Loading...
HPB 08-15-1990 4 AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING WEDNESDAY AUGUST 15, 1990 5 : 00 P.M. FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL Please be advised that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record.. 1 . Roll Call 2 . Public Hearing: Variance 88-17, 102-106 North Swinton Avenue, Michael Weiner, Owner. 3 . COA 8-111 102-106 North Swinton Avenue, Michael Weiner, Owner. Design approval for restoration and new addition to 102 N. Swinton. Windows, doors, siding, roof, colors, fence, sign, landscaping, parking. 4 . COA 8-131 234 North Ocean Blvd. (Nassau Point) , Towers Financial Services, Inc. , Owner. Randall Stofft or David Poist Authorized Agent. New construction. The approved COA 8-012 has expired. No change to exterior plans from original COA. 5 . COA 8-123 137 South Swinton Avenue, Winston Condominium Association, Richard D. Kirk Authorized Agent. Paint exterior with change of color. 6 . COA 8-124 54 Marine Way, Martha and Charles Barrett, Owners . Repair and rehang existing windows, install new windows and door to front of house. Paint exterior white with dark green shutters . Recover existing awning with dark green canvas . Relocate tool shed. 7 . COA 8-125 112 N.E. 1st Avenue, John & Joan Baccari, Owners . Rear of property: Relocate fence and create a parking area. Recommend change of use for rear building to accommodate a professional architect' s office. Property is located in R/O zoning district. 8 . COA 8-126 203 N.E. 1st Avenue, Arthur and Rosetta Clark, Owners . Repair 3 windows and install a fourth window on north side of building. Paint exterior white. 9 . COA 8-127 123 N.E. 1st Avenue, Jerome Vanhille and Gabe Banfi, Owners . Rehabilitation and restoration of single family residence. 10 . COA 8-128 101 N.E. 5th Street, William Ayers, Owner or his Authorized Agent. Replace windows, paint exterior with change of color, install driveway, repair garage, upgrade landscaping. 11 . COA 8-129 228 S.E. 7th Avenue, Kathleen Patterson, Owner. Re-roof house and cottage, paint exterior, new fence and gate, install carport. 12 . COA 8-058 Continuation: 503 N.E. 2nd Avenue, Gerald Kunze, Owner. Paint stain color selection for existing fence. Finalization of design for west facade. 13 . COA 8-130 223 N.E. 1st Avenue, Gene Fisher, Owner. Paint exterior with change of color, install picket fence, re-roof, awnings, shutters, landscape. 14 . Progress report Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines Manual, Clemmer Mayhew III . 15 . New Business . 16 . Unfinished Business . A. Dedication of the S.S. Inchulva State Historic Marker, Tuesday, Noon, September 11, 1990 Meeting will adjourn and reconvene at 840 E. Atlantic Avenue. 17 . COA 8-119 Continuation: 840 East Atlantic Avenue, Boyd Building and Bridge Restaurant, Bertram • Handlesman, Owner, or Demetris Tomasis, Authorized Agent. Paint with change of color, awnings, deck. 18 . Adjournment. MEMORANDUM DATE: AUGUST 9, 1990 TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMBERS FROM: PAT CAYCE SUBJECT: HPB MEETING AUGUST 15, 1990, AGENDA REPORT 1 . Roll Call 2 . Public Hearing: Variance 88-17, 102-106 North Swinton Avenue, Michael Weiner, Owner This variance will allow the applicant to add 397 square feet of office space to the "Clark House" at 102 North Swinton Avenue. Please read the letter sent to 300 ' radius property owners if you need additional information. One phone call, in favor, has been received from a property owner on N.W. 1st Avenue. No other public comment. Recommend approval. 3 . COA 8-111 102-106 North Swinton Avenue, Michael Weiner, Owner. Design approval for restoration and new addition to 102 N. Swinton. Windows, doors, siding, roof, colors, fence, sign, landscaping, parking. The HPB voted conceptual design approval at the July, 18, 1990 meeting. The plans are enclosed and have not changed. The roof will match the existing roof and a color sample will be available at the meeting. The windows, doors and siding are indicated on the plan and are deemed to be appropriate. I have concern about the window glass being tinted gray. Pat Healy-Golembe has information about a new type of glare retardant which is colorless . The location and height of the picket fence is not specified on the plan and will need to be addressed at