Residence 850= = flt Excellent 863= = rkAltered 858= = Dates: Beginning 1928 844= = ❑ Good 863== ❑ Unaltered 858= = Culture/Phase 840= = . El Fair 863= = a Original Site 858== Period 845= = ❑ Deteriorated 863= = El Restored( )(Date: )( )858= = El Moved( )(Date: )( )858== . NR Classification Category: Building 916= = Threats to Site: Check One or More El Zoning( )( )( )878== ❑ Transportation( )( )( )878== 0_ Development( )( )( )878== El Fill( )( )( )878= = ❑ Deterioration( )( )( )878== ❑ Dredge( )( )( )878== _ El Borrowing( )( )( )878== ❑ Other(See Remarks Below): 878== Areas of Significance: Architecture _ 910= = Significance: ' • 911 = = IP do Page 1 ,' \\ HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 �: , FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Field Date, I is I o2DO.7 0 Original i _.�-- 4� Form Date_/ // 12,0b 7 Update , Version 4.0 1/07 Recorder# \` Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. \__-__ Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instruc- s. Site Narne(s)(address if none) I)y 0 f evt- Cat L Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name / Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) X1 building 0 structure 0 district 0 site 0 object Ownership: Oprivate-profit ❑private-nonprofit private-individual ❑private-nonspecific ❑city ❑county ❑state Ofederal [Motive American ❑foreign ❑unknown ;:LOCATION.:81:MAPPIN AddresS-_(inaude N SE w# St Ave etc.) �0 P-M._ V Z).j r L 3 -cti-eA Cross Streets(nearest/be►ween) Girt'( -tic_ i�lvkc $ irf�2,5`q 8 S l iee-ET- USGS 7.5'Map Name&Pate Dt � [ iL I:`1A j 000 Plat of Otfter Map City i Town(within 3 miles) . / In City Limits?*es Ono ❑unknown County j3� V3 Co . Township �b Range ✓ Section 1 co '/.section: ONW ❑SW ❑SE ONE ❑Irregular-name: TaxParcel# 11.—'4' - 4 V —(�- 3L4--BOO -0 30 0 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block Lot UTM: Zone 016 '17 Easting 0 Northing 0 Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) TIISTORY . - - Construction Year Oapproximately ❑year_listed or earlier ❑year listed or later Original Use* Vj�e t,.¢.cJ From(year): i1 q To(year): �cXI —Current Use* `G{ t-/ From(year): 191,43 To(year): c..A rbt--C— Other Use* From(year): To(year): Moves: Oyes goo ❑unknown Dates Original address(if moved) Alterations yes ono ❑unknown Dates 1 QSt' Nature* >t-# ` y . t . Additio n`s= Dyes Ono ❑unknown Dates t`lature* - ,---" , Architect(last name first): $wild r last name frst): wnership History(especially original owner,dates,profession, the Resource Affectedby.`aLocal Preservation Ordinance? Oyes Ono Clanknown Describe DESCRIPTION style .e(r.�f� �% Vet,{ Eicfenor Piano t2 r C,f �c�f'ti Number of Stones Exterior Fabrics) S ( c e..z O_ Roof Types)* ?-I.ce t' Roof Matenal�s)•_T Cc[_1-'L-. Roof secondary struts.(dormersetc.)• ��,�. �+,/.{�dL� _ ( � Windows(types,materials,etc.)• s 1`s-m-tMTs C�n.n d. — d�_ (Q,4-1 t,--r'C'' S&L'-e Qc) fr --Q ►e.eawAr.44k Urt^-- frunri.t..— Plating shing Architectural Feattl (exterior oil-interior ornaments) O(4&vt" 4 ccL +V e on - nor i iny....t v1C_.A. . Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) tAJOOA_ 2e90 456 tir mar=S t-A— c1d1 .5'rcv .e.1_ t,17 *Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO-Appears to meet criteria for NR listing:Oyes Ono ❑insufficient info Date'_/_/ Init. 1_I KEEPER-Determined eligible: Dyes Ono Date_l_1 ❑Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: Da Ob Oc Od (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources 1 R.A.Gray Building 1500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399.0250 Phone(850)245.6440 I Fax(850)245-6439 I E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 • DESCRIPTION (continued) - .. - Chimney:No._ Material(s)• :. - k..- ; StructuralSystem(s)• t)©od ''1' z, ( `'. L Foundation: Type(s)* CLT ..G nr Material(s)• �' Main Entrance(stylistic details) Of;56 vVc�( � 0J— (P c/c( j vy C a 11 Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof typ etc.) dec.e' L_oc-i i.. _ '}"T'14'-e .4- .•t.,' 1, Condition(overall resource condition): Aexcellent ['good Ofair ❑de eriorated ❑ruinou ' Narrative Description of Resource CAN--4,/fl .-4t 4,/ I"�v.p-a.- tVoa 5 0, _s, .p 414 �"reC , - M' fl4 t 5:ems �- — 1 d.i 544 Ntc he - _. -. ' Archaeo ogical Remains --. _ _ 0 Check if Archaeological Form Completed *Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions(coded fields at the Site File). N RESEARCH ME 'HODS;'{ctieck all ilia a. ily) _' ❑FMSF record search(sites/surveys) ❑library research 0 building permits 0 Sanbom maps Cl FL State Archives/photo collection 0 directory 0 occupant/owner interview 0 plat maps ❑property appraiser/tax records 0 newspaper files 0 neighbor interview 0 Public Lands Survey(DEP) ❑cultural resource survey 0 historic photos 0 interior inspection ❑HABS/HAER record search ❑other methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) '- - OPINION OFRESOURCESIGNIFICOICE _- . • Appearstto meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? yes Ono ❑insufficient information ;Appears to meet the criteria(of National Reeisterlisting as_part of a district?; es Ono ❑insufficient information Explanation of Evaluation(required,whether significant or not-,use separate sheet if needed . r ! / 1V{ff`� 'I..�.� ''� .-1_,__t rf t ,..4. d ..$.F.4 1 A -�.. off'! 1'c'-,+C•-�(--r,i Q(: % 0,1•i 7i �'.k-C_,-' 1 i. >,u,i i; t./� ......i 1`/a I /lv ir•vj Il-:U,`?/✓l l%-`�,1 Cl-Lk fi �'C Lrr..i ?'1'_t G)0 'J_ 'L ... r � :1� �� 4 n i� .