The URL can be used to link to this page

HPB 03-04-15 AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD o � Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. MINUTES - None IV. APPROVAL OF AGENDA V. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC VI. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.) Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VII. ACTION ITEMS A. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District Property Owner: William T. Hatcher Authorized Agent: William E. Hatcher Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a contributing structure. B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Owner: Karen B. Galvin Authorized Agent: BNT Services, Impact Windows Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the replacement of windows and doors on a non-contributing property. VIII. REPORTS AND COMMENTS Board Members ❖ Staff VII. ADJOURN A wty E. ALvaye/k Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: February 25, 2015 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owners: William T. Hatcher Authorized Agent: William E. Hatcher Project Location: 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 File: 2015-090 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) associated with the demolition of a contributing dwelling on the property located at 134 SE ft Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.2.6(D). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lot 16, Block 70, and is located on the west side of SE 1st Avenue between SE 1st Street and SE 2nd Street within the Old School Square Historic District. The 13,150 square foot (100'x131'-5") property contains a contributing, two-story, frame vernacular home built in 1931. The Florida Master Site File survey notes that the structure is associated with the developmental history of the area that occurred during the 1920s. At one point, a boarding house was established on the site which served as a destination for soldiers en route to Miami; a barber shop was located in the south, one-story wing. There are no other COAs on file for the subject property. The subject request is for the demolition of a two-story, contributing residential structure, which historically consisted of three dwelling units/apartments, while only one has remained occupied over the last several years. The historic structure has significantly deteriorated over the years with dry rot and termite damage to load bearing walls, the foundation, and the wood framing. The attachments include an explanation of the existing conditions. In September 2014, the subject property was cited in violation of Chapter 100.10 (Individually Designated Historic Structures and Structures in Historic Districts) of the Code of Ordinances, which states the following: Structures that are individually designated as historic or are located in historic districts shall be maintained in a secure and attractive manner. All defective structural and decorative elements of such building facades shall be repaired or replaced in a workmanlike manner, to match as closely as possible the original materials and construction of the building. All exterior walls shall have all loose material removed and patching or resurfacing shall be accomplished to match the existing or adjacent surfaces as to materials, color, bond, and joining. All cornices, trim and window frames that are damaged, sagging or othe,wise deteriorated shall be repaired or replaced to be made structurally sound and all exposed materials painted, stained or otherwise treated in a consistent manner. At its meeting of January 13, 2015, the City's Code Enforcement Board required that the structure come into compliance within 60 days or be fined. The Board Order (see attached) states, "the exterior of this property needs to be restored and preserved." However, during the hearing, the poor condition of the structure was discussed, including the strong possibility that the structure 134 SE 1 Avenue:COA 2015-090 HPB Meeting March 4,2015 Page 2 of 5 would be demolished. Subsequently, the subject COA request to demolish the historic structure was submitted. On February 3, 2015, City Staff including the Historic Preservation Planner and Chief Building Official (CBO) met both the property owner and contractor at the site to review the conditions. Due to the structural insecurity and unsoundness of the building, the Chief Building Official declared it an "Unsafe Structure". The subject COA is now before the Board for consideration. LDR SECTION 4.5.1 ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), Prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to ObjectWe A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretaiy of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. LDR Section 4.5.1 (E) Development Standards: All new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Deiray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. (E)(7) Demolition: Demolition of historic or archaeological sites, or buildings, structures, improvements and appurtenances within historic districts shall be regulated by the Historic Preservation Board in the manner described in Section 4.5.1(F). Demolition of any structure, whether contributing or non-contributing, shall not occur until a building permit has been issued for the HPB approved redevelopment. All structures approved for demolition and awaiting issuance of a building permit for the redevelopment shall be maintained in a manner similar to that in which it existed at time of application unless the Chief Building Official determines that an unsafe building condition exists in accordance with Section 4.5.1(G). STAFF COMMENT: The subject request is for the demolition of a contributing structure; however, the redevelopment plans for the lot have not been submitted, nor has a waiver been requested to permit the demolition prior to the issuance of a permit for the redevelopment. Therefore, it is suggested that, if the Board opts to approve the demolition request, then a condition of approval be added to further ensure that the demolition shall not take place until the redevelopment of the site has been approved by the Board and issued a permit. (F) Restrictions on Demolitions: No structure within a Historic District or on a Historic Site shall be demolished without first receiving a Certificate of Appropriateness pursuant to Section ' 2.4.6(H). The Historic Preservation Board shall be guided by the following in considering such a request. (1) The Historic Preservation Board upon a request for demolition by a property owner, shall consider the following guidelines in evaluating applications for a certificate of appropriateness for demolition of designated historic sites, historic interiors, or buildings, structures, or appurtenances within designated historic districts; (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill criteria for designation for listing on the national register. 134 SE 1 Avenue;COA 2015-090 HPS Meeting March 4,2015 Page 3 of 5 (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the city. (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local histoiy, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. (e) Whether there are approved plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the surrounding area. STAFF COMMENT: In consideration of the criteria above, the structure was not deemed eligible for individual designation on the National Register, however, it would be eligible as a contributing structure for the listing of the Old School Square Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places. Reproduction of the subject structure could likely be performed, but at a higher expense than a new structure due to differences in building materials and techniques when comparing the replication and the new construction. However, the existing details, scale, and design elements are something to be considered during the review of the redevelopment, should the demolition be approved. Historic structures always help to tell the story of an area, whether its developmental or cultural, both of which the subject structure appears to contribute to, regardless of its deteriorated state. There are not presently any plans for the immediate reuse of the property; it would be ideal for it to be appropriately restored and rehabilitated whether for continued residential use, or for the adaptive reuse to a commercial use. (2) No decision of the Board shall result in undue economic hardship for the property owner. The Board shall determine the existence of such hardship in accordance with the definition of undue economic hardship found in Subsection (H). (3) The Board's refusal to grant a Certificate of Appropriateness requested by a property owner for the purpose of demolition will be supported by a written statement describing the public interest that the Board seeks to prese,ve. (4) The Board may grant a certificate of appropriateness as requested by a property owner, for demolition which may provide for a delayed effective date. The effective date of the certificate will be determined by the Board based on the relative significance of the structure and the probable time required to arrange a possible alternative to demolition. The Board may delay the demolition of designated historic sites and contributing buildings within historic districts for up to six months while demolition of non-contributing buildings within the historic district may be delayed for up to three months. (5) As a condition of the Certificate of Appropriateness approval for demolition, the Board may require that the applicant take such steps as it deems necessary to preseive the structure requested for demolition including consultation with community groups, public agencies, and interested citizens, recommendations for acquisition of property by public or private bodies, or agencies, and exploration of the possibility of moving one or more structures or other features. (6) The Board may, with the consent of the property owner, request that the owner, at the owner's expense, salvage and preserve specified classes of building materials, architectural details and ornaments, fixtures, and the like for reuse in the restoration of the other historic properties. The Board may, with the consent of the property owner, request that the Delray Beach Historical Society, or the owner, at the owner's expense, record the 134 SE 1Avenue;COA 2015-090 HPB Meeting March 4,2015 Page 4 of 5 architectural details for archival purposes prior to demolition. The recording may include, but shall not be limited to photographs, documents, and scaled architectural drawings to include elevations and floor plans. Two (2) copies of such recordings shall be submitted to the City's Planning and Zoning Department. One (1) to be kept on file and the other to be archived with the Delray Beach Historical Society. At the Board's option, and with the property owner's consent, the Board or the Delray Beach Historical Society may salvage and preserve building materials, architectural details, and ornaments, textures, and the like at their expense, respectWely. (7) The owner shall provide the following information on his/her application for any contributing structure in a historic district or individually designated historic structure: (a) A certified report from a registered architect or engineer which provides documentation explaining that the building is structurally unsound and is damaged beyond the ability to repair it at a reasonable cost. The report must include photographs to substantiate the damage. (b) A certified report from an engineer, architect, general contractor, or other qualified professional which documents the projected cost of repairing the structure and returning it to a safe and habitable condition. (c) An appraisal of the property in its current condition, its value as vacant land and its potential value as a preserved and restored historic property. (d) Documentation that reasonable efforts have been made to find a suitable alternate location for the structure within the City of Delray Beach to which the contributing! individually designated historic structure could be safely relocated. STAFF COMl'JIENTIANALYSIS: In accordance with the Subsections above, the Board may grant a demolition delay date in the case that there are other interested parties who may be able to rehabilitate the structure, or provide an appropriate redevelopment plan. Due the Unsafe Building declaration, the Board may not require that the site be entered, particularly for the purpose of salvage of materials or details. Regarding the documentation of the site, Staff has taken photographs of details on the structure where permitted on the site and from a safe location. However, prior to demolition Staff would request that the landscaping immediately adjacent to the structure be removed first in order to permit Staff to take additional photographs of each elevation prior to the demolition. Further, if the CBO deems it safe, Staff would request the ability to have the demolition crew salvage specific details that are deemed important upon inspection by Staff prior to the demolition. The property owner and contractor (Authorized Agent) have provided documents which strive to meet the required information noted in Subsection (7) above. These documents are attached, and should be considered by the Board in making their findings for the request. (G) Unsafe Buildings: In the event the Chief Building Official determines that any structure within a designated historic site or designated historic district is unsafe pursuant to the applicable Code of Ordinances, the Chief Building Official will immediately notify the Board of his findings. Where appropriate and in accordance with applicable ordinances, the Chief Building Official will attempt to have the structure repaired rather than demolished, and will take into consideration any comments and recommendations by the Board. However, the provisions contained within division (A) of this section shall not apply to the Chief Building Official's declaration that a building is unsafe, nor will the Chief Building Official be precluded from taking whatever steps, as may be required by applicable ordinances to protect the public health and safety of the community. The Board may also endeavor to negotiate with the owner and interested parties, provided such actions do no interfere with procedures in the applicable ordinances. '134 SE 1t Avenue;C0A2015-090 HPB Meeting March 4,2015 Page 5 of 5 STAFF COMMENT/ANALYSIS: As previously noted, the Chief Building Official (CBO) has "red tagged" the structure, which means that has been deemed unsafe. The CBO has not ordered the demolition of the structure, and is aware of the subject request. A chain link fence and gate run the perimeter of the property, and the gate has been closed to prohibit trespassing. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) for the demolition of the contributing structure at 134 SE jst Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, subject to the following conditions: 1. That the demolition not occur until the plans for the redevelopment of the site have been approved by the HPB, and issued a building permit, that a waiver be submitted, reviewed and approved by the HPB to permit the demolition to occur prior to the redevelopment approval and building permit issuance; 2. That, the landscaping adjacent to the structure be removed prior to demolition to permit Staff the ability to photograph each elevation of the structure; and, 3. That Staff be given the opportunity, subject to the approval by the Chief Building Official, to select details and architectural features to be salvaged and donated to the Delray Beach Historical Society, or other interested local organization. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) for the demolition of the contributing structure at 134 SE jst Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative) RECOMMENDATION Board Discretion. Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preseivation Planner 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District I' IIstSt ss - - \. I : ' --SE.jI St -'.- I P I 1 -. I . ' - •- :: : JL I ____ , I It : ', r I I I - , . - - V ¼ 1 j P V . I \ -. t-'.' r - / % F 1 1 __ : p : : -, p I I rI - - - 1 - I 4 ----. i V q —ri - - '•p r' / ' 1, 1 4i - - !: k ( - i: L VV - SESt V I/ '. 7 ' .: ' ' / L I -. - -. j4 F - . i% 'r i .1'c 1!, .i -h- '- - I:J? 'L ] i't :_-1. --..-- - - '1 - ii .u1 I . : LI ..- . . -.-.-.'-'-- ' . -' H - I•. L : I- - - h- - - ____ - . j' T ----- --__7 V-E - ____ I i -Lrt. -15 • ri.d. rnIid. iunt1y- :. .IJd -c . II:i, ] -t!L vi dr' r I]ci'i; 7J . . - PcL3v 1lOII11 , 1C "± 141[ f . llj 3 ' J{,_ l3I- lLtIr - - -- -- . - \-2 Lic.#CG0061503 CONSTRUCTION & DEVELOPMENT January 15,2015 Attn:Amy Alvarez City of Deiray Beach Historic Preservation Board 100 NW1Ave Delray Beach, FL.33444 Dear Board Member, We have been working with the owner William 1. Hatcher on the code violation(14-57832) at 134 SE 1 Ave in Defray. I have visited and inspected this site for necessary repairs. The Secretary of Interior Standards for Rehabilitation of Historic Preservation for this 1934 home would be impossible to repair due to deteriorated structural sills and beams. In following the preservation guidelines in severity of deterioration, replacement distinctive feature with new feature should match the old design. We have put together a preliminary cost estimate for the repairs. Scope of Work: Shore up the existing house to remove damaged sills and replace with new materials. Remove the existing damaged roof system, including damaged roof coverings and install with new structural beams. Remove areas of supporting frame walls and building walls. Remove damaged floor joist system,and install new with flooring. Demo the rear of property, roof walls,foundation. Re-build with historic-like materials and restore with the same features. Remove wood siding(board on board). It is in our opinion, that this structure should be demolished completely, and the rebuilding cost would be around $328.00 per square foot.Total cost for this location $640,000.00.This will include the design plan, labor and material. Sincerely, William E. Hatcher CGC061503 1020 South Federal Hwy. #102, Delray Beach, FL 33483 561-330-2621 I 561-330-2670 I hatchergc@bellsouth.net John Holt P. E. 925 AZURE AVE WELLINGTON, FL 33414 / 561-358-5432 DATE: Jan 12, 2015 Re: Site Visit/Existing 2 Story Wood Structure Evaluation Owner: William Hatcher Address: 134 SE. 1st Aye, Deiray Beach, Fl Area Calculations: 1,954 s/f To Whom It may Concern, It is in my Professional Opinion after making a site visit that was built in the 1931 that I did notices Mold and Structural problems that may take a lot to repair. And in summary the building should be demolished. It is also my opinion its always less expensive to build new then to remodel an existing building( unless the building can be saved ) This One has to many Issues to be saved. Here is the List of my Finding: 1. The Wood bearing Walls on the South side of the Building Need a major Construction Repairs and Have Dry Rot. Which is a Major Cost to the Client. 2. Rear of the Building has to be totally Removed and rebuilt with the newest electrical and Mechanical Building Codes. 3. All exterior Wood Siding has to repaired or replaced 4. The Whole roof System must be replaced 5. Mold is see in many areas on the first Level. 6. Exterior Wood framing has Termite Damage And Deflecting in some areas 7. Existing Wood Stairs are Unsafe and Do not meet safety Guidelines 8. Wood Floor Joist Have to be replaced - 9. Square foot price for historical could run around$328.00 per sq ft, put reproduction cost at $640,000 making still a heavy burden to the Owner even with state, local and federal grants 10. Please see attached pictures. In the summary, the house having NOT receive proper maintenance over the years and deteriorate beyond repair. If you erQuions please call. John HOlt, 7" /Z'7/, -3.- . -V - 'S- -•- --.- - - - :: -. S - 5 ...S ' _ _ •5_ ' .. S - _ _ S'_ - - S - S --- .-- 5. Si.-.- S S'55 - S-S S555S - S . 9 -' •--— -- S 'S •: - '5, - 5 ,. - : --- i .-'.-- --- 5- - •5-•'.,• 5._- .-_—•;.-.- c,--------.- . .•_'iS . • - / ..-1.- "V - - - '.- - -- - '; I - -, > - — 3 V 5. - - --- — is.'.-.. ...i. s'- __..- ___ - ' .r- . - -• S5t 2 - .-:- • ç - -,, V - - 5.'- '1 — — 4 ) - - •' S - - p?-- - it . :- ¼. - :-- - - : ' . : -' ' '¼. - \ - -.---'-, --.. ¼ .- -.. .-- '¼-;. L'- 7 '-.v j - .- t;' I . -' .-- 8 - '¼ 4- '. ¼ ¼ j I I I ---- .4 4 ___ - '¼ 1 - I - . -. - - I - f - 4 - / • 4. .: ult - - -- -. - - - - r - i __ \ - - - J - - - - •\ \ - -- -- —=- - L, . - --- -S-- - - - - .-'- - - - - It. •=' - - - --; - ---- ----'--,.--- - - - - - - - - --- -- / : - - ;r . - b -J - -- - : - r - - - -,-- 1 - - —; _-:_ -:- - , iL . -, - - I - V a - -" I - ' -I -i - r - - I - '- - _;____ - - - I - Hi ' - - i.— - I ' - - - - - - -- ' H. 2T - -- - - :-- -- ---- - -- : - - -; - - !'- j / c ¼ I ) J : - - - _ - - - - - A ( - - I- - 4 -.- - '- . • - - - - - - ' I / . - - - - --b -.s- - q. T ; .. - - - - .. - .--. - - - '-.' - - - - c - , & ? _zi - - - _4- t - - — - -Th- — •t 4 - ' - - - 1' ___ _____ ,- '-- -,---$4 -v - ____ - --. - , _____ - — g 4_' - - -- - -:•- '- . - -A ,, - - -. , -- - - ' ---- '- ', - .- : -b--- - - - tL - - - : 4$t - - - -. - % - - \ - _- .s '- I-. -: - -\ o- - - - - .- - \ 7- t — -- -2-- I -, 4 -.' t'r ' - 4 - -1_ ' s-J - - / ,, - j ' ! ; tt % J :k - • - - lIt _._ ••._-;_' - • •'.. - - 0-9. 4 • - • .- ' -. • -- - 4 4 -- - • II 'I - : 4 •- • •,-,--- - 4- - - :_ - 4 - _;--•--f -=-'-- F - -,-- S 4 It- ) 4 - 1 .- - • 4'_• • -- - -- -- - -- - - - - -- •-•- 4- .• I ; _______ - - ;- .d - - - -' -- - A '• •2:' - : - -,- S -S. I - - 4 - - - • - - •• 4 - I • -.- - • 4 _ _ , - - -- I • 4' - - - • • - , , - , • • -- -1 -- -. • • I_ ? • - S . • - 4 1. . Jr -' it •1 I • S I ? w p £ - -- . - - - - - - e -- - -- -- - :' - : i -- I ' :-; - - - T - - - ___ -. — - - .44 - - - . - - - -- -1 - - . - - -.- - - -,.- - '-1 -- - -- - - -. -- •1_ I - - - -- . -* ._* - - -- - - - -; -c;. - _i- --=-:- - =- - 4 _4-' - ------- - - — - - a 4 - - : - - - 1 ' __• _ -- - -i----- -v --. i- - _,.__--1I_.--::. - - - r - 1 - - - 1 •-J- - -- :- •-- - -- — : -- -c - - ft - - - - - - - - i- - - - - - -- - - -- ---- :1 ------ = : -- _,- 4 - - - -- - - - - - - --.--.- -J4 - ; ,- 4 = j : ; - -- 1 - - __=_f_ -- -. - .- - - - - Florida HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder PB10581 ! File Electronic Version 1.1.0 FormNo 200503 First Site Form Recorded for this Site? NO FoanNo Fe1d Dale(YVYYMM) Site Name(address If none) 134 SE 1 Ave. Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names SurveyorProjectName Old School Square Historic Resources Survey Survey# I. National Register Category Building(a) Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 134 SE 1 Avenue Cross Streets(nearest/between) SB 2/SE 1 Streets City I Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YES County Palm Beach laxParcel#(s) 12-43-46-16-01-070-0150 Subdivision Name Map of Town of Linton Block Lot Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) Old School Square Route to(especially if no street address) USGS 7.5' Map Name Publication Date > Township: Range: Section: 114 section: >> Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) Style Frame Vernacular Other Style Exterior Plan L-shaped Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 2 Structural System(s) >> Other Structural System(s) ___________ Foundation Type(s) > Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) >> F Other Foundation Material(s) Exterior Fabric(s) Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) >> Other Roof Material(s) Roof Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) > Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys Chimney Material Other Chimney Material(s) Chimney Location(s) Pace I of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM SPB1OSB1 WindowDescriptions Jalousie; Others are obscured by closed shutters. Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) A parking pad adjacent to the stoop leads to the enclosed porch. Porches: #open #closed 1 #incised Location(s) Facade Porch Roof Types(s) Shed Exterior Ornament Cornerboards, exposed rafter tails, board-and-batten shutters Interior Plan Unknown Other Interior Plan Condition Deteriorated SttüYeSurroundin $ Commercial:SOME of this category Residential: SOME of this category Institutional: Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Numbed type of outbuildings,major landscape features) Archaeological Remains(describe): None If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? NO Narrative Description(optional) I . .. Construction year 1924 Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): %i Ldcatións or Cèlitions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes >> . .'-. - —. _.1 ' _-.- - - -c-.-- - - s Structüré Use History Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended >> Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) RESEARCFI METHODS Research Methods Other research methods : . :.U.. Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? NO Name of Local Register if Eligible Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES Area(s)of historical significance >> OtherHistoricalAssociations Old School Square Historic Arts DistriCt Explanation of Evaluation(required) This building does not warrant individual local designation or NRHP listing due to its poor condition, but it does contribute to the district as a representative exanpie of domestic architecture from the district's period of significance. Page 2 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8P310581 Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: >> I RECOFDERI11FORMATEON - - - Recorder Name(Last First) Hyland, Mattew; Tuk, Jared RecorderAthiress/Phone 618 East South Street, Orlando, Florida, 32801 407.423.8398 Recorder Affiliation GAl Consultants - SE OtherAffihiation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? NO SHPO's Evaluation of Resource Date — r' . — kC ,rIr 00_ 0._.L .a4_- - - cjiRan i . L - E- : ; . E —' - .A)- 9]c - - - - r - SpleieM Jnfbafl faiu UP - -. )O&..r - _ : — L4jla1 Zo:- 2' 2 Fric9inenfs - - c - . -= PAPER - (2) LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP A TTACHMENTS (3) PH0T10F MAIN FACADE B&W,AT LEAST 3"X5 Page 3 of 3 PB10581-200503 Supplementary Printout USGS map name/year of publication or revision: DELRAY BEACH;1986 > Township/RangelSection/Qtr: 46S;43E;16:UNSP > Structural system(s): Wood frame > Foundation types: Piers > Foundation materials: Concrete Blocl > Exterior fabrics: Siding-drop Shingles-asbestos > Roof types: Gable. > Roof materials: Sheet metal:standing seam > Roof secondary structures(dormers etc): > Change status/year changed/date notedInature: Original, intermediate, present uses/year startedlyear ended: Private residenàe:1924; > Research methods: Sanborn maps Pedestrian Examine local property ecords Library research-local Plat map > Area(s)of historical significance: - - Architecture Community planning&development > Repositories:Collection/Housed!Accession#IDescribe > [Other name(s)]: Page 1 Of I - - - / - r P ______ 4 .; b1 — - - -- - * ; 1 1= )91414 P • •;o £c . ••• 4 . i'% ____ 0R404 •.s O?i- 1' .4VE. . •.• • N . f __________________ kn • I d_1 I - ffS r • • • • •• ,-_I& - *JI4fl Mtrf'rit l _ -••IP. j - • :1 •, • L4: 221 i : ' | i L Paqe HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# 8PB10581 Original FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 351 Update LI Conzut GudeTo Hsto1caI Structw.Fotm (or deIId k1StTUCtJOflI Recorder Date 11/2001 Site Name 134 SE 1st Avenue Other Names None /1/15 711 Project Name City of Deiray Beach Historic Resources Survey.Phase II Historic Contexts Boom Times National Register Category Building Address 134SE1stAvenue Vicinity of West side, between SE 1st Street and SE 2nd Street City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969&1973 Township 46S Range 43E Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr NW Irregular Section LI UTM Zone 17 Easting 0592496 Northing 2926814 Land Grant Unknown Latitude N/A Longitude N/A Plat or Other Map Aerials Architect/Builder Unknown Construction Date 1924 Circa LI Alterations I Date 1988 Type Windows boarded Additions I Date 1946: 1950 Type Room addition;Screen porch addition Moved LI Original Location N/A Original Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence Style Frame Vernacular Exterior Plan Irregular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 2 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Drop Siding,Asbestos Siding Foundation Slab Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infill N/A No. of Porches I Locations/Features N/second story/covered entry stoop Dormers LI Number/Location N/A Outbldgs. LI Number 0 Nature/Location(Describe below) N/A - Roof Type Gable,Shed Roofing Materials Composition Roll Secondary Structures LI Comments/Location N/A Chimneys LI Number ..Q . Orientation N/A Location N/A Materials N/A Wood Windows Type Boarded up Light# Unknown Metal Windows Li Type N/A Light# N/A Exterior Ornament Rafter Tails,Classical Surround Condition Fair Surroundings Residential,Commercial Narrative(general, interior, landscape,context;3 lInes only) This house has undergone many changes;the porch has been enclosed with metal louvers and concrete walls. The house is set back from the road and features jalousie doors on the north side. Despite the alterations,it still retains the majority of Its historic characteristics. Archaeological Remains Present LI None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes,attach) LI Printed Monday.May 06,2002 Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# 8P810581 Consult Guld*To Hlsto,lcal Structure Forms for dstallod lnstnacdons Eligible for National Register? Yes Li No I Likely, Need Information Li Insufficient Information LI Significant as Part of District? Yes II No LI Likely, Need Information LI Insufficient Information LI Significant at Local Level? Yes EI No LI Likely, Need Information Insufficient Information LI Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This building is associated with the developmental history and exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School Square area during the 1920s.Due to its historical and architectural significance,this building could contribute to the locally listed Old School Square Historic District,when the historic district is re-evaluated and the period of significance is expanded to include later historic resources. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS DHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBIUTY DATE YES NO — SHPO EVALUATION OF EUGIBIUTY DATE YES NO — LOCAL DETERMINATION OF EUGIBILITY DATE YES NO — LOCAL OFFICE Research Methods Past sites and surveys search at FMSF,Building Permits,Local and Non-Local Library Research Bibliographic References Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey, 1987; Delray Beach Historic Resources Report,1999 Location of Negatives Janus Research Negative Numbers Roll 2184-25,Exp.21 Facing W Recorder Name Susan Daniel,Skye Wheeler,Jennifer Bradley Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH.2935 FirstAvenue North,St.Petersburg,Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5'MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,PREFERABLY B&W,AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Monday,May 06,2002 ' lI II . Iq 4 it I p -. - -)1.•-- - '7/4 ,çf - ; ; • :::-j .: IlR • IIIII - ' lll hlhlI . 8 •,• ,••.__ :. ] Ii i:- !I : • SE 1ST ST = rI i 8PB10581 - : / SE2NDST NL USGS QUADRANGLE MAP , ' / .1, j -I . r ' - $ -" 1 _______ I 7 -- / P , I ______ U.r •/ ¶ ' : 1r - ' - , - Ui ' - I " - - .1 J - II '--- ,. s,-I--- - ' ----3. - I -' '- - I - I I- -% .- . -' - ' - I - I - --- ____ '4 . . - - N TH ST - -- - r - , - - I - r Sc. I 1 - - ---- - - ----- I - -pl.e7p .3 -' I I -- 1 II I / .3- II I - I I - L - _' - I - .:•i. .- /://..-.- t 4I ' 1 irWI AQI4 — - - : rL 41 :r. ; / ?II •• 4 :1 III - I - - ,' ' - - - t : '- r - I .- 3I I ; -- -- - - I ' - I - i-. - - II $ ? ' - - L_ - 41 : . ' _ L '! ' I I - IIfjL - I . T..2 - -. I J 41 - -- I il- I " tL - . ?S1 / / - - iii ;' : ' : I3i I ::_.\ - l - 1 • ljI -s I - 1 ne Ridge i • . •'?i._ I - - ' - I I -- j - 3I II I 1 1 - '2O . ::. 'a:..: f 1! ç - ; a.... s I :3I II J -. . - -21 -J - ,3. I- .. I'..!,I.-; ..-. ,. I Locatiozi of SPBIQS81 - _____________ •q Li •: JL/SG5 Vuathngk DL1?a &aJL ilortcia '19O2 PR I9 ) I - MI -I ' __________ U -- I rji• i e . •.:.. .';< - . 2 .-- I - _ ? - -. : 47 -., ,-. t? - 4 J' :. 4. .4 , * . - ' p '__4. JI I tj L ' — .— cI (Ji1Ifl' — .' if -' - - e -' - I -__ ,-.. F - -- I - ..P11_ - r# •I .4 1 -I -, I - r - 4 .. I 4 3 -.4 - IJ - .4 •4_ 'iV-.- . .5 . Sy. S. .... S ' ' : 4 F 3 IT J : • :.: i : - '5, J. - -'- I 4 - - p - - T 5, 5, * - CITY OF DELRAY BEACH VIOLATION ADDRES. AND LEGAL (Petitioner) DESCRIPTION LOCATION: VS 134 SE 1ST AVENUE,DELRAY BEACH FL WILLIAM T HATCHER SUNDY&CROMER AMND PL LTS 15& 16 BLK 70(OLD 134 SE 1ST AVENUE SCHOOL SQUARE HISTORIC DISTRICT),ACCORDING DELRAY BEACH,FL 33444 TO PLAT BOOK 14120 PAGE 1184 OF THE OFFICIAL (Respondent(s)) RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY,FLORIDA PC#12 43 46 16 B4 070 0150 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ORDER CASE NUMBER CEB 14-57832 This cause having come before the Code Enforcement Board for hearing,and,based upon the evidence,the Code Enforcement Board enters the following finding of facts:This property is located in the Old School Square Historic Arts District. The exterior of this property needs to be restored and preserved. Please contact Planning& Zoning Department to schedule a meeting with the Preservation Board at (561)243-7284. Based upon the above findings of fact, the Code Enforcement Board concludes that the Respondent(s) is the violator(s) has been properly noticed,and is responsible for the correction of the following violations of the following violation of City ordinances 7.1.3(A)(1001); 100.10 (A). It is the order of the Code Enforcement Board that the City of Delray Beach has introduced evidence to substantiate the allegations contained on the Violation Notice. The Respondent(s)shall pay a fine of$50.00 per day if violation continues to exist after 60 days from the date of this hearing. Upon complying,the Respondent(s)shall contact the Code Enforcement Officer who shall inspect the property and verify compliance. If compliance is not achieved,as noted above,it shall constitute a continuing violation with daily fines accruing at the rate noted above and this Order may be recorded in the Public Records of Palm Beach County,Florida. Once recorded,this Order shall constitute a lien against the property upon which the violation exists and against any real or personal property owned by the violator pursuant to Chapter 162,Florida Statutes. The City of Deiray Beach may foreclose on any lien which remains unpaid after 3 months. Done and ordered this month 13th day of Januaiy,2015. Cod En9ment Board,City of Del y Beach,Florida Chairperson Sworn to and subscribed before me this 2l' day of January,2015. yPuic - DANISER.CLECKLEY ---- - Commistion#FF050762 ExpiresJanuary3,2018 Bonded miulroy Fon lontnonce 000-385-7019 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH February 10,2015 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD A. CALL TO ORDER: The scheduled meeting of the City of Defray Beach Code Enforcement Board on January 13,2015 was called to order in the Council Chambers at City Hall at 100 NW First Avenue,Defray Beach,Florida,at 1:30 PM with the following persons: B. MEMBERS PRESENT: OTHERS PRESENT: David Boone,Chairman f) . Code Enforcement Staff Ronald Gilinsky,Co Ch. -".. Cathy Kozol,C.A. Ross Freem. c' Kevin Homer . C. MEMBERS NOT PRESENT: 4' Stanley Brodka Jason Dollard Penny Sugar D. CASES DISMISSED: 14-54488, 14-56531, 14-56766, 14-57070, 14-57474, 14-57524, 14-57591, 14-57667, 14-57796, 14-57813, 14-57846, 14-57850, 14-57902, 14-57934, 14-57958, 14-57973, 14-57998, 14-57999, 14-58002, 14-58008, 14-58014, 14-58057, 14-58073, 14-58173, 14-58180, 14-58181, 14-58189, 14-58375, 14-58477, 14-58375, 14-58477, 14-58501, 14-58512, 14-58673, 14-58674, 14-58715, 14-58717, 14-58727, 14-58746, 14-58747, 14-58790, 14-58903, 14-58993, 14-59007, 14-59034, 14-59090. 14-59161, 14-59172, 14-59174, 14-59186, 14-59187, 14-59198, 14-59293, 14-59306, 14-59337, 14-59339, 14-54488 E. CASES POSTPONED: 14-57368, 14-58322, 14-58741, 14-58749, 14-59825 F. CASES SCHEDULED AND HEARD: see attached Board Orders G. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: December 9,2015 H. ELECTION OF NEW OFFICERS: Jason Dollard nominated and elected Board Chairman;Kevin Homer nominated and elected Board Co-Chairman. I. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board,the Chairman declared the meeting adjourned at: 3:25 P.M. - BOARD CLERK: Danise R. Cleckley - -- ulceb/hearinglminutes LegalZone eLaws j eRegulations eCases j State of Florida Florida Statutes j Florida Administrative Code I Florida ( Sign In J Sign Up fl Deiray Beach Code of Ordinances Code Of Ordinances Title 9. General Regulations Chapter 100. Nuisances - General Provisions § 100.10. Individually Designated Historic Structures And Structures In Historic Districts Latest version. (A) Structures that are individually designated as historic or are located in historic districts shall be maintained in a secure and attractive manner. All defective structural and decorative elements of such building facades shall be repaired or replaced in a workmanlike manner, to match as closely as possible the original materials and construction of the building. All exterior walls shall have all loose material removed and patching or resurfacing shall be accomplished to match the existing or adjacent surfaces as to materials, color, bond, and joining. All cornices, trim and window frames that are damaged, sagging or otherwise deteriorated shall be repaired or replaced to be made structurally sound and all exposed materials painted, stained or otherwise treated in a consistent manner. (Ord. No. 72-06, § 1, passed 12/5/06) IF , V: VV _VVV j - —* d • V V V ? j J V - 1 'i s)( JS1 p V VV V V V V iV V V VVV V4 V ' - 1 ( rç (V / r - * I III VYI I , - i-, - - V V V V V V VV VI V V V V V V V VVV V / V r f f ,_J1I I t - / iI f I r : - c III IIPVIIH V I V VVV VV V V V I ; , - 7 - •V V V V IVV V V V V VV IFV VJ VII!V / T • - - V V I 5 - 1r I - VV VV V V l VIII IIV V - V VV V IV r V V VVV VV H V# S III V .VVVV V V - V V. V V V,V,V VV V ; VI VVV IV V V . V V VVVIVIVI VV V V VV V: ,V VV IIV VV V I I II 1 j ç I V V V - V V V VJ VV VIVV VI- LIIJI I V V VIV I V iI V.4 I I I jIII I I M/ tt: L II I'J II I I IL I I I I II ill I IIV ., - k L / . (4 , _ ç - , If :' - 1' 1iiti , / 1 - — yd II ' \ / r -L I I - - % l _)_ - -. - $ 1j11 I , . . - I - I, --I I1 I hF if I 1 - -' F I H Jiii I II * I 1I Ii I I IJ P IWrIi rjlL IFIJ Iti - - - -- PIIJ .V - - - r I - .,-•I' r ill - - - 1 * - / I ,-.- k j E ; I - • - I '!± i 'L 'I ' - ,:1 L ,-. •14 9 t I - - TT) I - -- 4 I ' - I - - - - - - 'I - U - c / _ .i I -r •It? 1 I !- - T - 1 _ , F I _ = ; Tj ' - - : - - S - - L .- ) t I - - 5- - r - -i ;.; : 2 i_ __ - - - -I I c / If - I r 1 I I - ' wT I I 11 4 I -- --- - = 3 . 2,. - - _- _;- , - Ti - I - - iT - -1 r- a- c - - . ! - - wi4 - -- I -- - r - - - - - - $- . - - - - - --,-- -- ;- ._ - -=-- - ,-.- __f_- -- _L. 1' Lt 4 , : Il, % ( . : , ' I - S $ I / -' / " - t ( - 4'- I 1 ( J ?I III I - - -. l 11 :, II- . I ;.i- .4 - 1 5.. S. ' 5.:: I, , ç .5 5 5 5 ---5 '1 1 . I I Y -- - - - & '.: 55 5,. 5.. : t ; : , - ; I I - 3' k i 1 - - 4 1 - I r - If - , ' J - i_ -- - I - i: L ' - - - 5- 4 '5- i -5, t- - - S., r • L • I f. -, •- S'v •*• ,• S 1- • & - - - 4 - .• , ,: i-' 51 • ' : It-* 4 ' I - fC..(s. ' ' ' - - •—.-•- • I • '- - ,. - - • - - 'V * - ___._-.z - o � -s r -I-- • - - : - •, '.. A ' V - -_--.5.= -'-'--5- L•sI'_ \ 4' k- ? 1'- --- / - -5- 5,. -- - 5'.. , - . ' \_ , . t .5 1 5'- -' - ' *5' ••:"- -- • - 4 •) \ '-5' ,"'4 ,, 'f , 4- \' J 4' y;.•4 - 4S.:k*1::_ 5'5' 5' , '-\ ffi ' ,4 . 4 * 4-', - k L'-- c ' } _i__S.J-•: ( '- c u •; : ;#'; L 11 -5-- ±f1fl , E ' ' - / t- -- * - - - - - - 5'— F - T - '— - ___ - •- z• - - -. • -5L -- - _______ - - -- : - - Ti--- ==- - - F - =- ii - - - = --- - - . - '1 -. -- - - i_ i - - - 4 - - - - - " - % 1* : - I Z iT- j * 1' - * I -f -- - : i - -:I __ : - - -- : - :: - Th jT - - -Th -- - --- -; --- - -- :- --•- 4L ! -= -. z - -- - :- T3 ! - - 5 - r - - _* - - - M -. - - - - • ---- - - - ---- - EiT---_ - 1 - -- •_ 4r -t I ET -' - - - - J - f - ' - : (L ;j a- -: - -- - - - - - L = I 4 - - 1 I 4 I II I - 1 4 \ IF { I ry I J - III II IiI I - I - i,j'-- I '' IZ r r - - - I Ij II!I — I I - - -- ... a .1 I - \ \ - \• -:-• - - \ •- ' J i'- N' 4- II / - 1 - •- ' ' - - \ •; • • ' - i III — ' , - ' II j I FjI - F1 F1IF FF F'ri II . ''i , FH ' II FFuui,I I I '' Fi I ] II hI]11H]11 F,' II] - / - : i- !I - - - -- -- - - - - - - - - - - -: _ - - -i- - _-.t- - 4 - - - F = _________ I I4 --T -- - -- - - -- : i = i; - - - - - . --. ' _-_4 - - - - - T : - . - ___ -- - -- - - - - --- L - J - - ---- - L -- - - - - - ( -- - -_ - - __;;__ _ ___ - p ___ r - r - - - r - - - I - - : I ' -'-= T11 - I = -- JX A. , 1' (1' r = p \\ - \\ - / ; \ \\ \ - 4 ., \. - — T : . '? ) . ,' ' - - -1 L Ti 4 7 - .- 4- - / 3 I -4t 1 La - -- - tt = - —rn - - T.__ _ ,c_ -- I 1 II ill I! / / I 1h11t -I - • ;. - I II I t ? ;_M - I I/ ' / ,f i c I - _4 I II II •; II ' lI ,* I / IiI' I< - - ' :: T III :4I: 2 8 / ' 4 .I [I , I 1ç: I I I k - I I II" ____ ,__ - I I - - I 4 - -_- 1• - I - - - ( / IMIII I I I I Ii - I I ' I - I I I - I' I H, I 4 I III4 : •;- - - i__. ' '-- - - J' ' L , 4 I I I1 I I I 4 I I I 1I11ü IIlI I - - 'Ii IJTTFJ . - r _________ - 11111 1 - .---_ - I I lIIIII I I I II I I I II I I I I I I II 14 I I IIf( I 4 I III 'I I • ' - S .•• - • b, -:- - ; -' - • ' rn 1FF I FL - A ' 1' ': "r •F • .' .:' - • I I - ••' • . •• - : .- - c ? 1 I S ' S S •, S \ S • S • JI• - I '' ' • :' ' S • S •' r! 1 - II IF - —: 5 - ; J II I FF,. (' 5F 'ss '' ' ,I'l - 1,_ -i I - 1. I L L - - ' ; - ' • S ' ft - - ' jIr F F ' / / :- -' -4 I j IF II F F ] r Fr I ' 5 5 •S • .:- . • • 'YF ' 1 • ' r • s • • S - S I F IFIF M IhI F F F 1F r F F F FF F F - ft I F F FFI F 1II f r F F F rr rr F / ) F - - - 11 - . !!!!!!!. T7,, 4 I .i Ir I / 1rr I I r c - II - - -. I - r . 14 - .. I I• . - . -:i 7 - . L : - •- .. , - • . • • •- • p . • . ••-,.,--. ,- 1 - 3 I - p!pV' - - c- - 4 \ . A - $0 ___ • ,r :' L 1- - - - ; i1;=4 I : t V . ' ; . . Fl l - - . . .. V . V .V:V . "h .VV_VI.:. 4 -rn III I - -- II - VV .4 V-V - * -* - :L:-;2=--- - V.- - - - --V - -'V.. V --V.-.- " V I V.- I F •. VV• •,• •._: • • . I' -V I ''4 . t- . 4 V ¶ II I IlI ll V. :' ] p I I 4 I I 14 h lI! Ij ., V ' I •1 4 t ' 4 . - ,i h11 'I,,,,. I . '1 I '*I V. 41 41 T I' II I jJ : 1 II .V • hm l II 1 41 - - 14 . ' ,: ". . . --'-V.' •' V . V . .- "• . V V . . - 4 L 44 lI4IL I I -- - - - - - I I11f = t - : L - I ; j - t9 :- - -, - I. - - S 4 -J -- - 4 - , _T _ - -- 1 AYAIBLE * - - iiI! 'g t\ 1 ; ____ ---- : - 7 - -- V \ _S_ .-.\ " / I I /4* S - t r :? - - - I : ci I - / f - - : - - - Tg1 - 11 - - -- - :- E [ : - ' -.4= T - - -- - -- - ' : =Lf' - r \ - I - - 4 ' - \ n . 4 -=- j. (I 1 it t I 4;:. t - - I A / _ ''1: I I - .-1 - _ - 1- It ti f ( _ A --V Alt •s 4 1 1 - I - T1 11 I! - HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Karen B. Galvin Authorized Agent: BNT Services, Impact Windows Project Location: 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 File No.: 2015-101 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for the replacement of windows and doors on a non-contributing property located at 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property (Lot 2, Block 6, Del-Ida Park) is located in the Del-Ida Park Historic District on the east side of North Swinton Avenue between Northeast 4th Street and Northeast 5 Street. The existing residence was originally a 1,300 square foot, one-story, simple ranch style home built in 1956. In 2000, a two-story rear addition was approved (COA 415), and has since been constructed bringing the total square footage to approximately 2,200. The structure is classified as non- contributing to the historic district. The current request is for the replacement of all existing aluminum windows and doors with vinyl, impact-rated windows and doors. All existing accordion shutters would subsequently be removed as well. The existing windows on the original portion of the structure consist of single-light awning windows or jalousie, whereas the windows in the 2000 addition consist of multi-light awning windows, or fixed, multi-light octagonal windows. The proposed windows are single-light sliders or fixed octagonal throughout the entire residence, with single-light French doors to match. The COA for window and door replacement is now before the Board for consideration. LDR SECTION 4.5.1 ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, All new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Defray Beach Historic Preseniation Design Guidelines, the Secretaiy of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(4), Alterations, in considering proposals for alterations to the exterior of historic buildings and structures and in applying development and preservation standards, the documented, original design of the building may be considered, among other factors. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(5), Standards and Guidelines, a historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the ii North Svntcn Avenuo:2015-101 H 'B Merriinq Morch 4.2015 Pzqe 2 of 3 Secretaiy of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Defray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. The applicable Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation are as follows: • Standard 2 - The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. • Standard 5 - Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a historic property shall be preserved. • Standard 6 - Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentaiy, physical, or pictorial evidence. Pursuant to LOR Section 4.51(E)(8), Visual Compatibility Standards, new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. The following Visual Compatibility Standard applies: (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. STAFF COMMENT: There is concern with the subject request as it does not comply with the intent of the applicable Standards, Guidelines, or Visual Compatibility Standards, since the character of the structure will be altered through the use of single-light and sliding windows. Additionally, the proposal includes the use of vinyl, which deviates from the aluminum material originally found on the structure which is readily available. Further, there is an existing difference between the window details of the original structure and the 2000 addition which should also be maintained when replacing windows to retain the desired differentiation. The generally accepted solution when replacing historic awning windows is to install either single-hung or casement windows which replicate the light pattern provided by the lines of the awning windows, with the casement type being preferred. Given the above, positive findings can be made to replace the existing windows subject to the suggested revisions. It should be noted that the use of impact-rated windows is appreciated and beneficial in that the exterior will be less affected whereby permanent hurricane protection will no longer be necessary. - 411 North Swinton Avenue;2015-101 HPB Meehng March 4,2015 Page 3 of 3 ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Deiray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Detray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative) RECOMMENDATION Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, subject to the following conditions of approval: 1. That the window type be revised to casement from sliders; 2. That the window material be revised to aluminum impact from vinyl; and, 3. That the light configuration for the new windows replicate that of the existing windows, with a difference between the original structure and the 2000 addition, as opposed to the single- light configuration which is proposed. Staff Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preseivation Planner 411 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District . - - - - '-. -. - - --', -- - / V' '4 - -. - - - r' I 't41111!AIIh! -W - ., • -, - _' - - , - . -., -. -- - / -' TI - - r I 1 •1 I - f z - - ' r - __ i - NE t - NE,j - .I. I - - - - ' I ' - -. ,- E' 1Pi4i * -, II - ' '- - ' IHI 1 -: -. - -.