Loading...
HPB 12-07-1994 r DEAAYBEACH Ai41013ftaity AGENDA 1993 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING • CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: December 7, 1994 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: First Floor Conference Room Time: 6:00 P.M. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286.0105. I . CALL TO ORDER II. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: A. Recommend to the City Commission that the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Solomon David Spady House be designated as a Local Historic Site and listed on the Local Register of Historic Places. The property consists of a historic residential, single family home located at 170 N.W. 5th Avenue. The legal description of the property is as follows: Lots 5 and 6 and the North 26 .25 ' of Block 19, Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida. B. Recommend to the City Commission that the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Susan Williams House• be designated as a Local Historic Site and listed on the Local Register of Historic Places . The property consists of a historic residential, single family home located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue. The legal description of the property is as follows: Lots 5 and 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida. Historic Preservation Board Agenda December 7, 1994 Pae 2 III . CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-239, Villa Delray, 127 S.E. 7th Avenue. Youliy & Magdalena Popov, Owner. Approve a free standing sign to be located at the front of the building located on S.E. 7th Avenue. IV. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: Discussion of the establishment of a convenience store use at the southwest corner of Atlantic Avenue and Swinton Avenue. V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Historic District Representatives B. Board Members C. Staff VI . ADJOURN POSTED ON: DECEMBER 1, 1994 Steven Taylor, a ner MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA PUBLIC HEAR I N G MEETING DATE: DECEMBER 7, 1994 LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM I . ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by the Chairman at 6 : 00 P.M. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Miller, Charlie Williams, Sandy Jamison, Betty Devitt, Vera Farrington, Julie Morgan MEMBERS ABSENT: John Vaughan STAFF PRESENT: Jeff Costello, Steve Taylor, Diana Mund II . PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: A. Recommend to the City Commission that the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Solomon David Spady House be designated as a Local Historic Site and listed on the Local Register of Historic Places . The property consists of a historic residential, single family home located at 170 N.W. 5th Avenue. There were no comments from the public in favor or opposing the designation. It was moved by Ms . Farrington, seconded by Ms . Morgan and passed 6-0 to recommend to the City Commission approval of the ordinance designating the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Solomon David Spady House as a Local Historic Site. B. Recommend to the City Commission that the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Susan Williams House be designated as a Local Historic Site and listed on the Local Register of Historic Places . The property consists of a historic residential, single family home located at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue. There were no comments from the public in favor or opposing the designation. It was moved by Mr. Jamison, seconded by Ms . Farrington and passed 6-0 to recommend to the City Commission approval of the ordinance designating the property owned by Douglas T. Williams and known as the Susan Williams House as a Local Historic Site. III . CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS: A. COA 8-239, Villa Delray, 127 S.E. 7th Avenue. Youliy & Magdalena Popov, Owner. Approve a free standing sign to be located at the front of the building located on S.E. 7th Avenue. As the applicant did not attend the meeting it was moved by Mr. Williams, seconded by Mr. Jamison and passed 6-0 to continue COA 8-239 to the Board's December 21, 1994 meeting. IV. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: Discussion of the establishment of a convenience store use at the southwest corner of Atlantic Avenue and Swinton Avenue. The Board held a discussion with the property owner and Bob Abdin, applicant. The Board stated that although they did not feel a convenience store was an appropriate use for such an important corner of the City they would review a formal submission. The Board revised the agenda to add the following Discussion Item: Discussion for new construction of a single family residence at the northeast corner of N. Swinton Avenue and N.E. 6th Street. Tullia Taylor, applicant, presented plans for the Board' s review. The Board felt with a few minor elevation changes to the plan and with a submission of a landscape plan they would be able to approve a formal submission for the proposed residence. V. REPORTS AND COMMENTS: A. Reports from Historic District Representatives None - 2 - 12/07/94 B. Board Members None C. Staff None VI . ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board, Mr. Jamison moved to adjourn the meeting at 7 : 10 P.M. , seconded by Mr. Williams and passed 6-0 . The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for December 7, 1994, which were formally adopted and appr ve_ by he Board on December 21, 1994 . /; L....: � / ��, Di Mund If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official Minutes . They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes . - 3 - 12/07/94 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING DECEMBER 7, 1994 AGENDA ITEM II .A. SOLOMON DAVID SPADY HOUSE 170 N.W. 5TH AVENUE ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD Conduct a Public Hearing to obtain comments from the public with respect to recommending to the City Commission that the Solomon David Spady House be placed on the Local Register of Historic Places . THE PUBLIC HEARING Pursuant to Section 4 .5 . 1(C) (4 ) of the Land Development Regulations the Historic Preservation Board will conduct a Public Hearing with respect to the historic designation of the Solomon David Spady House. The purpose of the Public Hearing is to allow the public to comment on a proposal to have the Spady House designated as a Local Historic Site. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places . Pursuant to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , the Board determined at its meeting of November 2, 1994 that the subject property conforms to the criteria for designation based on positive findings to LDR Section 4 . 5 . 1(B) (2) (d) and (e) and 4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) and (b) . After hearing public testimony pro and con the Board will make its recommendation to the City Commission. Y: SYAID Y I-IYB.IJOC �t r t• DESIGNATION R E P O R T HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA a t r r a5F h Y : : �i z r " fi -a1}'" Er;- 1"" fir,-Lr+3. .� • r ..�r, •rf ,S'' r, i,Wit ?"E�.` f 7 f3 z r- k X t _ ,.,t.."' -t f r n z.. a ^ f 1 l...e.Y i,.^1�K�.�'fG�/'/.1V �y .� Fes✓ y { a S , • Y .• � G ��1^L" .;� _.'1 3 -g_ e ,,,:-,r Ay y-'�jrL> -FS4.. i _ s Lr Y __- f�'f" - y CCCy i t{ i E.r t - • ks 1 f ^- ��..S y ,..-,,t'3 �� : S r. 1 r t -� ..'� i(,1., r�,( t Yy ✓ ".3 r } '" ,, _ix-'.4-r+` -rt`* ' 1 ., ,„_,.„.�," ?..t r 1 4. „.,..„,,,.,. F• x �' y „tee '4..r '' -r`� ,�,�r<f`__,`��- .vy'' .�vtr~ � t I, � ��517sr' .�� t .f �r xj'� La3c,:;`k.S.. .s '�L" ; ti"r-.� a� =itiY3y �" �." _=L f a M .Y' -i ut r3' 1 a. e''? :s.._ ✓__z.;..• dr TL'Z,l.:-j r .....� ..s c„_.....,_�.�_ _:. �.c. ..r..r. _ +.=._�.'T�.u__�.._...