- C - v.,,�i i.' '! v •�lii i t i 1 ri `LJ > �L' �� to (- t z c <_cL r� - ; c y— Area(s)of Historical Significance(se ,N tional Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:eearchitecture",'ethnic heritage',"community planning&development',etc.) • .DOCUMENTATION' _, Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field&analysis notes,photos,plans,other important documents that are permanently accessible: For each separately maintained collection,describe(1)document type(s),'(2)maintaining organization'(3)file or accession nos.,and(4)descriptive information. Recorder Name &1.4 L t k�S R .) Recorder Contact Information;(address l phone l fax l e-mail) a 7EF—qg Recorder Affiliation 343?1•a._S,.0f81.. _— ?cu f— Use a Supplement for Site Forms or other continuation sheet for descriptions that do not fit in the spaces provided. 0 USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required © LARGE SCALE STREET,PLAT OR PARCEL MAP (available from most property appraiser web sires) Attachments 0 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format:(pian paper isacceptabie) Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. i V DEPAARTMENTORSTATE FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE • Division of Archives,History and Records Management Site Inventory Form FDAHRM 802== = DS-HSP-3AAA Rev.3.79 1009= = Site No. • Site Name 830= = Survey Date R6n4 820= = Address of Site: 6o Palm Sn»arP, 11P1ray 13P.2ph 331A/ 905= = Instruction for locating 813= = Location: Palm Square • --- _ 868= = subdivision name block no. 3°Ioo. County: PALM BEACH 808= = Owner of Site: Name: Fred J. Brotherton, Inc. , ; Address: 185 Atlantic Street, Hackensack, N.J. 07601 902= = Type of Ownership enrrnrate 848= = Recording Date 832= = Recorder: Name & Title: Smith, Sanford I. • Address: HPBCPB 818= = Condition of Site: Integrity of Site: Original Use Residence 838= = Check One Check One or More Present Use Residence 850= = elt Excellent 863=_ Altered 858== Dates: Beginning 1928 844= = ❑ Good 863== ❑ Unaltered 858= = .Culture/Phase 840= = . ❑ Fair 863== itOriginal Site 858== Period 845= = -. ❑ Deteriorated 863= = ❑ Restored( )(Date: )( )858= = ❑ Moved( )(Date: )( )858== NR Classification Category: Building 916= = Threats to Site: • Check One or More lie Zoning( )( )( )878== ❑Transportation( )( )( )878=_ ail Development( )( )( )878== ❑ FIII( )( )( )878== O Deterioration( )( )( )878== 0 Dredge( )( )( )878== O Borrowing( )( )( )878== O Other(See Remarks Below): 878== • Areas of Significance: Architecture 910= = Significance: . • 911 = = 4110 ARCHITECT Unknown 872= = BUILDER Unknown 874= _ STYLE AND/OR PERIOD Mediterranean Revival 964= = • PLAN TYPE Rectangular 966= = EXTERIOR FABRIC(S) ' Stucco 854= STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S) __ Wood 856= _ PORCHES 942= = FOUNDATION: Concrete . 942= ROOF TYPE: Flat 942 SECONDARY ROOF STRUCTURE(S): 942= = CHIMNEY LOCATION: 942= WINDOW TYPE: 942= = CHIMNEY: 882= _ ROOF SURFACING: • Pitch & gravel 882= = ORNAMENT EXTERIOR: Ornamental trim 882_ = NO. OFCHIMNEYS 1 952= = NO. OF STORIES 1 950= = NO. OF DORMERS 6 954= _ Map Reference(incl. scale & date) Delray Beach Topographic 1:24,000 1962, 1983 809= = Latitude and Longitude: o • 800= = Site Size(Approx. Acreage of Property): LT 1 833= = LOCATION SKETCH OR MAP N Township Range Section south east t_., UT- 46 43 16 812= _ UTM Coordinates: 890= = Ql Zone Easting Northing e) `� N- Wcd 6o fi-j -SE 1st St. Photographic Records Numbers 860= = Contact Print . , ••1 ...„.......".-- - . • - %vs.- - ----71-a. j ,--'",-,----- I ,..• '" '..„..' ,•--, __:,..;..._ .. , - - ... • _ .. .,, z._ ...„.... _ , '',. i _,,,_ r r ,_, , _ __.:_,„ _,.: _ :,, - . 1.; i IL t. '',...,.., 1"": ' 1 , • ,4 --, . 1 1 N 4 I ! ,1 Ito , F 11: i ' I illi I I) ,,:. .„..,-.:i...;;;,‘-j- ,..4:,--,,-4- f , ..- 1 1 I li . l' I I V' ---_.4...„ i I i .f.1 , I -•t• ' --.t - ,- *•-•V`‘'.• 1!.171 I 1i ._. ...... 1 1 I I I t It I 1I 1 I I . ..... . .I . •1. I•• -.... ZA 1- .,•- t I, .--• • • • , . • 4- - I Q •••• . • . . . • ' • ... • . . / ' • 1 .....,V • , . . • . •• . . • . ' • . . ...........••••••••••••..... . • . . . . . . . , ... • , . .. . . , , . . . ...,-.;-.-;:•.• ••• •--.•lz.-..,• .•.., .. -.. • - ...--.;••,i%.1•-;','.- . " ...,.. . -. • .•• ...:. ..• •• .• • :' ' . '. .,...',„:7a,*. - .... --.....,;...Z.''' • 4ii.t;,....'''':-•-•:.. r . ' t•-.,.c...2.e. 7.-",,,',.:.,"" l'.''..;;;;'..,•1 • tt,i4air.,.=:14. ••=.444.1114, '512". . . .".. .,.-7');. ","::::-.s.;:s.,;:.'-'."--"A‘4. j4:,•'=,W•11,7 "...r- V-.= . rg---)0,-.441- • ,.......7....N,.,..,.. 7,*.t. ___,,,.--•.-r......—it...7,7. ...711.• ir.,r4'•:4...!''....,,i;efillai,.n...4.4!.....7N. .„ ... • . - -— - . ------—--- - . • • ..•• a . .-• -L._...-,.... 1811111104r':!.,'-•••"!'..'.• .mimemia*--- . .„,., ... . i%- ...'' ...r--.''''ir''' '''s..''''4U": •... ..,,,,y:t,.--....iglir•--w•i4'. •'• --..''',-';.i.t,r.k..,t-"P"I' • ......:,. '.... ... .'---c•.-:-.••‘`ii-f....--if.,..€•;tkirk;,-4?.•:;(e0,0.;.. ,,..,-;e .4-...,... ..,••*.'. .:-...,;r.-•.:,..:( ,:o2.5,..-z!•••";----4 -- ,........_,,,,,----wr• -."-- ' .. ----i ' ':'''..'zi41-01V4.'. :'''''.' -'...i**-- • ..,-.3.. - " - - . - - l• . . • . . . . . . .. . . . . . • . . - ' • • - . --..---...>•••..-.;•zr•-.2,. .•••,i',.. .1-.:"..*,•z3.;•-!:-;:.-..-..-...-.,...z..•-;-•„..„,."---•--- . . f . .'-''''...'',.:.5.-,;14::'''..t...`;A:-;'ff:-%4 ,i.itiVai'...'''..t.`;'''':•--!:.''il,O'r . ‘.,-4.:1`1!..‘-'k•'0...--PY•lr.bffifl.i'934r;.?'•,:ie..;4''''''P*--•;- . . ....,4'. 4 -... -gt.•-t'-11'., '•"" 41!;,;-41%.` '' '4k,f•'....'•'*rt...0, '.1ZT...' ....t.k.' 'N '''' .. • , . . -1/4-'.11,•,• - ".....t:f.IWINT‹.'.. •' ,.•,...ii.:Phk:.'',V...•...cfr.;'.1-`i c!'.'"!v.!'..-...,:,,',.-44. - . IN•M•16 .. . . - .• ••••• ••.• .• I . 6. • t.1 I M • . ••416**.•''' i . . .; . / e...--. ---\ ' i" i • 1. " :.,. .: .?...,i;1, ., .--. w . • .) .„), ) k- •.1. , ii RI ....... . . 4: .• • , ... .• ). i. . . - . • ' ,. , . ... • . - . _„.. . . ' . .• .. ....„7...s. ... .. .., _ - Ili. • ..• • lb . ..- ' • - -.,..,..o.i•t&aft,01,e........