Loading...
HPB-01-02-02 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: January 2, 2002 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was cancelled until the next HPB meeting on January 16, 2002 as there were not enough Board members to form a quorum. II MEMBERS PRESENT: Mary Lou Jamison, Gloria Elliott, Gail Lee McDermott III. STAFF PRESENT: Wendy Shay IV. ADJOURNMENT: The meeting adjourned at 6:30 P.M. The information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for January 2, 2002, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on June 5, 2002. If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. 4;> qP AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: January 2, 2002 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. Sophie's Choice, 38 E. Atlantic Avenue, Commercial Building, Old School Square Historic District, Barbara Marshall, Owner. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of an awning. B. 777 N. Ocean Blvd, Residence, Individually Listed Property, Roger Cope, Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness for a second story addition and for the installation of a retractable canvas awning. C. Sundy Inn, 106 South Swinton Avenue, Commercial Building, Individually Listed Property, Michelle Balfoort, R.A., Authorized Agent. Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness and Associated Class III Site Plan Modification for the Sundy Inn Restaurant, to Allow the Expansion of the Outdoor Dining Area. III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff IV. ADJOURN Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: December 27, 2001 HISTORIC PRESERVATION MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Item: II. A. - Meeting of January 2, 2002 Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the addition of an awning on the front façade of Sophie's Choice. Location: 38 East Atlantic Avenue ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the design elements associated with a Class I site plan modification for the addition of an awning at Sophie's Choice, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). BACKGROUND Located at 38 East Atlantic Avenue, the business known as Sophie's Choice occupies a one-story commercial building on the south side of East Atlantic Avenue, between Swinton Avenue and SE 1st Avenue in the Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD) zoning district. Designed as a Masonry Vernacular structure, the non- contributing building was constructed in 1948 and expresses limited architectural design or detail. The most recent Board action which relates to this property occurred at the Board's meeting of September 15, 1999. At that meeting, the Board approved elevation changes to the structure which have been completed. PROJECT DESCRIPTION /ANALYSIS Project Description: The development proposal is to install a forest green shed style fabric awning on the front façade (north side) of the structure. The awning will project 3.5' from the structure and will be 20' in length. The awning will serve to shade the building as well as provide advertising and attract customers to the business. Design Elements Analysis: LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8)(g) "Development Standards" provides guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The guidelines are as follows: The Board Shall Consider: (a) All improvement to buildings, structures, and appurtenances within a designated historic district shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility can include but is not limited to: consistency in relation to materials, texture, and color of the façade of a s 38 E.Atlantic Avenue, Awning Addition Old School Square Historic District Page 2 building in association with the predominant material used in surrounding historic sites and structures within the historic district. The awning is designed for pragmatic as well as aesthetic purposes and is compatible with the surrounding historic structures and appurtenances of the building. The addition of an awning will neither alter nor destroy any of the extant historic fabric. Considered a reversible treatment, the design elements for the awning do not inhibit eligibility of the building for listing in the National Register of Historic Places or the local register for the City of Delray Beach. The color is appropriate in its contextual relationship with the surrounding commercial district and the location and style of the awning will not detract from the Masonry Vernacular style of the historic structure. RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness request to install a new awning on the front façade of the contributing structure at 38 E. Atlantic Avenue, based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8)(g) and the Design Guidelines. Attachments: Fabric swatch, & Photos Report Prepared by:Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner HISTORIC PRESERVATION MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Item: II. B. Meeting of January 2, 2002 Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the Second Story Addition and installation of a retractable canvas awning Location: 777 N. Ocean Boulevard, the McCauley Residence ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is approval of a request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for a second-story addition and the installation of a retractable canvas awnings to a contributing structure individually listed on the local register pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(J). BACKGROUND The subject property is located at the southeast corner of N. Ocean Boulevard and George Bush Boulevard and is zoned R-1-AAA (Single Family Residential). Situated on the east side of N. Ocean Boulevard in Delray Beach, this Mediterranean-Revival residence is a contributing structure, individually listed in the local register. The oceanfront residence, historically known as the Koch Residence, was constructed in 1933 and is considered a paradigm of the Spanish-influenced style represented throughout South Florida. The three-story residence was designed and built by Dr. William Frederich Koch as a seasonal residence. Particularly intriguing features of the building include a triple leaded glass oriel window, Gothic influenced tower, arched windows, and extensive use of local building materials such as cypress. The building expresses elaborate detail and is one of the few extant buildings of its kind in Delray Beach. The most recent action by the Board to this property was on September 5, 2001, when the Board approved replacement of the windows and partial re-roofing of the structure. DESCRIPTION The applicant proposes a 285 square foot addition to the second-story, cantilevered over the ground floor kitchen along the north and west elevations. In addition, the applicant proposes the installation of retractable canvas awnings that will serve to shade the second and third floor terraces. 