Loading...
HPB 11-01-1995 - DELRAY BEACH AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: November 1, 1995 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: 1st Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I. CALL TO ORDER II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES October 18, 1995 III. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. Pre-Application COA 8-265; Parking Lot Associated with the Redevlopmentof Block 76; Presented by Jeff Costello, Senior Planner. Preliminary review of the site plan and landscape plan for a parking lot in Block 76 which is being developed by the CRA. B. COA 8-264; 721 N. Swinton Avenue; Del-Ida Park Historic District; Douglas Mackiewicz, Owner. Replace front window with a bay window and enlarge front entrance porch. Replace window on rear elevation. ;.. _ HPB Meeting November 1, 1995 Page 2 C. COA 8-263; 203 Dixie Boulevard; Del-Ida Park Historic District; Shane Ames, Owner. Renovation associated with the conversion of a contributing property to an architect's office. V DISCUSSION AND ACTIONS ITEMS VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS A. Reports form Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VII. ADJOURN Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Planner POSTED ON: October 26, 1995 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DATE: NOVEMBER 1, 1995 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I. ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairman at 6:00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Vaughan, Buck Miller, Julie Morgan, John Johnson, Debora Turner, Pat Healy-Golembe MEMBERS ABSENT: Vera Farrington STAFF PRESENT: Pat Cayce, Jeff Costello, Diana Mund II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The Minutes for the Regular Meeting of October 18, 1995 were before the Board for consideration. Ms. Turner moved to approve the Minutes as presented. The motion was seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed by a vote of 6-0. III. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: None IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-265-Pre-Application: Parking Lost Associated with the Redevelopment of Block 76; Chris Brown & Ron Hoggard, Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA), Applicant; Presented by Jeff Costello, Senior Planner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of direction on a pre-application basis for the site plan and landscape plan for a parking lot in Block 76 which is being developed by the CRA. The Board felt the sidewalk should have paver block bands with stamped concrete. B. COA 8-264: 721 N. Swinton Avenue; Del-Ida Park Historic District; Douglas MacKiewicz, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA for the modification of the front entry porch, construction of a bay window with glass blocks associated with the front porch, and replacement of a window with glass blocks on the side (north) elevation. It was moved by Ms. Golembe, seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed 6-0 to continue COA 8-264 to a future meeting for the following reasons: • Bay Window and Porch Expansion: The Board members were unable to determine from the applicant's elevation how the bay window with glass block would relate to the balance of the front elevation. They expressed concern with how the superimposed mullions would be constructed and affixed to the glass block, and they were unable to determine the height of the bay window sill. The style and dimension of the porch supports was not specified on the plan and they felt that this would greatly affect the design of the expanded porch. • Window Replacement for the North Elevation: The Board felt that the elevations of the north wall would be needed before glass block replacement windows could be approved. The Board requested that the applicant return with scaled elevations representing all the proposed alterations. Additionally, the applicant was asked to provide detailed drawings for the applied mullions for the glass block and for the new porch supports. C. COA 8-263: 203 Dixie Boulevard; Del-Ida Park Historic District; Shane Ames, Owner. Item Before the Board: The action requested of the Board is that of approving a COA to allow the renovation of a contributing building associated with the conversion of the property to an architect's office. It was moved by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Morgan and passed 4-2 (Ms. Golembe & Mr. Miller dissenting) to approve the revised plans dated October 26, 1995 for COA 8-263 as presented based upon positive findings with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8), and the Design Guidelines, with the required exterior fire stairs which are not indicated on the revised elevations, as well as the exterior paint colors to be reviewed when the project comes to the Board for site plan review. -2- 11/01/95 V. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: None VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None B. Board Members The Board felt the LDRs should be revised to require elevations as part of the submittal for COA approval. Ms. Cayce suggested the Board look at that section of the LDRs and they would discuss it at their next meeting. C. Staff None VII. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Ms. Turner moved to adjourn the meeting at 8:25 P.M., seconded by Mr. Miller and passed 6-0. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for November 1, 1995, which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on November 15, 1995. Diana Mund If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. -3- 11/01/95 MEMORANDUM HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING NOVEMBER 1, 1995 AGENDA ITEM IV-A Pre-application- COA 8-265 Parking Lot in Block 76, Old School Square Historic District OSSHAD Zoning District CRA Redevelopment Program The proposed parking lot is on the site of the old Pierce Tire complex in Block 76. Only the western portion of the parking lot lies within the Old School Square Historic District, however the planning staff has requested that the plans be reviewed solely by the HPB as opposed to a dual review with SPRAB. This item will come to the Board for a formal review on November 15, 1995. The purpose of the pre-application presentation is to allow the Board to review and make comments so that any concerns you have may be addressed on the plans for the formal review. In order for the parking lot's construction stay on schedule it is necessary for the plans to be approved at the November 15th HPB meeting. Senior Planner, Jeff Costello, will have full scale plans and will discuss the project at the meeting. file/coa265pa .ul. se9.a•20.[13s00•. / — -- l I O 1 r:• FUTURE T 9 Nr` PARKING LOT WW a,r NOT IN CONTRACT r y —_—_� I••• il i i 6 a.mur •• 11 1 1 1 1 1 Li 1 1 1 1 I el i 1:: sc ItsI 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 III ----1 • : r IL_1_J_ 1- 11 _I r_.L_L I 00.OW ,L 1 ____i l:} LL II i I 1 I I I 1 11 i _ ^__I ::: ZNero)'20'N 12s.OT r III11I1fII 1II I -.