----- - c? --, L.k Id3 Rd - Ljke 1(13 Rd .................................. .. .........NE'4tISt I' NE 411%St NE 4th St - - ---- ___ _ \ - - '-' . . Z I - II I ' -_ F - - ! - iu -u &- L ' . . - I I . - I wNrciyRcIr ' I 1- I -- I____ rt I - . - ' , 1 \ I Ut BuT SIVk Ifl - IWI JLt Wt dow Addi& : tLIL. I ' W ht y Ctj St i' i'.L t ki U h I 3 I Phorw L L S . 3 i i is.i wjvw.bntcrve.COm 954233O12, HOA. M 'w 4QW ; '/// /.L - W H Room W H Styk Strks GIai Tint Grad Prk* 1 c Jj sd' 2 s.'. ' 3 / , / I /? - / ' ':' H ( 5 •)L ) i H 6 3 ) I ' 1 — . • - L... . b 8 - .- / '. ( c-. c ?'l )I 1 _ 10 •R It t R- Irt ;' •.. 11 : o L/ ) - 12 / j 5 Lj ( / ICP 13 0' _1__ 14 ')I... C' l ' -. 15 'p.- >c, ) 1) t ' '' ) 7' •'- 16 J ' '' . - - - 8nT agrees to provide&install the above products per code to the above address. Price includes tax,removal of all job related debris,weatherproofng, drywall,stucco&window sills if damaged during install. - . BnT is NOT responsible for paint,alarms or flooring. - • 40%deposit is required for all materials. - -, Financing is available. Customer agrees to terms of this contract, Product: CustornerSignature Tax: - Labor: ,. - -j - X TOTAL: '- / , (less deposit) - x TO1ALDU[ (after in5pection) . ràdb9 FREE i6hofTOlK Mobile Doc Scanner from www.stoik.mobi // -- -- -- - / t l2. / / _, / / V I1I I ---, iLI iS1I 1.j II / L - - -: Last Modified Date:1/26/20151:06:57 PM PO#: Job Name: Job Address: Quote# 3378111 MATERIALS LIST Sales Person:Chris Doolin ShipTo: B N T SERVICES INC Customer Bill & Karen Calvin Account# 1673 SW 1ST WAY UNIT A3 411 North Swinton DEERFIELD BEACH,FL 33441 6790 Delray Beach,FL 33444 Phone#(954)233-0126 Fax#(954)752-0245 Phone# Fax# Line# Item Description Quantity' Line Pricing 1.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.500w x 49.25CR Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.500 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 2.1 FIS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.500W x 49.25CR Size selection:Custom Size Conliguration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.500 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 3.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,503.00 Location: Size:72.750W x 61.375H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Iriterlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SOP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.750 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:61.375 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 1 of 5 4.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $570.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 37.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:37.250 5.1 SH500 SH500 VINYL WINGUARD IMP Ordered:1 List Price $345.00 Location: Size:17.750W x 37.250H Configuration:Equal Lite Frame color:White Frame type:Flange Sash Outboard Color:Solar Ban 7OXL Fixed Outboard Color:Solar Ban 7OXL Outboard Color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer Color:Clear Sash Inboard Color:Clear Fixed Inboard Color:Clear Inboard color:Clear Colonial style:No Colonial What kind:Sweep Latch How many locks:One Lock Screen type:18x16 Charcoal FPA#:FL239 Actual DLO width::0 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Width:17.750 Custom Size DLO Height:37.250 6.1 FD555 FRENCH DOOR SERIES 555 Ordered:3 List Price $3,527.00 Location: Unit Configuration:XX Door Type:Out-Swing Door Size:Custom Size Opening Width:72 Opening Height:79.75 Actual Door Size:71 314 x 79 1/2 Assembled Width:71.750 AssembledHeight:79.500 Hinge Side:Left(right hand hinged on the left) Active Panel Side:Active Right Panel/Inactive Left Panel Send Hardware:Yes Inactive Hardware Prep:Yes Hardware Style:Series 800 Hardware Color:Satin Nickel Send Inactive Hardware:Yes Frame Color:White GlassType: 1 3/16"(3/16 Tmp-5/8 air-5/16 NA PVB) Glass Color:Clear Glass Color:Clear Argon Gas:Yes Low-E:PPG Solarban 7OXL Threshold Options:1 3/8"Exterior Threshold Send Unit KD'd:Yes Grid Style:No Grid Which NOA:13-0815.03(Expires 1/23/2019) AnchorageType:1/4"Elco Aggre-Gator Certification Type:Miami-Dade NOA(in HVHZ) Door Glass Type:"1 3/16""(3/16 Tmp-5/8-air- 5/16 NA PVB)" Door NegativeDesignPressure:70.0000 Door PositiveDesignPressure:70.0000 Door TestN umber:FTL-7339&7371 Door CondResistance:61.0000 Door Energy Star:Qualified in all 50 States Door SHGC:0.1700 Door UF:0.3000 Door VT:0.3600 Door VTCOG:0.6300 7.1 HS51OVWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 2 of 5 SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 8.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LlG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 9.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,033.00 Location: Size:54.375W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:54.375 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size OLO Height:49.250 — HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,033.00 Location: Size:54.375W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:54.375 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 - 11.1 H5510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page3of5 12.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 13.1 HS51O VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 14.1 AR520AR520 VINYL WINGUARD Ordered:3 List Price $719.00 Location: Frame Color:White Frame Type:Range Symmetric code:HX 1 Lite Glass Type:7/8"LI G(3/16 Ann-3/8 air-5/16 Ann/Ann Lami) Outboard color:Solar Ban 7OXL Interlayer color:Clear Inboard color:Clear Calculated+:80.00 Calculated-:80.00 FPA#:FL5012 Certification#:190-701 &232 Certification Requirements:AAMA DLO Width:22.750 DLO Height:22.750 Total Products Ordered AR520:3 FD555:3 HS51O:11 SH500:1 - TOTAL LIST AMOUNT: $23748.00 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 4 of 5 :" ' . . , ' :: F - It 4 / p -' 1, - - -4 J-' - -. - - ; ':, '— ' ' - ' -- - ' ° .'- - -. -- - W- - - r" •c - • ___ - ___ ____ 411 .. _ - ________ - : c- - . , - r- . . - - I - - - - - . - •- --'---'.-, - -. -• . ---- .. -. - - 1 1 I = Z4J I - . . - - J - ' '- '6 - --i W -' . ' - —'-- ' - - - - t- -'' '- ' r . .• .... . I'-J.. F ' - -v-v.— .. ,— - 4 — .- - & ' bç- t:- ' - " ' - w • - - - -4 I, '- '\ç•. l - •• •• • ' - - -' , — - I - - 7 T F I II ? - U ', ' r 4 '' .- - -' - — { — — I I [_- ' ' . sL_ j. I,.� - I / * V' I , I " * ? VV '1 - ... : : M V V)V V V • V • V U V V V& •V V Pt VV ; : : V •V• Icj— V V V V V V 1- .- •—.---- — 3— I .- 1. I _______ ' V -. . 3 I V : . v ' 'tf' -. S / 4- I ( * — . V V V: V . f • .. $ - .- ' I -V s , . q V V V V V VV V V• V VV, VV -. - V sr,. - . a \ [ - 3I . -; :-\ :-::R:_:._:-- "'i i/1' F .•• • V * . •.. -- r- .. . V - . , r - -- 4* r 411 I I f cJI T & W , Il — . • L I ' Vc — • '. V. . V V V V -V...-. V • 4 *V - . - - r :' . V •V ••V . . —' .. * VV ' — -. -. . \• ., V • -I. . V ; .:V.., VV .: • V - p - ' F T2 k 1 ? H r A - 'l , . .'., -- - . 1. (. . '-- ,-- - - .,. - , r r / J I L r r F F: k / . • 1 : j : • •:; /1' 7 1r - V V - - - * , 4V - -V- - - - V V V V V - V V - :- liii; 1,( 1 V • - -. . 11 ___ ___ V V V ; ' V,V - ' ii ii :: . - I V VV V I :;V : - VNVV_ ;J. ii' I V ' - V ! l V - . -r ,J I V - I - 'V V VVVV?• VV VV V V - V • VV • : V V . V : ; V - - I 3 p * I -- • /' . r \ \\ : v/ I ' /.- I " 7, '\ ti Wb% / ii — — - \ 1:1 p p;:iE / / 1 - J ) - - •Y it 0 i'4 - 4. - 4" I '1 - - I - 4 - I IIII ; : -. - I I & I . ?1i' ' 4 . ., ., AGENDA = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD v � 3* Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program,or activity conducted by the City. Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. MINUTES - None IV. APPROVAL OF AGENDA V. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC VI. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.) Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VII. ACTION ITEMS A. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District Property Owner: William T. Hatcher Authorized Agent: William E. Hatcher Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a contributing structure. B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Owner: Karen B. Galvin Authorized Agent: BNT Services, Impact Windows Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the replacement of windows and doors on a non-contributing property. VIII. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Board Members Staff VII. ADJOURN >4 Wig/ E. ALvc+,re/' Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: February 25, 2015 DELl O 1 1 D W.BEACH F 1993 Ail-Americacity r 2001 SIGN IN SHEET 2001 Historic Preservation Board March 4, 2015 PRINT ADDRESS OR ORGANIZATION ITEM NO. FULL NAME c./!-9/l1 /7/4 7c t1E 4v3 JE / •¢al= /f E 8, LV/i0 9/7 A) 5(x),A14 )4G —� —1) 07, 1e (-17l Avg. Historic Preservat , Board-Voting Sheet VII.A VII.B HPB MEETING HELD: ATTEND 134 SE 1st 411 N. March 4, 2015 Avenue Swinton Ave. COA COA Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to Mike Dutko OM Approve Approve 7-0 7-0 John Miller P Y Y Andrea Sherman P Y Y Price Patton P Y Y Rhonda Sexton P Y Y Ronald Brito P Y Y Angela Budano P Y Y Samuel Spear P Y Y ***with additional conditions added by the Board Adjourned: 7:30PM (1) el OA. AGENDA = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD P 44, 3 Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Regular Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue **RESULTS** The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request.Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Site Plan Review and Appearance Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. MINUTES - None IV. APPROVAL OF AGENDA V. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC VI. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.) Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VII. ACTION ITEMS A. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District Property Owner: William T. Hatcher Authorized Agent: William E. Hatcher Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a contributing structure. (Motion to approve COA,Approved 7-0) B. Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District Property Owner: Karen B. Galvin Authorized Agent: BNT Services, Impact Windows Consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the replacement of windows and doors on a non-contributing property. (Motion to approve COA,Approved 7-0) VIII. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Board Members ❖ Staff VII. ADJOURN — Awty E. liva,reJk Amy E. Alvarez Historic Preservation Planner Posted on: February 25, 2015 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owners: William T. Hatcher Authorized Agent: William E. Hatcher Project Location: 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 File: 2015-090 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The item before the Board is the consideration of a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) associated with the demolition of a contributing dwelling on the property located at 134 SE jst Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.2.6(D). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property consists of Lot 16, Block 70, and is located on the west side of SE 1st Avenue between SE jst Street and SE 2' Street within the Old School Square Historic District. The 13,150 square foot (100'x131'-5"') property contains a contributing, two-story, frame vernacular home built in 1931. The Florida Master Site File survey notes that the structure is associated with the developmental history of the area that occurred during the 1920s. At one point, a boarding house was established on the site which served as a destination for soldiers en route to Miami; a barber shop was located in the south, one-story wing. There are no other COAs on file for the subject property. The subject request is for the demolition of a two-story, contributing residential structure, which historically consisted of three dwelling units/apartments, while only one has remained occupied over the last several years. The historic structure has significantly deteriorated over the.years with dry rot and termite damage to load bearing walls, the foundation, and the wood framing. The attachments include an explanation of the existing conditions. In September 2014, the subject property was cited in violation of Chapter 100.10 (Individually Designated Historic Structures and Structures in Historic Districts) of the Code of Ordinances, which states the following: Structures that are individually designated as historic or are located in historic districts shall be maintained in a secure and attractive manner. All defective structural and decorative elements of such building facades shall be repaired or replaced in a workmanlike manner, to match as closely as possible the original materials and construction of the building. All exterior walls shall have all loose material removed and patching or resurfacing shall be accomplished to match the existing or adjacent surfaces as to materials, color, bond, and joining. All cornices, trim and window frames that are damaged, sagging or otheiwise deteriorated shall be repaired or replaced to be made structurally sound and all exposed materials painted, stained or othe,wise treated in a consistent manner. At its meeting of January 13, 2015, the City's Code Enforcement Board required that the structure come into compliance within 60 days or be fined. The Board Order (see attached) states, "the exterior of this property needs to be restored and preserved." However, during the hearing, the poor condition of the structure was discussed, including the strong possibility that the structure 134 SE 1 Avenue:COA 2015-090 HPB Meetnq March 4,2015 Page 2of5 would be demolished. Subsequently, the subject COA request to demolish the historic structure was submitted. On February 3, 2015, City Staff including the Historic Preservation Planner and Chief Building Official (CBO) met both the property owner and contractor at the site to review the conditions. Due to the structural insecurity and unsoundness of the building, the Chief Building Official declared it an "Unsafe Structure". The subject COA is now before the Board for consideration. LDR SECTION 4.5.1 ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 2.4.6(H)(5), Prior to approval, a finding must be made that any Certificate of Appropriateness which is to be approved is consistent with Historic Preservation purposes pursuant to Objective A-4 of the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and specifically with provisions of Section 4.5.1, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretaiy of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. LDR Section 4.5.1 (E) Development Standards: All new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Deiray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. (E)(7) Demolition: Demolition of historic or archaeological sites, or buildings, structures, improvements and appurtenances within historic districts shall be regulated by the Historic Preservation Board in the manner described in Section 4.5.1(F). Demolition of any structure, whether contributing or non-contributing, shall not occur until a building permit has been issued for the HPB approved redevelopment. All structures approved for demolition and awaiting issuance of a building permit for the redevelopment shall be maintained in a manner similar to that in which it existed at time of application unless the Chief Building Official determines that an unsafe building condition exists in accordance with Section 4.5.1(G). STAFF COMMENT: The subject request is for the demolition of a contributing structure; however, the redevelopment plans for the lot have not been submitted, nor has a waiver been requested to permit the demolition prior to the issuance of a permit for the redevelopment. Therefore, it is suggested that, if the Board opts to approve the demolition request, then a condition of approval be added to further ensure that the demolition shall not take place until the redevelopment of the site has been approved by the Board and issued a permit. (F) Restrictions on Demolitions: No structure within a Historic District or on a Historic Site shall be demolished without first receiving a Certificate of Appropriateness pursuant to Section 2.4.6(H). The Historic Preservation Board shall be guided by the following in considering such a request. (1) The Historic Preservation Board upon a request for demolition by a property owner, shall consider the following guidelines in evaluating applications for a certificate of appropriateness for demolition of designated historic sites, historic interiors, or buildings, structures, or appurtenances within designated historic districts; (a) Whether the structure is of such interest or quality that it would reasonably fulfill criteria for designation for listing on the national register. 134 SE I1 Avenue;COA 2015-090 HPS Meedna March 4,2015 Page 3 015 (b) Whether the structure is of such design, craftsmanship, or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or economically nonviable expense. (c) Whether the structure is one of the last remaining examples of its kind in the designated historic district within the city. (d) Whether retaining the structure would promote the general welfare of the city by providing an opportunity to study local history, architecture, and design, or by developing an understanding of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage. (e) Whether there are approved plans for immediate reuse of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what effect those plans will have on the surrounding area. STAFF COMMENT: In consideration of the criteria above, the structure was not deemed eligible for individual designation on the National Register, however, it would be eligible as a contributing structure for the listing of the Old School Square Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places. Reproduction of the subject structure could likely be performed, but at a higher expense than a new structure due to differences in building materials and techniques when comparing the replication and the new construction. However, the existing details, scale, and design elements are something to be considered during the review of the redevelopment, should the demolition be approved. Historic structures always help to tell the story of an area, whether its developmental or cultural, both of which the subject structure appears to contribute to, regardless of its deteriorated state. There are not presently any plans for the immediate reuse of the property; it would be ideal for it to be appropriately restored and rehabilitated whether for continued residential use, or for the adaptive reuse to a commercial use. (2) No decision of the Board shall result in undue economic hardship for the property owner. The Board shall determine the existence of such hardship in accordance with the definition of undue economic hardship found in Subsection (H). (3) The Board's refusal to grant a Certificate of Appropriateness requested by a property owner - - for the purpose of demolition will be supported by a written statement describing the public • interest that the Board seeks to preserve. (4) The Board may grant a certificate of appropriateness as requested by a property owner, for demolition which may provide for a delayed effective date. The effective date of the certificate will be determined by the Board based on the relative significance of the structure and the probable time required to arrange a possible alternative to demolition. The Board may delay the demolition of designated historic sites and contributing buildings within historic districts for up to six months while demolition of non-contributing buildings within the historic district may be delayed for up to three months. (5) As a condition of the Certificate of Appropriateness approval for demolition, the Board may require that the applicant take such steps as it deems necessary to preserve the structure requested for demolition including consultation with community groups, public agencies, and interested citizens, recommendations for acquisition of property by public or private bodies, or agencies, and exploration of the possibility of moving one or more structures or other features. (6) The Board may, with the consent of the property owner, request that the owner, at the owner's expense, salvage and preserve specified classes of building materials, architectural details and ornaments, fixtures, and the like for reuse in the restoration of the other historic properties. The Board may, with the consent of the property owner, request that the Delray Beach Historical Society, or the owner, at the owner's expense, record the 134 SE 1 Avenue;COA 2015-090 HPB Meeting March 4,2015 Page4of5 arch itectural details for archival purposes prior to demolition. The recording may include, but shall not be limited to photographs, documents, and scaled architectural drawings to include elevations and floor plans. Two (2) copies of such recordings shall be submitted to the City's Planning and Zoning Department. One (1) to be kept on file and the other to be archived with the Delray Beach Historical Society. At the Board's option, and with the property owner's consent, the Board or the Delray Beach Historical Society may salvage and presei've building materials, architectural details, and ornaments, textures, and the like at their expense, respectively. (7) The owner shall provide the following in formation on his/her application for any contributing structure in a historic district or individually designated historic structure: (a) A certified report from a registered architect or engineer which provides documentation explaining that the building is structurally unsound and is damaged beyond the ability to repair it at a reasonable cost. The report must include photographs to substantiate the damage. (b) A certified report from an engineer, architect, general contractor, or other qualified professional which documents the projected cost of repairing the structure and returning it to a safe and habitable condition. (c) An appraisal of the property in its current condition, its value as vacant land and its potential value as a preseived and restored historic property. (d) Documentation that reasonable efforts have been made to find a suitable alternate location for the structure within the City of Delray Beach to which the contributing/ individually designated historic structure could be safely relocated. STAFF COIVIMENTIANALYSIS: In .accordance with the Subsections above, the Board may grant a demolition delay date in the case that there ars other interested parties who may be able to rehabilitate the structure, or provide an appropriate redevelopment plan. Due the Unsafe Building declaration, the Board may not require that the site be entered, particularly for the purpose of salvage of materials or details. Regarding the documentation of the site, Staff has taken photographs of details on the structure where permitted on the site and from a safe location. However, prior to demolition Staff would request that the landscaping immediately adjacent to the structure be removed first in order to permit Staff to take additional photographs of each elevation prior to the demolition. Further, if the CBO deems it safe, Staff would request the ability to have the demolition crew salvage specific details that are deemed important upon inspection by Staff prior to the demolition. The property owner and contractor (Authorized Agent) have provided documents which strive to meet the required information noted in Subsection (7) above. These documents are attached, and should be considered by the Board in making their findings for the request. (G) Unsafe Buildings: In the event the Chief Building Official determines that any structure within a designated historic site or designated historic district is unsafe pursuant to the applicable Code of Ordinances, the Chief Building Official will immediately notify the Board of his findings. Where appropriate and in accordance with applicable ordinances, the Chief Building Official will attempt to have the structure repaired rather than demolished, and will take into consideration any comments and recommendations by the Board. However, the provisions contained within division (A) of this section shall not apply to the Chief Building Official's declaration that a building is unsafe, nor will the Chief Building Official be precluded from taking whatever steps, as may be required by applicable ordinances to protect the public health and safety of the community. The Board may also endeavor to negotiate with the owner and interested parties, provided such actions do no interfere with procedures in the applicable ordinances. 