HPB-09-04-1996 4-
DEIRAY BEACH
All-AmericaCity
1993 AGENDA
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH
Meeting Date: September 4, 1996
Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting
. Location: First Floor Conference Room
Time: 6:00 P.M.
If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect
to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these
proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is
to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105.
I. CALL TO ORDER
II. ELECTION OF OFFICERS
A. Chairman
B. Vice-chairman
C. Second Vice-Chairman
III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
• August 21, 1996
IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS
A. COA 8-290: 246 N. Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic
District. Contributing Single Family Residence. Owner Terry
Eichas.
Renovation of Single Family Residence.
•
HPB Meeting
September 4, 1996
Page 2
V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS
A. Reports from Historic District Representatives
B. Board Members
C. Staff
VI. ADJOURN
Pat Cayce
Historic Preservation Planner
POSTED ON: August 29, 1996
file HPB9-4
>::::::<::::::::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::::
igigmmplimggpmgmtgotmgmmonen
................... .................... .................
Pursuant to the Historic Preservation Board rules, the Chairman and Second
Vice Chairman are eligible to serve another term in office.
Meeting Date: September 4 , 1996
Agenda Item: II
Project Name: COA 8-290
Project Location: 246 North Swinton Avenue
The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA 8-290 to allow the
renovation of a contributing single family home.
BAG KG ROUND
The house was constructed in 1941 in the Minimum Traditional style. It is
constructed of cement block with a stucco exterior finish. There are no plans on
file and no photos available, however the original windows were most certainly
wood sash, either double or single hung and the roof was of cement tile. All of
the original windows and the cement tile roof have been replaced.
,PROJECT"DERIPTIN
The renovation consists of replacing all of the windows and exterior doors: the
installation of awnings; new roof; painting the exterior; and the installation of an
asldriveway. All aluminum hurricane awnings will be removed.
Windows
All of the windows are to be replaced with single hung aluminum sash windows
with muntins, and will have a white factory finish.
Doors
All or the doors will be replaced with wooden doors with a 15 glass pane
configuration.
Roof
The roof is to be white fiberglass shingle.
Meeting Date: September 4, 1996
Agenda Item: IV-A
HPB Staff Report
COA 8-290
Page 2
Exterior Paint
The main color is to be yellow, Porter #6218-2; the trim is to be dark green,
Porter#7056-4. Color chips will be available at the meeting.
Awnings
Awnings are to be traditional shed style and will be covered in dark green vinyl.
Vinyl sample will be available at the meeting.
Driveway
A driveway will be constructed in the front yard and will be accessible to N.
. Swinton Avenue and NW 3rd Street, see survey for location.
The jalousie windows on the north and south facades still have part of the
original wood framing, however it appears to be badly rotted. The front windows
have been replaced with aluminum sash windows and no wood framing remains.
The Board should determine what sort of framing will be used on the new
windows.
The driveway location is consistent with the LDR's.
The minimum landscape requirement for single family house is not applicable to
the proposal. However the applicant plans to upgrade the landscaping. At a
minimum, staff suggests that foundation plantings and screening for the air
conditioner be required.
The exterior colors are on the approved color pallet.
1. Continue with direction.
2. Deny with reasons stated.
3. Approve with the following conditions:
• That the window framing be uniform on all elevations.
• That foundation plantings be installed.
• That the air conditioner be screened or relocated.
HPB Staff Report
COA 8-290
Page 3
Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E), approve COA 8-290 with the
following conditions:
• That the window framing be uniform on all elevations.
• That foundation plantings be installed.
• That the air conditioner be screened or relocated. w\A-
�<z: s �1 �� e sly •v�� 13
file/coa290sr
LJ 1
.'. ,,1•. -ice''
r.
1,,,..ii.. I
•
•
.:7 -9''c'A' eltea.-t- .� 1-
1 ti • �
,�hsr
• vt fr . . i;.: ,;:.,-zi;;-;,:.„-..it-x , '''`,-- -': , `,. '..)-!,.- � 't�!. Asir
•
•
:ii.Y ,,, •A : - •\ n _f', •;� 1%:.N)
lei --'-
I ..-: _
i , ' r
I
• t iT
f:�y:
�l
((.2r
•
•
_ ..
•
/ /
�. .
