Loading...
HPB-10-21-1998 DELRAY BEACH trawl All-AmericaCity ' 1 I ' AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: October 21, 1998 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes'the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER (Roll Call) II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES August 5, 1998 September 2, 1998 September 16, 1998 October 7, 1998 III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. COA-357 Pre-Application, 21 N.W. 2nd Street, Noncontributing Single Family Residence which is being Converted to Office Use, Old School Square Historic District. Bill Bower, Owner, Dick Sheremeta, Authorized Agent. Request the Board's Comments and Direction with Respect to the Elevations for Renovation and an Addition to the Existing Structure. B. COA-334 Continuation Sundy Inn, 106 S. Swinton Avenue, Contributing Structure, Old School Square Historic District. John Szerdi or Rodney Romano, Authorized Agents. Approval for Light Fixtures for the Off-Site Parking Lot at the Northeast Corner of S.W 1st Street and S.W. 1st Avenue. HPB Meeting October 21, 19982 Page 2 C. COA-362, 302 N.E. 1st Avenue; Contributing Mixed Use Building, Old School Square Historic District. Ann Schnabel, Owner. Approval for a Change of Siding Material from Wood Clapboard to Vinyl. D. COA-362, 303 S.E. 7th Avenue, Noncontributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Marjorie Stafford, Owner. Approval to Install a Chain Link Fence which is visible from the Street. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports from Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff V. ADJOURN al- Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: October 15, 1998, 1998 File/u/agenda/hpb 10219 8 • MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: October 21, 1998 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairperson Turner, Susan Hurlburt, Tony Keller, Shane Ames, William Griffin; Betty Diggans arrived at 6:06 MEMBERS ABSENT: John Johnson STAFF PRESENT: Jeff Costello II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Mr. Keller and passed 5-0 to approved the minutes from August 5, 1998; September 2, 1998; September 16, 1998; and October 7, 1998. III. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA-357-- Pre-Application: 21 NW 2nd Street, Noncontributing Single Family Residence which is being Converted to Office Use, OSSHD. Bill Bower, Owner, Dick Sheremeta, Authorized Agent. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is to review, comment and give direction with respect to the appropriateness of the elevations for the Bower Office Building. No formal action is required. The Board felt that the elevation reflect a 1970's ranch style building, which does not relate to the bungalow character of the original house. Mr. Ames made several quick sketch suggestions which would be appropriate for the front entrance and would reinforce the bungalow appearance of the original structure. The Board recommended that the applicant's architect come to the Board and present some simple sketches as alternatives to the proposed design, before final plans are submitted. The Board further requested that the handicapped ramp railing and the front step railing be made of wood and be residential in character; and that the shutters to be used for,hurricane protection be defined. B. COA-334—Continuation: Sundy Inn, -106 S. Swinton Avenue, Contributing Structure, OSSHD. John Szerdi or Rodney Romano, Authorized Agents. Due to a conflict of interests, the Chairman stepped down and the Vice-Chair took the gavel. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval for the light fixtures for the off-site parking lot associated with the Sundy Inn. It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Mr. Griffin and passed 5-0 to approved the light fixtures as presented. It was moved by Mr. Ames, seconded by Ms, Diggans and passed 5-0 to approved the final design for the sign (item not on the agenda) as presented. The applicant presented a design for a trellis for the existing wall on SW 1st Street. The Board recommended that staff review the plans and drive past the site; if the trellis is appropriate it may be staff approved. C. COA-362: 302 NE 1st Avenue; Contributing Mixed Use Building, OSSHD. Ann Schnabel, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval to allow a material change for the exterior siding from wood to vinyl. It was moved by Ms. Hurlburt, seconded by Mr. Griffin, and passed 6-0 to continue this item to the next meeting to allow them to see samples of the corner-boards and the 6" clapboards without wood graining. D. COA-363: 303 SE 7th Avenue, Noncontributing Single Family Residence, Marina Historic District. Marjorie Stafford, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a chain link fence and gate which is visible from the street. It was moved by Ms. Hurlburt, seconded by Ms. Diggans and passed 5-0 to deny the use of chain link fencing, however the Board voted to continue this item so that another filing fee would not be required if the alternative fencing proposal cannot be staff approved. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None -2- 10/21/98 B. Board Members None C. Staff None V. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mr. Keller moved to adjourn the meeting at. 7:15 p.m., seconded by Mr. Ames and passed 5-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of a meeting of said body for, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on /G,2f 4 i-/ 1998. If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. • • -3- 10/21/98 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC 1:'-' 1RESERVATIPRESERVATION BOARD ' Project Name: COA-357, Bower Office Building Project Location: 21 N.W. 2"d Street, Old School Square Historic District ITEM ``BE F"ORE THE BOARD PRE-APPLICATION REVIEW, NO FORMAL ACTION REQUIRED The action requested of the Board is to review, comment and give direction with respect to the appropriateness of the elevations for the Bower Office Building. BACKGROUND The existing single family residence which is located on the at the northeast corner of N.W 1st Avenue and N.W 2nd Street was moved to the site from N. Swinton Avenue in 1992. The lot adjacent to the east is vacant. The applicant has purchased the existing residence and the vacant lot. The proposal consists of constructing a 2000 s.f. addition to the east of the existing 1494 s.f. residence. A site plan, which staff supports, has been submitted, which accommodates the required parking. When this proposal first came to the Planning & Zoning department, staff recommended that the applicant bring the preliminary elevations to the HPB for a pre-application review. This did not happen; the final elevations have been submitted. Staff feels that before the working drawings are prepared, and before the formal COA review, the Board should have an opportunity to make comments and give direction with respect to the appropriateness of