�.:_ THE SOLOMON DAVID SPADY HOUSE 170 N.W. 5TH AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1926 Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 170 N.W. 5TH AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION IV. HISTORICAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared October 1994 by Vera Farrington, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board Member and Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 170 N.W. 5th Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1926 Architect: Unknown Builder: Unknown Present Owner: Douglas T. Williams , 118 N.W . 8th Avenue, Delray Beach FL 33444 . Present Use: Residential Present Zoning: GC General Commercial Legal Description: Lots 5 & 6 and the N. 26 . 25 ' of Block 19, Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida Property Control Number: 12 43 46 16 01 019 0050 Classification for Designation: Architectural significance, good example of Mission Revival style. Cultural Significance , home of S.D. Spady, prominent black educator. Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 4 II . MAP s j*-------- ----- _____ -c ;.% -'2 INEI ''<. < __ n -..,-----_ ST. _-____.___________. d' NAY. cN R _ , _,____J WEI 111 MI ill - 1ST Si. .ill 11111"11 c • --------- _in III c _______; i III -=mir, kld L___ _____ _ i A V E N U E 1 Ill A T L A N 7 1 C IS ---- „_____-_-,--... a lc aim Eii-ii iiEi.Iii * -- 1ST -iIl...lI..I, 0S I __- == C _ a..I.I..: .iii p_S_iI_._ ..:.-. 0., P a __ •.... . a -___,-4,. N 170 N.W. 5TH AVENUE PS.J.,),'r+C:47,u11i00 OTf Of R1PJ.1 ELJ.ril.a __ cAG'7AL figs£L'tP STWEW--- Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 5 III . Architectural Information This building is a good example of the simplified Mission Revival style which was popular throughout the City in both commercial and residential buildings during the 1920s . The Mission style is distinguished by its simplicity of design and ornamentation. The prominent features of the style include the following: Roofs : Predominantly flat roofs concealed with a parapet. If gables are combined with a flat roof the gables are covered with terra cotta tiles . The parapets generally are bell curved with curved elevations at the corners . Roof scuppers (drain tiles) are set within the parapet walls . Porches : A front porch is characteristic of the style, often extending the full length of the facade. Open balconies are commonly found above the porch on a two story structure. Walls : Construction is either hollow clay tile or frame, finished with rough or smooth stucco. Windows : Either casement or sash or a combination, usually multi-paned. Chimney: Usually project from the wall . Chimney tops often have bell tower shape. The Spady House incorporates many of the classic features of the Mission Revival style. It was constructed about 1925 and was completed prior to July 1926 as it is included on the July 1926 Sanborn map which is attached. Built as a single family residence, it is a two story rectangular building of stucco over frame construction set on a stone foundation. It has a flat roof concealed by a decorative parapet. Constructed as an 8 room house, it had 4 rooms on each floor and an 8 ' by 18' porch across the front facade. The roof of the porch is flat and is also concealed by a parapet which matches that on the primary roof . The original window openings remain, though some have been altered in size to accommodate standard factory built windows . All of the original sash or casement wood windows have been replaced with aluminum awning windows . The openings of the original screen porch have been enclosed with aluminum windows . The chimney projects from the south facade wall and is capped with a bell tower covering. Drain tile sucppers are set into the parapet walls . A 12 ' x 18 ' garage was constructed in conjunction with the house. It was free-standing, probably stucco over frame construction with a flat roof and Mission parapet. It has been demolished and replaced with the existing garage. Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue ' Page 6 IV. Historical Information The street address of the property is 170 N.W. 5th Avenue, formerly N. Blackmer Street. The property is legally described as Lots 5 , 6 and the N. 26 . 25 feet of Lot 7 , Melvin S. Burd Subdivision of the North Half of Block 19 , Delray Beach, formerly Town of Linton, Palm Beach County, Florida. Block 19 was not subdivided into lots when the Town of Linton was platted in 1895 . In September of 1915 Melvin S . Burd, of Burd' s Produce Co. , shipper of fruit and vegetables, subdivided and platted lots on the north half of Block 19 but the subdivision was not recorded in the Palm Beach County Plat Book until April, 1925 . This would indicate that construction on the north half of the block did not occur prior to 1925 . The Spady House is located on the west side of N.W. 5th Avenue, a block and a half from W. Atlantic Avenue. Solomon David Spady' s activities as an educator and black community leader were of major importance and influence to the City. Mr. Spady was born in Virginia 1890 and graduated from Hampton Institute, now Hampton University, in Hampton Virginia. He was a student of George Washington Carver who became his mentor and counselor at the Institute. George Washington Carver was a botanist and a pioneer in the field of agricultural chemistry who fostered in Spady a lifelong interest in the subject. Spady was one of the founders of the New Farmers of America, a national organization which encouraged black people to become independent farmers . After graduating from Hampton Institute, Solomon Spady taught school in Cape Charles Virginia and in 1923 he moved to Delray to take a teaching position which also carried the responsibility of principal . He remained in that position for 33 years . The school that Spady became principal of was located on the east side of N.Blackmer Street (N.W.5th Avenue) between W. Atlantic Avenue and N.W. 1st Street . This was the site of the first school in the settlement which was established in 1895 by the Dade County Board of Instruction and known as Delray Colored NO. 4 . The Town of Delray was part of Dade county until 1909 when Palm Beach County was established. The first school was little more than a thatched hut, but then so were most of the early buildings in town, the thatching and dirt floor soon gave way to a wood roof and floor as the little school grew. In 1916 , on the same site, the Palm Beach County Board of Instruction "constructed a colored school building in the town of Delray at a cost approximating thirty-five hundred dollars . This school is in charge of Professor Clarence E. Walker and has done such a remarkable work that it has attracted the attention of the trustees of the Slater fund, who very generously have Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 7 been donating five hundred dollars per annum towards the support of the school . " 1 It is believed that Clarence Walker remained at the school until his retirement in 1923, when Spady became its head. Given the excellent reputation of the school, it is easy to understand why the Palm Beach County school superintendent was anxious to find an outstanding replacement, and sheds light on why such a well educated and well connected teacher would consider a post in a pioneer town with a population of approximately 2,000 souls . By 1939 the enrollment had outgrown the "standard frame schoolhouse" and the out-building classrooms which had been added. With insufficient property to expand and construct a larger school , the School Board purchased land at N.W. 4th Street and N.W. 8th Avenue and built a new school which served grades 1 through 12 . At Mr. Spady' s suggestion, this school was named Carver School in honor of his former mentor. In 1951 the Board again addressed the need for more class rooms and the 1939 school was largely demolished and replaced with a new school . In 1957 black high school students moved to a new building south of W. Atlantic Avenue and took the name Carver with them. In 1958 the School Board in recognition of one its most