Loading...
HPB-05-07-03 eft c� AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION v = BOARD MEETING (f6 �P CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: May 7, 2003 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Randolph at 243-7127(voice), or 243-7199(TDD), 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES • January 15, 2003 • February 5, 2003 ■ February 19 2003 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. McKeever/Fischer Residence, 255 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Bruce McKeever & Lori Fischer, Owners. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a shed. B. Old School Square Office Building, 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Designer Sign Systems, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a sign. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments B. Reports from Historic District Representatives C. Board Members D. Staff V. ADJOURN i \( c cal.�'� \Ac Wendy Shay, Hisgoric Preservation Planner POSTED ON: May 1, 2003 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: MAY 7, 2003 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:02 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Mary Lou Jamison, Gloria Elliott, Gail Lee McDermott, Jim Keavney, Rhonda Sexton (arrived at 6:10). MEMBERS ABSENT: Bill Branning, Francisco Perez STAFF PRESENT: Wendy Shay II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The original motion for approval of January 15, 2003 was amended by Ms. McDermott to include the minutes collectively. The motion was seconded by Mr. Keavney and passed 4-0 as stated below. The Minutes for the Public Hearings/Regular Meetings on January 15, 2003, February 5, 2003, and February 19, 2003 were before the Board for consideration. Ms. McDermott made a motion to approve the minutes as written. The motion was seconded by Mr. Keavney and passed 4-0. III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. McKeever/Fischer Residence, 255 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic, District, Bruce McKeever& Lori Fischer, Owners. Action Before the Board: The item before the Board is to approve a COA for the construction of a shed in the Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). Ms. Shay entered the project file into the record and presented the item to the Board. Ms. McDermott inquired about paint colors. Ms. Shay stated that the pre-fabricated shed comes with a white powder-coated finish and the applicant felt that painting it would be a maintenance issue. Mr. Keavney noted that the shed was already on site. Ms. Shay agreed and stated that the applicant had requested COA approval prior to delivery but that if the Board denied the request, they would have to relocate the shed off of the property. It was moved by Ms. Elliott, seconded by Ms. McDermott and passed 4-0 to approve the installation of a shed at 255 North Swinton Avenue based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), (j) and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines. B. Old School Square Office Building, 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, Designer Sign Systems, Authorized Agent. Action Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is a COA for the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). Ms. Shay entered the project file into the record and presented the item to the Board. Ms. Shay stated that the original design of the sign was a monument sign, however, the applicant has revised the design to a free-standing sign and that staff supported the revision. Ms. McDermott inquired about whether the applicant will request another sign. Ms. Shay stated that it was the applicant's right to request an additional sign at a later date but that the sign design as presented provides adequate signage for the building and its tenants. After much discussion, it was moved by Ms. McDermott, seconded by Mr. Keavney and passed 5-0 to approve the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7(G)(1)(b), (G)(2)(b), (G)(3)(d), (G)(7)(c), and (H)(2)(a-c) and the City's Design Guidelines, subject