777 N. Ocean Blvd. COA 2002-071-COA-HPB Individually Listed Historic Property Page 2 ANALYSIS LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(4) and 4.5.1(E)(8)(g) "Development Standards" provides guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The guidelines are as follows: The Board Shall Consider: (a) A historic site, or building, structure, site improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended from time to time. (b) All improvement to buildings, structures, and appurtenances within a designated historic district shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility can include but is not limited to: consistency in relation to materials, texture, and color of the façade of a building in association with the predominant material used in surrounding historic sites and structures within the historic district. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation offers the following guidelines for consideration of an addition to a historic structure: (a) New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. (b) New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. Addition In dealing with a contributing structure the issues regarding the appropriateness of an addition are fundamental and must be viewed as critical in order to retain the historical and architectural integrity of the structure. Consideration of the location of the addition, its building materials, scale, massing, and reversibility are essential factors. The proposed addition will replicate the current Mediterranean Revival style of the extant building with its stucco and wood exteriors, including the repeat of the Gothic- inspired cantilevered window seat, and installation of the relocated existing rose window on the north elevation. The west elevation along the front façade is heavily landscaped and is not visible from Ocean Boulevard. Additionally, the proposed addition would not lit 777 N. Ocean Blvd. COA 2002-071-COA-HPB Individually Listed Historic Property Page 3 be seen from the east, beach front elevation that has access by the public. No existing building fabric will be destroyed by the construction of the addition but some will be altered by it. The proposal complies with the R-1-AAA zoning district development standards and is designed with suitable scale and massing in relation to the existing building. The proposed addition will however, be inconsistent with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards and the Delray Beach Land Development Regulations Development Standards in its architectural features and design. To ensure that the addition is consistent, in that it is differentiated from the original structure, the addition must be altered from its current design while remaining compatible with the extant building. To achieve this, it is feasible to alter the exterior building materials such as the stucco pattern or texture on the exterior elevation or via the installation of modern windows in the proposed addition. Retractable Awnings All supplementary appurtenances installed on or near a historic building must be assessed to ensure its compatibility and its necessity. The installation of a retractable canvas awning on the second and third floor terraces is a reversible and compatible treatment that is both pragmatic and aesthetic in design. It is believed that the residence was constructed of hollow clay tile. To ensure that the installation of the awnings is compatible with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards and the Delray Beach Land Development Regulations Development Standards, specifications for their installation must be clear and concise to ensure that the historic fabric is neither irreparably damaged nor destroyed. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Continue with direction. 2. Approve as presented. 3. Approve with staff conditions noted. 4. Deny with reasons stated. RECOMMENDATION Based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1, approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for the 285 sq. ft. second story addition and the installation of retractable canvas awnings on the existing contributing structure at 777 N. Ocean Blvd subject to the following conditions: 1. The new addition shall conform to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards dictating that any new construction shall be differentiated from the original building. '' 777 N. Ocean Blvd. COA 2002-071-COA-HPB Individually Listed Historic Property Page 4 2. The hardware for the retractable awnings must first be tested to ensure that the historic building fabric is neither irreparably damaged nor destroyed by the installation of the awnings. Attachments: Proposed Site Plan, Floor Plans, Survey, & Photos Report Prepared by:Wendy Shay, Historic Preservation Planner N1 f •� • ✓'. iiiI i. ° '�{�'- ..✓.L�"• �':�'%'' air 'I'! • ftltillil0tt • „�� , N.101 • uurHy raabr •' Comma• IC 1l` t rVA .r�� � • • 3laroga' Y pit f ' n 14.6nt 74'6v ti • • H,+Ry���SyyT{� : D • r t�yy y f i.VLlIL • ' : 27i IS !"4fC�1 2"41f F a ` . • • j . , — •!tri Elam TO'x:fY I • • • • • • • 00 7yRyw t_ _F— _ .— , , r .r�. rprap • Sal-In ftitrnerc •t'• P Y'1 trw Fes'at i"u�'j'� _ 7,,)„,. • fl 6 • r 34 , • • • • flair'ram I r', we-., it..;.••1 t4=Plica,,,.16% k • SECONC QQR • l.... • • —it. • • y o • • • .• a ' 4 .; r . • , t„..,„ • i.i . ....,. ' a. . a 341fc06 1 • • Momb BoFtonY • ' w. • EG•�CGT2` ° t ri. 1 • M� ;!..KI•F1p{,tbt 1; 1 • . .. 11 i----- . ° b. • -�-s ° ` IhGr�' vp6�sclo6vk•�Grodatt�o� ix rn Fu` si %rjram,0,,, mtnamt9i=gilthilitmilir4t ,Cu3§ u'dmF »nnt7as di.•�;• .1k b atIttuu,nawpautAri,; S 4niM1.4+AKNIa B riwU alRatil};fc;,itomt.'uc • • .1 1 • • U. • • F • t Ir I 0 I I 1 1 1. I 17 T 11 THE McCAULEY RESIDENCE PHASE II: A .MINOR ADDITION TO A HISTORICAL RESIDENCE I_ _ 777 NORTH OCEAN BLVD. 1 • DELRAY BEACH, FI.ORIDA 33483 1' GENERAL NOTES CODES VICINITY MAP INDEX a p ARC4 ! EG'1RA_: I�Jt ;R� 1 1i rL1ri1FM, A¢Ac0AIRArn .. CC WA// t ':i I L1 •i1 1 ntr r.e(NNE, Q 1 T'E COJI AC OR Sun U r r^OC1 PT ARO ALL CIl•mn A•C, 11AIDnaJ?T D,: CY` 1S I,ED•1N 1' •• ' ,.. r4IC1I V n-cr55ln. 0 Or r i LYJRY I�f.Y( I �� I .(IT At 1.