The URL can be used to link to this page

HPB-12-02-09 60 OA AGENDA 0`fit � HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Meeting Date: December 2, 2009 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. REGULAR MEETING AGENDA I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 103 NW 3 r d Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Bryce Newell, Property Owners; City of Delray Beach, Authorized Agent. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness and waiver request (2010-013) associated with a fence and arbor. VII. ADJOURN WORKSHOP AGENDA I. DISCUSSION ITEM (Non-Action) Review of the Old School Square Historic District resurvey completed in January 2009 with additional discussion relative to the district's history and designation, and an overview of surveyed properties, benefits of historic preservation, and incentive programs. Notice was provided to all property owners within the district regarding this item. II. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Board Members • Staff III. ADJOURN anw a atUmez Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: November 25, 2009 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD December 2, 2009 MEETING COMMENCED: 6:07 P.M MEETING ADJOURNED: 8:00 P.M. IV.A. NAME ATTEND 103 NW 3rd Avenue COA Waiver- Fence Waiver-Arbor Approved 6 to 0 Approved 6 to 0 Approved 6 to 0 ROGER COPE TOM STANLEY T DEL FIANDRA Seconded Seconded RHONDA SEXTON Made Motion Made Motion Made Motion DAN SLOAN ABSENT DARLA SERNOFF Seconded PAM REEDER DELRAY BEACH tigacci eiN All-America City 1 I 1993 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2001 Regular Historic Preservation Board Meeting December 2, 2009 PRINT FULL NAME ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION exrcva 40-4,?,7/c GP k LI e ,sc.. j 3 ' NE I rTAvf oiK1 ,K1U P A A41 37 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD ORDER In Re: 211 NW 1st Street/103 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District Bryce Newell and Jodie MacLellan, Property Owners Dennis Thompson, City of Delray Beach, Authorized Agent ORDER Following consideration of all the evidence and testimony presented at the December 2, 2009 meeting before the Historic Preservation Board for the City of Delray Beach and Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1)(c), fences and walls over four feet shall not be allowed in front or side street setbacks. The Historic Preservation Board finds that there is ample and competent substantial evidence to support its findings that the application for Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness and waiver associated (2 1 - 013) with a fence on a contributing structure on the property referenced above is hereby granted denied by a vote of 5- Pursuant to LDR Sections 2.4.7(E)(1) and 2.4.7(E)(3)(a), a decision of the Historic Preservation Board may be appealed to the City Commission so long as a letter of appeal is received by the City Clerk within ten(10)working days of the a do�. • g appe.lea. Based on the entire record before it, the Historic Pr, :y'r'.Lion Bola• i d/,•t• Order this 2nd day of December 2009. I ilk Chai Jl Histo is Prese :t • ' :• copies to: Bryce Newell and Jodie MacLellan Dennis Thompson HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD December 2, 2009 MEETING COMMENCED: 6:e)/P.M. IV.A. Old School Square Historic District NAME ATTEND 103 NW 3rd Avenue atia VOTE 6 , 0 C b ROGER COPE f' TOM STANLEY T DEL FIANDRA I � (9/fu1., RHONDA SEXTON / 7JW912 49 DANSAz .4-Zr ' A / / / / /' / / /7 DARLA SERNOFF I 02triL PAM REEDER f 2 -3-0. .%- //n/e, MEETING ADJOURNED: P.M. '401 Itvew Alks : , �/�r;4-' %fir,e HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD December 2, 2009 MEETING COMMENCED: 6:07 P.M MEETING ADJOURNED: 8:00 P.M. IV.A. x 00 (F —U v NAME ATTEND 103 NW 3rd Avenue COA Waiver - Fence Waiver - Arbor Approved 6 to 0 Approved 6 to 0 Approved 6 to 0 ROGER COPE TOM STANLEY T DEL FIANDRA Seconded Seconded RHONDA SEXTON Made Motion Made Motion Made Motion DAN SLOAN ABSENT DARLA SERNOFF Seconded PAM REEDER Old School Square Hisoric HISTORIC CONTEXT • Contains the earliest standing structures in the City of Delray Beach. • Rather than a homogeneous area in its chronology or architectural typology, presents a glimpse of the historical continuum of the community. • Contains buildings from every decade since the 1890s, from a wide array of architectural styles: Vernacular, Queen Anne and Bahamian influences, Bungalows, Mission, Mediterranean Revival, Art Deco/Moderne, Minimal Traditional, and some International Style inspiration. • Uses have included residential, commercial, offices, institutional, religious, governmental, recreational, educational and cultural functions. •Layering and variety of building types and uses that provide the basis for the district's significance. • Many early residential structures converted to light commercial and office uses, providing an opportunity to survive amidst the development pressures of their current urban environment. • The newly found niche of these historical resources within a modern context has also brought about a renaissance for many of them, as their conversion to commercial and office uses have brought along substantial rehabilitation, for the most part sympathetic, of their historic fabric. r „Mikillgallm...443Vaigatzhrdim,ELTIM17,MILV!!".2,52557¢M,..51:31S14..h6J1111-112,,,,,%-.:ruitt''' ,„..1,11.&."./.!--tAtt,,,t7,761M-ai.lt!tt,,,,QTEL,c=1,21Z11112.Tn-1.1,..-.4,..:1,f,t,...t.:..i..L.=/J.,f1,17,,,,IT7,171,7,Vit,L1111111,,,),:,01,...11,MI,V1 . 1• InneaVi"swaitir"7"1 e, 1. 0 . .— ad Scho _ Square His .oritc District 1[ _ 1.... POST I 4; • . Ti •• OFRCE s CASON •••.. .*•*.•:. METHODIST ,;7-0,,:i CHURCH BRE .:•;.•;.• " •••• IRON 1 Designated February 9, 1988 by Ordinance 1-88. tm t . pans I 1 L. — , sow VI=IRRIA D f,'•," r-'-'''. : ,;•::•:•WM •:,•••:. .-;,:- ,...;.-,- II-Olt if----7---- --::, ::::: - . Iiimiliii. - ATTORNEY EN REHR • 4.'," r . 1 r.. , ,47. . ' -: aulaNG ; ... 4 lel'- .: .. ,,..;/....,?! ...,.., . . .'-'- : '.. A . . tr? . ,- • M 1111 i.:. - ..:' :'t,IJ: gm :: : ,, I.11111 — .... • • . CONTRIBUTING-1998 DESIGNATION HALL t , 111 . -, - New-coNTRIBuTING , , _ .,..• .„.., : ,,,,,r,c,.,,,..,,, :.,El ', , . - - • .-,---..t,...,5.,,,;,,,t,-; t cesetwerr .. , ,t3.--,,t.,;,,A;;$,, ..* ' .,-,-• IP AP . CONTRIBUTING-2009 RESURVEY . . . t ., . . , 1,...,:iti• 4,!:..,...,,ri.4.-„,:.,,,,,,,,,, . . , , . t 4 ' ,,,,,-.... ;3•46.,p.r,c; IM • . . If .;.. ,'*-wife. . .,. : „. •:,11 • : -..,: ,.. EXPANSION . - j' 16 iitiiii.'o.ii'-- • , - r: L._ . it •'are -sE l' .- -sr. , ! ',4,, 11111 ' ' , 1.•:•:1:1 , ., . - ,. ,.. r in 7,71:i=,-;1, -, . , . ,, Ill II, , ', . ,. m ...!' 'Ealing' • 11111 {,,,ali.1.1r, - •!...M IN , _ .. ,, . , .. , S . . -AIM IN11.931N1Wiiiii Iwo t.) I= t,,t,:gr.mu.,,,,- ....,...., NI , . . . .- miii •:: ..!.:•!•1 • . - WM IT It ." Ili.' $ • . ;-,•••ii_5.; , '. ... I •;•:: Area recommended ': .. . ... . , .. . ,,.. . . — - tA ' Ns , Boundary for Boundary ;', ....... . _ .1.!?,i,t :.,... ' Map - 111fil Expansion m........ _- __., ,. ....._,. .„ ,, aid Sclool Square HitQric is:rict ❖ 2009 Resurvey Recommendations o Expand Period of Significance to 1965 o Reclassify 23 Properties from non-contributing to contributing o Seek listing of the district on the National Register of Historic Places o Consider extending the district's southern boundary to SW 4th Street. ❖ Period of Significance o Guidebook: When identifying the historic context and significance of a historic district, the stages of growth in the neighborhood are labeled as "Periods of Significance." The character of a house constructed in the early twentieth century is vastly different than the character of one constructed during the 1930s and 1940s. While both houses illustrate an evolution, and are all more than 50 years old, each belongs to a specific time frame in history and each period of significance has its singular importance and special characteristics. Properties in historic districts must relate to the periods of significance that are documented in the historic district nomination. o National Register of Historic Places - SIGNIFICANCE: A district must be significant, as well as being an identifiable entity. . .must be important for historical, architectural, archeological, engineering, or cultural values. Therefore, districts that are significant will usually meet the last portion of Criterion C plus Criterion A, Crion B, other portions of Criterion Still. Criterion D. i Old School Square Historic District PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE • Development patterns show construction gap between the 1960s and 1990s when few if any new structures were built within the district. •. Date of construction of the most recent structures around 1955, indicating surge in construction activity immediately following end of World War II. • Field inspection of the district did not identify additional structures being built between 1955 and the mid 1990s to the early part of the 2000 decade. Existing structures did undergo alterations and in some cases additions, but the level of construction activity was relatively low during this period. •Reflects general development trend of most communities at this time, when post World War II development movement was away from the city's center and into the suburbs. -Delray Beach necessitated the rapid construction of affordable homes; local builders employed masonry construction (concrete block and other sturdy and easy-to-use materials). A number of examples of Masonry Vernacular buildings are found in the Old School Square area. • Extending the present Period of Significance to 1960 would cover new construction and alterations that will be 50 years old in less than 2 years from the date of resurvey, namely in 2010. • Appropriate to extend the Period of Significance an additional 5 years, to 1965, in order to provide a comfortable margin to include any construction activity, including alterations or additions that will acquire the 50 threshold using this time frame. Old School Square Historic isLrid National Register of Historic Places. SIGNIFICANCE: o . . .considered eligible if all of the components lack individual distinction, provided that the grouping achieves significance as a whole within its historic context. . .the majority of the components that add to the district's historic character, even if they are individually undistinguished, must possess integrity, as must the district as a whole. o The number of noncontributing properties a district can contain yet still convey its sense of time and place and historical development depends on how these properties affect the district's integrity. ❖ National Register of Historic Places - EVALUATING CONTEXT & SIGNIFICANCE: o . . .historical patterns that can be identified through consideration of the history of the property and the history of the surrounding area. In accordance with the National Register Criteria, the historic context may relate to one of the following: •An event, a series of events or activities, or patterns of an area's development (Criterion A); •Association with the life of an important person (Criterion B); •A building form, architectural style, engineering technique, or artistic values, based on a stage of physical development, or the use of a material or method of construction that shaped the historic identity of an area (Criterion C); or •A research topic (Criterion D). • Old Scaool Squre. His±oric DjsTrid Old School Square meets the National Register Criteria as follows: o Criterion A- An event, a series of events or activities, or patterns of an area's development: due to associations with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad pattern of the City's history as it represents the initial footprint for settlement and development of Delray Beach, with structures existing as early as the late 1890's, contains the Old School Square and Sundy House which are listed on the National. Register of Historic Places, represents the 1920s Land Boom and 1930s settlement following the Land Boom and includes post World War II growth from the 1940s through the 1960s. o Criterion B- Association with the life of an important person: due to associations with people significant to the City, such as John Shaw Sundy, Delray's first mayor, one of the early investors was Frederick Henry Link, Reverend John R. Cason, the Methodist Church Minister and Delray Beach pioneer. o Criterion C- A building form, architectural style, engineering technique, or artistic values, based on a stage of physical development, or the use of a material or method of construction that shaped the historic identity of an area: embodies one or more distinctive architectural styles or types such as the Mission, Queen Anne, French Colonial, Mediterranean Revival, Bungalow, American Four Square, Monterey, Neo-Mediterranean, Minimal Traditional, Masonry and Frame Vernacular, Ranch, Art Deco/Modern, Bauhaus, and International, with structures designed by renown Architect Samuel Ogren, Sr. Old School Square I- iisoric Dis:rict ❖ Historic Context - Local, State, and National o A local historic context represents an aspect of the history of a town, city, county, cultural area, or region, or any portions thereof. o Properties are evaluated in a State context when they represent an aspect of the history of the State as a whole. o Properties are evaluated in a national context when they represent an aspect of the history of the United States and its territories as a whole. These national historic contexts may have associated properties that are locally or statewide significant representations, as well as those of national significance. ❖ Criteria Considerations: Certain kinds of properties are not usually considered for listing in the National Register: religious properties, moved properties, birthplaces and graves, cemeteries, reconstructed properties, commemorative properties, and properties achieving significance within the past fifty years. These properties can be eligible for listing, however, if they meet special requirements, called Criteria Considerations, in addition to meeting the regular requirements (that is, being eligible under one or more of the four Criteria and possessing integrity). Old School Scuare Historic isric ..,., .:...... ......:. ....:....�. ., ,a.:..., ....: .;,,:.. ...:.::a.4 .. .. ,:.. , _..,. ,.:;'{A..a.,. .... yr„ ,..wa a. ,.......r . .. .. ..,.,,...... b,. ..._. .. . CRITERIA CONSIDERATION G: PROPERTIES THAT HAVE ACHIEVED SIGNIFICANCE WITHIN THE LAST FIFTY YEARS ❖ POST-WORLD WAR II PROPERTIES: Properties associated with the post-World War II era must be identified and evaluated to determine which ones in an area could be judged exceptionally important. For example, a post-war suburban subdivision may be the best reflection Of contemporary siting and design tenets in a metropolitan area...the nomination preparer must justify the exceptional importance of the property relative to similar properties in the community, State, or nation. ❖ HISTORIC DISTRICTS: ...eligible if they are an integral part of a district which qualifies for National Register listing...documenting that the property dates from within the district's defined Period of Significance and that it is associated with one or more of the district's defined Areas of Significance. Properties less than fifty years old may be an integral part of a district when there is sufficient perspective to consider the properties as historic...by demonstrating that: 1) the district's Period of Significance is justified as a discrete period with a defined beginning and end, 2) the character of the district's historic resources is clearly defined and assessed, 3) specific resources in the district are demonstrated to date from that discrete era, and 4) the majority of district properties are over fifty years old. In these instances, it is not necessary to prove exceptional importance of either the district itself or the less- than-fifty-year-old properties. Exceptional importance still must be demonstrated for district where the majority of properties or.the major Period of Significance is less than fifty years old, and for less-than fifty-year-old properties which are nominated individually. ... . _ _ _ _ ______ .... . _. _ _ __ . _ ,. Old School Square Historic J s- ric Minimal Traditional } - ' • During Great Depression, style developed as a compromise ��yreflecting traditional forms with minimal decorative details. ,. tFdr[e.....z.; i Ij � 4 "0 i ,�,o,,,, , • As housing became affordable and new building technologies .�},, ' s ip, ,�, ,C i4,,`.,$, . j allowed for prefabrication and mass production, simpler homes. "I,t.6\ '�t" ,A #°:'• j j `'4Y -- • Inspired. by Tudor cottages popular during 1920s - 1930s; SF ' Fs` x , , : wI�� F� w: reflected •in dominant front gable on main elevation. 1 r � uP-- -' ,--`.e-- ° ' , x , z • Symmetrical plan, clapboard or stucco exterior partially faced '. .' � w• fa`,s� ; .s � r ' 4 ti with stone/rock/brick at times; one-story, single or concrete tile roof material, shutters and cornerboards. • Typical details include low to medium pitch gable roofs facing front, modest overhangs, prominent chimneys, decorative wood ,' ;''°'< details or vents on gable ends, inset porches supported on 4' , . ,. decorative wood supports and sparsely used Colonial or other :;,., , traditional applied decoration, such as door and window i r _ �2 - surrounds. ,M `" 4 • Most popular immediatelybefore and after WWII. . . . _ ,� � � • pp • Illustrates transition in residential design from period just `" r ' 1 before World War II through the 1950s. M,, y n,, '.+ ,+4! .Fes A.r. .,_ • A number of Minimal Traditional-style houses are present in ' the Old School Square Historic District. 0 laOldl Square Hisoric Dis:rict r .wh+;:.x .r .;..:...:, w x.::-.._..^ ..e«,:..aa w .....;:!'n. ':-..1. .. .. ...a.,..:n, t .xe.r,ts'7,rY,7Ytjfl. :4+.R.*.'..ff*? ry ...s., . <f^ .. .:.i.F,., S.c .v tw;•..-.n -;x. .n'a2cr .. ... s ., Frame Vernacular Masonry Vernacular uis,.. .w.. `, •-' X:.:z. ,,. a y 4r0,\,, ,, i! v� i,l}ji it� .i f JJ 1 v +i�'.. l.,., , t yy/�$ -r r q'Jr �i I ('<7 d 1 1 : r ," v` `"A li# 4t:'r"l.14, ' + jai ``+ i L s)� � i } y + ,k:R `„4''^" �-0y� �ff _i u ,, 6"W.,,-4, 17,.. lt1'. lic by `�i,iii {�� !f.,t � �ey9d R;; t Ii,�: ( , j f' ,1 04- fink , 5 ' `,.1,' ' I F A , .i^1 '' — g - I-,,'I *::.-0 , z.,.; s;' ,la.s '',, ft4t!IL, • i1 tY +a � 4 S +c ,L 4 { t 11, it 1 , r. w r.,i.,,, ✓+f . .. t , ,,,..�-.i i yi:�sext t t * 1 , 1 W s.,xi- v zr.a 4..x 1 w�W�'t t, t. .c.s r f2' . i° ,tt, ii, : t `k "Sa'+'` �.rx 7 ti st 5 Ma+ vr"' {`.,t -1-- �, ' � Fx`4: ..,f' e n t� i4`�,'" T+v £ k yyLx f'Y R ; .f ,M r< . ,::-..,,i�Y`t r� w"' ` s .+, �^�>< it9 R ti SY a T} c h Ya. � a Y � k �i t. r • Hipped or gable roofs, a gable-end façade, open • Competed w/ frame construction pre-1950. or screened front porches with a hipped or gable • Primarily constructed of brick prior to 1930s. roof, and a central entrance. After WWII, concrete or cinder block used • Craftsman-style inspired architectural details i most frequently. often found in Florida's frame vernacular houses, 1 • Finished with stucco, brick veneer, stone include exposed rafter tails & knee braces at the i veneer, and tile. house corners or below porch roofs. 1 • Influenced by Mission and Art Deco Florida • Usually sided with weatherboard; sometimes 1 trends. trimmed with contrasting corner boards. 1 • By 1940s, typically built with L-plan: side • Built in Delray Beach beginning in the late 19th gabled main block w/ shallow projecting ell on century; continued in popularity into the 1950s. front & shallow front porch, similar to the • Later houses often feature elements of Minimal popular Ranch style. Traditional architecture or Colonial Revival-style • Decorative cutout vents on gable ends. details at the doors and windows. i .. 0 . 1_ >,.,.L 0— d Sc-aoo-� aths:oric r,>.... 4 •,'.>...... ,x...,.., ....a::...;e.t:. „seer.,- ..-t.. _+:..:a k.._., �. .>..._..._ ,w.,.rn�.::.vas...,-..::.::. ........ r.. ..._ _..'