HPB 04-01-1992 AGENDA
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 1, 1992 6:00 PM
FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL
Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any
decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to
any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons
will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose
such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and
evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does
not provide or prepare such record. Pursuant to F.S.286 . 0105.
1 . Roll Call
2 . COA 8-166D Renaissance Dental Studio, 503 N.E. 2nd
Avenue - Jay Kunze, Owner
Construction of a Planter Box on the West
Facade
3. COA 8-170A Boyd Building, 810 E. Atlantic Avenue - Jack
DeNiro, Owner
Color Change for Awnings on the Front and
Rear
4 . COA 8-177 310 S.E. 7th Avenue - John Frysinger, Owner
w
New Construction for a Single Family
Residence
5 . Finalize Plans for HPB Exhibit at the Delray Affair, April
24th, 25th and 26th
6 . Approval of the Minutes of the March 18, 1992 Meeting
7 . Reports From Historic Districts
8 . Unfinished Business
9 . New Business
10 . Adjournment
MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
PUBLIC HEARING
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 1, 1992
LOCATION: FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM
100 N.W. 1ST AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL 33444
1 . ROLL CALL:
The Chairman called the meeting to order at 6 : 00 P.M.
Board Members :
Christine Bull Present
Wayne Campbell (Vice Chairman) Present
Daniel Carter Present
Sandy Jamison Present
Pat Healy-Golembe Present
Buck Miller Present
Rose Sloan (Chairman) Present
Staff Members Present:
Diane Dominguez, Planing & Zoning Department
Jeff Costello, Planning & Zoning Department
Pat Cayce, Planning & Zoning Department
Diana Mund, Planning & Zoning Department
Rose Sloan moved to amend the Agenda to hear Item #4 (COA 8-177)
before Item #2 (COA 8-166D) and Item #3 (COA 8170A) as these
applicants were not yet present.
4 . COA 8-177 : 310 S.E. 7th Avenue. John Frysinger, Owner.
The Board approved COA 8-177 for new construction of a
two story single family residence and guest cottage with
the condition that all Building Department development
standards are in compliance.
Pat Healy-Golembe moved for approval of COA 8-177, seconded
by Wayne Campbell. The vote was as follows : Christine
Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes;
Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Miller -
Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Said motion passed 7-0 .
At this time the Board returned to Item #2 (COA 8-166D) and Item
#3 (COA 8-170A) as the applicants were now present.
2 . COA 8-166D: Renaissance Dental Studio, 503 N.E. 2nd
Avenue. Jay Kunze, Owner.
The Board approved COA 8-166D for a planter box on the west
facade of the building with the condition the planter box's
exterior is finished with stucco and painted to match the
building.
Wayne Campbell moved for approval of COA 8-166D, seconded
by Pat Healy-Golembe. The vote was as follows : Christine
Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes;
Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Miller -
Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes. Said motion passed 7-0.
3 . COA 8-170A: Boyd Building, 810 E. Atlantic Avenue. Jack
DeNiro, Owner.
The Board approved COA 8-170A for change of color and
material from aqua vinyl to dark green canvas for all five
store front awnings . Dan Carter recommended that Brandy's
Atlantic Avenue entrance canopy (approved aqua vinyl) be
changed to match the dark green awnings . The applicant is
of the opinion that Brandy's owner, Ron Branscome, will
agree to the change.
Wayne Campbell moved for approval of COA 8-170A, seconded
by Sandy Jamison. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull
- Yes; Wayne Campbell Yes; Daniel Carter - No; Sandy
Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - No; Buck Miller - No;
Rose Sloan - Yes . Said motion passed 4-3.
5 . DELRAY AFFAIR: Finalize Plans for HPB Exhibit
It was felt that the site of the HPB booth was undesirable
and the expense too great ($150 entrance fee and $100 tent
rental) to justify official participation at the Delray
Affair. If possible a table will be set up inside Old
School Square to accommodate a small display and
informational material. It was suggested the Board pass
out brochures and buttons and set up directional signs in
the Historic Districts so Historic Tours could be taken by
the public. The feasibility of this depends upon cost and
other factors .
- 2 - 4/1/92
6 . APPROVAL OF MINUTES: March 18, 1992 Meeting
Wayne Campbell moved for approval of the minutes for the
March 18, 1992 meeting, seconded by Christine Bull . The
vote was as follows: Christine Bull - Yes; Wayne Campbell
- Yes; Daniel Miller - Yes; Sandy Jamison - Yes; Pat
Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Carter - Yes; Rose Sloan - Yes .
Said motion passed 7-0 .
7 . REPORTS FROM HISTORIC DISTRICTS:
None
8 . UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
The Board was informed that Dean Hoffman was appealing to
the City Commission the Board's decision on his fence
(COA-175) . Upon further discussion the Board decided they
would provide the Commission with justification (i.e.
photos of the fence, etc. ) for their decision.
The Board was informed that Palm Square-Marine Way
Homeowners Association was appealing to the City Commission
the Board' s decision on the Patio Shoppes (Variance No
88-25) . The basis for the appeal being the Board's refusal
to recognize them to give any input during the discussion
of the site plan. The Board felt this was not correct and
asked that a verbatim of the opening statement be done.
