Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
HPB-01-06-1999
DELRAY BEACH tritd All-America City ' I 1! ® AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: January 6, 1999 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES • November 18, 1998 • December 2, 1998 HI. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-9-368: 38 S. Swinton Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Old School Square Historic District. John Szerdi or Glen Rimpela, Authorized Agents. Approval for a Re-Roof from Wood Shingles to Copper Shingles. B. COA-9-369: Safari Steakhouse, 4 E. Atlantic Avenue, Contributing Commercial Building, Old School Square Historic District. . Steve Hall, Owner of Business. Approval for a Projecting Wall Mounted Sign. C. Pre-Application COA-9-370: Music Club, 30 E. Atlantic Avenue, Contributing Commercial Building, Old School Square Historic District_ Butch Johnson, Owner. Comments and Direction for Proposed Front Façade Changes. HPB Meeting January 6, 1999 Page 2 IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN 4/. Pa Cayc Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: December 31, 1998 U/Agenda/HPB-1-6-99 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD ATTENDANCE LOG 1997/1998 MEETING DATES DEBORA JOHN I SUSAN ANTHONY I BETTY VERA TONY 09/03/97 P P P P P P P 09/17/97 C AN C E L E D 09/30/971 P P P P P P P 10/15/97 R E SC HE DU LE D 10/22/97 A P P P A P P 11/05/97 P P P A P A P 11/19/97 P P A P P P P 12/03/97 A P P P A P P 12/17/97 C AN C E L E D 01/07/98 P P A A P A P 01/21/98 P P P A P P P 02/04/98 P P P A A A P 02/18/98 P P P P P P MEETING DATES DEBORA JOHN SUSAN SHANE BETTY VERA TONY 03/04/98 P P P P A A P 03/18/98 P P P P P P P 04/01/982 P A A P P A A 04/15/98 P P P P P A P 05/06/98 P P P P P P P 05/20/98 P P A P P A A 06/03/98 A A P P A P P 06/17/98 P P A P A P P 07/01/98 A P P A P A P 07/15/98 C AN C E L E D 08/05/98 A A P P P P P 08/19/98 C AN C E L E D 1 Meeting date rescheduled due to holiday. 2 Meeting canceled due to lack of quorum. • MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: January 6, 1999 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, Betty Diggans, John Johnson. MEMBERS ABSENT: Tony Keller, Shane Ames, William Griffin. STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce. Mayor Alperin was present at the meeting. II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: It was moved by Mr. Johnson, and seconded by Mrs. Diggans and passed 4-0 to approved the minutes from November 18, 1998 and December 2, 1998. \ III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-9-368: 38 S. Swinton Avenue, Cathcart House, contributing single family residence, Old School Square Historic District. John Szerdi or Glen Rimpela, Authorized Agents. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for a change of roofing material from wood copper shingles. It was moved by Mrs. Hurlburt and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 4-0 to approve the use of copper shingles based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E). B. COA-9-369: Safari Steakhouse, 4 E. Atlantic Avenue, contributing commercial building, Old School Square Historic District. Steve Hall, owner of the business. - 1 - 1/6/99 h Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval for an illuminated projecting wall mounted sign on the front (E. Atlantic Avenue) elevation. It was moved by Mr. Johnson and seconded by Mrs. Hurlburt and passed 4-0 to approve the sign with the following condition: • That the sign be removed or altered to conform with the approved design when façade renovations commence. C. COA-370: Pre-Application: Music Club, 30 E. Atlantic Avenue, contributing commercial building, Old School Square Historic District. Butch Johnson, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of giving comments and direction for proposed front façade changes. No formal action was required. The Board felt that the revisions to the front façade presented a good contemporary version of Streamlined Moderne, which complimented the details of the 1939 Moderne building to the east (32 East Restaurant). The Board encouraged the applicant to go forward with the design as presented. However, the Board requested that formal plans indicate elevations of the existing structure as well as the proposed changes. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members Mrs. Hurlburt said that a request had come to her attention to completely drop the Vista Del Mar historic designation. The request was that the designation report review should be removed from the January 20, 1999 HPB meeting. Mrs. Hurlburt stated that there was great dissention in the neighborhood as a result of the proposed designation and that a petition had been circulated by those who were opposed to the designation. -2- 1/6/99 • l C. Staff Mrs. Cayce said that she had a copy of the petition and that at least 21 owners were opposed. But that the January 20th date had been established at the meeting in June 1998 and, therefore, the Board must go forward with the formal review of the designation report. The Chair questioned whether it would be necessary to take public comments at the meeting as the Board had already heard public comments at the April and June, 1998 meetings. Mayor Alperin stated that in his opinion public comments were at the Chair's discretion and if the item went forward to the public hearing there would be an opportunity for all interested parties to be heard. V. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mrs. Hurlburt moved to adjourn the meeting at. 7:00 p.m., seconded by Mrs. Diggans and passed 4-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on f2�i�zz, 1/ -194 If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -3- 1/6/99 STAFF REPORT B O R D Project Name: COA-9-368, Cathcart House Project Location: 38 S. Swinton Avenue FO RE - THE =BOARD, The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a change of roofing material from wood shingles to copper shingles. The Cathcart House was constructed in 1902. It is currently the residence and office of Virginia Snyder. Cathcart House was purchased by the developers of the Sundy Inn and the Rectory Building and will eventually become a part of their south Swinton Avenue project. The unifying stylistic element of the development is the use of copper roofing. :.PROJEC.T DESCRIP7TIO;N Remove the existing wood shingles and install copper shingles. Shingles will be treated with an aging verdigris patina. .,. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. RE-CO, MMEN.D:AT,ION . 1. Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve the copper shingle roof associated with COA-9-368. File/u/coa-9-368sr Meeting Date: January 6, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-A 1 REVERE COPPER PRODUCTS ' BENNINGTON SHINGLES . Roofing That Reflects Your Style \� \ „✓ ! " � — 'sac R . j ':� i � _:dam . Z. ji,4,iiir 31 4. * # ------,- _ No ......„,„_,---.. . . _ • ....„ -- ' • ...• • . -. . . _.- -...._, . . • ..•••••"1.,—••----,-... -... ......_." • .".c.44,;I 1. ,•:3•••— --;-..,„---.. -....I-. ' •• ....--•,--...;-;__::„.....-----• --4--------.....;____--,., •-i•-z---.:1-r:-.€:--,-..• : ....,.--,-•;.----,-71-:--••- -- _ - -------:--,---,...-- _-- -- • rd.' • - - • .. .. ,-••• jorivIrrel -. • 4 L ------.77::::7.7t ... . ... ,:. - ";' ...• .. ,::....._---...----- :....:....,.--------7:--7;;;;-.".:::::::?:;,:to, 1't:.I''''''... ---L"..: .1.•4.-••••• ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''• - -:. • . .• 4.•.; 4. -•.‘ •:..I.L. - ./ _ .., • ,,,, .3...•". .0,......a‘. • ,-.,..:•••ei • na.4 II •• • . • • • '."::,,: it ••"1-1.letAkt.. • ''.:1, • . • --I • . ... ' t ' ...• .•.' • -cri!..V.4 '- - - • i . ..• ...r;6,% ••;:,,4%,/, -j•-„. •••• . 1 . : A" ,---F.---• • • •• •-r1;•iir •'.._!, . II; - :44 i ==--_ I ....r,-..„.,• ,. ..... ---.:-.. f_____-- . ....1 V: ml-41,• ''' „••••••iril----Z-T\ 7 AEillt••=L.------7.7.- • .. .— . .e..... •••••••••-: il : . - . . • . •- • -ft,--- f . -lir.• a -4-41- _ trs . A - • - . - -.. ._. .4410 AP., • ...,, •'''91106Pjlit- 1 s ..OAR\1747) GED• - , --•- _ . . - . - ' ',.•• - •. - - - .-.•,.--:• .,-.-......e.--&---•<-.1,te.,2-4•.1 r••••_.7),b.F.,.1-4-Nfu••••••-----,-,se4:•--:••`,,•.:--,--=--- •-: • '----,:-..*::- '- -.---4--.-L-:::Z.-..:_:::_:.e.,••••-•1:_ .74,:-..:4-er.v..T.F.:g.....;;.r... ---,...-4.4t$44--4„..4.1,fq-,f•F.•:,.'-':.-22;•;•:..c•-,-2:;-..•• ;--.--;'-• ---_.: .....:?...4.--.--y---:.-r.:....;„. -.J.-0a...., •.