The URL can be used to link to this page

HPB 08-01-07 • MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF DELRAY BEACH REGULAR MEETING MEETING DATE: August 1, 2007 LOCATION: City Commission Chambers MEMBERS PRESENT: Keith Snider, Toni Del Fiandra, Roger Cope, JoAnn Peart, John Miller, Linda Lake, Kim French STAFF PRESENT: Amy Alvarez, Denise Valek, and Terrill Barton I. CALL TO ORDER: Chairman Miller read the City of Delray Beach's procedures for Quasi-Judicial Hearing for all the items on the Agenda. Chairman John Miller called the meeting to order at 6:00p.m. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. II. CERTIFICATIONS OF APPROPRIATNESS A. 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Community Redevelopment Agency, Property Owner&Applicant. No ex parte Communication. Ms. Amy Alvarez entered the file into the record and presented the proposal for a Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness and Class II Site Plan Modification (2007-256-SPI) associated with exterior alteration to a non-contributing multi-family structure as stated in the Staff Report. Staff recommends approval of this item subject to the conditions as stated in the Staff Report. Ms. Alvarez handed out a checklist to be used for the Board's considerations. Applicants Presentation: Walt Gerhard, Property Manager, Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) stated that the north wall on the second floor is unstable. Also, that they are proposing aluminum around the structure up to forty-two inches (42"). It is at thirty-six (36") now, and they will continue the railing down inclusive of a set of stairs. Public Comments: There were none. Board Discussion The Board's comments are summarized below: • That the satellite dishes will be coming down; • That the Bahamas shutters will be on the first floor(double windows); Historic Preservation Board Minutes - August 1, 2007 • That the Board is pleased with the colors; • That the dumpster enclosure is not seen; it was part of landscape's review; • That since it is a multi-family unit, whether a concrete block is required; • That it can be either screened or concrete; • That the shutters are appropriate to the era; • That no additional lighting was indicated in the application; • That the overhang on the South side will remain; and • That the windows were recently replaced in January. For the record, Ms. Barton asked the Board to go through the checklist before a motion is made citing #'s 1A, 2, and 6 would be applicable to this application. This is taken from the LDR as part of the Board's analysis. There was a discussion that the points are difficult to answer and could not be compared to adjacent buildings at this point. As a stand alone, there wouldn't be a problem with them. Ms. Barton asked if the materials and the colors are generally compatible to the Historic West Settlers District and to state that for the record. The question was read for the record. Are the colors and materials compatible? Yes, but the color scheme is boring. Ms. Alvarez detailed the color choices as stated below: • The shutters are sable. • The eyebrows are snow berries (white), the railing is similar to bronze. • The trim is Rockwood Terracotta. • The overhangs are a form of yellow (Glad). • The wall out front is Butternut which is now possibly a rail and may not apply. The Board summarized that overall it is considered to be compatible with the knowledge that is before the Board. Motion/Findings: It was moved by Ms. Lake, seconded by Ms. French, and approved 7 to 0 to move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(7) and (E)(8), and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines subject to the condition that screening is provided for the dumpster, refuse areas, and mechanical equipment. B. 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District — Sally Gebo, Property Owner. Ex parte communication: Ms. Peart was speaking to Linda before the meeting but it will not impact any decisions. Ms. Alvarez entered the file into the record and presented the proposal for a Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (2006-420-COA) for the installation of accordion shutters on a contributing structure as stated in the Staff Report. 2 Historic Preservation Board Minutes - August 1, 2007 Applicant Presentation Ms. Lynda Kidd representing the applicant stated the Board approved shutters on her house which is the neighboring house to the applicant. Ms. Kidd's comments can be summarized below: • That existing frames would attach to the shutters and they are painted white which was previously approved by the City; • That pictures were presented of her house which illustrates what the applicant's shutters would resemble and that they are not really visible; • That they are easy to install; • That she hoped that last year's approval would yield other alternatives(shutter types) than what is available now; • That the only alternative would be impact glass which would be costly; • That a neighboring property at 202 North Swinton has had its front door sealed with aluminum siding and the windows at the top corner have plywood on them for the last four years; • That she was cited for not having a painted fence and this property has not had a painted fence for the last five years; • That 220 North Swinton has looked like it has for the last 1.5 year; • That 214 North Swinton, was used as a supply house for a plumbing company, also used for an artist, and has had plywood down for the last 3 years; and • That she requested the City to look at their guidelines for safety alternatives for resident's shutters. Public Comments: None Rebuttal Ms. Alvarez's comments are summarized below: ■ That there is a system referred to as, "Fabric Shield" that is easy to use; • That there might be an accordion shutter already installed on the front window underneath the large awning (without documentation for it); • That a box underneath the awning might be an option, but if the awning is removed, it may be an issue in the future if the box still remains; ■ That the other addresses mentioned have been cited; and ■ That canvas awnings age and would have to be replaced in the future. Board Discussion: The Board's comments are summarized below: • That they are in favor of the residents request and it is more of a safety issue; ■ That the shutters on Ms. Kidd's home are visibly not appealing; • That the Board is hesitant to state that you cannot protect your home especially in the Historic District in spite of the fact that they are not aesthetically appealing; • That the Board is attempting to conform to the LDR and appreciates that the adjacent properties are not being maintained; ■ That the Board is willing to allow the shutters in spite of how they look and their operability is well received; • That when the design guidelines come before the Board, that could be part of the recommendation; 3 Historic Preservation Board Minutes - August 1, 2007 • That in the past the Board has denied accordion shutters and will continue to vote that way based on the LDR, although these do look radically different than the boxes that roll down; • That they would like to see it painted to match the structure on both properties; • That the shutters are not permanent and can be removed without damaging the historical integrity of the house; • That the Board is there for consideration for those that need it most and are trying to maintain the integrity of their historic houses as well as protect them; • That there are houses on Swinton that are boarded up with plywood; • That the windows are not original and were replaced in 2002; • That there are other"sister" houses on South Federal and near George Bush; • That the builder is trying to be named and that the houses withstood the past hurricanes; • That the applicant had researched an alternative that didn't alter the look of the home; • That a precedence not be set for not looking at alternatives; and • That the Board should offer research/alternatives to the applicant when they present an application; Ms. Barton asked the Board to use item 1 D from the checklist which follows the letter of the law of the LDR pursuant to Section 2.4.68 and 4.5.1. She added that the Board has been appointed not only to apply the law but to apply the facts of every case that comes before the Board to the law, in making the findings. Otherwise, it would be up to Staff to administratively approve whatever comes before them. The Board does need to follow the LDR but they do not have to be concerned with setting precedent. Ms. Pyburn wanted to make sure that it was clear to the Board that they have the ability to take the facts of this case, apply the law, and make a determination. The Board reviewed the checklist as noted below: 1) Are the shutters removable? Yes, but would not be removed after each use in their design. 2)Are they located so that they are not visible from public the right of way? Yes 3) Are the tracks compatible with the exterior surface and structure? Yes The Board is split on question # 1. #2 is a definite no. #3 is a consensus of yes. Motion/Findings: It was moved by Mr. Cope, seconded by Ms. Peart, and approved 6 to 1 (Ms. Lake dissented) to move approval of COA-2007-264 for 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Section 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. 