9 . NEW BUSINESS:
The Board was informed that the meeting for the National
Trust Meeting on October 6, 1992 in Miami will be next week
in Miami. Pat Cayce stated that she would find out the day
and time and call the Board members with the information.
10 . Wayne Campbell moved for adjournment at 7 :40 P.M. , seconded
by Sandy Jamison. The vote was as follows : Christine Bull
- Yes; Wayne Campbell - Yes; Daniel Carter - Yes; Sandy
Jamison - Yes; Pat Healy-Golembe - Yes; Buck Miller - Yes;
Rose Sloan - Yes . Said motion passed 7-0.
Next meeting is scheduled for April 15, 1992
- 3 - 4/1/92
The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation
Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the
meeting of said body for April 1, 1992, which were formally
ado ted and ap roved b the Board on April 15, 1992 .
/) i
Diana Mund
If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as
indicated above, then this means that these are not the Official
Minutes . They will become so after review and approval, which
may involve some changes.
- 4 - 4/1/92
Verbatim from Historic Preservation Board Meeting of March 18,
1992 re: Opening/Closing of Palm Square.
Wayne Campbell, Vice Chairman:
"We will not be entertaining any comments on the closing or the
opening of Palm Square. Our Board has no authority over that,
the Commission's rule and. they have total authority so we will
not hear anything about the closing or the opening of Palm
Square. "
"The order we are going to be doing this; we will open up the
Public Hearing, we will read the application, the letter of
justifications, the March 2nd letter from Mr. Bridges as
contained in the packet to Janet Meeks, we' ll ask staff if the
hearing is properly noticed. We will then accept comments from
the applicant, comments from the public in favor, comments from
the public against, and then we will close the hearing. Then it
will be open to comments and discussion by the Board, and then
we will vote. "
Susan Ruby, Assistant City Attorney:
"This Board really doesn't have the authority to do anything
about the closing or non-closing. The City Commission has
already voted to temporarily close it, they may want to open it
at another time and I 'm sure at that time when a permanent
decision is made they can ask this Board for their
recommendation, they had not asked this Board for a
recommendation as yet. "
AGENDA ITEM 3
COA 8-170A
810 E. Atlantic Ave, Boyd Building
DeNiro Realty, Jack DeNiro, Owner
Change of color for approved awnings.
Mr. DeNiro has leased 4 of the five stores on the ground floor
of the Boyd Building. He has an option to lease the fifth store
(the wig shop) . He plans to install uniform awnings over each
store front. The awning style will remain as previously
approved. He is requesting approval to change the color and
material from aqua vinyl to dark green canvas for all awnings.
Mr. DeNiro prefers canvas, which is historically correct, to
vinyl . He has stated that canvas, in a color which would match
the approved aqua, is not available with fireproofing.
Fireproof awnings are required by City fire code.
I have suggested that the applicant bring swatches of colors
which are available in fireproof canvas to the meeting.
_________ _
-- - I j
FINDING OF FACT
HPB Meeting 12/18/91
AGENDA ITEM 7
COA 8-170 840 E. Atlantic, Boyd Building. J.C. DeNiro,
Realty, Owner of Business, Stanley Miller, Architect,
Authorized Agent.
1 . Awnings for E. Atlantic facade
2 . Renovation of rear (parking lot) entrance.
At its meeting of December 18, 1991 the Historic Preservation
Board approved without modification the above items 1 and 2 .
Please see attached elevations for details.
The Board approved the color change for the awnings, from plum
which was approved at the time of the Boyd Building's renovation,
to aqua with pink trim. See attached color swatch.
The Board also approved the request that a sign be painted on the
rear awning subject to the Sign Administrator's approval.
Vote 6-0 for both items.
AGENDA ITEM 2
COA 8-166D
503 N.E. 2nd Avenue
Renaissance Dental Studio
Jay Kunze, Owner
Attached is the sketch for the proposed planter box on the west
facade of the building. This was discussed at the March 18,
1992 HPB meeting but because it was not on the agenda it could
not be reviewed at the meeting.
RECOMMENDATION
Approve the planter box with the following modification:
Cement blocks on the exterior of planter box are to
be finished with stucco and painted to match the building.
. • (-/-: v -) - 2_ ., _ A )-Q___ .
:71 .-rifirililla- . . M El El
. ,..e, . . mei - .
- tL15IIU• - . .' illarlis .., • _ __ �-
i-•�
C'NT - � t_
: : '� 'l � LyT-1_hL�
, P B • El 0
.,. . .
‘ „. . 3:
eIJ FVItp•Xvow)_G►PC1'T.. c1`I_Ew pi_gl;'rc_�,
A
AGENDA ITEM 4
COA 8-177
New Construction on the west side of S.E. 7th Avenue, Block 120,
6 .02 ' of Lot 21 and all of Lot 22, (third lot south of S.E. 3rd
Street) .