134 SE 1Avetiue;00A2015-090 HPE Maating March 4,2015 PageS of5 STAFF COMMENT/ANALYSIS: As previously noted, the Chief Building Official (CBO) has "red tagged" the structure, which means that has been deemed unsafe. The CBO has not ordered the demolition of the structure, and is aware of the subject request.A chain link fence and gate run the perimeter of the property, and the gate has been closed to prohibit trespassing. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) for the demolition of the contributing structure at 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, subject to the following conditions: 1. That the demolition not occur until the plans for the redevelopment of the site have been approved by the HPB, and issued a building permit, that a waiver be submitted, reviewed and approved by the HPB to permit the demolition to occur prior to the redevelopment approval and building permit issuance; 2. That the landscaping adjacent to the structure be removed prior to demolition to permit Staff the ability to photograph each elevation of the structure; and, 3. That Staff be given the opportunity, subject to the approval by the Chief Building Official, to select details and architectural features to be salvaged and donated to the Delray Beach Historical Society, or other interested local organization. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-090) for the demolition of the contributing structure at 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative) RECOMMENDATION Board Discretion. Report Prepared by:Amy E. Alvarez, Historic Prese,vation Planner 134 SE 1st Avenue, Old School Square Historic District • . FSE.1st St -. - SE,lst St c S • . It .i / -- - .V. : I 1 ' j. I fr /J till I -1 ' I I i/ // b' / - I I I i I ftII , - V . • - --1 II -.:1 . I I II — • . . II . t I A - I I! i,.. ' II $ -- 4 ii F J p - Ii . . . 1 . II _ .l . / 4, _E .I II 4. ' I C // 1 $ I I - . / 'j V 4Th 1 V lit: - ¼ • -;t - %t ¼ 11 /1 • 4 — - I( I V $ J 1 % .VtI /t c IT1 __ _________ •' 4_L : 7 Z__L —w _ - —'-1-' I -- - - — • - - - • -"- - ? -•'.' ''- .,••, .,_,.• - -J.' tI.1- !-: 1=----- -1 .-,3- I * . i=-! - " '- • • - - - -- -- - --: j'i - I - - E r IJ It J çy - I' '1- ; .• I- ' - - - -.-,- - -----7 Iç1 - - -L - — - - - — -- - — --- - _.f__ -----,ye',. -----..-raaasa.ash..L.._— C'11 . Ot! 1 •- iiL - rir !. - t 1T' iad C ir' j1rjrrji ir 71 • .1: '- 4* ''4d Ed 9.r J ft lv ' - - - Lic.#CGC061503 d CONSTRUCTION & DEVELOPMENT January 15, 2015 Attn:Amy Alvarez City of Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board 100 NW 15t Ave Deiray Beach, FL.33444 Dear Board Member, We have been working with the owner William T. Hatcher on the code violation(14-57832) at 134 SE l Ave in Delray. I have visited and inspected this site for necessary repairs. The Secretary of Interior Standards for Rehabilitation of Historic Preservation for this 1934 home would be impossible to repair due to deteriorated structural sills and beams. In following the preservation guidelines in severity of deterioration, replacement distinctive feature with new feature should match the old design. We have put together a preliminary cost estimate for the repairs. Scope of Work: Shore up the existing house to remove damaged sills and replace with new materials. Remove the existing damaged roof system, including damaged roof coverings and install with new structural beams. Remove areas of supporting frame walls and building walls. Remove damaged floor joist system,and install new with flooring. Demo the rear of property, roof walls, foundation. Re-build with historic-like materials and restore with the same features. Remove wood siding(board on board). It is in our opinion, that this structure should be demolished completely, and the rebuilding cost would be around $328.00 per square foot.Total cost for this location $640,000.00.This will include the design plan, labor and material. Sincerely, LjJfrh William E. Hatcher CGC061503 1020 South Federal Hwy. #102, Delray Beach, FL 33483 561-330-2621 I 561-330-2670 I hatchergc@bellsouth.net John Holt P. E. 925 AZURE AVE WELLINGTON, FL 33414 / 561-358-5432 DATE: Jan 12, 2015 Re: Site Visit/Existing 2 Story Wood Structure Evaluation Owner: William Hatcher Address: 134 S.E. 15t Ave, Delray Beach, Fl Area Calculations: 1,954 s/f To Whom It may Concern, It is in my Professional Opinion after making a site visit that was built in the 1931 that I did notices Mold and Structural problems that may take a lot to repair. And in summary the building should be demolished. It is also my opinion its always less expensive to build new then to remodel an existing building ( unless the building can be saved ) This One has to many Issues to be saved. Here is the List of my Finding: 1. The Wood bearing Walls on the South side of the Building Need a major Construction Repairs and Have Dry Rot. Which is a Major Cost to the Client. 2. Rear of the Building has to be totally Removed and rebuilt with the newest electrical and Mechanical Building Codes. 3. All exterior Wood Siding has to repaired or replaced 4. The Whole roof System must be replaced 5. Mold is see in many areas on the first Level. 6. Exterior Wood framing has Termite Damage And Deflecting in some areas 7. Existing Wood Stairs are Unsafe and Do not meet safety Guidelines 8. Wood Floor Joist Have to be replaced 9. Square foot price for historical could run around$328.00 per sq ft, put reproduction cost at $640,000 making still a heavy burden to the Owner even with state, local and federal grants 10. Please see attached pictures. In the summary, the house having NOT receive proper maintenance over the years and deteriorate beyond repair. If you a further Qn stions please call. John Holt �Z/V. L..}f. f ,• � �.`..szac t r «a ,^� *�7 7 ... 1r " n � 'T�l^ t z& ra ".V.c a r �s a►� l - a.: x 2 -y _:. F - s . < r 3`V , r � / - r ,, r,, .. . ..... . . . • . . • ..--,- - .. . -•----•••••• ",, -•,-- ... --:.•-,.......i k.-.-..,-- ----=-- -;------7F',,.:-- .--=-------- ....- .--7:'-cr — , -.-----...-..— ..,...,,s,---,,,--,--,-,-..„— ..1--, i.— . • - ,. -,4,,,:....--.);77,-,;,.,:,-,,,,. --- ----44,6,-4-:j.7.-N. • .-• ..:--- --:.ttfis - '.'t 2,'.11.'...'".,-"_7.",-,: iif;:`,,:;.`.....,7,-./.. ;'1,-.al.,;;;-- ----*---74=i-..:;,......'""---,.-- .7„.. „....,,,,,,_,..„-'4. ---•-•''''''''..;4-. - --;:t-,F1,'..!,72.,,-"•-• - -,., ••''•- '7''' -;',i.'"5„&„ .•-.'„-,„..---.:;-- '.-.;,,:';i7:7-; -..--.T.,-_,:, • '''.44 '''-: _,,,-- .''' ' -""`-'.1-‘-''' .,,,-- -.:-.. '.•''-';,4 '-' ..;-**-*•-•' '---------:" ' --"*.-tik-,„4,,..-.---.--,-;---,...,_:--------.1---_.1'-'---....--..-,47..,:i ..-• ,-.- -:*';`,1:-.. --.:- -.,,,--7--i4); ' -',"---.,-:;,;_z--ft.;.2:".f..-----"'"' - ' ' - -.i-z-,,-,-4.,::,--.,-•F.,.-,2.--.'''...--14,7-','"---7---7.-i..,--.,.7- . ,-,--- -,,-v.'7,-;;;.N,_..40,..i'--;•- •_-_-•„ 77-'7'-7.7"-_:".". :1:. .,*.f's'''.,---,,,,,-1 . . . . . .., .Y,s•I'''' . '-11:::,\- - • ''-':- ..-` ., ,I\ ,;.."'-' -..t.'-;',..-'...-:,--...-,V"r''''''.,41-...TV:z:::;- %.-:•:-..,,----;1.,'.,-.4.,4-:,..„,77-1.„21,...:.•:,....... 1. 4,„ ., ;.„.,...--,,,:-..,',' -.4....:;,;;- .` :'-''.-- •,i,Vs•:.......,-7 ;-.....s.mtik-wi„Avg....-:,,,,,,,-... ,,', --'-. ..e..15.P,‘-.,-;-..,=' _;:f4;.,...„... --"---. ‘-'4:'''' -• ''.11.• ''','--"'''':::'."..tt' -,.. ,.--'"-ev,.1., ".L.-7..., - 1`.. 'ZI..,....s..,.:_:,--4--ix.',......"2..'. ;'tb.,,,-...,':*%,,,,, 7.,, r*fr,J','", , • •Y.,.. __.)"-.-' 2'1,-4 -,,,-.-271.7.-'Ir.:, ‘,„ -!.,.::,-.,,,,,,,,,,----1?-^. ..,:__-:17---,..,,,,•>.7.:,...7:-... ---.,.".;.----.Ar-7,,-4.4.ill,- '.'-'!.4......1,4... :7'....Jr. - ; .. • - -.. ',.'i. --,:' ;',1;!-'-",....'',.-A-'i!,..-„•- : . . ,...-z-,,,..cf., .',.t.rAt ,. l'..c.,..?....,.... --.•.tottf...-*4.-4,--.7---7e.4.2..y.:...::../.•• '. ''";,-;,.,------''',.. ..,:',..7,A; •-•lifd-'-,!-Vt., -'7--'5-.6", ..,'"'I -'" ''-, -.--ii':,:-0,- ,„-;:',:-..'4.,;-,r'-ii•-';.‘'-;‘,''7..i-•,--1../. -.4-r&-.'11;234...,r7.-,,.,...->:,--*,g,,K4.-...X-..-`,.. ..eV,4ia.,;-"j,'4igq.Tq.----:•,'"".;.;:;:Via.:-ire4.41:4..:!..."'ff.''''...''';;;; ;;'''.-r .#.1:44.5",P4,,..c...ze,,',1,,(•;-':,jejA,,,t,.; „..,,,,,,2+%151 .-...C.k..,,Vrie?,!;:v-,.,-:,;5::;,',..::,. -:,., V.1,-: ',0,:.'"e''.-*;%"?. .„;,•Pb.:4,-;..;, -,,..;4.ii.',-;17..`','-.. :::-`54, -Ar'''4W.4`..:...0•rzr,0,7.1‘'."V,,,..aff,+-t"S‘:-;--1 -:'''':W7..r.-- -'-':,-,.`..,7':::! ,•44.14:...'t'''.-,!.r.1.444.1-:41.-i'"?t,7-'YA''.' 'f.'N':.' '-':74 7;.0 'WL''. .' f:',$•'- '-`44'4.4*. f' ..trtti'''N'."•,,C....,,f..1,•".t.'i:...',.= A Z.{,:ii-,*11.,;;;':'--. .1;7?1;-.;,..rii.:1,2:4%--4.*:_,.'EVI,Ve..''.:':Z.V.:.?:ike ':.,-24.'".' '",. ''.tc:iii. ..-S.t'74..... N...--,.z•-f, ,--. ,-:*.:::=•:'-'1? _ . ,-.-.:,.., .....:- .0, ,,,,,,-,...-.5.,...;..,-2„.,_,...,•,,,g,i?....,.,,,.-...,,v4Avi.,,,I.1-_,..:),,:,-,..):.:::,,..k...,,p._,--m*:‘,,in-„,..„Nit ,,,,,..,..41. ,..,?;,...„.„.,,,,,,,: „,. :-,,,,,,.. ... ,...,:,..,,,, ,,,w...„:„.,,,,,,,,,,:,.1,w- ,,,,..,..•,..lis,,,,,..6:,;;-...,,.,:‘,.5.,,,,:..-:., ,iti-Aosr....04,4;,.,:.„,„,,,,, r.,..:;.,,,-,!-5,..i.,..2.;-:.:,,,-;,,,, ••',4"-'• ;';:.'•'' -.J.;;!,.'",... :1"...ti c;;:345,X4/.1"r•f",;;;11.t4ttrg.,,,';'"4,-ki'-7.1..7.;:-..-.•:,i;-,-:". •:'.14.!:-`;.31).;,,,r,,,AX.„..,itkAel;)1144,!4';...0:: '-.'t.X,e';',1.'iZe..;;;;:y; r-v--,---.1%.:Th-Ttt,?‘ 14.4.,.t..„.,,ps.--• ,.- 1. •.• ?,,..d ! aP, ; •'-,•L' 1: "'•":, ''.'k f " .":- .----"___- ,,;•:„.„,...i. -...-7::: - ' -., s • 4"Z:;77_ ".....; ••",'`it, "?`'..!-,,47 - ' - ._.•,',1." ..17 ,..." N ''..c.?"'''s. '41....:',...,;4:'.. .,""-."..". -',.1. ,• • .iii" ...?,k, _...-, ' 4' '-':-;:',."..'*:,,, "• %. • ''',...,...,:-„; ,•••440,'Z'.- 1.,.. . ';" Vr''.' ''''';';•734%,4".... .-4 "-' '";' „ - - <'1 ‘ ,. ' ''' .‘ --""*"*_.r.::,••41,ri..g..„,.:4i.„......1€4...,:2.,. . ..... . _ .. ..• .....,....... ..,:•:„...„.... ...,:...„. ..4..t. „...e. . , ... . ....„_....,.. . ..:, ..., L•,:% ,......t.t..„.:1....,7_,,......,...5,..„ ._.,... .., •.,,,....,04r.i.....;*„......„..,v• ..........,,, ,,t,...‘„,, •• .. ....,...,.:1:„..,...„...,„....e.,....,...„... .„..„. ,..... .,........„,......,...„..„,..,..,...,..,. „,,,,,-..--, ...- .,. . ...., - '4 ' ,, ''''',"c....k..ZA,..,..,„',r..«,;•-":.:TV,zi:2-1-`'` -.Z.L"-.C."Z".''''I''',"?".11N-•- ''' -- ''''''7.f•-r-z-',,,;,:z-4,7•:;\--..",,,.... r --4,Na:„.,..a,,,,,,..arc;,...A.:...,- • , • _ _ ,. ti ` 1 4,_,_ .4„,_, It s : _ .. IN + = _ • i = F • F • _ - 4 ,S 1 • S ' '. -:''''''''-':-* : ----: a '-'1-::1-1-':::---1---t----:--1-- ---''''- '.1-' ' '-'-' F zf _ __� - - _ -- - _I l._ 1 z4 � i ti > �� $7 t, . -:-..:` :. t Argi... ...'`' .:-1 ,-*: 7-1,-,';I.-, .,-- -' 41 : „ : RI _r-' _ ."7"......,-.,;:.. ' = • •' ''' '-_-7---- -.r 7:::_r__777::::_„:,, _..„.„. : ___: ,..a...„.____.,..., ......_ _, :r__ . ,. . _. . ... __ . .,i,e,„7.7.: ___ . ,, „.,.., _._.„„,;;,), ,,...„.„..... . . ....,,,„,.. , ___„____ ..._ .., .. .,. ., 1. 'f,;,_ , ,, , -- - - -.:- - .--,. . --;:- -,._., -------- } t X . `"- V _ 4, s y 0 t - .* sue' , • � f '( F 'tq4 tE _ *S -�, 3 - _,, * __-,_,. -,_ - -\ ,,..c- __-__ ,__- _ ___ o-�' P �4 i 9 w jig- -'r` ''- 3 Yam ` +� !_. - -t M /tom - !r _ k,° i ' ' - - _ r' .3'b.._ �.i�- 1 �1 - / - ! „S . h In � -wrap • - - • �K i• '.a'�a�r Y` - A3; "!• . r; .,, - M ...it... •R a •�t^ -✓ a ,.. `--r,• T.'i'u.-r •r x2� `. ,Nt. r ,g •k,- Vie, •-r0 .t om r�• �'tf`. ._ ,`cy • a �ti+r�e��„a1 :r�3 ,: a vn- : x �r � �-G , s\ 51'7R.w�r_•"�S{Y.��, ln>� •,k " Z ; ''t �-t }. t."' y • ► ••� { * ... ..st ,:�' ,. z°.ill{--...a"....-4 r �a�' i,.- rr ,�l r --1 f .- A. 'I''":'-' = :\ • a,l�• ' a ...- ,_ '3' •••-.. --' �� '141 < Si•7:-...�+ `F� _ • .i.' 3E -,1:;% e`er. ..>o. "" • • • 'ram �4 �w � �y7 `�"7r $ Tim .o:. _q . +Y4- ,t+,. ,� mi #'"- --. Y ,Y:�. _ ,er.0"4 1 1s r ,-� ,,. .,,t h .xi}' o �w- �..1 - • • .1;. - T S .,- l� •a2••• "7-'`._ rr!^ Nam , ^�.Y`a*a: - ! ,F a.-. c 4' } AV-. • ,< • • $ - • +1M� , . � .'7r �� 'k. r- • r r � s as ' a , ' • `ti t.^`- y -- Tr ,- ..s4 �4• ` v 4" `i _:{w.. � m` "y1-y* . F . tJ- . • . . t ;N .:,.�. �qt :7r:;,.•, *Va L t, n a a 4. _ •t � : .�, .`f '''.;}!� y. . • ..*y4i..R"�i$ .�.,y.y4<v %. i -.--.� - -t tZ `-- ti1:e - NvY°. 3.•, -'-'R �` _ y-3-&-`- "/ +cL 43� ` 1. '.rt*r l 4 v. w.i�4\ -G. Y =^.*r 1 -k y �'__ �� -� � �:'``•�� A�s •tiw � ti v : �� =s, r- '-�.. �:,. L•"` a�4 a- -�t,{.� «.,'� -s��- :_.. -.=�' s F4ti'r=T�^C-t -. � � `t -�•cy` �,. •,�..,a `�.��T"• S . ``::``" ,. {Z> --k,-i- ��- ��*�.1 ` `•--�,�. •�a"A �a .,� "�� ;'il� '` � 't., �•..` . :�-it�.�� vt�`�� .}�� :}� • U•t,1t�,`°'t,�aS�- �} ..��-,' Yam.._ :.� ,, ti,. . i ".': -• \ .ems.Z,'tw '+Z• tom--• \ ,.ti'.- i' `��{ R ;~„ •` _,_,o .,, --s ••�` _ '. ' F c;v1-a-> r 'd 0,.a' • y rCr- r�i ♦• }' S � �? �*,.� �:_.,,�a t{::- Z - J =� "sc _b 't'+ Ys - '��,.c W kt�fKtir •� •l � }t� •.'V` �..`£ •-yh.- �� .R;- y,,.`•'-.tr `� t.,4 .S'. -"`,tC - ` '.ter •'' n • '.hq t'' •. `,'�{-+ ! _.,. oN • i \ aL't - ' ' }s ue 'Ix• 4 • i :-.-. fie-] Y`1-.". a,�1� • jT �s•,mot f y ( _ S.:„.,,, �- ��'�•�y �iy • u ,k t` s , { s} xA s • 1 "mow �d �r ��' �„ �`a'R •. � � F-F_s:XX` ��V .o.,yi�` v �� t''• T t��r`t�' T� _i . 7 3 '^* . '-� '+rc '�, fir. -A-•. +• x =�` - v: ^�t: �'—t �M •+�'` 1 }` •- `'tj_ _j ,.� 3 -t- �� { ." j •� �. :�.:iri .�^Gq. ' r `x _4� i{ f ,' l'. 7 trS`y. . Yt �C zZ. 3��'1I... .., - . _ a 1. G 1.^+c`t"i a s 2':.r- .a. . ;•-- t '7� __♦ ',t��a•.:r --. -� v - �s �-� Z. a ',y ",,. ♦ ,., ytr-': f titti ,— , i -' q,� .A �t : r - t- i �-d-' �-1. _. ,mac a-.f•a ,,, .ems „1 e Z y i-r... f ?--,C••--,7 i'� i- { '-'f i� 1, ?T.4.• 4: 4 ->AK-•`r' _r� 'g.;i. �t.'j ` +� 4^ �.,., ` '' w r h .3 T� � X'' �r \ �t :� }� � Pk' l �'s��'� 'tip 'J t " fl z .,.,. y= yy r ,. .4 y��' 4�, s" .� > Y Wi` =y i� i E - , ;, _ — •1 F ,• *i _ r1 x .►'- _s '` p jd T f' ,d' R ± `sL� ` `j.- t\�� , _-, ,Y L ,, • .'Y�,iK,,tv,- ,tt SYy 4 � 7 •.i t , :Y "•►s. '� rry .4� gib^ •. � � • 1 - 1' -�'j,l� ♦-•'` - • '�yy 77 � fit'?�� tU % `t l'- `� ..��` z ��Aj�� : 4 'a. • a_ `!'`' ` r1►�pt. r am 45,1f .i.`T,,; �. ,, + �2 I1. . - •ti- - @': 4 •i �� ..7p • '• `}} :4'� .1 r a A �. 1�t,rt3rr -'� h"- \ ;A, "'lq -_� ,. ; .._L 1 r `�'!N 2�.t's' •i 1Y. Sc".y, t'.t_Cr - t \,?•"'7`-• A 1� J `.p ''s 1L,� _r .y ,...1. ��i. 4 i• x �}'` rx .s�t -" �',�,;; 1.2'l .. s, 5 - FtY■'} _ r�� \ �:.� Jt ....:.- - N-4-4-Y. ,,,:,:i ....,-..,- -1,..- .-, -..--,_ x -,,,-. ..„ - -.,. „.. Ii _ • .'!?z,�.•�-- _ ` ', ._ t j•.-v°"�S :_ .•.r. • •a'�- .•. � ' '�' ; •, r ‘ 'A -i\�`s;' - •. Y i .� � _-, .. s 't - •'` • *t .'4 \ ; : . .,.Y.}• •{{ '� S • � �-++�,�y. - `:` Iti _ , _ t�� i:w Ate.^q{��• ., �s �a dt�,. fit'- - _ - _ �- _ '► _ i `• } cis a C 1.• ;'? n�t r �t^� y 1 ,t 4 " i W. I �tlg" kM 7. ). I( t , k 5_ M • % l .• 0 ' ...? A : ' ,I4 .i'. ; " A '.'0-• f,'r, . .1,- ; �u1`+ . ir, I, 6p �k r.*FZy. / F I,. �p k ,�•' Lk Y "•,XHlelltlln y�glNp�II� i •�1 ? 1, aF �• ',.� M4' �' ▪ jai r re " + i a "I M1 § { „u', 11 A M ,.1 k Alf: • 7 l • I II 6II1 "ddI," ph pia ' �'a' I II "� tl • }p- `..+w aKc J 1w �I p"' 'IPA :n•It 1 _ F "1:,A,*" �Iy1I • .AII + " Ip_ n ''"jlllr�'I�wll�w;. n • _ .• I ..• �� w b',:',,It.,' + IF "�v',.. M ', ..�.Ft • r,• • y v i1 r / k "� A • }" f^i' 1, . tF N. + .. a • • tll R' Mi' •''L •.. .. •sne • •t, w s •,• I • 1 q 1'iY i ii", F, y' , l . k .F ks 't.r. �"s _ -,, 5 w - t s --fill -_______.- _ Aillk;=-1 c�— - .i x/. ti S x.. a x -- _ 1s • _ _ .ram>_a-•- - � _ -- - — __ P� — _ _ - � _ - t C iT - - % x ->�_ _• # _ yad�# �s �- _- -r - - - - -- =- k f ge- - ,- = - yam' { .sue i--"--- = ..-=''''1:5 -7-.7-_`-t--1.ta,,• :-.';',-.•-,:-.-_-=,'Siti;%,.'_,Z, -.1'a -.,H-i--‘' _ _ _ ' 4 - , _ . • • -F • n._.s ..r ,..y- yi i-- t L - - u` •; , - \ram Florida Master � \ Site#8 PB10581 Site�"� _ HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Recorder# Electronic Version 1.1.0 Field Date 3/2/2005 [; File --1 Form Date 3/29/2005 First Site Form Recorded for this Site? No FormNo 200503 Form*=Field Date(YWYMM) .... ................................................ :: ......:GENERAL ilti F`t1RMAllON?...... _... ... _:..:_ _, ....:: ....._::_ .......... ....... ... Site Name(address If none) 134 SE 1 Ave. Multiple Listing(DHR only) Other Names » ___-..�:°:!:'-:_=--_::�..-,_;::�:�_:;`;€i:':;_:,1"=:.:::::...::::_:: :::::__::::;:_s::::::a:::::_ Survey or Project Name Old School Square Historic Resources Survey Survey# L 161 National Register Category Building(s) ._:.._�:...-...LOCATIO:N.&:1DENT(FIc Tt('�N ...:......... ._. , ._�:. ....:...`.. ..:... Address Street No. Direction Street Name Street Type Direction Suffix 13-4 SS 1 Avenue Cross Streets(nearest/between) sE 2/SE 1 streets City I Town(within 3 miles) Delray Beach In Current City Limits? YES County Palm Beach TaxParcel#(s) 12-43-46-16-01-070-0150 Subdivision Name Map of Town of Linton Block Lot Ownership Private Individual Name of Public Tract(e.g.,park) old school square Route to(especially if no street address) ..MAPPING..._ .................. .... .:..... .: ...:..... ....:.. . .. . ::,. USGS7.5 Map Name Publication Date »i1 €,'RAY BBAG`fir_I:`fl�fr= F__;=:::-'2;M ,...---��::_-:=_.� � __ .:.._.._.......--- Township: Range: Section: 114 section: >> ?L6S_:-f S`:.-a ' tgfgP _=«= Irregular Section Name: Landgrant UTM:Zone Easting Northing Plat or Other Map(map's name,location) Style Frame Vernacular Other Style Exterior Plan L-shaped Other Exterior Plan Number of Stories 2 Structural System(s) >> t -tiid'?' eu= ^r, i Other Structural System(s) Foundation Type(s) + 0 =-gar'- ,-a� `.. Other Foundation Types Foundation Material(s) » Mean-15if5-4i....................................... Other Foundation Material(s) ExteriorFabric(s) » `: _.. ;_-. I:V-; °l ;cgs a 1 Other Exterior Fabric(s) Roof Type(s) >> 'ei la` � xI B-l.w w gi$gWW,g, Other Roof Type(s) Roof Material(s) » SYag£;5i`satalsCaridiugis`aal; Other Roof Material(s) tee::: Roof Secondary Structure(s)(dormers etc) »; i::z r, sss:=:i?sr ei it:= =:.i!i ii-:.;;:_ Other Roof Secondary Structure(s) Number of Chimneys Chimney Material . Other Chimney Material(s) Chimney Location(s) Page 1 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB1O581 . ......... ... ::.:... ...i.... _....:..:DESCR..... (eoritifiliti ...... ..---.. ..... _ _... Y Window Descriptions Jalousie, Others are obscured by closed shutters. Main Entrance Description(stylistic details) A parking pad adjacent to the stoop leads to the enclosed porch. Porches: #open #closed 1 #incised Location(s) Facade Porch Roof Types(s) Shed Exterior Ornament Cornerboards, exposed rafter tails, board-and'-batten shutters Interior Plan Unknown Other Interior Plan Condition Deteriorated Structure Surroundin s • Commercial:SOME of this category Residential: SOME of this category Institutional: - Undeveloped: Ancillary Features(Number I type of outbuildings,major landscape features) Archaeological Remains(describe): None If archaeological remains are present,was an Archaeological Site Form completed? NO Narrative Description(optional) ....R'Y ;_ Construction year 1924 Architect(last name first): Builder(last name first): Changes in Liiatiiiiii-Of Conditions Type of Change Year of Change Date Change Noted Description of Changes i. -Y-......_.._.._F:c.rJ�l:..r??_^L5e: 7.aI7'^9':il:i�i�'.Ei�i uM:L-�=_.__ _._. i`Rya`'• _ .:�r3�16?.�ro .:r_:�v,?��.;�.r Structure Use Histo . Use Year Use Started Year Use Ended » :alvatsfarie: r:2'%W= )m?z Other Structure Uses Ownership History(especially original owner,dates,profession,etc.) • ,. RESEARC T METHODS_ Research Methods >> Sa?iliiirn Nape q T''-=1=W`r ' -`_- Other research methods .._..... . .. SF1R :EXp.R._SEALUTI.O..OF S1 :E.: :....__ Potentially Eligible for a Local Register? NO Name of Local Register if Eligible Idividually Eligible for National Register? NO Potential Contributor to NR District? YES Area(s)of historical significance » A' cl - e u S:: !':_ rt,:r =,i` r. Other Historical Associations Old School Square Historic Arts District Explanation of Evaluation(required) This building does not warrant individual local designation or NRHP listing due to its poor condition, but it does contribute to the district as a representative example of domestic architecture from the district's period of significance. Page 2 of 3 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM 8PB10581 OCUPinmNTATION: Photos kt a etc)_._ .... ' : Photographic Negatives or Other Collections Not Filed with FMSF,Including Field Notes,Plans,other Important Documents. Document type: Maintaining Organization: File or Accession#: Descriptive Information: .,::dsi___=_ ;,-._E.-..r::_--y:-=------::° :: .:___�::i;...a, :F---i:• !z�-:_:� z'z_a_9a__:a.:=°i_;:[;:r-ca�ot;!r,? ,_.---'--':_:_`:a:-_:_-::_ -- ,...._ ...._.. „ra ._:._ _ ^ , tee, ar-.F:,-. �,cass�s;� ,-- -„ ----- - - .i.Cf),F bER..[( E...... AT(ON Recorder Name(Last,First) Hyland, Mattew; Tuk, Jared Recorder Address!Phone 618 East South Street, Orlando, Florida, 32801 407.423.8398 Recorder Affiliation GAT Consultants - SE Other Affiliation Is a Text-Only Supplement File Attached(Surveyor Only)? NO .. `r. 1--,0 tw -._.z ". ni 4%- '_` i ST 1T : l"E,,,u- V.CPlfi ,t ," : ;'' s - 4- -t° --- a 4-2 EEP a',� 10 ' -dw FF 'SHPO's Evaluation of Resource r . C"utfuriliR4tuic 0Te&Ma. 6_A're m� _ = • -!, ?0E,I;y P-3-Ideg- z s Efectronla orm )s � a.-�F.g1P5:0_• -,•.•-t . --=-•- .�;.iP- - --=',.j=.<, Date _ t._.... ,_,_ :,k..q+:4._ .__:,.-.• .,-.,!,:a,•-•;:_5t�: @.e=ea,'; s I4ii_ a._:-,PL•7.ra:-=i- _.z r '4 . .. �r.2. .. _.. ....gym.. _- �"1.._.ura_ d=t__.... a ez,-�•-.,e:n_:::_7:,.;-;.�.:..i__:.. �, . - ... Form _ -r'Oder�zo x _... - _-., .._._ . _... ., :: _ 'c ....r.....r..._..,.or. -4......,� 7!iCSx' -_.._•�:::c:rs�._.. __:;:: ... .,..•..,_a _,-._...1.._._.�.._.......c ._ _ ..., . ,r'£I::_'_.. ..._a..c-. �=i:,:x._r�-v._r,S _-.___;i_ra :: -__ ___ - ..`,__..:._..�, �''vL"'_e'.i':�_: _i_'iii: ;"-..::i:".i��:•,!:'-_ �_F3_Ec_,r.: _:. -r —. .::ti, .. -S1 4eh.._�...,,,-ta Sn_.x-._i a. .. _ - -.:a:i eii-- - -_ :i i i! _:t.._..g_ .:::_.�- �v...,•u Buz,.:ccc'-=E.;�:,�eveS�:EFS= '::=c i;ia._ ��fi='::_r.,r.,'-:,;:._..._......,_"v- _...._. �_-:=;F'orrrr°t�uality-Rankfn __- -_- - ca-r-�xs ---'— .. =r --,caSkr_.-..____.t.. v.m.�u.c .,�.un.. �' -F_..._. .._..... cc=i'�# rJ�c.� � 517.`:�aL: � _____ _ ___ ....................... __ r-_.2 - m a d.Lci _:,Y,r'r .•Yr - _ — die :_i?;'ir�f=E,1 _ Q!..Q�1A' - - :nl.�. xv:J'�,-' a.'._.�e.-aoos ?E9��L1 z��L�..c=5:=i� :c��_-...._......_._�Form tatus ade< .. R _�f ;1, , _ {::i_ei ,a , = .LT4 FERN_•a ==m - :�___::::,: x_._G.��:� :s gal. 7 r s=--- - -...._... •-'•---�...._. __..------=------•--_..__ , �_._�Wit._� ems.-��r ,;'°'s,_. _ t _......_;'�=_.::::=s��_=-� �b-ti-.. _- c i:� ,:,•r.