Loading...
HPB 04-20-1990 11/1 AMENDED AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING FRIDAY, APRIL 20 , 1990 8 : 00 A.M. COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record or the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. 1. Roll Call 2. COA 8-028 A 132 N. Swinton Avenue, Chris O'Hare, Owner. Wooden fence on N.W. corner of property. Wooden gates at entrance to porte-cochere. 3 . COA 8-104 201 N.E. 1st Avenue, Anita Shannon, Owner. General exterior rehabilitation, including windows, doors, roof, painting and sign. 4 . COA 8-105 131 S.E. 7th Avenue, Cheryl Jones, Owner. Install new roof, new canvas on awnings, paint house and trim. 5 . COA 8-095 A 18 Lake Court, Vivian or James Van Dorn, Owners. Install new roof. 6 . COA 8-106 711 S.E. 3rd Street, Jerry Barding, Owner. Construct a wooden "T" dock on the Intracoastal Waterway. All necessary permits have been issued. 7 . COA 8-107 527 N. Swinton Avenue, James Dalton, Owner. Reroof with same material as existing roof. Paint exterior. 8 . COA 8-103 A 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue, Charles and Jeanne Goodson, Owners. Presented by Robert Pitts or Wm. Maher, Authorized Agents. Allow a change of use from residential to intermediate care facility. This is a conditional use in the RM 10 zoning district. The Board' s recommendation will be transmitted to Planning & Zoning and will be considered by the City Commission. 9 . COA 8-103 B 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue. Approval of site plan including, parking, parking surface, handicapped ramp and landscaping. 10 . COA 8-104 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue. Exterior refurbishing and enclosing garages facing N.E. 4th Street. 11. S.S. Inchulva State Historic Marker. Linda Reeves, representative. Recommend placement of marker on City' s public beach; 10 feet north of the concrete utility pole located at AIA and Casuarina Road approximately 4 feet from sidewalk. 12. Approval of Minutes: January 19, 1990 February 16, 1990 March 3 , 1990 March 16, 1990 13 . Unfinished Business A. Report on Historic Arts District 14. New Business A. Discussion regarding change of HPB meeting schedule. 13 . Adjournment /11/0, AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING FRIDAY, APRIL 20, 1990 8: 00 A.M. COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record or the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. 1. Roll Call 2 . COA 8-028 A 132 N. Swinton Avenue, Chris O'Hare, Owner. Wooden fence on N.W. corner of property. Wooden gates at entrance to porte-cochere. 3 . COA 8-104 201 N.E. 1st Avenue, Anita Shannon, Owner. General exterior rehabilitation, including windows, doors, roof, painting and sign. 4. COA 8-105 131 S.E. 7th Avenue, Cheryl Jones, Owner. Install new roof, new canvas on awnings, paint house and trim. 5. COA 8-095 A 18 Lake Court, Vivian or James Van Dorn, Owners. Install new roof. 6. COA 8-103 A 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue, Charles and Jeanne Goodson, Owners. Presented by Robert Pitts or Wm. Maher, Authorized Agents. Allow a change of use from residential to intermediate care facility. This is a conditional use in the RM 10 zoning district. The Board' s recommendation will be transmitted to Planning & Zoning and will be considered by the City Commission. 7. COA 8-103 B 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue. Approval of site plan including, parking, parking surface, handicapped ramp and landscaping. All 8 . COA 8-104 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue. Exterior refurbishing and enclosing garages facing N.E. 4th Street. 9. S.S. Inchulva State Historic Marker. Linda Reeves, representative. Recommend placement of marker on City' s public beach; 10 feet north of the concrete utility pole located at AIA and Casuarina Road approximately 4 feet from sidewalk. 10 . Approval of Minutes: January 19, 1990 February 16, 1990 March 3 , 1990 March 16 , 1990 11. Unfinished Business A. Report on Historic Arts District 12 . New Business 13 . Adjournment • 4 A r MEMORANDUM DATE: APRIL 13 , 1990 TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD FROM: PAT CAYCE SUBJECT: AGENDA FOR HPB MEETING FRIDAY APRIL 20, 1990 1. Roll Call David Martin has resigned from HPB 2 . COA 8-28 A 132 N. Swinton Avenue, Chris O'Hare, Owner. Wooden fence on N.W. corner of property. Wooden gates at entrance to porte- cochere. A small office building is located on the N.W. corner (rear) of the property. Mr. O'Hare requests approval for a wooden fence 6' tall with 1x4" rails and 4x4" posts, see sketch attached to COA. The fence is to be on the property line to the west and north of the building. Gates will be installed to allow access at the south and east ends of the fence. To the south of the main building, facing N. Swinton is a trellis which gives the appearance of a porte-cochere. Mr. O'Hare has had problems with cars driving in, thinking that there is a rear exit to the property. He proposes to install a pair of double gates with wooden frame and wood lattice panel, attached to the east posts of the trellis. 