-u•arm -b... I (7�'t arm u r �'/ ` Q earl K Iowa .. maw4.11410 {,[l .rmur 1 rrlmaur I rule tr armor r _ ^ z I I f I i1 + t: o• CV Z i , . !.. . L.. UJ j _ i I I I 1I { ....... ,_c_ ... a - c • I I. arlo:ur I rrmur 'Icr{ tcrl aarlmur l r I r. . E 1 1 1 I Ii r ,(_ • armor _ �tar� (W crl II Sue ur 1 I^I arnmur I 1 = ( o a ici s u t$ $ ".. is t. I�M�■�I� 1 0 •.:..." i ....................:..:.::.:.::..:..................... ....... ........................... ..... ................. ............................. .... ....... .. ...... ............. w •.. ... titW.::..:.....•'......... •� .........................•........ . ... ....................................... . .................. .............. U` = . L I- K K �. t � urmur ' 'i I rla 1(1 aram ac r ^� I CI trlmur .{ ^� _ I - _ t 66■ � I .:•:.$•'- 1 arm at - tar i i J ,` rr ..... I a caK _ �g I. a _� _ LLtT I kc y ` 1 ` ` I lI sr r If ar suq 1 •rs] 1 Z = n e o to r.f NOT INCLLDEO - . —i . ) ral z Ser5r2r E 12C 9r • I PIPN INC LOT aA'I Ng :., k I..; L__ 1 \k 1 '' I I Ie o 10 " ROT INttUOE0 O , —I— 3i L. o ` -- T� Tfr , ca or IIBr07.20'N In.00' maw Ii0r02'z0'Y 50.00' ,u r• i 70.W 9'07'2091 li 00- _ ALLEY 0 SITE PI AN r CRA PARKING LOT BLOCK 76 REDEVELOPMENT i „I .5,rr ::1•4 ,. ,/ •1 11). 01 I 1 l I I .I Is,i. I I I •Is1l ` .r, ' , , :l . ., : t. ... .. _ . . . +:: • .ir:...::u +, 1p' • tL •S tt .}Lt A .FL1 • ~' •t 1 ►•,< �.c':/ ,of • __ % .t. • I Z f S 9J°1 6 B B/ LI 91 S/ a f! tr.vc, r. o> i ����� (<.1 . ..SC/ ' �i� SL C g•!,....7 WC/ rcr •i • „•':':!::;ir.•.;::..a,`''r ts, 4P - :,.;. --�z ;,�r L y I \11 9 _ 2/ 9 J - '.�;,r: . " ' ZI a• .� lZ :•�._,: ' f z -cc' + 9 ' I e 1 '•s ` a ..A . / 9 , • 11 ... rl _ o o /. NI ,� £ .,,,, ...... ge :. . • • • .• ... . . . .. , /I _:..... 1.• v.s.,•,,z.: • .. G 7/ f?� S " ;DI;�: 't�!II • c� ..;•. 01. '` b a OI y 'c z�' :[ F/ . Milla t 6 •-! 1 6 . P• l c, 1�r; b 5 '' r 9 Z r 1 . .8 a .. ` 0! i.,9 z •i r SSwa•g . S/, 1•• • '.s C1 st 09 " rt•1 pr '9:I j j 7� v .. �'�.t 2/ 6/• y d'/ , ,l •�9 C l.,.' 'i�`ou ~' f. •u�P>'N•. • • nt•I �.a •c. I .)i, �' , ,••i, ' .SU •. " -,0-' .rir ,1nY •7 re/ , CY .71lr ;NI C x •7Jrl ,)m x.0! •)t'! .J'" .7sr/4 •c•'.7t!/r, '' .•.•`.,.. . . i r,��: S/ p a 9/ •G. a a 9/ • 9 C� 9/ 9 �; y 9/ 8 w ti .9/.• 'i.9 ti ,• ^�, •'8:i 9�.lt -4' s`{ ;' ` vim. n..,,; `� S/ L + • S/ L • , S, L • • Sl L ' ' Si L Sl 'L '. . Sl .[ •, ). • %' �' 9 _{; S i --- __ __._•, _ .. •• �.'_:__ 9,,, +;: % ^ ; o,'l6 • P/ 9 ' ' r/ 9 • 0/ 9 , , b/ • 9 ' • b/ 9 , 6/ .9 • t/ _ _ —,,T, ;t- LI S 'i S E! S • •-Li 9 F/_ .. Li S t o , £l S ' • CI . S .' 61 £9 f^L/ •_ _ _ +" ,r!rt' Z/ 7 , , Z/ P •• 7 2/ �,.,•;---: b . y • Zl l .✓ Y , o'/^ ^y J 2/ 6 £ r n '�l .� i J9 ?'@ c' ' . —..-_. ..-._ .. "� --�"ta // ^� S `--. ' // C • ' // £ . • // 6 • • // F , • // ^F•' // F • •`• /l —1 .1 . D! 11 - 17 ;I) . o/ Z •• at Z • , of 2 • ' 0/ Z • I- of ~.Z ' 0/ 2 ► S Di Z ' I. f/ r i a ,C, �I•• e a tX r6 / o of 6 / / ? 6 / ' k 6 / >, x 6f()) ` . — — ___ � / k ti 6 / h asp L / i •'I...^ N •4 Jr. N rr ' ,', ,r. ," 4 . i , t. '• •Y ,.r. •.r,'' ,y 11 •:r• ••Y '• Y •t N 1 r•• �Z .rf 111[r, ' -•r, '7 x ON Z1. '.7 w t' '` ''ON Z '" ''.(N N 1' ,,....3 • +r, ,t J f, :, .uo• iJ ti• l`I' Al••.• ° CS I•r. t;r, 4':r ••„ ;'J , /• r• • , / rr ti Ft( 7.Z .7 r•', Cr , 's 1/ !rr rr Jrr .�+ .✓!(' ./'' ., 1f `�-1 ~- r/rr 1tII _�� _f/ _a Z/ -- / f •�/ //^ s( r !� ZI y • !CI //' // 'I r/ // ;n p/ lv „i 1 r.. ti I PI )•,' __el. 6/ i' a ,�,, ;; • 1 _ =I ^ CI jl . C/ ' r ^ ' _ 0/ S/ •• 01 -Sl '• P0/ - 0 �/ N ',� — - tl., ' zr . �' g— _ [' . 6 ^�y'a • 9 'el/ • • .9 3 L/ • •8,^ ° ry!• ^9 6 N r/ .Q�': 'I L 9/ L L Sl L • ' L !1/ • L I ^ 0/ , L.,• ' j I S/ _ o c' G c7 . (r 1C g • C/ '•� 9 • 8. 6/ • i 6/ • • 9,: P n° t��'q y L�k9d 4/ —� - ct S o1 S f/ , S S zOZ • S a OZ S•,•• y h. g •* 9 LI 81 ,-• It P Ii r Z/ �v, • C .".lZ • 6 /Z 6 •' ^t d C S II 8r • ZI f �' r t1 f !/ j .- T: 6l 9 F ZZ • r f ZZ Y. f b� n Fr�tr c1 t_- :,^ fZ Z Yi v fI z t' of b Z FZ C Z a 1., r .t • 1 z • -r.r • r — _ Z 2 }, -' •� t/ ,2 T /Z C [tr t---7-— P S, // o S•$.1 •/ r G li / ri . / 6Z to a / ♦` ,7�Z +. •YI , rr,1N of or °1 M' "t •zr :714 2:1 / c; ., rr' f1• •r• .r. .•Tr •Yr . r., • t/ (, CY ,�'' .7hC/ ,.Y •i� 7d GL£1-C,"+ N � ^, « YS f« OAF r,r •,. „ �� • .l: „ 'S '•q; .'E/ .tZ/ F. St .,1! .�, yZi�%{' •7��• _. gyp'/ ; ,�Pr 1�l •,.r, '�r�r,•d•.rr �S'• Lt / '•' r r i`~ `Z ;„ 9/ El •, 77 // Ci ' 1L Z • '' 9i t/ h ti 'b 9/ 17 r .e F! _9/ ,: ' tl , • 6/ 6 ' -. c [I Zi 9t F • �(LI Z/ A . L%� �, Z•%. ;� 2/ L/ b a�. r• , Z/ • 8/ �'& " `/•--.. • s< is o/ • 1 __ _ u _ r-;; • 6/ II • a - • SZ t • •9(b/) � // • Z • 8/ " I/ • . I/© _6I • 4 S1 x • /r • L/ L • >. • �'_._.. �! -.9' , ' Cl :poi±, 91 6 �)' • re S '0(6/) . of•' . 6/ 0/ • • 0/ — 6/ • 1t , • a , f • 9/ '.9 ' c u GI STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING NOVEMBER 1, 1995 AGENDA ITEM IV-B COA 8-264 721 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Noncontributing Single Family Residence Douglas Mackiewicz, Owner ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA 8-264 to allow modifications to the front entry porch; construction of a bay window associated with the front porch; and replacement of*a window on the side (north) elevation. ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT This single story c.b.s house was constructed in 1956. It has a plain front facade with a roof projection over the front door and adjoining aluminum awning double windows. The existing concrete front stoop slab is approximately 5' long . The applicant is proposing to extend the slab for the length of the roof overhang. He will remove the existing aluminum roof supports and replace them with wood columns. The double awning windows are to be replaced with a bay window. The bay will not be cantilevered but will have a concrete block foundation to the height of the sill and will be plastered to match the house. Instead of glass panes the applicant is proposing to install glass block in the bay window. The side (north) window is glass jalousie and the applicant is proposing to replace it with the same glass block as those used in the bay window. STAFF COMMENTS The bay window, slab extension and wood post roof supports will enhance the plain exterior of the front elevation. However, staff feels there is a design conflict with the combination of a bay window and glass block. Bay windows are an element in Colonial Revival design, while glass block is more closely associated with Streamlined or Art Moderne style of the 1930s and 40s. The applicant states that this is a new form of glass block, which when seen from a short distance, gives the appearance of clear panes. He plans to install wood mullions to simulate a traditional bay window. COA 8-264 HPB Meeting 11/1/95 Page 2 Staff is unfamiliar with the type of glass block being proposed. Perhaps the Board members have seen it installed and could comment on its suitability for a bay window. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1. Deny, based upon a failure to make positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8). 