--'--� a _:nrccc ... ac..` ate-. - �' " .▪{`r'y�P.PEE c14 'C-'S cAr cT=--TF:gi a'E':-_€ €c if l ... - - mrc�°n:_ _;._:c.....__cs x.a .r.� cnc� =dam er3!a u,_;{: ��=cocc,_�'=:=___?"::!?.,,la�:c.r.:n�,. _ :.,g,:r. i!F°�cii@i.^.fia�3'x,L�.'.I lI°^�-g'E'vi9:.�!13�:f:�a•a'S _ _. �vu.. _ _ ___ ____ __; - _-:, • .....__.. .F..... ..--::-c3'' er.a7r £ -'.u{�'aK1°' -- '=c s. °h'1,::te!.�''�,,,,t1.c_rrnSr_ - r ram- ,u...b "-___..or'u�e...;..n,._.="G=-_'x.-...rs_.-......... .3i'.;'CawL.zc- -.. ... _� �..en..__-<:-•�-o ��. .::_ .. ks! _ - .. ._.._.._ is- • _3r'r�- r,pc.rvv,•, "1" �5,.: :.v- .t_._.,_a,ay:°.ii:::�s __r. -_ -,f•'...._-. .�.,.n, vT.o.a.,,-c;.. - _ •� .w,au:,ryn .:..........:�eil_jl:_=_�I:_�i3ii�"_h4_. __ �.._. :c�� , ..__e-- ,.,r� - .._ =" ..:,3..ffi�"cc' v-mr-„_rl_.i9" ,•„r�:mz�v:cr._.'r:�: :;.. :__..: .Suppgme►r}in or ILM!"-n Tatu� r ' up .__..._--...--Z:r tii4I:.�.,b �l= EMSF afferk - -- �- _�= -- - -�-�' ----�--, R'--- - ti=,_�� • �:�:�., =-- �:-„ -:-Sri _ .�.�-' •-ir"' ='SUpP14 eitt FI, Stetui rcr PP,,RTi$2 2J tf't. � • ai" : cc _'_ er6Efif Date 0�2044:0 �qr _= =Ac; ii •sw u- # .- — _ - - :....� � v LS � 8 ==�•r__ma-r`se=nr- .._-..�=e �,.,:'-,.`F_..tid:��j4 _ _.a.+.e:•� .wm-os.�__ ___ .-_ ______ _ __ .:�� -_ 19x'Ss r_ kY'•rri v '6`n �`r---:.r�.5�.•r.:`�7 iu.s°:..=��r- e-eynr ._�a —.. 'r:��.'c�I •��i`F''F:�-;o��.>r ..,:i-c,i:_i r: ,=i A!:: .': - .3._.IK-=P*61.Fr'iia w' a _ T - _.�f:... ,.tie ?'` _:::=ii-,- _ -_ - :..- i _,_,, .., z •,,,i'_-,Et, -. r �:. @'. F `a m.4,cur ".., _ --__.-, FTa -- : sti.ra i=s . . - . �._.._.-..,.:, ram-s !f,w.ia�,._� __: - �.zru 1-r»•-. i . ..-. ..,. �':. '-(��'T��m�7�,�It,> _.__.. •'l'#,-::!'.Cs F.d:?^.:.r- _. .n s?�°, --;t.:+,-- • �'Y ,-+4! �eEt its' -_ -_ _..�T..'.-:- _— _.-• y,-�.r=f`e't!.__�}::c=�,.,r7== .._... .. t•n��:�:;�,3:,��-`F�='��::,,e�°a:a=- _-r-:,:.,�:p 4 ., -,-_.- t ``_ • .a.:d:!T��_ c df �p�;N�°.,�..e,�a, ,- 4 E` �� •t3 x:�s._ � � . :w:�:,�'�r ` -s. �- _;.:".r . - ..: rz • • (1)USGS 7 5,,MAP WITH STRUCTURE PINPOINTED IN REEL REQUIRED .:.. ...- ..:r._. PAPEF? (2) LARGE SCALE STREET-OR PLAT MAP ;.._ ATTACHMENTS (3)_PHOTO OF;MAIN FACADE 8&W,AT LEAST 3"X5" Page 3 of 3 PB10581-200503 Supplementary Printout > USGS map name/year of publication or revision: DELRAY BEACH;1986 > Township/Range/Section/Qtr: 46S;43E;16;UNSP > Structural system(s): Wood frame > Foundation types: Piers > Foundation materials: Concrete Block > Exterior fabrics: Siding-drop Shingles-asbestos > Roof types: . Gable. > Roof materials: • Sheet metal:standing seam > Roof secondary structures(dormers etc): > Change status/year changed/date noted/nature: > Original, intermediate, present uses/year startedlyear ended: Private residence;1924; > Research methods: Sanborn maps Pedestrian Examine local property records Library research-local Plat map > Area(s) of historical significance: Architecture Community planning&development > Repositories:Collection/Housed/Accession#/Describe > [Other name(s)]: Page 1 Of 1 . I. • • i : pg /65 t/. . • • i • •• • - • - . , ' AO SEC. . _ i • • - . • 1.1 . •:i 4' -' FY • 2:--il .5.T, -6; ..-: 46.74 M.50' -(..1 ' . t .- -"‘ ('-' ..1 ___,7_ 1 oiler-j!P c`f)' ' • •-----4 - t‘..41.1.-- —0- ii .7, .'.w. .4....: .:. _ ,f it • e, .5_=,,,_ -k . , ‘3-)"N : LI . eli. .... e,... ie. t•-........1 . 4_20 -.,. „. .. . , . •, r s , • . . ..21,41 p.j ,_. 6 , __ • • r. jitzt 1, gat ��{ :d . �'� '" •:'♦ a � .t': 4a ,-."""77.11„J..if S�•_&_ Jsu SO ►'7 ,, 0.0.3„�'P- y 9` • ,r „c _ ,.r 4 .fir ii 71a3 23.95 ,. s� '7t s A — .4. . 19/'d e Ift it ,.'le ON. I-- t- -1-- 4 co: I ;I. , tz__,. St 1,... . ..::. t'" . ; . . . • . • r c- ,...., . ,, . ,_ . , ,(ntaiii‘voslroid,',•-rdh, ----i•- _ . • . /tea: • r--4 kZ fi ••c...ile 1.4 . .,.. , . litlit 17.'• it c. e p F . e oi) • • F- ,t I L . -tom - Amur 640.40 YE '•co '-'9•.& . xisr "� _• -e o 1°° /� z2 t Q! m 5 �t N 9- ,..• •• •IrT ; ',.::•r . . B ; RAILROAD £ ti • ti 4A 11707P739� • t'•'S`' s•c 2Z1 ',NI , L . L Page 1 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# 8PB10581 Original FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Recorder# 351 Update ❑ Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forme for detailed instructions Recorder Date 11/2001 Site Name 134 SE 1st Avenue Other Names None j14 5 71 1 5 Project Name City of Delray Beach Historic Resources Survey,Phase II Historic Contexts Boom Times National Register Category Building ' �r'ibn.�'i 5 if '��'hry Ja•anin4 t �•,p` , 4 i 8 � E. 1 Ater. ,,,.�i a- 'r' ;' _ '�- .V,Vrt` '° 1 £ .•;F!!G-t n, " 1 r 1 ,�yy1;�yS{p r 7 5��',P `,�-� �,�, •a, ,r t?}� r �'' '��l 4r�flt r._ .- � �� hm't:d�Ca .1.;!� �wF�.�-�i°c��4�;fn'�� Address 134 SE 1st Avenue Vicinity of West side, between SE 1st Street and SE 2nd Street City Delray Beach County Palm Beach Ownership Private Subdivision Block# Lot# ;'ri. - r ��, y. ' ..:y •9 l..• Ay..jr HM'�, rjAj.I. .1,firl• 4A t: w:q• t � :r`� �: .�KJ.i�` • ." •� ".`w=l .. �`r+w-c €<n. ��I,�� t dY'.-.e..,A!�ip"w. _ .'h'�,�j°`;i:;3., ;��i"4j`�i•. USGS Map Delray Beach 1962 PR 1969&1973 Township46S Range 43E g Section 16 Quarter SW Qtr Qtr NW Irregular Section ❑ UTM Zone 17 Easting 0592496 Northing 2926814 Land Grant Unknown Latitude N/A Longitude N/A Plat or Other Map Aerials n�:. r year upe r 1 B k . `�i 411, y ��r u le 4 rat ''r ,- 'r,nr41,; 0.,. .:.1 i ?•..N.,s!..f 1 c..0:-- MM +.t;'? alyet rk M,etl:7•.e;F: .._ 3 , ' +3 :tir ..n�Yr•F _ ,. ,i;en ti f c;i�`,! �v! ��J•.?c4„'''4 Architect/Builder Unknown Construction Date . 1924 Circa ❑ Alterations © Date 1988 Type Windows boarded Additions © Date 1946; 1950 Type Room addition;Screen porch addition Moved El Original Location N/A Original Use(s) Private Residence Present Use(s) Private Residence ��, �1-��f•�#r��"r��t`� i"�Ytut��f��,{.{L4yw 1 n� :"�Y.sv. '• ��''��,,, �=,.,? £f�'''�','�'T�'``�:�' 1,�a" - �j�n }si�sz 4. `i r'`•,- „ I FfYr.i�w P 4.l.{,.?' :aaak r-.�r--, r,"•+`1'rt�`V`{ "`>w I 1 +.�� *WPI ? 4 I"q.�f ir,{ .�'-, "e43 .y-!^I P IO l�� * � w �"6i,�_�z_ �='t�A��lb'S:,�t=t'.MO�-:dik rY�'��"l��i,',.u „�,�*i '�.d�1�`_ „v,,,'� 4 Style Frame Vernacular Exterior Plan Irregular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 2 Structural System Wood Frame Exterior Fabric Drop Siding,Asbestos Siding Foundation Slab Foundation Materials Concrete Foundation Infill N/A No. of Porches 1 Locations/Features N/second story/covered entry stoop Dormers ❑ Number/Location N/A Outbldgs. ❑ Number 0 Nature/Location(Describe below) N/A Roof Type Gable,Shed Roofing Materials Composition Roll Secondary Structures ❑ Comments/Location N/A Chimneys ❑ Number 0 Orientation N/A Location N/A Materials N/A Wood Windows © Type Boarded up Light# Unknown Metal Windows ❑ Type N/A Light# N/A Exterior Ornament Rafter Tails,Classical Surround Condition Fair Surroundings Residential,Commercial Narrative(general,interior, landscape,context; 3 lines only) This house has undergone many changes;the porch has been enclosed with metal louvers and concrete walls. The house is set back from the road and features jalousie doors on the north side. Despite the alterations,it still retains the majority of its historic characteristics. Archaeological Remains Present ❑ None Observed FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes,attach) ❑ Printed Monday,May 06,2002 Page 2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# 8PB10581 Consult Guide To Historical Structure Forms for detailed Instructions �?� 'rfk;�4F�1�'�`i�'��,?`� �i� e: mks'+ ,-��,1>.G��F C-..,,,i xEft, '�'(/� j .�,,,,,, ,� s Y, t M"N �Tt tr-,l_it T-U;f' n'F�"Ai};„f-,.,..fi)lt�'y7� ��,§�'.fT�. 1�..,,�i*KiW, ..;��+�F: c'>.lr1WOOW } � '" � illik, t�� +'cGxt"t ,�-,+.�.r �,yF� �- '1hrr� air Eligible for National Register? Yes ❑ No 0 Likely, Need Information ❑ Insufficient Information ❑ Significant as Part of District? Yes 0 No ❑ Likely,Need Information ❑ Insufficient Information ❑ Significant at Local Level? Yes 0 No ❑ Likely, Need Information ❑ Insufficient Information ❑ Areas of Significance Community Planning And Development Summary of Significance This building is associated with the developmental history and exhibits the architectural elements of the Old School Square area during the 1920s.Due to its historical and architectural significance,this building could contribute to the locally listed Old School Square Historic District,when the historic district is re-evaluated and the period of significance is expanded to include later historic resources. DHR USE ONLY OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS DHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER DATE KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY DATE YES NO LOCAL OFFICE }it� --1Hil�= �4'3't- t; 1?,�,�5 a:.�Rx'�i'"�*I� cy 7 w°A�i�i kY}.`!-'S}t r� ,Z��+ .�.. r „" 1 t 3`�- .,�'U�` � t+�y y�.. i�/�T( +ivy{�p�}[ �7 �9gf },qp a w M o..-trS�Y�1.a4..r;': . ; ; ;' ;{ q�� <z)'�r;'f i, .,.1 .. r}r s�`OTWO 'f R4�r N1S 4-'-' 2M f�+4.'�x. _ .','' b'SS FT. � ` Yt. bL�.'��r 4'Y.�j'��'NMl-};n'�7;-.L Research Methods Past sites and surveys search at FMSF,Building Permits,Local and Non-Local Library Research Bibliographic References Delray Beach Historic Sites Survey, 1987;Delray Beach Historic Resources Report,1999 Location of Negatives Janus Research Negative Numbers Roll 2184-25,Exp.21 Facing W `'; �.° ��`' :. a.�f "s_::` ,,J i w " s /',,'?4 io ',i �, y N ..1'- +9 z �i -' ' �t1l r. 'rj,S,y.ta+ +�s. --�M,-rr ,1' ,�s -.` -' �� - .-�:R..11aal nfa � .-_ .. � �t� -��l::i] -uwµ�'r�r.:!!- �' _-u fi •-��- : Recorder Name Susan Daniel,Skye Wheeler,Jennifer Bradley Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH,2935 First Avenue North,St. Petersburg,Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5'MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE,:PREFERABLY B&W,AT LEAST 3x5 • Printed Monday,May 06,2002 ;•iliii!:',':'''. -,.....PiiiiN1': ,,i;:plithci'i'' --i!iiii.lik''. . .,11iiiir:-. ',..!,iiiiii111!!':' ..--q„1046"-tiggr,, ri,,;.1K441',1111 ''' .,:-..i '111;1:11111, ,,,...'• illiilim,.:).i.:.'-,",...' ,:,•:- ii:.:•-•...i,„.....,-,1;;•;1.-.,1":::1'.- .„#i1,1,,,,!!'-', ,.',.i.,'.;!,;?: ii;ji•iliy:11.!••• -i.lioilili...!' 1.1.61,1177I73:,!;!;1111:“'•''•- „.:.,:tiV„i"itil,;','•''' ...,,,.ilf::•11111111114;;:.'' -.,•yli,11111'illir:'. ,"..•4::;tp.i..:1:1,11Y,1011.1:11 .,'!::'!:''' ,,,,,qqii;11',": •:,...::,.0.,111.- r.1:1;:ii,i1;,:i 1,111111.,,. ;.1:1!,1,11;,i.o., ..1,,,i)lillior•.i.,;..,:i.).:,,,,,,,(”- • .„;.;.,0.1..1,,,„ ......„...1,,,,,,,„Ai, . ...,„.) Li .„... , ,,, ,..1,..1.,,,. . •-'-•..•- .1........ „- ...'71ill,11111'.,:::;:—."721111i1P -'..*,-.".;',i.:2'...;::.. •,.'7":"',.i!,11:1111 li::,, :.:1..5.2.11 " -":::::.,,..1'..1,:i•:;-,:;:;....: •4.11 1 ll'!i,1:ri,;". % 4 . ...-.....,•:',V.;;TV.::-. :,.:',,,:l 1 I,i '',i, • *..1.. V11.1..iii.11::, .„..,..."''''''-!11,1,..,li.:44.,• . • . . ...'• . . ..'., • .. 4114 ':. . .. --0.,;.t.•;;.ie.,!:'.'** ..f;:r.1.11? • .' . . ..o..". ' .••• .:. .. , ' • • , , • .- . ., .... . • • :W c '..f.t .• .0" • -..." , : ..:'4.-.9.-.. ':"''z:'...".")'.: '-,..7..:.• •:- : . ',..',.!.:••*e. -"..!- .'•, ....'-.. ;; ....,:...:-•2.'..,:-."!•::1:7;•':i"':- - .. '''..;.)"•i'-liA' '''..- k'': ' •' . ' -,.":' • • - - v '• -1/9 s • • .,i.'.7... .. -1 ,- • "-.. • • • . . •I.... • • • . . • • , •:, • .• • ,EL14111r r.---14,---•••-• ‘' • I • •-: -..-... ... ,, :-.1-'-'"?.-1":;.'.•'.....,,,..•:.• .'.I•,::‘... .; '''''''':::::: ......-•F: -- . ' -....... • .... . •:*5:,,IF.e,...,...,f,••,:%,,,•: . .. , . . _ '•''- '•.',7V.:.t.,.:4:.:::-7...,,;;;;4)3.• -'ii iili ;;::::..:.-.!. .... ,,,:..,.1H c 01111.011 I'M;.... ,,.„,. . . .' 11..i:!811"1111"......." N111111111!!:;!;:!:: •...:::11i111 iljigilr(1.4;:::": ....':•:,`,.., ,,IllilltiVIV:......;,..-. .......4.;!liNl1 I it.,1,1„„,..,,,,,,„.., ............1::-.1.,.,1 I 0,1,r,1,,,„„,,,,. ..,....„,,,,..„,1,i,,,.„, :.. ...''...i.. .::1111111)1 :;....'. . :'.!Cg..111i!IIIIl li'll :i:. ...:; 'l'hlil'IllillL;i:.::::.! ''':-.iSI;IlikIIIP!1,1!.F..11:..WIA:r.::. i:iige,111.4 1 1111110. 11 1 r,,i,,,,,,,,,,f:!!1!1. ...,72,;Tilillplilligallird SE 1ST ST --I • ___ _, i ._- 0 1 _ L. >,‘ 1=1 < [1 1 > 4 V D < 1.— _.t w'ir I t cli z 1 —,/ > i z JIM C•1 ...... § II SI .-- 1.- -:-••• •1 ix CI) F1 1 -,‘ I-' 1 = ci) -- -2 Ili 14 ILI U) jri ----- D „._---r-i----u-- 8PB10581 — [ -Lik Jz — •<.. , J - - / ,. , e . IL l SE 2ND ST Ili k • USGS QUADRANGLE MAP �-�^-ywC. '�'� .Ik .S '��1 'a:r. i` ;oT f I'. . - ' ' r, "�'.j -,..„-- . _ ' `. k .:.,..•...,.... -,i ( .,.• 1 k -s r .. :cx4t" fp`....*2,-,..-,tit..:.„-:-.4--:i, ' Jtia: ,! -, _,r„,ig .;.: rr)f/ , i - i s` i'sr •, ,, a, r ;.1 r �1�. ! ! .it Zf' . �• F,�r-•g1%+ sfT 1 -t"y, Y' w ,i�• .�+"• zt�F �` -•... % T f��l7: l s�1� !> , rt,a � t, i t .vcK3J, zY}/ f j.�_: (j 1'.F. • .fit" ,+. *>i•y(i "�' ♦�,I- "atl--"` .„^ � 'S t{x} djj�l .�'.`',•� ' <;mw 7 I-1 t ''� ::l I 'a j� 4 • • r�„-.+41•1:=S . •• _ §.1.-- 1 a" '.�a�f3�`a-tr..fs ia,i. _ _. 4 i .i 51 %..�'� t �`I _ '' " " _ r .+,. !,, 1 -- �. rov.! ' -'�'. ,Y 11 �I t. . 111 (9 _ ' .-C fl Ir 1 :-'.....-,.'?;:—..---..-1.- •-• r r 1..'.'� " -)*,'�-y-?-- .77 , 1 '-f Al"F." r �1��- gyp' • ,_ + r _ �• � ks `�c ��xS��,7 'r• ,�. ''. t � �' fy` 'Fad.:` f}"-- ;75i.�'�tiii�4 t x�5•;.m i � t i iyC A ; ; ,_'-' t f 7} �` �+.,f 1 two 7 ..Lf S �7 ' q` \ n,•- y,4 �. ie�,;-, ip-y- kT ,y, }0 4,i---,-1 r'f' t ss J• :qi , ,s -f�_ :'•1 � 1 .- .}'y (Y�... t• __ rIS. -� -+` _, � .-s >t u`7 �'ii i iA 'e'44'�i•C"' -. •\ ; 'i- I t C,, T` i� 7 1 t. b c. 'S. /�,, Gi'i 1 -1.-..-• '( — �� - 1. • �-c ' •l 3-. a1 fiSi �4, s• �'1. -! r�. � , .I,.,•�`:��s - �—+'t^; r t' r IP.t • 1 141-`•�` . -' , r�N"'3s' •-• m elt ;s1+ E ,r ,. �: . is 1, �s�• .. 1"r Yr 1 51 s; yp a , X4 - 3'2°. , ,...i - ,t "`" la s • r y,+• �t,•-!!�•'• .i f- �^ ▪ '' .1 +St t ,1-:. -.:1-• '!.. 1 NI ,,_� T..'" c !la a1,T1"l ST YLY X 1 �"'q' - ' ,Y , -° ,o C t 'C• ... u ( ~t.. .�. . i J. 1 t-- ,. l �'r` s:1. .K �'� !:t _t.4 r s �� .- 5. f f 1 r, • ' t •• -� ': e-r o ;.; 5;: _ { i -„s;' ,t t a . H 1i: -r" 1_s, + + -a▪ "4 I.t. t : I .,..n: •y• :' '! '-''1— e4,,jyeiF-4 , —1. }. t 'rt�" y 1 1 t . I' --a-,emu .Fr �, 1 t i ;t I J -Z tat, S`,; 14 f •1 a 3 -., I x I t ,? , - sC - . { •2 iia-- .74y._ 4 .".>. + ,. I1, 1 <:..'r- ;-,. if, 1 ^ - WI' v F_ arvi`1 1• I t _.e f Zr I i Lxi. ; :4jt 44 Kr, 15�'+1t4''-. .1 ..1. S,+'� •{ 'k`` „S- . 1 -: ' , ) d '( , �.�'�: 3. � : �+ `�"•� 1112��1 yr,r -fi j, � /..0 � 1"13. J'�• t +�:�✓•� .ti � ./ . ♦�♦=„ ` #� �. :0, I Y 1�� .''# ' .t 1 1 `ate `� { . t _?; t t r° � .F}•1 4 ?• _+ � . 1 •'� j- +, Y y+- `+ sS _ . ''F 1 - . a-., Ea,a 1ri i! '1: :d ; ,�i�; � ,,.. ...,.•..,„.. ..,R'� l.,,,, '},4, t. ,+.,�; 51-�t•..rc` ja i..,Y..is.s f .ram? f .f . I�1 a E 1 , I + 1,;le�: ' '..' "�. ' ( qx b >• ' -1 T. , I-. fr---"r------:---4."i '-.) . :--- . : -,-_A--,...- MN.: J,,;,.,--4,1 -.:44,v.-.,,a -!•-• I ' t't_- •• <:r • I!!gg 1''�;��;"'` i 1` fit,d' .; ',4�.`��y��pC t ; ix- i} d'• :33'��t`i ih '•2 i . r- c i" E31 'qS Aetia �,bA ,w s .3.4 l .( ..• `�7y5�,�1 ..1-__ a.4. + ? :. -+.'V• M f�4 9 ,; a -', +�+� iti s ors 'tr • ' Bd 1- ' ' 1" .{ , t�� - � 'g,,11.21,i,t;.,c "�'� } y}1-. v� d, ;F l 1 -,� - tf ,b..fk u o.. } ! ,rY1 't• 'I..' ,• ts�+ . M,, t•3' 1 _ ''f,c ! !1 +. Paf q„_ 4 I 1'41 i."-.cl TA` 's�t1 _ 11} . ...... -_•� � r, �''�`,♦�'.1t6.� '?•St a � �.�, 'A`¢ i x-?.T. , ifs�2� I ; 1�.+6$s+�� ,- ?t c .,S� C� J r ,$J1 ►--� ',e 11`.-ss4, -r,- :-.!• `• 1t'�"'i-~ r t -tti !.<!t 1., --fi.L.16 A;' f, r • 1,, „ � �, r-•i .- 1 -, I •r 1 t if -# I G' /1 • 1 i .,1 'iii. • Ir I. t �_ 4 k``li't. tx,. _l. t_ f>> 2 • `tts1, I t 13 M.; Y ti' �,1 , :pj 1`s Y -'� 4 ?' ' .�- +"t� J�!. 9't:,a,.�i } , �;, iir_ 1-.i� I L ih si `"•Iti-.., -�1j:t-:.el � s .•-XY "F' , `'t ,t " w:2 . F i2; G' '#t ... ,- t i _ ty , .., 5 .. f . --": r lI S, yf' - r ,,',Ay.'•.. �r�-r'. r+r i y��. _ ,1�-.s e.... 1 �l:7......_ s .+ �, �-y� _ t� �, . 1-r ' • • -E/. ■ �¢x�, Q.Q. -c'i 1,,r-+' rA t17 . +y j-1 I t 1 .r■ r: C,, !ti K, t •1-.r �, ��jh� J 1'3 �'� �.� ��` d +�t n xq�� ( / Pt • ,, 'S i •■ i ' .,ice e N I mo? cry -4 11 iIF., ,, ti E ,`♦'.+m„,,,- y�.:y•1 '_-.toy .. 1 -4q8• tF { ``c i •". t•?` /� :.of • i' I •-a'1 -1 ri't�-I, = :?t t1.W V....e I r ?_7 y;'S2 I "' .`�• - a gi.t-1.1 :�.: t {2_ t F. i-}.4.t f.•aavtw�l r ` ,Yc-y: i 1, .it , 'fay, I .� , a• rt`t y •`S.2 •,g 4-• . .li t�•}r .1 F .- kt •i. " '1"▪.,lr C'1 ,,. raft! 1 1 `cI '1-' ? • .7•Nr -i 4,,,ti"�" ,•i S,: " ♦t . =..,i,. li � i! 1 'yY4�,- a•ti ^4-. r ` - 1 1 f Zi r , t•t. ♦' Z i K- ▪ ■ •r ! a-3•i ;'`4£ .. - ^.r�, .•1 �' ,1 r 1 ` -, ..'"�' -^ . ,. .. 1 . 1 1 j .1 .�." "' -_ -fir g ,r? i ▪j t • i a t I; .• .t=\t•t ,,- 1 > I "`+c&! '`' ` -"�v�, r �:1"' ` T..ri - 1 � «t`tr q ti 3 f r_••1� ri"/le, t f■ ilk{ T , " / . ` • . b Q .F'-'+C F '''7` •c . r. e -• +t",.' :f f-.I.' 1 r.-.' -tit ■ I,� . ! , ra • •-,r; `-fit,. I F:?'i , '�t 1--•<ti a 1':-.::;.3.- i• fi"- t ��,c3+. .ifi 1 rt! Y 1• C; n• e Ride ., i .� ' 1 ` t a, c' '_„.-"• ., r t_ti:iL ,.. amp;.:_.. . . r• t � 'f.�`• � .-{,nl •• . • _ "� �� t.i riy�-;,T',•' t it 1 1 !� i 1•er�� k tr 1t (1{ % .A r# M ? Spa 1 ; t`'• 1_. _ ,�� 1 J . .I I -- ....•.44e, ■ sf t- ;�b g a; t , 1 : %�._• i s�m,-'�e1� , 1 t 7• - • t s1 ra..Y•u .s,�d..♦1. -/ <. j :.,"1`..!....,,,; � i 11�• � i�1k. �_a; i . -t LO L- -'•�� >Kwllr• ' • ■ I � , •• ++��7.r .'z 1 1, ii;t f tl,.•[.-(a�.1 t .'(■• 1O7'H �. •. ,....„ , .■ I f1� -'',, 1,.-i �.�- 1 � .� oy: ,t I j �e(i*A •t�il,••(i{,;'�,j� - Location of 8PB10581 • ,-. ' sss. I�1 t.'` :';;..E._t',".' a� :+ USGS Quadrangle•Delray Beach Florida (1962 PR 1983) =' .,4 ' �r r --:1 •;.:. r:1_ . 'lt=a.•.....�G r c,Yr �_____ ... . 1 i t; �t I1 Iie :: • i • , i. F 4" v' a I it f� • Iv 'L+ t • t �T• r 1 l •A+Y,• Q•*w}� . �'6�St� �„ '� ,y1 C F l�I i 4 "i/ ' ,eI' A. ti Zh. • ,.:A'�rrC�+1dor `A r <"`I _ '{.,", F. `' �t k �'1" S�; 1 ' <': 1 "'. q�R,y -•••+•'r41t.,.t 1r.. .� y �4C �y �, Q. i • i fs f r s r („»air`3 , 1 a sm r `rV c r ' I ( ! 1.4! lr 1 • • ah f .-" ` \ i" t'" «� Jicx,r>o , `, a ix, :A ,;b a •1 ."=1 L. +n� �, .rya r+ f a w' E { '.., .n --,.. ' a: ` r7 rx' . r. oJ,•r M • , «..S c i «.. h. ... IS:', j J�,7 I�{ J , PI: 1I \ { $/ 1 • r;� r j 41 rir 7 ' as r If'::... A•'7u .«,�.; i di �{<;► +^ 4 rip �' b aa4Gr yw�ij --isj • •'r' nth 3 t I' rx �44 � � ty�k",. �� • i ,rt�i t 9 '�,'*�Wie 7h 44/ iJi tk 3•nr s,�" • ." ,n4r �,� w ti4 �_�_ 4' y��+'e�a.. .� '' i'�v3'£i+ .. ��" f t y, a y. H f///// ,y'`y �uC"A.. p'�..>..N. ti lF t;,"tJ '.� H• a wb"'- a ,r„°tea``.• • tt Jl�r.,;4._._..., i:., 1L8��.,o+rr �!% �k,> r • . ham:r... u= .,F? .'p+t'«f! ..;�:'5. n. • i I 9 S. +Kw k4.+. � j ' r► ' i P.W r , ' �#n Fr.'' A. r S #A. TY« Tw n rr M 1yo / rr t x KUit ,ct r t r"r. r a :� i�r ,ater•"" T '�.`'t'°.46,,,,,F,�1•`�'rF„i �°7 1 .+•, �� 'i3&/l 0. .7fM , s6.'. 'fi :fi., ''•J ,'r r t l .• .F r ``�M``'44 f,;e./'1'f,.y •,. ', "F "•'1-S/l�'y" 11: P a� i'ter: ' r"a'+,"!* ' „ `I'i' t3 .,*- 1r,yy :•f ..'. . ` r r,. T•, 117 I j' c 4�,qr. ji�r�d. ' ` .4+ ¢J r •��>Ikt . " i, r }'^ ?,.« ` , l •� . . . . ., • s a S 1 .Arty Cf M1 f JdJ 1 • xan... .Y.' ^ 1. .+ , x .. .' •S'4�x ti f�,. ,,Nii;' '6 ."r t b Q ' y� i - 4 '' ;� t i ,fi ^{ r' B4- d _ y rb .. c Y t+ sEia K + • � ',i .. it n rc ',,"141" � p'`w.. l� #� rw d t n ' .. t^ E�'^ ...r t �. xa±�"4h:1 �� e pany ;, tatr � i ^4�a,o+r wf • k '- Y ''`a.4 wr+ r1r' "' 2 r h+�a'Eh» rk!*, he ri�-ry r 't,` ' ' a ea �- i ri : �Y ry ,o-r—.a i5xA T. r r I • r CITY OF DELRAY BEACH VIOLATION ADDRES—AND LEGAL - (Petitioner) DESCRIPTION LOCATION: VS 134 SE 1sT AVENUE,DELRAY BEACH FL WILLIAM T HATCHER SUNDY&CROMER AMND PL LTS 15& 16 BLK 70(OLD 134 SE 1sT AVENUE SCHOOL SQUARE HISTORIC DISTRICT),ACCORDING DELRAY BEACH,FL 33444 TO PLAT BOOK 14120 PAGE 1184 OF THE OFFICIAL (Respondent(s)) RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY,FLORIDA PC#12 43 46 16 B4 070 0150 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ORDER CASE NUMBER CEB 14-57832 This cause having come before the Code Enforcement Board for hearing,and,based upon the evidence,the Code Enforcement Board enters the following finding of facts:This property is located in the Old School Square Historic Arts District. The exterior of this property needs to be restored and preserved. Please contact Planning & Zoning Department to schedule a meeting with the Preservation Board at (561)243-7284. Based upon the above findings of fact, the Code Enforcement Board concludes that the Respondent(s) is the violator(s) has been properly noticed,and is responsible for the correction of the following violations of the following violation of City ordinances 7.1.3(A)(1001); 100.10 (A). It is the order of the Code Enforcement Board that the City of Delray Beach has introduced evidence to substantiate the allegations contained on the Violation Notice. The Respondent(s)shall pay a fine of$50.00 per day if violation continues to exist after 60 days from the date of this hearing. c Upon complying,the Respondent(s)shall contact the Code Enforcement Officer who shall inspect the property and verify compliance. If compliance is not achieved,as noted above,it shall constitute a continuing violation with daily fines accruing at the rate noted above and this Order may be recorded in the Public Records of Palm Beach County,Florida. Once recorded,this Order shall constitute a lien against the property upon which the violation exists and against any real or personal property owned by the violator pursuant to Chapter 162,Florida Statutes. The City of Delray Beach may foreclose on any lien which remains unpaid after 3 months. Done and ordered this month 13th day of January,2015. Cod Enfo ement Board,City of Del y Beach,Florida Chairperson Sworn to and subscribed before me this 215t day of January,2015. (451filoatc_ l Public o:......;., DANISE R.CLECKLEY — ----- - ,�i 4 Commission#FF 050762 ;..... : Expires January 3,2018 n o,..... Bonded Tim Troy Fain Insurance 800385.7019 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH February 10,2015 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD A. CALL TO ORDER: The scheduled meeting of the City of Delray Beach Code Enforcement Board on January 13,2015 was called to order in the Council Chambers at City Hall at 100 NW First Avenue,Delray Beach,Florida, at 1:30 PM with the following persons: B. MEMBERS PRESENT: OTHERS PRESENT: David Boone,Chairman f) Code Enforcement Staff Ronald Gilinsky,Co C Cathy Kozol,C.A. Ross Freem. Kevin Homer aft C. MEMBERS NOT PRESENT: j Stanley Brodka 7.;;1Jason Dollard •Z Penny Sugar D. CASES DISMISSED: 14-54488, 14-56531,. 14-56766, 14-57070, 14-57474, 14-57524, 14-57591, 14-57667, 14-57796, 14-57813, 14-57846, 14-57850, 14-57902, 14-57934, 14-57958, 14-57973, 14-57998, 14-57999, 14-58002, 14-58008, 14-58014, 14-58057, 14-58073, 14-58173, 14-58180, 14-58181, 14-58189, 14-58375, 14-58477, 14-58375, 14-58477, 14-58501, 14-58512, 14-58673, 14-58674, 14-58715, 14-58717, 14-58727, 14-58746, 14-58747, 14-58790, 14-58903, 14-58993, 14-59007, 14-59034, 14-59090. 14-59161, 14-59172, 14-59174, 14-59186, 14-59187, 14-59198, 14-59293, 14-59306, 14-59337, 14-59339, 14-54488 E. CASES POSTPONED: 14-57368, 14-58322, 14-58741, 14-58749, 14-59825 F. CASES SCHEDULED AND HEARD: see attached Board Orders G. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: December 9,2015 H. ELECTION OF NEW OFFICERS: Jason Dollard nominated and elected Board Chairman;Kevin Homer nominated and elected Board Co-Chairman. I. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business before the Board,the Chairman declared the meeting adjourned at: 3:25 P.M. BOARD CLERK: Danise R.Cleckley u/ceb/hearing/minutes LegalZone I eLaws I eRegulations I eCases I State of Florida I Florida Statutes I Florida Administrative Code I Florida f CSign In j Sign Up 1=E•-1 Delray Beach Code of Ordinances -: Code Of Ordinances Title 9. General Regulations Chapter 100. Nuisances General Provisions § 100.10. Individually Designated Historic Structures And Structures In Historic Districts Latest version. (A) Structures that are individually designated as historic or are located in historic districts shall be maintained in a secure and attractive manner. All defective structural and decorative elements of such building facades shall be repaired or replaced in a workmanlike manner, to match as closely as possible the original materials and construction of the building. All exterior walls shall have all loose material removed and patching or resurfacing shall be accomplished to match the existing or adjacent surfaces as to materials, color, bond, and joining. All cornices, trim and window frames that are damaged, sagging or otherwise deteriorated shall be repaired or replaced to be made structurally sound and all exposed materials painted, stained or otherwise treated in a consistent manner. (Ord. No. 72-06, § 1, passed 12/5/06) "C �r Irr f,�,",''yrd fwa:i, " I. ,3' c +s { rh. ''' ' � I�IIIII'IIIII I e I I !