Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
HPB 12-06-06
o`'��•�'� AGENDA x 0.<f. *P HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: December 6, 2006 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144, 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I I. CALL TO ORDER ELECTION OF OFFICERS First Vice Chair, Second Vice Chair II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES . ___ LQvvember 15, 2006 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House, Mr. and Mrs. Erskine and Virginia Courtenay, Owners. Consideration of Part I of the Tax Exemption application to improvements associated with COA 2006-454. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Reports from Historic District Representatives • Board Members • Staff V. ADJOURN r ilm# E, r46 ee Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: November 30, 2006 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD PUBLIC HEARING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA MEETING DATE: November 15, 2006 LOCATION: City Commission Chambers MEMBERS PRESENT: John Miller, JoAnn Peart, Linda Lake, and Jeannette Dobson MEMBERS ABSENT: STAFF PRESENT: Amy Alvarez, Brian Shutt, and Denise Valek I. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Chairman Miller at 6:00 p.m. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. • No one from the Public addressed the Board on non-agenda items. Chairman Miller read a summary of the'Quasi-Judicial Hearing procedures. The Notary swore in individuals for testimony. • II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. 135 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, Community Redevelopment Agency, Owner, David Miller Architects,, Authorized Agent Reconsideration of conditions of approval associated with 2006-419-COA. Chairman Miller opened the Quasi Judicial Hearing. Chairman Miller asked if there were any ex-parte communications. There were none. Staff Presentation: Ms. Alvarez entered the project file into the record and presented a summary of the staff report. Notices: None Public Comments: None. Board Discussion: Board discussion ensued and all Board members felt that this diamond did not have any historic significance. Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Motion/Findings: It was moved by Ms. Lake, seconded by Ms. Dobson, and approved 4 to 0 to eliminate the following conditions: 1. That the diamond be retained on the front elevation of the building. 2. That a single awning can be installed on the front elevation of the first floor as originally submitted. Final Action: Approved 5 to 0 B. 711 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District David Rosenbom, Owner, Harold Tuttle, Authorized Agent. Consideration of 2007-020-COA associated with the partial\demolition and major additions and alterations of a non-contributing structure. Chairman Miller asked if there were any ex-parte communications. ,., Ms. Peart asked Mr. Shutt to clarify the meaning,of ex-parte communications. Ms. Peart advised she spoke with\Ms.Livia Landry, Who lives next door to the applicant, today regarding this item. Ms. Peart advised that Ms2Landry was unable to attend the meeting tonight, and requested Ms \Peart to ask the Board some questions relative to this item. Ms. Landryalso_advised her neighbor would be attending, however, Ms. Peart did not see her in the audience. Ms. Lake questioned if this was legal for a Board member to speak for another person. Mr. Shutt advised,as long'"-as__the Board `members do not talk amongst themselves outside of a public hearing, you can`talk..to anyone about anything, and disclose it at the meeting "If-you have a conversation with someone and their statement could sway your opinion,you must-disclose\that information. Staff,Presentation Ms. Alvarez entered the project file into the record and presented a summary of the Staff Report. Ms. Alvarez}advised that she prepared a Square Footage Addendum to the Staff Report to\clarify_minor corrections regarding the square footage calculations that were stated in the original Staff Report (attached). There is not much of a difference, only 1% to 2%. Applicant Presentation: Mr. Rosenbom, 711 North Swinton, advised he has been going through this process for a year. I have tried to work on this project with these comments, however, you have to think of my side this is my home for my family. I have a problem with the garage in the back. I need a backyard for the kids; I need a pool and a playground. If I put the garage on the back of the property, my cars will have the best view of the property. It is not logical for me to put the garage in the back. Regarding the two parking spaces, Livia Landry parks her car on their driveway, and it is on the setback. The owner at 721 N. 2 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Swinton (next to me) parks his car on the setback (which is 30 feet). He has a one car garage that fronts Swinton, the door is facing Swinton. He has a high hedge and you can't see the garage. If you want I can put a big hedge on my property as well. My garage is on the north side of the property, and it would be difficult for me to enter the garage. I can do landscaping or whatever to hide it. I think it is more logical to put my garage on the Swinton side of the property than to put my bedrooms on Swinton Avenue. There is a lot of traffic. I am 36 today, and I can bring the car back and forth to the back of the property, I can close my eyes and do it, but maybe 20, 30 or 40 years from now I might not be able to do it. I want to get on with this process, I have wasted a lot of money on this process and it is a nightmare for me. I had a seven month time out. What I learn is that I have to wait. I heard about the new rules that were not approved already. The height is 24 feet, if they want me to reduce I will reduce. We have a 27% footprint and the recommendation is 30/35% we are in. We are OK with the setback at 29 feet. Then they asked me to put the setback on the.side of the second story. Right now I have three setbacks on the second story. Maybe I will work like Houdini. If I do a new setback my second story will have to stay in the air without anything under it. Today, tell me what I have to do and I will do it. If you-want me to reduce, I will reduce, if you want me to put the garage in the back I will put'the garage in the back. Please help me to get out of this it is a nightmare for me. Regarding the garage in front of the property I found two on Swinton, 721 North Swinton and 411 North Swinton. There are 15 more in Del- Ida Park. Right now I will listen to you. Public Comments: Chairman Miller inquired if Jhere were any comments from the public. There were none. Chairman Milleclosed the public_ hearing. ;, ChairmanMiller;inquired if there were any questions of Staff. Alvarez addressed parking in the setbacks. I don't know when their driveways were established, however, those are'the requirements in the LDRs. I do not know about the garage at 721 North Swinton. I do know about 411 North Swinton and that structure was built in the.1960's I do not know when the garage portion was constructed. In regard to the second,story, rather than doing an additional setback maybe the roof plane can be broken up. Board Discussion: Ms. Peart questioned if you are driving north do you see the garage door. Amy advised if you were driving north you would not see it, but if you were driving south you would see it. Ms. Peart advised this is a hypothetical question, is there any way to do a garage door that did not look like a garage door, possibly with windows in it. Chairman Miller advised it would not meet code. 3 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Ms. Lake asked if Ms. Alvarez had a recommendation regarding the change that the garage contains a secondary appearance, and is minimally visible from North Swinton Avenue. Ms. Alvarez advised it needs to be secondary when you look at the Historic District, the garages are to the rear and pretty much detached. It should not be such a prominent feature. Ms. Del Fiandra advised that most of the garages are at the same setback as the house. Mr. Miller advised this is flush with the front of the structure. The front of the garage has two windows facing Swinton. If you are looking at this from Swinton it is minimally visible. The only way you will see it is from the north. Ms. Lake made a comparison with the Love house. Ms. Del Fiandra advised that the Love house has a prominent entrance. This house does not have a prominent front. Mr. Miller advised that the front door design is one of the conditions of approval. Ms. Alvarez advised the LDRs required that-parking spaces are\located outside of the front setback and it presents a problem as it is:presented. �� Ms. Peart questioned if the LDRs were optional. Ms. Alvarez advised that you would have to have positive findings that complied with\the LDRs. Ms. Shutt questioned if she said that-the garage itself was within the 30 foot setback. Ms. Alvarez advised the garage Was in the setbackhowever, the space should be located within the front setback. Ms. Peart questioned why this was given to us if there was an LDR requirement. Mr. Shutt advised he could seek a waiver, but I would have to look at the section. I don't know if we waived that requirement before. -.This would have to come back to the Board as a waiver. Ms. Alvarez advised this would be a waiver, variances would be a setback. Ms. Pearl advised that she has,,to speak to Amy regarding this issue for clarification. Chairman Miller advised this is a pretty dramatic difference compared to what was presented the last time. There is a stairwell on the plan that is set back 7-1/2 feet. Mr. Shutt advised we are operating under the old conditions because the new ones have not gone for firsttreading. Chairman Miller thinks he needs to do something with the front door area, and possibly putting a window on the second floor facing Swinton Avenue. Other than that I don't have too much of a problem with the rest of it. I don't want to have this gentlemen come back, I would rather get this done. This is an improvement over what we saw before. I don't know if we can put a gable on the front door. Ms. Del Fiandra questioned if the garage could be moved back so it was not so close to the road. I appreciate the fact that he wants the bedrooms in the back due to noise. 