Loading...
HPB-03-03-1999 lir • .CH AII•AmericaCity AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: March 3, 1999 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-9-375 1009 Nassau Street, Non contributing Single Family Residence, Nassau Park Historic District. Daniel Carter, Authorized Agent, William & Nancy Swaney Owners. Consider Fences, Landscape Plan, and Resurfacing Walkway, Porch and Driveway with Old Chicago Brick. The Existing Driveway Encroaches Into the Required 5"Landscape Strip and Will Require a Waiver to LDR Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b). B. COA-9-376: 21 SW 1st Avenue, Noncontributing Duplex, Old School Square Historic District. Gary Eliopoulos, Architect, Authorized Agent. Consider Demolition of the Noncontributing Duplex. C. COA-9-377 The Rhoden Building 2 East Atlantic Avenue, Contributing Commercial Building, Old School Square Historic District. Steve Cohen, Owner, or Kelly Maudsley, Authorized Agent. Consider Previously Approved Renovation Plans for an Expired COA_ HPB Meeting March 3, 1999 Page 2 III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff IV ADJOURN Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: February 25, 1999 U/Agenda/HPB-3-3-99 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING - MEETING DATE: March 3, 1999 LOCATION: First Floor Conference Room I. Call To Order (Roll Call) The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:05P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, John Johnson, Shane Ames. William Griffin. MEMBERS ABSENT: Betty Diggans. STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce. II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-9-375-100 Nassau Street, Noncontributing single Family Residence, Nassau Park Historic District. Daniel Carter, Authorized Agent, William & Nancy Swaney Owners. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for a waiver to LDR Section 6.14(B)(3)(b) to reduce the perimeter landscape strip between the driveway the abutting property line from 5' to 1'. Granting the waiver will allow the existing asphalt driveway, which is in poor repair to be resurfaced with old Chicago brick. Based upon positive findings to LDR Section 2.4.7(B)(5), it was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded Mr. Griffin and passed 6-0 to grant the waiver to LDR Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b). • At the applicant's request, the Board reviewed the plan for the addition of a railing and an awning for the front porch, which if constructed will require a variance. The board found the porch treatments to be appropriate and suggested that the applicant make a formal request for a variance. B. COA-9-376- 21 SW 1st Avenue, Noncontributing Duplex, Old School Square Historic District. Gary Eliopoulos, Architect, Authorized Agent. - 1 - 2/3/99 Item before The Board The action requested of the Board was that approval for the demolition of the noncontributing duplex constructed in 1958. Due to a conflict of interest the Chair stepped down. Based on failure to make positive findings to section 4.5. 1 (F)(1), it was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 5-0 to approve the demolition associated with COA-9-376 with the following condition: • That the demolition permit will be issued when the site plan is approved by the HPB. C. COA-9-377- The Rhoden Building 2 East Atlantic Avenue, Contributing Commercial Building, Old School Square Historic District. Steve Cohen. Owner, or Kelly Maudsley, Authorized Agent Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval of a previously approved plan for exterior renovation to a contributing commercial building, whose COA has expired. Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1 (E) and the Design Guidelines, it was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 6-0 to approve COA- 9-377 as presented with the following conditions: • In the event that wood shutters with the required hurricane wind load are not available, operable aluminum shutters will be installed. • All hurricane panels will have direct mount installation. • That the door of the east bay of the front façade be relocated to its original center location. However the door may remain in its existing location until the bay to the west is converted to restaurant space. No CO for the additional space being converted for use by the Safari Steakhouse will be issued until the door is relocated to the center of the east bay. • An interior wall will be installed inside the west exterior wall of the Swinton Avenue shops to block the view of kitchen and storage areas from the street. The wall must be installed far enough from the west exterior wall to allow access for window cleaning and to give realistic depth into the windows from the street. • That all the second floor windows be of a 2/2 pane configuration -2- 2/3/99 • That simplistic stucco windowsills, 6" to 8" in depth, be added all second floor windows. • That the shutters will be painted dark green to match the awnings. • The applicant will return with the specification sheet for the globe light fixtures and will indicate their location on the elevations. • The applicant will return for approval of the signage. ADD-ON AGENDA ITEM D. COA-9-378-New construction of a single-family residence to be located at 300 N. Swinton Avenue; the northwest corner of NW 3rd Street and N. Swinton. Tony Keller, owner. Mr. Keller stepped down due to a conflict of interest. Note; This item came to the Board for a pre-application review at the meeting of February 17, 1999. At that time the Board encouraged the applicant to go forward with the project as presented. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for the new construction of a single-family residence. Based on positive findings to Section 4.5. 