��II a�� r �p:',N odlbuN°I�"�?' x � 1I�,N .�i�.n, , /I r /'1�1a1 I I •I 4I I H'�1 I � f� II � 1/� �II �t.. 1 a.. ...'.._ . .::......., „..., ,,.„...,.....,,.........„�I dtl �I ,I 0�, �� I' ,II.II� m�4 pi......,,,„,,,„,,, ,!:,,i,,,,,,. o / I , ... G r I ,a r • rr r ..s� tiy y.i h i 1 " I'^N L 1 , iiIii,,;ft,P:'!1,1,,':� ! .pk$ f• • G aA , ,, I r gym I,o f v 41 III I` ;. . a ,I a+� � `�"�� i1 4�� +, ?Ilit rhg1alG'I� � ;� �� .- II • � - 1 , d .. . l �t,l , . ll:a' }4. A li ,. 1,4 ..,,,f ,,,,ill II� ..., ,•,.�,' a ....'� f d N w u t ( f, s r/ 'f l m fa J I , r:1F , l , T.rII F Ir ,'� d.,nh lye tl �'�+ I !' , f p rl 14 , , a 1 Pµ•,W� ,a 1 I4 f 4.� . I . ,/ -!'. rrfJ xpl r� .4 f Ilil 1el yr�arl x Yi iG"�II a*I�o IP ''4.-I"�' •II II I,N�I�I , tl I. l'u it 1 1l 7 :fir�l�^r m III l I ,y�r ."ten '". d �l J • i 1 ,I v r m I a �I'I d�, 71.twsJ ,'�" ( r N III dtl l,i `Lr i l"� r. • 1 P a ''"� N T l i rt,h��'t 'Y' r• r 4.., a - r,'. ' ` t ?. r .x 1 Y r rr 1 yply,, 'k I I I E; �'.fIt d '' 7. AA a. . , r , , • „� r xr,lll n G •„r ' t •o11I I*'r,x II11r1 h;II P „,"III C iF�ii'I q9 ll:lGlllIr PI',��II"i�� : i� f fir , t ' : a r M , p �If I ^' 'e N,I$ . .c.�ek,-r' ,;,,,, .,'d', tl f 111 �qI 1111 I�11��1 ��'� p� i �� M" �I 1 �7�yy_ 4 � � , 1 � :, c 1 ., , r l!11� ?IIr, NI}1 ,,. ,7'' I IM�;..y . t1.., {, �'"..L ' ?b� .,- ''. r ' 1 3r, � L y' �d7. :xll 4.,. ,��".w`}r!� '� I.'a"1�mpyy��Gy(• .f�1'} /�/r ,r� - / ,. r r J 'i ..I^V. 4r1�� rL 'f - t • • I I 4 I d ..N I I � I�r7 ,,,, ,.,1 d I ,ifl N Wi -'k .1 I"',P� II""1'1,.1 r r w ,, ',, - :�d • �,I IIP, NI II IIIIIIIII ,IIIII 1 i11115,:r x;?yllir;�; ',r lllill I'lII,11 pP5,11l' '1 Ni911I 7'gll w i I ll gll'I r,u III IIII III III,'!I,+,14 � I II �" 111;4;l..i 1 III I r",a Nk �I IN ,nr I ,'. I�i11��'N I I I I ��,.n I,,: I IJ,I..,�'III ��'.1""I n�rt�lll" .�'I r p r ,$,::.u,� I�h�I •I��II I I a • ,,,...IL.,^ ;•�' r `1,� II II 1 ra rL A r, Y', IIhM Pnf • ' II l 1,.1y Q rr { '-a N 4',I�'� 1 Ir :�I�f,;ldN�Y "N �, IINF,I n 'r,�" %'r '� • , • . E'. Ip • • J • .w ,,,I tr 9 ,�;�6 • ! .� II II I,�, 1u G q , l4x ,>� T w �r 4 x a l•^in' :w. "r,'' INS„;,• '.I 'r,4 '✓'f" r: . • •f l i _ r • 1 I ;I rr' r! l; " � N l r� I u k �r �u d t- s,�. �'� .' ... � � 1 ��1 a It a Iw, 1 d.J 1 w" 14: f7d IG ,fa .. ra ' R 7 �w� b :' ': 1" 4 1 . d�,:. ,ui�G U1IIINI 'u 1h ,I ' Ft w", •e,'1.. r/•.r 4 r,. . ., IriN11I,I,,Ill 'II,IIIIIIIIII n,'11-./l 1hI1,;;rllif,ilx dr 11�' II Jrm1, 1. I .. :i ryh' GhLLr,I. I L. I I Illhl I 1 ,p"1 1�i:l' gN ldl'I, t,:;J I"I I MI,1:��11 � Ifi'�I I.,rN,�I T ��:,, �6 I. � J.r :,r.! r .r rdi� l'llf! ,'1111a1 N It!Bl1lh IIIII IJ �:1,, 1 gil� :i, dill N;. ,,,,,:I I. „I P.. I',, II h ;:;, 1 hI . fr' J,h �'::^�,I� I,q,N�,I � � IH:�p:.1 .' .I, f�uJ �I� w�'y.q �" nN dr: r "';,:,! 11,,,.r .hI I Ihl IJ.I.,l !.r.„Ii,'7,)INhN1'a J.wll� rol Ij1 ':;N .:•W:�:'I�III r 6p 1";,:.,,,,, �k.,a': 1�,1!,IN �j'' p ;/': ii, j;.., r �• ,� .•..r. '._{ .''r 11 .i�N II1 , .:.•! IIII�GI.,,I IIIN J p I IIIII NI ..:,,IAN.c, ,F.!'M� r x+w� K „r.l .w ` Lr• .'•. , 1• --, ,;� a I ,. II Grl F I I11 J�.i II Pt I 1: II yy uy,� �� I ��K % _ .. N`. ^C 4 .��Nbl6 I� � � � �• �., �. a lx�l��1 4r II?' � I"xnPll `, d 'AX , r:,N +,L'G'�MwJp h Gik. a :..1 r hrl;� v _ t • /e taNr t, nGNPI'I ,q jI �IG:Yu�r*Wa"4-I JP '`:fs w .r Oy� u * ,'p. d t ,:kt ,f�•+'.•,rr •L h""s ,•• �} 0 4,r llllrl ,Y 1 " r lx dal tt I I�r,N illd��d 111 ; 4,! Rw " fK' \. Fz rt�j. t r / • ��'1.. '.' �1� l 1N'�" 'It 11,IN 11,1 hl lli`1 J 1x h�IIrNfiGI N CI I i!,T' N ICJ a.,', r 1. , ... I• 'un,,,x „ P i ..t />' • 'r ,r i l r j.' ..J•. •'Q f 1 � Id il: INI�I 11.6!Plliil It i f r� ' INll �� V �� Ir111,1jll I Gq ��!.I ulhr I. � � 1 � M`r� • I ltltl I f r 111��i6!I11Pin �Il�,•.i.„Itl,;110,i�I,II11hi111 dN IIGl • '' 'III "". .. i ,j I•I I .. • I :.,� II� �, w ,+ a ,� "',•.� `��, Sri �� • /� r„; .I,u1 ,�"I ..r."i d 1 WII! t r�3* 1 ul r•0],•l Itlylrl q/.GI fi IF �i,„ • d rr r F+'..ai_ i to N 4 Ir • • • ..N' 1Fr xs _ . ..•: n yam a :r ..! •o n vallMq�a NrNry p, s f .. ,i% ( g/i4 - r �r r1 a4aN'm ,r„� ,.rr N, I l' r 141n a �I 9 o IN�I ' II I',i 1, ''� �_ �. r a� :. s .m �I�1INI I Il1111 II IIIII l it IIIN ' 1 I .. , .W i�� II ,v M ,VI: �,�.. % • �•.,;• t.>1."0NM r';9',e"r P - 4�♦ r 4v + 1 ��^F -14 µ IIN1L9 I al 14 • 4,,!`... b. w T dll0 .. fN l-• IIkN 'N, '✓Iuw . t n I.� '•,, t ,dam"" tt 1,„ 1 )i 111 1� 1,I . ,. : •.. ''' ° �: a,:l�W':1", I I I r I x".a rl re Pah li!1r Npph'ml I� 'N��A y�r�y1 f N:I� pl N�,I� II N P'p 1I IIINn r,lI I�GI�II N III''�II I,r�ry1011 1tItµIxxryII pIJNI Iikd�I,i1n�' P • Cr• IINa lu Ohl w,k x i :ppr�,�;I il 1 .5j� h l wG tl 1 J" I as r n lrl au'. II '"'�,,'�4,,'r* M 1 ry r I,SY -,.t ,,..,..,, W4.a,I. ,1� ,", Grlrl Ihh,GI IrI,,.d, ' 1 a,,V ll11 j1N1�l.,, r 1„' ,y I I,It!rr hlr'1,N" I µ,N�r,r„„nI 1 Y u ri mmrL n 4 si I,, "mx"'° il1:',,,,I I�!,.II1I6,F'rr66 ,, 1,,„ II:I„, .IM ':F"INII,. , II r �+""fl"?'� N 1J 1 Ir 1'.:: �.+:INI r, IN,,,r:,,, "."',, 1 .. ,d M' IIIII ,,I:I IIII',i I';�VI, I'W�'� r,1dN�1h14'. m4 41,0,1ulI G911 IId.;. eI I"4,i* 4 •Ir ,.,!��,.': r ri a,., Nlp,ld,l�,•oa I�.:��. ;f , yN II a,.1,IIU.I INI�I, Iy. �I „1�I „I�, 19r GII g�,�ld hlpl I 11. 1,�r, ll.al. .11 r. I,1::.a',Ill.l ';I! III 1 r,a'I;.. !„I;IY�x III wlpl �l1.1 P U I:,hlrr:��l III IIII yNul 91 d 1 nr IJ1'I �W " ,,,�, I.. �i �11,1j1'u I,uNM i� , ' 471!•' LI�u Ial4ri 'L ,�,Y"J �n '�..r. Y tli i,i,11''101.I•t.11.;:,,11 "''. :I. :.1Gw^4 x r'.,�,rl NI ,..;, .°,,. i5 "G. I1 1 w ar �J, Nl�lt r I, 11:11�4�p� w ,1:ia:a Y tlu� yr,'+ `$ � a a. Ybl l�" ,, e YI 41t'1ry:dal kW •,4,�uCK r�p'�q 14 m 1 e a', r ph1'µ �� R,' ` .° i ti m , pp rr Illh,�,w ghlliaybrt,q n a' x .C,.�N ' .' '.:': .!M 4 • '.i;..I'�,u" . N' '.G�IVI.l.41w pl dll,,,+u.r..l. u!,ti,l,y�16" .G�,�� '.!,�,q J'�" "N�'",I I,:. I 1 w '��I.._L...._� 1� ° r � ._ .. r _... ... ... ..... 1 , • .„„.• / • , * , , —,.. • gr ... • • .1.- i — ,-. ..- ., ..-' ... , • 1,, .,..-• , ' . ...,,, er . - , 0/1 ,-,,,...•r . '.„. , ,,.... . . .. , ... ,',.1,,I.„,i.';.', ',, ..,ik:,4,-.;,:,....0.,;,..i..,..,-,„. .. .,. ,:. , . : :•.::::::.: .1 i.:.,,k!.,,n,,,,,,:::0:.0....prmin:21:::.r,,,.:.::,,,, , pi,:: .....:,.•v:: ,:,:,... iI.-•,•.•1,!!-••-•N:- rt-2r.r,... .., ...., 1,1)1.10M0MrAIVIIIIIIrMI;r110::::1111050111'Ak:::111"10i::11f 4::i l!',1:1“..: ::::'::::,.:/-,...4.,:7,7.3.*'•' 'f,'.'i,,s• .....1[1.,,,,,,„„,t„„„„,-:40:tmapilplimpmotoitippow41,IlisaA,,,tw,,,:,,,,..„;.:,:,,,,,4;,:.: :,10,•;.',:,.11,°"."1::-., ...,..,,,,',. ,,,,i, :„- „,.-*.'..,:-.. ;•-mt.!:„:!iit:),,l- p„00:!:,, : ,,,, , : , . ;:,,,,,,',,:ahliohloo:opootmigiNimiimilmth.ovp,,,' ,'','.7,;;,i'Aik,,,I...,, 71',•'',1,,,.;'''':,,'''''1,'•11114;414;iii.,',4,4..,,,,i,i,'.,,, ,.e, 4...-,.,: . r ;',:..-.--,...-; ,i, priii 1.,:!•'', ,0, ,, iTI1:1'; 14,4,,,i,LL:J:.!,,'v.r1:1J,IiI,',::11;',,I ,ii,1. ,,141,II,I,:,,,11,,,1,,,,1 l',,I,/„.,e11101!1,11g,11,1.,/,111 ,li111,01!',:,!!,',i,Ii,,,1:::',III:1:1'1:11',1.:11'1,:,:',1,1,!...:, l''f:: :,'.1,1,1,1",1::1'" ,: ,.. ,r;!...'...' . ,-!....:.,,,;„:,,,,,,:;.•,.::',,,F,,,,,,•::,; „„,:,,..1 •4.J',,,,j,,,...jte,, 11101;1111,1 1,1p11,1,',,•4111.1!1,111;1 Ili.,,j1,,I i,,l,r, yl,,,I,,,,,1111,11,,,.,,,I..:,.,,.',:,,,,,,I,1:.,..,,1,,'.,.,.,1"I,,I.:,,''!1,,i ',,'.1',1',;;;;;.'„'.'.'111'1''.'",'''.'.:1'1'1t1''''''.''''. ' ;'' 1 ' : ., : ..-; .-. .; ,...,.,11,./.'.,' ,::11.,,'',,...''"4.1t,k,,.7;..Q,, j:' ' 1 ,: : :,: :::. :!" ': :':' ::'' .' ::::':.' .: .:;. : . : ;;''' : ::. . -."-.7' , ,,,,'1.1'''f',Iir,:k1 ltl'ill',10.'ll'"'I.,'re'.1'1!:'','!''•''''':il:'',M17'''l 11'11,' ::';,'1'[..',1,',',L.''.'.'',' ';1,'....''''.'. ',, ',...'i'' '. ',,'. .'' ';:' ',' . , ,-. . ' „;!• ' -,-,... '' .'' ,...,., •' '',,:'J1,','''le'',';',1,,,,r,,,'ilr:j1:1'il,rlij:[1111ii10,,, 1hlii,'I'rfilt1,11'i'.(1111:11e$IINT'il'I'lj:11j1Illil'1101;11!'ll'''11;1111'11 • . . ....., . 'ij,,,.. , ,,,...," : I. !•••:,::::•i:.':—': '• '; ! • , :, r ,, .. .. , . ,. . •:•' '..,,,,1",74.:•,•*-..•." #,!' . -r111:.::;:::1,::.::.:.::,•1,:,::•:;,,,:,1„::::,::, ::::- :.,.14„,,:........ ".,..,4„,,ii,.:!:::: ;r• ,:.!..;::::;.1,1„;;:::::::::,,,..,-...•::::::::r-4.;:.:,:::...,:..,,,, : ,. . 1 - .-- •71P-'' •- I ' I', ,I; ,.•-",.."'*.--: • . ,, , , i :, : ,::::•::,: i,..:.1.„..,,-::1,1- .::,::::,„!•.:. r •-: ,' . . • • ,r414,-- „..,„ -; -. • , • • .',:.:;,'''•,,' I.!:',,4...::1,:,1,,:,,i7",:,,,,,,:,!::A::::,..,;:r1;11:,!1•11,,;(!,:ilr,,1:::.:,,•.,..„,.!,„,;,:,, ,.. . ..,r, : . • :,,:(#!:rilr: :!I:,4:: ::.,.:..,„,,,li,i:„ „ ,,„,„,,!;:,,,:::[1:,!!:;:: • - f.:;,..!:•;••••!'. :.If4,„,,,,e ., . ,., '- :,:... : -.:f! .o:ii.,: 1.: ..,, ,,,,,111;::,:v1,;!:„iryill;11111,11.:0,1,111,:::,,.,:,,,,,,I, , ::,,,,, . . • . r ss ' ,..4tr :.....", ' i rr•4,r',-"°',.. r.e.f:r." '4'.4..,..'" ",,,,' '.'.,,.'",,.,.. ,1r, ,,,,.'.i''-"'•,' '' ',',, : , .01ii7°.t".7.,:i r.V.,' ... 41 ...r,-;,7'.....',,,,,,. ".,[:1,,,'!,'V 1 I'ilil , 1','' ''r I it i I., ''..,',.' ' ,..0.4';'''. .11,1P..'......,,0V'''''144. 'IA'''41''./11 1V1111:11,1lh 14'illiriliilli'''I'l 1 iii41:',11')'111':11111'''111, •7,'..'''' II' : -Air.,.--„,,,,,,,:,;„•,10,„'''il!,;., ri it.,1 ,.,J.,,,,',,,...11,1[:1',':...';:I,'er1,,,',,',.;:, k '''';4.' '''''''''''' . . ' ' 4 T.'' ..4 r"fiii:'/—'Ili>. '401,..11‘;':' 4',4.i,4401,,',/,'„:::,,,;,,,,,,,',1,-;i',:,111::.L',.,,,..,1,,,,.,',1,„„•,:',::'!,';', '.:,:„::.' . .0, . , Ailk...„,„,,,... ....•f, ,A;00.,,;:p,,,, , ,,,,,,,,,:',,,,,''',,,,.,H,',,,'''',-,',',,,' , ' •-v" 't.i,41040... ,,,,,,,,,,,,,',:,!''.,,,.;',„?.....t. ,„..r.,;',.,-.:,..r..:',.,:'',.. ,r :,,' ', '',.1',, ''' , . . f .' "'''''':'0,n .J,. ,1,,,.,„,1,.,,,. ,rir; ,,,,, I 4.4 10i. ., ', ,, .• "ill,jt,!. 'elll'11,,!11'i' '"t.,,''.'',',1,111''''..1:.1; .11:'',' y.,, .., 9.''',, '. .7, ,r'4:.1 1,.,1' • .4.....111 ',,i''7 i trilif '- ' ...,am•••:•'• ,,1 , i( , ‘,E, 1 '• ''' ''41: 0'. )7 '' '',.' " : -1.1.../, ,.: ,_ .,. ...,.....:,....,. .._.,,..., • :::::7.4----;:----4-4Th---::-L--:-i::-] " Il s , K �C£ • - fl ' 1 • ,lam F!'-_ f • I • _ 5 3 = _iie> � ' •� ,� _ i• ...• " „ ,� �� i i f • ` ,1/4. r_ 14 fi�t. --.. ._,I.-___T_,- ___z„,—_,"4.-------_____7,_,____77_,_ ___Ap _ " 7_ ,, . , ._, _„,,,,,,,,, , __ :_ ,_ ____:,___. (t fit�a /" r°' -i- 1 p' _ •i y. 1 - - _ � -� ." ,._ _. s ��h Af - �` _ - - € _ —If - .£ S fit r f if }FL Lf A _ `Z t !R •.. ram"'-;,� g-' € - F -, . ,ili ta s tea+. `f`+/'S Ewa`. .`s"^�-" 1 __ - f�Q + ��`� r i •± `IJ • .. . Apilit. si _�! • _ r iQ • i t`t ■i1-7 -4- ,:` • 4(1(1��- • I• ) t t. J•— � ' . 4 I• ' _ +i Y 3f-.c.'— { t tee- - R _ - _. f I '•7 lk' "4 i't - - = Y , .... .,.�..... ._ , ...w. 1. +a►� • yr .,y -•row 1 . 1 .. „-• .....ti1..p+.{ j i • t F r,;_ ; :7 H �� , E � v 8 1; . -- ' I ( !0"--.•*— ,.,, »- "mow».._ I t y !• ! r • r r r —K _ .1'h tea. r--+s F, .1 1`L f- ri _ i. _ . .t . • _ 'S; 4 ' _.z4i. y� ,.. tom'+ - ,wa.. , t is ; _ ' _ ice{ 4.. 'F' ea,4 �._� . _ 3a 3 ; __:-.„_, __ ..------ _ ,__,------_ ' t ` ; i 1 - •-- * . z, r - , C. -s ,, Sri 4icir. # _ - 4t _ s �_ � j' __ it II . t 4 __ i/ L • w,,„` • y �_ J•..r i. t = _ _ - -ig # � y{r r :>. ,. + st _ _ f r? r�k d/b'. f[ L it E{ � 411 i .--it'_",. 4_ i.. tR.k 4 �•.. -% 4 1t k f $ff - (d i l •.�.f ( /1 : .r _ £Tz .♦ • �x P 3_ `: ..* i '3;�r ) -, err ,; � 4v AI 1 f - r r },._ _ at i F +1d i t .~� 2 r t - a.-� � i � •,t k.'#' Y �-.'# J )§' }rl ti `s 'F\ �'�l ` / y tj t 4+ ( 1J�' j jig r4. ,r� _- r 4- 5€- r j �I �y �; - it •__'4� ; ♦ + I� Le.' .�2 • - \ 't.�'E } `ki - - + � 1' 3 if ai. >Y' 1 T 1 k• ♦ ,.s t { - i .;.'l • rit k t i -.�- i' - ♦ ;.{#�-�!}-yj�a. _ :�- s j /��.a�� tyl.>�Tt..t..-�� s M r • s. k ',▪ ' e 1 4 ! #�€ ��f{ ry"t _• t-. 1._ J( '',` �7 4�' * �.,'f , I'"7 �eY 4 _•. t _ i J _ k rz }.. �-, { t =,l j� 1 t • •! , 1 .w- x i'i E - r,. r�itg - � r yP-rt.( + � `- ��k{ x' 7.kE' . _ '2 ' \ i S- '!-4 l� .� j, -'`_ l.:_ �,, •F ?t '.-}[i.—... sl c ra t-{ *,. It.. a 11 - ` Oi lhl. 1t 1 a�;EL�� f.r"I .e/ 'i _ kceiil! _r 3 IC�� `'� fXt��e ti_ , ! ,}r3 T � �8i • _4/1.'•.:,--- :... - ▪ - x t I 1` ., -. ,,;� , 1 . ' r sip.`r h j -i T- 't1' -'''A''''` .-'i Ye All k �_� ''• .T 1 t ` i4...„.., ,...,. .�; 1 t_Xth .il� k .'i - p �g ,Z,� .e it E t i y- = 7 ' f'' -1...14_,-!' AttC.rie NI,s, ii!...: _ } vol_,,_ - •c , y q't r•. f \ � f,: .. }1 1.4,-i }. kifA f r - r .t "� J t`1ln �•yr,Pw,,iftw,,-,v,. +♦- ' !ifi ` Vim, � . F i , i\ii _ C i 7 ' l i 4,,jai, 2 A .. `ie'ii •:' ),i t,T4� E } ! • 3- iK t = • _� - 4 ! t -_r a§ _.21,--:-.4!—:;',.-,Y_ -r- -,.,1".__-1.-- tit ' �7 kl# 6 r A ! .r l ..:t ` i it �i_-skt - t ---1li t 'E1 ,1j,1 ,- � f j� i 1st ` y E+nj!`f+" di F—'� ; e 1 Se; k i 1 t I,' j {-. e .,t 7 kr \ ! • } - I1's _ ��=�- - _-1 t t 1 i• y; t , - � �� 1. p.4 ems'..• �.:. k • alli { 1 t[ ' �� ; i• � ' f'fr 7 ! ,V s`l ',4►4 a :>� r'�•1 ,� K,} 1. ` 1+ -y4 e st dt' - -.a' r ,� •• t ter • 4``i k ." ',f, ,41,E ' hri� • t t' _-!a 1 • t #Y # 1f,4it zrij'�k/ .} ,r .1ir,.. Ir xrf+t� { � ,R ,F jf 4• ; 11' r ' r. jai{ ,fib Les .t •' r it 4t -1 t p, I`LIp1 !r' ! £ �_ kii - 3- ��' #'1 4+ MyY , f t,M• I.rsp '{�RSt�t�i4!y, i r `• ,•4J..... r �t I �44g-4 +k' \ r l..'• , �.� 1 �M T� qt. }..r' { '3 - IS f 1 , «f• t .::ji ' d 4� a' I'1y 11 t!4�' Yi 4) � r fk'� +e • �..1{ t t.3;i. �1K r` �. I �' r, i L"a: ,fit 4 �� ' .# ,..1 t,k,.y `�• :41.: 14 • ,, [ lTyy p I # �?I ,,, f i. ;al {1. , . • n 1 i1•. .J•n �'`ri �w • Tit 1. .1�'t r -Z ilk,,J ., . -, Tt ."'" ' ,0 4* • " .. ''‘'',.. " A f. .4, . . ,, . • , ‘" N1.1 1' i 7.....,.t +;.1elio.,.•..., ,‘,,1. , ,.._ � ��-- y' .` 'R` '" s - r:., � j+L s�: '4 - ,sue - r= ,.-" I t • t • fr �h ` i• 4 r �� \ . • i - T h1 ''Fwf 4b {r E `•, I r � i n 7j ,rr , ` t - y o ..� t _ 71 ie • '4 tirl; by n • _ t _ ' _fi _ _ 1 r, • • 4 •- \ •. f • • \`` t ` Lam • .<40, Y y� _ _ _ _a- -��. sa ':. _' -- _ -..t. rf=,,rf r !; `e,--.-r—ri r f r W.r•'! r 1.;— r-: ,r,1 J , :- 4------:' ., - 1-f:• :.t1 f, -*, -.-. - -___, :.,----,11-',.--4_ $ii.--v-J ' ,4-7 -?%„-- )::.--,--. ! � mayy; 1• I l, ..1 1, il,--,,- : ; , '-,,.', - -'---:--,,, I_-_-*--4.,,,r!)-(,' ,-Al-f-r-'--:':7-4.1 1';'t!_,,,,,, -__.:' -- --:' '-'- -----'..:::: L- -; Y_ELF - #1 - _ Y } z- s %cei F -- s t i i` `i' q I __ � ` 13- --_ #e 'i # ir = * �� j _r ' f 1 S3 i t .' € } #-j it. i-.( - . t fff = _ , �t f -.t x - : a- ## %'t 7 11 €'�� 1 r ti fs— - = - r t♦ r--' ! ti f 1.. J # _ -,_ �� y 3t r r . ; . . " 14'Z''''" .';':41''''' '..J'•••'i-,'71`.1":V:1, '-'.4.:-•"1",‘:::''''''1,•;,.....",--''''''''''','••••-'•..4 .....2....u-'4' '".'--•-•.:.7.:-...-r-•! "..,',2.•..,7.••',.-7'''.., '`' ' ,''• '' ,-•-" .. . ' .- .:1.4..."'' p.... :.; 7- ,,., ,"...• •:•, . , 1 ;44:7:•,,,,„•74',7,1,,,,i,11,7,T1nrIVI •.,4•ii,••;r1";"1:1Si,,,,I,j,11,,••,..• .. ,,.,''''' '7,4,.!,-,,,•(:.',.','•..'••• - ••,•";•'":4,,:.-,,-:'••••'•---"',--:•-••'"-,":"-"-• ' '• '-'''" - ' - -• '' ' -;.1" . •( '''') .. . • ' •''''''''''.. •.7 ' "-';'••:' ,,,.rlr,„,,,.„:,;•.4,.,,,,•,1,•„;,,,,..,0,,Itt,,i.1,1,1,,,:,;k•:,'',„4.;11',;1_ ,,,_"-1J,41,•."14;.,44,;„.., , -r,,ti.Z•-ev,' ,•..4,•-„,44.-. '-‘,,..7,,J`..,1•'.:.:;,,i,,..!..-..,;: ..,:. - .:-::::7.,-.. ', ,.......,:.,,,'•-• : :',.. ,,..,. . . .,.-:,. , ,..;:,..-.:.'...., •.:7.,..." '•.it. .'lc,•:•,"...r....... ' :7„4/'00,t, ' '' '.' : . , , •-.'' ',1','';',:,',,,!: ,';;!,141.„ - !Iglitt,,..:,';-,""';', ' 6t...-- ,:'1:,.,-'e ,* '',,a, . t-.,, '... '.,'':' .. ..- '''.,,,,,^'''''''•...'2.*>"" '`t • ••;"`‘` '';`';•••"-- ''' '';:• '''' • •7111?‘''''%4-11• '.-.,;.).i. . ii!.-,,,,,...,:,.,...;/.,•4•,,,,,,.......,.....t.,,.:,..:_ ;:i., ,,,..,,t.„:....•.7,,:....,,:•:::.• . .. . •.• •,,...,......:.,._.::. r:,.........•,..,. ::,, ,• ,.. v • _. ..„. .....,,,.,,, ,/, , , ., .,. . • ''''''.":" ,,' . ' ,.':„ ....'r.'..0;,',' ,,I,;•'•.•,' '').,';,,;-•,.;','„.ii,•1',,!...',,f,',,,, ,' "'' ": ' -• ".: •:'• '. ' •:- • .. t'A'‘, 1•• - . ••• : ,.- ' ., '• ••."''.'-',.:.• '•,••.'••,..,',•',d,':',.'.„..,.'''•.I',11,1:1,''ir''.' .. .•• • • •-' -• •'•- . •?.., , ... ., • . . ••. --...,,,,,,, I ,, - , '. ,,,H•-•'';',''':,i'',':,11,r,1;,J''',''.:'.::'','',•,:'.1,,::::.:,11,1,!,,i3•,'•,'J'.,',1:,;:,.'irli':,11ill'i'li:il.',1:1Y,1,'•1',;',4,,'''1,:,,:i•:,•,',,,,','.',',„'''..:.', '•',,...1:',..;::',,,--'",,-, - :,.. 1011 r' • z "1.0 e• - 7 /o• • -•-.-- . ‘ i•- ''''',,'.••'.;;;;;',,'4.11;'::,;•'''''''''1'1't1;;!11,l''''.'I''';''....'11'''1'.' 41.1'11 ;,''',1',,1,'. ,' .''' ::',,,'.1' ," '4.,,.•,. ._. , 7 4 ,,, - . .. : : _,. ........... .,, .,f ' .....".••••4(.0.,,,,,,. , •....,.. '. ..,:,1.y...:',.i.'c:•,',.,'".'..,'1...,'‘,.'',,.'..c:'-','..:'...:. , .,,,. :..,„.I.d:, .,,....,,,,,,:,,,,,',i.p.:',,, .: 1 ,.• , ' •:( .: , — • P. ... .,••.,•:,.,4,\. .,,,,:,.,,,:!,1,,,,,,,........,„.,1"..,•.4,0111,,,.,111,,,,,,,,,::,:."11,1'...1!.1111.,.,,,,....:. ,,I,:...,:i. .. ,0. ....,....,„,:,,..., ,,,.., ., „ . ,.....r ,,'••I'th'IFF',111111111111,,,,:i.,... :1,11,1'lli..:1:1:.,,,I!,.,,,.:.;:•..,,,,,,,,:..11111.1,•1:.•:,...,'...,..,...:y.,1,1'J'.11'1,1:!','!,:'.0.;..,d •••• .-— .. -. . ,. ,•-) ..-..,, - .. s4.,i,,:ii.•:.:,,, '.,!...,.'...,,,......'„"1:,,,,I,...11.1,i,.•...„..,,,,...,"::. . .,....... ,:,,,,,..1.:, . ,,, :::;,..1,„,..,.., ...,.. - ..'" . . • .••"."..1-.,,,,,..:.. . '•14...i. ' . ' ..../, ''',..,;,;.,;.,. . .•.... ' ,"lt."-tk,f', •,..,'•••,... , - •14i... . 4.,. . LI :.. .. .110.' 111.,,,,::..,,:,:,1,..da,:"':.".:"!!.'' - 46. '4'4L'I'ili;',,.- - .''.',,,..17L,' ,-ff.'-‘'' • . , . . . . - '4N,,,:l.''''''',:::1".. .,:•.,„,,,„\ r• . . , . '1,1.,!•.:If'•-••••;*.„--. ‘-.••:,:••.,1-, • '• ',,..., . , , . ., 4.....,:t .,. t.,..,.,„ •. ""t.,,Iii,•.i,:;•,,,„„ ,• .-"; , , ,•••1 PI• ,..'•• •••'‘P"• .•, , - % . ''''''ill''','1111L', r/PI% '.--4' • .- '4.,..c. ..,. . .4.;.. .;, I' t .. .,, 'k......" '...-...':;'.F ' • -..' • . , . .,. - t•. kl ... 0 ''. r„ i ,,-,,, , e • .i....,.- . , • ..%..4. ',_,.---- ,..,........,,• . . • • i•••;•-'.1,'•:`,,.•••... ,. 1.. •--."'.!f'` ."41:% ..„.r. •-•:•.• '• '-,•:'.:•.,,,,,',',.:•••••.,,_ --. t.... . . ' ''''-',. '-r.• :., ,,,:,'!"•,:',•,,•..•••''' •,,.•ie,,,,, ,4 "1 r . . . , . . PK , •. 1'4',":7;'-1,,:. • '' . • ' t . , .., .. ••,4,,,, • . --.ss•;;:.,•'77.-.,, . ''''1',.•LI, . , • '.- , f's .`•-",444,:"„;, ' .. • . ....,.. ..• „. ,.. • • • 4 447 .. .,„ , ,. • . . '. 11.'";-•' .. .. -', ; - .., c. . , . . ....‘,...• .,..•,,,,,,.,, )•.. ,,,f,,;,•.:•.:,•• '',,,,,,'.,•••••,;.m••• ,. . - ,. ,,. . . . .,. . -......... , . ..,.. ; . I; . ',1,1 ,,••,;••••,,,,,,..1•1,..t.•. ..;;;Iii...., 1,1. '',-,. ,., • ; . • - • • .- .,.,•„•,.•.,„, • •,... ,...,;•:,;,..1.,,,r;.:••••,•,.,. ,'•',....;•',... '''- • N., „„ss . ... •-, . ,.... ,.,. .,...,. , . .-...,•,,...,.-:' • ,: ••:...,.....1k4...,,,....,:,,,,.. ..,..,,,,,,,,-,.., .„,. ; .... - • . i':•...:.:,•,.... , ,',..,,, ',. '..,...,,,,q,„1:,•,:il,„:,,„, , 1..111,1,11,1,,,ii.,,,,,:.,.,,-., . i, . ' ,, • ''',1', ': , '.1,.!...'N::1`111,1'..1'.1,...!,...:.,,...-''''.':',.. '''•...... .H. I, •„. -s.. -.,,,,,,,,,:!.....,,,,,,,•.,1..,,,T.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,....,,,. ,...--,-.. ...•... .• - ',...:...:,' . ---••-, ,,1),10111,i1,i.,-",,,,,..40. ' ,, . •----.44 -'•,,,,,,.'.,:,'0.!0..,..',„4.4,,, ---„, .1!'0''.,'.',,';',,;''''''1:1.,,,../',.''...', . ''-''... _ ' '''''",..,..4'..i.4'1',4J',.'''',.,',''''"...•''''-`, ...., '`;•''....;:'':''''''''.1'.41;1,.'4';-.4.-';4:;q•'..4:-.; , ''. --`•-••• •• ''-••'-'''''' iikt''I;' ''' ';''''''',`,.., , ' '''' ' ''''•41' 4'" • '' " 4, ` „' '..4.. 4 4 , - '1.11P''4",••• '''i,1,••,,,' 4,111,'A 11:11,,",',;,,'''I!'''.,'•,'",'7. ''''"'-,, ''". -- '1 '•;•--:', _ - •*""'--h,:,':..::,•,,,•,,IL,ik,,,14P1,•••,,,',;,',',.:1,"41.,4•,'•,'„,":,,:'•1,j2j1'1,'', ';'''';'.1•'!",^1,., ' '‘FL2.- '•'•''ri'''''6.,'''''',••••,•.,''1.L'',1•71,1'3.'•.,','',;','', •1;.. •A '4'4'';"'''.1.:'..;'""ttiiit4H1.',.'''''''',,,'•'''`-,'..'"' ,.;',.',.'''',,,'„i'..,',.;71.17•,•:,...,,,,,, . ' \4%. ',, •'i'•,.,r,,,!'11••.. ,'N',„,,,,i,',,,... , . . • '4";;',.. .,..".',,,,,; ,1,,, ;;" ;''''''.*,pqr,ii,1•• r. ..'.'.;'';',"., . .. ......„.._. ._,_.... , •••••,•••••.„,. , . ••.,:•••,,,...,..• . ,,,,•••,,. 41,,,,,, .... , ,,.. ,„,,„„„,„.,,„., •,,,,.,...,,,..,.,,,,z,,y,,;.„.. -,,,„1, . P. .. ii.,,,,,,, IK '4.. ,..1, t,, _ ... )`' . . . - \'''[4'''''''' 1 ,, •4i.4.4.‘r., . 111.11 ,., . .: '''''.': "'", 'Fili,4'1'.t•, '"I,,:',,,,,,,, '•4,),A, .•,•,, .. :-,-_-.,...",',..,"...,-.:„..;'...-•• • ''L' II '',1','1.1',.,1••'.1',,i4,'11••;44,,,, 'I, ,',,,1••,,,'',11:,,, , ' ..,,i,' 41,, r. ., \ V.t 4 -It, •-,..5 ! .-!-.•.11.•::.,•,•.,1.--------4.,!,',!..4P1,!,!,111,,,4.1.,71:!4„,.....,, .... '''ill.r.••' . .,.!!!,,;;!1'1,!!!!,1„,0 „•!,,, •!••,Ti.',,,,,' , . •-,•!,,,,,,;••..,,,,,,•.!,,„, ir ,„••!!!1,•„ - ;..---.,_ "'"'"------,,,,,, ... , , • ,,h,.4•,,!•,,,r,,,,,,,it,!!•:.,,,•-.7,1..'pl!!!'!:!ilil.,4!•,..!'".. .•'•-!.IN r!!1,,,,',,,-!4,,„:1,•,,,..,. !'''! ''''''"•••••!!''''''''' 1:1'!'",.:''-'411" ' l'I'''''' '7'i'' ' "''' ' 1‘ ' ''''' ' . .-.4. ‘t,. 17 • .1041/4 '".....; ... ... ..,.....,, . .„..,,•,,,q,7,,,2,2 t,41[1,74,111,1,,,•:•„,,,.•., ,,,,,,,,:,,,,,,,„,,, ,...4,,,,',,,,;7,--'•,,,',.•-,,,,.,, • ' ,• 44,', •..........,1/4.• . .,....., .• ; •..,.,,,,,,,.. r.:. .• .• .,,... •\ \\\: ' 4',;41,,,,:n ' .... _. \\ - s .,c...,;4.,..,..:,.., - - , , ..,4,i m ,44 .4,„ -, • r, . ‘.. .. . \,.. .. •. -.,• ---, - --.. .... ..L.,...._::::7••-:,...., '7••:.•,-- ''Sir:•, '''-•••-'.,,, i•A',. 7-. •',' ' •:,:'•',.'14, """ ' '' - 1'•'"' "„•,,,,,.,4.-.„.•,,•',•",,,,,,,,,, ' ''' •' - ..... . 1 -- • • . - . __ •- - - _ �-- - - _ i " r �'` II* -II-' •ter•=" ._ = --��' -� • ,\ ""-_. _ yam =z 1� ■i + '�-' �* ", _� • "` Ts r • cs " ^ _ - , _j- L _ _ • '"� -- _ • =f r . -C: - f -_z ..ram . �: - a r - Me = + - 1_ a ' ! `E# 1 a 4t '3 F �� 1 1� j *i , ..:, 14 4 j _ ' p " _i - ,, f r 1 .� s • 11 yl' - .� Sl Fi. 1 .1� - 3 �� •. 1 r # i 1 — '�.� + l f ti "* _ ��>. r -.t `+^t t art, �j� yy�,� ' Y- 1 1 . �` \- ,ll,i '� .M'��.". .' YFi�r. ' f+ _ 11' - plc _ y f b y is t „t A '� ��'r �' - \ fit- �`ti Y`� i- �' 4 �! ,. . r.„ 'r," , '„:?I"I ..-,,,- --`-,E _,.. -j • '„III .^„ram, II w j j.IIJ�+ ',r'cw n l: ""T,'7 Tr"'"�',s Nrp!,"'.yl' •rr' .. ',r t f tll tlM!M 1Ybl rl X M 9nTTl 1 .rp €:,X 7;7 ,\ �IIP a", xl I� i�Y'.: _ /,r''.,,•rry N4 ,,' Aa:f4,�t A ,� a - ..; h ri k -,c •a - "'„ a I,I I':, �: '4 €' . ri'•,je ,,'i° r , `t f 1'k` " �'Or' r .I, ,,p"". `.I�a, i..•lldl l ' ..' 9 y r ,,, ,, I'N. l,�,,,1 :::�,_ I ,._,i' 1 !� 'k .•�' 1,1 ;, r i i11 �f d: ,111 1 p .I IT Y 'h IY'�;I F'' «II P ,M1'7 Q k :ml.r w ,,. :^ .. ,w r.`i. ry, �. ,L ,, ,.., X 1 I' 4.r. , . ,•,�I, rt,u rla rl :. ;,, 1...t., `'nS•',� : 1.,X ...�..� 11 'lldll� ti,. � 'I,.,.. a al :I ,...Y I' 1�,: I � I'.f jJr 1.i �ql�i; I r a G yi T � �. . •� r � � � '",.•+,Ir I;I,'� ,.c . I'r 1 ,;,•,,,; 111..;,,,,r �� I P 1 L,I �'I ; I". ,b4X y � d r,J .. , �,,. � � �, I ,1 � ..� I II ..,, �. yd I ... ,,,,„,11 , , �' n I "i�; 0 I'',yq: 1Ju rd ih :�I'', "� uv ,I J1 rgl7r 4 r _„r M.. .:r X rlrl.r,4r.l III 1,. r1'q"y. �IrIIP w l .n.X.� X , u 7. ..U.,�. 1,..�u,�., n 1 I I:J d„J 1I71� 11„ N.. J ,. , ! 1 d r,I •� .. I._ G ! u, IIG V+ ,.I. „ yfn "G".r:^ 1 „ •• 9 IIIJI Ilul l Tr; h III ♦ ,,,,, .,..,'' , .', 61 I + ''' rrr 1 , ��« XJ1N al. b l4q' Elp. ;w, , ::.,., ^4„ :!r ',r i `i; 1 r,,, rl rr,,,, ,111 ,,1 ,•C N:XI ,, IP ,'IT. I,,::, n lho,;44J +•6, �,ti ,.,+ ;" 'w6.. .:"'M G"ai r �,,.. I. lard, dl I,..�rM. 'y. ,, .I<..r r ,,,;',.� Id^ ,�, I , � r y4 °"I "!. 'a , ��y�'. 1,,,�•9 -.nl�', '.!•.',, . ro;dl..,�r. a� ,w. „ �""�. ,,,,. ,f I •�' ',";�. Y"'i:' n aa k4 ..,�� r -,, ;,, ,�'.., ��'"� a ., .•,. „ ,,,,1 .. ply, ,,r „,, I . >.1' . II M� r 1y f T. 'x' W. 4 :!� * •,4rpd. " ;:n .r - „�', �' �w,,. �*a X r R ;,u ��N'od °�;1146� � ,13�w I I I d '�4ry 1 l,:�r�, 4 �,' M,?,:v,�I I 1�I�'I l,p„I I ..1 I i, �� ,+,I'll",IAi', II . �. •„ �,,: ,.