illustrious principals named the school on N.W. 4th Avenue in his honor. Solomon Spady' s wife, Jessie, was also a teacher, she was born in Florida in 1894 . It is believed that the Spadys built the house at 170 N.W. 5th Avenue, however it may have been built on speculation in 1925 during the land boom and purchased by them in 1928 . All of Mr. Spady's energy was dedicated to improving the educational standards of the segregated school system in which he taught . He often inspired his students by telling them of personal encounters with Booker T. Washington and George Washington Carver. Mr. Spady, with persistence, broad intellect and a passion to educate had a great influence in setting the goals and increasing the quality of the schooling available to blacks , not only in Delray but in the State and County, in the decades preceding desegregation. The Spady house was a meeting place for intellectuals and community leaders, and his students and their parents were always welcome . The fact that he chose to live only a block from his first school and four blocks from his second tells us of his total commitment to be identified with his work and with the involvement of the community he served. Solomon David Spady retired in 1956 and returned to live in his native Virginia . 1 . Narrative Reports of County Superintendents, 1916-1918 . State Department of Education, Tallahassee, FL. Research Report - 55, September, 1967 Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 8 V. Statement of Significance and Criteria—forte-es-lgnation Statement of Significance 170 N.w. 5th Avenue is a good example of the Mission Revival style of architecture as built in Delray Beach in the 1920s . It embodies most of the major features representative of the style and has not been altered to a major degree. Most importantly the Spady House has a high threshold of cultural significance. It is associated with the 33 year career of Delray' s most prominent black educator and community leader from 1923 to 1956 . It is important to the identity of the neighborhood to recognize this site and to make the community aware of its existence. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Criteria for Designation Section 4 . 5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or ( 3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property and justification for designation. ( 2) "A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in the city, state, or national history (for example, the homestead of a local founding family) . " 170 N.W. 5th Avenue was the home of Solomon David Spady and his wife Jessie for more than 30 years . Mr. Spady was the most respected educator in the community during his tenure as teacher/principal of the only school for black students in the City. The house served as focal point for those interested in in education and community affairs during his ownership. ( 3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed to have architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 9 (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " This house is characteristic of the many Mission Revival style structures built in the community during the 1920s . It is appropriate to offer recognition and some protection to this structure because many of Mission Revival buildings have been demolished, or have been altered in such a way that the original style cannot be identified. (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " The Spady House contains most of the distinguishing characteristics of the Mission Revival style. It is simple in design and ornamentation, and has a traditional flat roof with decorative parapets . The original openings are intact and the front porch has undergone little change . The bell shaped chimney cap and parapet sucppers are existing as is the rough stucco finish of the exterior walls . 170 N .W. 5th Avenue is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 . 5 . 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria be met. Designation Report 170 N.W. 5th Avenue Page 10 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Resourceful Rehab, Metropolitan Dade County, Division of Historic Preservation, 1987 Narrative Reports of County Superintendents, 1916-1918 . State Department of Education, Tallahassee, FL. Research Report - 55, September, 1967 Sun Sentinel , February 22, 1992 Delray Beach Historical Society Archives City Building Cards Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1926 Oral History Documentation Ruth and Spencer Pompey file/y: spadyz L. W_(�i ' ''� Z• �vl �Ai'130RN FIRE INSURANCE MAP D l`� ,J 4__,..: JULY , 1926 0 NZS N ,�t 'o N. W. 2F4c El Q a QQ,f; G F•,tl t f; Oi co E � 1 I _ b I w r •fi 1 � x p Et Jz z z k I2 .. guA ,v Fop h �D D•L 11 0 f }, Uy --�it b b 1- D' W R• „,,, rE? ,.,, ,...„_, ?!! _ D I ° l l r t-_... A k V ( . . .1 a Y r p ' K it .s t Y �✓ . �n Y• 1 V )) J IC / J.�C n-''" 9 4-9 f i it's C 0 079 1.o7 N. W. 1sj y* 'fil DP f 1 N _J o .'O • Igt t NB, El „ Elr- . „FP NU CN,' I LJi CB h 1 CNOO ti f l' , i No SJZ Sli..�rrC w.4Cn. .1 •,-.o I1. �.v • '.1 16 i r. g 1,p; r r. Ea ,.; 4 VA s I- d * ID4 D I .,( N6( ri Y__ut,,,-1 ram. ~' L s.r t r t'�' fi •,'- -se \�1R SY' o .i s ( C 7 � V= Z rj ` • ! ,F.r`-• -r } as ti jt� ' F ` l ti tS K,S 5 .2 ., 3 ` `t 4tti -s i Z k Y t Y .'" illt..t ., ; :'I ' a of r� tea, ).. k,.♦ *+ t .", $ { Z.f Jf!" f H N Sr J ` y `7 L , d w .� y ,,r sj,, �+ rt y A` . t't ti: T t s ;_s k i.: t tt. ll, c'iv � _ is '� r .� Y .k' / M •t.- •` ->F r.. i i 4 raw � ':r ) r l . ,.K. rK�M .> •t f -♦'r � 1`- 1-i .- y ..1Lt 1-. ti"2 Ir .---.�-.--- - ._- - ,� c l �"is t 3< !- i''r L . ' If; 4 t. 7. ,,,, f { • lr — REAR ELEVATION' r s :vn z t a 7 .r°.- '1 ,r 'k , A h 5�i t y r Lc T "r-til � y l n z'n r r1 , rr:c > ,{ L v y♦+ `mow.4 u ti ---t l hi-3Y�'- 1. ro a K -.'ti-tilt E ,, ti `j ,`--- •,t.,, r o. '.,. - a -r L _ ,,,`-2•;<,,,,,- ..-. °'w.ri c i'..e r:f -V- �•-i'`` '`e'4t�.E --_ t!- -0.. .,,rtY.'2`"�; at,.n '%; r e;%4 `*,,`-1.. yv h Sty : ,,• �.'." -,. - `i L:.�i izi-=�n` •' -s 4-y act-��•-.:Ye-� ,. 1';'' 4t .rY'c ti"-. '..,'V ce , s+ •'a ? —4x'r=-i Y: Y 3 S".aA sLrr '� n .r`t ' t .T' �.fi. -lia Y."C. ) d 1.. �-. i s ,yz7.2 . t - �ya, i i �^ "F ,yT'� ��'( hyk' `SL41. Y h. Rt� 5 ti {'.- rtil-k '' .." x'�1`v" •.-ry i� 4 �`.� T,e r5 tr S'' '4 d'' Zr*1c-`� r ., ,t r `$� ta"a. .i A---; 4`� t--ct. 1 t '-.- '6 y U^r Ya" �15 4 I:AA. }•k ti `'-c.4> X•.. r ki_i',t4;%"-_,:.., T5� 4 r� a,�.r"z��'� -�,.-s�;2,�' t,r•✓''s',`''i ,r" y1"`• ] 1 t ivz r ,�,. `+�. 1..-�sNt. rf4 ='"!. . yy ftia- } t ,r.` r<� �,'� 4>.r,1.,,:r:t 2 4.` } r W '*` -%1 -♦ \- . A'x.y1-.,i.. CJ s,r y -i -.r. 4''ia ,y.X s` -a tYL.'e, ,,.._ ,'...vY ss,F,:514 :i . -� ` ^r• ...- x S J 7 ',. Y1 } J lC.L ;:if.{"" 1 ,mac` Y Ly ..,1 9 k L S ` f"a r.k '♦ ,4 1 s }4 >i u 5-'t♦:`ia>;,,, .bu ,. .'_Y, . --^- �Z '`:.T% - Y y -ik 'C •r .-..�.�.- mot 4s ;I*j t".'�..Y,i'V- .t"`t-;-.---- 4• - i 't,.: '"' - T'•:-�i.'�'1 ` s t _ .4 -,fir;;-, a r Cyst K ✓ �. >5'� 3 : •.� = �" r y 3 �'i 1"`Sv ..r.v,rti"v� � vz.>< y tiw.-.f, ^'- .a�♦ '... �'�� �. ': tea. f yy'4. -�y^�� '?. 'j ••�'e'... - i ce,, Y'' 7%4 .-,S a. wit 3,. � '`�Z ., �.,,.c .,_• t „.-. - __ yam...'�*r u 7Z7 $,r%_&,k c 1,.. t • ' "{. / /• f +. -- ..f J r*.---.,--1`,-S 1' - 't: ate... i _ '—' f" ., :, 1 .:f . Tom. • r -� f }Lt L .~.,.- zit" fli"-w `.i: /•- 1" �� i� TM .,y- r 'z= L- Ay Sys \" ' ^ v6� '1 y3ti' Zi s i • Jt: :, ti _ l '.• ;. 'I -2-"h3 i.`-. _"` .ti_. a i. - fs.. "�5 �. v ", `- t' 3` -. ;:; .. . -. ra- .,.,� n �s i.j .„g,.. . . . � ,.-- c -,, i ., "" b ' �'i-- S te S`�x�1ua i } s 'i� a -.w ,:1 r "4•--r.,= ` -z�� .l.; f � t s t r-'r ,h ..>,y -v. .+3 Vie+i' i-r-..w"rc " ' '` 'S ?. y. ..+ti x: K.". >- s �. ` yo ,,,,,, e t4 sy `.; Z . .. • . ^ ' t x x rs 1 ,x. v". r.`G , cs - L >is v .. sy . •,c .� f� •- , Y,* ry .� 4�c` l. "al rti t S i:, z . ar z" �'�y "z h x,}. 3 t. 1 .. l?. -t^�"..;-1: 'y .5 $--+l f°'. C- •,.� 'L♦s.� !� .. - '�; a a-r� a _,?;} tiT' s,� .- 1t � --31su't.,t4 } L•..0 ., F. ; Sr, •'Y -s=7r'i -T ^:a , : � i ?