Loading...
HPB-04-16-1997 s DELRAY BEACH itittia. All-AmericaCity 111111. 1993 AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: April 16, 1997 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES • April 2, 1997 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-307: Sandoway House, 142 S. Ocean Boulevard, Contributing Building, Individually Listed in the Local Register of Historic Places. Palm Beach County, Owner; Carolyn Patton, Authorized Agent. Design Elements and Elevations Associated with the Conversion of a Single Family Residence to a Nature Center. B. COA-308: 625 N.E. 3rd Avenue, Non-contributing Single Family. Residence, Del-Ida Park Historic District: Robert Kipp, Owner Approval for Security Bars Installed Without Building Permit or COA. f • HPB Meeting April 16, 1997 Page 2 IV. DISCUSSION AND ACTIONS ITEMS A. Review the Designation Report for the Trinity Lutheran Chapel and Establish a Date for the Public Hearing Pursuant to Nominating the Chapel to the Local Register of Historic Places. V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VI. ADJOURN Pat C La Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: April 10, 1997 file/uagenda/hpb4-16 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: APRIL 16, 1997 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Vice-Chairman at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Vice-Chairman Johnson, Susan Hurlburt, Betty Diggans, Anthony Damiano MEMBERS ABSENT: John Vaughan, Debora Turner, Vera Farrington STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Diana Mund II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The Minutes for the Regular Meeting of April 2, 1997 were before the Board for consideration. Ms. Hurlburt moved to approve the Minutes as presented. The motion was seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 4-0. III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 97-307: Sandoway House; 142 S. Ocean Boulevard; Contributing Building; Individually Listed in the Local Register of Historic Places; Palm Beach County, Owner; Carolyn Patton, Authorized Agent. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA for design elements and elevations associated with the conversion of a single family residence to a nature center. It was moved by Mr. Damiano, seconded by Ms. Hurlburt and passed 4-0 to approve COA 97-307 based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E) for the elevations and design elements, with the exception of the handicap ramp and entrance and the inner guard rail for the second floor east deck, as presented with the following conditions: 1. That the applicant return to the Board for site plan and landscape plan approval after the City has finalized parking plans for the Sandoway Park and Ingraham Street parking lots. The revised site plan will incorporate the handicap access ramp and entrance; 2. That elevations be provided for the new access ramp and entrance door; 3. That alternative designs for the inner guard rail for the second floor east deck be presented to the Board with appropriate elevations and shop drawings; 4. The roofing material shall be white fiberglass shingles; 5. The house shall be painted white with dark green shutters; 6. That notes on the plans indicate that canvas awnings are to be installed on the front screened porch. These will be considered in Phase II of the project and will require Board review at that time; and, 7. That any modification to the exterior not specified in the approved plans, will require revised drawings and COA approval. B. COA 97-308: 625 N.E. 3rd Avenue; Non-Contributing Single Family Residence; Del-Ida Park Historic District; Robert Kipp, Owner; Robert Going, Authorized Agent. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA for security bars installed without a building permit or COA. Mary Lou Jamison, Del-Ida Park Neighborhood Association, stated that the east side of N.E. 3rd Avenue is the highest crime incident area in the district, partially because of its proximity to the railroad tracks. She felt that safety considerations should be considered and stated that she had no objection to the security bars in this particular case. It was moved by Ms. Hurlbut, seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 3-1 (Damiano dissenting) to approved COA 97-308 for previously installed exterior security bars with the following condition: • That the owner provide, for the record, the cost of installing the security bars. IV. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. Review the Designation Report for the Trinity Lutheran Chapel and Establish a Date for the Public Hearing Pursuant to Nominating the Chapel to the Local Register of Historic Places. It was moved by Ms. Hurlbert, seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 4-0 to set May 7, 1997 as the Public Hearing date for the nomination of the Trinity Lutheran Chapel to the Local Register of Historic Places. V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives -2- 04/16/97 None B. Board Members Ms. Hurlburt stated that a few of the residents on Vista Del Mar Drive expressed an interest in becoming an Historic District. C. Staff Mrs. Cayce informed the Board that Mt. Olive Church's alley abandonment would be going to the City Commission's May 6, 1997 meeting. Mrs. Cayce informed the Board that National Preservation Week is May 11 - 17, 1997, for which she has sent a proclamation to the City Commission for their May 6, 1997 meeting, and was in need of one or two Board members to be present. Mr. Johnson, Ms. Hurlburt, and Mr. Damiano stated that they would check their calendars and if they were available would attend the meeting. Mrs. Cayce stated that Ocean Breeze Estates was interested in becoming an Historic District. VI. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Ms. Hurlburt moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:00 P.M., seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 4-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for April 16, 1997, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on May 7, 1997. Diana Mund✓ If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -3- 04/16/97 Project Name: COA-307, Sandoway House Project Location: 142 S. Ocean Boulevard The action requested of the Board is that of approval of the elevations, with the exclusion of the handicapped access entrance and ramp, associated with the conversion of a contributing single family residence to a nature center. The subject property was constructed in 1936 as a 2 story single family residence and is now being converted to a nature center. It is located on the west side of A1A directly across from the public beach. Sandoway Park and parking lot is located directly to the north and the Ingraham Street parking lot is located to the south. In order to save the house from development pressures a group of interested community members formed the nonprofit Friends of Sandoway House Nature Center, Inc. The group was able to convince Palm Beach County, with funds from the Florida Communities Trust and the City of Delray Beach, to purchase the house. Last year the project received a $25,000 matching grant award from the Florida Division of Historical Resources. The Sandoway House was designated to the Local Register of Historic Places on December 3, 1996. Site Plan A separate report is being prepared for the site plan, which will address concurrency and parking details. Part of the City's agreement with the County for the purchase and conversion of the house is to provide 30 additional public parking spaces in the area. Handicapped parking spaces will be provided in proximity to the Sandoway House, currently these are being proposed in the • northeast corner of the Ingraham Street lot. Because.the parking plans have not been completed by the City, it is not possible to finalize the location of the handicapped ramp and accessible entrance door. The most recent preliminary parking layout indicates that the ramp will commence approximately 20' west of the front property line and run 10' north of the south property line and continue to the entrance door, which will be at the front south corner or the porch. .When the Meeting Date:April 16, 1997 Agenda Item: Ill-A HPB Staff Report Sandoway House, COA-306 Page 2 City's parking plans are finalized, the applicant will return to the Board for site - plan and final COA approval. Modifications to the elevations may also be necessary at that time in order to fix the location of the ramp and entrance. Landscape Plan The Center's front yard will become a dune garden which will include plants native to the dune environment. Bill Wilsher, the County's park planning and design superintendent, will design the natural landscape plan and irrigation system. The rear yard is largely taken up by an existing swimming pool, this pool will become an artificial coral reef. The landscape plan will not be considered at this meeting. When the plans are finalized the applicant will return to the Board for landscape approval. Elevations The overall description of the work is as follows: • The existing building interior is to renovated to meet ADA standards. This includes removal of interior doors from main access corridors to insure adequate egress widths. • New handicapped accessible bathrooms are to be installed in an addition to be constructed on the northwest corner of the building. • A new handicapped lift tower for access from the ground floor to second floor and garage floor will be constructed in the addition mentioned above. • A new stairway will be constructed on the west wall to comply with the fire safety requirements. • A 5' 6" addition will be constructed to the west wall of the garage. The garage will be used as a class room/meeting room. • A new handicapped entry ramp and door are to be constructed at the southeast corner of the building. • Prior to new construction hazardous material abatement must be carried out for existing asbestos floor tiles in the kitchen. In addition, existing lead paint is to be removed (where paint is severely peeling) or covered by new paint where abatement is deemed to be unnecessary. • Any damaged floor, wall or roof area is to be replaced. This includes floor boards or exterior siding as necessary. HPB Staff Report Sandoway House, COA-306 Page 3 • New interior raised floor and threshold ramps are to be constructed for handicapped accessibility to the main areas of the house. • Repair and reroofing of existing flat and sloped roof areas as well as renovation and repair of existing east and west side roof deck areas which presently have problems with leaking. • The east roof deck wood railing is to be repaired. A new handrail meeting code requirements is to be constructed behind the existing railing to insure protected access to roof deck area. • Upgrading of all electrical, plumbing and mechanical service to meet the new facility requirements. • All new exterior wall construction is to use and match existing ground floor and second floor detailing and materials (where applicable), in order to insure proper compatibility with existing portions of the house. • Partial demolition will occur at the following locations: 1. West wall and roof of the existing garage area for renovation and expansion of this space for new use as a class room. 2. Partial demolition of ground floor and second floor rear bathrooms for addition of a new exterior construction of a lift tower. • According to the architect's notes, canvas awnings are to be installed on the front screened porch. Configuration, style and color will require review by the • Board. • Paint colors have not been specified. • It is unclear if the entire roof is to be replaced. If replacement is necessary the material, color and style need to be specified. • Staff has a concern with the new guard rail to be installed behind the existing second floor front deck guard rail. Perhaps it would be more appropriate to construct a new wood rail, as close as possible in design to the existing but which meets the code requirements, rather than use the double rail. HPB Staff Report Sandoway House, COA-306 Page 4 REVIEW BY OTHERS .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. A courtesy notice has been sent to the Beach Property Owners Association, their comments, if any, will be available at the meeting. A0gPONIIRgIAgr000lloomminimmulli 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. RECOMMENDATION 1. Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve the elevations, exclusive of the handicapped access ramp and entrance door, associated with COA-30-q. file/u/ww/coa307sr Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 1 • ik r 4- RR R r. -i. .. .' I.:•r#:-i i ii i sin . .._., ism • ' t. �. - �.,..- - ��• �. is •+..t .f`.�•+ . }• j` f f' 1111 ' .-y .1:�.,�•ti L^ s't' i .. Y Y 1'.: i J I.L .•:ti •1 ji. �j:` y p-. , -... . -.owl...4,n.: •- ,,y1.w : . '"Cyc...3.1 —..4~.-. . ,4. fit. _ ...... ��.. •" �. _Y..V•n •- - .a•- East Elevation I. .-f I' �` • `_ *...,_ I • : ::::e —:•-:=:''' ii . -- -.;--4, 't. ...0.....- r , I i iin . Y r ;.1 r" # Ir f :' 'II ;'-'i ir ' T� ,�`i � � / / i''''.;#,."'4;t . ;� • ., a•�~` t'i _`r J j -k . # "W-416‘I P.4&I) 4. , . b.: „(4%10.v..___,., +iY. - Jam:: - ... l -. -. .1. I _.�•�.=1�" Vim.. ..- Second Story Porch (Observation Deck) „. I Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 2 1•.w...w"`� , r r .- '„ e ms•`-\ �; , •T • yam. _ r �� i j, .• i .... .•...', .1 . j,"f,i-.,.••• - 7../..r, , . .,i-• r , .. , ..,.., _ ,...,../.. , ., ,..i. , pr, . .,„ 1,,....„_...(... • , . , . ,„.. g -,444- 4i ,r) , dr- ' .% ___:/,..••;,......]T.- :•• ' - iiCCi, tE ,Fet :'` - �r .. �-` •: •.r I 1 _• . •-fir' ` ~„`' . Second Story Porch frdm South 1_' se,,�j it,u� . i•-•k*t .-4":-2`le''S„- A?7S K '3il`p`L rs. .` .- F > lY-:;g:x-'.'tir s� `��”� <�:s• � c 3,tc Y"`�' �"'Ss•�a �?-.',,.' + �. 3^..',Yr"`r�'%pr ..t'"�`d u;P';, ' `",:c"h +S.="4r � —`,-.� {,i'.,.a�' '`r 4-.. "n' .t'x1'1�y 'tf � .Fa •zi lf.9.i+ yq"�rr-,i fit A r• L . -..fit`'. ' `, 9! FGr4. k.rr r &4 € Z-.:«t ''' _ ^1^1p', '' �e£� -._u- r,,.3 .h' t c 'rote-,,a,,a Xa r92'�.+Y+ X - i -1 ,_ '.. Z n�. '' ''r'^£s-ry , rcr S-t n+v,+ .,nl Z. . A.p i` .e.,�4v e-a ,.,.F �'.�£•..d+.rvz. ; '-srn x, - -'. -e-. i'•r -r ^"' M� ^ -4-54,i .1F,±Z rem YJ ` ` -s- _ - • 'i '` -1+" ,w e-Y- >a.?S s`� 7: i"s" „ 4: _-ram-+•,;.- i r r. .i ,..c x -. :.Sn ,7.er \s,'•C... j' .tn Ar'us _y ... ' -t rx x"'1 sue- '' r • ,�. Yam: T fit.. • r_ k . - !l��� •.'4 ' - t .Nc ?k,_ .'Y 4'+' ,,, 5SZ 4�iy-,rT- j- 4yt 4 -` tom. _'. f f' . _ t _ �' .. `per.`. ♦� roc "�� _��i Y""F f��"'."�o a_�. h- I -��� Ciiimic "�'- =' `•� :� r~ -'.�.J ijiv ri,,S=' .�`a .....i. r:;��• `.J�-sect-�..:.t:r:3t>'FI'i..41F.i''..1.1.•••_,I. View of Ocean from Second Story Porch A.; L • -• Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 3 i....-- - . • ,•-• , ., . , ,, - ..,.....t.,,,,,,,vrril,,„if/v., • . 4 .. ..., 1#:;,,,..44.1' ','i p.,„ r.,...,:.,,,„. • - .,.1..., . • •,..,..„:„ ,. . ,,,. ......._ ) ,./ ,,,:!4. , 7,1, ,,,,...;.:, ,o., -. •:. , , . i fy /..ii ., , ,, . ,' % 'k,-..!!. .'.i-I :1' 110:gi . ,,.A 1. -,!..#4.t ....--- •I IV '•4:If .1. :". % .• ____3. . Its - i'. . .f...- , ..,,,.. , . k ; .. Jai- ..?.4. . . II --V .-: , • - - - .. . . - -e :4:- . -,,, veil,- •-.-1F4..r. -..1.?-:.xi- "4-`; '. 1:;: A... .—.—.— • • . 42. 1111111.,:::.-linil----,-- -7-:::. . -4.40440E. s:::2.0"; • 1'...: 7 • ..;j11. ,..-:L. . „ . ..:m.. : ,..... . • • - . .. . • .. •.•-- z .. . -,. . .. •••:F. ;is.-:-- -::- '"1!` - 40.4141,..,%-,aiW14. ,•- r...,,se-.A.. . .... — --"' . --Ai,.•.4. 1r.015,...1.rea..apz.,...--40 Oiliby....... r " ... .. - , .... 4,-!'4,*i--:--= • ,-,,.,-;„---......- ".i.....--..- 411810010111124.4-0010P......„..,,,,,,,,..‘1, ..... -...r.. • ', ,,,......2 ;-ilf. .-• -- • -rrr- - .k ...mii401,0,.,:.• ... • . ... . ..- " 2 ...- • :•- " •„---,•• North Elevation as seen from neighboring Sandoway Park . . . INUK1.-,-.1Jr —A____ _ .... • - 4 • -.- 1 - ,• :14A, ',,.1. i l."I• : . ---7- , ,• . i . .. . • . rip mum INT' • .. -4-, • s ..........! ., . i- f . -.. 1.., . . I , . -• . 4..... - ........••••••••mom.... • ill WEI .----,---L;- ";k:-.* :-.''t'- _ 4 • i • 4,' ' • . 41..... ...• .1 A , ' -- • f 0117 i 1 ...- .,-...Li::..,'_4-s'••;;.;.- _ ..._.., , III ,...lzak.a.... • _ _ XL."... ..• 411••7" ,':;•-';-•'''' 1.;IS- ? -..!.,11)... .•"°. - "". - 0 ., '-- . • .i ...I; ''' 7' a. 4; t••I.,-.: .4.1k"MA iri,..,•;'•:): .- ! ;41.....,,.....• ,.. * ...„ /......„:;....:-....,:.....K....:.1 i ,i ,1110----_.... -5/.... - --,-,:r.,,*-- ,..iv.- ,:i..•-..7•:,:•:'.. , .14 ..• -4:A4?,•k;e, %•..7;,..± •--•I/'"` '_ __=_,... _ _-.'•-." ---Z--7.Z7:- i .:— ..**.i•JA Vitt•1.-:.ri: 1 *s . ____.---..=—...••• _ ,-..=-----------=-._,_-' V., '''' -,r " .--...f.,-et,., 0 • ' '• -1—. i \ •••;q. ' ei, ,:::_--..-,f, ........ , ____ ....% . . ...t.r.!_,..z.„fie :______,--_... .,,..$4, ..., .._____ . ...,,_.. _. . . ,., ••••• AA• .. -. • _..m.. . .ls j_ :.4•••6.1 ,.ei, '• . .r..•11 ..- 1 .,..,. . . .. •i'l'''"' 111111111 "C// 1- ._ ' 71.2 1-1,...7• r".......,,..",•zri..7...:1.•-.-•,;.• - - ' -").; •,- " ....:z1t.:-.- " Malar Milli - ;..-• ...-. , • s . ••• :::-- `-, v..te,:m'4'5 •-' "- - . Af6 cf ,.•- . .v..f.:.••• 4 ' 2-17.:.t.;.1.:•,.: :: .v' :raI- liamm, iL--___T--=', .-,...f: ...iJ .; )vs,.....,... .,,.. ...._____. ... :,.;,.. .K.,.. _VW mu FM .•..'.),::::4'...i:42,....4.:. ilirr-IMTS:Zillirs , 1100„,.,7,,, simat-P,..-,..-.., 7.:-..r• , „..; :.:i . ,--. . - - -.,.,--:',,:,.•-e:-.:-.: IMILIT,2.:r.--- .1.:- • . ,• ,.-.. • ....._.....,... .a-., / :..,...:,.... . i......,;',2A1-14....r........,i .•, -.. ...s.: .s. - - 7 - . :.-."..- .T,:::vitr''..A.27 --::: .!---c-. .;:.--. • • .`V. . t• .• ..• — • . ••-• ......, •• ..It .i.:.,:1/41,1' -•- ' .' • • , t ,.. • -.. • ' ..... ...— r - Detail of North Elevation -- , _ Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 4 t . ,. • .1,.. • . ,•*.i.,.;__. . AL,•7:' ,.•%-i:. [ t;', ?'' • ..,,--.• a rY ,e — _ '► View from Northwest `h a?� �.` C4 .fib { sa• j4S visa b .r.� ram.•• - • illa :,_ • _. ,,, l`i • y ,_ .1.- - _ _ . ti - Kit - _ •ti.. ' '•- •- ..e-..-tee. { <a 1 I t 'i f ___ 3 � Attached Garage _. Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 5 s • r � • ly• ;� L H. � . h 7,yp _ , , .fY.' i._,�.Y +T - • may_: t 1 • III ?s` ' '' °` 1 1- b ,-*t jis. 7 ;\ t _ I \• Rear Second Story Porch over Garage 1a Tti ` ` s . r"rer - � ' . rw -�'' 4. `• '1 Y 7' c,r �x. "ice / .' —'�` b Q i's'ti � , , t �s -_ te ' �� �, °S0" :V'r."k,,-- vr• e, rT,�'--5 s . .3 k --,.4---- ,,_., ;IL tr i3 '+ j. 4t014, T -" Sa- r_�Y- fix} v ''-- .(f I rt z ; ';/ ;r r# — . -:t ' am- , 0-,, -_,tji.-t s �.+ i`� -1 t/ 1 r.} -_ r s .aw -- _ 'ti :rr ;••/1• • ' • ���'.�•�.-. _ + ,,.. `• .li^ �..1�`'i 1 ti~ It _ M tl�. A 2 ; 1 }) tiy~ p�t� •t or, +a !' , }}�� h • Eave detail nr• z . Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 6 • • L~ .1 e t-' s f- 6 1 ? ��snit WA 1111111 MU A } 3 3 1 < mil 1) ll 4 F . .!LP .1- F-14, 6..? 4,7 •5.'' ' ,'.'* r t_ - 1 # ..vs7. 7.. . - --"---.1 French doors leading from Porch to Living Room Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 7 5 =. s .; r, 1.,...::::,,J.,_. t _ .. . 1 , . . . . , ._, .... ..._ . ._.. .: ....... _..., ,...... .. i i _ ../...e:„.:: :, , i ' ' (- .: - -..*,-.,-- -4',.: ;,,...1 ' all.. a . a1•P t _ -,. g ,. • -$ 4 - - - • .1. Living Room West wall ;e• • / — - Wi • f t t. ' a S �,; . 1-F• -lTfrtk . _ . i' ' 1fiiew from Dining Room through original Porch to Porch addition f ' Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions • Page 8 • • • ( s ," — _- ." • ,i 1.'!ii,-; 4,,,,g,,,..,, / - ,--..=Y--'/--..r. -t`s ''..----'----:''.----.:--/-•_,'-'-..1= .7-,,V,,;,-$..-".4',..'— ":".1-''''...'-''-:1.1,kft.,,,,•:.1-,:'''I-._: , - •� ' .. _ _ � tom'#" >i` .F • wb- ce. S �+ Transom over First Floor Bedroom door (1 a1. r -r ".. -� .:-I a x - $tom`''+,; '- ,4 s.•- i '•Y 31 _ P Y.i- • •• ."`R -hit .,.+..`1st. •"4• t i j 4 l � i ' ' ter • _s T < `� t • - # ,t`�r dA i -t`•C` '- 1 }'qlT f z4, S 4T - Wood ceiling in Kitchen :r! J Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 9 f >r/,. eta _ • IL �I t f) t f t Ys %4-- Al i z- . r� . jt ; 'r� '` -3;• ' ,- - -•' ! `fie;: . N Vim_ ► _ t3 -;s'�,�R — "F; r 4Y. < ,,.x� a __ r`1' .ram i L._`. t Z 1 -ram ti,t, 3 k y� r{ p- L �. ya�..��Y 4 a • �. -N: 0 M ----.sue.�- - .• T r off ."?a,. 4 t. 57- I .- 4• Arched window at Stair Landing Sandoway House Nature Center Photographs of Existing Conditions Page 10 t 1 s-, ,:-:r n.F - d{ t _++ zz Zes a. T -r2 � S � y .en+a• ! 4 O O� + OB v!A`� x, a0® 00 00000�l►�►O lanos�O�legaNAVa.. �'-90®!�O 11.0000!®�� °�"�00 '� 'S`°4 ' t!gn®®gam�� ®® ® itatoin.•g� `ilw®_.: • Tile detail in Second Floor Main Bath -t 3 ` . • , { t 8 .ter ' d - . E W .-f Ott' ' a s / i t s l i, tJ-,t' a { • r LIL H f « '• Water damage in Master Bath (due to Roof leak) U 1 I [ ► I ► I N.E. 1ST ST. LONRY\ (STREET La z DELRAY z ' ( w 1 a VETERANS SUMMIT ¢ > Q ATLANTIC PARK CONDO W = PLAZA i / N TERRACE w 1.61 NJ CAM/NO REAL I,; CONDO <UW o HOLIDAY INN o m i z 1 a Q ATLANTIC AVENUEo WATERWAY EAST _ _> COMMERCIAL tom.. CONDO _< c '� 7 �- > z 1 / .--P a cavil ,- BAR a i 0)HARBOUR ocoCONDO _ . Q _ I I� Illajliirill CtLi1111111/ W i- 171 Mil i OCEAN PLACE � QMini • CONDO •Ill 1.1111110011M UT ROW :i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i: : , / INGRAHAM A On J Q z , ._ U Q OCEAN TERR. I LL1 Q SEAGATE OCEAN TERR. -11 0 1- TOWERS ■ Cr) 111111E S T. U _ z ►- Q U Z tY - BAY STREET Q J z }. LANIKAI Q VILLAS CONDO LANGER WAY r — U vi I N —ilmili— SANDOWAY HOUSE PLANNING DEPARTMENT - CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM087 f • Project Name: COA-308- Project Location: 625 N.E. 3rd Avenue The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA-308 to allow previously installed security bars to remain. This is a non-contributing single family residential rental property in the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The security bars were installed by a contractor who failed to obtain a building permit or a COA. The metal security bars are installed on the outside of the windows. The Design Guidelines does not specifically deny security bars. However, it states "electronic security systems should be investigated as an alternative to these devices. They should be installed so that they cannot be seen from the street." ........................................ A courtesy notice was sent to the Del-Ida Park Neighborhood Association. Their comments, if any, will be available at the meeting. 1. Deny, with reasons stated, and require that all bars be removed. 2. Deny the use of bars on the front windows and allow the side and rear bars to remain. 3. Approve as installed. Meeting Date: April 16, 1997 Agenda Item: III-B HPB Staff Report COA-308- Page 2 ::>::>::>::>::»::>::>:::::;:>:::::;:>::>:<:::>::>::>::>::>:::<:»::>::>:<:::::>::>::»::>::>::>::>::::>::>::::>::>:;::» Board's discretion. f file/u/www/coa308sr ':.1 0:,i?.-,,-3•,•,,i0t11 lei' iii- °••••...t'''' ' .:'''...,...?..•:•.{. • fir, „� ct'•-: �c /,• �f • - - e-.9, r4 �^ t - "(' ' ' _- s,i.4r W _ - fi r . aJ+ _ - va V.. ,..yam -.. . n •ti- .cFrV ~' om w '`� : _ .moC'' < J r -i�„ . �i : j •-1_ •` . --.Y � - •' . •� �. � , ! _ Z.1 � .a - fT . R . 3_;': may. - (�`�;YF'�; I �•- �.� /3664 54 52T 't�3. I 1� (Subd.ofSae9.,T.46S f?*JE) so i J1, O 1/1. ,,b lBrr /5 /4 13 /2 J/ /0 9 8 7 6 5 4 16 /5 4 /3�:7 // /0 9 8 7 6 S 6 - 0 2 15 'Lit EMI- ,� 1/ y 1176 ��i8 3 . \ .,I f:c' lb l7 /8 /9 10 11 11 73 Zs 25 26 27 In 9 0 /7 /B /9 20 1/ 11 13 Z4 ZS 16 17 28 19 a Z/ ' ` ,irQ 341,ee 41 J 56 b rs,3. • c ' 16 7 M ,_ 4 :Tr,: M I ., 9TN ST. so 'o°„ sp 5o t1 13,1: tti / figit. WE ram K /la41; , ,7. 77 .os y /S /4 3 /2 // r0 9 8 7 6 5 .4 /6 /5 /4 /3 /Z /I /0 9 6 7 6 5 4 . 13 �8 E i � N 2 �, N Z = Ri Ma WM ' 4 • f - 3 i� W� ' /P / d 3 y ' • 3 / Jsa ' 9 •0 . 3o Sp . l 18 N 1 N 3/ I Mill// - 16 17118 19 10 1/ 1/1- 1 13 11 25 16 17 19___ 17 /8 19120 11 12 23 14 2S 26 27 26129 o t �1A l ' Sc' ,a a. so so .. • • ® + :•'". 9 ' P.HOfN/X PATH I 60� I = • !So oa37L Sp, NNW ' W7 g ,0 sR Sp ME ��nl ,f. - 8TH N. 8TH ST, •. 4 a ' '°i,. So - So IJ,.- So „4•is o 7.74.4 125 •us • ! °d' s.• 10 in '_ t a 11.2/I Io I1111 i6 /5 ti • \p. S �' \ .' ,(D ? 1 I ,� 6 a ,2 ° o �4 $ q • ti �+ O• 33 H © �• �wie. I r M 5 Kr �. . im/ 0 3 ° i /3 0 ,SD ® \ L 9p c GO /!3K '$ 6 /0 //o 'O �� Ti. ' 4 r.‘4., iit • 4 "... tz 4 ,..4 y' •9N So • Ito So ,0r,6 7 6 J ® * , ,, io ' ,r�E 7 TN C T' R 2 / is' „ 'N; . ;p Tv ,0,�,7, e 40 3a tl 16 1s 14 sr. +' �22 2/ 1019 /8 /7(,61 Q • 19c .! IN im��— ' • 14 , 19 . 0 2 •• ' .7/ Q J K I d 'O :7 n1 T7 -o \ 1 °s ea • 17 ,5., so i 1 Sozstrec r /g ee,e,e.4,r_y , 6,•' n:. 7r,,i.ti; .If,T ..�-S 6 7 9 roir/°�.—....a Q.X-- ak 1 //v LAKE .$ ' TERRA E ...... •• - I-k Io1.6'0/5° // .y 0 • 9 /• . la - (ee ,,, *ti � ,`n N.E. 6 TN T. u� ° '0 1 ° 4\. 1' / ',a1 �- [+„ 2 e .'o°,q ,06:d I ,.\nado4 0,' • 50 �\ 23 • ; 1f../3/I4G Y7'15/16S / / to :° ' „ a ,> \ �' 'i:. 7 0, �` c • bn. an& /JNi rP• `' 4.,••• , $ 2�- \,6 1,, y0 ^^a: s\ •„' ,`0 r�• 11 • a' �•--�y �����,.,, ay 'I" 'fr. '� .�. b o9 p \`� \• Kids^ a ' 1/ I ..i /b 73 R �'I>•i 47 64 ' ray.!• H4ik ti•�4. o a J y c 3ti�(` G �` 6, 1•'S '. 5 '`. .6• o 01 % C O `b ;i i5 14 : 39 GS 63 �i \l.3z.s' h s6 b \b \^ V /9/>� ' N /4 ?SVEII 49 62 �. 7. o �P ` 9350 71.. I$t Os', 76 65 ►17 G q'L rJt' f�135. ".a I•'/!f • r.7,f'.i " ® ime, N T Terrace 'e I N.E. . TN I . ST. \ % C14 L q'at I!S �If',!S IJs /Jf s0 /JS 0 0 0 UNINIMINIIir-,. • 6 2 ' . /3 16 37 So 6/ ti �\ \ o1`Fi - o Vi 3 R 2 27 '; 36 D �s/0 60 h o ry /0 19 o $ at3.7. //..°4. \D 0\ b / 7v 5.'h° N.E. 5TH CT. � • /2 6 h a 9 3a T. 33 54 57 R l L a ,,9 St G /� I 8 • 3/ d 2 SS 'i w.saMECf ;o o4 • ,•o„H' b. \1„, N 3o w.So So /. • ® s o'to "s• /I�'• , ,.•' r3S' .Y'/!S ISs •56 c 7,...............„,, !} niof '_ \� �� .0 \y cSo ^ /,ss o l9 /B /7 /6 /5 /4 a ze^' /0 N.E. ST , y Is: h b � , I•\' 0 /o5' 0 8 ,ots!•' 9 ' d i sts c0 ,JS ,as' ;• • 40 czs.!' 9 y\o o \y v .°0 2 .2 a /2 ry (if' ors /I B 0 0.`tie\\ d• c \ti 'r 5� ��� D 3r'5 6 7 8 9.a, ,• 4a 3': (t! ' 8 ' I .3 1,pJ} ' 53 2 /7 A 10 3S 'n h 38 N (!\ �y 133.53' 766' 12656 4' � C' 79 l 4. � So' So „3./� R 7 '(`'�r6% ;e7s�77^�\ ti/L s_i •Mgri •� - cze.s' to N.E. 5TH ST. ' 6 ' '!�4 , ' .t /S . � wad , 40 _ `01 �'69 So .. Sp' I7 9l 8�,6 5a Sp �Zra S I S _S k1 � N 32 ` J/ _ --5/ • : y 22 2l ?o !9 .8 !7 16 /4 2' /7 /6 /5 /4 /3N I,/ , , k 6 , 6 /3 . NM 3/ ' 42 O $ N 6 •� Q 'N // 1131 0 1r , /27' c W ros. 7 `So,w,,� ® 7�' 7 /2EMI 10111 ' 43 T.•1 au � ! 0 - 5 6 7 8 9 /0 //• _ /9 " '2 i, ' �5 6 7 80 �� I Q 8 433a 8 // ` 16 19 � - t �.o° 35 ,9 =' `q 35 ,999e,• 5o So' 1O25�So ; 79,� 50 .. . So 3 60• . / z, 0 9 /o , , .� 6L7?_...- — ' N.C. - - r - 9lde Bp So ''Z a/ a ••C. ,35' , 13S' 6 N. .- rf Sr .,, DESIGNATION REPORT TRINITY LUTHERAN CHURCH CHAPEL/LIBRARY 7 a/c J4 t °s 1,,�i,'‘`_ • • 5>x ". `11 t ry > i �/ .'� r it • tY . r j� t. y 1 I .l i . /1 1 sew i.4. i. . !. • • f H x • k j - �s _ ' HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA - - 1 - DESIGNATION REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS I. GENERAL INFORMATION II. LOCATION MAP III. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY IV. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE V. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VII.BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES -2- 1. GENERAL INFORMATION Present Location: 400 North Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. Moved to present location in 1965. Original Location: Southeast corner of N.E. 1st Street and N.E. 5th Avenue; Block 110, Lots 1 & 2. Date of Construction: 1904 Architect: Unknown Builder: Constructed by the men of the congregation, under the direction of the Building Committee; Mr. Adolph Hoffman, Mr. C.H. Miller and Mr. J.S. Wuepper Present Owner: Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church Present Use: School Library and Temporary Chapel for the Haitian Emmanuel Congregation Present Zoning: Community Facility (CF) Legal Description: The Chapel is located on a portion of the Trinity Lutheran Church complex; Section 8-46-34, Delray Beach, East 1/2 of Lot 12. The chapel is the only building in the church complex being considered for historic designation. If the church complex expands, requiring relocation of the chapel on the church property, no loss of historic status will occur. Property Control Number: 12-43-46-08-21-000-1340 Classification for Designation: Architectural and Social Significance -3- II. LOCATION MAP I I I I 1 I I `- - — N.W. 9TH ST. > >< i> IV r ui N.W. 87H Si. ul d- x a ¢ GEORGE - BOULEVARD ffi N 111111111 z z Z 1 LA N.W. 7TH ST. 1111111�U N.E. 7TH ST. liii. . -�1� 1111 N > 1.4111111111WLAKE TERR. % cz9 �c. N.W. 6TH ST. J� ,:Z . � �-; • N.E. 6TH ST. _ � JO ' , wS , z ` ♦ N.E. 5TH TERR. ter• ■ E �Jp WOOD LANE KINGS LYNN ce D` ♦ z �, , N m W� Q ref N.E. STH CT. CHAPEL/ B BEVERLY DR. LIBRARY [ ,. BOY SCOUT —0- 1 1/4 N.E. 5TH sT. \ HUT TRINITY „ • LUTHERAN EVANGELICAL CHURCH z— _ N.W. ani s. LAKE I D A ROAD N.E. 4TH ST. _ F CASON METHODIST a u; CHURCH a a- > ui a a a z - .L4 3RD, Q I- -.CT. z a = M L z a K N M- d' — N.W. 3RD ST. N.E. 3RD ST. — o — z I- . N N 3 3 z CITY z z z z Z z ATTORNEY BUILDING I I I I II N TRINITY EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH ---l- -CHAPEL/LIBRARY LOCATION- - ill PLANNING'OFDELRAY BEACH, Fl DEPARTMENT CITY OF DE A-SANCTUARY B-FELLOWSHIP HALL D-CLASSROOMS -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: 1MA32 -4- III. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Constructed in 1904 as the house of worship for the Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church of Delray, the chapel is the oldest existing church building in the City. The building was moved from its original site on the southeast corner of N.E. 1st Street and N.E. 5th Avenue to its present location, 400 N. Swinton Avenue, in 1965 and served as the congregation's place of worship until the new church was constructed in 1971. Since 1971 it has been used as library for the Trinity Lutheran School as well as a temporary home for the Haitian Emmanuel Lutheran Congregation. In 1938 the simple wood vernacular church was remodeled and enlarged by the addition of a vestibule, decorative entrance steps and a rear extension. The building's exterior was stuccoed and five decorative buttresses were added to the north and south elevations. Beginning in 1940, with the gift of one stained glass window, the church began to replace the original double hung windows. The beautiful stained glass panels which now grace all of the window openings were installed, over time, as they were donated to the church. Though enlarged by the front and rear additions during the 1938 renovation, the chapel retains its original window openings, front door location and roof pitch. IV. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE The Trinity Lutheran Chapel is the oldest existing church building in the City. The chapel, as it is referred to today, was constructed as the church and original house of worship for the Trinity Lutheran Congregation of Delray Beach. The church was constructed in 1904 and was originally located at the southeast corner of N.E. 1st Street and N.E. 5th Avenue. Twenty two feet wide, fifty feet long and twelve feet high, the building was built as a wood frame vernacular structure with wood clapboard siding and set on a pier foundation. The front elevation faced west and had centered double doors with two windows flanking the entrance doors. Four wooden steps, without a railing, led to the double doors. The roof was a single gable running east and west and was surfaced with wood shingles. The roof overhang was minimal and no shelter was provided over the entrance doors. The north elevation had four symmetrically spaced windows and the south elevation was identical. There are no photographs to indicate the original east (rear) elevation. The land on which the church first stood, Lots 1 and 2 of Block 110, was purchased for $75 from Henry Blackmer, a surveyor who came from Michigan with the first white settlers in 1895. Mr. Blackmer then donated one half of the price of the lots, $37.50, to the church building fund. Henry Flagler, founder of the Florida East Coast Railroad also donated $100 to the fund. It was Flagler's policy to donate land or funds to establish religious institutions in the towns through which his railroad was expanding. The chapel was constructed by the -5- men of the congregation under the direction of the building committee; Mr. Adolph Hoffman, Mr. C.H. Miller and Mr. J.S. Wuepper. The total cost of construction was estimated and budgeted for $950. Construction began in August of 1904 and the building was completed by December of the same year, when the first child of the congregation, William Hoffman, was baptized on December 4, 1904. The interior of the church was finished with painted wood paneling and a used organ was purchased from Mr. Stirling of the Stirling Commissary for $15. When the church was built, the congregation could not afford to buy standard pews so simple wood benches were built. Later, backs were installed on the benches for the ladies' side of the aisle, however, the men found the benches with backs much more comfortable and from time to time they too used the ladies' pews. In 1913 Mr. Wuepper, of the building committee, was asked to construct backs for all of the pew benches. Electricity came to Delray in 1914, and by 1915 the church was electrified for a cost of less than $25. In 1919 Trinity decided to lay a sidewalk 50' in length in front of the church "providing the town would give a quit claim deed not to collect any more money from the church". Also in 1919 the congregation started collecting money to build a steeple, thus reviving a resolution passed two years earlier, unfortunately, though the proposal was revisited many times, the steeple was never constructed. In 1923 the congregation replaced the 19 year old roof but not with wood shingles, as in 1916 after a serious fire, the City required that all roofs be clad in metal, tile or a composition material. On Sunday afternoon, September 16th the disastrous hurricane of 1928 struck and the church was tilted off its foundation. This caused such serious damage that the congregation voted to demolish the building. Just as demolition was to occur, along came a Mr. Reed from Miami who offered to repair the church for $400. When the work was completed it was felt that the restored structure was sounder than it was before the hurricane damage. Sometime after 1932 a photograph of the south elevation shows that the rectangular windows of the church's south elevation had been given a decorative Gothic arched header, which leads to speculation that this trim was added to the north elevation as well. In 1938, with the Great Depression on the wane, the congregation began a building fund to construct a new and larger church. Plans, in the Gothic Revival style, were drawn up by Samuel Ogren, Delray's most prominent and prolific architect, the new building was to cost $12,000. However, the new building was never constructed as only $500 in pledges could be raised and it had been decided that the work could not be started until $3,000 was pledged. By July of 1938 it was decided to remodel the old building once more. The building was moved slightly to the rear of the lot and a new vestibule, with a secondary gable roof, was added to the front elevation and the church was enlarged to the rear with an additional window constructed on both the north and south elevations. Five decorative buttresses were added to the north and south facades and the -6- exterior of the building was stuccoed. The cornerstone for the remodeled church was laid on July 31, 1938. With the completion of the landscaping, which was donated by a member of the congregation, Mike Blank of Blank' s Nursery, Trinity Church had a totally new look. The chapel's beautiful stained glass windows were installed as they were donated starting in 1940 when the first window, depicting Christ in Gethsemane, was presented by Mr. and Mrs. John Schoeller. Windows were later donated by members of the congregation including the Hoffman family and Dr. William Koch. The church sustained minimal damage, $500 worth of repairs, during the hurricane of 1947 and otherwise remained in stable condition till its relocation to its current site in 1965. V. HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE Adolph Hoffman was the first person of the Lutheran faith in the area. He was • born in Germany and, while a student at an agricultural college in Stuttgart, became aware of the unique farming opportunities in south Florida. He and his friend, Frank Haller, a Roman Catholic, decided to migrate to Florida and arrived in Delray Beach (formerly Town of Linton) in 1895 the same year that the first Michigan settlers arrived, and only one year after the area had been purchased by William Linton. During the next few years Mr. and Mrs. Hoffman constructed a house on N.E.G7th Avenue and Mr. Hoffman conducted Lutheran readings at their home. In 1889 an ordained Lutheran minister held services for the first time ever in Delray. As only one minister served such a large area of the state, official services were held on an annual and sometimes semiannual basis. A number of the early Michigan pioneers were members of the Lutheran faith, thus greatly expanding the little congregation as they continued to settle in Delray. On July 17, 1904, during a reading at the J.S. Wuepper's home, the little group of worshipers determined to establish a formal congregation for the purpose