2. Approve based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), with the condition that standard glass panes be installed in the bay window. 3. Approve as presented based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8). RECOMMENDED ACTION 1. Approve as presented based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), providing that the Board members are satisfied that the new style of glass blocks will be compatible with a bay window. file coa264sr • i \�� �N� ._��Ao�Wits— {._ � k *All ji, w 1 f t-y ..«: '+i. ;ram a,. t:!+^F`5;: • • .ht... • ttt!:,_ •jrrr'iksfi:.".r.•FY,jl).•,t,•.• _ ,• �, R�" ,.�', `-r11 4'. :s(# )IQ y• rta't'1, •a•-Al J_w '•' ,. �; e�f.+s4��� �.,� �`,. re, --'-.,•.t.---_:::-.5_::::::--_-:-_,, • �..•.4.5'--r'. _spe• ► r.'r .i z 't:.� _ ..— .a<x ` .4 oa v'.,.- J I. o f;}F�I arm r - +1'a"_i .J 'J 1n�4 -!.' � • " , 7. ;!�-�, .__� a}) a.- .1.: ' l• 1 t 1 'III -t ..�. I .•4 > > _r. �" • r te s.'-�'c ' yj't! �••fv� ?'-: asc. — �Z`•t, f .vw ilui 1471:y' F!', A Y _ • 0 r • /Doze, SZ48 To z-XTENO 7 -e, EiCT .� So,44 T ,6i9Y tif4 i ev 7-0 ,46,94.A' ,Oov. . �..c - srJ-�r- • • • t3.^J 1 i 1 .. • J r:..y,Jr .4;f,a..14 .01.ifirl }i • c+ f... • +aj4J.r, 'f g• + )+t,a• V.,47 Via.•. ?:iriy.��. {Xv '� 7rt.i(�'a{:��%���c�:'t� j:ir i. k s9� li , ;., \ a � L./ Oar . , ` j i b �� fI • • 3 Al):):,,..;\ I. .. ' -•..1, .b .''' ..q-• . .,:-.,...,.,- • - c.; i 11 1 \ Z._N ' /. •• • ,'/iS�0,47S' /D is -�Ei°.l 6Q l�tl I7-.V GcJO40 /��►S • • C/i9E 0/4h Dau) . ., .,___ . ,,-..-•••-•-•*::-'--4.--y•--"-...---,----....-....,---- 77.:_.::::::,.-.!--........Z.7-...- -:::::-....;.'.'.:.:7:":"'.','''. -••:• -.-- • • 7 ( N .:-. . .. i 1. , . s WI NT 0 . NJ , , , i • _.. , . 1 i , . I 45Tiffl i . ro, r . lAtAt-l< • . \ . • . • . . .... . : 1 . . .....; • - - , • • • /2o F-L/Nr: a! ..... 1 6r nv ! / k;,..6401?: tr,vorioir, . .0! i i 1 • I / '. • ' / . ! ! 0 t- ... • .. i . 1 , . . . • . • . t , , . 1, . • /1. ... .. , ... . 1-.-_2::. 1=4: -. .;..- .- .r :. 1 . 1. • ...... -. .. 1.' .1 7 '. /, . //7,/4:' ' 1 . 1 , 1-- , .1 • . . , . • , • • • • .. .. . . . ' ...•. • . . . - • ,.. •,. • ... . .. . ... . .•• .•. • e . . ... • -, ., . ' - . . ...-... ... . •.•-•••,• .. . . . .......,• . '• ',..,` . . • .•!.....:'• . . ..... . ....... . . '.':''. •: . r., ... • • i •'.' '., r..• '.' ..• ','.'. .:•• • . . .. . . . .. , . ... . ••. . • . Y. - • • .. . . ••:•::•' . • • . . ... . .• .... . t.a. . . • .0,:. ..• . .. . . .. •.. . .. • . :7.;:u..:. .. .. . : . . .. . .s. . . , . I I I • • i ! .- . I : . -.: 1 I I • ; I : . I I j I I I . . . .. -1 --1-- I I I i i : • , 7 7.... i ; . 1 vf/ / m 7- (5 A/ 1 1 . • i . 1 . : i . , , . . . , ,. . . , ,. ., , , .i I ! . I . , I I • • I I . I ; ! .•1 I I 1 ! . .! 1 I I I I 1 I I I : i 1 I I I I • , ; ! i : 1 I 1 i I 1 1 . • 1 I I 1 i I - . I 1 li i I I I 1 ... 1 . ...-.........1 ' w.... • 1 • ' I 1 I ^ : 11 • ....._.....•-.... .., . . I , I I .--_. . . 1 I 1, 1 I I -.-- r"--•-, . ' . : „_-.- ...... 1 1 , 1 . . .—....-.. ----.... ,......---.. .----, I . I I •. - . ' . .,,,......e... ... , ..; - . I . . -—.... ............. I I . — ...... II m•i I ... ..-... ---. •..................., I ...--...... i 1 t 4 ; I I .....---•• ...-..-.. o , 0 I I I • t • • 1 4 , .4. I I , 1 : . I I 1 1 I 1 1 . t t• , 1 0 • ; . I I I I I II I I I II Ili I : • 1, I ; ..1 . I I I I . :;immapic I 3.8.1.110 1 . ' ; I I I I f I ' , 1.761.' I I . . . 111111f l 1 (1 ft Iii11 [ 111, ( 11 li ili littif i 1111 ( 1)1 ) ill 1 ., Lir( . , I I. • . . . V1, ',E vi , R. . F 0 ril '', I • . , . 1 1 : . , si -T- g. 11 . ,IE ''..-7-- • i , ., 1 I I 1 i . . , , , i • y B A Y W • I : N D O • W -eivers1—%.::.. - :� # G THE INTERIOR -`— -- •ctrical wires for outlets or .;x�.- ,,0� tly pack strips of fiberglass •etween the window frames - ;. .1. :11 framework.Add insulation ill• •i .. t � te 3- ' _ '. ,l --_..:-T:-+` z•: • ■`I • .�.. •- ,....• , �a Tam ` Y.- ... . . . r-. wo•t;: j it f =d� E r : [, • 1 ..v -e•fi wF�i � r+," t. - • .. I r. R i Jiy. . • •'lec.L. _ -• ••y. .. ' fir E. ,4.i k _ 1 it ; .;4 •1' • " x I DRYWALh •' • II I INSULATION t� g� r, �� s �. •• � k �- —AND VAPOR 3' — 11 N • s.• .II . ti:: . - -jf BARRIER '•.-3- ":: >. ",.- < -t ty yam•;-� . f � •I k# �'� Ih •i• ;,.,wry.x�•:,-% 5- ti,�.;,�. f.zi''��•.;,` • ' t `r on,vapor barrier and dry- • '+ r, �+ :z * c i•k insulation between the _ '.r. and house framework. i -~-- i ti w_ Y. 221/2' °lC:' k- -j%.,�1: _ END CUT ;j • ••e.' - - • _ -cam-t 77•t• - Ems'- k `F.:. ` '• a for trim boards once the • '►'.: ' `='r_ . �4 _ _ 'and sanded.Fill nail holes ' f�.• paint the trim and walls to .; • j� .",10.: • :'.. - • - - - . . - . - . roject. I between the wall studs,then staple a ! `.,`• plastic vapor barrier over the frame- 1 low do ,. 7.;j e�ia work.Nail drywall to the walls.then • V2 ' • �' is -. '•3 apply tape and joint compound (see o- ' �'• �i: z ti: ki, 'Drywall Perfection, April'J1.p.64). I you build an _ - I- ; : °' Apply interior window and baseboard ;; I; moldings,paint the walls and trim,then • addition withif t•- �: + extend your flooring into your new bay t.; - __-.1 . I _ . • window area. j no foundation? l`i �=•ti It's time to celebrate!You've finished : ; i : '; '�•+ i. i! one of the trickiest projects you'll ever Cantilever • , tarklLr. TFH ! . your floor— Art Direction•MIKE SMITH Photography•PHIL LEISENHEIMER,IA STUDIOS I ' ff';f'' J,t1;..', +.•••.•: Illustrations•RON CHAMBERLAIN like we did. c. .7.--T. ..7:.-, i =---- • ''••'-'•t7?c,�:!L;-= Consultants•OAVE MACDONAU),GARY MEICHEIS, - h' .yy4.f..:•''.• SUSAN MOORE,RICH SILL , — I fEBRUARY 199.1 THE FAMILY HANDYMAN 43 • I PC Glassblock®Patterns !. election THINLINE'"SERIES The family of PC GlassBlock®products incor- porates rectangular,square,hollow,solid,reflec- �_ir, tive,corner,finishing,paver,and customized +� t I i,le '� ' r "signature"block.There's a product for virtually ;; {I 1s �, ,� any glass block need...and product selection isi{ I ` _.. +,. „ i 4 ,4, F the key to attractive,efficient,functional designs 6 y+ , r t ; ' h �F .. The THINLINEm Series is specifically designed ' I ;_ ' `l < �\ , ' >+ 1 .. for applications of limited size and weight. } � �i 4 = r The REGULAR and PREMIERE Series offer e -----" — , b r•y;, the widest variety of sizes,shapes and patterns ' • I i,`.=. _.v?A, i i' %�,%../ 4.1 for the ultimate in design flexibility. CIRRUS®Pattern DECORA®Pattern DELPHI®Pattern Made in America Combination of the DECORA® With its distinctive wavy undu- Prismatic diamond design pattern and stippled texture on lations.Maximum light trans- offers maximum light trans- exterior face.Maximum light mission/subtle distortion. mission/highest privacy level • transmission/medium privacy. of product line. REGULAR SERIES - t i°6i�01° e � 'ate_'--'-.':-- �2uiIIiU , �� 4 'I uGvL�tJ,tr i. ;fl•:` r]. �i ''_- {- ` f--•,„7-. +# .: dal '4 w d t rnc;eec0e fat, : ,; /t > +"t=fE�t � 'I may; I 4Kf�B�S8E� (s� L: I,. ti t I _i1 i s If ( ! _ter r`�. 4t 7'- - f ,t :>�[:l iJt t-ii^� i`� �5'£ ,. --,,,r-ter ;:;ti i .