Loading...
HPB-03-18-09 Co,-` AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Meeting Date: March 18, 2009 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Delray Beach CRA, Property Owner; MacLaren Sign Co., Authorized Agent. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for a freestanding sign. V. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. COA Approval Matrix Discuss Staff's proposed revisions to the matrix, for clarification purposes only. B. HPB Award Categories Discuss additional types of categories as previously discussed by the Board. Note: Award consideration to take place at a future meeting. VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Board Members • Staff VII. ADJOURN anu' E. C2'evaxerz Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: March 13, 2009 t HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Authorized Agent: MacLaren Sign Co. Project Location: 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 18, 2009 File: 2009-108-COA ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a free-standing sign on a non-contributing property located at 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND& PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lots 4 and 5, Replat of Part of Block 27, Delray Beach, and is located on the east side of NW 5th Avenue between NW 1st and 2"d Streets. The property is located within the West Settlers Historic District and is zoned Central Business District (CBD). The two-story concrete block and stucco, multi-family structure was constructed in 1959 and designed by architects Samuel Ogren and Charles Toth. The building originally contained nine apartments and one office located on the ground floor. In January 2005, a COA request for the installation of new windows and tracks used for hurricane panels was approved by the Board. An application for new railing, exterior alterations, entry'arch, color changes, and site improvements was approved by the Board in August 2007. The current proposal is for the installation of a free-standing sign located approximately five feet (5') from the front property line. The sign (above grade) measures 60" (5') wide, by 49.5" (4' 1.5") high, and will be finished in stucco matching the texture and color of the building. An aluminum arch will be on top of the sign, and resemble the entry arch recently installed on the property. The letters will be of black plastic and state "Carolyn Quince Court" with the street number below. The building has been name after the late Carolyn Quince who was a Delray Beach resident and CRA employee at the time of her passing. The COA for a sign is now before the Board for consideration. ANALYSIS LDR SECTION 4.6.7—SIGNS LDR Section 4.6.7(A) is noted below as it applies to the subject signage request(emphasis added). (A) Purpose: The purposes of these sign regulations are: to minimize the possible adverse affect of signs on nearby public and private property; to foster the integration of signage with architectural and landscape designs. 133 NW 5..Avenue COA 2009-108 HPB Meeting Mach 18,2009 Page 2 o` (2) Preservation of Community's Beauty: The City of Delray Beach which includes a beach resort community as well as major office and industrial parks relies heavily on its natural surroundings and beautification efforts to retain its economic advantage. This concern is reflected by actively regulating the appearance and design of signs. (3) Property Value Protection: Signs should not create a nuisance to the occupancy or use of other properties as a result of their size, height, brightness, or movement. They should be in harmony with buildings, the neighborhood, and other conforming signs in the area. Staff Analysis: The above noted LDR has been provided with particular emphasis placed on those components applicable to the subject proposal and appears that the proposed sign complies with the intent of these regulations. Therefore, positive findings can be made. LDR Section 4.6.7(D) (2) (a)-(c) addresses "Aesthetic Qualifications" and states: The aesthetic quality of a building, or of an entire neighborhood, is materially affected by achieving visual harmony of the sign on or about a structure as it