to the following condition: 1) That the sign text be reduced to 30 sq. ft. in order to meet the sign requirements for square footage. -2- HPB Minutes 5/7/03 IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Public Comments: None B. Report from Historic District Representatives: None C. Board Members: Ms. Jamison inquired about the colors proposed for Old School Square. Ms. Shay stated that the colors will remain the same. D. Staff: Karen Schell, from the City Clerk's Office, requested that any Board Member who wishes to return as their term ends to please contact her (specifically Ms. Elliott and Mr. Branning). Ms. McDermott requested a support letter from staff and the Chairperson for a State grant for the Milton-Myers Legion Post. Both Ms. Shay and Ms. Jamison agreed to do so. Ms. Elliott inquired about paint color approval. Ms. Shay stated that any building painted without approval must come in after the fact for administrative approval. If it is controversial it will be presented to the Board for review and approval. Mr. Keavney inquired about painting natural finished. Ms. Shay stated that the design guidelines discourage painting any natural finish, however, if it has been painted in previous years, the owner would not be required to strip the paint but could chose to do so. V. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business before the Board, the meeting adjourned at 6:27 P.M. The information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for May 7, 2003, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on June 18, 2003. If -3- HPB Minutes 5/7/03 the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -4- HPB Minutes 5/7/03 pELRAYBEACH DELRAY BEACH Ental AB•AmencaCBY NI•AmencaCity e� HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORADUM STAFF REPORT II1 1993 1993 2001 2U01 Agent: Bruce McKeever and Lori Fischer, Owners Project Name: McKeever/Fischer Residence Shed COA 2003-188 Project Location: 255 North Swinton Avenue ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is to approve a COA for the construction of a shed in the Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). BACKGROUND/PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Parcel 2 of the Stratford Atta Bowe Plat and is located on the east side of North Swinton Avenue, approximately 80' south of NE 3rd Street. The property is located within the Old School Square Historic District and is zoned OSSHAD (Old School Square Historic Arts District). The interior lot contains a one-story frame vernacular house constructed in 1940. The 1,468 sq. ft. dwelling lies at 255 N. Swinton Avenue and displays wood board and batten and lap siding, exposed rafter tails, and modern single light and metal casement windows. On October 7, 1998, the Historic Preservation Board approved COA 360 to relocate the contributing house from its original site at 116 S. Swinton Avenue to its present location with the condition that the owners would return for review of a landscape plan and any proposed exterior changes. The Board also approved the demolition of a detached garage, constructed in 1952, located adjacent to the historic dwelling. During its meeting on November 17, 1999, the Board reviewed and approved a landscape plan, paving, and the installation of a six foot (6') wood privacy fence at the rear yard (associated with the new site plan) subject to the condition that the rear maneuvering area proposed be eliminated. This original parking configuration allowed two cars to park in tandem along the northern elevation of the house. The applicant submitted a COA for a Staff Review on August 1, 2002. The applicant requested to extend the driveway to the northeast corner of the house and to change the driveway material from pavers to chattahoochee. The applicant also requested to install fencing and gates between the southwest and northeast corners of the dwelling and the north and south property lines. Both requests were reviewed and approved by Staff on August 1, 2002. Agenda Item: III.A. Meeting Date: May 7, 2003 McKeever/Fischer Shed COA 2003-188 255 North