•••• .•••••••.,.4"*-1.per,...•-• .,:•• -T.;,•..1'••..---."....• -"-•• . - -- - . - •,* -,-•-•-•••' --•- -- -"I'-4•• -•-•••-•••-••:::•••-•••1•-""'-,•-••••"/Ie-...•••-••.••:.-A-r.r",--?..:••••.,----..-...•.....,"... -... . `• '.' -. ...''-•- .• a38 South Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach • • _ . • . • • • . • . . • , ,,k\ i STAFFREPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: COA-9-369, Safari Steakhouse Project Location: 4 E. Atlantic Avenue, Historic Rhoden Building TEM ;BEFORE THE :BO:A,RD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for an illuminated projecting wall mounted sign. BACKEROUND= The Board approved fagade renovations, including signage, for the subject property on February 7, 1996, however, the proposed renovations have not yet commenced. The approved plans include the removal of the faux brick and awnings and the use of flat wall signs. The applicant is aware that the sign he has requested may have to be removed or altered when renovations to the building commence. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The two-sided sign is mounted on an aluminum bracket which projects 36" from the wall, and is 30" tall. It will be located above the awning and centered over the entrance door. Two down lights will be mounted on the bracket to illuminate the sign faces. The sign is sandblasted wood in silhouette and painted with an enamel finish. The colors are black, yellow and orange. The text, "Safari Steakhouse"will be a blend of yellow and orange against a black background. The drop of the existing awning will have the same text painted in white 4" letters and will be repeated 3 times in 6' sections across the drop. S T A FF COMMENTS The sign is appropriate to the existing facade. If approved, it will be considered temporary until such time as the approved renovation is completed. At that time the sign may have to be removed or altered to conform to the approved plans. Meeting Date: January 6, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-B HPB Staff Report COA 9-369- Page 2 A:LT'ERNATI<VE 'ACTIONS ;_=' 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented, with the condition the sign be removed or altered to conform with the approved design when façade renovations commence. 1. Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), and the Design Guidelines, approve the sign associated with COA-9-369 with the following condition: • That the sign be removed or altered to conform with the approved design when façade renovations commence. File/u/coa-9-369sr . . . , , , decorative enameled balls V i Bright i ,., 0, T.,. /II . ---1 Image , _,„ , • SIGN SYSTEMS 11111)14ecorative down ' hting ,,,,,, ,,,,••-"N,- ,4°.,..1) - COMIETE DECIMAL DOW'S 1, .1""' , .. !EON ( ,,,:...'',. J1 . .,, ::n1 i ,p COMMERCIAL 6' 4, , , Aluminum fabriatecl structure RESIDINTIN DESIGN 1C)11 t =.' . CIC.M,,,,___ '.;..'."1.'. P , ..1 featuring decorative downlighliig and enameled finish EgAldON VINING 561-278-7814 "MVIt.77:-a ',.):,i,;,,,,..,,,,v1e. ;;;...„.- 561-278-0259 FAX, decoralWe sand lasted .7,-, ,. ,-;:;,-,-,-.1„' ire"""""."77.7,' '1 375 ff 3rd SUM II paneLs wilh enamele finish , ° • *'` ) ocuwpot Rum luni STEAKI-1C)( lqi- . SCALE/NTS ..... --1 ( ) . u till ,e3 sp-r tet,6-re;1-1 (op. II CUSTOMER Lnd View Side View ---4ii lie"/IQ.,/ P. 0 VS 11 'J '...0 .1%•,1 % t.,7.'1 ' '',) i' ' i WW1 ele VA V siari . .......1.1 ktshig„ii,r,' ' ::,'•,, '6 ',:''',f steak ous e . ' • • ,I s.,,, , „' ,, „, ' h•,,,..• jk 44;`1,1,1, ;;' :1,4151;,r3 .,1 1 . i , IT t 1 ,t),, t 11',,:, ',,),,, ,;,,,-;..,''o•,•,,,,,%. P7/;'.74 il ,n: /al 5;4,14'.41 I ti l' '''' /'',''''',''4' '4...? I.'(' ,'• ‘ ,-,,,.. „. 11 ..,,,....ii ,....—'I.'J I DATE ', ' ,',•:,, ,,r, 108/98 ,+r., DRAWN BY: )!ff!T ff4 - caN/ if 41,,. i41) ,f I I,Ili' dtf/OCOgr- et10,1 . rgefose r 3.., 7.sr it Y •a--liaw---- , ') 4,..,-. . .._ , • —— — - - 7h/e Priming/0 the Property of 13rIght image,Inc. _ _ ' 4 1 • 1 l '� • :;4, ♦ � attq* wu &b— Bright Image SIGN SYSTEMS COMPLETE EIECIWON. CtSPLAYS NEON CO'.WEMNL b RFSIDQ4ML DESIGN AWARD WW1NG 561-278-7814 SAFARI STEAKHOUSE SAFARI STEAKHOUSE SAFARI STEAKHOUSE 11 561-278-0259FAX 7 375IE3d STREET ti 9 ,,. :• >r1��i'r' ' , �•�' EEU A-V-TEACH, tnoawa3 .aaI HIAnalleillW A' g t'' `1 N 'f{I I; litf77. ..Alliii. , ,:,I711, I,r , ' a ,4A {Ply,l} y , -v , —7( I I' • +I Ak ,) j •' 1%' I I I � I II u II Ih� �;6 Prlf i i I �~p ^ t;r . � � IL�'i ,- I � II i (rkF / ;i{I� 1�1 pdir `SCALE/Nis ) '! 'r •1 ,,, I,I � • , ; � I, ,Ai ,t,,jL .. 41• { :'N' t, Ivt S 1 , / , l • Wt, j, LLw a' , '••a � rI '' �', : t�,110 R0,Ir�4I��u t 4 �"4 Li"11 - NtAttV'i�zf ',t I I ' ' t �,,,,il!,4 �'r F', ,1� l� LI � dl�ltiti ty I I CUSTOMER a ' I ', ' �r •f14 rN,1� ,� ` „Id , 4�1'c1Ir'Itru,ry r y, trr r' ` t v � r ,,, tI ,,,\,, ,,, Li r.,•.• •.I.r :a,..-..,.,.I..f , .•. . ...•. r..n.ulr4 t. r :: . r .f.# , ,:I.+.nT � • s , 'r!, y 6o5TON5I ir 1 C `qt)'^ r ( ' • , I p l on the beach (, a?I i c II;. I,rl ;I I N,4, ,I,a•I P I'n' .I'.114 i.I I:A,..,. ••.aI,o.l n PI'I I. I 4GLOU /i //O.5 I DATE , '�Eii?R; Ti ,�x �` _ IV18/98 I jI��IS•;ti)�it,,,,r ffl v„t',,III,,', �; /J/ q ((' +: DRAWN BY: _ _ . ,.. ..., f 1u Claw . _,....: .. I .,,,,,5,,,,____,;,,,,, : . ,. . . , .. . ‘,„:„........„),..., `�. ._ Th/e Drawing/e the PPoperty of Br/ght image,/nc. . 1 At torney at Law The Tattered Book . , 9 c? 9 9 kakik.ao . agalaap mksaik CI r= = = = c LJ r • 2 E. Atlantic Avenue PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION 55, t. 17•(•‘,,VIA ig‘ 4R; rA.4 Vo.,Y riT,fz," ria 134;;c`-, 61"a4 t4. A'4;‘;4:1 irj 2/7 /Li?4i 0 1 \ FRTI--1 1- LI- VATIi-IV • • ---0•0011111.1 .111" DELRAY BEACH Wad All-AmericaCity 111111 AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: January 20, 1999 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: COMMISSION CHAMBERS Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) II. DISCUSSION AND ACTIONS ITEMS Formally Review of the Designation Report for the Proposed Vista Del Mar Historic District and Set a Date for the Required Public Hearing. III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-356 Continuation: 115 SW 1st Avenue, Contributing Multifamily Building Associated with the Sundy Inn, Old School Square Historic District. Rodney Romano or John Szerdi, Authorized Agents. Approval for Demolition. B. COA-9-371-Pre-Application: 115 SW 1st Avenue Old School Square Historic District. Rodney Romano or John Szerdi, Authorized Agents. New Construction to Replicate Previously Approved Renovation Plans. The Proposal Will Require a Variance to Allow the New Construction to be Located on the Original Footprint. HPB Meeting January 20, 1999 Page 2 C. COA-9-372 The Anchorage, 60 Marine Way, Contributing Building, Marina Historic District. Jack DeNiro Owner, or Don Day Agent. Approval for the Installation of an Awning on the Second Floor East Terrace. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN GCj Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: January 15, 1999 File/u/agenda/hpb1-20-99 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: January 20, 1998 LOCATION: COMMISSION CHAMBERS I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, Tony Keller, Shane Ames, William Griffin; Betty Diggans and John Johnson. MEMBERS ABSENT: None STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce II. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS Item before the Board Formally review the Designation Report for the Proposed Vista Del Mar Historic District and set a date for the required public hearing. Before beginning the discussion the Chair explained that public comments would not be heard. However, if the Board votes to accept the designation report and set a date for the public hearing, the public would be heard at that time. It was moved by Mr. Johnson and seconded by Mrs Diggans and passed 7-0 to set the date for the public hearing for February 3, 1999 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-365-Continuation: 115 SW 1st Avenue, contributing multifamily building associated with the Sundy Inn, Old School Square Historic district. Rodney Romano or John Szerdi, Authorized Agents. Due to a conflict of interests, the Chairman stepped down and the Vice-Chair took the gavel -1 - 1/20/99 Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for demolition of a contributing building located at the southwest corner of the Sundy Inn property. The applicant is proposing to demolish the building, on the basis that the structure is too deteriorated to be rehabilitated. An evaluation of its structural condition has been provided by the project architect, John Szerdi. The proposal is to reconstruct the structure from the foundation up, while salvaging flooring, siding, etc. as much as is possible. The design will replicate the renovation plans, which the Board approved at its meeting of March 18, 1998. However, in order to reconstruct the building on the same footprint a variance must be obtained. After discussion, especially with respect to the Board's receptiveness to the variance, it was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 6-0 to approve the demolition when the variance is granted and the COA is approved. The variance will allow the building to be reconstructed on its original footprint. B. COA-371-Pre-Application: 115 SW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, associated with the Sundy Inn. John Szerdi or Rodney Romano, Authorized Agents. Item Before the Board: Give comments and direction with respect to constructing a new structure on the footprint of a demolished building (see above comments for COA-356). No formal action was required. The Board suggested that the applicant prepare elevations for the new construction and formally submit the plans with the variance request at a later date. C. COA-9-372: The anchorage, 60 marine Way, contributing building, Marina Historic District. Jack DeNiro, owner, or Don Day, agent. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval to allow an awning to be installed on the second floor east terrace. It was moved by Mr. Griffin, and seconded by Mrs. Hurlburt, and passed 7-0 to approve the awning, based on positive findings with the Design Guidelines -2- 1/20/99 I IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members Mr. Ames questioned a chain link fence on N. Swinton Avenue. It was pointed out that the chain link fence was probably installed before Del-Ida Park became a district. Mr. Ames then asked what could be done about existing chain link fences. Staff said that if they are in such poor repair as to be a code violation, the owners can be cited. Staff said that working through the neighborhood associations to convince the owner to plant a hedge of vines to obscure the fence is about the only remedy. The chair questioned if oral histories were available.' Betty Diggans, who works on the project for the Historical Society, explained that it is an ongoing project and that tapes are available at the archives room. Mr. Griffin asked when the house which was moved to NW 4th avenue will be completed. Staff stated that she didn't know what was causing the delay, as the plans had been approved. C. Staff Reported that the consulting firm of Janus Research started the historic sites survey on Monday, January 18th V. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mrs. Hurlbut moved to adjourn the meeting at. 7:15 p.m., seconded by Mrs. Diggans and passed 7-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board onr.?4h,i /7 , 191. -3- 1/20/99 If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -4- 1/20/99 M E<M O R A N ;D U HISTORIC_... PR.ESE` RVA.TI, ON: BOA'RD. Subject: Formal review of the Vista Del Mar Designation Report The action requested of the Board is to review and comment on the Vista Del Mar Designation Report and to set the Public Hearing date for Wednesday, February 3, 1999. The Board determined that the proposed district generally conformed with historic district status at its meeting of April 4, 1997, and asked that a designation report be prepared, pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1( C)(3). The next step, pursuant to Section 4.5.1 (C)(4), is as follows: upon completion and formal review of the report, the Board shall set a public hearing date on each proposed designation. After conducting the public hearing, if the Board finds that the nomination fulfills the proper designation criteria and all procedures have been followed correctly, it shall vote to transmit the nomination to the City Commission with the recommendation that the district be listed in the Local Register of Historic Places. The City Commission shall consider the recommendation through its standard ordinance adoption procedures. File/u/vistasr Meeting Date: January 20, 1999 Agenda Item: II ARTICLE 4.5 ARTICLE 4.5 OVERLAY AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT DISTRICTS The Districts described in this Article do not establish uses or categorize uses. These Districts, however, do regulate allowable uses in a manner to mitigate adverse impacts of such uses upon the natural or man-made environment; or regulate development so as to mitigate potential dangers to the use of such developed land, or to otherwise implement policies and objectives of the Comprehensive Plan. Overlay and environmental management districts need not be shown on the Official Zoning Map. Section 4.5.1 Historic Preservation Sites and Districts: (A) General: In recognition of findings as set forth in the original enactment of Ordinance 13-87, passed March 10, 1987, this Section is created in order to provide for the identification, preservation, protection, enhancement, perpetuation, and the use of districts, archeological sites, buildings, structures, improvements, and appurtenances that are reminders of past eras, events, and persons important in local, state, and national history; that provide significant examples of architectural styles of the past; that are unique and irreplaceable assets to the City and its neighborhoods; or that provide this and future generations with examples of the physical surroundings in which past generations lived; and other purposes. (B) Criteria for Designation of Historic Sites or Districts: (1) To qualify as a historic site, or historic district, or historic interior, individual properties, structures, sites, or buildings, or groups of properties, structures, sites, or buildings must have significant character, interest, or value as part of the historical, cultural, aesthetic, and architectural heritage of the city, state, or nation. To qualify as a historic site or historic district, the property or properties must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in division (2) or (3) below; to qualify as a historic interior the interior must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in division (2) and meet the criteria set forth in divisions (3)(b) and (3)(d). (2) A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in city, state, or national history (for example, the homestead of a local founding family); (b) Is the site of a historic event with significant effect upon the city, state, or nation; 4501 SECTION 4.5.1 (B) (2) (c) (c) Is associated in a significant way with a major historic event, whether cultural, economic, social, military, or political; (d) Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, economic, or social trends of the community in history; or, (e) Is associated in a significant way with a past or continuing institution which has contributed substantially to the life of the city. (3) A building, structure, site, or district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria; except that to qualify as a historic interior, the interior must meet the criteria contained within divisions (3)(b) and (3)(d): (a) Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles; (b) Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction; (c) Is a historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder; or (d) Contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment. (4) A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historic significance if, in addition to or in the place of the previously mentioned criteria, the building, structure, site, or zone meets historic development standards_as defined by and listed in the regulations of and criteria for the National Register of Historic Places, as prepared by the United States Department of the interior under the Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, A copy of these standards for the National Register is made part of this section as if fully set forth herein. (C) Designation Procedures: (1) Buildings, structures, archaeological sites, or districts which meet the criteria for historic sites or districts set forth in Section 4.5.1(B) may be designated as historic sites or districts, and may be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places. (2) Nominations for historical site or district designation shall be made to the Historic Preservation Board on an application form developed and approved by the Board. 