the design elements. STAFF :COMMENTS The site plan has been through full review by the P&Z staff and is appropriate and compatible to the site, especially with the parking lot taking access from the north/south alley. The footprint of the addition is also compatible to the site, staff does not recommend that the Board suggests changes to the footprint. However, there are several inconstancies with respect to Section 4.5.1(E) Development Standards which are apparent in the elevations: (c) Proportion of Openings (Windows and Doors) and (f) Rhythm of Entrance and/or Porch Projections., Meeting Date: October 21, 1998 Agenda Item: Ill-A • HPB Staff Report COA-3572 Page 2 The addition will be stepped back from the front porch of the existing building approximately 12', which will create an interesting break in the plane of the south (front) elevation. The hip roof on the front portion of the addition is also an attractive feature. However, staff has concerns with the proportion and spacing of the windows in relation to the wall space, especially on the front and east elevations. The existing porch has a flat roof and is enclosed with a fixed pane and glass jalousies on the west and south. The redesigned porch will be enclosed with siding; a single window will be installed on the south, and a door on the east. Perhaps a French door could replace the window on the south. As the front porch is located at the 25' setback line only a step would be allowed to encroach; a railing, to create a balcony effect, would not be allowed. However, a thick hedge could be planted in front of the step and, if allowed to grow to railing height, would have the visual barrier effect of a railing. The flat roof over the existing front porch is inconsistent with the pedimented gable over the new entrance. Perhaps a less classical approach to the entrance would be more appropriate to the irregularity and informality of the combined hip, gable and flat roofline. Materials for the project have not been submitted. The existing house has aluminum siding, aluminum single hung windows with applied muntins, and a composition shingle roof. Staff assumes that the windows, siding and roof for the new addition will match the existing. As the addition is approximately 1'/4 the size of the existing structure, a great deal of aluminum siding will be visible. The Design Guidelines state that "artificial and manufactured materials are always obtrusive and inappropriate in Historic Districts." The industrial railings for the handicapped ramp and front steps will need to be redesigned to be more residential in character. In order to understand the relationship of the existing structure and the new construction, the Board should request that the revised plans show all 4 elevations of the existing building. File/u/coa357pa H - - - - - - - - - 1 .- \ r a o .—.-a j3,,,,,,,,,,,,T7 DUMSTER --------- .� it min'n u n� i 1-� 1 WC MEN r 913 I U I \ I 1\if IA_ \ --,_) /—`, J %C • Ii/C WOMEN 4 Y EXISTING PROPOSED s 1,450 S.F. 2,000 S.F. (, 1,10 111 CZ to l )_ ONE STORY Illil / COMMERCIAL • y BUILDING %.1 0 A 1 ] ,,,... ,.. 0 iet, ., ...,„„,::,. ,..., e e'.i;.�*�2��) _ RECEPTION •1•::`: e `I::;t .� , 1, 1 • i -d I; -:' ':)(:)0 11 WALKWAYaDOOOMIP • • '7 • 0 00009 ' .. 00 CON C i i a i I LTD I I i II Ili II I I L — F_ -- — I_J— ---- �= � ® r- Nim-eh) SOUTH ELEVATION SCALE:3/1 6"41'43" • . 11. 