-0340•-•..m..,11,-....-...nosso-••••4:7-iii`7-----;r,..,-•,'-'!...,,,.,,,',lc:• - • •-••,•••••*••••••;rwel -:'',.`4,m,....A.45,••••••• ...-.-,;,,,..••••• .'•'.,.•- , . . '•-•" ' .. . . . . 1 60 Palm Square Delray Beach - . . • . • -- — - A TL-ANT/C AVE.-- ;.;„•; — T -- g �) ^ ; ir . /I12 3 4 7 8 l'` V L O C A T/O r/ As4A P ••,'V• fy '. ' 1. I V (J l O(_ h /?J� '' �•'•l �( �[( I` ;� c' SGALI.- /•'LV� : I% J , .r . • I. _ I 1e 1 . V ( - -•117-LANTIC Airf r r N. ILI- •; v Ir • - �! [ • _ N ccil h -O• : `iir:• 2 �� Z, 11 C! :•�1' f am° I C.R/G/NAL R.G//T -- vs/AY . �, SS < r.., i - -_ I 1� _ I ";i 1 16 OV n� JCL .a .�..�r-•r.r 1 It' r • .;'1•" f (•--3? 'lb 1 - • .. r .SE / :r v—c7 Pi%E.iLA'T �.6.YT•C`1%:4Y-� ; 14: '4 o•S f.ti'!R^%;CHM(.vr ;• . } `-� . .... _iay�(..e_ .! PVC .frx• . • 2 • r1-1 9 24, 1' .00 t. L• }} } • O V / lIORY /. r � . � . r _-. . .. . • ill j C1 ,, FR 'SJ((((O;� l o ]�:.(s..c n••U% boo' - •. !i.?.: ft. O V o Z . :1...rl• r 1. !Q•` I . iir 1�i•i • I :i - • ' .--:#.4 .J 1 LTJ:da..11 0 z tj-) IQ . :70'...': i I • . Ft . ‘‘ `'. 13 a. i - 0 ki : 2; —ry. 1.0 ,c - -—o•7' 'C) 4 s',I .(I' •1.:1/"-,'•• ( I 1 ra-c.(1r 14 L s'ra(. w.ta `t i.ti "} }. .--- . - - • . • _ • o o qq iI• n W � ��Ji�� . . , . . J `V 2 3• 1• C • '.f l.Y~r . i . 1 if ▪ u. ? :I ( ``•';t1 '. • • pREpARr !nk • Art A/.rr/c T c H ir £ Co. , 1V£.ST PAl .81-AC//,FLop/wA . • SUA'VEY Of. So orii /DO' OF IVoRPI 563 6 0' '. . •. • • OF EAST /DO.' of l'J'EST ZOO-r OFBL UC(('/Z.S" `t I `:(••": DEL RA Y BEA Cl� 1�F-� >%, L i;v ro,v, FLORIDA ` - • i • e" .r.FO�- LEWIS E �'A/, ATTORNEY ... r , o..rs APR/L 2 /9S9 1 •c..c /..' 30' I •Lar •CCc • C. / I•.oc NO. 3 - ' E. ELLIOTT GROSS & ASSOCIATES � ENGINEERS & SURVEYCRS U�'.� , I HEREBY CERTIFY that the plat aho-n hereon Is a trv• and c o•r.ct c•D,•s•nlatlon of• P sl• ad Surveyor survey made under my dlr•ctlan, and that said surest'Is s::oral.to ll.•best of my kno.lad[• Florida Cerllllosl• Ks.ro ky and bellef, and there ar• no •nerosehn•nt•, e•c•pt it (toted- / ono.° 4F •.'.s / ..o.•599•2I2 D w • • J.`7 •.-I�•r• •,•-r.• •�?• `o�Sj 's; _r;•v,,..1. ,.6 y: . At".11,:f.te:11;-Pet.:1Z•. - 4.I . , 4 ��_ I ..-1 te ' �� it �'t.. ♦` { . . • 1 - - _ _ •9.• .•tea _.•�: _ ... ..... - • ...,r,e,;.--•- . " . " tc'• • • • t ,<.t 4 .r 7 -t J• �1 ,:S..~ •S. �.Zi*7•i3�L• 'Ya i •• 2J. S ?- ` •, t• .,. ...-:w & $ 1." ••Lys 3 . -'. • 1f.:1,Sr.:- �•r,• •~ ';w.-,C'.,t • '� C••I. _•• •:�^• •� ,f�*'` Y` :. t . � • • •' i7` .• 4• . _. . a',. :i"�... . A y. •tT.i t•'• t e �. . rw . �.t l .ter . j � ` "- ♦ ,c t~ �.tT 4 .• . • T•A.. 'E�t eilt`it s` 4•` .. tr ��lT 4 w .": `'�` r. y y".".�4t'r:t :• �.��+t6t:�f Lam► '' �'�`�r :�e;,�.iLt•�3iR�c:�e+7. ::.+^� .a'lGsivc{9r+.Ea.'a—•�*.i;'r.yi�ra .A..►� ';0 t••, t -. C,.,,_, ,•,t I,,, 1 ,.•, •. t,•-.1 ••1, . : • Xit),Q, ,, $ 1 q2s STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE • r OIrlotrinofArrru.•%.lu1ln,r Site Inventory Form rimirBM 802= = end ii•Crirrre Miluitj•manl 1009 DS-it$PJAAA rifle J 79 . Site No. Site Name - 830= = Survey Date : I.r14 820= = Address of Site: �^ • - , r , 905= = Instruction for locating 813= = 1 /.1m. ,T:nr•e. --- :r• : : 868= _ Location: l rr subdl li iv,s,on Croak no lot no 808= = Owner of Site: Name: %-.....‘,4' '^`"r"' -�, '^.- . • DaVid.C4t lie tr , Address: 1 i ..,t_ ^a..- .i _:.,..• , . ' _. 0 7(411 = 902= Type of Ownership r'n••---••- 848= = Recording Date 832= = Recorder:Name & Title: • •rli 1 ••I -•`^ - • -- ' Address: !'•` '1':I =' 818= = Condition of Site: Integrity of Site: Original Use ___, • _'• 838= = Check One Check One or Mo'e I • ;• r 1: • 85Q= = Present Use ____ _ St Excellent 863= = a minted - e"s= = Dates: Beginning 1- 844 = I•-I Good erla= = f I LJn,ltorriI E`A_ = Culture/Phase _ _ 840_ 11 Fair __ 86J=__ S.Original Site ---- -•--E`JS= Period 845= = _ — n Deteriorated 863= = F] Reslored( Mate It )Eta= = NR Classification Category: Threats to Site: - q Check One or More • �u Zoning( H — -- — x Ie11l= = P liars:co,lion( X - — - �)878= MI fife Oevelop_monl( M x lete =- l I. Frill x _--- xE7 18a O Deterioration( )( — - x )B7°= = 1-] Dred;el X -.— x 1878= • Borrowing( x._— —x )e78 . [1 Other(See Remarks Belo - ,--— _-----_87e= = Areas of Significance: - - .: Significance: rzt--9-acApA 911 = = • ARCI-ti rrc r thot tuwn .. 872 = BUILDER . _ _...- Urtl:uowti_ 874 = __ • STYLE AND/OR PERIOD — :'e/2 i `er 1 " :' -' '1 - - ---- 964 = = PLAN TYPE 7:-:c."'+n";"=1'� 966= = EXTERIOR FABRIC(S) -4.,._ ? - 854 = = STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S) _- _ . _._ — _Wood 856= = PORCHES --- _ 942= = - FOUNDATION_ _ —Concrete_ --- 942^ ROOF TYPE: - --- - --- ?: -- - - --- ---- 942= SECONDARY ROOF STRUCTURE(S)_ _ _ _ _.. ._ _ 942== CHIMNEY LOCATION: _ _-_-_ ___ 942 = WINDOW TYPE: _._ 942= = CHIMNEY: 882= = ROOF SURFACING: 'tc4 g �@1� -- -- -- -- ----882 = = ORNAMENT EXTERIOR: . - 0.111424Mt 4i 1 -"CAtte{ih !h�• lArtivr-A 15882= = NO._OF_CHIMNEYS _I _ ._._952= = NO.OF STORIES1 950 NO. OF,: DORMERS - 0 - - - - - 954 = = Map '7Aeference(incl. scale & date) __ ._!'`1-.=-=<__ = `'•._r�_^rjhin 1 ::)il Bonn 1 ' 2 1"�3 809== Latitude and Longitude: - _•__ _ __' __ _ 800= = Site Size(Approx. Acreage of Property); ___ _ - _ 1 —._ -_ _ - 833__ Township Range Section LOCATION SKETCH OR MAP N _south ___ __east_ _ ___ _ 4% -r 43 1c UTM Coordinates: 890= _ -.?t TiT•-1i .11T7-D - b 7U' - N +'3 ES [— .