..,n...,..,, Properties Proposed for Reclassification fl '.s'� ` ' Address: 131 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1950 J,y ,� Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular L. iit. �#' to s �o7�h, . �.. , �I _ , r ,t , . ', ;Evaluation: ...contributes to the district as a T ` '} , E V...' � y ,x . representative example of domestic architecture from the ,,� i• t period of significance. g district s e o i n i el i ' Y j \I ‘. lt-''' ' kte4r, '"s•. .1 4, g P, <, +M�1�8, Div �+ , ;,i♦ .u4*yes.�.�..yr• !l, 7" ,,awl s � t.... 'A'�� -... � , i +4% . 1: 9 ,,� '., i i s '0. '�• M t .,i, 3+ 'i t '; a � iy i 4 .ice '_`¢f y n- r'e Ril lilt , f 1 N "j k�. I y�14 � • 9 r IIIIIN 'i irbw C !$ ..,A.,�I , '`1,•el r ,.L74, , f _... y� 1 isF41 rya a>„a t �^7 � , 1 : '� { KMI■ � �.i ':e � � i�� i � �j r F• ,t,, r r ', 1/.. it ,.,a' { : t . d44% , 1 l h ) yr 7 a r ! y .L fi i R ..' G� 05 4 x �y� z l• ..... ... .._ ..f _.:. i ". ... t +rY Y.i 1. `` _ T Address: 302 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1945 - • '"�rroo �r�c �r All Breeds 2164081� .- '`' , CA • Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular/Contemporary `; "{ , , ' ` 'fg , ,, Evaluation: 2001: ...associated w/ developmental r » .. ,w.-- ',';, n x , .'=-4 history & exhibits architectural elements of Old r" _ti a - k-, . j , t� r� %' Y ,i '' `'i' ' School Square area during 1940s. Due to historical & , architectural significance...could contribute...when the historic district is re-evaluated & the POS is expanded to include later historic resources. 2005 Continued... 2005: ...conveys historic architectural character and to the surrounding historic district. 2008: Contributes to character of historic district association with Delray Beach history. It warrants individual local designation only. Plus, it contributes through its stylistic features and scale. 1111 _i_ ou _ HistoricOldh a Jistrict b.., ,'1:....i .,�'.. ,,,:_�L... ..t.:ivti... _;..a: v ...... .1 R' .M ..1.. }- '..,f.) ..t '�'.'l.L - w '.Ii0.l`I.. `'L6 ie.,.:. .;.�:�. '^' .. ✓2. !. a`u.A.•.. ...v..�.Y�'. Properties Proposed for Reclassification Y '' Address: 326 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1945 '..'t 4.1 ,r. Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular : ,j.;: x• ;' ,� 7 '��; s,." - .I Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient �� 1 _` ' ,r;' architectural distinction for individual designation and 1 - s :`� 4 NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a l tea; T„•. i1 4 11 til;4 representative example of domestic architecture from the ` '' ,"r fir# �� I ; district's period of significance. .� ";' `" `' " .' 1 4'Ir`w?ri`v� ";"Iz�4*$ «w.P'', i i Note. City Building Records note 1928 construction; 1949 Sanborn • Y' '� v ',' St 410 ,,, •tt7! ',Iv t { `. �y,� Y, YL t `�+'4. `t j .-ctpt , X,a: Insurance Mapshows existingfootprint Staff cannot verify1945 '`6'j ' k ' 1,; , } i t`'` ' date. 1988 designation mapindicates 1957, likelyfrom Property [.,-..,,'„,.,,,...,.,* ii t :Y� ` ,,„„t �,, �k ; . 4 Appraisers Office. Staff has found that this date is frequently an , <. ,, ,,n .4i f t. , C incorrect one when noted by the Property Appraisers office. r L t g , 4 `* . r jj{1 T[S �F, v t i <. of r ; N 'Q, t c� < �,+,o its Address: 342 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1946 - I = , R} • t° Al:t t f- +1 ' ' y'a; Architectural Style: Minimal Traditional '. ,. J Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient - , :;� • J4 110M architectural distinction for individual designation and 1 °'�•,r , ,'„ �`,,# �,, ,: a ,+ _ t w , Q NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a 4 r .� ' ,� .4 . N., ,, ` ,, :'' representative` example of domestic architecture from the .,- r��` �' p �. , district's period of significance. k t k' i'K }� a ,; - � 4 ,,,pay, 9=19 i9,919=9 Old -, 10 0 - ._ Sc ioo Square H s oilic District Properties Proposed for Reclassification 114t T Year Built: 1950 ,,,,f,44,1,, ... le:i• 1\'\t\IX`011,1 Address: 235 NW 1st Avenue .--- ; Ipiii \ .m ki I \‘it Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular ,,,..6 ',., ,— .'' Is. i,..s.'", '•,. ,,,- ,•:,,,,, Prx•ifiii,,, A . ;V:11.1,,l'A.,,, , .\ ,.1' •',:. ' ,!:.;. ..i.i.r, ,,,„.; , ., ' .,. , .', ,,ii tot' qt, Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks 0 e,0 1„,-',- -- d:eqe f ,• ' • ',0-5.4r1s l'i) '''''I' ' ' ''1 '4":C' --:;- s''''' i - . . .‘ '''...:441t•J''''''''':' ' .. 1' sufficient architectural distinction and „..,.:.„,-.., ,,,,,i • .. •,,,, .. , , ..,r. f ( ,. ,1 1,,, signi historical ::...,,..'' '''1:4CW,.. •,..";: 1,;?ti-ci,----;#--,Ak‘: ,,,..1 11' 116 '' ,c " '/1 ' '' " ' 'ficance for individual designation and NRHP Ali , ,... 14, _-__1.___ CI-A -";•,.., ..., „, , -,„ ,1 ;(411.kfloA • • • ' - '"' ....4 p,'• ::_. • ''''fi. - --.."'-k / listing, it contributes to the surrounding historic district '''''....'1'''-''''''.- ''' "r" ' \'''''''''' ' ''7 ''''''''''' 1/II.'Ili'''. •' ' ' through its architechtre. 2008: Contributes to character `-i ,`,,,•`:-1-'-'1-'11';',"'.-2::-=.„,..„'„1„,'I'' - -, of district through its sense of scale. : 11;1'..-..4.44 : .ity)2 ',1:611,4j%''' ‘', ,444-/T4..214Art,,,,,,,,,.""IC,'2,'1.$2.2 -''-'2,',2`,' '-' Z .•'-' \t!..' fti- w --.,- r,....70 ,,. . :...:-.7- - .!_lAt . , ' - i4,.."-r• -.7,'Nzit..' ' rwit'., "' ,, .": ; •,.t.tire4 4,41'0::,,:-=,•1/4--•--•.- '-.,..„(1-L -,,,,---^-,4 3`Y, -7 F-•:•‘1-!"'. " 2,-*".‘‘s' . 2,--,-2Z,- , -` -•,...:'2'.,.:2--,'' i '.',. '5',17--; t,!..:.,;•' - . - --- 7 - —'.;._+', , , --.„•'.—,?'.-- / - •, -4,,,' 4'.. _ 2...'.7. 2 .. ' „..-r.42i 2 ::'',."2-t. ,,. r'.:;". -'... - '. ' ' •44- •":('i' ;7.- "'' .,..., •‹• . , -;' .•,,'-,L„t:.:`, ' - ..., . L : .st- 7.!** . -„,—,...,':7',......Y..,r'';1';--; ,,'7., 2..1..,.2 z'72"," '2,,""'"'73•„'''...--,--„', '', --:,- , ' ‘--•i'Vr---,r- ,,," Address: 48 SE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1955 . ,,,,,',' - ,___„_____ . , ... ., - ,., ,,-, vt.-, Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular , . ,,. ,,,,, r2c, k,•Ln.. .--, i .Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to character of district ,, . , ,,„ , through its sense of scale. . 7,!;,,,,,,,l,„. - 3r,.-,•,:.4.: ,-'i-;fre 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient ea,fie.417,-, - and ---- - - .-----..-- --..-„:, .., .0 .. . ,-.. , . ,..'s'`..'"i• •-- ., •r- 2 ,;,..s., ." '2' "''. /architectural distinction for individual designation ,,. ,0,,4„_, ,.. ,,,,, ,,, ,,, ,„,, ,,,_•,,_,,,,_,., ,.,,, ,„,„,,,,... ....,,,,,, - „....., m4,-,,...„„ ' A.',.-- . ..,,',,,c, ....,,,,,-,-, . NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a O- T''''Z'''."-}* F:1,,k l';:`,-, '.-;-""''.2;L..\2;.;;'-s-,.-,.5-,..,‘3s,,..,-,_;,.._i-d.,:, 4,-10.ez.-,.- .- ...„ .••,..,, ., ,;,,-J, „.-,,,,, r .1„...)...„1-44-„r'-;`,,s4.."3-,1,',-, i',.-..r.v.,,------1,,,:,-...,-,>,.r,1,'.:.,, ','.----_',.• -. --......',-Y.-ft--'''..-::...,..--.----,",4-i: '''-4.,•from , ,.- ,,,.. , -,,,t"---,1,,,--,," '''' ',.--:, -''',-, ',-t ,•', -, ,...',_, ' ;',;- ,, .--•,',..',,,,-4.,'.-• -`• representative example of domestic architecture . ,,,„.., ti,,,, ,-6:-.1't,,V:r„A, :-s.--4.1..ir ,_.,1,-,?-1,-7-r•-v,,z,..:----i,-..tt.t-t,?•...,, the district's period of significance. _, -, ,;„.,„:.......,*,...,,,,, ...,,,,,,,-.1„;;;,,,,,,„„,,,, :.,„:so 4,,..4.,,,v, _..... • ,,,,,..,.„..,,,,,,..„,,,,,,,,ti/ - '.,.1-41--M•5:4,,z-r- ',..27"Ii•t-,•,,,••t ‘7 i-.,,,,--. t-- ..n.e..011", . • School Square [is :uric Dis ric Properties Proposed for Reclassification '�' "4 ; f �j,' �x sir I op t ;�V { 'r=a` �' Address: 181/z SE 1st Street/102 SE 1st Avenue t er �,f',, , 1 A �: { ,- �Zw �* ° 1 T Y,.,Ay ;1 q �•� i '" S; t;a f �a t , • �,�.� w., asp Year Built.• 1925/55 !jl �� .irL t!; ,` ',,� ; ti .�a: ` ArchitecturalStyle: Frame Vernacular � ►.4, }'f. �* : y ��, y a: valuation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient 14' 4 c 3 r xf. h.,F-e3,{y*., 'ai4 �,? s ' jb y'r!y , ' ti',R"3� r c; ,k . _ `+,ti ^� 'Es.. fit • '. l r- �` `;tf ' architectural distinction for individual designation and L :; ' " NRHP listing, it still contributes to° the district as a .-2,,itk,NI'<.-- _,:-- -- ,,,, ..x.�. •� ty11' �w . °°,: .1. 4 1pp kip ' '.i a' u., y{ t i' r�'� pia' x�. : ,{.,..* 4,�$i ',, ,`S w' ` , tri'4, �'�, ti ; �s �� re resentative exam le of domestic architecture from the tt: •'a . t,,( --N. } , ?'...., :\ ..,,,,I . ,e ,:.. 1 , } �yn'4� e,, district's period of significance. ��y : f , i 1987: Fair Condition. , i ` '° �t��., '" � ` "� V. ' Note: Buildingnoted as 1925,and added onto si nificantl in 1957,with t ��1� it xr tYF a g y K , t ,iloi.fiH, -,a4 . �,�it4g„40.44\m, ; remodeling complete in 1944 and 1950. Identified as a contributor on S y 't q J ,� maC from 1988 ,: .. ,. a c.,:•ttr!i4.i t �' R syj '�a}iL �•��;i` ,}'„S ��,�.�E S��,r«54y rr .'�E�c+.f "*q }, _. ... �, . " If .,�4i yi �� y . r� {° rc ', .-a :,A. 2 4' r' f1, �,;yi:..2 erA t4�i ,1 , 7 I r it 5 l r., T'�. s a; ''; s "' ,!,i l., 't k.#R`',(Y�'" `•t'�' , �• j"'�A. 4A j�' _ A..' '. r y J' 1 eke}. i *+•-.,r, . >.,` a ,` \S. :.°( ! I'1 rid t: 1950 i ,*` � ?411,7n4 i jr, `A .i�3)� ° 'r + . Address. 21 NW 2 Street Year Buil • u r,, N,,, , ' „ '� ,� , ' Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular kr: �. � �� "``�' �` ` _ Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient .; =r h'''�,��; _Li 1:,;, I ' �G:hL architectural distinction and historical significance for }:} ' n" e C • -j!�r + .:• fill T '7:''' 3.a.. „�,��. at r�` individual designation and NRHP •listing, it contributes to { r , �` ' ` �` the surrounding historic district through its architecture. 1 k n i ' ' Note: This buildingwas relocated in 1990 from 106 tiill North Swinton Avenue when the structure at 102 Northwanton venue was enlarged on the North' and converted to' office-use from single w � - family. " '�E•�` �F�"� s 6 o 0 e f ..,_ _ ._ 0- c- SchoolSquare Historic JisLricL Properties Proposed for Reclassification , ,... Address: 15 SW 2nd Street Year Built: 1950 ' . . ,',' Architectural Style: Minimal Traditional Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to the character of the district . . . 1,14f, -, - .1:, through its sense of scale. ,,,,,,,k , ,, ,,,•,.......le,$,-„r- -,,,„-I ` ,,.,,..,-.1/1 .-, - frs?..\4* ) 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient architectural 'r 'I°;''''' ' '''''-. - ,,x4.4nw.,- ' ,-411',.." '''':"" ' ' '• '',4:,' distinction and historical significance for individual i 4.,,.. . ,',", ' '-' '4,,Nri,s1-4t..1...L , i.' ,sb''„•• 4K,-. ° designation and NRHP listing, it contributes to the ii - ' ''' ' • ' ' --L. - ' ', I, ,si surrounding historic district though its architecture. e 1 , .,• . • 1 1 - . 11 4 1 Iii,044;;;;,t4.,,Lt,,,,,,,,ti,,,;',,, ,,%:00-5;•,,,,,2.,,',,';','‘i,41,41;''';',' IRIPVIPloo.:.";,.:',,,,4'7, ';:,',,.,'',i;'„,-,,,,,,',.„,-A,2'-- ' .1,,TrIV*1491.4.ft"rtl'$'4/,`t ICV'r Y.'45:4 '4';‘;f.' fri:47'.i....":-.1- .....-r.'-:".,.,, ,t,'..' ..--..•'''''-'_-, ' ,,, - ''' ; 142t..10.1.. 04...4. AtV'''''',-WI-. • ''''A.'-"'i41,,t-,...f.rit44'4p,p,'":,',4g-i',.;*:,-. ..:44 ..,— 41e 4 4 'Italle, A ,-..-, ...-:;41-i;-?217-Ane.. .5g- '',' t.4:. *.•':$.;t1f14;'.4‘t'a;-:t' ' ' .—__ --- :, -- —„,_,:: ,. „,,,z,,' - ,,,'rs';;;., -".'"dit L' ..."'":"..—'''''''' "-,...',,':...,...-3-,Iilit A,,,i,i sr::,"'y',./.1t1 1.A,,,,..,t -i.....-ik,.., •-:,,_ ,i,./ ,.."'l ''•,' .,e,' * , ' - '';`,7 .., •••:--•-, - -" '1••'''' ':' - . !''.!--,:- ' ' .-. • ,• ,,,V• ,,-'41•11,.,,. ,‘F •••:,.„-?,,,,,,,,P,,:,_,, - , : '''''„ •','.,,' -•'''. — - ' ., - '„ , " ,‘ ,t,#, 4,,' ,.4--,‘ til,y,h.'4"--•CI,, r.,,,„14,,,,,,. 4 4 4,t4,3, ,O,..,,t ?, '- ' - .. . - - - -- ' • _. . , -,- - ., .,- ',„ r,; - .. • ''.'' ''.7'etC•=1-311-'' .•.'ij. L-4,44$4, .- vo,,,,,,) : ,,, c‘, .'-, 4' A..'. A - ''' , :,*A A."'"`''' , •' -,, , ' ' ,- '+ • ' ' I: 1, , ,.' , 1 ' ' ' ' '',4i ',.,:,;;.:A-.',4'..,p,,',44%;-''‘f: tvi.i33,..k.,ilzkiii,,,,..4Aix.?'-'4.'t ,c4-,;04.4,4;.', et,,,, , .... - .'-,,-.!•,-,',,r t'...-:.,..,{.t.,,,„'...W4-1„ ,...,"„,-,/kg,,,,,,-..4,,,,ii..„:.;;;t4,;,, r.? ,i,,,,,„VvF,:.., ,,_ ,f; . ...,,,...-,,v,,,,,,,et-,-,-4.1--,04,-,-,,,,--;„,f„t-if,...-;.4,t-a- .1 .,,$a4-44 ,. •%-V,•••41 '••,,..4),`,4t7 t ,`ii.i '-';.,>1-t30.,,,,'',:t:4er'il•••,..•Ii‘4r,-.,,4,1;''',1;','r, /,'11/1_,,,-„r. •,ii, ,4.',•,$1:-k=,'t,?° ,,,,, ' A 1-10F:4,?4,4,;-,,g:,:vg-,.pY.;,...,p-,,,,,tt,c,-,>,„,,-,:ci.c.t,:.--!..11,.(ii 0,,,,,•,,,,-0 ' ;,..,... 0 .1,0 14%1 I ; -• '„°' -• ;" -., ';4'.,,'Ve:9`:t'r,C;fe','.41r14445`5.1,71V.,joor r(444-',-.*S'' ,".5...-1,:,-,." 4 ',I 4 e',. „"t•,,,,,etc:ii.t. ' /11 .-'' '.' '''''tay-Y-12.-,--7-44. 0,-,....4•,,.7...f.-,t'..'sk-T ,,,, -,1 - ) ., , ..,, ,-1„.. ,1,-.• . 4 1 •itz„r.'7,qe,.,,;,,,,rk„. ,,, ,.)./., ,,e •••.v..;41...4.Z.;„?.. ,1•1,,-,..,),,r-f,., :.-.1,•,:c1 . 1 i til:' . it#11011111101*,: ia" ir'''' '14.-Y7 'Address: 8 East Atlantic Avenue Year Built: 1950 I °i'','1`,.., '''i--. -' "z..'el- ,-4.=•-'4}%,'-',1:-*t ;.--. ,-. -.., -M,,,.41, , A .= 1 ,*.:,,.:,:`•4• ,,i':.,, ;(-.1.44,,, ,. ,.4-„A 's, ey.-.4.. ' 6• , ,- ". - ' d , , , , .,. ,,,,,,.. ,- Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular i' ? :'''' '''' ,, 7,:::;(4%,4'''', -.,.. '''-i9,:''...atzeni.'"' ',.P oits....:;-.'• ;7 Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to historic district in i ,. ,,,„ ,,,,„ , , ,,,, ..„ k , r 1,, „,,, t s,,r,.1 , • , t-o 1 I 1 ,LI,,, stylistic features and scale. ,..;,, ('',.,-',1 , ,,I.:1. - I*,, ,-- ril ,;i54.,,,i..,, ,.._ ,,,,,, .,., - r ,.... .=1 'vt,N.6 1 J " ;,....fA...,,•„••,,,,k= 2005: This building possesses sufficient architectural ,-1`..,:z-1-',;,',':1,',..''''.''''' 1 ,; ' , •:-.$ • - i i',3,4-.....3:•....;:,,,--' • • • ,..:,,-,,,;.1.-,,,. -.‘„, - .w_.ttiox-trp.11,,,,40, ,,T7,v,,,,,,ocei.,,,,, ,,,", 7 ::: ' uni".":::li',,t ti;at',41 4, distinction and historical significance for individual ',vri, -,. - - - --, . . 'T.-. 0 , 4 , ,y,, , ..___ „ ,,,, ....----) f--------- '•. -'r1it' A'fr ',., ; .1 ..o MN 44,...:,4 t , ,, ,„,,,,' '",•_,----' , \ , i• • t ,A,4t ;?-416._„;.,.. ' • ‘, ----•• —, a , m..,k•,', „,,, 1, local designation only. It contributes to the district as a F ,.1 ., , _ .,, representative example of commercial architecture -, - from the period of significance. , ,,w-x-,6....-n. i.!••:. ••- • MIL_ C AO iS _1. 11.0 I Old S o Square Historic D ---g -t Properties Proposed for Reclassification -„ .. . *-,,-- .--------------"--"°'"—"'*T'-"r .. .,e;,.i'' ,,,'-.' , *,.,,,,'.,,,e v.,- :.-.., •,k,. (-, ,.,,,,,,,..-..-, A., kl- -,. Address: 16 East Atlantic Avenue Year Built: 1950 •i'4, ''', ,_4(:AA ..,,, , , O., , Architectural;-4-...:ts,..11471.,,,t-,,. tc....„. -.-.•.. ;..,:,1% i.- -.-.74. iA,,... Style: Art Deco/Moderne ,7-,714,!,.. ----14 Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to the historic district in its v!`...,,c4,4 A, 5 -- [ --•4';`i-....1 ...t ,..,*. -,..,,, ., , -- , ',•,,,.4::-.:4.,,,Aliii ,.'44.., ..4i stylistic features and scale. ---A r, :,-4-•-'%"t:‘,Y‘z1:-;;;44,1).-01 Ir: i c„;•-•11 1'4%.'. ,i,e:4,211#0.-,t, OVA 2005: ...possesses sufficient architectural distinction & historical -,..--f---_-_-_,.i.--,_,---.; -1.-.4-•4011Virig4) ft:' , I . . . . significance for individual local designation... contributes as . . . representative example of commercial architecture from the ..: , (-.) , of' POS. • 1999: Located on Delray Beach's main thoroughfare, is , .,,''''' ' ' -7',4 ., ,,, :',-'','4 ,._.•..t.. '7,-' ';-:'''' ''',-.7,-.''''sr"7'''" :' representative of the city s historical commercial -'''''' , B.k.,-, ::;.'' --,,„ i,, - ,.. e. .. .;-`` ., '-'1','" ''. -;',' ' ''-'-• '.'''''''''—'''''' architecture illustrates the early 20th century development of $ •K''1" -.- V-''''','''.'--,'-'::-'' ''7 '''''';"'''-..'•%,;- 7:- '''si favi:=,,,. ,,-," ,-,,,* ,,i,i Delray Beach's central commercial area could be considered a contributing resource within a local historic district.. 1 .''''' ,,•--41'.1'1:;," tqi?•It. t,..,.!AWfic '',', •• t'VT.--4.„-,4.-f "„, ,, t:." ,,- 10,0:Wkr.e. 1.: 'q',13;4V.," Iv 1'1;1 stA , .1; k . i, •,,l, ,', • . ''Ivietik; , -- - 4 o...L ---, ,t ., ..7s.'t' ' '''... - 4.4 1,1,44:r•K-,4' t W ' :34d .,, t• 1.ri-rfn l ',..,. , ',.!;.'•7;•, 11',,l. raw ,..,tA '' .P. .4'4' /'• Is':#4 ..41.c.:4( ,,,..,. •,. 'P.f, Address: 38 East Atlantic Avenue Year Built: c.1955 sffi*"."' .1.--r'4.,e %....' 1 ‘,-' ,'; ' ... ' ' f '''',•—g.••44., * , i..----..-...„.44, — ,‘ --- 44 - ' 4,,, ..,- i crk•A' '1141 :1'--s• ../:, 's 'n ,k-':(:,',,.--. ,)AF.,, ' Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular 4 ,',.•`-.41.1 k 1 ..: '-'1- ' "Ie. i` f.- , ..Y` .•..-.1:,;Li,, - 1 "A,c . . Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a representative • -. ,,,l',.., •-:-.‘,. A -I, f ;','4, .,,'-,,‘ , ,'.• ,'', a.,, • ,- ,,,....,-, „,:,-,,..,, : example of domestic architecture from the district's period of imi7,- '40, 1" ' - i 4•''.'.. ''' . significance. },-,t, ' ,'Q '.t, Ask 1999: Located on Delray Beach's main thoroughfare,... is 45,;lig, - ' e't4 iiii ii-A.4; 1.' . 1 ,, il -w. ..; ...' ---,-, ; s; , ; representative of the city's historical commercial architecture also -1/.-•;.'s,-----. ./4-41144S,, ' ., , . r, 1 . 4 illustrates the early 20th century development of Delray Beach's --------= , , -.---'' 5, . - central commercial area...co-uld be considered a contributing , - - - ---. ,-.. : ---- - . .le, ',--•' , , resource within a local historic district.. -' lik4 ''- - . .-• .-J--)-4- L.,.- - is* Old School S uare Hisao a is 9istric Properties Proposed for Reclassification :2,, .�;., _.._... ..._ _.. ._._. ...._.__,_. ._. .. t � r' ,i1V�. �` ) a1 ,t4 `^ Address: 10 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1951 dg�,,, 9 T� if I ,.,4 0 �9 fi`.,i ii ,��ti-, Y, -, , r, . Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular 1 . +'�,`x�, i ''' " ` Evaluation: 2005: Docs represents the historic and {e f: ti. 1 p�' ` a R,/' • p ,: development of commercial fast-food preparation, post ri e w" ,i a ',t ' .'Y 1" - World War II commercial architecture, and car culture in �� f . . Delray Beach. It maintains integrity and contributes to the r �� y gY' tY ' '"' surrounding historic district. 7 a,' fy 11 r�•a r { ♦ r " q n ? N ` �t 7 r. 1 .,, oins4f ,,, ' mc . i`�iq dMQi ! a td wy * 9 G a •, x , • ' r 4 F � Address: 227 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1950 r. r*y., { v p' Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular 'y�; Evaluation: 2005: ...due to its modest architecture, it does 1 A'�;� ''#i.: 9 ,.._;^ ` f", • _ ` y ,: contribute to the historic district as an example of - - ' ' R11. ''' '` "� `ri"J =t domestic architecture from the period of significance. I r� w'. ' 2001: ...associated with the developmental history & •• r; , .1' , , t ' l A cY+ s ..''' - r. + 1-., exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School ; 1,-,': .,. ,;ass -- - • r Square area during the 1950s. Due to its historical and at g .,,a x 1 s: ° 3 ' r architectural significance...could contribute:..when the y historic district is re-evaluated and the period of ,fit ,‘' 1 4 r/i r significance is expanded to include later historic resources. ` M1 r'- °'' ' .r o o --*•,... o -... o ..._ Old C oo cual'e ist-oric Jist ict..... Properties Proposed for Reclassification .. -,,-.‘ \??r, Address: 255/65 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1945 it Pi,'";,,-;',/i-V , Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular s„:=;i •-.4.,-(4,- :-'21.,d/if 1,,, •-- ! , •( Evaluation.. 2005 contributes to the district as a -t----1,;(4. , .t.t.,.... •Atol•• :114, -. , ,,,,,..'' , gi i•• 444, t , • -• ,,.,•,...: •., ,,,,,, _, • -4.k., - ,-,i,,,, ---‘'.1 , 4 • „,-.5',-,..,--77., ---y-R1 ..4•••., , - i •••,r,-4; , / 1.'1 representative example of domestic architecture from the . , • .. •,,,,;-•-,,, .1. ,. .. -o„. ... ---, , '" - r------- 0-4.. .f• 1 ,..t. .r.,-,-„v;,' - ' - ,,,,,r'--,-.,-.- ,,,. --7,---',..-----,f7:1::_ z- ,./.',..", iloW.1), _.`,',..,i•kh :' ' district's period of significance. it.F.- .3"7„, , ,4.NN J. ,. ..!2 , .'" • - -----., - ," ,;•51',0;!,1 1 , • • 'r .''''''''''' ' ' r.'-' '''';'' ----f: '1, :-,-t:'---11 '''''- - -.,-,-:::`, -,e,':',` - 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and i -,-......_ , ,, ---..---,--4,- •-• , i,,..tt,41.--t, , t t ..' " -. f • . --'- ---- •:','„ -..-- '," ' ;:2-3;" - -•li ,‘ ' :f !,--- ‘- :",* ' ''^4^74 • • --"' ''''' 1 -t-''' ' ' " ""' exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School ,.• ,,,•.• ...,..,...„,„„,, - i ;..• ,-.,--, 4, ,.. ,4, ,,,.., -,1,4 f,'-i,' r, ,--1,-.. ,-,4.