� ,7r . s r7•FIREPLACE AND CHIMNEY • • ? L aL -m� iHyF,j t ,2 ,1•.... .tom y �" �,. r ,,,;... .�.; v ' '- ..� 't vt ., T- - a i Tr K} a � } - _ .w s .. f .. ,rkti --vv � �.,-. ti .�. ,..�•s 7 x.✓ • s5 ., A4, _.> t-.'t"'vs-'-:E'.,> '..• `j .e•:`1.. yyjt f-� . .�'.1; v �� J.<' .,� ,-..�ri;-31',-" � N ter.- -':- - ``. `..�. •z �. t t` i� r>7 , a> y1. ."""*` \�$Ftc �.. `.y •L.••+a �S`L _ J ? C - 7 a.,::"'.4'`` +1 cv>T..,, t‘.- \ - } .. .3�+r [• ` '.., -4..4 rrJ •-,.'c ;'_�i 4+.. ; ` t 11•y.,^ j - _r T ,_"f' 4,••C'4--L'`a• ...,.Z+ 73,,'` - v,s t�J .. 1. Z' 1 - sc ti r3i t q T r .J �' -.x .^'�r_..�' � \ '�.; ,�" -su �" ^ y4,7;" i-rz)%t"... < r3. :..r'�-V''" ty �" `T.,-C, .t.- w_.,.f r_1i 7"..tom �T?�'r '�" '.\. -'�.✓� V V �'-�1 L � �4' tom •ram"`7�1, .� z �� 49 ii 4•7.�, 7 SCUP 0\ PARAPET '1\7 -t-�,�gm , � t� i -' r t JET �- -f- _ ,i' ice` r i 3'""t`�✓t Fes ?' 1ti `• � `. �� . _ ' z , tip" ^� -_. 5 ryt z.. S\ 4 ��.4:q.r J� r w ..e. 5�{ } .Y• Y F f.t, .j T ,,,c_i .�`000 � L - { i. "1{ ".l. 4 yy • • i ` - FRONT PORCH OPENING SOUTH ELP`'ATI::'a "- - `�v r. - -• i - _.' �'t, tr.-* :t ✓ _` — �� �, ----:-1--" ✓may /\' 1%Y" tiy -i - �:-•'=-L•C...°2i., .71... ' ✓_mil,-,r.._.."� ��"�.�sb , it _7i, ♦ .--x.y C 7t } ''t t` t:* .y --r r - y., r Y '.c - .. .} ,J t.x !r v (s. - f f'L K' i, .`,•Y {i`� ,.L L L ., tf' - - ;1 4,, . i"f y .:',. -t .} 4' rv4_ - 7t^. af • -. ..t- r tii` i'. )<_i1 { "`. '< `t ?) ! j 3t w L a'7•'!d .= '^4 l;L Y tj r 3y s S .k-i ..,'e. YS ,. a:f°".,i s} • y c rss.V y. tRh t ,�' s iat"'•f r '....1 _)S tt " Y 5? y,'-i4 .. +. .' �� tit 5 ;1�,z 7.44 . i�}p; s ,.r �' 't '�� v J 1Z . .,11. ot.r + �N v - 4 .y .fit s♦ : cir. 4,"(tn f �� � , y,i f �. .v - .} N{" • t. . ::; ,..l ,, ,.J 2, e. . �. s T Y r-t J .. t. .`•,-~ a `A'1,L., s t :i-)t e L , �^ti l"s ?f.-c _'i', ^, -f i _ r 3 2 r: -- •( s 1 j• ` ,V,, } ;T- e ; t `. 7 c. `" ., • t� t f ' r y -f ,-.• L 5vr r •..' ,, 3 F,.'r { S•L.y` >�rjC(s'`.fA ti 4 J if._ • ,-;, ,.f _•.>-. 4. --, ,-- - .S ;. 3A. f i• .1;'- > ,.y. 4Zt 4 7.R3_ M1 v,{N' `. ;a�♦�-- ♦ r ti ; j- (' tit Js-f t� .y.,, -� -` .3Y" 5( y l 4 ;..:'..;3..,'-.;.::'."..c4,.r 'r,s• iT-1�f +1 W 'hir2c K\ ".. t t , �-. t,/ <. 1 ¢ =f? k r r xi1 :� fi s 3a>c .r-i {k t r l -, Y+ ‹s •,y s ,�L� r4 'r ` -, :\s 3 ti a..`r f 1,: ; kL.. i>. ^ " t .L Si a-'s r r „:1`.. r` a t ;l - tfI t>`-,"'}' `=`ris ;T ,,. µ '! 4cty-F�,r'7 :� `�,E. v,, 2 t : -, ", sue* ., }1 .,�y^ �Y Y -r r) ,,,r .t. �,i i s 'h it `� k ~ }c- r:�'� . L .ti: )r �.i.t�.r ti4 3 `^F may- 4 r 1 L. .r -ta.-i _,r, "r fir• .,Li t1 ,� ': '' 9 4f�- tf; o a 1 J-.4 }lrZ 3 i { tVt �,5 1i- 1 •'$ L. y-'•oS'J,.-. . r.7,.._.t1{.F r,, t f9 , y CS,t Ji3+r.. ->i .t. %• .l {"tr tt'terZ ! i sY'a✓' cY J l a f1 n' v Y'`' .i:- i,N l -Y S P-- 'e f ? s S :.-- --c+R„r s>�'< 4 jrt, : -- ---5 4•ty.r 3�• rtis r1 -1',_''c,,fY�'. y�Y -,rt ,::,-;. r• Y- i S. `M F 1 t r 2 h K.t T 'T ,' N 4}A r ♦ ice,r fr .•-[ �{.{ram. ._ `t2 .r. a. ..t . 1.4 s !t j{,� a:r ,15 J r i, _' Ytr„ e^ Y ,, i '".,-,. F :r 1 4Ss�r1 ~ ii"sit�.� "^ - { . '� �� s,,, ♦. s "�.' j, e Ct .�. top' ^�� +�P i t � i r- - -Sk•.N'f,r 1 i� r ++. h. ti is Cam+.y.,t�a e* t 'li r 4d3,4 „ -i �„. key ` y k i ,,tJ lrLLh :s. = r) J3�-. y .,,r -- w au ,>>IE ,g n t `4. i- f+.r t �- 5,15 G„.yZ.:4 yx. `T�p` r i J vld} ram'. i >�s. : .:. .,..;: .._. rF r { tL.l4j t. v 1,,V 3✓x„s 1 ` -i' i c "r1 rl'- ` rh > . l:. s..s )9,I,t "v s2�J ^+ :L r ?tl'+-" }....r-t.t, >..._ ` 'r -:� 7' ^'L r,,r s. f T; 1.. .4 ..r ;f 3�,:-,...,d': -Zi ♦:.. w1,.+ .~-,.f +. �,. i L-r 1"tii: r. L J c �,r.,z I .c ! r»` .y_�y t. X.^`` Jai f sc yt y c. •. - - ,-r,.'_r�±' .. ...a. --<.,y"5+"�t i itis �_a Ln�i,, t .yY` s:..t.,f. x,?:rr'..., .r� 'z--..y'4 r __ BELL CURVE ON FRONT PARAPET • ti-.--; " y rg Y.v� )ri - ,� 2r i• ' t � ,, M==:_ G f � . - 7z t Lf-ch ".5 . i - . r Y w� �7S r r. �. ue c. tiA 'c s f P n - 5z - r_ ♦ 't-z t , w 'i Yaa,r -�` ' Y - . :> _ , �'i, `� � , 4L +- 1 x .*ai '+ '; R Fp , s ) ' , Y r" Ji r7 , " a K `.s -r r r .c r , t 7 t` -'a' k ) v a ...wj e ',, r♦Sar '', s� .kr: e ,s-Zt.C,x ' ds'.' 1Y . . . S„A � ,,r ,...,- S tc r '-o f` . < A;- ,,,,} y4k , . _ rs~ , rs..=„ at "i 3� -, :,.t`f= r t:,¢rate <> r.� �` r .,k' s ,�' tr) 'ti �ti `. . •' t 'v,t. ' ci 0� 1- .�7' . T af rue,- . r ,, a4, .-p 4i?�y '1 -C . - `^ ,,,c .rr :t i 4 .Y } , t 1f g r 1. ' "` J ��< r ~ G r L ' i t'' X� rr;:r^ -v " r-"e • i sue-- �:7 "' z` --. f ` , I- r '+ r r 's -te,,- f t4` a y-. i ♦ pce0rr ,,f,- tP � -., -- ,. • 4 + fnr a r-c: r `i 'M''1l -)-- Yv t " c,x h',1/.. .5K 0 4 s5s f23ilr C l3- ^-, a f :,-tf%. 4 y :, v .. v: t i 1 .aT , @' " s. • t,"• lr,_., un`' =3 P ,z: s'S,-. . r- ,`,-7 ,Z r t , j . t"�sI �-,r r a ' - t= -,1'4-. .�y�a t v ''t a1 y --,2 _, . - ;F.,<`.. --r fr'{{N*Yr.♦ ate.,} )twtT W t.« `l-Y2' ti�3" -y^+`)''"6 [': F ; �< S c t• h=ti.; .t 4 '.r 1='3 s tt �i Rs. a1.4 �,.i. -i., tt,k-,.-+.r,-. - r t.'S?r''Y 'F}r,s Cf-., 4 s` -3�aft�C r n; T - e '4 r 73 st .1 `S r •z,r ir,z .?.tit�1�`�...�^^`.-� kr y �.rE-.;z1s��j+ .rf r+ te N s,�r ; 2' , , ,, -1• � 4+''' e r e. :- Y . >;.�yx •s 4. }.g, _`�-'N+ir: ' a s av - „ y" .-sS "t 1 .. �:, -tf-;-• t F 'a"L.-, f 'i t tf.' "- 4s'..-7-10v: .�i-Y':,_,-fr.c"` 'o..`^' T -,.: + Z _ \ '�r i `s. --c! a �.t.a,� ." 1 .y ' 's,l� S ,-,�c�'"`� yy 'tom .,+; '„` ', -,c- 7 ``'' r;�w' `c 1 �` )'iF. . ter-3`.' C Z ti s. •i- Z-•,i'. lF'k'. -S "'+ y 4, >_ ,S.c $ ..; i 1 { ;.` \' Fj2 t \ r`' ' : 4; .�,.. V .Z ZfirR t..r r )7s a.,� , 'fit. 7'u Ly - Z ' ` .'a �< .5 ♦ S.s.`‘.`": +ti a4��L•�, sue. -. :t ,• • '- "'': i ..ts.L; iti ). . i2 rho,,., ,s +" {i _`\ 4 . ,^ ` ti� ' y „'°ry/i`„ y`Q \ `,,om 2' j„i. , ' '3 us.,. „i ..-. i. 7- r 'r .L.\ yt.>: ?ram t.x'y )f.cr{.s1r t ;�":(s _ • iL `"^y-Y'.c'.,-;-; _i t '1 `�"a-.» , o•c -e sign $ �f -s4� .%` _ ` t -k . - ".. +..• _,: -1t'i.l, f �12 . S . _s•r';'.r;`3, & r.Z..T - BELL TOWER CHIMNEY CAP . - r' `. 11t t L+K .,r `3 -: c� ♦ 3! 1 ,♦ 1-v. )t`z E 2 C vteb f'.Y • .:. 4 ♦ 3 4_ -" - rvr 'S [ 'nl > JY3 ri } T •4 ^, � z4i's S iZ a ; '•jt- � � ? . s , i X ' ' fr nJ L )Sg;'': Y -r � r ' r "2 zz;" Wr --3 , f, jr^ ` l r w � jt t 1a „. rrl 1 Ir."kri. >W i > s s ♦ t 1 n3 I� > • Lei Y r., t Yt t73-- ,, � 4-- t ` -, ti „i » -3 - \ e'^ S C ,tF ',-5 1 r , 'c^,.t, ! •' <L. L. g 1 t 3: "I > _ ,,, ifY .s+.r S3C {4 , r"i {r t .� l Sd1 / a 5.� '' ^^- l•!-, 3.?•I � r • ei( F i,.Y✓j1 F.,! .-' -.st r^ i, X' . y ':• 3 -Z-+, ) jl .. iL" ., t.e Y}s`ez, 1 s fr. s � St'y r,. .r ' 4 Yr i�SQ4 a -22 "- rF`M`t"' ,a �r ti } �s >• e . w -",1 ram{ f` ` � ! t _ + } .• - .' S - J' ..� ' ` f ' `,� `� tti s :zT.`„.,„• • I { _ ,,_��S,, 2_ _ ,, ;i`it'4 h_-c '4_f.,,z t -R� i • • _ N . _ i'''.: , a• .�-jai-3'' -.Y.•i FORTH ELEVATION =l • :7 r_ -f 4:,'�Y;xJr= ice S k ^t ad *-U t- 1 - ,a i . ' h - G'i� Y �ij7 • l ,-. :[. ,V ) { ma �`r `L -� YytikI ° rts j �__.- -t de "^ —ai Ys r IT Yip � .+ •S" s.y ,� 7 a.. � } .. . ..,, ]w C "•� r�;--.•. -J - `r- .-.Yts".+�f^�}r � v••.,+��''T.ya'• l .-1 �.♦y..''�'r-�:)`y-rs, "^`��'. � ;�:\'"l c.a-4�� A'3em�, ;l rb : . :4 - -' t- v�' i• ^• __ a i a XI --- .-ck . - . s+ _ / `.' - tt -' f f /A + I\ - y - + 7������/ ��� kF "T"� ,'`" fit . L E^Y F S •• er , Yti t ♦ 1:r.: ,X;; fr - ` F `- �. fir_. ♦ :• \ ♦ .,=ti ' t FY 3. l y) / •••Y• i ., - , i •/ -, .�S � .zz2,s,� j fam - ` . yA' � rl b Y r f r 4'`• "ems ir t +> ` Stt . ye..yi5`--.�� - r .-01' ">i . -- tt '''' -t,' f t.Z4%, -rr - F / tT 4�Y' I r s 11" <Z `,, �V ,r.a -¢ 't" - 1f '� - Jry } - '5, y .� 4 r l; ;+^� i-sTa , r°^'c�' %ems �in':">1 '''' --�-Y'-•.. C I? T - -,,-ti,1 1 v,, fy., r,z' .'{ '•s z- y.r rii .13_ ` .• -.. ,I f5y ,• y _ w N ! - , - " ` hi . -•au t..,t, c Y _y1 ':t 4t - /"t ♦ t' L ^•t - } '!�r �. . Sr t '1r = 'r ;_; ta � aFram- -ccs 431t.:•=a,+r ;f w.t. . 1',,;--. _..-.:•> __.._-..L..es.•....•n-,. y.,1 .-.aw.s; :ac.. _....-_....,.,..�. .Ys .--�.dr:,_ r• SOUTH ELEVATION STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING DECEMBER 7 , 1994 AGENDA ITEM II .B. SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD Conduct a Public Hearing to obtain comments from the public with respect to recommending to the City Commission that the Susan Williams House be placed on the Local Register of Historic Places . THE PUBLIC HEARING Pursuant to Section 4 .5 . 