relates to the architecture or the building or the adjacent surroundings. The following aesthetic conditions must be met: (a) Garishness: The overall effect of the lettering, configuration or color of a sign shall not be garish. "Garish" signs are those that are too bright gaudy, showy, glaring, and/or cheaply brilliant or involving excessive ornamentation. Garish signs are not in harmony with and not compatible with the building or adjacent surroundings. (b) Scale and Conformity with Surroundings: The scale of the sign in terms of area, shall be consistent with the scale of the building on which it is to be placed or painted and the neighborhood or streetscape where it is to be located. Scale shall also be considered in terms of Subsection (F) (2) with respect to height and area. (c) Quality: All signs shall have a professional appearance that enhances the visual aesthetics of the area. Staff Analysis: The proposed sign is not considered to be garish or out of scale as it is complimentary to the structure. As far as the quality, undoubtedly the sign will have a professional appearance. Therefore, positive findings can be made. LDR Section 4.6.7(E)(7) contains signage regulations for all historic districts. (c) Allowed Totally in Standard Setback: When considered as a part of a site plan approval, or modification to a site plan, a sign may be located totally within the ten foot (109 setback area provided that: 1. The sign height is not greater than seven feet (7); 2. The sign area is less than twenty square feet(20 sq.ft.) Staff Analysis: The proposed sign complies with the subject regulation, as the sign measurements do not exceed those noted above. Therefore, positive findings can be made. 133 NW 5 Avenue COA 2G0 -1 v8 1 APB Meeting Ma=18:2039 Page 3 of 4 LDR SECTION 4.5.1 — HISTORIC PRESERVATION SITES AND DISTRICTS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(5) and 4.5.1(E)(8) provide guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The applicable guidelines are as follows: (E)(5) Standards and Guidelines A historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. (See applicable Standards and Guidelines below) (E)(8) Visual Compatibility Standards All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances within a designated historic district shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front fagade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of a building, directional expression of front elevation, architectural style, and additions. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m). The following Visual Compatibility Standards apply: (a) Height: The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible in comparison or relation to the height of existing structures and buildings in a historic district for all major and minor development. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. (Standard 9) Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines The Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines suggest the following regarding signage: • Use materials and sign types that are based on historical precedent. • The scale of the signage should relate to the scale and detail of the historic building, and not overwhelm or call attention to the sign. • The material of the sign need not be identical, but should be compatible with the construction materials of the building. 133 NW 5r Avenue COA 2009-108 NPL Meeting March 18,2009 PageLo'4 Staff Analysis: No direct reference is made to signage affecting historic structures, sites, or districts within the review criteria above; however, there is specific intent to project the importance of preserving "character- defining" and distinctive features, and discussing scale and compatibility with respect to new construction for historic structures and districts. Overall, the intent of the review criteria has been met as the proposed free-standing sign is appropriate with respect to its scale, style, and materials. Therefore, positive findings can be made with regard to the Land Development Regulations, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108) for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108) for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108) for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Staff Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: •Site Plan •Sign Details •Photographs i CtqrtQuirteeax Court 133 • 60" - __ 3 N = =l s 12" .080 ALUMINUM FACES 1.5"x1.5"x.125 ALUMINUM ANGLE SUPER STRUCTURE WELDED TO FACES FACES TEXTURE COATED FINISH TO MATCH BLDG ALUMINUM ARCH TO MATCH EXISTING BOLTED TO STRUCTURE WITH THREE 3/8" SS BOLTS 1/4" BLACK PLASTIC LETTERS ADHERED WITH SILICONE CLEAR 3"x3"ALUMINUM SQ TUBE POSTS WELDED TO 1.5" SUPER STRUCTURE SET IN CONCRETE i ”ii i_i d __ ,...... ... .. ....po .;11111 MIIIM1IIp [II41IIIfIIE.,.-, , ,j Zv , .ate • 45 ;., .' r C,tL^.M1-�O�in. I3 • L :, ter 34G' -tes '-'. .:',••Tf'= ____ -.... t. . •_." 7 _ '. -r"e _- . h " �= u '4y � �_ AS R -4 ^v. �- -T = } 1.Y :� 3g -.. " t � - F ems-� 'Y.� Z F - ,s, -�. -3^`tar .s -"" -_ x .. ;. S . � ��-<a - J far.. ; .. r �.� _ �_. �= �= ?cam ':'�,iez; :• .x. ; "�- -;��`.`.-a* ,Bc_,. .�.�; S 4fI.� qC .t1 himr �� , ' - 'p-�t 1:,11;..i:'!t.I..i 1:''''''''',.'4:,. r. -::2„ � 77.7.1.1-;1141:1,.v.t.1%,*: !t�� ��� 1X y� ¢o ', ?�l, .u , .tI si: �� ' * `S. lru � I N �` efrii_g"ii:4'....'g;-:1:-:, ...ji..'1''..',.',;.'._ i::'' '" 1i i - Q ' b 11 .. 1111• !. ar .. as .re 4f. ���iii L Si 4.-...,-r 7104 ill • ®Y tit I• ►�-egt �. ��_ I 'Sty l.A r. - n.:, . - ` fix. - 1 cTYPtca Ci /9 r CO an!t GUTTER �`9 '9 2� E26 2 o . ' RDA w19.W !sue a — �' 1 — — — S.1MIr1509'(1rr-R.CYJ * • ` NW 5th AVENUE owe 1 ``� . '174. N +!9 r VALLEY&t y: q f 0 --r<?_ - : --W Tm WEST LOTLDE • �`� �� �9 <9 2p 2 2p� CONC.WALK N00.00'22" k21 ?•00.006— — — .. p3 . I 20 �� Oj 9 f Uj 1 ctiOH813S .� lb el g I \—APPjr<?,5. 511/W TAKING •• s •5 C'- s C `1 ASPHALT PAHlmN6�2oa� 447x. ! NJIS °old 11 A 2p V 20 V ' '9 * A -.tS b V'9 t N 1u 0 r 2 __. ,� CONC` Wax °5, 1 -20 2� — i v s ao' I 7.9' • r PAXg _ ` KC' a ,2p� B9 `,p,,s 2�� -II 4 a u 2,1 CONIC. Q N � S WW 2 f. o .� ill i 1 1 1 _ 4 sr- 4 o ( a :2 CONC. : {pp 2/ 2pi. Cao r la • ti eur Mr 7.r 4.0' 2�1' it 'NI O iS 2 STORY BUILDING S • ' • (APARTMENTS) = - F.F. 4/ • EL.21.03 20 t per v. LOT o { 20� caw' WALK; p 25- ' 1 LOT.5 �IREPLAT OF PART OF '� sr " 1?) - BLOCK 27. TOWN OF LINT �° •S • • ' (P.B.21.PG:Itt P.B.(.R.) W \ • • - Ow • P on uw 42W 20t $ a p • OW <f i d _� 2o . t t t I . _y S00°00'22"W(":4-kt, er2 '2 y100.60' •, 16' ALLEY NOT PAVED) \-r VALLEY GUTTER(TYPICAL) ga AM Planning & Zoning Department MEMORANDUM TO: Historic Preservation Board Members FROM: Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner DATE: March 13, 2009 RE: COA Approval Matrix Please review the attached proposed changes to the COA Approval Matrix. Changes are proposed which intend to clarify the existing matrix. However, all components of the matrix may be discussed at Wednesday's meeting. HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD COA APPROVAL MATRIX Action Contributing; Non-Contributing N/A Staff Board N/A Staff 'Board Additions X X Accessory Structure(Less than 50 square feet) X X Accessory Structure(More than 50 square feet) X X Awnings(New Installation or Type/Size Change) X X Color Change X X Deck(New or Replacement) X X Decorative Shutters(New or Replacement) X X Demolitions X X _ Dock X X Dock with Structure X X Doors,Alteration/Material Change of X X Driveways, Installation of X X Exterior Surfaces, In-Kind Repair of (Siding,Stucco, Etc.) X X X X Exterior Surfaces,Alteration/Material Change of(Siding,Stucco,Etc.) X X Fences,Walls,Gates X X Fountains(Visible from Street) X X Hurricane Shutters X X Material Change(Unless otherwise specified) X X New Construction X X Patio X X Roof,Material Change of X X Roof,Re-roof or Like Kind Repair of X X Signs,New X X Signs,Alterations of Existing (New Sign X X Face,no change in size,material ortvoe) Site Lighting,Replacement of X X Site Lighting,New Installation of X X Swimming Pool X X (Located in Front Yard or containing Features measuring 1'above grade) Swimming Pool,Alteration/Installation of X X Windows, New Installation of or New Configuration/Type of existing X X Windows, Replacement of Existing(Material Change) X X Notes: Requests not appropriately covered by the Historic Preservation Guidelines or this matrix may be