�,,: `t.-,.....�_-t"=Y: t.:r .' I • ARGUS®Pattern DECORA®Pattern ESSEX®AA Pattern TEXTRA'"Pattern VUE®Pattern m�i1nded perpendicular flutes. With its distinctive wavy undu- A fine grid of closely spaced Gridded,subtle directional Smooth,undistorted faces $1=imum light transmission/ lations.Maximum light trans- ridges.Moderate light diffus- design.Maximum light trans- allow maximum light transmis- ::lium degree of privacy. mission/subtle distortion. ing/maximum privacy. mission/minimum privacy. sion and ultimate visibility. PREMIERE SERIES f,+tea {• --I-4 'w�-1;e r• �S"'� I 1 ` 1 jt sinuuiuuuun� I - x +? Ai; I ttiCCtittii{IIau ill. I} Z • t • # + c c+t s ,} 4' l'• w »-.« 1-' �" 11,I *i- + �r�r.�la :h,.S# __ ��.««II«L'iit««« � {:�� i� ..tilt ;.+ �Y W4. ,L µ- - u«euUt au= i 1 tI i• . '.--Pa 1?-.;- * 5 - ,uun,utltluuC .�- I1. .£ ) • I .' •u0uuu11Niuiiu {I I, i ` - •'�' • i 4 .,. .,.II + uuutuiiuinua ` ...1 J�I'I't-�� f DECORA®Pattern"LX"Filter SOLAR REFLECTIVE Glass THICKSET®Block, THICKSET®Block, VISTABRIK® Fibrous glass insert adds Block,DECORA®& ENDURA"Pattern VUE®Pattern Solid Glass Block .-. moderate thermal and light VUE®Patterns Ideal where thick-faced,heav- Modest distortion,thicker- With 3"of solid glass,high - characteristics.Maximum The highly reflective,thermally ier glass block is needed.Nar- faced block.Maximum light impact strength provides privacy. bonded oxide surface coating row flutes provide moderate transmission/good visibility. enhanced vandal resistance. for increased thermal „light transmission/maximum DECORA®Pattern also Excellent light transmis- characteristics. privacy. available. sion/good visibility. ''�', r I Ill�'� ° t.l ` tl .�t �'may'+4 �t3�/ �''' E i 0A0 ,t, Ili •, '5, [.,O. . ,!.Ix, iv:,-. .. t itt ttlik'''''' « :1 fa....J,-- • '. I- .., -,1 •- — It!! - '••••:-..: 4 Ft:,' _ ,_ I dBlock'"Finishing Units, TRIDRON 45° HEDRON®I Corner Block, Encurve'Finishing Unit, PC®Signature Block :111C0RA®Pattern Block®Units, DECORA®Pattern DECORA®Pattern PC®Signature block is custom- finishing horizontal or vertical DECORA®& Hexagonal corner unit allows With arched,soft edges to manufactured with your corporate !IV.es of interior panels.Two sizes VUE®Patterns you to form 90°corners round out your design logo or other design pressed into . , available for use with REGULAR or Create angles or resulting in a gently rounded options or finish panels.Use one or both inside surfaces of an THINLINE'"SERIES units. configurations continuous glass face.The with 8"x 8"EndBlock'" 8"-square REGULAR SERIES from 45-360°for block can be used in combi- Finishing Units for a stepped PC GlassBlock,unit. columns,alcoves, nation with any other finish- panel. t and undulating ing unit. panels. l' 1 ,0 • PC GlassBlock®Products Continued lel • 1111 Pattern Sizes Weight Heat Thermal Thermal Visible Shading Sound Impact Com- . Nominal/ (lbs/kg) Trans- Resis- Expan- Light Coet' Trans- Strength: pressive Actual mission: tance: sion Trans- mission (in-lbs) Strength (mm) U Value R Value Coef. mission: S.T.C. (psi) (Btu/hrft:°F) (hr ft:°F/Btu) (°F) (%) PREMIERE SERIES DECORA® 6"x6"x4"/53/4"x3:/8" 3.5/1.57 0.48 2.06 47x10'' 50-554 .45-.504 50-60 400-600 "LX"Filter (146mm,98mm) .. 8"x 8"x 4"/73/4"x 3:/e" 6/2.72 0.48 2.06 47 x 10'' 50-554 .45-.504 40 50-60 400-600 (197mm,98mm) 12`x12'x4'/113/4"x3%e 15.3/6.93 0.48 2.06 47x10' 50-554 .45-.504 50-60 400-600 • (299mm,98mm) 4"x8'x4"/33/4"x7/'x37/4' 3.5/1.59 0.48 2.06 47x 10' 50-554 .45-.504 50-60 400-600 (95 x 197mm,98mm) 6"x8'x4"/53/4'x73/4"x3/" 4.5/2.03 0.48 2.06 47x 10' 50-554 .45-.504 50-60 400-600 (146 x 197mm,98mm) SOLAR 1 REFLECTIVE 8"x 8"x 4"/73/4"x 37/e" 6/2.72 0.51 1.96 47 x 10'' 5-20 .20-.25 39 50-60 400-600 DECOR*& (197mm,98mm) VUE® THICKSET® BLOCK 8"x 8"x 4"/734"x 37/e" 10/4.56 0.51 1.96 47 x 10' 50-554 0.65 50 2500 DECOR*, (197mm,98mm) ENDURA"&VUE® VISTABRIK® 8"x 8"x 3"/7%'e,3" , Exceeds Solid Glass (194mm,76mm) 15/6.80 0.87 1.15 47 x 104 80 53 1508 80,000 Block 3"x 8"x 3"/3"x 73e" 6/2.72 0.87 1.15 47 x 10'' 80 Exceeds 80,000 (76 x 194mm,76mm) 1508 8"x8"x11h"/73'e",1:/z" 7.5/3.4 0.87 1.15 47x10' 80 Exceeds 80,000 (194mm,38mm) 1508 DELPHI® 6"x6"x 1"/6,1" PAVER UNIT (152 x 152 x 25mm) 2.8/1.27 47x10' FLAT SHEET GLASS COMPARISON 1.04 0.96 47 x 10' 90 1.00 FINISHING UNITS • EndBlock'Finishing Unit HEDRON®I Corner Unit TRIDRON 45°Block®Unit Encurve'Finishing Unit F ` 1 7:/4" Itv �, � ;• 70/'�" i 7°A" III 7°!i« tix, 't:p1�1_f t 1 i f I lt� ��! 3:b '�=;` 1 L III ; --� ,,�" V. t'- ".1 t~ 1-3 1/4- I i T- S:G" 3L' 3% L I L'�' II I . 3 7. F-7/a -I DECORA® DECORA®TL DECORA® DECORA®&VUE® DECORA® 8"High 8"High 6"High 8"High 8"High 8"High 6 lbs 2.72(kg) 2.8 lbs 1.26(kg) 4.3 lbs 1.95(kg) 6 lbs 2.72(kg) 3 lbs 1.36(kg) 5.1 lbs 2.3(kg) REGULAR SERIES THINLINE"'SERIES Can be used in BOTH SERIES REGULAR SERIES REGULAR SERIES EndBlock'Finishing Unit EndBlock'Finishing Unit HEDRON"I and TRIDRON 45°Block"Corner Units r , PL•FxPN�SC1l SNP �""'� JE . ,TAIDRON_•- ', 1 . • , 45°Blocky Unil%/rr[iiiii Encurve^ 01/ z. Finishing Unit - 00 slim."..0iiiIIiiI ( Y _•*Y • (r' ,_ . _,.. . k 2, DELHDA PARK ►— .R NE ---1 ----8 t h-- -— Sr----. -- t IS 1 1 24 R( •.. -,... .1‘.... ...., es • '04. ; S t 2 -x QP 41*4N k• NE 7th ST ` `r- • 1� �� i 1 t5 i • . lei 22 : 1 i6 :tO 1 Z 1 t : _.• ,%o421: 1 ,.1 s S .. 4 .Z R . n A� i t2 Y IL O � . c., • LAKE TERR -t `' i. i i . ` . 26 q . iO4 s•• c ' 'O 6% N; ; .. NI ..t: 1....: .i‘1440. % - i `.** tE. 14.*:j#12 p t- Pig' 't ' 0 i . . a i 14 :-.: -1* '0.. • • F- R . 7 20 tall 4,7 <)\-k-. ‘ 3 ! . AIL r tG,4�� S' ••• 1 !1 �� tlE 5th CT 1 . N •.• ,4 • ::! J:FA : j:%t*j •.. -d - -NE 5th 1ST -t • f •.• . , t..• > - - - > .? s t Z , +L :. . 1 S : f .., 4 l Q. ; = 4 3 i D - 7 lr. STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING NOVEMBER 1, 1995 AGENDA ITEM IV-C COA 8-263 Contributing Building 203 Dixie Boulevard; Del-Ida Park Historic Residential Office (R-0) Zoning District Shane Ames, Owner/Architect. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approval of COA 8-263 to allow the renovation of a contributing building associated with the conversion of the property to an architect's office. BACKGROUND The building was constructed as a single family residence in 1925 in the Mission Revival style. It has two stories; is of frame construction with a stucco finish; and rests on a concrete foundation. Additions have altered its original rectangular form and most of its decorative elements have been removed. However its original porch, though enclosed with metal jalousies; porte cochere and original front facade window openings, remain intact. The project came to the Board for a pre-application review at its meeting of October 18, 1995. The purpose of the pre-application presentation is to allow the Board to review and comment on the proposal and ask questions of the applicant. The plans were submitted on October 12, 1995 had had only a cursory review by the planning staff before the pre-application presentation. The applicant will convert the structure to