HPB 03-02-1990 AGENDA
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
SPECIAL MEETING
FRIDAY, MARCH 2 , 1990, 9: 00 A.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL
1 . Roll Call
2 . Introduction of Vickie Johnson, Neighborhood Planner for
Pineapple Grove.
3 . COA 8-097 Victor Nocera, 122 S.E. 1st Avenue. Install 8 new
solid core wooden doors on south side of building.
4 . COA 8-099 Danielle Baudouin, 1023 Nassau Street. Reroof with
same material as existing roof.
5 . COA 8-062 Continuation. Hank Allen, 332 S.E. 7th Avenue.
Reroof .
6 . Anita Shannon, interpretation of proposed use change for house
and cottage, 201 N.E. 1st Avenue.
7 . Acceptance of designation report for 19 Andrews Avenue
for Local Register of Historic Buildings.
8 . Discussion of Design Guidelines contract.
9 . Discussion of Old School Square Historic Arts District.
10 . Approval of Minutes : October 20 , 1989
November 17 , 1989
December 4 , 1989
December 8 , 1989
December 15 , 1990
11. Unfinished Business
12 . New Business
13 . Adjournment
WM
DATE: FEBRUARY 28 , 1990
TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
FROM: PAT CAYCE
SUBJECT: AGENDA AND COMMENTS FOR MARCH 2, 1990 SPECIAL MEETING,
9 : 00 A.M.
1. Roll Call
2. Introduction of Vickie Johnson, Neighborhood Planner for
Pineapple Grove.
3 . COA 8-097 Victor Nocera, 122 S.E. 1st Avenue. Install 8
new solid core wooden doors on south side of building.
I have on file the completed COA, the filing fee and a
notarized agent authorization form.
These doors were installed and painted without approval of
the HPB and without a building permit. However, compared
with the broken glass jalousie doors formerly in place,
they certainly present an improvement to the overall
appearance of the building.
4 . COA 8-099 Danielle Baudouin, 1023 Nassau Street. Reroof
with same material as existing roof.
The applicant requests approval to reroof in the same style
shingle, material to be fiberglass instead of existing
asphalt. Color to be the the same as the existing roof .
5 . COA 8-062-Continuation Hank Allen, 332 S.E. 7th Avenue.
Reroof .
The applicant' s existing roof is white cement tile. He
proposes to remove the tile and reroof with asphalt or
fiberglass. He describes the roof as "leaking badly" and
cites the additional cost of reroofing with tile as his
reason for proposing the change of material. The house has
an interesting three gable configuration on the front
elevation which gives prominence to the roof as an
architectural feature of the building.
•
Wig
I explained to him that the HPB did not usually grant
approval for this kind of material change, and suggested
that he get estimates for the waterproof sealer system. He
did not seem to be receptive to this avenue of approach.
Shortly after I spoke with him, I received a building permit
application from Paul E. Hahn, roofing contractor, for the
reroof of 721 N. Swinton which came before the Board some
time ago. The HPB did not approve the material change from
tile to asphalt and suggested the applicant consider the
sealer method. I contacted the roofing contractor and the
sealer will be used at 721 N. Swinton. I mention the above
to remind the Board what action was taken on a similar COA
and what the outcome was.
6. Anita Shannon, interpretation of proposed use change for
house and cottage, 201 N.E. 1st Avenue.
Ms. Shannon is a skin care professional. She proposes to
buy the Mackel house and cottage, located at the corner of
N.E. 1st Avenue and N.E. 2nd Street. The property is
currently in the RO zoning district which does not permit
this type of use.
David Kovacs suggested that Ms. Shannon come before the HPB
to discuss this and get your opinion as to whether this
would be a business that would be appropriate in the HAD
district.
7. Acceptance of designation report for 19 Andrews Avenue for
Local Register of Historic Buildings.
Pat Healy is nominating her house for inclusion in Local
Register. The designation report is enclosed. If the
report is accepted, the public hearing will be held at our
regular meeting, Friday March 16, 1990. .
8. Discussion of the Design Guidelines contract.
The contract is enclosed. Stan Weedon will update you
on the progress.
9. Discussion of Old School Square Historic Arts District.
Stan Weedon will present this item.
10 . Approval of minutes.
11. Unfinished Business.
a. Financial report, This Old Town Preservation
Conference.
Expenses $3 ,357 . 27
Income 3 , 520. 27
Loss to Reserve Fund $ 27 . 00
b. Community Block Grant Fund Application
When Lula Butler spoke to the HPB on November 17, 1990
she stated that this is the time of year for her
department to apply for this grant.
With consensus approval of the HPB, I will send a memo
to Lula requesting that her application for C.B.G.
funds include "funding for rehabilitation of homes in
local historic districts, when the recipient qualifies
for such assistance" .