4 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Chairman Miller inquired if there was any way the garage could be counted as a two car garage. It seems deep but does it have to have two entrances, can it.be tandem? We could get past the waiver that would be necessary, one parking space is half way in the setback. If it is counted as a two car garage and the requirement is two parking spaces within the setback, it does not matter if you use them, it is a matter of where they are in the plan and how deep is the garage. Mr. Rosenbom advised the setback is at 35 feet, because we have a porch. The wall is at 35 feet of setback, and the addition is 15 feet more setback. From the wall when we go to Swinton we will have 20 feet to park the cars. I think those parking spaces are in the setback. The garage side on Swinton the two windows are existing, one is very big and you asked me to reduce it. We won't change anything. Chairman Miller advised the Board is looking for more detail so it looks like the front of the house. Mr. Rosenbom advised the windows on the west side of the second floor will be six over six like on the first floor. Ms. Lake advised that most homes have a feature on the front door like a stoop. Mr. Rosenbom advised he can take off the porch on the south side of the property and add a porch on the west side. I,will be glad to do if it is better. Ms. Alvarez advised that the LDRs require,certain FAR percentages, and a front entry feature would be great. I know there were some"questions about moving the garage back. The garage is-located in the existing structure, and everything else is new construction. The decision`would be based on what the Board finds compatible with the area. Ms. Peart questioned how manyygarages are on the front of the house in Del-Ida Park. Ms. Alvarez advised-that on non-contributing structures there are carports. I don't know to answer your question Ms. Del Fiandra advised that;some have carports, which gives it more of a setback and staggered effect. r' Ms. Peart inquired if he was planting a ficus hedge on Ms. Landry's side. She was kind of hoping you could use something other than ficus, because ficus is considered an invasive plant, Mr. Rosenbom advised he will speak with Mr. Landry and they will choose the hedge, Ms. Alvarez advised the technical comments did not speak against the ficus, and the landscaping would have to comply with the landscaping requirements, and could be part of the conditions of approval. Chairman Miller advised that a front porch feature should be added to the conditions. Chairman Miller questioned what was meant by the north elevation, second-story roof plane in No. 5. Ms. Alvarez advised the bump out that Chairman Miller asked me to measure was not depicted on the front left elevation. You can see the gable end. On the north elevation it looks as if it just goes up into the hip roof and it does not. 5 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Ms. Del Fiandra asked which one is correct. Chairman Miller advised the west elevation was the correct one. Chairman Miller questioned if it was a gable or a hip as it is drawn on the north elevation is a hip. Ms. Alvarez advised the front elevation would be a gable. Chairman Miller advised it looks like a gable on the east elevation, this needs to be clarified. I would prefer to see a hip. Mr. Rosenbom advised maybe he can keep the roof on the second story to go down. Chairman Miller advised it juts down and is not shown on the elevations. This needs to be clarified whether it is a gable or hip end. Chairman Miller continued with the conditions. No. 5 yes,' No. 6 yes, No 7. has been accomplished, it is setback pretty far (20' from the front wall plane) from the front of the building, No. 8. is this an LDR Section that he would,have to,:get a waiver for? Ms.Alvarez believes it would be a waiver and it could be a condition of approval that the waiver request and would go to City Commission. Chairman Miller questioned if the setback went right through his parking space. "Ms. Alvarez adviseddyes, therefore, half the car would be on it and half would not/be • Ms. Peart questioned if this had to go to City Commission. Ms. Alvarez advised waivers would have to go to City Commission. Chairman ,Miller advised variances are, I don't know about waivers. Mr. Shutt advised that variances do'not go to City, Commission they are either approved by HPB and then go to,Circuit Court if it is appealed -,If we keep that condition there they might be able to wof k;:with staff where they can come up where he can get the two cars in there. Then,he can maketthe decision if he wants to come forward with a waiver request to HPB for recommendation and would then go to City Commission. That would be up to the\applicant. Chairman-Miller, questioned if that condition was eliminated would there be a problem getting a building,permit, would that be reviewed by P&Z. Mr.'Shutt advised you,couldd t just say we would eliminate that condition. We would have to do something staff wise. You would have to comply or get a waiver from that provisional,believe. Ms. Lake inquired what should a parking space look like, could it be grass, etc. Ms. Alvarez advised this is not part of the issue. Ms. Lake questioned if there was enough yard space that'`could have grass with stones that would be an attractive spot to park the car. Ms. Alvarez advised you could do that, however, you would have to show two spaces that are in the buildable area outside of the setbacks. Ms. Peart advised she will probably vote for it because he has made so many considerations and has come back so many times. A 3,500 sq.. ft. house seems like we are trying to squeeze a house that is too big for the lot that is why we are having this problem. Maybe that is why the houses are smaller in Del-Ida. If the houses were smaller we wouldn't be having all this trouble, i.e., garages in the front, parking spaces. My house is on half an acre and it is 3,000 sq. ft. 6 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Chairman Miller advised that part of it is that he is keeping part of the existing structure as well. He has to work around that too. If it was cleared I don't think we would have this problem. Ms. Peart inquired why we are keeping part of the structure. Chairman Miller advised it was his choice. Motion/Findings: It was moved by Ms. Lake, seconded by Ms. Dobson, and approved 5 to 0 to move to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 711 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7) and 4.5.1(E)(8)(a-k), the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation with the following direction: 1. That a front door is specified, and a front porch feature is added; 2. That windows are added to the second-story west elevation;, 3. That items 1. and 2. of the landscape technical items are complied with prior to COA certification; .Q 4. That the north elevation second story'roof plane is corrected; 5. That the chimney is properly depicted oh all applicable elevations; and 6. That no required parking spaces are located-within the front setback. Final Action: Approved 5 to 0 III. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Forward a Recommendation to the City Commission to adopt the revised Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines. Ms. Alvarez advised that the,.consultants have revised the Guidelines, and various LDR amendments that you have already-reviewed. The revisions do include additional maps, language�~reconmending that new construction, development is designed in order to conform now. There are preakdowns of the historic districts with regard to their zoning "andarchitectural styles. There are additional photographs involved, an updated COA approval matrix, an extended glossary, as well as the new Appendix E which contains district impact studies,some of which have been implemented into the LDRs and some of which\have not at this time. Basically the revisions have been made in order to help with objective rather than subjective review of the applications in order to help the Board, staff, and the_applicant. Staff recommends that the Board recommend approval to the City Commission of the revised Design Guidelines. Board Discussion: Chairman Miller inquired If these are the revised Guidelines. Ms. Alvarez advised they were. However, there are some LDR Amendments that have occurred since your review of them two weeks ago. The Guidelines will also be further revised based on those LDR Amendments. Those are mainly to the building height plane and how to configure that. Eighteen feet (18) is being proposed for a one-story structure, and that will be lowered, and then we would have further streetscape evaluations and surveys. 7 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Chairman Miller questioned if that was a little premature to vote on this without seeing the final product. Ms. Alvarez did comment on that and those revisions will be made prior to being adopted by City Commission. Ms. Peart advised what if they didn't feel they were ready, could we postpone it. Ms. Alvarez advised the LDR Amendments are supposed to go to City Commission for first meeting on December 5, 2006, and adopted at the second reading on January 2, 2007. When I did inquire about postponing tonight's review, it was mentioned that at first reading on December 5, 2006 that the Commission would want to know your thoughts and what your recommendation is. On December 5, Staff could mention to Commission that you felt you were not prepared to make a recommendation'. Chairman Miller advised he had two major concerns(one being we have not seen the finished product, and two the only Architect on the Board iis,no longer on the Board. Although I am sure there is a lot of experience\here I still would like to see a trained Architect take a look at this. I have made recommendations thattwhoever is appointed here, and I am no saying anyone in particular, but we need an Architect on the Board. I would not have a problem postponing this. j - Ms. Del Fiandra questioned if the buffer zone portion could be further reviewed. Ms. Alvarez advised that the information you have is already in the LDRs. Chairman Miller understands that there is a time line'getting these done as quickly as possible, but if it is a matter of a couple of weeks I would rather have it done right and not regret that we didn't have the chance to look at it beforehand.There is no,telling if we are going to have an Architect on the Board or not."l \don't know who the Commissioners are going to recommend or approved, but\at the same time I would like a little more time to review these. Motion/Findings: \" Motion made,by Ms Lake, seconded by Ms. Peart, and approved 5 to 0 to continue this item., N Final Action: 5 to 0 to continue this item IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • ■ Public Comments Ms. Ellen Key, 321 SE 7th Avenue, advised she attended the workshop that was presented to the City Commission. She advised her one story house was built in 1992 and I recently had it reappraised, and was advised by the appraiser that her home is close to becoming a tear down because she has not maximized the square footage. I am hoping you reconsider that our block should not be classified a Historic District. Ms. Alice Finst, 707 Place Tavant, advised that she monitors the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board, and Planning and Zoning Board Meetings. Ms. Finst said it would behoove the Board to attend the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting on November 20, 2006 as there are two very important items on the Agenda: 1) REG Architects is presenting the Historic District Guidelines, and 2) the Signage Ordinance. 