4 Historic Preservation Board Minutes - August 1, 2007 III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS The Board's comments are summarized below: That work is being performed at NE 3`d St. / NE 7`h (Hartman House) regarding repairing the existing windows; Question as to why people are being citing for frames on houses; That Ms. Alvarez can look into specific addresses. Question as to whether Ms. Alvarez reported people for shutters and why hasn't she reported them (plywood on the windows), which is worse than hurricane shutters; That Ms. Alvarez found that some of the accordion shutters were approved and some were not applied for, or approved; That Ms. Alvarez can look into code enforcement compliance regarding the plywood; and That Staff does not pick on people as Ms. Peart stated; and That a house across the street from the Kidd house was cited and it is stated in the Staff Report; Staff comments are summarized below: • That the LDR amendments will be at the next meeting; • That there may be two items maybe three on the next Agenda; • That a project has proceeded forward as a result of a matching grant from Palm Beach County; ■ That it is difficult to find applications for the Historic District on the website site; as they are not easily visible; • That (Management Information Systems) MIS, handles the web site issues and it would be easier for Staff and the Board to advise them; • That work is being done to get the Historical Markers and applying for grants for them becoming available by 2008; and • That a presentation will be offered and notifications sent to notify people regarding the Markers, once everything is finalized. IV. ADJOURN There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at 7:05p.m. The undersigned is the Acting Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for August 1, 2007 which were formally adopted and approved by the Board on September 4, 2008. Denise A. Valek If the Minutes you have received are not completed as indicated above then this means that these are not the official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. 5 • (( O AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: August 1, 2007 Time: 6:00 P.M. Meeting Type: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District — Community Redevelopment Agency, Property Owner&Applicant. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness and Class II Site Plan Modification (2007- 256-SPI) associated with exterior alteration to a non-contributing multi-family structure and additional site improvements. B. 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District — Sally Gebo, Property Owner. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (2006-420-COA) for the installation of accordion shutters on a contributing structure. III. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Reports from Historic District Representatives • Board Members • Staff IV. ADJOURN A wvy E. Ai/vowel( Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Posted On: July 25, 2007 OLIR AY BEACH DEFRAY BEACH i HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD 111 MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT �',11_ 199.i 2UU1 1993 Property Owner/ Applicant: Delray Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Project Location: 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District HPB Meeting Date: August 1, 2007 File No: 2007-256-SPI ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) and Class II Site Plan Modification associated with exterior alterations to a non-contributing multi- family structure located at 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND'/ PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lots 4 and 5, Replat of Part of Block 27, Delray Beach, and is located on the east side of NW 5th Avenue between NW 1st and 2nd Streets. The property is located within the West Settlers Historic District and zoned Central Business District (CBD). The two-story concrete block and stucco, multi-family structure was constructed in 1959 and designed by architects Samuel Ogren and Charles Toth. The building originally contained nine apartments and one office located on the ground floor. In January 2005, a COA request for the installation of new windows and tracks used for hurricane panels was approved by the Board. No other requests or approvals are on file regarding the subject property. The subject application proposes the following: • Replacement of existing concrete wall/rail along stairway and second floor with a capped, aluminum rail; • Exterior building alterations including addition of "eyebrow" detail and new louvered, Bahama shutters at first floor windows on west elevation; • Installation of entry arch (detailing and material to match new aluminum rails); • Color Changes per the following: • Wall—"Ramie" • Trim — "Carnival Yellow", "Glad Yellow", and "Rookwood Terracotta" (See plans for details • Shutters —"Sable" • Railing and Archway — Color not specified — appears similar to "Rookwood Terracotta" per submitted color elevations. • Landscape improvements; • Parking improvements. 133 NW 5th Avenue—2007-256-SPI HPB Meeting August 1,2007 Page 2 of 3 DESIGN ELEMENTS ANALYSIS LDR Section 2.4.6(H) —Certificate of Appropriateness: Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), the Board must make a finding that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with the provisions of LDR Section 4.5.1. Future Land Use Element Objective A-4: The redevelopment of land and buildings shall provide for the preservation of historic resources. The objective shall be met through continued adherence to the City's Historic Preservation Ordinance and the following policies: Policy A-4.1: Prior to approval or recommending approval of any land use or development application for property located within a historic district or designated as a historic site, the Historic Preservation Board must make a finding that the requested action is consistent with the provisions of Section 4.5.1 of the Land Development Regulations relating to historic sites and districts and the "Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines". LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(7) and 4.5.1(E)(8), provide guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The guidelines are as follows: (E)(7) The construction of new buildings or structures, or the relocation, alteration, reconstruction, or major repair or maintenance of a non-contributing building or structure within a designated historic district shall meet the same compatibility standards as any material change in the exterior appearance of an existing non-contributing building. Any material change in the exterior appearance of any existing non-contributing building, structure, or appurtenance in a designated historic district shall be generally compatible with the form, proportion, mass, configuration, building material, texture, color, and location of historic buildings, structures, or sites adjoining or reasonably approximate to the non-contributing building, structure, or site. (E)(8) All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front fagade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids on front facades, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of building, directional expression of front elevation. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the façade of a building shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic sites, buildings, and structures within a historic district. The following suggestions from the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines apply to the subject proposal: • Deteriorated features should always be repaired rather than replaced, unless the material no longer retains its original features or has suffered such physical degradation that repairs are no longer a viable option. 133 NW 5"'Avenue—2007-256-SPI HPB Meeting August 1,2007 Page 3 of 3 Analysis The building plans submitted with the original permit application depict a capped rail system which is similar to that which is being proposed. However, the existing rail system, which contains a decorative concrete wall along the perimeter of the second floor, is not consistent with either the rail type noted on the original plans, or that which is proposed, but is more indicative of the architectural style of the structure. While the proposed capped rail is not inappropriate or incompatible to the existing structure, it would be preferred that the existing rail system is repaired and/or replaced in-kind in order to maintain its character and provide a more compatible solution. Landscape review has provided that screening be provided for the waste facilities which are located to the rear of the property at the alley. This has been added as a condition of approval. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Postpone with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(7) and (E)(8), and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness for 135 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet the criteria set forth in LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(7) and (E)(8) and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative. See above.) RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 133 NW 5th Avenue, West Settlers Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request and approval thereof is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets the criteria set forth in LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(7) and (E)(8), and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines subject to the condition that screening is provided for the dumpster, refuse areas, and mechanical equipment. Report prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: • Location Map • Survey • Architectural Plans • Photographs Illlll111 1 h LAKE IDA ROAD moo- 4TH ST. I I 1 - > > > > > 0 > I a 'a a a a a I t — N.W. 3RD _ ST. — .,i - > d I- N 0 z N I I I_- I- ix n co ) d' r) MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. 1 1 I Z Z z ST. im 11111111/ imill - z 3imi Z z 3 moiM - — Z sIN � = immi 111111 No 111111 ra MI ffi ATLANTICIl AVENUE — I 1 1 I WIWI I N 133 NW 5TH AVENUE ' --mmi- ( - SUBJECT PROPERTY 12-43-46-17-05-000-0040 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH. FL ::::M LOCATION MAP 1 PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT __.__. -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: S:\Planning & Zoning\DBMS\File—Cab\Z—LM 1001-1500\LM1030_133 NW 5th Avenue ff REG �,� 'ilk • • •4tctrrtcrt ��"RY • 3y"FtE Yk l p 9 r p 'J < r • 1 •PLANNt R9 j ) !!�®°"'�IIGiI+°+ 7fS� n,r ..� c Y • yt.•n ti'i t _ Q eF"'r7 /•",- s C"UL,ix.'d. ..:2 € y :r r t ,r t t`d Ac� ,• 4 !F + t f +1 1�33 ��t.� ,r l#' „ { J. i:' ,,. ,['.�' �!' • ,, 11 ! } •,yi rr., ..,:15, Y 5_ry' Tr 7 r: Y A_.t;,t.�.I } u -' ,�- st y • - lr' , J;fp r 3: ,: ^ w P' l 4P r,,,;a i( a 2 osr • { ,4' :yi r. ,:41 7 , •,F� • ,:7:<f ..d `A'V41"�1 R ,11` .: ,'''r�i -'; +,A 6' ',SE �, `'4.e 4','� H, ' �"� I ' '� ��: ;!� :Sn 7.�,: 4 :;v.�' 4 •t'�Trt!c • "r v'G-n�},.,,i s �"y. x `.,z..N 1�.�,�1�1 y rl t.ak / � -. ., :,,.I� 1 „;. :I.'..{+I'i • {1 .3;4:1 ' % e,.J.« :;14, r I' '`. ',�.. .. :., ''',.: ..lit' ': i,'iit F'A :».E1 .1 1'f'"' ,�.' �.►� ! �';3?71A':• �"t'xi y 2r'�•r133 sa'&r?f "i' n� 7':�,: r.�'w IT 'S M3.� ,71 �}�:. �Y.+. •.T '7� "'' ,d t'� � \ .: ,' ' .,' '," . 7 iA�/S k. r,,..• T fh.tvg.,,,g,:„!,..-u• t .ug�i'D ,if1 !,-D' •k gTY; ,� `� •. !"•I• -_ r.. .1b`.xeT.}.x .:a .t� "'j' v -'� pt : xs }'�i".��'y' Y T 'ST4�s,, ,5:�, xYr,'�,r '"77'�`7 "�.q{Y •,�. x' ,�..•- ,.,r.T P7.. - . :'::, •. Y'1)4 Y�4.Yf 1' �tR '+. .1 a.:,.. gg11 .A,'Ir1Aj . �,:sei q ..I > ,.fit. i . Psr.ISLG . e !'' e /J,,,, , i,,,rl• 79vt. dr Fk.,-„. — �I ...i�.-, rk , , ,. r . I 'r;. ? t sYr.•:;.J, .f i:{`.. !k4:�"ivd,L !r,?,•. :.:;".: .r� y{�.^',• �' �i..y °(i Fiyn.. i�i 11• " i,.E` .,�"'��, i,', Y .�pY' K.Y'+ -W y .�6'4L t :pg ' y .2yK ..YAihe;� P 1 t :, - .;.1 t `0„4 kk t'r c' ilF - 4wr. ! Tl.- ,'Ij•r L ! A r r :- bf9�� ` urn1 .� � F": i A . ,d � Y� '.� � �,.�- a. � �t � r �f.:L:wy��-� � IIDSIA'R rOGIMAY.Sl9TE 7Dl ' .c..I�' ^.. )f 1 X •lk_„;' d,'Eh..'';,, A, •?: f1. ,4-:4 P_. :ii" },- , i�1'^3• {,(��f'S.1•':1� ?d.' j.4 r:i•. t '' ;11 /. REST PALM BEACH 1 �•N PsI., .xi�i "� .,i L5 ,C}'� �y..h�'I `�: �� . '�,^r :':`•: "SF ?'�,�� y*�..'�.f J t't. ,3�Aw:. � 1_ r - ��;.. E L 0 t!D A ]lbl : 7p ry..: 1_ �� li 4' tv.�1' �':v.� `nn3��71 .f •n':77 F ,�f��1 F' ' a!! l V� , d i )..' 2.3"r 116 11 611.7 111 x ' ..1'►. �l(i-` '.�, IA1 A7.. � twu t A( �i31�x t T .i' (1l II�61 r-71J6 , a�4 y ii j� r•+.: Tl.+. iv Ic �s ,, "N?'f i{ r' i y �£ r, Nf x.,q k ' s' `' } +.i !• ,w�' r •: }�' r :F•:, S y'.rd P{ p A Crd'S i ;Y�Q�.]'hlr Ar,1 1 ��r• I{I .,, pm'L rom sA.�rY''� r� 1 ,ki. i I r ''F1.a�'" - � '( i 1 ^• !I T ;`n • .1 CORPORATION NUMBER hY}.,,., . 1 .fK�4, �.F �1 S"t-y-.1.. _S,�t• ��.��+' T.�'v 'iR' rt tt L�'xc.�' }t II 14: �i i'7 ; it �'V. l�}, I r .� {�� AA Oro7u1 p311i`'' t I Q �y. 71,. .. .r 1 AQ&. ,.,r A 6e� .q .Ar,is , "r1 ,� l., P ,•.i, P'•' ti_.,_.: ,f x.r4L ..� .� l I ,� y 1¢ � A 7 ,� . '10;31 ,a j:. '1'A' 1 a'° A, ""'� r" ,.,ram 'th ,;� 1 + r •i s � d 1,e.t.fsGl.y t f: :r:.. I a a upt. k r h :. ....{ t'V. y 8 4'�'•• t-. xc. "14. ,,,, fir .a:. r 5 r fit l5� t.. So t ,,..�v� e§ obi ✓ 6T �.a: I .�?'s`• ,q� 7�Y!'�.',,,,� ,..., I,` 'l 1 :. :V.; �,` �w Tl .,.�'� r 14h ` '"'? r '�� r•� r � 1' J f :�gr ..,c ✓1f � '''. 1L � 1.. '� ,A, 'f.— .1 . +'4ry A .. ) i A `�C ..H ;. 1. • ' ff,r^ r •.1, �:� t I. ll ".•. + �QTt . Iv' Al.:''''':'''.....''' t..:.. r r1.`, 8 ..�. , LrC „ ►• ST b ,, r , i� y1- 1ti ,T ��,+ F ! Rf :..tl d -e ,�+ 4 t :t --- -- • ", / .I�. 1 'N, f t .''• _'!r 4,3!A,° ``"� # � a �`�lw1'q 16, �• 5.� . ! Aa 4 •r"s - Rec h'''ly •;{,..��~.�'Y r^;� gi..t' s'�i I:j r j{ry 'y ' :'''' ' j� d"11 rlit .'• .:Iirli 11ii7 ' ;4' :. 1P , .��.�4fri��Yl '$4'4" )r a. t G`�1 is /,t 3 Ay vyep e^e }q-E • , * ■■■■■"2 T.'' • 5 '� •;4`,,. ar'e;.1, x' 1r �' _Alp 7lirl Lt i , � o-Y.! p �h Yu. tc •'\4Q y r Sf,.r ?s r., 7 .-A f t! q !: s V � � ,f r S� ,7� � r tu�C Y • T. D ':. -4v`V r �e�i. e hh dd '�tr � r. i ` 'd � lr ■a._ v °L ;:ti@ 3.1 „ irfl¢S+ ti+.Fl ■ ^ a" ■cC` - 1 A • 1 V .,,,,,,,,,I,,,,..,,,,,,..... .,,,„...,,,,,,„„,....,., 0, ! 133 N1\'Sth AVE ,:; 1.:40 i • Y ; t'A r r :t 12'i �-.Ixf in�.tll!!t!! - �'9rY6, % ,2' -'' '. A r „� '7Q� .I.i.':,i ' , i ,: >+i �il ! r , ,k , .,,,,',.,,. ,,,,.° 1f `R�i- '.1 ,i�M''�. A I :... •_ PROPOSED a r, '; —�,.�<.:V. • Ar x•�tbi . :0 ? ,. )•',,,EM,14/!,y .10 I33,RNriw�lll!curt!� , a 5 { �f •... ;. 04., 'i4 ,� x,ir ' e,tt r,el •+A ,': t� 1.1II1silo,'m1 ;a" :ti • 1 RENOVATION � c a .• t '''R Frt � Naga r-y w fs, i L� .Is1.,.�i�r�' r J�� j �'i•,..�7'y � 1 , a 9x[j I ka i ?i.+er�'h4' bA / s 1 r 1 I 7 / �� . ' a • t�r�`^v DEI.RAYDLACII,II ti id.': ilf t: 1,".•�1 .Jl yY 1, P,,Pr•� jrJ E, AS ,7 �� t -I �( �• �/� ,e..... .ter 7, F Y q x r 1 {1 41�. x•i,..Y:t. �-f •�@.�� p .t.� 4: yfii ,/P At !.�vr p 1 •'. / I J R I. CRA p e I a $�, ?�r ..dam , �l ,y j!"��iy+p t,,•' \ ! 'ti i- • 1 ,? II ';,L a Si 'Yi+ DELRAY BEACH °1. 4, i12, 1 .ij7� :h t.�/itif. I(/.1\,. . I�fl�►I�1l ::c i ,...I1 .I, •.c_ � .r._, • r ' r " .•�ipi inv I,.liwiiiiiip u4. . �. Q, t.� • • • I�' REVISIONS No. I �o-r �:� ,.. 1 A' ."- ,! I -,7 .. y yr . 1 t r t 1 ? y? s �� r' `'' .Afr T'A r �j f w y +el iits di:' �. e,{ I, • -. I.:'[ I.. r x I J ys+ 1' P ? if'. p yi,- A�� 1 SI�•�. vow. � qt 1 • J ;) /T II�1�� I 1 .j , � •: +•t1 l f } 6 i J ..T y A - DATE 1431 tDE .. .,7 v t 1 r • �_ S. NTS L.'. r • ti...t.r l' , J �� VD CHECCED RED • `A r rt 1 r '� RE(1Na DUD? t r l A I ( A Ps53$d cn t Lr r ,r1.. .A +.1;I1'. , •.y. ,. . drt. .y12 . } n I r .;I d r 1 1 g cswcrtan 133 NW 5th Avenue Delray ;each ''j'U' Proposed Renovation yl lux z mo J 6 , NW 2nd STREET 1 ce 012 fi g - - SURVEYOR'S REPORT: a.,N N °' I. Reproductions of this Sketch are not veld without the signature and ?" 1.U O i IL the original raised seal of a Florida licensed surveyor and mapper. (l)p 2. No Title Opinion or Abstract to the subject property has been F-'m n. provided. It is posher that there are Deeds.Easements,or other f� m a % SI Instruments(recorded or unrecorded)which may affect the abject Z J . ¢f C l property. Na search of the P16tie Records has been node by the 4'af I 1 Surveyor. a T 3. The underground utbties shown hove been located from field survey 03 O. hfarmatbn and exlst'vg drmvi,gx The surveyor makes no guaranties that uv the udergroud ut.)ties shown comprise d such utftles h the area,either y ,� F h serice or abandoned The surveyor further does not warrant that the 1- I w d 1- o underground ut Iles shown are h the enact location eLcded although he g does certify that they are located accurately as possible from re• uwoo iv$ Information avalabie.The surveyor hoe not physicoly located the I� IT uderground nherees. 4. Bearigs shown hereon are assumed based an the centerline of SW.5th Aveue having a bearing of N00022'E.5. Elevations shown hereon are h feet ad based on the Natiional�� t--- - - - _ Geodetic Verticd Dak n of 1929. )' © f CCI ,0 , gg I' Is1 I 31',x-cut 4.6 feet west al east end of the west concrete island at .y ip p I • 9 s I Intersection of West Atlantis Avenue and S.W.5th Avenue,Elevation• W 9 p 17.010 feet. I- 1 6 . . 2 ST Y euaowa r, I d. 0. The specks of heel en shown hereon were Identilkd to the best of < \ ] �' a9 ta'�T(APARTMENTS) t y.,"s 'v6 �u' knowledge and abity of the surveyor,without the benefit of an aborist 0 Jl:i If.nn0e F- \ u g '' of\utv •� o or biologist.It's the responsbilty of the end user to verily the identity O i9' A Hr ,�.0 a of the species. 9. Abbreviation Legend:ASPH.•Asphalt;BM•Benctvnark;�s �\ o��I ,�' C01n �' �/� g_ +' Centers;C.B.S.•Concrete,Block&Stucco;CAP.•Corrugated-Meld Z I W 1 IOp - :I"' oar sear q Pipe;CONC..Concrete 0.IP.•Duehle Iron Plot EL.E levotkre FD.• 0_ �, oo _ 1---- X a ''6 a\ $5 I. Found FPL.•Florida Power&Light Company;INV.•Invert;f.P..Lon Z S 8 y% .pit ,ft' g I-u.<W.f . y Ppe•,IR•Iron Rod;LB..Licensed Bushesr,MS.Measured;N/D•Nit N s , &Disk;O.W,Overhead Wares•,P.B.•Plat Book;P.B.CR•Pain Beach W• 4 ® ,r+ me wrwe �_-.__. ___._._ sE _F16°1 —='1' a mv '•�.._ 9' _ - - _ County Records;PG..PegG PLS..Professional Land Surveyor,RCP.