Loading...
HPB 09-20-1989 AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD SPECIAL MEETING WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 20 , 1989 8: 15 A.M. COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL 1. Roll Call 2 . COA 8-070 Continuation, 832 E. Atlantic Ave. Bridge Copy Center, Sign and Awning. 3 . COA 8-068 Continuation, Goodwill Store Signs. Presented by Mark Little, Bright Image Signs. 4. COA 8-081 701 N. Swinton Ave. , Steven E. Baltz, owner. Windows, Awnings, Deck and Fence. 5 . Old School Square • 6 . COA 8-082 229 S.E. 7th Ave. Owner, Ralph Barding or Agent, Roger Zona. New Construction. 7 . Linda Reeves to discuss Historic Marker for the S.S. Inchulva (Delray Wreck) . 8. At 9: 00 A.M. the Special Meeting will be interrupted for a Public Hearing regarding the nomination of 610 N. Ocean Blvd. (Ocean Apple Estate) to the Local Register of Historic Sites. 9 . Video presentation: Jerry Sanzone 10 . Approval of Minutes of August 18, 1989 meeting 11. Unfinished Business 12. New Business 13 . Adjournment 1) GdAry MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD i9,4 t°aoe.D SPECIAL MEETING SEPTEMBER 20 , 1989 8 : 15 A.M. ///jy/g? MEMBERS PRESENT OTHERS PRESENT Alice Finst Jerome Sanzone, Building Dept. Clemmer Mayhew Susan Ruby, Ass ' t City Attorney Dave Martin John P. Johnson, Director, David Nathanson Historic Preservation Board Palm Spencer Pompey Beach County Patricia Healy, Chairperson Stan Weedon, Ass ' t Planning Director Steve Boltz Kim Parham Steven Gordon Roger Zona MEMBERS NOT PRESENT Pat Cayce, Preservation Planner Diane DeMarco Excuse Absence 1. The Chairperson called the meeting to order at 8: 18 a.m. . 2. The recording Secretary took the roll. 3 . Ms. Cayce suggested to amend the agenda to have Old School Square to appear last on the agenda and that the Board walk over to Old School Square to look at a large scale model. The Board should check the Atlantic Avenue side of the site to see the progress. Ms. Finst motioned to amend the agenda as stated above. Seconded by Mr. Nathanson. The Chairperson asked if all were in favor. All Board members were in favor of the above. 4. C.O.A. 8-070 Continuation 832 E. Atlantic Ave. Bridge Copy Center, Sign & Awning. Mr. Steve Gordon addressed the Board, he read a written statement. The statement read by Mr. Gordon expressed his objection to being singled out (as stated by Mr. Gordon) as a guinea pig. Mr. Gordon feels the Board should have notified each current tenant and landlord of the proposed plans regarding the restoration of East Atlantic Avenue. Mr. Gordon rejected all of the Historic Preservation Board' s suggestions from the meeting of September 15, 1989. He wants to paint the awning and repaint the existing sign as presented, originally, on his COA. Mr. Mayhew stated the Historic Preservation Board' s intent in suggesting the same awning and sign treatment as the Silk Store, also in the Boyd Building, is to unify the facade and to have signs, awnings and colors that are compatible and aesthetically appropriate to the architecture of the building. It was recommended that the owner of the building, Mr. Burton Handelsman, be contacted when he returns to Delray, to see what can be resolved between tenants, owner and the Historic Preservation Board. The Board requested Mr. Gordon to wait at least a week or two before finalizing on the above. The Board feels after the meeting with the tenant and owner some solution to the above problem will occur. The Board voted to continue until the above meeting takes place. Mr. Nathanson motioned to continue until the special meeting. Seconded by Mr. Pompey. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Not Present David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Yes Mr. Nathanson motioned to amend agenda to bring item 7 up to the next item on the agenda. Seconded by Ms. Finst. The Chairperson ask if all members were in favor. All member were in favor of the above and the motioned carried. 5. Linda Reeves to discuss Historic Marker for the S.S. Inchulva (Delray Wreck) . Due to the large interest in the wreck a group of concerned citizens would like to place a plaque on the beach giving information regarding the wreck. Ms. Ruby expressed her concerns regarding the City' s liability and we should consider Mr. Weldon' s (Director of Parks and Recreation) views on the above. Ms. Healy feels the Board should continue the above until the next meeting or special meeting. Ms. Finst motioned to continue the above. Seconded by Mr. Nathanson. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Not Present David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Yes 6. Public Hearing regarding the nomination of 610 N. Ocean Blvd. (Ocean Apple Estate)to the Local Register of Historic Sites. The Chairperson called the Public Hearing to order at 9: 00 a.m. . ( 2) Mr. Martin arrived at 9: 02 a.m. . Proper notification was given to all property owners within 300 feet as required by Code. Mr. Siemon addressed the Board regarding changes that were made to the original report. There were no other comments from the Public regarding the Designation. Ms. Finst motioned to designate the above property to the Local Register of Historic Sites. Seconded by Mr. Pompey. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Yes David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Yes 7. C.O.A. 8-068 Continuation, Goodwill Store Signs Presented by Mark Little, Bright Image Signs. The Historic Preservation Board at the August 18, 1989 meeting voted to continue this COA. The Historic Preservation Board approved the signs as presented by Mr. Mark Little of Bright Image Signs. The signs are not lighted and are constructed of sand blasted wood. The paint color is Blue *1219 and the letters are to be white. Mark Little suggested possibly painting vertical bands at the north and south corners of the front facade and the possibility of accenting the windows of the north facade with painted trim. The color to be the same blue as the sign background. The painted trim on windows and front facade is at Mark Little' s discretion. Mr. Mayhew motioned to approve this COA with the above mentioned conditione. Seconded Mr. Nathanson. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Yes David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Yes 8. C. O. A. 8-081 701 N. Swinton Avenue Steven E. Baltz, owner. Windows, Awnings, Deck and Fence. The applicant is requesting the above COA for replacement of Windows, Awnings, Deck and Fence. The applicant expressed his concerns regarding the upkeep of the above (3 ) property. The Board approved the above COA with the following modifications: 1. The new fence is to be painted or stained white. 2. The applicant will, at a future date remove the carport awning. He may recycle the canvas to proposed rear awning. Ms. Finst motioned to approve the above COA with modifications as stated. Seconded by Mr. Nathanson. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Yes David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Yes 8. C. O. A. 8-082 229 S. E. 7th Avenue Owner, Ralph Barding or Agent, Roger Zona. New Construction The applicant is requesting this COA for new construction after the existing structure is removed. The Historic Preservation Board found the plans for new construction incomplete and inappropriate for the Marina Historic District. The applicant/builder will return with additional plans that will be appropriate for this area. Ms. Finst motioned to continued until the next meeting. Seconded by Mr. Mayhew. The Chairperson asked if all members were in favor. There being no member in opposition, the motion carried. Ms. Finst asked what efforts are being made with regards to the relocating of the existing structure. The builder will be responsible for relocating the existing structure, if possible to an existing historical district. 9. Video presentation: Jerry Sanzone The video was based on the progressive development plans for Atlantic Avenue. The Atlantic Development Association is responsible for the video. 10 . Unfinished Business Discussion regarding location of the Pompey Marker, Ms. Cayce feels the best location would be, the corner of 5th ave, two blocks beyond 1st Street on the west side of the Street. The new site is City owned property. Mr. Pompey will continue to negotiate with the Church to see if they will reconsider having the Marker located on their property, and Ms. Cayce along with Ms. Ruby will look into the above location. a. Ms. Cayce asked if the Board would approve paying the registraion fee for both Ms. Healy and herself, for the Florida Trust Conference. The fee is $65. 00 per person. (4) Ms. Finst motioned to approve the above. Seconded by Mr. Pompey. The Chairperson asked if all members were in favor. All members were in favor of the above. There will be a special meeting the 20th October, 1989. Ms. Healy left the member after the above Video presentation and Mr. Mayhew chaired the meeting from this point on. 11. The Board Moved to Old School Square. The Board moved to Old School Square at 10: 30 a.m. . The meeting reopened at Old School Square at 10. 45 a.m. Mary Lou addressed the Board. The model of Old School Square after completion of Phase I was on hand for review by all members. Each Board member expressed his or her opinion regarding the model. There was extensive discussion regarding the Master Plan. Ms. Ruby worded the motioned for the recorded, to modify the current COA as shown on the Master Plan, dated . 9/14/89 by Currie Schneider Associates, not including landscape or color scheme. Seconded by Mr. Pompey. The vote was as follows: Diane DeMarco Excused Absence Alice Finst Yes Clemmer Mayhew Yes Dave Martin Yes David Nathanson Yes Spencer Pompey Yes Patricia Healy Not Present 12. There was no approval of the Minutes of August 18, 1989 meeting. 13 . New Business Ms. Finst suggested the Board look into an awards program for New Construction, Revitalization, and Landscaping. The Community Appearance Board maintains such a program. Awards from the Community Appearance Board are given out once a year. Ms. Finst feels it would encourage people, Mr. Mayhew stated he suggested the above two years ago. Ms. Finst motioned to discuss annual or monthly award on the next agenda. Seconded by Mr. Martin. The Chairperson asked if all were in favor of the above. There were no members in opposition. 14. Adjournment. Mr. Nathanson motioned to adjourn. Seconded by Mr. Martin. All members were in favor of adjournment. The meeting adjourned at 11: 55 a.m. . ( 5) NOTES TO THE FILE FROM Pat Cayce September 26, 1989 The Historic Preservation Board was without a recording secretary during the months of January, February and March of 1989. The following minutes are on tape but have not been transcribed. January 20, 1989 February 17, 1989 March 7, 1989 Special Meeting March 16, 1989 March 30, 1989 Special Meeting The minutes for the meetings from April thru September, in this folder, were transcribed by Dureene Moore and are on hard disk in her file. August 18 and August 29 minutes are filed: HPB 21. September 15 and September meetings are filed: HPB 10. File/minutes