1(C) (4) of the Land Development Regulations the Historic Preservation Board will conduct a Public Hearing with respect to the historic designation of the Susan Williams House. The purpose of the Public Hearing is to allow the public to comment on a proposal to have the Susan Williams House designated as a Local Historic Site. Based on the analysis and testimony presented at the meeting, the Board will make a recommendation to the City Commission as to its placement on the Local Register of Historic Places . Pursuant to LDR Section 4 .5 . 1(B) , the Board determined at its meeting of November 2, 1994 that the subject property conforms to the criteria for designation based on positive findings to LDR Section 4 . 5 . 1(B) (2) (d) and (e) and 4 .5 . 1(B) (3) (a) and (b) . After hearing public testimony pro and con the Board will make its recommendation to the City Commission. Y o W LM H P B.DOC DESIGNATIONF-z1,5 _ , , _ ...,), , _4.," ,,,,x, 0 , — , .,,,, <, „ , p ,...„ , , ,, REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA / , e,-,7,Wit::;:f3z•:•: ;:sf,;-4 4.;-..- .:-';',.?t,-,-'3. -4';,:.%-, 4.,• `-f.4,• --- ,------- • ';.-:-v--. .=-`•- i t• ''' .?•-•;7,. "rm ---,1t't --- , -,..,..,... y.::.,.„�v`i „--�3-. t } c. �.. ��t •,j,-_,71,,-;-_ ,_ " .w _,,,.1_ ^'K y • +-R•^"`. t....,_ _..„_sim._ ..- > �_;�� til -u� ..Sr r-1 -r. ' >: -s.�-.4. jcv -- " ,.� ..bGa ---A, }Y5, M' • t 'Sg2 ',/t } T�. rn• yr y�-".2- _ 4=4 • .at 't`s•v wry• �' i�'X , ^-c.. a* s s b r.z<*'. '.a t ci{' .�-. k � s r 1 r.-s. • .�.s,T- - .c�4. 'I7,II .y� boo- .rf i `3.�i., x: .. "' {rr -'wc. �;,zt•s .t T".sk"- �tii~t ' - ..r3 .d'3 -'y %lk. S" Y }^R -is. ."'•2-'FeQe t. Yy t. .4.�. wil" fib .- 3 , l F5 -'T • £.y, ..1 [i! \�ill}17, Ttz, -;!XP%-• L' -'ter -, ,:4 Por THE SUSAN WILLIAMS HOUSE 30 N.W 3RD AVENUE CONSTRUCTED 1935 Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 2 DESIGNATION REPORT: 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE TABLE OF CONTENTS I . GENERAL INFORMATION II . LOCATION MAP III . ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION IV. HISTORICAL INFORMATION V. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE VI . BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES VII . PHOTOGRAPHY Report prepared October 1994 by Vera Farrington, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board Member and Patricia Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner, City of Delray Beach. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue a Page 3 I . GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Date of Construction: 1935 Architect: Unknown Builder: Isaiah Bruin, originally from Quincy, Florida Present Owner: Douglas T. Williams, 118 N.W. 8th Avenue, Delray Beach FL 33444 . Present Use: Residential, single family Present Zoning: R-1A, Single Family Residential Legal Description: Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36, Town of Delray, originally Town of Linton Property Control Number: 12-43-46-16-01-036-0050 Classification for Designation: Architectural significance, good example of bungalow style. Cultural Significance, home of one of the first midwives in the community. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 4 II . MAP __ . ]�._ J ti < Q—� '< -- r _____ _._. , ___. 2:0 ST. WE �2:NC z n Ill_i I W L (-^T Si z :o "'1 < "Y Lill i CITY — J HALL I_ __- -Q 1/L[- 1ST St �_ 1 N.E. 1ST 111 - I I 3 z OLD SCHOOL Z z z SQUARE � TENNIS - 'WI 1I1l1i11I1Il11 S,ADIUU I I 1 ATLANTIC AVENUE I(�1I ICI 1 jl(l l 5 DEPJRTIIENT oLicE WU err 1 1 ` ` + , 5' COURT aT—, a � HOUSE ._ _ i o z i _ cf N ; I 1 P __. tn • A. ST, (!T S.E. 1ST S.W. 1ST - = _ _ to N — "� 30 N.W. 3RD AVENUE r..A.k`:NG D67 AR 711 CM C::f Cr DCMY BEACH.R. -- Os 4L 8)$£U4P 5i tW-- Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 5 III . Architectural Information The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is a good example of the South Florida bungalow style as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . Many of these homes were built from pre-designed plans purchased from publications such as the Home Owners Service Institute catalog and the AIA sponsored Architects Small House Service Bureau, or from local lumber companies . But whether designed by an architect, or constructed by local builders from pre-designed plans, they all share the basic design elements of the bungalow. Walls : Horizontal wood or stucco exterior facing. Roof: Low pitched gable roof with the ridge either perpendicular or parallel to the street; often with multiple gables . If the primary ridge is perpendicular to the street, the front porch is usually roofed with a separate offset gable. Roofs often have exposed rafter tails . Porch: Porches are prominent. They are usually deep and extend the full width of the facade. The porch roof is supported by piers . The design of the pier supports is usually unique to the house and varies depending on the creativity of the builder. Windows : Double hung or casement, multi-paned and arranged for cross ventilation Plan: Usually rectangular and often modest in scale. The Williams House contains many of the classic bungalow features . There are two gables at right angles to the street and an opposing gable roof covering the front porch. The porch roof is supported by 2 traditional massive piers which are broken at the middle with a molded cap. Above the cap the piers taper gradually to the porch roof's supporting beam. Exposed rafters are visible throughout. Original casement windows with a 4 over 1 pane configurations are a feature of the front facade adjoining the porch. All of the original multi-paned windows are in place and most of the functioning wood shutters are existing. The house originally had wood siding and possibly a wood shingle trim. However, the facing has been covered with vinyl siding so it is not possible on visual inspection to determine what style of wood siding was used. The house has a composite shingle roof. The foundation is a combination of pier and cement block. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 6 IV. Historical Information The house is located on Lots 5 & 6 of Block 36 . This block was subdivided into 16 lots when the Town of Linton was platted in 1895 . In 1913 the block was replatted by the owners, J.H. Jackson and W.H. Brady; 39 smaller lots were created out of the original 16 . Lots 5 and 6, and most of the replatted lots were purchased by George H. Green and his wife and the balance were owned by W.H. Brady and his wife. By 1922 there were 14 structures on the block including the Primitive Baptist Church on the northeast corner, and two grocery stores fronting on W. Atlantic Avenue. When the Town of Linton was platted all of the streets had names, the change from names to numbers was adopted in 1924 . The streets which bounded Block 36 were as follows: on the east, N. Beatty Street (N.W. 3rd Avenue) ; on the west N. Larson Street (N.W. 4th Avenue) ; to the north, Miller Street (N.W. 1st Street) . Though the historic house was not owned by Susan Williams, she resided there during the last 4 years of her life. The property will be listed on the Local Register as the Susan Williams House. Susan Currie Williams was born in the Bahamas in 1870 . In about 1898 she and her husband and their small daughter Agnes, boarded the Sir Charles Orr and set sail for their new life in the Town of Delray. Susan Williams had been trained as a midwife in the Bahamas and it is possible that she had been asked to come here by the Bahamian settlers who had established themselves in the community. Her services were soon in demand, both as a midwife and general nurse practitioner. The town did not have a resident doctor until J.R. Cason set up practice in 1905, ten years after the first settlers arrived. Medical facilities were available in West Palm Beach but one had to travel by train (Florida East Coast Railroad) to get there. A compete o b bies did notingmeiddwife was essential to the community, a r arrivals to conform to train schedules . Nurse "Susie" Williams delivered black and white babies alike and gave other medical attention as needed. As medical facilities became available and doctors moved to the City, Susan was called upon by the medical profession for home nursing. Tall, slender and imposing in her white uniform and dark cloak, she is remembered even today, by those who recall seeing her striding purposefully along with her black medical bag in hand. The original Williams homesite, now demolished, was located at the southwest corner of S.W. 4th Street and S .W. 4th Avenue. Susan William' s daughter, Agnes, married Grover Cleveland Munnings in 1924 . Mr and Mrs Munnings purchased Lots 5 & 6 and built the bungalow in 1935 . At the age of 80 Susan Williams suffered a stroke and moved 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue to be with her daughter and son-in-law. After a long and distinguished career in public service Susan Williams died 4 years later in 1954 at the age of 84 . Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 7 V. Statement of Significance and Criteria for Designation Statement of Significance The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue, also known as the Susan Williams House, is a good example of a modest residential bungalow as built in Delray Beach during the 1920s and 30s . The house presents the major physical elements typical of bungalow construction. With the exception of the vinyl siding which has been installed over the original wood siding, most of the bungalow's defining character remains in tact . Additionally, for the last 4 years of her life, the bungalow was the home of Susan Williams one of Delray Beach' s first midwives . It should be noted that the original Williams homesite has been demolished, as have many significant buildings in the historic black community. It is appropriate that this building be listed on the Local Register of Historic Places for it is worthy of the protection and special consideration afforded by that designation. Criteria for Designation Section 4 .5 . 1(B) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach outlines the criteria for designating properties or sites to the Local Register of Historic Places . It suggests that at least one criteria from paragraphs (2) or (3) must be met to justify designation. Listed below are the criteria which relate to this property and justification for designation. (2) "A building, structure, site, interior, or district will be deemed to have historical or cultural significance if it meets one or more of the following criteria: (a) "Is associated in a significant way with the life or activities of a major person important in the city, state, or national history ( for example, the homestead of a local founding family) . " The house at 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue was the home of Susan Williams, one of the first midwives in the City, from 1950 until her death in 1954 . For 10 years after the first settlers arrived 1895 the community had no doctor, the nearest medical assistance was in West Palm Beach. The presence of a competent midwife was not only significant but essential to both the black and white citizens of the community. Because the original Susan Williams homesite has been demolished, it is appropriate to recognize the house she occupied during the last years of her life. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 8 ( 3) "A building, structure, site of district is deemed= O=-haw-e architectural or aesthetic significance if it fulfills one or more of the following criteria. " (a) "Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by one or more distinctive architectural styles . " This house is characteristic of the many modest bungalows built in the community during the 1920s and 30s . It is appropriate to offer recognition and some protection to this structure because many of the early bungalows have been demolished, or have been altered in such a way that the original style cannot be identified. (b) "Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style period, or method of construction. " The Susan Williams house contains most of the distinguishing characteristics of the bungalow style. It has a double gabled roof with an opposing gable over the porch roof . Exposed rafter tails are used throughout the roof construction. The front porch is prominent and its roof is supported with massive piers . The plan of the house is rectangular and the multi-paned windows are massed for cross ventilation. 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue is worthy of being designated to the Local Register of Historic Places . It more than fulfills the criteria for designation as set forth in Section 4 .5. 1(B) , which requires that only one criteria be met. Designation Report 30 N.W. 3rd Avenue Page 9 VI . Bibliography and Sources Delray Beach Design Guidelines, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, 1990 Resourceful Rehab, Metropolitan Dade County, Division of Historic Preservation, 1987 City Building Cards Property Assessors Records, 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1926 & 1941 . Oral History Documentation: Douglas Williams , Grandson Agnes Munnings , Daughter v I • • � _ t 1 f `� i 3" ,..�y.,,F -c.�-ice-- - � r �' 7 f4 4,r+2 f �; �1 Xy� Fhb `4�5, ... t' l .li ci s rr`..} . wr ~ �� `' I 5 r r `•-st ~ -'fi �.I7""s: + (�#` -�f (p sG+F� y, .t f • o- r w ;l y -s^' ._ass. .,-r __"_-- r L ; ' K $ Y' .. f4 `z 4; ..`;: Ewa... ' w� .t ,� �..; - •a .S, yr ;{�.} --"..ti�� i.;� �.. y '> .q� �.� X _ • '3 .ski s--xw' "1 � +z •1 "`4 •41 �' f''. � . .f. .��, �T L .-< - . v. t4 "L- - ,•: 5 f j�5., ..a'y,.r-� " ' - �' � 4 r_ rE"`r -- 1f P 4 i .:.4 _. ,- l i -Y' '' �'�,' z £ r �rsrt,Y'�:•t, +�N f �A. i -� .qt i t,� r i`r E F _:y � -G`t` "` .e. his 2 ;. y - " p' 5 `Z0-' e , e '' . ' 3 4' -'"? . 'Z �, i s i it �-'. r _ � u. , 15 u z F •' I t i tj x # Y L y._ s �'s �; r _ ■•ra art l Y�..,�y..; +�, i 3'. _ t -�N5 b.t G�3"t. Y a��-,f+- kl X{ :.: 'iti , ��,. ,r '�•.^ F • .,�- F .-f, k� .7 :`& i - .`fir '.: _ ,..k- •- •'` s,ts t r,%w - rt- ;FE .,y j t y -,,c S r J:y..- .... �1r �2T?�`�.`r�G. . Z -fir r t� [ c.s.-- .tl,.r ^.4y t^- 5.�' ..:.•. ras { t • .^ . + tt-`y�` �G•Y�', �A s .a+r'jli y, L .sue IV�' l. 4 9 A f "mi } y ,1 T{„r .x;----v'v-tv ."-= `Y.^\,.xe •.- y 6. ', . *+r `--•'• .-74 afit lf•J^e3C r . G' 4 Y, am. "• y x �, E'4,- £ • i' � ' .c: Vi.T ,'` 4 - - '', .i • ' i - j � e '-'4, 'c„�: 1e • a''.- / °'`9 " • • • ((• >f` Cx-' '�. l�'t..`."It ,fu t IV: - { — g 1_};' ..tom i�ja •'F n Y .• .J+, ,,,, F`�",} Y"t}- 4Yj/Y. s. -t`" 1 4 �SFY-. ,3r rs.3 t h XS E- .'��' 1 Y .c rT. >.r fM, i.. -` 1 ▪ t• r t _ y J __'t `t 4 4f1 .t• a tiS.`_' ., :+ i c ,, -- f r /Zi-- `i.- -�i,. •S< ::_ �/`r J• ..i,4 7 ., 4 s -.w• - it L• 'y`ri ▪ I riff r ` j t .h r,- . G �,5 -<1.e.1 z.1�- t -,.••F''xs-•4,rC" e•.r-S A t �., } y Y y ` r "-S. Fk .� �' s.�f ci_ tr `-i✓ r'itA'+3'�-s= i +' ' �{ -F-Y.. `Ya^• '` 1P t'C > r .,. ., is t .s -r^K'. ) -fti5c•J j4"' <fw• rYit' f r 2- 'rbt.`-i4; , 7 `C ..r�',L-33 i.., t 't l`•tz ,c.-r1, —5 il-0 ,v, "` .r.i.cam -' F_ - "a ' Y Y ,••� y a "r.�� t z 4-` :;r,� ,,Ns,i,: ..a _3 c..,,ti .ny s C may,,._ ;• "'w Lw <4 ir. t t"'}.. i.4 1.af-+2 „%?,,.cr, - - ,%.a,,ra. `,, ,,,,y, x.t. ,, j,a ,t- '�, c '. r•� ,;z`-. • 1 . } •,- -,,, — :. e._.,-: •.- ` -r it 4= ,, -sue` __ ,',., z-f i• m `,,y ¢ j�.�s,., 1 v,,r¢▪x,;,--. ,.._ �`i t`f 5 .„... 3.'-f._ x, f7 1 r* ��- t r r ` ,A e s`4t ,3c -„,•r'`•.4 T J � 'y. ;ram " ',;"�" ,SG .^"p."„{ w.r ". F �Nrs`'L Y"`r3-t Sa,: " . a-4 -L�S-G ` a Z k.� �-.�. 4 fi.,� LF *'{ ', l 'yk" '7 ..,i�'�C'V4.A-;*-t y. ... .t- 44.... '.,, 1.a l"'' '•i,+ 'F riyy-�,. p '? Y,.,-?7 kN:r� $.-�_r�'hnra?+��.::;.-.. A.-.- _--k, . `,r'� 7.Ftt�,-'Y `yY�f4 7..,.ni�b" '-„+!t • YF yy ,,.i, y .-> r7 Yt S., >v. -S _ I,.