Loading...
HPB DESIGNATION REPORT Page Separator Historic Preservation Board Designation Report Box # 36 Folder # 5 Delray SO 8373 • Historic Preservation Board-Voting Sheet Ill IV VIII.A VIII.B VIII.0 VIII.D VIII.E HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND Approval of Minutes 23 S. 701 N. 531 N. 106 SE 7th 8 E Atlantic Nov. 7, 2018 Agenda 7/18/18 Swinton Swinton Ave. Swinton Ave. Ave 8/1/18 COA COA COA Tax COA/Signs 10/3/18 ,!!' Exemption e-,j'9 / S) Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Re . VOTE to Lynn Gelin / Approve A,pprove Approve Approve Approve tom Approve AIF S/0 (7 �IU .0 �S16 -I -4' s6 1 IP , 6 Benjamin Baffer '/ ✓ c i/ `/ / '7 Andrea Sherri, 4 A A ✓ ✓ ✓ v Paula Newman- ✓ ✓ ✓ / ✓ / Rocker ✓ i/ Reeve Bright A A A A A A A A Andrea Harden ✓ ./ ✓ t/ ,/ 4/ V L., I Tracy Caruso ./ ✓ V' / f / V V AD John Klein ✓ ✓ / ✓ ✓ .7 Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservation Board-Voting Sheet VIII.F VIII.G VIII.H IX.A HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND 143 S 126 SE 7tr, 201 NE 5th Ct. 110 Marine Nov. 7, 2018 Swinton Avenue COA Way In Lieu COA Concept Plan Attorney: VOTE to rec VOTE to VOTE to NO VOTE Lynn Gelin to CC Approve Approve Benjamin Baffer n / / Andrea Sherman ,l ., Paula Newman- `� Rocker ./ Reeve Bright A A A A A Andrea Harden ✓ ,/ Tracy Caruso 'I z ../ John Klein 11 tZ Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board ADJOURNED: i4 Lc/ DELRAY BEACH biiiiiii All-America City ' Mr® 1 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2 Historic Preservation Board November 7, 2018 PRINT ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION FULL NAME ‘ / e 2M L,6', -1-1/1Cciori ---A tOtneV,C,Gi te\/\6e 15 .-cl ;a k7g(fetti i_crg-- We(war-di p(e*604* -4/--- n5 ,, 0 _ 4c4, ,,v.,-- cop.-5,0- „it- ),011),x.._ . .,:ill it f.. 1110 fAc.)-7,44::),, Lc,(„A„,, (PO coi, kt(-4 2/CF I (,- ,,,: bc„,,,,. 1-0-r Li_c_ \- D \f‘'`'' '''i-- 'Ai C...___*9-AE q),(5---7C t .V 0 _____- ter. _ - N W 3 -,-, t (aTjt - L ---t,;„ occ"--' LT' REL 614-I•e,( S)-,(6.- ‘4(m L ( A G r 7r1 eC ( 2SSf �O]d 744... c'-, 2 y E L.c c, po u L o S 11C, 'k`-'‘ A v1-t ti A 1AL,A ,V I X A DELLRAY BEACH R � A ad All-America City 1 I 1993 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2001 Historic Preservation Board November 7, 2018 PRINT ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION FULL NAME ��, b A bk 'f L9“ l c-t V 2 /cic,/ //014 o w (t- 4/ Historic Preservati J3oard-Voting Sheet III IV VIII.A VIII.B VIII.0 VIII.D VIII.E HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND Approval of Minutes 23 S. 701 N. Swinton 531 N. 106 SE 7th 8 E Atlantic Nov. 7, 2018 Agenda 7/18/18 Swinton Ave. Swinton Ave. Ave 8/1/18 COA COA COA Tax COA/Signs 10/3/18 Exemption Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Rec. VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve to CC Approve AIF AIF 6-0 Administratively POSTPON POSTPOND 4-2 6-0 D 6-0 6-0 Benjamin Baffer P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Andrea Sherman A A A Y Y Y Y Y Arrived 556p Paula Newman- Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Rocker P Reeve Bright A A A A A A A Andrea Harden P Y Y Y Y Y Y NO Tracy Caruso P Y Y Y Y Y Y NO John Klein P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic PreservatiU*Board-voting Sheet VIII.F VIII.G VIII.H IX.A HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND 143 S 126 SE 7th 201 NE 5th Ct. 110 Marine Nov. 7, 2018 Swinton Avenue COA Way In Lieu COA Concept Plan Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to NO VOTE Lynn Gelin Deny to CC Approve Approve 4-2 6-0 6-Oi i'* Benjamin Baffer P No Y Y Andrea Sherman P Y Y Y Paula Newman- Y Y Y Rocker P Reeve Bright A A A A A Andrea Harden P Y Y Y Tracy Caruso P Y Y Y John Klein P NO Y Y Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board ADJOURNED: 9:15PM CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: Hideaway-By-The-Sea Address: 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina District File Number: 2018-218 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the November 7, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Request&LDR Section Approved Approved wi*h Denied** Conditions CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H) X *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. /LUG, Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Roger Cope, AIA Cope Architects, Inc. 1142 NE 1st Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 copearchitectsinc@gmail.com CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 23 S. Swinton Avenue Address: 23 S. Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District File Number: 2018-214 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the November 7, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Request&LDR Section Approved Approved with Denied** Conditions CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H) X *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. Ck-IAL 71--a'(.— Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Alfred Celcis 23 S. Swinton Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 201 NE 5th Court Address: 201 NE 5th Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District File Number: 2018-209 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the November 7, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Approved with Request&LDR Section Approved Conditions* Denied** CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H) X *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. of/Lc et_ Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Enterprise Contractors, Inc. 2559 Webb Avenue,#2 Delray Beach, FL 33444 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER EXHIBIT A Conditions of Approval 1. The applicant should return to the board to determine the style and the color of the roof finish. 2. That the porch columns should be metal or wood. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: Tin Roof Address: 8 E. Atlantic Avenue File Number: 2019-010 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the November 7, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Approved with Request&LDR Section Approved Conditions* Denied** CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENES-SIGN x 2.4.6(H)(5) x WAIVER 2.4.7(B)(5) VARIANCE 2.4.7(A)(5) *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. (ay._ci"(.C—A- 741a-A—Ch-"' Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Mark Gregory 18 Salina Avenue#29 Delray Beach, 33483 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER EXHIBIT A Conditions of Approval 1. That proposed neon lighting be replaced with Channel Letters to be more compatible and appropriate with the architecture of the structure; 2. That the awning mounted sign does not encroach into the adjacent right-of-way on the north side of the property; 3. That the proposed LED light bulbs within the"A LIVE MUSIC JOINT"text be frosted; and, 4. That the sign box with the text"A LIVE MUSIC JOINT" be painted grey to match the awning. Jcciiind 4i� w�S 3'/&cAi& - C. WESLEY BLACKMAN,AICP 241 Columbia Drive Lake Worth, Florida 33460 561 308 0364 wesblackmanc gmail.com PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Principal, CWB Associates, 2004 to Present, Lake Worth, Florida. Advise private and public sector clients regarding land use, zoning, development review procedures and applications, code development and research, comprehensive planning and historic preservation issues or projects, due diligence review, expert witness work, public relations and communications using a variety of social media platforms, work on large mixed-use urban redevelopment projects. Planning Director, Kilday Associates, 2003 to 2004, Supervised four (4) employees in planning department, prepared land use and zoning applications for private and public clients, consulted on land use matters, made presentations, in-depth project research related to island access and sovereign submerged lands. Director of Projects, Trump Organization (Mar-a-Lago Club and Trump International Golf Club), 1993 to 2003. In charge of planning, development, government/public relations and historic preservation. Project manager for construction related projects. Worked with National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Town of Palm Beach in conversion of the historic 18 acre Mar-a-Lago estate and improvements from a private residence to a private club, in addition a 215 acre championship golf course and clubhouse; along with a 62 acre addition to golf course. Planner, City of West Palm Beach,1989 to 1993. Staff planner reviewing development proposals, comprehensive plan text amendments, zoning petitions, land use plan changes, code writing, concurrency reviews, designed and managed city's concurrency system. Planner, City of East Lansing, Michigan, 1986 to 1989. Staff planner serving Planning Board, Downtown Development Authority, Economic Development Corporation. Consultant, Wilkins and Wheaton Engineering, Kalamazoo, Michigan, 1984 to 1986. Specializing in Community and Economic Development for various communities throughout lower Michigan. Analyst, Michigan Department of Commerce, Lansing, Michigan, 1983 to 1984. Reviewed grant and loan applications from municipalities throughout Michigan. AWARDS Florida Trust for Historic Preservation, Award for Outstanding Achievement, Mar-a-Lago Adaptive Re-use American Institute of Building Design, Award for Innovative Special Construction Techniques,Trump International Golf Course Page 1 Coordinator, Rail-Volution Conference, Miami/Lake Worth, Florida South Florida Blog of the Year 2009, Miami/Broward New Times AFFILIATIONS AND APPOINTMENTS Chairman, Land Development Regulation Advisory Board, Palm Beach County, Florida (since 2000) Former Chairman, City of Lake Worth, Planning,Zoning and Historic Resources Preservation Board (member from 1998, Chairman from 2001 to 2006) Former Commissioner Lake Worth Community Redevelopment Agency, 2008 to 2009 Former Chairman Lake Worth Historic Resource Preservation Board 2011-2015 Board Member, Palm Beach County Planning Congress (Served as President twice, currently Treasurer) Former Member, Board of Governors, Historical Society of Palm Beach County Member,American Planning Association and AICP, American Institute of Certified Planners EDUCATION Alma College,Alma, Michigan, Bachelor of Arts, cum laude, 1983, Business Administration, Finance, Spanish Estudio Internacional Sampere, Madrid,Spain, Intensive Spanish Language Course, 1982 Harvard, (Continuing Education) Retail Development in Traditional Downtowns,July, 2003 Urban Housing, Mixed Use Development,July, 2006 SOCIAL MEDIA wesblackman.blogspot.com Features current planning, zoning and economic development issues facing the City of Lake Worth, Florida Twitter: @wesblackman YouTube Channel: Wes Blackman Page 2 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Alfred Celcis Project Location: 23 S Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District HPB Meeting Date: November 07, 2018 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) 2018-214 for color changes to the house's exterior walls, house trim and the shutters on the existing contributing building on the property located at 23 S Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lot 10, Block 69, is located within the Old School Square Historic District and is zoned Old School Square Historic Arts District (OSSHAD). The property contains a structure that was constructed in 1938 in the Frame Vernacular architectural style. The structure contributes to the district as a modest example of domestic architecture from the period of significance. This application is for color changes to the house's exterior walls from the existing white to Orange (Nuevo Terra PFC-12), and color changes to the house trim and the shutters from the existing green to white. ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Items identified in the Land Development Regulations shall specifically be addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development application/request. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1 (E)(7), Visual Compatibility Standards, all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section. The following criteria apply: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. 23 S Swinton Avenue, COA 2018-214 Page 2 of 2 The proposal includes repainting of the house's exterior walls, house trim and the shutters only. The proposed color for the walls is Orange (Nuevo Terra PFC-12), and white trim and shutters. All other existing elements will remain the same. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-214 for 23 S Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-214 for 23 S Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-214 for 23 S Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). Attachments: Photographs and color samples Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner • P, t 1 t i � yY', r lc r dr' , •4 . pio J, a '�1 .+I' ,k' .•c . �; '� 1�� I- R k IY1�irt ' Jr , , •iS C • 1 • • qq.�� N..� ' • y i A.R. r 'I ;�, • ky4}'fi� ',�p1 4i,,'.. , r '�`{' . yf.�W., ' S 4� N I �A j' .}� I y W9 ' 7 , 1 ' '. '.'I.' ,' ' , �� .���Y '1r !!' >4e,jra.:.:4:,;::,:;: ., . .....r. ... .1 - t,;. . ? 1 �!- . '..r ` 11*a. 1?yl. , �Y �,�..3■ hg ,+ � ., ; ,�d `��� ��'.; '� y�,� .t a.,„, .. _. ‘, ..it-,,,-,.,1 , � �!. e a' ;fir. <' i:. • 4itI \' .1/ � �` "'X I. - .,pit 14. dill 1 ... .., r , ,! ..,,„,,,,, , . 1,, . .! ,..... . ,. . ...1 * 141111111 — '' ill. • '' , aitje, ' ' 4,...al ' ,.- r y "�' .1 „� "�E`,y,a r•� 9} ii! A .fir �} Y ` •. 'IP • _ � ' mot I'/ 1 iii. • ,k, .4. .. i 1 /1•„ Rt t 4.t r. • Café Iruna PFC-05 Dark Walnut PFC-25 Rich Brown PFC-35 Clay Terrace PFC-30 Desert Sandstone PFC-28 Putting Green PFC-70 Tile Red PFC-04 Giant Sequoia PFC-09 Coronado PFC-20 Gold Torch PFC-29 Washed Khaki PFC-33 Moss Covered PFC-39 Brick Red PFC-02 Santa Fe PFC-15 Iron Ore PFC-14 Cold Lager PFC-22 Putty Beige PFC-37 Woven Willow PFC-34 Deep Terra Cotta PFC-10 Terra Brick PFC-08 Pyramid PFC-19 Gathering Place PFC-24 Spanish Parador PFC-32 Elemental Green PFC-3F Red Baron PFC-03 Sahara Sand PFC-13 Sonoma Shade PFC-18 Tan PFC-23 Light Rattan PFC-27 Garden Lattice PFC-36 New England Brick PFC-01 Nuevo Terra PFC-12 Rusty Orange PFC-17 Grain PFC-21 White Cloud PFC-72 Terrace View PFC-41 Michel Rose PFC-07 Georgia Peach PFC-06 Inviting Veranda PFC-11 Classic Mustang PFC-26 Wool Coat PFC-16 Traditional Tan PFC-31 Color chips are affected to some degree by the type of light in which iney ara.iewud,exposure.o and sunlight,and the age of the chip itself.Oc-ssio-'-'Ily,there may be a r 1 �t. 1 r�7 CI � .. f• ..,. ' �F• • ,1 .,t. .. 11•' ,t` r/Il,"+d�4lJ, j/i i �j .�i fj�i�'-�..C� ,�^b--.�'- r.��f\r\ t��t1� ►'" ,r /� tf 1t1; •// ` 4r/, i / �, I �4 . , ,�� I. r � ! ,," •r �jl,,. ,. I � � 1 l lfl1l-,I. 11%iti -•1'•-i.*i#.1; I r f ; �' ' i•' ;w .fi �tr i I. 1 . •JjIp •,a 1 Ti� ' v I ,I ,1, , \PIA 4 _ •• 1 Ar A ,!.,,,,e,i..."."'1 -\ ./' I .--,,, __ .„,...N,,,,,,,,:l ._ : CI ( �r, A /''r,{ 7 _ of c •i,, \\ ��- _ /% �'� �•r � ,JJ ., c` .FrAil .. , 411.„, SAY I I kfy 7 A,j 't.a 1 f.,..: ,i ,� tr ''!r ' ti1C4_, _ - \\\�\\' -�- 1. S�`� ,' ?t` 4 I.. �� \P ;,al 1.i aMj Rd , 7 ® ' �� 1.,/ Y ' ______, ,_,,..___:„ ._.. .. .., y i I /1 vxra'la': ,I�• — I 1.� I li ji\� ®' � ~ r� it t Y: 'r 4q �!•f • • • =h �i 4fr wl , . s�: r (� r'j `l 15, i 1 �}? f � l /mac . , , . ,., _,, , .. \y- 0 .,, ...;• _ ... .,,. , ,..ilr,'' F i' 4�s 5tir4. • it PI wt!e'.i' S' _'1 i,.,._P`"" !Wilk NUN'¢n' t 1t' ° „r♦b` . - _ • • ,. . . , 1 1.- ..,� ,' r 1r, r� �i v ''it / `•5.'�. 'I{ :.g «.�.� t Pd`f .- gy t� ♦ a 3� ,Y • 1 ' • , �y r.., /.;� 1 ' ^'4 ►' IA ; `,, A :h:kMra•w +RS^`h:uY;:cq'� .t .erp t; „ i '� �'^' !r'r �. 1 � � • 7 tt ya r.:.."r ♦ f: ..... i.: I N.,.. ',�i I �� %. '; .a •,.: !• M •• ..:,. �� n..t.iti•+ �•'.. OYD * 4 # 1 'r f , ?f,,A , Fir/!drit Ip,v,w f ! t,, rf : 0�. „cry ity0 a / \ GR ys• c: x,,la?,� ► p ti °'. „..A.� F COUNiy COURT J U . �> t. y'�1 'l ,,, +g ''�� I GRGUP4 1 ,...,. .: .?,- . i ', / ' � r rut, • • 'w f+ i � ii . ' 1 • •-h�_��"� �(��� 't �l`� '�, .�.. ,�/ . V. 1. iaiS/ '1 r , �'',,,,.4.e-A.-' 1-i 4•-y�: r- „ ,`�4�4k.v:{ • ,• + •r' . '� "\}•• �� Vrl\ ni ��`' '� •T, �! ,�• ry,� 4�' j� !o i;' .,4„ ,, t�, y ��rkx 1,,t � i! _ tz:100^,rg/rjY - \\\\. 1�� �<. �j�t� "ty UJ,��,�' •t• .. �^,��' ��.t,,j, , y,�j��'• •',` kl j s , d, o /� �' c��: y�.��/�t�ja /Y t4..� !�� r `�' 'lYrFt��y��(KI�'„t..ii "R.J' ,4, t`11,,,t .,i.. 's•ryyjj'. T • ''. /ti. •- .n1 �.4 1/r / t' ':r'J{j.'. /(p��rl �l'{� �J l>,�5\1A'i.t:i ili t/ ',.. �.. ,1` ,, ;;' .•1, !•t�j 1 Y ,,'11 ',A t 1. /. Ir / 2:� rt��� - 'r �i 1 ,'1,,,, 1 11 ,.. eft, � r Q', i•. �a• >fi.•K .\ / ' t4 '{14 i•, • !` ��L�\ t ( ‘ '�, A i f ,i/ : 'a r l l Ste. '.,c4r� .r..: {•Sf�. t. •9�- ' 4Ji� '<`�t'l�.t r ti��$ t '1'��� � 1�'(. ���n ,�" � � �`••r�,�l/�• ' � r'� i � • ,I t (����,',I' :1�` �� '� ''''"Ni! , X r{ .0 1r� qf,\t e2_ •cur, .\,•�tt f,� i d r� l �{�\ rr t t V � � t/ Y ^.R'ti w. • y �� �`i' 3Yi p, l 4 r(j�/' tl ry)y�J ,,� ✓ .,w, �al. l.t' r � r,l e, y ;,, l ' a,,,1t{' 1 , 1 % • \t n:y i,• (S 1 � ..fit t;, i{ r r '1 Y (•'R a U. + f ,e �`' `614 • , 1 i 1' !j' lt�P�4"1 S.A 1 r., I� � " 1 " • • '' l ' ' r \ � • r�' ,l� y• `l � ''• t ♦ � f ,. .. rl11' \ IB��4 t L�'g . . t r ✓ t t it � , r 4 i a , ` \, s ( J ,); • .,., ".. `��,yv., • ti Y %'tea , r•.,.1 t 0•\.',. ° j, , -/ .,!if it i '' I 711110...�yi.:_}, by t _ ;III f III ' r;!��� +\`,�1k1��sf/!: � A t \ 4 w. • • '��,. N r ��� °,i; [ " , r� - r `,u�a M r Al i e'• , i4 `.a k `tir;� a •, ,wk • � , ;4. {` ' Ti! ;(? jF^f I, L A,` �\• •`'l /�% }YID / t ,/ 1``1—.�• -, t. a 'art t`r. �� �.;' .S -\ ` \�� \ \`I, '•{ h.6 +\ `��'� r r 1 .�' ,Ir ,y\ r t�` �R, • +�at �� `�� ♦�.�`1,{� / _ ' 1, ail \\\ y 4. T I I --.f. s . 10r �R, � ® � .. .. ... ., •� _...�11 I �t ` � � % 1 �AI• r �Y ~n �„ II 11' ' _:y, l -{,,fi , ,1 +\tl l " +`t,t 4 ''' % N 4 , n ',n ; ft /t _ /t _ • I �q'1 I�'Il, IT" L �- -� .'Yt '�.. y,y:♦ iyy 1 r,; �{ � I 1 r1. i ». 1�_{-^' , ! ,.•yfi I,r'{ �✓*� t , 1, in -q ,,,�".S+r %i i I ict• d;, � . ,: " gl3t �� �s` ell' v�`': �...}. :.(i ��: 3 � i �1 -, E -' I • :Ir..; yq `:4 4 i . '-t,. �`tY t•1ICJ':lt.' ,,,r'� .,.. �� ' ( th __II ` � '� � I 4: I, T.._. ' j°St"'itl r' ;/ %° �1�5 L 7 -... -.t`'t J., r�/�t _ IAtIiirt.r T ��� Vi y�� y, tag va rr. ��j ynl'if,44 1t`4. ,` '1•.l' t., ..""�li1 1 'y - . r C; II '.R iIl 7 .:V� ' t '- .^, !illy' III I!_i' .t. y f `:. q r r N rwruA.A �I t :i. f? I 4' �' ,its.-.�.r�-.-c_ S'T x . .. , ...... 4 A: ,v HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Samuel L Spear, Jr and Kenya F Spear Project Location: 701 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District HPB Meeting Date: November 07, 2018 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) 2019-008 for color changes to the trim and the shutters of the existing contributing building on the property located at 701 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property, which consists of Del-Ida Park, South 15 Feet of Lot 3 and Lot 4, Block 1, is located within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property is zoned Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). The property contains a wood-framed, contributing, Minimal Traditional style, single- family residence constructed in 1940. The HPB reviewed a request for a replacement of the damaged flat, asphalt shingle roof with a cedar-shake shingle roof at its May 3, 2006 meeting, the request was approved. The subject application is result of a code enforcement violation from September 25, 2018 for the work being done without the permit. The proposal is to change the color of the trim and shutters from the existing dark green to Dark Purple (Dramatist MQ5-43°). ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL lt,:ms identified in the Land Development Regulations shall specifically be addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development application/request. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1 (E)(7), Visual Compatibility Standards, all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section. The following criteria apply: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. 701 N Swinton Avenue, COA 2019-008 Page 2 of 2 The proposal includes repainting of the house trim and the shutters only. The proposed color is Purple (Dramatist MQ5-43°). All other existing elements will remain the same. There is concern that the proposed/completed color of the shutters and trim clash with the pastel green color of the body of the house. Staff requests board discretion for the subject request. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-008 for 701 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-008 for 701 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATION Board Discretion Attachments: Photographs and color samples Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner • • , V/emM.r7', r r ;iv . 1 -at. /h`..r t' ' {(� w „S ..spa .a,� ./ �� a. /�+•/ � .4, �1 • l - tf •its .�.( „,1. '. �.ir� �, - `t S' . r,l I g,, 1 r ; L :'''' .. ,.,,. ...' ... i , • . . C. `�1~ 'ca roses y �S\` ,.. J ,• Awm r.r_ • • s�,i �" `ice ; ; ;•♦�^, .' 1 tea■ r r' / 4 ♦ I, t ..c i .).• .__..• • • it4tk il ,'',AtIotio7A. ..,",...1144,.i. *,7.‘ ift4...*I.s. .r• . ,' 4 • x Vey• r M;,FS,t�E., t gi ' 4* • -••'~ ,2` pig -3 �j�i . E.. ,•. .. +.ry,.,... - � . ,"'� - 4 1 Spr�Qi ' r ♦ Jn�! tip, •^� '� t 7. et- s • • • • ... ale' ,.' 1 ii-'7' yea. ,. I[ ' •;;; �LLti', #�r�t • • q�FteCloir • + $ = •i ,let 1‘ My t, , f • - �, A �1* """r •*'" i Pit �♦ COLOR SAMPLE & FINISH SCHEDULE Existing Colors/Material: CI l( g( Ai Proposed Colors/Materials: etc,Q E r J ATTACH SAMPLES AND/OR PHOTOGRAPHS OF TYPE PROPOSED Please note type of material proposed. ROOF AWNINGS WALLS RAILINGS/ FENCE FASCIA DOORS •; WINDOWS :EENING •/POOL) /1441 COLUMNS OTHER fA; i ��y i�`F �� , t f a ' il LIB�1 ii\ 1, , , ' vat, ', I ��� ��: t�.� ¢)`11� '�` •CyT A * 1. ,^M1.1 I a rtt Y F1 _� t 1 3 - B y T v� E • 1111111111111.11 If lit 15 [.' r�/�/r i' i _______ i ; r r, IL J/ 111 r r r P 7 _ 1, nr F �r t /".4 _ 11 /. ii ,^` rs M • J L. /y 1' 1 ♦ , '•s i \� -1 " to H r(, 4. N A"' , -• k.• r I '/_/ `.1 f /! .. /\,, t f tI i\ I R •"ate' • '4'�r'Ffr[.lb• At�.‘{w .�l v�� ",.rl .Mw 14 t • x�Sy 1 a F1�' r .EeXi2ir �:F:'�.?914.Y7ik __" FfS]�V YE, �i ik}'$ Z3c+vS cyy• 4a ".�y,�,��•� ` �• `• I 1J A alltd S37,0y ye- tilt__ (11/)Ltda :' ,j4/4.6 ,� - Xi&Ycsv d O : i GADS /911 t / g (11-rnj/-c4 --o s ,cam • /e7eiL 0670., ?e.1.0E �kcw4.1 7 ymn ;, 4,guic_ ?-e_cc)X_XIS �Ov /1O, ��P l.{ ,9-1 2 _ (cui - - - A. ,Wy I f) �K.,6J2C _ 6 0 6611 I i l v`ZC�k l�l Pcat-e77ot_ f k.�c c Sc(t) lums ��S6 ' — .c.e.c� fL Mc 4 2-3 (5. dI in 7 0_ - Co /c) aeLz-V-- kiu_c/ Of_ /G/s - 0164 E4_ L11 E- ctll0 -E✓ ctop C6f - Co_c_ ' et__L 33 - ch cept vin 1 . At/ - ` / 9 au)af_d 4144e-c-- 3 112(- tC Cotot-l-e_eu - /1Xkki 6-4 6-0 / J4/ S 701 d. &In 94-Vt . Q.POL11 Cc c Oc-; Co 4)-- . /(10 App x)Oce_Q <n Cc.dvoutt�. e-y - • / fc- �.11� Wylo2-4t-d )0A_ 4 I off eu,2 tic o10 IVek.._ ( i1 Cuce- _._. GGitaG CtI - - 1110/1�. - 3 - ti Cc lam- ? i ca - o-L Wc,a_a_d - t3h - cI Yr(fl AA/ 6711eTIE, 6 -0 JiL col Jig/ l . (j)in i cht. E - r lit Cu./1(.11i) - v&c.e_be — /7 Po3rpOLd /v 6 7 ' -pit G Cj- ,c�i X.ea`e'�--' PCUU-p6-el6 -0 /11/0-4-ri _ id-C-C-t- , '� none., : /ALI y4rot_i pcur-t_ 60/4 dAce_d_o .414-d -Aft - 4oLL 7-eaQ,Lci Pkiy � ict 8 - Su,/ 6 - — to/ 44_,--5 dr s ox_._ wlr ce-Lii 0-)L._. /, I I't any C6. • u,61 c C-xL/4-e ec 5 — hog - t-1 it_ d AID ii-e ✓! u ` u ,r: 7 / °dui - M‘cLitcp/t. cd'ice-F 1,7- / L3 6--LE p ti JAI /1-S � C Glee- ccc.nC�s�Sc�t.i / Su>>n i o/� c�sa /i.etc. �n-4..C1n )fc l-& "47ur. 410hCCLA-f- J91-;`-i t ///4--V0 - 15f1(7) . ific-hc-La -�' / i �/lam lid 6L,Ce.c,ir /. dif 7tv / PO4y (lieu 414 A� J¢ppLvv __. Pzret? dic.)n �. �licca.4-1- AO at I,1�r d /30 _ Sixtct_. t...eau�ly i?-ec ? C c — &cch .. u.4cd r el f o o 9 213 p_ x cs v iix 7 LJI-)cc__c_ ‘8/ e 7p0 1G U kL T %& Jt)1 • 426 Y67- 7tp p s ( 1 Lb/ Lcy-e2c4--- Ac r- - d if cq - /44/ I a-- A}in dozOS / la._ 3x_cx 2A4C - ✓4 - good r ie - 9a4 Pifq i7 at I de s''? K,o 4/-7 _k.,c.ru_cd Ka�.2 u Et-jr0 0 CA f--/k gat 7 4- c/( sso s5 64. Ji - lox V-LI ADA) 71/- e4 koo ft€Ica /21-a4C-- --- )c) it4 /C_ n /4/-p llccer- 00n / lG - AlcD --Ton tr6 ZLYA-A-Cti Cif_ ( e_c_c S 5 -3(13 — ec,LA-I C 777�. A c734CE-2r cc)I/(1-, €_. 2oc)6 fricAO 41-10-4_ /o /pArri ACUI- ZOff._-1Y `ItoisC.ift-X4 Uc7 (\cid/L. /!v nE U�.G p2o/9 - 0ie A/C-"/ lopouic Axiii(a4d (16-k GVaa2A ud,u-i /oc �S'r,� I�Say, .0.? /lei Oct ecct3 15/I_Ce.1-1- 4a-th OcLicoz_z_ Sdet,tA SaJtA_A__ A-� - Abo r 3�c1 w.c_ f� 6 AGENDA = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD �44)- 8�'P Meeting Date: November 7, 2018 Time: 5:30 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES • July 18, 2018 • August 1, 2018 • October 3, 2018 V. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC VI. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.) Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VII. LEGAL BOARD MEMBER TRAINING VIII. ACTION ITEMS A. Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-214): Consideration of a color change to the existing historic structure. Address: 23 S. Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District Owner/Applicant: Alfred Celcis, secratariat@comcast.net B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-008): Consideration of a color change to the existing historic structure. Address: 701 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Samuel Spear, Jr. & Kenya Spear, sspearjr@gmail.com C. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-014): Consideration of an entry awning installation to the existing historic structure. Address: 531 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Becky Luttbeg; Becky.Luttbeg@gmail.com Agent: Donald Day; Don@DelrayAwning.com D. Ad Valorem Tax Exemption (2019-006): Provide a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic Property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure. Address: 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District Owner: Dan & Donnamarie Sloan; dsloan@sloandesign.biz E. Certificate of Appropriateness— Signs (2019-010): Consideration of a new illuminated neon wall sign and a projecting sign to the existing non-contributing structure. Address: 8 E. Atlantic Avenue; Old School Square Historic District Owner: Sure Ring Inc.; algmkt@gmail.com Agent: Mark Gregory; mgreg01@comcast.net Historic Preservation Board Meeting Agenda: November 7,2018 Page 2 of 2 F. In Lieu of Parking (2019-023): Consideration of a recommendation to the City Commission for an In Lieu of Parking request for 2 parking spaces in association with a Class V Site Plan and Certificate of Appropriateness applications for the residential to office conversion and addition to an existing contributing historic structure for use as an office. Address: 143 S. Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District Owner/Applicant/Agent: Nigel Development, Inc.; JMayo@hmn-architecture.com G. Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-218): Consideration of the installation of 2 new aluminum pergolas to the existing historic structure. Address: 126 SE 7th Avenue; Marina Historic District Owner/Applicant: Hideaway By the Sea, LLC.; pricepatton@aol.com &copearchitects@gmail.com Agent: Roger Cope, AIA; copearchitects@gmail.com H. Certificate of Appropriateness — Signs (2018-209): Consideration of renovation of the existing structure, a new 555 sq.ft. addition and construction of a new garage and guest house to the existing non-contributing structure. Address: 201 NE 5th Court; Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Rochelle Greenberg; aprilphool@aol.com Agent: Enterprise Contractors, Inc.; eciwork@aol.com IX. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Concept Plan Review—(2019-017) Address: 110 Marine Way, Marina Historic District Owner/Applicant: 1250 Crain Highway, LLC. Agent: Gary Eliopoulos,AIA; gary@eliarch.com Discussion regarding the expansion of the existing villas and 2-story addition to the 1-story apartment/garage structure located at 110 Marine Way. Note:This review is non-binding and no action shall be taken by the Board nor shall there be any written report resulting from discussions at the meeting which may be construed to be preliminary approval of the development concept. X. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Staff ❖ Board Members XI. ADJOURN tifi,tcItJLQ 1411(0%i_ Michelle Hoyland, P`rincipai Planner; HPB Board Liaison Posted on: October 30, 2018 The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program,or activity conducted by the City.Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Rebecca Luttberg Applicant: Donald Day, Delray Awning Project Location: 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District HPB Meeting Date: November 07, 2018 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) 2019-014 for installation of a fabric awning on the existing contributing building on the property located at 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property, which consists of Del-Ida Park, Lot 1 (Less S 2 Feet), Block 3, is located within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property is zoned Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). The property contains a contributing single-family residence constructed in 1947. This application is for installation of a fabric shed-style awning on the north elevation above the front door. The 6'4" wide awning will have 4" wide pink and white stripes, a projection of 3'6" and height of 1'6". ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Items identified in the Land Development Regulations shall specifically be addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development application/request. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Histori ; Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1 (E)(7), Visual Compatibility Standards, all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section. The following criteria apply: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. The proposal includes installation of a shed-style fabric awning. The proposed awning will be visually compatible with the historic residence and the structures within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. 531 N Swinton Avenue, COA 2019-014 ' Page 2 of 2 ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). Attachments: Photographs and color samples Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner r! / /� vim; �:: a r -. �' ; of �.� - �'� 4 frf *. , E�� 'T'� , Iv; / 1`�. ! _ '-r 1' - , � -4-r fir, t... ' I • . ... .,......_.. ,,,f, „..- • Y�, .g , am _,` • J t _,!r l/I ,. , _ . ..._':4'....'-'. 2."-t':',:,..,--:- . -, -,'• :- '4 ., ... ._....... .., ....„._ . .. - - - .• ter*- , r Q1 mil, _. _ - = _s a" ¢ - r COLOR SAMPLE & FINISH SCHEDULE Existing Colors/Material: Proposed Colors/Materials: ATTACH SAMPLES AND/OR PHOTOG; POSED Please note type of mat ROOF WALLS RAILINGS/ FENCE FASCIA DOORS WINDOWS SCREENING (PATIO/POOL) COLUMNS OTHER -5 - _ ,.......,,,,,. , - ,°'_•••.-,.,••• ....,,/•,.1.7.,..-0•.".-r,...,:.•.i`'4...',„....r-J''--i•' • a_..,, 41*;...,. ..r-e ,„•"•%‘,,,.... . . ,'•,'7'_' .'..,.. ...- '• „-••/.'•,,' .' ' . . . . • ., •.. , _\,,;., ,•..2,•..'A...I..&f1‘,...-- /iIvii/ i7•i•JAP't, .- /‘.•,ftA.,e,r'.t••. a,,„•,,. t / • , "If . ' / i . ' — . ' I \ . . ' .V 'i • . , iir 4110•••.„ /If - • • A' '' ' /4 ;a.,i :.,,....,,,,,,.. „..,,.i;k..-::-........ - } ... . . . . 44... ' • ri ..'.' • ' gir:V' • ,/ k ‘ . 1.. , ....,-,,,, ... ,,, • . '—.,,,s. • - - - r•J.. N ••••1151" -.........._. , • i ''. t;,-' L.A. -• i4,AH, '.i ,,,g,,,,V'' ; ,, . , , illit,...I.. .• %,- of \-. an "IN .641 00 iiii .441— '`4414' 1,0".' `-'-' - •' 'i 1 ......--_,„„,,,--, e-,•4... , k vii 'V • i •••,„,,• 1 Ae ,..le . * • , '‘er i'*"i'. .. ; - ....' '.. .1 , ,, , • . . 1 • I, ".'• , ' Tr ..;It.kl ..., A . -44%.'. / IV V- ," / . g . / )/ 0 r, y /, ... ' /' . 1. (.1 • . i ; ii/ / ' . CO 1* , //V ' •• ' .. a) pa , -.-..•-• 1.. . s . .. \s117 ,76'ailik i 1 i al Nt•-•• % ^ . ).4 4- . . - 4 1 t. i..,• a) ... kOhri;-40-724% • • A iiii, ..,1411.? . - • •441 '' . .':... , •"0•• I ••• 4 , **. ' • ' ' h •, . 1. a) • • . . > 4 lei . . .. . ' •-':. • ":".'',; •?>=,-ti,....4-.q;, , 4' ' .. .'. •.'''''111 •I,'71,1 • , ‘I ., -.1•C 1*-4. ve . 4 ._— , :1 4•J , ,',.:, '':': 7'.. ..." ' . 4 •4. ;,•••' .- -•-•-•** • 4-1 CI ' ' , ,'..1 .-3 , 1 •ec..,' . -,.....' ,-.- . • r• :21147.! ,-,:' i 4-1 -.-1 • '-'•-, - 0 , fi' ::';',.;.:4 ' • , •,,,..* • e- - *, 0 3 i ' • r •Wir. 4,1.,er 4....,..4 : - 4 ••••.4,4-J .,• . , .1 u) •.. ;„.• t ri!"!";.-.,•); .,:•, I 4',,,.‘44"".• 4 ›,.., , , .. , .•: 1i- .... I, I',•": -..4 1', .41 !,,..... . "'••• , 111••** 4 ,%..-1..--;....40: 0 Z • ''. ''• "I • • .'''...- •;If?'' '''''' •••,u.'i sslii .:.,t,.rie-;,` . ._ 14,• +0 !: • ' '••‘ °•.,4,4 46:::' • 11'•_ 4(4,,,*•'1, ...tr.. :51111k ah pa tn •• .''', '', '• •,,',;1',.!:'• 04`/- tle,• ....# ' 3 ,•,^rloi,o,-;;..- ',.“.77?::-i!, •. . ', . .z- •-• Aka .t t., c4 4, •.,st ••1 ' .. 0 • I1 .J:. ...--.,-,__,, Z.' 'M'14,' ' ,ad:,.tl c.rft„,‘:• 4 ,,4: spi. —--,, ...:-..:, ' ' -5,- . -. . . 1,- i.‘ ..• —A..." Xr• rx . I .?. . ! , • .. . . • * A 4 w :1111C4c.....1.,, .• t si 4:14:'. • ' ''I i • .if 'ir-,,,• '4 •• ••••;"I'1 4r... 4 •''..."4..',ezf.1'.,'"'., ''''. . ''''' - ..`--,-;4-. ,'.koe rL g.. - ,,; •,,s ! ' ,.o.• • , . ,, ),,..,, , •' ' ' 4,, I ... , .411...,,.) ' ..., e l' OlVt it. V..> '''' % ' • • . . •,, , 47* 4iIr • I ,-141440. M,.;'•..N.-14!..sTerr.' ' r—.'''k .4..' itin: ... ::•40 f' ' ' ''', ..-:--lif...-.-„-V --..„.. 4. 4 ' fw ' .01 ' 7'0•"` 24 . .'WA ' *ea . .44. .... .... .";t.,...,. *•'4',..-..e'T: ' ' . ''' • " . 't. •-•' ' o.. . , " - ----- ••, . 4-'.' ' • ,,,..), '-.,' ; ',„. ( - 01411 %. li •a ' .. II '..%:-; ... ... . • '' r;...,''17'' " - : ''', , , J P . .I I I A I A 7 r- Vitt ••'-'",'-',•:T•:.:-:.,17-,',,.•,4-,r,.,-;- r, . ..., i ' .,, , • . --• ';''''-'*''Z•'-'' ''-` ''''' . '.,---,-, ;''',"t',..•'. ,i. • . e‘t..i., ..,. Ile: c• '..• • -,..:4*. r ...-1P-, _ '':• .' • rt.' t NI . 1 I— : . • fr4 '-'• ,,,,,, • (I ,.... -‘1. . '' . 1. ., , - s ‘,14 ..'t e . , •‘, . '';',.4-'f-44'.4.-.;.'',..,4..i —4.. ''-.':, ' Ai t i-A .. .... — .... ..,,,,,.; .. . ....,......›.*;4,1...- •'' # .' F�}� II'//'���� AWNING (� FRANK L BENNAR00,P.E. O \BRUV DOOR !/,1WNIN PE10046640 /aGfiw>:C.\ • PEA 823 OIDATI6T0,P.E • ATTACHMENT TO HOST STRUCTURE INFORMATION PE* SCHED.40 PIPE PER TADLES TYP. AUD FOR i PERMIT O,+LY U.N.0 NOTICe,If Tll'!SHEET 00E5 NOT CONTAIN AN ORICINA4 1'WIWEELDED3TAB6.T OPTION LONG SIGNATURES,ENGINEER SEAL: IF WEA!15 A DIGTAL STEEL TAO 3/16'FULL FILLET SIGNATURE ON SHEET!,THIS WELDED TO PIPE. SHEET IS PART T,A DIGITALLY SIGNED ITEM,SHALL REMAIN IN �' DIGITAL FORMAT,&PRINTED COPIES OI THIS DOCUMENT ///A ARE NOT CONSIDEREO SIGNED .]}•, AND SEALED.UTHERE IS NO DIGITAL S1GNATUA5 ON•!' I", / • A .E.. OG THIS SHEET D0E5 NOT CONTAIN • 2w MAX:: �• Th AIN AN ENGINEER'S I;•.4 : CENTER BOLT • ORIGINAl51GNANRE 4 SEAT, THIS SHEET IS A COPY,DRAFT. �y I I .I.a.l, orn O N T z "a pz 1 �® wm,.IUs m o U J Uw . W P u- ut m (1-6" 3/a" pipe 6 ZY )55 ZQ oWxq //� I • Da �'a� 6I3 I /�wYaA ,G l /�� wZX W orvm 68 wW oHwyl Bi • - * 3 3�V�� �x W O W 52 �_31_6." , o • a1 GENERAL NOTES: z 7 t / ° 1. ALL STRUCTURES HAVE BEEN DESIGNED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FLORIDA 1--1 >rani 0 p•'?i DEO BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION(2017)AND ASCE 7-10(MRH=15',EXP='C',V,1•=115MPH(3 Z ¢m SEC GUST),RISK CATEGORY[,1.5:12 MIN.SLOPE,PITCHED/GABLE ROOF,MWFRS ROOF -1 DIE) . T • OVER OPEN STRUCTURE,OBSTRUCTED OR UNOBSTRUCTED WIND FLOW). MAXIMUM DESIGN LL fl-,' u I" PRESSURE OF 25 PSF. Q 6 u aJ q i ['V„a MAY BE CALCULATED WITH THE FOLLOWING CONVERSION:V,16=V„R'J0.6I Z ''F .3 i1" i MC 2. ALL PIPE SHALL BE ASA SCHEDULE 40 OR GATORSHIEW14 GAGE GALVANIZED UNLESS U m F7 Mc-)J NOTED OTHERWISE. YID 9 1D 3. ALL WELDS SHALL COMPLY WITH A.W.S.CODE,CURRENT EDITION. ALL WELDS SHALL oo n N T IIII.61H BE FULL LENGTH WITH 3/16'FILLET(U.N.O.),COVERED WITH ALUM PAINT. .-I ( 4. FABRIC COVERING SHALL OE REMOVED WHEN SUSTAINED WINDS REACH 75mph LU 0 zH ( - (90mph 3-SECOND GUST). FABRIC COVERING SHALL BE EXTERIOR,NON-METALUC, [� j•,.-41 NON-CORROSIVE,&WATER RESISTANT. FABRIC SELECTION IS BEYOND THE SCOPE OF TH35 w WALL OUTSIDE INSIDE CERTIFICATION. " PIPE THICK DIAM DIAM 5. FRAMES WITHOUT COVERING HAVE BEEN DESIGNED BY RATIONAL ANALYSIS TO I O V 1�'w 1/2"DIAM 0.109" 0.840" 0.622" WITHSTAND V„11=170mph(3-SECOND GUST)WINDS IN EXPOSURES'C'AND'D', 6. THE AWNING OWNER SHALL BE NOTIFIED OF THESE CONDITIONS BY THE PERMIT 5 ' ' ' '- P 3/4"DIAM 0.113' 1.050" 0.824" HOLDER. NO WARRANTY,EXPRESSED OR IMPUED,IS CONTAINED HEREIN. Pll 1"DIAM 0.133' 1.315' 1.049" 7. THE EXISTING HOST STRUCTURE MUST BE CAPABLE OF SUPPORTING THE LOADED `i SYSTEM AS VERIFIED BY THE PERMIT HOLDER. NO WARRANTY,EITHER EXPRESSED OR 6 1-1/4"DIAM 0.140" 1.660" 1.380" IMPUED,IS CONTAINED HEREIN. • 16"MIN FILLET 1-1/2"DIAM '0.145" 1.900" 1.610" 8. ENGINEERING EXPRESS HAS NOT VISITED THIS JOBSITE.INFORMATION CONTAINED o 11111 WELD EACH SIDE, HEREIN IS BASED ON CONTRACTOR-SUPPLIED DATA AND MEASUREMENTS. ENGINEERING ANCHORS EXPRESS SHALL NOT BE HELD RESPONSBILE OR LIABLE IN ANY WAY FOR ERRONEOUS OR k FULL LENGTH INACCURATE DATA OR MEASUREMENTS. DIMENSIONS ARE SHOWN TO ILLUSTRATE DESIGN ERANCHDR ANCHOR SCHEDULE SCHEDULE(TYP) ! 145MSAT 2"O.C.MAX • FORCES AND OTHER DESIGN CRITERIA. THEY MAY VARY SUGHTLY,BUT MUST REMAIN4 • 3/8"ELCO CONFLEX(2S4"MIN EMBED TO WITHIN THE LIMITATIONS SPECIFIED HEREIN. WORK SHALL BE FIELD VERIFIED BY OTHERS g Orl/2"MIN CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,33/4"MIN EDGE PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. ENGINEERING EXPRESS SHALL BE NOTIFIED AND GIVEN AN $ 3/16"MIN 1/2"MIN DISTANCE,6"MIN SPACING), OPPORTUNITY TO RE-EVALUATE OUR WORK UPON DISCOVERY OF ANY INACCURATE3/8"POWERS WEDGE BOLT(2'/c"MIN EMBED TO INFORMATION PRIOR TO MODIFICATION OF EXING FIELD CONDITIONS AND FABRICATION ' ; ,, CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4 "MIN EDGE AND INSTALLATION OF MATERIALS. con IM,T I GIEIIUED EAPREss• 1.5"MIN a 3/16" MIN 3/16'' MIN-• 9. ENGINEER SEAL AFFIXED HERETO VALIDATES STRUCTURAL DESIGN AS SHOWN ONLY. W MIN �� DISTANCE,4�"MIN SPACING), USE OF THIS SPECIFICATION BY CONTRACTOR,et,al.INDEMNIFIES&SAVES HARMLESS THIS WIDE TYP. • 3/8"POWERS POWER-BOLT(2"MIN EMBED TO WELDED TAB PIPE CLAMP DIRECT "Z"BRACKET CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4 1/2'MIN EDGE ENGINEER FOR ALL COST&DAMAGES INCLUDING LEGAL FEES&APPELLATE FEES RESULTING ATTACHMENT ALT MOUNTING FROM MATERIAL FABRICATION,SYSTEM ERECTION,&CONSTRUCTION PRACTICES BEYOND SCALE:NTS UNLESS NOTED ATTACHMENT ATTACHMENT ATTACHMENT CLIP ' DISTANCE,3 3/4"MIN SPACING). THAT WHICH IS CALLED FOR BY LOCAL,STATE,&FEDERAL CODES&FROM DEVIATIONS OF Ial ANCHORAGE OPTIONS • 3,...HILTI KWIKBOLTGROUT-FILLED III(2 1/2"MIN EMBED TO THIS PLAN. N.T.S. CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4 1/2"MIN EDGE 10. EXCEPT AS EXPRESSLY PROVIDED HEREIN,NO ADDITIONAL CERTIFICATIONS OR DISTANCE,5 5/8"MIN SPACING. AFFIRMATIONS ARE INTENDED. i - HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: November 7, 2018 ITEM: 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, (2019-006) — Provide a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption GENERAL DATA: Owner Dan & Donnamarie Sloan ``�y ' o, - _ - e _ s Erg Location. 106 SE 7th Avenue, west side of ®_ ' ' ; SE 7th Avenue, approximately 60 feet •r ,n north of SE 1st Street SE 1r,t st • Property Size. 0.21 Acres 414, , ; t • ;r . Historic District Marina Historic District -f , Current Zoning• RM (Multiple Family Residential — i Medium Density) i , :. lli p ' �^ t R �y ..i+.. Adjacent Zoning. • # , =` , 4, •41 . North: RM -, , South: RM ' East: RM Y,R� F* West: CBD (Central Business District) i, 1 + '+ Existing Future Land MD (Medium Density Residential ` 7- �: ,ct `' Use Designation 5-12 DU/Acre) = T tr Water Service Public water service is 6 v � A ! provided on site. :ILb2„0�,, ; - I' NORTH limita A, Sewer Service. Public sewer service is provided on site. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure located at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 4.5.1(J). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Unit 1, of Sloan Hammock, Land Condominium, and is located on the west side of SE 7th Avenue, approximately 75' south of SE 1st Street. The property, joined by a Unity of Title and executed condominium documents, currently contains four structures consisting of 5 total units (two 2-story structures, a 1-story structure, and a detached garage). The property is zoned Multiple- Family Residential-Medium Density(RM) and classified as contributing to the Marina Historic District. In October, 1993, the Historic Preservation Board approved variances to reduce the required side and rear setbacks for a proposed 3-bay garage, a variance request to reduce the distance between two residential buildings within the multi-family developments, a waiver to reduce the right-of-way width on SE 7th Avenue from 60'to 40', and the site plan, subject to conditions. The Board required that a sidewalk be installed along the west side of SE 7th Avenue from the north property line to the northernmost parking space. The Board also gave partial approval for the proposed architectural design elements. While the development approval expired, the variances remained as these run with the land, as opposed to with the validity or establishment of an approved project. In December, 1995, the Historic Preservation Board approved the restoration of the historic dwelling, expansion and upgrading of the existing one-story triplex to two stories, construction of a second-story on the existing single-family residence, construction of a three-bay garage, construction of a swimming pool, and the installation of fences, walkways, and decking, subject to conditions. One condition was that Unity of Title and condominium documentation be recorded as the development proposal contained three individually platted lots. Once these documents were recorded, the triplex became a three-unit condominium unit, the two-story, single family residence became a single-unit condominium, and the one-story, contributing structure became a single-unit condominium with an associated attached garage. Then at its June 1, 2016 meeting the Historic Preservation Board approved a COA and Class II Site Plan Modification consisting of additions and alterations to the 1925 Mission style structure on the site, as follows: • Addition to the south elevation with French doors facing south; • Screened porch over existing patio on the south elevation with simulated coral rock columns and decorative trellis supporting new awning above; • 2nd story addition to main structure consisting of 910 square feet; • New shed style, fabric awnings on residence (Sunbrella, Forest Green Tweed); • Extension of chimney to second story on north elevation; • New single French door on west elevation of residence; • New Weathershield PGT aluminum clad wood windows and doors in medium walnut finish; and, • Alterations to the detached garage that included a new flat, single-panel door on the north elevation and new shed style fabric awnings (Sunbrella, Forest Green/Beige Blvd. stripe). The applicant is now before the Board to request review of the Tax Exemption Application for the aforenoted site and building improvements. Based on State regulations, an Ad Valorem Tax Exemption can be approved for a project before, during, or after it has been undertaken. The applicant therefore requests consideration of the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption as the project is complete. 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of November 7, 2018 AD VALOREM TAX EXEMPTION Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J), a tax exemption is available for improvements to qualifying contributing properties in a designated historic district or individually designated properties, as listed in Section 4.5.1(1). Qualifying properties shall be exempt from that portion of ad valorem taxation levied by the City of Delray Beach on one hundred percent (100%) of the increase in assessed value resulting from any HPB approved renovation, restoration, rehabilitation, or other improvements of the qualifying property made on or after the effective date of the original passing of Ordinance 50-96 on November 19, 1996. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(1), clarifies that the exemption does not apply to the following: (a) Taxes levied for payment of bonds; (b) Taxes authorized by a vote of the electors pursuant to Section 9(b) or Section 12, Article 7 of the Florida Constitution; or (c) Personal property. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(2), explains the exemption period shall be for ten (10) years, unless a lesser term is set by the City Commission. (a) The term of the exemption shall be specified in the resolution approving the exemption and shall continue regardless of any changes in the authority of the City to authorize such exemption or change in ownership of the property. (b) To retain an exemption,the historic character of the property and the improvements which qualified the property for an exemption must be maintained in their historic state over the period for which the exemption was authorized. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(4) provides the parameters for qualifying properties and improvements. The subject property qualifies as it is listed on the Local Register of Historic Places. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(5) requires that for an improvement to a historic property to qualify the property for an exemption, the improvement must: (a) be consistent with the United States Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended; and (b) be a constructed and/or installed improvement as approved by the Historic Preservation Board and as established in rules adopted by the Department of State, Division of Historical Resources, FAC 1A-38, as amended which defines real property improvements as changes in the condition of real property brought about by the expenditure of labor and money for the restoration, renovation, or rehabilitation of such property. Improvements shall include, but are not limited to: modifications, repairs, or additions to the principal contributing building and its associated accessory structures (i.e. a garage, cabana, guest cottage, storage/utility structures, swimming pools), whether existing or new. The exemption does not apply to improvements made to non-contributing principal buildings, existing non-contributing accessory structures, or undesignated structures and/or properties; and, (c) be consistent with Section 4.5.1(E), "Development Standards", of the City's Land Development Regulations; and (d) include, as part of the overall project, visible improvements to the exterior of the structure. The project meets the above criteria (a)and (b)through previous approval by the Board of the associated improvements outlined above which constituted its compliance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as well as the rules of Florida Administrative Code 1A-38, promulgated by the Florida Department of State, Division of Historical Resources. The development project further meets criterion (c) per the COA approval, which applied the LDR Development Standards in the assessment of the proposal. Finally, the project meets criterion (d) as the project encompasses visible improvements to the exterior of the building and related property. • 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of November 7, 2018 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(7), any property owner, or the authorized agent of the owner, that desires an ad valorem tax exemption for the improvement of a historic property must submit a Historic Property Tax Exemption Application to the Planning and Zoning Department upon completion of the qualifying improvements. (a) The application shall indicate the estimated cost of the total project, the estimated cost attributed solely to the historic structure, and project completion date as determined by the Certificate of Occupancy issued by the Building Department. (b) The Historic Property Tax Exemption Application shall be accompanied by a copy of the most recent tax bill from the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser for the property; a new property survey illustrating the improvements; a copy of the building permit application indicating estimated project cost; a copy of the Certificate of Occupancy/Final Inspection; and photographs illustrating the before and after of each improvement, including both the interior, exterior, and all new construction. The photographs shall be identified with a date and description indicating the impact of the improvement. (c) The application must be submitted within three (3) months from the date of issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. (d) The Historic Preservation Planner will inspect the completed work to verify such compliance prior to Historic Preservation Board review. a. If the Historic Preservation Board determines that the work is a qualifying improvement and is in compliance with the approved plans and the review standards contained in Section 4.5.1(E), the Board shall recommend that the City Commission grant the Historic Property Tax Exemption Application. b. Upon a recommendation of approval of a Historic Property Tax Exemption Application by the Historic Preservation Board, the application shall be placed by resolution on the agenda of the City Commission for approval. The resolution of the City Commission approving the application shall provide the name of the owner of the property, the property address and legal description, a recorded restrictive covenant in the official records of Palm Beach County as a condition of receiving the exemption, and the effective dates of the exemption, including the expiration date. c. If the Historic Preservation Board determines that the work as completed is either not consistent with the approved plans or is not in compliance with the review standards contained in Section 4.5.1(E),the applicant shall be advised that the request has been denied The qualifying improvements were completed and the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application was submitted on October 10, 2018, within three months of the Certificate of Occupancy, which was issued on September 24, 2018. The tax exemption will be limited to the increase in assessed value (as determined by the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser) resulting from the subject improvements and provide an abatement of taxes on the City and County portions for a period of ten years from the date of approval. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(8), Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant, the covenant required in order to qualify for the exemption: (a) To qualify for an exemption, the applicant must sign and return the Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant with the Final Application/Request for Review of Completed Work. The covenant as established by the Department of State, Division of Historical Resources, shall be in a form approved by the City of Delray Beach City Attorney's Office and applicable for the term for which the exemption is granted and shall require the character of the property and qualifying improvements to be maintained during the period that the exemption is granted. (b) On or before the effective date of the exemption, the owner of the property shall have the covenant recorded in the official records of Palm Beach County, Florida, and shall cause a certified copy of the recorded covenant to be delivered to the City's Historic Preservation Planner. Such covenant shall be binding on the current property owner, transferees, and their heirs, assigns and successors. A violation of the covenant shall 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of November 7, 2018 result in the property owner being subject to the payment of the differences between the total amount of the taxes which would have been due in March of each of the previous years in which the covenant or agreement was in effect had the property not received the exemption and the total amount of taxes actually paid in those years, plus interest on the difference calculated as provided in Sec. 212.12(3), Florida Statutes. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(10), Revocation Proceedings, provides guidelines to revocation of the tax exemption upon violation of the recorded covenant. (a) The Historic Preservation Board may initiate proceedings to revoke the ad valorem tax exemption provided herein, in the event the applicant, or subsequent owner or successors in interest to the property, fails to maintain the property according to the terms, conditions and standards of the Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant. (b) The Historic Preservation Planner shall provide notice to the current owner of record of the property and the Historic Preservation Board shall hold a revocation hearing in the same manner as in Section 4.5.1(M)(10), and make a recommendation to the City Commission. (c) The City Commission shall review the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Board and make a determination as to whether the tax exemption shall be revoked. Should the City Commission determine that the tax exemption shall be revoked, a written resolution revoking the exemption and notice of penalties as provided in Paragraph 8 of the covenant shall be provided to the owner,the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser, and filed in the official records of Palm Beach County. (d) Upon receipt of the resolution revoking the tax exemption, the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser shall discontinue the tax exemption on the property as of January 1st of the year following receipt of the notice of revocation. The Sections noted above regarding the "Restrictive Covenant" and "Revocation Proceedings" are provided to demonstrate that the tax exemption is binding, and if violated, the property owner would have to comply with the consequences. The tax exemption request complies with the criteria contained in LDR Section 4.5.1(J) as the Historic Preservation Board approved the associated improvements by making positive findings with respect to the applicable LDR Sections, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation; therefore, positive findings can be made with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(J). ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Recommend approval to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). C. Recommend denial to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon a failure to make positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). RECOMMENDATION Recommend approval to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application (2018-150)for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7tn Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). Attachments: Tax Exemption Application and Supporting Documents Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner A Delray Beach .cs ( oe, HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD 1.1311 „' � STAFF REPORT 'IIIII AMERICA 0 � DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT -- EP 100 NW 1"AVENUE,DELRAY BEACH,FLORIDA 33444 always defray PLANNING&ZONING DIVISION:(561)243-7040 • BUILDING DIVISION:(561)243-7200 COA-Signs Meeting: November 7, 2018 File No.:2019-010 Application Type: COA-HPB-Signs General Data: IIP - Agent: Mark Gregory Applicant: Mark Gregory Owner: Sure Ring, Inc. • Location: 8 E.Atlantic Avenue e r Property Size: 0.22 _s_-: FLUM: Other Mixed Use(OMU) _1 Zoning: Old School Square Historic Arts(OSSHAD), Central Business District • (CBD) Overlay < - - Adjacent Zoning: • North: OSSHAD - • East: OSSHAD t I • South: OSSHAD • West: OSSHAD { Item Before the Board: The action before the board is the approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA)-Signs associated with the installation of a wall and a projecting sign located at 8 E.Atlantic Avenue in the Old School Square Historic District, pursuant I to 4.5.1(E)(7). Recommendation: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-010) for 8. E. Atlantic Ave, Tin Roof, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5)with the following conditions: 1. That proposed neon lighting be replaced with Channel Letters to be more compatible and appropriate with the architecture of the structure; 2. That the awning mounted sign does not ePerch into the adjacent right-of-way on the north side of the property; 3. That the propose ent light bulbs within the"A LIVE MUSIC JOINT"text be frosted; and, 4. That the sign bo with the text"A LIVE MUSIC JOINT" be painted grey to match the awning. D Background: The 0.22-acre subject property is located within the OSSHAD (Old School Square Historic Arts District) zoning district; the Central Business District(CBD)zoning overlay and the Old School Square Historic District(OSSHD). The property consists of the West 26' of Lot 4 (Less the South 14') and Lot 5, Block 69 and contains a two-story Masonry Vernacular commercial building constructed in 1950 which is deemed to be a non-contributing structure. The structure is classified as noncontributing to the Old School Square Historic District.The 2009 Old School Square Historic District Project Planner: Review Dates: Attachments: Jennifer Buce, Assistant Planner; HPB,November 7.2018 • Sign drawings buce(a-mvdelravbeach.com,561.243.7138 • Examples of other sign installations throughout the country • Elevations ---------------- -----•--- ---- PAGE 11 • HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT +II+ AMEkICA always defray Resurvey recommended that the subject property be reclassified as contributing, as the Period of Significance was being expanded to include those eligible resources constructed between 1944 and 1965; however, the owner requested that the subject property not be reclassified. Upon adoption of Ordinance 10-10 on June 1, 2010, the Period of Significance for the Old School Square Historic District was expanded to 1965, and 10 of the properties that were recommended for reclassification were not reclassified to contributing, including the subject property, because the property owners elected to"opt-out"of this process. At its meeting of April 4, 2018, a Class II Site Plan Modification, Landscape Plan and COA request was approved for facade improvements, exterior color changes, installation of a new pergola and retractable fabric shade covering, new cabana in the outdoor area, aluminum railing system and a wood fence. The applicant is now before the board to install new signage mounted above the awning facing north and a small projecting sign facing east/west. The proposed awning mounted sign on the north elevation is 3.4 SF x 8.6 SF for a total of 29.6 SF. The sign will be attached to five 2" by 2" square tubes with up right gator shield tubes welded to the awning frame. The letters are supported to an aluminum back panel, open channel letters to be fabricated of aluminum backs with returns. The illumination of the sign is neon in the lettering of "Tin Roof', LED in the lady and exposed incandescent bulbs and sockets are exterior grade mounted in channel letters of the words "A LIVE MUSIC JOINT". The box is black and the wireway is attached to the existing steel supports. A projecting sign on the east elevation is proposed at 1.3 x 3 for a total of 7.8 square feet. The sign is double sided with the Tin Roof logo in LED illuminated cabinet with print on a plexi glass face. Review and Analysis: Pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.7 (E)(7) Design Standard Matrix, the following matrix sets forth the standards for various types of signs when located in various zoning districts or defined by use. The standards set forth therein are subject to descriptions, interpretations, exceptions, and limitations as provided for elsewhere in these LDRs. The subject property is located within the OSSHAD (Old School Square Historic Arts District) zoning district; the Central Business District(CBD) zoning overlay and the Old School Square Historic District (OSSHD), which allows no more than two signs per lot or parcel or development. The size of a maximum wall sign is 30 Square feet and a projecting sign the maximum is 30 square feet per sign face. The proposed signs meet the intent of the sign code with respect to size. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines,and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.24(F)(7) Development Standards, All properties within the Old School Square Historic District are subject to the provisions of Section 4.5.1. LDR SECTION 4.5.1, HISTORIC PRESERVATION, DESIGNATED DISTRICTS,SITES,AND BUILDINGS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation,and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3), Buildings,structures, appurtenances and parking shall only be moved, reconstructed, altered, or maintained in accordance with this chapter, in a manner that will preserve the historical and architectural character of the building,structure,site,or district: Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)1, Appurtenances include, but are not limited to, stone walls, fences, light fixtures, 12 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT °i4", fp6{6RY! 1IP' AMERFA e awaysd es y steps, paving,sidewalks,signs and accessory structures. Based upon this code section signs are considered an appurtenance which shall preserve the historical and architectural character of the building and district. As the subject property is located within the OSSHD the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation are applicable; hence, there is importance in preserving "character-defining" and distinctive features, and discussing scale and compatibility within historic districts such as the following: Standard 8 New construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. The intent of this Standard has not been met. The proposed sign with its use of neon tubing is an improvement to a noncontributing building within a designated historic district that compromises the integrity of the district. The new restaurant Tin Roof is located within the heart of the downtown Delray Beach and signage within this commercial block is generally very conservative with each tenant space having the minimum signage as to not interrupt the architecture of the buildings. Although illumination is allowed under LDR section 4.6.7(E)(7)(5) many of the establishments have chosen not to illuminate their signs along this block. The use of neon tubing was common during the Art Deco period but is inappropriate for buildings of another historical period and the existing structure was constructed in 1950 in the Masonry Vernacular architectural style. A condition of approval is added to replace the neon tubing with channel Letters to be more compatible and appropriate with the architecture of the structure. Additionally. staff recommends that the box surrounding the words "A LIVE MUSIC JOINT" be painted grey to match the awning color and also that the incandescent bulbs in the words "A Live Music Joint" be frosted to reduce light spillage of direct light onto adjacent properties. The proposed recommendations will help protect the historic integrity of the building and the surrounding areas. The wall sign is proposed on the north edge of the awning and the projecting sign is proposed on the west side of the north elevation. Engineered drawings have been submitted and reviewed by the building department confirming that the proposal will meet wind load requirements. In addition,the valance of an awning is often a visible and unobtrusive location for signage. The Tin Roof Signage is unique in that it is attached to the awning and is supported by aluminum poles and is positioned above the awning 3' 4" yet does not impede above the roofline. An additional condition of approval has been included that the awning mounted sign does not encroach into the adjacent right-of-way on the north side of the property. The projecting sign on the west side of the north elevation is below the awning at 9 ft.; thus, subject to the above noted condition of approval, a positive finding can be made on the placement of both signs. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(7) - Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, facade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1.Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m). Visual compatibility for all development on individually designated properties outside the district shall be determined by comparison to other structures within the site. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(7)(I) Architectural Style, all major and minor development shall consist of only one architectural style per structure or property and not introduce elements definitive of another style. The proposed sign includes the use of neon tubing, which is a sign element utilized during the Art Deco time period and is not appropriate for the 1950's Masonry Vernacular architectural style of the structure. Compliance with this standard can be made provided the neon tubing is replaced with channel letters. Assessment and Conclusion: Provided the conditions of approval are met, the proposed signage meets the intent of LDR Sections 4.6.7(E)(7)for the Old School Square Arts Historic District and 4.5.1(E) Historic Preservation. - -,13 ep£SEAyf 0 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT . ERICA ahwys defray Alternative Actions: A. Continue with Direction B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-010)for 8.E.Atlantic Avenue,Tin Roof, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5),subject to the conditions of approval. C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-010) for 8. E. Atlantic Avenue, Tin Roof, by finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). �4 DOROTHYJACKS t . et 413a ._A e7 .,.a EAll a:. 4. •• YietiQT9RgrtrR_tord ` ��"�1 �. 4 '.r.: t: -- 1 Owners . , rr ii ' .•�T'' .. L *1, RE RIN G IN.: v . r ~ri 1 Property detail ,f 1 f ,,,,mon 8 E ATLANTIC AVE _ _ , ,•��. i 'll 0 ` t 1 Munk Ipaluy DELRAY BEACH t. Emma �.* ri 11ryTel N0. 12434616010690041 _�� • - 1SOOdh hwn DELRAY TOWN Of ' !' ey'" j.1 t:- t 666 z :I t 8ouk 07913 rain 0914 ,tom . ��� %ale Date AUG-1993 _ - "'�' ( 9409 BRIARCLIFF TRCE - ! ' 4. e Itt`• { Addles, PORT SAINT LUCIE FL _ 3 .e. s= h, _ r • 4 34986 3358 `` ( •s .•i4 (.ts.- 5 T .! l ' t. • !I,e Ifpe 3300 NIGHTCLUBS _• r `., TOtel 3003 1 7, j .ee�i H� I.�.'-' �. ',WIMP feet *6` . 44 _ .• - . . • 'N_ rr - -J 1111 1 . • �. ` �.-y-r _. flf ►�' --., f: r - d- I _ Wo �„�s' - tl 1y e fir• ' Proposed Sign 104" 1 towir,_ '1 k AV) 4, Lill 4 1 ..ijo , . 001% 41 " • 4t A LIVE MUSIC JOINT 25'8" i. y9 pi Jam' �'`I �_ _� 2'.'15.'!'.97,4 N . t`. " : , / rr fs'. ' . r- I r ti'�rl _i_ 41 I:t" 1I �� �/ e_( Facing North Sign Cross Section � I I� I_ Sign Awning Tin Roof above awning, Alive music Joint on valance Sizing and dimensions 41111R6 Lew/ Awning Valance Face Sign Attached to (5) 2" x 2" square tube up right gator shield tubes uprights welded to awning frame. Uprights need to be properly spaced and proper high from top of awning To be provided by awning company. Tin Roof letters and cabinet to be fabricated of aluminum .080 backs with .063 returns 3/8"through bolts with nuts and washers top and bottom on each up right (4)for Tin (2)for Girl(4)for Roof A Live Music Joint panel to have one 1/4"thru bolt per column thru awning material letters attached to raceway with 3116"pop rivets or machine screws average(4)per letter 4 individual components:(1) A live Music Joint 8'tall x 118"wide box with letters secured to awning face (2)"Tin"channel letters 24"tall by 43"wide(3)Dancing Girl 24"wide by 37"tall (4)Roof channel letters 24"tall by 48"wide �j Awning Valance Face Project.Tin Roof 8 East Atlantic Ave Delray Beach;Fla S11.0%at 11111111140 1, ,. St A LIVE MUSIC J4Awnin g i I1 Li _ Li Letters supported to an of aluminum back panel 080 backs wth.063 returns **tram titLid light with connectors 1!111 5 vpt :N2 'itralYdf Open channel letters with neon outline within metal canTube Supports with neon ties ai a oao.a;ade nanermmnElectrodes booted ?WetV*RamsI:om it1 Sin tW6ef 206f8C.t70UPtiodt0eed.E �C. Neon tubing �',, ' IsawtamengnvdoegxunrmeZaeFait II Tin Roof letters to be fabricated of aluminum.080 backs with.063 returns ii Patl 1i4'through bolts w11b nuts and washers top and bottom on each up right B' (4)far Tin(2)for Gid(4)for RoofTuna Creo�. letters attached to clay 3116`pop nve s lr nrachne strews avenge 41 per leer Fi -i-- - — Bonded • \ kOnnectSvii l ':r:y tiP7ica a^r}-,.,h: •• 20 amp •`• Mather Proof ••• • • Incandecent bulbs and sockets exterior grade Mounted in channel letters. Letters attached to wireway. Wireway to match awning color. Wireway attached to existing steel supports I I LED Ballast 12/24 Volt 1/4"through bolts with nuts and washer(1) One per support • j' II Bushing Trimmed Plexiglas Face I Letters Build to UL Standards and Bear UL Labels with full color print iiiBack Panel Letteseuatolocaiwitig code rerweeers8 undennpasLaboraamsstemaats Existing upright support _��„„„,,,,�jNem,„„ Channel Letter for dancing NVie Flom.Bebop Cade C„aole•and my and al armee of.alneer Nem.Eleam Com girl Pr y0yatw...'2n¢nr..Y.at].ne tHNN N carom anaunes and allcoe.,.Ap.eenmnea+EC m ue N:eginoonennue+naane 0a r wn Pe current NEC mu FBC One 20 NTP Gan.M one 20.np Oncnnoct Seem©Ea.'mmia-+nc Sean ta comply. 1,NEC 600SyStemtooebonded LED Diodes itt alto 444.,„ tir A ): 1-11/ E MUSIC JOINT • \., r .1. • • • \ • Typical Light layout on each letter Non animated Up Right column spacing 1 1 I — I E it 1 I i I 1 I 1 , L L , I .„,„..........,,,...... MID POINT Awning frame by awning comany____,,, cr.„,2c:;,,,,,,‘:,..„,/,..,",:.teLti _i:.___,:-.. 2,...‘" ; ,,,„LL,„„ --;!,; t•-:,TTus., !?.::::::•T,T.-.._,..„, --- --- I- ' 3-,.'Ic•-•1-'0''''..."1,,' ;Tccl ! '-iPrif:','Jg:: 2-7. 79a.'7'."-;,Z:t. ww;,,,,_•.,. . 1 EI:ER;-,L NO-ES ii, ca.cpactT '-' •,,' I . i i---"---.--.. —:•••-, c.4.-, ,.--1..7-:-.• -----...... _, ;••I--.;i'• 4 , , 1 'ANCHOR SCHEDULE ,. T 1/4.sTZCIThaa,;laces , I :`: •,Tre4 T.: ext.:r.,concTcte to Onto J,-- IL ...:,31, .:.,,.......7....:;,... ' Il ' ,""tour Ji.-I '-P.."P.S'cr ' "'' 't.:''T;:;'.ftt ‘ ':- -.',' ..,,,,, ,•,......---,.,• Side View U -- _ - ___ _ Sign Cross Section 51 -- Fro' ting Sign nil mcomimmiassiommoi 36" gir16" "r alZ0i Projecting Sign ( A LIVE MUSIC JOINT ) ! LED illuminated cabinet with print on plexiglass face LED illuminated cabinet with print on plexiglass face 36" • 16" If, E..A LIVE PelUS-+C JOINT ) (*wined Sratdi Isialifa ilp211.0 20 amp Weather Proof Tim el jtlockf 12/24 Power Supply Box Flat plexiglass panel with printed graphic 3/8'x 4" expansion bolts,wedge anchors or tap cons O ! � 1/4' thick aluminum base plate d Cabinet fabricated of.090 aluminum with an internal angle frame 1"x 3" center support d LED DIODES Cabinet fabricated of aluminum welded assembly Letters Build to UL Standards and Bear UL Labels Letters built to local building code requirements& Underwnters Laboratones standards Project: Tin Roof ofAlt electricalFloridairingngd iodtallhapshall comply awith the articles of th 8 East Atlantic Ave the Forid Building Code Chapter and any and all articles of the current National Electric Code Primary by others,1/2 raceway with#12 wire THHN All breakers and timing devices shall be identified at time of installation Delray Beach, F I a All components Lift_listed and shall comply with the current NEC and FBC One 20 Amp Circuit and one 20 amp Disconnect Switch @ Ea Transformer Sign to comply with NEC 600,system to be bonded • I I I ISCOPE OF WORK 1/(�'f���//-w'p��'.n1 • 'n • REMOVAL OF EXISTING FINISH MATERIALS.PARTIAL DEMO OF EXISTING OPENINGS TO M„V[i ACCOMMODATE ACCORDION STOREFRONT SYSTEMS.DOORS.NEW EXTERIOR C RAILINGS.LIGHT FIXTURES.BUILDING FINISHES.AND INTERIOR RENOVATION.ALL is ,: " WORK TO OCCUR VATHIN EXISTING AND VESTED BUILDING AND SITE FOOTPRINT. 9 Caw n1.. LEGAL DESCRIPTION THE WEST 28 FEET OF LOT 4,EXCEPT THE SOUTH IC FEET THEREOF.AND ALL OF LOT 9 5.MCGINLEY B GORMAN%SUBDIVSION OF BLOCK a.DELRAY REACH.ACCORDING 0 - TO THE PLAY THEREOF,RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2.PAGE 93.PUBLIC RECORDS OF 111.1 E PALM BEACH COUNTY,FLORIDA. •r..r.n...n.. ....„ - se n,..1 ...Comm fra.wrw.lrc. ". '....-'- O `., HISTORIC INFORMATION rrl:E rran...MO - -NON CONTRIBUTING BUILDING .TWO STORY MASONRY VERNACULAR BUILDING CONSTRUCTED IN 1050. ... c.. Eeen s.mr Emo.....wro 45.5-5504150 r—r,...rum—_ Ulm.,N.1601,14 ��� ���� ���� alb'�� SITE DATA �,.,p I�r S, r40 40 "`��A SITE ZONING j © \ LOCATION nAP ZONING DESIGNATION'. O56HA0 �Y~'/OF F� M ZONING D DESIGNATION: OMU(OTHER MOPED USE) \• -A _fs _ _ EXISTING USE. RESTAURANT p- 0 �4 „ LOT AREA B.)I3SF 9 IE \`\ . _ PAT10 ` � `/ — \\ \ BUILDING AREA CALCUTATON IFurrc 00 1 \ ao �\ EXISTING GROUND FLOOR AREA: 2.580SF V 1 ' B PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR AREA: 2.580 SF (/!' 14)• h TOTAL AREA ATGROUND FLOOR- 2.5BO SF py11Ne e e EXISTING SECOND FLOOR AREA: 309 SF ��.,.. PROPOSEDSECOND FLOOR AREA 2NBF \` • mVAT&ass ® 1 �- - � I TOTAL COMBINED FLOOR AREA: 2.8025E JJ ,\ PTO I N e Q SITE AREA CALCULATION _ LL ` T 1 ,. ., i "----'4 - .1 \a ° BUILDING FOOTPRINT: 28829E 28%OF SITE _ �8� \� �T PATIO AREA: 2.8925E 2TI6 OF SITE EJ p 1 _ t,„\ BORALER tAl \' LANDSCAPE AREA: D396F 10Y OF SIZE �`!y```S.`\ +nl MAIN �1Z ; ` PAVEOIPARKING Am: 3.505 SF 35%OF BITE 04 \\ ll , -EflWCF, 1 ,I ® • 1-1 g�TpJgRAG�p TOTAL AREA. 9373 SF 100%OF SITE 1 •=sLI -I I. 468E SITE NOTE ITEMS: W Il, 1.ALL EXISTING PARKING TO REMAIN. 0 ` 1!•y""- ; _ \ ® 1�t 2.DUMPS1Eq AREA REMAINS IN CURRENT LOCATION. Ui BUILDNG SET BACKS: { - �s t `�, Ty REQUIRED'. EXISTING: PROPOSED: Z Z B 4 " - 1 NORTH S10E(FRONT- 1050.MIN.15'-0'MAX. ID-0' 10ra• O W `�\\\`"V1111 ���LL-�.. KTI CHEN . ` WEASTSIDE: V-0• Ba• 0'-0• F Q WEST SIDE: 0-0• Oa' 0'a' O U `` BOUTIi SIDE 1BACIQ. 10'a• sea• ez-0 I 1.M 1p1 V ` �. . I ®v 7 1 I BUILDINGEXIS HEIGHT: TO IIEMAIN. O pc \ A •Gib," B l d g ")�• REQUIRED EXISTING: PROPOSED: V d7.. NIT : HEIGHT' 0 96'-P 1TC 1e e' W `VC, SO.RP re \�L FLOORS: 2 2 2 ' N QQ r tr CNIC OPEN SPACE: W O 5 \ F%ISTINCTINF \ REQUIRED: EXISTING: PROPOSED: CO � 1 H SITE SMALLER THAN D% 0% 0% d EMMA 4 fi \\\ /. \, , 20.0006F. * Yilie \ - - BEATING COUNT L-• RI' 8 ] B \ RE0001E0: IXNTNG: PROPOSED: „a,,,ym,.^„;' ^ • TOTAL SEATS: NIA NM 124 arr. nrir.,m.nnw.,, \ PERVIOUS/IMPERVIOUS .re M I \ ---- _ REQUIRED: COSTING. PROPOSED: ^"^`�^`°•` m� 20 . N IRS PERNOUS: SEE NOTE BELOW B33 SF DO%) 8338E(10%) A P9SRMp1a a INOVI01. IMPERVIOUS: SEE NOTE BELOW B,M)SF(BD%1 B14)9F(BO%I a M2Mabn 4lnmmp lml) \ --042N- ...i j •9.8.16(B)(4)TO ANY MODIFICATION TO EXISTING DEVELOPMENT WHICH RESULTS IN AN n uu. u...,.CI PUR•vglen .a az.MmM r \ e uzB.,.«,. Sil INCREASE OF 2596IN THE GROSS FLOOR AREA OF THE STRUCTURE.OR STRUCTURES, SITUATED ON THE SITE.IN SUCH CASES THE ENTIRE 811E SHALL BE UPGRADED TO PRESENT LANDSCAPE STANDARDS.IAMD.ORD.22115 521/I06) 0 PARKING CALCULATIONS PARKING, EXISTING: PROPOSED, "1Y1O1 STANDARD8 B • COMPACTEDRDD SPACES S ON SITE. 2 2 HANDICAP SPACES ON SITE: I I Floor Plans TOTAL. B B ..'n'r. (IDs100 R ,1 OVERALL FIRST FLOOR PLAN 0 PARTIAL SECOND FLOOR PLAN •ALL EXISTING PARKING TO REMAIN. ' '� � A-100 3F32'-ra A.IaB slsr-rr °Ecr.— I I I I wmr • I I I I MU" &$ ht,OF F{� S4g$ onyx,W. ONNAErER i17414 a ^�'/ 011/17/18 F I_ 1MM hh 1T 9'V 3 s ®® I I -- f U co - Y _________ID:I�J ..�ii.,mi.....iii C l0 .o, > _= ,, 111_111111,' �11 ==_ aw ' �::I�iiiii�iiilliiiiiii I: u., Zo io o Z 1 EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION O CCAJO, 3ne'=no• U W E I- O e A A \ - -' - 1I - - 10D'.-U„8' -wm.uu� F. C!�,. ,eW.-e; 1.k G ; n.5 ii‘ • INIMINEIRIN ._ .,,w,F,==.Q �e:..._ A m,.M ,....,.,w-... . —,...._ w,.. a North �'M ..� A, = A101 Elevations 2I PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION 3 PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION-ADA UFT AND CABANA SEATING/STAGE �- ■ A 401 0 3ne'=Ib' A401 3/1e'=1b' 1 I I I I LAT/R E E V G I?0 U P7A-s --7- ...,..., iI=OZ: i ,',:r 4.7;„:4, '-',. Li I I ...••••.....•..•.6.... ///—••.•.,•,.L,....,. .,.,„, \A- 11 _ I _1 I,' • ,L, I ) ,..L.°0',`,',2,S- w co \Ili .:JT[-•rEj-L, ....,-____ •< W 0 W IT3..-- 4-• > 0 I= 1 I EXISTING WEST ELEVATION W 0 IL Z A•603 I 3/10..1.-0. 0 CC 0 <,C 1.4 C I- 0 3 o •— ,,,‘* SE I— CO CO ...........,-... ..-.-.-, .th --....-•-•-•-•-•---.-.....-., ....,......... 3 ,..,.., . •r , A , . , .-F_ --- —: A • .. .L..;7'..,'.:,,•-..',7' -...1:72:::.t.7...=:::-7.-.-..,-. , . .....,::i,,.:.;.•- 0-...,., —0—,1PL1-411,1-0•0111,11,--,5011011. S-2,110.39.101.10101111.--STMZ. F Pal 11•001.1. 1 ....,$: 10 . • • 1 • 1 - '''''''.• c::'•:'•'....,::: camt.le A .. .___'_ _ •."_ ', \•' . .:.::',.-: V: _------.. •-jmNIIIIIIII I % i 7. - :• r 1,, \ . Le.,,,,,o.,, ...... ,, .:illlil , I% . ....., .................... „..„:,..,„.,.,::„...,....„. ......, West Elevations 21 PROPOSED WEST ELEVATION 3 PROPOSED EAST ELEVATION-CABANA SEATING STAGE 01,11 F•F•F,F ii.••10 1 3115.=I.7 A-103 3/1(1..I.Cr '1' A-403 2 1 ,..,.. ce,,role I I I I • -.1._., (e..1.1.....'"""....ft."T -..., .i ) , . , . ,...„.. ..... 11 A 1.4 ., .. ., ,. . , . . .,, ,.,.. , . : i .... .., 4 , . . _ . •.---lit . . • . it .. . --,.. ... :---. . ...... . . • .. .. .. . . .. • : . ..,:111WW,. . - . . ,,_,:: ., ' , ..-•- 1 -4I F .. ..:. ..... ....._ „ .48 f ,. ......_..7.1,,,s... .,. wo. . IP ANK ...'RFC. , _... *. 1 1 . di E ....., A ,.1 ,14--• 0 ,[ i A lj t'l 11 . , eft ..• I ovii 111. , . mil Plit . n71 .... -. •,, .... , •a '..-74461, illr is; ' \ itili.- , ,II I I I i rl I I ig- 111, !it 11 k •i'...' , ., . . . t if 115. ia.ii 7, . 4/- ) 4111 ''. .... - I II ...... 4 ..,1 110 I — — 111111111 4LN/ft lilt / V Ilk 4. . el 11 /11:I . 1, "47. 71.11111111": ik— , . .... _ is • • • I . - A i a� _' • - _. ,� •• :�':: i. I. /A �_ a �ti_ • j o. 9 , "1s di ii \' 41 41 rrSTARBUCKS' --- -s _:�--- - - a __. ... �.a �Y � ;__ �_` - • t• I Deli ,.\ 'tip n. t .,t _ 75 �i r�' ". �a t .. .. .J . _y x - Aye e ! I \ IMMINIIIH.6 i 1' , . r.'4 ' .. ' . . • , I. . 1 S f 1 , 1/°V M1 + 'A , i � , ri , 4,1116w6 '' Ill Ifli*,,r,• ., , AttOrl' - ..matatairsi tiot ._. .,. IIII ..... ,. ION _,..-7 Al '4* 4.. l "; ---- - . • ------1 I III • . 1 - , , ...... ....-- i,.. t'111 ''::,'ii,:':1 - '''i:',- ,It',,,i a,. . 1 4 , -,' , :MS OM••••••• 4::;.''IL:,''.:''.,' 1 ..''Ill ..-1:` -7--- -- ' 4. •I 011 _ ;T.-,--,,,, _ i ,,,,.p,•0... 74001 ,,,g, po. ::‘,,i--,, I,a: ."- 1111111..0111.111.11ft,, , 4..4. . : a. O. .... . . 11111111 . .,,..4 ........ , 1 iwiliamil I 1 ..... . • 1 . . ..,..• _ .,.. ...... . .. .. .,.. , ,...., .:,../:,.,.,i P . , , N, ,• , •... ., .: . , . , • _. _..... A- . - . . liTh.I . 1 .A..:, •....,• .04. • 11 • . 1111111" * • .4,'', , ' . . • •. f- • • • •-• g'-, I • • ' • •• • ' 00°P' iiillPer-Ne_. • • ...... 40. . .4 .0 ,, , . ..aoldin ... i - , WO .14,1,T1 ek. • . „ r 4... .t,. , ,. • .• , # , , ;... . •- ' - ' • 4 Nt li 414 • • . .... , •-*-2 ' - „ , :' --; ----:-. ' -'-,_ Op -.•,-,,, . •, --, •. ._ . - ,.. ) .1, 1 ' i I" 7.. . ; '...' .4k . • .--. .,..--... ,.,-.^. S II to- „ . • I Ili 1 .. •.., . ... • .. . , •,,„ . •Z•71; . -' -,.'''' .'"''' •. _. ..:, .. .. .„.,......,.... : . .. . .. _ -1 4 . ,• , HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT f' MEETING DATE: November 7, 2018 ITEM: 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District — Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-218) for the installation of 2 new aluminum pergolas to the existing historic structure. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness GENERAL DATA: Owner/Applicant HIDEAWAY BY THE SEA, LLC - `qi Po = — -:err, :_, -'t Agent. Roger Cope, Cope Architecture, Inc. . t Location- West side of SE 7th Avenue, , 4tr ` ' M I . '• 'r between SE 1st Street and SE 2nd r Street _ I Property Size. 0.16 Acres "Wilt 11. - .-, - 4 Historic District: Marina Historic District 4 tr < ... . 'itIlli ,N ss Zoning. RM (Multiple Family Residential . f t I ' 41 '4 Medium Density) ! ` Adjacent Zoning. : :• 41111114 North: RM -Is - . East: RM i 4 . { I ` South: RM West: CBD �: ' g . : -ii iiie , ,,,,. Existing Future Land ` Use Designation. MD (Medium Density 5-12 DU/Acre) - 4t,,, Al . Water Service. Public water service is provided i on site. Sewer Service. Public sewer service is provided _ ` 'Z�"`` - on site. !r. _ • a_ NORTH 4 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-218) for the installation of 2 new aluminum pergolas on the east and west sides of the structure located at 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The property is located within the RM (Multi-Family Residential) zoning district. The 0.16-acre lot measures 50' wide x 135' deep and contains a 1,660 sq. ft. existing duplex. The historic Post-World VVar II, Mid-Century Modern style structure was built in 1949 and is classified as contributing to the Marina Historic District. According to the City Property cards, the historic structure had a floorplan consisting of six rooms, flat roof and composition shingle roof, concrete block construction, stucco exterior walls, plaster interior finish, and terrazzo flooring. In 2003, a Certificate of Appropriateness (2003-053) was administratively approved for rebuilding of the flat roof over the existing enclosed porch on the front façade (East Elevation) with modified bitumen. At its June 13, 2018 meeting the Historic Preservation Board approved a COA request for exterior renovations and additions to the existing duplex including: 1. Construction of two (2) 65 sq. ft. bathroom additions on the south side of the structure, one bathroom for each dwelling unit of the duplex; 2. Construction of two new pools (one on the east side of the property and one on the west side of the property); 3. Installation of dark anodized bronze aluminum impact-resistant windows and doors; 4. Installation of a new bitumen sloped roof to match the existing roof over the enclosed porch on each dwelling unit; 5. Removal of wood-framed washer/dryer exterior enclosure on the North side of the property; 6. Installation of new fencing, landscaping and hardscaping; 7. Exterior color change to Benjamin Moore —"Frostine" (white); and, 8. Reconfiguration of the existing non-conforming parking area. A variance was also approved at this meeting to allow two new 65 sq. ft. additions to encroach 7.5' into the required 15' side interior setback on the South side of the property. The subject COA includes installation of 2 new white aluminum-framed pergolas on the east and west sides of the existing structure. The COA request is now before the Board for consideration. ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ZONING AND USE REVIEW Pursuant to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), Development Standards, properties located within the RM (Medium Density Residential) zoning district shall be developed according to the requirements noted in the chart below.As illustrated, the proposal is in compliance with the applicable requirements; therefore, positive findings can be made. Development Standards , Required Proposed Setbacks (Minimum): Front (East) 25' 40' Side Interior(South) 15' 15' Side Interior (North) 15' No Change Rear (West) 25' 28' LDR SECTION 4.5.1, HISTORIC PRESERVATION, DESIGNATED DISTRICTS, SITES, AND BUILDINGS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E) - Development Standards: all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Standard 2 The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. Standard 9 New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. Standard 10 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. The pergolas will provide a covered area on the subject property adjacent to the new pool and patio areas, creating an exterior living space for each of the units. The white, aluminum-framed pergola structures are differentiated from the duplex yet are compatible with the massing, size scale, and architectural features of Mid-Century Modern style structures. The pergolas will be attached to the residential structure in a manner that if removed in the future will not compromise the integrity of the historic building. The proposal meets the applicable standards noted above and their intent as the proposed changes ensure an appropriate exterior alteration of the historic property and duplex structure, protecting the historic integrity of the duplex and its environment by allowing the modernization of the exterior living spaces with durable materials. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(7) - Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m). Visual compatibility for all development on individually designated properties outside the district shall be determined by comparison to other structures within the site. Applicable Visual Compatibility Standards (a) Height: The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible in comparison or relation to the height of existing structures and buildings in a historic district for all major and minor development. For major development, visual compatibility with respect to the height of residential structures, as defined by 4.5.1(E)(2)(a), shall also be determined through application of the Building Height Plane. (b)Front Facade Proportion: The front facade of each building or structure shall be visually compatible with and be in direct relationship to the width of the building and to the height of the front elevation of other existing structures and buildings within the subject historic district. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. The proposed exterior alterations to the existing, historic duplex are appropriate and compatible with the Marina Historic District. The height of the 2 new pergolas (9') does not exceed the highest element of the existing residence. The proposed pergolas are compatible with the existing proportion of the front facade. The pergolas continue the flat roof line of the original Florida Rooms that characterized the original structure. The white aluminum frame of the pergolas is a durable material that is compatible with the Mid- Century Modern style of the historic duplex. The proposal meets the intent of the review criteria above; thus, positive findings are made with respect to the sections indicated above. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-218) for the property located at 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulation Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-218) for the property located at 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and by finding that the request and approval thereof is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulation Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATIONS Approve Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-218 for 126 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). Attachments: Site plan, elevations, and survey 10 0 10 20 30 40 LEGEND SYMBOLS [ . CONC. = CONCRETE .X) AIR CONDITIONER v1 0) I I I CBS WALL = CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE E111, CATCH BASIN N L TWO-STORY c= CENTER LINE cN JJ•D I SCALE. �„= ��� D.E._ODR DRAINAGE EASEMENT lei YlATER METER O. —� 2 PARKING ADJACENT BUILDING F.LR. =FOUND IRON ROD 21 IRRIGATION VALVE ♦�-' - SPA ES - I F.N. FOUND NAON PIPE BACKFLOW PREVENTER il i., N • m ,,.4♦, ♦♦;,� F.F.EL.=20.33' I ( F.D.H. FOUND DRILL HOLE FIRE HYDRANT OD "� T ♦♦ '41- � , ♦♦� I ___ I ♦♦ I ♦,�� LM.A.ARC OIAKE MAINTENANCE EASEMENT YlATER VALVE ♦♦� "%„I _ ' __ _____________COVERED________ __ LS- LICENSEDEDSINTE AN - CABLE BOX (^ O � FPL. TRANSFORMER () Lt k ♦♦ ♦ - - - - - NO 1.0. - NO IDENTIFICATION ♦♦♦♦♦� _ ♦♦ \d?---' - . CQ ELECTRIC BOX♦♦♦VM J /,9 N/A NOT APPLICABLE y UL ♦ ,♦i � • •'9 - d' Q' NCVD'29-NATIONAL GEODETIC VERTICAL DATUM OF 1929 i ! FIBER OPTIC 03 �;/ - �,♦,I- � ' • �p I NAVD'8B=NORTH AMERICAN VERTICAL DATUM OF 1988 �J MANHOLE (r 0 O O N�� . °°a ♦,\- _ _ - - O/L = ON LINE ♦�♦�' , z° rs i �"I - _ _ : P.B. =PLAT BOOK �C.` UTILITY POLE 1 ♦♦ pp ♦ti l�. : PC. PAGE I. LIGHT POLE �I N ���� _ !\� �d U ��� 1 (PJ PLAT `ti CONCRETE POLE la O Q O ♦♦ � �- W \� �� - LOT 8 BLOCK 70 I U.E. - UTILITY SEASEMENT <} V • I • • • `9 a ♦♦� -ASPHALT PAVEMENT RP.SIA. -PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR AND MAPPER `�= WOOD POLE O er ♦'1 ♦♦ I. : : P.C.P. -PERMANENT CONTROL POINT ,- \ CQ -� �„ � \. - - - - - 'A TELEFONE BOX ♦♦;� <i ° ° ,`„I : - _ R/W RAOIU57 OF YJAY ANCHOR O ♦♦•♦� a •♦�♦♦ ` 1 - ISAOA =ITS SUCCESSORS AND/OR ASSIGNS C/) VI,• r _ I - /° ♦♦1 _ _ " - F.I.R. 5/S Cj EXISTING ELEVATION Va m ♦♦i ¢ J I _ AT/MA =AS THEIR INTEREST MAY APPEAR •♦♦: Y •¢' `x� 1 1 1 9 PARKING SPACES u I♦►�♦�� < - - `♦♦�I my. - 2 PARKING- O - - Jam- 'N ALB tl 6761 COVERED AREA O> • I j- CBS. WALL • �;♦=�1 ,`♦,�,, •' SP/TGES ': C ' nt - q I /ram o.°- OVERHEAD LINE OH „• ••,7 `C♦` r .\�('� 131.50. I \�j - I CHAIN LINK FENCE(C.L.F) OW�„♦'1 : - 55 �„� .� - /. I - Y - - - t '1 2 OG I —., WOOD FENCE(W.F) ♦♦•♦% W o� ' of t u—u—n—u —u—" —� a—it—ii—n— , —c METAL FENCE (M.F) O O o W ♦♦�♦� s W 9 �♦♦ s. 6'W.F. 90'2q'05"o E '>7 o \ co6C. ����Z I ♦AN 6.5c o �1, h J' I, o ,�„ I r.._._,•_ • �i .— o Z / 6'�I I R `� o; A C�YJ * - I - L N C'- J�" 6'- - ." - s 01 In L; W ♦ANIA W �Q NI 8 ?0 „—"—" �E o,. Io' I o� 0��w Qom 0C QC Q• Q z ^z �• � Z.I J : ♦`w � o J O >vC0wo°Fo° C �hQ►♦VI INt. o� 2C s o p Q�IOO; e♦� o ♦VN1< o� 7:5' 7.5' S' ALLEY m ��� o�oz QQ a zo `►♦:��� I i o U LOT 9, "tea f4Qsr=w o o WQ ♦%ma Lo L • ♦1A I BLOCK 70 1 3 0o ,Wo � o� o�a `��� ♦♦. Z o 38.0' _ A\1 I Io Q % ; O % , atio `�- 2No 'o QUO) L.-,I?� —km4st , r- ,♦�_ 1a 31.80' 0 .0- ',�- ,� O o.2 io° orW =L`` =zo alq LAWN °a J�s ' J�CQ .►ft•`oI -,9 \- o I 00 Q IC �Op g'=U�z©-R TCJh LQo.TV ° � `i+ ? ,�` J] a' 9.25 6Q�, mo •o.,J- ,2\UC a"" `''�i h C L,, ,, GgN�, ♦♦♦ ♦♦V � NO T 14 o -.w ��� eW �Q ia ►♦♦♦;° CONC vw% c° r N i l ON',...-______. 4 0�� ©© <W ti©� Q. o �01 H \ QOI` ��° soOWOo� eC ��~O °o o ♦♦ ' 8.00' ONE-STORY o GH o Y °�ac�"nz= OU C���, =,� �pz2W `�A 1 • ♦ CONC. WALK ° RESIDENCE 143 N / �61� GH;)1c ! o mS`Q ,¢owo,,r ,_,Z k oo ♦tea ° ♦� o 9� ES oo7o -g� 2U>< e W, O♦♦ : od F.F.EL.=18.83'(NAVD'88) Milla\ ! " G ��o o w o%r° z<w3oo§w u z��o ♦ ♦ co •I ' O ~ Jo,2p> Wo owaa'' i- � O�OL�,I WA I • �� 30.1' 49.20' m LOT10, z Y ����z �<w � o hmi >C=� A z � '' `- �� BLOCK 70 I U s N�w�ma ♦♦♦'� J z II �� z o �'♦i a�j �� J� CHIMNEY �_ O ♦♦♦, per.- 1 N U ♦� \"/ a s I f` - I JMM Li ♦WI - , \p- m ♦4 ' 1 -add II ;� z -SVVV J VAN% c3 Oze r � l �h2Y ., r ;v S.= `� 2 p o m p JO • did, # , � \5' ` �' ' a yalyl C I 0 = W rn �T J ♦♦� 90`29'05" co % C' �, Q T o a♦v. d a.♦♦♦♦ k s 2 m o C OO ♦ ♦ �♦♦ ♦♦ ♦ ♦•y ,A `O A A ♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦�m. �♦♦V,mmov . , • - � • 5 SIDEWALK . °° ° ° I. 0° 0 r o o = ♦•►♦�•♦♦•♦ ♦► y ♦� �♦ia�•1 ♦w, EL'` CONCWAWA .G6s < °` PARKWAY CONC °. F.LR��1 I2�— . cfR„ . WAN& 2 W L,-, Z C NV MAW AV a ° o . o w G V J WNW •••ti 3 ti • • �9 6'ss 2' CONC. GUTTER J6�d. 7 z= LU 555555 v WA 5%`N ♦♦♦♦♦♦♦V WAN V 66'- j Q m - - `"♦a — - ' ti �Wok N. 50' TOTaLR�w SE2NDSTREET 1 — � o �_ , � ��♦�♦♦ % 24' ASPHALT PAVEMENT J6 • �6 c Q a ` o ♦♦♦♦♦♦,v s �'�♦♦♦,�♦♦ 6 d o ��♦�♦�: ♦��� .� . CONC. C�ONC.° Allillik CbNC. ��a ti o 0 o ♦, ♦tiiii♦tii♦ti,•,•••♦••••••♦•♦♦$4•••••••• :•♦••♦`••� ♦♦'♦•••••♦••♦`♦••••♦•••••2`•• ••♦ `♦`♦"♦•••♦••••••♦•••„0•♦♦0,�3 %S %S♦`♦♦�S% %*ti� %% %ti% S*S%%♦♦�♦%N %%%�ti SS S%**S•%2S%%*%*%%%S♦`♦♦ S%%S%%%__ \ Cs o z N h C V) ♦••♦•♦41"���♦IIAN♦ VA�♦ �♦�♦♦W `♦A♦NIAAP AN♦•♦v ..s♦.+♦♦•hamay.hwi0"ki.♦♦4ka"l.s♦go,$6,.s♦.:♦w♦w♦.aisAm,��♦,www0..♦ . .♦ % .,.♦♦:.w..♦s..♦.� yA AWAI.> ♦ MA*.♦ 0611 a>• — _ co ,�,' , W o O L„O L. •`♦♦♦♦a•♦•♦♦♦•♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦Ai♦•♦♦•♦♦♦♦ sm ••♦♦ ♦ * ASPHALT t ASPHALT o 0 0 Q L� Q a a ul c) a- 0 / 4 ! � /// ' / ; // /,'i , /, i/ i / -/' / / i SITE STATS: Gross Site Area: 13,150.0 sf i /, �� TWO-STORY / , j o W ' / � � � ��! � /�: � less 2'-6"Alley ROW Dedication: 2505 sf ADJACENT BUILDING ji" New Total Site Area: 12,899.5 sf /, F.F EL 20.33 / 1 � � ��� Existin•1-story Residence: 1,317 sf �J //� /-"i ,/ /�i , /,' 'z' ;// 7// Existing I-story renovated back to original porch: 254 sf ____ _CQ�IEREQ----"-- New 1-story'Addition: 2.789 sf „- t\ \ �� i New Total Building Area: 4,360 sf LL \ ° t(t � I 11 �' 1 Max Lot Coverage Allowed: 5,159.80 sf 40% O g1 Lot Coverage Proposed: 4,360.00 sf (33.80%of Site Area) I Sidewalk/Curbs: 960.24 sf ( 7.45%of Site Arca) j i TOTAL Impervious Area: 5,320.24 st (41.?5%of Site urea)I !�. .I i J - - AS .,�� n,�'..�iYT a ^ LOT B, BLOCK 70 - -- ---- ' Min.O en(landsea ed)S ace Re 'd: 3,224.87 sf(25.(kl°/) . Open(landscaped)Space Proposed: 5,676.00 sf(44.00%of Site Area) O •� 1 :11 '�� 1°. _ $� Permeable Pavers: 1,903.26sf (14.75%of Site Arca) 1 1 r I - I� �t , _ I Total Pervious Area: 7,579.26 sf (58.75%of Site Area) D r < O ° ) ' 1 >~ F Water Bodies: Not A Geable (__,' 11 0 r: < I / SETBACKS REQUIRED PROPOSED V U i- — ! `I _ Front- 25-0" 30'-0"(Swintun)/25'-0"(SE 2nd St) CC3 c� �� 1• , 0I I �i 1 j I j �� Rear- 10'_0" N/A U -0 ! 1 /; -- 1 1 N90 00'00"W 74/.50' ! " 1� Interior side- 7'-6" 5'-0"(VARIANCE) w r I;`. r II /. 1 I. - ! ! '5'8 "p6t = t. 1 1 : Street Side- 1�0" 24'44'" '--.+ e� �' - - _ ^-•_ s-a- -- - - --- -- -_-o- o,n -i'- II _ I Height- 35-ll" 1G'10"(existing) 3-. EXIST :SOD & EXIST — - i o - --�.. 1•lours- 1 1 3� cn I �1 SAT 'FARKWA?f, TO 2 it ---- _i______==—I =�_-- I-==I—=-=_____- --^I�� 'y15-O'EXi5T&Lir '" t,r-, 1- 1 1 CUR ,iii -_--- - 1 1-6 Y-6' MISCELLANEOUS DATA:Intended Use oEStrucmre:Professional Offices �I G REMOVED (REF, R TO- f ` 1 �c rnoPoxo - --� ,Lz e �'� PARKING STATS: �t i A Ler ) r• • O - _ Acorro w 'I ? 8 b Total Building Area: 4,360 sq ft T 1 - - ' i -0'Iu,^Y i -less exterior porch: 254 sq ft E, REPLACED' W ITh NEW ;i a i i -i u ruAg.... -less exterior wails: 260 sq ft PAVERS FOR TWO !NEW 6'� Ii �t ' Mar�� t j less mcch.rooms: 114 sq Et I ' ON-STREET PARR 1LEL r j'I T$ i'� z-'�'R00� fi i I Net Bldg Arca: 3,732 sq ft/300 sq ft=12.44=12= /� ! O 11 ' ,l'! n'i Y ' CELL. ISM) ovev-r, I b \` 1 STALLS AS - - --- - i i 1 O III RGOUFLO YQ R !1'� -1.1 3 .focal Parktn�Required =.11 Stalls(indd 1 Fig `' - I •'•' - ._ j W 1-_ '- -------------- --'••'16.• • • - - i 24'-O• I Per Salim;4.4.24.G.6 none.rpatr exemption shall be dialled. ',,,-PARKING ` " II 51-iO�NN - I �' I I € LOT9, 1 Off-Street Parking'-_Provided= 8 Stalls(Meld 1 IIC) I I W �i1 v� BLOCK707 $ ate4cr q� t 6 7� On-Sweet Parking Provided= 3 Stalls(per LDR Sec 4.6.9(E)(2) w I h li, 1 / J I p I _GUITtae 3 Total Parking Provided = 11 Stalls O III I -> t 0 I 3 1' j N it ),% jt% j tro5crl , 1 \ z 1 W jo f ii, i > s s in 1 b I a LOT 18, BLOCK 70 i,,...:. 'I ,--..- ' ; t I_ _..= � i�� AM �F=__ //////�� =N ,\ _nsari�n ```````�W ' ••• _ l.\C CO\L\ILIA IS I e, Q 11 14 I ' --- !f , Vas■f. 14 �j i t p • e = . 1! z ! - V �'i ,Li atPpw�.- _ Iii 1 OO C•CWGJ i b l>O 1 I' 1 ° ll asS 1 /r gA� I I '.5.-0•WO 5G7CACf, ,• ),, - 1 , 4,0-0•',, r i _ /, '� j j-1 .N 70'-0.06TACL IXST S6R1GTlRgD 1, I :x r j �' ; / �� it 2i�5/�rcw RCN 4 nk e*r a n+rt i aro5m15rRUGn \ RA �, zl �, - I I _ I. ---- may,7{ -__ _ ...... ....... - (�j it Yt l �, !F t1. 1 i _ BLOCK 70 T -+ + i l P 8 =-- --'-- \ - — �_. LOT 19, BLOCK 70 11_ . !: l it i ARCHITECTURE ti �; ;•1 !I x '.... 1 3 1 IF ,� - .. I I i �v 1 1 ; i w 4NS4 6, p �1 ma .�:M r•,.� M e n Ili n b�D ( ! I weueeo. 4v 1 III vat _r�4-4•ItW 4r.ti QP T?4- I'? o rarx3 b Asrttus LEGEND: ,��'; �t +ttC p _ '': 1 I I if -. ___-__.-__. — _._. ;WD711 V1R�3 ,''a� '. 1 cS C° 1 I (� UNDERGROUND ELECTRICr�'7 i �� r �.� 5=6 A , I 1 o FIBER CRC Car ?� �. ti �. I I . • I AII. U z -, / / / \---- ••---_-„-- - --- .. .-_ .. .. -.. - - - - - - + r� C EXISTING SANITARY SEVER LINE _-' ` N9Q 00 00'E 131E 50' - ??o ' LISTING WATER MAIN UNE G'�'a'b ���' . I j� 'LE � / EXISTING OVERHEAD LINES w".,� .,n ,: I 4 2T-0' 1: o n-o• -1 :::7�° ° . �v i / J WOO Pam u —' WI i i_�Wh1-�_M Y9Id WM �tAl\ l+Q.( ....._•. WM WM W.M VAN HOLE i,, Wi:r.C L'R .�. ,.T., FUR OPTIC VAULT EXISTING SOD OPARKWAY'TO 15E REMOVED 17 030 �n1 _—_._ ___ ! I' ____-_ (REFER TO DEMO SITE PLAN) REPLACED BMW PREVENITER 2018-09-20 ----------- - -___._-----fit -_- _-_._ _ __ __W ITt1 NEW CONCRETE FOR NEW ON STREET p misION TRIANGLE swot. 1 -10-0 SE 2ND STREET PARALLEL EKING STALL A5 5 OV✓N ------ _ - vw,ANcO/ fRREQUESTSn4BOL.- 50' TOTAL R/W £ 'I 8 QUANTITY OP PAWING STALLS SITE PLAN I, _I 24' ASPHALT PAVEMENT 1 —-— CENTER LK OF SIl UI/AUEY \�• DaSTING GRADE ELEVATION — I / \ o \ ° �% PROPOSED GRADE ELEVATION A0. 1/..--,y, ,,-,:-/ y- <,:,/: ,,,, ,, /,,, ,, , ,,.,. ,-. - ii,-, „ ,. ., ...,,,,,.._1cf,- SITE PLAN r -4; 1 ` I 2 I 3 1 4 I o e N PROJECT DATA: 0 0 o a 5, o N PROPOSED TOTAL G-,R.^LLVD FLOOR AREA- .-1,120.00 50.FT. .-265%OF SITE I I / 6-8' / I I 12 PARKINS 4 PAVED AREAS- .-2,911.00 50.FT. .-43.2`.OF SITE I I I ) - OPEN LANDSCAPED SPACE- .-IbB8.00 S0.FT. .-25.0%0-LATE - AL ---------- PZ o DATER BODIES(POOL)- .-359.00 SO FT. . »%OF SITE EXISTING CONCRETE CURB TO REMAIN �-1 w o TWO(2 NEW NATURAL GAS METERS 7 (+-11'OF PAVING 816'fL0.1'!.) H II \ ® EXISTING CONCRETE CURB TO REMAIN w TOTALS .-6,150.00 ea.FT. ID.:`ro OF SITEL EXISTING POWER POL i•' \yI PROPERTY LINE 50.00' GAS I EXISTING POWER POLE TO REMAIN O o • ,_,. X B O (� • 4,(PLACE EXISTING OVERHEAD SERVICE FEED UNDERGROUND) i 3 I.l. • .0 I B'HIG CMU PRIVACY WALL,TYP.G YARD ` < A ./p�/ DATA: a� f LANDSCAPING \VLv 1 f 'A E 0-� PAWING DATA: RyGUIRED PRO ID=D NEVJ 0'HIGH ALUMINUM PRNACY WALL,TYP.AT REAR YARD-7•� ) -"�` L y PA -1- 1 0 £ u o 0 ` 1M/ �� I PAN NG 1 SI G < o U R`I-MULTI FAMILY RESIDENTIAL: THIS AREA SET ASIDE FOR POOL EQUIP!,c"- j 10'POOL SETBACK I I NEW 4'HIGH,BLACK COATED CHAINLINK FENCE TO MATCH EXISTING,TYP. `/>`/I- <c/[<- 111.40(2):;: ::: _.__— PAVING �/ p-: — Y_---TOTALS= /(T (2) ) (TIRO(2)PE'RO'S HC D) t i r �G e G El :G 4' REMAITYP. II I I ALTERNATE AREA FOR POOL EQUIPMENT ` A I I /A/4i ;, I -NEW SWIMMING POOL-UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT . -- - (TYPICAL OF TWO(2)) ' NEV ALUMINUM TRELLIS SYSTEM OVER NANA DOOR OPENING,TYP. L tiQSG1F G -'F--�r///J//I PAVIA I I I ILO EREO RO011 SYSTEM,INTEGRAL GINTER,WHITE FINISH,TYP.) I L ill /1 ____ BUILDI G SETBACK LINE(WHEN MULTIFAMILY) S f TE DATA: (APPROX. 6,'150.00 SQ.FT. OR 0 SS 4TRE I Ft 25 nFF3 QARF- 0 I NEW OUTDOOR SHOWER ZONED Rim (MULTI FAMILY R_SIDEN-IAL) - 11 , /r I // PROPOSED USE: TWO (2)SINGLE F•1 ILY ESIDENCES (NO CHANGE)I )A I• .',.:'-'.-,/,-,.;;,.„� z; a A HO 1 Q; V 1 /� ./ NEW 4'HIGH DIU/S UCCO PRIVACY WALLS EXI ":G 4`HIGH BLACK COATED CMAINLlNX FENCE TO REMAIN,TYP. \ / /� I REFUSE COLLECTION AREA OBSCURED FROM VIEW) c I 1 //',.4. ,'0/'. ,.-ice./� />x.. 2 K \\T 4/4. �//r j I I Iil I FXISTN:G PLYVIOOD CABINET TO BE REMOVED / \ U P Vlt '1,..,,,/`/ /F FTT EXISTING AC CONDENSING UNIT TO BE REPLACED/RELOCATED _ l :,:/,"'-;:. j/_.�'y f///l P (SCRECNED 1'!/LANDSCAPING) j//''�� \\ I %/�/ .',. EXISTING ELECTRIC METERS&PANELS:ONE(I)TO REMAIN&ONE(1)TO BE RELOCATED 1 1e4e I \\I Y // (METERS ONLY TO REMAIN OUTSIDE,NEW PANELS TO BE INTERNAL) w EI5TIT�IG 1 STORE' ; '//r ;;'' � m w a J N I_- I /I k /,S 34 4 =7E - =Ls TWIN TOWNI-1OM S I I 7 1'RI - NEW 8'HIGH DIU/STUCCO PRIVACY WALL I.GATE / /% /'V — I (EXISTING FIN,SUB @+7.40'FIAVD) ) i--- -- "',41,- /�.//� ., .. -- - W, Z _ ///T.//'/r .' EXISTING 4'HIGH CHAINLINK FENCE TO BE REPLACED WITH 4'HIGH BLACK COATED CMAINL.NK FENCE TO MATCH,TYP. Y�/-W>I.E. I NEW 8'HIGH CMU PRIVACY WALL 6 I f�., . it AKA. - W Q H I i f j/; , Q N w W 1 PAVII 16 '/ �% /� .r' L1J m �V EXISTING AC/ANDSCAPI UNIT TO BE REPLACED/RELOCATED 1— ti I ��i///���� ,1r" ( (SCREENED w)uNDsrAPln'G I �� � j /,',;','. EXISTING WASHER/DRYER TO BE RELOCATED TO INSIDE OF UNIT 'I _ GENERAL ERAL GRAD I,(G �OTE p�: 1 I ,,,,,,/ /3S ^'//� 1�' (DEMO/REMOVE WOOD FRAME'SHED'ENCLOSEURE; '-1(y I� GRAD I\ �-'91 jr j// I"-�/�1� REPRESENTS+-35.87 GROSS SQUARE FE I (] j//j / FT.VihIG EXISTING 4'HIGM CHAINUNK FENCE TO BE REPLACED L!/NEW 4'HIGH BLACK COATED CHAIN..'NK FE/:CE TO PIATCH SOUTH PL,TYP. Q 1)UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL THIS PROPERTY BE GRADED 50 THAT STORM WATER I /�/ / / I � RUNS OFF ONTO ANY ADJACENT PROPERTIES /j // /�/� I _ H g �;, //�� per,^ NEW<'HIGH CMU/S UCCO PRIVACY WALLS ., 2)SEE SUFFICIENT PROPOSED FINAL GRADES AND iSSOC1ATED DETAIL INSURING STORM NEW ALUMINUMi S SYSTEM OVER NANF DOOR OPENING,TYP. t° //ir�/ I I'. ni I (REFUSE COLLECTION ARrA OBSCURED FROM VIEW) WATER DOES NOT FLOP!ONTO ADJACENT PROPERTIES. TRELLIS F _ 1 'I // I •3. ® 'o `P (LOU'EaEO R00•ISYSEM,INTEGRAL GUTTER,WHITE FINISH,TYP.) a yr/ / 3.)PLEASE SEE SURVEY FOR EXISTING GRADES S ALL PROPERTY LINES E.ON ALL P t :1 ' j'`/' �� O ADJACENT PROPERTIES.MINIMUM TWO(2)GRADES PER PROPERTY LINE. ! 3'-0• [.' L - ,,J - 4.)PLEASE SEE FLOOR PLANS FOR FINISH FLOOR ELEVATIONS OF ALL STRUCTURES WHICH ARE ALL I 1,6 '<- ( !NG I 0 I G--1 NEV:OUTDOOR SHOWER • PI MINIMUM 38'ABOVE THE CROWN OF THE ADJACENT STREETS OR ROADWAYS. 1 ` NEW C fU/STUCCO PRIVACY WALL;HEIGHT TO MATCH WINDOW HEAD U 5.)PLEASE SEE SITE PLAN AND OXTAILS FOR MINIMUM 3'DEEP SODDED SL'lALE BT'/FERN SITE'S ' j//��.� a , Fy N c PROPERTY UNE AND ALL ADJACENT STREETS OR ROADWAYS. ' A NEE SWIMMING POOL-UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT T, y, EXISTI rG 4'HIGH BLACK COATED CHAINLINK FENCE TO REMAIN,TYP. CI I O WI PAVING (TYPICALr' - j Jam OF TWO(2)) El _ PAVING • I Z p'F��'�� /vet LEGEND: ALTERNATE AREA FOR POOL EQUIPMENT ( 'Ll SYMBOLS1 1BOLS �(, }..ND• —.—.—_—_—____—_—______.____—_____�__. .—.--. —.—mot—F OTT YARD BUILDING SETBACK LINE v L'< - _25' µII NEW GNU/STRCCO PRIVACY WALL DROPS TO 4'MAX.WITHIN FRONT YARD,TIP. 4 .� 3 I 2:7-IT 1 W Q„ V ,5 .(� fiI ^ I i I—FC i - p V j V • 'HIGH CMU/STUCCO WALL • V` I—i N y.�3' EXISTING TOPOGRAPHY(GRADE)TO REMAIN-SEE SURVEY I in - q PAIg62K lA_Oscs aN:^ _ 1 /Z, LL _ xNB. PROPOSED NEW TOPOGRAPHY(FINISH GRADE) THIS AREA NEW PAVEMENT TO MATCH EXISTING/ADJACEN'T CONDITIONS _� F II I ( 1 0 7V E D ETE CURBI , U Z= I EXISTING CITY WATER METER TO REMAIN n'() [ I (f—�I I I�I �Q .� t 9 .•--4, I) - THIS AREA NEW PAVEMENT TO MATCH EXISTING/ADJACENT CONDITIONS a A L) u _ 1 .1 I n UI I Q THIS AREA 15 EXISTING ASPHALT PAVING TO REMAIN,TIP.U.N.O. PI- _ i gym, i � � ,� I�'I I o I 'i,�,, I ��'• CL. I T r -1 T -1 I 0 5 _ L - }!� -r- C < 1-- aROPERTY UN y 50.00' i UW OS.APING I LA+05CAPING p PAINT PARKING STALLS AS PER STANDARD CITY OF EXISTING CITY FIRE HYDRANT TO REMAIN / I DELR(.Y BEACH STANDAR S(CURB IS\Y 1EELSTOP) J f TRUE I p 1I \ P — EXISTING CITYWATER VALVE TO REMAIN S I� TRUE /// I P. \\ Q I I I �y // i I NORTI-I - - - - - - - - —° - - - - - - - E �it- i A4 E PROPOSED PROJECT CHART: 4 (+-12'OF PAVING 40.R.O.W.) tss 5'-O' d'-®' 9'-O' 9'-0' 9'-O' 9'-0' S'-0' RH MUD.LOT MIN. MIN. MIN. MIN. MAX. MIN. MIN. MIN. MIN. MAX. PERVIOUS IRPERV1 JS AWMU:UM ALUMINUM ALUF[ILUM UN / LOT. IDTH LOT FLOOR LOT OPEN LOT FRONT SIDE SIDE AE TO BUILDING AR. ARIA TRE'J15 TRELLIS TRELLIS (R) DEPTH AREA FRONTAGE SPATE CDYCPAGL STBAIX INTEliIOR STREET SETBACK HEIGHT (p.RJ (s4.R) SETBACK SETBACK SETBACK JM b (sq.R.) (R.) (sq.R) (RJ (k) IRA (R) (R&WIX 10.1SMACK (R) (R) (tier.sde) (front yard) (roar yard) LDR lDR 111fi (R) (N.) (R) (IL) o V 8 / REQUIRED 8,000 60 300 3,000 60 <0 NA 25/30 115/30 !L: 125 135 2,]00 <,05, , 0 15 25 10 Drawn O O O �\ I� (//(\\ RW CO E 0 l T (1 PROVIDED 6,]50 SD 135 1,]50 50 25 40.5 15/]0 NA 127.1 21.25 166] 506 15.1 40.5 27.5 pro ect No. ---1 I I N:. 8 I EXISTING 5'PUILIC SIDEWALK TO REMAr— EXISTING 6,750 50 135 1,660 50 60 40.5 10.1 P NORTH NA 27.1 123.25 4,460 2,27 NA I NA NA 2017,(J2PATTONCOPE 3 Ie No. O ]s Q SOUTH ITEPLAN tw 6'HIGH Gar Date — 1 ��.^�+Wr/'�� �J,(�I SITE /•'f'1 r� 12' 12' SEPTEMBER 24,2018 - y 1 y'\C1-LIT CT�(�!—{(C SIT P� I� DRIVE ADJACENT PROPERTY DRIVES SHOWN FOR CLARITY— DRIVE y '�'RI ADJACENT PROPERTY PARKING SHOWN FORCLARITY Drawing No. ARA� I Fr I.eU^'-O' 2 G © COPE ARCHITECTS,INC., 2018 I 1 I 2 I 3 I 4 I 5 I 6 I 7 I 8 I 9 I 10 I 11 I 12 I 13 I 14 I - 1 7 I A3.1 A4.1 1 M CV om %li • N .715 C,_o, / g o N N o f o M °u a a <‹z- — --L - _ _ �___�_ o-I o = \ EAST UNIT FLOOR AREA: GRAND TOTAL FLOOR AREA: L NEl'f AWMINUM TRELLIS SYSTEM:INCWDES ONE(1)4'Xa'ALUMINUM(OFFSET) C €=- E EXISTNIG !BLDG. DATA. L B --- =- O Q' pp _ LIVING AREA(UNDER AIR): +-830SQ.FT. LIVING AREA(UNDER AlR): +-1,6605Q.FT. 9 y COLUh:ry CENTERED ON COLUMNS OF TH=EXISTING tDG.,TYP.BOTH UNITS T__= _ EGRESS lINDOW GARAGE(NOT UNDER AIR): +-0 SQ.FT. COVERED AREA: +-0 SQ.FT. Tp (SYSTEM TO BE PAINTED WHITE TO MATCH THE BUILDING,1ST) --- �" _ COVERED AREA(REAR PORCH): +-0 SQ.FT. --'--- =Q - --� •� GRAND FLR.TOTAL AREA: +-1,660 SQ.FT. - -_ -- �•1 WIDEN EXISTING V(INF WINDOW BY SAW CUTTING EXISTING FLR.TOTAL AREA: +-830 SQ.FT.=-==-3F = _= 3 II I EACH END EQUALLY(INFILL TO RAISE SILL) O WEST UNIT FLOOR AREA: tO! N V. \ C 52 — MASTER LIVINGGARAGE AREA(UNDER LU AIR): +-830 SQ.FT. K _ ate•'•Dp^/ I GARAGE(NOT UNDER AIR): r-0 SQ.FT. _o BEDROOM V3 I COVERED AREA(REAR PORCH): -:-0 SQ.FT. ;1 -A6 Pr�iytL-s, = I EXISTING FLR.TOTAL AREA: +-630 SQ.FT. U me FAMILY•'L� .---,1 11 - WIDEN ENDEXISTINGEQUALLY WINDOW BY SAW CUTTING �a I ) I,-'Al ^) QU LLY(INFILL TO RAISE SILL) O i I_ - 1f PROPOSED !BLDG. DATA: _ �I �� �_=Ta-' �__- I ) EAST UNIT FLOOR AREA: GRAND TOTAL FLOOR AREA: (W(J Z I1 I /1 LIVING AREA(UNDER AIR)' +-895 SQ.FT. LIVING AREA(UNDER AIR): + 1,790 5Q.FT. I— `�T M � /� GARAGE NOT UNDER AIR +0 5 FT. COVERED AREA: 07 Q I 4 1  0 b%`• - �-t-EXISTING WOOD CABINET TO BE REMOVED I ( )' Q +-0 5Q.FT l y W M A T- — -- — --_ COVERED AREA(REAR PORCiI). GRAND FIR.TOTAL AREA. + 1,790 SQ.FT. M a AS —� n- J PROPOSD FLR.TOTAL AREA: + 895 SQ FT. �.L T a a a a CO/ WEST UNIT FLOOR AREA: Mr- _HL >o O - L�i�• ,5 ___ LIVING AREA(UNDER AIR): +-695 SQ.FT. ! ig O O )"I 011 ! r`! e ISTING AC CONDENSING UNIT TO BE RELOCATED GARAGE NOT UNDER AIR +-O SQ.FT. �0 J I �• - -1 •N f �r 4'11' COVERED AREA(REAR PORCH): 0 SQ FT. U- y e eI i A' -1 /1((p'I 6A f i= ,��' fi PROPOSED FLR.TOTAL AREA: +-695SQ.FT. ( - A9 EXi$TCG 2X.,LOAD BEt,'t„'�L'-WOOD 5 PART ION TO I�l1:N(.vD ONE(U LATER 5/8'CRTI:'.::L TO Es.yn ODE I --4.- LI I i I Fj...__ -EXISTING ELECTRICAL PANEL/MUER TO BE RELOCATED < LO a LU j LLl I Il m O LIVING �jg �'9�' r a = EXISTING ELECTRICAL PAN'EUMETER TO BE RELOCATED A8 ICJ 4 20 Ca.STEEL 5TOD a 16'OL.PART ITOR l"G:E(U LATER CF 5/e'CRT-CALL EA:H SIDE ROOM [] ,' _ �F �- 1`�W VI 1 33 �'C O t EX15TItrG NON-IMPACT GARDEN IYINDOIY TO 6E REPLAG:p <1.11 < n- - �' I �I O a I +- kP` I (G`NTER NEVr YfINCO1V ON SIf:X,INFILL W/C+.U) ; A7 0 / A6.0 Q o v Al NEW e'OM L":W!V'2'k2'P.T.DD.F:RR'\:a b'QG t GN=(U LATER C 5/b'CRTL'IALL EL:H S:Dc _ 1 ` I a �.b NELI B'all WALLLWYM'PT.ED.ft:�PY a Ib' L.4 ONE(I)LATER OF 5/6'CRTLLI:LL(Cx�a£EN BOARD IN LET A�ASJ. -'4' L� I A8 I 'o " 1/2'RIGID HALATION BOARD BET0B?1 P056I'NG D. Q __,, IXISI G 6'CYd WALL W 2'JO'u.RIRR.JL-a 16'p TO RS 1AfN 4 ON=(U NEC'LATER CT 5/5'DRTC:4LL ONE SIDE 4 (I t---T 1 PI 1 - tell 2'JO'P.T.CA.P11562G o la'O;./ONE(U NE LATER OF 5/8'DRTLA-L ON OTOLlITE BIDE A '',I �- U F) — - = E4. R I EXISTING FIRE WALL TO REMAIN ;e 5t L. I Ip' !,,jrI,.. a igall1 m 11 I4111- 1 II1 I I"IW Z M " ` h REMOVE EXISTING DOOR B.INFILL TO MATCH EXISIM ' I--1 CONDITIONS 8 ENIN GROUT SOLID '9 WTI F - A4 $A'JC,T/RSP:OVE EwSTeG at(".ALL FROM TOP CF b,e,'DOOR Daw TO Fi isH FLOOR % , I - ( ) a WALL LEGEND: D o Q i '/Q. �-f-—- FILL 1'fIt:DO'iJ OPENiING YJ/CMU TO HATCH (n Z m u " - / FGGsnNG amACENr coNpmoNs fff w to - __ I : EXISTING CHILI WAIL TO REMAIN Q Q --:A3 $A"..C;JT 4(cl1OY6 IXISTeG OM WALL Kai "SILL D011 TO Fw'\i$H FLOOR(Iw1vSTRY:(ILEAL) _ W O u - J R )iF T� NEW CMU WALL IT o i '.-A22 NEW ItoILL(CI-EIc b'-8'TALL DOOR IS W1015 )TO MATCH WALL TYPE"Al n FJ r ID LL _ Illttt�����!ll���fffl�� I-1 .0 5 NEW STEEL STUD INTERIOR NON-LOAD BEARING PARTITION EXI$TIX's,Na:-LOAD DAARXST FILL HEICsH'7$'CT.1 Dr77162 PARTITION(12/rlll' - -( 3 EXISTING 2X4 HOOD LOAD BEARING PARTITION TO REMAIN Z ._. Al,- ih7'-hOR PLASTER TO I�17A5`I),Ei.R L.S"E�. y1H I Vl'$T3 sTL'D$c Ib•o;. (T_,�I I t_,, 1 y •, U a i'' II W SQ.V ATic3'WT4�s R'G•:D P:x:LATIa:AA¢>�-TL'ES;$TIaS,TFc�:TWO(21 p�� r.! '0 O RC-- , -r _ FILL WINDOW OPENING W/CMU TO BATCH ����/�����/�flfA NEW INTERIOR PARTITION W/SOUND ATTENUATING INSULATION V. E LA1 525 5/6'TYPE•X•DRYWALL E:.CH$'.:_-RILL FcGFiT LIvIIK:c L' EXISTING ADJACENT CONDmONS Q W T .... A,.. EXI576 8'OM WALL W/270'WV.fl RP./N-s a 16'CC TO R MAN t 01,E(U N ')LATER OF 5/8'DRTWALL ROOM __ ____ - RELOCATE EXISTING ELEC.PANEL 66 E I 0 A a 0 1 a'RG:D wx ATIa BOARD L EN azR Gt m SA1'1CU NEW WINDOW OPENING,ADD FILLED CELLS SYMBOLS LEGEND: O�' El- WALL TYPES No scA`e1.0e. As i L,4 ,,C = {I,', .,,,i,\ - ISIIN'G AC CONDENSING UNIT TO 8E RELOCATED A WINDOW TYPE,SEE SCHEDULE ' I - M£w,p,,1 e WINDOW PRESSURES(P.S.F.) D _ I 1,�'- FILL WINDOW OPENING W/CMU TO MATCH O DOOR TYPE,SEE SCHEDULE �•0 r[1 -Y` �0 '(' EXISTING ADJACENT CONDITIONS \ - / Q... Q: a filth , DOOR PRESSURES(P.S.F.) aa IIj. r I I -'11 L__� (i 1 F J i3 6Y!/17: u — Y � ® _` 1 I I ®r --61I �'M SYMBOLS LEGEND: FT 8I77 1/ �I I / ---_ 11 r_--rLr REMOVE !STING WOOD STRUCTURE;LAUNDRY ROOM 1 1 I (CAP UTI �r �) O -„ _fir___ T 1_ __' J __ 11 NEW INTERIOR DOOR TYPE,SEE SCHEDULE filtosl Zi r, 1 FAMILY ' MASTER �s vsp 5 1 1 , I I- I ii, I I _ 'uWIDEN EXISTINGWINDOW V CUTTING'%b I Lq-• EACH END SQUALY(INFILL TO RAISE SILL) A2 ARCHITECTURAL FLOOR ���� 2 IL T � rl Al4 a(_e• =c- � I � _ �' rt? � I z 0 Q DrowDa "� �, 4; BEDROOM — I 5 RW COPE 1.B a E=a===-3'� =- J - A Project No. _ WIDEN EXISTING WINDOW BY SAW CUTTING 2017.82PATTONCOPE 3 0 NEW ALUMINUM TRELLIS SYSTEM:INCLUDES ONE(1)a•Xa'AL M1NUM(OFFSET) I _ O m I� EACH END EQUALLY(INFILL TO RAISE SILL) CAD File No. = 6 COLUMN CENTERED ON COLUMNS OF THE EXISTING BUG.,lYP BOTH UNITS '• - EGRES IYINDOW 1 4� I PROPOSED FLR.PLAN ra (SYSTEM TO BE PAINTED WHITE TO MATCH THE BUILDING,TYP. ___ _ Q.1�� Dote �'N\ T - ,=_„ �-I 1 ■ ..„„„,„.1.,.,,, SEPTEMBER 24,2018 Li n O S s` Drawing No. I aQ'-IO' ��--/ A - A :1; or ..fs' J7 ry. /+.. 9 O o ® A f 6'-a' 1( I-D-B' .! A4 '� 4 A4.0 © COPE ARCHITECTS, INC.,2018 i 1 2 Ial AC v.. - -nST,Cr[CAL .ter.,, 3 I 4 I 5 I 6 I I 7 I I 9 I 10 I 1 1 I 12 I 13 I r..�.,a•�r,a.4,,.t of 14 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: November 7, 2018 ITEM: 201 NE 5`h Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District — Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-209) for the renovation of the existing structure, construction of a new 555 sq. ft. addition and new garage and guest house to the existing non-contributing structure. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness GENERAL DATA: l t . , Owner/Applicant Rochelle Greenberg I (.‘ Q► ,_...r" :s4. 4 Agent. Enterprise Contractors, Inc. co.0* .4 i Nt bill St um a r'• �% Location Northeast corner of NE 2nd Avenue y, s r" 1Y "l= T'T and NE 5`n Court a 41f Irt Property Size. 0.30 Acres Historic District: Del-Ida Park Historic District `" ,�, f4L. ^ t►; '4,rf Zoning' RL (Multiple Family Residential .�< -. �� i - 'R' Low Density) ?' e . • I,, o O+` 4 '„Y:• - 3i`` 11 Adjacent Zoning' ' ,t), North: RL East: RL • is. ; >ier;. . • Sit CAI South: RL .. _ = West. R-1-AA '.,.t > 4, ; > ; 1 c Existing Future Land l '11C , ' �� r - Use Designation LD (Low Density Residential) F 5th S t ,r�,,.., -.mid, NE 5th St A' = t , r Water Service Public water service is provided ; • p 1 � on site. - A + _ -' ;;f a rr, tir.l S� t ' .r Sewer Service. Public sewer service is provided • ----.: .;' ' ` 6:' on site. 6,NF 4th St Ap _ -el r, '-'irfl'i — A '' --__.;-. NORTH _1 r-" 1 �. 