8 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 Ms. Lois Brezinski, 110 NE 7th Street, advised she came to hear David's presentation, and thanked the Board for postponing THE Guidelines as it deserves careful review. Ms. Brezinski advised she attended the individual Historic Guideline meetings and has a good understanding where Mr. Gonzalez was going. What started this whole process was when Andy Spengler wanted to develop four homes. My concern is that after all is said and done we might be right back where we started. If we go by what is being proposed we are back to 30%, and before you know it we will be back to a 3,400 sq. ft. home. Even though there is no one here tonight, we will all be back screaming again. Ms. Peart advised because of what Ms. Brezinski said, I am having the same problem. I voted for the LDR changes. Mr. Roy Simon said the problem is the people have small lots and the lots were not intended for houses that are/large. Will we end up with anything better than we presently have. When Mr. Rosenbom says that to use the angle youand percentage criteria, is there anything that says have to use all three criteria to build the house. Ms. Alvarez advised that all three criteria would"be used together. \ Mr. Shutt advised we can word it in such a way that it will be clear. However, everything is open to interpretation. We will make it crystal clear that all of these conditions have to be met. I don't see how we cannot do that as that is the intent of the City Commission. It is not an "and" or an "or" , but that is up to the'City Commission when they adopt the ordinance. Ms. Del Fiandra asked if there was .something_to protect the residents who are not looking at it as an equity-situation. Ms. Peart inquired if the plan for 711 N. Swinton Avenue had met REG's new Design Guidelines. Ms,Alvarez advised it did. Board discussion ensued,relat a to-streetscape, and Ms. Alvarez advised it would be included°in'the new ordinance. pa ps Peart inquired; about Spengler. Ms. Alvarez advised he has not submitted lications applying,any of these new standards to his projects. Chairman Miller inquired if Spengler would have to apply the new guidelines or the previous ones. Ms. Alvarez advised he would have to resubmit under the new Guidelines with the exception of one property. Ms. Lake advised that the Board should tour the districts and document any properties that are in such disrepair that at some point they can come in for demolition. Ms. Lois Brezinski suggested that visuals (utilizing a CAD system) should be utilized when the applicant comes in with a new proposal. • Reports from Historic District Representatives • Board Members • Staff 9 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board November 15, 2006 V. ADJOURN The meeting adjourned at 7:50 p.m. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for November 15, 2006, which was formally adopted and approved by the Board on Denise A. Valek, Executive Assistant/Board Liaison If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above,then this'means that these are not the official Minutes.They will become so after review and approval,which,may involve some;changes. a *� 10 UEERAY BEACH - - - UiuF.BEACH All•Am�icaCth All•M�icaCih HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD �d ' IP MEMORADUM STAFF REPORT IIIP 1993 1993 2UU1 - 2001 Property Owner: Mr. and Mrs. Erskine H. Courtenay Project Location: 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House (Individually Designated) HPB Meeting Date: December 6, 2006 COA: 2006-454; 2007-019 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is to approve the preconstruction application for a Tax Exemption application related to improvements to an individually designated property located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 4.5.1(M). BACKGROUND/PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lot 21 and the West 35 Feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade and is zoned Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). The original structure (limited to the second story portion) was built in 1955, while the first story portion was constructed below the original elevated structure in 1981. The existing structure consists of 2,750 square feet. Named for the originalg owner and designed by architect Paul Rudolph, the structure is representative of 20 century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. At its meeting of July 5, 2005, the City Commission passed an ordinance that listed the subject property on the Local Register of Historic Places. At its meeting of October 18, 2006, the Historic Preservation Board approved COA 2006-454 for a two-story, 1,936 square foot, handicap accessible addition to the existing structure on the south elevation. The proposed improvements have not commenced and the tax exemption would apply to the expenditures associated with the following: • Construct a 1,936 square foot, two-story addition; • Repair and replace (like-kind) of original window openings deteriorated by weather conditions; • Replace (like-kind) of original cantilevered panels located in the first story ceiling/second story floor in the southeast corner; • Replace (like-kind) of existing 4x4 posts/columns within window framing, as needed, due to rot; • Replace flat roof and all AC ducts; • Install copper gutters, and; • Replace (like-kind) original second-story floor material; The applicant is now before the Board to request review of Part I of the Tax Exemption Application for the improvements stated above as approved with COA 2006-454. All landscaping associated with this project is not permitted as a legitimate expenditure as it is not interpreted as a "site improvement", pursuant to the Florida Administrative Code 1A-38. 2"2 Se a€ireexe 200 -v t 9-;OA Preccnstr:iction Tax Exert tro rt n Ap i cation.Pa 1 nu Gi_ce l eae 6,20666 .. Based on State regulations, an Ad Valorem Tax Exemption can be approved for a project before, during, or after it has been undertaken. The applicant therefore requests consideration of an ad valorem tax exemption as construction has not commenced. AD VALOREM TAX EXEMPTION Standards for Qualifying Improvements: LDR Section 4.5.1 (M) (5) (b) states: For an improvement to a historic property to qualify for an exemption the improvement must: (i) Be consistent with the United States Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended; (ii) Be determined by the Historic Preservation Board to meet criteria established in rules adopted by the Department of State, Division of Historical Resources, FAC 1A-38, as amended; (iii) Be consistent with Section 4.5.1 (E), "Development Standards"of the City's Land Development Regulations; and (iv) Include as part of the overall project, visible improvements to the exterior of the structure. The project meets criterion (i) through previous approval by the Board of the two-story addition mentioned above which constituted its compliance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. The project meets the criterion (ii) as being consistent with the rules of Florida Administrative Code 1A-38, promulgated by the Florida Department of State, Division of Historical Resources. The project meets criterion (iii) through the COA 2006-454 approval which applied the LDR Development Standards in the assessment of the project. Finally, the project meets the requirements of criterion (iv) as the project encompasses visible improvements to the exterior of the buildings and related property. The additional improvements meet the above noted criteria, as well, as they are to be like-kind replacements. Any differentiation from that of the existing shall constitute an amendment to the application and require further review by the Historic Preservation Board. For purposes of the Tax Exemption, submission and consideration of Part 1 of the construction application is permitted before, during, or after construction has begun. Part 2, the "Final Application/ Request for Review of Completed Work" which is submitted when the work is complete, will include documentation of all costs incurred during the project along with the approved building permit application listing the cost of the work performed. The Historic Preservation Board will review the Final Application to determine whether the completed improvements are in compliance with Part I of the construction application. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(M)(14), an applicant must complete all work within two (2) years following the date of approval of a Part 1 Construction Application by the Historic Preservation Board. A Construction Application shall be automatically revoked if the property owner has not submitted a Final Application/Request for Review of Completed Work within two (2) years following the date of approval of the Construction Application. Following the aforementioned final HPB review, the matter will be forwarded to the City Commission with a recommendation to grant or deny the exemption. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. 