Loading...
HPB 05-17-1995 DELRAY BEACN Alf America City 4111' AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: April 19 , 1995 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6 :00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286 .0105 . I . CALL TO ORDER II . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: April 5, 1995 III . PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: None V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: Review the designation reports and set a public hearing for May 3, 1995 pursuant to designating the following properties to the Local Register of Historic Places : A. The Blank House, Constructed 1907 , 85 S.E. 6th Avenue B. Historic Monterey House, Constructed 1939, 20 N. Swinton Avenue C. Historic Bungalow, Constructed 1925, 24 N.Swinton Avenue. VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VI . ADJOURN POSTED ON: April 11, 1995 4a • , tricia Ca c-6r, Historic Preservation Planner MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: APRIL 19, 1995 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I . ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairman at 6 : 00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Miller, John Vaughan, Charlie Williams, Betty Devitt, Vera Farrington, Julie Morgan MEMBERS ABSENT: Sandy Jamison STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Diana Mund II . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The Minutes for the Regular Meeting of April 5, 1995 were before the Board for consideration. Ms . Farrington moved to approve the Minutes as presented. The motion was seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed by a vote of 6-0 . III . PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: None V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: Review the designation reports and set a public hearing for May 3, 1995 pursuant to designating the following properties to the Local Register of Historic Places : A. The Blank House; 85 S.E. 6th Avenue; Constructed in 1907 . It was moved by Ms. Devitt, seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed by a vote of 6-0 to set a public hearing date for the regular Historic Preservation Board meeting of May 3, 1995 to designate the Blank House to the Local Register of Historic Places . B. Historic Monterey House; 20 N. Swinton Avenue; Constructed in 1939 . It was moved by Ms . Farrington, seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed by a vote of 6-0 to set a public hearing date for the regular Historic Preservation Board meeting of May 3, 1995 to designate the Historic Monterey House to the Local Register of Historic Places . C. Historic Bungalow; 24 N. Swinton Avenue; Constructed in 1925 . It was moved by Mr. Vaughan, seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed by a vote of 6-0 to set a public hearing date for the regular Historic Preservation Board meeting of May 3, 1995 to designate the Historic Bungalow to the Local Register of Historic Places . VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None C. Staff None VII . ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Ms . Farrington moved to adjourn the meeting at 6 : 30 P.M. , seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed 6-0 . - 2 - 04/19/95 The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for April 19, 1995, which were formally ad p -ed and apprpv 'd by the Board on May 3, 1995 . /j ///rui 't' Dia Mund If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes . They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes . - 3 - 04/19/95 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING APRIL 19, 1995 AGENDA ITEM V-A, B & C ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of reviewing the designation reports to affirm that the properties are eligible for listing on the Local Register of Historic Places, and; Pursuant to recommending to the City Commission that the properties be designated to the Local Register, set the required public hearing date for May 3, 1995. BACKGROUND Blank House For the past six years it has been a goal of the HPB to designate the Blank House to the Local Register, and hopefully to the National Register. The Blank heir who inherited the historic house was not receptive to designation, and the the threat of resale and consequent demolition was ever present. Fortunately, Mr. Bonchak, the new owner recognizes the significance of the building and its relationship to the history of the City. He has requested designation of the property, which encompasses all of lots 12, 13, and 14, the original homestead of the Blank family. Historic Monterey House and Historic Bungalow. When the Board granted COA' s for the Historic Monterery House and the Historic Bungalow it was determined that both buildings would be included as part of the inventory of contributing structures in the Old School Square Historic District. This designation is a legal formality that officially recognizes their addition to the historically contributing buildings in the district. The designation reports are stamped "draft" because the photographs are missing. My camera malfunctioned and I lost two rolls of black and white photos taken on a beautiful sunny day. Photographs will be added before the public hearing. RECOMMENDED ACTION After reviewing the designation reports, set a public hearing date for the regular HPB meeting of May 3, 1995 . - - -• .', iv;1,f; 7,-..--; DESIGNATION REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA - -••--k--,:d-,----:,---••„-:;•-•,--:-,,i.4.t,f.z..-.-"-:f. _ ,'1-_ ___.,_....,.,,_._,.....,,,,.,,i,m,:.,L,---.-:.,,,:,?::::: -ec._ ..2.:•::,:-.:=:-.•.-2:f:..:::--,•_•.--,-;-:!..,-,*,-iy-4: -.9:-•-A-,,i_:,-,-,;---)c--_,,,...E..):---;;i:;:-:1; ,.....- ,::::-.:•.:3".:-...;-7,.,-2.,:::,.-.,..-il•.t.._,,,i,p-ii.-,,:-•.',-,-;-:',.-::: •,,_-,..:;:•-<ci.----f.7.1•17.-i::.,,,-:--,..:::-::.7----.;:zmY::.-..- --:-=',:----• .--:-..,;---...,',x.e.,--,3:L,z,-.-..„4.-. .:::;.--,.:',:',-,,-t‘2•:...-.-:::---;•.--,•-' ,-.:',',-,se•'%;:••••-----':i.--;',.-.,g.•,•.,:L',.-.:..!.. ..c,..-.--.7,_Ii,n,•.:--;-:,-....,-,--.-.:•-•_--•,,.-T.--,_:,::,...:•-%,:..=:•:--;,---,.-:•-•;,,,:p.•..----,,,77.-i.; ;„,-....4,:-;---Y,1,;,.....% ‘.:,.• .-•,...:,.?:-:-.4...-...-::::.•s,,,•-_-1,-.:.- -.::,,,,..r.i.,•,-;•:.:=.:'.;,,,,,..::::;•? •-.--..-7;•-.:-;-?..-:5'..: ::i.;=, -.-:--•.:',...:-.'w.•7--?...:;%:.=----,...:-...)..z-i ...',-,-•-::!;!,‘:;':::'•7;ss..--‘1..;..,:,.-',•,-:c:::-..:-.f.,i,-,...::::•,-,;:,:::.,.*':;:-..,),,,,.....7•_....;•:.:1:,-.--.;,-..,;:,-, ..-...,...:-.--:•:;:;.-:::.....„-._,-.. -:-„,,.-;:,!,,,,c..,:-,..L._,.:0,..v.,:,...1.,;:?i....,,,,..,-;:.a, r•...t,.. ..,.,-,-r,-...-,..-•-•.,••!,,,,,,z,rz---r...-.•,,,,,,,,,,---,,,-,.f...e.`,..-.:.:2:4,:-.-1,Rz•,:,..,z.,.-47,.;,-,7-,-,,-..-7',>.::,'---;',70S--7.:%-vAt':-I',1-,:"'-',,,z-!. ..4;f:'5:,'-,:;,::;'-':-:":;•'''.7W0';'MZ.:;-'-':"-.`-'''''.i,--!1=v-F',...::::T::7*-.-';'-'4'7.,.-4.-:'5'..-.4-.:!:-::6--:---'..-,-;-;;:;..,-1',-'.,!----`:,-7--;.":i::-1--.1`.-z- ;;;X, .,.oi-..._,...-„---?,,,..j:,,,.,..:-:..q11,:'.fs.;:,--",-=`;‘...,-;:vz:t.'=":.-..---fit.--,%-,%-v.,-'''- s'"--- :::-.''"----•- ,_:.14,,,zi, .1Fi-%';.-rix-::i-;:%_'---,,,.--.^:?;::4;-.i.f.z...i3.iY.-rf--C,----.) •-:-"' ‘ - -. ''''''', '-----.7...:;,-'11"7 ----",7',..2-''''''''="1-::-,-.1'i.:;:-'42A1--F:-.?t,".Fac 1—--:'-';'::-:- ;:'-'--<=".':.:-7-S'il,:t;;--i7 ,',•'•;-:;lizr-.`.:---'' - - .,.-z-;„;e;:--c..- ' •' -- —-7 ,..:.-44.A.Z,:.•;i:,-ilt..gr-i:-"Acii.;. ,.::-. ,....•:,1 1::pelr7, '..,.ir ...1.,g';,4,...i.A-, . . "'''''''-tii. ,.;::,' -';„i'ri----i- -------••-_.t.- ::-_,..,,,.f.v.-.... _-_-...,_,:._.:-.....,,,..,-,-.,z.-Ag: -;,;,,,,,,--,,,:-.7.3....,..--_--,,-..:„.c---•::::7:-=-: -.. ..':,--,---s--..4;k:1-.,--_-:-_-•: ...:.::-.A-1,. .....-,241: ‘Y;-',":.1t,,,,,,,Si-fii.-,',:;;-.3.1t--:1A•-.--,-i'-:',:.