- '. . . ,,,,,. ,, ,- ,,....,,i,...,,c,..4 . ,,,por.,•.,,,,. ,,,i,,, 4 , . , „,,,i-a, , -,,, *,--' .,' - ', ,,,4,1,'4' ...1 • ' 1"*.tr- i -4k4z.',` "'t,:0 '.:, Square- ' ' -44 area uuring the 1950s. Due to its historical and i• •... ,,,,,..iiiak,„...,,,,•;,iL.4. •• ,.. .......2, - ,.....,.,....,‘ '..,„•• ., . ;:'''.:',. i, "..,,:.-..-- ...,,,-• :;-7-'-':.--' architectural significance could contribute when the ''''''''''''', ' '4 - ' - ' ''''''"..---.---,-• • --'4';'-e,'''' P.' ''''-',' ,,,, -' historic district is re-evaluated and the period of ----, -,,,:„...- ,. - .,-• d'A• 4'«•*.r4•5•••''.•-'4..r•'''.: 4"":,.••,•,•0.•:,,.•,,,, ,• .p.` .,,,,„r"'' y ...L.,,, ,. ., ,. later ,. '"4-'.,'''•:'" ':'".''''' ''''ql'V.i.4''.'•::'--,-,g4,',‘"v-i,- ,:: ' ., ,'• ,!, '''-'1-- -' * ."4- ,''',..,", 4--` significance is expanded to include l historic resources. ,,,{, ., 1":"5:'':,,,'10..,' '1:1''''' 14.,;.5:•4:t 0"0...-*-...:, ' Ce.k'4 +;., ',..:_,,1„',::2,,,'.%...t-"t/I''''.'',','-',4 p-- ....' ,,it,, . . . . ,.. .. _ _. ...... , • 1-,-t. \AA,.., , , * Address: 314 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1947 '',...'_` l• ....',r, 1140,e .., 7.1, i! ',,, ..k ,,.4, , it • i h, i• * ...,.. ,. Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular •. - )••_,.., ,4- At. .§i. ,. .,-t. ., v . . — - ,' i 0 . I:•2 4" ' . &Ar, v, ' •ts t. ' li: ,- ,.,+NI '...tt,lt, ;}':il..21;*'. Evaluation: 2005: ...it contributes to the surrounding '•.„'s,i,t,'''.: ,,,,,.. „,.• ,••„, ' ,,", Avt• s. i•fr ,„-,,"!,-;,,,:.4.,-,- ...ike, J i .17,',••••,' , ''' "-‘i:tr, -!,t,7 •' '• , i ..,,,,,.,•,. na.!,,,..:--,:.,-...._;,..1 - „„,,...,,,,,„. . :45,1'i, .,. o, s• • 'lLit «-Ii.;.(,•; 4" ' '••.4'..:•''''/S•-•'' 0 s• • - 9"kmtl'l ` historic district through its architecture. '-41.7.,,i,...,•• 2', q F' - i'1' . -,:lt;:*`,.-,z,-------tosii.if%-ii..".22-143A''..A.Piz-4iis ... , 14; 4 4e' ;....1 r..- 4(4 t t', ' " • ,5-:...--...-;.",r-,,c.-,,,—.7.7'.."'..—.7------_-:,----., • A'4'', ",`4F '`.. 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and l'-'in.,,ti '1,..p.'N-",i,,''•.,, .r,'I, • 0 ikN. ‘ '.1 ,„,. .--.----'-->`-• - ---''.-:---..---:4‘"--,...-.-... ,''''.:--t__5.,4,,,,,, ',..1 r ", ' ' er., ''. 2 1'4. . ''-::. ifi'ir----AAI"":4---;'"Aa-•-•• '—' -i-----' '"4' " exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School ;Tett*, 1 4'' '''lb ;0 • ,;',/1,.,!'5 .(1'-7::: , 111---i-t_laiiikT 1-,drr: -... , -- , .1".- Square area during the 1940s. Due to its historical and "IV' 1,';.'4' '4:1'''''.',';'):-. '''A k.--- :\.±--':''''144-- 4-‘"''''''''.11--;:,I 11 '' '` '414.... 4.1?••••,4., / , ...,„ ,.' '',' i... '.. • ;. k'4... %.,4':• — I et' • (II' •( ....Vt'a., . •.. 1 ',..4 "..' ° 11 ' '''e ,i ',.f • architectural significance,...could contribute to the re fes;';'‘''4"-',...:-''. .,. ,,,,' if: ,..:, , L,,, 4 ..,4 locally listed Old School Square Historic District, when 1' •(,- -.-=‘-..,.- ' ''' 'I,' ‘‘f:,?r;: '''' • • • • • • ' 4..';', \ . " - I ki, . ,,,, - , ,. VA-', 2 2 ler , the historic district is re-evaluated and the period of --4,-,--- , - p.,4,...-.,, - ' ,'-- - • ,. • - . — significance is expanded to include later historic 4,-„„...;',''',!..0.," •:-.‘ - ---i•' ,.."", - ..--., ..•-•,-2-:". . , ,- --• .., ,i,,, .,'•• -.4';.‘.. thA .....,..---...,- .._........, -• ,..., ,,,,.., - ...,.. -•..2 •• •, , . . .. . •,-,,,,,,,- - - 4,4..^..,. . -,.„.. ,.-••,,,, •, _ '.' .•• "'0 ' ' 00 ''''' E.- i,fr-til resources .r.-....; —' :' '...:',/,1;,-''..'"‘:'''''''' .- ',..- A.,- ' , •',..'''' '' ' -'.'•.•• L'.a?4kt:•4•'`. ".".,•,••••., • Old Sc S .-ire His:oric Jis:ric Properties Proposed for Reclassification � 'iS;L�: i {Z� t !� gyp;+ li '` � �� '3, i('''I,1 I' fJ E Address: 317 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1950 ,} Architectural Style. Vernacular :A 1�r L 3 ,l nAi �"-« i Jet +i i 4�f5'.'' 1 ' J Masonry '` a, -1 4 t .,?4:t�41 it f� t d )i; ,r t 11ka, �� tiA ,. 3 4 t , t), , 1�j ..,• Evaluation: 2005: Although this resource lacks sufficient r t �r� y{ '+'fit 7,' t ti 'l.� �1 UitY y I 1 7 + , •,'�Ad'ft architectural distinction for individual NRHP listingor local ' �',•p ^1 "'+c 4 a • .I._., 1 u , ' f designation, it contributes to the district. , ivt,' k,..- \` i:Sitg'.1'-';'''f;7"::,:.,d1 ', 1: - - 1 f ',A. •-r— V: 5,047. pjit Aw, tit •ti. 1 LS F+7/r �?.ti'•mt Div. F44t, x p l a h , 1 • ��, .: 9' r.r 'f� 7s 3s•4Aga' It «.: K 1� t •"i.J +6'y' ,P, 'f> ,Y y st 5 ..,+d "''" a5� �`FI... �S-'•9't d Y"Sw"" ,w,�,nu.,r.w-.+ y - - - - - - ---- - ....„. '_ ... ,,,,.„,,,,....„.„,.. 7." !' - 4 .- v 6• .tom �.+ Address: 333 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1946 r.;. ,,- `�: ..�i '\�; :--,. Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular �'1 , Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest . ' .� ¢° -.i ..., '�� `" `• example of domestic architecture from the district's period of t ' r •- ',"' '`;: r 6i 1+; A.t + 'y,. , ., significance. � Y 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and ' ''4' exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School Square r area during the 1940s. Due to its historical & architectural m t,..: significance, this building could contribute...when the ' s,, ,. -- t;; a ^t!v r S t , ' { J t ;•ff Its , + , 1 t^ L, i.,. rs, historic district is re-evaluated and the period of significance , - ,.; -_ , is expanded to include later historic resources. i.' '" .0/I. ".:e , ,. , 3 a,:1..�:,.4rrh<�id^.n^, 4,�,".h,,.Y N.;Y.".y.,t t M,.L,.•�i,,:..,r:,+�4^Y....,Sw L:nr�..,a..a., ,t,,. '..:........ „W S.,..f.i,„G ',u(..xr^I.n.sw..'YP,+.:(A14Mn.�W':.6„"4�45Y;C.r:.,Y�...w..k•.e.i4.L1'••1`x,.'I.1•...,.d IL.�r a.r,C+u...k1L5. .?..... .'d?"4{tS�uW IA.V,?!M..C..•,1�: - coIiSqua:eHistoric Dis FNr1:Ji5l. c : Properties Proposed for Reclassification � r')r y .�,, F Address: 337 North'Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1945 { A h ko`,,t1., , ��1 I Lt ,G` , Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular '` ,jj\,tY, ; Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient 1t 4 4� .Ft l'Y r1.y.M till'14),. Yr! 4; , �° bh Ta F ,, }yAy� wz�• �� r . architectural distinction for individual listing and �' , 4 }tit''� , . w` , ,�;�. ti ,, v t,4 =, ?v v ,.G,,, designation, it contributes to the district as a modest �51 n'•,M4yd�1 .°, L4 3 ' .a k "., *b, " $ 1e..t! j_, t Ili ;1 L ''j 1' - 'a w f• j, �`' ` '-'°` example of domestic architecture from the time period of i, 3 r ,‘ :� significance. ri } 4,4`., , 1985-1986: Good Condition t Y e F ♦4 jyr t ! IRS `"" ,7.:6,44.e1-ri�rq Son o ;Nu.r�, ti # ". 7.EL : t tr. ' y,,yam, t G s+• 1 ,{^fAA;d h�*h�Y� s�p"'��. :1 ~r �, ) 5 ,. z {..r ,. .w....,... ...... n..,., ... .. . .... �, r R,'a rT�p4I"�M14.�e"'C�g•*,Z;. .T,1 V i� • `� .c ' L t t t -5 - • L1 : "�1'' :',/.7 r--"1. MlxiI '4V, : '`i 5 } L .' , a ;C i4 . ' �'..-y.h f6 i -.,�'C,- h ,, �, t ,•f *� .�`k°1 t his j..i r m,s,' ke Address: 353 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1948 L,, dR �_ :' �` 'L,;4, .A ' .14.r't ,,? 4, r � �� #~.'?.KEY P[-- S SW. } 1 ,kt , F,, 'v r Ja A R a 4..t y �. w Z P.L t y,t Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular ,� _ �.T.,, , ' r r �` to Y ,;,i ` x ,` r;r�x,k ;, Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district. G,'- -,. „, -.. ,4,71`3 l'x,,A _ 'i , • ;, 2001: ...associated with the developmental history & r ` , ,I 0iiir .'',, t ry To', , 1 tire- , tip - € exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School' t H rx s a _„ ^ E.. k ! ` • y tr�, ger+ron,t&',, r i-.'."M 4 t.4 • r,:, f sn.6sr:. } f ,,, Square area during the `1940s• Due to its historical and , r� r . "' _ ,}L s ,,, , N k r N architectural signifi cance this building could contribute, '° x . - .' �"x4°a7 �,',Y+`5..4.J, '•d::4th�,,,,g-.. +v..x µ:•• - _,,".-�k„..;e'' Z 5i"tif�.nxR'ri�-S� s.• ,,,, .��,--14.., �` ...when the historic district is re-evaluated and the period of significance is expanded to include later historic resources. o c IC 0 Schoo Squelre His-toric aLT 4 Properties Proposed for Reclassification Address: 27 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1950 r Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular Evaluation: •2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest ,•- - example of domestic architecture from the period of : --_ ' k " -significance. . )1. 4 yy p L yr it .�t71it }''�M!R ft- �� , ,:w t.. .. ,o F� \' '" s aid a 4- ., *, F Jar r'u�i 4. `, . +$' k,k a r 'd, t a .,,,k :Viti'r`t iW ;" ;-mow SMt'. 5w yy;' t 4"° '"'F 1id'`t y -" 'k, 14ri-a,r r;s•,3 c ,r,. t�ll,41`i +a,,, 'z E,rr 7, ," y -,i, ,s2.,,y .,, r ;t, S�F ex''*b :tc "Y✓ o,lrf�y'a t. L , .y yt`r��jew,'''^ S e C�f4r a 11• k r.."y!rls > 4r' "'4,, i1'rt-.,6„i rs� .t.M', u*•":, 4 i Y •V L� : f Y 7 M 2 ,'1 _ 'i,` h '4 � �Ai i+.ii..;.40 ,r'„,, ,` riki+ ' 'i,; j.�' yam', ..a-,. ,� e�, #'�;m r /,..„,"-1:,,,,,,,,, i,,,, � c g a � r•z ,,....... ,„,,.,t,;,.,.„,_ft ,,I., , ..f.,4....., :,,, ,.„:,..,,g.:,.:,ms,:,,,i- , ,4,-, .-)a .;`, , ''.14"..-f.'-Xt., .=•nabs1 f.-rs-tq „°wi,,,r..r4,r-=1, ..�. 1.: 'P a,, , .. .a1,-. ,..r ??,k. .?a.1. , . Address: 119 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1948 � e walk; 1 1 9 ,. y Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular , Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest �!Ilr I: l example of domestic architecture from the period of ' ' . III; :, l $..1.r }„ ' significance. �� MU u rq ,u 2001: ...associated with the developmental history & :- .4 s R a , exhibits the architectural elements of the. Old School . ': - a- . — ` a ,r ` f� , Square area during the 1940s. Due to its historical and ,'p' " " i •" • , hT . 'p ,, , 0' a r €` architectural significance,...could contribute when the ,"' r %' t�, o r ,. � �x$`. ; R^fL� Cj � x�F'4�"� ��• �'S�(•� � � T'^}'.4+�`�",4l T�+�`s`�� +b' S historic district is re-evaluated and theperiod of , ,. pµ, r `� x :° : �, �m �..,_ • p 1� 1 '+l�-fi . s Zs�vv �'.t;> ��,�,5 � '`f� Stv+-Ys ' �'�`,� �r t, k 1.-'—• s tf "l44'rt 'b..0n" ° r ite-a`, +',..., y i • Ittvlig. it'- r'` tl411), 1 3 significance is expanded to include later historic resources. gay �� - . r � ,, 4 At , �,�, .0- OIi ScooI Scuare Historic Dis :ric ♦. .,...if:? .t,.,4....i..:f...l 2.xvx"'..1)YTr t,•"h.R .i. �Y,..ii.n-<.� ,As:N.Fk+ .?:�3 �., .i +:w,3 Tai e,:•i:M14.'pf<.7+11:.•W d.f AJ:,ti:s�-µc�;1^i.D'FNi,F� ..:N.;r1S,faa..tn""'�if1�i!SEA"C.Y.+9. .�,��whyGtiT1.`.rt,;Y?.Mh.. ...'1 f..+HaY..I'«r`t`rq.i}'.F.>I.i 1. ,.�... .. Properties Proposed for Reclassification Address: 123 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1947 I r \ f } ,'' ' Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular , mom ,�i l,.' }Y (4,:• Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest 1, f ;, _ - ;y,,. ,.. i, ! °�� example of domestic architecture from the period of �" y� n -- `� ' }t ) •,, ,,_ ,*' ` significance. i�' tea. M ` 3k h :< c,.. ,1 :ii {i ■ ::: , i ,Tt? ( K,` 1 I Al I III Nisi' #.zi 1 i r • / y i itl "r s w I) y• .• f e +.,.� i;, a YaW.N j i l� } ,6r _ „ a � 'ak YF`. 9 >^f itit a , '~? " r�, d.ate.uF N' iw,c' ;� , r �. o4 .. . •y> hir!«, .sexsx'.. .' ,. .F ., _ r j .... ....... k..,t „,--,.n �.:t' Old Schoo Square Historic DistricL .1,,,,,.Vx.,ta. t."iu.,.'_:.,.... .4:.•' 1_�t..:.r:- .�.. '.....^.r.t..4r��^H...11.1. ♦. ,n. s '.-af.1 . x],.i.iC04 P�.tv.^x:':.3 .., P M:.lY...,..:�i.44Jd4K.:...,iVN�Fi1!}4.4 xt r!tiYwMf(:R MF-4s M, v.. r...iv . s .a>. ....: ' Defining Contributing and Non-Contributing ❖ Contributing: A structure which adds to the historical architectural qualities, historic associations, or archaeological values for which a district is significant because it was present during the period of significance of the district, possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at that time, is capable of yielding important information about the period, or independently meets the National Register of Historic Places criteria for evaluation. o NRHP: Generally, properties eligible for listing in the National Register are at least 50 years old. Properties less than 50 years of age must be exceptionally important to be considered eligible for (individual) listing. (See Criteria Considerations.) ❖ Non-Contributing: A structure which does not add to the historic architectural qualities, historic associations, or archaeological values for which a district is significant because it was not present during the period of significance. of the district, due to alterations, disturbances, additions, or other changes, it no longer possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at that time or is incapable of yielding important information about the period, or it does not independently meet the National Register of Historic Places criteria for evaluation. _ _ Old School Square Historic Jistrict i7w:+a:a. .t:.ss.* 3Y.^;ir 414' 9r...N..,:c, 4..sd.c.:n{ .,..i,..,M w:.:r.,., a: ..si.t .t;.•:.rl.. ,.:..:s,..F.ca,::....;•:ia ,..ra..3 ?r+r..:+ .trro+.r:. �.°.+,-*.....r 'rn .t .•;^Yi'.r.?A.-ro. r r,.t+;r.,..: .;s•a:n r.w..._..««..>> ..:: ::,.:a r rt.-.�..nd'i er :';;.. t ,t .;i,:a *. Review of Contributing and Non-Contributing :• HPB review required for all exterior improvements within a designated historic district which includes Contributing, Non-Contributing, and New Construction/Development projects. ❖ Review criteria is the same with the exception of demolition requests. The LDRs require that requests for demolition of Contributing structures submit the following: • (a) Certified report from a registered architect or engineer documenting that the building is structurally unsound and is damaged beyond the ability to repair it at a reasonable cost. (b) Certified report from an engineer, architect, general contractor, or other qualified professional documenting the projected cost of repairing the structure and returning it to a safe and habitable condition. (c) Appraisal of the property in its current condition, its value as vacant land and its potential value as a preserved and restored historic property. (d) Documentation that reasonable efforts have been made to find a suitable alternate location for the structure within the City of Delray' Beach to which the contributing/ individually designated historic structure could be safely relocated. ❖ Many items may be approved administratively rather than reviewed at an HPB Meeting. Old Schoo_ Square His-:oric DisLñcL Benefits of Historic Preservation (General) ❖ Less impact on the environment and on infrastructure and reduction of sprawl. ❖ Less neighborhood opposition. Neighborhoods are much less likely to oppose a project to restore a building that has been in place for 50 or more years than they are to the construction of a new building. ❖ Protects the architectural and historic character of buildings or neighborhoods. ❖ Greater property value appreciation than comparable non-designated areas. The fact that both residential and commercial property values increase in historic districts has been demonstrated by studies across the country, in communities that vary greatly in in designated historic districts than non-designated areas, occasionally they are the same, but in no instance are the rates of appreciation lower. It is the design review requirements of designated historic programs, which are responsible for this difference in value. ld Sclioo Square Historic is :r c- . N•,.S k:":"t wv, ,.a. .....: .:. ..v.riR.`!; .. ...;:.4. .... . Ge.r.,k.yJ. .i4"Y . n? .C1:.` ^. .,..?.5tf I\s. .c'4,I+ t...:.GY"Y.ss:.....3 ir•,:47i..x r.1.^YY:iG2'. „ .. ...... _ r .. r , s..n.t,,, r..,9.!.-Local Benefits of Historic Preservation •:* Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Program - Contributing & Individually Designated o Exemption applied to City and County taxes. o Exemption based on structure's increased value resulting from completed improvements. o Interior improvements qualify o Include additions to contributing structures and/or detached 'new construction on a contributing property. o Available for all uses Single-Family Residential, Retail, Office, Restaurant, etc • Variances to the Land Development Regulations - Contributing & Individually Designated o Properties not in a historic district seek variances at the Board of Adjustment (BOA). o' HPB variance criteria looks at historic nature of property. o BOA review requires basis of a hardship. •: Review Fees: COAs (non-site plan associated), HPB variances, and designations NOT INCREASED in 2009 with other review fee increases. Community Redevelopment Agency Programs ❖ Site Development Assistance Program o Commercial Uses o Partial reimbursement for exterior improvements Old School_ Square His :oric Jis :ric-y Community Redevelopment Agency Programs ❖ Historic Façade Grant Program (Available for both commercial and mixed-use projects) o CRA purchases permanent easement to the building façade; grant funds (purchase amount) tied to building relocation and/or façade restoration. o CRA funds may be used as matching funds for other grants received for the same project. Recent program amendment permits that up to 49% of grant funds be used toward interior structural repairs. o Success Stories • Delray Beach Historical Society, 5 NE 1st Avenue (2003 & 2007) - Relocate 1926 Bungalow and restore exterior; relocate "Hunt House" and restore structure. • Masonic Lodge,44 E Atlantic Avenue (1997) $45,000; Exterior restoration. 44 E Atlantic Avenue T,,, 1 a t__ , � 'Ny r,1� .1 r r 5� �P S }1 r Z•4s ,., i 4r � �`�, y .N > 1 fYois f3 x K{„A..; ;i ( A' d �e s .' '• .s+�" +. • ; - 3 1'� �2i �r t T�iiik,, I'' r'�TBOOTS .�P ' 1 „ aii �ii �: LPy� a jit 1,� 11 � f4444r.:ay„o,�—ry�v �rSFr � .� dx�.'�,� �S i� -�' rl � � 1� � ..----" M(� � �'e � -. r 1.;*� Grs t i i.k _' 42. �.�1 � 4 1 .,r — 7 1 ��r q( �t --, 11 yg�� 1� p .. ''� ..`" f'` _ :xr r.-- :.� _ , nij� � s � "+,�T R.. " "- ur» r^s i #, #fin �. Si r 4 _ �R . ».:Ji. z.n.: .S� 'r ,Y',' . ;, xJ` '- .5' '1'iiC�r .. , ,. 1920s 1990s-Before 1990s-After * Program guidelines being revisited to see if there is a way to offer more help to nonprofits. - ,' . 1 . /...... „-_,- --,# 1D-°, ,-, #41 Itn: -1_ 1C1,_....... ,_ 0- C- SC00- Sciliare :. isto ' ( _. ....z..-, ,,,' . , , :,, _. ileite.;,, ."-,' ,f,,,,.;,..„-,•, 4 ,, t•, ..•i i.•.7, . :....T.'-:,-;? :'i, ,:",", r- , ....... .,10.4 ...,-- ...-:--....b., ...4g1 .4_,.,:-,.. .,....-,, 4.!..:,;,-„, ,, ,•,•,...„ ; r:), , , . . .. 4-H . 4 • [ ;.s .r.„ ,,,,6,444,4„-e• .,.. — .*--- — ., (7.Jkl.4.,?.ii . '‘.. -,. ,,..:-1,1.,,,:,,,..,..:4 .; _ , •-,.. :,.1..,..4•.,1-r,,,-:-....,:,-,4.... . i,-- 'Elf . . '4,A,,s '2 gat ,...-4,-.tir.74.! _.....:_,...., ‘ - '• . - I r ,, El . -e—a. , ....,,,t4; ,• i,.h.f ,.., N :, •11.„., ',-:, . 0, r _ .f,,'tr.-:, •r•,-;:, - '''.. . ' 1 .1 ..f • f -if,......,15..' , , - . ,-.• • 17 iiiii.11141:,Ii11111111111111111111 . ,.',.,*r..;',.7.-4,-„',,,.40'.4.;...,,-...'-'('.,--:'..,','-' `-'`,';':'-.'','-,:,:(..1::--...•,kvi.4-,1-:,,,t,,,N "-----"*"."'..,......mompimmismum........__ • ',..,: - ii;.".:i,'-r.,...„.;, 1!likow........_ . .. . Pit:;3•ii',4?-it";11,;k140". ''' r.,.,."Z-",;"".":141.,,,,J.-t''•.i.i.i';',..4,1",-.4.''''I'','",,''',11:.,,i . -,.. , .....•- ite., ,11, ..,..„,:;;,11., .‘,NElire ..• . .. •'''.tftr'-'4,..'74.11 I, - ',.:-Y4!‘r1%.n• -,,, 1•01,4,1611Fib. ..... . .L...-1-- ,— ,,,---,4,--,„:-. -_NI,r,,, i '-'7'.•-,-4.'''-- ilit:;,10"'"ki ',..:: ''''•-::-:',,.-N2::'i...;,...‘, .:,.-+•;,;,,',H ,t,".1 , ' I,} -:-•--—,;-;21, '4-1•.,,,.‘ , 4 1ig - '. - I .. #.• .."------1 -. " .-. #.# 1, 4 ,,. flr ,,,, ' * Rif. , . S. r• ,, ,1f",' •;;1.1;!- lirk • ''', '‘,. • • . . ' Y. 0- : . _ '. .'• - ',.-,, 4:it .‘ - . _...ri• /S•ti'3H" Tr'"Iumi i ; , 1 - •. . ' ,,,,i. ,-,.,..-',". • „.. '1,1 ', "•-,37,w0.41-,,,-:, ,;•*),•Ii..:ri::: „te.,44.46:'.-t i''' .,4 A.: ,..f•':`''' -•••••1 . ,, 4 :r , „ i ,)-''' r'-'-''''0:-,t,t,:."1.4.•tir.0417:',1:;-•'•4`A....;,',..-.1;...;',:„...' ' -. d fe--I'''''' . '-' . -,;• ,, ,. - 'ht..,i :4( 1-"*" '.---' 4--1 ` -1-1 ' 'j,•'.,.' 1.4.,;r4'114.,/...1.,:c,,' !,'d . Y.r,Ptit ' .1T. ' -' ' - - ' .1 1 6 '..! .' ' r ,,,„,',4,1,1,..,,,..,,..2,•:!, :4,1,#4,Li..„ ,s.. 4.,,,,..-:,:: Z..*7.,t 1:;_,',;;A4.`ri, i; ' " — " 1 '-''' ; '4_'i-4,-;;;.!,—','-'! ; ,-,,R,--..-ii...-r• . i .'„ _.,,.':'•:;:AI ; i'..;;,-,,;1, ' .'" ,r4..;5.•:-:-`;'"•-'!'•.4::.4.''.. "1-.:,"....f,'",,,...,..4.4-°;,,!-..2.',-;',.‘.;•,.'',,,..,,,,,, ,„ . ,. ., . - .. '',!„4,,...1).,N,... ''," .•• • i: F, n",..... 1....:'••,,,--4,....• . or• • . . -i'.' . ,t. , .' .'A i 14,li,:,.• 4 '''''' k ' ''' if'''s0i4., ''1.7i:,..;:i:417.".'''''',.-'7,'.'..1.