2/3 2"2 Seabreeze Avenue 2607-019-COA Preconstruction Tax Exemption Appl cation.Pact I HP3 Mee:rng December 6. B. Approve the Tax Exemption Application Part 1, regarding COA 2006-454, for improvements to the property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(M)(5)(b). C. Deny the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application Part 1, regarding COA 2006-454, for improvements to the property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, based upon a failure to make positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(M)(5)(b). RECOMMENDATION Approve the Tax Exemption Application Part 1, regarding COA 2006-454, for improvements to the property at 212 Seabreeze Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(M)(5)(b) with the understanding that the Final Application/Part II shall be submitted by December 6, 2008. Report prepared by Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: • Staff Report for COA-2006-454 • Tax Exemption Application-Part 1 • Photos 313 DRRAY RLACH DELRAY R WCH '+ AIFAmerica" ry HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD AIFAma riaCi MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT 'I 1993 1903 2001 2001 Property Owner: Mr. and Mrs. Erskine H. Courtenay Project Location: 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House (Individually Designated) HPB Meeting Date: October 18, 2006 COA: 2006-454 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) associated with an addition located at 212 Seabreeze Avenue (Sewell C. Biggs House), pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND / PROJECT DESCRIPTION .The subject property consists of Lot 21 and the West 35 Feet of Lot 22, Delray Beach Esplanade and is zoned Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). The original structure, the second story portion, was built in 1955 while the first story portion was constructed below the original elevated structure in 1981. The existing structure consists of 2,750 square feet. Named for the original owner and designed by architect Paul Rudolph, the structure is representative of 20th- century regional modernism tailored for the Florida environment. At its meeting of July 5, 2005, the City Commission passed an ordinance that listed the subject property on the Local Register of Historic Places. The application is now before the Board for the consideration of a two-story, 1,936 square foot, handicap accessible addition to the existing structure on the south elevation. The addition will be connected to the existing structure on the south elevation by a five foot (5') wide open walkway with an aluminum rail on the first story and a five foot, eight inch (5'8") wide enclosed walkway on the second story. The wall planes of the second story walkway will primarily consist of glass. The new construction will be finished with stucco and painted "sweet bluette", an icey shade of blue. The height of the existing structure is twenty-two feet (22'). Portions of the addition measure twenty-two feet (22') and twenty-five feet (25'), while the elevator shaft portion extends to a height of twenty-seven feet (27'). The addition will contain a ramp which will slope from the drive area up to the covered paver walkway which meets the elevator entrance and continues on to the previously mentioned walkway which connects to the existing structure. The first floor will contain a studio space, full bathroom, and a covered deck. The second floor will consist of a bedroom, full bathroom, and covered deck. The upper story will contain transom windows on the north elevation and bands of glass block will be located on the east and south elevations at each story. Three skylights will be located on the roof plane. DESIGN ELEMENTS ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), the Board must make a finding that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes 212 S•.'.abraoGe• veau'v 2OO6 45.-CO -hPR_ October :5.2006 pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with the provisions of LDR Section 4.5.1. Future Land Use Element Objective A-4: The redevelopment of land and buildings shall provide for the preservation of historic resources. The objective shall be met through continued adherence to the City's Historic Preservation Ordinance and the following policies: Policy A-4.1: Prior to approval or recommending approval of any land use or development application for property located within a historic district or designated as a historic site, the Historic Preservation Board must make a finding that the requested action is consistent with the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations relating to historic sites and districts and the "Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines" LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), 4.5.1(E)(7), and 4.5.1(E)(8) provide guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The guidelines are as follows: (E)(4) A historic site or building, structure, site, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended from time to time. (E)(7) The construction of new buildings or structures, or the relocation, alteration, reconstruction, or major repair or maintenance of a non-contributing building or structure within a designated historic district shall meet the same compatibility standards as any material change in the exterior appearance of an existing non-contributing building. Any material change in the exterior appearance of any existing non-contributing building, structure, or appurtenance in a designated historic district shall be generally compatible with the form, proportion, mass, configuration, building material, texture, color, and location of historic buildings, structures, or sites adjoining or reasonably approximate to the non-contributing building, structure, or site. (E)(8) All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front facade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids on front facades, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of building, directional expression of front elevation. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation recommend that: The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. (Standard#2) Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time, place, and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or architectural elements from other buildings, shall not be undertaken. (Standard#3) New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. (Standard#9) 212 Seobreeze Avenue 2006-454 COA.1-4PB HPB Mee:,no October'8.2008 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. (Standard#10) The Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines recommend the following with respect to additions: oLocate an addition as inconspicuously as possible, usually to the rear or least public side of a building. oAdditions should not be located in front of the established front place of a historic building. olnsure that the addition is secondary and subordinate to the main mass of the historic building. Additions that overwhelm the original building are not an acceptable solution. Analysis The proposed addition respects the historic integrity of the existing historic structure. With respect to the above noted LDRs, guidelines, and Standards, the proposed addition appears to meet their intentions. The front of the property is considered the north elevation which faces Vista Del Mar and will have the least amount of impact as the visibility will be minimal. While the height does exceed that of the existing structure, it remains secondary and is not overwhelming, regardless of the vantage point. In addition, the lines of the existing structure are carried over throughout the addition, providing unity throughout the design while maintaining that the addition is clearly new construction. Landscape Plan Pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.16(B)(4), the landscape provisions apply to any modification to existing development which results in an increase of 25% in the gross floor area of the structure, or structures, situated on the site. In such cases the entire site shall be upgraded to present landscape standards. The existing landscape is minimal which compliments the architectural style of the historic structure and as such, changes have not been proposed. In addition, the area where the addition is proposed is primarily sodded. The lot is bordered with various types of palms while seagrapes provide greenery along the south elevation and border portions of the driveway. However, should the City Horticulturalist determine that a plan is required, the applicant shall submit such plan. Based upon the analysis above and throughout the report, positive findings can be made with respect to the LDRs, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interiors Standards for Rehabilitation once the condition of approval has been met. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness and variance request for 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness and variance request for 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does z 4. 212 Scabrceze Aienue 2006-45=-00A-HPB HPF.5 Mee`r:Q October `$.2006 not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. RECOMMENDATION Move to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2006-454 for 212 Seabreeze Avenue, Sewell C. Biggs House by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, with the condition that a landscape plan is submitted subject to determination and subsequent review by the City Horticulturalist. Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: Existing Photographs, Survey, Site Plan, Proposed Elevations. _ D- _ (n 0 LT 1.1 z \ fl BEACH DRIVE -w I Q _ > Q SEA SPRAY AVE. - VJ _ 1— SANDOWAY LANE - Q -so WATERWAY LANE a Z- a — o 1— — _ ¢ ZZ cc Lo 0 0 - LAING ST. —, D MAR DRIV N p VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE C V 1 RIV OVTh.."------w Z • w > hi J z a _4 THOMAS STREET I z J J C c, ~ w LLJ DRIVE w I- 1ST CT. z ¢ Q yr w I— O a m m a (%) 0 LOWRY STREET ci GOwCI) k,__,__,_..- w z \ w w NJ /�\ w z M Q m a N w U 0 N SEWELL C. BIGGS HOUSE -711111!— LOCATION MAP CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL �y-, PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT Iii;$ SUBJECT PROPERTY -- DIGITAL SASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM972 • • r • • Robert G.Currie d Partnership,Inc. Architects,Planners 8 Interior Designers Robert 0 Currie AIA Jess AI Sowards AIA Jose' Apria A 4.400022 134 ILL le No. TIM i iiib C,e]20- i • APt [016.W 6lCMua r.T..a D•.60 AIL..OP M4r. ] nN.T. r •FLY mF Ta6.In„ND DG .x.RY[6R U t.) CgTlR ORIr FFFu. �. �c�.� �.0 2:1 ]$ m Ni.CNiW {T• y: Ye;.:SnYs�.JI Iy_..• - _ Raw[D.E a.24CM4 1.6006 F )kb IW.blei6 ` ,1+�16ta i_-il ..�fcONGRit e[Yt 4 PLY O'LPfR R00 .FFFFg PA.OIWLMIL 'I.� rma GC !RpMr OWN PT.W 6n•WR RTYKT'° DRIP M!R r.l.W W6 Ttl rIIXY OTT.00 k c 44,1 MT% r.sso rREfW Yt R i u.O/44 FLG 6 FP. 1.1011 �FL.)eM' NNILATCN pp, ���� k FL]e.•' NGL.sTIONtr W� 1 ar•Y.)P OG � Oar.=CN CCNCRiTI Mat m 11'.9T• �1.i1.1 } �' YL,�1HA. -ly Ei_]9 M' nCA CO+CRlD �� 1 1� lNF.DER6 •'1 k", T ". ]�v��l:in re�NOr el c'1p1viu_f �l 6nrcow PAPER. > •-s. - {9�;,�. L.60.'