---- . ..: -.--•:-11:-..-,:: ; ;: --i-=1:- — ' Illi 0E111 mirigninil ____ - - ..-.,.-:..-_-„,:;•.?- `.-.---.4.41k-W-s;":--pg.--; nom _____.—---- JWPAP2ke„; --- . , ,-. --_-:-.:.:,.., ...___,..,....._,,„ ,f.:-....-.:--:_ t::---,i,:::...,:re ,.._ -..:1:, 1r.. ....sf.4 ,-.....--- 7 ..'..-_:.':1.•; ,....t.iv...- ' . _ . --1,;-.`,'1..:- IN.-..,_--;,-,-.4-—C.!'"-1: •-..---,::71 • _7.:.--_--7:: ::- -fl..,----..:'-f.',i.:-."- ",_ i .. ..,. 4.--;E„, , 1:::::::,::,:,., . 13.:3.-":':'1'.-13:::•:`:::-.1 _ _ _._...,......_t_i __:-:-1 :-.1;:-:11-2-1:.--.......ill: 17.....,::::,...:,:ir.:;:._:1,--.1 [...-:-... F...... ....--,:;:l. „..x„..i,.;.-:---r. :i1. -:-.:--.--,-...:-:-:••::. ,;:.. ti„..!--.:7-7;.,--_,,,,,_-:.:: ..,,...:,:„........:-.,;.-:„.-....,•-:f.,_ ___4„.-_..._ -_,,z,_:„....."...._::...,fr.-,.i,:...:=1:.......... _ ,.,,I.7 -4(iz.,,,..,::.:1f,ak,. 1 1... ::,:••-it:-.,..1_,:_--...,-;: i„.....--.... .._.,.:1,:. 7.-7;1,-:•-;:-......51--:,,_--,--;.,:---..---..5.,,-.,.:fz:,-74.7 --i.--,,--,.-7,--,-;-;.7-q- ,T .r.:-7:zq-:--:.-2-::.-_r:',.-;-c_,::..•„,:-.-..:i..i-:-:-.L.r:•:•:.---,.,.}:::..-r-J.,___,-,.._,:_,--, ;,-4 ,i.:1,,,.77.,z„--3.1.n::.;:-_.-, ,:.:_.,il:,-_._,::_r_--:--;-, , —....'" -: ' . ,;-;7 -T*.7•VP'.r. --"I'l:'''''' '''''''',,,, y..7,, . •:-, :•,•-••'-':..- :•-z.:471z-.4--.4.---,4.:..i.,.. , ,,,,.,•,----------------- --;-,.....3„,,,,,,,,,,,..:.,-.1.,,,,,, , „,„cwl.:,.- :....:..v....,,,,c1%•..,,..,-.„...„.,,,,.,...I., - •'----k--,,7tr—. ..„-,,,--.. .1-. :---...„,.ttzte7-i. .x..,-„.,.i.„171....--;.,ci-...„.1; •wir-4-:-,0 1:t.--,.... ...4. --, , --4,i-:: • .......-.4tr.o..,•,,.,...,,,,,,,,.L 4..,„•.,4,0 - THE BLANK HOUSE 85 S.E. 6TH AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1907 • • Designation Report 85 S .E. 6th Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 85 S.E. 6th AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE IV. HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared April, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. Designation Report 85 S.E. 6th Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 85 S.E. 6th Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1907 Architect: Unknown Builder: Unknown Present Owner: Michael D. Bonchak 90 S.E. 5th Avenue #1 Delray Beach, FL 33483 Present Use: Single Family Residence Vacant Future Use: Commercial Present Zoning: Central Business District (CBD) Legal Description: Block 117, Lots 12, 13, and 14, Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida. Plat Book 1, Page 3 of the Records of Palm Beach County Classification for Designation: Architectural and historical. Designation Report 85 S .E. 6th Avenue Page 4 II . MAP —� ,— --. r— I,,.. 1 0 0 z z a a 0 O �- ' 1 N.E. 1ST C Q DRIV , › 1 O ¢ 1 O O Si (/1 Z , 14 I _ N.E. �1 1ST ST. LO --� �. ' 1 s 1 �� Q 8 1 z z 3 1 - .1. 1 I _ v� 1 _ p�ZAC VETERANS 11 ! z _c"�,—• . III PARK I A T L A N T I C A V E N U E 111 ,, [-1(--- WATERWAY EAST I , CERW& cIAL ___ ._.._ MI:M. aEr /i---.-C rcInE J CONDO il,1 > > ~ BAR Q Q �.:.:.,. HARBOUR 1 ;�:::! CONDO TSi ST.Till !- - O 1 li 1 J W �y 1 2 3 w- ILI Vi 2ND Si. • INGRAHAM n c ---1__: R.I- h 1SEAGATE w TOWERS ( j ! z • 1 -1t--1 1-4-1 i1 r m m 1-7 i i I s N . . BLANK HOUSE M1 PLANNING DEPARTMENT' Designation Report 85 S .E. 6th Avenue Page 5 III . Architectural Significance This house was constructed for Delray Beach pioneer John R. Blank and his family in 1907 . It is a two story residence built in the early frame vernacular style. Overview of the Early Vernacular Style ( 1898-1915) Delray Beach' s earliest structures were turn-of-the century frame or masonry buildings designed and built by local craftsmen. Materials generally had to be obtained from West Palm Beach or Miami, as the town did not have a building supply company until 1911. Early vernacular houses were plain. They were planned to provide protection and security. There was little emphasis on decoration. The City' s inventory of early vernacular house are often reminiscent of northern farm houses, as the style and method of construction were consistent with what the pioneering families transferred to their new location. Some adaptation from their northern counterparts to Florida' s climate can be found in large open porches, larger windows and roof overhangs, and masonry pier foundations rather than a basement. Typically, early vernacular houses were rectangular or square in plan. Roofs were gable or hip and the eaves extended out over the house walls to provide protection from the rain and sun. Rafter tails were exposed and without carving, knees braces, if used, were also plain and undecorated. Exteriors were covered in plank or simple horizontal clapboard, occasionally batten and board was used vertically on additions or outbuildings . Wood shingles in decorative shapes were sometimes used to compliment the simple clapboard. Shutters were usually batten & board and windows were double hung, some with a four over four pane configuration. Window surrounds and porch posts were plain. Major Features Rectangular or square plan Horizontal clapboard Open front porch with simple porch posts Plain window surrounds Batten and board shutters Double hung windows Foundation piers with ventilation Gable or hip roof with overhanging _eaves . Designation Report 85 S.E. 6th Avenue Page 6 Subject Property The house contains all of the classic early vernacular features . It is almost square in plan with a small ell on the south which may have been a later addition. The hip roof has overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails . An open porch runs the length of the front facade on the second story and larger open porch wraps around the front and south facades on the first floor. It is of frame construction with a horizontal clapboard exterior finish. The windows are double hung and the window surrounds are plain. A secondary shed roof covers the front porch and is supported by ten simple posts . It is built on a masonry pier foundation with ventilation areas left open. IV. Historical Significance The John Rudolph Blank family came to Delray in 1903 from Bay City, Michigan, which makes them part of the early "Michigan Connection" as the settlers from the Saginaw area were called. They founded the first tropical plant nursery in the area and were successful in shipping palms and other tropical house plants north on the Florida East Coast Railroad. This was a period when palms and other exotics were in great demand for hotel lobbies and public spaces as well as for home decoration. The nursery was centered in the area of the Marina Historic District, which accounts for the many beautiful trees found within the district. The house has been in continuous ownership by the Blank family until it was sold to the present owner six months ago. Several family members still live in Delray Beach. V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance This house is one of the best examples of the early vernacular style of architecture to be found in the City. It is in almost original condition and features all of the major physical elements typical of early vernacular construction. It is considered eligible for individual listing on the National Register of Historic Places . It was built by the pioneering Blank family who migrated to Delray in 1903 and were part of the core of successful settlers whose energy and resourcefulness helped the town to prosper. The house has been in continuous family ownership until it was sold six months ago. Additionally, while the date of construction is generally thought to be 1907 , the City' s Building Cards indicate that it was constructed in 1903 . This date coincides with John Rudolph Blank' s arrival in the area, additional research may more accurately confirm the date of construction. Designation Report 85 S.E. 6th Avenue Page 7 It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property. (2) A building, structure, or site will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a person important in the City ( for example, the homestead of a local founding family) . (3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " This building is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places. It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one paragraph of the above criteria be met. Designation Report 85 S .E. 6th Avenue Page 8 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992 Historical Structure Form, Florida Master Site File City Building Card records City Tax Records, 1912 and 1913 Viola Blank Henderson, oral history Delray Beach Historical Society Archives H. Haild Zeder, Information Form for Dates and Migration of Early settlers, 1895 - 1915 file/y:blank :i •7 it 411? 