7 LI .. - - L - 1 -- _ ® ---- --- ® um - _® ® ---- oaoo -r-- t s�CG`& 1 440RTH ELEVATION SCALE:3/1E" PO" • a r,i�i1l1 Il� Ifllf1111i1ltil��� 11Iti l/ L}I f111fy� I11f f1liiliIT1 i Tl ini i_Illili— ,,rrll�-II[ IIl Illl I 11111- 11111.II1i1 I.1ti lLJ11111 11� I. l 111--II1I11 lil . IIHIJI lil.-111� II-Illl1 ,� - . "- - _ . - :,•n IIII l �Ihllll IT i� III II I I ��II ] 1, 7 S._ -..�1 p I-II �1I 1 LH iI 11i Il1IIIII II111� itii1� IIIIII I1�111 IIih 11 II_II]�II_ iii111_lllln_li�r�r..Yi �iL-ii. iYi"11 f irifiuiIbY11. Ii:ll 1ii nil[I iilil Il llUliiliIili!!I II 11LLCM.111I1I11IIIll11 J11ll_W ,1lI_Il�l 1 1J11_�I-11-:111 1_]I1[ I_l111II_l1 III_l 1I I_IUiII_�11.111_JIIi 1it[Itiliill -- _I ----11 1✓11U lam aal 111 _111 U]40.1.1 u 11.1,U441,1,11_111 i 1.1.u j I ___- 1= - = ==I ____ ° _ ____ = =_ ____ - _ _ _- ---= 1� _ - ---- -- ---- ---- L • • WEST ELEVATION !CAL:,,,. I'O" �II - 11. -loin ki-1601111-116fill-O_Iill_V1r11-111.1111_111111d11 _- -- 1 - _ ---- _ --- _ �_I_u 7-ftfr....7 -_ _,, —__1—_ —_ 1_,__::= ::::=____. = ;___.--; --I"—17---_-_- :::=______ =k=.—d— _ _ __ !____9-: _ ________-=_=] EAST ELEVATION :1 , . • - -....,"''••••• ' 442., 1, •'1.:*•5..-••••:-.•-•\?..;,-•;?•:-.e..2iyi:;•••',;•:-:',..,:-..*:,..- - i . • ••••,.„-- -,•,. -‘ ." liv,•* '.*•'****q;1•',F4*.!* 4?"'*.,...;-**-.J..,-. •••:,..;•:.;;.•••-•:::::•'''''- ,.,...r• ' .1;7.7. ' '-' '•.:,--`---$ ' "I''''•".-Ak-•,.';')':•:;a-•.4.`:-.--?. .t:-••-• --.1111111%.- - , ',-,,,:'.1^.-00r.gr•e-i„...7.-1.-...•'-,•sQ_i3.•..„,_ .•-•..- •. „... ...,. • . , . ----- - • 'r • ' .; I, , ,-......, . . - •-. , . . . .. „y II I. • • • .,. ,:•• - n1i ,0 11 7,,_ •. ...,- . _ •- • . ..,-..L. . .- • _ . ---• - • . . . • • • • •• . . . . • - -. . -- - - - -- -- . •-,> . . ..,-.5:-- ', '.•,.....,. .:.:---.1.-.1.4fis...?..--;,,I.- - -..--&i- ••• ------,i....-twi- • -•.,-:,-4;.-....•.,„s-•- ....... . , _______ _ _ •-_,.. ,.4"P" • ,..._. .14...ii - - am.......• _ - --- . - -- -.. alling '-• . .. _77.1777 - -__--- . 1-,-,• . • - - . . - .- . . • I !.- •-- _ -. -, ... •-'... t:-**•.. . . — • ' _ 1 ' • ..- • - • • - .'•-.:•-• ;".--,, .„;•,:....:*:•:' ..•. • r: ,:.‘:-.'•:,..,--.-`•;,•••--•c .*-•:---* .::••-"•;.."*'_•:-'''. ••. : -•.••'•-•••' * • ' :-.?;*•-•4.1.f'...•-',..%:::•;:li::';.;,• .. ., . -_••• :2-;---,-'7.is;,..?;*•:: .;•••..,*!....--:,.:, .‘..:...„•.0.".•...:* ,' •. , , . f-r" 1.'•,.. ..:',r" . .:::',:' -•,..2",-,•, - • • •-••:•. :.... . i 1 1 . _. S I � I I I l i N.E. 1 1 J-1 I I I . i L A K E I D A R O A D E. 4TH sT. 7 POST l CASON OFFICE METHODIST CHURCH w -> > > < < a a N.W. 3RD ST. N.E. 3RD ST. MI 111111 - Li -Mill NMI V=—Z 2 CITY w �' 'ATTORNEY Er'um> I i- x BUILDING IN =Q i 0 - I MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. DRIVE N.W. 2ND ST. N.E. 2ND ST. 0 z IN (n q AI o Z Q z CITY I� HALL _ W I- _ 7 / 1 I N.W. 1ST ST. N.W. 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST ST. / 1 J wLLI I 3 ZO z Z z 3 j COMMUNITY _z z z CENTER z TENNIS OLD STADIUM L 1 jCfl SCHOOL I /// SQUARE ATLANTIC AVENUE — . 1 II I11 > POLICE SOUTH >I( ILi I ui > N >' .-a < COMPLEX COUNTY ` �— 3 ` I = COURT o LL; - {--� HOUSE N n N——< �� I oz M_ 1 W N W U1 I fn (N N N Vwi h r ,ak N CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL — 21 N.W. 2ND STREET — PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT I -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM293 fat STAFF REP_ORT, HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Project Name: COA 334-Continuation, Sundy Inn Project Location: Northeast corner of S.W 1st St. and S.W. 1st Avenue, Sundy Inn Off-Site Parking Lot. IT"EM'"BEF,ORE THE.. BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval for light fixtures for the off- site parking lot associated with the Sundy Inn. BA C KG=R`O U N D The parking lot and associated landscaping were approved by the HPB on March 18, 1998; the light fixtures were not'included in the proposal. PROJECT DE S C RI PTI ON The light fixtures and poles are made of aluminum. The poles have a 37" high decorative base and will be 17.5' tall. An inverted "U" curved bracket that is affixed to the pole supports the light fixture. The light fixtures are 25" across and 18" high. Six light poles will be installed on the parking lot site. STAFF . COMMENTS The applicant will specify the color and finish at the meeting. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS. 1. Continue with direction. 2. Deny with reasons stated. 3. Approve as presented. RECOMMENDATION Based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E)(9) Visual Compatibility, approve the light fixtures associated with COA-334 for the Sundy Inn off-site parking lot. File/u/ww/coa334s5 Meeting Date: October 21, 1998 Agenda Item: HI-B a - t 6 .t ' ]0' ii /li" I�� 78 mZ t1 i tr �I . qt I 11/ 1�'-6"d 11 �/fit wwNOv� �� t 16-0 CENTER ottfr,"14. . t ; iltd0, ;b • 1 ' 4-1 NR:::;;; . fiji -. . ( . ' ( Ai ti • Iff, ..if - f-it f r_ Ili 1 I�1 r 09-18-98 DELRAY BEACH, SUNDY 3/8-,-1•_0-. DMS40 ' i-T— f.R. pMsao 251528 I III II 1n1 Ii I • i1ARTN LUTHER KINC JR. DRIVE N c ?MO ST. 1 CITY "' _i HALL 1 i f N.W. 1ST St N.E. 1St ST. 1 I IF!A M Li - COMMUNITY CENTER Z LJ := TENN!S > ow J STADIUM I I I SCSOUARHDO'E El I ' I ATLANTIC AVENUE I SOUTH I 1-' 1 III 11111 '. TY COURT HOUSE i , P, IIII - - s.w. 1ST ST. S.E. 1ST S_ I I I I ® :::::::::: :: I I -' S.W. NMI El • [,_,_,: 2ND ST. S= 2ND ST. III I Z . II I O - , „ II I - 1-+ W1� I I IN ' N) z I N } — --I I 1I — I S.W. 3RD ST. tS.E. 3RD MERRITTI I — PARK — , 1 ► -I I; _ • STAFF R EPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD =- Project Name: COA-362, Ann Schnabel, Ann's Quality Grooming Project Location: 302 N.E. 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval to allow a material change for the exterior siding from wood clapboard to vinyl. BACKGROUND The single-family residence was constructed in 1945 in a contemporary split-level style with a prominent shed roof. The exterior siding is horizontal wood clapboard. The single family hone and detached garage were converted to mixed use (residence and pet grooming establishment) in August of 1991. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The proposal consists of covering all exterior walls, soffit, and fascia, including entry on the south side of the residence with horizontal vinyl siding. The house is to be white with dark green trim. STAFF COMMENTS . The applicant has discussed the use of vinyl siding with staff on several occasions. Staff has pointed out that the use of vinyl siding on historic houses is inappropriate and that it is the Board's policy to approve vinyl siding only for new construction. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation recommends that the original siding be maintained and does not recommend the use of vinyl siding. Our Design Guidelines state that synthetic siding is inappropriate and should be avoided at all time. (See page 28 of the Guidelines, which is attached) Vinyl siding is considered inappropriate for historic houses as it contributes significantly to the loss of historic character by hiding the original façade. Furthermore, such siding can conceal signs of deterioration to the structural system of the house, allowing major deterioration to occur unnoticed. Meeting Date: October 21, 1998 Agenda Item: III$ ` s HPB Staff Report COA-362 Page 2 ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Approved as presented. 