• it i 1 re 'Cr •9' ,3 if = 4 JJ�a. w5 - - - Reinforced Concrete Pipe;R/W-Right-of-Way;W/CAP•Witha33 .e $ ,,.., — Hs• N'�Nf € y 1 Surveyors Cap;W/•With. g E l -. or ,00 wrn wl� M m 10 L9 11, co Z T I J rl.nHn a vv1 LAPDDESCRIPTIODk P" Z •2 a 0 y qy t ) • Lots 4 and 5,Block 27,less the west 5 feet,REPEAT OF PART OF W ' Z [n 71 j $ �,P "• Imo, nil e s , BLOCK 27,TOWN OF LINTON,occordhg to the Plot thereof as < F. m� n••k, 4),P ,� 7 �r 1_,-q4 recorded h Plot Book 21, Pogo 43 of the Pubk Records of Pahl 0 < } y W 0 __ _ _ Beach County,Florida. p) 0 m 0 LL .g o nevru•vw 1489'O8'O1"W 130.57' ' - nwar �+• I 40.. \Lam moo r"masm Sold lands situate In the City of Delray Beach,Palen Beach County, i I "'0p a�04S Florida and contohing 13,055 square feet(02997 acres)more or 10 �' O a 11 s a � s %l j o Z N m nyil J ' rr� Fq CERTIFICATION 1-Z 0 e x My o. a„ l� - - I HEREBY CERTIFY that the attached Boundary Survey of the hereon a 0-0)( /+ 5¢ -— — — — — — — -- -- -- desahed property's true and correct to the best of my knowledge and U Q W C a t brief as surveyed li the field under my direction. !FURTHER CERTIFY 0 2.g V s 'k� that lids Boundary Survey meets the kMnimun Technical Standards sat (/� b at9p. LEGEND \ 472027, oridalStatute. There Florida �orenaabovestrative ogroundeicrosuant aadmnsn N0<aNOK0 BOLLARD other than those shown hereon,subject to the gxdficotions noted hereon. Q Z(]i q 'a$ •® CLEAR OUT c�c}ZOO � coma o.ET G W N�m� ®f Dm10 ELEVATION TREE LEGEND -> •; tl IK c-- cur ANCHOR * LC D:Oi<...5� HAMICAPPED PARKING SPACE r /A� Q(I��0 m F G g LIGHT= HEDGE POLE (� OAK 6 1 j10.7 y��-+.-eb4..1-e... * Data:___{__ _ Y l ✓` �. ` P 4€0 (AMBER CP REGULAR PARKING Lroowu PALM MICHAEL D. Na,.L.S. -ow- OVFIeEAO WIRES Q U�QgW'H SPECIES Florida Registration No,3268. Ed WATER AFTER AVIROM de ASSOCIATES,INC. t, ,( • w000 UTILITY POLE L.B.Flo.3300 I s L�oLL,yt WATER LICE(FLAGGED 00 OTHERS) 1' y 4/S u • a - man WINe_ .. REG i M 1^ II'I"I•f' II_._.•",� , ewlaxe — ,al oI/TIOr 1"' •INTIa:O.a Mg I I �4 Zoning:CBD OJ —1i 3I •..1 3.1 IN a 88 20'�> F0.IliD to 1 _ 1n WO La/saoo a Land Use:CC 111,1 11.1.1 1 r1, ; ,TM z tB/3a00 vdP ,b,> Iii i[ I. lu,1"4ucu1+11;.1 _ �� aro•IA w/CAIr,as.ass. (313..2'300 .13 $89'08'Ol•E 130.57' Ni — J 'P nn,, 4' 1 i, 4 11- 't° 17, • [5 — — _= �.. MOW - 0r.iftl n, .� sns [K�'i;�J ~ '�'' ao 4a.1• s�nw 1xTdOt¢t18'1, � Ar ` Et _ TDMSo ►1611D6NT M•mIl C I • : III w 1 1�11 1111III111I srwai DOtI�9a81iAT.aRI6: l�A,p W11T TALY BIA1y, yr�9I IATLANTIC AVENUE ILOIIDA 333 1'Y Y:RaJR Tq II I4 I1 II PM oaxr.I ._NI I 1111- "t D1o•Llf•f71 11`ai`i` • t`� 7 y°1. vox, IIrATn•11r•ee� ®>9,6'A , "� ° SITE LOCATION mnowLeas LPL le L' �2 •1g 01 R,O� T J N NTS LIJ Ig s4.s °A, gdp `° = xO , O I SITE DATA 6 x = _...._...._...._..._. _ O a % v°p°Ezi Site Description Lots 4 and 5(less the west 5 feet) ._a-z-r �4-. Q Block Town of—' 133 NW STH AV. �° >, v do" ' '�tL3•d n — — Existing Zoning: CBD Q - ;o o PROPOSED H Land Use Designation: Commercial Core APARTMENTS 1 ad ,6ti _ N a I Adjacent Properly Zoning: CBD RENOVATION •� .. IQ 34.4' = :' = w . —" a I Adjacent Property Land Uses:Commensal Con&CF(Community Facility) .F./ Y Z I y Existing Development: RiIL/ ry°� $ 6� to T aundry/Stomge 61 gsf t gA z g Parking Required: I6sp DELRAY BEACH Al I g j$ -•1 16'm/ 9 Apartments(1.75apimit) 16sp iv ; ; �—� 'I Palking Provided:On Site 10 sp(1 WC) tusVlvme HC 46.1' aw�1' 1 a� 1 34.4 - t C� , 4 o� I DEVELOPMENT DATA s 2s Dr v°rJ ¢'/ yo ,E;5' v I - Site Area: 13055 sf(0.2997 ac) `° 1--�- Building Coverage: 3028 sf existing(23.2%) Wo C� y' vA.M./moo walw �•o8'01"W 130.57' ��s.Too Existing Hardscape: 4511 sf LB./sao0 1 4o, I WO v� DATA 06-II-160: La/3so0 Et.42n.6a pro Landscape Area: 5516 of I Zoning:CBD Building Height: Existing 2 story 17' lNu DRAM VD Land Use:CF ;P') a MOM eta ki oI / o a,aN. KM Irlr z I .it NOTES: :1-r. iJ,�L. �, SITE LAYOUT PLAN I.This drawing was prepared for ,fir.1 ` { I N submission to the Historic Board Review 1.} - - SCALE 1:40'-0" — — and is not for construction. — — 'iSi... 2.The information presented is based on the Survey prepared byAvirom&Associates,Inc. SITE DATA ,y dated 07-24-2006. ,o'S `�yen. 3.All height information is based on the existing building data contained in the initial construction documents on file at the • 1 93 Delray Building Department. 1 . of 1 • N.IL.A.MY OM1EKOI / �d ons > > m--- , ; U m REG iyy� 1 1 -� •.RCATlscls _ rT'a+o�c= ��'"'Uit�� nl�, '��A,fF'f"o R. T,••T — f-a,,,, — IJ •P L A N N d R S h.ls� =L—`I. I�,- ^ INCOAPOR.l Id I L > L� =F _�: \ _, .\T.pfSlbLti -� N•MII'-ITG>L.I �-LI VVm•a Tnanw OWEST ELEVATION fOYaM�CM NOf2T4I/SOUTH ELEVATION � T 1 2 v0••r-0. O 1/0••P-m• SOUTH ELEVATION 15 MIRROR BST.1911 nr„ !AMMO wemau +e,- RICK OONLAIFy A.G, ��-•� —��\ rlo lmaw nrt ISBSIDBNT A4•WI1171 '-�--- / 120 I DCTID scHWAY,SLTIBNI +W -Mv's WEST PALM BEACH �, �_-- Inn FLORIDA IS41 _ __ u CS N co Fit 51 11.O 1 9.3117 ES— —Ini-7 Eli \ © / Ys1•, n R -.�-. I�--�1n{--�-�;T` [.sa exu.' FM. U 6 IS pIILf f�•f 116 --� I_ ❑ I I ,. I m erlrco PH CORPORATION NUI.IDPx LJ u M-0D72Mf N•RlY•RYldt 4m94 °r n nom 11 J rixnw C.T.N.4ANI OEAST ELEVATION O SOUTI-I/NORTI-1 COURTYARD ELEVATION O MOLDING DETAILS VW•1'•m' 5 Va.•P.m• 9.•I.-0. NORTH ELEVATION 19 MIRROR EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS PAINTING SCHEDULEJil T. O.>cxlrl T0LMD1cq l+vucT rxcw I�u++.cneal. PAINTING SCHEDULE& -----ALLEEY----- I F9 YAW CO MS MAT y AKA.wn Iem .., MANY �,.,, RAT Kw W 4NO NEW ENTRANCE WALL R,p.M lN0 MT Rll.l uRLIM1. 1 011011. .-.r.wT OU CCSI R.1 NNROl TLuan. IST NW 53 Ave 1 , I I-.PANT OA Ima RAT .HRJIN WILLIAMS I F.I M IA..> RA, .I5RYN WM1LI.M1 S , I �n RANT ma.,,. rI-Ar .m..In srcww WILLINJ DEIRAY BEACiifL I I EXI9TD:G i DELRA HEACH TWO-BMW Mina Na 561 2768559 C09 BLDG. REVISIONS N0, I -_ 1 I I EXISTING pi �� EXISTINGI fLYiPTWO-STORr �IIipll' TIUO-STORY II - CBB BLDG, - CM BLDG. -I In T OTKRI I DATE 033007 SCALE A9 SHOWN 1 1DRAIN CH S - II CHECKEDRBO ROOM[ aon ji LI - _ MM •1.11511. P74 NW 9 TA AVENUE PAINTING SCHEDULE& WALL DETAIL PLAN NORTH Alb, SITE LAYOUT PLAN CONTT•�HENTS N III 1/140.1,-0. • A-1,01 • 133 NW 5TH Ava UE ZI, , , PLANT MATERIALS LUST . PALR0T6PAMa • j F M�• • fTPI.FERN • 22 Asnme wra:Fw 15Gm . USTRCNPINtT ALM i .� iL.tO{m 1rrGxGrorG AMSCLU511321,6 FERAL SS Hn fw 'i� 14.4144f ;C� Ff' 1Z�/ I NJ ma Illi•� 19 ua urwHP • 4y4,• dY'14:':,04) 3 a '!;}iTi-3�a�LP i I=I I=I I•I V 3':1A . 'i',� le .� 2lamv 55 remw.wnrxo i,.: l X Ci SOW.ie*ow _ G�IIIDUTTRMUb 1��__-�— ' ' 6 GG I 64 3-GAL t3 Mx 24"5m 1 L,PI: ECatme TORS DE EMR ALL 35.nA M1TD'1•L%FaPhfNT,IADCR APO•APERVLY]I PEEPED Cannes 3�x�C�+,�y Fiji.,F�j, FOR TIC NSTNAATW CE PEVtV5 FMATBCALS I A1FD A r-n i kV j 3 6GrPw.. 102 W/M.aLarA Y'aw.a+o' 01 TVEfMAY.fD. Nw Sa 1 E; 1,."1,` w� —6Cwr Rum t µ•' 2.4npw55�ruv„, P3�C y�Hr.x 5.5ra 2 EmmaRAW MATERIAL%GRA55 APDWEDS 5Wtl EC RO.WD DY "4•'. }.:x-a to•„'; ; t, —SRvwx Eaw:roce Gum 33 H..rmrx LAID9GV'E C(dtIRADTRt • I i 'O"" !�7GusOvrA xm DNARFFREE4.6H 'a AuPwrrmom.5Sw+uDEF #1CRCUER. I 3Gwa2,:rwa(Y'5m• 156uC.kw.ac n .bar .�M� �.ALL FlAhTT MATBd.L9lD'ATxlD MbT PE APPR0hD DY Ct1Y i S JAIRuPrN5TµMDAfd7HRfgLTUOrC`T PRI�'R—TO NSIALLAMIITxnseulaPwsn � ..l., 6'Fit X4'Sra F.G. a ..AW9G•PE atttRACTCR:' NOM'AL.UtIltC9 MGR TO fX.RG. •� 1FarcKPwu WART F 24 °a w AuPwrtMaTFcwsS�+uDEDwnlEn PATH A WALWYTwrnE. • 4GaoC.m '—' 39WwnFDw 3G.re�...s CPSOL FROM TVEDCAVATYN RT:A`D um OWLET TCPSaQ.3 ':;;'� 2 6 HruAvPRMDsn 7. A41numGDEDDSwu PAVE AGRAMMFFF�PRGENTP RDCCE TRAVELER'S3Tiosot,ocr. M1"l:: ': ..,. I-2Pwrmn Pwu TL AoIAA M FD70T;RAT®NFO TVE TCP 2NIF..�ff 5Q4 AS Wfl1/5A - ... 3Twmm� nmn ■■ 4 p rawa SCRf.Vf APREA7Y)j PRILit TO MGM. 1� lEON; 8.ALL RANT 5A`D T1�55W ILDE STAKED. IL t x Tyy —22GerkwPwrr !' 6 �5 PEY5.s 5"GL a ALL RA NTIAMBCV.59Wi.H4TE ALW7LWA TADLET9.OR ECM. (.-... Nsv`.an G4BDAGEPAIM NYRPI�RATED MO PVMEG PM 3Turoa Dau fv' } 2Gran 3. V.AL PAArte DEM NALL REEKA 3"LAYER CF FLm-Mux1 N ,i.r.. ' 'X 25Dom Frateli, 15'M,'I�MA14'Hr. ix 3Twxmms 4 5aonawwm 141 it l.vuifAPECC.MRILTAt� F161/ff NL rtANf w.TF>auaA/� Nt•� ••• .•1 `l: C.:—25cnuHxxTxww 0 3-61.4 2liA AlECUMELY WATERED NV WEELED LML RLA.ACCEPTANCE: aj 1TrAsmiaPw.: t.:� 0. :.;-40Cana:o 2 `xi rwnunMi xl wi: lt,'—27fmnu+ �'D.,: 32W:f:TATc 6OuecJ.aac BpY Ac5F 5T0. Fi r i 32WwRArxrrxlas ;ice NxSi l� , E, —6MxraaarrPwxe L!ri•.' �Carruw 4 APEJA�4'?Fhx24'ann 't.. 'Jr/V.'s if L�1t 1'.`.r•t. li'. 3 •l•. IP ol'Am p SAHT KNOWWRE • •-.,.11.AAi+ 4iti '••sri :.d T dj' —�� VFarw.Fort TT3,,-aG�wrat 24"Ncx 24"5m 2hwwDiaPAue 19Fcar.0 Fca 6tA'".1 N 'A':: 6sy.k' w UNARFFAAKAHATCIEGRA% ' i �„yUxt '�� {" y4 BGaoCwu gd da � ...... :MN..1 .../ik r.'t 3Gwm24urrAw j 1Pwxom Pww p t 16Cmwgmawro 12 Vorousa.i3YF tilt MYTITGQhRYPA1M N.eSn j NwSx 1 0 �` g 1a6' 'Fh 8a.17Hr. �t vI \I I_=.J O.1 L. i` H CYFm4Ara .I. 31Ka.x 31,000w.Scelzmul :ATAN ;, ��ir\'� j j o.5 "\' • -j FesoAk.yvP�raQax SCE-WALK Revision#:• • Scale: Landscape Plan: 2006-076 Landscape Design by: N. Davila City of Delray Beach Date: 6/7/2007 OE 1,E= nor otr 133 NW 5th Avenue Community Redevelopment Agency • I I,. Vil�I. .72s0G[ -I T�MG.CR -.ALLEY I _ I I Lie.:�I i=.7. ill HEFJ1TfI i I _ II CONC.SIDEWALK411C I Waft .......� LANDSCA.FEp I ,K„„y I—_ _� '; AREA wT- 1 1111 • 4 STORY - - - --. " IF fm,.e.r,uw PUY — A►,}BISIFN'� �' am • f_ BUILDING [� ,[ „ — Ini It , (�. , TM.,c.cR. 2 STORY 1 t'lv� III i —roIA mirk:m , MULTIFAMILY T _ —.L I II _I RESIDENTIAL AS BUILT'S �l I sO T _li/I — I—r °R ___ J' 173 Are 1 a .� I n iiiiii' :",,,it .., DF7JtAYBEARi,R. LANDSCAPED —��; _ __ T _ U L u uu.d ..� iUnnisr f,[' — --a-8— wawa — i CRA LANDSCAPED -_ - ARE4 Or scale. i I P.id ;Mt6+r - i /�lo� � -- m . =r- I' D PAS CON 7�IDEWALK - I l�'3`a•�'. 1 I I CNAEY y3# I I,YAPoCIIYs ' I 1 1 , I. 1 — tl^^� ll�g+ _ L_ REVf3ICNS N0. UV I-® I 1 1 III _ I' .I,.. C._..,- _, . 91DEWALK J • II II _ LLOLL AWRY i!J �,♦�ppT� - FIFTH AVENUE _ �LPI67 o t-Ej DATE 02.2001 LACE • (i i arm SGIB AS NO7FD DRAWN Smsaai _ED QG'� O517E PLAN Props No. • L.