4'.:,-- it 1'V DESIGNATION REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA ,zk,..,..-,2...-..;•-'....,.,yt,e-,...; ,..---.•, .,..-..-.1:..:-.1::.;,.-:..!.‘, „...,-.-.--:,- ....-,r..:...:•'--,-', .,('-'.%•:-.... -.:.• •'. -:•-•:. ,' •••••..-.'',:--...: -i: •--...: --_::. r..•..-.44..., -4%,•&.s.r,!- -",-,:f.:4,-;4,.#'-:,i%t.,fp.......-,4,.f.,-;......::::,-...:....... ,• -.. . ._... .. .,,, , .. .._... , ,, .,., . •lirr;;=1:.-:.o..iov.-:'.:,1..:‘,. -v,..;..:.;•.••.10,-.f.::4:11-4;:...--4.4.:-$:,;i7..7.:.f.1,,-....,-...‘y...,•:,7 ,.....i14,41'....'-ig."-‘4274,-tlr, t 5"...-.1"-4".:?''•,`:-''''''-'',''''‘`'-;',2::':'-','""--.,-• 7---,7..1,.:4', -",..,',$-V.L.c.'tr'.,).;F:...-^.-,,.. .*.: ,1-: 'Atz,r;f:.?%.-,''..!-,,;•'- •),-;----.....:-:---i:,r s'.:.•:..:-;:1;:,.:..".;:-,',..7...:: ''', •-- ,- ;'•-".°: •14...•?.:4--:%:',..;.?cr,-:4-.S.:,''.•,---,e;).-)`:•‘--:=r-1....'-'-'=•:-::•-4.-.'.,- :: raiA.:,•'"V•Ill''.7?i 4.• g..i,'";'n:V•• 7.• •*.:-!;...T."••:".•Z r'..":-,--•. ..'•.''S-•.:• AY,'•-g4,V,--..`v•t•'-.."\V....'-,..:-r . :3--'' '.V....-!"t`'..'...:'-:(41•‘-'::-::','",-1:,..--7, ,..SAA:••,-.)-V..:4•••..?A.1.•tt.,r::-.::1;teN.T,44`...,.t.%:."A;A',.......Z4,..A;-,:•->-••1:-'--,•:-,5:4,•\--,,:i'r-,;•:•`",%*-,;;;;--t:..."=7:4S1' ,,-....e. ,;,'..1..-..- •?...:.,;':-.':s:'.'-. -=,..,:*-. -4.1•14.:...;s:;.p.,•,-Sli,:--.4.':e.I-1,11.•,:-_-,-,,.......,7„-•-s,.`"-f-..1.4_,....::.-1--.7,Z...:,1)s e",„±"if;'?-.,:...,........,:,;sy..-....:1;:.;;‘,1,..-. •-,),:-.:.., ,f,2,..,.....-..,e;)•.''ilti: 1..!,.!,--;',......1."---.'.--.A.;.:1.7'-i--;..; -•-s,.-3...i.,•;;;',,,‘..":..:)...,.:.i..c.. .',...-p-A• 3!t--*`..4.*:.';',"•-•."4,;.*/. -,,;;;.)5:•,>4.?--Z,'....-A‘F-',V7:•,::•,,:z,...A.,v,:,.Z-vt:e...?1,•,0%Li.;C '''•:.vv..-i•A2,1 4:s.i,t;.;....7;'...1;-...%.,.:;.....17.S.4;;;7.4.1. ..,:*: 1. '1.1m.rowlAttVV4ANttam-:,t.-- 44'.'411'.'.":'''":"'.:-..' 5':f-Y. ::. e--... .1.--.....:--'... ...f ., ,. .:.:'W-A.,..",...-... Mot..4".."•,;,,:•• r.., i:Pd t . . 4.1.4,t z,,I,1t f, •,`•. "..... .•r ‘.krt.:f ? ' -tik-',•••::' "-VV. ....r, .;..e•,....if:7"4"-,--1,00; . .-`,..3-1-c,"'-''' ,4,,,, I. ,.. . - :...-.4,- -t., --•••-.'''' ' ... . ..• ...., r.: ,.--..-1,..r.,.21'-...e.; ••I •. ...E., lor, 15...,* • >..,:--I.•...P.r.-74. • .1.:0>2.,!.:;:ii-Zi..:37:;44:44f e....M. Atg...;:•ti;V:.*'3,..,,,.. **- ..1 ! . ...... •:.1....4..s.7.a.,„::;...:37,2gz.„._,3x.r.szr,44._lb- ___.,„.„,,,,,,.. .-;_ta.4.41r04,..: -,..:...s." :'-t•rtM,..!P-.-...---..,41g.".%-z.....xit`If....Zil. :• .• ..0;•_-:-.--a.:::: --5,....t.01,11 .7.. gr,.. - • .1,..,,p40.1..(1.t.:n..7"-.*.-A'i' ':,'"-'-‘-",,-''•-c,-..-7--.7..—•::-;• :::41ei Ttil .: z.--•••• -. ' . -.). , . ...v.‘ 1 •*- “4.2-...,7-.r..*,gerrr.f.:',3,t-tt: 1-'-"` ,- ./-4:,,,t;.--.. _ :tr,1,j,„.-t . ,,...w.r ; *— - --=' ,....-.---' -,'--z.....-........ 14...-dolt.-,s,..1...e441-,:p.,.,.:;:z. • ...,•api...,..- if •:, •*,,..: : - . .,-.- .... • ..k... .,,...x.2,:••.--..-- , .-. r. .„, :,.-:- ' I. , ..,.....-..-... ..„,.....- i, t 1.,--vi.-:v-1-.2.--.:.:''.:.-Fi,!--':.'..,;:.-:,!.'. ..'-'-.---..i.-1,, -,X.--3--'''•-:.:', . 1 '.-:..,...•-:-i!:,.;-.. 44.-1..qz.-.-- :-,„....2.‘.2 - ' : --.'1•7:;-'f-i,-,.'• '''.''''',;:----- :':::•,=:..:,---.;.--....'1 1'' irk:- :-:: ..,::.-.%:..::....'-;'-f-.:-.-..:----.';>;-:•'..t.-ia 11 1"--"--:RI •-:71,-;•:-:-;..,ii-L"-,-,••••-:,---ti.. -- t... .: . ___,,,,,-, -:-._•.:-....-_,-...4. ..4.-.1.;..,,..-.:,-,....-te .1.62%kts ,,,, : ,,,,+...:.•-1.:..,-....-;,:-„e-A---: ji. -.-..-• , , t it;;au"0 L.JI.,L.....ffi.1 :-•-r..„,.......-1,-..--,747-,11-•._.,4..-_. •...,..--.•:: le c...-_-:_•„-_ -...,.-iii- L.....:_-• t.. ,;:- 1;:: - -1.1 .)'•'-'-Zi`",...-4.'-e%:: -.';:• , '-',--3 WI•••••••P A• . V.3 A A-,.- r7t41... A,. A ,. ,,iset''''"?,,;;."-,;--.'1,•' _-,,,,.... fr . ,.. t:s..,..-7.,..,--.?-:,--...Iii.,......_,.........,12,..-•,..,-__:,'„,..1..it,T.•-...••,,.....,.......„,f;.•,;,,...,..4„,,,,,..'.,4::,--4.7..;,.f1,1;;`,:z„,--..,,-..-it.e.r.....?.,Y.L7_7,:tV.:4:1-...vel.g.sv.,....•:,t......s,",,,.4`•-,4.,,:,:.,,,...,,..•\;.1,..0-::',-;:.!........,:;-: •••: - t.. • ......--_,,:13-•t•I::.:•••--:',1':-',.;;1-- •-,:,•"--::-.-:,;--;.• -. ,f--:;Y: ,-1 -**.`: - .i" ...i .-, -.:;,.. - - '-` • .:1:-.:i';':::17-:;!':-,-7:;:f-s,!..,.-;','"'i,-.;a:-.2F.:-.A.1.--7-''2.-;:(5.c:r;%:;='..23.-:7:''.'":;::.:;:. -444• 1-, •,... . -- •',-•'- -. ----,---/-m' . ,-.:•::::-;:::::;-:::.,-Pc--t•.;.----.-.....-pl .7-,......r.:....L.:.il,,,y-..:-.4-/).......-.7- :=;.0::-: .:,. -,......-:-, -.- -.... :-. -7; •:- ;-......---•:--.!. --- -..::::-.41•. .-s-e,.r I :.,%, : :.! -f..,;,`;',--: ,...•?...TI:%Y:7-:-1:1_---:': faIlr.zi t'a•,' -15_.,•-'.1%----eg-.7".:1:• ,.r.',,,,i:.•:',:..: .4f7 ::---.-:: ,..-...-1.11:-.-----_-..,:-..-%,,-.....-.. -..1--:_,...:;.,....-._-:::,-,-.--::,-.-,-,...- _:-.,....----....:'.:—. ..i:-.....,-.-4.,:s• -i..;-.1-t.:,./- -,-,.-_-.---b)•h7t-:-...:.-- :.„. —...tr-:,.-: _..-.-;::,;.;:„,..-i,,..f.--;.t.f.,-..-,..:-.:10".;-:--A.r..-";;I•-:,••,....•A=-bSs-;•Kg."!.-`1%:-. ..i-' '.77:Cr.V.'..--t-*',A•1-7. --:1-:,FI;.''Z' •i'll';',..'!"--.4`:'•':-.*•-•••----.'`'f,:: '--A - - ••... •••..-• •••.,.-4 t...i'.: _','•-•-1.---7-.7`.27•''•"-----5-ift,'•,-..1-'''-. t:-.-',1••••••%• '..•"-'•;•-' ..,:;11.!-Z37.7-5 i Frraormr_. '; -:'‘•;'•-; 'A..."- '-"; '". •-•.•'•-•-•, .•I .1-:•-•••••':-A.,-..,'••••-•,`,-•. A---t.7:...;;..: •••••••;.•v.:4,z=-..r-.,:•!:••••,_-.•••,,-'. -••'.-,- 77-•.....A.,_t'.,r,- :•-•;,-- •.3......4,...,...•••••••43A•n:A.cr..."7:. '4;-:'•''' :. ,-;'...' :''-.1'''.''''--'''...•'e '.-L'-'.'--'.:-:- :.'.'•--.V---'''.-.r ".;‘...-''''';•--- '''.•—Z '.•-• .... . -. -' • - .---,-,-,3-4.1 - Mt,- •••.--.S.' - • • •-......, --•-•,..1----,*•--"- -44;ig,,IS-4,w.. ..4),)....,7• ....4./. •,.. '.-e--- -r•••-•',.'-'"'"'"-" -•.”--•,..Z.;444.,.....1-.4........74:0..,,.•,,..74........ ..__,_..--,.0,,,,, ..._.,.„., 2...--3••••73.17". 7"----, -••' -".-.1-. -,..... -..1 • - .„7, •-.....-.........m..,-••,- - ..7.•- ";,2,....'"." .".:-,,',..,..,,,.:1%,,,-,''••'•-•-;;;.:...1.;.x • 't i‘s,te''.•,:i",:), -.:-.., -t."1;=„14,YZ"e12'-',1•••••,:,',;„14;.-rsvgit?.-1- . ....'• 4^..2 ;,--tit&tjoittk•Arkra,,,,:r4.,...,..4.6Wi.A.44i4:„.tt4A,14.,..,..14.W! 5'11Ftr:="''''j.:' & ., , -..,---•4,..-e,1-4.'WkitlrarhksVZ4‘7.'Z'Aita --1=1::-.i,.;•-•,r,&,..,..;_-4•44:74,-11-g;1;f-=azv,,I9,-;;;:z,,,,.:3.-.41-i?:t3',.•----- • :•... tiE,34:- .,41 .s.gr r.,,,..1 ,,5-4 ?:.. :11.Q;A:163-'1'i'ig•i:3'"A'tgitt‘z-14-14'-`.._,-...,,,,r4vsyLakz.c,L;-„-,.:.*-4, ''ikopt 1,4.1.:::: ,,,,,,v3A41%-)i.,-1/4-yA..,.:4tItc.g.k.,1,,;z.p..,:r.:Ii4,,-1-.-4.77. _,,,,,-.....-.---:...,-,,,,,,„..„:„.„,..<1 :- ,--,=•:*t.--,:,,,,7-0.....1,x,,..,,,,....-.4--,...„4 zivti,.,-,1,...iii,,,,::,,.:,,:„.,1,,-::„.:-.11 ,,,c,:i.:,,,,,_.,s,,f.;:p,f<a),-.0;?.,:vi,,f.-.1,Kit.::.e.,-..,....r4;f-4i...11-.:,-....vei,t 4,i73:=4, .-t.11:1•420A-4.;14-1--",,,, z...,,,„-ie 00-re. .voTiw..spai.:Afve,,.-5.,_,-witrAvver....,441e3m.144,44,,f,:ive::::4-4 f:f.