-;!:".. t•'1,, ' -'‘;'.ilf66/r'r., L'It•\.• ' ,r;I_ "4",',,k.,_ . ,f,l V-: , '1,.i. . ' ' ',,,,%• ' iit CE: 1 F,''' ',.. ''' - r• -- --- ,• ' 1,'..-- . •- -- -' --- k'''s:t • •c , ''.- , 0::-: ' .N.-• ,' tr, , ,..Y...,..' , . ' 4 , '-'-'''•-' 4•*: ,.. i•',t,'' . . , ' ' '''"'. - fit `-, ''''' Ill '.3. ,1 ' "' ' 1 11, Ai i ,,..-^:•-• - - ., - . ...,:,i......Ad"- ....„. 4 II' p, III .,i,,, „ 0 1,6 t,„ ,.N..'a.'lb 111''. \• ' .."'''', t "k ' L'.' i ' :7'i' ? ' - 41 ,,.,. r.,;v f, .- -;-• .,`.. ,,....r'...,,,-..4 •i; .. • 1 1 •-•,:' - --"i' r ,...,,-44,..,..,.,..,.; ---,, 1 ,,. :r. •,-; .. ;',^r..-',.',,':•,.^.7"4"•',‘-.1 r .','.'.,';',:l.•••.1 Yclk.•--.- -- 1...4.......,:;-.S.....„, iitismo '1''t".4.,-.,"t;.q1fL:'' `;•-•• -,,. t-",..:.,, -' --- - •• 4..'::-7,2.;,,".,'„ ii i 44,itIt' lliiiii-;,'2',''',i4e-'-' ' ' j . . ma asswa.1116. Old School Stare - iis1:oric District HISTORIC CONTEXT • Contains the earliest standing structures in the City of Delray Beach. • Rather than a homogeneous area in its chronology or architectural typology,.presents a glimpse of the historical continuum of the community. • Contains buildings from every decade since the 1890s, from a wide array of architectural styles: Vernacular, Queen Anne and Bahamian influences, Bungalows, Mission, Mediterranean Revival, Art Deco/Moderne, Minimal Traditional, and some International Style inspiration. • Uses have included residential, commercial, offices, institutional, religious, governmental, recreational, educational and cultural functions. •Layering and variety of building types and uses that provide the basis for the district's significance. • Many early residential structures converted to light commercial and office uses, providing an opportunity to survive amidst the development pressures of their current urban environment. • The newly found niche of these historical resources within a modern context has also brought about a renaissance for many of them, as their conversion to commercial and office uses have brought along substantial rehabilitation, for the most part sympathetic, of historic fabric. f a..ar•,+sutuww.Yt,.�. . ... 6. .t...u�. a. ... ...:'1�1 _v.�L.+ _n'L...1:.+.. ._. ,. t.tu.....G.._�.._._a..._k.t..c�...,.....�.[u.......i. .... k.... .. D A R 0 A D e OldEl ' ' ' School Square Historic District 2,.., ,,.,.. POST ' 1 '_ CASON T +•M ,..•.. r .. + :':a +m..,+,A ;+, ,.,.,+ a+e[ .Gr. k,Y,,f�.c'u:nl!r�v�lah'%f l,'S� d:4,kn•i.°'V"n, cM}an` ..w,-eL.•'•• k.�,�•:tu'7J'/'Ta�J#+:nw d k +ti!t'a ru ✓E.4s.14bu +c rf+ nz�<5+.'�.vt, 1 .. RTC Designated February 9, 1988 by Ordinance 1-88. a ? Si ■ hi.: mil Ea — 1,,, Dom 7tnill RR I e 'R ..; ! — z ORM R ATTG911EY t = M. ; • �� r ,t BU �• �•d tDMfC 3';... : i I_ +�, i I: _ „ •,, 4 eve? Ifi r� w 41I t ,7, rya .... •••�+ •.r'' F� I 4f._ ° ; � t .: ! ;V CONTRIBUTING-19BB DESIGNATION ,I CITY ;x L • . # 1 HALL E N I NON-CONTRIBUTING • - i OOMKRRTY • « ;. �� 3 # 1" ♦ 4 CONTRIBUTING-2009 RESURVEY , Y + j ,'aaJATIE.• •r POTENTIAL EXPANSION _ - �� iit um= y r-1111 ` ' ' . :1 (III I • r__IIII iil , — - di�� ¢ , III f•f• u* 1R /L . . _ �' Illll lIlll � F, III; _ _ ■ Area recommended x _ . l• '� �� Boundary _ for Boundary . Li r,:, _:,,- ■1 Map ■I■ t Expansion ■I.' ..., , :,- 411 . Old Sciaool Square Historic District ❖ 2009 Resurvey Recommendations o Expand Period of Significance to 1965 o Reclassify 23 Properties from non-contributing to contributing o Seek listing of the district on the National Register of Historic Places o Consider extending the district's southern boundary to SW 4th Street. ❖ Period of Significance o Guidebook: When identifying the historic context and significance of a historic district, the stages of growth in the neighborhood are labeled as "Periods. of Significance." The character of a house constructed in the early twentieth century is vastly different than the character of one constructed during the 1930s and 1940s. While both houses illustrate an evolution, and are all more than 50 years old, each belongs to a specific time frame in history and each period of significance has its singular importance and special characteristics. Properties in historic districts must relate to the periods of significance that are documented in the historic district nomination. o National Register of Historic Places - SIGNIFICANCE: A district must be significant, as well as being an identifiable entity. . .must be important for historical, architectural, archeological, engineering, or cultural values. Therefore, districts that are significant will usually meet the last portion of Criterion C plus Criterion A, C1jrion B, other portions of Criterion Ciar Criterion D. • { Old School Squ.ire Historic Dist: ics, PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE • Development patterns show construction gap between the 1960s and 1990s when few if any new structures were built within the district. • Date of construction of the most recent structures around 1955, indicating surge in construction activity immediately following end of World War II. • Field inspection of the district did not identify additional structures being built between 1955 and the mid 1990s to the early part of the 2000 decade. Existing structures did undergo alterations and in some cases additions, but the level of construction activity was relatively low during this period. 'Reflects general development trend of most communities at this time, when post World War II development movement was away from the city's center and into the suburbs. •Delray Beach necessitated the rapid construction of affordable homes; local builders employed masonry construction (concrete block and other sturdy and easy-to-use materials). A number of examples of Masonry Vernacular buildings are found in the Old School Square area. • Extending the present Period of Significance to 1960 would cover new construction and alterations that will be 50 years old in less than 2 years from the date of resurvey, namely in 2010. • Appropriate to extend the Period of Significance an additional 5 years, to 1965, in order to provide a comfortable margin to include any construction activity, including alterations or additions that will acquire the 50 threshold using this time frame. Old School Square Historic Jistrict National Register of Historic Places- SIGNIFICANCE: o . . .considered eligible if all of the components lack individual distinction, provided that the grouping achieves significance as a whole within its historic context. . .the majority of the components that add to the district's historic character, even if they are individually undistinguished, must possess integrity, as must the district as a whole. o The number of noncontributing properties a district can contain yet still convey its sense of time and place and historical development depends on how these properties affect the district's integrity. •• National Register of Historic Places - EVALUATING CONTEXT & SIGNIFICANCE: o . . historical patterns that can be identified through consideration of the history of the property and the history of the surrounding area. In accordance with the National Register Criteria, the historic context may relate to one of the following: •An event, a series of events or activities, or patterns of an area's development (Criterion A); •Association with the life of an important person (Criterion B); •A building form, architectural style, engineering technique, or artistic values, based on a stage of physical development, or the use of a material or method of construction that shaped the historic identity of an area (Criterion C); or •A research topic (Criterion D). Old School Squ . re His :oricDisric(4 Old School Square meets the National Register Criteria as follows: o Criterion A- An event, a series of events or activities, or patterns of an area's development: due to associations with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad pattern of the City's history as it represents the initial footprint for settlement and development of Delray Beach, with structures existing as early as the late 1890's, contains the Old School Square and Sundy House which are listed on the National. Register of Historic Places, represents the 1920s Land Boom and 1930s settlement following the Land Boom and includes post World War II growth from the 1940s through the 1960s. o Criterion B- Association with the life of an important person: due to associations with people significant to the City, such as John Shaw Sundy, Delray's first mayor, one of the early investors was Frederick Henry Link, Reverend John R. Cason, the Methodist Church Minister and Delray Beach pioneer. o Criterion C- A building form, architectural style, engineering technique, or artistic values, based on a stage of physical development, or the use of a material or method of construction that shaped the historic identity of an area: embodies one or more distinctive architectural styles or types such as the Mission, Queen Anne, French Colonial, Mediterranean Revival, Bungalow, American Four Square, Monterey, Neo-Mediterranean, Minimal Traditional, Masonry and Frame Vernacular, Ranch, Art Deco/Modern, Bauhaus, and International, with structures designed by renown Architect Samuel Ogren, Sr. d School Square Historic Djs:rict . ❖ Historic Context - Local, State, and National o A local historic context represents an aspect of the history of a town, city, county, cultural area, or region, or any portions thereof. o Properties are evaluated in a State context when they represent an aspect of the history of the State as a whole. o Properties are evaluated in a national context when they represent an aspect of the history of the United States and its territories as a whole. These national historic contexts may have associated properties that are locally or statewide significant representations, as well as those of national significance. ❖ Criteria Considerations: Certain kinds of properties are not usually considered for listing in the National Register: religious properties, moved properties, birthplaces and graves, cemeteries, reconstructed properties, commemorative properties, and properties achieving significance within the past fifty years. These properties can be eligible for listing, however, if they meet special requirements, called Criteria Considerations, in addition to meeting the regular requirements (that is, being eligible under one or more of the four Criteria and possessing integrity). Old School Square Historic Disd:rict CRITERIA CONSIDERATION G: PROPERTIES THAT HAVE ACHIEVED SIGNIFICANCE WITHIN THE LAST FIFTY YEARS ❖ POST-WORLD WAR II PROPERTIES: Properties associated with the post-World War II era must be identified and evaluated to determine which ones in an area could be judged exceptionally important. For example, a post-war suburban subdivision may be the best reflection of contemporary siting and design tenets in a metropolitan area...the nomination preparer must justify the exceptional importance of the property relative to similar properties in the community, State, or nation. ❖ HISTORIC DISTRICTS: ...eligible if they are an integral part of a district which qualifies for National Register listing...documenting that the property dates from within the district's defined Period of Significance and that it is associated with one or more of the district's defined Areas of Significance. Properties less than fifty years old may be an integral part of a district when there is sufficient perspective to consider the properties as historic...by demonstrating that: 1) the district's Period of Significance is justified as a discrete period with a defined beginning and end, 2) the character of the district's historic resources is clearly defined and assessed, 3) specific resources in the district are demonstrated to date from that discrete era, and 4) the majority of district properties are over fifty years old. In these instances, it is not necessary to prove exceptional importance of either the district itself or the less- than-fifty-year-old properties. Exceptional importance still must be demonstrated for district where the majority of properties or the major Period of Significance is less than fifty years old, and for less-than fifty-year-old properties which are nominated individually. 0 d Sc r ool Square His:oric Jistrict Minimal Traditional 1 • During Great Depression, style developed as a compromise y.i- ,Y� � 11F ; ' . reflecting traditional forms with minimal decorative details. --;; • As housing became affordable and new building technologies -•: ;, Itt ii: ,g?, allowed for prefabrication and mass production, simpler homes. + " } �''$� ' . r- , k 1-i-fr+'q��' � ' • Inspired by Tudor cottages popular during 1920s - 1930s; N.,, firli !!I reflected in dominant front gable on main elevation. ..$' _ - �ii; k • Symmetrical plan, clapboard or stucco exterior partially faced � � ." � t a with stone/rock/brick at times; one-story, single or concrete tile roof material, shutters and cornerboards. • Typical details include low to medium pitch gable roofs facing front, modest overhangs, prominent chimneys, decorative wood < , .;' details or vents on gable ends, inset porches supported on .,... ,.,. 0 -� ' decorative wood supports and sparsely used Colonial or other ". ^ ° �,w,i^�,. t " ;, traditional applied decoration, such as door and window 4 , �` .K; ' ,, ;, `� r. ,, surrounds. `' • Most popular immediately before and after WWII. M . tn� ` • Illustrates transition in residential design from period just �y a t. ¢y�"1�'Xi�A.�1 f.J'r s t 3�f�._='�''�•i. �4'Yfil�/�t9X.StTr.. N'L R before World War II through the 1950s. • A number of Minimal Traditional-style houses are present in ' 's t the Old School Square Historic District. .........._____________....................___________-_________,, __________________ . 0 .,_ ad SoOI Square Historic Dis:ric Frame Vernacular Masonry Vernacular ",l .„, ` �iM,, n is 5h4',. t ' �I 3,a{'�i >., t •r/ :W. ,j at?: r '�r_ AT �.�Y�t\ t 1. t!• i�4 �. y r ! (� +dP" r7!'Tr"a v 11 � d+^.'F ti ''' a ,', c ti a!i vA r F '31� !n _�, ,r..a d'P y- 1 � A-...' . 'n i r a 6 It -t S� '�Y Y.y .. , t ,,. t 3.31 ! ...•v Y , S ) Yl e JY,� ,.,.•;,,,,.. `f fl 4.7 .,r4 S ,k•»e "k m ; ,ti3 ` !I j ,, I !.Y L. 1 e% t asAw X :. 9 5 Yj % 1 r: h 'Y ?:: J:.Y k .1,. M � ,,yiagpy - a #:.SR A ." i r t y *.S � ..i' 'R f FI' s a tp ' }Yl D ,i1 4, i ;{ '' 4 ,,, *a< { t a r`� ti I,�, F. i,( i ri i ,1,7i t A s,- w r k Ai 4 7,i .f �� ?! a"�, z__. �r + t t a '—uga �at*�.`+fl"'"� ,k..r.:t 'a's '��Mw a $Y,C"q,..$ ha}uM YA f l t b ,. r s, xtiT,a, 4,04,;f4?4"'ttnky�?7, tis . 't'"S'r'". t:, f,U'tr'^f'a 2„�,,71.'7 i "''nt ?� ACx'4-r` -t4 ,�S�p..y.t t 1, +aTW«t aY;.,.,:,, , '" t7, iA ,4, 3.' r o v3 7 �4 t e 9" 4 N r ipi a +x A. .1t4`i.i '.. i, :ti,YEA t '5,....z; a ., ".:;. ,: k�4'$ a , i.- 1 n t " �sv r a. r 'a~ a y iF t - 'S� �' t s * ,y e° fa,.., a 74- '� tYrt.a. i yy y5�� pp.. �'G:.. �Y. ' — 4RtA. IJf,..}g9i'i i.��.':'.Y; ...11 . .. ,. , .. �F 'y. 'Av. • Hipped or gable roofs, a gable-end facade, open • Competed w/ frame construction pre-1950. or screened front porches with a hipped or gable • Primarily constructed of brick prior to 1930s. roof, and a central entrance. • After WWII, concrete or cinder block used • Craftsman-style inspired architectural details most frequently. often found in Florida's frame vernacular houses, t • Finished with stucco, brick veneer, stone include exposed rafter tails & knee braces at the veneer, and tile. house corners or below porch roofs. • Influenced by Mission and Art Deco Florida • Usually sided with weatherboard; sometimes trends. trimmed with contrasting corner boards. ' • By 1940s, typically built with L-plan: side • Built in Delray Beach beginning in the late 19th gabled main block w/ shallow projecting ell on century; continued in popularity into the 1950s. front & shallow front porch, similar to the • Later houses often feature elements of Minimal . popular Ranch style. Traditional architecture or Colonial Revival-style • Decorative cutout vents on gable ends. details at the doors and windows. .. ...,,. ,.... ..,... .. . ,.., .. ...... . . .. .... Old School Square IH1is:oric Dis:rict J,a.a,i..:i,k Y.. Yn.M'..i..t+.i 3.n'R4 ir.P'Ut.os 54':".'.St^A•.a."':.R4=`i."1:'4Yf"r.!'.tt: .. - - 16f IOW Properties Proposed for Reclassification ' t Address: 131 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1950 t lutiCi:' q,(4 • ;Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular ¢fv � ` Nt � Evaluation: ...contributes to the district as a , , ,.' f..,ff, ,,,:. representative example of domestic architecture from the ''-..., r t.';; 1.r•'w: I. district's period of significance. t ,, ,.. 4 e. j. ` ! .',.. i s t [ ky KR QQ r + ,. 1 A �. - '-�� i nve tee.. ^' ."...''t'a.• r r , , ti c „ ..:av .tt w �s 11F c 1 r 'i a y, �.w ' �� r k t w�"' � ?� f t ,err ;y „� Rlliipi S r dkm� , " � 3s� '�:. ' }� ' rt �e _, A • .:1 Vie..fix. , •4., ( 11111111111 - o 1:, ,, I . '30`. 1•. :le. yih, ^r 1r � s. ;1!f 011 • �.*N,= �' , n $'y`1 •f .t, .,.. .` .11 •}'�'�!*; .;4'.L: y .. 4,Tr.:.r* Y't{9!y ''' ✓ rE� �.+4( } - Y t {U. +°;' ..i �, ?'.b4 x°..may. ,:• •, r ,;:,d.' t »_ t - I f �{aa:�fi�u a P,t^ 44,r Y.a. t ' 'i. y i6r+"i'•r"h}. Ns y r r x '^ •r{ ' ,r ... .' `.� ' , a ! :ji 1• . ., ,..,. {' Z I Lnt ttfftfi-- f .Q 1.- Y. t ( i r . 31 a } i . o -tP Address: 302 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1945 ; . � ; ` 3ROOMry �` \ Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular/Contemporary ` ` A��Breeds2764D81 _ �}" �� ,� r a ��<'� r�& K r4"�7,,,,".,,.�[� ,�te441 ,4 tip`,fry t✓ :,, , Evaluation: 2001: ...associated w/ developmental r ,,,, ,.�, R,t �, .• , .s, . history & exhibits architectural elements of Old °`�4 '' • A `1"'`� ` y ' ' �' School Square area during 1940s. Due to historical & sue``"��' architectural significance...could contribute...when I the historic district is re-evaluated & the POS is `" '"'"` ""' ;; : expanded to include later historic resources. 2005 Continued... 2005: ...conveys historic architectural character and to the surrounding historic district. 2008: Contributes to character of historic district association with Delray Beach history. It warrants individual local designation only. Plus, it contributes through its stylistic features and scale. i ,_ , . . . . ... .. . __. .. . .. ....„ , .... . .. . _ ..... , . . - . . . ... _ . HistoricD0_ istr ic.._. Properties Proposed for Reclassification V .. .. 4..,.):..,,,ti'`' Address: 326 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1945 '`` .: " If'''- `e' .° 4 Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular + In ti 'r' 3 Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient C � 7, y;�, . '". y �� - i''''At,,,-, .ails os7 ''1, > ," ,=ti architectural distinction for individual designation and + i'' N „ _, . NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a y r .f , svr ,4 4 '�`:dt' 1F r , ` n, t'. ;�1;r F4 i representative example of domestic architecture from the •:-',-2 t, kFv.. rWi ,; i;� 1 / - 1 1,, districts period of significance. .a�,r`<.`U'W'M y • < .a. `•' a -c`..r Yq t.,' 7 r x , ; w 1 �} 4 -G fy - Note: City Building Records note 1928 construction, 1949 Sanborn r t ! ; , }z 1 F r a Insurance Map shows existing footprint. Staff cannot verify 1945 , , , R . { a1'4 '' �, a'''I'''''''' '''4` *` ' ` '..r.,''` date. 1988 designation map indicates 1957, likely from Property 4 z '` 1 T� " r r ,: 'Jhy 1 7'. Appraisers Office. Staff has found that this date is frequently an ,. f ' 4 ,k.z y ;' CA "eu..x a4Yl. 0 '1.'' }t ; r+, „Y °r , ,� + incorrect one when noted by the Property Appraisers office. ., , 4 f .0 , ,,, r �f � a� -jP ti u`'i y ytil e t, i . - ' ' 'ti.,.i..iiI"�f t i" p R'{��{pg 7 }R "E++�7ar Address: 342 NE 1st Avenue Year Built: 1946 41 _ , ,u ,n�':`t f,:, I ;p•1r 'k#rui i A �' 'J� `-, i t At... h'''' I(`,.-, to i• ,>:,� ;`�kii,yA,�j;.S;., ,, Architectural Style: Minimal Traditional 4 1 4 '7 Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient 1 ,, a . ,,,=, , • .140 architectural distinction for individual designation and r7 .7. } y=$tT y F y F a it�^� i� '.� "+'� X '��rA.� e f .n�to � { e r`�.. Yp �4 r 1.; K �e i, ! r, � T�Fn16� pj bg f F NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a � �►,L > r.s� ., representative example of domestic architecture from the 4} 5 s , , r �n district's period of significance. t4 w,4,1r.14h )! , '�` + ''# a '''*"' " W,, e„...