____-I L___-- f ---J `---�11 N O LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN SITEPLAN morv4•••r-m' &LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN - I CONCEPTUAL DESIGN A-1.01 • • aax1N+MrM r 1 { O O I I I', { O O I. • 1 1t Tea LM 0,, 1 A�ECITd"----',...1 I I a I I RdZ1KAdZi 1 ��YIM1I M { 4 =Baa1 II'. i' ta�a { { eenaau E 014V'RANI. I y 61O+.1e 1�3 WW1 I-�W'. I 11 (a Leaza aaa •YIO. nirr { Gala I • 1 i_i iimR "° RESIDENTIAL, )"' wR:: BUILDING ij f AS BUILTS _SOS_— .=u+... , I . . , 1 - a� u3NwsmA.e bP1RAY BEAM FL ILACI a CAD a `. O4_ _ L " L 0 OO _ O66 _ T I= _ _ - ! DERAY BEACH �� i C 22gat i i 4 REVISIONS NO. I z. II X Gar[ APA:I IA A!A YYI�t A _ itr. DATE O1N07 tasa Casa SCALE AS NOTED G Al ' DRAWN m 0 a O[.QA'L23 QBC[ED 'i !� 1 EajedNo. L { L • . Ali UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN N„ { LI4 .r•m^ • UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN CONQPNAL DESIGN A-1.02 ..., .� „....,..,..,.,'._. ._.,r..t�....,...._,,„.'.�..,, ,.,*.,-,.•�,.,'-r,k.:.;3, '� >,«.,. 4.,.�",';�•. •.,:oI,',��,.)�a�tr; i t oL i.; .•tq .• • l�.:. A .,;7•- • �yi:rr'• 67,.,,itk„� �.,�"P-A Xn , �, ' ',�� 'i ,,%�,>,�, :r. ' ,yw. �-..M'r��' r�<., - } '.;�r a"> `r•{y , ttr,:�,t?.. '� �i xr � . 1:EEtY N 4, ;' t;�;:>.:i."*iti:x ti'Xrnr.,•',jj ,f„ ,',:',, ' f t:,'Si;:++af F(r {dr.ex;r �0 �waa-,. ,.� : � 3. � q Ff;s'. .f7:`T3'IA<,e Xr ";'•3,.x;; ;v;,w ;,,.-aa,:T ? S s �t . 'i P '. d!)!,,t t, ;1R ,. .^tI r 4:, �� . 1 . r �. ,�ax. � ',v t ' .r i� .�:.r l�, ; �,rw,�l.n ot,;: s xk,1 Li f, n ' a..?, rn. . tt.,, x',�. („L'rr tr. u,.•;k <. ' .i.,!;. ,t t ', 4 „ rt r " 2 l.: ;.,.'-•ter-;r:-i. -rt .< .�" ;,^ �.,,; , ,,., ,,i„„M,.rs. ,�{.,n. .,Lt rei ,r" t . : ..{rr.,t,, .,1,J.",:+'!. ..ttr, b ,, . ' sii , r t :p_9,:i,.„. . ,d:,tl��. .v ..:..;. .'... t,'..,.. � ....,... ' , ..;_�,,,. v,�t'„;•.�,,t,, .,,1rr.'. t,.:o,,t .:t: ,. _ ` t tli,, i ) uaa , 3g,: .o.r.,. r,.::.�. ,_.«, r� _..,.....,_�;.,_� ,.. ., .,,-..rr ..�,, :..;.-'; - ,:-,..-.r.,a•,'t ..,. r ' , ,.'..,r H,, :c.+i , , • t 'i i 4' 'I t ..` .. • 3 ...- 7:.u•.�r"tri.C',s;6T >44•.j y,7nf°r�S'`n^:' .lt K.it*rt.„,••'.,.�'L'II •Jr.t tt} 'L i yy k - 35 4 4 """ : t G �Tj yJ, ^ z? , ;3 ` dy't > .Y .�SY ? r��y�� ' r ` g • 6ll .. ,, la .w .7 K �.ryT,Y« ,n ac > t wi'r iS ,q N Y ` Y : . 't ° Ywrztzt R . �r t :$4 � &C, —FYr zl , G1�, q r1, H? � .. y '-�, ' cil'c ,'gi� t' r` ; a{ " ` 1�"f rXk� ; •t%� � 1, Y gy ;� Z7 . .. n � ' ak• �' Ln "e i 1 t ^f' ti� 3 y , ct1Rj+ l Grpx "Wi" yKr .?< \ `t v 'a'�t •ic 1 y , ijr0 ,i, � �r4�rr7 � k,"h�;58,,•. .uLsr� t & �a 4? 3 � ? ' c '� a rx;,4v F aenn mot' x' ',Cnstructin S vp�i i '• K �i Z neittontKtCFLt t .,`- . ._ • - w ' �,sk+k`t'i 43^+a rls'r, F rJ tDPiajBeah k ,}<$<1 w� , �xi r 4` � ;,YO • • • • • • ; t • � 1 G cF ..y� ) p:1;:^x7 ; r4J n f r • ` �"' 'YF.1 +...:i k ^1 � U;.wxY''}WM . T.. .,^� .N 1 � .7:7'. t s,.� A'�k�pga a M,�'"• ^ '' 4 f •'� •TY7' �� , i. ,.., .• A� .1 ( ,^ 3 . ' ,•*. r.tlr ryR e s.' m, r • f , r w - f^' wccd� , !� � EI" roP} •� , ,� •.r,n• ''' ' ': .• , Y.M•r1«gya:A'a • . .5 " ;,..i � 4. 4•� • r 'i" ,.. ;;'r, J 'T ' ,,,i.'1 A H -• •r ; ` r^c: .x, " 2' Y<., ' ., t. ri' r. h ' r P i r w :: ra iig;r," ay ',....- .F+* , '"4:: . •an^>M rt ? 7i T $'iy 't 'Stipy�« rS,. !tts -' , d: '..>¢l i4v"• • • ,i.;1144,1 :h. ,tr' k:Mi. i ":)u1", "..'- !^M,'". ' 4_" . 1 r ^r E(i II tv l',. :t s ix:' 'r„rv„h� i• IS "�C , . .cU I, . :L•r•*'Fw^:S�lr , .G. s�( 'A. ' 7Pr ; ri! �x^A_it ^ �sy S1. r.+' .a r 't� 1 �7!!i i i'!: :.,t `Y;;I. g i!> ,t.t,I.r II MM:11 i '. ii?�,,r! Y"F: ' i ,, V7 't I't :: u,., �; `. ar:.. , ' � i.nt i';; . _ ' x:i ( � ra • 'ta r 11 c.w.�u:u.,.ur_"p+i:,.A.-:::: { � — •,R, ', Y. .afis i.�' i,R '1.14, ",1r, ( . e.'.w W.", YOk:•£704$0*.:/§4'.,,, 4 _.: ' •'.'• 7n jC' '\ t.,,,tr� rt^r$:.,� • � '! _...� � J ��j r.: x,=, "T — 1 .... .;„ '� � t"L 1 �x a� ,p+ f . ., _. . w .mm — t 1 � t i r�,hIJ1 r. A rrw .r.r,„. � ;! r`L. ,t "�,itG�..'' "c �+F�� ,/ . � rym .a{. ,w. • •tL r; • ' ' ' . ' '.., ,...'' ..:, ... '' .:.',''','':' .'..':',.'.. '.''''.'''''''' ''''''''''','-''..'.,,,''‘'..'..,'''.,,''',..',''''.'..'',''.. ,‘''',.','.,'...‘:.' .. ',,:.''.''''.'',.‘ ''' ''....'''.. .: ' % '''' ' ' '' r:':: .%1 4 •p ... � -A. 41, u .i>.?:ka,sv.:: «•i:f, tt.� i •i t ` �! i 4+•.t `iii,41, '),,:., - jj ..t:.• t 1 y r r„k,'i '3 `'\' t r' t { yiTni ;.a: r u:1:.,a:,, Mom,. ..r {j,a;, ";littrt, t, •f:.*.7•-' ... 1 ,,., ,+k '• r'f711it i�irjl.,IY�xy�tet ac`#'"N� S�4,ta•i:e.r� .� wwx-:ky'hk '',rF'?'+i;;k r!17 ,'! Ss4 '1.+: .t°j,+.,yl ,/j ',Y.. _S P`Y� •Y•r �# 'r �,r,,:i., r e ti'n),, ..t 3q:,.;rl, �. , ,, , ',+ 1t "ij1r17,,t111 r 1i,jilk?, .gi l"Y{1fi;l,,,�f:Zt,ttf,{.t f y x'ef, a s �,F:: �'q k-r -4 >:i ,., f3,l= {; 3i,,`, ..' ,, y^ { "{vr;{ I!{�, . t 7 0 rt r, f 1 .t A\al' f if, � ,r .''{,ti 6.,r ."':,r r :' 't .r .$ t,',,r, s„ll,i„t,1•4 it I It II r 1'titf tt r tr ,th' r r,. '. F`;1''. r .zx. FN t,i+. f ,c•'.:• ••: 1., ';r' t ;, IS 'f'1'ii.8 ! „'f;:j:'' 'S4 I! i 1�1 i I t , $y.`,, i,,F,,, §t, ,!r a r'?'•' a _ •.YJ,H,...' .'� )` r,d:r t �:,. I1,h'r,!'. •a! 'f f 1 rs1 :,;I Sr fir „f,4 fi {' i ( ,� 4 '. tt el ;;, .i . SNtf 1� '�'•.•!{,I, r,fYri y•... . , fr,, �;i, i rr,r s „: 'n; .,', P,'A -*,,.Y� r 1, !: r: , ' .f, , a t r,. ' .'''" f1},t f`f. •a){ " r .,: ; ' ,... ::::r ;! .: .:,...:;.,- ,,.'{ '+ae� 1.1. :a l ,•slx.„.r,' .•r,.41i,; -,' rs ',t f'}I,r,? t t, ili • r: x ,C,i.,,t.1,,, i,1,•.', r,l„r1'c. yJ "1:. a i.. ,.-.5'r„ 'K .:5:, \h i ti t+l',Stt}1 I" 1 furl _ Yif ,.i,rc,q,, t i `''s.f' f.�'`w ., f t.,. d F .,,, i ,� n. , L,,1.. .r. .1' •In (., i .t, I i r t 4 #, ''ififA•X';;1+ 1 d ). r ,,i ,i,, Y, r 's ,i. --$1..ggr.x 1 v i,•r: SI i 1h1 i tt ;i�"d ri ... s ,µ ..}-1 '7 d?kl,��., a,..rw,rr E �; ,1, �`�j ! ,,. : . .:,,>. ._, .. ,, � y+ : ,i! ;r1!».,�;E;It,;k:;;r ,4 f1 ff 1!` ,,,r!11 � t. ._ .... r,,, r., ' , :," �,+1 (Itr fi .r , •-^i�'}Y; ,. •may .,.., • F..r. as�( ,�{? tt� �i� , .� 1'Ic i.`f�'u,!..', {:rt:�:r't r ,., .. PS '" t 1 r�s S x�,'. 'x�r�,. , 1' i i v",^e ,>, .i-C' „h a. 3. Fr T if 7 1 i ,1 4i• ,-x' r r "ass � r pK.p s r +ln j {r' {if # i r aw li "t. 't.r� i`li r„L' d ). , '+'� fi, r: ( "� � ';frl 1 ! .... . w f.a i a t i[,, - to ' ` ,F ", ti 1` ' .. ............. ^ j5� L N' S 1 ly Tf Hi R , d t .:• v S I i 4YY" ,,,t...itw } $' r, „,tt{' • r5! "!}T° " A r rT a . „r�+ W ,T,:•. .,J n '.t,} f t y. ,hf,. 1 {Pj\ 3 t ll ..xi' •' 4 y� yh f i§ 3 $it i ,, „ J561J 336 2621 i _ �'' M, < i ,!£ ., ,t `. f• ,>r , < , . , M a , 1 4 . tt g �' ' y ,rat.' ' #. '') '�• 'x s' • .F 'I.!>/7 •e•, r,,,fl,;{iii`'. I' t „ .4! 3•'[k�rti�{ t i, {r..r', , ar, ... ..� �i a,r q 2 Z ' d pp s "r 4 •i l f„Ji 'al'ex kr,ku ,p R' y � ,r s u rt,, ?i7 r,', • •:4iixa4. a+y,f�t ,4,y: s J.t47 , ,1 .. gAl9l �q, • �Ji ,q .: ..�, „evr'z,:+ rur, •x:,•, �r• M q:,1y s r„'', ••• -'�:' 7�� ill c,.'x,�� i '.1 1 __. tt'"aa ' 'fie` qg.�+.".�. :1.,,«.,i ..'"w'� •t ",ram • ,:r1:;,. liti',,^ .Q r, • ....... .,... _- .. j f I.---- sC! S_.`,+• :.n*^,.':-c, '� k G �rr,yw + � ,r r'r,i:f im'FK! 311Mg.✓ :'l YH" Y",`� . ,> •,••• .1►• 4sin ki" !r"�'ii , ssr>.vT.' �.Gv^ >;,f.•-.-,t",. ti'Y,7,i!' ! ."S. �.1'' - ,...7%,„„:< f 7.1r'.117, 'r 7,1:, 't Y• •! i r, f�2x t �:vrt;>w+-;* yy r+ "� "r j rilk [M�n tt'i I1,, r t , 1 1 , \ ,w i, i :'-,i .ayrVjyy�i �tg`'a,Frrf l!.�"�l.: ,ma,ygtl..,1 '«t,r i- ➢' t�::..d,+-�t'a*r x I ( ; l r„r.r,::r�''4t1 fi "2' ° „�".''.'' i1,1,,,,' + r" ; ,17 ;? t 2.'e s�';:4 ,a f%+-r"' •ry iy r t r$..' e q xy'"i ih r•; _,t#•r ir. 'l'�li}l!t I. 'ri•::' 'rf • • '•� , r.' } •^ • '.. '"' ,,,,4r,'a°. :,1,"ad t,tc fN fljCti„}{`R� }'rid rl �F r,tr, `.�Y ,k !1`*� 'Y y .'w' • t Y� r .,eV{ t' 1.a • � ,3., , ryrl 4 >;Y • ' t,, ' {.5v r „ r�'r, f �� r v, . .k '4.'c' ° r�t;:'w aat'''' !r. .,,h '�. tF t,jR irp c a ,•4..,4.. ' t ra' i r '+ ':11r(1i;"yr 3„ at Nf {'xr:, i zjr., „rs: pr.7r. , ,,., r#, *, r., ;r i s ,'�',fir,: . ,",, r sit,.xr r' s:, :' t ? . r :� 2 r: ,.,.--!:',,�. �.i1.y �,r,d 5,� '�f�� 'h-. ;."r Y`..p� �.�,�,°. '� f.>;;;- .x,�', s"`,,,ti.4 i, 7' a,f�n,y,t'y+•. », .,., r. ..:,' ..�.. :,r, ' .1.the a �,,,.s ^r ,1' �` J ,fi 4g s1 ,R r f4t .;H., .r S y '• nl,. ,,,ra.l.,1^.. �. .;�. ,.. ;,.,- '':�� ,, ,�.,r;.:�?,�f,,nr ',.4a r. ` ',.�r �,r;.,' M,x,• „er'�r+.� .;�,:n E',i4e',.yt '��'' i•'�v r. 7"-"ft�A.�^ .rrt.: `:t,'P F^:,,1 ,,. ; h 7-1 , , . .„ .. ' :•, 4., rl f i .1T'7t .44 ,.4•7,r• r, r;1, , r., a :, , .,. 1„i,•9 a. .._. ,.. -,..'.'� . . � :: ,� : '+'" Jt '"N'„W x ^r't`f dy',yr st�'vd r't'' s �"l:F';"s { r, ..t. t !r t ,6 ab ,dr. Y!F«•, ' ; :;. r�r. •• .,i r .1�` 4 x , 1' tr ., rH, .,'.,i t�rF .14,},. ., ,., �' �: IS': ......: : �it, `ti:.'9'i .f.,•,,. .1,114..:,?� �, 4.}.,,.,r1,U,,,,1,•,r . ,.. _ .:. .,. : �I ii : �I r "ti s. .. i•. ,,,,,. ,( ,rig,,,,,,,,,f. t 13h .I, ,. "o, '' :' ei# ..un .t.,,.. . .}.., 7 i.,. ,,.:. �. �"':'. .i" � .'. , t '�� %,"G"F"�._ 11 , rl r6 : ��:ntt�.l4.r ,r• ,,...,,r pp.t. ,,.F1;., i., (':{",,;....,,,. .. �.,'. ,: ;i�-r(.....:,.n .;�,,. . ,.r I. ,..:4c r d �l, f..i •r., ':"+ . ,. , F, r.v, ,..,.. 6.'>I .-, '1 I' !rlr # •,: _••K •,`, .'.d,l .!. ,it tt i „ . .i,...,.:r „r,,,, , . ,.. `.$sr",'+ ' ;,.,' - • ,... f f ry tiv.-, n 11 <, .r 1'.„! .f au. '"f 7. .""'...•`•uL.r_ at'. >i,�, .t. 4" rrf 'I • „r" 't. ,r,, f ,.;r .air: �' .,.,,. ,•1••;A'r •l. {, f r ,�Ir,, ,n'" L +'�': �a„ +tt r� ,iilr'h�' r+..