1(E), it was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 5-0 to approve the new construction with the following conditions: • The siding is to be vinyl, yellow with white trim. • The roof is to be white fiberglass shingles. • The applicant is to return with a landscape plan • An unimproved alley runs along the rear of the property; due to the nature of the alley, the City has no plans to improve it. The Board recommended that the applicant apply for a variance to reduce the rear setback from 10' to 5' to allow a swimming pool to be constructed between the house and the garage. -3- 2/3/99 III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None C. Staff None IV. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mrs. Hurlbut,moved to adjourn the meeting at. 7:20 p.m. seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 6-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on ;7A- , 1999. If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -4- 2/3/99 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: Coa-9-375, Dan Carter, Agent Project Location: 1009 Nassau Street. I,TE M : BEFORE THE BOARD . The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a waiver to LDR Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b) to reduce the perimeter landscape strip between the driveway the the abutting property line from 5' to 1'. BACKGROUND The one-story single family residence was constructed in 1964, the driveway was installed in conjunction with the house. On December 15, 1998 window and roof replacement were staff approved _PROJECT DESCRIPTION- The proposal is to replace the existing asphalt driveway with old Chicago brick. The driveway is located approximately 1' from the west property line, where a 5' landscape strip is required. In order to replace the nonconforming driveway, a waiver to LDR Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b) is required. A white picket fence, with 6" x 6" posts with caps, will be installed across the front of the property. The existing front walkway and porch slab will also be resurfaced with old Chicago brick. The applicant is proposing to upgrade the landscaping and irrigation system. r ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.7(B)(5), prior to granting a waiver, the approving • body shall make a finding that the granting of the waiver: (a) Shall not adversely affect the neighboring area; (b) Shall not significantly diminish the provision of public facilities; (c) Shall not create an unsafe situation; or, (d) Does not result in the grant of a special privilege in that the same waiver would be granted under similar circumstances on other property for another applicant or owner. Meeting Date: March 3, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-A HPB Staff Report COA-9-375 Page 2 A majority of the driveways on Nassau Street are located less that 5' from the abutting property due to the mostly 50' frontage of the lots. Resurfacing the driveway with a more attractive paving material will result in an improvement to the streetscape and not adversely affect the neighborhood. Waivers to this code section have been granted to other property owners on Nassau Street. OTHER; ITEMS The porch railing and awning shown on the plan will require a variance as the porch slab encroaches into the front setback by approximately 2'. The owner is undecided as to whether to install the porch detailing and asks the Board to comment on its appropriateness before going forward with a formal variance request. The porch detail and awning are not included in the formal review. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS' Waiver 1. Continue with direction 2. Approve. 3. Deny, with reasons stated. RECOMMENDATION ' Based Based on positive findings to Section 2.4.7(B)(5), grant the waiver to Section 6.1.4(B)(3)(b) to reduce the perimeter landscape strip between the driveway and the property line form 5' to 1. File/u.w.c o a-9-3 7 5 sr J��-LL3 Lj VETERANS BARR N N PARK TERRACE w 3 ATLANTICPLAZA CONDO a o DELRAY BEACH ---] z a < MARRIOT w ATLANTIC AVENUE WATERWAY EAST � j!!0J; Q 1 -Q- I COMMERCIAL —4 <�. rLI) ; CONDO — J -Q > a I -� o�M It, v> I B �� a. BAR o ),Et..) o�� I HARBOUR om��CONDO S.E. 1ST! ST. 12 MIRAMAR STREET ir- LLI QF— rWQ ¢ OCEAN PLACE -'CONDO -- o ED COCONUT ROW / ( I° S.E. 2ND ST. , INGRAHAM AVENUE Q W S_ •-• OCEAN TERR. I C.)N. EAGATE ■ OCEAN TERR. O TOWERS 1111�. 111 .: II 1 —� r NASSAU ST. 1 Z _ MI a F,, — wN.. Z , , S.E. 3RD ST. (l) > BAY Q •=111v O a C) U LANIKAI VILLAS CONDO Q LANGER WAY ,I �a CI L.; !— vi SEAS..IE �� ' �' S.E. 4TH ST. CASUARINA ROAD I MA'4';2R or `r 0E-14/ 7I ( 7/I V > 2 ) 9 N 1009 NASSAU STREET CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM215 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: COA-9-376 Gary Eliopoulos, Authorized Agent Project Location: 21 SW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District. ITEM 'BEFORE THE ,BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for the demolition of a nonconforming duplex constructed in 1958. PROJECT DESCRIPTION. . The property was purchased by the developers of the Sundy Inn. It is adjacent to, and south of, the Rectory Square parking lot on SW 1st Avenue. The request is to demolish the structure. ANALYSIS The demolished structure will be replaced with the contributing single family residence which was located only a few lots south, at the northeast corner of SW 1st Avenue and SW 1st Street. The structure was moved from the property to accommodate the construction of the Sundy Inn parking lot. It has been temporarily located at the southeast corner of SE. 1st Street and SE 1st Avenue. The replacement building will be converted from residential to commercial and used for a small retail establishment. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(F)(1), The HPB shall consider the following guidelines in evaluating applications for a COA for demolition of historic buildings; (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill the criteria for designation for listing in the National Register. (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the city. Meeting Date: March 3, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-B w HPB Staff Report COA-9-376 Page 2 (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local history, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. (e) Whether there are definite plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the character of the surrounding area. The structure would not be eligible for listing in the Nation Register, nor would it be eligible as part of a district. The duplex could be replaced at a reasonable cost and is not one of the last remaining structures of its kind in the Old School Square Historic District. There are definite plans for reuse of the property, which will commence, when the site plan is approved. STAFF COMMENTS It is appropriate to replace the noncontributing duplex with the contributing structure. However, the site plan submitted with the demolition and relocation proposal indicates that the parking will be located in the front yard. Parking in the OSSHAD zoning district is to be located to the rear or side of structures; therefore, the Board cannot consider the relocation of the replacement building at this time. It is more appropriate to defer demolition permit until the site plan has been approved. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Deny the demolition. 2. Approve the demolition, with up to a 3 month delay. 3. Approve the demolition with the following condition: • That the demolition permit will be issued when the site plan is approved by the HPB. RECOMMENDATION Based on failure to make positive findings to Section 4.5.1(F)(1), approve the demolition associated with COA-9-376 with the following condition: • That the demolition permit will be issued when the site plan is approved by the HPB. File/u/ww/9-coa 367sr .• -• — _ __.___ r'---, ;,.•.4--_>. ... 0- .-4... ,...., zii ' •• --c .... as .4.7e. - 7- • '••-,,,•-•-`,:'- -- n• .-.1...3togit:..•.• d:r • ..-. .-,--. • .• • pc.' --•-e-•••••-.: • • • - — ..„..,.r.-ISS`: •.-. k ci.- - t• .;:;-••;#...7...:1 %.=,. t?'t -•'?"...rr•• • `•- •- ..14,,...% '' A 1 21,1';Zecf;-...."7a;- .-,.- • -,C1--' .4-'-• - -4- ..:•••:„. .‹.•-... - • • . . . - , .1, 7"- :..=-•;2'. :r'a.r.i.•----- - , .._•.7-1.-' 1 ' . 411,-,,,.2....--•,,, -..1 .----. _ '-'''`-"4..--‘;41.-;‘'-- -'r-'1.-'''.:(::•:4.7tIfitt -,--1-4----: '-'...---f::::-.---.1•N ._- ,.,.--„...,,..... ,-..:,..---;....7-'7I -...--:-..•:------ -_ .. • ----..-- , .i f• • —,,--_.,-.,--I--• :--- L- __-..:, :z.,...,- — --.-. _ir.---..-._A--1 a..t.1/4,•.-k,;,,,=',....7..:r.r• .•. i •:-J'''.t..i.:i.,; • s •. -..•i•A:4-z...i..,-• -,:._ .....z..: -•-.•. ., f...• ---- ..., ..-„,..z. :A.,.---.-- .• 44.f":- •---•..-...:, ,-.kr...•.•te . :. • •,.' '`.... • ....--:_..1:, - -- -1,---6::•:,-3,• •-•• . : ; fi f• . __•-•.......,-r: - --------..t -, ••,-,..:.•••.----.-r: • .......4-pr..-=-F.k-_----k-m-r• — -= L. .:-- - - _;------.7,,,,..q.,-.4-.. _ ...-... ......-..b.. ... --.....,„,-,,, .... • ---,--,.;-_--,. ..-...--_-.7._....•,„-:-.....,„„-_,,,;•-•-....,.__-.....-;__-._.-..z,-.,..-____:..,....,_ ......7. _.___-________- _ . . ..... .....,_ -..____ . -_,,,t-.. .,, ..r..g,,,aaffl,....-t.__ .....-_,, - -..- ..„;•;._,.,:i.„........-------.- .-1.7"-:.,:4,..e...y.„..:f,-.......1_...i...:.-_-_ ____ _ _ . _ • - - -_ DUPLEX TO BE DEMOLISHED D.--- . -. . _ - _,_.-------..--v .....:- .---,...,->,---..„....„.„----- ,.___,_ _ ___--- — -,.._ _----,„,..------- - - - .;-, -- -- - ___ _______ _ _ -.---_-_---_-- ..,...._- . -- x itio - no 11 1 — iIt -'----; ---/-,7---- .• -__-_. ,--.....-------.•• qi..- _ -. . _ ________ - -- . • :.- —.•i- __ _ —___------,_ — - • i -- -,-- •--- --....---..=.---•„:- -_-------------_____ . - . - - - -,,,----,--------- - --_____.___-:- -=_••.-..._....-:.-_____-.--._ -.------,---?..../_-:. ..------::-_-----,„- __ - __•.z,-;-_...--z- — __7_-_-_--,, ... . • '...--- --.-_-„„,.____....---.---- • •- - - -r--•••• - - --- --- - - - -,-"- -- -_-___---=,--- . --.--_-_ --1"-- • --.`--'''.------.7 - REPLACEMENT BUILDING J 1 l 1 1 1 1 I I IU i I I I UU UUI I ll I i _ MARTIN LUTHER K _ JR. DRIVE N.E. 2ND ST. w > —u w > LLi> a —a a a a o a� Ji'ii N ,vI 'ti i di.; Z .._ v, N ,_ N.W. 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST / ST. r U w COMt.r_ '\1ITY z z C= R z Z w Z ,►,� z W z TENNIS OLD STADIUM Q SCHOOL SQUARE I I ATL = NTIC AVENUE II POLICE SOUTH i 1 COMPLEX COUNTY I >I COURT a- W HOUSE Q-- 3 W t /1 • pp- ii. ii. .. S.W. 7 ET ST, S.E. 1ST ST. I � Z o a 0 F- o f— v) o = Z W cc �� N z � 2 H _ in SKr 2,.= ST. S.E. 2ND ST. W �_i __§vi -§ I1 1!,11i — ui 1 Q v.i, ., N W W N § W N N N V1I 4 , 1 am, � 111, - 21 S.W. 1ST AVENUE PLANNING DEPARTMENT (LOT 6, BLOCK 61) CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM214 • STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: COA-9-376 Gary Eliopoulos, Authorized Agent Project Location: 21 SW 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for the demolition of a nonconforming duplex constructed in 1958. PROJECT. DESCRIPTION. The property was purchased by the developers of the Sundy Inn. It is adjacent to, and south of, the Rectory Square parking lot on SW 1st Avenue. The request is to demolish the structure. ANALYSIS The demolished structure will be replaced with the contributing single family residence which was located only a few lots south, at the northeast corner of SW 1st Avenue and SW 15.- Street. The structure was moved from the property to accommodate the construction of the Sundy Inn parking lot. It has been temporarily located at the southeast corner of SE. 1st Street and SE 1st Avenue. The replacement building will be converted from residential to commercial and used for a small retail establishment. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(F)(1), The HPB shall consider the following guidelines in evaluating applications for a COA for demolition of historic buildings; (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill the criteria for designation for listing in the National Register. (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the city. Meeting Date: March 3, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-B HPB Staff Report COA-9-376 Page 2 (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local history, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. (e) Whether there are definite plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the character of the surrounding area. The structure would not be eligible for listing in the Nation Register, nor would it be eligible as part of a district. The duplex could be replaced at a reasonable cost and is not one of the last remaining structures of its kind in the Old School Square Historic District. There are definite plans for reuse of the property, which will commence, when the site plan is approved. STAFF. COMMENTS It is appropriate to replace the noncontributing duplex with the contributing structure. However, the site plan submitted with the demolition and relocation proposal indicates that the parking will be located in the front yard. Parking in the OSSHAD zoning district is to be located to the rear or side of structures; therefore, the Board cannot consider the relocation of the replacement building at this time. It is more appropriate to defer demolition permit until the site plan has been approved. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Deny the demolition. 2. Approve the demolition, with up to a 3 month delay. 3. Approve the demolition with the following condition: • That the demolition permit will be issued when the site plan is approved by the HPB. RECOMMENDATION Based on failure to make positive findings to Section 4.5.1(F)(1), approve the demolition associated with COA-9-376 with the following condition: • That the demolition permit will be issued when the site plan is approved by the HPB. File/u/ww/9-coa3 67sr ..,... , . -- -:.-....":t . • - -,,..,•-•..., _ _ 4-• ".- %.4p.c '"f' .I./.4:41.• ,'"._.,,.,f.,4::: ....4::*:•S•!.. ' .7.. 1-: , "',.../. • - ... • ,'"'#t".?‘..... ...,-.... ... • .._... . . n't,,,,.,....c%;,....N;...-• -k_ 4::;A:*.• - 4---.•.:--,.-.:-•f-. . .. . r:--- . , "1*,, - c2' •-.e.,-„,----ilv,"....«-::!7--...?. - . ' • •- 'A,,d, lblY*...z.... :.. - -- • •.4.:• '1....-* -..i.=T" -•-?-.--.4-.7%,:?...Z.... - '''...'-.:;•.:r.::.%•.•,-• - -.'• -'' . ..;%- _....-.....:'.'' '' IV' - ...;-..•--S..., i .1..::,..,-, ,1. -, ',..:,. • --- . ____—_ . -,----.:-..i.1.'....."... 't-.J 4 . • ;IP.:::1...:....riN•!;.'s' = ..1-.-,00-vr.-..----7 -- -:------. - — :-..re;:.11,_74-q..,k. .2.‘:',":-:3-":.-±,----:'c'N'Is::'•:-."*F.if.:;---.- ..''..-;•:::::-.Z:.,:..-.''''-:?:•47-'77.--::--.11 :1r,*-----=';'-'.. •"al'.; ' " . -''''%,_;-••• '- !..'..!•;;;-7.i-- ..,--..- - ":."-'.:•!--....- ----v-•:,•.-.. •-:-..••••1=-'--7'-'-'°'ke.---i'..-f 3-7i fel-EiPi 1:::-..' ANii..;;,1::: -: • 1 :.:. . _ !..-A.,-•'-':,.. *.",- j-•-;: --'-'2- '-'- ir:-:'42,ti.?:-. •-*,--1474. s‘;.--•.e.'4 Ti'..3:4. -4:- -N- ..,4 . .. ..)-_,..--_,- - ---. ez, ..5..i. 1/4.. 7' -':: : ._''';•••''''..41;.-.-.• • :. . .J .. • • ...-:-41.IN'. • .... ..-A. --- -- - ,.. •.• - : - _ / ... . .:-..121.1318 t• . - • ...-- --- - - . •...-.-...-,--;.,------_37 -------• --....- - • - • -7.--....... .,---......44-..--• .•-- -7--...... . -r,„ --....„ -...,--44-_--,-----.-....-•.,,,..--..„;_••• .. --••. --- -- .---, ......-0-07,- ....,,,-------.,_,_ _ --...-.- •:.....-- --.-.----4:s5.---.4---------:. --- ..,.....- • ..... --. .- = .-- - -----------7,,:.-...,•.-,"--,..---___-___-..----ms-, -n. • ••----,--- -....—.-...-,....4---..-•.i.„---..,-.,,,..,„„--„,„•_-„----:-.-, -..,,-. ,...-_-,-..,•,..A-•-:...... ..-....--•••,......----,--:,--...._,.•--:-.....-----,--„, ... .-• --- -- -0.-f.•::"... .., . 1-,-.......:•-,5„.z..-1,-.1,...-,......,,...,...,......,......• -.- .......•:.- •-..-,.4--.-,;:--..".1.73.. ?..7". -...1-.......'.....-....-7,2rVeT :'"',......' . ....;,..sa•,r•:.,; -"... •r-r.r.•,......:..st-i.t.:,:......c.;:•.,..s.--.4:L.-„,„-s-.... ...,4"-.;ii.,I... .--.-;7--f:', DUPLEX TO BE DEMOLISHED 5-.:-- -4. • .„--,..--_...,.: ..--,- • .., -:-_--..,.._.,- • -•_. . ,...;,_ 1....,---Vt....,„--7,7-2:-.•-,,,. "'-X,--,-‘,..-:-. --‘•-'---t--.-- ac...,....,. ,,.....--- -.3.:z --'...- - -,-;.,.-... .,.--- :,....-- -- -._ ---- -...,..,... ...,......._,_..„..T:4•'2--r •;------,_._.:. 1` --'T.AF-Z,.._ "-__- --------4,,- ---... --.,..---7.'f,..-:'-----.. . -•-•:_,--- -_ -- --- - -.---cL--_--_-1— ..........•:.--'.--'\\ -'.:•.7__.; ; - • -• - T..f.,„••-• __:-.,es s . ,....r..- ..._ ----- - , - • la \\ _.,...„7-e,---,-_- =-• -- • - • i _ _ _ _ _ , _ ....,, „-.ftit,-;;;----_...-=--••:-'--'.'' ' - -'- e -7--- - - , . .. •- - •. • - '--- A.-- - ,-51...7_:.-_-:.-.:,----•-_-,- '•---_______._.__._--.....,_-77:-.7...-,-;7_,----•s ''"'" ---=5.------'-'----7'- ---,--3--_--_...."-_:•----;•- ---------- .__- - - "__.-.,..--,,-.:--7,-,7 -_,--- --- ...00. ... • :-----7 -.•_..----'-'7 .r-- - - -e------,-- - . — als-- --.--„.........-...,-;:z;-71.7,-------........--.-_,...--r•- - .,—"-re..„---,"?" ------ . . . ••.._-...:":.`r,..--'4---••-•_,-..... ...............-r,„;.....- ..:.....::::,.Z.,.;:-.--7--.-. .,..:-.7;.........--.,-.--.-11 -.• REPLACEMENT BUILDING 11 1 I II 1 II L I I 1 1 ► II L_I p I 11 1 1 I I I L _ MARTIN LUTHER K JR. DRIVE N.E- ST. • W _J > ¢ > G > W W -W —¢ a a , ' <a 0 Q 0 — o w a N z Z Q cc v I _ Ci Li x o 3 - 'n N z IL. S N.W. 1ST ST. N.E.. . ST. 1ST Lil TYCOW., Z Z CE'• =R Z Z wi w w a.] Z Z Illif ZZTENNIS � OLD STADIUM Q SCHOOL SQUARE I A T L ,L NTIC AVENUE II POLICE SOUTH I , I COMPLEX COUNTY I > COURT HOUSE W w Q > Q j > Q Q w 4 1 S.W. i EST. S.E. 1ST ST. ' ' I > Z z it Q N N O o Z - .= N Z v1 M M Ln • I S.w. 2`,_ ST. S.E. 2ND ST. ' tr;/ _ I ,vS I /15:;ct vi w I,.w v1 vi vi I vi vi I I N ---aoft- 21 S.W. 1ST AVENUE PLANNING DEPARTMENT (LOT 6, BLOCK 61) CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM214 TAFF REPOR°T HISTORIC �PRESERVA-TION BOARD Project Name: COA-9-377, Rhoden Building, Steve Cohen, Owner; Kelly Maudsley, Agent Project Location: 2 East Atlantic Avenue, the southeast corner of E. Atlantic Avenue and S. Swinton Avenue. I EM_.,BEFORETHE .BO_AR._D An approved COA is valid for 18 months. The project was approved by the Board on February 7, 1996, and requires reconsideration. The action requested of the Board is that of approval of previously approved plans for exterior renovation to a contributing commercial building. BACKGROUND--, The two-story portion of 2 East Atlantic Avenue was constructed by the pioneer Rhoden family in 1910. It is the oldest building on Atlantic Avenue. The Historic Preservation Board considered a previous renovation proposal for this building at its meeting of December 20, 