referred to Staff or the Historic Preservation Board. Any Certificate Of Appropriateness permitted to be administratively approved by Staff may be referred to the Historic Preservation Board at the Planning and Zoning Department's discretion. Revised:03/2009 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD COA APPROVAL MATRIX Action Contributing Non-Contributing N/A Staff Board N/A Staff Board Additions X X Accessory Structure(Less than 50 square feet) X X Accessory Structure(More than 50 square feet) X X Awnings(New Installation) X X Color Change X X Deck X X Decorative Shutters X X Demolitions X X Dock X X Dock with Structure X X Doors,Alteration of X X Driveways, Installation of X X Exterior Surfaces, In-Kind Repair of (Siding,Stucco,Etc.) X X X X Exterior Surfaces,Alteration of(Siding,Stucco,Etc.) X X Fences,Walls,Gates X X Fountains(Visible from Street) X X Hurricane Shutters X X Material Change X X New Construction X X Patio X X Roof,Material Change of X X Roof, Re-roof or Like Kind Repair of X X Signs,New and/or Alterations of Existing X X Site Lighting, Replacement of X X Site Lighting,New Installation of X X Swimming Pool, Located in Front Yard or containing Features measuring X X 1'above grade Swimming Pool,Alteration/Installation of X X Notes: Requests not appropriately covered by the Historic Preservation Guidelines or this matrix may be referred to Staff or the Historic Preservation Board. Any Certificate Of Appropriateness permitted to be administratively approved by Staff may be referred to the Historic Preservation Board. Revised:09/2008 • HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Authorized Agent: MacLaren Sign Co. Project Location: 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 18, 2009 File: 2009-108-COA ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a free-standing sign on a non-contributing property located at 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lots 4 and 5, Replat of Part of Block 27, Delray Beach, and is located on the east side of NW 5th Avenue between NW 1st and 2nd Streets. The property is located within the West Settlers Historic District and is zoned Central Business District (CBD). The two-story concrete block and stucco, multi-family structure was constructed in 1959 and designed by architects Samuel Ogren and Charles Toth. The building originally contained nine apartments and one office located on the ground floor. In January 2005, a COA request for the installation of new windows and tracks used for hurricane panels was approved by the Board. An application for new railing, exterior alterations, entry arch, color changes, and site improvements was approved by the Board in August 2007. The current proposal is for the installation of a free-standing sign located approximately five feet (5') from the front property line. The sign (above grade) measures 60" (5') wide, by 49.5" (4' 1.5") high, and will be finished in stucco matching the texture and color of the building. An aluminum arch will be on top of the sign, and resemble the entry arch recently installed on the property. The letters will be of black plastic and state "Carolyn Quince Court" with the street number below. The building has been name after the late Carolyn Quince who was a Delray Beach resident and CRA employee at the time of her passing. The COA for a sign is now before the Board for consideration. ANALYSIS LDR SECTION 4.6.7—SIGNS LDR Section 4.6.7(A) is noted below as it applies to the subject signage request(emphasis added). (A) Purpose: The purposes of these sign regulations are: to minimize the possible adverse affect of signs on nearby public and private property; to foster the integration of signage with architectural and landscape designs. 