3 . COA 8-104 201 N.E. 1st Avenue, Anita Shannon, Owner. General exterior rehabilitation, including windows, doors, roof, painting and sign. At the March 2, 1990 HPB meeting the Board voted to recommend to P&Z that a skin care salon be determined to be a similar use as those which are allowed as professional offices in the RO zoning district. P & Z will consider this at its meeting April 16, 1990. This COA may be approved subject to P&Z's approval of similarity of use. The following improvements are proposed for the property: Replace windows and screening. HPB should require that replacement windows, visible from the street, be double hung and of wood construction. Screen installed on porch in rear of guest house. Replace door of main house with solid wood. A wood paneled door would be appropriate, a flush door would not. Screen doors on front doors of both houses. These doors should be wood and not aluminum. Repair chain link fence. A hedge, allowed to grow to the height of fence, should be required to screen chain link fence from streetscape. Suggest that any gates be made of wood. Roof repair with matching material. Replace damaged siding with matching siding. Install a lamp post style mount for a 2'x 2' wood shingle sign, white background, black lettering. Sign to be located at the corner of N.E. 1st Ave. and N.E. 2nd St. (see survey) . Ms. Shannon says she will work with the County Extension Agent for landscaping suggestions. The removal of the inappropriate brick wall surrounding the banyon tree would be a great improvement. Paint both houses white with black trim. 4. COA 8-105 131 S.E. 1st Avenue, Cheryl Jones, Owner. Install new roof, new canvas on awnings, paint house and trim. The roof will be replaced to match existing roof. The new canvas awnings will be exactly the same as existing awnings and will be dark green. Ms. Jones plans to paint the house the same colors that the Echols have used on their Fontaine Fox cottages ( across the street and 2 houses north) . Pale pink with a very dark green trim. I have color samples for the meeting. 5. COA 8-095 A 18 Lake Court, Vivian or James Van Dorn, Owners. Install new roof. The applicant applied for a building permit and the application was sent to me, along with a sample of the material. I drove past that same day to see if it matched the existing roof and found that work had already been started. I phoned the building department to see if they had been issued a permit by mistake. No permit had been issued. As of yesterday the roof was half completed. I have written to the Van Dorns and have placed them on the agenda, but the deed is done. Fortunately the roof is appropriate and seems to be the same as the old roof. 6. COA 8-103 A 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue, Charles and Jeanne Goodson, Owners. Presented by Robert Pitts or Wm. Maher, Authorized Agents. Allow a change of use from residential to intermediate care facility. This is a conditional use in the RM 10 zoning district. The Board's recommendation will be transmitted to Planning & Zoning and will be considered by the City Commission. This request is to allow a residential care facility for drug and alcohol rehabilitation. Maximum number of residents permitted is 20 . Direct 24 hour supervision is required at all times. A staff ratio of one on-duty supervisor to eight permitted residents is appropriate. Please read the attached application to P&Z for a more complete description. The HPB cannot approve changes of use. The Board can only recommend to P&Z and to the City Commission. P&Z will meet on Monday April 16, 1990 and hold a public hearing to consider the use change. It was for this reason that P&Z asked that HPB change its April meeting date to the 13th. Being unable to assemble a quorum for an April 13th HPB meeting, this hearing will be without HPB imput. I have had phone conversations with Mary Lou Jamison, Chairman of Del-Ida Park Neighborhood Association. She reports a great deal of response from the public hearing notice, all of it negative. The neighbors feel that having the Association for Retarded Persons group home in Del-Ida Park is enough and they do not want another group facility. They also feel that it is quite out of character for a relatively small historic district to have two such activities within their area. Mrs. Jamison will be present at the public hearing to represent the Neighborhood Association. 7. COA 8-103 B 401 N.E. 2nd Avenue. Approval of site plan including, parking, parking surface, handicapped ramp and landscaping. Please refer to the attached site plans. The applicant requests approval to widen the existing paved area and to add 1 paved space for handicapped parking. 3 parking spaces will be surfaced with stabilized sod. The dumpster to be enclosed by a wooden fence. A cement handicapped ramp is to be installed on the south end of the front porch facing N.E. 2nd Avenue. Please see landscaping plan for plant list and plant removal list. Though not indicated on the plan, a hedge to screen the existing chain link fence should be included. 8. COA 8-103 401. N.E. 2nd Avenue Exterior refurbishing and enclosing garages facing N.E. 4th St. The applicant plans to repair the exterior of the buildings, with no exterior architectural changes. Sample materials were not submitted with the application. Applicant requests approval to enclose the garages facing N.E. 4th Street. Type of enclosure was not submitted with application. • L.004 ea. If use change is approved the applicant will have to return for HPB approval for specifics on exterior renovation. 9. S.S. Inchulva State Historic Marker. Linda Reeves representative. Recommend placement of marker on City's public beach; 10 feet north of the concrete utility pole located AIA and Casuarina Road approximately 4 feet from sidewalk. Roger Smith, archeologist for the Division of Historical Resources in Tallahassee has been to Delray to dive at the site, has researched the text and has designated this as an official Florida State Historic Site. The marker has been delivered to John Johnson's office in Boca. Recommend to the City Commission that the marker be picked up and installed, at City expense, at the location described above. No other City expense is involved. The marker is paid for by private contributions.