*`r,,:i` •L: t rC`",,r, f) '1 t>lt ,d,,,x�' .,rin�h, y,,� „?W r. t �7f„ Y,n f �y r2 1,• 'Y++�1. .,1'. P"": i ,{ ?.i � n „ 1 ' ... + .. .. .! , '.i ., r r .. w ;. re,l ,:\?, ',1M,- di •13,1i'',,t''''',"r d*,F M ,.' ' . , Ca ., ... s• .,r r „ .. ,.,( �.,,..,,., r, ,,, r ,1,,,rp. 4,r, ,,r,.rt;.,r;. X�!'A,,.,f,,.3 „ ,l ,a 1il ,.. �r p.r p .. rt2 ,_ ! i - 5`i i)w t F� r ..., o..,. .,"r , ,,.. ,.o ..., ,,,. f F. , r , t.... i`ru,:�. . , ,.rf , �1 t,l } r.,21 ,I 1.r{ , .a..,> , ,+r w+t' . +r•,,,:. � 4 1i,r,t 1 1,. y_'___.... .,. , ir=.<i, f,�, 1,, .,,..,.. ,",...,.;.,x�x u9-,,,=! +,�•. " , . . _,> ._,,..?t-.r.trr. ,...,� 1,. ,#', ,� �"r, ,,, 'ir F: .;3, 1 t.r' rt. , rh' I .1,.. ',. tf. :.{ �t:( .f � ,.� v ;1.. :.i > fl+",,}{t't ,y, i,x„a.l.., ,., 1 ., r,.., ,,..,..r r ,'.:•. ,....;�. _.�,. ,:' r ,rn t, 'z, d'S>: � 7`n.� lu..'k. ..,9b r,,�r� 5r,o'u„ ,y., '•ru.: ,. �' ,.� ,,.'..-. . ,. �,.,.. �.,<.•,..-> ><,, �r r,r �. .1. „.�, , 1, ,' }i 'kt :,},7".,.�i' m 4..xi4"` -� e ,.�.... r'u.. tr ,, ,, r,�tF. . .' _.. : t x .. r t ., � ,.ftr .�. d 9! s«. , 3. .. � '' .. . ..�' .. io°.. , {'; p,...;,.• , ,,. ., .,."hf•,W!,•. r.,, ..,,_,L r..... +, al ,r. ,.>. ,,.t�'>. tanr+a t j),1f,.tir`{,I�'Ec,,r, 7..�``,,,.,,a•1.,, tr,,.li{�4»:� ..r„ "k'* _ • -e 1.„..:�z,. .,1 ,nrr 'a - `.t =t'7,>'3'; '`r,r _ r �. .. .,:,.,,.•„ az". a e..a.,find,.I��a 1_,l a ar,E v' .ac,.. w.,s n k.�f�?±,.1„1�;, !r.a ..r, .{+ 7 1. ,i, �. r�' �r,�• r. . .�' ,,,r. •,•:xr , -'.,,tr !, ..i ,u rr -G,.._,.. , -., r-a.'i.d'i..,. 't;1 „.,_,�:t, I,,,+ r t,, t1.r< „ ,,.v r., ,Ot-' !� ,• ;t r`,"i,> � n ak,,,,;, -',t:• (.r,, ,t t,-„'a ,r,,,t,.''{SNd •r}t ct c'0,•,'r:> ,ry ?Zt`. .11�t+.0;^.f„+, .mfiM ,{e.r ,47_,rL r, f, ,4. ..), ;L„Jf JJ ,'t,. r`?f 1; x• N. 1r r'k, �3r „i'U. tnttwr¢ .� t).,i,t S:1a,2'. . 3 '.,t,,• `` ..I..:,r ' U ,G: Y '1 1, 1 4. .J. ,�, ^It•;Y„ ti-yN�+q•}i f,* It' .,,k ,X• .�Y "4L `'PS , y r i� S�. i .I� ;i:,.G .i' .§�. i v �,•� '.... „•,;.�,... ,,. r,,,„ '.., ",, .:tf>" !, U„1, �r �, ,fit r: rr,,. ,�, ,.r, 1,N>',-1. .,...�.'Fi.r,Y. �,..,c i ,, ..:Y-s4.:,e{t,;it{ 1..(^.. .., �r,f;�.°;, „ irp.t! Irit' !.. a,:,to.. a o:� �'`1t . t,�P \ ,c,i i:,. ,t, t,,.,r, )r.,, ,.,1 „r.F i t,,, ."1t'i a,t L+R ..t ,{G.,r't21,2#t .,t5 '� .rt „ .t2: ',t'il f ! �+<S"f +. a k "�'-.;r.-2."•nie ,"--',',,:.', ,r,l: P c^rc, ,.r.'t "r.� ..F,.• t�. ,r;r, 'f-r i. ,Ir ,o, ,P•f ,.ur+i ..tid, ,� '`} .> u.'.{`,.rd,{. yi ".rir � .'xY, ��. 6 g "W .,,� �'nSa's „�.('rr:,'."�'�. .`4f- •r Fs' rr t'., wi:. ,t zt 5j ,(;r^.n :)M •I r,l I;.'$M`„ •,N, .'r.F � .1•r.a:,'{ ,ix^3 't7, ,, 1 r� ',h ,�' 'rr,•" ,,.✓^ ^A'i5 .r' "; nx.p,I !, .r r,R':,r,r-; t. ?�' '•7`1<' b : 7,<' ',yn `'�,.,.",. *'7i� o.r ;vioir�Y..dha;,.,,N,... '�,�„� :,.r',,L r;t •:?„ "'r. ...r:r,r, .xr (1, r,y ,.i ^'a ',. ,7,ad+1•,�, r,t' a! °��, '7� r �` „tw.h,J, rh ,,;�4 r. ..„ t. pp..�<,'!",., �rr. � i r,}Ciy�+..�; Ji:: ^i .^r,:a-•,. x. .mry 1 RR�iu' r 'Ir„S .t°,1„' �.,4�<x".+.,4� S�i�.k •�, ?El.rit r � ,��•t :. ,,,. a. 't %u••'liu,.i,,,'.,4t x ^'X,�., '„f`',r1I2p,);'�u, r,t,'-.r. :tFS7',. ';^';, ,' {1 }�,1;ii{ ;{({ }..01 ?[. ,.a ,. __ t,-r <,,�i;h't 1 .tt• u'•'•0105: �.2., ,i" �f^xC5„i 'F.Cii � `*7' 'r,J:fk,';,15. .:),','dt1., ewP{.:. >_1. r ,.'<,�,'(y+�, t�'`d•t' N i'i:,, -tC,t, a. e „rvi. ,.t. �;:, ry f,. ,P -1`f. ,r:;r t: ;i.• c nx� (. +.,�+;"'� d:: -a.Sa :vr u�` k. r�k _ pa �7, t .'C,, u8' is"�i {3.j#wx�.r`�, � s {F�. :Kt(y;'ri;, t, �t{ 1 ,.u+r S,'I,�1r t#" y�itN t Itt�A�ly,.,t'N'{^}'.'�r,�`i A� »l"`.v .y' a P,v,>,.;,t„,?,,:l?1�, � '"4 �yy�r�`�`, y{�t s '�',;�.r� g4 r" ,1.1 ,{.,•lis; }i ',F,. .r, ' }'•!r.n •",4 .., ,,�4x,3}'r4+ . 'i.�ft'j r{l,.1,1(ij,•0,,v �c,,S,,1, r. `.,r,n 0' 0, yf, .,b.. ,,„ w,4••• ''t* •:.p5' 4 # 2d:ri{n.i,y ` ,ii' '"'9Y:,�.., '.r'4M'�~�`�cr�bV,.r:::',.t"4tiSM4;L k`�;';�:+rfk � '','�., >''�,...+t "r.,. `;'S•�:` 'w:r�N..� .,.;.'.rt,,,E`rs., ,,t,g,u �r: '�..• ,,,' � :� �. & .q, •sj. c .2+S,�t, ✓'+,ri? r�•':,.e '�.+1.•.t,fr .4df"' . f ..� , "ro ..,�.� L,4;,:X..6 �' :46' t,•�#, S>�f;u,,„, ,�q,.,tu��r.;`! �' y �- •t:wrr� '�s �` t`"' ;,F �'1 `� �,�`s+.,4X` � :{� �'^"`,+ra, ".. ,g„'`. 1 r s?r�'+ t �, .y ^utiCfl,', r5, N',� .'4�j. yy��y�, p ,N,,, {� r � a# ; �i�f,�, �`. ,� ;^y� `ll:�i r,>F^. Mr�d+ .r 't�t�' � '�.^ ,frx: � ''t it �• d. ;sw�1. � �! :� '",t .1"4r?:a,�!'rR ,, .;A' '��#.' u��',`'�; i.'i• :..t' t�� :,�,;� e-., ,,t,.. ,y .. .'N n., 1 �,'.c• ;s��k r.�L .l.iiw ,';',,, : ,'N• .ar, x. dA''''ild' ,nY,'^,_1,• w" �.,;: fir, ^.A,1,4 ; t. ,•�q �`I t 'Y {11 :. ,,,.,r' r114;-at ktr� MSIV ^.tr•C�u'd{i': !':a 71 " ,�i5. ,s'. .l r 9+u��S ti ^a'1r.��` ,.! Nw"4 lt, �t�. .'s. .�1d'ta'�.,t,+;tuff'. qq��'�''E ':I,','�„i;�j ,t.'c^',I'f:.q' •d ''J S ,.�f r Rx gn +�"'�ya i,t, ,e .l,y.rA r. nax,.1 i.�,3>.E .t :�,' "t ',� a: •' 11 �„ r'§tr,. n,u�,'�SS` wM,. •,•�,tt,',s�Nw1x :ktt4 c. 1.- y„, r. tt .r3,u4�..)�..,,; !�.y}r,,�o-f`�t. .o` w.y?;;' 'g+�,... •r•, � y. y,.,.v�. r ?y 4 , !a7 t:F,a u. A� 4, _ " .,n, .0 '^h`i' :W:,., :.. ��•�yur t +fr�s.. ,m„ ,#, .r,+ P',at' i,r°,;ik>z i < .ktri,. ar <;A'k,�'• r :`a .1^`: ,r;.' y :`�',» { F. fi? +,� '.": '< .u.',t, :,^�.i. ;r,q•.� *1•. ti<r..,??ri:"->?�rt.?."a'7 ¢. .� yr $ p.r. ,w }' �CCt•Prt. ,�da,. �5t t .�1'"„*�a•,fi{+ri+it�.g Nl:,+n. � ,�%.,'�' •:� '�',h �li,yx �.1�� r�.', >� :'de-r .�d. Y`r'f• {:'a• ...h.� ''3i:� :,`� �'N�{. r�'. e� �'��'_t�� ae•i:r� • .b .i, �I e'" •1. ,' ;:�i,. tiaz>H .�.• ,ram N .,�„ .�• , �,� e;n 5: „�,„. r a �., ,zj1.,, , .. ,r`.; t. ci,: '.:t' s ,waSu;=v}, t a ;�+,nt.r w a t :i '^`R� r,, t„" .ram ry :1;1�:. � r,Y, ,rryi §„a,'. ?`. �,',r.S.., �,.�j "r ,Gtiv, h�'.r t, �.t. .�,� e�i a:. ai�Y x.,, '�'"f�,. �ryi .; ,,n �..,'�..° "':C ':rG. ,,.«Nl k t, "yf• ,r't, :',±, ,,a,4 aR r'. t� 1.1 :l,1� ,' <! '*� , .n ,iG ,. �tr•S;i•`"'`,.Z;?r��, f`f, ', ,:. ? ...:lr .,f �,C y r rt+�l,'f' :`,;• ,.il x. „c((jwezgfl..i� 94j,t< .i" a,'S� 5, r tdy y �i,,,�}'. �G),� ,.;d• F,;'V' \''i .2� sn� .s.jr�rY• e! a Jti1M $. ,c. .1 �' r.. ,.d f;�h, y,,.,� �{Kt }";, �r,P¢'d. ,vzi f�.-022;7r a.,,( .,}y;n'�I.�i%- -� y�,y� y.12fi" .;�.r+{tn��'..��f}'y, `i+,:� }.t:�'t.• '^,i�1^w,..,nn:' 1�rr �t '+ 'W. :}?.�+l;r �K ),• i i{ y,I;�f,ry y� mful,,> ,� H. :SJ' :1- 'Jr'i .nAr,C • i�`" uf iC V,�(1 �yy„ ,�1iS5141t� 'Ap..i2 r''�1�a",fY i,'r•'N•h�'- '� , I�711' 'i "iyN.v,' t��'•� ,�;+a,','yi. !'!f' 6Y. :'#�'�:..} YY% i ,b :J Y }��.i!r� L../^1 ,,14v't h1.��R''p` v',!"'e, ! >,y, t). G ..jjyy"",,}},�t' �,''''yA,�112'��._ g3'Y ti:.•r211'f l'S, ,.1)` A, �.t.1�'...4, y::. ,}4 'ii=''v `1 .4 .dF o`, Y.' rr�.••n`• fir. .'!r.',r' ;A �.,.,,, ,eA .4fF, �.,,1'`, f ' :'M, rEF'1!2u�±t 7.'e'S.}t 'r,K.\.r Mb,. ,),� "wP,. 'x„ ^a S `yd:• �'*��:,,)� M �.2 '.,,pt;, +„"� x k. ,x r�,��.... f,. r; •i:3•r •a, ,, ��' ",` � 1' �'f aVi +;M F,`�, ;h n �^°�,r' .st .;a ;cs',• 'r7•l�," a, ��,: w;�•.u��R�, ,i. ".7 s. n .d,',* •�:4.,.Y, t d '''�„ , M?.r� ts, ' ' � fl?�..� .�r,w� '. 'h „a13 ..'.� 6gryn.:w�rr.-'��It"t.t ,,a: �.,yv",,�,.. y. y ",�,d� gyr *'n , ,,',{�,•, ter., ,cyg'W ,t-, a ;>rr Z„ri• � .f�,?: � iY, '1" „f. I. t, .,A4p.i kvy.1/44 a,. .,»2:,i h'fex .1t,r, <'. '.t y' '''N.rk iz'+:e '.'f ,,, ,s.,. C'='a 2,y A ;'''.:gg s,',:,'S;q•n,, y ,?">�''S it., �l•• ,�„4,. .� $ t iW t#,. � t .�.a ,r� +•,,.P�':'.•,„'^,. ��$ 4,n;E- !;..^•., �mac. V;� a. 1 T "=rr#�.,r.,. :-a*a'A 1'`'fi' 17 f..,4"�.,ijD4'i',ryt ,d ."t'"'j•"" .� ,'fir ±1.:ft AK r r.,1 ,• `. .il:w 94 ,t: i t.,..r: „? ,�, , <n ac �sr , ,,T'a},: t, ,.,^..'. `3'u i rcr.,•,r M,.,.... d ',.:s., ,4, �,) ,` + "! �t��.,`d e••<" .`{"'�• e,66 ��,�, ,,fi �a��`�u7 tld�. t..i �"s ,t^, 9 'r L: '''�IC. %n.. � .'f �%i.'tY, K` ,r t^';r ..., :4,{.4;n�L .'f+'"J ,..^n,,6^ �a.�v r` ^J5 'e)'•:7 afi'" ,rta; '-;;�7 t'i';',", ' Y. N-•.; .,t P y t 'iv'.yt *. 'w,.: :r' : e :a y.. ''r r° ,.'g.+,. f:bV,,Sy. .fi�.,p. 1 'l"'X_ y..fi,..>;.. +, ..,d,:r�i~�r�;';�1,:T,M}(�.�.,ryr!t'�2'��;.F..,M _+. .�';+'l'�;.'f� w mot' .�, ��r. ;`. .s '_;r ro� ''S -�r.'. ,..+� :ram .'�"'t+"s ;.., ' i v,44;.4^}Y.;i o A ,1'Sr�'i»`l.r•z-. , ,i,.b} :,, •,J', .. , ," :, , . ..r. b.rv.,ri�,.: r , .. .. a ....., r li REG III t��'y` ,'A��g.� ....�- •ARCH/TSCTS lerf ��. ,�'. ��- f {� /+� �$ w I l� T 4 i ions .P L A N•InrraRN.S R S Ate' fiR /2R ,+A , INCCRPCRAT£D --. , i'af,. -;..' -......-vm,._,,,,w4) :111 ��►. I J - (1/10 Ilir 199Y - >. :'� RICE CU\/-r11.G7. A I A. .I ,�/ .ty ,, - k"'R"�> } 111\I111'Ni 1R1017111 _ ,'': _ —-5- �.n` r PQ p ImS UI'IL HIGHWAY,cI11IP 201 yl .. D chi -. -WO /� ll WEST I'{I.\I IIf,1Cl1 f`I o Ill "�' / '",.tramrkvn y • fLOR111,1 ”II/1 r p ... +, Inc: 1cA II fi{9.A}.IM1 \ ., A W- ,„1 '{..✓Q� 7. - xww.ie�r.h nri F ,• :aT�\ `,.1 r -5 'M '+ .�,1,� ' i�• ('.()IU'(711 r\IION NllAllll:lt / i rj I3 ^' ,*, •, r A,' . ,, C' '4� Anam+an --.4.,r'.....,"- /..... .-' ' ,,..""... 1 „iiii iiiBRA .,... ,.,..._,,, .._ _.. - 17' j 1d j,� ■ _ 1 `I l/. `..7 „ ` �� ` \ IJtJ �` f`" !w�',J ((l .nT�, / v 1 Fl �� aI. �. A .•I - t\. \� 1.� � �1t J 'jw. L , 4 � i •.�lliillir 1 -'' r ' r� 1; 133NWSthAVIi �' -IS \�� ; �m'IN ..101d k ;*- •--- ` ; --• �L" I 1 i ;II �•�:= PROPOSED L (� RINOVATION 1 `� 1 \1 �1 e""""'+t .�+�33�!!! cy Ian I . „ I II . � , M / ''. lilli >�`I I ( t -1+-+a.. I,. I .;If ''.d Yt. '-yr �t'' �, r' 1 Y tl>: IA �' / l.k I >. .1 s1 1: Il ^'�.�. — ,r . . ,I, 1 V- I `� yr !�R `', t , Vt,+` -f,; 'S �y a r f►, '' _ i ICl/f"-� u I `ll l✓'7 I '� UGLItAI'OCAUL Ii.. cRA 1 V��S 7 �'( /.' O �{, /' t III \ Y1 I,I e: :'I UGLRAY l3GACFl s - )r Y. !. � Pi.l- •...IAA,>F'�;/%. I.£,.c , . r n :a' I/ '1 �1 lai.�11.1;��1'(�1�1,1•: �`. :�� 11w 11 FF ' Y 11 `� I I .�il 1 j ,I I, '� III''11 a �I II�1 �II•,I 1��I. E 4• ✓ ! , ( P .i I'in .: 1\: ly r1111111 O�r� �I IFYI 1 t u I1_ {�I� ItGVISIU\S NU. _, / }1 ir,1 1I ' d /� l 1 II :l1N1 AAI:II¢'A1'114Y[�'��.JIB I ill �. �� lIl �F, L I ; I, 'l� I. ! l �� I �� '�!��_�� I�t1� 1y �t.11 �17F t1N5�� .� ,A �, t{. 