--1 rr1 I.. -r r.t 60 if) . ;;! iSt :;t . Photographic Records Numbers --_ -_— _ 860= = Contact Print s lar ©o Q C HOOM f QO(NJ© BETIMES,S9 OTC May 7 , 1992 David Clitter 1102 Harbor Drive • Delray Beach, FL 33483 RE: General Structural Evaluation of Rear Shed in Northwest Corner of Residence at 60 Palm Square in Delray Beach, FL. Dear David: As per your request, a structural inspection of the rear shed in northwest corner of residence at 60 Palm Square in Delray Beach, FL was conducted. The structure consists of wood framed one story structure with a floor area of 200 square feet which was constructed in 1928. The following observations of the structural repairs which will be required to bring this structure to existing code were made during this inspection. They are as follows: 1) The existing roof rafter system must be replaced due to the undersize of the existing members to meet existing building code requirements. 2) The existing flooring rafter system must be removed and replaced with a poured monolithic slab with thicken edges at the structures perimeter. 3 ) Replace damaged structural member on the exterior walls as required. From my observations, it is this engineer's opinion that all of the above listed items are repairable if you are willing • to incur the expense to meet the intention of the existing building code. If you have any questions regarding this letter, please feel free to contact me. Sincere Robert E. Fetrow, . . 200 Knuth Road, Suite 214 • Boynton Beach, Florida 33436 • (407) 736-7047 Fax (407) 736-7099 e .: 27, 2-22-57 ---Frame• urluest,.•Cottage & Wall Along Rear P/T, -, i 3000.E ,I8••x.-_16 .� C.�.���.�� ,�' - C � •;uIARL'ES; DEIBI, *' /� r� DIsrRIcT 25 nth. 'ttsbur h Penn ,,CITY OF,.,DELRAY.;:BEACH -FLORIDA;. re ;.. r . Ave,. , g t tb �eQr3t,;�os��55 C I `%r` SUBDIVISION • • BLOCK LOT a - S •., Improved OWNS k L vy� r_ ' 1� h T' � a • �3�,31l3z! Vacant p ! „rP. a. i R VY' �Yl . N. BZ'3.21�"� .. . . -. • 125 . _ ...- - •. 3) • . , • . . vacant . ADDRESS r 2'1,.•! B.0 �i1 #e i C:Ct;Vo ar ,J� p v DESCRIPTION: #3386-Remodel Interior-$1 Ann_1 /7/55-Ted Roth OWNER '� r�= - Lanais F, 'R. Bellow-�=M`� ^: �S ADDRESS _.. ' S 1001 of N 563,6� of E 1001 r co ��/ V i l} (.-f...t OWNER w .5 v -- (j fir.'f Y o errfeo. ROVAR `. - �c INEZ C. MpONTC OMERY, f74 4 de 7 r'__ ADDRESS • , 60.-Palm.;,4�tr. :.} :'City. YEAR- 1949 1950 1951 •- / i t'.-'k 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 (( EXEMPTION i'-' LAND '-C) O C) VC'pia •Z.SI e J < I 1 4 (, {1 pt 6� J J(/ eL BLOCS. s4f4- C.�, 59 V~(4- _.r j..;•....<.' S_y' 1��{��y (:e..) .=J Ga l 0 // 9/4 // /L.':7, ;,�•,;t'' 'f/ , :1.,ir.. ■�_ [., TOTALS 4 `I,3 i `` > (/ !/ ` '' /� o 2 'U O. t'"'a� i, ?I)/• r<-,7, (.,r) r tit c,J ` /3 'Oro /3 2 J // V t;>-7, r J'. ,,,.,' ,Ill 1 PER. PROP. .149 ' • • s DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING BUILDING PLAN BUILDING DIMENSIONS ■ ■ �TY�PE BLDG. �,BB9EMENT ROOF �T. FINISH MISCELLANEOUS ■ L F 1 r '----- L17-t -- �f rcti?Ey HEIGHT STORIES yl�Single Dwlg. /'[/ ---__Plaster ■ • !..' - / l , �',., ______None Gable Sprink. (Fire) 1 ---- 1 3 2� ____Doable Dwlg. _-___Part __-r Hip -p_Pineratal _.___.Fire Escapes ` _ - �A r -- 7' f ----.�J7 N i� X y f t „•._.� �` .Ta ______Duplex Dwlp. .—_Full �L✓lat .. - Metal Hardwnod ___-_Refrigerators � r - --� - I i :=----- •.� • r, r .' /.' :c. t , fi Apartment —_..Dirt Floor Mansard '--• ------1---=1:--I_�t _ ---- /t.l X ,; ( ' - Marble&The ---Vac.C.Sys. -.._Store ____Cement Floor Panels Skylights • _ ,t_ ---- _-_Store&Office Finish PORDHES - - _ ► fi`` 9 I I �f `t'a I cn 1100 FLOORS __ Fireplaces ■ _ - _-.-•+1 __ I (- --_-- -[�_t.t?�'ti..� ,_ _Store&Apt. �$ X j D Front Wood Joists Incinerators - _ f - ' HEATING - - -- - ------ LI I- -- •-�Office X Side C ° f: /In y'�(j u/� _____ e _Solar W.Sys. - - - .. I I 1 X. ---___Hotel ---_None z-3(ex % Rear -___Steel Beams -- _ ■ u d `---- -_.Reinf.Concrete Air Con.Sys. __Theatre ---.Staves X Sleep. - ■- __ _Reim TIN �'- ��yy ---- ____Garans(Apt.) ---Oil Burner Dirt - IT -- CONDITION Fkcplace EXT. WALLS FACTORS �1 A -j -- ,-a•41- ___.Garape(Sore.) FLOORING __ _ • -{- -FL -- - ��fl GOOD FAIR BAD • Garage(Prot.) ---__Wood Siding �/ -_No.of Rooms ■ I _ __ i• �- CONSTRUCTION _ ••Pine ---_._',Des Station Brick -__.Apartments --- - •:--_ e r _--_----E� _( _ 1 .. __ Church - ---_Hardwood _ _ • = i Wood Frame Brick Cased Roams&Apt. _____School Cmierete P• - - - - -- t ---- - ---- Lumber Sheds __Steel Frame •''1•'--Stucco)rr6-are.._-Tile .-___.Fin.Attic R. I ------- Ir •-- Miill Shingle •--- •______ - �'-- F`------- `��I------ __Reid.Concrete Metal Marble --•,Fin.Base.R. - h v e _ ROOFING ---- Terrazzo Linoleum Date Complt. v .T a i . I•-• 1 ---- SO.FT. V.P. —fAL ;__Shingle .-_. ConcreteT[ie -__.Apo - 'yr l -�=_ I I-1 -- -t- - PLUMBING -- - g - r _ .4d.ar Pitch&Gravel EXT:•TRIM 55.Remodeled ■ I ■*• •- N I 4J-C " t Li I j ---- r 4? U �/ r-. ) _-_Metal FOU.NDATIONS r�r ____ _None - ■■ -- s T-- - I- -_ - ti Plain Fixtiras 1C'• --- I Llit. ---- VALUATION ___-__Composition Stone :'_(Ornamental _I__Toilets LIGHTING - ■� 1a _ LI" k_6 Conerite __Wood Bathroom: //v �a ---�- ---- RECAPITULATION - __Electric• - : L _-_-Slate __Brick •Stucco The Floor ----- ____.Tlle-Flat or Tile- _ Terra Cotta 1. Baths-Bnllt•In - ■ _J..8..__- --- $ lc. o Gas • ii Ornamental Piers Metal ShowersS+.; .•/ Lamps - 71 I I I nI t • -= l IIII I_ I L_ThLIII LL — t• LAND APPRAISAL - I Ill v' -R I I I --- I I - • -I-i] I I ADDITIONAL I I'-I-. I I i - BUILDINGS Front and Depth Unit Depth Corner Front _ 'Price Factor Factor Foot Value Valuation LOTS ACREAGE ST. (IMPROVEMENTS /d'L L) X ZPt..r} 4 er - }evel Level _--.Dared __KWh Hilly TOTAL • X - Low Rocky Sidewalk BUILDINGS $ Enhancing Factor __..-Rocky __:_Swampy Carl) Detracting Factor ': r.%. ACRES Swampy .___-_-Farm "--Water TOTAL ....._-.Wooded ------ Sewer LAND .__.