an office for his architectural practice. The project requires a formal site plan review which will come to the board at a latter date. At the pre-application review the Board had the following comments, and direction to the applicant with respect to the exterior renovation. After reviewing the elevations the Board felt that the proposal was inconsistent with the Design Guidelines for the following reasons: Staff Report, COA 8-263 HPB Meeting, November 1, 1995 Page 2 The proposed architectural design elements are transforming the Mission style structure into a different style. The building is being dramatically changed to something it never was. The Mission style elements which should be enhanced are being overshadowed by the introduction of architectural elements of a different style; such as the abundant use of decorative moldings, balustrades and roof decorations. • The Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for rehabilitation state that the historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time, place and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or architectural elements from other styles shall not be undertaken. With respect to the front porch enclosure, which as proposed, no longer appears as a porch, but is incorporated into the front facade; • Original porch openings should be maintained preferably with transparent materials, i.e. screen, lattice, glass or in the Spanish style, screens with iron or wood grilles or rails. It is inappropriate to enclose a porch in a manner resulting in the loss of historic character. In reference to the proposed window location changes on the front elevation; • It is inappropriate to cut new openings or block in original windows. The Board reflected that the architectural embellishments appeared to be added for visual interest as opposed to preserving the structure's original Mission style and made the following recommendations to remedy the situation; • That the applicant review our Design Guidelines with respect to what is appropriate to the Mission style. • Architectural embellishments should be undertaken to enhance the Mission style rather than introducing other styles. • With respect to the changes to the front porch enclosure and the front elevation window locations, the Board suggested that they be undertaken in such a manner as to be consistent with the Design Guidelines. As a result of the pre-application review the applicant has presented revised plans for the exterior renovation. The revised plans are before you for your consideration. Staff Report, COA 8-263 HPB Meeting, November 1, 1995 Page 3 ANALYSIS OF THE REVISED PLANS • With the exception of the lower sills, all of the decorative Styrofoam molding around the windows has been removed. • The ornate balusters for the porch railings have been replaced with simple wood balusters and railings. • The pineapples have been removed from the parapet cap corners. • The center portion of the second floor roof parapet now has a Mission arch configuration. • The round window to the left of the front door has been replaced with a rectangular window. All of the above changes help to reinforce the Mission style. STAFF COMMENTS The changes mentioned above conform to the Mission style. However, the front facade remains inappropriate with respect to the Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. • The original front porch remains incorporated into the front elevation. • A new porch has been superimposed in front of the original porch. • The original shape of the Mission arches on the porch openings have been altered to a rounded arch. • Two of the original window openings have been altered to accommodate a false symmetry of massing. Asymmetry is a feature of the Mission style. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Due to incompatibility with the intent of the Design Guidelines, staff cannot support the enclosure of the original porch so that it becomes one with the front elevation. Nor, for the same reason, can staff support the new porch which has been superimposed in front of the original. To bring these elements into conformity with the Design Guidelines staff suggests the following: Staff Report, COA 8-263 HPB Meeting, November 1, 1995 Page 4 Porch • That all of the original porch openings be retained on all three sides and that the original arches for the openings be left intact. The porch may be enclosed with solid panes of glass, with wood grilles in front of the glass if desired. Or if operable windows are required, they should consist of casements without horizontal elements which follow the curve of the window. • A small barrel tile pent or shed style roof supported by wood brackets should shelter the front door. The new porch; roof; and railing should be eliminated. Window opening changes on the front elevation For the reason mentioned above staff cannot support the window location changes for the front facade. • Retain the window openings in their original locations. Comments on the balance of the project Because the remaining elevations have been altered by inappropriate additions staff can find reason to support the balance of the revised plans as presented. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1. Deny COA 8-263, based upon failure to make positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), and the Design Guidelines. ,ff2. Apppye COA 8-263 as presented based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), and the Design Guidelines. 3. Approve COA 8-263 based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), and the Design Guidelines with the following conditions: • That the original front porch be retained in a manner acceptable to the Board and appropriate to the Design Guidelines. • That the new front porch be eliminated. • That the original front facade window openings remain unaltered. Staff Report, COA 8-263 HPB Meeting, November 1, 1995 Page 5 RECOMMEND ACTION 1. Approve COA 8-263 based upon positive findings to Section 4.5.1(8), and the Design Guidelines with the following conditions: .. • That the original front porch be retained in a manner acceptable to the Board and appropriate to the Design Guidelines. • That the new front porch be eliminated. • That the original front facade window openings remain unaltered. file/coa263sr APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY -BEACH, FLORIDA 1.00 N.W. 1ST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444 The Historic Preservation Board meets on the first and third Wednesday of each month. This application must be filed 15 days prior to the next available meeting. Address of Property 203 N( 1 ', i 61.,uic7 Affix One Clear Picture L. . ♦ . w -. • •q)66.. . • ...• .N. .sir, n..,. .r. 'Jir:4!-'!.+�_c: �•..'_" l2U/ . -.-,'-',`......'...^*. r.•-r.„-•,,,,,•;11,- . ... ( ( ,. .. -- •, . . .- . -.--.---;.`;...--•: • • - ',11P!...,''. • 3=1-..i. II IR - .v •i • • Th ...,..:.1, --- . -..-,,,•-... ........4.,•,... _ Ani. . ,4 r• Alf--0 - -,. : I' ; • . . 