.ea. 1r:1;.a.1 !I.t 1 e Trc BEAN -rMO6D 4LLv.IDl4 L.TN N.OG !]l]w+ 1,1`.� (])ri.)x•1 weinn I pA 41T.D0. W6!'CD%rLalIO.6K.TN0 CY T...OWL j i NOIC 001.1 44.TAW.. en•41T.OD.Te1M101�•I 1 )J SD.Rx.nND '1■�, eT.CT RfN6r.M !)1 rT)sN) FF.rtel IAl1 ] °A". }6a■A !« 4! .� COURTENAY tau a Oam61.e.O �-N D�rNAew BEDROOM �, � ,�, 4 RESIDENCE Nd�iOR.LL�D ALUM r W r Kp vXlD 4,LLv rC],LL \LAN chi a:m FLOOR.101.s R-f NYt•TICN {{II BED-..• 1��Tee OAR 6n rue 4rn eO. el6ru 4Yr.eD. IJJ r D. 6104{0441 MR -RFL.eNNn rt62 OI6A'OW41RaIX r4CRtR] t )Ma 6000 Jahn Tel d6n•DlWR0.-K OAR PM rill 'i y 6Q 6lRCT1lT4U RDANCER Art • 9 ! III WOOD fiIX ON N�'RYfsaaD bE4iNPtl ALL[ •" _N•aGw ewe.w oc YK+w roe R0.^R f I 6J.16 Cru n .i.v. D J016re r +IelccuD FLOOR k i�` Dy11.F��11�• ]J l.�'A PLATS FL 16.1 • e• M1IYUCO Ili 1 '� 1.sx':S..f.�. 1� �eeccro FLOOR + • i eEc°rm FLOOR Ir 1 6@' 6TNCnw.L DR61U.tle -CRIOET!NUN `al zx esOnt eae1J `Ir ` rua°t r rc n.rem wrt )><n.oaa uOlel_ t m 0101P.t AO. 1 ;■, rcLOCO wnaR i�tl NNOT.R.6L IN STUCCO.rMrw, 30 r ■■■ 212 BEAR BEACH AVE. aT<rx.YD. CClCR! E]N N IRArt w 6ECTKN ,! RR D.OrED 4.Lv FINAL LC4lR WIN RAY CurLfE�6e[FLOOR PLAN )>>J], urN Oa aa1 FLmR neuTN] DELAAY BEADH FL 1,I �A):76. LL6 COIO4.L 100011 R[ -u PO 141.1. AGEDA INVONAlL 16_I. " 6bLLA... IE, Nd1.1Ka1 i�. b b �sll�T-„SIN RYViEW S w_ � eJd•CHI STUD Isr STUDIO ! DECK a erg. ,�. 6n1KR.a,.1D. .7 ki i .n6rtED,w.. 1 I_--`.-eTIClO FN.! OFF6641.611.14 sTurcO rweN A ` m NAe ]r{{ua ,yA ems-m .1y ;L NV rF !l r "f e .'� FARa l� 4 ,�. T r .�5 h{ '3A�• •T � >�X 4 i A'^j R s��..4\ i �`Lee w LlKLYtI � S 1111004.1 if n DR at ' ;Ri 61....].ce r.<lD V711,4 `a VAPOR D.meReN �71b :::6 i '1, r-=?Fitiftii=f.I1T.,.;'^tom "•a; n Q. • RN Orw°l 4cia40lb dLYED TERTR n* 1[R'Lll TI¢ARD 601E MATED 601E I �. I 6R.D[N.x1leE[66111.11.11.1.) Ouvnxc Ian 1 4RIOL OVA leCE6TNCNRAU ELDle• I I IEL]T0' 1 1 WALL t �IU][RWirl 4ExIerN44R.De I I F>a6iN4cR.Oc I_ I '"�`c:+e*wo.OE SECTIONS „Ai 6R ttrOrO L�1 NFL D[YOO .uaeR CAN N.DFYvw see eTwGDnwL DImDr f\ 02.29.04 I In711/.F roe e.uel. co 04020 r e WALL SECTION 9 WALL SECTION WALL SECTION C°""""`""" � rE A4.01 W •PLY MALTA!ea.e-43 61.4•111411.11 PT ON Z AV CON RAO= 0 NOM IONACANAL OKADA* COPRA 01.11 CAIN I,be rz.... I.•• .; Nits 7 ',VAL AIANDPAlL ALMA WY I DECK 1114 VZ.V.I.PI ''''' 15 A Robert a Currie - f•11111AL 1•051 1 i FLOOR MINN A•MR oaken oven T•cb••• 11-14ACT PESIOTAR Partnership,Inc. 0. PLTD000•11.1..1 ON A.•ID AC. AL.MD"PAID AA.TOP PAW. 1 1! DJ PT.•010111•:4'ea HI OTONOTAIT TO MAT. A.A.AV OFICKADIA LAMA PANDA BRIDGE RobertArchttecolacuroiPlerewimArs& Interior Doeigners d Jess M Sowards KA i 'A."="algial ri rufrror. _ 1 Jaae N Aotta AJA .000.71 134 NL I.A.m. O..AAA n.na• ANA Mr Al 171-1.1 6 ilkl.. owl NOM•1141.111.1.0.11.11. 1,2,,,,,::,ge,,,-gr.,,,,„c.„ e LOWER DECK SECTION CALK .00161111111.0311 COCO 11•4 i PUN TO rittak•Onia0" W leci reaVX".612,N 4 41 loos R 11111111K...._ HAN 0121. A.DriSIACIDA 3 CI.A.TON WON.PAM IILVVATON el., COPP.OW.ova.AT.IA LIDVATOD MALIAN.ROO., ALNATION ALAPT rItr Palf-eiVarvollSIS° II CAT.DAP CARA PL La OrrOND ...• ORCTID INMCNO RAMA•A°OA INSTALL ANTI..MOD DT CAA 1. -__._. . AA Cot..TA WA OTIOJCAAAL D... 5 ••••1.71ACTAIAL DP.A11.0-., 1 el WALL SECTION/ELEVATION DJ BA JC411111•0..,A. 1. .1.•.01.OPJr.OAR I.T.ta.-.,'- 1 i RV `."'°•IUCCO P.1 i•PM.0.•acEO I DALV.DIA PD..2.4.4•161 AG Iill r...'"' A-L'.!.. 1M '4 A • Li 411411111 ft CPA TA gWINIC-11.11AL ir SireArl':''AIT.4004`1'7 4 MT.1111.T.UP ROCIAD 4 ) MO,.SD At A 8.1.111.11NIDAD CANAAN. .yr A , A I trla'OLP MA..WON ACCK.DOC. 4 1 ADDITICN MOOT. I,,6:1...Ai 1211 rPAINTCL 01•1•ART CCITEK FL., MA.HIN. RO,M -- RAN'AlkT•AA.2.41trA'Alll/1.1 .141.411 DOAN IAA.- T.DAM JOISTS•IV DAA I AAA,••r Of I I 1 Nede q .................-...... Jo..- .ii .......,,.. _ kw...WEE.1.1,WI 14.1..411. 6 RESIDENCE.rik.404.4.,.,gopi,,,,,55, .w25i".titMITA A 4111 Ilikk: ...WI 1,4-1. ..110.4110.41 JA016•A'OA -- 6 t'L OA DAD fic. .I I I I Aso.e•unsre 1 § A ...1.•.*Cl• ,•. l •114 .4412;10 rOMI NOLI-ATIGH : NOM 6.11CTUNAL 0.111.• I •,..Cirr.DD.DIANTID/ ItIOCO Doom.0.1.KR II i i A Mt 2TRCJ.I. ,/4. 4.....A.A.._".........".....1."'-r I 10,1 COWAN.OCTAL § lit XrADA•304•A'0 It' 1 C.O.•111.10•1 b le.11 da.iT HEULAT. Cil g. I 111.1.110.0...MUMS • la,ler•aT RANSTANT TINTDO. • 11 0. 11,04.IIA. MAHN 111,2D 11•14.10 CA ADV.DOOR BRIDGE I rAttE"`"7:3F424". I '•i CLOSET'A' ot• .0 - WT.•11111.111AL DRAIN. FON ADNECTION Dem. AD Cone...TIE AI BEDROOM I .14120 OA 2.1.4 212 SEABREEZE AVE ri.r`rualrrau,I'=rPAVOI.L\ MIA,.Nom . 00140101AL ir, NA CONC.TM I DELRAY BEACH FL g ..; • . pl FA= EL.YAW rA ''... . ..".... kAIIIIILA- --....A.A....... ........... ig - lOttie lif''it-t: '7 --•-- +ACCOND PLOON--. /I 41111/1,5 ta . VIII J7RirFc-:'' 1PIP fit Nc29 i e Iry 9i, --......f.I••,••- -- FrO•DOAS r .6.12,Or a a j 4 r.I. rsial I a,141.06 PLAN AD,E11 CCV.1.10 6 Ilk ,-- B 11.1 DATT 0AULAT. AI I.-AM•le 014 CA• NI ) 111VCCO Di DA.V.,APAIAD - ... ,,,.1-2.4.4•4111,aris.1•T.:.102.10;tot' I .L.... .0. CORM.NM ii Afffawrsv.uire..°"'"AL I PAM,.ON 11.7. OD PURAdil M.C.G. arot 1-" 1 IFSTUDIO W. 11.11,6Td• C.C.9.1 lb•*V .• 7°yucca•UAW...! all lalc4.04.11. 1 BATH . - r t (1, 201A40.!cl d o...0 INI I 07 I WALL g SECTIONS 1. 6 t , r • - EV, e - 1 .r ga •a , •WAWA.•141 ea. 1 _ o 0ig1 I I . _ l_de0i 4..2...9..2..( NADsmcna.O... ':6 . fl...:,.0..L.4 .. WAL.SECTION/ELEVATON ;:,l6.01e WALL SECTION/ELEVATION rz A4.02 Lu , • • M CV ALL i. I p Robert G.Currie Partnership,Inc. !ir„-,--in;••07 Archltecte.Hannon)& t Q wmr•a p 1 Interior Deaignera • Robed 0 Cvrie AIA _.! VIVA, Jess M Sowards MA Q 1�•nux'.•o.e •'c^•'s•"'OK Joae'NAguAa AIA enwe •••,wFr.•"- m rc••• x271 'oa''n'•.r11I 10 hoar* ',rw tY ••° IINh :�•ccg-ZUu' — Jes i. ' . -5154 1e, r•,wx.u•c.w — 2.Mai tt CAMEL rur IT •F MUM Mt Rri+a: .L ♦ nos V. •..rM40101 / t mmialMMIEBEEN.I. • PIANO maaw mrWC .• O TYPICAL LOAD BRG O 3 INT GRADE BEAM O SECTION ©SECTION tpL EXT.WALL " PI 1•40 MOCK N h ea o P «,",r W Ele IX X X E'XISTINCs RESIIDEN• X-.,X .. . COURTENAY t 1 1 I 1 1 , „�I 11,, II . .e 1; •11111 � RIM RESIDENCE .1114171777.41.14 IMO I I I I II I I I Wlr MT;w i 41)SECTION ©TYPICAL SILL / '"'"'" e,rtwv s O•cu•. e• LI i mrt'w•. i .� u ® Ii�•'cu\l, ,:.tI MLOW a..• gib' � . o .�.`r _ /i o �`7 r-1 rd.•'; .lt(1 m �r�n if • IN OMo.4 I —J t.•n t,...&Nan 212 FALV F7F AVE W E.:.°. !Ii! DEuuv a CH FL It. 1 , .• #101..:„I I IkI —�—� 1 i �1 i SECTION 0 r n�r—�_ _�p1 id ©ELEVATOR PIT O .• ,r••x. � I j- //� •xsnw fau3r xr��n°crclafl TO EDGE . //)—i l---_g,, I 9 1 ® �I /�/ H ion•m m0iiu a MM.. / -11- �I 01 d / °u x•uo•ac•u•••WOW // I I b I I 1 4,cs.e I I C/..// > 2015101c 01105.1C MU I%• fed II I 1! I I I 1 I-1 /511 AY. FOUNDATION ..9 Il --_ __ i-- i- i ro=� /wde.>, / g PLAN+DETAILS H -- --ram L---1, —' ® M ° gi OM.PI _ .. 1f I 07N29.01 IIJC "1 ' ..v' FOUNDATIONPLAN rwool CONNECTION °"" M.I.InG5 0 e w � Z 7' --' u uuiru4 prer ra ao.o•aa � va.rtnux VOA"TM /�-�L. d Y 1 mw'OA.� "' �1°I r ,025 4 f Robert Q.Currie ,..".'p ' G,n ` . 1'0 ,.r.e4•oc 2r'n o'�oW x•a Partnership,Inc. ,..r wmu ! ( InteArcrioroDesigners re 8 d o.+fi"'o+ *"wr maa '•� &� exO.,w:'o'.c'r' Robert SowardsJess M Currie ALA 2TM MI 274.051 rv,e.c .l ae NApuile AIAL0002 � eSy xS..,n'"o"l: „ 0 SECTION CONNECTION e SECTION el CONNECTION1205251002415.00- LW 6 SECTION emu.. v.,r.r a.�,, ,..,.r ,�.. ,...„ KK., ,...r.r �,am,w ao5 le swn a)f..a. � e.a mnI 50.2 AV PrO . .. ..I8rg►�6tati ola -` :'—tip. 1Iii19i�11'�1'�1 li� wrartr b It )y� wc''u'ra W'.a oc n,xko rx.uo. L� 1 �mc.n ��•�' uIII .O x^ r. .._00SLOOPF..rr a a COURTENAY ` RESIDENCE SECTION e SECTION m.�., o EXIST.BLpG. m rx1911149 101 yDgTWN II rw.4.5520 01100d na 41 4410124.1 *,'te. Z ' .\ ••v rcwa �..ao .. �.eca+o FLOOR Nui o ill 1 n'r� 2.2 i ;o a•ry'ra. 212 FEARFEEZE AVE ox.,w �u.. x�� rau L �._.-_.�._1 vx aiY•uo.�uuv s•vbm y1 +iflpi ' ry. `w� �,it_ 1. gIi 1 f r o o" .C.041�M0.� xW raa -✓ le_ II 4 I : o,na..n ®. 0. !ruan t" x n�o� ` mrtsu. .u. N... e,a.,u..vac� n e CONNECTION ,41,4114/4‘‘Nlit:&\. •I'l Hq , ....., OWin,lx�aau . ro w..or c d "`,;.4 ��-., wnwnr,rua C- I j ,w ro cc. w�w w.nn.. �e.caa Koon �'•��• �����, , a •o 1® ���04. ��r ,J'� 20i oi0u ♦••••••••••••��•••♦ ... x• w.a ��4 X3 1 ' `A1 l .. ,sue SECOND FLOOR 40, a I y t�'�'` _ '.,i�'���p 4,'b +DETAILS FRAMING LAN i Li\ WWII §'I IIIL -'-. Ill 451A [7:1) q!��Ir ► i ��� FLOOR FRAMINC3 PLAN ,0.12,.a„o az04 xert awa;x•n.neccr MAL 4•1"u,i.a.w .�uw R� NET UPLIFT�IAG�AM w'r�e"'x•''OA4L'O101T 14F3`L. S2.01 • CeAgr ExIvnIM sane M.wunou y CI Al e • i grre, 6—An. ...4.11, iw ear. - AOlc:ruxvrcR ��II nrnvr Robert G.Currie R iwa xorrzm u. E ArcNtects W aliv �. i;` Interior Designers & n,,.rr rlli v au it Robert 0 Currie ALA �Wt.t,ex u uro,e Jess LI&awards ALA III .J°..171 Apia ALA Deroeel e..m Ile.. M.Tnr eel vr.'.�ii.1 fS CONNECTION CONNECTION 2 CONNECTION SECTION D Puuv ov»o. <Drmm 7. • k'wx ...IL.'DIG Wenx r•s x wi�«mc ,••� mw.Ia•o.e an,r SELL . — }G!r'aea G� �ill �. a. m � I wo T ' On. � . irMi ae.re wiiYlp vco hill i t �I COURTENAY O CONNECTION O CONNECTION O CONNECTION RESIDENCE 8 6 SECTION .�,: aw•.re .�,. v•.rr esmi 0 EXIST.BLDG. KV �®_ ^,w-r'o ry Cl..v°"'.:a b •'r % Y7i°cs'. �"�"."mil"•c,P?2.^�...a" �00e0 wcnx.wiuw �Ipit � wm,. /milorAirinr,l r �o®oo ®moo Q ,",..IeG .........:...e,. 0 I , ���® 2 { wnlTu"YL •t0 I,.L ijI We NY Tw�f III Ill l..lIi sem moo®o EA FEZF 1 � 2128 Ff�—AVE L°•,r � 'ij' ., °°°a���°'llna.slu00lIII 1.1 ... '��eor�r. evw R DEIAAY BEACH F� YVI rr Y.'M•D.,.'mK �l j ''I"" ell ✓.cc TYCM n, r: e T ta, �,LA.'Iffy isle'RT iae,'PS CAM OHM. P�•mxTuomm TO.0141, Tn.RAT ROOF smav n nvw toe RMS.. .we..•ae 1,14.1.11.O. 1-rI-Po TN REVIeW' �,,,mµy !�aiiI uu1 nll6fl;llllllln1111119 IS to m CafmnA - nncv 1 Il ORMI.U. ��p a ii lid lllln(IubU7�''I'IIIIIIIIItlIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIi11111111111111111111111111111171iN1111!1lnt 1. 1mJOlIl i,lnl mill 1.✓)!ill(y milt ni..'III@nPgi14911uluwuogl I III141111';IVmllgmji9ui4�litlnx ,1iN nnlnlgn¢}C nf; 6 SECTION I.1► ei _ J� r 1i a IL , lilll e Ui amp i yg3$&' C.1_,.� e��/, p(1111111 ni'tIicl:.l,; t C - I ELEV.ROOFf114!i :� i'I�1' k 10 mD ro.D, FRAME PLAN T. Ail ierr%0i; ' Ii �4 \_.m;',�. �ly�0. IIII� :i; QQ u �,xx�J of .'�rC, '..01,�,� i' u�'NI ,. E. g u-0 a �,r�o ROOF FRAMING e —a l ii I f a ��sn g PLAN t DETAILS .D.te $ �gili g , g ,rll!Vligl .0 WC'g. �JrlA Ol r. o W. 'l%•WI'•..—.�'Ir,, a t nrmuHnmm�nlma �II ROOF FRAMING PLAN uivannnne I 07.29.04 11711 0 1 I1i15 I nm UPPER ROOF FRAMING PLAN r,D.NuEreart 4020 nDus v.•ro .cus vr•10 ��ii 040201 dl • e DR+�nHI NuuB[. ' M- 33.01 • •• 1 RIOTING 07(]T! KW A.bit iwmr -w C. j nrsr• _wio8 r 'ar]m]emu» ""-" :r]2•'i♦•a rvw, I MaM Robert G.CUrrle .,COWS WMw{JO rparWYYrm WM�UM Wti M,r Tor run artnershi ,Inc. _,._ .