\\ . i SC -loo Square His oric Dis--ric-c k...) - - - ....J... Properties Proposed for Reclassification Year Built: 1950 Address: 235 NW 1st Avenue .... 1'•-i:' ' \ shY I ;-7;,,,.. ..,'stc-' f-r.... )11 Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular ..- / ,./. , . • .1 . it lil t 1 '' \`' . -,.......-)-- -....,-;._ "-.•-„A..:' :-.,1 . - ,41;11;.,• ., 7.:" 1. 1'ii: II', ' ' ' ,. Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks , ,, , a k. ,,-..-..,,,,„1",-.3-',„„ - ' . .,:,r; -.'''.• -...;' 'e ._ • , t -1 tl; --' 7-- ,, ii i „/ f --.:'''°'''''''--• :' . s.' -*.s''.i:i''''''`'C'. '-'-'l'•' ' ' 1 ' IV 4 sufficient architectural distinction and historical '\‘' t•,:qw-s-:_-- -•'„! I ,t 7 i ,' 'i' signifi• 1400 '41 ,..... . 4 :„14 1:-.:• , ''t ' 4-.',,,,,,411/V,, -.4-,,,,...,,i,- t 1 t''' - cance for individual designation and NRHP met‘if •-;:,-, ,s, 14i-i' .,, .,L.. - • ---tip\-. .„...i,-..,..-1'4i 4 '; 1,".;,4—'1 ,Ifiktliff% i 4 4 • ''././'t\ '',•, ' 1 '‘-- 1 1.1:•,',/- '3-5 ' .--.... 1 listing, it contributes to the surrounding historic district :,......,.....,..:., ,,,„a:4,i., .,.- • ,-.',. . - ,..' ,„•.4.,:r. ", if ,t,'..r 7 • , 'I' ' .. 1''''''' ' '' ' l'P'1-4:•ik?': ..f... "''''I through its architecture. 2008: Contributes to character ki,,i, , ---,''' ,''4.,''''.'''',:','-'111,.",-•:'-'•-'it''''' -- V".';':-'' ''''"•••e ''''' ' '''''''''''';'• -'4''' ....••• y 1:''' '' • '''; of district through its sense of scale. - "....•....-J:,.-.....,., .tti 1.'--;•", ,.; . ..„? ''" ":- . . • ..: :-''1`'--'•-,1 : 1 ".•• 4,46v . " - .- - .-..x... • • -7- ::-,:,.... . - -,-, - ‘, . ... 1 ..,,,,.,i , „,#,=„ .•:i- , /i„„_„, : ,-, -..., . , , ,, ,-.,-..., . , ,.: '...7., - - ,'...' :••':.• ,;`,...$' III •`=" . ',- , . ' '''...:' .;: '. - '", ;, .,.• ,.'. .-',1"„ ',. :... ,,,.-. j i, .I., 1 _. ../.. --.,.„., -A,05,-„*.- ••( ..f...=',:e..;),,,e- i. 4',••••.,''',-. ' — op •,,Arlya--, _ ,,, ,• ''' •14,&t, ---,:,'---taqu't -., ;„:',;r44k'-:t- .' ./i44t7VV4ZV;a';It,4:.2'' .'.,'"••• 7ct".44...'.7"-'.'.,-:.i,:t.:,`e, ' '..% N1 • ' • j‘ \,\\!'•,, \ , , ' -..-W-,it,i': ..4; • `,•'-'-!‘"`-'''''',,.. - - , ..- ,-;••,Pokr, 11k...- - ---- • ',.. --•.:-. --- -...-,,,,,,,-,:,•:.---' '' ---....,,•,.•=f;., .• .::.. _ . . --=.-: '-..-.."----,;-_,•,. •f-,..7_,:i..!..--"-`,.. ,:-.. =.•--...`:=---•;:-.,r,-,...- -- --•'- -4.-• - - -•-. e '-')- '' 'e -.,...,,,---',';''';''''',".-,?:'..2',.'2‘.•,` "„'''.,--:;,-,;,--;:-.:;. ---•-•2,-'''•.''' , .,", '•'.. '%,'1-Le.- ,',.,- -, -';'-,,,'':.':',.'`Z-7'-'.7,'q'•?%."',1, ''.:.---',';'''''. :: :'''--:,--'",-•. ',.,,,--' 04t,,,,,,:HiL A 1,,,,,!...+MOPI......* s , . , ...„,,,.. Address: 48 SE1st Avenue • Year Built: 1955 ' ,,, . - ..:, , ,._ ,-,,.....,,... .: '"''' :-.- .......-- -%-'7:-::•..--',.:.,,..1,,-..•..-;-;.f '''-'17 ',.`" :'-'. . -.. --_,--7.-......z.-z1-'4.„,-„ --- , . . ,,, Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular • . ., , ' ki, .....1,1,1.4..,,,-. : ..„ , Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to character of district . , ie*...+'-':;,,,,%-,;.,,,,,--,.'-'il- ,:ly,;:•I'i,) ,, - 2'1..-1-,'''''''i'''',4 .iii,V:q•I'. ,341 i 1 ., . -- "-' '''''"-' .- -, ; through its sense of scale. 1 . .,.**.4., ;...,t..7."44..,•a-.: - . l''''- - --• - - i ' — 7,1.1...4.tg,.., '!Li , ' 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient •tizi..4:477,---: . - . , , ..ingo...„.,......7,,,79.Ffs! • • • . architectural distinction for individual designation and - i.::,•.,?::`,-,,:,',:t. .--:`,..•..c.L;.z.",:iiii::::: NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a -,g,H113,..1?.:R.-4,,,,,i-,,,,iE,772,,t:,,If3:.,..,,,4 :,:,,,,,.i.:::?,. .•,,,:-,1,„.71;„?t,:.,-i.'-'2,3,1.5.,,,.,..*4-,,,'!'4,::.i,1.1,..:•;:,,I.,,,i''',.;,,..,,,y,'.N-„,„,c,,,l,,:„.:_':7,;;;y:::::',',2':',-...-,,,,:;",.;',,,_::k...,1,:',..-,•.,--..,!,;; . .0,-,' ,.1,7,-41?-',.-. .,.4-f.f.v.:.,,,,If-,:7....--g-,:-.'..,-..q,,;..,-,,,=„:-.•::-. ,.„---., ,,-,.,:,...,,, .,, ..-,,,:•/4,-.„..,-..,.:‘,..,,,- .-y, . -,•w,e4at -:,,e.:-.4-.11 --,--r':4:r, .,r= -..r-.•,...„-. 7 representative example of domestic architecture from ‘..,--;- ,- ., , er i,',.Y.,qz0,4..." '-''.- '',:4','''!-",',-‘-v-f".;..a.`4.;i:,i,,...-:2_,;;:;`,.,/.,,,',‘,,',,•c, ,,!...,-:I -r..•;',47.0-#.:tlaul;,-;'- 7„,...44 the district's period of significance. - -, ,..'.0.:,'''iits;41144,`4;`,.4/1q4'04SA'A4-i4;4•;"?:1„.Ike''el-t':';'''':41'01 ' '''''t"'•!1'..!,.'-'1,..-2,:',/ ! . , .' 4^;',,-,,t2 ".,P,,,t-'1,•=irit•e'rq=i:Vt'rr:0-!'-''''''‘- '''',"'''''' i*U'-';''''' ''''''''''V''' ` ' 111- 1,14/14 . ---- - 1 OIcT:.Sthoo Square Historic ns:2- A .z c m tg::l-0Ikt.'•a.f..,..':l? -,uNEi;i.;.!».. U.J9.:YC a,-.:�„ .w..,e. :::�W.,n '.,at.....:h.i. ii'.u:'W.�C Y.i.. e:6.�,.i.�..:.., ...r+fie::.. .rr.rnN.,.+n,f...'Yn.^L.>iX'>."i%.txnY.,n VY ......♦ . ... ... .v.-.._ .. 2+... n.......;.7'F}HS.. '.:¢r..•C,di.4ac;!x+f,??4nY✓A.''.ia.hl� Properties Proposed for Reclassification r'l r ' . x J,F f '' "- 'P $;0.,r` Fr ,1 :'' {^ al 4.40,'„� = Address: 181/2 SE 1st Street/102 SE 1st Avenue ! t ' fir` ' 0; .i c ;_. '�` '� ` '; ; fl .4ir* 1 Year Built: 1925/55 rr�}h r tad � t14��xKuf{SI iy �� I''s\ ,:„ r r t '7 t', , fe.4 �" \1?..x\t, , --, Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular P t �,, 5 ,. 6 4, N •y; 4 Y41''' Evaluation: 2005: Although this buildin lacks sufficient �^ y ,r 1 4.41;ri ,t trh�t »-fit# ' > "ks` p L7 gtT :aF 11 crS K {"rr, �✓. fp�, , a r i\�'7 £1 � :k t ~ , ^''•' fh % 4; i+ 1‘1,..,Ki, x ,, architectural distinction for individual designation and > ip<{�✓,5 l y 'r'i.�.. r f .. 1 -,- 'Fw P ,ttt.r' t ' )J?' L a „}- ' ,� ,i,,,� P NRHP listing, it still contributes to the district as a i J t ' ' .4 r � a t ` representative example of domestic architecture from the Y t` ,r " ••i x' i,, r t ` . r O.,,10..,,,t`r k i.rl l� t ` Iy I‘,'' 4'7`-�y',--'t '` ' '`' 'I ' "'� .• IV district's period of significance. r,itr ' ,,1 /J. \ is ,+l u. ,` Nl. it, 1 , , {i ,I.'I4-xf ' •, I `a ,r ' -2^ 1 J) 1987: Fair.Condition. f Y r '''1�4 1 ' 1 Y' f ,4 r r �� r` t r 44,, 4� rx ; `- "` `» . .„1- ' Note: Building noted as 1925, and added onto significantly in 1957,with l'- ' tfit=', `4y r�a9 tc4't, Ate'tgA,t,��►i,� „igiteat� t*. .' ` .; r remodeling complete in 1944 and 1950. Identified as a contributor on �.: r ' „ r map from 1988 j a t e 1 ', s% y' r r "Pi yr f o.sr f, fk J- it-, „1 J Y r yr' , ... r..,. ;. 'Y, .y'1,'• .�;Yr{�y.".; p i r.�t\,Ur rk f } >� ' ' 4.k £r r ^ 5'fit,� '\�" P�a;A OrC.b{�,r��`rl"` ,�7 i •Ar '}" °,4, { yi,,.' F ' J 7 lY r 42 CI t+w 4 �tP i+ai y .,,F r'as.++Y C r.m.'+.Ad Yf +�sQ; �3, 7 L%`�'21 1 C... ,,/ Ir i'_J*R ..�."1.i f YI'L ,,4v '''' + jr i1 t.: j.4 s",'''1 �t?'Ke^i..f '''S' Yt rY£.'4**, V �� ., i I'',�,I1 r ii r 2s Address: 21 NW 2nd Street Year Built: 1950 r ,„"a1.Y' ,\`'',+,�,r ` _,'.I, ' � w r' -`1 Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular .\ Y '1., ., Evaluation: 2005:- Although this building lacks sufficient s , ,,,110 � , • - I ,. ,,, ,. architectural distinction and historical significance for w ?: .r, ' 1 `J` I A�� , ; , ak.-xs t..,), r r x+y..... 1II I .— j 11 individual designation and NRHP listing, it contributes to ; - : the surrounding historic district through its architecture. )1 I . 1 1 !! 11 1 i k ` j[ ; ti ' ,Note: This building was relocated in 1990 from 106 North Swinton , ,.._ , , i j I II I Avenue when the structure at 102 North Swinton Avenue was `; enlarged on the North and converted to office-use from single- , ! family, h ft'i it .s e s y.4 Old SSquare .Hisoic Dis .:ric .r.g., -3a''*,9"..cA AA Properties Proposed for Reclassification n `n '' Address: 15 SW2na Street Year Built: 1950 ` '1 . ' '`',''.I Architectural Style: Minimal Traditional Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to the character of the district " F ,' . , through its sense of scale. `if^°fib+ ,, '* ,.4*' l r 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient architectural ', '"'A s ,.,�'' `'" distinction and historical significance for individual i; - j , t�'° • desi ation and NRHP listing, it contributes to the . x - gn A. ' ref ;j; l ;x .•' ; ' ,. 4 surrounding historic district though its architecture. r i s^1 � a-c• "• x+Af,Zy ��""k ,. r ..6 r�. rd `T („.., p . f t s' r. , a t rt- tt > }x �� x," F aA ..u Y o w f. ' -...,.. . .: .,,,t -p,7 .:k t 4i� w _f•'V'�,,r 4 °tp i, tfi a � � fr fP:i��.h °u�.�r+'Crr�$'��i ,j`,3': �{�'r¢ e.f F�`' k. l J.':aiiky t' r 4 3> •rz't ` ;z"Wit" ' p s ,s 'n ,tin .t,t y V '.4 ar,''�t� 'k,.{- 1. r, ,` rif• l ,,JJ `.?1,•'� „1 c }\, :.4,t p s =411 �t It�v ••;f1,,':''TM•(a, '1' ' • .�1'' i A kT. '1' N. v.t-LTA `L.1,c}'[.:<.E C,? �e-.3.14(1v: ;:. -.+-.,.•.-.^rr[ .u.+nay.s- 'xcw -awmne+rr e+�w .,va's,—�..-,,, mmi. c ft• y •* 7', t,fR0� 'S i ' S: aria �+4 r "�f k 4,AriP,� ? + *s 7. �� x}4 K I lyi , il'p'�N.„44 *e rr. ,5A,_ yf �� r,•CY i`'4y�„��v.f7,` 9 \ y �.. .c .li` '*.}Yr r ,w��'yi41 , f a ,M SS'(}i ;,, r v.: a iz?4 t.rE ,�3�!rfrq�'4t�✓�� { rE X fis..�4r.alYd4-�y�;� 'f'""jk , Fxf: � i` +�r` •.,�airit'.C-7r c: .'tt�'•- 5�3•, ' �z 'g r #S{ t,ti 7r�:f �. w rZ •7k l4.?:.;: .�i lS 0,: air {�.� 1'a 1T. • JVart t;I h, f r ' 'SIC 4 M'Sf. y a 1� 7 J ' r a f r rs-� *+tn.?{fir'}.'"! �i' ,p � �'{_e7 'Y S i � � ,''"qa" � `�i�t#�,��t..r��. Address: 8 East Atlantic Avenue Year Built: 1950 ., rn,� �� -- l, -ramoL ,• £ =a, ,2;fr .p �'��t T Aft i°' `if.'t '°• i:, �' ., w Y11 G+. ti '' �{ a Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular �^` ' � y "` �' �'� ' �c4f i; r ar Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to historic district in its P $; Yrr.r ,.e ' �i stylistic features and scale. �, ,-p .. , ' ,A„ .,:� , '�£x k`i 2005: This building possesses sufficient architectural ` r ' ; i. •�` •� = 1 ' 4� A.• 'f' distinction anii historical si ificance for individual ,' __^= '� _ `>.4' !."n � ,` , A significance ,;,,r --t r-- .a-.nib" .iN'k. .i p� ®` "`1 f `� local designation only. It contributes to the district as a \ ,',/..-,� ... , �I g y ,/.;. 4 L. representative example of commercial architecture - - . ' r, ,;�,.,,,,, "' `' �"1 s" from the period of significance. :; i - -- , '�w • , i„, _ _ __ , 0 d Sc lion Sqii ' re Historic Dis--ric-t Properties Proposed for Reclassification .i iyvk.2 '' ;1,,,,:.--1 ' L' Address: 16 East Atlantic Avenue ??,,p,',i,„..,;.::, •. .. ., , -,•*.t..4, 41.:. Year Built: 1950 ,t, % 'p,..4-1;VA . .$'• , ' 1A..4 . . t. t .c.r.,,_' - t: , ,'ill'i,r-i: .‘::'..,;,41::k.';A>044'4! '''''': Architectural Style: Art Deco/Moderne •.,,,. <,,,••=i• 9•t, .,. .•.-, , ri t.,4t-•:•,,,, ,,,...-,.1' .''.1 ','‘.,. 'i.,' •kr;13**),Ik...$*),,,!;-401% ''' 4.,f. • ;,*.:*:: :''',7k..,•''' . '' -----4*'3/4 q,,,,i4,-.44.: 11;.4;ft4til: Evaluation: 2008: Contributes to the historic district in its ' •tu.',..,,..',341'.,,r ,., , t--- i r -.., v, .;,.4:-.' 4 A , *13. '','11 V'',•7‘f.g,.,P.l-,-!.-')',-%4,;(..'.i.:-.-.!i T-(r'-1i;,.li-,.-,t.-:-,:r,,-k.T,.tk-4,i.,,-.'.----t'7-4r-:,,I-'-1•'.'VT,..•,;:'-:.-••,,•,—p4J-.'..---..1...-.--2-L-I- ---_-,_,--;.--.•-,'-"'-"•--'•'-.4, '4,,,'.11}..<:,; i2i..,nCi‘.fI'';''L.''.1....i4 stylistic features and scale eAta- : 07 ,i , - ?, ,•4i = r . 0 i ' , ,? e2005 possesses sufficient architectural distinction & historical i'el Y.-••••42.4Viirro ;12'; • -';g1:4-4.4-414 W - significance for individual local designation... contributes as , t , I . I r•-• representative example of commercial architecture from the \--' ' -r,t.10‘-‘c, 7-•?,,,,r,,, .7 ,-pg..4v4•4',,`''- -I ..: _ r., ,I r . ...../ • 1 -------4 1; '' :741; '''.----1 — ,i•-,.• • ; 1999. Located on Delray Beach's main thoroughfare ..is --,,.,-;.,,,,, .,..-,.,,'„-tti.,..-1 „ ,„---•,,,--, ,,.... ,,r-!fl:7:41-1 titr. , e, , -* i• , *,-,:•\ ':!.....,.,.,., "- •, ' ', '....,,-,• "':',,, ' • •• '''''. 1 V , 2-2.1 4'4 • • --- • 4 , . -• - representative of the city's historical commercial , \#. , „...... ;-„,...- ..•,,;-...•:A.,-•:‘,..,t.:'-',--,,..4.,- 4 architecture illustrates the early 20th century development of , ,. „1,,,, , ,,,•-'t L -,, ,,,',-, .,.•...'.- , • , ,..' . . , t:, ',,,„• ,,' . ,...,-'t , ..t, t...1- ,' i...-•-•'-f.--, .---.c' ---.,-.•-•-,•,,,.7.I.--'..--. :4`4,4[;' ,-,':.';•Z.:'L i.:".../;`,' ,--: V-;;;::,..=: ,',.' '1:4-,`,.:'',,r.i. Delray Beach's central commercial area could be considered a contributing resource within a local historic district.. -.• •• • ....,. , • " -,-,'i'.7.4t,-.v-s,..ti...,l,..,...,p,,'.k,•.,.%,f.t,•,;:;1&i1r..e.iV,-,, ,,',41.'..., „.., : ,-,-- 4,:,.k.„.,,,,,,,,,k. „,....iiira•toNtirfiit 4i,...4'flo ,,,,,• r. Y., : ,:,;,. -, 41. *,,.. .3A-i,,, •1‘,,‘.',!,:',' Address: 38 East Atlantic Avenue Year Built: c.1955 ME, ,t ? #,r .1, N.• .. ,„, .NI •,<-,.'-,,.- ,./;,,,k, ..p.,:i.--..,n.' t•s-gx" Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular , ,J.,:st ,:',.,-„•-.1,-;lint.,..kk.-,... -.- ---f-;4' 'Y' ?"'', .4 ';',}47.,;`. • 1 'c u'*."-'i 'lf::' S• -,,"/-''.1.;e' ' 1;•-,1:: •,-. ,..-',' '4 4,- Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a representative N:'1,''t2::',',.;.4)i 2" ::2"':'' "2' 22' ' 2. ',''.' ' '•'1 .*'" --' t 42I'2 ...,-Ic 1.2,, • '2.-_22 - ,; 2 • t•'iz 22. ,22•., 22'2- ' ' ... 22.2.-'c....2° -2 -. •••-.2 -222-,.---“,- example of domestic architecture from the district's e• • awe 2- ,,e2•:`-2-,,,,2,,,,..:„ ... - 2 A- 2, - -•,-2..,,,,,•.-,.„-1 period or ,,, . • .1- Vts •..?...ap-i significance. 1999: Located on Delray Beach's main thoroughfare,••• is lig_ , 8.[ ,t,-...,1 ' rs-:,..„,,--.,. 1 .. ,,,I 1- ....• . . . . . . representative of the city's historical commercial architecture also y w,,, • , wite.,- - , - , ,, „ , , ,,, „, ., ,,' illustrates the early 20th century development of Delray Beach's ------- , „,e = -- 2,,,, ..•;.,„.-..•--',,,:::-.,.,•, I-, . -.4"-: 't, . . •..... - :. . ---, ,., - •,,- central commercial area could be considered a contributing - -- •,',•.., ..,' ,,-- - , --- .. ...--.------ , resource within a local historic district.. -k4 -,-z - ' -J-,•••,•.r,,,,.,,.-,. . . . .. .. . . . Old School S4uare District Properties Proposed for Reclassification x''' . ' •', T - Address: 10 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1951 •r tab _ , , , s= t _ Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular fotisio Evaluation: 2005. Docs represents the historic and ` �' `1�t, `r , �ffi� f development of commercial fast-food preparation, post Ns World War II commercial architecture, and car culture in �1 �''•;�1RJ lV jj f / tI t( t�� ` , r ' � ''_1 7/ ` n -, r` - ; `xa 4 ' ; Delray Beach. It maintains integrity and contributes to the I. i ``- surrounding historic district. i'° k. b g r ?. r.N 66 �Y 11s 7 fy/ 4 'ti j ,- ,,.,,"ems,#, ti ��- •Jyi '_�1•Y R } • R ;. '� '9 Y:L 4 '> .wt S..i. ; ; Y.�r-,,. .r'P,. *s i t ,V'' 55.0'.xy ` "ISA ti.'f ,�� 4 evs. s. .tz r, \` ;i ft•. 3.t 4 0, ::'sKa r..r A n, , ,rt. Address: 227 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1950 Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular _ - µ U. c •.•- s r Evaluation: 2005: ....due to its modest architecture, it doest;', /. ''� `, ' '' t , ,01s �"-_ r : : y z contribute to the historic district as an example of -, V r • t . . , t, e, s-iv, , ' k t Y 1 a f • , ?x R domestic architecture from the period of significance. 1 ;r 4 � �, 4 R a'} 2001: ...associated with the developmental history & r ro ti d t , r" exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School ,- , .. ,i ,, •,1, Square area during the 1950s. Due to its historical and sat s 't .'e>•!,:P t'g , '• architectural significance...could contribute...when the h l'd4 40;• hit historic district is re-evaluated and the period of ' try significance is expanded to include later historic resources. • NM NM • / 0- d Schoo- Sc tiai7e His-Anric Dist---° i- ' .ca.« rJ •r:a.r.:Z.S ,.:. nt,.+,.:.. ,5 �.�,..:.: ra:c+ -__ .�-=o^+ .._aze- `�Y."hx..s�_ =`�fw�+rssv,'+Fyx...,,q,. ..... .... N.,,,,.,.s,..„4,,,„,,..+ :47±+ii+w....."ur 'M„,.........,;;tin:.nY.0.,7G.y.„...rt,..7 Properties. Proposed for Reclassification ' , R �� Address: 255/65 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1945 wi r �? ��•�,R f r Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular '� " � :ftri �'' Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a ., _ lit --, ': .., �'�; � ,Yi fd, •� -�`,r, ,>w.. s.. > ,di t . , representative example of domestic architecture from the i, k t 14, -2 , . l tP, ,,(;,A, ,,' district's period of significance. �1,, _ ` , F.*, ,,l.E4:: " , ,T' {';'-' 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and ' ►.r.am. �� „ f .:4 fi� " ' " " . exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School 1f ;e �.:'�? a t1 �+ ; .� "t 'x1 I *fir e , a ,., 1 1 ,a , '.,•�,��. Square• during __.; area the 1950s. .Due to its historical and f ` .. architectural significance...could contribute...when the T , s, historic district is re-evaluated and the period of ' u° s,i '.. ;-: sa' r••e. #-�4,j ,v .t, .,z� .. x x - a ;,:: y '- ` :wA k�' ��: "� Gt' '-' ` '' ,� -4;. ,',T significance is expanded to include later historic resources. 4 °' Tx"`-�r+; fi .I, '3,.4il'4il ,, Gk4 1 S.Ge,,, �'+:•-z- ` , V,7',aetll "Riq� Address: 314 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1947 ., 44, I 1 { Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular . �•i� j.41;1, 4'''�£'� ' V,' Evaluation: 2005: it contributes to the surrounding ��ii . , .1'1 ;,1N' i1 at;{ ,,,r, gg9• �t R e N � .wit ` L a - r j,� � w X; historic district through its architecture. ` , Est 44. „ ( ' {P�k ,,• �-e . t.�r $ si -(1l£4 _: fi . E �� 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and v67,4 i;, i k- a'� t r41 y t t °v t'; ,o. a ty x.r R.: .a.'h'1 rY F exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School pl i" )t r , • ,� t fi a* ',ix x,fl,P,� Square area duringthe 1940s. Due'to its historical and - it ' ' • • �' q ."`•4�. ry `Ig �• j y • h t A t}lty? architectural significance,...could contribute to the t4-•say i4-' x °-' i . .1-< . '' �19ti4ti*-, ,} ,.44.R • + �" - -e F, • 1, }, Sri i 8:4 locally listed Old School Square Historic District, when ry r, ; `' 4 °:` + .r, "gip t the historic district is re-evaluated and the period of , u. '* �., ;, '� , significance is expanded to include later historic '{•�",. `\ P;� ,; resources. ..- t^.4 w.w.y+ r t ` ` :s� k• , — -- ,....,, ._. : a .. _ .,_ _c oo uare is-:o_- ic is-LricL ......... sm,a`Al‘.....0.27.0eAte al '!...1N-tri.4w Pt.....04 Properties Proposed for Reclassification Address: 317 North Swinton Avenue tr-- Year Built: 1950 Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular t41ti '1,,.. ,tt. ,, 1 I (4 AY •Is!rt.'41043.,e ,. /4 ilY 1-"Iliv k , N'• ,L- , Evaluation: 2005: Although this resource lacks sufficient kjft,_4'',. i • f 1'`,.y,.,,,41r;ei,i, -.61.4!,,;.. •''',,,f ,ei ''.. 'C f 4 \ #:A '1 ..... ' :4''1?al architectural distinction for individual NRHP listing or local ,',if ite,,t.i.t,1 designation, ut it contributes to the district. f : c. t-.!...^.-,),,f.. ';';-,--,,,' ' ....,,--;.!,-; ,:, ‘.,4,:ifii,, 147-1 -"p.,,,."1--`• i to.• I,..ri-;• 11:''''''-', ;,.• z., : -*, —'.,---'''Olt- '--- , ...----''', 77,,kt cwwiltf 3„ 13 'Ai.‘,\ -....„, 46 11.. "... yin ph ,, 0,0',.•.i , 'Oil • - ' 'i.4 (;',. • ;'.)... -t.• ;Oita -,-- ' _ ..., _ .•:-sr•v /te *.•4,.. ...t-17,••••-v--7-- ' • iz' ---,:.-- ."*.vo-•s.., ,..„' • .5-'4, -; -14,2-e1+;4-/.0.,,,, 1 '' - ,'.'.",'. islit ' I 4''''''•1,I- . s 2.:-141--:61--- ,, , 1:71Lill'4, ' 1•74.V.--4'iil,t ,...,;, 4$,i,k1 ,z1, *,-.'',,--,-;4's...,irl. - `., -4, 1:.' .s,,p44.,,,,.,:,...0, 1* . 4P44. e-7\tx,...,..-'--.P•.' ;0'1.1 :... ,-4.170€.,-,,,,,04 ::,, ,a,‘..,---,,?;.• A.,,t,..i.41 fa---,,t,,,,..." .....,--...,,- ., 43.1 'el.3.1f3,3 ,43.I." s4tr$ SilbIS'?'4•44 . s''st.."' 33-ttlriffrIr .A.''' 442.41.4.,', 43333'43$44!3C.g.3 . '3.33' . .3. It'dr00.,‘07..oria ,7 -404,(3,.....,114,'Z'a,"1„grl , ' f taPs.•4te.0• Af' a''.`r Ir.%' A Pi,-ex'-,,P ,,;,44,,e' -.I 1,AN-1.-',--c?4,-:',5,*-FIV"---"4w‘ - . '-'4°''',"'' •-7-,4 ,L. g'Iv'r‘.,t,t4:- 14441.0,.c.:A': •,,,t71,...g 1.....V.4 k,, 40 .., *"..:"*.,. VA.. ••''',t'. ....... Built: Address: 333 North Swinton Avenue Year 1946 ,i0 .....„, &,,, .„....";,,. i : • .,.. - ,,, 9,.to ".„0„,,e ...• , Architectural Style: Masonry Vernacular 'rib:, riv /Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest .i ir. _ „:-:.„1!.11.,..,„4,4r...4.;,.. ''''k;,,,-ft-,L.-‘,‘,YeiiiigA.,_ ',,,'-:„ ---.__ ' ,, • ' "4 , ,Z1 t example of domestic architecture from the district's period of ' i, "Ar ' , .' V, significance. , 2001: ...associated with the developmental history and i„'„, r. .....or .- exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School Square r „ , r • • • • & area during the 1940s. Due to its historical architectural . . , 1, .,,,,,,,,-;-`4`,A.Z.4 '..,".".* 2., .....=, 4-,,,,,?-,V,',,-, ....-., ,-',-. -,:% ,,, • , r significance, this building could contribute when_ ... the .4. . , '''‘'''''T 1 • ,) ...-V,...„-• ,,,, ,.. , r•.—-r, '-' ,',".'**,:*'1::,:.? j,''4:-,:- ' ' ;' . :", , :',' ', L' historic district is re-evaluated and the period of significance tx ::.,,,,.„.,,,,-,,,,,,, ,,,,,,. , , , .. , , , _ ,, „ is expanded to include later historic resources. , .,:',,,,I,N,,,A.„,,I.,.., , ' Scliool S ua:e Iis :o Aic IJisric : u:....k.°.:., t.,. .,n:,'m f✓�.t''.i Y.e4?':�. ..v r.:' .rv. r c,.:., ..:;,...P. . l:•i .),.:..?Yes;•. t a. .Y..:. ee..t.;.:c:,�. ..y..�,.t%.1 .. ....�aiJ.v.'.�. `!S*Q ).yT.'ry.::'•#:b ...:•t' ^f',ti. .J r_..,; 5..: _ ve!.F^:1 ,Fq-.1,.: d,4 r' a_%iN�.r Properties Proposed for Reclassification `r\ r c �,, „, , Address: 337 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1945 '�� ' : �,,`,�'`,j�� ` + �, Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular fi. "N,L\ e,, 1)4 ' Evaluation: 2005: Although this building lacks sufficient 1 t,s t X rG � `� � , ,, , K .w �-��., �.:��t � �� - t architectural distinction for individual listing and , "r , ,,, , k ` . , tic I� 'i a=5 v it ,, , designation, it contributes to the district as a modest b +'aih'` " s' ;'3,` r "�; example of domestic architecture from the time period of p � i 7 gy f 1 IttIII" ;4 w' w , °. Y , �.,,� � significance icance. v t r � L • 1985 1986• Good: Condition o wi ias, • F NR w� 1 3 � •}' tr`4 !�RPi"' h(1 t•4 'yyx rh ..x' 4+f*. ...1,--e. ‘..-',..:"..,,,,,,,,,-..,,,.,,,,-,- --..--,:z.,-.„....--,.,- ,,,..-.,.--,-,..:‘,..,.,,,,,,.., =-__„..,-„,--,.,„-... ,, . 't1' ''' r ,-.,...,„,,,,,. .. . ...... .,.,,,,,,i,,,,,,, . :,,,,,,.,,,, .., .,„, ,d,,,.„..,. ....,,.„4,1„:-,;,•1/41---',,4. -- "4,,i,•4A,A. At:A.-,,--fr, ,sty Y- 3 n Y „l 4,t per '�7-rf sx. < �'`� Address: 353 North Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1948 �e, `�•�� .� � �`�� "�', ��1 ,4 �-� X. n+a (i,,,,,,c yk 1°k y"+ � f.Ci ,, ^3`2,y' Yl ''_: ..,. 'LA' lr,'y, , _ , t_ ' f.;,1—a. Architectural Style: MasonryVernacular s . e � .s ,W,,, • ' ;_` .,tr , ,,r 4:�x n ty s o- i,. *, ; , n g t + fro rey 'fa,,f) Evaluation: 2005: .contributes to the district. -. , , „ 4E e1. ' 0 yip cr �¢ ,� t 4. Y .. �� t � �.saz . 7�Is' � a. •�" I 2001: .•associated with the developmental hist y T 4 ,q wit' - a' . exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School , < ,� 7 fy`. •}4 - 4- ^ , + , .' n S x K r.7, $� j` ' y;:'' 7 �n'f. 5 , , f�' ,,,,Y}y '4, � `4 ..t ,V Square area during the`1940s. Due to its historical and �Y ',ti °7; '� ,, ,.,} ',, architectural significance, this building could contribute, � *�{r rt TYk w ,,, + .. r `- . r . ---t�.,+•..«f•a�;'> 1�.`' .„ ''4 -� ,.. A ...when the historic district is re-evaluated and the period , - ' t�=-4; g- =c - -- - �--,- of significance is expanded to include later historic resources. f ; 0-. C_ School Square His yogic District Properties Proposed for Reclassification Address: 27 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1950 Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular k • I _ 1 Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest .. - - example of domestic architecture from the period of - .� ,p ;,1 •significance• �� Y 4 11 i t`�Y r a f 7� rs 4 '? art" : y L "1t000k M , !e• - 91.:. - 3 Mom. h l .. 4{" ,L: e� F : y{ 1 'l 1.;S ia A,),,, Ift v, t1r '�' .tr . ,e, kii,, ,'Its'' .t..t"x 7 . y,t a t: 1 y.,'''„ ,4c ayc 4.,, 4 , 4A f4 .,.r� le. K r ik i.^`, r 4.7.,q Y�ii 5 . r ''l i 'S r75, J .1r Z•'t -.a x.+aKi t 4 7 a r ^?,Pl a i...l5, 07"*47;t4:6'.'47 :ii''',•11',"ata'''';.^.74A1**4"' •�' >S� �y"�� yt�,�+�+ r�,a sa"4ro'V�}"�:��j` '��;}""t 1 � ,fir'? N' '0 ,€1"Znc x rart�- rA + ? "1-y F„e {'linrSr` ,T`yJ(! q ,h ,p� .-,.m..� 1. -0if -.k y4,,.� L1ai,3,�+"2. . 74,,..-1Ia r of -r '` - tU:.-P,t,tt , t'hr`ly"v..,'. ,Y' e�gt i.M,,e' a��. ✓{`d'r�Ibitt '�K�` .( tf}470,'' tA,trd 4Yf' :4•tA t a ,q ' Address: 119 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1948 . ' „�ti�y Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular Evaluation: 2005; ...contributes to the district as a modest , .� m t z FIN example of domestic architecture from the period of . + /.,-.- '} I 1( „ .- n .mom ■ _ 4l4 5'� <`I \ 1 f significance. ,� ,,, '' 2001: ...associated with the developmental history & -':. 4r r . exhibits the architectural" elements of the Old School f 5 - 4� a •Square area during the 1940s. Due to its historical and `"n h,'` f" t , ,„,.,. ± p. r 4 �' �, r-.4 5 ca s �u a �` s ,C,, x r *5,.33 architectural significance,...could contribute when the .a a`, °�=r;1 ,'-�� ; ��, ,,,,,� , `', ,,_.- ,,;x5�4,, d {� ,�, historic district is re-evaluated and theperiod of s ��,,,t �' jx 3 y �s t" ,�. : , •, „M , o : �� '�J 1�'n��'�.{.•�� .53x" '1 Y '<'"Jti.�" )7Y:t a'tis i Y"f, Any , .x F significance is expanded to include later historic resources. }r r' ,k,`'� y. � ` ', 4 ' `-i :" J. Old Scool Scuare Historic Dis :rict .., n J... ,.: .,x, ,I. ,,..:,.r v"e.. •G.�'+..a _ ,:'. ...F�a.,.,l..i,4 .1C,".Jr-t ..m ar>TA.. r 01,.F w„✓#'...,,.4, 4. ...r v u.Ya !.y+V, r...1. ae t ,.. dLa,. , .,P **AFL.7eiT .....v41.:XJr1:Y...+....ry.TK,..t[..:.� F 1 }.. �,.s4 �-..,. ,:P „ .t S 0.."". xt*..r..7! Ff�MTB:kI'." i..V�'T^�" F•. i),:.f:� . '"., n r �tl.i fi�F*P_„ J .:A a,� , Properties Proposed for Reclassification 7. Address: 123 South Swinton Avenue Year Built: 1947 1 Architectural Style: Frame Vernacular : �' ` .1,� 4''7'/ ' Evaluation: 2005: ...contributes to the district as a modest ' '� W 'Mita _i t'' '� x �.{ example of domestic architecture from the period of 1' a "„ 'r-•-•--� --,,. ., .F ' t.if`{1, •• 4 fr,V,f, .: . significance. 14, * r 7 1 T '„ • r F ,e ��yy 1 yj 1. ill 11i 31 i'id li rG r ,1 J ,x�'w�r P 3 ,,M >~ ,t 11 4 a rIIi f �� 3 ' ;) � i e tt,r trill F ti r: rr t r1111111� , iM1 r,a'� n ??4,,'t , - t A1""b fs y f7S rk J �f -,. r .-.a erg..,*.,441.-f." ' fie "'l y ,�-. fir._.,.7 `� : .�'f3{� - - rtr 'x�Y,tM'F"< t ,t5 r r J, +a, �f4,,. '•, r-.'', s-Yr 'i' • t s, r y , t� ,. d,o.An ti ,> L«'�r ..,.; le I * ! ....V t •.,. +;r i xY °s Slj i , r , h. f a r. F,n Pf , f < * r ', `r , � =' 6 2 1' Scaoo_ SqLare Hisoric Defining Contributing and Non-Contributing ❖ Contributing: A structure which adds to the historical architectural qualities, historic associations, or archaeological values for which a district is significant because it was present during the period of significance of the district, possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at that time, is capable of yielding important information about the period, or independently meets the National Register of Historic Places criteria for evaluation. o NRHP: Generally, properties eligible for listing in the National Register are at least 50 years old. Properties less than 50 years of age must be exceptionally important to be considered eligible for (individual) listing. (See Criteria Considerations.) • Non-Contributing: A structure which does not add to the historic architectural qualities, historic associations, or archaeological values for which a district is significant because it was not present during the period of significance of the district, due to alterations, disturbances, additions, or other changes, it no longer possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at that time or is incapable of yielding important information about the period, or it does not independently meet the National Register of Historic Places criteria for evaluation. o y _ Sc_i_oo,,. Distnc-:Square Histo is i nTNs 4.'N.�` NJ,f:,"..iFs. t1w.,Cr ..Pt7.ri'. `-.. ,5..,:✓a ,�::w .: 3 .r,d:. .c 1:f1.. dA.':."'.a.S. DVd'ii,A+u ..^w1 V.#n. ,r a:,1.» sex,::i i<'4�rqS,"»I, .1r4.fD:N.;.', .,..Q r"O/f.7.A, n .:..'G-... '"t.'rda=.1.., .. ,...Y„t;... e,:.4..ff:{S+1:b7.':..1 :;,.u.'.1J,'y,,:':;iW'< Review of Contributing and Non-Contributing • HPB review required for all exterior improvements within a designated historic district which includes Contributing, Non-Contributing, and New Construction/Development projects. ❖ Review criteria is the same with the exception of demolition requests. The LDRs require that requests for demolition of Contributing structures submit the following: (a) Certified report from a registered architect or engineer documenting that the building is structurally unsound and is damaged beyond the ability to repair it at a reasonable cost. (b) Certified report from an engineer, architect, general contractor, or other qualified professional documenting the projected cost of repairing the structure and returning it to a safe and habitable condition. (c) Appraisal of the property in its current condition, its value as vacant land and its potential value as a preserved and restored historic property. (d) Documentation that reasonable efforts have been made to find a suitable alternate location for the structure within the City of Delray Beach to which the contributing/ individually designated historic structure could be safely relocated. + Many items may be approved administratively rather than reviewed at an HPB Meeting. Old School . District Benefits of Historic Preservation (General) ❖ Less impact on the environment and on infrastructure and reduction of sprawl. ❖ Less neighborhood opposition. Neighborhoods are much less likely to oppose a project to restore a building that has been in place for 50 or more years than they are to the construction of a new building. ❖ Protects the architectural and historic character of buildings or neighborhoods. ❖ Greater property value appreciation than comparable non-designated areas. The fact that both residential and commercial property values increase in historic districts has been demonstrated by studies across the country, in communities that vary greatly in in designated historic districts than non-designated areas, occasionally they are the same, but in no instance are the rates of appreciation lower. It is the design review requirements of designated historic programs, which are responsible for this difference in value. Old School Square Historic Dis :r cf t N} x1.5:"4C w'A . : ..i•., r ._ ... .r .:'n .., ., ',.. x.. _ . .. . .. .. Wk•..i..S sl l r i. i 0vk n S u .,.,,..I. ,. 1 a.U'ri-Y.l.M 1R,.,nr'Wt 1. V. f ..,,... r ._ . r P. r •4...T..!G..r. . Local Benefits of Historic Preservation ❖ Ad Valorem Tax Exemption Program Contributing & Individually Designated o Exemption applied to City and County taxes. o Exemption based on structure's increased value resulting from completed improvements. o Interior improvements qualify o Include additions to contributing structures and/or detached new construction on a contributing property. o Available for all uses Single-Family Residential, Retail, Office, Restaurant, etc Variances to the Land Development Regulations - Contributing & Individually Designated o Properties not in a historic district seek variances at the Board of Adjustment (BOA). o HPB variance criteria looks at historic nature of property. o BOA review requires basis of a hardship. ❖ Review Fees: COAs (non-site plan associated), HPB variances, and designations NOT INCREASED in 2009 with other review fee increases. E ,.x a >r_• z�.: .,,.r _ ; .xr:. , ..: s•._ :r..u._. , ,_.r.u. ._,:_. ..:,�_.. , ., ..x.. . .. Fw .,r.;u.. ,„ r •..,� .ra..• _.n,. . , .� ..... m r .,,.. .,r .,,...,..x. .. r.. . .x� r,. _ Community Redevelopment Agency Programs ❖` Site Development Assistance Program o Commercial Uses o Partial reimbursement for exterior improvements Old are Historic Dis :ric:` Community Redevelopment Agency Programs • Historic Facade Grant Program (Available for both commercial and mixed-use projects) o CRA purchases permanent easement to the building facade; grant funds (purchase amount) tied to building relocation and/or façade restoration. o CRA funds may be used as matching funds for other grants received for the same project. Recent program amendment permits that up to 49% of grant funds be used toward interior structural repairs. o Success Stories • Delray Beach Historical Society, 5 NE 1st Avenue (2003 8E 2007) - Relocate 1926 Bungalow and restore exterior; relocate "Hunt House" and restore structure. • Masonic Lodge, 44 E Atlantic Avenue (1997) $45,000; Exterior restoration. 44 E Atlantic Avenue .++'k� j 4L 1 1 4 ' � * h f r,/ n., x j; n;' 1f�� _ `� r Y � � fi Y5'tr�e4sl ��;�.. I . IIf r»' �" l �.} 1�i5 �y, ;f;' ' lei Bwis ,(�„ i i �y�. {{ i Ai °' � u kp 1.• p id tk t �tr��4 , fFfz � � r#"4h �i i' 4 �' 4 1 _ �q' ylf{- -- mrrm„►Y %,71.-`... A 0.4. r .x ? ; ,. " `} ttr 1 A • � A rrIii F t V .: r , -3 n aa: f f..:iA 1 - ij �� $�:p+ tw� s��. 1920s - 1990s-Before 1990s-After * Program guidelines being revisited to see if there is a way to offer more help to nonprofits. , ,,_..., illidt,.,_.,_„.....0- ., C C 100- - c are Histhric us ric „...,, • ., ... , , ,..„ ,..... .04, ., - - i,ri*,,,,,,,,,,,, ,pr---.. ''NNZN ,, .C. • /..• • *'''..44.,>,' ..• _, - l• ',;',,v, ., ',:r..5-1 ,- .. ,- ,,, ..i‘,,.„;,-, 4,,.1, ''..t.'''.'-,-._4.- k.t.'ij- , ::' ‘, .' r;•.'`,:-:,., •,•'- •' ."' 1.,,,...-•-•.; ;---.,-,..;-----,,..;••• . .. fp.e-1 ••7.. t .c.,'.,,..-, ..,:e, -,•,.•_",..1 •-. 1._: llia A' ,: . • . _-',....1_1'.• 5, -= wt,... .•- - .' •'''. ,•.••0 0, , ii„,..,'• „•P,,,:-2.. •-•7 ...' i , •c v ,,,,, !!,.. .4„./1 ,..,,„.., kro•t•,.' ...22,.;,...5 ,..‘,.' ,•'•, , - ..- •,. .,''.i 1 1. 'Irlillk,Inir .,- ..,'11 i '111 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 ii 1 , . .....„,„,,..„.„....,,, ,,,,,,„,'"-Z‘f, • .,,....,-. •., ,,., •R-", x„ ' .t4 i. '--, • ,.'I tp•-+4...,A.1.. ‘V\\'Vle, '* '...„111 --'I, .tr.'i•-•,-,i4-.41;," E T:--• iii,--:li'1 -z:,'i.:-; *...,,,, :.,•,-------;---;:- „ 7 r„ k,',"...-r.'-'.".;41eirPitli--,Y.,...,,,,,,?,, ',;,2:S..0—.71:1,, E,.'wkstrz '•,:,'..t,se:-_ r4A.4.0-41 ..m, .. ,..1,,,....__:..--..zze 410,,,,...'41,4,.,„,ekatp, ...- --,4.1.•%.,14k.".7..... .011.,'1 ..,,,,„,,•„.,.., ....i:-., ...,,s..,,,••••••:.,.,,,tt..•••:,.-.•-0,0 , • • Ai,..!•.?s....:'I" ; • • ;,'. . ,22= -- •••-, • ...7,-..-,72,0---...1•••-•-n-f•r...m-f.• '..,- -4.'1••••••••••''*. • ii________ /1-•....,..t €. ,,," =•••.--- - • • - "--. -,'' 11•1111•11=11111111Mmoo...-,....,. + - 1,-.1.7...%Mr ,,,,, ',,,4' ,, , qt... 411.';;VIA41, 46 ..,, %. f...1.), . ,,'..k'.4.h. t:''''''?"".;";',,"'.4..,......;111- ,,,, ,,, .... ., ' , r.,,, ,,,,,,...„ s's)e, .,..." , '."„ •'-,-..,...., : ' ''' '• ....-61 ';:4- i-01 ..1.;,11 44 IU(;' 1 t..g, T." *-.t,'-'11 II. ..-".1 j,:,-1 ll'.,:.. -1 I- 'nil •.• :. - '''*"i• I I I •' •-` g•-; ,;.,-,,,r.„.- ''?,,t,„' „,,,',- f 1 .• ; ; i ..,-,•-•„' -- ---',i ' +,4 . e'1.''1,0, '' 2 ,,,,a..."• , ,' ,`,..,, , '.0.,.,,i1;•t,,i4,,,,.:1,4,1,..,,,t.,...A.SINtkl,..0 ,, ,rt.,' f, .` 4.5:4„..,;WAY;Iiii5t1'^-7,-/r4rr-,. -trA.V..fr . ' ' - . , - • • - - ,V.414"-L'Fi.A.i.'`‘..tfi:P4It4jit-,;TI.N, ' \*'••'*3/4,•' e,.„i,,', ,_,..,, .„.-:,:-.„. ,,`, "l'"''''•- l'. • ii,,k,it. y .-,,,,R.„ 41.4.4.-.-,,,,, -, ,,,,f4oll, ,. , i 1,, , , ,,4,,,,,;,, • ' ---,.- . •••• tIV.-•:i,i.i, 1,,,,, , , , .- k. .,, ,,,,, , ,.. . . ,..'Y• ..1 i '`'' ' ' -,.' te' .'• - l'-': 3.''''-''''--.21 ; •----....'"ii-,., -'(-.•/'•" -.77-3.---.------.---,:t;•:::q;ii . pa..\,; - ''‘ •• ,-...,- ,•7.=-:-.-,.',..,0-., ..--"i »,- f`‘1.-:,.. '.,--, ;'' .!..tf /..2,-..1.,,,..- ''....',:•••• .,,,..,., ,.,,,,,,,,, ,..,,J.,.., . .. ,-at."....!.,i WIt ', ,,,' i v•-,1;7: .... . 6 .. ......„.........., • :;p8.4, , '''1.,-, _ .;.. '.'-'-,'.''' "-.' , r,;4, • ,. .- .. i . s....1 rt; ,.,••••,-11.3'-.7.7 ..,..„-. „. ,-,,grj,2t,t7: f -•'-'..?;•.1''.i',`.1":'?',./1.?"..1.*."..'..,„••;',,,:v.'",....T.,.'' ,. ,-, ., • - , . , . - .F.'.s....,-.1,-=.,-.., ., ,t,'•'. ,,,,,, .. ...,.,..-..._ .............r. 1 ,.:''•••‘•', -:•„•,',-/:E..-eI..*;;-.-•-'-....'.',------..--,-•^-,,'„,0".,..c-.,.-':,••;- ,',-,:'•.'.",.,,.-,.'-,",:.x;,,.x;.,.:4.:0'...,.,,',',,i--.•7-..'• . , , ' - i=,-'..'''''',1-''.•9,-.'„'.t?••'••1;,;•.,,;•A•.:t‘'.'..'.,.'•.e;-.,..t,,1-l., 1,,, .'"'7'.-',..1-'.•`'7,•;''.1.*4.4:,':.'';.7,'•'`''4,''..`"*(..-'-7':..q.,0;:":'.,';'i.d,''7'.•'i;4.L'•,'.?.'.0'.-..I4-l:=.?*'''''"'''.;f,.'.,''';"',Y1;"4.11:,._ I—i',.'',"..'• ',..,..''w,',i,,,, —. .(.•"_','".f.",f-,,,•'i't.1fo„fA..:in l'..t-M4.•",'.,-2.1,%M.',.Pifj4t4..T-..,1•::c;.'.,•.f.',;',.e'„.t',,..,...p.,,4.;..',:a• 4'....4.7 - 1- ., ' a •-- . .-..,4 1,..,..-` , ' '' -' ' . " ' ' ,_, ,.,- ,Pt ' c ' '''' ' ', ' 'P4 ..,' 4,44•4 7 `.t ',..,•,.„6.,,,,:, .., .„-,-„,,,,, t 4 .rtg Hee.mi In(.inT, 1 -;i1 Angirimm-tliolili .''- 1'-'777,-.'-,- i. 1,,..' 't 4.,........d............4....,„,-'' `4-• ,4`4. .. ., .,'. -.„ ',..,,•,,,t,',,4 , ' V1... ' ...:'1'':41 P F:-',, ,,,,, ,,;.' i I ,.......4....', •:,..*,., .;',.,,,,-: •"47,,',,-„t.,..::..,.,. ' . ;1,, 4114.,.,,,,,,,_ ,.., ___,,•,.. .. .i..: . __ , , ,,....A10,17•'w;,tlie-IA:-i--,A•:-..',..,',:,':,-.. ::,;-... -77-1)1.... -,9,..$....P.4j.. ..;;4',..., .TrIr'Fiii''ii , , f'' - '.. ,..--,,,,..r';',4'le--,::...-,r;:i•'1,:',7.'-'1j.',•,•:: ':‘,,li:;:;.`'''''-'` 'ill"—'":"""'"'"'"'"*"*"" -...- •7/ ,•'.0 a ,s,':',11:''',,:-.;,`A'',;::„. ', '`'s':,f,.;:',',,se'.. .:`•-• ' "•••••?'„N '' ' ,. "1+- .t.`... •.'..'s.,, IX _„ .._. ',.,,.,. 1 ;$!..', ,,. yidfak,!;',‘,''''' .''''' , *---- , , - " "''' - '"- * - ''''::'' 'R•ier'''' .-.''''''' :. ''.... .' .. /,:,„ , .,' ' .;.:.., ;, id\,'`: ,'..:‘‘':'''''',...,...., ',Ili":4',..`1 ..,1,4 --- 'A.- .•.,.''', '11*- ' ' • .-- ::"'"n -;•;.4, ',. •.' 1"4. ,, , • n - ,'.'-',',4- •,..- •-, .4,- .. 0434', . , • I, '' '- 4 .t. ,, .,1,- ‘" ' >6 .:r.,,' ,, t :',..`• • 1, . F:,,,. /. ;''' 0 pc"- .i.... ,ty. ,..... . . 1,, ... . ,... ,,, i -1.h• .,__. ...4.: ....i,:-.., ,. . .,."." . -..._,.._... .. C 1 1' 1:•,, ., ' „ ' , WiatiffC4 .4. i 4 , ,, .. ...3,s r , :''.. 1 ' IA' . •,a, . ek,,Yq„,.. ' , , 4 • ' •,3+- ,t, _i•''' - '' "*...,....i 4-t•.:'' "iF( 1' ' •-•-.; i '. ' .J, 07 O ;‘ :''''t 'AA i•.:1: i. - ,.,...„. :. • ..; n '' ' 1 */' ,i . n'''T I-iv-% ,_,••,t5, - -t• ' • —1 "7.;:'1"-Q -1 ' .`,.....4 ". 1 • 1,. ..; $:*,. ,, , ,., .--. ''•`•';:-',..,'.: ---- ..,.,, .. t , l'':„e: , Itc.rk`',1'%::':;)1..„l '.'''Is:\T-ttl',1,.4‘'i,,...-eLM'..; •..,Lr',,,c :.';.,.•j,,I ,:. ,..., , 4.:7--,,L-,:,,,.,,-..‘ .:..,...-,:,,,:c:'-,1.1,-;'4, ,:,z 1 ,.. - '-;,,,,-' 4.`'''',.... ' • ' 'g.,:.,it,--.',,7t : '...:...T.!,44. '..".v''''''-"t"IC'4,--',.'^ 4' .-', '0.'1,s?.,-• 4e''''tle.4r3:.:C,..t : ,,T,,,,,....?,,f.-;•`e.1.:,.7.-.,...;*J.-,;.-..1,.., ... • • ....., . „'.1. - - - - . , 1., ',..,•., '4.••••:,,,t•p•‘..-3---.---,v„...- l•f,••*-N4.••,-1.,,f,A-i:•,iliv,,,,,-.04.A,•••,0,e -'••• ' - • - .• • '''- 1,..,:-..:., .1 ',•:',"-''',.. -,i Aftivro',.,,;, t,.i,:r., , -, `l s%;2' v /t �v I yf D , - 4 d -11 ;.; / L��r i - --. = 7 z, (- __ - sssS - - �, tza_ • \ 0\c0 v- 4- _a) 7, / /4 3 wit) 3 .62.,,G, / '2 p /p -0 13 cow ,ra \ /ee o ___. _. , . - 2, ' __,._,_06j_ ‘.-6,., \ f 64vz ( ,- .____e. r ____. . \,_ / w' /0_..? 721.3 9, , e ..,? - Cam-- e______ --- ..--1----,,y-ff . e,---- 9 ., . --,,L,. . ' 0 ,iro A -1 , / -=1, /J, , Q.__- .._ n � 1 - - Q/o 9' ,1-, e 7 // jd a ems---"----° __,../ A..) CV-- &,.e. \ "---az----- ,/_J ‘ - . -- ,..i 5 i,-____ „_. 6.„,„ ,____„, ,i _ , .____„/ 6 ."-c.,d- , cqz- ,,z,,i- N ) . ,_.7._ r6c. 6) c) , / , , — yam /47ir-A- A. / .t z,zi --4 c- ' ______------------- ,) ,.....„. - ,.___,# ir- — ,.,) )/L „ 0„,- ,-- __,__ ) ,,<- ..,_ 9L,_..„,/, -4, _....„ /lal- P ` L' er, /f . 1)17-' d-- 2/1 „,,A---t- / .2.-& A / „y‘ _ Q / - 4, • z ,. - 6...) -,g4vi-e-J2-. / _�� / ' -- 1- i /( 2 /i t — ----- Z_. k ' c 7 P4- At-< ' WA) lam` -'- -. .7uPggigiPE--..rf 0A-t- o .c L:1 ' ''L 9 ,--- ____,2,-) 4.to / .V- ___-e - --=- .__ t 1 rif2a/l--) , 2-... --\ 74° 77 ____.-. . 0 X( aa-c ,coo /—,� ` 7 ) _ id 4,40 p 1 p )2_ di - / hid / '94" 9)/ / 2IN p`1_,c( _.____ Poka.,-. _ ( ,--, ___ : 60-A-L.,": 42-9tLeIL___ Iii_____ es)-2-e— _ ../ 7 .=..___,_".,.._ fl k 0 °j--/- J � ' -- a. a-, „..---A.z..c_t„ A ` / _,--_ , `-'n- =ef /-- ea,tiu-I t..v ,/'° ,Ris, --- 04-7-- op v e Y- p .;-, r- 0 i_� Z „__J3,;; _ nvx 11-Q tJ 0 s ) , aa_ r / fiiejtoA- e.") ( 0.) a J9 71z09 *AA, 09 0 eLpittA "1_1 th,ta LA,Lk,c. c if A c_ I - I P Vi C 2-- ga - .101 c 6z, Co 0)7_1'4 ) ) C,&,44, 2 1.046P N C_, a-7- ) f _---' e-- -c, z:7°c,-)A—L: _____2_,. ___,-- _,) _______,__ , ----- -----i_ IL- ---, ,4,7 ' 7 zs / & /J 6 -b & ,2____ / 722,0 -; 2_,2 _ /(4,\ 0 eLOa- 21 _ __/7 - 0 C. / ci )41,(4-th- , N ,-,_,±, c/.0 ( .____Ns,, ,._s12_ _ N)--- c 2A ,._.t r :-cei 0)/1 N------ i`') --E ' ' < , \ 02____J \ _r#'" • • pyri-et-) - - � � _ot 2 A/--- c A"...6/ - Cam —"42-- 71EZE- i" 2 _2__Q - z? ' V'i'' t �� Nci_____ T r ',I � / % /9'‘J pi /0. ./. Mi-frii-lav) 7--- ,z-/ 3 ____C_Z_r____/ es _, 7______. ,, (4.1 '----) — -72z,,- .' ).) ( ______________— r- c--- /i- /9- /& .62 /Q ,_--z------ --- - h / Jr I-- /9d, ,,C ..."• - C C q— 1 / t ---- --; o' --,!` j CC 1 9 s"? \ /-9 ,__e___e9/ - z t, . 7 e.___, ,4100Ete- c.__y ----- --\v \ -)---X---- 12 cg--- 4z/ \,. r K' ,,V1 2) • 0) ,J' ,22 ., ' -2---- -A / .3 .____I —r ` "Po 122 Dllc;r76 •-- I, Ot C (off- �� c. ' (02‹...— cti I X )/ ----77. i c_____---1—, / 4 , , ,. ,:, , ,,‘ , , ,, , 1 , .--c,,L„ S iv A=t- ,G C. /,--z--_) N. / r" 0.1- S CCr-r) kr 9/ / , 'v c G / z /.& N -Th2 Ze. )</ (-5 c 4-f 90c. z1,-09z- a)11 U 6 w � • I./ ci 4,1 ors ,n (/- 6s) ) 4/1,9 94; /A1 c 2_ ,Z/.1(1)_ - ) _2/d-ieL e, 4,z - 6 )/ Li-J (t "/ r� " 61,01414. ____6/ 7)AALT - `/ o t2) _i/ 6 ) - 0' 4._____ ,# / m / r ( 7--- 1 . , (..y / 1 L/ \ .' 1 - /i 2f4 1 � % YZ '.ii., - -- C, Sf 171-. /- J 0 ) Z) ' /, ,, — 6X( /1 - ./k ' 4 _/'/ I ' / i 1 kC's Xj- ) 9') 7oV ) 'd i -02: 0 ._....,./ .P..--- ir, - '' ' 1,, --2.-/'-e7,,-)4-,&<,-)1 clip ' l free ate - �- � Gam, f V CJ J z 2C- 4e.o/ ) 2_. 7-"i&N G-a .,// e 4 01_, - 1 _ � � rc� • / l _ apd- "0 0) i 9 ) 0 c/L .mod - _ - _ _ 7-- r ..o r 657-2e2 -174- _____r J-6 r N ( a&, 1 /0 , crx) _ • ot o ir) \77-19- 9 9 0 \ tf-d llY- gib / - r`' ) ) eA,fry) i o - *})) ---42 7.-- ,6_____I -4-- , .y / >z__ - -j2t-,,c-k--r \ G-/9"/ aJ , � / _ - Y* .,2-, 4 f -- --'. ___7'__,4 r --i---- . 09-J // - _-___, 7 ±—A71,- ff/ 4r or J.4Y)/iN V(.2 All(..'' L, (---e------M--_ /* ' o d \ _2__ 3 / z) AJ--- 4,,____2‘___,___1 ) , ,f,-71" \ ,Cc r12.,-;„ / / - df-A/fPa' r Q 07L_e_ p (,/ C / — G 0_ ici • �1� r i , derniz.� / /I - ) I Y `-J / YYL€4.Q f N > - � / a a C.7/ -- d 17-7 C\ p("7-L 0 , Rc I 4 p i d © k• c ) i C . �. ' • ' / v . N i/A-j ' 2'Z wee AGENDA to`�.ar HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD Meeting Date: December 2, 2009 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. REGULAR MEETING AGENDA I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 103 NW 3`d Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Bryce Newell, Property Owners; City of Delray Beach, Authorized Agent. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness and waiver request (2010-013) associated with a fence and arbor. VII. ADJOURN WORKSHOP AGENDA I. DISCUSSION ITEM (Non-Action) Review of the Old School Square Historic District resurvey completed in January 2009 with additional discussion relative to the district's history and designation, and an overview of surveyed properties, benefits of historic preservation, and incentive programs. Notice was provided to all property owners within the district regarding this item. II. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Board Members • Staff III. ADJOURN anw afteci z Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: November 25, 2009 I HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Bryce Newell & Jodie MacLellan Authorized Agent: Dennis Thompson, City of Delray Beach Project Location: 211 NW 1st Street/103 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District HPB Meeting Date: December 2, 2009 COA: 2008-090 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) and waiver associated with a fence on a contributing property located at 211 NW 1st Street/103 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION' The subject property consists of Lot 8, Block 43, Town of Delray, and is located on the northeast corner of NW 1st Street and NW 3rd Avenue. The property contains a concrete block and stucco ranch-style structure built in 1959. A detached garage constructed in 2009 is located to the rear of the property. In May 2009, the subject property was reclassified as a contributor to the West Settlers Historic District. In 2007, the Board approved a COA request for the installation of impact rated, 6/6, single hung windows with defined (not flat) muntins throughout the principal structure. In 2008, the Board approved a COA for the demolition of a circa 1983, detached two-car garage and new construction of a detached two-car garage. On September 17, 2009, the City Commission approved a Hold Harmless Agreement for the installation of a "removable fence" within the adjacent public right-of-way to the east (rear alley) and south (side-street, along NW 1st Street) of the property. In November 2009, a COA was administratively approved for the installation of landscaping, brick patios, and a 6' board-on-board wood fence located along the north and east property lines (including the alley) and a 4' along the asphalt line of NW 1st Street. See attached site plan for additional details. The subject request is to increase the height of the fence along the asphalt line of NW 1st Street from 4' to 6', and to install an arbor at the front of the property. The arbor measures approximately 7' in height. A waiver is required as fences and walls "over four feet (4') shall not be allowed in front or side street setbacks" for properties within historic districts. The subject COA and waiver request is now before the Board for consideration. A recommendation will be forwarded to the City Commission meeting of December 8, 2009 103 NW 3`a Avenue/211 NW 1' Street, 2010-013 HPB Meeting December 2, 2009 vt Page 2 of 4 ANALYSIS As noted above, the request is to install a 6' fence within the side-street setback, and a 7' arbor at the front walkway connecting the sidewalk to the front door. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1.)(c), fences and walls over four feet (4') shall not be allowed in front or side street setbacks. Therefore, a waiver request to exceed the 4' height limitation is required. Waiver Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.7(B)(5), prior to granting a waiver, the granting body shall make findings that the granting of the waiver: (a) Shall not adversely affect the neighboring area; (b) Shall not significantly diminish the provision of public facilities; (c) Shall not create an unsafe situation; and, (d) Does not result in the grant of a special privilege in that the same waiver would be granted under similar circumstances on other property for another applicant or owner. The property owner has submitted the following in support of the request: "...The side of our home faces an alley (formally NW 1st Street) which has now become a place for vagrants to hang out because it basically dead ends to the Delray Beach Tennis courts. This alley/road is not a viable street and does not allow for cars or pedestrians. We have also had issues with people urinating and drinking along side of this alley because it is dark and somewhat secluded. We want to build a six foot fence around the sides and back of our house for privacy, security and to deter the vandalism and theft that has been a common occurrence since we moved in. For esthetic purposes we want the fence to be six feet along the sides and back of our home. We are planning on planting bushes along the outside of the fence and adding some lighting to deter people from hanging out on what is now the entrance to our driveway." STAFF COMMENT & ANALYSIS While the intent of the decreased height within historic districts is to maintain an attractive streetscape aesthetic reducing the adverse affect on the neighboring area, the waiver may be supported as follows: (a) NW 1st Street is not a through street and the fence's impact will be minimal as it transitions from the taller chain link fencing of the adjacent Tennis Center (not located within the district). The arbor is considered a feature and will enhance rather than detract from the neighborhood; (b) The provision of public facilities will not be affected by the increased height of either feature; (c) The increased height of the fence intends to create a safer situation for the property owner given the tendency for transients to congregate on the property and utilize it as an access way to the alley and adjacent properties. The increased height on the arbor will not create an unsafe situation; (d) While the circumstance regarding the fence is uncommon in a historic district, the request would likely be supported should a similar situation occur. Regarding the arbor, similar requests have been approved for this type of feature. Based on the analysis above, the request to increase the height of both the fence and arbor as requested may be supported. 103 NW 3`d Avenue/211 NW 1't Street,2010-013 HPB Meeting December 2,2009 Page 3 of 4 LDR Section 4.5.1 — Historic Preservation Sites and Districts (E) Development Standards: All development regardless of use within individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts, whether contributing or noncontributing, residential or nonresidential, shall comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, these regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (8)Visual Compatibility Standards. New construction and all improvements to contributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. (i) Walls of Continuity: Walls, fences, evergreen landscape masses, or building facades, shall form cohesive walls of enclosure along a street to ensure visual compatibility with historic buildings or structures within the subject historic district and the structure to which it is visually related. STAFF COMMENT & ANALYSIS The subject request is to increase the fence height from 4' to 6' within the side-street setback and install a 7' arbor at the front of the property. As noted in the waiver analysis, these requests will not detract from the neighborhood nor the contributing property. They are appropriate and compatible, and the additional landscaping along the fence will help to mitigate any potential negative impact on the streetscape. Therefore, the request may be supported to install a 6' fence along NW 1st Street and a 7' arbor at the front of the property, as noted on the attached plans. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2010-010) for 211 NW 1st Street/103 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Deny approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness for 211 NW 1st Street/103 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative. See above). 103 NW 3`d Avenue/211 NW 1st Street.2010-013 HPB Meeting December 2, 2009 Page 4 of 4 RECOMMENDATION Certificate of Appropriateness Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness for 211 NW 1st Street, West Settlers Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Waiver Request— LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1.)(c.), Fences and Walls Recommend approval to the City Commission of the waiver request to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1.)(c.), to allow a fence taller than four feet (4') to be located within the side street setback. Recommend approval to the City Commission of the waiver request to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(3)(a)(1.)(c.), to allow a fence (arbor) taller than four feet (4') to be located within the front setback. Report by: Amy E. Alvarez Attachments: • Survey • Site and Landscape Plans • Hold Harmless Agreement Ni MUHLY GRASS-TIP-3G, (8) NOTE - SEE ATTACHED PLANT LIST FOR DWARF FIREBUSH-3G, (12 QUANTITY BREAKDOWN AND SPECS. SILVER BUTTONWOOD(2) DWF.CROWN OF THORNS-1G,(8) >c >< ><,>< x ,x ,)‹ >< >< >< x x x >< x >< >< >< >< >< >< x >< x ._ * 4 . JATROPHA STANDARD(1) / / x i 4 ,../ ,.! ---. TI-IRYALLIS-3G,(8)// /-l'Ew PAVERS a) `-,,,,,-.-er:' \sr-..-.,•;+' x 1 5,--i' ',.,;',. ••••••',',k'• '',/ / •,":' x , 4,',...."-GUNI[30 LIMBO-(1) ,„4!) PORTULACA-1G.(15) "- .1-. ' ., PURPLE LANTANA-1G,(13) x ) .-, ' ' ' ......_ CASSIA STANDARD-(2) :=4",,, It, -, . ,'"',. ' •-•_. QUEEN EMMA-7G,(3) CO,FEGERA IE JASPINE-TRELLIS(2) / ,: ' • '.i•---14114LY GRASS-3G,(6) x ARBOR 4.ri FOXTAIL PALM-a Is'EW PAVER PATIVAY-90 5.F. 3 3. ,'-4:1 2,:'..4,1 mi.;1'• •`," X 1114! -, 35': '0.0:!-, ----BEGONIA WHTE ANGEL-3G.(5) , 0 , ,,,,,,/,/,/,,,,,,,,i ,,,,2 FTI-i:PYLEALLLANIS-TANA3G,(321G,co ,,,,/,',.•- / /, -.:1, ...,,,..... • ,•,,.: ,,,,,,,,_.). : QUEEN Ema-7G,(4) x x q- .'4. ly `'. • \\.14.;{.. , 0 e''', " GUMBO LIMBO-(1) 1 ‘\-----•', ',..;•'' :4"----- .''''.'", 0 ' Ti-RYALLIS-3G,ca x PORT1LACA-1G.(14) • ' -------- ,,,,,W, .4i,,01, 7-I,EW PAVERS CASSIA STANDARD-(2) , -, : _ .., tZ-• //z / //' RELOCATED FOXTAIL PALM /'/'/1 / //'i X • '•• . , • 7!: OWF.CROWN OF THORNS-1G,(21) MUHLY GRASS-3G,(6) % , i z,' 1 1 /z ;...)„. .. -(6 r;' ,V JATROPHA STANDARDS--(2) x BEGONIA WI-ITE ANGEL ('•.) -. ' '',. ." • 1.,.: -3G,(8) 1 'P .4 I.,.•,,: / // // / W .. i I) )140":"..!,,P, / /// ' > ...I) / , -"-', 7 x — 0< > /// X X 1.• 1,1,,,) 3..701... / / X Iii• x x x IS.r/Ox x .4 .) >4, , •.. 7.0,,,, FENCE-SEE NOTES FOR EXACT SPECIFICMIONS/LDCAllON X X z •;/--PODOCARPUS PRINGLES -3G,(24) - PODOCARPUS MACROPHYLLUS-3G,(30 x x x qo x x x I ; •aip-tX >1,N. 7'"T,IA,i,g:s_<.-• ,•••'-,' -'-‘e'4e0o),c' z'P4‘,c-c.,,„ ,,, ,,-4,--— , 4 't4 '?,f•PW%- ,''„V-4-,i'`-zrR-1,*44- „ .74 ..7e1-,44 .7:11--,,,_,, C;(Z74. VA; al, ill "'T.. . ,.:t• I, /ti A AllighL N Revision#: Scale: Landscape Plan: LANDSCAPE PLAN Landscape Design by: PETER ANUAR Date: 11/25/2009 1" = 10' 103 NW 3rd AVE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH s t iiI � �� _11Z �Z vt '54- s5-1311+16 I • 1 - �. r00-03 1 LOT. 16 .( �, S LOT 15 �, f • � � Iv l , .r ; '� IYI .r _ . .` Y N } Y� 4. - , Niv \ e. .,) FD 1/2 IRoN ROD AND CAP (P&M) 76.50' E '.1,,,.O • x--18.5 %04., ("' ' .5L.% " ' 17:. 22 2' ,*\41/431/4-115 V - �TP 33.0' • ' GARAGE o ASPHAt1 0 NI NI N DRIVE kii . r i. 1 1 11 �� u_ -\ e icv _r,„ . -„,, , 0 i• • .:i pz, V ,-?/ •• - . . . , Iv.1 • i r- z i 14.4' I I_l \' / WSJ 28.�k' b c o to to • r x r F7 c,-' • F I U tr 6' �� o I ��- Isr I =l �v i N ' eTh a c— m IiiA 0 l7.0 21.0' :. ¢I � : - TIC x .! 107 IZ • z ; �; ; I ONE STORY T rk3 ‘ F I - SINGLE FAMILY uS 1 • . a RESIDENCE oi= t~7 r • O 4' ^` r ` 0 3. r 32.2' _ 20.5' , I 13.2' • • - E ,L"0I. -, COVERED o J • ENTRY • I E IN 2 O oV • '�j� N 0 "7� cV Z e • I l l D 1/Z IRON 5' CONC. sIDEWALK 1 . I- ROD AND CAP o (P&M) 76.50' o N 20' ASPHALT PAVEMENT ---_Y--- _--� - NW 3RD- A • . . ,.....,::::,i,;,,i:.„.„z__,,,,,,,,:::., ,.s,,,..,,. iti,ti:...„4.,,,,,,,....tzil,i.,,,,,:.,..,2,,:t,z,:::,....:,!:,_.p.,,,,,,.,774_;..7„,,,,I.:s....1.-`=-,';;,:, opirir ,::, , , , :, ,,,,„ i, te l-1`,'-'-': -t'','-:e..;.,: P '''''..! ,ii t — if:,:itsi , ivie „Ttki i t 1 t e U1Tk:fItIIi t;:s ,i _ y�M.47-7;',a �7 .�� .y 1 i .t,':-..,: i i t, 't ,,,t„,,kf-,:ir.t.'-.ttv r.,-;.' ;.-..4(4..q. ,-,..,, , 5 �i+ y S,�s+'''r�n—+, rr a �J�,k= _Fz -+x ..°1 . .fir".... =a'�y --'.r :r' ,; k; ; ; 1' a Ra ,.rtfa Z 118I11111111IlIIIIli1111IIlII1lllIi111111111 11111l • .• CFN 20090342454 OR BK 23474 PG 0191 RECORDED 10/01/2009 16:22:21 ImmAP Prepared by: RETURN: Palm Beach County, Florida `) Sharon R. Bock,CLERK & COMPTROLLER R.Brian Shutt,Esq. Pgs 0191 - 196; (6pgs) Si City ttorney s Office . 1st Avenue 81ra v ch, FL 33444 a- '- ,),,0 2 °ter ,,,--) rr, ,c„. -3 ,-,-.--_, c. \c„ 6.- (!: HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT THIS HO HARMLESS AGREEMENT, is entered into this k day of i. ' ,,_„,\, _► , 20 Ay and between the CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, (hereinafter referred to a ") and Bryce Newell (hereinafter referred to as "OWNER"). ter' ).' ti5VITNESSETH: WHEREAS, OWNER owns(jiro'perty located at 103 NW 3rd Avenue, Delray Beach, mil/ f-'.``)�1i. , v Florida, and has requested CITY to allow'or the installation of removable fence in the _. public right-of-way; and ~- WHEREAS, OWNER agrees to hold CITY harmless for any damage which might be caused to the removable fence as a result of maintenance within the public right-of-way 4- or any action brought against the CITY as a result of the removable fence in the public right-of-way. A NOW, THEREFORE, for the mutual covenants and matters set forth herein, as of the C' date set forth above, the parties hereby agree as follows: s 1. • The recitations set forth above are incorporated herein. 43 2. OWNER is the owner of property described in Exhibit "A". C 4 Book23474/Page191 Page 1 of 6 • 3. That OWNER wishes to install a(n) removable fence in the area, as sown on Exhibit "B", in the public right-of-way pursuant to the City of Delray Beach C ide Ordinances. No structure or any portion of such structure shall be within 10 feet~c• c City's underground utilities. o OWNER acknowledges that the CITY shall assume no responsibility or maintenance the removable fence and any improvements thereto, which OWNER placein the public right-of-way and that OWNER shall be responsible for the upkeep and maint*ce of such removable fence and associated improvements in the �public right-of-way in-`a4ordance with the Code of Ordinances of the CITY. i� •,j �L+ 5. OWNER, zgideration of the mutual covenants set forth herein, agrees to defend, indemnify, and hole .ha`ttfless the CITY, its agents, officers, employees and servants Vi;t from any and all claims, suits, u of action or any claim whatsoever made, and damages, which may result from the placemerCot existence of the removable fence and improvements in the public right-off/w.jy OWNER further agrees to hold the CITY, its agents, officers, employees and servants arm�ess for any damage to the removable fence and associated improvements OWNER places within the public right-of-way. It is understood that any cost for replacement or repair of the removable fence and associated improvements shall be the OWNER'S responsibility, and the CITY will not be held liable for any damage to the removable fence and associated improvements as a result of any maintenance or construction within the public right-of-way by the CITY. 6. The CITY may at any time and in its sole discretion request that OWNER remove the removable fence from the public right-of-way and OWNER agrees to immediately remove the removable fence from the public right-of-way. 2 Book23474/Page192 Page 2 of 6 7. All notice required or allowed by this Agreement shall be delivered in person or maid to the party at the following address: s ^ CITY: Environmental Services Director o City of Delray Beach 434 South Swinton Avenue 0 Delray Beach, FL 33444 OWNER: Mr. Bryce Newell V 103 NW 3' Avenue �r�'� Delray Beach, FL 33444-2623 8. This Agreement shall be binding on the Parties, their respective heirs, successors, legal representatives, ,permitted assigns and shall be recorded in the Public Records of Palm Beach County and shall Ayith the land. 9. This Agrees tt,shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Florida. Venue forty}claim or lawsuit arising out of this Agreement shall be in Palm Beach County. �t ffff'1 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the.parties hereto have entered into this agreement the day and year first written above. 3 Book23474/Page193 Page 3 of 6 1•' ♦ t 7.ATTEST ;"' CIT. OF 6ELRAY : 4- • DA L -1;�::::q: ,,, . ;�,`,, BY: , .Pua �� ;. k.= ,:...,,,,. ...2.,.„,., ............,..„,..„:„.t,c, Av.P , ({ra das,t Q l ii;:" ,,e)By.'r .t... .;�. ' . z ttorney WITNESS % OWNER: • / i a' • "Ir,i / By: 4n/,0 �'. .E. .Re m c ew eLL- (Print o ype '. r>:•3') (Print or Type Name) -gam 'fin 14,0ay Public Slate or Florida r ,ry :� Troy hr?e;cll d• r�^?' "•:>•:,�.^ t r:;,:mmis^,;on DD457,14 (Print or Type Name) ~r o (SEAL) . L=way;oen5/2009 rj STATE OF Fto&i)-0- (,, U 1 `' COUNTY OF QnLti Vy00-c.ki :-...) { The foregoing instrument Via;iijacknowledged before me this 1 4day of Am... .-.. T , 200'by 1 R; Ce P l._ (name of officer or agent), of /0'1 , 3iv() A-�►te (2a-n M cv 33(1 ame of corporation), a . - sr place of incorporation) corporation, on behalf of the corporation. H= �� on• y own to 3 e or has produced (type of identificatio •- r s _-•• .':,a not take an oath. AIR • S Li atu•e o • • . Public- State of am,ion 4 Book23474/Page194 Page 4 of 6 Exhibit "A" Lio113, Block 43, Map of the Town of Linton, n/k/a The City of Delray BeaCti, according to the Plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 3 of `;;rrthe Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. • 5 Book23474/Page195 Page 5 of 6 DELRAY BEACH 103 NW 3rd Avenue 1I f Exhibit "B" 4-6 1993 2001 a) a) (0 a a" "' Location of 103 NW 3rd Av Z Fence r, y�\ .., ' , N (r NW 1st ST ,177, V��4;,� as ' r a. co (t;1 v <.. .