{RlCS J N-rA•MIR.en!t,ce M EDIT all j �-'f -.E III'y 1I T I v MC IR•+ROOT FUN 1. T?CO.1FASTOF IT AL l OT D e :00575.0 •R✓'.CES, ',EA I A a10 rLCCIR J 1' FDITCP, J 1 V I c6 dlt ,Y.?r+r-^.^Fn N. µ. DrERA'IaP CR MIT S LIT a-OCTANT-0 OJI[F.S',oft SibD FD-ff .AV.N OD IS 7-TOUT ( ! �!- ? �( ( 1 AIPFLY41.AV..M.5,,,CI.,IS n1 E[_II CASE_. �l�r Q�1u r I Alt MID f!C F1A� 51NID M LT 5116 OO 1111 ED•OII l .. ���aaai...F 1 V. 111 l• esr WAS I 3. ALL COTS FOC•'OI Ab YJFJ^l4,N'^ TALL•O'FO^1 TO T'-T El OR OA A C SS'E CO AOA•10,IP-SJ EDITION, -I F,111L! ( ' ' �C�'+ j I it 7, dot Ens•kV MY'J 0IIVA'kl' cO F I o w LCCAI COVES. r !(J{:�'-� 5 y 1ST}p ) 1�P�' +;f I rl Or !MI J.`5'11,0 ELE vat1'.`A () 1-0 CO,0RA 1OF 5 11 VI It tic a'5.'E AV Et RE•rON�e!FOR ALL CT-OR ME!,R_ULA Oi5 A,D CODES NAV^a JLIISD!C7..OI i&I'- . )-'�{ i 5 .. Liii V4 1 R YERF C6110 Or 0. ELE A. IS C0.7,1015.A•,^.DE1EV91a.9 \CLLD70 EL:/Ct\CCC9AAi_T:91IED:O ...iii i AyF I� 7 1 rC10R C CO11E4 10 CO 51FU^1 D` I r 1 W C"T 5 DELRAY eEAf.H F_CRIDA l' •` 1E. . 9[L '�$ 1r 4f.. S A0 CN TS CR 1 S.OI9 E Y t i TIC VAR10.5 FLEtc 05 Cr CO.\TT CR PALY STEAD.,E ! 1� JJS.. TI E0,1,*,DRANT.GS Ab/OR GDtRAL'NOTES f4a_L E'_ER T1T STATE CO FLORIDA it' t!',.II I11 1O THE At2.'110Y CF T:F_ARDETEC0 cTED 41ELT INV EE•OFL rRCDE D'. .1 T.A\57EV.SO Iiv0.VE0 DO NOT!CALF 1 II[I L QI f 1 y U A DRnu Y % I 1�tl�'Ik S},,A r 1. 6. TVE G N RA COI,RAC'OR MALL C0000IL.TC fib VERFT 074 ALL 'el •1! ��+• E'I5: TRA TCRS TF_SIZE_AVO:OCA-OI CO ALL P.PM13,DCC;EOR/. I 4 Q TFENC ,SLEEVES SPEC:AL DOLT+G FOR FO:EVENT 00,,, TS, , I•d 1L „_•'�'^ //yyEF ETC I •C• Kn M. lam •1 I. THE G_.`_SAL.COIIRACEOR MALL Et OP ELT rrert1SIELE FOR t.....1`, II;I.i '-T A_i..'T4V5 AVD f0EI;ODS Cr Ca-011.'C.O Z 91 A_,I- Cji�� S. S CONTRACTOR N/A_L DE RES0O15 D FOR 1 EA'.?0 ALL F1I N• E 1, 7 {{A La{.. _L� CO ILI .. 5011445S CLEAN AT COIPLC'IOI 5 TOE SCR'Am E:.ALL 00 000 S 1 •�-TT -- 't x ":.^�".` ALL tYCESS VA'FF AL AV DEERS FRO1 T.r_-C°RV:MGR_• A ,.LF•Y �r' CC e%r JCn Nit"0*.FETTCV'6 400•I:r FAL RESFO.S BLITE Cr NYE r"" �,+ �=' /..Il i CDR.FACTOR 4,:/0R 5SZCOI?RAC:0R AVD 1-ll57 D`_WES FOR ALL f ',00♦♦ 1 Y`F_�I G I ,� IIEY•.to'XI 6._•GOCFAC•ORS MICR-O•A•F OA•'a! Qj;'rl.�i lux�F. ., �.,.... IO. '4C OEVEFA'.COIIRACTOR NIA_EC REN0151ELF FOR 419'ALLOG - •^A SOLO POT,DLOCYbG 0EL'OD ALL 54ELvtiG.Cl5n1t!.ETC,CR EaJI •°Ra,IR�°AX° SYMBOLS ABBREVIATIONS PROJECT • TEAM m S. FOAL 111STC7:O65 ARE PEOJIRED FOR ALL 001111tS •• ELE�`RICAL: (-D=AILN.MeER • ARCHITECT, GENERAL CONTRACTOR. Z DETAIL REFERENCE, Ag1 (-84EE'ti:MDER ,''. CCFE LCJ!(IEC'I in. GR CCEYE."I If '1�1 I. ALL TOR:64ALL CC DOVE C.'ACCORDANCE L"'4 RATIONAL CIE SN AVE\1,= 5/5.^.C.D 501514C CONE' w ELECTR'CAL CODE AND SMALL C0'if1.T E'1':1 ALL LOCAL U RILES AND ORDNIAVCE6. E c. DELRAY EfEACJ,F-Cf:DA 334E3.5/15 ,I;ry?Q P.M:A 55E55 .. 1. TIIV1Yl1 EIR:SIZE MALL ME 0 A0.,EXCLUD1.G CONTROL r-E, r aE O E'.RINS U•LESS O11:ERLrSE NOTED.ALL COY OUCTORS S''ALL DE_ F-ELEVATION 1.1 H=R ;TIC,(5EU7!1-b?C\: ! 'COFFER U't1f TJ.i7 OR TNU::IISLLATia.. EL_vATICV PE=EREN.^.E: - "' ' P.V fSEI;!17-TOFF v 1-SFEEi N'J`1HER EAX(5EU711• S. 0151 COXES 14'. PE PRESSED STEEL 14 DRY LDDA;:D49. E'rl FAX(:E')IJl-5A9C CAST A_LOT SAIN T-ICADED YVE.5 N'JET CR 10.0,LOCATIONS • .. AV SPECIAL En0LD5)F=5 FOR 01400 cLASO:FIED AREAS. EL'AIA STRUCTURAL ENGINEER, U .�F. D'6COT'EC;04010IIE5 C-A-L DE 1I.O.RATED 6'EAVT•DV1Y, O,D lA<E.OJIC<•OCA<E`Y'_OSUREF A5 R•OJIRED pT (--SECt:CN MA1?ER x••Fh FC ,IIOV Re ECENCE: 1CCP7 D.E,4.3 R FE,PA 5 it 51 Or T-1E T11EN1 Cr T1E5E PLAA TO S'-1014 EVERY S1NOR ti"(--SAFE•I�JiF7EP er au., r _BETA CO/S'RJC11_N.4E CCMRAOIOR,S ExPEC•_D-O I EJ tECIF5IA C21E 5.1'E 720 FJR:1E-I Alb INSTALL ALL 1'E,'151DR A CO`1rLEIE ELECTRICAL NY -EQ.ES7A RCF.DA 351FS O "St'r.NO PROVIDE A_L REM f:f-EV•S AECCSS[R-FOR role• , Mr II TO E_PLACED IN PRC0•ER LCR<1r,ORDER P.Ji(5FC[75•1;ID 6. ELECTOR CAL 6T STD'SHAL.Ft CCY10LE'E AND CTEC'IvELYRV PC.Tial, 5: "° GROAINDED AT REOJIRCD ET 1JE LATEST E.DITIOI CF TFE REC. 1(-••A:L NJ'HER r- 111011 f°'E• FAX(EFI15'S•199C 1 A 1L VAtCRIALS SL'ALL SEE 11EW b/c°EAR,.:DER R11ER'S LABELS. J� • L e. eERE ar-llcnSLE. TTEP.ICR ELEvATION ,{,I I-1N1ERI0R ELEV. - L ILO.RR 54ALT EE Pa=pR;D BY 4 LICENSED E:EC'RICAL PEFEPENCE, '�`r' (-51EE;1::;M."ER FD1a:acwR a:a PCS,CLASS x T.VA LIRE F1A a 76E cm- PROPOSED LANDSCAPE ARCHTTECTE h PLE'ED SYSTEM SHALL BE FILLY O"E_.RdT;K ANC ACCEPTED ET •"' ° I L 1.00)/ORC.I:TECT. _ ALL EOp:SHALL COOFD:NATED 11 OTHER:FADES TO AVOID r-"'r• P.GRAY,r5CF:Lr7ROZ,1 MD g•ScC'A^4 INTER EREVCE JMTN'AE^ROGREEN 5 GOISTRJCTIO( n.C0ITRACTOR 6JALL G.InRAYREE ALL I'ATER'ALS 4D SCR?:A1y'.F „� ,�E.•,a C71Y'R-n SJMOI AIE1(E FREE O DE EC'S FOR a. ROD 5 oCT LESS T I V C,E YEAR ROO-1 PIP EPENCE, .W I-ROC-)NUMBER DELRAT E tAC-n.cpDA?pie root, DATE ECG to IOC n `OFFFD Col Cn AN D E S NIA/. DE COTLEIED 51115J rw F110(5FU71F.r[r4010'110I L C IA E AO NIA., SOLID!R Ld E. T CR REPAF FI� CF ANr Or[R I",! M of TLr 1 TAI LA:al vuc 1 VAT HATE-BEEN COC,R REEEPE\CET (0(._COOP Nl11ER 1 °DN0 D x o PROPOSED CIVIL ENGINEER. ///''���III 11.ALA R C 1 D TIT:RANCE SHALL III FRONDED FOR PRC-ED1101 ,• AGA1,4 NLI'T 5 PRCPERIT DN+AGE FOR T�014,5151 CF '- ME EOFKVIII.e,11.11••n.c GERdLD D OGh"y',PE. D.c01 ACTOR SHALL TAT STOP ALL rERrre,FEES.1`19rEOT545. L';1NCC L REFERENCE, O(-'P1N7C111 NJ19ER 'E3Z ECLM SDE.RAL 11GJ.3l•,'1,'1E IC _4VD'E5T!1:G. .nE Tn•m DELFAT EEACH,FLcR'DA 330.3 Rnc I., ,.,.n L F^H.t.e. NOTE PEFEREN^,=: 1-REF"cREN'_E 1N15ER v°,. ^^ F10(5E'1215 0,10 2D^I.C9 FA%1'FP76F•457A CAa EI.•MI //�X PROPOSED MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL/PLUMBING ENGINEER, w3n'F.Beal R_VI51CN REF_RENCEI L\4-FEV15iON 11N79ER .E-_ F_.:,.. ,r..r r c.'y nr F•TYIce A4:1 AE.F-OV14,E5 i I.•ON !FIE KS.PL)A'/EsUE • .o..+.... Ei'CA Rd10:t1.'IR'DA 3?l37 A O.0 • n,. nun !NO(III)3EC-T9 ® E:E_u0'-/'!5,'R..,7:91 EAX(561/3EE41'3 . F , DO R I DOOR FRA"E REilARK5 d�mrl Il i ,1 + •; �_.� . ..I I .. I— i . .._ — —_ — d No , 'clofN I L,hr GL:-K -"— -- — MATERIAL KEYING LEGEND_._.. ._..._.. . .. _jMe3 ... • tie J,J an.ear-ter; ! 4 VIE I re I r. TTrE MAT `RE 11 raLa m,4 roe - -�- 1 _— I _ ?r o nrrnr !n ! I rtr _J__ -- u I I n r.r.lx e• errRome ur+ trw. C� G Q� =� trc"SOW A,,ifl CAW Y1DttM( C[ 4.,,$fl nl I 11 1 . • w e !'-rxr-!• I L•_1 C) --- (=)(=1��- I.R. �, 1lraf anlor re auto r*na,rawl r�cr•-ee nr�rerol I , I _— '-1 7 PAM ROPY !1 I N' lt� _- rY11_ e•NIIke.NrmrUCC 0,00A _I--I___I-11 —_�—_ I I . 1 I e:.el:.t ..:nxng L .LYr,] n — 1F2 .5.-! _ IY'k• •cbr Ty.nn • - I IfrlR.rtr�;a1.1'M. j —I `TT72 ____ 1(_,•/ v-_IN.,.1V!:lrtr.C�Ht9r,.r f N -I I —_�.__---I i n I N 1 !.1'k.'