1 i {• i I t 4 I41 P .O 441 I'i' (.? � '•��'. ;111 1 1/•i. 1.-11` �' v(' 1. � :.e M1' }' 1� •:'-S'I 7 ".J,, I 1 } ,11,00�l +c l s,.t I I . 14 1n 41, as 11! I d q �1h GI I E / �o�� /� ' % +<I�I'�� 1 PI� .' I} � 1 1 .. P I `,y„` I x4� �,at/ . I I-1 ,I I I�ItItl M 1 tK 111,1!I J ` 1 ` - - r 11I I UA71i IM1D!Uflfi t I' 1 .f/`�,(ti.a ,F/r� • I. �..>-- -•� SCALE N'IS I -,1 •, CHECKED REG EEG No, IMlli: . _ _ ._ ii, pit 7UMi 1 IV Nvmn n 1E A.,„.,,L(..,,,„,..... „. ,. ......... . ... .. • • . \ orvnaa to�ir:xamn,�•n Loy gal/ 133 NW 5th Avenue Delray beach Propose enovation , ill s� . ...- - .,. .,. • ' • ' , - .; .i....:„.1J.. „• , . . . , rri.,.;.....• ,„--4,,, . : ., •,,,.,,....... r; , ', • it'i.i 1:•;--T••••;;.-r7.:. r;1747"D .r..::fi,-'..,. i:‘ %\,, ,., •;iviramor,...- .,-...._,......___. .fi. ill:: -.P.4,', ;.I.,,I,;:_i,:-.' E--.4.444'..,,-1 i:_' ''''..::1-'.s' ';,'' .i 1 $:*Ze..-0---'c•••• --____. L-31...,•,,,,, ,,f.f:,,..:',....1,!„, _-_-._.._.„.___..„,„-,,_:,,• ,% , ,,,.... .-e+.::m 1-***-•;•.'•• 1 .----------:---- dososve.a.,ota"Ja.w.A., ky:,$0. .. .L 1.:4 --1,7J i P. • ..-, ...,:....„....„--i- - = . • ft-,...4::,,,..,4,4.•!.,N,,A,A.,,,,, '.1.•-•-• -,..,,,,.1.?.,-,,t,..44,,,ji., •:,..th "..•'-' -rt,....: .-:, !i,I,;., :„..1 1 . ,..4.:41r: ,._.. ...,.. . 1 ,,,, : n ...,.., ,,, , .., ,,.. ,,..„.. ..4 . ...,,, -..,.c.,•,,Ii. : 7.,...- 430.., r i'.'..... ; .., ' ....- ,-:',4r,:VAPP:. • -.'N‘;11 - . 'Al'it'll,. '':-11.-11t;A.....'":0;-/A li‘ • , - , '''''''`if"'""""PM111 '''.1- './i'•:. .:1.:•• -.!.4A...,..' ;,F., i . _. ... :, • ,• ,-!,.1,-. . ,,,,..'.1a-, -r-• • . ',,,,-. '.''' o'f:' ,. ',It 11 •.,);'.' : - .._r...1,:y:4%.'i!),7.! -- ',.:. ,.. .... -kitt.,1114,N4+ ____-• , .„,-.-1, ,„, '-i,...?-d•*...,'-, 4 trfl„..,4 ... 0, i ';‘,,•?,,J,:.:';', i ,:::.:,4,-:2....):Iii,,,ni,'Fif3,,,,,•... t cp.14';• .-4. 11117., . ,......K.'" ' 't , ), ' 1,,' S ' '', ,,XLI, c.-4 c„,,,•1..,,,,.,.„,.-. . _ , itle -'••1.-:-• •••••— . -•-'1..)!..W,. .)`• • • t I r., , ... - ., , : imi i r—na,•,,t1gi.+i '-i'Ls.-1'-.1 ll ti ''.f.a'''.A ....i.i#-Jit'i , '...!,P ;- ;•,,, k.,„4:,„„..'_,,,.-- 1' t,..,, 7-ii, '44,:`'.11-it.1.,:--,-,!„.,' -'..,'''• ati',1•:-•:‘,..",..''.:1:' '''/-`-%......:, TS71 _ , t. • 1 'qpnital..7,- ' (,-,; r, e 74. I. . . - •.',Af4mA.th'-'•IV.:,3. ___-_l'.:,000**1,,,, ,',„. •, .,. .. . . i • .„,...-i.",,._ ,,, ,,,...„..„4:t .,,,,.._ ..... ..,..•.... 1 .- 1 . ,. ',•;f,-:"; . ' 1."-- . "_71.::. 1 , . ,....,,,t40,414ng.,..?••1,,,,,,,i-.'. . .......,....... .-„,.....:...1.\ . ._-. -., 4- i1_,,:--,.. '7-17.-Iplpillat1;:l 1----1, 1 1: 1/21 ., -..,,...,. .- . ....,,,,...4.;,...;:t,f,"'.:,..,:-- •':,•-'.,..,,' :• •"'..1... • , ,.. .i; ... ..,.. . .'••.' . .• t :; .., i I.: • • . ULLRAYULACH d HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD IvluluII MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT (I��- 2UU11991 ?UU1 Property Owner/ Applicant: Sally A. Gebo Project Location: 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District HPB Meeting Date: August 1, 2007 COA: 2007-264 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness request for approval of accordion shutters on a contributing structure located at 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic Arts District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND/PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property, consisting of Lot 2 and North 30 Feet of Lot 3, Block 58, Metcalfs Subdivision, is located on the west side of North Swinton Avenue between NE 1st and 2nd Streets. The Minimal Traditional style structure, which was built in 1941, is considered a contributing building in the Old School Square Historic District. In 2002, administrative approval was given for two separate requests: window and fence replacement. Documentation within the window replacement file shows photographs of existing hurricane panels painted white which matched the exterior color at that time. No other Certificates of Appropriateness are on file. A Building Permit was issued in 1999 for the installation of hurricane panels on three new windows and one new door. The application before the Board requests consideration for the installation of white, accordion shutters at all window openings. Hurricane shutters are typically reviewed administratively. However, due to the proposed shutter type and their visibility from the right-of-way, the item is to be reviewed by the Board. ANALYSIS Development Standards LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) "Development Standards" provides guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The applicable standards are as follows: (E)(4) A historic site, or building, structure, site, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended from time to time. (E)(8) All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front facade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids on a 242 North Swinton Avenue—2007-264-COA HPB Meeting August 1, 2007 Page 2 of 4 front facades, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of building, directional expression of front elevation. The following applies to the subject application: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic sites, buildings, and structures within a historic district. Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines state and recommend the following with respect to hurricane protection: • Window shutters that are removable are preferred. • If the tracks are to be installed year-round, they should be painted to match the exterior surface. • Accordion or roll-down shutters should only be considered when they are in locations not visible from the public right-of-way. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation recommend the following: The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. (Standard #2) Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a historic property shall be preserved. (Standard #5) Exterior alterations, including shutters, whether serving a purpose or not, should respect the character of the building and be sensitive to its architectural integrity. Permanent shutters visible from the right-of-way not only have a visual impact on the structure but also obscure additional detailing within the window frame which then conceals this significant architectural feature. Removable hurricane shutters are the preferred option for all buildings in historic areas, particularly those classified as contributing to the historic district within which it exists, as they are not visually impacting. Therefore, in accordance with the Design Guidelines and Standards noted above, it is recommended that the existing removable storm panels be maintained or replaced and painted to match the exterior of the structure or that some other appropriate method of storm protection is installed for those windows visible from the right-of-way. The request to approve accordion shutters cannot be supported as it is inconsistent with respect to LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(8)(g), the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of COA-2007-264 for 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Section 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. 242 North Swinton Avenue—2007-264-COA HPB Meeting August 1,2007 Page 3 of 4 C. Move denial of COA-2007-264 for 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in Section 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative. See above) RECOMMENDATION Conditionally approve COA-2007-264 for 242 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Section 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation that the existing removable storm panels be maintained or replaced and painted to match the exterior of the structure or that some other appropriate method of storm protection be installed for those windows visible from the right-of-way. Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: • Appendix A • Location Map • Florida Master Site File Survey 2005 • Photographs 242 North Swinton Avenue—2007-264-COA HPB Meeting August 1,2007 Page 4 of 4 APPENDIX A Previous Applications RE: Accordion Shutters Address Historic District Classification Meeting Dates 222 Palm Court Del-Ida Park Non-Contributing (1956) 01.19.05, 02.02.05, 02.16.05 Action After reviewing the item, the Board approved the application with the following conditions: 1) That removable storm panels or some other appropriate method of storm protection be installed for the windows at the front of the property which are not screened by the arcade. 