.` _ _ �� ,
1. a,�
lrz :. f
s,zt' , .c '4 : ;•, •. - 4: - -. _ '^ � .c � w" ��'�:.;�"i. t•�S14 Stye -�,'.. !• ; , `•\
-••:, _'. =.,w_4sSi.rL{ '-+ J o , 1. v� • 9'-
i 2 T/-f
•
• • t
t' • I I��u �
,., / a.i • . . , , I',
It r �%I /' I ,
,:. f-y
/ ,l M S -y ', 1 -
•
t-,
‘ .
. -
•
r• -.,.
•
-,•.•,-wg. •••,-.„s-A"..'r--"'Srgz,N.tt -
,,,-,.._ . .4.,...-,72.,51.,-;.•zi''.7...:-: . .-*;. ' -.. ' -',.• . •--. • ,•"t:.....:,.--_,':•.'.:•';2•.....‘: ..---.7-•:•-:77:•••''''•••••'-rw" • ' •-.
Pi- •••-,t---44'•-•-•",-e3.-‘142:;"rtrt.:••-,......_•..,„..-_,_. . . ..- _.:. r•-.. :-....-•. ••• . . . .....,. .
r*I-4..1,":4.,°.*.• ''.. 4,4;... ....---7-'u•-. .r.,',4q;.•••'..'4,5t.',•‘.:::',., -•• • "-30•.`• ;1`•,...w....y. 43., ,,,,....*.....71,7..."- .4-••••- •-
..i. - .4
OWS
,r_c., G wiND . ,
4., siNGLE HUN • SERIES 14,
..:.„.,
4
MODEL 14-1 FLANGE FRAME MODEL 14-2 FIN FRAM
, .
.... ,,k
— . ..,..
,:i _,,z, , . :-.•
. _ ._.._ .......
- - --- - .....- 0.----.
.;-,...7.1. -. ----., • :, ,, ...„.
— ---- —
.................. ••=1.......•1•1 ii.. ........... 1,............... 4,,„ , . , ,,
------ 111..........11 11..........••M 434 t,,,...
..... .,
.'"."'''..."'" - 0•111====IMIIIi IM.....1111==.0 ,._,i,
ill
1" ...".'.. " INM=M0=•=•■ $ .•.../1MM
..' :. . ;•..: - .", - ... .........--.....
--";• ' .,, ... • 1 1_ , i. 1, 1 ,........
'.;:_.; I • , . ' '''.- ....Pi ‘r• ' •.-".
••••••••'••'• ...........m .. ,... .
'-""......,... - .' - , -1...`ir,7411.,.., —.—••••••
-'•.:."..: . • --.1, r•:-1...4 4..s- tes4...,.,. — —
.40..
_ _,
.............. _
'_...;...';.t,;-;.,'.,,,.,'--.:.- ''.--.,.:,.....,..--i t-,.•"*•-,.*.'.*-...e.•-,-.X..,!..:,tr.-..:,,--r.",.:„,.w_'-,!.-,,.,-..,,'.,,z.:.,T....4--.-•3;.,.1.-.-.-.r,:-;',_-=--,_,._'7..•...,•..:,--''.!'•,=,..,..tt...,-;;7;".0,--i.•-.-:,"-..•‘•:'--‘i.:.',.r,""._-..,-.,"N"..1.7*-..'..'-'-7f.-..:,..V-."-".;:3k..',_..-t:i•':.:.
,:...-'s..„....*..... ,• -
...'.V.,.Z...,............—....-.- ..
. = i..„•
•,.
s,:•s-
f
' 0 - - . -
1 — •..,'.'
. 4.'""•,.4' •.44;
-,'.1 • ." ',,F:2/16:4-'e• ..-tellOZ-.,, .-.?': / . 'f, :±1 ', '''''''''-'s::..'4 -.7-..7-.-. ' ••4 • .--•-' 1::-.• p
.,:- .,-,-....-....„..„.„ :.,„,...: .- . _ ic,•.I -- • - -."--:=- - ---1: -- - ' f - 4''' ' -
.: -,-,•.-,-..,,,•.a" ..?:*-";,• 7 '---4'i
::_ . .„.„...;„... 4 ff..71-;4''.".V.'-' - f;! . . .--.. - a.....-,.•.., - , ..,., .