1995, and voted to deny the Certificate of Appropriateness 7 - 0. It was the Historic Preservation Board's opinion that while the proposal was creative and imaginative, it did not meet the criteria for alterations to historic buildings. Nor did it enhance the historic character of the Old School Square complex, directly across the street. Therefore, the Board was unable to make positive findings for the proposal. However, the Board did support the addition of 4 storefront windows on the Swinton Avenue façade. The Board recommended that the proposal be tabled to allow the applicant to return with revised plans which would be compatible to the criteria for alterations to historic buildings. This suggestion was unacceptable to the applicant. The applicant appealed the Board's decision to the City Commission at its meeting of January 23, 1996. Before the appeal came to a vote, the attorney representing the applicant stated that a revised renovation plan had been drafted and he asked that Board member John Johnson and I be allowed to review the revised plan for compatibility to the Development Standards of the Preservation Ordinance. We reviewed the plans and determined staff could support the revised proposal based on compatibility to the criteria for appropriate renovations. The City Commission voted to continue the appeal to allow the Historic Preservation Board to review the revised plans. Meeting Date: March 3, 1999 Agenda Item: II-C HPB Staff Report COA 9-377 Page 2 The revised plans were reviewed and approved by the Board at the meeting of February 7, 1996. These are the plans that are before you for consideration of re- approval. 'ANA;LYSIS OF THE =PR;OPOSAL The building will remain commercial. A residential rental apartment on the second floor will remain. The proposal consists of the following: • Addition of four storefront windows at ground floor level, on the Swinton Avenue (west) facade of the two-story portion of the building. • Removal of existing brick veneer and faux pilasters. • Remove the shed roof on the southwest corner of the second floor and continue the new parapet to the corner of the second floor. • Removal of the shed roof over the Swinton Avenue storefronts. • The removal of clay tile features on the parapet. The jogs at the top of the parapet will be infilled. A new parapet cornice will be added. • The addition of new glass globe light fixtures. • Remove existing awning and replace with a single shed style awing across the front façade. Add awnings, same style and color, to all first floor windows. The awning will cover both window and door of the storefronts of the Swinton Avenue elevation. • All window frames will be painted • Install wood and glass doors as indicated on the elevations • Operable wood shutters are to be installed on all second-story windows, (see staff comments). • Exterior finish is to be stucco and painted to match the Jason Building to the south. STAFF COMMENTS 6M With respect to renovations or alterations to historic buildings, our ordinance does not require that a building be restored to its original appearance, only that the alterations preserve what architectural features exist and that the renovation is appropriate to the architectural character of the structure and the historic district; and that the alteration be compatible with the Development Standards of the ordinance. Staff believes that this renovation accomplishes these goals for the following reasons: HPB Staff Report COA 9-377 Page 3 Compatibility with the Historic Preservation Ordinance, LDR Section 4.1.5(2) which states that buildings shall only be altered in a manner that will preserve the historical and architectural character of the structure, site or district. With its clean lines and lack or adornment, this proposal preserves the historical and architectural character of the 1910 vernacular commercial building. Without actually restoring the structure, it emphasizes what is existing of the original window and door opening of the Atlantic Avenue facade. Compatibility with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation state that each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time place and use. This renovation proposal removes the inappropriate 1950s "slipcovering" of simulated brick and pilasters and restores the character and ambiance of an early Atlantic Avenue commercial building. It adheres to the attached example of "appropriate renovation" for a simplified traditional vernacular storefront renovation. Staff recommends that the following be added as conditions of approval: • In the event that wood shutters with the required hurricane wind load are not available, operable aluminum shutters will be installed • All hurricane panels will have direct mount installation. • The original center door of the east bay on Atlantic Avenue (Safari Steakhouse) was moved to the left, without a building permit or COA approval. In order to maintain the original fenestration and door openings the door should be relocated to the center of the bay with a window on either side. „ ..t....... ALTERNATIVE ACTION! 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. 3. Approve, with conditions. HPB Staff Report COA 9-377 Page 4 RECOMMENDED ACTION Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E) and the Design Guidelines, approve COA 9-377 as presented with the following conditions: • In the event that wood shutters with the required hurricane wind load are not available, operable aluminum shutters will be installed. • All hurricane panels will have direct mount installation. • That the door of the east bay of the front facade be relocated to its original center location. file u.www/coa9-377sr • • * : *4. •..� •i -7, ii., •-~'4{tip �r J . :Ap...* . s'..3-,._. :t4.... •-,..t'..,"\:-: --...-"-rcv.#.•:."'":.i%--.J..,-,e.•,," 'Vt. ....pt:' „,f i, :. . s. :st.. i.. .;•• --„....-.-.A.. 1,1..•....‘,...1 . .4-1 • - • ... .,,et...„ • . ,. . ,. -.0-e_ .k. ..„. ...... • , - 1 • . : • • - — - •• _ - ~� ^.. �, t • ` •Wit- •/•' R , o i' •:R •.. • I. . . ..— . -:,. -1.1 ' .. 1-- - T -- II. -L _, ii..„,,, ,.. . . i ..., -, :,._ -. 