Loading...
HPB-04-18-07 REVISED AO OA AGENDA V HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING ,g(!,�'q% ,.74P CITY OF DELRAY BEACH Meeting Date: April 18, 2007 Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers Time: 6:00 P.M. The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact Doug Smith at 243-7144 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings, and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City does not provide or prepare such record. Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District— Howard and Judith Gale, Property Owners. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (2007-175) associated with a roof material change on a contributing structure. III. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS A. 2007 Historic Preservation Awards —2"d Annual Selection of Winners to be recognized at City Commission meeting of May 1, 2007. B. National Preservation Month Poster Contest—5th Annual Selection of winners to be recognized at City Commission meeting of May 1, 2007. IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments • Reports from Historic District Representatives • Board Members • Staff V. ADJOURN A illy E. A Uva re' Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: April 17, 2007 MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD PUBLIC HEARING CITY OF DELRAY BEACH DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA MEETING DATE: April 18, 2007 LOCATION: City Commission Chambers MEMBERS PRESENT: Linda Lake, Joann Peart, Roger Cope, Kim French, and Keith Snider MEMBERS ABSENT: John Miller, and Tony Del Fiandra STAFF PRESENT: Amy Alvarez, Brian Shutt, and Denise Valek I. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Vice Chair Lake at 6:00 p.m. Upon roll call it was determined that a quorum was present. No one from the Public addressed the Board on non-agenda items. II. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS A. 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District - Howard and Judith Gale, Property Owners. Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (2007-175) associated with a roof material change on a contributing structure. Ms. Alvarez entered the project file into the record and presented a summary of the staff report. Applicant Presentation: Mr. Stephen Cowing, McCabe Brothers, representing the applicants, advised that the owners of the home are planning on doing a major renovation and are waiting for the roof material to be approved. Mr. Cowing presented pictures to the Board depicting the very poor condition of the roof. The new roof would be a dimensional 5-tab shingle. Public Comments: Vice Chair Lake inquired if there were any comments from the public. There were none. Vice Chair Lake closed the public hearing. Board Discussion: Board discussion ensued relative to the type of material being utilized. It was the consensus of the Board that a condition should be noted in the motion to cover the type and color of roof material to be utilized. Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board April 18, 2007 Motion/Findings: It was moved by Mr. Cope, seconded by Ms. Pearl, and approved 5 to 0 (Mr. Miller and Ms. Del Fiandra absent) Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic Arts District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Sections 2.4.6(H), 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation with the following condition: 1. That the roof material be a Certainteed, 5-tab dimensional shingle, and light gray as submitted and on file with staff. III. DISCUSSION AND ACTION ITEMS: A. 2007 Historic Preservation Awards — 2nd Annual Selection of Winners to be recognized at City Commission meeting of May 1, 2007. Results of Board Vote: The following properties would receive the Historic Preservation Award. Renovation/Rehabilitation • 137 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square (Office) • 204 Dixie Boulevard, Del-Ida Park (Office) • 144 NW 3`d Avenue, West Settlers (Single-Family Residential) • 226 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square (Single-Family Residential) • 129 SE 7th Avenue, Marina, (Single-Family Residential) New Construction • 111-113 NW 1st Avenue, Old School Square (Residential) • 136 NE 1st Avenue, Old School Square (Residential) The following property would receive the Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Award: • 204 Dixie Boulevard, Del-Ida Park (Office) B. National Preservation Month Poster Contest — 5th Annual Selection of winners to be recognized at City Commission meeting of May 1, 2007. As No Posters Were Received, The Above Item Was Cancelled IV. REPORTS AND COMMENTS • Public Comments - None • Reports from Historic District Representatives - None • Board Members 2 Minutes