133 NW 5'Avenue CO.;2.009-108 HPB Meeting Mach 18.2009 Pace 2 o 4 (2) Preservation of Community's Beauty: The City of Delray Beach which includes a beach resort community as well as major office and industrial parks relies heavily on its natural surroundings and beautification efforts to retain its economic advantage. This concern is reflected by actively regulating the appearance and design of signs. (3) Property Value Protection: Signs should not create a nuisance to the occupancy or use of other properties as a result of their size, height, brightness, or movement. They should be in harmony with buildings, the neighborhood, and other conforming signs in the area. Staff Analysis: The above noted LDR has been provided with particular emphasis placed on those components applicable to the subject proposal and appears that the proposed sign complies with the intent of these regulations. Therefore, positive findings can be made. LDR Section 4.6.7(D) (2) (a)-(c) addresses "Aesthetic Qualifications" and states: The aesthetic quality of a building, or of an entire neighborhood, is materially affected by achieving visual harmony of the sign on or about a structure as it relates to the architecture or the building or the adjacent surroundings. The following aesthetic conditions must be met: (a) Garishness: The overall effect of the lettering, configuration or color of a sign shall not be garish. "Garish"signs are those that are too bright gaudy, showy, glaring, and/or cheaply brilliant or involving excessive ornamentation. Garish signs are not in harmony with and not compatible with the building or adjacent surroundings. (b) Scale and Conformity with Surroundings: The scale of the sign in terms of area, shall be consistent with the scale of the building on which it is to be placed or painted and the neighborhood or streetscape where it is to be located. Scale shall also be considered in terms of Subsection (F) (2) with respect to height and area. (c) Quality: All signs shall have a professional appearance that enhances the visual aesthetics of the area. Staff Analysis: The proposed sign is not considered to be garish or out of scale as it is complimentary to the structure. As far as the quality, undoubtedly the sign will have a professional appearance. Therefore, positive findings can be made. LDR Section 4.6.7(E)(7) contains signage regulations for all historic districts. (c) Allowed Totally in Standard Setback: When considered as a part of a site plan approval, or modification to a site plan, a sign may be located totally within the ten foot (109 setback area provided that: 1. The sign height is not greater than seven feet(7); 2. The sign area is less than twenty square feet(20 sq.ft.) Staff Analysis: The proposed sign complies with the subject regulation, as the sign measurements do not exceed those noted above. Therefore, positive findings can be made. 133 NW 6' Avenue COA 2009-1 v8 HPB Meeting Marcn 18,2039 Pane 3 of 4 LDR SECTION 4.5.1 — HISTORIC PRESERVATION SITES AND DISTRICTS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Presentation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(5) and 4.5.1(E)(8) provide guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The applicable guidelines are as follows: (E)(5) Standards and Guidelines A historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Delray Beach Historic Presentation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. (See applicable Standards and Guidelines below) (E)(8) Visual Compatibility Standards All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances within a designated historic district shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front fagade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of a building, directional expression of front elevation, architectural style, and additions. Visual compatibility for minor and major development as referenced in Section 4.5.1(E)(2) shall be determined by utilizing criteria contained in (a)-(m). The following Visual Compatibility Standards apply: (a) Height: The height of proposed buildings or modifications shall be visually compatible in comparison or relation to the height of existing structures and buildings in a historic district for all major and minor development. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment. (Standard 9) Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines The Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines suggest the following regarding signage: • Use materials and sign types that are based on historical precedent. • The scale of the signage should relate to the scale and detail of the historic building, and not overwhelm or call attention to the sign. • The material of the sign need not be identical, but should be compatible with the construction materials of the building. 