2) If removable panels are installed the tracks or channels should be painted to match the exterior of the building. Address Historic District Classification Meeting Date 10 NE Street Del-Ida Park Non-Contributing (1956) 10.01.03 Action After reviewing the item, the Board approved the application with the following conditions: 1) That the tracks/channels are placed as close to the windows/doors (openings) as possible so that no paint shows through or that a negligible amount is viewed; and, 2) That the proposed accordion shutters on the first floor of the front façade for the two, paired French doors be changed to removable storm panels. Address Historic District Classification Meeting Date 246 N Swinton Avenue Old School Square Contributing (1941) 10.04.06 Action After reviewing the item, the Board approved the as-built accordion shutters. Address Historic District Classification Meeting Dates 305 N Swinton Avenue Old School Square Contributing (1925) March 21, 2007 June 6, 2007 Action After reviewing the item, the Board denied the as-built accordion shutters at the March 21, 2007 meeting. The property owners requested that the Board reconsider the denial at the June 6, 2007 meeting. Upon reconsideration the Board approved the as-built accordion shutters with the condition that they be removed within one year from the approval date and that another type of approvable hurricane protection could be installed. • 6. LI I II I I 1Lj y �p NP NI -r CC ��F�� Q N.E. 5TH TERR. CC -3 WOOD LANE i Z / �/ KINGS LYNN ,= Q�p j' n' c e 1 I _ _I Li.J 0a N.E. 5TH CT. a D � . BEVERLY DR. Z G� �o Q ��D 4 in N.E. 5TH ST. iLZ-j LAKE IDA ROAD N.E. 4TH ST. > > w > > > z - li, Q Q Q Q......, ,..,.., b., N N Z ' > (n I a I N.E. 3RD ST. 1111 w w ui Z Z ZMy I- cn > a z I 'z 1 V' r') N N N.E. 2ND ST. - - r - 3 Z - .O Q 0 cr - 3 w C § Z a ce - Z Z 0_ w Ci z 4i 0i... G- - N.E. 1ST ST. m �� /I R 1I - N 1 SUBJECT 242 N. SWINTON AVENUE I -= PROPERTY 12-43-46-17-49-058-0020 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FL N5S5S1 PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT LOCATION MAP I -- DIGITAL BASE MAP SYSTEM -- MAP REF: S:\Planning & Zoning\DBMS\File—Cab\Z—LAt 1001-1500\LM1029_242 N. Swinton Avenue Florida Site#8 PB10490 Master HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder# Site � t1 Electronic Version 1.1.0 Field Date 3/1/2005 CM File ` Form Date 3/28/2005 F First Site Form Recorded for this Site? NO FormN 200503 orrnNo=Field Date(YYYY4Iii GENERAL INFORMATION Site Name(address If none) 242 N. Swinton Ave. Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names » Survey or Project Name Old School Square Historic Resources Survey Survey# National Register Category Building(s) LOCATION & IDENTIFICATION Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 242 North Swinton Avenue Cross Streets(nearest/between) NW 2/NW 3 Streets City I Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YES County Palm Beach Tax Parcel#(s) 12-43-46-17-01-058-0020 Subdivision Name Map of Town of Linton Block Lot Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Old School Square Route to(especially if no street address) MAPPING 11 USGS 7.5' Map Name Publication Date »DELRAY BEACH;1986 Township: Range: Section: 114 section: » 46s ;43E ;17;UNSP Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) DESCRIPTION Style Masonry Vernacular Other Style Exterior Plan L-shaped Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 1 Structural System(s) » Masonry - General Other Structural System(s) Foundation Type(s) » Continuous Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) » Concrete Block Other Foundation Material(s) Exterior Fabric(s) » stucco Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) » Hip Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) » Asphalt Shingles Other Roof Material(s) Roof Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys 1 Chimney Material Brick Other Chimney Material(s) stucco Chimney Location(s) Pitched roof; exterior Page 1 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB10490 DESCRIPTION (continued) dowDescriptions 6/6 DHS, wood Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) A gravel driveway adjoins brick steps. Porches: #open 1 #closed #incised Location(s) east elevation Porch Roof Types(s) Shed; fabric awning, Exterior Ornament Shouldered chimney stack and window sills Interior Plan Unknown Other Interior Plan Condition Excellent Structure Surroundin•s Commercial:SOME of this category Residential: SOME of this category Institutional: Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Number 1 type of outbuildings,major landscape features) Archaeological Remains(describe): None If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? NO Narrative Description(optional) HISTORY nstruction year 1941 Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): Changes in Locations or Conditions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes Structure Use Histo Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended » Private residence;11941; Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) RESEARCH METHODS Research Methods » Sanborn maps Other research methods SURVEYOR'S EVALUATION OF SITE Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? NO Name of Local Register if Eligible Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES .ea(s)of historical significance >> Architecture U[her Historical Associations old School Square Historic Arts District Explanation of Evaluation(required) Based on its modest architectural character, which complements the district, this resource only contributes to the surrounding historic district. Page 2 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB10490 DOCUMENTATION (Photos, Plans,etc.) Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other Important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name(Last,First) Hyland, Mattew; Tuk, Jared Recorder Address lPhone 618 East South Street, Orlando, Florida, 32801 407.423.8398 Recorder Affiliation GAI Consultants - SE Other Affiliation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? NO ****** MASTER SITE FILE USE ONLY° �- - s - '- SHPO's Evaluation of Resource Cultural Resource Type: ss Date Electronic Form Used: S13.0 .< Form Type Code: NORM Form Quality Ranking: NEW Form Status,Code: SCAT Supplement Information Status NO SUPPLEMENT FMSF Staffer: Supplement.File Status: NO,SUPPLEMENT,FILE Computer Entry Date: 3/28/2005 Form Comments. — \ *cam t� a is Iir Zif .. 1,'' -- ____,..--' I - --- ....‘ All \ 1 REQUIRED PAPER . ATTACHMEN --• • OF MAIN FACADE, B&W,AT LEAST 3"X5" Page 3 of 3 111;ilif."1.16111111111. _ r � i � v Yy. 'r � '� E : r 7 7� ' v _• ry•--- is -4., Ji' ft'A s ;a ► EXISTING i : WHITE METAL FRAME: 1 s k r. '�.: •• 3r r 7§.b. }{ • • • • ___....,..,,Ailiii u 246 N SWINTON INSTALLED SUT ' i_Li i yy,, i'x P . . 242 N.Swinton Ave x µ �� i ti ' . Zr1j - 2 t - am- <n _ 1 : • - , _,. '6.- %711. - . . .-. I do A-: r �. y� EXISTING WHITE FRAMES FOR METAL ram. SHUTTERS ° - + Itz,./7 111 4. ri y_ f. ,�-sr:.� , �, sw� vc. k r' 1 246 N SWINTON AVE $ 1 air / - - - 01 .. .. } . .., „vie --„..00440r- 1` dill \ it -` I I ::,_ "linliiNk ' ."' " 1.' jr,-,,. . �� I cia ( r II ... ms �'` ?- , �� _ - -_- __ A �. \` � Vi r " • , F./ :, 1 I -4. n ......._, ... ,. k , i ii., i' l --- - ; -TN,. 242 N. Swinton Ave SHUTTERS INSTALLED 303 N. Swinton Ave ._. ,_. .-,.., .. ,.,•_- zt.. 1 .•,:, c ;,..„,;•., _ .. .. ...__.• ,,, ._ .-..,k,,,..i„c--„,c., tt...,•-- ..•,f. 1 ' '.,':,'.-,-401.,4...'' • i. •''''.4" . ''''.:' :::-Ii- Ilt: ) , .‘• ''' ,:. 1: • .. —let; ,.• . , , 401111 `— A - ---.. -.. - _ , • , . .1; ,.....mi. ..• .-. . . - - • . *-- , 0 . '- -- '''''-4'.:.--:.';‘,--•-eji:z. ..',.,-::-'14* --t.g-';f:A*,,_,„ .;.--, • . . ',,,„,..,;,,,...,..3','',''''' " _,- , - ••••----------;-' ' -.....-,-,.. . - • -- - — — . . . 4, ..T-'94'• . . rex .. ... : •.,...4.,.. _ . . f,.------i-- _-,,,• '4' —— ------=.1 ...a..............IS I 11 220 N. Swinton Ave .. . .,.. •, „,.. .. •:• .,...- . . . . „ -4- 1111 . . - -._. . . ' ., ''''. -' ,'-*tt-"-- = 7--- — - -.7. •-, , •' ." . . 2 '' A;T'i - ..2' -/ },4,_.,0'•-• ----I. --- --'".Orts" - r"<- — • ; - I. -• .. 214 N. Swinton Ave ..,,,. .4#...,.., * __ - '11— -(/arlk-* ,------: e.-"---- /-- &CIAAA-9-.—a4a. ____9-L- 4/ 9 _ __ )b4. 062A „7' ee "1/1 0- -i ° )2 c--7-)-1-q-- :_-/ z1k. ao () 7 a s---e, - 13 A ----Q \ C . _s p -r L ) -2 fcl-L.L ,_, C i. _T-' R-A 1,k) L__ _—, / r , A) --G' ) (. )3 hl� cr‘i ,i) E 6-JL-( upz- . •J/(-1 04, 2e.t. 2 -�f -s�1 0 / j 1 `t l j • -rho i r r7 , cr — Ai•dh1-e- (40_ (0, e 1 /Z k,,(;tk K n c —To n — j)-, a.Q - c 12r-� Lind — � �j''`c� n h t �' Y) 0 /p,„/;.k., 60 ,c , • 4-A-1 .4- ) ,2m 6- h;) I 2z,& fi ,/(c 627" J � )( ' () z ,_J/ 61), =2_ P24 6 / -4,, 6 ( �;' _ C} 2 ,, . ' 4 / c2_ ,- o /2- i __--0 )%,i_ \ e__-1 ' V v1 /l aZi: ' ') .r /2%/1--4 c_., J c Z l .) .)- A°'./ ec2Aii z,, a4 27 ,---- 0 , .7 C./ 0 C7) 1 V 77)4) j - JX't - 77/ • ) cif e31‘ r 2J a)/d° \ 07„) CLA.11-1- N 0 , e //f �-� �� Q O CLl n a ________) )') !_2.-- _.fi _ c.L _____ ia-.. , /14,2L) ,____ ____, r . ______ - . .f, a, oz.z\\\ __ c._, vi__ o � h 4N _,_z___=._,4 .__ ' Z_ 0 fe r 7<a__ c,) 5 62 ----' 2._.— --p .4___. ,--L---/— ,___ ,__ .., 0 c>) --- (, ,,,,,,__ _______7_. .,— - s_____,,_____t ... % 5 g - QG 2 C A 0 \ 0 yr � cuc-c7) 6 Oh . ./0) L.- ,/ `->/-/. .- 9 f) N v > La_47'!(,1( LA-1) Ov ) �^'��e v rI LZ4 01/eL ? c>2_. 9 0 ) i{f j-- 7) • ‘0 9 cyf 9 t;*1- 0 727,?-2 P ) f' qa° a) la- L,e4, 11,12L ov IAA) b2"( /(. 9 � 9 O rc QY C r ,�- - t .„ A-19} #4114 _ a-)2 ( ) i 40V I ►� DELRAY BEACH o � o All-America City 1 I 1993 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2 001 Regular Historic Preservation Board Meeting August 1 , 2007 PRINT FULL NAME ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION L r� LVJOD b 1 7- , bo � v oci OA AGENDA v ,� �r `�,p.4y IV' HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: July 18, 2007 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. THE SUBJECT MEETING HAS BEEN CANCELLED. THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE HELD ON WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 1 , 2007. S. 4 Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted On: July 12, 2007