John Frysinger, Owner
20843 Via Valencia Dr, Boca Raton 33433
276-5600 (0)
483-9383 (H)
Two story single family residence and single story guest
cottage. Frame construction, horizontal clapboard siding.
Aluminum windows with 3" wood trim and wood sills . Asphalt
shingle roof. Total square feet 2,474 .
COLORS
Siding: Pale peach/pink
Trim: White
Shutters : Very dark green (Uptown Green)
Roof: Light gray
Floor plan and color samples to be available at the meeting.
COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATION
Request more detailed landscape plan.
Indicate how space for additional car will be accommodated.
Aluminum windows to be vinyl clad.
Recommend approval providing all building department development
standards are in compliance.
J >
APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA
100 N.W. 1ST AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
The Historic Preservation Board meets on the first and
third Wednesday of each month. This application must be filed
15 days prior to the next available meeting.
Address of Property S. E. Seventh Ave.
COS e—17 '
Affix One Clear Picture
74.1-43EIVII‘•-•% 47.-0,k;• k Vc.0;;;,,
a• .ram r ..� • i� t\ l j!• i �
; J
•
•
••ti: -.i�iL. t•'V P-fit �.i� .. .� ...
Frysr„ q c r lot-front vi c w
I. ..—.A
id Df S E. T///.eD S T. es_ ____-----
Igo.06.
eo's0
dew rF.F- f1 'SS
••
t�
N EY/S>i..16 C c
as
,a GS 38,1t' tiuti ,� Zvi
I cP. ., \ : /.35..DO• IV W ?AID' W
�1.01(t0S<Na I.R5. k t� 4'
�`"` �`d"�" Z Irk DESCRIPTION:
r,d��9 " B9.' .sti .4o'
1 e e. o.r ,1 dS. - GOT ZZ q� ga Q The North 6.02 feet of Inc 21 and Lot 22, Block 120, BLANK - NIC
WALL. �� Os.........,....„..o �L OG.. /ZD op o ( VI
ry` f � 3 N SUBDNISIOtt, Delray Beach, a subdivision as recorded in Plat 6a
kl �/ N • , Q 13, Page 20, in the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida
�l �qh��'� 1q x Ei 5'51 a W• O 1, CEI2TIFIG\TIOtI:
V1. 61 N t64 • ��4 , `Q
.O�
k t c �; h h I hereby certify this sketch as sham hereon represents a survey
V y i �b I made under my direction and to be true and accurate to the best
0:tt. B9• a%- . I h of my knaaledge and belief, subject to easements and right-of-t..
=�+ 1 Qs q`1,_14 �-- v9to�•h of record.
g51�• Ia dN. G.ot' Or Lot 21 ,f. 2s.4. ; e�__1i'✓�--
E�ya ql t <<q4 01 L�a,rP �o.»' .N/.�5.DO N t j97' I cv I+• iscered Florida Land Su�>yor
r .75/' ,+ Nro0 F4N� `I G t V Date of Survey: Sept. 5, 1991
2500
(V; N 31.79' ' 7•
avIcpiAla
h
,(ow£Sf!F. It 7.3? I z
'` THE S. 43.96' OF .C,or 2/, d L Y• a !z o
W
/t/Or A PACT OF S UR✓EY•
--y
i3J.ao'
_
�— 0�1( P(V,SOh
/lArrl� co/ t.',we .Gar 2 -- 7277 i
/E r BOUNDAR>' AND ELEV//r/""SURVEY esr7 I,
NOTES.' °'"Seer.
,..✓.vv/<.orEs CENTER L//+'E' /�fP.4.[EO FM': JAC.r F.tYS/N66.G
/. T/1/S SMY✓ >' NEET.: TVf Nb✓/N UN TEENN/LAG p/f N. 4.0z'OF40r t! LorzZ, &OCR/24 �NWP„
,t/�✓"-/NO/<.4rES R/G.`/t-Df-W.✓Y
cSTAH0.4,P0S DF CN//FTE.e 2/ //f/- • pr .. /NO/GATES /'�X /N6 ELEiAr/oN d�N�'-N/GNOLS SUaO/✓/1/ON =el,
ly
T. E 0.0677 aNS ;e r/ BASED DN N.G 1!D. (N.4r/cN.OG ra.5.t9_ /N0/LA1ES "°
• GEooEr/c vE.eri<•oc o✓/rU/�1). /,�f ^- /HOirdr`s/Or/ or', FcvN. GEtTê
R ENGINEERING &
�3rNrs svevEY /s tocarEo le FZ000 zo vEs URVEYING, INC.
''X' ANO We"leis‘E[Bl, ACID,¢D/NG To Ti1E FRS~W%N G�/� /AWN PrM ser
Ere ,rii, 5, N.OAYEG No, /ZS/02 4�¢ A-x-x -••/NO/IATES i'dr,,.VG FfNte P.O.BOX 243
/(1AR GATE J.4N- S, /989. ,,/,yp/cArEs F/N/SNEO FLooR DELRAY BEACH,FLORIDA 33444 y or
_
Sa�`Er OF: �323 S.L; ynAvE�oEc.eAYdE�LN FL. FF :....:;. . --_-
•