1 1 Illio; . ... ,' •••..i'-' ' );,...,•-•'''t,, -. • , , — ee,. i - .-,- -i . . • ....,--..,..„,,_..-:• -:-"/ '' .....:"' i ,.1.!/ .‘„.1 v i,' - ,. .• • • • • • " . - .. •.-----i...,•.ii:,..., _:-..!-::. - . -• ---- 1-1'. ` r ..1)-4•.,- • ',4 - "*. r ..... • •' ' '... .....— . • .4... tt..:' ‘ ..• t IP ' . .. . . . . . — • ... . . _ a,. • • , • I. - . ................... ., 4. I . 'I ›.''',.„.. i . • • 1 1 I rli s : . •, ; •• : : ; . 1 ' 1 , • .., _ ---).., :--.•‘‘,. ' - - I I I I- -.. • . • ; .. ,,:t •,. - .---- -::...:.---t;::;;-, • . • . -..z ,. .;. , ,_ •••-----:-N__;=.. .... ..',:,, • , .. . '----- ' --•;/.:.. , -.. . 7 P.. .; , ,...., ... .. . • . . , . . •.„ - ..-7.• !,..r.,•••?., . . . , . . . . :„.••., -;,..,.,.. . _-. : ., ,.,•,,. - . . - ... • .- -• -- .. . • ...-- - --- - • . . - , - ;--..... . . • • • . . .. i 12d1a6/1 )2gxt • LE.r 7 IZE/071_, I 'If' ••• - ::'. ' ''..-. • .. . "-r' --. 1 _ • ' . • ...`..t. ''.."#/. . ..3,p; -t0•1 . ‘• - - • -- ,... •oie, .iiir, ,.,. . :-....,r., --to .. • ,,... ,.„.'ft% .164,01/, . : ...'.....' ...t.. • 11 '41, .". ".• ":- •• .-"--1g-:•• ...• .... 1..g - . -...• :..!:. ... ..:•,.;"" . .... . .", ,...•'•• .• s'`.— • .--,C.....4 1• • : , ‘• • 1:4.-;...1 I Iii••. t, . '• ....-.....ii '..:••. - . ..::: .*ee-1. . . • •i ' ..t..... 0.1' ••• :!. . . , .. . . ' • .. , . :;;/1•°. ' ' V' i le t " ... ..... , ',..e .• !, 1 1 ••'..!i I - i.', ' '' • - - • • • • • 1 • - -.''..•,ti.,....:, • , . . .., . . ,.. •1, ...-%. . ' . . ". • --•''!•;,...-,..., • *.,• : • 11'014i,: .#:.1'•.. ..- ,.. ,..1 . ., 0.1.PlegroriPel•14Niev.'" '".....v•1...- :4." ..' ..•. 1....r‘ '" - • Pil 0,0 b P>7-Al • • 4 '✓r(t�.`� l' .,ram 'r••.4 4 J. rn _ -'•1+` _ +' ,r's' 441032 ♦ '. i{i L•,`'' • s .,�yPu r yL,ti ma,y 44 '�.! f _ a., c - • �! -•••1 •-Ky! - ,• t. > - y i , ..w..,�-,tee , . •— • . "me•' °- yG \ ...t:. :.r'' . • • L%7 / `I ,u7 .• . • • ._, .:. , -1,, - 7100. . . . • sad-+ .• l • •� .. �• ,\\ Vim,_ i 4 ...,i _ I'� - • .' i \ �• \c \ ---"-00 • . ..vt„a. ...Al S' W - . . . . 1, .'• �/ �'•1' • • • • . .. i 2- 12io� S/D'e" � ' • • • - • •'••• -.2., .• . , -;. •- ( NR.SVA-lr,,rdswmpmitsz ; • • - • • 7- $/9-- • • • , •• •• iv. •_;4 •• • •• . . • . . _ • • • - • " .•• • . . . 4 - .• . .• , ' • • , • • r? 7- Zt. xwallr DEL -HDA PARK, 1, .. , '. .% i : i iR — tl E^ v • 8 t h-- .. _— S T — I r"--", ; 6.v. liiii;•.. ..:. .1.1. 3 f .r ' 4..: ' .S t Z -z QPA '-i Qv NE 7th ST . �. ilto %4 , 22 • •, t6 ,,. SU.BT�.T- ?I I , - o ' r 4 1 r- i A � 1 12. ; )t . A' 0 �. - LAKE TERR c Vii4D417 a> - •..- 4 %• ` 1 • a ! We S. ti. f liNC' I : 3 •a gee _; ., is ; �P� . 16 • f7I* EtIutIwi.x.tti'dI . 0 Sa • dliti,7 ,.... . 1 1. ; 3 1t4 - +`� � -% .:;ILr - S� 1G ' ; 4 , Z 4. 1 s. _ i�!1 - % " NE _ 5th Cr t t� 4j h, RL i -s .1-. :': : i f. I •I ..44 %. S • i , ,O.•- 4 \.. a-t 1.-.: - NE 5th ST •: • r� ( 1 1 i i - 4 1 :, t 2_ ` ': 4 j I D = : I . l cl./ • - -• • • . 1 1: . . 1..:.. -7:1:...:-.'::::•; :::'-......:;',-..."-•:;‘,-.':_:.`;;%:-;.':::.:.•---77:7--.::--_-77-•-•::.7:'• .71.-- —• --7- -.--T•--. -7- ----:-—-. •::-...-. • • • ( . . . .. • - •••,1- ----r_7-2.. --...7.'••I --7---'. . ! i• : .4,..,:":•.:- .;.•:f•Y•-:",:17;:;:_.j:`..:•;-:,:f:'::t'::•,'-. ...:- `..::r••••':-.;•:•*.::;-!;"-7.•:',--;;':'..•":z:;."..i.•:c. ...::'''."•;..7-!..1.-:'--•-- -. r•-• .. ":-. -• '•, : i .,I-:.• • 1....."•:""."''2.,..!=•-•5:;`,1,-•:•.::,"":.•;:..,•f '' ;;:.",• ••.."1::.•"::.::,:'-'7! _i i fei...-..':..:,,:.•,',...-:.-"j,.....i\.,..'. c-.. ,-••• • .'"••-- :- - __ ...1..- i\..- 1_,g. [ s:": ::.: '''':::.:::3;ii%;:i.r.:;;%:.•-: ;.-.......--t:"...7..:•:7;2';- :;.'::.-.-."-;-......:Y'f•:•-•":-' ' .1 .:-.'.%•-:.''. - ----_:_...._-___._ ..:__ -.- ' ' • ' ' --''3.`.-...!"..1.1/ ` •-•`:!:::•••,---77--"-----•-•- ...„..\- --''-‘•l•-•.,::•.-':::....r. -...--'1.••,•••.---...:-.••• ...-,••,`.:•••-1.1.',.-1,;:1,, -::-,".•:•'••;',-,:•:•;.,..•.."1,-..;...•r...it-,,..,-;,-..: .1 ,,.....- . . ' I .• .;•••-.,'4•:-,...".14...i....:. !1..:;11....;',•.!.1:•••''':•..V .4..--L,1E.-7 ,..--- --- .4:"`2..r.. 5 " fi ' .: --_ .: — .1 ...!. •,•.•-• ..,.•,,,f ;:.-...t.i.::e."...•...•• :.;;;;:....!5 Ff..:...,:..: , .••••:••,•i ........ • .._ ....--,• .:., , ,.::..:,••:: - 1.• ,,,- ......;,.t.:,.. ....--.2.-: .,..; ..,.. .. ,, . ./-:,:-- •-•-,.if-1..,-. , • . .,,-_-•,c . .:,, , , , .. . , Pv"---1F-... I. 1-;:." .•..: ••••••.!:1::"i'.1:-.:!:-."•:‘•:":-•:•:_i•-••' ••';,•••'..,1-`:-•••!,....•:;I- .• I". .:: .4.,7. --='-9.G-' — ,- •\ .1*`..•':• : ,1 !. :::: : •::•.:.--:-1••..-:-.f...:.:s.,;••:.- :•,•:::.,:•••••-,!-1.•• •••1-. '.`..:••••';-- .4.-,c,nn , . --.• ••,• •"-••.••-- ••••••'••• .-.*,•••• 4•;.1 4: • •••. - ...I • Fr......:cr- c.., • l....0 ..7^5(.-...z.: .•7 :;•••:,S;..1;...,• .......;.••:.4. •'‘.......••••:•,.,•I 4 I.:- : t..,•-•;• - . .•1!;•;:,', 7.%: ;,...-•:.:•.!.".•,,',"';‘;'..1'......:' •:::;•:-;••:•••.:,..i",:;;.:;:I f:,...,•": -;:--:::•: /.•.•.•,..-.1. r.-:•', ;-....y..... :•,-,;•-•: :.;:-..:,;;;;:.•...: :.....,..-•4.:,...-...:.--• ....... .....:.•-•......sn .-:•••.•:. ,•• • • •%it: ;;;;•:.-.• •.z.:,::•.•...-,•••:•.,:,:-••-- --le::•-.t!.•••••;;;1••••••i.•,....,•- •••..::•: --;••...,,• . . . .. •; , .. . .., • , .,•)‘. .. . ..: 1! ' . • •• .•? , . ti. • . , • . . : • • ..•I s, 1 ..... ; •4.. •.:*. 0 . • • ,11.;.: .•;.'... ;;;,...•;:.•;:i:-.:;....,:.i...::,:..i:l..;•.71::,.:.f..,...-,..c.,11;717...),...:•:,:.;,-1./.11;.i:::: :..t.c.......'-'......•:c..;:t......7.,....i•-4. .:•:;.,;....41,... ... :.. . .7.tf.: .:•..,•r'...;:i.';',...,;(;...:',..i:.:7.:i-•::!,!...rfi'...I.:!.:.iy.••:•...-.: ...:.:;.`;..:.?.5...i..);, •••,•.....••: . .:"...''.• -•`,1.- :"?:.;'•••: .',.-..-;':'./..,',... 1,-.12;1.6-;•;.,-..••:•:;.: .:,,-.,.,.-c,•:.,..ii : .L.p /....,. :- .., :: .. ...,. •- • 1.,:j:i . . . .• r.l.. i7=' . 1 ? ; 1.4‘ .••••-.4;'.7':;:".'"..f".%:•-:;"4;1-:-..41.4' "..r..•,-."1••,Y11.-:::;'. --• •-•.•:1::ff?v- .:', 1...• 4 t . • : - 1 "-• '' - --- 1 • ••• DI r 1 ... f•ts 1, ;: .7:..•.:.. .-..*; :::•:•:::11:•..:.".....•;:r:r.: .:;•:..(-)..4'.... . : 21' c): 1-: -.•:..,.;•,,- . • / • < t- - ..•-• ;, i,f. -..: c-•'••:•••-•: -f --:s.-.;: ' %c••••tc•;-:; :.;:.••,,i-:?ii.,.L-111. •• •••'?----- - - : I - - "I .. i 1 ••••1 !.;;;.::, • •1::":'.."::-•':::::::--...;..".•:-.c.::•:::...;..,7:: 1:7:1 ,:••.-:••:‘::':1::.., •-`.:r:— .=-!.-:- ". -.•:' CV;:•••••.; t..: ;.'../' • : -3-_,. - .)-, -• •••••••-• ''''' k.n :--, 7.1.-:."; ::•••••-r --.•••••i •••••-' . . • ''-i '.?•'• .:"`-':::::•417••••-4•-1..t....i7.;.,.:.-_*..;f,;.:fi_:.;.." 1.;:-/:.: •••••••:z..?z••;z;Y;;,::-....1 \ :;;•,:••••• • .ii.e '•••••[ ,:i...;.*:•.:::"7: -;•••".".".%f.- !?."..":4`.541`i •;..I.','-•;-•-ii-,1•-r.r"-.7. ::-...1,.• _. ;',4-.; :-'.• ..-', 11-1:•";---c;•-•.-11•il ...'1:1-=";?:-,1":12•-•1•%•lil'i.:'- i-; /..:• ;*. •;:.•-• k•••1 ;"\ C--0 7;.".: ' - • i ..•...„...;. ......z,; 11 .1. • I I 1 ___J 1 --- {f ---; , ,4•7*T ::: 2'' .;,' 2,11-4 " "• ..,L.f....:a.T.f..).....;.4,x,;; 4... •.„'. 1• ... . ) .b.' , ..... , ... _ . .., .:•:•, %N.-_, • • , ••,1:-. ...••• :.,!;f:,...-:-:,,-;•.f.,---r,•:•"•:,.;.•2,..,-•••.,.• :-.-:/.../-:-...,...-...„--;.•-,-,-N,.. ,-.