• ----T14-41-;•ANA.44-c..f.....i. t..v..i-v.fm:15,..,-7,..4., y «,-. , -..4-b.444. " f47,Re4:.'f,', .t. -'.f•'..3•;:,, HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1939 Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 20 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . BACKGROUND INFORMATION IV. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared March, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 20 North Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1939 Architect: Belford Shoumate Builder: Unknown Present Owner: Community Redevelopment Agency 24 N. Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach, FL 33444 . Present Use: Vacant Future Use: Office of Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board Present Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD) Legal Description: Lot 12 of Block 60, Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida Classification for Designation: Architectural significance. • Designation Report 20 N. Swinton Avenue Page 4 II . MAP _> t a Q Q _a 1 1 III or1 I 1 2ND ST. N.E. 2ND ST. 1 - o N F- V1 1 111 — LtJ Ji— Ccj — M z r- a 1Q 3 W r CITY — . ' HALL > 1L — IL: I' I N.E. 1ST ST. 1 /11 OLD SCHOOL 1 —z SQUARE l TENNIS ":" STADIUM mint lig i i ATLANTIC AVENUE I I ' POLICE SOUTH >a DEPARAENT •• COUNTY E � > 1 111 ! COURT i HOUSE iLI1 I. o o z -. 1 I ■ . si N N - -_ xi. t 4. tsr ST. (n S.E. 1ST ST. 1 Z N 1 ui1 3 3 i; ui ,✓1 ui ui r ui 1 '1 1 - I [ _ I 1 1 1 1t 1 1 1 _ _ _ 1 N --egion- HISTORIC MONTEREY HOUSE Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 5 III . Background Information The subject property is one of two houses which has been relocated to the Old School Square Historic District. The purpose of designating the building to the Local Register of Historic Places is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the Old School Square District. This house was constructed in 1939 in the Hillcrest subdivision of West Palm Beach. Its street address was 1031 Hillcrest Boulevard and the legal description was as follows : The West 37 1/2 ' of Lot 18 and the East 27 1/2 of Lot 17, Block 6, City of West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. The neighborhood is bounded by Ridgewood Avenue, Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and Interstate 95. In 1987 the county Department of Airports announced that it would begin a buy-out of houses in the Hillcrest subdivision that were in the flight path of the jets arriving and departing from nearby Palm Beach International Airport. Approximately 360 houses would be purchased and demolished over a four to five year period at a cost of about $30 million. Many of the residents concerned about the future of their architecturally significant buildings questioned what could be done to protect them. The Historic Preservation Planner for the City of West Palm Beach found, in a preliminary study, that many of the houses were architecturally significant and notified the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board. The HPBCPB, in turn, notified the State Historic Preservation Officer who informed the Federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation of the situation. The Council, through Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, has jurisdiction over use of federal funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect on cultural resources. Further research and survey work documented 30 properties which were considered eligible for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places and an • additional 28 properties were considered contributing to an historic district. Two plans were considered for the Hillcrest neighborhood. Plan A was to create an historic district for the 58 houses and rezone the property from residential to commercial or alternate use. The rezoning would allow sensitive adaptive reuse of the properties for other than residential purposes. The second plan, Plan B, was to provide a relocation plan through creative marketing, the houses were to be given away along with a cash benefit equal to the cost of demolition; a documentation plan; and if necessary a demolition plan. Ultimately, Plan B was found to be in compliance with Section 106 of the National Preservation Act and was adopted by the Airport Authority and the City of West Palm Beach. At present approximately 18 of the 58 architecturally significant houses have been relocated. Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 6 In 1993 the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) entered into negotiations with the Airport Authority to relocate two of the historic houses to a vacant parcel on Block 60 as part of their redevelopment project for that block. With the relocation agreement in place, the houses began their historic journey south in January, 1994 . Logistically it was an interesting relocation project. The houses were moved by truck to a point of access on . the Intracoastal Waterway and barged south to the City' s Knowles Park. From Knowles Park they were taken by truck to a temporary site at the northwest corner of S.W. 1st Street and S.W. 1st Avenue. The houses were left on their moving skids and a temporary fence was erected to protect them from vandalism. In June, 1994 the houses were moved to their permanent location on the west side of North Swinton Avenue in the Old School Square Historic district. The City is currently planning to purchase the Monterey house from the CRA. The City will then enter into a long term lease with the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board who will use the building as their permanent headquarters. IV. Architectural Information This house was designed in the Monterey style by prominent Palm Beach architect, Belford Shoumate in 1939 . Fortunately, Mr. Shoumate' s original plans for the house have survived and are added to this designation report. • Overview of the Monterey Style The Monterey style has its origins in the Spanish colonial architecture of early California. As a revival style it was largely forgotten until several noted California architects began designing in the style during the early 1930s . Being highly suited to moderate and tropical climates, in the days before air conditioning, it quickly became popular in South Florida. Two story Monterey houses are generally rectangular in form and usually have a gable roof running the length of the building. Often an extending ell bay is at one end of the front facade and is topped by an opposing gable roof. The exterior walls are generally framed in wood clapboards but may have masonry or brick walls on the first floor. A distinctive feature of the style is a front balcony which runs the length of the second story. Usually French doors open out to the balcony. Front entrances are generally simple and located under the overhanging balcony. Rafter tails and the cantilevered balcony supports are exposed and are often carved at the ends . Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 7 Subject Property This building was one of the 30 properties in the Hillcrest Neighborhood survey considered eligible for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places . It is an excellent example of the style and presents all of the defining features of a Monterey building. With its clapboard siding, front second story balcony, horizontal gable and exposed rafter tails and simple entrance, it is true to the style. An interesting feature is the original one story portion of the front facade with a bay window and secondary gable roof running parallel to the primary roof. Originally the structure was rectangular in form, an addition to the rear of the building was added to adapt the building for use as the headquarters for the HPBCPD. This sensitive addition was granted a Certificate of Appropriateness by the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board. It provides space for a display gallery, handicapped access to the building, handicapped rest room facilities and an exterior stairway to the second floor. Information about the Architect. Palm Beach architect Belford Shoumate AIA ( 1903-1991) was a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of Architecture. He first started practice in New York City in the office of Joseph Urban, Urban was the architect who designed Mar-A-Largo. Shoumate' s first commission in South Florida was in 1937 when he designed a home at 1221 N. Lake Way in Palm Beach. Built in the Art Moderne style it was named "The House of the Future" at the 1939 New York Word' s Fair. Mr. Shoumate was in active practice in Palm Beach for over 50 years and during that time he designed over 1,500 buildings in South Florida. V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance This house is an excellent example of the Monterey style of architecture which was popular throughout South Florida during the 1930s and 40s. It was designed by one of Palm Beach County' s most renowned and prolific architects . In its original location it was considered eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places . In its present location it is an asset to the built inventory of historic structures in the Old School Square Historic District. It is a visual compliment to an important historic corner and serves as a constant reminder that beautiful buildings do not have to suffer the fate of demolition, but can indeed, with imagination and ingenuity, be useful to a community. Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 8 Designation of the property will preserve, protect and recognize a distinctive architectural style, as well as the distinguishing characteristics of craftsmanship, design and detail unique to the Monterey style, which was prevalent throughout South Florida during the 1930s and 40s . Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property. (3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " (c) "Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect. " This building is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria of the above be met. Designation Report 20 N.Swinton Avenue Page 9 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992 Architect Leaves Imprint on South Florida Landscape, " Palm Beach Daily News, August 22 through 28, 1988, p. B9 National Register Nomination Report, El Cid Historic District, West Palm Beach, FL, Prepared by Beth Miller, 1994 . Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, Quarterly Newsletter, Vol 4-No 1, Summer 1989 . John P. Johnson Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach, Belford Shoumate's original plans . Palm Beach County, Facilities Planning, Architectural Division, Plans for Project No. 91240-19 . file/y:house aF a . :PP' ' -4 a.' ;, k ,*1 DESIGNATION REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA n ��f 4+'Ct tT`�" _ '�.5.` '�'j- T jfC'�A.n � ` 1S.j + ,`4 t ..3 tom,N.p.. a.Ax L -.-,,~' 'r�� f i.t ot��1.�+, t t- :iCf'. ,,'4F4' 'd -"sue+ Lt 1. • �e • x. N �.l+.cf 1 .44yw�i4+ ,,fs-vvf' w4r.T �'{r, . 4.• f'I ♦ tr t 1 < ..r J ; ----_____ -''IX,-;.: ',,iis:---..-conl•-•:;,:.&•) ,-.....-_-..,.-:.'.:::i-:!:',.:--,:1;,'.14:1?•-•'•;:e-f'1147::;• :••.i..;'-'A.;;V717.".,-'.'-'-;--r:••;.':'-''• - .:•'.':---- -, .:-..,.:.=:.,:t.',i1,E.:?.,:x:.'2:......!::,-....:.-:,,i:, ::,.-.,,,,,,:..::::.i.-;:i.y.;c.a:.::-- --:-...,-..---:':-.--);:,_-!:...--; ..::: -i :::_:-; -.- -.:i'.:-z--4-',.--.A..i7-i.i.:::-:.---,---A ;1'-.- 1,11 I. fi.... i �• ,j 12� - 9iy '..-C.$r 4 ,rii�.gr "s_ftic y,s",1-4:-ki. '• - � . y," ti t tI.~ A bitj ic � _ j 'YPI;r.it , v S� rFr^ . � it 4 F . _ l J..,f• L _s f,,- ,Sf V y�.r ^ tf tC Ysy {,ty t. t6, • ,r _ ! . r Z..,-• -. r� .t .G +'Cr''^w. ..-:.. ;-• �.r -- f T .1,0:,• . r 1 r j••sis.r - t.-Tt •}• f r•I .fj 4=' t••4' 71 ,.. - 4 : - '5 .6 , -•.tf' •k tlx Sr yt•4' tf at-.t4 a,Y. .r 1 ., > r 4;F1: rk U'4y v •,, "Z.:tP .", f• t e 4.rr^f.e,j l C A 9tf ' € y+ti ti �'^i t + ,- 1.O a. r .rc1p ysf n. r y. ' y Y., w s, v -h 4+•frr Ji' fJ�4. 1 y �: '•-... ?K.r�v WaC-, •'a� a q�9 -'�� I.. 1.� rfa1J� c�t •'S.. sf. .7 1'Z•''w r L Si ^..y ..V f PYl- t'+:I s , "..}" r r7.T 4.fi-•rL "4 ri.t -i.t. Y t -t- >`- ,.. h'. ,r,, '1 K-+' F•• ;f. ! 3"fX' °x r«i,' r S-S f ♦ry4 + ..S.L.+fl>4 ?t f P `Y.y^:.M£ nN.�r t.. ..l•+ -rJ'j Ja ., fN.'C.•.trt A b y Vr Nr - ° p .jt 'r j,� :,..i".N. tisti /,ro .•.y 2",w �4ii L /<1+��- 4i 3 4 "L .' it.lr.. i e+f t t 1'to I,-a r ; 'w8.r..C{f3t ; f Sr.vri::r'�.Yt it i,7.i..`�-.7-'s,w.` yr!t YA K.§2.t+-.1 �Y r,;sa.tpto.'7` r+.,) ! .,i�.f � t•s•' cf i rx{ ..ktf Yf•.w�u_A ��- ., .. .4'M 4.,5 /-J` ay E t_r• P� , r i •. r t r Jy r� t3+ .. !: r fr -• ! -• r •• a .ty. `4fe.'..,r..., .-.-YJ!..a••x-.♦....`:s_-.:... -.4., •••.....- . rfI:_ .... �� s�s't".,:..fi`-".fir. :1.- nk lt��k �i�t. HISTORIC BUNGALOW 24 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1925 Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 24 NORTH SWINTON AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . BACKGROUND INFORMATION IV. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared April, 1995 by Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 24 North Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1925 Architect: Unknown Builder: W.P. Smith, West Palm Beach, FL Present Owner: Community Redevelopment Agency 24 N. Swinton Avenue, Delray Beach, FL 33444 . Present Use: Office of the Community Redevelopment Agency. Present Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD) Legal Description: South 50 ' of Lot 11 of Block 60, Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida Classification for Designation: Architectural significance. Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 4 II . MAP a a` } a a Q a..11 1 o 1 — MO' 1 1 Ill1 . � 1 2ND S7. U.E. 2ND S7. 1 - 0 1 1111 N 1 — w 10 /11 Z — ,- M z Njj5 _ 3 LA1.. 2 CITY — HALL f N.E. 1ST ST. 1 — I 4 f Z' 2 — OLD 1 — SCHOOL 1 Z SQUARE / .!.`i!.' �� 1 TENNIS - 11 — 1 STADIUM A T L A N T I C AVENUE I POLICE SOUTH 1 =1) `' faCEPARMENT . COUNTY > COURT 4- x HOUSE Z r 1 I 0 — P 1 - 1 • z il z a N vl — n INCC — CC ti 1ST ST. U) S.E. 1ST ST. ^� 1 F=- O Z Ni 1 1-4 f 1 3 3 �- VI If; vi Li LA 1 . • 11 1 , I l 11 1 1 1 _ _ _ 1 I N �' HISTORIC BUNGALOW PLANNING DE-PAR/NEN7 cVN OF DELRAY©EACH, FL Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 5 III . Background Information The subject property is one of two houses which has been relocated to the Old School Square Historic District. The purpose of designating the building to the Local Register of Historic Places is to formally acknowledge it as an addition to the inventory of historically contributing buildings within the Old School Square District. This house was constructed in 1925 in the Hillcrest subdivision of West Palm Beach. Its street address was 930 Belmont Place and the legal description was as follows : Block 5, Lot 5, Hillcrest Subdivision, City of West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. The neighborhood is bounded by Ridgewood Avenue, Parker Avenue, Locust Avenue and Interstate 95. In 1987 the county Department of Airports announced that it would begin a buy-out of houses in the Hillcrest subdivision that were in the flight path of the jets arriving and departing from nearby Palm Beach International Airport. Approximately 360 houses would be purchased and demolished over a four to five year period at a cost of about $30 million. Many of the residents concerned about the future of their architecturally significant buildings questioned what could be done to protect them. The Historic Preservation Planner for the City of West Palm Beach found, in a preliminary study, that many of the houses were architecturally significant and notified the Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board. The HPBCPB, in turn, notified the State Historic