4 ..lie i ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness(COA) associated with alterations and additions to the non-contributing structure located at 201 NE 5th Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property is located at the northeast corner of NE 2' Avenue and NE 5th Court within the Del- Ida Park Historic District. The property contains a 1969 single-family residential structure built in the Masonry Vernacular architectural style. The 1-story 1,522 square foot single-family residence exists on the 0.30 acre property which is zoned Multiple Family Residential - Low Density (RL) and is a non- contributing structure within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The subject request is a COA for alterations to the existing single-family residence to include: • Construction of 555 sq. ft. addition on the north side of the structure • Construction of a new 808 sq. ft. detached garage and guest house structure on the north side of the property; • Construction of a new pergola/breezeway; • Installation of new impact resistant, aluminum framed, windows and fiberglass doors; • Installation of new white, standing-seam metal roof; • Painting the structure pale yellow "Lemon Souffle" with white "Palm Coast Pale" trim; and, • Installation of new ribbon strips and driveway. The proposed 555 sq.ft.addition consists of a master bedroom suite, kitchen and family room and interior renovations are proposed to include reconfiguration of the existing bedrooms and bathroom to accommodate the new addition. Landscape installation will be reviewed by the Senior Landscape Planner in conjunction with the building permit. ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant.to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ZONING AND USE REVIEW Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.5(F) - Low Density Residential (RL) Development Standards: the provisions for R-1-A shall apply for the single-family detached dwellings. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.3.4(K) - Development Standards: properties located within the R-1-A zoning district shall be developed according to the requirements noted in the chart below. The proposal is in compliance with the applicable requirements; therefore, positive findings are made. Development Standards j Required Existing Proposed Open Space (Minimum, Non-Vehicular) 25% ! 82% ! 56% Setbacks (Minimum): Front(West) 25' 38.5' 32.84' Side Interior(North) 7.5' 1 62' 7.6' Side Street(South) 15' 20' 20' Rear(South) 10' 10.1' 17.4' Height(Maximum) 35' 13.45' 15.6' 201 NE 5th Court;COA 2018-209 HPB Meeting of November 7,2018 Page 2 of 5 SUPPLEMENTAL DISTRICT REGULATIONS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.9(C)(2) - Parking Requirements for Residential Uses: two spaces per dwelling unit. Tandem parking may be used provided that in the Single Family(R-1 District) or RL District, no required parking space may be located in a required front or street side setback. Positive findings are made as the proposal includes a new 1-space garage and there is sufficient parking outside of the required front and side street setback within the new driveway on the east side of the structure; therefore, required parking is provided for outside of the front or side street setback areas. LDR SECTION 4.5.1 HISTORIC PRESERVATION: DESIGNATED DISTRICTS, SITES, AND BUILDINGS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Standard 2 The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. Standard 9 New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. • Standard 10 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. The proposed changes to the existing non-contributing structure will eliminate the future possibility of the structure being reclassified or considered for listing as a contributing structure to the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property owner, agent and architect have been advised of such. Conversely, the proposed 1-story additions and improvements to the property are visually compatible and in direct relationship with the low-scale of surrounding historic properties along NE 2nd Avenue and in the district. The existing 1-story non-contributing structure is situated on the southern portion of a large corner-lot property and the 1-story addition and garage/guest house structure are proposed on the interior side/rear of the existing residence. They are not placed forward of the plane of existing structure, such design protects the historic integrity of the historic district and surrounding area. The proposed modifications add appropriate visual interest the Masonry Vernacular structure and to the adjacent streetscapes. The new addition and garage/guest house structure have been designed such that should they be removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic structure and its environment would not be impacted. Further, the proposed architectural features will protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. The proposal is compliant with these standards contingent on the conditions of approval. Based on the above, positive findings can be made with respect to compliance with the Standards. 201 NE 5th Court;COA 2018-209 HPB Meeting of November 7,2018 Page 3 of 5 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(2)(c)(4) - Minor Development. The subject application is considered "Minor Development" as it involves "alteration of less than 25 percent of the existing floor area of the building and all appurtenances." Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1)(c) - Fences and walls: Fences and walls over four feet shall not be allowed in front or side street setbacks. The proposed aluminum rail fence and CMU pilaster/stucco posts which surround the structure on the west and north sides are within the front and side street setbacks and meet this requirement as they are proposed at 3'6" tall. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8) - Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings,structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m) below. Visual compatibility for all development on individually designated properties outside the district shall be determined by comparison to other structures within the site. The following criteria apply: (a) Height: The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible in comparison or relation to the height of existing structures and buildings in a historic district for all major and minor development. For major development, visual compatibility with respect to the height of residential structures, as defined by 4.5.1(E)(2)(a), shall also be determined through application of the Building Height Plane. (b)Front Facade Proportion: The front facade of each building or structure shall be visually compatible with and be in direct relationship to the width of the building and to the height of the front elevation of other existing structures and buildings within the subject historic district. (c) Proportion of Openings (Windows and Doors): The openings of any building within a historic district shall be visually compatible with the openings exemplified by prevailing historic architectural styles of similar buildings within the district. The relationship of the width of windows and doors to the height of windows and doors among buildings shall be visually compatible within the subject historic district. (d) Rhythm of Solids to Voids: The relationship of solids to voids of a building or structure shall be visually compatible with existing historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district for all development, with particular attention paid to the front facades. (e) Rhythm of Buildings on Streets: The relationship of buildings to open space between them and adjoining buildings shall be visually compatible with the relationship between existing historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district. (f) Rhythm of Entrance and/or Porch Projections: The relationship of entrances and porch projections to the sidewalks of a building shall be visually compatible with existing architectural styles of entrances and porch projections on existing historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district for all development. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. (h) Roof Shapes: The roof shape, including type and slope, of a building or structure shall be visually compatible with the roof shape of existing historic buildings or structures within 201 NE 5th Court;COA 2018-209 HPB Meeting of November 7,2018 Page 4 of 5 the subject historic district. The roof shape shall be consistent with the architectural style of the building. (i) Walls of Continuity: Walls, fences, evergreen landscape masses, or building facades, shall form cohesive walls of enclosure along a street to ensure visual compatibility with historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district and the structure to which it is visually related. (j) Scale of a Building: The size of a building and the building mass in relation to open spaces, windows, door openings, balconies, porches, and lot size shall be visually compatible with the building size and mass of historic buildings and structures within a historic district for all development. To determine whether the scale of a building is appropriate, the following shall apply for major development only: 1. For buildings wider than sixty percent(60%) of the lot width, a portion of the front facade must be setback a minimum of seven (7) additional feet from the front setback line: 2. For buildings deeper than fifty percent (50%) of the lot depth, a portion of each side facade, which is greater than one story high, must be setback a minimum of five (5) additional feet from the side setback line: (k) Directional Expression of Front Elevation: A building shall be visually compatible with the buildings, structures, and sites within a historic district for all development with regard to its directional character, whether vertical or horizontal. (I) Architectural Style: All major and minor development shall consist of only one (1) architectural style per structure or property and not introduce elements definitive of another style. (m) Additions to individually designated properties and contributing structures in all historic districts: Visual compatibility shall be accomplished as follows: 1. Additions shall be located to the rear or least public side of•a building and be as inconspicuous as possible. 2. Additions onaccessory structures shall not be located in front of the established front wall plane of a historic building. 3. Characteristic features of the original building shall not be destroyed or obscured. 4. Additions shall be designed and constructed so that the basic form and character of the historic building will remain intact if the addition is ever removed. 5. Additions shall not introduce a new architectural style, mimic too closely the style of the existing building nor replicate the original design, but shall be coherent in design with the existing building. 6. Additions shall be secondary and subordinate to the main mass of the historic building and shall not overwhelm the original building. In consideration of the Visual Compatibility Standards, the proposed addition and new garage/guest house structure are generally appropriate and compatible with the existing non-contributing structure. The architectural style of the existing structure is Masonry Vernacular but includes elements from the Mid-Century time period such as the shed-style roof in the rear of the structure where an addition exists and the small 1-over-1 windows placed high on the wall of the south and west elevations, these windows emulate the profile of an awning style window. New windows with dimensional muntins are proposed for use on the existing structure, addition and new garage/guest cottage. The existing smooth stucco finish will be retained and the new garage/guest room structure will have the same smooth stucco finish. The entire home will be painted pastel yellow"Lemon Soufflé"with white "Palm Coast Pale"trim and accents. A small open air porch exists on the west elevation (front) of the existing structure and a new front porch is proposed to wrap the building to the north elevation along with the new pergola/breezeway connecting the residence to the garage/guest house, adding visual interest and detailing to the structure. The new porch includes PVC over steel columns with aluminum railings. This is the only location where PVC is proposed and PVC is not a historic material nor is it authentic to the Del-Ida Park Historic District. Given that the property is situated on the east side of NE 2nd Avenue, is a high visibility/traffic area within the middle of the Del-Ida Park Historic District, the PVC columns shall be switched to mental such as 201 NE 5th Court;COA 2018-209 HPB Meeting of November 7,2018 Page 5 of 5 aluminum. This item is attached as a condition of approval. Otherwise, the proposed materials used are compatible with historic buildings and structures within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The proposal includes removal of the existing shingle roof which has an offset peak to install a new roof with a peak that is centered on the west elevation. The new roof is slightly taller than the existing 13'6" peak measurement as the height to the new peak is 15'7". The existing 3:12 roof slope will be maintained. The existing/original roofing material is asphalt shingle,which is most appropriate for use with the existing structure. The proposal includes the installation of a new white standing seam metal roof. Installation of the metal roof does not compromise the historic integrity of the structure, its use is reversible and the life span of a metal roof will exceed that of a flat asphalt shingle roof; however, the most compatible material for use with the structure is a shingle roof, an option would be to utilize dimensional shingles. If a metal roof is to be utilized a mill finish would be more appropriate and compatible with the surrounding historic district. It is noted that the proposed changes to the existing structure will eliminate the future possibility of the structure being reclassified or considered for listing as a contributing structure to the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property owner, agent and architect have been advised of such. Conversely, the proposed 1-story additions and improvements to the property are visually compatible and in direct relationship with the scale of surrounding historic properties in the district. The existing structure is situated on the southern portion of the large corner-lot property and the additions are situated to the north side (interior) of the property, which is the most inconspicuous side. The additions to the structure are visually compatible and do not overwhelm the original structure. The overall design maintains vernacular architectural details appropriate for the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The proposal meets the intent of the review criteria above as a generally appropriate addition and new construction; thus, positive findings can be made with respect to the sections indicated above, subject to consideration of the conditions of approval. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-209) for 201 NE 5th Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-209) for 201 NE 5th Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2018-209) for 201 NE 5th Court, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5), subject to the following conditions: �1, ki 1. That the proposed porch columns are metal rather than PVC �1r It---- Attachments: ■ Survey, Site Plan, Floor Plans and Elevations Report Prepared By: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner Rochelle Greenberg Residence Addition 201 NE 5th Court Delray Beach, FL 33444 Visual Compatibility Statement I Visual Compatibility Statement October 14, 2018 The following statement is based on the requirements in Section 4.5.1(E) of the Ordinance 30-08 09/16/08 and Amended Ordinance 38-07 2/5/08. The prescriptive ordinance states that, "New construction and all improvements to both contributing and non-contributing buildings,structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individual designated property shall be visually compatible."The considerations regard height, width, mass, scale,façade,openings, rhythm,material, color,texture, roof shape,direction and other criteria forth in Section 4.5.1.This residence is categorized as a non-contributing structure. Height "The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible." This is a single-story residence with a 3:12 roof slope and a ridge height of approximately 13'-6"above surrounding grade,while the proposed ridge height increases to approximately 15'-7" above surrounding grade.The same 3:12 roof slope is retained for a low-profile structure which complies with the Building Height Plane of 2:1 Ratio. Front facade Proportion "The front façade of each building or structure shall be visually compatible with and be in direct relationship with the width of the building and to the height of front elevations of other existing structures and buildings within the subject historic district." The front façade reflects the proportions of the surrounding existing structures as it maintains a large portion of the existing residence and a low-profile roof supported on simply articulated columns of a front porch. Proportion of Openings • "The openings of any building within the historic district shall be visually compatible with the openings exemplified by prevailing historic architectural styles of similar buildings within the district." The existing windows are being maintain on the street sides of the residence.The addition will have similar single hung windows with grids similar to the existing windows.A French door with panel grids is proposed on the Crafts Room of the garage addition.A number of the existing impact windows are being re-utilized on the garage addition on walls facing existing wood fences on adjacent properties. Rhythm of Solids to Voids "The relationship of solid to voids of a building or structure shall be visually compatible with the existing historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district for all development,with particular attention paid to the front façades" Page 2 Rochelle Greenberg Residence Addition The facades facing NE 2'Avenue and NE 5th Court retain the original facades except for the change out of windows in the small gallery room facing NE 5th Court. New windows facing NE 2'Avenue in the dining/kitchen space and the existing utility room follow the proportions and appearance of other existing single hung windows. In achieving the desire of the Owner for a large front porch facing NE 2nd Avenue, a series of simple columns with brackets provide architectural elements that may be considered as rhythmic or repetitive elements set against a shadowed porch area where window openings are forward and set back in the passing view of the home. Relationship of Materials,Texture and Color "The relationship of materials,texture,and color of the facade of a building and/or landscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the historic district." The existing residence is, in the majority, a stucco-on-block structure painted a flat brown with white and cream trim. It is darker than other more pastel exterior colors. It is the Owner's wish to maintain the white and cream trim finishes and introduce a lighter exterior stucco finish.The stucco finish of the addition and the new garage will be consistent with the existing finish which is a smooth sand finish. Roof Shapes "The roof shape, including type and slope,of a building or structure shall be visually compatible with the roof shape of existing historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district.The roof shape shall be consistent with the architectural style of the building." The existing roof is a gable roof with additions through the years with one area nearly flat.The proposed addition maintains the gable roof with the same slope for a low-profile roof.The flat roof and portions th°3 /0;--/s// (4,4-4-6/: /q6CE Pki7Cric-- (LEic fiL4/-7/ Ssca.4_4(__ - ,..eacxt ki/-7 ___ //„ �ccSJi9-u lJr li � C aryLmtgei_fF k.) /S L.JW c.�c_r u d�.�e,,C ,/? ?. EA_ C42i k 4 2/ U.-f-emu- t' yl.(-/ci & - 7cu,,.23 /t/j/(Y-7( J / 3 / Jrac L 6'1° AMEMM i - ._d Cc& •, t /n mac. c� /9- 0/ /4-41.1j,kcc4_,E 4 cc cc.. E cA--ii /11 '1 - y //cAE-//i- `4) /4 ( tj_ /701 16aki 46 () €__ 0r/6-IL 0 /9-,5 / �o / /de o 6)4- _EY--e- 4,)E_ toj le `17b, ( d i v Ha-a-cs 8c)ld- 03D 40-7P-it C.L.C-14 zee Li /CceLjilt ci a 1' r 0dp atuid ctiLc.. au/itici-eit_14 - Ana ?cuil - c(z_oc_c( L_ — 7to rc� k /v 6 SC 74 „A ,NE_ cf-ipy )L-6_ (4-7Lb cui /0c.„_/ 9- 00 6 /90-idic ( u( - noJ'Ai 6-7( / ICY LIZ 16 ybo 5 a730 3,,,A.L 4/0' 0 ./7-- 64o ' biLteic,h1 4701/ca.4."-- -1-ctitde A. ?!..a .g-�jnKu�e-d . T ,(-ou PP P,wcw-----cci i u� 0"4" 12- 1 c Co-ww.e4t_r - nun �rr� - %�n ; to/LD _ , _ -- Q�. Ci3 - , 9 ✓ c ) /a () ?„.0 o_m_ 1- , t•cflc rk_g_icica cL - hp — / a _ _ S ✓0 - i-/A7 - W)culcday 613f ?Ics cc;..))aSA(5-70 Lc3 c- ^ " / d - i .�-- 6ce-to /L-- ,VS C4-)/ AO II is !I Shca3 he fro 0/d S vC' / S c as U14 �mac✓ 64 cu. AGENDA v = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD €4, 3%P 44yMeeting Date: December 5, 2018 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC V. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.) Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VI. ACTION ITEMS A. Rules and Regulations of the Historic Preservation Board Review of the Rules and Regulations of the Historic Preservation Board; a recommendation will be made to the City Commission on their re-adoption. B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-014): Consideration of installation of a fabric awning on the existing historic structure Address: 531 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Rebecca Luttbeg; becky.luttbeg@gmail.com Agent: Donald Day, Delray Awning; don@delrayawning.com C. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-030): Consideration of construction of new two car garage. Address: 101 NE 5t' Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Virginia Ritter and John Kolkemeyer, driguana@earthlink.net D. Ad Valorem Tax Exemption (2019-006): Provide a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic Property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure. Address: 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District Owner: Dan & Donnamarie Sloan; dsloan@sloandesign.biz VII. LEGISLATIVE ITEMS — CITY INITIATED A. Ordinance 03-19, Review of Designated Historic Districts and Properties within the Beach Property Owners Association Overlay Districts (2018-213): Provide a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Board regarding Ordinance No. 03-19, a City-initiated request to amend Land Development Regulations to specify that the regulations and guidelines of the Beach Property Owners Design Manual are not applicable to those properties located within a designated historic district or which are individually listed on the City of Delray Beach Local Register of Historic Places. Planner: Amy Alvarez, Senior Planner; alvarez@mydelraybeach.com Historic Preservation Board Meeting Agenda: December 5, 2018 Page 2 of 2 VIII. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Concept Plan Review — (2019-049) Address: 1120 Nassau Street, Nassau Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Charles Luciano Agent: Roger Cope, AIA; copearachitectsinc@gmail.com Discussion regarding the demolition of the existing contributing single-family home and construction of a new non-contributing structure located at 1120 Nassau Street. Note: This review is non-binding and no action shall be taken by the Board nor shall there be any written report resulting from discussions at the meeting which may be construed to be preliminary approval of the development concept. IX. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Staff ❖ Board Members X. ADJOURN .}(1jACIL116 "- Michelle Hoyland, incipal Planner; HPB Board Liaison Posted on: November 27, 2018 The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program,or activity conducted by the City.Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. 0„. AGENDA = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD �40`�►,,,. esP *REVISED AGENDA* Meeting Date: December 5, 2018 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC V. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.)Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VI. ACTION ITEMS A. Rules and Regulations of the Historic Preservation Board Review of the Rules and Regulations of the Historic Preservation Board; a recommendation will be made to the City Commission on their re-adoption. B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-014): Consideration of installation of a fabric awning on the existing historic structure Address: 531 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Rebecca Luttbeg; becky.luttbeg@gmail.com Agent: Donald Day, Delray Awning; don@delrayawning.com C. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-030): Consideration of construction of new two car garage. Address: 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Virginia Ritter and John Kolkemeyer, driguana@earthlink.net D. Ad Valorem Tax Exemption (2019-006): Provide a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic Property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure. Address: 106 SE 7tn Avenue, Marina Historic District Owner: Dan & Donnamarie Sloan; dsloan@sloandesign.biz E. Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022): Consideration of an elevation change and change in proposed use from a medical office to a mixed-use building (medical office and residence) to a non- contributing structure. Address: 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: S&E Holdings, Inc., steven@stevenhacker.com Agent: Gary Eliopoulos, AIA; gary@gearch.com Historic Preservation Board Meeting Agenda: December 5, 2018 Page 2 of 2 VII. LEGISLATIVE ITEMS—CITY INITIATED A. Ordinance 03-19, Review of Designated Historic Districts and Properties within the Beach Property Owners Association Overlay Districts (2018-213): Provide a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Board regarding Ordinance No. 03-19, a City-initiated request to amend Land Development Regulations to specify that the regulations and guidelines of the Beach Property Owners Design Manual are not applicable to those properties located within a designated historic district or which are individually listed on the City of Delray Beach Local Register of Historic Places. Planner: Amy Alvarez, Senior Planner; avarez@mydelraybeach.com VIII. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Concept Plan Review—(2019-049) Address: 1120 Nassau Street, Nassau Park Historic District Owner/Applicant: Charles Luciano Agent: Roger Cope, AIA; copearachitectsinc@gmail.com Discussion regarding the demolition of the existing contributing single-family home and construction of a new non-contributing structure located at 1120 Nassau Street. Note:This review is non-binding and no action shall be taken by the Board nor shall there be any written report resulting from discussions at the meeting which may be construed to be preliminary approval of the development concept. IX. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Staff ❖ Board Members X. ADJOURN jijAcitito An (e44)._ Michelle Hoyland, rincipal Planner; HPB Board Liaison Posted on: November 27, 2018 Reposted on: December 4, 2018 The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program,or activity conducted by the City.Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. DELRAY BEACH All-America City 1 I 0 1993 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2 001 Historic Preservation Board December 5, 2018 PRINT ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION FULL NAME 6.49/ey P rtiUfove,Us re-ere/ V/ .D 6"e- f,Uj 1 v-r� /4-QA2—' AtclGrstN 2:2/0 Ceeric OvJ Li DI d, L IC s� S7( Vhiw T(A4A/m 4LLL 1 /40, friA it:2.7 VOLC'Sc-c}-i 3 i/g.7 d-n-e_ar rci / Historic Preservati 3oard-Voting Sheet III VI.A VI.B VI.0 VI.D 230 George VII.A HPB MEETING Bush Bld. HELD: ATTEND Approval of Rules & 531 N. 101 NE 5t' 106 SE 7th Ord 03-19 Dec. 5, 2018 Agenda Regs. Swinton Ave Street Ave COA Review of COA COA Tax Designted Hist Exempt Dist. Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to William Bennett Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve to Approve Approve to P&Z CC AIF 5-0 5-0 5-0 5-0 5-0 5-0 Andrea Sherman P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Benjamin Baffer 621PP A Y Y Y Y Y Y Paula Newman- A A A A A A A Rocker A Reeve Bright A A A A A A A A John Klein P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Tracy Caruso P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Andrea Harden P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic PreservatigBoard-Voting Sheet VIII.A HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND Concept Dec. 5, 2018 Plan 1120 Nassau St Attorney: NO VOTE Lynn Gelin Benjamin Baffer Andrea Sherman Paula Newman- Rocker A Reeve Bright A John Klein P Tracy Caruso P Andrea Harden P Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board ADJOURNED: 9:15PM Historic PreservatimMoard-Voting Sheet III VI.A VI.B VI.0 VI.D 230 George VII.A HPB MEETING bush Bid. HELD: ATTEND Approval of Rules & 531 N. 101 NE 5th 106 SE 7th Ord 03-19 Agenda Regs. Swinton Ave Street Ave COA Review of /d7's✓/ COA COA Vt-L, Designted Hist Dist. Attorney: VOTE to — - VOTE to VOTE to tj0 �I VOTE to VOTE to Approve Approve approve �t 1 Approve Approve Oinfrf:r- AIF / v (?j3i Andrea Sherman / i✓ ✓ / / ✓ ✓ / Benjamin Baffer b,./4 4 ✓ Paula Newman- Rocker A i-1�n A 4 4 /4 A ,4-Reeve Bright ifr v fr 4 # 4- A 2 John Klein V Z ✓ ✓ / EZ / Tracy Caruso ✓ ✓ g/ / ,/ Andrea Harden V ✓ Z / ./ ✓ • Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board S 0, C)cil,/ Historic Preservatimff3oard-Voting Sheet VIII.A j J HPB MEETING y.J IC) �" S HELD: ATTEND Concept Dec. 5, 2018 Plan I 1120 Nassau St • Attorney: NO VOTE Lynn Gelin Benjamin Baffer Andrea Sherman Paula Newman- /l Rocker / Reeve Bright John Klein Tracy Caruso Andrea Harden Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board ADJOURNED: 9:15PM CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 531 N. Swinton Avenue Address: 531 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District File Number: 2019-014 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the December 5, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Approved with Request&LDR Section Postponed * Denied** CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H) J -0 *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. AL__ALA/ cee.„1..." Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Becky Luttbeg 531 N. Swinton Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33444 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 101 NE 5th Street Address: 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District File Number: 2019-030 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the December 5, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Request&LDR Section Postponed Approved wi*h Denied** Conditions CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H) s'I) *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. 471-X Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Virginia Ritter and John Kolkmeyer 101 NE 5th Street Delray Beach, FL 33444 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 106 SE 7th Avenue Address: 106 SE 7`h Avenue, Marina Historic District File Number: 2019-006 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the December 5, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Approved with Request&LDR Section Approved C Denied** AD VALOREM TAX EXEMPTION 4.5.1.(J) S- o *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. al/L-A,Ut' Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Dan and Donnamarie Sloan 106 SE 7`h Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33483 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD BOARD ORDER Project Name: 230 George Bush Boulevard Address: 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District File Number: 2019-022 ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the December 5, 2018 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and pursuant to the respective Section(s) of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Delray Beach, the Historic Preservation Board fmds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support the findings, as applicable, for the referenced projects. Request&LDR Section Approved Approved with Denied** CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.4.6(H)(5) S-0 *Conditions of Approval are attached as Exhibit A. **For a denial, the list of findings not supported by the Board are attached as Exhibit B. aA—"' Chair Historic Preservation Board Return Original to: Gary P. Eliopoulos GE Architecture, Inc. 1045 E Atlantic Avenue, Suite 303 Delray Beach, FL 33483 BYLAWS THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Article I: General. The Historic Preservation Board (hereinafter referred to as "the Board") shall be governed by Section 2.2.6 of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach, and the Rules of Procedure hereinafter set forth (the "Rules"), as adopted by the Board and approved by the City Commission. Article II: Officers. 1. The Board shall elect a Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson and 2nd Vice-Chairperson annually in the month of September, or as soon thereafter as possible, by a majority vote of its members present and voting at the time of election. 2. The Chairperson, or in the absence of the Chairperson, the Vice-Chairperson, shall preside at all proceedings of the Board and shall rule on all points of order and procedure. If both the Chairperson and the Vice-Chairperson are absent at a particular hearing, the 2nd Vice- Chairperson shall preside at the proceeding of the Board and shall rule on all points of order and procedure. 3. The Board Clerk, appointed by the City Manager, shall administer oaths, record proceedings of the Board, keep minutes of proceedings, take roll calls, record votes of the Board and carry out related duties pertaining to preparation, posting, and distribution of agendas, distribution of materials to Board members and preparation of Board Orders for signature. The Board Clerk's designee shall assume the aforementioned duties in the absence of the Board Clerk. Article III: Hearings, Quorum, Order of Business, Conflicts. 1. The Board shall conduct a regular meeting each calendar month in the evening hours (after 5:00 p.m.), unless there is no cause to hold such hearing or if a particular hearing coincides with a Holiday as designated by the City. The standard day of hearings shall be determined by the City Manager. Workshop meetings and special meetings may be scheduled at the mutual convenience of City staff and the Board. 2. The City Manager, or designee, may call hearings of the Board. 3. A quorum is required to conduct a hearing. A quorum shall consist of a majority of filled positions of the Board. All findings and orders of the Board require a vote of a majority of its members present and voting. 4. All hearings shall be open to the public. The Board Clerk shall administer oaths to all persons testifying before the Board. 1 5. The order of business at hearings shall be set by the Board and may be modified by a majority vote of the members present. 6. If all business cannot be finished, the Board may adjourn unfinished items to a future time and future date certain. Notice of the future time and future date shall be given to the respondents affected by the adjournment. 7. Conflicts: A Board member shall not abstain from voting unless the member has a conflict of interest pursuant to the requirements of Florida Statutes, Chapter 112, Section 112.3143(4)(a). 8. Board members shall comply with the rules as described in Sections 2-441 to 2- 448 of the Palm Beach County Code of Ethics. Article IV. Absences, Removal from Office. Board members may be suspended or removed for cause according to the procedures for removal as set forth in the Code of Ordinances of the City pursuant to Sec. 37.24. Article V. Parliamentary Procedure. Roberts Rules of Order shall be the final authority concerning questions of parliamentary procedures. Article VI. Hearing Procedures. The Board shall be governed by the "City of Delray Beach Procedures for Quasi- Judicial Hearings" as adopted by the City Commission on March 17, 2017, or as subsequently amended by the Commission. See Exhibit "A" attached to these general rules and incorporated herein. Article VII. Adoption; Amendments; Required Review; Effective Date. These general rules or subsequent amendments: 1. Shall be adopted by the Board by a majority vote of members present and voting at the time of adoption. 2. May be amended by the Board by a majority of members present and voting at the time of adoption of the amendment, however, said amendments will require approval of the City Commission. 3. Shall be reviewed by the Board every two years. 4. Shall become effective upon approval by the City Commission. 2 5. Were adopted by the Board on this day of , 2018. Chairperson, Historic Preservation Board 6. Were approved by the City Commission and became effective on the day of , 2018. CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA ATTEST: Katerri Johnson, City Clerk Shelly Petrolia, Mayor Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: R. Max Lohman, City Attorney 3 r HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Rebecca Luttberg Applicant: Donald Day, Delray Awning Project Location: 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District HPB Meeting Date: December 05, 2018 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) 2019-014 for installation of a fabric awning on the existing contributing building on the property located at 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property, which consists of Del-Ida Park, Lot 1 (Less S 2 Feet), Block 3, is located within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property is zoned Single Family Residential (R-1-AA). The property contains a contributing single-family residence constructed in 1947. This application is for installation of a fabric shed-style awning on the north elevation above the front door. The 6'4" wide awning will have 4" wide pink and white stripes, a projection of 3'6" and height of 1'6". ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Items identified in the Land Development Regulations shall specifically be addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development application/request. Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1 (E)(7), Visual Compatibility Standards, all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section. The following criteria apply: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. The proposal includes installation of a shed-style fabric awning. The proposed awning will be visually compatible with the historic residence and the structures within the Del-Ida Park Historic District. 531 N Swinton Avenue,COA 2019-014 Page 2 of 2 ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). C. Deny the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by finding that the request and approval thereof does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-014 for 531 N Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H)(5). Attachments: Photographs and color samples Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner -4ri Ai 4r. / i_ i ri ,i,,,,. . : ,...___.,_-__ .�,��: `:r I I t -_ __-- _ .. ti � ti a y COLOR SAMPLE & FINISH SCHEDULE Existing Colors/Material: Proposed Colors/Materials: ATTACH SAMPLES AND/OR PHOTO POSED Please note type of mai, ROOF '� � WALLS RAILINGS! FENCE FASCIA DOORS WINDOWS SCREENING (PATIO/POOL) COLUMNS OTHER -7, ! , ti,mil • AY • d is r.4116 ,-„,444,7. • 4°7* ''-..•'.4 ..**411/5 . •44,7, "••-'''• Asialill,„. • 4, • ( , a , ,F l',4144,414( �Y 4 �,` __.. • • /' ' .. • p , .i �';� . l..� r !-- 4,. `, ': • : , fy .y-..&1y .;...-- •bl• -.. J• , y T •+• V-4 ' sitw� � % - 4. o f •I.. ` - _ 'It I. . .�37,t mkt .Pr^ *M6 '.k '1 1/ i)7, • As tea. ',j y� b e��` J YN n s " f / , 3 • • • A. •kl:, . i x • v4. .4 q A y7 f'h{ 1 5h •)� t 1 '71 met,"..'� Y 4 { {^r 4 k { a N• 1j; -V *.{/♦I"�P ` • v 1:' 1 ¢ { dnyf 7Vb > ° • av i + � • .. '® N i `a r `; .ir , r• <Po -r-:n:.,,a+'Mtt♦'a'mnr. �.. " ,,,,,,,,.N.,...,,,,,,,„,,,f fs a,d E r e w9w1f � ' '� ,}� tiw r _ F r 46' Ili .s �je� ' y to "1► 4.0 ,•ice i .;•Ys r '�C x FRANK L.FINNARDO,RE. n nn�� PEA 0046549 f�ln°1 o RIC DOOR Ai�nnnnU NRIG 1// \ aCSI C,s c. fa.a mn crA.r,ws �OIIr0 DIBATI6-10,RE c'w ATTACHMENT TO HOST STRUCTURE INFORMATION VAL III HOli I SIGHED.40 PIPE PER TABLES TYP. AI >H 1 PEHNiI ONLY UNp., WET ICT:IF TMiS_FH[1 T DOES • NIONATURE•EN D WELDED TAB OPTION ATUSE&ENGINEER SEAL: 1"WIDE MIN.3/16'THK,2'LONG IF ITNATE O DIGITAL STEEL TAB B/16"FULL FILLET SIGNATURE ON SHEET 1,T115 WELDED TO PIPE. SHEET IS PART OF A REMAIN IN SIGNED FILE,SHALL IN -.� DIGITAL FORMAT,&PRINTED �s COPI[5OF T OS DONMENi A 10 STAL ONSCDC0.ED SIGHED AND SEALED.IF TIGRE IS NO DIGITAL SIGN4NRE ON SHEET 1 • TRITON SHEET DOES NOT CONTAIN AN ENGINEER'S �• 2 MAX _ - ORIGINAL SIGNATURE&SEAL _ CENTER BOLT THIS SHEET SHEET IS A C'OPT,'DMFT. / Z -N tl Z o 4.__________-----.'.--.'-'--- .HET f 1 �0 W m,.,UE m o I I ' 16 TCJSS Z OIliU ��S 6' 3/" pipe Oa_ �¢W 96 /, I `�< o,°m z ./�1 wNLN G I _ Z'\ �No.. w F-� •l Will 01. , • . , ,„...„..... Br'W"�� 3tl s1 0. 4 Intedw ri. oW w . ...„ W GENERAL NOTES: 0 z .S ' 1. ALL STRUCTURES HAVE BEEN DESIGNED 1N ACCORDANCE WITH THE FLORIDA I-I >a Pal 1 BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION(2017)AND ASCE 7-10(FORH=15',E%P='C',V,,1*=1151.IPH(3 Z ¢TA O -8 SEC GUST),RISK CATEGORY I,1.5:12 MIN.SLOPE,PITCHED/GABLE ROOF,MV/FRS ROOF ill M N OVER OPEN STRUCTURE,OBSTRUCTED OR UNOBSTRUCTED WIND FLOW). MAXIMUM DESIGN w u+-I ""1.- PRESSURE OF 25 PSF. Q 66 n c u VV.„MAY BE CALCULATED WITH TILE FOLLOWING CONVERSION:V,la=VPR•40.6] R- .9 = 2. ALL PIPE SHALL BE ASA SCHEDULE 40 OR GATORSHIELD.14 GAGE GALVANIZED UNLESS } oZo U m I/1u - NOTED OTHERWISE. Q Z>Ieil A3. ALL WELDS SHALL COMPLY WITH A.W.S.CODE,CURRENT EDITION.ALL WELDS SHALL n/ on O 'FT R BE FULL LENGTH WITH 3/I6"FILLET(U.N.O.),COVERED WITH ALUM PAINT. --I m m mNI -~A 4. FABRIC COVERING SHALL BE REMOVED WHEN SUSTAINED WINDS REACH 75mph W C1 .'0m YMI6" . (90mph 3-SECOND GUST). FABRIC COVERING SHALL OE EXTERIOR,NON-METALLIC, Q BAyy, A NON-CORROSIVE,&WATER RESISTANT. FABRIC SELECTION IS BEYOND THE SCOPE OF THIS W010 PIPE WALL OUTSIDE INSIDE CE5. FRAMES WITHOUT COVERING HAVE BEEN DESIGNED BY RATIONAL ANALYSIS TO 1 L7` _ \v I I w THICK DIEM DRAM WITHSTAND V,. 170m h(3-SECOND GUST)WINDS IN EXPOSURES'C'AND'D'. W _ Pik+ 1/2"DIAM 0.109" 0.840" 0.622" 6. THE AWNING OWNER SHALL BE NOTIFIED OF THESE CONDITIONS BY THE PERMIT o F5' E o 3/4"DRAM 0.113" 1.050" 0.824" HOLDER. NO WARRANTY,EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED,IS CONTAINED HEREIN. Q07 THE EXISTING HOST STRUCTURE MUST BE CAPABLE OF SUPPORTING THE LOADED Gfib 1"DIAM 0.133" 1.315" 1.049" SYSTEM AS VERIFIED BY THE PERMIT HOLDER. NO WARRANTY,EITHER EXPRESSED OR * 1g 1-1/4"DIEM 0.140" 1.660" 1.380" IMPLIED,IS CONTAINED HEREIN. CC S. 1-1/2"DIEM 0.145" 1.900" 1,610" 8. ENGINEERING EXPRESS HAS NOT VISITED THIS IOBSITE.INFORMATION CONTAINED . 6=�P S. 346"MIN FILLET HEREIN IS BASED ON CONTRACTOR-SUPPLIED DATA AND MEASUREMENTS. ENGINEERING qg WELD EACH SIDE, EXPRESS SHALL NOT BE HELD RESPONSBILE OR LIABLE IN ANY WAY FOR ERRONEOUS OR ' & FULL LENGTH ANCHORS #14 SMS AT ANCHOR SCHEDULE INACCURATE DATA OR MEASUREMENTS. DIMENSIONS ARE SHOWN TO ILLUSTRATE DESIGN 3 2 PER ANCHOR FORCES AND OTHER DESIGN CRITERIA. THEY MAY VARY SLIGHTLY,BUT MUST REMAIN LET 2" /� / 12"O.C.MAX8LR MAX 411, SCHEDULE(TYP) 1'�1 • 3/8"ELCO CONFLEX(21/c"MIN EMBED TO WITHIN THE LIMITATIONS SPECIFIED HEREIN. WORK SHALL BE FIELD VERIFIED BY 0I HERS 5q g -1 a� 1/2"MIN CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,3 3/4"MIN EDGE PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION, ENGINEERING EXPRESS SHALL BE NOTIFIED AND GIVEN AN g 3/16"MIN -d �1/2"MIN --r- DISTANCE,6' MIN SPACING). OPPORTUNITY TO RE-EVALUATE OUR WORK UPON DISCOVERY OF ANY INACCURATE a S 88 $ `\\ /! x' 1'Sj aLa • 3/8"POWERS WEDGE DOLT(2%"MIN EMBED TO INFORMATION PRIOR TO MODIFICATION OF EXISTING FIELD CONDITIONS AND FABRICATION ,, F �� "�®S�p `' CL? 3/16"_ _ CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4'"MIN EDGE AND INSTALLATION OF MATERIALS. mrrxumEEAIGISSIG EIEIFss• 1.-' 1.5"MIN 3/I6"• ! '• MIN 3/16' MIN- - DISTANCE,44"MIN SPACING). 9. ENGINEER SEAL AFFIXED HERETO VALIDATES STRUCTURAL DESIGNEE SHOWN ONLY. MIN • 3/8"POWERS POWER-BOLT(2"MIN EMBED TO USE OF THIS SPECIFICATION BY CONTRACTOR,et.&I.INDEMNIFIES&SAVES HARMLESS THIS WIDE TYP. �. ENGINEER FOR ALL COST&DAMAGES INCLUDING LEGAL FEES&APPELLATE FEES RESULTING S WELDED TAB PIPE CLAMP DIRECT "Z"BRACKET ALT MOUNTING CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4 1/2"MIN EDGE FROM MATERIAL FABRICATION,SYSTEM ERECTION,&CONSTRUCTION PRACTICES BEYOND SCALEN 0 UNLESS NOTED ATTACHMENT ATTACHMENT ATTACHMENT ATTACHMENT CLIP DISTANCE,3 3/4"MIN SPACING). THAT WHICH IS CALLED FOR BY LOCAL,STATE,&FEDERAL CODES&FROM DEVIATIONS OF I"9 ANCHORAGE OPTIONS 3/8"HI I.TI KWIKBOLT III(2BLOC"MIN EMBED TO THIS PLAN. N.T.S.NTS CONCRETE OR GROUT-FILLED BLOCK,4 1/2."MIN EDGE 50. EXCEPT AS EXPRESSLY PROVIDED HEREIN,NO ADDITIONAL CERTIFICATIONS OR a DISTANCE,5 5/8"MIN SPACING. AFFIRMATIONS ARP INTEND PD , HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 5, 2018 ITEM: 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District - Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-030) for construction of a new two-car garage. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness GENERAL DATA: Owner/Applicant Virginia Ritter and John Kolkmeyer �.�{ °� Location. North side of NE 5th Street, between ''r • 4 *- ' -► . a- NE 2nd Avenue and N. Swinton : • - _ " ° ':. ` Avenue . ` Property Size 0.42 Acres Y: �,° • ' '., ��c' tir ar t^ Historic District: Del-Ida Park Historic District ,°' Ee NE,,thSt Zoning. R-1-AA (Single Family Residential) .Q C--. - a ` . : ; ii, Adjacent Zoning. . i 1 m North: R-1-AA ; East: R-1-AA w s �,` : r Q1 South: R-1-AA l• ;Nt.- West: - , -K 4. -i II R-1-AA S - z `" �� °` � NE dth St m T. --- ` -Ar*, ,._tom' rig w �- ^J 7. Existing Future Land ti ;, ca Use Designation. LD (Low Density 0-5 DU/Acre) y "Zr>- y ne'ry.Row t ,1 Water Service. Public water service is provided a ' . on site. k Q , c' i Nita j'adison'Ln Sewer Service- Public sewer service is provided ' A 41 . a. Y' . z on site. z a iii ° ` a 7� t tL S . f S 1�-r3 . -, ,.�r - NORTH ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) (2019-030) for construction of a new two-car garage on the west side of the property located at 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property is irregularly shaped and fronts on both Fern Court and NE 5th Street. The 0.42 acre lot contains a 1,500 sq. ft. one-story, single-family residence constructed circa, and a detached single-car garage. The Mission style structure is classified as contributing to the Del-Ida Park Historic District, but there are no records as to when the garage was constructed; thus, it is not considered a contributing structure. Building records indicate that a Florida Room was added to the west elevation in 1965. At its meeting of July 3, 2013, the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) approved a COA (2013-187) for two minor additions to the residence, demolition of an existing single-car garage, construction of a detached garage and guest cottage. The COA was significantly revised and reduced in scope by the property owner. Those revisions were administratively approved and consisted of a rear kitchen addition/expansion, and addition of a home office and master suite walk-in closet. The total added square footage measures approximately 350 square feet. All new, impact-rated windows were installed throughout the structure, and the flat roof was refinished. The two additions were completed vesting the project, but the detached garage and guest cottage were not constructed. In 2014, an Ad Valorem Tax Exemption was approved for the subject property. The subject request is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to modify the approved two-car, detached garage. Originally, the garage was to have a half-flat and half-pitched roof. The proposal includes a simpler, Mission style, detached two-car garage with a flat roof and corner parapets. The proposed garage is 27' deep by 26' wide, and 11' high (13' with the parapet). ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL Pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ZONING AND USE REVIEW Pursuant to LDR Section 4.3.4(K), Development Standards, properties located within the R-1-AA (Single Family Residential) zoning district shall be developed according to the requirements noted in the chart below. Development Standards Required Proposed Setbacks (Minimum): Front(South) 30' 30' Side Interior(West) 10' 10' Rear (North) 10' 10' As illustrated, the proposal is in compliance with the applicable requirements; therefore, positive findings can be made. LDR SECTION 4.5.1, HISTORIC PRESERVATION, DESIGNATED DISTRICTS, SITES, AND BUILDINGS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E) - Development Standards: all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. 101 NE 5th Street—2019-030 HPB Meeting of December 5, 2018 Standard 2 The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. Standard 9 New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. Standard 10 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. The existing garage is not a contributing structure to the historic district and is not in harmony with the existing contributing single-family residence nor the neighboring residences. The pitched, shingle roof style on the garage is not present on the applicant's property nor on adjacent properties. As stated in the applicant's Justification Statement: "There is no record as to when this garage was constructed and its location proximate to the neighbor's residence gives the impression that it is not a part of the applicant's property'. The proposed garage elevations are designed to resemble Mission style of the existing contributing single-family residence which will be compatible with the existing structure and the surrounding area. The two-car garage will have individual arched openings with brown simulated wood grain, aluminum door in a barn-style. The garage will be detached from the residential structure so if removed in the future will not compromise the integrity of the historic building. The proposal meets the applicable standards noted above and their intent as the proposal ensures an appropriate exterior alteration of the historic property, protecting the historic integrity of the single-family residence and its environment. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(7) - Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m). Visual compatibility for all development on individually designated properties outside the district shall be determined by comparison to other structures within the site. Applicable Visual Compatibility Standards (a) Height: The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible in comparison or relation to the height of existing structures and buildings in a historic district for all major and minor development. For major development, visual compatibility with respect to the height of residential structures, as defined by 4.5.1(E)(2)(a), shall also be determined through application of the Building Height Plane. (b)Front Facade Proportion: The front facade of each building or structure shall be visually compatible with and be in direct relationship to the width of the building and to the height of the front elevation of other existing structures and buildings within the subject historic district. 101 NE 5th Street—2019-030 HPB Meeting of December 5, 2018 (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. The proposed garage elevations are designed with a flat-roof and in the Mission architectural style. The garage will be compatible with the existing contributing single-family residence and the surrounding area. The two-car garage will have individual arched openings with brown simulated wood grain, aluminum doors in a barn-style. A single goose neck styled light fixture will be situated over each garage door. The proposal incorporates three 4/1 style windows, similar to the existing structure. The height of the garage does not exceed the highest element of the existing residence. The proposed elevation changes to the approved detached garage are compatible with the existing proportion of the front façade and are appropriate and compatible with the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The proposal meets the intent of the review criteria above; thus, positive findings are made with respect to the sections indicated above. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Approve Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-030) for the property located at 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulation Section 2.4.6(H). C. Deny Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-030) for the property located at 101 NE 5th Street, Del- Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and by finding that the request and approval thereof is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet the criteria set forth in Land Development Regulation Section 2.4.6(H). RECOMMENDATIONS Approve Certificate of Appropriateness 2019-030 for 101 NE 5th Street, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H). Attachments: ■ Survey, Site plan, Elevations, and Pictures. Report prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner • . ` ; £' .... • e . qx S �Ak-�,„ `L b eI„ ,:- q>f . y^may. _ r +F . wraci " -- ..' • • .�� ... y ' rP..ar...y+►, ,+'.-""w--•••- --„an '•'„fir .Ar .,.t�„ . r ,y,;. >- ..rw.y.� w. .r. .w»' .au..•+w+►. AJr'-yd11. '. ,. < ' NWir^ Mir`:•..rr y��r .k sr .r5r✓ *ii�-:. 'w' Z ii.1 , + (�.,. _ i r` 'o%w" MPr s•w,WW s'is�i MwiWn- -,ice. aO*-'M . *, .yt4'4l ..:_-.i• P` n.., +�....r.N. !^' ___rr r+rrt..r�r'•.Away::+ems«•!�'. ., ,. a � �. JFMF. �► wr�..y,,w....a.rw• ..r. slr. w-A ` • Yrt T � •PI ...... .*. b t opioift .;,. s-.ryp/ . . Mr w *rf" 1 'N+. n... I.e.1.f.r a.. •. woo. In"-mow te ar/ ... ca.WNW 111..E^1�..=-wa.an..+� a+s aa..M . 'q+••• I /00AArr a--, .n v�...r...«wuwF^ �� wr:a. * - .-0.* Or 4 rm.. • ,,• ,,.. ., , m. 3 w... :.,.. n.,m .vmY" yw , .a.:.. .614. :.NMI ,.Io ...r....... -•.,..�«-••. ,a•...*.•......- » • - . . _ -' + ♦' .�!' 6� J 4.. rMly�w a ' ia... - J - ``: ' _ Aa 1 e- N m* . • Y ,;• E A • II ... .. i l II .a• ;•,. w . ,. :,. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 5, 2018 ITEM: 106 SE 7'' Avenue. Marina Historic District, (2019-006) — Provide a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption GENERAL DATA: Owner . Dan & Donnamarie Sloan _ 4 Location• 106 SE 7"Avenue, west side of • *3 F A1..,�•ti ° r SE 7" Avenue, approximately 60 feet a, i& '`�' tr9 south of SE 1st Street r'7cs`~ -* " '` ' Property Size 0.45 Acres ,. . `11,."'la,' ;%Ca -�. Historic District Marina Historic District Wit. ► ` a,,-` -r 91 Current Zoning RM (Multipl , Family Residential — ti Medium Density) '�" -I . r+' '; . i „. In. IA j Adjacent Zonin �iR 1 9• ,a_ gg- _r North: RM S [Q"_:.L " i..;v. South: RM r '.it• # - t 'y East: RM " West: CBD (Central Business District) ! ''-4+-� _ ``• ii r3 ill Existing Future Land MD (Medium Density Residential > ", Use Designation 5-12 DU/Acre) seznn St - ige Water Service Public water service is Y..