¢ j&L'� - `h ,X▪ S _ {" ,. t SrJC 'a•" " ' 7"' `., -;,- • ".,..c• t s.r'} `Y '' y,'t,34 ,R1Y..r' r _ S X!4{ —Z F 'S- ` J �'1 r i ti• t{ ? t .,i 14 4Pik �-. .e'..x �w-Y- ,z -•ate- a_-• Y P. .e...�-..-.- - , ,..t-;v.... ,-At_____..„*--1.-.---±1%..,!i::• -;:..77,„„,-.,..%-14-S,,,,:;,`SMei.4<?-7,,:i:;..-L-'74,r.I,.-,-,;l'i?-7i::-.14•7-4. t- .-----.------.. '''' * =/7,464 `fi ;. r�FS- .,e. r r rt { l. `.' -, �is' X( y , ►" sr 4'3.. J r f if• ,. 3 _" •°1 .tyr"i'o Sw�*�}"�..�S•r�'4 �,4'Yyr` ti,� CI '•-^�Y .'y• '.x �- II ir r - L.`��-t rt.'1 lY S Yt_. t, '- � j 4[2i�{(, +...., .x` ZJ .ram .s. i t ,v c t41 C- +`"'Y� ""'. z�' c .� �y';17., 4i �� I `� 1-,es ` .1 �i' ,. _, " '�+"1', i;5 .i .I f % ti �`..M<tiST. ry h,},,--Ss ..f,.-�'4 t} wl,,I.. �.t'-y}"F'7 ,_: i.. .\ �, r ti. Cr r t,c y,.-'.'?,. -a M •T L' �'` . x,4 ,� 3.+7 ) ._.r <d L,a'� T , `'�,."'4-l' �'`-�}, `� --.,7 ,zc' ,,. "� 3 +1 -s , �s `r -. ' Zti � sT �4 f ? '3? cam -,,,,,-,A.r n T' 3.,..._ \,.,:::,,L,;,:-,-_‘,.--' ,,,--+t r st 3;` :i'` 1- 9* -4' "' f 4r--,-Pr,Z;:ON..,...-zi.1-i.,•-c;-k;l:*4,-. i....-tc .ram - c. -t,r.y 4 s' i. . r- .fit-• K � ice' 'K+lh- � �',+A.fy� ..V,> -'+�... . v4?'' ��. 1, r 4- t 4 6-j- S -.:. .i _ .. 14- z y;, (, . rat k. li y 4 . ,yam u..,,��y 'fr -41x_ K �Y..L t i..l'�a�T^,� '�.'�� Ky��s,,.�, �r. '' tt[lt F Y .h 4CY '�"C Y N. CF• ' <�2rzS.\ J� r �i 1 }.? z t 1t c s ^" >i k- i� fir s�t�,.Y1}'., y ff+4;..7,....-1;1:.---c:',iti ''"`1 -`--.. .. .v r t 4 k ��t,. ..,. > :z. . F•f >> ja i :7, Y.<'<i. •j ,:', K r - x `�T4; -CIC.r Ja t, : .,, S ... •�. 7 1`' -. �r'S 4yk`r { r�r- z 6 �'S.`�r' Tyzt-^. �� _ + t f ,q�;ytiti. • t _t' ,-t-' 3 -� _`"-y't z._. i.•-z.t sr- .:;,.?r• . }.y.. �.._.rn�...r,�-+cr_.4 z�,.- '�Y �!!!Rtt rt-c 5 rk i .3,Y .�U+._,::,,St ..-- v, -'„~\.l -r-l-- 4+,,,, J.i !,:i.:7K 4 -,.`r�J + "✓L�3 f-;1, / 1 lr.',: p-- x •-r Lz 4.ea ,at3-. .I 5 J .2 ., ) at,` .,,1.. f.^ k-t- -3 r tt it > F `•�.. y..4a^r .f'4\f�2 ^`y -,,,-. '� 5 S• .r h� r am'-t,s 2` ,. r , .-..'y x 7. .,. r,..'c. + "'u9 i^ he. ;? •Y L.Fi.L a-,,.'^' it . r* � k 1'/ t.>. lr 4 ; ti a �1. 4.%. ,, •5 •rn.;•k 3�.Y�J-Tl7y .f:> )i i �gl -P.`�+Z� ?sy .. r �':: tf�s/i�A .t H' r (.°'14r{-`. .E '-�. 3 n�c s A-ii'y.,..S ° '. `-. .c. ' .t A' ?�'t�55+. .'„'•"- ~4. s 1 z. F .}a F > r i ` :- ,�rrk".�".. --.,2^`t �f n� 4 .r a i� ?� !. s�k,,r�s. s r' n < - yly > r.. xr N hS• `�_ ..n t, .4J'-k r J• }_ ir.?. s q" N i i' ;-. ,7 `".' 1�.rah 1� -t .r?,k4_.'•-tis- y.14: -1 -a- .,...• :-.,--V.v '+, f. y .r Y+< :ti,, �s •, iy .{` >-•' Zt ✓T .. f a7• l" l- r. ,.`- �?:F � Z y�i ,4-Y .S' • i-f'k a } r.~' r t � ?.- a' --14.7 `:;>. � =� p, •�"Z- ; a �ei .. A1 .A r � -.1. i+" �- . n �'`C F 3 3•r <' yz- c-'a t'z zit.. - .; h h aV- '-k. r --—mil,r I d,•. ,!• r. '4 ",, kv. 1"'F`7 ? �` .cv...-, N - Tr+ `•.x r',L'rr..;; {r'�L < ';1< � it � `7s+ se a it _q -_*:•F•ei s3; �--LI • `Lr��„,.,1A-S--5-.4rScs9,,".,9,1_"r' r ti--w. ts--te h'C� *4. � "yi -er,��a �r-� 1,,z F�, r.,Cs xny �g b a' ' 4` °'z- iS� r.. _ ca,-. � •^'af( - .-•C,'-F j_ ., ✓-p N� >"-vyTMz'.C�«•`+-F ✓/tom t� ti"^ �,�� Zr C�. � .,e r3'IF �u' �r.-r"? tiR i �r3 K+'i`c , �..?';i3- ': r-,. :,t,r .e7-G�i•:.,.+ { t*F •z-41-i•u ;•c. r•..�: r i.%•:- r,,-i.,." `'' r �`CY'rYs,:it 1c +•$'-`L'�ry." y'}•+.- .;,• t Z--s „ L ..e }yJ._ r•_`i„s 77 1:'•t'ali�4V7-rt.-%^ ',1' -^J -1-i -,.74�2y�- .. ,,,,,,,,, s s," , ;:'twY-y.!y ` .-2t` n z.15 .., >.:7__.s 31,s Y-cS L•+ I.'~-". .§C:'ase'S>as:'is �< zs��§ Y r %.,,,a4.. .., . . .., ......c..,),,t‘„,...,W: ....-- -1...,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.. ..,... E_ , ��( lam"\ , ' ",.^ fit'..*. r _ iFil� +t c ,1 l _may VVV--- .. t.' '* t`1.v �ai� .\ '..-„yam\ ,, j.kV+, r V ,tt,7. 4 . fix^,. V � � `e ... ..:.,.....,...1... _.,........,..,,, .. . .,7.4..„,,,. . . a�a� ✓• ° i r Yv J - ✓<..,..„1!...._..,..,1„,,,. ...,,,..10 .. .......:. ..._4\._ _..,_...7...:„7.7_,. ... . ...f,..„„,„ „...,,,...,.. , ,rt. 17-7-1--,÷.-r• . '1,1 '-k-.•H • :.-''''!"',--'' -::-,.;.,• ,,r-:'. am:: • 1s► a } .,!t�. l Lew - .a SV�'a'. ....ar-T 44' h }tom- -s }�- _ _ ` # '-'' sr ' + ,' •1 3 F c > +t_. 3 x �d may * �fa� i 4yr A'+o-' .T {, a _.------,,,,A,,,, vRf t :dr ail �•r it.Jx rr•`• .. l,GA.:1.:.y �y f' ryl� �.� —..zr� 0,,?• 'c�v,,'Z` -.� r'3e,+c '�,..(-�,„h k,�w r i.-v x r x ty .T'���'a• t-,sue. •. R A4..;-.�J' . •y.e S. .., ,j.^k 4 av"'-r '. •''.'1 , rS- 3-,. `:%-,,,t.t.f `CYr•'- -T- - l''.r - -',r,.'l i. �`.: ..; ,-".''`•4"•t C >`A ?,. f1.,,,- s-7� -k, :1- `.7 y ci fi.ry,v ' : • r _s .- ......r-_ ;� ,1...-: ,,t ';N .,,,.'yi j_ .:1„zi �L,r?�- v . r-fi^•A`''k;E' -.. 'ft" F .�1 - apt.' . t•-�.• , -:= :z' f -•' "''e ri _<-4+„ a ,"�.4'ti j tia ^ * _ • .�-`i• ;::-.r ' �tI .0 ,"•'�E-..c'{i:ti .•'. V. •:r -,.,.. . .,.4,-.-3./Vm,.:•-;ti • L'�-. N't':Y-I-"'•'.• .. CZ ,[�'r►`.7-? >'-::� \j,1_, .- { �i . _,L f t.. -57 _�?: a -�S��-v s- ''� c. ��i'`�'S^�1.:?t�Lx:�� 'c. .�f� .\ .o.i..17rch o.:�-.i-�.. �.G� r.x`�,`7i'31.�.7ai4.2is n .ciL STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING NOVEMBER 16, 1994 AGENDA ITEM III .A. COA 8-239 Villa Delray Seasonal Rentals 127 S.E . 7th Avenue Marina Historic District Youliy and Magdalena Popov, Owner ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is that of approving a free standing sign to be located at the entrance to the parking lot associated with the Villa Delray Seasonal Rentals . BACKGROUND Villa Delray Seasonal Rentals is located on the east side of S .E. 7th Avenue, south of S .E. 1st Street. According to City records, the building was constructed in 1951 for use as an apartment complex. The building has been used as a seasonal rental (weekly, monthly) by various owners since 1956 . The property is currently zoned RM (Medium Density Residential) , which does not allow weekly rentals as they are commercial in nature . Thus , the current use is non-conforming. No further development history exists for the subject property. ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT The proposal is to erect a double faced free-standing wood sign. The sign face is approximately 3 ' x 2 ' and will stand 6 ' high. The background of the sign is white with gold and green text, and pink, yellow, green, and peach flowers and leaves. The sign will not be illuminated. There is no indication that a previous sign existed on the subject property. The sign and its location were approved by the Community Improvement Department' s Sign Review Committee, at its December 2nd meeting, subject to review by the Historic Preservation Board. Staff Comments The sign will be located 5 ' from the western property line and 29 ' from the southern property line (see attached survey) . The applicant has submitted a variance removal agreement which states that the sign will be removed if the setback area is ever needed by the City. 0 4 • 127 S.E. 7TH AVE. LOT 22 AND THE SOUTH 22 FEET OF LOT 23,BLOCK 126 �T ;•fi'trl fodndP —O `�°h4o — A SUBDIVISION OF BLOCK �I z ` ivederyP> o I I 126, DEL RAY FLORIDA l 72.00' I 8_lom. � •50. �� �' or According to the plat recorded in Plat hook 11,Page 4,as recorded in the public records of 22' 2A' tor i focl/7d //e".I.•• - I 1 \ Y Palm Beach County,Florida;said land situate,lying,and being in Palm Beach County, I, • ,..• t — ti 0 Fovcyd I - Florida. tone./ -i' I I ea'aIr_ -- 1 U A L ' 'il• 5 ;i2 AV 1: /rf'—I- I 5do• \ • ;t y !. f \n \/ \ St + < 1 Sf Mij 41 vvi76 i `'f �2 �° N \ '' �i st 1 ' , \ \ \ \ \ 'vorTh 3 � 5 ; CD IOB' 500, l—�JS„U. CI :i •it• .L n < SN 7/ r p 1 NORTH o�ehb. c90o -x 6 Si r Sin 1).!!: IM—Ia. t Not to Scale Pit/a Co✓arced ( O Q 6 SI I > ~" CngC, wd// y,. , anI '637 SI 7aS! 7Sty Vicinity = 1 I Map 1 Z Lit..non rod R radius (} =central angle P.O.il.a point of beglnninp 11/L:.utility easement 07'Chh l I.P.=iron pipe L=arc length CL=centerline P.C.=pool of curvature fi=bearing basis lino wd// Mph=asphalt Fsmt=easement Conc.::concrete P.O.C.=pant of commencement 0/S: offset b �+ p Candied To: 7 YQ)O�Lrt �21Q�f�����l.. r L � �"cy' YOULII'1'O1'OV AND MAGDAI.ICNA 1'UI'(>V Jf/ ��^•� 1 S.I_.4th Ave.,:wile 205 ✓�Chd:rl nK • I �ti 5c:,; Delray©each,FL 33483 6 SOUND MORTGAGE CORPORATION r h , ,,• Phone 407•.'