133 NW 5' Avenue COA 2009-108 1-IPB Meeting Ma ch 18,2009 Pane or Staff Analysis: No direct reference is made to signage affecting historic structures, sites, or districts within the review criteria above; however, there is specific intent to project the importance of preserving "character- defining" and distinctive features, and discussing scale and compatibility with respect to new construction for historic structures and districts. Overall, the intent of the review criteria has been met as the proposed free-standing sign is appropriate with respect to its scale, style, and materials. Therefore, positive findings can be made with regard to the Land Development Regulations, Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108) for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108) for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (2009-108)for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Staff Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: •Site Plan •Sign Details •Photographs Coto1ijQuine COW't 133 60" _ = Y Ni 7 .'i 12" .080 ALUMINUM FACES 1.5"x1.5"x.1 25 ALUMINUM ANGLE SUPER STRUCTURE WELDED TO FACES FACES TEXTURE COATED FINISH TO MATCH BLDG ALUMINUM ARCH TO MATCH EXISTING BOLTED TO STRUCTURE WITH THREE 3/8" SS BOLTS 1/4" BLACK PLASTIC LETTERS ADHERED WITH SILICONE CLEAR 3"x3"ALUMINUM SQ TUBE POSTS WELDED TO 1.5" SUPER STRUCTURE SET IN CONCRETE . >' d • - - -- •- r, ....7.....:1/4... ;,„ A ..„, . .„.... . . .. z.....4- ..-„.:.....i4-•••••--,,.:;:„•;7:-.z. -------vv„-: t........._ ;II, _..,-,......mei.,_ .- 1#IIIl !111111I1iII IIIINIIIIIi.,.. - �j}y��ft, _ , 1 r �� •Carolyn guinea __ ._. ...--._ ..... .. . �.,... w k,., - yy +.sax r- .,.. rr- L _ '�:=... :'' ;-_ -4A` ,. -yes,,,, ^`'c ,..- +3 t E +Ss ' - ` , g3 F 1. r r r 7 g9e. i e i R yt k r%� < r 111 Q-74-:''''1 I '':: r !`: 13. I ����� �tr 1 '111111 Ai 9 .� �y , Nor. i�! FII ti [IL ,_ . p,1. • ' a a, _. r am.,' • $*4 aF,,r fir.:-., �' . ' r .o.k 3-.w - , k { ig '9so {r tie&01 TIER tTYPICAu '`yes '9• °�s RIM EL•19.89' ` • E. NW 5th AVENUE ow I►.=15.53'OrR.C.PJ IV c - ''.6 2'VALLEY r; q: 4 <9.,le 42.15- e. iiv . '�� -----w[PLATED WEST LOT1.>NE • '9 �'s---9- 9 0r 20 - �p« coNc.Wax NOO°00'22"�'°ea I'00.O0' �a O, is, !!{9 t 1 cosi.b813S s ;) C30SS IAPPARENT'3S t/MI TAKD fl 5 _ ', ' NJIS 11 aASPHALT PAHICKG\ i•2 `1°�2 ' m i % iP?C o w A tl?• cam wax 'Do • -rb 2 ''s y ao• v I , 7.9' g SLO• __... Ir ---..,--.-..,. ° ^.. - Q� . .S 2�4'. ..7, a Q O ,51 p N l it r' 1 _ g $ 7 C ( 1 — En. =a cow. i �cb c3, 0 ,modb O ,'0 F7.8' ! eq.., ..a S I 1_,6 ` �,/1 8S' Y4.P l g 4.1'- ' i 4.0• 7.1' ':` — © p 2 STORY BUILDING p eo • = (APARTMENTS) = I . FF.9...21.03 2 • LOTo r'o,4 CONC. WALK i j 0 `�i r30 ' _� LOT 5 '.REPLAT OF PART OF ''' 'Cp. BLOCK 2T. TOWN OF LINT.Y" - ' ' ' (P.B..21.PG:4$.P.B.d.R.) A ' • Ow . 11' va y ps'• >O �— on--III G W pM4'.----Ow UW Qyy �% OW 0t�' 206'l f I 1 I - 1' co?.; SOO°00'220W 1,20/ . s 10O.O0' . �. 16' ALLEY (NOT PAVED) �r VALLEY GUTTER(TYPICAL) <` AGENDA -07 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Meeting Date: March 18, 2009 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Delray Beach CRA, Property Owner; MacLaren Sign Co., Authorized Agent. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for a freestanding sign. V. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. COA Approval Matrix Discuss Staff's proposed revisions to the matrix, for clarification purposes only. B. HPB Award Categories Discuss additional types of categories as previously discussed by the Board. Note: Award consideration to take place at a future meeting. VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Board Members • Staff VII. ADJOURN anw E. Ctiva cez Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: March 13, 2009 SA0.47 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD March 18, 2009 MEETING COMMENCED: 6:0 P.M. /A) Pi IV.A. V.A. NAME ATTEND COA 133 NW 5th Avenue COA Approval Matrix VOTE ROGER COPE JOANNE PEART I TOM STANLEY T DEL FIANDRA DAN SLOAN RHONDA SEXTON tA ��c MEETING ADJOURNED: P.M. DELLRAY BEACH O R D A Illii AII-America City I 1993 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2001 Regular Historic Preservation Board Meeting March 18, 2009 PRINT FULL NAME ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION '0 °'t. AGENDA 0�`�.a`,. �P HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Meeting Date: March 18, 2009 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Delray Beach CRA, Property Owner; MacLaren Sign Co., Authorized Agent. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for a freestanding sign. V. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. COA Approval Matrix Discuss Staff's proposed revisions to the matrix, for clarification purposes only. B. HPB Award Categories Discuss additional types of categories as previously discussed by the Board. Note: Award consideration to take place at a future meeting. VI. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Board Members • Staff VII. ADJOURN anuj E. GU?ttouterz Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: March 13, 2009 GM201I06 City Of Delray Beach Florida 9/28/09 Accounts Payable Transaction 13:38:10 Group number • 5748 Accounting period . . . : 12/2009 mm/yyyy I ling date • 09/30/2009 mm/dd/yyyy Transaction date 09/30/2009 mm/dd/yyyy Invoice number • 09/24/2009 Account number • 332-4164-572 .40-10 TRAVEL & TRAINING Project number Amount • 634.59 Liquidated amount . . . : .00 Discount amount .00 Retainage amount • .00 Net transaction amount . : 634.59 Voucher number • 001038 PO number Vendor number • 17985 MCDONNELL, MARK Description 1 TRAVEL PER DIEM TO ATTEND Description 2 • APA FLORIDA ANNUAL CONFER Transaction type code . F3=Exit F12=Cancel F15=Group Inquiry F20=Imagi GM201I06 City Of Delray Beach Florida 9/28/09 Accounts Payable Transaction 13 :38 :10 Group number 5748 Accounting period . . . : 12/2009 mm/yyyy ! _ing date • 09/30/2009 mm/dd/yyyy Transaction date • 09/30/2009 mm/dd/yyyy Invoice number • 09/24/2009 Account number • 332-4164-572.40-10 TRAVEL & TRAINING Project number Amount 634 .59 Liquidated amount . . . : . 00 Discount amount . 00 Retainage amount . 00 Net transaction amount . : 634 .59 Voucher number • 001038 PO number Vendor number • 17985 MCDONNELL, MARK Description 1 • TRAVEL PER DIEM TO ATTEND Description 2 • APA FLORIDA ANNUAL CONFER Transaction type code . F3=Exit F12=Cancel F15=Group Inquiry F20=Imagi Planning & Zoning Department MEMORANDUM , .„ TO: Historic Preservation Board Members FROM: Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner DATE: March 13, 2009 RE: COA Approval Matrix Please review the attached proposed changes to the COA Approval Matrix. Changes are proposed which intend to clarify the existing matrix. However, all components of the matrix may be discussed at Wednesday's meeting. � aQ ....„,j.... ..p.,i, L..),416611 .,/) .Z/44,802/1-1-' ,. ault,p0 c,r,-)271220-46'K, HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD COA APPROVAL MATRIX _-, � NIIIII.IPII�'� _ ,._.- °; .A- Contributing Non-Contributing Action N/A Staff Board N/A Staff Board Additions X X Accessory Structure(Less than 50 square feet) X X Accessory Structure(More than 50 square feet) X` X Awnings(New Installation or Type/Size Change) 0 (,K) X Color Change X \— X IA" Deck(New or Replacement) X X i ]'��tN Decorative Shutters(New or Replacement) ,;) jag {n.> X X Try-- Demolitions jX X " Dock X X Dock with Structure _ X X Doors,Alteration/Material Change of X X Driveways, Installation of X X Exterior Surfaces, In-Kind Repair of (Siding, Stucco, Etc.) X X X X Exterior Surfaces,Alteration/Material Change of(Siding.Stucco,Etc.) X X Fences,Walls, Gates X X Fountains(Visible from Street) _ X X Hurricane Shutters X X Material Change(Unless otherwise specified) X X New Construction X X Patio X X Roof, Material Change of X X Roof, Re-roof or Like Kind Repair of X X Signs, New and/or Alterations of Existing X X Signs,Alterations of Existing (New Sign X X Face,no change in size,material or type) — — Site Lighting, Replacement of X X Site Lighting, New Installation of X X Swimming Pool X X (Located in Front Yard or containing Features measuring 1'above grade) Swimming Pool,Alteration/Installation of X X Windows, New