12 . New Business
a. Consider what action to take on the enclosed
letters from Old School Property Owners
Association.
13 . Adjournment
..11.110
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
SPECIAL MEETING
FRIDAY, MARCH 2, 1990, 9: 00 A.M.
COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL
1. Roll Call:
Chairman Patricia Healy : Present
Diane DeMarco : Present
Alice Finst : Present
David Martin : Absent
David Nathanson : Present
Rose Sloan : Present
Spencer Pompey : Present
Staff Present:
Pat Cayce, Historic Preservation Planner
Stan Weedon, Assistant Planning Director
2. Introduction of Vickie Johnson, Neighborhood Planner for
Pineapple Grove.
Pat Cayce introduced Ms. Johnson, who informed the Board
that she would be preparing the neighborhood plan for
Pineapple Grove. The first work product is a detailed
land use inventory.
3 . COA 8-097 Victor Nocera, 122 S.E. 1st Avenue. Install 8 new
solid core wooden doors on south side of building.
MOTION: To approve as submitted.
Made: David Nathanson
Seconded: Spencer Pompey
VOTE:
Healy : Y Finst : Y
Nathanson : Y Sloan : Y
DeMarco : Y Pompey : Y
MOTION: APPROVED
4. COA 8-099 Danielle Baudouin, 1023 Nassau Street. Reroof with
same material as existing roof.
MOTION:
Made: Alice Finst
Seconded: Spencer Pompey
VOTE:
Healy : Y Finst : Y
Nathanson : Y Sloan : Y
DeMarco : Y Pompey : Y
MOTION: APPROVED
5 . COA 8-062 Continuation. Hank Allen, 332 S.E. 7th Avenue.
Reroof.
MOTION: To approve as submitted; the material is to be cement
tile.
Made: Alice Finst
Seconded: David Nathanson
VOTE:
Healy Y Finst : Y
Nathanson : Y Sloan : Y
DeMarco : Y Pompey : Y
MOTION: APPROVED
6 . Anita Shannon, interpretation of proposed use change for house
and cottage, 201 N.E. 1st Avenue.
MOTION: To recommend to the Planning and Zoning Board that the
use be determined to be a similar use as those which are
allowed as professional offices.
Made: David Nathanson
Seconded: Rose Sloan
VOTE:
Healy : Y Finst : Y
Nathanson : Y Sloan : Y
DeMarco : Y Pompey : Y
MOTION: APPROVED
COMMENTS: The applicant expressed that the proposed business
was skin care, nails and hair removal and that the business
would eventually be in the cottage adjacent to the car wash.
Norm Radin spoke in favor of the use as a cottage
industry/business which is the type of business which the
Pineapple Grove Association is trying to attract to their
neighborhood. Mr. Clemmer Mayhew also spoke in favor of the
use.
Upon questioning by Mr. Weedon, the applicant indicated she
would be the only employee and that her business was one which
is professionally licensed by the State. The applicant was
advised that if the Planning and Zoning Board interprets the
use as a similarity of use she must still appear before the
Historic Preservation Board for a Certificate of
Appropriateness.
7. Acceptance of designation report for 19 Andrews Avenue
for Local Register of Historic Buildings.
MOTION: To accept the nomination report and set a public
hearing for March 16, 1990.
Made: Alice Finst
Seconded: Rose Sloan
VOTE:
Healy : Y Finst : Y
Nathanson : Y Sloan : Y
DeMarco : Y Pompey : Y
MOTION: APPROVED
COMMENTS: Chairman Healy stepped down for this item.
8 . Discussion of Design Guidelines contract.
Mr. Weedon informed the Board of the progress and status of
this item.
9 . Discussion of Old School Square Historic Arts District.
Mr. Weedon presented a detailed analysis of the uses vs.
existing zoning as they relate to the proposed zoning of the
proposed District, and led a discussion on the proposed uses
within the OSSHAD. The Board upon discussion and consideration
rm 41
determined by consensus that duplexes should be eliminated from
the list of allowable uses in the Old School Square Historic
District. Ms. Sloan, having left during discussion, was not
present for this vote.
Mary Lou Strollo from Old School Square spoke in favor of the
proposed ordinance.
The Board elected to postpone further discussion to their
meeting of March 16th.
10. Approval of Minutes: October 20, 1989
November 17 , 1989
December 4, 1989
December 8, 1989
December 15, 1990
The Board approved all of the minutes as presented except for
the minutes of December 8, 1990 which were approved with an
amendment that item 1(c) specify Clemmer Mayhew.
11. Unfinished Business
No Discussion
12 . New Business
No Discussion
13 . Adjournment
The Board adjourned by consensus.
PUBLIC NOTICE
The Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board has been invited to
Patricia Healy-s home for coffee and rolls:
Friday, March 2, 1990
8:00 A.M.
19 Andrews Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida 33483
•