.t' :rbR•M;�R>?' ...' fr r' 1 i _ _ r+mA'.•1Cli•14fI.GlrtY'rN na!'.`Oh 1--I I„ r , ruiiav oo... ..;o re ier.-rntc r.;e vwo-cra:r CT t�.lc io:�:itio� — - •n e.•m r e core lcwia.cl At eYKABA_t to co ,ct or. r.r! I I I '.—I I I 1— •l.v:•Ko.ne¢lEl to ovte MD..,Artc•roe tr.ti e.N.R! ' , re I 1- _ I Irbrze e...a.n _ _ - - I_ v; t I r..�..,• a I e� _'-!•xr.f• ruRa eanrr>m� .n• I �;1, ___ �`/U�+`�--arm llro aa.l.uumr.ar:rr>..r-..co 1 —1 �' L.—! [J V -_ICY-rm 51.0...a•'Inn•_A 1•OCA 6.0,,, ,[11 • i I I • • -L� !^_C I'!o ',el R:V1 Mfr j Kam ____ — I _�_ --- rt:re.vo I '',lROY, 'K2._{� `) - �J ' ---- J S=,---I'slcc.:O,Lt.o e:bl.1,0. CAle-v1 r.:on.N.:.r.•., • I I i� Lt.Li [)(_) u,tlrr.•r leer Cm,-rife a cAlern;l..m'0.1,40 AC'1 =I i II I J- i j • _ I-- I 1 �— —1 I —J_ tA I • W4, I I Ec°o vi - — � i ' I ILI wax W . Qg En , • LEGEND U C: i it ?.I P.. i1 f. �� ) a , I Rue 1 t III i 1�' I { Kl�SR R,D U • �/ II "-...__. I 'I -_—_ it +I i] `'a.'.w -x-r,•: i e 'tea l e ' z .' �, KI l J A PAIRF:c' DCJB_ECA.Er'•EN1 DCJELElcASEIE'r FyEOP.�,_ ar M� k4'd 1 _ ,..mr.revra+ evN ere vue: ..mi.: 2 j GENERAL NOTES ;81 1 T-µ WI _ U 0 G1 INTERIOR DOOR SCHEDULE A' 1 . -4J I�' I M' rT.C100t4V:COI MIPrCRAM 1..,1`;i . . B^ RA 0 CAScFITT Fiy.ED PCNFE LOCATED S\5i E CASEFIN- RELOCATED DC:°LE CAEEK-SNT v ii'Amer'\ "C3ryrc�,er rOce r..q tCMAC-1 Roo': ease,FLOC, WALL9 c=''_. YNci”: ..at•- ROAR noror.aertt cnr„•n nou:l, 1 pp I I F.refl sei[s: I 9 �,i i 1 f i�, ;tre.N fu.wy fPntr r..o eve;t.uxr�rNNnntteuRovlr ti t , it rom mrtb.+wr'rrw n...r..1 + t wrg•a,g At r.O.0 rSCM M, --I]— -Y 2C.C5S t A CeS r KR 1-Y;1'd rt•re1_t Y' y� ,r I n.r>ac,�.r ree:lrnrt+t l.lOvr;,r tome +7Gy --i-1�—' nec D:5A./cCi.I VI_lCe•4r Ff•LM'Co rq 1 • ��— —_�--'i 5-S!Wen'rJSta Ca-Steele r:rz5:tC.. • �_-+- 1r— arft�ruor zct rtrartir,,�el. { -I-I I ! . 1 } 4:FT_[l•:n Nut rlrWUr:1}tC ere • • I R:e:l ty �_I-�__�__� misvtor r.•o orrt rcvwn euNe e..». S h'F.JULES r+r.l r.!!t14 r _ — —�— 1!C:rK.A lli•!1.,Sll'rtwettren lK �'•r �h iTrt i f+arotr r:t_�wrr+C.Ntxtae' r-+:nt A. CI ROOM FINISH SCHEDULE H8 EXTERIOR DOOR AND WINDOW SCHEDULE A 1 ,0 • ' , , ° :o=.. r.A zinrcTs.Pit.,x, _ II 1 I. ---- ---- - .... ._..... ^- - _. , A 7 gi iv i •I . 1 I • ; . ! •I i I H I ' . . 1 . 11 E.---L---ECTR'CA---1_---§*1461_---l_EC; ND:------ : __i_l_ ; 1 ; 1 li4, ,•••;0:•-•••, •:,,,,...4.;.:P., e, ,......,,,..:.,.:.,0,.:,,;,....;,,,.,....,,, , 1-6- ,,,,...e•-,e.fJ,.:ot,.,.v.I 1.,,....,:tt 7:'.f^,,11. .1 ' I . I .t 1 < tl...!0.,,.,,,, e'• i',4'7;5. 1.2''''''''" . , FAMILY ROr.t.1 I, rg Mr..:cs Art, et 1,^,1**"!..,,,,,,,, ''''''''''''''' I -.---• IKI A r•11 1 .._-•-_,rims o.,,., -- • 1 _pa.lc anA, , . . I r:..) '''' ' - II I - ,,,.,,[...F."00,t I :.[ -\ ..!”.11:,,,:r j:::..:1:1,9Crtx117,:et,PO Pr^..•rt..el ni•ct ,..:.,,,,, ill Z I • I \ '\• ..0 O.\ w 4 , .. rd 2 tI i. 1.Ii, \2/ 0›CC-I iI 0W r / jj \ nct_ e. , DINNG . .. fOl wom : j ki 11.1 LE>SSIA :'.I H [iv,:1:•:. i . ,---\ I-6< u r Z I--- . 1 1 - , --- . .. , w--. KITCREN I•' I .,;{ WALLUG I ENID: I— r- • .i . ', 1 , • i I, 1 / .v. , t., • '..'..----r • '• I PAM,rAw•re,err.T.e..v.Ar•Aor I I ' Y\ ( ,,..Z I 1 i ! 0 I . g U 6 i.,0 .1 ,.,ralbrizi,, ‘\:‘.I.< 7 ''' .I 1 .•' SYMBOLS LEGEND: .I lY T- ' r 1 .' 1 J 171/.,'i., 0 EtCV.171.7.,fet”-1,..41 .• lnrig '® DOC,ITT,IEEE t.S.V.I.1 • : 1 I LIVNG 1.1 c,-,:m1,6e.-PT e,IPA?) I ROCM IF .., ARCi—IITECTURAL FIRST FLOOR PLAN ENTFAN..7.-E COURT ' eCALE,1/1.•r-C lie / iC.:•:.:9 ; FLOOR AREA: .1.0.r /ri:;;•.=?. , cr•r..,E+,OFLP...71.":.; • 10,.r...7....• •1.104.ea I'. I :i..1'..,)!.'"i% ! )7,1 etl.q.VC' /1 C•c•.,A, . ..... .• - I •-i. A2.0 ..::tr:...ji..!:',:i..:4.7.,:...i...."',..r........ i . , I . I I i • .. i rr------'. . •I ./ 4. i t• . . I 3 . +c I' 1 ea• ,..„.„,...„.„,..-_,„ • ---.1--1, , . i ,..,,a Tr•T coca".c ,'.**'.4., e 1 .X ELEC7RICAL SYMBOL. LEGEND: i 1 • MASTER 11 i li .64 ,A;v k..r:-!,/Cf iil, 0., .(.....:..!,Dv!"....1 a.A,.CACI I atDp.ccti ' er C '" II. _____II,c) .! s : •.- .0,,•-•,..••,,,,,i DC,,q. Ax.,,,...„3.4...;,,,,..;,,,,:,,,, 1 0- li4 ,--,,-, MASTER ,(...31, II I 1 ee Ct.',2,DCI.E., •ACII,ra:,,,,,,,, ' , < ..,,..o... D.. .I p "•.''. „, I I /I 0 i.44.:'..:;',..11.;:/,,,,,,,, II I -.• --.- ';" 1 r.,•.".'...01 M.i...,E gl..1.,DA'', JLJL _ i I :, .......,„...---1 ,,•••P,CE'D ED•-,.c.' .. T • -:=1 / ., I I. . -.../ '.. '.. ----• er„..„..,.,..,„v...,....I I.11(C.kirk a rck.ccl Ex A t11,AND, 1----!:' --'-' - ---- 1 (..) 1 ..„..,....:.l'.. „7.!•-v,,,tx+.11PAEIASE,11.,ADLA AnD.W1..1'V IA 11%,.1`,-10 At A.S0VIEC Z 1.11„,'elm, \. .,i okokTre"JCR A, ArPv ACI DIII,.1,C0,9 A.,ELVICCI ED L.li • • • • 0 CLO. / .. V1— •< z / 1-1 ' F-.] ' ......,•,,E.. •-c . I I ‘(. ,V,Z1,.1,... .-17--''''"''''. 16/0 .1,c,.%(11 i I s1-1 b..00/1 -;.i. . L -- , - , .. /.,•,.., .,. ,,..,....,,,,,,. ,., • —. ,:9--5,.1.'... •$ 1, 1 C al I 0 1,1AS A ExIt.5\0 ',.. I I ,\c 7.21.2 1 i-2-1...i• 1 .--ce•oct•kT a e TT n CERA,11,..?GYM fp.....1,,0 E,P..rx...Tr LJ v 5 0 eEDROCT41 <2 k kr_ook4Ta.rar oT, ---.., •;.cx cet- • .....ji, ,. I , z ',.... • 4-4C Atit3R .1-1 : (1-T./.4: ' ....I___.: 4-4. , . I '4'1 .4.1 4 ' 4 II' rti7-4n-47741,14i-et.4';.14'7,741f1T.'dTatTi!'""" , t ._..„,..n 14 ••,\...,,l,TERr..4.,../ :.i.„.-T S. 1/...—• -1---.1--....-.,,y_. . i I i 1 - I --I-- 1,Ii147; LI'' iii.-LEE ex Ix'Al/E1EXii-T4E-ACI..11It...ICI ECri=”1 —IA I—. I.,,I '''""''''''' ' .4-,70ILET -T `.'14 T'-411.:1:-.--..- 4' I' I -I l' I. I'l . (..3 '.;. I " I „.„' fi,,s,, ',ROOM Z '4' I . 4' I V.-4,71 '-•.., , _.,1444,4441e4.4E12L-4,4„,„ ,..14,.,,To.i. .„.'-,.... tu>V7rso.T;-4.114Eif..e.is,eAice ; .3 _ . ,,,,.,,,, • 1 ••. NIS --r ,., ,, ',. ,, ,,,.,...\.„, ,.., , , p„ VErrADX/filt'C!....ALER _ Tv ,,---- i- 1 !f.1-pqi •••• .,,,-.....,.'f,...7,....i—11'. jr!— I 1 . R ii4414...9 I I. Tt LL.1 t 4 i ASTER n. ..1 t , '''''P';'''''''.g.'• -,,7-,';',,I,,'"'"cy-qi -1 rl " • g.r.e.f.e.i7:•-•--, ..1 - •• ISATTIRCX$41 °I;0.- __.,..„e iXrIA7VTAICSI tot, 1C, ' 11-,_1. I WALL LEGEND: i• 1 • - '.N '' I T):_,......,,,, CVA,V.41.TR--10 4 .,..,,,,,).. "ALL t''I'I'—'ilf_11•:-7•21 IL-I•••••••ILI' II ii,---•cartkAant To Tkko Hy',Cc1.011.0.1C,RAC.IX.At[DAD`,wkokkoto e):::6i 1 ... 1 ./.s,,,,-- ,r fluiraLd...,,e•CIE A'a,VALI If PE 67711C.,Al.CAA..J,161 ' ! 1 i !./1 ,7,..!_go,i )c,...1.?,-.<...,,,e,..., rii.f.A.1p°,:t...-fr5-1,r ---1 I/1'i I u., vttrX.C.1 Al...I.XtrAer ADD tic. - 0- • I, I lJ t I i I SThIELOLS LEGEND: ,i, . ... (21 41.1,C11tR.ett EGIESAtt ®qjirtrIL" 11_1 47.4riTIT; -g I ". 4 I eAfTI • ;I:I ' , •.' :I g4.;4•T.T4 ,ze 1 a D op , ,., _.A WI,CC-1.1, ,. •1 i. 1 1L I I , .0, ,.•.,.,,-,.NC EGACIDLLE I •' A_I-A4A,V12.