-.`;. "ti' 1 provided on site. ; sy; „-y,, NORTH Sewer Service Public sewer service is provided on site. ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action requested of the Board is a recommendation to the City Commission for a historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption request associated with additions and alterations to a contributing structure located at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 4.5.1(J). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Unit 1, of Sloan Hammock, Land Condominium, and is located on the west side of SE 7th Avenue, approximately 75' south of SE 1st Street. The property, joined by a Unity of Title and executed condominium documents, currently contains four structures consisting of 5 total units (two 2-story structures, a 1-story structure, and a detached garage). The property is zoned Multiple- Family Residential-Medium Density(RM) and classified as contributing to the Marina Historic District. In October, 1993, the Historic Preservation Board approved variances to reduce the required side and rear setbacks for a proposed 3-bay garage, a variance request to reduce the distance between two residential buildings within the multi-family developments, a waiver to reduce the right-of-way width on SE 7th Avenue from 60'to 40', and the site plan, subject to conditions.The Board required that a sidewalk be installed along the west side of SE 7th Avenue from the north property line to the northernmost parking space. The Board also gave partial approval for the proposed architectural design elements. While the development approval expired, the variances remained as these run with the land, as opposed to with the validity or establishment of an approved project. In December, 1995, the Historic Preservation Board approved the restoration of the historic dwelling, expansion and upgrading of the existing one-story triplex to two stories, construction of a second-story on the existing single-family residence, construction of a three-bay garage, construction of a swimming pool, and the installation of fences,walkways, and decking, subject to conditions. One condition was that Unity of Title and condominium documentation be recorded as the development proposal contained three individually platted lots. Once these documents were recorded, the triplex became a three-unit condominium unit, the two-story, single family residence became a single-unit condominium, and the one-story, contributing structure became a single-unit condominium with an associated attached garage. Then at its June 1, 2016 meeting the Historic Preservation Board approved a COA and Class II Site Plan Modification consisting of additions and alterations to the 1925 Mission style structure on the site, as follows: • Addition to the south elevation with French doors facing south; • Screened porch over existing patio on the south elevation with simulated coral rock columns and decorative trellis supporting new awning above; • 2nd story addition to main structure consisting of 910 square feet; • New shed style, fabric awnings on residence (Sunbrella, Forest Green Tweed); • Extension of chimney to second story on north elevation; • New single French door on west elevation of residence; • New Weathershield PGT aluminum clad wood windows and doors in medium walnut finish; and, • Alterations to the detached garage that included a new flat, single-panel door on the north elevation and new shed style fabric awnings(Sunbrella, Forest Green/Beige Blvd. stripe). The applicant is now before the Board to request review of the Tax Exemption Application for the aforenoted site and building improvements. Based on State regulations, an Ad Valorem Tax Exemption can be approved for a project before, during, or after it has been undertaken. The applicant therefore requests consideration of the Ad Valorem Tax Exemption as the project is complete. 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of December 5,2018 AD VALOREM TAX EXEMPTION Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J), a tax exemption is available for improvements to qualifying contributing properties in a designated historic district or individually designated properties, as listed in Section 4.5.1(1). Qualifying properties shall be exempt from that portion of ad valorem taxation levied by the City of Delray Beach on one hundred percent (100%) of the increase in assessed value resulting from any HPB approved renovation, restoration, rehabilitation, or other improvements of the qualifying property made on or after the effective date of the original passing of Ordinance 50-96 on November 19, 1996. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(1), clarifies that the exemption does not apply to the following: (a) Taxes levied for payment of bonds; (b) Taxes authorized by a vote of the electors pursuant to Section 9(b) or Section 12, Article 7 of the Florida Constitution; or (c) Personal property. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(2), explains the exemption period shall be for ten (10)years, unless a lesser term is set by the City Commission. (a) The term of the exemption shall be specified in the resolution approving the exemption and shall continue regardless of any changes in the authority of the City to authorize such exemption or change in ownership of the property. (b) To retain an exemption,the historic character of the property and the improvements which qualified the property for an exemption must be maintained in their historic state over the period for which the exemption was authorized. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(4) provides the parameters for qualifying properties and improvements.The subject property qualifies as it is listed on the Local Register of Historic Places. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(5) requires that for an improvement to a historic property to qualify the property for an exemption, the improvement must: (a) be consistent with the United States Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended; and (b) be a constructed and/or installed improvement as approved by the Historic Preservation Board and as established in rules adopted by the Department of State, Division of Historical Resources, FAC 1 A-38,as amended which defines real property improvements as changes in the condition of real property brought about by the expenditure of labor and money for the restoration, renovation, or rehabilitation of such property. Improvements shall include, but are not limited to: modifications, repairs, or additions to the principal contributing building and its associated accessory structures(i.e.a garage, cabana, guest cottage, storage/utility structures, swimming pools), whether existing or new.The exemption does not apply to improvements made to non-contributing principal buildings, existing non-contributing accessory structures, or undesignated structures and/or properties; and, (c) be consistent with Section 4.5.1(E), "Development Standards", of the City's Land Development Regulations; and (d) include, as part of the overall project, visible improvements to the exterior of the structure. The project meets the above criteria(a)and(b)through previous approval by the Board of the associated improvements outlined above which constituted its compliance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as well as the rules of Florida Administrative Code 1A-38, promulgated by the Florida Department of State, Division of Historical Resources.The development project further meets criterion (c) per the COA approval, which applied the LDR Development Standards in the assessment of the proposal. Finally, the project meets criterion (d) as the project encompasses visible improvements to the exterior of the building and related property. 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of December 5,2018 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(7), any property owner, or the authorized agent of the owner, that desires an ad valorem tax exemption for the improvement of a historic property must submit a Historic Property Tax Exemption Application to the Planning and Zoning Department upon completion of the qualifying improvements. (a) The application shall indicate the estimated cost of the total project, the estimated cost attributed solely to the historic structure, and project completion date as determined by the Certificate of Occupancy issued by the Building Department. (b) The Historic Property Tax Exemption Application shall be accompanied by a copy of the most recent tax bill from the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser for the property; a new property survey illustrating the improvements; a copy of the building permit application indicating estimated project cost; a copy of the Certificate of Occupancy/Final Inspection; and photographs illustrating the before and after of each improvement, including both the interior, exterior, and all new construction. The photographs shall be identified with a date and description indicating the impact of the improvement. (c) The application must be submitted within three (3) months from the date of issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. (d) The Historic Preservation Planner will inspect the completed work to verify such compliance prior to Historic Preservation Board review. a. If the Historic Preservation Board determines that the work is a qualifying improvement and is in compliance with the approved plans and the review standards contained in Section 4.5.1(E), the Board shall recommend that the City Commission grant the Historic Property Tax Exemption Application. b. Upon a recommendation of approval of a Historic Property Tax Exemption Application by the Historic Preservation Board, the application shall be placed by resolution on the agenda of the City Commission for approval. The resolution of the City Commission approving the application shall provide the 'name of the owner of the property, the property address and legal description, a recorded restrictive covenant in the official records of Palm Beach County as a condition of receiving the exemption, and the effective dates of the exemption, including the expiration date. c. If the Historic Preservation Board determines that the work as completed is either not consistent with the approved plans or is not in compliance with the review standards contained in Section 4.5.1(E),the applicant shall be advised that the request has been denied The qualifying improvements were completed and the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application was submitted on October 10, 2018, within three months of the Certificate of Occupancy, which was issued on September 24, 2018. The tax exemption will be limited to the increase in assessed value (as determined by the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser) resulting from the subject improvements and provide an abatement of taxes on the City and County portions for a period of ten years from the date of approval. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(8), Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant, the covenant required in order to qualify for the exemption: (a) To qualify for an exemption, the applicant must sign and return the Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant with the Final Application/Request for Review of Completed Work. The covenant as established by the Department of State,Division of Historical Resources, shall be in a form approved by the City of Delray Beach City Attorney's Office and applicable for the term for which the exemption is granted and shall require the character of the property and qualifying improvements to be maintained during the period that the exemption is granted. (b) On or before the effective date of the exemption, the owner of the property shall have the covenant recorded in the official records of Palm Beach County, Florida, and shall cause a certified copy of the recorded covenant to be delivered to the City's Historic Preservation Planner. Such covenant shall be binding on the current property owner, transferees, and their heirs, assigns and successors. A violation of the covenant shall 106 SE 7th Avenue—2019-006 HPB Meeting of December 5,2018 result in the property owner being subject to the payment of the differences between the total amount of the taxes which would have been due in March of each of the previous years in which the covenant or agreement was in effect had the property not received the exemption and the total amount of taxes actually paid in those years, plus interest on the difference calculated as provided in Sec. 212.12(3), Florida Statutes. LDR Section 4.5.1(J)(10), Revocation Proceedings, provides guidelines to revocation of the tax exemption upon violation of the recorded covenant. (a) The Historic Preservation Board may initiate proceedings to revoke the ad valorem tax exemption provided herein, in the event the applicant, or subsequent owner or successors in interest to the property, fails to maintain the property according to the terms, conditions and standards of the Historic Preservation Exemption Covenant. (b) The Historic Preservation Planner shall provide notice to the current owner of record of the property and the Historic Preservation Board shall hold a revocation hearing in the same manner as in Section 4.5.1(M)(10), and make a recommendation to the City Commission. (c) The City Commission shall review the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Board and make a determination as to whether the tax exemption shall be revoked. Should the City Commission determine that the tax exemption shall be revoked, a written resolution revoking the exemption and notice of penalties as provided in Paragraph 8 of the covenant shall be provided to the owner,the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser, and filed in the official records of Palm Beach County. (d) Upon receipt of the resolution revoking the tax exemption, the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser shall discontinue the tax exemption on the property as of January 1st of the year following receipt of the notice of revocation. The Sections noted above regarding the "Restrictive Covenant" and "Revocation Proceedings" are provided to demonstrate that the tax exemption is binding,and if violated,the property owner would have to comply with the consequences. The tax exemption request complies with the criteria contained in LDR Section 4.5.1(J) as the Historic Preservation Board approved the associated improvements by making positive findings with respect to the applicable LDR Sections, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation; therefore, positive findings can be made with respect to LDR Section 4.5.1(J). ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Recommend approval to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). C. Recommend denial to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon a failure to make positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). RECOMMENDATION Recommend approval to the City Commission of the historic property Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Application(2018-150)for improvements to the property at 106 SE 7th Avenue, Marina Historic District, based upon positive findings with respect to Land Development Regulation Section 4.5.1(J). Attachments: Tax Exemption Application and Supporting Documents Report Prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner From: Dan Sloan ds 1/50@?bellsouth riot I - e Subject: Re:Additional Requested Items::Tax Abatement Form/Application for Phase 1 renovations to 106 SE 7th Avenue just completed. Date: October 17,2018 at 2:06 PM To: Hoyland,Michelle tloylandM0Prnydelraybeach corn Cc. Donnamarie Sloan rlonna<< sloandesign.hiz Hi Michele, \k at° Attached is a al copy of: 1 CO from Building Dept(was also on the flash drive submitted previously) 2. Signed and Notarized Owners Consent forms from both Donna and Myself to appoint myself as Agent in this matter 3. Signed and Sealed Survey... NOTE Signed&Sealed ORIGINAL IS 24x36 i'll be dropping that off... Abe had said just drop off 11x17 size of all plans/surveys/etc.(was also on the flash drive submitted previously) 4. I'll take a whole bunch of Elevation Photos from a step ladder as soon as the Awnings are installed in the near future and send them under separate cover...there is a lot of landscaping/trees so it will be pretty hard to impossible to see the entire north and south facades for example. I'd like to drop off the originals for items 1 to 3 this pm if ok... Please let me know...thanks! Dan Sloan,Architect AM,t,EED A.P. Sloan&Sloan Architecture+Interior Design AI A,AS( &FGBC Members RC�� f.56 U 243-8-8755 D dan@sloandesignbiz p www.sloartdesign.biz C7 y OCT ? 1 20/R City cP bevel �elr Delray Opent ay Eeac City oft 1r00 N1d 1ST AVE Florida 9&Zo��g DOe,Dt. DELRAY BEACH FL 33444 CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY/CERTIFICATE OF CDW LKTIOti Application Number. . . . 17-00167664 000 000 CO Issue Date 9/24/18 Parcel 12 43 46 16 D7 000 0010 Property Address . . . . 106 SE 7TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 Subdivision �a . . SLOAN HA�K LAND COND Legal Description . SLOAN K LAND COND LAND UNIT 1 MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT Property Zoning . . . UNKNOWN Owner SLOAN DANIEL & MARIE 106 SE 7TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5243 Contractor CONCH CUSTOM HOMES INC De cription of Work . ADDITION - SINGLE FAMILY valuation SS 141,67S Construction Type . . piipQiOi�t Occ�u aZoyeType RESIDENTIAL Building Code Edition . r`T BC: 1994,1997,2001,2004, 2007,2010 - NOTES: ADDITION OF 11STIF TO SINGLE 2NDY FLOOR MASTER SUITE uplift test ok 04.24. 18 pe CODE VER: FBC 2014 L) M. S tb•N Cc+D1 Al °A, HISTORIC PROPERTY Qits.SEA.AD VALOREM TAX `#4v. °`' EXEMPTION APPLICATION AMERICAExplore and Enjoy Our ge HISTORIC PRESERVATION B F&CEIVEo t a Submittal Date: Property Address: 106 SE 7th Ave, Del y BeactO(fLj Q 2018 Historic District/Site: Marina_Historic District City of Delray Bea�� -- Plannin &Zonin INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLETING AND FILING THE TAX EXEMPTION APPLICATION The submittal of an application package will require an application submittal appointment. The appointment is required to ensure that all required materials, exhibits, and information is included and provided. Prior to the submittal of the application package please call the Planning, Zoning and Building Department at 561.243-7040 for an appointment. All application packages will only be accepted for processing when deemed complete at the time of submittal. If the submittal is deemed incomplete, the application will not be accepted until all components, including any fees. are provided together in one submittal. Applications may be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Department at any time between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., Monday thru Friday. Please submit application and ail required materials at the same time. Incomplete applications will not be accepted. The Historic Preservation Board (HPB) will act on a tax exemption application at the next applicable meeting upon confirmation by the Historic Preservation Planner that the application is complete and satisfies the requirements of LDR Section 4.5.1(J) and is therefore eligible for review by the Historic Preservation Board. This review period takes approximately sixty (60) days. Please review page 9 for complete application processing information. Tax Exemption Applications must be submitted within three months of Certificate of Occupancy (Final Inspection), and no later than July 1st to receive the exemption on the following year's taxes. The application must be accompanied by the $100.00 processing fee (make checks payable to the City of Delray Beach). Please print or type all of the required information and ensure that the application is complete and accurate. It is necessary that an owner. or an authorized agent, be present at the Board meeting when the application is reviewed. If a property owner wishes to designate a representative/agent. please execute the 'Owner's Consent and Designation of Agency" form found in this application. Pursuant to the City's Land Development Regulations' Section 2.4.6(J)(2)(b) no application for a COA will be accepted by the HPB unless it contains all required and pertinent information. A pre-application conference with a member of the Planning Staff is strongly recommended_ and can be scheduled at your convenience. All projects will be reviewed and evaluated for conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings. The Standards for Rehabilitation are broadly worded to guide the improvement of all types of historic properties. Revised. 10/15 The underlying concern expressed in the referenced Standards and Guidelines is the preservation of significant historic materials and features of a building or archaeological site in the process of restoration, rehabilitation or renovation. Evaluation is based on whether or not the overall project is consistent with the Standards and Guidelines. Proposed work that does not appear to be consistent with the Standards and Guidelines will be identified, and advice will be given to assist property owners, architects, or builders in bringing the project into conformance. Notes: 1. A digital copy of all plan exhibits and application documentation provided on CD is required with the submittal of the application and each subsequent resubmittal. The digital copy must be in a PDF format and shall be prepared at a size of 81/2" x 11" or 11"x 17", depending upon legibility. 2. Citizens that request a presentation before the Board or City Commission that is on a portable flash drive device must provide their media to the City Clerk's Office, no later than 12:00 pm one day prior to the meeting where they wish to present. The City laptops will not accept (won't even recognize) anyjump_drives inserted without prior IT scanning. There will be a zero tolerance policy on this. Applicants have the option to bring their own laptops for their presentation. 3. Board & City Commission Presentations: All applicants are now expected to present their items in full to the Board or City Commission prior to Staffs presentation.City Staff will introduce the item and enter the file into the record; the applicant will then be given time to present their item. Followin_q the applicant's presentation, City Staff will provide a brief overview of code compliance and recommended actions, in addition to relevant information not provided by the applicant. All applicant presentations must be submitted to the Project Planner a minimum of 3 full business days prior to the day of the City Commission or Board meeting. For example, the SPRAB meetings occur on Wednesdays.The applicant's presentation must be submitted by 5pm on the Thursday prior to the meeting. • 2 12 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION APPLICATION Project Name/Address: Sloan Residence Renovations &Additions- Phase 1 PART ONE -APPLICANT INFORMATION: APPLICANT Name: Dan & Donnamarie Sloan Mailing Address: 106 SE 7th Ave, Delray Beach, FL. 33483. Telephone Number: (561) 243-8755 E-Mail: dsloan a(�,sloandesign.biz AGENT Name: Mailing Address: Telephone Number: E-Mail: OWNER (if other than applicant) Name: Mailing Address: Telephone Number: E-Mail: Applicant is: Owner[ ] Lessee [ ] Other 3 12 PART TWO - PROPERTY INFORMATION: Property Control Number: 12-43-46-16-D7-000-0010 Legal Description (attach separate sheet if necessary): Sloan Residence, 106 SE 7th Ave., Delray Beach, FL. 33483 a/k/a Unit#1 Sloan Hammock, a Land Condominium , Delray Beach, FL as recorded in PB 12283Pe 841, Public Records of Palm Beach Co., FL. Zoning Designation: RM (Residential Multifamily) Property is: in a Local Historic District XX in a National Register District Individually Listed on Local Register Individually Listed on National Register Use of Property Prior to Improvements: Single Family Residential Use of Property After to improvements: Single Family Residential Original Date of Construction: 1924-1925 Dates of Previous Alterations: 1995-1996 (All new Structural Framing, New AC, All New Electrical System, All New Plumbing System All New Roofing and Windows Has the building ever been moved or relocated? ( )Yes ( XX )No If so, when? From Where? Description of Physical Appearance Prior to Improvements: Provide information about the major exterior and interior features of the building. Describe the building in its existing condition (before improvement) — not as it was when first built(unless unchanged) or as it will be after improvement. Note the architectural style, exterior construction materials (wood, brick, etc.), type of roof(flat, gable, hipped, etc.), number of stories, basic plan (rectangular, irregular, L-shaped, etc.), and distinguishing architectural features (placement and type of windows, chimneys, porches, decorative interior features or spaces). Describe any changes that have been made to the building since its original construction (i.e., additions, porch enclosures, new storefronts, relocation of doors and windows, and alterations to the interior). Other buildings on the property such as carriage houses, barns and sheds should also be described. Finally, discuss the way in which the building relates to others in the district in terms of siting, scale, material,construction,and date of construction. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED 4 12 Statement of Significance: Summarize how the building contributes to the significance of the district. This summary should relate to the significance of the district (including the district's period of significance) as identified in the National Register nomination or district designation documentation. Is it similar to other buildings in the district in scale, building materials, style, and period of construction? Note important persons from the past associated with the building, former uses of the property,and the name of the architect or builder, if known. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED PART THREE— PROJECT INFORMATION Type of request: (XX) Exemption under 196.1997, F.S. (standard exemption) ( ) Exemption under 196.1998, F.S. (exemption for properties occupied by non-profit organizations or government agencies and regularly open to the pubic) Project Start Date: 4/4/17 Project Completion Date: 9/24/18 (Certificate of Occupancy Issued by Building Department) Total Estimated Project Costs: $139,500 Total Project Cost Attributed Solely to the Historic Structure: $139,500 PART FOUR: APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS Please provide one complete of all applicable items noted below. Warranty Deed Survey — Provide a copy of a survey from both before and after the improvements when the building footprint(s) has changed. Site Plan, Exterior Elevations, Floor Plans —As approved by the HPB. Attachment Sheets—When necessary. . Photographs (Labeled) — Provide a before and after photo of each exterior elevation, all new construction, and all interior improvements. Each page should contain a before and after photo of the same item; provide a corresponding description of the photos and the improvements. Photographs are not returnable. Polaroid photographs are not acceptable. Such documentation is necessary for evaluation of the effect of the improvements on the historic structure. Where such documentation is not provided, review and evaluation cannot be completed. This shall result in a recommendation for denial of the request for exemption. NOTE: All features should be identified with the approximate date, a description, and impact of work on existing feature. All pages should include the property address. Most Recent Tax Bill X Applicable Fee, payable to the City of Delray Beach - See cover sheet. ❑ Executed Agent Authorization Form 5. 12 PART FIVE: APPLICATION REVIEW For Historic Preservation Planner Use Only. The Historic Preservation Planner has reviewed the Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application for the subject property and hereby: ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property qualifies as a historic property consistent with the provisions of s. 196.1997 (11), F.S. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property does not qualify as a historic property consistent with the provisions of s. 196.1997 (11), F.S. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property qualifies for the special exemption provided under s._196.1998, F.S., for properties occupied by non-profit organizations or government agencies and regularly open to the public. ( ) Certifies that the above referenced property does not qualify for the special exemption provided under s.196.1998, F.S. The Historic Preservation Planner has reviewed the Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application for the subject property and hereby: ( ) Determines that improvements to the above referenced property are consistent with the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, and the criteria set forth in Chapter 1A-38, F.A.C. ( ) Determines that improvements to the above referenced property are not consistent with the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, and the criteria set forth in Chapter 1A-38, F.A.C. All work not consistent with the referenced Standards, Guidelines and criteria are identified in the Review Comments. Recommendations to assist the applicant in bringing the proposed work into compliance with the referenced Standards. Guidelines and criteria are provided in the Review Comments. The Historic Preservation Planner has reviewed the Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application for the subject property and hereby: ( ) Determines that the completed improvements to the property are consistent with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, and other criteria set forth in Chapter 1A-38, F.A.C., and, therefore, recommends approval of the requested historic_preservation tax exemption. ( ) Determines that the completed improvements to the above referenced property are not consistent with the Secretary of the Interiors Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, and other criteria set forth in Chapter 1A-38, F.A.C., and, therefore, recommends denial of the requested historic preservation tax exemption for the reasons stated in the Review Comments below. Review Comments: Signature Typed or printed name Title 6 9 PART SIX: OWNER ATTESTATION I hereby attest that the information I have provided is, to the best of my knowledge, correct, and that I own the property described above or that I am legally the authority in charge of the property. Further, by submission of this Application, I agree to allow access to the property by the Historic Preservation Planner of the City of Delray Beach, Planning and Zoning Department. and appropriate representatives of the local government from which the exemption is being requested, for the purpose of verification of information provided in this Application. I also understand that, if the requested exemption is granted, I will be required to enter into a Covenant with the local government granting the exemption in which I must agree to maintain the character of the property and the qualifying i rov ents for the term of the exemption. Daniel Sloan, for Daniel & Donna Sloan 4/ Z10/01/18 Name Sign/Lire Date Complete the following if signing for an organization or multiple owners: Title Organization name I hereby apply for the historic preservation property tax exemption for the restoration, rehabilitation or renovation work as approved by the Historic Preservation Board. I attest that the information provided is, to the best of my knowledge, correct, and that in my opinion the completed project conforms to The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, and is consistent with the work approved by the Historic Preservation Board. I also attest that I am the owner of the property described above or, if the property is not owned by an individual, that I am the duly authorized representative of the owner. Further, by submission of this Application, I agree to allow access to the property by Historic Preservation Planner of the City of Delray Beach, Planning and Zoning Department, where such office exists, and appropriate representatives of the local government from which the exemption is being requested, for the purpose of verification of information provided in the Application and this Request. I understand that, if the requested exemption is granted, I will be required to enter into a Covenant with the local government granting the exemption in which I must agree to maintain the character of the property and the qualifying improvements for the term of the exemption. I also understand that falsification of factual representations in this Application or Request is subject to criminal sanctions pursuant to the Laws of Florida. Daniel Sloan. for Daniel & Donna Sloan 10/01/18 Name Signature Date Complete the following if signing for an organization or multiple owners: Title Organization name 7: 12 • RECEIVED BY OCT 22 mig PART SEVEN: OWNER'S CONSENT AND DESIGNATION OF A EN form must be completed b ALL roe owners �1 Y of Delray Beach (ThisP Y property hY Development Services Dept. Planning&Zoning Div. I, Donnamarie M. Sloan, the fee simple owner(jointly with Daniel Sloan) of the following es (Owner's Name) property (give legal description): Sloan Residence, 106 SE 7th Ave., Delray BeachJL. 33483 a/k/a Unit#1 Sloan Hammock, a Land Condominium , Delray Beach, FL as recorded in PB 12283 , Page 841, Public Records of Palm Beach Co., FL, hereby petition to the City of Delray Beach for approval of a Tax Exemption Application for the property located at 106 SE 7th Ave., Delray Beach, FL. 33483 and affirm that Dan Sloan, Architect of Record &Joint Owner is hereby designated (Applicants/Agent's Name) to act as agent on my behalf to accomplish the above. I certify that I have examined the application and that all statements and diagrams submitted are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge. Further, I understand that this application, attachments and fees become part of the Official Records of the City of Delray BeacH, Florida, and are not returnable. J.J/ ��',,, f,•� (Owner's Signatu ), The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this %Th , day of L%L--!—J r • 20 tX by 13 t�/ ;1,-;/2 (`,c , who is personally known to me or has produced t' ' (type of identification) as identification and wild-did take an oath. (Printed Name of Notary Public (Signature of Notary Publics Commission # C/ `� ? C , My Commission Expires ( %' -� (NOTARY'S SEAL .4,1 E.Darty NOTARY PUSUC a -STATE OF FLORIDA Demme."FF995974 8 14 'ltt t4S' Ex lr'i N17/2020 &CEI o v ciB PART SEVEN: OWNER'S CONSENT AND DESIGNATION OF AGEN Y CT422 (This form must be completed by ALL property owners) QekeeitYof Z0/8 o De1r I, Daniel Sloan, the fee simple owner(jointly with Donnamarle Sloan) of the following descranp 9e4 on/ces O (Owner's Name) /19 r, ept. property (give legal description): Sloan Residence, 106 SE 7th Ave., Delrav Beach, FL. 33483 a/1Ja Unit#1 Sloan Hammock, a Land Condominium , Delrav Beach FL as recorded in PB 12283 , Pale 841 Public Records of Palm Beach Co., FL, hereby petition to the City of Delray Beach for approval of a Tax Exemption Application for the property located at 106 SE 7th Ave.,Delray Beach, FL. 33483 and affirm that Dan Sloan, Architect of Record & Joint Owner is hereby designated (Applicants/Agent's Name) to act as agent on my behalf to accomplish the above. I certify that I have examined the application and that all statements and diagrams submitted are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge. Further, I understand that this application, attachments and fees become part of the Official Records of the City of Delray Beach, Florida. and are not returnable. / ' ' ///L---- I. /7 (Owner's Signature) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this / 2' , day of =--'- , 20 / D by Lbw 1 SI®a^k , who is personally known to me or has produced 1 u r:C1 0-- L.2 L-r (type of identification) as identification and wh did take an oath. -J 1 \:\ (..--c--L., ----: --.- .'.3 t---4---, , / ..J.A-L.,, e: -A-----,•-\--- (Printed Name of Notary Public)} (Signature of Notary Public) '-'--) Commission # r F`/ \Lily , My Commission Expires I " -- (NOTARY'S SEAL) ,s1cer , NrisryE.amity 4 NOTARY PUBLIC 'k> E STATE OF FLORIDA y^,:, `Caron=FF995974 '''''Itle ExpJrt;a 6/9 Y/2020 9;' 14 • City of Delray Beach Florida 100 NW 1ST AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33444 CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY/CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION Application Number. . . . 17-00167664 000 000 CO Issue Date 9/24/18 Parcel Number 12 43 46 16 D7 000 0010 Property Address . . . 106 SE 7TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 Subdivision Name . . . . SLOAN HAMMOCK LAND COND Legal Description . . . SLOAN HAMMOCK LAND COND LAND UNIT 1 MARINA HISTORIC DISTRICT Property Zoning UNKNOWN Owner SLOAN DANIEL & MARIE 106 SE 7TH AVE DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-5243 Contractor CONCH CUSTOM HOMES INC Description of Work . . ADDITION - SINGLE FAMILY Valuation $ 141, 675 Construction Type . . . UNKNOWN Occupancy Type RESIDENTIAL Flood Zone WN Building Code Edition . (7k S O3C: 1994, 1997, 2001, 2004, 2007, 2010Zi NOTES: CONSTRUCT ADDITION TO SINGLE FAMILY: ADDITION OF 1ST FLOOR LIBRARY, 2ND FLOOR MASTER SUITE uplift test ok 04 .24 .18 pe CODE VER: FEC 2014 THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH ENCOURAGES THE USE OF ENERGY STAR PRODUCTS. Building Official . . . . . . . Steve Tobias, VOID UNLESS SIGNED BY BUILDING OFFICIAL OR DESIGNEE RECEIVED BY OCT 22 2018 City of Delray Beach Development Services Dept. Planning&Zoning Div. The described portion of the structure has been inspected for compliance with the requirements of the code for the occupancy and division of occupancy and the use for which the proposed occupancy is classified. ADDENDUM "A" To PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION APPLICATION for 106 SE 7th Ave., Delray Beach, FL. Dated 10/1/2018 Description of PhvsicaI Appearance Prior to Improvements: <Provide information about the major exterior and interior features of the building. Describe the building in its existing condition (before improvement) —not as it was when first built(unless unchanged) or as it will be after improvement. Note the architectural style, exterior construction materials (wood, brick, etc.), type of roof(flat, gable, hipped, etc.), number of stories, basic plan (rectangular, irregular, L-shaped, etc.), and distinguishing architectural features (placement and type of windows, chimneys, porches, decorative interior features or spaces). Describe any changes that have been made to the building since its original construction (i.e., additions, porch enclosures, new storefronts, relocation of doors and windows, and alterations to the interior). Other buildings on the property such as carriage houses, barns and sheds should also be described. Finally, discuss the way in which the building relates to others in the district in terms of siting,scale, material,construction,and date of construction.> A BRIEF DESCRIPTION and HISTORY of The SLOAN RESIDENCE 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida, Updated /06.06 File: History.SloanRes.COA.doc A. HISTORY of the RESIDENCE This Contributing Residence was constructed in 1924 and is one of the oldest residences in the Marina Historic District. No specific information about the original owner or builder was able to be found. The Architectural Style of the building is the Mission Style,which was rooted in the American West and Southwest and was a very popular 1920's boom Design. All of the historic districts in the city of Delray Beach have examples of this style. The one story building had an elongated rectangular plan. The Exterior Construction Materials included a Flat roof system (tar and gravel) with distinctive curved parapet walls around the perimeter, and a textured Stucco exterior. Frame construction was utilized with a crawl space, decorative roof drain scuppers and downspouts (galvanized and partially rusted out). The distinctive architectural features included: Stucco exterior finishes(which was done by skip trowelling on stucco and then smoothing out slightly with a damp sponge to soften the edges), Curved parapet walls at the roof line, 4/1 and 5/1 Wood double hung windows and 6 light wood casement windows in the rear bedroom,a distinctive masonry fireplace on the north facade,and Terra Cotta Attic Ventilators (rectangular shaped hand made with (6)subdivisions, installed at an angle to keep out rain but allow air to flow into attic). The interior has distinctive features including a concrete fireplace tooled to look like stone, Wood Door and window trim, "Dade County" pine flooring throughout except for the bathrooms,and hand plastered walls. B. DESCRIPTION OF PHYSICAL APPEARANCE (Building Description before 1993-1994 Renovations) Changes made to the original building prior to the Sloan's purchase of the property in 1992 include a front porch and one car garage which were added in the 1950's, the front porch windows were replaced with crude wood slats and the porch door and garage doors were replaced with inexpensive store bought wood "Barn" doors. One of the dining room windows was replaced with an aluminum awning window. Certain windows had been so weather damaged that they were boarded up. Interior alterations included: removing the original claw foot cast iron tub(and burying it in the back yard)and replacing it with a very inexpensive steel tub with stick on vinyl tiles as a shower surround. The Exterior walls and wood windows show extensive termite damage, which needed to he repaired. A secondary (not to code) bathroom had been added to the rear of the house in the 60's. This bathroom has an incongruous shed roof and board and batten siding. 10 12 Addendum "A"to the Tax Abatement Application for the Sloan Residence Addition PAGE 2 of 2 A BRIEF DESCRIPTION and HISTORY of The SLOAN RESIDENCE 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida, Updated 4'06i06 File: History.SloanRes.COA.doc C. DESCRIPTION OF 1993-1994 RENOVATIONS (This work was designed and constructed by Dan & Donna Sloan) This work encompassed removing all rotted perimeter and interior bearing stud walls and reframing same with new 2x4 Pressure Treated Wood Stud walls. As part of this work new foundations were installed for each bearing element. This painstaking work was accomplished in 8' segments as the old structure had to be carefully braced prior to removal of rotted wood wall segments. At the same time all floor joists, ceiling joists. and roof rafters were either replaced or new 2x pressure treated members were "sistered" to the side of each and every member. Again. very slow process. Next custom made wood windows 4/1 or 5/1 light pattern with traditional narrow mullions were installed with "Florida" style exterior brickmold to match the original windows. Exterior wood French doors were then installed Subsequently, all mechanical, electrical, and plumbing system components were 100% replaced and the structure was insulated.Next all walls received blue board and a very textured layer of plaster except for kitchen, bath.and ceilings, which were finished smooth. As all of the old doors were missing from the home (not one room had a interior door) salvaged doors from the Pennsylvania Hotel in West Palm Beach were located. These 1926 doors were of varying sizes, but similar raised panel styles with crystal mortise set locksets. A custom doorframe was built for each door and each door opening was in turn built to accommodate the particular door assembly. Interior door and window trim was installed replicating the style prevalent at the time and based on samples found in the home. Cabinetry was then installed, final mechanical, electrical, and plumbing system components installed. Then floor finishes and painting and staining was completed. 11 12 ADDENDUM "B" To PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION APPLICATION for 106 SE 7th Ave., Delray Beach, FL. Dated 10/1/2018 Statement of Significance: <Summarize how the building contributes to the significance of the district. This summary should relate to the significance of the district (including the district's period of significance) as identified in the National Register nomination or district designation documentation. Is it similar to other buildings in the district in scale, building materials, style, and period of construction? Note important persons from the past associated with the building, former uses of the property,and the name of the architect or builder, if known.> This Home was completely renovated in 1995-6 with the goal acting as the Architectural Centerpiece of the of the "Sloan Hammock" project (106 to 114 SE 7`h Ave). The intent was to create a complex that utilized a historical structure as the focal point and incorporates a modem interpretation of Florida Vernacular Architecture in the new and renovated surrounding structures. This created an intimate development that retained the old Florida charm in a modem day setting. The pubic spaces of the property and accompanying gardens are one of the most intimate and charming in Delray Beach today and the historic home is a key feature. The single family house that forms the focal point of the project was constructed in 1924-5 on a 50'x135' lot and was designed in the Mission Style of Architecture. We restored this structure to it's original character and constructed a garage home office outbuilding of compatible architectural style to the rear of the residence. An intimate landscaped courtyard was created between the two structures. Through the years numerous additions and modifications were made to this property. The most unsightly was the broken asphault and concrete paving of most of the front yard and side yards. As part of the restoration the paving was completely removed and restored to landscaped areas. The new garage& parking area off the alley provided the necessary parking capacity and would utilized the existing paved alley for access. Because of the location of the historic residence on the site space is at a premium. Therefore, the construction of the garage required a variance form the RM setback requirements. This project falls under the RM Development standards due to City Staffs requirement that the three lots be combined in order to develop the site as a unified project. The lot was originally developed under the R1A Development Standards which are more appropriate for this historic district. This historical residence is similar to other Mission Style homes in the Marina Historic District built slightly later. Several of these Mission Style homes are 2 story with a Barrel Tile Mansard Decorative Elements, a mixture of Single Hung and Casement Windows, and other typical Mission Style design elements. They all have Stucco Wall Finishes of varying textures. If interest is the fact that a famous local architect, Samuel Ogren, Sr., drew up plans to reconfigure the home (which were never realized). These plans are the only drawings or records we have found in the Delray Beach Historical Society Archives or City Building Dept. Records to date. The name of the original builder and architect are lost to history. 12 12 Jan-31-2881 l2:®lpt 01-4337( 67 " �--�.� ORB 12283 Pg t3.4.2. Can 18.09 Doc 8.?e Return to: LISTICK & KRALL, P.A. •,' 616 E. Atlantic Avenue Delray Beach, FL 33483 a Q(. ; v This instrument prepared by: :j HARK L. KRALL ESQ. C t 'I i. n LZSPICK & KRALL, P.A. YOi`Qu���v ;iey_..� 6l6 B. Atlantic Avenue Plarinjn - --,, f Delray Beach, FL 33483 ("ZOfTlf1CQ r • 4\ Quit- 1aim Derd THIS�, -\ DEED, executed this Jam— day of 'N- ,A.D. , 2001, by H STO& PARTNERS, a Florida General Partnership, whose address is 106 S.E. 7t1 ue, Delray Beach, FL. 33483, first party, to DANIEL SLOAN ::., and DONNA MA. r-/SL�AN, his wife, whose post office address is 106 S.E. 7th r I- Avenue, Delra ia^, FL. 33483, second party: a �' 1 '' WITNESSETH \t the said first party, for and in consideration of the li ,, sum of TEN and /101-0- - - ($10.00) DOLLARS, in hand paid by the '= V' said second party :* receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, does hereby `i remise, release an� claim unto the said second party forever, all the right, title, inter tfr claim and demand which the said first party has in and to the followin es ribed lot, piece or parcel of land, situate, lying �; and being in the Count Palm Beach, State of Florida, to wit: c. Unit 1, of SLOAN CK, a land Condominium, according to the di Declaration of Coidd�) ium thereof, as recorded in Official �4 Records Book 9271, x 8, of the Public Records of Palm Beach a County, Florida, said being located within the boundaries of: 4,1 '` Lot 2, Block 118, o thehhe Plat of Delray Beach, f/k/a Town of c Linton, according to the,-R thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 1, .,1 Page 3, and on the Plat onkling & Thorndyke (a resubdivision of Block 118) according t the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 4 2, Page 8, both of the • c Records of Palm Beach County, r Florida. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the sg. together with all and singular the x. appurtenances thereto belonging o�izi anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, liKrxr-1 ity and claim whatsoever of the said first party, either in law or e. �, ', Gto the only proper use, benefit rt and behalf of the said second party fo. e�y IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said firs a has signed and sealed these + presents the day and year first above wri,., L Signed, sealed and delivered ��l in our presence: HISTORI���`'t S, a Florida general part ershi .. Cep` . By: (SEAL) Witnea signature Da to `General Partner SINCE THE Pt1R2QF THE GRANTOR PARTNERSHIP Printed m of witness ARE THE SAME H� GRANTEE'S, MItGIMAL DOCUMENTARY STAMPS ARE ATTA� ` L: ; . ... . • ORB 1 aa83 Pg 434-a O DORO1HY H. UILKJN, CLERH R8 COUNTY, FL % / V witness to e� 'C�- , • [JI�� `i� Printed name of witness , � � STATE OF FLOR COUNTY OF PP T. .EACH •": The foreg 'ng � . trument was acknowledged before me this day of , PARTmrl, =� 2001, by DANIEL SLOAN, the General Partner of HISTORIC NERS, a • C general partnership, who is personally known to me or who has produ Florida driver's license as identification and who did take an oath. qlp Ze.. 0 u;IWW No Print ame M• �e� L:. #CQ¢ LL Y.,+ e NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDA 4 F. Serial No. -: . k ' ;') My commisson,expires: za O vc z � o , ..L 1 ,. ..„,. .:.: 4i (i-(7 %> ,,, til e . .,,, 2018 NOTICE OF PROPOSED PROPERTY TAXES AND PROPOSED OR ADOPTED NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS Full Parcel ID. 12-43-46-16-D7-000-0010 DO NOT PAY HEARINGS taxing authorities which levy taxes against your property will soon hold PUBLIC Legal D Eacription: HEARINGS to adopt budgets and tax rates for the next year.The purpose of these SLOAN HAMMOCK LAND COND LAND UNIT 1 THIS IS NOT PUBLIC HEARINGS is to receive opinions from the general public and to answer questions on the proposed tax change and budget PRIOR TO TAKING FINAL ACTION. A BILL Each taxing authority may AMEND or ALTER its proposals at the hearing. COLUMN 1 • COLUMN2 COLUMN 3 Taxing Authority Your Property Taxes,Last Year Your'Taxes This Year Your Taxes This Year A public hearing on the proposed Dependent Special Districts ', • • If proposed budget change Is made if no bud$et change is made taxes and budget will be held at Taxable Value Minute Rate Tax Amount Taxable Value Millaqe Rate Tax Amount Taxable Value Millaqe Rate Tax Amount the locations and dates below COUNTY 6-- 4.7815 1,172.71 251,460 • 4.7815 -1,202.36 251,460 4.5537 1,145.07 9/04 6:00 PM 561 355.3996 County Operating � T-�245,260 ( � ) County Debt 245,260 .1208 29.63 251,460 1165 29.30 251,46C 1165 29.30 301 N Olive Ave 6th Fl WPB 33401 PUBLIC SCHOOLS _ By State Law _ - 270,260' - 4 2710 1,154.28 - 276,460 4.074G 1,126.30 276,460r 4.0883 1,130.25 9/05 5:05 PM(561)434-8837 By Local Board 270,260 2.4980 675.11 276,460 2.4980 690.60 276,460 2.3911 661.04 3300 Forest Hill Blvd WPB 33406 MUNICIPALITY . _ _ Delray Beach Operating 245,260 6.8611 1,682.75 251,460 _6.7611. _ 1,700.15 251,46C 6.5482 1,646.61 9/066:00PM(561)243-7128 Delray Beach Debt 245,260 228E. 56.14 251,460 .2108 53.01 251,46G 2108 53.01 100 NW First Ave Delray Beach 33444 INDEPENDENT SPECIAL DISTRICTS So.Fla.Water Mgmt Basin 245,260 .1384 33.94 251,460 1310 32.94 251,46G 1310 32.94 9/13 5:15 PM(561)686-8800 .120930.40 251,46C So.Fla.Water Mgmt. Dist 245,260 .1275 31.27 251,460 .1209 30.40 3301 Gun Club Rd WPB 33406 Everglades Construction - 245,260 • .0441 10.82 251,460 .0417 10.49 251,46C 0417 10.49 Fl. Inland Navigation District 245,260 .0320 7.85 251,460 .032C 8.05 251,46C 0302 7.59 9/06 5:30 PM(561)627.3386 190 E 13th St Riviera Bch FL 334C4 Children's Services Council 245,260 .6590 161.63 251,460 .6403 161.01 251,460 .6266 157 56 9/07 5:01 PM(561)740-7000 2300 NighRidgeRdByntnE3ch33426 Health Care District 245,260 .7808 191.5C 251,460 .7400 186.08 251,460 7424 186 68 9/11 5:15 PM(561)659-1270 _ 600 Okeechobee Blvd.WB F P L 33401 20 5431 5,207.63111PM 20.1478 5.230.69 1111111111. 19 6014 5,090 94 SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR EXPLANATION NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENT LEVYING AUTHORITY PURPOSE OF ASSESSMENT UNITS RATE ASSESSMENT CONTACT INFO. SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY OF PBC GARBAGE SERVICES 1 181.0C 181.00 (561)697-2700 CITY OF DEL RAY BEACH STORMWATER ASSESSMENT 1 62.68 62.68 (561)243-7298 • Total Nar1-At4VotoremAtasessrrient :�43.68 _R■ VALUCT�FORMATIOh! Market Last Year j2017) This Year(2018) Market(also called"Just')value is the most probable If you feel that the market value of your property is inaccurate sale price for your property in a competitive,open or does not reflect fair market value, or you are entitled to an Value 478,000 478,000 market on Jan. 1,2018. It is based on a willing • buyer and a wiling seller. exemption or classification that is not reflected above, contact your County Property Appraiser at the numbers listed on the Taxing Authority , Assessed Value Exemptions Taxable Value reverse side of this page. , Last Year This Year Last Year This Year Last Year 1 This Year County Operating 295,26C 301 460 50,000 50,000 245,260, 251,460 If the Property Appraiser's office is unable to resolve the matter County Debt 295,26C 301.460 50,000 50,000• 245,260 251,46D as to market value, classification, or an exemption, you may file Public Schools 295,26C 301,460 25,000 25,000 270,260 276,460 a petition for adjustment with the Value Adjustment Board. Municipality Operating 295,26C 301,460, 50,000 50,000 245,260 251,460 Petition forms are available from the County Property Appraiser's Municipality Debt 295,26C 301,460 50,000 50,000 245,260 251,460, office. Your petition must be filed with the Clerk of Value Independent Special Dists 295,26C 301,460, 50,000 50,000 245,260 251,460 Adjustment Board on or before: 5:00 PM September 14,2018 at 301 N Olive Ave, West Palm Beach, FL 33401. Assessed Value is the Exemptions are specific Taxable Value is the value market value minus dollar or percentage used to calculate the tax any assessment amounts that reduce due on your property reductions. your assessed value. (Assessed Value minus ' Exemptions). Assessment Reductions Applies To Value Save our Homes Assessment Cap-2.1 percent in 2018 All Taxing Authorities 176,540 rn am- Q M - Properties can receive an assessment reduction for a number of reasons including the Save our Homes Benefit and the 10% a Z - non-homestead property assessment limitation. -:- a.a...,„. w d�O0 =- w , . _ . , . , Q rn = o Exemptions Applied Applies To Exempt Value ( ra = = Homestead All Taxing Authorities 25,000 F. W O Q .. A c Additional Homestead Non-School Taxing Authorities 25,000 rn O fZWa - a w C_ . 