Loading...
HPB 06-27-17 iocyd _4eitda I /4-i6/ s_ 6q) — kiy--/ C/cutz;L a.)/(4; /3/3 - Cis2/11/ /7(-P i.P,��/ %rcE N . 51A-aeig ytkehfit______ `f�IST(J-x-rL auLkocii-10--A_ "Ack-r—t QCrscle-x.�_ ffeLAJI ,i/u — he./ (ixiluxdra,b it_ (Li A, T/a,c dew! is /26, e-L _MA? Ctk S` ruf A Wit-t_de4l ,c.eft,La /14n _�u.,�v..t.� rtv� 4.)a Sir) )thiC - /lc r c.L.49 Scat_ - )&4361-itta 1-/Jca_h_. lig — Ceedety / - — 'aco-kk �hUr 2_c.r NcLitacrt. el 6) J &f CJta;e ,c.e..r,d-e..���� tj0//fit 62'r ? 40/ A-id( Tiotc(4_ ht-tytt-alL 3 LE,/ IGt 4cailt - / Aitc)f. g. fhpativii ktc(t ,- d d,, 40, —ift.croxcl J lek;)/ Jiscuz..44 B-iC (ii A u yeat a' iloi !TX k c s% . /13 — cfdE 4._trskt_ci IL44.e-,ak.,t4 cox J i-itg. 06-)us_c.araa_e- 4j CA-C JL. On - Aft. ,, It 6Y-46 / 60 COA- (l,oicO?o do u fr.rcf aL. )4A. AO - Jr n /f 11/IL 1f-/d J ' - A/7 60E( t. e. o cac_c✓ f1i7 . Jcor — J-iu q &kr 3 a� (,oii- W ) a� s. Sto, - Th,iat F. /acct./7 — 40 /11-13 / 2' EXa4eAl (�Ul¢ ( c,c - ô1 ) 6-D 19-6 11-6e,cdu..4 /4 J=171-6 Ofd T CaA ccuu-- 0 7_ /9--(3 icC4L4,-; SLit'Q/Q &x1, h, , 7 A-fita !4 LSDa -env,u1- rt./ fa2 ,L d t- B/d f1 „ / fL 4Id . 7,1 5 - L. alcA A8 / /1-6 Inc d, z & moz,- ��07) J . citv,i) ,—ten s/dy El ) 7�13 /J,V£an Sl� s . dl<Jrn :v /l ,r14(11 /d1 4-CC., 0,6 /9.?5-61. tc). 33 ?1d7 b '" do a) Ail- u 4 .0 /3/3 3i/k. t.3 / 3r gw, 47. v S. 33 / /9-3 P{ SE r 'r St )d-/dy j6/, I 0/t LYC R6 r .7a at ,tea . B z/r se- / sr y4L )(1-/d " 7 ' 158 / tAn tOrki0 7YE�p+fi &� 0�)46 _ (}06.1..actt . /9-15 �i4-� �✓SC�P-p r - aAfiT- 771-70E._ J1LCa. LdSCCata2) �'� 4cc'7r._e1E3 ju.hc.-2— .€1.5 /4- C(Dit-4X • :5 ir 4e-3q— icittifiry \-(10-14(Aitt(3 s onc 4) '� AGENDA o = HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD ‘111111"rg� Meeting Date: June 26, 2017 and June 27, 2017 (as needed) Time: 6:00 P.M. Type of Meeting: Special Meeting Location: City Commission Chambers, City Hall, 100 NW 1st Avenue I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. SWEARING IN OF THE PUBLIC V. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (NOTE: Comments on items that are NOT on the Agenda will be taken immediately prior to Public Hearing Items.)Speakers will be limited to 3 minutes. VI. ACTION ITEMS A. Certificate of Appropriateness, Class V Site Plan, Relocations & Demolitions (2016-073): Consideration of applications for Certificate of Appropriateness, Class V Site Plan, Relocations and Demolitions associated with the Swinton Commons project, which includes 35,049 square feet of retail; 22,525 square feet of restaurant; 21,872 square feet of office; 44 dwelling units; 50 residential-type inn units; and 109 hotel rooms. Location: The subject property is located on the south side of West Atlantic Avenue between SW 1st Avenue and Swinton Avenue and north of SW 1St Street. The development also includes the Sundy House property on the south side of SW 1st Street, between Swinton Avenue and SW 1st Avenue. The property also includes the property on the south side of SE 1st Street, between Swinton Avenue and SE 1st Avenue and at the northwest corner of SE 1st Avenue and SE 1st Street. Applicant/Property Owner: Atlantic Avenue Development, LLC and MGM Sundy House, LLC Agent: Bonnie Miskel, Esq, (561) 405-3321; bmiskeldmbblaw.com Planner: Scott Pape, Principal Planner; (561) 243-7040 ext. 6215; pape(u�mydelraybeach.com B. Conditional Use(2016-101): Consideration of a request for conditional use approval to add one Residential-type Inn unit to the Sundy House at 106 South Swinton Avenue, establish/expand the Residential-type Inn use (associated with the Sundy House)with 24 new units on Block 61, and 14 Residential-type Inn units on Block 70 in association with the proposed Swinton Commons development located within the Old School Square Historic District. Location: The subject property is located on the south side of West Atlantic Avenue between SW 1st Avenue and Swinton Avenue and north of SW 1st Street. The development also