-ex.Dt;',A., —4 III OCCIR F1L7EVJACt(PAP/ I I ' / I I i C. . , 1 I—VELIEVIR EC,A.C.4 I• .1'F • ARCHITECTURAL SECOND FLOOR PLAN L, , eLAI E. .I'.r .II. ISEDROCT-1 I RAZ . ........, X.Djon VA EXISTING FLOOR AREA: , Afr,,i',, \ II 2CC•09 LNDIA AXE,. A IIII ea F". \ C0,111,AMA. I'E/111 '11A2\DF_R,1.4. 2.0 1 ;e4.1 ADDED FLOOR AREA: '•,'..0.6,,I, ,/I " t-oTk.o ko -c...c. 1 A3.0 li .- . -'I-.::"..7.--; -7.4.-•1'.'=7'-'' .•_-. of -,.... . , . • • I II I .. . •.-... . .. • I I 11 • .. 1 li _I\ •/ ' 6 i •it , 'I e I . . • ELECTRICAL SYMBOL LEGEKD: I I I I • !.. I e---• i',..',.:',7,:',',7"''' I i ,i 1 1 • 1 . I.,.,,..:•,,/ I 4.2. VA...1••1,,,,P.1A.,..pl:,.: or,.,,,.,,,,„ I .0_, ....-.1•Fi.v.,. . .1 I 1 . r. ,I.V1,1••',/, Z rlri.,1'6,1:7•11,,, .6, IV,1/2 te: I I ...,,,,,,,1•,:ile",:f h < :•:11,,,•11, •••t/.1 V.I.I 1 • . r p '11/1,,JA, 1 i I I I r ,... ,:,,,r^s,r 14,,.-,r,,, 0 r.•47,7i.',!;',',„...;. I ' A , 1 I 11 A.1,,!•..,!..,.„. . 1 i \ .., •1 <-=---h- 1,1'rt..,"efl er . • I 1 I 1 \ i'• '.-;'j'ill:gfr,,'=.71..'!::/,':•f;',1:7,=-7g.1:11!...."'.',,,,,,, ...-.II.::...--.,- II i I . • I 1 .., w I I \ , 0, \ ' 1 f of w . i \ 0 --- I I .._ . . l Ln •< Z Lii F4 \ —1 --- [-."'t 1:I-- II • '01.:41-errt'01.1.;14:•;IT';t I Perk, CZ'Ir•-• e .I 6 re , 1 i . , .,• ........ , .1 .., 1 . •,..,,,,...,7%1M,GRA,:I.',cla,nre11110 1,15,11e/ LI 8 6 0 . m , -ellTA.[TM 4.1 Lel!V MC,4,1.2...1 C•I',..r.,--.1,...., 0:..,' 2 ,:-.„,mon riyry,r Ir.,I,rx 5,t1--. • ! 7..7 ... T-- ----J-V.,•,i,-...' • 1 I I I It 1 —I ; ,i'l I I'-- . . Li r r . 1 ':I 7,11.....;-----,--"I'•," "i 7:1'.• i e . 1 i (..0:e',ID.'0 It.LI•et•e'''C.c.e-r,:,,,,..,41 I•/..1,145,01,“-^lIS I.... I . .--.:•t:-..,.. .'- -.7.1:1' '' U K' I I ,C\!;;‘,7",,;,•`:.g7,;'.,,,., "-- 1 I ,im ,. (—.-..-1e4 Me,P.N1.1•1:V11,1146,IIR 70 CI._'AWL/0 e4,-/ I Ltl 1 I ' I 1:I ,,/' 11;.t l.„'. • ---r.---'s. a: t,, WALL LEGEND: s,/ fi. CTICE \\..., l'! I U n,i 04 Zi2 i I i '`„V:f-d.i. I IV Li ........ .. __ ... a. >,- .,....,--=2:lo.4,,le 1,1170 1.1.1,1'M le,IV,A,-,41,4. -- • Pan 6\',( 4,ns..m e..,,,V_tie. 1 0 < - I•.' ._ -1. r ri1.41 ee,C1,111.11 lo Pe,•,.. /I, , , U g symaoLs LEGF,Npi •_ , .. , D v.cm rrpc.ts,e.v-...1-rsur I k 1 I ..' . --. . " "r•-7C-7•I'-'1-...tIll--r_j a „oc.Pwrekrre,e.,14 I ..•'/ eteCl,rrel.tel e'...ErtIS / illbliglikleb..... O. b/•,11 rm.".rr.e,./ , I. . • I 1 , .1' :In ARCHITECTURAL 11-11R1:) FLOOR PLAN . 1 i 15^-411. .II-e I 1 I VA' ,Ce, ,... . . I I CAC,'11'., ; • • ---•- -. - . I ejel le. FLOOR AREA: / ( • 23C I.C. • :WI.AC...1 ••>Wee!A IT '.I.k.)Il.le reet Pr,4,1,4• e,ea II, 1.1;.•2‘:. 1.FP_,..\.',:: I r'fill 11.".1i•J1:[ . 16,,Iltt,I. / -,e,I,,1,0 \•,1I.6.,?"• '0. I . -...._.....• / I I . A4.0 0 CO.(4.,.:',ZZI.IC.2,1C1 I .1.:•••••::..Z.";7:1,:....Z7i:r..-1.'I l'I•‘ 6. -Z- I ' . ,.. ' ' 1 I.7' • I 1 I I A . I r I. / - I In I r iA MATERIAL KEYING LEGEND ri —1."„ .s :' ,''- Elatld_ ' 1 e. I �.r7•u.alt�l^e ( I I I 1 .I. . 9, •1 ^fl.R.'gl.^.ritVhI43 Alt-,110'G1'EU•rem,' I • reasN.ert_�.�1i' � eor_.»rt rtcr. I I I ). efr wp I 1 x: ri I ). rNS� la 5.e' se, I N II_:) ..T \--rc COCAFR rcn, -+-I I 1I ��-•rAl�vl S Era:N,i nF>r�-crt r_� VI.DOC.I ' _ 7 Ere scar;:r EI .L— . rn:.rbMn \ t 1.11 J8 WINDOW JAMB Z 3",.1•-0" HEAD SIMILARW - Q Ex,:...__, UY U i(. V) k :tiJ --_-I_ __ ....._._Frs•w1 co,"ecrEaa•t 1,-cr 7- for;e:_F i ._._.._rm.eto:ETC,"a:O!:At, __Im id -, C!{IK OA7;tR P^J E lCfilA' I \ '— Q?.E�e= <,c; O Il /Q�� C Pe;COCO!rEnr ,, II c:N'b.!fYr•�nt•!Wr V;�,0 Y U. Txr II [ 7 1 = . StCOL \ r?ECAST CO•C.r:2 EE: / L ..._ T1 I �6 E%tEV Eny 0 I- I Li NE%,Ec'OC E'I:GO I - ', s E"tr$471 ��CC.:CRE.E r'_CC.0 W>D f 1:0103.MA \I.4 r,r N C CC/3 V/e151A'10 I I/1'6Tr\,t COn09 I-.T` {{! %:01 E4 WINDOW SILL E5 I DECKING DETAIL Q, 3�i o E I'If3'%%E• I U 0 earn.nw..ve -exv.•,a rote vr rX/E•P}ICp: VRLLIA I'r'roc, it TnO Id rP.I.r�Ci M V N6,1.....,'�.I IR•G�.4Y pOAop bYIl:F3 'O_ _rL i Y'OC, lim. /� y TAIW.5EE :':. '�- rIcdICPE2 IflOG: - M cne s2- l ac rtna_ fY ___ 1 'J_�x lrryryr 1\ .EE C•YAJ -:f5 f%1[RCt S�YYA +I. LI_.1 I..a 7'kl/r. bL['rCR• Li F. LI ] - { 1{$'I , / I:(I''1 v_e/e.;a r3AO V1t•')e_3•ST^E`Se CnV.:__CitsE, :xrt t;a I s[e:w•r. a"c exati�r1=" 33A 02, ,ort`M'X I0'/r•lrAt21t 1 LC' I 5EF l.ve'.•[ w':I l-vu tMCVe Ei rle na'Itf[O •c• V.isa GW:II K. r:EVI'xtCrrr,t? I4.V'0,# I.III rkm Fr eaTr.VlC,0.11 I'I'he. Moll YL am nVl M ne.M nn, 9It, I• et.'LEQD II i.:L'1 v.a!' I rrcjwl n__�-r r:�ru1n�`T 5577 S Cva•:Ee,ot•,r4'A4xtm.51 nv/tvn Erl. lac :Il�_,.t4O4TlG!tC4t4 CIt2ITC ee.,I.rSrlfl I , _ C4OYTr.RRv,J 4`D rtErt3�KTIL4W 1 I ..,Ii.I:C [L4. L. TH114.11 t•e.'•t.e 1 A4 REMOVABLE STORM PANEL A8 EXTERIOR DOOR JAMB D1 BUCK ATTACHMENT A5.0 ' — 3"•*1•-0• (AS REQUIRED BY CODE) 3•.0•-0" HEAD SIMILAR H.T.S. (� 'E Aio tc�s,r+c, MI I 1 I .1 A . ./ 1 II ' / 1 E. 1 I III I 11 I '2 .113 I II I /4 ftiIIJiI 0 0 1 i( 7 i 1110.11111' I 1., a .1__1' li . ,,z,,,,,,477..111 005110 00701 brrne3 I- 11---1. 11 11 il : 11, ' r It ,..n.,• 1 .!:[flOi. ..rd -ct: rillIN 1 1- Siati icill "tf. /-, I' 41.1,,,.-A,s,C,T(tH0r7oY43n.1z,173, I 1 .,.:•-..._1_—„_.A.__A._._ 1 0D0IWM6 1 1 rm . . . . _. 3I1 FP AIR P413(T•DOCt 'I I0N11D),0CG 01 10001001.111 IKT 1.0C0 0.106 -—... •••.. irri3O,-11 , n wo lO1 1 - , - ( 0z v) , (/) •4 0 (i 1 (l) l'I I 1 ‘1 . 1 7 e >1 il , L >-6 W LLI 8 I Er', _ l',/ -1 __ _ . ...U.__ . Ill' II o,.,,,, 1 SEDDIO 510(117100100) • 0 0)co F- 0 M X 101.1%V r 1 ?id —, r k I) A A 2,:' An_k A t i Al F-- 1 ENTRY ELEVATION (UJEST/AIA) ) MUD V ITS10",NO IDNYTA7 70 MD(CD01/OD Yr DM 040,1,•1111£10, 0 SCALD V1.•I.D. . .,...'''' II, 7 - 'F'Er'ut14 e/sE/7.11VIIVETIATF 0 MI/010111010010. --—-- .-1 I _ Ho ) -i-d, i 010011 V \ 1)11n/a 01110 14/01,011t ID 0111001)01111000( L l<1 i i_LLO I — .--f-..t. I .---- NM G.0/0.11.1 kV 70 01/0/0,0. t••:...,0•I ?I ; Z g .-1111 .-' (045C 7/ U"•i I , lillr'---,7,- c,1, i ---. -._ rill ----111fiN / 11/0/111_,::; :,...__,......„... '..Iffill( 41=1_ -,....ittf2_,il 11 t 1ft 11 ill fl 1- l'''Tr' MjI!P'Thb 1 1 iat_..f. ...„ , ,.. __ d1 ,,N-72,7,1 -,,,,...,z4. &::72,- - -,,g,,,pr,..-, s, a r_ r-.. t- --1 ' 1 NT tre YTS IC 1U'.Mg. ' ' Ills ill ' ,, 4t) .I I i a• ( IVA`KV,. l_'• I, / , ...... „‘ -, TO 10 1 I I J t IL / _ _ . _. _ 0,00. 14. .. . _.. --- Ell 1/I D NC A2 0100101 05 1001 Dr•',17 He SOUTH ELEVATION max II f0f:ILK,Eh 4I1D RD em DOT(PC0100111urr /1 EC../1 E.V I'•r.r• nil 01,031.1 TS KAY I,fl..0 imIrr, A 6.0 \ G CODE mcrrtrcrs r.rc,2000 .--- / / A i A I . i / i / i 1.• , .. • ,., ,, 1 e , „ ( '' • 4 I ',.. 1• 1; I / I II I 1.1 , III 1 11 1 12 I 1,1 , 14 I l 1 1 11.1A4A4/5°\4 iki A4,AIR 11) A 4 1 -.-_--- Intl5/V 0011113 WO 11,110£TO 111101 • I 1 I 1 1 NA•10 V ; • i g ... KV 011/1111011/101001101.11-0.0 MO,----••\ 1/ , r 1 A la MITIR i ' .