(Electric Light •,„7-0T41. LAND VALUATION Gas TOTAL LAND AND.110GS. $ AGENDA ITEM 5 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING, JUNE 3, 1992 60 Palm Square, Marina Historic District. David Clitter, Owner. BACKGROUND This is a contributing Mediterranean Revival style single family residence and accessory structure, built in 1928 . The property was listed on the Florida Master Site File when the original Delray Historic Site Survey was done in 1987 . The accessory building was probably built for a guest or maid's room as it was constructed with a bath. This small 12 ' x 16 ' building was built at the same time as the residence. Evidence of this can be seen in the matching roof parapets, one original window and the frame and stucco construction. It is indicated on the City's building cards in 1942, which is as far back as the official record goes for most properties . Also on the property, but not listed on the Master Site File, is a noncontributing 1950 's rental apartment. NONCONFORMING BUILDINGS The accessory building is nonconforming. It does not meet the setbacks for the RM zoning district which requires a 7 1/2 ' side setback and a 10 ' rear setback. It is located on the rear property line and encroaches 0.5 'on the adjacent lot to the north. It is in very poor repair due to neglect and has had code violation citations. The Chief Building Official, Jerry Sanzone recommends that the building be demolished. Mr. Clitter has recently purchased the site and plans to do extensive remodeling and restoration to all three buildings. Pursuant to Section 1.3.4 (B) a nonconforming building destroyed by any means to an extent exceeding 50% of its replacement cost cannot be reconstructed. The cost of reconstructing this building will exceed the 50% limit. However, if the cost is computed to include the cost of work done on the main house as well, it will be within the 50% limit. In other words, if the project is considered as one historic site the total expenditure for restoring the residence and the small building would not exceed 50% of the replacement cost for both buildings. There is precedent for this procedure, recent examples are Frank McKinney's Executive Suites on S.E. 6th Avenue and the Charles Barretts ' guest cottage at 54 Marine Way. A letter, attached, from Gator Engineering states that the building is repairable if the owner wishes to incur the expense. Both buildings will be brought up to current building code Page 2 standards . An instrument, acceptable to the City, will be obtained from Richard Raab to permit the 0.5 'encroachment on his lot. ACTION REQUESTED Make a recommendation to the Chief Building Official, based on the historic nature of the buildings, that the proposed work be considered as one rehabilitation project, and allow the accessory building to be restored. STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD APRIL 7, 1993 AGENDA ITEM 4 COA 8-183-A 60 PALM SQUARE DAVID CLITTER, OWNER CONTRIBUTING MAIN RESIDENCE AND ACCESSORY BUILDING; NONCONTRIBUTING RENTAL COTTAGE, MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT ITEM B E FORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is that of approval of COA 8-183-A for a site plan and landscaping plan; and a request for a recommendation to the City Commission regarding waivers from certain landscape requirements. The site plan includes the construction of a swimming pool, patios, walkways, a 4 ' high wall to screen the pool, a fence to the south and 2 parking areas to accommodate a total of 4 cars. The parking spaces will have a pea rock surface and the driveway is to be paver block. The parking area is located in the front of the property; 2 spaces to be provided on the north; and 2 spaces to the south. BACKGROUND The property consists of three buildings; a single family Mission Revival style main house and accessory building built in 1928, and a rental cottage which is noncontributing. It is located in the Marina Historic District in the RM zone. On June 17, 1992 the Historic Preservation Board approved COA 8-183 for the exterior renovation of all three structures. The nonconforming accessory building had been condemned by the City when the applicant purchased the property. Upon recommendation of the HPB, because of the historic nature of the accessory building, the Chief Building Official allowed it to be rehabilitated and brought up to code. The rental cottage is currently vacant but the applicant wants to retain the option to use it as an income producing unit; as a result, 4 on-site parking spaces are required. The applicant had not completed his site plan and landscaping design at the time of the 1992 meeting. ANALYSIS The applicant is requesting special action from the HPB to recommend to the City Commission that waivers be granted for relief from certain landscaping regulations to allow the site to be developed as presented on the site plan. The request for waivers is as follows: COA 8-183-A 60 Palm Square Page 2 Perimeter landscaping adjacent to a public right-of-way (east) . * Pursuant to Section 4 .6 . 16 (H) (3) (a) , a 5 ' landscape strip between the parking area and a public right-of-way is required. A waiver is requested to allow a 3 ' landscape strip between the north and south parking areas and Palm Square. A 5' landscaping strip between Palm Square and the 2 south parking spaces can be provided by moving the 4 ' high stucco wall 2 ' to the west. This will :not interfere with the location of the thep000l and swimming theol 4 'as 4 ' are feet are devoted provided between a planters wall and p A 5 ' landscaping strip between Palm Square and the 2 north parking spaces can be accommodated by moving the parking area 2 ' to the west. This will create a 7 ' foundation planting area as opposed to the proposed 9 ' . Perimeter landscaping abutting adjacent properties (north/ south) . * Pursuant to section 4.6. 