2. Deny, with reasons stated. RECOMMENDATION Based on a failure to make positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E)(9) and the Design Guidelines, deny COA-362 to allow the use of vinyl siding on a contributing structure. File/u/ww/coa-362sr • • ? • «! 1 •/•• • !'/r,• -r ) I/ , �___ ••.a,'. .'L•;,- / ..:1/1_:_iiiek • - .;.t .• 4...e4 .,-IL iy.a • 1_ .....-=.i, f i , r Y-r _� '*•!.: �ti`r+J-..a °+ l"7.a "mac .«�v"Z"'�•z.y" L ...�' } r � —� i ._..F `")' �4 h tom - Y' i•.�.Y`sz•. _ ,yb "..•r . 3i^ y" ♦- ' 's 1 i"y-4v�.�' rr." .�!"s 3 Y • ;R+. S,sY tS k �• i Z�:`<y4 .` 'e_ -"-"'yj:i^..u_.•••••177-m`F"- :✓y'z-".Y4 �• z!,• _�l K".,--..:,+l�- i"' `L---L.- .. e-- -•___ n � � • r '. .+— • ttt111���777 • • •• - -- - i i . / T!J',•)4•f! !/:.r..', • . jrz. _7, i 1 / Ii•. • g r phi ; - s _ �Ns ss �s? Y ' � ay � jj • s - rti T _� wLr�T.•.3•�--.b -fl -- -K. 0'••"-'• _ ".rMy .. ' 'ti _ -..-.. >-.�y.t-- c" t�-r".•r .r•!-� � s{sC•- c••.>ess ,, r - ^•t -, . Ott..-. -...-- . - '''••.r'�rrf'tC-".,...... - re S 0 SI-IINGLL SI vu_ --J� - INAPPROPRIATE Ift • Removing a major portion of wood from a facade instead II A—Square of replacing or repairing the deteriorated wood, then * B— Iisti cale I I r reconstructing the facade in order to achieve a uniform or 0 c— octagonal A. B. c. improved appearance. .0 D— Cove — L-—Irregular _i - I L • Stripping painted surfaces to bare wood, then applying F— Variegated — ri__, — clear finishes to create a natural look. D • E • Failing to find the causes of wood deterioration, i.e. faulty ) E. F. flashing, leaking gutters, cracks and holes in the siding, deteriorated caulking in joints and seams, plant material WALL CLADDING TYPES and weeds,or insect and fungus infestation. Dry wood and Subterranean termite inspections and treatment should be A—clapboard routine with wooden structures. J B—Flush Shiplaps Joint C— Tongue&Groove • Creating a false architectural appearance because of insuf- 1 D—Board& Baum A ficient documentation,or introducing a new wood feature r incompatible in size, scale, material, and color. r _- 4. • Synthetic sidings should be avoided at all tiriies. They t,,, .....:. ,� , ��� � �r conceal original buildingmaterials. Most heat loss occurs due to windows,doors, attic functions (80%, as heat rises), B. thus siding is not important as an insulation material. — Weatherstripping doors and windows and insulating the attic are far better choices. These materials mask the advance of termite infestation or wood rot. Severe moist- , I Fkl. , ure problems may occur because siding traps moisture in --, = the wall cavity. C. • Also, siding adds to the expense of roof replacement at a later date because it must be removed at the sides of i 4110 dormer windows and above porches to install new roof 3 i " flashing. Importantly,it can be a fire hazard.Aluminum acts r : ,° i, 114 � � ); like an oven wall, intensifying heat. Vinyl emits poisonous = D. gases as it burns, at the same time it hides the path and VI direction of fire as it travels along the walls. Vertical batten boards offset the horizontal `11flyds and shingle patterns. r 28 BEVERLY DR. I Y G••• I ljill ,:11 411 TRINITY N.E. 5TH ST. 