0LJ a°-Q L `- O il- - wT Oar, _ aww,* () rf v a ES re., '� _2 Z ozcf'QO zzw roaawr 0 Z N 9 9 cb,0� Any exemption that impacts your property is listed in this section along with its corresponding exempt value Specific dollar or ^ Z _ w co.- percentage reductions in assessed value may be applicable to a property based upon certain qualifications of the property or c7 property owner.In some cases, an exemption's value may vary depending on the taxing authority.The tax impact of an exempt o value may also vary for the same taxing authority,depending on the levy(i.e.,operating millage vs debt service millage). cad 450586 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, FL , Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 10/01/18 COA#2016-139& Building Permit# 17-000167664 . . byi w. ,f �1. -'�•,0 Jr -‘.4‘ V :*. * \ ye• e. 11111 ai i R r ev 0. , — - �' h . { j , r '+ .. ar► A.,,t , I Elevation "A-A.3" (South Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 1 of 8 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach.FL. Preconst Photos 2/29/06,Post Construction Photos 10/01/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 ' F '. j.l �� ~ " fit A 5tret :41Ii• i *, ilk. .. '-ir iptir it ,s.- .,.0,400 -4guir, '- ‘i , it :. =,/ 1-- ''' -- - .,i t , ajir I -r awr/'l" - #ia x j Awnings are Not Yet Installed. SA Estimated Installation Date Is 10/15/2018 tea. f i Elevation "A-A.3" (South Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 5 of 8 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue,Delray Beach, FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 10/01/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 4 Qom, 77 1 1• ' ♦ . 'r , l � - . 4 .. ,! ,,.. .. „4„.„.„_. : • ••••• ,„... .. " , t -,,,,,,,,, .,. .. ,,_.....„ ., , , _ „.. :,- , 1 .- " ,.. . ,. . , , ....,.. _ , .. , . . iFit - ,`,' , - - _ \II\,-: ~ - ,, Af.lit-"- �a ors Elevation "B-A.3" (North Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 2 of 8 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 10/0 1/18 COA#2016-139 & Building Permit# 17-000167664 .e ! f i/ p " f (j 1 l_ •f . t j % '.itpiraki, t ion 1 7 . Af 011 ., 41 ill' iz ...• • ,,,, . -.4.* 1 a 1 i „lima p..... -. ( ' •-:,. ' ,1 XL. 1,..i , . iiii, A • - -. __ , �► x rill `µ Important Nate:Awnings are Not Yet installed. Estimated Installation Date is 10/15/2018 _, „ 1 `� Elevation "B-A.3" (North Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 6 of 8 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 10/01/18 COA#2016-139& Building Permit# 1 7-000 1 67664 •. 1 le kt '• ,_ • _ a air etp._ _ alMith' — - it_ fo, . ... • { L • ..f •. • w J h. {t w t Y ' 't • r , �+ • ~:1• ? 910 / r git %," 0:.'. 1' _ - . - % .t... • /- n $ - - A� 1 - i .1, 4 ; t 014 i i i I i Ai s ' ik, Imatlls■t Net- Awnings are Not Yet Installed. Estimated Installation Date is 10/15/2018 Elevation "C-A.4" (East Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 7 of 8 1 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 & Building Permit# 17-000167664 iltitl ,-- k-_,. 1,,,,, , ji ,.. . 4,..._. ,.._.. ). ,;-. •., ','.PT-. Iltk,., . 4.1t.,. „.,.:7. '''' j" -..'1.‘ 444::11:4W-Ae— ''' 7i.;::-i'l - , -i, , ', .11, i - _ .-* - .( 7 a ^: 0 Mf ',i�y '', r'i� i, 4— -__ , , �,u '',, 1 �� .k.,�� a .si` 1 A > •� il+_ _ _ .,A..-,.„, _.,.,._ t __ __ _ tee` \� nn�nn-,nnnnnnnnnr,nna�,nnne n _ Elevation "A-A.3" (South Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 1 of 11 t Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL,Preconst Photos 2/29/06,Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 \a I iiktt q4. �, Z act.,;•.- _'Y � ;%;-..L4-- ''-''','r 4 , , _, ,., , , ,,,,,.. " ,,, ,,,, ,'il '' ,rwir- . rt. * . , • 1 .,...-,:,,„ „.• ,,,,, ,,, .., , 1 i^ , ii IIf t ---,---____,_ 1i - �- - 1 . yj' " Elevation "B-A.3" (North Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 2 of 11 I Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach, FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 & Building Permit# 17-000167664 i . -, , -4iii1 g,zd: ),'' j �' `i. ' ids ' 2 , ,• "r', .+apt + t"i . � „I,lJ ii t_ifi i•-,,A\i,i 1_-m„_.;_.*-.34,,,•,.it.1__.,;..::,..,w,'t, ,,\,:-,.' r ,veg;f.`li t!,., i4---,,,..,. Fr. ,,, , ,, , , ..... ,' i,;i ,,_',,_,_,_,,,.,,,.,,,.,•„,..,,,, ,i .. ,� 1 l' :i 4pyup a; 3 --ti _ ., , A 0'0\ ,1,:., NA ';'," itiY\ R ? + a i t _3. '' _ _ -- " Elevation "C-A.4" (East Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 3 of 11 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 T t f ".+111, tea r • � ,! — \� —\ f - '', ,. x ?tA IHI i7 \k\ tr� _ �� !l j 1 1 , j 1 , ,i Elevation "D-A.4" (West Elevation: Residence :: Pre-Construction) Page 4 of 11 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL,Preconst Photos 2/29/06,Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 Alt 'k- -- ' • - __ • ‘ !Ar.,, • . ,' , i t + d - /ai.+: 'Fly + ,t ' f , Ilk, 1- ',4 t' --t-% 4- • t sil - #t- sa,. Ir. ..,,_.. „..,-;31. .i--4,..- , ,., ,. u ,.. ,. I. ' ,) It ` ANS ! t* y . Y .. . � ; AtESL f I. r T y I. •w -774#-- Elevation "A-A.3" (South Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 5 of 11 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue,Delray Beach,FL,Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 IIN't‘ it ' ;I:ii.'111 1/(///. . ' ' • > . • . - y i i f :P... i ;ii, :lei's: t '`hi{ , s , :,r,A w +s o�1 %an A T -mom v. r 2.Si.. _ ., _ _ _ OW s. i M sr. -ice k' - _y .. ei'.. - \:- , . i iii,,„ .' Ye t Qf I.. r '`_ �4,t .. I- — _Ilf Important Note Keystone Column Covers a wall cap are Not Yet Installed.Estimated Installation Date is 11/30/2018 s . Elevation "A-A.3" (South Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 6 of 11 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 &Building Permit# 17-000167664 il «7 . . . ..,. 7 p • . t : / • t I a' ; t • 6 f f t /44.- • 1 ' �rhipj''y 4 i �2 f `1 ,it v - Nies" 0: ,- . , ...., . , , , . , , • ' 1r1 t • - f • . a%,� 4 <�. i ill4"6" ''''''.' __,,.. -," -,..4, • 4.�11 Ill • t v _ .' - S E0 Ar e- 42� 3_. iiiirvi ...., ....4 ailk: i . ilk i ill e. ...., , . , \,1�dlrow! � : "��� 11/11 ra N• �' r :i Eli ii. :+f _ : . t4I I, ip\ ill 1 t i 1 47q \l 10" f 1 tom . Elevation "B-A.3" (North Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 7 of 11 I Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL,Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 &Building Permit# 17-000167664 r, �> _r yam, „�, �� \ ;` .�. • �• / i i • .'21‘'0118::04,, A ' PIP' 4 ' ,IS , %. \ .4 +4 , , . - -, , __ i ,.., A Ok ,,,, -°.A. 1'`t IVt • _ �! f 2 -40 "' *.1 �` 111 � _ IV s ;aft E- _ .%.I"' , ` ' =;a.%r_,• 1J.o t , : - - - ' Y�u 111111 EEr a 1!' " , A. i . F Wilt F �� `_` ,i`• • 41 .� 3. , �1 ii. ,,.*,,., -74, ' '//fir --='. .,_ .1,-.,, ' k, ,9.,- - ;›, ' iiii� r 0 11 .+. 1 Elevation "B-A.3" (North Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 8 of 11 P Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139&Building Permit# 17-000167664 t*211 • 7 'IOW f, rP" . i ' I i , t ' - — '� ,ter. '� 4 4 J ti '`� * !f 1r + 04`1. ` , \ 1 •. , ,, ,- . ........., , - t Mom: a .it, -, ' 4' . ' 1 , ',Yy „. , ry^N �: .� s ' ,,,m . k:, ,.. , , . ... .. 4,„,. ,: 'r. 0 ey .. - _ il': ,,,-; 111;) Y he*IS-. Elevation "C-A.4" (East Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 9 of 11 Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06, Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 &Building Permit# 17-000167664 . ti . i 4SZ: A . ,r; ) y bt• x' r• y , F`,, ..i ,........ I i . it- a 4 dj . . f 4. rirf ilk tok_r - i P a y *� a •14. • idai ::_rob: ,, IN I „. ,,,,,, . _ _ or 41, si . .! l 1 f M. ' • , .,�. i, I '' -- F ' Ww, -- 1.4 4 it.,,..._ . ‘, ' L y . . ..4 pi 1 ,. 7.„ 2 Elevation "C-A.4" (East Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 10 of 11 r Photo Documentation for Tax Abatement Application for Sloan Residence Renovations & 2nd Story Addition Prepared by Dan Sloan, 106 SE 7th Avenue, Delray Beach,FL, Preconst Photos 2/29/06,Post Construction Photos 11/11/18 COA#2016-139 &Building Permit# 17-000167664 , t . ' 1 • 1 . lif 't • . I"t .C • +!` :fit , et ,-, -: *- it / 4,..tei ,... l4 , ,r AIL , ifit 1 , T. A, - - r ' ' Tsf ♦ 4 l 1 _ , ..,;,: litri‘ 311:..! ' '14).,1 "� r 0 Oil 9 2).., ' 1 Elevation "D-A.4" (West Elevation: Residence :: Post-Construction) Page 11 of 11 The tVerL Shown in these Plans Shall Comply with the 2014 Ronda Budding Code w/any Amendments and(asapphca5lrt the same version or the Florida Mana echcaL Eleclneal. Plumbing,and F.usung Building t',deist Framing and Other structural Details will also comply phy with ICC-00(Previously S51D 15.aa1. SLOAN RESIDENCE 5A N • MASTER SUITE ADDITION -411 vv _;= SLOAN e. E e^ .: N Li ' � 106 SE Seventh Avenue, Slam„....e,c Delray Beach, Florida 33483 ' yFadiF Delray IkadL FL 1101,12,23aAR5.5— AA2F1m:2E8 MEP ENGINEER: ARCHITECT: INTERIOR DESIGNER: • BEACON CONSULTING ENGINEERS,INC. SLOAN&SLOAN,INC: SLOAN&SLOAN,INC.- Day. appr Rensmn No. Mr.Joeven Valenzuela,PE ARCHITECTS&INT.DESIGNERS ARCHITECTS&INT.DESIGNERS , 4/c/1c ISSCLD FOR QCNSIRR'nON 100 NE 6th Street;Ste.102 Dan Sloan,Project Mgr. Donna Sloan,Project Mgr. 2 6/30/17 .-n -:^,,nR. ,= T.FRL from CZ to 1F g l g Adt l ice},shin 2.1 Fluor Floor Boynton Beach,FL.33434 106 SE 7th Ave.,Ste.B 106 SE 7th Ave.,Ste.B 'c*I Knee Wall, Add NotC3 (561)424-3270,.ii(MB7vt3964 Delray Beach,FL 33483 Delray Beach,FL 33483 email: (561)243-8755 (561)243-8755 PE#60287 email:dan@sloandesign.biz email:donna(gisloandesign.biz AR 95577&AA26002208 ID 0002527 • OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATION: APPLICABLE CODES: COPYRIGHT NOTICE GROUP RM-MEDIUM DENSITY MULTI FANIILY RESIDENTIAL 2014 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE �..:`s ,S 2014 FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE -Yr "= �wt`�1v` TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION: 2014 FLORIDA ELECTRICAL CODE TYPE V-Unprotected/Lnsprinkled 2014 FLORIDA PLUMBING CODE (Existing 1 Single Family Residential Structure 2014 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE CO In S-"1 U O a-^ to become 2 Story Structure) 2008 ICC 600-STD.FOR RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION IN HIGH WIND AREAS ! Q >-,Q Shan Residence Addiliem&RerosatioN Coo •— r �-' se n6 Mxm¢Delray E..h a .. .r O.�N Desi n Parameters ag; d Rio LIST OF DRAWINGS Ln c3 Design /-Ule D Rh.etL.�New Ahl.Saila_ad FL......MO Coau SE ndl Net SF lb ...:Mote.....Medium Devsg':RA .Arlo a as re Whoa Ms ,rol n/re- I w I. , Tina Luton. 0 cr I so,..ra,nn,l�.e-- Ao Ceee.SMt w/CA um.tans... Dr..List slags.Fame,.NhMamE,.mm.ersut =x cc Lin. .-GTE ALG m Foe skeane seame miming root ewe a¢u ~ a..1.1nsu5050,11 4201 UISNOL:Rat Fl<er flan SEWN.Or ft.Cat..000(3.w.e. EXvOswE[axOrTlaM: A2n1 MEW One Owe Pon wan Door a whin SONS..:Generator.. A2026 NEW Ent..MUM Fan Floor Mao sar.9 Ea.re2 TldlOe2.i.61Ar.,nd.ma ALV2 new nisi Om mime Pon a...¢. 3 MEW GOOF MIGHT(tm.wsernon) ff ALOE law se*Mow rho N adage General Noss ermined . MEAN ROOF HEIGHT.i,:enne Simons _ AL.second El.PedmaalaAn9 Pon Among Nem codas w/Ca.s.eon slam,eO. No. Date hue Nines 0 .nags Wigan snox.0 Rake Haan..cams.Etc BUILDING HEIGHT:X c or•SU may or MC a .A3A1 OUSTDIC N.M 6 sow enamor SaemwO Ffw.Wmaca.Deorc66m1.r6mua ' A2C2 Emma aura SSS wets 50500 skry ES 3.Nand r.Cows.a E..,Elmleah 102 NOV W.:..M Ea.ewetwmxev 9.w.enr M.o .OmnL 6 Wane,RemgW \ /' s BUILDING DESIGNED AS. rlvam mendd.md ,A32a Remoon Web 155,4C tales istsneed �/ \11 11 1rr�FrLL�---IIIIIL'_ .VAS 1103.1111010.Oa/A..9b,a0. seew.s Callow M n 1 I 1 1 9 d[•v Lis runnel AAO,11.E Elate some-it Lie Brave-. 1 I 1 I g AAC52 tun w.rs null.-nee.,......lo yes snowing W.O.w.ltib.S.ab Y' / \ / slows mumrm Remao-s.m.+ Let Slden.AR477 /m.o..,Pig.ea Fs.v -.r.sart As.) tnnplgOMeue.0SM.,too-on..sm.Na ramO<tt.n Eoma0R...e-3' ' •. RAW xa eu..95.waat ue. dining nr condemn Remus,serum Y DJt[`_ - • - T Iva/vec.n,,e VELOCITY UEECOEFFICIENTS HAVE SEEN D.vurE 46.01 eye OMB.Mlme wet ieml.sr .aerl4 Rrcw.tm.Beal. Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+ID. ENVELOPE mNvoxexTswcuvDlxe AS APPLICABLE. APPLIED TO MAIN WIND FORCE RESISTE.SYSTEM,GT UIL005A mmlw4 A.6sw 05L000DetNA en: 11t6- - SF.7th Avenue,Ste.Ft • .... SIM EP0w96 Nam Faun..Nan 0Nma59 Gem 6 Emory.lmmt.n. - - Delray Bch.FL.33483 (nine Sp.In2D mp5) 53 HIM ltt PI Dena R..rap .s Parisian e5r. ra SMp 1 Red a Panv news F...BASIC VELOCITY PRESSURE: _ NFSF 5261 MENMgum.Sea. near a min Na .•nE mina nem ion.me OW N a al in Roo, new Pe ma (SOU 24��5$ _ 3 ,ut..a and speeammpnl a^•sz.al ...ma Including WIG IMAM.on D.aLwneews not.: ASCE Tx.BASIC VELOCITY PRESSURE. L x ESE Unmoral Dem. .. N0.01 MAC nea.6 Mots NOTE:Actual Dwign All Exterior window.,Dare, MI.woo 5.o.a Fla Fn.FYn-- .+.Laa455as�law .. Garage Doors.a.Similar Envelope Elements Must.e Eo.mrtaw csEzs .E' • x- •- Indicated on Construction Plan.. - Sloan Residence E ernk L. -EL 00002�at ElaGnl Nan Mew dams WO s. MASTER SUITE ADDITION LOCATION MAP:IOPSEith Ave nue,DeIris Bill.,FL. Used'or onu. s e.a.ItAeaeLens. — r wnetelan RI6SE 7th Avenue t 9 rr 1: FSF ELKO MN Sen.uv.a N.rllwsmy/aEF P.n ,a,.rowa. „G.a.. --.. L BEARING 1300 Mn neemWP.d54eA10 a Eger Lind NO.,Talculatic. Scale,,Not T.scale - - .>.,«. .,.,.,. t._ 1.. a --..R. COVER SHEET - - _ w REVIEWED wwsxEAnwuLREQUIREMENTS: Miles N. FLU Lie.sen aMn MIAOWewoo . ',Mon 2 Stier Nm wt.n.nm seam monomeric torn SAHd2N.an..Bests.Sal.,5aav2l2r.s NOTE Geolechnical Report Supporting 29MP5F.oil bearing capacity is ON FILE with 1996 Delray Building Permit D.Sloan Atom Roo Moir.Salo Application/drawing package for 106 SE 7th Ave D.Slate As Nast Cover Sheet --a..,,iaan '--' Ao A0.00 1D13 ,.in.---nu.SteJOID,In.vim Total gags The%Voti Shown in these Mans Shall C'rmrly with the 2O111 Florida Building Code w/any Amendments and(as apnccahlel the same ` of the Florida Ide:hani.al.EI meaL 1'fs..,---ng,and Existing drcCodelsl. F,-,- Ind Other Soo:.-. .a.IS will arse Wall Type Key .,n•. ...-cc edit(p...- •-IT to-w, ® New I Hour Insulated Wall w/5.n25"Mtl.Stud at 24"oc.,2x6 PT sole N plate,R21.Open Cell Spray Foam,and 1/2" Type C GWB each Side. ntn ap w w,L:nNe,t Rout C..k) New Non Bearing Int. Wall w/3.625"Mtl.Stud O • — at 24"or.,2x4 PT sole plate,Sound Batts,and 1/2"GWB each Side. ®New Non Bearing Int. 7'-2" 17'4Y' 8'-6" 3'-6" 4'-6' 4'-9" 9'-0" Wall w/1.625"Mtl.Stud a i } i r _ at 12"oc.,2x2 PT sole - - _- r plate,and 1/2"GWB one ) „ �' Side.(around perimeter j "..4-,,e ill , ___$_ of 8"block wall inboard T A/C :,.,-,Mt:ca of 2"iso insulation board #1 '1 New Interior Bearing r 'I Wall w/2x4 PT Studs at T 16"c.,2x4 PT sole plate _ dale top d I/2"and �{' �• Breakfast u,. ar;. Bata and I/2"GWB 6/�IJI each Side. Guest /Dining ".l Bed ® Living Rm.2 p "� ins t Room Foyer, to I h rez. , i r'1 - Bath 7 Jo Q J Cop]RhilIT NOTICE #1 Bath O Guest —e.-... - 104I Kitchen #1 Bed �" :en.r.."...a.t,...",. I10 1 1 1 :, Ref v 1 ao� -- - 1—_— - »_wr- - ...-- al Existing Concrete IV tr.,- c.nx Patio with 8"x 8" i' Cl. Library I, cv w p perimeter footer x I l ie I 1 I.'1 as 0�'' 0 I27-8" cn U 35'-8" i 18'-4" , No. Cate how Nuus FIRST FLOOR PLAN- EXISTING CONDITIONS ' Scale:1/4"=1'-0" i I i I , `v cel Alvan.4sn5i;77 ��Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+I.D. Itrn SF.7th.Venue,Ste.B Delray Bch,FL33483 (trill 2438755 ra....i" Sloan Residence MASTER SUITE ADDITION 106 SE 7th Avenue "^"" FIRST FLOOR PLAN of Main Residence Existing Conditions; r�e„ First Floor Plan °�" >- Sum�'"n°� A2.01 -,°.5'�" A,Marl — o,i"N A2.01 snnoa ai Sloan Res_Eta I'andun_']dl ,n, TOO Sheer, The 1\Inds Shun n,n these rive Shall comply with the 2014 Flonda Budding Code w/any Amendments end(as applicable)the same version of the Florida blechamcal.Electrical,, Plumbing,and Existing Building Cutlets). Framing and Other Structural Details mill also cnmph,with lCC-rIO(Prermuslc:_Tri 1 i:-"' 1 * I ! W -- l-I -a1'-rd-ae 1.39.AfE'r .r / — _ — — _ — _ _ I_ f _ �.SW.wA Slaao lnc in Pcd'ti1aH ' r t SF-th Ave. . — _ Dar*. w43 ! • ' 1s\ fi9t ,-O _ t___ - - - -TTq- } r755 k I'.bs f. 5r_ M� i -in �r m.±c, � 6 i`, 1 q r t ° In I nt - f rii , I v No LqQ Appr`! a 'S!4- - . _ _ _ _ _ -7`i�i_._ —._.{__ �1-;"-rc1%6 I a _.,-t-LI t tl-I r Isstico _.,._....• o iso'FlafH- u{G.lI?R� uFo`ekvt�nlGt- q,."rz' _� . _rt''SMN t _ —— o — _ —_ — __ __I �•-,moo _ _ — — — —_-_ ,_r ` COPYRIGHT NOTICE Existing South Elevation:Main Residence �r ..--eM.�a.e,..•,. Scale 1/4--)' .1'-0" V °' O� 0 >,O' a)... ;-1.-t cn .-i cu czt rc o • rl r - IIIIIIil ! 1 / n . . .I.�1 1r, I t f I „1'', i 'tutuelSl"an.ARnau.: -* Late —`- Rate r,17fo • 0+4" ," `Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+I.D/' .�- Lt l --—— — — — — — — ___--�i' _ ,e4EF/X.1 lk'' 1W SE 7th As'enue.Ste F �.77.- +�- _—— s — -r*m - Delray Bch,FL 33463 _t . -- — 1�'r i'� nu24_ns �,3,itnt -- _cr a:id- -'bib ` — 4 n...r.. Sluan Residence MASTER SUITE ADDITION 106 SE 7th Avenue `^'•' F\LSTING ELEVATIONS of Main Residence r... D.Aoan r.�,m than Re,M,tr Ste Existing Elevations `—°DAm ' „ •P-0 Existing North Elevation:Main Residence A3.01 .............A s `_-' A3.01 Scaler 1/4" .1'-0" VI lino —.I .t Re_Me SiL Setnv,e-r- Total gloat. The(Vert Shown in these Plans Shall Con qlc with the 22l14 Florida Building Cede w/any Amendments and(as applieeh el the same, ` an:.n of the Honda hie.h .t:. Pluminng,and E-esneg ak,.i-- FramingandetherStruct, - ,.m�l.. 5 i • 1 1 1 -I ._- t'- --� -- f .:, • _ 1- q 111111! ' i - 111111 I }u1. i _______, • . - .I rt r, osu:nc R reu-nc. • _t_C+se+,,r.P.F(lo COPYRIGHT NTt ITICE Exisiting East Elevation:Main Residence Existing West Elevation:Main Residence Scale77/4'11=1'-0" Neale:T/41 •1'-0" u0°� O CU GOO a:1=1 i—owcl) cis v 0 y� Il� N 2 034 o 11 m Cu - Issue Notes .1s \St r' .`St — __to'o M 1 . -1)-Lf -4)-Vf +VT _'I IA -4p--Vr. 1 t I t s e 'lame]Sloan.ARv 77 rillill.1,1=m14 _.- I• — .a...Sluanl Slwn-Avenue.te.B+I.D. Ik.SF.7th Aseue,Ste.B Delray Bch,FL 1,4153 • � (Sol)24ia75S • 4 0. — Ian. Sluan Residence MASTER SUITE ADDITIU,: 106 SE 7th Avenue .-"`" ExisriNc EI.E\A110N5 of Main R..idence D.slum .�.s Sean Res mstrW Existing Elevations "`oSlm Existing East Elevation: 1 Story Garage "E-A3.02" Existing West Elevation:1 Story Garage A3.02 -.'D.stun -" Scale:1/4"=1'-0" §tale:-l/4'r '-10" 1//a 7 A3.02 Leal Sheers Slv.n Res--Akio-Sie2Utet to'-u- NOTE:Soil Bearing Capacity of 2500psf is being The Work Shown in the Mans Shall Comply with the2014 Florida Sodding de.,/any utilized.Geotechncal report suppoting same is on file .Ammendmenls and(as applicable)=hesame of the Florida rr,hanieal,Electrical, with Permit for 1996 Repairs to Residence that trwming,and F„-•-_=:,l ding Cndeisl. encompassed all new spread foundations.Also same From.nga^au he.::•- DetaaSu•al also Existing 3/4"Water Meter&New City Installed 1" -r"'I'" ' --'1 i$1p1'vas"a^'°'�''' PVC Water Service Piping to Residence.(Complete value is shown in Geotechnical Report on file for 1996 - { New Water Main Installed under SE 7th Avenue w/ freestanding Garage Building. t"Poly From Main N Water Meter). " S 89'09'00"E p - _ - _ . - _ _ - - _ 135.00' UPGRADE METER TO 1"SIZE. Fg1D IP - - A _ - the. 3V'x r l2",'oncrele - - - - -a-_ - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - - ,0.0:•cal O"d+ • Pad uuth(3)e5 Each flay„/ ❑ FND Pc,WASHER Line o(Rouf Above a a 12`<IY integral concrete - '---- (0.15'N) - 1 t ct. pedestal m center.Top of , i1 Pedestal at tnir AFF.25oo psi „,s to. Z —1 Ti `tea.Q .. R tJ J ,_ _ y � ,,,Eli,„ Q .'• I tadle,:anway to 1W T6.:rr ., .a.v l .T2L%�-9 co. ' c%i n _ Stack&Sccer Run rs'/re-/ m •v STAIR Sl'PPURT Fl`l`TER_New 3'6"ales 1Y0 x 1065E7thAvenue Concrete Pad with(21=5.Dowelintoadjacent on t:, to mw'all(corer with 131=S ee lr b nxlLs epoxy 124a-,3 Ild Existi 1 story "°' �' w1SfmpsonSEL Tupp offmw•ratn'-t-5"AFF. _ aM ❑ m u.l,..<sd.•awi.n.a s.< Garage/Study 2500 psi min concrete. ma _,,,, ❑ 'b nWO:-E1aAR;;r- VI (No Changed PATIO w "'" a VIIN A:e,wn,, 0o F L d� Q3 27,-fin �-.... Nov 6fr: hth Slat cn Grade with 8" 8" u'i 0 u Existing 4"PV',- a age '�' Thickened Edge VF tong Existing Residence MI L0 I� G eair S n•-den., zi � Fuuterw/ 5D with 11)=5 and oiells�l6Ec.c Residence n IT)b ,I/,/I. Update F.u,aan.- Om �_ _ r tinting Pahs i.((Awaits 227 high trim = F I!)'} P i wall.Wit.cs.J Culunu.0 k tine te.ill:ap, ,plate n'/Simpson SET epos),anvhonng a 4/is/l; IS$t'F.D FOR t:i: .- New 2n Story Bakony Above l l' Spanuh'taar ce IT:l Beams,le Sxeen adhesive.On other 3sides klonohth.o Fouler w/ _ I (Future Phase 2) I I-.utrls.Sn,n ilvvr,&A,. .,•:.t. 10'-6" bottom width of ten,HT IF 21r,n-/(21.5 I I _ �/ Cont.&65618/1U IV1\'b1 doubled UR.75a/Y 1'— +"° •r+,. uF Fihermix Additive.pronde.75'recce fin "„p I - - -O°we. - �— I wall oula plate.ALIGN N'f s)FSLAA 4VT(H FND I _ 'It- `�" �-EX(SItN(i STS)DY P (0.13'E Ytroa 6'•O� - - -i— - - - - - - .}�� - - - - �—- - _ _ - _ - _ _(D.11'E1 O < 1 srr O e.v. �, / (2'-n" 33'-6" NO P0WASNER ° , a .re (1)s3Vertical where shown and i4)=5 Vertical I8.3„ (0.15'N) —at each 12"x l'-"Pier.Embed 6"min.into / / ring 8"Thickened Edge helots and sere —I Fx stng,-oncrete Patio Slab w/8^x 8"Thickened Edge with secure th Simpson SET 2 epoxy anchoring adhesive. w/(I)=5..VDD(4)12 s12 Poured in Place Conc.Piers 213" COPYRIGHT NUTICF. All CAW w be filled Salo with 3U181 psi pump high and grout solid.A 3"dia.Alum.pipe Column will be ..a s.c..,.Iru.:.o,. — nux. 'installed by FramngContract..r at each pier to/(4).5".< ram.. cen.a,, srst..e.ti"i "'` 5.5"SS redheads.(SEE DETAIL SHEET THIS PAGE) ""'e oi_,m..u,yu..mn.s r."..r.i..a New 4"Poured in Place Conc.Knee S-Poll-or high w/(I) 5 at top.Extend(1(=5 Reber trim each adjoining 12.r 12"< 2(ht cone.Pier(hp of 26 LF)Fill solid with 3l3R) V ice, ;"4 purnpmtx.Note:Remove Frick F.erder cwept at new screen .. door area and start new wall.-n::rr--re'.-:;_rtdat.:.n. I,.I 0 CC/ I..' - 0 11 NEW FOUNDATION PLAN: Library Addition & Patio Piers Scale:1/8"=1'-0" ai o 1—7 v Et� �cn Can I .I�. °� 2 xis- NEW 3"Dia x 2^1,o11 Alum.Pipe / Column with white powder coat 31/Y )s/p finish.8"x8"a t/2"base platen•/ Top of Column Hole for Screw•1.5"Hex (4)5.5"r 1/2"din SS redheads into new Cone_line&g PiaE 8ml0"AFF ;1��1 (wpu-al°(2per fan) No. cafe laic Notes Column Drawing for Speeds.or r Column) 1/4"Alum.Buckets:c/holes for 1/_'S5 Thru Bulls i ri'se"xl/2"Plaleatmpat I' ' NEW tier for Columns.12^. ) i 1 eel Y ; 12"l' ed Concrete Culumn rm=cx'lumn ` r I f .v+.5"r 211"nt Poured n Maw Knee 711:ipt"VIIell:8 \ r x • , o.>ntet�laan,.iRvsar,' Provide;5".3. Recess Top o Concrete Cap Wall w/(tl=5 Cunt and(D=5 Vet 4'sa for Sale Plate x I max CToxye)into Existing 8xN thwkeneJ Stuart&Sloan,Inc:Architecture+In v.Design +12"AFF dgrofpace slab(Approx 33).Fr e'IU/1U l\'elded l\iretlhlesh.Dc•ublc within 5'o( -5411W uprods-Er ding rnrm NeeNElV'3"LTax {"uall xtY Pugh IPb SF.7thA:•e.edge °CF:vrrc{41 per Pia.tiircd w fuoter rebarri0o1-Tti Alun Mpe,'olumn withavDelray Beach.FL3'U3&=3 Hoo rTo s1/2 posepl a /(41 B".g' Sol)24-+r755FinalldsluaniFsloandes Mz Fa P shitep•eplace w/14h.8"x gM'dui holes fur l/2"Jw A 5.5"SS5 % ® o'x6"lU/tltWelded WteRedheads Top Buckets of 1/4"To of Existin Patio / (t satPg " if ( (F; rig) alum„/olts holes kr yr dia 0 8"AFF ssThin M It and yr n)•1°n N Conant,. flee a ,•,x ''`}'� Inset!vanilla(typrul) Sloan Residence Renovations o min — EeISTQ,ic::oNc•REf,E (S a Top View for more info. Typical of 2 Middle ',New e5 rebel-16.Long / Existing Layout I-,tending�'into Existing PATIOSLAB on Grade Columns. Slab on tirade with Alonohthw a.huwn Thickened rotas with 8"Thickened EdgeFastm,>`t&Westmont &Proposed New layout Fouler:sin An:inercre Min 8 y r 5- Topof Bond Beam 1 ¢ J5 1-Ago..Anchor With Simpson /1)a.wo nuaus.tn'. Column to have only x/14b/lv PiMrmnh additive I T Epoxy.Then mall(21:. 'Jets• x w(voter) New Foundation PL. over 6ma Vapor Barnet over Epo.. - 12"x tr r ter 'lunges +12" AFF I B' I 2 degrees at eU l'Ilan,Tnv4x Compacted ScJ. Reber at SDdegrees. �rk le pa(Integral to 'f--'I` degrees to each other. Showing PorchEnla tl.o Liban' poured Nu & Work � Monolithic Footer @ Library Pier&Column at Patio Detail fil Alum.Column at Patio Detail o.�� ""R'" R +ah<m 5.1 Scale:1"=1'-0" F r .o,o,mt.,,o s.t Scale:1"=l'-0" rtr.,..a... , u... t, o..., Scale:1"=1'-0" w ...._ ,. W D.Elam ` vs--I.a- Foundation Plans y Dstun 51.01 S 1.01 2/1/20, —°( 4l'u.''R$ 1 )canRes_,201,toes LTrat)- The lFs'rt.Shown an these Plans Shall C omrly Flitch Plate Stair Support Beam Per Detail"52.B}"; with the 2Bu Florida Budding Cede w/any supported one end by Alum"Stair Support Column" Amendmentsand(as applicable)the same as shown this sheet,other end bears un foundation at �,O(e:Plp e &sawn of the Florida Mechanical,Electrical base of stairs.Angled Stairs and Horizontal Beam UPPER AREA PERIMETER is 2x8 PT Rim Joist attached to First Floor Double Sole Plate IDC'a 110[1 Plumbing,and Existing Budding CLde(s1. Stair Support Column: Connected with"Stair Connector al"as shown un Framing and Other structural Details will also Below with l2p HDG Nails at 6"o.c.+Simpson A35 clip at 24"oc on inside face of rim joist. j Slightly' _ _ .�.mph',rch I '-alxl lrre.�,�,=I•sSlt�arts•+or. See Detail This Page. sz.B3. an�e see New 2x8 PT a2 Fluor Joists at 24"oc.,(double members where double line shown,single d e tall I dwg5 Hand Frame Steps:w/(3) 2x12 PT t " ' "' """ singleshown) 12pp - gPly ..'..r".-. shank nil leachsde.tv/2x8bridging/blocking s `n (typ) 11 5 tt r.r capital. -nro member where sin 1 line toe nailed to new knee wall-with HDG or SS ring of . Stringers and 3/4" treads and where dotted lines shown ' 1 t l , risers(will have Bamboo Nosing I and Risers Applied by Flooring ....7..........., y, }„—y 2xa PT a2 Knee Walls Spaced a Ste v "` ) - _ Co.subsequent to d in) zs „ai m ar Fr,m 1 s shown with tarp j' cl ry r ., aligned with Existing Permtter Double Top Plate of '� "' 1st Fluor Stud Walls.,Single Bottom Plate&Double r y • , •,, " " ••'�• a Top Plate,studs at 16"oc Attach bottom plate to _ES---- CLOSET AREA(Lower Level Area):New c L = Existing Roof Sheeting with 3"x=9 Coated Screws -2,l_, 12 ph-,t,.er ' t 1 `. 2x6 PT 12 Fluor Joists at 16"u.c.,tare \ Coat at 12"oc staggered.(TYPICAL SYMBOL for 2 ' i= ..e nailed to new knee walls with 12p HDG a knee walls) <_\HOW to r . or SS ring shank nail each side.tv/Solid ) „ ;n (2)2\u5' • 2x6 bridging/blocking where shown with \' l dotted line. i - 1 I r SF-titAss .,. t. 2x6 PT a2 Knee Wall with topaligned with Existing i Toe Nail Rim foist to fast floor stud wall 'a Z g I Odra,'M-87 i double top plate with tip HDG or SS .e Permtter Double Top Plate of 1st Floor Exterior Stud Walls, . s :43a75, Nails at 6"oc plus Simpson A23-z clip at 7 a" I _. _ _. ._.. __ Iv - Single Bottom Plate&Double Top Plate,studs at 12"arc • x `-' '`^r"'< .'i E Attach bottom late to Existing Roof Sheeting with l/4"x In is a AF:53- 32"or on inside face of perimeter rim joist :n KP g g I >,v n:us or equal. 6"Coated Lag Screws at oc staggered w/2"square a. f „..oi n �,,,�� .,���.....�,,-- „f �.,„,, . q HDG washers.Connect bottom plate to studs with . Simpson SP1Z connectdur and Dbl.tarp plate to stud with - •�'' `- " "" " ' ' " ' '' a! SP2 Z connector on intermediate studs and twist haps on � istuds aligned with floor joists above.Connect Wall studs I 4 to 2x8 Floor Joists with Simpson MTS 16z twist straps. Added uplift resistance provided by 1/2"PT Ply sheeting i a on one side nailed at 6"oc.(TYPICAL SYMBOL(or I knee li/201 ItcpdaUpdatedcn bulr e 4/17/17 LsSUFD F.Rt N<7RUCTilN 4wall) i j 5,. c ,ee 3 overall b/rv/I7 -hanged knee nan6 ..._._...._...... .. ...._..._ _.............. "' NOTE:This knee wall is aligned with existing 1st floor height • upaaw ens se,e Vtredule - fv' bearing wall belmv which has continnus load path and 6s t uplift resisting clips/straps from foundation up to top of 25'-'_I/2"(Rim Joists) wall just under root sheeting.(See Sections for more info) New 3/4"T&G CDX Plywood Subileenng,Glued and Nailed to 2xb Fleur Joists with At HCGer 55 • ring shank nails o"edges/12"field.Cse DAP'Smartbond"Gel From Cnsh.ino Suhfl.ar Adhesive OR Lockbte PLOW subEaor adhesive(all per APA"Studifloor"System).Exterior most line of rlvwood to , -, 5 be PT installed concurrently with floor framing,balance to Fe CDX rated subfloor plywood. C �' - 2nd FL. FLOOR FRAMING PLAN IMPORTANT NOTE:UNTIL AFTER ROOF 15DRl'ED IN-Temporarily tackdowpeniedoANDRal COPYRIGHT NOTICE screws/sheet until Rough Deane.Plumbing,AC and Insulation is complete&inspectevi AND Roof.., ".r I..r..iu"mv— M Scale:1/4"=1'-0" Dn•ed In.Then Glue/Nod Perabucr. n ,,..."e,•a.�.•,ru. ss New Stair Support Column Axonometric �y Scale:N.T.S. V �,-CJ O- '' Design Trusses for 4'x lO'Solar O O `•" Collector(AEI'Solar,Inc.;AE-40 41•a"' 1-i CCS(Sa Cn Model).1.52 lbs dry wt.+1.2 gallons of water wt.<shaded grey rectangle> — Centerline of Bedroom Coffers(See 1,•i i•+ I Reflected Ceiling Plan for exact En r. Xi' a1 _Frame Opening for dimensions) 41 0•r-i •1•, Northernmost 3'-8"+/-of trusses 2x2 Skylight 2x4 Wood Frame 2nd Floor Cont. i•I 1•J N ccsrl this area are cantilevered and bear Bearing Wall Below Structural Connector Schedule:Sloan Residence Addition Project y . on Shadded Bearing Wall Below as „ - - - tl u r, I T'. _�� t_ S"DeepOctagonal Coffer-See NO. DESCRIPTION MANUFACTURER UPLIFT carat& UPS caoxav PROCUCT 0- ��//rT shown.(Only securesa,) in Stair well —.- I'�F--i F•`i and landing area) Reflected Ceiling Plan for Exact Required Pranded:lbs O W \\\ _. I I '_ mension9/FuSillumng. I Root Truss to Chl.Top Rate 3•e:l Maas Simpson 480 lbs' 145016s FITS 30 erax r��-1 --_ 1l r f y Dt '2nd Floor Exterior walls.nee lb worst cafe sl s lb typical•nfft valueN ss• V J I—I Ysin oPP ._ - ---o r 3 x 3'x N"Deep Square New Engineered eered and Approved Roof Trusses at 24"o.c.(reduce to -\� 't' Coffers-See Reflected Ceiling 1 b Root Truss to Ca Top Plata,br.-.,era ware Simpson 961 lbs• 14501bs FITS 30 rear l2"or 19.2"arc at coffers if required Plan for Exact Dimensions. Erg typcal spin value/Voss. for Truss Engineering)w/5/8" ( 'z.a Floor Ink a wilt.gat lb xc•st silo.74a m j Issue (typo I Ku rail• Fetes g CDX Roof Sheathing,Clue and Nail • with lt)d Ring Shank HDG nail 4" i / _ col.T P ets'to Ein 255R.En will studs Simpson 320 Ibs 1065 lbs SP2:cod ' Edges,6"Field. -) 2x4 Bottom Chord - - 1 n B[d[Ing at g'U,C.Max I,I ,1 R_or-Exterior Walls.320 lb worst.ass,279 lb repeal uplift value/stud' _ ``sv i `ss& Truss Engineer to provide for AC I / , 0' / nail with(2)lip nails at _ __ 1, 11 main Ducts as shown on each truss unless 26 NewDbL Top Plats Is let,8r9-WRY Saws Simpson 641 Ihs 1065 lbs SP2 max j I l '..c._ I 1 i Mechanical Plan,Solar Water `--- -- otherwise specified m _ _•zra Floor inc erg a'af e401b vast cos..ix ID typical up[tl value/stud. Heater DL as shown on Roofing Truss Engineering. r Iklaniel clean.aRti3O77 Plan,and provide fur Coffers as -r. 3 214 R.sloe,M So Plate I hr nrg.war only' Simpson 641 lbs 885 Ills SP4 mete % DSte:, ! shown here and on Reflected - Ceiling Plan. -- - - - ---- • Double Ply Girder to .N�Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+LD. «pporL Roof Load plus lb M.erg.oar Si Plate to 2x8 Root duals Sabo IA ex 69 Screws 160 lbs/screw 381 lbs(screw 1.75•emhedment 106 SE 7th Avenue,Ste B 1 d dead load of note frame Delray Bch,FL U53 • wall below. eet and Si.2x8 Rim Joist to 2nd FL.Sbtds Simpson 320 lbs 1130 lbs META'S ones Del 124}8755 NOTE:Provide _ 'Install(6)too I 1.5•HDG Nails at Tarr joist 8 i6)led x 1,6 ADCs Nals al 2nd Floor aids above" ceilinghtfor 5 New 2nd FL xeFYm Joist W 1st R.s*ads Simpson 320159 1.� Ills MSTA36zmai, width of stairs Insali811oilxts HDGb lsatrimic tsin)ISO,t.5 800 l Sloan Residence on First I 6 MASTER SUITE ADDITION Zx12 Floor Joists at Stair Area Simpson 0lb 50)lam 1165 ID LUS 210 106 SE 7th Avenue (eastmost) 1 �_ Q rS x 6 Simpson 185lb LL DL 13a8b w,.: LUS 210 Lower Truss I ,Double Girder Truss at Level Change of Roof::See 2nd FL FLOOR FRAMING PLAN (only) 1.1'i Building Section A4.03 far more information. &2nd FL.ROOF FRAS IING PLAN 54"Dlamehv x 8"Deep Circular Coffer-See Reflected New Second T' ---- Ceiling Plan for exact dimensions. o.swan Snap Res May So- Floor& Roof - 2nd FL. ROOF FRAMING PLAN Framing Plans �"..Dwe' _. " Rn,wN B. Scale:1/4ee=1.-0" S2.02 - s2.02 2/II2UJ gf 51unees 810T31e-jltlbvib,'ss Teal Slims, The Pork Shown In thew elute Shall comply with the 1014 Ronda Building Code w/any Amendments and(as aprltcaglrl the same not the Flonda ilrchannaI t'.",cal. `rlumhing,and Fusung h ding t'�Je/s). Framing and Other Struu aural Detals will aLs ELEVATION MATERIALS LEGEND mply c•ah ICGpA1 ._IDt n Fabric Awnings on(21 French Duun l —_--_ A _ &(41 Windom of East Facade.See ' .� 1 1 I A. Terra Cotta Chimney Thimbles ti 1 " ' Notes fur Fabric&Etc I; • 24'-T' Top Pt tz _ '_ 12 72 B. Reserved 11111H111111111111,23.AR,,,-- .Para et - ""�x 11 ; r 'I '-r , ; , ;!; �� # C. Decorative Pitched Roof Element:, Hand Made"Altusia"+� } -- C-- Terra Cotta Barrell Tile in Natural Terra Cotta Color. 2x6 RS Cedar Fascia,ti_ ...� - -}-- } - - Board, Copper Drip, w/ 1x6 v joint pine Soffit under&9.25"x 9.25"nt I T1 ' . I' .1l _- ._ . D___ 1Vd.Brackets at 24"o.c.,soffit&brackets painted brown to match windows. D• ILI i! rA I �`—'�_:� � _73'-+n � walls. -. Ij �; _ E. 5/8"Stucco:over 4"Wood exterior (typical) _ ./ /17 ISSUED F°&,C' _ .. , u/3rll- '_l+.,se LN A.FFL Ecm,L. 12'-T'F.F.L.Master Bd.Rm. '" - _ _ _ . F. Sunbrella Awning:w/Black Powercoat Alum.Frame - i above 3x8 or 4x8#1 PT or Spanish Cedar Trellis. ....iii) I (Awnings by Separate Permit) )...__i . _G G. Replace existing machine made barrel tile with Hand r. _ t. ( Made Terra Cotta"Altusia"Barrell Tile in Natural Terra Cotta COPYRIGHT 1NIuTICE 1 - 1 • j jJizii9 . 9 ff H. Decorative Cast l�fedallion:8"x 8"square and 12"dia.round,1 fi_ '1 r : l. Live 0 ai , I. CladWoodFrenchDoor(s):Bz.vinyloralumcladding• I - , - t o'-0" (Weathershield in"Adobe"Color,Pella,or Anderson Impact rated)or �- O O • d> • j I -1st Floor Owners Option Alternate PGT Alum.With"Walnut"color"Eterna"Finish. CU L=CI3 t?I l' tt i _1 r — ��-- �_ tF. . . 1a4,� Q) - F^- -�- r- J. im.Coral Rock Columns:12"dia.Tuscan style tapered column on Q 0 cn a N } Sim.Coral RockRect alar Base 1 _r - - - angu ea cu i -13.5"EEL. *---_ i �NI'' Library K. Screen Panels:Charcoal or Blk SS Screen panels in Ipe WoodCC% Addition Frame.To be located inside of line of columns.w/ all SS fastners. ,. New Notated East Elevation:Main Residence L. Tapered Posts:6"x6"PT#1 or Spanish Cedar supporting "C-A3.03" decorative trellis above. No. Date Issue hem M. Reserved. N. Existing Colored Concrete Patio:with 8x8 thickened mono.footer around perimeter.Optional:add 2'x2'coral rock pavers on top of �,tu " rl4an,AR;s4' concrete deck set in mortar bed. -`Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+I.D. llo SE 7th Avenue.Ste.F Delray Bch,FL 33563 (Sell 243-5755 Sloan Residence MASTER SUITE ADDITION 106 SE 7th Avenue NOTATED EAST ELEVATION of Main Residence New Notated -,..- DSta. Wen Fes arse Si, Elevation -- A3.04 r^ a D.shun s J/e- 1'-n `"ohun A3.04 i/Uxuu snxrsn_setrsv-7utm In 19% Total m•.a. The t\'ar1.3hu+rn rn these flans Shall Comply ' with the 2014 Florida Building Code av/any Amendments and(as applicable.the same �.l' .A y,.. -- `FluamhcnglinJF nne Pu Flunda dding CodllCompl. I 1'It J-- -e A Framing and Other Structural Details will also 1 fc,mrb with'i -aiiO rPr.,n,asl••._TP!is'ii, I i — _ 24'-7" •12 72- I t4'-7"Top of Top of I 12 1 t 1 \ t ram'` -t2 Parapet Parapet - - tt `�•. P"I 1 Ittl. I t I t tit \('< �C p ..v�t2 1 r @qq11 D ,I t,N Is 1y� __-_ f-- f E a q r ~ ©� 1t II 1 0 1— I--I µ 13'_4" Mann Fr Slam Inc M i, . © © -12'-7"2nd FI.FFL�drm, �RUe.il between eld/new" -'I VC _ "I- _ tpr:F,h.,ax. 1 a..ln p. 1 l2'-T'F.F.L. °dray Beads FL ` _-- — _- _— _ V 12'7"Second Fluor rstu:a>•a7s; I , ___ FFL::Ma_tar Bednwm& Master Bd.Rm- - — — — — — — - a a.n�.r saa I _q•_fl.• B M25tr211111 - + Bathroom IL _ _ , 9'-8"2nd Fl.FFL Closet Area E l_ I _.a -.-� �' - _ m m:ra � ti�. C. t - G ,T ''i ' 711: S ] ' i ` Ir{I ! 133 ]..--•--1All I 1 - .I �. 3t]a..• ap,•rL•-s:�n h"tes[�: _. 199�1II '�4 , all IµI i LJ //,; Idamc I 11 ---� 1I. .l i I I l O I �'-,1 ! - I.L.-- - - „ " I, ri .... f 1 �- .- 1st Flour t,•"�Ke t F si _El.. . _ _ - s 1 -- ll t �� r ems_-/ — e T i l3 - -- _ F.F.L.F.. s" -,3 ratio L ^+`.� -- _.. Library — _-yam -4"Bath 2FFL ea \• l' - _ I —. Finished __— - - _ - -- .- `.•'�"^.o.`�'>t i12" _13 5'Library FL:or Level/ 1 .---I-.. I --'K `,-1YJl"First Floor -Finished Floor Level _N 'Finished Fluor Level U'-ti"First Floor -Finished Floor Level CiiPYRtGHT NOTICE New South Elevation:Main Residence"A-A3.03" New East Elevation:Main Residence"C-A3.03" Scale:1/4"=1'-0" Scale:1/4"=1'-0" • _? E- -A t--c o�.a.0 cu a ' r—� f- •— • �'V"aFTtY`'/ - -----� 2.4'-7"Top of aS�"' Fj,� I - - - An .�.l:Li}r Parapet '�'' y a^f"li xl liriii�l'S -d.,;r r �O - �e 2 7 ' -. — _ — 21'-U'•Top of r--i V] pA r r, -�.J l ' YYY ClovetParapet- Crl r1 _ Clu=et Area C18.-4" ` — - — _ . .'ding Ht. ' -�' .. -et Area / nc. caste i:,nr nevi °jj6 Zs�x L- r li slit Reams \ ;' l2._7.. / l27"FFL f� � O - liir ^nt�l;i .e '_--F . I I j 2nd Flour - -- -' 1 - - t ---- - —. ..— — ; - — — - p t v aR. - Floor Second i i FFL-Master-- - .. .� I T aide- / Cont.Reveal ter,I. 9'-8"FFL Chnet I a Bedroom I _ , f _ -ie FFL::Master . sPanre151yan•aRS5677 _ - i * betwe nold/new H Area 9'-8" — r __ _ Bedroom& Crary. stucco r, _ a I i�- _ „O �_ FFL -� - _ -J- Bathroom "'"Sloan&Sloan Arctutecture+I.D.' -- - I , — t t I i I.;et Area j _dr. Itln SF.7th A enue,Ste.R l i i [ _ I _ _ '. ,, Delray Bch FL i3483 HI t s ! !1 ii / ' l t 1%3- a,—± ( I 1 i r 3 ! (f K a. tj 1 'I l ih--- 7- U'-lY t��;.• .� )p'� ! — IT-IT' _ - _ _ _ — / _ _ - - .- __ _ I 1 (' Sloan SUITi ADDITION Fitt Fluor pI °' T -— r.t Fhx r L U'-U"First Floor MASTER SUITE ADDITION FFL I _.. - V- , -- FFL ..-�""'J / Finished Flour Level ^� l06 SE 7th Avenue - - - Nny 2•In'.es-Impart ._-_+4"Brick Patio NF.{1'ELEVATIONS Rated French Door.Fait. -- -8"Patio FFL Ftruhed to match balanm FFL of Main Residence of eyrsonglst floor doors. .•.•• D.Sloan r.�.a Skim Res Mao.Ste New Elevations ....e.D.Slum a .tom A3.03 "-" New North Elevation:Main Residence"8-A3.03" New West Elevation:Main Residence "D-A3.03" °51ua A3.03 Scale:1/4"=1'-0" Scale:1/4"=1'-0" a u"ao _tl SItn Rea-atae 51,201.'lo•-.- Total Te er 10'-2'(Awning) NOTE:ALL AWNINGS BY SEPARATE PERMIT The Work Shown in these M G Mans Shall .mply * F with the+1t14 Honda Budding Code n/any Ammendments and(as applicable)the same New Suuhrella'Fire- version of the Florida Mechanical,Fdectnral, Sisk^Awing...Blk Fremomeng and Order Structural and uldingC will al.s. Alum Frame..4chor to .•mr;)pith 0.Y cll. - - wan and Rafters w'ss Tapcous or Lags. - Engineelang b) _- S L O A N _ _-��--------__ -Aamg Co. • ' Fame verneat and I tomer out roads) i r New Hunter Green Tweed=82UU2 • 1 "Firestst"Sunbrella.owning w/ • - - a Black Pmvdercuat Alum.Frame. a _ ---- - -__ (Typ of 3 Awning on East Facade — —,49.-lam — _ and 2 on North Facade Flanking Fire � r. S I ( - N Typical Window and Dour Awning New 3xll0 PT 61 Pia I, r' Place)-By Separate Permit.-See - - - -- - 1 • ..._.- Style w/Blk.Powdercoated 1"dia. a %Cedar Cant i i Photo this page of Typ.Design. I Alum.Frame and"Firesi cesium ces Beam wi Decorative !! SunbrellaFabric"Forest Green 55 Bucket Rafter Tails- 1--( - - -- Tweed 082002".This Design is C4Pofj) �_� - '_typical of of(5)Smaller Awnings being �- _ - _` 7,' --)-- Sr . .. added to East and North Facade of New Blk.SS- s . _ f y Hemte:NOTE:Secondary Awnings ��Wa • ! I •4 ` I •I {•s—_- . Dre7. llytt{�i '1 ..4. 17L i .i;a` 11 _- I+1 - .1. ___ f _ '_ _ _ _ ter__ _ New Matching Precast -- - Reysonc Column Base I of - - .. h�.x�s 1 - --- , I/tt cpa.,N�. ,g.- .sun - )- '+^� 1 - New Clad Wood impact Rated a 4/1./17 issLFvn eC,45-rxlXIION 1 light 5068 French Dour to replace exiting unit.Anderson Clad Wood "AFF-Existing Brick Patio over Unit w/"Terratone"Color Exterior Concrete Slab-To Remain. Finish. A NEW PARTIAL WEST ELEVATION(Screen Porch) c NEW EAST ELEVATION- 1st Fl. Awnings A305 Scale:1/2"=1'-0" A3.05 Scale:1/4"=1'-0" , Copyisiulrr NUTfcis t�:�..a.e .ate* 1/4".Vuin Column w/ U €.{ all 55 Connectors.See 0 (t$ u t Strural Sheets $„t O New Sunbrella"Firesit"Fabric Awning"Forest Green Tweed '-0 ^^ '14 =82002"w/Bik Puwdercoated Alum.Frame and all Stainless / dale PT et us Spameh Sunbrella Rceset Fabric Awning 4. a Steel Fasteners/Connectors-By Separate Permit Cedar Decorative Trellis =s'-rkrt Forest e:reen'roved sv ` (Engineering by Awning Company) iv/a0 55 Connectors.Fee BRV Pase•d u Permit)d lam.Frame. ^V. r Structural sheets. Scram - i-r -New Decorative 3xW Pr al or Spanish Cedar Trellis - C1J 1-1 rr and all Stainlev Steel Fasteners/Conneciorrs-See " ��_ - -�'' is CI) Cd Structural Sheets fur Column Detail. - - - , O New l2^dia Tuscan Style Sim.Keystone Column w/Matching New Bartell Tile to match Stoup 1 I I 3,10 PT.:I or .4 03 ill Key"tune se an Bad matching cap un 4"emu knee walls. Roofing w/Copper Drip& I •�I s mPi rash Cedar Cr) _ - - —, I Flashing. 'Raisers New Light Fixture to match units I I• :t 5� - - x��— on balance of home. - i 11 I 4 IRre El r r Replace Existing Bartell Tile with New is L +s4( Screen I'rO' care rave nvus — - re 1 'Altusia"hand made Bartell Tile un Fes'T1F) - -- 1 �7dg l • - 7ljl!f Sq A}}YI� Existing Stoup Roof.(Prix Option) -12^dia Sim r' r r _i ��w �i 1st 1 I1-- - I+ 1 l -�� < - sNew Decorative Cast Medallian-8"s / iumans ne I s1 svr N r. �,i_ i fa +, New Clad Wood Impact Rated 1 ( :I 6E W s s - D.timl 5lwn.-1RVc?!.' .� - a. _I light Dbl 2668 French Door for -- ___ - - _- - - ---- •- Darn ,l ._ — t rw• Libra Addition.Anderson Clad Ural - �-�f- t' -' 1- "-" l'F _ w/"T rtatene"color cladding et w/ �_h(hh,ng Sloani Sloan,lice:Architecture+Ink Design :,'—.= �_ ,r+. ._ y! .s _ .. T-` _ r1 ,, ` 4. T i _._ '.. _ matchexisting chu a&B Copper lDrip - '-�__. - _- __ -- S sty.,. Delray Reach.FL AVR3 3,, i FtL of Patio.Slab.. r i.:, t i - 3 ... above $ G- 'Faye /Soli 21?x755 FonaiLdslaana'sloandesign.bi2 1 1265 a-/. - ' ''c _46"FII.ofLibray 2 4(( IfueFrame,r peon -. ' K.K.--_- uq-; ... _ .•.4, :'.* _ .. cab; c born_K a tone Knee wall cc. 5.5"AFF topof new Pates Sun. New 4"CMU Wall-I course high w/4"x 4"bond _ h s7 1/4 55 Tapa•ns as'_4' +0co"FFL of Living Rnom .,.max.s./Black 5S Screen I Vire Keystone rarer.Du:kw-land beam w/(I)=5 Rebar Continuous. - pdchea to south for drainage. New 7'-"High Screen Enclosure-fabricated of Pr 01 Pine or IPE 12-I)" • Sloan Residence Renovations (Scuppersm midpoint between w/Phifer"SeeVue"Blk SS Screen Wire-See Detail this Pa a • Existing Layout ach column). s &Proposed New Layout ' NF1V ELEVATIONS B NEW SOUTH ELEVATION PORCH COLUMN DETAIL Showing Enlarged Lilian &Porch w/Fabric Awning " A3IIS Scale:1/4"=1'-0" Scale:1/2"=1r-0" a,.,n_ D.Sloan �••Hem ItPvdemx Rmn-aauu .".n D.Slum .r 1/4'-st New Elevations "'"� " A3•os A3.05 _ a/t/2R,2 " — Lhrmkttc._1oonitn_s2Ui.suss i The Nark Shown in these Plana Shall C•umVly THERMOPLAS TIC MEMBRANE ._PVC/TPO= EE.THERMOPLASTIC MEMBRANE PVC TP0 THERMOPLASTIC MEMBRANE PVC withtnde od(oaiplica Codeethe ae = Amendments and(a Building the/any Y n of the Flurlda Alaih,nteaL EIeetns:.., SIRE-ALUX BONGING Plumbing,and Fxvung RulAing%AN, AONE90 Framing and Other Str rural Details n-III, l� \ / \ I ..�.WATER Cr,T-O-F .;.mrly r...:1,ii_F7-5,11 XPre...„»I ._TD III •E 1 THERMOP ArIIC 2 CARLISLE FASTENER k REFER TO I MASTC — /REINFORCED 2(2601 E. �.J `SEAM FASTENING PLATE. -4RAL COPPIG AIKXJCABLE VMCN* .- - - YAX.12'(305mn)O.G / (AF_Si E0:110N) r , !II, CARUYE UNIVERSAL _ - l�� �NJ -.CREASE ENE LEMMA.LIOPL fxC DETAILS • I IN�II //-�9NCL-P.Y$EA.ANTO -1,HT • , CB,� �="l, '�1LL!'Ilrl(1� A,RE-°LEx BONDING _ , ADHESIVE • �E - • Tx<RME-,SAC 0.... � c coA-m WEAL 41 Vey e• • /' y 1: �,Y^ `> (, _. / 1 AMDW 1/4^D.F SHEE-V-AL SCUPPER I ❑ 'R NFORC_O FLAS+NC RDT A. - CV-ED.D.VA.ANT MIRED.ADM.. (BY INNERS) HOT aR WELD,I-1/2' I:;-,- I £'TXWS OF COATED / (3gne.;1 4. C CUT A-CNG ONES�' WELD ❑ METAL. S T LI .I, HOT AIR YF_.3.I-I/2- ,-. t' / (33PP)MM. -__. _ - 3 F N 4RAA F I 11 �',LCRNER�Lb INSEEI � 0110 MALAAT(BY_ I 'NC]^ILA LCR 1c�O -,n:❑i I SI k 51I ERS) LJ\\ Ef WATER Cu OFF uASIL❑ Od Bc d s .Jo'yir'u' mnun,}a AWN,W¢SS' • i 2 EAT w[Le r "'��7' ()ern)WOE REDS I -- NOTES 6 NW-RCAF. WOOD EOS T S ARE INSTALLED ONLY A' MEMBRANE OVER SCUPPERS TO SECURE METAL SLEEVE AND • i-,.INi❑4 PRE MOLD 9DE . APPROXNAATEL�1:6'(3me,)DAMETER BEAD OF .Oxt MJS E%TVC PAS-THE ROTH OF METAL n CORNER BE-ORE CLT-EDGE SEALANT 5 RECuR G CN CUT EDGES SLEEVE FLMGT_ // NOTES INSTALLATION OF REINFORCED TPC V-MBRANE AND RECOMMENDEp __IId-maamP ._-/ I:a: aP'r ON Cur EDGES P -__%PVC MEMBRANE IWS 2. INSTALL WA4 BASHING PR CR-0 SCWPER INSTALLATION. k r DL I PO5111 FASTENING ES P'10 8(132 TO Z2Dmm) Z -GAL REFER TC SPAL - :. P-L_S.PPIFMPNT4 1f / • P 'ROM THE CORNER AN) /0 mm TO '(13 TO 251 ) c.c. ,1 .R c. d{; 3. METAL SCNS3ER BC% =POM EDGE OF LE 3N E Z TO BLDO(INC, ,, ,,--,-,,,,-NC • ' COrIMJOLS F S :') fAR ERS SOLDER A. 5.. V- / '% 2. APPROXAMEELY 1/0 (3rE )DAMETR BEAD OF 22 WHEA RCOC I a 0 WATER-TIGHTF REINFORCED TAO MEMBRANE ASEAAANT:S AD R•\'ICOMN NO<_L ON ' 6 y VAPOR R A A. WATER. CUT-OFF ASPIC C 'JFF<R CUT EDGES OF SPAR_FLEX PVC MEMBRANE _ RANCE uJST B-MADER CONSTANT '7®Q/' 0N,1 NSIOMS min i PLACE A LAYER U LASTC MEMBRM_ \ ( COMPRESSION. . 3. REFER/0 CARJSLE SPECFILAT1ONS FOR ACCEPTABLE IL --- - - UNDER THE METAL PROTECT AGAINST 61 CARLISE-STENERS AND PLATES ® 8 'S2 APPRO%. MOISTURE IMF TRA .DINTS. <.'t4 i y." 5. SCUPPER FLANGES MEG1 BE 1CTALLY \ A WFEN u51N6 EJ OR IB V L OEUBRAk' APPLY P ©C)rb 9- 152-229 4. FASTEN COATED METAL-LASTING TO WOOD AT Il'RED 3�NON REINFORCED PVC F�ASNINL 4-1/2'(1'4mm)DAMETER'T-.DN'i VJT•-H AT A. [4.5-DE..^f1-T_5 APPROX. NA__TRS USING 1-1/2'(35r'Hi MIN.RING SPANK 3. TEAT WilW E n li HEAD. 2'(5'mm)COVERAGE MAST NA..S SPACEC 6'('52H.m';ON CENTER AMC " x�REu.F PACE AAU HEAD. �E.D SAUCE-IN IENSECTONS V SIP-AAC EC APPROX.1/t)I31mn). ._13PANE 0V:P 109*1. 6. INIVD1SAL SING_P.•SEALANT S REDLRED AT F_AS-I.NO EDGES a'.SP,'PT R Elh'Z. -.-. ..,-.r®.�Pn _ DETAIL NO. _ COPYRIGHT RIGHT NOTICE aswe.A PRE-MOLDED INSIDE CORNER a■��.EI� ,11 •T••••usc waevAsn OCTAL.NO. �Rt YEu9RPrf_ .— DETAI.NO. ( �.V=Aa,s.Isa.noL lLASNiNO AF 14-6 U_15A ( ...I •r•wam wwa COATED METAL WALL PUSHING 1 u_1^^ r - :I�AppgOH0 9.l:.IRAIE SCUPPER AT DECK-PVC S 1 g U-18C 'K: AD: r IN la owl•IPeu •PA CAST For•Eaueral rorn.a r.a_.I......,I• 11BL1mA50C�Rk A❑ -•SIE W., FPranl Ina ral>,>nr. Gar •,L,OI, ❑ -~SEE NOTE(5;. ua•P,emN.nPn.I<n.rme,Pse .u.oss THERMOPLASTIC PVC' ^^••v.•...�••�w OwN.F•.. ..-.-a.-eLaaN•PPP.AW rP'•nP.n•P.s w.na. $— (0]oo r.f.I.AA..a'..••.P.MPI.•rl.rxg,•r nAYen y_-.. J1a0 se.se...br P wa....P5•..tW.vy.r 1,...,I Lrt %J ' II THERMOPLASTIC MEMBRANE PVC TPOli i•H 0 �0• p • Z l— NAY STAINLESSSTEEL STEEL ^�.WATER CUT-OFF ye • A4CMPkG R,T ^/)Et W ttL.CEC WTT�T1FRu0PLA9TC 1~ PRE-M0.DEJ FIFE EASXING 0 �, En NOT MR-VFJD,1-1/2' f/\ li- '19mm)YIN.BEYD.•D V r -ASTNAG'MATES IT a _- --- ,1. Date 1 Issue News k SEAM EASTENWG PLATE.RAIL 12. I • (305mm)P.C. ,, • BOO • i i , GIMENSONS Run 0 3/A• 'S I TO A'P tel SLIan,AR,SFAl/ NI:-S Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+I.D. R'MCVE ALL EXISTING LEAD AN)FL.AS•ANG MATERIAL BEFORE PETALJNG PRE-M0tC1,PIPE IUi,SF.Ith Avenue,Ste R WASHING. Delray Bch,FL 3.,483 2. TEMPERA E OF THE APE PE,.R^r(RATION MUST NOT E%Ct30 IAD-(60'C',WHEN u511G PVC AND (SPi)2R?11755 LURE 160E(7,C:WHEN uSNG TPO RASPING. ..,••. 3 PIPE SEAL MUST HALF INTACT RIB AT TOP EDGE,REGARDLESS OE PPE DIAMETER. 4. INSTALL A MINIMUM OF 4'AS'ENERG AND PLATES AR0.ND THE PIPE,ECMALLY SPACED. I FASTENERS AND PATS CANNOT BE•NSIALLEC AS SHOWN.THEY MAY ALSO BE POSITIONED i4 Sloan Residence CUTSC•_THE PIPE MAXIMUU'2'(30Emm)C.C. ANC PLASHED VETn THERVOPLASTC REINFORCED MEMBRANE/CUT-EDGE SEALANT.REFER-0 ET-A L-SA. MASTER SUITE ADDITION S FASTENERS AND PATS ARE MOT REQuIR<-D ON Ap1•000 SYSTEMS UNLEIS PIPE 0AVEhR LU6 SE 7th Avenue UICESS'e-(452mm;, 4. ON MEf'MIfA. Y F45 EKED SYSTEMS,HP-x=ASTENERS ASP)PRAN %NA PLATES OR HP-XA .emu NEW ROOF DEI'.11L5 M FASTENERS AND PIRANHA XTRA PLATES ARE REQUIRED OAEP STEEL AND WOOD DECKS OP. for Alain Residence CONCRETE GECKS,CD-10 OR HD'4-10 FASTENERS ARE L SED MITH PIRANHA PLATES. (All areas to be new ut rerouted) .,_. D.Sum rGrN Plea Res Maly.Se DETAIL NO. -...rain. -!!l...��� New Roofing TP D.Slum • At Noted _I-•Aemelm 4na PRE-MOLDED PIPE FLASHING ��P61� U�A _,,. > ,...Ie Details DSm 0 -.VI.PTn, addl..In P,�P a<r z1P.IP_> <•..A. TnERVOPASTK JM A2.06 A2.06 Ca dr.s•..••es.a asru•,.•e...ur..... .-�., a/In/20I1 of a1 "NISP 51,2014,IP'1,• Total x110ANa The IVeek Shown m these Plans Shall Comply 3"PVC Roof Dram at NW with the?m J Florida Building cede tv/any Corner of Main Roof version and las apphcat lei the same of the Florida a nucal,ElestncaL Plumbing,and we%Bos Codels). 3"PVC Roof Dram Leader Framing and Other Structural Details will also to Grade .mpl..+....lh.'c:: Yi irrr„•,u>I•.,t_'tr.+I+-.:v. 4"PVC Sturm Drain to Drywell • (pitch I./4"per foot min) - - • _ —Approved Plastic Drywell(s)with total • storage capacity of 856 Gallons,2 units Existing modified ro with b roofing to be _. • ganged together with surface drain inlet replaced with New Tamko --- w/grate.See Calculations worksheet& "AWAPLAN"Cap Sheetheet over over 2layers of _'1 Detail Cut Sheet for specs on unit(s). Fiberglas over 43Lb Tamko Base Sheet - F3—- New smooth Eirtish:4ltusia" \ Barrel Tile in natural tens Gotta (installed per 15year warranty directions and - -- 2nd FL Roof Drain Axonometric color over WR Grace Fire and Ice current NOA)over existing 5/8"CDX HT Peel and Stick Secondary Plywood Roof Decking.Use all copper Barrier.New Copper Drip&cap Flashing&Scuppers tvhere shown. metel.Over lx wood decking Replace existing galvanized mtl.Wall New R'Car& R.iCrain and 3-M'C eP ^K attached to Perlin'sloped at " drain run d,n, v s'c:aiwnn a per ding with New l all Low Sloped 1st Ju. d rim Drywd,,,,ma, 12/12...SEE ELEVATIONS. '�a,n per details.(Typical all Low Slope 1st Flour Irevmm tram Piping Uppm..21•Imam (TYPICAL SYMBOL) Roofs tin residence).(Typical up - .ALSO rrae,dr 4•+J•.m.rsm),u5Y0Retc (T real all Low Slope 24't)" Slipper.ldiseent to Drain Fluor Roo.•on residence) i • 7'-2" ! 1T_�,. ,.-ky, 4.�.. „-ty, EXISTING 1st Floor /71...... I �` ' p r Lk:a,,,--44,g-,4,-a 3,.nre, Low Slope ____ i 11/ liE huge Tank PJI Roofing- l i 3ar.itck uen 1. Exoungt'.pper Scupper and downspt.ut :/r/r AJm.f sun+r<s,ant GARAGE ROOF to - _+ ri" fit.+roman JIC/G U�tiEDRR.ICYS RLt nOx be RESEALED at � t � New rTimiayi and r maCo. 7' any loose overlaps ._ �'.�; M Capn of roll roofing. ` ThimblesiSi�De "� red,meisamoraeve 4,Rade ALSO replaceN T REPLACE EEsi .�t;'�,'nsggsn pa, Sky Light lui to roofing in 8'x 8' -MtiN12SNICsib,ng'stoht dewed Sir - Fiver 1,rgRm.cxiLnq TAM aopa ur troaun.Ip+rPully v ynwden b COPYRIGHT NOTICE j RUM Mc un LM nwr wtngyr N'''' t✓.. -.'I Div Detain p..arsraa Y.C._ym.l e..y Yn w centerline Pitches 7/<" - / • �,Me....�„�„y,r„",,,,.,,r-s...it..u.. _Triangular Area a ft per toot min.app ell new EXISTING <dashed>where N �� br,. F meta, } Lsn;',,5s' 3inm nn _ / _ -� .� .r 1st Floor �°" leaking at North& g Roof to be `//� r Rs" Itr sduod up m Raui park and \� Wpm. Dou,tm IJ,Yy Eight l.�-aMiin �-� -J.-^T South Scuppers n l ngRin.,ehngr5ee dr S Re-roofed v u) it a (PRICE 01"11ON) Dewitt NEW it' ' o u s~°� O 1 72nd Floor Roof '� _ 7 O O • / T/2nd Floor01 U er area) Existing"Altusia"smooth finish '� issi f•Z•l a•,. CRICKtT - i Roof - ( pp 1 = Term Coto Barrel Tde W remain. • b` TT.symMl (lower area) - _:.- (Natural Terra Cutta Color) Cl) i, '� la) ! t DJ � a / OA a mesa � w (/© * IasII s," a aaie . EXISTING n NEW TRUSSES&NEW \� C.) t--i _,_, ROOFING::Tamko t4 \ .- 1st Floor _ REPLACE Existing Y x 4' "AWAPLAN"Cap Sheet over 2 Roof to be curb mounted Skylight layers of Fiberglas over 43Lb !3 40'- " x • w/Nett'"MAXIM"Brand Tamko Base Sheet(installed per ' Re-roofed Impact Rated,Low E 15year warranty directions and ,t. Dao- t::u<xom Glass.',Curb Mounted current NOA)over 5/8"CDX I .i model. current Plywood Roof Decking.Use '� Compatible PVC or Bronze Roof yam,• a}> New 1st Fluor Drains where shown and all +C.L/ Rcct Area Existing 170lb modified roll roofing tube `all i r r c\alt REMOVE Existing 2'x 4' copper Flashing&Scuppers -I- _..(. J replaced Cap Sheets over with New 170Lb layers of i i Skylight&Install 5/8" where shown. 35'-8" u- 2 / a CDX Ply and 170Lb • l8'4" Fiberglas over 43Lb Tamko Base Sheet / Tamko Awaplan PATCH. 54'-6" 4 (installed per i 5year warranty directions and • ,el Sloan.ARSS�TI (Price Option Item) current NOA)over existing 5/8"CDX D1te- -•' Net.3"x 4"Cep per Scupper and Pl d Roof Decki Use all r don•nspaul irim1ar51 Slde of New roof )^a'1O rb'• ct)PPe .a'''Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+LD. segnnon Flashing&Scuppers where shown. Ion SF.7th Avenue.Ste P. -Relocate Existing Copper Scupper and Replace existinggalvanized mtl.Wall Flashing Deha}'Bc43-5 a'c763 do.,nspout from West ui roof K trot)24_R755 segment to South Side as shown. with New Copper Lapped Flashing per details. "_. (Typical all Low Slope list Floor Roofs un Eresidence) NEW ROOF PLAN— w/ NEW SECOND FLOOR - Scale:1/4"=1' 0" Sloan Residence MASTER SUITE ADDITION 106 SE 7th Avenue NEW ROOF PLAN Approx.Roof Areas:9 square of new flat deck,2 square of of It fain Residence&Garage barrel tile roofing,7 square of optional garage roofing. +" r."..m D.Shan Anus Res WO.Ste. New Roof Plan -'D.Slam At bated A2.05 o'Awn a,ss,t A2.05 2/1//w:7 —a/— Sisa,:;"h5eslr�amsis si, Total • Existing 3/4"Water Meter&New City Installed 1" The NarkStrai n,n these Plans Mull Comply I Ssma,®tun r..irnwaw PVC Water Service Piping to Residence.(Complete ,nth the 2D1d FknJa RWIJmg C.•Je.,/any New Water Main Installed under SE 7th Avenue w/ encenJments and(as aprl hl)th w $ a° 1"PolyFrom Main to Water Meter). \e,n,on of thr Flonda Atcha IFk tnml, a S 89-09'00"E 135.00' PNDa Pwmh,n J t an a td - d(s). O - - - - - - - - _ _ _ UPGRADE METER TO 1^SIZE. + v x x �_ _ _ _ _ _ _ (0.07'Wi Q;, ,,., Framing and OtherStructural l`ral ,W I.will aLso 0 Fx0 PK/WASYER .- O Leine of Roof Above _ •- ____ (o.15'xl _�-Cm J `D mtv P. 0. a Z --- - ! S L , am ♦az• • c Q E ungr PVC El teas - I ' 6.00' sssras _ �1' ,.:i'Suck k Sewer Run I J 1111 �, _ 11110114.:',4 _ - _'i. 'x Oh SE 7th Ave. ''' w ❑ . xisting 1 story a n pj be. ❑ ara e - PM xisting 1 story Residence- u... • 106 SE 7th Avenue Sloan J;Sloan r- t U Da.ay H,adi 5 en uc2S ok,taabu • i .uLeaRa t O -� ' to o0rr25AARa5T N1 t\L {,{I6�W_Yo • 1r 1 1 ,� e S - No. Dale Appr Rama Notes 0 MET I, n. 1 �, -� .I. 1 /,0/I7 Add Nee 3'1'/5 Sewer Run.au. END l (0.13' �no® _ _ -O_y,a _ _ _ _ FNO IR d, 1SIM Wrt Sewer Into,New 1-Water Mo. a.. - - - _ _ - - _ _10.11'E),t O IMF 71. klq i/1:/f- ISSUED WRCCU'IPLCDJ!� FNC aKk ,0.15%) \�.� _ E osn',/ . 10.15'N) `� .- . ki !•^ tea S r_,L: iggi EXISTING SITE PLAN Scale:1/S"=1'-0" �— COPYRIGHT NOTICE PHOTOS of Existing Field Conditons of Proposed Tie in of nol.b.,mn... .. new 3"PVC Sewer to Existing 3"PVC Stack and Sewer run at north side of garage.(tie in and added cleanouts per plans) U cri c U o ).0 sue,s'1 O Existing 3/4"Water Meter&New City Installed 1" I-t~ E 0"�ra-t rua,tcxxcEPVC Water Service Piping to Residence.(Complete >r. New Water Main Installed under SE 7th Avenue w/ a) 0.t-I cu ,yea 1"Poly From Main to Water Meter). rN�/ S 89-09'00"E n I-s� CD O - - _ _ _ _ _ - - 135.00'- - - UPGRADE METER TO 7"SIZE. (ouJ�'w) Q) 1 New •- Sewer--New 3"PVC - __ _--- MD PNINPSNER Q t,ne of R.w[.