the meeting. Janet Meeks is the planner on this project and she will be at the meeting to suggest that a fence or hedge be installed on the north property line. This is required by City Code as a buffer to the adjacent residential property to the north. Aesthetically, I believe a hedge is the solution to the problem. Having two different styles and heights of fencing will look cluttered and will detract from the visual impact of the building from N. Swinton Avenue. The parking meets all city requirements . One parking space can be removed and I recommend that the space, nearest to N. Swinton A 7• be removed and replaced with appropriate landscaping. The location and style of the sign can be approved. Due to the current zoning change from RO to OSSHAD the size of the sign cannot be approved at this time. Recommendation: Approve a hedge, rather than fence, for north property line. Eliminate the parking space nearest to N. Swinton Ave. Deny tinted glass windows. Approve everything else. 4 . COA 8-131 234 North Ocean Blvd. (Nassau Point) , Towers Financial Services, Inc. , Owner. Randall Stofft or David Poist Authorized Agent. New construction. The approved COA 8-012 has expired. No change to exterior plans from original COA. In August of 1988 the HPB approved COA 8-012 . COA 8-012 has expired and COA 8-131 replaces it. COA 8-012 gave approval for the plans and elevations as presented, subject to approval of the applicant's variance requests . On April 21, 1989 HPB approved the variance requests. With the exception of the location of the steps in the four swimming pools, the exterior site plan and elevations are the same as approved by the HPB in August, 1988. The original COA 8-012 did not address, color of barrel tile roof, samples of paint for exterior, material of balcony railing, color of paving tile, fencing size and design or a detailed landscape plan. The applicant was requested to return for final approval of all the above. Staff recommends approval of COA 8-131 including changes to swimming pool steps. Applicant must get HPB approval for all detailed above. 5. COA 8-123 137 South Swinton Avenue, Winston Condominium Association, Richard D. Kirk Authorized Agent. Paint exterior with change of color. The condo association requests approval to paint the building. Mr Kirk will bring paint samples and will welcome the HPB suggestions. 6 . COA 8-124 54 Marine Way, Martha and Charles Barrett, Owners . * 7• Repair and rehang existing windows, install new windows and door to front of house. Paint exterior white with dark green shutters . Recover existing awning with dark green canvas . Relocate tool shed. Everything done by the previous owners of this contributing house was done without building permits. The new owners are making every effort to correct the situation. I approved a building permit application to allow four sets of existing French doors, not visible from the street, to be removed and rehung in the same location. The boarding-up which you will see on the front facade was an emergency situation which I authorized. The applicant is requesting approval to restore the front bay facade with double hung wooden windows to match existing windows. She plans to install a new wood front door. The upper panel of the door will consist of an antique stained glass plaque depicting a lighthouse, the lower panel of the door will be wood. Approval is requested to temporarily relocate an attractive wood tool shed mounted on skids, which is located smack dab in the center of her back yard, to the northwest corner of the lot. The shed is so close to the house that the contractor cannot get a wheel barrow between the main house and the tool shed. The house is to be repainted white and will have dark green shutters . The existing front awning will be recovered in dark green canvas . Recommend approval. 7 . COA 8-125 112 N.E. 1st Avenue, John & Joan Baccari, Owners. Rear of property: Relocate fence and create a parking area. Recommend change of use for rear building to accommodate a professional architect's office. Property is located in R/O zoning district. You can see this better if you drive into Cason Cottage parking lot. The request is for approval to move an existing fence 20 feet to the east of the rear property line. This will create parking spaces for four cars with entrance and exit from the alley. The surface is to be shell rock base with pea or river rock topping. Wheel stops are to be of wood. If it is determined that one hard surfaced space for handicapped parking is required, approval for that should be granted at this time. Recommend approval. 