- M,]r "� ! I •W S.S Architects,Flamers 6 oa,Tw i-'�'cg'S:.icui►�'y'w '1 W,, a• rou Vs. • wrw TM Interior DesIgnera u v. .1Mrw'•,rt [ [ M,a Robot o Club AIA • Jess Al Sowards AIA Jose'N Apulia AtA Dway .a no.. u.1 r R. 27.051 iw5' + CONNECTION ©CONNECTION CONNECTION ©SECTION 111. 1-moll. q. ,u1.1001.0C.�r O.cullly u.•-r-r O O rau,. ua•r-r O v„ ua.r•r 003 ION PD�a gmb" prrW�wa MnN POurt 0).1Y.O{ 00000.11. 10 OM wwcrna Wmx •P W W 11...m MN. {� M,O•W QC N rt w �}� 5[IL iY� •..... • 'v..roc �11�iWYi All „A„ A rr I nra•,w Pun t3A III PUH■ONrU I 1 Ali ` «w>4M, r• v"'aw V C. it ^\/ WUN re i .� I rou I 1 • b �i y b 4 MAR MI 1 COURTENAY O SECTION 0 CONNECTION e CONNECTION O CONNECTION RESIDENCE v_u,� u.•.r-r ur.re rcx,. u.•-r.r CD rcua. u.•.r.r i . e + EXIST BLDG wcw u..Twn ua. •o IMP �'.,, • =MIL.. ©�®© p I�I d ®0©0© z v x • I[ •—• ••TQP-1"7 ..I,R'r WUrW , 1, •. ®©©©� 4 �M�10�. U 1Y TYCW ii a —\,l!1.1,1 i:i 96110912101/1 UM. A 0©©0© raF1G AVE n un r., [�. /� �1-''., ..,..1 u wwr .2 } eortm o aten DELRAY BEACH R. y ,al In•iM'W r ,],,.r PP ,]M••,YJ »•Y� QOM rrP]a�Kr �TW •T4MW uYMNYLi PN 'TQ Ii.�r lrOCl lDri COiTMpeWr PtMfgMSQaruu. 1 VIMI r141. 1W6;gtlOWMIIilmar 1 ' r I! mair enn4ange m Haskekcawn.gamige a p I n�aN evRw SECTION I CI'. I M 1110011Q� !: ' , ■ nor rso•a Il. +wqF i1 PI , II NI 'Qlr�p'I'li&W�NITJ�IIdgA1n10 i. • ® \/ __ur 1111411:�' �� rr ® i— � I4rdrO� a'�� 0 'i �J' nii ;;;; 9 rcu. u.•-nr F Y 0 MLrY I i . LLwr !ill I wx irifIc leirpir,i‘l t — 4 w•Wu �a 1 �,m• m iv 5 Parrw.vac III 1 i ELEV.ROOF /' ..• , oMt rAME PLAN �, .M• FR i PrAi �' :�pG�r \_ s a +'' 2o�s�o�errs ..r %� I� ,.J� wuw , Y• ®� • wuxw Tmt U ./ ii W rr,FW TMGa/ �Q }y� /,•► T +'8 . I__ /"I� ' �ru�' F nrl`'�o d�� ROOFFRAMWQ SP r - r\. �I Tl I(1L�1. ��u.+nwr 0).°a Itiv..4' PLAN+DETAILS 000 81 1.1111,4 \44 $• 1 ]1:::7JA:RYIR�1� ~i I 07.29.04 I 7C712.1. e p �; „,-,siheo ',,, ROOF FRAMING PLAN UPPER ROOF FRAMING PLAN �. 1. a u,w • urw wur °G "'"4 ■� r.-ro 0+0201 0 O.. D..Wuuou • S3.01. • • / / SPLIT A/C UNIT SCHEDULE • cce oro W ",ol, 12 /g/� 11 • runnw ��NPRLr COO T0UI.CC0 Nc r 4 N[mR"oVO.ATOR ROUND OM ...[..a[c.0 15� turn N / 6 eta FAN/'COL$RCT10NTrTrcR 030 [ Robert a rrie ,A TREADED RDD .'%rt. M,,,,ND �IN WW1. 004.Fe� •Rcl,. Perinerehlp unc./ WiDN[AS.MTrr D oDCV r1 rM�nw w00/::nM H urz 00A, AreNted4 P oersro 8 ,/.•MAAR. e9a•CGIDCN9Arz DR.IN CNt« Mlerior Deslpnend O 9Y NNS nmrn RAC DRt rn r. ,w.rz aR,.D w[ST "" IRTc, TM[cT Robert O Currie AIA 111A11111 b>x,+ r.un w[TADT/rnrt• 9mn 9uA Jeee M Sowards AR --aaroT.MS COL Ga WIT.). 9 v Jose'N Apulle ALA A O0WT11 WC M.SW. RoOn rau,IBS a 9/I,5 9,'.9 11,.x 1N A«.v IMI CCNOTNTAIT MIN a/. ,A 1t 5Su D.4ae1 1.4 nx0fo: 1_ PROS.11. 011.i[041.001 MD GIST.n[CT 9w. ��nT[x Fm HEATNO CA.ACIT6F MUM [..mm. ROCIOCu RICI.COY T1011 MO B.PROS.TM MW TA.. 9. N.vAL.TCx G AOTY RnM 00001 o 0.00300103 [,■ 000 AA `rx�`ca CONTRACTOR. MM.ITME 1 TLi[iw Kw/B.A./0 "n30/ OM COL r.RWr aT.9o.D. CABINET CEILING FAN AIR HANDLING UNIT MOUNTING DETAIL .. a ' \ MCI.J x.T.9 &IMA 5 J CONDiN5INO SECTION• T• _... CONSTR... ArvM •FTRID RMt CDfO . COOD 20)1.1032 '• • 27 ' VOUD UN[T x'a� BIB 0/�[ 9CAL 0/1 • G RR.NO TVI a (Ffs,.r.A. 1D ID 30/1 µ°'1/' SjW.R/r /OASEAS o,0/1 /0TS1.0 n 0/1 IA 9 1., ., IL . 13 •NnMSN 1 rACTORY wSCCNNTCT CIRCUIT M AXUS ••N.0WAR 0YLICIIRRTN11110rz011011 .••CAC,.CIRCUIT A [ Tn nit[ p PRON0[AND INSTALS 5RDCR0000 NTCTROR0 n1a1N09TAT. RCOURTENAY • RESIDENCE i • j II II • _ ...�.._.__..�-_....� q II-n It _ II II .._ 212 BEABRFF7F AVE z -1i C �I�1.= DELRAY BEACH FL II E V.iW II II .ANIMAL• REVISIONS t • r II rir1. 1 . II { ,,' /1°:' R� 10.or1 &di w F �.� GwR1Nc m1T■_ j �.� FIRST AND .T 4 �I - �•".".� ��.�� - a SECOND LEVEL g . r M ... .� • o I �.� MECHANICAL PLANy� YR.. .rt.CALL A... w.wS C w aOOR Ot07.29.0t I JC mL____ ����7 / , cur.nlu rm.cvO RV Ono. ■■1." 1......"......111111 AOe ..nv c1n • u0 "e.1..MC� "°"a•0 co 0F0201 •FIRST FLOOR MECHANICAL PLAN H SECOND FLOOR MECHANICAL PLAN b DRm. S N.E.CR VC.To 65 M1.01 DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application Part 1 —Evaluation of Property Eligibility Read the attached instructions carefully before completing this application. Your application cannot be evaluated unless it is complete and all required supporting materials are provided. In the event of any discrepancy between the application form and other supplementary material submitted with it (such as architectural plans, drawings and specifications), the application form shall take precedence. Type or print clearly in black ink. If additional space is needed,attach additional sheets. GENERAL-INFORMATION(To be completed by all applicants) 1. Property identification and location: Property Identification Number(from tax records): Attach legal description of property Address of property: Street � ''. S t` A 13 p it F x I A V f • City IJ ram-i„ 4%.1 B l;(4..c t.( County la ivy, _A c 7-i Zip Code 3 4 8 3 ( ) Individually National Register listed (:61Locally designated historic property or landmark* ( ) In a National Register district ( ) In a locally designated district *For applications submitted to the Division of Historical Resources, attach a copy of the local designation report for the property and the official correspondence noting the property owner of designation. Name of historic district , R 1 • For locally designated historic properties or landmarks, or properties located in locally designated historic districts,provide the following additional information:Name of local historic preservation agency/office //��!_i,L o-c b E L 1Z r4..11 7-3 G'ii-c.7+ Mailing Address 100 o ('J , U'• j '-r A V - 1.1 u y City )T L R,tit„ E tic pi State '1_ (O rL t 0 4 Zip Code 3 4 L¢L/ Telephone Number(S1,1) o:i 9 3 - 4-Z 8,-1 2. Type of request: (PlExemption under 196.1997,F.S. (standard exemption) ( ) Exemption under 196.1998,F.S. (exemption for properties occupied by non-profit organizations or government agencies and-regularly open to the pubic) If applying under s. 196.1998,F.S., complete Question 9 on page five. 3. Owner information: Name of individual or organization owning the property F iZSk l,..J k., 4. V 1 la-C.' i ry I p, �C)V iZ-�-r�� 1 Mailing address oR t as S p "lS rz.a l 'x, L 11- 1/ , City E'I-CZ 1= E/ic (-f State 1 O tt t b x) Zip code 3 L{E - Daytime Telephone Number(-57)) (0 ^ 9 3 y If the property is in multiple ownership, attach a list of all owners with their mailing addresses. DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Two—Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application Property Identification Number Property Address 1= 'b L `A I= v r b F_ t_ tt.:i-rq 4. Owner Attestation: I hereby attest that the information I have provided is,to the best of my knowledge,correct, and that I own the property described above or that I am legally the authority in charge of the property. Further,by submission of this Application,I agree to allow access to the property by representatives of the Division of Historical Resources or the Local Historic Preservation Office,where such office exists, and appropriate representatives of the local government from which the exemption is being requested, for the purpose of verification of information provided in this Application. I also understand that,if the requested exemption is granted,I will be required to enter into a Covenant with the local government granting the exemption in which I must agree to maintain the character of the property a the qualifying improvements for the term of the exemption. V )'IZ t p l ti) #'14 C1 1-4 fJ �v Name S•`na• re Date Complete the following if signing for .n org.nization or multiple owners: Title Organization name EVALUATION OF PROPERTY ELIGIBILITY (To be completed only for properties in historic or archaeological districts): 5. Description of Physical Appearance: Ss vvs4 G iA S Cam, ,s�-r��,.�-�- �n�� S � 9 80 1ST •F kcDor.. A A) l C4-'� l 4/l ,U I 1, ,s T i\,/i C��S t q .• C F4 it-Art/ `C Date of Construction / f s S' Date(s)of Alteration(s) I q 0 Has building been moved? ( )Yes ( tKo- If so,when? 6. Statement of Significance:) S1 1= G a., D \� � iU Q i—+���J)5:8S 9(11— Q OJ T \\_52 \oLIA, S o y1/4.44 ct. v� �,� - DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Three—Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application Property Identification Number Property Address / S i= 7i E. v 7. Photographs and maps: Attach photographs and maps to application. DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Four Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application Part 2—Descri tion of Improvements (To be completed by all applicants): Complete the blocks below. Include site work,new construction,alterations, etc. Property Identification Number Property Address . 9a 5 E I -;i C.ifiZ "Z G AVE-. De'. R ti t„ :'j� Feature 1. r Feature /}D i T r a IL) Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx.date of feature K-%42. -7 Describe existing feature and its condition: oq STa ( 14 pi-A.) i)i G;% �3- +j :t-tc i.+ n Cp Y►V14-e"r p cry-, cou-r C Zrx'f I .t-L cr 6, $ 'o ' c�4> i-s-,ss w at— 1 C7. F LOC 0- Photo no. Drawing no. Feature 4-i;4.,t y ! tA1 c V p e W y Fla L e9 Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx.date of feature qr c Describe existing feature and its condition: P t-r'ciz to y�'7 c a 3 `�1 WI- ISIlT► ^-' t w ��c��r LA; 1 w‘c-1-- I k' Photo no. Drawing no. Feature A r.. T ; >_ E 1)4 ez. Pa_A.r.eis Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx. date of feature i Cr s s' Describe existing feature and its condition: (O I y I woo • ' 'c t r'9 5 r i Lc 't7 j p 33 :.1fCiS t I N E. Photo no. Drawing no. DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Five-Historic Preservation Property Tax Exem.tion Application Property Identification Number Property Address 2 fa e f V e J ELT a A-tip a.PC II , FL • Feature 4 Feature Cj it • sv 0,L (Lc., Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx. date of feature 1�, fa_g_ e Lp-GE �c ,C 1ST ) X Describe existing feature and its condition: wn o (per.? C D L U vr,r� 411 ZO? `k. GuLrvt. ( 7 V /AssocFArf.() i.JttiDo F= 2 rr w ' G AS ti ti ri 0 z () Photo no. Drawing no. Feature 5 j Feature l'A1 f'E0 r- c �! e— C}i uc45 Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx.date of feature ao 0 T F 00 r ALL f • C- . Describe existing feature and its condition: �L-� T Roo F) tic- � � I c F A f'► �Tc rL G OPP4tt Gu;icrtc5 14 (S-t-Os �- ` 4 ' b`s:7 ioc2. /t- rtor� ,opewz_ Photo no. Drawing no. 0 (� O N t� ice/ i tZ G.. i � < s Feature 6 Feature a T.