{bate Cleanuut ' (D.ts'x' t • - 1 New Cleanout--, _ U O • Eotmg r•P{'t_. 4--J - seo near os 09 '• stall i • Sena,Run - ' w v V xo. Doe bout No. f .,--' NOV 3"PVCSudk Sew.Run:to 0e moo O mamas , X • 106 SE 7th Avenue • existing Unused 3-PVC Sewer Pipe under ,.s m u) W Existin•1 story - North t1 all of E.isting Garage Bldg.tv/(2)Kew m r r b leawnCn•haaahu.tn. ❑ Garage/Study s"n. Eel, ❑ In \ . o• (l'4o Changes) NM a Existing 1 story Residence w/ Proposed Second Story Master Suite Addition-106 SE 7th Avenue o' n' `o > \ ., tDyntel sh.....{Rv5?A • 27_g., o 1)a1 1 future zne�Ky , rr ,,.,,a.a —o Sluaii&Shia '1 L ExwUng4.IN.' I„:or, �' -� O ."�"�' n % n,nr.SE7thechzre+lnt.Design o sass xner Run ru ,.utwe Phase zr Cr.{l, I e - 106 SE 7th A•e. Delray Reach,FL 33413.3 C residence -- --- O •- - • bnF r /Pn po a I n N h knm Eusung Nbra,y ails c Ic 1 &I II are h�, P (rw1121'-KISS Fsenad:dslaanL'eluandesign.Frz e- • I New 2ncl Story Balcony Above I ..uyl (Future Phase 2 1 I Co .' I,o - y Q @ y J Y '� �(� �j tr�� Replace lauls,DM:uuR f 0 .y'f �04 QOWE I . r FmrAD r*'7 WJiKwi/ 'J FNO I- Q •-ctt _ _ ;. ., e„ Una_(PRICE RID I d. sane tder Sloan Residence Renovations i0,13'E • _ a s.�,_ _ _ _ ♦ - - 1. _ .t _ _ _ _ (0,1 PE)6 y,at O� „PR In•6. - _ _ 33-6" Existing layout `/ NOOK/WASHER &Proposed New Layout ' E E We 7 r Ntg•3" Nenv DM loco Fr.nm 13.w/ (o.t s'x) ..,,,.•. _ iN.sent w,wt:�ac SITE PLAN Existing Site Plan Sr SITE PLAN: Proposed New Addition(s) nSlum Prop ell Layout in9e Scale:1/S"=1'-O" —d D.a m rtir.. l/e-,r-o' 111 Site Plans -"o. A1.01 u.ren&PW L oh Res.,2Yta,wx +47.4,-515 ' The%&•r4 Shown in these Pln,Shall Comrty with the 2014 Flonda Building Code w/any ,Amendments and(as applicable)the same 7..--- A n of the Honda Ale hem.4 Electrical. • r•7 `Plumbing,and F Aenng Building t'ode(a1. +48.5,-526 Framing and other Souctural Details u ill alw '-24.-7"Top of Parapet mr•h,,th t'i:-aXrrre, ) sm'I'-'-, NI �� i 47.4, S I.S ti ICI -t ,1 llt�- - ®. E I � @a t .--.IZ-7"2WFl FFL R aItwnveen uld/rim • j � --_P`dr^'. t -o(np) V l2'-7"Second Floor '� I- F /9'-0" FFL::Master Bedroom&Bathrcwm _ _Y'-s-2w Fl.FPLUm 4rea \ 71H a#1 �nr-r� �.I— H 2(T A + NM �1 1 f ',, -1+46.3,-50.4 ! _1 `'\ � / 4"Bath 2 FFL -S"Patio FI l_ _ ( 5t n sw.,Inc C I x {r ta,t `-43.5"U"Mary finished Floor Level t aF ce:�.Y. 1r �y Elsa. Finished First FlooFlor Os, 2, E5 (� Finished Floor Level 1 �. \ New South Elevation:Main Residence "A-A3.03" Y ' Scale:1/8"=1'-0" { 1 7- '- j { I i�! /-- (F10 - 7 /,.� +46.3, 60.6 a s/aa,c Changed mawv-"from vPasa Parapet / I I +48.5,-52.6 i� 2 3 Int 11 �' f. �' /'.. l2•-7,.� �i -fir.4, _ µ.ay -® i r r / 2nd Fluor 1 1-c - Area FFL Closet C)N}Rlr iR N.)TlCC FFL-Master _ �/� Bedroom e.ao., t -0 rt... rate aj f r FJ'trr.tiv 4 MI IJJ . f,- P m.,r,u „'(/\ First Floor i _-- K a .gal - --'� cu J e�,Ncsrigs,Risers t. - FFL U r J�-+rre6whed popl_: CONNECTOR-2;t/2"606t T6 Alum.— a,-' .., O Pmvdercuated White tr l 2"55 ThruF..lt New North Elevation:Main Residence "B-A3.03" -0 r ,w New Stair_Axonometric-Cutaway View From Scale:1/s°=r-o" I cn > -r v Scale:N.T.S. � r- N � • c�w o 4-47.4,-51.5 n . 'C 24.-7..Tor at ton Cate ,,,,,nnux V 7.. — ,r art • - Topof � a+-1aR'H>a)a'. -- _ Para• pet /'. . 7- k- I '9 -aq q v a ii1j�(t , •— —"-S 21' I t" st 1� t� • a '+ D I Ir tit I' _1 ``t1t1 1 D I 16 4 I 1 I - 1 I Cullum Ell ! _l2'-T'F. _ _ _ _ — —1� - i camel�l'an 4R�qr 13i ,. t / `. Master Bd.Rm. ��,-11. eat __`` YS" ar`--T- --G FF4• _ - m '��.Sloan&Sloan-Architecture+LD. t'luset 1065F.7th A.enue,Ste F • - 1 - Area t 4^�•(I _ Delia)Bch.FL i-+4c: -43.5 9_ __ - t _ _. _Ist Fl.,or d try.- _ - _ _ _ _ . -_� 4 -r ,nt Fl• . -• "st Fl.c EFL rrt LibraryFF'_ -i +46.3,-50.4 __—.- FFL v.:,L�.,�.`r:a°rNw�nM t. FFL . FF'_ .-w waln r'"`4 Sloan Residence mW1 �nt.w. +46.3,-50.4 MASTER SUITE.ADDIT4in1 • New East Elevation:Main Residence New West Elevation:Main Residence 106 SE 7th Avenue • "C-A3.03" "0-A3.03" _-' IViNTJ PRFSSLRES Scale:1/8"=1'-0" Scale:1/8"=1'•0" &STAIR DETAILS Wind Pressures, T.uEt5loar. ... Span Res"`'a"' „ ,,. „ „. Details, Schedules °""" Aa"ate New Stair Support Beam Connector 1 , New Stair Support Beam Connector 2 , S2.03 pan 52.03 Srcale:N.T.S.' 6`cale:N.T.S.- ; a,Rny 51u Alstr SS-Coo,to t.,. 1i't I The Wert 5hu n in these plan.Shall Damply T R L C'T URAL NOTES(continued) with the 3114 Florida Building Cede Av/any STRUCTURAL NOTES-.5%uun Re:Fid nee P �eci Amendments and(as applicable/the same Ven(odlum•ro110 1 . -..u..X1l501> n of the Florida klnhar.ai. w) el. Plumbing,andExisting _;;,). rTMI40RR DESLtWnes,Arome0S,P RE0IATWN TO EVDTING SINGLE PAMELA RESIDE0FUI STALL T:RE. S.,L ALLAIAn`NRS OLDMNS SHOWN ON PLANSHAL L EXTEND FRUAI Framing and OtherSIT. I:also 63S.4COMREVRE.'G INTOP4'4I NTRE.TLRE, DIAPHRAGM TO OLIPHMGA(LIE FLOOR TO ROOF FLOOR TO FLOCRI EH: I with ACC-tiiklNpre .LASIFICIERN: ID1a R7 IU.O.N_I -WORN I .vmp Y14T _ __ _ �. 1 ALL SL4X'NRI:ULUAO:S AT WINDOW AND DOOR JAMB,,SHALL.TEND hoe •((41 KING NOTE DIE NTRA•,TOR 15 LEL RES INSIBI.E FOR INMAIING, s� FROM DIAPHRAGM R`OI.VHMG4t MR FLVR TO WOE.MAJOR TO „l-. I AKITA RIFNt,AND S00(000NG LLxa Fyn PR U'FRONS'40 PREGRAL.IN 'FLOM IUU..I. -.. CUNNECIIUN WNW THE WORK THE FIE:INFER F RELURD U NOT RF-TVNRLF FOR THE A NO I IFTNUDS LW CONSTRUCTION UR FUR MT ATM X..,PRECAUTIONS AND ..il CLINCRFFE CI`LUFINS - ' rR`GRAAL. - -- I 0010ANDs't1A1p.ARUS ;.W.L MRT ALLL"O E NLL'1EN'SSH N WUNHALLEMENDPR•Bt - DLAPHRAGM TU OHROAPALY B ILO.0 HOUR TO ROOF.FLUOR TO FLUOR IU,N.• _ PER FLoRIDA ILDING J I.WIND WIOS4AI .pk VoSd-LTLnph DOE,IDIa EDITION. ;.IR24LL CONCRETE COLUMNS AI WINDOW AND DOORJAMBS SHALL EXTEND . 7- `v - - ALL EXPOSURE IL PROM DIAPHRAGM TU DIAPHRAGM LIE M.A.EWE FILURN sot no • - -- aLC RIM.CATFA.,11 LL FVRMIL.Uh1 RN•RC La.EINT.BNEILAS As - -.I -I. _ a TP.FNMAwVli UCIURE CAI AS al, S.I fUNRA • 11 THE PALLIECT WAS 15..NFD IN ACCU.AAEITDI THE h L MASONRY UNITS SHAL L BEAST ITS GRADE N ABOVE GRADE WITH,IINILIMI - - 1=.. ` LL1.FLORIDA AULCING LODE.SEISE EDITION; LVALPRWnESTRFNGTH OF 1pI0 PM UN NM'AREA OF INDIVIDUAL UNITE ALL __ u._BUILDING SIOF RFt;LIREMENTSNR RDN'NRC'Eb CONCRETE IALI 31S. LAID SHALL BE LAID IN AFULL BED OF MUPFAR II.RUNNING BUNDIC.I:.U.l LAT@TFDn10NL s.2 ALL MORTAR SHALL BE T'IPfic IN ACLDROANCE WITH ASTM NO\FI.'ATION.SO T nyar WITH A MINIMUM COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH OF 1,10 PSI AT K DAAS Aw - ALI.MANUAL UF STANDARD PRACTIEFLA DETAIL I.AMEFu AMER./RCM TYP.BOND BEAM STEP DETAIL --� el a.Slaan`Inc TRULTURFS TALI MS,LATE.F,CRIUNIL S.L GROUT SHALL BM1 In.SLUM...IN ALi RO N WRIT Tt P IFICAt1ON a ION OF R AI'_. J7e HAM.G A I.UNIMUM WDAIPRSIVF TRENGM)F 010 PSI J... SPNIT 1)0N FOR SIRLI T:RAL L 0NCRETE FOR WILD UGS iA“NI L Ari PLAN.VIEW 1E,1- PLAN VIEW Delray R. WTSt E,IT.UNL SaALLI. 'ARTS MAASN0.A BEARING 4PIDSIIE R4 LL W.4LLBE ANSTRI:CTEC so act,13,7- UNIN DOTED PY A QUALIFIED ENGINEER.ND ANSTRU IN ACCORDANCE WITH - kR - 425.MANUAL OF>tANCARD'RUTILE FOR WELDING-REINFORCING S.M. THE-WILDING ODE REQUIREENT NR MSOP0,TOURI. RK Al - ""'- DLL.LA UNNOhNIN RF3hNR.S CON,RTE CVNSfRI•TR`N 14fA5 -TS? ND-SPECIFICATIONSONRAt{SJNP'.1A4"ILRES CI IBM ANT DLL.LATET ED O.B 5 kJ.UK DA1cµB•aOa ' ;1 LtaI1F1 A�W� TI`A FOR HOOD CONTEL lq ®f- N.L. NATWNALDEIC. 'iNDa LATBT u.PRUVID .. L4SLNRBEOM WITH SIDk B4S1DE.'U CONTINUO.'AT ----- - - 1 r ,I EDCODE E1RR,IAINWN"SILL EXTEND BP S•BECJNO EDGE`E OPENWG Lw_ IL. ,--- - ��'�� �-' -�P.N.NKTML - L7.WILDntGIUO RPC ONTO AND SPELIFiCATIO FUR M Be1.0VIDE HOT DIPPED GALVANIZED LADDER TP6 HORRUM VINT B• Oiiiii - STRUCTURES I ACT-.WSIaI A415r..{sT1JJ-rn_95 REINFORCEMENT Pc.\lAt le'UN CENTER tt•R1ICM.IN-ALL ALISJNM:WALLS. ___ FDITIUNSL PRO IDE D°.TAR Sit?ANGELL,.AT CONCRETE NLLIINS. ♦c�snrn J_A.40411.m N;.1mvN00 OLUMN- PLAN VIE PLAN VIEW ,. .-_.._.._, ''''1'..."' , sprat� w A aNIIAd . S.SIITIQNS AND➢TAll5 ALL 1. N SHOWN ON PLAN SHALL EATEND FRUAt . ....•Lan DIA HRA4 I TO DL PHP_AGM LE FLOOR TU RUOE FLOUR.FLUOR �aL� - 5.I ALL DFIAILSSaTI SAND roSHOWN ON THE DRAWINGS ARE INTENDED TO IUD. 1 i TYPICAL MASONRY DETAILS Client AppN/1nr alert' _ BETYP . DSH.L APPE1 TV SIMILAR 511LArIONS EIS-E\VHETIE IR:LE. P�.1 OTHERWISE SEILWN.L 7 ALL ILWBR UL WINDOW AND DOUR IAMBS SHALL EMEND _ _ _ 2'3I .4/17/17 Isvied fur Consiu.linn• FROMD R{,AI TO DIAPHRAGM MR FLOUR TO ROOF,FLOOR TO - --- 1 5 FOUNDATON FLUOR,IL.J.N.L �y •Y BI.ALI.SITE PREI'.ARATIoN AND ESCALATION WORE KW BE PERE,..IM5 IN STRICT - ES 9 E11'FITS A SUILSAND WL'NCATIuNS INVESTN-.ATN PREPARED BYA�, g 40051.RULT N • APNEA'.TESTING LABURAIMK PAIL/TO FOU NDATNA WORK_rPFr �oI 1.L SPIN":GROUT FOR ALL EIBEDEC REAR DOWELS AIrO.....1.10.SHALL BE - 1 _ e rAr C.I THE BDUDIN.SITE SHOULD BE EXL'AVATFL TO THE DEPTH AND 5TENT TNINUATEl STMPSON SET EPOA":DR HELM INC.EPDXY "\ Ie -- " SLITS THE SI.RPC.ALL SUPGRACES 51i1LL REAPPROVED INtVEM.B1 THE SS.-m.SU - -' ENGINEER PRIOR To BACKER.. Il INIU. =`I- r u{BOTTOM of FFXJ1LGS.-SSLAIED TO BEAD ON"OIL NABLE OF S,AFT,A IO.L ALL STRUTURAL WOOD MEIBERS ARE DESIGNNED 1 ORI USE MOISTURE ��-"am 1 �' SUPPORTSNG 2:W NO.APPROVALIIIARIIIN-MUST INDICATE THE SOIL IS CONTENT MUST ES LRS.OR LESS.STORE 11000 FRAMINC.AROVELROLIN.AND ..MACS1UNMdgA ---_ - SB1015•t`WTAu .1DEQEATE 1U 5.1FIR SLSTLN SPFJTFIED SUM BEARING PRESSURE. ENDER CARPS WITH PROPER AIR 4I001110ION - I. 04 TOP OF ALL EEO..F01`TINGS SHALL BE INTPILAI41 SMOTE W=ALI L111PEEEAi.ALL BEA'LTSEERN PINE STET.a_LAC413E OR 1rrRNE2`EQUAL _ N EXTERIOR KNISH GRDEC.N,CO ALLOWABLE DESIGN SIRESSES SHALL MUM-NATIONAL15 DESIGN SPETFEP000 , �/ A asRAbaPE - COPYRIGHT NOTICE OS LATEST EDITION).N.SHALL BE ELSE PSI MIN.ALL BEARING IVALLS TO BE PRENDRE 3 • 05 E%I_AA'ATIO11001EiLLALL EI VATTL SHALL BE KEPT DE'.E1LAA'ATE N TREATED PINE BETTER. �_- __ iE_ - - LxA�•µ1Wyr1d - P+�•waBlVc A OGAR.1.AND DIS�NRAS INDILATED,TARE EVERT PRNAMTONR`GUARD - ?F ��1 / FIST.wn�.b.� �;� 4GMI:ST N'BICriEIIET OR SETTLEMENT OF ADJACENT STAUI'TtRE.LTRITtES. W.I PINTOS-P--♦PILL. 041 TREATED LUMBER P Ml1 Rp,\N.E WRH.141TA • 11' PRL'GTI.PROVIDE.N,BILN'EG URSH0RENG N'D-ESIRA TO.AVUN STANDARDS TVA MLDsII0 v.1XE RETENTION MARFRLSLN10NL11T MBR.O.T�t�y IOW ES 6� ' s•w. �nwI.I.II....ru.u-..G.... s TTLEIsxIT OR 1.1,LN:wa T OF..NG FOUNDATION OR STRt TIRES. WIN CONCRETE MAKIN.UR uf1TSNE OFBCIDINC.AIL I WEAL IN0UMAT KITH T- W'ra Am' ei DIMENSION ALL 13 TENSIONS AND ELEVATIONS SHOWN UN THE STRL'CTLR{L 1VLVDIREIFEkO H LLPE NOT GIPPED GALL'.,{AIDED JRSTAINLESS'ST£EC. ' DRAWINGS MCI.BE VERIFIED AND-VORDINATEDW WITH THEIRHnDTL - ENE TYPICAL MASONRY FILLED CELL DETAIL DRAWINGS BA TiHI.ELISRLTOR BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH THE.UNTP ,- TYPICAL CONCRETE COLUMN DETAIL A1� Ll O1(040NCTE SHALL..BROUGHT TO THE 101100UNU0 THE ARiTDI-- MaLROOE 0I ID.EIUSSES I.RATED,PLKTOOD SHEATHING, _ x1 �..•J. r\"'I CI) ENGINER IN WRITING PEPURE PWCEEDING WITH AS,WORE. NNNECT TO TR.,.WITH NMS L J'EDGES e"FIELD WHO., U `L 0•A�J 7.CUN0RF'TF 111101E FRAMING PLANS FUR SEARING AND UR BLOC..PEOU1RE 1EMS. y 0 >4 0•� �L.ALL.:IP..'LRSETT.To...RPM UNLFY"Nu II..S''0 LUNG 14.BE WIDE SHEET.S WITH LENGTH NLTgS FRAM., AA1i� r NETTED oil..,E STAGGER PANEL ENDIDINTSJ-•C'TR.ALLANV 1.1 SPACE ALLJ. W - CI) TIE BEI ELAND COLUMN:VW PM PURR IT PANEL EDGE,AND END VINA 0A4T4 mmtt r- r r UK 1. 01E MAK.GPLAN F RDIAPHRAGM N*WSSO TIT.SIZE,MM... Dy+Y 100000 V �� _Y 4 tos r •r-J .� rrr+ UK SLAB GRADE 70W PSI lug.T L %p,.... �'R' -y. .,,--} cn c1 /_5 Vcy t. RA GROUT NAN PE D E:'FL S ALL NAILS USED FOR STRUCTURAL F1AAIIN E IRS /� �� • I I � ID NAI W O'r^(�y�4-L SH.4 - L ALLN' L OLSHANG AIK -^C!�. \v\ - - - - - • - 03 SLUMPS SHALL BEJ MINIMUM ANTS"ALLXIML'M L.CM.ILLB GALVANIZED QM RRUSNERE.. a METAL -' ^1 • STRAPS...BFn TALLEO WITH RU AL U LIT BOL THERANT 1.11,U,- PIBnEe 'S Sin _ �_ - N:/ -A ALL LAONCRFTF.ToHA1FALAXHIL41WATRL'ENIENTRA11u ELF a. KILIPSo L , FNFL"NRPRLNLLTSORA.R.F R&M. 9 - • a _ +w gBMF.1v1PAt SHALL NOT BE ADDED. 11F HAILING WILL NOE BE MWEITFED, o • T�`�y !' r ALL JEL RET S WORE SHALL.UMPLI WITH THE RELIC IREAIEIS OP THE UI 11.wWDIRL:4B m �F•.. • O +J BUILDING I ODE IV IIRLT.T EDITWNI THEM]DETAILING MANUAL IN)I ST-. ILL WOO ROOF ERUNi."HAVE BEEN DESIGNED IA PROF.MONAL P.IALIV e� . ^I l.r BUILDINGS EI TIONL LAND THE WEL FOR TRUITLRAL C ONCRETE FOR ENGINEER REGLSTERED IN THE STATE F FLORIDA. 'm. �/'N WOOD TRUSS...ALL BE ERN.IN At C CRD.AN'.F ITH THE-TALK PI ATE �' LI.OoslNxl GIPIIIF1av AAv. VJ r� -.L.CONCRETE COVER FOR REINFORCE..STFFL SHALL BE....REMUERFD EN THE. I1_tV INTILIOIE HANDLING.DWIALLING AND BRACING OF IIWD TRUSTS LATEST All SPETTFII'.1DONS. CUMMEATAIW AND RD VAIMED.AnONS,HIS ION ESITIUNI.BRACING IN THE S..1: PLANE OE THE WEB AIEIBEIC: rt At .T.ALLRWFU LNG TFMSHALL PE AUNUFACTURFD FROM H.4 STRENGTH BILL.1 MSS..0..M Gro AFPBUC E -.. vulx sNEumLAssaPmlr wnuAo•LL Lora STFE.fOMOIUIINI: TIDEN -cGR{DF.si nLtATO4L BRACIW:SH.AtLBEPFS"IAAINN BAUMTONaL PR{CINGIPIM ITHiCI: i Ages: rce e,A Ar[rinR¢islgCt not Ammo,la lvEmm wUc NUABNAItU'AI{OI,IHWBR4ClNGti1U BECUNIINUOLS ---- -. _.. eLA.NSNELM.AS TO,COM 14.M...I No. DAM',.LAP ALL BARS MINIMUM U OL ITEic - ER1 SE NOTED ON DRA1etric, , qS LA'ALL IMF A MINIM,OF a INCH.(UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED; FLEA MINIMUM OF TWO RI.OF DIACONAL PEAL INC.ALMM..ONSAT EACH - XAr... - [MICAL W0r LEMUR CLOSET N BEAMING LLICATUN' -__'1 _ - IS PAT.WS 'I RMNFOPlTN`BARS. ..0,„„,,,,,,,,.,,,,,....,..urmrorwo. ...WHERE COLUMNS ARAM:INTEGRAL PART OF CONCRETE WAIL,WALL 115.THE BOTTUMMALS STALL PE P.C.B':CONTINUOUS LATERAL P.CO./. - --- --- REINNRCTIENTSHALLBfiNNTININUUSrHRUTH6COLUIihS. STAEDAT Y-1 ON CESTEP.TITH♦EIUNG ATUH-MUSSES. WTNII OF Y �' ' .v.2 ALL HOU.SHUWH IN REINFURLTAIE.T SHALL BE ACI PBi ML1.131. TRUSTS IF NU CEILINGIS ATTACHED To BC'TTLII OF TRUSSES,BELAUD SRAE st4 n . b T I EBP HOURS UNLESS UMWVISE NOTED, BE ARNIANM DN EITO AILED ILL THE TUPCF THE BURUI HOP. Tv1 RJR I:RUDE BEAMS LAP ALL NPSTEL AT AnLS'PAN.ANC LAP BOTTo °LAGUNA.PLACED. K U4:REH TO THE LATERAL BRACES SHALL BE ,. M. n V' -, ^i , 11 { 11.-IUVOSL•PNRI LOCATED AT EACH END..BUILDINGEL REDS al Fh TO:LENGTH DMLONAL _ \ t ;.5A.CO T5UCTIUN MINIS IN STRUCTURAL SUBS AND BEAT IS SHALL BE T BRACING SHOULD BE ROTATED AT ID WT INTERVALS MC.urawlta �� 1a I J. n IIDSTANAHD REVLOIN..`WIN)RE.NWPLTLIG LUNTUIUULS ACE, >amel SIU'an,ARV5e i 11•iNt,AND ADDToNAL SHEAR FNITUN REIINNRING. - Ll'b✓t` It worm muss.ICVN1 IN U EDE L.,Nc._.Rn-111I-4 PmVn NAv mawRLN.v % 710.IVNCRELE COLUMN: v.AAa.. wffiS. \Lu ,gym `I ••+ '.10.1-ALLCUNCRETF NLL'11A:S SHUIt1.UN PLAN SHALL EXTEND FAUAI 11.6 PUP L'IIURD BRACING.IF PLVIVWODR'RINI:SAPPI.IFD OIPECTa 11 Tor arum P4i11 R' i1Pfu;eu6a'u bSluan lIOr SFan-Architecture+l.D. CIAPEIR5GII To DIAPHRAGM HEFLouRTURIOF FLUAIR To FLuoRT PPUPERLA LAPPED AND NAILED TO DNF0UP DIAPHRAGM ALT1UN.BY_A11NG 0•-, u0©T9'�la -.1.1". LP�U��0L lv'r nm15VNUFFO�mcru (11iI SF.71h.A1-enue,5[e.6 IU,OALE REDDER..IF MATINS ARE USED.DIA.NAL NP CHORD BRAW LNG LS REQUIRE D L .4sLs L+J•RA.vN.W"IC ur Delray Bch,FL 334E3 AT SAL-H EEO IF BUILDING EG:ED5 M FEET IN LFl:G15t,DIAGONAL 0RAL'It, ..11t2 nLL.AINC.RE.E C:VLCAINP.4i tA.NDCI\'AND DOUR LAMBS SHALL ETFFNO SHOULD BE REPEATED AT 3FWT INTERVALS. .AILS ,,._,..,,,,,,,,,„....,..0,„,,,,„.,,,”,„„,,,,,,,,,„..,.,,,, Col)2L'-FTI55 FROM DIAPHRAGM N OLAPHR{GM:!LE FLUOR TO ROOF.FLOOR N -•S++x•s Iu EI,vClBenui FLOUR ICON, II'.DU Wei CUT,DELLOR NOTCHR%TF OR FLOOR TRUSS.TVTFHJL1 IYARTEIN SUMS ISOCAIM.µLWIA1SKr.v..,¢urrE w1ILWITILL moelxeG -�•'�• T.MASONRY AM.:AL FRIAtTfel.E,CINETR LIVROOUTE MBILAPIPAL ELE•'TRC.1L aA .V®.. 'd 'IErAUTnO�n+rc_ PLUBRING.SITE STIES:AND LOCATION'S WITH TRUSS LAID,PRIOR TO EPOTOH. S.IM.a50NE,UNITS0f.1LL BE AST.LN0 GRADE N ABOVE GRADE VI ITHIRNTAIUM >"�Aa.4 E+Ilses mnE .O`MPREATVE>TRFNGTH OF ZINu PH ON RI000IA OF INDIVIDUALCNHS..ALL «,1.,51.1.LL OEALINUTCI...IT4,DCIGNED IN Atl`RD.AN£HIM NATIONAL - v,A+BCAa,wcq w.v_LgA µ CPR:SHALL BE LAID L-A FULLBED oe AtORrA0.IN RUNNING BOND I:'.NU., DESIGN S(E10.000 L`Nin FOR WL`C`D'V NSTECI TRIO„0 4 PA-AND NATIONAL 1s�..ra sl ALL MORTAR Sit\LL B6TTFSIN ACCORDANCE DESIGN TDWD,ARD NRILRAL PLATE•:U0NELTED WOOD TRL,5CONSTRL'-TION. - 4.6yyy N Sloan Residence RD.ANCE wIT11 ASTI SPF_T.ICATION O. .NI'TN T IS,AND THE LOCAL CODE LURSDBTUNS. mM.A IAINuILtt coslrREn'n'E>TREL:cM OF Lsm PA AT aL D.M.S. .mmn-EI.14ONfrc,Tnr,Ilm1.w0r--c. %..,.N MASTER SUITE ADDITION I..DO NOT OVERLOAD ROOF TRU..MTH BLDG MATLs - 106 SE 7th Avenue 1.3.GEL UI MALL BE.A HIGH MC..NILO IN AL,V RD.ANCE TOTH ASTt SP&ER:ITWN Ruse CLSHAVINGABIINDIEII•...EP145015E STRENGTH OF 10NI PM rlW.CONNELIOR r1.10 SHALL PE MINUE:1,UPD P1 A IAT.;A MEMBER PLATE 4O 40 0011A'"•em MM., TYPICAL BEAM BAR PLACEMENT.DIAGRA!.'l SLTP.R AND KLATT FEET - '^T" SPRCLTCTAILS FS& STALL...Mt IAAMLNR':PfiARNIA.SHEAR WALLS SHALL BE CONSTRUCTED • L'saEa CSC ' INSPECTED P.,OUALIIFD ENGINEER.AND CONSTRUCTED IN ACCORDANCE WTIH en- %"gGTem[a%CCR•m MI DETAILS THEELILDING NEE PFCUEEITENT FOR LLASUNIE,STRUCTURES-L.ACIS.ASCE R.MISC. STRUCTURAL NOTES-a .Ae✓„e,7a zr.7a ar `E 150TO10 5 TSAI N.AND ST2IFIC.4TILIINS FOR ALASEKLI,TRU TURD-LACE 5.W,1?.r F s ESN 0,.anT EDITION). I All operating French Glass floors,00,t ind,lol to he provided with vinyl insect screens.XIl glazln0 to he a r.>_. rv..o S.S.PR0110EA-CS ALAS0NRVBSAMISIIH 1S5,51C150000 C0N5N000S.VT laminated insulated LOIIL•impact Rated Glass.thickness as pertm5ldaITurers spec.(See Door.`Windnw ErsRQ:m, aurrYw.alh�ti CMS' 4D.Slsio 51>0,Res s'OV Ste ESR':IVINWll i1LL E`nE005501IV"BE'.vNp EDC.SUE UP6NLG. `Lh1Ihde)\I1slidinggl d JT Fixed Panels if required by Cook TO IV tempered shall bc,nlcmpertJ at 2n.1.M.0�5M V 0W 4D~I Structural Notesl 'PRuI IDS HOE DIPPED L:ILVAN�D LADDER SAFE HURPOIJi>C TUDCT no upcl0IRR to E L I Ede A.pp -d Il1un IT to V r Well aA required an 1)glazed.Lmdorcl and douls if -�•D.Slam Al NaUAI REINFORCEMENT 0GA.AT1e ONC:TOA'OTI:AL n:ALL AIAA)00 WALLS 11IpaL1To I.4 PLUS IS nut tit din: (.nII 0..A'_Lh.dLaLI WOOD TRUSS BRACING DETAIL Schedules, Details .:...1L PROVIDE DOVE TAR SLOT ANCHORS AT,VN'IRETE,.VLLl1IA's. S8.01 .C...Rn,00N RI' SB•D1 ALL TRUSS to TRUSS CONNECTORS To BE SELECTED BY THE TRUSS ENGINEER AND FURNISHED BY THE TRUSS FABRICATOR. Of t170n x 51001 EniUSR Ste_Om1 IS u. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD , CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 5, 2018 ITEM: 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District — Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for an elevation change and change in proposed use from a medical office to a mixed-use building (medical office and residence). RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness GENERAL DATA: Nt 9th'St Owner/Applicant S&E Holdings, Inc. ok Q° _" ,-4'� tiettiiirilrilliF. 41.' . ri'l Agent Gary Eliopoulos, AIA ed, - 60101111111 � r ii " GE Architecture, Inc. 1' : : :. iyi_- , t ems r^- ;r ; ' ri- s Location. South side of George Bush '1NtilL Boulevard at the intersection with '0 .; N. Dixie Boulevard .. o. z ' ;. `. w t • : _ . Property Size• 0.46 Acres ,1 ;a._ K y� 1r Historic District: Del-Ida Park Historic District �^ ` ` a il �� ` Zoning. RO (Residential Office) z ; �, .. : ._-Ir.. Adjacent Zoning. - i . 1r� North: RO , ,� �"'i East: RO .. x : #41/ek ' .z9South: RO ' d. r r_tWest: RO �' ,�.�' '*.�,: ��- �, �-._ Armie �, .ter 1 �, • j 7- Existing Future Land `� I "� Use Designation. TRN (Transitional) AYStr, ': l ' .' Water Service. Public water service is rovided 4 de '+� ' ' p . . . 'ems ei s 4.,04.,d i1 on site. �. Sewer Service. Public sewer service is provided Pr `,g.4V F % 4 -, ". ' '' ��on site. ( . ,;� s , �, } " ,. � NORTH ::�j-,:it -.; t. Mom..;._ - a .- ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is consideration of approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) (2019- 022)for an elevation change and change in proposed use from a medical office to a mixed-use building (medical office and residence) located at 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject 0.46 acre property is located on the south side of George Bush Boulevard, between NE 2nd Avenue and NE 5th Avenue (Federal Highway), consists of Lots 23 and 24, block 11, Del-Ida Park and contains a 3,837 sq. ft. office building. The property is located within the Del-Ida Park Historic District and the Residential Office (RO)zoning district. The structure was built in 1959 as a residential duplex. In 1977, architect Charles E. Toth designed a major remodel of the structure which included a substantial addition that was built for conversion of the duplex to a dental office for Dr. A. Merlin Wuebbenhorst. Due to the major alteration of the original structure in 1977, it was deemed to be a non-contributing resource with the last district survey. At its meeting of November 1, 2017, the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) approved the Class IV Site Plan Modification, Landscape Plan, Elevations and Certificate of Appropriateness (2017-155), for a new 3,427 square foot second-floor medical office addition to the existing 3,837 square foot, single-story medical office. The subject request is for a COA to change the proposed use of the second-story addition from previously approved (not constructed) medical office to a single-family dwelling unit, increase the overall building height, increase of window sizes, adjustment of second floor banding and lap siding, new roof deck and addition of a stair tower to access new roof deck on the structure SITE PLAN ANALYSIS Items identified in the Land Development Regulations (LDRs) shall be specifically addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development proposal. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(B) — Principal Uses and Structures: Within the RO zoning district Business, Professional and Medical Offices as well as Single-Family Detached Dwelling Units are listed as Permitted Uses. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(H)(2) — Special Regulations: A building or structure in the RO District may contain either a residential use, an office use, or a mix of uses. Based upon the above, buildings may contain a mix of uses; therefore, the proposed mixed use (medical offices and residential unit)are permitted within the RO zoning district. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(F)(1) - Property Development Standards: The standards as set forth in Section 4.3.4 shall apply and specifically, the maximum height permitted in the RO zoning district is 35'. Approved Proposed Top of Parapet 28'4" 29' Mean Roof of Large Tower 30'5" 31'3" Mean Roof Stair Tower N/A 35' The chart above illustrates compliance with the required development standards; therefore, positive findings with this code requirement are made. 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 2 of 4 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(G)(2) - Parking: The parking required for business, medical, and professional offices shall be at the standard of 1 space per 300 square feet of net floor area. However, this requirement may be reduced to 1 per 400 square feet, or at least by 1 parking space, when there is a mix of residential and office use in the same structure or for an existing structure on a property located within a designated historic district or an individually designated historic site. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.9(C)(2) Number of parking spaces required, Requirements for residential uses, (a)Single family detached residence, two spaces per dwelling unit are required. Based upon the above, the total parking required for the mixed-use building is 12 parking spaces. This is based upon 1 space per 400 square foot of the 3,837 square foot dedicated as medical office space, which requires 9.6 parking spaces, rounded up to 10 parking spaces required for the medical office use. And the single-family dwelling unit requires 2 parking spaces. There is a 9-space surplus of parking as 21 parking spaces are provided on-site (2 handicap space, 6 compact spaces, 3 parallel, and 10 standard spaces). It is noted that 3 of the 21 parking spaces are electrical vehicle charging stations. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17 (H) - Special Regulations: (1) All buildings and structures shall appear to be residential in character regardless of the actual use therein, shall be kept in a sound and attractive condition, and in established neighborhoods shall be generally compatible in architectural style and scale with the surrounding area. (2) A building or structure in the RO District may contain either a residential use, an office use, or a mix of uses. (3) All parking for nonresidential principal uses and conditional uses shall be located in the side or rear yard or adjacent to a rear alley. No parking shall be located in the area between any street and the structure (building). Where there are existing buildings, administrative relief[Section 2.4.7(D)] may be sought from this subsection (3) provided it is determined that compliance with these provisions is not feasible and that the residential character of the area will be maintained and that such parking area shall be substantially screened from off-premises view by, at least, a four-foot high hedge. The existing structure is a non-contributing building within the northern most portion of the Del-Ida Park Historic District fronting on George Bush Boulevard. The second-floor addition and renovation strives to maintain a residential character since it is intended to be used a single family residential dwelling unit. Parking currently exists forward of the structure facing the adjacent streets, thereby not compliant with this regulation and is an existing non-conformity. Further, the building is situated to the back of the property, making a full reconfiguration of the site layout impractical. SECTION 4.5.1 HISTORIC PRESERVATION DISTRICTS AND SITES Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), Procedures for Obtaining Permits and Approvals, Certificate of Appropriateness for Individually Designated Historic Structures and all Properties Located within Historic Districts, Findings, prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. In accordance with the above, the previously noted criteria have been analyzed throughout this report. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. In accordance with the above, the previously noted criteria have been analyzed throughout this report. 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 3 of 4 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(2)(b)2 — Major and Minor development: The subject proposal is classified as Minor Development as it is "The construction, reconstruction, or alteration of any part of the front façade of an existing noncontributing residential or non-residential structures and all appurtenance." In accordance with the above, the subject proposal has been reviewed as a Minor Development. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(5) — Standards and Guidelines: A historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. Standard 9 New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. Standard 10 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. While the structure is not designated contributing, the proposed improvements contribute to the environment, protecting the historic integrity of the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The proposed addition and renovation of the existing structure have been designed to ensure that the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment will be unimpaired while also maintaining a well- known medical business in town. This is an important contribution to the fabric of the surrounding community may spur restoration and improvement of other properties in the district. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8)(a-I) —Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height,width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria in (a)-(I). The subject request is to change the proposed use of the second-story addition from previously approved (not constructed) medical office to a single-family dwelling unit, increase the overall building height, increase the sizes of the windows, adjust the second-floor banding and lap siding, install a new roof deck, and add a new stair tower to access the new roof deck on the structure The modifications to the original approval have been designed to address the Visual Compatibility Standards while allowing for the continued use of the structure as an office. The increase in the overall building height is a result of adding a course or a layer of concrete blocks to the structure in order to slightly increase the height of the ceilings inside of the structure. The increase allows for the modernization of the structure. The increase in the size of the windows is dictated by the increase in the building height and is to ensure the windows are architecturally balanced on the building. The changes to the second-floor banding and siding is predominated by the changes in the windows, allowing the windows to "sit" on the base of the second-floor which will ensure appropriate architectural proportions of the first and second floors. The approved panels in the large tower are being changed to 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 4 of 4 windows. A new roof deck is proposed as well as a new stair tower to provide access to the roof deck which is situated to the rear of the structure. As modern day demands for commercial office space change, the applicant's proposal for adaptive reuse of the structure allows for adaptive reuse of the existing structure and site while maintaining a neighborhood based use. The unusual shape of the lot paired with the "saw-tooth" layout of the building offers additional visual interest to the streetscape as well meeting the requirements for rhythm of the building on the street. While the building is non-contributing, the proposal will help bolster the district as a whole given the use of authentic architectural and building materials such as cedar columns and aluminum railings, aluminum shutters, aluminum Bahama shutters, aluminum windows and doors, wood brackets and gray shingle roof. The proposal incorporates horizontal, simulated stucco siding on the first floor; and, vertical, simulated stucco siding on the second-floor. The approved color scheme will not change and is proposed to be off-white and crème colored walls in Grand Teton White and Acadia White, respectively, with Brilliant White trim, fascia and columns. The window frames, shutters and railings will be Black Beauty while the aluminum doors are proposed to simulate a stained mahogany wood. Based upon the above, the proposal is compliant with the requirements for Visual Compatibility. ASSESSMENT&CONCLUSION The proposed changes to the approved addition is appropriate and compatible, and will have a positive impact on the surrounding area as well as the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property is surrounded by a variety of established professional and medical office based uses. Based on the above, positive findings are made with respect to the Land Development Regulations. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H). C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H). RECOMMENDATION Approve Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in LDR Section 2.4.6(H). NOTE: If the COA is approved, the following must be addressed prior to certification: 1. That the site plan be updated to note the correct setbacks in the site data table. Attachments: ■ Site Plan and Proposed Elevations Report prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 5. 2018 ITEM: 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District — Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for an elevation change and change in proposed use from a medical office to a mixed-use building (medical office and residence). RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness GENERAL DATA: Owner/Applicant S&E Holdings. Inc. = � r � '* ' `, ' Agent Gary Eliopoulos, AIA *�YkTr• �._ 4, 4k / . 1 GE Architecture. Inc. �' ` .. Location South side of George Bush 4 01 Boulevard, at the intersection withAn " , N. Dixie Boulevard `>.i t'' .. . 'h 1w 4 �. _ - 7 Property Size 0.46 Acres : George Bush Blvd iAiie .. Historic District: Del-Ida Park Historic District "' ;1. x ik Zoning• RO (Residential Office) +!. Adjacent Zoning \��4•; '• 4.•�4 `.c- 4v ' North: RO �, `:�� `. •r_ East: RO : '' • South: RO �2A(N > West: RO - A,,`- ' # ` , d&'a' 4 >> �r e t Ott. fir. . Existing Future Land - riikk I• •. _. Use Designation TRN (Transitional) — -t `' „ , : Ir• .. -....w.:..,,A '1., • lkil Water Service Public water service isprovided �, _ on site. g' ,,,, 1 . Sewer Service Public sewer service is provided N. ` �. ` 4: on site. ` •••,^ - , .Y , A• :' ' .' . ' w• • ;�" •°y • NORTH 1 .._,. . I.",2k WS l'1� ' ct. IS•I.3. _-maw_R. ._ ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is consideration of approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) (2019- 022)for an elevation change and change in proposed use from a medical office to a mixed-use building (medical office and residence) located at 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulation (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject 0.46 acre property is located on the south side of George Bush Boulevard, between NE 2nd Avenue and NE 5th Avenue (Federal Highway), consists of Lots 23 and 24, block 11, Del-Ida Park and contains a 3,837 sq. ft. office building. The property is located within the Del-Ida Park Historic District and the Residential Office (RO)zoning district. The structure was built in 1959 as a residential duplex. In 1977, architect Charles E. Toth designed a major remodel of the structure which included a substantial addition that was built for conversion of the duplex to a dental office for Dr. A. Merlin Wuebbenhorst. Due to the major alteration of the original structure in 1977, it was deemed to be a non-contributing resource with the last district survey. At its meeting of November 1, 2017, the Historic Preservation Board (HPB) approved the Class IV Site Plan Modification, Landscape Plan, Elevations and Certificate of Appropriateness (2017-155), for a new 3,427 square foot second-floor medical office addition to the existing 3,837 square foot, single-story medical office. The subject request is for a COA to change the proposed use of the second-story addition from previously approved (not constructed) medical office to a single-family dwelling unit, increase the overall building height, increase of window sizes, adjustment of second floor banding and lap siding, new roof deck and addition of a stair tower to access new roof deck on the structure SITE PLAN ANALYSIS Items identified in the Land Development Regulations (LDRs) shall be specifically addressed by the body taking final action on the site and development proposal. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(B) — Principal Uses and Structures: Within the RO zoning district Business, Professional and Medical Offices as well as Single-Family Detached Dwelling Units are listed as Permitted Uses. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(H)(2) — Special Regulations: A building or structure in the RO District may contain either a residential use, an office use, or a mix of uses. Based upon the above, buildings may contain a mix of uses; therefore, the proposed mixed use (medical offices and residential unit)are permitted within the RO zoning district. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(F)(1) - Property Development Standards: The standards as set forth in Section 4.3.4 shall apply and specifically, the maximum height permitted in the RO zoning district is 35'. Approved Proposed Top of Parapet 28'4" 29' Mean Roof of Large Tower 30'5" 31'3" Mean Roof Stair Tower N/A 35' The chart above illustrates compliance with the required development standards; therefore, positive findings with this code requirement are made. 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 2 of 4 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17(G)(2) - Parking: The parking required for business, medical, and professional offices shall be at the standard of 1 space per 300 square feet of net floor area. However, this requirement may be reduced to 1 per 400 square feet, or at least by 1 parking space, when there is a mix of residential and office use in the same structure or for an existing structure on a property located within a designated historic district or an individually designated historic site. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.6.9(C)(2) Number of parking spaces required, Requirements for residential uses, (a)Single family detached residence, two spaces per dwelling unit are required. Based upon the above, the total parking required for the mixed-use building is 12 parking spaces. This is based upon 1 space per 400 square foot of the 3,837 square foot dedicated as medical office space, which requires 9.6 parking spaces, rounded up to 10 parking spaces required for the medical office use. And the single-family dwelling unit requires 2 parking spaces. There is a 9-space surplus of parking as 21 parking spaces are provided on-site (2 handicap space, 6 compact spaces, 3 parallel, and 10 standard spaces). It is noted that 3 of the 21 parking spaces are electrical vehicle charging stations. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.4.17 (H) - Special Regulations: (1) All buildings and structures shall appear to be residential in character regardless of the actual use therein, shall be kept in a sound and attractive condition, and in established neighborhoods shall be generally compatible in architectural style and scale with the surrounding area. (2) A building or structure in the RO District may contain either a residential use, an office use, or a mix of uses. (3) All parking for nonresidential principal uses and conditional uses shall be located in the side or rear yard or adjacent to a rear alley. No parking shall be located in the area between any street and the structure (building). Where there are existing buildings, administrative relief[Section 2.4.7(D)] may be sought from this subsection (3) provided it is determined that compliance with these provisions is not feasible and that the residential character of the area will be maintained and that such parking area shall be substantially screened from off-premises view by, at least, a four-foot high hedge. The existing structure is a non-contributing building within the northern most portion of the Del-Ida Park Historic District fronting on George Bush Boulevard. The second-floor addition and renovation strives to maintain a residential character since it is intended to be used a single family residential dwelling unit. Parking currently exists forward of the structure facing the adjacent streets, thereby not compliant with this regulation and is an existing non-conformity. Further, the building is situated to the back of the property, making a full reconfiguration of the site layout impractical. SECTION 4.5.1 HISTORIC PRESERVATION DISTRICTS AND SITES Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), Procedures for Obtaining Permits and Approvals, Certificate of Appropriateness for Individually Designated Historic Structures and all Properties Located within Historic Districts, Findings, prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. In accordance with the above, the previously noted criteria have been analyzed throughout this report. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, all new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. In accordance with the above, the previously noted criteria have been analyzed throughout this report. 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 3 of 4 Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(2)(b)2 — Major and Minor development: The subject proposal is classified as Minor Development as it is "The construction, reconstruction, or alteration of any part of the front facade of an existing noncontributing residential or non-residential structures and all appurtenance." In accordance with the above, the subject proposal has been reviewed as a Minor Development. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(5) — Standards and Guidelines: A historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. Standard 9 New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. Standard 10 New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. While the structure is not designated contributing, the proposed improvements contribute to the environment, protecting the historic integrity of the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The proposed addition and renovation of the existing structure have been designed to ensure that the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment will be unimpaired while also maintaining a well- known medical business in town. This is an important contribution to the fabric of the surrounding community may spur restoration and improvement of other properties in the district. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8)(a-I)—Visual Compatibility Standards: new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria in (a)-(I). The subject request is to change the proposed use of the second-story addition from previously approved (not constructed) medical office to a single-family dwelling unit, increase the overall building height, increase the sizes of the windows, adjust the second-floor banding and lap siding, install a new roof deck, and add a new stair tower to access the new roof deck on the structure The modifications to the original approval have been designed to address the Visual Compatibility Standards while allowing for the continued use of the structure as an office. The increase in the overall building height is a result of adding a course or a layer of concrete blocks to the structure in order to slightly increase the height of the ceilings inside of the structure. The increase allows for the modernization of the structure. The increase in the size of the windows is dictated by the increase in the building height and is to ensure the windows are architecturally balanced on the building. The changes to the second-floor banding and siding is predominated by the changes in the windows, allowing the windows to "sit" on the base of the second-floor which will ensure appropriate architectural proportions of the first and second floors. The approved panels in the large tower are being changed to 230 George Bush Boulevard;2019-022 Page 4 of 4 windows. A new roof deck is proposed as well as a new stair tower to provide access to the roof deck which is situated to the rear of the structure. As modern day demands for commercial office space change, the applicant's proposal for adaptive reuse of the structure allows for adaptive reuse of the existing structure and site while maintaining a neighborhood based use. The unusual shape of the lot paired with the "saw-tooth" layout of the building offers additional visual interest to the streetscape as well meeting the requirements for rhythm of the building on the street. While the building is non-contributing, the proposal will help bolster the district as a whole given the use of authentic architectural and building materials such as cedar columns and aluminum railings, aluminum shutters, aluminum Bahama shutters, aluminum windows and doors, wood brackets and gray shingle roof. The proposal incorporates horizontal, simulated stucco siding on the first floor; and, vertical, simulated stucco siding on the second-floor. The approved color scheme will not change and is proposed to be off-white and crème colored walls in Grand Teton White and Acadia White, respectively, with Brilliant White trim, fascia and columns. The window frames, shutters and railings will be Black Beauty while the aluminum doors are proposed to simulate a stained mahogany wood. Based upon the above, the proposal is compliant with the requirements for Visual Compatibility. ASSESSMENT&CONCLUSION The proposed changes to the approved addition is appropriate and compatible, and will have a positive impact on the surrounding area as well as the Del-Ida Park Historic District. The property is surrounded by a variety of established professional and medical office based uses. Based on the above, positive findings are made with respect to the Land Development Regulations. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H). C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet the criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations Section 2.4.6(H). RECOMMENDATION Approve Certificate of Appropriateness (2019-022) for 230 George Bush Boulevard, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in LDR Section 2.4.6(H). NOTE: If the COA is approved, the following must be addressed prior to certification: 1. That the site plan be updated to note the correct setbacks in the site data table. Attachments: ■ Site Plan and Proposed Elevations Report prepared by: Michelle Hoyland, Principal Planner HACKER OFFICE BUILDING NORTHEAST ELEVATION IP y\T • ; \fit I k. y s � ,,ti .ti. a . ti * , .r I ip �I 1 r1 1k r + Y i% F 1.I . ii, ,I i -i'1, 1t 'S 5 - - : i '! - . ' Y '- rl� r' ; , 1 11 , r , , . j r I r L. i , 1 , ,,, ����� iiii, ! _.,:iii 1,4 .: _ _ • .. .... 0,,, . . . ... , . 2' p : iii ..... . ... . ._, .. , 1 1 ' "I .. 1l `.t r'� .I • ... i t4odiitea41&e1&i/ HACKER OFFICE BUILDING 1idW?,Weeze4 W/a►,idev (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.IS PROHIBITED. I 'A.". 1 :r• HACKER OFFICE BUILDING NORTHWEST ELEVATION ii ,, < 4Fit ,;?;,, ,Itti - - , / ; ' ,* ' ,.t - [1;i riiii i I-- Pj I ........, , . . .. -- s 1 fa t`ll tii .i 4,lit II I .. .• � r ., ,.1 tit ��r ^(� ' r . an, atuec4/O ro liCI HACKER OFFICE BUILDING (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN•SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES ANO LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.15 PROHIBITED architect 1-: , •." A,N,'..'`.• ''...•r.- HACKER O , FFIC,E B U...IL(DOT...fI.N.GN ....,•4.. ,. .,. -•-,.., %'SI • -O,,:"-:"" S0U T'\NH" EA A''S'4 T .. .,.., ELEVATION Ilry.. 2nF . yr . . 4j ( \ ". "`...• -I". e`'' //' %illit .,-_,-,. ' ' C/.'P'' Nv. - • ........ • ./ 4\ ,,X!...,,X. / . i r, , I ' .X '4 ,r .. ....,. !., I 4,1 %' , • 0,1* . i'•' 'I r' S• ; . ' .. ..k -‘ Ar I ' ' - ' -' k -' Off I , '4,—___ • • i .A I .. 1 .., , . \ \. ' \ ,2,...,...L_••., ...,,,,,,,__ .. • . i . • 1 '.;•:' IP I I . ,..., ,,,........... ,, ....., = 0 . '-- • . . ..m., ... .1, ....... , MN 1. 1=1 =MOM" IIIMI .11•01•1•011•11111 = -- = : 1:1 '' r . NM 1111•111•111111111MMI' .' X . EE --E,ilW----- NEE116--11 r- 1. .........,iii • • • - - • I . , • , '11IP ,' • IIII 1111 , = amr, ,,=2, 111 NI 1:101 NE •_ • •• ,,.., MI IIIMINIIIIIM no .INIIIMMENI flt .,. • 4 INMMINNI • "Pr 100 IF = .1I,.., II. 1 ..... , ....., Mil 1111! 1101•• • • MOM 1•••• i•/WM IMMI , MI Mil MIN ••••1111.111•11111 Mom ,=.1• 11 MI 111••••••1111 =I.i=••5.......hia .1 ..,,. , 1.....1 NM 0111•11MMIE AM:ilia/WO . 1111Pre,/•=MMI , • , • •-• . . e_raiditea41 661 e."rditiri/ HACKER OFFICE BUILDING e ,„4,„...,.. „ e9-1&fidn' (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE MINIS DOCUMENT waiouT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC IS PROHIBITED. architecture,inc. HACKER OFFICE BUILDING SOUTHWEST ELEVATION i • . ' AU $ ..4:: • i� c 'a�if• � `� I '''� -_1 h 1 �. t�\\\AIN( _ ,..,,N,., • \,,,,: :_II_ I._,I_ -1-'IP..' —77---- .., N\ V - • , , \ :diT � 4 �- _� 1,,,k i 0 . A \ -\.'s Igi . I'' 11111lllll110111 1115111111lllU 11IIIII�'�'�'IIIIIII = !_ �'�"'�°!'"'�' A Ill .1 - ,mil== . . , ! . ,. • ---- c' 2............ 1 '1-1 .7," ',' n 1 iiir _ ,, 161 i c iiii Li L , , lij • .%u&w4d(4valioaz HACKER OFFICE BUILDING e le4.,9eae4 ,,,,„,„,,..v (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT 15THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.IS PROHIBITED. .. \ ri.:47.-:•:--- t '----i Ol.,,4E7- i".::?•C" 1--- j H___zr______,„..---zz•:.;:„,.. r:•=2,. . --______-_„/ , ) ' ' , ,. i v Aprecshigit,e,c1r,Planner nnd . . AA.26002044 ...-_ ,_(_,,,I.,, __, __ _ , 2,,__, ,....„,_ __ ,e2:_,;\:2:::•.-LaNsii.,.,_ • ,.. f.:,,,,.,,,,,,:;z-.14.;,, . . ri.5S.,r0,, 0...„•., I 5I I ---L——1— — r I _1 T -.. ' ,-;-.....,..,...--- t— ••• . i I',..•'...) '. S.CONS,,,ON• '\.• )A 1 ( (-,,. • 5 1 VICINITY MAP ED I, I, 1 r,";:„.•---i —,/..._. ' r,'• .. •,1 — , ! . J . 1' ,•,-—' .4 • ls ._.,_=_,L%—.=•__,, ,,.(,.. ...—._1_,.__=..i___.._.—.__>. :_.._i_i,.._,A_L_-__I .. _.,2"="-17.-.77--:----/ (E..."';...-7-..7:72.-.--:•-•••'-.A ,1 II I/t.:./.._j " i „ 2,I, •:' 7,' i — ----I-0 /-1. - 1-1 •) :=,.;,:: /:-. ? r il<,, /I - ->-;,-:,......,, J / / §iN ['-''''''i e• 1 ' I , . — ) , / .. 0 :-.74+7,4-71:1:-2:::: ! 1 t --t ,,. Tt..• .....• 1 1 .R• 1 =•:-..=.••=•.... V 4 r ) ,-, •,. - -- .„ ...--..,— ,. ? -", . ,,, ,,,F,',\ .• ,,, °,',',/‘ ' /' . '-'' " i -."1‘ ,,,,....,......,,0,,,,,... P A *\ A- , ....\ / ,'-171,7•==.... it,GrNetAl..07[5., 6 PROACT TilLI „' • , ' ‘• ,:, ,.., ' . .MEDICAL 1/. '' l's4is //' / \ , \/./ \,/ / „, ‘„ \ • r_// OFFICE I. \ ' 'N '''‘," \ /6 1:".":".."1—•• E BUILDING \ ' \ 27 \ ./ - •2/7./.. '''' • ''rFAlt074:." / '\ , PROPOSED SITE PLAN E9 A \\' s\ , t' \ / 1 1:i 7 */ —...g16.. \ NN\ <> /. • .'„'.\ / GENERAL NOTES: / / /•t? \A„„•‘,:i-Sir7"....-7. ,' ( Fa-> ---- . ) A\ S'''f:'' / '' / '/7 ' •' /../ , ,',' ,°ye*7,5 Tv,a xats,PxcIrcx env excl,..Axe, 9 ',230 GEORGE BUsH BLVD. < t::::,;'...:4-=,:Tt``.'-'-',:cl:re.,-74;..., 9 DELRAY BEACH,FL , '\, •-,,,\% 1 d...-.. V L.1 e ..rik \\ \\k-e\\ y • e;'' a' .:7-::==t'.7,'g;Zf'aZ,',!,:'-•V":a.'0-'.'- . < /F4-41:// l,\ e ••A r•IFF:17:::::::7• l''' ,3 ceN•leArCtOm 5.+ALL STPRTI.CCA•T ARO 001.0' ,, WO 1,.atx.ALL IN5E,V5 Ave,-.0,3 4.0:55 , ... > ) ''''."." / /= dk'*"-#? ,//• :::''.."' _,,,,,,... , IR,.0,SNNLS MCA,uieGERS 5-An 1, ,.....,.,,,,....... a'r.,.:-•-2--,7,— , > , I t 1:4, --T) E:::=7:;771,..1,,, \\.,./V,/,‘ ,/ / N 'r.ff-",.71.°,:.°:,;,',Wg.t.7„:.7.,:,IP:W.: 7 ..7-Fi•Ex-----.AI #( ) •—.-...........- ii's Lx7":::g`o4:4:1al.r...:04.g,`..vg:;g:a• t.!b\:!=:::-...-7.:1,-,1-'•,,F.Z.'-':..":117:1.S.:17:'"I i••=-1,r1:-.1-.1--".=— > ( —°— • ' . 7.,=:;:::::!'°°-----y------ ,:t -n:47.,-,:ig,=::,-,... <, ..,.....i..,..,.,......, . ., A ••••=0-c,,.•,•.c...r•-6*0.••..0••.• ..) 6 — 1 APPROX.BUILDING AREA CALCULATIONS 15,1••.10 e.1 kr ) ) I • /"--,/ ert•eNc IlLt reReae: /I•0 .// PROPOSED ) \_''". ' " ' - •••••••• s,rea,i.C.'!AST,ql 0,1,1,61I0ruil. ,,,SITE PLAN „.„.,—, ,) •"'••"••• ,., ,,,,,,,,,,,„,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,.,,,,,,,, 10'.±:_-!:_'IL_><•.1,21.:YS2:2....?!:0.2°,••••^•'", TM.041,01,ARTA •.51. „ 6 , _} ' - ;•••;i'',: rex ex PAK.]I cax.crn axxxx,, .21i or La• r,.,,, Af•R,AL1 PR AIR,. R'T I •S.5),el } 5,05 ?..0331.1) I 1',,1Z ' 709066 ... 2 VEHICLE CHARGING BOLLARD ,' e ot.r, ,••• e cx 1.41 rect,,, 1.4.70,e,•1,n. ..; ''''""."."'" ,e.c me..nre” ALLCul•e,.4, , A1.01 SCA!r.N LS If.e. ee. ''I".''''"'''' P A1.01 ---------- . . , .... k. ME-.-IiIr- -----/-------________,•••=.• if.,771.77. Ill I ___________________- A • Archnect Planner end _I_LIJA.. r ....... k,rkl..56,276 6.29 • , •_ . _ •-- - N- .'POOKR,0 PRO.SC•.6 LO.,,rn 6,4 !I N A ...... Lp..:=1 r 61,5,6,44 'lli_1 VICINITY MAP 5, 11111N A _I ....• ........‘i •1 ' v. e ____R, ...,• __ ___..-__ ___ ___,. ____... ....___..__I _ _ ,.,., ••J__.--.._.---- ,- It? •- J11—..7J .Lco-2:. i ,______.• :',_ III di <---) A .-„u4, , it,...„--.,..__..... .„ / ,,,,,... N,„ __[-__, e • 11 fl- /1÷..:07 f_ -=mt.: ni r r> ......, .• 0 / ....-.....-X yl .--.....trs•zunr;_./ . ,/ \ S, A___ :I ' , .•''•- . F,..7.7".E.•:':: ....,/ r ,DO NO,SCALI ORAL64,6 6 . , , -,",-sc.) \x ' .>,, \'-Te ',.. „ ...„ ./.411"--..................— , ... . ..,..., s. . , ....,/.. • ,, '7 / . EFL;FAT ,/ i„.3 MIXED USE • ‘ -:•: •.„ . ‘ s'• , LEGEND: '1 BUILDING \ 't?,\ . ••••- - \../ \ / ' - .--- ,- • /!'',.;::!.77,71:-.',-, .•• *,?''"', '/ •.,* , /// • 1. '7 ..............., • ./ . !EAlq.',•:.:••••• Y\ .,\., r•-• \ '• / , \ ' ‘` \ "•m"..."."''''`. ,',,, ,„„c„,c,„ N •\41.''\‘` / '1 ViT,'1;''''.`.ir \, \ •.. /1\ • 7 • ‘. \A ,' ..4:7.2;; ' • .-. r!.E_GAL_ 11, PROPOSED SITE PLAN 401, \.\. ,,,„ /, ,, :::,=, , e' ,, , N. = ''''''..:,i'cl,'2;''''..r.IE.c5: :•;Z:,.4-7''''''''"' / ,.,t ,:,.." .ti."/ ,/ ,- :,•.,...,,...........,,cc....•.`,..-.,.GENEFIAL NOTES: ••••0>.\.....:• '," \ / ), .k• 1 A':',' •W / 1'.4.'",,','"'"'"'"Y.7.".:n',"g;'4.... 1 OvrR 1,05 Tv,6 CONVPRJC/161 IND CCCaraNrY .'1 230 GEORGE BUSH BLVD. <•"" \ \' ' / ,' 1 t'r.;:o=u7..TtLigelnre..;We..,t5 ‘.1 DELRAY BEACH,FL ,„,, • •\,. / / .,. .//' 0°;' 4,\ I.+ /\ 1, F..`,......:%,...TkON6 30 Tut dr.er,,C•RR 61, 7................;=.2....,.." ‘,.4 \ • /grZ72 ..................e... ...'.0e,an..16 0.40.1.N V A:=...•:.:az.....:7::: 40 ..,. i ,•' '-.'----'--- n.g.7,7,.5',14.-""•.`,7'''1'.,C.:••=r ..' A I 'i A 7..11T.,........Z....Z.i..:E.7....,. * Alp A "' , ZONNG /—.....,.......... le 6RA,,PER 10C 6/• 'ZI - A ',77.7.7••;,`•:•:;••••,.7:g7fr...••',7.'..!:, / C APPROX.BUILDING AREA CALCULATIONS \ t ',') 1,6,101,1.1,Lt / ) r,PROPOSED '..SITE PLAN ( .rrt. TO.,<Auto....rONOt 0 I S. I ,,,,,,,, L:%7:::1:::::V.:::•%C::;;'°:: S,ER,Car, :"^IlL,'..r7.4*:',., •>SS,V' 2,:: ..7,'' Ma / , ctau IRSC,66,..1:16 1,6,51,SETinCKS )i' Jon HUVIIIP 1 20 50816 2 VEHICLE CHARGING BOLLARD , .or woor, A e• 615C 6nerET ars, Ai 6.TO.• 2;, 11.011.Nr.WW1, M 01 $CAlt:NTS A1.01 rr ‘,--------" ..„,_,...„.„.,„,..,„„,,,...,„,...,...„..,...,..... ` '---] ti 'Architect,Planner and ROOF DRAINAGE CALCULATIONS Designer AA-2600204d :7-:•4.;:=7.74k:e7'20,, ......`•. ''''''•"•' eeet ee.et et,'ete.e eeet et,.1 Ere7:47-;:e.:7— "" te tt le tt et tt te tt tet et 4.4 te.te tt te tt 4 te.4.4. e.tt 4 et.et 4, e.4.4 et.et t. ....,,,,.,..,,,,,,,,..,.......—...,...., ..__" I gl -ri h .1 X ,„ tccenrca , ,?7•1, ,7-:..,,,. ,7"- II A ' ------- -\ PARAPET HEIGHT ETLCEPTION, 7-----1-- / I .44.4.ttee te..44et.e,vete ft----.,_i iSF:Z-7:•••7:;:e"EF4•7.•." 474`141fX€1.::744..•ffeila.•:FZ;• l tee4.4.4 41 I i' It..74•17.4F:g.":4,:"greg,tE. :17,•=4",4Ttle•4;tilL4X.,T.rne•-r• li !ill I I 0 'T .,, ..,,,.,,..„...,-,.....,..,,,...,......,.....,..,,,,,....‘...,,...0,,..,...— -----..x i •1 ' .6\ (:-> -, , ,-.• - ---------__k___ A ),-1 I ge'ra":::;:.:17.17.114742•Iti:::L ...It-, --- tP ':''' ; • .41 '''. " "L.1 \ 1 ''''''''' '.''' ri = BUILDING -- b 6 e 4 li \ t t, I rrt l't-•-lt t ll i Ht.t. "'''''•'`'......"' ''''ghr • ,, r :1' fiy ih ! VZ•j• . .. <-, •' I-I ,, .....—, -141. I 1 I ;111 ,•11 —,--- .„. ii „,,,,,,,..„..„. ,„! t __....,.., , ki ,A .. _,:r --\ 1•: - --;"'"'r 1 , !f.. ---,— 'll 230 GEORGE BUSH BLVD. N ,r.1 — .9 DELRAY BEACH,FL r c.--__A ,,, --" b- 2 PROPOSED SUNDECK PLAN r..1,0 1111111. /12.02 $CA11.2 I --.r.„ , ....",zc,...,....,...., .sj Fa•:IF::A c:e•''''' 41.F..ri.:•.:7„ • -IL•:::::::4"--4r,F-IF:::' 16 _ '7\s„ :Li /.. . - ---- _ _,..- ---- 616A202 :.:?.....':7 r:::=4;fAVX:''''• e8$iM.:5,::::::17:24:•617:0----A — ".4 .,PROPOSED N \oTEs. ROOF PLAN PROPOSED ROOF PLAN A,02 SCA!r:3/16..1..0. 'E4g:4.:74'''1•5:•••''•:"5 r' '' 120'' I 20150616 P A2.02 DECORATIVE RECESSED STUCCO PANLES. A. _ CURRENT APPROVED ELEVATIONS ® e+ ,7 \— ® uuuunpnl ImII e ,>e :.—_ .— .—.. .. _. 9J arnhlr.r.tn rn,lnr.. °® m -0,, ° a Architect,Planner end +n. '."'4../— rr II I�i ear,.l r� � ■�I -- O - 'a�'^ M f M 6002044 IMF°. t� ,o, Lp f?! F�! a 4=4. REQUESTING _ > �, i t ° ° !F Ii INIFIlitlixii ° . 11 i �Y1= E6II — ���1����aIIi��E' ,...,�,, i0 G»�' mulls °11�i1 _ I i a : 11f�1® HEIGHT TO BE !; P m = III,I'II I!IYI ° ° 11111111111,'�:R. = t ,. '.. INCREASED BY va I ® —_ .— — I�IIIII�/ I I(f �� © pu fdli ' ..�. , — — ® II_ — �1 _ Q �11 -51 1-'—i- REQUESTING WINDOWS IIII_ III 1 1 o11 Q I IB o ' TO BE INCREASED IN +" 7" , I III... • l WIDTH AND HEIGHT .se_ . o . J 3 4,1w0rm I — -- _ - ^; ,ri. \'m r — \-^ ' -- 0 PROPOSED NORTHEAST ELEVATION PROPOSING DOUBLE o SCKE:a t6 d'-0' v.�m�\ W �. WINDOWS HERE. - IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ° e +m. 6\'-'-�_ - - — -- - s En ElVP ® ° 05 !i MEDICAL 44.7........ — — o� 5 OFFICE 4,,,, _* BUILDING 11101114 = - '• mr. 0 .4, . , I ,.. C.,-; 6 x, t ° it kill II 1 iiii" 1111 o- II 1 1! Al ,i„E ° - 1 ll T� _ 'IV _1:L till: iiii _allele _�\ 1 —_ _ _ —_ ° 1111111111111111 - 1 ® © ° ° IIJIIIIIIII _i o-- © �q ill t II K.41_111 = � WI 11 °°_ I�� IE" !TrI, y� VE , -DE RAYGEO BE CH. L b _I I--� a DELRABEACH,FL i� _ — ���I� ri�i • .:...,...„..,� c - © 1 — ° ° pill 1•1,�i,-i [ Y1 Ft 4:77,=m PROPOSING DECORATIVE SHUTTERS TO BE REPLACED ® !' ...=5 -' EXTERIOR STUCCO WITH ACCESS DOOR TO ELEVATOR MACHINE ROOM. PROPOSED NORTHWEST ELEVATION i - ELEVATION NOTES A+ SCALE:vte.ra 0 o.txr,u .r -.1,-o,m...w.°....«..... LT:l. El ..,--74-7:70,....::::;:rm,,,4 ;r:-.................: me(FIXNFea ®� m..°._......,,..,a.. ro E ,.........ww. _ m o . .. red." e O°.'.nm...rr ®.i.. ..:,,... ,a.. . j. O i NOTES: Y rat MAWR o3eiA]ee M.._.4..,., .._ .m. --- E 7 „ m ...».._ .,... ® ....o._ •t,PAM LLA'BA It ❑• o �O00Ar'�w�Aoo H ., m..... ... r © PROPOSED Harr aaew aoca ��"'�'" ••'••,'••••,"•••••'•"• ❑n " ...-.. ELEVATIONS �" ..... ,...... ,..... e• `. ®& ,..,, -...... ® ..m 0:: o❑ ..ter ... a ... _ _ Er e .......,wrm o 0 0 _ .... ..--.... w ..-...». • C.. ....�.,...�. 2 A3.00 ' - ,__, - r , E„ Iminallif ,, A 2 4 i7A"...4V4•1:“..\: - '\_ ( ( A\ __i ___ v Architect.Planner and --. r. 1-• 1 l''• 0,11 ' 1 .1I 1-"'----''i " -'-'' - '-----"--'-'-'''-------`----'--"-". .!.] ‘` 0!Designer IPPIVAiVid L. I 2 'I -I 4;7;:::::'4:7;'''''' - < — ------- '1' ID - - ' •.n- - ' / -T--- -- Efl --' - r---- . r . A 'A' [Id f--. [,•1 L 1 ,!]III 2 I - 111-i--- r- if.1 1,,,,,,..v,:v,T,;', ( 47,---7-;;;;--- I: ' 1 : 1 1 -11. 1 ri , -] ' __Ii_F,, I,(3,_ 1- :I] ill '_._, .L., 1 1 In IU 1 yll ' f"' : t- It ,t..' ...' •4,.. 9 ,A 47iTi''''":711/4'1'."---- 'f ,,' E2 llillIMEE-pit 'T_III Lili,111111111,_11111F)+:.1.ii=1 _Hrio,) n ,i{,..,.).1,1 ,,T1, i[iL,i-E.,:i,,,,Ini,, II_I______5_,,71'._=,_.__,:m.::_.-i_: .:i ',:, E q'S--"6 ------ ---- '--'U I n l_iLD iiiirq _,±i_j_-_j--, t-i_ t„ F:- -E.;-77 e,)1 ,- (-)[J.---` T .."71,,,, ,I1,...,. .1‘.,1.0 D =7 _ --1"-I El/ CI..;]._ _ [57- Lt A ;L::.:v.2,1.:•A's,' 2 A .- / , /- --i-' , PROPOSED NORTHEAST ELEV. ,- - - r- E) I I Ile E _)j\•, k6 :I (_ [:,. k•-::,-•I1I_•-#:'kiciIpI_iJt7--' !) -'.Pi,_[,E.111l,iii t _-)_I1„_=_i,_j..1.__1r1/,-'-1.P.r,E1PIIN t_I,','I ri,l.f.,1q.,p,-r.1,1aI,i A l-l.,7f-;,,,},LL..i 1 -17II f-07Imd j7i rrr-A'ri-CI 1-,E1Im. 40L!'A'Ilt 'i1i l l \)I MIXED US E> ) 1 I1 )1;1—ii e 1 ,„ BUILDING i r . 4A (/ 4 n j A =v 1E y 1 . 1 ( . _,., , (,, ( , ,( , , ,i . --- /E -- 1> 11%1_,\ W.4_,/jd ,.. ['.3 r'i 1141\--,: 1 _ ,-- .. s 23D GEORGE GUSH AVE 1 z ' 1 li '- nil HFR 1—' -2-'• Ill 1.11_ ,...1_ i i_ 1_1 it iF if,.., „,,, lei_ nr„,,, , g .1 i_*17: '( R-- _- - -.21= -I-I ---J.- P I- I-" 111 I ''' — • E 1.2-c' 1 6) ) IOU WO - I i‹) ('' IR. ., ., . .., 4:=.7-:.7 - -.(:' -1 1 .-,-.......... A,4:4---- i ,, i En'...F.:5:f=g'7 EXTERIOR STUCCO 2 PROPOSED NORTHWEST ELEVATION .'-,\,...__ '.I__ ,/'A :4';.7,-,4,;:Vi°-:,..:z...--•=•:.r,,-.=,:f.w.r,L-0- NIT, SCA,:31,1,0" ELEVATION NOTES E,..,-- E.t....;..7„;:„.F.FF.;.,„:,:=.•,-,.zir.7.--_ U.t1R7r..27-:•"•,«;;A77,7 r47,^i.'%':,Z,V1=1;.tr' [1 i'Fi4°,1,7.:FA7 W...".:Zr.r.1147..7,,t E,:,,,...r.t.!:;,=,-,::.•-,-,...7-.-,7,- - , 0 i•,,`-11-11;7.7.,•,:- .F"-='::, .•....„-7.2.==.7,;,-..r=,.....-x,-.-.34.Tr..,::,--nz.z.-"^ E i7:•,;',7,..4:F.,..:70-75 ..1:.v.I. ,;.., ,47..,k... , .-.: , --1'..12:4,41=,..---'-'72, ,4-%- E pol:S47-72:N1-711.22,F.E- E r,,==-4,-.=7:4,.. t.t.v..:..,°,•:.-,mx....-„v;.-.171:'",=.7:r4t=',.c.",= us-rr rIATUFES i'77--74:6-1f...-7',IFI::''' .. -„".',1,7."::: =Tn..=v.,1=.:.---.:,:r.-----"-- 0------ E l''..'''t27,%:7===7:2"T:;'''',V`'''''''''•' [iii 3::::::::::::::::::::: E:4,°„.ria,;.:iF.q.41.1:,tr,..- & :`,"-.;-%-=:=7"-' ----'' ,:i.„:4,„:„,:.:..,-,=Az-zofz.....-•- ,, ;.-.:=74;,-:.t.g.t,",;-.=r,:--------- E°,;1.•;'.:420Vif::•;Ncr,zif.:„. [,-_]-- , ,,,„.L.,,, E.,.. ,,.,,74' ,,,,-,...F.:',.:itz, E:•:-:vI=1!:,,-',...,4ii.-:=4;71'7-..,i',. .• A '''''''''' =7"-;°.":=.7.';i*,;- .= NOTES: a r" 616A300 [ I'!**L-'.1:: . 1;ffia'."4.-.,-. r,;.r.-..x.=,°,:-...T.,....%----- El ...17,:ij„,:•,, ,,F,r.Fi,r,:74..-.:,.7.;,-c.- ,„,,,-.„---, E.-.4.:4,;;‘,•,4,..m,7.2.7.-,:11,r,rg:',... —Mgr)PriteLkiriESTP6P1 f.ANT LEGEND E Z:=;',14,1:1`.7.:','11,t1=7"47..., E g.2,;:z...:7,.-....1T,,.,•,:=-,...= '..i-2F..a•-'::7i,;,.'E,':,1-IFFIEF,.. III-- 'E:•:....:,,,Igilti71,.-''Sir ,PROPOSED,Fmnarrs000n.,s.141,11>Cc,b,V 14:, `,F,:',..7.12:,Z.IWZI"..r.";:.1;:14-.,',,,,,, F.7,:,a,..... .77.,ziF.:7-1;',..• O74.,-,-r;P:.•;„,,,,....„- :.,ELEVATIONS E,.7.75,;2L;EF•Fov'i-T,t;,,',"=. E •:°.4.1:.a..-7-,:"17ii;'S.Tii-'1" :•,'LL:7.,..:. -..•=-..----- 2cfc(.0 Tar 01 ITraj, ==,,-:.--..T..r,-4.1, E:„:,,•:;.:,,,:,,zr,-,:fx,r.7.1:-.7,vtx...-.' iii,L;4,17,-.:=4,,,,.,-,c.v,- ,-,,,,,,. „......, „-- „..... ..,...,....... ,,,,.. , ..... . ... :=:17. ....A.,A. EI ,,,...i„ =„„ E r.,!:.•,,,.=-..!:.r,-.1....rx.,.,-4--. E ili-17.17,i1Firallrrarv,•!:%,„ ru - F3 I...,== E'-'4%•:''';',i7 i., 7„ , ..i.';'7''... F:77,,,,.F..„,:ip .r7,„ .....-T ,-, :-,•n,,,L....z....._,-;.=-.7,-;=. — .- r. 1,20.16 I 7r,JG' El - -•',.,°A"''''''.... E f.r=gila::=V:. ...2,. 2. •. u . ::`4,==="117:: A.4.,44,..,,,,,A...0,A_ E ,.:,!...-gr4.A,1z-•-'-^---- E;;;;;;;:°..;„:";;; -, H =,..,,,,,,,,:,,:z,„,L,,_„,„, „ 70150616 ,,......,,,,, E. Far..7.°.:4i1E.F.FSx'. 1:5.1',_T4--"'""'""*"--".1 "..--z7:AzL-7L`7;:in` =al ! F.:,,,,,,7,F,s,F=.1.,,:=7;-.....7,4„,-7- E:24:,==•:74.....:,=,-:-.::::::,!., Fit"-,;-7:.,F;;F-',F,F$,..'--- P A3.00 PROPOSED ELEVATIONS HAVE LARGER WINDOWS. ® APPROVED ELEVATIONS ° 1 g e ® IIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIII — _ �°m E. .. •ve..w. Architect.,.. i�,i•1 r. — I /� -I r r 'I HT,' II 1 I II 1 ig I pill \... , —\` ..,, Desifi Manner era n AA 0020N i [ill-- I a I I 'd' ^I'1 .I/ 111 ° t ® •a'_.u. ,.,,..,. ,«.x I �IIIII0 P d«.n �I�1_H rw,a Imo' -Ali_ -~�— ' «......., ❑ PROPOSED ELEVATIONS ARE TO , PROPOSED SOUTHWEST ELEVATION "'"e ' HAVE REAL WINDOWS INLIEU OF A3.01 SCALE:etl e".1'.0• RECESSED STUCCO PANELS. °I /s.>om.a e = IIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIII1II w /,0s::,m'.'. / 71;='" !MEDICAL �':�'""""� 7 OFFICE MI a ,f • — — ed..'-:r:.',.m g BUILDING o ' ��;�� ._ _ W. '� ''�°��I'Ihih..... — — — �s PROPOSING TO •d INCREASED° II11 111//1111 `+ III rl 1I I� I[?>i Lo� "Ill I� Ifll�o > s�i� SECOND FLOOR _ LIIIlIIIIIIIIII'hIIIIII1d11illlI IiIMIIllllillilll I9..III I IIILIE I�IIIIIIIIIIIIIII o ./ °�; DDEPTH BY 8". ® I11 I� I,I _ I. ,- rl l-1 ° p - ^'�IrI ° pJ05.4:17:r . B 230 GEORGE BUSH AVE IP 11 '.I1-_1 I --( ° " Mini-_--- I-.I Q ?� e DELRAV BEACH,FL ■ CBI' !©+ L d ® . ° _u III u= SS/ ew WPM.q P m — 1 e ..:n_r. A 4 PROPOSED SOUTHEAST ELEVATION w.pfeagim�B -- 0 SCALE:Sx1f.r.o. , CaM'87rS Nb"'[aOABBN► ELEVATION NOTES :::. ` A. ,1erMr ME CO eolE ml 1JWf FUDUIES ®^.°a"� © I�-"^` 0 ,r'_ O „«..,,n.s_m uEAmA u,s.. ,.,+,.,, ,..,«.. I — _.......... w.. ,:a.. .e..e.ew yg®.. .`,+ .". 1 -.`«...... r.,.-. ❑:,,� ❑_«m _ ,e.a. ❑ ..w... Lug ., �i 8 ID NOTES,nib r nuumn u ." Xs:em..e ". .u�r- ^0'i r """"" 'J e , =:f. .unw .ume O .s.vr." N a]oxANll EXTERIOR STUCCO Ern --,.., E W 1.......«..r..u«e.. ® Lr*= A.n.e 0 PROPOSED ,...K Err.. .. ,M.,.w... ,l,. ,..,,., .•,.. ..,.,u,,,,.,v,,.. 'l, ELEVATIONS ^ri,.o.rx�r....m.... .rw...........".0 ®•-� r'� f0l ryenq°m.... ur.—.a— 1❑�' wn y „°'„ ..m,'.w "7 �aa i° ,f MAMA I OEIJC r ) , i. - otr,• ... v----, ----/ ] __./( F i_l__. -,. ''''''',3 N.:`'7 7:71: ) ) i( i ii__..—,....,..— • .--ir -,-. ,_.]:jr__iiiir ._.,2____.._..._.,141_ 1 j ji]pi g / , ' re-ir.Piirro*roe. t-i,AA.260020A4 r f ' — 17-I 1:— II-: ''. ''r-'1 71' +1111 it 'i 11 r" l'il -<; -1— 1 il —11 --I— Li - ! - . . t !A' .f., i OW...en riwn. 33413 ', hj;Vi V.2;411%0 _r\ I i 1 _ I.I A 1 1 T i O''ei:i eierre. ,•,.crerr 'Zi''''''' --.'-' 'T->7\L,_o ‘, . ---- ;;,-, f il -( 1 t' v. 1-411-11-: Hla_i _ _ .. ,_ _ _ 1 .1-Fliii-r_14_7415H-31 -p.,_ ..-, __ I I_— _ it (- I ,' i--f :::: ,,,,;.,•,s,7„..., PROPOSED SOUTHWEST ELEVATION A l' A3 Pi SC.r 3 ic rr i i.e. 7—I-'_ !— 71-g-67,i'.',165E7R1 tra. t. 0 111111111121111 \.,\ \ - . .___. „_. .•. . . ..,....- .,,g . ,, -, _,2 F .„,.,.,,..„ . i,,,MIXED USE BUILDING ( a — . -.„ ) ll 7-..,14- szy--/eds-upowagm. ovp,,,igoymp, - 11 1,,,,, „1 ___.0 ___ -, ( i-i, 1 , , i,4 54.1,,_______._ _--_,,,, • __E ) l -1:3; - - -- --u----w-;-,LL R (L ., - A _r-----,. 0 ---fTinti I- [17[1,, Ill *111T* 1 TI111 " , 1 ) , .. .23D GEORGE BUSH AVE ! '' P-.'1_71_1---..1 1_11- e ' [111[IN fl ini 11*-'-iN '''''-1-- •-L-.71 < ! i DELRAY BEACH,FL i '( Ek,-,- -i== n- , -1__ \_r' -_, R DMIrTn - -I ) A b 1 r \. H, V EB--11 I ' ‘•-•,, n.„..,=,., TFy = ,UU 1.-17 ‘,.....- ..-,.........- , A 4111) PROPOSED SOUTHEAST ELEVATION oto-FretiffET1,sF) EXTERiOR DOOM.WINDOWG COIARONENTS mocutooeh I ELEVATION NOTES • SCALE r 3 i 5.-1 i.e. 9 A TlindiMr.I. ictr 41) li''-ff FP"'ES E - .= '' -47:FF'. o.- .."-' E F -- E F.IF17°.ii'.. ;,-5' - lE 7------`=-Plr'"''''""'.--" 1 1 mr-"^- ---- .--- ,.,---- 1 0 z,-,::,,,......,;;;;Tx,„„„ -.-------°,7-7-4:10 -• - E F,y,..-7.5.=:..7.-gr=1:v.r....=:, E t.,,,r,.....T.17,rz:z0=7:,-.7.„,... E f...11.--.7..-z-,-.-'''.„.1rTiFY=:`-°::' E FF;Tr."..F.'677:74:i7kai%T:,::. E;.;:v.;:ti`i;q....:74..,77,,,,L.:-,!:71'.=, '' ''''''''.'-'.`";.'"'::7,5"7. '''.t.'''"' E F.'''7;"1,',71=7:i'- '7,3:".;;;i:?,:l..iq...: A E :7-'•',==•';-;-.,-- - — <>FF,,F,i-7:0--- ":7-;::::".7-7,...-,:-:----,- 'th," .'''';•-•••••--!,--- It.Z..gt,y3.-*;."'g.r.---;,:::-:-.- E ;;;.:.,-(s...-..,-..'s,...,....--•••-:-..,, I--- — . - •....4.S.M 111 .:17E„,. N ,,1:7...„..,..- ....,, E]g. . .„T.g, E.r.:-.''zIlii..7.-, 17::::::71:;;/-1-:::•-•. •----`- f.x.1=g.7z744:.:.;1,74-,=-- NOTES. ' i7-lit...F.----..7.=---------- El••-•=5,1".t.----; E Fgr.:=- - ,,,... ' L',...alf.: ' "io• ,..i:::-°71%,:ia-1125z,z,,,,-. ' L:.7.,........:::.°1-===::',.r:0""'" 1 El E.:-X.':TE-;'RI'.'O'-7R:7 S:T:7U"..C:.gCrO,------:::::---- r...,r - - ' E -,---.7:----;., ... E _,.„....,...,,...,. ;,,PROPOSED " --,"-- - El=?...."'""' E ,,,7,.•....v.t=1„'''''.7.7".:°1=- E:..g.:„.7.i.,..a,:,,,y.,.;F,E:::,,7.-;,.., E F;,-.7:..-..417.-Ii'-t-"i-.7,;;.'''''='; LI f'fYg,.:i77:':`:',FIL-.:77Li4 :::::--;`,=•-77:- ELEVATIONS i:T7'7F4iFj7:1',"-ii-v''''''"'.7----''''''"1- &F;2-''','4.7.;'•:'-'--, ..-,-.',. .°K.'--"q,':7.7.-F.:,6,-%4'''"' E.;;:4,:,;:r.:Fr.,.--::=;':::...ff,....- ,,.,„„„.!,:=7„c„,_,,,,.,,,,, ; 't ...2-7.i.7.-,-;:;',.;'...=,-,=.°.:.-wzr-vrxtz:;-- F.:,;.ii,s,..7.-..7-7-,,,=:.._,1 E;.7,,F.q.FF:=.:::„F.,:r.?.-Tay E r'''''''''':;="t.:547.1 ".cs- Illi .:-A.'.1'.1"-=•":,:=7:=1:.:7,•r:^ E Z`...'",7,=='!..=:,=',°- 1 '-"`"'",-...""'''''''"''''''''''' ,'•".'.=..,-"':,!=tr.ttrr.47::.,17.2:4",:'...tf-f=""'" .AD I , ,..:,•,,..-:L,,=,,f.:-T--: , z.7-:4- I°a 1 20150616 "-— ri ',.';'..7-''S.'"7:,i"-"•?';':7:1-7:-:77- E r:.77,=------ E iFFIE-7:!44.=-:°:7:FL';,--2Ft..v. F:577-`-' 7"-"rt&t.j.fg-77.4.7F:flg.iT, I A3.01 HACKER OFFICE BUILDING NORTHEAST ELEVATION .., 2111'41110.11FAIRr, S':'- • F. IP it ..., . ...0..... ,:\. .,, ,_ ..... ,,,,,,,,,/ , . . ___.... _.....: r i , . ...... r L',:,-,, et : tit\ ,. i1, � � � , !I `� aii ( I -.TN = F/ '� yes., 4ii 1 , Y , , it ; . • !!!! , . , : Ei ,1 1.' ,g ' It!it,' III ��� - - ill ��llll II R ,. .. r e 1 _ (, . .c i: f'..r.." Iii' t .. . 'r i_ I. f/ (041 tead HACKER OFFICE BUILI)I NG g .. gdz ecte/4 (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT 15 THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.IS PROHIBITED. HACKER OFFICE BUILDING NORTHWEST ELEVATION , ... 4 . .. ,_ • . .. t I F . . ' I(4 I• ..•. q . • .'.N S F, ., 4.)7.4.:,,,:, _ ... . ‘, . . _ , ., ,z.-) ; 41.., ... . . , -, - .e-_ .•... ' — '"I 1. • ‘'\'•'-,-•.:\ . . ' ,, 1 t . \ s .1.;.-,-, r itc ,.,,,..4" , . , , ., • 4.- .•,---**- MA .•',,,„ , ,,, ,1 \\\`,. '' . ' ...s • ,,•N 4:vs. .—....:, • , 4 ',.(i;..i1:1. ) ' , .- ... - lea t I ' i ' \‘ .'' .. t( 1 \t'.%:\' . '. . i , f' - .. . __ , _, , .. . , ,tuw, I;, i I ii 1 . I I iiii ;11 Pr [ . pli • ,, .- ,• __ _ .• [.:.. .... .. ..,1.- I F A1010.41104116:',.. - .F i ..J a Ilh b..71 MiMil il .1 iitigm._ "ivr,71 pow - __1 ,...!::... II as . . Jo,- /at/taw/al 604redian, HACKER OFFICE BUILDING 1e6a,,,93eete4 ,97/04,mia, (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC 15 PROHIBITED. :•, '11 . __ HACKER OFFICE BUILDING SOUTHEAST ELEVATION 11111"lirqIPIIIIIPFIV• t..,A44 '' , . _. 46. 1 . 1 'eli '!I ‘t1 % 4 '. it f tl • ‘ ... , , Al . ' N : 1 i i z 1 il , . - 1 = =I i..... i _ I lil r, • IM �:., , PAW/ate a a Ig�taalian' HACKER OFFICE BUILDING e .„ ,.e„ , eveider (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN-SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUMENT 15 THE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.IS PROHIBITED. ..r. t t.,rO,,m HACKER OFFICE BUILDING SOUTHWEST ELEVATION r t • • •• -:4-01P t ."-''''''‘,--- ‘, --....e ibli ...,--Y . ., - • ...\ \v .iiiii, ,-&-\ ' ..e..''.;,.. . .. .• .7t. .,.• .„ , . ,. • - . •.1._,- ..,-,...y , • ... ...... ..- . .--, VI ' . , . . ,...-, i , . .1„, .; s ,• , .- 10 I 1 ,' t '., ' ' -' 1.-' A 1'''* .‘,,..''' ,..2.,i''.:I/,;:n..,%v /i At *.‘, . V4.; . ‘.,,. midi 4 ,i i ',; - •' 1:'.• . _ . . . . . _ •• . , I '1" ' •1 .' ,'•.' '' . ; •.,. 7,; ' . 1 1 " lt 4. . 'e. ... '. , . r ' A •' ' - ',•/.' f' P . ... . , I I Ill:__7: :i. ... 1111•111.11/ lillilliffill111111111 11111111iiiiiiiffillill IIIIII1 111111 IMMIIIIIIII 11•11•011•1110111110 1 . ..... . . • = . • 111•1. I i..._ . .7 1. 11•1•1 . 1 1 I 5, Ili i i n '7 1111 II °111111IPPI IN 1 I ;I-11 I' : , . •:: .. 1'Ai ii j. •. ; , , . : , . 4 .• ,._ .,• ' :1 '' •• • . .. ...._ . ctkere,41 e-Yeivaa HACKER OFFICE BUILDING g a gate/y/,Weeich4 gle4idep (TREE PLACEMENT IN RENDERING DOES NOT REPRESENT FINAL DESIGN•SEE LANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FOR ALL PROPOSED TREE TYPES AND LOCATIONS) THIS DOCUAAENT ISTHE PROPERTY OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED AND ANY POSSESSION,REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF GE ARCHITECTURE INC.IS PROHIBITED. t. . r n i ,_.::f..... 5.,:lir4L-•• ''-- 7-1;4:7'.77- - -\A . I ,I i 7 Architect Planner ond _s r t. rt:,Designer „ :...i...........-...= 't t6 AA.26002044 'f! . --, j - _:,TN'' O ...—„,„Ponere,le LoseTro cs. e In• sr' e, \' I 1 0 e 0 e 0 e I ':,,,•;--- ve4 1 ,....,IA,O'Of 0 GIP.,pu3•1 15 VD,d0 OrYt 00.45VAIO 1.41,2 1 ' i i L VICINITY MAP 6 I _ = 0 )ri0P CCNST,CIVI ' "\.. ...", —--L,-trIL 4... - --•—t•• .....,/71? Fir-a-::-.7.7-7...-: if; A —, i • I II / / , , \ ...... I • , , _ rj/li:.Ili !•—`‘'D/).,, e Ai,,),,?eiv ,,s,.. \,,,7''^‘,z,,, „i // /./ss• /s„..,,,9-/.../...,, ,„., . ,•,' ,;7,,,, '=7.;:r..;.f,,".7::.1'....`•g:' Ar . \.,-*8...k,k,' . , 4., //7: , s ,..'•'`,Y''''' ,>/ \ ' ' ,›.s.. '7 .., \`''.-q.,-,-,, • .A.-..\„ /40,/ ...,....... fere e.r.r.AL sores. t ess,.'sr 3./...1.' •I„,. */...../. 3 \\,,../, \ / , .k., S \'‘.!;..3\ / ' y/ 't! ,l, ' \ \ '• ///,' , ,/ ;MEDICAL •-•,•- \•'-'''' ''''k- • \ F.77.7.7.1."•••• BUILDING 1:14•7--1:.="-. \ ".1. 27 \ \ '''Z\ r/ \ /4 ‘.2/ ,•''' 7/ [_______I V.!::',"1,,'"17.4c=r" LE;.:e.i.,."-.1 <\,.\, X.‘,,°,‘, \ \ _ •/ . 6.s.-e•r.Eb10,4 N \ 'V .' — srSIA.,/11•,1^0, \•/ \ '''''' .. ././V ! i . '1•C,1t0:17." /'\ * ./Y IF ,LEGAL V PROPOSED SITE PLAN , ,,,,,,,.T..,•••.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0.• I,,,,,,,,..•.'','.''T,ft,' 6. 01.01 SCAM)1..10.0' ED , 4\,;,...., . ,, .\\ „ ,1 ./,;tx ... „ ig4,5' ,, L Pert0See es SAL.etAe3,cos.43,PLaso• Ill ---\ •X'. v\------ / / /4. V,/ .\. , ,/F.,i.F.r.j4-7. / , .IT.e.sn•....•eo so.Ass.IFFST Ts.,ran 04.146 TYPE 0[041.,,C1101 WO CCOIPA, :CF0F,.:1:1:7•1.A".AL"A2.1.°‘'rA'171,'=';Ab 2.230 GEORGE BUSH BLVD. ^,DELRAY BEACH,FL .19,Y I 1,.([..0,4A,096,,ALL KR,ALL C0.11,,045 /MO 1,10...0.45,7,C Joe,re 1,1,TO ( (1] ) ,t‘;:.:,'• \\\,,Y.,,Te, /......,......T.L.r=r.... .,T.- •,,, / Ei..7-r-L'''• ,•'' 4",;., ..?•• '''.7.7;:`''''''"'"7'i'F.•;".a.F.,°F;7/",,,F,7 •> k J \ 1 COW WIC?,LUATLII,,,OLA IT Ab 0,0 r < ) .::::=,f7;.::--\;\ , ,,,_„ „ // A/\\?/ .** \‘ .\.•,./ L'F',r-i • •Zy. / ( < 1.ALL Or•Ae0 AND erG,06 0.0.1.4 0,7,F Fail----.:I-I+:-'..tr... ,----,--.) k -\''- , A,q ), , FT„.F.s.;7!--:k:.-F:=wv,':ci,°trr'-1-44-t:•Evi-4+‘:, i • W t f \X), ()),---eee„ sr,411.1n4 eSsIss...se,TUE 4,41TECT. > ) \\ • / , ' Vr•t=t•.....".....L.—:: • \, ,' A(ZONING ..",-......„--...--.....,.—.__.... .,,,,,,,.. A S . / ,, ' P.E.,05,,,...,...,;e0,C;(4,•1,„.„%r•.,.,1,10.erse.pscr OTO.0.11,-2‘) t4 11?!.:1 1.'11 ';TI;1 i'16 Z.7 In t A rseees.,Se0 es..CE ARA•SOC..,••01.SF j ( . .. ............... ....-..........., / t 1,'> .•,,<) ))) / APPROX BUILDING AREA CALCULATIONS / AI UN•Ix / - WV)''' WorTTOOpAAT,*.Y,AS,.l„"VOa"T,/l A,,SOr.2Ne6°.2 I s1.,.-•w-r.1es0 I,>/...•'l e 6-A...c,r — 'MPR S'SO,'r'P'li'a Ol SMEAD , SITE PLAN I O, .1 / i.F.',6`,',:'''','',`;'::".".,.., ', ,',:;'• sr.es 1,,,•essassrle u.L.,...11. •11.DI 1/4% / AtuTi.a,P.,,, •IC 4.71 St / ""'°''''''''''''' •>fel SF else ) 0,,2.,7 I Gr,JC _ ' ./,_ /.._",„_./..,_,,,, .. ,..._ ./' ps......,......,,,erFr. AM A.1.' Cr.wt.!,GrICACKS reS.s.Stre,er-SACKS AA''"r BOP 15',.tt 15 e• 6 DE Seer,It AB, 31•...•To 3.•• 2 VEHICLE CHARGING BOLLARD — ..- ,,--,—, ,--,,•.,- ,; °^----- ALLOJAITT-t UT ,,., uekTue AI 01 SCAI r.N T.S ,,,, r ......“.., - ---. `, i_l_l_T • 7_ '.&".7"-- E.T..,174-",, ...,..=..7.::n•r. ....... • - =T-- -11 . .. . . t . . ..._ ...., .... _ r .. r r } i ..1.... ' 1'.1 : 9 Arcliiteci,Planner and 1 t,ii Designer e,AA.260020.14 • : ' i nrr4i,rs'ilit:Viis L..J1 kv J 1 , I ,z4 Ma°'On otAtt Piet' /E3 ime,-.N..„1 o__ —e _o__ — .1 — __,E- 1 N.,--' --_e 4---,--1. 01--J,3--71 7,,,,,=7.Ln'A.r.°.‘--- .•• CV.:Z. '111 - 'ri:rC7t'''''Ll7077•Ft7:3F1•"''' \bi b,,, I I .....7t74; •-•'•."T•uC.' ---'4't, A : N4 • 1(t, - VICINITY MAP ED I, A I L'''''---.--1 „.. ..,, 1 ('‘. NI (-)` I l , Ill I' ep — 11 1-13_4r- III\ k .,... Ah.....* .../- d-' ........... ,,,,,,........„.„....,.. , \ r ,): '-t-. _...-- , ,,,nnOACT IrTa A • i "/ -• '''\''../•••> .7.` , r: % ' ',> -. 7 N('' -,, ,,:r7q = 7 7 1\ '•"A'A"L'"'''''''•••••." t MIXED USE = BUILDING ,/,./ /8, , . ,/W 1::.:-:-:-:•:.:1...'5. 1 ,,, IVALKI.,TO .". ..2.,=',21...., \ ri ••,„,\/ %. / I .17irr,Tir.;tre.7. gips.;..os.0 i 6 .--- . , .....-./.?..::".=.\ • '' \\ \'' • ., '8, '../ A • 140/Nr LEGAL • ' , PROPOSED SITE PLAN CD'i \ z --:' li:.•rr,22,2 \ es . 6 l \' *•\\ //' ' ''','' /. .3/ ,' Rsco.on n r..,et.,cm.i..,.,..0. 1 A Ai.or scAl f i v..10-0- A h.*• -40, \ ,,, \ 1 /3/ , / ,, ' , \, / ii:1:-...::.•, ;;/' \:\8 88,' ,..,„- = / , , „„, ,/ GENERAL NOTES: \,,•: ,_, - . / ///. ,' A'.--,-- --;\,'-- --- 4 /' i•-!? \4,\,,,,,,/ELS:74;7- //ip,NIF ," / 7x/ ..88,Or 1,4•00,ANCE WI.ALL RP.CLAtt'VeS 9 A'\ •'••.".f„. ' , -,230 GEORGE BUSH BLVD. , , ...\\ )./\\,/ 1 .' 1 ' \ •••, ..• . \ • iii:,==.7..°;:',":,,Z-7,:::::`,17/4:..,8 9 DELRAY BEACH,FL , r,. , .., , • , ' 11 t,C FIN,04,t0V4 'te ''' \ • ePrOt TO '\>\\•".\\Ne\•\\? .//// ‘•<,° tei I COtt,te.tat<It,0.0•4•AAGTOR A•All.,,M1 i t: ...,::::i2A...:*'":•,...n...\:\ .,-61. ::::::.i.:-..1:.r.. , ,, -\,46::,;:, tg,'• ,p1/''' 'f'!:-..!8F,;:c`;,714=`;':"...=F:7t1L"::;14:1'./L i J \ •\''' .-1 /.110r .....Fr...-..,t, 99s1.'r WO I,WO,ALL.45,PV6 ANC.,A,,LES r-- • ' ''', \YAt. ) • Li-Hi-5U: • ., NC) ' 'fi / N / • /-.--... , .........., r etAltet A,,,,E0 TO et TttOt.AtO it,A...L .....-,t, „ ,...,-.....,-.„.......-_,....,=,.. zzn A c:, ,..2 /. "''""•'°si\. ' ••., .4.10 r• , mc-on.,,,,, .,,,,,,,,c,,,,,..,•,.....,—..— • , .0.,. le OtAttO Mt COO OP. ) t4,'' g t:Ital.:FS.':;•:'i i::" A „111.40,8 MO rrff PTI,,,4,,,111„.114,„ .iiii E.5.4:11....:,......•.... // C APPROX.BUILDING AREA CALCULATIONS TO•AL VPACIOMO,M0 t t,•IA,ACEO / / ( PAO.,I. 2)•0 ' ,PROPOSED `,.;' "'"' ., ,, 3 ) •,,,SITE PLAN ..'”",,•' ,,,,,, , . . . • '''' r, r.',.,';',';. FiE',-:. OP IA. ' •ITOVAZIT're, •SW OP 2',7Z •)•n''''''3.''' lox ,„,,,„ ,....,,,Or MA:, P1CPtOtt,OF-VACRO ? 2 VEHICLE CHARGING BOLLARD 'y'' :,..o„ ,1Z 7" ::,°,; ' : ;-°.,'7„••• *i SCAr:NT.S . — AI "--- ,..„ —, r,•':'..Z.°Z .) •; A1.01 01 L n-r,:f), , „. „„ IENO: ( , .. ------ FiFt=ile.'"'" r r; --) k---- __, .:.,„,,,......,..„..,,..,..,.....,_.,..c„...„...„.„ `--1 'Architnct Planner and ROOF DRAINAGE CALCULATIONS IV De3Ipner AA 2E002044 ......—,...,,.............,---, ' r.'-'-= -2"-ill _L,'• .—...,......—... t',:,v, fll•:..1:, fl•tv, a•:::::, 1'41i_ ,;,T,TA. /...T.0.0.OA C.A.P.L.Y 0.4....AGO b..."....•••/..!,C.A•1,1,1(tb......1 1 / b - ---.---_,,___''t•- .r I / ; PARAPET HEIGHT EXCEPTION i•:F:..747.7.2,4:47:3•11:Fi•••`:"•••.1.t74'..f.r.t7.`411,:f,',I t.-,t.',1.f."..".7.,t;- lt k el; „.I I _:,.,• .... 41, . b•.., lf.r.:=7`.11g::.*:•••,....T.t‘,..`,`Tif:=';..`,"...ft,ff:....loTt.•.•- .:__ .,..._ !, 'I-1:F -747- -?' p. A .e A e> , L.1--,----,------ r;i -' --il •,..i \\l' -.a.'...• — .L 11 f• •• .;•MIXED USE - BUILDING '''L-_-,,, •_],_ ---- 0 I • nri ' i'• .,' i.: `).:_iR ±e•-:-.__ . t e .- h4 t_ d (., [---•-,. " _"':.''...,,,c..... .2'-- ,,1, ..-•••f.f1.,fAil_fk:::.-,,,,, .1 I— t• i • I.V.a,'7.-rf.t..,.,... 1 ..r \ , ----- •--, p A d •,_./:"...`'.: '.!: v\•••., -— e) 1 0 h GEORGE RUSH BLVD. ,,It V ‘,.., ; ,-, r •—..L—, w 0, ,,,i DELRAY BEACH,FL i,c.--2\ -" bmac 2 PROPOSED SUNDECK PLAN ___.,) .... / i A202 Scot r:310.-1-0 , -0::::::.•••- • -=';l-L,7,7.:-•- g• Igial'adri.:1•1':i.". : :......:r.:7,..;r.r.f...-- I n f 6 _r_,-'of. 1V•A r-FF':::.1.".",:::. -477".'F-'• --. V _ a ..: t I i /- _ :4 i,,F-71.:EF...,...--:•:,..7.' PROPOSED N \OTES : ROOF PLAN PROPOSED ROOF PLAN rlr',,,,,, SCAlf 3...1, 330,3 I'GE,JC' A ,n, 1015061E 71 31 r A2.02 9 DECORATIVE RECESSED STUCCO PANLES. _ CURRENT APPROVED ELEVATIONS �. l e \_— IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII'JIIIII �..o.....�— — — a •�...u.. ` ._ arch trcrurn. } •1121 nu p • Arcnitecl,Planner and ::lw_.. .. - • �., ui� } a�t ' ti DO Signer .....W'� --. - .r9- ��� .iir. ��■ I C ° ,�,v a E• '.7' ` AAigner 44 , .y; 1 P YI B-� Oil � I�REQUESTING > 4 ° aHEIGHTTOBE °i�° ° _ i � III MIS Q� ill tII ® INCREASED BY ,.'w��, .. °i® ,--- - ° �11IIIi. I1I•IILIIIIIIIIIIIIIP _-I o — o el o llllllllllll1110,,.11r, i= - - — y m Ili i1� r'_11- o-� 1 "^m11 �—. ° REQUESTING WINDOWS t Ilii m, ; Illl cl C� III _Ili F-T i : — 1 ° o !O(I =I I_ o TO BE INCREASED IN ii 'FI's:iaie st\ _ --- — I C WI ;o= o o • Erg,"�Q �J. t WIDTH AND HEIGHT_ +:17..•,.x._.. -c- 1 -- -- --. -' Fl Gel _ .. ``__..[A1.2A 3 1'"""" ._' . A`-^. --. - g PROPOSED NORTHEAST ELEVATION +r.:.'.77`� _ PROPOSING DOUBLE p +'"`""R\ WINDOWS HERE. m IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ° >."..'...._.:.•� F_ _-- — - - - - p .f p p p rs� MEDICAL -- .— — °,' ` O• FFICE �:w.'r"""�',, -- - . .—. `Ai B• UILDING --————gill! Ill • _ ,..1 : ., _ ^ r g 3 ! ® AL;lbLII_ 1.4 I II II I ° LEI I , ! . .1 .. Pi I ,a11. I , il _: .„ I, i ® co IIIIIIIIIP p ® ©° y=.4 � _ __ — = e lun._—[11,1_,c: Ei rim —1 � i a O f q �°,DELRAV BEACH,FL CIA I k::..:;;��,a;. --� 0.._STI, PROPOSING DECORATIVE SHUTTERS TO BE REPLACED s\- ,� Q EXTERIOR STUCCO WITH ACCESS DOOR TO ELEVATOR MACHINE ROOM. PROPOSED NORTHWEST ELEVATION :°3 e - _ �� ELEVATION NOTES Aa. SCALE:11e•.1-0' i rtr E:.. ..._ ❑ ._ , .. ..._m.r.._... .-,-,.....,,.,.,ww.r.�.,.,.�,.s..,.., Cuff FIXTURES — .,.,......u....r,.m. „ Q .......woe, O 7 E. �.... E � ...s...... .�.....�. o E ..... .• 8 ®A — trtNM. mr.wa....+..1..r.w.mu.un.x "'".... ---- E`Ei „ ow••••,•••.••"•• Me ..nm. ..ewe NOTES: eJOtAJeo _ ®it.:-av= ....gr..,i7ATEF:3?":=1.1:" �w O00AK"si _ ....... ,• .. E ,t .,... m• _ PROPOSED �®® �.:e ... . e. . . E ._... ELEVATIONS ��� o r fir ..,_....z,. o b ..., ..... E .�..... o�.... ▪..... �sss© :, �wm©S© E` Q;_ w...uw, ❑ . ¢0Ae.1e SOS© EA'ww.., E.'T E r._.,....... ® . Yr` .. _.•wn.w.we▪v...wra xuwm, I GErJG �0�0© ........ ,.......... _,.. I" M .,...... a<'.., . L F mrsmox ra.m r. w E "'" E,.,....,....m.,....... # u., ( � \_ A.) 0 i [ �_' LlJQlllll1I III -., ,^✓ ,.- - ay2'"Iil r � .- ri ) ,, li uo"i w�<"� l N IlI0y y�µ����a " ( 3 t - 1, Ill.l iJj I I./ ❑ ry._❑ O __ rd.,4,1;,r D ,d 5. S. j ' < r Architect Planner and _ 8F y�L ( _ i . u >t '{..J • l v Designer v x1 1/ �. � / III ,� r j i 1J' T O 1R��d t �. An26002oaa �..w t , I — « � 1-1 y a 1 f . 1J J �f L J II Ili " JJ,)41 1 6„ A y ,A > EE -.1 I IDI11111111�IE, "I < iy-1. IF. 1[I It �I a.r. as Y j r 1J "Ey .a—— �s4 Ff J ) .1,.yC.b. ::: ) E ;T- _ — � c ['A—IT,I ,{P Hi r u I 77��� i -_h J Clip CJL 1J I 11_ l 1J yj """'° ' [ EI �l�— / PROPOSED NORTHEASTi_cr ELEV. °, _ /A i ys cair:]i6 ra n 4.• -r' ( r II III 1 II[f m c llv`i1aU°lu'„ . . ( b•,,,, -_ J R ❑ 4 I I- 1 0 w ®® m ❑ `�.n- n[17711 ) :I,MIXED USE 4,� c v tl I [ .■ Yn - ', BUILDING /. ` [,?"aa,�y t cif p� i :FN.; I I i I i I a ( A \ ( ., ��`hl �.n'F.... .rfM61111 I1�11,�Y Yy i� LI��i g i i 4.1. M1 \! �.m°',....,. xd:teP- --- - A (1 ❑ r� �I�-- 11 C 1J I —' .1J,- •14�_ R i "/�}. — ? = 1_IJ,11 _ IJJ J I J - - .� i I_ - i i ', -t JI �� � •� 11 4°a ..., »`fin � n = d _I (� n �7�I � 3]O GEOHCE RUSH AVE I. lIs ,� �� J _.J I ICI t 1�_lJ���T� I� U O y DELRAY BACH,FL EJ e 4-:' r I. ��_.. EXTERIOR STUCCO 2 PROPOSED NORTHWEST ELEVATION /r �.,°� .°..,.. .e. Sca1.Cp,e. - —_ `�..- _�� V ,•.....r,i,,.»u ELEVATION NOTES 0 ,o aE L» ° » uart FORUMS p y �^ LI Ee w�.. _ IJ g..., ..°,. NOTES. v r. 616a]o0 . c tiVtdo PRCSq.Fr T lE 0O T 1 gS 5 Exmurn Doors,wrvoovrr n: s "' '�." ❑ PROPOSED 6Xk1'ONEMH nro cuoolr »o u,...°...°....e.,., .,°,.°.a. °,...... .,..°. _ aaa =vtui msm � E"" E ,,,,,» ELEVATIONS ura.9 ,nu+. ,,.s,. .,.»,,. O M •.cu lJ a' .. %'„ "•1~.W ..a, - rww , ' ".» 0'r•'.'• i O Ii ••• .°,..a•.�.. ° ,.r.........•+c...»T„ '11.J0.16 I WI ero» n — El' :'.e EI]i o■.v ..rve. ae•».- un., O , y..a° e..u.0 V..e l"=1 orm-..e..,..aoic.. ..a.° .on wuYnrn •, . u ... ,�... ^•' . . • u°.... ..o..,. p3 J0150616 ..mr°,..., ,,=.t.M-. ,. o 7.°, ,r,,.°M.„,,nr.•..,, .,u.r ..r.a,,.,. .,F: A3.00 I PRO ."..:::::, POSED ELEVATIONS HAVE LARGER WINDOWS. ® APPROVED ELEVATIONS .. ® IIIIIIIIIII�IIIIIIIIIII- -�,;;,;�,��� g g e i _ .11 _..F::.....:......7. 1 .. --,— _ - _ _—. — m Architect Planner and . +... ... Dees ne CI A © I I l�ii�� Anzeoo2a4 I ■■ � � , I I I .....,...... v o-ti,e.......m 1. o l - o I „ "-coo, arJ. iLE idal I.p 11'� ����- I a ... 0 I ,ll em::=mod k!::,..,.., .......... PROPOSED ELEVATIONS ARE TO PROPOSED SOUTHWEST ELEVATION HAVE REAL WINDOWS INLIEU OF "'0t SC"LE""°''''O. RECESSED STUCCO PANELS. Pa punnpmuupumq - ® i'i'ij�° --'�- .-. - - - - - - ---^ �; MEDICAL — +.�.... ,. 1 OFFICE C e. Z.it li BUILDING ° ' ciiir- i. +^ PROPOSING TO ° �o 0o n flU r If.o — — — + '° IN° III n1 p• - °° — ' I, k SECONOOR IIIll 111�i1��11 �+ r!I !91 © .° II?�i °� r� 1=1 �I ® 1 DEPTH BY 8". - -_ :j 1111 llIIil 1111111 11111111iIll DMI 11111 11111 I11;Mt IIIIII�'E I�IIIIIIIIIIli, o 1 . .....•.... ? ea — C' 0 7© 9 r■ t4mT 1 _1 Q - 0 _g 11 `�_II - IH I ,l, -- - - -- --- - —..- a 230 GEORGE BUSH AVE F' P L I'1 1IIIJ �} (I Co, -'� ! till (I I I I�H LJ —0 /1 e } DELRAY BEACH.FL ■ -7 1 LJ =1_I J LJ l i u_ o ill PROPOSED SOUTHEAST ELEVATION . vezirowasPREaoar ELEVATION NOTES ° %��''� '`ate" R�If n..ru 2tl..1 Llnn RCTU E;... , '.; . E ❑»...«.. , E: E ... ... ..... --- ................. ,... o .PNlfLEDEa A. irc R w " m ., N..s... a�a......,.a., .. OTE$Mw el:• o R " o EXTERIOR STUCCO 0 1'. p...•. ❑. '' 'e:t.^., ' ❑ -2.= j .. _ C1�n �. '-o '"'"` I PROPOSED Fil — ® E °""'. „� ;ELEVATIONS 1 s -. n.,,.,.....,>s El�• Hall..... El _ "...20.16 I GELl aii 0 .,,a 0.�.. ... 1 , .,m j ^^�^ aria IIINIII( , n1 - �- °�• a 4 11 v —,.LJ!-.� r.Ji.- �.n,❑ r / __ ,,,...,.,..,. A I and �� j Architect,e , YR ,. ri A gc t A 26002046 I I- 1 j -_ Y PROPOSED SOUTHWEST ELEVATION f A3.01 stet e;316-1,0 - - A --_'zi _�. rpe �I;lti m , u �;n, O ril en O ... " n?netiw Rna "iencmbl,., \_._..., _._� ___I ,.,,_./ -., ` a MIXED USE r° %,.1 n, eJ inn Iv I.n nm np, I Li lei h B m n 1 �I �I Y \ '� I BUILDING c m ❑..n n n y 4�n��rm lemur uip L°rN'isie,fupir�Tan,�1',IIu1� Ru i�ril�u"jii�lip"fi'�iii uot�1J o N�fo i p ,�b ( �s ... � 1 ��I�Yy�4�a1dry4� dY� d��IYAg�a� %d��� y � ���c i��nY�16i�7w ), (' �4 171E x �� � ��_ n ] ' A n ��J II l .11 �- (' ,.,, -,1 I III I Its -- -. II ill —� 1 4< f ,T --o ) n -- l J'�� a [J LJ p`{J _ 0.- _ _ „ 1 Y I? Ig � — _ �` 230 GEOR GE BUSH AVE 7 '/ �__ _ �� -�I � �'���� -0 " DELRAV BEACH,FL Al' �f n 0 i 0 I b i _� I ) L .w,•rr 4 o l .gy .`]fa,....... (a_,.__ 't� :a �o !- :o: A �� ,\ PROPOSED SOUTHEAST ELEVATION "°tl'°°� �VKDilitMREGTPSF 7 A3.01 SCALE:31,'-1'-0' ,..+••w,e•.,•, Exlcw.,H DOORS,WNDOws ELEVATION NOTES __ ,..ee wQ - w.....�,,. a.e OOAIFVNE—AND CLAD''' .•cw°.,u,,.w....,.ww,.re..,... rfl .e ... :r:Fie W,..ra�e,re.. H z":•"-°..,.:w.n,'—'°""'',eu.n. ` iac ut --iac(A LgFR RXR/iS ❑ s ,o..w. ❑r ...,.w .... ...�... ❑ er•.,..._....., V ,e ❑ w. L :. _ o ..,.,...w.,... .,.. �.� © ` Ll p� NOTES: tl •..row..,. rv,v,.m.„•nwwn•.cv,,..an----. ,u ^�'�7 nrt.ew j E z•v......•..u...._..e ••,•,e.., u m ..,.ew. O rv.-..w�, n,°...r,w° � 616IU01 10 w .yr. n r, Cl. 2 ,`lo EXTERIOR STUCCO E S .. ❑G ❑° _ ❑ ,..w ..�.,..�....e.•....,.., ...,o. ......• � PROPOSED O W ..,,�,...ww. ,,,, ELEVATIONS n- roam.,..,.-.,.cn 1,1.20.16 I GENC ,., ,....a enm u.°e. f01 061 mcw ..rt.0 5 e .•.,°,._. ....Q°,.°,'.w . o:,.°,.,.�,e�,oa...,,..,, ...,r'....d.,.,,w.w., P A3.O1 November 15, 2018 City of Delray Beach 100 NW 1st Avenue Delray Beach,Florida 33444 Attn.: Michelle Hoyland—Senior Historic Preservation Planner,Planning&Zoning Re: Letter Requesting an HPB "Concept Review" Project: The Luciano Residence @ 1120 Nassau Street Mrs.Hoyland: I hope all is well. As the Architect-Of-Record for the above referenced Project,please accept this letter requesting a "Concept Review"before the Historic Preservation Board(HPB). Our proposed scope includes full demolition of the fire damaged,single story,wood frame,circa 1939 structure. We have two(2)professional structural engineering Reports stating that the home is damaged beyond repair. Our scope continues: we intend to develop a"replica"structure,we intend to reposition the"replica" with it's front Entry façade +-11.41' closer toward Nassau Street so that we rest upon the"Front Yard Building Setback Line"—much like our neighbor's home to the East does. We intend to build the"replica"with a CMU shell as opposed to a 2x4 wood,or"stick"framed shell. We intend on elevating the habitable interior up to minimum FEMA standards as dictated by code. We intend on eliminating the dropped,or recessed,floor located within the of the rear of the plan. We intend on enclosing the Carport and converting it into a true Garage(single car). We intend on raising the roof bearing point,of the main body of the house ONLY,+-2' to allow for more volume inside and to introduce new transoms above all new impact resistant windows and doors. We intend on using Energy efficient"Clear,Low E"glass in all new exterior windows and doors. We intend on introducing real,unpainted brick where current fake,painted over brick exists. We intend on using REAL wood siding,ridding the home of the fake aluminum siding currently in use. We intend on using a western,red,cedar shake roof rather than a mundane asphalt shingle. We intend on introducing a new 5'x 18' front Porch complete with wood columns and a roof above. We intend on expanding the existing footprint toward the rear(South)so as to capture modest additional areas for new interior space. We intend on adding a partial,"subordinate"modest 2"d floor to both the East and West"wings",again toward the rear(South). We intend on re-landscaping and re-irrigating the entire site. We intend on seeking"variances"as necessary to accomplish some of the above. We intend on offering the existing structure to any civic minded,well intentioned entity willing to carefully relocate it to a new home—preferably to another historic district here in Delray Beach. We intend on producing a well thought out,well built,"replica"home that The City and the Nassau Street Historic District will be very proud of. We respectfully seek , make our"Concept Review"before your Board on it's December 5th meeting. Thank you for your + • •- ation. ' Sincerely• r/ �/ 1/ Roger Cop ,Ar '• 111 RWC/jad Cc Chuck&Kat10 - Cope Architects,Inc. 114 NE 1st Avenue Delray Beach,Florida 33444-3713 Pho 561 789-3791 Anton & Diane Del Forno 323 Maxim Drive Hopatcong, NJ 07843 201-259-4079 December 4th, 2018 Attn: Michele Hoyland &All Historic Board Committee Members Representing Delray Beach, FL Reference: 1120 Nassau Street, Delray Beach Florida Discussion for Rebuilding a New Structure on This Location We, Anton & Diane Del Forno are the owners of 1112 Nassau St. in Delray Beach Florida. Our house is located on the west side of 1120 Nassau St. I understand that on December 5th, 2018 a discussion is scheduled in front of the Historic Board for the possibility of the historic home that sits on the above mentioned property be teared down because recently it was labeled condemned. Unfortunately, I am out of town at this time and unable to attend this discussion. Therefore, I am sending you documentation showing no mention of it ever being condemned after the fire until recently. The documentation will show that the house was put back on the market after the fire mentioning fire damage was caused to the structure, and was continued being showed in its stated condition. Also attached to this email is the fire department report stating that the fire was contained to one area of the structure, and the rest of the building just had smoke damage. It is my understanding that the only way a historic home can be teared down and rebuilt is if it is condemned. I am also very concerned about the new evaluation building requirements. Since the past 35 years since we owned 1112 Nassau St., we experienced flooding in our cottage multiple times that caused damage to the point where the first floor was a complete do over. We did the cottage over approximately 8 years ago because of flooding. This was after the new pump system was installed to prevent Nassau Street and neighboring streets from flooding. Thank you in advance for your time in addressing these concerns of ours. Sincerely, Anton & Diane Del Forno , . Hoyland, Michelle From: antondelforno <antondelforno@antondelforno.com> Sent: Wednesday, December 5, 2018 9:09 AM To: Hoyland, Michelle Subject: Dec. 5th 2018 Historic Board Discussion Regarding 1120 Nassau St., Delray Beach, FL Attachments: 1120 Nassau St. Listing Pg 1 001 jpg; 1120 Nassau St. Listing Pg 2 001 jpg; ARSON NARRATIVE 1120 Nassau St. Pg 1 001 jpg; Arson Narrivie 1120 Nassau St. Pg 2 001 jpg; Historic Board Letter Dec.4th 2018.docx; Lang Realty Warren Heeg, 1120 Nassau st. Sole.docx Dear Ms. Hoyland, It is my understanding that the Historic Board will hold a discussion this evening at 7 PM regarding 1120 Nassau Street in Delray Beach FL. I've been informed by concerned neighbors that the buyers of this property are now interested in tearing down this historic house which concerns me very much, especially that the fire depaitinent saidit only had the house only had smoke damage, and the fire was contained to one area. You will that information in the fire department report that they filed. The house also kept being showed to buyers until purchased. Unfortunately, being out of town at this time, I cannot attend this evening's discussion. However, I do want to express my concerns as I am the house just west of 1120 Nassau Street. I'd appreciate you getting back to me confirming this information was received. I will be in contact with you early next year when I return to Florida. I look forward to meeting you. Thank you again for your time. Diane Del Forno mobile 201-259-4079 1 12/4/2018 1120 Nassau St,Delray Beach,FL 33483-NILS RX-10388314-Coldwell Banker —010 a ,. _ , c3 ColdwellBankerHomes.com i - RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE 1120 Nassau St, Delray Beach, FL 33483 $804,375 Sold Closed Single Family 2 Beds ' 2 Full Baths 1,188 Sq.Ft. Updated 13 days ago Rarely Available This Beautiful Historical 1938 Beach Home Located Four Homes Off The Ocean and A Couple Of Blocks South Of Atlantic Avenue. Property Back On The Market. Property Has Fire Damage, Please Cali Listing Agent For Addendum and More Information Full Property Details for 1120 Nassau St General . Sold For:5804,375 Taxes:$8,891 Status:Closed Type:Single Family MLS ID: RX-10388314 Added:359 days}ago Viewed:74 times Interior Heating a Cooling Interior Features:Volume Ceiling Cooling Type:Central Appliances:Dishwasher.Dryer.Microwave,Refrigerator,Washer, Heating Type:Central Water Heater-Elec Flooring:Ceramic Tile Utilities Rooms Utility Description:Electric Service Available,None BATHROOMS Structural Information Total Bathrooms:2 -- .-._. Full Bathrooms:2 Construction:Aluminum Siding Stories/Levels:1.00 Square Feet:1,188 BEDROOMS Year Built:1937 Total Bedrooms:2 Master Bedroom:Separate Shower, 15 x 10,Level 1 Lot Features https://www.coldwellbankerhomes.com/fl/delray-beach11120-nassau-streeupid_21272296/ 1/3 • 12/4/2018 1120 Nassau St,Defray Beach,FL 33483-MLS RX-10388314-Coldwell Banker Bedroom 2: 12 x 10 Lot Dimensions:55.0 ft x 100.0 ft Zoning:R-1-A( OTHER ROOMS Lot Description:<1/4 Acre Living Room: 18 x 12,Level 1 Kitchen:9 x 8,Level 1 Water Features Other Room 4:Cottage Water Front Type:None Water Front Desc.:None Parking Parking:2 Spaces,Carport-Attached,Dnveway Financial Considerations Tax Amount:58,891.87 Location Terms:Cash Area:4140 County:Palm Beach Subdivision:Nassau Park Driving Directions:AlA SOUTH OF ATLANTIC AVENUE TO NASSAU STREET,4TH HOUSE ON LEFT Listed by Lang Realty/Delray Beach Schools serving 1120 Nassau St School. District:Palm Beach Schools Score Name Grades Distance 0 Pine Grov.. Elementary School, Delray Beach, FL PK-5 1.3 mi 400 Sw 10th St, Defray Beach, FL 33444 n Carver Community Middle School 6-8 3.3 mi 101 Barwick Rd, Delray Beach, FL 33445 ill � Atlantic Community High School 9-12 2.4 mi 2455 W Atlantic Ave, Delray Beach, FL 33445 Disclaimer:School ratings provided by GreatSchools. Ratings are on a scale of 1-10. Learn more about GreatSchools ratings. School attendance boundaries provided by Pitney Bowes and are for reference only.Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility. Price €t Sates History for 1120 Nassau St Date Details Price Change Source 8/13/2018 Sold $825,000 -8.23% MLS 6/25/2018 Price Reduced $899,000 -5.37% MLS 5/26/2018 Price Reduced $950,000 -3.85% MLS 3/11/2018 Price Reduced $988,000 -10.1% MLS 12/09/2017 Listed $1,099,000 — MLS Disclaimer:Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices.Information is rot guaranteed and should be independently verified. https://www.coldwellbankerhomes.com/11/defray-beach/1120-nassau-streetlpid_21272296/ 2/3 a .. 06172 1 1FL1 1 31 1211 1 2018 1 1 116 1 1 18-0003678 1 1 0 1 1 kr5cm -' Narzate ,- : * • P.rson Narrative: ti1S-1.3 1-.2"2 :,:essie StLeat, L?s-lrey 8,7ea,:h t):i !,,-:ednesee. F.erch 21, 2°18 et apprtxima:ely 12 .71. nrs. .c. was d:ispettned :c rvest. .gae a 112:2 7sse..,..1 :=5t..roe , DaZray i--;ea( -. The wtather was clear, the zeT.'aterezure was 75i:, ana third 7.4-rfn erf_. : -ste ee...7a,7ii. wir'a :he 1nd:ides:: Commanaer, Captain Y.eaci, wht state& :ha: no i5 the tits: parstr th scene. tip,re Lis artival he estatiishec command arc ai:sectet Li.ie ecttens tf the thonm.h? ehiLs. ':-,,, stai7-at theet when ne arriv&t ne ha& heavy fire condirodts at. Lbz: casspet. a7-C, and the s:tiaLtre b ..e:i it. T:e s:azdd that rho t";,-s- arric s..Ippressicce company .,,e,is is&des. -ill w,th Cadtair, Turndacia, 1 ihtert'fewed Cap.ien Thhheach wet seeed 7.nat he tr:d. i.s crew pal7.ea a ptc-cenntsz and ar.:atkod hne far4i, from the rear of ic stredtsre ;sta's- ,_: . -ht elnt s7LaZat that ehere were energi2;ed pow -,-.7 1Ch.es :hat they haa td ae:;.ici, -ts.::i'n teL.,y into line s'a...-s ,' '-,Tpossithie. The flre was, thEreftee, extindais.,ie trot: thh zsitsitc nr. _he beilatn . : .;,:„ ,....,,,,,. :- -.,,,,,, en, 'a.esy Ellen Csnset who was sitLine es the fstnt posdt cf htar she wee e.., 7-ie store. .!-: ,.: ezatet thee sa. sas : red :n bass-3(.3 for eighaeren vears ad was in 7-7h2. ritnc,abt tf tat cc it. Sne stazeci that eri inspection was scheduled for the ftiltwihg clay. Sac aer:let any sda,ant ace tt the strud.tar.e cc tat the elecerical systar. .'.3 .,7e, :let any cc.cart dreeled,s. with eny applandes, bree',.ers trieriihg, cen power fellufes ect. She 7J:en :tit. me .hae .'.s: had a friept s:tyg win :21.. ,:h0 was 7o-me a: ze time af :he tare. ,......., -...J...e_ ,,,,:s “._.:.:e. at ,..—a t...2, L.:. ,..:.a litre. iris st-aeet znat set ..7as it the eeca Dil=:,0fr. . whee she .": :.",.f what s'ne testridat as an exlcsitn. She went tt the frtnt. Ott: ant was diarcat,ec by cdharr7ittian wtirS.ers eSt .were .;tri.f.h.,.; atrtss the street :t net re-enter th:e nctise • dete,ase it is on fire. Ma wdrr7.ers :hen he.'.ded her by peshing her nar e..7.t. :7,1: the C‘i-ahel.e.y ant . lh-ic t.ne etraeh in iler ..":. eway from the f'if . iier ,.7taic7o is "S.,:,.pcst ,:L-1- i; :ia:n,,. Lexc5 li:camse ,S1,'-:7 SiiD 11/1 . Lhe ttitstfactirsn waskes Whs i,-;ehse witnesses at ens fire end assisten ,...-s-,. '.11 -,: SI'reet, ',. ..st :,..an. heath. '..thay sa:ed, ..Ja7. Lair-:' heart aa dee:Lesion and 1cdk.et at tt sea smei:e comin fst , the seridtsrd. :',hey notified :ha o,:her the re-ass they ware weraanc on, Petri-are ,-Eihkin, at Caj-i. Si'l to report :he fire . Tney than weat aiirtss the street arc 3ssisted t:7,7.-iss. Frsi7sss as szated above. [ 'The elirt-:. re is a sinie sticry, single fambi,, ectose. 1t was bisil.j. ip 1938 and is cthstruteed et writ--a with vinyl sii-ing. The toot is ea:list:asstied ct asphalt ehin..31es. The dimeraitns are appraxfdare1y :,2'.,:,4' . Side 3 nentaihs: an .:..a.es carpcf watn a 12'x0' enclose& ,ati.litv recat et: the Cif.) hhrrer. The atrlity room is the area of orhgin. The fire dem.ade was conteinet tr. this 7C-2Ci*:!. arid . SJ:3- 5d '.±.r..:= dtnsee zt she faadir. The taco ttna,:-.1-ts a asni.ng machine and dryer. Whee as'eed, ettn zhe owner and Lhe 'Sties. scares that they ate use the appliances . earlier ip Lee Cay, est thay i.,,,,n3 r:0: :1.r- ass at the time of the fire. Thera was extensien - i 1 I 06172 1 pm ! i 3 1211 1 2018 1 I 116 1 1 18-0003678 1 1 0 1 1 Pxson I iNarratIve i ---- -- m, v:--,Is Yery .1,1ctl annsien 1.:ttc .:I:le .Fj-v:Ic space. The ;-,-.,:. :7-. z--art Of 1.'!"C :2trle C7:::y na:,I S7', . cle:eac. 'The elece,E;,1 eerv:ne :.,etner heaS ancI mnt- r were Ibtated br Icna eat .,-, e, e:'., tec ,,:t_Llity . ree:t. There was ,tn c pc,Lc. anci I,r.ansfsf7e: between Ilis propery .:.1e.i th Freperty tna es . The ser72n.e IInes :'et nh br. 1,as :::77)7! .!='. ,1r- !, ola E,--.-h •,.-..:,, -catner aszi 'box cus-.,: nere-,: :13.::h,st!in .ihi dansge. ,..ime. 7:,,anant- Tetlre: I-I.e7, .e I , . , • This property sold for$804,375 4 months ago. View all 31 photos 35 rx 10388314 01513284380 636x435 MAP STREET --: - ''t ; 1 ?, t } - ' j *- - 8%ter i. .......\ y t ..,... , ,. ..,, „ . . . _,,..,_. _.,z„..... ......__T,-. ..:.4,_::s.: .• r, it Y r``" -�' '4.,--.-mod >�f a K iss • 4y [ House Sold on 8/13/2018 $804,375 Never miss new listings between$700,000—$1,000,000 in this area 1120 Nassau Street Delray Beach, FL 33483 — NASSAU PARK, Palm Beach County 2 beds 2 baths 1,188 sqft $677 per sqft 1937 build 359 days on site RARELY AVAILABLE THIS BEAUTIFUL HISTORICAL 1938 BEACH HOME LOCATED FOUR HOMES OFF THE OCEAN AND A COUPLE OF BLOCKS SOUTH OF ATLANTIC AVENUE. PROPERTY BACK ON THE MARKET. PROPERTY HAS FIRE DAMAGE, PLEASE CALL LISTING AGENT FOR ADDENDUM AND MORE INFORMATION Listing courtesy of BMLS/Lang Realty/Delray Beach MLS#RX-10388314— Report a problem Property details for 1120 Nassau Street Last refreshed 6 minutes ago The Building Year Built: 1937 Construction: Aluminum Siding Type:Single Family Detached Stories: 1 Front Exposure: N SqFt Total: 1438 SqFt Source:Tax Rolls Interior Rooms: Cottage SqFt Living: 1188 Living Room Level: 1 Kitchen Level: 1 Furnished: No Flooring: Ceramic Tile Interior Features:Volume Ceiling Master Bedroom/Bath: Separate Shower Room Dimensions Kitchen Width: 8 Kitchen Length: 9 Living Room Length: 18 Living Room Width: 12 Bedroom 2 Length: 12 Master Bedroom Length: 15 Master Bedroom Width: 10 Bedroom 2 Width: 10 Financial &Terms Membership Equity: No HOPA: No Hopa Terms of Sale: Cash Short Sale: No Business Type:Voluntary Possession:At Closing, Lease Back Restrictions: Other Terms Considered: Cash,Conventional Location Subdivision: NASSAU PARK Area:4140 Directions: A1A SOUTH OF ATLANTIC AVENUE TO NASSAU STREET,4TH HOUSE ON LEFT Geo Lat: 26.456634 Geo Lon: -80.059932 Geo Area: PB05 Street Number: 1120 Street Name: Nassau City Delray Beach State/Province FL Zip Code 33483 The Property Lot Description: < 1/4 Acre Lot Dimensions: 55.0 ft x 100.0 ft Lot SqFt: 5,493 sqft Zoning: R-1-A( Parcel ID: 12434616270000151 Waterfront: None Taxes Taxes: $8,891.87 Taxes: City/County Tax Year: 2016 Beds Total Bedrooms: 2 Master Bedroom Level: 1 Baths Baths Total: 2 Baths Full: 2 The Listing Status: Closed Close Date: 2018-08-13 Sold Price$804,375 Contingencies: Inspection, None County Palm Beach Heating&Cooling Cooling: Central Heating: Central Utilities Utilities: Electric Service Available, None Appliances Equip/Appl Included: Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator,Washer,Water Heater- Electric The Community Governing Bodies: None Pets Allowed:Yes Waterfront: No Private Pool: No Subdivision Amenities: None Parking Parking: 2+Spaces,Carport-Attached, Driveway Carport Spaces: 1.00 House Sold on 8/13/2018 $804,375 Never miss new listings between$700,000—$1,000,000 in this area • From: antondelforno To: Hoyland,Michelle Subject: Dec.5th 2018 Historic Board Discussion Regarding 1120 Nassau St.,Delray Beach,FL Date: Wednesday,December 5,2018 9:09:10 AM Attachments: Historic Board Letter Dec.4th 2018.docx Lang Realty Warren Heeg,1120 Nassau st.Sole.docx Dear Ms. Hoyland, It is my understanding that the Historic Board will hold a discussion this evening at 7 PM regarding 1120 Nassau Street in Delray Beach FL. I've been informed by concerned neighbors that the buyers of this property are now interested in tearing down this historic house which concerns me very much, especially that the fire department saidit only had the house only had smoke damage,and the fire was contained to one area. You will that information in the fire department report that they filed. The house also kept being showed to buyers until purchased. Unfortunately,being out of town at this time, I cannot attend this evening's discussion. However,I do want to express my concerns as I am the house just west of 1120 Nassau Street. I'd appreciate you getting back to me confirming this information was received. I will be in contact with you early next year when I return to Florida. I look forward to meeting you. Thank you again for your time. Diane Del Forno mobile 201-259-4079 According to the Local Historic Preservation Ordinance, a property must fulfill one or more of the following criteria to qualify as an historic site : • Is associated with the life of a person important in city, state, or national history; • Is associated in a significant way with a major historic event of a cultural, economic, social, military, or political nature; • Exemplifies the historical, political, cultural, or social trend of the community in history; • Is associated with a past or continuing institution, which has contributed substantially to the City's life. • The building, site, or structure is deemed to have significant architectural or aesthetic significance if it: • Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by a particular architectural style; • Embodies the distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, or method of construction ; • Is an historic or outstanding work of a prominent architect, designer, landscape architect, or builder; • Contains elements of design, detail, material, or craftsmanship of outstanding quality, or which represented, in its time, a significant innovation or adaptation to the South Florida environment. HISTORIC CARVER HIGH SCHOOL Table of contents General Information Tab A Locator Map Tab B Overview Tab C Historical Significance Tab D Master Site File Forms Tab E Photographs Tab F Architectural Drawings Tab G Sources Tab H Letters of Support Tab I GENERAL INFORMATION Location: 301 SW 14th Ave., Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida. Date of Construction: 1958 Architect: Gustav A. Maass Builder: Palm Beach County School District Present owner: Palm Beach County School District Present use: Full service center Future use: Adult education, culinary institute Present zoning: CF. Community Facility Future zoning: CF. Community Facility Property Control #: 12 43 46 17 00 000-7060 Legal Description: 17-46-43, SE 1/4 of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4 (less W 30-feet, N 25-feet and E 25-feet RD R/ W) Classification for Designation Historical, cultural and architectural , r • C3 OF DatiV.1 ---mttoiPa 0:3-Pre- .sro seNoki &Lma-3m1) ezt-geGoticd--6404-- i IN(0 8M6 m D a. • /Mr CitiNer_ ms 1111 bit6tk C N " 9-2-1 (1 Fats..Civet) et-i-nr=z) 0 0.25 0.5 miles JACKS ► hwiC0. ...."1 4 !it • - - • 'a te ` � 4 kli - . Search by,.r7�vrrer, Add*ens or Parcef ' �" .rtr, ' e GA der Qi 00 E Aot , - - , . --, .. _-..., .xr•-•. . [ & , . ki."' !Li' ' .."•. &...M. *qr.:* ..". `fj a �.,,�; fir. --_- .• •- .le" �J/ ri••a�fr. ,..e....�� `__ ,- —.. '_ �.�L \ 11. ;' i' '� r SW 3r I?I 1 _I . _ • „_ ' r F .ar• . ARC WV � .. r /_ , r' _� 'C:_ . � - ate••N *'^ • t - - - •L• r t� r- '. - --Jig , • '.. . Auburn Cn N �_4. .. Of .t .. w•-• ' 1. 16 i' ... t, t' iiiii- yr • 6- „ SW art,Sr-" �"ak # "Auburn Cyr Ali. .., it - .... . • 1 it it ..... 1. .kt.--li>t I . 0 % -SW 14h A-4e-- JACKS -'tith,1 ..,..„,._ . _ ... __, 7.4,Illi $1"••••- 1 . .., — .., ie., i',01,11‘..-„,, Li Pcir'..el -..--. 1• 4-,.; '' . ." Zi..., ilk • 4*. .., .0. _ ...Zr-'1:'fa- nod -e-,0,--45, -,I.gt 12' 7 4110 = fr AYP 44 i 0 0 4- i <'' "ICAO t iir".i. ...--,, . --. •, _ . .. .' lik172 i- , CA; , *, ,_-7 " , ' '..:- 1 P 0 P ' 401,7''''' - 'PP.,. '. _ ° .it F--, . .1. It- . IA rind SI , 41111110r M.r I.. .. ii ,rm, A)'1. . . .-......... 1....das-Is ....,...,.... .. ...'". : . ,.‘ . < 0;Silf,i4 . . ......-N --4 '—se • ......, ..., .. -,.......i _ - — ' '--' " • . , h.te - ...) Pa -. _ 11 31,;..- wi r (--- . *JO 7.‘ —"—f $....-7 .....• 11: . . . , 111,-`11-;4.,-4.4.10,- i 4.,... "' ria.41114.:- .':,...''''''" ..-, --- Ir.- •' L.: -' .-`:4t7--,1 IWO' ::. "i' ", _. - -?"-- • ' 1-11"1111P".1.-41-: ' '1 , * ilia , T4ioritio;‘, ; In. . I 4.. .. • r•- • Mite oil r , ilk .r.. •• im4.7"..... ."--4 ;----.. r ---... Plif . t ' ' .... . 1111•0" _.,.4; ... „a., 11/4,,,:.P..- i at....... 4-7-21r, . „. r- . .........,! . . — 6 .;,.11r10, ' ••• * .... N. 11,. t'. ...iii . ,,,...., .:. 7. .4 - - 1--- $ . F"milk.. i 0 ry.e—iiit , 11;1111- 6,1' 4 ---•- . • i ' t - --a. .,...,.. ., ,A ;4:;.,,;-. is 49.11 ,..,. J‘I'''.. t A ' 11_ 1-' • , - 4- ' . • _i a_t__ . ... .ftiall - -_ . WIZ Xii sP . . FRI . .. . '1 i., ' r _ , • iii•,.,I.. , ir..., 1, taiirop •*161171111,. litClillaillir ... 5 ; t , 9 * _ ; *.rd . .., ' a 411.1 46 * • t $ - . 4. te.:,- t "., , _ _'... .., . . ..,,,.. - • ' .. --...."•-,•".‘-. __Ilift.ir'7 r- r,. •It J ..". • GO I. 44... . VD 111 •..it- VI! -1411-00'. - .'t'. 4". .i.,mboomrimaltt"J"-- - . -e• . _ . 30 I -. .",.11 ) '14 --- iii\l - lit . A - lit :1-.1. , 1 ,44.fri I It.' , jel p...., 4 .. ....,.. ii, ,... . ....".. . _ ,.....,_ . , ,:-.- 1,......,.....„,..„... , , .. i PI • ' A.I.' alt. - I ' WV dr• • , t ,, • - -. .11.. 0 41•di...4 .6t ...... , .,--......, . - ... VE Le ,,k-'i -Ftf-1.(4 _. r - . _ - ..- 41ear 4,10 . ii. 0, _ _. ... "t_‘i,et.44, , ,„,7'*. irilie vino If • - ''''' - -- --,ow - A-Ant, or , , .' -,. %,. io ,.. • , F L- 7 i1.7 • ,1 . ,!, , 6 ,_,. ,.... ••••11,AA,- - - .dirlr. . A' '' 1.41141.2I .- 't & - . •A 11‘. - 4 • ,,., •:-. , s,,...: I gividm . .. 0 . D F "' " 1 D %......griliWs ill It'," - ' .6*. ' - i g- ' ,-, • , ' ; , .:. . _.. 41".. r.....: - -— g .# ,,,,,,--- • ,. • . "-411 1 1 E ' 14 ,, - .,04. .c _IF i 1_,I r E A - '' .- - `--1 1 ik 1.-- , f - ..„. '4' 44111' 1-2" 4*" ' IS 0-0 ..41/4 L .A ..I .4 ,- - .- -, 3 - 1; I I . .. . Jr__ 1 , , . 41. . ,-- SW etti:Sr—' .:11 t. ••=.1-,.. , .--• — f ,` wi, . eo it, --A". Auburn ilb Di".' tilkoollial$4110411m.. . ._ t . V OIL A • 4101, ' 1101100 r..4,Ai ,4—Wm 0. , 'tirrir, r": • / II .1 1. i , - • 4111110 r ft, r411/1,,, - l• * ip lin•.; t lire% - -4r, * i. ...,,,......0. 4:0, .... .a.s ,ra, , -41 •• r r- tillib' ' .4 V• YP. ", i ••• ix Ir. 'Y . 1 . e t i n .• • - 7 . le\ r 4' l •r..' . . f 9 bill ..., - P.ZAiliiiii64 -r. _1, ' 'Cr vi . 4. Vilmilltim- i'"f • - - I� DOROTHYJACKS (. t r .. , , ., x. PAPA Home - \L�i. la fit-St rT�r Et ' OR i Search by Owner,Address or Parcel * 'm 1"r. w f 1 © O Bi 4ii" r— ._ �- • v: • rR 76 •r-"'A 1 it----.' - L li ) J.C., _. ` _. View ProoertvRecord `'i r ` '� ''• Rell itit'• SW Ind St ! ,4 r. t°��, • Owners (`r' f ,�_ -aixiLIIIT %'• ` t SCHOOL BOARD OF PALM BEACH COUNT -c '1 •-a ka `- I _ � —._ "7 -_W , 4 FL ,„,.. tT a. y.11 a - �S W y PLANNING&REAL ESTATE SERVICES ay .1��kr 9a-• . r I �•a x.RiLF'.+ -- ► . 9 Property detail 'l yAl « f, •°--• ae ,G-. 1. 1-" ., r,, - ,`• ,r 301 SW 14TH AVE ' f ,4► �h'•_ _ .�+ f • T S �: _ ', it �' �r L''r? +ti. DELRAY BEACH 4 - '7 i"^t � -. r�"�� '2• ~_ 12434617000007060 1�ry,_.• .t' �Y=1�.i '�••.F'. ,j Ri + m +-.a$W 3fd St' l 1 !r . _ - - Q < R 02714 1498 , , 1 ita. - - 5 r JAN-1977 � 'G n-:....r . .-. '.; — , - '�Nr.. SW]rd Ct . f �` 3300 FOREST HILL BLVD C- . - l d. ; ; �f n rr • 110 r' k, r_ _ -. r..� -SW 3ed Ct' WEST PALM BEACH FL •: ' '• "i, —_ -�r .•' -� 33406 5813 ' '- -- _I �a:r ByVMst y _ - 8300-PUB CTY SCHOOL '.! .9r '�t F: 112780 ; _ _ sw4tn`st t,o � . w +rah a► f Sales Information # _ _,, '? - Sales Date Price -t t•�}N a _. - _, - •_��� Auburn Cur•N '` Appraisals `ry a -'"'te r r. .� ` ,` Tax Year 2017 ,.rit„— } •+ -q`i _4��`' 54050.894 1, �Jtllr' ' t-,t �- • 4-• t orx ..rr,[ _ f`� ' �!' r. 41.060,833 SW aw �t !, ;• �- 45.111,727 . � y�ii .►.re �-. ��. 1"''• S' � h 1 All values are as of January 1st each - •• r„y �a1 w isl, _� r veal - '- - T w + } • ,~ iambi � . -! _ - • t 3 •;1 = -+s�n � a'►Lxlc. ,-__ ,Beach Cour. al Assessed/Taxable values Tax Year 2017 Taxes Tax Year 2017 VA2uAe`2 l/*t*w c.tik C31 M'-4,-.5l tu'l SO Sv,) 1-4 f )a.R `1 t(-�. Carver Overview Just before the turn of 20th century, the pioneering African American community in the fledgling town known as Linton was pushing for the county to educate their children. At that point, what little schooling that existed was taught in a thatch hut. Minutes from the Feb. 6, 1896, board meeting of the Dade County School Board (Palm Beach County would not be carved our for decades) note, "The patrons of Linton are pressing their claims for a school to be built at once." The minutes further note: "There are presently 25 children of school age." At that point, a resident named RR Frazier donated two acres of land "fee simple" near what is now NW 5th Street to the fledgling school board. Thus was born School #4 Colored. May 5, 1896: the Dade County School Board "ordered that one coat of paint be put on the Linton school, the board to furnish the material, the patrons to do the work." The school struggled mightily during its first several years and finally, in 1907, School #4 Colored was closed by the superintendent for lack of attendance. It would not reopen until 1915 under the name of Delray County Training School. Seven years later, at the urging of his mentor, George Washington Carver, the renowned African-American agricultural chemist, Solomon David Spady came to Delray Beach to serve as the third principal of the school. At that point, the Training School had 100 students in grades 1-8. By 1934, it had grown to 336 students in grades 1-10. It soon outgrew its building and in 1937 the school moved to a new building on NW 8th Avenue and renamed George Washington Carver High School. The first graduating class came in 1939. In 1958, the school reopened in a new facility at SW 12th Ave., and SW 4th Street. Around that time, C. Spencer Pompey arrived at Carver He served as a coach and social studies teacher for many years and was a prominent civil rights activist throughout the county. Pompey fought for equal salaries between white and black teachers, protested Delray Beach's whites-only beach in the 1950s and pushed for the first organized recreation programs for the city's black children. Carver became one of the state's football powerhouses. Between 1947 and 1963, the school won four conference titles and won three straight state titles in 1961-1963. The 1962 team shut out eight of its 10 opponents and the other two scored a measly 19 points combined. Desegregation led to the school's closing in 1969. It merged with the former Seacrest High School, the predominantly white school in the city. Seacrest students chose the new school's name, Atlantic, and Carver students chose the team mascot's name: It would be the same as it was during Carver's time. Thus was born the Atlantic Eagles. It is buildings #1 and#12, original structures on the site now home to the Delray Full Service Center, that are respectfully submitted for application to become listed in the State index of Historic Structures. Carver High School' s roots 1895 — Colored School #4 Delray opened on NW 5th Avenue, one-half block north of Atlantic Avenue 1912 — School closed for lack of attendance 1913 — School reopens on same site and is renamed the Delray County Training School 1937 — Training School moved to a new two-story clapboard building at NW 8th Avenue and Lake Ida Road. 1939 —First 12th grade graduation 1940— African American citizens petition to have the school renamed George Washington Carver Junior- Senior High School 1946 —Palm Beach School District approves the name change 1959 —Carver High School moves to new campus at SW 4th Street and SW 12th Avenue and the old school is renamed S.D. Spady Elementary School 1970 — Carver and Seacrest high schools merge on the Seacrest campus during integration. The new school is named Atlantic High School. Carver High School is renamed George Washington Carver Middle School. C. Spencer Pompey, long-time social studies teacher and coach at Carver High, becomes principal at Carver Middle until his retirement in 1979. 