-2. ---,..• --- , . ..,‘. "A.- •;••- ..--..-, , :•:. .:-1:;,,;.:-4•,,,:--_-,i•A•;-.. tli,,;;;-::,.•,..:,.,--t-iiL..-: •,-:,:::,:•:,•t.::::.-:-::•-•':,.\:..: . -'. / • c 7:..,Z-1•:-• .:-.E-:-..= ..- ;f:';,i'i:?-::-:5i11,,,-,.;:,'.1. -(r1:?- 1;..-1•:-:,.:.--::.-;::', ;-i, 'i;: --..--7--' --.--- - - ,:. '' •'I.-' Y•--:1 • - N ;. 1::..;.1..t."-,;:l..::.'";.?:F1:::2.,..7:::'1,--'-';..:'::::..-:Z-•!%; i ., :.: .! .. .. .1-;:i;'-..f.•:; \\ •• -2 ".:7-7: k.7. i • •• • 1. ,. 72;i•,...7.*:•..v..,...ii*:. v...::.:•"•.',...::•.q..--", ::.••:-."...1........ s:•::-..);•.-... . . ./ . . . ... . •,,,. I ‘-.1 •-•:1"!...:fi.-.,:.•?C::!• :%:. ''''1. .. iF-•.. . ••••'.:. •- .-• ; •-•:-......- •-•: - -" - • z'L'I• -Ts" ...:* -• •.: es. j t••. • `:- . . . . . [ ::-:'.., .:.••i:;:;•;:'::•:•2:1J:-•";';_5-:..;i:t"%f. :',..:=...'."•17::••••.''?:-:1•.:i• • "..;',.;:•.'",•",..1. ..?:. ‘:,.'',-..;,;-:"• C• " :*--"-:.:-::::,"•': ::)."...•:%":,..•;`,••'%!"'i'it •,•'•.•:".44..7!"*;•.•.,:r;1',sf......:,.....•.:,....N.:,.., kt..-.;p p.6...: • • - 3.•-•• •--.i:..:!:.I.:e.:-V.:..,-/.).-.•:-•i:;'.•;•z'f.:.•7_,:::.i:- •:.- '-'•.,'.-.11••.';--‘:!:---,\\,;,-..---::\.....". ' .- ''..., .• ...!'. ,. / . •) • . ";-, -• i.,•-•.F.f;•'.;7 -i').„(Zii.' ';.:::-.T::'.7.:.'..r•.:••:'. ..!'.*::-.:',...:‘ -\*..:..., `.-. :'.- ;. ..... .. - i> • ._.1_ / ' ' . i.....•••;•,;".::::.:.;,,;,....1:ii.'..•.:.-.;.;...q...:I•-'.. -•-•'.•••;' - , • • • ,•- s • --- -.." ...,•,- • Q. • • - • . t r.:... ,•.I...::,..„!.....,:q;;;,..N.,,•;,?.1:::. ;7i.:•.‘'t, ,*•-"f:',:•..t.. :i:„-•••• •r..."---•• ,1•s - % \s •••- • . .'.1.•-.:„1,'..i..:::: ;•!ik.::•,..tf$i:.:...:•:-.-;%-•'!.. ..1:"..?: .-:- .:-:;:.‘*.' ,::,.•••-:' " ''.•-:'"•:'' - • -..• ..i - • ;•.; •%1.•;:,,:.•,:i3-:•.--'•;?'-';:4-44:;-:.-.:-•'!...:::.f.;,','.:* .."-",:••.•••...i'i- ..-;).:::••••'-. \: " -••-7:-."-:"%•: .1.:-." ...- 1 ? L ' '4...7....,fsl.:::•.-;?.:-.4:',-,•4;.;:::•.f.V.:,••:.••!1'•:.-,•••••,,...,1:::,••::(•...••-,4...1',.. ..":•.•:,..:::: •, • •, ‘v:: • - - -.e. '• ii t .f. .,.11',••:._;.!:,...),t..7.?z?',:.:I',1.4.'::,.::!.*,;.:••••,::•••,--;1..,_•%•.:•,..!4,::-•;:•:;"f:7....'•••••••1•:.•‘.,.-•: •'',4‘->------ ..- •,'. - -...' - 4 N ,) - .. . 1......1.' ::.;1":••;!t..4••;..:•?.;:•,•3;.Q..•:k'.;!,,!;;;:;:1-,5•i•.•:•,•7.-;;•:4,:-..'1!:4,;..)•,;•::•:•.,-;•.-•.;••,,:.....4..7. .....:;--:......-..-•;".......•..• i: • • '-•..• ••••- 4:4•'.... - I -•' • 1.;•:;:•.:•'.:1••I.C.:,:-...,:J.4 .:),-;:•.•:-.I..":::;•••::!..,•.:',-•!.:::...,'..:I..;...:....,7 ;....:-.),;:f ..:1...,:.....,- . . .. 1..: . ../.: , .. :::: ..... • • • .• i !. ••: 1 . . ,;F:4:-%•••••••:••-:-.• •,.• ...-.41" .'-::•:':. ....... tr.,- .: . :•• • . ! ; t •I . •.•,... ) • • ••• ':: '''••••:.:- •.: ••• '....:1%.I.:• •;.I.:•- ‘,...'':; '.1..,•'.•:'.•r.::'••!.• • :-4,1/• sl' 44 • .;." .-. . •- -•• - 9 • "1 ; :::: •---2.:.--..--.f.,..-'••••:;:.-4•;-- .t•- ::••;•-.,4,-.;iv-. :•F-.,::-.•----.-: ' - ., ./ . . * -..: ::•'I---',"-1"?..-i•.. .•...--..,,-.*. •:"?!...:•••:..':•1•--7 .:.:•...--, -:-..--•.- ••- -.- -..-•-• - . - •:- .•-••1-;.:1:-.7:-.:::,.--•,:.","•:%.;-.-)./.-,1:F.?.:::•::'.:-.:-::....:• • - - -"- •- •, - /'- ..-- , . .::•'"•:.;;tf-;•.:1•:',;.. i..-':"•._f;•-•:!;`•;r••:•=`•1*.; -:Y-7.-":-:----:--• —:.-'-;=;../. ..- :: •-•:::•-•:•11:...:1.,•::•.. -i:::-.7•-.1"*:,: t• -•••--,'•' '.-•;--, --•• -,:-.." •.- . - • 1 • - . ''•" '• ,•••••:--r\';--.\-::.-i•.:::-; .-""i.,*,•. 11:: .-.--, - : •-••-.ti \.:, ..;•_--- - •••!:. .... -.--•-•:',:•:\.-":-:`•:.-•••.•-----••-•--•''.-.;:=-1- ---.:7 -'--'.. . . ...1-• '':1<-;':%":*.".\:*--!:','• --....f.f.:-•-. ? A• . • fi•-.;.., I.:S.'-'?"- :..';.`,'.6:::-..:.. -:..: .-..•:•!.. •:;,::.•!;:---;;;-, -.:, • .i. .. I )* • ' •1- ::\''t'...:(:::•••••••'...!,:;.•'*--;•.;:-1: ••-6;--: -. --.. . .:1; ..., ..-:.•!...-.._ : ,.. ..N\.....„ ... ..i,. ...._. ,..\ \ 7-•,_____(3 ______ . , [•::• .... -:.:„....„.;•,_.:•‘•:,,,...:••••,...:...,...,. -.• ••.N . .- • , z. .. • f r•:: • . -•:.;:•;',;.:-.,4-..;-:, :.,...,:. .. ....•:.:, ‘;•,.: .....- . ,::...:- .- . -: . .- . •1. 4•• ' •• .,!:1%;•-..1 :.-;:'i. , '- 1:•..f"••••\‘-'• .-,•• . '.....:.:- i\:.".• . I if:• •.- -?:•'..r•-:.4.'; '1:-.4...`-;."."- "" '••.:•' ••:.:- • .:Z-.... ..-- •-• •.'• ' • II. -ii,..•;......:i•••."•:6i:::i..f,:;••••••••••:•:,'.'••••‘.1-r.--'''..• 7. :. \"-'..-1:-.• s: . .:: ''... • - -..-- • ::-..........i•-•1•:':•:-.1.••••.•-••::.*:•:'•'..:',.••.:: ;.;::f.', - •".,-... •••••;1". ._,A•:!., •.! . - • • .. . . .- . . - -• ' :. • . . • .• .. . • • • . • • . . ,... .-.•..,!...*:::.•.c.."...,.,-...,,:-,•::..7,-..-:•.•:-.::-:•.:.•:•:" .•,::•;•-.'• •:.-1,-.. ....---N: :-.-..•-: --..,.- .:' •• • ' • • . - ••. ... •.. . .. . .. .. • .- ., . • - j' !-..- •••••::---7.• 11...'r •t:_:.-1';f:"'-".•.---:..' ::•••••• ." •-•:-: ' -! ':.:-.. •',‘-..'•1-:--.. --. . • - - • •• - - - • t i, .--:I.---.:.:•1;•..7..,;-::...'1•: ,::.....•.:1::•-•:".':•.;-."• .• ''..,''. '-:--::.• :• •...:.: .-..'."• • ...- , • , • •• • .-• -• • • • ! ";-. -•••::.•••z--:',!1:14:",:•..-::-•:-•-,• -: -:..• . • - - ••• .-.\ '."- . . . .. 1 :. • ... . . ....,... .., .., ............. .,..... . . .... . . ... . .... . .. ,"..;::..'•-* :•,-'1Cr.''•• .7..:.' :' • : • .- • • . . .. .. .. . . . . - . ‘z•.•--.:':-.1:,.:-.:.:.--:.. •.• -:•:"- • . , . . . ., I . • . - . 1 1.....:y..::. '.."...".;.. ....:.1,..-•:•.:::.•.-•-:'-;:. -..:-'•• -. 1',.:',-f€:,:..-;:.'-'.:•.::::.."...'•;:.:,.. .: i•-.-....: •-:-- . ,- - i . • . . . • . " ' - • . 1..'.":.:.;;''.1..'.;::•::c..J.- • -:.•-,. •. . . - . . . • . . • •. . . . C . ' .• • .-,I-t•-..,.....,,,,et•N 4.•Easy-IC."r•-•-•.6,0,•,,•-•"1.,::•....-•‘,1....:O 4,-3•••1 rt•-•41.On1 a.c t.4,4..1..,:•^:,1/i.sita 0::::.4i,I.., I • . • - 1 i • • "• • •. . ';'....E" .;:i‘:' . .; . C E.A;fA I. .....t......:i. .....:.•::.:: -. • .. •" . ' . . . • .: y,..1-,,t.,..,...t.•,t-.‘i-.,.-...-..,0 I,.,•actS.,C.,............,:1,-,•,,•-• •-,:,••f,,O,,•t.4,‘`,:...,^2.... ;41•,-.3 I.0,cf 4.4.,,,•: ..,,CM ,C. :.•,..,..,,,C, 10-..::.‘ 13-' ".,.•I4.-•••,...••..•"‘.., ,., ..'0 ,,. , *1.,•••••1,4"."...r.,,,,,,,C4:1..•••:••:11.1•. . . • 1 . . . •,.'• 4•......,•.. .. .,r.... 11.14C . ,: 4: :,t4 P.., 1.4 .....7:4.1 0,IA..: .... •4•14 :-. I.4.1.,r,,,-.:.• S.,,.14, ,72•C7. l‘ ,. 4,4. co ......•1 Z...,..