Swinton Avenue Page 2 During its meeting of November 6, 2002, the Board reviewed and approved a COA request and associated waiver to reduce the five foot (5') driveway setback requirement to two (2') along the north property line in order to accommodate the construction of a 10' driveway with a 2' planting strip on the north side of the property. In association with the rehabilitation of the house, the driveway has been constructed and associated landscaping has been installed. The applicant is currently requesting consideration of a COA for the installation of a shed and is now before the Board for review and approval. PROJECT DESCRIPTION/ANALYSIS Project Description The proposed project involves the installation of a pre-fabricated storage shed. The shed measures 8'x10' and is approximately 8'8" in height at the apex of the roof. The aluminum frame shed displays a front access door and gable roof with aluminum lap siding throughout the exterior including the roof. The pre-fabricated exterior has an enamel coated white finish. Development Standards LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a-k) "Development Standards" provides guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The applicable standards are as follows: (E)(4) A historic site, or building, structure, site, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended from time to time. (E)(7) The construction of new buildings or structures, or the relocation, alteration, reconstruction, or major repair or maintenance of a non-contributing building or structure within a designated historic district shall meet the same compatibility standards as any material change in the exterior appearance of an existing non-contributing building. Any material change in the exterior appearance if any existing non-contributing building, structure, or appurtenance in a designated historic district shall be generally compatible with the form, proportion, mass, configuration, building material, texture, color, and location of historic buildings, structures, or sites adjoining or reasonably approximate to the non-contributing building, structure, or site. (E)(8) All improvement to buildings, structures, and appurtenances within a designated historic district shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility can include but is not limited to: consistency in relation to materials, texture, and color of the façade of a building in association with the predominant material used in surrounding historic sites and structures within the historic district. McKeever/Fischer Shed COA 2003-188 255 North Swinton Avenue Page 3 Analysis Based on LDR Sections 4.5.1 (E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), and (j), the shed must compliment the existing historic dwelling in relation to height, proportion of the front facade, relationship to materials, colors, and textures, roof shapes, and scale. Currently, the structure meets the requirements as stated above and displays a continuity of design in relation to fabric, texture, color, roof shape, scale, and massing. The shed will be installed at the northeast corner of the property and will meet the minimum side (7'6") and rear (10') setback requirements and will not negatively affect the surrounding properties. Based on this analysis, positive findings can be made with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), and (j) and the City's Design Guidelines. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve COA 2003-188 for installation of a shed at 255 North Swinton Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), (j) and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines. C. Deny COA 2003-188 for installation of a shed at 255 North Swinton Avenue, based on a failure to find positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), (j) and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines with the basis stated. RECOMMENDATION Approve COA 2003-188 for the installation of a shed at 255 North Swinton Avenue based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4), (E)(7), and (E)(8)(a), (b), (g), (h), (j) and the Delray Beach Design Guidelines. Report prepared by Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments:Survey, Specs _ _- • CI-2.2 mrFKAR.6 _Cr.Leal t 8200..005900 EC 1.H1E.OE-2ME rA FGlE•IRE. 