1995 — Carver Middle School is renamed the Delray Full Service Center Source: S.D. Spady Cultural Heritage Museum archives. Carver High School Fact Sheet The former Carver High School in the Southwest neighborhood of Delray Beach is historically significant for at least four reasons: Associated with a famous person or event: Solomon D. Spady was sent to Delray Beach in the 1920s by George Washington Carver and Booker T. Washington to run the school, which was then called the Delray Training School. Later, C. Spencer Pompey served as coach and social studies teacher. Both men were not only prominent in the African American community, but movers and shakers across Palm Beach County. Architectural: It was designed by Gustav Maass, a well-known mid-century architect who also designed the Seaboard Air Line train station just west of Interstate 95 in Delray Beach. That building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Cultural: Carver High was an important, and one of the few public, gathering places for the African American community. A generation of residents attended graduations, neighborhood meetings and other events at the school. Age: The school building was constructed in 1959 and is more than 50 years old, the benchmark. When it was built, Carver High School served African American students from Deerfield Beach to Lake Worth and west to the farm lands. It not only educated students, it nurtured them during the dark days of segregation. Carver's roots date back to the 19th century, when pioneering African Americans in the fledgling town of Linton were pushing the county to educate their children. Then a part of the Dade County School Board, School #4 Colored was opened in Delray Beach Site Plan#3, developed during community meetings, not only preserves the two historic Carver High buildings (Now called Building #1 and Building #12), but also incorporates a football field for Village Academy. Site Plan#3 provides space for needed adult education (Building #1) and the former cafetorium (Building #12) could serve as a much needed culinary trade school. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE Built: 1958 Architect: Gustav A Maass Period of significant: 1958-1968 The former Carver High School (Building #1) is a symmetrical, two story, Mid-Century Modern style with a sweeping cantilevered concrete covered central entrance. It faces north towards SW 3d Street,just west of SW 12th Avenue in Delray Beach. It is composed of steel and CMU construction materials, stuccoed and painted a soft beige. There is another cantilevered covering for an entrance on the west side of the adjoining building (#12). There are stairway bays on the east and west ends of the building that were ventilated by an air brick pattern (popular in warm climes to provide better air circulation) and lit by a two column bay of windows. The rest of the fenestration consisted of aluminum-clad projected awning windows in columns of five horizontal windows in a bay of four columns. It had a flat roof, typical of the time, and symmetrical vents to let rain water escape. The modest campus was connected by a series of concrete breezeways to protect students from the elements. The buildings also are significant because they were designed by architect Gustav A. Maass . Maass was born in New Orleans and came to Palm Beach County in the early 1920s. He participated in the design of railroad stations on Florida's east and west coasts, including the Seaboard Air Line Railway Station in Delray Beach. That station is listed on the National Register of Historic Buildings. Maass designed many buildings in Delray Beach in the 1920s, `30s, '40s and `50s. his Art Deco style was reflected in commercial buildings along Atlantic Avenue, including the Boyd building at Atlantic Avenue and the Intracoastal Waterway, which remains today and is the site of the present Deck 84 restaurant. He designed a Delray Beach home in the Virginia Colonial Farmhouse Style (1936) for farmers Marshall and Jeannette Butts DeWitt. Late in his career, he designed the Mid-Century Moderne Carver High School, which could well be one of the latest surviving Maass designs in Delray Beach. The Palm Beach Town Council designated several Maass-designed houses as landmarks to be preserved, many of which were in the Mediterranean Revival style featuring simple windows, barrel clay tile roofs, and stucco exteriors. The Carver High School building, unfortunately, has been altered over the years and is in need of being restored to its original Maass design. Another building was constructed to the east of the original, and the entranceway was moved from its original position to the space between the new and original building. The original entrance was filled in with extra classroom space. One of the reasons the non-profit Save-Carver High organization is seeking historic designation is to seek grant money to restore the school to Maass' original design. CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE Carver High School not only challenged and educated its students, it nurtured them. In the late 1960's, integration made a profound impact on the Carver High School community. Metaphorically, its effect was as if the umbilical cord was severed from a strong functioning body composed of love and a nurturing source which had spurred students over the years to rise to levels of high expectations. The culture of Carver High School was not only of historical athletic prowess but a nurturing multifaceted entity composed of a sense of family and love that was solidified and protected by the community. Carver High School was our "Village", which had such a strong connection with everyone....parents, students, families, community and teachers; all focusing not on academic training, but on physical, moral, nutritional and even hygienic excellence. The students would dare not come to school without appearing to care about their appearance. In the rare instances that would happen, in the words of one teacher, the student would be told: "you had to do the hygiene dance"; cleaned, kempt and prepared for the trials of each day. Thus, everyone took pride in not only their scholastic abilities but also in their appearance and behavior. Pride in one's self, was paramount at Carver. Carver was a close-knit community. Teachers were your neighbors. Many belonged to the same churches, social groups, and even shopped at the same corner markets. Every aspect of Carver High had a profound impact on its students and community. The cafetorium was a gathering place for Black community events such as talent shows, plays, kindergarten graduations, musical concerts and community meeting, not to mention its primary purpose of providing daily lunch that everyone looked forward to. The school family made sure that no one went home hungry. For many students, Carver was a safe haven and their home away from home. Some students were there from early morning to late in the evening due to their involvement in many after-school activities and studies. Track and football events not only attracted the Carver High families but also community members at large throughout the county. The Eagles had outstanding winning records in sports, especially in football, basketball, track and field and even more impressive performance records from its stellar marching band. The school invested in a family oriented culture. The school was the hub for any significant social, political or economic changes that occurred in the southern part of Palm Beach County. This era was a troubling period in American history especially because of Civil Rights and Vietnam War. The school was often the site for community exchanges. Parents received support and advice with their personal and financial decisions. If there was a critical or financial need, someone within the school family, be it an individual, a group of teachers or an organization, helped out. Often, teachers served as surrogate parents. Mistakes were not used as punishments or failures but as an opportunity to learn and grow for both the teachers and students. Cooperative learning was a necessity; 'You teach me I teach you.' Thus, Children were encouraged to do their best. The Eagle Pride sustained them. Carver served students from Lake Worth to Deerfield Beach including Lake Osborne, Boynton, farming communities (Rangeline) in West Boynton, Delray, Boca Raton. Very few children felt isolated. The soul of Carver provided a competitive spirit in all areas, be it academic, the arts, sports or public arena. Despite the students' low socio-economic status, Eagle Pride spurred graduates on to becoming lawyers, doctors and other medical personnel, entrepreneurs, educators and professional athletes. As stated by noted historian, John Henrik Clarke "History is not everything, but it is a starting point. History is a clock that people use to tell their political and cultural time of day. It is a compass they use to find themselves on the map of human geography. It tells them where they are but, more importantly, what they must be. " We are attempting to preserve our historic presence rather than being eradicated from the map of Delray Beach. This fact alone, that Carver serviced so many families who were bused, or walked for a better education demonstrates its significance and value. The NEED for preservation results from the hard work, dedication and determination of our early pioneers. Our early pioneers are an important part of our personal stories and family histories, in addition to paving the way for generations to come. Preservation also allows for the windows of the past to remain open. Knowledge and retention of this historic site can inspire future generations. C. Spencer Pompey and Thurgood Marshall In his memoir book: More Rivers to Cross, C. Spencer Pompey devotes several pages to the landmark class action suit that sought equal pay for black school teachers in Palm Beach County. In the fall of 1942, Pompey had dinner with several of the the other plaintiffs and the young NAACP attorney who would argue the case, Thurgood Marshall. Marshall, Pompey recalled, had a commanding presence (as well as a particularly hearty appetite.) The case was styled: Charles H. Stebbins et al vs Board of Public Instruction of Palm Beach County. In the book, Pompey wrote that Marshall argued the case before a "Judge Holland" beginning Nov. 26, 1942 (although most of the other references to the case cite 1941 as the year of the trial.) The case was also cited in The Palm Beach Post on Aug. 23, 1992 and again in The Post on Dec. 19, 1999. The latter article was co-authored by Stebbins Jefferson, a long time member of The Post's Editorial Board and the niece of Charles H. Stebbins. The case was also cited in Pompey's obituaries that ran in The Post and the Sun-Sentinel on July 25, 2001. Historical Structure Form Florida Master Site File Carver High School Building #1 (Classrooms) Building #12 (Cafetorium) Gymnasium 301 SW 14th Ave., Delray Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida Constructed 1958 Designed by Gustav A. Maass, AIA • Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 PB 17717 �► \1 FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Field Date 5/11/2018 ❑Original I = - Version 4.0 1/07 Form Date 5/11/2018 ❑Update � MI Recorder# CTV �, Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none) Carver High School,Building#1 Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) Ebuilding ['structure ❑district ❑site ['object OWnefShip:❑private-profit ❑private-nonprofit ❑private-individual ['private-nonspecific ❑city ❑x county ❑state ['federal ['Native American ['foreign ❑unknown 41-31 Al lil t l r; NAVfT-I(t I't Street Number Direction Street Name Street Type Suffix Direction Address: 301 SW 14TH Avenue Cross Streets(nearest I between) USGS 7.5 Map Name DELRAY BEACH USGS Date Plat or Other Map City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In City Limits? Ayes Ono ❑unknown County Palm Beach Township 46S Range 43E Section 17 '/4 section: ❑NW ❑SW ❑SE ONE Irregular-name: Tax Parcel # 12-43-46-17-00-000-7060 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block Lot _ UTM Coordinates:Zone 016 017 Easting Northing Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Construction Year: 1958 El approximately ID year listed or earlier ❑year listed or later Original Use School From(year): 1958 To(year): 1968 Current Use School From(year): 1968 To(year): 2018 Other Use From(year): To(year): Moves: Dyes Eno ['unknown Date: Original address Alterations: oyes Ono ['unknown Date: June,1975 Nature filled in original entrance; Additions: Eyes Ono ['unknown Date: June 1975 Nature built additional classrooms Architect(last name first): Maass,Gustav Builder(last name first): Ol nepr is eiistol�.(�S�e AI Spr ni argil Gigs!$§$f�atstioy,et �st owned by the Dade County Seoul Buaid,now owned by Palm Beach uwny Schools e re cessor ore c o Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Eyes Ono Dunknown Describe Trying for local designataion Style Mid-Century Modern Exterior Plan Rectangular Number of Stories 2 Exterior Fabric(s) 1. Concrete block 2. Stucco 3. Roof Type(s) 1. Flat 2. 3. Roof Material(s) 1. Tar&gravel 2. 3. Roof secondary strucs.(dormers etc.)1. 2. Windows(types,materials,etc.) Aluminum-.lad ujet,ted awning Distinguishing Architectural Features(exterior or interior ornaments) Sleek,sueaudined design. Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO-Appears to meet criteria for NR listing:Dyes Ono ['insufficient info Date Init. KEEPER-Determined eligible: Oyes Ono Date ['Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: Da ❑b Dc ❑d (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources I R.A.Gray Building 1500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399-0250 Phone(850)245-6440/ Fax(850)245.6439 I E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 iofBr ctu -rwirr , ..a) Chimney:No. Chimney Material(s): 1. 2. Structural System(s): 1. Concrete block 2. 3. Foundation Type(s): 1. Piers 2. Foundation Material(s): 1. Concrete,Generic 2. Main Entrance lsttvlisfic details) ean,stmp a It s,sweeping concrete awning over enuance. Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof types,etc.) Condition(overall resource condition): ❑excellent ❑good ❑fair ['deteriorated Ominous Narrative Description of Resource see attached Archaeological Remains ❑Check if Archaeological Form Completed (. I ri.)L r(dir'p ll, 1 , f t 1 ❑FMSF record search(sites/surveys) ['library research ['building permits ['Sanborn maps ❑FL State Archives/photo collection ❑city directory ❑occupant/owner interview ['plat maps ['property appraiser/tax records I]newspaper files ['neighbor interview ['Public Lands Survey(DEP) ❑cultural resource survey(CRAS) ['historic photos ❑interior inspection ❑NABS/HAER record search Pother methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) mwot ice, Z a,zTc-0N aucorc/vt Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? Oyes Ono ['insufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district? Oyes Ono ['insufficient information EgiliaLation otEs aluati�eriareAqu edd�v ether significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic heritage","community planning&development',etc.) 1. Black history 3. Architecture 5. Ethnic heritage 2. African American 4. Athletics 6. .G Q L L d 13TA'Al rOTi Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field notes,analysis notes,photos,plans and other important documents 1 Document type Artifact collection-open to public Maintaining organization Document description File or accession#'s 2) Document type Photographs Maintaining organization Document description File or accession#'s Recorder Name Price A.Patton Affiliation Delray Beach Preservation Board Recorder Contact Information 1020 Tamarind Rd.,Delray Beach,Fla.561-573-2598,pricepatton cr aol.com (address/phone/fax/e-mail) 0 USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required 0 LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP(available from most property appraiser web sites) Attachments © PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format(plain paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. Page 1 ' HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 PB17718 _ _ FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Field Date 5/11/2018 ❑Original f ' j Version 4.0 1/07 Form Date 5/111/2018 ❑Update 'IT 11" Recorder# CTV Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none) Carver High School.Building#12 Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) Ebuilding ['structure ['district ['site ['object Ownership:❑private-profit ❑private-nonprofit ❑private-individual ❑/prriii ��// vate-nonspecific ❑ 0/county county'�['state ['federal ['Native American ['foreign ['unknown AiYC ITrON Street Number Direction Street Name Street Type Suffix Direction Address: 301 SW 14TH Avenue Cross Streets(nearest!between) USGS 7.5 Map Name USGS Date Plat or Other Map City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In City Limits? Oyes Ono ❑unknown County Palm Beach Township 46S Range 43E Section 17 '/4 section: ❑NW ❑SW OSE ONE Irregular-name: Tax Parcel # 12-43-46-17-00-000-7060 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block Lot UTM Coordinates:Zone 016 017 Easting Northing Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Construction Year: 1958 0 approximately E year listed or earlier year listed or later Original Use School From(year): 1958 To(year): 1968 Current Use School From(year): 1968 To(year): zols Other Use From(year): To(year): Moves: Dyes Eno ['unknown Date: Original address Alterations: Oyes no ['unknown Date: June 1975 Nature Additions: Eyes Ono ['unknown Date: Nature Added to west of original structure Architect(last name first): Maass.Gustav Builder(last name first): O?arimr Iikki ounl (senocotlDy o tinieal owner,dates,profession,etc.) Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Eyes Ono ['unknown Describe Trying for local designation Style Mid-Century Modem Exterior Plan Rectangular Number of Stories Exterior Fabric(s) 1. Concrete block 2. Stucco 3. Roof Type(s) 1. Flat 2. 3. Roof Material(s) 1. Tar&gravel 2. 3. W� Roof secondarystruts.(dormers etc.)1. 2. itfi nto m-ciao projected awhiul; Ditinciuishi 1n,Architectural Features(exterior or interior ornaments) ea ,srmp tnes,sweeping concrete a ntng over entrance Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO—Appears to meet criteria for NR listing:Oyes Ono ['insufficient info Date Init. KEEPER—Determined eligible: Oyes Ono Date ['Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: Oa Ob ❑c ❑d (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources I R.A.Gray Building!500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399-0250 Phone(850)245.6440 I Fax(850)245-6439 I E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 111. 0—'lr,tU'�1Nr..t q f t _:.ill) Chimney:No. Chimney Material(s): 1. 2. Structural System(s): 1. Concrete block 2. 3. Foundation Type(s): 1. Piers 2. Foundation Material(s): 1. Concrete,Generic 2. Main Entrance(stylistic details) Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof types,etc.) Condition(overall resource condition): ❑excellent ❑good ❑fair deteriorated ['ruinous NarrativeDedscription of Resource Archaeological Remains ['Check if Archaeological Form Completed 1-F TAR t„r(IKO,][ o(UAW rr-a yiztli M ritql.< t 1-17;) ❑FMSF record search(sites/surveys) plibrary research ❑x building permits ❑x Sanborn maps ❑FL State Archives/photo collection Elcity directory ❑occupant/owner interview l plat maps IIproperty appraiser/tax records ['newspaper files p neighbor interview ❑Public Lands Survey(DEP) ['cultural resource survey(CRAS) phistoric photos ❑interior inspection ❑NABS/HAER record search pother methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) • T-DiTON Vf.1} I�TtiT- �. ✓!;L)I bti?"11 t� t Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? Oyes Ono insufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district? Oyes Ono ❑x insufficient information Exolaauattii quaoffEsa"ou3 Inoterirr euiredhw ether significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic heritage","community planning&development',etc.) 1. Black history 3. Architecture 5. 2. African American 4. Athletics 6. F URkAI!at 17[r1.lrt'U7iol Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field notes,analysis notes,photos,plans and other important documents 1 Document type Artifact collection-open to public Maintaining organization Document description File or accession#'s 2) Document type Photographs Maintaining organization Document description File or accession#'s i i (,s U Ri L'� Dg1-;t U ixTjro,l 1 Recorder Name Price A.Patton Affiliation Delray Beach Preservation Board Recorder Contact Information 1020 Tamarind Rd.,Delray Beach,Fla.561-573-2598,pricepatton(2i aol.com (address I phone I fax I e-mail) 0 USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required 0 LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP(available from most property appraiser web sites) Attachments © PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format(plain paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. Page 1 j '`\ HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 PB17719 :M \ Field Date 5/11/2018 FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Original - Form Date 5/11/2018 0 Update r j Version 4.0 1/07 `I�'� Recorder# cTv Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site Name(s)(address if none) Carver High School gymnasium Multiple Listing(DHR only) Survey Project Name Survey#(DHR only) National Register Category(please check one) building ['structure ['district ['site ['object OWnerShip:❑private-profit ❑private-nonprofit ❑private-individual ❑private-nonspecific ['city Ecounty ['state ['federal ['Native American ['foreign ['unknown Street Number Direction Street Name Street Type Suffix Direction Address: 301 SW 14TH Avenue Cross Streets(nearest/between) USGS 7.5 Map Name DELRAY BEACH USGS Date Plat or Other Map City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In City Limits? Oyes Ono ❑unknown County Township 46S Range 43E Section 17 1/4 section: ❑NW ❑SW ❑SE ONE Irregular-name: Tax Parcel # 12-43-46-17-00-000-7060 Landgrant Subdivision Name Block Lot UTM Coordinates:Zone 016 ❑17 Easting Northing Other Coordinates: X: Y: Coordinate System&Datum Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) ;<c-et• ;t �'' '+' dint tl I ''1�_ - 'i:Y.. T Construction Year: 1958 0 approximately 0 year listed or earlier 0 year listed or later Original Use School From(year): 1958 To(year): 2018 Current Use School From(year): To(year): Other Use From(year): To(year): Moves: Dyes Eno ['unknown Date: Original address 301 SW 14th Ave. Alterations: Dyes no ❑unknown Date: Nature Additions: Oyes Eno ['unknown Date: Nature Architect(last name first): Maass,Gustav Builder(last name first): Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Eyes Ono ❑unknown Describe Seeking listine on local regis 7� ,= - Mp ) r ... �,1 � .s- J`�..1�•IY $ . _ ..�.. -=tt„_ fit-. — Style Mid-Century Modem Exterior Plan Rectaneular Number of Stories Exterior Fabric(S) 1. Concrete block 2. Stucco 3. Roof Type(s) 1. Bowed-arched 2. 3. Roof Material(s) 1. 2. 3. Roof secondary strucs.(dormers etc.)1. 2. Windows(types,materials,etc.) Distinguishing Architectural Features(exterior or interior omaments) Sleek,suearnliued design. Ancillary Features/Outbuildings(record outbuildings,major landscape features;use continuation sheet if needed.) DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATION DHR USE ONLY NR List Date SHPO-Appears to meet criteria for NR listing:oyes Ono ❑insufficient info Date Init. KEEPER-Determined eligible: Oyes Ono Date ❑Owner Objection NR Criteria for Evaluation: Da ❑b ❑c ❑d (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File 1 Division of Historical Resources I R.A.Gray Building 1500 South Bronough Street,Tallahassee,FL 32399-0250 Phone(850)245-6440/Fax(850)245-6439/E-mail SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site#8 DESCRIPTION(continued) Chimney:No. Chimney Material(s): 1. 2. Structural System(s): 1. Concrete block 2. 3. Foundation Type(s): 1. Piers 2. Foundation Material(s): 1. Poured Concrete Footing 2. Main Entrance(stylistic details) Porch Descriptions(types,locations,roof types,etc.) Condition(overall resource condition): ❑excellent Ogood ❑fair ['deteriorated Ominous Narrative Description of Resource Archaeological Remains ❑Check if Archaeological Form Completed RESEARCH METHODS (check all that apply) ❑FMSF record search(sites/surveys) ['library research ['building permits ['Sanborn maps ❑FL State Archives/photo collection Ocity directory ❑occupant/owner interview ['plat maps ['property appraiser/tax records ['newspaper files ['neighbor interview ❑Public Lands Survey(DEP) Ocultural resource survey(CRAS) ['historic photos ❑interior inspection ❑HABS/HAER record search Pother methods(describe) Bibliographic References(give FMSF manuscript#if relevant,use continuation sheet if needed) OPINION OF RESOURCE SIGNIFICANCE Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? Dyes Ono ['insufficient information Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part of a district? Dyes Ono [Insufficient information Explanation of Evaluation(required,whether significant or not;use separate sheet if needed) Area(s)of Historical Significance(see National Register Bulletin 15,p.8 for categories:e.g."architecture","ethnic heritage","community planning&development",etc.) 1. Black history 3. Architecture 5. Ethnic heritage 2. African American 4. Athletics 6. DOCUMENTATION Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File-including field notes,analysis notes,photos,plans and other important documents 1 Document type Artifact collection-open to public Maintaining organization Palm Beach Count Preservation Board Document description File or accession#'s 2) Document type Photographs Maintaining organization Document description File or accession#'s RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name Prce A.Patton Affiliation Delray Beach Preservation Board Recorder Contact Information 1020 Tamarind Rd..Delray Beach,Fla.33483.pricepatton(kaol.com.561-573-2598 (address/phone/fax/e-mail) 0 USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED Required © LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP (available from most property appraiser web sites) Attachments 0 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file,it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format(plain paper is acceptable). Digital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels,24-bit color,jpeg or tiff. 1 CARVER HIGH SCHOOL , .,.. - ii. .... -,=I a A r,7.3 jimplig i 11 i .....,.....A..... ...• .... 1.1111111114 01.11.111.111 I : 1111.,.'.' 111111111 il I 4 t 7""•••ri5 st-r........ma" 00 NO 1111 r IIMMI mu..."-:41 in.11,10,,i;;Iiii-moi Wit,*41, )imall amp fal alydillill . t 1 t• WI = c ..t . • , '-, I . _ i grweiggrr . , 1111140 ' - r (0, , a... ,.....,......„ ... ili' 1111 M , al • alrivil i it'0 r 4. ,..,c .... r J . ' 4 •00 I 0 IIIII . • , . , . 6 . • 4 . . iv'' , ' 0 • • • SA ' . ‘060 igif, . •-• . ..0 ..4 4 , .___, ••••• „, .1 • .r.4. n # r 6 . • • 1,, ., .„ .. •It/10i . 4 * - . - • 4. i'••••• : —• y'6 .. ., 30 • , . . ,P. * I., '' • • * . , .... .q.. ,.., . . • .4'''' .fr• ."' '4 . .* p, 4 . • ' • 16 9. so • . if.. • ,4 .. Ng . .4. ,• t• 4 " • . '-•.1 • .lie ,. ' 5: - . . • ,- ": ' 4 V A .• ,1 ..1 . . ,,*Ai L .• ... o• 4. 'ibe..•A•• ' .. .•.,..7 , . , • + . A • • 'II- 4 ' . • • NI • .. -__ • 1.4:. I,:if, . le,... .. , as. .. .t••• - - • 4. , -. -,,, . ....... _ _ is . - ....*4 - - . ..: i : . .. . . • _ ____. ,. • ,,k,..1,.. .... •,, • I '..., ---- -,' ' :. t, ---.:A ..., 44•-k , , , ie, --,,v,•-.. : . .::•. `, - ....---- _ , :n;por • .. \ `tc.-: 4. it. ..• i 21t. N _. ,0- ). . 1. N44f,:*!, -...A, ft'c. - • a ,•.6 '!• • .— '4*4' % • ' ;,., • •••• . / .4,• ..,..r. A•,- . _ - ' 4.• , .‘t • ' - .:Nle, • gi-21/4 , , A ', .. 1.4,—1I. ACM t ••6 . 4 4 ...440 • 4 .. 'X4 '4 6 .•'P # .. • '. - - . • . . ...._ I...-. ,. _i_. • i •1 w . •,, ‘..., ...-..„, .j _ . . .• . .ne•i, . , 41... ,.,,•• . .: . . „ • • - All , ':- 7f. •; 4„ . .•'• , - i s vr7 <_ _ " Etas " j;,ie �r 1 IAs, 4!?' I.y.. 'ems"". ` '` . , a Y ; , r..tA,s i es I-...•. ,iiilrior , l is r. (yam •'�. ; . -fir 1 '4'!, ./40,10 ''"— ....--._- - /R ♦r y) A ` "K t w. AT . LPALM L • BE COUNTY FLORIDA R ri ' + RA 6!A Yr `' .,, To se e4eCT&p toe.Tot { { +A ' BEACH COUNTY BOARD OF PUBUC INSTRUCTtOH TERM; ). . • ' a : EOZAR 5. WORT MAN At.A. � GUST A NA . „ , . I►SS.a1.A ....-,:� ° MMSM1M at Cm rTKT e new JINI tir is' 4 �. i ' " tow.« + rw C +,.r t M mo r w r.111. Ito. i r , ',A-1w 41,0„,. . y5 '� p,e.r w'r j M� s • .a,: .,. is r - -? ` 44L '' .' 1`' r,,, 4111.R'1A71 Jf ` * r6y ': i '4004- i/ \ , ' yil .l. ..,/�/ "-/S./ / Y...: • /: : / {Gk/r H . / / j r\ W.M \ • C" <, a d� . \ .;a y r h r �� / r` /r / • Za g \ a>�4• @\ . . ) : ZJ : 9w: .S sy k9 G r Y3 !,v ( 3 rti.p : ' A )J ` $ oy o • y��ti. r r.- . !q/�ekpf. � Yx` ' �ta ' Y J �" ! Jis C •� eyry l y.A; r ?.;(fi'.J J ,, . '', \ ,Yt 44•.,,J < ,:,. y •,-�}:; r r w a � . 3; w bf '';.,-W�t. �. .''',• . 4 v :t A ;. A ) } � Xz ,,r..,,: R � 0 } 4rY S•y"7. .2 �f :x , .t t L.R ...6E< H PALM B A 1 ' T TO ' E E 1C1"6.� .0 # .- . C4', At0 :ARC 41TiCt ► , sscr • .. 't . a t�#2:_) 1 .,I ,..., .,. :1 , It . .,.. . .'`-. • tti, 000 r. .. oil . . . . ,. ,sit„..... ,,, ,.., __.....7......„ .,y t r _ -1 _ J . r,• M RR • • t tw , 1 i• i • f s r N . f •oil tai r,•.. g \i. j 1 999��� ' r 1 .1 '..., MO li A ..._. .,.. . .. ... :" - . i N . • :./a� • .r Y. r till - 4 �,i ` [''% �,vj y s. 1..i '` r , a 'Y�'•.''• I .y ♦ ,f_. .. a .e�iw•! �,h['.7\ 1n(a'' • ,; t ` .. •• ,t t r') • :t .:s:;t .. [Ic :F" ? ...-21 t y.:+s ,.- ,,,,44.. . •y YT w., i aU'r J w. Mr0 Co Spencer Pompey and Mom Frank To Hearst _/ �/ r F , riiiI • ;inri... ,. F...-, I--r, ,,,-,- .,1 '.__'.14 :-; -• • lir-i- , ,, ; , , , i r- IlLaillinil.-' .um ' -....: _ .._,.. k_1171111111.-, ITT' .' ! ! F• I , . m_. ` —��---- — Ste+« r--.•_. "* �W 1 e.e.sr ,gXya -;"---,....rr ''- ..•_ - � i"' •rr Ate` .- • :sat ='•;'• .. SOL7. • 4, 1_ 1 _y r '�i� IL �.f,' ,, F..-_t. v of `�' , ),/ ! " -� i `••ram' ��q7�t�- iii A , .. 44 j r.•V -• M" ,�11 1, iv: �MO aT"l by s ►1 • • t1 • 4, r r /i �n�d ti 11.-' • 11111 . . J4i1 • -'' -.00.• • .1'' f a r : •a +: t�i�F`ro,' .. ��l.!i ', .• •Y'!� • � •+�V,.•l�l ..� a r.�'"!11�k` ► Mt A• b -4 i - , i '7S `Uiy •; •:^-fir.. . 'Z�t '.\1 • I s ,s,`e,�.,. w.•.�,�a1� ." 1.t' • ,i1ii('1' �. -"^;er 'Xs��y'i 1 • .►� - „v' I .,,1*- "ems'"' '>!•a— I$ ,r ' i t. ~ Y.;• i 1 l eye r,t 'r• :,V"`A� ..•:�$1—"K',`.e.Lyt,' L'r' —....._ 1 i L .--..-- ,-. Liftiminiew Viii"...."mi••••-.......,,........._ t•-•--. -"!'&.-'!"•...h1111111111-.— :........, 111"101•1_ r L.-- 71—1 -— °1111141.111 II , ..d. -,..... ****,... .......... . • Pill"11111 A -„,/' .......111. 1611M re - . .1,. . es* 1 , , •. , •— p., 1 a„,,,,.., u. ,....... 1 ,, . . 4, s' ". 'Mir f "MI I.,1 t' i '' '' ' '' -4-• . . • , •440 il C - _..... ...___ I,. [ t,k".t.' t ( ,• / / Ihnia Vila limn '',i • . .../ ' ' . _:' \W''' '• ' / ' ' .-,Z..' '..•7.V _.....4 .,' 1---1- '''.- i:*) ''‘:,•--- • -w 1.. . . , c".. . ..._, ..‘4,.. .. i _......_ ... . G .. , , .. „..... r- . . , --,-,, . , '-!-4L ''' ,041- ,.. . ..,...,.... ,.. i • 4, Nor ( , .,.. ... .., % igill Illi ' i ..." . .1 i je * :.,,_....._ f , i - •,'"-- " .., ,r`... , _ ii pirr. _64 e 0,i k (h /\\ '' 1 , 4. i , •••- %• • le t'Ili 10 • " \'ll "a,'// \'', \ ,/, k 7 .,•44 ..., • ' ' ../ ... 'A i ' 1 •, ,, „10----- --------r.,-; I e -:-...--,,wily I,.- - - ' P1:71) \ ‘ (. ,...,,,, .. ,..,•-• - t .,f; f 1" e . , • ,.. , ,,, , ... J r 1 r‘°1 ......, • • '., • ''. .. .......0111 Z)."' ,.. * r.,.,„„ _,, ,, .•*, ,..':::. f.k.,'...,i •-. • ' ,.. . " 1111110i, -'• • -..- -etS.,,7" ..." • .... •,- .t.'n - ',../ - ,..;,-, '-',4- . ' sr.:1-1-,, -. , . ';,;,.. —,_ r;,+:J••= e,' ..:..4...:444;..4 -.._-______r_ .... . --'• -, ''''. '..' II . Ivettn z '.: , ,,,,... -,, , -- , -'Pt-2,••'74.2.i.:4„,w•e„ .1,14 ----,;,, •=A •:.'•--- . .- ' '1 VI z, ,4--, --,*- , ;.1--_.-,.., -' ..,X'.4•1144:; • ''' '''. ‘ 'Nif Xrik • - P`•.',-.1" s ' 4i ',.' .--.0...., . ' .., ' .,A'-^ "4 . ,4--,•••41,,,- ..i 4,4t.t,-NC• .LAIt./.:- .. • r ...,,,r%.•tkitt.$14...., i--.....s‘,.....' ?.1,,e,„„ , 4.• ''' ' ' '' ' ' 4:-.. )ti... • "z1 -i"zit,10,:- "...*: ' - • , . . _____— . . .. . . • • 1 , ; 1 j 1 J i .i . . i [ . I L — • I 7. ....• --!.' 7 1. _ I • . 4 !re---.-. ___ . . 1 I. . ___..... __.SE11.1•E11, i .. • . I I I • { , I • l• ;I ,kl...! G.,11.6i ittL, 81, •41, ..1.al.11.,ru.,,,,A,.. 1 i 'A t---• I '' 1 I .1 i 1 A-.1 P.....L‘. ....,...... t.t . .0 4 i ., . .. ,"'''. ..,....”,.. --•• .,,—,--... ,.---..... ,',,,,,,• .f.,, ..... ,,,..-- .. __ .. -- --- •• - • • 1,C40. • 1 ' . . - • . , ,.. • .. •• , , . •, ..,,, 1..,,,_'__, ,.:/' i1 ...•::: ,Pa v..1...:. ,, " • .,.. .• 1 I I I • I .' 1. ,/, I : • • .' , •,,' •,•• ! ,,, , .'y.... ..........r.i. ,.:,,. .'47.,,ik Al , 1 .., . • ...vv.,. ,,.5:r....-'—-.:41r. .*: • •'" , '4 k\:\\ 1,,,,"...;,.'.,,, 4- '-: • ILPI.zi.. ' 'N. 7, .';i.rs . 7'2- i . 1 el.41•Ef. ) :.'''s oR.. .; ,A..— , \,,`O.',.,'';',:,,),.... ;,,,,,. l_L__i !••!.•1.1•4.1J,;;L___._ __ . . ,• 1 C f •-1:.z...72--V,.. ". ,:_•.*....,..1.:_...L . , . ,4.4 • • IT .,, , I 1 , , • „ •• •'' -. '', . .7., 1 1 1-. l''' 1' ' 1% 1 ... •• 'i.:" ..11r11- --t•-7^k-'"---1‘ ,I' ,I 1 .1 ' off ,', i, I I` ' 'i \s\ *--- '\ s• ..,1 / , . ‘..., ..... 7\, - .,1'•A,1.1 . , 11.„.,t:, 1 1: / 1..., c " .s.... _I) , ti' (eve', -....:_ .___.__ „ • • , • .." 1.--.-1 .,.. t t I.1 :, .1: ,st',<,_.--.1".....: • :... •— ----' ''. i =;-•-r----:---:- t.,._ 1• . ,. • .• , ;{,, : • , -,__i_. .-,---• .7---t---------- rJ I i . ...' , * ,...• ,o,, 1 .„{ 1 , , Dr..5.C,1.-1P1101,1: ,,,,i ••. • l'e,4s-s6.1••• AG .0..co W.,'6. 4 b E.A.T•4 -r.*F . I 1 1 1 !i ' •• ' i i''''.' • I e../..5., ,V -,4 n,YI%WI 1. •,1.)/....,1.1, . I I I. i:511,01•,>i II..}1..5'.•.',.2.....,_v. •-r- ...S1-.<'1.1, O. ] ' . , ,st..v.,sIn.. 43 DI.,••• 1 * i.1 . . • . ' ;•'\,, ' ,s 14.',,R.,-' E-E-Ef•-sk i •••,.-.....-••• ,• ,A1 I .6' .A., ,,,As •.1, ...• •la i II ..".F...,Y.,,,••.1-4 r..•4 I, c,....,..,..u,4 .2.46.E.., ' • 2...0•••Aws 1 I ' ‘I:L 0',. i'...t.K, ACAT,MO MAI' • I • . • ..,0. .t.:,.17., '.. . n Xti% •:•,:.31.•Ers... •• -- 1,6 sA . • • t • - .. - 3,,,,', 1,,..,,JPALM BEACH COUNTY BOARD OF , PUBLIC INSTRUCTION . . - PIAT [..,, , • bighli EDGAR 5 WORTMAN A.I,— .-.-•. n..6, ".•-,-.. !IIII0111 GUSTAV A.14AATSA71.A ossAmost.A1.1111r I I • - . 7 - ` | | ---- / � | '7f 74W If ET - � | - f � -- ----__ ------------. - - - I I •,j,..r......'7......Z.. i I • • . ,1.14••A.... • r .-6'• . 7. .,•,.'IA I•.rs•(..i,_,.tO 4.'...to,f..' 1_,,-,1 3,.-•I„ *.t....4)• =..• 1 flii---..••(4.-) • ' • .a ,. 4 I ... ,. I__ .... ,., ; •;,;'' •.•.;•••• • 1 r M.•.7.0%1r -,•-C•i'VP•Vi.^T 7'-? - ••••••.' - ;• •• -I•-• •4 1 :4\▪-▪-.7..7..z.:-... • f - • F.11...,,,L.,t................ti• _ ,fr,....!.„... ; ; ..4 +. ‘ -. .!:.. •, ,t,' •-;i- , -,44 i , • , 1 I ,1 F . • • 1 :1 1 i"hat` I —.--I t M ',•' i ,. f f ' . •. i'i. •' :. .., .! ,r •. .' li .• ij '• •'. ---1 I:, . . , : ', ' LI/ .._ ' . .."I i I. • ,.... t-n,-, i‘r.I !. • . ••1. '; , • .. ' r ", ::.1.0 U PJ D_A,Z1j...).y...,, PLA4 WIta 1.) - •-., fm.r tr i"....C •........ .......,... ...4•,.-- , , . . . .i .. . . : • ': '"l'' a ; ' ' , 6-., • 4.-. .!: ... ••••li .....1;•-•.. . _ _ Atm... • • I • .• . . . 1.-.. ' .4, ••-•.• • if.,,, -'....- • 'f ' I . :,:-•-•+.-.; . ,. ...0 ,r.' Ell [En i i••.:4: it •- , -• ‘'..•• „ . ..., flit: •• 1 L..t. • 1 • ,. ..,,....-:;::: ::•7 .4.7:7- .7,........7.- '!."-• ".-,... , - •., • - -..,r LI,7,..-ka.k.ilig• WA, ---1 s r 41,.,.,' ... °. ,r- ' . ' ".' •. i .:01.1.1.4•:. lll 1"1•••I,../.. -. .•.,,11.1d.1.I.....) • t' - :"C: l's i)... 1,6.....— —i.1.4'_6 ,• - . 4.' .. . I . •.• . * I_I ..•• t . '• ,11. . • ='-'4••!------s= :_i t I, • I .•K 4 6. i' b \•. 6:21-..*••-•, • ',1 . .,,,.1_0 . 4 6.1., ..1,....'• 3 . IC. •._____.___ , ' :.ILE,_...'... 4! 4 [..... .I.H...i..if.,.. ..,, .. . . _,A.L_I'L 1,1 .i:r:, ',..J t .... - :•.,L •1•_._*-,-- 3 I' "6. i L •-•-.------ -.I .••••••;,.4.,Akt, I VI'1 ! '• 1.5 /1 I • ._ P 7--,-;., I)t.i•..., ,-:_- . ., 4 •' • , . , . ! r t • .• .:, 1.. t I t ....•a . !, • ..1" ,-1,--.....,,:.,--...J.m...--...,..-....16........--,.....—. ,„;.. L -.- 1 ; ' •• '".11 .. ' ^ • • t... ••,' .'•• • 1r... ' 1 , I . , r.• I - ..t9 t • '.."-LTJ, '' tr. :•- l_t if..:•f__.A.:.; • ,fr..t...' f. . r• 41:••••.11 . ' A-..-•61 -,-!....". •' \I;lk)(r C•i T.11.,..-. - Lk 17. -1 j;, / :.......,....{........- , - -•,„„;;, I- • . ' . 7-----; i ....,..•••,....1..... j, li -16-r:......-11-!..,.....-A....— r••••,...er!...1.-,- I .,-f.•‘.11".. . )I,T_ , ' PAi,..M SEACM COUNTY WARD OF 1 IA43-. 11- , --.... PUBLIC INeTRUCTION .._, . 4 MAN•ilt*A*10,•.A 1... •••••t_ I r .,..-r , .„.,____ ,, ..o,rar,, wa.s.r • tZL, 3b,--..._......, _...... ....—. - Sources Spady Cultural and Historical Museum archives. -Dade County School board minutes from 1902-1918 - Archival photographs Delray Beach Historical Society Archives Carver Eagle yearbooks from 1957, 1960, 65 Palm Beach County School District building, department records City of Delray Beach archives Palm Beach County Historical Society Interview with Delray Beach City Commissioner Shirley Johnson, Carver High Class of '64 Interview with Paula Rocker, Carver High Class of '66 OFFICERS 2017-20I8 x,�o�c. °oP Chairman of the Beard HqISTORICAL SOCIETY J.Grier Pressly III a P sn - �, First lire Chairman 9f PALM BEACH COUNTY Thomas M.Kirchhoff,AJA 4aaecN° Sand lire Chairman Mark Stevens Third Orr Chairman Ross W.W.Melri_er Secretary Richard S.Johnson Jr. Deputy Secretary Carey O'Donnell April 12, 2018 Treasurer David J.Thomas III,CPA Central Counsel Mariano Garcia Dr. Debra L. Robinson Member at Law Jeffrey P.Phipps Sr. Vice Chair Member Entering School Board of Palm Beach County Robert W.Ganger 3326 Forest Hill Blvd PAST CHAIRMAN West Palm Beach, FL 33406-5869 Mark B.Elhilow BOARD OF GOVERNORS Re: Carver School Jeffrey Alderton James Beasley Jr. Margaret Cheryl Burkhardt Dear Dr. Robinson, Ann Margo Cannon Joseph Chase Kevin Clark On behalf of the Board of Governors of the Historical Society of Palm Beach County, I Graham G.Davidson George Ford 111 want to express our endorsement of the restoration of the building known most Mary Fre a5 i recently as Carver High School and its inclusion on the historic register.We believe the TheHKeeorableBradleyG.Harper Joproperty meets all the requirements, not least of all in its architect,Gustav Maass, Russell P.Kelley III George Mavlios who also designed the American Red Cross building in West Palm Beach,the original Sharon Merchant Rehabilitation Center in Palm Beach, and many landmarked homes. Penny Murphy Peter Nicoletti Lisa McDermott Perez As collectors and protectors of our county's history,we are well acquainted with the Karen Swanson Kimberly Walkes change that has taken place on this site—from Colored School No.4 to Delray County BOARD OF ADVISORS Training School to George Washington Carver High School—each a more positive step Cressman D.Bronson toward a quality education for African Americans.The building is alignedmultiple with lti le Katharine Dickenson GeorgeT.Elmore great African Americans, including Carver,whose student Solomon Spady became its Mr.and Mrs.William M.B.Fleming Jr. Dennis Grady principal; Dr. Booker T.Washington, who helped resurrect Colored School No.4 as William Graham DelrayDck CountyTrainingSchool;and C.Spencer Pompey, who also served as principal. PaISe R.Heoins pp p Pat Seaton Johnson Gary S.Lesser The Historical Societyalso knows well the struggle and resultingsatisfaction of savingThe Honorable Karen Marcus gg William A.Meyer a building. Our own home,the 1916 Palm Beach County Court House,was rescued Harvey E.Oyer Ill Jorge Pesquera from razing in 2002. For 10 years, it has allowed us to educate hundreds of thousands Sidney Stubbs Jr. of school children and other visitors about our history.The saving of Carver High RADM Philip A.Whitacre(Ret.) School would not be a sentimental gesture, but an opportunity to extend the story of MEMBERSIO BOARD the site in a meaningful way. Erica Whitfield School Board f Palm Beath County Danielle Hickox Moore Sincerely, Tow;of Palm Beath Council Mack Bernard Board of Palm Beach County Commissioners Jeremy .Johnson,CAE PRESIDENT AND CEO President and Chief Executive Officer Jeremy W.Johnson,CAE The I9I6 Court House 300 North Dixie Highway Downtown West Palm Beach onady Ada , Post Office Box 4364 West Palm Beach,FL 33402 BENEFACTORS 56I.832.4I64 I hspbc.org Thomas Anderson Martha DeBrule Melanie&Chris Hill Patricia&Howard M.Lester Sonja&Mark Stevens RICHARD AND PAT &Marc Schappell Mark B.Elhilow Mary Hulitar Betsy Matthews Annette Stubbs JOHNSON Brenda McCampbell Bailey George T.Elmore Pat Seaton Johnson Sydelle Meyer RADM Philip A.Whitacre USN(Ret.) { J'I'11 PALM BEACH COUNTY Margaret Cheryl Burkhardt Frances&Jeffrey H.Fisher Russell P.Kelley Ill Pauline Pitt William Sterling WilliamsHISTORY Julie&Michael M.Connors Anncli&Robert W.Ganger Carol&Thomas M.Kirchhoff J.Grier Pressly 111 Robert Wright MUSEUM Susan&Christopher Cowie Lorrain&Malcolm W.Hall Patricia Lambrechr Frances G.Smile II Board Officers G� S r0,0 Board of Governors President— Howard Ellingsworth �9 Bill Bathurst Vice President— Michelle Donahue Leslie Callaway Vice President— Laura Simon Roger• (.1, Roger Cope Treasurer— David Cook Q ���� Michael Cruz Executive Director I DBHs Sylvia Gwynn Winnie Diggans Edwards G —{ John Miller 061�- -� Alice Pearce Archivist Hilary Roche Kate Teves \ r Matt Shipley Steve Miskew Roy Simon A non-profit 501(c)3 organization 3 NE 1" Street, Delray Beach, FL 33444 561.274.9578 • www.delraybeachhistory.org "A knowledge()four history is an absolute necessity if we are to be sensitive and constructive artisans of our futu re. " May 10, 2018 Ladies and Gentlemen, Please accept this letter as support of the Carver High School Historic Preservation Society's efforts to preserve and adapt the campus for a contemporary use. We support the team's efforts and vision to utilize the structures for a vocational and technical skills center for the enrichment and betterment of the surrounding community and the broader Palm Beach County School District. Carver High School is an institution in Delray Beach with roots extending back to the 19th Century, when African-American pioneers in a town called Linton successfully got the then-Dade County School Board to build their children a school. The structures that make up Carver High School are historically significant for the following compelling reasons: 1) The school building is more than 50 years old, the benchmark. 2) Carver is associated with a well-known educator who changed the face of Delray Beach forever— Solomon D. Spady. Mr. Spady was sent to Delray Beach in the 1920s by George Washington Carver and Booker T. Washington to run the school. Later, C. Spencer Pompey served as principal. Both men were not only prominent in the African American community, but across all ethnic and socioeconomic groups in Palm Beach County. 3) The school was designed by Gustav Maass, a well-known American architect working primarily in the Mediterranean Revival style who designed public buildings and private homes in and around Palm Beach County from the 1920s until his death in 1964. He designed the Seaboard Air Line Train Station just west of Interstate 95 in Delray Beach in 1927, which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. 4) Carver High was not only an important educational institution but a significant and important gathering place for the African American community in the dark days of segregation. A whole generation of residents attended graduations, town hall meetings and other events at the school. We ask you to support us in preserving this meaningful, treasured and historic location and to pursue the historic designation. Collectively, we all have a responsibility to keep our historic structures and stories alive for generations to come. This is an opportunity we should all embrace. woultZo• tie 0 1.40,40e...4........ Winnie Edwards Executive Director BNARD CoUN F L Q R 1 00 100 S.Andrews Avenue,6tn Floor•Fort Lauderdale. Florida 33301 • 954-357-7457• FAX 954-357-5769 July 19, 2018 Timothy A. Parsons, PHD RPA Division Director, and State Historic Preservation Officer R.A. Gray Building 500 S. Bronough Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-02-50 Re: Carver High School Buildings#1 &# 12 Delray Beach, Florida Dear Mr. Parsons: As Chair of the Broward County Historic Preservation Board(Board), you may think it unorthodox that I write to you regarding two structures in Palm Beach County, however, it is my opinion that this is an important matter extremely relevant to our core mission. The structures about which I am writing to you are in jeopardy of being demolished by the Palm Beach County School Board. This fact has come to our attention via Paula Newman-Rocker, Co-Founder of the Carver High School Historical Preservation Society who through her organization is an advocate for their architectural and cultural significance. Ms. Rocker made a presentation to our Board on the significance of the two structures and appealed to us for support. After researching the facilities and learning that they are registered on the Florida Master Site File, our Board determined that advocacy on the part of our Board was a prudent step. Therefore,they have authorized me to write this letter of support to your good offices. Often in our State, School Boards take the position that they do not operate under the authority of a county or a municipal entity because they are governed programmatically by the State of Florida. In extending this thinking to whether they fall under the requirements of local or county Certified Local Governments or historic preservation ordinances they do not feel the need to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness relating to the demolition,renovation or addition to historic structures. It is the opinion of our Board that this sets a dangerous precedent. In this particular case it could lead to the loss of two significant structures in our State. Broward County Board of County Commissioners Mark D.Bogen•Beam Furr-Steve Geller-Dale V.C.Hotness•Chip LaMarca•Nan Rich-Tim Ryan•Barbara Shane•Michael Udine www.broward.org It is our hope that by apprising you of this situation that you will review the documentation and additionally become an advocate for saving these structures. In order to assist you with your own evaluation I have enclosed supporting information on Carver High School Buildings#1 &#12 for your review. To my knowledge the most informed person on the history, condition and potential for demolition is Ms. Rocker. Her email is cmic486747 uaol.com. I am sure she would welcome your inquiry and will answer any questions you have. Our letter is simply to inform you and advise you that the members of the Historic Preservation Board in Broward support the preservation of these structures. Please feel free to contact our offices at 954-357-9731 as well. Respectfully, • William J. Gallo,AIA LEED AP Chair, Broward County Historic Preservation Board cc: Ruben Acosta, DHR, Survey and Registration Supervisor Jason Aldridge, DHR, Supervisor of State and Federal Compliance and Review Rick A. Ferrer, Broward County,County Historic Preservation Officer Paula Newman-Rocker,Carver High School Historical Preservation Society I Page 2 of 2 April 10, 2018 Ms. Paula Newman-Rocker Co-Founder Carver High School Preservation Society 236 NW Eighth Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33455 Dear Ms. Rocker: As one of the founders of Old School Square and a former member of the Governor-Appointed Florida Historic Board, I wholeheartedly support your efforts to save the former Carver High School buildings. They are important pieces of Delray Beach history. Having lived in this area for many years, I have known many graduates of Carver, and know that they played a significant role in the history of Delray Beach. But its birth was even more amazing. Booker T. Washington and George Washington Carver sent Solomon D. Spady to Delray to start this school. An impressive piece of history lays between its walls. And you need those walls to remain—not just have a plaque saying it. In my opinion, school buildings #1 and #12 (on the present Village Academy campus) meet four of the requirements for designation as a local historic landmark: Age: The 1958 school building is more than 50 years old, the benchmark. Associated with a famous person or event: Solomon D. Spady was sent to Delray Beach in the 1920s by George Washington Carver and Booker T. Washington to run the school. Later, C. Spencer Pompey served as teacher and coach. Both men were not only prominent in the African American community, but movers and shakers across Palm Beach County. Architectural: It was designed by Gustav Maass, a well-known mid-century architect who also designed the Seaboard Air Line train station just west of Interstate 95 in Delray Beach. That building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Cultural: Carver High was an important, and one of the few public gathering places for the African American community. A generation of residents attended graduations, town hall meetings and other events at the school. I believe that the preservation of these two original buildings of Carver High School would serve as inspiration for generations of residents of the Southwest Neighborhood as well as showcasing the school board's commitment to stand up for the history of our schools. Sincerely, Frances Bourque Deiray Beach Historic Preservation Trust Dear Dr. Robinson: The board of the Delray Beach Preservation Trust wholeheartedly supports the grass-roots effort to preserve and restore the original Carver High School building and strongly urges the Palm Beach County School Board to agree to list the building on the local historic register. Carver's roots extend back to the 19th Century, when African-American pioneers asked the then-Dade County School Board to build a school for their children. The parents succeeded and "Colored School # 4" was born. When it was built in 1959, Carver High School served African American students from Deerfield Beach to Lake Worth and west to the farm lands. It not only educated students, it nurtured them during the dark days of segregation. We firmly believe that the building is eligible for listing for four criteria: Historic: The school building is more than 50 years old, the benchmark. Associated with a famous person or event: Solomon D. Spady was sent to Delray Beach in the 1920s by George Washington Carver and Booker T. Washington to run the school. Later, C. Spencer Pompey served as teacher and coach. Both men were not only prominent in the African American community, but movers and shakers across Palm Beach County. Architectural: It was designed by Gustav Maass, a well-known mid-century architect who also designed the Seaboard Air Line train station just west of Interstate 95 in Delray Beach. That building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Cultural: Carver High was an important, and one of the few public, gathering places for the African American community. A generation of residents attended graduations, town hall meetings and other events at the school. For the past decade, the Preservation Trust has supported and initiated preservation and restoration projects across the city. We were instrumental in restoring the Willie Franklin home on NW 4th Avenue. We spearheaded the nomination of the Old School Square Historic District to the National Register of Historic Places, an honor which was approved in Washington DC just last month. We are working with city officials to get the historic Frog Alley designated locally. We support this historic designation because it is important to show not only how far Delray Beach has come, but where it began. All that remains of "Colored School # 4" is a plaque. Help us retain a more tangible remembrance of the past. Sincerely, JoAnn Peart President Delray Beach Historic Preservation Trust Janet M. Naughton 806 Windward Way, PHO8 Lantana, FL 33462 May 16, 2018 Dr. Debra L. Robinson Vice Chair School Board of Palm Beach County 3326 Forest Hill Blvd. West Palm Beach, FL 33406 Re: Carver School Dear Dr. Robinson, As a Palm Beach County resident and historian, I am writing in support of saving and restoring the Carver High School building. The building is significant to Palm Beach County history, for its role in the community and in education. The site held Delray's first school for colored students, and the Delray County Training School, a facility funded with monies from the Julius Rosenwald Foundation. Mr. Rosenwald, president of Sears, Roebuck Corporation, was invited by Booker T. Washington to serve on the Tuskegee Institute board of directors. Washington urged Rosenwald to contribute to build and improve schoolhouses for rural black students. Consequently, between 1925 and 1932, Rosenwald contributed funds to 11 Palm Beach County schools, including the Delray County Training School. For that reason alone, the site deserves national historic recognition. The surviving building, last known as Carver High School, designed by prominent Palm Beach Beach architect, Gustav Maass, who fabricated the landmarked Palm Beach Public School, American Red Cross and myriad other noted buildings, served as a place of education, community, and pride for generations of African American youngsters and their families. This symbol of hope and change should be saved and placed in the National Register. I urge you to give the Carver school revitalization your full support. Kindest regards, '/ .\ /08, anet M. DeVries Naughton