• . ;'',-,,tt .-..4-- -..', -.--s-',-••." '''''1---;:-,,,,,"._ 1 ,A,,,41- . - ' ,_
-.. ./1C,„At ..l'• . gi-;r'-:-..-- ! - tl 7 I. ---,=::--..;: 11 7.,7...7.,:=t::::- ,.-- rd ..- . ,, , ' ' k
'-g-''...i?, ..........--• - I.,.-......-........-.../--... - ,-, -0, %.,.. 's , . • Ac• ,:::,'F. - ' ; 2-4,, ''.; ;IV--i. j -2.-:--.!-7.-..k.,-.-7.-•:-....-•-•• 5 ,..v. N ., '. ' , -%A •:.
....,--•,-
r...• ' , .."7“ -...,--v.i. •" :-I.- ; •-• . _ ."1; _ _._. V-' -. .. • , \ -,:•'.., , • •,z,
,11.0, :--1 '--':•-'•1-:.-_,:: . • -
• - •, *vs-
•': / ---• ., .--tr ' ‘ •
..,1'....f I• '' : -
51%.--;:' e •
, _. ',..,;.'•. _ .-:-' : . '. _ :....: _ .i,e,,:_k74 .,,,. r:,,,'•'...---t,::,...*---; ..i. .,...1
-.:.:..-
‘ . - ' ' -- •.:;,,la,C ' v - ;.. '.„ -,, •
tri.
' ...
; -.. t•';' .1;.1. -''''
il•t•-', -:i'V
•-4"- •-'f-
' 1F1
• • ,
-
/
qr
'''. '' • ' • FEAT & BENEFITS
..: :.
• •-•,c,:. •-.. • .• ... !,,.,.:
..,.1
-•.•
V4?'
.. •Durable all aluminum •Available with clear, '
- • - • ..-..
construction obscure or energy- . .Ili;•. I. ..
•Meets Dade County's efficient tinted glass ,k- . ..'
... . - ••••;,,•_.,.: 7:-.. ,%,:,,.://4.v--•:;;,r,z ;•-,...zi;'..• ;..:,'...-.:,••:,- '•,•'--:- • -;.::‘•,-.•,,,„,*.A.Zysz,l, rigorous forced entry-.1 'et; ' :.
' : -• • • .-',';‘,.-:,-,--4-;•••ff.,‘P•!-A-It--- C':; - -''''' .': •-•-•7- -.'-':: , •-gt-c-'7',•-- code •Available in standard or
!•."1,1_.-.4,;;;I:f.4 ..-:,
• ' ' -• . :.-i•f.:;•--.•-,„•:-:•..,..,:::,..-f.•• '. , -.- • ,,kkv, ,,•&'• Colonial Grid styles
• • _ . -, ..• •-•,,,,,-!,1•,.,-;‘,-.44.,•,.;::•--..;,•.-f(.. - •••• • •. . •,-:•;,/;-,•,,vt;-..-'.' •24%Stronger than
' •• •--,•••*--•,.--.4 •••'`-',..k;... .': , ; ''r"'•.‘.....'nS'-...,. .: •Available in mill finish, ,`,.•,--eri, I'S
- :•;i•',•,:-.-,.- conventional aluminum white or bronze
•., - . . - • •t, windows
•PA-14 Single Hung A 'AA:A: Nati.
r------ Bilinings . •Block and tackle
.. • i. -ii:
Windowsb carried in stock •-•„AA_
exceed all design load „,.,.!...,.., ....,
y Home Depot meet or .1••••• c-, ,',
operations .; ,.,I I
?-. ii e
-:. balances for ease of• Frame types available for masonry,or wood requirements of South
Florida Building Codes s1;1111111•7•1:-%
:,i•
,
••• frame construction
,, _ 1,.. ,,- and ASCE 7-88 for up -'%1'.....:::,•:','',::".1.I:
$ lAt. rnerican .High security lock(s) to two floors
-I?
:-(..,.,;•':,5:-;:,,,,,;-,
1- .'..:,-. •':1, . --:..,,..:•?-,. - • ••-,--' •.-- '- •• . . -
.:;!.....0
G..1,1•
I .
.--4 0
1 i' 56.0-0 -- .
.2_0.4.