8 . COA 8-126 203 N.E. 1st Avenue, Arthur and Rosetta Clark, Owners . Repair 3 windows and install a fourth window on north side of building. Paint exterior white. A tenant installed three windows on the north side of the house without the owner' s consent and without a building permit. Applicant is requesting approval to repair the three improperly installed windows and to add a fourth window, to the east, along the same wall. Applicant requests approval to paint the house white with gold trim. Applicant will bring trim color. Recommendation: Approve repair of three existing windows . Deny installation of fourth window. Approve white paint but specify exact trim color. 9 . COA 8-127 123 N.E. 1st Avenue, Jerome Vanhille and Gabe Banfi, Owners. Rehabilitation and restoration of single family residence. A stop work order was issued on this project because all the work was being done without building permits or COA approval. All of the windows are scheduled to be aluminum. The three small windows facing N.E. 1st Avenue will be awning style. I believe that all window glass is to be tinted. The applicant plans to paint the house in one of the three shades of green at the top of the attached color chart. Trim to be white. Recommendation: The three windows on the enclosed front porch should be enlarged and the lower level of the windows should extend to what was originally the porch rail . The shutters on the south front window should be denied. At a minimum all windows facing N.E. 1st Avenue should be wooden and have clear glass panes . 10 . COA 8-128 101 N.E. 5th Street, William Ayers, Owner or his Authorized Agent. Replace windows, paint exterior with change of color, install driveway, repair garage, upgrade landscaping. Bill Ayers will install custom made wood windows. The house is to be painted the same color as Old School Square, using the lighter shade of blue for the trim. Metal awnings to be removed. Batten and board wood shutter will be installed. Recommend approval. 11. COA 8-129 228 S.E. 7th Avenue, Kathleen Patterson, Owner. Re-roof house and cottage, paint exterior, new fence and gate, install carport. I am unclear about this project. The application came by mail and I have been unable to contact the owner. The paint colors can be decided if the applicant brings samples, or chooses one of ours . I don't know what roof material is planned. The carport will need a variance before it can be installed. The roof of the carport looks to be aluminum. Stan Weedon suggested that the roof could be painted and that a 12" canvas drop could be added to the front and sides to give the appearance of an appropriate canvas covered carport. 12 . COA 8-058 Continuation: 503 N.E. 2nd Avenue, Gerald Kunze, Owner. Paint/stain color selection for existing fence. Finalization of design for west facade. Mr. Kunze will bring fence paint/stain color samples to the meeting. Mr. Kunze wants to finish the west facade in the style that the HPB originally approved. I will bring the plans to the meeting. 13 . COA 8-130 223 N.E. 1st Avenue, Gene Fisher, Owner. Paint exterior with change of color, install picket fence, re-roof, awnings, shutters, landscape. Paint samples will be available at the meeting. The front chain link fence will be removed and replaced by a white picket fence. Aluminum shutters will be removed. A canvas awning is requested for the front porch. 14 . Progress report Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines Manual, Clemmer Mayhew III . 15 . New Business . 16 . Unfinished Business . A. Dedication of the S.S. Inchulva State Historic Marker, Tuesday, Noon, September 11, 1990 Meeting will adjourn and reconvene at 840 E. Atlantic Avenue. 17 . COA 8-119 Continuation: 840 East Atlantic Avenue, Boyd Building and Bridge Restaurant, Bertram Handlesman, Owner, or Demetris Tomasis, Authorized Agent. Paint with change of color, awnings, deck. The restaurant will be closed due to renovations . Staff felt that an on-site visit was necessary before approval of the COA. 18 . Adjournment.