- .. ---- 1)t 1 I-11 k 1 II . 10•15,11-.011•01-1,10 WW1 I A.ift[11.tf}:.'•...i..L.lj 41 'i 1.0/1,dt 1.11 .,1 . .J iiti tit,i : I r 1 4 ,0 , . ..... _J.._ ___,_ , 4 :.,,,,7,...,,:&7,77..,;,?..ra:e:W.-A7;1::;.%./.7,7iii: ---7,:f,:f''''''' ( ., . , ,' ii,, 1' _ 1'elfz, ... -- ,-,75:-Sc: _______ 111171.KEIVIT1,101111-111LIO000 11111.11.10. 0.11AAA 0 - ..1()‘ --i------ 11.- , 1111 - --, 91- --i ir \, , i 4 f t ' l'fd i , i 0{{} l' 11111 I I lit llgI( 11 li' II •il ($7)\ (q•I,L1) )...,k;gi.:•lei,...t,,,, • . 1 : •„ 11 H ...../ ,---_. Li . 0...) Z AI LJ .; •-•1 I 1 I „,,, • 1 -/cm ":--crIN 111 ,, ,,,. 1 ,/ 1 ' --- —• WA C.r.,11)PDC 5,1,19,30 C) V) ' 10 TO I I' • / I R.,Prflf,17 C/LT,OL'IPM101.1.111,4MI - Z / 00 , ./ (' III'11 LJ 59 p . .4,....-er • ___ ...,.,..„. ..—_ . I - -1 8 ,,. 1.,f)W-TX1,1323=1.t.O.XN-.)15 <(2?t• 2 FT.F1%,1,151131!It SIM'IVORR C12 ,,AUL 0 NV CCKPLIF Tr CLAM Ale(Sat,51.,,, i lal 43 1,),(I! 1.1.1 a I.. EAST ELEVATION (ATLANTIC OCEAN) 11 I i . 1i ,' 'f 6,..4.Er VI'•1,r (- , k 1 I Z 1 0,1110 KI/111.02,t.r.rot 10 11/riA/1 11 - I -•-'. `61'1 ) ..., cl . '11 1 • I- • z i iiWn ).;:61 1 ,iii,;11', .1 [ „Iilr,,,,,,„„,1 ,,,,, ,-,-,,, , . iii .-„ , ---„T,„. ,.:„.,., ., •,.•,., ',..r;I -.....,...,..----...„,„,..,...,.... ........ ••••••. 0.. ' 1 if tirt •i-rilblii• 0 i -11/1/11/a 'fit ' ' '.. - i 0 ;t fr, 1 1 r elf,itilli k . iti.4 - .I , . iL 20._ . s,--,.11,4 f-. ,'. --lit ' 1 ii ,, _ _!. .,----- 1.1,-Til. .,,,,,,.RI PM 111101111/071G ••- •-•••••\ K1, p mi..,ftg !Ft5,4 01001,011114X1010.1EIC(11.011/001,0t0 MCC 1019,16,OARS- - • - I 'Ill - 1 • '•1 , i/ rf.FLRMOE KT.WI l'AVC,1115 MIT/ I----F,-.- ,I.L--,111 1,1 I I ,,I ' IMI 1 114 IMI III ' 14..1 1,410G11,1-011.10101,014,11 --- I_...III .----- 1E1111171E Kt 101,1101 7/13 --•• • -- • 7'77,-11 11- ..1 I ii Jul 1 ! _ f .• 1 '.__. 11•1101101011111.-0 F191 3A.10 MATO.11,011,13 -) MU%P .1)1ACV 11\11'11(V 1 tf.) ----tX151111151Cal/4r, I 1 I .C.MietOrtIVOIT1 ..(..--• 10•01'1, re1111,211.111 i r. TO W11.191t 1411.A4 MALI V.' "\..\ Z 1 fr1LW 11 11-11C/311;aE xre. • (( -,,,..- ...-•••,) , 10111101•10.WW1 ma,"I, /-••''' "3 i). I V It 1 I. 1 I . C101)0 NYC. 0,11 CFNAVI14 1,1111111011,1011111- 10,1151-11 ,/ -.I'.] - onTro 11,0 10 TUN fvo RI 10 tirCSI tvil. Si II 1 !I . ,." ELEVI.DWG LIME!.C5,}CO A4 NORTHELEVATION ftr.YY.UMA 1C it01 IMIX1.110011 SPX0.0 1010M 10 211A11 r K.,.I/4 I.O. , „ _, I A7.0 ' ......_ MItt II 11,1110 1, Cl COOL I001100.7,S.00,2001 I I t I , I . I / ' - r r HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH ---STAFF REPORT-- MEETING DATE: January 2, 2002 AGENDA ITEM: M.O. ITEM: Consider a Certificate of Appropriateness and Associated Class III Site Plan Modification for the Sundy Inn Restaurant, to Allow the Expansion of the Outdoor Dining Area. • I L II 1 Ui 11 ' NAP.TIr. LUTHER KING JR.. DRIVE T � I N.F 2ND S l I I 1 a e < CITY HALL A rt.,k 1ST S7 N._. 1ST ST. . GENERAL DATA: 1. h w Vi COMMUNITY i_ CENTER i' ner Sundy Estates L.C., Inc. - TENNIS i_ I� OLD _ STAD/U!. S NOOL plicant/Agent Michelle Balfoort I SQUARE Balfoort, Finnvold Architecture, Inc. ATLANTIC ' A V C N U r Location Southwest corner of S. Swinton i Avenue & S.W. 1st Street 1 COUNTY I i I I COURT ■ Property Size 2.12 Acres i HOUSE II Land Use Map Other Mixed Use 1 <in Current Zoning OSSHAD (Old.School Square 1 - • Historic Arts District) 1 is u Adjacent Zoning North: OSSHAD S.W. _1ST ST. S.E. 1ST ST. East: OSSHAD a I I I I I I I I i iyi$ : South: CF (Community Facilities) a si :::.I..� I: West: RM (Medium Density Residential) & 1 w CF a - • Existing Land Use An 8,661 sq.ft. Restaurant with a �• III j Residential-Type Inn and Botanical S.W. 2ND S7. S.E. 2ND ST. Gardens. a ; ii l Proposed Land Use Site Plan Modification to allow a 487 Ai _ ' . j sq.ft. expansion of the outdoor _ I- 'N IN i NI i` I Vl= dining area at the northeast corner i mi of the site (re-allocation of existing ;1 floor area). i • Water Service Existing on-site. S.w 3RD ST. S.E. 3RD ST. Sewer ServicA Existing on-site. MERRITT i PARK • • N - • • Ili.c. ITEM,BEFORE THE:BOARD The action before the Board is approval of the COA and associated Class III site plan modification request for Sundy Inn Restaurant, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.5(G)(1)(d). The subject property is located on the south side of SW 1st Street, between S. Swinton Avenue and SW 1st Avenue, and includes a parking area at the northeast corner of SW 1st Street and SW 1 St Avenue, within the Old School Square Historic District. BACKGROUND_ The subject property consists of Lots 1-3, Sundy Estates Plat (1.435 acres), Lots 9 and 10, Block 61, Town of Linton (0.45 acres), and Lot 11, Block 62, Town of Linton (0.24 acres) totaling 2.12 acres. The proposal also involves an off site parking area located on Lots 20-22, Block 70, Town of Linton (10 SE 1st Street). The properties in question are zoned Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD). The following are the most recent land use actions which relate to this development proposal. On March 3, 1998, the City Commission approved the conditional use request for the Sundy Inn, to establish a 23-guest room residential type inn, and a 7,302 sq.ft. restaurant (including outdoor dining) with botanical gardens. The proposal included the provision of parking via the installation of 29 on-site spaces and a 42-space parking area at the northeast corner of SW 1st Avenue and SW 1st Street. The conditional use request was approved with the following conditions: 1. That the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site close by 11:00 P.M.; 2. The floor plan for the first floor suite in the proposed 8-unit structure must be redesigned to eliminate the potential for 2 leasable guest rooms; and, 3. That at least 40% of the guest units are suites. The HPB (Historic Preservation Board) approved the site plan on March 18, 1998. In addition, numerous site plan modifications have been approved for the site. The most significant related to changes to the residential structures and increasing the outdoor dining area interior to the site to provide a total of 8,115 sq.ft. of restaurant floor area. On October 5, 1999, the City Commission approved a conditional use request to allow the expansion of the residential inn development. The total number of guest rooms/suites approved to date is twenty-nine (29). An associated site plan approval has not yet been obtained from the Historic Preservation Board for the expansion. At its meeting of July 17, 2000, the Planning and Zoning Board approved a conditional use modification request to increase the outdoor dining area by 500 sq.ft. in conjunction with relocation of the bar to the southeast corner of the restaurant, resulting in 8,615 sq.ft. of total restaurant area. The proposal included providing the additional required parking via an off-site parking agreement to utilize 16 parking spaces in the parking lot located at the southeast corner of S. Swinton Avenue and SE 1st Street. The Board approved the conditional use modification with the following conditions: HPB Staff Report Sundy Inn Restaurant—COA 485 & Class III Site Plan Modification Page 2 1. That prior to the issuance of a building permit, an off-site parking agreement be executed to utilize 16 spaces of the 20-space parking lot on Lots 20-22, Block 70, Town of Linton. 