• 5.-oul,10.7.-321.e.--4 rAP •4? it _ -r MAIL 4 DISK
.____.=_ LIEIK.ills luilaS-Reo) • !oo 1-517RN-( kr <Le,*Coso4
G ARAGE-
.1q .
2.CD. Z ••:.
•8:: -....:, ...-.;:.,..:::-4.".••••,;, f
• -\:. - x
...;
• k CC)13C. ..
.. -
C-INP.) .: • x
- sa. OT 1 BLOCK 58
- -
F'.F. •... •....:.. ... - -
Ai C-.
LOT 2 BLOCK • -• F,•-i
- 15.5. :-LI
.• • l343: ;‹
.-,,•: 'F.-I:ARIDA -
-ROOM 9.
E4 .C'l
1 . rd
,...4 ,.
_
,...4"
75-1-tfpL71 c& VI en
en E
• a.Lc- ,
. -
. a
20.5'
.,*..
i - PoRcg - t- 1 — I
- -
• 1-' .....--.1
I
t;:::-StOs'?' ___-: -.•'''''
•
fouklo.. /a" t.13• Ek ci.42 ,-...o ca
uk.uurviesRec)) A 1,4? -...,..••• ire. N ,-- .i
I-0--truD C.M.
25'
• •
i JA/lt 56.00'
! e
,
/5-
I
en
,,
246 SWINTON AVENUE
C
I - -roLido okle
cuukrum )
a t, 8 - _-_ �. _
1
1••' •O b
�j• • /6 • 27 2 • 6/3 INA /6 h .•,, 2 23 2`
•. zs ;R 3 : • /7 • 26 - 3 • 3 -- - /2 /7 . 3 -';
27 --- '
3 22
'}�s q . 5 . ts/9 - • 24 5 •
m /7 `'/9 5
12 ` 6 : : zo - • 23 64.
9 Y To • • 5 20 • • 6
/3 -� 7 z/ -•
22 „1�7 49 57 •
8 2/ 6 73 /9
2 Ut ill• /C6' /3o eS0' I-
/4 o •e� = 22 - z/ 8 tf) _ 2�.a 3t;0.6. I � �� 22 /8 Wo 9123 = '9Q ` 9 �3tTEcr' ��6��,e22
B r�r I/7 . N., 9
/6 • v • ro : b z4 9 • /9 /0 /O .; /9 • O s'L`!Jy/Il TO/tJ /� /6 Q ' /o
h /7 • •// : x 15 t • /8 m// ' _//_`:. _._1--- �`T"�i N • /l k
45, • : /2 ;33zs A h /7 /2 - _ /2 _ /7 Q /5 •
• /2
,3 zb /6 /3 R 4 /3 /6 '4- 4 /3
4 27 M 15 14 4 Q-. • \. / 13
„
504 14
'� �ss•h Lzs• t. / 6•
0• 3SS�so'�, /ado' ' /:fd6'q•50' -iK_ ; ,.-
/7. --- ;/32.6'•o 5d h /3s.r
3 s 0 /6' ST
. St' /03 -4°' /84.G. 'So• 6La'Sn /3Jd' /3LP /3u'• p /3/" /3/' -p 45• ,32.6" /9t.6• /
ass; • . IS �4� 2 /� �8 24 ... �3 24 / �R / 9 'n / Za h 3�., /_
2 5 �- a z.s 23 ^2 h 23 2 • 2 m /o `" 2 23 1°n t°n 2
I no a
• c • 3 /s5 .� 3 ' 22 3 ' ' 22 , 3 ' ' 3 np• // . . 3 22 :
J /r6 N I • 3 •
• 5 • 4 •
;. 4 • • 2/ v 4 - • 2/C 4 • •" 4 a /2 • , 4 2/ . •
• Q ' 5 ' • • 4
Q , .5_ 20 $ 5 204 5 5 /3 5 20 • • 5
. E • o . ro _ i� 58 6 66m ' •
6 W� �� _ • /9 ' /9 6 6 /9
• .7 Y.714 17 r; 4 ' eN7 : • /8 Jr • /8 7 • , . 7 15 • . 7 74 /8 7 P
• 8 . a 6 41•°8 • • /7 ' /70 8 _ •i /83,• . 8 tZ, 17 • et1 -
a /O • 9 :it F I• y /6 4 9 • •p 275 ' 9 /6 - . B
a I • Q • m /6� 9 • u) 3r 9 Y
i/c•h1 ;iP /043Z • /5 /0 • • /5 • /0 _ pp
a • to� /5 ' /oo -
// h 47s 474 4691 j /or.s• N /4 // +R /4 // �R y/s �4 N �o // /a •h = : "//
$ •.. .I//2/3,i Q o// /2 0 0 /3 /2 co /3 /2 �tE1 s4 y ;o 12 /3 :a N o /2
' .35.6• ,50'Q7Jd7S 465 143G 60' /84.G. Ise• ,n4.5O'h /35.6' /3S6'h ...'4 /8'.#• /3/./•'.9 of Of t'p� /39' -v1 /324• /32 '•1 '•1
5 4/ /35•/- I.