of the Historic Preservation Board April 18, 2007 Ms. Peart advised that Aleida Riley was concerned about the concrete posts that were erected on the grounds of a home in the Marina District. Ms. Alvarez advised Engineering and Code Enforcement will be handling this issue. Board discussion ensued relative to signage in the Historic Districts. Ms. Alvarez advised that she has been working on this, and we have until December 2, 2007 to submit the information to the State for a grant. Ms. French advised that the West Settlers sign was in need of refurbishing. The Board advised that some signs were not replaced in the District after the hurricane, and questioned who was responsible for maintaining the signs. Ms. Alvarez advised she would look into this. • Staff Ms. Alvarez advised the Board that the two appeals (238 SE 7th Street and 706 SE 7th Street)will be heard at the May 1, 2007 Commission Meeting. Ms. Alvarez advised that a Charette with local architects regarding the LDRs is scheduled for Friday, May 11, 2007. The time is yet to be determined. V. ADJOURN The meeting adjourned at 7:15 p.m. The undersigned is the Secretary of the Historic Preservation Board and the information provided herein is the Minutes of the meeting of said body for April 18, 2007, which was formally adopted and approved by the Board on May 2, 2007. Denise A. Valek, Executive Assistant/Board Liaison If the Minutes that you have received are not completed as indicated above, then this means that these are not the official Minutes. They will become so after review and approval, which may involve some changes. 3 • PEP!"IIUCM UEERAYOEACH NI-AuericaCit, IW-11me1icaGh HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD �I MEMORADUM STAFF REPORT (II'�� 1993 1993 2UU1 20U1 Property Owner: Howard and Judith Gale Project Location: 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District HPB Meeting Date: April 18, 2007 COA: 2007-175 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness request for a roof material change on a contributing structure located at 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND/PROJECT DESCRIPTION The property consists of Lot 14 Less North 1.25 Feet and South 15.70 Feet, Block 59, Town of Delray and contains a Minimal Traditional structure built in 1935. No previous Board approvals are on file. The existing structure contains a flat, cement tile roof. The subject application proposes to remove the cement tiles and in order to install an architectural/dimensional asphalt material. Additionally, the color would change as the existing tiles are white, and the proposed shingles are grey. Re-roofing, either repairs or replacement, is typically reviewed and approved administratively. However, as the applicant is requesting a change of the existing material, the item has been brought to the Board for review. ANALYSIS Development Standards LDR Sections 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8)(g) "Development Standards" provides guidelines in evaluating Certificates of Appropriateness for the alteration or addition of exterior architectural features. The applicable standards are as follows: (E)(4) A historic site, or building, structure, site, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as amended from time to time. (E)(8) All improvements to buildings, structures, and appurtenances shall be visually compatible. Visual compatibility shall be determined in terms of height, front façade proportion, proportion of openings (windows and doors), rhythm of solids to voids on front facades, rhythm of buildings on streets, rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections, relationship of materials, texture and color, roof shapes, walls of continuity, scale of building, directional expression of front elevation. The following applies to the subject application: 112 North Swinton Avenue 20Z7-175-COA-1-PB 1"HP%3 Meeting April 18,2007 (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic sites, buildings, and structures within a historic district. The Delray Beach Design Guidelines state the following with respect to roofs: oPreserve the roof's shapes, decorative features, and materials, as well as its patterning, color, and size. Stripping the roof of its historic material, i.e. slate, clay tile, wood, or architectural metal is inappropriate. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation suggest the following: oThe historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. oDeteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Analysis The subject reroof application proposes to replace the existing cement tiles with a grey, architectural grade dimensional asphalt shingle. The installation of an asphalt shingle will not compromise the historic integrity of the structure nor its historic fabric. Additionally, the type of material and its color are appropriate, as they are visually compatible with the Minimal Traditional style structure. Based on the above, positive findings can be made pursuant to the review criteria noted above. RECOMMENDATION Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for 112 North Swinton Avenue, Old School Square Historic Arts District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in Sections 2.4.6(H), 4.5.1(E)(4) and (E)(8) of the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Design Guidelines and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Report Prepared by: Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner Attachments: Historic Survey 2005, Color Photograph 2/2 Florida Site#8 PB00315 • "Masten \ Site ', = `LLB HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder# File Electronic Version 1.1.0 Field Date 3/1/2005 ��_ Form Date 3/24/2005 —t Site Form Recorded for this Site? No FormNo 200503 FormNo=Field Date(YYYYMM) GENERAL INFORMATION Site Name(address If none) 112 N. Swinton Ave. Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names » " Survey or Project Name Old School Square Historic Resources Survey Survey# National Register Category Building(s) LOCATION & IDENTIFICATION Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 112 North Swinton Avenue Cross Streets(nearest/between) NW 1/Nw 2 streets City/Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YES County Palm Beach Tax Parcel#(s) 12-43-46-17-01-059-0142 Subdivision Name Map of Town of Linton Block Lot Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Old School Square Route to(especially if no street address) MAPPING 7.5' Map Name Publication Date >>DELRAY BEACH;1986 Township: Range: Section: 1/4 section: » 46S, ;43E 7;UNSP Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) DESCRIPTION Style Minimal Traditional Other Style Exterior Plan Rectangular Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 1 Structural System(s) » Wood frame Other Structural System(s) Foundation Type(s) » Continuous Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) » Brick Other Foundation Material(s) Exterior Fabric(s) » Weatherboard Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) » Gable Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) » Concrete tile Other Roof Material(s) =f Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) » Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys 1 Chimney Material Brick Other Chimney Material(s) Stucco Chimney Location(s) Pitched roof; interior; rear slope Page 1 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB00315 DESCRIPTION (continued) Window Descriptions 4/4, 6/6 DHS, wood; Awning, metal Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) A brick tiled walkway leads to a brick tile portico within squared posts. Porches: #open 1 #closed #incised Location(s) east elevation Porch Roof Types(s) Flat Exterior Ornament Scalloped porch trim, molded rake boards, molded lintels, and projecting polygonal bay window Interior Plan Unknown Other Interior Plan Condition Excellent Structure Surroundin's Commercial:SOME of this category Residential: SOME of this category Institutional: Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Number!type of outbuildings,major landscape features) A one-story, wood frame, gable roof garage stands at the rear of the house lot. Archaeological Remains(describe): None If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? NO Narrative Description(optional) HISTORY Construction year 1935 Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): Changes in Locations or Conditions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes Structure Use Histo Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended » Private residence;1935 Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) RESEARCH METHODS Research Methods >> Sanborn maps Other research methods SURVEYOR'S EVALUATION OF SITE Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? NO Name of Local Register if Eligible Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES Area(s)of historical significance » Architecture Other Historical Associations Old School Square Historic Arts District Explanation of Evaluation(required) This building is a modest example of a common type of nationally popular domestic architecture. It lacks requisite architectural distinction for individual local designation and NRHP listing; however, it contributes to the district. Page 2 o f 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB00315 DOCUMENTATION (Photos, Plans, etc.) Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other Important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: RECORDER INFORMATION Recorder Name(Last,First) Hyland, Mattew; Tuk, Jared Recorder Address I Phone 618 East South Street, Orlando, Florida, 32801 407.423.8398 Recorder Affiliation GAT Consultants - SE Other Affiliation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? NO ****MASTER SITE FILE USE ONLY*****' SHPO's Evaluation of Resource Cultural Resource Type ss Electronic Form Used: silo a e D t Form Type Code:"NoRN Form Quality Ranking:NEW " Form Status Code SCAT Supplement Information Status: NO SUPPLEMENT FMSF Staffer: Supplement File Status: NO SUPPLEMENT FILE Computer Entry Date: 3/24/2005 " Form Comments ��—� • '',`"- •-kLiN,- Ottititt, ,* ,„., , 4, 1E1_ __------ : ':'-\-- ------_--- ' - '-' ---':' .4.4'4 .r 1110. 3 10 "WI tj " : � D � I tF , `r r • — j` w } w .,,. a '` ...n �..y T REQUIRED I Y ,.; :: - V : ,. ` ` PAPER '; ,s sa - i GiyLJt;;S28,AN,— LEAST 3"X5" ATTACHMENT' , Page 3 o f 3 PB00315-200503 Supplementary Printout > USGS map name/year of publication or revision: DELRAY BEACH;1986 > Township/Range/Section/Qtr: 46S;43E;17;UNSP > Structural system(s): Wood frame > Foundation types: Continuous > Foundation materials: Brick > Exterior fabrics: Weatherboard > Roof types: Gable > Roof materials: Concrete tile > Roof secondary structures(dormers etc): > Change status/year changed/date noted/nature: > Original,intermediate, present uses/year started/year ended: Private residence;1935; > Research methods: Sanborn maps Pedestrian Examine local property records Library research-local Plat map > Area(s)of historical significance: Architecture > Repositories: Collection/Housed/Accession#/Describe > [Other name(s)]: Page 1 Of 1 oCt Planning & Zoning Department (�P P MEMORANDUM qy e• TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMBERS FROM: AMY E. ALVAREZ, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER DATE: APRIL 13, 2007 RE: 2007 HPB AWARD BALLOT The following pages contain the formal ballot for the 2007 HPB Awards. There are two categories: Renovation/Rehabilitation and New Construction. Please vote by marking one project in each category and bring these ballots to the meeting of April 18, 2007. In addition, you may also choose one project below to receive the Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Award. Site visits to the eligible properties are strongly encouraged. Should you have any questions regarding the property and/or structure prior to the approved improvements, please contact Staff and additional photos can be emailed to you for further consideration. The awards ceremony will take place at the regular City Commission meeting on May 1, 2007. All Board members are encouraged to attend. 2007 HPB Awards Ballot- HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 Page 2 of 4 RENOVATION / REHABILITATION ❑ Address: 137 NW 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Office Date Approved: November 3, 2003 �l'• `` , -- Project Conversion of a 824 sq. ft. one- _ oYN 4� nil Description: story, contributing, single family . , ,. residence to office, demolition of an ,4 867 sq. ft. one-story, contributing _ cottage/ garage, and construction of ' _ a 1,526 sq. ft. addition on the contributing building. ❑ Address: 204 Dixie Boulevard Historic District: Del-Ida Park ..k 1' Use: Office Date Approved: June 4, 2003 y, Project Conversion of a contributing, 1,153 '"�` Description: sq. ft. one-story, single family home to office, construction of a 3,283 sq. illittref f i s .. - - ft. office addition, and demolition of " a 372 sq. ft. contributing outbuilding -g „, (garage) in order to accommodate " v Er.a the construction of a new 1,090 sq. ft. detached office building. ❑ Address: 144 NW 3rd Avenue Historic District: West Settlers Use: Single-Family Residential ;t _ .41 Date Approved: June 2, 2004, December 15, 2004 ' Project Renovation and rehabilitation of a II = _,'" 4 Description: contributing structure. ____Alimilidlil Address: 226 North Swinton Avenue Historic District: Old School Square { . Use: Single-Family Residential ' c" Date Approved: December 15, 2004 t r� i Project Construction of a two-story, 1,888 li v. ": " Description: square foot addition to and w - --{t.4. renovation of a 1,490 square foot �' . i 'P ' ' , contributing, one-story, Spanish l° 1 'g`' Eclectic style single-family dwelling. tix, 2007 HPB Awards Ballot- HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 Page 3 of 4 RENOVATION / REHABILITATION CONT... ■ Address: 129 SE 7th Avenue Historic District: Marina Use: Single-Family Residential .x... Date Approved: February 19, 2003 Project Construction of a 353 square foot, _ Description: two-story addition on a contributing �"' — structure, demolition of a contributing garage and non- ' contributing addition on the main dwelling, and associated site improvements. 