'INN gill oIL a: L U THERAN ,�, Z L` LAKE IDA ROAD (N.W. 4TH ST.) ` N.E. 4TH ST. _ MA POST - CASON lim OFFICE Eli - METHODIST Elli - CHURCH W II z NIM - Lil _w > uj > > > =a Li a < — immii . IF _ iii:iiiiiiii! N.W. 3RD ST. N.E. 3RD ST. I - Li lid__ IV— < - • _NM a■ — ;— CITY =2 av, — ATTORNEY NMN ME" "'� —I- a BUILDING I _ = = II, MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. DRIVE (N.W. 2ND ST.) N.E. 2ND ST. o Z - } I- -J — zO 3I 1 z— W Zaz CITYHALL to z N.W. 1ST ST. N.W. 1ST ST. N.E. 1ST ST. z = 1 v COMMUNITY L., w z z CENTER Z z Li TENNIS OLD STADIUM SCHOOL SQUARE i/I/i ATLANTIC AVENUE III - �- N SCHNABEL PROPERTY III CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL 302 - N.E. 1ST AVENUE — PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM294 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD `< Project Name: Coa363, Marjorie Stafford Project Location: 303 S.E. 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District ITEM BEFORE THE : BOARD :a The action requested of the Board is that of approval for a chain link fence and gate which is visible from the street. PROJECT ;DESCRIPTION The proposal is to install approximately 26' of chain link fence along the front property line (S.E. 7th Avenue) at the southwest corner of the lot. The fence will return, approximately 30', to the southwest corner of the single-family residence. A chain link gate will be installed in the return. The purpose of the fence is to enclose a swimming pool. The applicant plans to install a hedge in front of the fence. STAFF COMMENTS The applicant is aware that chain link fences that are visible from the street are inappropriate for historic districts and cannot be staff approved. However, she feels that the Board will consider the proposed hedge sufficient to screen the chain link from view. Pursuant to the Design Guidelines, chain link fences are inappropriate in historic districts. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS 1. Approve as presented. 2. Deny with reasons stated. RECOMMENDATION Based on a failure to make positive findings to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(9), Visual Compatibility and the Design Guidelines, deny the chain link fence associated with COA-363. File/coa/363sr Meeting Date: October 21, 1998 Agenda Item: III-D Sep-22-98 14: 52 Marjorie Stafford 1+954 779-7813 P _ 01 * I SC_ 3110, •STe-E-7-7feet 5.315' AS1RL,1 goAD7 i. (IN N z , . ...:: 1- ` i �. , $ ' r1.5'-a� . . . ,-_,,,JC., 31•'a+dI +3-�, - VI - , \rE. - C'J� co L�7 1 ---1DCI Zq.2.d {c.c.o1 6•.�o.?ik,: • • . �3 W {•�� 1N • •• QRTN° N > rr 3.8oi 4Q � /� p 6,40, . .. . oc,T.T.4 Li.)t O \STo R`-1 c=.35 �44 ' '-' t Z r 8cD<>xc o �,p W alp. N .. " 1 ea r.> Ro 0 (� '38. G7 raC 4 cAP �.k.,i.D j 1 ~ , 0 n• 101="13A"i5.0' LOT Z I- '0 II ! C Y.)cn" l CJ--J D Cy- \5-:1 II O.ID'Lopc.-.7,--L -zcif - 7" 8Z.cog' I 1 Mifie6W5SCIZS gat' T Z----—Fo,...1,..1:1 ,k, Ie....) ____,_,.........._, --‘0f-ittit4 LI Nt)cfv4e.E. ,i! • -- �--- ..sz°o tU R . v_ Q -boa►.)E' L ,,,,-.a Ron*GAP LC-TT f-4-. "i-Aoe+.» i. s v� . u So tL-TSi rJ C, ELEVA-n otu = (0 35/ ,PrC?.t a Et 'IA l at., 5;-1 I 1 G�0. 41t4 = 5,3' -- . _.._ ..... .. ..._ .__ . MAKubriE-- STAFFagp FLOOD ZONE "AV ( EL.=8 ' ) , ADDRESS: COMMUNITY PANEL NO. ; 303 SOUTHEAST 7TH. AVENU , 125102-0004-0 DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33433 DATE: 1 /5/1989 . - ?}(ate,- : 24.3-e 'c ' Fkx : Z.