Preservation Officer who informed the Federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation of the situation. The Council, through Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, has jurisdiction over use of federal funds when it is likely that there will be an adverse effect on cultural resources . Further research and survey work documented 30 properties which were considered eligible for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places and an additional 28 properties were considered contributing to an historic district. Two plans were considered for the Hillcrest neighborhood. Plan A was to create an historic district for the 58 houses and rezone the property from residential to commercial or alternate use. The rezoning would allow sensitive adaptive reuse of the properties for other than residential purposes . The second plan, Plan B, was to provide a relocation plan through creative marketing, the houses were to be given away along with a cash benefit equal to the cost of demolition; a documentation plan; and if necessary a demolition plan. Ultimately, Plan B was found to be in compliance with Section 106 of the National Preservation Act and was adopted by the Airport Authority and- the City of West Palm Beach. At present approximately 18 of the 58 architecturally significant houses have been relocated. Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 6 In 1993 the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) entered into negotiations with the Airport Authority to relocate two of the historic houses to a vacant parcel on Block 60 as part of their redevelopment project for that block. With the relocation agreement in place, the houses began their historic journey south in January, 1994 . Logistically it was an interesting relocation project. The houses were moved by truck to a point of access on the Intracoastal Waterway and barged south to the City' s Knowles Park. From Knowles Park they were taken by truck to a temporary site at the northwest corner of S.W. 1st Street and S.W. 1st Avenue. The houses were left on their moving skids and a temporary fence was erected to protect them from vandalism. In June, 1994 the houses were moved to their permanent location on the west side of North Swinton Avenue in the Old School Square Historic district. The historic bungalow serves as the office and headquarters for the Community Redevelopment Agency. IV. Architectural Information This house was built in 1925 in the bungalow style, by West Palm Beach contractor, W.P. Smith. The architect is unknown. Overview of the Bungalow Style The bungalow style became popular in South Florida during the 1920s building boom. Many of these homes were built from pre-designed plans purchased from publications such as the Home Owners Service Institute catalog and the AIA sponsored Architects Small House Service Bureau, or from local lumber companies . But whether designed by an architect, or constructed by local builders from pre-designed plans, they all share the basic design elements of the bungalow. Walls : Horizontal wood or stucco exterior facing. Roof: Low pitched gable roof with the ridge either perpendicular or parallel to the street; often with multiple gables. If the primary ridge is perpendicular to the street, the front porch is usually roofed with a separate offset gable. Roofs often have exposed rafter tails . Porch: Porches are prominent. They are usually deep and extend the full width of the facade. The porch roof is supported by oversized and prominent piers . The design of the pier supports is usually unique to the house and varies depending on the creativity of the builder. Windows-: Double hung or casement, multi-paned and arranged for cross ventilation Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 7 Plan: Usually rectangular and often modest in scale. Subject Property This building was one of the 30 properties in the Hillcrest survey considered eligible for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places . The house contains all of the classic bungalow features . It is rectangular in plan with a main gable roof parallel to the house. It is of frame construction with an exterior stucco finish. A small bay on the south facade has an opposing gable roof. All of the rafter tails are exposed and decorative knee braces support the roof. A secondary gable roof covers the front porch and is supported by two traditional massive stone piers which form a part of the porch wall. The piers are interrupted in the top quarter by a cap molding, above the cap the piers are stuccoed and taper gradually to the porch' s upper wall. The piers and the large chimney are constructed of irregular stone with exaggerated mortared joints. Wood casement windows with a four over one pane configurations are original to the building. The conversion from residential to office use required virtually no alteration to the exterior of the building, with the exception of replacing the front porch screen with fixed glass panes. The Historic Preservation Board granted a Certificate of Appropriateness for this minor alteration in order to facilitate the adaptive reuse of the building. V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance This house is an excellent example of the bungalow style of architecture which was popular throughout South Florida during the 1920s and 30s . It features all of the major physical elements typical of bungalow construction. In its original location it was considered eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places . In its present location it is an asset to the built inventory of historic structures in the Old School Square Historic District. It is a visual compliment to an historic street and serves as a constant reminder that beautiful buildings do not have to suffer the fate of demolition, but can indeed, with imagination and ingenuity, be useful to a community. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 8 Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property and justification for designation. ( 3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " This building is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria of the above be met. Designation Report 24 N. Swinton Avenue Page 9 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Historic Preservation, A Design Guidelines Handbook, West Palm Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1992 Historic Palm Beach County Preservation Board, Quarterly Newsletter, Vol 4-No 1, Summer 1989 . John P. Johnson Historical Structure Form, Florida Master Site File, Site 8PB00907 Palm Beach County, Facilities Planning, Architectural Division, Plans for Project No. 91240-31 file/y:house-2 DELRAY BEACH Ali4 i&caCitY lI1J ' AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: May 17, 1995 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6 :00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286 .0105. I . CALL TO ORDER II . APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: May 3, 1995 III . PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-249, 345 S.E. 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District. Mr & Mrs William C. McDonough, Owners. Demolition of a noncontributing single family residence. B. COA 8-250, 345 S.E. 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District. Mr & Mrs William C. McDonough, Owners. New construction of a single family residence. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: None HPB Agenda Meeting of May 17 , 1995 Page 2 VI . REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VII . ADJOURN POSTED ON: May 11, 1995 • . C Patricia.Kg'weeet. H storic Preservation Planner MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: MAY 17, 1995 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairman at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Miller, Sandy Jamison, Vera Farrington, Julie Morgan MEMBERS ABSENT: John Vaughan, Charlie Williams, Betty Devitt STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Diana Mund II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The Minutes for the Regular Meeting of May 3, 1995 were before the Board for consideration. Mr. Jamison moved to approve the Minutes as presented. The motion was seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed by a vote of 4-0. III. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-249: 345 S.E. 7th Avenue; Marina Historic District; Mr. & Mrs. William C. McDonough, Owners. It was moved by Mr. Jamison, seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed 4-0 to approve COA 8-249 to allow the demolition of a noncontributing building based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(F)(1), with the following condition: * That the demolition permit and building permit for the new construction be issued simultaneously. B. COA 8-250: 345 S.E. 7th Avenue; Marina Historic District; Mr. & Mrs. William C. McDonough, Owners. It was moved by Mr. Jamison, seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed 4-0 to approve COA 8-250 based on positive findings to Section 4.5.1(E)(8), with the following conditions: 1. That the final landscape plans be approved by the City Horticulturist; and, 2. That the chain link fence be 4' in height and vinyl coated. With the stipulation that the south fence be located at least 3' east of the southwest corner of the building; and that the portion of the fence which runs north to the building be wood painted white. V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: None VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members None C. Staff None VII. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mr. Jamison moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:00 P.M., Ms. Farrington seconded by and passed 4-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for May 17, 1995, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on June 7, 1995. /, ' Diana Mund / - 2 - 05/17/95 If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. - 3 - 05/17/95 L STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING MAY 17, 1995 AGENDA ITEM III-A COA 8-249 345 S.E. 7TH AVENUE DEMOLITION, NONCONTRIBUTING BUILDING MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT MR & MRS WILLIAM C. McDONOUGH, OWNERS ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of granting approval of COA 8-249 to allow demolition of a noncontributing single family residence. BACKGROUND This single family residence was built in 1954 . It is constructed of cement block with a stucco finish and aluminum windows . The house was built by the Porter & Grace contracting firm, using stock plans provided by the original owner, Dorothy Bennett. ANALYSIS OF THE DEMOLITION REQUEST Pursuant to LDR Section 4 .5. 1(F) ( 1) , when the Board acts on a COA for demolition it shall consider the following guidelines before granting approval: (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill the criteria for designation for listing on the national register. This house would not be eligible for listing on the National Register. (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. The building could be reproduced at the current market rate per square foot for most single story residences. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the City. There are a number of houses of this approximate age and construction style in the Marina Historic District. However, HPB Meeting 5/17/95 McDonough, Demolition Page 2 most of these structures will be approaching fifty years of age within the next five to ten years, and eventually it will be necessary to consider the impact of their demolition on the neighborhood. (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local history, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. This structure would not promote any of the above. (e) Whether there are definite plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the character of the surrounding area. The plans associated with COA 8-249 for the construction of a single family residence will not diminish the character of the area. STAFF COMMENTS If demolition approval is granted, staff recommends that the demolition permit and building permit be issued simultaneously. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1. Deny COA 8-249 to allow the demolition of a noncontributing building based on a failure to made positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(F) (1) 2 . Approve COA 8-249 to allow the demolition of a noncontributing building based on positive findings to Section 4 .5. 1(F) ( 1) . 3 . Approve COA 8-249 to allow the demolition of a noncontributing building based on positive findings to Section 4 .5. 1(F) ( 1) , with the following condition: That the demolition permit and building permit for the new construction be issued simultaneously. RECOMMENDED ACTION 1. Approve COA 8-249 to allow the demolition of a noncontributing building based on positive findings to Section 4 .5 . 1(F) ( 1) , with the following condition: That the demolition permit and building permit for the new construction be issued simultaneously. file/y:coa8-249 ... • 1 `.... -4* • .4744,r-;?.;•,- .•• . •''''''''''• ;,;;,,•,•••.:.,: , ... _‘::•;:;,,,:.,..., . ,,,..:,,, i. ,,...;:,.,..,...:,,,4i....„..•.:.•,:...:,',..•;',..,....,....,.....04........--. .4:;,,;(1.4,il'. 4,5...."':"i71,,oz.:,,C....:1:•:.'.,,s'l.::::e.:11.16::::...L..;;;,.• -•!..,S.-f•'•5... • . '..•••••::,',_,'•'..,..;;-,:>,,,,_-1 •-f-4- •',• • . i..-.„.. .:•,.... • •.— -!.;:fe-•,....• 2 ...?,•;',...e,‘.)....,z , - .I •,‘ -• --,;1- .,, , • :lc'_a-,zi.-_-,. . , ... • '....'.f.lee..;;;.:.:....e.'-"- ,•,. r t , 1— :v,•-.!...4 .,'.• _ 1 . .,.,.., ---,— -. - ? . • --1: - '- . ':::••';' . .,••,,r1.--7:7-.•'.•7:--:*. r'. • -. •• - -••: -.... • ---•-• •, ...., • .!il)•.' • •.',.3-...,..•-••••j!.1,•`-, • • . .-. ..I I ,t ,.• : .%. ,:.:::.:*•' . ---- . '- . .. . --. ,• ....iiir..rt, . ;- i;t - • . -- ••••`.` ,''i...7.4-•.-e.,74.-,t,'..)'i 1."'• '1 .-'s.-__,...„.,=0"'4.••••- : ,„.. . . . . . • , . Y.i:i.., ... • .. ,.. .. . __ _ _ . ...•• ••4• •/C..5. ..4.' . . - ' • . ..' 4'. ....X' -.... ..... .• • ....'iU', • • . . - , .. . ..:.-...--. .... - ....., . •'. •- • --. . '''' • ,.. . . .. . . , . .. .eoll• ,..,I • '- ..-. :-.,,v..,.•'''.. . 4,ri. •.,,>:•:,. -7.44..,:.•,. .... \ - .. : .:,...-. „§ 1, . • - _I . _ ., • _ .... _ . -, s — . ,--: --. --F:.-114.,i. •., . • • ''.'''--.. -- 4',..'....... ..- ? . • ', ), . '--.' v..-.' :,-- , •... ...:‘,••"' ; 4:. .. ' .., . . :''',:..',-i;i4.1ji.1-''1;.:r: . :.... "'' ' . .,'..."'!.!,•11r r''''.:'''' i f..... . • . . . ' ' -;„,4 . ...., ',..4. ,..'" ,s,,,,,•x,..:•• ,,,„-:,-•:., ,,..,. „' . • ::r,:•,..,,,„--•••„,.-..„,„;,.,,,, ,„ ,ot• .. • .1 -, w.•';•e•-• .•..1. ot?... . ,Jo'.:, ..1 . , 1 • •,"... •• •••••% i!... •••. • — .: • . ,,:. '--...;:,4-•-•,-.r-.....- ,,,..•..., :,..,..,,7,4........„,,,,:.,_ ..:•-•-:, •••• ,-- 1,0. .(i. :-s - - ,),:k.:,..:..„. 5-..-:-;=-'...2„:.-•,•,' • :, ••-- „ ,•:,:-:%•;,....-,-.,:•-•:.: .,I.A..:•,.,.... .J., , •:.! Ct.',::'.• rt'' 1'7':1'':'.-.::' s.-:;.:.;'7'•• -'::"• •;-:'-:•if:;;.:;•::•:. . P'• ...' . . IVA': '''''•----• • ' s?,... ‘...... . -,. • . ',.ti''!1 . . 1 • . . .. .•• • i'40 .,,,' ..' . ., ,.i e • ! . , .• . . rttig4 . . ' I :,. . : . .• .. -Al • • . . • . • .'.4,.,,,,—.‘,,,a. .V.4....r................ •. it s.t•F • . , . . t •. s i , ... . . ' ,• ..,-. • s.,•,.1.! • ' . '''..--•..• : . '::'„'i.:.. • .,..;.:14 • :. -.-7'-'......-%:-•tr." . • - .' .4.4'. -.'" • ••••',. ',' . • . •-• ' I . . •.•? ••,.! • ••....•.•:. " .. • ..... :•-,-,----...-.., . . ,,.. ''.:':': . .. -.•..— . - .. • ; . . ..,, . .. !...,,,,,,c7:...,..