.n3-c(',24 r fanCa z t • ,f1 Fax z<3.4n6s Its'Successors and/or Assigns ATIMA 71,t�` Wont Palm 7;tfe76:19 O✓c✓Ore7K/0 - h1.'(�I. ), �U .�� We a I*dm Fax e,76nt DIsh1LA}'TITLE&ABSTRACT COMPANY ' �N 0 _ _ __.. _ Toll Free 1-8W//3 bb31 Fax Free 1•l oo'J'✓1-nnoo STEWART TITLE GUARANTY COMPANY found/'=R I p O / >a��i�S P!�1v • I hereby certify that the'Sketch of(3ound;fry Survey' Food Zone: "x" �`/o / r "f,'P/✓UF C 47 7' shown hereon meets the minimum technical standards ( Ma No: t7 '0 1 , set forth in Chapter 21 HH-G, Florida Administrative P 5 T-Oao•a v q ?'� -- Code pursuant to Section 472.027. Florida Statutes. 1 •-._ _ map Dam: I-5-9'� Nor:valid witless or' 72.00' Unless otherwise noted elevations shown hereon are with embossed based on the� Nationals eodetic Vertical Mourne;1929. nod t."nri/ ',ore hit/.r•,41nn Ohl I Dorn: 4.1'. , 4 HPB Staff Report Villa Delray Sign Page 2 The Marina District is residential in character. As such, staff has concerns whether a free-standing sign infers a commercial use and therefore, may cause proliferation of additional signs in the district for similar uses . It may be more appropriate to locate the sign on the building so as not to detract from the residential character of the neighborhood. If relocated, a positive finding to the Design Guidelines can be made. ALTERNATIVE ACTION 1 . Continue with direction. 2 . Approve the sign associated with COA 8-239 based upon positive findings to the Design Guidelines; Signage. 3 . Deny the sign associated with COA 8-239 based upon failure to make positive findings to the Design Guidelines; Signage. RECOMMENDED ACTION By motion, approve the sign associated with COA 8-239 with the condition that the sign be relocated onto the building. Attachments *Survey & Sign Elevation Y:V=LADRAY_DOC ,. . , _ _I __ . .•. I , . , ..? ,,., „., .../, I -..... „,....--..-----\....._. . 1 , l• 11 (-14-.\ LI---:-•'-"' :LT ! .4 „..1 I • , • 1 1 . SIGN REVIEW <__.... PLAN REVIEW , STAFF REVIEW SPRAB , 3 I ENGINEERING : )(-, . I -- • . 1 4i-•"‘N_ N. /-1 MS .j • i - (a s .sCID%c`‘c i i • 1 ,..% . . . . . i • i i . • ,i 1 X t .)'. i,..'..;• ' _-- 3 ,0 r j 41 ‹...._. „... .../ i • ---> ! .-1...." 1 ,.,---:-. .-:4-1..,.-,..• 1 t;;,, ...„..;?,,...,.....,. .,.;_..,.-..---',.,.....-_,,,2,---.\„,',:%,N..-....1...'-fr.-:,'-', '''',7=-•,,'-',"','— , - •--s----- .,z,..-7.-. -7:,..':',--.?'..:—"..'--,--,.':-.----,-',1-..,.=-•:,:-`•.;.,..,:• .,--r-,-;„.:':.-•;,,,:.:',..,--;.1.,:.,..7,-,,,-..."..,..'..:..-...'.cc.,.: . ....1*.....,,..,?t•aorTout.................,......................... ---.t,-- ..4*. :i•t-, . . . . , -, ":,- 4. . ::::2-',-i;,--:'?:':-';.•',1-`--:,:".i.:. `-,i..' .'.1 'rr,,' ;.'-,:':i'-•'2''..:''..., ':':'zi%Z.45;-W!''.1".•'.':.;.:4,,.!--':, -,:-.1:,'-'":',.. :.::::r.'::-'..-.?1...-:1.:r-:, .fi'T;'.'-,:i:::":7` __ ... A... . ... , ":=41., ;:::----7::'.'4,1':z."1 r;..?-4*"-:,,,..`..-.1';!:;--,,.:-.X.:4;:•-.::...:.--,,,...i.::;..,,:_,:,.-_-,-..,. .2.-:.„.+.:,..„,....,..:•4 - ,. ,......„--,....-,-,,t,71.-..'r-•,--,.''... '-... •- ... ):-ei---.--- .;.,. 4 '%7::-,t'L,-;'"I'Y ';%'•',.-,.;:-i:-.:i.,,:::..,.1%..,-.-,-"'-'---_...,.,,,,,,7_.. ..k.. -:"-,•;-.4..7,4-`V ..0%'•..--f.,V;;,-.'. V.',.'f"'. . - , -,... „ . e;*?-'11.!...,,;7tN.95.---;kic4'..•!f::.:.!:•.--.-.1.',.- ..:...,,,:i:.1"..:,-,z1-..q :-. :i.:: .,,-ri;fr..',:."•;;;;.....-., -,,,-Vi:..:-.,k• -4,7,-;%.,,,,,..-., - --::,,,-;:•_,:',',.'.;,:',-,r...,',.."-`,::,•:-11).:%Zi;A . 1 tir A ...t.-- , , , \ i -t- --1 . , . ''F'•-•;•. ,',.,•:, --`,. .„,"- ,7-2s"4th--.-i..L--_,,,.,':.•,,,,-,,,..,,.,.:;-.•:-..1- ,,,51_t...--- - • .4-1''''Y": ".....'S,...-',!•';:.--1','-.-'5-':.-..;2;;;;',!.'r-F,-'? -'•- ''.'17 t i .,/.....,,,-..,.•.4_,-- .1"'•;.;4•,• --..'i-,:...,:';';;;-....'1:..,=.?. .,--.1. -, ,.-c.;:.X:, ••-.-f.:1'..",*Y":;‘,..r..,-::".':.!:...',1:'. .','"7..?.....71'.7;:.Z',';'3,- i " 1 -7-., .'..--;-;'`i:''"..F;?-4.....2.':"J•it.liri.i.:,.;j:f.%•:.:f;, , itif-'2 jj.;:-`,‘,?.. At;.-3' ;!' . 4 • I .C..;,. t,_: &1:1_1(s 1.1.,/::1,1'...]1•(5,2 ,..::.,:.': 14 1 . . _, .,.-, --: 1 • .11'.':,.,:!:.%S — ''..,- -;',...,..,'..,•‘-• : ....:.".y.4 .;......._,. u . ., __..,_ . . .,..,-,a,..: ., -...,•---...',''."-Z.'1;.Z.:,,'.'.,4T. .--;‘,---.e.. !,•-."- ....-71•-- ,Yf':- .!i:;:-• ...'i..1-t- -i-7'...-:5'-'-11,-•Z'llf-- - ,t.;--7 .ft' -'.', .1.-4:,..t:4'..i,:',;' :-:!, --1*,..;•:-..,'_,,.`-.1,- ,.-...,,,-.•-:-!4:4 -7- -,•-;'.",,,C-7ci,4":-.'.:1:13:".`& . . . ,:''''-r.4,'--:::'7.:'2;f,':..--',1,V,P......;',:f.,,,r,..,4-,..,•.:,..z,..,..:,-,. ''Y"- ;'-`;`-•ke.)- ','.•,-- -:-I'''',-,--,,i...i.::'‘,".'•- ,,,,,,,....7^,N1 .....' ,fitZit! ..-. - -..'"''.'f. '-:‘‘''•Q... 1.1..‘'.,..?•:7•45.,'S.::0',..- ''' t........................,-..... • ........".'...^.- . ^ ;.1‹..i.4-'-'2.4.4".4^. "" ..,-' ' 1 . .+."" *-•'.....,- ."'-':',.',••••• '..r,.'•.!.V.,-, .... . , ..,„ 'n-r.7,7:7'7;? : -.7,-;'..z--;,,z--75-^,-,-.'-' , -• -. - •,.:., '---.-,'...--.f-:'-...!-•:--.7z7e,,:.i.i---',- --,-,,--..-... --,,;.-,..z,-,.„-,•r--......,:,-,z‘r,:•,;-:.!.::: ;-:.-.:";,,-..-:!....?:i;-‘,1:-,;:.,....;-1'f.-,-;.,r.--,,::`;',--:--:-5:.': ::4,..',,,r..7-3-4---rz:', :-":,--: -!-,,--;-..,',..---;:t. ,•"....-'•••. ..,'y ;;....-•:-...,...:-,z$•:,-----.;_17-__-.,.,:_---- • F.,',r- 1!'-f-.;;,-,;.-''''''--.,...-:'.t.7-;i'f',..?":..- ',`---';',•i-'':."..-'''q"''''''''-'''':'"'•7:2';'1-';';-."'''''''''''''''''''''-.'''4.;'.1.1",:,7,.K‘„-•.:--.7 .--:14, ':-.'.2?::: ::f.::-;:.:-- ,15.6.A-.:;:';i,Y.:•••;...,7-!,:c.,:;-,T-; :.:-,,5','.:.-2:- .',-..::: ', ,.-..-;:,;?;.: ------ -- • - - ••-------- . .,„,,... 13 -,-..-4:..,:-.--_--.."47•:-.-Zr,f!--a;-' ,-- -,,. ,73-',,,:.F.7.12,- ---f,',.W. ..e,;','" 1:1-r,s.,-.i,'i-t-S-:-.::.'-.',„'-','.i.4t.,.i..-.-Lr,, ,.....,,.;','c':- .'-,,,Ntt:',. .q4r'›,....„.`.1.•-,----,' -4.4;-.,,!:4•-•-.,-....t=v..Nt.,-,,..‹,..-,.`7.. ..,,,c-o,..;::::.,,,..,--')--,.t..,,-.7.--...c..1.-.1.-'-',-,-..„'i,',41:,..,-,---•' ',,.. -"N •i;..',.4_4:,,,...zr.,-,..;.-J....-.:.,..?,,,,,,,,-..-.L,:f.-q..f.z,,,---. --..-,,,:::.-.-i,r..-.-t..4.-1,?,;:z..,..-y.,--,-...,--;,,-4-:-...s-.--.;.,,,-....,'''; .f,,,:it, v,,,,i1,4*.Fz,::-,--3.1.,..r4g,..'.. .-;':.'•:';',-;,-.-.:',-;f:,ii:-.... :-';',1-,.-if..-±-,:j:1:::: :-:-,2,-,.. . .;-. -,..--',::tV- -•:--::-.••..k:-.-..:.-„,.:-..-2,-;--- -.7..,..-;.:,.,--,_-:...,..: ,:;:;,-,-:_„..,,,,..;-.----- - .,7,- .,..c.c.i.,..- -,.. .,. .,T,..-.:,-..,- •—- ,-.,-,-;,?1.,:-.41,:..-,-..,• ..,,,,,,,::,7-2.::-..'':. ,.,,,,i.d,7-A, I ';'-', ,i;r::: ---:' ''-'''-'-,f-:".-- -• ,-'..,,,L.! 17-....`,,?C,,....-"i'4",'•,•,-;...11- ,,/-,,„--,--c.----,-i-•-,--„---,7.7..r.----,,-,... P.' .T.. '-'1:47e..-rT‘(2;f-47.;;;;4--:, t',-\'.,-','1-1'.‘-,W;:'?:.:-..A,,,;.,...-,- •.;ma.:,..;,-Eii.„...,,.,▪ ' "7--,....1;,..4...k. TA ,_,--,:, ,i,,,-,;;:,. .-„-- ;•;A.;-.:J„:,::,, ,,-. ..+,--'_ -... ua - ..;41:1...,,,x.„:".,:.4'V-4"•tIgi!..C .,;.7-,=.-: , -.- ---,-E744g.A .,:-..,',!._•,;-7:FTI.- ,-..,,_ -_-'.--: ,A.,,,,A,,-. .,—..E.,--...:-1:*•7--:.1.-..-.:,:'..'-- ,. • _ . --,.i.--4:4 ••-,-5.1z.:4Z----"---1-e,'-;,,-- 1 ! LI, „,-;:-.., --,‘„..4,. .,.„-. ,,,,.....,,,,,v,1,...,.,,,,,,,• 1 1 . -,,,-4-:--,,,,-.4s j — 44...,':... .',-;.- ,-,-,..4.,,..-7,7,,,-4.--.„4... .„-z,'4,-,-,:,•,,,‘45--,,,-7:-•,:,!;. <&-.-,.!..-,.....-.-:,,,:z---.547.,,---..!7., -,,*--'),-ry,.,z.,.,..,--,,,,,,;;:,.. .... • ; I ,;;,,,.. 31.,ntrf.ittPe.,3•....7,i'- .2...',,--,./.k;i=:,72'''--, ',,,---,----- ,..,,--',•K'''' - -.'&-•.4'54i4i, .-..,:ia',.:-.,-,!,--.';;I:,'.7, •• ; - ''''''''''''a-':ti--- ' ''''-, :.::::-Z.I.1-5-re,'!!!;.!."'-.7..,,i..17.- :`.:,,=-74-.:.•; -):',. X. 1 F.-..',141.-7...' ..:-_...,...;„..c -.7.,.-s,......,.?,4.,:,... ',..-----;.;-,,,..,,,,,..,..•-•.1,--3,-.:....,--.:-').:',' !,,.,z„,,...;.1.„i:rj.,c•f•-',.'A ....%,:ri';',:., ,,---;Z7,,!,t1c.4.,..;::;:;"1-7,..-_,?s.,;',.4:Alim;;-,71i-,-;:-7--;.,...2.Z .,:',,: , . c;;T3A:,.:.-..iv,i.4 ,-4v.,1...i ,,a...7: ` !2.-.,.:: ::Y:.;,.,„ e-'-1::, c,Z4-.i,11,:,1',-5.-;7--i,-*:;',.:;',P*-1,,-. .-ffir?.,;_'-1iFF;77,-7,-.ATil'52',.C.,";,.. • • . . ! --- . _- . - - - •