includes the Sundy House property on the south side of SW 1st Street, between Swinton Avenue and SW 1st Avenue. The property also includes the property on the south side of SE 1st Street, between Swinton Avenue and SE 1st Avenue and at the northwest corner of SE 1St Avenue and SE 1st Street. Applicant/Property Owner: Atlantic Avenue Development, LLC and MGM Sundy House, LLC Agent: Bonnie Miskel, Esq, (561) 405-3321; bmiskek(c�dmbblaw.com Planner: Scott Pape, Principal Planner; (561) 243-7040 ext. 6215; papemydelraybeach.com Historic Preservation Board Meeting Agenda: June 26, 2017 and June 27, 2017(if needed) Page 2 of 2 VII. REPORTS AND COMMENTS ❖ Staff ❖ Board Members VIII. ADJOURN ArzAtlii Michelle Hoyland Historic Preservation Planner; HPB Board Liaison Posted on: June 16, 2017 The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service,program,or activity conducted by the City.Please contact the City Manager at 243-7010 24 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Adaptive listening devices are available for meetings in the Commission Chambers.If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing,such persons will need a record of these proceedings,and for this purpose such persons may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made.Such record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.The City does not provide or prepare such record.Two or more City Commissioners may be in attendance. z Historic Preservatio-4oard-Voting Sheet III VI.A VIA VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Agenda Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 VOTED ON COA COA COA COA 6/26/2017 Waiver Site Plan Landscape Elevation Mod. Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED FAILED FAILED FAILED AIF 0-6 0-6 0-6 0-6 Angela Budano P Y N v N i N 7i N John Klein P Y N / N 7, N 1 N Andrea Sherman P Y N N N N Bill Bathurst P Y N N N N ?/ Andrea Harden P Y N N N N I Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P Y N N N N Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatioard-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 14 S.Swinton 20 W. Atlantic 22 S Swinton 21 SW 1st Ave 38 S Swinton Bldg. A Bldg. E Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4 Exhibit 5 Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED 2-4 2-4 2-4 6-0 0-6 Angela Budano P N N Z N I Y - N 02 John Klein P Y / Y Y Y N Andrea Sherman P N N N Y N Bill Bathurst P Y Z Y ' Y a Y / N / Andrea Harden P N N N Y N Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P N N N Y N Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatioard-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA 40 S Swinton 44 S Swinton 6 SE 1st St. Bldg. F Bldg. G Bldg. H Exhibit 6 Exhibit 7 Exhibit 8 Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve 2-4 5-1 5-1 Angela Budano P N Y Y a John Klein P Y 1 Y g Y Andrea Sherman P N Y Y Bill Bathurst P Y a Y 1 Y I Andrea Harden P N N N Price Patton A A A A John Miller P N Y Y Page 3 ***with additional conditions added by the Board 4 Historic Preservatio -board-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 44 S. Swinton 381/2 S 52 W Atlantic 20 W Atlantic 351/2 SW 1st Swinton Ave Bldg. G-ACC Bldg. El Bldg. T Bldg. U Bldg. V DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED 0-6 2-4 6-0 6-0 5-1 Angela Budano P N N Y Y Y John Klein P N Y a i Y I Y Andrea Sherman P N N Y Y Y Bill Bathurst P N Y I Y I Y a Y i Andrea Harden P N N Y Y N Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P N N Y Y Y Historic Preservatic oard-Voting Sheet VIA VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA 14 SE 1st St. 18 SE 1st St 181/2 Se 1st St. 48 SE 1st Ave. Bldg. W Bldg. X Bldg. Y Bldg. Z DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve 5-1 5-1 5-1 4-2 Angela Budano P Y , Y Y oR N John Klein P Y Y Y Y .Q Andrea Sherman P Y Y Y Y Bill Bathurst P Y Y i Y I Y , Andrea Harden P N N - N N Price Patton A A A A A John Miller P �N —y Y Y Y Historic Preservaticr oard-Voting Sheet VI.B HPB MEETING Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons June 26, 2017 CU Attorney: P VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve 5-1 Angela Budano P Y 1 John Klein P Y Andrea Sherman P Y Bill Bathurst P Y Andrea Harden P N Price Patton A A John Miller P Y Historic Preservati3oard-Voting Sheet III VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Agenda Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 VOTED ON COA COA COA COA 6/26/2017 Waiver Site Plan Landscape Elevation Mod. Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED FAILED FAILED FAILED AIF 0-6 0-6 0-6 0-6 Angela Budano P Y N2 N' N2 N John Klein P Y Ni N2 N' N Andrea Sherman P Y N N N N Bill Bathurst P Y N N N N2 Andrea Harden P Y N N N N' Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P Y N N N N Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board . Historic Preservati board-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 14 S.Swinton 20 W. Atlantic 22 S Swinton 21 SW 1st Ave 38 S Swinton Bldg. A Bldg. E Exhibit 1 Exbibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4 Exhibit 5 RELOCATI Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED FAILED FAILED FAILED 2-4 2-4 2-4 6-0 0-6 Angela Budano P N N2 N' Y2 N2 John Klein P Y1 Y Y Y N Andrea Sherman P N N N Y N Bill Bathurst P YZ Y1 Y2 Y' N' Andrea Harden P N N N Y N Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P N N N Y N Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatic hoard-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA 40 S Swinton 44 S Swinton 6 SE 15t St. Bldg. F Bldg. G Bldg. H Exhibit 6 Exhibit 7 Exhibit 8 RELOCATION RELOCATION RELOCATION Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin =; Approve Approve Approve FAILED 2-4 5-1 5-1 Angela Budano P N Y YZ John Klein P Y' YZ Y Andrea Sherman P N Y Y Bill Bathurst P Yz Y' Y' Andrea Harden P N N N Price Patton A A A A John Miller P N Y Y Page 3 ***with additional conditions added by the Board 4 Historic Preservati oard-Voting Sheet VIA VIA VI.A VIA VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 44 S. Swinton 381/2 S 52 W Atlantic 20 W Atlantic 351/2 SW 1st Swinton Ave Bldg. G-ACC Bldg. El Bldg. T Bldg. U Bldg. V DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve FAILED FAILED 0-6 2-4 6-0 6-0 5-1 Angela Budano P N' N Y Y V2 John Klein P N Y2 Y Y' Y Andrea Sherman P N N YZ Y Y Bill Bathurst P N2 Y' Y' Y2 Y' Andrea Harden P N N Y Y N Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller P N N Y Y Y Historic Preservatioard-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA 14 SE 1st St. 18 SE 1st St 181/2 Se 1st St. 48 SE 1st Ave. Bldg. W Bldg. X Bldg. Y Bldg. Z DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION Attorney: P VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve 5-1 5-1 5-1 4-2 Angela Budano P Y' Y Y2 N John Klein P Y Y Y y2 Andrea Sherman P Y Y Y Y Bill Bathurst P V2 Y1 Y' Y' Andrea Harden P N N2 N N Price Patton A A A A A John Miller P Y Y Y Y • • Historic Preservatioard-Voting Sheet VI.B HPB MEETING Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons June 27, 2017 CU Attorney: P VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve 5-1 Angela Budano P y' John Klein P y2 Andrea Sherman P y Bill Bathurst P y Andrea Harden P N Price Patton A A John Miller P y ADJOURNED 6/26/17 @11:00PM (NO VOTING) ADJOURNED 6/27/17 @10:00PM t Historic Preservatio3oard-Voting heet 4,4 .frio, 4407,. .i.,,,,,,L,.. III VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Agenda Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 27, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 VOTED ON COA COA COA COA 6/26/2017 Waiver Site Plan Landscape Elevation Mod. Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve4' 0 o -(9 0 Angela Budano / n 11 John Klein / 0 t/ n Andrea Sherman / I' \J./ Bill Bathurst / 4 /1 4 4 Andrea Harden Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller / 6 il 4 4 Page 1 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatii board-Voting Sheet / / ./ / r1"14 ./ VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 14 S.Swinton 20 W. Atlantic 22 S Swinton 21 SW 1st Ave 38 S Swinton Bldg. A Bldg. E Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4 Exhibit 5 Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Appro a Approve Approve Approve Approve d VI' t?' - il . 6 ° CAI Angela Budano 0 ✓ n John Klein / tZ /1 • Andrea Sherman n n n Bill Bathurst t✓ ✓, / ✓ n Andrea Harden r ' ✓ n Price Patton A A A ' A A A John Miller 11 /1 V n Page 2 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatio103oard-Voting Sheet / / / VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton i Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 40 S Swinton 44 S Swinton 6 SE 1st St. 381/2 S. 441/2 S Bldg. F Bldg. G Bldg. H Swinton Swinton Bld . E-1 Exhibit 6 Exhibit 7 Exhibit 8 Exhibit 9 Exhibit 10 Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approvf Approve Approve Approve Approve g At ' c' 1 5 - 1 . Angela Budano ,./. GO Z /, John Klein / V ✓• Andrea Sherman ✓ / Bill Bathurst Andrea Harden Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller / 11 , ✓ , Page 3 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservatio3oard-Voting Sheet VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA 52 W. Atlantic 20 W Atlantic 351/2 SW 1st 14 SE 1st St. 18 SE 1st St Bldg. T Bldg. U Ave Bldg. W Bldg. X Bldg. V RELOCATION RELOCATION RELOCATION N RELOCATION Exhibit 11 Exhibit 12 Exhibit 13 _ Exhibit 14 _ Exhibit 15 Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Approve Approve Angela Budano John Klein Andrea Sherman Bill Bathurst Andrea Harden Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller Page 4 ***with additional conditions added by the Board • Historic Preservati©l1 3oard-Voting Sheet VIA VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA 181/2 SE 1st St 48 SE 1st Ave Bldg. Y Bldg. Z RELOCATION Exhibit 16 Exhibit 17 Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Angela Budano John Klein Andrea Sherman Bill Bathurst Andrea Harden Price Patton A A A John Miller Page 5 ***with additional conditions added by the Board Historic Preservation]. naoard-Voting Sheet .7 04(0 VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A -' HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton ,✓ HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA COA t 10 SE 1st St 381/2 S 52 W Atlantic 20 W Atlantic 351/2 SW 1st (WS• Bldg. H Swinton Bldg. T Bldg. U Ave donjon Bldg. El Bldg. V AlDEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION , c,[� Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approv Approve Approve Approve ?-4 / . l k, Ip s Angela Budano /1 V / / 11 John Klein ✓ / ✓ ✓ n Andrea Sherman ✓ il ✓ ✓ .7 0 Bill Bathurst , ✓ / . Andrea Harden V in / ✓ 71 /1 Price Patton A A A A A A John Miller / 0 / / ✓ /1 i Historic Preservatic board-Voting Sheet / ./ y, / VI.A VI.A VI.A VI.A HPB MEETING Swinton Swinton Swinton Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons Commons Commons Commons June 26, 2017 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 Class 5 COA COA COA COA 14 SE 1st St. 18 SE 1st 181/2 Se 15t 48 SE 15t Ave. Bldg. W Street Street Bldg. Z Bldg. X Bldg. Y DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION DEMOLITION Attorney: VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve Approve Approve Aper rove 1 • I 5' I3--- Angela Budano / ✓ il John Klein ./ V ✓ / ,/ . Andrea Sherman Bill Bathurst ✓ Andrea Harden Y /I 0 0 Price Patton A A _ A A A John Miller ✓ / , (/ (V t/ Historic Preservatiooard-Voting Sheet / VI.B HPB MEETING Swinton HELD: ATTEND Commons June 26, 2017 CU Attorney: VOTE to Lynn Gelin Approve s ( Angela Budano John Klein Andrea Sherman Z Bill Bathurst Andrea Harden A 0 Price Patton A A John Miller