-LP ILO O ' - Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx.date of feature' I e(q& . PlA- C u-/ ")« Sri I-' . Describe existing feature and its condition: l 4rn^i S-S cam-� 4atoc-vv`r49 Photo no. Drawing no. DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Six—Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application Property Identification Number Property Address 2 / SF A fe- `7 f > 1 - E L TC-A-t„ 75 t`«C /f Feature 7 Feature j)�C.<<_• IL)C;<-3-14 S i 5•€. Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx.date of feature j q g, i U 2-00 Describe ex isting feature and its condition: WQA t wv a J ak _ ZooD woo 6_ssoc p0_fj , ,vAGet_ Photo no. Drawing no. Feature 8 Feature P \i Lt t.1 f L f-t/•1T K `XOX FS Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx. date of feature 1 1 3 t' z s • 7 `- Describe existing feature and its condition: 0. 9- Sl—f►I t.2 -.fJS5 (tee w oV - Photo no. Drawing no. Feature 9 Feature Describe work and impact on existing feature: Approx. date of feature Describe existing feature and its condition: Photo no. Drawing no. DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Seven—Historic Preservation Pro.erty Tax Exemption Application Property Identification Number Property Address '12 Property Use(To be completed by all applicants): 1. Use(s)before improvement: 1= 5 t n v-;- 2. Proposed use(s)after improvement: 5.5 I b',&_3 f j ii L- Special Exemption (Complete only if applying for exemption under s 196 1998 F S.(property occupied' by non-profit'organization or government agency and regularly open to the public): NOTE: Applicants should check with local officials to determine whether or not the exemption pr'gram offered by their municipal government and/or county allows the special exemption provided by s. 196.1":,F.S. 1. Identify the governmental agency or non-profit organization that occupies the b ' s ing or archaeological site: 2. How often does this organization or agency use the building o chaeological site? 3. For buildings,indicate the total useable area of the bull.ing in square feet. (For archaeological sites, indicate the total area of the upland component in acres) square feet( ) acres( ) 4. How much area does the organization or .-ency use? square feet( ) acres( ) 5. What percentage of the usable ar-. does the organization or agency use? 6. Is the property open to the .ublic ( )Yes ( )No If so,when? 7. Are there regular h..rs? ( )Yes ( )No If so,what are they? 8. Is the property also open by appointment? ( )Yes ( )No 9. Is the property open only by appointment? ( )Yes ( )No DOS Form No.HR3E101292 Revised 09/03/00 Page Eight—Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application PART 1 APPLICATION REVIEW For Local Historic Preservation Office or Division Use Only Property Identification Number Property Address �V"Z••• • The 44 .ocal Preservation Office ( )Division has reviewed the Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application for the above named property and hereby: (.Certifies that the above referenced property qualifies as a historic property consistent with the provisions of s. 196.1997(11),F.S. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property does not qualify as a historic property consistent with the provisions of s. 196.1997(11),F.S. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property qualifies for the special exemption provided under s. 196.1998,F.S.,for properties occupied by non-profit organizations or government agencies and regularly open to the public. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property does not qualify for the special exemption provided under s. 196.1998, F.S. • Review Comments: \ . Additional Review Comments attached? Yes( ) No • Signature • Typed or printed name e• • Title Y l` (fir Ke Date . i t• j�jtt r• • .,e-.. f! k•11 tC k, vt� z� � 1,t��yry 1I .l :,:.:::::',,::::'114--7;111-..-,.....:,—_,:i:L.._'':,*_::' r�y1 I.r•r.;-,z}11',., •, -• ,r, \.• y , ,,y ' '� /,1-"„Y',-.f ,,1,. } 3 ,a� f,p'wyf ypi�` f.Jrj• /'s tir , *, 11 .;.. --,«Yr' �'�; .i:a.J„r,r£ r G.f' '1. <.} �'': .. 7'w i "'" .,, .a. k, ,t«' "4a + . . 5..,.,,,1'. :. '' r `'�?'�'r�w'�Y'`� :1- �1 't:� f I '^.iZ� `.Y` } r' �\r,P",, e"" ..;�. . ' `.: : t t^-� � .1ih r •g::, .; // ,' � :y y.'( .,. t7 . ''' :fl- ', ,,-. w f`' i.%,.\, i leN rl .` I< 3 !t.--, "1 > '. . -r %/j ,�,"'#, r_;�lt \;`'�.,.•.. `.i 7�,r. t t.;�', 1y�r4i. . t » . : ":yl. ''. 1i.:i' y'_ sow !r "i ...�j'l`.' • L ei flt\ g :4 �1 k �' { •� / :C< �. ��q!+ /:�,,,,,, i x !e x%'k r,,i, .`J: v/' ks:., :ififi ' ..., ? t ivy t ''67'a' y\ ii J8 :•', �. t\>� ✓ t>• '` !,'t5;.;; . v,. �;:! l ,r^.. ''. is 1. „ / , A • ,'' . .,' `, ys k. ,,,,x "s}y £..,1� rs .�>�` r 1. .i a -*,:• R �`•e - i .i 5 �'` •'i \ + .r i •y'�Y3�1,�' r r 1� \ / L; ,f `,.,, y. e� .t 'T ,4 �•k ,.l Zs rtA i.� i'„#`. i' y7. ;i\\ :��r�l i' �f a~..f .'• �f ''. ' i... kIra:41:` � � ` ` j is 1;2! F, 1r t F t..,.a S„C L� - r F.17 ` ". f ^ ;.1 s t'i'k�.i;. 1.. t +++any, ' ' z {I , `�/ 1 f ., t' y h:� i''' t + ,` r f 1' '•-° L -�,`x..7 {} Fi7''=.:;.• +,j i+r,r"' ip °' �_: �, �:i ti S✓.+,r`,:yk3,.„.di i� 1; •i st, 1A, � ,� , yz --a11 r' a � � �-,• � ) 'h's .. r� ..• ,��//r !� r i,,z /fit' ::F,,c 'k r,y, .,# w • r 1<� _ ✓ ,:�.:=. 4 } p .ti ,1 e@ " Ss��v a b,t. 1 • r" y, tir ? r -:`�:.�"�... ",.� ��1.^. .•i yr ,�j.; , '>M•'w, 1 's:: 7 .^ f �� . t +'Sjfr '3! - rfr ` = '*`�• .`v'"t•.. d � � ,,, ` 1 1�` :.: 7 S•` . '`� q v l r`.if�'G' :-). A� • r 'o". t� ,{?°`x"w" ,.',' � •,�' ,, j } i r!1 ,," \F'. ,.`., '� r3 ♦� � ` _ '?' *Mc' �';,'b:t . �� {;.,,� °a ,.�� `'^ �'..'`-., �fi�t r . � �� r ��s?..' �� i1 .t •st, �?Y1 lt��k1 •� { ''' ,•5. 1t� �`+f�c .`,� rf<x ot .,i. ,r ;r'< : ,tt' '� -,y '►„ f st. d:. 3 ,E+" ':, }F• ` \ 74' *�",,,\� tty . P. r sc" `;J .,r't ,?r f rtrite,: a n ��x Y � i. � , 7 FF A { j s., n�:y3 .,�""�. '',.~ a„ ,`1 f 'X.. k'.,r 0.r it 44, ,�i:.. t °v{' " z7 ;i',i '"'...,. Y,+, `Lr:;: 5. \.1'.' _ ¢• .:ta a� ,) ��w"+ m'• X.�. 'e .r let . r ,1. 1•+, 3 .�.,,'`.'".. «k e g -:# };.--.h:� (5 r 3 i; .k. !Ay �'t,y'�, ' „ k ✓;It, .. e : ^, !�•4,10.' '. t� �~.H`.m'; .,„;4., •, .1,0":41 ��...'`•"�'-�~'• .,...,;�w..! K. >,Ir S'. i ',., y ,, ;r ,;' , .;r~`' ,:r} z i .,' i > a �""e,`§ ,a..✓ :* } .. y .. r w� • q, � •: .,Y� x tx+N..: g:=) '< it'A• F • �,. 2q� •1 <l .,-'t, r .�"., e''474 1' �i j et' tR.� ?; :\i T.v,., 1: ,S" + c l. _f .'''', 1 }, , ' v : ( `:i. x. " .•S• tir xE '�",:.'ilk 4 ,. .. 4. . ` a. q f' .1•'-'•,'^�'�..t,",}�+• ,,,i,,,‘, 1�;{ 1 thy, j.' .r": .,, .,,, - «� ,. 1, . ^`.v?!v �• ., <„`•,t%<• ,YY'v" w•,, ? , � A 's4i* x� L ,^C• 3, , ` '' i, Y .�,, ! .} r,.t: *, `_E} �'e y; x*j:t p.ff.� b , +'^'� .,:i y t rn,*^'"y'.P t ---- N,' • e,, ,,i,, ., li. ; .�' • 1 '4 •5 C� 4"; +: y� ,sr .{ 7. ',.. • . •y , �' _d p . '=e• L•� . .a ��,� x i��,tl� , � � tt _ �, � '-•,�\•�� • �a�r �S .�`, t �,B P���'t��ii��a r j�f"" � r�T 1 "w.. (, �� r�' . vim v. _ �x a' •+,� v'.A �' ,� 3" lA.+`.^ ! ':_S1 • \, '- , i y !' ° t. ar :r"e .> .• A'''... � s.iCt r"-` ,ff st + •'"• 1 1 f ; :� : f 7 t72 f. ,lc yj s �L riW " - ��r ryW, ri''4 t •4. 4 !F! M,g . '%' :2 }1 1 '!. ` & #' T ;'.1 ,..,.?.. Z ',..'. ;.11‘• t ...< ... m �;` �'�� f^ � ir.. • 4. s� ��i"c.•?�,^�.,�.7�'Y .'� � p { � 1e ,Cp. s��'1 ��% • ���" aA .�1i� �t�, ♦1 7 ,$ F` •Y7 7R1 ram_ . e- -,;, (. - „ 'f 'I ' �„-;, ,A 1,`• , t ' - . c , - �' {7 • tt d A!" Y � >� � ,.m' A`+ '' ', r • "r ,,',, PP r,r mfi a ,, c �f � 1 a � whet" �w „yp k c_ ' ,Yt sr t„ zl }T'Alt",:Y t\ • r , • \ , \` '` ks ` i-; ! , I r ti :1\'' p::".' ifr » 1 ki ii r, �� ' : �1, f \'t t, ,....-„,„,-,441I,tcyf'kg'4, i*i {{'.is < �l: i t�1�' R<. t l_,i 1 '��.IY „' V F 4i i y e.��t ....... ,i7 I ,,,,,, oi 4. ) j/ l * 'f L S 4 ' �'} '4 !/ f `�"' �`r !41 kip}� �t,�,,L, iY'r'•d Y!y 4'4 Nt Y i N1 .Z • 's 1 ''+,A �„"`SSS _ + `'l,,. ? d�� ,. .., tf R * t'' , _. _..�.-_ — ter nomi.�,,.t - _. r7�r•p� ' g r,, r i"by d4 ..':::.. 1,7 n+ _� E� ;:... ,t - -- -g- ..+ ,.- { ' t p �.��r<- t �`, ,,,�"""".�+m�e ��{��µry' lj1, �( " �a..` . .-:..�...,�,� _ ,�! `IIY.Oh .e^.r.��\w....�'M�j 1 S 4�6 {'�Y AYd z3 '.S.,'.vyyi� t�.e- ,. .L _`7— <: ..,_1rjY .� .fix—r, 4• l\wrt.r1 u, 't' (.. S�~ s "Fr: - , ism -----..-.3 --..--r_.,,,�)2 "/ V ...ate ,,,~` ``-:; R�^:.;1. t, It ',' *"t' �'{� A'is .}� � �', � 4 �,a]tlOY.,—y �' :\�^� I l .�.», f<�1' �r. 1'.i���wE.� C ;,� r 4 4 I ' � � �s-' alFil � f � .� �__.,.. py,., �.r� Yt+ `^`.,�,�`*,,..,:,.�5 r ,�1�$v'r�� h' S ,:,g• ' !1t .. ....,....„............, „, , ,,,„ a .......ws..wiw..w.. ,t'C ._. .. ...i.n,�.•.+.• .`. `.. .J ,4,4%r j .....,......w . n, , .....<. ..,,.. ... � t ,..r..r.......... ar".... 1 bti ii ""'".....:L...""''."*"."'"""."= - .-- _-- --_-,7_.:„_=,....„,"'""'"'",„,::`,.' X ,...1,*4 zg .,, 4 , \ , ••,..,..„)„,.; vt. .....--.7.--...7.7....---ti....- ,---. . - -- z.;.,.......J !, :.:1 ., i ,.'- 1 .:x.i. ,.. „ . . ., ,., i . \,..,,c... .. ,. ,� � R+.eR apt �; '-;t 4 4 r.. s �'n+«� ,.,., i, + • yj' 7. ,{ j. .r .n.- ..r i. 1•,-'-' ' i,'''y ° ;.$--.*,!.'f try<°.;' •'k'.*", "'"'"•"''''k r„.'* ' 'i"''''' . 4 °-�• . ` 0 °¢ r f .4 - tag ' �;o • A"^' ...,.ber • 1 R✓ �Cr�'� , " , 1 0/ 1 1 / 200 1O/ 11 / 200C ,,, . 1 �tea _,. .,,,,,.: '74-7;,,,,,,,,,„...._._ ..„,,....._ ,, ...V‘ ,. r \;,..„791, .,,, qi , ././,.1.,.) . ,> .,,,c141,v.,,,,,,. ,A•e, , .. . ,, ,.... i, 4/. ,•", ,," ,,,, ,,,••• ./ , • , . if t.. \.,. ,„. ,v,/ . , , .,„ , ,,„.„. , „ ., „„ ., . . .„ •,,,,,,,,,, ,,,•.,:,,,:,,,,, -...1 • . ,. ..., A IA,4,1,..;,,,,, N, -%--- ..'•'' -----------'' —,-"'"'•<,,,'„,....,..,,--;:',.. ,q' ' • ‘--,,t,'.'-. •':: •,:`,:.':',‘"..<:',:::,:'-'-':-i-- ' ' '::.:..''' .••• ' mopillt,W 4 ..n.q -_ ,is ,�% --�'—�",,--— , ....iji, 1: 119- ;.1.,:,-'-'---- .'-'•-.. -•- - .' — ' ' ' ' " Gar+ r� , ! , ,,. r� . . Rom/`- �,.•"-' Y 1. z,•"'/��„ % f �. # j - _....'��,�•"" (� ,- .4-4 is' .i��..•^�""�r —.••: ,�..•^-"^•'•'.gin a • IJlJ r f; ,..'fi t �•�-^'" .y "� r. +..•;..� ram:--;, I . x A,,,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,,,, 'b:. " t t''$ r It t .s � �+R //' • s rk �. ., a i ,.... } . z t , Eli t}�y"Erya }t s r' ' ` s , d -'�bs �• R •`'c ."Srl' �r a i " na s a - _ '��i *� .+i y {a s , .t a o F • s .. 3«a Z '„�* Kq'` S' ' '4''',ry': • to r, • ' Jt iag 't ili Sa J . t. i`d.+R� '" o- r e f,. ° t{ g 1', € 3 � : '• s ' 0; �;ice• •S+Q"y 4ix+,R� r .-x{ �' " Y! ,a,. fd - S �` : Y I " ;I` 4` 'r ^il' .;:, r". r ,„t ty'1:$ R'' ..y�. • t,y t'*� ,t «a. y,.�kf ,4' p.'M e ,zr w. TO...,' .:13 § ' :s .. • '.:,N1 t 4' '4 ,.r•s4, A 7 ''. "0'' ar'�°' x;' '', ....l' .i, EE d!a 1 F a at. ' ' y 4'* a '..#>Y, , pain. ••,• ,, .,3n ,i .. ,. gar" .''N �>• m '4i k : d',•.F 3. i 0: '•', •a '; '"t t h.< e'�R♦ • • +fw "' S.x tl, • 3f S J [4.4g0.$L D4P' • F :.E'` ` r ..� • a'i� F` S9•••..�Y.t 1,r. >` }..:"' E^ Y r,?. i pint q;A. .. '`�,t ...w l is ,-* I . +.ter t�"f t ..r f JM'-N.,.a a��.�Yl4.�"t ' ." 3 w � £«.�• ..a'�i y�j.,. �'¢ Ii, fyrfi �f',� �}�;,. a�.t't*,:�,a� 'x �~' w �' t`ti�c .x t � ). '.. ,: • t� �:'� y .C. i, w 5:•',. elfy ,z a`"r ;' .:;.t.�! f; ' �. � .. , r .« C' ^`fir�.' }" }xs k's' 'y.. k k k�. a w ..{ « e, .i�+3 {eq aA» �.• 0y • w ...fir a. ire ,A e`i � .a'.,. ?5'h . '�.y x'� .� ,.,'. .� ,ra,# .,•H• - >�F'� 'f+ tYt: Y.. '.Yr�.:3 t�d�% A a,,,+• :77 ,yA'T44`+,.•�?;•�., .^�,. .�. .�, .�+. J.' �'�t��w�i', ..q. a ,r �� � :tA���. r"�:. ,��{,, ` .' �5' 'w�'= as .:rF sc�'' ta�a. ate' � ,.z. ., ., ,. ,r..a.:,,,, .l�„' '.q, ,r '.�k, ! 4 aB +,.,.+..1'.,•ate, :, "?#"' .A :; .�,h. ��,,.. &. F�.., y 'q #. - `b'�" � �;;xr, ya. };�.: ....y q4 p`s $ g§' p.:.wr, y,�, -ta '�+ :'Ff awz4.. r' t+.,;� 'a.-X� h ,:Yx ;k"'I .•�o •, 'n�- tt°:a qq ty,, t!4'�a�,V F� �' .:«"� { '�b. •. �Y. ka'A�, �..' 'Y!r .xxt . +' 3.. 'Y,i. % " ,fl"P' �M, .K, f ��O �'Jt`''r �b tk, x.��.�.V.. t.•+Y Y 4i.� ::yi'„: x�. .i � r ,.. rt ewa^� ? i� �� .5:-� :�' a.g "s:d'Y". iNr „ '�4 „� ,t, ,.�- c. �•. ^ems 'Jc? �kim •. .� `„' .�,.' �� '#ro,. �a �, '� �'' g, �`� �" a�, �'� ,�' Ora t.o .� a ,��; ;��"`� .� � ��>.' � ar :'3,w, ?, ,.a �. 4 ;�"3' fir- +. ,r, `�: �``� 'a, s g ' 3s <.. u',T �,'°'"`� fi,#5;,;:,'�xe Ck z �` �;„.. -�"> 4 .tx':.k `3s 5 4p.!;+f',s. xm"},. ,yf, ,�,: ...M t: �. ,.x c, �«�� F..y�''e pY;;[+y•,.,;:��� '4..� �t..'� Fr•a9#sxx � -,.,.,�. � • ,r f,T'�.• T�, ,.t, �., w, K. � � F � µ� iw .�a& a' °` v�d�.�•'' ��'X � ��>$.i'>. y,.<.�:;.3.. 4 -'?ri ''�`1t t ,; t a .:a �'�� .,�� ' Y ' '�s �.#T�:r'"'ft'� ?' �� �'tG 7wka�,M�4 f'hm�, 'e-#� �5:: 1 �•"'t:dz. �t�s.�r�s Y;. *'',';,,� �.,,r ..rty t� �P,,.f<r..� . ,-t. ;`;�t7 s. ';.� 4a° r .d°z;�.', i. "�ld,I".. ..;'°`13. VP.:° ja t, #4 V. is i..r';` 'C. .t.. , rW 8' 4r.�1',' '.i.�• ,. �2 r,' k'' #0 zt;.. 0 ; s x i r j;. T+.1,its x 4 <t*'` , e a�3Y @` �i..Y^ . *.,'.4 � .' 4.,k, i,• i�"ia t . i r"ar'tii+"C'.'.•, ^+k'; �,tE�. .� ww»Mr� '�. `� .M� .3�i � � '�,«�,y�. `�o> n:a v `�i°. r � r �� __yy .s,, 3�,r�,� " (�� 5� Sf.. ,n'+±:" «; � i,. ''r;f �, ,�..x }t,.�.�.; '� ;i'� � °y..�; fka r •� ..°d�.;.yP'�,x.ta r�;titi, ,a ,�` .;°4 r �r�i�,. � «», � ,l°t. ^•g�s'Px,F; �;<.. .F #� 5 .Y.n4� � va•�` D�S .�;.�,+. ..y�t, �t.° c t a.. �x � �, ,�y+„`� � :�`A� i� +.t,.'t,3.t1y." >7'4°a"(��;,,,p� ,� a . « ° .n r. 7g; , 6011', .r;.t .i� ."ii 3 s.«� \.„,ii .° {'.• `;. .•,t' � ;y.' i `�F.ir, .,: .t,.�: `v. F� Y s i:�M �q .� 6� r �s 4•>,: '.Sa: t :c � %`, .�. ,L.«g� ,.�` ...1'�"�,`+�. ',s.�'!. • F .f#, � '� ''=5 k.., �:1 ,�! ,# ",fi``�1.5 -r,t �'°r"ar v.., k'a T. 4`' s< &::^�..,. �`�Yf,�3 `� •k. a N` .w°'.•, ,:*''r. ny , :'4 s" '" �!s. .'s+t�- 4',.. 'b aa':'t V n a. Yt. ,., •,fi.Rr ,<%•::•,' .,, < : •� '. {q .� '�. •+�^ fit. f �,> *' r�y ' �`e,a4»S,,°w? a.�a`�'�° � r,:M � ,tr ;� #: �"�`' •�. a.�•� Y L., 'S,"4, t� e a, E N '� �,t' �+� 'i��ar,r.,, � u ,�" r:t' °i` '1i,),s Q_y,,, y�y - •� .r Sin ;a rE�� e.•, �} y; `..,' r�t;M t a�Y „+,. ro [p� �i< ,� u � °: :Fxq (( &( '4;; @ 3s' �m der• fy� •,� ' �.; ,.�,,�, fCC ,xS sr��k *r'•+�t' ,�ir�c t. :r t ''�< .� 3a. x ... ;;,, `95 ;;jj )b..a , , vnV'.:'i.-' Y.x,4,'i. ! } .>i .�s'#s'I Y,. k.t.. .i tE ;, n 9°`', .fi � e �+.: 't m,,,y'+ � �6�� .f �r�S� a� r�.i �v'R'+�`�S .�,Y� P�:a �,. t-:i :,�• >;�. '�'„ ��ia'.u. ,&.=•r.�d + . .r4 s� ,-�roM'°'v .."7�'a+' � r• x #�'3, `S� . �` .,ar' S �'.+.'•',t z i!e, '�'%��,f , ,, .,q.. ,.D, ,M, �y�;xj,�-.. ,Y ..1 I .t., 'Po-+",.Q.. a. # > ��'��'.§ "d:� ., .�J.:x .71e .�' y'�: ^'.�.'a' .a`�. (rM1.v,4x'!..$'u�:'"`eky s ,t7 "ti, , .d4' iit', .n,i,, .k . �4",t; y, .q '. 'a�.�' 'rt.m� ,a,w'. y.'x .:s ci Y�. .r t <',ts i.r u,'+(�, :v �'; ? e�' f 'i i l>ym t i � � .�q3‘�' r•r+.K'i ' d ;'t ��,.,� �' �t , 5 . :�N . . �'; ,. l :�r. ��fit.; i; • '!.f K> i 4,.. .Ri ti 'R '>.' to- t{•n t'. . , .., +fit�� `c ', s}�4� 5r�� t • sa ,�} F t71jrt i �'\,\ ' vx rtr 'in� 51 "ti Y w^`S r x* ,,r7^' i ^-i a� \ . *s...."t` 1 r r: ^r+y:,x^,w .?}*...-r^ r.;r,!; `'�x'+' \ti v: , N r7;,.C . ,, lj� 'a.^ . :, ,if�?Y ,tSv w� '?3 r :a'i :. '7+.,:5,,,,^. ,,..�� d! ,� y +�� ^r'^•h • k A.. y V t F a. ���I '�ti \\ TX4 y,..a } 1). 1dy. 3\ ,, '1, .. NV . r C L h�y,ry�[ b 1. 9'� 4d' ) ) a" i V h Mt 1 / a '-y'�f'�: '6� r _,1 �Il�i +- - i ,.' �1'.� i v .7� �htii ys3� ,µx.y ✓'w ,�a'..J aL � s x „A,�:.r' 'i, �`.;a 'a., +4. � - a 's` Y ltr}R ••"'>z Q:w a�s.C �^r .w sf� R a��.x � j: T 1 P., ,.',.r-Sfr}7�k .(..I,1S.,,✓r,'.yr .. , r/ i`x. .,..• ,Wy'S rF.,es i',ri ° 7 a' SrR t,v+tek t ,.F' ` S aj# 1,�" ,.-i _. ':.4 �5, x,.E�ri x,�„ a?� � ;� ��� e of � ,H�iaA'���, as: �,. :.�. ,.�i'an. t i r^a rrr„P, ,�' �� �. �. trt i >,..<, �.�. .�; - ., �� ., :��,ati+,.,,a. Sd, r „, n;��' `� '��v,i �€ ti.ko�r�+��ll, �� �rti ,l •7 � .•. ,...^� �,� �'' �, '��'' r`� �.��"a � r. � :� r �f as�K t Yt�•' tf,k � t,• � t .�t .�.!� "� e�P"',R'' ��f. •a�r(, �' ti.a.� a ��f' �.T�yY�x f�iF� ?"Lw.x� ; h r�� '�`}r� `�.�." ��.r.1Tw� ?��k� �'lnC ">a rr"*� Ais' POY _h a *� 7!. $, 4 '�3 �'i ,g"1 :a f�j�� dr �br � ,�r w : r',7�r. .:" t,, ,,;�,y"�f Y rtKq�t."rq e dyi� tt ,� 3�. rn,rY*' a � j :} aen!'tSS�'�F !`x���� �1;,. I� ,5;�. .,y,au!�mrl ra't,;M tr� ✓"�^ �.Y +?, -�p,tl�''� �,5�` �,y,.iaw .,,,fix rt,r�"�f i„k.y�i,;.t k �y"'� .�:, '1. .r., .Y.: ... .� ,h,.,, � qv : t S�'..1'a ,a�nt � ,�4 rt,.tY y L r✓��,�,n,.�� rr, �a R,.{ �;✓ �`a �,s a 1 �.tc t 1.7�', Yx�,f ns: ,, X. -•..- �g S,� � :m�- {t .rtk 3. ' �y ..i,. A r�i n� wxK.i.??,R. ,. r a nE x, 4 yl r. i r,. ,,k . }.i' K .f(.. ; p r e�TS` ,7... .,.. ,' :,b',T.4,+ '}Y, 1; :"�.(,t.a :��„ �.e�e tt�i�:f x�t. ':y�.t; •i•� ^- r,-,,;,.'. } _:4 Oki.�,r ,',. ,fs'a a,,. r d. .. 2 •' `a-. „rY. X .�' 4�' :e� . �'�:.,,�� ,,�, + }w.' ., A. �''7FY F.r. n.�. f'.� ,.�, ...3tl"•,.���: sad. x -•^ r� �, ����. r. ..•x. yr L �_ t ``.� -r � :.. �h':r `r;.4,,, ��>< ,,{t � A,,,' ', a t 4. Y d F- a: ',,,, ", ,• � ;y ,v - •ter,,x.,,,,:F ,, ,4 ti.,tp, � #,. i. \..,.,f y ,w w $ t :v< n h' A !, t ,' .rig ez�.� ;S ��' :.6 '� L::U. w �7 •y •� "�� ,r�' ;i '�'�.� e:. \ ./� ..},' ! y":, ' o: �e.� ; :'.- <,,' 1 mr y.,: .� .'vKV,, n ' I't i. t ra. . >. c � 7 �.c: t..�. h�. 1'r �s.Y'a .,a..�.&a s r rar .r.� .M1 t'�? ,4i.:. �' t. .as , .,.: it�.=.,- ik `�•� a�M� ?�'. �.r�u,.�� i?;'=..,�.�r(,. . }'�,,. ,.mnLf �. {ti{ �>>k s a. a taa: n � r:y -- - ', / � :yam'',. ( ; ,��-...rb• X „.; Vie, .,4f z:. .., 4 *,rt,'44 ax ' x i a. ,~/ ! _ { �':, i� �W':r, �9"i; t,�"C,., -rT7a"x,^ .. >ta 5 �d4y`., �,;r t .., •'� v�:, ., �, ,, Ant' �,,.d;Q '�i '^', ,.w �j" ,.,, ;, ��1,ui• r w ,� .. ,r „ry.., 't .,;ems`" { a,, : ...,.� '� ,rW„ , .,,,pp ' o ,., V,M..x. ,�Y.' SCR.a�,,a SPb°�n'Y0 `I rr tt i'a. i;?wa{t .'''. fir' k ,•'ti• `m' ,b4'� /w4'N,t• d: V,'' T� x��R i ?, Ah 6 rA,,,,yy,�.y 3. i.:� Cy,. "A7�, ,..,drf +�'�vk � .i',5 '' rt4 r� , lair /:', f 1 a .�, dta i,. 'uS k 4.••k;,, 'Cur••r rt r l+ F;; F k". :5.?u . • u • i i+' a w� s, g1,ya%x �t�+'> a�. a. � f r i �'.�.t t "�"MR M1. y�, Cr S8 �` ,P" �y - .:��` L •t 1 "aa` �' Y �a u �w.. b�a,'" �' V � sh raWy1 c '�r1"4ix' . ^�q �",f r§'.Fj'n�' .r�t,,.y e��tS �,. d� ;,y s Q"�tt;��, 7 }* a'$i r�>ri. `.'a1F 1ti� �-. r fts'i .ra'7rt t 4 v • r ,i`"i. 7 ,{{�',rx'' °'c�Lr ° :g$t 1° t t, ' i 44. t .�, k"yo-"•t'�.*;'' Vl;. 3+ " ,tom¢'i. r` u .e,"'.+ i• .i' a>a f . R M•, "iW Srt'"` ,y€ M r{7, s n x 1`.$ +tf" w7�t r sky°9 �Yrtw�J' 4a ��jrwm ' k' P. i w, a. 1 tRq..rt ri� �\,�5„ a tNt, qR'r A3 '� .eM y �??"e, e J y,•. - ' .-�ii,.....1...*„. 'k I�t u�,:„ k Y F,,,+ 1.;k' �," '"'T a-,i Cy..Y .;ye�, �a c,4,1, ,,f3arf ., `t"' rw M•14,` p R �, a41 u ••• �—�� a� , �,, o::, . 4 f� �a,d; i,c .,7 w.,r J P.a`,'. n<Y. .1 m �,�,,.y sylaurs.'i•''^, wtt t "',yp^`'�,., +t ' � sd�.:ey'krr„R _�-• /'' �Y7 '•1 �`I�'C;" I .. y P :.���� t. .,,y,Y �aL,.,�!;Ila ,.•�} r� •� .r�p `""� � fl ;4 '' ",� '^ ;,:tK $bph 6.;.r•2 P dtrk;, .�44lp r t;'1 2R ,'?N4 k . ..�. � r{'1"+??n:}°hrynyy i' fn,t�}.x�a,C r�i. t>{i�r. w+�!y. '�✓"a,.,k)f. . e"�•, T 1..t���RT . rt s,}J '^,MS> k�a7 � �. vw wdcu. a Y wxt t f"b'P}evpx.. a ' ! .rd e�4 4`nfl° uvv s t y aR y4 n d-� • „�,,,�;�uctn9..�,ws 4 �5 'ti(i _ • 1 s��G.� q . ° a 1 .�, y ,.,.._••••tt„ ... 'zr s u.ow'a7sy £..S a..✓, 4 S`� \,*'� ,ri #+ 7Lh 4.1A . v e;a {A' f .ram yt $Y r t •• r0'M w7 P�� 1 rfh7>mII ^ x,,,la,yyprYs. p7 waY.dw3['rxl'6 � s ) t� •'t �4'' ilRi w t i kyF y S 4 � J:. q te - teG d -t yR t1 .a t x .. .. .rt$t�*•p.n^" x N x s .., c4r$:; W .v•T r x _ ''1�a tn5 i,r x4.c:%nwa L.2-._a. S`s 43t r ss�7`' a • ro' r1t"s',j,: Rr i t r e r - _ . r t J rC` _ d I l t T •-• • . • , 1. , _JF $� �1I f f J I t " f , rL—i-- i— " i'it f' r - .. . - _X�4.. -emu' ! } 7 i ! ' " y' . Jai 9 •'I;iI ? J _ � ` �'�. } � "! : � i. a3 v ` 'r: eery -•` ,, - - - �^1 � • i . 1. — _ : - - RZ. ........... oil A 43--' 0 &-E 51 A A ANU lit On 04, S tar- -q .00 SO*, :fq GOT fit rd Aw ................... .......... .. ........ WWI vs. ............ ya; All IV IF 0 1 ""IN. _g im, IMP IM ORB I t 4X- 222 15; 413K AW g--m WOW-- S Wfk mist NA-11 PAR Q 470 ,;z h -,,J�Txoljyf MONA AVY.- .............. ;my ................... Av . A 4 r ARK Age. _ ,,_,,,_: :...„:„.., •=e_: : (_::_f. if.i„ii.../.1--/_,._./:-_-,,,.;.,...„,,,,-. -,. ...:::.fitl-f.:(1-,: _ •• , • ` '�� - - .* r "' . - .. - ., t ' df3't f .` r-- ,7_/f fR�,#;'-!J-;;;-„-11-,''i;-, .4 :.:':-„Il-i,'..::'''.;..,lig;.'-, 1"--e;:=P114:t 7 f,, ___,-,_--,,,„.=,:,,,::,, ,,,::-(,.,wir-;3i„,; -::=,,,,::-.-,--:,?_,:-.,•,--,,'i,,,_. ;,a,,i.'"Z2,1:47:q7-..- -----4=•P-4----CC,-.1V-4;--•I i .1"d.m p1�1y/ ,, �F t U r e .'* __.:ems r I--. .k ,", .- :_{ • �. . e. 1.0. !'te r. /Nb i t N f t -� f /' ! J ,{ \E` 71 -!rw.atik'. _/�r Mtn,/k -z_ .F ,� f, .T E'r�H a .i ". --- -.. ' - --1 "'��.7iwc` ski" , -,= _4"±.�. xr S z* § -'1 "4 -•-, -- �� R�t `�-. .may . ' Y ,y -.� `� '. } -.} -.-r bs- .j _ - is x'- �.. x-F.w1w,.c.r �" '` .-Y-w �'j" - }� , -'=ate. . " - 't.. r rt ram t -s -ram•. - �,-` a- .a tar?.- ,yamF"' " i + --_ t-",.s `�d- ,j, Y - - _ s am t x _ - {� _•�'xA � � �.�'' ^�` 4. �l .� �''� Sea '�� 4� .�� � • Y� 2 f•k�,t�' � �+�'.sue- �.�--� _ a' �- ��`���`�, �-�- .�+, ... ' _ , ^fi C1 g... ' ,+< -.3¢ y _ - - 'sue Z --w - -:- -' `� _ ,.{sue 1 .re a+ 1 -1 77* £ �e a _y -,�3. -& , -R^ i \`t` � - sir;._s4 3 . -..R.-te"`. a"„.. Fi HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD December 6, 2006 MEETING COMMENCED: 6:00 p.m. NAME ATTEND ELECTION ELECTION OF SECOND MINUTES 11/15/06 212 SEABREEZE AVENUE OF VICE CHAIR VICE CHAIR Appointed Linda Lake Appointed Roger Cope 5 to 0* 6 to 0 VOTE: 5 to 0 5 to 0 ROGER COPE JOHN E. MILLER,JR. Made Motion LINDA LAKE Made Motion Made Motion JEANNETTE DOBSON TONI DEL FIANDRA Made Motion JOANNE PEART Seconded Seconded Seconded Seconded KIM FRENCH ABSENT * Roger did not vote due to the fact that he was not at the November 15, 2006 Meeting MEETING ADJOURNED: 7:15 p.m.