'A"^�?%R 0-ZW R..E E.0.9rE AGM.C.SPS •Gllf?0 8r 1T'6E 00126�AOR.OD • c:' ilrL4. rtltl roal • ..... - MTIUNCE 9�- 10.ILY0 BFMUT.@. an II(/aa 4.waz[ .gE1NTIDA101(O>✓yF1rt. i> NWIH EA. • -�� w4uC r.er Wr ...SE�O.eSr.,1-� a.f A{l+tt 2114 3 • - l,.[i@R � MULE ® ...a..."...,.... ..BWU•�lr rM1^I 1.M t� ID.al ]51/.9t 2 u00rO S'S1Baro00+O r6+l�LRAMC�.E 61v CF1tH1 oar �rl ��� tan o+.e ratan rr4ve+....m R.,r.,.a. �f¢wowrel..aE.f.an. so*+w RAM • 1[.SEW ;i�.l►� /��V• > '\ a.Yml bar .•.Yrr0n.m.,4 a waver oo.ere•..,Vm..vu.].42-Vr 2.r0069,r1ff aA®r••Vtb. . /.,r I 'Ia\fl I Abl[E T.rG4r vas f.[w of r.. ^E ln1RN RAM.M aPD+ 1[..-•. �� \� �•Y�; 'a REM RAMS 5.9�14 Ii �f j I ml. mz.ernn am so t� m+.sw 7 G.NGEOLV.eSTMIO ' ]Ir.- .n¢..14ern Imo. v. •/I���i ►i� �t. ff lii p3 .,I_I�Q .evo...d tea.•e., �. s®n+acr�croaiesne ��jIP OTw01 ar-¢OC t4a/,a.w-+nafre.Yl mnom r.mn..w.zm ov.crb+oV•n.xrm '1'-P rolllF I/ ��' li/ • " �' Oar eV es�Jen1ba 6F'r 1V:r.•Y•mm 1.E.a.at, • ¢ ( III /IF rd t e n.oai,...>,a.,...a red w.s¢>,+e..wn vo 1 ®{/is 6-0 r-c �. i Na pile-'IrI ��-2..rpr1W RAZE 9eq.e-6•10...v.an.1 PIP....Q}.aT STd I ?t)11F ad 90p..tSl rolllrG I 9]I/lF ( T_r r M Swa.•R• L 49-6••7,a......Tvs� am K-•••+. d .;" , SR...n, _ .r TABLE 2 FiN Ea SPACTC TABLE N D I �`'. • ' OH - �---vry t6-a ro¢ol a. o.on+.....m a a.•vrm�.me-=..n,...a. I v®,:m.. I .I I z z \I�, yr.o�.o.s ` '.a u_o rz ITe rz r-.. J 9EE cET.G eat\�:il LN.,,,.i.%.k.'41--;„,,....1 -• +.afTd7 Fl NATCf-1 wm6 OC)C'fi 2 SWn t.KT'FI S +90 u•`.•e.,a...am Es.6a.,,.:.. oan,gym a.o.,a r.:...�' -nw«,.-.. .•.•..e.u....e.-,.n1e 1 zd Iz�n - to n.m. Tlf rr .� I 0-0 I r r- �= APPROVED o0 fc. DOCUMENT.unaaa lnev.tts=.v+saans}mmac*samz•esas aG. eta vas>.,E CV el%TS 0'vu I rKIANPalN 9rr0 IDG raS WIV. N z...EAaEn s I �n.ID Ma 41..s+ TABLE 2 SfRxrr R1•+-&7 I c12.2 PF..I aYPf �11 =•'MIT • _M.VS•i 9•Al all RATE I •E 4�Qr QM.O. e_coQ`l�FCR g.AEvE CR�eF MI 9'®5 W :..tn* w[a..ra-c.�a •.�4 .tt w z4 a^yr ar.cco ( v5f OF#t>ahG+ I .00a v SE aw alre O ,�n r rFc 4 n --9-2.3,2 T'1 hl. 'i f' I i 1 - I .9e rnwl9 IIwi _A _ •• .• I I I 3:.,E 5 2••n.AR1• z.r n, I, I -x S.L ;; <t=. �I1 Q M.Prinn comply with�• I Yr 0..V4V le0, '�-'a M• r-r: J Florida Mrnufacl=zVd Bld.93-eo oa„ro+v n. C-':zXxv Tl-2,F1K4-11-EAI'fa r� •�;,.E _...,__,,_.L..., _.,__,,, ` .`•. ! 'r-;-1 -1 '-� ' sra e.rwa ` 2..�nw REAM.nd adapec.C-odu aad' "�'",,,'"ro+ Vt z•e Qile...o "*•' 3 i r•.os°•tra69fD o1 tsls NE P_lss•s cz•AO W,c� s L yr nsmvv hHlfler'r to tl.e Eotlawl Gitaiu fi y :Aer+J 3..,r.,,N ntLw•aE v.a-+sew 4- 4� 2,.E 9sEu]rtS IMED A®.E UE 1q/a ao ro>o 5 3O%�N P9a I `__ 2.a SC3V1CGw1m-..['tiort TJPr �/'.. III�� Orc�a><9 Ryn A FlATYIY 4 WO M(X7$ 1 /ra .c. i ^.0 D.+... .w.m.J..r.. Alowablea,Nan.+ AGT.rcvly. I z.r•c ln{ Imn�ocor WA/L AllChr T rFTAI Mail Velocity�O I �' - "•Im RATES©an I r. .6 zoo. �: �.'.e { S-A.f- 9 \ mKCv I 'mt! I�e am:axe 1 F Reties;fizt.CJapr V vs�.ras RAM i .lm.m,a,,...• oar., 1 a. s-m.7••.s�.: .I -a.,.r a.mat R..ae al arena S•reaan r..1..e..n a...I c..a..,,.-. ZZZo r..an.eno vxc+ Mao*o.rzi x-� >,on a..em•.n+ae+•eoar.-.�Tan zxo-Q Pranr �S! Irm .6a v.-ov.ws lq,0•015AQT,CF AL 1nE...or All+r.Flew Laid 7 wm /RL9•ci£ ~� 2 c¢ TAME a Appro.a!Dar• b r t`t L` f-t z...csaa - vsss.uT..-6 sru..•.nv+el.r� tiA 57IIE wCE 9ES tld,lVaA).lH11111rtf CI "wES O.•fJ�5 M.M 60•✓tS II�.e'..4a-Wv•r 3T�Cea ace, . I I i Za oG wnA.-Cer•F.00 M M j • .roVa1 of this DRc•mrna doa.4_ a z..'•�•..� �.I l,« 1 2 RRI Era t4-0 .. , .m. ... _ Cr/ V0 T"�a „m It a, s T.i friuX' 1.�1....1.� an f, 1�� CPTLTrAC SELTTTr I sm J c. r or Appror<[A Orr;ae ._ -:..m.r l,ra. _ ��s ___ T}SY7l C:'-1 F'cAtFi a T 1 - I w to IIIIIII'llllllll�llllllll�llllllll,..Ellllll,.s. dlr fe ., '-� • , �is ....6>gG 9034E.. t-t , I .-. , -Z U� ,� ne � �� =..mot, -z.z9arrE,+.ves -sae.neawe n,...r. W` -< :..ernro.aAr- -m >..I..o.a.a.:ae. n',m..o,toe Q_ Q I ' v,+ero�e~�.r_. ..' >sav area vim....sr.:_ z c_ 1-s- -10.911M Q K Ia.9M16 W1 2-w98Si NP "� /n i '� 9�am•r H lrc,,• -�� 3�agJ'•6- \ / /•erceam....mLman [m»r Lora pa.earr cm•MET r Ca.., _ ` rbe u1 �40'^' -vvfl.sm,P lmo.rnsll ara e.,a«..za.,,,VrV •nn.