� I �,j,�' ,r: �hl'. I JI I•I., rv, ,.r � y NI ' I'. y. m..; � r I �! a :�' J:''a, uM,,� �'� 4 �� I'11,� I , ,.' � . .; �,�_��y ,�. '. ,'.1, 1 yG..:. „',,'11II n ' r N'y' 1'Dull l,v,,"4 y: r:y r6X',,. i,�II°III I• :. 1 I' ..•, a ,r r F411r SKI `� ,,.u,I ,�Yp1t ,� N, r, �y R .!I.: III' n 1 1 :;'.3 4 I 4 ,.^y Nla,t tl®I llilr;Ill 1 .I ly� .4�".. ^ryd I l,.'i' ,�ql I,ply lgl'll n:'' n ' 'X '4,.,•�.f IITM+%�u�,h„+Tr4 'Y IG " +. r .+ rY X,i', ;1 1J�n 4.N» „Im_. w II ,; ��-' ' ,�' lyld 71{n ''ING71I •,., .: .'",P r" ,r --M M1., r �' �� . I III r a C I III -"f � � � � I�I r ,+m, 'n r ,yam a d ,.�' w,� ' q J "`r b ju',''ti w., ,,w,yy I ..,� :: 4 ,, .a,4,1,p,, ,� I SI( d I ( : �d"CX 5. - m"„,C WI, 12�4"n A €1 4 '� fW Y� ',� I: "A I, •'04bid7 y tii.,n '4 /7 ?�3 4 r II 1 ..,�- r'4yr^X , , ), II, u.,r Ir, �. 'L: w, ry f;.. �NI lill � V , u , , �''� d � rIF ,', r; � j, �� I l�'jl!.' �� ' d Q I Ir. 4 !'�:.; r%:�: ; �� a,. �•• w d ... l• ,m II ! Ih Jl �, A^^p:C �' r� I l ul'I 4'r�� j I 1 �r �, r y Ir . ti F I a4 I� 111 1l' , r 1;. ,., IN I.: �r: ,I IJh 4;l .�• . ;.'� • )S . -,'... .. I� 11 ,., n .'" 1 �. 'III" I' I, ♦ '', .,.nl'1 Illy u� ,� 1 r,„ III Oil � � .... 'IpP�alul�::�, � �I ��iI ,' i c.70. �. ,t�'s" .,r r� ,rs— pw qq 1 �I lxq N` r 11 �i.li,.(� Td „ j '�,' 'r a {la �I' M�►ullJfr� • ` } .•.• I; uw•...,� � A I'�i .,. ,!f 11 " LJ rl'"ry. ah I wh I,�:.`nl ltl .ir, 4'nr 11 1"II,,,,�11 , P,.rtl ',Y'""' M?'„I± �n {14114. yP, ,:I I'.„ I'� '(Ylrl )� . ., ! '+�ii�� 1I,N•rrL'„ .. "' '� apr "�"+^?. ,�, �, nll I r" 'v�,y + ��T yI" i r� rirrilY �; ,.J�d. l y,� 41 r IN�,,, ,I¢..o. ,�dC ,�� L It..' ♦''W41.."�r ',TMA. la ;. .,.,.. , ;. l� + dZ,u.r a•! I, a^;, 4 a hf n ''�cl� u 4•r '/ I,` °. •"'yr �, •a y, W � "';"'" •s^ wed''rea... ,� "�,�, yam' "f I�rld �^� „rP,: 7► 7 I a I, ' ',y� y� • 4;d r I ,r lR,pla "A .. F 49, na' M.r,rv. �t T 'Worn il"�� 4M It.W �V 4 h ti,� YN d r' l 1„�NM1J ^ li II i " 1 ,I've • . . licr.�•ry ' '' 'Mg. ,,. r .irr'' 1 rd[.bh.l' ;„A .vf* J 1 I r.'I 'd•'' w' �` •%.,. 1 ..5. 5 '� `A '''.'.- � � • 4 ' "a�Mi"' �"L^ ��.�:� 1^ �" 'x n n�.f `/h �'":,; • x ?�''R y� A �I, " -, yr 17 l l � t i 4. • r.° ri w"* �! , ',." 'S a eF s�^ �. * iti 4 p ,�3 r. •c.lr,' ✓ ` . r ....• , 4A, " n.•r'°r� AOi^., ,I 1 �' IIMI' ,- pi "ram ►i i _ r t $ u I ` • �= A r`: `• .'} fit„ i' ' f ,.. ,. ..., k"� II ,,,,li .. WII �"� �. Y -••rvm� ,. ° 1, I A h rill r, .1' X FJY' I. ' ,� 'u1�14 r 1�( 4 m "� l i III I I I , AIL I .y v u lw,.Mr s u' ti• aI, r „, ! •Y G1 -• 1 ( _I :: ;r, ' ''hr. laV! '� � , A sj M1 ..„ S" ICI i6eII11YMIC y a 1` jkrR..:. ' ��;",.I,, ■ tiLA T •.. • AA++ ]I *�IY . f; IM I Ono". uy 4 , ..,,•, • •;x r. � A ' Ifi4 , y !TJ a q 1 wl, • G� "I ° III 1 wow *^fPl ��}r 4 ✓• y S AI J I' 41 a f'I, J411 4'yI'�yI�I,I11 y. 1 �n, ' 4 "l a uutltl ' IP i S 1 ' w+w I tl li ial4II II� 1 I; 11 ,•, I l I' 0 I y:' ` �� psn. rxp I. P111m 4' 1 �,I \i 1 • • ry dl �Xrl M" r41. 7 . 1,?•44 •Ir:. 1., �' 11"rr n ^, I r , yl S, w ' I pt r ar, a I' ly 1 I r; 6 ,du 1,. - v r ,mrl l r, Iww r �"" • , 'rrt 'Ir p • , r ,. 11 '''. „ W"tfr r I A,1 .r�G V A a. k. I..uaer�. Np" yl'^�'�;� �;. w,.... of f � .-.. - 'tlllw ' h A� 14 rv'r•" 'dl'' 4 llG A,1 44.�'� I _y ,9 r• X{ Y H •_� /G" Y 1 r h i -- ,r • S• i M x t lu y :l , yr �4{ Vi r ml !i^ p w k x 1 • .•i. h I NBC r,• �f, '� yl lu �'.0.'; d., r A i� •�7"�Ix»� nl ^ t n11 III Ayrl rl IICYu ry,gl u, f xlyu d • N, � Uu mI4,,„,a� I �� I II' III I fill !1 I I:�I l�lu�l71 �!. �4 r I i.. �r - I'"Y t IK ;� I; y, u IIII IIII ! h II�, [1 I c 6 '141,11,! N,u1 ..I Jhl "uy arr ,:! ^�4 u"I�(fi` 4.,i i I i 1y''r,1 r :it'I r1''�1 1;I. : '.:: . * I � 1pyl�Al ,l I'C,`:,. r N � ,^,/ • ,i' '. .at ;,, .�I,,:i ill: u 0 �I&: IIX, I d, 1111 ,:I, j„YII I',,c;, II' IY'III III u G, 1,I„� -�u 'um+lu :,1 �N1u','F """ 1 �d�l�l r110 i,! r : •-a., ip, „upr� y h N '. CgCrl ! , .;: ra N.� $ 'W� »I ��Y Fil:',,, 1i W^PItl N, I rl�'u f lu l,� JV.I 'f 1r r ; �a'Iall '.�, I,:k'. Ir III lidIM III'OoIIIIIilhllppp1l1 ^I +I�r. r .,! Y a..�:. �; I III rl II .. u�glN I611 b 4 (III N J I ' 11:1. wY n. ,Y y jl j „� nI1 R -„, y rAM e, �e. 1 „i t1 eh!A "a M.s : 1 • t i ' I p Yl �i!Wli l nN Nll m I I ! (III' N �l dIl dr, ti x, IIIA 16I �4k� ,ar , ,-,„,:".,..�� .. 1B d �Nu 4 _ _ - + r_r' r'' P 19„'III II p III `,' III ll INVIIMI ljr y 1 41 • NI 1 'f _ram .r •. �- w a"mmlYl ** h/ III YI .y .nll'" : y �I'1I n I',I t• { i I . a1� Il f r•Y �I T }�. 11 I a , ��t. • ..� ,.., � I A ,. ti .. w,r: j l; S y I W? f a „Y I # f I .► I gy` • .,' r fyi;-•-_- \ - ""- I • ^• � n4pdu."Y,,pnp ! '"4+' ,e .u.,II, ` J 1 1E,ii, �.-,: •}: ✓' y !- I MINI 1,�r' j l III e^ a ` 1.: "` 'Wr +�'Y.::: / .. sr: r i!r III ,I '11 r .�'a W.ne y,,, .. Nu I, L1' W 6 it .�' '. t �.- ' -"/a , y� - '11'1 Ill: II'!L. a 1, /t'� , • q� i x•, • ,,,,,,,rerr "+ n „/ ''.r r,*i.+J '.• '$ •,I 'a8 • • } -✓'. • •yr• _ r ,A .� .: '' � .. ,.,+n,. .,• �" `';„': ;� t,,,' 0. �'^ :'.� ;,, ,'FBI, ''.✓' '. t' �` 4, '`",�• � Aa`Y / , I rat "r ,I' AID n hi _ " w % y..-.. :^ ' °` .+,,,. k 1 +'I N � r � y I .� ;,:,„„'N If xw 1 N' AIM ?;.„ ;;dd » r , Yr , N ;.. yr T.II. tlC�� I III�y'(�!II, I I r I,, r l a;.:q'e: 'III ;:��., �.,',�,xWy ,^Io�,..�.3c,M_ � r„ -� - P,`. r aliN�;�'a f *' r� ; ,�^ � a ^ ,�� 1g . ", ,V„",. .. ti1:Nll�.:, A,I' �a.... LII1�,�II,, u nN� .I Iry.'- ':�..,� >, 5. 4 , ,b; ,+A r l 7 :�'I� f �..., of rAM!r�I I �yNNl,ll „Nlaa ds,^ ,.h.F' •:I� �,�.I e,',, yr •�' k'7M ,al I Ir l!1�- , .»e. r _ �:'Ltr7, •,. .,.^ . ,.^-•� , "I lei l,..!, 'f:'r y� , lfon �� Yyw��:P .yP.'.' n,Ah i",µ d^,I»w•-•r'a"1'ti+.. r7'L� Irk ��: �I•,��N►� �x eM!I%�.: .., ��r � �r�, 0.r.,'yC^ k,.` �Fes+.& ' •u.,�;��F ' wx "n' rr •.. / } _.. .y , :Pr 1 J 'F . ' .::,. 4 ,µ , ,?. I "' IPI �'''!... • ,x*r-)4•.- +3` .,A.m t y;: a ; h,.',.B'1, e ,I-,.. I" �� . rt_. Yhl..l L'r + . un, r r - p1rb. ,. „M r'I �f}r�' _, �.u,d , '�'..� � N�'�.I N... ,'� w ,I„uuM;I'^, r",: " -. , '4k IV x!:.,Nu I"+ �' cl ".`,. '. ., .'. ...,:"' . .'!,�� r; 'S. .•: .,d'' uIILL I;1 ,I LI',,�I. „ n ,y. ... I.' tl ' J. 'a ,.�I ,. ,II, • rh, ,x I 1 A*r .0 f, a xl I1,: I I 1r e •e ,s :N:, , Y titI'..�,I�I.y ,G,IIi lai., wd ".,,"d.. a.�. ,} 1 ��llf , ,Itll 1 ..w r v 4 ':�Ir„ . I q,,,,,LIo III,: I .� . , L I�,Lf�.. ' qp,�" I,,I,,�,d:,� I. � � I� ., I G, �, ,:,,,tll_I I II, �LI»�''» I:,: ,.:,. . � , . ,. ,,:• n ,e" !6V.I»,n .,!I. -,' ,I r» i1 du '''' IJh1,,l 1, u 40 I put i11,.II�I xLr ,.hr �L,, „ „ :!,NI .I n. I,I�,, '11 11 w, „..In, I,..,,,, 1. .ls7+ "';;. I ,, „ :.n „r �r �r: .;.,,,,,,...;.,,,..,,,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,,I.,..„. .:,. . yl NI.1,IJI"' "" ,� I I, 'a. !� ".L� n N, I , ....�:, N�1 .,�� , -. : .t. C: .," : .,, I ru� �; , , ,„. ,y �i�:, Ia II +IxV,�. �I p".� ..III,, III�,r.,l� � � tll,n; .��.� u4 AIM x,,,�! ,N I "»d, N I„L I;�y.'"��%�..r"¢.5.�: ,:��. i � ,M I. r I dll It..;. ➢ n ,,p ry7�'��rk A ,. I' r„ ;� .-r • i; r :. I"-;A _"' t� :.I:.rNl r , �':a!, � T„r� '"''::�'I.W ;dW 18Pd�d I+�Ia�I�,IW ry, .�, � 'r',, � �� .:'� r f�, _ 'tiA,: w-.��{� J.F :f�, ,�,: e :4 h r rn.. n+,5ul. r Vie:°n""T' 7!' Nury d .:i .I^", «," ,A ;,'.r r •,''F^" r }r: 'I I N 'I 11li;'llii / w AI :JI 1, j �. ,I,�, .' ��r. 1 :'.' �.., Irl, ,!�F I �! I' 'r 'ry !1 Iry'Iv' '� r,I r." uy1:u�.. +III�"I a ,✓. . :� „: • _ ':r'' a '* „1 , f 1 I, J':.: • ,Iu„ u w.',; r Arw r �I^tl h, I,,. 4,!.N „ ... o .. .. ,r'r' .in •,, ,� „ I. a ..»:,, I , .',, -' a ,. .LI,. III, r �f�_ i'IPa.iII I„aC' I,- P. �we I.I„�,: -A.II II II,; IL,,., I n!I„ Ilu� n ! -� - I. dl. , a ,J 1,, �I,T'�,k 1, I�L JI:.,.� "N" rR..,, II k91,m' !I I:I I".'�Y�'�,, : 7,,,?'. nl rl ,.., h nal' +..', - I a: '�.,1,II„'::!II „�� h w.:... i I�,,IINI II•,.,..,,�,I d ,,, , nl Ifl III ,I,I.,Ir�,,,p IIII II In,V ,„aVl 0. ul a I,4 ° ! 'I!' 1^ulry ,x ,IIII 1 Y r /.�rl r + 5 ; .al•+ re' ?''. r ! ^'" !, INI'I r 4 _ •f t A .: •`� l4 M f I , I^ rl _.,- .l - �. „�':! / R: .I1.. rl'" f � NI I„II 0.°l�+s 1 I,.,,ti % FI. A ,� ..r 1, ''o' - _ , ,' f J' �' I ^ : dY Ili:-,.,a $1'''':u - .. I„! + .6i!i ,.I,.. x' r^. a „� 'i i - ,, +,.1.� d ,.`I »,.I ..I. ,�'';:,, ,:!r I. .I III II,I I JI : ,., •: I! r.. r' L;a .I. R:....I „ ,m" I. 1„ ,. ..:1,.,.. I:,:,. II ,L,�,,. .'.:- • .'7. L.. I .". i I. d ,. �: ', �d; I I. I u�J,.. t ��1�,lll ,.� ' IU I- I p..,-'-0I I h L I Inw I I!,;..:�:r l l ,III I .,:,d, , I�.�f��l,•� �IILIJ I I I, '! J. L :I ; I. 0..,•l ,, 'llna."':. 1 I1.1 „'I ".Iy�!' -In Iui,I .IIII ,+I.I',',,i ,.I,;..r :•; I,,. I !1 ': n:'I'- ' I Il It I Ip, °�,-' ,:•-- - � - i dI, B da��i. I 1 I � ,I ,; I ,a I r � ,d III 11 d A ,.n III III e .,: I : .. � � �I I II p AII, I x fI II I 11�1 IIIII III. I d - °' �' I 1I i, t 1 Y u' x 1 "ail 1r,x;' N III A N III c h 1 I ,I A II '.WI f � <z i _ _ t ems .' - -_.-_- r II, � -F. �1 lki: �d..R _ - ^ P - A�Ili 1 � I ' i /§� - tt 'a - ti ,; iii: _._.:::± ---,-, I. .. ' -,riz ! - - + ; • f €_ •# # 1 , , t - it:..; 1 iti.i..i...:4:1:._;14taik... �- I 4 J < p 1( b -• q � o__ II s I d ' t II • ' i 14111 '.411,11°ki ere ' ''I* � }` �� Ataw r • 1 - ! 4 414 _: a j 141. .1 7/ft, • -. , - A ,; I "ett;iiii , 7 ' ' - / • ‘;''.1k,1......,t,....111-'1,". ' ,,r 4-44-\ • � - ,ems to _ .' t - a t. . 1 kl.7t7.4 .r-litl ;- !_1:;1:--..-.*!--ii__:.4 -.._:` E 7 a - ,11 _, _=iit.,,_ t_ i - _ „ k r s y S } 3. L �.� >fr 1 44* i g y-- f^IIIIII l I1(;pa iI u,:'1ry'P'N lduln II IN I,l II I Ixq IIhh II ! �II ";' a 91 I I �� III I I liIIlll ' il'dl �I h Ill1lril, II III IIIIry I Il l . �',l p�l,ei'd d !Ip I�II 11ll l I I II II d.l • �I Ial I I .P I �I 9I41 p i1I I 1:' 'II ^I ipn'�P.d I-� ,IN 1 II,�rgl i k�' • _ 7 npI,,,,0, ;y lf 1k II yw "T d 0liry" I Irlhll� ,i A 4eNald , ll lgl N T iuII�I I II I, I I'lu I l rIV ' P I Iq: � IdII�Illl I I1 I I I II IyIIII I; ,II II ,nI1lr',0 Ill:FI I I I I • �I I IIIIIN�II IIIiI,� IIiI I III III: I I II 010 I Ill I 'I00 I I li' L'I{dY l , . I I II � I, "III: 4 i � I i l I rl 'III I -x:: II'lih�Al'IS I Itill iM : " I H • ..�xw • w ul, IIII I di IIII _ - ",,p' 3, nl l 11 11 l l l g l U�l I,I I �I III IIII IIII� III IIII YI t,!'+ "� •, I. IP I III l„Il lh ql1.llli7d u��' I III III p l,,'11�I 't,; IIII ':A+' ✓w °'.. • ! : • • '7, • i. u11,'V'N I III � p •Ills �' 'I:'llu MI4 I N�I�IIiIiI�J',lull 4 • • • • •• IhII'dk h1;,d''mN 7 , ' .dd-Al♦ . I ;r ^''� i 1 _ - IIIy 1 w. ', e M — d • • • 'II • • i:u 1.If I M ',,: h KIW I�I✓!I III W • .I R I i p 1 I 4 owl r I��ut I II r I °I i ..Nw rN w ; N 4 �my ludo 41 d Nd r._:M p 1g i " 4 7' I� r !e • y I i I II ,h1e��i '. • �':1�I pI Id JI ✓ded III I.,, I. 7+ u� dl : •. d r M h IIII Y u G • Iv v'� jrp l I 'I'�� al '. i 1 11 • li;�. Id d 1,IP • d'pl h I'I �Ilr' t l IIII d, hl %}, ��III II "III IIII ",I ,.I II' ti, p$ Ix .. o'„ F: II Ilu II,I '..'I II., '.: tl 'I II'"iI III11 I 6 M ul U�I I il; IIL pp + 1 ,,N loll,1 I �', P ,• i!P Iul f "N x 41 yy uIJI�` .. p II I!I IIN a111., II !I III d"., d '�k4ild M.. p 114. � •d• • � •i add I I I xu I •�' h 'ry ti. IN a N7 .ew7 1a.•d i r 7 9 • l' Orly d h :d ��i, ;I ! IIIIr m w l hl I d ! • ,i+ III '' ..e�yilil N rl �IpII I'"IIII � Ir j • v itII '17u1 I :!I I a Ji1 I�'p��I yii111 v ,. J�illj • ply III. IIII r l n I I„� 4 IIII IIII < T I 1 h!'N Ip IN III "IIW, • • • ° I I. 45 • • 1d.1' ' III IIII:, I' III d� IIII NI. 4,; II �7rf ti dP : 'N • y` f, v r .ew 4 I 4 rC: Gu u' • ',I 'II f ! I t h., ' t pia ywl,.w aN• •r * TNr4'��w't Y q ygll I . 1.. ., ._ a,��.,�„ N u6a :' ' • • � • I I IM u, 1 I d IAh I 1II I �I l • Aal T': VIII hull 'I,IIII N I I' ';'�r I N ,, IIf v ,,�I I V!" III Irr�', • •,..:!i Cf: 4 k „ :I NI :: - 'fit t dl �1 '�+: .. • • u .M 1 • F % am . w^^ -j 1 se ,r} 1w r M of aT P,MN �'i ,. rl • 'j i In II F jj pp !P a1 , III o; 'a . M 7 n k ! ry II ql I1 J' • �' III 0 j 119�1 • • 1 IIII I.. • III .y bye; - sx -3 t•:-* e t S'° a �'' _"e*+i. to --r '„ - , °yy. ► S• t- a ?f _ s I ?e - - - _ - e am_ � _ P. .. - F --- , ..- 6 —.�_.l T as - ' mot_ ' _,_ _ h _.-'-1- I--—-— _ _ i:=, :—„t T„.r---——1— 77 _- '_A-8,_1--v__..i--'—A-_-i..-,-Tkk - 51 i sue'- /' t \-- ' { [ ,', ""‘Z--,w-_.1`,-----r-'- _A-L:4‘ - - ,," - --' z' • _ wi..i.,..-\,.. '', -V-,-__-::=______=_ ___,,___i_ __ _..,,.:;_t:.,w,-----%„ • S' 11 f • a 2 + • L'et 4 r � ilift ---x, ,,_ III= a _' G a l f -" k a - _ _ • "NY d Um �f"UT� • al .^I+ ' wy '" r a 1 I II;"mmµ tl uII pt �� • • .;.. l'µAr:L W r µI7 1 ,� , d , r ( p. ' �. TI I a � �� 4a,. 'T*n ^ ,rll I �� M I��II"�"-'W ° rri ,. .� , ' ti� * r '4'NII p ' "xG I 7 P r�V' rf�w1� ,Gy jN. t:.:d I w1�IiPIH�T�mI ,�, , i , i�+ Pp' 4p I 'h r �XW,in :� a p .v , y 4�`5 yly' 'as 1Ip T ek 4,.. ` W,wl l 1 • r ik �q - A s L i Nr C a, 4 w '' " l �"I W r.",,, W 't I N d 4 ^ " � +tl I.lIIi,• 1erf I �!^ n �iJ41� ' . , H w.,w; bd,f yI N'II pn • 0;:1,,i.. ,,,„„ 1, i —c 'll pP ii J il N d 'IIb I nll l �� • 1 Q ' N1U �CI d NpIv .Nl m rw'''' ".- In 'h ; Ili(' lh .1..,'; , li, I Y a IP II nNll IIIINIII 'III i, 1' 0N P 1 Nl fir,; w PI a � 4. A,g ll14 �X�y M41 w4W.�w. .• ; ,.. �y� ... . m � �' • q� VryiiIaw *Ik 6 " IL� r un * ,. r .P � 1 p;: r - r u ' ,1 ::. r..� WNra� �� I ' Fhl I - • .,'.; ayµ ?yrl '. w r I III, II rd �Id1I wI a *M ks,:,. 1II I , n•n •I4iAq�"1r 'PIiUl NPiI ur J .N l'r yI • 1J,,y I h q1,. I !, , Ia 4. 1I GII�INI l I II '' .j ' dj,ol',1;;•,,l �� 1,l I I I h ! � '. f 1 1 11, ! ••: l�l(llipi�Ill��11N1I1�I I I I1,I1'llrIia " •:' ,, „,,,, •,,,,:: ,I, iI 7VI III 116I1N�If� JN��WJu " �*NF�F�, •l,l",:' ' �1 I � „Illy i 1 :IyI IIIII N� I� -�I i�1,47pI 1Ni,i, �III I .,„,,II ll II : 1�'GiIu 04I IPIi,i rlII h, n1 �II III ,I,' I II j i' n+l I i II��,,i�II IIiIiIIillII °INIIN'0III II I IIII,I )I IIII 14I0,,,„O lg ,Iw .�• II MIrI IN„,,, .: , 1 I III lauylIIINIIIII,,I IIII II 1 11I lI I Ir w I I':•,: , . • ,,,,,,:•:,II I,lI iI ICI�; lik' ! !•14, ,, " I I " lll r II pt IIC n ! I I i' II'III WA i A ,I 1�III' 41� I {V�"Ir IIIIIIUI'III' M § N 1:IIIII I; Ir„ l Illul ,I ,,J" n ,1' II, �r g II k !,•.,,,;,,,I,,,,',:;,i',,,,.''. • ,, , ., ,. • ,:•, • 1. :1ri�Yll l y� ,7II � l '' IIh 1'1I I �hll N�� '. • , Jr , lr ,.y l .h. IIiI1V i ;:Elm'1 II I' t Il' bi r * °!- I I h7N'tJ 1p u<'n V !I " . . ku� ._ ;I, .V ] vJ'di _.1,:.. W._ I2'u¢ . ". _... -= ''-'1=7--,--et=--*-_ -, -.-,-• -F--,_-:I--,--:--1-::::,i i_ __. -- - ----. -v:= 1 - ---,---F I I -,----- ...- •- -,._ i., -.."....--.--7.-- --, , ..--___,- .„,,_-.,_ _, . ._,-_-__„,„„•4,__„_-_ _-=,,.-„,,,,,_,__,,_ , . i • ---41_-- ,„ A -774,7-:_:_--.1:277,-,i-J7.4,, --_-_.-, .. 'r -,z .•_-: I --- # '---'-'- 1----' ---i---,;-rff----.-- Y ,t, f <,, • ,, • 4_. , , \:1'-.liC.'-'._‘•_ . lii. *.,, -• *1,'-',v ..,),-.. lis ., 4 i- I A:, r -,, ‘4*.! • . I I. I .,... , ----,.._ ' -E: ----... - - i t ,__„,------:-_- 14,44,tts_ . .4 i .. i 4 t t • • • ,, - . . . . 4 1 i f i 41 .'.-rr' . ---. -- 1 f i.,. , i ' . , • _-;1,.- -. ' :''' ';',i .-.-.--jr= t''„.. .0 - I . :14#- S-r-- l' - I 'i-'-'±'. 2'-; '7 li ::-;• tt -=--_ __.:;" :-: ._• . , _ ,- 1 ,-,-,-:-_ . ; - i --l-,-- = , .. --i;-- .-4 , ,_ ri;- • - -, ----T-;-.A . IT ----.-.. .-------1=1,,, _.. '''I . „,x_„ ... :1 I il :,'-_-=-_ --,-,.„1- . i ..._ :,: .-. ..__ - ; t ,-.,...____„rs-1 -.--_ : i ?- :::- . -:-Ii 11 '', -',.--4'_ - ''---_ i F. ,::::=*, : :t, ' `,-,,-----1- 17,! '':- ' . 4 ' • ,: 'It.-* .-- = •--.-- • .) _,_=.- '•. ir‘-.:, 1„--'- .:-,---wil i V . - .4'4_7147- _ ,i, . .. . _ -!TR_ ____,______ :I A-'1-'1—P.4 ? ' -... ----,: sr ..t -,•ik 7 .--...,.;:-.. ----_:.--_ -•=4:__-:_f-s---f----7,---s--i & - , -, ,- --A-;:%t i I i ,;... ---... ;, L-== / IT -,, -,vg - 4 - - - - f'1 e- --1-1=-V-' I --', .„--Atti r a 1-,r__--- P'- --='..-.. : , ;,'.. -: .,,..,--'it-• -,I i .rf=__ - ' •;, ' , ,..,D.'" . __- -, • ,i - . . _: ... ,.. r - • - 1 , - ' '1:--i-. j fq.-1- P.1 k 'i,'-, • -1:`- 'f', . ' II, '' .4if . Oil°.. 1 -4"--4...A.- . . •‘..‘. ...mg , ', .-_ __i„ .., i. ., . . _. .. ., = 1 t.:' --... -' li . ., I,- . . ..r -•' "-TO" I : - . .-- . . . . . . .: . . . . . - ... .., r i . : ' • - f...-.I-- „: 0„. 1 . . . . . -1 .',--'i . .I. • . ...:i •- - - - -: -, - :_:- -, ,--I - • It .1 .i.i !_A-•:---,.: -.- '-= : q‘ ,---:.- i :-_.1 :,--, . -_ ._..,, ---• -...- -__L,..., Y HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEMORANDUM STAFF REPORT Property Owner: Karen B. Galvin Authorized Agent: BNT Services, Impact Windows Project Location: 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District HPB Meeting Date: March 4, 2015 File No.: 2015-101 ITEM BEFORE THE BOARD The action before the Board is a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for the replacement of windows and doors on a non-contributing property located at 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, pursuant to Land Development Regulations (LDR) Section 2.4.6(H). BACKGROUND & PROJECT DESCRIPTION The subject property (Lot 2, Block 6, Del-Ida Park) is located in the Del-Ida Park Historic District on the east side of North Swinton Avenue between Northeast 4th Street and Northeast 5th Street. The existing residence was originally a 1,300 square foot, one-story, simple ranch style home built in 1956. In 2000, a two-story rear addition was approved (COA 415), and has since been constructed bringing the total square footage to approximately 2,200. The structure is classified as non- contributing to the historic district. The current request is for the replacement of all existing aluminum windows and doors with vinyl, impact-rated windows and doors. All existing accordion shutters would subsequently be removed as well. The existing windows on the original portion of the structure consist of single-light awning windows or jalousie, whereas the windows in the 2000 addition consist of multi-light awning windows, or fixed, multi-light octagonal windows. The proposed windows are single-light sliders or fixed octagonal throughout the entire residence, with single-light French doors to match. The COA for window and door replacement is now before the Board for consideration. LDR SECTION 4.5.1 ANALYSIS Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E), Development Standards, All new development or exterior improvements on individually designated historic properties and/or properties located within historic districts shall, comply with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Development Standards of this Section. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(4), Alterations, in considering proposals for alterations to the exterior of historic buildings and structures and in applying development and preservation standards, the documented, original design of the building may be considered, among other factors. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(5), Standards and Guidelines, a historic site, building, structure, improvement, or appurtenance within a historic district shall only be altered, restored, preserved, repaired, relocated, demolished, or otherwise changed in accordance with the ill. North 5wintcn Avenue:2015-101 I(i� Mee'Irg fViecch 4,2015 Page 2 of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, as amended from time to time. The applicable Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation are as follows: • Standard 2 - The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. • Standard 5 - Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a historic property shall be preserved. • Standard 6 - Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical, or pictorial evidence. Pursuant to LDR Section 4.5.1(E)(8), Visual Compatibility Standards, new construction and all improvements to both contributing and noncontributing buildings, structures and appurtenances thereto within a designated historic district or on an individually designated property shall be visually compatible. In addition to the Zoning District Regulations, the Historic Preservation Board shall apply the visual compatibility standards provided for in this Section with regard to height, width, mass, scale, façade, openings, rhythm, material, color, texture, roof shape, direction, and other criteria set forth elsewhere in Section 4.5.1. The following Visual Compatibility Standard applies:. (g) Relationship of Materials, Texture, and Color: The relationship of materials, texture, and color of the facade of a building and/or hardscaping shall be visually compatible with the predominant materials used in the historic buildings and structures within the subject historic district. STAFF COMMENT: There is concern with the subject request as it does not comply with the intent of the applicable Standards, Guidelines, or Visual Compatibility Standards, since the character of the structure will be altered through the use of single-light and sliding windows. Additionally, the proposal includes the use of vinyl, which deviates from the aluminum material originally found on the structure which is readily available. Further, there is an existing difference between the window details of the original structure and the 2000 addition which should also be maintained when replacing windows to retain the desired differentiation. The generally accepted solution when replacing historic awning windows is to install either single-hung or casement windows which replicate the light pattern provided by the lines of the awning windows, with the casement type being preferred. Given the above, positive findings can be made to replace the existing windows subject to the suggested revisions. It should be noted that the use of impact-rated windows is appreciated and beneficial in that the exterior will be less affected whereby permanent hurricane protection will no longer be necessary. 411 Nortn Suvinton Avenue;2015-101 HPB Meeting March 4.2015 Page 3 of 3 ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS A. Continue with direction. B. Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. C. Move denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan and does not meet criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. (Motion to be phrased in the affirmative) RECOMMENDATION Move approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (2015-101) for 411 North Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District, by adopting the findings of fact and law contained in the staff report, and finding that the request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and meets criteria set forth in the Land Development Regulations, the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Design Guidelines, and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, subject to the following conditions of approval: 1. That the window type be revised to casement from sliders; 2. That the window material be revised to aluminum impact from vinyl; and, 3. That the light configuration for the new windows replicate that of the-existing windows, with - - a difference between the original structure and the 2000 addition, as opposed to the single- light configuration which is proposed. Staff Report Prepared by:Amy E.Alvarez, Historic Preservation Planner 411 N. Swinton Avenue, Del-Ida Park Historic District r. '-11 . ,,I. , ,.,, t� F r^r.� •,.„l ti." 1 �• I,, .., ... ,..„.„,1.,..i: 1„ , �, a " Y !� 8 '.«.S i !• v� � n�.... . t1.,' w. l , G , . s , , i II , L; l '� 7. .. ., o .„4 ,, , • ,„ t I 1 / . �� , :CI �r } l . , . .,. • "Alitw , �,— : � ._ b • '•'-' ' • , ,,,,,.I';,,.;. .... ili , - - - 0.1 . . ,., • ' • 3 6 w ` ,F71 ` 1 ` Y IY �b 00 YPo wr k F 1., ,�p� a i, �,• Z .„ �� 'SDI"' WiMrvl y��l tl ' I ' { k h. '+� ' ._J•r1L IYI • 1 • t Q . iNEt5tN St � i t a yNE 51tf�St l � � : l • • i �1 .r t tN° tain � t4 I it } M4w ' #' . . l. rf f-•1� �q, _ rY�"^. it �� i„ I'I1 ! I 1� Rl- 1 F a : , , , , 4 p _�! • " IIt '' 4, 4', ' Mt ! 1 • ' ,�4 I I • 1 '. . " _ Yii Ill tty3 n'� iny�+ ; yyy t.R x i'11'-1 1 I 3 1 i �' � 1 I � � . , .a. • ',rile 11 Ii{ „ , ,:1 p 11- �1� ism- ��L � - NEJIhSt .. +aar ,.i . • - r . . _ • x . • -' NE 4th v Lake Ida i2d' l ►M+ac.1e _ E 4th r \ S M " • T{ Y c _ II • • I •1 3 u "1 r • t .,"• + t,. ..,� }} 1 11)11.,Tol«t4' " '.a 'F ^�.._ } �1: Wi I�t1y � F t' . + '�' a ,. 4 1 •, -# •' p�.;�` ``t '''* hr 1 1 1i ':"M ._ •.77 1"�t i' ''+—.,,, ',s 6!. �M;?hry ,,, •: tirN Cannery Row C ----' x 4 , 't 'i, ",..; L "•.: M�F k:+ ,,. ":;ii j;:i;; M tl 1:"', . .� 11YY1_1 L• , ` ." ._ I':_ ,. �,....,. •'7.- FII 4 6 r'�� ti� ^• . r-Li'('r C'1.cj l•'; : 1 t, !' ilibir !I I lr BnT Services h1C. \l ,.'' 1 f,l.