> ,..-:-.. ...-: .' •:::::.......s,-,,,,--....,,,.-.r.EAF, .:, .. . ., - -• :-..- -•-.--..:.,.....•...: - •-•,........4.:- ....,.--.'..,..-:,;-•••• -,-..---..t.ci.,-:-.::•• :-..,..,-....i -... • Y.; . . . , - - '.---:-. • • mor.a...,..1., ••• ••,..1.....Q. 1 — ,.....k.- . STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING MAY 17, 1995 AGENDA ITEM III-B COA 8-250 345 S.E. 7TH AVENUE NEW CONSTRUCTION, SINGLE FAMILY HOME MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT MR & MRS WILLIAM C. McDONOUGH, OWNERS ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of granting approval of COA 8-250 to allow construction of a single family residence. BACKGROUND The proposed structure is a one story single family residence of 2265 s. f. excluding garage, patio and porch. It is of cement block construction with a stucco finish. The windows are to be aluminum double or single hung with muntins, and will have a white factory finish. Exterior doors are to be wood; the front door solid with raised panels, the others are to be glass with muntins . The roof is to be asphalt shingle, a sample will be available at the meeting. The exterior shutters are to be operable. The front facade has a 21' x 6 ' porch with a wood railing and three wood support columns. The driveway and walkway are to be paver block. The exterior paint color is to be pale gray, the front door and shutters are to be colonial blue, the porch posts and railing will be white. Color samples will be available at the meeting. A new swimming pool will be installed in the rear (Intracoastal) yard. The swimming pool requires that fencing be installed. A chain link fence is proposed for the side property lines, a cocoplum hedge will be planted inside the fence. The height of the fence is not specified. The north fence will be set back 45 ' from the front property line and the south fence will be set back 83 ' from the front property line; the chain link fence does not negatively impact the streetscape. A decorative wood fence and gate will connect the fence to the house on both the north and south sides. The landscape plan has been reviewed by Nancy Davila, City Horticulturist, and will require some modification in order to comply with the minimum standards for single family new construction. A copy of her comments are attached to this report and her sketch revisions to the plan will be available at the meeting. ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT This project is consistent with Section 4 .5 . 1 . (E) (8) Development Standards, and with the Design Guidelines with respect to new construction in historic districts . HPB Meeting 5/17/95 McDonough, New Construction Page 2 It would be preferable to have a side loading garage, however this would require a major modification to the design of the house. As nothing in the Development Standards prohibits front loading garages when the project otherwise conforms to the stated criteria, it is appropriate to make positive findings to the Section 4 . 5 . 1 (E) ( 8) . Staff recommends that the height of the chain link fence be limited to 4 ' so as not to block the adjoining properties ' views of the of the Intracoastal; and that the fence be black or green vinyl coated. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1 . Continue with direction. 2 . Deny COA 8-250 based on a failure to made positive findings to Section 4 . 5 . 1(E) (8) . 3 . Approve COA 8-250 based on positive findings to Section 4 . 5 . 1 (E) ( 8) , with the following conditions, That the final landscape plans be approved by the City Horticulturist, and That the chain link fence be 4 ' in height and be vinyl coated. RECOMMENDED ACTION 2 . Approve COA 8-250 based on positive findings to Section 4 . 5 . 1 (E) ( 8) , with the following conditions ; * That the final landscape plans be approved by the City Horticulturist, and * That the chain link fence be 4 ' in height and vinyl coated. S� � � - '��c: t...4 k 3` \TA SW c_cDc- u 4 cJ` w file/y:mcdonugh Memo From ' NANCY DAVILA Horticulturist/Special Projects Coordinator COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT To: Pat Cayce Date: 5-10-95 Re: 345 S.E. 7th Avenue - Landscape_ Plan 1. The sod proposed on the left side of the front entry needs to be deleted and replaced.with ground covers to comply with xeriscape principles. This is very important, later, when the irrigation system is r designed so that shrubs and ground.: covers are zoned " v separately from turf areas. 2. Per the calculation sheet provided, it is indicated that 1,538 s.f. of shrubs and ground covers are required and that 7,691 s.f. are provided. Sod is not considered a ground cover for the purposes of these calculations. By my calculations, only 1,012 s.f. of shrubs and ground covers have been provided. Plans need to be revised to provide an additional 526 s.f. of shrubs and ground covers. Suggest additional foundation plantings along the south side of the house and enlarging the planting bed in the front of the house along the south side of the entry walk. An area to encompass the Oak tree by the street would also help to meet requirements. This square footage can also be accommodated in-the back yard which might enhance their enjoyment of the pool area if done in a way as not to interfere with the intracoastal view. 1y NOTES': t\ I 04.30 " = EI:EVATION BASED ON NATIONAL 41 .j / . , i, II GEODETIC VERTICAL DATUM • 1019 ,>ddO -7'/.1'0�/ '• BENCH MARK SOURCE: STATE 1 G)��/CQG/l ROAD DEPARTMENT BENCH MARK AT ATLANTIC AVENUE & THE LET ?O' 1� 'y1O'�U'N.'*�� ` \ INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY Ni- 1 ) /33. 45. •*'PC537o7 1 ".,}. FLOOD ZONE: AE EL 8 pal / Ckl 4 \ /•4/AA)41: /s;d/' ,dJr. \ '< \ n\'l DESCRIPTION: t\ :-,7c a r.:-o ' ( ;/ THE SOUTH TO FEET OF BLOCK 128, TOWN OP * 3 O �t� `Q I I NJ LINTON (NOW DELRAY), AS RECORDED IN PLAT • t\• / `^ V �1 O BOOK I, PAGE 3 OP Tll¢ PUBLIC RECORDS OF ,• ✓ V1 ,�� / J// /S/ % M �� r' 4 PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, LYING WEST — 1 '� '^t•) `.) 0 � / OF THE RIGHT OF WAY OF THE INTRACOASTAL `. WATERWAY StIOtIN IN PLAT DOOR IT ON PAGE O • • Q �, I80, AND LESS TIlE HEST 20 FEET TITER EDP, TOGETHER WITH 25 FOOT RIGHT OF WAY • 0: / ABANDONED BY CITY OF DELRAY BEACH • / Q! RESOLUTION NO. J-95, RECORDED IN -4 ✓/I//7 ) ✓____. OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 8687, PAGES 1000, �! — V C/,t/f9� (I I 1010 AND 1011 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF , -� — i soar,;/�/.df>,�,ae✓ear/�9 _�/ �4AW/0,5 • \ /./1 / PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. D �" ¢"/ c cv °OD13 -- —- o . ?3 ,7 • l\ I30UNDARYSURVBY ,_..,_.-/!l\‘.:.k,__ :QEE> m -_ ._' ------ —',iB=oPAida>Eooe--_z_ // FOR r✓C0 ` t\ \ f i N. BILL,lfcDONOUGII• 1y / /,,e,x/ DO r Fv///D 5/- y I I I HEREOY CERTIFY that this survey wee made under my responsible chars,. \ and meets the Minimum Technical standards ee set forth by the Florid* r//TY/!'ao 25',Pia/1r oFu/A✓ /'Q///.?>O \ ��\ Board of Professional Surveyors and nmpere In Cnapt., 61017-f, Florida 1:j !.1/D,(/(/,�JBf.Q ' • Seminlstretly.Cod.. pursuant to Section 412.021, Florid. statute,. \ • �'L.3 353 Aa,o voo,./d a y C/ry dr a.lny net ,, Q \ DF OEG-iP/eE,¢t'// \ k p rill Id .Itnouc .n i[ X���r Q .PESoaU7/D,d /t/o. 3-95 v cp emh.e,ed ,eel. C ` EAOW///c k/c-r644/0 OFF/C/AG /QECo•e.o `I,�C ,. e3o'.f'�G92-, ,zflacs/OD99 `` ''' I!/?/EYO/1 39Z'- • /O/O G /D// S ` GlgIE10, S IITER G'6RIE � II G.. • i/— /N ; / /-, ..) /- /-/ , -, ;,•. . . ENGINEERS,. SURVEYORS. LAND' PLANNERS /�/ ,/�� ,GJ�) "-/ // i /^ // / /---. � ;.• • • 2601 NORTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY, DELRAY BEACH. FLORIDA /- /_ /7 / /l/ /i /-//7 C._ G_. o.,I: el.ab+1 ,c,u: /,/..�D. ' AP,P/L • /1/99S o YRIG�i"199:3Y 03:7!S!l :U7T_R a 03R.'£ti, .WG. o.ae.o.:9¢-d7d MID sOUV oa.-a s60 •/4,r