+ovwr..-.[om a.... O'YF.. III/,� .� i a -� Tr a...o_n aoaVc 4EVATtiT.r WITH wngONS AND OOCl1 m re I m 5 � W c1 fi n MAR. .T. I •rx•r ma, X. ■�■■•� �� � t1'°IT - - •-ter v :m as 4 1▪ /."r- ••"•••-.la 4 Roar warn.I . M1 eles..as.a�z.•BJI10.aATF �e........m a..o e.a....•5•a.e o.r,..e a y x.a..e.co,.•41.10rc1 I.4•90 fI.". 9-F:05i11 •-1 AT IAt?+i=Pfitri«FT1 ".CItC" FiaR FR^z•*•23 PS..w z�`°.r.4�iEt;m�. IIMI�IIIII,IIIII,IIIIIII(�.r ....mc �r 4E"T-'a . mar voma - aulf yr_r ' O won Al.p.w.A Mq.Momee:a..p....tr..+e..e• S tiIIIIIIIPP mom�o> a_r.v>ra ¢�.a ��r.6= _,�•�; n�T�,..o:rfa��aa..•r.a�.e car ears a a� �.aa ML.:AAfWIIE IC (1 Ir.6J11W RAM rv..•.>• - ..a.v. W ' vafi.G..r WE MO `u' ��r..,�, I AAA '1' .0 rer.z eom. aB'c o-s.t1F..oa �� m.a:tw rA2iE4 l.la7p.tA,Z aupWAg,E FFJCSi 5vA/-6 rty2 R'+.E>Fi\C6S 3 I L4E r.HE.1W 9•0t2 n x.r fa.rAfT 2-M a a..r rT o.-m[ea. ... `. ��•...- 1Oi J / 9g 4E 91,i.10.wv - I.ri1®KAO KM A E2cm Q`F A FVATT7d WlTF^T�:••,-•••• OW61r0 sr •. O}OE.E 9AA•r 9.f�0 9(Jef rerW rw>••'n. .. _ .4E1 • . E-M Rw..�I rl on®e.s - - 9+71 ram F cep FIFMCYFT^fX]- "O(XTK�z*= -- w. z-.w m-___ [ZG/GV.WMve. r.=.rr-.v ens. gem LLI Y-4 pr � 'rA.Fi..�4a�_04�aC#�V7M, , 1a.f..v. I ,e l.•m -.a 4 M.,. 0+:. 9t.�T3_F 1 C41.EVE AUGER Az.IG11 a•.E..o.�.m,.. 1 r-97 ._zm C: .-x rile G 'I- -r. +9s+a:ur I I r-.m >_EM _ ._ - I Cf.'KY•.�N w a-r 1 ¢ s-atr _ • I t11 - el aA�®:M 9G73i 9t0E.HR FE.UEI r-e� I r_ 2[i 1(FgRA^�1 mCkai C£E,ME..ai 9ff a.aAa•.00r I A I s_ - �1 G not Eli f�J.Plan No. t,S! 'Z�Za 6o C24ECKr v „'Tt'xa " Approved By RICHARD L BULLOCK - w aac mat cm srsa a 1RTn. nacre)ma - mnta - - Fly i:fOC71 CA`SIF1kJC7Lf•! CIAAP CFTPS 2.4 a 50O°c 2 r:41 mr 1varA Err au-/ ••o,11.0.343 a 7tnf Tti - l .Lli(.Ga t.C� Auc�n a�f° [rwe�rEmu Modular Bull ing Plans GXminer '- a'-� 9✓/f"_' HAsa' .eoa am wm.am Ary---^ Rondo Certificate$lA1 Ou3 l 7 tE0,99eS 60e•P.9.•6 • . "t 9'Atp.TZ-ra aD0•ftet}l'fd.E molamQl M1•60 a.w.a)ICAO 6 1�CS6�INIt�NAVFIVUE _ (PIAT`ec `S) PARCEL 2 — It ' IlI500'q t I �o�No ,��/ D,� S'TRATFORDATTABOWE V rJJ V nil+ r72 erz en) p P According to the plat recorded in Plat Book 77,Page 200, recorded in the public Fout.10 3"6OIJ6 MOM. ;Al records of Palm Beach County,Florida;said land situate, lying, and being in ( UNN UMf ErzED) Palm Beach County, Florida. `/ 7WXY � MCP SET Y2lli.g. _jcr tr _ i• NEQ {��. ',l w 1 •! Rio, a c ti ry� .y z 2 I,_ FDL /�117P ri 01J 5 BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON ARE RELATIVE TO PLAT t a .7 AND ARE ASSUMED. <-_'"'•s�^--�r�._._:,^,� ;;a,•;r>::r...:�.....�_ _. 17,5 > Post t ? w \p 0t1( d Office > - e. 3 `> �`_ al-S! ELEVATIONS SHOWN HEREON ARE BASED ON C o ST •+ > i t Q , a a vYf N D v\/ V 4'.0 NATIONAL-GEODETIC VERTICAL DATUM OF 1929 Q r , I- /1- > > ; t+ Sw E Visi a 1 Z.4 UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED. tru> m .s T w \l 9 �X4. a a-,-,-:\ w; Q • z a Vt�NO BELOW GROUND IMPROVEMENTS,FOOTERS, ST '1 NE '1FOUNDATIONS OR UTILITIES HAVE BEEN LOCATED KING city ii BLVD IST NORTH N ��E S70K�rOR SHOWN ON THIS SURVEY" v �Fialt • w N w NE 1 Ct. e R ES I t7 E t`l G E 2-I c x z n • z 3 z Not to Scale LOT4 rrrwnitv Ccn[eraSTu =. < 2 r >< \ NO ABSTRACT OR TITLE SEARCH WAS PERFORMED _ '� NE ,t, n ST • BLO�CK66 Tcnnis Cv I: ]Atlantic'PARC ` I BY 7H(S OFFICE TO DISCOVER THE EXISTENCE IFANY Z ,•IW �..EASEMENTS OR RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. 111__ ,3�y;•„a,� ;�s�`�:i pjVe( s Vicinity •t s>�_FRi' (P.$?tiPG81) \ z1.ct N ,c Map �, I -.1 O.R.B.=official record book Tran.=transformer pad P.B.=plat book P=plat PG.=page IZ.4` 'ti C.B.S.=concrete block structure F.P.&L=Florida Power&Light Typ=typical el,power pole I.R.=iron rod 10.4' x P.C.C.=point of compound curve CM=concrete monument R/W=right-of-way MI =measured R=radius P.C.P.=pennananent control point P.R.C.=point of reverse curve =central angle I.P.=iron pipe D=deed P.O.C.=point of commencement P.I.=point of intersection ®=bearing basis line RP=radius point 0/S=offset P.O.B.