16(H) (3) (d) , a 5' landscape strip between the parking spaces and abutting properties is required. A waiver is requested to allow a 3 ' landscape strip between the 2 parking spaces which abut the property to the north and the 2 parking spaces which abut the south property. The required 5' landscaping buffer between south parking area and the abutting property can be provided by reducing the length of the parking spaces from to proposed 22' to the standard 18 ' . In order to preserve to the visual impact of the unusual arched front door and its decorative surround, it would be appropriate to recommend the waiver to allow a 3' landscape buffer between the 2 north parking spaces and the abutting property. The additional 2 ' gained by granting the waiver will place the cars out of the sight-line from the street to front entrance. The applicant has provided a letter of justification and explanation for the request, which is attached. Parking and Landscaping The basic parking configuration and design for the entrance court is attractive and appropriate. Utilizing 2 parking areas lessens the impact of a parking lot. The use of pea rock and paver block is consistent with the residential character of the COA 8-183-A 60 Palm Square Page 3 neighborhood. The site plan calculations meet development standards including the non-vehicular open space which provide 3, 115 square feet; 2,500 are required. The 4 ' masonry wall which screens the pool is completely compatible to the Mission style main building. Extensive landscaping is provided throughout the site. However, the only area which is a concern for the purpose of this review is the proposed parking lot area. The landscape plan indicates screening of the parking areas with a Cocoplum hedge. In order to meet the requirement to provide shade trees every 30 ' on center adjacent to the right-of-way [Section 4 . 6 . 16(H) (3) (a) ] , the pigeon plum tree at the southeast corner of the site will need to be located further to the north and an additional tree will need to be provided within the landscape strip adjacent to the existing Coconut Palm. Pursuant to Section 4 .6 . 16(H) (4) (b) , sod and irrigation must be provided within the unpaved portion of the right-of-way, between the edge of pavement and the east property line. This has not been indicated on the plan. ALTERNATIVE ACT I O N S Waivers 1. Recommend to the City Commission approval of the waivers to LDR Sections 4.6 . 16(H) (3) (a) and 4.6.16(H) (3) (d) , based on a positive finding from Section 4 .5. 1, that all of the requested waivers are necessary to maintain the historic character of the main residence and its relation to the streetscape. 2. Recommend to the City Commission denial 4 6 . 16 the H 3aivver requests to Section 4.6. 16(H) (3) (a) ( ) ( ) ( ) based on a failure to make a positive finding with respect to Section 4 .5. 1. 3. Recommend to the City Commission that a waiver from Section 4.6 . 16(H) (3(d) , which requires a 5' landscape strip between parking spaces and abutting properties be granted for the north parking area. Site Plan and Landscaping Plan i. Continue with direction 2. Approve COA 8-183-A and the associated site plan, landscape plan and pursuant to Section 4 .9 . 6(D) (8) (a) approve the use of a pea rock parking surface for 4 parking spaces and the use of paver blocks for the driveway. 3. Deny COA 8-183-A and the associated site plan, landscape plan and pursuant to Section 4 .9 .6(D) (8) (a) deny the use of a pea rock parking surface for 4 parking spaces and the use of paver blocks for the driveway. COA 8-183-A T� 60 Palm Square • Page 4 RECOMMENDED ACT I O N A. Recommend to the City Commission approval of the waiver from Section 4 .6 . 16(H) (3) (d) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landscape strip to 3 ' between parking spaces and abutting properties for the north parking area only. B. Recommend to the City Commission denial of the waiver requests to Section 4 .6. 16(H) (3) (a) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landsca a strip to 3 ' between the parking spaces and Palm Square; and Section 4 .6 . 16(H) (3) (d) , to reduce the _. _-74uired-5 ' w e landscape strip to 3 ' between the south parking spaces and the abutting property based on a failure �-y to make a positive finding with respect to Section 4 .5. 1, that the requested waivers are not necessary to maintain the historic character of the residence. C. Pursuant to Section 4 .9.6(D) (8) (a) approve the use of a pea rock parking surface for 4 parking spaces and the use of paver blocks for the driveway. D. Approve COA 8-183-A and the associated site plan and landscape plan by making a positive finding with respect to Section 4 .5. 1 subject to the following conditions: 1. That a revised site plan be submitted addressing the requested waivers. 2 . That, on the landscape plan, the pigeon plum tree at the southeast corner of the site be located further to the north and *h�� ate..—�. tox�al tree be--grov•ded rr;�hin the >andsca� t tc aes •^g Coconut Palm. 3 . That a note be provided on the landscape plan that sod and irrigation will be provided within the unpaved portion of the right-of-way, between the edge of pavement and the east property line. (• E I APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 100 N.W. 1ST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 The Historic Preservation Board and meets on the lication must first be f filed third Wedrioray of each month.tote next available meeting. 15 daysP P Address of Property 6o PM-i ` 6 1.{ E C004 -1g8 " Affix One Clear Picture • t: ' ". � t,• •. -' '.ett - ! - T-- , __ yam_• —. .."i-1 ` !^! L. ' if i p6A i • r .: _ 1_' ..i • . •-. ; .ii ..r"\ (n„, , . — 'ial -_,.-, T S .« J:� - • �? ,, s s:yy.S-. 4 sue- sr!"S F 1� ,. Th r3•.4... •,-.--.+=•••. r--1iE I"i 1MEG P4rvnc1' rE..CC, ( -#-Li— I I • GUt51 —�) LA7oO EWE— �_.___—:" -- / Nou5. \ I 1 5.f GAL ... :.. 41AiIR _._. . ._._ .._ .__. .. _ __ -• 1 U / / Hfla[C d f.fG. •.9 uttAVtL I�—.