�lltc_ 1._{''! _ lillpod windows&Door, Addi ,, `1 i 1 - . ; tj l 0 3 ` .W. t st 11'.iy 4:3 .. 1 it y,`3t.,ltt ;• ! '``1 DOOrt ld tic�cidh. I 133 441 `ryll i '''•, PlIonr _`! 1 r :1 I 1` 1 1 k:SO..13 1 151 15a. www.bntserve.com Eniail Lae'- '. L'by T ; t t 47.1 954-233-0126 I-10A:_. / M4'asure Ni2tts; L'1 ' (.'- 1 c s ..,iv. . W H nouns W H Style Series Glass Tint Grid Price 3 I7: ,h 1 `16 1, I I Ic r i- I. l� - ,. # /.,•..1,t x, i 7 t`1 j� 1 Cs- , 6 3) I i j a `i,, j, ,-, A ` 7 ;1:. ,-., b.... 1 1 f 9 oil%., 7`t )'`) F-1 A' S..0 1..4 i 19 C .1-- II .-` t .2 `'-1 i-t._.F tit; 4 �> 13 ; < - - Ali tc`•o, ' % 11 14 1 I_ .. Oc '1 ,,,_ ^ Si 1 is n'i/` 56 . 0l,• 1 7, s — , to 1 M,y L,1••d LiI0',//, G`).-ltyl- , fCfr..-. '..-2 j c` , 1) slit . '7 4 I--_)c.n'l' (,.—)1 % k ' 1...= , 1 1,` '-)0 .. I I ,.ar- BnT agrees to provide&install the above products per code to the above address. -Air. Price includes tax,removal of all job related debris,weatherproofing, drywall,stucco&window sills if damaged during install. BnT is NOT responsible for paint,alarms or flooring. 40°ro deposit is required for all materials. ``s• Financing is available. Customer agrees to terms of this contract. Product: _ , __ Customer Signature Tax: ------------ Labor: (less deposit) -' `1, 00 TOTAL DUE: /C.' c-L`-; (after inspection) _ __._._._. Processed by FREE version of ST01K ' .. Mobile Doc Scanner from www.stoik.mobi • i ' , • r ---I I- / 1 1 ,• /< ---1,/ --,1 ,,,-- ,./"- ...--" q , i , , ,- ....-- t -/ •-•,..(.71;(., Tn I ,..C:t ;r ,• t_ itc•t, / / ,,,,,,`" -.1.•:,,r,, ! 1 1 ,' 11,');•: ./ i ',1.'.:f ;;,',,,Ut . ,' 1 •..,-,` , ' ' ' : J irt,J ,,' l',11„rd, ''' Ll'i,1 i-'-----,,,,,,,...,-,' ic•"...>fc I i / Last Modified Date:1/26/2015 1:06:57 PM PO#: Job Name: Job Address: Quote# 3378111 MATERIALS LIST Sales Person:Chris Doolin ShipTo: B N T SERVICES INC Customer Bill&Karen Galvin Account# 1673 SW 1ST WAY UNIT A3 411 North Swinton DEERFIELD BEACH,FL 33441 6790 Delray Beach,FL 33444 Phone#(954)233-0126 Fax#(954)752-0245 Phone# Fax# Line# Item Description Quantity Line Pricing 1.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.500W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.500 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 2.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.500W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.500 Actual DLO height::0 - Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 3.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,503.00 Location: Size:72.750W x 61.375H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SOP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.750 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:61.375 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 1 of 5 4.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $570.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 37.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:37.250 5.1 SH500 SH500 VINYL WINGUARD IMP Ordered:1 List Price $345.00 Location: Size:17.750W x 37.250H Configuration:Equal Lite Frame color:White Frame type:Flange Sash Outboard Color:Solar Ban 70XL Fixed Outboard Color:Solar Ban 70XL Outboard Color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer Color:Clear Sash Inboard Color:Clear Fixed Inboard Color:Clear Inboard color:Clear Colonial style:No Colonial What kind:Sweep Latch How many locks:One Lock Screen type:18x16 Charcoal FPA#:FL239 Actual DLO width::0 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Width:17.750 Custom Size DLO Height:37.250 6.1 FD555 FRENCH DOOR SERIES 555 Ordered:3 List Price $3,527.00 Location: Unit Configuration:XX Door Type:Out-Swing Door Size:Custom Size Opening Width:72 Opening Height:79.75 Actual Door Size:71 3/4 x 791/2 AssembledWidth:71.750 AssembledHeight:79.500 Hinge Side:Left(right hand hinged on the left) Active Panel Side:Active Right Panel/Inactive Left Panel Send Hardware:Yes Inactive Hardware Prep:Yes Hardware Style:Series 800 Hardware Color:Satin Nickel Send Inactive Hardware:Yes Frame Color:White GlassType: 1 3/16"(3/16 Tmp-5/8 air-5/16 NA PVB) Glass Color:Clear Glass Color:Clear Argon Gas:Yes Low-E:PPG Solarban 70XL Threshold Options:1 3/8"Exterior Threshold Send Unit KD'd:Yes Grid Style:No Grid Which NOA:13-0815.03(Expires 1/23/2019) AnchorageType:1/4"Elco Aggre-Gator Certification Type:Miami-Dade NOA(in HVHZ) Door Glass Type:"1 3/16""(3/16 Tmp-5/8-air- 5/16 NA PVB)" Door NegativeDesignPressure:70.0000 Door PositiveDesignPressure:70.0000 Door TestNumber:FTL-7339&7371 Door CondResistance:61.0000 Door Energy Star:Qualified in all 50 States Door SHGC:0.1700 Door UF:0.3000 Door VT:0.3600 Door VTCOG:0.6300 7.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 2 of 5 SGP Actual DLO width::0 • FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 8.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 9.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,033.00 Location: Size:54.375W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:54.375 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $1,033.00 Location: Size:54.375W x 49.250H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:54.375 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.250 11.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price - $1,234.00 Location: Size:72.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size-- -- Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear - Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:72.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 3 of 5 12.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):XO Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 13.1 HS510 VWG HS SERIES 510 Ordered:1 List Price $706.00 Location: Size:35.875W x 49.125H Size selection:Custom Size Configuration(OSLI):OX Frame type:Flange Frame color:White Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color::Clear Inboard Color:Clear Glass type:7/8"LIG(1/8 Ann-7/16 air-5/16 HS/HS Lami Colonial style:No Colonial SGP Actual DLO width::0 FPA#:FL242 Custom Size DLO Width:35.875 Actual DLO height::0 Custom Size DLO Height:49.125 14.1 AR520 AR520 VINYL WINGUARD Ordered:3 List Price $719.00 Location: Frame Color:White Frame Type:Range Symmetric code:HX 1 Lite Glass Type:7/8"LIG(3/16 Ann-3/8 air-5/16 Ann/Ann Lami) Outboard color:Solar Ban 70XL Interlayer color:Clear Inboard color:Clear Calculated+:80.00 Calculated-:80.00 FPA#:FL5012 Certification#:190-701 &232 Certification Requirements:AAMA DLO Width:22.750 DLO Height:22.750 Total Products Ordered AR520:3 FD555:3 HS510:11 SH500:1 TOTAL LIST AMOUNT: $23748.00 Quote# 3378111 Print Date 1/26/2015 Page 4 of 5 „ ; :„,), ,:t. __, ,,,.... , , .....,s.,,c 7...7c;:z.::,,,,,,,,,,..*.v...,..::.1,"114....1.ii, .. we2'irffr ,V-.1..,...;::'... ,.r :, .t -.np¢nn r w.4'..^iJ✓^ >.A5Y�:w:'73T >,aiiris��6Yki8 �.a°i t r a .,. IA a�v,'�.,. }s, '.:�..'.�"r'ran.9.`".i'•F'" �awt ,, M�i .- ('P,,,,y^,^"-,,.••*: `` t ,. 0,11,2... � 14 bk;,, r 19� ., idmI�� igss +� -' `` •. B onvxmovalev • -- � »„yr_ ..•' .. Z4'�i ,1imP] y y l-.. 9 ...i1P• !t>ap$ �..+ - va',tC�l'E� :. n .;� M1G,Ti ''ts5i*CL�•'Sr,�,- ':,a�'ui,,:. l^y .,, J/?`"i^v. L'!!'"•w 1' x, .,y`,., �...u..f .. p+� !F i y a. arA" r r 'r t r: + '.�.> •'% n1,. ..ry . x..._ y�}� - x°,$'k"• 'mot`i�t .. via % .;.y�, :,. r _ _ „_ ��.eo✓ :”. -rr-i,-, EF'ti0.4'ia.SfSeF9�y �: osossmitomarrasz tyr y Ert spa d :la -.: c, hdri W '�mi t �^ ID:T i,& -,.. f �crAr" v" i e54164Ar its m/TN, �:.Is§a.,9': ` �' t anii U'rr.�.��"4 ' 'Vi- '' •.t" �,Tj' .�;Fvn .R5 i T. ,�sw+aYt • r":"R 4�..•rc 6.2 14*' t 1,='S -a,arl.a '"'• Ns+..� MAc e' 'F,' "m ,r . ^i •^q Maa••` r�•'+�•as ws *. .caro .= S mom. .r .. •l41 1,, r e4 t ,'T1R 23c8"Y40� �5 "r.''.r➢. n•+w-mrr ,N r n' `.,.m-rrvc.re a:... ,.-® Lk:rt.yr:li' gC •t ;;r.. •,•aRxsC"J-�,fa,. .+r- e} .—,y may. .'lam:' wa.'T ,,.�,�i- ..._ r 1 i { �.'g �'.e r '�, !o�yth- IE:GssT1v� 's"t.* ."'•�"�` 'it '� 1. a��" a 4; s•." M;rwt'�+.::.�.. s.wanoilt� � -.-r' - y 4'.,,, y4 n i t �a'''' �.. :.... '",.r' � 7 .•pa ':r 65C7R5'..• ,¢• Y�7A',i"+.3� y'' ca d'. :ii. V ..a ! e r*+ i*•n7 tr+r r-; r Y ft`r s lc a y P}, S a„t r �,,.GSkV•�f+wr vhaWwra+.".ri 73+ r:. .,,... v�G��fr4�� 4 ! .r J'�'t)k i.. {twi.. —v �, . -rtr�r�" f.":�*.�-Ar.MOR ve ,:� k -- ka r•" A r I.�r . ;t rtr,r 1 r s �:: �i". �p7 �_ ryrr •aa�a 1P�C ,R'.�spg.A SA x.�i`+� "3"3''u � � , • ei i ". ,+ ..t.zn w-,.... 5 .tea+ ae � .b.cs- a1 I o t , �r ".: • + ^ {•�. " 4 ' -m°'"mT rmata - 'li c .o_ +fit. ,- 4s, r :sue Y ni "r Q its 1�ca-alter ". y e r 21' f fi 'r ,Ai ...,-, .m^s r. r• CP....1•era"u .0,E=.+as ta�aaru+a+ ..... Fraz er 4' ,� 4 a t w t �' a ^' n iv, +m, ..+eyc, '!? M "tetra - r� rsw Ifs :*s,taib':r rs! r�•r r i rr^r 50 �',,:. ' • :: �i$,- s. .'fir.. . w..�" `+ i^�0t rt: &•R 'J�.Orr, s.{' :- .St{a_,,' r � 9 �-n ii.m sr, ;_4 �K.c. r'f{ `:-+•r ,t•1...4r•. c.,+'.''.A + ''1 '� �i ,e '7'.67'"A9eR3S,C+5iCa:.s1 .n,n .t^'23:5a la�stf2..A~<+"" 1 A" P r` .00 }/ ' - • r a so, ` �'. �k. x` •. , i t41iA a r'. ` ` rs •:smart b, , F.,,,:"... - r� Jt ,�- �`1 'it -[Tlµ " i"'+�"� rw• , a;t r; _ x3� • 1, fr 'fir ;,,�. '.,.�� a •y6PP+ �l, vh� e` �. !/: t .. 4 ,\,,� �» ,fix ! ; tt' �,w ^ !j� r° :13'-•1 1 y 0 's ,r '*,' S� 4'i:•\r� -,� �1,i �r_t ?+AVz�`r'r.,A r.hr •fir'''' -.e. ` •it-+> ,';:;"` Ti . y+, ,.,in ', �. �„ % !G81 x t•• -c, y�Y4., "r i�l��V i'4 '...,,,.F,Jr��, rt��c'. y�°'.•P�r�.i'#'�C ' 11l�•, �j • If+e!S+� _ W�, -car+ +''jw`• '� 'l-4 ,. �7'►'1'Sn v1:r K,'t w� i'd'tti +?: fe' ,• .: '" -�. IrIl �' �` rl ,�,'�• ._.,_.. �, 'r �' i\ y!. r r1, r' � 1 !ff' i��P� b -,S.�.s^4t fie' ' I,.4 i rc �yS ^�. .R�t s ° 1 Ta 6`c ! yt1IAS` t ! +k r i 31` r �hr �� ;n ' y i1 `'S`� p1�..rpj r+"t ";!} 1 �� i �i,�, s�%pr .r y ^ •.,,rite.; �. �.:` o r.. • a '? @rat +4 t_ 01144} ,y en d, e i eir" y rs •� / •-. 't i' I 6.:}fir,.. h • -.k; �Plf r. 9t e4C Yv%1�t - r► r + +•3'1 C`, t��'uIRtJ 's." q�gy -r,..�' d� 1r. a -se 3 ..id ,rP, I 1. r + �. a 1 - P t y�: / 4�. Fa74..agK+zr.•e 7"z asts J w '—ram' C `A', r '�1 'rn?as`"rr ,w , kr•z '�r.�,e*qv�'-� "'�'e 5r:t.HA*it�r^ .5. i> t+ r, :..:� ^�5 .. pi i N.,,,r a. ',••, r • .., ,c x!t4 S,. µ ict +''kS �C+ 'y+.f vlr .1 kr,'' �s�,,, /, b nR r 'n�}i t � ,,i�. �'' c'Ur , 7 y f tP,•`„k y r • . r t f > • G , a . �'��r,,.x .rr..:'. ,.n,.., i °^,d rr ?•r: n r= <a; ° :, ! 'r{ ,, �.s + • •r ,x > ' r ..♦. : b+ taa Wit+ . ,r ,-•� -:' >, :..:� � ..:.ly,,.. :: '': r �'..�r� r r� 1'Vi t "'.F i{ ,.+ ., a ', 4 4 x .:ril of 1 "q• "� _ •," W { r i x kk.�3r • ^i r ` 3 i', aw a• ( tit ! i. Le d...orrLOR,4cwl"7 t 1 it ' r., r /.: :7, •F ., r ,..,0.2t44 .. r .+9t.YAe . �c:.c,,tf,,,�ir»d.:r ;-2, :^iit&,w^... ., ,'r .{ r •;3�, r''?,e� „i, v' r. , r: i, r ♦. i' '"S ,4:..!*•.i q.,, ..L�.r` . 1 r ay',.:�sr '.,X.,•,f l.' I.S,.+I »,' e JM7 w P r r ' . ¢ t9 YyS p ' ;y4 d a y III eg TM N # R 'j r.r.r..e rde i rC M c. � b r�xr a nr^�+,...- 8 9 ,;" 1.• • `,c'• , •:5 N.:a ' • 3 �."r S,*t y.i•., tiRY , I *I , .9 ,' fA ^•ti ., j19WI syt, t • ro 4t Fa . aw 0I tC t a; i r. •. 7- l :. ,:;Af '. z+ ( �y■ t , " K+ nay I ptt % ;., ,a,,,,,e., :;'. ""`- ,y ;.f . H ,.e y a 't it ,. t yd' 4'.�. H1�">�`�' M1 T. ?1lItHR 4*fir yUr t I 'spG I "t• ` _. .I .uttvv.-y«�r,c'.:�z-am• ..etaR:c`` r-M,P� C.141: �h "t4, x 'l k0115O t c . ZiPo�Sr I t {d I ;o. ;i i 'il '� ''''s : x»iiii •,mac, ,e �! t 5 .1.. v CK '. ai silS 1 i' 1 �t 11 viC �( " `-?-a'r q'v'� -' 5?" t .... I s i w ' 'C(3'tip, rtit>;'.1�, ...t+��.�.�".� ,...,. ..,.: E c r rwf, { 1 I ! r >'; k RVir °r bt x 4 a 6emr Y 7 'ry'r�t1 • ir 7 s s '' l'y Art"� G 4 R ✓ " .i aS y pn-..::, ,s, �.'n i.�a T 2 7 - ^i a.:.:ti Stwi ri.y.Y�* v 1,'-. . *lit ; IWO %r L'{1.a ;r ` .T. ', d{{ ti ♦ _. "ry, ,•,;, I uf :, 7 :s, rty h I '. +f° .. ,�, '1, t•• ', -, -1 t' , C 1 ,. ,u' v � '1 " it'" k` a dr i Y 71 • 4";„,.•,,,4;xf,,„r„.1',,,,,„ ;',. %,14•01,41,i,o,,,k,X i- ' ‘''.:' 4 ' ' ' ' i".1 i ''I '.t' ....4k t.. .1..‘...at" 1.4 .. e 1Nr. 1,..01."..S. ..4.1114t7...1.4.":.i.4.1ilit, V.Z , . .i'.41 a � F, " �/'�j� ac Vr, u - *ti err\ • " ! M y '� ' A /iW w ?.-Ni...';'": �� 4� I 81g T %'\ om.:♦ qg i e., igg t f ` .:•r ~" d'��+.` y° , < r + ;yp \.'u ,.',, $ f :� ak ,,' U Y!' / v� - --)'''''a-5 y�u a w� MS.r t " 11;! 4 y ly b R M�� F t ,14� ,: h'i. tN .. f t2 �r. �.. - yam. A f�: :y l� y ~x�l' ?tr "hnli:r t ' n,.l rf i ♦ t '* y.', "e re- �1i ,. :' " �3 ifi'� 1 $ ^'+ :.: .w t! .:..' .,.' -` :,7,F, •sf y� j'•' yI ....... r , �"!� '. .w n:r. «.t k .,r. r a.: ��JJ G d "Vy':.kyn a..t - Y. ;`....•, ieu i,:flftr. 1 a' },»jt �S* yy 1L��.`}..'„•♦ �,� • s� - vFM 'r, p�'t w:Y� at%a.4 gy.re 1 +., v, .y-, f .. i .i1 ..ram t, '�.. V e x v :�': 3t`i' a.,:. ' ;.4. ov "r- ."''::':3^'>..s^ir..: "tkt3 -itt r.4,` ¢ '` -:.'�..a•`aY'J._., ,.. s.n"`a-;t ',.►�a '�4a�",�.°'i i, l ...:v:... •x.v'�+e _"t ..A'd17 a�:aysik. • P� r+ f r' �� u y 9 t d r, {! 1 tit ,,�� .,..,, ,,,� �,,j�,�M ,�� !;two. ti�i�4y�lj 1�lkP�.}R °t T�R < y� fiy Iw h 'fz°:� •d'n�i{� , 4 y`�any _ ,� :f"•` i;: ",4�•'�^ _ '....--. n^� u r . '.4•'•"""'- +\,{+• i '�' 1•.._. — 7` y{ l¢ tiy. .t ,I{ ��ir" /1,,';4,,'[l's' * [ 116,_ ./;' ''1,[.''„'":.,, ,,f 4, ir, ,,,,., ...,,,,‘„,,''..:.,',.-.:::."*.-.....' "'.''' ' i ,,,ri , ,.., , . .,.. ;,,,,,,,;;.--7--- . g �. S'.d., ":i 7��,j— i �I �r !'•'� �7 �r 3F7 w�r.r i'� {l r t,Y X, -•'a',*-�r.y,�......_ w t ,(' '`r:. i•w. I y •[, ,' .1�j" I' .1f ^"^.•..'.r— 4 '` r y s" "z" }. li ° e '. , o zw 1', ' i .. t I ' 4 1 ii ' '�^ "'•.. .• I) dfraib tvf l0•,�7'y I i '�• t; t s, J i �,� a -I ,� v aka y Y� _..... G Y • a; } fir. a "'' 1'I ' A . , Y } �.1i 1 , .t,, r r au • _......, ,ark 7, ,t ......,..• l ' e .6h wu 9 + 1 r ' 1 f rr tii r Lykl' '^�r4 , �� cr!S �• a ,-,� }fig ' ! ! r tir>f ,yM '"Ar.� , , � P �y� 5 '� ��': � ��.? N. '�,�,�� ^"� �-. ` y�ry,,,�4 !. r i •-•4� a e p.l '74.g .+ ,'; .rz"' 7 } . . ,� 7.--,�T , 7 1•' l.�e�.r.•, �r d• r ,k' � '.•okra �r ►'s. �F'.• �v''�p.�.� I. 4. .1= �. i ,nt a _ r 1 �` � .•a a�t i '' 1 ��r-:.'sfv"� _ 'fib � _ ��,,.� ��"'r"'>'•"�Iy �� ,N�:,,`.'ut4 1 "'?J Ey,�`". .ae 1,{ri ^� sa6,Rr"'?C" �1,��f� ,•��'�y'""r'rr�'��r'��-�� _?•.. � . ,.'^�+,/� � - -•:-!.• .N, - ,''t;k y, 47 . !-r 1 ,f r `;any �'£%r i 1.a r; * .. ti. l� i/" p,,s, 3'y C.'" .`' •r'3 r'" ...ti + + eroP :1' iy .. . yl.y'.:✓m...ftil' .aN t+kt^ti'g ''ti "..''.'.''.''.... ;''''.',,,I: .x!+.^v, x .r _ ' ti• „� e- . '�. � W2 r. efl ?'4 n r�'ty� r �- ri .' a„+Wr� _ �,. 1�.. . :a• yt, e � . rr d,•o4?:ry ` 'Va.; „+ : T .;;o-4. > � . dT11., ': . ;ya i4 i' 7 srT.ti i'a,r �lw fir .,p; �1n y4ti r�,.' "'i 'r• :,.. � ` � ,r �rn:+� �,•o, �P.y,...,,r�`: _�":3 fit" ��"�.: ��'> ,R►^�.„ .,y,: + �','t �un�., . �* ,.,_4', »'1I i�,�*xkw"��"�K� •. w,., ��. . ._��.:��_`'.�. .. ._. ... +a, +n. .•O... . �+. , , . . •t '''ra,h,f41,'.'•','' ',I ' '‘,''.:'''','t-'; -.1;r-,J''.'';, r ),,i,..!;. -t.c.,1,,,.. r".. .._ ..-., ., ,, , . -.-. ': : , ..., . ..4.,..4.1,,,,,,,„,.,.r.'4,:,'','1" '.--',,,i',/'',..'^....•. '-'''-''',.,,, vf • '"e''. • .-.. • , „ , --'),-;::',.:%.,-"-,:;:::?„-,-::;",/;:-:,:.:'"•-,-..-:::, ys4>''''' L';.,.. '' .,..:.:...'Ait,...;•i,A,4:1?,,,•`.\;,'... ' '-'11';','''li. ,. ''''• ' , • .2,i,.4.irl .,:::-':4„..• --.--,:'-',-_--.. ..------,,-.1.--,-; -.., .., . .0 .. . ' ' .''.2'.• ' ''''• . 'Th ''''', .• , , . . -- -- .- . IC• , . ...,' . , / ' r.."1'01, I . . 4. . :C". '•.',,r:T.,:,',''41: • . ' . .' ...'''..-.. . . :t,,''' ... .' ' ..:...'- ..' '..,..' ....' r-r:-. 1.,,, . ,... 1 ... . ..„ ..i , . • ..--• <' <...,,,:::,,,,,,:,",,.' • • ,,,,1,,,1nt.l',t...r.:.. .:.,,.p,•.,:,,:,4,:,,0.,..*1'.,)f f.7.4.-.-4„,0::1.:....•-4-.4 N*0e,$.4.:-.,ve.t1.,•„g;...:....,.---.,.-,/.;--:„,,;,-,,•-.•(--,.-.y':-:._tI.f.; '. ; * :' . ,..i .,, , - . fr*. -,• , . -ai ......:14.6 iev,,,,y • •+!'I.• ,.—.-• .- ,.. . '..). ..s•Yi*FIY,"7-.. ,?.4.,,i,7!.:. ,'.: '•• • .....-.::... '''' '%.";110.: .• &,'" -'.•.,IH,;....'••'• .--• - . • •.fi.,-/•. . , . . • . . • i,,,.-.: ' •-..- ,;',"07-.-i•,•••-,.; •.,;••.; . ., . ..•,,••„ ,w., , .. ,. ...... . ..,... ..,.1 ,-,,-:.;-',,r,4;',.',-.:1',-.,j,,,:,,.•:: ,-...,,` 4,, , ,,',,",,, ,,,,,-„ . ',.,,•':„.. . ... ,"- • - - ' •--' - •• • ;•• • • ,, . . • , •• . . ., , . , ,... .. , . '''4.!'•''''i. .,'.':":•:•!''' .,, ',•-•:-",•.',"••-.../..-•:::-.': '-.•...-.-..f.•-",..... ,,.,:t.y,,v:i7;:-,1t.:fli:i.,fr.!,;:-....,2 ',.;-.. , . ......- -• .:. •: ••• ' ,, ,.? . ;.;'s..,-t-4.:'ir",,,,/,',.!,".•!, :. 1•::".r.' •--- '' '''•-.. "•-'-• ---•.'-'''.''-'-'- ' • r• •- ••-• ''•-•-•' '''''-:- ':,.., ,,,,,kr. .-,:,,,34,,,,,,-,,,-., .1110,14'',,IP,',,r,1,,;',' r*.d -:-: rt.r'll .; ,,.. L.,: i ,..,. , . i,,, _,,. ,,.. .., .., -- ,,,H,rf,e0,4,11,, --,411.tiii;,,,:-,,,,;:r,„?., .---.::: , ,...,,,... •,,.:,:-,::.i:,,.. .,;r.r,:,-..,:,,-,• ,-,.. , -.,-!.:,-,.:7t.' . .....- . . -...,,.. r.,...:.,ftt,,;,,:q,r.R;;;;*,14 ,,,,t. ...,54,1‘1;..,,....:.,,,,I4r.y.,,,,„'..r,v..i.',..pitil.?,,,, -,1,, ,.. , . ., ',7:1411"Z41'?i.i'! '''1'..''. ',{''7.;','"'",'7"".:1'2",',.:""'''''':::";,.;,..;'',:.;""'''.%•.''.4.'• ''''' :• ' . . .' .. • ,I.,?4,,,,,,-,,,,,..,1, Om,'' .,.;?...t, ''•T:‘,"-s.''',i,,,-ct..4..,,...,4.,f,, .,,,,.,4;,,.,., [ ''' . 1.... i l'-'''i ....,.*:',:t:', .`.1.' .0:.!,;"..',:',„li",t.':.,1' . ' ' ,',r?,4..,,i'rk,.,:t;,,,,,t, ', .,,,...-.., -,,,,;,..;,..:,...,. .' .. ,,,,, . :,,,,,,,,,,..,,v. :, ..1......„1, ,,,,,, .:?,,,t,,i,7.,,,,....:.:::„.,,,,,,,,,,...:.,'„,,•:i;•''•7,•, '',• ' • , . ';`;'16'r.l'''.e1,14.''..,,'''' "4i'i''''-'•'••'•'•:•;-1.`,4,;..•'•',;'?, .'••'11-.'gt•I6','"•$,,:),0 '.''''. 71.... ''..,".."',4 I '.: . ,,,,.:,,,,:':.,:.0::1,:,i.,-.. igir.,,,z,,,,,w.:,,,,,....,:,,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,,.,,,,.i,,,..:,,,,,,,,,,,.,.,..,,,,,,,;,.. ,,,,..„,,,,,,,,,,;:,.. „?,,:b.,.. ,i0,:,,,,,,4,..,,,l':'' 1.4, ''..',: it,4...441t,,f4t.r,i, 4:i:40,4:74.klt,, ,ttito,;tr,..kk'?1,0'''J.:,-4.,, : ',.t..'ir' '0.1:::: , .. : '..,..".:,,, ,', l ,:r2,014'.:,':4:,\.- 171, , ,: ; --;..1 ,!:',i7,,,,;':4",t;',;,'.1.:.i.2,..;;:.,/.::-.-','-,.‘:.;.::;,,-. • ..,. ,4,4*.„ -,:..,.-',$,4-.c.,,,:„..,,05';:: k:-. , 11,5:,' - 'il..r'i: Arr;. r rr ,,,,..9,VP.,r4,1,,,ai,. . Ii:,..':i'.0,41, 4,'--V,1-1,,,-;•;".4.4W-ir,i.-i,,i: : ,,•,.. '1%4'e,,,,,...„•,•'/4.1/1, ''''Ytthit^Y.A-OA',eo,„,4.1,•'•0;,0,3„•,•,,,',i,.i., . , Ir'P ti';h''04.?•'''';‘'..t.'n' , ,r,4r1M,'Ir i',1.,Iyikr4 4,k,,;,,'t.'.'.;5:,1 -.,..i':t.': .•-: •1''.; ...., .. ., ...,,,.,-,. . :, :',,.P.',.:,,:,,,.i,'...,' ,, „*,'?.4T,, .',,,,,,,'„,,.-,1r,"=-,....tti"qAP';'5.:',.:,:;!';''',,:t.'''.1i.1.....if.k.:..4.t.c,,,4;..?,,,..c,:', '.. ;:'4 " 11.41;'6'''11.r'i,'4'ifit'''. ''' :,.1"i..), *,-;*,.-',‘..' ' -- . - -.",''.:..-' ."'L'-: ''' - '-' - '' '''' ..‘. . " ''.....''''''''''' ,'p ,..„,,*„.„..„ „,,,,,..„ ,.., ,„,„.„.1, .... .,.. , , -.., - ..,.:;,,,,,i-.:,,i11011:1r#,-A ''.. 1 ',Ii„, -* IF,' •-, -Ft--,,:,,,,Y-,,..- -,...,..,,,(%,„„,,:e, \-:- -1';i'i.,ifit,iti'll.'"f;,,,,,:.,•'-'1','","''''''."-..,,y-111,,,:„A:.:!;14,,,l'il..[,',,.},,,,I,.,......:,,,f,•,,,,,,,,. ,, - ,..,r,,,..... ' •,4.: ..:,..,4-','••:•,',,,,,,,-Toi,.,,, ,,,p,t,,,,•,..1•',1;,1,4,,,,,..,, 4.• ,„ ,,,,,5•,,•,•,, ".,,....',,lioq-,z;,,, 4.••,•• 5'' —lip., ' . .ti.r,n,.14 ' ,,,, i't '.i. '''' 40P1,r' 'Sli'''''''"}i'lit v,,,'41•,,-%.,&?..,,..'..,7...4..-•.,,,...,•.:,,,,,cv-,0,..!:,,;:i4i,:.;:..-i. ...*:,, ,,,:.,,,.(,..;.,.:,.„7„,.,,, ,.'7fr,0 ; ..-,..1e.,,.; .,;•4,1',.tt)' ' ... . 1",-.,',i,:.,.,,,,:lv:•,',,,,';',,,,,;'!..::;,...,,,:::,,,,4,it.....,4,q,,!...r,:),;:-..1,...-!1:. e..: -...,'.,.fri-:.1.?,,,."..4‘p.',7:: . . ., ,.;4,,,,,4,.,:',,,,, '0 .,.' •,i...4,,,,y5,,,,,,,,,10....,,ic„,,i,,,.,,,,..:..,... , ,..„ , ,::-',.:'',,"1 ''.if;-44t17. f f, V. , ' ' ' „.•„'y'',',,•,';'I.. ,"•'. ;,.,:.«,,f i -i,v&•,, ,-, tf..i,,.,":,..';',f),'i,i,.,'F.1:,.I.,,,,L''' ',?,.W,',.f.,:j,,'.'.,:41''.(,,'i,'I',',6.,'''.'4''I:"r'..;;;.4,?!f,.'it4.?J,'1;,'',.,1;'?t!,',,T,,.,.';„:'?,..'.,,':,!,'.'i.„';;q;'f;',.;J,t . ' -: ''. 1, ' ' 1.,' ' . .,,,'•.- -- ''„:.:.,..,,-..!;. ', '' ,,,,,:t!''''';'. 1,:t.'1'11;„4,';'?-1';'...:f':','1.1.a4.'-,:.. ''tif,,i1.1..*:4t 44''.:,- ,..„.— '...,,,zv,,,,,, :;',1.•,,:,:i'.:,,.0,1.,,,, ,,,,'4;44:1,...,,,,,,,s,„Iym,,\-,,,,,...,,,,,..,.-,.. ,,..- . , . ' ' . ---q-— ' . ,--;*.•;,,,:,• "i.4't.:-.,:,,,,-,..9,1,--,41'.',..,-,:.,;..r.....,,t,'',.:7.,..-1,::!,t,..,,, L'7,;,•'',.."1",;,,, ,',),','''''''',..,-,'",..i'L","'1':'''.1.1,"''',"7,'..',"','",".... !,7,'''''''7"Mti'l 1'"7"'":.f'';'1:"..'4. " ' ' '' 'J'" '. "'''''''' .. " ' . " . '."'""''''''''PeAj""1141,1A l!'•&:J117141'.'''''j'n-""'"'''\'''"i'.'"'.''' '. ' - .., '''_"''!"',..!."':.;'.7t..;•:;',.''1,";.-',..1"..:,'''''''':','"''',::".":". .?? '-`,. ••'ff'r" _,„......-,•"' • .''-'''.''i.;,-.'",',`'...,'",'-",•,:1-".".•••!'"';',..'.,,,,-..,','-'....',',..,.''.'‘•;••••••!•`,.,"1,-,-.:::,i'?"',..';',7,-,.,.-•.1.''••,,,,,,. ••,.,„'•,,";•,', , ,, ,....-- ___...„,....• VI;••f:I'',''';',':',.'''',••'.*;'::-.,,:',j•,r;,'''l':,,..",',',•,',';','•,-'7...:.;•,i..•,t.,,',7".i., ,,,,,,,,,,,.,,..,,,,,„i„,..,,,•.,1....,,,,,.,,,,,.,„„„..... t.,:"Si-',":,,"•4','',F••,''‘-''•••:' '',' -'''''''''''uj • Yi cud,...%.':.„,4,, yy P,p%„},+:i.,,P-,. k, 7 G qL iti`y lti D '�^. y '1'''' 11'1 4 V'''74'4'41:''''''‘I''''246”IPC:fsil•v:''''"4::1:14'*`, �JI k r' Fy Jl,„,H.a...'k'7k1?h,6i#JY Mr'.441 Af11.., • • Rm+ dJ} �p', > r e. '�S c 9�"J1 a �1T 1 N{h v y i 9,�il f 1 �L'1kf S '"N4'a •n. 1 � zit �a a��i �� ' a � � k } 1iur '. tari »� of r ° �,fi+ t '� n I��{ I '14,ik '.,'Fxm " :, �h,i+P Nk)1 f 1 .s �1t '^"'°'�aai„ar 1 i. 1�f 1+. 1 v' { k F d f 1, � a�. ° j as ar'. It r &,, .� , 1 73 '°>�.�q ; s .t� q <rt , � N,`f � :S. t - � y t�"i.. y, a o ua�'rx ,' 1" �^+"' 'r , � ,��n � � .. � +I'" '4� �F ��, a s fir' n T '' �'�'"?,j'N�¢er r,��yy�y "s'";�Yh•, ..t r,r "re }I hfa P '..: °'� „, "'" ': fr•� 4 t,. year.;+v. '1 ±, tl - .j ��', la 1 ' + l`'qi C�mwmafC, ti'. ,i,.-j 1 ''!+ 3 Yi �' c. �� "ml -�ir.da x� ��}..C+ �� j r v P• syif 4 � r.+,.r'�r>�':.,R '.�� f�� t�' Sera s 'd �. i f r. f i q 1 ,rN ta r, yh1 4 .,4• � r m.: ' S a4 '' Ml f ✓ .D^ � g, ^•�.+: A! Y k >. �t�N }'hl �µ t 1 .I !i t r Ce. " „� `, .,. AV ;: s"�1 .,. 1 w' �'. 0 '" Gv:%>.",t!7,t;f ra 'a3+F�,ya .`. E I'�! y,x � a"d 'M !? I G, ;� , f i� x ::..1{ •, ' 1� � >a f� ;;f'i +c. " ,+ I:,, e,Dk� . 4 t'°' t e h.. �hn a .1 y+t xb ak+.� 9Y ft• ;if df0. ¢ STi' ''M"a'b, iY ,44 t 147117 5 s � �. ♦.� +� • fry iR r„^�'� � it b":.,r ka ke I�ki ..t.. .. , �yR x�fr ti� b �t� Wl b ! +'1 '..iys14'ri' r N ps.M ,w °F n"z3r ' a �jy�'°?: " Ifu�r ^';. i a + It .i'lr, aa4�.SPf �F`6 ,J � r�,, r 1 i o Y J * f� �' vlC11 y�I`st"� 4t;",}. • ' +�i t<'t t ' ?r�`"'•} Ili Jlh`�`" ft `a"'"4 ,b t 7 G t ._ fa� h t1 . C , a�, 'N ,� s 3 a,�e d� Cc a,Y a _ �f �., d, a �h 1 y I �. t P s1 ^afr.9" a t} tf },�a n!a'�laFi t 7 r �- :{ } j Nfi 1 t + I, ti fH kr 'f �'Qq� , x ; 4 uxur �� 4 a 1 S" �;•+. tN.. �l i}} , N (,. '" _' S ^ + AJY -. C t t ,. .. . '•. �a r' f } s r - r ,s a r l c u � � H � ` �.�t. ! 1 � tr t a a 4 d �, �i R'i me t I nw-r d l + A r 4yt t� a t c { .w, m' H i i ry (ff:�1I�i rI ju� n 'k .4 >; Y + yr ! < Iw r n `� th s $ jltlrt�4 fti 16it ', "`I iam' ' .1 afi ft�,, • }}� • A rc+Mr�w'�µ;t" 6w'fit.ak✓;• 0l'1 , G TM" -,.1' �X �°' � 4a ` ; �. �` i� • • a"-tf '.s yl;-:h `Sii ..f�f t Nt�1 C tx.".1•.c `� y'p y''«� r..s , "P"1a ,, ,,,,,• ; a 7• ... . ,.--- ./../.."I.: 1�Ott Tl d n � /� 1 I " s.ti � ^ � } I I # Y r'.T iF _. ,'I I -,^ ,^'►..._'` ,`A� r`v' 'r �,y... Wt Y fi ` / . �ti _.w4 f/f P ,� ` / , ear 'y '4' '' /'"' i .,'�`� ."Irk t :II' .V: 9 a1 1r) 1�—` u- w '• fl r r t '+� � !� 5�",,m , 'i� ,� efl� ,� p �e. � skn Foot a pr• r' .1 ilia- YG /f �.� = jp� 4 pq .7r P'J' .a ', Il t ,/ "may '*i I '+}y I r t � //.�® `' ' C*^i� � t �+r�1�*T'�n� r� ,-.. P "t'� K�� e y,r,t � 1,�1 �''- '' ; ."( /// �, y J l (� , t �k�ar' Aa r ' / 'I.;1 t • �� r T•*.k R - Ate • I4, 1i.,l� c ,I { s i tiff,, Ft Ji�n�P Pl �' P ! �' -r N. ,, �ty yf)A i • ,.� i t t t 8� I S 4 S I Llt{ �1 f 4' f I 0 t 1�' il 4�'"7 ii t',1 t , W E '1 r Icy. e f x iY't n i ,,.k' ' - tNt � iF9 {4 ✓0 � � I $$e a .i{n fit °� ".. g _ ..,_. ityl lL C t } i. t • • .i ll,k t I t Z. � .�+t, w�~ it�o{V i ^ y t .Ertl , Yr+r y hw�:r `p"q5V o r tk Y.iif l }t A tr, 4 ii/ir' Y •�7,4 } rf :- & 1IIj '1 t"f ' tx ntt I � n 1 q_.........>^. eNi i .: J • r Sx • i i1tl 4 bit r! I1" A J, f { p0 , 1; Si11 • n <- f I0P ^ 'rwli ^� , ' QM,,Y�b, � ti.% /4 :'. 1t ,vim,•