2. Provision of a mitigation plan to alleviate queuing impacts on Swinton Avenue. An off-site parking agreement has been executed and recorded. Also, revised plans submitted indicating the valet stand would be relocated to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from the beginning of November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M. Subsequent to the conditional use modification approval there were minor modifications to the interior dining areas, which increased the floor area by 46 sq.ft. (8,661 sq.ft.), which did not increase the parking requirement, as there was sufficient parking to accommodate the additional square footage. Expansion of the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site occurred earlier this year. At its meeting of December 17, 2001, the Planning and Zoning Board approved a conditional use modification request to expand the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site, subject to the following conditions: 1. That the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site close by 11:00 P.M.; 2. That revised plans be submitted indicating the valet stand would be relocated to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M.; and, 3. That this approval be subject to a positive recommendation by the Historic Preservation Board. The associated site plan modification is now before the Board for action. PROJECT :DESCRIPTION, The development proposal is to expand the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site by 487 sq.ft. through re-allocation of existing seating area. As the seating area is proposed at the northeast corner (perimeter) of the site, the impacts of the proposed seating area as it relates to adjacent properties is being evaluated. SITE PLAN MODIFICATION ANALYSIS COMPLIANCE WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS: Items identified in the Land Development Regulations shall specifically be addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development application/request. HPB Staff Report Sundy Inn Restaurant—COA 485& Class III Site Plan Modification Page 3 LDR Section 4.4.24(G)(4)(b) and (c) (OSSHAD Parking Requirements): LDR Section 4.4.24(G)(4)(b) and (c) states that restaurants shall provide six (6) spaces per one thousand square feet of total new or existing floor area being converted to restaurant. Residential type inns shall provide one (1) parking space for each guest room/unit, and any other nonresidential floor area requires one (1) space per every 300 sq. ft. of floor area. The Sundy Estates 'proposal is constantly evolving with the current approval for 8,661 sq. ft. restaurant area, 29-guest rooms and a 300 sq. ft. greenhouse. The parking is being assessed on the uses that currently exist and/or are under construction. As development proposals are submitted for approval for the 17 remaining guest rooms (29 proposed, 12 completed), the parking requirement will be reevaluated. Given the current site development plan the 8,661 sq. ft. restaurant 52 parking spaces, and the 12 units require 12 parking spaces, for a total of 64 parking spaces. The proposal provides 64 parking spaces, which are accommodated in the following manner: • 42 parking spaces on the north side of SW 1st Street; • 4 parking spaces within the 4-unit guest house; • 2 spaces at the valet drop-off area; and, • 16-space parking area at the southeast corner of S. Swinton Avenue and S.E. 1st Street (currently being used by and under same ownership as the Sundy House). Stacking: As previously discussed, revised plans must be submitted indicating relocation of the valet stand to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M. REQUIRED FINDINGS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.5(G)(1)(c)(Class Ill Site Plan Modification), a modification to a site plan which represents either a change in intensity of use, or which affects the spatial relationship among improvements on the land, requires partial review of Performance Standards found in LDR Sections 3.1.1 and 3.2.3, as well as required findings of LDR Section 2.4.5(G)(5). LDR Section 2.4.5(G)(5) (Findings): Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.5(G)(5), a finding that the proposed changes do not significantly affect the originally approved plan must be made concurrent with approval of a Class III modification. HPB Staff Report Sundy Inn Restaurant—COA 485& Class III Site Plan Modification Page 4 Within the Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD), "outdoor dining which operates at night or which is the principal use or purpose of the associated restaurant " is allowed as a conditional use. With the original conditional use approval of March 3, 1998, establishing the residential type inn and outdoor dining areas, positive findings were made with respect to Future Land Use Map Consistency, Concurrency, Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Compliance with the Land Development Regulations. Positive findings were also made with the conditional use modification approvals on October 5, 1999, to allow the expansion of the residential inn development to 29 units, and on July 17, 2000 to expand the outdoor dining area by 500 square feet. There will be no impacts with respect to Concurrency. This modification request relates expansion of the outdoor dining area through re-allocation of existing seating area, thus there will be no impact with respect to Concurrency. The current proposal seeks to expand the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site by 487 sq.ft. This is a re-allocation of existing floor area. As noted above the proposed addition will not have any impacts with respect to Concurrency. Positive findings with respect to compatibility with adjacent properties were made with the conditional use request subject to the following conditions: that the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site closes by 11:00 P.M.; and, revised plans are submitted indicating the valet stand would be relocated to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M. REVIEW BY :OTHERS: The development proposal is located in an area, which requires review by the CRA (Community Redevelopment Agency), DDA (Downtown Development Agency) and WARC (West Atlantic Redevelopment Coalition). Community Redevelopment Agency: At its meeting of September 27, 2001, the CRA reviewed and recommended approval of the conditional use and site plan modification requests. Downtown Development Authority: At its meeting of September 19, 2001, the DDA reviewed and recommended approval of the conditional use and site plan modification requests. West Atlantic Redevelopment Coalition: At its meeting of October 10, 2001, the WARC reviewed and recommended approval of the conditional use and site plan modification requests. HPB Staff Report Sundy Inn Restaurant—COA 485& Class III Site Plan Modification Page 5 Courtesy and Neighborhood Notices: Notices have been provided to the following homeowner's and civic associations: • • Delray Beach Chamber of Commerce • Old School Square Historic Arts District • Presidents Council • Progressive Residents of Delray - ASSESSMENT -.AND..._.CONCLUSION , The development proposal to modify the outdoor dining area is consistent with Chapter 3 of the Land Development Regulations and the policies of the Comprehensive Plan. Positive findings with respect to LDR Section 2.4.5(E)(5) (Conditional Use Findings) have been made in the staff report. A limit on the hours of operation to 11:00 P.M. within the outdoor dining areas in addition to the extensive landscaping has negated compatibility concerns with respect to the adjacent properties. Revised plans must be submitted indicating the valet stand will be relocated to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the COA and associated Class III Site Plan Modification for the Sundy Inn Restaurant, based on positive findings with respect to Chapter 3 (Performance Standards), and Section 2.4.5(F)(5) (Finding of Compatibility) of the Land Development Regulations and the policies of the Comprehensive Plan subject to conditions. C. Deny the COA and associated Class III Site Plan Modification for the Sundy Inn Restaurant with basis stated. STAFF, RECOMMENDATION Approve the COA and associated Class III site plan modification for Sundy Inn Restaurant, based on positive findings with respect to Chapter 3 (Performance Standards), and Section 2.4.5(F)(5) (Finding of Compatibility) of the Land Development Regulations and policies of the Comprehensive Plan subject to the following conditions: 1. That the outdoor dining area at the northeast corner of the site close by 11:00 P.M.; and, HPB Staff Report Sundy Inn Restaurant—COA 485 &Class III Site Plan Modification Page 6 2. That revised plans are submitted indicating the valet stand will be relocated to the southernmost portion of the valet drop-off area, from November through the end of April, between Noon and 2:00 P.M. and 7:00 P.M. and 9:00 P.M. • Attachments: • Location Map • Sketch Plan • • ..• 1 -- i =1 -,7 v —7— I y . I ; .. .--- ' 1L-.1 Li _1 . < :4J i lit ]< < < > / NW 1ST ST ST. . . N.W. 1ST ST- 1..L.1 _ J II/ --- 1 _____ _ -'- : Pi CV COMMUNITY ._ D ._ " _ CEA'TER —7- 'y I ‘. I:____• .. . _ > I TENNIS _, OLD -.., ,S 1 ADIUm . < SCHOOLL'i L . . . Lj J •::: i , , , Z . • • ) SOLI ARE z ! ' ' 7i / I 1 ' . '-..i • ATLANTIC AVENUE 1 po,/:;:- SOUTH r 1 . . , , . . . ! / COMPLEX i COUNTY 1 COURT I HOUSE I . ---iL, „g 1 --r- _ I. . , —I • > < > _ Li ::•3*.K:::::•:* —.7 1 . 1 I .:::::;::::). - -; i I iliE:E:K:ki:., igm::1 I r--1 I S.Y. YST ST. I I.'.V.. 1ST ST. S.E. 1ST -- z. 7 I • I i I I-- 1 / I V":"Mi.:•>:+:•:•:•:•:•:•:• :.:.:<•:.:W*. I I I . . I > I<: -4:::;:;K:::::::::•::::::::::::::: W.1:::).,56t. L_ , , , < , , , .....,..............: ::: :::::y. ,--t- :.:::::::, ::::::: 7 1 1 1---- .1---1 , i 1 1 I ,! I Ln I 7 Li IV ! 1 , . i .........):.: .......... ,___ 1 1----- I,- , I 1 I I Iv' i 1 ,. . T—in I I 1 0 =_- r1 1---&-1 I-- 1 1 . 1--- • S.W. 2ND ST. S.Z. 2ND ST. ' // . . . , • • • • • I !! !. ! • 1 i .. z ! . 0 i __ ,,, 1 I-- • L., 1 ..5 1_ -zi 1 i _..., ,,_i . 1 .. 1 1 I-7 1 . 1 , : cr) .-1 L_ / Li 1 Li :-.--.1 Llil vi . I I ______ i vi 1 j ( I in' I--- ST. _ S.E. 3RD ST. S.E. 3RE' ST. i 7 7 MERRi 77 I I I 1 I I 'r I ,----n-' I I I i vi I ,_ __ I N I . --iiime-- SUNDY INN CITY 07 DELRAY BEACH. FL PLANNING e.: ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIC.:ITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MA. RE 7: LW.377 I AI " .n.11 Im,.m rNINII is I J (entroonT rimtEvo1-v nnol RTranmr-,INC. 4 -'-- 1.. _ — __ .Nato 4.l�,r.N _ _ . — -- I 4 ={mot ,- -� --_. bVunsCLA 11_SIILCALCUl1Agp71L-- rAra,ro cAttuMM*t1_- /� /� ION /�r� C \) MAP l/btu IMPr4H, �•lo Y•-,N.-u.w - - LUC /\I IC)N M/\1 \�/ IVI/\h \II� mIn.l CIA KEY 1,... .�, ^^0 ,....P,�,........"'.." �........�� Ira MeNaII�A I.w tvet ar. 1.re[ RCALEI H.I.R. MTV, 1a1.� MI.1..MOM-plaaal.I. SCALE! N.I.R. ...., ill.t'. MIMI MI Nall j� .reM I:9 Y': "r"� rv ��attamar.ax tPa a.•v. I.e«w.rna rnarEnlY uNE .•,.... tea,.. �.,., ..Imalient WI I..,��:.....P.... lal r tm RA .an a..v. n m w r t•a� IMANIMMIMIll rare°Nu a�v. to t°n r. 1 I.T.tr. .,I jr.._ 8111A AIEA -Tr TIT=-I.--' --. /�;'%i.,• j%' .R/7•AI�IlII PII..ww tiler V..4 r.. eP., 7,U,T S.E. I-CI r.. 1 1 )';.' __. Kan,IP:IT+. M1,40•.•Ilr�,.IPaa .--- —1=—r ;," r/ y - jinn.IA v m.. m v. Av urm Ilwwe ` ewer,mem er-m ern 4I A '17'9f a a a DININA A ` ' �i• 4;qS1218II AUNONY 1 + A 4-r Ilwiw le, u.,..,mow. r`�w II d,rr w P,TI C.. • 1- ICIICIIEN • yj o ) *-_-1- 0):1 971'LIR;. "IsiTI a�-•••'•,•, p s,'� ,�r., ,r ��� - I A� / �:�c:�: n',�'.'ea�.aru+. aaaww.wr....nw. -- �`�_.� ,� ---Iw.w 4..111 v,w► [:�� • NOUN!TITATP/ APDLU,IIC AREAS C rI I'� :� { ' v.'amI Iw ar. IAA,IYtIfR71 AYE . ;."',; .y ('1:: ev ii/,• !%^ DUN p MAAI OAN nae :n I/ o r l n F. f t Cy ACp •,r NlEA J:� All �� TJ Ii�-_ Mir. —u�/ la . w : --7 i'jt:�iii, oo gg `/`. , iJl2 �� //�� P,v. a .nl v .P. 10lIDI �y1�1 IU<XNI _ 1 ! /\IIIY1! : .+a nP1eA w/A ii^i .�.v. di �66 , zi,,�. 1 AREA/51/1 ._ —,. r _yaNa .+��. AN rr A CAE r.. •.':i�; --- Q �...',. O pN4E a .nt .•a.MR M.M. um 1.�.w ,In R � %1 �� r jI r: J,JAp s . ,,' .rrk,• p \r pip O 6IOUf1 ,,` �. J•Y' yi:y 1N3 O % y" \� J. % NiCA%I / ..A ° TL* rAM! ° �\\ LHS-I4,I5A S.E. - woo*,CCI.Pa EXISTING SUNDY ROUSE SITE PLAN 7 \/ \J �► i7��/{7V�SCALE: J/Jz'-I'-o' --- \�J_------ — — --- /\I.R9[t