-: I i ! . _ SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR'S •Most properties change over time; those changes that have STANDARDS FOR REHABILITATION acquired historic significance in their own right shall be . These Standards were established in 1990 and are endorsed by retained and preserved. •Distinctive features, finishes, and construction tech preservation professionals and agencies. The Preservation iiiclue� Manual has been developed from these Standards and the or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a historic specific needs of Delray Beach's historic sites inventory. As property shall be preserved. design guidelines cannot address conditions of every single •Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than building,property owners are encouraged to implement these replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires standards when maintaining their historic properties. The replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall Standards may also be used for: match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual •Certified Rehabilitation pursuant to the Reform Tax Act of qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of 1986 missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, •Determining evaluation benefits under Federal Tax Incentive physical, or pictorial evidence. Program. •Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that •Conformance for the National Register of Historic Places cause damage to historic materials shall not be used. The program. surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be undertaken using the gentlest means possible. •A property shall be used for its historic purpose or be placed 'Significant archeological resources affected by a project in a new use that requires minimal change to the defining shall be protected and preserved. If such resources must be characteristics of the building and its site and environment. disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken. �. The historic character of a property shall be retained and •Newadditions,exterioralterations,orrelatednewconstruc- tion shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of ' features and spaces that characterize a property shall be property. The new work shall be differentiated from the oldavoided. and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural atures to •Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its property and its environmenect the historic integrity of the t. time, place, and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development,such as adding conjectural features •New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the or architectural elements from other buildings,shall not be undertaken. future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. NNW Ir. . • .r Via. PORCHES and PORTS COCHERES K , :} ,' c' i t.. tea"„ `«v - r t r aa .q a � c�wa tea`��: aY 5� ,,3i 1,4,t,..,,,,ti.1.. :s,4,,t,ku.‘,,.‘,.4..v.ordk, y..: , .,,, :,:t: %.... �, . `, � �\ .... ... . �. • ...� vac 2, di $ °I i , € 1 r Porte cocheres brought the automobile closer to the house. By t 1*fit } 7945,25%y of a house was devoted to the garage. ,r4 4 ' i , ?Y (44 t f' -F Porte cocheres are structural appendages providing auxiliary 1 r }j function to the side of the residence. They should always be _ _ ..! ` ` '41 ..`fi !,' .+ S;f:,; '• '.- �. $..: - %� retained and restored. Top; An open porch retains the architectural character of this Craftsman Cottage. Bottom: Grilles and glass have been combined to keep the APPROPRIATE Spanish flavor of this facade. • Original porch openings should be maintained preferably INAPPROPRIATE with transparent materials, i.e. screen, lattice, glass or in • Removing an entrance porch when the building has been Spanish style screens with iron grilles or wood rails. reoriented to a new use. • Designing enclosures for historic porches can include • Cutting new entrances on a primary elevation. using large sheets of glass and recessing the enclosure wall behind the existing scrollwork, posts and balustrades. Enclosing porches in a manner resulting in the loss of .;_ , Wood frame casement windows are a preferred alterna- historic character (solid materials, like wood, stucco, or tive. Minimize the number of sections. masonry). Do not cover columns, railings, or eaves. Metal u f; awning and jalousie windows obscure the original open ..,�; t• ings. . _ .. .. ____ ___, . ,,.,..„,.._,-----' T an* WINDOWS b .. .,. a a. ,,, Before heating and air conditioning, windows provided a t ■rq� source of ventilation and aesthetics. The simple vernacular 'F � ` """ hung window evolved into more elaborated classic Colonial '' -, � x „ � �« and Mediterranean openings. Maintain the original size, / :�. 14 1 i$ shape,and paning as well as the wood trim as it determines the " ,,.M '' ;; rhythm of solids and voids. Sash and casement dominate the r; ' fps pre-WW II styles, while awning, jalousie and pivot are the y f�, a 2 6 modern y st les. iiii g ,r ilk. APPROPRIAT ,., ,._ •,,, i •-s., E ,-,ail a `�; • Retain distinctive windows which feature sash, muntins, c`. Elm 1 glazing, sills, heads, hood molds, paneled or decorated jambs and moldings, and interior/exterior shutters and II 1111 blinds. i ,■ i • Maintain with periodic cleaning, rust removal, paint re- ,"`„1 moval, andreapplicationdic of4.r . protective coatingsystems. ° n •f'�« � �, Recaulk and replace weatherstripping making windows � �„ -�pp g g .,< , „� ��, watertight and improving thermal efficiency. 5, . • Repair frames and sash by patching,splicing,consolidating, or otherwise reinforcing and replacing in kind. ��,��� '�z�� ��, � � ��. � "`�`"� :774,,,t 2 Design & install new windows when the historic windows , z 1,;,;117::: are completely missing. New windows in additions, or 4.____ t` exposed party walls,should be compatible with the overall a design, but not necessarily duplicate the fenestration r i, ak pattern and detailing of a character defining elevation. LI — INAPPROPRIATE i of! • Cutting new openings,blocking in windows,and installing ,,,,,..t , ; replacement sash which does not fit the window. „_ x • Changing the historic appearance through inappropriate _ �yr , design materials, finish or color which changes the sash �� N depth of reveal, the reflectivity, or the appearance of k frame. Retrofitting or replacing windows rather ththe an l maintaining the original. Bronze, black frame, or tinted =e'>' No:' , ,'"„.; ' _ 1 windows are not preferred choices. Though double hung were the most prevalent. many recidenre, • MISSION Rooted in the romantic American West and Southwest tradi- f ® /lA1hUtilli olligii/.intlia11Mlnr ® tions,this was a popular 1920s Boom design. Del-Ida Park, Old {/{r72 School Square, and the Marina District exhibit many illustra- 1 I �;_,� -n- n o tions. Both one and two story, the Mission genre was simple, inexpensive to build, and conveyed Florida's Spanish origins. t. 1- � Rich in character and charm, they preceded the more elab- MO ` 011 orate Mediterranean Revival. lJ U ❑ D Roof parapets with red tile roof overhangs, large square piers , 0 — �� P P g � g q \ _ as porch supports,and distinctive porte cocheres were promi- 1 i.— nent. The lack of decorative detailing was complimented by wrought iron grilles, and inlaid tiles. FEATURES - Block/wood frame with rough or smooth stucco surface Two ranks with sloping tiles Flat roofs with curved or central bell shaped parapets Arched openings for windows, doors, and porches with , , , simple stucco molding."Visor"tile roofs over windows Open front porch £kIIII Casement or sash windows � ' wy. Chimney tops often bell tower shape °°� ;', " " Y ' '"h-R` Often arched porte cochere attached /Minimal, if any, decorative elements (scuppers: roof drain x. . _ 6.. /1 tiles) A Del-Ida Park Mission Villa original.