4 ._ S. + 4 t.e+41c twit'4,,5t-:,= :7"aa r T - :� j • - •...ti. �. , . ,.-it f~ 7.. '. .- . +' �;-f $ '!.'f it . �� ?. i iiK-„ fY,4,.:'f. .•�,: - r -*���}J:�mil�l'.' -r,- ..-• ' - "- •-y�L� -:444f•-< -' !••'�• /.-3.•••',.:0= •,7�v-b-..;': a'•!'.-r!. - ' , . ..••• s. orb,- . .:•�-.- • ...• • • ...el-•- • NORTH EAST ELEVATI ❑N OF HAITIAN ART BUILDING • • '---_;i ._•--:✓— _ - - 3- ' ,f ••55..+.fie :Y.w4 ;'sa: ° y - -. -•• _ - - -r `' .` .. '.a,._.. -; -2 3"1. .."m►. j- r ems' 4 1 e .. }...'- _ -i{1' _ : i ; �. 'S�,s -•^rt • I _ • - =:`•" may'! — = • e,ate;'"••.:;... - SOUTH EAST ELEVATI ❑N OF HAITIAN ART BUILDING .,,.. , -_,•-1.2.74,.-Jrnri.1.-7'.. .:-.i--,-..i.:-:,1•,,t..±.. .....,K••:•F•ve;:•••-',•'•*.:',.----!"••''1.,,,t I:0- ..• 4.1 ' • - - .-••- - s...--.4, ::-.fr--1_.:.-..,;,.--_..4...:.•,..z.-..-: ,•e.tc.....:.-•-•,-,..'• •.---- •-,--,-. -,..• - .. ... i , - .:•-,...--:-..3i,,,,,...-4-:;;,;..:-.%ieszi*.-:.*„.-->,,..7.1 1 -.....,..- ...4: :...-..--,:,-;..-.....c 2.• ' -,. ...-''-'-:".'4'.-.1•-1-.1.7*-;-:41".e.,:ki4:littr_e„.' - - !''',:tz%-:,!,',-;;--..,,, ,,.-v 1: .p...4i) p,..--,-;,-4..---41.,_ •.,-..,47....-..c.f.t,„--0« ••-•=;•''.•%.. .,„' 14.!...'se.fi,-.31,. ..:_;-,.. - ;r.. -0 - - ;-,.. ;....,•:7'4:1 -,,2c..4 •-•f-A., - ,.,•....:,,,.. z•-9,-,.-.•,, '.• ' .:-...0.--.1,,,i-,-„.re ':-.-. '-, • '---L.,-.tfr i-4-;Y3.0.4.'t. .• • ,,,- c`k!-,Z.,‘,4".1.-ig,-- 1,Frr.,:, .., , .,-•..ip.„,.-:#oe,;• - A.......r.„..- -.--- - • ,,,,...':41;:c•17..t.....$..•-:.,;.,r.,,,,,,1,4.,,l`.. , Izi.p,---‘.... t-,"_;:i-z.,.-i- ,=_.,k, W.,,, .!,,'• - c.1.1.9„k%ktj . 1 '" ;-,.'..-:;;V:04-4•Iitt....4tr,;:,;',..t_:.',f::: '.';':',W-•:;.?".;..Y.•''''..:'2., 41-.;::,•1,.."'"i-sy,,,"..V:4": •."''.....,,,:s -,-`-.2: - - '...,!:".....:-..:T.:',1,.',*;724,-;;;'," -.14•ii Ve.,,t., _........'''',.,_.4M _.....___,.....! - •.--..-47, 'L.'S ‘.,..1..L.,.,FtY-er,.?"-'i,F,‘,-,>••15',. -',„,;" .7.•'-.,":-,:.-...!-•:..'.1;'.•:.-::t4:1"?.,,.t....L7,......•,rd, .L.k-r -We ,1.-- ':' : ... '-'''''''' -:.r- ' ' .--. - ••-•-•‘-,--':..'"---'5.-•_'<•'.n.7.-...:..-'5..1'-r•••47•A • ,...e__,„,,-.., . : .., , ..-.•.,.,7••,.',..A.,..,` pr.,.... ....;.--;,---, .... ..•-`2:•,,.,---,,c7:1-:-;:-,.:,,'::-•:7-;,Vee...-i_-.::: .--.4 - '-• '‘ -.4.f...:'.;•:.---•i,i, --:-.':'`'.1:',--.;.---&•1.:•?-2::".'-I '..-',;',•:i?-,-- ,A,...... - — :..: :.:.s.-. :, ,.:..:s:::1:: g,-2=, • 1 tikz....-e- .s. ..-.F...:•- .--.1.- - - ._._ .-. . . 41-14it -. ' 7.` . • t' -1%-','--V i•• • jet ...,,,,,'--, . - "4.-.1. K''' • 1 Ka k. --...i-,::: . i •,...- •-".4 ..,,____ )4 *1011i . e ...- .. , • „Ant i, t• ..' ' 1." li - - 14•'ir:-- t. - :. . - • •.1 .. ,---'• ' ,5•!z4; -... 14. ; L4, '..-..•-.." I-7.41•••.:::-,,: • - P-.11,•,:::•,:ji--kPt,", 4.14i -, ---..c17.......,,.... .: .7.,,,,,,, - i .7••., . .... 4,* .•••1,-`k 4::' "U ,,-.., •.;• ,,. -",.1-'' ''•• '-j.,-"":"--,-,2-L.-,:, 1)-4..,!,r±:V; a._a• _ -... ;:---: -,';;;.->,....,..fr • 7*--i-.4- 4•16,•1,. ..4• 4--.- -,..„ -.........„2:.-2.-.,-,;-!._,- 4 . ,,-- 7,1-4 4.-:'.---.•‘'''.•-•:",•-4.%..,:y.",- 1., %,c.4.1-,..••••• --• '''.,%:: wt.., di- 4 ,f4..--. ,-"-4.-, ,X74‘..-:4 : L. ''•'• 44...*.,:= •./Z4 Nr.x.4,,,,,,- i • .4•91I p •. ---..li - - • ‘."7-,,.. .,.."-r.,.:•= - 1 • —- - — -- _ -- --.--_ . . .... ___ ---------'411 1 ---....-- I --__.:_-------------- . •--- ------- .•-"----.'...:- ..o..-- ----•--:''"*".... _ -. - - ' 4,r ...-• ' ' ... ,?,1•-•-.-' -•:,,,•<., ,,r"...:,''''.":','",C„.4,3vrito,,V,„11! . . .." ,4- ,"c•-.... -..c- ..„.".4.....,.„ . v.40-A.....,.4.1......114.. .— ' - --..--'--1-:-,Z-..:.:4;,,-; .-Yet.F.t....%"..... - •. 4,,` V ...N.4..,t'.-..-:--';-•-• "" I 4- --•• -'1',47-.-"A% • . 1..0... .,:..2%. ....7,..e.....,..1:9-,447. ......... 4."'••-• .s.:•• 7.s,..-.1,- ,!..f;'•%-r..017;`'.e.r.,,..:•••'•". S-4.:::'-: -......,..% fi sh...4-.....t.',4.1,4.-7...... , • ... .4.'•••••••&,........" f;..A., ..'•.-*•ti:.4-•-'"'' -- - -..1 - - - - - - - -- --------- - - . . WEST ELEVATION OF HAITIAN ART BUILDING - --- - ______ ---- -- ---- ------ — 1 -- . - .-.--,=_-Fs-•,..ivg-,,--...t%:f-.... '' 1 --, • •- •-•;---:-..-••• •••.-,...;=-••,,,,:._,-_ • fill• •• ' ••• . .•- - -.•--n.,-.;..... `,..,..e--..•,-;-..• i',-.. It • 4. .. . . . ----.. , .-..--.2.:--.;..--..:..‘"• -....1;,--.”.7_,,-': ,-...- ... .-.. ,-. ...., 4 I 1 - r _......,... \t -. F.-.. . -:,,It. ' •,. v.• , - • -.NZ... •.4. '•• :...... .............)rZ•IL:4-' • • I V,, • .- • - •••-.- V..,• , if - - ,:. -, 4411k I , ake: „ie.' • ' / ... - -'• -4.•?•i: c.;•:,.,:r.e'.... - •' • W - ... .J," - • -' 11"-..--,s11:1\ ..• — • i ., -.•s-. • \ ..` • _ : -4-„, - - • . . \ . . •, __ -7.• . -!:••••_ -1._-L.-.... - _. k . ------..,-- ---__ - , • ! -- 7.- ; j. ..*. : : 1 _i_ rtl i---- - i • , i - . .. . • 'ami______. , . ___,..• _ _ • ---------. _ -- 1 • -- - •• - . ---_ -- _ 1 _ . 11lAlj. -•-- .•... .- --- • -_-,_ it- - ,,,. ----,,.... F-,-..r-- :--,--,„-:::,,,_ 1- - ....">'•'"'-'--- •.,1..-- ...:''..:.:,%4•.-'4%.,'W•••7---1:. - - - - "....... 1.'":••••':- ,t'f2.•"!•,..."_. :- - - - - -:-.:;;, ::.:;.-:;-!":.';‘,r;• - _ ;II:4-%.S..- t'... " •-:-.--._ --• - - -;'-' *.t..:4Z:Pt; .: .1•5--1'-'.."-'-- "' ".;-:-;..-"..-- .- AO.' - ---.------ _ - -_ _-- -- _ - -- - WEST ELEVATION OF HAITIAN ART BUILDING . _ J I I I I I I I 1 UI I ► i I LIL-I L-J1 1 1 I i1 I L MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. DRIVE N.E. 2ND ST. > — w > Lui =, ' w — -'1 • - �: - 0 w Z z N — CITY �• HALL 0 3 ~N- 0 = cc Z —. z ' ,- - M Nsr N.W. 1ST— ST. N.E. 1ST / ST. J _. w COMMUNITY D —z z CENTER Z Z 4 w Z wll / z Z TENNIS > OLD — STADIUM SCHOOL SQUARE I I ATLANTIC AVENUE iii POLICE SOUTH PIP ""' I COMPLEX COUNTY > COURT <'- HOUSE -- —Ell Q -MI S.W. 1ST ST. S.E. 1ST ST. > Z z < - N cn O 0 I- 0 2 Z Lv IY sr NZ !n M) 2 o cc M cn S.W. 2ND ST. S.E. 2ND ST. W 3 I _ o Z Li Li Vi 3 Li N 6 vi vi N '-mi. ' 2 EAST ATLANTIC AVENUE PLANNING DEPARTMENT CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM214 DEIRAY BEACH All•AmericaCity ' ' r AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: March 17, 1999 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) IL APPROVAL OF MINUTES • February 3, 1998 • February 17, 1999 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-9-379, 219 SE 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Debra Donham, Owner. Change of Roofing Material. From Flat Cement Tile: Color, Terra Cotta. To Barrel Type Cement Tile: Color, Antique Green. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN arZe Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: March 11, 1999 r • MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: March 17, 1999 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:05 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, Tony Keller, William Griffin; Shane Ames arrived at 6:18. Betty Diggans has officially resigned from the Board. MEMBERS ABSENT: John Johnson STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: It was moved by Ms. Hurlburt, seconded by Mr. Griffin and passed 4-0 to approve the minutes from February 3, 1999 and February 17, 1999 with the following corrections: • The minutes of February 3, 1999, Agenda Item II, Public Hearing, should reflect that 4 persons spoke in favor of the Vista Del Mar historic district designation. • In both the February 3rd and February 17, 1999 minutes William Griffin's last name was misspelled. III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-9-379. 219 SE 7th Avenue, Contributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Debra Donham, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is to approve a change of roofing material from flat cement tile, color, terra cotta to barrel type cement tile, color antique green. - 1 - 3/17/99 It was moved by Mrs. Hurlburt, seconded by Mr. Keller and passed 5-0 to approve the roof tile as presented. Additionally, the Board approved the replacement of the existing awning fabric from white to taupe with cream trim; and replacement of the metal balcony railings to reasonably replicate the existing. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None C. Staff ADD ON AGENDA ITEMS 1. COA-364, Dittmann Federspeil office building, southeast corner of NW 1st Avenue and NW 1st Street. 2. Mrs. Cayce presented the color scheme for the building and noted that they were compatible with the approved color pallet and did not require a vote, unless the Board felt that they were inappropriate. As the applicant was not present, if a vote was required the item would be presented at the next meeting. The Board felt the color scheme was appropriate and no formal vote was taken. 2. COA-374-Continuation: Saveway Market, 139 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for two 3' x 8' temporary aluminum signs to be installed on the north and west elevations of the building. The text "Saveway Market" will be painted on the aluminum; blue letters outlined in black. It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Mr. Keller and passed 5-0 to approve the sign with the following conditions: • That the temporary signs will only be allowed for a period of 6 months. At that time permanent signs, which must be approved by the Board, will be installed. -2- 3/17/99 • The Board does not feel that the "SAVEWAY" font style is appropriate for the historic district and does not want the owner to consider it as a logo or for use on the permanent signs. 3. 330 NE 1st Avenue, contributing duplex, Old School Square Historic District, Don Fee, owner. Mrs. Cayce presented the proposed paint colors to the Board. The colors are compatible with the approved pallet, however, the mustard-yellow was deeper than the yellows on the pallet. Mrs. Cayce presented a sketch for a pergola the owner proposes to construct at the front entrance; it will require a variance and the Board's comments were requested. The Board felt the pergola would be an appropriate addition depending on its distance from the sidewalk, and generally felt they could support a variance. The paint colors were approved without a formal vote. V. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mrs. Hurlburt moved to adjourn the meeting at. 6:40 p.m., seconded by Mr. Keller and passed 5-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on Ga � \ 21 , 1999. , _ If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -3- 3/17/99 DELRAY BEACH bital All-AmericaCity I ' AGENDA 1993 - HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: March 17, 1999 Type of Meeting: Workshop Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:30 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) ll. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Preservation Awards Program U. Creation of New Historic Districts C. Comprehensive Survey of the City's Historic Structures and Update of Existing Surveys HI. ADJOURN Pat Cay Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: March 11, 1999 File/u/agenda/workshop-3-17-99 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: February 17, 1999 LOCATION: First floor conference Room I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:03 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, John Johnson, Shane Ames. William Giffin Tony Keller. MEMBERS ABSENT: Betty Diggans. STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Jay Jamback, Assistant City Attorney, Loretta Heussi. II. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES It was moved by Mrs. Hurlburt and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 6-0 to approve the minutes for January 6, 1999 and January 20, 1999. II. PUBLIC HEARING Due to a conflict of interest, the chair stepped down. Variance-57: 115 SW 1st Avenue, Lot 2 of the Sundy Estates, Old School Square Historic District. Rodney Romano or John Szerdi, Authorized Agent. Those who were to give testimony with respect to the variance request were sworn in by staff member, Loretta Heussi. The Chairman opened the Public Hearing at 6:10 PM. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of granting a variance to LDR Section 4.3.4(K) pertaining to front setback requirements. The development proposal consisted of demolishing an existing 4-unit contributing apartment structure and constructing a new 6-unit hotel building on the footprint of the historic building. In order to construct the new building on the footprint of the existing, a variance was required. -1 - 2/17/99 It was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Griffin and passed 5-0 to approve the variance to LDR Section 4.3.4(K) to reduce the front setback from the required 25' to 6'2". IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-9-356, 115 SW 1st Avenue, Lot 2 of the Sundy Estates, Old School Square Historic District. Rodney Romano or John Szerdi, Authorized Agent. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for a modification to the design elements of a previously approved plan; and approval for the demolition of an existing contributing structure. It was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Griffin and passed 5-0 to approve the modified design elements associated with COA-9-356. It was moved by Mr. Ames and seconded by Mr. Griffin and passed 5-0 to approve the demolition of the contribution structure located on the site. B. COA-9-374; M&J Saveway Market, 139 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District. Max Nicolas, Business Owner. Item before the Board: The action requested of the Board was that of approval for 2 wall signs, one on the west elevation and one on the north elevation. The signs are 10' x 6' for a total 60' s.f. each. After discussion with respect to the unfinished landscape and paving plan and the inappropriate security bars and gates, it was moved by Mrs. Hurlburt and seconded by Mr. Johnson and passed 6-0 to deny the signs as presented, with the following direction: • The sign permit application must be drawn by a sign contractor; and • The text of the sign should include only the name, address and phone number of the market. Mrs. Cayce announced that she had 3 requests for informal pre-application comments after the agenda was posted. She asked if the Board wanted to consider them. Add-on Agenda Items: C. New construction, two-story single family residence at the northwest corner of N. Swinton and NW 3`d Street. Tony Keller, owner. -2- 2/17/99 The Board encouraged Mr. Keller to formally submit his application as presented. D. The Steve Cohen property at the southeast corner of NW 1st Avenue and NW1 st Street. The proposal is to demolish an existing contributing Mission Revival style single family residence and construct a 9,300 s.f. office building with an associated parking lot. The parking lot cannot accommodate all of the required spaces and the applicant will purchase 8 spaces from the CRA lot adjacent to the south. Staff presented technical comments from the Planning staff. After discussion the Board felt that the building was too large for the lot. That the building was too massive and that the size should be reduced and the design should contain more residential characteristics. Additionally, the Board felt that the longer side of the building should face 1st Avenue with the parking to the east rather that to the south. D. Renovation to the front façade of the building to the west of 32 East Atlantic Avenue (the old Backroom Bar). This is a revision to a pre-application review, which eliminates the stairway to the roof garden restaurant. The Board liked the proposal but wants to compare it with the plans they previously reviewed. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEM Discussion regarding the agenda for the Historic Preservation Board Workshop scheduled for February 24, 1999. After discussion each Board member listed five items by priority for consideration on the workshop agenda. VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None C. Staff None -3- 2/17/99 VII. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mrs. Hurlburt moved to adjourn the meeting at. 7:30 p.m. seconded by Mr. Ames and passed 6-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on , 1999. If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -4- 2/17/99 STAFF REPORT HISTORICa PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: COA-9-379, Debra Donham, Owner. Project Location: 219 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District. 1yTE,M BEFORaE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a roof material and color change for a contributing single family residence, pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E). P'ROJ,ECT © ESCRIPTIOt�I Remove existing terra cotta flat cement roof tile and replace with barrel type antique seafoam green cement tile. STAFF COMMENTS The contributing house was constructed in 1935. It is faced with old brick and the wood trim is painted white. The green roof will add a third color to the palette. A white canvas awning in the front will be recovered with green canvas similar in color to the roof. The proposed changes are appropriate to the house and the historic district. ALT ERN ATIVE ACTIONS 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. RECOMMENDATION Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve the proposed roof tile as presented. File/u/ww/coa-9-379sr Meeting Date: March 17, 1999 Agenda Item: Ill-A m 1111111 1111 ; 1 l 11II J (HIM) li L_IJI I I I I ! IIII I II ATLANTIC- AVENUE IIWATERV✓AY EAST )) COMMERCIAL I:: •- n CONDO .N a II 1 t I Q Q d > > I I BAR/ R / CONDO I S.E. 1ST ST. I MIRAMAR STREET o BUDS ' I ©_ . 1 J ,�- , _ 31 Q IIGIa OCEAN _ 41 PLACE 'CONDO W W Vl I COCONUT ROW �--, INGRAHAM S.E. _ 2ND ST. }_ AVENUE Ii1 I 1 3 SEAGATE 1 OCEAN TERR OCEAN C TOWERS —' l TERR. 1 W L_ ' I ,_ -�N AS AU, S T. 1,5 i I ( Z III k S.E. 3RD ST. BAY STREET 1 0 O Z Z O O LANIKAI N m m VILLAS • I I- CC m I- CONDO O 0 LANGER WAY O O Li w La !n Z w VI Vi Vi VI I S.E. 4TH ST SEAGATE , I CASUARINA ROAD I MANOR �� 0 DELRAY o.crn. • lift" S.E. STH ST. BEACH (BUCIDA' RD. 1 I , WOMEN'S , CLUB *AO,t--4.:r -> > Q La a w . 0Q Q IF- —( o I N .111. � S.E. 6TH , ST. BARTON MELALEUCA RD. p Q 2 = APT Q a a a In co CONDOS O ill. oRI$5 LatiRD. 0 o Lj CHURCHILL Q S.E. N n 7TH - .N�� CONDO TAMARIND RD. Q H se U O V) Z O v<1111111 i co -- BARAIFTT �› - Z w w Li BANK �' vF' N•: U O u, N BUILDING -r 5v„vi . U S.E. 8TH ST. BAUHINIA ROAD __ �1 r l� I I I I I I (-ice I. -- N DONHAM RESIDENCE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL (219 S.E. 7TH AVENUE) PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM211