HPB-07-03-1996 DELRAY BEACH
All-AmedcaCityr
' I i!
1993 AGENDA
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
Meeting Date: July 3, 1996
Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting
Location: 1st Floor Conference Room
Time: 6:00 P.M.
If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect
to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these
proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is
to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105.
I. CALL TO ORDER
IL APPROVAL OF MINUTES
• June 19, 1996
III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS
A. COA 8-217-Continuation: Doc's All American, 10 N. Swinton
Avenue, Old School Square Historic District. Mark Little, Agent.
Approval of a Text/Copy Change to the Existing South Facing
Nostalgic Roof Sign.
B. Pre-Application Review for New Construction of a Two Story Office
Building on a Vacant Lot Located on the West Side of N. Swinton
Avenue Between W. Atlantic Avenue and N.W. 1st Street; Lot 9
Block 60. Randall Stofft, Owner.
MEETING DATES J.OHN V, BETTY SU$AN VER.A JOHN J. ! DEI DRA PAT
09/04/96 P P P A A A P
09/18/96 C AN C E L E D
09/24/96 P Al P P P P P
10/02/96 P Al P P P P A
10/16/96 P Al P P A P A
11/06/96 A P P P P A2 P
_ 11/20/96 P P A P A P P
12/04/96 C AN C E L E D
12/18/96 P P P P P A2 P
01/08/97 _
01/22/97
02/05/97
02/19/97
03/05/97
03/19/97
04/02/97
04/16/97
05/07/97
05/21/97
06/04/97
06/18/97 _
07/02/97 _
07/16/97
08/06/97
08/20/97
1 Betty Diggans was out with a broken ankle.
2 Debora Turner was on Maternity Leave.
inigniglimipmEnifiR
"mum MEETINGNWDATEVi giOMI .V1 JU I U+ 1 .:::::,:::V RA. .. JO N : D : A'1`::;
09/06/95 P P P P P P A
09/20/95 A P P P P P P
10/04/95 P A P P P P P
10/18/95 P P A P P P A
11/01/95 P P P A P P P
11/15/95 P P P P P P P
12/06/95 P P P P P P P
12/20/95 P P P P P P P
01/03/96 C AN C E L E D
01/17/96 C AN C E L E D
02/07/96 P A P P P P P
iiiiT . . :::: . .<:>: . ::»:<::::>::> : .:.: :. ::.;.:::.;:.>iii ::.:::::>::>::>::>: .:P:>;;:::>:.>:.::::>::>.,: . .. ::;::::::>::> .:.: .. . ::;: ;.:::>-»: : .: . .:R <::>,:,:>P T:::>:
..... .........................................................................................................................................:::::::.::.. . .::.:
02/21/96 P P --- P P P P
03/06/96 P P --- A P P P
03/20/96 P P --- P P A A
04/01/96 P A P P P A A
04/17/96 C . AN C E L E D '
05/01/96 P P P A P P A ,
05/03/96 P A P A P P A
05/15/96 P P P P P P P
06/05/96 P A P A P P P
06/19/96 P P P P A P P
07/03/96 P P A P P A P
07/17/96 P P A P P P . P
08/07/96 C AN C E L E - - - - D
08/14/96** P A P P P -P P
08/21/96 A P P P P P. P
* V/P = Vacant Position
**Meeting postponed from August 7th due to lack of quorum.
HPB Meeting
July 3, 1996
Page 2
IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS
A. Reports from Historic District Representatives
B. Board Members
C. Staff
V. ADJOURN
Pat Cayce
Historic Preservation Planner
POSTED ON: June 27, 1996
file/hpb7-3
MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
PUBLIC HEARING
MEETING DATE: JULY 3, 1996
LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM
I. ROLL CALL:
The meeting was called to order by the Vice-Chairperson at 6:10 P.M. Upon roll
call it was determined that a quorum was present.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Vaughan (arrived at 6:15), Vice-
Chairperson Morgan, John Johnson, Vera
Farrington, Pat Healy-Golembe
MEMBERS ABSENT: Debora Turner, Susan Hurlburt
STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Diana Mund
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
The Minutes for the Regular Meeting of June 19, 1996 were before the Board for
consideration. Ms. Golembe moved to approve the Minutes as presented. The
motion was seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed by a vote of 4-0.
III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS:
At this point on the agenda Chairman Vaughan arrived at the meeting.
A. COA 8-217 Continuation: Doc's All American; 10 N. Swinton Avenue;
Old School Square Historic District; Mark Little, Authorized Agent.
Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of
approving a COA to allow a text/copy change to the existing south facing
nostalgic roof sign at Doc's All American sandwich and ice-cream store.
The south facing sign has three panels, with Coca Cola logos on either
end and Doc's in the center. The applicant's proposal for the sign is to
remove the Coca Cola logo from both the right and left hand panels, and
have the left panel display the Pepsi logo and the right panel with a "Grill
& Dairy" text.
It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Farrington and passed 5-
0 to approve COA 8-217 as presented based upon positive findings with
respect to LDR Section 4.6.7(E).
B. Pre-Application: New Construction of a Two-Story Office Building; Lot 9,
Block 60; Randall Stoff, Owner.
Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of a pre-
application review for new construction of a two-story office building on a
vacant lot located on the west side of N. Swinton Avenue between W.
Atlantic Avenue and N.W. 1st Street.
The Board recommended that the applicant consider a way to reduce the
massing of the roof, by possibly adding a small cupola or other decorative
element to break the roof line. The Board also recommended that a
walkway from the sidewalk to the front entrance be installed to
compliment the residential character of N. Swinton Avenue. The applicant
has not decided on exterior colors and the Board suggested that he
submit several alternative combinations when the project comes for final
review.
Mrs. Cayce amended the agenda to add Item III.C.
C. The Anchorage Condominium: 60 Marine Way; Marina Historic District;
Alieda Riley, Owner and Board Member.
Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of giving
their opinion of replacing the rotting plywood behind the second floor
balcony railings of The Anchorage Condominium with yellow canvas that
would match the existing on the east balcony.
The Board was of the opinion that the matching canvas would be more
esthetically please than the existing plywood.
IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS:
A. Reports from Historic District Representatives
None
B. Board Members
Mr. Johnson handed out a list of items he felt the Board should workshop.
The Board set August 14, 1996 as a workshop date.
-2- 07/03/96
Chairman Vaughan reminded the Board that they were required to
disclose when they have been approached out side of a meeting by a
member of the public or an applicant.
Mr. Vaughan disclosed that he had received a phone call from Frank
McKinney informing him that Mr. Malone had placed an ad in the Delray
Times for July 4, 1996 that insinuated that the proposed South Ocean
Boulevard Historic District was to preserve racial segregation.
The Board requested that the Building Department provide them with a
staff liaison for their meetings.
C. Staff
Mrs. Cayce informed the Board that the porch repairs for 6 S.E. 1st Street
had been staff approved. However, any future elevation changes would
come before the Board.
Mrs. Cayce informed the Board that 227 Bankers Row had been given a
stop work order and would come before the Board for approval at their
July 17, 1996 meeting.
Mrs. Cayce informed the Board that they were invited to attend the first
meeting of the newly created Preservation Society of Delray Beach on
July 15, 1996 at the Judge Knott Center.
V. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business before the Board, Ms. Golembe moved to
adjourn the meeting at 7:30 P.M., seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed 5-0.
The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information
provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for July 3, 1996, which were
formally adopted and approved by the Board on July 17, 1996.
- , ), --,1ft1/7(7)///
Diana Mund
If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this
means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and
approval, which may involve some changes.
-3- 07/03/96
...SS-iiiii:S'S'LS:::4:^:8ii::'.v^•ii:SOif is??.:Y::'1��'•:i ii:iiii::::::.nw::.:::::::::::::::.�.tiii}ii:?.H :'. .. .: .:: .... ....:. .':, . ..::},,v-:Wt?;::��:•i.-i:.�•}.v::�::.:::::::•:::..Optplopapp
�
. f s
.........:.....:....:.::.:::...::v:::::::::::::.::::iiiv}}:^i}?:4;::::::::.::.:�::::.:::::::•i}:•iTiiJ?-}}::::::.. ..... -f...f......M::..r.:.........v:....:..�:::................................... ...
........... ...........:.....:.......• .v:::;wv::•i:::::n::�:::::n...••vn.rlrrl.:m:::::v:x:..rxfir:f:::::::n�:::::. ........
Project Name: COA 8-217 Continuation
-Project Location: 10 N. Swinton Avenue, Doc's All American
The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA 8-217-Continuation
to allow a text/copy change to the existing south facing nostalgic roof sign at
Doc's All American sandwich and ice cream store.
For background and project description please read the attached staff report
from the Building Department's Sign Review Committee.
This item will be reviewed by the West Atlantic Architectural Review Board and
the CRA, their comments will be available at the meeting.
1111111111111111111111141MOMAMMINE1111111111111111111111
.:::.::?.:.>:::.::.;:.::
1. Deny with reasons stated.
2. Approve as presented.
3. Approve with modification which are consistent with the Sign Review
Committee's concerns.
1. Based on positive findings to LDR Section 4.6.7(E), approve the sign - _
associated with COA 8-217-Continuation with the following modification:
• That the right hand sign panel have the Pepsi logo and that the "Grill &
Dairy" text be eliminated.
file/coa217sr
•
Meeting Date: July 3 ,1996
Agenda Item: III-A
z)y
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
Cy
i5
AGENT: Bright Image, Inc.
PROJECT NAME: DOC'S SOFT SERVE
PROJECT LOCATION: 10 N. Swinton Ave. .
I. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD:
Consider approving a request to change copy on a flat wall sign
• pursuant to Section 4.6.7(E) (7) of the Land Development Regulations
for Doc's Soft Serve, 10 N. Swinton Avenue located at the northwest
corner of Swinton and Atlantic Avenues.
II. BACKGROUND:
The rooftop sign on Doc's Soft Serve was designated a nostalgic
sign by the City Commission on March 28, 1989. The Commission felt
the sign had considerable historic or nostalgic appeal and was of
a unique design constituting expressions of art rather than simple
advertising. The sign was unique due to the snow cone on the
rooftop sign.
The Historic Board approved a text change November 3, 1993 from
"Doc's Soft Serve" to Doc's All American" on the east elevation.
The sign was restored to it's original colors. The portion of the
text which was not neon, and the ice cream on the cone, were
painted white. During daylight hours the sign presents a dark blue
background, with white text. At night multicolored neon surrounds
the text and borders the sign.
The applicant is requesting a copy change for the south elevation
rooftop sign facing Atlantic Ave. There currently is three panels;
"Doc's" in the center with "Coca Cola" on either side. "Doc's" has
blue copy on a white background and "Coca Cola" is white copy on a
red background.
The applicant is asking to retain the "Doc's" center panel and
change out the left panel with "Pepsi" and the right panel to •:.
"Grill & Dairy" . The "Pepsi"panel will be blue and red on a white
background and the "Grill & "Dairy" panel to be blue copy on a
white background.
III. RECOMMENDATION:
The Board has the following options:
1. By motion, approve the applicants request for a copy :
change on the nostalgic rooftop sign based upon positive findings
with respect to LDR Section 4.6.7(E) (7) .
2. Deny the request as submitted.
3. Staff has concerns with the proposed changes and believe
that as presented, these changes would weaken the integrity of the
"nostalgic sign" designation. We remind the board that this
designation was given to signs that have a historic or nostalgic
appeal and constitute "artistic 'expression" , and "not solely
advertising. " We would recommend denial of the sign changes as
proposed.
c: Visions West Atlantic
CRP,
,
r
,4 . • I
i
Y
,' It right)
•SIGN
375 N.E.3rd Street
iil�lll Ii ! ( 1 ! I illiiiil.I 1 II 1 ri1 I i ,fl Ills l I .
il;' III I� II Ili it II 11 II l I11 III DELRAY BEACH,
I,. 1111 ,I.l l I, II I ' I Il p III {tli II I
... 33483
II :II
Phone
(407)278-7814
l II ,'quo'Si �: , ,S GRII,L b Fax
k I IIl 9 Ir: Ill & D A l RY . (407)278-0259
!�' 16J illI1:IIJulill Ull 1. lir
( a§k rs 1.. � n+Ww 5n nea �� s ro� rlIIan � a
E-Mail Mall Address
'n t. II 'I A i,,,, ,i]i1 I lll n 1 .. '� „7,, fl ; ll}tleJ ernI net': . I I � u un . it1 IFnnmWn y i '; +i4 w ,:., nanoe•.4iiWi;wwiiii�iiiiiiiil..e ..: I ...! ,i
..:::::::............................
SCALE/ NTS
'b .X d av,44 ii���Y�,,�.,1i.1.M.Iaa ii :,, w ,w > �fl,I f,
: .�+. ... ,a"�t �I:r..�:.�i5?s?F.iSli rrx:e,-.; U..' ', yt�l I:iil �. w,ll:1':J "r '' r ,.!. ' kNw
1 ,i iuHi uiat nrt p A{ .i. uta & �iyyq.1'd yz ifle... ,s aY x r 1 s cAsPw"''iw.:..L. i
tib
.
.
�
'
"' ,
ry4„�up• � t 5+q aH gr�{ ,�, � *. � dII l � I' ,� . I w 1 lC r.c %t�t4 i41r ft .1I t f r ,:R t d�1aH DpiiifjI ' , y }dG
•
cu.3TOM E�
I7 i IIIi ise t 4 1 It �,'' u iri Pti ,
i. it iif r tII I I l: i iY1 4 1,1'1it I q a '!, }H ti t sd a b p
H!:< 1 atiE I tiw � i :j id i* I )+' f i xY Y 7h 1 i lil4a If k: I if 1w k 4 t t ; t y1 jy � � dv 10 s IIp! s aw Ytat IJ���141., q l �^ •1!::LE .t kIt' iI �s4 ot4�3 � � II i"i,It I1 i�* ; c ;s .: I I f. i '
. , t ,, ii, .,Lju w �i4 �.H l .. i �3 +j 1 , A� ✓i Jn � �
.ii
lii.
di sz d l i i ; a l ig f if ` + s ip ,t 3d1 i :' + t -k ;vf�" f E, 4., f}} la zk,ti:fr ti . r , t i: a � s ' v)4x i1 i i ix ji T 2 ,r.^ .. o-sS i3 lt , , � 1 f a at j, Y p Ed qi F /4 i H I w i i4 t ' 1 T,1f igH a I i0 0 i. s �*w A Th , i �:ir,, I I I L � ' 16l ,i I:i I I � I I If i I I ifl :i ,i l I w R , i �I VIEW DATE
•
•
lif
`� �:: �� I I Illl >' i I UNii _ I II (I I .�. .Iii !.ii:kd i' 'd if, • SiGNRE
. _ :�... : .
PLAN REVIEW 5-1-96.
s= ELECTRIC DRAWN BY:
STAFF REVIEW DAVID
ll }� SPRAB
` 60t-- S: C-.r-�,.A e1 as Iv0s��V 1L, ENGINEERING
nn
ALLOWED ' NOTES: Sign for Approval DRAWING
-XtS' w Date
PROPOSED 63 -�r S ~ c�```�`,t
4C.c .. lef-4- ri qL'� ovx,Ly
MATERIAL �le��o V ,;,:\SIGNS\DRAWINGS\DOG-PEPS.CDR
This Drawing is the Property of Bright Image SIgns
,
•
•
•;-...!.Z.;,:.:,': ..,:....•:',:.:Z•Z,:•••.:.:•,::::::.: :..:..-.Z,:•.1..:-.',..'-:-.:..:•:••• .... .
• .
..' .-'''.. 7..• '•-•'!...:;•...,;,,?:•.•:.:.1•?:.i*3.,.;::Z:-.;::.;.:5 :Z•,•;:.: 2:-:.• ''.. - ......, :::::,;:.:.....?:.::;•;...... ..3: .: "M :27..ni :.:.::.j.::...?::::.::f.....i...:,...s.. . .
. i
. . .
::.:''..:•.:•::-.....':::::.:'...:.::...; :,::. P:-;*:::..-.:: ':*.'." ; --------.•••••'•••••'''•••••••••-•'••..-•-••••••' •-•• -"'•'•••••-•••'...."*.••"•-• . .. _
•
• : ...• ...',.... ....".. :. :. ' ' .
. .. ..,... ..
•.. .•,. ' •. "•`".,,,...s....••••••,...,.,.s.. ....,.. . ..44!: .41114 ti::‘ 'kr 1 1' • • .• .:•::*3:-..:,Eb•-':::<,..:•• :.4*.i::3:!:::Ii$.'?..:i:3% ,• :••••.:-::: .::',:q:,:::•.•-::-:•:::: •:';•••..-„•:•,*'..;'- ....`,•,...,\I,,•!;-:;--,;.2...,•!...:,?...;•;:, . .0,V.I i i ,14.t iii,\,•t 1• . :. . . .:.••'::...:::!•;.::,;;.: .
.%•::,.:•;.:..-:, ',:',:.::::::-.. .:,•:i: :: :::. n:• •:::3ii:•?...;•.:-•.• '‘...,!!...:•*7-.TI st11,•,;!..:--;;;',I,‘,,•fi•;.z,•:',"„'.4:4:1'.. ..7•1'.$."14(i' ,4,,. il - Il'i.- II
r[f:',i.. ;,:-•:: :-..-:::0: :.t.?...... -,:::-,.:-....F..:i::::.,-.?:..:, -.......:::: .. :.:-...:!1..„.1.:. .!-. .7.:•i.;•...",41'•,:,:eliY...,Y;74,!1.-1/.:tii.11' ..; .-1.):-1.-'11-.',..1;:. :;; .•'.A•. • . .
.. •.-.- • ••• •
. .. .
. •
. .-..... .......•..., .. . ...., ... . • :..' .i i,';',1•krt•ii?.."'-': ...s.-:th..w.,,,,,',4t,-t,.&„ tv,k„_ ,,,r,.,•:-.41--.i.,•-.4.-.:%; -•,,,:r,!.:!,..-::... •
• •
.:....-......,.,.....::.?.:./...c.: .,.:..g,,...• . s.;i:.-.,••••••.:, -: •••• • t••••,..,-1-,,,..,..,,„:,,....-:-...w.l.....„.1,•-•.:*•••••c•-,m•y•,-,r.,...1-i..--,,...,..z.,..,•-4:-., ,..4:,..,,4f.v... ..
• - •••ii:- -, ---;:•.••••.:-.i:::•::•;...• -:::S,: i.: ... i::::•.:: •:.:•- :.•-• '4._ .F;•;i,..,s'-''•t7:. , t:•• ::.--,-,5:-••-•-•=g-:----',.1,.. . 4t,. • '- - . . ... .-:. ..-
-••••-:-:::::-.::-_,-..,,:::,...::,„:::::::::.,:::.::::.........::... .-.:. . • • :•-/-.- , : iitt6.-.-4- • . --...•--, .-
":-:•:.-.::-.:•.,.::.-•-•::-..:-:.:-•:-.•..:::;::-.,s,:.,::::,;:: ::::.........:--,:-..•........:.-. .,... .4••••
..--:..-•:.,.. ..••-....::,-...:::.f. ....;;3::.i.... .f.,::::;JE,..',.:.:::•... ..-.:,...-- - f
r'S A': I . ... . . • ........... .
•...,., ::.::.;,-.:,,,-,1;.f.:::;::: ::;:,,x,,...v..;:.:,;?..4....:;ii-i..::::.,,,:;-zi,.:,
&era— 00— _, ...:.:,::::;,:•:.:.i..:::::::.: •..„1;:,::3,,,i;;;,:•,::.:::..• ........ . : ..::
.1 I.11111111111111111111:.1111111111 111111„11111111111111111i1 ,. . raor-Ingi -
1..:•••..."'"" *--*-- ...,sr, r'''''
. • I .;•...,•.•iy7.;•.,;.•-.,,.;;:!.-,;.!:.--',`,::1114',18.i4i;ii.i.::.;'.;:::..:•.::.*' .....P1':',:::Z;•';-;i:':;•:.:-3Z;..‘1:fOlis,Fp3.1„.„.... ., . ..., .:.j:zi.-•;•••;-:-;'$);;I:3:::',..:.:'::.:i•4's 1111hi $$1 i•13 33%)>1;:;:•:,%•--'•••••••11
';:•:•:•4::?..:....,-.•..f...:. l:;.;•;3.115...3.;;7.1 1,;.34.,.,-1;;.:.'.;;,•-•!..,.3 3:'•3.;
:..'''.:-' ' • •• • :::::7;3'..,..;3;:•.;:r:3•:',.:..•
''...::::':':".''..' ,3.,:::?‘-',.::'31..??,.:‘,: '.:!.:3••••,.'"•7'•:3•::•••:3..: ,',....:_
IMMILIIIIPI! - ---.. • ---•.•'• •
::-:••••:••••.:'• •
:=7........., 3--•-•-r--- '
.................00000.••••• , s\ _
.. .:.:•.......:.....
.... !. ..,. ..',..::.,
.:. • .i::::,..-:*::::.:..:;*':i'••?•3:.:-.::::i....:*i:,;.::,..i..i:.i,i:i:ifi:::.:.:-..:: . •,•rr..N.'77n rf.:i.4 ' ; .. ..... 7.7.;•x-7,,.. .:.•:•:-....:•,...-:,...*.,....-.::::: ,•,-:.,-....;,•3:::: :---3:;. -.• - .
.- •i.:3f3:;:.:•:::-:-:! :4:.:3:3!:ifi*i-:::.,:3:if3:?:..::....: :3 :;::::::.:.:,:...:.... ts•k;!.--:• ...7-:.:•,:iii,,-...•••••,...: ..• ._-----
...-....•.
..•:::.:-3:;•::...... ...:-.•?.:,'.;%.::: ::::,•: ;.: :.%.!;::-..•' ;':-.:-...?:: •-•7•1::•,'• 1 ::-.'- '•:'•If .. _.;
..........._ -•- • -,-: . ,:-..--.-.:-.;:::: :-.,.-: :-...:y- .'•:;: fs..:':..:::':::•.:".::.:-........f.,:-.
--•,...••••••''..,':•;..;:••••••'::-'••••••••:-:i:*: :::.:: :::::::::::•-,..:;7-::•••'-'-'•••-- •,:. .1. "--t .. '-•' I . --7' -• .... . ..... ..
...,.....,... .--;;:::-.;----:::....;,IR:::.:,:,':.-.3;'2,•:.-..;:!.'':::::',..-;::,:,,:I..;'' . ' I
'''''-;i::: :',E.-:. 4.!$.:i1;:•:::.:: ;:. ;:.i:,,:•1..?..:::.•.,::: :•::.- I , :: __ _
, -• •I - ; • , -.-'•.:'"-' :-, --.'.s...',.'' .. - ....•,1:.:::::: :: :.-::::
•• :.• --. !.- .• - --.:::.:,•.:.::...':.::.::,.:;z:,:::;:-:,
— --.).‘---,--7r .....-, ,• . . •••. ,:. .-..„:„;-••:.,,,,,,...,,......:;::,:.:: . . . .
•:-:-...:-.-?:... .*.--A,•,.i8:.ris3N :-:••v*:•.,:i*f:ii:•.-:•.:2::::::izi•--. _,_..._„,....,,_______. _ , , __.k.1 1 -::::. .:; --:,-f-.,--:--:.;-::.:_-,.;:i:-::? : ?•:•,: i:.?:,:.:... .-
- -
•-:-.••-:<..., s 3 f ',€'*- ' --1 r 1 ---- ----- - .-.•:•: •.::::•,---!:::•-:••••• -•••.•f:-:•:,• ••;,•$.::,,:.:
: .,',74•:!?:::S•:,):!:-'i.': ;' ;',.1...:!:.. :;',•.': •.:' • 4'•;;'I'. i.;•:••:=•'.....". .!.1 ! I r r -..'•''
•-••:,:••‘•;:::•••'..f••::.;;;..f:..•: .• ".. '•'.-.....n,:•5,:•i...:: ;•'
..'".:•.:.::.;S.2.........1.....•.- .::-.-.:...-;3f.'F% :;, ?.•i:-;*;:., .
•:•:•-...,•;;;::,:•,;;;•$•:.,;:',4•2;,?,,;.:-•; :-..:•...?$•-.':•.:,-z:.:-:.--.....:'-.!•f....„. • ....'.. -`•,'.- .. .'-:• •-(":.. •,.......i I. -. ..--— : - :;.f-2,: ::,•,:::7--•-•..,..5.,.•.'-•-:.-•::%:; :?.':iV$.?;?88* :;1.: - '- 1
.:Z-Ici;:•-:•f•r„:;?,::::,-..;•:z•TI!:,;;$••.•i",,:::;7:,:zzfr•-: :::::, ...:•;:::;:-::,-...••;•,:..,,...E ....,'.....L..._...,:„... : ,..,;;;il.,-.7:;';'• - -:-.-.1.......--•.'....":..-.- , :!;.••••;;,...:::::•:•-•:,:•• •-:. •••:•••:'-:::::: :::•b3$.33'.33.:;3::33*:=.: ••_1-
:','"':.•''•:: : :-0 .'..3.3.?:')..:•ii.'..3f,43:;37:33.33 ?. 3.•:..H:-:::-..:,;••73::3-:.•:•-•:••••.•
. - • .: . -:-....-.:-.::-. :..7.... :•::.::: . • .c.
....-:•-•:-,•...--;,:; ;;;;;.:,,;•::,:•,-ti;:33:3:::-•••••• - ,::1•,,
-..:•.'•:•,,?:,,, ,•:•:,•:.-;;i•;:,:::•••••••:;::%f,..*.,•,:::_::.::;•,,,,:.'f:i: :•.;:ff::.i..:-...*,:•,..........:i
:;:::•1•.::),.::::::: :!Si: P.Si:•:::11),0.£i•iir0;;,?8;:•.3.:Z:1:•!•:;,'-,",•'•,'W,c,'•''',',' 5..eVr'V ;"•.••::F.: •-•.'•;•:••. • ':'.. i.',!.: '.:•,!-8.•' '.-,.?*:'.f.:.- •
::'::.1:::-.::::::::::•:::,:•-•:.:-.:•,.:-::••:;,:t:•::••:,:-$:•••:-:•:;.ve.:-:::,,,•:...,•,:,:-....:::....::::::::,:......•.
.,.:::::',,,i., :, : • :-:•..T.•:,•::•.,::::'8',::: ',::::-::::-,:•': •E'.1-i
.-- • •
.• . • ..... . . .,. ..
. . , .
•
' ' •• . •
•
•
• •
. .. ,..
• •tv.- • :. . • ••::.
• . .-: ,.. ,.. .. .. ,. ••••.•
•
..... .
• -• .
. .:• ...;.
•••
...•:.•:::::: :'::.::•.::.,..:.:'•.. •i::. .
•
•
• . . • •-...
. . .. ... ..
•.:
.. ••
: ......:.-.2: .•'..Z'.'?..:::•:- .'.• •••••-fr...'±'''.:,..-..
. --.77"''..;. 1.:.) •.ii'.1 I I 1, .; - ‘:. -..•'......• .'••••i.. •,''''''.....' "7.....-:...-,.- ..sl.:':,‘
.' ., '.. 1 .; 1 11 3‘ 1. . • '''-'!• ;-':-;:'•.1.-•4."..-!.'.:.: T...••;••':1-•-•••• •1:-P'r••'•'•:'!-T-'-'::•:',:••;•--;.f."::.'•:'!....r.-.'':
. .• •.I.,t 1 i I/t 1 ! •.. •,. $-;I•';:•!•1;:ir;',:8; tc4r2;!;?.;> > l!',,ii..P "4"'.•:•';--_-_---;1*'.:;;;•:;.•::i,
- ;i.... . j.:•:1,1 i':),'.•I. ; •.„..: '.*:T:!.•'.:-..,•-"•-'•••••:••-••••`. -.:,•:: •-*'-'•••.•:•:••:'•:.-.
•-.7.i.'-•::: :•;;•-:::•::::-..:• -i.:;.:::::',••:-....-•.-:..:.:;•-. • -. --
... - .:-",:il.ki.41i:,•-, . ' '-'':1;:. s :: • .' .. . '--' . • ..-: . .::' -• ,i.•.- - • .. 71-• %II"%t..-'--.• . -:f
. . .
• ' • • ::'-- ''';'''.: '-', '-I. •' . —;i..1:•1)i . . ,
•- .
•
• .-.• --.,7::''...:-;•:-,'---r.'-f,',:. ''''')/. ',1 , s‘its't‘4. : - .
;•.i-",:.::::_,-, VI,.p t. )V,.. -..' . ••
.•
.•
. .
• — - -
. . •
!...,..,-,••. •,` ,.•,v• • , . LAEri A SIERICAN 5:': • •
. .
..- -... ; .I ... ..
...„ _. ...• •• •.•,...-- AL . .
. ... ...
liel-0 CIS .
•:- .:::::_:: ••••:.::?:-*-:.:.-...: :: :-.••••: ::•.;.:,i..:.::..,.... :,,,.i:F:: ,-,.-.:: , , 1,11 . ._ ---_-_--:;,-:-•- . .•:
.• _. :..-- ....-..--.,i.-i:, :.::•,...:::-:.,-e.,•• .• ••-.7i, •
••::::,.::::--:-..-...!••::-...iii::;•:*•:::-,::::: :.;*:::,::::;:.:•;::.•:,„.:::......
p.NQOPtik3A'-'--
....,.:::.,,,...,,,.......,:::•:.,,,,, ,,:•-,i,i *:,*.,:;...:.:..i.,,,,,:i.,...,::.:,.;-.:. , _ _____...-. 7.1,,,v.1...s.....7.;.,,,,.........._....._._.
:,..,,,,,,,.....,.,....:,.:•-.,.:•,,,,,,,,, ...)1i,,,. ,:;:;..-..,:..:;,:..,:::84ifi
iiii.?; 3.3.'s?,<C ',:VA05•,l/pViii1;0'w*:0;,3,4,m1,,, ,:.;:.,:... , _ . •-- ., ,„,..:zsi,,,,...„..-....
.... ; 0.0.001.........mmoll••• iv•e----- — -— -------- ...••,..•• .•• . . ............-..,.., _..
..•----..-
.-.-.•-• - . ..•• ..•.• -.. .. ,
..-.: :::••• ---''..r.:i:.:- ..ii:: - .. . ...,I. ... .
--iA.. •:,.:••.:..... .,..-;-:::::n,,.:.:.,-,ii.,•:: :,.. . ..::::::,-,.,::.,:-,-:
\ .