4502 SECTION 4.5.1 (C) (2) (a) (a) Nominations for historic site status may be initiated by: (1) The Historic Preservation Board; (2) The City Commission; or (3) The property owner.. (b) Nominations for historic district status may be initiated by: (1) The Historic Preservation Board; or (2) The City Commission. (3) The Board shall conduct a preliminary evaluation of the information provided on each nomination application to determine if it generally conforms with historic status criteria. • The Board shall then prepare a designation report which shall contain the following: [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (a) proposed legal boundaries of the historic building, archaeological site, structure, or district; [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (b) any proposed conditional zoning regulations designed to replace or complement existing zoning regulations with regard to, but not limited to use, floor area, density, height, setbacks, parking, and minimum lot size; [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (c) analysis of the historic significance and character of the nominated property; and [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (d) analysis of optional historic interiors for those buildings and structures with interior features of exceptional architectural, aesthetic, artistic, or historic significance. [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (4) Upon completion and formal review of the report, the Board shall set a public hearing on each proposed designation. Notice of said hearing shall be made to the owner of affected property at least ten days prior to the hearing by certified mail. Additional notice shall be given in the same manner as provided for a rezoning action [see Section 2.4.2(B)(1)(b)] and by notice published in the newspaper at least ten days prior to the hearing. [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (5) Once the public hearing date is established, no permits shall be issued for any new construction, alteration, relocation, or demolition of the real property included in the nomination. This delay in the issuance of permits will remain in effect until one of the following takes place: [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] 4503 SECTION 4.5.1 (C) (5) (a) • (a) The Historic Preservation Board denies the nomination and no appeal - is filed pursuant to Section 2.4.7(E); or, [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (b) The City Commission formally approves or denies the nomination. [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (6) After conducting the public hearing, if the Historic Preservation Board finds that the nomination fulfills the proper designation criteria and all procedures have been followed correctly, it shall vote on the designation. A majority of the entire Board, present and voting, must act in the affirmative to transmit the nomination and the Board's findings to the City Commission. The City Commission shall consider the recommendation through its standard ordinance adoption procedures, except that at least three affirmative votes of the City Commission is necessary to make a designation. In the event that a directly affected property owner objects to the historic designation, the Commission approval shall require a super majority vote of four votes. [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (7) After conducting the public hearing, if the Historic Preservation Board does not find that the request fills the criteria, no further action will be required and the request will be deemed denied. However, an appeal may be filed and processed pursuant to Section 2.4.7(E). [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (8) The Board will issue an official "certificate of historic significance" to the owner of properties listed individually on the local historic register or judged as contributing to the character of a historic district listed on the local historic register. The Director acting as City Preservation Officer, or his appointee, is authorized to issue and place official signs denoting the geographic boundaries of each historic district listed in the local historic register. [Amd. Ord. 30-91 3/26/91] (D) Review and Approval Procedures: Once property is placed within a Historic District or designated as a Historic Site no development order shall be issued without first obtaining a Certificate of Appropriateness (C.O.A.) pursuant to Section 2.4.6(J) from the Historic Preservation Board. Obtaining a C.O.A. is required in addition to any other process which is required for the development application. (E) Development Standards: (1) For the purpose of this Section, exterior architectural features will include, but not be limited to the following: (a) The architectural style, scale, general design, and general arrangement of the structure's exterior; (b) The type and texture of building material; and • 4504 VISTA DEL MAR HISTORIC DISTRICT DESIGNATION REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 2 • DESIGNATION REPORT VISTA DEL MAR HISTORIC DISTRICT TABLE OF CONTENTS I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. DISTRICT INVENTORY IV. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES Report prepared for the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board by Patricia Duane, Beach Property Owners Association Board Member; Susan Hurlburt, Historic Preservation Board Member; and Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, April 1998. -2- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 3 I. GENERAL INFORMATION Location: The Vista Del Mar Historic District is a two block cluster of houses located on Vista Del Mar Drive. Extending east and west, the District encompasses two subdivisions: Vista Del Mar Subdivision between North Ocean Boulevard (SR A-1-A) and Andrews Avenue; and the Delray Beach Esplanade Subdivision between Andrews Avenue and the Intracoastal Waterway. Subdivisions: The Vista Del-Mar Subdivision was created by Frank Crego from Ocean Beach Lots 5 and 6 and was officially recorded on October 26, 1925. As originally platted there were 28 building lots; 22 fifty foot wide lots faced Avenida Grande (now Vista Del Mar Drive), and six slightly wider lots faced North Ocean Boulevard. Many of the lots have since been expanded in width and there are now 16 houses and no vacant lots. The Delray Beach Esplanade Subdivision was platted by H.H. Wellenbrink and his wife Charlotte and Willard M. Waters and his wife Willie and was recorded on January 24, 1938. The subdivision originally contained 47 building lots, 45 lots faced Vista Del Mar Drive North and South, and 2 lots fronted on Andrews Avenue. Through expansion in lot widths there are now 39 houses and no vacant lots. Present Zoning: Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). Classification for Designation: Architectural and Cultural Significance. -3- ., _ .,.. Q I C ` J BEACH DRIVE /*---------------------- s / SEA SPRAY AVE. L,.i Q wSANDOWAY LANE Q CC 1 Q O WATERWAY LANE a t Cr) �� ¢ a z Ct O ow › L Z Z a fn C) LAING ST. LAING N- ST. ■ • ■ \\ \1940 194T 1111940 7953 1954 1946 f950 1938 1953 ■ •• •4T •\ 1978\193\_Ill•84■ 1957 • 1941 \\\ \\ \\ ill ■'\\\\\ \ •.,ou ,os "m nos\ \ \ ■ 17 ,mz :"z5 ■ H VISTA D L\1032N MAR RIVE �NORTII 137 zo ,zos :,sue ,zz, \,zz5\ 251 1998 �: al ai \ "'a VISTA DEL MAR DRIVE \1957• _iii \48 1954 \930 938 0947 1978 0 \� 1202 Imo `"zzz$ 1230 1238 124a / • 1941 n in ■ ■ G \\\\\\ ��\\ \946 \\ REMODELED 1995 al ■ 1964 2 1954 1940 1963 1968 1986 1961 1955 `� 1953 1940\�1939 1955 1988 1989 —• \. ■ •■ ,\\\ 1103 ,", = 1951 \\\ � 937\n■ ■\ 015 • ",7 "z, ',. ■■■� ■■■■■■ ■■■■■■■■■■ ■P ■ VI TA D - MAR DRIVE SOUTH Q`"'`\o • 1941 ,ozo \\ 1034 nw \u n+a .a \• \47 ■ 1940 1964 194\ 1960 1955 �1941 1953 1952 \1940 ■\ \\\Q \\\\\\� \\\\\\\\ \\moo\\\ Ill■ _■■■■■■ ■u■■■■■■u■■■■■■■■■■ DORCHESTER CO—OP 0 cr THOMAS STREET Q I D Lv Z w LA./ > C,) 0 m k tt i DRIVE z NJ w Li - Q ILa Qo WCA ¢ cwn ¢ U 4.1 '�. co �' LOWRY STREET "v N PROPOSED N. -"411111111"— • VISTA DEL MAR HISTORIC DISTRICT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL PLANNING &ZONING DEPARTMENT 1034 - ADDRESS 1960- YEAR BUILT - CONTRIBUTING -- DIGITAL RASE MAP Sr.sitM -- MAP REF: LMABO Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 5 III. DISTRICT INVENTORY The Vista Del Mar Historic District is comprised of 55 residences. • Contributing (over 50 years of age) Buildings 25 • Non-contributing Buildings 30 The Contributing Buildings were constructed in: • 1930 - 1940 14 • 1941 - 1948 11 The Contributing buildings represent the following architectural styles • Minimal Traditional 11 • Florida Ranch 5 • New England Cottage Revival 3 • Colonial Revival 1 • Mediterranean Revival 1 • Bermuda Cottage 1 • Monterey Revival 1 • French Colonial Revival 1 • Vernacular 1 IV. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE The contributing buildings of the Vista Del Mar Historic District are representative of the diverse eclectic architectural revival styles which were constructed during the Depression years of the 1930s and up to the Post World War II era of 1948. • The most prevalent style in the District is what is locally referred to as a Resort Cottage, however, for purposes of style classification for the Florida Master Site File Historical Structure Forms these residences are • -5- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 6-- classified as Minimum Traditional as described in A Field Guide to American Houses. Whether built from building plan book catalogues, or individually executed by a trained architect, the Minimal Traditional houses in the District have a common theme; Colonial Revival. This is evident in the use of horizontal wood siding, corner boards, attic vents, rectangular double or single hung wood sash windows with true divided lites, wood shutters usually batten and board, and decorative door surrounds. These houses have gable or cross gable roofs which were originally surfaced with composition shingles, or less often with flat cement tile. The use of screened porches, on the side, front or rear is common and helps define the Resort Cottage from the Minimal Traditional Colonial Revival styles constructed in other parts of the country. The Minimal Traditional or Resort Cottage style was extremely popular in Delray Beach in the 1930s and 40s and examples can be found throughout the City. While many of the structures were built from designs purchased through plan book catalogues, prominent local architects, Samuel Ogren and Henry Pope and others produced many examples of the style. The second most numerous architectural style in the District is the Ranch house. The five homes in this style are typically asymmetric, one story structures with dominate low pitched roofs and attached garages. One or two of the Ranch homes have had a second story added above the garage. In several instances decorative elements of Colonial Revival style are present, however, it was not unusual for builders of Ranch houses to add traditional detailing loosely based on Spanish or English Colonial precedents.2 There are three New England Cottage Revival houses in the district. These have an eclectic mix of features, steep gable roof with prominent dormers, wood casement windows, horizontal wood siding and some Colonial design element. With the exception of the vernacular residence on North Ocean Boulevard, the balance of the homes feature the popular revival styles of the 1930's and 40's. 1 McAlester,Virginia and Lee McAlester,A Field Guide to American Houses,New York,Alfred A. Knopf, 1988,Pg.478 2 Ibid.,Page 479 -6- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report _ Page 7 • CONTRIBUTING RESIDENCES, DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE SUBDIVISION 218 Andrews Avenue, Bermuda Cottage, 1940, architect unknown. 220 Andrews Avenue, Minimal Traditional, 1947, architect, unknown. 1007 Vista Del Mar Drive, Ranch, 1941, Lester Avery architect. 1008 Vista Del Mar Drive, Ranch, 1941, Lester Avery architect, built for Charlotte Wellenbrink. 1011 Vista Del Mar Drive, Mixed Colonial Revival with modern shed roof addition, 1940, Samuel Ogren architect; cost $6,500 built for Drexler family.3 1012 Vista Del Mar Drive, Ranch, 1948, Samuel Ogren architect. 1014 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1940. architect unknown. 1017 Vista Del Mar Drive, Altered Minimal Traditional, 1941, architect unknown. 1025 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1940, Henry Pope architect, built for the Griest family. 1027 Vista Del Mar Drive, Mediterranean Revival, 1940, Samuel Ogren, architect; built for Marie F. Hall, originally 8 rooms, cost $11,000.4 1028 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1941, Lester Avery architect, built for Marguerite McAdams. 1032 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1930, architect unknown, moved to site as land was not filled until 1937. 1102 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1940, architect unknown. s Delray News,November 8, 1940 4 Ibid.,April 5, 1998 -7- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report - Page 8 1108 Vista Del Mar Drive, New England Cottage, 1938, plan book, one of three houses built on speculation by Wellenbrink and Waters 1109 Vista Del Mar Drive, Ranch, 1946, architect and builder unknown. 1112 Vista Del Mar Drive, Ranch, 1941, Lester Avery, architect, built for Charlotte Wellenbrink. 1114 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1947, Samuel Ogren architect, built for Dutcher family. 1125 Vista Del Mar Drive, New England Cottage, 1938, Plan Book. One of the first houses in the Esplanade subdivision; built on speculation by Wellenbrink and Waters, cost $4,000.5 1138 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1946, architect unknown, guest house for the Delray Beach Hotel, 130 N. Ocean Boulevard, moved to site in 1957. CONTRIBUTING RESIDENCES, VISTA DEL MAR SUBDIVISION 234 N. Ocean Boulevard, Vernacular, 1937, architect unknown. 1209 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1941, architect unknown. 1210 Vista Del Mar Drive, New England Cottage, 1940, architect unknown. 1219 Vista Del Mar Drive, French Colonial Revival, 1934, architect unknown. 1222 Vista Del Mar Drive, Minimal Traditional, 1939, Samuel Ogren architect, built on speculation for Ray Del Realty Company, cost $5,000.6 • 1225 Vista Del Mar Drive, Monterey Revival, 1934, architect unknown. • 5 Delray News,January 28, 1938 6 Ibid.,February 3, 1939 -8- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 9 THE ARCHITECTS Samuel Ogren was the City's first registered architect. He designed over 250 buildings in Delray Beach, most noteworthy are the high school and gymnasium at Old School Square, both buildings are listed in the National Register of Historic Places. Henry Pope was associated with the local firm of Pope and Blake. Pope designed many distinguished single family residences in the City. Lester Avery practiced in Miami Beach and was commissioned by Wellenbrink and Waters, developers of the Delray Beach Esplanade subdivision. It is not known whether he designed other homes in the City. Plan Book houses: Included with the district information are the elevations for 1125 and 1108 Vista Del Mar Drive, unfortunately, the name of the publisher of the plan book is not documented. V. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE The Vista Del Mar Historic District is comprised of two subdivisions, Vista Del Mar and the Delray Beach Esplanade. VISTA DEL MAR SUBDIVISION Vista Del Mar was platted in October of 1925 at the height of the Florida Land Boom, by Frank Grego. It was created by a subdivision of Ocean Beach lots 5 and 6; the eastern boundary is North Ocean Boulevard and the western boundary is Andrews Avenue. Twenty-two 50 foot lots faced Avenida Grande, renamed Vista Del Mar Drive, and six somewhat wider lots faced North Ocean Boulevard. Through expansion of the lot's property lines, there are now sixteen lots in the subdivision, all of them are built upon. The 10' wide median strip down the center of the drive remains as originally platted. The disastrous hurricanes of 1926 and 1928 signaled the end of the Florida Land Boom, the two hurricanes and the start of the Great Depression, essentially put a halt to construction in the City until 1934. The Vista Del Mar subdivision, being platted so late in the Land boom, suffered from the economic decline in real estate sales and construction. While some lots were undoubtedly sold, the lack of building permits issued indicates that the lots were not built upon until 1934. -9- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 10 During the early years of the Great Depression Delray Beach became a winter colony for artists, writers and wealthy winter visitors.' Unwilling to display their financial stability in