=point of beginning P.T_=point of tangency fOUNr7oT101.t D�=drainage easement = Asph=asphalt L=arc length Conc=concrete not field measured M.H.=manhole CL=centerline Esmt=easement C.M.P.=corrugated metal pipe WPF=wood privacy fence U/E=utility easement ALUM.=aluminum Calc=calculated R.L.S.=registered land surveyor Chaff=chattahoochee CLF=chain link fence P.C.=point of curvature PARCEL 2 'c LB.=licensed business ELEV=elevation P.R.M.=permanent reference monument Renner, Burgess, Inc. Certified To: r ��� 1 S.E.4th Ave.,Suite 205 BRUCE J.MCKEEVER AND LORI D.FTSCHZ R Defray Beach,FL 33483 MON i ICELLO BANK, D'� --! Phone I � 56 t-243-4624 1' If �{i k Fax 243_4869 Its Succ sans and/er Assigns 1� $ SHED �-t—�F64.4GG (Tyr) Lens West Palm g i �1 t r. SurveyingWest Palm Fax 735-76�41 THE TITLE GROUP OF CENTRAL FLORIDA.,ANC. O. 74- �7/2 / �� Tot Free 1 800-T73-5531ELITY NATIONAL TITLEINSURANCE COMPANY. p Fax Free 1-800-954-4408 .' : 1< 1 Authorization Number Lt365p! } t Flood Zone: �( _F s I k.___, MOOT I her by rtity at the Sketch of Boundary Survey shown hereon Map No: 1�5 I(� � s G,PJ zj,1/�/�LL meets th minim technical sta ds set forth in Chapter 61G17 6, '; FOUNDa GONG, /gOhl. Florid minist tiv Code urs nt to Section 472.027, Florida Map Date: _ z 1Z L.S, # rjOB�j Statutes. +• � ? ? ' _� / ^M1 �tNatidix>7esr ��QLi; ; u r Date: -7 Z, sga with embossed IVOr �� , - 20 Ha A. ess / Job No: l�� surveyirsseal S.No.5089 Revised: DEIRAY 6EACH DEIRA,BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD 11 111/- MEMORADUM STAFF REPORT 1993 2001 2001 Agent: Designer Sign Systems Project Name: Old School Square Office Building Project Location: 75 NW 1st Avenue ITEM ';BEFORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). BACKGROUND The subject property consists of Lot 1, Block 60, Town of Delray and is zoned Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD). Located at the southeast corner of NW 1st Street and NW 1st Avenue, the property contains a 9,300 sq. ft. two-story office building. Constructed in 2000, the contemporary building displays detailed frame vernacular architectural details such as knee brackets, turned posts, and divided light windows and doors. During its meeting of May 3, 2000, the Historic Preservation Board reviewed and approved a Class V Site Plan, Landscape Plan, and Design Elements for the construction of a new 9,300 sq. ft., two-story office building. The COA included a request for demolition and an associated variance and waivers. The project was completed as approved. The applicant returned to the Board on August 1, 2001 for a modification to change the previously approved impact resistant metal shutters for decorative wood shutters. The shutters were subsequently approved and installed. The applicant is now before the Board for the installation of a free-standing sign. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The project consists of the installation of a single-sided, free-standing sign. The proposed sign will be constructed of urethane intended to mimic the look of wood with a sandblasted finish. The proposed color scheme includes white frame posts and font with a forest green background which will compliment the colors found on the building. Old School Square Office Building 2003-113-COA 75 NW 1st Avenue The sign's decorative, curvilinear frame will display the building's street number and text which will read "Historic District Old School Square Office Building." Five individual panels will be displayed below the frame (attached directly to the posts) listing the individual tenants. Decorative posts and caps will complete the design of the frame. The proposed sign measures approximately 80" (6'8") in height and 60" (5'0") in width totaling 33.3 sq. ft. The sign will be angled to face the street at the corner of NW 1st Street and NW 1st Avenue in order to meet the 40' site visibility triangle lying approximately 10' off of the building's northwest elevation. No lighting is proposed at this time. ANALYSIS The Board shall consider: SIGN REGULATIONS AND DESIGN GUIDELINES LDR Section 4.6.7 (G)(1)(b) addresses Sign Design Standards for "Free-standing signs" A free-standing sign is not affixed to any other structure. It may be either a pole sign or a monument sign. Neither the pole nor the base of the monument shall be considered in calculation of the area of the sign face. A free-standing sign may not have more than two faces. LDR Section 4.6.7 (G)(2)(b) addresses "Conformity with Surroundings" and states: The scale of the sign, in terms of area, shall be consistent with the scale of the building on which it is to be painted and the neighborhood and streetscape where it is to be located; but in no case shall it exceed the height limitations set forth in Subsection (7). LDR Section 4.6.7 (H)(2)(a)-(c) addresses "Aesthetic Qualifications and Standards" The aesthetic quality of a building, or indeed of an entire neighborhood, is materially affected by achieving visual harmony of the sign on or about a structure as it relates to the architecture or the building or the adjacent surroundings. In addition to the mechanical limitations on signs imposed in Subsections (G) and (I), the following aesthetic conditions must be met. Scale: The scale of the sign must be consistent with the scale of the building on which it is located or painted and the neighborhood in which it is located. Scale shall also be considered in terms of Subsection (G) with respect to height and area. Meeting Date: May 7,2003 Agenda Item: III.B. Old School Square Office Building 2003-113-COA 75 NW 15t Avenue Garishness: The overall effect of the configuration of color of a sign shall not be garish. "Garish" signs are those that are too bright or gaudy, showy, glaring, and/or cheaply brilliant or involving excessive ornamentation. Conflict: The colors of a sign shall not conflict with other signs already on the building or in the immediate vicinity. Design Guidelines The Delray Beach Design Guidelines state the following pertaining to signage: Sign design and placement in an historic district or a historic site is an important element. While preservationists believe the building facade is the best sign an owner may have, the need for design guidelines refines the existing regulations adapting them to the particular character of the specific location and site. The district's character is maintained when signage does not cause visual disruption. The sign should not obscure any architectural feature or detail, or interrupt the views and appreciation of the building. Signage should compliment and not overwhelm or compete with the established architecture. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation No direct reference is made to signage affecting historic structures, sites, or districts, however, there is specific intent to project the importance of preserving "character- defining" and distinctive features, and discussing scale and compatibility with respect to new construction for historic structures and districts. One such standard states: New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. Conclusion The proposed sign design, dimensions, location, and color palette are appropriate in relation to the style, scale, massing, and design of the building as well as its relation to the surrounding commercial signage. The proposed overall sign height will be 80" (6'8") with an area of approximately 33.3 sq. ft for the sign body. Although the sign will not interfere with the line of sight of the two-story building's façade or interfere with the site visibility triangle, the proposed square footage will not meet the free-standing sign requirements pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.7(G)(7), which states that a sign may be placed within the front yard setback if the sign face measures no more than 30 sq. ft. As Meeting Date: May 7,2003 Agenda Item: III.B. Old School Square Office Building 2003-113-COA 75 NW 15t Avenue the proposed sign exceeds the 30 sq. ft. requirement, it is recommended that the text on the frame be reduced to accommodate the 30 sq. ft. requirement. Based on this condition, positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7, the City's Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards can be made. REVIEW BY OTHERS During its meeting of April 25, 2003, the Delray Beach Sign Review Committee reviewed and approved the free-standing sign as proposed with the condition that the frame area be reduced from 33.3 sq. ft. to 30 sq. ft. in order to meet the requirements of LDR Section 4.6.7(G)(7)(c). ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve COA 2003-113 for the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7.(G)(1)(b), (G)(2)(b), (G)(3)(d), (G)(7)(c), and (H)(2)(a-c), and the City's Design Guidelines, subject to conditions. C. Deny COA 2003-113 for the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, based upon a failure to make positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7.(G)(1)(b), (G)(2)(b), (G)(3)(d), (G)(7)(c), and (H)(2)(a-c) and the City's Design Guidelines with the basis stated. RECOMMENDATION Approve COA 2003-113 for the installation of a free-standing sign for 75 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Office Building, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7.(G)(1)(b), (G)(2)(b), (G)(3)(d), (G)(7)(c), and (H)(2)(a-c) and the City's Design Guidelines, subject to the following condition: 1) That the sign text be reduced to 30 sq. ft. in order to meet the sign requirements for square footage. Attachments:Survey, Sign Detail Report prepared by: Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner Meeting Date: May 7,2003 Agenda Item: III.B. • • FOUNp'JAIL uwouMBEKEP WUND NQIL p15K .//� uNrJuf1ERED NW.I,STS7ItEET \ 'A,5111 i ` FouNOIIL bQ. v. _ UPPUn6E90 E—E__�� \ JP oAIL L015K---" 013L60'' 3a � c 1 \ moo. �9 :N 513�.'1 I \�FDUN91fZ 1.2 $16N 'v. N • i � OLeNNF1Z LocA--toy- IL — - . I e 7 8 I PAVER 6QitK I , cOvERED o I' 5.0 � o N . 8,7' , \ 1+ t. \ 31.D 1.LOT1 \ //11. "LOQC60 i • w rO.t. I 4'AIJ c. 2 STo2, \ a \.: \ 1Ultplrl�7 r 1 .� \ \ aSPNoLT P�rlK1NGg ii. • Nf \'.�\ 3.7' '1 iii I i 3.4' it • • 0 g \ u I CO • a c. (7(P.� , G.3 i s c 51 3� : : . ZO + GONG, (-IYe)� O 'o 9 enL7i-D151, — folrt f 1.1�Nt POLE �.... I j FOUND 518 l.RcAAP s, �� ��` ��. "\, `\.• : 1 -0E3E00,SUIT,oBKIAr1 FO11NO DRILL tkJ1 E 1 ' col-t.Gu2E3 • • LOTS BLOQK60 • • • -0 • ►' `Z' der .2:St7.'_ :,; oor. Z co•w S �i'` 1 . Zst rty�=v .dw—.. A"LAN IC '} I �,:miI® OA Iran.=Garulormer pad i PA.=plat book P=plat PG.=page ;� F.P.E. =Florida Power T XI..power pole I.fl.=Con rod. :i G. ye II B YP=IyPICeI • 7'r, ,pourU CM=concretemonument FVW=dghiol-way M=measured H=raruus : • $I r;_,a; _till ®.,.St I• �'ll cordial point P.I1.C.=poml of reverse curve =cwrtral angle LP.=ken p4ro O deed ulcordi Gent P.I.= mlotlnl teveron - f Tile. !� Anp i asphalt Ii line- L=we eng point Con ousel j-N. • ¢Q < ®pr.-Q `• NORTH k '9 P.T.=point ol tangency' Asph=asplwll L=arc length Cane cnnnete $t , I•,--• anal =not Gold measured M.IL=manhole Cl.=eenlerkm r - �t A metal pipe WPF=wood privacylancey Esmt easement', - - /pp`, Not to Scale Cl =chaini link ALUM. =point lcum CalcLA. calculated i'?� w ill 14� t --O'- mwrvpe WPF woodchattahoochel CLP=chain as lance PC=poaluminurvalwe LA Gcorued busness a C+: _ ;surveyor&mapper t. $I T ELEV=elovauon Pfl H.=pcuuananl reference nwnumem::` Ct= > ' > . a � Vicinity Map 11.1 15"w Oval 6"h Oval 3-1/2h # t--- 41j1) _, 2-5/8" I HISTORIC DISTRICT 43-7/8" Oi0 SCHOO 5-1/2" I SQUARE / 1 3.1/2" I OFFICE BUILDING 80-5/8" 6" 2-1/4" I FLEET MORTGAGE CENTER HOMEMEDS INC. JANE-ROBIN WENDER, P.A. SOUTHPARK MEDICAL GROUP ANDREWS & ASSOCIATES, LLP --->8 )110 ••• •.*'....:111100.\ 1.;• -‘•••' —" "wo' 6`, ' '":••' "4". 36" bESIGNER S Y S I E M S 3245 West McNab Road Pompano Beach, Florida 33069 954.972.0707 FAX 954.972.1040 DOUBLE SIDED SANDBLASTED SIGNS Draw Date: 3/31/03 File Name: Old School Square-new monument.cdr LETTER & BORDER COLOR: WHITE IBIS DOCUMENTISTHE EXCCUSIVE PROPERIYOF DESIGNER SIGN SYSTEMS, BACKGROUND COLOR: DARK GREEN POMPANO BEACH,FLORIDA,AND MAY NOT BE COPIED,REPRODUCED, SCALE: 5/8"=1-0" MANUFACTURED,MARKETED OR SOLD,IN WHOLE OR IN PART WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF DESIGNER SIGN SYSTEMS.