:,•.:
*.i•;,.;
. .,‘
• ,
:::,:«:-..1-,...,,, ,.......:-....,..•.,:;;;;4-„.,...„,:::::::,&:.....„..•- .•••1
,....:.....--••:,.........::.::. .....),,,.4.,:•_.•,!•,:,......,...-...:•.„,....... •
:.,
, !,-::?:::-,;:,..: . -..---..„..f......i,-.3:::.:! .*?. ...-;
- % •
. ....1;:....*:i:.::•..1..-.::: ::. ':....3'..."::::.--.;.i..:--;:•':.... -•*;:.. .-.''."..:::... tri •
'.:- •''.'..:-;"....-:•'::.::::...7 :::::;.'::::''.:•••'..."':-.::.' • • •''. •.. .,
:.ii:•.:.!...:...,,',':•i:i:.?:.f.3:-:*;:i:i:if?:.,:*i:::,.:H..7:i.:!:.:::::-.:::•--- • -i f!..
11 . ..^•:,:.0:.::::,,:i..i:-.:::•,.•'. ':-.;:.:":::,.--.:f,:::.:.:4**...:..: . .
::.;.::::::.:',:::::.::::::.....,::...:. ,•'......i: ...,*i:;.•::f.::''.•.. :..1
Aar • 41 - .......;,i::':--;:;•.•:;....‹'.-. .:,',::"....:,:!;*'..::::?...1::::.. ii
:,:.-'.A.'f:-:;:;: :;':.. .:''... :':7:;.:.7........:::•.:::.......:.:.
'''.... •: .:::.-:':i%:::;;•:; .,...;,::-.:-:.,.:•, ..'. .::..'•,';,...:-...
..,
. . •
.. .
. . .
. . .
•
•
. ;. .
••
.• -.
.• .. . .
.. . ••• ' ••*----*--
• .
• .
•
23 Cob . 5 ?4
s = 20 Y?o '` Zo
_ 49 57 9 6
' 2t 2/ '8 W�R /Atc6' /384 y 5o•• / .6• ,..,,., 7 6 /9 7 22'
EN All _21 2 7 7 3 !B • B ei •cry
7d1 20MU
' 9 • Q • D o, l� ?/ t�
9 �1 to —_ 9_..e p - 9 6 23 • j . •0 /7 • N.' .9 20 =
o 'r a 2.1 9• • /9_ /0 • • 10 ... /9 • • 10 (l9)C,,°o . 5 `�'
i : 25 /B m// • • //_ /B - - /�..t. �/�a' 4 25 •• — - . /1 /B . ��• • '
z :` f /7 /2 /2 .k ---I
_/7 • . ' /2 a /7J A ' ' : 3 26 ' •• Io s;11 /5 • / ' ems,:
tb $ �Y 16 %3 ±Y - 3 /7 ...
,as•- A 7 n k / .5' /356'� 'Oj /1J 6' ,sd'6• �! //4 15 n ! :o 9 !2 /3 '_' v --� ,4f
�. So > .,50' 1+66• , /36•of /3,• ,'• n .5••4/3z6.3 a• /32.6\o Sb. /35./• mil. a 43
,�: 3 D. s ST. '6•• �R K am• .
43 • 4,0' /54.C• •41• 6za 50 /3S6• /35.6• it 40'• is /3'j II'• .° ,3/. Ib�_ N. E rl; /b• 4Ili ° 3RD "
�;2 /� r8 24 / h 24 / h / g �045 /3;6b is, / �• , ,• N So / ."
/ 24 .o ;$�4:•
2~ �t5o �' az.s 23 2 23 2 'R •P- /o = iii p 23 y o o e
•3 li as 1' 3 �3 • 22 3 ' 22 3 • ' 3 tA' // • . 3 22 - 2 Z3 �, s w
4 � ;• 4 • • 2/ r 4 • • 2/tee 4 • 4 /2 . a 2/ 3 22 • 1 �.
I - • {- f
5 Q I'45 : • 20 5 = 204 5 • � /3 . = 5 20 , 4 2/ •
s •
4 m N 42':Ts : • /9 5 0 s = •_ /9 58 6 /a • . 6 5 20 • ,n '
17 . \6 Ni —7 ' • /8 — 7 • • /8 7 • r = 7 /s . - 7 7 � /9 O ff33?I/11
9° kl vf.�8 • • /7 m 8 '�=/7Q B • . h 6 • 3jy • 8 17 8 /7 = 6 .