,s. 2NO.,6 /6 ST /b; 4) m /6' N. E.,6 6-
• ns.s7' Se• -se• srs' , Bo' 3.'dd y .*s-6' ' /35.6 'fO• . /3.^.6' ; .d«. ,) 6e'4 /j;•�. `• car, , in /3/' /3/• ,-, y /35- /35'in 50- .3S' 6-,
7 k ^ / 9 �- / 9 / 9 ki $ / 9_ / 9 ; / 9 n. ° /
1. 8 h
2 /O ; 2 /0 • = 2 /O ° • 2 /0 : ' 2 /o 2 /0 : • 2 /
Z 9 • •N ?• et: �• S' . 7.111E
et m // y- -,,,
.....47
-�•I 7 ,v2 g 4 3 4 .35
/2• _4 40. /2- • 4 5 r /2 • \ e 4 _.59 /2 _ 1 • 4 /2 ` ' 4 /2 • : 4_ ,
/3 • 5 /3 5 /3 • 5 /3 = 5 /3 ' 5 /3 r 5 � 3 : .
/4 ' ' 6 /4 -In : 6- /4 -6- /4 • 6 /4 6 /4 = 6 /4 ' 6
/5 ' • 7 /5 ' ' 7 /5 ' • 7 15 t • 7 /5 • ' 7 15 , • 7 /5 • ° 7 /
t /6 W.
- 8 /�S 8" /6 8 /6 ^ 8 /6 n 8 /6 ^ 8 /6 . 8 1
OW K. /V /35.6' 60. '40.' -t5.6• ` /3SG• •50• /35.G /1IS6' .Q /f/.L' /3/6'o O /3!' 3/' /35 /c ,3.. �' /35
K ST Z. /4-
/G•ST" /6• 4 to N. E.„• „---
5 135• SO•- /36.4'^ etS6�• •
$O 49 ^ ,M6' :3:.6• 3 278' SO /25• /35 is SO 135' /
7 g /4 g J/2^ 3 3 / T / i 2
/3S-
, 8 • :P. 54 'tce
` 2 8 ' • 2 8 3
3 9 - • / 1 9 i� 3 9 0 • 3 9 4
10
^ _ / 44 52 • 4 64 /0 ` ir
N Nk' ' 710 As, W •,
'4 9 �" ___Erelli? r 6 /2 i. -. i- 6 /2 •r i- 7
L 12 h t4 pg o:o v V y
sv :3� ...."1" /f6.1 �, ^/3G6 /3Lc' ". co " /25 /2 " " r35
1 Y� /6' • 1.•
I I j ! a
N .so •.. - .13• /3 I/4.1 /5•I /6• so• /3.;
• 14 I /5 I 16. 4o -,ILd /4 115 1.r,6.e•33'N 1/31
/4 /S /6I/7 /B
el . /s' , 273 so z7 s5,:• ATLANTIC -
h
- It . , , ' ti . ' Il ( ' ) { t 1 I 1 ( I 1 1 , 4631- 1 4t7 • I - I - 1 -Ia!r 7• .7
°615 4.1312 4/ 2j3i4 5I6b gl 2 3
(: . •3) I I
lii: 7 j� i
l 3
, i
t-A DELRAY BEACH ATLAS ROBERT E. OWEN .9 ASSOCIATES, INC.
The map thown hereon be.been prepared front the moat authentic Informed.
It I.offered to the user for what ever value It truly have and no respon•IbUft7 is