of building a church and requesting a resident pastor from the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod. On August 11, 1904 the congregation decided on a name, and as the readings and services were held in the German language, the following name was proposed, "Evangelische Lutherische Dreieinigkeits Gemeinde, Delray Florida", (Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church of Delray, Florida, the name of the town was changed from Linton to Delray in 1901). While the church was under construction in 1904 the' congregation decided to rent a small house nearby to use as a school for the children. The children were to attend public school in the mornings and in the afternoon to receive instruction in religion and in the German language from the pastor. German was the usual language for church services, with English services held from time to time, until -7- the outbreak of W.W.I. Though only on a part time basis, this can be construed as the real beginning of the parochial school movement in Delray. The German language school closed at the outbreak of W.W.I, however the congregation had always harbored a desire to open a church sponsored school as an alternative to public school. In September of 1948 a new school was opened in the parish house directly south of the church, thirty three students in kindergarten and first grade were enrolled By 1952 the school conducted classes through 4th grade with more than sixty pupils enrolled, and by 1955 a separate school had been erected on property to the south of the church. However, within a few years it was apparent that more room was needed for the school, and the church purchased its present property at the northwest corner of North Swinton Avenue and N.W. 4th Street. In 1963 the groundbreaking ceremony for the new school took place. In 1965 the congregation put its property on N.E. 5th Avenue up for sale and the church was moved to the Swinton Avenue site and served as the congregation's house of worship until a new church was constructed in 1971. The original church became known as the chapel and is used as a library and for the school, and for the past several years has served as an interim house of worship for the Haitian Emmanuel Lutheran Congregation. VI. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE Trinity Lutheran Chapel is the oldest existing church building in the City. With the exception of the vestibule and the rear addition which were added in 1938, the footprint of the original structure is intact. The side elevations retain their original fenestration patterns except for the two windows which were added with the rear addition. Though the building has been stuccoed and the original windows have been replaced with stained glass, the simple interior presents the visitor with a visual reminder, in both size and proportion, of the City's early vernacular church architecture and reinforces the role religion played in the life of the pioneers of the City. The City had other early churches in the same vernacular style, however this is the only remaining example of the genre. Historically, it is important to note that it was in this building that the congregation voted to establish a church school in 1904, thus, though only on a part time basis, establishing the first parochial school in the City. The Trinity Chapel, for its architectural, historical and cultural associations with the early beginnings of the City, from pioneering days to the present, is worthy of the protection and consideration afforded it by designation to the Local Register of Historic Places. Criteria for Designation To qualify as an historic district the properties must fulfill one or more of the criteria set forth in LDR Section 4.5.1(B)(2) or (3). Trinity Lutheran Chapel more than meets the criteria for designation and fulfills the qualifications as follows: -8- Section 4.5.1(B)(2) A building will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (d) Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, economic, or social trends of the community in history. • The chapel exemplifies the social and cultural importance of religious institutions in the development of the community. The chapel was constructed only nine years after the first settlers arrived in the south Florida wilderness. (e) Is associated in a significant way with a past or continuing institution which has contributed substantially to the life of the City. • The chapel is significant for its association with the Trinity Lutheran Church of Delray Beach. Additionally, it was the congregations desire to establish a church school which began the parochial school movement in the City. Section 4.5.1(B)(3) A building is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria: (a) Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles. • The chapel's original simple unadorned vernacular style is typical of the construction methods in the early years of the community. (b) Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction. • The chapel, as originally constructed, incorporated all of the characteristics of the City's early vernacular style. As it stands today it represents, through it's decorative buttresses and stained glass windows, the ideals of Gothic revival ecclesiastical architecture which was popular in the 1930s. It is also an example of a simple building which was renovated to reflect the changing social mores while creating additional space for the growing congregation. -9- VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES Kuolt, Milton G. Seventy-Five Years of Memories. Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Delray Beach, Florida. Hackensack, NJ. Custom Books, Inc. Britt, Lora Sinks. My Gold Coast. South Florida in the Earlier Years. Palatka, Florida, Brittany House Publishers. Information for Home Seekers. Picturesque Delray. 1915 , Delray Beach, FL. Delray Beach News Journal, March 4, 1938 Delray Beach News Journal, July, 8, 1938 Report prepared March, 1997 by Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. file/u/cayce/ww/trinity - 10- . .J'2 r 1 �F' t �T, �� •s a itK' � coT . y '� • • • • '{ � 1F J ItZ i : r'C. r.+�» ,{wl- ".= ti .4 C ' _f p, ' s s«t"+yj`%s-• t, u • mow. i_. r y t : i The Church and Parsonage-About 1909 f7;0 1 'ti .