2007 HPB Awards Ballot- HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 Page 4 of 4 NEW CONSTRUCTION 17.1 Address: 111-113 NW 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Residential G` Date Approved: March 2, 2005 Project New construction of a two-story Y`t n It ' Et , ir, i Description: duplex and associated site ;�:;a > = improvements. � P _ Address: 136 NE 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Residential Date Approved: July 7, 2004 at Project Construction of a 3,780 sq. ft., two- a T Description: story, duplex and two-story garage/ .!. guest cottage. , t i. c cc: Paul Dorling, Director of Planning and Zoning Mark McDonnell, Assistant Director of Planning and Zoning t J 0,,, Planning & Zoning Department ( MEMORANDUM TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMBERS FROM: AMY E. ALVAREZ, HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER DATE: APRIL 13, 2007 RE: 2007 HPB AWARD BALLOT The following pages contain the formal ballot for the 2007 HPB Awards. There are two categories: Renovation/Rehabilitation and New Construction. Please vote by marking one project in each category and bring these ballots to the meeting of April 18, 2007. In addition, you may also choose one project below to receive the Pat Cayce Historic Preservation Award. Site visits to the eligible properties are strongly encouraged. Should you have any questions regarding the property and/or structure prior to the approved improvements, please contact Staff and additional photos can be emailed to you for further consideration. The awards ceremony will take place at the regular City Commission meeting on May 1, 2007. All Board members are encouraged to attend. 2007 HPB Awards Ballot - HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 Page 2 of 4 RENOVATION / REHABILITATION ❑ Address: 137 NW 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Office Date Approved: November 3, 2003 Project Conversion of a 824 sq. ft. one- . �4C- „ I Description: story, contributing, single family glair, '" Na lu } '. _ residence to office, demolition of an '� ► '1' 1 867 sq. ft. one-story, contributing cottage/ garage, and construction of 7,�. a 1 ,526 sq. ft. addition on the contributing building. ❑ Address: 204 Dixie Boulevard Historic District: Del-Ida Park Use: Office Date Approved: June 4, 2003 - Project Conversion of a contributing, 1 ,153 M� _ Description: sq. ft. one-story, single family home +t=":i' - _-- to office, construction of a 3,283 sq. '4 , rpmilleminmi ft. office addition, and demolition of 4 - u a 372 sq. ft. contributing outbuilding (garage) in order to accommodate the construction of a new 1,090 sq. ft. detached office building. ❑ Address: 144 NW 3rd Avenue Historic District: West Settlers ;-,_. ., - "- '.4; Use: Single-Family Residential ► ; '� f , Date Approved: June 2, 2004, December 15, 2004 '{ ,_...r _� Project Renovation and rehabilitation of a 1 ' I - ' `,' q: . -1 Description: contributing structure. i I =_ -. Address: 226 North Swinton Avenue Historic District: Old School Square " ' t Use: Single-Family Residential a, ,- Date Approved: December 15, 2004 y 1t f Project Construction of a two-story, 1 ,888 • + ,i . _ .1, 1 Description: square foot addition to and �`. ` �, � ;"c` '- renovation of a 1 ,490 square foot iy ` i� ;�, contributing, one-story, Spanish : --- ir Eclectic style single-family dwelling. - ..i* . 2007 HPB Awards Ballot- HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 Page 3 of 4 RENOVATION / REHABILITATION CONT... ❑ Address: 129 SE 7th Avenue Historic District: Marina 'rv-1,`, Use: Single-Family Residential ' =-;- : - Date Approved: February 19, 2003 • / , :"" " Project Construction of a 353 square foot, yt,: Description: two-story addition on a contributing * p� structure, demolition of a contributing garage and non- —IL contributing addition on the main lijitdwelling, and associated site - improvements. 01 p 2007 HPB Awards Ballot- HPB Meeting of April 18, 2007 ' Page 4 of 4 NEW CONSTRUCTION 1-1 Address: 111-113 NW 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Residential Date Approved: March 2, 2005 -- Project New construction of a two-story ;` , ' a li it * 4, Description: duplex and associated site . ,,, improvements. 1 ,-==iiaiiii n Address: 136 NE 1st Avenue Historic District: Old School Square Use: Residential Date Approved: July 7, 2004 Project Construction of a 3,780 sq. ft., two- _1l �4i Description: story, duplex and two-story garage/ ' , *" ` f , . guest cottage. -, 71/4i �K cc: Paul Dorling, Director of Planning and Zoning Mark McDonnell, Assistant Director of Planning and Zoning DELRAY BEACH F O . 1 All-America City I 1991 2001 SIGN IN SHEET Regular Historic Preservation Board Meeting April 18, 2007 PRINT FULL NAME ADDRESS OR ITEM NO. ORGANIZATION