(� - U �' O CO 8/14/200 Delray Beach GIS 4.qY e4 i ADMINISTRATIVE SUBJECT: EMPLOYEE BENEFITS City of POLICIES AND PROCEDURES 3% Management Match Program MANUAL Delray NUMBER REVISIONS EFFECTIVE PAGE 1 OF 3 Beach EB-15 11 DATE: October 21,2009 SUPERSEDES APPROVED BY: }/r EB-15, Rev. 10 r -Tr-: ' a'""-`'�\ avid T. Harden, City Manager EB-15.0 Purpose: The purpose of this directive is to provide administrative procedures for a 3% Management Match Program for certain eligible management and key employee positions. EB-15.1 Policy: Fiscal Year 1996-97 established a 3% Management Match Program for certain eligible management employee positions. The Program was expanded in April 1999 to include certain key employee positions approved by the City Commission. A schedule of all currently eligible management and key employee positions is attached to this policy as Exhibit A. Eligible employees can elect to contribute up to 3% of their base salary into the ICMA 457 Deferred Compensation Plan or 3%I of their base salary to the ICMA 401A Plan with 1 the City matching the contribution in accordance with the following terms: 1. The total combined contribution of the City and employee cannot exceed the amount allowed per Internal Revenue Service regulations. 2. Department Heads who have opted out of the City's Pension Plans and who are already contributing the maximum allowed into their 457 accounts (per Internal Service Regulations), may contribute 3% and receive the City match into their ICMA 401A account. 3. City and employee contributions shall cease upon the date the employee no longer works for the City as a regular full-time employee. 4. A re-hired employee who previously participated or was previously eligible to participate in the matching program shall not have any buyback rights under the matching program. 5. An eligible employee who desires to participate in this matching program may contribute more than 3% of their base salary (subject to IRS regulations), however, the City's contribution shall not exceed 3%. 6. Participation in the Program is voluntary and can be stopped at any time by written notification to the Finance Department. The City's matching contribution shall cease at the time the employee's contribution ceases. EB-15.2 Procedure: Eligible employees must complete an enrollment form (Exhibit B) advising the City whether or not they wish to participate in the Management Match Program and the amount they wish to contribute. Current ICMA 457 Deferred Compensation Plan or 401A Plan participants must also complete an ICMA Change Form to reflect the change in the amount of deferrals. New participants to the ICMA 457 Deferred Compensation Plan or 401A Plan must complete an ICMA Enrollment form. All forms are available in the Finance Department and must be returned to the Payroll Administrator. Exhibit A ICMA 3% MANAGEMENT MATCH PROGRAM SCHEDULE OF ELIGIBLE MANAGEMENT AND KEY EMPLOYEE POSITIONS (October 21, 2009) ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES FINANCE Assistant City Manager Director of Finance Telecommunications Systems Manager Assistant Finance Director Application Support Specialist CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE Chief Information Officer City Attorney Network Engineer • City Attorney II Project Manager/LAN City Attorney I Purchasing Manager Senior Programmer/Analyst CITY CLERK'S OFFICE Treasurer City Clerk Utilities Financial Manager Deputy City Clerk Budget Officer CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE City Manager FIRE Assistant City Manager Fire Chief Sustainability Officer Assistant Fire Chief Public Information Officer Division Chief/Professional Training Division Chief/EMS COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT Division Chief/Fire Safety Director of Community Improvement Battalion Chief Assistant Director of Community Improvement Administrative Officer Building and Inspection Administrator Deputy Building Official HUMAN RESOURCES Neighborhood Services Administrator Director of Human Resources Assistant Director of Human Resources Human Resources Consultant/Benefits&Compensation ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Human Resources Consultant/Human Development Director of Environmental Services Risk Manager Assistant City Engineer Building Maintenance Superintendent PARKS AND RECREATION City Engineer Director of Parks and Recreation Construction Manager Ocean Rescue Superintendent Deputy Director of Construction Parks Superintendent Deputy Director of Public Utilities Recreation Superintendent Deputy Director of Public Works Environmental Compliance Manager PLANNING AND ZONING Fleet Maintenance Superintendent Director of Planning and Zoning GIS Coordinator Assistant Director of Planning and Zoning Manager of Maintenance Manager of Water Treatment Plant POLICE Manager of Water/Sewer Network Police Chief Streets Superintendent Police Major Police Captain Police Lieutenant Accreditation Manager Administrative Officer Assistant City Attorney/Police Legal Communications Manager Technical Systems Manager ENROLLMENT FORM 3% MANAGEMENT MATCH PROGRAM This program allows a City match of up to 3%of base salary through either the ICMA 457 Deferred Compensation Plan or 401A Plan. The City's contribution will be considered as FICA wages, therefore these taxes will be paid by you (7.65%). Participation in the program is voluntary and can be stopped at any time. To stop participation, please notify the Finance Department. Name of Participant(Print) Social Security Number Start Date I AGREE to participate in the 3%Management Match Program and wish to match %(no more than 3%). I wish these monies to be contributed to: ICMA 457 Deferred Compensation Plan ICMA 401A Plan I DO NOT want to participate in the 3%Management Match Program. Signature of Participant Date Checklist of forms to be included: ICMA(457/401A)enrollment form for new participants ICMA(457/401A)change form for existing participants FOR PAYROLL USE ONLY Completed by: Date: City of Delray Beach Administrative Policies and Procedures INDEX - Numerical Rev Effective # Date BUDGET AND FINANCE BF-1 Check Signing Procedures 1 4/5/90 BF-2 Investment Procedures 2 9/4/01 BF-3 Forms Control - Cash Receipts 1 8/28/09 BF-4 Billing Procedures/Disputes, Delinquent Accounts 0 8/28/09 BF-5 "Fair Share Fee" for Palm Beach County Road Improvement 3/4/85 BF-6 Staledated Checks 3 8/28/09 BF-7 Budget Transfer Policy and Amendments 3 8/1/07 BF-8 Check Cashing Policy for City Employees 2 8/28/09 BF-11 Worker Status—Independent Contractor/Employee 0 4/24/89 BF-12 Check Requests 3 8/28/09 BF-14 Deposits of Revenue 1 6/16/89 BF-15 Investigative Funds and "Flash Money" 5/15/89 BF-16 "Red Flag" Consumer Protection Policy 0 11/1/08 BF-17 Review Process for Financing of Capital Projects 3/16/90 BF-18 Payment on City Construction Projects 1 8/28/09 BF-19 Capitalization of Interest Cost of Construction in Progress 1 8/28/09 BF-20 Return of Utility Deposits 1 8/28/09 BF-21 Capital Assets 5 8/24/09 BF-22 Recording Cashier's Checks 1 8/28/09 BF-23 Debt Management 4/4/00 BF-24 Grant Administration 10/1/06 CITY CLERK CC-1 Residency Card Procedure' 2/12/07 COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS CS-1 City's 800 MHz Radio System Administration 8/29/02 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS EB-1 Long Term Disability Benefits 5 5/1/04 EB-2 FLSA Employees Leave Days Policy 14 1/15/93 EB-3 New Employee Enrollment in City Group Health Plan 4 3/10/99 EB-4 Dependent Insurance Coverage 5 1/22/09 EB-6 Administration of Retirees' Group Insurance 2 11/11/02 EB-7 Health Insurance for Employees Age 65 or Older 2 4/8/98 EB-8 Life Insurance Benefits for Police and Firefighters 5 7/19/05 EB-12 Deferred Compensation Plans for Non-Participating Employees 5 8/6/03 Revised:October 21,2009 Page 2 EB-13 Pension Buyback 1 8/6/03 EB-15 3% Management Match Program 11 10/21/09 EB-16 Family & Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA) 5 4/23/09 FEES AND PERMITS FP-2 Fees for Use of the City's Portable Stages 1 9/29/08 GENERAL ADMINISTRATION GA-1 Establishing and Issuing Standard/Uniform Policies and 5/1/84 Procedures GA-3 Internships 0 10/5/09 GA-2 Physical.Inspection & Evaluation of City Facilities 5/1/84 GA-5 Employee Gift and Departmental Fund Policy 7/1/84 GA-6 Agenda Preparation 1 6/6/01 GA-7 Grievance Procedures Concerning the City of Delray Beach 1 4/26/93 and Handicapped Persons GA-8 Dissemination of Employee Information 1 2/24/89 GA-9 Time Card Procedure 1 7/8/85 GA-10 Designation of Smoking and Non-Smoking Areas 4 8/28/03 GA-11 SPIRIT Award Program 3 7/7/08 GA-12 Driver's License Check 2 9/15/94 GA-14 Complaint Tracking System 1 7/26/04 GA-15 Safety Devices - Use of Seat Belts 1 10/15/02 GA-16 Telephone System Repairs, Modifications and Additions 3 3/15/05 GA-17 Emergency Calls 911 2 5/27/93 GA-19 Florida Driver's License 1 5/1/98 GA-20 City Recognition and Gifts Policy 3/15/05 GA-21 Emergency Management 6/28/05 GA-22 Non-Travel Meal and Refreshments 4/18/08 GA-23 Charitable and Benevolent Contributions and Special Event 5 1/1/02 Funding GA-24 Charges for Removal and Storage of Abandoned Items and 10/16/01 Administrative Charges for Nuisance Abatement Matters and Lien Matters (Supersedes GA-24, Rev. 1&2 and GA-26) GA-27 Travel Advances and Expense Reconciliations 12 10/1/06 GA-28 Outside Employment 2 10/15/93 GA-29 Cost and Procedure for Furnishing Copies 6 9/28/09 GA-30 Disclosure of EEOC Position Statement and Documentation 6/8/89 GA-31 Display of Flags 1 3/11/08 GA-32 Service of Process and Subpoenas 9/13/89 GA-33 False Alarm Billing, Collection, and Charge-Off Procedures 3/19/08 GA-34 City Employees Doing Business with the City 1 2/23/00 GA-35 Background Screening Requirements for Volunteer Coaches 5/1/00 GA-36 Compensatory Time - Police Department 11/1/90 GA-37 Unusual Occurrences/Command Responsibility 5/7/91 GA-38 Hazardous Waste Management Policy 12/1/92 GA-39 Employee Development and Training 9 10/1/08 Revised:October 21,2009 Page 3 GA-40 Car Allowance/Mileage Reimbursement 9 12/1/08 GA-41 Employee Suggestion Program 2 5/27/99 GA-42 Use of Cellular Telephones and Other Portable Communication 3 7/25/08 Devices GA-43 Employee Incentive Award Program 5/1/97 GA-44 Volunteer Marine Patrol Insurance Policy 4 4/19/01 GA-45 Inspection of Work Area 12/14/98 GA-46 Emergency Conditions Pay 2 8/8/05 GA-47 Use of City Logo 1/5/04 GA-48 Language Incentive Pay 1 8/17/09 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IT-1 Reporting Computer Hardware and/or Software Issues 8/26/05 IT-2 Use of Hardware, Software, and Data Resources 8/26/05 _ IT-3 Hardware and Software Approval 8/26/05 IT-4 Password Security 8/26/05 IT-5 Electronic Systems and Communications Tools (E-Mail, Internet) 8/26/05 IT-6 Accessing the City's Internet Account 1 10/1/06 PERSONNEL PER-1 "Smoke Free" Fire Service 2 7/28/89 PER-2 Donation of Leave Time 7 3/31/09 PER-3 Service Awards/Retirement Awards 4 10/1/06 PER-4 Classification and Pay Plans 7 8/5/02 PER-5 Entrance Requirements, Fire Department Medical 2 10/15/01 PER-6 Policy Against Harassment 2 8/20/08 PER-7 Temporary Disability/Light Duty 1 5/6/03 PER-8 Affirmative Action Plan 1 6/8/94 PER-9 Alcohol and Drug Testing Program for Commercial Motor 10/1/96 Vehicles Drivers (CDL) PER-10 Workplace Violence 4 8/6/08 PER-11 Dual Employment 1/12/98 PER-12 Comprehensive Drug &Alcohol Abuse Policy 2/13/01 PER-13 Exit Process: Leaving Employment with the City 11/24/03 PUBLIC WORKS PW-1 No Idling Policy 0 6/9/08 PW-2 Fuel Delivery and Prices 0 4/2/90 PW-3 City Vehicle Use 0 6/3/09 PW-4 Leasing of City Vehicles 0 6/3/09 PW-5 Damage to City Vehicles; Advertising on City Vehicles; and New 0 6/3/09 Vehicle Acceptance and Registration PW-6 The Issuance of"P.I.N." Numbers and Approved Use of the 0 7/8/09 Automatic Fuel System Revised:October 21.2009 Page 4 PURCHASING Purchasing Manual PUR-1 Purchasing Card 0 11/1/08 PUR-8 Debarment or Suspension of Vendors and Contractors 0 8/22/89 PUR-11 Inventory Procedures for City Water Meters 0 5/1/85 PUR-13 Vendor Service Report Form 0 2/2/87 PUR-15 Minority Vendor Program 0 8/25/87 PUR-16 Bid/Performance and Payment Bond Requirements 2 5/8/89 PUR-17 Newsrack Ordinance Fine Procedures 1 12/15/89 RISK MANAGEMENT RM-1 Risk Management Division & Program 1 12/20/07 RM-2 Bodily Injury, Property Damage, and Worker's Compensation 3 8/25/08 Claims and Litigation, Investigation, Reporting, Administration, and Settlement Authority RM-3 Right-to-Know and Safety Orientation Program 0 9/2/91 RM-4 Personal Protective Equipment 0 7/16/09 RM-5 Disposal of Totally Wrecked Vehicles 2 12/20/07 RM-6 Employee Statements Regarding City Liability 3 12/20/07 RM-7 Theft of Employee's Personal Property 2 12/20/07 RM-8 Transportation to Medical Facilities of Injured/III Employees 1 12/20/07 RM-9 Drivers' Identification Cards 0 7/16/09 RM-10 Workers' Compensation Claims Administration 3 9/1/09 RM-11 Rental Vehicles & Purchase of Rental Insurance 0 12/20/07 RM-12 Certificates of Insurance 1 12/18/89 RM-14 First-Aid Supplies and Distribution of Medication 1 12/20/07 Revised:October 21,2009 City of Delray Beach Administrative Policies and Procedures INDEX — Alphabetical Rev Effective Date BUDGET AND FINANCE BF-4 Billing Procedures/Disputes, Delinquent Accounts 0 8/28/09 BF-7 Budget Transfer Policy and Amendments 3 8/1/07 BF-21 Capital Assets 5 8/24/09 BF-19 Capitalization of Interest Cost of Construction in Progress 1 8/29/09 BF-8 Check Cashing Policy for City Employees 2 8/28/09 BF-12 Check Requests 3 8/28/09 BF-1 Check Signing Procedures 1 4/5/90 BF-23 Debt Management 4/4/00 BF-14 Deposits of Revenue 1 6/16/89 BF-5 "Fair Share Fee" for Palm Beach County Road Improvement 3/4/85 BF-3 Forms Control - Cash Receipts 1 8/28/09 BF-24 Grant Administration 10/1/06 BF-15 Investigative Funds and "Flash Money" 5/15/89 BF-2 Investment Procedures 2 9/4/01 BF-18 Payment on City Construction Projects 1 8/28/09 BF-22 Recording Cashier's Checks 1 8/28/09 BF-16 "Red Flag" Consumer Protection Policy 0 11/1/08 BF-20 Return of Utility Deposits 1 8/28/09 BF-17 Review Process for Financing of Capital Projects 3/16/90 BF-6 Staledated Checks 3 8/28/09 BF-11 Worker Status—Independent Contractor/Employee 0 4/24/89 CITY CLERK CC-1 Residency Card Procedure 2/12/07 COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS CS-1 City's 800 MHz Radio System Administration 8/29/02 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS EB-15 3% Management Match Program 11 10/21/09 EB-6 Administration of Retirees' Group Insurance 2 11/11/02 EB-12 Deferred Compensation Plans for Non-Participating 5 8/6/03 Employees EB-4 Dependent Insurance Coverage 5 1/22/09 EB-16 Family & Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA) 5 4/23/09 EB-2 FLSA Employees Leave Days Policy 14 1/15/93 EB-7 Health Insurance for Employees Age 65 or Older 2 4/8/98 EB-8 Life Insurance Benefits for Police and Firefighters 5 7/19/05 EB-1 Long Term Disability Benefits 5 5/1/04 Revised:October 21,2009 Page 2 EB-3 New Employee Enrollment in City Group Health Plan 4 3/10/99 EB-13 Pension Buyback 1 8/6/03 FEES AND PERMITS FP-2 Fees for Use of the City's Portable Stages 1 9/29/08 GENERAL ADMINISTRATION GA-6 Agenda Preparation 1 6/6/01 GA-35 Background Screening Requirements for Volunteer 5/1/00 Coaches GA-40 Car Allowance/Mileage Reimbursement 9 12/1/08 GA-24 Charges for Removal and Storage of Abandoned Items and 10/16/01 Administrative Charges for Nuisance Abatement Matters and Lien Matters (Supersedes GA-24, Rev. 1&2 and GA-26) GA-23 Charitable and Benevolent Contributions and Special Event 5 1/1/02 Funding GA-34 City Employees Doing Business with the City 1 2/23/00 GA-20 City Recognition and Gifts Policy 3/15/05 GA-36 Compensatory Time - Police Department 11/1/90 GA-14 Complaint Tracking System 1 7/26/04 GA-29 Cost and Procedure for Furnishing Copies 6 9/28/09 GA-10 Designation of Smoking and Non-Smoking Areas 4 8/28/03 GA-30 Disclosure of EEOC Position Statement and Documentation 6/8/89 GA-31 Display of Flags 1 3/11/08 GA-8 Dissemination of Employee Information 1 2/24/89 GA-12 Driver's License Check 2 9/15/94 GA-17 Emergency Calls 911 2 5/27/93 GA-46 Emergency Conditions Pay 2 8/8/05 GA-21 Emergency Management 6/28/05 GA-39 Employee Development and Training 9 10/1/08 GA-5 Employee Gift and Departmental Fund Policy 7/1/84 GA-43 Employee Incentive Award Program 5/1/97 GA-41 Employee Suggestion Program 2 5/27/99 GA-1 Establishing and Issuing Standard/Uniform Policies and 5/1/84 Procedures GA-33 False Alarm Billing, Collection, and Charge-Off Procedures 3/19/08 GA-19 Florida Driver's License 1 5/1/98 GA-7 Grievance Procedures Concerning the City of Delray Beach 1 4/26/93 and Handicapped Persons GA-38 Hazardous Waste Management Policy 12/1/92 GA-45 Inspection of Work Area 12/14/98 GA-3 Internships 0 10/5/09 GA-48 Language Incentive Pay 1 8/17/09 GA-22 Non-Travel Meal and Refreshments 4/18/08 GA-28 Outside Employment 2 10/15/93 GA-2 Physical Inspection & Evaluation of City Facilities 5/1/84 GA-15 Safety Devices - Use of Seat Belts 1 10/15/02 GA-32 Service of Process and Subpoenas 9/13/89 Revised: October 21,2009 Page 3 GA-11 SPIRIT Award Program 3 7/7/08 GA-16 Telephone System Repairs, Modifications and Additions 3 3/15/05 GA-9 Time Card Procedure 1 7/8/85 GA-27 Travel Advances and Expense Reconciliations 12 10/1/06 GA-37 Unusual Occurrences/Command Responsibility 5/7/91 GA-42 Use of Cellular Telephones and other Portable 3 7/25/08 Communication Devices GA-47 Use of City Logo 1/5/04 GA-44 Volunteer Marine Patrol Insurance Policy 4 4/19/01 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IT-6 Accessing the City's Internet Account 1 10/1/06 1T-5 Electronic Systems and Communications Tools (E-Mail, 8/26/05 Internet) 1T-3 Hardware and Software Approval 8/26/05 IT-4 Password Security 8/26/05 IT-1 Reporting Computer Hardware and/or Software Issues 8/26/05 IT-2 Use of Hardware, Software, and Data Resources 8/26/05 PERSONNEL PER-8 Affirmative Action Plan 1 6/8/94 PER-9 Alcohol and Drug Testing Program for Commercial Motor 10/1/96 Vehicles Drivers (CDL) PER-4 Classification and Pay Plans 7 8/5/02 PER-12 Comprehensive Drug &Alcohol Abuse Policy 2/13/01 PER-2 Donation of Leave Time 7 3/31/09 PER-11 Dual Employment 1/12/98 PER-5 Entrance Requirements, Fire Department Medical 2 10/15/01 PER-13 Exit Process: Leaving Employment with the City 11/24/03 PER-6 Policy Against Harassment 2 8/20/08 PER-3 Service Awards/Retirement Awards 4 10/1/06 PER-1 "Smoke Free" Fire Service 2 7/28/89 PER-7 Temporary Disability/Light Duty 1 5/6/03 PER-10 Workplace Violence 4 8/6/08 PUBLIC WORKS PW-3 City Vehicle Use 0 6/3/09 PW-5 Damage to City Vehicles; Advertising on City Vehicles; and 0 6/3/09 New Vehicle Acceptance and Registration PW-2 Fuel Delivery and Prices 0 4/2/90 PW-4 Leasing of City Vehicles 0 6/3/09 PW-1 No Idling Policy 0 6/9/08 PW-6 The Issuance of"PIN." Numbers and Approved Use of the 0 7/8/09 Automatic Fuel System PURCHASING Purchasin Manual PUR-16 Bid/Performance and Payment Bond Requirements 2 5/8/89 PUR-8 Debarment or Suspension of Vendors and Contractors 0 8/22/89 Revised: October 21,2009 Page 4 PUR-11 Inventory Procedures for City Water Meters 0 5/1/85 PUR-15 Minority Vendor Program 0 8/25/87 PUR-17 Newsrack Ordinance Fine Procedures 1 12/15/89 PUR-1 Purchasing Card 0 11/1/08 PUR-13 Vendor Service Report Form 0 2/2/87 RISK MANAGEMENT RM-2 Bodily Injury, Property Damage, and Worker's 3 8/25/08 Compensation Claims and Litigation, Investigation, Reporting, Administration, and Settlement Authority RM-12 Certificates of Insurance 1 12/18/89 RM-5 Disposal of Totally Wrecked Vehicles 2 12/20/07 RM-9 Drivers' Identification Cards 0 7/16/09 RM-6 Employee Statements Regarding City Liability 3 12/20/07 RM-14 First-Aid Supplies and Distribution of Medication 1 12/20/07 RM-4 Personal Protective Equipment 0 7/16/09 RM-11 Rental Vehicles & Purchase of Rental Insurance 0 12/20/07 RM-3 Right-to-Know and Safety Orientation Program 0 9/2/91 RM-1 Risk Management Division & Program 1 12/20/07 RM-7 Theft of Employee's Personal Property 2 12/20/07 RM-8 Transportation to Medical Facilities of Injured/Ill Employees 1 12/20/07 RM-10 Workers' Compensation Claims Administration 3 9/1/09 Revised: October 21,2009