l 9 • 0 • /6 a 9 /6� 9 • $ 276• 9 /6 = /x
/0 %ILk/ 11,R /0hN • /5 /0 • /5 /0 • . •
.7 o ' /off 15 , • o ` - 5 14
/ / $ /4 // /4 // 'R —�T9 T�+��0.4 0 a, h // !a h 2 : I/
// /20
Q gI m /3 /2 /3 /2 y (tEs s+' °oy' /2 / /4 • zz •v
/43G. 4 /84.G 4.' 524 50'b /35:6• /3S6•h O'14i ,J/./• mix.) of of t, /39. 5,t /326. /32 h so.N ' /2 fB t z ~
�• 2N0.i6. ,5 ST• ,61 4 to le N E.s. /6-
6te' y 43 .3sb' /3sf I3'6' l :JSG• L3 /7.;C• ivs• tri / /. , }p' l6• 2ND b
/ 9 ^. v I 9 e " I 9 j.' 4 / 9 ," n / 9 n /3Ir /3s'b So'H r3s ��s 40' �i
r. n nti)
t. 9 ;o / 9
2 /0 • 2' /0 . _ 2 /0 = • 2 /0 : ' 2 /o • 2 /o • 2 /0
•
. 33 - '
3 // ki a ' 3 // . • 3 // • • 3 I/ • • 3 // _ • 3 // • = 3 // ' O
4 ii
/ 2 • 4 !2 4 /2 - ' 412 I
5 / -- —.. A3 • — 0.� 67 • 4 12 . ' 4. 12
5 /3 = ' 5 /3 • ' 5 /3 ; • 5 /3 • ' 5 !3 • •' 5 T`5 13 = ' 5 13 = "
6 t4 e M'6—- /4 - 6—- /4 ' • 6 /4 • "•-6
/4 = 6 /4 : - 6 - —
7_ /5 ' ' 7 /5 • • 7 /5 . • 7 /5 • • 7 /5 = • 7 15 • = 7 /S in `'
8 /s " ,1 8 /6 " ."a 8 /6 8 /6 ", 8 /(, '? 8 16 h a
35.6' 6i8 u^,40.r- .use• .b /3SC• "64• n/3SC /` /4f6• ''go " /JLC' •6• /JLC•'� - r /3/ ib /3/' n 4.• /35' /33- 5•n /� /_ 6 / 4
,0 O /c
K so' G ST.' 6' e N.E.,� /ST ° o
6 45-6� 4n '4'.
.N.6' :3:.6• - 276' SO �tl y
/4 /2 " 3 ' / 7 4
' 3 — Location of new construction
O' _ _' 2 —8 ' t o Pre-application Review
I g g R Agenda Item III—B
it. 44 52 36W -�
W
,: Ulm a 6 8 r z
��? 5 // ' too C) s .' I! 6 MIMI
•at1 �� —�
r
0 6 /2 ," v 6 12 7 '
I & x�
14kH+iL1L J3.1/4 I /5 1 /6 /3 1 14 1 /5 i /6 13 1 /4 /5 116 I n.a• so' '� ac�cse I sae' g 9 L'i
// 3
27B•
M .� 5d 5, 7
.' -ATLANTIC - �o
. ' ilt = • ll - " f t I l , r 1 ,•
,,6r1 . . I x - - I -I" x• 7• •
1 sa.sc ,ss s� Qy.
IV `his 4 3 z $1 I2345i6 J ! Z
3 6, / ,j
2
(= .
3) `
I roro '� .N1
kl '7 24 v /35' l3s• /cr / rzor U• ..c.,.
' .
Ii
n 7 I /'J }I 296m• 3 m</
./ BEACH ATLAS ROBE E. OWEN a ASSOCIATES, INC.
O
The map shown hereon has been prepared from the most authentic Iofonmation available,pubik and private
It 6 offered to the user for what era value It may have and no responsibility I.assumed for errors and ombsk
4
Memorandum
To: Chairman John Vaughan, all _Members and Staff of the
Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach
From: John P. Johnson, l/fember
Date: 07/02/1996
Subject: Your request for written observations concerning the effectiveness of
the Board
1. Can the Board request a comprehensive survey of the City's historic resources to
determine which pre-1950 structures may be eligible for designation and
protection?
2. Can the Board request an updated survey, with current photographs, of structures
that are currently designated?
3. What effort can be made to revisit boundaries of the four existing historic
districts? What efforts can be made to create new districts?
4. What City-initiated building or education projects can be done to demonstrate
that historic preservation is a public priority?
5. What can be done to nominate more significant buildings that meet the criteria
for designation?
6. Can the historic preservation ordinance, that was adopted in 1987, be reviewed
for compliance with the changes and challenges.to the law in the past decade? For
example, Florida's Certified Local Governments Program has a new model
ordinance that was approved in September 1995.
7. Has the preservation manual, Design Guidelines for Historic Places. been
reviewed since it was published in 1990? For example, Florida's Certified Local
Governments Program has recently published a new model for design guidelines.
8. How does the COA Approval Matrix, printed on page 55 of the Desian
Guidelines. relate to the ordinance?
, r
t
9. How can property owners, neighborhood associations and Realtors be made
aware of the benefits of historic preservation?
10. How can owners be made aware of the permitting procedures that effect
designated properties?
11. Can the staff prepare an Annual Report to the Board, the Public, the City
Council or the Press?
12. What fmancial and other incentives can be provided to owners of designated
historic properties? For example: the County and two municipalities already have a
Tax Abatement Ordinance.
13. How can the Board be consulted on all variance matters that may affect historic
properties?
14 What special training can be provided to Code Enforcement Officers in the
historic districts?
15. What special training can be provided to Board members? Can the Board be
instructed in the current procedures for due process?
1-6,Wilat-can-be-done-to-attractindividuals-with relevant experience to be appointed
to the Board? Can a position of"Alternate Member" be created as a training period
for future Board members?
17. What can be done to help property owners, who consistently present the Board
with incomplete applications, who need a Certificate of Appropriateness?
18. What can be done, during or after, with the increasing number of unpermitted or
inappropriate changes to historic properties? What procedures and penalties are
provided?
19. What opportunities can be provided for communication with other Advisory
Boards and Committees? For example: Affordable Housing, Code Enforcement,
Community Redevelopment Agency, Downtown Development Authority, Planning
& Zoning Board, Site Plan Review and Appearance Board..
20. Can a private advocacy group be formed to assist the Board in meeting it's
responsibilities?