`' fir+�,, - ..4,..: - ..;#1.!;-----‘---'- ' ram : , tiff {. . + F•j .4j . a � �T,� 4 M'L ~, a:ma`s.,, si'..- 5.. .. .. •• • • . : -..- Trinity Lutheran Church after the 1928 Hurricane r - x`•• 7-4.�+ ''r ice.--F.,4--$ `" c :: ai Ft4w•••• ,,t'-* '"-'a- y r �, ;C:ysi!- ... F� ,--, S y ; r"-, ', a.-^yn' - <ti. 2 �+ .r `a.Ri_%max may. .' •7-. sR�i�7i s.�' t fa."» 2-htiafiatC•Y^ �, 3'•` .BLS ? •s 1'tr•n f 2 L e.• dip. - �3 r+� t• r .s:x'n„`t3r,� ,,, tS..S;: SnE� r . t`,, .,rlt.$, '�.�"''-.4 ;,,,fj � .. . 1,F 1 , r .j E w r f�:' gift y iY ..v.:7`A+"i . y r "r •��f'nT =F1ll` iV'� - -.F f J , .i1t' ..t }.fi4y Za) i • '• 4 : 4 { ,. e.y5icy,f}n 1 11 .Si -' +"^.1 + i , �r� t.41►'`.tlr,,. S�h, n_t.,,,•.i r� . wi .„.5. r 7... ,WA+1..+ Itinity IAA hcran Church about 1932 ti-` - • • fit':'i,;;;:...*."'1::::."'-i''''' '`:::t1.;17:::1:::2'V::44;`);'!..1..'ii. --r.:C.":'•_:-'f--i';;'''.4-,.'4.1:-.::7-f:'::;.:4,"7.•:... .;. � -mac. 1 � r e. �4 � i t 4 i � r;'� ic. a'..fir •'Y`{{ �''f` , TTss� ,. f.1 t.. �'4 �' „� •i tfilt� c-' j • -- Fy ,:`lam.� f r:• .. " t .•a .F i ✓ -ns %� asa�Asx '. .NI a•r«j -' ¢`F�j YY��'s!._Yti-''...\•"�..�._ ... 4.L_ 1 ... .,.-. ._ ..,�..;?:i`u�.-r art.» .��... Exterior of the church during World War II -vr .� --r a N t , : ,lo ;r;' �'F s..+C�i.,F r. ,CYa rt S -h am . _ . r h Aa.,j- 1 h t7:5 : Z - �- Tr X : � Qt Jf !�; Si i a y i X. i. Interior of the church during World War II • • t! •••*-i C ir -t /Pi iy 1 ",n.. nF� ,I y $ : .' ..- , \ t)l ` l w S '` - • ; ! �, •r�;'L" . -1 .' r °. I,I ±fiI ,\` ,„. ,ni!. j M'; ...- itik :.,c:i.';:-?.:.;•.:41'.:-2-.... •`.:-i ..1.;. . "• . rr 9 ; .. r i' ti.ia'.i!I. I . t is t • • •'i - e--- - __ PRESENT LOCATION :e, • • �'rat, ' s Pi�"�,''') Ar tL I k .T: _ I.r'- it.'li .. . • • • ya.ca?>bl X .✓ .c.1'!��-,.r > '1 j(+ .5" y n c1 R,4�y' +r V"c+. 1.1 u. : 1 ,y 3.'' t-;'' ," a rC aG: ti....aA?'^ :: _ j.s fri -'. W.y?.tr'f r.z Y. . . H f^". 1k2�s > rx�"n ` 'Y•sE'�i . ` 'i +Kf'{ ..' yx.'ryw /rays A p�`tt.` .l :� ..a5:,.4- .4 i. • • - - ;C ._...1 1i':7�• •�F?-W fi Yam. NORTH ELEVATION r r r J t I • • ' -11' '• :r—f • - f - i. :7.-:;....7--..:7.;.",.:: • `i E;:,•. ° =H.arm ySyAv ,� u. h.7 •i*? - �3 ii:r• .T,'r''-tiesi � rt- ,,,74:'r of'L�.. 1 • t �" C ly-*ffa „srl3 'iyp_Y L f 4$'4'&.a� Y *cex' }•s, is .3 t cm d � 4, ,r'`� �� .r '.f to 'k3• i.'�..,�.i°a �• -,� s r ,a''`t-''!•el (J.:Fil 't?.ri.� -Y' .••'-_.,•. 7_.i-T. �. r .T "Y.jla.::n x' Ge l fJ 4� a 1� ., •�.r.f2',_ `v l ..., f' r.fi;T .r ,,-. ., .^. ¢'}, •Vf•. 7...'t (v.4.�,,r��l �r11 yy+-`�[j�(>�,n.1KJY1 75"!!'''' Q;br• �4'. SOUTH ELEVATION I t.t.,:i , .-:•-...;,:.•,:-:,,.;,..,-,-:- iv,•-:-••••:.• . ,., ,. ....../. .-4-,,..,,,.3. f.ic,•••k ill.is _...,,,,..-i_..,_.,...:., • .7.•-__-.___.......- Jl. ' t ' ,,I IV...* - . f i' - ,t -� I .fir• • —s • �1 .i ax r i " i-co.c, -Imo, +v l' a k_. .,�v,„dam • + F1 ` _ • i . r •• a r \ I . . ;,sue -s'7,1 �i !II I ' a Ste.• ••a ::• :s>, - 1 REAR ELEVATION L�THNCHURC/ -1 1 J)i 1 Meal.'.v1 t — t• 1 —— . •J S01 1 JAN.(9 40 h l r DELRAY i FLA- r h�1 1 N. 14 1 I v • FID11 1 `1 L1 o II4 W z .2 l -1 Q O �`, x •J 0 �O Q V ,i 1 In i`` Z f . r2. Irl J k l / P 1 ) f -D 1 M/7, I rJ (CA) -L COPY Ft!G4-rr S.ekPJF.iO(?/J MAPPING & GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SERVIC:i_- N THIS SANBORN MAP IS A CF RIII-IED C(i,'Y PRODUCED BY SANBORN FROM IIS AM:HIVI:S 1 li e r'+ I' " INFORMAf10N ON 1 HIS MAP)S I1c i ivEO FR()'A 1 t _ SANdO/INFIELD SURVEYS Clln%OUc:I1.D IN i __� j1z 'a _________ ...___.. .. I (Y,..,/I -- 1 _ . • 1,. _ :/0., 14,. 8.frep,..., -..-. 1 \.v Wy.' Alt/ a/).' o•,� (v- ,�. �,�^.�.-�._Lac _ xi'3f' ,i/✓f .�: � I f�--:.. ... .. l_ • .g n / TH�Sid2:.a' r 40 r � ,1* 6" • i P. ,1 .•6/ ».6 L VISTA DEL- MAR DRIVE2. ,r, Lix /3 ^ ,38: 31, �6 v 3S 34' 33'" 31- 3/. 30 e U E L lQ ' 26 sZ .:a Jo- ;� �� • if z_ + T •t/7•C 7s oS Y_r,3 ' ;7 .21 13 24 7 . 6i 7s ss A 6~ .•, 1 �► 29 /S /6 !B b!Q To 1/ . - • /4 ~ ° ' 44.1 45 47'` 7� ( r es (3 � .- - _ ,, - 7 �( ( 392 .QO� 4/ 4�' 4=c 1.j so 1 sr r w► Q i / ,53�1 's' 7 7s, N . 2B r .a.. ,as 4 .�: :I 4 34 • • i£ N R *R/ �• �9s e o I w ,/ a 6Si 65a.6SacJa- - ar��22 S Hii! L 7 7�� ,/5 ,� /7 i6 /9 20 Z/ ,`/6E �„r�- A I ' E • _ -------�3 26 MrchG e! ,Y, arydtes (` 11772 _,2p ]4 6 r �I.-7�.II S al t 7S J!!6 .'n _-- L4 — `•�--� L• 45/60 v •, 8164 11.50' Q1so /35 ., 8 — i .., -- —1 7 25 :nz6& 17 0 s c 19.) . , �'• • .3903 n i' B h j/e 4 ~ 30 Q t j(�� L4 A (p 14 Zl.s• J7 s7 11 sQ L33 io J!0 7' C� V — sr3 ,s�' o ,� THOMAS 5'T. ss — O' �--g•'gr zn —z .Sd yQ� M 57•t� 7 9d� 93 �� •-' ;v 9 'T 0 C E A lV54�' �� '� Q/ sYacht "�`� 4' � �� :7-' • 4 �C � w r 40 1 JST as t 1 ' X 1 Js 2- _f7 l� 24B B 300 Basta 1� •see2� f�� 3 E`'�' �39 SG'y /O c Y K- I —= 1/ o W a j �� P� �7i m a !�, s,�2J 36 223 ob 3oc t ir'� i`.!Jo _ Bf� /N VE *Qea ... '' Sz3a&,' //•?6 R? %' /ao. ,oc' •So2 tw io nQ �ro„L7 (��i7o /SR,fin � 3 S no 6 r,l 5 n 3 � � o D 4�. — • V LGT .Q' z° ° 7 po� I. av t 'n r.iolty p ¢� r ` I 222 .s '� ,00 ,00 ,Sv 5. •d+ S� 92.Sa sa 'O ,35 Q -- 4 �", — ) L - _Lc- Y— •:-- , -z / .4 y �t� .{d r -_ Z-- v ,']7a - _s+y vx c� r •„w�=!«. -!8`v ss�I��• ee ,SO,<f‘ M L •. Qri rir . , „ „�„�; `.45 Li - Z N ~ pN,• I.�f aG •. LI f,„.._..,_. �J zi . �BK 8 a ,sow. Y J' • �� /3 LL Q 4 N. Z • 41.CI . � 47 � ;,.: -12kJ W . 23y p9 ); .* �� T '` fir % ,70 '222 --- --�-- .l 14 0 ° ,.- ,rt721 .c- -Ts3-70- x —r wory�� w , •jh v • `'il of Delray Beach Q 9`V' • �`� - ^ a a 5 Q f5s',sc• q . �f7 N54v.So� 8 /)` 2 9 0 C iCZ J .. •Il 14 '/43!! BUY 'n ,. 1^, hh ` V 1 v il{I rm. << h O • ,I5 4�3 2 /. _ u . I. i //�. 2,0 ]7 316.•!! 1 n1• �� ie' ,rei tfa .+,I••.Vl P. 40 1/4 /V��q GA. g; .v Lo ,0 ,: / .'saNa so ! Jo -fit.' � iOCE : t ,44 s 9! I MINIM Mg P • SC.4Lf /N _F Er //1/ ) .C" ---71 7n___.' art[ •DO - l00 < ed /y / //-i� S=c - -�y ' W n�c� i- r-, .? /06 exi-d,•-,i, c,,,t,e(,v,i/A_ ,, y /9_5 (P,e,t-z ) 4- j/�l ,�tZp/ue> // // /C •• �?�4'/) r #/g/ /22‘ -n..ft/;'-c-1-1- --/ /s�� ( � ) f V /11,9? // (le� • / ) % J � � ILC« lezi,"-- 2A-a--0 jv Ac- rn-�4- - 5 d y_e�-- , `ii V S 1 . ( -) a . /6_7 I, 0 2/44 3 • ja 5 - 1/ A6-1- / 37(3 -`'v /3/ it (/-- ,,e.,e) 5- / 3 / // 3,,,k,„ (/a/ (73e- tde (p d 1, ('Z - ) any il d i7. On j S' 1/0/ �Ze . . ( 7) . MO -7- 71, ee--, N-fi-, ( a •ZG(Jtj '° (6-r_e,_44, j il 5 . aezti j/S� / - ./.--&7,A? __U/ . /3 j/5 i. 7 5/1--. (664)