•_.emu _._ . . �L,o .� � ct -- L I ,eAai<1Nc, • II '. ki B�iQ I �1.80 . • c do • F„i . I t 5catt.�to , y ' _ ,_ I 7 4 4 I ' �� I _ I _ ��_.— , KEtiIGLNGL 1.:0• �.xv _.._ :•21,.•s.ae• :a 'I I — !� r I \ mm u ' `YSwe a•4' ex151100 SADAI, PALMS I • — i E'LMtJll¢ \. . ' ,� R'G' J I SPECIAL — 5.03 •n.i I ,'AVItJ(t �' :1:k:eaI'4.5 ,,. •7.1'1 _ 1' �w ..—_. • l. GlaGt.It.A1eP I • 1• '• �. •1I �c •( %LOS4 elVt. /A140 1 i XDRIVIi l• ze ea /o 'pAvo , 3. 1 \ \ '� _ I t • —y nL ._.— t—Ovtt NtA9 • x •Z.. PLMLitafTS'' �• J • I AWNiN4 I / •.'I. nil ° I �4, /MCK T POGL _ _ �—. y1 OWNER y I rJALtct.tA'( �• . I, 4,•.frit.... 4.4 ` S '1 PA11Q r;• a�/��xS.�j. 1 t t v. /'L—rC a... ..,_,..e0...7.7.:\ I' . , ..... G2 y a i ..�� 91v — -- I / C _ OtLP , J: I u •5.4 I , C 4 CPI,ONAt. CCIUn.JS W , F-- r001, cm. _ t ;. .iuuO IJAtL• R,y` G Vt4ON•� N41 ,AA+L ESL. . D u4N1 Y I .VOL yI B • PAWL • 10 timeg 11WSE HOUSE Ff• ►.Ol l I 4'Witt. •v Otte I „ aAleeo Sr. 3: I Wt1w tww1. • ._. _..._._—•----._�� •. .,4AVEL • h •• , 5A15to 1ti I c 9Al2KINE,I ' I i AQOV4 PA1t0 i I RaPOOL 1 5.4 •y- •_ _ _- — —__ _. WV)etx,a u. Q�IIII rlAJsge S.2 of Awrt2 =�—. :va0� '� i� I aIiIININ ...1 =..i OS EELOW fA110)•I —.... a- i ,0J •-) I r1 o �l S-x P:A •4l eg- . irL •.J:- 1 • I I j KEY Oil PLANT&SPECIFICATION • •PALMS of 2 Cnacm•mP•numM F., (European F P.cn) A*N.biol. •Cl. / C1ry•uWuc•ryv.4le,cen.(A P.u,.l 17MN, •ry clump,min•can,I NI M. •CN S Co •nrcdr•'G1•r1Mry41•n O.a?ICoaoM PWnI 1 ZS ooG.W..•I'QN bond,27 o.• m• N. ....Nov.WKm•n / \ • PE 1 Prycb.p•rma•4p•M(AM.•nd..P4.0 12,14'11T.,1 v4.060 . / ` 6 PR 1 Pln•nis ro•b.N11(O...A O..Pan) /•N,4'Bp.ENS,larrtr. �� -7 NO 1 Nrodlpin d K•ry11T11rgl•Parn) 1'M..101,woodman • } I / CA I C/nnl•cS1 r•nd•(R.d S.wry W.Palm) _` r•10-N.,l 4. I. / / -' / \ TREES / I /II • CO 2 Cocoul6 diu•,.I,B BPgwn Plan) Cl B 6 CT 1 C•IUB.pa.IK•y LLnrl K AT.lull OI 1 �� 'CTx 1 twit. .pp.t. S.wl...cl.p.IrW ..---...se.---.,,.. `�'_ •CTS I Cam•sop.IO.rc TI•q a'ht.,lud `/� P y( 'CtvAL�' fHNCi y,T 44, 1 I I Ns 1 N24N••pp.'S•mho4Ph'IHD4culSnndud) N�,' •y �r ... .._ .�_._ / I a•M../'Bps.,V c1.M•nd.,d 1..�_ r �..�1:1=\ /��... / \.i J. r• I - ,1 �`- :• • PL I. P,b4m lina•MI SaaaloII4* lYO ..0 ` ..i \ / I 1'M..rrp..mu•I Inw.L wr•'e 1.,B6B.• i — '�._ ;_, • 09 I Bu..r..mruo•lOumoo undo) -y T'-I 10•n6,r sp.,•el..ass 1 •.L.12A. WLL SIOLTAK�^\ GUCSi \ 4 �' I SHRUBS,GROUNDCOVERS,S ACCENTS ‘. -..v• •�N/ r• AZV / Aphl.mum!.♦rlp•••(Vrp•4d 1N1 Vnpr) '--T HOU9b .II •) --_ -" - - -- - -!'I I . Nary dooms 34 pl.,lull III : WAirl • rI ( _. m ,I G loop.m.••U. .n4• q p4 cdonl '11 a: Hfn1F•Z T.,.., n..•,1. rr.Tc� GEAv4L •rN..uL.d.lr.w o.•1,I 1.mn6roroK, I f,1L. •1'� �ua:i.,,. ,I pAa KING • 1 I BAO 36 0•II.NB. ,p.(A••ond 8•om•6d•) V IEI�� -., �,I'� ..o r..•' �rjp� �i_1 /j1 CA 3 00•nt..JO-Oloaat I.p..Luc,m.,101 ram. -I COvEAEO ,I 1L �\ KPH I a u C'E,i bdshus 14. .km031 400m w4mj V� ----- T I 6�F` I • I CO 19 G•M1*..0,ada(TT+yJe) I '� 24'N.,2/•Bp.,lull ,' - 'I II p ) A\ CN • LC T• L.nl.n.'Gold Mound' II 5c12EE11E0 , •x ��" -- -- — '- tuna I• I-C 11 14dcbda pllnornum'AnOmmda'(And omd6 P•I ski.fc \VIII PAt l0 \ lull clump.30.21-M•00'N.,24..p. Ili — • • I • 11P 10 24.n1.34•ice,IA3al.wens 6'ba c. I • • I K 112 ha.No,•GI•nr /�( _ 20'M.,10'1q.,Luc,7•'o.r. • - RI /�'� 6 12E410E144E• \, / `I• I A T Iri1�ra.eu oc.,y r v� uerm jl LL c•n, • -. .• .\ • JC 21 Junw•u•wN•ra(Sno••J••oune) I) �_� II W7• 2d '. .♦ ( .. 12'M..13'1p..170c. J.- rill (� •�• a W 363 L.bp•muwd'Er••0•••n Ou,u' s I.i Ili -. �,tt y \ F: I I�n1o.l.oe.,Irnl,minlr. i ik. L• P(;. �� �. I • LL • }I L4Valrrm..edrm lL4u•u1,m NWpa \ \n • **IA • NE a2 Nrpn,pl•p•n.B.1•n(Bd.lon F•1n1 1114 y•'L\ /r • O I 12'M,12'1p.,NI�Y ry.on1 Arywn u••a.n N•rn.N '- :/-1 • I /• A��...///k,� \. �X � - I 6H sx c pn..nra.00ml.a / I' I tll / Ji 11I ® AI'' ♦• • '/ ' 4R J Fula c.R'Ip,N'.c. v l • --A II. • • _ j1vl �J )� Z V� I.•I « 1 .I ,{ I M S Mb,M.•ua 10,11'o.c.•Fbw,d N,c.n Yn) " ( � ) /\NQ NE. E� 1)✓ I• III\ Q_ I MP 22 Munry•p•ncJ.•(O1uq•Jawrl•) • (/ ^� 1 •u. A CI 1 24'M.,2/'Bp..3/'oe. �• • 'al I .01 ��� ...r 1C t=~•- Wr�r_ • GII2GULAK I •NO / N•rlum o4.•d•r MAO PM 04•M•r SUMrd) /.\11uu =1, %t • \ ,, J� IL� PlumbV •.� Ct� II1 I1% I •._y--_;. G. Ln! .!c _...•r• . • I SA 5�99 Shc.al«.ubp,'sa.(O.,n$cn.n1.1,) 0,1mtinarzi•$:N\.,....„. I� .� 1 I �•rr .. . I SN 9 SI ul.nicolsi(wnn.Biro d P.Adde) t ,�� cr~^i.:'IvE GAtE' vrnl.,m1 .. i�/j1�� 4I [ I \Mrs _ /'` RT �WNEIZ • ♦ • I SR 3 Sb.41r414.1 Bad of Prdu•1 'Ii�'.�i,• 1• lit ® J • PA110 I \., ...4. •• 2TL,7 rp..lu,,min]ppp ,T�� •'.(�'�.�14"111 \ -1 A56 2 {3cG55'G GC11npl,TES G. �'>r trifan .� / 1 ! \' ! I Ifoil4 O.4 MT NO• L PLANT MATERIAL 10 BE RC: III, 1/ 1 !'� .__ _ ` ,i I full �D�1QSC i -�._. ` \, + 1'L B 1 .`,./y •Sod to b•SI,Augu.l•ul•fbraiam'.C' 7 /:� 1 ; POOL �1,D .Aa•od u.d 4ndKW.IO,•c.n•10.'. L c•- •0' 91ErSI dwr•lwwo jOLL• .. Tr,ullr•frunk ,Conlp•c wp.n•Ipu lot n'fir" iI I M XEc15CArE, plan!N•1.PI•n•nd•p•clot ..... / Mulcn,lop•o I,•ndnnn,lrlab•ait .I �� IODL LIt,NT --_- ___(-4r•\ I SPECIFICATIONSI J I • _ � {-4'Hl. rilUEEG h1A•LL• n - \' 17IN061ENClATURE:AlES (- " •' PJtyt 10 ItAICA HGf,E:'I Nr• ,c•d.•.�d•51adup:�" 1 I) 1 NOU•16 5A 11_'�IyI _____._ — —_ avcEr P• 1 I pp•cl colCm rJro10a co.0I.0_ ^ •PUNTLISTS:Ovama'u,II.•,a'RAISED SPA - ' pl•NM.11•L.pIK•d•nler.rw•'eGIUVE6 1 LN I Ou•n1T•,hornond•NInnr.(` _ .. ' N 1. 1N' PAIL•:•''Il•1 rl, I \II • Irudc,lcnd• u•l auamm�u r. • _ZVi41•• IW11N LWIII• I ���;; landt<•p.N<nrKl. • y•1 _ - E PAT10 1 1 •SUBSTITUTIONS:No I BI SI l< I� '1 •,..,.II - -- 4 _ !� • <; rlh 4 t--- I Nnrdd wbuAulan„n•I b.did u, �• ,•Pi...., % .. .i .. I ,-.•_.-_� _-- � • ;PUNTING SOL:Topl01 N•:N: �a \. al: ., r `•11 j ` • . 2 0.10•plu•d./n a alaw,.ol.• I ,♦ 1 \� !. �;'r P001 • S�1.ALK:• -_' _ '1 u' �.i � 1..lad n,o,nd ra.,..1• .f~ 11 `.Af. 1. .T-. • .. ._ -_, s. • Alternatively, after discussion, the Board approved the location of the driveway and the ramp configuration proposed on the plans dated March 18, 1993 with the following conditions: * That the existing driveway to the west be removed and replaced with a walkway. * That a vertical railing be installed on the ramp and that a hedge be planted and maintained to the height of the railing. * That the color and finish of the driveway surface be approved by staff. 3. COA 8-197-A: 48 S.E. 1st Avenue; Old School Square Historic District; Ninan Cherian, Owner The Board approved COA 8-197-A the sign for the Mariposa Adult Care Home with the following condition: * The background color for the sign, which was only specified as red, be approved by Pat Cayce. The Board recommended burgundy or a color relating to the awning color. Sandy Jamison moved for approval of COA 8-197-A, seconded by Pat Healy-Golembe. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes . Said motion passed 4-0. 4 . COA 8-183-A: 60 Palm Square; Marina Historic District; David Clitter, Owner The Board moved to recommend to the City Commission approval of the waiver from Section 4 .6 . 16(H) (3) (d) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landscape strip to 3 ' between parking spaces and abutting properties for the north parking area only. Sandy Jamison moved for approval of COA 8-183-A (Waivers) , seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes . Said motion passed 4-0. The motion for the Board to recommend to the City Commission denial of the waiver requests to Section 4 .6 . 16 (H) (3) (a) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landscape strip to 3 ' between the parking spaces and Palm Square; and Section 4 . 6 . 16(H) (3) (d) , to reduce the south parking spaces and the abutting property based on a failure to make a positive finding with respect to Section 4 .5. 1, that he requested waivers are not necessary to maintain the historic character of the residence was denied. - 2 - 4/7/93 V Sandy Jamison moved for approval of COA 8-183-A (Waivers) , seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - No; Daniel Carter - No; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - No. Said motion was denied 4-0 . The Board moved to recommend to the City Commission approval of the waiver from Section 4 .6 . 16(H) (3) (a) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landscape strip to 3 ' between the parking spaces and Palm Square; and recommend to the City Commission denial of the waiver request to Section 4 . 6 . 16(H) (3) (d) , to reduce the required 5 ' wide landscape strip to 3 ' between the south parking spaces and the abutting property based on a failure to make a positive finding with respect to Section 4 .5. 1, that the requested waiver is not necessary to maintain the historic character of the residence. Daniel Carter moved for approval of COA 8-183-A (Waivers) , seconded by Sandy Jamison. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes . Said motion passed 4-0 . In summary; the Board recommended all requested waivers except that abutting the south property line. Pursuant to Section 4 .9 .6(D) (8) (a) , the Board approved the use of a pea rock parking surface for 4 parking spaces and the use of paver blocks or an approved equal for the driveway. Sandy Jamison moved for approval of COA 8-183-A (Parking Surface & Driveway) , seconded by Pat Healy-Golembe. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Said motion passed 4-0 . The Board approved COA 8-183-A, the associated site plan and landscape plan by making a positive finding with respect to Section 4.5. 1 subject to the following conditions: 1 . That a revised site plan be submitted addressing the requested waivers. 2 . That if the Seagrape tree to the north is ever removed it will be replaced with 2 Pigeon Plum trees. One to be located at the northeast corner of the parking area and one centered on the north parking area property line. 3 . That a note be provided on the landscape plan that sod and irrigation will be provided within the unpaved portion of the right-of-way, between the edge of the pavement and the east property line. - 3 - 4/7/93 Sandy Jamison moved for approval of COA 8-183-A, seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Said motion passed 4-0 . 5 . REPORTS FROM HISTORIC DISTRICTS: Mrs . Cayce informed the Board Alieda Riley was working on signs for the Marina Historic District. 6 . UNFINISHED BUSINESS: Mr. Carter inquired about the enlarging of OSSHAD. Mrs . Cayce stated that she had completed a preliminary study and would present it to the Board at their next meeting. Mrs. Golembe inquired about the color of the Naussau Pointe Project. Mrs. Cayce will check the file as to what the Board had approved. 7 . NEW BUSINESS: Mrs. Golembe went to Washington D.C. to lobby for the tax credits for historic homes and for more government money for historic programs. She felt things had gone well. Mr. Carter spoke to the City Commission at their Goal Setting Meeting in March in reference to the tax credit for historic homes. Mr. Carter inquired about the Swinton Avenue Beautification Committee and the Board expressed a desire to view the plan. Mrs . Cayce stated that she would speak with Nancy Davila about presenting the plan to the Board. 8 . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: March 10, 1993 & March 17, 1993 Christine Bull moved for approval of the minutes for the March 10 & 17, 1993 meetings, seconded by Pat Healy-Golembe. The vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Said motion passed 4-0. 9 . ADJOURNMENT: Pat Healy-Golembe moved for adjournment at 7 :35 P.M. , seconded by Christine Bull. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes. Said motion passed 4-0. - 4 - 4/7/93