a nation overwhelmed with unemployment, the winter visitors rejected the flamboyant Mediterranean revival style which was the hallmark of residential construction during the boom, and commissioned instead the more traditional, restrained buildings of the various Colonial Revival styles. There were many fine craftsmen and builders in the City and construction during the Depression employed their talents, often putting expensive architectural elements on the interior as opposed to the exuberant exterior detailing of the 1920s. This trend culminated in what is locally referred to as the Resort Colonial Revival style. DELRAY BEACH ESPLANADE SUBDIVISION The Delray Beach Esplanade subdivision was platted by H.H. Wellenbrink and his wife Charlotte and Willard M. Waters and his wife Willie in 1938. The subdivision originally contained forty-seven building lots; forty-five lots faced Vista Del Mar drive North and South and two lots fronted on Andrews Avenue. Through expansion in lot widths there are now thirty- eight residences and no vacant lots. In May of 1937 the Delray News announced that City entered into an agreement with property owners north of East Atlantic Avenue and adjacent to the east bank of the Intracoastal Waterway to fill the low lying land in an attempt to eliminate sandflies. This property, known as the Muck Lots, was no longer used for farming and had become a swamp filled with pools of stagnant water, it was a breeding place for mosquitoes and sandflies. The proposal was to dredge an area across from Veterans Park to create a yacht basin, the fill was to be used in the immediate area and adjacent to Atlantic Avenue. Once the basin had been dug, the dredge which was owned and operated by Clint Moore, would be available, for hire, to fill private property to the north.8 The dredging began for the Esplanade subdivision in late 1937 and in January 1938 Wellenbrink and Waters recorded the plat and applied for building permits for three model homes. VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE The Vista Del Mar Historic District is worthy of designation both for its architectural and social significance. Architecturally, it represents the type Britt,Lora Sinks,My Gold Coast,"Artists and Writers"Palatka,FL Brittany House, 1984. s Delray News,May 14, 1937 .10. Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 11 of residential construction which was popular in the City during the 1930s and 40s. In addition to the two Plan Book residences, examples of the work of prominent local architects, Samuel Ogren and Henry Pope and Miami architect Lester Avery are represented within the district. Contributing residences contain elements of detail and craftsmanship, which represented in their time, the adaptation of the popular styles of the day to the south Florida environment. Culturally, the district portrays the political, economic and social trends as reflected in Delray Beach during the 1930s and 40s. Criteria for Designation To qualify as an historic district the properties must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in Section 4.5.1(B)(2) or(3) The proposed district more than meets the criteria for designation and fulfills the qualifications as follows: 4.5.1(B)(2) Historical or Cultural Significance (d)Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, economic, or social trends of the community in history. 4.5.1(B)(3) Architectural or Aesthetic Significance (a) Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles. (b)Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction. (d)Contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the south Florida environment. The Vista Del Mar Historic District exceeds the criteria for designation as set forth in section 4.5.1(B), which requires that only one paragraph of the above criteria be met. • 41- Vista Del Mar Historic District Designation Report Page 12 IV. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES City Building Cards City Building Permit Records Palm Beach County NAL File Delray Beach City Directory, Volume III, 1953-54 Delray Beach News, 1938-1941 Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey, compiled by the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, July 1997 McAlester, Virginia and Lee McAlester, A field Guide to American Houses, New York, Alfred A. Knopf, 1988. Britt, Lora Sinks, My Gold Coast, Palatka, FL, Brittany House, 1984. Original Plat of Delray Beach Esplanade, Book 18, Page 39 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, FL. Original Plat of Vista Del Mar, Book 12, Page 21 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, FL. Sales brochure, Delray Beach Esplanade at the Beach, Wellenbrink & Waters, Developers u/www/vista-hd A STAFF REP`OR`T HISTOR' C PRESERVATION' BOARD Project Name: COA-356 Associated with the Sundy Inn Project Location: 115 S.W. 1st Avenue The action requested of the Board is that of approval for demolition of a contributing building located at the southwest corner of the Sundy Inn property. BACKGROUND The subject property is a 4-unit apartment building, constructed in 1925 by the Sundy family. It is a two-story structure of wood frame construction clad in horizontal wood clapboard; a portion of the clapboard on the 1st floor has been stuccoed. The building is set on a concrete foundation; it has a hip roof, which is finished in asphalt shingles. On March 18, 1998 the Board approved the floor plans and elevations to convert the structure from 4 apartment units to 6 hotel units associated with the Sundy Inn. At the same meeting a variance was granted to allow the balcony on the on the west facade (S.W. 1st Avenue) to be widened by 1.5', thus reducing the front setback from 3' to 1.5' where 25' is required. On September 16, 1998, the Board voted to continue this item to allow the applicant to prepare the following: • Plans of what will be constructed on the site; and, • An evaluation of the building's structural condition, prepared by a qualified architect or engineer. Pa2OJECT DESCRIPTION The applicant is proposing to demolish the building, on the basis that the structure is too deteriorated to be rehabilitated. An evaluation of its structural condition has been provided by the project architect, John Szerdi. The proposal is to reconstruct the structure from the foundation up, while salvaging flooring, siding, etc. as much as is possible. The design will replicate the renovation plans, which the Board approved at its meeting of March 18, Meeting Date: January 20, 1999 • Agenda Item: Ill-A I HPB Staff Report COA-356-Continution Page 2 1998. However, in order to reconstruct the building on the same footprint a variance must be obtained. The variance is discussed in the staff report for COA-9-371-Pre-application for new construction Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(F)(1), the HPB shall consider the following guidelines in evaluating applications for a COA for demolition of historic buildings: (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill the criteria for designation for listing in the National Register. (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the city. (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local history, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. (e) Whether there are definite plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the character of the surrounding area. Staffs evaluation of the guidelines are as follows: the subject property would not qualify for individual listing in the National Register, but could fulfill the criteria as part of a National Register district. The building could be reproduced at a reasonable cost. The structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the Old School Square Historic District. There are definite plans for what will replace the building. As the design of the replacement building has been previously approved by the Board, its effect on the character of the surrounding area has already been considered. Due to the fact that a variance will be required to allow the building to be constructed on the same footprint, it is recommended that the demolition be approved when the variance is granted and the COA for new construction is approved. i HPB Staff Report COA-356-Continution Page 3,. ALTERN.AT..IV.E. .AC.Tt-ONS.. . .. 1. Continue with the following direction: that the demolition will be approved when the variance is granted and the COA for new construction is approved. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. 3. Approve the demolition. 4. Approve the demolition, with up to a 6-month delay. RECOMMENDATION . Continue with the following direction: • That the demolition will be approved when the variance is granted and the COA for new construction is approved File/u/ww/coa356sr2 • ' • f -f • .1 • .. .. . . ..... . ..-.........._.......---________..—._-.......-_.._ ..... ' • • • •• • , .-... . ......... •• • . :. - ' '.4.'""•0..4•iref:••••';L!tAk.,....i.,;;%.,:•.6!:,.fr,:it,e7k.,;::..,,17c.,;:774..,...re•?..7...,,,,,, 1....,...1,, . •-..•-•••••-----•• • -ipr,r,'7 k • . „.._ •,., • ,F,v-,.4?A 41 . •,,,'.p,,,,;•..,, .4.i ...t..1*,..4:.4,7444, • . •'--'• . .-••"5 •••.`7,4F •• ,,, ,,„-,,-•rrtzglr•-lalla''•,,,',,,, • tl,•?.hot,.,.ti,,1,,,atr,",„,,Itir.ttit.t,," .-:,••;.,..,-:41: '_ 447, 41,:y.:611,4'.V.7 r,,t;,.•41 '.` .•-rk.41:-:',...n. ••,,,..;•.z.,t.,.:74.••••'......-- t•el,: 1"1.'4='-'51411a1115,-y.4147,. er••444''1'... .., L'xtre,Pr.?ri• '.t' ' ." '. '. 9'1..4'' Lit•t•X..''n' ' '‘•"1,154,70Zirj.Vii'•41' ?I''''•''4.441:24, t7,0•"'..trrt-iftotitic.i.t.f.--444.,s,.r.. ..i.1, •,.'"•••- " ',.. ' '1- ' " .,•. ,. ._,„ — ..-- .... .....— •L-.— _ 111';'"• I'Irta. 4" ..‘.. "". '. . - ..• ....ii'At.t'•41 VOX'''..........•. •,•••••'-''.,: . tt.....,,,,,rikt.v..a..... , ...,....... .,1,;.•,......,..L..,.„, i ts,... .,, I„..5.4.,,,,.., ,„ . ... ,6,:I. • , ... if", . Lin' '-'omorrimmis. ',I . ...••••• ,,,,,4,, ,t.,:,,,.•,,, ' ',. . • . ‘......., • , , ,....t..:1,• ,. . , . • • ' .(•,•.• . ,,• 1 I i . , I • .4.•••• ''0. , , .• 1 •• •• . . 1 I • -1 •. :';',".••••••.''. ' 11 .....,!,....1.•••' 1:...1 v.i.,:•• • I • • • 1 !., • I ; v..... ,, :,.. , . •.e;, ..1. .;•Ao.:L4.••••••6• 1'11 n ... 7... 'I I . • • '• • L..•• •.. • ..-.......« :..... . ...-.:II • le ' .: "•,•-•::tr-•","4:=17"-Ii rrirPri„ n .•"-"Tilririll'y 74. ."""""'" '1.- -71"....-77.. ...".-.r.-.'.r" .." .......1..1.W.i.N W r,P;1177;r`r.""V"7:91"r. . -•R...14'..,14-711.77(;;Vr7 Yr 7,N X 7:1" $ ,,,, 7kr171717-1"rrgr."" .,;:;,..."...".. ...•::A.,,p..: ; ' 1 0 i'+ •••4 •.4 • • • 4 I • • • )••• • 0 •• • 0 • . . P ' .1. A 4 to !''......),;,11,15. ' I • • r,s.o.e ; „0„,... 4,„•.p.•. ,t...***4 .+4,....•,,,•,, ...•.....••• _ . • • 4 • 4 ,,,. 9 . „...: • '1,0• : 0. /:::•,-„,.... k•••.... • •. • • )••• .4.'.4:4. 4 ••••• ..... •••••=%:,‘ :,I • • t \ .. .N" • -. .• .0.7•*-. • • •-•PI,o- ••r••r,• P••-,r-•.1 .•-••••-••-•••-•or, •• ' ei;. .. • 4.MIA 102,0"•,••••.,,...•••••••..•.... ••r• .• • r..7......-rw•-•,•••••• !pin,pikil ..,,74,... - "Cr/Irirr-'71.`-'71' .• t . . 4 I • .) ••, •: • • • • . • - • ••. . . . .• •• -..."'• 4/ -r-114:.!t1 ... .. •.11'ilfAl:ftetta,: 16.!;••••''':k••.....0.. ./.• .... .......•';.6.'61'.....1. .. . • ....... . . .. ... .• .• . . • a . ...,.. ..,. . • . ..• . , .6 . . . . .. . .:„... AAA: ...• ..r;,......,....:....1-....r.-,:„.-1 ••. ;,,..., ::: *N. !:,.../...,1...:+:+:,.4,:,.:,:. •..: ;•e. • ,_14. . •,) ..;.....1•:•...• ' ..- .. • •°.I.'.• . .- . _.•.... . . • - . . . -- •••-• • . ... .. .I ... S. •'..• •'' Irt0) ')1•••• • '..•+•1'.4•!"1.1•1••• e. Ak,.; ,S. , ''',_ •0 f• • i • " lb\', - . V •,•,... • I,., .47 0..$46. I •• • • . ,%t ' .le . •I 1 . ) . • ' • .. .. , . . 4. . ., . . , , . . '. • . .N‘. e., ! P ...•4 '‘ ot. 2 ' . ' • • ',.. . . i 1 • 1 ' • i .•:N. ;:',.'.:t i:Vraer.a.i•Ar4,414. I'.', ?' ...;' ' 14 I 'r'. i..,..,..•::,!..,..:‘,.;,.,%....•:.c:;;;:n7.„,.!.....,..., .......,, ' ; 1 '41 ...• I • 1 ,' Tale...14'.i,10p, Ek;• ,3 Vi.10:,1',t '•I el.. ......': . .'7. ' 'it' . •,... ...7,rii. r ,le 41• 40 . ••1 . ,. ta 2,x..;.,....1 .. , ,„,.„,. ,, „, - •, ..... ...g •1 ....... . .., goafutii4u.srau.vogrimt a• .. A: . I.;....:,......:-. , Iti.;.:Z. .. At : .; •:.i..,.. •. • -w, . . ,,,ftiota 4 . i 11 '..;.1.),.; 00,1 - ,,itt .. Wit via n.,,..k : Ae., ..'.* k'' •% •• i •.' 1 ... -,. • • i 1:',14 ..(' ' , '• . lak ''rVgt 4 .11 i la .,,.,, ." „,,„. ::•:I ., ... .. , 1,. PI ; . . • or .'. • '4' • •• .. tr 50 111;3'44:Yr'• ' , ., • . A S I ' ...:! , . ?'"'• '. V.i....''',1,::" . • .It.".• a..14•00 ! ,,1 il , •: . .1 :14 .' , f( • All's , )`,P,s11 :,.:', ,v .1.,,...0.., . t't •• ) . . . i.,.„rx.•, .„ , , .,4-. ,, ..)),.4`, . 1 • ;. ....,; • i:(11 'd I . .114 ,..7 a ' ' . ., ... • . .:.. . . ti...ii.a..: . ' . . •--,4,•. 1 ,! . ...• i • . -lir •el,. ., • , . .. /..,. -,, .'.-1 .0; .'. ...Of ANL!. .• ,i IIT'', ' . I,' . . . .. ,.. f‘411,k1P$ ,. $Es:::.. .... , •. . . . . • ' ,.'7.f.!..•go,i,!): ' ' ', . . ... ,.. .il,.... .il . $ • . . .• . • • • • • .'. l• .„. . ..... , ......., .-. .. ...,... . < < G < < _ z CITY 1 " HALL 1 z z N.W. 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST ST. I I J o ,n N I el . u N z �ry COMMUNITY D CENTER Z I . _ J 1J Li I z z z TENNIS OLD LI! !Liz STADIUM SCHOOL SQUARE ATLANTIC AVENUE 1 ( 1 11 POLICE SOUTH 1 1 COMPLEX COUNTY COURT — { HOUSE in W Li iii ,i Li Ilf i < S.W 1ST ST. S.E. 1ST ST. > II II z < N J n i W Z U) T N H L7 c Z • N o - -7 1 II 1 �' III I-- S.W. 2ND ST. Z S.E. 2ND ST. I I I W II Cl) Cl) ILi Q _ I vi I ui vi o vi vi I ( I II z N W S.W. 3RD ST. S.E. k 3RD ST. I Nil MERRITT PARK N SUNDY INN CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL (LOT 2, SUNDY ESTATES,ES, 1 15 S.W. 1 ST AVE.) PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM212 i -- +s STAFF. REPORT HISTORIC:. PRESERVATION 130ARD Project Name: COA-9-372-Pre-Application, associated with the Sundy Inn Project Location: 115 SW 1st Avenue. The proposal is to demolish the existing contributing structure and to reconstruct the structure from the foundation up, while salvaging flooring, siding, etc. as much as is possible. The design will replicate the renovation plans, which the Board approved at its meeting of March 18, 1998. However, in order to reconstruct the building on the same footprint as the existing structure a variance may be required. As the site plan and design elements for the project have been previously approved, it is appropriate to consider the new construction as a modification to the approved plan. File/u/ww/coa3 56sr2A Meeting Date: January , Agenda Item:20 Ill-B1999 ,.. ... . . . . ' . .. .. ._.. . . , . . . . . • . . • . • , $ ..-------..............s„,................„.............. . .• • . • ....„..o.„...,...------------------r--------.... . . • • ••.----1 II 11=7:1L___11_11 II_ 11_11_1=211 IF-II 11-11 11_11_11_1L _1=1 11_ _11_ __ll II II If'-- • . - ____.• . / - -. - L J _ .. . _ . , , . . _ F-1 1---- I-1 I— III MI IIII = , iiimiNgioni • t ____I 1 I 1 OE JUL__ 1 im..."4,1 ite•NYirilbs ::.054:ti . .....,. . .,......... . ..„....4...... , • . ::.:knim8;;40 .. ..... .._v.:....,......4 . ..... ........A.,.,,,,,:::,..,,,,,....„:0..,- ••,.....:=1.. , I : . . • '.:"..,//4.4.?" .."'"V",',...: :,...A.. (711 _____ ___ ..___ j All 1111111111 1•1141I _, : . . _ r 0 tir . • — .'-- ------------- ----•—• . , ——. . . — -- I i • _ : — — , — — • - — • -- . ,..------. . • __ — — ' — - — — 1 - F1 . = = I _ : F . ) _ . , -- .__ • .,.. ___ ., 1., t• ,1.1= , II , fr --. - - . -.( 1- .- --I1-___.1 - Iti • . . ., . . •' ' .. . • • 1 WEST ELEVATION ,6-x/s'T/4/G. • • • . . . ,:. .. . If .... • • .. ..,,. , . ••• . . . , .... ;•I .._ • .., .. . • . • , ,,,• . . .„, .. . • . • • . . .1;1•:;,,, . • • . . . .. ,.i.,„..,, , .• ..!•?•,..K: . .. . . .. . ... . • .. . . . . . ., . • . . . . , . . . - . . . . . • . .. ... . . .. .. . . . . . • ., . r $ :..' ,k`:',”7,-'. • . ) .• i.';';;:'`..•'..'. k'g''•'•:1'ii' . '' * .. .. . i•:'?I.`'.•'.: •'..!'', ''1,....' ' • • . '.1.7‘'.,0.2':..;• ''',' ..2'.'.1. • •• • . . ' •!: ' • •1 .. . , ... •. • • . .. .,. , . . •:.'';': '•• . . . • .: • • . .. .. r 1. 7.‘.. . • I . i. . . , . . . . • . . • zdr] __) - 1 . . • • . ,,,,-.-___------ -- [F=1:=Ii . _- ____._-_,,„... . . ,' •,, . . I .....,....„.... i :• J .../.. ••••,.., •$ I' r-- ,-1-11- ...... .. - I 1 f i . . I .' . I ; I i_I---i____ 1 .........k .........-‘....--.1....--11.-.*--. -.......1...---1.--..i..---..-..- --- '. . ., 4.! On • . . . • . ;'• y, )!. ;•1 H :LT . , . . , ,:•. JUL __• ____ 34 AL.._\ a. 1,•) . . ..1 . — '_11):111-1 1 111111 11111111[11[11111 11111 I , ..—.___, _. • ., . . , . . .1.-.....,, , . , •. ' IP:,.'. .- •;, -,',: .; . • . • , . . • •. . .• . . • -_ . . t• THE STABLES" • .. . . . . • ii l'-01. • REMODELED EXISTING TWO STORY BUILDING SCALE: 1/8' . . . . . . . . .. , . . ••. i• •. • . . . .. ... • •••• . . • .. • • .: ,''''•!.: ... .::''':e..'. 4.'.'":,'''..‘.' iro' ' ,, • c.!. :'' . ' .. . . . . .. .' . ... .. . . . • ..• • . , t f,;': , • . . . • . ••., , . .. . .,• . • . . , •:........ ... .. , .. . . • . . . ' 1 ' . . • 1:'; . . • . -. . . . . .. . . • 1, •' . • . . . . . ,.,.,.....„..„.....„...../>-.7....----... ''''.....---.-.\.........................„..............s, • . • • ---....7-s....--- ----------„, ! II ll ILILL_IL11 11 I11 II 11 II 11 11 II II___11 11 II II II 11_ =C-11. 1 i . _ - —- • — _ I ... . . • . _____ - • _ _ _ i•I ' - — _ - ,- 1 . ' • I. • ______ y. t _---------.—......—.......— ._________...................................___......._.---__.--.......____....... .._..........................----_____—_-------- ;•: t,. . " --.--.— — —.___.........--........------........—...._____._. .---.........._._____.-_----------•--. * , [;.• :t • . t • ..,.....:, . , . •"'•tict't 1. • s;t'iA"i , . i •1,10'; • ‘ ,t;i•••ii'', .a.-,;•;;. . he t•s,• ' . • 1 I • • — .—.— A.m...ra owasmomme • I ltt'ii . . • ' • ' Jj.,;11(„1., •• ..11;,...t:. • 1.:0'SN . • ' 'IV k , • . . ' -1•41'';1 . . . •....:,.„t • * ; *'...'*. •*. i.'%...: . . 7 6 AS:r ! ELEVATION . . . • • •• .. ,,m.,, .;. , . •• e EXISTING TWO STORY FRAME UNIT . . . • .:-....: . ......; • L. . .. , ... .. ...,, •, %•••,., . • • . . . . . " •,,bni,„ , . •. . tt.,,,,I.,. . .• Jr r • . . q;••‘',?,': . . • . ".4.1,4 dr; _ . ........ .. ;i1.4'..i... . . ...... ..... . .. . ... .... . ••,,(q,. .. . . . . ,. . • , . . .• .. • • . ''., • ,7''.1 1';'1";e211. , 1 . . • • . . . , • , , .. 'I'...;..ne r.,,,•'N'i...,••.,''...1%4i; !‘i,'-' I •. . . ..,,. . : ...,%:--Ell,..;',,,,!,'•'.',7.':.,......,,, 0,4., i.. . . • . .. . . . . . . .. . . . • . - . • . • . . . . . „ . . . . .. ., .. , i . .C t . • • •.. . . . . .. . . _ . • •• . . . • 1--1 i_ .i_ - ,_, • IP, Cr 741 —__ , - - -ium Numminam i_ N immumairmamaaromiimmaaa a_ ,- , - • , 11 7:'' '..' 7 111 " HI 71 I kr. Ell 1.11 INEE11 -77' ma 7.-7 ra-27-71 7 dia its 5-H.,. .': 111111E1111111111111111111111 ir In ....1Hin 4111 .. . , _ - imminglimman y. U .-- II U n Nome 1 I ..n..."-1• ' 1 . ., . .• . . , • . • •:•, . . : "111L.... V.:•:: .... R. mina Tn :,*... .:.: li 1110 . ‘_'., ''‘ 1..• ' . : ' :• t ••: 4 ill Yi, I\\ .: .:.:: 6.11M In :.: :..1.7 I : :... ii lb - • :• 1 9 i___,. .• , m Il L_II • • . .1 m _i __ , 1 , li , II it . , 'THE STABLESw . . REMODELED EXISTING TWO STORY FRAME BUILDING EAST OVERALL COURTYARD ELEVATION • , T , . F' , < > > < CITY < < - ' "I HALL - I I y - I II Z i N.W. 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST ST. o 0 Q v' r n N N ilit - COMMUNITY D CENTER z • L_I 3 3 3 > w w z z z -NNIS Z OLD z z III I S-4DIUI� ISCH l I J< SOUORE OL I ATLANTIC AVENUE 1 1 ( 1 iliii POLICE SDUTH COMPLEX D DUN TY _ ✓URT N - -'OUSE L, uj . /(111 . ;.,:, > ; > w Li> > _ I W S.W. 1ST ST S.E. 1ST ST. it > III .1z it < - N 0 C z N Vi Z 0I -Ell ® II II " 1 1 1 Il I- S.W. • 2ND ST. Z S.E. 2ND ST. I Li) i 1 1 C I vi Ivi ui w l vi vi- vi viI I O vi vi I I Li I v S.W. 3RD ST. S.E. 3RD ST. II 1/_RRI TT . I - PARK • N SUNDY INN CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL (LOT 2, SUNDY ESTATES, 1 15 S.W. 1 ST AVE.) PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL a4SE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM212 f • • STAFF R E P O R T HISTORIC..,PRESERVATION B OA R D ... Project Name: COA-9-372, J.C. DeNiro, Project Location: 60 Marine Way, The Anchorage Condominium „... .�, ITE M �BEFORETH E....BuO A._R D The action requested of the Board is that of approval for an awning to be installed on the upper east terrace. PROJ..ECT DESCR.LP.,TION .,...'......... The proposal consists of installing a shed style awning across the south and east portion of the terrace. The southern portion will run from a projecting wall for a distance of 15' where it turns the corner and runs 9'4" along the east wall. The awing will be 3'6" wide and will serve as protection for 2 windows and a door. The fabric is yellow vinyl with a scalloped drop and white trim ALT:E'RNATIVE ACTIONS . . . : 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. 4. Approve with the condition that a letter of approval is received from the Anchorage Condominium Association. RECOMMENDATION Based upon positive findings to the Design Guidelines, approve as presented with the following condition: • That a letter of approval is received from the Anchorage Condominium Association before the permit is issued. File/u/ww/coa372sr Meeting Date: January 20, 1999 Agenda Item: III-C • 1 • 1t,' 1!11111!1111111111111PIIIII.1111MMI11111011111114V: • • • • NAME: ,G. a N.ti o ADDRESS: G 0 1l A(]�1,s Z- (1)`ra� - Ci c\......7 W.O.# Q 4 7` 2 REMARKS: GENERAL NOTES: SUB: LD r..A. DATE: 1 O-2,rj-q , DELIVERY: I.Al pipe to be ASA Schedule 40 Celvenlxed,U.N.O. 5 PHONE: 2�g_ �3 7 O 2.All welds to comply with A.W.S.coda(latest edition) 1 0�1•�A Inside SCALLOP Cower welds with aluminum paint. -NI —_ACPLIQl16— _L_aeeua n��12E \ BINDING COLOR: W\.•.i 4 e • 4,All structures are designed In accordance with the ^.'•," following codes BMW edition) ^- r �/•,•�,/ , .: a, Gnull Fiends Building Cede,Chaplet 43 POLO! \�\\0 i NU, `u n l' U(�LOlt �I"N_., _ ` -" 11 IIIP:A11 C01.0111 u)�1\(A• b,Palm l�nt�nrd mono()Qedei ei111 Iltl ell per to d ``� , �� _ _ ____ ___�.--__ .__.._..__-__.-_.__.W_..__.-._-.__. .__...__..__...._ 'a m BasmU County a i r m ie e o,w r load, No. T11R D COLOR: \ DELRAY AWNING, INC. GROM: BRASS NICKELED PERMIT: a, CBy of West Palm Bosch ordinance modlBcallon • to standard Building Code,sect.2201.3(4)(d). 6,Canvas awnings shad be removed when winds reach', ' TYPE Aso,.-...'-•Z`^^' maximum whole.gale force or Installed In such a • " manner Ihal the fabric will release from the frame' COMPLETE L•- _- 'with a wind load al1516a/se.It. • 6.Frames without covering will sustain 140 mlRr wind. RECOVER 7.All conn,cUon's shall be fylly welded.Thus: I . ,.,, •�'�(� REMODEL ` 11„ "91s•V <TP • FRAME ]/s'US 511 III iro - , _ 8.Frames without covers designed as per ASCE 7.86 exp.0 COLOR C..\./a rL DPN6101 9EILD,XINIB.N 2' - - - 9.All frames have been designed using rational analysis. • IlEADER - I PA'36'I5031 B . - - -- - - —Attachments la buildings Should be made with:— t lung 611EOulaL.SPELIFn• \Q` 1.3/8'legs In 3/8'exp.shields VALANCE 9 4 ! l'wedgeanchors(Into concrete) . DOWN , 6 [ Ao+cHox1 17•c�w,ti _ ." 7�� —-- 3.3 8 lags(Intowood) �/��,( 4,3/8'lapconc(Into concrete block) r , i ` 6 -M.'s 5.maxlmum spacing shall be 36'c/c. •• • OUT 3 -6 i �' 11 r_g•t ..., o'i LENGTH A t/prr rD P �/ POSTS p IX ANCHOR .. ..1, .. • HANGERSAL,_,...,„,,,,,.....,_„v . .SCREEN —_ �- . • ... ACCESS " TASSELS ...... _ ........ .. ... _... • CURTAINS - _. ...... ROLL.UP } a ` A• rii �FASTENERS 14 14. , s l 1 + , -d He r w 7- DRAPES I-.Cl.cf.. • ., K,, TIEBACK fi aT", 74 FaI i ' • / )fir r'_` 1' i jr 'C' .'' .. I + 1 q -::'' I 1.": . 1; ' 4 • I t • G,p �. .i i(;t w,,r?fit•. • V /"1/YV/7V :{C I,rmrr sa ;ai /v ,yar{+r+ v.,.. �1 # • iv t I N'NM AV°Alt AIN/H1 efW//f✓' /NeAP 1L144,1 n!<•YnV,w/,a RA4P/fta[•tt,t•MIr.M.Y✓/NY • •ate f ! nGf�Ya.vnlrAtWA..r•.tnNtx•'iiq• R lf9�tT' Or a ' !! _ {_ ►••ro.,avos.anr vnsrMww� i ..., ,. f _i • r_ •• i e R\,�w.,[�L KYiotnrw.v✓!/er di ow//ni✓rnM' MI•f• ri••.•n ..•• ( I A N_q eraiisAri.,1 k(tM•MMdN/d1A.'ft U ,r,.t i Rh;l4U9,1 .^ L 1- �~~la_, 0 r -' rZ C=\oo if/�5vrl riaeve,✓ttr..av• I , i y —, -- L Ie• 1 .t rCVW rr/ A .Irr �: T —-, b ^ ,, " , .I o f M'.44 .wct4tMM/illt.t'H'f• % • • t i*b f[O —_• ,r►• ,i,: 1 1 n[rvs,io,dctardt✓rwe,•..A.ter t t f f . - i .... j Ti r✓!r/nrs.n✓.v/n6rw,t, iwi V ` L. i t .,, [tuvlvAuu marl. • C , 1J. •� // , [I• i , \V ./Kt{7X/rV//t4/rK/✓!1•7/M•ti i r 9 kti Vrri•/'nY r•✓c+.wsurMalrwvr © •T1 • i t!' B�' . r 1 (, (i 1 ��• lWe vAdmu++yw.rseww tJl on •; G, -[•) 4 , wr .vrtx�trwuowi• �y• aR�l 1 L 1 u • wolf,".,ro„v�eo sv4'xasrr v MI ' ' f / r ►. E . nttttAtrYt/auwrafrno.ttaf,rs ,1 •.• �i+' . f 'N !//tw•ar0 r/MXrlpKlf/,WI►ynd nr i• Z ; r•v or.e ezehr a w•.+a•tonn. OJtea ---; j '; id Q (/1 ,^,sr ,0, ``\lt rc' I r.+y�svhvaurslotr.�arwnk lf) r.�7 ) .,i.f ►' I•A`:,'i'/$: \ ' 1 ' j IrAxu /r i►4•410~ir ,�•� - �! • t NY• f O. Q • r-�. 1-J L. /•� , O • _ Lr✓KN'4d.tdAwtl�Afl.iVfY,P • L. -I 7 l`L IV Z , =' , ...... al fj Aff CQiq v Ad ce+an,avNw u✓n,1 X • _. _- • � 1 ( I `r /tW 04M/4%fr,WYIOwr.� wr Cra • [° / V 'M+Yt,r4 r,AGI rr•.r AYiY✓AVA•4vr Li.. I' - , hytti 11'[t,t0:le t✓MINtscwr 1. `' 1 • rlwv/. rtcoa� EL Et -177cNS -,"'rl,urPi,..i/! i IN.tO y, ♦i7♦f V,` Y•+14rY✓ lvr wY/.! I!7/5• �'i/SI/•4....J<i•rot. [ r 'df.rl'Of•V!!S!'lt llNl C/llNr,oul,,W//lr,..,o 1 • • .. . ..i.�- -S. -E- -1"—Sl-/FEET _L_ J Q'lu.wlsaiorrdvrf rwscr • i • • • SUifV Y�•rQ/o • 1'It(EI, 311iE1 ; 1 j 1 d 1 c., .