Installation of or New Configuration/Type of existing 4,' A_ Windows, Replacement of Existing (Material Change] k,a )` Xi .4. Ns Requote : ests not appropriately covered by the Historic Preservation Guidelines or this matrix may be referred to Staff or the Historic Preservation Board. Any Certificate Of Appropriateness permitted to be administratively approved by Staff may be referred to the Historic Preservation Board at the Planning and Zoning Department's discretion. evised:03/2009 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD COA APPROVAL MATRIX Action Contributing Non-Contributing N/A Staff Board N/A Staff` Board Additions X X Accessory Structure(Less than 50 square feet) X X Accessory Structure(More than 50 square feet) X X Awnings(New Installation) X X Color Change X X Deck X X Decorative Shutters X X Demolitions X X Dock X X Dock with Structure X X Doors,Alteration of X X Driveways,Installation of X X Exterior Surfaces, In-Kind Repair of (Siding,Stucco, Etc.) X X X X Exterior Surfaces,Alteration of(Siding,Stucco,Etc.) X X Fences,Walls,Gates X X Fountains(Visible from Street) X X Hurricane Shutters X X Material Change X X New Construction X X Patio X X Roof,Material Change of X X Roof,Re-roof or Like Kind Repair of X X Signs,New and/or Alterations of Existing X X Site Lighting,Replacement of X X Site Lighting,New Installation of X X Swimming Pool, Located in Front Yard or containing Features measuring X X 1'above grade Swimming Pool,Alteration/Installation of X X Notes: Requests not appropriately covered by the Historic Preservation Guidelines or this matrix may be referred to Staff or the Historic Preservation Board. Any Certificate Of Appropriateness permitted to be administratively approved by Staff may be referred to the Historic Preservation Board. Revised:09/2008 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD COA APPROVAL MATRIX Contributing Non-Contributing Action N/A Staff Board N/A Staff Board Additions X X Accessory Structure(Less than 50 square feet) X X Accessory Structure(More than 50 square feet) X X Awnings(New Installation) X X Color Change X X Deck X X Decorative Shutters X X Demolitions X X Dock X X Dock with Structure X X Doors,Alteration of X X Driveways, Installation of X X Exterior Surfaces, In-Kind Repair of (Siding,Stucco, Etc.) X X X X Exterior Surfaces,Alteration of(Siding,Stucco, Etc.) X X Fences,Walls,Gates X X Fountains(Visible from Street) X X Hurricane Shutters X X Material Change X X New Construction X X Patio X X Roof, Material Change of X X Roof, Re-roof or Like Kind Repair of X X Signs, New and/or Alterations of Existing X X Site Lighting, Replacement of X X Site Lighting, New Installation of X X Swimming Pool, Located in Front Yard or containing Features measuring X X 1'above grade Swimming Pool,Alteration/Installation of X X Notes: Requests not appropriately covered by the Historic Preservation Guidelines or this matrix may be referred to Staff or the Historic Preservation Board. Any Certificate Of Appropriateness permitted to be administratively approved by Staff may be referred to the Historic Preservation Board. Revised:09/2008 ??? s _ I 7 al J4/2/4J404. - . afr-e)/4 Pcxn- ,/72, )-Lf2.6_2', 12- - ezT c92 19 _ re /7 zc ,vp /lean -imfariti cdos log — \ E'er Jy'^/ ,...2_g___S _ _ - T7'/ .t / o', - /- . 61/-- ( .‘• ...- •''Th i/'-"L 't..1 *. r , - - 4 C ,-' v /6°' c (`:7e..--- `1 , --. . /// - - 1' .7_)/eiteLd k--/-*--) • C 191 -‘,-.2---- - . 0_ ,7/ C ak ^eel J1 - 6 / ,,. - 0)24 ‘ — �20 ./(_.2,,_ o-) t9c)-7 •N /c2 „dc-t7 6 ,/t1 .04 3/4 / ij CZ- /// ›Ci5142:* 187201 ,„-/- D./ c L ) • ,desi-t6 /ex.. -841 :c-f-d>frikatg 7</An - ) azw14117, // 4_12 • / G (2f ) c(4, /62 ,$11 Jdv c7)j z< . -a- ) 7 1 /1 i' : -,46 //,' , •-'Lli.°F.-..A-ANII,10. r.-- 7A74(i)_ _ . e _JoariP - Ltri%Ily-W_AA- 2' v / _ ,', . ai9v0 Aw..., ir) --, - / q Q C/ _______*._40000:, ./ , . %al__ c‘i,..\ _t aq i ,-Jiiiall, __,, /• /".' 4 .- / &,ze-,„,) � 0" i/ . • IP . e._----" —I /7 c==:.------r/.....)e C..----1 e... eaL • , akedief±:C.--) . ' ; 24øi ,a4a442.94p0( ) ) 12 _Ct41Q (ach,AA______ N /'" &P-s-Vegeui) 0 1 ;/, "// �� � ED a. l 'f a c i- 4110,41 -- - -- / / "7/ ,/te- L. --Le-A77LAA- 17?,,,,4 , Q I/001z, }} ._ cam • ) o��,