`t3- $S82 - IVT-EN1'ioN : ?AT cAYcg FENCES & WALLS ;-" '"" White painted wooden picket fences have been the traditional -;,, ' ' ' frame for Colonial Revival and Vernacular buildings for dec- I ades. They have always been an integral architectural land- ` ` • t ,. scaping element.Spanish style masonry walls are also preferred ie ' ;�1 •_ ,> '' - ;Fr, ,A to enclose Mediterranean buildings. >,' , Maintaining original fences and walls is important. Unpainted t .� _.a► ..:.'Q ..t: .t, wood fences and chain link fences are inappropriate for any .,.. - - Y historic site. Green stained chain link with complimentary hedging height may be used in rear yards not visible from the " ' I' ` streetscape. All new fences should be compatible with the '. .. „'```�, _•`' ,�}"4a', '=o• .:.•, ,.K.,,. �r�'. style, texture, and fabric of the street. r" Ornamental iron fences can be appropriate for certain period ,,•,< ,t . ,,t 4�+ ,� styles. „4 4,1/4 ;,-, .fi141:444; r ." Creative fencing is encouraged to enhance the architectural "' 1 ',�` charm and character of the historic site. ,�, ' __ ``''"n .w_r,... .01 3 PARKING • ', ,. , ,'L r '•t The City of Delray Beach has adopted a Landscape Ordinance li a• . r . ' 41 which establishes minimum standards for screeningparking `�F• ` I i rt 1 • ,1 �'� �` r , � �j and other vehicular use areas.Ever attempt should be made to ' to r Y p , obscure vehicular use areas from the pedestrian view. Fencing, P rl I '' walls, or landscape buffers can mitigate the negative visual o. s I impact of automobiles. l '" i I e i Parking requirements are set forth in the Zoning Ordinances. a ! ,. Either destroying the building's appeal or inhibiting direct ' . • '"' ''°A ' pedestrian access should not be permitted. t:,. •. `; ' n { ' '3", r. '�• . . \4. 1 Y' 1,jy ' ,. Previous page 4e \ei ,. 1.+,ti 4'3v�1. ^2V .�..„, 1•..It .+y,,,,,qs , ,h;, . :, Top: Wood fencing,low plantings,and natural brick walkway. Top: A glass block light, white painted brick, and sawn wood Center: Keep vegetation low for aesthetic and security. lattice contribute appropriate historic site elements. Bottom:A concrete/wood fence with potted seasonals creates a Bottom:A wood trellis with a waterfall of bouganvilla is supported sensitive landscape setting. by attractive irregular picket fencing. 46 11 I I I W l 1 1 1 1 I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 m 7 l l 1 1 1 1 1 i W_.I LLJ 1 I I ,_-._J III ! 11 A T L A N T I I C AVENUE u I 1111 11 (1 I , WATERWAY EAST - - ir COMMERCIAL a o CONDO N N � I � � I a �' _ ' 1 .a .c C w L. a_ a BAR o v`i . > > HARBOUR ¢. ¢ CONDO _____ S.E. 1ST ST. ` � I MIRAMAR STREET I 1 I © BUD'S 1 I oII2 tO ,_ ; /(JD IIII n . Q OCEAN N "PLACE ll Q "CONDO L w I Cn !n ICt LJ INGRAHAM COCONUT I ROW�——� S.E. 2ND ST. I— - AVENO; l 1 z 3 SEAGATE OCEAN TERR. 00EAN TERR. TOWERS y y W Y - NIA S S AU� _ ST.Q� If II III S.E. 3RD ` ST. f 1,1` - - i BAY STREE7� o C Z Z o LANIKAI m °� VILLAS ~ LANGER WAYCONDO 1 00 e N - Z _ w ui VI VI N 1 I SEA GA TE �— S.E. 4TH ST. CASUARINA ROAD ` 1 I MANOR 0 o a r//III//4 I I I I 11 I BEACH af71s• DELRAY S.E. STH ST. r- WOMEN S r BUCIDA RD. CLUB J 1 ¢ P410 e _Io a Qom W W Z n �. ul > > I Q w wW,4* y Q Q I— O . S.E. 6TH ST. p ' BARTON N MELALEUCA RD. c _ I APT Q OL> < ¢ L~p CONDOS . oL. U RD 0 0 Lai Lil CHURCHILL Q CONDO �Z`+ n < (n 0' TAMARIND RD. 2 S.E. __ 7'H __ . I— ■■ o . 0 Z O 0. v Q� wZ — G CC w w W—— nAN / PC Li In U o N N- N BUILDING ` I" I 5EP�' . V S.E. 87H 50- BAUHINIA ROAD n1 11 r I I l 7 r N STAFFORD PROPERTY -v 30,3 Z TLC AVENUE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL - 0 Z S'E' 71 r� A V C I V V C - PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: LM282